Town Council
· recording 2 hr 34 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
342 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:51 Mayor, Councilmembers, we have before you an item for this workshop that talks really about three distinct things. One is community and economic development and specifically financials and proposed performance measures. Secondly, information with regards to Mammoth Lakes Housing and there is also an item included as I will further discuss.
3:19 In this presentation on MLH that will continue to the regular portion of your agenda and that is an item with regards to MLH's request to forgive the $900,000 loan. So that will be discussed and will continue to the regular agenda where you can take an action. And lastly we provide some information about real estate assets.
3:41 I will walk you through the slides, which really are designed to serve as the table of contents, if you would, for what's in the report. Alan will talk to you a little more about the first piece of the presentation, and that is community and economic development. I also want to take the time and speak to you very, very briefly and speak to the employees and the public about
4:10 A concern perhaps that we have discovered and discussed and that is that we haven't spent sufficient time in these departmental presentations to really discuss what each department does. We believe and we know that members of the public and to a certain extent even council members do not understand
4:34 Fully what each department does, as you should not. But this is an opportunity for us to tell you what departments do, what they don't do. It's an opportunity for us to allow you, Council, as well as the public to ask questions.
4:50 And for us to provide information about the purpose that each department serves, what programs and services they provide, what concerns they may have, and so on. And it fits very nicely with performance measures because that's really where you start discussing at a high level what performance expectations each department should have and moreover, how those performance expectations link.
5:14 To the goals and priorities of the council and the town. So we'll be spending a little more time in presentations from here on discussing not only performance measures but also the services and the programs that the departments provide so you can link the two. For community and economic development in attachment A we present budget details. Again, no decision by the council is expected. The budget for 12-13 has been approved.
5:44 13-14 is really your baseline budget, which is part of your five-year restructuring plan. We also present prior year actuals, as we have done for every other department. And we do that for both community and economic development and workforce housing. We talk about positions. We also included separately...
6:05 As part of the workforce housing portion, the contract costs for Mammoth Lakes Housing and the breakdown of those costs. And lastly, recommended performance measures, as I indicated, for the CED department and housing are included.
6:23 And as we go forward, and I'm going to say it again and again, it's going to be repetitive and it's intentional, as we go forward with this process and move us closer to 13-14 budget process, we want to make sure that we start building a truly performance-based budget that includes performance measures in addition to financials.
6:46 On Mammoth Lakes Housing, a number of attachments have been provided. We attempted to capture questions that have been asked in the last few weeks when various Mammoth Lakes Housing related items were before Council and attempted to provide responses to those questions in these attachments. So what you have, and I'm not going to discuss in detail any of these attachments, but we are available to answer your questions. So what you have are five attachments.
7:15 One is investments that the town has made in the area of workforce housing for information. That question came up recently. Attachment B2 talks about or provides the breakdown of MLH's budget, which is only a portion of workforce housing expense. And the budget breakdown is provided both on the revenue side and the expenditure side.
7:41 B3 talks about customers served and assets that are owned by MLH. B4 talks about housing activities, duties and responsibilities of the town. And the intent here is really to show that MLH provides so many services to the community that if the town were only to provide what is legally mandated, the scope of services would shrink considerably.
8:05 B-5 is an item that continues to the regular portion of the agenda, and it has to do with a request from MLH to forgive the $900,000 loan. This information was before you previously, and it is continued in attachment B-5. We also wanted to take this... Yes, sure. Because I recall as I was reading this, maybe I missed it, and I didn't hear it tonight.
8:37 Do we have a total of the funding through the Measure A housing, and there's your, whatever it is, the Measure A housing ordinance, do we have the total of the funding that has been raised, or the revenue that has been raised as a result of that, the passage of that ordinance from its inception until now?
9:03 I do not believe we have that number, but we can easily provide it to you. It seems to be that's a pretty important number to compare it to the amount of money that's actually spent. Great. Most of that money is going to be reflected in attachment B1 because whatever housing expenses the town has incurred since the passage of measure A is going to be in B1. But I don't think it will. It struck me as I...
9:35 Reviewed this, that we raise a lot more money than actually goes, for example, to contract payments. Now, I'm not looking, you know, to sort of expose that money has been spent when it shouldn't have been spent. That's not at all. But it just seems to me to be very helpful.
9:58 For us to know what actually has been raised and designated as a result of that ordinance in comparison to the direct expenditures and for that matter the indirect expenditures because of course community development has housing expenditures as well. We will try to get an answer for you by the end of this workshop because I think it's relatively easily accessible if not through the budget document definitely through the financial system so Cindy can run that report for us. Great, thanks.
10:27 What we also promised you in the past, and this was just a good fit as far as this information is concerned, is present to you a summary of the town's assets. Not all assets, we did not include streets or sewers or things of that nature, but most of the real estate assets, pieces of land, buildings attached to it, such as community center.
10:53 We wanted for you to have an idea of what the town owns, what value that land, that those real estate assets have. As you will notice, and I think it's here on the slide, staff is not recommending that we sell or transfer any of our real estate assets.
11:17 Especially in today's low real estate market. But it's important for us to have this discussion for you to see and for the community to see what assets the town owns. So that's the catchment scene. Our next budget review is going to be on February the 20th in the format of a workshop. And the focus is going to be on recreation and measures R&U. And I think with this, I am ready to turn it over to Ellen for her to walk you through her part of the presentation.
11:49 That focuses more on the Community and Economic Development Department, what they do, their staffing, workload, and so on. In the meantime, I'm going to excuse myself just for a few minutes. I was checking to see if Cindy is here and see if I could get an answer to you on Measure A. Unless there's anything else. I think what we would suggest is allow Ellen to go through her presentation and then we'll be available for questions if that's okay. That's fine. Thank you. I'll be winging this a little bit, but
12:47 And you've seen some of this before. This is really, I think, a recap of the presentation that we gave back to you in October during the restructuring presentation, actually in a slightly briefer format at that time. And I think that presentation may have got a little bit lost in the noise of just the overall bigger discussion, primarily because community development at that time wasn't really part of the contentious items up for discussion. The decisions had been made. There were certain positions being lost or attrition that were just going to be carried forward.
13:16 And so at that time we presented to you really a sense of where we were at as a department relative to the restructuring plan and as that related to the approved 12-13 budget. So this first slide is the budget approved 12-13. I won't go into the details. It's not really relevant. And the second slide is really where we stood at the time of restructuring with about 7.75 FTEs, the principal planner myself acting in the management role for the department.
13:45 With our planning staff and our building staff as well. And then some staff shared between finance and community development for TOT. And then permit technician funded at a halftime rate. So that was the approved plan. We are currently...
14:04 Having our permit technician work full-time through a temp arrangement, and that will be a time for discussion in the next year's budget. But this is where we stand right now. And as you know, I recently resigned my position from the town. Another, the administrative analyst will also be leaving. And so that's going to have an effect on what we do. And I think at this point, we're still trying to determine what the best way to move forward is. But that's one of really the messages of tonight is.
14:32 You know, additional changes are on the foot and likely in terms of the organization of the department. This slide really tells us this is where we're at in 2008-78. We added a data point for where we will be with mine and Karen Seiber's departure down to a little over six FTEs, assuming that positions aren't backfilled.
15:01 And this is just a little bit about what we do. Some of the core functions of the department, including collecting revenue through the TRT Enforcement Program that Community Development has helped to spearhead and staff and bring to a very successful place at this point, where I think something close to two-thirds of our revenue target achieved at this point. Having support for some of our special events, things that impact visitors to town.
15:24 Through our planning efforts, encouraging investment and improving our commercial districts through projects like the zoning code update, the mainstream plan, performing strategic planning efforts, figuring out where we need to go and how we need to get there, and working in partnership with our outside organizations as well in all of those efforts. And then finally, continuing to work to streamline and improve our processes and our things to make ourselves more efficient, to offer better service.
15:50 With the dwindling staff resources that we've had over the years. This is just some more statistical information on our permit services, a high level of activity in terms of inspections, code compliance, customer service, greeting people at the counter, being really the face of the town in many respects, along with the finance department since they moved up to that area, providing support for our commissions.
16:15 And something I'm going to mention, or go into a little bit more depth on, is giving a lot of support to other departments in the town. I think community development, maybe more than most departments in the town, has been able to really reach out, provide services where they've been needed, TOT in particular, but also for Public Works Engineering, for the airport.
16:34 And to provide the depth and level of technical support for those departments to keep those projects and those really essential services elsewhere in the organization moving forward. Just more on that really is it, you know, we've had a lot less staff and we've picked up a lot more work. So these are some of the things that we've picked up over the years, the last couple of years.
16:57 And in all of this, our permit volumes, despite a bit of a downtick when the recession really hit, have been remarkably consistent. We have a high permit volume. What's really changed is the size of the valuation of those permits. So we have a lot of people coming through the door, people making small improvements, remodels, improving their property, small tenant improvements, and that sort of thing.
17:23 But the numbers of permits stay the same. The amount of revenue and the monies that we collect in terms of permit fees from those has really gone down substantially. And that big red spike in the middle is the village and the huge amount of fees that we collected from that project.
17:37 So that's the trend. It's really, I guess, flat as the new normal. You know, we are seeing some uptick in development activities, some sense that projects are coming back, that there's a desire to revisit some of these previous entitlements, come forward and reinvest in Mammoth, and the community development department is really the face, and the department provides that service. Ellen, while you're on that one, what's...
18:03 What's the change between the peak and where we are today? Is that a 20% decline or a 1,000% decline? I think you could probably, if you were to, like, normalize that data, you know, that $182,000, you know, peak would, you know, that was pretty, that was an anomaly. That was really one very, very large construction project that really spiked the values in 2005 and 2006. And, you know. If you use 50.
18:33 You used 50, I don't know if you can do it now. So 50 is, yeah, 50 and we're down at the average valuation is around 8, 86. So there's 500% in the clients? Yeah, so it's a substantial price at 20% of the value of doing the mental arithmetic. And, you know, similar trend, we're really flat and I think that there's an inclination to think that there's not a lot of planning activity, that there's not a lot going on.
18:56 That there isn't much work for planners to do. And what this says is, well, you know what, there's actually a lot of activity at our counter, a lot of people coming in. Code compliance, you can see we had a big push on code compliance in 2010 that's really dropped off. And code compliance is one of the things that we have a hard time doing when we don't have a lot of people. It's an ongoing problem, it needs enforcement, it needs attention, and it's one of the first things to get by the wayside when we lose that.
19:23 Ellen, at this point, is our code compliance mostly the TOT enforcement? That would be principally it. We obviously deal with life safety issues. Johnny, if there's a deck about to collapse or some really significant life safety issue, obviously we deal with those first and foremost. But it's really kind of as we can. Sign issues have come up recently in the last two to three weeks, and as much as we would love to say
19:47 We're on it and we're going to do that thing. It's really hard to justify those things when you have so many more pressing demands. And so it's really a question of balancing priorities and co-compliance, like I said, is really probably one of the things that suffers the most when you use staff. And one of the other things is those minor, the major, minor, and ministerial planning permits. Are those use permits or building permits or both? So ministerial permits are building permits or, you know, over-the-counter permits.
20:15 Types of things, signed permits, that kind of thing. Actually, I don't think those are included in those numbers. These are just, these are planning permits. These are, okay. So it's not, that's not including permits. All right. Major permits are things like use permits that will go to the planning commission, and then minor permits are more like administrative design reviews, things that require a little bit more review but not, are a discretionary decision by the town, but still require staff time to accomplish.
20:40 And this is a, you know, I think, this Rastafarian bar chart here is, you know, a little bit of a, you know, or it's like green, yellow, red, the warning lights are coming on. And so the first two bars are really the change from the 12-13 budget and the effects of restructuring and where
21:01 We assessed that workload would have to shift and levels of effort go down and that those numbers represent the numbers of FTEs that are dedicated to those various, you know, major connectivity areas for the department. You know, all of them show a decline and I think in that, and I think I mentioned to you in October when I gave, I think I showed you the same slide, is we really made an effort not to
21:24 Sacrifice TOT in all of this. So we took, you know, we made adjustments in other places in order to keep TOT at the same level. And despite that, you know, the number of people dedicated to TOT enforcement has gone down. And that might, you know, I think that to some degree is sustainable given that there was a sort of big startup effort with that program to develop the program to come up with regulations to figure out how to actually do TOT enforcement properly.
21:48 So this was our effort back in October to kind of give you a sense of what
22:19 The effects of restructuring would be. And I think the same thing, we added the words and attrition to this, which is you're losing people. It's going to make, you know, both my departure and just the general loss of staff makes it harder to be in that position to be ready for reinvestment.
22:34 Because we're focusing on the core things, the business coming through the door, rather than the thinking and the planning ahead and making the changes that we need for Mammoth to be truly ready for reinvestment when, you know, and it's starting to happen already. And so we may even be a little behind the curve on that. It's more difficult for us to turn applications around quickly, to do the same-day turnarounds on permits, to do the, you know, the one-week review for plan checks that our contractors and local developers have come to expect.
23:03 It makes it harder for us to give the support that we currently do to all the departments. Jen's done a fantastic job in supporting the airport and really giving that part of the town's operations some of the care and feeding that it needed in terms of the public and moving the airport land use planning pieces forward to UT collection capital, as I mentioned.
23:24 With fewer staff means it's just harder for us to keep on top of the things that we should be doing to be in compliance with state law, with our housing requirements, with the monitoring we have to do to help our planning commission to do its job by being timely with our agendas, by working with them strategically to move forward on their projects and priorities. And the thing that's very, very hard to quantify is what do we do when that big project walks through the door?
23:52 Because it's going to happen someday, you know, maybe not in the next two months, but, you know, in the next one to two years, I think we're going to see those big projects coming back to town and expecting that high level of services as we've got a great project for you, Mammoth Lakes, how can you help us to get it done? And, you know, I think that's one place where we can certainly look to other, I mean, call it outsourcing or just call it contract services to say we have these bits of work and these projects that come in.
24:21 And we need to be ready to service those projects and give them the attention that they need so they can move forward. And those things are hard to anticipate, but it's almost certainly going to happen. Pursuing grant funding, we've definitely had a decreased level of effort in the amount of grants we've been pursuing. Just because grant writing takes time, you want to be thoughtful. And grants are the thing that set you up for the next two to three years' worth of...
24:47 of work because it usually takes that long to write the grant and get awarded, get the projects going and so on. So right now we're doing very little grant, in community development at least, grant application work. And then finally, which is the heart seeks above the screen and I can't read it. So it's, you know, obviously the cumulative effect is really one of everything being harder to do. It's both our core services.
25:12 It's getting the priority projects done, the zoning code update, maintain tiers of compliance, and, you know, I'm not going to repeat myself, but, you know, you can understand that with less people, it's just harder to get everything done. So what are we doing to address these issues? Well, community development, I think, has been one of the departments that has really taken the lead in trying to be innovative, to come up with new ways to do business, to make our processes more efficient and effective.
25:43 The technology improvements that we're investing in or working on implementing are really a critical part of that. We're continuing to push forward with the e-permitting and to allow people to apply for permits online, improving our archiving records management system so that it's not nearly as laborious to create the good project record and files that we need to keep as part of our business records, and expanding use of BasicGov system to encompass TOT.
26:11 And we're seeing, you know, those things require a sustained effort, and we need to continue to push forward on them, and it's, you know, it's going to be challenging, but we understand that we need to do those things. Those are really essential. Again, grant funding, we're looking for ways to fund the activities that we need to do. These are essential functions. We've been very successful at getting grants in the past, and there's no reason to think that we can't continue to be successful in that. And then, as I mentioned, permit streamlining. And then, to the extent that we can,
26:39 Looking at ways to get assistance with the stuff that we do. And code compliance might be an area where there is opportunities for volunteer help, contract planning for some of these more of these projects that come through the door, and some low level. But much of the work that we do in reality is pretty technical. I mean, it requires a certain amount of expertise. We have an incredibly experienced staff here with, you know,
27:03 Five, between five and, you know, 10, 12 years of experience, I mean, really cumulatively a great skill set that is very hard to replace on the fly and with volunteers, except at a fairly low level. I mean, you don't really want to get it wrong. So that is really, I mean, it's not a great conclusion. There's not any more to say at the end. But I think, you know, at this point, obviously, there's something, you know, we need to figure out how to move forward to
27:32 Allow the Department to continue to function and to do as many of the things that we're doing and the positive things that we're doing as well as we can, given the resources constraints that we have. And Mariana and Cindy and I have had a lot of conversations about what those constraints are and sort of the framework within which we need to operate. And so I think we're starting to formulate a plan, I think, that will help us to certainly get through this fiscal year, again, relying really on our...
27:58 The great staff that we have to continue doing the good work that they're doing. People ask me, what's the best thing about working for the town? And it's really the staff that I've had to work with. It's truly a privilege to have such a great team that are incredibly competent, self-directed, know what they're doing, know how to get it done. And I think they're going to continue to do that in my absence. So I feel very positive about that.
28:23 And then going forward, it's really, I think, there are some bigger questions, obviously, with the budget, you know, just in terms of what roles different departments, you know, to play, what the different management needs are, and those things, I think, will be resolved in the next few months. But in the short term, I think we're in a good spot to continue to do what we can to keep the really essential things that we're doing moving forward. So, any questions? Thank you, Ellen.
28:51 Jill? I have a question, and it's on page 404 on attachment aid on the recommended performance measures. Since this says community economic development slash housing, do these performance measures only relate to what the town staff does, or does it also incorporate what Mammoth Lakes Housing does? These are intended to apply both to the town and to Mammoth Lakes Housing, although I think for housing,
29:21 You know, it could apply to both. I mean, that's the reason why we wouldn't have the same thing. Okay, because then number four under housing, I'm having trouble figuring out what that means. Well, this was really based, I think this number four is really more one for Mammoth Lakes Housing, is that typically nonprofits, you know, it's a pretty common conformance standard for you to say, well, if you're an organization that's supposed to deliver a certain package of services,
29:50 You know, at least 65% of what you do, and it could be staff time as well, but it's not administration and overhead and doing the other stuff. It's actually working with your clients, delivering your services, and it's just a measure of efficiency and how you as an organization are expending your funds to accomplish the things that your organization is supposed to achieve, which in this case is delivering housing programs and services.
30:14 Okay, I'm used to working with state grants where you only got 10% overhead. So I'm going, oh, this one's... Okay, and so that, and is that something that Mammoth Lakes Housing is able to meet? Yeah, we reviewed these with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And then one other question is, I know you made the comment that...
30:40 Applying for grants takes time, but I also notice that in our five-year plan, additional grants to continue some of our planning efforts or other things are anticipated, I believe, in our five-year budget. And I'm just... I don't recall the counted money that we haven't actually received. Okay, that's kind of the question I was asking. You need to stop doing that. Good. You don't always get the grants that you're applying. Yes, that's where I was heading with that, is we're not counting money we don't have yet, right?
31:10 Okay. Yeah, it's a risky strategy. Yeah. It took a while to get out of that habit. Those are my questions. Okay. Anybody else? John? Ellen, you worked with what other municipalities before Mammoth? Prior to joining the town, actually, I worked for a consulting firm. Okay. And so we worked for a range of different cities and counties, mostly in Northern California and the Bay Area. How many years? I have about 12 years in total.
31:40 Between the town and the consulting company. The reason I asked is, in my mind, this is performance-based budgeting, and would you say that that type of budgeting is typical, normal?
31:59 It seems like there's, I mean, I would say it's not a universal trend. It seems like a lot of cities are adopting performance-based budgets. It's a really difficult thing to do, I think. I mean, and Marianna can speak to it as well, is, you know, one, you know, some of the questions I had when I was developing these was, you know, you really have to be, you want your measures to be aligned with the goals that you're trying to accomplish. I mean, those are the things and they should be, you know, specific and measurable and all of those things. And so,
32:27 You know, I think it's a useful tool. I think, you know, working towards having a set of goals that you're working towards and being able to evaluate your progress, you know, that seems to be a pretty reasonable way to work. I was just concerned that there, I mean, our staff is limited to begin with, and I don't, personally, I don't want my staff working, focusing 15% of their productive work time on...
32:52 Working on performance-based budgeting measures as opposed to doing the work that they need to do. Yeah, I think you'd have to think about the, you know, there's a cost to doing business and, you know, to monitoring and tracking and doing those things. And so I think when I was coming up with my measures at least, I was thinking about what things do we already measure and have the data to know because it's, you know,
33:16 When you try and set a standard that requires collecting a whole bunch of new stuff, I mean, that does generate a lot of work and you report it and, you know, there should be an outcome of that effort. Thank you. Ellen, you know, each of us has a similar or different set of priorities which may be consistent with what the department is doing or not. So if Mark were standing there, I would ask him this question.
33:47 Where are you on the zoning code update and can you commit to a time when it will be completed? We are making, I would say, very good progress with the zoning code update. We're moving forward with bringing chapters forward to the planning commission for review. You know, I think we're generally on track. We are putting more time and effort into the commercial zoning discussion, I think, than we had anticipated when we, you know, months ago when we were talking about our schedule.
34:15 There. So, you know, it's going to be a push. And I've talked with Sandra and Jessica in particular about kind of, you know, because we know that's a project that needs to be, we need to maintain momentum on it to get it done. We have a grant funding deadline that's, you know, going to be here before we know it. And we have a lot of work to do. So I think that has to, we have to make the focus on that goal in order to get it done. I think we're generally on track, but it's going to be a push.
34:43 When you say you're on track, how long is the track? What do you expect? How long is the track? I think we're looking to, the timeline we have is to publish a public review draft, meaning a complete, you know, consolidated, compiled zoning code that you can actually hold in your hand and understand it looks like a zoning code somewhere in April, May.
35:07 Of this year. Of this year? Of course, yeah, this year. And then we have to do a secret process on that. And, you know, I would say that we are aiming to be going to public hearings on that document in the summer. Okay, that's very encouraging to me.
35:26 I don't want to overpromise, but it's... No, I understand. ...that's where we want to be because it's been a long time coming and we've spent a long time doing it and it's like to lose the momentum that we currently have would be pretty... Well, in particular because we've got to get it to match the district plans that have been approved and that remains a very high priority for me and I'm very pleased to hear that. I was hoping as you were speaking that you weren't going to say 2014.
35:53 I hope not. I mean, I think we need to be mindful in particular about some of these. You know, I think there are some discussions that bigger changes maybe because I think what we want to make sure is that the zoning code really remains within the umbrella of the general plan. Yeah. And if it looks like it's going straight too far outside of that envelope, that that's when it could be a longer-term effort because it, you know, just provokes a whole set of discussions about thresholds and people and all these things.
36:22 That's going to be kind of a critical checking point, I think, in the next couple of months is are we still there, are we still within those bounds, and that's the thing that's going to probably drive the timeline more than anything. But, you know, I don't see any reason why we wouldn't get it done this year. Thanks. Unless, well, you know. I'm not going to, I mean, it's just three months ago I said something. Any other questions? No, that's it. Thank you.
36:51 I just had a couple, if you don't mind. So understanding that the zoning code update and working on the downtown neighborhood district plan and TFT enforcement and permitting are probably priorities from what we've outlined and we've worked on. You guys are strapped over there and you're doing a lot. If you had something that could really help you get those done, what would it be?
37:17 You know, the thing that we've, and I've had a lot of conversations with the staff recently, just because we're like, oh my God, what is he going to do? And I think what I've heard, and I agree with this, is that what we lack is some of the, I would call like sort of lower level assistance to just to get some of that core rote stuff done. So, you know, the tree permits and the sign permits and the simple plan checks.
37:45 You know, it's just the day-to-day work. And I mean, Jen is really absorbing a lot of that work right now and then moving up to some of the larger projects as well. And where we, you know, obviously can best deploy the technical skills that we have is really to get things like the zoning code update done because that's a longer term and more complex project. And, you know, what's killing us is all this little stuff that we have to take care of every day. And it's still important. It's, you know, absolutely a critical part of what we do.
38:13 But it does, you know, it takes away from doing some of these other things that are, you know, I think are mission critical longer term and essential for them to be ready for investment when it comes back. Okay. And then you mentioned, so knowing that permitting and some of that stuff that takes up your valuable time, you mentioned self-serve. You're talking about, like, computerization for permitting? Yeah, what we're working on, and again, Jen Jen is actually spearheading this. We put it in her court because she's a...
38:42 You're a great person at sort of driving these things forward, being a bird dog on them, is that we are working with BasicGov to develop that. It's really a customer portal that involves deciding what permits can actually be BE permits, meaning that you don't have to have a structural review or a special plan, a plan check.
39:05 These are really like the re-roof permits, the small electrical, the bathroom remodel that has really minor plumbing and electrical work. And those are the things. We're looking at some other cities and what the range of services that they offer through e-permitting to do that. So that's the building side. And on the planning side, it probably will be things like sign permits and tree permits where they're just really over-the-counter permits. They get processed very quickly. If you follow the rules and protect the boxes, you can get your permit and you're done. So that's what we're aiming towards.
39:35 You want to get it right because, you know, there's obviously there's liability and issuing permits for things and you want to make sure you're giving it the right level of scrutiny and approval, but I think that would be a huge thing. And it's just, you know, it just needs to be pushed forward. And then I think the TOT and just making that whole process of collecting and reporting, TOT revenues and compliance is the other side of that as well, and a slightly different related project is getting everything into the same system.
40:03 So we're not dealing with multiple sets of data entry and we're tracking over here. We don't have any way to tell when people are late or change their unit counts. I mean, it's really, you know, we have a long way to go in terms of making that process more efficient, but I think we can really do it. Okay. Thank you. Anybody else have any other? All right. Yes, Mariana.
40:28 I want to see if anybody in the public had anything to say as well. Let me just add, if I may, I promised to get you an answer, especially to Councilmember Wood, on the amount of revenue raised through Measure A. Our records indicate that Measure A revenue began coming to the town in fiscal year 0203. So from 0203 through fiscal year 1112, we raised approximately 7.8 million.
40:56 In the current fiscal year, the total Measure A revenue is going to be approximately $800,000, maybe a little more. So you're looking at $8.6 million in that 10-year period, including the current fiscal year that has been raised. And very quickly, on performance measures, if I may, Councilmember Riesman, it takes work to collect information for performance measures.
41:23 And by no means we know more than anyone else that staff are just overwhelmed. They're completely overwhelmed in every single department. So by no means management would want to create additional work for staff. However, what we have found in many other places where we have worked, that we've looked at, is performance measures really allow not only staff to get more clear direction from the council on what's important, what's not.
41:51 But also for the Council to make decisions. For example, in the time of limited resources, if only a certain amount of money could be spent on a particular program, a particular activity, a particular department, then performance expectations need to be adjusted, and we do that through performance measures. So it's a very helpful tool, but we will have to be mindful so we don't overload staff with data collection. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Yeah, Mickey, do you want to come up and say something?
42:22 Hello. Good evening, Council. I'm Mickey Brown. I'm Vice Chair of the Planning Commission, and I also serve on the Zoning Code Update Committee. And I just wanted to expand a little bit on some of the previous comments. First of all, I have the luxury of only having one huge focus, unlike other people, and it's really to be what I term developer ready, which is the zoning code update. It's the understanding of our development impact fees.
42:49 And ultimately solving our transportation slash parking issues. And we are making huge progress, but I just want you to understand is that the only way we're going to meet these deadlines as far as the zoning code update is that we really have to have the commitment that we pretty well can have the use of Jessica full time between now and probably to completion. And the reason that is is that
43:18 We're moving forward with our workshops. We're moving forward with our commission agenda. But there's a huge amount of staff preparation time that has to go into all those meetings. And so it's just key that, and Jessica at this point will be then the last person that has the history of working on that project from the beginning to end. So you hate to put burden on one particular person. That's going to be very key for us to hit our deadlines this year.
43:49 And thanks for that because it is a priority for us. I know last week or so there's been some rumor of why we got off track. We haven't. It's still a priority. We just need to, as a matter of fact, channel it. And that's why I was asking the questions. And I think I appreciate the input from you and Ellen and everybody as far as what it will take for us to keep this on track and keep our focus going down that path. All right. Thank you. You guys got a lot of work lined up. Yeah, a lot of work lined up.
44:20 With that, I also want to say, Ellen, thank you for everything you've done. I want to say thanks for everything you've done, Ellen. And as far as the rest of the staff and community development, I really appreciate, I mean, what you guys, I've had the opportunity to work with you and the TOT enforcement, and you guys have really stepped up to the plate and helped take it to the level it's at, and it's going to make a difference in our town, our community. I mean, a lot of people think that
44:49 Community Development is just planning. It used to be the planning department, but like you said, it goes way beyond that. You know, bringing these funds into town, it's one thing. We have, you know, marketing, bring everybody here, but if we're not collecting those funds, what's the point? And that's also the funding that keeps everything happening, the snow removal, everything else out there. So I, for one, having worked with you, really appreciate the work you've done, and thanks. I really do. I really appreciate it.
45:19 Okay, with that, I guess we should move on to housing and talk a little more about that. So, John or Rick, did you have anything? Pam, were you going to give a presentation? I don't know what the protocol is supposed to be. Neither do I. Okay. Well, I guess we could do then if anybody had any questions or comments on just the material we have, we can move down that list.
45:50 My questions relate to the item we'll be dealing with on the regular agenda. Okay. All right. And then let's see if I have any for this. I think mine related mostly to the final item as well. But let me just actually head on my iPad here. They could probably wait until the last agenda item. Okay. Yeah, I think we'll just wait. So I think most of the items we wanted to discuss were...
46:30 Related to the... Oh, actually, no, I know what I was going to talk about. So moving forward, we've spoken a bit about some of the challenges we've had with housing and ways to go about it. And I really just wanted to turn to you and Mayor Pro Tem Wood as far as a new way of moving forward with the program.
46:58 And one was to work more with private industry if we could on some of these items as opposed to just buy and build type of mentality just because we've had some issues, in my opinion, with competition out there. Sorry, I'm trying to open something here.
47:20 I would just like to see us go about it a different way, and if there's a way we can focus more and be very specific about what it is, like if there's a housing for a specific need for a specific type of employees that we desperately need up here. I remember when we first started putting housing forward, they were saying, oh yeah, we're going to be able to use housing to house our police and our teachers and people like that. And I know it was a generalization, but I think a lot of areas in a lot of specific areas
47:50 Employment areas may not even qualify for that. And I think the down payment assistance is a great program. I think if we just channel these properly. A problem that I do have is, and hopefully we can change this moving forward, is just when we have these units, these properties that are deed restricted going back and us paying to keep them deed restricted, paying multiple times to keep them deed restricted. Somebody goes and wants to turn it to market rate, we end up paying to keep it as a deed restricted property.
48:20 And I just have a bit of issue with that. I'm just hoping that moving forward, if we haven't already, I'd just like to see that addressed. And so hopefully that's something you and I or you as your group can work on. I mean, I have some suggestions I'd be happy to throw at you. That's about it. So that's all I have as far as this. And then I can wait for the rest of my comments on the last agenda item.
48:45 You know, just to sort of speak to some of the things that you're mentioning, Mammoth Lakes Housing hasn't developed a rental project since 2006. We've bought four units in one complex and rehabbed that were in terrible shape. And it struck me, as we're in an economic downturn, times have changed, but there was an article in the Times over the Christmas break about how
49:11 The people who were here were underserved. There wasn't enough workforce in the restaurants and the hotels. There was just a general lack of service-level employees. And I know that there are a variety of different housing types that we can provide and that we should be providing, and that's always been our goal. And I think that we often lose sight of how important the lowest-income earners are in this community.
49:41 One of the things we were asked for in preparation for tonight's meeting was sort of a snapshot of who it is we serve. So we went through not only our ownership lists but our rentals as well and really developed a list of all of them. We made a very brief list. It's certainly not all-encompassing. But we do service quite a few middle management as well as lower income.
50:08 Mountain employees, hospital employees, Vons employees, people that are necessary to make our community what it is. And certainly a lot of the focus is seen, at least that our focus, because we have the most number of units, is being at the lowest income, where I think it's true that people are living in better conditions than they have been. We don't see the overcrowding issues we've been seeing in 2004 and before we had gotten started.
50:38 The down payment assistance programs we offer certainly open up more doors for more people who have a little bit more income and want to make different choices and can buy a home and not want to rent or not want to live in a condo. But I think that if you really take a look at the history of the organization and where we've been and where we've come from and the changes in the programs we've made, that we've really worked to adapt to...
51:04 The changing of the community and hearing what the community is saying about what's working and not working. We want to continue to do that. We're more than happy to sit down with you and listen to different ideas about ways we can provide housing, working with the private sector, other grant and funding opportunities that are available to us to make some of those partnerships more feasible for folks. And so that's something that we're
51:32 We've always wanted to do. We want to continue to grow and expand and change with the times. And I think that the board is willing to take a look at it. The staff certainly knows and is exploring different options. For example, we're foreclosure intervention counselors these days. If you would have asked me what that was in 2006, it's a new thing that we've made up because we're trying to adapt the housing programs to the community's needs.
51:58 And I think we'll continue to do that and can continue to be successful. I think that Ellen spoke to the fact earlier that projects will come back, and when they do, there will be a further need for housing, and we need to continue to keep the infrastructure and keep the programs in place so that when that does come back, we're ready to be able to respond to those needs again.
52:24 Are there any programs, I mean, for example, subsidy programs? I assume they exist in other municipalities. I've heard of them. So instead of buying or building another property and renting it or selling it off or whatever and placing so much burden on housing in the town and even going out and getting grants that we're going to have to pay back, couldn't there be maybe a subsidy-type program that we provide the subsidy as it's needed above, let's say,
52:54 Let's say affordable housing rate may be $800 a month, the market's $1,000 or $1,200. You bridge that gap, that gap rent, if you will, just to help people get into housing. And then if the need goes away, and work with a private partner on this, if the need goes away, or if the property's not being kept up to a certain standard, you can pull it and go somewhere else where it is.
53:21 And the reason I ask that, I think there's a lot of benefit that can come from this. Not only does it fulfill the housing need, but it also doesn't create the competition. It actually encourages a lot of the empty spaces that are already out there, if any, to be filled up and be brought up to a new level. So if housing says, we'll subsidize a certain two-bedroom condo on Lupin Street.
53:48 But it has to be up to our standards. And that will encourage that property owner to bring that level of service up, quite honestly, for that person. And another thing I think can happen is as our market starts to become full or saturated and there's not enough housing, I think there can be programs put in place instead of saying, well, we're going to go out and build, housing's going to go out and build some affordable housing projects.
54:13 We put incentives out there letting the people with vacant land or with room to put more density on their property. We can encourage them that way to build another unit. It doesn't even have to be due to restricted because they know the subsidy's there. And I think that can go on. I think there's a number of different avenues that we can do where housing can fulfill the needs that it has set before it.
54:36 And we can also fulfill some of the, I think, the pitfalls that at least I perceive out there without impacting housing. And I think that's really the route I've been wanting to try to go down for some time and really lay some of these things out there. And maybe you've already looked at it and maybe there's reasons we can't do it. But I think that's just, for me, I think there's just a different way we can go about it so we don't end up having these big loans or we don't end up getting upside down on the properties or losing our
55:06 Our deep restricted properties we pay for and have it turn into market rates so we have to build another one later. I mean, they're just frustrations I feel. There's a certain constituency I have out there that I think feels that too. And I'm just really asking if there's a different way we can go about delivering the product that you want to deliver. There are programs out there, state and federal funds, that can do that kind of subsidy. Most of them require either an income limitation or there's also a rent cap so that there's not some sort of
55:33 Windfall, so to speak, going to the landlord who's taking the subsidy. And so there are limitations with that. That is something we can look at further and explore, although I'm not sure that it needs a different segment than what we're currently meeting. And it requires the landlord to meet certain requirements, which I think would be great because we do have units out there that need to be fixed up. Additionally, you know, this is the kind of program that
56:00 If the town were to restore the commitment of 1% of TOT funds, that the town could subsidize through the 1% commitment of housing funds. I mean, those funds have been diminished to the amount of the Mammoth Lakes housing contract through the restructuring process, but if that commitment was again brought back to the full 1%, those funds were used to create housing. Obviously, there's...
56:26 $900,000 we'll be talking about later tonight that was allocated to creating housing from those funds. So those other kinds of programs that don't come with state and federal dollar limitations can be utilized through the housing commitment of the town if the funds were made available to housing again. Yeah, and I guess my only real argument is just instead of us creating more housing, creating more supply out there, let's look at what we already have and improve it and find a way to get people into that and improve.
56:57 You know, the appeal of our neighborhoods. Right. Absolutely. And we can do that with state and federal sources that come with strings or we can try to use local sources that we, you know, the council would set the parameters on and through the housing allocation of TOT. Okay. And everything else? I have a couple of comments because we've got the opportunity to talk about this now. One of the things that, you know, as I have observed and participated in,
57:26 The housing part of things over the last 10 years or so is that I don't think that anybody is really sure. I know that people are sure of their perceptions, but I'm not really sure that people or that we've effectively measured and then communicated the results of the measurement of whether the community that we're serving, the constituents that you are serving.
57:52 I think we also don't know specifically whether what we are doing or what we have done, and you point out accurately that we haven't built a project in a long time, is actually interfering with the private sector. And that's information we've got to have. I mean, because I think we all take perceptions that we have into the discussion, but...
58:21 I don't know that we've effectively measured that. I think it's the responsibility of the Board of Housing, and I'm the council representative on it, to explore that, to explore different ways of doing business. I think you do that through an update of your strategic plan so that you can set goals and priorities, bring them to council, and then begin to implement things maybe in a way that's different because there are a hundred different ways to get what, you know, to spend money on housing.
58:49 I remember years ago, Kathy Cage, when she was on the council, said, buy land, buy land, buy land, because land was cheaper then than it became. Now it's cheap again. So we have no money to buy land because the revenue that's being raised is being used to pay off loans, fund the administrative activities, and the rest of it goes back to the general fund. We've cut into it. So there's that debate that always goes on, and we ought to continue to have it. The other thing that I'm not sure that we really know, and I don't know if we can measure it accurately, is what the
59:18 Actual vacancy rates are. And I realize that vacancies are seasonal. And vacancies occur or are influenced, the vacancy factor or rate is influenced by whether or not there's construction in town. Because if there's big construction, like when the Westin was put up, they took all the housing. And then there was a horrible squeeze on everybody. So I think those are things that I think the board has a responsibility to bring back to
59:47 As sort of a foundation for a discussion about how we might do it differently. Because I don't think that there is just one way to do it. I mean, we've gotten tens of millions of dollars in grants that are either no longer available or we're not pursuing because we don't have matching funds. And I don't know anymore that it's just about building new housing. One of the competing theories way back when, when Kathy Cage was advocating buying land is
1:00:15 Don't build new product. This is Gordon Alper's position. Rehab, rehab, rehab. Take existing product. Either way, you're taking product that is either substandard or deficient out of the private sector and into, in effect, the public sector, which is good for the quality of life for those people who are served by it. Just two other comments. One is we have to be careful
1:00:44 If we just assume that we can solve the problem by giving a developer more density, we've been through those wars. They happened 10 and more years ago. And of course, you get the folks in the neighborhood who are impacted by the density standing up and saying, I don't want workforce housing, high density housing in my neighborhood. And we've got that quality of life social factor that has to play into this as well. We've got to find balance. And then finally, last thing I would say is the obvious, which is that we can't be short-sighted about housing because
1:01:13 It takes a long time to put in place. It takes a long time to identify a need then to find the funds put in place. And I agree with Ellen. We're going to see a turnaround. It's going to happen. In fact, the seed is already germinating, if you will, and that'll place demand that maybe we don't have now.
1:01:39 At least in the way that we're going to have it. So it's going to be important to remain long-sighted instead of short-sighted. And I think the board's got a responsibility to do a lot of things along those lines, bring it back to council so we can have a good discussion about it. Because I think we're probably all a little closer or maybe more on the same page than one might think. That's what I have. Thanks. Thank you. Anybody else? Anybody in the public want to do a comment on this? It is a workshop, so...
1:02:08 Welcome to come up and speak to if you like. Okay. Thank you, Pam. And seeing none, we'll go ahead and move from our workshop on to our regular meeting. We're a little bit late. John, do you want to take a break? Yeah, we'll take two minutes.
1:02:38 Thank you.
1:04:26 Here. Here. Here.
1:06:26 Okay, we have everybody here. Rick, do you want to do a pledge? Certainly. Please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, another God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
1:06:53 Okay. At this time, we'll go ahead and open up the podium to the public. If anybody has anything they'd like to say that's not on tonight's agenda, please come up to the podium and let us know your thoughts. Down in Hustleton. I just wanted to talk about the town manager. And I just, whatever the outcome might be, I just wanted to say that he has done a great job for the town.
1:07:34 I had the opportunity to be in meetings with him and he's made sure everything went smoothly, worked with the Forest Service very well, got things on track and made sure everything went forward. I'm sure there was people that didn't think that, but I certainly did. I had brought several issues to him. He was very positive.
1:08:01 Followed through. We didn't always agree. We butt heads on some stuff, but he was very professional. I also wanted to say how he stood up for his staff in front of council, and I just thought, you know, whatever the outcome is, I think that it could be a loss to our town. I think he was a great asset, and I just want to publicly thank him for all his hard work.
1:08:31 Thank you, Donna. Appreciate it. Anybody else in the public have anything you'd like to comment on that's not on tonight's agenda? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move from public comments on to councilmember reports. John, we'll start with you. Thank you. I have none, Mr. Mayor. Okay. Michael? I have none. Rick?
1:08:55 Just one. The Mayor and I attended the Town Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Liaison Committee meeting at the Mountain on Monday of this week, and what I want to report out is that that relationship that over the years has ebbed and flowed is flowing again. I think that the Mountain and these two representatives of the Council are very much on the same page.
1:09:23 regarding how we might and should and will grow our way out of the current fiscal issues that we've confronted over this past year. The mountain, as people know, does have a number of pending and impending development and development-related projects, including a land trade. Those things are moving forward. I don't have a specific report on progress on any of those. I simply
1:09:53 Wanted to let the other council members know that I feel like the relationship is a real positive and productive one between the town and the mountain. And, of course, as an employer of 3,000 people in the wintertime, it's an important relationship. Great. That's all I have. Thanks. Okay. Jill? Yes, I have one item. On Tuesday, Michael and I attended the Forest Service Water District and Town Liaison Committee meeting.
1:10:22 And there were some important things. While they couldn't be specific, the Water District said they feel there's been substantive progress made on a settlement, and they have another court date on February 14th. Then we spent most of the rest of the time discussing how to coordinate summer projects between the three agencies, and there will be a lot of work where we're doing street work and the Water District will do it at the same time, fortunately, instead of finishing it and tearing it back up.
1:10:53 So we hope to have that happen. And I just wanted to also point out that the Forest Service told us that their scoping process for the Shady Rest Trailhead for motorized use will be coming out soon. That process will be coming forward with they have decided which option, but we also all admitted that it might be affected somewhat by the Casa Diablo proposal.
1:11:20 But there will be something coming out shortly. And the Forest Service also reminded us all that they are one of what's called an early adopter on the forest plan revision, which means a lot of their staff planning time is going to be spent on that effort, which is at the federal level. Great. Michael, did you say you didn't have anything? Okay. I just had a couple of items. On the 31st, I attended the Wounded Warriors.
1:11:50 Luncheon up at the Main Lodge. And just every year I go there, it really makes me appreciate what we do have. It's, you know, especially in the light of a lot of the challenging things we're going through, particularly financial, you know, we think we have it pretty bad. But it really is, it's very humbling when you go up.
1:12:15 To the Wounded Warriors and you're thinking you're having a bad day because of financials and you've got these guys up there that are smiling and having a good time and some of them don't have any legs and it's humbling and it was just a great experience every year. I look forward to going to it just because I meet some really wonderful people. Also, I had another meeting with the Mammoth Mountain, actually Bill Cockroft, who's been working with Michelle Tomer on the Mammoth Bike Games.
1:12:45 Just making a little bit of progress on that every time we meet. Right now they've really got the schedule nailed down. It sounds as though they're going to be bringing the sentry, at least part of it, into town, so we'll be starting and finishing here. And really going to try to animate the rest of town now, and that's going to be our next task and goal is to start working with folks in Main Street and maybe build Mammoth Road on how we can add some other animated pieces to this to make it just a really big, vibrant event.
1:13:13 So that was a bit exciting, and I'll keep everybody updated on that. And then I had one question, and Marianna, I think you and I spoke about it, and I just wanted to clarify it before I announced it, but we spoke a little bit about the Measure U funds and the air service, and I wanted to know, were we able to clarify if those were not used for the air service?
1:13:35 The $325,000 that the general fund was supposed to borrow for a few months from Measure U, we did not have the need to eventually borrow the funds in the current fiscal year because the council gave us authority to repay back. So it was a timing issue, but at the end of the day, cash never transferred between Measure U and the general fund and the $325,000.
1:14:05 Okay. Thank you. And I ask that question because I think it's important to point out that as some other council members have stated very strongly that we do try to honor and respect the measures as best we can and not use those funds for anything other than their intended use. So while some people may think it was appropriate or not, I just want to let folks know it didn't actually end up coming out of there.
1:14:35 With that, I'll go ahead and end Councilmember reports and we can move on to commission updates. So are there any commissioners, other commissions out there that would like to come up and give an update? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to department reports and emerging issues. Good evening. I'm going to be presenting something to you a little bit later on a police reserve program, but I'd like to give you a brief update on where we are on
1:15:13 Volunteers and some technology improvements that we're looking at in the police department. We recently sent Karen Smart, retired Sergeant Karen Smart, to a course on volunteer programs where she came back with some good ideas on recruitment, selection, management, and some ideas how we can use them. I don't have a timeline of when we'll have something to you, but we will be coming back sometime in the future explaining some of those programs we'll be implementing. In the area of technology, there's several things we're looking at and working on.
1:15:42 One of them is we're working with a vendor to implement an online crime reporting system. This is done in a lot of other cities that would allow, under certain circumstances, people that want to report a relatively minor crime, they can do it online. There's no cost to do that. It means we don't need to send an officer out or have the person come into the police station and complete a report at the desk. So it adds a level of convenience for the resident and also
1:16:11 Is a reduction in workload on the police department. The cost of it is going to be relatively minor. And it will be part of a package that will be coming to the council at some time in the future on the town technology program. Another program we're looking at is an online crime reporting purchase program that some cities have started to do.
1:16:37 What we do is right now we spend time and there's a cost to get a copy of a crime or traffic report. There's limitations on who can get them, but if you're a victim of a crime or a party to a traffic accident, we will sell you or there's a fee to get the report due to the time associated with it. If we go to an online reporting system, there'll still be a review by our staff, but it won't be the copying. And the way it works, there's no cost.
1:17:03 To the town, the person who chose to use that option would pay a fee to the firm that would manage the program. The benefit to them is they don't have to come to the station. They can get it immediately, and a lot of times for insurance purposes, it makes it easier, and that cost is minimal. That's something we're going to be going forward with, and again, there will be no cost to the town to implement it. We've been working with the vendor that provides the surveillance cameras in the village. I'm happy to report that...
1:17:32 They have, I think I've told you before, there were a number of cameras in the village that were not working. They've all been repaired. The village and the mountain are expanding the number of surveillance cameras, not just in the village but on other mountain properties. And we've been exploring the opportunity to have access to those surveillance cameras, what's going on in the village and the police station.
1:17:55 Obviously, we don't have anybody to sit and monitor that, but the benefit would be when an incident occurs, we can get access to that immediately. Those cameras are recorded. It can help us solve a crime. It also saves time in us getting that copy, which is often very successful in helping get a prosecution. It means we don't have to make arrangements to get it from the village. It looks like the cost of that would be very minimal, and we've just started discussions. We've talked to them about some type of...
1:18:25 We don't know what the cost is going to be, but the vendor indicates it won't be very much. Finally, we've been looking at the same vendor at the feasibility of installing surveillance cameras at the skate park. There's a number of logistical problems that might make it not cost effective, but we're looking at options to fund that. So that's just an update on some of the things we're looking at with volunteers and technology. Any questions? Any questions for the chief?
1:18:55 Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Any other department reports? All right. We'll go ahead and move on to the... Oh, real quick. Yes. I have one for department head Ray Jarvis. I don't see Ray. Okay. I'll direct it, yeah, to Peter. My question was, if I may, is to have staff give us a report at our next council meeting on the 20th.
1:19:25 As to if there is anything we can do. What I've noticed, and I've noticed it over several years, is that most of the malls and most of the businesses remove their snow after a snowstorm. If they don't remove it, they'll pile it into a location at the property for snow storage. And then eventually, you know, when it clears up and they have time,
1:19:49 And their snow removal company has time, then they'll go ahead and have it removed. But I've also noticed that there are malls and businesses in town that just pile the snow at the start of the season and there's no storage area and then just leave it there. And the problem is, there's a number of problems. One is it's unsightly over time. Another one is that it becomes a public safety risk because it melts and creates ice.
1:20:17 In and around the snow storage area where people can slip and fall. And then the third thing is that it removes parking for the customers that want to use that business by leaving the snow there all winter. So if I knew that there was an ordinance or some kind of code compliance that we could maybe enforce that in some of the areas, that would be helpful. Yeah, we can bring back a report and we do have an ordinance that discusses snow storage on site. Okay, great. Thank you.
1:20:47 Okay, thanks, John. Okay, so we'll move on to the consent agenda. And is there any items that council members want to pull? I would like to pull six and seven. Okay, Joe's pulling six and seven. Mr. Mayor, I'll move that the council adopt consent. I'd like to actually ask the public if there's any. Anybody in the public have any idea if they want to pull off consent? Okay, sorry, John. That's fine. Then I'll move for adoption of consent agenda items 2, 3, 4, 5, and 8.
1:21:17 Second. Okay, we've got a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. We'll go ahead. Joe, you wanted to talk about 6 and 7? Yes. On the cell phone policy, it was brought up by an email I received today that on page 1 of the policy, we don't have a handwritten number.
1:21:46 But the second paragraph under B, Policy, talks about sell your phone should not be considered the primary contact number for staff, but some of our staff that are in the field a lot of the time use that cell phone quite regularly. So I didn't know if there was maybe some way to have some slightly different wording that make it clear that if you've got someone who their whole job is to be out in the field saying they're supposed to call the desk number doesn't make much sense.
1:22:16 What if we added to that sentence? Acceptance. Something like that, yeah. Something like that, and so add some wording into that. Okay. Anybody else comment on that? No. Okay, then in that case, I would move that we adopt the resolution as Andy will amend it, approving the town's cell phone policy. Okay, so that's item number six.
1:22:46 Yes.
1:22:47 Okay, so is that a motion then?
1:22:49 Yes.
1:22:50 Okay, so we have a motion to...
1:22:52 A second.
1:22:53 A second to pass item number six.
1:22:56 Go ahead and get a roll call on that.
1:22:57 Councilmember Vickie?
1:22:58 Yes.
1:22:59 Councilmember Vickie?
1:22:59 Yes.
1:23:00 Councilmember Vickie?
1:23:00 Yes.
1:23:01 Councilmember Vickie?
1:23:01 Yes.
1:23:02 Councilmember Vickie?
1:23:02 Yes.
1:23:02 Yes.
1:23:03 Okay, and then item number six, Jo?
1:23:06 Number seven, I wanted to make sure I understood in this one how long this,
1:23:15 It's...
1:23:16 Policy would be in effect. You know, it says at the end of the program, but is this something where it's just for the winter season, or is it all the time when we don't have snow? I just wasn't sure. So the experimental program would be to follow at the next three-day weekend, which is the president's weekend. And then kind of seeing how that goes and discussing it with police department, fire department, and adjacent property owners to make it a permanent parking area.
1:23:46 You have a limited parking area, the two or three hour limited parking duration along that one side of the street. Okay. With the permanent, we need to do some repairs on the west side of the road, so that would be in conjunction with the resolution to come to council for that. Okay, so you're thinking to have it for President's Day weekend and then review it? If it's snowing, we wouldn't implement it. Right. Because without the permanent striping, it's still a little bit difficult for people to park.
1:24:16 Adjacent to the Kirk Winter Snow. Peter, could you, for the benefit of the public, describe what it is this agenda bill, this experimental program is? Sure. With some discussions with some of the business owners and the village company, staff put together an experimental program that Martin Luther King's weekend to try to add some additional public parking in and around the village area.
1:24:44 And in that program included Hillside Drive on street parking and Burner Street on street parking. And we plowed the parking lot at the tenant's courts. And so with that, it added quite a bit of parking, although there were a few problems due to, you know, not really looking at all the existing parking signs that were in and around the area. So what happened was...
1:25:13 Since there was no parking signs in areas that we didn't want parking, it's essentially people and visitors parked in all streets within the area. We've since corrected that, added more parking signs along Canyon Boulevard, which isn't really wide enough for on-street parking. And Burnett Street really isn't quite wide enough to have on-street parking either unless we've made it a one-way street. So with that correction, kind of observing how parking...
1:25:42 We call it an experimental program because we're just testing it to see how it works. And we didn't have a sandwich board or any signage at the tennis courts, so that really was not utilized at all. So for this program, we'd go ahead and put a sandwich board out. We were pretending to try to have that for the workers at the village area, but rather than get no use, it'd be nice to get some use and people can use that.
1:26:11 It's already signed to allow parking throughout the day. It's not limited time parking, but not any overnight parking. So that, you know, it is providing a little bit more parking within the village area. And then the agenda bill also describes some additional options that over long term where additional parking may be available through some construction or paving of existing not paved lots in the area.
1:26:40 I know some of those things come with costs. Great, thank you. Okay, that's helpful. Thank you. All right, so if I understand, option one says continue the experiment through, essentially, I'm just summarizing, continue the experiment through the President's Day weekend, and then you'll be meeting with staff and come back to us if there is a different permanent solution. Correct. Okay, then I'll move approval of option one. I'll second that. We have a motion in a second. I have a roll call, Jamie. Yes.
1:27:12 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Motion passes 5-0. We'll move on to item number 9, which is the confirmation expiration of a temporary reduction in plan check process. Ellen? Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. The purpose of this item is to bring for your consideration the confirmation that a
1:27:44 Waiver reduction in the building permit fee, which was approved in 2009 and scheduled to sunset in August 2010, but has not been actually enacted, that sunsetting has not been enacted, to confirm that that should actually occur. The agenda bill provides some additional detail and background on that fee waiver. Separately from that, the council has previously discussed
1:28:08 Waiver of the DIF fees and has approved reductions of those. It will carry forward until August of this year. However, the previous discussion by the Council did not address this particular aspect, which was a continuation of this waiver that was provided for that really covers the plan check fee, inspection fee, archive fee, and so on in that reduction. We've given you a little bit of information just so you have a sense of the value of that fee to
1:28:35 Some of our developers by giving you some actual project examples and values associated with those. For example, the fee waiver on a million-dollar, home with a million-dollar construction valuation was approximately $8,900. For an approximately 12-month period between 2011 and 2012, the town waived a total of $45,000.
1:28:59 And average over the past two years has been approximately $50,000 a year. So that's the estimate that we have come up with that the town would actually recoup if it were to continue and to reinstate that fee as was intended by the original resolution. Obviously, if that fee was allowed to sunset or the townhouse would not give direction, that it should be continued.
1:29:24 Then the town would continue not to collect those monies and continue to contribute to the deficit that we see in between the cost of providing services and the money that we recover for those plan check and permit fees. And obviously we're having to pass on the dollar value that contractors and developers will pay when they come in to submit projects because those fees will go up based on the sunset.
1:29:53 Thank you. Thank you.
1:30:23 Okay. Thank you, Ellen. I guess I'll open it up to Council for discussion then. Ellen, I have a question. How long has this been in place? The resolution was adopted in 2009, February 2009, and was scheduled to sunset in August of 2010. So it was approximately a year and a half
1:30:48 The fee waiver program intended to stimulate development at that time alongside the diff waiver. And while the diff waiver has been extended, this was not confirmed alongside that diff waiver, which is why we're returning to you. So technically, if we did nothing, the sunset would have occurred and we can continue to charge that fee tomorrow. Otherwise, if we wish for it to continue, we would have to return for a resolution that would approve the fee waiver on a more formal basis. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions for Ella?
1:31:17 Anybody in the public have any questions on this item? Okay. We'll bring it back to Council then. Yes, John? My thoughts are twofold. One is that I would like to see this extended until August 15, 2013 to coincide with the extension of the DIF payment. And also the second part of my thoughts are that in deference to a substantial segment of our community, the construction industry,
1:31:47 Contractors Association and so forth. I think that it would be a sign of good faith to them to continue this until the 2013 August date as well. Okay. Anyone else? Actually, I'm going to speak as to letting it sunset and to consider it again when we look at DIF over the next couple of months. The reason being that at this point in time, General Fund is subsidizing
1:32:17 The community development and building an economic department to the tune of $800,000 and that if we keep these fees down, we're saying right now that we don't have the money to hire staff and yet then if we keep giving all these waivers, we're definitely not going to have the money to hire staff. So my feeling is that it should have sunsetted and we would look at it in connection with the diff. Anyone else? Michael, any comments? No. Okay. Rick?
1:32:48 I don't have any comments. Okay. I see both sides of that one. I'd probably say I'd be in favor of maintaining it on a temporary basis. At least, John, I think it's a good idea to make it coincide with the other diff reduction. We can wait it out until August. Kind of a, with so little new home construction going on, I don't know if the impact's that huge.
1:33:20 Did you happen to have the numbers for, say, like a year? Yeah, the value of the waivers or the amount that the town has given in waivers has been, on average over the past two years, about $50,000, so it's $45,000. Per year? Over a 12-month period, most recently. Okay. So I think through November of 12, through December 11. Okay, great, thanks.
1:33:43 Okay. Well, with that, I'll look to entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion that the council adopt option number two, request the staff prepare a resolution to allow the temporary 50% reduction of plan check fee process and inspections fee and 100% reduction to the archive fee for single-family homes to continue to coincide with the diff expiration date of August 15, 2013. Okay. Do we have a motion? Do we have a second?
1:34:13 I'll second that. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Jamie? No. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. We have a motion. Passes 4-1. We will turn with the resolution on probably February the 20th. Okay. Great. Thank you, Ellen. Okay. With that, we'll move on to item number 10, which is the adoption of an ordinance establishing standards for new
1:34:42 Reconstructed Wood Stove Inserts, and I'll be done by our Senior Building Inspector, Johnny. Mayor, Town Council, Community. Why we're here tonight, as some of you know, is we have an issue in town regarding wood stove inserts installed in the prefab fireboxes. What you have in front of you is an ordinance that our town attorney has put together. We have people in the audience.
1:35:10 The contractors, the Board of Appeals, Bruce Woodward, and the fire district, Tom Heller and Chief Harper. What we've done over the past, since 2010, has the town staff and the fire district and the contractors working in collaboration with industry professionals throughout the country, meaning NFPA, testing laboratories, UL and Omni.
1:35:38 Realized we have an issue in town. And what has happened is we've had, to be very frank, we've had eight fires. All the fires have had a common denominator where we've had charring of a certain framing member that was installed correctly at the time of original installation 30, 40 years ago. And when the wood stove insert was installed,
1:36:05 For all intents and purposes, we had basically a self-certifying program where instead of ripping off your entire wall, we allowed a self-certifying thing. And somewhat standard in the industry, however, in our climatic zone where we burn fires far more frequent than a normal person in Southern California.
1:36:29 The heat that's generated, the BTUs that are generated with the wood stove insert in a prefab firebox has created an incredible amount of pyrolysis. To put it in perspective for you, like I said, we've had eight fires in 10 years. Some may say that's not a great amount of fires. However, we've had certain complexes that the HOAs have put a moratorium on it.
1:36:58 And we found 27 out of the 60 units that had pyrolysis. So it was just a matter of time. It was a ticking time bomb. With the heat generating on a more frequent basis, it's just a matter of time. And the one thing I would say is we've had eight fires and zero injuries. And so from my personal opinion, my professional opinion, that's, you know, eight might not seem like a lot, but it's one too many.
1:37:27 So what we did was we came with, like I mentioned, the contractors, all four installers, the board of appeals, the fire district, all in a group effort over a year's period of time and put together a list of more stringent requirements. If you want to put a wood stove insert in your house, that's fine, but you need to do these eight items. These eight items in 20 or 30 years,
1:37:57 Will allow us to sleep at night and not say, you know, what were you thinking? It does add to the cost of this. However, someone's life and safety, there should be no dollar amount. So what we put together is an ordinance to be adopted to be part of the sale of transaction. We're not asking people to stop with the wood stove inserts.
1:38:25 But we're giving you a 10-year time frame to fix it and take it out. And I think it's very important to say that the town, the fire district, the contractors, the board of appeals who are appointed by you all are all on board with this. We've gone over this every which way we possibly can. And everyone feels confident.
1:38:52 I believe it's appropriate to say, you know, the chief is here, but the fire commissioners, their board has approved this. Our town attorney has approved this. And with that, I'll take any questions. I'm not as good as Ellen up here, but hopefully you get the gist and I can answer it in a, you know, a layman's type if we need to. I've got Tom here. I've got Scott from Clean Sweep here.
1:39:22 Bruce Woodward is here from the Board of Appeals. So with that, we would ask you with one minor clarification on the ordinance to approve, and Andy may have to help me here, but to waive the first reading with one minor clerical error, and the clerical error would be to add in in the ordinance. Let me help you out because I have my notes.
1:39:53 Just due to a drafting error in the process, there was one requirement that Johnny and Tom wanted to include that I think is a good one to include that just didn't make it into the draft that you have. So that additional language would require as part of the installation of a new insert that the contractor also has to certify in writing that they've educated the homeowner about how to use the insert, how to properly burn wood with the insert, and how to store firewood near the insert. So that's it. That's the only little...
1:40:23 I think we'd like to add to the draft that you have. Okay. Yes, John. Johnny, thank you. You mentioned that one condominium project has put a moratorium on those at that particular project. Had. Had. Okay. It seems like this is pretty black and white and pretty clear that this is a problem. I think my curiosity is, was there any discussion on making
1:40:53 This, giving this a shorter time frame in the community to get these inserts replaced? Was there any discussion in having a shorter time frame? Than 10 years? Yes. 10 years seems pretty lenient. And there was discussion about it. There were some of us on one side of the fence that said do it within a year. We all agreed that even if we did it within a year, there's...
1:41:23 There's four contractors in town that install wood stove inserts. If we said a year, we'd still be dealing with this in six years. We would. We wouldn't be able to replace all the inserts in one year. And it would take you six years or seven? There's between 3,000 and 4,000 of these installations in there. Okay. It's just a number. Okay. I think I was...
1:41:54 You know, I think all four contractors are amazing contractors. One is here right now today, and I think they can get three to four done a week. So if you just extrapolate out the numbers with the winter conditions and when people sign up, it's still a checkbook that's involved.
1:42:19 To lessen the pain, you know, we gave people time, we gave it to the sale of property, and I think from my point of view, and I believe Tom's, and he can get up here and speak as well, we're very comfortable with the 10-year time frame. Okay. For some reason I'm not. I'd like to shorten it to five. I mean, is that too ambitious still? Because we know even if it's 10,
1:42:48 They're not all going to get changed out in 10 years. There's going to be some people that don't do it for whatever reason. Someone bigger than me is coming behind me. Okay. Chief, hi. Not taller. That's a tough decision. I think I agree with you. I'd like to have them all out because we're somewhat just waiting for another accident. We've identified the problem.
1:43:11 But it does run about $8,000 to $10,000 maybe more depending on the facade that's on the front of that fireplace to fix those. So it's pretty expensive. Obviously our community relies on people coming in and being able to burn fires not only for the heat but for the ambiance. So are we totally comfortable with 10 years? No. But we're trying to be reasonable. Can't change them overnight. Okay. Seven and a half.
1:43:40 I've got just a couple questions. I don't know who will answer them. So this is, there are no state standards or this goes beyond the state standards because of our specific needs? This goes beyond the state standards. To be technical about it, wood stove inserts are allowed to be installed in prefab metal fireboxes, which were the old school open face fireplaces.
1:44:10 The manufacturers of the wood stove inserts allow this in their owner's manual. Per the building code, that needs to be a listed device. What all these manufacturers have done is they've tested to these industry standards. They're not listed to the industry standards. They're tested to it. And way back when, in whenever it was, the wood stove insert manufacturers
1:44:39 Originally came out with, we'll install these wood stove inserts in masonry fire chases. They realized one day or one night, whatever it was, that hey, we're missing half the country here because the masonry fire chases are on the Midwest and the East Coast. They moved out to the West Coast where we have all these prefab metal fireboxes. They started buying up all these companies.
1:45:07 And it allowed their insert to be installed into the prefab metal firebox. So this ordinance is without a doubt more stringent than the building code. And you kind of mentioned it, and I think Chief Harper did also, that this does require taking off the facade in most of these cases to check the stuff? Yes. Okay.
1:45:38 Basically, what it does is you need to frame that fire chase with metal stud. And, you know, we've tried all sorts of different avenues to, you know, not circumvent the issue but to see what we could do to lessen the blow. But the fact of the matter is, yes, the whole facade needs to come off. The cost to install the insert is not a huge cost.
1:46:06 It's your finishes. You know, what kind of rock work do you want? Do you want rock work from floor to ceiling? Do you want, you know, that is at the cost. And, you know, it's unfortunate. In another project, I gave you 27 out of 60, we had 11. We had one fire in one project, and out of the 17 units, we had 11 that had pyrolysis.
1:46:33 And then because we're adopting the ordinance, are we going to be the ones notifying all the owners? We are already doing that. Per the ordinance, to make it more efficient in terms of resources, the ordinance reads that the fire district and the town have the enforcement capabilities as a joint effort. That was one thing. Yes, it's a town ordinance, but
1:47:05 Yes, I can do this by myself, but I need help. And without Tom, without Tom and the fire district's help on this and the installers' help, we'd be in a lot worse situation. And, you know, it's obviously coming to you, but the time is now. We have the resources. We have Tom. We have the installers that call us every day. And so the fact is the fire district and the town have the enforcement capabilities.
1:47:33 And it will also be tied to real estate disclosures. Mr. Mayor, if it's appropriate, I'd like to go ahead and make a motion. Okay, turn to the public first. Anybody in the public want to make comment on this item? Yes, Terry. We've already had one condo that we've dealt with this, we've dealt with Johnny, and we had to cut it out, we had to cut into the roof to realign pipes, the flue pipes, and the owner had to totally rip their...
1:48:05 Fireplace Apart. It's pretty extensive, the things that they have to do, understanding that we want to be fire safe. So we've brought it to our board's attention, and we're trying to come up with some type of solution as to what we need to do. In the ordinance that I read, it says that if you put in a pellet stove, that you don't have to do any of these retrofits.
1:48:32 Okay, because we have another unit that's going to be closing escrow, and that's what they're planning on doing. So when we're looking at trying to retrofit the entire complex, that's, you know, definitely going to play into that. You can put a pellet stove in cheaper than you can rip your entire fireplace. Terry, while you're here, I drove by your project either yesterday, I think it was yesterday, and if anybody else has seen it, they put up new unit numbers on the exterior of your buildings.
1:49:02 A couple years ago? It looks great. Yeah, good job. Well, it's very functional. It looks good. So, and one more prompt to Terry. You know, they did put up a new siding this year, which looks amazing as well. But, as always, Terry brings up a great question. This is specific to wood stove inserts. There are wood stoves, wood stove inserts,
1:49:33 Gas stoves, gas stove inserts, pellet stoves, etc. This ordinance is specific to wood stove inserts to where you place an insert into a prefab metal firebox. So to answer Terry's question on the record, yes. If someone wants to take out their wood stove insert and put in a pellet stove insert, you're fine. Because of the cost of firewood?
1:50:03 And because of some no-burn days, you know, people might want to go to the pellet stove instead of the wood burning anyway, and we would actually like to see them. The less wood burning, the better. Anyway. I know that Johnny mentioned that there were eight fires, and he said that was one too many. I think you meant to say that's eight too many? Eight fires?
1:50:34 Okay. Okay, that's fine. I also know that Terry and I are both associated with condominium projects, and it's not so much like a single-family home where if a single-family home goes up, it may or may not impact their neighbor. But in a condominium project, you've got units that are five to eight units.
1:50:58 All together. And so if one goes up, it can take the whole thing up. I'm not willing to risk having a fire under those circumstances, particularly since the problem's been identified. And if I made a motion, which I will at some point, I would like to set as a goal a five-year time frame as opposed to ten, because regardless of whatever the amount of years is, it's not going to be
1:51:26 Completed in whatever time frame you pick. So pick a shorter time frame and have a shorter goal as opposed to the 10-year goal. So Mr. Mayor, I will at this time make them. Did anybody have any comments? Yeah, but if the people who do the work say they can't get them all done in that time, I don't want to put us in a position where we're making
1:51:51 You know, we're putting people in a situation where they're in violation of the ordinance just because they haven't been able to get someone to do the work. Could be economic stimulus where they hire more employees and do more than three or four a week. I think it's more the ripping out the wall and putting it back up than the insert. I don't think we can get that many inserts done in five years. You could put a five-year plan in place and then...
1:52:19 Maybe fines don't come into play for 10 years. What if we set a five-year time frame and that in some way incentivized people to get it done in that time frame and went with a pellet stove insert as opposed to a wood-burning insert? It would still take close to the same amount of time to put in a pellet stove insert, maybe a half a day, less.
1:52:49 Just to put in, because you wouldn't have to mess with the facade, but the five-year plan, 4,000 stoves, is going to be hard to get done. If you're a businessman, which you are, and you have a wonderful showroom, but if you're a businessman and your request to get something done comes in higher than you had anticipated,
1:53:19 Would you hire and train more employees to do a higher level of inserts? Absolutely. We're already gearing up for other programs that we're constantly hiring more people and growing. And if it did come to a five-year thing, then we would bring in more for sure. There's a lot of contractors that are not doing new homes right now and they could come on board.
1:53:49 Thank you. All right. Any comments? If I can just talk to John real quick because we had a quick little quarterback huddle. Maybe not requiring them to be replaced within five years but requiring and really get the education and outreach out there on a nonstop basis requiring that anyone that has a wood stove insert have an inspection within five years and that enables us
1:54:20 Almost the same thing. Once we go out there and do the inspection, now we see the issue, now you've got to do the work. May be an issue or may not be an issue. Well, I can tell you from a personal standpoint, one of the complexes that I brought up were there. My unit did not have an issue, but I still had to replace it. And so that's where that law of averages doesn't work and goes to your comment about, you know,
1:54:47 When you're in a condo complex, you typically share a common wall. My problem could be your problem and vice versa. So maybe consider like an inspection mandate within the five years and once you get on the books, you know, we work out something, you know, I'm sure Andy could figure something out to say, hey, once you've been on the books for the inspection, now you have X amount of days or months or what have you to, you know, either put a pellet stove in or
1:55:16 Or do your wood stove. And that's another good point, is a lot of these homeowners and condo owners, once they've seen the problem with the wood stove insert, the contractors are doing an incredible job of educating them on how much hotter and efficiently these inserts burn, and they're getting rid of them completely, and they're putting in a true wood stove. And now we have no issues again.
1:55:46 Back to absolutely perfect, you know. How about if we do this? It seems a bit convoluted right now. Maybe have Andy get together with Johnny and bring this item back to us in two weeks. Is there any urgency tonight? I think it should come back. I think I do need to huddle with Johnny and the fire district. There seems to be a consensus on council that the direction we want to go.
1:56:15 And rather than trying to make a motion tonight and get it wrong, come back in a couple weeks. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Yep. Good. Okay. With that, we'll move on to item number 11, which is a police reserve program. So, Chief? Yes, good evening again. I'm here to talk about a police reserve program, and we're moving forward with implementing one.
1:56:47 It's one of the ideas that's been presented to help offset the loss of police officers in the police department. Many police departments in the state have reserve programs, and at one time, Mammoth Lakes had a few reserves many years ago. Because of our remoteness, we're always going to be hard-pressed to get a large number of people that would be used to being reserve officers, but we're moving forward to see what we can get started with.
1:57:14 As I've mentioned before, retired Sergeant Karen Smart has agreed to become a Level 1 Reserve and run our volunteer program. We've also got a retired Southern California Police Officer who has relocated part-time to Mammoth. He's expressed an interest of being a Level 1 Reserve Officer. Both of them are almost completed in the process to be brought on as Reserve Officers.
1:57:41 A level one reserve is in all essence a regular police officer when they're on duty. They can perform all the functions of a regular officer and can work unsupervised. Sarcoso College recently completed in November a level three reserve academy, and they're going to be starting a level two academy in March with an expected completion date in July. A level two reserve officer is also very valuable. They can't work by themselves, but they can work.
1:58:10 Under the direct supervision of another officer. So that means they can work as a second officer in a car or even more valuable at a special event like Bluza Palooza or New Year's Eve when we have a lot of officers they can work footbeats with another officer. And they have full piece officer power. In the Cerro Coso class that just graduated there were at least two of the graduates have expressed interest in becoming reserve officers with us and they both
1:58:39 So we could have as many as four reserve officers within six months from now. But those two that are going in a level two academy, they've expressed interest with a caveat. They would like compensation for their hours that they donate or that they would be working. Post requires a minimum of two shifts a month, 16 hours a month. So that's what we're looking at.
1:59:08 If we're going to be competitive with our neighbors, specifically Bishop and Inyo County Sheriffs, both of which have reserve programs, both of them pay their reserve officers, we're going to have to have something that's going to be competitive with them to attract and retain additional reserve officers. Bishop pays their level ones $35 an hour.
1:59:31 Inyo County pays, I'm sorry, Bishop pays $15.25 an hour, and Inyo County Sheriff's pays $35 for level ones. Their level two and level three programs are paid less. There's also a cost of outfitting a new reserve officer, just like a regular officer, comes to about $3,000. That includes reimbursement for firearms, leather gear, uniforms, everything else that is required to be a police officer. So my recommendation, and I don't have a resolution for you tonight, but...
2:00:00 If you approve this or give direction, I'll come back at the next meeting with a resolution that we'll be amending our pay matrix. But my recommendation is that we establish a pay scale of $25 per hour for a Level 1 reserve, $23 for Level 2, $20 an hour for a Level 1 reserve, and that falls in between what Bishop PD and Nino County Sheriffs are paying. The estimated cost for this year would be approximately $7,000 or less.
2:00:27 And next year, based on four reserves, it would be about $24,000 a year, and we have sufficient funding to do that. If we ended up with more reserves, it could go up, and then we'd have to deal with how we're going to fund a larger reserve program, but that would be a problem I'd like to face. So with that, if the council approves, I will come back at the next meeting with a resolution for you. Anybody on this topic? Anyone in favor of it?
2:00:57 Yeah, okay. Do you need a vote, Tierney? Yeah. Yeah, we need to do a vote. So, oh, I'm sorry? Do we have public comments? So, yeah, is there any comments or questions from the public? Okay, then I'll turn to Council for a... I'll move, we approve option one, which is approve the establishment of the recommended pay scales for three levels of reserve officers and authorize the purchase of uniforms and equipment for the reserve program. Second for motion. Motion and second. Roll for motion.
2:01:27 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Thank you. And I'd just like to add that anyone who's interested in becoming a member of the Mammoth Lakes Police Reserve Program to contact the police department, we'll let you know more about it. Okay. Thanks, Chief. Appreciate it. Okay. Now we'll move on to item number 12, which is looking for direction for the write-off or forgiveness of the $900,000 loan from the town to...
2:01:55 Mammoth Lakes Housing for Construction of Aspen Village Workforce Housing Project. Good evening, Council. Cindy Myro, Finance Department. So before you, you asked that this loan come back to Council for further discussion. So the $900,000 loan was originally used to finance the Meridian Court Workforce Housing and subsequently reinvested into the Aspen Village Project. The funds were used for construction and financing.
2:02:24 Before converted into permanent funding to buy down the cost of deed restricted housing. So the $900,000 is still due to the town. We have a resolution that authorized the town manager to convert some or all of that to a grant. So before you is the decision to make on whether you want to write off the money due to the town or to continue to leave the loan on the books.
2:02:55 Figure out a way for Mammoth Lakes Housing to pay us back. Okay. Thank you, Cindy. Any questions or comments? I have a question. And, Cindy, just because you went through it kind of quickly. So the loan originally was used for Meridian Court, and then the proceeds came back and were reinvested by Mammoth Lakes Housing.
2:03:21 So, in other words, did we really get to make the use of the $900,000 twice? Yes. The funds were not actually ever repaid to the town. No, but you... They were collected as revenue from the sales of the Meridian Court Unit and were reinvested into the Aspenville. Okay. Anybody else? Any comments or questions from the public on this item? Okay. No, I'm sorry, Lee. Yeah, go ahead. Come on up. I have a question.
2:04:01 I went to the affordable housing meeting last night, and nobody told me that it was canceled. And I was going to ask some more information on this, because I don't understand this at all. And I don't think that was right that I don't, you know, they, you guys need to let people know when meetings are canceled and stuff like this. But affordable housing was the vote of the people, two-thirds vote. And I think a lot of people have asked, how much affordable housing do we need anymore? It ought to go back to the vote of the people to see if they need it anymore.
2:04:30 And I think the affordable housing should pay the money back. The town is short money. They need to pay it back. I take a loan from the town. I have to pay it back. You're laying off all the officers and the people in town. It's a slap in the face to them. To be laying off a loan like this, I think they need to be paying it back. Okay. Well, another thing, too, is when it comes to affordable housing, I personally don't think they're doing that good of a job. I live in Sierra Valley sites. There's places where business...
2:05:00 CARF's on part of the affordable housing project. I've mentioned this to them many times before. It's a liability for them. It's on their easement. And the business next to them, their headlights are always sent to their bedroom windows. That is not respecting the working people of our town. I'm against affordable housing, but they're in our area, and I'm going to protect them. They are human beings, and they should be treated like human beings. There should not be lights into their bedroom windows of CARF's.
2:05:25 They don't plow the properties well. I took somebody around with me the other day, and there was a whole bunch of snow on it still. That is a liability for affordable housing if these people fall. A trash can had been opened, and there was trash all over the place. I was advised that somebody comes by every day and, you know, looks this stuff over. I would like to see affordable housing maintain these buildings better and take care of them and respect the people and act like they're human beings at least. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Donette? Hi. I have a couple questions.
2:05:55 So the $900,000 I get was reinvested back. But isn't there still a loan that has to be repaid back to the state of California? And how would that, if you forgive the $900,000 or the close to a million, how would you pay that back to the state? Does that mean the town would have to come up with the money to pay that back? Or does the housing come back up with that money if you forgive that loan so that turn around and...
2:06:25 Makes the town responsible? Is that correct? Are you understanding that? I think Cindy can answer that. A couple things. I want to remind Council that the $900,000 loan originally came from Measure A dollars, so it was monies that were designed and set aside for housing purposes. There is no loan due back on this particular project. We do have two other projects out there that are due in later years.
2:06:56 But not related to this. So it came from Measure A. The TOT dollars in Measure A going into the housing fund. Right. And so they got the money from A. They did the project. In the town, where's the loan come in?
2:07:16 Because the town has those housing dollars into a fund. Mammoth Lakes Housing does not get 100% of those funds. It goes into the fund. So when you're putting 1% of TOT into housing, that's close to $800,000 a year is the 1% of TOT. But the housing contract is just over $300,000 or $385,000 or something like that. The balance of that money can be used for other housing projects or that the town...
2:07:46 chooses to fund. Okay. Okay. I think my question is, maybe I need some clarification on this, but why would we consider writing this off in our financial shape? I mean, Rick, maybe you could help me. I'll direct my comments to that, but I'd like to hear from Pam, who has, as do I,
2:08:21 Since my signature is all over those resolutions, the history of this. Pam Hennerty, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. So this loan was originally, quite frankly, never intended to be repaid. In 2006, as you recall from Ellen's graph earlier, we were in a booming time of development. There were more construction workers in town than we knew what to do with, and they were occupying all of our units.
2:08:51 And there were construction jobs everywhere. When you subsidize a project, whether it be with most of the time with state or federal funds, that triggers some sort of prevailing wage. We've dealt with federal prevailing wage on the projects that we built with state and federal tax dollars through the home grant tax credits and bonds. So all of our apartment complexes, we paid federal prevailing wage at that time.
2:09:19 The wages, even still at this time, the wages that contractors were earning in the town of Mammoth Lakes far surpassed federal prevailing wage rates. It didn't even make sense. The federal prevailing wage was really a burden on the contractors because they had to do certified payrolls. They had to certify payrolls. Mammoth Lakes housing staff had to go verify the payrolls. We had to do interview employees to make sure that the payrolls were being met.
2:09:49 When in fact everybody was earning far more than what was necessary. But if subsidy is structured as a loan, that doesn't trigger federal or state prevailing wage requirements. So the resolution, I wasn't in charge at the time, but I remember the discussions taking place. And we didn't know what kind of subsidy was going to need to go into the Aspen Village. We were hoping to build it like we built Meridian Court, which was we got a construction loan from a local bank.
2:10:18 And used the $900,000 as equity and got a construction loan and built the project. That was what we were hoping to be the same model for Aspen Village. So we used the $900,000 as equity, got a loan from Eastern Sierra Community Bank and built the units. But because that, and the resolution at the time was written in such a way that said it's a loan that is forgivable if necessary at the time of sale.
2:10:48 Quite frankly, we didn't anticipate the subsidy needing to be left in at the time. We had sold the Meridian Court Project, deed restricted all 24 units. It was quite successful. We were able to recoup the $900,000. It was our plan to continue reinvesting that fund into projects. But again, this was 2006. At that time, then, Mammoth Lakes Housing went through a change in leadership.
2:11:14 And the project was retooled again. It went from being modular construction to site built, which required further architecture and engineering plans. It didn't get started as we had hoped. It did get started in 2008, and the units came online about an hour after the market crashed. And we sat on them and sat on them and tried to sell them.
2:11:43 Because of that, the downturn in the market prices and the downturn in subsequently deed restricted prices went down and the subsidy was needed to maintain the affordable units in that complex. But I think that the resolution that was adopted demonstrates that the project was not necessarily going to be required to ever have to be repay that loan. These were workforce housing dollars.
2:12:12 At that time, the commitment to workforce housing was as strong as ever, and the commitment was that if it was required, that the funds would stay in the project, but if it wasn't, that they could be refunded into further projects. But ultimately, the fact that it was not a grant in the first place was really to help us to gain contractor attention and get bids for the projects and help those contractors avoid
2:12:42 Prevailing wage requirements. Okay. Thank you, Pam. Any other questions from Council? Okay, we already went out publicly today. All right, see no other comments or questions from the public. The only thing I would have to say is, you know, I mentioned it before, just the town's being asked to forgive more debt. We addressed this already, I believe, in a couple previous Council meetings where there were some loans.
2:13:13 And we were told that we had to pretty much pay him because, in effect, we're a cosigner on there. I think it was to the tune of about $700,000. We don't, we just, we're just not in a position to be doing that. It's just kind of an odd way to be doing some accounting, in my opinion. I think I've already said all this stuff. I'll slip for a motion. I've got comments. I'm prepared to make a motion. So,
2:13:49 I signed the 04 ordinance and I signed the 06 ordinance. I'm very familiar with what was going on at the time and I don't know that I can articulate it any better than Pam, but the quote loan was really nothing more than a fiction designed to assist the contracting community, designed to attract contractors to bid the project.
2:14:21 Without having to meet the onerous requirements of the prevailing wage at a time when the actual wage was higher than the federal prevailing wage. So the way that this was crafted was to initially call it a loan and then in 2006 it was converted. The resolution is entitled a grant.
2:14:47 And then in the body of it, it references the original loan and then provides the town manager with authority to convert the loan to a grant for Aspen Village at Mammoth Creek. So those are sort of the structural technical aspects of it. But listen, there's a practical thing here. Mammoth Lakes Housing is funded by the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:15:16 If Mammoth Lakes Housing pays the Town of Mammoth Lakes back, what funds do you think will be used by Mammoth Lakes Housing to pay the town back? They will be future Town of Mammoth Lakes Measure A funds. So you're using the same funds that you collect to pay back funds that you have already given to Mammoth Lakes Housing to invest in a project which houses local workers.
2:15:45 It doesn't make any sense unless your motive is to take the $900,000 out of future measure A, bring it back, and put it into the general fund. If that happens, the public will know about that because I will tell the public about that.
2:16:03 The point is that if you pay the money back, it goes back to where? It goes back to the housing fund to be used for housing. Since it's going to be used for housing in the future, why not leave it in the project that it was invested in? It doesn't make any sense. This is not complicated. It is complicated, I think. It sounds very complicated. And that's why I need to understand it. Yeah, I didn't find a problem with it. It's very complicated. I'm not finished. I still have the floor. I'm sorry. Go ahead.
2:16:32 The last thing I'm going to tell you is this was one of a number of loans that the staff brought to us for forgiveness. You may recall that the way that we booked the REU two years ago was that it was funded by a loan from the airport, but the airport was financed by the town and the airport had no money.
2:17:01 And sure enough, we thought we had $4.3 million in the REU when in fact we had $1.3 million because it was a $3 million loan from the airport that was never going to be repaid other than funds from the town. So we said wisely, let's get rid of that loan. Why would you book a loan to yourself that you would repay with your own money? One, the intent at the time was it not be a loan.
2:17:31 Two, you're using the same money that you've already invested or you're going to use future money that is designed to go into housing. The only mean, the only motive that I can imagine, because there isn't any other, for requiring repayment of a $900,000 loan is to divert measure A money to general fund purposes for use on expenditures that don't relate to housing. I think another option might be to sell some assets.
2:18:01 And, you know, I think that we could look at in the last three months how much money the town has used to bail out all these different loans that are out there, loans or whatever you want to call them. I mean, they're, it's, it's the very least the accounting needs to be fixed. Oh, there's no, but that's what this does. Yeah. You know. So I'd like to address, you made two points. Sale of assets. So if you sell housing assets.
2:18:31 Assets that were acquired with housing money, are you suggesting that that money would then go into the general fund and not be put back into housing? Why would you sell a housing asset that was purchased with housing money and then not yet use the housing money, not use the proceeds from the sale of the asset for additional housing? That doesn't make any sense at all. The other thing I want to mention very clearly, let's not mix up loans.
2:19:00 That the housing entity obtained from the state, for example, down payment assistance, loans for down payment assistance, which you've indicated is a great program, which are due in advance of perhaps receiving all the down payment assistance back as the units are sold. Let's not mix those up.
2:19:20 Because that's not a loan to yourself, that's a loan to the state. And where do those loans get repaid? Not from general fund money. Those loans get paid from housing money, and they're allocated from housing money in the future in our five-year plan. So there's no general fund subsidy. This is measure A money to the tune of $800,000 a year that the voters said
2:19:44 We want to put into housing. It was appropriately put into housing, and it's appropriate for us to pay those loans back to the state, but that's not the same loan as we made to ourselves. So if we built a product with these monies, and what did we end up doing with the product? We're renting it, or we sold them? What happened to the proceeds there? Where did those proceeds go? Did they come back into housing, or did they come back into...
2:20:13 Well, there were no proceeds, essentially. Mammoth Lakes Housing, the units sold, again, as I said, at the crash of the market, and there, so there was no proceeds. The product sold at a loss. Okay, so if they sold at a loss, then we are paying a loan because we paid for a product to be built, the product got sold off at a loss, there's a debt there, and now,
2:20:41 We're having to pay this debt off again. There's no debt. The proceeds from the sale of the units paid off the construction loan. That was the only debt that existed. But the proceeds from the sale of the unit did not cover the $900,000 that we're here to talk about. So this is a $900,000 shortfall? Is that what this is? Yes. Well, yes. Essentially, it's a subsidy to leave those units deed restricted.
2:21:11 I would argue that it's not a shortfall if we got to use the money twice. Right, which we did. And I would also say, Matthew, to your thing about the accounting is, you know, that is one of the things that we have cleared up. There are no paper listings of receivables that will never be received. That's all been straightened out over time, and this is probably the last one, and Rick is right, that the airport one was, if anything, more egregious.
2:21:38 When it was set up, but we have straightened out our accounting practices, and from my standpoint, the fact that we got two projects with the same $900,000 is important, and it was a paper loan that was never expected to be repaid. Okay. To tag onto that, I just have one more comment, if I may. Mammoth Lakes Housing is in the business of subsidizing workforce housing. It's a subsidy. Call it a shortfall. It doesn't matter what you call it.
2:22:12 I expect that this council is going to have a debate in the future, as we should, about who we should be subsidizing. What I'm hearing, Mr. Mayor, from you sort of generally is that you think that one of the solutions is to subsidize the private sector as opposed to subsidizing the actual homeowners or the renters. I think that's a great debate. I think we ought to have that debate. To what extent should we subsidize a developer, for example?
2:22:38 Who may be willing to either rehab or build workforce housing but can't afford to do so because the cost is too high in relation to the rent structure. That's a legitimate debate. That makes sense to me. And I think that that may be one of the directions that certainly the housing board is going to take that issue up and bring those thoughts back to the council because that's realistic and reasonable and meets the times.
2:23:05 But it's still subsidy. We're always subsidizing somebody. That's what public funds are doing. And so in this instance, essentially what happened is that we subsidized homeowners and subsidized, I mean, when we give a down payment assistance, for example, and this wasn't used for that. This was used to construct something. We're subsidizing homeowners. We're subsidizing an individual to
2:23:30 Allow him or her or them to get into workforce housing and serving a market that otherwise can't get into housing. And so I don't really see it as any different, but it seems to me that's a little different from what Councilmember Bacon has suggested, and that is, it's just a paper, this is just an accounting transaction.
2:23:50 That's either going to be cleaned up or not. And if it's not, and there is some sort of repayment over time, because after all, it's the town that provides the funds for repayment, the expectation would be that it will go right back into housing. So I think you just clean it up and move on. All right. So with that, I'll make a motion that the... I have a question. Sorry. There's a lot. So I just want to make sure I understand. So I get what you're saying.
2:24:22 And I get what you're saying. So, and I get what you're saying. But the question is, if you, it's an accounting thing, you take it off the book. How does that $800,000 get repaid back to the state of California? Would that be from the...
2:24:37 I just want to make sure that money gets paid back. Could you explain that? Sure. Those are different loans than what are before us because those are grants that we got from the state that need to be repaid. So, for example, the state gives you a million dollars and says, here, you can dole that out in the form of down payment assistance. And your terms of your down payment assistance are, gee, when you sell your unit, you have to pay back the down payment.
2:25:02 Okay, that's a program that we have. But the state says, we want our money back in five years or ten years, whatever that date is, which may be a lot sooner than all those down payments come back because the units haven't sold. And so the housing, which is really the town, has to repay the state. So your question is, well, what does it pay the state from? We've budgeted the payments of the two loans. There's two of them totaling $600,000 or $700,000.
2:25:29 For a payment from Measure A funds, which is the housing portion of TOT, so they don't come from the general fund. Okay, so you're taking the money from Measure A. When will that happen to pay back the state loans? Will it be over several years? I think they're scheduled in 2015 and 2017. 14, 15, and 15, 16, they're two separate loans.
2:25:58 And we do have it in our five-year plan to repay those funds. And I think to your question earlier, where would the money go if it came back? I would go to pay those grants off with it instead of having the general fund do it. Yeah, but the general fund is not, isn't it true, Cindy, that the general fund is not paying the grants back? It's Measure A money there. It's the Measure A portion of TOT that goes into the housing fund.
2:26:24 Mammoth Lakes Housing does not receive that entire $800,000 allotment of funds, so there's extra funding available to pay these loans back when they come due. Let me add, hopefully not confusing things, but clarifying, with regards to the two payments back to the state,
2:26:44 The payments are scheduled to come from the general fund. They're in the five-year restructuring plan. However, Council Member Wood, you're right. It's only a timing issue, even though it could have been any funding source, frankly.
2:26:56 The general fund is going to up front the repayment and we will eventually collect the funds back from the properties. It may take us a few years, so it's really another loan, if you will. So we do another loan that gets forgiven in another five or ten years. Disagree. Well, because the housing in the five-year plan...
2:27:17 We have reduced the amount of money from the 1% going to housing. Right. So the point is that although it's technically general fund, the reason is that it is all of that measure A money, tourism, transit, well that's measure T, but tourism and housing technically is general fund revenue because it's unrestricted. But we put it into
2:27:43 Housing Fund, Tourism Fund, and we've been very diligent in making sure that that which it is designated for actually goes to that which it was intended to be used for. And so you can call it general fund, but it's still measure A money because we've restricted from
2:28:07 I'm not sure whether I can articulate it. It is still measuring money. That's the only way that I can explain it. You may be able to do it better. You have made a political commitment to set aside general fund money for housing, tourism, and transit purposes. Better put. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, Martin. Martin wanted to. I'm sorry. Nope. Sorry. Martin Kleinberg, Council. Concerned citizen. I applaud the fact that we're cleaning up the financial house.
2:28:36 I mean, that's a good thing. My concern is, being a construction contractor, I have concern with the term of calling it a loan for the purpose of evading public works rules, because if it always was going to be forgiven, then it's really a grant, and if grant money enacts public works rules, then
2:29:07 That's evasion in my book, and that's all I wanted to say. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Any members from the public? Anybody else? Okay. Would it be to the town's best interest to set aside a portion of that housing TOT money, like $200,000 each year, and pay it towards the loan, and then it's paid off in the future, and then you don't have that loan back to the state? Would that be an option, maybe?
2:29:40 Is it repayment back? Well, I think this loan is, as Mayor Pro Tem Woods putting it and Pam putting it, it's actually, it is Measure A money, so you'd be paying Measure A money. There was the grant money, which is a separate conversation. Exactly. That needs to be paid back, and that was my question as well. Yeah, so my, so I get the accounting thing of the 900, but the, your, when you were discussing the, when we were discussing the payback,
2:30:08 Of the 800, instead of waiting for each of those years, could you actually take a percentage out of that TOT from housing and pay back? We have already structured and built into the five-year budget the repayment of those loans, so we've taken care of the repayment already. It's already in the budget. But you were saying that was coming out of general fund, right?
2:30:31 It is, but it doesn't matter because we're going to get the funds back. It's really just a timing issue. Okay. So I guess my point was because each year you get $800,000 for housing, could you take some of that? There's no surplus left in the housing fund. We've already used the surplus to basically divert money back to the general fund, and that issue has been discussed. Okay. Thank you.
2:30:58 Donna, if I could, in very layman's terms, we collect $800,000, Measure A. The Council has, in its infinite wisdom, taken some of that Measure A money in this latest budget crisis and applied it to other things unrelated to housing. The Housing Authority
2:31:22 The housing entity receives about $325,000 of the $800 to run its various operations. And so that leaves about $500,000 or maybe a little less of housing money that can be used for either housing stuff or if the council decides for something else. And that's something that the voters are either going to be happy about or unhappy about. Well, we've done it.
2:31:47 But we haven't taken all that $500,000 in the last couple of years, and the reason for that is that there are existing loans, for example, this year it's, I think, $200 and some odd thousand dollars that we're paying to the state for other grants that are required to be repaid. And so, to think of it in very simple terms, and I know that you have an accounting background,
2:32:11 You're borrowing against one to pay the other. Well, no. You start with $800. Take the $300 out to administer the various programs. You've got $500 left. We're spending $200 and something now to repay other loans we haven't even talked about yet. Those are going to be repaid by the time these next loans become due. And so either way, we still have measure A money to repay these loans that we have to the state.
2:32:35 Now, the benefit is that when the money comes back from those that we gave it to as they sell their units, that comes back in the housing fund later, and that's part of the timing issue. Okay. I was glad that you explained that because there's been a lot of people discussing, you know, have come up and said,
2:32:52 What are you doing with this money? And that's never been brought up, and I'm really glad that you brought that up because I think that's really important. Me sitting here, I didn't know, had any idea that you were using some of that money to repay back loans, and I think that's really important that it's explained to the public. And you're right, I do have an accounting, and basically you're taking that money, trying to solve your other loan issues, and then try to stay above water to get to the next issue. Sure. And that's what you're doing, and by you explaining that, that explains it.
2:33:21 Listen, I can barely understand that myself. Oh, I understand perfectly. Thank you. Thank you, Donette. Okay. Are there any other comments or questions from Council? If not, we'll go ahead and entertain a motion. I'll move that the Town Council forgive the $900,000 loan payable by Mammoth Lakes Housing. Second. I'll move a motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. No.
2:33:51 Yes. No. Okay, motion passes 3-2. And with that, I guess we are going to go into closed session. So thank you everybody for joining tonight and appreciate your comments.