TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2013

Town Council Rescheduled meeting

· recording 3 hr 22 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

402 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 All right. Good evening, everybody. Welcome to the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Town of Mammoth Lakes, regular meeting for Wednesday, July 24, 2013. Jamie, roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Before we get to the regular agenda, there was a closed session this evening that four or five council members participated in. I was not there due to a conflict, and I understand that Mayor Pro Tem

2:48 Bacon is going to report out on closed session matters. Thank you, Bill. There was no decision made this evening on the purchase of the property, as noted in the closed session listing. We have separately committed to continuing the public process and bringing some information forward. There are certain items that we cannot discuss in public because they are closed session items. However,

3:16 I did want to point out that we will continue the process. And the reason I say continue the process is because anyone who has questions about the intentions of the town, all of the entities involved, you can go back to the May 16, 2012 agenda where as a public item and you can watch the tape on Granicus, we discussed several of the issues that have been out there

3:45 And if you would like to know the facts rather than some of the rumors that have sent around, I would suggest that you look that up, look at the agenda bill, listen to that discussion. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Joe. We'll move now to the first item on the agenda, which is the Pledge of Allegiance. I understand John Morris Therese is in the audience. He's going to lead us in the pledge. Pledge of Allegiance to the United States of America, to the Republic for which it stands.

4:27 John, thank you on behalf of the Raging Association. All right, next item on the agenda is entitled Correspondence. We have received a number of items of, sorry, I'm, you know, we've got like 45 items on this agenda, and I guess I moved over an important one, which is public comment. So we're going to go to public comment, and now is the time for any member of the public who wishes to address the council on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda to come forward and speak, and

4:57 If you will state your name for the record, Pat. Good evening, Mayor Wood, Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon, Councilmembers, City, Town Staff, Members of the Public, my name is Pat Hayes, I'm the General Manager, newly installed in April with the Mammoth Community Water District, and my purpose in speaking with you this afternoon, this evening is in regards to the recent settlement, and at the sake of

5:25 Being redundant, what you might have already heard, already seen in the press, I thought I'd take the opportunity to outline what the settlement agreement details and offer any opportunity for you to ask any questions about it. This lawsuit, actually two lawsuits with the City of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power involved two items, one of which we've been working on for almost 25 years.

5:52 And that's the Environmental Impact Report for the Mammoth Creek Fishery Bypass Flows. And then a second item involving the District's 2010 Urban Water Management Plan. Prior to that time, we had not heard anything from Los Angeles. The District had established water rights through the State Department of Water Resources back in 1947-48. And we were operating under the premise that those were

6:22 The L.A. Lawsuits questioned that. They put forth rights prior to 1914. Long story short, after about $750,000 of legal costs on the part of the district and probably at least that amount or more on the part of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, we've worked out

6:52 I think a very optimum settlement agreement for the future of the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And it also makes good on LA's situation in terms of water conservation. So in short, I call it a win-win circumstance. The build-out flows for the Town of Mammoth Lakes by our planning documents are exactly 4,387 acre feet, which probably means hardly anything to anyone.

7:21 But a typical family can get by on about a quarter to a third of an anchor foot a year. So generally speaking, what this will allow us to do is reach build out and still have adequate water supplies for the town to flourish, to continue to grow from the present state to ultimate build out. It will allow us to continue to extract water from the ground and to use recycled water and to take service water from Lake Mary.

7:49 The agreement terms, it runs two periods. Primary period is 50 years for the first one, for which we're going to pay the City of Los Angeles right away, $3.4 million, which will go to building water conservation structures in some of the LADWP controlled lands. I'm told it'll be for a sprinkler system in the McGee Creek Basin. And then in about 50 years' time, if we're wise in terms of our water conservation,

8:19 We can accumulate credits for another 10 years before that period expires, taking us to 60 years, and then we make another payment for the next 50 years. So if we mind our P's and Q's as a community, which shouldn't be too much trouble, we'll have 110 years before we kick the can again. At this point, I'll open it up to questions, if you have any. John, no questions, Pat, but I wanted to, first of all, congratulate the Water District and congratulate you.

8:49 I think for some people in the community it might be difficult to understand the importance of this agreement and to have it finalized. And I know you've worked on it for several months, if not more than a year. And so congratulations and thank you for your efforts. Thank you very much, Councilman Eastman. Good stuff. We're very pleased to be where we are and that we have at least 100 years in front of us before we have to go through any other process. Is the agreement signed?

9:16 It is. It is. Okay. Thank you. Signed by Tom Smith, our president, on 7-11. Great. Thank you. I'm hoping that's a lucky day for us. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you, Ms. Mayor. I just wanted to say that after Greg left, I think we were all kind of wondering what was going to happen next because he was a great manager there. And I've only heard great things from your board about you. So I just want to say welcome as well and congratulations on that.

9:46 Councilmember Layman, thank you very much. And with due credit, Greg did a lot of the hard strokes of helping get this agreement, the basic structure of it. I won't bore you with the water terms, but consumptive use and return water credits and all that sort of thing. He really got things going in the right direction. Great, thank you. Thanks very much. Andrew. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, Andrew Castor with the Mammon Track Club.

10:16 And tonight I'd like to recognize a vital organization here in our town for their services, not only with our races that we produce, but the community at large. So Mammoth Lakes Police Department has been an integral part of the Mammoth Track Club and the High Sierra Striders producing events. I've been here since 2001, and I've personally overseen 20-plus road race events.

10:46 And at every one of those road race events here in town, Mammoth Lakes Police Department, without batting an eye, has risen to the occasion and provided safe traffic control for our registrants and our volunteers. So I would like to present Chief Watson with a plaque of gratitude and thank you on behalf of the Mammoth Track Club. And thank you, Chief.

11:32 Fourth 5K, 10K road race, Footloose Chart House race is on for this year and hopefully everybody can come out and enjoy the fun. Thank you. Good night. Thank you, Andrew. Terry. Mayor Wood and Council, I'm up here as a private citizen, Terry Stelick. And I just want to just state my disappointment in the judgment of Mammoth Times for the July 4th front page where they so

12:06 Irresponsibly, in my opinion, placed something that says the last blast on the front of it and then buried the article inside the newspaper. So, yes, shock value, someone going to buy the paper, maybe. There's a lot of people, but the only thing that they're going to read is the front of that page. For a community that lives and dies on non-tourism and where it's been spoken that there's going to be, I'm hoping that there's fireworks down at Crowley Lake, that there's going to be fireworks in one manner or another.

12:35 And I'm just really disappointed that they would do that. So I guess I'd like to ask the Mammoth Times to be the first to donate to our next year's fireworks. Thanks, Terry. Jane. Hi, my name is Jane Baer. I'm representing the JLA Project. And for those of you who don't know, the JLA Project built the Vilcum Brothers Skateboard Park and donated it to the town of Mammoth Lakes for $1.

13:10 And for the past seven years, the JLA Project with the Town of Mammoth Lakes has a public-private partnership that takes care of all of the maintenance and sometimes we do landscaping and different things. This year, the Town of Mammoth Lakes has provided the material for the maintenance and we have provided the labor. The JLA Project has two major fundraisers every year. We do the putting contest, which will be Saturday.

13:39 September 7th at Sierra Star. And then this year we did the JLA Bank Slalom. It was a very successful event that it was held on Chair 5 at Mammoth Mountain. Our main disaster of the time was that in our registration we did it online and before we knew it in an hour and a half we had 248 entrants and we only had a field for 150.

14:08 So we had a great success, and we hope that the bank slalom will be one of the premier bank sloms. Anyway, next year, we hope to increase our event from one day to four days. So we bring quite a bit of tourists to the town for our event. Also, because our event was such a success, we have raised all of the money to build the Little Brothers Skaper Park, and so we are hoping to have the same type of agreement that we had before.

14:37 Where we build the scaper park and donate it to the town of Mammoth Lakes. We met with a contractor today and so we're actually ready to start even possibly this summer and have the area complete and ready even for the end of the summer. So I just wanted to let you know that that's what we're working on right now. Jane, thanks. Jane, real quick. Are you working at all with the Park and Rec Commission?

15:06 Yes, we actually worked with Peter Berlusconi and the skateboard park was part of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System plan and we were part of that plan and we at some point had thought that we were going to have to ask for matching money through Measure R but we have all of the money for the skateboard park itself. We'll probably be even doing another part.

15:33 Next summer, but that would be just an area that has pavers, picnic benches, and things like that. Can you share with us what you need from the town at this point? Basically, we're just working with Peter Bernasconi to make sure that we're going to be following the rules and regulations that the town needs us to follow in order to build. Great. Thank you.

16:03 When we go to do our event that some of you guys will all come out and support us. Our petting contest is something that anybody from almost a toddler to somebody who's 100 years old can come out and support. It's just a lot of fun. And it's September the 7th. Thank you. Thank you, Jane. Lee. The correspondence we talk about next, right?

16:36 Actually, we're not going to talk about that, but if council members have questions about the correspondence, they'll have an opportunity to ask questions or make comments. I'll mention it next because mine has an issue with it. Okay, I'm happy to announce that the emergency cards are done that I did last year. They are completely different. It has the same concept, but they're brighter colors. If we need a large number of them. Thank you. Excellent.

17:17 The reason I changed the colors is last year where it says police department, fire department, it was dark green with red. And people have a hard time seeing colors. They couldn't see it. So I really brightened it up. I took off a few things. I took off Turner Gas because there are no more that combined it with Amerigas. We now have Eastern Sierra Propane, so that's on there. I took off the weather because I have the mountains website and the town's website. And normally when you look on those, it automatically has the weather for you.

17:46 And that's pretty about much all that I've changed. Oh, and then the tourism is put onto this also. And then on the back, it's a 3D emergency numbers. I'll be passing these out all through the town. And I know, Jo Bacon, I was told you guys have your, what is it, for the condos when everybody comes and does everything, what's that called? Homeowner meeting. Yeah, homeowner meeting. Somebody told me yours is this weekend. No. No. Okay. We've already had ours.

18:15 Well, I talked at John Morris, and I'm going to be coming to the next Tuesday meeting for the Lodging Association. So anybody that needs these, let me know how many you need. I'm going to bring them. And they're just going to be passed out. We ordered 10,000 of them. And I'm very excited that the Fire Safe Council still had a grant. They gave it to the Fire Safe Council, and the Fire Safe Council paid for half of this. And then there were others that donated also.

18:41 And I'm hoping next year maybe more people might get involved because there is no advertisements on this. And it's by the people, for the people. And I want the people to know the town did not put any money into this. They have other issues. I did not even ask them for it. So this was done by the people being passed out by the people. And I would also like to thank Scotty and Simone from Mammoth Taxi.

19:06 They volunteer to put these out at the airport in their little display case, and they'll be putting them in their taxis also. So I thank you guys very much for doing that to help outreach to get the people to understand what's going on. So I'd really like to talk about the correspondence because I have an issue with it. Go ahead. You've got the podium. The reason I want to talk about it is sometimes people make mistakes, and that's okay.

19:34 And somebody brings it up to you and you fix it and it's fine. But when you don't fix it, it's a problem. Mine was put in on the agenda upside down and it wasn't all in there. My issue is with the town of Mammoth Lakes and with the lack of public safety. And I'd like to read it because it's not all on the internet. It's upside down. Why would somebody put it upside down and not fix it when I believe Matt Lehman called? Did you call also?

20:01 I did, but it was after it had already gone out, so I think... But it should be able to still fix it because we called so early. Ms. Gash, my understanding, because I have looked into this issue, is that our scanner scans handwritten documents in an upside-down manner. We attempted to fix it. Jamie personally attempted to do it several times, and we just couldn't get the document to work.

20:33 So I apologize if no one has gotten back to you to explain this, but that's what I care about. I would still like to read it because there's a lot of people that aren't here and I want people to know it. The main reason I wrote this is Michael Grosblatt taught me you need to put your name on a dotted line if you have a problem. I would like to see more people in the public stand up and take responsibility for our town if you want it to change. If you don't put your name on a dotted line, you have to go to court. The judge will throw it out and say you're sick.

21:00 You need to put your name down and stand up for what you believe in. The reason I'm writing a complaint is I cannot sit back anymore and watch the Town of Mammoth Lakes public safety deteriorate. Public safety should be the foremost number one priority. The Town of Mammoth Lakes has it backwards. Public safety and the infrastructure is at the bottom of the list with funding only, only if money comes available. My complaint is against the Town of Mammoth Lakes for putting the residents and the guests

21:28 In harm's way when it comes to public safety. The town of Mammoth Lakes has deteriorated the police department to a minimal staff on many days with 30,000 people in town. Many events have a lot of alcohol that keep our minimal staff police department very busy with the rest of the residents and the guests on our own. You can only ask our minimal staff police department to do so much before you put their lives in jeopardy. Another public safety problem is the lack of animal control.

21:56 There's way too many dog bites out there, way too many dogs without leashes on, and way too many dogs running loose, and dog stuff all over town. People sometimes pick it up and they leave the bag in your yard, or they leave it all over Main Street or something. That is not a very good thing for our guests to see in town. Why does the town of Mammoth Lakes not enforce the town of Mammoth Lakes laws? There is no excuse for the lack of public safety. And why haven't we had any wildlife outreach education?

22:25 This morning I was out, I walked my guide dog every morning and there was a humongous spill in the four dumpsters out by Rite Aid and a lady was walking by that was out of the country and told me she is very scared. She goes, what do I do? I'm scared. What do I do if I run into a bear? Please help me. Why does your town have this happen? And I told her, all I could tell her is animals are unpredictable. If you see them, walk the opposite direction. Don't go near the dumpster. If you're in the woods or something, wear a bell or a whistle with you.

22:54 And then go to the Forest Service Station and ask questions. We need to have an outreach. Our town is dirty and people know it. And we need to start working on public safety because if you live in like the Knolls or the Crest or the Bluffs, you have no idea what's going on in town. If you live in Sierra Valley sites, the Blue Roofs, and I will say it, Criminal Row, you know what I'm talking about. And our council's not listening to the people of the town.

23:23 You need to start listening to your constituents. Thanks. Thank you. Just for your information, I didn't see you at the two strategic planning sessions, but I'm sure you'll be happy to know. I was asked to leave town. I had to leave. I understand. I'm not faulting you for that, but I'm sure you'll be pleased to know that public safety and funding of public safety was among the top five priorities stated.

23:49 And that was one of the outcomes of that session. Why did it say only when money comes available? Indeed, we're hearing you. But thank you. Thanks for the letter and the comment. But why say only when money comes available and then you have the other ones you put the money into? Well, it speaks for itself. Because you're putting our officers in danger here. I don't want to debate. It's public comment. Thank you. Anybody else from the public wish to speak? I see Kathy. Hi, stranger.

24:19 Welcome back. Was that you that waved the other day, Kathy? Going to shady rest? I'm like the bad student hiding in the back of the class. Hi, my name is Kathy Cage, for the record. I wanted to follow up. I sent an email this last week. Everyone graciously received it, and I got a nice response from the town manager about filling the position that's being vacated for our town building official.

24:45 And I wanted to just follow up in public comment for a couple of reasons. And I wanted to specifically ask the town clerk to show in the record that I'm commenting on my request to have the position filled with a full certified building official now that we're losing Johnny Gates. So I'll preface my comments by saying I feel like it's a great loss. Probably many of you have gotten that same feedback. It was a surprise to many of us.

25:15 Very difficult, inopportune time, of course, in the middle of build season. It's never really good, but it's tougher in the middle of build season. But I suspect those of you who don't work in the trades really don't have to think about it very much. I mean, honestly, if the department's working well, you know, you don't get comments, you don't get calls. They just go about their business and do it.

25:37 You know, Johnny was a particularly fine individual, and he worked for a long time doing the work of a building official without having the title, probably not the pay, that type of thing. Having sat in the seats that you're in before, I understand how difficult it is to lose good people when you don't have money to pay them.

25:57 And I suspect that's at the base of it. I mean, Johnny and I aren't drinking partners, so I don't know the story of his life. But most of us who, you know, live and work, it's a small town, a small building community, you kind of know. I mean, sometimes you've got to do things for professional development. You know, we've been hanging out at the assistant building official for a long time, probably got a great opportunity and took it.

26:18 We've been without, for the rest of the general public to know, we've been without a building official and, you know, a chief person in charge since we lost Byron Pullman a number of years ago. And, you know, it's not a good way to operate.

26:33 You know, the people that are junior to the building official that now that are kind of left, which is what happened over time, is you kind of shift around who's making decisions and how's that going to happen. When you're in a building environment that's kind of going fast and furious, which we have been in, it's super important to have one person in charge who's qualified and knows what they're doing.

26:57 It's a combination of your inspectors and your plans examiners and who you get to contract for plans examination. It's a bunch of technical stuff that as a council you probably don't ever want to get into. But it's really, really important to have the right person doing it. And anyone who administers the building code, which we do in the town of Mammoth Lakes, needs to have a designated building official.

27:22 I just wanted to make public my request that you make that a priority to fill it with a qualified person. I don't know the problems with overlapping pay scales or if that's maybe at the heart of it, I don't know, but somehow that seems fixable. It really seems, I just want to reiterate the importance it is, I think, to those of us in the trades that the town do it right and get a building official.

27:46 And that type of thing. And I just wanted to kind of wrap it up with a sort of overarching comment. The reason why I came forward at this time, trust me, John, you and I sat in with one other horrible town council where you have no money and you have to look people in the face and you cut their position and it's brutal. You know, it's not having enough money to do all the things you know you want to do and keep the service levels where you want to have it. If you don't have the money, you don't have the money.

28:11 One of the kind of lessons learned I've taken away from our horrible airport debacle was that that was negotiated at a time when we had really serious budget problems. And at the time, the airport was a drain on the general fund and we're trying to balance the budget and some, you know, charming embedded, you know, community guy comes in and, you know, and we sat there with a public-private partnership mentality on thinking, you know, we both have the same interests. And to me,

28:40 One of those things in retrospect is when you're on the public side, you have to really be super protective of the public interests all the time. And the reason that ties into the building official is that there are so many decisions that inspectors and building officials and plans examiners make all the time. Huge amounts of judgment calls all the time, every day. Every inspection are judgment calls.

29:06 But where it gets more important is when bigger developments come, and we all suspect that'll happen again, and we hope it'll happen again. We know it will. And we need to have somebody there with integrity. It has to be someone who's a direct public employee. You can't contract that out. It's got to be someone who's only loyal to the general public, who pays their salary, independent integrity. I mean, honestly, I'm not defining Johnny, but, you know, we're losing him.

29:33 I just wanted to reinforce the importance of that, that despite the fact that we're in a very difficult budget crunch time, some things you've got to commit to doing well. So I hope we can count on you all collectively to, you know, fill what are going to be hard shoes to fill. Go ahead. Real quick, I'm sorry. Is it true that the state of California requires

30:00 Yes. That position? I actually have pulled some additional things from the Health and Safety Code. I didn't add that to my email with you guys. The general interpretation to my understanding is you can go maybe about a year or so without having one, without being in compliance. But we've been many more years than one without having a designated billing official. But it is my understanding that you can kind of stretch the reasons out why you don't have a certain amount of time, but we've been a really long time.

30:26 I think your point is it's not only a position that's needed in our community, but it's also a position that is legally required. It has always been my understanding that that is the case. And so I, anyway. Thank you. Kathy, I just want to say, officer, go ahead. No, I was just going to ask if it was appropriate for Marianna to give a quick overview of the short-term and long-term plans for that position. Okay.

30:47 Sure, and I was going to do that in departmental comments. I can do that right now. Later, it's at your pleasure. And I'll talk about Ray's position as well perhaps later. But on Johnny's position, as far as we know, you're absolutely right. The building official certification is required. It doesn't have to be a separate position. As a matter of fact, we don't have enough work for a separate position. We don't have enough money for a separate position. However,

31:15 And this was something I was going to address under Johnny's item. Johnny has worked on so many different things. When I asked him to put together a list of projects that are his typical projects, I think that list is five or six pages long. But there are three separate components. One is building inspections. Second is code compliance. And the third one is solid waste.

31:39 That does not include the building official, and Johnny himself is not certified as a building official, so you're absolutely right. Thus far, we haven't had a building official. We need to have one. So in crisis comes an opportunity. So in a crisis that is before us, i.e. losing Johnny, and it's an emotional and professional crisis, we're trying to move on and focus on the opportunity. And the opportunity here is to...

32:04 Have a building official certification. We will have it. I'm not quite ready to release a plan. I'm hoping to send an email to the council, which is a public record tomorrow. But right now, the idea is to have a position to fulfill the building inspector duties, to have a position, most likely part-time, to fulfill the code compliance duties, which is something that we need. Lee just spoke to that need. And for those positions to handle solid waste between them.

32:33 But also to have most likely on a contractual basis we need to work out the details including the unions and conversations with them. Also have the building official certification worked into that plan. So we're aware of the issue, we're aware of the need, of the legal need, and we'll make sure that it's part of that plan. And I know this isn't a regular agenda item so I won't get into it very much, but I was concerned that

33:02 Because it's going to be attractive to, financially, to contract out the building official position somewhere. And that's primarily what I was interested in long term in not doing, honestly. Because anyone that works for a private firm and doesn't have the independence a building official needs, ultimately. You know, you can always pick up contract inspection services when you need them, that type of thing. But again, just because most of the council members, you know, like at policy level,

33:30 It's tough when you don't have enough money to go around. It's attractive to go for the lowest priced option. But I don't know if that would be the case or not, but I wanted to really urge you to not consider at least the building official duties, to not contract that out. Because I feel like the... It's my understanding that the origin of the California Fair Political Practices Commission and the rules there started in problems relative to development. Payola and that type of thing.

33:58 You know, it's very endemic in that part of governance and, you know, with our regulatory abilities if you don't have someone who has integrity and independence and that type of thing. So that was my main goal. Thank you. You guys at least got my message. Hopefully, you know, we can, you know, move ahead in a very solid possible way. We did. And the only other thing that I would mention on this item, not to go back and forth, we'll have a long meeting, is

34:22 I rely very heavily on Johnny's recommendation and expertise as to what position or positions could do the work that he's currently doing because he knows it best. So I think it's important for you all to hear that. Thank you. Thanks, Kathy. Okay. The podium's still open for those members of the public who wish to speak on an item that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Seeing no one else, we'll move on to...

34:51 The correspondence, do any council members have either comment or questions regarding the correspondence we have received? If not, council member reports and additions to the agenda. Matthew, can we start with you? Sure. The only thing I have to report today is just that I went to a TOT committee meeting this morning, and with our new TOT compliance people in there, they seem to have just taken the reins and jumped right in.

35:20 Kind of moved along without a beat. So I think they're doing a great job. And just some of the information that's being reported back, it sounds like some of the TOT compliance efforts are well on their way. I think they have, I think thus far since the program started, about $750,000 in new monies that are being collected from those that were not otherwise paying. And this week I think they're reporting about another...

35:45 50,000, I think, that have been put into the queue on top of what's already in the queue. So I just wanted to say thanks to those staff members that are working on this. They're chugging along pretty well. And also the BasicGov, which is going to be our computerized system, is also moving along. Given just the challenges we have with staff, they're getting it moved along pretty well. So I just want to say thanks to them.

36:13 Also to those members of the Lodging Association, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, who have been helping keep this on track and the importance that this has for our community. I mean, I think of what would have happened had we not collected that money in the past year. Had this program not been as successful as it was, I think we would have been in probably a little bit different place than we are right now. So that's all I have. Matthew, real quick while we're on that subject.

36:40 We lost some personnel that were doing that previously and generated the large amount of money that you mentioned. And I think because we lost the personnel that were collecting the TOT, we were all a bit leery that we were going to lose the momentum that we had and the ability to continue to enforce TOT collections. So it's good news, I think, to all of us that

37:05 It seems to be that now we're back on track with that. Yeah, I think that they put a good system in place. It's not perfected yet. It's getting perfected, but this good system's been put in place, and I think hopefully we'll stay on track. Good, thank you. John? I didn't have anything to add. Will you add the urgency item when it comes to you? Yes. Okay, thank you. It's just a couple of items.

37:33 At the last meeting of the downtown working group, we proceeded to approve another huge chunk of the commercial zoning chapter of the zoning code, so we're moving forward. There's a higher percentage, but not 100% yet on your zoning code update, Rick. And I also wanted to report that the mayor and I attended the first

37:56 Mammoth Lakes Recreation Steering Committee meeting this week with a very good interchange and exchange of the ideas and looking forward to that next meeting. All right. Thank you. A couple of items. A couple of council members, specifically Councilmember Lehman and myself, participated in the Community and Economic Development Director interviews.

38:22 That's five words for that position. I think it was Monday of this week, and interviewed, along with others, some candidates, at least one of whom was either qualified, and that will be coming back to Council, so I'm pleased with what we see so far. Secondly, Mayor Pro Tem Bacon and I attended the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Liaison Committee meeting this morning.

38:52 Presentation was given with respect to what MLTPA is doing and how it is expected to interface or how it is hoped to interface in the future with our partners in recreation, whether it is under the umbrella of MLR, that is interfacing with MLR if it is formed, or whether it's something that will be handled through the town, but I was quite pleased actually with

39:20 You know, a very well-articulated presentation about what it is they actually do, and that's going to be coming back to Council as well. There is an urgency item that I understand staff wishes the Council to add, and I'm going to suggest that we do so as number 14A, which will be the first policy matter, and I understand that we need some language in order to adopt.

39:45 As always, anytime you're going to add something to the agenda after it's been published, the council has to make findings that there's a need to take immediate action on the item and that the need to take immediate action came to the council's attention after the agenda was posted. So before taking action on that item, if you could just somebody muster up a motion in a second to make those findings, then we can add it.

40:07 I'll try this. I would move that the fact that it reflects an item that occurs before our next scheduled meeting that would make it an urgency item. Is that good enough? That'll do. Second. All right. There's been a motion and a second. Can we set a roll call vote? All in favor of that motion? Aye. Opposed? None. Motion passes 5-0. We'll add it as 14.

40:32 And it relates to the closure of Minaret Road during the 18th Annual Mammoth Festival of Beers and Bluesapalooza. All right. With that, agenda item number one, it has been requested by staff that that be continued. It is entitled Introduction to Newtown Employee, TOT's Compliance Specialist, Suzanne Felkel, who's not here this evening. And so my expectation is that it will be continued to the next regularly scheduled meeting in August.

41:01 Second, item number two is council presentation recognition of outgoing assistant building official Johnny Gates. Mayor, counsel, we actually skipped departmental reports, which I assume that we may address again, but I was just going to say. Really, I want to get through this agenda a little more quickly than anybody else does. I just wanted to say, because I think it's important, and then I also wanted to comment on Johnny.

41:26 That count the priorities that the council approved on July 8th and 9th that Mayor Wood mentioned are here. So they're available for the public view. We'll also have them online. So I wanted to make sure that the council and the public know that we have them publicly available. Secondly, just very quickly before Sandra speaks on Johnny, you know, there's...

41:51 No amount of words will describe how the organization feels about his departure and how the community feels. And I know that for a fact I feel that way. People that approach me express their feelings. Johnny is loved by everyone here in town, among staff, as well as in the community. And that combination is quite rare.

42:16 I haven't known Johnny for too long, but I had a chance and a pleasure to work with him in a number of capacities. One of them was really on employee issues and specifically on mediation and negotiation items that resulted in significant concessions from employees. Johnny's style is he would tell you how he feels and why he feels that way, but he will say it in a respectful manner.

42:43 Most of the time, face-to-face, one-on-one meetings. And that speaks to his professionalism and it's a reflection of who he is. So, John, we'll miss you greatly. As I mentioned to staff and I mentioned to you, we will try to focus on the positive and try to celebrate your accomplishments as opposed to focusing on the

43:12 So tonight I would also like to thank Johnny for his more than 10 years of service to the town. Johnny's departure is bittersweet. We're really sad to lose him, but we're happy he's moving up in his career. He has provided an excellent level of customer service during his tenure here, and he goes above and beyond the call of duty on a weekly basis.

43:45 He takes on new projects with enthusiasm. He's always willing to help out a fellow employee with questions or issues. His outgoing personality and his willingness to go the extra mile has earned him a great working relationship with all of his coworkers as well as the contractors in town. I know his strengths will help him in becoming an outstanding building official for the city of Truckee, and I'm glad his talent will stay here in the Sierra.

44:13 Johnny, on behalf of all the employees, I wish you the best of luck in all you do, and I really hope you come back and see this often. I understand the Contractors Association has a presentation for you as well. These are the guys that are on the other side of you. This is unusual and an honor, I'm sure. Well, Johnny, we definitely appreciate everything that you've done to work with us as the Contractors Association. Martin and the rest of the team came up with the idea to...

44:55 Present you with a unique plaque. It's a certificate of appreciation and recognition for your years of service. And we tried to, Martin really ran around and made it something unique to the community that you can remember us by. It's signed by the board. And like I said, we really appreciate everything you've done with us. You're going to be a huge loss. I don't really know what else to say. You have anything to say to Martin? Yeah, I mean, Martin Kleinbarton did.

45:23 Vice President of the Contractors Association. I share the same sentiments that almost everyone in Kathy Cage got up here and said, Johnny will really be missed here. Johnny and I have not always been on the same page, but over the last year or so, we've worked on a bunch of little projects and things, and we were really coming to some really good things.

45:53 Now he's leaving. So, you know, from my heart, you know, it's really, we're going to miss him. With Johnny leaving in just a matter of a few days, for me personally, it's not bittersweet. I'm selfish. I can't stand losing Johnny and his family. Johnny is the epitome of what the community of Mammoth Lakes is about in a number of areas.

46:36 He's not only a fine worker for the town of Mammoth Lakes, and as a dichotomy gets along with the people, his job is to make them do what is correct. I can't think of another building inspector that we've had in Mammoth Lakes, or one if we could possibly have, that has the ability that Johnny has to balance his responsibilities to the town, and at the same time...

47:02 Get the people that are building things to do what you're supposed to do. Johnny has a wonderful family. He is the epitome of what a person could be in the community of Mammoth Lakes. He's a fine man. He's a hard worker. He's active in the community. He volunteers his time. I mean, there's so many things that this man does and has done for this community.

47:31 That I personally can't thank him enough. So if that's what I can do, John, is wish you luck and thank you. Sure. You know, so the only other thing that I'm going to say is that anybody that can go through their adult life with the name Johnny has got to be... Johnny, on behalf of the town of Mammoth Lakes and the town council, I present to you this plaque which is a statement of our gratitude for your service all of these years. I wish you the best. Thank you.

48:15 I have a short thing that I'd like to say. I don't want to embarrass Johnny, but I am the town attorney for the town of Truckee, as well as being the town attorney for the town of Mammoth Lakes. And I wasn't involved in the selection process at all, but I have talked to the people that did the candidate selection, that did the interviews, and they had 50 or 60 applicants for that position. A lot of really, really qualified people. And at the end of the day, they thought that Johnny was clearly the best. And I think that says a lot about Johnny. And I'll tell you that after they made the decision,

48:44 They have been looking at the articles in Sierra Wave and the sheet about Johnny and the town manager and the community development director both separately came up to me and said, we're looking at these comments and people are reacting as though it's been a death in the family. They were just completely shocked and blown away that a building official could ever have that much love from the community. So Truckee is very, very excited that Johnny is coming and he really beat out a really incredible field of people to get that spot.

49:20 So I'll try and do my best. But this community has meant the world to my family. It still means the world to my family. Mammoth is going to thrive with or without me. Mammoth is going to prosper. Mammoth is going to come back. But I would not be in the position to be able to progress in my professional career if it wasn't for Mammoth, if it wasn't for the contractors, if it wasn't for the co-workers, if it wasn't for the community, if it wasn't for the support.

49:51 of this town that comes out all the time as a family type thing and a team effort. And, you know, from Heidi and myself, we're going to miss this place, but we wish you well. Okay, we're going to go back and... I'd like to say something about Johnny. Johnny, who are you? Johnny is one of the greatest people in this town. He did help Sierra Valley sign down a lot. But I'm going to put a different twist to this.

50:48 I understand why there's a mass exodus of this town of the employees. I understand why Johnny's leaving. Our town is pushing our employees way too hard. About two years ago, Johnny and I talked, and I was going to videotape him working all day long so that our council members could see everything that he does. And I drove around with him. He knows how many minutes it takes to drive down each road to get to each place.

51:16 That is how busy Johnny was. He was pushed very hard. And I have a feeling Johnny would still be here today if he wasn't pushed so hard because he does love this town. And I do hope our council members realize there's a mass exodus and you need to value your employees and treat them as if they're your executives because each one of them are very fine citizens of this town and they try to do the best job they can and they don't sometimes feel appreciated.

51:45 Thank you, Johnny, for what you've done. Thank you a lot. Okay. We're going to go back a step to see if there are any reports from other commissions or department heads. And seeing none, we'll get back on track and go to agenda item number three. Thank you, Joe, for helping me. We are going to go to the consent agenda. And do I have any council member who wishes to pull any item? And if not,

52:18 Is there a motion? We can make a motion that council approve seven agenda items three through 14. Second. Okay, there's been a motion and a second. Jamie, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us to 14-A, which is the urgency item, and that is entitled to adopt a resolution authorizing the Minaret Road closure and parking fee program

52:47 For the 18th Annual Mammoth Festival of Tears and Blueza Palooza, I see Peter on the agenda, so take it away. Mayor Wood and Councilmembers, this item is for one of the town's favorite summer events with the Blueza Palooza. This item really is about authorizing closure of Minaret Road for approximately 500 feet south of Minaret Road to Minaretian Boulevard. This will allow the

53:14 A private parking facility with paid program which will raise funds, be managed by the noon and sunrise rotary clubs and raise funds for the local high school school band program. We've done this program, this will be the third year of the road closure. The missile code does require the council take action because it is a fundraising event on town property.

53:45 Closing the right-of-way. And I believe there are also members of the, I think somebody's here from, yeah, Sean Turner's here also if you have questions regarding the fundraising event itself. If there's any other questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Questions to Peter. All right, none. Does the council wish to hear from Sean Turner or any member of the public? If not, I'll mention it.

54:20 Go ahead. Go ahead. Oh, all right. While you look for it. First of all, I'll preface it with saying I have participated in this the past two years and it is a great opportunity for a fundraiser and it definitely improves the traffic situation. So with that said, I would move that we approve option one, which adopts a resolution designating Minaret Road as closed for a period of time and direct staff to continue to work with the event organizer.

54:49 Second. Okay, there's been a motion and a second. Any additional discussion? If not, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

55:03 All right, it takes us to agenda item number 15, which is entitled, Approve the Proclamation Declare on August 16, 2013 as Choose Civility Day, presented by Stacey Adler, Superintendent of the Mono County Office of Education. Stacey. Good evening, Mayor Wood and Councilmembers. Thank you for providing me an opportunity to present this resolution to you tonight. The Choose Civility Initiative came about during a MAC.

55:32 A multi-agency council meeting several months ago following a presentation given by Tom Shagnon, the Stanislaus County Superintendent of Schools. He began a Choose Civility initiative in his county after he had attended too many school board meetings in which both attendees and board members were behaving badly. They were cursing, shouting, insulting one another, and all in front of children. This uncivil behavior coupled with the increase of

56:02 Uncivil behavior that can be seen today on TV, in the national press, and via social media was the catalyst that led Tom to do something to try to improve social discourse in his county. Although we rarely have public meetings in Mono County that are less than civil, the MAG Committee, which includes Chief Watson, District Attorney Tim Kendall,

56:31 Thought this initiative would parallel nicely with the program being implemented in our county school districts called Positive Behavior Intervention and Support. The main idea behind the Choose Civility initiative is to promote civility in our everyday interactions. As our wristbands, which we have for you, say, just be nice. So why civility? Civility is a core community value.

56:58 Civil dialogue is necessary in decision making and we want to be good role models for our kids. This initiative includes 12 principles based upon the work of PM Forney's book, Choosing Civility, 25 Rules of Considerate Conduct. Our 12 principles include listen, respect other people's opinions, accept and give praise, apologize earnestly, and speak kindly.

57:28 These principles will be rolled out one per month over the course of this year. So as you said, our kickoff event is planned for Friday, August 16th in Mammoth Lakes, and the resolution before you asks in part to name that day be Choose Civility Day in Mammoth Lakes. Thank you, Stacey. Questions? I understand there were some questions at the Board of Supervisors meeting. Oh, yeah.

57:58 There were. We're civil tonight. We don't have any. That's much appreciated. While you stay there, I was moved that we approve the proclamation as outlined in Agenda Item 15. Second. All right. There's further discussion, first of all. There's been a motion and a second. And if I could have a vote of ayes. All in favor? Aye.

58:23 Opposed? None. Motion passes 5-0. Stacey, I have, before you go. Yes, sir. I have a proclamation, let's see if I can read this in one of my glasses, of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, declaring August 16, 2013, as choose civility day to present to you only half the town council. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right.

58:58 It takes us to agenda item number 16, which is Appeal of Tax Collector Notice of Determination of Past Due Transient Occupancy, T.O.T. Taxes, Penalties, and Interests Regarding the Property Located at 275 John Muir, and I understand the owner is James. Is it Caviani? Yes. I'll indicate just as a reminder that this council sits, I guess, in a quasi...

59:29 And I will point out before we start that I have not assisted staff in this. I'm advising the council only.

59:55 And that separation of functions where I'm not advising the staff helps to ensure due process. If I may ask the town manager, do you expect that our staff, Shannon Freeman, is going to give a presentation first and then the appellant will give his presentation?

1:00:13 That is correct. And generally, Mayor, we try to follow the processes outlined on, I think, page three of the agenda, TOTI appeal hearing procedure, statement and presentation by staff, statement and presentation by property owner, questions from the Town Council, call for public comment, and then deliberation. That's great. Thank you. Thank you. I see that. Shannon. Thank you. Okay. Mayor and members of the Council, my name is Shannon Freeman. I'm here to represent.

1:00:42 I'll give you the details of the Caviani case. So it started in January of 2012. Sorry, I'm very nervous. In January of 2012, we opened the case and Mr. Caviani was received his first warning for renting transient in a zone that was not zoned. In April, we still had no response, April of 2012.

1:01:14 So in May of 2012, we conducted some sting emails, and we received responses giving nightly rates. In September of 2012, we sent a citation, and in September of 2012, we did a TOT assessment. There was no response after that assessment, so then Mr. Caviani did respond, and we did a notice of a hearing on September 20th.

1:01:46 From that September 20th assessment, Mr. Caviani requested to have a hearing before the tax collector on January 14th of 2013. At that time, he presented his documentation detailing the past rentals of his property. The information provided was reasonable, and the amount for the past due rents was reduced to $8,772.06.

1:02:16 Which included penalties and interest. Mr. Caviani paid the $6,965, which was the taxes. And what we're asking for today is he's requesting not to pay the penalties and interest of $2,674.41. The ordinance clearly states that if you rent on a transit basis, whether it's zoned or unzoned, you are responsible for the penalties and interest.

1:02:45 That is Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Section 3.12.050. Good question. Thank you, Shannon. Questions? Shannon, the original amount of the assessment was $20,980. Is that correct? Correct. Thank you. And that original amount is just an estimate? That was an estimate based off calendars that we received on the website. Thank you.

1:03:20 All right, so as I understand it, you extrapolate from the information that you have derived or did derive from the website what the appropriate tax would be and penalties as well, and that's based upon information that you were able to see that's essentially public? Correct. Or available to the public? Uh-huh. Okay. Go ahead. You were going to say something? And then when Mr. Caviani requested a hearing before the tax collector,

1:03:48 He provided documentation showing the actual rents and dates that he did have people there. So that's where that original, where it lowered down to that $8,000 based on the information that he's provided. Okay, so in essence, the property owner, Mr. Caviani, actually conceded that nightly rentals were taking place. It's just that he disputed or disagreed with you that it was...

1:04:13 That it would have generated as much or did generate as much TOT as was originally assessed? Correct. And then he provided documentation to show us what actually had happened. So I see that attached to the agenda bill are a number of attachments, and in particular attachment number two, which is entitled TOT Enforcement Case Summary. I take it that that's something that was prepared by staff.

1:04:39 As you were going through the investigation of this matter? Yes. Is that evidence that you want to have the council consider tonight? Yes. Okay. There are some other attachments as well consisting in large measure of correspondence as well as what appear to be website

1:05:11 I want to call it solicitations, but I don't mean that, advertisements for rentals. Is all of the stuff that we have something that you want to have us consider tonight as well? Yes. And then my last question is, has Mr. Caviani received all of these documents that are in the packet before us tonight, to your knowledge? In other words, does he know what we're considering?

1:05:37 You know what, I just kind of took this over, so I would assume that the person before, Patricia, would have forwarded all of this information to Mr. Caviani, or this would have been part of the notice of determination that was sent to him. Okay, is that your understanding of what our practice is? I believe that's part of the practice of the T.O.T. committee. As being a person on the T.O.T. committee, I understand that is part of our process to keep the owner informed along the way. And the person that was doing this before me, Sandra, who's behind me, is nodding yes.

1:06:05 Mayor Council, in addition, I think it's important to point out, and it's in the report, and Shannon mentioned this, that Mr. Caviani has paid $6,097.65, which are the taxes owed. So the taxes assessed by the town have been paid by Mr. Caviani. What he has disputed and hasn't paid...

1:06:32 Are the penalties, interest, and enforcement charges that total to $2,674.41. And so I believe that that's the amount in dispute. Okay. And a question. In looking at the detailed documents is the penalties, interest, and enforcement charges were recalculated and lowered when the amount of the taxes was lowered. Is that correct? That's correct.

1:07:03 Okay. With no other questions, we'll have a statement and presentation by the property owner, Mr. Caviani, sir. Yes, hi. I have written my speech because I'm not a good public speaker, so I'll read it to you. I'm here to voice my complaint against the method that was used to collect what the town staff calls TOT. The total amount computed was paid in January.

1:07:32 Only the entrance penalties are being distributed here since they contain some errors. I was told that my presence at the hearing was not required and that it could be conducted by telephone. The first phone meeting was scheduled for November 4, 2012. I waited by the phone and I live in Southern California. I don't live here in town.

1:08:00 I waited by the phone for several hours and finally I called them and I was told that the meeting date was changed but they forgot to let me know. The second hearing was on January 14 and I received a phone call at 11 a.m. and I was asked if I had any questions which I answered no since they had not sent any documents to me prior to the meeting.

1:08:30 I obviously had no questions. They forgot to, or somehow I did not receive the documents, which I'm referring to the new ones that were adjusted to a lower amount, was not sent to me at the time that we had the full hearing. And all the documentation here

1:08:57 They say that I was present in the meeting. They don't mention that it was a phone meeting. I was not present. The whole thing took about two minutes because I have not received any documents. I have no questions. I was not aware of how they conduct their business, but I hung up the phone. The next day, I received an email that showed the new amounts.

1:09:25 Looking through the computations, I found several mistakes. When I emailed back that I don't agree with some of these papers, they told me, well, at this time, the only thing I can do is appear to the town council, which I did. At this point, it's hard to bring all the mistakes one by one, but I thought I could just make an example.

1:09:56 That you could see, if you could distribute this to the members. Does the staff have this as well? I only made five calls, half an hour before the meeting, which is another reason for not being prepared. Help is telling me to let you know that they send this stuff to me, the whole package that you have on Monday, and I was on my way coming here on Monday.

1:10:51 And I checked my email yesterday morning, and I emailed back that I don't have any of these, so I had to make copies at the town stationers from the documents I had in my laptop. And those are the documents that I was able to print to show you. It's a basic common sense. Anyone with an elementary school math knowledge will figure out what is wrong here.

1:11:28 The first page 13, I mean page 12, which was the original amount that they sent to me as being due, the total TOT, the total tax amount they guessed to be 15,634. I highlighted that. And two lines below that is the interest they computed

1:12:01 So here we have total tax, $15,000 something, total interest, $1,200 something. So on the second sheet, on page 13, you will see the correct amount. The total tax dropped from $15,000 to $6,097. And if you look two lines down from that, again, I highlight the tax, you will see that the interest went up to $1,358.

1:12:31 Which doesn't make sense. If the tax went down to one-third almost, the interest went up. So I thought in a hurry I could make this as an example of some of the mistakes that was made. At this point, instead of, I don't mind if Council wanted to go through every fine item and figure out what the mistake was.

1:13:10 Could be done, but all I'm asking for is that the Council choose an option two, which means that consider the amount of tax as the total amount paid and not required it. That's it. Okay, questions from Council. Mr. Kerr, we had a couple questions. How long have you owned your home? Oh, I'm sorry, I can't see very well.

1:13:47 Actually, this is a good question. I built the house myself. I purchased the property in 1995. I worked on it myself from 1997 to 2000. I did all the labor myself. 5,000 square feet home, four stories on a hillside. I built it all myself. And on October 13 of 2000, I had car accidents driving here from

1:14:20 The rest of the house I had to hire people. So it was, I've owned it since I've taken law. Any other questions, how long have you been renting your home? The rent didn't start until 2010, and basically, since the weather doesn't agree with me, I used the house, and my daughter said that she could take care of it, I wanted to sell. She said, don't sell that. You worked on the house, you should keep it.

1:14:52 So I said, fine, and she discovered that there is a way to rent with some income to pay for the house of kids. As a matter of fact, there is nothing on the veto that shows that we are not supposed to do this. We were surprised that there is such a, we thought, if you own your house, you can rent it. But then we found out the hard way that now you can not in this town. And we obeyed since then. As soon as I found out, I stopped.

1:15:27 Running the ads, we are advertising for 31 days or less, I should say, and nobody wants it, and the cows have been staying vacant. So you're no longer ran under 30 days? Well, you would like to, but it's hard to find the... Thank you. I have a question. A question of Shannon. Yes. In slash staff. Do we have the ability, or is it appropriate to...

1:16:02 We figure the interest. Yeah, if you refer to, I believe it's page number 75 in the packet, which is the actual notice of determination, this sheet here that Mr. Caviani handed out, that was solely based on the estimate that we got off of the calendars. After Mr. Caviani did provide his bank statements and things that are also attached in the packet that we went through to find out actual what was rented and what taxes were due, the notice of determination,

1:16:34 Determination, which is dated January 15, 2013, does have the correct periods for the taxes that are due and the correct penalties and the correct interest. And that's where the total 2006-74-41 comes in? That's correct. Okay, thank you. Quick question. But this is from November of 2011. He just stated he was renting his home in 2010, so we didn't collect anything in 2010, right?

1:17:03 Well, on this Notice of Determination, the first period that he said he started renting was October through December of 2010. Thanks. Can you calculate the interest? What's your methodology? Interest is calculated at 1.5% per month after it's delinquent. So, for example, in October through December would be due the end of January 2011. So it's 1.5% per month coinciding up until the date that it's paid. So I take it that...

1:17:39 The numbers that are reflected in the agenda bill are not accurate because interest continues to accrue daily, six months later. Yeah, so Mr. Caviani, he paid the taxes, so penalties and interest do not accrue on penalties and interest. So can we infer that

1:18:07 The original interest amount was also an estimate because you did not have the detail that was later provided and you were able to calculate for each quarter. Yes, that's correct. Mr. Covey, I've got a question for you. This is your opportunity to present evidence at what is a new hearing. And what I've heard is, by way of example, the interest, you believe that the interest has been computed or calculated incorrectly.

1:18:38 And that provides a basis for your request that we waive the penalties and interest. Is that a fair statement? Basically, I feel that the whole operation wasn't correctly and necessary. There was no need for all this happening. That's why I mentioned that there was a first meeting that you forgot to call me about at the second meeting.

1:19:15 And that they told me that it's okay to do it without being there, but that wasn't the case. And if they had told me that no, I have to be present, I would have mentioned everything, I would have gone over everything, I would have had my documents ready to question every line item. But that didn't happen. And even in their writing, and even in her speech today, she said that I was present. I mean, I was not. There was a phone.

1:19:45 And that's different. I wasn't there. They also didn't send this stuff to me, the documents, prior to that meeting. If they had done it, again, I would have had a better chance if we had phone here and saying that, yes, I insisted we get such items on such things or questions, but I wasn't able to question any of that. So basically, since they screwed up the whole operation, in my case, I would like to

1:20:12 Well, given what you've heard now from staff with respect to page 75, which is a calculation line by line of the interest due on each of the assessments for the periods that are described there, do you still disagree with the calculation of 1,350? Well, I really don't know from what date to what date they're doing it because, you know, I'm confused. Well, how could they figure they...

1:20:41 On the first assessment, they come up with one figure for a higher total, and on the second one with a lower one. I just don't understand how it was done. Well, do you have a different figure that you think... I have not figured anything. I just know that there are several mistakes on their computation. The other question I have, maybe as a matter of curiosity or maybe more,

1:21:05 This matter has been continued on our agenda, I think, three or four times. I don't know why that is offhand, but is it fair to say that before each of these hearings you had either a packet or at least some opportunity to see what the staff was going to present to the council? Well, I thought that all I need was to present my case.

1:21:32 And I was prepared to do that. And the evidence that I provided you today was put together in a hurry today because I received the package just two days ago. I mean, by the same token, I was supposed to be at the CIA several times and it was postponed because of my health reasons. And they had the opportunity to send the package to me and I didn't get it.

1:22:00 You know, if I had received it prior to the other meetings, I would have, you know, provided more detailed analysis and brought it over. But I thought to this point I just have to show up here and tell you that what happened on this hearing day was not done correctly and show you that there are mistakes and that should be enough for you to make a judgment.

1:22:27 I didn't think it's necessary at this point to go back and figure everything again and go every one figure. And this should have been done at the meeting that they told me I don't need to be. And also that they did not send the documents to me prior to me. So let me ask the staff, I know that this has been on calendar a number of times. Is this the first time?

1:22:52 Mr. Caviani has received the agenda bill and the packet and all the supporting documents or not? I believe that we did send him the agenda bill and packet with the original hearing. Just to clarify, this agenda bill packet is made up of documents that we have sent to Mr. Caviani through certified mail. We have proof that we've sent these certified. So basically, the process included...

1:23:21 Sending him the assessment, which is what he appealed to the tax collector, and then the final notice of determination was sent to him in January. I don't believe he sent that certified mail, but he appealed that notice of determination, but hasn't brought the issues that we're hearing today forward to us since as far as I know. Let's talk to you about that. No, and this notice of determination, which does have the amount due, was sent January 15th of 2013.

1:23:50 It's my understanding that the previous TOT compliance person, when the notice of determination, or when the case was open, that, you know, the notice of determination was sent, and I never received any information from anybody that the interest was incorrect, or that there was a problem. Mr. Matthew. Yes, I have a question. So my real question on this is, Mr. Caviani's presented,

1:24:18 The TOT of $6,097.65 as of January 15th. And the town has stated that $1,358.87 was due in interest for the period of time up until Mr. Caviani paid his TOT. Is that correct? That's just the interest. That's correct. And is that an accurate figure up until the time he paid?

1:24:48 Yes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions from council members of either staff or Mr. Caviani? Mayor, council members, if I may, I missed a little bit of a discussion. I apologize. But I was reminded, and I was going to speak to this as well,

1:25:07 I haven't touched this case, but just based on what's in the packet, which is a public document and has been online for weeks and weeks and available for anyone to view in this state, this country, anywhere else. But all of these letters that are addressed to Mr. Kaviani in this packet were mailed to him and some of them were mailed certified. So I think that's important to know as well. Okay, this is the time for the public to provide comment.

1:25:38 If any member of the public wishes to do so, and seeing none, we'll call for a council deliberation. Any council member wish to take the lead on this? I'll go ahead. Go ahead. You know, my thoughts are these. It seems like every time we hear a case, there's some different reason as to why folks have trouble or an issue with

1:26:08 with why a penalty interest or even the TOT is due. My personal thoughts are that in this particular case we have a property owner that's essentially agreed to the fact that this TOT is due and we have a system in place whereby we do outline the penalties, interest, and enforcement. And while I

1:26:34 You know, I can sympathize with the fact that there may be confusion on part of the owner. You know, we have laws in place. This is how the town functions. This is how we remove snow on our streets, provide police protection and everything else in our community. And I think it's important to understand that, you know, the town needs to take a hard-line stance on where we are with this. And I, for one, am in favor of just upholding.

1:27:04 What's on the books as presented by staff? Anyone else? I'm prepared to make a motion, Mr. Mayor. Okay. I'm hearing a council member wishes to make a motion, so we'll hear that. Make a motion. The council approves option one and uphold the tax collector's notice of determination dated January 15th, 2013 for the amount of $8,772.06 and direct staff to take all action necessary to finalize the appeal. The property owner has already paid $6,097.65.

1:27:35 Would be responsible for paying the balance of $2,674.41 in penalties, interest, and enforcement charges. I'll second. In a motion and a second, a further comment from council members. The only comment I have is for the benefit of the appellant. Based upon what I've heard, frankly, this appears to be in order. And therefore, I'm supportive of the motion. And if there's no other comment, I'll call for the roll call.

1:28:06 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, sir. That takes us to number 17, which is to consider extending the development impact fee diff reduction. Thank you. The item before you tonight is to allow the town council to consider the extension

1:28:36 of the temporary reduction of DIF, development impact fees, for an additional 12 months. The Council has temporarily waived DIF for two years, and the DIF waivers will expire on August 15th of this year. The previous resolution adopted by Council includes a requirement that the Council review the temporary fee waiver program and to determine if it's had a positive impact on the economy.

1:29:05 And whether or not it should be extended. And if no action is taken by the Council, the DIF waivers will expire on August 15th. Staff has provided the Council with some statistics showing that there was a minor increase in building permits over the past year. However, that evidence could have been because of the economy in general. There's a number of factors that could have resulted in that. And although the connection between the DIF reduction and the number of permits issued isn't clear,

1:29:34 Staff would recommend continuing the DIFF waivers for an additional year to allow the town to undertake a comprehensive study of DIFF that would include a review of the current DIFF program as well as an update of our town's capital and our development needs. So therefore, staff would recommend the town council choose option one and continue the DIFF waivers and I'm available for any questions that you have. Thank you, Sandra. Questions? I have one and that is, because I don't remember, is

1:30:05 Based upon the priorities that we established a couple of meetings ago, is this comprehensive review in your work plan? Have we funded it? No. I'm seeing the town manager and I'm hearing the mayor pro tem saying no. And actually, no, and I was going to push ourselves a little bit more on this to say that we need to review funding the comprehensive study when we do our mid-year budget review so that we would have the study done before this 12 months expires again.

1:30:34 Because we have not funded the DIF study yet. Yeah, I kind of thought so. Yes. Well, the reason I ask, of course, is that if the rationale is to extend so that we can do a study, but we haven't funded the study, then the rationale doesn't support the conclusion. But I guess the second follow-up question would be if we choose

1:31:02 Because I think it falls within one of the priorities that we've established, or at least is close enough to at least merit consideration of funding. Do you think that a comprehensive diff study or review can be done in six months if we would choose to do that mid-year? Well, from mid-year possibly. Right now, no.

1:31:25 We'll have to evaluate at mid-year what else staff has on their plates. And it's not just Sanders' department. Frankly, Sanders' department will have some role, but perhaps 50% of that role is going to be in hers. It's also public works and finance. And if I may, my idea of actually...

1:31:47 Making it an item for discussion at mid-year is that if John's rosy opinion of TOT comes in that we would have money to fund it or at that point it's the kind of thing I would consider taking out of the REU because it's a one-time study. It's something we need. So that's why I wanted to strengthen it by not just letting it go and come to July next year and say, oh, we have to extend it again. It's time to plan for getting this study finished. It is part of what we say is reinvesting.

1:32:17 And getting ready for development. When we get to mid-year, I will be supporting the swim team at Whitmore as well as fireworks at Crawley before I fund this. Is this one of those things that's mandated? Do we have to do that periodically? I say that because, as you know, I put on the table that mandated things

1:32:44 Don't count as priorities. They're mandated. They come before priorities. There are two pieces. There's a mandated report on how we have used the diff fee revenues that we collected, and that is an annual report. Since we have had a freeze on the diff fees, there really hasn't been anything to report, and we haven't had staff time available to...

1:33:10 To have that report prepared. So that's one part, and that's really looking at the past year, how were the revenues spent, which again, there's really nothing for us to report on. A more significant piece of this study, and that's really what the consultant would have to focus on, is, is if the right mechanism to fund the capital improvements that it currently is funding.

1:33:34 Is there a different mechanism? And so that's really more of a forward-looking study that needs to take place in conjunction with all of the other reinvestment or preparing for reinvestment activities that we're having in place. But I also will mention that on this study and the reason we haven't engaged anyone, we would have found the money, so to speak. We just passed the budget and this question came up. Any consultant, any study, especially study of this sort,

1:34:03 We'll take up staff's time. We just don't have that staff's time to assist the consultants. So why engage a consultant if we can't help them? So that's really the dilemma for us. In six months, we're hoping to reassess what all staff has on their plates, and that's going to be ready to fund a consultant's project and also to engage a consultant. Rick, I have a question of Andy, if I may. It says here in the staff report that the council...

1:34:31 That according to the resolution that was passed, 1252, it includes the following requirement that the council shall review the temporary development impact fee waiver program in one year to determine if it has a positive impact and should be extended. If no action is taken, in other words, we're talking about waiting for six months before we take any action, so if no action is taken to extend the temporary fee waivers, the waivers will cease on...

1:34:59 August 15th of this year in another less than a month. No, and I was not suggesting not continuing the action. I was saying pushing ourselves to make sure that when we get to this time next year, we know what we're going to do and we don't have to keep doing these temporary extensions because we've reworked the DIFF program. So we can have our cake and eat it too this evening? So to speak. On this issue? Yes, thank you. Okay. Sounds like you want to make a motion?

1:35:31 Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council choose option number one and temporarily suspend but not eliminate the development impact fee program for certain projects specified in the resolution for 12 months. Second. A motion and a second. Any other comment, deliberation, discussion? Thank you. I don't know why I want to get to the TV. Before 10. Well, it's because it's the thickest part of our packet.

1:36:04 Time for public comment. Any member of the public wish to speak on this issue. Sorry. Mayor, Town Council, my name is Jesse Baldwin. I'm here speaking as an electrical contractor in the community, president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. I'm also serving on the Board of Appeals and Building Advisory Commission. I just want to say I agree with your decision. We support it. We definitely wanted to see some more review go into.

1:36:36 What the development impact fees are going to be used for, how they're assessed. Currently we don't feel like there's enough knowledge about it to sustain that. And I also want to point out one really thing, one item that I feel is important is if you take a look at attachment three, which is the agenda bill dated August 15, 2012, it was notated in the analysis section item number one.

1:37:01 That for fiscal year 11 and 12, there were 11 projects that were subject to diff reduction. And then item 3 in that same section indicates 7 of the applicants were influenced and moved forward by the diff fee reduction. Where, you know, 4 of them would have built anyways, but 7 of them built because of the reduction. Now, this is not addressed in the agenda item number 17, the agenda bill tonight, dated July 24th.

1:37:27 The number of projects is listed, but not the number that were influenced. And there is some discussion in the agenda bill about we don't really know, did it help, did it not help? And I think it's difficult. There's a whole lot of factors there. If somebody doesn't have enough money to build anyways, they're not going to build just because there was a permit fee reduction. But at the same time, I think it is important to note that there was no reduction in the number of units built. There was a small increase.

1:37:56 To encourage next time going forward through this review period that the building department ask people that are applying for the permits whether or not their permit decision was influenced by the diff reduction or not because that's what was done previously and that data was collected and we were able to say out of 11, 7 were influenced. Currently this last year does not look like that data was collected or it was just left off of here but that could be an indicator.

1:38:23 You know, that we could use to gauge how well it's doing over the next year. That's all I know. Thank you, Jesse. Other members of the public who wish to speak on this? Bruce. Bruce Woodward. I'm the chairperson for the Building Advisory Committee. And we got up and we spoke to you a while back about that we were in favor of removing the waiving of the permit.

1:39:30 Thank you.

1:39:59 Thank you, Bruce. And I go along with Jesse, although I don't know exactly what you're going to vote on, but I'm just going to assume like he did that you guys are voting to extend this. All right, voting is still open for those who wish to speak. If not, we have a motion. Tim.

1:40:31 I guess just my name is Tim Flynn. I'm a property owner, resident, business owner. I was one of those houses that was submitted before that June 30th date. And anyhow, just for the public's knowledge that there is still development impact fees in place. And there is school district mitigation fees.

1:41:00 Fire District mitigation fees and workforce housing mitigation fees that are still in place. And so those I would like, you know, obviously school and water and fire are separate from the town, but the housing I would like to have taken a look at because I really don't see how a single family home

1:41:28 Okay, podium still open. Okay.

1:42:03 Motion to second. Other comments, deliberation, debate? Nope. If not, we will call for a vote. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes fine. Zero. Before we go on to this, is there consensus from at least two other council members to consider this funding the study at midyear? There is on my part. Yeah, I think there would be. I tend to agree with John, though. I think we put some other things.

1:42:31 On there. Oh, it's just to consider. Yeah. We've got several things to consider. Yes. All right. So there is at least a consensus three or more. Moves us to agenda item number 18. Authorized town manager to enter into a five-year professional services contract in Moro County for ongoing information technology and geographic information systems

1:42:59 Services for an estimated annual amount of $258,016. Mariana? Mayor, Councilmembers, in the interest of time, this Council has seen this issue, has discussed this issue, has supported the idea of the contract on numerous occasions. So what I will do is really focus your attention on page two of the report, that both in financial terms as well as

1:43:25 In terms of what's included or going to be included in this contract breaks it down. So there are two components to this contract that we're seeking with Mono County. One is the information technology services that I will return to in a minute and that's those services are described in attachment A. Attachment B are the geographic information systems services.

1:43:51 What is an attachment B, GIS services, is already being provided. So all that this contract will do is take that service and make it part of this contract. So that's not a new contract. It's not the new scope of work. It's really just making it, putting it all under the same IT umbrella. The first part, attachment A, is a service that the town needs. We used to have that service provided by a single position, single incumbent.

1:44:20 And the problem with that is it is close to impossible to find a person who both fixes computers as well as functions at a policy strategic level and helps us to move forward on issues such as digital 395, cloud, and so on. So the beauty of this contract was Morneau County is we're getting the entire IT department working for us for the cost of one position because we will have access to the various specialists at those various levels.

1:44:49 What's also included in the cost is $30,000 annually for replacement of our equipment, software, and so on. Last but not least, these amounts are included in our budget along with some other IT costs. That's listed on page three under the fiscal impact. And I believe Jim Letty, the county administrator, is here in case you have any questions for him. This item is before you here today.

1:45:19 To conceptually approve the scope to provide the authority to the town manager to enter into the contract, the item has not gone yet to the board of supervisors. We wanted to give you an opportunity to see or to say to us if you have any questions or concerns on the scope, it will next go to the board of supervisors, most likely in the month of August, and from there we'll proceed with the actual contract language. Thank you. Question?

1:45:46 Mariana, as far as regarding the basic gov, where are we at with that and when is that going to come online? Well, so I guess it's a question that's somewhat outside of the scope of this report. So basic gov, we're moving forward with the implementation as fast as we could.

1:46:06 And Shannon, who was presenting TOT, is leading that effort, and she's doing incredibly well. My understanding is there are time and staff issues on both the towns end and basic govs end. We have done as much as we could on our end to provide a list of bugs, so to speak, in the computer program that needs to be addressed. Basic govs is working as hard as they could.

1:46:30 Given their staffing and summer schedules to address those bugs, but I think we're getting very, very close to going online and going live. I do not have a date yet as to when that will happen, but several components will become available online. One is business tax, second is transit occupancy tax, and the third one is e-permitting, which is something that is innovative, creative, progressive.

1:46:56 So that's the status as I know as of today. Great. Thank you. Okay. Questions or comments from the public on this agenda item? If not, is there a motion from the council? Yes. I move we authorize the town manager to enter into a five-year contract with Mono County for ongoing IT services per the attached scope for an estimated annual amount of $258,016. I'll second. Okay. There's been a motion and a second roll call, please.

1:47:28 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Takes us to Agenda Item 19. Approved the formation of Undergrounding Utility District 201-3-01 for the Main Street Highway 203 Undergrounding Project. Peter Bernasconi. Mayor, Council Members, this item has been before Council several times, and this is one of the final actions that will

1:48:05 Lead to the undergrounding of the Rule 28 portion of the project. May 1st, 2013, Council did direct staff to work with Mono County for a loan of the Rule 28 funds. May 17th, the Board of Supervisors did authorize a loan of their allocation for this project. That agreement has been executed. Purpose of this agenda is to allow Council to approve the formation of the undergrounding utility district.

1:48:34 2013-1, which allows the town to utilize its Rule 20A money and the loan that we received from Mono County allocations to construct this portion of the project. The Main Street Highway 203 undergrounding project consists of undergrounding approximately 1,200 feet of overhead power lines along the right-of-way of Main Street between Mountain Boulevard and near Viewpoint Road. It's at the property line of

1:49:05 The Mammoth Rue Project, as shown in the exhibit of the agenda bill. In order to utilize the Rule 20A undergrounding funds, the district must be formed in accordance and findings made in accordance with the PUC requirements, which are included in the staff report. So with that, Steph, if the council has any other questions regarding the project, Steph would be happy to answer them. I know there is...

1:49:36 Public comment also related to the project. I do have a question. I just want to make sure that I understand this is that this one project is taking money from the property owner, a loan of the county available money and all the money we have available in order to do just this portion. Is that correct? Correct. The 20A portion just utilizes the funds that are collected through the utility boats and allocated through the PUC.

1:50:06 So the Rule 20A portion is the 600 feet from the westerly property line just beyond the existing bus shelter in the field to the east. At that point, the project will become a Rule 20B project which should be funded by the property owner, the adjacent property owner. And that's all the money that's available? Yeah. So we're utilizing all of our Rule 20A funds and borrowing five years.

1:50:36 And then utilizing the range of some funds to fully fund the project from the county through a loan agreement. I think it's worth noting as well that this required and requires county participation. And I'm really pleased and commend both Tim Fesco and Tim Alpers for listening to our request.

1:51:07 And then taking it to the Board of Supervisors that then passed it because in essence we don't have enough credits to do it all and have to go into the future in order for that to happen and SCE has allowed us the opportunity to do that. And so we can accomplish something by using things that we will get or credits that we will get in the future to accomplish something that's important now. And there's contribution by the private sector or the property owner that's directly impacted that.

1:51:35 It really becomes a win-win between the town and the county because we get a project now. They haven't really identified a project long-term. In the meantime of us paying back the loan, they'll maybe have identified a project and they'll be able to fulfill that project at that time. Okay, other questions from staff? Members of the public who wish to speak on this? We can share. Oops, there's an action.

1:52:30 My name is Andy Odd. I'm a 35-year happy resident part-time of Mammoth. I own a condominium in Viewpoint Road for that entire Viewpoint Condominium for that entire time direction. I often spend summers here, and so I'm very, very enamored with Mammoth, and I am very pro-Mammoth. In addition, I serve on the

1:53:02 I am also part of the officers of the organization Mammoth Alliance of Property Owner Associations, which is a loose group of multiple condominium owners. The reason we formed that, we formed that prior to the recession, the reason was there were a lot of things that we felt that condo owners

1:53:32 were not listened to by the town. The reason they were not listened to was because they had no right to vote. So therefore, why should the town listen to them? So that's when we formed that association because there are a lot of common interests that we have. And this particular project that we're talking about right now is one of those. So I would like to describe it.

1:53:59 From an engineering standpoint first, very quickly, and then I know what you're going to say. You're going to say, yeah, we ain't got no money. Well, I'm going to ask you to think out of your box. Think of a different way of approaching this. I believe that what we have right now is a result of an approach that maximizes the cost of doing this

1:54:30 Minimizes the quality of the product. And for that reason, I am speaking here right now. So, if you would look at the chart, and I'm sorry I gave away my last one, but I'll remember it. I have a two-page detailed letter in the file, which I presented back on June 19th, but unfortunately, there was no discussion. I've heard some rumblings about.

1:55:00 Some people actually heard about it. It was incorrectly mounted on the website so nobody could read it. And so that's why I drove 300 miles today. And please, if I get a little yancy, excuse me because I'm very, very tired. Okay, we heard exactly correctly by Peter that the undergrounding is from Mammoth.

1:55:27 I'm starting from Mountain Boulevard to Viewpoint Manor Property Line. I have shown that on the chart in orange. In addition to that, what already exists on the ground is if you look to the west of Viewpoint, there is a hole there where it transitions to underground and it already transitions to an underground vault. So we have that vault there already.

1:56:00 I believe what needs to be done is continue this undergrounding that has been approved all the way to that vault. Now in order to do that we need a cost estimate from Edison on how much that would be. That's what I am asking you to do. I've been told that I need to send a letter to the town.

1:56:32 To get them to request from SCE such a cost estimate. Now I'd like to point out that currently there are five poles that exist there which I show in black. These five poles are planned to remain. So what will happen is there are only two wires involved. I want to emphasize that point. Two wires. Five poles. Two wires.

1:57:04 Each wire less than an inch in diameter. And so my request is that you consider, since these two wires are going underground anyway along Main Street, to just continue them to that underground vault where you can just tie into them very simply. So that is the genesis of the project. Now, right now, Mammoth View has committed a certain amount of money.

1:57:36 We have a budget, there is an amount of money that is allocated for their portion. So I submit. If, now think out of the box, please, because if you're going to think the way we always do business, there's no point going any further. Think out of the box for a minute. So, since there is money allocated, and that money includes, by necessity, adding another vault.

1:58:06 In order to go from underground to above ground, which doesn't exist today. That vault is quite expensive. And I think you want to get that number from SCE. I believe it likely, depending on how SCE responds, that just the cost of that vault not being there will cover an additional 700 feet of two wires.

1:58:38 And the trenching that's required to go there. The trenching equipment will already be there because they will be trenching this. So it's not a matter of asking SCE to do something new. It's just to continue another 700 feet. So the type of numbers that SCE has been quoting for undergrounding

1:59:04 is in the order of, depending on who you believe, either $1,000 per linear foot or I've been told as much as $1.4,000 per linear foot. So that's about three quarters of a million to a million dollars to bring two wires 700 feet. I think that just blows me away and for that reason

1:59:31 I am asking Edison to give us a rough order magnitude estimate, realistic rough order magnitude estimate on what it would cost to just continue that for the other 300 feet. So that's one opportunity out of the box for cost. Let me tell you another one. The mainstream unification process is ongoing. I understand that the grant application is

2:00:03 Has either gone out already or is imminent. I don't know what the latest is. Maybe you can comment on that later, but is at least imminent. Now what that does is it takes the retaining wall that's currently on Main Street and they knock it down. And they move everything over by four feet where a new retaining wall will go. And the new retaining wall will then be...

2:00:32 Be in a location where it will require those existing utility, at least three of those existing utility poles to be removed. Now how much does it cost to remove those utility poles? According to the present design today, which I want to challenge, the policy of SCE is they relocate like for like.

2:01:02 So when I ask them to do something different, out of the box, I get like for like, that's the way they do business. Well, this is not like for like. If we want to continue like for like, there's no point in talking anymore. So, if you combine the opportunity of Main Street Beautification Project together with what's going on,

2:01:30 With the Mammoth View Project, we had a win-win situation completely, so long as we can get around the business as usual. The third project that's involved here in the same area is, if you can see the Viewpoint Road. Mammoth View Project requires better access to their portion of the project, so they will be paying for improvements to Viewpoint Road.

2:02:04 Now, Viewpoint Road will be closer now to Mammoth's retaining wall by four feet. So the area of location for the poles that you have is diminished by four feet. In fact, I would submit that it would be extremely difficult and extremely costly

2:02:29 To put those poles onto that very steep grade that's going to now exist. It's already a steep grade with the existing. When you have the new retaining wall, four feet further, obviously the grade's going to be even more. So where do these poles go? I can't get an answer to that. You take a look at the existing drawings and they're very clear. Poles to be relocated. Relocated where? We'll worry about that later.

2:03:05 No, no, no. Worry about it now. This is a unique opportunity. Think out of the box. Okay? So with these three projects pulling together like that, the savings will be, saving number one, you will not have to build a vault with transformers, impedance matching equipment, etc. at that location. That's a saving.

2:03:35 Saving number two in terms of the Main Street project, you will remove those poles. You have to do that anyway because that's where the wall is going. But guess what? You don't have to replace it. Now, in my simple mind, and I am an engineer, in my simple mind, the cost of doing something like that is very, very significant. So rather than doing that,

2:04:05 Let's run these two wires underground. Now, what's it take to run two wires underground? So, Mr. Rob, I don't want to interrupt you because I, in particular, you're a train of thought, but you've been at it for nearly 15 minutes and the limit is five. Give me one minute. So I need to have you wrap it up if you wouldn't mind. I'll finish. So the third saving is not having to relocate those poles. Just get rid of them and throw them in the garbage can. End of discussion. So we have three options.

2:04:33 There's no question in my mind that those three options are better from a technical standpoint or from a financial standpoint even more so. And that's only if we get estimates from Southern California Edison. And that is why my letter requests for you to request from Southern California this type of an estimate that breaks it down so we can look at it as what is best for the town of Mammoth Lakes rather than what is best for

2:05:04 Southern California Edison. Now, I have several other ideas which I won't go into of additional opportunities for cost saving, but every one of them requires information from SCE. So I plead with the council. I've been told that I can't ask SCE, even though I did. They told me, you can't ask me. Town council has to ask me. Okay? So I'm here. I'm asking town council to do nothing more at this stage than a fair,

2:05:34 Rough water magnitude comparison of undergrounding versus the current baseline. Thank you. Peter, I've got a question, and that is, I recall in our previous discussions of this, and including the discussion that we had with Tim Alpers and Tim Fesco, that the 700 feet issue was

2:06:05 Considered, but I don't recall what the outcome of that was. Can you give us a summary of that piece of it? So rule, there's several tariffs, the rule 20 tariff related to underground utilities. Rule 20A speaks to the funding allocation that's collected through our utility bills. And it has a minimum length to construct of 600 feet. So you have to be able to fund with allocations 600 feet.

2:06:32 of undergrounding. So in this case, we met that requirement because the county gave us a loan to assist us with our project. So what we're proposing to approve today is the boundaries of that 600 feet and that's it. So that sets the Rule 28 portion and allows Edison engineers to continue to work with that. That project in itself, by the Edison procedures,

2:07:01 Is a totally separate construction contractor than the Rule 20B portion, which is to the west, I mean to the east. So to the east there's going to be some additional undergrounding, which is the Rule 20B C portion, and Edison also participates funding-wise in that, in that don't pay for removing the existing wires and poles. The property owner or some other party,

2:07:32 It's required to pay for all the other costs. So that includes digging the trenches, buying any additional vaults, and paying the cost of Edison pulling new wires. So it's, the only credit comes in from Edison is that they'll give you credit for removing the existing wires and pulls. All the other costs, including Edison's costs, are borne by the, in this case, Mammoth View Project. It's going to pay for those costs. So essentially,

2:08:00 Currently what Mammoth View did was they put a deposit, the town forwarded that money to Edison to pay for their initial design work for that Rule 20B and C project. It also included them to do a cost estimate of the 28 portion if that kind of fell through. So that funding that they provided would do that as well. So that's the difference.

2:08:27 We did talk to Edison regarding combining the projects to make it, you know, a little more efficient. The efficiency comes in if the BC project hires the same contractors as they hired to do the A project. But there's not an ability for them to include a 20B project in their 20A program. The PUC tariff really doesn't allow that.

2:08:54 So those are the restrictions that they're bound by that we're obviously subject to because they're the ones doing the work. Correct. We did forward, send an email to Edison yesterday with this letter asking them if they would provide an estimate or if they would need a deposit to provide the estimate. They haven't responded to that yet. I sent that to the regional manager. So,

2:09:20 I understand totally what you're saying, Andy, but what we're doing here tonight is setting up the utilities district that goes with the 20A, B, and C funding. For the 20A funding only. 20A funding only. Okay. Now, wait a minute. Let me finish. And then so that whether or not you've already made one contact with Edison about this rough order magnitude, and that would come back to us presumably as a separate agenda bill because there's nothing in tonight's agenda bill.

2:09:49 That would even allow us to direct a letter? I'm trying to figure out how to work through this because sitting at the utility district to deal with the 20A does not say that we wouldn't consider or ask Edison to consider these other options. Am I correct? Correct. So the email and what we requested to Edison do was, you know, we actually already asked for the rough order of magnitude. And the question was, are they going to need a deposit? Similar to what we did previously.

2:10:18 Or would they do it on their own? And that they haven't responded to. That information and further staff review or discussion of what Andy's presenting can happen outside of tonight's action to set up the district? Correct. May I comment on that? Yeah, briefly, please. I'm sorry, I'm tired. Well, we're getting tired. I know how you feel, believe me. I'll give you a minute. Okay.

2:10:49 Funding includes that potential vault that I identified. I believe that vault should not be there. So therefore the funding should be already more by the amount of that vault, which is many thousands of dollars. I don't know how much. I need to get that information from Edison. So that's how this is affected.

2:11:17 If you prove the project as is, you are approving that vault that has to be there. That's less than one minute. I understand. Thank you. John? Peter, did I see you and or Jen on Main Street today looking at the power lines? And if so, can you share with us what that meeting was about? We were meeting with Caltrans and really reviewing the portion, well, reviewing the improvements that will be within the right-of-way related to the sidewalk.

2:11:45 And the other safety improvements for an HICP grant. And is it correct that this agenda item that we're talking about tonight, as far as moving the poles in this 600-foot section, that that, even if it's approved, that project, it won't take place for another year or two, possibly three? Is that correct? Yeah, 2015. 15. Okay, so a couple of years. Does that give us...

2:12:14 Time to see if we are granted this grant or if we make a grant application next year at the same time for this project on Main Street communication? Yeah, so a little bit about the grants. So these types of grants don't pay for any utility relocation. They do not? So that would all be out-of-pocket expense, not grant expenses. Okay. The town does have a franchise agreement with SCE.

2:12:46 So if there's a facility that is interfering with a road improvement, then they'll relocate the facility, which is what Andy was indicating, they'll relocate the facility to accommodate our improvements to the street. So in this case, we're going to be widening the street with a little bit wider shoulder and a sidewalk. So for those improvements, they'll need to be moving the utility poles that interfere with that project, if we're awarded the project.

2:13:14 And can you state once more again what your email communication with Edison was yesterday? Yeah, I sent Deborah Hess, she's the regional manager, forward her a copy of this just to make sure she had seen a copy. It was included in the packet. And then asked her if they would perform an order of magnitude of cost for that additional section of work and would they need a deposit to do that work. Okay. Good. Thank you.

2:13:45 Okay, other questions? I have one quick question, if I may. So, assuming we go forward with this as proposed, can we still ask for a letter and see if there's a way to incorporate these changes into the process since it's not going to be happening for a couple of years? Assuming that there's funding that comes available, I mean, I would like to at least ask the question of what the cost would be, which you've already done. And I'm just wondering, can, assuming there were...

2:14:14 Some funding source that comes about, could we integrate it? They could be integrated. Okay. But to the extent that the tariff allows them to be integrated. So the Rule 28 funding can't be co-mingled with other funding. That's the way Edison treats it. So the projects could be, and the plan is that the Easterly project be done at the same time as the Rule 28 project. But the way the funding works with Edison...

2:14:44 In the Rule 28 funds, those are independent of any other funding. They can be coordinated together and make it work so that it's smoother, maybe cheaper, but not co-meaning. I think I got it. Okay. Thank you. All right. Could you allow me 30 seconds? You're standing there. You own it.

2:15:07 Okay, we talked about that as entrenching. I'd like to also understand how big should that trench be to handle two wires? Because taking a lesson from the incredible work that Elizabeth Tenney did, if all it is is a small... Remember, it's not a trench that you would imagine this huge thing. All it's got to do is get two wires on the ground. How deep do they have to go?

2:15:34 I'll bet you I can get enough volunteers to come out on a weekend and get the job done free of charge. Well, if only I said Caltrans would let you. Only if you would let us because you're in charge, you're the town council. Actually, we're not. We don't own the road. I feel, I really feel like we're not. I have been, I will tell you this, and for the benefit of the council, my limited involvement in it made it very clear to me that

2:16:00 These are crazy rules that the electric company imposes in order to bring the wires down, and we're fortunate enough to be able to have these credits available as well as private participation in order to make this happen at all because this town has not budgeted any money for this project, and I'm sure it would not rise, at least in my view, to the level of priority that would be required to bring it up to the top and spend money on it if we had it.

2:16:29 I appreciate the approach that you've taken. I think the suggestions from the council members are good ones, but tonight all we're doing is forming a utilities district in order for this thing to move forward, and I think that what the staff is probably hearing from council is that it wants to at least begin that inquiry process to see whether we're going to be able to accommodate the...

2:16:56 What you are requesting us to do or help to do and all I can say is that I would expect that to come forward. Okay, well, thank you for listening to me. I apologize if I'm thinking out of the box but I believe that's what I read in the newspapers. We should be doing.

2:17:16 This is a way, an opportunity of actually saving money and getting a better quality product. But you've got to think out of the box. That includes SCE, that includes Caltrans, that includes Town of Manage. That's all I ask. Thank you. Thank you. If Council please, it's Council's pleasure, I'll try to craft a motion. I move that we...

2:17:40 Waive the first reading and adopt by title only the attached ordinance approving the formation of Underground and Utility District 2013-01 and direct staff to communicate with Edison and return with a response about the items in Mr. Ott's letter. Second. Okay. Well stated. There's been a motion and a second. I don't hear anybody wishing to speak further, so roll call, please. Yes. Yes.

2:18:09 Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Thank you. That takes us to number 20, which is approve resolutions regarding the Old Mammoth Road Benefit Assessment District number 2002-01, annual levy of assessments for fiscal year 13-14. Peter, is this yours also? This is mine also. I've got four of these that I'll try to consolidate and, or not consolidate, but rapidly go through to...

2:18:37 Excellent. That'd be fine. So for the benefit of the public, we're going to take 20 through 23, which are resolutions regarding the levying of annual assessments for a number of special districts or assessment districts, including Old Mammoth Road, North Village, the Juniper Ridge, and also the Bluffs. Go ahead, Peter. First district is Old Mammoth Road, assessment district.

2:19:07 Which pays for the maintenance, some of the maintenance on Old Mammoth Road from Main Street to Mammoth Creek Park. Currently, we're not proposing to increase the assessments from last year. And the attached engineer support provides the information related to those costs. So with that, there haven't been, staff has not received any protests related to this assessment district.

2:19:32 Peter, before I, you know, it's just great to have somebody sitting to my left because somehow I'm not with it tonight. This is a public hearing. This is a public hearing. I should know this. I did this for a few years. Apparently I'm rusty. So we're going to open that public hearing and call for a presentation of staff. We have heard a partial presentation and proceed, if you will. Thanks. So we're not proposing any new improvements within the district.

2:20:02 This year, just maintaining the existing improvements and the assessment of $13.02 per linear foot is proposed to be included in the living. There are, for this particular district, the town does have a couple costs I'd like to note. One cost is we do reimburse the assessment district for snow removal costs as they are reversed by the state to that extent. In this case, there was two properties that have direct benefit from the district.

2:20:30 And those are included within the Public Works Budget. One property is the Park and Ride Lot, where we pay front footage assessment. And the other property is the Mammoth Creek Park, which we pay a front property assessment. So with that, staff would recommend, after you take any public testimony, you adopt a detached resolution. All right, thank you. First of all, questions from Council Peter. No questions. These are things that come before us each year, and they seem routine, but they're still important.

2:21:02 Next, if I could have anyone from the public who has comment either in support of or in opposition to that which is presented by Peter. Andy, I wonder if we could ask a question. If any member of the council either owns or leases property within any of the benefit assessment districts, are they conflicted from voting?

2:21:37 On that particular agenda item? Yes, there would be unless the public general exception applies, and I think that all of these are small enough that you wouldn't be able to get a big enough segment of the public to be able to take advantage of that exception. All right, so no conflict? There is a conflict, yes. Pardon me, there is a conflict? Yes. Okay, all right, great. Since no member of the public wishes to speak with a closed public hearing, call for counsel deliberation on each of the agenda items. Let's start with...

2:22:07 I will move approval of option one as written. Second.

2:22:36 Okay, there's been a motion and a second. Any addition? We don't have John. Nope, he's up and left. John is up and left, but we still have a quorum, and I don't think he's left. I think he's just left temporarily. If there's no other discussion on the Old Mammoth Road Benefit Assessment District, Jamie, roll call, please. Council Member Eason? Council Member Laney? Yes. Council Member Marlado? Yes. Everyone's in favor? Yes.

2:23:06 Yes, motion passes four with one no-show. He's coming back. All right. On number 21, which is the North Village Benefit Assessment District. I can give you a quick staff report. Quick staff report. Yes, but first of all, if you can accuse yourself, you announce it now. Okay, I'll abstain. No, you actually have to leave the dais.

2:23:36 I'm leaving. Where is the probably interest owned within the district by Councilmember Raimondo? He's indicated that he's going to recuse himself and will not participate.

2:23:48 So with that, do we have a motion? I have one last question. We need to open the public hearing separately for each of these. Oh, we do. I'm sorry. I thought we could actually combine that, which is what I had intended. Well, you can combine the staff presentation. That doesn't actually have to be during the public hearing. That's what I'm going to ask. All right. But you do have to open each public hearing separately, take public comment separately. Thank you. I have a question of Peter, if I may. Where's the southern boundary of the North Village District?

2:24:14 Essentially, it's the Interwest Project, so the southern boundary is 80-50. Okay. 80-50, okay. So that includes the plaza, all the projects that Interwest built within that area. Okay, then my next question would be for Andy, and that's, I live right outside the boundary. I'm not paying into it, but I'd be impacted by the... If you're within 500 feet, which you are, and if there's likely to be any...

2:24:44 Change in your property value as a result of the decision, then you've got a conflict. Okay. And I'll recuse on this one. All right. And the others. All right. Well, we still have enough to go forward. So, with respect to North Village Benefit Assessment District, I'll open the public hearing and call for public testimony either in support of or in opposition to the resolution that's before the council.

2:25:12 If none, we'll close the public hearing call for a council deliberation and a motion. Mr. Mayor, I move that the council approve option number one as presented. Second. Okay, there's been a motion and a second. If no other discussion, Jamie, you will call, please. Yes. Yes. Mayor Wood? Yes, motion passes three with two abstentions or recusals. It takes us to number 22, if we can have the two council members back.

2:25:43 This is with respect to the assessment district for Juniper Ridge. I'll open that public hearing, call for public comment, either in support of or in opposition to the resolution before the council tonight. Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing and call for council deliberation or motion. That we approve the resolution confirming the existing assessments diagrams as written in the agenda bill. Second.

2:26:19 Okay, motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us then to number 23, which is the Bluffs Assessment District. And just a little bit from a staff perspective, there is a couple of improvements that are being planned for this district. The others are pretty much maintenance. We are planning, if it's a...

2:26:49 Relatively minor snow year to repave all the streets next year within this district. So that's the only difference between the other districts. Yeah, I saw that. So you're going to repave early because snow removal costs were light? Is that how I understand? Did I understand that correctly? Correct. It looks like, yeah. So it looks like after this year's assessment, next summer we'll be able to repave all the streets. They have deteriorated quite rapidly in the last few years.

2:27:17 And you did some minor improvements, maintenance improvements this summer? Last year we did a seal of all of the areas, repaired some areas. We'll do some minor work this year, just enough so that we can get through the winter. Great, thank you. Repave it next year. Okay, thank you. Again, we'll open the public hearing, call for testimony from members of the public on the Bluffs Maintenance District.

2:27:45 If there are none, we'll close the public hearing and again call for deliberation or a motion by any council member. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the engineer's report for physical year 2013-14 and adopt the resolution levying the special assessment of $2,100 per lot. Second. Okay. In a motion and a second, welcome. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:28:13 Okay, motion passes 5 to 0 and takes us to number 24. And the question I have of council is if any councilman would wish to take a short break into this. We've been at it since 5. A 5-minute break would be great. Very nice. So we're going to reconvene at 20 minutes to 9, 6 minutes. Okay. Ready to go? John's back. Hey. We're back.

2:32:13 And if we can have your attention, we're going to now go to the main event. We're still in the public hearings section of our agenda, which takes us to number 24. Consider formation of Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District, MLTBID. Consider adoption of a resolution forming MLTBID and making related findings. This is continued from the meeting of July 3rd.

2:32:44 And as John climbs to the podium, I would like to point out that we've discovered that there's a typo in the management district plan. This version of the plan is new from the last time you've seen it, I believe. And there's a small but important typo that we'd like to address. There are two places in this, on page one and also on page nine.

2:33:13 Where the rate of assessment for restaurant one uses is discussed. On page nine, there's the correct reference to it, which is that it's on all gross sales. On page one, the word food is added. So it's gross food sales. And of course, those mean different things, because if you limit it to gross food sales, you would exclude beverage sales and other ancillary things. But that was never intended to be there.

2:33:43 So you have a slight inconsistency between the two, but the one on page nine is the one that's really in the body of it. It's the more completely explained version, and that is how it was intended to be. The one on page one is simply an error. So we've consulted with MLT's assessment attorney, and I feel, as does he, that this is simply a typographical error that can be fixed, and the council can, if it chooses to, adopt the management district plan.

2:34:11 By correcting that mistake and simply deleting the word food from the restaurant one category on page one. All right. I see that. And that's handwritten page eight in the agenda packet. John Urdi. Great. Mr. Mayor, Council, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Thank you. I just wanted to give a very brief overview of where we've been and where we're going and why we're going there just for the folks that haven't been part of the public hearings in the past or that haven't been following the process here. And the first thing we wanted to put out there is why would we put together a T-bid like this?

2:34:44 And really what it is, it's a plan for growth. We have one industry here in Mammoth Lakes. One. It's tourism. That's easy, and really what we need to do is we need to secure funding for tourism marketing. I understand that there are some concerns because this is change. You know, there are a lot of people out there that aren't comfortable with change, that aren't comfortable with opportunities, that aren't risk-free. There's risk involved. There's always risk involved when you do something of this size, but we feel that it's a risk worth taking to help increase our visitation.

2:35:13 Really during need periods, and we've talked about that. We've talked about midweek in the wintertime. We have a huge asset that goes fairly unused for us, and we need to increase those visitation days. Shoulder seasons, spring. You know, one of the things, we just got the May numbers for Mammoth Lakes, for TOT. You know, we started, the last two years have been records from June through October for both 2011 and 2012. We've never hit a May record until this year.

2:35:40 This year we did $375,000 in TOT in the month of May. That's by far the biggest May we've ever done. So we are starting to expand into those shoulder seasons. We're expecting another record June on top of the two previous double-digit records. So being able to fill in those seasons summer, yes, we're busy on the weekends with our events, but we need to figure out how to make sure that we're high occupancy Monday through Friday as well, Monday through Thursday.

2:36:05 And what that results in is the shorter down periods, better staff retention, better service for our guests, and frankly, more ownership. You know, people enjoy working here because they have consistent levels of business. We have major competition for our visitors' time. We have a lot of competing destinations. In fact, there are 79 TBIDs in the state of California right now. There are a lot of people. The city of Los Angeles doubled their marketing budget with a TBID, so they've got a lot more money to keep people in their backyard.

2:36:35 We also have out-of-state competition infiltrating our backyard of Southern California. If you look at flights and you look at marketing in Los Angeles, you've got places like Steamboat, Telluride, Aspen in Colorado, heavily marketing in Los Angeles to get folks to come over there and visit them. They've added flights in all of those markets as well. Park City, Utah, same way. Jackson Hole, Wyoming. They're all looking at Los Angeles as a huge opportunity, and every time they pull somebody out of there, it's a loss for us, and we can't afford to lose any more ground.

2:37:04 We've talked about the success stories in the past. Napa Valley is my favorite one since July 2010. They're up 38% in TOT since implementing that TVID. Santa Barbara is returning $6.40 in tax revenue for every dollar they spend from their TVID, which is strong. Our marketing area is one of the most expensive in the country. I think New York City may actually be the only other DMA that's more expensive than trying to get people's attention in Los Angeles and Southern California. We need this money. We need to be able to get that competitive edge back.

2:37:34 And we need to make sure that people are aware of what we have to offer on a four-season basis. Collaboration. Lodging has really been the provider. We've had TOT in place, and lodging has really funded tourism marketing, and they've been the workhorse. Getting retail, restaurants, and skiers to participate helps us bring other major beneficiaries to the table. Consistency in messaging and branding of our area. One voice.

2:38:01 Everybody rolling in the same direction, getting this on a collaborative effort, working towards one common goal. I put some printouts in the back for people, and if the folks at home, if they go to MLTBID.com, this is a five-page report that was put together through California Travel Association, and it really outlines what this is entitled Tourism Marketing Districts, Creating Jobs, Growing Our Economy.

2:38:26 TBIDs, TIDs, TMDs, whatever you want to call them, they're all assessment districts that are geared towards tourism funding. So that is some great information for folks to grab. And again, if you're watching on TV at home, you can grab that at MLTBID.com, as well as our management district plan and other information as well. Some of the adjustments that we've made to the management district plan since we last saw you, Mayor Pro Tem Bacon, at your advice, we looked at the lower end of our spectrum.

2:38:56 We presented it last meeting. You were absent. One of our things that we did do was that we added a $50 level for those restaurants and retail that do $49,999 or less. So it's a $50 piece. So it's not the $500 that we originally talked about. We did determine, and I think there were 71 or 73 businesses in restaurant and retail that fell into that category. Mayor Lambin, well, Mayor Lambin at the time.

2:39:22 Town Manager, Mariana, and we sat down and we worked through that to make sure that that was fair as well. One thing to add is that that does not affect lodging. So if you only rent your condo for $2,000 a year, you're still at 1%. Lodging is the standard across the board is 1%, so there's no $50 threshold. That's just retail and restaurant. We also looked at, based on some of the feedback that we had from the community, we looked at the air subsidy component.

2:39:49 And one of the things that we did is we went back to our air consultant, air planners, Kent Myers out of Vail, Colorado, and said, can you go back to the airlines, both Alaska and United, and from their origination and destination data, can you tell us what percentage of your traffic is local? So literally locals, 93546, that are flying in and out of Mammoth Lakes. The reason for that is that when we look at the subsidy, or when we look at the TBID,

2:40:18 The benefit has to be that the business is paying in. And when we look at locals flying, that's not necessarily a benefit to restaurants or retail or to lodging. So our suggestion or our remedy to that was to say, okay, well, with Alaska Airlines, I believe our number was 20%. It's in your packet. It's the last addendum. I believe we had 20% from Alaska Airlines and 17% from United Airlines as classified as local. So what we've decided to do is we would move that portion of the subsidy due each year.

2:40:48 Into our Measure A funding. So the TBID would specifically be towards funding just the visitors. So the folks that do not call this home. So those are the two major changes that we've made there. John Lambeth couldn't join us today. Unfortunately, he was already committed because of the change in schedule. We do have Melanie Cottrell and Marissa Martinez from Civitas if we have technical questions on the legal side. The last thing that I'd like to present with you, and I don't see Derek Johnson from...

2:41:17 Crystal Craig here, but I wanted to address one of the pieces that he's brought up here saying that his guests don't use town or that they don't benefit from town. And I printed out a few things that I wanted to add into record, including the homepage of the Crystal Craig website, which the first line in the second paragraph clearly states, only a few minutes drive up the road from stores and restaurants in Mammoth. So clearly that's a benefit. I also have a number of TripAdvisor reviews of folks that have

2:41:43 Enjoyed the stay up there, but also enjoyed coming into town for events, going up to the mountain for bike park, going to the restaurants, and taking advantage of what we have to offer down here in town. And I did not really focus on fishing, even though we do stock a fair amount of fish in McMary, but those reviews, I think about 50% of the people that say there commented on the reviews about fishing. The one last piece that I would like to submit to is a response from Crystal Crag, and this was a few years ago, but...

2:42:12 You know, it was something that was challenged with the pricing that they had up there. And the response was, part of the response said, because we're only open a scant four months a year, we need to be virtually 100% occupied to cover our costs in those four months. You know, I don't believe they're a not-for-profit, but that's what it sounds like their response there is. So, you know, obviously we've got opportunity. One of the things that we've been very clear about is that even if we have hotels that are high occupancy, there's opportunity for rate gain.

2:42:42 So yielding up, being able to get another 2%, 3%, 4%, 5% on your room rate because of the fact that we've got more awareness and we've got the basic law of economics as a plan to manage. So I would submit those to Jamie. And I would open it up for any questions. Jill? Yes, Johnny, do you have a couple of questions?

2:43:04 Sorry. And one of them relates to what you just said about the air subsidy. On page 7, it says we'll provide 20% or more of the cost of such efforts to account for local passengers. But back on the budget page, it says any additional funding required to support summer service would be paid out of the existing tourism budget. And that would be the additional... That might be more than 20%. Correct. And that's already budgeted in the measure rate budget. That's existing funding that's already in the measure rate. Okay. All right. Yes.

2:43:32 Then my other question was on page 10. Are you still talking about implementing on August 1st even though we're on July 24th? No, we are actually looking at September 1 at this point. Okay, so that, okay. Okay, and just to make it easy for myself is, yes, I could not be at the other meeting, but I listened to it all and I read the agenda bill. Did anything change in the agenda bill from last time to this time other than just changing the date?

2:44:04 I believe it was just the date change specifically. I don't think we had anything notable. Andy, do you have anything to do with that? Melanie? I do believe there were some minor edits in the agenda bill just to reflect the fact that there were some updates to the plan, but nothing substantive. Was the letter from the President and CEO of California Travel Association, wasn't that new? Is that added? Yes, you have letters from both Cal Travel, John Severino as the CEO and President. You should also have a letter from...

2:44:41 Carolyn Boteta, who's the President and CEO of Visit California as well. Thank you. Other questions? Any other questions? More about any. No. John, thank you. I'd like to take the opportunity for the public yet again to present comment. We've been here before, but we have another opportunity for those who wish to speak either in support of the proposed TBID or in opposition to it. Anybody?

2:45:22 I'm about to close a public hearing. Go ahead. Mayor and Council, I realize, you know, what's going to happen is going to happen here. I do have a few questions, though, to get right to it. How many tourists have any one of you guys spoken with in the past day or week? I myself spoke with over 100 just today. Do you know what they're saying?

2:46:21 This is the feedback I'm getting directly from the people who are here in town right now, the busiest time of the year. They're saying Mammoth has become too expensive, with a combination of sales tax, TOT tax, now the possibility of an additional 1.5, the T-Bit tax, on top of the rest of the resort pricing, a lot of people are saying it's just going to be too much. People have already stopped coming to Mammoth, and

2:46:53 Like I said, they're saying this is going to be the breaking point. I feel as a lot of other business owners in town that I've been talking to feel that this is taxation without representation. It is a tax. You can call it whatever you want. But if something is going to be calculated as a percentage of my gross revenue, then it's a tax. And again, this needs to be fair and consistent across the board, I feel.

2:47:26 I don't believe it is. If one business is going to be taxed, then all businesses need to be taxed. I can't selectively say who has to pay the one and a half percent. Can I charge only the tourists, not the locals? No. So how can you say which businesses have to pay and which do not? And I'm not going to take up much more of anybody's time here, but I feel that after the airport fiasco and with as much work,

2:48:06 As this T bid needs, I would think you would want to take a deeper look at it before we go ahead and push something through. I think this needs to go out to the people of Mammoth Lakes for a vote before we go down that same road again. And thank you for your time. That's all I have to say. Thanks, Glenn. All right, podium's open. Still open for those that wish to speak, either in support of or in opposition to the proposed T bid. If not, we'll close the public hearing. Call for...

2:48:43 Council deliberation. All right. How do you want to do this? What I'd like to do is start from the outside in. Matthew, would you like to start? Sure. I've had the fortunate opportunity to be involved somewhat in this process on multiple levels. As John said, I've, after the

2:49:09 Some of the concerns that initially came up, I was able to sit down with Town Manager, John and others, and even members of the public that had concerns. It's certainly challenging. I think any time you head into a situation where you're looking at businesses that are being taxed, you can't take it lightly. I've never been a big fan of tax. My thought's always been that in cases where

2:49:39 Government taxes you and what they do with the monies, you know, often you don't really know. In this particular situation, I think there's been enough detail for me that's been laid out there. I'm looking at how the taxation is taking place, where the money is going, and I think it actually fits very well the need that this town has right now, and that is to grow out of

2:50:09 A very challenging situation. Mammoth for decades has struggled. We've looked at each other and wondered why we are so different and why we haven't had the opportunity to quite honestly drive a lot of folks here. I look at the efforts just in the last three years, you know, saying that people aren't coming here anymore. We just had our best three years ever. So I can't buy into that and I have to attribute a lot of that.

2:50:38 To the marketing efforts. These three best years have come in probably some of the three worst times in my lifetime economically. And again, I think Mammoth Lakes Tourism has done an outstanding job. And I think if we give them the opportunity to do more, I think they're going to be successful with it. So I'm in support of this. Thank you, Matthew. John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

2:51:08 We had one person speak tonight, but we did address this same issue, was it two weeks ago? Yeah, two weeks ago. At that time we had written comments from people in the community, we also had people who came up to the podium and spoke. When I added together the written comments from people as well as the people that spoke at the podium two weeks ago, the numbers were...

2:51:35 Exactly even, 16 and 16. 16 in favor of the T bid and 16 opposed. My wife and I had the opportunity to travel to Palm Springs, California last week and the property that we stayed at in Palm Springs, there was a 14% occupancy tax, TOT tax. On top of that there was a 2%

2:52:06 Benefit Improvement District, and on top of that there was a $16 per night resort fee. We're not Palm Springs, but we are in competition as a resort with areas similar to Palm Springs. As Matthew stated, we've had increased occupancy the last two summers. We had a good winter as compared to other resorts. So,

2:52:38 I don't believe that people have stopped coming to Mammoth at this point. One of the pieces of input, one of the letters that came in our packet is from, I don't know how to pronounce his name, John Severini, President and CEO of the California Travel Association. He states in his one-page letter that there are several critical reasons

2:53:10 Why the Town of Mammoth Lakes Should Move Forward With This Initiative. First, he states that TBIDs have proven to be successful in over 79 cities and municipalities just in California alone, which have resulted in incremental revenues for these cities and municipalities. An independent study

2:53:38 Shows that the estimated return on investment for T bids is over $70 for each dollar invested. I don't think we're anticipating $70. I think we're anticipating more like what, John? It is $136. Okay. Thank you. And then the third thing that he mentions in his letter is that Mammoth needs to establish this T bid just to stay competitive.

2:54:14 With other resorts in the western United States. We went out, we, the community, really a select committee of business people and lodging people in the community, went out and interviewed and got Mr. Urdi to come to our community to promote tourism in Mammoth Lakes.

2:54:45 In my opinion, he is at the top of the top shelf in the western United States to promote our community. If we can't show the confidence in his ability and expertise by giving him the adequate and proper funding to promote Mammoth Lakes, then I can't think of anyone else that we could bring here that could do the job. So I'm willing to give Mr. Urdi the opportunity.

2:55:14 To show us what he can do. And is the time frame, is it five years? Five years? So we'll certainly know at the end of five years if Mr. Urdi and our organization is going to be productive or not. Thank you. Thank you, John. Michael? I, too, have been involved in the process. I've sat on the committee. I want to thank John.

2:55:45 For doing all the legwork on this. I mean, a few years now, there's been a lot of speculation and talk around town of where this T bid came from, and it came from Mr. Erty. To concentrate on midweek and shoulder season is the focus, which is the priority of this T bid. I think all the businesses in town could benefit from an increase.

2:56:11 As John just mentioned, the data is very compelling in 79 other cities on the success of the T-Bid. Just in the last meeting, we had several business owners coming into here and saying we have to do something, we have to try something, we need to move forward, we need to move the town forward. As you know, I mean, I've been a tenant since day one in the village. We've successfully been the beta tester of a program just like this. We've been charging three-quarter of a percent of a resort fee.

2:56:42 Since day one for 10 years, I see a lot of people have really enjoyed all the amenities that have been provided by this resort fee in the village. You know, I think the increase in the TOT and sales tax that's going to be generated is going to come to the general fund, which is going to go directly to our infrastructure, public safety, etc.

2:57:13 But we've got to drive more people to town, period. I think that I haven't personally heard very many people bragging that they're making so much money that they don't need any more. I see businesses struggling, businesses closing. So, you know, I agree with the many comments that have been said that we need to try something, we need to move forward, we need to grow out of our financial problem.

2:57:44 So I'm very supportive in moving this forward. Thank you, Michael. First, I'd like to start with a clarification. At the last meeting, which I listened to via Granicus later, there was a question of whether or not Matthew was going to read a letter that I had submitted, and it was part of the packet, so I see no reason to reread it at this point.

2:58:09 I am grateful the fact that the items that I brought up and some procedural things have been changed in this latest version of the management plan. I'm also quite aware that essentially the law allows the majority of businesses to ask for a T-bid and that it would take a majority protest for those who are within the district to change it.

2:58:39 Where I differ and where I will be voting against the T-bid is because I believe that every business in this town benefits from tourism and marketing and that it is not just the ones who have the direct relationship. I believe that everyone has it and everybody should be paying for it. Since that is not a part of this management plan, I will not be voting for it. So thank you.

2:59:08 So I want to begin by indicating that the comments that I'm going to make won't make any difference because I can count votes, but I'm not supportive of this too bit and I'm going to tell you why. I'm going to start with a little history. So many years ago, a wise town council jumped on the redevelopment bandwagon.

2:59:36 And an area for redevelopment was created that was designed to be the answer to the town's then financial ills. And that redevelopment area, strangely enough, which, by the way, I thought was a great idea, and redevelopment is no longer even an option in California, but it certainly was then, and it was a tool to revitalize communities to do exactly what it is this TBIG wants to do, and that is to...

3:00:06 Bring more visitors, bring more revenue into the pockets of people who live here as well as the town. But to my amazement, I was in the audience at that time, the redevelopment area included a golf course or an area that was going to be a golf course. You could never understand how a golf course or an area that was going to be a golf course would qualify for blight. Well, it didn't because it was challenged. Great idea, bad bill.

3:00:33 A few years later, of course, we decided that it was appropriate for us to enter into a development agreement, a 55-year development agreement, with an individual who wanted to put a couple hundred condominiums up at the airport. I was in the audience then, too. Some people think I was on the council. I wasn't. But I was keenly interested in it. I remember very clearly how

3:01:03 This was going to contribute to what were then our financial ills by creating an opportunity for TOT that we otherwise wouldn't receive. Clearly, air service was an important, very important piece, but the airport development agreement preceded air service by about three years, and in 1997, this council, not this council, but a council, crafted an agreement that

3:01:33 Whose language was actually revised from the dais on the night that it was approved. And this was going to be the answer to all of our problems. And I can remember standing in the audience thinking, great idea, but how in the hell would anybody sell a condominium at the airport? It didn't make any sense to me. Great idea, bad piece of legislation.

3:02:01 It wasn't legislation. The legislation was to approve the contract. What was really wrong with the contract, as we later found out, was that there were not provisions in there to protect the town in the event that the FAA withdrew its permission, which had previously been granted, to allow residential development at the airport, and we will pay for that for the next couple of decades. Three years later, I was on the council.

3:02:32 I happened to be serving as the mayor in the year 2000 when Interwest and the town entered into a development agreement that called for the development of its properties within the resort corridor. It was an important agreement at the time. It took us months to negotiate. There was a lot of public comment. It was also going to be the answer to our financial ills. It was going to be the key to the success of this community. Great idea.

3:03:01 However, in that agreement, what we failed to include were penalties for InterWest not completing the project that it said it was going to do. So we got 25% of a village. I remember the phrase, you know, that Dana Severy, the mantra actually of Dana Severy at the time, rising tide lifts all boats. I generally believe that, but I don't think the rising tide lifts all boats equally. And I think if you look back, you find that it didn't lift all boats equally.

3:03:34 So now we are at TBID stage. I think it's a great idea. I remember in 1998 suggesting publicly, never went anywhere, it was just really a lead balloon. John, I'm sure you can imagine this, that maybe the people who benefit from the marketing that the town provides through measures A, a couple of measures A,

3:04:00 Would, that maybe they should contribute, and maybe they should participate in their own destiny, or at least whatever that was going to be, and sure enough, what you've done is you've brought that forward. I applaud you for that. I said about six months ago that I was not in favor of a tax increase, and I differentiated a self-assessment from a tax increase. I understand where the money's coming from. I understand whose pocket it's coming out of.

3:04:28 But my view was that if a bunch of businesses in town or business owners in town decided that they wanted to participate as I had been calling for once publicly and I got beaten up and privately for many years that it was a great idea and I still do think that. However, I don't think this is the right bill. So some months ago I was introduced to the TBID in a meeting that the town

3:04:58 Mammoth Mountain Sea Area Liaison Committee attended. Mayor Lehman and I were there as representatives of this council. And the idea that was laid out to me at the time, I remember it specifically was, that in exchange for a plan in which businesses and lift tickets would be subject to assessment or tax, the

3:05:26 A portion of the Measure A money, up to a million dollars, would be taken away from marketing and put back into the town for things that this town desperately needed. And we know from having conducted a strategic planning session that this town desperately needed a whole lot of things that weren't related to marketing. My view all the time is that you've got to have something to market. It better be pretty good. And we've had that discussion over the last several weeks.

3:05:55 Three months, two months later, we had another meeting, came back, same group, a number of people from the town, on the mountain, John Urdi was there, and the plan had changed, and that was, it was going to be a T-bid, but the million dollars was not going to go back into the things that were, at that time, and still are important to me. And I'm not suggesting it's the wrong thing to either take a million out or leave a million in. I'm just suggesting that there's a sense

3:06:21 In my mind, that if you've got $7 million of marketing and an $18 million budget, actually if you add the 4.7, it takes it to $23 million, that there ought to be balance, and I don't have a sense that there is, at least enough of it. So, I asked for three things. One, I wanted the ski area's commitment, formal commitment. I don't know how you get a legal binding commitment, but a formal commitment to not reduce its own marketing budget.

3:06:49 I got an informal assurance, but I didn't get a formal commitment. Two, I was concerned about the rate, and I was concerned about the rate in particular on retail, because you see, T-bids are everywhere, but they're not on retail in restaurants, other than in rare exception. In fact, I don't know if there's any retail T-bid out there. I can't remember. If there is, I'm not aware of it. Third, I wanted to know very specifically how the money was going to be spent, and I've gone over your budget, John, which is categorized into six or eight categories.

3:07:20 I haven't gotten the level of satisfaction that the funds are going to be spent. And these are funds that this town doesn't control. We vote because the law says we have to do this. This money goes to a marketing organization. I have great faith in that organization. I have confidence in this board. I certainly have great praise for its director. But I don't know exactly how the money is going to be spent.

3:07:50 So, as I understood as we're going along the dynamic of this, and you know, what you can't see from the audience is that you get a pretty good feel when you're sitting up here, especially in the middle, by body language and knowing the personalities, how people are feeling about things. So, the Brown Act is what it is. You can't talk to anybody, but you generally know what's going on as it's going on. And I've had a sense for some time that this T-Bit is going to pass, and I've been...

3:08:19 I've been troubled by it because I don't like its terms. And so I've tried to work around the margins. I've talked about, had some discussion about capping the Measure A contribution at $2 million. I understand that was rejected by the board. I've had some discussion about pulling back the

3:08:46 Business license fees, which is about a quarter million dollars out of tourism and getting them back into our budget so that we can do the things that a lot of people in the community say that we ought to be doing. Didn't get anywhere with that. I am pleased that the $500 fee for small business was reduced to $50. I consider that to be insignificant but very, very important to those businesses and there are a few of them.

3:09:12 That have gross sales of under $50,000. I think that's a good step. But what really motivated me is this. I, as many of you know, am a lawyer. I don't represent big companies. I represent people just like you sitting out in the audience. I represent small business owners. All of us in town, almost all of us are small business owners. I represent individuals.

3:09:36 And maybe I'm uniquely qualified among those who are up here to know not everything, but at least something about what goes on in those businesses. And I don't know whether the fears that I hear are justified, whether they're unfounded, but I know that there's a great sense of trepidation, great trepidation about this. And the reason for that is that businesses, is the obvious, is that business owners are at great risk all the time.

3:10:06 And are dependent upon things that are well beyond their control, and they don't really know how this is going to turn out. And so my thought is, well, you shouldn't not do something because you've got the fear of the unknown or failure. And so what it ultimately comes down to for me is a question of fairness, and I go, Joe, to your comment, and that is,

3:10:29 If a majority of the individuals, I don't mean the majority of revenue, but if the majority of the individuals in this community who are impacted or will be impacted by this TBID said, I'm for it, then I'm for it. Because I support the democratic process. But I haven't heard that. What I've heard is that there are...

3:10:57 Believe me, I'm staring right now at all of the players in this community right now. And it's very difficult for me having developed relationships with people who make a difference, a significant difference in this community by virtue of the fact of their size, the number of employees they have, the products they deliver, the tenure, the longevity, whatever it might be. It's very difficult for me to say, I don't like this T-Bid, but I don't like it in the end.

3:11:22 Because I've got a lot of clients and I've got a lot of constituents who are saying, I'm not for it. Had I had more constituents say, or if we had developed more constituents who have said, I am for this, and truly there was a plurality, I would not be making the comments that I'm making. Because quite frankly, I could make the argument on the other side. It's that close for me.

3:11:49 So I come down in favor, in opposition to the TBID for the reasons that are stated. I don't expect to change minds. We've been at this for a number of months. I know how council members feel, but I want the public to know why it is that I'm not supportive. Thank you. John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. What Rick says about individuals or businesses struggling,

3:12:20 is true, and in fact I heard on the television today that there was a new survey out, and that survey said that 75% of all Americans today live paycheck to paycheck. Very, very difficult economic situation for people in the United States. I look at this as an opportunity within the community of Mammoth Lakes to make a difference and to change that. I wanted to talk

3:12:50 Ask Mr. Urdie one question on the retail. Are there other T-bids in California that include retail? No, not on the T-bid side. We are definitely groundbreaking with that, but because of the fact that we live and die on tourism here, we felt that we expanded into restaurants and retail. Obviously, there are business improvement districts all over the country, all over the world, that are made up of multiple types of businesses. So the fact that retail participates in an assessment is not a new thing.

3:13:22 But in the state of California, as far as tourism business improvement districts, this would be the first. Thank you. There's a lot of people looking at us for that. Thank you. The final thing that I wanted to mention was if you understand marketing, and Rick mentioned the numbers, the town of Mammoth Lakes budget, whatever the number is, $18 million, $23 million.

3:13:48 And the marketing budget, which is projected to be roughly $7 million, if the town of Mammoth Lakes takes, let's say, $1 million out of that $7 million, so you're only using $6 million to market, in my mind, you are taking away the opportunity to allow marketing to generate the incremental money.

3:14:15 Spend 6 million, you're going to generate whatever the multiplier is. Let's use 5. If you do 6 million, you're going to generate 6 times 5, 30 million in return. If you have 7 million times 5, then you're going to generate 35 million. So you have an opportunity incrementally of increasing the amount of revenues by 5 million dollars just by investing one more million in marketing.

3:14:44 I come from the viewpoint that the more you can spend on marketing, then the more you can generate in revenues to re-market year after year. The other thing is the money that comes back to the community, let's say you invest $7 million in marketing each year and you get $35 million in return. Of that $35 million, a certain percentage of that already does come back to the town of Mammoth Lakes as our share.

3:15:15 of the revenues. So it's not like we're not getting that the town of Mammoth Lakes is not getting a portion of that money generated back to run the municipality. Thank you. Thank you, John. Other comments? I just had a couple quick follow-up items. John, I agree that it's

3:15:43 This is an opportunity to bring in additional revenue, and I think the focus has been it's a tax, the one or one and a half percent tax. But what keeps getting missed is the fact that this money isn't just being thrown out the window. It's driving additional people here that will be bringing more of those dollars back into the community. I think Michael Ledesma made a very good point as far as the employees and how that additional one or one and a half percent was going to be taken.

3:16:12 Away from the employees somehow because people weren't, you know, if they were going to have to pay this additional tax, they wouldn't be tipping as well. But I think what it's going to do, it's going to, if it helps bolster the midweek and the shoulder seasons, it's going to help these people have a more sustainable job. I also think by looking at the concept that this is going to be bringing in additional revenue, sustainable revenue, Mammoth's going to be making a change.

3:16:41 And that is we're not going to be just throwing money wherever the problem is and patching holes and putting our finger in the dam wherever the problem is. We're going to be able to look at our issues now, which is, let's say, our police force or our staffing levels in town. And instead of getting the money and putting it there today, we're investing in our future. So when these folks do start coming up here, we're going to have a sustainable income stream. So I think it's important to note that.

3:17:10 If we look at this program, and for some reason after a couple years we don't see it working, there's the opportunity to opt out of it, especially after five years in particular. So this isn't a forever thing. It's a good opportunity to see if change will work for us. And, you know, I think if what we've been doing for the last 20 or 30 years hasn't been working for us, it's probably not a good idea to keep doing the same thing.

3:17:37 I just wanted to add those additional comments and leave it at that. Thank you, Matthew. Mr. Mayor, I'm curious from John if he has the information of the T-bids in the state of California. Do we know a percentage of those that have gone through that five-year time frame? How many of them have renewed, have been successful and then renewed their T-bid? Of the 79 in California, there is one that has not been renewed.

3:18:10 Oldest one started in 1989. It's actually renewed every year. There are two types. Some of them renew every year. Some of them renew every five. We obviously went for the five here. But there are about, I want to say, 30 or so that are the one-year renewals that have been renewed every year for 15 or 20 years. So it's a fair statement to say that of the 79 T-biz in the state of California, they've been hugely successful.

3:18:36 Yes, yes, they're very popular. And they've done what they projected to do. Okay, thank you. Other comments, questions, deliberation? If not, I will entertain a motion from any council. Before the council makes a motion, if I might, for those of you watching at home, Andy Morris, town attorney. There are four things in the resolution that should have been updated, but weren't. So we're going to, so we have kind of an errata list that I'd like to point out to you, and I would suggest that

3:19:08 If the council is inclined to adopt the resolution, that the motion should incorporate these four changes, as well as the change I previously described to the management district plan that removes that word food from the restaurant type one reference on page one. The four changes to the resolution are in what I believe is the eighth recital. There's right now only a reference to a hearing having been held on July 3rd.

3:19:31 That reference should be hearings having been held on July 3rd and July 24th because the hearing was, of course, continued until tonight. In paragraph 2, rather than this taking effect on August 1st, I believe John Urdi said that it should take effect on September 1st, which would mean that it would run through August 31st of 2018. In paragraph 3,

3:19:54 The management district plan is not the version that was dated in June. It's actually dated July 16th, I believe is the current iteration. And finally, in paragraph 9, there is a parallel typo to the one that was in the management district plan, and the word food should be removed from restaurant type 1 sales in paragraph 9. So it should say gross sales rather than gross food sales. Okay, thank you, Andy.

3:20:28 With those suggested changes, does a council member have a proposal, a motion? Mr. Mayor, a point of order, I wanted to check with the town attorney. Is it appropriate, if there is a motion, to make that motion as stated by the town attorney?

3:20:50 Yes, you can do that. I think that I was trying to be fairly clear in my comments, and so you can just paraphrase it that way. I should also point out there have been a couple stray references to this being a tax, and of course if the council is inclined to adopt the resolution, the council should do that knowing that this is not in fact a tax, it really is a business assessment, and it's being adopted under the Business Improvement District law rather than as a tax and not using the procedures and laws that are applicable to taxes.

3:21:26 I'll go ahead and make a motion, Mr. Mayor, that Council approve option number one and adopt the attached resolution forming the district and approve a contract with MLT for the collection and management of TBID funds, giving consideration with the changes suggested by our legal counsel. Second. Okay. Jamie, you understand that motion? You're looking at me. All right.

3:21:57 No, not yet. I just want to give Council one additional opportunity to change somebody's mind. If none, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. No, motion passes 3 to 2. Thank you very much. We are going to adjourn to the next scheduled meeting, which is Wednesday, August 7th at 6 o'clock.