TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013

Parks & Recreation Commission Special meeting

· recording 3 hr 42 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

270 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:31:06 Review and pride comments to staff regarding the PowerPoint presentation scheduled for February 20th. Do you want to go through that for us? Look at the PowerPoint. State facilities. That's, um, I have one. This is just something that I put together as well. The same as Pat, but it's, I gave one to Pat, yeah. There's that. Can we make these as well? A lot of this is for the recreation and foster care. Wish I was, just didn't hear myself.

1:32:34 Okay, Stu, did you want to do a quick breakdown of your PowerPoint, or do you want us just to make comments? I think, I believe, I know, staff sent this to Commission probably about two weeks ago, and then the Chair just requested it be put on for tomorrow. It's obviously been printed, as you know, so Council have it. It's in the packet. So what I think the goal is today is just to receive any comments that I can verbally present to Council tomorrow night.

1:33:03 The premise tomorrow night is really just an overview of each department. That's really the priority. So provide council with an overview of the department's purpose function and receive any direction from council at that time. The discussion is not so much on, as we believed in the past, on outsourcing. It's really just talking about what are the needs of the department. Can there be...

1:33:28 Produced more efficiently, you know, options like that. So that's really the change that we've received from the town manager. So it's not a, it's not a discussion on, you know, anything other than that. It's really, hopefully, and that's great that we can discuss it today on really what we need to communicate to council tomorrow night on our department. So. Okay, and with that I will start comments from Pat and go around to

1:34:00 Teri, any comments on it? Okay. Given my comments, I thought it was a good overview of the department and I think it helps to make people aware of some of the elements that are involved that once you have children in the program where you actually participate in some of the programs yourself and I thought it was great to add the additional information about volunteers. Hopefully that will be something that will be increasing.

1:34:32 Steve, one of the comments for just, and it's probably too late because it is already being printed out, but just in this overview, you know, you mentioned, like, talking about what are the means, there's no real, you know, all we say this is a summary of kind of just what we've got off of, but it doesn't necessarily list any of our challenges. The Recreation Department is kind of the case of, you know, whether it's something as simple as funding or the fact that the tennis courts are...

1:34:58 Yeah, I think this discussion, this workshop that we're having, I think Council is prepared to receive those comments from the Commission as part of this recreation, you know, review process. I think that's really where they're trying to...

1:35:23 Gain that understanding, you know, would that further direct Measure R, Measure U, would that further direct our current maintenance, would that further direct any additional funding that we might need? So I think that's more of a comprehensive process than just, I mean, they gave me five minutes, so I'm going to probably push it to ten, right? So that's kind of why it's in a PowerPoint. So really that's the premise of tomorrow. So I don't know how specific Council will provide us direction tomorrow.

1:35:50 Yeah, but I think our longer term process is really focused on that direction. And I agree, I was just wondering if that's something that is being asked for in this presentation, or it's really just, wait, this is a synopsis, and we don't know these things already. Yeah, and I think the only thing that might change that too, Commissioner, is coming into the budget cycle. We're going to present mid-year budget, and then we're starting in the budget cycle. So again,

1:36:18 We'll have the opportunity as we move forward with our budgeting, you know, to present those things. So I don't want to see us wait until we finish this process at the end of the year to be able to bring something forward. So I think it's a good question to ask council tomorrow night, you know, exactly that. What action do you want us to take from this in regards to, you know, our programming facilities or, you know, anything like that? Okay. That was just the overall comment. I did have just two real quick questions.

1:36:48 On volunteers, when you refer to over 140 volunteers, where are those mostly from? Town. Okay, there are all the locals. Yeah, so that's, I think I listed the programs, but that's all the volunteers that come out, help all our community events, youth theater. Yeah, town cleanup. Yeah, town cleanup. And a lot of our programs, instructional basketball, you know, that's all a volunteer program, t-ball, that's all a volunteer program. I mean, that's why it's a free program, because it's relying upon volunteers, so.

1:37:18 We've broken down the hours. I can give you that detail if you want, but I just kind of went on youth, adult, and then community events to give you a broad perspective of where the volunteers come from. Okay. The only good question I had was with regard to the soccer fields. Now, you only list two. Those are the two full-size soccer fields, but you're not referring to the smaller AYSO. Because they're the baseball fields. Okay. Yeah. So we have two, yeah. Well, we have the little woodwork as well. Yeah. Which is at the end of this. Okay. Yep.

1:37:48 Thank you.

1:38:13 Homepage is the second most visited site after the home page. I think that's a really good argument for moving toward a web-based recreation software. So I thought it was a good overview overall of the departments tonight. I have a couple comments. I think as a whole, just municipal recreation, we're doing a great job, I think, what you just presented.

1:38:41 Gives the community a great oversight of our municipal recreation. In the conversation of restructuring and reorganization, I think that this commission needs to have a conversation. There's a conversation that started quite a few years ago, a couple years ago. It was facilitated. There's many documents, and it's called Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

1:39:06 How do we reach beyond the traditional recreation? What does that organization look like? Where does it live? Does it live within government? Is it totally private? Is it a private partnership? How is it funded? We need to bring partners together. We need to have that future vision. It needs to be entrepreneurial. We need to bring recreation under one umbrella. Right now we have trails. We have special events. We have municipal.

1:39:34 And everything's really fragmented and siloed right now within recreation. We need to figure out, we had a great long conversation as to why we weren't the Parks and Rec Commission, that we were the Recreation Commission. And I think that we need to look beyond municipal recreation and see how we start fostering recreation as a whole and that municipal is a part of that.

1:40:01 And trails are a part of that. Special events are a part of that. You know, we have the track that's coming online. You know, how do we start getting these partnerships formed? I know there's a lot of conversations that are going on, but I think that's fragmented as well. You know, where's that agreement? Who's doing what? You know, we need to have an organization that's going to be able to pull all these things together.

1:40:27 You know, what does a structure like that look like? You know, how is it directed? How are the funds leveraged? How are the maintenance done? What are the funding opportunities? You know, and that's bringing in the county. That's bringing in other private partners. And it's, you know, kind of looking outside that box. Visitor driving, you know, so that we can bring recreation as a whole. Like I say, we're doing the municipal in town for our kids. Great. And I think that's wonderful. So we need to still...

1:40:57 Nurture that, but we need to look and start pulling the rest of it together. And I guess that's one thing that with looking at the presentation that was done that I really see when I pull back some of the studies and some of the comments that were made and why we're the Recreation Commission, Recreation Department, and not a Parks and Rec Department, that we need to really start looking at that and how we can accomplish that. And I'm pretty much in the same place. The presentation that you put together is great.

1:41:27 As it goes for Municipal Recreation. I would have been a whole lot happier if there would have been pictures of cross-country skiers and snowshoers and fishermen and snowmobilers and OHV users because we provide all of that through Measure R and Measure U and the MLTSCC. All of those things exist within our current recreation department. Stu may not be doing them directly at this point.

1:41:53 But we need for one cohesive recreation department, whether it's NGO, whether it's in the town, I really have no leanings one way or the other for it. But we can't be paying administrators to fragment and have one person doing cross-country skiing and have somebody else doing swimming and have somebody else doing and expect that we're going to pay through Measure R process or whatever an administrator for each one of those.

1:42:22 Eventually we run out of time, space, money, the whole nine yards. We need a recreation department and tomorrow is going to be our opportunity as commissioners to speak to the council on this, to tell them that this isn't what we envision if we don't, if we disagree and this is what we think the department should be. We have that obligation as well, but I wanted this conversation today specifically so that we could explore that. Is this what we want?

1:42:51 Recreation, Mammoth to be through the town. Or do we want that big picture that we keep talking about? Even in our recreation master plan, it speaks about visitor driving, it speaks about collaborative planning, it speaks to all of these things, yet somehow through the years, with changes at the top in the town, the focus internally seems to bring us back to providing

1:43:19 AYSO, T-Ball, and Swim Team, and then farming the rest of this out. I think it's time we look at not farming the rest of this out, but having a Recreation Department, and again, whether it's an NGO, whether it's in the town, or whether it's a 50-50 mix, I don't know what that is, but we need to get to the point, we're giving money for cross-country skiing, we're giving money for track.

1:43:43 We're giving money for, and eventually we have to deal with all of this. This should be one Mammoth Recreation Department, and I think we need to add to this presentation the photos. We don't have time to add the photos, obviously. But as commissioners, I think we need to express the position that we want to see Mammoth Recreation cover Mammoth Recreation. We want to be able to grow product.

1:44:13 for the town, for the benefit of our locals, and to drive visitation at the same time. And we put it in all of our plans. It's there. It's not as specific in the plan that some of us would have liked for it to have been because it goes off to a consultant who does the same thing for a thousand different regular little towns. We're not a regular little town. So those are my comments. And you can tell I get emotional about it. I didn't yell or anything, but it's good.

1:44:43 Well, what are, you know, what's the goal of this discussion then? You know, because as Stu has pointed out, this is already going to press and being made tomorrow. Right. Other than us being present at that meeting tomorrow to be able to comment and such. I guess I would be looking as tomorrow we have a workshop at Council. You know, this is what we're presently doing. There are other things that we're doing, but the problem is it's very fragmented. And there's, you know, it's really not cohesive as far as bringing it all together.

1:45:11 And I would like to see from council is, you know, what would you like? We went through a lot of steps, a lot of meetings, and a lot of expense to look at a Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I mean, there are actually documents that says this is what is municipal. This is what's Mammoth Lakes Recreation. This is what town staff otherwise could do. And there's all of these plans out there. And we kind of continue to speak to these things, but we never seem to implement them.

1:45:41 And so I guess that if we're looking at a whole recreation picture, we need to start looking back at that. Maybe we need to bring that information back up to say, okay, is this what we want to do? And I guess I would be looking at it as council. Is this what you would like us to do? Or is this what you want us to continue to do? What is it that you're looking for this recreation department and commission to accomplish? I think they're probably looking to us to let it.

1:46:11 to give advice to them as to what it should be. And I think that there is a lot of cohesion already, because I see Stu and staff coordinating a lot of different elements. They have their hands in a lot of different things, in addition to the actual implementation of municipal recreation. And perhaps along the way, as budgets have peeled away money from the department, it's gotten to the point where, I mean, you have three or four people handling

1:46:40 This department. And I think doing a great job of keeping all the balls in the air. Maybe that's the issue. Give more money back to the department so it can be more of a whole cohesive element. And getting back to what Sean was saying earlier, I mean, that's a very good point. That maintenance money has been peeled away from this department and parks. And maybe that's something that needs to be communicated to council. And I know, you know, funding is really tight right now.

1:47:09 Maybe that's what they need to hear from us. And I think this is our opportunity to remind us that we're not, not only are we not just recreation, but that we're an economic stimulator for the town. I mean, where some of this money is, you know, where we have opportunities to generate money and not just looking at cutting and cutting, but by looking at recreation as a overarching hole that we have opportunities.

1:47:35 But I think it goes beyond that. The money talk, and we're only going to scratch the surface tomorrow, there is money available. We're playing MLTPA and Friends of the Inyo for a summer of stewardship.

1:48:04 Program. Could a Mammoth Lakes Recreation do that without paying for two different organization structures if it was all under one umbrella? Could Stu be doing that now if we took some of that money and brought those programs over to the side? Can we create a Mammoth Recreation and put fractionalizing, as Teri said earlier, into a whole bunch of different organizations? I don't know what it looks like, but that's what the town, it seems to me, in their restructuring plan is looking for.

1:48:34 They keep saying restructuring, and the plans that keep coming forward are plans to shrink. I think we actually need to look at restructuring internally, and believe me, I have nothing but praise for the park staff and what they've accomplished, but we really haven't looked at it from outside of the box. We keep trying to keep it in the box, and somehow we need to blow that box up and find ways to make...

1:49:02 And from my standpoint, and we did talk to a couple of councilmen yesterday on this, and they would like to hear from us what, as a commission, how do we want to move forward? Do we want to be just municipal recreation, or do we want to be a Mammoth Recreation umbrella and carry more than that? So it is the one-stop shop for recreation. I mean, that was the vision when we tried to create MLT FCC.

1:49:29 Hasn't been very successful yet. We're making changes that are hopefully going to fix that to make it the one stop for trails. But do we bring that back into the Rec Commission and the Rec Department and create a one stop shop for recreation? I think it already is because whatever the MLT FCC does comes to the commission. And I think it's staffed to some degree by the Recreation Department.

1:49:56 I think it's still very fragmented, though. It's still, the way that it's all being put together, it's a very fragmented process. And I'm not putting it, with the staff and the recreation department that we have, I mean, they are doing an incredible job. And so, but I'm looking at the same thing that Bill has just said, is bringing it outside of that. And how can we make it better? And you know what, I just, I don't, you know, I kind of, I printed up something that was in the RecStrats.

1:50:26 And some of the weaknesses is lack of vision and sustained effort, facility maintenance, peak weekend experience, comprehensive centralized recreation information, funding, threats, this is really important, mindset for change, economic environment, competition, inability to get along, sustainable efforts, quality of experience, state and federal funding, unrealistic environmental constraints.

1:50:54 I think that kind of the mindset for change is a really biggie there. And I think that's kind of where we keep stumbling over ourselves because we keep thinking of what we are and we're not getting past that. How can we make this bigger? We keep saying recreation is the engine that drives the economy in this town. Tourism comes here, but they come here for recreation. Unfortunately, they're not coming here.

1:51:24 for all of the municipal programs. So we need to find how we have that, how those are married, how we have the municipal, how we have the, you know, the economy driving recreation opportunities. And I don't think it can be done in the structure that we have right now. The structure is not sufficient that we can do that well. We can maybe do it, but it's not done well. And I think it is the way that we're doing it right now.

1:51:52 We're continuing to fragment and we're continuing to silo and I just think that it's giving recreation, it's becoming weaker because of that. I think it all goes back to money. It does go back to money. If money goes there, I think it could be what we want to do. So how do we bring partners in? How do we figure out how we leverage funds? If we want to maintain the trails in the lakes basin, are we better off?

1:52:22 Waiting for a partner to come and say, here's what I can do, and then paying what they ask. Are we better off in our own department trying to figure out ways we can accomplish that and moving that ball forward so that we're not paying for three different organizations? If we want to groom for snow play and for Nordic and for snowmobiles, are we better off waiting for each of those groups to come forward and saying, okay, here's your $30,000.

1:52:51 Go off and do your thing. Or are we better off bringing it in under an umbrella with their help? I'm not asking for them to go away because that's how you set your priorities is with public input. Bring it under one mammoth recreation umbrella. So there is money there. We're spending it. Are we spending it effectively and efficiently to get the biggest bang from it? And I question that.

1:53:17 Getting back to summer and stewardship, I agree. I don't think you need to pay two organizations to do it. I think you pay one. It'd be less oversight. But somehow, everyone's agreed to make it a couple of organizations. It doesn't need to be. Or you bring it in-house with just their volunteer help. And don't pay any organization to do it. It's another possibility. And we haven't looked at that. We keep waiting for the outside, for the people that are...

1:53:49 Passionate about something to bring that idea forward and pay them to do something. Instead of saying, this is a good idea, it's in our plan. Here's something that's in our master plan. How do we move it forward as an organization? We wait for a proponent to bring it forward. That goes back to, I think, what the council has talked about with restructuring and to have volunteer efforts, you know, capitalized upon.

1:54:13 And I agree. I think that the process that we're working on right now

1:54:41 Might answer some of these questions, but because this is coming up now and the restructuring question is coming up now, I guess this is something that I've talked about many times sitting up there. I just, you know, if I'm barking up the wrong tree, then I guess I need to stop barking and just, you know, determine what it is that we're supposed to be doing. But when we're moving through this prioritization process,

1:55:09 I'm looking at all of this to say, what is it that we want to accomplish? Who can accomplish that? How can it be accomplished? Is it within the organization that we have now? What does that organization look like? Is it one organization that does all of this? Is it two or three? I don't know. I just see that there's a benefit of bringing things into an umbrella that it's just a lot more cohesive. I see that there's a lot of disconnect right now.

1:55:37 and how the trails, the MLTSCC is working with the commission. There's a great disconnect. I don't see that. Well, I think probably because you've been sitting at every single meeting. Well, I have because I have an interest in it. Yeah. And, you know, so I don't see that there is a big disconnect. And we've got two members, you know, on the commission who are part of that committee. So, you know, they see a disconnect.

1:56:02 I don't know if it's so much of a disconnect as it is, more of a frustration just with the first year as part of what we've accomplished. I remember you and I talking about this, and me saying that we shouldn't necessarily be as frustrated with it, because I'm just wanting to see it happen faster than it has, I think, certainly for the MLTSCC this first year. It was certainly a steep burning curve. Again, I guess my goal, or my question for what we're trying to do here today,

1:56:30 Is get back to what's going to happen tomorrow. And, you know, the goal is obviously going to present this very brief overview, which is five minutes. Ten, maybe. And that's exactly what it is. We're going through these processes right now of reviewing plans. So a lot of those answers, as much as I'm going to be able to say tomorrow, and that's why I brought up my concern that what I would like to see.

1:56:57 is these are some of the challenges that is facing the Recreation Department. Obviously the first thing could very well be our funding is getting pat. But some of the other things are that, you know, just jumping ahead with that overview that you said that you provided pat is that we don't have good events in sight.

1:57:20 Tennis courts are currently needing to be repaired every year and probably just replaced. It's these things that I want to outline sooner rather than later where we need to go through this process that we've identified could take up to all of 2015 to get done. But if the town council is looking for direction from us as soon as tomorrow with regard to their restructuring...

1:57:48 They're going to need some of these answers sooner rather than later, which is why some of my frustration at the last meeting that we were going to talk about the MLTPA's proposal, but now we're not talking about it because it needs to go through legal and that kind of thing, is as much as it would be too soon to make any kind of recommendations, to be sure, at the same time I think that we do need to be having those discussions.

1:58:13 As soon as today and tomorrow, specifically, what are the challenges and what do we want to see accomplished in 2013? And that's one of the things that kind of brought this discussion up and need to make the comments that I've made, is that, you know, John has brought, had brought that proposal forward. It was tabled, not by us, but it was tabled. And it wasn't a matter, to me, it wasn't a matter of necessarily exactly

1:58:42 Exactly the information that was in that proposal, but it is kind of the proposal itself. Is that the direction that we're looking at going? So are we looking at outsourcing certain things within the department? Or are we, you know, what does it look like? So we have this proposal that we could have discussed as far as, you know, what is it that we're looking to outsource? Are we looking to have a whole trails organization?

1:59:09 Are we looking to have, because the conversation has came up with special events as well, to my understanding, I wasn't at the meeting, is that, you know, special events is looking, well, we need an administrator for special events, we need an administrator for Nordic skiing, we need an administrator for trails, we need an administrator for, you know, municipal, and I guess this is the conversation that I feel that we need to have, and that I think that is where I'm saying that everything needs to, all those things need to take place, but how do they take place? How is it?

1:59:39 Managed. How does that whole process move forward? And the way that we're moving forward right now, I don't think is necessarily the best manner in moving those things forward. I truly think that it needs to have an oversight of one department. And do we have the makeup within our recreation department right now to handle that? No. It needs to be different.

2:00:07 Or augmented. Uh-huh, augmented. I shouldn't say, yeah, it needs to be augmented because what we're doing now is great, but it needs to be embellished. It needs to be boosted up. It needs to be more than it is right now. And currently, from my perspective again, we're augmenting a lot of other things. We could have talked about John's proposal today. Should that augmentation be coming home here to provide the same services perhaps for less?

2:00:35 Whether or not it's an NGO or whether it's the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Department, we need to have a discussion unless we're comfortable with that PowerPoint being what the Recreation Department is all about, and I'm not. I want it to be more than that. I want it to be, and we've tried to push that envelope. We've gotten the council to give us money outside of the R&U process, that facilitated process to go down that road, and somehow through financial constraints or

2:01:04 Change of position at the top. We keep getting bottled back down into just this. This is what a recreation department in town looks like. Well, that's fine if you're Costa Mesa. Well, no, because they're a resort to Torrance. But that's not who we are and what we are here. We need to be more than that. I'm not suggesting we stop this. I'm just, I would like to see us, if we have consensus on the commission, say that somehow to the council tomorrow, because they're looking to hear from us.

2:01:34 What our vision for recreation is so that they can start working with that vision in their restructuring process. You know what? This is the 11th hour. Stu gave us this a couple weeks ago. We could have given him all of this kind of input. We could have had a special meeting just to talk about this and focus on it beyond, you know, what this proposal means. So now, you know, I'm uncomfortable with trying to...

2:02:02 Change the whole scope of this discussion for tomorrow, this 10-minute, 5-minute discussion, to be something totally different. You know, if you want to say, I like what Sean's saying, the challenges that are faced by the department, and maybe you throw out something, you know, these are some concepts, but we haven't really fully discussed it. And to think that we're going to, which I thought a good portion of today's meeting was to talk about

2:02:28 Park and Recreation Masterclass. And come to consensus on that. And, you know, we have all these other little side things that are going on, which, you know, it's all good discussion. But, I mean, you're talking about changing the whole concept of things and not really giving the full discussion. Well, I don't think it would be changed overnight. I think it is, it's the concept is this is what, you know.

2:02:56 You're looking for reorganization and restructure and how you do things. So is this the path that we need to go down? And so do we need to look at that as we move forward? Well, maybe students can say what you said at the beginning in terms of you said that this is not so much restructuring. Is this just an overview? And I do think that this presentation does allude to the fact that we are more than just municipal recreation. It talks about the oversight of the view and our funds. It does talk about events. It does talk about

2:03:26 Trails, I mean, it does at least touch on them, you know, for being a five-minute presentation, so. Can I ask a question about just tomorrow's agenda? The workshop is from five to six, okay? So this is a five-minute presentation. It's ten minutes. What's the rest of that? Yeah, it's a recreation department workshop, right? So it's the presentation of this material here. There's also material and measure arm as you and the performance measures of the department specifically.

2:03:57 The performance measures. So how we are measured. And that's typically, as we've been in the past, it's just visits to our rink, our pool, number of surveys we collect. You know, those type of things. That's what we look at every year. But specifically what they've asked for is, you know, how are we measured. And I do want to reiterate, just comment on, I'm glad the discussion isn't just about replacing and outsourcing, because I think that's the reason why, from a town employee point of view,

2:04:25 is why we don't have any employees. So this is a very difficult conversation. So I'd be very careful where you want to take it. So I just want to... No, no, no, just let me finish. I know your point. So when I started the department three years ago, been department head for three years, the majority of my time was municipal recreation. 25% of my time is spent on municipal recreation. 25%. It should be 100%.

2:04:54 But with everything that the town's been going through the last three years, it's been very difficult. So I'm spending an odd amount of my time on all other priorities, being Measure R, Measure U, public information, the staff reports, the commission reports, the council reports. So our department is small. We're very restricted. So be very careful where you want to go to the discussion. It's not really the premise of tomorrow's meeting with council. So I think if you want to discuss this, I think you want to schedule it.

2:05:22 and actually have a nice, have a decent discussion, but not on this, not on this premise. And you know what, I know I've talked to you. It is not a matter of replacing current staff. It is not a matter of replacing municipal recreation. So anyways, I just, you know, I just want to make sure, and I know I've told you that, you know, I'm not looking and saying that anybody's doing a poor job or anything else.

2:05:48 We just need to, that's where the fear comes into. And so we need to have that conversation. And that conversation does not eliminate staff or things that we're doing right now. It just opens that conversation and looks at that big picture. And what does that picture look like? Is it somewhere we want to go? And how can that happen if it is something that we want to do? And I think it might be more appropriate to discuss it in more depth on the commission level as opposed to...

2:06:19 Putting out snippets of information tomorrow. That might just be an individual opinion as opposed to the consensus from the Commission. Which is why we are bringing it up today because we've tried to bring it up and unfortunately it is something. Well, okay. You know, if there's something comprehensive then put it onto the agenda and let's look at it all together. You know what? And to think that the grass is greener on the other side.

2:06:45 I'm looking at trying to get back to having a recreation and having that as a cohesive one umbrella type organization. And so unfortunately this conversation has obviously gone a personal direction and that was not meant to. It never has been meant to. I think we've been put here to look and to have a future vision. And I guess I can sit here and...

2:07:15 Just say that we're going to do status quo. I'm trying to see what is that future vision. And it doesn't exclude staff and it doesn't exclude what we're doing right now, but it looks outside of that box and what we can be for recreation. And so, unfortunately, I actually am very sorry that it took a personal note because that was never what it was meant to be. And with the conversation with at least a couple of council members, I think they're looking at...

2:07:44 A bigger picture, too. So anyways, we can do with what you want, but that's just my opinion. I would just like to make a comment that I hope when commissioners are meeting with council members that they're talking about comments on an individual basis as opposed to representing them. Absolutely. We are, absolutely. That's very true. I never represent. I'm getting a sense that.

2:08:14 Several of the commissioners are meeting with council members and talking about different approaches to take, which I think should be a group discussion. And this is something that happened a couple years ago. There's been a lot of money and a lot of time that has been spent on this. There's actually organizational charts. Okay, so we've gotten through our last hurdle that, you know, we've cut and we've cut and we've cut, and we're functioning.

2:08:40 And so do we go back and do we just number one table all that conversation that happened and all the information that was brought forward? Or is it now time to bring it back out and start looking at it and saying, is any of it valid? Is any of it something that we want to move forward with? I think we're leaving a lot of things on the table. And this process right here will hopefully bring some of that to light. But those are partnerships. They're funding sources. And I just think that that's

2:09:08 a conversation that we need to have. If we want to just table all that and never go any further and not have that vision for the future, then I guess I need to know that now because I'm on the wrong commission. Well, let's not make it personal. Can I just say something? Sorry, I agree with what you're saying, Teri, but at least two of us have not had access to what you're talking about, and it is something.

2:09:34 That would be good for all of us to review. That's what I'm saying. Probably would be. And to all look at it and talk about it. Absolutely. And not to just put it on a shelf and not even consider it in the future. So I do agree with you on that. But I just don't know that this is the process to do it right today. I guess the conversation is that we're looking to reorganize and we're looking to what the structure of recreation looks like is now is the time. All I'm simply asking is that question.

2:10:02 Do we bring these things out? Do we look at what that whole picture is? Or do we stay status quo? I think I would suggest that we look at it as an entire commission to have a full discussion on it. I agree wholeheartedly we should. The focus of and the reason for putting this on the agenda today was so that we could simply ask the question, do we want to make a representation to council?

2:10:33 that we would like to see Mammoth Recreation go beyond, not pull back, not do what we're currently doing, but go beyond what it is currently doing and how it is currently doing. And I was hoping that we could reach a consensus where we could say as a commission and not just as individual commissioners at tomorrow's workshop that yes, we would love to see this

2:11:01 Department or Entity expand to take on that role of recreation. Not to eliminate someone, not to stop doing the t-ball and the little league and the soccer and the pool. I support all of those with all of my heart and soul. Do we want to be more than we are? I think that's the question. I think that tomorrow we don't need to go into here's what we envision ourselves being. Just a simple statement saying we see ourselves being more than this.

2:11:34 Not to threaten anybody because the council is looking for that. This is their report of recreation and I don't know how it's been brought to staff. I haven't been in those meetings from the top down or what's been represented to them. I know in my talks with council they're seriously thinking of how they can restructure this and they're going to be looking at us for help if we see the need for our department to change an offer more. I don't want to.

2:12:04 I don't want to bring it back. I want it to move forward and get bolder and be bigger. And I think we have it in our power to do that with the funding mechanisms we have at hand. So that's all. I'm not saying we want to tell them we want to change the world tomorrow. No. I just would like to see us make a statement as a commission that, attaboy, let's give our staff a pat on the back because they have done a huge job with the resources that they've been given.

2:12:36 Would I like to see them get some help and would like us to be able to pass this point? Absolutely. And if I can say something, and you do have some comments. I know. Okay. I guess I'm looking for reasons why not to do that. Again, I think we're trying to shut anything out or just say that people will point out what we want and specifically say that we do want to be something more than what...

2:13:07 We are right now, which is municipal programs, which are great, and likewise, we'll say that as well. I guess what I'm looking for is a question, why not be able to say that? Why can't we come to a consensus, if we can, with regard to just being able to say that we want to see the recreation coming up more than what it is right now? There is some specific outlines here about what's next. Those are specific. I don't get that there's anything wrong with that. I'm not looking to add to these specifically.

2:13:36 As much as say that there's more here that we can't do. Can I read what's on tomorrow's agenda? Yeah. Yeah. Discussion and direction concerning the review of the budget and proposed performance measures for Recreation and Parks Department and budget and priorities for measures R&U. So you're commenting on the budget and you're commenting on proposed performance measures and the budgets and priorities for measures R&U.

2:14:06 Right, and part of the need to expand our scope is

2:14:36 Because R and you are certainly involved. Budget R and you would be involved. Yeah, Budget R and you are involved. So that was, you guys think about that because I know Brian had his hand up. Thank you, Neil. It's an incredibly challenging period and I think I just want to offer my support and endorsement for the recreation staff. I realize all of you.

2:15:08 have indicated that you don't find this to be anything that is strictly personal. I don't believe any of the recreation staff feel that way. I don't believe you're acting in that way intentionally, but the end result of what you're suggesting be considered with outsourcing recreation ultimately involves disregarding the capacity that you have right in front of you.

2:15:36 For a guy who's seen his budget go from, or his time commitment go from 100% municipal recreation down to 25% in the last three years and not have the Recreation Commission find some way to do a better job of supporting him in providing those specific tasks and accomplishing those tasks, I think is regrettable. I think a large portion of your frustration as a Recreation Commission in what's not being prioritized,

2:16:07 in what's not being proposed that's new and exciting shouldn't be laying at the feet of staff. It should be laying at your own feet. We have talked for years about our vision, our goals, what we want to be like, which peer resorts we want to model, how grand and accomplishment we think we're capable of achieving and what those things are.

2:16:36 With all due respect to all of you, and some of you have only been on the commission a short time, and some of you have been on it for a lengthier period of time. Some of you were trans, survived the merger of the Recreation and Tourism Commission, which I will still go back and say I think was a poor solution to a problem that didn't need to be solved in the way that it was solved by merging those two departments or two commissions, which have now been split again. You know, we've got real talent.

2:17:05 in-town staff. And I just respectfully ask that you guys give that some consideration moving forward. Do whatever you need to do as a commission to decide what you think is important and in what order it should happen. And then support your staff in meeting those objectives because I think they're eminently qualified and capable of doing that. If you, as a commission, will lay those things out in a clear way instead of punting.

2:17:33 Routinely about needing more information, about not understanding what counsel is asking of you or what direction counsel wants to go. I would really appreciate it if you guys would establish those priorities based on all of the research that you've done very diligently for the last three to five years. Give your staff an opportunity to perform and I think you'll finally do a hell of a nice job for you. Once again, I would like to say that I think our staff is doing a hell of a job.

2:17:59 With what they've been handed. So that has not been anything that has came out here today. So maybe we're going through this kind of the cart before the horse kind of type thing. Because the process that we're going through I think is in the end run going to come up with what we're looking to do right here and create that. Unfortunately, kind of the other restructuring and the other comments are coming forward prior to this.

2:18:30 Process going to be done because it is taking a very long time to get through. So our staff as it stands right now would be very involved in any of this moving forward because that's one thing that once again I think that we have an issue with as we're working in a silo. So not looking at changing something or doing something without involving our staff that we have currently to move something forward. So anyway.

2:19:02 Any other comments, John? John, I'm just speaking as a private citizen. Is the status quo going forward, Stuart, the way the town manager's assigned responsibilities that you can only spend like 25% of your time in municipal rec? Is that, I'm assuming those assignments are coming from the town manager, is that right? Yeah. Okay, so you guys have, you know, in case you haven't noticed,

2:19:31 The town settled a lawsuit for tens of millions of dollars. This issue has to be addressed, irregardless of the big picture of what else we do. We've got to find a solution for this. That has to happen. I don't think it's acceptable to anybody to say that now the only recreation staff that you've got is going to be spending three quarters of their time doing something else. That's got to get addressed. Then we've got to address this issue of the larger recreation challenges. Status quo doesn't apply to anything anymore.

2:20:01 We are in new territory. We have to think outside of all of our boxes, summon our political will, get to work and figure this nonsense out. Because this is not acceptable for anybody. So I would encourage you to let's roll up our sleeves and get to work and get this stuff figured out. I don't think this is any question about staff or non-staff. It's just that the town does not have the resources to perform. And either we as a community step up and figure this out,

2:20:27 Or the status quo is going to be you get 25% of steward's time and that's it and nothing else happens. And I don't think anybody wants that. So I'm just speaking as a community member. Thank you. Thank you, John. Sandy. Sandy Hogan, speaking as a citizen, interested in recreation. I understand what you guys are saying. You want to move on to things. But what I heard and what I know to be a fact is you have at least two members who have no idea maybe what Mammoth Recreation was all about.

2:21:05 For you guys, it may be as very familiar. I don't know about Sean. I think he came in about that time. But that was not a public process. That was a very small, convened group. And it was more an ideas type of session, taking notes. I've seen some of the notes that was never made public to anybody. That's not correct. That's not correct. Well, I guess what I'm saying is. And actually, once you go back to the beginning, I'm sorry, you're talking about what.

2:21:32 Mammoth Recreation Proposal, the Terry Gooch-Ross Sessions. Right, right. And I don't believe those notes. I mean, I didn't obtain those publicly. You couldn't forget them. You know, those are the kind of things that I believe Pat's referring to. She's saying, let's have that discussion. Maybe the time is right to have it. But it's not right tomorrow night for you guys to try to convince two members that have maybe never even heard about it or don't have the information. That's what I'm saying. I think that's what Pat's saying, is you should agendize it.

2:22:02 Make it public. Let us all in on what Mammoth Recreation is about because maybe it is the right time. But that's not RecStrats. It's not the master plan. It's all the trails or parks or any of that kind of stuff. It's an idea with a lot of notes and there were meetings, but it was not a public process. You had townies and you had others, but they were all invited. So I guess what I'm saying is

2:22:31 I know that you guys feel strongly about it. That's great. But you have to realize that it's not fair to ask others to come to consensus on something where they're saying, you know, I'm not really up to speed on this. Let's agendize. Is it for a rec meeting? And I think that's perfectly appropriate. I'd like to hear it agendized. And that's probably maybe a good step into looking at do we need to reorganize and look at things differently or not. And I guess that would be the only consensus is do we want to?

2:23:02 Move forward in looking at what something like that might look like. For me, this wasn't about outsourcing or about Mammoth Recreation. It was about having the conversation as to who we are and where we're going to go. I did not want to stop the conversation. I didn't want this to be our only conversation. It has been put to me by members of council that they would like to hear our ideas, our consensus on

2:23:29 Whether or not this should go forward, and it's been brought to me by the public. If we have no consensus, I have no problem not bringing it forward as a group tomorrow. I will give my opinions and ideas on what I think the Rec Department, how it needs to grow and what we need to add to it, and we can all do that as individual commissioners, and if that's the consensus of this group, I have no problem with that. So let me go back to the audience anymore.

2:23:59 I guess the only thing is when you talk about, if you're just talking about expanding the department, great, but you're not, because you're mentioning NGOs and other partners, perhaps. So that's where I think it gets a little murky, and I think that we could all support expanding the department, giving it more money, and giving more money for maintenance of our parks, and things like that.

2:24:24 But I think when you do talk about NGOs and other things like that, that is outsourcing to me. And I'm not ready for that conversation. And you don't even want to make the suggestion that that's a possibility? No, because I don't know anything. I don't know enough about it. I think ironically, in having an NGO discussion pulled from our agenda, I think that's just making this conversation very difficult because I'm not sure some members of the audience even know what...

2:24:53 We're alluding to, first of all. I also just wanted to say that I think that we need to bear in mind with the settlement that, first of all, we're one of two commissions left standing, so I think we're very fortunate that we still have our voice and our oversight and our charter that we do have from council. And I think it's worth remembering that council has been so willing to work with us that we were, of all the cuts,

2:25:21 We've got a little bit more recreation on the neighbor's store. So I think that's really positive. I just want to say one other really positive thing in that reading over the parking right master plan, I'm sure it's really frustrating. I mean, obviously, I'm a fabulous member of the commission, and I'm sure it's really frustrating for some of you to really have the same discussion year after year. But I realized in looking at that that there have been some major successes that are a huge credit to the commission, to staff, and to the community.

2:25:47 I mean, the Parks and Recreation Plan is only just approved, and since it's approval, we've already got the Charlton Playground first phase completed, and we're well on the way to starting the second phase, and we've got the, you know, the Whitmore Track and that whole facility. So I think we just need to, you know, it's frustrating as things can seem at times. There have been some really major victories for recreation, and this community is really passionate about recreation, so I think that our charge is broad, and I don't think there's an excuse. Okay.

2:26:19 That all being said, it appears we are not going to have any consensus on anything to bring forward as a commission at tomorrow's meeting. I encourage you to all show up and speak to Recreation as individual commissioners and community members. Okay? Bill, I would like to ask this question then. You know, how do we discuss things that are outside of the box?

2:26:48 How do we come to some kind of consensus to even try and raise the bar on what Recreation Department can be? And again, you know, with town staff involved in it, to the best that is allowed in those conversations, but how, you know, as Brian pointed out, or, you know, just pointing fingers, whoever, you know, whether it rests at our feet.

2:27:17 At the budget speed, whatever the case may be, I'm aware that we may not all be able to fully sing Kumbaya together, but at the same time, how do we have these discussions without having it pulled from our agenda? Considering at the last meeting, and I heard two different times during the meeting, that we were going to have a discussion, two days later we got an email saying that we weren't going to be allowed to talk about it. So I guess my question is,

2:27:45 How do we have this discussion in an open way that I'm not trying to, you know, put anyone threatened, but be able to have these discussions so that this commission really can make some sets of priorities that includes how the law stands. Thank you, Sean. Yeah, I think we have to agendize them. Had we stuck our feet in the sand and absolutely insisted that that

2:28:11 Item we put back on our agenda. I believe we could have gotten it put back on our agenda. As the chair, I didn't think it was worth the fight or the heartache. I talked to staff. Staff believed we had a timeline already established for that process of bringing that forward. And in my conversations with them, I decided we would just let it go forward at that. I talked to a couple of council members on it.

2:28:40 Because one of them requested that we speak to it, and he said he understands timelines, he had no problem with it, it wasn't worth going to bat on. I think the best way to approach it, and this is, I really don't know how to get there, Sean, or we would have been there, I've been here for 16 years, the conversation that we're having now, and the prioritization process we're having now, needs to be done.

2:29:09 In that conversation, we need to have the conversation of how we're going to accomplish it. If we find that tennis courts are particularly important, then we need to have the very hard conversation of where they should be located and what they should look like and what the capacity they should hold. Regardless of what we're prioritizing, we need to have that conversation with it, and as a commission, I don't think we have in the past. What is the best way to move forward?

2:29:38 Is it the way we've been going or is there another way to look at it? My only problem with John's proposal as it comes forward is we haven't had a chance to look at all the pieces. Is it best to do that piece separate and the rest outside of the box? So we need to agendize this conversation and a recreation conversation as we're going through these workshops to set our priorities.

2:30:05 I think we need to start adding this conversation to the start of each one of our workshops on our priority settings so that we can get to the conclusion of both at the same time. Do we want to outsource pieces or don't we? And I guess that's what I'm looking at is do you piecemeal it to one piece here and do you piecemeal one piece here? And that's the reason I had a conversation with some council members because we had our last meeting and we're being told, well, this is the direction that...

2:30:33 Council wants things to go and, you know, so, hey, you know, finally I went and spoke to some folks because I need to know, you know, what direction, am I completely off base or, you know, do we want to start looking at different options and how can we accomplish things and is that accomplished in-house, is that accomplished with an outside contract, you know, those are the conversations that need to happen.

2:31:02 And it isn't, you know, we just can't be, I don't know, as emotional because otherwise we'll never get anywhere. It isn't about a single person. It isn't about a personality because I do think our department has done an incredible job with what they've done, but we need to figure out just what Sean said. How do we have those conversations? How do we move forward? That gets back to process.

2:31:29 And that's why I suggested that if we want to have this conversation, it doesn't need to be agendized. We all need to have the same information so that we're all dealing with it from the same standpoint. Also, process happens to be, too, is that our last meeting, we were kind of forced, I think, to push something onto today's agenda that was maybe premature because it's my understanding that there were board members and staff.

2:32:01 that had gotten together and talked about what the process was and were all, and I think you might have heard that. And everybody was capacetic with the timeline. And then all of a sudden it was mentioned at the last meeting that we had to escalate, that process had to be escalated. So that's why it does get back to process. And if there was time and why it had to be escalated, I don't know. Well, I'm sorry.

2:32:29 And so that's why I think... Bringing it on the last agenda was to have a conversation about it, not to make a decision about it. It wasn't to escalate it or push anything faster than the timeline. It was so the Rec Commission could have some of these discussions about it and about the future and how we were going, not to say, yes, by golly, we want this to be outsourced, we want it to go down that way, because I have a lot of questions on that process.

2:32:58 Maybe our understanding was just different. My understanding wasn't that I was trying to push it forward. My understanding was that at least one council member would have liked us to have that conversation before tomorrow night's meeting because he wanted us to have a clue and maybe ask us some questions. I don't know why. I've talked to him since and if it doesn't work, it doesn't work. But getting back to process then, then what is the process? If a council member, one council member wants us to talk about this,

2:33:27 How does that go? Does it go to the town manager, to staff, then to us? Is that what the process should be as opposed to it going to one person of the commission and all of a sudden it's a commission issue based upon one council member speaking to it? You know, that just gets back to process and it would be nice to be clear on what that is. Well, let's agendize how things get on our agenda.

2:33:55 I have no problem with that. Frankly, I think that if a commissioner wants something on the agenda, unless it's outrageous, it should go on the agenda. If a council member wants us to discuss something, it should go on the agenda. If the staff, if the council commission votes 4-1 for something to be on the agenda, by golly, I believe it should be on the agenda, regardless. So, anyway, let's, we have...

2:34:24 It's feeding back through the other mics. Brian Knox again as a citizen. Is there still, is town government as a whole, meaning council, the commission, and staff, are we still waiting to hear from the town's legal representation as to what exactly?

2:34:57 The town can consider to be outsourced. Has that been fleshed out completely? Are we formally waiting for them to determine what parts of municipal government can be considered appropriate to outsource? I don't know that that specific question has been asked. It has been asked in terms of the proposal that MLTPA has brought forward, and I've only been told it's been asked. I can't speak to whether it has or not.

2:35:25 Or how it's been framed. So I can't answer that. I think there was some interpretation a couple of months ago. Yeah, so it's on a case-by-case basis. So I think from the proposal that we're receiving, the town attorney did produce, and because that's more aligned upon Measure R funds, you know, there was a memo produced specifically on administration of town funds as it relates to Measure R and Measure U. As it relates to Measure R. Right, so...

2:35:54 So for the legal representation to determine what council can do legally or town government can do legally with general funds and use that to outsource current municipal programming that's being provided in-house, that hasn't been answered. No. I just respectfully ask that the commission is going to offer any kind of opinion with consensus tomorrow that they would consider offering the wholesale

2:36:23 Support and endorsement of the work that the Recreation Department is doing with its incredibly limited staff and its meager 5% of the municipal budget right now. You offer your wholesale support and endorsement of that situation currently up until at least the time that legal counsel determines that you can actually carve away even more of what you've already carved away from the Recreation Department and outsource.

2:36:50 Yeah, and I will reiterate, I am not yet committed to outsourcing or insourcing or anything else. The conversation of what Mammoth Recreation needs to look like is one we have to have. Anything else? We need to move this to our next agenda item. We do. When we ask for agenda items at the end of this meeting, we'll come back to this because you're right, we've got enough talk.

2:37:16 Yeah. We don't, yeah, we don't show the end items. That's going to be on our March meeting. Yeah. Okay. So, which means that we'll have to ask for the March meeting and we'll have it here. We can answer something to be on the agenda before that, so. You can. I encourage you. If you want something to be on the agenda, take it to Stu. Okay. Or take it to me and I will take it to Stu.

2:37:39 I know on most commissions it would go through the chair. Frankly, I am not going to not put something on the agenda that any of you want there. So let's move on. Let's go to the workshop, review, and discuss Park and Recreation Master Plan. And we have a couple of things put together by a couple of commissioners and by staff. I thank them very much. This first one is what we have put together.

2:38:08 Okay. Stu, did you want to give any kind of a preface or anything on the master plan, or? Yeah, I believe the, Pat put a very good summary together, which captured a lot of the scope of the document. What town staff did that request the commission was to produce an analysis of an existing facilities, which is a two-page document that you've got there.

2:38:34 So that looks at our current facility, the program use, and comments as in regards to what's programmed there, what's needed there. That's a two-page document. We also... No. Yeah, that's the one. Yeah, so that's it there. The one that you're probably holding up was what Dennis put together, which is your parks inventory, which actually goes on one of the tables in the document that just shows...

2:39:04 As a level of service standard by 2025, the last one was 2006, so this would be your 2012 inventory. So that kind of slots in there. And then you have the Parks and Recreation Master Plan Summary that Commissioner Agnich put together. And I believe the recommendations, I think it's page 67, speaks to the next step. So I think that's...

2:39:31 It's a pretty succinct document. It took quite a bit of time to put together because there was a lot of public engagement. And then if you did have a chance to look at the needs assessment, it was a very, and I know that commission participated in this process as well, it was a very robust process that went out there to the community. I know there was, I was engaged in this process at that time as well. So there's a lot of very good information on needs assessment of what the public was looking for. And a lot of those are represented in Tier 1 and Tier 2 projects.

2:40:01 I can't quite remember where they were, but Steve Spidell was actually engaged in this too. But in those recommendations, I was trying to get to that page because it did speak to a lot of good recommendations that I'll get to. Yeah, I know there was that one, but there was actually, I think it was at the front. And I didn't really organize it. I just pulled different bits and pieces. Some of it's the same.

2:40:40 Information that Pat has on hers. Yeah. And I guess one thing that I was looking at and see if this is something that we could do, I would like to take something that is kind of takes what we originally did from RecStrats, and I started doing that with this, and I can show you that, is take each of our different plans and start putting it all on one.

2:41:14 into one table. And so if you see, I kind of just, I changed the print a little and I highlighted, and these were some things that I pulled from the master plan. I didn't get through half of my thing as putting that together. So if this is something that we want to do, then, you know, we can do that as a commission. We can, you know, give staff the points that we want to put in there and they can put that table together, whatever. But I just thought maybe in the end,

2:41:41 If we have all our plans and see what all the comments are that goes with each of these items, then that we have kind of a working document that we can look at. Does it need to be in a different format? It could be whatever. But I guess, you know, with high altitude within each plan, what points within each plan fit within high altitude and what are the comments that were made? And I guess that's one of the things I started to do here. And I think that it might be beneficial for us in the long run is to then have that.

2:42:10 As our final document that we can start working on. If you're willing to continue doing this, I find this incredibly helpful. Make it, you know, three or four colors or fonts or whatever is necessary so that we can see which one was added out of which plan. But I really like it. I really appreciate getting all of these plans just into one document. Right. I think that's huge. Yeah, so page 30. Sorry.

2:42:38 Bottom of page 30, I don't know if you've got your document there, but it summarizes the needs assessment survey, and it identifies facility and program needs, so I thought that was a good, yeah, have you got that too? Yeah. Mm-hmm. So, yeah, that's where I'm just bringing your attention to, that page there was pretty succinct in regards to summarizing the needs assessment. And, you know, I didn't see in here, because one of the comments that I had in what I had put together was that you have a needs assessment.

2:43:37 I didn't really see how often that was re-evaluated or, you know, reassessed with either a survey or whatever you would want to do to do that because I don't think it, I think it isn't something that needs to be reassessed from time to time. Do you think that maybe RecStrats did a little bit of that? I think it did, yeah.

2:44:02 And that's why I was looking at, because RecStrats I think was probably a good starting point for everything that we had here because then we can take everything that's been happening throughout the years previous to that and see how it fits within that document. Yeah, I would love to see the, I know that, and I don't pay close enough attention and should, that our staff does run assessments on a regular basis. Are we capturing the people? You guys have heard me complain.

2:44:39 Over and over, how do we get the general population of Mammoth involved? We see the same things rise to the top because we have the same groups pushing very hard for that. Whether that represents the majority, I can tell you that when I tell people that the top scorer in RecStrats was a field house and I take that out to the public and talk to them about it.

2:45:04 I get sort of belly laughed out of the room because we have so many needs and things that can enhance. So I still have that. How in the world do we get these, our staff does a great job with them. How do we get our surveys to be reflective? And I had a conversation with another staff member that is not part of our recreation staff. He said he had some ideas on that. So I hopefully will, for a meeting or something, I can pull that together because I still.

2:45:34 I should say one thing. If I could. These were public meetings. Significant public noticing went into those meetings, and a lot of people showed up. And it's probably just appropriate to characterize what happened. These were dot exercises, and people put dots in these places. But people did participate.

2:45:56 There was probably a more ambitious public outreach effort for anything that you can imagine doing in the future, so I just would caution you not to discount it too far. That's all you've got. You're not going to get a whole lot more anytime soon. But one thing to point out is that I think in RecStrats there were 90-some people, individuals, who attended multiple meetings, so it looked like it was a large number of people getting input.

2:46:23 Maybe we need to do a survey online like they did recently with town government. I think 1,000 people responded to something like that, which is a better... You could try it. You could do whatever you want. But again, I'm hearing the very limited capacity of your rec staff and again, how you engage your partners. Is that realistic or can you make good work out of what you've already got? That's my only point. And maybe that's the next phase of this project because it's our goal in this first phase. It's just to basically go through the...

2:46:51 Absolutely. I don't want to redo the documents. I don't want to go start all over again. But we do regular surveys. Stuart and staff do regular surveys for the things that we have. Is there a way that we can help them and enhance those to involve...

2:47:11 Some people outside of the programs that are already there, I don't know, and that's the question I'm asking. It's been a frustration of mine now for only 40 years or so at Mammoth, is how do we pull out the... But I'm going to say something here, is that, you know, we've been criticized from the audience tonight about constantly going back and looking for more studies. Right. And at the same time, I think John's point is will taken, that, you know, we did it. We need to use it, yes. So much of the public, you know, I was here for rec strats, not so much the master plan.

2:47:39 And I do want to hear your comment here in a second. Yes. At the same time, you know, I'm hesitant. Public process needs to be, it's very important, needs to be done to be sure. But at the same time, I've heard criticism of this commission before that we're constantly too much into going back and requesting interest rates. So at this point, while I don't want to discount the process,

2:48:05 At the same time, we do have some really good information there. We do. And we need to start making decisions and moving them forward. Absolutely. I just want to clarify, I'm not suggesting that we start over the whole thing. But you could probably put together, if you wanted to reach the greater community, instead of people who tend to come out to meetings all the time. You know, there's the same, probably a handful of people. Maybe an online survey of...

2:48:31 Ten questions or something. I do like that idea. I'm just thinking that that's appropriate for phase one. I'm not saying now. When we get to phase two, it's important we bring our constituencies with us. I know that Teri and myself and I know Sean, I know all of us speak to a whole lot of people. Some of us are in the public and speak to, and we need to ask them those questions and bring that knowledge back with us as well.

2:49:00 I think that's what I'm saying. And I didn't mean it to dive off this. I just kind of generally, how often would you reassess these, you know? No, that's a very good point, Karen. Steve Spidell, private citizen, ex-employee of the town of Mammoth Lakes and project manager for this particular master plan that you're talking about. One of the things that we strived early on in the process was how to create a proper needs assessment.

2:49:27 If you'll notice in the document itself, we never made recommendations as to one, two, three, or four as far as projects to move forward. That was a conscious effort by staff discussed with the commission to leave it at the feet of the commission to have this discussion amongst yourselves without going outside the process again and treading water or trying to get additional input. But as Commissioner Souser put it, you come with your constituents. So it's up to you.

2:49:55 To go ahead and set that priority list, and then if you want to get public comments on the priority list, it's probably perfectly appropriate. But as author with somebody with a little bit of stake in the process and blood, sweat, and tears in the document, I urge you, make a decision.

2:50:13 Make a list and move forward. Thank you very much. Thank you, Steve. And this list will be made and it will be brought forward for public comment at the time that it's put together. And Elaine Smith, private citizen. And just to echo that really and add just a little at the tail end, even if you make your list, one, two, three, four, five, in the process of building any of those things, and we're thinking the major capital projects, you will come into

2:50:37 Times when you can't go forward with number one, you have to go to number two, or you have to go to number three. So even if you were able to, and I don't think you are, say we're going to do one, two, three, four, five in that order, when it comes to getting out in the field, on the ground, doing these things, they won't come in order anyway. So, you know, getting the top five would be, and you'll see those in all those documents, that it will come together with, there is about a handful of things that people want, and then proceed from there.

2:51:07 And, you know, also when we're looking at this, we may have a number one, but it may take us 10 years to get to that number one, so then other things are done in between that time, and that's what we're looking to try to resolve with this, so that we can... Just to wrap up on the survey, so just under 13,000, 13,000 surveys were distributed, and just under 600 were completed, so it's a pretty good, pretty good collection. The needs assessment, that was the recreation, yeah, the document.

2:51:40 I mean, 100 is like a sample size, so I think that's pretty good. I still just ask the simple questions, how often do you do it? But anyways, thank you for that clarification. Anyways. Okay, so what's your pleasure in tackling this? I think that one of the things that the level of service standards I think that it calls out are hugely important to understand where we are.

2:52:11 Yeah. And one of the things I have to say that I didn't put through are all these tables because I wasn't going to recreate all the tables. And so I put my little paper clips on everything that these need to be probably copied and put into all of this. And one of them was level of service. The other was need assessment. Can I ask someone to define level of service? I think I know what it is at the same time.

2:52:37 I think there are people in the audience who can explain this better than me. For the record, Steve Spidell again. Yeah, my pleasure. Level of service is as much an art as it is a science. And one of the things that we did to establish level of service was look at what our existing facilities are and rate those per thousand population.

2:53:03 In the years past, national parks organizations created sample levels of services. For instance, for every 1,000 population, you should have 10 picnic tables, two basketball courts, and a swimming pool. Some example like that. So a lot of municipalities use those national standards. But then over time, people realized that different communities had different needs. Different communities were made up of different types of people and different folks.

2:53:32 Now encourage on a national level is explore yourself and see what your levels of service are. So we used sample communities that we felt were similar to us, and then we looked at others that weren't really that close to us, but maybe geographically close to us. So if you look in there in detail, Sean, you'll see some of the examples of other communities, what they had for level of service, and then we kind of did an average and a compare.

2:54:02 And then look to ourselves to say, is this really realistic? So that's how we derived our level of service and made our recommendations. One of the questions I, I'm sorry, go ahead. Well, thank you. And then additional facilities to achieve the level of service for 2006. Is that, was that a, I don't know, an upgrade or can you explain what it was for 2006? Right, that was our model year. That was our target year. So we said, okay, we have.

2:54:30 So many picnic tables, but in order to meet our new proposed level of service standard, by 2006, we'll need to add three more. And that carries through all the way. So Stu, I want to ask, Stu's going to have to leave us at 4.15. I wanted to ask him a question on that before he leaves, if that's alright with you. Stu, do we have a table with what Dennis has given us? Do we actually have a table or can we get one?

2:54:59 that shows where we are at in 2013 versus our recommended standards. Yeah, Dennis didn't have sufficient time to go and count individual picnic table or bench. Yeah, I understand. But I'm assuming we haven't actually added many picnic tables or benches since 06. Yeah. We had some benches on the trails. We had a new trail. We have a new trail. There's some up on Lake Murray Road that we got from the Forest Service.

2:55:30 10-15? Yeah. Yeah, 10-15 benches is probably what we've added for Steve. I'm just doing these real quick. You don't have an idea to do so everybody can hear you outside. The acreage and total parkland acreage, when you did this, we already owned Trails End Park, but it wasn't made into a park yet, but wasn't that acreage included? That's correct. So any acreage that says we need

2:55:56 That's already in the mix. Our needs are above and beyond with Trails Inn added. Correct. If you look in the plan, there's actually an existing conditions map that color codes each one of the parks. As a matter of fact, that graphic used to be in this room. But yeah, Trails Inn Park was part of that. And then as I recall too, the bell-shaped parcel at that time was identified as open space, I think.

2:56:24 So it was added into the parkland space? I think it was under a separate category of open space. Open space, okay. And I just wanted to point out that I didn't put a column for 2025, because I'm sure it's too far off. So when I look at the need for 10.48 acres of additional parkland in 2006, I can pretty much assume today that our need is still that 10. And remember, it's based on population, so I'm assuming our 2010 census,

2:56:54 Was a wash or we lost a little population? Right. We gained population. What? Well, I'm happy about that. That's great. All right. So, yeah, we need some more parkland. 13 acres of additional parkland. Could be, yeah. Do you understand why I'm asking it? So that we can see the, yeah. Go ahead. That was it. Oh. You know, I guess I would just like to ask, why does level of service not speak to quality? It only speaks to quantity.

2:57:24 And so in here it speaks to maintenance, but we have the level of service. I would almost think that level of service should speak to quality and quantity as opposed to just a quantity because just because you have something doesn't mean that it's really sufficient. Yeah, unfortunately, I think that the assumption is made there, correct me if I'm wrong, the assumption is made that once we purchase that, we're going to maintain it. It may not be practiced, but I think that that assumption is... Well, I think there are two things that are called out in this, and one is the emphasis on maintaining it.

2:57:53 Which is a huge issue. And then the other one is access in terms of proximity to neighborhoods and transit. I think actually it's been a while since I read the document, but I do think there is a statement in there about the importance of maintenance. Yeah, there is. There is. And then the other thing we were looking at at the time was the trending of maintenance dollars. So we wanted to maintain that trend line.

2:58:23 I think that if we, with those assumptions that Bill just took, we can look to see if for a thousand people, where we sit within our parks, you know, when facilities, are they sufficient, and we can look at that. Because I think in the final analysis, that's going to be important for our priorities. How do we want to move forward with this today? So, anyways.

2:58:54 Do we want to go through and say, you know, what points we want to put into our... Yes, so page 30 had facility needs versus first tier and second tier, and then it also identified programs. So I thought it was a pretty succinct table that identified what the 580 responses.

2:59:25 preferred or indicated that they'd like to see in Mammoth. And then, I mean, you can just kind of go through them. I don't know how you want to address them or what we want to add them to. I think they are pretty consistent with what we saw in RecStrats as well, so I don't think there's anything too difficult, too separate. We just have to make sure that they exist on our...

2:59:44 Teri's putting together for us. Yeah, the one that I put together is I grouped them all. It just has some suggestions, and these were suggestions that came out of these facility needs and programs, is some suggestions that had an aquatic dog park event, performing arts venue, multi-use cultural. It was described as open area for multi-purpose use, such as indoor soccer and indoor public events, running track, children's play areas not necessarily.

3:00:12 Well, yeah, children's play areas also in the multi-use classrooms and studio for recreation leisure programs, climbing wall, youth, teen center, sports training, batting cages, golf nets. So those are kind of things that were talked about for the multi-use and cultural. So those are kind of a little bit more specific than the RecStrats got as far as that went.

3:00:39 But they're also in, but it's in RecStrats. So what is, I think if we're going to do a multi-use, you're going to look to see what the uses are that you want to do that. You'd look to these, are they still viable uses that you want to do, look to RecStrats. The snow and winter clay was in RecStrats. The field and quartz were in RecStrats. So all those things, I guess that's why I'm looking at these things that were in this first tier and second tier were mostly in.

3:01:07 RecStrats. The teen youth club was not necessarily in RecStrats. New picnic facilities were not necessarily in RecStrats. But I think the rest of it was... Open grass areas. That wasn't in... Oh, here, new open grass areas. No, that wasn't in RecStrats either. So, you know, so those are items that were not in RecStrats, so we can identify them as...

3:01:37 Being an additional item, but they didn't have a tie, you know, to RecStrats, so. So I think if they're here and they're not in RecStrats, then you just need to add them to your list and put where they came from. And I suppose whether they were first-year or second-year, because a lot of outreach went out from this master plan, from grass areas. Didn't the planning commission just deal with that? Sorry. I just had to throw that in.

3:02:16 I don't know if senior facilities was identified in RecStrats either. So that was called out specifically here. Oh, right there. Yeah. Not too sure about a teen youth club either. No, teen youth club was not. That's pretty specific. So those are the ones that need to move over to your list. Well, you said you haven't finished the list yet for this one anyway. No, I haven't. So I'm writing these in so that I'll add them.

3:02:50 And I think we could probably go through the back of the facility needs and cross off the ones that have already been met completely and not have to deal with them because there are some. We do have a running track. Yeah, but it's not indoor and it's not complete, so I think you still be... Well, in the... That was part of the... In that one, it was part of the multi-use and cultural facility is that there was an indoor running track. And so that was part of that.

3:03:23 Master Plan. So, you know, I don't know, programs, we probably ought to put another whole thing together on programs if we're looking at that because this is more based on facilities as opposed to programs and so we could have another whole list as far as programs go. As you continue your table here, Teri, was your thought to mention that this is part of

3:04:04 To list that this is mentioned, this item, dog parks, for instance, is mentioned in the master plan, not necessarily in RecStrats, you know, wherever the idea is. So then we'll be able to see when it's all said and done, do we have ten things under high altitude because it was mentioned in every single plan, or is it just a freestanding item over here because it was only mentioned once and it hasn't really kind of grown anywhere else? I guess that's why I was looking to try to put it in one.

3:04:34 Table. Does that make sense? So that's why I was looking at just doing, you know, this here. So it lived in the Parks and Rec Master Plan over here. Okay. And I probably need to add a call in here because that's getting too... That would be great. Absolutely. That's it. Yes.

3:05:00 Can I ask a question about the information we're putting together? Whether or not as you go through it or when it's done, would this be something accessible? It's on the web right now. The first run from RecStrat is on the web. And as we build things, then Stu will update that, I'm assuming. We're going to send them to you.

3:05:24 First he has to get it from me. Yeah. He had to keep sending me emails. Come on, Terry. It's a challenge. It's okay. We've got it. About how great that the three of you now have stepped up to the plate. Well, that's why I was just trying to figure out how we can make this work and have something that we can work with in the end. And what I can do is with this one, I'll do that and send it to you guys to make sure.

3:05:55 It's captured everything that we needed to capture because of all the different comments. Then it can go back to Stu and he can make sure we captured all the comments. Is there anything else that we want to put on here? I have Pat's information. I don't know that we would put the inventory within this. That's a whole separate document. We just have it and we could probably compare it to what.

3:06:30 the level of services for where we stand right now, and that comparison can be made. You know, I just, I really like what Pat summarized here with you. Proximity to Maniflaced Neighborhoods. You know, Love Trails and Parks, it's as far east as we can get, but, you know, Whitmore Coal, actually, that's a very simple example. Unfortunately, it's not as approximate as

3:06:58 So I would like to lend a weight to making sure that future programming and facilities are... Good point to bring up because that was one of the things that I had pulled out too, that we pulled out some different stuff. And one of the things that I was trying to figure out is, okay, so parks and facilities to neighborhoods, access and affordability are important.

3:07:26 And need partners. That's one of the things that I've pulled out. And so that's kind of what you're talking about, outdoor, indoor recreation for residents and visitors of all ages. Where does that live in our grand scheme of our, do we want to just put the goals and policies? And that's another whole piece at the end here.

3:07:54 You know, I feel like as we can do this towards the end of the process, obviously it's going to be really setting the priorities. I almost feel like we need to create a scoring sheet similar to what we do for Measure R that, you know, identifies these things. How many documents was it called out as score one to five? As we look at what we call the low-hanging fruit,

3:08:23 How easily put into place, how easily purchased are these, I don't know, I kind of think that this is going to be more of a subjective question, Teri, rather than just listing it, and it will probably be destroyed. Well, and I guess maybe what I'm looking at with that comment is do we put the goals and policies and do we list them just kind of like we are doing everything else, and then when we get to the end, we look at those goals and policies.

3:08:56 Maybe then you prioritize those and, you know, these should be weighted higher than these and, you know, I don't know. No, I think it's also too worth bearing in mind that we go forward in terms of maintaining our current facilities, you know, because there's a lot of discussion going on right now about the community center and sports and parking and that it also happens to be the closest playground to where I live. So, you know, but I do think it's worth, I call that too. So, in the end,

3:09:26 I don't know if it's a scoring sheet. We need some kind of criteria to post to each one as to how well it fits the needs and should we be looking elsewhere to supply that. I mean, that's really what you're talking about, isn't it? Yeah, it is. Yeah. So if proximity to neighborhood is important, I mean, our problem is we don't know what neighborhoods have the densest population of

3:09:54 Old folk, young folk, toddlers, but something like that we are going to need in order to lay out where is the best bang for the buck. Well, the map in here is good in terms of it does show if there is a map that shows the difference of the existing facilities. And also, that's also something that can be addressed in terms of transit too. It doesn't necessarily have to be. Yeah, exactly. And it can be transit. And Trails End Park, at the time, Trails End Park was one of the highest.

3:10:23 Density of school-age children. And so, is it still? It probably still is, but I don't know. So, you know, that was actually, it is kind of a nice place to have a park because they can walk down that path. They're not having to go out on a road and they're right there at that park. So, anyhow. Well, and there are mitigators to things. Trails in park doesn't get as much snow. It's on a mud. Well, that's right. So, anyways, so those are all.

3:11:02 Yeah. So any addition to the list, to the, what are we going to call this thing that Teri put together for us? We're going to have two lists, one for programs and one for facilities, I guess? Yeah. So she already asked, did we see something? And without going through every single thing that's called out, I don't know. I guess that's going to be our homework.

3:11:37 Dog Park is one of those things that needs to be added because it wasn't on anything with the rec straps. Right, so you need to put Dog Park on. Someone's eyes are still focusing after looking at all this stuff. And some things on the needs assessment are currently being offered to some degree. They are. There's after school care, there's pre-school care. Maybe Steve could address this.

3:12:10 Did people think at the time that we needed more of that for those kinds of programs? I know, but when this process was done, did people think that we needed more programs in these particular areas, one of which was preschool care or after school care? Were there programs similar to what we currently have now and they thought more was needed?

3:12:37 Yeah, I think there were, actually I think there were some that were in flux when you're talking about daycare. I think at the time there was a commercial daycare provider that was leaving or something. Oh, I know what it was. It was the church across the street for heaven's sakes. They, yeah, they built a parsonage instead of having their daycare. So that was a topic at the time. The other thing I think we did in the plan was we suggested

3:13:03 possible locations for a lot of these functions, like the dog park or tennis courts or something. So we actually showed which one of the existing facilities could facilitate the particular capital item. And then science and nature instruction, I know the Valentine program offers quite a bit, so were they not as active? And also at the time... And that may fall into information, maybe people just...

3:13:32 Aren't familiar with what's happened. We were talking about interpretive programs at the time, you know, as part of our trail system and the Lakes Basin Path and all its interpretive hadn't been created yet. And then there was a private developer who, as part of his development mitigation, had an opportunity to have educational seminars and perform those right along Mammoth Creek.

3:14:02 As a matter of fact, I think it was Jacques Cousteau's son was in town and led a group of 10 people or so. So that was, you know, one of the program elements where he, as a developer, saw there was an opportunity for him to add something to the community. As I recall, Steve, the science and nature instruction really was more, not instruction, but...

3:14:29 Interpretive signage. Rather than instruction, we could really put interpretive in there and it would be as or more accurate. I'm not an expert in anything, Bill. I don't know. I'd love to be more accurate. Yeah, well, I... Yeah. Yeah. Because in my memory, I don't think anyone was calling for classes or traditional instruction, just interpretation of the science and nature, the volcanic, the stream, the fish.

3:15:02 And I'm sure we have interpretive down here in several places. Excuse me, Chair, but I do have to apologize myself for the previous engagement. Thank you, Stu. Welcome. I think there was some discussion about interpretive programs in RecStrat. And I think it's in here under information. It's under information, yeah. Right. So information is, right. And I'm sure that will come up quite a bit later.

3:15:40 It comes up in all of them, yeah. I think one of the problems with this thing, it's kind of hard to read. I think I need to put, you know, it needs to have some lines and grids and so we can separate these stuff and clarify a little bit more. So anyways, I have that same issue. So, but it is under information. And, you know, I kind of pulled some things apart too because like under biking community, one of the things that was in here was

3:16:15 Connecting gaps in town in signage. And then, you know, the things over here that we're in RecStrats, where RACS route signage needs inventory partnerships. So, anyway, anyways, I just think this is, it's too, it's going to need to be kind of reorganized a little bit and changed with, I think, the, yeah, the concept, I think it's okay.

3:16:41 The only problem I'm having reading it, Teri and I don't know how to solve it, is that the explanations are three columns away from the one wound. The length of the process goes to the end. Yeah. Yeah. We could do that. So put the short, the mid and long term towards the end.

3:17:03 And the explanations and where they, which plans they come from. That makes sense, yeah. Yeah. Or next to it or underneath it, yeah. Yeah, that's, that would help me out. Well, I almost want to say that that almost needs to be subcodes. So, for instance, if they're high altitude or that, you know, what is a high altitude? So, Betsy would kind of take the same thing and put...

3:17:31 Program, so anything that would fall under programs for that type of thing would go here, and this is programs and facilities, but it's not specific programs that's high level. Yeah, because some of them, like using the high altitudes that Sean already started there, the trainers would actually be programs, would move over to it. Well, I'm not sure that you wouldn't just leave those things here, but I think that if it's specific programming, that it could go into the program. This is just a generalization in high level.

3:18:00 What could happen at that facility? So that's, I think that's what this is looking at. Well, I guess what I was suggesting is, for instance, with regard to multi-use outdoor, just use that as an example. You know, we've talked about, and I know that the event site is kind of like that project, but you know, if we were to create a venue that's for 200 to 500 people, a venue that's 500 to 5,000 people.

3:18:28 I'm hoping that's coming in that feasibility study that someday we might get, but I have no idea what the RFP looks like. I'm just using that as an example. So, I mean, even if I jump back down to something that is

3:18:56 Like multi-use outdoor. Again, creating a sub-column that is picnic areas. I guess what I'm looking for is that multi-use outdoor is a header for some of these categories that need to be called out. But aren't we going to have to, and this is why it's going to take so darn long, aren't we going to have to go through this list one thing at a time and call out everything that exists under it and then call out

3:19:25 The importance of each thing that's under it. So there's going to be a sub-prioritization process there. And then we're going to have to call out, how do we achieve it? Do we achieve it in-house? Do we not achieve it in-house? Do we leave it for outside partners? So all those conversations, once we have this list, and that's really all we're trying to come up with, going over our plans, once we have this list, then the work starts of doing exactly what you said for every one of these.

3:19:53 It's going to have to have its own sheet. It does. But at the same time, I was just saying the sooner we start out than that, I feel like better we can go. But you can say the same thing about like a community center. How big should it be? How many people should it be? Should it include a pool? Should it make them? Yeah. I mean, I think you're going to have that for every. We're going to have it for everything. And then prioritize it. That's good. That's what we want to come out of this.

3:20:22 Could do that. That would be fine. I would be happy to work with you too. I know, really. Steve, where'd Steve go?

3:20:50 She has enough going on. So, you know, anyways, I guess I can, what I would be looking to do is take what I put together here, what I put together here, is there anything that you guys see that might be missing between the two that we need to put into this table? Between the two, you take RecStrats and Mr. Point.

3:21:18 For the master plan, I put something together, Pat put something together, a lot of it's the same, some of it's different, you know, like I guess I'm kind of struggling with the goals, which is one reason I didn't kind of put that in mind. Mine said the goals and policies and I kept it because that was at the end, it was the conclusion and that's kind of the only reason I put it there was enhanced quality of life for the residents, promote healthy community through physical activity.

3:21:45 Promote visitor recreation experience, resource, contribute to town economy, and take advantage of the town's unique setting. And I guess what I was trying to say, okay, how can we put this stuff in? And I guess what I was looking at is saying, you know, okay, RecStrats was create the best high-altitude alpine recreation experience. Something I need to go back and see exactly what that was. So did we put those kind of up here? Is this what we're trying to?

3:22:12 Create, and then that's where we put these goals and policies. You know, I don't know. I guess I'm trying to figure out how we incorporate those things. Yeah. They do, yeah. So I guess when we're trying to put that all together, I guess that's what I would be looking at. Let's take all those and say this is what, you know, this has came out to be and whatever.

3:22:40 And so that's where I'm looking at some of the goals and, you know, we've already done the master plan, you know, for the trails. Provide and encourage a wide variety of outdoor and indoor recreation readily accessible to residents and visitors of all ages. I think I had that one in there too. Link parks and open space with a well-designed year-round network of public corridors and trails within the surrounding Mammoth Lakes.

3:23:08 Provide parks and recreation facilities and programs that foster a sense of community and nurture the emotional connection. So how do you put these? I guess that's what I'm saying that these don't really live in a category here. They would be just simply kind of a statement at the beginning or the end or, you know, and then that's, we would be using these to make decisions on what we're doing here as opposed to putting it under a category here. Am I correct in that? So I could take these and just put them in.

3:23:36 at the end of this table kind of type thing or something? The goals almost give us our first set of criteria, don't they? Except that we've achieved some of them already, so that's all what it is to help provide us with the criteria for our... And they'll bring up that whole kind of nasty conversation again, too. Parks and Rec Master Plan.

3:24:01 It says right there at the beginning, outlines a vision of existing recreation facilities. Master plan primarily covers developed facilities. So it isn't really looking at what maybe that future vision looks like or what, you know, so I just, you know, there's two different, this was looking at one thing. RecStrats was looking kind of at a little bit different. So how do those two marry? So I guess that's kind of.

3:24:30 You know, if we're just looking at Parks and Rec Master Plan as our goals, I guess I have an issue with that because it is only looking at this one section. It's not looking at the whole thing. We need to look at all the goals and things that want to be accomplished in each of these documents. And so I think we need to be careful with that. And so we'll put the goals down there and it came from this plan. Goals from here came from this plan. And then we'll use it the same way as we do the facilities if you guys are okay with that.

3:24:57 Because that's like one of the first statements in this Parks and Rec Master Plan. That's exactly what it says. So like with trails I have down here, connect local trails to schools, homes, business, and trails. That one kind of threw me. But maintain access to town trails, connect gaps within town, accommodate different users, plan and develop staging areas, signage, preserve trailhead access. So those would be the things that I would put underneath trails.

3:25:32 And, I don't know, is that on the right track? Yeah, you'd put that under trails because then we have to ask the question of have we achieved that? Yeah. So existing facilities, I had, and that's kind of the same thing, maintain and upgrade existing facilities, bring up to ADA, rehab, cost effective maintenance.

3:25:56 Seek funding through grants and partnerships, interpretive signage, engage citizens, reevaluate provisions of facilities, needs assessment study. And so those were, that would kind of go under the facilities. But again, most of those are just questions that we have to ask ourselves in order to make our priority list of where we need to go.

3:26:29 And I guess that, you know, the reason I keep going back to that is, are our facilities sufficient? Can they be made sufficient? Are, you know, those are questions, and I think that's kind of what that's alluding to to an extent as well, and I think that's the information that Stuart's given us here is all going to be good to have, to help us out with some of those.

3:26:55 I would still love to see percentages of, what is the percentage of use within each of these facilities? You know, is it used 10% of the time? Is it used 100% of the time? I don't know. And I don't know if that can be answered. So anyways. Anyways. I'm sorry, you were asking.

3:27:29 about what percentage are they being used? I would love to know what percentage facilities are being used. Did you say percentage, you mean of maximum? Yeah, so, okay, so, you know, we have, that's a great point. Yeah, I'll take, I'll go back to Community Center, because that's kind of one of my good questions there. So it's Gymnastics, Zumba, Fitness, Youth Theater, Special Events, and Tantum Athletics Community Events. Okay, so.

3:27:58 Is there something going on there every single day? I mean, because we were led to believe that there wasn't much going on and when there was a parking issue that came up and they were trying to figure out where they could put parking, they were saying, well, there's parking going on there every single day. So does that mean there's events going on there every single day and things going on that I'm not aware of and I'm not giving it enough credit that it's being used more than I think it is? I don't know.

3:28:24 First Five Plate Group, MLTPA, has had a hard time, they've been trying to move around their days to accommodate, because it's just really probably used right now. So I'm sure that staff is all smart, because they're in the schedule. But it's not just that one. No, it's all of them. What's the use of our tennis courts? Do we need eight courts? Do we need six courts? Do we need four courts? How do we come up with that? I don't know if we can come up with a percentage of use.

3:28:52 And then the other question would be is what are the inadequacies? So, you know, if we could add this to this facility, and I do see like the community center says if we add Wi-Fi, that that would help. But, you know, as far as the facility itself, you know, what needs to be done to that facility? Can it be done, you know? Yes. Your question is just burning in my head.

3:29:22 A lot of the levels of service that are called out for a lot of the specific things in the master plan were gleaned originally from other areas' master plans. So when we say that our level of service that we're looking for for SAM volleyball courts is 0.24 per every thousand people, which is, you know, an X number of courts, is the SAM volleyball court getting

3:29:49 Use, and I may have read that wrong, but I'm only using it as an example. Are they getting used? Do we really need four sand volleyball courts? Or is that saying we need to take that out? Implementation schedule for parks and recreation facilities? Sand volleyball, it says what we need for 2006, which is two years prior to...

3:30:13 We didn't need any, right. But the level of service they're calling out, because we already have one, and at, yeah, 0.24, and I'm assuming that's per 1,000 people, though. So for every 4,000 people, you would need one. At 8,000 people, you would need two, which is where we are today at 2013. Do we really need a second volleyball court? Some of these things are going to have to be addressed in how the current usage that Teri's talking about is being done.

3:30:50 But I think each facility probably fits a certain need. I'm sure it does. I mean, look at the ice rink. The ice rink for the roller rink. Sure, it's a low percentage of use, but it's filling an inch for some people. And then there's that financial grant amendment. Yeah, we can't get out of that one. We can't get out of that one. But, you know.

3:31:20 It is what it is in bulk of the skate park. It looks like it's pretty heavily attended when I go by. But that's probably a small percentage of the community as a whole. So they're each providing a need. And I guess when we're looking at these facilities, what I'm looking at is, can it just provide a need or does it have the ability to grow?

3:31:46 And if we want it to grow so that we can grow the programs or, you know, add additional programs or grow the current program, what does that facility need to look like? And is that the proper place for it? Is it the proper size for it? What needs to be done to that for future? So I guess I just, you know, we've been band-aiding things and we've been moving along at status quo for so long. I'm just, you know, I like to look.

3:32:15 at the future, which I guess is what, you know, we're supposed to be doing here, and what does that look like? So that's what I would be, I'm looking at as I'm moving forward. I don't know, maybe are you guys doing something different? No. I think that's the way to look at it. So do we just take this and between Betsy and I and I'll, since Pat put this together, I'll maybe work with Pat, I'll, you know, put this together and then Pat can add some things if she sees.

3:32:51 Things that I missed. And then we send it out to all of you to see if there's anything we missed and then we get it to Stu. I think that's true. That's right. You know, I think that the charts, we can, you know, pull out the charts and we can, you know, Stu can probably scan those and put those out there. And then we can just take the...

3:33:17 What question? I'll just ask you. Well, the table that I'm finding was fascinating is the one on 66, the implementation schedule, which has to do with prioritization for park and recreation services. And it shows what was needed for 2006 and then how many extra after that in time incrementally. But I'm assuming that that was based on proposed or expected population growth.

3:33:44 So I'd rather see, and I didn't see one in here anywhere, I'd rather see one that shows me what the current population is and what the... On the preceding page 65, it does project 2010 8,500 residents. Right, which is about where we are. About where we are, yeah. The other thing is the summary of the next steps. I have these paper clips on a lot of things that I felt was important but I didn't necessarily pull out.

3:34:19 Summary and next steps. Prepare a feasibility master plan for each of the town's parks and other potential park areas to assess alternatives for new facilities and parkland expansions. This includes analysis of program feasibility, consideration of each facility's role in comprehensive and linked park and recreation system and developing there. Anyways, to help determine park usage, develop and implement an on-site user survey.

3:34:48 They should distinguish between residents and visitors, maximize existing parks by completing the trails and park and ice rink, as well as other recommendations for ADA and safety improvements, and through a public process with the Town Tourism and Recreation Commission prioritize recommendations for new facilities presented in this plan, and work to develop policy recommendations to assure adequate budgeting.

3:35:11 So anyways, you know, I don't know. I think that in our summary, I would add that to summary and next steps to this, but that would be the conversation that we would have when we're all said and done is this still what we're looking at in our summary and next steps. I don't know. Is that fair? That's where it goes. Okay. So to recap, you guys are going to finish this up, pass it around to us, and we're going to see if we see any omissions.

3:35:44 You'll give it to Stu, he'll post it. Well, he can check it out, too. Read it and make sure that he's comfortable with what it says. Right. And then we'll move on next time to the trails system master plan. Unfortunately, what that means for you volunteers, and if you need any of my time, let me know if there's something I can do. I'm more than happy to help. Well, I'm not sure that one of you guys shouldn't.

3:36:17 Do the synopsis on that because you guys are on the MLT SCC. Except that we need the synopsis to get the things that aren't already listed in Terry's table listed here.

3:36:41 From that plan, or do we do that at that meeting? We could do it afterwards. We could have the conversation and say, yes, this is what we want to have added, kind of like we did today. Are we comfortable with adding that? Yeah. And, you know, if I have time, I'll go through it as well. That doesn't mean that, you know, because I think it's nice for all of us to go through these things because we all have a little bit different items from one of those. And so that's why I was asking you guys.

3:37:08 From what Pat put together and what I put together, because it's the only two pieces of print that I have, is there anything else that you see? So if you guys take the stuff home and you see something that maybe was missed, then let me know and I can add it. So, if that works. I like what you're suggesting too about that table on page 66.

3:37:32 It's a good piece of information. It is a good piece of information, yeah. Okay, so that's, you know, just another chart that I think we were going to ask the students. Just a scan and, yeah. Yeah. The one on page 66. Yeah, because it really lays out what, in terms of, especially in terms of the municipal side, it lays out where we should be and where we actually are today. So maybe we want to actually identify the tables that we want.

3:38:01 Do the scan and add to, I think we're adding, we're including the tiers as far as the needs assessment goes, so I don't know that that needs to be a separate scan. The types of facility and possible locations, is that something that we want to? You know, I think that I'd like to deal with the prioritization before we start dealing with possible locations. So do we want to just, well, if we're putting the whole thing together, though, do we want to have it?

3:38:41 It was page 23. And then here's page 24 is property and venue size and square footage. So on page 24, Sean, is property and venue size and square footage and a bunch of different identified properties. And then there's current programs that we were offering at the time. I don't know that we want to.

3:39:19 You know, I don't think we need the 24, the thing that's on 24, that has to do with specific events. What? Yeah, I don't know, I would, you know, because events, you know, I know we're not getting into prioritization. I would have to guess how it's going to be up there, and that may not be a bad thing for us, but we're not talking about locations for quite a while.

3:39:49 And we can certainly call out all of the different tables that are in here because each one of the tables provides us with information. So maybe we just ask him to pull out and post all the tables. And also that map. The map is good. Yeah, that would be... Which map there's some of all the facilities? That was also good. Yeah, sure it is.

3:40:42 These bullet points, I don't know whether I pulled them out, I'll write them out, but I had them paper clipped and I have it highlighted. It is these factors that should be considered with selecting locations for expansions. Proximity of parks and recreation facilities, town residents, feasibility of expanding or adding needed improvements to existing facilities.

3:41:09 Parks, Affordability and Availability of Land, Compatibility with Neighboring Land Uses. These might be some other points that are just bullet points that are in here that it's on page 48 that might be beneficial. And then there's the activities. Here's the location and existing and potential. So I don't know that that needs to be put in here right now, but I think that would be helpful in the end. Kind of as, you know, this is what was looked at.

3:41:44 You know, I think we almost just need to bring this with us each time so that we can reference back to the, because you don't go more than two pages without something in here that we're going to need to go back and look at. So instead of having Stu pull this all out, we don't need to waste this time. Just bring this with you each time so that we can go back and look at the tables. And when you make a comment, if it's on a table, please reference by the page number, even though you know that I'm not organized enough to make that happen for myself.

3:42:12 Okay, that works. Okay, we need to end this thing. Yeah, I'm good with that. A few guys are good with that. So, I will close the meeting. Do we have any public comment? We chased everybody off.