TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2013

Trails Committee

· recording 3 hr 5 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

427 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 I don't want to get into that like I don't know yet.

0:04 I said that they need to know.

0:06 Oh, I am too.

0:07 You know, I have to say, there's a little bit of a scary moment, of course, with her.

0:11 And I think it's dangerous.

0:13 Past that, as long as that doesn't be known about.

0:16 Every year, I know this year's specialties.

0:18 Well, I know.

0:19 Yes.

0:20 That's what John said.

0:22 I can't tell you how to do it.

0:23 But they need it.

0:24 That's the stuff they need.

0:25 Okay.

0:26 Got it.

0:27 I'll go to the polls.

0:28 There's a full legislation.

0:29 Thank you.

0:29 Thank you.

0:45 Yes, I mean, that would by far be the best place to pass something, but John has made it very clear. Even when we downscale it to, like, a thousand people, you know, by the exchange. So even if we wanted to even think about it, it's exactly right. This is going to result in permanent recruitment on the ground, but we shouldn't be a force, we shouldn't be a committee.

1:09 I understand that I'm thinking of all the things I've had over the years and how that's changed. It's gone back and forth. Honestly,

1:31 Usually when it goes one way, it goes too far. And it might go the other way, it goes too far. There's always, you know, reverting to the building. I thought we had gone through the slogans here that, you know, maybe trying to get something done.

1:52 It's okay. I think that's why we just need to inform this group right now. We're starting to investigate. We're not going down this road. Which project are we talking about? Consultants are coming in. Bill's project. My project. My project. My project. You know how I get internet in here? Yes. And is there a password? There is a password.

2:22 Because I'm going to use Google Word. Yes. For discussion, I'm sure. Okay. Trying to keep it brief. Okay. I think I have a little thing set up here that should facilitate discussion. Well, the nice thing is, is that there's always stuff to do on this, but there's too confused. Oh, just do it. We've got to be done with the content. Yeah.

2:51 Yeah, I know, that's my feeling. It's going to be moving on. Well, this is a 15 minute event. I hope so. Can we, John's presentation? I'm, I'm training. Oh, are you really doing the, we're instructing? No, the active event. Oh, okay. Training. Uh, what I was going to say was, that's pretty exciting. It was awesome. It's so good, there's just so much detail. You know, as soon as we get.

3:16 So, tomorrow is digital. Can I call you? We're okay.

3:34 I'll pull my camera...

3:36 Ten o'clock, I think...

3:38 Ten o'clock I think is...

3:39 Let's see...

3:40 For how long?

3:42 Ten?

3:43 Two hours.

3:44 When did it summer?

3:45 Ah, man.

3:46 I see a great...

3:47 Point of style issue...

3:48 Point of style is...

3:49 Just stand...

3:50 I see where it is...

3:51 They're going to be wrapping up.

3:53 I see...

3:55 Just before 10? And it doesn't carry over. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. They need to stay. Well, Bill says we're going to be here. But in any case, I don't know. I'll ask our coordinator. Yeah, because we're just going to start. Oh, there is. Oh, there is. There are a lot. All right. Mr. Coordinator. Thank you so much.

4:26 Good to see you. Is this on? On? Yeah, that's on. All right, with Mr. Salazar arriving, let's go ahead and call to order this meeting of the regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. Roll call, please. Stu Brown. Yeah. Sandy Hogan. Here. Bill Salazar. Yes. First Chair Bill Taylor. Here. And Chair Sean Turner. And I am present. Okay. Okay.

5:00 At this time, let's go ahead and ask for any public comments that are not otherwise on the agenda. Mr. McFarron. Morning, everybody. Actually, it's afternoon. It is afternoon. I just wanted to give a real quick update on a couple of things in partnership with John here. I think we're going to do a little plumbing out there for you.

5:23 Okay. Okay. Okay. First is, I put a couple things down on your desks. First one is actually a trails report. Our Lakes Basin stewards have started, and one thing that we've committed to do is each week we're providing a report on the condition of trails in and around Mammoth. These trail reports are at the Visitor Center. They're on our website.

5:52 They've been sent also to Monaco County Tourism to pass around. And if you'll notice, it includes all aspects of front country recreation around the Mammoth area, from Convict up to Obsidian Dome, roads, trails, as much as our stewards can get to in a week. I also wanted to give you a little update on uniforms. Our stewards are going to be wearing, as we discussed, green vests with the...

6:19 MLTS logo. I'm actually running over to Designs Unlimited right after this to get the patch made. John was able to provide you with the high res image to get those patches actually made. And then they're also going to have our friends in the Inyo in partnership with the Inyo National Forest on the other side. So it will be on both sides. Can I ask you a question about that? Yeah. So you're saying one side is MLTSCC and the other side is

6:46 FOI or? And Forest Service. And Forest Service. Okay. All right. Thank you. And then, you know, one thing is just a funny thing. The best question our stewards have encountered since they started was, number one, why are you carrying a shovel? And then number two is, how far is the lake? I counted it up. We've been asked that 35 times. So the lake could be much loud. It could be even horseshoe. It's right there.

7:13 George goes down the list. Or that mysterious Mammoth Lake. Yeah, one of those mysterious Mammoth Lakes. And once again, this weekend, you know, Mammoth, the community, proves that they show up. 51 people came out to the Panorama Delo Project, which is amazing. We had six FOI staff, two staff with MLTPA, and John from the Forest Service came out to represent the Land Management Agency. And then, Bill, you were there as well.

7:43 Yeah, I was there. I'm sorry. I was there. Sandy was there. Great. And we had two council members there, Matthew Lehman and Joe Bacon. Awesome. Thanks so much. I was in the Whites actually doing another National Channel State project that day. So we had 51 volunteers, and they got one and a half miles of the Panorama Dome Trail cut back into the ground. In addition to that, a mile and a half of maintenance on hiking and biking trails in that Panorama System.

8:11 We finished the 12B connector. The new trails now connect to the now improved Panorama Dome trailhead. 40 pounds of trash were picked up. A lot of that was around Twin Lakes. And 114 MLTS logo signs were put up and down the bike path. Great. So once again, Mammoth shows up. Thank you very much for... Can I ask you a couple of questions? Yeah. Can I ask you a couple of questions? Yeah, sure. 114 trail signs were put up. How many more still need to go up?

8:39 Yeah, this is for John, who managed that part of the project. Okay, before you stop waiting. Do you have a schedule? You were going to provide a schedule. What I handed you earlier, I got ahead of myself as always. One is the Mammoth Lakes Trail Report for the last two weeks, and beyond that is the schedule of SOS projects in bold. And the SOS projects are in bold italics. What we did when we were planning for this is we went to Monmouth County Tourism as well as other local websites.

9:09 Called all the local events we could to figure out where we could fit our days in. So what you see here is a full list of the events we could find going on, as well as our SOS days, which are in bold italics. And then at the bottom of this, on the back of the second page, is our 2013 interpretive hike schedule, which will kick into full gear that first week of July. And we've got trips running Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday.

9:38 And Mondays, both day and night activities. Paul, I guess I was asking for the schedule of when the interpretive people with vests are going to be up at. That's what I'm looking for is... That's what I'm looking for, every day but Wednesday. Okay, so, and are there two people on... Two people on staff, they'll be up there every day but Wednesday. Okay. On Wednesday, what we're actually going to be doing is having some of my crew work with folks from the IMACA...

10:07 YCC, Youth Conservation Corps, doing trail maintenance in the Lakes Basin on Wednesdays. And what are the hours that somebody's up there? The hours of people that are up there are, it depends on if they're doing a night hike, but in general they're up there from 8 to 6. 8 to 6 p.m. And essentially do they stand right there at the horseshoe or are they always moving? No, they roam around. Unless they have a set interpretive activity to be at, they're going to be on a trail or in a car moving around.

10:36 Across that whole area. Okay, but primarily at the trail heads themselves, or are they actually? At the trail heads and on the trails. I mean, literally, they're walking them. You know, we have had, I think I added up 35 trees our stewards have already cut out since the year started. So they're out actually moving around talking with people. They don't stand in one place unless they're waiting for a hike. Talking to people and carrying a tool, obviously. Talking to people and carrying a tool.

11:04 Before us, there was rangers used to do. Yeah. Yeah. No, and I just want to make sure that, you know, I feel like it's important that we do reach those people that are at the trailhead somewhat confused saying how far away is the lake. So, you know, they're the ones that obviously I feel like need to have somebody reached out to. So while I know that they do need to be roaming the trails and such, a big part of it is getting them away from their cars, away from the parking lot. Well, one thing we hope to build this program into, it's been something.

11:34 On our minds for a long time, but it's actually set up a number of easy ups and build a volunteer corps of folks who are willing to sit in those on busy weekends at Horseshoe, Purple, and just provide information. So we're going to kick that off in a small way this year by putting on an interpretive training for folks who'd like to do interpret tours, mostly focused on consolidated mine and horseshoe geology.

12:01 And we hope from that to get a growing number of people who were trained up, invested in the lakes basin, and then kick off this idea of, you know, a lakes basin ambassador or a host program. We didn't build it into our program this year, but it's something for the future. And, you know, you're right, that's where a lot of the confused people are at the beginning. Yeah, it is. That's where I feel like we could do the most amount. And if that's something that, you know, this committee may want to consider,

12:28 Is some kind of easy upstation program that is either there near Poconovi where you get people just as they're passing up or all the way up there at Horseshoe that is kind of a destination that is just there in the parking lot. I mean, it's great that we've got volunteers that are moving around from site to site, but it might be worth it to consider something for future years. I think so, especially right at the entranceway. You know, we've got that large parking area now where the...

12:58 The bike trail ends when you come in there. That would be a place to station somebody because then you get them right as they come in. So, yeah, I think it would be a really valuable program. Paul, when your stewards are doing the interpretations, using consolidated mine as an example, do you have a script for them? Yes. Are they operating on? No, we have a set script that actually was developed in partnership with the Forest Service, Lawson and Carroll.

13:25 And there are a couple volunteers that do it now. Noel and Jay Dyken are a couple of them. So that's the script we're using. We'd be more than happy to sit down with you guys and get some more background on it. I can find the script we have and pass it along to them. I'd love to see the script for that and any of the other interpretive walks that they're doing. That's the one we have a script for. The other ones have been created by the stewards themselves.

13:52 So, but that one, because we're going to try to focus more volunteers on, we have a set script, and the stops on that one are really, it's not like wildflowers where they change, the stuff's there, thankfully. People love it. Oh, can you email that to me?

14:06 Yes. And then I can distribute it. Well, Paul, thank you very much for your reports, because I think those are really helpful, and I feel like that's one of the best places that we can reach our visitors. And I'll be real curious to find out what the winner is for the number one or top three questions asked is going to be. So far, why a shovel? Then where's the lake? I'm sure we'll find some good ones. I'm sure there will be. Okay, thanks a lot. Thanks, Paul. Yeah, thanks, Paul. It was a great event this Saturday. Glad to see you guys out there. Hope to see you.

14:38 All of you up there at one of the events this summer, there's five left, so your chits are getting short. Let's see, a couple things, I just want to thank the sponsors and emphasize the importance of getting the community involved in this trail system. I went down to Footloose, I think two or three different staff meetings and several other mountain biking folks and said, look, these mountain bikes need your help. This is something that I think you guys care about. Sure enough, they show up and you gauge the community with this system.

15:08 It's critically important. And it showed up in terms of how many people showed up on Saturday. I prepared for Steve a couple of ideas about, you may have some funds left. I'm not entirely sure where you guys are at with your pot. But for example, the Panorama Dome Trails, now that all this trail work has been done, temporary signage, you could probably use about eight signs up there. I've worked.

15:34 Talk with Friends of the Inyo. We've got a very simple program figured out that could have a consistent kind of temporary signage program. Four by four posts, very simple wooden plaque with an MLTS logo and an arrow pointing places. Those kinds of things can be needed over the course of the summer. Probably need eight panorama dome, probably another eight or so for the Mountain View Trail, the Earthquake Dome Trail perhaps. And if you had money and you could enhance it to Friends of the Inyo's budget, then they could route it up, make that stuff happen, just be a good consistent program for that.

16:03 There's also a bunch of other things on the list I've prepared. And Steve, I think, has hopefully helped me today as you get into your project list to identify where those opportunities are. But certainly, the website now needs an update for the Panaramba Dome area. We now have new trails on the ground. We've got new information to share with the public. So that's not something that's currently in the website content management budget. So that's something as you guys build new things, new things that have to be put on the site.

16:29 That's all. You guys got a lot of work today, so I'll sit down. It was a very successful event. Thanks to everybody who showed up. I think it was the biggest turnout ever so far. But everything that we can all do to really get the community invested in this system is going to be the best for all of us. Thank you. John, the website update, would that not be included in the regular maintenance contract with the website?

16:53 We're going to get an update on that later. Sure. The way the website maintenance contract is structured, because there's no way of anticipating when new infrastructure is going to come online. It was structured in such a way that should new infrastructure come online, depending on what it is, a budget can be put together advising you guys, okay, this is now done, this now needs a page, and I can work with Ray and come back to the proposal and say, look, to do this is going to cost about X.

17:20 But there's no money in that. The current website management contract, there's no money in there to do new pages for anything, but certainly not for new capital stuff. So when the college connector goes in, that will need a page. And I'm not sure where the money comes from for that. I have some questions along those lines as well, but let's save that for our agenda number six. Thank you, John. Thank you. Can I make a public comment? Sure enough.

17:42 Please. So I want to echo that Saturday was awesome. I mean, it was great. I think 52 people showed up, and it was a lot of enthusiasm, and they got a lot of work, and it actually looks like mountain bike trails now, and you can tell where the hiking trail is, and everybody just did a great job, so the place looks much better, and that just, I hope we can do, keep having those huge turnouts and even grow up on it. It's pretty impressive, so great kickoff. I just wanted to echo that we could use some signs there.

18:10 And that would really help get people figuring out which trails are the mountain bike trails. We're going to see proliferation of trails in that area if we don't really designate them. And there's still a couple of trail segments where it's hard to follow even after we scratched it. It's just so wide open after the fuel reduction project. And I'd like to make sure, you know, if the committee decides to

18:33 Put money towards trails there. You know, the Forest Service is there to support. We'd like to be involved in the design of this temporary trail sign that we want to put together for both earthquake fall, uptown, downtown, and the Panarama Dome. So, thanks. Can I ask a question after three people who made public comments? You know, it sounds like we had great turnout on Saturday. Why do you think it was so much better than before? Root beer. He likes the answer. You are now kissing what?

19:03 Thanks for advertising again. He's quick. It was a chill group here. Even better. Good. I'm glad it came out of the cold box. I think there's a couple things. This program is now in its fifth year. So people know what this program is. It's been going on for a long time. They sort of anticipate it. They see it come in to get ready for it. The second thing is the direct connection of a user group to something that they really cared about, trails that they really loved. I think that made a huge difference.

19:31 And I think, you know, just a good community-based marketing campaign, a lot of getting a lot of people using the available tools, radio advertising, all kinds of other things. And again, this is the fifth year of this program. People know what it is. They know what to expect. We've got a lot of regulars showing up. I think the mountain biking community really turned out for this because they really care about those trails and want to see those things, you know, get back to the shape that they're in. Just so you know, I just passed around a photograph that you posted or emailed.

19:59 Congratulate Kaz on all the good work on the trail. Oh, yeah. Well, it's a great opportunity to see the Forest Service in uniform with the shield on after putting in a rock trail designation at a trailhead. I mean, it's a great opportunity for everybody to show what everybody's capable of doing. Saturday was a great opportunity to do all that. Great. Thank you. I know we've had a long public comments, but I think that was all important stuff. Is there another? I apologize.

20:28 I realize you want to keep it to five minutes, and I will try to do it. My name is Mary Kay. Some of you know me. And I'm here about restoring the old Blue Diamond roots. Just a tiny bit of background on this. About five years ago or so, I mean, we've been in the process for quite a little while, we noticed that a lot of the Blue Diamond roots, which a lot of people ski and a lot of people snowshoe, were losing their signs. And so we started picking up these signs that dropped off and collected probably over a hundred of the things.

20:58 And so it has not been a project to put these things back or to keep up the old roots. And the roots, as Bill Taylor knows, were put up sometime in the, I guess, mid-70s. I think you were in the Forest Service at that time? Early 80s. Early 70s. Early 80s. Early 80s, okay. And Sue Fairley was the other person, was an intern who's now with the Forest Service, was also part of the project. So as a Sierra Club Recreation...

21:25 Person, I was very interested in, not only me, but a lot of people were very interested in restoring them and getting the roots back on the maps, the winter recreation maps, because year after year I've collected the recreation maps, I guess starting in maybe 93 or something like that. Every about two or three years, roots would disappear off the root maps, and it was becoming less and less important to put these things on and show people.

21:54 That there were existing routes. Well, the thing of it is, we've got such beautiful groomed trail skiing everywhere now in the lake space, and it's fantastic, and you just can't beat it. But this is a totally different, unique experience. It's being off groomed trails, going into all kinds of terrain, and getting stuck sometimes, but knowing that if a storm comes up, you've got those blue diamonds, those routes to help guide you back.

22:23 And keep you sometimes en route. And it's really fun tracking them. So about three years ago, I guess it was, we asked MLTPA when they were doing all the GPSing of the trails to GPS the existing Blue Diamonds, which they did. And I've got, Steve got the map for me and it's wonderful. We've got everything that MLTPA did with their very expert equipment. Well this winter, I and about four or five other people went out and did our GPSing also.

22:52 The same routes, but doing it a little differently, plotting where things were not, where there's big gaps in some of these things. And the five major areas that we thought we wanted to start with, I should preface this by saying that I'd had a talk with John Riegelberger on a bus going up to the mountain in January, and he said, are you guys still interested in keeping this project going? And I said, absolutely, and there's a lot of people that are really interested. So we GPSed it this winter.

23:19 And the five main areas that we would like to start with, and we have John's permission, we just don't have a written agreement yet, and I think John Kaczmierski is going to help us with that at some point. The five main areas that we want to reestablish and put the missing blue diamonds back up, and possibly slight changes but not much, the obsidian dome area, the top of the knolls,

23:46 Going from the Visitor Center all the way over to the Scenic Loop. The areas in the Lakes Basin I don't think we're going to touch because there's so much trail skiing there and it also goes into the wilderness and we can't, they think they don't want to have signs up in the wilderness. So we're probably not going to touch that. So let's see, oh Earthquake Dome is another fabulous route that goes around the dome and then it connects down to Route C.

24:16 And let's see, the one coming from the mountain. Bill, you probably know the one coming from the mountain. Yeah, God. It's, well, anyway, it's. I don't remember. C is the one out of the cinder shed. I don't remember. Well, tell you what, we need to move on. And so if I could just ask you. Okay, this is, yeah, if you want to ask some questions, go ahead. I've got lots of information on it, but I think we're in a good place to probably get the Forest Service written agreement going and putting up the Blue Diamond. Some of them this summer. Well, this is something that we want to.

24:45 Discuss further at another time, or? Just to keep you updated, I don't really think there's anything that... And it's on our... Yeah, I might point out, Sean, that it is on our tracking. Yeah. And so I asked Mary Kay if she'd come for public comment to just explain where she is to date and then have an opportunity to talk with Kazmerski to move it forward so... And I was just going to add that the updates will be good and then at some point when we think it's appropriate, then we really need to talk about how we...

25:14 Interface that information with the website. Make sure that as we add to the system that we're keeping track of everything. Then we won't have the same problem we had last time where everything starts to disappear. The other one important thing is the mapping, the winter mapping, and I don't know how often that's going to be done now anymore. It doesn't come out, the maps don't come out every year.

25:40 It used to be every other year, although lately I think it's been going three and four before they've been produced. Yeah. But that would be an ideal thing is to have all these roots because they haven't been for quite a while. Once they're up and tagged, right? Yeah, right. Exactly. Yeah. So hopefully we'll do some of that stuff this summer. Let's talk about that, Mary, because we actually need to reproduce it for this coming year. Oh. We're out of our old maps we ran out this year. Okay. It's time to make a new one.

26:09 Excellent. Then we can talk about it when we meet with you and find out about the agreement. Great. Are you working at all with Fred Richter? I know that was one of his dreams. He was retired from the Forest Service in the 90s. I know it was, too. There are a lot of people out there that this is a favorite project. Exactly. Yeah, there's a lot of them. So I know we've got a lot of volunteer help. Good. Great. Okay. Thank you. Any other public comments then? Let's go on.

26:43 To business matter, actually I guess we're going to talk about the consent agenda. Anything that anyone would like pulled from the consent agenda? I had something on the first one, May the 6th. So do we want to pull and discuss the May 6th minutes? Chair, maybe Sandy can just tell us what the issue is and we can correct it and still approve both of them. Yes, that's true. On page 3 at the very bottom,

27:21 I think I asked to have it noted that I opposed that only because there was not a current budget presented. Say that again, Sandy? Oh, on opposed? Yes, on the opposed. I think I just wanted that noted. Yes, I'm sorry. That note then would we... Because, opposed because of a lack of a current budget presented. Lack of current budget. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then I just had a question on page, the next page. It almost...

27:55 All of the next items just said no action taken. And I know actually what happened there was we stopped and we just postponed everything until the next meeting. So I was, I don't know if we just need to note that. Rather than, you know, going through each agenda item, just saying the following items were postponed. Just a suggestion for the future. Yeah, if it works. Yeah. Save a little paper. One second. I'm good.

28:24 That's all. So your suggestion is just in the future to just instead of saying no action taken, just moved. Yes. Okay. You know, the remainder of the agenda was moved. Was moved to the next meeting or something. I'm fine with that. I don't know if it's... Okay. I'll move to approve as amended. Okay. Second. That's what I'm looking for. Okay. Those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Was there a second on that? I'm sorry? Stu. Stu. Yeah. Thank you, Stu. Got the fire in there.

28:57 And that's for both sets of meetings? Yes. Minutes? Yep. Thank you. Okay, Steve, would you please update us on staff and MLTS coordinator hours? Right. So this is a continuing item on the agenda. The top part is unchanged, that chart. The bottom chart has been updated to reflect the month of May added to it.

29:29 So you can see that the staff box, we've totaled approximately 54 hours at $5,400 expense. And then the coordinator position is $9,906 to date for a total combination of $15,300. So we're on target. We still have money left in the coordinator contract.

29:57 That top-out amount was like $14,000, so it should more than cover us for our June meeting minutes and whatever we need to do. And even if we should decide to have a second meeting in June, we'll probably have enough money to cover it. And then after that, the contract is over on June 30th. It should be being renegotiated now, right? Because we have made approval for...

30:25 It's an additional year. That was in our funding. Your recommendation is to approve it as reflected in the master tracker. That will go to the recreation commission tomorrow and town council on the 19th. But to your point, it couldn't hurt to have those discussions a little early. I would like to see seamless. Mr. Chair, if I might, one other recommendation. This staff report is really very important.

30:55 However, I see no reason why we shouldn't just add it to the consent on future agendas. I don't think we need to have Steve get up there and quote. We could save some time, and if we had questions, we could pull it from consent. So my recommendation would be that we add the consultant and staff support page to the consent. Good idea. That's not a bad idea. Yep. Now that it's systematic.

31:21 No, I think that's good. It's systematic. Yep. Perfect. I am pleased that this is presented at the beginning of the meeting, though. Yes. And that makes natural sense, then, to just add it to the consensus. Absolutely. If everyone is comfortable with that via consensus, let's just make that so for future meetings. Very good. Thank you. Any further questions, then, since this is a business item on that business matter? Okey-doke. Number four. Update on master tracking list and U.S. Forest Service SOPA list.

31:51 Yeah, what I'd like to do on this, if I might, is again direct our attention to the master tracking list supplement, which is the suggestions for programmatic and physical project implementation. Member Hogan offered some edits that I've put in red so that we can see where there have been changes or additions, and I think that...

32:17 For those changes and additions, it makes a little more clear our relationship with the Forest Service and how projects are coming forward in both the programmatic and in the built type proposals. And as we go forward with our discussions on the master tracker, I think that we will be referring back then to this implementation schedule as a guideline to help the committee to direct staff.

32:45 Direct proponents as to a process by which we will evaluate, which we will come forward with budgets, staff reports, etc. I have a question actually on page 2B2. Thank you. And it really gets down to how we address projects when they're brought forward. You know, Steve, going back to ancient history when we were planners,

33:16 And making findings. I think we need to sort of have that same sort of process where we can say that it is consistent with the objectives of the committee. It is consistent with the trail system master plan or other approved plans of the town. It is consistent with the objectives and requirements of whatever the funding source is. Because if it's Measure R, it's different than general fund. It's different than Measure U. It's different than grants. So that we can actually

33:46 Sort of be systematic about how we're approving projects and just documenting what the decision process is. I think you have most of those points in there under B2B, but just make sure we have those and we're actually making specific. Make the findings statement. How we're actually meeting those. I think that's very important. Thank you. And maybe, yeah, and maybe put it under 2E.

34:18 To approve the project, including the consistency. That would clarify it, too. Say that again, Sandy? Under 2E, you can just add, you know, before, et cetera, consistency. And that would, adding it where Bill said and then right there, that kind of underlines. I think he actually has most of the items that I'd written down into be

34:45 And it's just what I want to start seeing is this thing is actually do that now. Yes. Yes. Yes. Exactly. It's great. My only question on the ones in red which are coming from you is the project is routed to the UFSF to those guys. Actually, that would only happen if it was a for-service project, right? Yeah. We aren't going to automatically run everything to the for-service. Nope.

35:20 Only the ones that Forest Service holds sway over. Right. Yeah. So add, um, I don't know, on those on National Forest. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So in this place, we put Forest Service down there to you if it's... Did these look good to you, Tom? Appropriate. The red, that's... Or, so it's either Town of Mammoth Lake Public Works or... Or it could be BLM or it could be Mono County or it could be...

35:48 I don't think we need to listen to everybody just so that the idea is there that it's going to move through the proper government channels. Which may be a more adequate way of putting it. Instead of putting it on or UFSF, just appropriate governmental channels. We're probably not going to go through other ones. Yeah, I don't know. There may be times. On UFSF land probably. But essentially what you're suggesting there is all the way to B2G.

36:18 Essentially saying that the project is read through the U.S. Forest Service for development of the appropriate agreement on National Forest. Yeah, when necessary. We're outside the purview of this. Yeah. We could add also, or other agency with jurisdiction or authority. Let's add that as well as the, making it clear for projects that are outside our purview. I don't want to get too...

36:46 Wordy about it. The whole purpose is just to show that we're going to take it through a government process. Yeah. Not necessarily what branch of the government work. Yeah. Okay. So one more update there, Steve. That's fine. Yeah. Well, I appreciate the working too much because you took this on kind of. Oh, this is great. Started it off and since we made several changes, but they've all been appropriate. And if anything, it helps us decide what projects we're going to really spend time with. It's very complete. I mean, I just.

37:15 Yeah, I mean, it's wonderful to have actually the process lined out. So if somebody comes in, or anybody making one, you can just hand this to them. And especially, I really like the idea of two, which is either the program or the project, either one physical or built. But here, the staff report part. So that we really have some, you know, we've had oral

37:41 Things described, or we've had written things that might not be real clear, whatever, but I think an actual, something that gives us the hard information and data via a staff report, I think that's just great. Okay. Yes. So, any other suggestions on the supplement, or discussion on the supplement? I think, John, did he go down to get his packet? Was that it? Kazmierski? No, no. Because he didn't have the, he hadn't seen it, I guess. Yeah, because I just asked him about it.

38:12 Go on and talk about the Mammoth County list. Yeah, yeah. Anyway, if he has any problems or suggestions, he can give it to you. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. So one of the things I did want to point out with the master tracking list, I've moved it out of draft now into an actual title document. I've retitled it to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee Master Project and Budget Tracking List for fiscal year 2013-2014.

38:40 So in doing so, we've maintained a lot of the formatting. We have shifted some columns around. So what I've done is had the first column, which would be the approved funding for 2012-13. So that was the 292 that we have been working with. Then the next column is signed contracts based on that 292.

39:08 Column is mostly for your information to figure out how much have actually been paid out against those contracts. Then through our discussions we have the 2012-13 funds to carry over to 13-14. So those are monies that we've already talked about where we're going to shift that from completing the work this year to looking at completing it next year.

39:36 Then we have the next column, which is 2012-13 funds that are going to be reallocated to different projects in 2013-14. So those numbers are in blue. And if we look on the second page, we see that that totals up to approximately $43,000. And then if we look back across the page, that allocation is going to be determined by this committee. So that's how we'll figure out. Either confirmed or shifted, right.

40:06 That's how we'll figure out where those go to what projects. And then we've already discussed the 2012-2013 funds to carry over to future years. For instance, the Sharps discussions that we've had and the Lakes Basin discussions as well. So those are in green. And then finally, the last budget column is the recommended 2013-2014 fiscal year funding.

40:35 And that was the column that I was directed to balance out at exactly $300,000. And we were able to do that. And so that is then a brief discussion of the reorientation of the columns and how we are showing our accounting. So I think that it's appropriate for us to continue today. We have approximately an hour to talk about how to spend the $43,000.

41:03 That has yet to be decided. And then also to make final discussions or any recommendations for adjusting the $300,000 for next year. Present that then tomorrow to the Recreation Commission. Ask for their approval of the recommendations. And then finally move that forward to Town Council for approval on June 19th. Okay. So to be clear, it's the $43,000 that essentially were...

41:39 We're going forward with, this is the budget that's actually being presented tomorrow from the Creation Commission to Town Council, like you just said, but that we are still reviewing that $43,000 essentially. That's correct. Thank you. So in terms of process for this meeting, we have a request that, or it's not really a request, it's suggestions that John mentioned in public comment. So are we actually talking about trying to go through those now and amend this budget, or should we?

42:11 Approve this budget to go to the rec commission and then under and then save the allocation of the additional funds for I guess maybe item I guess I don't know how do you want to do that pleasure because we have allocated an hour for this discussion I think there's two ways of approaching it bill I think one is to continue as you remember the last time we were talking project by project by project we got through to the second page and

42:48 I think it was 551 Winter Grooming. And that's sort of where we left off at that time. So if it's your pleasure to continue those discussions and allocation for those projects beyond that, or to just accept this as it is printed, presented before you today, with the understanding that in the future meetings you will be discussing the appropriation of the $43,000 to select different projects.

43:16 That may or may not be included on the first two pages of your master tracking list. They may be on the third or fourth page. Or it may be something that's brought forward. I'm open. Yeah, that's what we need to decide here. There's a bunch of stuff on here that shows recommended in 13-14 in projects that we actually yet haven't talked about.

43:44 Right, and we talked about placeholders. We talked about them being placeholders. Right. Because we may not allocate that much money to MLTS grants. We don't know that yet. So if there are other needs that are above and beyond that, such as temporary signs on the Panorama Dome Trail or are leading to the cold root beer, that we then could move some of this money around. It seems to me that that was our intent.

44:14 Well, before we even go there, and you're right, Bill, because I believe that some of those were placeholders as well. I think the question that's before us is, you know, do we even want to tackle this today? I know we've budgeted 60 minutes here to discuss this, but I just want to make sure that we don't confuse the issue with regard to what is being presented tomorrow at the Recreation Commission and then going before Town Council. That's kind of what I think Bill is actually addressing too.

44:41 Because I was thinking the same thing. If we start making a bunch of changes, then it's harder to explain to the rec commission, to whatever. I think it would probably be better to do it as we did as a placeholder, but clearly stating that we understand that there are some things, and we probably will discuss them at our next meeting, that we want to fund immediately, like temporary signs, things like that. But that really, some of these...

45:10 You know, we're pretty sure we want to do them, but we haven't had that staff report, you know, that really clear outline of what it is so that we know what to fund. Well, and we haven't laid out potential sideboards that we want to put on the projects. We haven't talked in the direction we want to see the projects go. Well, then I'll make a motion that we forward the, you know, whatever, tracking list. Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee Master Project and Budget Tracking List for Fiscal Year 2002.

45:42 13, 2014, dated June 3, 2013, as it is to the Recreation Commission as a recommendation for funding. I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Is there any further discussion? And we do have a comment from the audience, but before we even go there. Yeah. Yeah, I'd like to discuss it here as well. Sandy, why don't you go first then? Well, exactly. I think just mainly that we should clarify.

46:12 And you guys will clarify to the rec commission tomorrow that even though there's 43,000, you know, and we haven't specifically assigned it, we do know that some of these, they just need a little more discussion and specificity to them. We know some, there are a couple of them that haven't even popped up that just like a panorama dome signs, earthquake fault, temporary signs. So as long as that's made clear, because otherwise I know a lot of people get antsy about, you know, we haven't assigned that really.

46:41 But I think you guys can clarify. That's the great thing about it, just going forward. Yeah, and my comments would go along the same lines. We need to clarify that and clarify that we haven't finished, that we're comfortable with this as is, but we haven't finished prioritizing or bucketizing everything that's on our list. And there may be things that take priority over stuff that is on this funding, and that funding may well get moved. And so would we then, for the purposes of today's meeting,

47:09 Have a little more discussion about that under item 11. Just make sure we know what we're at. Yeah, if we get all the way to 11, that's a good idea. Well, if we're going to postpone this, we better have time. Yeah. Yeah, the only thing I would say is to clarify, it seems to be the hot word here, to clarify the clarification, is to reduce any ambiguity. So, I mean, if we want to say that this is still kind of a...

47:42 You know, work in progress or whatever budget it is. So if we take item number one at $31,900 for, you know, staff, is that amount approved to go ahead and start contracting with Steve or is it not? So I mean, so I don't, do you expect staff to come up for every item? I mean, I think that's just the clarity. So I mean, once council approves this budget, you know, talking from a town's point of view,

48:11 You know, we want to obviously have a seamless transition. How do you want the community to kind of handle those items? Is it a, do we have a policy? How do you want to address that? My understanding, please correct me if I got that wrong, was that the numbers that we recommended are the recommendations for those items, and it's only the 43,000. Right. That's unknown. And so we're not, we're not intending to do that. So I just want to make sure that that's.

48:35 Is that the case? Well, that's a good question. So I just want to clarify, because I think I'll give you my take on that case. The 319 is something that was actually above the original, and we actually had a motion and passed specifically that item. And anything that we have passed as a singular item, I have no problem with saying that is what's going to be spent. So for that amount, personally, I have no problem with that amount going forward.

49:03 We also took a vote and passed on the... I've got to put my glasses back on. SOS. On the Summer of Stewardship Days. So those should be able to go to contract. But all the others where we just said, yes, we think this is what we want to spend, but have not dealt with them, or made a motion, those numbers are placeholders. Let's Basin Stewards is one of those. The website content is one. Hold on just a second. Yeah, because I guess what you...

49:33 What you're asking for is clarification because you're right, town staff needs to do that, but I think we did stop at about 511 or 551. We have not yet discussed 551. And my concern there is that, you know, Mammoth, Nordic, Winter Grooming is going to see this pass, but then if we are not clear that that's not been passed on a specific basis, that they will view that as money being taken away if we decide to revisit that.

49:58 I do have a little bit of a comment on that particular item if we want to discuss it. I've outreached to Mammoth Nordic on at least three occasions, invited them to be here today, and I was told that they would be here today. I was also told that they may not, and this is...

50:17 Somewhat unofficial, but it was verbal at the time that they may not be requesting funding in the future, but it was put in as a placeholder for discussion and so forth. And due to the fact they're not here today, we haven't received a formal proposal from them, I would assume that that request is not being made at this time. Well, then I think what we are going to need, and to Stu's point, as far as clarification goes, starting there at 551, that...

50:46 All those numbers there are in the recommended 2013-14, but essentially we just moved those there, who I would say is placeholders as well. So we need those listed like in pink or green. Well, we want asterisk against them. So maybe for the items on the first page, I think they've been approved, right, because obviously we're committing funds and we're moving forward with the challenge cost share with the Forest Service. So the first page should be right.

51:11 And then is it the funds from 551 down that we have an asterisk to and we just have Steve mark the asterisk as approved but pending further review? Not all of them because some we did. We approved the website. We approved the Lakes Basin Stewards Program. So those two don't need the asterisks. So that was my question to Steve. Yeah. You've got the official record. Can you go back and asterisk everything we haven't made a specific motion on? Sure we can.

51:38 And then do that identification in the presentation that we make tomorrow. In our notes, I think it really shows. The one thing about 551, obviously, we couldn't award it until they do an end-of-the-season report anyway because that's always a required step. And it's a winter thing. Let's just talk about the process here for a second rather than actually

52:00 So what we've got before us right now is a motion in a second, and we're having some discussion that may change that motion in a second, and we still haven't heard from John Kazmerski or the audience yet. But I think that the discussion that we're going is to put an asterisk, if I'm getting this right, by the items that we have not formally voted on, that these are placeholders. What was the word? Recommended funding. Okay.

52:29 A placeholder for recommended funding, but we will be reviewing it on an individual basis, but this way that it can go forward to the Recreation Commission tomorrow and then after that to the Town Council, just as a straight, clean recommendation with those asterisks. Now, because the recreation meeting is tomorrow, I think we're going to want to put those asterisks by those items right now.

52:53 I'm not comfortable with it. It's in their packet, though. We could spend a few minutes. I think we can do this pretty quickly. I think we can. Now, before we actually go to those asterisks, just because I am seeking comment on the current motion and second the two. What I was going to suggest was, why don't we withdraw the motion and the second and we'll reconfigure them after we're done with this. Okay. May I take the comments from the audience? John, did you have anything that you want to say?

53:22 I think you guys are on the right track. The only thing I would add is we talked about it a little bit last time. Clearly the list shows that there's more demand for funding than what's been allocated. And originally when we started this committee, we knew that $300,000 a year wouldn't get everything we needed. So just think about how you frame another Measure R request like we've talked about in the past. And that goes along with the conversation.

53:48 $84,000 for interpretive signs, for instance, may well need to be a standalone measure R application. Yep. And then that moves $84,000 back into the ability to, you know, maintain and build other trails. I don't know the answer to that, but that's, yeah. Well then, before we go back to the asterisks, John, did you have a comment before we actually do that? And again, we're going back, the motion's been rescinded, and we're going to actually be attaching.

54:18 That's right. Did you have a quick comment? Appreciate what you guys are doing. Appreciate the need to get this to the recognition of the council. Just a reminder that the list that I put together has to do with specific seasonal issues that need to be addressed to get them done this summer. This trail system lives on a seasonal basis, so I'm hoping you guys get through what you got to get to and then come back. These are not ideas for MLTPA project funding, right? These are things that need to get done this summer. Got it. Thank you.

54:47 You're right. The timing is of the essence, specifically like this. I think we just want to get it passed first. Something we talked about, and I wanted to clarify because it came up as a question at an MLTPA board meeting, was we have paid for the advance work for this year's summer of stewardship out of funds that we carried forward from the current fiscal year, or that we allocated in the current fiscal year.

55:17 So this $20,632 then carries us all the way through the advance work next May, June for the following summer. So we're ahead of it. Because there was some discussion about repaying, and we're not doing that. We're ahead. We're ahead. There's sufficient funding for next year's, next fiscal year's program. That was how I understood it, but there was a question, so I wanted to clarify that for the record. Steve, did you get that? No.

55:48 Good, so it's clarified for the record. That the allocation for 5-1-1 represents the full fiscal year allocation, including the preparation work that needs to be done for the summer of 2014 SOS days. So in other words, through 6-3-0-14.

56:18 We had a funding gap this last year and we filled that by using some of the unallocated funds and I just want to make it clear we're not going to have that funding gap again next year. Thank you. So I'm just waiting for Steve to make his notes and then what I think we're going to do is with regard to those items 5-1-1 down, we are going to go through and just make note of those

56:52 Items that have individually been approved by us for recommendation, correct? Sounds good to me. I'm more than happy to give it a go. Okay, so we've been talking 551, Mammoth Nordic Winter Grooming or a Winter Grooming Program. The 20,000 has not been discussed nor put into a motion or approved.

57:17 Correct. Because we haven't gotten an end of the year report either. Yep. Go on. So that's an asterisk. That's an asterisk. That's an asterisk. Correct. The grant program. Winter egress. I'm sorry? Winter egress is the next one on the left. Well, the winter egress goes back to, oh, I'm sorry. The winter egress was, that money was not spent this last winter. So that's just a carryover. So we're moving that money to spend it and to implement that program this coming winter.

57:47 So that was approved, but that's not on the column that we're focusing on at this time. Not part of the new $300,000, I think. What we're interested in is that column. So we have consensus on that $1,500 to do that? Yes, we do. Okay, so then the grant program, we had $8,500 this year. We're going to move $8,500 to next year. And my allocation here is we're adding an additional $7,500 to that $8,500.

58:15 So that we can have a total of 12,500 to work with next year for grant research and development. But we've not voted on that specifically, so that's getting an asterisk. That's correct. Thank you. Exactly. Which number are you on? That was 441. 441. MLTS grants. Right. Got it. Fundraising, we've had continuing discussion about the appropriateness for that, so that has been moved then into the reallocation.

58:41 Yep. I think we had consensus on that. We did. Lakes Basin Steward Program. This is Friends of the Inyo. And this year's contract we voted on as implemented of 29,000. So it does not receive an asterisk. Yep. It's a tick. It's a tick. Next one is the website content. Whoops. There's a typo. Content should be scratched. It should be operation and maintenance.

59:12 And if I've made a mistake, I hope John Wentworth can correct it. But I think that's the way it should read, is operational maintenance. So that's a signed contract that has been implemented as of April of $34,750. So it does not receive... I'm going to pull you back to that. Because I believe content is appropriate there. While they're not going to add new content, in changing the content as in what trails are available and what...

59:41 Types of those things, I was under the assumption that that would happen under that contract. Can we take that on on our next business item? On the business item coming up? We can. Okay. Because right now I'd just like to get through this. Get through this. But essentially that box gets a tick. Is that right? Yes. Not an asterisk. I think we need a choice of term then between the different types of contract. We're going to discuss that on item number 731.

1:00:08 Printing maps, guides, and so forth. That $3,000 of 2012-13 money was not spent, so we're going to carry that over to $13,14 and spend it in $13,14, and hopefully that will be coordinated with the work that the Forest Service and John Kazmerski mentioned earlier with the map update. We're asking for an additional $3,000 to go along with that to make sure we got our QR codes and all that stuff coordinated, and then maybe to Mary Kay's point, the additional...

1:00:37 Mapping of the Blue Diamonds that have fallen off would also be on those maps. $3,000 in red gets an asterisk. Asterisk, right, because I don't recall a specific vote, but we definitely are, I think, consensus on it. Then the wayfinding update, 472. Again, a proposal has been brought forward. You've received that. You reviewed it. It has not been formally voted on and approved. Asterisk. And so it would receive an asterisk.

1:01:06 The pedestrian easements, again, we've talked about that. It's been on the agenda information for a couple of meetings at $1,900. That has not been voted on as far as a motion, so it should receive an asterisk as well. And then the sharp NEPA CEQA 221A is an added project I put in there.

1:01:26 In full disclosure, as a way to rectify and get to $300,000. So that has not been voted on nor discussed. There's an asterisk. Then finally, wayfinding mapping update. This is kind of a combined deal where we could actually add 10 revised maps to our existing type 2 and 4.6 to help with our wayfinding. And as John pointed out earlier, as we bring these projects online, we need to go back and change our mapping and so forth.

1:01:55 Again, for a recommendation, $5,000 to help with that effort. Hasn't been discussed. Deserves an asterisk. Okay. I think we've done a pretty good job of kind of identifying here. One more clarification, if I could, Chair. So the process moving forward, so we've identified these as pending projects. So to move these forward, so I'm assuming staff, Steve, would bring them forward to the MLCCC, they'd move forward to the RC. Would they again need to move forward to the Town Council?

1:02:25 I would hope no. My opinion would be no. I'm thinking that the last step is the Recreation Commission. I mean, we can make the assumption. We'll just confirm that. I think that's what we want to say. But I think the internal process right now is that once we flesh them out, the projects come back, get reviewed by TC, go to RC, and then because you've actually have approved funding of the 300,000, I'm assuming you wouldn't need to go back to Town Council. Right.

1:02:52 I mean, we'll probably just check on that anyway, just for clarification. Yeah, and I would think we might, this is our tentative one, but I would kind of see it, you know, after we've gone through staff report, the specificity, now we know what we're talking about, and we'll probably confirm a lot of these, it may be a slightly different amount, but we may come up with some new ones, and we say, you know, or totally changed ones that aren't in this budget. At that point, maybe it's November, December, I don't know what, we go back with a list of those.

1:03:21 Depending on the timing needed. Well, I think, well, I mean, in terms of Stu's question, my recommendation would be that they just go back to the... Commission. The rec commission. Now, if for procedural reasons that can't happen, then it can't happen. But in terms of an efficient, effective process, that's the way I would prefer to see it go. Just...

1:03:48 Just on the chair, so quickly what we could do in our agenda bill for council on the 19th is to state that it's the intent of the MLTCC for these items that are identified in an asterisk that add up to the 300,000 that would be reviewed and vetted through the MLTCC, go to Recreation Commission, but this time this body is not recommending or there's season need for them to go back to town council and maybe have just town council affirm that as one of the options. I think that's probably a good...

1:04:14 A good policy recommendation, if that's something that... I think so, and that was going to actually be one of my comments or questions, is what is the exact, you know, wording or definition that's going to be assigned with these asterixs. Essentially what you're suggesting then, Stu, is that these still can be reassigned, is that we're making it clear that these monies can be reassigned with recommendation to the Recreation Commission. Correct. But not necessarily going before Town Council. Unless Council sees a need for them to come back and...

1:04:44 Makes that. Makes sure that that's included. Makes that recommendation, yeah. That makes sense. And one other comment that I'll say with regard to these monies is that some are going to be more timely than others. For instance, these temporary signs that we're talking about. Whether it's the $84,000 up there, what was discussed with regard to the panorama bike trail, earthquake trail that's coming up, those kind of things that we've talked about. So I want to make sure that after this budget is approved, the recommendation going forward, that

1:05:14 You know, we'll want to take on those things pretty darn quickly. Jump on them. And July 8th is, you know, a month away. Yep. And maybe even some of those things, you know, we're going to be missing some windows of opportunity there. So I don't know if we want to... This goes before Town Council when? 19th. June. You know, I don't know if this committee wants to discuss having another meeting, and I'm not one to be proposing meetings, but at the same time, because those temporary signs with regard to...

1:05:46 You know, we have talked about some temporary signs possibly going in place for the earthquake bike path, and now we're actually talking about the Panorama Dome temporary signs. If we wait until July 8th, when are we going, and we approve them on July 8th, realistically, when are we going to be getting those in the ground? So I don't know if that's something I want to discuss this time. How do we approve? No one's brought to us a budget or a detail.

1:06:14 Bill, that's a comment that I want to make is that you're right, it hasn't. I think that we don't want to really start discussing that at this time because it would only confuse what's going forward to the Recreation Commission. However, again, for this committee to show some successes this year and get them in the ground as soon as possible, I guess what I'm saying is that I'm asking a call for a request for funds that would be specifically to the Panorama Dome.

1:06:45 Temporary Bike Signs, and I believe also, John, Earthquake Fault Temporary Signs that we were talking about. Yeah, Earthquake Fault, directing people off of uptown, downtown, over Earthquake Fault. And just talking timing here, and John will go to you here in just a minute, just because I want to understand the implications here, if we are to show success with regard to these this summer.

1:07:13 I'm just kind of thinking through the process here is that this gets approved by Town Council because I don't even want to discuss this until after it's been approved by Town Council. But if we could get some applications for those funds for these temporary signs, specifically those two, and there may be other ones here as well, would we even be able to, is that something that we could conceivably discuss the week of June 22nd? Is that something that if we were to approve that, is there any way that those signs could be ready in time for

1:07:43 The earthquake SOS day, which I believe is scheduled for early July. Is that? How fast can Drew route? Yeah, how fast can you? You know, I think the way we want to talk about framing up this proposal is we definitely want to be cognizant of the fact we don't want to put too much money into this or too much time into it because we want to think about the right sign type for the entire system.

1:08:12 And I think this may help us. This process may give us some ideas that grow out of it. But maybe, you know, if we identified eight intersections on Panorama Dome, maybe we just focus on the priority ones. So I think I would encourage us to think about a tiered proposal. Here's, like, the absolute critical signs that need to go in, and maybe that's a handful, four or five, between Panorama and Earthquake. And then maybe tier two, here's a second bite, and here's how much it would cost to do a few more, and maybe tier three.

1:08:40 And again, you know, I am pushing us here a little bit at the same time. I feel, and I don't want to rush it so that it's done poorly, but at the same time, we are recognizing that these are temporary signs and heck, summer is here. John, do you have a comment? Yeah, a couple of questions. So, I had a conversation with Steve about this subject over the last week. Steve advised, and I may be wrong, I'm just trying to figure out what's going on here, that you have $43,000 at your discretion currently.

1:09:08 For short-term immediate projects, is that correct? Sort of, yes. It can be considered that, yes. Okay, so I prepared, MLTPA prepared a list not as requests for projects. I'm kind of looking for your, someday we'll get your priorities of what you want to do. But these are just identified action items that need to happen this summer based on a seasonal basis, based on what you're talking about. I've got a list of these things here. I've shared them with Steve. Oh, you want to hand them out? Yeah, and again, if you want to...

1:09:38 You know, if you want to get to a specific point in your meeting to say, okay, let's start talking about these things, then maybe we can have a good conversation about it rather than just kind of throwing things around all the place. Well, and that's why I want to be clear that what we're discussing and really the action item, the business matter that we're discussing right now is approving this budget. And I think that just to be clear, the best thing that we can do at this time, and if that's the case, then maybe we should just entertain a motion and second and vote on it. When you're ready, come back to this.

1:10:08 And then, but at the same time, I just wanted to, before we actually heard that motion, that I wanted to discuss some of the timeline, some of the things that I'd like to see go forward with us. So having said that. Right, and I was going to ask the question of Ray, but perhaps Stu can answer it for the eight interpretive signs that could, oh, here's Ray. My question, Ray. Before you actually. It's the same type of question. Okay. Because I want to know, would that go out to contract, and if so,

1:10:40 In other words, how fast would those eight signs, would they go out to contract or would Public Works do them? That's the interpretive signs that are all ready to go. It's the packet that was presented to us. And it's, oh, let's see, it's number 472 wayfinding update. This is phase four, installation of eight interpretive sign panels for the MLTS wayfinding.

1:11:11 And it was a memo that was given to us. These are the signs that are sitting there ready to go be put to the ground. Sandy, if I could add a little background to help Ray get up to speed. Yes, that would be good. Bernasconi and I discussed this, Ray. These are eight interpretive sign panels that have been designed by the Forest Service. And Peter's recommendation is that it would be three contracts.

1:11:38 One for the steel fabrication for the framework. The other would be for the installation of the steel framework. And then the third is the pannier or the publisher of the interpretive signs on the panels and then have them installed. So I think to answer your question that you were asked of Ray, it would be through a town process. Right. No, my question was how long.

1:12:04 In other words, I understood these to be ready to go. Yeah, and I talked with Bernasconi, and he felt that if we were able to get the budgeting approved by the June 19th Council, that we could turn around then very quickly and try and get them in before the snow. Okay. So that was the goal. I defer to Steve. Okay. I defer to Ray. Okay. Thank you, Steve. It seems to me that if we have this immediate need,

1:12:34 Jerking other things around, we could take the money from 400.1 wayfinding mapping updates, because this is a wayfinding, and take it out of that pot and then backfill it as we need to later. This is something that's already in our budget and would allow us to do it almost immediately. Well, it wouldn't.

1:13:06 Still have to wait for the Council. For July 1. But we wouldn't have to meet. Right. Then we wouldn't have to meet. And whoever has to do it would know as of. But we don't have a scope. We don't have a budget. That's the issue. That's my concern. It's nothing. You know, as I recall, the eight intuitive signs, there were some questions. We did have to. And some specifically from you. Yes. And I still have questions. That's why I don't want to deal with that budget, because that's a whole different project. 400 is a...

1:13:36 Wayfinding and mapping allocation anyway. And Paul was about to jump up and tell us how much 18 temporary signs you're going to cost. Pretty little, I think. We were going to make word signs routed on Redwood. Basically, that's, you know, keeping with Forest Service standard, one-inch letters. We're looking at about $100 a sign. And that includes time and materials. It's not a lot. Well, the question is going to be for this committee then. You know, do we want to open up this budget that we've already discussed with the asterisks?

1:14:07 To include these items. I would just include an NTE of up to $2,000 out of the $5,000 for this project. Barry, you keep referring to number 400. 400. It's the last one on the list. 490. Thank you. Oh, 490. I'm sorry. Store my glasses. Me too. I'll buy you some new glasses there. Yeah. Okay, so 490. So what you're recommending then is that we just...

1:14:39 Approve at this time. No. NTE of 2,000 out of that pot. It does. To build these signs. But you understand that wouldn't be available until after June 1st. Yeah. July 1st. July 1st. Yep. Yes. Yeah, but did we, we know that they can't get going until July 1st. Uh, Bill? Well, yeah, you'd have to go before then. Well, I think we also have another option if we don't want them.

1:15:08 You know, mess around with the $300,000 is you can go back to the $43,000 and reallocate. The problem I was having with that is that it's not on the agenda for discussion today. Yeah, I think we're on track here maybe with using some of that money from $490,000. Right, and we just put back in when we need to. Did we previously approve that? Well, we've not, and it's got an asterisk next to it, but what I guess Bill Souser is suggesting is that, you know, we're talking about

1:15:39 You know, we were close to being able to take a motion here, and this is fine, I'm glad we're having this discussion, to be able to approve this budget going to the Recreation Commission and Town Council as the way it is with the asterxes. What I think Bill Souser here is proposing is that we actually take $2,000 from that $490 to go towards, not to exceed, temporary signs for Friends of the Inyo.

1:16:05 Now, in addition to that, though, I'm going to ask about John Kazmierski. You know, we talked a little bit about the temporary signs for the earth, for directing people from the uptown, downtown to, and the reason why I want to include that is because of a timely matter as well. The 18 signs includes that. Well, then, never mind. I wasn't sure if that was part of the 18 signs that Paul was talking about. According to John's thing right here, the 18 signs would cover uptown, downtown, unless I'm reading it wrong, John.

1:16:35 Uptown, Downtown, and Panorama. Right. John, is that accurate? I think Paul's numbers sound good. I counted eight needs on Panorama Dome, and I think what we've seen at the earthquake in Mountain View, it shouldn't be more than seven or eight out there either. If there's more, we'll figure out a way to make it work. So I would, Mr. Chair, I would make a motion that we take the asterisk off of wayfinding and mapping updates for an NTE of $2,000.

1:17:08 To be used for the temporary signs on the Panorama Dome and Uptown, Downtown Mountain View and that they be installed on the summer stewardship days in July. Do we take the asterisk off? Because then if we do that, we're changing that from 5,000 to 2,000. Which we don't want to do.

1:17:29 So can we just add another line? Just add a line. And change the 5,000 to 3. Yeah. With the efforts to test. Yeah. 3,000. But is that going to be confusing tomorrow for the recognition? No, because Sean Ryle explained it. May I ask a clarifying question? Not to confuse things, but when I read that line item, I thought it was for updating some of the maps on the type 1 signs. Yeah.

1:17:51 That's what I thought that was for. And it is. Okay. But we can move another 3,000 from the 43 end when we have that on our agenda so that we can legally vote on it. Got it. Okay. Sorry. This just gives us a way to handle this today and not have to have a separate meeting. I like where you're going with it. Yeah. So that's... As long as we don't confuse things too much. That's my recommendation. Paul, if you want to say that, you better approach the podium. It's okay. I'll follow up on Steve, whatever paperwork I have to do on our ends.

1:18:22 So it's like a part of a staff report. In other words, we have the actual information. Just remember that the money won't actually be committed until after the council votes on the 19th. Yes. Okay. But if the council votes on this, yeah, it actually won't be available until July 1st. Won't be available, but they can start planning to do it once the 19th is. If the vote comes down on the 19th, then you can start moving knowing you can get a check sometime after the 1st.

1:18:52 Because it's got a tick. So do I show this as an asterisk of the 3,000? Yeah, the 3,000 will be an asterisk. And the 2,000 will be a totally new line item with its own number and its own name. Not for tomorrow, though. Yeah. Yeah, it will be for tomorrow. Oh, you are going to? Okay, we're going to change the agenda item. It will be the sheet that goes to council. So it needs to be the most updated one tomorrow. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So that's the way it will go unless it dies for lack of a second. Okay. I'd second.

1:19:22 You guys have it figured out. I'm okay with it. Outstanding. We've got a motion in a second. Is there any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Good. Okay, so get that going. Well, darn, if that didn't just cruise right along. That's good. I like that. So then in our next meeting in the 8th, then we will hit some of these others that could go in. I just noted.

1:19:49 That we actually did something today that's going to go on the ground this summer. I want to gather. That's great. Now for clarification on Bill's motion, it was just in regards to this temporary signage. It was not for the budget. That's correct. Okay. So we still need to go back to Bill's concept that was withdrawn. The concept motion. For the entire. Yes. That's correct. You just need to read. And in his motion now, the $5,490 is going to be.

1:20:19 3,000, so there's another line with 2,000 approved for temporary signs. And now we know what the asterisks are going to be. That's right. Well, that's great, because I think what we just did is we just avoided creating another meeting, and we also are going to get something on the ground this summer, so that's great. Good job, everyone. Well, with that, actually, that allows us to just move right along, doesn't it? No, we have to make the motion. Yeah, Bill's going to make his motion. So, once again,

1:20:49 Oh, well then. I move that we recommend the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee Master Project and Budget Tracking List for fiscal year 2013-14, dated June 3, 2013, as amended, including identification of tentative funding and amendments to line 490.1. I will second that motion. Any further discussion? Those in favor.

1:21:25 Aye.

1:21:26 Those opposed.

1:21:29 Then it carries.

1:21:30 Okay, now we can congratulate ourselves.

1:21:34 And if there's anything else needed, I would say on that, for the interpretive signs,

1:21:42 let's see, maybe get with, so that we could get more than, in other words, we have the interpretive sign, the 84,000.

1:21:50 I mean, I'm anxious to see those get in the document.

1:21:52 So I guess if anything's missing, maybe meet with Ray.

1:21:56 Whatever, if that's a complete staff report so we can talk about that at July 8th so we can move on with those contracts too because it sounds like we could get those in the ground too and that's something really substantial we can point to. Well, I think that we've already got a pretty detailed presentation on that and we started to talk about it but there was a lot of questions and we ran out of time last time. Yeah. So I'm not sure what else needs to be prepared.

1:22:20 Get ready to vote on it next time and then we can move is what I'm saying. If there's anything missing. You know, because I think we could point to a number of things in the ground this year with those. All right, very good. Okay, before we then leave, just to put it out there, the pages three and four, I don't see any further items or needs for discussions in there. I don't know if you, in reviewing your packets, have...

1:22:56 Seen any need in that. They are included in the tracking list. So I guess they are covered under the previous motion as well as the SOFA list. So I'll just point that out and make sure that there isn't any additional discussion needed for those pages 3, 4, and 5. You mean for today's meeting or all in all? Because I do see need to discuss. Okay. I do see

1:23:27 See that a bunch of these, the new, everything that's listed as new, hasn't been put in any bucket lists so that we can go back and look at what the new projects are and then rate them versus the projects we're looking at funding. I mean, that was one of my concerns in the first place was how do we prioritize new things coming in versus old things that were already there and the effectiveness going forward with it. We just did prioritize some brand new stuff.

1:23:56 We did. We prioritized, sent it to the top and approved it. Anyway, I understand what you're saying, but I think that's a different exercise than what we're doing today. Today, I agree. I'm just saying yes, in future meetings, there is need to look at each one of these items and prioritize it and put it in a bucket. We do need to do that. But not today. So again, the email that I sent out directing your attention to the eight

1:24:28 Interpretive signs and the packet that is handed out before and the representational map on the board. Is it your pleasure at this time to move on and not discuss that project any further? Yeah, because we're not going to discuss, Mr. Chair. Yeah, I think the discussion is going to be, are we taking this on today or after? No.

1:24:59 I think that by consensus I'm seeing that we're taking this on another day. And just by saying another day is because I don't want to confuse this at this point with regard to presentation before it goes to Recreation Commission, Town Council. So that can certainly be, as Sandy's pointed out, one of the top items that we can discuss at our July 8th meeting. Just making sure all the bills are filled. Consensus on that? Agreed. Okay. We had a comment from

1:25:28 The audience, before we move on, move away from this business better. So just to help you understand, so are we talking about this list today or is this going to July? This is going to July. All these items on this list are going to July? Except the ones that we approved for the temporary signs, yes. Okay, so understand there's a lot of season. I think, Sean, your point was well taken. The summer's going to be over soon. Thank you.

1:25:55 John, this letter is great. I mean, it's very helpful in understanding what is a priority, and I think we're hearing you on that. Okay, anything else on business item number four? Steve, let's move on. Next, we're going to talk about the quarterly report, and this is your PowerPoint presentation that you're going to be making to the Recreation Commission and Town Council, and you're going to run through that with us? Yes. Steve, how would you like to discuss this? Because, you know, I have questions on individual slides. Do we want to let you...

1:26:32 Go through the entire thing and then come back to individual slides? Or do we want to ask questions, come up with those slides, take them on at that time? What's the preference in doing this? I think I'm doing this report and then we'll... Yeah, go back. Yeah, I think I feel most comfortable probably going through the slideshow and giving then discussion about the slides and then we can go back and look at each individual slide or...

1:27:04 Talk about the concept. Okay. Can you move any chairs for anybody to be able to see? No? So the first slide. Back up just a little. Back up. There you go. Now you're good. Okay. So the first slide is, again, our logo, who we are, Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And then this is the Coordinating Committee's quarterly report for June 2013. I was presumptive enough to put our draft.

1:27:41 Vision and Mission on the slide for discussion. It is on the agenda today. What you see in italics is the coordinator's recommendation for what that mission and vision might be. We received input from a couple of members. And so the vision could be that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is or will be the best alpine recreational trail system in the world.

1:28:08 Containing an integrated set of recreational trails, wayfinding, and interpretation that transitions seamlessly from the urban to a natural environment or the national forest lands. Then our mission to achieve that vision is that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee is a group of local recreation trail users providing guidance,

1:28:37 And the enhancement of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System experience through programs, projects, and budget recommendations. A little background on the committee itself. In February 2012, Town Council directed the Town Manager and Recreation Commission to present a proposal to convene the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. Followed on February 7th,

1:29:07 The Recreation Commission passed a motion to convene the committee with a scope of work attached. On February 15th, the Council approved the establishment of the committee, the initial composition of the committee, a seven-item scope of work, and the four-year term of office for the members. The previous commission composition consisted of Sandy Hogan representing the Mobility Commission, Bill Souser,

1:29:36 The Recreation Commission, Jim Smith, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Bill Taylor, MLTPA, Sean Turner, Recreation Commission, Dave Wilberg at the time, Town Manager, was representing the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Jonathan Kazmierski was identified as an ex-officio representative of the United States Forest Service, and there were user groups that were considered or asked for future consideration.

1:30:02 The current committee composition has been reduced and modified slightly. Sandy Hogan is a member. Bill Souser, Recreation Commission. The vice chair is currently Bill Taylor, affiliated with MLTPA. Sean Turner from the Recreation Commission is the chair. And Stu Brown is representing the town of Mammoth Lakes. There is additional staff as needed and support.

1:30:28 Ray Jarvis is the Town Alternative, John Kazmierski is the U.S. Forest Service Representative, and myself the Coordinator as a private consultant. We have additional resources through the Town of Mammoth Lakes for the services of Hayes, I'm sorry, Hayes, Jessica Morris, and Peter Bernasconi as needed. The seven items scope of work is listed here, and

1:30:56 Basically, the recommendation is to move forward, recommend and prioritize projects for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, including a five-year capital and minor projects list, recommend budget allocations for prioritized projects for the Recreation Commission prior to submittal to Town Council from within the proposed annual $300,000 appropriation.

1:31:22 Establish a regular meeting schedule for project review and project reports. Determine a process for implementation and funding based on the requirements of the respective projects, technical, legal, fiduciary, timing, capacity, and so forth. Projects and funding will be assigned by the committee to those entities who can best meet the project requirements and needs. The fifth item scope is to determine the requirements for staffing needs and the engaged in

1:31:51 Entities as Needed. Sixth, Establish a Budget for Staffing the Committee, Incorporating 6,900 appropriated from previous year's Measure R. And finally, identify the user groups that need to be included and determine the appropriate size of the committee. So the first item of work, the Trails Committee has put together a master tracking list that has numbers, tracking codes for the projects.

1:32:20 Project's names and descriptions, priority appetization or bucket list numbers, funding and accounting, lead organizations responsible for the work item, current status, next steps, actions, and notes. And these are meeting then requirements of scope item number one. You know, Steve, you probably don't actually need to read each slide to us if you can summarize them because we pretty much know the details of the material in the slides. If you get to one, we don't.

1:32:50 Be sure and highlight it and let us know. So the second work item then again, we are taking care of those items within the master tracking list. So our appropriation signed contracts paid out and so forth. I'm sorry, I think I may have punched this twice. So here is a unfortunately teeny version of the tracking list, but it shows you the level of detail within the tracking list and how we're able to do it. So it's representational.

1:33:21 Not intended to read. The third item having to do with our regular meeting schedule is exemplified by an agenda heading for our regular meetings. We've been meeting at least once a month, sometimes two times a month. Work item number four, the Trails Committee has put together and now has voted on the implementation steps and that's how we move these projects forward. Item five is determining

1:33:49 Requirements for Staffing Needs. Over on the right-hand side shows how we account for those needs. Item 6, the incorporation of the 6900. That's already been included in the top portion of the right-hand example. And we have established a budget and tracking method for staff time and outside entities to assist the committee in their work. Item number 7 is to identify key user...

1:34:16 I'm sorry, user groups and determine the appropriate size of the committee. At this time it is a five member committee as represented in this graphic. And our accomplishments here just recently we've been talking about today are the trail state program and also on the right is a list of scheduled events, excuse me, for the future this summer. Winter grooming program this past winter.

1:34:44 Also, our accomplishments have to do with the U.S. Forest Service Challenge cost share agreement for the Sharp area. And also, we have accomplishments for putting together the website and making sure that that's being monitored. And our future projects that we look forward to are continued funding of Sharp with the Forest Service, continued funding of summer.

1:35:12 of stewardship programs, trail days, the website, developing handouts, maps, and guides, exploration and development of grant funding opportunities, implementation of eight interpretive signs on the main and the lakes basin paths, updating two and four, six maps to show improvements to the system, and other projects from the master project and budget tracking list as determined by the committee. Thank you very much. That concludes our quarterly report. Thank you.

1:35:42 So particular questions on slides? We'll start back at the end. I'd just like to make a comment. I really, I think it's great that you've tied this right into the scope of work. You know, that is really, I think, very important to remind everybody of the initial scope of work. It took us a while to get going, but you know, I mean, I was going through it, I went, all right. Yeah, and we are going to be taking on further discussion on the vision and mission here in a little bit.

1:36:14 So with regard to the first slide, you know, I guess what's the best way of doing this? Do we want to go through the slides again and discuss each slide? If we're going to amend that later, then let's not talk about it now. Right, I would agree. I would agree. Yeah. I'm just wondering the best way to kind of take this on. Why don't we just go one at a time and see who has comments on what slides. Okay. Excuse me, let me get note pads when I can. Okay. Make notes for me. Yeah, John, hang on just a minute.

1:36:44 No. Okay, so what we're going to do is actually individual committee members are going to make comments as we go through the program. Bill? I think it's a good job. The only thing that I would have any comment on other than that we're going to change these shortly is the 84,000 on the signs because we haven't voted on that. But since it's being understood that it is a placeholder, I have no problem being on this.

1:37:15 So you're talking about putting it on the future project side? Yeah. Well, yeah, the future project side talks about... It is a future project. Yeah, and it is a future project. Whether it comes out of the 300,000 or not, it doesn't make any difference. That would be the only clarity. Other than that, I think it's short to the point, gets the job done, and if council has questions, they can ask us, or on the rec commission, where this is going to be viewed first.

1:37:43 Manana, and the council presentation is on the 19th? Yeah. We're out of town that day. So, Bill, just to clarify, maybe that's like, say, MLT SAC proposed future projects? Or proposed projects? Yeah. Or just proposed projects. Don't say futures, proposed projects, because I think it's almost. That sounds good. Thank you, Sue. Is it really the same? Yeah. Yeah, it says, yeah, that's fine. Proposed projects. I think that's good. Well, while we're on that slide,

1:38:12 I did have a note on it. I think what happened is you put continued funding of summer stewardship slash trail days, and the other one would be continued funding of lakes basin stewards. Those are two totally separate programs. I was going to say the same thing. And it was skipped, yeah. So what you're actually proposing here is saying, so item number two would be continued funding of summer stewardship and trail days. Right.

1:38:41 And that perhaps that third bullet could say continued funding of the Lake Basin Stewards, which are different. Two totally separate programs. And since we're on that slot, there's something that I really want to state here, which was, and this is proposed projects, is I really would like to say something about future projects or proposed projects, is just stronger wayfinding and public outreach, something that I really want to make sure that we're doing.

1:39:10 An important component, I think, of what MLTSCC is all about is, again, engaging the user groups, public outreach, and our wayfinding. Because if we're talking about these temporary signs as well as the additional signs, that that's something that is discussed in the mission and the vision, but I think needs to be outlined in this slide. So I would say strong rather than stronger. I would say strong. Active public outreach and community engagement. Or active. Okay.

1:39:43 Strong and active. Active I think is great. Let's say active. Sounds good. Yeah. My only problem with adding something on there that says that because I think this is pretty complete. If we're going to add how strong we feel about that then we need to add a line about how strong we feel about creating new trails and finishing trails that are unfinished and I think it's an important piece but I don't think we need to lay out everything that we

1:40:11 View is important in the slides. You're saying that's part of our process? Yeah, it's just part of our process. Might we put something on the final slide under thank you about ongoing public engagement and outreach and kind of leave that thought? That might be a good place for you. No, I'm not sure where the best place for it is, but I feel pretty strongly that I would actually like to make sure that it's clear that we are

1:40:38 Trying to engage and inform the public as much as possible, whether it's the website or additional signs. So I guess that's just something that I feel pretty strongly about. And whether it's on the thank you slide or whether it's on the proposed projects, I just want to make sure that we're being clear because it seems to be a tie-in from the first slide, which is the mission and vision, which does state how important it is for public engagement.

1:41:09 Maybe the thank you would be appropriate. Thank you for your participation and input. Well, I don't know if any of the committee members feel that way, but I'm just, again, wanting to, you know, without getting too nitpicky, I just want to make sure that we are making it clear that a big part of our process of proposed action items is going to be strong or active engagement with the public.

1:41:38 It's actually information giving. Yeah, there's a pretty solid. Well, I've been listening and understand that, but I think that the way finding really is specifically a task. The outreach actually, if we change that word, because it's outreach sounds kind of like promotional, like marketing, and it's really about connecting the public to the trail system through information, education, the website.

1:42:06 So maybe stronger wayfinding and public engagement. Something, because I mean we do, it is a project we are working on as opposed to simply trying to sell what we've already done. I'd say strong rather than stronger. We have been, actually we've had pretty good attendance at all these meetings, a lot better than a lot of meetings, so I would say we do have public involvement.

1:42:31 So essentially what we're proposing here is just an additional bullet that says strong wayfinding and public engagement. Steve, you okay in concluding that? Yes. We'll just do some discussion here and then we'll take comments from the audience. Since we're on that slide, any further comments on that slide? Just jumping back to that page, since you corrected the lack of the lakes basin stewards,

1:43:03 Over under the one that says MLTSCC Accomplishments, you've basically got two of them there for trail days. Maybe, yes, maybe with one of those, you delete the second one and put in Lakes Basin, the Lakes Basin Stewards Program, because that's missing. That's what we just said to do. Well, you did it over here. Oh. But I'm saying over here. In other words, you got trail days twice.

1:43:30 I see, I see. And they're two separate programs. They are. However, I can see why Steve did it this way because there's existing graphics to put that there. Yeah. I don't know how many existing graphics there are for the summer of stewardship. They're lakes basin stewards. Huh? Lakes basin stewards. They're two separate. That's the problem. They're getting confused here and they're two separate. Okay. So I guess I was just saying, you know. Let's have a picture of one of the guys in his guest. Yeah. Yeah, with his shovel. With his shovel. With his shovel.

1:43:59 With his shovel pointing to the lake. I've just been informed by the Friends of the Inyo that they can provide me with a graphic to help augment this. Perfect. I think what we're asking for then is that one of those graphics is going to be for one of those trail day signs. Yes. And the other graphic will be the graphic. I think what we'll do is we'll drop the panorama dome since it's already happened, slide the trail days over the event schedule, and then add in a photograph supplied by Friends of the Inyo.

1:44:30 That will be representational of the Lakes Basin Steward Program. Okay. I was just, I only have one comment, additional comment on the content. That's under the MLT SCC accomplishments related to the website. Oh, okay. Don't worry about it. All I really want to do. Are we going to build? Accomplishments. Next one. That one.

1:45:02 That's not a very striking graphic. So if there's something you can snag off the website, it's a little more punchy. Big font, big font. And put the, where it says Mammoth Lakes Trail System website, that title is smaller. Yeah. We've just been informed that MLTPA can help me on the graphic. I'm sure they can. Yeah, because you want to emphasize website here.

1:45:29 Yeah, that little bullet, somehow the font on that bullet appears to be smaller than if you just go to the slide immediately prior, the font looks a little larger. So if you can just enlarge that font a little bit and have a sort of a punchier graphic, that's all I am. Yeah. If I can say with regard to the accomplishments, because I had some comments about that as well, is that if the committee would agree with me, I would feel that our number one accomplishment, first off, has been the

1:45:59 MOUs, the cost share agreement with the Forest Service. If we could, I think I'd like to change the order of some of our accomplishments, if that's the pleasure of the committee. You know, I also think that our number one accomplishment really has been the agreements with the Forest Service, and I'd like that to be number one and highlighted, because that's a big pat on the back to the town, this committee, and everyone involved in that. Forest Service. Forest Service.

1:46:28 So if we could, I mean, this is my feeling, and I just want to throw this out there, I don't know how critical this is, but I feel like the number one accomplishment is that agreement with the Forest Service and that an arguable number two is the website and or the trail days. So if we were to change, and I would prefer to move the, for instance, the Mammoth Nordic, no offense to them, but just essentially instead of having that number two,

1:46:55 I would want to make sure that the Forest Service Agreements, the websites, and the trail days at least are coming first. I guess I'm just suggesting changing up the order of accomplishments. Are there any other accomplishments that we'd want included in this? Because, again, we do need to be showing what this committee has accomplished. That's good. Good recommendations. I have one other little thing. Under work item number...

1:47:28 7, where it says the list of us, and it still says TBD under me, and it's like, you know, we decided on our size, and of course the Mobility Commission is gone. I would say, rather than putting in LTC, maybe just put the word transportation, because that's usually what I focus on, kind of that broader thing, in other words, not just the trails. Trails is a part of the transportation system, but

1:47:58 Because it looks like, well, we're still trying to decide what I'm doing. Transportation advocate? Just transportation. I mean, I serve on the LTC. I serve on YARTS advisory. You know, but mobility is all about. Mobility was a fancy word for transportation. I still review the CIP, you know, things like that. So I was just trying to think what to put in. I don't want to put in LTC because then you'd feel like you had to put in an LTC member.

1:48:28 You know, if I were to be gone. I think mobility advocate is a great. Yeah. Whatever. Yeah. Okay. Transpiration, mobility. If I can actually address that with regard to the work items, I had some concerns, and maybe it's still appropriate, but, you know, my feeling, I put a big fat question mark, going back to the MLTSCC scope of work, going back here, right there. Now, item number six, establish the budget staffing.

1:48:57 With regard to the $6,900 that is two years old now. Do we even need that in there? Well, because that was the original scope of work. This is what I know. Part of our accomplishment is we get it done. Yeah, so I have no problem with it being there. I think they'll understand.

1:49:13 I understand that. I understand. I think so, too. Governmentees, if you will. Yeah, and I guess that was the thing because I wanted to get away from the governmentees. Yeah. Yeah. You know, and I had a couple of questions with regard to are these really needed, but I'm aware that because that scope of work is outlined in our original, I don't want to say charter, but at least our original budget, that I understand why it needs to be there. Yeah. But at the same time, you know, that leads me to file slide number four, the previous committee composition.

1:49:42 Again, do we need that there? Do you want to go back, Steve? You know, identifies Jim Smith, Dave Wilbrick. Maybe we need it in this year, but... I think it's okay. Okay. I think it's good to track the history. Okay, that's all right. I'm just asking... This is the first one of those that have been done. Exactly. So this is going through the whole process and... Yeah. Okay. But to your point, I think under...

1:50:10 The scope of work, maybe you already said this and they missed it, but it probably should say MLT SCC initial scope of work. Initial scope of work, okay, that's a good idea. Because obviously number six has been done. You know what, that would address my concerns, but thank you very much for making it. Because it really, because the rest is really a summary of that initial. That's fine, I have no problem. So if you could add in the word MLT SCC initial scope of work, Steve? Got it.

1:50:39 And did I hear agreement on this mobility advocate or transportation advocate or whatever? You know, behind Sandy's name I just put mobility. I don't think we need to say advocate or we don't need to say commission. She was put on there as a member of the mobility commission to represent mobility. She's still representing mobility. Yeah. So I just have it say mobility. That's kind of why I want to be a more general one. Yeah. Yeah. But I don't think anything other than the single word is needed. Okay. I agree. Does that make sense to you? Yeah.

1:51:11 Can I ask one other question with regard to the slide that discussed work item number seven, which is identifying user groups? I feel like we're open to criticism here with regard to this, that we're not covering enough user groups. And I know that, you know, this is, I think that the item here is really to discuss the committee composition. And obviously it would be tough to include all the user groups.

1:51:42 But I sure would like to somehow make note of the fact that, you know, we are getting better representation from mountain bikers, from the fat bike groups. And I'm not sure, and I'm really asking this more of a question, is that, you know, are we leaving ourselves open to some criticism with regard to not having enough representation there from that user groups? I think the answer is we are leaving ourselves open, but

1:52:10 I don't actually think that's a bad thing. If there are user groups out there who would like to be engaged and would actually like to be on the committee, it would be nice to hear from them. And maybe we would choose to expand our membership, maybe we wouldn't, but nobody has come knocking that I'm aware of. So it's both, and yes, in some ways it exposes us, but we discussed the item, we said we didn't have...

1:52:34 Feel the need at the moment, and we've said that we're open to other user groups if they're interested, so I don't think it's a dangerous place to be. Is it identifying the user groups that need to be included and the makeup of the committee kind of two different things because the forum itself includes lots of people, anybody who wants to come and participate, and the recreation commission is another forum where input can be solicited. I think John was right because I think originally there was the committee plus there was two additional seats in user groups.

1:53:03 So I think the committee's made a consensus that this is the committee. Right. So we did. We voted on that. So that was it. And I think the other half of that is that we are considering funding for Mammoth Trails, which is the user group connected to our experiences. So I think it's separate, but we're also trying to reach out. I think it has to be there because it was on the original scope of work. However, we need to point out somehow that it was by the direction of this body that we not add any

1:53:33 Additional Members at this point to the group. I think it was left up to us. It was kind of like an open, if you want to expand it, do it, but. Right, and since this is a presentation the questions are going to be asked on, if somebody asks a question, we can be there to say, this was the determination of the group that we decided to stay at a five member. Mm-hmm, that's correct. Board. Thank you, I literally wanted to ask that question just for the discussion. Good. Well, stop it. No, that's the beauty of gratitude, right?

1:54:02 Are there any more discussion from this dais or John Kazmierski before we go to the audience? Thank you very much. Good job. Thank you, Steve. Thank you, Steve. Good job. Excellent. Very nice presentation. One comment would be that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System logo, we provided under contract a Mammoth Lakes Trail System logo that has a trademark associated with the name, and I would encourage the town to use that version of the brand with the trademark in it.

1:54:32 Also on the list I provided with you guys this afternoon, I would really encourage the committee to start to prioritize putting together intellectual property program to start protecting your assets. MLTPA provided some information on that a couple of years ago and I think it would be a good thing to pursue. Thank you. That was a great point because I can tell you as a business owner who just went through some trademark issues that if that has been trademarked, let's get the R in the circle embedded into that logo.

1:55:02 Is that what you're saying, John? TM. What I'm saying is that we deliver to the town a version of that logo that has a trademark in it. You already have it. Steve, I can help him find it if he can't find it. But intellectual property is a pretty significant undertaking, as you know. I do. You start with the idea of having a relevant brand associated with a trademark, but the town is going to have to take some specific steps to register and protect their intellectual property. MLTPA provided as part of the original...

1:55:32 The inaugural documents of authority. We spent some money on some legal advice. That's been delivered to the town. If you want to dig that up, it's a very good roadmap to start going about the steps necessary to protect your brand, to protect your intellectual property. Well, my understanding is that if it's been delivered, and we already have it, yes, we do need to have an ongoing effort to protect that mark. Yes. But that we can put the R in a circle. No, it's not the R. It's a...

1:55:59 Trade the TM? TM. Okay. The logo you have is a TM on it. Thank you. Okay. So let's just make sure that it's on... That's what we start using. Everything. Yeah, just... Yeah, you should use that on everything that you... I mean, the plaques, we've got the TM on it, it's all... Okay. Thank you. One thing I saw in there, it said grant funding, and I just want to make... Excuse me. For Graticus, can you... Oh, Donna Hustleton, sorry. Thank you. One of the slides said grant funding, and I just want to make sure that it's not grant writing and fundraising.

1:56:34 Because you're not allowed to do that with measure or monies. And our attorney, the town attorney did speak about that. So I just want to make sure that's really clear. I just want to make sure when you're saying grant funding, it's like you're giving money that you got that a grant has been issued or you're matching funds. I just want to make sure the money's not being used for grant writing or fundraising, which they're the same. Yeah. It says actually exploration and development of grant funding opportunities. Okay. Yeah.

1:57:04 Maybe it should be grant funded. Yeah, maybe. Because funding to me seems like you're going to write a grant. Maybe funded. You're not supposed to use my job for that. Yeah. Rather than the ING put an ED. I guess that's a... I think we need a point of clarification here from the chair or somebody. Yeah. We have left this... From my standpoint, we have left this in there because we want to go back to the town attorney and ask for...

1:57:34 Clarification, because what we got back from him saying that it couldn't be used for fundraising and making the assumption that grant writing is fundraising. I don't know a non-profit or any other entity that doesn't do the grant writing thing, so I am sure there is probably a way for us to word that to make it legal, and that's what we need to go back to the town attorney and ask. Non-profits and town government are totally different, and this is public money, and this is Measure R money.

1:58:05 And if you go back to the original, there's nothing about fundraising or grant writing. And you cannot charge Measure R money for that money. So the only way you can use it is for matching grants. You can't use it to write a grant. You can't use it to fundraise. It's all as one. And I just want to make sure that's really clear. Okay, we've got two – so they're kind of two separate things. What I was going to say was that clearly we understand that position. Right. If you go back to –

1:58:35 The charge from the council that got us going, we are not restricted only to measure our funds. We can actually ask for general fund money. So I think we're okay because as long as in our accounting we're making sure that we're not misappropriating measure R or any of our other funds. Within the total umbrella of what we're supposed to be doing, seeking grants,

1:59:04 Including potentially writing grant applications is still part of the role. It's part of the role, but you can't use the measure. Right, but that's not our only funding source. I just want to make sure, because since the $300,000 is this, I just want to make sure there's a separate. Got it, Annette. Here's what I heard. There were two separate issues. I thought you were talking about the PowerPoint.

1:59:27 And so if we did change just rather than saying funding opportunities, we put funded opportunities. That's very clear. Very clear. Okay. And that takes care of that because it isn't even the subject of funding or getting funding. It's just we're looking for opportunities that we might fund through grants. Right. The second issue, though, I think Bill is correct. We got an interpretation from the town attorney on fundraising, but we've been waiting for one on the grant writing and we haven't gotten it yet. So that's something for us to...

1:59:57 Still request, and for next year. To satisfy this presentation, would you be comfortable with just changing the funding to funded? Yes, for the PowerPoint. It really changes. Does it? I'm not sure. Fundamentally changes it. Funding, it would be asking for grant funding, looking for sources to fund the trail system outside of our current forces. How about if we just say grant opportunities? That's fine. Okay. Okay.

2:00:27 I don't want it to sound like we're trying to find ways to give away more. No, exactly. Can I just ask one more clarification on Dawn's comments? Because you said that $300,000 is this, and I don't see it that way. The MLT SCC is here to help direct the management of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and $300,000 to measure our money. So you could have whatever you want about grants in this presentation, because that's part of the charge of this commission. But we have to, like Bill said, make sure we're not spending measure our money on it.

2:00:57 Whatever council says we can. Right. And I'm just curious, Danette's referenced this several times. Can you have a copy of this thing from the town council about fundraising? The attorney, yes. I've got it somewhere. Okay. Yes. Right if we could get that publicly known and also just as a standing item, it'd be great to have that direction back from the town attorney vis-a-vis grants. It sounds a little odd to me, but if that's what it is, that's what it is. No, I mean, he stated that very clearly. Let's agendize this for another meeting. Yeah. Yeah.

2:01:24 Because we do not have complete clarification with regard, but for purposes of this presentation, this business banner, I don't strike in the word funding will satisfy everyone. Yep. Yep. Yes. Absolutely. All right. All in all, I think it's a great presentation, Steve. Okay. So it goes before the Commission tomorrow. Of course, those guys might have more comments. You guys. Okay. Not me. All right.

2:01:55 But for now, we're going to move on from that business matter. Thank you, Steve, for putting that together. It looks good. You're welcome. Okay, now we're going to have a... I have one question. Can we have about a five-minute recense? Yeah, but let's keep it. Three minutes. Three minutes. Three minutes. Sounds good to me. Mark, set, go. If you say three, we know it'll be fine. Okay, status and update of the MLTS and MLTS website. OUs, et cetera, et cetera.

2:02:31 Congrats. Good evening. Okay. At this stage, both MLUs have been signed by the town, and they're waiting for service, they're waiting for their signature, and then I believe they're done with the MLUs, so we should have complete control. That's correct. They're on edge dust. Great. Okay, that was nice. You got audience on that.

2:03:02 Okay. Thank you, John. Go ahead. Yeah, just real quick. The forest plan revision process is underway. It's obviously a very extremely important process. To date, I don't know that the town's involved in it. But at the meetings, interested parties have been at these meetings. There's something called a wiki process, which is subject to kind of existing conditions for the forest plan update. It's going to close June 30th. It would be very helpful.

2:03:29 If either signed or draft copies of these MOUs could be made available to the public so they could be used in updating the section of the forest plant existing conditions that have to do with the forest service partnership with the town of Mammoth Lakes. I would just request it to the chair if you could perhaps direct your staff to facilitate helping to get those documents available. They would be very useful as part of the forest plant evasion process. Confused on that. Yeah, so what you're asking for is just

2:03:57 John Kazmierski, when do you expect Ed to sign those? He's been out of town, so I'm hoping to be able to connect with him this week yet. So the timing would be fine. I think we should just plan on doing that. I'll make a note to talk to our forest planner, Susan Joyce, to add those. I'm not part of the immediate team, so I can't comment on the appropriateness of putting them on there, but it sounds like a good idea to me, so they'll just have to make a decision. So, W.

2:04:28 Sorry. It's me. Your comment is just to add links onto this website going to the wiki. To take these documents, you can attach these documents into the wiki. The relationship that the town of Mammoth Lakes is entering with the Inyo National Forest is unique. It's an interesting thing. It needs to be part of the forest plan revision update process.

2:04:53 It would be helpful to be able to have those documents associated with the wiki as part of the current existing conditions of a relationship between the Inyo National Forest and local community. Okay, I see. I get the point. So is that something that we can ask John Kazmierski to make sure gets linked? Followed up on. You'll follow up. Yes. Okay, thank you. Now, with regard to this item, before we move on to Business Matter 7, and just talking about the website, status of the website,

2:05:24 It was brought up earlier that the web updates are not included in the maintenance contract. And it sounds like now may be a good time to discuss that. Yeah, so my new content, John, when a new trail comes on, we need to pay to have that whole thing added to the website. But current conditions and all of that will be updated as part of the contract. Is that not...

2:05:51 Correct. That's correct. And I'm speaking with two members of the website partner team, the town and the forest service. So correct me if I'm wrong on anything. Day-to-day operations, trail conditions, we're starting to work with the forest service to feed all that information to the website. That's working fine. Right. If and when new infrastructure comes online,

2:06:10 There's nothing in the website management contract to pay to build those new pages. So when the College Connector comes online, those pages have to get paid for somehow. We did significant work on the Panorama Dome over the weekend. There are now new alignments. There's a new physical look and feel. Those pages would need to get updated. So that's where we're at. Wouldn't that be just part of the current conditions?

2:06:38 Not when you're Panorama Dome, we've completed a whole new trail. It's new. If you look at what the site currently has and what a visitor would see on the ground when they get there, two different things. Well, but my question for you is that, you know, aren't you just, that page already exists for the Panorama Dome Trail? Well, the contract was specifically written that way because it's not possible to anticipate what kinds of changes on the ground are going to happen. What we have in our contract,

2:07:06 Is the ability to advise the committee and advise the town, okay, we're going to need a new page, this is what it might cost to create that page, or to update the page. If you make a change to alignment, if you make a change to signage, if you make some physical change on the ground, you know, that has to get changed. Okay. Thank you. That was my... I don't think so. It doesn't sound like... Just a suggestion, because we're in the process right now of resetting our enhancement.

2:07:43 Contract. Originally that contract was initiated and signed, not initiated, but signed last December. We had some issues related to delivering on that scope of work. We're in the process of amending it right now. It's possible, and I would just suggest that projects like the College Connector and the others that we're talking about be included in that contract. There aren't specific

2:08:10 Content Recommendations in that contract, only general, you know, whether they're destinations or experiences, so we could certainly include those at this point in that contract. Yeah, and my only problem with that is in the original contract, the content and the experiences, there's a lot of experiences yet that need to be, and I can't see that contract handling all of it. No. If there's an immediate,

2:08:38 Need that would supplant the developing the experiences I can see moving it into that, but then we're still going to have to ask for additional to that it would seem to me later on to build the new experiences. Right. I think that's right. It's just a question of do we want to take this new facility over here and add it? Right. I would think we would. Yes. Just so that it's known and people can see it. But certainly, you know, I don't think we have enough funding at this point as originally envisioned to do all of the stuff that we were

2:09:09 Planning on doing. So at some point in time we'd probably come back with an RRU application. Before you know more content. Yeah, exactly. And just the letter I handed out, you've got 42 trails that currently don't have pages. There's 13 new activity candidates, 53 new experience candidates. And the website is being managed. We're linking it. It's out in the universe. And it's very easy to take like a duck pass trail.

2:09:37 Go to a TripAdvisor someplace like that, establish a page for it. So it's working pretty well, but it would probably be a good idea to get the full inventory of trails in the system to get their pages up and going. And again, it's June, and it's summer. It would be great to get these in the summer. So what does a new trail page cost? It depends upon whether you're doing one page as a one-off or whether you're doing them as a group. And the contract that Ray has been talking about is designed to put together a group to achieve economies of scale.

2:10:07 But what kind of cost then for a group? I'm not prepared to target. Well, because that's the kind of information we need. In other words, according to our process, we need a breakdown because if we're talking about a huge amount for each page, 42 new trail pages, that's a lot to me. I think, you know, the way we were approaching that contract was the first part of it was to identify what content we wanted to add. So we haven't done that yet.

2:10:36 So once I get the amendment to that contract completed, get it back to MLTPA, we get it all signed, we hit the reset button and go, that's what the first step really is, is to identify, okay, what is the content that we want to add to the website? So that's kind of where we're at, and that's why I'm just thinking it might be good to look at things like College Connector, you know, the projects that we're working on this summer.

2:11:05 And add those to the list, you know, maybe as a beginning. And then the other additional content that Bill's talking about, you know, may have to come back later, just depending on how far we can go with the funds that are currently available. The way I'm understanding your comments, though, vis-a-vis what John Wentworth is saying, though, is that so we're going to miss being able to have this up for the

2:11:36 Website for the summer. Well, I don't know that that's true. I understand the urgency because before you know it, it'll be fall. That's the way it goes around here. Ideally, if you want to get summer content done, that's why we had the contract originally done in December. It didn't play out the way we had hoped that it would play out. So here we are. I think once we get this contract reset, we'll get together and work as expeditiously as we can to add new content to the website.

2:12:06 And at the same time, there's the ongoing content management, which, you know, we're underway with, so I think that's in good shape. But as far as enhanced content, different contract, different set of circumstances. So we, you know, we will work as quickly as we can with MLTPA to get that going. Will that come back to us at all, or no? If you'd like it to. I'm not sure which part you want to see, but I don't think there's really a need to have a contract come back.

2:12:35 The contract was actually executed in December. This is really an amendment to the contract because of circumstances that we encountered along the way. We're, like I say, restarting. But what's going to need to come back to us is a request for more funds to build these 53 new experiences. Well, we have to see how far we can go with the funds that are available based on, as John said, what content we're talking about.

2:13:03 I think we had a, and correct me, John, if you're wrong, but I think we had kind of an all-inclusive number of experiences, destinations, et cetera. We have a different amount of money available to us now. I don't know that we would have got all of those completed for the funds that we had available to start with. Now we have less funding, so clearly...

2:13:26 The deliverables are going to go down. It's still a discussion as to what deliverables we want to address first, and that's part of the scope of work once we get this thing going. And that's a discussion between the partners. Here's the list. What are the priorities? What needs to get done? And then make that determination and see if we get done for the cost. However, some of those priorities may well need to be set by this body. Sure.

2:13:54 Yeah, and that we would come back to you with. I think, you know, what we would want to do, I believe, is between MLTPA staff, Forest Service, the partners, is we will, I think, establish sort of a draft list. We can certainly bring that back. And I'm hoping we can bring that back for the July 9th meeting. That way you guys can look at it. A draft list of what you're looking at. Yes. And all other potentialities that are seen so that we can see the whole list.

2:14:24 All other potentialities. That already exists. We can provide that. I would think to Sean's point about the summer, if it does come back in July, we wouldn't be able to wait past that just because photography, getting out on the ground, you get a GPS thing, some of these things are way out of nowhere. So we need to get moving on. Way to heck, John. Excuse my French. Thank you.

2:14:55 Hi. Good afternoon. Pat Agnich. I guess I just would like clarification. Was that 42 or 52 extra experiences or trails that need to be added to the site? Since John's the one that wrote it, I'll let him answer. So that was 42 trails. These are trail candidates. So what will happen is there's 42 trail candidates, 13 activity candidates, 53 experience candidates. Those candidates go to the partners.

2:15:25 The agencies work it, come up with the prioritized list. That would be helpful. Thank you. So there are more trails out there that need to be added to the website, and this group will make the determination as to the priority system for that. I guess my only comment is that over $1 million has been spent in developing this website, and my expectation is that it would have been as comprehensive as possible. So it's kind of disappointing that there's more.

2:16:01 Not a million. It was a quarter of a million, I believe. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm correct. The website. Any other comments? Questions about the website? No. Let's move on. Okay, so now we're going to get a presentation on a status and update regarding the US Forest Savers trailhead-related projects. Mr. Kazmier. Okay, when you say trailhead-related projects, are we talking about the motorized trailheads? Are we talking about what I'm prepared to talk about? I can talk about both, but I just want to get a clarification.

2:16:40 The agenda says trailhead related projects, John. It's pretty open. Okay. So let's talk about what you're prepared to talk about. If there's any questions specific to motorized, we'll go there. Okay. So next Wednesday, I'm kicking off the Forest Service resource inventories of the trails that we've identified as wanting to move forward for consideration.

2:17:11 Building, and there's really two sets of projects, and I may have to restart Google Earth here, sorry. The first set of projects are more defined in that the Town and the Forest Service collaborated on a grant application, Paula Sarbanes' grant application, and we received funding for two trail projects. One is the Lake George Connector.

2:17:38 Which takes the area right near Poconoby Lodge and builds a new bike trail essentially through the western half of the Lake Mary campground and connects up to the road to George. And then the second project is a study, really a planning grant to look at the Lake Mary traffic flow, pedestrian conflicts in the Lake Mary area.

2:18:06 And study the feasibility of adding more another trail or doing something different with the traffic pattern. And where the Forest Service wants to get, and we've talked with the town about, is we want a decision on that process. We want to come away with this planning process with a plan of action, really, not just a study that informs a NEPA process, but actually complete the NEPA. That's the goal.

2:18:31 And so those projects are very well defined. They were defined in the grant application and we're moving those two forward. What I wanted to talk about today was the Sherwins projects and really take a look at the work that the Sherwin Working Group did, the SHARP document that was produced, and then the Trails Technical Committee. Can I interrupt for a second just for a...

2:18:52 Point of Order, John? Sure. Okay. So if we could then say that we're done with that trailhead discussion, our agenda item number eight is sharp. Okay. So if you have nothing further to add about the scenic loop or shady rest. I don't have anything since the last week. Perfect. All right. So I would nod to the chairman to move on. Sorry for confusing matters. No, it's fine. All right. So in the Sherwin's area,

2:19:17 We need to take a look back at what the Sherwins Working Group did. Here's the map that a lot of you have seen over the past. All these different ideas that were brought forth in that process and the community said they wanted to see move forward. This was a collaborative effort. We had lots of different stakeholders at the table who had an interest in these trail projects.

2:19:45 I'll note, though, that not everybody was at the table, and not everybody that walked away from the process, you know, was 100% happy, but that's kind of what happens in collaborative efforts to make compromises. One of the outcomes that I think is worth noting is there was interest expressed by the Sierra Club. Actually, Mary Kay Prentice, who was here, authored the letter to the Forest Service thing, and they really wanted to see these projects looked at holistic.

2:20:15 They wanted us to not go through NEPA one project at a time, which I think is fairly reasonable. In the NEPA process, we have the responsibility to look at cumulative effects, that's past, present, and reasonable, foreseeable actions. And although the Forest Service hasn't officially adopted this proposal, I think one could argue that what's on the map here could be reasonably...

2:20:43 I think that's the exercise I want to go through with this group. I don't think we're going to get through it all today. But we need to define what is reasonably foreseeable. What trails are the highest priority for this community to move forward? And where should the Forest Service this summer, starting next Wednesday, really begin focusing their efforts? And with that, I want to note, we have the two defined projects in Lake Mary and Lake George.

2:21:13 We also have, as we go through this presentation, there's some projects that I think we can all agree that we all want to see move forward. So we've kind of got this tier one of projects that are high priority, everybody wants to see move forward. So I'm confident I have an effort right now to get my team going and get the folks on the ground and start doing the resource surveys that we don't have to make decisions here today in order to keep this ball rolling. The ball's rolling.

2:21:39 It's got momentum. I need you guys to think about tier two and tier three projects. So there's the summer map. I'll just real quickly highlight that there was also the winter Sherwins Working Group map. And we should really be thinking about the winter use as well as the summer use. The summer use is where we see the ground disturbing effects of trail development. But there are also effects of winter development too that have to be analyzed. And we need to start thinking now.

2:22:08 Do we want to weave any of that winter use into what we may be doing in this area? And I think it's probably a good idea to do that. So then in 2010 and 2011, MLTPA led the Sharp Technical Committee.

2:22:31 To go out and take a harder look at some of these trails that were identified by the Sherwins Working Group. Got a lot of community members involved. Keith Dolly, our Forest Service Trail Specialist, was involved and provided some training and advice on how to really go out on the ground and figure out the best alignment for some of these trails and to think about some of the other circumstances that should be given consideration when trying to plan these projects. So we've got a good start on a lot of these trails thanks to the Trails Technical Committee.

2:23:01 We need to go out again on all these alignments and have the Forest Service we really would like to, as we're doing the resource inventories, also make sure the alignments are in places where we think they're most appropriate, that there's no resource conflicts is the whole point of doing the study. And then I've also had a conversation with the District Ranger about his priorities and what he thinks we should be moving forward, and I'll go into that in a minute. But I just want to show you the good work that the Trails Technical Committee did.

2:23:31 And we can go through, you know, it's a lot to go through these one by one and maybe that's what it's going to take in the future either with this group or a subset. But we kind of need to decide which of these projects should be highest on the priority list. What's our bundle that we're going to move forward in a NEPA process beginning hopefully this fall and winter?

2:23:54 So this was 2010. Sheryl's Technical Committee wrapped up all of this work right here. You can see they looked at back in the Solitude Canyon area. The main, we call it the backbone connecting trail, I guess. I've been referring to it that way for a while. From the Barrow Pit area out to Tamarack Street. The trail, I think it's 13, that comes off the Mammoth Rock Trail and down to the Barrow Pit.

2:24:20 The Borrow Pit itself has a major trailhead, and then the paved mup that goes out to the Mammoth Creek. So this trail right here to the Mammoth Creek, the Borrow Pit, and Tamarack are paved mups that, you know, really, there wasn't much debate on it in the Sherwins Working Group. Everybody thought these were really good projects. I think there's a lot of agreement to move those forward. Developing this Borrow Pit,

2:24:49 As a trailhead, giving consideration to the needs of the ski area for motocross and everything, seems to be kind of a center point of this whole plan and something I think hopefully we can quickly agree is something we want to move forward. John, just so you know, we can't see your cursor. So just be, I think I know what you're talking about. As long as you're reading off the segment numbers, we'll be okay. Yeah.

2:25:15 Is there a laser thing? I don't know. John, I got a pointer. John, as long as you're reading up, we're fine. I thought there might be a quick laser pointer here. Anyway, so then the Panorama Dome is another area that was looked at extensively, and then the connecting people from down in the Panorama Dome to the Mammoth Rock Trail.

2:25:47 All right. So this was 2010. Let's go on to 2011 so you can see the continued work of the technical committee. This was really focused on how to get people out of the Sherwin Meadows and up into the bluffs and connecting them up into the lake space in the Panorama Dome area. And it's some tough terrain. The trails technical committee went out and found this route up into the bluffs that we think we can make work.

2:26:19 Another thing the Technical Committee did too is they made it known that they were looking at this and identified some concerns. I think this committee needs to be aware of, like I said, the Sierra Club has some concerns, but there's community members, not everybody wants to see these trails built. We need to make that known and we need to understand that. There may be some controversy involved with it and perhaps that controversy needs to guide our strategy a little bit as well. Do we want to focus on

2:26:49 Projects in the first round that we know we're going to be able to implement with little controversy and we're going to gain more public support. Maybe we have kind of phase one, phase two, phase three of NEPA, I don't know. But it's something to think about. We don't want to have our first, I don't believe, our first project be highly controversial and really, you know, stymie our progress in this whole MLTS. So something for you guys to think about.

2:27:17 I've talked with John Regelberger quite a bit about it. And given there's some controversy up here, he's kind of labeled that as a low priority set of projects. Given it also would be very expensive to develop that trail too. There would be a lot of retaining wall and whatnot need to be built. And then you've got some public access issues into the bluffs and other areas that we need to work through. There's private land in this area. And it's not just this project that we have concerns about with private land.

2:27:47 That we really need to be aware of and cognizant of. And I know the town has some existing easements in here and there's still some concern. So anyway, I went through with the district ranger and I sat down and discussed all these projects with him. In the purple are the existing Inyo system trails. The yellow, orange, and green, which can't really differentiate the yellow and green too much. Maybe I can change the color on here.

2:28:16 Green are the trails that the District Ranger, the Forest Service that we believe are high priorities. Yellow are really the trails that we think is kind of that second tier. And the orange are kind of the third tier priorities. But these are all trails that we've said, or John Reichelbrugger has said, he's comfortable moving forward and looking at. Now the goal is to do resource inventories for all of these. That's what we have in mind right now.

2:28:44 The money that we've asked for from the town, roughly $150,000 over three years, we're hoping that'll get us there, but we won't know until we get into this and see what kind of obstacles we run into. For example, heritage is always that big unknown, where we run into arc sites and if we can't move the trail, the whole idea is to avoid when it comes to heritage.

2:29:11 If we can't move the trail, and we're fairly certain we're not going to be able to avoid some issues over at the Mammoth Creek area, we've got to go through the process, and we've got to incur the costs that are needed to mitigate those potential impacts. So, real quickly, we'll have some choices to make, I think, at Mammoth Creek once we get in there. If we want to build a trail adjacent to the Hayden Cabin and go down to connect to the bridge at Mammoth Creek, we're probably going to have to do some archaeological testing, dig some pits, and it's going to get expensive.

2:29:39 Pretty quick. So then we have to decide, you know, does, do we stop looking at some of these other lower priority trails in order to pay for that or do we, you know, try to do it all and find the money to go through the heritage process. So just wanted to let you guys know that's, that one is for sure on the horizon. I know it for certainty and there may be others that we don't know about at this point.

2:30:05 So, that's it in a nutshell. I mean, we can go by these trails one by one now. I don't think we really have time for it. Like I said, I've got what I need to get this ball moving and have my IDT meeting and send folks out to start looking at the Backbone Trail, Tamarack to the Borrow Pit, the Borrow Pit itself, Borrow Pit to Mammoth Creek. We've already done a lot on 13. We've actually done a lot on the Backbone. We've already done the botanical surveys for all three of these trails.

2:30:35 Some of the heritage survey in the wildlife. So we're already a ways on these projects. But then from there, you know, the plan is to start looking at some of the other trails in the Mammoth Creek area. That's kind of one of our high priorities. And then go back and look at the connector up to the Panorama Dome, getting Mammoth Rock Trail in the Panorama Dome a little bit better connected.

2:31:02 And then down to Mill City as well. The bluffs, like I said, I think because we do a resource inventory, it doesn't mean that the project's going to happen. We can get the inventory done. We know there's a desire from the town to do this process to get these trails done. So we can always do the resource inventory. And if the district ranger or this committee decides, hey, let's not wrap that up into the first bundle of NEPA, well, the resource inventories, again, as I've mentioned in the past,

2:31:29 The only thing that really goes stale is the wildlife. Wildlife, once we do it, is good for about two years. And fortunately, wildlife is probably the most simple in this area to do. Although I will mention, there is one issue with wildlife. The Yosemite toad and the mountain yellow-legged frog are likely going to be listed as endangered or threatened species here in the very near future. And that's got a lot of potential to affect projects.

2:31:59 Our two projects in the Lakes Basin. Maybe just shape them a little bit differently. Hopefully not stop them or anything like that. But also in the Sherwins Meadow area that could have some real impacts to the way we move forward. So we already know that's on the horizon. But again, back to my original point, wildlife is what goes stale. That's a moving piece right now. So is the sage grass. Right now we could do a wildlife report under the existing laws and say there are no...

2:32:29 Threats to sensitive and rare endangered species in this area. Tomorrow that can change. Heritage resources and botanical resources are pretty steady. The Forest Service has a list of species that we have to take into consideration our sensitive species list. And that right now is undergoing some changes for plants and animals. But we don't really expect it to affect this project that much. So anyway.

2:32:59 That's kind of how we're thinking. That's how we have to be thinking when we want to make sure these projects move forward. We've got to think about what's the best way to bundle them. If we are going to be thinking about all of these trails, if we have agreement that that's what we want to do in the next five years or whatever, all of these trails are important to build. It probably has to be in our cumulative impact discussion, but it doesn't mean we have to

2:33:27 Analyze them as a project up front. So, you guys have any questions? Do you all have, I mean, and maybe this, you know, I think the Sherwin's Working Group, everybody said, these are all important to us. So to pick one out and say one's more important than the other, I think is a very difficult thing to do. I really do think that the MUPS that we talked about were very, you know, well received in that group. I don't invite anybody else to make comments as far as

2:34:00 Participated in that process. What was important to the group. I think what I remember in that group, really getting people from down in the Sherwin Meadows up to the Mammoth Lakes Basin was really, really important. And unfortunately, that's where the controversy lies. So we've got to figure out a way to deal with that in the future. And like I said, there may be some strategy in delaying that, taking on the first set and having some successes down low.

2:34:28 People can see the good things that come out of a trail system. Anyway, that's all I have. I had a question, John. Do you see the trails being included in the Inyo National Forest trail system, all of them? Well, what we've talked about with the town and I've talked about with this group is that a MUP would have to be under special use permit. Right. A multiple use path. Soft surface trails, we have told...

2:34:55 The town and the county and anyone else who's asked, when we add a soft surface trail to the system, we still have concerns about maintenance. And we are willing to add them to the system as long as we have some assurance that there's a maintenance agreement in place. And, you know, we've been saying 20-year maintenance agreement. We want to see, right now, it's very challenging to maintain the system that's currently on the Inyo. And to add to that, the only way we really can see doing that responsibly is if we know the funding is there.

2:35:24 From another source or the support is there. I don't think we need this anymore here. Yeah, I guess my question actually kind of went to the basic philosophy of would some be, you know, we used to have the EPA, the encourage, prohibit, allow, and some trails, especially when we were doing motorized, we didn't necessarily, in other words, they were kind of, they were the ones that people could go on, but they weren't,

2:35:54 Encouraged. Encouraged, necessarily. They weren't shown on maps. Yeah, exactly. In other words, and I don't know if that would still apply to this, it might be a concept you guys might want to think about. In other words, maybe there are certain major ones that are, of course, designated as Inyo National Forest Trail System trails and signed as such, and other ones maybe are kind of exploration almost. Yeah, you know, they're open to use, but you don't advertise them a lot.

2:36:22 I can understand that, and I can see how that probably worked in the past. From my perspective, the whole point of the MLTS is to brand a set of trails and promote them and get people here to use them. So I think to include that type of approach in this MLTS effort would be kind of tough. And so there's already a little bit of that going on. I mean, the trails down in the Sherwins meadow area, they've been there for years. And they're user-created trails that aren't part of our system. Some of them have some issues.

2:36:51 There's some crossings that need some help, and depending on the year, we get blowouts. So I would prefer, personally, and I believe that if I discuss this with John, we didn't take that approach, that we make sure anything we're thinking about would be added to the system. So the thing I didn't touch upon is the trailhead. We would prefer anything that we're developing that has a long-term maintenance cost, especially that more solid developed infrastructure is taken under special use permit.

2:37:21 Yeah, understood there. Go ahead. I was just going to ask any other questions. In the list of projects, there were a few that were stated that it was probably preferable to have some future study done before they were actually taken on. Would you be planning, I'm thinking Solitude Canyon, I believe, is one. Would you see that as one where you would do the surveys now, or would you...

2:37:48 In other words, do the main document with however many trails and then in the future tear off the main document and do that one separately. I think you could do a couple things. And I would advise that in Solitude Canyon we take kind of that Lake Mary approach where we do some initial resource inventories and we have a pretty good alignment. I mean, it was studied very well. And I think that the alignment could work. And if you do the alignment plus a pretty good buffer.

2:38:15 Where it creates some options of, hey, there's a resource conflict, we can move it over here. It's really, it's a resource survey to inform planning rather than resource survey to, you know, decide if your proposal works. So I would encourage that we do the resource inventory back there. I know there's already some concern in wildlife in that area. So we have to really think about that. There's going to be some concern about a little buffer on the wilderness there.

2:38:43 Whether we're inviting inappropriate uses into the wilderness or being so close, immediately adjacent to the wilderness boundary. So I think we may be able to at least flesh out some of the issues that we could be facing, but maybe that does become a Tier 2 or Tier 3 project that we have a better understanding of how to move it forward once we decide to do so. Or you could just take it on and see what happens.

2:39:09 I think you want to be strategic though. When we bundle these projects up in NEPA, you don't want one single trail to hold up all the progress of all of them. So John, what you're asking then is that this group take a look at these trails and help you come up with a prioritization for implementation? I'd like to know if this committee has priorities. If you guys, this set of trails, if you guys believe strongly that one trail is more important than the other.

2:39:39 And I think, you know, a good homework assignment, you can get on MLTPA's website. They house all these documents there. And you can read what the Sherwins Working Group wrote about each one of these trails, all the backgrounds there. The Trails Technical Committee went forward and looked at these in more detail. And a lot of the public issues are in that Trails Technical Committee, or those two Trails Technical Committee reports. So I'd encourage you to go do some homework, talk to people in the community.

2:40:08 And come back here. And I would say really by mid-July we should really have this list kind of prioritized because, like I said, I can keep, as my botanist runs out of trail mileage, I'll just keep them going on some of the trails even if we haven't decided their priorities. But at some point, if you guys say there's some trail that you don't want to see worked on, there's no point in spending the money, whether it's for, you know, future planning or for this NEPA process. They don't want to waste the money.

2:40:37 Well, I did spend time last year walking almost every one of these, other than I didn't go up to the top of the Sherwins, but I did walk an off, well, almost all of them. I didn't walk all of the equestrian trails either, but just off the top of my head, I'd say the bluffs is one that I couldn't, I would say I'd hold off on that just because terrain-wise, even if there were no access issues. Sandy, can I make this agenda, suggest that we make this an agenda item for our July 8th meeting, because this is important.

2:41:07 And then besides what... Oh, I thought he got something today. It sounds like you said by the middle of July. So what I'm saying is that I have enough to get my team going. I'm going to get them out on the ground. They're going to start working. And I just need to know where to point them when they get done with the first set of priority projects. If you were to tell me today, don't do the backbone, you know, the tamarack to the borrow pit, or don't do something...

2:41:34 Those are where I plan on. I want to wrap up those surveys that we've started. I want to get the reports finalized, and I want to move a couple of the other projects that I see as broad support. They're kind of no-brainers, in my opinion, the Trails Technical Committee has looked at them, and get those going right away. So if you guys see something that you're like, no, don't work on that, I should know about it today, but if you're okay with pretty much everything on there and you want to maybe just massage the priorities at the next meeting, I think that's a good plan.

2:42:02 I think for my use for the prioritization process, important to know what the Forest Service's thoughts are, not just sharp on our ability. I don't want to waste my time butting my head against a wall to get past something that the Forest Service really doesn't think is appropriate. So I would like to see your preferences as well so I can have the information from both sides. You know, in talking to the District Ranger, there's nothing that he said is,

2:42:32 Off the table. There's some that he feels like Solitude Canyon and the connector up to the bluffs that he knows are going to have more controversy, have potential resource issues, and his advice that he, I think, is very, why his advice? Why bite off something that's going to create controversy and slow progress of the other projects? He wants to see this move forward like everybody else, or like most of us. So that was his advice.

2:42:58 And we will have to probably look at those in the cumulative effects analysis, so it's important to understand the resource issues with those projects as well. That's why I think really the plan to try to get as much of the resource inventory done as possible is a good one. It may not have to be as thorough in some places as others. John, you're going to be here for the July 8th meeting, correct? I hope so. We'll see. Well, so you say that just because I think your input's going to be critical. Yeah, I plan on being here.

2:43:27 Couple of irons in the fire, but I don't think I'll be leaving before that. Maybe I'll just put as a footnote at the end of this meeting just to track who is potentially here for July 8th. Okay. Because I know I'm not. So I just want to make sure that we identify a quorum. I plan to be barring my wife goes into labor sooner than the plan. Oh, okay.

2:43:52 Congratulations. You know, if she's in labor, I can probably skip out for at least a half hour. Trust me, they don't need your help. Okay, so we're moving this to the 8th. We are moving this. Is there any other discussion, John Wentworth? I'll entertain your comments. Yeah, this is an extremely important, significant project. And I'm going to echo what John Kazmierski said in terms of establishing priorities. What are your priorities?

2:44:22 Those need to be known. I think the other thing you need to start doing is start doing some cost estimating. This is going to cost a lot of money to start doing these things. You've got a NEPA wagon going. I think it makes a lot of sense to direct your staff or whatever to start looking at, okay, what is the soft surface trail going to cost per mile? I think you need to start thinking in terms of who's going to be building these things. The Forest Service makes a lot of sense for the Forest Service to do this NEPA work. It's very efficient to do it that way. But I'm anticipating if there are mountain bike trails, if there are equestrian trails, you may need to be talking about

2:44:51 Outside contractors to build a lot of this stuff. I don't know how that's going to work. But most importantly, I'm interested to know how you're going to reach out to the members of the Sherman's Working Group. This was a pretty significant collaborative effort. This was 30, 40 people, eight meetings over a summer. We kept that whole thing together all the way through. And we produced, all of us produced that document. I would advise you to find a way to reach out to the members of that group so that you start establishing priorities between both agencies.

2:45:20 You've got some input from those folks. I think it would be you could be creating a hornet's nest where you wouldn't need to build one if you didn't do the proper outreach and say we want some of these folks in the table. If we agendize this item for the July 8th meeting, would it be appropriate for Steve Spidell to be reaching out to those groups? John Wentworth, should it be you? I think that's kind of soon. I think I can. In the process, it seems to me, because we're talking about resource surveys at this point in the process.

2:45:49 And I think what John was asking, what Cass was asking was, are there any that we want to reject out of hand now? Or defer, I think, is what I heard. But nonetheless, I think even that making that decision without hearing from the participants of the Sherwin's working group, I think would, you know, be a little presumptuous on our part. So I think that what we need to make clear is that the July 8th meeting

2:46:16 To the Sherwins Working Group is an important meeting to attend. I just say that's a really good idea. You need to get all those folks understanding that stuff's moving forward and, you know, we're not trying to weed out any of the trails but trying to figure out which ones to tackle first and how to package them. I think what's really challenging with that is getting those members to understand some of the things that I described before as far as

2:46:43 How to strategy, I guess, you know, how to strategize and how to package. And I think you want to make those issues known to the group, and I'd be happy to repeat what I just said so that everybody hears that on July 8th. I think there's also people in the community that did not participate in the Sherwins Working Group that we need to make sure we're hearing. I would encourage you to hear from them. But then, as Sandy said, there is the formal...

2:47:08 Process to comment on these trails, but I like the idea of including as many people as possible now. I would hope that that can be a very lengthy process. When you have 40 people who were very involved in this project and they care about it a lot, if they all show up on the 8th, be ready for a three-hour meeting about this.

2:47:32 Bill Taylor just made a good point that, you know, this almost sounds like a separate workshop and not that I want to, and I agree with what he just said, not that I want to propose another meeting, but you're absolutely right. But for the second time today you are. Let's propose a second meeting. Although what I was thinking was if we really focus the agenda item. So it's not a broad brush, let's rediscuss sharp, but focusing on the specific question that Kaz asked. You're not asking the

2:48:00 Public. What trails do you want to keep and why? It's are there any that you think aren't high priorities? And that's the only question for the day. Maybe we can keep it shorter, but even, you know, I mean, it's going to take really tight control and focus because, you know, that, as Kat has pointed out, if we get 40 people in the room and everybody's got an opinion. And my point is not to say reconvene the Sherman's working group and all of us are all over again. That's not.

2:48:29 I think, John, I think we're kind of at the same page. Let's get ahead of it. Let's get the people knowing that this process is happening. I think it's also going to be an invaluable opportunity for this committee to start establishing expectations as to what can be done. You're looking at doing a NEPA. The other question might be in your summers, where's the CEQA in all this? But I guess... We've... That's actually... I should be saying that all along. This is the NEPA-CEQA... It's a joint... Yeah, so... But the town has their role in helping...

2:48:56 Crap, the CEQA. We're doing the resource inventories to inform that. So when they're out there doing the inventories, they're looking at the state-sensitive species list as well as the federal. So you're getting environmental analysis probably, maybe, for everything. But in terms of actually building all this stuff, constructing it and maintaining it, I think it's an invaluable opportunity for this committee to start saying, OK, if we were to build every trail in the system, I could give you all the multipliers. It would cost X millions of dollars.

2:49:23 Now, Measure Art, we can't pay for all that. So the John's point about phasing, what are our priorities here? Get maybe some sort of a consensus from participants. What do we kind of want to do first so that you get that buy-in from the beginning and you're not dealing with the opportunity or arbitrary committee decisions down the road, which I think could be more of a problem than doing it. But that's not the question you were asking as I understood it. It was that you're putting the specialists in the field.

2:49:49 Yes. And if there's something they don't need to look at, you want to know about it. If they need to look at everything, and maybe that's our decision, then they'll look at everything. They look at everything. It would be nice to prioritize it a little bit because the botanical window is short, especially this year. So if we have a trail that we just don't get to, which trail would that be this year?

2:50:18 I think you don't want to look at it as, you know, we're not going to do that project. It's just which ones do we want to move forward first? How do we want to package this up? John, just for grins, if, let's take the connector from Tamarack out, what are we calling it, the backbone trail? Which I have in a view as a very important trail. But for price concerns, in our phasing, would it be possible to start that out as a soft surface? Yeah. And then later bring that in?

2:50:49 Absolutely. The proposed action, we just have to frame it up that way. We intend on constructing at first a soft surface trail that would then be developed into a multiple-use path. So yeah, I think that's a good strategy. I don't want to ignore the money part of this. It is extremely important. We don't want to be planning anything that we'll never build. But what we've said all along, the Forest Service staff and the town staff have discussed, is let's get this neap on the shelf. It's very hard to find money for planning.

2:51:18 It's easier. It's not very easy, but it's easier to find money to build stuff. It's very difficult to find money to maintain stuff. So we want to get the planning done for, I believe, as much of this as we possibly can. Get it on the shelf. Make it competitive for a construction grant. Before we commit to any grant that builds it, we need to figure out how does the town or do we have the money to maintain it. Well, and one of the key points is actually the pave mups or anything that's ADA.

2:51:47 Those are the most competitive. I mean, they actually, that's the kind of trail that we can go after a grant. The LTC has funded a number of, you know, helped fund a number of these through federal and state grants. John, I'm going to ask you to sit down for a second because Jeanette was waiting and we're not there just yet. The other thing I'd like to point out too is that I think the town has a certain expectation about the type of trail that they want to build and maintain, being that a MUP.

2:52:17 So to Bill's idea of coming in soft first and then expanding it, that may have some internal problems. I'll point that out. All right. Danette, did you have any comment? And again, I'm going to ask you to keep it quick. I just wanted to say, John, I thought that was a really good presentation. And I just recently, with a friend, walked the Sherwin behind Snow Creek and through that. And I thought it was maintained really well. We didn't have any issues. And I think...

2:52:47 For me, I love that trail. I think it's great, and there's quite a few people driving on it, which I was a little surprised, but that was just my opinion. I just wanted to say that was a great presentation, and I think that a lot of people would have a lot of input on the trails. Thanks, Diane. What's the way of dealing with this, then? Is this something that we can handle on July 8th, or are we going to need a separate workshop? I think initially we can handle this on July 8th.

2:53:18 I think what they're asking for is the exclusionary, and I think we can do that among ourselves very quickly. And not even talking exclusionary, it's more deferred. Yeah. Because I think we've all bought into Sharp. It's just, I think he's just asking. Okay. Steve, can you word the agenda item then for the July 8th meeting to be pretty specific that we are not reopening discussion, you know, reconvening the Sharp working group, but essentially

2:53:47 Specifically answering the questions that you've asked us here today, which is what can be excluded. If you were to try to frame it in a way that is going to capture interest from those who participated in the past, but also not reopen the door for rehashing Sherwin Working Group, maybe it's planning strategy or something like that. You're strategizing on the NEPA-SEQA planning processes for these sharp projects. I don't know.

2:54:18 That's what we're doing, I think. Any other discussion on this, John? Do you have a... Just a quick question. If, Steve, if you're going to have particular phrasing you want to use for the agenda item, if we could get it in advance, that would be helpful so we're all on the same page. We're not saying something different from what you might be saying. If that's possible.

2:54:41 That's a fair request, Steve, standard procedure. Comfortable with that? Yeah, just if we get the agenda, if you get it in advance or something. The other thing, Sandy, is that background trail has been designed as an ADA trail. Yeah, I know it has. Exactly with that in mind. I know it has, exactly. Thank you. Yes. Okay then, so we've completed that. Our agenda shows that we've got at least 45 more minutes with the discussion ends, however it is, 4.30. You know, I'm frustrated that we keep...

2:55:08 Postponing the mission and vision, fortunately we did get to discuss it last time, but essentially we do need to adjourn this meeting, I fear, and that what I would like to do though, unless there's any further discussion with regard to the additional agenda items, perhaps we should just at least make sure that everyone's on the same page with regard to future agenda items, if there are any new projects that need to be mentioned, and that the one thing that I would say before I

2:55:39 I want to make sure that the mission and vision is at the beginning of the next agenda, at the next meeting's agenda. You know, we've only got a working discussion. Will you show that in your PowerPoint as a draft then? Because in the PowerPoint, mission and vision were, you present that as a preliminary or draft, something like that, fuzzy, that we are working on it.

2:56:12 One of the things too that I'd like to point out is that the third page of that agenda item is a list of discussion points related to strategy and prioritization establishment. So if we have any time today, I might suggest that we at least look at that and begin a very quick discussion or to use those as guiding points to

2:56:43 Our next meeting and discussion of Sharp. Can we discuss that then briefly here before we adjourn this meeting? How brief is brief? Let's take five minutes. Can we do it in five minutes? Yep. Steve, that's fine. I'm for it. So with regard to page three, options for discussion related to strategy and priority establishment, you know, I had a couple of comments on there as well, but do you want to make a presentation for us, Steve? No. For brevity, it's out there. Let's talk about it.

2:57:14 Does anyone else want to start? Okay, which one are we talking about now? You've confused me. I put it all the way. This is business item number nine. And part of our handout, there was an options for discussion. And we're going straight to page three and the options for discussion related to the strategy and priority establishment. And, Steve, do you want to start? Well, I think, Chair, the priorities for funding, I think that's something that's familiar to the Measure R, Measure U process. That's something I think.

2:57:43 It's been established in the past. Commission's taken that on. So has the Measure U Committee. So what staff has done here is try to compile a lot of probably elements contiguous with those funding cycles that have been held in the past and trying to maintain some connectivity to the trial system. So that's the priorities of funding. And then the strategies is really trying to seek some

2:58:07 You know, short, medium, long-term direction, you know, of this committee and the trail system in general. So that was, that was kind of how this is structured. So it's probably a great starting point. I think we'll be adding to it. I think it's probably a good, a good discussion item. And I would probably recommend that to committee members, you know, look at this and prepare to come to discuss it in greater detail at the next item, in the next meeting, so. Yeah, I only wrote down one comment on my paper on it, and that was priority for funding number three.

2:58:35 Continuation of reoccurring programs. It's the only one I really took issue with. It should say after re-evaluation or some or because not everything is reoccurring. After we look at it, it's something we want to just move forward. That's a good point. But if we're going to discuss this again later.

2:58:55 I didn't eat dope in my mouth there, did I? Well, no, I think this is important. This is okay. And again, we're going to keep this really short, but that's actually a good point. I like the idea of continuation of reoccurring programs after review. Yeah. You know, the only comment that I had with regard to the strategies was with regard to point number three, maximizing community engagement. There were a couple points there. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, certainly keeping them engaged.

2:59:24 However, the high-altitude training, I'm not entirely sure that that specifically was something to the trails. I mean, obviously, that's something the Recreation Commission has put high on its list. But with regard to trails, I'm not sure how much that totally ties into what we're talking about with regard to this committee. You're just making that note. You could actually just consider just removing Maximize and just put community engagement or active community engagement with, you know, such and such.

2:59:51 Maximize might be a word that you might. Actually, the way I would change that is I'd get rid of the bullet points and just leave maximum community engagement. Because if we're really going to get into who we're going to engage with, we would have to include everybody from the Striders to the snowmobile group to the motorcycle group to the... You could just say what recreation uses. Yeah. Maximize community engagements with recreationists would be fine. I have no problem with that. Yes.

3:00:20 To get down and start doing bullet points, yeah, it doesn't work. Well, and it might be better to certainly list the user groups, but I just was, you know, yeah, if we're going to include high altitude training, you know, I can think of dozens more. So it might be best to just remove these bullet points. We want to maximize community engagement. We've said that several times today already. I agree wholeheartedly with that. The other comment that I had was with regard to the strategies about developing promotional activities. You know, in a lot of ways, that's...

3:00:49 Kind of, you know, are we talking about marketing? Are we talking about activities that, you know, like the opening day promotions that we talked about? I'm not sure exactly what all that means. But, you know, I kind of had a question there with regard to promotional activities. You know, does that really tie into what Mammoth Lakes Tourism job is as far as marketing goes? Or how much do we want to actually be pushing promotional activities? Yeah, but we want it to be there. Well, again, my only...

3:01:18 Comment would be, I don't know that we need to list how we're going to be there, because those are strategies to be developed, but it is certainly important in what we do through the website, through the... Mm-hmm. We should discuss, I mean, let's think about it, I understand what you're saying. We can maybe wordsmith this a little more deal. I'd like to think of it, because the strategies are the major efforts

3:01:52 At a high level, we're going to be undertaking to achieve our mission and vision. Yeah. So we're kind of doing it backwards. Yeah. We haven't got the mission, so. But I think these are good. Don't get me wrong. I think it's all good discussion. Good start. Just a little later discussion. Yeah. It is, yeah. John, do you have a quick call? Just be brief. That's a lot. Yeah, no, it's no problem. Just in your discussions, and I appreciate mission, vision, all these things you've got to do, I'm a little concerned that the trail system master plan seems to be kind of,

3:02:23 I'm not sure where it lives with you guys. And I think it's going to be very important that it's very clear that you guys appreciate that document, the value of it, all the things that are in there, and that you're tiering everything you're doing, that that's where you start from. I think that's going to be critical for your credibility to make sure everybody understands that that's where you're starting from. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. Are we comfortable moving on at this point? Yep. You know, and I don't know if there's any, just real quick, I'm going to ask, does anyone want to add any new projects to the tracking list at this time?

3:03:03 Okay. And it sounds like our next meeting will be July 8th. Point of order. Yes. Can we open and close 10 or do something with 10? We'll spawn it. The opening, continue the discussion regarding annual opening event. Yeah, my comment would be the same. We've already opened for this year. Yep. All right. So let's post working on that so that we can come up with an annual strategy. Yep.

3:03:33 So I think what we're discussing here, Steve, is that we're going to postpone it indefinitely. Put it at the bottom of the list on every meeting. So then you asked for new projects? I did ask for new projects. And I was, again, I want to say that we have accomplished quite a bit. And every single time I come into this meeting, I think that we're going to get through stuff, but get through it all. But, you know,

3:04:03 We are getting a lot of things accomplished here. It's just there's a lot to cover. A lot to cover. All righty then. Would you like to make a motion or anyone? So July 8th, where's for everybody? July 8th. I will remind that it sounds like those of you that can attend the June 19th Town Council meeting because Steve will be making a presentation. We're highly encouraged to be there.

3:04:35 And so far I have a motion. I made a motion. Second. A second. All those in favor of adjourning this meeting? Oh, wait, wait. Not the first. No, eighth. Because the eighth doesn't help you see me. I thought it was always the first Monday. The Monday of the first full week. Oh, that actually would be the first week. And Sunday starts the week. Sunday starts the week. But we bumped it off for the commission as well because it's...

3:05:05 It would have been... But it's at 1.30. It precedes the... At 1.30, that's okay. It always precedes the commission meeting, and commission meets on the... The 9th? Yeah, because it was the week of the 4th, that's a holiday week, so we'd have a... Okay, okay, okay. No, that's all right. It's at 1.30, that's okay. Okay, I have... I think we were voting on adjourning this meeting. Aye. Aye. We're done. Thank you very much.