TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2013

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 51 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

240 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Thank you.

0:24 Thank you.

0:52 Thank you. Thank you.

0:59 Yes. And I choose to do that. It's the smartest thing I get. Because this is, like, this will go down the other place. It's going to take a touch. My brother's going to wear this in this house so far. Yeah.

1:24 Thank you.

1:48 Thank you.

2:09 Thank you.

2:55 Yeah, yeah.

3:15 How are you? Good, thank you.

3:33 Yes, next blue sheet. No more opening day. Oh, all right. Better than that. Great horses. Opening day.

3:49 Okay, good afternoon everybody. Welcome to the Town Council of Memphis special meeting for Tuesday.

4:18 July 9th, roll call please. Council Member Leighton. Here. Council Member Leighton. Here. Council Member Leighton. Here. Council Member Leighton. Here. Council Member Leighton. Here. Here. If, no, we aren't doing the pledge. No. Habit overtakes me. Now is the time for public comment, which is the appointed time for any member of the public who wishes to speak to the council on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Anybody have something to say other than on what we're going to be talking about today, which is the strategic planning session?

4:48 Yes, sir. Mr. Walker. Yes. Oh, you remember. I do. Yeah, Gary Walker. I don't have anything critical to say today. I want to congratulate this group for doing a planning session and priorities. I've attended a lot of city council meetings and board of supervisor meetings in different counties and cities. It's really amazing how many don't take the time to do this. I know it's a difficult exercise, but I think you're doing the right thing.

5:21 And I've been very impressed with your city manager, with your, with Stuart Brown, and members of your, and I was impressed with the last meeting. So I think you're doing the right thing, and I just encourage you to keep it up. Thank you. All right, the podium is still open for members of the public who have a comment to make on something other than what's on the agenda. All right.

5:49 I was reminded by Mayor Pro Tem Bacon that there is an updated working agenda for today. It's in the back. It's got yellow on it. If anybody wants one, there are plenty in the back, and we'll be happy to have you take a look at that. That's what we have before us. And with that, we'll go to policy matter number one. The Town Council will conduct a strategic planning session. This is a continuation of what we began yesterday.

6:19 And, Mariana, how would you like to proceed? Do you want to provide a summary from at least your and my perspective, having put this thing together? And I don't want to take credit where credit is not due. It's something that I had some participation in, but it's really Mariana's document based upon what she heard from Council yesterday.

6:44 And so I don't mean to suggest that we have somehow come to conclusions together about what Council has done, but it is an effort and I think a good one to summarize and put brackets around what we discussed yesterday. Thank you, Mayor. Mayor, members of the Council, yes, what's before you and copies are available for the public as a working agenda. We wanted to make sure that we give you tools for today to conduct this meeting as effectively as possible.

7:14 So what I have attempted to do is in this document, which is really less than two pages, on the first page, the first section under the summary of the July 8th discussion, we attempted to summarize what we think occurred yesterday. And what we think occurred yesterday is some consensus was forming, perhaps not fully formed, but was forming along

7:40 Three priorities. One is to fund political commitment areas at the current level and those include tourism and marketing, transit and housing. The second priority area is revenue generation and there are three components to that. One is to support economic development as well as the zoning code update.

8:06 Two is to continue TOT enforcement and that effort is fully staffed. We have two full-time positions and incumbents in those positions. And three is to seek and support additional revenue raising through the TBIT effort, not directly related to TBIT, but any TOT and sales tax and so on that will come as a result. I did want to include a note, and the note really comes from me.

8:35 Because there was a lot of discussion and has been a lot of discussion about what happens once the TBID goes into effect. Will be there additional revenue? Can we include that revenue in the budget? I am not comfortable including the revenue by itself without some backup. So if you decide to include the discussion of additional revenue,

9:03 Or to include the additional revenue as part of your balancing plan for the next year, I think there needs to be some discussion of how MLT's allocation would be impacted if that additional revenue doesn't come in because there needs to be a backup plan. So that's the note in yellow for discussion. And thirdly, the third area that we believed you had some consensus on

9:30 Is the area of recreation specifically related to the MLR process? What we recommend you do today is clarify the above three priorities, have a discussion on them, give us direction on whether we're accurate in stating those priorities, and discuss no more than two additional priorities for a total of five. And we recommend two more, effective management,

9:58 With several sub items including IT, finance system replacement, sufficient staffing and I specifically highlighted public safety where additional staffing is needed but also finance where I believe staffing is sufficient but we are currently looking at the organizational structure of that department.

10:23 And the last priority that you may wish to consider is infrastructure, specifically related to road maintenance. So I think I'll stop here. The rest of the agenda talks about next steps, and we'll get there hopefully in the last few minutes of this meeting. Thank you, Mayor. Okay, questions of the town manager, first of all. You know, I have one that... Oh, go ahead, sorry. Miranda, just...

10:52 Can you just clarify what your recommendation MLT's allocation, traditional revenue targets for TOT and sales tax? Can you just go over that one more time, please? Sure. So if I'm not recommending that we increase TOT or sales tax revenue targets from the budgeted estimates. I'm not recommending. I'm not comfortable doing that. However, if the council decides to do that,

11:19 And gets assurance from MLT and the lodging community that the COT is going to go up by an X amount and or the sales tax is going to go up by an X amount in the current fiscal year beyond the budgeted amounts. We can't just include that in the budget. We need to have some backup if that revenue doesn't come in. So if that revenue doesn't come in, that money has to come from elsewhere. And I think the only place for it to come is from MLT's budget. There's a natural connection.

11:48 It's not a very comfortable thought, and again, I would prefer not to increase revenues in the first place, but if there's a decision to do that, that would be my recommendation. Okay. Well, at what point would we be having a discussion about increasing revenues? I mean, we adopted a budget last month and projected revenues at a specific amount that then obviously translates, based upon MLT's percentage of that, into a dollar figure. Right.

12:18 At what point does that change? We are planning to have quarterly financial reviews for the council every quarter. In the past you had your mid-year budget basically at a six-month period. We're hoping to be on a quarterly schedule so your first review would be sometime in November. I doubt, however, that we'll see any direct impact from TBED as of September because that reporting would be for...

12:48 So you may need to wait until mid-year or even longer to see any direct impact from TBIT. But the gap for me, and Jo, maybe you can help me with this because I imagine you might be able to understand it better than I, is that at the time that we do the quarterly review, are you suggesting that we're going to reproject revenues for the remainder of the fiscal year at that time? If data warrants it, then we will. Then staff will recommend it.

13:17 If we get to mid-year where we would have some of the larger months anyway and the TBID has been approved and the additional revenue has come in, then it would not only be recognizing that revenue but potentially considering whether or not to increase our estimated revenue. Okay. Yeah, it's just a different way of saying the same thing. Which would affect MLT's measure allocation. Yes, but what Marianna is saying, in a way it does, because if we have more revenue, they get more. Right.

13:46 Possibly. But on the other hand, she's saying is if we decided right now to bank on money that hasn't come in the door yet, then if the money didn't come in, she's recommending that anything was expended would have to come out of the Measure A. Right, I understand. Or the REU. The other part of what you're saying is, and please correct me if I misspeak, but it's my understanding that

14:15 When we do that quarterly review or mid-year, whenever it ends up being or both, let's say it's quarterly and let's say in November we have revenues that come in for July, August, and September. Then at that time, at the end of that quarter, just from normal, we have a better TOT revenue.

14:39 And this proposed addition takes it off the table, does it not?

15:08 Well, we should just strike it through. This proposed addition would only be in effect if you decided to increase revenues today or in the next week or so from the adopted budget, which I resist. I would not be willing to do that. Let's wait until we have it in our hand. If we have it in our hand, yes. Yeah, I think we went over that yesterday. Yeah, so.

15:39 Okay. I had sort of seen it exactly the opposite of what you were proposing, which is evident from my confusion. But just to make sure, so should TOT start to increase, then the percentages going or the calculations going to any of the pieces of A and T would potentially increase. Right. Well, again, it goes up naturally with it. Yeah.

16:07 It doesn't decrease. But that's different. Yeah. I'm saying is if you were going to bank on it coming in and it didn't coming in, it would have to be balanced out using measure A. Right. But if we don't bank on it, then it's simply a natural percentage. Yeah. And I think at every quarter or even at the mid-year, if we happen to have additional revenues, then at that time we can start to consider.

16:28 Right, and then there's two things. You either deal with just recognizing and using that revenue, or you talk about whether or not you want to change your projections at that point when you've got some data. The question that I had actually was with respect to the TOT enforcement, which is, as I understand it, in the last budget, in the current budget, we have funded two positions.

16:57 Do you as a staff feel or find a need for more than two in order to effectively collect that, well, to effectively enforce the code? The reason I ask that question is that I don't know whether you're getting the emails that we're getting, but we're getting a lot of emails on both sides of the SFR rental issue. And many of those emails...

17:24 So, I'm just wondering if

17:53 The problem could be or should be addressed by the addition of another compliance specialist as opposed to simply leaving it at two, recognizing that we've only had one for a while. I personally believe that at two we're fully staffed, that could we use a third one? We could use another person, but I do think that we're appropriately staffed at two.

18:20 Two things, well actually three things as caveat to that statement. One is you may recall that we're moving to new technology, basic gov, from the antiquated financial system that should allow taxpayers

18:35 To pay their taxes online as far as business license tax and TOT is concerned, that that should make it much easier not only for the taxpayers to bring their money in, but also for those positions to track that revenue. Secondly, John Urri actually offered to us to pay for the third position out of his own budget if we could prove that it's going to cost cover itself. I'm still waiting for that cost cover calculation from staff.

19:03 Which to me suggests that the position is either not going to cost cover itself or they simply don't have strong need for it. But an offer is still out there. It's an open offer. And at any time we could give that proof to him, I'm sure he'll give us support. And lastly, I am aware undoubtedly of a few cases where houses have been rented on a month-to-month rental agreement.

19:29 But people come and go on a daily basis under that rental agreement. And it's a loophole that unfortunately we can't control with the current legal means that we have. So it's possible that's what's happening in some of the cases that you mentioned. So one of the things that I heard yesterday was that we've collected several hundred thousand dollars of what would otherwise be uncollected revenue. Do we know...

19:57 Do we know what the breakdown is of where that is coming from, meaning homes versus condominiums? We can't have a breakdown in the current antiquated financial system between homes and condominiums. We do know that almost all of that $700,000 collected over an 18-month period is from illegal rentals. But can't you tell that just by an address?

20:23 Manually, we'll have to go through manual hard copy reports and do that calculation, but it's going to take that. That seems to me to be pretty important data. Homes versus condos? Yeah. Would it be fair to say that once BasicGov's in, which should be about a month, we'll be able to do that? Yeah. Okay. It's going to be exportable, yeah. Okay, thank you. Other questions of staff? All right.

20:48 So what I thought we might or could do is take this first section with respect to what we perceive to be the three general areas of agreement and ask the council whether it wants to either expand on them or take away from them or add a subsection to any one of them. I will note in number three, recreation, just because it's not on there, that council may recall that that

21:17 I had a couple thoughts I'd like to add, if I may. With regard to our fund our political commitment areas, and I think Michael brought something up yesterday with regard to housing, and that was maybe looking at our needs and addressing how we might be able to

21:49 Change the way we're doing business there. And a thought that came to mind, I think we've discussed it before, but if we have, and I think when we originally passed the housing, its original intent was to provide workforce housing and support for workforce housing for our essential needs in our community. And I think we've done that to some extent, but I'm wondering if we can expand on that. Could we turn to housing and ask them to look deeper and see if there aren't grants out there?

22:18 Perhaps for city employees, specifically police employees and things of that nature. Reason being, if we could find sufficient housing, let's say subsidies that were out there, maybe we could work with our labor associations on exchanging subsidy for general funds that are going to these specific departments, freeing up general fund money.

22:48 So I thought that might be one area if we could dig a little deeper and find out if there's any funding specifically for municipal employees, that would be something that could come around and benefit us. And then on item number C, where we were talking about allocation of funds, and I think we brought up, you know, John Urdi offering up this money. I think, to be a little bit more specific, I think the money instead of

23:17 Saying that it can be offered back to us. I mean, that's still public money. I think we should look at that money as a business tax area. Because by looking at the business tax funds and using those funds to fund a TOT position, we're still keeping a nexus between business licensing businesses and between the needs that we have here in the municipality. So I want to be a little bit more specific on that. And then further,

23:43 There is about $250,000 there. I think instead of looking at the entire $250,000 as a revenue source, I think I would ask that the council look specifically at the needs that we have. So if it's funding a third position and it costs us $75,000, then we use $75,000 of the $250,000, not the entire $250,000, and try to find funding. So those are just two of my thoughts I have on the three priorities we have above.

24:13 Mr. Mayor, I have a suggestion or recommendation. I'm kind of sitting here in a daze right now. We're going back and forth through these things, and there's no continuity. I would recommend that we just start with number one and just go down the list individually and talk about each one.

24:32 As they come up rather than hopscotch and rent. What I wanted to do initially was to see whether there are additional areas. As you can see on the second part of that, we're proposing two additional areas, effective management, infrastructure, maybe more as well. There's no rule that says we have to. No, I was just thinking I'd like to get through the first three and then move on to the next section.

24:55 Well, John, I can get through the first three in 27 seconds. Go ahead. I am fine with all of them. However, I think that at this point in time, 2C should refer to it as through the proposed TBID effort since it's not approved at this point. Thanks. And I'm fine with all of it. And I'm not, and that's why I wanted to bring it up. Go ahead. So that's why I thought if we went through them individually, we could, is everybody fine with number one, yes or no input?

25:24 Number two, so on and so forth. All right, why don't you take a stab at number one? I'm fine, yes. Yes. So I want to, I want to, let's take on number one just for a second. What I'm hearing, the broad priority is to essentially have unchanged what we have adopted in our budget, which is maintenance of the political commitments. And then our budget has

25:55 identified how the various measures, monies are going to be spent. Matthew, what I'm wondering is, are you suggesting that we add as a priority an examination of one of the political commitments to... No, I'm not. I guess I'm just... I guess maybe I'm throwing it out there just as... in honoring these political commitments, I'm throwing something out there that just maybe...

26:24 Maybe it's too narrow of a stroke versus a broad stroke, but something to consider, I think. So here's what I think, what came to my mind when I was hearing it was, and as you know, I sit on the housing board as the council representative. You know, we need to regularly complete housing studies and have strategic planning sessions or session.

26:48 And I'm looking at Jennifer because I don't know when our next strategic planning session is scheduled, but it just seems to me that those are issues that legitimately the housing board ought to take on and bring back to council. And in doing that, I would expect to solicit input from council members to try to have an understanding from council as its representative what areas it wants to examine, because I think that your questions are good ones.

27:17 But I think that ought to be handled by the housing board, and it seems to me that I should make a commitment on its behalf to bring forward in whatever a timely way is that which we would do in both of those areas, both the housing studies so that we can clearly identify the current needs, and we do that regularly, and also, or it is done for us regularly, and also a strategic planning session so that the board can

27:47 Come back to you and say, listen, this is where we want to go. This is how we think we should be expanding the funds that you give to us. Maybe just a suggestion. No, I'm not looking to add it as another priority. I think we keep our broad strokes. One of the benefits I just saw, particularly with the police, was we have a lot of officers living out of town, and I think the chief has addressed an issue if there were something to happen.

28:14 Five minutes away or two minutes away, we're in a lot of cases 30 minutes or 60 minutes away. So just, yeah, maybe a recommendation or suggestion. Mayor, if I may, I also wanted to remind the Council that we're yet to re-examine and extend contracts of Mammoth Lakes Housing and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Their contracts are old, they're month-to-month, and actually they expired at the end of June.

28:37 John Uri and I are meeting on his contract on Monday and hopefully will bring that before you very soon. We need to do the same on Mammoth Lakes Housing contract and I think in that context these questions and these requests need to be made so we can include them in the scope of it. Okay, number two, revenue generation. John, you want to start with that one? Yes, sir, thank you. I'm thinking that from

29:08 What we're finding out as far as the loss of employees, I'm not sure that at this point the hiring of an economic development director, a full department manager, would be the appropriate move. We might want to spend the money that we're thinking for that position today on a couple of worker bees, I would call them lower level staffers, that can get work done in that area. I'm not sure that we're ready at this moment for a director's position.

29:39 So that's a fairly specific priority and meaning changing a priority from hiring a director to hiring additional staff to get the work done like the zoning code update. That's correct. Zoning code update is actually grant money, isn't it? And it's on schedule. No, I understand. What's your thought, counsel?

30:08 I'm fine with going ahead and filling the position because we've got so many of the other things that we're still going to have to consider to be ready for investment that we need that position and to a certain degree it would free up time where we have a senior planner, that's your title right now? Yeah.

30:28 Acting in two positions that either it becomes her job and we hire a new senior planner or we get someone else and she goes back to senior planner work and either way that gives us more worker bee. I'm just thinking that's a big dollar number to fill that position and it might make sense to get somebody in there to do work that she's doing now. That's just my feeling. Let me tell you what I thought when I

30:58 When I looked at this, I don't see the establishment, first of all, I don't see the establishment of five priorities as being in order of one through five. They're five big priorities. Other council members, the council might feel differently, but that's the way that I see it, because we don't have just one priority. We have a whole bunch. I think what I'm trying to get, and I think what the council was saying yesterday, is to have staff focus on

31:28 What's going to be required in order to make that department most productive? And we've expanded the role of the Planning Commission and expanded the role of the department from just planning. It's not just a name, economic development. We want to do more. And so I don't see this as limiting at all. Frankly, I see it as a statement and direction to staff, which is, hey, we want to support this department for the reasons that we stated yesterday.

31:56 I don't know that I'd really want to get down to the level of choosing whether it ought to be two employees or whether it ought to be a director. Personally, I think we're going to have a hard time finding one. And that was exactly what I was going to say. I mean, we know what's going on. And correct me if I'm wrong, but I think we've already put out requisition for this position in our first go-around. We didn't get qualified people. We've got interviews set up.

32:21 Yeah, that's fine. I'm just saying, the first go around, we didn't get qualified people for this position, and if you don't get qualified people, do you just hire someone who's not qualified to fill that quote-unquote position, or it might be easier to get people at a lower level to come in to do the work that we want to, and maybe in six months, maybe in another year, we say, okay, we're ready for this position.

32:47 Well, I'm not going to second guess our town manager working on a plan to restructure, and I'll also let you know that I had the opportunity to sit in on the personnel and risk analyst position interviews, and there were very good candidates there. What does that have to do with that? I'm just saying that having that, you might have presumed that nobody would apply for anything based on the, quote, current conditions, and we had some very good candidates, so I think you will see that in any position.

33:15 We didn't see it on the first go-around on this position, Jo. But Marianna just told you that she has interviews scheduled, and no, I don't think she's going to hire someone just to fill it. We can always look at interim and other things if that doesn't work, but I see this position is very important, and I'm going to go with her suggestion that she knows best how to do the detailed staffing in our departments. Make a motion and we'll vote on it. Marianna, do you understand we had ten applicants and three?

33:45 Three are getting interviewed, is that? I believe we can at least stand, and we're interviewing the top three, and Mr. Eastman, it is a very challenging position, because as you know, we're looking for someone to do A to Z, to be a worker bee, as you said, really serve people at the counter, but also do high-level economic development staff. Those three applicants seem to have it both, but once we see them in the interview, they may or may not have it.

34:11 So the interest was quite good, 10 applications at the very least. I'm pleased that we have at least three to interview, and we have interviews set up for July 22nd, I believe. However, to your point, you know, it's a sensitive discussion in the sense that I function and my training is such that you give me that authority and that responsibility to make these decisions. And you hired me for that job.

34:41 And I consult with staff. I don't make those decisions in a vacuum. We could go back after the interviews if we don't see a good candidate who can do it all and sit down with staff and say, what else can we do? Should we look at a lower level assistant plan or some other position and economic development management? So you still get two functions, but you get two bodies.

35:05 I would be happy to consider that right now. We actually discussed internally that possibility but then said we have these interviews coming up. Let's see what happens. If we get a good candidate, we'll hire that candidate. If not, we'll go back and reconsider. So give us a little more time. I am always flexible in my thinking and so I could go one of those two ways but let's go through the interview process, see who we get.

35:32 And if the applicants are not strong, then we'll look at the second alternative. When again, when are those interviews? July 22nd, and we have a good panel that includes a council member, I think Matthews on that panel, has a planning commissioner, a community person, Sandra's on the panel, and we have myself and Pam Kobylarz as observers. Thanks. All right, so before we leave,

36:03 2A. What's the... I'm here... I've heard two views. What about everybody else? What are your thoughts on that? I want to either develop consensus or find... My view is that we stay with the plan. I mean, I'm very interested in filling that position, but obviously I want to be the right person that has the qualification to do the required work.

36:26 And I, you know, I agree. And I also look at, I'm just going back at Report 1 and Report A. I mean, it was even a recommendation by staff themselves. They weren't asking for additional employees in that department. Specifically, they were looking for a director. And so I guess I respect their input as well. I see where John's coming from. I do. You know, it makes you wonder,

36:54 John, I am as well because it is a

37:24 This is a priority. I mean, it's just a statement of priority as opposed to a directive to take a specific action. And what we're really saying is it's an important department. It's an important position to fill. It's remained unfilled for a long time. And the expectation is that something good is going to come out of it. That is, that economic development will occur in the event we've got somebody with that experience who can bring something new to what we have here.

37:51 So I'm hearing consensus at 401 on 2A. 2B, Matthew, this relates to your question about funding a third position for TOT enforcement. Do you have anything more on that? Yeah, I actually wasn't after a third position per se. I was just...

38:17 I was addressing some comments. I think Marianna had made some other suggestions. I think for me it's either a third position or enhancing what we have in some way or another to just make sure we have what we need in that department. My concern was if funds came out of there, just really more where they came from. I see. Yeah. And if staff needs that and if

38:40 If they feel that they need that help and if marketing feels that there's also some benefit to come from that enhancement piece, then I would support it. But this was how I would support it if they decided that. We've seen as a group that it's been a very successful program in the past year, and I think that it's universally supported by the council, staff, and the community. What will be interesting this year is...

39:07 Last year we got a pretty big bang because it was the first year. We got $500,000 or $600,000, whatever the number was, $700,000. It'll be interesting if we are able to match those kind of numbers this year because we've educated a certain level of the public to where they won't do it again. So it'll be interesting. But I agree. I think we'll start out with the two that are being proposed. And it's two full-time positions. That's pretty good for enforcement. And see how effective they are.

39:36 And I think a lot of it, too, because one of them has taken on a relatively new to the position, and the other one is brand new to it. And the other thing I think we need to understand as a council is that there's a process that they have to go through, and even though they've collected, I don't know, somewhere around $700,000 new dollars, I think there's a backlog of double that or triple that that's still in the pipeline.

40:03 Currently. And so as they keep going, I think a lot more of that's going to start coming forward. But I agree with you. I think it's going to be interesting to see how it looks over the next couple of years, whether that improves or if they're just starting to get their handle at the tip of the iceberg. It's going to be an interesting process. So do we – so Basic Gov is about a month or so away from – I am hoping – I ask that question on a weekly basis.

40:32 I'm hoping that the online portal is going to be available for the e-permitting, business license, and TOT. I understand there are challenges right now on both ends. Our staff is still going through a list of issues that, bugs, basically, that exist in the system, but staff in BasicGov is also challenged by vacation schedules and so on, so they're not as responsive as they used to be.

41:00 So I don't have an exact date. Nate Greenberg has been excellent in helping us to continue a connection and a conversation with BasicGov. And again, once I have a date, I'll let you know. So the reason I say that is because with TOT Collection on there, with the illegal activity going on, what are we anticipating? People will just, you know, they're renting illegally.

41:30 Homes and condos. Are they just going to show up and go pay TNT on there now all of a sudden? I mean, what's the thought process behind that? No, but the thought process... Sorry, this 700, it's actually, John said around $30,000, is from a legal activity. So, and as Matthew just mentioned, I mean, there's a backlog of two to three times that amount of money. So, what's going to happen all of a sudden? We have easy reporting available, but yet we still have...

41:59 It's illegal to rent. What are we doing to drive people to all of a sudden start paying us without having to chase them, I guess to my point. We're making a great step by doing it online. It's going to make it easier.

42:11 Is anyone going to show up and just go pay their bill? You're absolutely right. So several points to that. One is these positions are also in charge of monitoring and entering data for TOT and business license stacks. So that part of their job is going to be easier with the online system because they won't have to enter as much. They won't have to print reports and check and re-enter as much.

42:40 But you're right, whoever is entering illegally, we don't expect them to use the system to pay. So that effort will still continue. And that's frankly not going to go away. And frankly, once it goes away, once people stop renting, then we're in trouble because we won't have that revenue. So either we legalize or we're going to stop that activity. But there's also a portion of that market, so to speak, that rents, that rent in legal zones.

43:07 They just don't have proper certificates. So once they get their certificates, then it's going to be easier for them to pay online, and that piece is going to be automated as well. But again, the legal piece, like you said, is going to remain there, and that work will remain. As far as the backlog, it's not the backlog that staff can't catch up. It's just the process, and I think that's what Matthew was referring to. It needs to take its course. We send a notice, we send another notice, we contact them again, we contact them again.

43:36 If they don't pay or they appeal, then they come to the council and they appeal. So it's just time-wise there's a process. And that's exactly right. I mean, it is a process and it takes a lot of staff time. So I guess what my concern is, it's not going to stop. So we're just going to continue spending staff time over and over and over again chasing people down.

44:02 I mean, it's not, this problem is not going to go away. And I mean, by the amount of money that we're talking, we're not talking about a small amount of money, we're talking about a large amount of money, about a large amount of money that we're sitting here talking about that we need. And so, I'm just trying to figure out, you know, move forward, don't move forward, whatever it may be, but how are we going to address this is my point that I keep hammering on. The money's real, it's there.

44:31 We need to collect the revenue and not spend a ton of staff time and people coming to council every other meeting, you know, appealing to get away with, you know, a discounted rate, so to speak, that they owe us because that's kind of what's happened in the past. And it will continue to happen. So my point is, is how do we address it? How do we limit this amount of staff time it takes? Are we just, you know, continue to say,

45:00 Go get your license, go get your license, but people don't do it. Well, and some can do it in corridors are not even doing it either. So, you know, how do we really just take this on and then figure it out? So, Mr. Raimondo, I think where you had it, and let me know if I'm correct or not, there's a management question and there's a policy question. The management question, I think, is simple and I answered it, and that is, do you need more staff to generate more revenue? I am not convinced that if you give me an additional position,

45:30 That I could bring you more revenue at least in the amount that would equal that position's cost. I'm just not convinced. I'm not asking for a third position. The policy question is do you continue the current status quo with where the rentals are allowed versus where they're not allowed and make it very clear to the community we're not going to make a decision on that issue. We're going to keep the status quo and then we'll just continue going after the illegal rentals.

45:58 Or do you bring this item up for a discussion and make a decision? If you do, then staff is planning to ask you that question. Would you like to have a discussion? Would you like to reconsider the current status quo? We will be before you on August the 7th, I think, with a report, correct me if I'm wrong, Sandra, that will basically seek Council's direction for staff to go before the Planning Commission because that's the right avenue for us to take.

46:27 to pursue the question of single-family rentals. If you give us that direction, we'll go to the Planning Commission, and there's going to be a cost associated, because then we'll tell you what the cost is. Okay, thanks. So I thought that we took that off the table yesterday. Yeah. Consensus yesterday was to table it again. Okay. So no report from staff on August 7th. Yeah. That's easy. Michael, let me answer you in one way. I used to be in charge of the group that used to have to collect from probationers.

47:00 Talk about a tough group to go with. And the reality is, yes, you will always need to have an enforcement effort because it's both the actual sanction for those that get caught and the general sanction for everyone else who knows they might get caught. So you will have it. But if we've been working with one to two people plus some pieces of some other people, the return is still high enough that I'm willing to fund the two general fund-funded positions.

47:29 If in the work that Marianna does with John Urdi and MLT they decide that another source of funding could give us one that could pay for itself, then of course, are we going to turn down a free position? Heck no. But I think that, yes, there will always be a need to do enforcement. It's, to me, kind of like the thing that we can see what's happened with...

47:50 Temporary sales that go past the three days outdoors and things like that when we don't have a code enforcement officer. So yes, there will always have to be TOT enforcement, but then the council's responsibility is to make sure that it is still making money, that we're not just barely covering or not covering the cost of the staff. I think the answer is in two parts. One is I think Michael's concern, which is do you legalize it or not? The other piece is the enforcement piece.

48:18 Where does it benefit us there? You know, in talking to a lot of people that are even allowed to legally rent, they never even went through the process because they had to come in and physically bring a check in or they had to come in and fill out a piece of paperwork. If you can make all this online, somebody who lives in Los Angeles that's renting their place out legally, it's probably going to be a lot easier for them. So I think that's going to be one piece. And then I think with the basic gov in place, the tracking, as Mariana mentioned, I think it's going to be a lot easier. Once somebody gets

48:46 Caught doing illegal activity once, it's going to be a lot easier to follow up on. We won't have to find their address. We don't have to go after this, that, or the other, so. But, yeah, it's a two-pronged answer, I think. So these things take time, and we're spending it, and there's a lot to get through, and we are going to leave at 5 o'clock, exactly.

49:07 We beat this horse pretty good, didn't we? I think so. What about, would the council consider adding to 2B where it says TOT enforcement, TOT education and enforcement? Because part of, you know, enforcement seems quite narrow. It seems to me, and again, I'm thinking about a priority or a direction which addresses one of your concerns, which is, you know, how do we...

49:36 How do we get people to stop doing it once they've been caught? My reaction to you, by the way, was they'll enter into monthly lease agreements. Right. But my thought is if we were to do that, it gives additional direction, and that's what I would propose. I think that's appropriate. Enforcement is actually education in and of itself as well. But I think that...

50:04 But that is correct. We need to educate as well. All right. Well, that's all right. Let's go to C2C. We've already talked about that. And with the change that Joe had suggested regarding proposed TBID and then the deletion of the staff recommendation takes us to three. Anything further on number three? Other than do we have 5-0 support to move forward on that? I'm supportive. Yes. Yeah, but we already, we already,

50:33 Prove that in a separate agenda bill, and it's going forward. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's really just an affirmation, a reaffirmation of a priority as opposed to a direction of action. I just was looking for clarity. Yeah. All right, it takes us to the second part of today's agenda. Clarify, or actually, we just got through A, which is clarification of the above three priorities, and then B, agree on additional priorities. All right, the first category is effective management. You can see that there's a number of things in here.

51:03 A is to continue the commitment to IT funding. That's what we're doing. That's what we passed. Any objection to that? That sounds like a very high priority to me as I read the chart. B, support additional funding for the finance system replacement. We talked about that again yesterday. I think Matthew at length and Joe as well.

51:29 Well, actually, and Michael as well, so there's, I don't have anything to add to that at all. I think that's important for the staff to know what we're thinking about there. And then third, which has a couple of hearts to it, is critical services. What's, when we speak of finance system replacement, you're speaking of the software, are you not? Right, on B. On B. Yes. Right, okay.

51:57 So it takes us to C, which is finance and public safety. On trying to think under what topic it would be for under effective management, one other item I'd bring up, and maybe it's under the broad stroke of just effective management, but I know staff had brought something up. I just wanted to see what the rest of council's thoughts were, and that was to consider

52:30 Perhaps an alternate work schedule. And the reason being with a limited staff, you know, the Community Economic Development Department has expressed times when they're working on a project. It can take a greater amount of time to get it done because you have to stop, go to the front, stop, go to the front, or deal with some other problem. And one of their solutions was to look at some alternate type of work schedule where maybe, you know,

52:59 Every other Friday or something like that they get Friday. We close down the offices so the staff can work on their projects or some other 980 work week, something along those lines. I just wanted to see what the rest of council thought. I know we've tried things like this in the past and I don't know what the hurdles are in looking at that, but I wanted to see if there was any desire to maybe incorporate that into effective management.

53:29 Matthew, are you suggesting to shut down the front desk so they have more time or are you suggesting to shut the whole office down? Well, I think... Well, just going up and people coming in and out of the counter. They suggested that before. Just with general questions where they may be able to make appointments still on Friday if somebody, let's say a developer, somebody's coming in and they need to sit down with a planner for an hour or two. But...

53:54 For just general questions coming in, if they can have that one or two days a month or whatever it may be, will it be helpful to them and will it be more efficient for the organization to allow them that time to work on their projects? And they've expressed that as something that might be helpful and I just wanted to get feedback from the rest of council. You know, that's probably more detailed than I want to get into other than the fact that I would again be tasking

54:23 The town manager and staff would come to us for creative solutions, whether it's a 980, whether it's an extra quiet hour in the beginning of the day or the middle of the day, something like that. And if you look back to the attachments to agenda item one, there were several things about that in there to be more efficient we could. So I would presume that something would come forward to us with the specifics of would we be willing to do this or that after they've figured out what would actually work best for them.

54:53 Well, I think that then as a matter of stating a priority, the question is whether we should add a subsection D entitled deficiencies or something like that because I'd like to keep the categories broad and the direction would be, the emphasis would be on finding ways to increase productivity of staff without diminishing or reducing services.

55:22 Public. That's what I would have in mind. Okay. That's, yeah. I'd be comfortable with that, too. I just wanted to try to incorporate some of their ideas because some of them are very good ideas and I'm just trying to think how we can, I guess, help staff help themselves in this particular case without deviating too much from our day-to-day activities. But, yeah, I think that's under efficiencies. Seek out efficiencies or... All right.

55:53 So, C1, finance. You're thinking about reorganizing or the organization of that department as it is. Is there anything, I mean, we've indicated it's a high priority. Any council member want to add anything to what's already there? Not to get too specific again, but I know one thing in the reorganization piece that we were looking for in addition to basic gov, in addition to maybe a new system,

56:26 That will allow us more effective accounting procedures. I'd like to also look at a monthly reporting for the TOT versus quarterly. Have everything go monthly. Can we do that? We can only get quarterly. Well, most of our revenue comes in monthly already. And I think to change it from quarterly to monthly, I'm now not quite confident that I have an answer, but I think there's a

56:57 Legal tweak to it, but I'll find out what the answer is. I'll make a note. I think this is probably more detailed for the, too much detail for the priority, but I'll make a note to myself and I'll get back to you. And Ashley, what I see is that if we're going to quarterly reporting, which, to tell you the truth, in the last five years, it never actually happened. No, I meant quarterly reporting to us that it's my understanding that the majority of the people are on a monthly basis already and that

57:27 You could project revenues on what you've actually received and not say, well, I can't tell you about March until John and Michael, who both give us about $170 each quarter, get their money in. If we can report on actual and project on actual because all of the big remitters are on monthly, that would be an interim step because I'm pretty sure we'd have to do an ordinance change.

57:49 That was my recollection as well, that there was some legal process to go through, but I'll double check. But you're absolutely right, Ms. Bacon, that my recollection is about 92% of our COT revenue comes in monthly. So it's a huge chunk, and we're able to project revenues based on that. What comes in quarterly doesn't really skew our numbers. With the basic gov implemented, though, we're going to have more real time.

58:16 It's more prompt and it's more real time as opposed to monthly versus quarterly. So I think that may be more of an issue as opposed to how often it comes in. It's really how fast you get the data in the system. Right. Right. Yeah. So right now, I mean, the mandate is to report it quarterly? Is that... Well, no, there's... So 90% of the remuters already report monthly. There's about another 10% that...

58:44 Report out quarterly. But part of the problem isn't just the revenue. A lot of it has to deal with the fact that what we're asking the lodging community to do now when they report isn't just to report their income. We're also now asking for the benefit of Mammoth Lakes Tourism to also report their pacing for six months out. And by asking them to report their pacing six months out, we're able to look into the future a little bit better and say, hey,

59:12 You know, looking into August, September, we're looking pretty good in comparison to other years, or maybe we're not. I think we're able to measure the marketing efforts, what's working, what's not working, and I think when we run into situations like this, we might be able to look out there a little further and say, okay, well, we're looking pretty good for August. If we really are in a bad pinch, you know, are we pacing on schedule ahead of last year or two years ago and get a better idea of that?

59:40 I think that has to do with some of the reason I would like to see it, and I think there are other reasons as well, but just some thoughts. And actually, Matthew, you are right that we change it to say, yes, let's get to the monthly when we can. The reality is that to me that's one of the pieces that the TOT enforcement group could help work with if we get to that point of the diminishing or once we have basic gov in and we've got the capabilities that they transition us to monthly. But that...

1:00:07 Let them tell us when they're ready to do it. Right, and I think the basic gov will be in place in having that monthly reporting, but the problem, and I think the hang-up will be in our finance computing. And so I think as that piece starts to develop out, just when we're ready, when we're able to get to that point, I just think it would be important to get us to where we're doing monthly reporting. Right now, we're at...

1:00:31 You know, when Mammoth Lakes Tourism is trying to find out what their budget is going to be for the next six months, they don't know how much money they have to deal with looking back several months. And that's just unacceptable to me. And it's unacceptable for us. We don't know. So I think we have to be on top of that at any time. We should be able to look back a month or a month and a half at least and say we know what kind of monies we brought in. And I just think by not having that, we're significantly behind the ball.

1:01:00 We're getting there. Well, I think staff has very clear direction from us with respect to the timeliness of reporting, which is what you're getting at. And we've complained a lot about it, and there are examples each time. Do we need anything more in terms of establishing a priority?

1:01:30 And then what was already discussed. I would love to talk more about this. I'm clear. And, you know, it comes down to staffing and technology. I think the staffing piece is pretty much stable. The bodies are there. We just need to see if they're in the right place, in the right positions. And the technology, we move forward on that. As a matter of fact, I'm meeting with staff tomorrow to talk about their analysis of finance systems. And hopefully we'll have that replaced.

1:01:59 Okay, next, C2 Public Safety. We did not reach consensus yesterday. Either we didn't get to it, or it just didn't happen, or it wasn't as clear to me. Yeah, go ahead, Terry. I'm speaking from the TOT Committee. The ordinance was changed about a year ago, and kind of the trigger was, is once we had basic government in place, that that would go to a monthly reporting.

1:02:39 Really important if the TBID goes through that that should be done and they should coordinate and it should be done on a monthly basis and then all along with what Matthew had said. So if we can, you know, really do everything we can that once Basic Gov is in place to pull that trigger for it being monthly. I don't think we've got any argument from anybody on that. Okay. I want to...

1:03:04 Tackle public safety. You saw it on my list as my top priority, but it didn't appear on anybody else's list as the number one priority. My thoughts, I mean, you have my thoughts. Thoughts from others. A couple thoughts, Mr. Mayor. One is that we asked the Chief of Police yesterday, last night, as to what would be the ideal number of officers to function.

1:03:32 Reasonably for the town. Do we have any update on that, Chief? Yes, I do. And thank you for asking. I won't focus on an ideal number. I'll focus on what I think is a minimal number. And today I located a memo I sent to the council last October where I was asked the question, what would it take to provide a minimum coverage of two officers 24 hours a day? And it's more than just counting the days and times two.

1:04:02 Because you have to have relief factor. So what I did in the report, and I'll make copies and forward them to you again. We're currently, as I know you're aware, operating on 10-hour shifts of patrol with two shifts, so we're operating 20 hours a day. And to do that, with the staff we have, it doesn't take into account any time off, and in fact, we have to have our detective work patrol one day and the administrative sergeant work patrol one day.

1:04:32 My strong belief is that we should have people working 24 hours a day and we should never have less than two people on duty in patrol. Besides patrol, there's three positions that have to be filled. My position is one of them. The detective is one. We need to have someone dedicated as a detective, although that individual obviously can fill in on a short term for a day or two in a patrol position. And then my administrative sergeant.

1:05:00 The other way to determine a number is to look at whether or not we're going to have what shift we're going to be on. An 8-hour shift or a 12-hour shift, you can do the math and you come up with 24 hours very easily. The 10-hour shift that we currently are on and were on before we had cuts provides for a 4-hour overlap period. So to factor in, there's a multiplying factor, and there's a number of different ways of computing it or sources.

1:05:30 I went to POST, California Peace Officer Standards and Training, and used a formula they recommend that factors in vacation, training, comp time, sick time, and the like. So based on that, that's kind of the background. To give us two officers 24 hours a day on an 8 or a 12 hour shift, including the admin positions, we would need 13 to 14 officers.

1:05:58 Right now with the additional position we have, we'll have 11 when we hire the new officer. If we were to go to a 10-hour shift, which I think is preferred because that in the evening hours gives us four officers working from 9 until 2 when is our busiest time of day, that would take a total of 16 officers. 13 of them would be assigned to patrol and those three administrative positions I talked about. Obviously,

1:06:26 That there's a jump to get from 1 to 13 or 14 or 16. And as revenue comes in and decisions are made to increase the status of the police department, we will look at what's the best way to use that extra position. For example, with the one extra officer that's been authorized and funded, once that officer is cleared to work on his own, we'll assign him to the end of the week in the evening shift.

1:06:56 On Wednesday through Saturday, we'll have, when everybody's working, we'll have three officers instead of two. If we get one more position, we'll look at what's the best way to sign that position, and that's how we would develop it. So it would be more important in your mind to go to three officers in the evenings than it would to go to 24-hour coverage? One officer wouldn't give me enough to go for 24 hours, so I would look at that at some point when...

1:07:27 And I can't tell you what that number would be between now and 13, maybe with 12, probably not until we have 13 could we go to 24 hours a day, 13, and that would be on a 12-hour shift. Thank you. Chief, what's the total cost per officer added? Well, it depends. A new officer is going to cost less than an officer with, say, 10 years experience because they have step increases and they have bonuses.

1:07:58 I'd have to go to finance. I want to say a new officer who comes in at the base level is around with benefits. I believe it's about $130,000. $145. And that's for a non-experienced officer, is what you're saying? That's an officer that would start at the lowest level. If we brought somebody in, for example, with five years experience in another department, we would be

1:08:30 Move them to a higher level. I couldn't tell you what level it would be. I'd have to look at a number of factors. They would start without any bonuses or anything. Right. I got you. Okay, thank you. Other questions? No. I'm fine with the statement C2 as written. Yes, am I. I'm not because I think it reduces the level of priority, but I don't think that I'm going to prevail. I think that a more succinct statement would be to

1:09:06 Prioritize the addition of one more officer, perhaps as funds become available, to increase the strength to 12. Well, I kind of read that that was in there, but you wanted to be more specific? Well, the only reason would be that it sort of, it then competes with everything else that we could do with more money, and all I'm trying to do is...

1:09:37 As a matter of priority to elevate it to a status that would be higher than everything else. Do you see what I mean? I don't know exactly what my understanding is to do that, but that's my intent. I'm not sure that the council agrees with me. I agree with you. Well, and if you look at number five on the next page, that one is more specific. What I guess, I'm wondering what the question is. You're saying be specific and elevate it to one additional officer, but it sounds like the chief's saying we need two to three. I understand what he wants.

1:10:06 Okay, so you're just... I'm just thinking about what we realistically could possibly afford. And I'm not... This is not a directive to spend money, but it is a... Chief, I know there's a whole bunch of money. I've been talking about it time and time again. What's that? I know there's a whole bunch of money. Oh, the... So, I mean, we're talking $150,000 roughly an officer, right? I mean, two to three. There's...

1:10:36 Three quarters of a million dollars of money that has just been collected, and there's a lot more, according to Matthew. One of the questions that I, when you were speaking was, in this year's budget, what's the number that we put, isn't it 500,000, for collection of illegal rental TOT? Correct, and that 500,000 is also in your five-year plan annually, so that target continues. We're already way over that at that point.

1:11:05 But that was in other budget years. For 18 months. Right. So the point is that money is accounted for. I mean, or putting it differently, we're accounting money. Yeah. $500,000, I brought it. So what you're suggesting is that... What Matthew's saying is that there's probably two to three times that stacked up out there. I love it. He's probably wrong.

1:11:27 Well, then back to my probationers, is you had to estimate what could reasonably be expected to collect in any 12-month period. Right. And it's not going to all happen in the next year. Right. And I think with the process we're given, I think we'll only collect, one, we're only going to collect about 30% of that money. And then, two, it will take a year to collect each portion of it as it comes up. I mean, what's it taking us, about a year now?

1:11:56 Bring in the money once we find the offenders, or maybe six months. My point is, $150,000 a guy, we've got to find the money. Well, but today isn't a money discussion for me. Today is a priorities discussion. The money follows. The discussion about funding follows. And I don't know when that happens. And so, and that's, frankly, in my mind, the difference between doing a budget and doing a strategic planning session.

1:12:24 So, and I understand what you're trying to say, Rick, and I agree with it in the sense that let's make one simple comparison. Rick would say his priority right now is to add one additional officer above what is already projected. So we'd go from 11 to 12. And I would say, on our next item that's coming up as far as road maintenance, I would say, do we have 750 budgeted?

1:12:49 Or 750 minus 160? Minus 160. 160. Okay. So I would say in the next item, I would say a priority to me is the same as what you're saying with police. I would say on roads, a priority to me would be to make that roads a million dollars a year instead of $750,000 minus $160,000. So

1:13:16 I see what you're saying and I see what you're doing. What it does is it puts both of those on the tables and identifies them as priorities of this council, or at least a majority of the council members. And then when we do have the quarterly review and whatever the numbers are or stuff like that, then we can go, you know what, just three months ago we said we wanted another officer and we said we wanted a million dollars of road maintenance. And again,

1:13:42 I think that we're, and correct me, Ray, I think we're talking on road maintenance, I think we're talking about next year to where we really have eight to ten months to collect that million dollars to be spent on so we'll have a better picture. So if we get to next April and we have to order the material to improve the roads and we get there and we had a bad summer, we didn't collect as many revenues as we thought, we had a bad winter, then we can go back, okay,

1:14:11 We're not in a million dollars. We're at $750,000 minus $160,000. So we've got more flexibility there with roads. We don't have that with police, but we do with roads. So I agree with Rick on making the language stronger in here and making it a priority to increase the staffing level. Because I see it as different from a funding commitment. We'll have that discussion at a point in time. I don't know what it's going to be.

1:14:40 That was my comment on public safety. We took 41% of the uniformed offices away in one year and I believe 57% from its peak and I'm simply looking to put something back in order to meet a minimally acceptable standard. It's not for me to know whether it's 12 or 14 or 13 or 15 but it seems to me that if we have

1:15:05 As a stated priority that we want to minimally increase, then that rises above so many other things that we're going to be asked to fund over the next year. If you would restate that language and then see if there's consensus? The language would be to increase uniformed officer, uniformed strength by one additional officer as resources become available.

1:15:35 And I support that. And actually, I think that makes it too easy for us to only add one when there might be a need for more at the time, which is why I was okay with the more vague statement here because it does say... You want at least one? I'd be thrilled. Because to me, increased staffing when ongoing resources become available does make it a priority. So I didn't need to have one because, you know, the minute you say a number, then everybody presumes that is the number.

1:16:06 Kind of like the old discussions, you know, well, developers could have 40 or 80. Well, did any of them ask for less than 80? Right. I like at least one. Well, I can, yeah. I don't see a difference between at least one and just increasing staff. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, as this, yeah, I'm okay with it as written without putting a number in there. Yeah, I am too. So, Michael, you're? I am too. Especially if we can raise some money to pay for it. Okay.

1:16:38 Okay, you heard it. There were two of us who would like to be more specific. Three of us would not, so it remains as it is. Thank you. I try. Number five, infrastructure. John, you've had your comments. I just said it. I would increase as a priority our funding for road maintenance to a million dollars in 2013-14 year and take that additional

1:17:05 Moneys, which would be $250,000 plus the $160,000, so that's $410,000 from our RU to accomplish that. Next year you're suggesting that? Yes, in the $13,000, $14,000. No, that's this year. This year. $160,000 plus $410,000? And what's this? $160,000 plus $250,000. I'm sorry. You want to do that this year? You want to make a change to the budget that we're suggesting? I do. Comments? Thoughts?

1:17:35 I actually like it as written because if we say that we go with what we put into the budget that we just approved on June 19th, yet the enhanced funding to at least $1 million annually once funding becomes available, if that funding becomes available in January, we've got the authority to enhance it to a million already. It doesn't say that that $1 million would happen after this year necessarily. I agree. It's semantics, but I'm just trying to identify the importance that I put on it.

1:18:05 We don't talk about it too much. In fact, we don't talk about it at all recently. And I think, Joe, it was you that had this copy to us on the election in 1986 as far as measure A. And in that measure, this is measure A, which most of us think generated revenues mainly for marketing, but also it generated revenues for new road construction and ongoing road maintenance. So I would submit our measure A dollars.

1:18:33 I'm actually supportive of it as it's written.

1:19:04 So I've got a different approach, and that would be that as a matter of priority to increase this year's allocation back to $750,000 as or once funding becomes available, if it does, to express it as a priority and then following that in the next fiscal year to enhance funding.

1:19:37 $1 million as funding becomes available. Again, this isn't a funding exercise. It's a statement of priority. And again, I'm with you. I want to, and I've stated it was my number two priority. I think it must have been my number three because I think MLR was one. I want all of these. My goal is to have all these be, in essence, on equal footing. Not because I want these five to compete with one another. They do.

1:20:07 In many respects. But quite frankly, because if it's not on the list, it's easier for us to say no when the next request comes because it didn't make the list. And I don't mean to shut people out or activities or functions or programs or whatever it is out. But if there's a very clear statement that we want to dramatically increase the road maintenance funding, then it, again, just seems to me to give it more

1:20:37 Wait, if you will, in the event of a conflict or competition for funds. And I think it was in all of our priorities, wasn't it? Didn't we all mention it? In some way or another, or in the budget discussions, we all mentioned it, yeah. The concern I have with this one, too, is I think Ray pointed it out pretty clearly, is

1:20:59 You know, the longer we put it off, it's not like we can just put this amount of money we're short back and fix the problem. We've actually created a bigger issue in that, you know, we let our roads deteriorate to a point that it's going to cost us, you know, more than it could have initially. So, you know, that is a concern of mine. And for me, this is up there. I mean, I'm going to say I'm okay with it as written, but I'm just hoping that, you know, as...

1:21:28 I'm glad we have it on here as a priority of the roads in particular because once, you know, assuming we can get some of these funds in there, I think this is one of the basic needs we have up here. This isn't just roads. I think it's snow removal and everything else too, so. My objection to the language is that it assumes that we're okay with the $160,000 reduction. Yeah, and I was sitting here without trying to wordsmith the details, just trying to figure out a way to encompass that because, as I said, I read it that

1:21:55 Should we be looking at mid-year review and there's more money? This is definitely my priority to put the 160 back plus more. Well, that's what Rick's language knows. And yet I see that this language allows us to do that. It doesn't say accepted. Oh, okay. I saw it just the opposite. So how would you word it then? Oh, okay. I would just say that I would just say to...

1:22:22 To enhance road maintenance budget to $750,000 during the fiscal year 2013-14 once funding becomes available or if funding becomes available.

1:22:35 So you don't want to limit it to the million dollars, you just want to... No, no, that's the percent. The second second would be enhance funding to at least one million dollars annually once funding becomes available. Okay. And then you've said it as a priority. One other thing I was going to mention, and I know Ray's got something to say, is that years ago we did a study, and it seems to me it's done a couple of times since I was on council, or when I was on council years ago, that...

1:23:00 You know, we talk about it generally being more expensive. It is so dramatically more expensive when you let something go when it reaches the point of failure, or whatever the correct terminology is, that it's stunning. But more importantly, let me get back to my statement yesterday, which is, I want to find a causal link between marketing and that which we have to offer the public. And it's not just the mountains.

1:23:29 It's not just these ski lifts, it's everything, including how we appear and present ourselves to the community. It's the pavers in the village. It's the streets and the striping as much as it is everything else. I know that a lot of people say, people don't really care. Yes, they do. They do care. The quality of the experience just really encompasses everything, and so I think this is an important part of it, right?

1:23:53 Just a reminder, and I'm sure the council is already aware of this, you know, I wrote the memo, a detailed memo about this subject to the town manager and it was copied to the council. What we're really talking about is trying to reduce the level of deferred maintenance. That's the goal. Because as that continues to climb, then, you know, the higher that gets, the bigger problem we have down the road. And as Councilmember Lehman just pointed out,

1:24:20 It does become more expensive, and yes, failure is the correct term. Once you lose the road base, then you're into a reconstruction project rather than a maintenance-type project. So what we identified as sort of the optimum level of funding was a million and a half to at least try to stabilize that rate of increase in deferred maintenance costs. So that's really what it's all about, is trying to reduce the slope of that curve

1:24:47 In terms of deferred maintenance and try to flatten it out as much as possible, if that makes sense. So a million is almost not even enough. Well, it's better than $750. It's better. Yeah. I mean, we can actually provide reports that show you, based on a certain level of investment over the next 10, 20 years, what does that do to your deferred maintenance cost? What does it do to your network pavement condition index? So it's quite informative.

1:25:17 Really the goal I think ultimately would you want to get to that million and a half as sort of an optimum level just to try to reduce that deferred maintenance. Okay. So I think see if this encompasses more or less what you're saying. Enhance current year road maintenance funding to $750,000. Enhance funding to at least $1 million annually once funding becomes available. Is that more or less what you're saying? Because that's the priority. The priority is to find the money.

1:25:46 And then to go to the million dollar level. And do you think that this language, you know, you're looking for that nexus between the marketing and road maintenance and police officers and whatnot, trying to understand where we're going with this, so if we exceed our existing budget, these will take priority. Yeah.

1:26:11 These will be put as a precedent before we take on any other projects, hopefully. You know what I think? I think all five are, in my mind, equal to them. And so if there are needs other than, and there will be, other than road maintenance, we're going to have to have a discussion about whether we hire a T.O.T. compliance specialist, a third one, or whether we put another $50,000 in the road. So I don't think this forecloses that at all.

1:26:38 But I think that it elevates it to an important priority. Well, I'm just wondering because the other priorities aren't really requesting any additional funding. These two are. Well, the new finance system will be additional funding. Okay. But that's under effective management. Yeah, but so is finance and public safety. Right. I guess I'm looking at one, two, and three aren't necessarily priorities that will require additional funding. So priority four.

1:27:04 And priority five are the only two priorities that are requiring additional funding. Which makes them first on the list if we get money back, not that we wouldn't necessarily. But one, two, and three will be the sources that will create that funding, hopefully. Yeah. So assuming we get that money and then we're going to identify a mid-year budget or some other time that we need to allocate some of this funding to these two areas. Yeah, and actually one, two, and three are funded.

1:27:34 Yeah. So there isn't a competition for it. We know what we're doing. And so it really does leave us with just 4 and 5. Right. Mayor? And also to clarify, once we get to the next step discussion, next steps discussion, what staff recommends, and you'll see it on the second page, is that we need to go back once you give us these priorities and develop a list of balancing measures if there's a shortfall expected mid-year this year or next year.

1:28:04 But also measures to add back. And you're right, based on your priorities, we're going to put infrastructure and police officers first on the list to be funded. But we need to give you that list far in advance of the media review, because we can't be deciding this again and going through the priorities again at that time. What I want to do, well, first of all, is there consensus on the language that is proposed by Mayor Pro Tem. Yes.

1:28:32 What I want to do now is give the public an opportunity to provide input, comment on the five priorities, including the subsections that we have discussed today and yesterday, because I know that we're going to, we've got only 30 minutes to finish this Part C, and I want to make sure that the public has the opportunity. We are going to adjourn this at 5. I go to the airport, so we'll get our... Yes. Elizabeth, I'm seeing you lurking.

1:29:02 Congratulations, by the way, on the Gateway Project. Thank you. Thank you. Elizabeth Kenney, resident Mammoth Lakes. Two points I want to make, and the first one is directly connected to TOT, and that is your compliance specialist that you're talking about, TOT compliance specialist. I wish you could drop the word TOT from one of them or very seriously consider the third position and have it include the code in general. We're very close to having the zoning code update done, but...

1:29:31 It's not quite pointless, but you wonder why if we can't enforce it. And we know there's no second chance on first impressions. And so if we want to bring these return visitors back, there are all kinds of things. We can prioritize the areas of the code that have to be enforced, just like we prioritize public health and safety now. But please consider allotting some time. Even a part-time position would be good because there are volunteers who are interested in helping with that. So that would be a good thing.

1:30:00 It has to do with a community and economic development director. I don't see it as a figurehead. The people who have left and or have given notice have left varying size holes, most of the huge in the infrastructure of this town government, and Mark Wardlaw left one of the biggest holes. We need somebody who will go out and actively seek development, actively seek economic, what am I trying to say, you know, projects, stuff, you know, things, not just building buildings, but

1:30:31 Things we could do, someone who can actively do that, who sees the big picture, who has background in architecture and capital improvements, I mean, that kind of stuff, not just somebody who looks at the code and figures out, you know, if you can check all the boxes. And that's not to demean the efforts of staff at all. It's just really, really hard for them to try and keep track of the big picture and try and do the job that, you know, Mark left behind. So that's a very important position. I was glad to see that.

1:30:58 The majority of you were in favor of filling it. So please code enforcement and please community development and economic development director. Thank you. Maintening again, Terry Stella. Number five is infrastructure, and I'm seeing that infrastructure is only being addressed as roads, and I'm wondering what's going on, where the council stands on facilities and the parks, because you have major deferred maintenance within those items as well, but I don't even see them being discussed.

1:31:38 So I know there's a CIP list with a whole lot of projects on it that address facilities and parks, and there's no funding for any of it. Didn't hit my list of priorities. I mean, of course it's a priority. I come from recreation, which includes parks. But in narrowing it to the top five, one of the purposes, at least in my mind, of the exercises is to be able to

1:32:11 Is to be able to say what it is that we are most focused on. Obviously we've got a budget for parks and recreation, as people are well aware. And it includes a lot of things, but it excludes a lot of things as well. And in many instances there are things that in my mind are just simply going to have to wait. It's not saying we don't recognize that that's an issue. And in a way I'm hoping that the MLR process and discussion gives us some creative ways to find the funding.

1:32:40 From other sources to also consider that as, you know, part of that whole plan of what recreation is in our future. But, yeah, I agree. It's also one of the things I'd like to see happen, but it just didn't fit in the top five. It was in my top priorities and threw out some examples of funding via grants and bonding of RNU for some amenities that we desperately need. But I think...

1:33:09 You know, there's some other stuff that's probably much more in line. Well, and Ashley, Michael, we did task the MLR discussion to include those points. So that's what I'm saying is I think we're not forgetting it, but, yeah, it won't be a first priority. Unless it's not a standalone priority. It's not a standalone, yeah. I guess what I'm seeing is that the council is saying that the facilities that this town owns are not a priority, however the roads are. And so I just want to clarify that, and I want the public to know that.

1:33:45 Everything's a priority, and the question is in what order? Good afternoon, John Wentworth, local citizen resident. I want to thank you for doing what you're doing, and I want to thank the entire council for demonstrating the leadership necessary to make this possible. I think it's very reassuring as a member of the community to be able to see a continuity as the mayorships and various things move around up there that I'm hearing one voice, I'm hearing one

1:34:15 And one set of ideas and debate coming out of this body. It's very reassuring to hear. Thanks to the staff also for supporting this effort. I've had a chance to read some of the supporting documents, which I haven't seen before. It's very interesting to read the kind of trauma that you guys are going through, and this is how we start putting these things together to get some success out of all of it. So thank you for your help on that. I think in Terry's point, the support of MLR, I think that I've obviously...

1:34:42 I'm very interested in that process. But there are communities all over the state that have things like an MLR set up that bring resources, leverage to existing facilities and new programs. I think I'm very excited about the opportunities that MLR is going to bring to this effort. I don't think anything is going to be just thrown to the roadside and left to rot and die. I think if you've got an engaged, extra governmental process that could be engaged with doing this stuff, you're going to see a lot of really good things come out of that.

1:35:07 I think that as you go through the process of rebuilding staff, I think that that's going to be a very difficult thing to do, but I think it's also an enormous opportunity. Because I think you can start looking at a staff that's going to be looking outside of the confines of just the government. It's going to be looking to extra governmental partners to leverage resources of the entire community. I think that's an enormous opportunity. I think a lot of great partnership efforts have happened the last couple of years, a lot of great examples of how that can work. But I would think as you go about hiring people, bringing new people on, point their focus outside of the government.

1:35:37 Point their focus outside to the resources that this community really has to move things forward. And I'm very encouraged to hear the discussion about the nexus between marketing and the product. I think that's a critical thing we all know about. And to get this one nice, closed, beautiful loop to move this whole thing forward is important. Finally, when you get to your next steps, Marianna, you talked about putting in the agenda packet about what the priorities of the council are. I think it's very important not to lose sight of the goals. I know this is a very limited time you guys have to talk about this, but I heard

1:36:07 I also want that granted so I can watch this at 2 o'clock in the morning and watch all the discussions when there's enough bandwidth to actually see it. It chuckles, right? But just to restate the community vision. If you don't get any kind of goal-setting effort right now, but just to restate what that is. Surrounded by uniquely spectacular scenery and diverse forests and recreational opportunities, the community of Mammoth Lakes is committed to providing the very highest quality of life for our residents and the highest quality of experience for our visitors.

1:36:34 And I'll just suggest you have to put anything else in those agenda items on a monthly basis to have that vision statement in there also because all the strategies that you're talking about point to those goals. I think it's critically important. It's great to have these strategies. It's very great to have these priorities in place, but to keep that goal in mind is going to be critical. So again, thank you for your time. Thank you for your staff's time. This is a very much needed and very much appreciated effort. Thank you. John, just let me ask you quickly on that is, you know, what you just stated is our, of course, the general plan, which is our vision.

1:37:04 And mission and all of that. And there is something in the agenda bills that references which parts of the general plan a particular bill proposes to support or enhance or whatever. Are you talking about something more than that? No. I'm just, I was looking at the next steps at Marietta. I have a feeling that your priorities are going to be the firewall that you're going to use. So when someone comes forward and says, you didn't prioritize this, you're going to say, no, and this is why. But to always make sure that the vision

1:37:33 Is there in such a way that you guys can point to this and say, look, we don't have the resources, we're finding new ways to deliver services, but it all points to this, it all goes to that goal. I just want to make sure that doesn't get lost in the shuffle somewhere. And that you don't get in a position of just ax, ax, ax, and no, no, no. It's like we're going to this place. And that is, everybody's reminded of that. I think Tom Cage pointed out a good way to track it, too. It was nice yesterday that he brought that forward and looking at the water district had done.

1:38:00 Something along those lines. And not everything can have a timeline to it, but it's always nice to have that in some sort of relationship so we can track, you know, are we on, you know, are we accomplishing our goals, so. John, I received an email from Mike Vance. I don't know whether you knew him when he was here. I didn't know him when I was, there was a peer, I think I met him up in Whistler. That, that, just to tag on to what you've said, it's worth reading to the council and the public, these are not my words. He said,

1:38:30 One area that should pervade all of Council's priorities is partnerships. In these days with limited resources, no one can do it alone. In the areas of marketing and tourism, the economy, economic diversification, revenue generation, recreation, there are tremendous opportunities that can only be realized by strategic partnerships. You have a commercial and accommodation sector. That's Canadian for lodging.

1:38:59 You have a commercial and lodging sector that offers skills, expertise, human resources, and education sector that could grow into tourism-related opportunities. Marketing and tourism provides natural alliances for resource sharing. It goes on and on. So I thought that that was important. He ends with, these partnerships cannot just be words that we will work together and then change with the wind or circumstances. They must be based on agreeing to where Mammoth is going, which is the

1:39:28 Current Vision. And agreeing to specific strategies that outline responsibilities, goals, and outcomes that will take you towards it. I just thought it was so well articulated that it ought to be stated and it's consistent with what you've stated. I personally believe that those are the keys to our success. Thank you. OK. Other members of the public? Tim. Tim Flynn, resident business owner. Yeah, I want to echo the words of John. I mean, obviously, I'm not going to be able to

1:40:05 Say it as eloquently as he does. But yeah, I like that housing is in there. I think we need to reevaluate where we're going with that. How the private sector, I agree with partnership, how the private sector and public sector could work together on that. And the community development director, I'm on the fence still.

1:40:36 I don't want a big bureaucratic engine. I think that the town is finally operating at a sustainable rate now, something that's sustainable. I'm just afraid of creating more bureaucracy. I know that that's one of the things that stands hugely in the way of development, is having to navigate the bureaucratic waters.

1:41:04 And creating another management position versus having people on the ground worker bees, as John put it, I'm open to it, but I would like to have it more defined, the position more defined, I guess. And I know it's a complex issue.

1:41:33 You know, I just, I know that a lot of projects don't leave the ground because it's called analysis paralysis. And it hits that stage and developers just take off. You know, and so, but I do, you know, on the other hand too, I believe in, you know, in reasonable development, you know, sustainable development, not overdevelopment. So, I know that it's difficult and complex.

1:42:02 And I just, I'd like to see some more definition than that, if possible. And also, and it, you know, me as a member of the public, it's impossible for me to show up to every planning commission, you know, watch every planning commission, and I'm sure that it's probably more defined. You know, one of the things that I'd like to see is planning commission meetings, you know, at a time when, you know, members of the public like me that work for a living, you know, not the retirement community could show up to.

1:42:32 You know, and that would definitely be helpful. Let's see. I do agree with the public safety. I mean, it's really important for the first responders. You know, I mean, I'd be interested to see. I mean, we just had a very busy weekend. I mean, I've never seen so many people in the village. You know, and how we kind of...

1:43:03 We're almost out of time. Anyway, I'd like to just see where that came out as and if there was any major issues. Today, just driving around, I passed six police officers, two sheriffs, and a highway patrol within a four-hour period. So, I mean, I don't, you know, I mean, I feel like we have adequate services, but I do believe that we need first responders. And then, you know, also look for these partnerships, even in the finance department.

1:43:32 You know, maybe look to outsourcing partially or, anyway, thanks. All right, putting is open. Dave Harvey, Mammoth President. I'll be very quick. I applaud you all for the strategic planning. This is something that, of course, is done in private sector, as you all well know. And without it, we wouldn't make much progress. Rick, you're absolutely right.

1:44:04 This is a strategic planning session. What you set your priorities as today may in fact change as you go forward, but that's why you have the flexibility in the body that you sit on. The funding portion that will come up way too soon is going to be your challenge. How does a typical government entity

1:44:33 Councilman Raimondo,

1:45:03 Brought up the situation of single family resident TOT collection, $700,000, that's a lot of money. How long that will last, at what pace, we don't know. We'll find out. I feel very confident with the staff that you have and how they're going about the process. I will repeat something that I've mentioned before.

1:45:32 And that is, and I believe Councilman Raimondo had touched on this, but we need to find a very clear path for legitimization of the single family rental program. I am sure that there are those in the program that are renting one and two bedroom houses,

1:46:00 in different parts of the town where it's totally illegal and will remain illegal, and that's something that I certainly do not support, cannot support. The single-family resident program that has been successful in so many other resorts caters to a specific demographic. That demographic is large families, extended families, typically

1:46:30 A single-family home that would sleep 14 to 16 individuals. The rules and the regulations that go along with that need to be very strong and need to be thoughtfully put together. I'm not up here to lobby for that today. What I am here to do is to tell you the challenge as you go forward in creating funding.

1:46:58 For all of these things that we would like to see happen in our community is not going to be an easy challenge. And I want to wish you all the best. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. I'd like to move quickly into what I think is going to be the easier part of our discussion, which is next steps and provide direction to staff through town manager. We obviously have provided direction.

1:47:25 There are five specific items that are on page two along with a couple of subsections. I have reviewed those. Instead of going through those individually, my question to council is do you take issue with any of the things that are on there or is there something on there that, something that does not appear on there that strikes you as something that ought to be included in the next steps?

1:47:51 I'll start. I think they're well stated and I am, I was a little concerned before that part of our plan right now was to go ahead and start talking about the showfalls or surpluses when it feeling like we were in a vacuum. So I like the fact that that has been scheduled for September, October when there's an opportunity for staff to provide us some of the detail and for us to talk about it and I'm fine with the rest of it. I'm fine.

1:48:19 I'm fine with it as well. I am too. I thought this part that Mariana in particular was very well done. And, you know, I don't know where you fit in all of this, this whole idea of partnerships, other than for us to remind ourselves that strategic partnerships are what get us what we want. One of them, as a great example, was the project, was the bike lane project from Whiskey Creek to Horseshoe.

1:48:47 That's a classic, perfect example of a strategic partnership that worked. And so there's more than one way to spin a cat. The other comment that I would make is that the expectation when MLT was formed is that strategic partnerships would be entered into in order to generate revenues from outside the government, meaning other than taxes.

1:49:16 That's something I'm sure that we're going to be, at least I'm going to be focusing on later, but I point that out because there are opportunities for all of these organizations. Strategic partnerships, for example, in housing include all of the programs that fund, for example, homeowner down payment assistance that come from other entities, in that case, either federal funds of industry by the state or state funds.

1:49:44 I don't know what strategic relationships there are with ESTA, but I can imagine several. I don't sit on that board. But it seems to me that that will apply most particularly to recreation, and that gets me back to, once again, that causal link between marketing and product. And recreation, of course, is the primary part. If there's nothing else, no more comments. John? Real quick, you mentioned ESTA. Strategic relationships with ESTA are,

1:50:15 Eno County, Mono County, City of Bishop, State of California, Federal Government, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, National Park Service, down to Ritz Meadow and stuff. So that's another classic example of the success of partnerships. GASTA wouldn't be an operation without all that. No. One of the other things while I'm thinking about it is that the private sector raised a million bucks on that track.

1:50:44 We threw a lot of money at it. The private sector put a million dollars into that track and then gave it to the town. Mayor. Go ahead. Before we adjourn, I want to take the opportunity and thank my management team again for making this session possible. On a daily basis, they have so much on their plates that, frankly, what they don't have time to do is think ahead and strategically...

1:51:10 Plan their months and years. They just don't have time. However, they made time. They found time. They pulled together. They showed real leadership. And not all of them are represented here. We have more members of the management team. But I wanted to take the time to acknowledge publicly the hard work that has gone into the preparation for these sessions. I think they were successful. And it's thanks to this team. All right. Thank you, everybody.

1:51:37 We will adjourn this meeting to our next special meeting, which is tomorrow at 4 o'clock, and it is a closed session only, so there's no need for you to show up. And just to remind all of us, it's in Town County.