Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 2 hr 55 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
360 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
7:51 That's it. We have all these crazy trail systems that I can ride in the summertime but can't ride in the wintertime. And it's multi-use, so I see dog walkers and snowshoers using the trails. But my bike that leaves less impact isn't allowed. What's the name of the bike that you've got again? Well, the general nomenclature is a snow bike or a fat bike. The specific brand I have is a Salsa Muckluck.
8:21 And just so you know, like Grand Targhee, Wyoming, big snow resort, or Idaho actually, it's right on the border, big ski resort, big Nordic ski resort, they allow fat bikes now. And their rules are three and a half inch tires are wider, less than 10 psi tire pressure, and you can only ride in conditions where your bike would leave less than an inch divot in the snow and stay on the right side of the trip.
8:50 So they are now sharing trails with Nordic skiers. Everybody's happy. Before I found out the rules, I was riding up Lake Mary Road. Everybody's high-fiving all the Nordic skiers, and I'm a Nordic skier too. You know, it all goes hand in hand. We're just recreation people. So I don't see any reason why our A, B, C, D, E, F, G snowmobile trail system shouldn't be open to bikes like mine. Of course, that is a forcers policy.
9:20 Right, so I wrote a letter last week to Ed Armenta. Haven't heard back from him yet, the supervisor. That's what they told me to do at the visitor center. So I wrote him a letter because it's a federal law or rule, whatever, for no-wheeled vehicles, but the local land manager has the, I guess, the say. And I know, actually, I don't know what I'm doing here, but I figured maybe somebody here knows some stuff or can tell me where to go next. So that's pretty much why I'm here.
9:48 But thanks for your time. And my bike's sitting outside, just in case you guys are curious about it. Literally, it leaves less of an imprint than a sneaker on snow. It's made to float over the snow, not dig into the snow. And when the conditions get too hard to ride it, you can't ride. So those would be the conditions where it would start making, you know, divots anyway, so there's no point to ride when you can't ride. So thank you. Thank you. You know, the other place,
10:19 That we might want to bring this up would be the MLTSCC. Because of its trails and because we now have that new working relationship with the Forest Service, this may be a place where we can at least start that conversation. And the reason that wheeled vehicles weren't allowed on there changed over the years because of the damage that the quads and such, which are wheeled vehicles, which are also made not to leave an imprint, were making because of the way they were being ridden. So that's how it became illegal on our forest for...
10:48 Wheeled Vehicles to go out there. And the guys who want to drive their Toyota pickup trucks down the Groom Trail as well. My bike's non-motorized. I just wanted to make it. Thank you. Yeah, it was a matter of trail damage, not whether you were motorized or non-motorized. Right, but I don't have the power to do it and motorize. Right. Just like a snowman, we lift up the trail way more than that. Thank you. John. Hi.
11:19 Nice to meet you. When I came in here, the first thing I did was take a picture of your bike and send it to my girlfriend because we've got a fat tire bike frame that's coming here this week to get built. I've also seen a letter from the Forest Service to Tamarack specific about what you're talking about. My girlfriend drives a snowcat at Tamarack because she proves all the trails up there. So we're very aware of these issues. I would second what you said about the MLTSCC also and our Mammoth Trails.
11:44 These are emerging trends in recreation. This is a very big part of the mountain biking community. I don't know if you've written around Mono Lake yet, but there's a lot of opportunities in this area to deal with our sandy soils using these kinds of bikes. This is a huge growth opportunity in mountain biking. We're going to have a Mammoth Trails meeting next week if you want to come to that. I'd love to follow up and all that stuff. So a couple of things. Some things were talked to the MLTSTC yesterday. I'll repeat this, but this is a different body and a different meeting.
12:14 MLTPA working with Mammoth Trails members submitted comments on the Casa Diablo 4 project. I think our letter is about 10, 11 pages long. It tiered from the comments that Ellen Clark made but provided a lot of specific information based on the needs of users that came out of those Mammoth Trails groups. BLM's got that. That's important as we get to some of these other issues.
12:38 The Forest Service, as we talked about yesterday, there's kind of a flurry of activity from the Forest Service of decisions and things that they're doing. Another project is called the Scenic Loop OSV-OHV Staging Area. These are staging areas for OSV happening out on the Scenic Loop. On the SOPA was a statement proposed action. The Forest Service hasn't posted any documents yet. I talked to Marty Hornick this morning.
13:01 They are trying to pursue this and trying to move forward with this. If it does happen, he says it'll happen quickly. There's some grant funding that's tied into this, so we should all stay tuned and make sure we provide appropriate comment on that so that those grants can come forward and those things can get built. That's the idea. Shady Rest, OHV, OSV staging area. A scoping letter's come out. Comments are due March 1st. There are ties between that proposed infrastructure and the ORMET project.
13:29 I think if people start paying attention to this, you start seeing that maybe the Forest Service is proposing to do something to benefit ORMAT through a motorized trailhead process. There's some stuff there that's a little bit funny that should probably be looked at. There's a major fuels reduction project happening. It's called the Sherwin Scenic Loop Project.
13:52 This is a different type of Forest Service action. Those objection comments are due by March 5th. That will be published in the Inyo Register paper, paper of record, large fuels reduction project in the area. Another project, the Forest Service proposes restoration of unauthorized routes. This is the Forest Service taking a look at some completion efforts with the Travel Management Plan of 2009. There will be two public meetings for that. I would encourage anybody who's interested in this to attend.
14:22 The first is Tuesday, February 12th, down at the Supervisor's Office at Bishop. The second one will be Wednesday, February 20th at 6 o'clock over at the Mammoth Lakes Community Center. The timing of that's important because also on February 20th at 5 o'clock, the Town Council is reviewing recreation as part of the restructuring business of the town. So there's some kind of logistics to deal with there.
14:46 Mammoth Trails is, we're going to have a meeting on February 14th, user groups, any, whoever's interested in this, we're getting the GIS and the route data from the Forest Service, so we'll take that information, overlay that with the boundaries of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, and so people who are interested, we can start looking at what are the effects of these various projects on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System as defined by the planning area of the town.
15:09 So it's a good opportunity to kind of come see what these proposals look like relative to the trail system, relative to the recreation activity that you like to do, so that when you go into these meetings on February 20th, people have some idea of what they're talking about, how you have a good constructive meeting with the Forest Service. We'll also start maybe looking at what that shady rest...
15:29 Project will look like because on the 19th, the Rec Commission and the MLTSCC are going to start talking about that. This is obviously a very important effort and we want to get a good, hopefully a good community consensus how to move forward with this thing. John, when's your meeting on the 14th? That'll be at 4 o'clock at the Mammoth Lakes Library and I'll send out notices on that and if anybody wants to get added to the list, just let me know. But 4 o'clock at the Mammoth Lakes Library. And the final thing is the
15:56 MLTPA drafted a proposal having to do with the future of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, and it was submitted to the town about a week or so ago. MLTPA believes it's important that the town council have a recommendation from the Recreation Commission vis-a-vis that proposal for their meeting on the 20th. And I would propose to the chair for consideration of the commission.
16:19 Possibly considering entertaining that proposal the 19th of February at that meeting, which will give you guys sufficient time to make a recommendation of the council so the council can consider that proposal as part of their restructuring effort on the 20th. If you have any further questions, I'll be here for sure. Thank you, John. Thank you. I have talked to a couple of the councilmen on that, and while they aren't looking for us to make an absolute decision, it would appear like they would at least like us to have that.
16:49 A brief go-over before their meeting if they have any questions for us at that meeting. So as big as that agenda is already getting, it would appear like at least we need a brief period of time to go over that so that we are familiar with it before their meeting. Yeah, just to comment on that, Chair. So as we talked about in some meetings that we've had, the goal is to get to the Forest Service first, get to the town attorney. I mean, the commission and the trials committee will have probably a lot more questions than we have answers right now.
17:18 We're scheduled to be on that agenda in March, the first meeting in March. I don't know if there's any reason to get in any earlier, but I think that leaves sufficient time to deal with it. I just don't know why the sense of urgency is right now. If I could, the Town Council has advised the community that the Town needs to restructure its organization and how it's going about delivering services.
17:41 Phase 1 of the restructuring effort is complete. Phase 2 of this restructuring effort is currently happening. On the 20th, the town's council will be talking about restructuring of recreation vis-a-vis the town's ability to deliver services. In my conversation with council members, they have requested that they would like to have this proposal. Some, you know, you don't have to make a recommendation, but at least a recreation commission having...
18:06 Engage with it such that at the designated meeting for consideration of recreation opportunities in this community, the council has something to work from. And I think it would be a little strange if a proposal coming forward at the direction of the council to talk with community partners and community nonprofits to bring capacity. The community is not brought forward in such a way that the council can at least have some idea what to do with it. I think that the solution is
18:34 I do have a request from a couple of council members that we at least look at the proposal, even if we make no decision. So if we could get a copy of that for that agenda and get it on the agenda just for a brief not to make a...
18:50 For just a brief discussion so at least the commissioners have an idea of what's in it besides Sean and I have seen it already. I have, Chair, and I actually would like to speak that I think that we should be prepared at the next meeting. I know that the next meeting is a long agenda, but at the same time I would like to probably ask for more than just a brief discussion, but perhaps actually consider putting a recommendation forward. And again, just to reiterate what John has said with regards to timing, I feel that it is important that we do it before the February 20th meeting.
19:19 I disagree. John Wentworth has provided a copy to me, and I've looked at it. And I really think that it needs more study than just a quick review and then making a formal recommendation. I kind of like more of Bill's idea that, you know, take a look at it, maybe make some comments, but not to formally endorse it. Well, but for today's purpose, if we get it on the agenda, it gives us the ability to act or not to act and to at least review it.
19:47 So that would be my request would be that it end up on that agenda at that very, very over-length meeting already. Well then, well, I'm in opposition to that because I think it would take more time to study. I kind of agree with Stu why I rushed this and that's your opinion. And I'm concerned that if it is on the agenda that there will be momentum to move forward with this when we haven't really looked at it.
20:17 and studied it and gotten answers from the various sources that have been mentioned. I was just going to say, isn't our 19th meeting a workshop? Yes. So in a workshop, are we able to actually make a suggestion? We are because it's agendized as a regular meeting, even though we do it in a workshop style. Okay.
20:42 I do think that we should spend a little time on it prior to the Council's meeting on the 20th just because otherwise I'm afraid that we might lose our opportunity for input without at least I've also John sent it to me as well and I think it's worth discussing and perhaps could we extend that I know that workshop is scheduled from 2 to 4 I mean I'd be glad to start at 1 or go to 5
21:04 Not to surprise you guys, but we've sort of already made the decision to make it start at 1 o'clock because of the other things we've had to add to it. So that would be a 1 to 5 meeting if necessary. Do I have consensus then? Yeah. Pat is opposed to putting it on. I would agree with Betsy. I just think that if we don't at least have that conversation and if we can't come up with...
21:29 some type of consensus to move forward, then we would ask for that extra time, you know, or whatever's needed at that time. But I think if it's on the Council's agenda for the 20th, I think that... I don't know that it's on the Council agenda. I think the Council agenda is to look at the status of Recreation and Parks. I know Stu has a presentation to make, and I think it's a matter of making them aware of what the department's all about. I think that there's probably still time with respect to outsourcing and other decisions.
21:59 to that effect. I am curious as to what the town attorney thinks about, you know, the proposal, and so that's why I think that there are other questions and layers to this as opposed to making a quick decision. But we can't even start getting those questions answered until we agendize it and ask the questions. Ray, you were going to say something to this. I would just like to add, I think we, and it's up to you guys how you want to move this forward. I think from the staff's perspective at this point,
22:28 What I'm hearing is that the council is involved in this. It's their idea. They want to bring it forward. And that's terrific. However, we work for the town manager. And what I would like to do is whatever your suggestion today is, if you want to see it on that agenda, I would like to take that recommendation to the town manager, have that conversation, because there are a number of factors, I think, that are going to be included in the discussion. And I agree you need to start having the discussion at some point.
22:58 Commissioner Agnes is right. The restructuring discussion is a process. There are no decisions that are going to be made on the 20th. And having said that, I understand the desire to get this out there and have it become part of the discussion. I think it's a good idea. But because of the moving parts involved with this, I don't know if it can all come together by that point in time. We can certainly work on that. But at this point,
23:27 I would like to have the conversation with the town manager about how we should move this forward. And like I say, I'm happy to take the commission's recommendation and your desire to move it forward to the manager and have that conversation. I think at this point you've got four of us who would like to see it on that particular agenda. So I'll move that forward. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. That was a long time for public comment. Yeah.
23:53 Anything else on public comments? We will close public comments. Consent agenda. Interesting. Do I have a motion or comments? There's only one thing on it, so. I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Moving on to policy matters. Review and provide direction to staff on 2013.
24:28 Youth Sports Funding. Hello. Hello. I'm back. So in your packet you guys have a copy of the staff report. Basically it's that time of year again where we start looking to open up the application process for the youth sports funding that we have every year. And this year we have $28,800 that are available, again, for appropriation.
25:00 And what did we give out last year? Was it the same amount? Yes. And last year you guys recommended to revise it from 28 to 23 for taking out that 5,400 for Husky Club right off the bat. So all we're looking for here is I'm assuming you guys got a chance to look over the application and
25:31 Just make sure if there's anything that you guys wanted to change or if there was any input from last year's process, I think it went pretty smooth. Everybody had a chance to be part of it, so if you guys are good with everything. Could you just clarify? I know we did talk about putting money aside for Husky Club. Was that like perpetual? Like always? That was my opinion at this point, unless there was a reason to revisit it. So then maybe for...
26:00 The attachment A, maybe you should mention that the sum of 23,000 in change is available instead of 28 because that's a little misleading. And then does Husky Club... We discussed that last year, but because we're asking, because you guys are also asking them to put in an application at the same time with the rest of the groups, I think last year that's why we left it at that...
26:31 Wholesome. But we can change it if you guys want to. I think it was last year. What I'm remembering is just to make it clear that of the $28,000 that was available for youth sports that automatically we're just pulling out that amount for Husky Club. And I think it does need to be made clear. I know it sounds a little more than it needs to be, but just to be clear.
26:53 Yeah, and I'm not sure that we don't just pull it and, you know, and maybe we need to set, make some type of policy as far as that goes or whatever, but that the Husky Club, I would still like them to come forward every year, just give us what their plans are and, you know, that we know, you know, kind of that they're moving forward and that they still hope. Yeah. And so I think that if we had that with that requirement, that's, that would be sufficient and then that way everybody else knows that really there is less money that's, that's.
27:22 Out there to be allocated. No. No. Any other questions from any of the other commissioners on the? I just had one comment. Somewhere in here, it was mentioned the importance of attracting diverse youth to these programs, and I just wondered if there was a way to incorporate that on the rating sheet, maybe under number five.
27:55 Because we do have such a diverse community and we're certainly trying to encourage diverse participation. Let's see. So it just says number of children participating. So, you know, we're looking at our program information. It's actually right on the front. It says if you ask about the specific diversity, I don't know that we can. No, I understand that. I just wanted to bring it up because it was in the.
28:29 I think that we have children out there participating and then the larger number of children is a great benefit. Oh, I agree. Was there any consensus there at all or are we okay leaving? I think we leave it. That's fine. Is that okay? Because it is mentioned in the instructions on how to fill it out, but did you want like some kind of breakdown? No. No, no, no, no, no. Because I did see that in the instructions under filling it out and I wondered if that should be something we should...
29:00 Consider on the rating sheet, but I think it's fine the way it is. Anyone else have any questions before I go ahead? I just have a couple of terminology comments on the rating sheet. On question two and three, it's worded in such a way that it's like we're the applicant, but we're the raters, so it should be have you received town funding, it should be has the applicant received town funding, which is more of a semantics thing.
29:29 I didn't read it that way at all. Really? Yeah, because the name of the organization goes on the top, which makes it related to them. Have you received? But you're right, the commission's completing it, not the applicant. I think that was Commissioner Egnich's point. Yeah, so that's for the commissioners, so we can change that, yeah. Thank you.
29:56 Okay, I had a couple of comments, and I don't know, and I've made a couple of them before. Percentage of Mammoth Lakes area full-time residents, including Crowley and other nearby areas, while we certainly would never want to exclude them, at some point in time, we're going to want to go to the county and ask them for a little more help with our recreation department to fulfill their recreation needs. And I don't know if it's fair to break that out or not, but I would certainly be interested to know what percentage of the kids.
30:25 Whose recreation we're providing are from our tax base versus Mono County's tax base. We've had the conversation over and over that we need to go to them and ask them for more support than what we get with just Whitmore. And I don't know if that's something we can or can't do. That's just something that stuck out to me. So you're looking for their place of residence? Yeah.
30:50 As we do this, all kids in Crowley and other nearby areas are considered full-time residents. I mean, they go to school here. I know they do. But that's a good point all the way around. Can I make a recommendation then that we do break this out into percentage of Mammoth Lakes residents, percentage of Mono County residents, percentage of out-of-county residents? Just keep it simple.
31:18 Feasible, though, that the organizations will know that information? Because, for example, you know, I have a PO box in town. And now I have two properties. We asked for that already. We do ask for the percentage of Mammoth Lakes area full-time residents. But it includes Crowley and other nearby areas. So what we could probably do is just take out the language that says including Crowley and just ask the number of full-time residents in Mammoth Lakes. Unless you want to...
31:46 I like the idea of what you're pointing out, just starting to collect that information for town of Mammoth Lakes residents, county of Mono residents, and out of county residents. And you're right, Pat, there may be trouble, but at the same time, if the organizations are able to say 40, 30, 30, or whatever the case may be, at least we're just getting, just starting to collect that data, because I think you're right, Bill, at some point we do need to talk to the county and be able to show
32:14 That, well, this may not be bulletproof accurate, at the same time I get to some kind of read. The other issue I have is on the rating sheet. You know me, I'm uncomfortable with these rating sheets because this is all such a speculative thing in the first place to give people a base score. But it says the following question will be rated on a one least effective to ten most effective basis. Funds will be dispersed based on a cumulative.
32:44 Points Basis, and I'm uncomfortable with that. That lessens? Yeah, because just because you get the highest score doesn't always mean that you get the highest dollar amount or the biggest part of it because you need to look at how much they're asking for and where it's going. I have no problem stating that one least effective to ten most effective, but to say that funds will be dispersed based on a cumulative points basis.
33:11 How about that the cumulative points will be considered when... Yeah, weighed in the decision. Yeah. Something along those lines, but not just cut black and white, because I don't see it as a black and white issue. Does that make sense? Mm-hmm. That's on the rating sheet, though. I don't know that it says it anywhere else on the application. It's not like the applicants know that... Oh, so they don't see it. As long as this is a sheet that...
33:46 But it's all public. So in the end, they're going to get it. If somebody gets a 42 and somebody else gets a 43 and we give more money to the 42, I'm going to have them coming back saying, hey, even though there was only five kids, you should have given us more money. I don't know. Thank you. So Stu, you said you were able to take that off. Let's just take off. Thank you. Before I go to audience, any other questions on the sheets? Okay, do that?
34:18 Go back to the Crawley versus Mammoth. Pat's right. You know, you all know I do the books for the swim team, volunteer for that. I only know the people that I know in Crawley, but there could be others, and they all have P.O. boxes, and I won't know that. So I'm the one that's going to give that data, and I'm not going to know that. The other part...
34:42 In this perspective, say the swim team, I would say there's 80% are actually Mammoth kids versus out of the area. Wouldn't that be against you if you went to the county and said, we want more money because there's more out besides the Mammoth kids? Wouldn't that play against you than for you? It's just a thought to think about.
35:02 Well, other than, except for Whitmore, we get nothing from the county to help us with recreation programs. You had just mentioned Whitmore, so I was talking about, in this case, I would, if I was to pull numbers, I would say 80% of the swimmers are actually out of the town of Mammoth Lakes. And it's going to be difficult to pull, I mean, I know a handful because, and they all have P.O. boxes in Mammoth, but I do know they live in Crowley, but I don't know everybody that lives in Crowley that swims.
35:32 So that might be hard. So I just thought I'd mention that. And I appreciate that. I just hope it doesn't work against you, that's all. And I don't think it will ever be exact, but as long as the town of Mammoth Lakes is the recreation provider for residents of not just Crowley, but Small Meadows, June Lake, other unincorporated areas of the county, I think it's worth it.
35:54 asking it in that way. Even if it's just for our own general information, it would be nice to know kind of where everybody's coming. It might be difficult, I'm just saying. I just know some of you. And this year we may not get a lot of that, but maybe if everybody knows next year, I don't know if there's an application that's filled out.
36:12 But somehow you know that person's, you know, going to be on that team, and so the question could be asked at the time of registration. Right, and we are setting up registration here soon, so I could make a recommendation on one of the forms just to check a box, you know, Crawley, Swal, June, or Mammoth, and then other, and that might help too. I can bring it back to the board and see if we can work on that, if that would help.
36:41 I would think that this year, because there's a lot, I know baseball's already signed up, so if we put it on there, then we just know for next year, and maybe it's an educational thing this year, so. I just, I just want to point out it could work against you, so be careful with that. I don't know how to work against us. Mammoth Lake kids happen to be county residents as well, so I have no problem with asking the county for that kind of help. Anything else on youth sports? No. Very good. Good suggestions. Moving on to...
37:12 Item number three, discuss and provide direction to staff on the recreation facilities and programming planning process. And I want to thank Teri for doing the work she has done up to this point. It is so helpful. It's pretty sad. I can't spell recreation right when I did. I can't read it right. I didn't even notice. That was so bad. I looked at that and I went, oh. Stu, do you have a little presentation on this or any particular questions or way you want us to deal with it?
37:39 So Ray and I worked on the document for you, and I know we're kind of going into uncharted territory with our first workshop, so what we've done is just put together some suggestions and recommendations for the commission. So right at the bottom of the first page there, we've identified six points that the commission could insert into their workshop structure, I guess is what we're saying there. So that's really what we're seeking here.
38:11 We can just kind of run through them one by one if you need to, but I think it'll provide a far more productive session and certainly gaining a little bit more understanding of staff and commission and everybody's role in the process and what we're seeking to achieve during that quality time, because time is obviously paramount. So what we're proposing here is one, staff providing a general overview. So basically at the start of the workshop, much like we do with staff reports, we just come forward, provide a general overview of the document that we're viewing and providing any attachments to the...
38:41 to the committee, to the commission. The second one would be the commissioners then present materials like Commissioner Stehlik did. Findings or just general comments related to the document. And then if you do want to provide any information in advance, get it to staff and we can make copies and get it around so we can kind of get that in your hands early at the meeting which would be very beneficial as well. So that was number two. So that would be so maybe each commissioner would go through their findings and general comments.
39:10 We'd move on to three, and then we'd just collectively conduct, you know, like a mid to high level discussion. Thought that was, you know, a good detail on the planning document. And then as we talked about as well, and these are just really notes from your workshop as we went through the first one, so I'm really just kind of getting them back to you. And then conduct a checklist of accomplishments or identification of items that need, you know, further attention. And then general recommendations, so captured by staff or a nominated commissioner. So as we said, you know, we want to make sure that there's something captured.
39:40 at the end of each workshop, right, that we can, that's actionable. And then identification of action items. So that's kind of, we just put that together. Let us know what you think of that and any comments you may have or we can enhance that in any way. And I'll start again with you. Any questions or comments on that? Stu, just to clarify, are you suggesting that after each workshop we come up with general recommendations?
40:07 Because I think we talked about that at the workshop and we decided that maybe it's best to just wait until the end of the process. And we did, you're right. The problem is we have to glean from each plan the things that we need to do without setting them up as priority and then go back and revisit those to prioritize them at the end of the project if I understand where we're going.
40:37 I think probably what you're talking about is just the things we've pulled out of there that need to go into the urgent and not so urgent bucket and the CIP versus the non-CIP things that go into their buckets. Maybe they're not so much recommendations, but they're at least you're noticing, you're identifying, you know, certain specifics in a planning document that you want to obviously
41:06 Capture. I think that's what we're saying. So we're just trying to capture something from each workshop. I think that's a good idea, and I think that was one of my suggestions at the last meeting, but we didn't come up with any recommendations, I don't believe. Yeah, we didn't come up with any recommendations. Or general consensus. I recall we didn't come up with any recommendations. However, there were recommendations that were called out in the RecStrats, and I think that it is critical, just as you've pointed out here, Stu, with item number six.
41:33 that identification of the action items. I mean, really, that's the goal of what we're trying to accomplish here. Now, as I recall, well, RecStrats already had those action items identified. The Parks and Recreation Master Plan, does it? How old are those? If you could remind me real quick. I think it was 2008. I don't think we need to get too far into that. That's for the next meeting. Okay, I understand. Yes, each plan has some action items in it.
42:01 and triggers for those action items. And while I'm not trying to rush the process, but at the same time just kind of following up on what Pat just said, there is an element of time here that I think is important to consider, especially considering the presentation that's to be made to town council the next day. So while we probably should not actually be making recommendations or proposals,
42:29 on February 20th. I certainly want to make sure that Stu's presentation on February 20th does outline things that we are able to accomplish in these two workshops specifically because these two master plans I think are the most important and I'm not sure to what level Stu can make a presentation on February 20th but I'd like it to be as comprehensive with regard to just identifying those action items.
42:57 that have already been done with regard to the Master Plan, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and RecStrats. Yeah, and I would say that I think we need to kind of clarify that because I think there's some confusion out there as to what we're trying to accomplish still by doing each of these, taking each of these plans and moving forward. And, you know, that I think needs to be then also
43:24 Given to the council, and I think that can be given to them, even if there's not any type of action at that time. So I know at our last meeting we did come up with a couple things that we wanted, you know, as far as inventories go, the bike and the inventory, our facilities, what the facilities are being used for, you know, kind of what percentage are being used. A couple things that we asked for that.
43:47 We did come up with a grouping, so we've grouped each of those, and I think if we take each of our plans and we continue doing that grouping, then that's going to kind of put somewhat of a roadmap out there for us as well, that then we can take all of those and start working specifically with those items. And if we come up with some type of plan at each one, if there's some items that we need additional information on, so that in the end, we can take all of that and then go from there. I don't know.
44:16 Well, and I think maybe the important language in number five is not so much recommendations, but just documentation of the review process so that, you know, there's an actual, you know, like what we did last time with the documentary made. Well, we have, RecStrats has X number of items that are weighed in RecStrats but aren't prioritized, just weighed as far as how many red dots they got. So we have all of those projects. Then there are projects called out in the
44:46 in the master plan for parks and in the trails master plan. And we need all of those items called out in whatever our action list is going to be for the end to prioritize them all. Start seeing where they cross over and where they work together, yeah. Right. So there does need to be a list made of all of those projects that are called out. Yeah. So that we can go back and look at them in terms of need and what the community's actual priority is in basing that. So that's what needs to be.
45:16 Documented in each one. I think that's pretty easy. No, I agree. And I think that's what I'm saying is it needs to be documented. We're not necessarily prioritizing as we go through this process. That will come later. Can't prioritize until we get the whole list. Don't have the whole list until we've gone through all the plans. Exactly. So I think it's just important that council and the community kind of knows what our purpose is and what our outcome will hopefully be in the end as far as what we're looking to do because it's not just a CIP list.
45:46 And that's very important. And, you know, it doesn't mean that anything that comes forward is only going to be something that the town of Mammoth Lakes is going to be able to do. It is going to hopefully bring in partnerships and because there's no way that the town by itself will be able to accomplish all of these things. So hopefully we're able to identify those partners, financial opportunities, priorities. I guess that's what I would be.
46:16 Looking and make sure that we get that out there. And the only other comment I have is on number two is I said, I think that's great, but I would have never gotten you the information that I brought forward, not that it was anything that was, you know, earth shattering last time, but I finished it right before I came to the meeting, so. Anyhow. It was very helpful. I would love to be on top of it and ahead of the game, but that's not typical. Hard to hold it. Yeah.
46:44 Well, I did say at the last meeting that I would look at the master plan and try to put something together and get it out to everybody beforehand. And I did see that there is an inventory of all parks and equipment and things like that in the master plan, so we're halfway there. Which has changed some sense of perspective. To me, the important thing in the master plan is the call-outs for agro-population and how the recreation facilities need to increase because that affects our...
47:12 Prioritization. Okay, anything else on item three? Moving to item four, review and provide direction to staff on the 2013 Measure R Spring Award project filter and checklist spring application form and use of town funds for special events. Okay, so Measure R, spring coming, moving forward. Obviously see the background there. So the spring awards scheduled open April 1st, closed May 1st.
47:46 As you can see, recommendations are June 4th, and funding appropriations on June 19th by Town Council. So a couple of things we want to run through here would be the Measure R. Project Filter and Checklist, first of all, the application form, and as the last item there is the use of town funds for special events. One thing that we didn't bring up on the last item, Chair, was the scheduling of that workshop.
48:17 Because I know it's related to it. I don't know if we can schedule it here or I'm not too sure. You mean the workshop to go over the... Yeah, so our workshop, just sorry to backtrack, but our workshop was scheduled on February 19th to review the Parks and Rec master plan and we were going to schedule that 1 o'clock to talk about those other items from the Forest Service. So I don't know if we can put it in this item or that item.
48:46 I think that we just add those. I mean, normally when we make an agenda, you and I go over it and add the things as needed. Right. I mean, there's certainly time to do it. I just wanted to notify Commissioner that was the action. Maybe we can do that in the manager's report that we'll just... Yeah. Okay. It's a need. It's been identified. So we're going to add that to the list and we can just tell them that we just passed out that. Okay. Gotcha. All right. So back to Measure R.
49:14 So before you is the project filtering checklist and the commission did indicate that they wanted to review that form so it's before you as well. The application form revised to represent the 2013 spring award is also attached and I just wrote down in the staff report on page 2 just a little bit of a background on what the council has indicated to staff of the discussion that they want to have on March 6 regarding the use of
49:44 Measure R and Measure U funds for that matter, you know, town funds for special events. So that was part three of that discussion. And that's it at this time. So I think at this time. Present it to you. The special events funding itself is coming primarily out of Measure U. So I'm not sure that that's even. Yeah, we should discuss it. I think that we should discuss it. It actually used to live here and that was something that we actually dealt with.
50:15 You know, I don't know, maybe we're, we can at least put our two cents in and they can decide whether we're right or wrong, but it was a great concern when we were handing money out to special events a couple years ago, prior to Measure U. It's a great concern that I would have too, and so I would just, you know, I would be happy to put my two cents in, whatever it's worth. And I attended the January 9th meeting, I was not able to attend the January 29th meeting of the MLT.
50:44 So I was present at that meeting and maybe can speak to some of the concerns or cooperation that came out of the events coalition at that time. Okay. Would you like to start it or do you want to have the conversation now or you want to have it? I think this says to agendize it for March, doesn't it? Well, council are discussing it on March 6th, so now is the opportune time. But it depends if you want to just go through the measure items first and then do the...
51:13 This discussion item, it's up to you. Actually, I think if we're going to deal with the special events piece of it, I'd rather deal with it right now. It's on your minds. So, Sean, you can start with us. Well, I actually didn't go to the events coalition, so I guess that's another question that I'd like to, or comment that I would like to, please let me know when you guys have these meetings, because I'm supposed to be attending those. And I actually had to ask for, you know, it's one of those things that, where'd that email go?
51:41 So that's fine. I'll make sure that you get forwarded on that as well. First off, and yeah, let's talk about just the recommendation or talk about this just because staff is asking for recommendations on three things and number three being special events. So if we can just knock this off real quick, maybe we can move on to the checklist at that time. First of all, just discussion of line items in events. Previously, money had come out of Measure R.
52:10 But now that Measure U and Stu, you can kind of speak maybe even a little bit more specific to this. What I am recalling coming out of the January 9th meeting, and again I didn't attend the January 29th meeting, was that applications for Measure R funds would be more for infrastructure that the town owns like this shiny new barricade that we have here, but that requests for line items such as marketing
52:36 would come out of Measure U. Is that kind of consensus, Stu, that we had talked about coming out of those meetings? Yeah, I think the Commission gave us that direction, or recommended that that be the best use of it, only because it was recreational mobility and arts, so I think the determination was made that special events are more aligned with arts and culture as opposed to purely a recreational... Mm-hmm.
52:58 Element. But, you know, the case can be made for both points. But, you know, because it was more of an arts and culture and they were the applications we were seeing at that time, that was kind of where they were directed to go to. But, for instance, yeah, so special event, barricades, timing systems, you know, tents and biathlon mats and rifles have all come out of Measure R. But in previously, and I remember last year, you know, poor Sandra Didi D'Amizio got up here asking for money.
53:26 for the farmers market, as I recall, from Measure R when absolutely every other special event was going through Measure U, and I think we turned down her request because she should have gone through Measure U, and I think that this year specifically we want to be very clear, even though Measure U has closed, is that correct? Correct. Yeah. So hopefully all the special events have gotten before that want money got before Measure U, but I think to be consistent, we want to make it clear that what Measure R is going forward in
53:55 looking to fund is more capital goods that the town owns on town property whereas Measure U funds are more for line item. Now the one thing that needs to be addressed with that I think though is the issue of supplanting because previously Measure R funds has provided funds for line items such as marketing to Jazz Jubilee and others and I'm not sure how we need to address it or even if we do need to.
54:24 Stu, maybe you can speak to that. You know, in the expenditure plan, it's very general in what Measure R expenditures can be used for. It doesn't say infrastructure and things like that per se. So maybe the expenditure plan needs to be looked at, and that's more of a legal issue. Actually, I don't believe Measure R funds were ever used for special events. We used to have an amount that came from council that was used for marketing. It used to be
54:51 And so that, it used to be special events. And then we actually asked that to be, because it was becoming, it was actually coming from Measure A at the time. And so we asked it to be marketing specific.
55:08 Because it was marketing dollars that it was coming from. So it actually was not Measure R money that was being spent on any monies that went to anybody. You're right, I'm correct, but it's not Measure R. It was Measure A money, and so that's why we asked it to be marketing specific. And so one of the concerns that we did have, you know, were people's marketing plans, which were not always very thorough. And then the other concern was that there were events asking for money.
55:37 that actually came and had a surplus at the end of their event and were giving that as grants to other nonprofit organizations. And so it was a concern that we had. It's like, okay, you know, we're handing this money out for you to put this on, yet then you're taking that amount of money or more and giving it to other organizations, which is very great and it's wonderful that they can do that. But if that was the case, then those need to come forward.
56:06 to an application here so that that's with everybody else as far as money is going to whatever nonprofits. So does that make sense? Isn't that the crux of the issue? That's kind of what I got out of this. If the event is making a profit, should that profit go back to Measure R or affect the next year's award for that event? Or do they get to use that for their scholarships and their...
56:33 Well, and that point was brought up at least at the January 9th meeting, and I thought, you know, and at the time I made the comment that running a for-profit event, and Blizzard Blizzard is not seeking any money for this event, but if a for, if from Measure U or Measure R, Measure A or any of those, but if a for-profit business or even a non-profit is asking for money,
56:59 Obviously the goal of this was brought up, and it made great sense once it was brought up, especially for nonprofits, is that the goal of the event is to raise money for the nonprofit. This is one of their fundraisings. So I don't think it should necessarily, and I now agree with this, is that it should necessarily be that if a nonprofit borrows $100 and makes $110, that
57:26 That $10 is that as soon as they're making a profit, that money goes back to Measure R. But perhaps they should be allowed to make a certain percentage over profitability. And then at that point, that money does come back to whatever the measure is. Does that make sense? So that it is, I mean, the whole point of a nonprofit having an event is to make money. So that nonprofit should make money by that event. However, should the event eventually need to stand on its own?
57:56 And I understand to get them going. And we've all said that as seed money, this is a great idea. And if they make money, as the event grows, we should be able to wean them off. So that bookkeeping needs to be done in such a way so that we can see that. At the end of the year, there is a profit. That profit is what they are putting back in their own pockets or giving out. Otherwise, we may as well just take the money and pass it along to the end user in the first place without going through the,
58:26 The whole process and the effort, which is not what it was intended to do. So somehow it needs to be book-keeped in such a way, does that work? For you it is. Accountability. So that we can see that in next year's budget. So it's in their line item for that decreasing funding. And I don't know whether maybe we look at what they're giving away or maybe we look at just how many years you can stay.
58:56 Attached to that appendage. And there's a lot of places that do, you know, year one, there's seed money and it's at this level. The next year it goes down to this level, you know, and it's a tiered thing. And so, you know, it definitely can happen. But, you know, that is a concern when, you know, you were having to deny one person of being able to have money for their event and you're giving it to somebody else, yet there's money that they're taking and giving to another nonprofit.
59:26 You know, and you know, I commend them if they make money and they can do that, but that should not then continue to get grant funding through Measure U. That would be my opinion. What is the requirement that they roll money they make back into the event versus?
59:41 Well, and I'm very much of two minds about this, which is why I kind of like the idea of a percentage, because I think we do need to keep in mind that with most of our events, and it's certainly a consideration when funding is being awarded, is the general economic benefit to the community. You know, a lot of these events are generating these revenues that are being awarded, so I'm not sure that it's, you know, it's quite as black and white as, okay, you guys made $10, we get the $10 back.
1:00:08 Let me just jump in here for a sec. So as Commissioner Stelic was saying, so there is some internal guidelines that the Events Coalition has implemented. So for a one to three year event, the most they can ask for is 30% of their gross, right, of their estimated expenditures. Four to six years is 20%, and then seven plus years is 10%. So, you know, it kind of governs the funding request.
1:00:34 One option is to consider Measure U as a loan. So, for instance, if a first-year event utilizes 30% of Measure U money, 30% comes back to Measure U fund. I mean, you could keep it as simple as that. I mean, that could be something at least as a starting point. You know, I like the idea of just the diminishing, but at some point you have to look at the dollar success of an event and take it off of the 10% as well, if it's being hugely successful.
1:01:02 Then they shouldn't have to keep coming back to Measure U specifically so that they have that much more money to give away. If at the end of an event they're going to have money to give away anyway, then probably they don't need to be attached to Measure U any longer. I guess if there's money that's going to be given away that I would have a problem that it's being used in that manner. If there's money that they've...
1:01:25 Gain that is going to go towards their next year's event, which should reduce any amount of money that they need to ask for Measure U in the next year, then I guess I would have no problem with that. But I really have a problem if it's, you know, grant funding, you know, giving grant funding to one place and then the grant funding is now then being given to another and it's not. What about the scenario where we're giving grant funding?
1:01:50 And they are making a profit on it, but that profit is turning back into operating that nonprofit organization. They aren't giving it back away, but it's covering their hard costs for everything else they do. That's a whole different scenario. I mean, this came about because we did have an organization that was actually turning around and giving the money away. But for most nonprofits, the Historical Society and others in the audience, they aren't. The money that's made off of special events is being rolled back into...
1:02:19 Cover the operating expenses of that important nonprofit, so. Which is not a bad thing. Let me ask this because, and I should know the answer to this, but events that receive Measure R or Measure U money, they have to turn in their budget at the end of the year? We need to see, is that completely transparent? Well, I think what we talked about last.
1:02:40 Yesterday in MLTSCC, and certainly for Measure U, Measure R is a performance report, so you have 90 days to submit that performance report, and in that you have to indicate how much awarding you received, how much you spent, and accountability of the balance. Say for instance, Chamber Music Unbound received $10,000 last year, they only spent $8,500, so there's a surplus in that account. It doesn't mean that they have dibs on that, they have to come back and reapply for those funds every year.
1:03:07 But the other thing, just to Commissioner Turner, so I wouldn't probably consider these funds a grant. I mean, I'd consider these a town funds, right? So they're taxpayer dollars. So it's not a grant you're handing over money. This is town funds. And I think that's the distinction that we're trying to make with this discussion. Fair enough. And I guess because town funds are being used, is do we require a final budget at the end of the event of did they make money or did they not?
1:03:33 That's the performance report. Okay, thank you. Just one clarification. And that is something that we need to be better at. So do some of those groups who receive funding need to come back? And hopefully in their application, you know, when they're presenting again, you know, we receive, when we receive the invoices, you know, I'm tracking that. So of the last year's $88,600, I mean, I only spent $84, you know, so I can give you that number as a total group from the events coalition, you know, if you need to. So we have that information.
1:04:03 Yeah, because that's a coalition. What I need to see from each one of those events is how that excess is being spent. Is it going back into that nonprofit or are they giving those funds, passing it along to somebody else? Because I feel that if it's going back to help run the nonprofit and whatever their, you know, you achieve your nonprofit status because of your goals, then I have no problem with that. If it's just going to give money to some other organization.
1:04:31 Then that's something that I think we shouldn't be funding. How we write that in is over my pay grade. That would just be included in the performance report, I'm assuming. So if there was, you know, excess funds from anticipated budget, what are those funds being used for? You know, I mean, we can deal with that. And that's what I'm asking for. In the report, we need to get that kind of clarity back, I think. In each of those events that have received money actually need to bring back a performance report. Which includes their final budget. Final budget, yeah.
1:05:01 Final actual budget. How many people they, you know, attended the event and their budget for the event and that type of information. And it'd be great to actually include that, you know, by being able to review the final, their summary report that includes their final actual budget.
1:05:26 Yeah, and you know, Jazz Jubilee did send us something that's actually was a pretty good, you could use it as a pretty good basis as to what we're looking for. You know, they gave us how many people were coming, attending from in town, how many people from out of the area, you know, the numbers of people and their budget. So, you know, that's what we should be requiring from each individual event. Yes. Getting back to the question at hand, we want to say that
1:05:57 Any excess funds need to go back into the organization as opposed to being distributed to a third party? I don't know. Well, let me ask you a question, Pat, if I could. You know, the goal of the Women's Club, though, correct me if I'm wrong, is to give money out to other worthy causes, right? So if the Women's Club was to take Measure R or Measure U funds to put on an event, does that mean that you'd need to pay back?
1:06:28 The Measure R, Measure U funds before you dispersed any of your profits to the non-profits that you did? Well, like you said, the Women's Club doesn't request money that way, but, you know, we have different funding accounts, you know, and so maybe, yeah, that's what I would suggest, that the money go back into the operation, whether it's, you know, there's minimal operational costs, but, well, food and things like that maybe for the snack bar. To me, rather than coming back to Measure R,
1:06:58 It needs to be in their report and would be part of the judging for any future fund they ask for for that event. If you have a hugely successful event, I don't want you to have to repay measure you out of that. But when you ask us for money next year, I'm going to want to see that report and I'm going to base how much I give you based on how much you got out of the previous year's success. I think it's more for our purpose and what we give away.
1:07:26 Than saying at the end of an event, if you're successful, you have to give that back. Yeah, I don't think that, you know, we want everybody to be successful. Absolutely. And so, like I say, if they're able to make, improve upon that event because they were successful this year and they're going to use that money to make that event more successful next year and maybe add another item to that event or, you know, some.
1:07:46 At least that's something else. Jen Daugherty is a good example. Yeah, then I think they should have the opportunity to do that. I don't think it should come back to Measure R, but I don't think that it should be a fundraising, something that someone's using as a fundraising, where they use this money to raise money, then to give away to, you know.
1:08:04 And if we see that happening, then it's not going to be high on our recommendation for future year for fundraising. Well, and especially when some of those organizations, those third-party organizations are also coming before us for funding, so it's totally stupid. It's circumventing. Yeah, I'm trying to get some quantifiable direction. I don't know. That seems to be somewhat subjective. What we're asking for to do is that their budget include any profits made.
1:08:32 On the event, on just that, and then how those monies were used. I think that's what we're asking for, is in their report, and that, those reports then need to be part of their next application as well, or that, so that we can see the difference in the budgets. Right, and then it's a, so the U Committee, you know, I'm just thinking, so then it's a subjective determination then from the Committee on Commission in regards to.
1:09:04 How those funds would be spent? Or that's up to the organization? On next request, not previous request, but future requests. Okay, so that might be considered more favorably if they gained a surplus and then requested less funds in the following funding cycle? Is that kind of... Less funds or they were showing how they were going to take those funds and improve that so maybe they still need that same amount of funds because they're going to use these funds in this manner.
1:09:33 To improve their event, to bring more people in or whatever. But without a policy saying that they can't give it to another outside group, it sounds like they can still do that. But then they have to. Well, yeah, they could for that year because it goes into their general fund. But that's what we want to see is what that profit is and what that profit was used for. If it goes to add two more chairs in a classroom versus it goes to some other organization.
1:10:05 I'm going to view that differently. But why not then just say the funds can only go towards being reinvested back into the organization? Yeah, they can't go to support a third party. Just cut it there and then they can't support a third party. That makes sense. Just some direction, I think, yeah. Yeah, that's fine. That's fine. I think that, you know, your percentages and tiering is great and then that, you know, any monies...
1:10:32 Go back to the organization, not necessarily the event. Go back to the organization cannot be used for third parties. What if it's a full profit? I'm not sure. Same? If it's a for-profit? Because you have a number of full-profit events. They should be coming to us for anything but seed money for the first event or maybe the first two events. If it's a for-profit, then I would say that profit needs...
1:10:54 Well, can I weigh in here? I don't think it's any different. It does exactly the same thing. If that person is making money and they're going to bring that to you and say, this is what I'm using it for, you know, it's not going in necessarily just going into their pocket to increase their salary by 200%, that it's going to improve the event for the next year, then you can still, so it's still either going back to the event.
1:11:20 It's not going to a third party or maybe it's not going, you know. Well, that's what I actually wanted to comment just when you were saying earlier about, you know, does money go back into the organization or does it go back to the next year's event? Because, for instance, in Bluza Pluza, and again, I want to stress that Bluza Pluza is not asking for any public funds, but in the case of Bluza Pluza, you know, any profits that we do realize really do go into the next year's event. You know, I keep my, that business
1:11:47 Plan, entire business model is completely separate from my day-to-day operations. I really keep the books, people, everything completely classed separately. So having said that with regard to recommendations that public funds are going to, is that the funds that an event is looking for, that event is to raise
1:12:11 Funds for the nonprofit. Let's just talk about nonprofits only. It is that, you know, hopefully if they can realize 10, 15, 20 percent profit, rock on for them. The money is going to be hopefully funding that nonprofit organization, but also that those funds are going to be set up for future years events to snowballing and making it bigger and bigger so hopefully they're not asking for more money. The biggest problem with a for-profit event is cash flow.
1:12:38 With regard to Belusa Belusa, for instance, we have to lay out six figures three months, five months before the event, before we collect any of that ticket revenue. Because again, with a for-profit event, all that ticket revenue is going to a ticket agency. It doesn't pay us until we perform, until we actually execute, to make sure that no event organizer just runs off with money and leaves the ticketing agency.
1:13:08 with the ball. So the biggest problem is cash flow. And something that I made the recommendation even in the events coalition is that if a for-profit event were to come asking for public money, let's say after we realize a 10% profit, that I would be willing to give back, say, the money that I had borrowed for my event because of cash flow issue.
1:13:31 Plus 5% or plus 3% or plus 4% somewhere right around in that ballpark. And I don't mean to be using public funds for a bank, but if this town really wants to encourage for-profit events, and we can talk about the bike race that tried to come a couple years ago and, you know, Kamikaze this year, which is coming for it. You know, I hope that the mountain breaks records with regard to the...
1:13:55 Revenue that they generate and the people that they bring to the town. How do we encourage more events like that to happen? One of the best things that we can provide for-profit event organizers and even non-profit event organizers is cash flow. It's just being able to put some money down for them so that they can make those initial band down payments, stage down payments that are critical that you can't put on an event without that money three months in advance.
1:14:23 And I appreciate what you just said. And I would love to have that in writing to look at to create policy as for how to handle for-profit events because I didn't look at it in that way. But that's very much the way that the airline subsidy works. After a certain profit, then it goes back to, you know, to reduce the subsidy. So it does flow back. So maybe that is something we need to consider is a...
1:14:50 Sorry to be confusing the issue, but, you know, that's the biggest issue. You're in the business, so I would love to see a written sheet so that we can deal with the for-profit issue as to, okay, you make your 10%, anything over that, X amount of the profit goes back to the...
1:15:07 So if you would volunteer to lay that out for us so I can have it in black and white in front of me. Yes, Mr. Chair, I'd be happy to. You know, if we wanted to bring this back to our next meeting, I know when I was doing some research online on special events and how their funding works and everything else, there's an awful lot of documents that are out there that are the applications for special event funding specifically. A lot of them have this tiering, a lot of them have, you know, verbiage on just
1:15:37 Stuff like that. And maybe we want to bring some of that back and actually put something together. I don't know. I know we're, you know, this isn't really coming out of Measure R and it's not really our, Measure R is not necessarily our purview, but I mean Measure U isn't, but it sort of falls on our laps as well. I mean, we're kind of in the middle. There's a go-betweens there. So I wouldn't mind doing some research and bringing that back because I think there's a lot of
1:16:05 Teri, I'd be happy to work with you on that. There's a documentation that's already out there that we could bring back so that we're not going round and round and trying to create something that maybe we can take something that's already created and tweak it. So we have a committee that will bring us that information back before March meeting and we can re-agendize this again. What is the timing on this? We can bring it on the 19th because we need one more thing on the 19th. Yeah, I do want to jump in quickly. So we have some comments from the audience. Yeah, I'll wrap up quickly.
1:16:33 So a couple of distinctions. So staff reviewed a lot of the special event applications and funding. Haven't seen a lot on for non-profit. But one thing we do want to say this year with our special events in general that staff are going to be conducting is really a good audit of what the town is in kinding. So currently what we're providing each special event producer, obviously a special event permit of $158 is a huge loss leader to the town, right? I mean that's...
1:17:02 That's just in probably my time and Dennis' time just to look at it and process it. Now there's hundreds of hours in there if we're moving things around. So we want to actually specifically this year for each event as best we can in summer actually audit and inventory exactly what staff are providing. So I think that's going to be something we'd like to come back in the fall with and bring that to the Commission and say, OK, this is what it's costing the town. I mean, this is kind of a wholehearted look at special events, which is kind of part of this discussion.
1:17:27 That's what I wanted to say too. And just quickly on Measure R and Measure U, I think there is two distinct differences. Measure R is sales tax generated. So if funds go into Measure R, there's actually an investment multiplier. Measure U, it's just use a utility tax. So the more money you go into a special event or one way to drive Measure R revenue, you'll see a return through sales tax. It's not going to happen with Measure U. It's pretty much of a fixed.
1:17:51 Fixed annual number. So there is that kind of distinction between those two funds as well. So the sustainability in Measure U I think needs to be highlighted as opposed to Measure R because it has that kind of, you know, there's that built-in multiply. So I think that distinction does need to be addressed when we look at those two funds. That's a good point. So I want to address several things.
1:18:18 The first one is what you need to do is restrict the money. You call it restriction to nonprofit or to profit. And basically when you do that, then you have control of how the money is to be spent. For instance, you talked about classes. In QuickBooks, there is classes. That's how you track it.
1:18:36 So, for instance, you have a non-profit that may do several fundraising where you can't tap into the other fundraising but you want to tap into the one that you have given money to. So how you track it is through the class. Then you restrict it saying you want it for a certain purpose. Either if you, that's how you tell if you made money on that event. Then if, in Sean's idea, in Terry's, you could work that arrangement only based on that.
1:19:03 When you have someone like the Jubilee, when it's just one time, one organization, it's very easy to figure out. But when you have a multi-type of fundraising organization, then you have to track it through a report system, and then that's how you would, and you would specify it's restricted for this purpose. So everybody has their own mission statement. So like the Women's Club, what Pat was talking about, their mission statement is to help other organizations.
1:19:32 Where other mission statements could be to help their operating system or whatever you guys decide. And so basically what you need to do is come up with how you want to restrict that money. And then you go back to only that particular amount, whatever you choose to do. If you want it paid back with 5% or if you want it to move forward. And so then what you do is then if you use a profit and loss with that class.
1:20:00 You can go back as far as you want since the beginning of when they've received money and look at the whole system and see how much money they've actually made, and that tells you how much is being carried over each year. So maybe they're actually only made $20 out of 10 years. Maybe one year was really good and another year wasn't that good. So you could ask for that. So that is how it, if nonprofit bookkeeping is done correctly, that's how you do it.
1:20:27 If that helps with that information. And that would be with their performance reports. Exactly. So you could ask not just for one year. You could ask for several years. They should have that. And that would maybe help determine how you want that money spent. But the bottom line, instead of making stuff, you need to restrict it. So you call it a restricted giving, a gift. And these are your guidelines. Okay? Does that make sense? I get that all the time. People do that all the time for my stuff.
1:20:56 This is what they want to use for. That's what I have to use it for. And I have to show it in a report. And sometimes I have to show it to the person who gave the money or the organization. I don't know if that helped. Thank you. Thank you. So as far as the special events go on. Actually, I guess there's one more. Evan Russell with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And I just want to try to shed a little different view on some of the stuff you're talking about because I think
1:21:33 Different organizations have different purposes certainly and they use money in their resources in different ways. And what was just said about tracking events, we do three to five events plus we have in any given day 15 or 20 different projects that we have staff working on. So we break out direct expenses.
1:22:02 for each of our events. So in reference to the food and wine event that gets some of the promotional dollars, we can tell you exactly what income and expenses go to that, but we don't apply overhead and we don't apply staff wages to it. And because we have people working year-round on all kinds of different things, it's very different than an organization.
1:22:29 Like Jazz, let's say, use them as an example, that has one event that they're working on and they're overhead and operating costs come out of that. So you need to kind of take that into consideration. You're going to have a different little look at that. The reason we started the food and wine event is when we were working on a business plan for a cultural center, which you guys,
1:22:59 Noah is something that has been near and dear that we've been trying to push through the college for some time and for a variety of reasons. It's got hiccups behind it. But we had a group a year and a half ago that looked at a number of other organizations. And one key one that we came around to was the Sun Valley Center for the Arts. And they've built their food and wine event over, I think it's in its 28th or 30th.
1:23:29 Year now, but it brings in over a million dollars, which funds their annual, that is about 60% of their annual operating budget for their whole picture, which is facilities, it's programming, it's the entertainment they bring to the community, it's the education they bring to the community. And our goal is to get the food and wine event here to a place that it's bringing in all kinds of money.
1:23:59 that we can then use to help fund arts and cultural programs in the community. So when we make money, it goes right back into our facilities, and we don't allocate anything directly to a staff salary or to a specific project, but it's an overall project. And when you look at this, you have to have some flexibility and understand.
1:24:27 We're different organizations, we're going to have different needs, and we're going to have different uses. And maybe that comes in some kind of a narrative that gets distributed with the profit and loss at the end of an event's cycle. But, you know, I hope we can make hundreds, thousands of dollars of net, but if it's going to be time...
1:24:51 We're investing time in it now with staff and with overhead and with things that we're doing to get it to that point. And in five years, I hope it's in a different place. But again, even after that, if we're making money, in our case, we're putting it back into the community in some fashion. Can I ask a couple follow-up questions, Evan? Yep. Okay. You know, and just to play devil's advocate because I love food and wine experience. I think you guys are doing a good job.
1:25:20 You know, if you're not assigning, because I understand you've got several projects, and likewise, you know, when I do my event, you know, all of a sudden my brewers and my delivery crew all become groundskeepers. And what we do is, as Danette was saying, I really assign their hours for the week, all of a sudden become 50% working for the brewery, 50% for the event. The week of the event, it's 100% they're working for the event. So my question for you is, you know, since you're not classing that, how do you know if the event is worth your while?
1:25:51 We look at Sean as an overall function of what we're doing. So we know what we brought in the first year and the second year, and now we're budgeting for the third year. We're trying to grow that each year, but we've been running the nonprofit for 25 years. We're probably one of the few that hasn't fully audited.
1:26:21 Financial Statement by our auditors. And at the end of the day, if we're able to support the organizations or the projects that we are supporting, that's how we've looked at it. It would be extremely hard. Would I put time down on my timesheet today for the two hours or three hours that I spend in?
1:26:50 And here with this stuff, and we have staff doing all kinds of projects. I could go through and say that we're going to spend 10 or 15 percent or 20 percent of our time on the food and wine event and the cost of our operations, our offices and our facilities and our computers. You know, we could take that kind of assumption and put it into the spread on things, but it's just really...
1:27:19 It's really difficult, and maybe in some organizations that's done, but I work with a lot of other college foundations, and I don't know any others that break it out specifically that have multiple activities like that going on. Okay. But wouldn't you say that when you are making hundreds of thousands of dollars on this event, and we all hope you do. Yeah.
1:27:44 that the need for you to come and ask for the very limited resources of Measure U would go away. Those are needed to front load to build it to that point. Yes. From the events standpoint. Which is what we're all saying. Once you reach a certain level of success, we need to find a way to wean off of instead of continuing to take these dollars to just make your event even more successful. Yes. And I guess the point I'm trying to get across here is you
1:28:13 Hopefully you're going to look at apples and apples. So if somebody's coming in and they're bringing a performer to you that's got their overhead detailed because that's one event they're doing and somebody like us or others that have multiple activities going on, Fleet Chitrio might be a good example is they put on any number of concerts during the year. I don't know if they track.
1:28:40 Their overhead for each one of those concerts that they put on. And the marketing money that they're putting into this now is specifically for their summer music festival. But if they're receiving monies for something like that, then they're going to be bringing back to us saying that they have these many people that came to this and they put on this many performances, which is what they apply for something.
1:29:09 Particular. So if they've accomplished what they came to do and, you know, they're able to increase their number of concerts next year or something like that, then you would consider that same funding. If they're just continually, every single year, keep coming back for the exact same funding but there's nothing changing, then you might consider that that's, you know. There's no reason to evolve or grow the event. Yeah. And I would make an assumption that.
1:29:35 Since you're keeping your books different and you have no staff time in the budget for the event, that when you make your presentation and your pitch for dollars, you would point that out to us so that we would bear that in mind at the time, which is then how we know so that we're apples to apples and not apples to oranges. And we can track it from year to year to year. And the key number I look at is the margin.
1:30:05 That's in there. If we grow revenue, we want to grow the profit, even if we take out those, the overhead factors, that's what we're looking at each year. Any other questions? Thank you. Thank you. I have one last comment. I actually have two audits a year, and my auditors actually require us to put our time against events, and we also actually used it this year to see if we were
1:30:36 Making money or not making money to evaluate it. And we use a big Excel program, and I'd be glad to share it with anybody, but we have to do that. It's required from our auditors that we do that, and so that's why we have to track all that. So we don't put overhead. We only put the direct cost, and it's a big formula, so I just wanted to say that. Okay, any more questions on?
1:31:04 Have we given direction yet? I've got lots of notes. So there's nothing definitive. I believe Commissioner Turner and Stella are going to maybe review some information they can maybe provide. We'll certainly do the same if we can. I think, Stu, the only definitive thing was in the report back that we expect their report to show. That's right. Expenditures, actual revenue.
1:31:32 Just really identifying if there was a surplus and what the surplus is going to be used for. For profit, non-profit. You know, when it does come to something like that, Nevin, I heard your comment very loud and clear with regard to the margins, you know, and again, just to speak a little bit about Balooza Palooza, is that our revenues actually have been fairly flat. My costs have been increasing, so my margins have actually been decreasing over the past three years with regard to that event.
1:32:02 So in many ways it makes me, you know, competition is good when it comes to events. You know, it sharpens our skills. It, you know, sharpens what exactly, what services and performances we're trying to offer. And if something like the Bluegrass Festival comes along that competes with my Hoppin' Sage, well then I'm going to evolve my Hoppin' Sage so that they're no longer, it's no longer competition in the, or at least that, you know, my event is going to be just as profitable. So I think that it is key.
1:32:29 Excuse me, and something, Teri, that I think we should be looking towards is some kind of standardized review of the final actual budget that allows us, if we are going to be making recommendations with regard to private money, whether it's in the form of just cash flow alone, or if it is money that is going to be given to the organization so that they can create a profit that they then turn around and whether they give it back to themselves.
1:32:58 Future Year's events, other nonprofits, whatever the goal may be, that at least we come up with some kind of standardized review for future awards of funds. I think what it is, maybe it's a standardized performance report, so, because I don't think it is just the budget, I think it's the attendance, I think it's, you know, the, all of that needs to be taken into consideration when you're looking at.
1:33:22 Funding these things. And also how we deal with for-profits, because we've never dealt with that before. And we certainly want to be able to make a policy for that. We have been asked by for-profits for money before, and it's been an awkward situation, so if we actually have a policy in place, that takes care of that. I just wanted us to do if the Measure U Committee is also going to...
1:33:48 To weigh in, because I'd just be curious to hear what they had to say on the issue as well. Tuesday, yeah, February 12th, yeah. Okay, before I forget it, and I wrote a note to myself here, in yesterday's meeting, the question came up about report back for the people receiving Measure R funds through the MLTSCC, and it was the opinion of that group that, of course, they had to make regular Measure R reports back, report back.
1:34:21 And I just wanted to make sure that we had the consensus that that's the way this body wanted to deal with that as well. I think we need to get better at having everybody report back because we have been remiss on many report backs. Absolutely. Okay. I just told Stu yesterday I'd get that done and forgot about it until somebody mentioned MLTSCC. So thank you. John.
1:34:48 Okay, so going on to the application and timeline process, which is the other things on this we still have to go through. Does anyone have any questions or comments on any of that? Of course I do. Getting back to those, like G and H on project filters, remember how that's like, we've been kind of struggling with it, and I don't know that this is a good solution, but I thought maybe flipping it around and rating it.
1:35:23 Instead of, for G, instead of long-term impact on Measure R, what if it's a short-term impact? Then a high score would, then it would be consistent with all of the other ratings, A through F, when we're trying to give, issue higher points. Higher is better. And then the same thing on H, maybe we could say limited replacement funds, limited replacement costs of project or service. And that too would then rate it high.
1:35:52 So we wouldn't be rating A through F as high as possible and then G and H as low as possible. Except for, you know, if it has very large impacts on Measure R, I think that we need to. Then you would rate it low. Yeah, we need to. But the goal, I think, is the rating sequence is, on the filters, the higher the score, the better.
1:36:22 So if we just kind of change the terminology around, then that would maybe... I don't think the goal is to say that we have to score it as high as possible. I think that we want to know that that is a detriment to the Measure R. It's going to take money that it's going to tie up funds for many years. That's why if you say, gee, short-term impact on Measure R, and you say, oh, it's a five, that's good. But if it's going to be a long drain, then you rate it one.
1:36:53 Which I think is the same. But I think that's what it's saying right here. Yeah. No, because now it's the opposite. Everything else, A through F, were... No, long-term impact on Measure R, I would give it a zero if it's going to be a huge impact. I wouldn't rate it high. Which is, if we look at the project filter evaluation guideline and their instructions that go out, it goes out to all the applicants, long-term impact on Measure R funds, considerable impact over a long period of time gets you a low score.
1:37:23 Minimal impact over a short time or long time into a high score. So it still scores it the same way. It's kind of the same thing. It's just your... You know, but I think that the concern with this, at least from what I'm remembering, and, you know, my memory has challenges sometimes, was that G&H especially came up with regard to applications that were for studies. Yeah, planning, studies. Planning. As opposed to... Where you just almost have to put an N.A., not applicable on it.
1:37:53 So I think that was the biggest problem with regard to that. You know, the scoring, and Pat, I hear what you're saying with regard to those. For some reason, I thought that there was one up in the primary filters too, but I'm not. Yeah, I think there was. But it was a planning versus actual capital project that was an issue. Well, I think the problem is that most of our project filters don't fit planning processes.
1:38:23 And where the struggle is, some of us were judging it on the project that the planning was for and not on the planning process. So our scores looked skewed because one of us said, well, measurable community benefit, the project we're planning for is going to have huge, so we gave it a big number. But the plan doesn't get us that, so maybe it shouldn't have that number. But I think that's...
1:38:49 True of all the way A through H, not just G and H, which is why I've always said it's a subjective process and not necessarily the highest score wins because sometimes you don't score high, but it's the best project. Yeah, that's my part two of this process because it's a struggle. I mean, I think we all kind of came to a consensus last time.
1:39:18 But I think to the applicant, they're probably thinking, oh, if I score the highest, I'm going to be eligible for funding. You know, maybe not the most amount of funding, but so why do we go through all of this philosophically, the subjective process, if it's going to be subjective? It's a discussion facilitator. It's not an objective venture. Which was my point when we got into this in the first place. Okay. Because I said that each commissioner scores it their own way.
1:39:48 And then we come back and recommend our funding based on that. And somehow that turned into the council wanting to see an actual score sheet, even knowing that the highest score doesn't necessarily buy you any funding. Because I'm with you. That's a known... This is a huge time-consuming thing. I suppose it assures that all of us read all of the applications. But other than that, it's...
1:40:16 It's still a very subjective process and always will be. I don't think you can take that out of it. If you take it out of it, you're going to lose some of the best projects. Well, we're going to come back and reevaluate this form as part of our C&P process, right? After this cycle, obviously. So this could potentially be the last cycle we have.
1:40:37 Well, we keep saying that we're going to look at this after every single cycle and we still haven't. And I don't know, maybe it's a matter of we do another one of these that's one's planning and one's capital. Programming. Yeah, programming capital versus feasibility. That might be a good solution. And so maybe we just have two different ones and, you know, so the questions are applicable to each. And it could just be the feasibility one just goes through the primary filter.
1:41:06 Yeah. You know, just make sure it goes through that way. Anyway, at least some regard because we do make that distinction in the application. Or eventually do we break it out as we did with the trail segment and say X amount goes to capital projects and X amount stays here and then we score them differently, you know, and review them differently. That's something we have to deal with. You know, do we allocate a half a million bucks to capital improvement projects each year?
1:41:36 I think once we get through all of this process and our prioritization that that is something that we're going to want to consider because all along there's been discussion as you take 30% towards capital, 30% towards programming and so much for reserve and so much for maintenance and operations. What are those numbers and can you put an actual percentage to it? And I think we might have a better idea of that hopefully when we finish our whole plan evaluation and prioritization.
1:42:09 Okay, so are we comfortable with the score sheet and moving it on with the definitions going along with it? So there was no change? Is that what I... Did we make any changes? From my perspective. I didn't hear any changes. No. Yeah. Well, I don't think there's going to... You know, because it's a spring award, I don't believe that there's going to be anything that's... You know, I don't know. Well, I have no idea what's coming forward, but anyways. But I think that maybe we ought to look at this and actually maybe...
1:42:38 Maybe do look at it as a planning and feasibility and a capital checklist. And maybe we have two. And they can even sit on one page side by side or they can be just a separate page. Our one side is one and one side is the other. So that we can, because it is, it's a struggle and we say this every single time and then we don't do anything with it. But we do something with it because we set our priorities each year.
1:43:05 And if we set our priority as a planning priority, then that planning, anything that comes in in planning should get an extra score because it meets that criteria. And we do ask that question in here is how it fits with the priorities established by the Rec Commission. So we do have that built in. When we say we want to finish parks, if something is coming in with a finish, we're going to give it a higher score there so it's going to get that bump.
1:43:33 So it's not that we haven't done anything with it. We just may need to do more with it. Because a lot of our funds do go for planning and it does get frustrating. So I'm going to move on from that to the actual application. But no changes have been made on the checklist at this time. I'm okay with no changes at this time. I think we're still going to struggle with it every time. I think we are. I just don't see a solution to it. Some of the terminology. Well, we have another meeting.
1:44:08 On March 5th, just to confirm, if we did, you know, if one of us has a brainstorm between now and March 5th, we can make that presentation on the agenda. So we still have time to change the checklist and the application, actually, on March 5th. So the application questions on the application. So the only one that I have, and we've brought it up before, and when I read through this today, is in Section 3, Project Benefits.
1:44:41 Number one and number three, how does your project service provide a measurable community benefit? And number three is describe the economic benefit. Well, incremental visits, revenue is the economic benefit. It seems to me that number one is more asking about quality of life benefits. And maybe it needs to be more worded that way. That was the only thing. I read through it three or four times again.
1:45:09 Man, if I was filling this out, I'd have to put the same answer in both places because I just... Yeah, actually, that's just all you would do is move the incremental visits revenue down to number three. Right. And because the measurable community benefit would be to the residents and the visitors in Mammoth Lakes. I think that's a holistic benefit as opposed to a financial benefit. I would be good with that. Student, does that make sense to you? Yeah, is there another way to do it? Do we just have three questions instead of four?
1:45:40 No, I think what Terry said, take the incremental visits, revenue, et cetera, and just move that part down to number three, and leave number one, describe how your project service provides a measurable community benefit to the residents and visitors. Well, it wouldn't be measurable then, because it wouldn't be quantifiable, so you can just say, describe how your project service provides a community benefit. Well, it may not be quantifiable, at least it gives them a spot to say that, you know,
1:46:10 Healthy kids are... I just remember that's why we added that back in the day to give it that measureability. I still struggle with it, but incremental visits and revenue, et cetera, are specifically economic benefits. I think it's health and happiness. It's more holistic. Can you change number one? Could number one just be, could we change measurable to say tangible?
1:46:35 Just provide the community benefit. I think I just want to say community benefit. That's kind of what I was saying. So just say, describe how a project provides a community benefit. And then it leaves it very open. Then they can, if they can quantify it, great. If not, then it's OK. I guess I kind of like measurable because it could provide a community. I mean, everything you do provides a community benefit. But is it really a significant community benefit or is it just?
1:46:59 You know, I don't know. And these aren't really answered that well when you look at the answers to the applications, by the way. So everyone does struggle trying to find the words quality of life between measurable and community. He gets a bit waffly. Describe how your project or service provides measurable quality of life community benefit. Number three says describe the economic benefits. We've defined it right there. I can just throw out that suggestion.
1:47:30 Yep, that works, because that's what you're talking about, yeah, that works. But I like measurable still, because it just... It could be attendance, you know, significant numbers of participation could make it measurable, or it could just be, hey, it's a great service. If only two people are actually, you know, doing that, it's probably not a measurable community benefit. It's not measurable, but it might still be a community benefit. Because I think even on the Measure U Committee, they talked about...
1:47:57 It was the mummy class with five kids in it. The mummy daycare program versus the... Better or worse than, you know, an event with a thousand people. Attitude? Check. All right. Any more questions on the application? Nope. That's twice gone. Moving on to number five. That 30-minute thing only took us an hour. I know. Review and provide direction to staff on the proposed Whitmore track and sports field use policy and fee schedule.
1:48:28 Okay, so... Do you want to make a brief... Yeah, I don't know if you can be brief, Chair, but we'll do the best we can. So there's quite a lot of work in here. We spent a lot of time putting this packet together, so... So essentially what we're looking at here is Whitmore Track and Sports Field opens officially, you know, April 1 is kind of what we're shooting for here. Although, right now, the track and the field are predominantly clear. The field hasn't been accepted from the town through its contractor yet, so we're not...
1:48:57 in a position to rent that field. However, the track, based on its controlled use and whatnot, is pretty much ready to be used. So a couple of things here. We've requested kind of an itinerary from Mammoth Track Club right now. They've got a lot of folks, clubs, people wanting to get down there and use it. And as it's a public facility, you know, it's available for public use. In this specific policy and recommendation here, it's any organised activity that requires
1:49:27 The reservation of the field. So for public use, they're more than willing to go down there and use that facility. The problem that we're facing right now, as Dennis can attest to, and kind of why Dennis is here, is just the general use, seeing a lot of dogs around that field. And as you know, with synthetic turf and dogs don't really go together. A number of reasons. Is it posted, no pets? So really the situation that we're facing right now is that we're trying to get a handle on some good signage and so forth to get down there.
1:49:57 But that's a challenge. But what we're dealing with here is, so from April 1 and from the general season, which is through November 1, is the fee schedule for that facility. It's the application form and the field rules and regulations. The reservation process is what we want to kind of address with you. So what I thought I'd start with is just kind of the fee schedule, which kind of goes to the nitty-gritty of we've got this field, what the heck do we charge people to use it?
1:50:25 So this is just a special event, more or less, that, you know, there's going to be an organized game that's going to be on there. That's correct. Or, you know, track events or something like that. That's exactly right. So, and it goes beyond special event, if a high school running club wants to come up and book the track. Correct. To use it, and I would expect any organized group to, is going to have a number of people to come up and, because that's not just general public use, it's not you and the kids going down to.
1:50:53 Yeah. Exclusive. So if you want to reserve the field. Exclusive, yes. And we do that already, Commissioner. You know, Stelic, as you know, shady rests. It's not as much as we'd like in that field and being reserved, but we do do that. But for this facility here, as you know, it's going to be very well utilized. So we want to make sure we have a processes and system, which is a little bit of our recreation software needs right now. Yeah, so if this is going to be, I'm sorry, I should probably let you do the presentation, but so if a
1:51:21 High School Track Club comes up and wants to go down there and use that, are you going to go down and clear off any other public that's down there? Yes. Okay. So you would go down and post that this is going to be reserved at such and such time? Yeah. So we'll have a board down there. We sat through some presentations. We'll have a calendar there. They can review it. And as we talk about in this process here, which we'll get to, you can only reserve the track or the field. So if someone's reserving the field,
1:51:52 We can't have the track reserved at the same time. People can be using it for general use, but we can't double up that facility. And likewise, if someone's reserving the track, I can't have a soccer game going on at the same time. So if you're renting that facility, you get the facility for that period of time. It's a two-hour minimum. So anyway, let me just go through. I only have one question on that. Okay. If the Mammoth Track Club is not running an event, but they are reserving the track for...
1:52:20 Practice Sessions, and you had a soccer club or youth football that wanted to use the field for practice. I don't see the incompatibility there. I would agree that there's an incompatibility for events. You can't have a football game going on with a track meet. Obviously, there's some issues. But if we're talking about training exercises... Yeah, no, you're exactly right. It's a meet. And we're really talking about organized meet. You know, we're not...
1:52:46 Remember Track Club there, it's just noticed in the calendar and it's, you know, anybody can really go on there. They're not saying, you know, you have to leave the facility. I think what we're talking about is a track meet or a soccer tournament or something. But it's not spelled out here. If I'm Torrance High School and I come up here and I reserve that to go down and work out on, which is not a meet, then the local youth football team could be doing some practice.
1:53:11 On the field as well. Depends what it is. So it's a little bit of subjectivity there, which I think is just based on the reservation. So I think we'd kind of like to keep it that way intentionally just to kind of give that flexibility. But again, you know, it depends on the type of the use, right? So let me get through the fee schedule. So we reviewed. You can see that we've got our current fee schedule in here that we've attached to you. We've looked at, you know, natural turf fields. We've looked at synthetic fields.
1:53:38 We've looked at municipalities versus college university fields. As you notice, municipality fields are a lot more affordable than college university fees by probably two, three times. So that's important to notice as well. We analysed, if you look at it, attachment A, we went through and selected as best we can from a variety of geographic areas. So we've got Carlsbad, you've got City of Sparks to the north.
1:54:04 Phoenix, way out there in Arizona, you've got Menlo Park, which is kind of the Bay Area, City of Dublin and Emeryville. So we've tried to get a cross-section of fields and who uses them. And we've put our categories down here on the left or something similar to them. And what we're really starting from the base point is that far left column is that synthetic, is that natural turf field. So for right now, if you look at our adult youth non-profit fee, it's $10, $10 or $10. I mean, that's all we charge for a baseball field or...
1:54:33 Or a soccer field. So what we're proposing is, you know, a $20 fee, $25 and a $30 fee, depending on when you're renting that facility. And then you can kind of go across the columns and see where they all range from, but you can see, you know, they're pretty consistent in regards to, nothing's extremely overpriced, except when you go to a city of Dublin. You know, they're looking at $90 per hour, these are all per hour fees, $55, $50, $65 for Carlsbad. And I did talk to the...
1:55:02 The guys down in Carlsbadon, they have high demand, right? So when they have high demand, you can charge, you know, pretty much whatever fee you want. You see a lot of people coming on, you know, for us, we know we'll have demand, but until we really see that demand, I think we're trying to create that demand. So that's kind of where we've come in. So we think those fees are pretty comparable. You know, essentially it's double a regular field, right? So if you want a synthetic field, it's 20 bucks instead of 10.
1:55:27 The security and cleaning deposit is important for us. And you can see they range in price from really nothing to $400 to $500. And that's because the field and its sensitivity to a lot of the use that we want to have. So we want to make sure that that's pretty clear in regards to a deposit. You know, they'll get back if it's satisfied. But that field, you know, we want to extend its life for. It's a very expensive field, you know. So we want to make sure that those users abide by the regulations that are provided.
1:55:54 in this policy. So that's kind of why the security deposit is $250. So that's something we feel strongly about there. So that's the proposed fee schedule. You can see if we go back to page two and page three, let me just walk you through it here because I know the chair was jumping in there. Just a couple of questions. Oh, it's jumping in again. I'm jumping in anyway. Local sporting organizations with the field use agreement, is that
1:56:25 Just local? I mean, if there was a sporting group that spent the entire summer up here, we would not give them that. Currently, that is only Monaco County Little League, AYSO, Soccer, and the Dog Agility Group have a facility use agreement, but they don't get charged a dollar. They actually have a different fee. So it's only the youth sporting organizations that are local, and there's only two of them, I believe, that get that dollar season. Now, that's up for discussion if you believe that they should be...
1:56:54 But what they're bringing to this as well is a lot of volunteer hours. And AYSO right now, for their contribution, I mean, they're actually paying all the striping. They're buying all the gold. So they're inputting about $10,000 in this facility. And in return, they'll get X amount of hours to use. But, you know, obviously they have this dollar per season anyway. And as did the football. I mean, they were able to get that grant for $50,000. Should I say local youth sporting organisation then?
1:57:22 Yeah, so local youth, yeah, we can clarify that. And while we're there, we'll just keep going down the list. So an adult, so a youth, adult, non-profit or government organisation. So if the county comes over or if another jurisdiction from another government organisation wants to rent that field. And I'm not distinguishing here and I know a lot of the research that we did do. So they'll actually have a different rate for youth and an adult non-profit. I mean, they go, they really drill down and I don't know, I try to keep out of that right now.
1:57:54 I just thought if you're a non-profit or government, it's $20. I didn't want to build so many fees that it becomes just too confusing. I'm sorry, so these are all per hour, but it's a two-hour minimum, right? So you're doubling this basically for whatever you're... Yep, so it's $20 per hour. And then we made the distinction here with a less than 10-day or greater than 10-day reservation. We have that currently right now. So for those...
1:58:20 Folks that can, you know, get that facility rented greater than 10 days, it's an incentive to do so, which is advantageous for us and for Dennis' crew to understand what's coming forward. But Stu, you're allowing groups to cancel one week prior. Which is our current policy. So then if you have another group as a backup who's willing to come in, do they pay the less than 10 day fee? Do they pay a higher fee? That's a good question. Good question.
1:58:50 Yeah, if we're going to use 10 days there, maybe our cancellation needs to be two weeks so that if somebody had that conflicting date, they have an opportunity to rent it before the 10-day time. Rather than changing that, I would make our cancellation fee a two-week cancellation fee. Or we could do seven-day rental and keep it consistent. I mean, that seven-day is consistent right now just with our other fields and facilities. That's why it's left in place. So we could, if you wish, here just make it a less than seven, 10-day and that would...
1:59:20 Sorry, less than or greater than 7 for reservation. I mean, it's... Or if they're filling in at the last minute that you waive the requirement, you know, you let them pay the lower fee. I'm happy to keep it simple, so if we just want to go to 7. Yeah, I think that's the simplest. Yeah, just do 7, that's fine. Keeps it clean. On this adult, non-resident or commercial use, I would say commercial use should be a higher fee.
1:59:50 You were over here for this one, yeah, so we don't use that, right, so we don't have a distinction, so I was just back over here with this other table on page three. Some of them have, so for commercial use, if it's a for-profit organisation and they're obviously gaining revenue, so if it's some type of special event, those type of things, they have a higher fee. What about the Nike group that comes in the last couple summers?
2:00:12 Where would they fall? So they would just come into that greater than seven or less than seven rental reservation, so either $25 or $30 an hour. Again, on the first year, I'm just trying to keep it somewhat simple. I don't know how we want to keep... I mean, we can certainly add fees.
2:00:31 Yeah, I'm going to recommend that we just keep it simple, especially this first year. I mean, do we have any interest? Have you had any? Okay, great. Oh, yeah, yeah, we just got to get this in place. Oh, great. But I think that we need to kind of watch that because commercially used, I think if somebody's coming in for commercial purposes that we should be, you know, making sure that we're...
2:01:00 You've got to dig down into what is commercial. Is a guy running a running camp? Who's paying himself from the running of a running camp for commercial use? Maybe it's over a certain number of people or something. I don't know. But, yeah. I think we've seen how many commercial-type groups we get for this first year. Yeah, we can play it right here this first year. Look at it for next year. And that reservation form, when we do get there, does distinguish that, too, so we can track that. Okay. So when we looked at tournament fee, tournament fee, because you're booking it for a weekend, you know, multiple day,
2:01:29 They did have a break-in fee, similar to City of Sparks. So we lowered that fee to $15 an hour because you're booking it for essentially 8 to 16 hours. That was quite a reasonable request. One thing we did add was this fee here in regards to recreation supervision or facility staff fees. So, for instance, if we do have a tournament fee, we're actually requiring that organisation to pay for staff to be there to supervise that facility. We think that's a fair request.
2:01:59 Where Dennis and I felt that that was applicable. Just to really control what happens on that field all day. You know, with tournaments, they're bringing all the coolers in, there's food coming in. You know, we've really got to be very diligent in policing that field and protect it. So that's kind of why that fee's there. And then secondly, on the other half of that fee, if Dennis has his staff moving special event equipment in and out of that area, we need to at least cover some costs for that. So 25 was quite reasonable. Dennis thought that was fair.
2:02:27 So that's why that's in there, and maybe this fee might become more prevalent throughout. So, Stu, could you clarify, because it wasn't clear to me. So, there would be the fee of, say, $20 per hour for adult, non-profit or governmental group. Then, on top of that, they would pay a staff fee. Good. So, yeah, so it's this top bullet.
2:02:51 Commissioner Adich on the top of page 3 of the staff report. So in addition to rental fees, special events or tournaments, we'll be required to pay an hourly supervision fee, $25 per hour per staff. Now, could there be for somebody that's coming in, if they are supplying somebody that's going, if there's a form that they're going to sign and says, you know, for liability reasons, they're going to supply that supervisor person, whatever, sorry, and...
2:03:20 That they're going to have some type of insurance that would be actually insurance against any damage to the property? Would they still need to have that person? That's required anyway. They'd have to provide that liability insurance. You know, we think for the first year, this was pretty, there were a lot of cases where it was there. So I think in our first year, I think this is reasonable. I think we can review it. Yeah, but I'm not looking at just liability. You'd be looking at damage. That's right. I want to make sure the field's protected. Yeah.
2:03:50 It's not a revenue drive, it's just trying to protect our facility and amenity and we are isolated down there. It's not Shady Res Park where we can kind of run down there. You're really committing someone to the field there all day. So, you know, it's a large tournament. I don't know how many large tournaments we'll get, right? I mean, or special events. It could be one or two. So I don't know if it's a big thing, but it is kind of prevalent in the fee structure that we looked at. What would a large tournament consist of? Soccer tournament would be down there. So, for instance, if AYSL, I mean, we're looking at bringing tournaments down there.
2:04:19 That's really what we'd be using. We'd be using Shady Rest and that field for tournaments, and we're really using that field all weekend. So with our facility use agreement, we'd pay a dollar to use that field, but we'd still be paying that $25 per person per hour for that supervision of the field. And personally, from AYSO's point of view, that's one thing less that we have to do. That you have to do. If I know that there's staff there, and it's town staff, right? So if I need something, the water breaks, the toilet goes off, you know, whatever it is.
2:04:47 There's an employee there that's part of that agreement that can take care of that situation. So I actually think it's more of a customer service type of thing. Okay. I was just trying to figure if it could be a detriment to bringing in a tournament. So if they have their own folks that they could. It's a minimal cost. Okay.
2:05:07 I think it's better to have staff there because then if there's some opposing group coming on and trying to use the facility while this group has access to it. I don't have a problem. That's all I was thinking. It's because we want it to be used. Well used. We also want it to be protected and covered.
2:05:24 Some costs, if possible. And to guarantee that, you know, if you all made that reservation, you get some support. And we also know there's just no one else available to enforce this. Right. You know, with the situation with the police department and, you know, and I think we're also going to have to talk about enforcement for times when it's just open to use. It's very difficult. You know, that's going to be a cost, too. Dennis can talk a little bit about that, too. I mean, we're planning to have a maintenance person there that manages the pool, our ball fields, and that facility.
2:05:53 But they're in three facilities, so they might pay more attention to that one if there's something going on.
2:06:24 We have a lot going on. Can I get you to come up to the mic since we're on this? Stuart, you were talking about this $25 per hour charge. Does that reflect what we pay?
2:06:59 So all of our costs associated with the employee, it's covered in it? No, it's not the full cost. Yeah, it's not the full break-even cost, but it's, you know, what we're trying to say is that, you know, he's captured with a maintenance fee and also, you know, a supervisory fee, but that person's really going to be there for that tournament. But that's not covering the cost of that person, I think, is what he's asking. Is it actually covering the full cost of that person to be downloaded for that time period? I don't think they could really.
2:07:29 That would be, you know, 50. So I don't know if that was really, I don't know if they can really burden that cost. It's hard to say which person would be down there if it's on a weekend. We're going to take the weekend person and say, hey, you need to focus on this this weekend. In most cases, I think that will cover their hourly.
2:07:58 Great. It just doesn't cover the benefits. Many package and the paper and the answer and the, you know, factory. It's straight across. Right. Yeah. Well, Benny says that he's out there in the fresh air. That's right. So that's the proposed fee schedule. So any other questions, I'll move along and just keep writing them down if you have questions. The commercial, but I just think that it can be reviewed at the next year.
2:08:31 Brings us to the next point. So we'll go to the application form, if you can, which is attachment C, I believe. So what we did here is we looked at, and it's actually all of it, so it's the whole form that people will get. Recreation Facilities Use Form is D. Okay, so let's go to D. What was it D? Yeah, now let's come back. So let's go to C. Sorry, Chair. You're pretending I know the alphabet now. Sorry, just go backwards.
2:09:03 So attachment C is the Whitmore Track and Sports Field information packet. So it's a five-page document. And I'm bringing your attention to that because you can see the comments on the side. So this is essentially what we would hand out at the counter prior to moving into an online, web-based kind of reservation process. So the comments on the side is what were provided by the Mammoth Track Club. So you can see in that first paragraph,
2:09:32 You know, the facility operates from April 1, November 1, weather permitting, between 8 a.m. and sunset. And the comment made by Mammoth Track would be, can I not open on sunrise versus 8 o'clock? We didn't see a problem with that. Again, there's no supervision down there apart from a parks maintenance person going down there. So we thought that was all right. But again, 8 a.m. to sunset is our traditional openings for all our parks.
2:10:00 So again, we're just trying to maintain consistency. So if we change that, it will only be for this field. Yeah, yeah, for field, yeah, for a facility, yeah. So it's a good distinction. But anyway, so we think that's okay. So I put that there. So, you know, we'll be sunrise to sunset. And it talks about on the bottom there in regards to reservations. So it really states, as we talked about, that any organized structured athletic activity.
2:10:28 Requires the completion submittal and approval of a facility use application that includes approved liability insurance and payment of applicable fees. So that's really the distinction. So when we receive phone calls, if it's an organized and structured activity and you'd like exclusive use, then you go through this process. So the reservation information that you see on the next subsequent pages, I believe we talked about a little bit of this before, it's consistent with
2:10:57 Our current application process for all of our fields. And you can see we've talked about the fields. We've talked about the security deposit. And then we have regulations, alcohol, sound, insurance, trash disposal, and vehicle access. Again, they're consistent with our other fields. I have a quick question. Just on the alcohol, since we're not going to allow sugar drinks, I wondered...
2:11:25 How we would control where alcohol is consumed, because presumably a beer would be just... I was actually going to ask, which town parks allow alcohol? All of them. None allow alcohol. Okay. Well, that's what I thought. All of them. Yeah, none. So why are we even, you know, because I saw that on the application.
2:11:47 Yeah, I thought it was a trick question. Yeah. Turns out it is. So, yeah, what we're saying here is prohibited on all town parks except at a concession area duly authorized by the town and properly licensed. Okay, so in the actual application, that is just trying to... It's a trick question then.
2:12:04 Well, no, I mean, even in special events, I don't take alcohols. Under additional information, it says, will alcohol be present? Under special permit. Yeah. That's why I say, under special permit, if there's a special event, then it could be permitted. Yeah. Under special permit. Okay. Through the chief. Okay. So it goes through ABC, and that's the process there, yeah. But how would we keep, I mean, it just, it seems like we would need to have the area for that, obviously. Exactly. It's like. We can suggest it. Okay.
2:12:32 Yeah, but if an organization wants to rent the park and pay enough money to rent it, it's an adult thing. They have to go through ABC and get the ABC licenses, and they have to live up to those rules, and so I wouldn't want to preclude it completely from parks, because that's where special events take place. Well, actually, yeah, that's right. And I guess shady rest, it's not even allowed with permit, correct? That's what I thought.
2:12:55 We have trouble. I mean, it's a softball situation that we struggle with enforcing over there. It can be. No, I don't think it can be. So we've permitted, I think, for a barbecue or something. The community, what they call it, the old-timers event that was out there under court. Okay, good point. We've had multiple events in the past that have served out there. Okay. I stand corrected.
2:13:25 What you might want to do, though, during adult sports leagues is have staffing there because it is consumed without a permit. Oh, we know. We don't enforce the loan. Go call and ask. We can't. We should. We should. But what we're doing is... It would just be... I'm not going to go out there and start breaking up fights.
2:13:54 What we are proposing, though, this year, because I know I bring up a good point, we've been addressing that for the last couple of years, and we had a position in the past that was called an adult sports coordinator, so we're looking at reinstituting that position. We do have budget for it. So that's something we're bringing to kind of oversee the adult softball leagues and tournaments, and that would be one of their responsibilities to work with staff and PD in regards to the best way to kind of enforce that.
2:14:24 Because smoking has been an issue in the parks too this past year. Yep. Well, that would be a question. You need to go ask, see what's going on. He has to excuse himself for a moment. If there was a problem down there, would it be Mammoth Lakes PD that goes down there? Would it be Sheriff? Sheriff, I was going to say, because that's county. Yep. It's on the county road, yeah. That's why we had the cattle coming in the bull fields, remember? Yeah, the sheriffs were, and the CHP were.
2:14:54 Pushing him in. Anyway, moving along. Okay. Got it. So I'm going to jump over to the track and sports field application form. So we have a form that we currently use, which I attached to this, which was attachment D. And attachment D was getting very convoluted in regards to what's already on that. So we created a separate one specifically for this field and facility.
2:15:22 And what we're really trying to find out, you know, when you look at activity details is find out if it's youth or adult, right, so we can kind of quantify that. Don't worry about those little symbols, that was just a bad printer. We want to understand what activity is being used for, so is it track and field, football or soccer, that's typically what they'd be running it for, is it practice, game or tournament, meet? You got a leave chair? I do. Sorry, excuse me. Okay, hope it's okay. Me too. Okay.
2:16:00 We're good. We do ask for a total number of attendees, and again, we break it down by youth and residents. So we're trying to get those numbers. Specific dates, days, times, those type of things. And then this is where you're obviously looking at additional information. Is this event activity a fundraiser? So that's maybe where that commercial interest, and we can start to track that. Will alcohol be present? Yes, no. If yes, please explain. And that's something that we can obviously guide them. Maybe we can put a little...
2:16:30 Maybe supply. Yeah. Well, they're going to have to supply you with all their licensing and everything else. Exactly. Or maybe we can change that to will alcohol saying, you know, would you or do you plan to, you know, have alcohol or, you know, have alcohol in the park. That might be better. Will food, will money, will there be amplified sound, will your activity include entertainment? So these are just all, you know, things for staff to ascertain the scope of the event and really what we're trying to deal with. I don't know how many people will really...
2:17:00 Fess up to all of that, but we'll see. Pretty hard. And then you can see we've broken it down to department use so we can start to track standard hours, any additional hours, staff hours, deposit. You can see it's $100. It's actually $250 now, if you saw that. Other trash or collection damages. So if we required additional staff to go down after that vent and clean it up, that's when we'd actually bill those hours.
2:17:26 And then for department use only, you know, we can start to track it and we have an approval process. So risk management really looking at making sure the liability documents are complete. And then the recreation department managers reviews to make sure it's scheduled correctly and it's the right type of use for that facility. And then while at the same time, once they walk through this process, they'll actually go ahead and initial and sign the Whitmore Track and Sports Fields Use and Regulations document.
2:17:55 So really what they're asking them to do here is to take responsibility for their actions and their event. This has been reviewed by the Town Attorney, so it is consistent with our policies currently. And you can see we really want to make them aware that it's their responsibility and under no circumstances will the following items be allowed or used at the facility. All these things here really affect the...
2:18:22 The integrity of that facility there on the field especially. And that's really what's going to be on the signs of the field too. So when you walk up to the fields, that's what's going to be on the gate and the fence. But isn't that inconsistent then with the alcohol question? Because you're saying that it can be permitted if a group has permission and they have the ABC licensing and whatnot.
2:18:45 But then you're saying that under no circumstances is it allowed? Not on the field. Under no circumstance it could be on the field. So if they were going to have their alcohol, it has to be outside of a fence. But it says to be used at the facility, to be allowed or used at the facility. It doesn't say? Yeah, I don't know. I mean, maybe at the facility within the track? Are the bleachers outside the fence or inside the fence? They are outside. Yeah.
2:19:13 So we can maybe quantify that. We can quantify that a little bit if you want. Maybe just say on the fence area. On the track surface or the field surface, right? Or within fence, whatever. However you want to do that, but yeah. On the track field surface. Clarifies it. Yeah, that's good. You want to make it as specific as we can, right? Because you've got to enforce it. And then the big one here too, I agree that I will be financially responsible for any costs incurred by the town for damages to town property.
2:19:42 Reimburse Town, Reasonable Attorney Fees, Forfeit All Fees, Deposits, and this is again consistent. All debris and trash must be removed. Talks about alcohol again. And then we ask them if we can take their photo for the brochure. And then for individuals' use, so if it's an organisation, they'll sign both, as you can see here. So they complete the two waivers, so they'll sign.
2:20:09 This first one, the waiver and release, and then they'll sign for organization's use. Also complete the second waiver and release agreement. So they end up signing it twice just to make sure. Who are you requiring to sign this if it's an organization? It's usually a board member. You're requiring it to be a board member, okay. Yep. I just, I don't know. Yep. I think you need to have it required to be a board member because that way it's going to be covered. Elected official. I guess I, yeah. Do we need to state that anymore? I don't know.
2:20:39 Yep, we can quantify that too. So the action we're seeking today is we'd like to take this to Council because they have to approve the fee schedule. The use and the regulations is a commission action. We don't need to take that to Council unless you feel it necessary and you want us to take it to Council, but all we're really seeking is a motion to approve the proposed fee schedule for the...
2:21:10 Whitmore Track and Sports Field for that facility. You're taking just attachment C to council? Correct. And all we're really seeking them to approve too is that fee schedule. Unless you feel that you want us to seek their approval of all those documents, but what we've been instructed to do is really only for a fee schedule is what's required. That's the only thing you need to, that we really need to.
2:21:42 Right, because it's town council. It's more of an administrative action, which in regards to the forms, but a fee schedule needs to be approved by council, so. Would you like a formal motion, or do you just need a consensus? I think a formal motion would be good. Thank you, chair. Vice-chair, sorry. Do we have a motion? So moved. So moved with any, there haven't been a lot of changes, but with the minor changes that. It's just, and I'll just run through those quickly, so the fee schedule as presented.
2:22:13 in the staff report, and we'll look at those amendments here. So we amended, Jamie's following along, and I can capture this too, is its local youth sporting organisation, and then we changed the days from 10 to 7, so it's greater than 7 day or less than 7 day, and that's consistent with the cancellation policy. And that's the only change that I identified. Okay.
2:22:41 Yeah, the only comment I want to make is just that we make it clear that this is the recommended first year. And I'm sure they'll get that, but at the same time, I can see some of the town council say, hey, we should charge a little bit more for this or that. And that's kind of why I put that little paragraph below it there. So staff recommends an annual review of the fees, which I think is really important so we can kind of provide an analysis. Okay, so we have a motion. Do we have a second? Second. Second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? I'm sorry, did we have any further discussion out in the audience? Okay.
2:23:12 Okay. And I just want to commend staff, too, for this work. Yeah, there was a lot of time and effort put into this, so I appreciate that as well. That was my Christmas vacation. Yeah. Sorry. And I appreciate the clarifications that came today, because I was looking at some of this and it wasn't completely clear. Thank you. You're very welcome. It's a good effort. We're very excited to get that filled up, and you can see that's kind of why we're trying to pursue a more robust reservation system.
2:23:40 Certainly for not only our programs but this facility because you can see it is quite awkward. A lot to do and, you know, as much automation as we can will be, yeah, much more convenient. How will it be publicized? Yeah, so we just talked about that today in a staff meeting and I'm probably going to bring it up in my manager's report so if I can jump to that chair. Let's move on to the manager's report. Well, wait, do we have to do anything? We're not there yet. Okay. We're on number six.
2:24:12 Yeah, but with the Recreate, the Active? Is that part of the? No, that was just part of the, yeah, previous package. I'll talk about that in mine. I just added it on there because it did give the opportunity to kind of talk a little bit about software, but I've got it covered in here too. Did you have anything that you wanted to add to your manager's report or explain in here? Yeah, so in addition to what's provided, we met on February 1st.
2:24:43 with Commissioner Truax and Agnichan, I apologise for Stelic, I couldn't quite make the advice, sorry about that, but that was February 1st for ActiveNet, and we're trying to schedule one with Easy Facility this Thursday at 1 o'clock. So the goal with this Recreation Software Review is to kind of make it a collective effort to review some of these vendors that we can kind of make a determination of moving forward. Something that will be coming forward, you know, if we do want to move on this,
2:25:12 is how we plan to fund it. We're looking at different ways to do it right now. One's an upfront cost. Others would be monthly costs. So whatever we do, we'll have to develop a plan to do that. So staff will kind of come forward with some options moving forward. I provided a couple of documents for you on the staging scope review for the staging area out of Shady Rest Park from the U.S. Forest Service. So that scoping document.
2:25:41 is seeking comments on March 1st. So that's that three-page handout that I think you grabbed at the beginning of the meeting. So this was discussed in yesterday's MLTSCC meeting and they determined that they would like the opportunity to meet collectively with the Recreation Commission to discuss that document because the deadline is March 1st. So what we were proposing was to meet on February 19th at 1 o'clock, just an hour prior to your 2 o'clock workshop for the...
2:26:11 Parks and Rec Master Plan to go through this document and try and provide some written comments back to the U.S. Forest Service on that item. So we can take that action with the recommendation of the Commission. That's a full hour beforehand. That's correct. So 1 o'clock. We'll send out that meeting request. And then the other handout there was a travel management community workshop. That is also on February 20th.
2:26:40 That begins at 6 o'clock up in the community centre. So we work with the Forest Service on those dates. As you know, we are here at 5 o'clock for our workshop. Hopefully we can jump over there at 6 o'clock and listen to the update from the Forest Service on that document there as well. So those two items. I've got a little handout here. If you want to grab it, it's a...
2:27:08 Just thought I'd bring it to your attention. February 23rd, the JLA project, which is the Vulcan Brothers skate park, conducting a bank slalom at Mammoth Mountain. That's kind of a big fundraiser for that facility. So you'll probably see a little bit of that coming out. So if you want to learn a little bit about that, that's here. As you know, a lot of those funds do go towards maintenance of that facility, which I'm not sure we're quite there yet. So that's that one.
2:27:37 The ice rinks, just to give you an update there, I know there were some numbers in the handout. We did have a total attendance in January of just under 2000, so 1946, and that includes about five days of closures and intermittent surface. Let's just keep it at that, right? So it was, as you know, we broke another pipe. We're lucky to have Dennis here.
2:28:08 After that, so fingers crossed we'll make it through February 24th, which is the closure of that facility, right? And then right now, because of the warmer weather, it's either early morning or late evening because it's just, again, too warm during that data. Because you guys aren't freezing it right now, you're just... No, we are. You are again? Yeah. It's just now that once we hit February, longer days, we hit these, you know, yesterday was 200. I don't know what it was yesterday. So we're struggling with shade again. We're struggling.
2:28:39 So we talked about the February 20th, so that's the Town Council presentation. I believe I did send this around to you last week. So if you do get any comments, I'm still going to add some information here on volunteers. We do run a high volunteer contribution right now for our department and a little bit more information on our planning documents as well, which I thought was advantageous. So if you do have any comments on this, let us know. We talked briefly about this in our department head meeting and really the goal...
2:29:07 Ideally is to provide councils a really good overview of what we do. Right? Kind of a good high-level discussion. I don't know how deep it's going to get into actually providing any restructuring guidelines. I think that's really April 20. I mean, so right now they're just going through this list of public works. They have community development tomorrow and economic.
2:29:27 And then Recreation Department, Measure R, Measure U on February 20. So right now it's just really an audit from Council in regards to what we do and then trying to determine better ways to potentially operate. And that's kind of why we've come out. And you can see here if we look at the last page, which is really what we want to reiterate, it's kind of the what's next to Council. And that was really the top section here on Recreation Planning, what the Recreation Commission is doing here.
2:29:54 With our Capital Investment Program, but also Recreation Asset Management Strategies, Programming Needs. We talk about web-based recreation software, as we know that's a far more efficient and productive way to deliver the method we're currently utilizing for reservations and so forth. With more pool enhancements, you know, we're really moving forward now to investigate, you know, what can we do with solar, and we want to, you know, look at pulling that forward in a Measure R application this spring, and also programming.
2:30:22 We have facilities opening, as you know, we've got trails in park, with more track coming full online, and we've got a lot of new summer programming, which speaks to my next item, but I do want to kind of request a subcommittee meeting with our committee members, commission members again on our summer programming template, so we have pretty much everything ready to go. We talked about a new brochure. Something we want to do with our brochure this year as well is to have the programs on the front and the pool on the back, so it's kind of you flip it over.
2:30:51 So wherever it sits, you're looking at something that we offer, and we'll pull our parks programs up. But something we're introducing this year, we have a new Mammoth Adventure Camp, a new Tetra Brazil soccer camp. We're looking at doing afternoon kind of supervision of kids after the program's ended. So if we finish at 3 or 4 o'clock, you know, we'll supervise those kids at the facility.
2:31:17 Until 6 o'clock, so you can kind of buy a two-hour block of time. So if you're still working and, you know, you want to get through, we'll look after the kids in that program. So we want to introduce that. Lesson times at the pool. We've got new hours at the rolling we want to bring in. We want to look at changing our advanced policy from 10 to 5 days. That was kind of a feedback that we got. And then we have a contract instructor looking and introducing some wellness program for seniors as well.
2:31:44 Some good stuff coming on there. And I'm sorry, where's that document, Stu? So I can send it to you again. It's a PowerPoint. Okay. I have it. You was emailed. I just, it was in a printed packet. I printed it. Okay. Terry's all over it. But you know, on my copy, the background is, maybe it's just my program. It doesn't look like that. Okay. Okay. I can maybe PDF it. No, no, that's okay. Send it around. It was just hard to read and I thought. I'm sorry. You had to intentionally.
2:32:15 Put a different background to it. So we can, yeah, I do want to get your feedback on that. I think it's... When do you need that feedback by? Well, we've got to a February 20, you know, I'd like to get it to the council prior to that workshop. So we would go out with the packet on that Friday, typically, when Jamie sends out the packet. Okay.
2:32:34 And volunteer support, I think, is great. Are you going to attach a dollar amount to that? We do. We have 144 volunteers that we utilized last year. We're extrapolating out the hours, and then we can provide the value of that already, which is pretty high. So we think that's valuable to put in there. And then we're about to post positions for a new tennis coach, gymnastics instructor, as you know, Michelle's getting married.
2:33:02 An adult sports coordinator, posting for lifeguards, roller rink staff and camp councillors. So we're trying to jump on that right now and get that rolling and get applications coming back because summer's right around the corner. That's all I have on my manager's report. May I make a comment real quick and you went over it so quick that I was paying attention to it until it went over. The Winterburn event is actually scheduled for February 22nd and 23rd.
2:33:29 And you have it down here on your report is 24 and 25. Is it different on the application? No, it should be on the application. I hope so. Let me check. Okay. Thank you. That's an event. It's a new event this year. Essentially, Mammoth Brewing Company is at least being the lead organization, but I am happy to turn it over to a nonprofit organization that wants to step forward. What is it, then?
2:33:52 Essentially what we're trying to create is it's a snow sculpture and bonfire at Sam's Wood Site encouraging admittedly amateur organizations the first year. But essentially because the Winter Carnival got, you know, there was some momentum behind it and it kind of got canceled with regard to just there wasn't enough time, at the same time we really wanted to do something at Sam's Wood Site that at least encouraged
2:34:22 Snow Sculptures, and again, you know, looking for either businesses or non-profit groups, school groups that want to do any kind of snow sculpture like what June Lake successfully did this last weekend. I don't know if many of you attended the one that was in June Lake, but frankly, it was pretty darn cool. You know, it was admittedly amateur, but at the same time, first year event, that's what it is, and that's what we would like to do as well.
2:34:47 Intent, anyway, of growing this something into much more professional. And when we first started reviewing this, I was amazed at the amount of snow sculpture how-to YouTube videos there are out there on building the forms, getting clean snow, and got permission from Sam Walker and Fire Chief, at least, you know, still submitting those applications, but there's no...
2:35:15 Resistance to actually having the bonfire and the snow sculpture at Sam's Woodside on that Saturday night of February 23rd. It's the end of President's Week. There's no real direct competition for any events, I think, except for Willie's Parade, I think we talked about. On Saturday, that's right, yeah. Saturday, but really no direct competition going on that night, so that's what the event is. We pulled the application for both Friday and Saturday night, the bonfire and all.
2:35:44 It will probably only be on Saturday night. So thank you. I just wanted to clarify that date, Jamie. Did you have any other comments from? As far as any kind of commissioner report, no, I don't. Okay. Betsy? Yes, I do. Saturday, January 12th, I actually went down and helped. Wait a minute. No, not those reports. On the manager's report, do you have any questions? No, the only thing I would say is maybe we should schedule our programming committee meeting with Stu right after this meeting since Stu's email is not working.
2:36:14 Pat, do you have any comments on the manager's report? Okay, I actually have a couple questions on the manager's report. Are you guys feeling pretty confident? I mean, gymnastics has been a good program as far as your being able to find somebody else that's going to be able to take over? Yeah, Melissa, the girl that's been helping Michelle, I think, is very capable. We're just trying to make sure that she seeks or gains her certification.
2:36:44 That's really what we're trying to do. So she's completing her application right now. So we believe we can continue that without a break in service because that's really, really a great program. Yeah. Great program. On the ice rink, where are we on long-term solutions for our issue? Do we know what we're up against yet? We're still doing some research, but he's not conflicting opinions. He still believes it's an installation issue.
2:37:13 It could be a material defect. If you're testing on the material, it was about $25,000, so the pipe won't be testing the material. We just experienced quite a bit of shrinkage or movement in the pipe. And both times it was well below zero. So it moved just that much more when we saw those below zero temperatures.
2:37:44 I didn't realize that the pipe in 100 feet shrinks 5 inches. Wow. So that's a lot of movement. Yeah. So we've got a couple ideas of what we can get into it during the summer months when there's not snow and ice out there. So it does move. Uh-huh. And what does the manufacturer of the pipe say?
2:38:14 Did send a couple pieces back and we haven't heard back the contractor do it. Because he's, you know, blaming us, we're blaming them. I said, oh, I know we need to fix it. So, you know, it's been running great. I mean, it runs, unless we've got to fire it back up. Okay. Thank you. Staff is consulting on the installation of the mammoth.
2:38:47 Ice rink, hockey, fence. What does that mean? Are we still looking at fence? Are we looking at the glass? Last we heard was hockey wants glass, so we have to come up with a design to support the glass. Okay, so we're still at that same point. Yeah, engineering's still doing research. What we'll probably do is during the summer, we'll do a couple of temporary panels, and, you know, we can...
2:39:15 Come up with a design that's simple enough. There's a few of these guys that said, oh, we can help install this. So it'll probably be an in-house project. Okay. And then on the market and feasibility study, does that have to go back out to bed since there's been so many changes, or is that something that we're still just going to be able to use the same? We missed a conference call this morning with that vendor just because of the town manager turmoil.
2:39:52 So we're trying to reschedule that with them right now. We're trying to get their scope back with their kind of changes and recommendations in their timeline. And we're trying to get that done before Ellen leaves. As you know, Ellen was in charge of that project, so she leaves Valentine's Day. So we're trying to get that wrapped up before she leaves so we can do a hand-off. So that'll end up coming back to Recreation Department to oversee. So we'll do the best we can. Anyway.
2:40:19 Okay. But it doesn't have to go back out to bed because it's changed? No, I believe it's still a satisfactory scope of work, as does Alan, too. So I think we want to pull the trigger with that group, and if they're willing to still do it with the scope that we've provided. Okay. Sounds good. Public comments on the manager's report? Yeah. I had no comment on the steward's report. Just a couple of questions before you guys break up. The library advised that for the Mammoth Trails meeting we talked about, it's actually going to be from 3.30 to 5.30.
2:40:49 Data scheduling conference later on for that. And in terms of the shady arrest comments, just for clarification for the Mammoth Trails folks, is anybody in the town's, like Ellen wrote comments on the CD4 document. Do you anticipate that anybody from town's staff is going to write comments on the shady arrest or is it just going to be whatever happens out of commission? That's a good question. I'll have to ask somebody. Yeah, fine. Just so that we can figure out kind of what.
2:41:18 Because when we, the Mammoth Trails, MLTPA comments, teared off of the town comments, it would just be useful for the middle of them. The final thing would just be... It sounds like, yeah. I want to say we'll teach more high comments. On that shady wrestling? Yeah. Yeah. I just want to make sure that, you know, how it impacts us. No, there's a lot of stuff going on. There's a lot going on out there that... Yeah, so I think we'll be... We had a few other issues this year with the snowmobile staging, which didn't really happen. Right.
2:41:48 But they wanted to, but they didn't get snow, but luckily they got snow the next day. Right. But that all impacts what happens to us. And you read how they want to take the Shady Rust Path and do something quite different. Right. So I want to sit down and... Okay. Obviously, if you can make it to that meeting next April 14th, I'd love to have you. It just concerns me because, you know, we've never had winter maintenance out there, and now all of a sudden... Yeah.
2:42:17 And I think just to Dennis' points, I mean, all the ORMAT comments we provided, everything that, these things should all be working together, you know, as one specific set of comments on this project. Because ORMAT's playing kind of a strange role in all this. But I think it's important to do that. And finally, just so I could understand the disposition of the commission and the staff with regards to that MLTPA proposal on the 19th. Will it be on the agenda? Is it not on the agenda? Does staff need more time to think about it?
2:42:46 It was consensus that it would be on the agenda for a discussion. Okay. And so that, but I don't know that, you know, depending on what comes up is there may not be a final decision, there just may be some comments. Okay. Is that stuff? I think that's the, that's what I heard come out of this. The only comment that, yeah, we would have on that is we met with two representatives from MLTPA, which is Bill Taylor, Jay Denkin, the chair, Bill Sauser, and staff.
2:43:12 Probably a couple of weeks ago. And I think the direction from that was to go down that path to get with the Forest Service, get with the Town Attorney, get our ducks in a row, and try and get it back to the MLTSCC and Commission on those first meetings in March. So, I mean, that's the timeline that we're working off. But if there's a desire for the Commission to expedite it forward, that's fine. Okay. Unless I'm wrong. I thought we decided that it was going to be on our 19th agenda so we could have some discussion prior to the Council meeting on the 20th.
2:43:41 There doesn't have to be a final decision made, but at least have the discussion and the ability to have that discussion if there's any action that is brought forward to the council. It very well could. Is that what you guys understood? That's my recollection as well. Yeah. It was four people said yes, and Pat was against bringing that forward. She thought it was premature. Yeah. We'll certainly go with the commission director just saying that was what staff and the MLTPA board.
2:44:10 Yeah, so it should be on the 19th agenda, yes. Okay, I just want to make sure I'm clear in terms of better whatever communications I have to provide the role on the same page. Can I ask a question? I was going to ask a question with regard to follow up on that because, yes, I definitely want to confirm that that's on the agenda for discussion at the very least. And Stu, is there any reason why we can't submit the proposal the way it is to the town attorney just so that we can have comments on the 19th? I'm just going off what we discussed and confirmed. So really,
2:44:38 The Forest Service is, you know, as we know, is very sensitive towards, you know, town and what we're doing with our trails, and because most of the trails are on Forest Service land, they'd like to be part of that discussion. So we thought it was a little premature to go and start that proceedings, you know, straight away without bringing him into the loop, and why would you want to engage a town attorney if, you know, a scenario was, you know, not going to be played out that way? So, anyway, I'm just passing on what we talked about and agreed upon. We certainly could, but as you know,
2:45:09 Yeah, we're just dealing with some unique challenges right now. We could absolutely get it there, but I'm trying to get the forest service first. The proposal is an internal sort of town of Mammoth Lakes to start with idea. And I think that to get the discussion, based on discussions I've had with council members after that meeting that you guys had,
2:45:32 You know, they would like to have some information about that to inform their February 20th meeting. I think, I don't know what's in Stuart's PowerPoint, but I don't know where the trail system is actually finding a home anywhere. And I think that, you know, there's never been any competition between the trail system and the municipal recreation department. These are two, you know, things that work together. But the council, the advice I've had from council is, look, we would like to have some, a recommendation or some thoughts from the...
2:45:58 Recreation Commission relative to that proposal at that February 20th meeting as it fits into the town's restructuring program. You know, I don't know how town government works here, but when I work down south, you know, the direction from that would come, you know, from council to staff and then with, you know, advice or recommendations to the commission.
2:46:18 So if that's the case, you know, I'm not hearing that from the Town Council to the Commission that we need to be looking at it. Well, as Chair Souser advised you, he's heard, I mean, we can stop being here. Well, was he speaking on behalf of the Commission or was he speaking on behalf of himself? Guys, I'm going to cut this off because all we've had right now is that this is going to come forward to our 20th, our 19th meeting because it is going to be discussed on the 20th. So how it's going to move forward from there, you know, we'll have that discussion and we will have direction from staff and from Council.
2:46:48 By that point. So, I mean, we do not act on our own. We're acting and we're just an advisory to council. So it is going to be council that makes that decision. So I don't want to have that debate sitting here right here right now. So I'm sorry. And I guess what I would like to say is this PowerPoint that I see right here really is just stating what we're doing right now as a rec department and what the staff that we have right now is. The process that we're looking at and we're going through right now is if that
2:47:17 Staff, if that organization needs to be different because of what we need to accomplish, then hopefully those are some of the recommendations that we might be able to bring forward with our priorities, and that may be where some public-private partnerships come into play, but I see this as just kind of just an informational piece as to, you know, what our recreation department as it is, is doing, and that restructuring is something that can come forward.
2:47:46 Later, I think it's something that we need to keep in mind why we're looking at this and looking at our plans with our prioritization. That would be my thought. I don't know what everybody else's, but I think that that kind of comes in hand in hand and we'll start working towards that. Is that fair enough? Fair enough. Okay.
2:48:09 All right. Commissioner's Report. Sean. Went to the June Lake Snow Sculpture, and for what it was, it was pretty cool. That's all I'm going to say. Very good. Thank you.
2:48:20 Betsy. Nice. I know you have one. I do, I do. I'll keep it short, though. Back on January 12th, Saturday morning, I actually spent two hours down at the Shady Rest Nordic Trailhead with a volunteer from Mammoth Nordic. I was just curious to see who's down there using the trails. And in just those two hours, there were just under 20 people. But what I found was really interesting was about half of them were local and about half of them were from...
2:48:48 Out of Town, including Pasadena, San Diego, and Bakersfield. Both families, individuals, and a group of friends. So I was really pleased to see that visitors are finding and using that resource in addition to locals. So it was a good morning. Good. Pat. On the report. Okay. You know, I'll make a comment to that, and I think it's something that we need to consider in our discussions as to what we're looking at as far as our Nordic Trails go and our...
2:49:17 As Brian had said, there's issues with the mixed use. I have owners that, you know, are kind of real concerned about because they go down there to walk dogs. They walk through their dog walking. And they are also Nordic skiers. But we need to come up with some definite kind of rules and regulations and maybe parameters as to where each activity can take place. And so I think that's really important when we're looking at that because it's...
2:49:45 You know, we don't want it to be a negative thing that these folks are doing. So, anyway. Well, you know, like on Forest Service land, they indicate that snowshoers, and going up to Tamarack as well, snowshoers or walkers, people with dogs on one side of the trap, you know, versus...
2:50:08 And so maybe that just becomes signage or whatever it is that we're looking at, but we need to keep those things in mind as we're going through our other process. So anyhow. And everyone seemed to be getting along at the time, so. Good. That's nice. That's always good. I don't have anything either. So let's move on to future agenda items. What do we have so far coming up there, Stu? Well, we're going to meet on February 19th. So we've got three kind of items to cover there. We'll do that NGO.
2:50:40 We'll do the U.S. Forest Service scoping review, and then we'll do the Parks and Rec master plan review, and then we meet again on March 5th. So March 5th again would be Measure R at this time. I can't remember off the top of my head what else we had on that. Measure R, and I think we were going to continue having just the item on the agenda for our... Special use? Town funds? No. No.
2:51:07 Just for the process that we're going through for our prioritization. Oh, yeah, Recreation, yeah. So just in case there's any comments or anything. Yeah, that's a standing line. So that's going to be standing. Yep. And then the use for. We can add that on if you want to. Oh, the youth sport. Oh, youth. I'm sorry. Youth sports funding. Yeah. I thought you had youth funding. Youth funding. Youth. Okay, Y-O-U-T-H. Got it. One thing, I know it's kind of backing up, but on.
2:51:37 That youth sports funding, it says that the applicant must be there. Is it understood that they will be making a presentation, or are they just there to listen? We usually give them an opportunity to say something if they'd like to, or if we make comment that they would like to speak to whatever it is that we've commented on, then they have the opportunity to do that. So, usually we just, it wasn't clear on the application. Yeah, it's in their best interest, I think it's, yeah.
2:52:06 We usually have questions of them, and there's usually somebody that would like to answer, you know, that would like to stand up and speak to their cause. So it's been rare that nobody's been there. They've been pretty good. So any other agenda items that anyone wants to see? All good. How about the...
2:52:28 Programs, for the new programs, if your committee's going to meet, is that going to be March or would that be April? No, let's do that March. I think we'll schedule a quick meeting here and I've got the information, you know, here I can go over it. But yeah, we do want to get that kind of locked in. I think that's good. Because some of the discussion is, again, on fee schedules. You know, if we do want to change some of those fees that we've looked at, that would come before March and then again go to council.
2:52:57 And we're trying to get the brochure and the material out, you know, by April, so we kind of need to jump on that. Can we get the true subsidy on all of these, including the facility costs and all our costs? We basically had an overhead, right, we just had an overhead of staff to everything. Yeah, okay, so you did? Yeah, we would have to do that, yes. Well, I think it's important as we're moving forward, because I don't think that we can really have a true idea of what we're...
2:53:24 Subsidizing. I mean, I'm not saying whether we should be subsidizing that or not, but I think that at least we would have the full picture as to what it's actually costing us for that program, especially if you're looking at adding in another adult programming person. That's a contract position, yeah, so. Yeah. So that's going to be, all those need to be, you know, included in whatever cost that you're looking at. So, anyhow, that's my pet peeve. What is the policy with subsidy?
2:53:54 Ten percent for youth and what is it for adults? Ninety percent, I think, for adults, wasn't it? Well, and I think that's something that we need to look at, you know, is that really what other communities are still doing? I mean, is that a true reasonable subsidy or do we need to look at what that is? I just think that we need to have the true cost that we can look at that picture. If it's still 90 percent, it's still 90 percent, you know, but. Well, I agree that I think revenues should go up incrementally, you know.
2:54:24 And you're never going to keep pace, but whenever you can try to close the gap. So I just think that we need to have that full picture. That's important to me, whether it's anybody else or not, it is to me. So what are you asking, Stu? I'm asking for the true, because in all the programs that we had, we didn't have facility costs, we didn't have staffing costs, we didn't have, they had the contract instructor costs and the program.
2:54:50 Costs for whatever they needed for that program, but not any of the overhead, the staffing or the facility. So I think that all of that needs to be included. All right, anything else? We have a motion to adjourn. Sure, I'll move. There you go. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.