TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2013

Town Council

· recording 1 hr 49 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

215 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

8:31 All right, thank you. We're going to begin with public comments. This is the established time for any member of the public who wishes to address the council on any matter that does not appear on the agenda to address the council. Anybody wish to speak tonight? Sean. Hello, Sean Turner, co-owner of Mammoth Planning Company, and I wanted to give you my annual report on Bluza Palooza. So, first of all, how many of you all got to attend councilors?

9:08 Okay. Great. And for those of you who have it, please make sure you get a chance to visit the site if you haven't already because we were able to actually make some improvements and I'll speak to that in just a minute. First of all, the big news, and this is just getting through the event, I'm always happy to report, no arrests, no ABC citations, no problems with bears, and I still have my voice. So I'm feeling really good about everything that really happened. And ABC was on site. I think Police Chief Dan Watson had a chance to send you

9:38 Brief outline of what his report was, but absolutely no arrests and no citations from ABC, which is just huge on my books. Tickets. We were actually down in ticket sales through Valetix. We are still doing some counting based on what we sold through our lodging partners. We're determining that a lot of those sales, we get so many last-minute sales for Bluza Palooza, and I think that the smoke from the Aspen Fire

10:06 Played a big role in that. We had so many people calling, asking about what was going on with regard to the smoke. There was a lot of social media, and boy, social media can be such a double-edged sword because all of a sudden California knew that we were having real smoke issues, and so unfortunately that may have affected it. We also had, I think, not as many big name acts this year, and a lot of that was just routing. We had a tough time really securing the bands that we

10:35 We did book and it was just tough trying to get those big names that really draw people to such an event. However, the exciting news about that though is that with the expansion of the site, we now know that we can go to 6,500 people on Sam's Wood Site, or I will call it the Wood Site because it really is two different parcels. And since we know that we can sell tickets now this year, or this next year, to 6,500 people,

11:04 That we'll be able to increase our talent budget a little bit so that we can go after just a little bit higher name acts as well as more name acts for the entire lineup. So ticket sales were down slightly. I don't have those numbers for you. I wish I did, but I'll get them to you. And unfortunately, our expenses were up. As you know, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area is not doing their next event there, so there were quite a few increased expenses with regard to putting up fences, taking down fences.

11:34 It was solely on ourselves. A little bit more expensive with regard to stage lighting because it is having to be moved from Sam's Wood Site up to Canyon Lodge. So unfortunately, we did have some additional expenses. That kind of makes up for it a little bit. But again, like I said, knowing that with the increased space that we've got at Sam's Wood Site, we know that we can go to $6,500, so we will budget accordingly going forward into the next year.

12:02 Speaking about that site, again, for those town counselors who have not, and the public, as a matter of fact, who haven't had a chance to visit Sam's Wood site, please do so. I've got to tell you, expanding there to the north, up into the hills just a little bit, that's where we had our Friday night California Craft Brewers Association reception for all the brewers, and it was so well attended and commented on. I can't tell you how many of the brewers, how many of the public really spoke highly of what we are calling Blanket Hill.

12:32 And the goal with that was to really be able to allow some of the public to get away from the main sight lines of the stage and the noise. So if they didn't want to have conversations, they could do that a little bit easier. So please make sure you get a chance to visit the wood site sometime this fall before the snow sets in. Thursday night is just a huge success again. We think we had over 2,000 people.

12:58 This is the second year that we've made it, we've included Thursday night. And we started this every single time we've expanded the length of the event has been just from an idea about, hey, this time we really need a dry run. We need a soft opening.

13:16 And I tell you what, most of the food vendors, all the bars had some kind of issues that if they didn't deal with it Thursday night, it was somewhat soft opening, they would have been just killed on Friday night because Friday night is just such a big boom of people walking in the gates. Traffic was so much better this year. Every year I think we continue to make...

13:37 The traffic turnaround, and we've got ideas for next year. It's time to get away from the carports in the street. We're going to need to go to actual trailers in the street just for wind and better identification of the turnaround there at the top of the minaret. We did a much better job. I want to thank the neighbors of Hidden Valley immensely for allowing us to help get the brewers out through the back of Sam's Woodside. It was so much easier.

14:04 Getting their equipment back to their vehicles. Again, in closing the street, it's just so much safer for the public. We created a lane for the line getting in, a lane for pedestrians coming and going, parking down the middle of the street, trying to create a truck show so that people can see the logoed vehicles, and then, of course, the one-way traffic. We do have a number of things that we are looking to improve upon within our own infrastructure.

14:33 This event has gotten so big that I use this analogy and it's so accurate. This event is a chain that is as strong as some of its weakest links. And every year the weakest links either break or present themselves. We fix those links and then the next weakest links in the chain really present themselves and we work on those.

14:55 Next year, we're working towards better communication with all of our paid staff and volunteers, organization internally, as well as working with town staff. There was some miscommunication, for instance, with regard to the trolleys between the town and ESTA. And I'm just reporting on this that we know that these mistakes were made and that we're looking to improve on them, that of the two circular routes that were going within town, ESTA was only running buses. They were running two buses on one of the routes.

15:25 Rather than one bus on each of the routes. So we know that there's quite a few things that we can improve upon. And I believe you've seen an email thread with regard to increasing just the town trolleys that do their own routes. And I'll just speak to that real quick.

15:39 Is that something that we are working towards doing, Joyce is now a member of the Board of Directors of the California Craft Brewers Association that really puts us at the same table as Sierra Nevada, Anchor Steam, some of the larger breweries in the state. So we're getting a lot more attention here in town on what we do. And that we had 81 craft breweries attend this year is about 20% more than we've had in previous years.

16:04 So we're really looking to turn this event into a five-day-long event in the same manner that San Diego, San Francisco, Sacramento each have created what they call a beer week that different restaurants can participate in having beer maker dinners, beer events that really concentrate on craft brews. So that's just my brief outline of Palooza Palooza for this coming year. It was a great success. I think we've heard 98.9% compliments.

16:34 And we focus on the other parts that we want to improve for next year. Do you have any questions? John? Just a couple comments. One, you know, I volunteered and I got to talk to a lot of people working the ticket booth. But you guys nailed it. I think expanding that site clearly shows that that's the site in town that we need to figure out how to own and preserve.

17:05 We've been doing a lot of studies on trying to find an event site. I think expanding it out the way you did clearly shows that it is the site. And I think we need to, with Measure R and U and putting our brains together and thinking outside the box a little bit, I think we need to figure out how to own that to be our site. But I talked to a lot of people, and I heard a lot of great positive things. A lot of first-time people coming to Mammoth. Never been.

17:32 But I just want to say great job and I thought it was a great event. Well, thank you very much. It was fun. At the end of the day, it's fun. And my partner here. Sorry, I have to speak up on behalf of the CCBA. Joyce Turner with Mammoth Marine Company. CCBA was very, very excited about how this event came off and we are so proud of all of our craft brewers that attended.

17:57 Out of the 81 craft breweries that were there, I think five were out of state, four or five were out of state. Every single other brewery was a California Craft Brewers Association member. And this event is on the radar screen in California. They love Mammoth Lakes. They love what the lodging partners did for them. They all took very, very good care of them and couldn't have done it without them. And I'm just proud to have brought that crew to Mammoth Lakes. They're a good bunch of people.

18:27 Joyce and Sean, while we have it, would you agree with Michael's comment that that site is a site that we need to look to long term? Yeah, I think 100% straight up. That is such a great event site. If we just ran some basic infrastructure for that location because of its location, accessibility, part of the reason this event is so calm and so refreshing and we had no real drunks there this year. I mean, there was just...

18:56 It was wonderful. I think because partially because it's in the trees and it's accessible and you can get on a trolley and you don't have to get in your car. It's a wonderful sight. Last kind of comment. My wife and I were fortunate last night to watch a television program on PBS out of Reno. And the artist is, and I'm going to mispronounce his name, but I think you might know him. Is it Joe?

19:26 Yeah. And he was with, I think it was Neil Young, and then another rock and roll guy, who I should know his name, but didn't know him. And I know that he doesn't necessarily fit, you know, our type of program, because his music is so fine that it would be hard to do it in an outdoor venue. But boy, it was a treat to listen to his music.

19:54 Oh, he's so on our radar screen. Yeah, no, he is on our radar screen. And what was his price tag? Oh, yeah, he's up in, he's got a few digits behind him. Yeah, he's up there. And that's the situation is that, you know, what we've had the problem with in the past with only 5,000 people. Last year we had 5,500 permission to. Now we've got, you know, 6,500 people, 6,500 people to go to. The problem before was do you raise the ticket price? You know, we've already priced out a lot of the locals, unfortunately.

20:20 Do you raise the ticket price to get these big names or do you raise the people? Well, now that we've been able to raise the people by a thousand, you know, that gives us some good numbers to kind of play with. And now we are in the zone of being able to attract Joe Bonamases. You know, that kind of crowd or those kind of names are the ones that we're really going to go for. And, John, I just want to speak to your, you know, question about do I think Sam's is or the Woodside is the best place?

20:47 You know, as an events promoter, yeah, hands down. As a recreation commissioner, you know, I want to be impartial for this study that is coming forward, but the comments that I was making last night during recreation commission was that, you know, the best darn thing about Sam's wood site, and I do want to make this comment real quick, is that it is so well protected from the wind. Last year when we had lightning and thunder and wind coming on,

21:12 It would have scared away most of the crowd. I know I'm past my time, but I just want to say this. On a scale of 1 to 10, and I know other people have heard this analogy, 10 being a perfectly warm, I'm still wearing shorts and a t-shirt at 10 o'clock at night, summer night, and 1 being snowing sideways in August, like we had at Mammoth Rocks about four years ago, at what point do you leave the site? At what point do you go home? Is it a 5? Is it a 6?

21:39 The bar suffers when you go home, the ticket sales, I read the weather report that's coming up this weekend, I'm not going to buy tickets, you know, because you can predict the weather five days out in advance. At what point does the consumer say, I'm not going to go to that event? And I know that the event study that's coming back is, you know, suggesting the foundation site, which is a great site but may need some wind mitigation, canyon launch, how much money is it going to cost to

22:06 Acquire those parcels and then create wind mitigation is something that we're going to need to consider when we are looking at the true price tag, including the long-term effects of how many events will be canceled or cut short because of situations that come up. And in answer to your question, yeah, I've been doing, you know, I've been in town for seven years now and in my opinion, Sam's Woodside is the best. Last question, I promise. Can you,

22:34 Down the road because the event is end of July, early August, which is, I don't know what the percentages are, but maybe 20% of the time you might have a thunderstorm or a thundershower on any of those nights or all the nights. Is it realistic to think that at some point you can put some kind of coverage over the bands on the stage so that even if it is raining?

22:59 That they don't have to shut down because of the rain? Yeah, we sure can. And we actually already have a roof. It's a light roof that would stop, you know, a light rain. And it actually works pretty well. But, you know, if you read my comment in the paper, I'm sure, a week ago, that Mammoth Brewing Company would be willing, if the town were able to find a way to acquire the wood site, and it is two different parcels, that we would be willing to make a contribution on an annual basis.

23:28 As long as that money went to infrastructure, think about this, and she knows the numbers better than I do, we spent thousands of dollars this year putting up fencing and taking down fencing. The electricity, we have to bring in generators because the electrical risers that come into it are too dirty as the power isn't clean enough to run sound systems on it. Sewer, we had 110 porta-potties on site. 112?

23:56 A lot. We had a lot of porta-potties on site that, again, if we could get some kind of infrastructure, instead of having to spend the money to bring in porta-potties and then take porta-potties away, let's start looking at what kind of, you know, real good water in, sewer out we can do for that site. Electricity. All these different infrastructures that then we can actually really can start sending more events to it. And considering that within a radius all the lodging partners

24:24 Are kind of within a radius there. It's not something that, and again, without putting down other sites, that the other sites, if you were to do a radius, it's going to be just open land. We are surrounded by town. Thank you, sir. Thank you. And my other business partner wants to say something here. My name is Gavin Turner, son of Sean Turner and Joyce Turner.

24:53 And I wanted to talk about Blues-A-Palooza's Sunday because there's a huge bouncy house every Sunday for Blues-A-Palooza. And if maybe you have a kid, you could bring him. Thank you very much for your time. Thanks. All right, podium's still up for those who wish to speak on something that's not other than something you're talking about. Good evening, Town Council. Martin Kleinbart.

25:29 Local resident. A couple things. I still was unable to attend the portion of last council meeting regarding the TOT enforcement case. I'd like to renew my concerns over the TOT enforcement on a single-family home that is in a non-zoned area. I think the town dodged a bullet at that town council hearing because

25:59 The person that was appealing, I watched the tape, you know, he quite naive, didn't know what to really say or to do. And, you know, I think that, you know, somebody's going to step up that's quite a bit smarter someday and things will be different. So on that note, close that one out. There's another concern that I have. Upcoming.

26:29 Future Town Council meeting, there's going to be approval of a construction contract for some new work being done over at the ESTA Transit Yard, and I've had some email exchange over the last couple days, and I have to renew my concerns, and I think at some point, I think it needs to be some kind of public forum, because I didn't see any public agenda item either on the ESTA Board or Town Council or any other thing.

26:58 That discussed the facility and what kind of improvements and what's going to be going on there. But my concern is because I did some work over there last November under a grant and duplicate thing is being done under another grant and I just think that there's some funny business going on there and I don't know that you're allowed to have grant money for one project and then push it aside.

27:28 And ask for another grant to do the same or similar thing another year later. I mean, it's not even 12 months since I did this installation work. And then as far as the paving and striping of the transit facility yard, there's proposed for a new structure. And I think that the whole traffic pattern and everything is pretty problematic. I'm not an engineer, but I think the people that are going to be driving those buses

27:57 Need to weigh in as far as what's going to happen. There's too many things that happen in this town, like airport hangers too close to runways and stuff like that. An engineer said it was okay, someone else said it was okay, but now it comes out that it wasn't. You know, we constantly do these things over and over again, and, you know, I'm not, I have no intentions to try to curb the project. The project needs to be done, but some modifications most likely. The future transit building that they want to,

28:26 That they want to build is on the south side of the property, backs up against another building on a zero lot line is what's being proposed. They're not going to be taking any advantage of natural daylight by putting the building on the north side of the property, just like the existing building there with roll-up doors in the front so that the sun comes in, lights to play so they don't have to spend money on it.

28:55 On electricity lighting, for lighting and for, you know, taking advantage of the sun to heat the building during, you know, daylight, cold, winter days. I just think that there should be some little bit of discussion. It's not too much of a big deal, but I just think that something should happen prior to the award. I had an understanding, Martin, that we've already considered that item and approved.

29:26 The letting of a contract for that work. Is that, is that not, Peter? We approve the design work contract. That's right. Okay. All right. Well, then we'll have that opportunity as it comes. And we've been working closely with ESTA related to the design of the facility. Great. Thank you. Okay. Thanks, Martin. Anybody else? Steve?

29:59 My name is Steve Searles. I want to get Sean and Joyce Turner. I've left the building so I can speak freely without them here. I worked all four days from before they opened until after they closed. I've been to most all of the events, live concert events that we've had in Mammoth over the years that I've lived here. I just want to second Michael's comments. They hit it out of the park.

30:27 I don't know. They seemed so analytical about the work that they're doing and things that they could improve that they just killed it. At one point, they asked for a show of hands of the people that were attending that were first-timers to Mammoth. Indeed, most people were from out of town. I think it was less than five, you know, maybe 10 percent of locals. It was all out-of-town guests. The amount of new people that came here and had a great time, it was just off the map.

30:54 You guys oversee the measure. You're funding. I think it's the exact thing that we should be funding in our community. They really, really did a great job. I walked mile after mile after mile on the property every single day, and I only looked for things that are wrong. You couldn't find anything. You never waited in line for a bathroom. It wasn't disgusting.

31:18 People weren't unruly. They weren't being overpowered. There weren't issues with the police department. It was just a great event. And so as you guys move forward and work on funding other events, I would just encourage you to look seriously at this event for their guidance for other events, maybe bring them into the conversation. It was really, really well done. And thank you for your time. Thank you, Steve. Okay, anybody else?

31:48 If not, we'll move to Councilmember Reports, and we'll start with John. I have none. Mr. Mayor, Matthew. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. On the 25th and 26th, Mayor Wood, myself, the Chief, Sandra Moberly, and Pam attended a League of Cities conference up here as a regional conference that we hosted for the League of Cities, and the turnout was exceptional.

32:18 Most of them are located down the high desert area. We're the mountain region portion of the high desert mountain region. But it was the first time hosting it, I think, in at least the last three years or four years. And great attendance, but we learned quite a bit, I think, at the meeting. Mayor Wood and myself spoke to the bankruptcy and where we've come since then. And I think what the other cities really got out of it was...

32:45 Just quite an education of what we had to go through and a lot of the challenges that were before us and where we've come since. So I do want to thank our staff for helping us organize that. They did a wonderful job. And let's see. Attended Bluza Palooza. I volunteered as well. Sean and Joyce's credit. The acts, I don't think they give themselves enough credit. It's just...

33:13 They were exceptional, honestly. A lot of them I'd never heard of and just thought it was great to sit there and find out somebody new. I wish I could have seen Kenny Wade Shepard on Sunday, but I missed that. The expansion was far more comfortable. They did have a lot more beer. Unfortunately, I couldn't hit all 80 booze, but I made a good attempt at it. Steve, you did a good job as well.

33:39 Actually, Steve was working pretty hard out there. He's our PR guy for our town. But one thing I find really amazing, especially in an event like this, is just how the community comes together, particularly when it comes to staffing and things of that nature. So I want to thank everybody involved, and the officers in our town and also the other towns, Bishop and the Sheriff's Department that came forward and helped us staff that. Yesterday I attended...

34:08 Myself and Councilmember Raimondo attended a meeting for the Mammoth Bike Games in the fall century and just wanted to let everybody know that that's coming along real well. It's September 4th through the 8th and as I mentioned earlier, it's not just going to be the century this year, it's not going to be just bringing back of the kamikaze, it's going to be a combination of the events. And from what I understand, the trending for

34:36 People that have signed up for the event already, they're expecting about 800. The trending is somewhere around 11 or 1,200 people for just the cycling for the century. So that's looking excellent. And finally, Cheryl Witherell was going to speak tonight. I think she had a concern during Bluesapalooza about the trolleys not running as late as she hoped with all the people drinking. But I think she had sent an email to the chief and to

35:06 Council and staff. And apparently that got taken care of. And she just wanted to say thank you to everybody involved who helped remedy that situation. It got people out of their cars and those that were drinking, taking the trolleys back up to areas, you know, for example, up by Canyon Lodge, which is a pretty good hike. So she was hoping that in the future maybe part of the application process where there's alcohol involved that maybe we

35:33 Automatically include an extension of the trolleys going beyond their regularly scheduled time. So that's all I have. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Matthew. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I attended our monthly MLT meeting today, and just a couple things to go over with that meeting. One, with the passing of the T-Bid, we're going to be expanding our MLT board to nine seats, adding two new seats.

36:01 The new seats will be a dedicated retail seat, and the other seat will be an at-large seat, which is basically for a person holding a Mammoth Lakes business license. If you wish to apply for either one of those, just email your contact info no later than August 15th to info at visitmammoth.com. Just a couple things going over air service, regarding our summer air service.

36:26 In June, we had 2,448 employments, which was up 20% over last year, so a huge improvement in June. In July, we had 2,718, 2,718, which is basically flat, and of course, we think mainly that's because we lost three flights due to the Aspen fires with visibility issues. Our August pacing is very strong. As of August 6th, we had a 54% load factor, or 2,381 seats.

36:54 Last year, at the end of August, for the whole month, we had a 64% load factor in 2,927 seats. So we're looking to outpace that as we're still early in the month. We also have our winter air service schedules confirmed. From Los Angeles, we'll have two flights a day, six days a week, and one flight a day, one day a week from Alaska.

37:19 Alaska also this year will be doing San Diego, one flight a day for seven days a week. San Francisco we get one flight a day, seven days a week, and we get a second flight four days a week from United. Orange County is going to be one flight a day, four days a week from United as well. The flights are loaded and you can book your winter flights now on alaskaairandunited.com and the actual schedules if you want to see the times are online at visitmammoth.com. That's all I have. Good, thank you.

37:49 Just one item to report on. I had attended all of the Chamber Music Unbound concerts this year, which again were sell out on several of the evenings, and I wanted to make sure that everyone understood that Measure U put up the temporary structure

38:08 Affectionately known as Edison Pavilion. It was used for the Food and Wine Festival, for Jazz Jubilee, and for Chamber Music Unbound, and this weekend for the Sierra Summer Festival. For Chamber Music Unbound, essentially it meant an increase of 100 seats to, whereas they were selling out in the college lobby, and it was an incredible use of the Measure U funds and these groups coming together to give us the structure for

38:37 The part of the summer for those events. And even with just one single violin playing, of course, it was Corey Serovsek, so he plays beautifully, but acoustics were great and the wind noise was not a problem. Sounds great in there, actually. Sounds really good. Part of that is due to Brian Knowles. Yeah, it is. Thank you. I have a couple of things.

39:06 Mayor Pro Tem Bacon and I attended the Town of Mammoth Lakes MLTPA Liaison Committee meeting on July 24. Actually a very good meeting because they sort of summarized what they've been doing all of these years and looked to the future with respect to their relationship both in the near term and the long term with the town partnerships that

39:35 They have, as well as the town, will enter into their relationship to MLR if indeed it is formed. That's Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And also their relationship to Measure R and U funding. Essentially, you know, their role is the stewardship of our trails. They continue to do that. There's a lot of detail. I'd be happy to talk to council members about that if you wish.

40:03 Speaking of MLR, we had the second of three facilitated meetings on Monday? Monday. Of this week. A three-hour session. Again, Mayor Pro Tem Bacon and I attended on behalf of the Council. It is a facilitated discussion which is examining whether or not this is something that we as a town should form as we have other entities.

40:33 There is a third meeting, and I believe it's August 19th. These meetings are open to the public. It will be posted. There are 32, I think, representatives from various entities and stakeholders and agencies in the community, including the United States Forest Service. Really good debate last time that sets us up for either developing consensus or not.

41:00 One way or the other on whether to form this entity, so stay tuned for that. I wanted to just take about 30 seconds and indicate, and this is because I've gotten a lot of emails and people coming up to me on both sides of this TBIT issue, I want to make it very clear that while I voted no on the specific bill that was before us, as I stated in my comments a couple of weeks ago,

41:28 I have, I do support and have supported for many years the concept of collaborative joint marketing under one roof and most importantly it's now the policy of this council and therefore of the government and I'm enthusiastically supporting it. And then finally I wanted to mention that our wonderful American Marathon and Half Marathon record holder, Dina Castor,

41:56 who turned 40 about six months ago, won a 10K race in Maine, and I'm embarrassed to say what the name of the race is, except that I can tell you that it drew contestants from all over the world, including from Kenya and other places where they run very fast. Meb Kevleski ran, obviously, from Mammoth. Ryan Hall, formerly from Mammoth, ran a number of others as well, including a couple of new recruits.

42:26 To the Mammoth Track Club. And I'm just real proud to say that she set a new American Masters 10K record to add to the God knows how many records she has and simply crushed the old record. So I suspect the American Marathon record, not the Masters record, but the regular record has been held by her for an excess of a decade as has the half marathon record. I suspect this will...

42:53 Stand for some time to come. She's on to Moscow for, she's a member of the United States team that is competing in the World Marathon Championships and will run, I think, Saturday, Saturday, yes, Saturday of this week and I don't know what the next step is for somebody who should by now be out of the competitive, off the competitive circuit, but she's just a terrific

43:23 Ambassador, not just for running, but for Mammoth Lakes as well, and I wanted to congratulate her for that. Okay, that's that. Next is reports from commissions and or departments. Peter. Mr. Members, Peter Bernasconi, Public Works. Just to give you an update on some of the street work we've got going and some of our contractor work we've got going, one of the items on tonight's agenda is asphalt work.

43:52 And we'll be doing thin overlays on Tavern Road, Crystal Lane, Ingsbrick Place, Monterey Place, Lech Court, Zurich Court. And later on we'll be doing the bus stop out by Tamarack and Old Mammoth, which is funded by the Plum family. We'll also be working, it'll be a few more weeks, but we'll start doing a couple of the ceiling projects, the micro ceiling projects that we awarded at the last meeting.

44:22 We're trying to let the companies that are working on the microfiber complete their work, get the patching done, and then we'll come back on Old Mammoth Road, Chateau, and another one to see how that works and hopefully reduce our long-term maintenance costs over time using that process. We also have our step projects and grant projects going forward. Sierra Nevada Safe Rouse to School project is under construction, and a few more weeks, that project will be complete.

44:52 The college connector path, the paths complete, the lighting and the signage will be another probably another two months before all the work is completed. Canyon Boulevard, we were anticipating to start work this summer. It is taking a while to get the federal approval to advertise. So I anticipate we'll be advertising in September. We'll board the contract probably November, December.

45:21 And start work April, May of next year and complete the full project next year. So that's reconstruction of the pavement in Lake Mary to Hillside, reconstruction of some of the pavement between Hillside and Forest Trail, new storm drain in the areas that don't have storm drain, and then a sidewalk on the north side of the street with intersection lighting on all the intersections. Sidewalk top to bottom? Yeah, so that's a big project, $3.6 million.

45:48 At the next meeting, I'll also have a report to council to discuss the 2014 STIP, which we've been talking about a lot at the LTC meetings, but just to give an update on some of the projects that staffs may be thinking about and an update on the MOU projects that Monom County helps fund on the southern access routes to Mammoth. And with that, if there's any questions?

46:16 Peter, just go ahead, Jo. Well, it's not really your area, but I was just wondering if you know how Digital 395 is coming along. They've obviously been through town. Yeah, there's, the town was one of the last legs to make the connection. So that part, I know that they're just about complete with that. And I understand there's going to have, in the next month or so, a connection so that they can start doing testing. Great. On that,

46:43 Peter, I noticed on Sierra Park Road there, they've gone and torn the road up. I don't know if that's them or the Water District and a few other areas in town. Are they going to fix those roads? I mean, is that our responsibility now? I mean, I know they've patched it and it seems like they're done. So usually there was both in that area. The Digital 395 folks did their permanent patch last week in that section. The Water District, they usually combine all their...

47:13 Patching into one contract, and I understand that will be done probably the first or second week of September. So the patches that are on Canyon, for instance, and the ones that's here at Park, which are pretty rough, those will be hot patched the second week of September. Okay, so it's not done. It's not done. Okay. Peter, do we... And Andy may have an idea, too, about the Digital 395.

47:42 At the meeting that they had a few weeks ago, was there anything of interest to report on the MOU projects south on 395? Any decisions made? No decisions, but at the next meeting, I started to put together a presentation. It got a little more complicated than I had to prepare for this meeting. Okay. Things are moving forward, and they've got several different alternatives they're focusing on to complete the work that they're obligated to complete.

48:12 Good. You'll give that maybe at our next meeting? Yeah. Thank you very much. Thank you, Peter. Chief. Okay, I've got my police chief hat on now, and I want to give an update on some activity that's been going on in town. We've been pretty busy the last week or so, in addition to having a large presence at Palooza Palooza. And I'll just add, it was a really good event from our point of view. We had very, very few problems, and it just seems to get better every year.

48:44 I think everybody knows we had a bank robbery last week. The best recollection is the first in about 15 years. I want to thank the public. We've gotten a lot of good tips. Surveillance cameras today are much better than they used to be. We got some very good photos from the bank. We've had a number of tips on who the individual might be. We had one person who we thought may have been the suspect. We've contacted that person and ruled him out. We are actively following some other leads.

49:14 I can't go any more into it than that, but progress is occurring and we're spending a lot of time on a very active investigation. Another event that's been newsworthy is a missing hiker from Pennsylvania. He was reported missing to us on July 29th, but he was last seen sometime in mid-July. He's a very avid outdoorsman and hiker from Pennsylvania who was here, who was camping at Shady Rest Campground.

49:43 He left there and never came back. He had a car being serviced here in town and never picked it up. Speculation is he went off probably alone somewhere on a hike. We're not sure where. Based on his logs, we had an idea that it might have been in the Mount Ritter, Mount Banner area. Mono County Search and Rescue was notified last week. There's not a lot they can do unless they've got an area to look.

50:11 Because it looked like perhaps he was in that area. They conducted some searches last weekend without any success. So at this point, he's still missing. There are a Facebook page called Find Matt Green that has a photograph. We have a very good photograph of him on the police department's Facebook page along with the Mono County Sheriff's.

50:37 If anybody has any information on where Matthew Green might be, we would appreciate being notified either to the police department or to Mono County sheriffs. And that's all I have to report on that. Thank you, Chief. Questions? All right, before we move to agenda item one, Steve, do you have something else? On the issue of wildlife management, last time we were in Sweet C, I mentioned about the issues we were having in Old Mammoth with the little black cub.

51:12 It was widely covered in the media. Thank you for the time at the podium. Got a huge response from the people that live out there because of all different things. Working on it hard, the people being more responsible, locking their stuff down. The Bears on his third week up in the Lakes Basin area and out of old Mammoth and that buys him a lot of time and time to learn and grow up. And so I'm grateful to the community.

51:38 Also, the sow with the two cubs that are reported out on that was covered in the media up in the slopes area was up at Twin Lakes today. And so that's very appropriate and great to have her up there and not in the back seat of cars. A lot of bears in town, I'm sure everybody's catching news from around the western United States with the drought situation. A lot of bears are getting shot and euthanized.

52:02 A lot of communities that we go to are killing bears right now. Mammoth continues to make me proud. So I just wanted to reach out to the whole community, thank everybody for what they're doing. We have maybe 90 days left of enjoying seeing the wildlife and it just comes with a little bit of responsibility. Again, back to the event this week, the 6,000 or so people that came to the event, they don't know.

52:28 We tried to educate them, but it was all staffed by locals. For that much food and that much attractants to be put out four days in a row and not get a bear fed, I just find it amazing. I would have bet money against it. They didn't get into trash, they didn't get into vendors. The town, thousands and thousands of our guests saw bears while they were here, but without incident. And so I just applaud our community, the great work they're doing.

52:58 In the morning when I get out, you do see one or two dumpsters that have been left open. It causes a big spill. It causes a lot of phone calls and emails to my computer. But out of 450 dumpsters, you know, seeing two open, I think that people are doing a fantastic job, and we'll keep working with the two that can't get it.

53:18 I guess my comments aren't so much directed at the Council, but our community, I'm so proud of everybody, and everybody keep doing this. We continue to set a bar for what's possible in coexisting with wildlife. Any questions from Council? Yes, sir. I'm going to embarrass you, Steve. Sorry. Steve thanks the community, and rightfully so, but he's also modest because

53:45 Most of the credit goes to Steve and his efforts. I don't know seven days a week, how many hours a day you work. But it's Steve's ability to push not only himself but other people in the community to educate the people that live in the community and our visitors as well. And that's why, you know, bears are feeding out of two out of 450 bins. So I give a lot of credit to Steve.

54:15 And also other communities, whether it's in California, up and down the Sierra, or in other states, do have, including Lake Tahoe, do have bear problems. And with the number of bears that we have and the potential for bear problems in Mammoth, I want to thank you, Steve, publicly for the job that you have done and to create a situation where the wildlife and ourselves can coexist without the big problems that other communities are having. So thank you.

54:44 Thank you, John, but as you know, you're wrong. It's the community, it takes a village, and so I'm just so grateful. We met families that came from Austria this week. They were at the Blues of Palooza. They came here just because they saw the Bear Whisperer show. That show's about our community, not about me. So I know you have other things to do.

55:07 This year I only gave stickers to people who came up and approached me and asked for them during the event. And I gave out 3,000. So truly our community is known for this task. And again, you're wrong, I'm right. I'm so proud of what I'm here. We appreciate what you do for us, Steve. Thank you so much.

55:34 I wanted to... You're coming back? No. Before we get to that, I just want to mention briefly something that I forgot, which is that Vons is having its grand reopening tomorrow with speeches and, more importantly, apparently free food. That's noon at the new Vons, which is right down here. So you want to come and watch those festivities. That will happen from, I believe,

56:04 12 to about 1245. All right. Brings us to agenda item number one, which is five-year anniversary award to police officer Daniel Henson. Before I get to that, let me just comment and point out that Steve Searles is a man of many talents. There was somebody in the police station today to meet with me, and Steve walked out and introduced himself as Chief Watson.

56:24 It didn't work. It didn't work. But he tried. Yeah, it's my pleasure to introduce the next agenda item, and I appreciate the fact that several members of the police department are here to recognize Daniel Hansen, and I'll point out to them that, no, I didn't forget to mention it during my comments earlier. It's an agenda item. So I'd like to ask Daniel, oh, he's here. This is his five-year anniversary, and I think it's kind of a statement on where the police department is.

56:53 Daniel's been with us for five years and he is the junior officer on the police department. We have not hired anybody in five years. But I do appreciate the fact that we are in the process of very close to bringing somebody else on board. And that's not only good news for the police department, it's really good news for Daniel because during the period of time he's been here, we've lost officers almost every year, which meant he's been on the bubble and facing layoffs for five years.

57:23 I think a credit to him is that through that period of time he's remained very positive. I know a lot of people would be, well I don't want to say he wasn't nervous about it, but it didn't affect his ability to come to work every day with a good attitude and work hard. And fortunately because as we have shrunk in size we've had retirements and other officers leaving to go elsewhere so we have not had to say goodbye to Daniel. He is our most productive.

57:53 And one of our hardest working officers, he's proactive, he seeks additional responsibilities, he'll soon be a field training officer, and he's absolutely a critical member of the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, and we're really glad to have him. Daniel's a local product.

58:11 He grew up here in town. He's a product of Mammoth School System. And his parents, who I know are here, are well-known to many in town. That's Craig and Marcia Hansen, the owners of Mammoth Business Essentials. And Craig is, of course, a very active member of CERT. So with that, I'd like to introduce Daniel Hansen and thank him for his service. And, Dan, I want to, if you can face this guy, he's going to take a picture. I want to, on behalf of Council, present to you this certificate of appreciation of these courses.

58:47 This town's recognition was your service for five years. But the other thing that I want to say is this, and it's important. Dan's parents have been longtime residents and business owners of Mammoth. They put this guy through the Mammoth school system and a credit to the Mammoth school system. It produced somebody with a whole lot of talent who wanted to come back or wanted to stay here.

59:14 That doesn't happen very often, unfortunately, in this community. As we all know, those of us who have raised children here or who are raising children here wish that all of our kids can come back. I'm just really pleased that you decided not to leave and that you're with us. And it's a credit to the community, certainly a credit to you and your parents as well. So congratulations. Appreciate it.

59:51 All right, Chief, thank you. And that takes us to agenda item number two, which is a public presentation from Ted Shady, Air Pollution Control Officer of the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District regarding the 2012-13 Mammoth Lakes PM10 and Meteorological Summary. I can't believe I actually said all those words correctly.

1:00:23 Hi there. I'm going to change the title of my presentation to the state of air quality of the town. I like that a lot better. Hi, my name is Ted Shady. I am the Air Force Control Officer for the Great Bay City by the Air Force Control District. I'm the Air Force Control Officer for three counties, Alpine, Mono, Nino County. I've been with the districts for 23 years.

1:00:49 As Mr. Turner mentioned, it may be impacting tourism this summer in Manhattan.

1:01:03 But I think it really does spotlight why air quality is so important for the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'm going to talk a little bit about how you've met standards and in some cases not met air quality standards in town. But I believe that clean air is more important to the town of Mammoth Lakes than probably any other community in my very big district.

1:01:28 The Great Basin District is bigger than nine small states up to, including Maryland. It's a huge area. But, you know, Mammoth relies on air quality for a lot of reasons. And for the next couple of months, you're going to be hearing about the town's update of its air quality management plan. One of the things that we awarded a grant fund to the town this year for was to update your air quality management plan, which really hasn't been updated since 1990, so it is well past due.

1:01:58 That update really, or the original air quality management plan came about in 1990 as a result of the town and Great Basin working together to resolve what at the time was a very serious problem in Mammoth Lakes. You saw the air quality that we had last week in Mammoth Lakes. Those were two of the highest PM10 levels we've ever measured in Mammoth. We had a 166 on micrograms per cubic meter on July 29th and a 183 micrograms per cubic meter on July 30th. The federal standard is...

1:02:27 So we were well over the federal standard. We hadn't had an exceedance on that federal standard since 1994, so for 20 years. But before 1994 and before those, the town and Great Basin worked on what were the first wood stove requirements ever adopted in this country in 1990. It was common for Mammoth to see days like we had last week.

1:02:53 For example, in 1990, we got a 162, 1994, we got a 164, 1991, 141, 138 in 1993, or 152 in 1994. So, you know, what we saw was not that uncommon. And we really, as a result of those, at the time, very innovative and somewhat controversial wood stove regulations, we showed that it could be done. The realtors at the time said, oh my God, you can't make people...

1:03:21 I think we showed that that rule wasn't the case. We've made great progress, as I said. No federal exceedances of the federal standards since 1994. But we're kind of in a plateau. I don't know if there's a plan.

1:03:48 You've got a graph in your head of something like this. It shows that in how we had these high levels in the early 90s and then really through the 90s and the 2000s, it dropped pretty precipitously. But we've been flat since then. And although, like I said, we're not exceeding the federal standard, we generally exceed the state standard, which is not 150, but 50 micrograms.

1:04:18 About 20 to 30 times a year. And that's just really too much. I look at some of the other cities in California and see how many times they exceed the state standard. And the city of Victorville is one that exceeds the state standard about as much as Mammoth does. So if you want to advertise on the Mammoth, our air is nearly as good. I think we need to do a little bit more. We need to drive those state exceeds the panel.

1:04:49 We were under the impression that the rules and regulations of both the district and the town adopted in 1990 required the change out of wood stoves on sale houses. And we were under the impression because of the turnover in real estate over that 24 years that we had changed out about 90% of the stoves in that. And so we've been kind of scratching our heads as to why we're not getting cleaner air than we are.

1:05:16 The days that we do see in the state of season typically occur on cold, calm, holiday weekend during season. A lot of people in town, there's no wind to push the smoke out, it gets cold, everybody likes their stoves. If those stoves are all compliant stoves that have been changed out since 1990, we really shouldn't be seeing those levels. Come to find out, the town has not been enforcing those regulations since about 2006.

1:05:45 I'm disappointed, I've got to say. We've had a lot of turnovers since 2006. All those houses that did get sold, some of them may have had their stoves changed out, some of them may not have, and we really don't know at this point. So what I would suggest that we do is that we need to reestablish the enforcement of those changeouts and that we go back to those through the real estate records. Your town planning staff says they have that information, they just don't have staff to work on it. I suggest that we go back.

1:06:14 Get that pile of data and start going through that pile and really kind of get caught up to today. So figure out how many of those stoves have been changed out, how many have been changed out. And then we commit, you know, from this point on to start reinforcing those existing regulations. You've taken on the responsibility to provide that enforcement. I have regulations that require you to do that enforcement. So I can actually write you tickets if you don't enforce. I have no intention of doing that.

1:06:42 But, you know, what we're really need to do is we need to get back on the, you know, to enforce that. To help out, I was, I am offering the services of one of our consultants, Lisa Isaacson, who I think you probably all know, has been managing our Clean Air Projects program for the last couple of years. We've got a large payment in the city of Los Angeles, $6.5 million that we've been using for what we call our CAP projects. We'll talk about that in a minute. I would like to offer Lisa services.

1:07:13 to the town to work with planning and building departments to see if we can kind of handle on where we are on the enforcement. That they compile a list, a database of sort of where we are, and that we come back and we report to the town council as to how we can build it here. But I think what you really need to think about is how to reestablish that vigorous enforcement of those change-outs department.

1:07:41 So with that, you have one of the CAP projects that we funded was a clean air calendar, a Sierra Skyscapes calendar that local photographer Andy Seltzer's worked with us on. It gives you 12 examples of what the skies are supposed to look like in the inches here. And, you know, we need to really strive to make every day one of those clear sky days in Mammoth and throughout the district area. Questions?

1:08:10 A comment, Ted, thank you very, very much for your generous offer of allowing Lisa Isaacs to work with the town to get caught up. I mean, that's, hopefully people understand how generous an offer that is by the great basis. We've got her in a contract with this cap project. We're going to have her in a contract throughout this fiscal year.

1:08:32 She's going to be wrapping up some of the CAP products that we have. I think, you know, she's indicated she has some time and would be more than willing to work with that. That's great. Well, thank you. And then I had one question. With the Aspen fire, I know that you've issued some alerts over the last two weeks. Do the fire officials that are working on the fire, do they listen to the Great Basin? Do they take...

1:09:02 Great Basin's input. Do we see any impacts of the input we may be giving them? If you ask that question five years ago, I would adamantly answer no. Five years ago,

1:09:13 On the other side, on the west side, they thought they were doing their job if the smoke disappeared off to the east. You know, that was a success as far as they were concerned. And for about the last five years, myself and one of my staffing members, a guy named John Beck now, have really been trying to make inroads with them. We go to all the meetings, we go to all the, we have participated in all the conference calls, they have been inspired, and there really has been an increased acknowledgement of the fact that there are people over here.

1:09:42 The smoke disappears over here, but there's not a lot of us, but we still breathe air and we deserve the free to clean air. The National Forest folks are a lot more responsive, I would say, than some of the National Park folks. The Sequoia Cane Park people are more responsive than the Yosemite folks. The Yosemite burners, they've kind of been going the world over there.

1:10:08 They don't like anybody telling them what to do, but Sequoia Canes and all the National Forest personnel really coordinate and communicate and coordinate really well with us, and I think it's gotten a lot better. They make decisions now based on the potential impact that those decisions have on community. Great, thank you. Other questions?

1:10:32 Ted, thank you for that informative report. Good evening. I'm just going to follow up Ted very briefly. Thank you very much. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Councilmembers. I'm Lisa Isaacs, a Clean Air Program Administrator. I prepared for you a very brief statement on the town's participation. It's in that handout I gave you, the town's participation with the Clean Air Program.

1:11:04 Essentially the Clean Air program began in late 2011 with specifically for this program about 5.6 million. We had 59 applications for funding and we chose 29 out of those applications. The town received two competitive grants and then one block grant of that 5.6 million.

1:11:30 As you saw, that calendar is one of our interpretive products from our Clean Air Funding, working with Andy Seltzer's on that. Right now, we have, of the nearly 30 projects we've funded, 19 are now complete or nearing completion. And our ending date for all projects, Town of Mammoth Lakes projects included, is December 31, 2013. Another very...

1:11:59 Aside from the calendar, a very noteworthy, relevant project for you that we've just wrapped up is the Wood Stove Replacement Program. While we have focused our efforts with this funding, we've emphasized the Owens Valley Planning Area. That is the area that has experienced the most impacts from the Dry Lake emissions. But we have funded projects throughout the whole Tri-County region.

1:12:27 For this wood stove replacement program, the town of Mammoth Lakes had a total of 27 new stoves paid 100% by the clean air program and installed in the town. There were 94 in the home of Mono County, but we installed overall 475 new stoves. Or when I say stoves, I mean either EPA compliant heating systems. They may be pellet stoves. It may be wood burning. They may be propane.

1:12:56 It could be kerosene. But that whole amount of new stoves we've just installed, 475, that equates to an annual reduction from the old stoves we replaced of 8.5 tons of air pollution a year. And just the 19 that we installed in Mammoth equates to just over 1,000 pounds of air pollution a year going into that air locally. So if we can get more out of the town, we wouldn't.

1:13:26 Be very excited to do that. Right now Clean Sweep has a waiting list. All the vendors that worked with us on this established a waiting list so that they had more to go to once we ran out of funding and they've got 22 qualified installations in the town right now that we could, when and if we have more money to install, we would love to start with those 22 stoves in the town. Specifically the town's clean air programs that we provided funding for.

1:13:56 Was it for a total of $332,000? We funded three different projects for you, two competitive. One was a street sweeper purchase, which has already taken place. You have a new street sweeper out there, a PM10 qualified street sweeper, and that was for an award of $200,000. You did have a cost share in there. Street sweepers are very expensive. The town had a cost share of about $97,000 for that street sweeper purchase.

1:14:22 We also awarded $50,000 for the Air Quality Management Plan update, and that is well underway with staff and Bill Taylor's assistance. And then we also awarded the TAN a block grant. We awarded all the district agencies. There are four district agencies on the governing board of the Air District, and every one of those agencies got $10 per person for their 2010 census population.

1:14:49 Which for the town equated to $82,340. And so you have a remaining balance. You have already received some of that money as a supplement to the air quality management plan update cost. But you still have a balance of about $53,000 in that one. So that page of your handout, I'm going to let you all look at it at your leisure, is a whole list of all the projects that we've awarded funds to, where they're located, how much we awarded them.

1:15:20 As well as the block grants. With that, can I answer any questions you may have? Because I noticed on my way up to Mammoth, I was out of town this weekend, on Monday that the Lone Pine Ballfields parking lot, which was dirt forever, was paid. And I wondered...

1:15:42 I actually assume that LADWP actually did that because I have an understanding that they have some relationship with those things. Well, I guess they did, didn't they, with their funds? And I see that as one of the grants on the second page of your thing. So I guess they're just out there everywhere.

1:16:03 That's one of the 19 that's either complete or nearing completion. They'll still be installing some bike racks to also encourage people to ride their bikes to the ball games. And you may not really realize it, but just paving a dirt lot results in significant air emissions reductions, whether it's wind-blown dust or...

1:16:25 And what's really interesting about that sports complex, Mr. Mayor, and I'm glad you brought that out, is that also has a community health issue with that one. It is directly adjacent to a residential community. And so that neighborhood is thrilled. There'll be a few, you'll see a few others as you, if you look close around town. And around the, I should say, around the tri-counties.

1:16:56 Thank you, Lisa. Thank you very much. Thanks, Lisa. Okay, it takes us to consent agenda items three, three through eight. Does any councilman who wish to pull an item, if not a motion? Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion to approve consent agenda items three through eight. Second. Okay, the motion and the second. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:17:27 Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number 9, which is our first policy matter, authorize the construction of the Little Brothers Escape Park with donation agreements, including the JLA Foundation. Peter, is this a presentation that you're going to give? Correct. Okay. Mayor and council members, the Town and JLA project, and this should be a project,

1:17:53 Have been partners at Trailsand Park since I think about 2006 with the initial construction of the Volcom Brothers skate park. Initially it was planned to be at the College Foundation area. Ended up at Trailsand Park. It's been a great neighbor for the people who live in the area. It's been a great park for the community as a whole. The GRH project has now been raising money over the past several years with many fundraisers.

1:18:23 And has come to the town with opportunity to construct a smaller Little Brothers skate park adjacent to the Volcom Brothers skate park. It will be located in your illustrative attachment between the playground that was constructed last year and the existing skate park. This item was discussed yesterday at the Recreation Commission.

1:18:53 Sort of a fast track item because Jane has hopes of constructing this this summer and a lot of the people who donated funds to her project would also, I think, like to see that completed. The commission did recommend approval of going forward with the construction of the park, contingent on completing the plans which are currently being designed, almost done, and completion of agreements with the GLH project.

1:19:22 Jane is here. She can provide more information. And with the funding that she's collected in cash, she also has some major contractors that are willing to donate work and construct parts of this project as well. Jane? Before we get to Jane, do we have questions? No. Peter? Yes, just one, Peter, in that

1:19:50 There was something about using Measure R design funds here. Does that leave us short, or are you going to have to ask for more funds then for other design? Because I know the park's not fully designed yet. So just a little history. So we did receive two Measure R grants for the park project. One Measure R grant was $40,000 to do design work, which include the whole park, including Little Brothers Park.

1:20:20 That is fully funded and it will include funding to complete the design of this Little Brothers Park and the state area. The other portion, which is the playground, I think there will be a small fund balance for that. That will go back basically in the measure of our account to be redistributed back to Charleston Park to finish the grass with another award or...

1:20:43 Okay, so there might have to be another request for the – we were already going to have to have another request for part of – it's not really grass, it's artificial, right? Artificial turf. Yeah, okay. And we also had a grant application with state parks to really complete the overall park, including that synthetic turf. And they came over and did a review of this project site, you know, substantially reviewed the project application.

1:21:13 And they really weren't interested in funding the turf area. So with our next measure, our application, we'll probably take that out as a separate item and then include discussion about matching funds for a future grant application. One of the things that Andy just mentioned is the agreement will require prevailing wages be paid for any of the contractors working on the facility because it's a town-owned facility, whether or not there's town funds.

1:21:46 Peter, I have a question. I'll preface it with this. When the original, what is now the existing skate park, was constructed, the contractor or builder or company that did most of all of the work, and I don't know whether it was the same company as the design company or whether it was a separate company. My memory just doesn't serve me well on that. As I recall,

1:22:19 Didn't either finish it or didn't construct it to standards that were acceptable to you guys in the Public Works Department. And I'm choosing my words carefully because this has been 10 years and I don't have specifics on that but I can remember very distinctly that we went back in and spent something like a million dollars to finish or change.

1:22:48 Or add to, or in some way have some involvement in that. And I'm not quibbling about that, but I'm the premise to my question. Okay, and I can give you kind of an overview of all the expenses for the park. Okay. I heard someone within the town once say it was $2 million. I don't have any idea whether it was $1 or $2 million. That's not the point of my question, which is this. How do we ensure...

1:23:17 That that which is being proposed to be done is going to meet whatever standards we impose, whatever design requirements we have, and ensure that we're not going to be expending additional town funds to complete what has been started, if that's an issue, or to enhance or improve what is put in in the event that you guys in public works are not happy with the outcome.

1:23:46 I don't want to suggest by my statement that I'm presupposing that it's not going to be done correctly or that it's not going to be completed. But in light of what occurred ten or fewer years ago, I ask that question. Okay, just to follow up kind of on a little of the background and the finance just to kind of clarify that. Essentially, the local River State Park, if the town had done that work at that time, it would have been about a million dollar project for that concrete work.

1:24:16 The town also put in a turn lane. That was DIF funds that paid for that turn lane, and that was about $250,000. The town also had a separate contract to install the bathrooms and the parking lot and the electrical infrastructure water, and that contract was about three-quarters of a million dollars. So the town did, you know, put in about a million dollars worth of infrastructure into the park that was needed.

1:24:46 As a park as a whole, you need a parking lot, you need restrooms and utilities. The water district also made a contribution. They originally were making a contribution that they thought was for the foundation parcel. They honored that contribution at the skate park and they waived their permit fees or they incorporated them into that $50,000 contribution and installed a sewer system, water system to the restroom facility.

1:25:16 There was an issue with the cradle. It's called the cradle. Some of the rebar was exposed. So the town did come back in the end and correct that work upon acceptance of the project. And I believe that was around $25,000 to fix that part. So the repairs were really minor in comparison to the overall project facility. I'm really glad that you clarified that for me because I remember the rebar issue now that you mention it.

1:25:45 In this case, and I think it was good to just kind of review the whole thing so that it's really, it's about a million dollars an acre to build a park and it's a four acre, almost a five acre park and that's about, you know, what we're spending is about it. When it's fully developed it'll be in that range. In this case, it's a lower level facility. There will be testing that's performed, compaction tests as well as concrete tests. We also will have our

1:26:15 Our town inspector out observing the work as work goes on. So I don't think in this case, it's certainly not a complicated structure. It's really mostly flat work. They're going to use shotcrete to place it. They will have a licensed contractor to do the work. And I don't expect to have a major or any rework required as far as… Do we have the performance bond requirements on this? Well, one of your…

1:26:42 Action is either to waive that requirement or not waive that requirement. So for them to get a bond for this work would probably cost, I don't know, a few thousand dollars, I'm guessing. So one of the action requests is that you waive that requirement for a bond.

1:27:01 We have the ability that's required by the municipal code. If we do end up waiving the bond, we'll still have contractual remedies because we'll make sure that our agreements with the contractor specify they have to construct everything to code and to our satisfaction. Okay, last question. Thank you for that. Do we know who the contractor is that's going to be responsible for doing the work? It's a Gallagher construction. Is that local? Gallagher? Actually, it's kind of a neat thing.

1:27:30 He worked on our original project when he was 18 years old. He came here and worked on the project. Oh, as a worker? As a worker, he and Brian Seiser. And he's just started his company. And he's built three or four skateboard parks in private homes, one for the Jacobs family that lives here in town. And so now this will be his first public project for a skateboard park. But again, I think for...

1:27:59 Peter's trying to tell you this is not a real complicated project compared to what we said before. Before we did 42,000 square feet. This time we're only doing 5,000 square feet. We don't have anything that, any obstacle that's higher than three feet. It's all got a gentle slope into it. The project will be done in probably less than three weeks. So one week to do the pouring, and one week to pour the concrete, and one week to do the finished work.

1:28:28 So it's not as big of a project, anywhere near as big of a project as the other one was. Thank you, Jane. Andy, could I just ask you to clarify that from your perspective, we don't need the performance bond requirement because you would be able to put something into the contract to protect us? A performance bond is an easier remedy, really. I mean, the reason you have a bond, in most cases, is required.

1:28:55 The nice thing about a bond is you have a pot of money you can call upon right away. If there's a breach, if the contractor does not fulfill his obligations, just call on the bond. It's easy. A contractual remedy is not quite as easy because you have to threaten to sue the contractor for breach of contract. Maybe they have any assets, maybe they don't. Maybe you have to go through the entire litigation. So I'd say that a performance bond is the best. A contractual remedy is better than nothing, but it's not as good as a bond. And we're talking, what, $340,000 total costs?

1:29:26 It'll be less than about $75,000. $75,000 for this piece. For this particular part of the work. The contractor's part is only $45,000. The other part is getting by, and that's not the area. Got it. Okay. Jane, comments, or are you here for questions? I'll just start in with where I talked to you a little bit about our history.

1:29:56 I'll go on to the part that we left here. We've been real busy the last two weeks, and Councilman Eastman went out to the park with me, and we sat down on a rock, and we discussed, and he came up with some really great ideas and actually offered to help us out. And so he really moved us on our way, and with his help and support, we are ready to go. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area would actually like to start tomorrow on their part.

1:30:22 Because Clifford's going on vacation to Lake Powell, and he doesn't want to worry about it. So if not, he will be starting on Monday, and it will be a three-week project, like we said. Yesterday, we went to the Park's Grant Commission, and we had a really nice surprise. We had five children show up, and three of them had speeches all written. And Tyler made one of the speeches, and she's

1:30:48 Ready to give you her speech, just so you can hear her little speech. Hi, I'm Tyler, and I'm 11 years old. My older sister, Shane, used to come to these meetings, and she helped get the Wilcom Brothers Skate Park to that spot. But today, I am following her footsteps and helped build the Little Brothers Skate Park, so little kids can learn how to skate and get better as they get older, and the Little Brothers will get more little girls to skate, which would be cool.

1:31:23 I have been skateboarding since I was four years old, and my family has been skateboarding ever since I could remember. Skateboarding is my life, and I want to see little kids make it their life, especially girls. I think that we should have a little brother skate park because I want to see the excitement on their face when they accomplish something. It would be cool to have a little brother skate comp so they can show people what kids can do. Thanks for listening.

1:31:52 Thank you. So we are ready to go, basically. And before I, I would like to say I thank you very much, Peter, for clarifying how much money the town spent on the skateboard park, because there is a lot of false information out there. I keep hearing that the town spent a million dollars in the skateboard park, and that's not true from what Peter told you. They spent the money on the turnout.

1:32:26 And other things that are there so the whole rest of the park can go forward. So they weren't necessarily part of just our skateboard park project. When the people came from a silo company to check the cradle, they actually did find out that the cradle was structurally sound. And there was just a few little parts.

1:32:51 So a lot of the money was spent to get the company to come here and tell them that the cradle was structurally sound. So actually the work that has been done on the skateboard park has been to a very high standard and has held up over seven years. We have money and we continue to do all the maintenance on the skateboard park. This maintenance is done in a lot of different ways. Sometimes we come in and we do it all. We pay for the materials, the labor.

1:33:21 And we do it all ourselves. Sometimes when there's certain materials that the town would like us to use, the town buys the materials and we pay for the labor. We, over the past couple of years, we've probably put in, I would say, $50,000 in upgrades in the skateboard park. We've done the pavers. We've done the landscaping. We've put in benches. We continue to do a lot of work. Also, I can tell you that

1:33:51 Our commitment to this park is going to be ongoing for a long time. We have the most unbelievable resources to keep this going. We have two fundraisers, our putting contest. It raises about $10,000 a year just in one day. And we did the bank slalom last year that raised $30,000. It's going from a one-week event to a four-week event at Mammoth Mountain. So actually, I foresee as having close to $75,000 a year.

1:34:21 In the JLA Project, we don't use all that money for parks. We use it threefold for parks, arts, and education. But we will always have the money for the maintenance for the park. And we're actually putting money away. So if you get to the point that 15 to 20 years down the line, you need a major overhaul of your park, we will have the money available for you to do it. We also receive $7,500 a year.

1:34:51 From Volcom that comes through 2016, then that agreement will be up for actually a renegotiation. You can continue with Volcom. You can try and do naming rides. You can do all sorts of kinds of things with it. So I think that we're a pretty solid organization. We've done good work. We've stood by our product. And it's something that the town can be proud of. And the use in it is getting

1:35:24 More and more every day. I went down there today at lunchtime, and there wasn't a single parking place down there. And there were probably at least 100 kids in the park skating. They were all over. I don't think you have another park facility that in the summertime gets as much use as this park does. Thank you, Jane. John. Jane, is there an event coming up this summer, or has that already happened? No, we have an event on September the 7th, and it's a putting contest. And the cool part about the putting contest is we have

1:35:54 We now almost have 90 sponsors, 90 businesses from all over the United States that each one send us $100 to fly their flag at our event. So we make about $8,000 in just sponsorship. And then we have everybody in the town come out and they can cut. We have a great raffle. We have food. And part of this year, what we've done is we're giving back to Sierra Star. They have a kids' golf program.

1:36:24 So our foundation buys their golfing equipment. So in turn, we get to have our event there. And also what our hope is is that on the same day we'll have our dedication of the Little Brothers Skateboard Park that will be done and it'll be all set and ready to go. But is there like a Volcom competition or anything? That event, I don't think that they have that one this year. What they're doing this year is Steve Claussen's event that's on August 24th.

1:36:53 That is a skate contest, and everybody's invited to come and skate, and Steve provides everything for the community. He just does the whole event all himself. Okay, thank you. Council, what's the pleasure? I think we have one more public. Oh, sorry, Martin. You were standing right behind Jane, and I did not see you. Once again, Martin Kleinbart, a local citizen. I have a couple questions before I...

1:37:26 Make any comments. Correct me if I'm wrong. Okay, the parcel is owned by the town, correct? Okay. And the staff time to deal with the permanent inspections and all that costs money, correct? Correct. Okay, so that's public money. Andrew, there is a threshold of California law that stipulates on public works projects.

1:37:57 Where performance bonds have to be in place. Right. But the town is spending zero dollars on the construction part of the project, which is why it's not going out for competitive bidding. But it's still a construction project on public lands. My recollection of that part of the public contract code is that if we are not spending money on the construction contract, we don't have to have a bond. But I will verify that. And if we have to have a bond, then of course we'll require a bond. Right. Because one of the things is that

1:38:27 Don't want a repeat of what's been going on. I will state foremost that I do not like prevailing wage projects because it just runs up the cost. But however, it is the law. And just like other things around town and in our lives, my lives, my construction business, we have to follow those. If we don't like it, we lobby our legislation and get those rules changed. But as they stand,

1:38:56 This is a public works project in all intents and purposes and waiving a performance bond, waiving a public bid. I mean, why don't we just start to save the town money? Why don't we just start getting some donations on some project that we want to build just like this and let them pay for it, but really it's somehow town money and therefore circumvent the prevailing wage laws.

1:39:28 I mean, there was a, six, seven months ago, there was a town council meeting where there was a waiving of a project, money, and it says, oh, it was always a grant because that's the way, that's what it was for the Mammoth Lakes Housing Project and that there were onerous rules of prevailing wage law and, by the way, the contractor, you know, was making more money than other contractors in nearby areas.

1:39:58 Well, the profiling wage law has nothing to do with the contractor. It is onerous on the contractor because they have forms to fill out and documents to take care of, and it's highly cost. What it is, it's all about the employees and nothing to do about the contractor. And as we know in these projects that there have been problems on...

1:40:23 On this type of thing, where it wasn't done properly, and we just discussed that, nobody's come up with the exact cost, but I think Mayor Wood, when he talked about a million, it probably wasn't the million, but it was a very substantial amount of cost, and not to have a prevailing wage requirement, and then not have a performance bond, you're just circumventing the whole system that was put in place by our legislation in California to prevent this kind of stuff. I have no intentions of...

1:40:53 Trying to derail the project. I don't think the town is in the position of waiving any more fees in our financial situation. It takes staff time. I've got a project going and I made sure very clear that the price of my permit was going to cover the cost because I didn't want any issues that...

1:41:17 I needed so much from the town to be able to do the inspections on the timely manner, I wanted to make sure that I was paying the proper amount to get what we needed. So, I think I've said what I've said, prevailing wage, performance bond, and I really think this is a public works project. Aren't we paying prevailing wage on this, Peter? Correct. Yeah, that's what I thought. Prevailing wage would be required on the project. Joe, you look like you want to speak. Yes, I'm a little concerned about waiving of the performance bond.

1:41:51 Not just by what Andy said, but also if you look at legal considerations on page four, it says that if we waive it, it would make the town responsible for completing the project if the donors fail to do so. And that's just, to me, I'm questioning whether or not we're being fiscally responsible if we waive the performance bond. From what it sounds like, it's just a few thousand dollars, and it sounds like, and I know Jane has done a wonderful job of fundraising, that

1:42:19 It protects the town for a very small amount of money. I just don't know what anybody else's thoughts are on just that piece. I have no problem with waiving the grading permit fee. I raised it because of my concern. I asked the question. And I was going to ask it if you hadn't asked it. Well, then I would move approval option one with the change that number two says to waive permit fees only. I'd second.

1:43:04 There's a motion and a second, so discussion, comments. Discussion, I remind myself that this is a donation project. It's not a general construction project that we would have someone else do. The organization, the JLA Foundation that has built this previous project of 42,000 square feet,

1:43:34 I'm just curious, so

1:44:02 If there were a performance issue, what would be potentially the greatest liability to the town financially? Is it the $75,000? Well, I think essentially it would be, is there a safety issue with whatever the work had been done? And didn't Andy say that we could cover it in a different manner? So I would say it's a fairly small amount of work. It'd probably be less than a few thousand dollars.

1:44:31 Town staff had to do something to remedy a safety situation. And to date, we've really had a good relationship with the GLH project on ongoing maintenance of the project, either having temps work on the project, sometimes they come in and do some work. We do have the volunteer program that forms for those workers to sign. In this case, it really is a donation project, so they do have to pay for billing wages as that relates.

1:45:02 But as far as the overall risk to the town, I would say it's a pretty minor amount because it would really just be a safety-related fix that we're completing. Could I ask Andy to explain then what it says on page four of the agenda bill where it hints that we would have to pay to finish the project? Well, I think that the intention of that statement is that if we have a half-finished project on town-owned land, probably we would...

1:45:29 Want it to not be a half-finished project. We would probably want to get it wrapped up. I don't think we'd have a legal obligation to get it finished, but we'd have a half-filled project. And just to answer Mr. Kleinbart's question, the threshold for requiring a payment bond is $25,000, and the threshold for requiring a bidder's bond is $5,000. So again, we're not spending any money on this, at least not on the construction contract part. I don't think we're required to have a bond, as far as I can tell.

1:45:59 Okay. I'll withdraw my second. Yeah, I mean, I'm with John. I think I'm okay with the way it's written. So what I'm hearing is a withdrawal of the second. And the motion dies for no second. The motion dies for a lack of second. Mr. Mayor, I'll move that the council adopt option one as presented. Second. Okay. Motion and...

1:46:32 Second, my only additional comment is that I'm satisfied that the risk is worth taking. And with that, if there is nothing else from a council member, I will call for a vote. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Yes. Motion passes 4 to 1. Takes us to agenda item number 10.

1:46:57 which is revision to chapter 3.12.020 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Reducible Code related to the exclusion of the T-Good Assessment from being included in the definition of rent for the purposes of calculating transient occupancy tax. I think the title of this is probably as long as you can. Cindy. Cindy Myral, finance manager.

1:47:25 So the agenda item before you is an emergency ordinance that will temporarily exclude the TBID collections from the gross rent definition for the purpose of calculating TOT. Andy, correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the ordinance revision is written as temporary so that Council could remove this revision at any point in the future without having to go to the voters. Yeah, that's absolutely correct, Cindy. If the Council were to make this a permanent reduction,

1:47:54 And in order to restore it, you have to go back to the voters because it would be an expansion of the TOT tax. But you do have the ability to make it temporary and kind of indefinite, you know, with no fixed expiration date. And then if you decide to undo this decision at some point, you can do it without having to go back to the voters. Okay. The proposal was brought before you with the blessing of John Urdi, our director of Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

1:48:19 It will make it much easier for the remitters to calculate their taxes and avoid the public perception of unfair tax and promote compliance with both the TBID and the TOT. It is an urgency item because the TBID starts its collection period September 1st. Based on our budgeted revenue for transient occupancy tax, it results in a potential loss of TOT revenue of just under $115,000 annually.

1:48:49 This revenue was not included in our budget. So with that, we are recommending that you adopt this urgency ordinance. Thank you, Cindy. Questions? Pretty straightforward. Is there a motion by anybody? May I make a motion to council approve option one, adopt the urgency ordinance adopting the amendments to municipal code chapter 3.12.020 as proposed. Second. All right. In the motion, second. Any other discussion? If not, we'll call people.

1:49:21 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That concludes our meeting tonight and we will be adjourned to the next regular meeting to be held on Wednesday, September 4 at 6 o'clock here in the council chambers. Thanks. Good night.