Town Council
· recording 3 hr 12 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
400 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Test, test, test, test, test. Can we get this mic up anymore?
0:29 Can you hear me in the back? Larry, can you hear me in the back? Okay. Y'all ready? Are you ready? No. All right, thank you all for coming. We're going to commence. So, I don't have a gavel, so hopefully we'll all be nice and respect the candidates' need to be able to hear what's going on.
7:07 So good evening and welcome to the 2010 Town Council Candidates Forum. Thank you all for coming. Tonight is sponsored by the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce and will be televised live by Channel 51 from 5 o'clock to 8 o'clock. You can also see it streaming online at mammothlakes.com and then you click on Town Council and Planning Commission meeting live. I'm your moderator. My name is Tom Cage.
7:35 It's my goal to present as many questions fairly and evenly to all the candidates tonight in hopes the community will obtain a better understanding of their positions. There are three seats open in the upcoming June 8th election with one incumbent and seven other candidates sitting before you. For those that are not registered to vote, you have until May 24th to register to vote, and I hope and encourage everyone to vote and be part of the election process.
8:00 I have met with all the candidates and explained the rules and solicited questions and ideas from them. Tonight we will have a blind draw using Scrabble Cubes, which we've already done for seat assignments, and the order of questions and opening and closing statements. The seat assignments will be the order that we will start questions later on after your opening statement. I want to thank all the candidates for having different starting letters and their first names, and I hope you don't mind if I call you by your first names tonight.
8:30 All candidates will have a one-minute opening of who they are, how they are running their campaign, and how the public may reach out to you. So just a quick brief who you are and how we can reach you in the future. All candidates will also have a three-minute closing statement to summarize and convince us why we should support them for Town Council. The candidates will have one minute to answer questions posed to the entire panel and two minutes to answer questions posed to individual candidates.
8:59 Please be as brief as possible to allow for more questions. In the front row, Eric Wasserman, the President of the Chamber, will have a yellow card, 15 seconds left, and a red card. Time is up. If you're finalizing your statement, obviously, I'm not going to interrupt you, but if we can be as succinct as possible with those cards, that would be great. We have a phone number for the public to call in questions. Hopefully the camera can pick it up.
9:28 It is 934-8989, extension 350. And we have the ability for you to email questions to chamberforum at npgcable.com. If you're in the audience, there are three by five slips of paper that are on pads that you may write questions. And Linda Wright from State Farm will be going around and picking those up and giving those to me. I will do the best I can.
9:57 It sounds like a long time. We only have three hours, and it will eat up a lot of time on our questions. I'd also like to thank Mark Deeds from Mammoth Crossing and Chamber Board Member, Carina Corpy from the Treasurer of the Chamber, and Jim from State Farm as well, along with Janine Hernandez for helping out tonight. Carina is in the back taking phone calls.
10:22 Our questions and topics will be in the following categories so the audience can prepare thoughts to that. First, we'll go over ballot measures, town management, budget, planning, DMO, and if there's any time left, other agencies that interact with the town. So without further ado, everyone relax, enjoy. We're going to start with a one-minute opening statement and that will go to S for Sharon.
10:53 Good evening, fellow Mammoth citizens. One of our big problems is getting all segments of our community on the same page. Do we want to be a livable community or a shiny resort? We need your help to take control of Mammoth's future. Our current government is dysfunctional. Citizens' desires are ignored. It will take time to regain your trust.
11:19 The new council needs to receive and listen to public input. Everyone has to understand our general plan. Then we'll find consensus. If you're ready to roll up your sleeves, get involved, and tell your town council what you want, vote for me. Good government depends on public input. You have to be engaged. As a town council member, I will have a dedicated phone, email, and Facebook page.
11:49 That is always open to questions and comments. Join me, and together we'll find a coherent town vision and help Mammoth be all we can be. Thank you, Sharon Clark. Dawn. Well, going along with the, going along with the, what you had told me when we met, Tom, I was very, very short in mind. My name is Dawn Varouk. I own and operate Elegant Bath and Kitchen, which is located downstairs.
12:19 From here. You can find me there most days, so I encourage anyone to drop in to ask me any questions, to find out what my views are, and also to express your concerns. You can follow me on Facebook. My Facebook page is Dawn4Mammoth, and that's four spelled out, F-O-R. I have an email or a website. It's dawn4mammoth.com. You should be receiving some mailers as well as some letters.
12:45 I'll be canvassing local businesses as well as homes, and I look forward to talking to each and every one of you. Thank you, Don Baruch. R for Rick Wood. Good evening. Thank you for coming. My name is Rick Wood. I'm a lawyer in town, having been here for almost 20 years. As many of you know, I have served on two past councils for a total of eight years. I am a five-term mayor in this community.
13:14 Thank you very much.
13:36 Or at my law office at 934-5821. Looking forward to this debate and the specific issues that we're going to get into tonight. Thank you. Thank you very much, Rick Wood. T for Tony Barrett. Well, good evening, folks. Tony Barrett. I think for most of you know I've been here over 20 years, and for those that don't know me, I've served most of that time working for the town in various positions from Tourism Commission to the Town Council, where I served as Mayor Pro Temp for two years.
14:05 And I'm currently a planning commissioner with the town of Mammoth Lakes. For those that know me, you know that most of my life here has been an open book. So for those that don't, I'm hardworking. I look forward to good leadership and working with the community. And in this campaign, I think what you'll be looking for is experience. And that's something I possess. How you reach me is you can reach me on my cell phone at 760-914-0157.
14:33 I have a website, which is www.barrett-2010.com and at Facebook at Elect Tony Barrett, Mammoth Lakes Town Council. Thank you. Thank you very much, Tony. M for Matthew Lehman. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Matthew Lehman. For those of you that don't know me, I am a local businessman here in town. I have a commercial real estate brokerage firm as well as a real estate appraisal company.
15:02 I've been operating up here for 15 years. I grew up, spent the majority of my life in this town. My family moved here when I was two years old. I've left here to finish high school down in Encinitas and attend college back east. I'm campaigning on a number of different mediums right now. I have a website, www.matthew4mammoth.com. I have a Facebook page, Elect Matthew Lane.
15:33 Elect Matthew Lehman from Mammoth Town Council. I'm also available on Twitter, but for those of you that are avoiding the computer, just call me at 760-822-5845, and you can also email me at matthew.layman at verizon.net. Thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Kirk Stapp. Good evening. Thank you for hosting this. My name is Kirk Stapp.
16:00 My name is Kirk Stapp. I have lived and worked in Mammoth Lake for the past 35 years. I recently, two years ago, I retired. I previously served on the Town Council from 1986 to 2008. I have also served as the President of Mammoth Lake Housing Board of Directors, and I'm looking very much forward to this discussion this evening.
16:24 You can reach me at akstapp at msn.com or my phone number's in the phone book. It's 934-2902. And I guess we'll just see how this discussion goes this evening. Again, thank you for attending. Thank you, Kirk. Next is Jay for John Eastman. Thanks, Tom. My name is John Eastman. I've been a member of the Town Council for the past 16 years. My wife, Lisa Eastman.
16:52 Works at the Snow Creek Athletic Club where she's been ever since they opened which was about 28 years ago. People identify me as having common sense, being fiercely independent, and I'm a businessman with a very physically conservative view on the town's budget. I have set myself apart from the current town council, from our...
17:19 Having fought hard on the many issues including budget expenditures, wildlife management services, and town staffing levels including holding town administrators accountable for digressions within their departments. I've enjoyed my years on council and hope to be of further community service for the final four year term. I'm available by phone and email.
17:48 Thank you. Thank you, John. I hope this is an A. A. Alan Bloomer. Greetings. Grace and blessings be to the citizens of town of Mammoth Lakes and those of you that are watching on TV and streaming on the web. My name is Alan Bloomer. I lived here in 89 and 90, come back 20 years later. I guess I'm going to be one of those that came back on vacation and just probably never left town. My platform has enhanced our community and preserved our heritage. I'd love to help Mammoth become the...
18:16 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
18:42 All right. Thank you, Alan.
19:06 All right, without further ado, our first question, and as I said, this will be to each of the panel members. You'll have one minute to respond. Tony will be the first question, Don will be the second, and so on. You all stated your position on the medical marijuana ballot measure, so the question is, if the medical marijuana dispensaries are allowed in Mammoth, what penalties would you support if there is a violation in the sale of marijuana, and would you be willing to write this into the ordinance?
19:32 That's a very good question, Tom. And, you know, frankly, if anyone reviews the ordinance, you'll see the Planning Commission did an extremely good job with the ordinance that we have that will take place after the ballot measure. And regarding your question, if there was any infraction by one of the owners of one of these cooperatives, they could lose their license immediately to operate. And they may not...
20:00 Take out another license thereafter. So we have put some very strict measures in it, and frankly, I think that's about as strict as you can get if someone has an infraction, you shut them down. Thank you. Thank you. Dawn? Well, based on what Tony said, there's really not much more we can discuss.
20:22 It is what it is. It definitely should be written in the policy that if the infraction is broken, or if the ordinance is broken, that that individual will lose their opportunity to do business in that business in town. Matthew? I would be comfortable with a single infraction warning if they do not comply with.
20:48 Ordinances, then I'm sure there's a line of people that would be more than happy to step up and take over that business, assuming that we'd ultimately find somebody that was capable of operating this in an orderly fashion. Thank you. As Tony said, on the plan commission, we have put very strict rules and regulations for these facilities. We are only going to have two in town.
21:19 They can only be located in two zones. They must be 1,000 feet away from each other and away from schools, libraries, and parks. They will produce sales tax, and I have absolute faith in our police department that if there are infractions, they will be handled immediately. Thank you. Thank you, Sharon.
21:44 Marijuana, medical marijuana is involved in medicine. There are people that need it for help with chemotherapy, other appetite suppressions, and also depressions, and pain enhancement. There is a difference between the infractions, whether it's the co-op or the cardholder. I have full faith in Mr. Klassen that he will run it as will be agreed to. The cardholders, once again, if they're...
22:12 If the co-op is following the guidelines, especially the ones from Redding and other co-ops on the coast, there's not going to be, you're not going to be able to get an amount that you can illicitly sell on the street. But if they, if the cardholder themselves are violating that, they're not using that medicine, and we find out, yes, I believe they should be held up to a misdemeanor, if not even a felony.
22:35 Charges, so there should be a look between the difference between how the co-op is being run and if the cardholder is abusing that privilege. Thank you, Alan. John? Tom, I'm presently comfortable with the penalties that are currently written into the ordinance. Thank you. Rick? Tom, I agree with John. I've seen the ordinance and I'm comfortable with the restrictions and the penalties. One could ask, well, what are the infractions that
23:04 There might be, and to the extent that, this is a zoning ordinance, understand that, that's what it is, it's not an ordinance to legalize the establishment of a co-op. It's an ordinance that describes where they can be in the town of Mammoth Lakes, and there are restrictions on those, and so if the infractions relate to the activity, it seems to me that the ordinance covers it to the extent that there are criminal violations that are governed by state law, state law will preempt by local law. Kirk?
23:33 Well, I'm in the minority because I think you should vote no on it. In the 34 years that I taught school, I watched it impact young kids over and over again, and I watched them mess up their lives. So, yeah, I understand the medical part of it, and I do agree that it should be available to those people that are experiencing chemotherapy and those kinds of things. But the message to young people, and especially the young people in our community, with its huge amount of...
24:02 Turnover of tourists is that it's a medicine and that it's available to everybody and that, you know, it's something like aspirins. So I've seen what it can do to young people and I disagree with the idea of opening two co-ops in our community. Thank you, Curt. Measure U is a tax initiative that would replace the sunsetting expiring utility tax with a new indefinite tax that will have broad options for its revenue use.
24:31 And be administered by the Town Council. Do you support Measure U and would you recommend an oversight committee that would make recommendations and monitor the revenue generated by Measure U? Dawn? Yes, I do support Measure U and I equate it with Measure R in that it's specific monies that's earmarked for recreation, transportation, arts and culture.
25:00 And just like Measure R, there's an application process. And the application process is not everyone is going to be able to receive those funds. Therefore, it's important to me to, just like Measure R, it's important that the application process is supported by whatever entity it is that's going to oversee those funds. And I think it's also important that the monies are not
25:28 But they don't sense it at this point because it's a revenue stream to continue operations. Thank you. Thank you. Matthew? Thank you. It's really important to know a lot of folks hear about Measure U and first thing that comes up is, oh great, a new tax. And I am not a fan of taxes at all. I don't like taxes, but in this particular case, I think it's really important to let people know the message is that this is not
25:58 A tax that's going to be a new tax to you. It's really just going to be a reallocation of a tax. I do believe that we should vote in favor of this. I hope that we do. It's going to be vital, especially moving forward. If we start losing out on tax money, I think that with the challenging economic times, we may be faced with some more hurdles. These taxes are going to be going to very useful things in Mammoth.
26:28 Arts, mobility, recreation, and whatnot. So, yes, I'm absolutely in favor of it. Thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon, let's all talk into the mics as well. I hope the TV's picking us up. If not, maybe somebody can call us and tell us if they're having trouble hearing any of the candidates. Thanks, Tom. This is not a new tax. This tax was used, a similar tax was used, or this one was used to develop Shady Rest and Mammoth Creek Parks.
26:54 Measure U funds will be dedicated to arts, culture, mobility, and recreation. Measure U funds will be dedicated just like Measure R funds, and the Town Council may not use these funds for any other reason or purpose. The funds cannot be added to the general fund. This is a positive reinvestment.
27:19 of our resources in our future, and I totally support Measure U. Thank you, Sharon. Alan? Absolutely in favor of Measure U. It is not a new tax, although there are a few things certain in this life death, and since there will be no sunset, this tax. But as we're working our way forward to being a world-class resort destination, we're always going to need to rebuild our infrastructure.
27:46 I have full confidence in John Wentworth with the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Parks Association, with the Friends of Inyo, the Sierra High Striders, and other people that will be putting in for these taxes. And with the panel that I see that's running here for Council, I have full confidence that this tax will be used correctly, because we cannot rely on Fed and State anymore. This is a tax for us.
28:11 They can't control it. They can't say what we can do with it. We can use this tax for the things that we feel benefit our town and our community, and I absolutely fully support Measure U. Thank you, Alan. John? Yes, I do support Measure U strongly, and I also support the formation of an oversight committee. I think it's important for the community to keep in mind that in the past to create and pay for facilities that we've had in the past.
28:39 We depended in large part in addition to grants. We also depend upon development impact fees. We have found out because of the economic hard times recently that development impact fees are not forthcoming, may not be forthcoming for a period of time. So Measure U creates and perpetuates a steady, reliable funding source so that we can create some of these facilities sooner rather than later. Thank you, John, Rick.
29:05 Tom, my view is that healthy communities invest and reinvest in themselves. I must say I had some concern about Measure U, and I was fortunate enough to hear a talk by John Wentworth, who's in the back of the room about a week ago, to a group that I was included in the audience of. And I'll tell you, for members of the community, if you have doubt, any doubt,
29:31 Give John Wentworth a call. Sorry, John, but there may be a lot of people calling you because it was the most articulate, rational explanation that I have ever seen or heard, I should say, seen and heard, of why this is an appropriate tax. So I'll leave it at that. I'm supportive of it. Thank you. Rick? Kirk? Thank you, Rick Kirk. Well, I'm the person that wrote the opposition article.
30:03 Debate, sorry. The opposition to this particular measure. It is not a continuation of an existing tax. It was sunsets. That means it is a new tax, okay, because we're starting over again, and it's perpetuated. So if you look at it, it's about $80 to $100 per household annually, and it'll go on forever. I agree with the committees, I agree with those different things, but I think you have to hold it.
30:33 Council or different councils because they change accountable. It doesn't have a sunset. There are no capital projects that are identified. The language described in it is very wide open. I mean, recreation, mobility, and art. I mean, that is as broad as you can possibly get. And finally, the CBiz policy conflicts with this. Sorry, my time's up.
31:02 All right. Thank you very much. You know, since most of you supported it, I'm going to ask for a real quick answer and a follow-up to this. Can I get to answer? Oh, I'm sorry, Tony. That's right, I started. I'm all messed up. Remember, I'm sitting real quick. I know, I know. Tony, you're... See, I've got to get used to this. This is not easy for me either. Tony, I'll make it real simple. My answers to your questions, which were two of them, is yes and yes. You know, at first I wasn't looking at supporting Measure U because I had a sunset, and I thought we should stick to that, but...
31:31 We do need to reinvest in our community. It's something I've always longingly believed in. And also with John Wentworth, with Measure R, they've done a great job. I've seen the oversight committee there. So I think we need to do this. And I see some opportunity to get the Brothers Skate Park, Little Brothers Park, finished. We've been waiting for that completion for many years now. And with the Mammoth Tract also. And, you know, I thought we would have rebuttal, but I guess we're not. This is a Chamber of Commerce forum.
31:59 So we're not going to debate, but you have a minute. So I want to use this time. I'm very concerned. I always want the community to have correct information, not misinformation. On the marijuana cooperatives, they are 500 feet apart. That means keep them 500 feet apart, whatever part of the district they're in, and it's 1,000 feet from our schools. And frankly, this is about medicinal use. It's Prop 215. It's nothing about children and recreational use. Thank you, Tony.
32:28 I knew we should have gotten Jack Winkler instead of me to be here. All right. So as a follow-up to that, since most of you are in support of this, the first Measure U, and Matthew, you'll start on this one, the first Measure U was leveraged by borrowing $10 million and then repaid over the next 20 years from the proceeds of the utility tax. Would you consider leveraging this tax in a similar way if passed? No, I wouldn't. I would not put a sunset on the utility user's tax.
32:57 I think, again, John Wentworth put it very well. When do we really going to stop needing funds for recreation, arts, and mobility? I think on the horizon, the long-term goals that this town has set forth for what we want to see for the vision of our town, these are items that to get the infrastructures in place may take quite some time. So no, I would not place a sunset on it. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? Would you repeat the question, please? Yeah.
33:25 When the first measure you tax, the first utility tax was put into place, the town council borrowed $10 million to use all in one lump sum and then repaid it from the utility tax over the 20-year period. Would you consider leveraging this tax in a similar way and borrowing the money up front that the utility tax may pay for over the next X number of years? That's what I thought you said. And no, I would not be in support of that. I think we need this money used.
33:54 For things that we need today. And I'm excited about the possibility of a public-private cultural center that would need operating expenses. We've got Mammoth Nardic that needs help with cross-country ski trails. Of course, we've got public access. We've got all kinds of needs that are current, and that's where I would like to see the money utilized. Thank you very much. Alan?
34:24 As I stated earlier, we can't rely on state and federal grants anymore. But when you have money that you can invest, it's much easier to get a grant from the states or the feds when you're already halfway through a project. When they know they don't have to fund the whole thing and they look at a town and they see that you're committed and you have the money there that is bondable, you're much more likely to get a grant from the feds or the state to bring forth some of these. And we're moving forward with the way the...
34:52 The welcome center, the visitor center is now part of the welcome center. We're getting more notoriety. We're getting more on the map. And by having this bondable, taxable, when they know that they're going to continue to see this come in, it's much more likely that we are able to match the state, match the feds, and get more money to help us with these infrastructure projects. Thank you, Al. John?
35:18 Yes, I do support leveraging the money that we receive. I think that's one of the big benefits and the intent of this measure. Measure U generates about $800,000, give or take, a year. And if you built a project and didn't leverage it, it would take you several, multiple years to do a single project. So I do support leveraging this income. Thank you, John. Rick?
35:44 There are two kinds of leverage. John just stated one accurately. I support that. Why not leverage? Why not use $800,000 a year to borrow several million dollars to get what you want now instead of waiting? Two, leverage is in the same way that Alan has described it, which is, and we do this a lot in Mammoth and have done it.
36:07 Thank you, Rick. Kirk? Absolutely.
36:33 You passes, I absolutely think you should be able to leverage the money. You can, again, you're getting things done today and utilizing that. All you're doing is borrowing the money using bonds and you're able to accomplish things like getting a roof on the ice skating rink or finishing trails in parks or building a track there. So leveraging is a tool that you should use if MeasureU does pass. Thank you, Tony. You got it right this time.
37:03 I strongly support the leveraging. We've had history with it, as we said with Measure U before. Also with our housing, when we passed our tax basically on the TOT to start our housing foundation, and you've seen what we've done with that. We took, you know, 36, made it 6 million, and we've made it 36 million. And we could do the same thing with this money for Measure U, so I strongly support that. It shouldn't even be about our future, or yesterday, it should be about today and what we can do.
37:31 For our community now. So I do support it. Thank you. Dawn? I too support leveraging using Measure U to leverage for grant monies that are possible as well as to borrow as we did in the original utility tax. Okay. That's it. Great. Thank you very much. All right. Those were the hard ones. Now we'll go into the easy questions. Town management is our next topic. Should the town council take a more active role?
37:57 With the town manager in evaluating overall staffing needs and issues of the town government, and if so, how? Sharon, we'll start with you. It's actually very difficult to tell who's running Mammoth. Is it the mountain? Is it the staff? Is it the developers? Or the town council? If the town council exercised effective leadership,
38:21 Developers and staff would present plans conforming to public desires as expressed in our general plan. After denying the appeal, town council members admitted that CBIS policy was inadequate. That's like shutting the barn door after the horses have escaped. I propose that the new council exercise its executive role and be accountable to the people. Thank you. Ellen?
38:50 As I've stated in the sheet from the ten points that Ted Carlton gave us, one of the things the town council needs to do is cut through this alphabet soup. We need to get through the CBiz, the DZA, we need to cut through that, get a solid general plan. It seems to me that the citizens after the village and the west of Menash were done, they just kind of went, never again.
39:18 From the constituency that I run across, they're really leery of anything over three stories tall. We really need to get back to the village and the trees language because that is one of the things that attracts people here is they like the simplicity, they like the rusticity of this community and we should preserve that at all costs. So basically we need to get through the alphabet soup and town council has to be staunch in sticking with that plan.
39:46 We don't need town management to throw things at us and then they're left holding the ball. Town council has to be the leaders in what happens in this town. Thank you, Alan. John? In answer to your question, yes, the town council should take a more active role in giving direction to the town manager. How do you do that? You do that with more frequent sessions with the town manager in closed session. And in those sessions, the town council has to
40:15 Not only identify what their priorities are for the town manager, but stick with those priorities. If you've got 5 or 10 or 20 priorities for the town manager, that's what he's going to work on are those priorities. But if the council goes back once every 3 months or 6 months or however often it is and comes up with a new priority, it's confusing to the town manager. So I think it's a part of the responsibility.
40:43 Goes with the town council as well in giving very clear direction to the town manager as to what their priorities are. Thank you. John Rick? Well, I believe that councils govern, they don't manage. Having said that, when there's a void in leadership, the person who fills it is typically the town manager. That's what I think has happened in this community. So how do you, the answer, of course, is yes, the council should become more active. How do you do it? You speak with a single voice, not five.
41:13 Thank you, Rick. Kirk? I don't know if the town manager has been doing a good job or a bad job because I haven't been sitting in on the closed sessions and listening to what the priorities are that the manager is supposed to be held accountable to. So at this time, you know, I agree with John that it is the council's responsibility to make sure that the town manager has clear directions and hopefully with a 5-0 vote as to where to take this community and how to direct staff.
41:44 That said, I would say that town staff's agenda bills are lengthy, convoluted, difficult to understand. There's one coming up on May 5th that is 115 pages, and it does not point out some basic facts in it. You have to go back to an April 21 agenda item to find out that this proposal is recommending
42:10 You know, a plan as well as a budget as well as a $95 million reduction in DIF fees. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Yes, you know, Town Manager has been a big issue for us this past year. And, you know, the Council needs to take the leadership role in the direction of the Town Manager. The Council should not be micromanaging staff. That being said, the next Council, and if I've been hired by you, I will work with the other Council members to do this.
42:41 And that is to give the town manager direction of what we expect in an immediate future. And that means not a year from now, but in the next three months. And frankly, the town manager currently has a clause that he can't be terminated for the first three months of any new council being sat. So I think the next council needs to take the initiative. You need to line out what our priorities are, what we want to see in restructuring, direct that town manager to do this work for us.
43:07 And if he fails to do that, well, then you start looking for a new town manager. Thank you. Tony. Dawn? I agree that council should take a more active role, however, not micromanage. Council is elected to oversee the town manager, and the town manager relays direction given by council to staff. There seems to be, in the past couple of years, a huge disconnect and communication breakdown within this process.
43:35 There appears to be a lack of leadership not only on the part of our town management but also the follow through with our council. Thank you very much, Don. Matthew? I think any town council or business or otherwise, there is a chain of command that you have to follow. I think one issue I've heard come through, at least as a citizen, is that too often our council does step in and...
44:03 Tries to give too much direction. They start going to department heads. That is not the goal of our council. Our council should, as many people have said, give very clear objectives to our manager, and they should be followed through. If they're not followed through, then you need to find remedies to that situation. But if management is not following direction, then at that point, maybe temporarily they need to step in and they need to take over a management role for a brief period of time.
44:33 But generally speaking, we have a structure in place. We need to make sure that that structure is abided by. Thank you, Matthew. Alan, you'll be first on this next one. Should we explore contracting with the county for law enforcement services in the town of Mammoth Lakes? Well, you know, I have to look at the fact that Red's Meadow is not a part of us. We seem to have to provide a lot of services for that. Having been in Reading and other communities, I have a very...
45:05 Positive outlook on the way the police officers handle the situation here in town. I've not seen them go overboard once since I've been here, June. And we do have Highway 203. That's basically one of our main streets, so we kind of have to deal with sheriffs and highway patrol. I would like to see a little bit more patrols during the day and during snow. I'd like to see a few more tickets going out for people that are driving too fast.
45:37 Right where I'm the caretaker of the church right now, there's a big new courthouse going in, and I hear there's going to be a jail there. I think some of the behaviors that have been cited and released, I don't think that's going to carry on so much, because right now, for an officer to make an arrest, he has to go all the way to Bridgeport, do the paperwork, and come back. So we might need help with the county and transportation. Thank you, Alan. John, do I need to restate the question? No, I can't. Thank you, John. Thank you, Tom.
46:05 In answer to your question, I would say that yes, the town definitely does need to do the analysis and have the discussion as to whether or not it's appropriate for the town to contract sheriff's services with Mono County. I'm not saying I support it or don't support it, but I think we have an opportunity coming up shortly where, particularly considering financial conditions in the economy,
46:31 Where it might make sense to contract with Mono County. I don't know one way or the other, but we definitely need to have the discussion and do the analysis, one of many analysis that could be done. Thank you, John. Rick? Well, many of you know that I've been highly critical of the leadership of our police department, and that is distinguished from criticism of the professionalism of the officers.
46:59 My view is that as part of what I am calling for as a restructuring of government, the police department needs to be included in the discussion, the review, the analysis. It's not for me to take a position on whether it's the right or wrong thing to do, but I will tell you this. The city of Thousand Oats in Ventura County, which is a city of 150,000 people, is served by the Ventura County Sheriff's Department, and it works well.
47:28 There for a long, long time. So it is not without precedent. Thank you, Rick. Kirk? Yes, I do believe that the analysis needs to be done. If it does save money, then I think that we should pursue that joint venture or partnership with the county. And if it doesn't because of transportation and those kinds of things or creating a jail here or whatever it happens to be that could reduce costs, then we need to look at that.
47:56 I think the question comes from there's been several incidents that have occurred over the last year with our police department that have been rumored out there, and I think that that also needs to be addressed. And that needs to be addressed, and I have talked to several different officers, and you do get different stories, but one of the things that the officers said, because it seems that they're so militant when they approach people and deal with different things, but there's another side to that, and that is,
48:26 How they're being trained and the fact that these cartels coming from Mexico have just literally targeted police officers and when we send police officers down to be trained, they're trained to literally look at everybody that way. Thank you very much. Tony? Well, folks, you know, we've gone through a lot of issues with our police department over this last year, as you've already heard. We did receive the press relief yesterday that Chief Shenley was retiring as of August 1st.
48:55 We bring an interim in as of July 1st so this next council will have an opportunity to work with that interim. And I'm in the belief that you need to do, we should do an analysis regarding the county, but we have a very fine police department. Yes, there's some bad apples that can be managed through good administration and good leadership. And folks, the people in Bishop did a great job of recruiting a very fine chief. And if they can do it, we can do it.
49:21 So I would be in favor of doing the analysis, but you know, if the county has money to spend with us, I sure as hell like to see them spend money with us doing some recreational fields and taking care of some of the needs that we want to see for our visitors and our youth. Thank you, Tony. Dawn? Yes, I think we should explore contracting with the county to assist in our public safety needs. We have a community of roughly 7,000 people, full-time residents, yet we have a
49:48 A budget right now that is $5 million for our police department which is budgeted for maximum occupancy. Those are big heavy winter weekends. We need to find ways to cut costs but not cut public safety. Thank you. Matthew? Given that we are spending $5 million a year or 26% of our
50:15 Our budget effectively on police force, I think it's something we certainly need to entertain being that we are staffed for the heaviest part of our season and our seasons are relatively short when you look at the entire year. We should look at the county. We should probably look more into working further with CHP being that we have a highway running right through the middle of our town.
50:39 And, yeah, I'm absolutely in favor of that. I think if we can share expenses wherever we can to create more efficiencies in our governments, I think it will be beneficial not only to us but to our county and possibly even to the state on a certain level. Sharon? I think we have a fine parallel with our fire department, which I think is excellent.
51:02 Right now with the police chief retiring, we have an opportunity to really explore what is both financially good for the town as well as a public servant's first duty or primary duty is public health and safety. So not only is the financial issue important, but we want to be certain whatever we do, we continue to protect the public.
51:30 I agree that perhaps like some communities do, they hire reserve officers at peak season. I mean, we need to look at the whole gamut. What is going to be best for Mammoth? And I think this is an opportunity to do it right now when we have a transition. Great, Chairman. Thank you. The next question, we'll start off with John, but I'm going to give John a pass because there is some issue with John sitting on council now with employee-council relations.
52:00 It's the order the way it falls, so you can handle it however you want. Here's the question. In the sheet, all the candidates rated our town manager from three to five with two of you abstaining. What is your perceived, and I use the word perceived since you do not sit on the council, so those of you that are not on council, this is a perceived issue with the town manager to rank him so low. I think I passed John and Kirk on this since they did not.
52:29 Ranked the Town Manager, but if they want to chime in here, they're more than welcome to. I just, if I may, just clarify for the public, the reason that a city and council member cannot publicly critique or rate a town manager or any other town employee for that matter is that town employee, including town manager, negotiations are closed session items. So anything
52:58 That is discussed in relation to job performance is discussed in a closed session. So it would be 100% inappropriate for me at this time to publicly state an answer to this question. Thank you, John. I appreciate that. And I'm sorry it fell that way, but that was the luck of the draw. Rick? Could you restate the heart of the question? Certainly. What is your perceived issue with the town manager to rank him so low? Well, as you know, I...
53:28 Was very actively involved as the mayor in hiring the current town manager and for the two years that he worked for the council that I was on, which was from six to four years ago, we had and I think continue to have a very good relationship. I had a weekly meeting with him. I knew what he was thinking. He knew what I was thinking. And I think the point of that is that
53:57 A town manager has difficulty when he's got five taskmasters, each giving different, sometimes unique, and conflicting direction to him. It's a very tough position. So I think that for me, the issue is that he's not been effectively led, he's not been effectively directed, and as a result, his performance has, at least in the public perception, suffered. Thank you. Kirk?
54:25 I didn't, again, I didn't rank him because the fact is I haven't been in the closed sessions to be able to hear what he's being asked to do. For all I know, he's carrying out exactly what the majority of council has asked him to complete, the tasks and everything else. So it's very difficult from the outside because it is a closed session item to be able to rank him.
54:47 Again, my criticism is of the staff reports that are over lengthy, that are not concise and get to the points. And I think that if that is part of his management style now, that has to be looked at. But if you're not directing him to direct staff,
55:06 To look at staff's reports and how cumbersome they are, then he's doing what he's supposed to do or what he believes is his management style. But some of this stuff is very convoluted and contradicting in the staff reports. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Well, I'm going to start off with saying the sheet because I'm thinking maybe you might have a bet going tonight about how many times the sheet is said. So I thought maybe I'd say it one more time, but not sure. No comment. You know, folks, I, as Rick,
55:38 Kirk John, I was on the council that did the hiring of Rob Clark and sitting on Planning Commissioner for the last four years since that time period. I've had firsthand viewing as a commissioner of interactions with the town manager, staff, and how our departments have been running. And I concur with Rick that, you know, the council really should have been giving the direction to the town manager.
56:01 But also I believe the town manager should have been coming up and saying, I see this going in the wrong direction. I need to do this. And getting the council to give him the direction he needed. So I feel that he's taking kind of a back seat over the last few years. He handled the Steve Searles situation very poorly. And our town deserves better. If he's able to step it up with this new council, then, you know, we'll carry on. And if not, then we'll look elsewhere. Thank you, Tony. Dawn? Thanks.
56:28 As I stated earlier, there appears to be a lack of leadership. The lack of leadership is in part the town management as well as the leadership that's been provided by the council. Again, being an outsider and not having sat in closed session, we don't know what exactly the town manager has been directed to do over the past few years, but being an outsider and looking in, we can see that there's a lot that hasn't been done.
56:57 There's a lot of issues. Budget, for instance, which has not been taken care of. That's completely ridiculous. And so, yeah, it's my opinion of, or my low rating of the town manager also reflects my rating of the leadership that he was given. Thank you, Don. Matthew? I don't know if we call it a low rating. It was middle of the road. We call that average. A lot of it comes from, I just think, basic decisions that have been made.
57:28 At the town manager level, I question what decisions would I have done differently had I been town manager. Would I look at maybe the budget? Would I have done more to enforce TOT collection? Furlough days, how would I have handled that? The furlough days I think have gone a long time. Furloughs are typically structured to be for short-term downturns in the economy.
57:56 It seems to me that by making the furlough extended out as long as it has, we've actually created poor morale amongst our people working amongst the town. So there are just a number of decisions, I think, that could have been handled differently, particularly with regard to making our town more efficient.
58:17 I personally like them. I think our town manager does a great job, but do we need a town manager and an assistant town manager? I would look harder at efficiencies. Thank you, Matthew. And you were the only one that ranked five in the paper article, so everyone else was below that. So you're right, it was average. Sharon? I have a rather personal issue with this question. When I was asked to vote on Old Mammoth Place, our water department and the
58:47 CEQA did not agree. So I suggested that the plan commission meet with the water department so we could understand what's going on. I was told that staff would take care of that. I preferred to go and hop to the water board, which is what I did. Found out there was a meeting. I asked to come to that meeting. I was told the night before our vote on Old Mammoth Place that I should understand that
59:16 Staff need to be able to talk freely among themselves. And that sent all kinds of flags up for me. I needed to know what the situation was before I voted. So that's when I went and took out my papers to run for town council. Thank you, Sharon. Alan? Well, a few things have come to light since that question was asked of me. I don't believe there can ever be
59:44 Hopefully in many cases, but I don't think you can ever have five people go on the town council, you're going to have total agreement. There's always going to be differences of opinion from experience. Once again, you know, he's had a really tough job with the alphabet soup. I mean, there's this, while I'm not necessarily for what was totally approved for the old Mammoth Place, it's been a five-year process, and I think it's about the town council along with the town manager.
1:00:13 A lot closer to understanding what we're going to have as our general plan. If you have to look at this, we're one of the few towns, cities, villages, whatever, that has a budget that's in the black. We're not in the red. That's just kind of remarkable. I think there was a huge setback with what happened with the airport situation, but I don't think that was necessarily the town management. Once again, I think we just need to look at the whole personnel.
1:00:43 Thing that we have here in town. Thank you. Maybe pair some things back. Thank you. We're going to move on to the town budget. I have received two emails from the same person. I want to thank you for sending them in. And if there is a candidate debate, these would be excellent questions. But since this is a forum, try to think of some questions to put in that context. In the meantime, as we move on to the town budget, I have one question for the panel. And we'll start with Rick. Who is your biggest donor? Me.
1:01:15 Thank you. Kirk? In fact, I'm my only donor. I donate to myself. I don't accept money because I don't want to be obligated. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Me, myself, and I have chosen not to fundraise from our community. I think times, economic times we're in, it shouldn't be happening. We don't need campaigns like that, and I want to be true to myself and true to my vote in the future. Dawn? Well...
1:01:42 I have chosen to collect contributions. I have not collected any as of yet, so everything that's out there is from me. Thank you. Matthew? My largest contribution was from some business partners of mine on a property I own down in Paradise. They live in Las Vegas, and my partner used to be a state senator, and so he was encouraging me and just supportive of me, so they sent me my largest donation. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? My husband.
1:02:10 Very good. Alan? If you do get a hold of me on my Gmail, email, Gmail account, I will forward the letter to you that I sent to the sheet in the Mammoth Times where, yeah, I'm keeping track of my time and everything and I'm sure I'm going to come in well under $2,000 and so, no, I'm not looking for any contributions except for Sierra Wildlife Sanctuary. Thank you, Alan and John. Once again, my, I'm,
1:02:39 My largest donor. If you're in town council in a small community, you have to remain independent. And if you take money from anyone, it's in your head that, you know, okay, this person gave me 50 bucks or 100 bucks or whatever it is. So by design, as both Kirk and Rick have mentioned, you learn not to take any donations and
1:03:08 Do the campaign on your own so that you feel good that in the future when you're making decisions you have a completely clear slate. Thank you very much. Everyone's staying right on time so we're going to get a lot of questions in. The next one delves into the town budget. Kirk will be first on this one. What's that? You just were. Yeah, you said Rick. Oh, I see. I thought that was just a... No, well, that wasn't actually... I'll be clean up. You'll be clean up on this one, Rick.
1:03:37 Kirk, why is it so hard to understand the town's budget? It seemed that there were a number of town council members that were surprised about the potential cost of summer air service and how the arts staff member is paid at the March meeting. If the town council does not understand the budget, how can the public be expected to know what is going on? Would you support a finance committee of two town council members to work with the town's finance department and report back to the public and the council on a monthly schedule?
1:04:08 Yes. It's okay to answer the questions briefly. There's several parts to that. First of all, if you look at the town budget right now, it's below $17 million. That's the operation budget. I think the council has done a really good job as far as dealing with that. The long-term financial issues that are still floating out there still have not been dealt with.
1:04:35 And I'll give you one example. One example is that $6.5 million that was in DIF fees. Did the council create a line item to backfill that if that is being traded away for community benefits? The council got in a lot of trouble in their budget because some assumptions were made. And those assumptions were that Hillside or one of these major three developments, Hotel 1, were coming forward.
1:05:04 And the council was never told that the budget was predicated on these assumptions. And it was millions of dollars that were supposed to come in in fees. It didn't happen. And so the council ended up, you know, starting to scramble back two years ago. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? In answer to your first question, yes, the town budget has always been an issue for most people to understand, especially our community. So what do we do about that?
1:05:33 We need to have a town budget that is understandable to our community, to the council, to our staff. How do you get there? In my opinion, we need to bring in a financial guru that's going to come in a very short time that could take somebody that's an expert in that field that can model a budget, model it off our general plan goals, bring us up to where we need to be, achieve those goals in the general plan through the budget, hire a true finance director, and yes, have a committee that reviews it with two council members, the finance...
1:06:02 Department, and I'd like to see two members of the public on it also so that it's reviewed and it comes forward to the council on a monthly basis. Thank you, Tony. Dawn? To answer your question, yes. However, I would request that the budget be reviewed not just by council members and somebody from the finance department but reviewed by a committee made up of real accounting professionals and finance experts. Very good. Matthew? In theory, yes, support a finance committee of some sort. I've read the budget.
1:06:31 Number of times. And for those of you who haven't, it's two volumes about this thick, and it's really interesting reading. I think a lot of it has to do with we need to start at the root of the problem, though. And if you look at the budget from another city, for example, I think it was Park City, they have a very legible, very readable budget. Go online and look at some other budget. They're much thinner. They're much more straightforward. Ours is, I think,
1:06:59 Lacks a lot of transparency, and I think one place we need to start is there. That way, I'm just concerned that two council members and even two people from the public won't be able to understand it. I would get a CPA on board to review it as well if we end up going that direction. So we may want to look at a couple of different avenues, not just one. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? Matthew, I agree with you almost totally.
1:07:25 I am a fiscal conservative with a strong financial background. I had 14 years of experience setting tax rates and approving budgets in Hamilton County, Indiana. The first thing we have to do is project revenues conservatively. Full projected costs need to be disclosed.
1:07:43 Any transfers in and out of reserves or between portions of general fund need to be clearly shown, not hidden away. During the year, we need updates comparing our budgeted revenues received and expenditures made against what was proposed in the budget. Quarterly, we need a projection of the town's year-end status. These few steps will protect our town funds and keep it from being wasted. I agree that
1:08:12 A financial committee with people who are well aware of what we need to do needs to happen and work with the finance department and report back to town council. Thank you. Sharon Allen? Yes, as Matt stated, the thickness of that, once you get paid for being on town council, if you actually read through that whole thing, you're probably going to be making about 15 cents an hour. It's just, it's thick, it's convoluted.
1:08:42 But once again, I'm still, I have to go to the fact that somebody must be doing good and reading through that. Even though it's confusing and convoluted, we're still in the black and not in the red. You know, how much, one of the concerns that we've had at the future of Mammoth meetings is how much do you spend on consultants? Are you going to save money? It's tough to pare down to find the right consultants to let you know that you're making the right moves.
1:09:11 The days are gone when someone who doesn't even have a high school diploma can run for a town council because to read through that budget and parse it out and know what it means takes a lot of intelligence. You have to be extremely literate. So yeah, whatever we can do to go through and try and pare it down so that it's understandable for the general public. Thank you, Alan. John? I think it's generally understood and we've concluded that the town budget is, in fact, very difficult to follow.
1:09:41 Simply because of the volume of it. So my goal, my personal goal, is to, starting in this year's budget, is to create two budgets. They would be the same, but the second budget would be something in the order of a 10, 11, or 12 page budget that would give the public a snapshot of revenues and expenditures for the departments. Also would give us staffing levels and the expenditures, or the cost of the staffing levels.
1:10:11 For each department, as well as capital project costs, so that the public could look at that 10, 11, 12 page budget and go, oh, okay, I understand. Thank you, John. Rick, clean up? Well, if you want the 15 minute version, go to my website, www.rickwood2010.com, you'll see all of the articles that I've written the last two years on the budget. It's pretty harsh. As you know, I'm highly critical of the budget process. One, it's not transparent.
1:10:42 When it isn't, it's easy to hide the ball. Two, we need a real forecaster. Kirk, you were right. We did a really good job on the operating side this last year. You know why? Because at the same time the Citizens Budget Committee that you and I were a member of that made six recommendations to council, none of which were followed, none of which have been followed, they hired an outside consultant for $15,000 who at the same meeting came to them and said,
1:11:08 You're budgeting too liberally. You're forecasting not conservatively enough. So they cut it back down another million bucks and sure enough produced a $91,000 surplus, which if you apply that against the $9 million they've overspent in the last two years, it's going to take 88 years to make it back up again. Thank you, Rick. All right, since we're on target here, we'll just keep plugging along. I have to bite my lip on the questions that I have as these go along, but staying on the town budget and also...
1:11:39 Our phone number is 934-8989, extension 350. I don't know if this is legible in front of me, but if anyone does have any comments they want to call in. Next question, Tony, you'll be first. There appears to be a projected town budget surplus for the fiscal year ending 6-30-10. The amount's between $500,000 and $600,000. If elected, what would you suggest the town do with this surplus? Put it into our REU. Thank you, Tony. Dawn? I agree.
1:12:11 Thank you. Matthew? If we have a surplus, I would invest that money into our DMO. I would put that towards marketing because I think that the marketing is reinvesting in ourself. By cutting our marketing short, we're effectively cutting off the head of a goose that lays a golden egg. We're not getting our tourists here in our town. So I would do all we can to get behind our DMO, get behind our marketing, get more people in town so we have more TOT dollars, we have more sales tax dollars.
1:12:40 And in the end, we have more dollars coming back to the town. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? I would agree with Tony and Don, but first, I'd like to be certain that we have a surplus. Thank you, Sharon. Alan? After definitely ascertaining surplus, I'd totally back up Matthew on that. We are a resort town, and the only way we survive is through marketing. Every time it rains, every time it snows.
1:13:06 Water is our lifeblood, and we are a resort town, and the best that we can do with any surplus is proper marketing and getting out there and advertising who we are and what we do, because that's, you know, we can't live here on our own, isolated. We rely on that fluctuating. You know, I don't know how many people we want to move in. We have a bunch of empty houses, but we need to fill up those hotels. We need to have hot beds, hot. Thank you, everyone. John?
1:13:36 Kirk Stapp and I, who cooks up here with me this evening, we go way back many, many years. The councils that we were on established for our town a limit or a baseline, if you will, on what the amount of money should be in our Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, the RU. That standard, if you will, was 25%. Today we're at 17%.
1:14:02 So we have a shortfall of approximately 1.5 million dollars in our RU. There's always going to be a priority of an individual or a council on how to spend revenue surpluses each year. Always going to be priorities, not to mention any priority that the town staff might have. So my full-on position and strong position
1:14:28 Is that we pay back the money that we borrowed in the last several years to our reserve funds, including the REU, first, and then after those reserve funds are replenished, then we can think about where we want to spend any additional surplus. Thank you. John. Rick? I agree with John and support that position as I have in the past. Back to the last question. One of the things that I would do is establish a budget oversight committee, such as something similar to a citizen's
1:14:57 Thank you, Rick.
1:15:19 The first thing would be to refund the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, get that back up to 25%. The second thing is that we've taken, to balance the budget over the last two years, we've taken money out of several different reserves, things that, you know, our insurance reserve are the money that was allocated for a
1:15:43 The Council, after you have replenished your reserves, then we can begin to look at, okay, if there's $600,000, but it should be a Council decision. I really agree with that. So if you're under budgeting,
1:16:09 And there are reserves after all the capital projects have been funded, then you can go ahead and say, we need to do this, we need to do this, the public is asking for this. Thank you. And we were informed that this isn't showing up on TV, so for those of you watching on TV, you can contact me at chamberforum at npgcable.com, or you may call in any questions at 934-8989, extension 350.
1:16:39 Don, you're going to be up on the next question. Would you support the cost of a DARE resource officer to be available for the school district? Yes. I think that investing in education, in our children, in the schools should be one of the most number one priorities within any given community. The DARE officer, when I heard last year, I don't know if it was when I heard last year that the grant money
1:17:09 The monies did run out for that individual. It saddened me, and I think it's a sad and upsetting, I guess, to see the lack of having that entity and that person on school campus. So I would definitely support it. Thank you, Dawn. Matthew? I'd be in favor of seeing an officer there for a number of purposes.
1:17:32 I wouldn't limit it just for dare. You know, we read in a paper recently about, or at least I've read some stuff on the Facebook pages about kids being bullied and things of that nature in school. These are a spectrum of problems we have there. So I think having an officer from our current staff being there would be a solution. I wouldn't limit it to just dare. But yes. Thank you. Sharon? I think I concur with everything you've just said.
1:18:01 Dare officers work. It's a real good role model for our children, and I think that would be an excellent thing to do. I don't know if this would be a full-time person. I might have difficulty with that, but perhaps this would be a good opportunity to hire a reserve officer who could be in the schools maybe once or twice a week. I'm not sure it's a full-time position. Thank you, Sharon. Alan?
1:18:31 I think we should have a full-time position. On top of bullying, you never know when a situation is going to happen. You need an officer who the kids have faith and trust in. You need an officer who knows the lay of the land. So we don't, anytime it, God forbid we should have any things like that happen in Colorado or any other school shootout, but you need an officer that knows the layout of that school. You can't be unfamiliar with it. And I think
1:19:00 If we have a good officer there, the DARE+, it does instill confidence and faith in the police community, and I absolutely do think we should have an officer there full time. Thank you, Alan. John? Personally, I think we can have our cake and eat it too. As was mentioned earlier this evening, we have a cyclical, seasonal period of time in Mammoth Lakes, so there are slack times where we have an abundance of officers.
1:19:29 So, and again, it's not a full-time position. It's a part-time position by definition at the school. So we can make use of our officers that we have during those slow times. The other thing is if you have to keep in mind we're a small community and our police department currently is located I think about three blocks from the school. So if there's an immediate need
1:19:57 As identified by the school administration or a teacher, we can have an officer there within five minutes easily to address the problem. And I would not support a full-time paid DARE officer position within our police department. Thank you. Thank you. John Rick? Yes, provided the budget is not increased. Thank you. Kirk? I don't think it's a full-time position. I think especially at the elementary school and the middle school, absolutely, there needs to be a part-time officer there.
1:20:28 When kids are in the high school, an officer has a sworn duty to carry out the law and enforce the law, and at the same time, he's trying to be a teacher, and there's an inherent conflict with that. The students certainly see it, and they resent sometimes, and then they sometimes use the officer. It's very complex, the relationship between the officers. Some officers can handle it very well, and some don't.
1:20:56 So I would support, strongly support at the elementary and especially at the middle school where the bullying does take place. But at the high school, I think John is absolutely correct. I mean, if there is an incident occurring at the high school, then that officer can be there, and they have been there within two minutes. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Well, you know, I think the DARE program was actually initiated by Chief Daryl Gates in L.A. quite a number of years ago.
1:21:24 It's been a very effective program throughout California for all these years. I have two nephews that went through our school system here, and the DARE program is designed for our elementary school and middle school. So I do support that. I think that would be a great way to continue our working relationship with the school district, and I'd like to see the county come on board also in partially funding an officer. It is a part-time.
1:21:50 It's a great thing for our children. And as for the bullying in that, yeah, I think that's something that we really need to take and work with the school board. If there's a role for us to play there, then we should. And again, I think the county needs to play a role with us all too in this. Okay, thank you. Matthew, you're going to be on the next one, and it's from the audience. I'm going to try and summarize three of them here, but would you support a blue ribbon commission to develop alternatives for the town's recreation?
1:22:19 Thank you.
1:22:44 I'm not familiar with the Blue Ribbon Commission, but we do have to do something with our recreation department. I fully support the DMO getting all the Measure A money, but we do have to do something to accommodate recreation. Having been a kid growing up here and playing Little League and playing on softball teams and things like that, it's an important part of our community. We have to have something for it.
1:23:11 Thank you. Sharon?
1:23:38 We have to have a recreation department and it has to be in our town budget. I would like to see a recreation commission as we have now, TNR, but I want the recreation, obviously the tourism is going to be taken over by the DMO, but we need a recreation department and a commission of citizens just like we've always had. And I don't want to see that go away.
1:24:04 The Recreation Department simply has to be funded in our general fund just like it's always been. I mean like it has had its money in the past and we need to keep this going. I think our children, all our recreational activities are necessary to a town that almost in some ways depends on recreation. That's why a lot of us are here.
1:24:33 We have to have it. Thank you, Ellen. Yes, our children are our future. And there's so much education you can do through recreation. The DMO, there's already a restructuring going on. DMO is going to get a lot of Measure A money, but I'm not sure they should get it all. I think a part of the Measure A monies and the general fund should be dedicated to wards, especially through the off-school times.
1:25:03 Creating tournaments, other things that are happening up in the village. I think I'd like to see more of the functions that happen in the village. The concerts and stuff also have a bunch of kids' recreations and games more structured towards educating them through recreation. Definitely as the DMO and the tour rec gets reorganized, we should definitely have a committee that continues to provide for
1:25:33 Entertainment and Recreation for our children. Thank you, Alan. John? I absolutely would support a Blue Ribbon Commission to help with the reorganization of our Recreation Department. I also would absolutely support 100% of the Measure A funding to go to the new DMO. Without 100% of the funding, the DMO would stand a less likely chance of being successful.
1:26:03 And now that we're transitioning, we need to do our very best to make sure that the DMO is successful. So I would support 100% going to the DMO. On the other hand, with this transition of park and recs and tourism changing and separating from each other and going with the DMO, our recreation department is very financially vulnerable.
1:26:26 And I have, in my own mind, I haven't shared it with anyone, but I have found areas of the budget for next year where we can find money to help supplement the budget money for the Park and Recreation Department. Thank you. John, Rick? Well, Bill Sauser is standing in the back, and he knows that I chaired the Parks and Recreation Commission way back when, before it was the Tourism and Recreation Commission for five years. That's...
1:26:55 Really at my core. It's astonishing to me. This is one of those, are you kidding me questions? Why would we take the Recreation Department as we have? The Town Manager has terminated the directorship. The Parks and Recreation or Tourism and Recreation Commission is now in jeopardy. How is it when we combined this five or six years ago?
1:27:17 Combine the two commissions, tourism and recreation, how is it that once tourism goes away, and it's appropriate for that to be privatized, that you would ignore recreation and deliver it into the hands of public works? They're good people, there's nothing wrong with public works folks, but they're not recreation folks. So I'm highly supportive of whatever we can do to keep this intact and have the leadership that is necessary. I don't see a difference between tourism and recreation. Thank you, Rick. Kirk?
1:27:47 I strongly support Measure A funding going to the DMO. People voted for those tax increases, and that's why they voted for it. So, you know, specifically for marketing. The councils over the years have never reneged on that.
1:28:02 As to privatizing Parks and Rec, Parks and Rec loses money. They provide services for the community, for our kids and everything else. Those services keep our kids out of trouble. If they're playing soccer, they're not hanging out someplace and doing things that we don't want them to do. So I strongly support.
1:28:23 A Parks and Recreation Commission, and if we need a Blue Ribbon Committee to begin to argue and to lobby the council to make sure that they're getting their funding to make sure that, you know, again, the programs don't fall to the wayside or anything else. I can't say enough. I think that Parks and Rec is extremely important for our community. Thank you, Kirk. Tony?
1:28:48 Well, folks, first, if you go to my website, www.barrett-2010.com, go to my Facebook page on discussions, you'll find a seven-page discussion of a reorganization for our town government, which Parks and Rec is part of that. On the DMO with Measure A, absolutely, we need to fund our DMO to the best possible outcome that we can have. We need to be competitive with the other markets throughout the resorts of the western United States, and Measure A funds aren't going to even bring us to that level.
1:29:18 So if you go to that page, you can see what I'm proposing, and I think that we need to fund that DMO over and above Measure A. Recreation is a lifeblood for us. It is no different than tourism. And it is just what we can do for our community over the next years of bringing recreational activities here, lacrosse, soccer, baseball, other activities that we can bring if we have the fields to do it, we have the funds to do it and market it. People come to our community for the environment and for recreation.
1:29:47 Thank you, Tony. Dawn? First of all, I'm not really sure why we combine park and rec and tourism together to begin with. It's my experience living in Southern California. Municipalities all have a park and rec department, and it's a great way. It gears towards not so much the visitor, but it's geared toward the people that live within the community. So I would support a Blue Urban Committee because I think that there's going to be a transition period.
1:30:17 Thank you, Don. You know, a follow-up to that, and since the audience proposed that, and there's some other comment on the cards, I've traveled, we've all traveled, and we've gone with our kids to tournaments, and we've seen the amount of lodging that can be generated by athletic things that happen in a community. Should our parks and rec be
1:30:48 Part of our DMO? Or should the DMO have the Parks and Rec operating under it and receive the funding for that? So I'm going to throw that question out there as a follow-up to this one. Should our Parks and Rec become part of the DMO? And Sharon, you'll be first on that. I don't think so. I mean, we're just trying to separate tourism and marketing, tourism and recreation.
1:31:16 And I think the DMO needs to be aimed at marketing for all of Mammoth. And if there isn't a recreational event, certainly it would come under the DMO. But I want our recreation department to stand firmly alone. And if we do need this commission to get them going, although what's wrong with the current recreation commission that we have? It seems to me they're the ones that have been participating all these years in that department.
1:31:45 And that on that commission and they need to be utilized to direct our rec parks and rec in the future. But no, I don't want to see the Recreation Department under the DMO is what I think I heard you say. That was the question. Thank you, Sharon Allen. Well, this will save some time for me on the three-minute wrap-up and I started to go back. What I meant by sharing the funds is in a way the DMO, part of that marketing.
1:32:12 We should be looking at how we're going to bring other children into our...
1:32:33 My answer would be that probably not. We should probably not combine them. Again, it's my
1:33:02 Opinion that we can adequately fund both the DMO by providing 100% of Measure A funds and our town park and recreation department within our existing budget, if you will. Thank you, John. Rick? My answer is no. Kirk? The important thing about Parks and Rec is that they lobby the council for activities and funds and everything else. So they are very focused about our kids.
1:33:32 That said, there's a close relationship between parks and rec and bringing guests into the community. So the DMO, somebody should just pick up the phone and say, we're having an activity and we need to use the parks or the services or whatever it happens to be. We're a small community. I'm quite sure they...
1:33:51 Whoever's going to be the Executive Director of the DMO and Parks and Rec should be in constant communication. But I strongly believe that Parks and Rec should stand alone. They should be able to lobby the council for money and for funds and for capital projects that benefit our community, our kids, our adults, as well as the guests that come to our community. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? The answer is no about privatizing or putting it with the DMO.
1:34:18 You know, folks, recreation, as I said earlier, it's huge for us. We need to capitalize on it. We need to implement our parks plan. We need to look at dog parks for our town. We need to look at starting negotiations and working with the county to look at the Hart-Howerton plan and what was proposed for Main Street at the opening to our entrance to the town of ball fields.
1:34:39 We have always looked at recreation as being a huge resource for us, and we need to implement all the work that's been going on for the many years that we've all been here. And we can do so by having a restructuring. Recreation stays part of the town government. And I'm not saying we need to hire a new director, because we have very capable people that could actually run what's going on now and implement the parks plan and everything else that goes along with it. Thank you, Tony. Dawn?
1:35:07 Park and Rec, I believe Park and Rec is best suited to be operated by the town, and that should not be combined with the DMO. And when we're talking about recreation, the DMO is geared toward marketing to our visitor, and that's a different type of recreation than, I believe, the Park and Rec.
1:35:25 Recreation under park and rec in a municipality is geared toward the community, to the children that are here, the adult softball leagues, the soccer leagues, the, yeah, so in any case, I would definitely not combine the two. Thank you. Matthew? No, I would not combine them. DMO is for marketing. And I would add just to what John had said.
1:35:55 We're already underfunded in our marketing department. If you look at other towns and communities, we're about half, if not less, than where a lot of other competing communities are as far as our marketing budget. We have to remember that marketing and driving tourism to our town is the engine that drives our town. If we start taking away from our DMO now, the long-term result is we're going to be taking away from...
1:36:22 From our entire budget in the long term. So I would not combine them. Great. Thank you. A caller asked to explain DMO. DMO stands for Destination Marketing Organization. In the 80s we called it a resort association. And that's what the town is moving towards to take our marketing independent of the town government and into an organization that will be funded through the town but run independently. I hope I have that right, John.
1:36:51 Funded through the town via Measure A, yes. Via Measure A, thank you. All right, one last question in between town budget and town planning, but beside, and Sharon, you'll start on this one. Beside yourself, what? Excuse me, I started the last one. Did you start, I'm sorry, Alan? It's hard for me to keep track, it's, you know. Okay, Alan, you'll start this one. Beside yourself, Alan, what two candidates would you like to serve with on town council?
1:37:19 I knew that one was going to come up. Easy, easy now. Going with Precious, and I would, I really respect what Matthew has done for bringing what was considered a big onus on the town for revitalizing and rejuvenating downtown.
1:37:51 The Village. It's just been a phenomenal recovery for that area. And so that gives me a lot of faith that he knows marketing, that he knows the outreach going forward. Myself, obviously. Having not been in town for almost two decades and then coming back, seems like everybody else has had, except...
1:38:19 For Don has had a swing here on Town Council, so there's a lot of experience there. All right, thank you. And just looking for new blood. Wrap it up for me. Have to flip a coin on the rest. Okay. You know, if I'm fortunate enough to get re-elected, which I would absolutely love, if I'm fortunate enough, I would be happy to serve with any of the two individuals that are sitting up here with me this evening.
1:38:49 Thank you. John, Rick? I think the community – well, first of all, let me have a mild rebuttal with respect to the revival of the village. It is the tenants. It is the tenants of the village. And I represented 17 of the 20 who were the architects of its revival. It was the tenants who deserved the credit. Rick, are you done? No. No. Okay.
1:39:19 This community is looking for balance, always has votes for balance. I believe that's the case. I'd serve with anybody here. Thank you very much. And just so the audience knows, this is a forum, so we will keep this in control. There won't be questions directly from the audience. Please feel free to fill out a card, and I'll be glad to try to fit it in. Kirk? I would gladly serve with anybody up here. However, I would very much like to have really smart people and people that do their homework. As we know you always have, Kirk. Tony?
1:39:49 Well, first of all, I would never even consider answering a question like that in that framework. You know, if I'm fortunate enough that you, the community, feels that I should work for you for the next four years, I will work with anyone else that you also elect, and I would work with any of these folks, and I'm going to rely on the community to make that decision. Thank you. Dawn? It's not about who I want to sit with. It's about who the community chooses.
1:40:16 And we think it would be the best three candidates to sit here and serve the community. I'd be happy to sit with any of the seven other candidates. Thank you, Don. Matthew? Well, I'm going to be just as indecisive as everybody here, but I will say I'm about new blood. And I'll address that in my closing statement. But there's a very good panel of candidates up here. And if I sat with any of them, I'd be happy. Getting back to the village, by the way.
1:40:45 Rick's right. That was a group effort. And I try to make that very clear every time that people have given me praise. I was one spoke in the wheel. There are a lot of people to thank up there for the revival of that village. The tenants are, in my opinion, the largest thanks needs to go out to them. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area really stepped up to the plate and did a lot as well.
1:41:16 And I think that a lot of kudos also need to be given to C&L and InterWest. I know a lot of people haven't done that in the past, but it's very difficult in a leasing position to have a owner really listen to what the market's doing and listen to their consultants that they've hired. So there's a lot of thanks that needs to go around there. Thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? First of all, four of us up here have never served on Mammoth Lakes Town Council.
1:41:44 I would love to serve, and I look forward to the community finding two more people for me to serve with. So one thing I'd like to do, if you don't mind, since I'm at the end of this question, one thing we've done with energy efficiency is replace the lights in this room. These lights do not need, only the linear lights need to be on.
1:42:08 All right. Well, we can.
1:42:39 Thank you.
1:43:09 Thank you, Tom. First of all, the town of Mammoth Lakes has a general plan. We have...
1:43:40 Some neighborhood plans, we have specific plans, yada yada. We have planning in the community. I would support the plans that are in place. Having said that, we have some shortfalls too. We need zoning updates for neighborhoods, well, for the community and neighborhoods as well in Mammoth Lakes.
1:44:05 And zoning is one of the areas that we need to resolve, hopefully within the next 12 months. Having said that, my basic initial plan would be certainly to follow the general plans and the guidelines of the general plan. In that general plan, there are three things, the environment, social, and economic.
1:44:31 Items that are important to the community, and I would look for balance between those three items. Thank you very much. John. Rick? Well, I think we spent five years on the general plan. It is a grand vision. It lacks specificity, and we're not done with the specific district plans, which is quite frankly unfortunate, but it is what it is, and we're getting there. As soon as we get there, of course, we'll change them. But really, over the years,
1:45:02 Thank you, Rick. Five years on a general plan.
1:45:30 District plans. We have specific plans. We have all of these plans that have been put in place, and it seems that they are in conflict with each other. So if I was fortunate enough to be elected, I would certainly be putting emphasis on trying to get all these plans lined up where they're speaking with one voice instead of having CBiz telling
1:45:50 The planning commission to do one thing and you have a specific plan that is saying another and you're coming back to council on a height issue or whatever. So these plans, all of our grand plans seem to be in conflict with each other. The triple bottom line I support, the economy, the social and the environmental. And I think that council needs to have, whichever council is elected, needs to have a discussion about
1:46:18 How do we walk through this? We have so many projects out there that have not been completed. Council needs to set some priorities, like are we going to finish Trails in Park first or are we going to finish the ice rink first? That brings guests into the community. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Well, folks, as it was said, five years on the general plan. We adopted it in 2007. As a sitting planning commissioner, I and my fellow commissioners have repeatedly asked our current council
1:46:47 to give a work priority to staff to amend our zoning so that it matches the current general plan and our current council has failed to do that. My first priority, if I'm fortunate enough to be elected by you, is to ensure that our zoning updates are done immediately. We have a committee right now that myself and Jay Dankin sit on along with three other community members. Jim Smith, Bruce Woodward is on that committee, Dave Harvey, and we can get that job done. We've decided...
1:47:16 At recent meetings, we could get it done within two months. We can get it done, but our zoning must get in line with the general plan, then take our general plan goals, match them to a budget, and we'll make the community what everyone has been looking for. And let's do it before we have to go and review the general plan in two years. Amen to that. Dawn? Well, I had the pleasure of sitting on the general plan committee.
1:47:39 For those years. And right now I think that we need to complete the district plans based on what the outcome of the general plan is. I agree with Tony, the zoning issues, the zoning is a little bit outdated and we need to update that. And once the district plans are complete, we'll be able to identify what and where certain things can be built.
1:48:05 So when a developer comes into town, there won't be 50 plus meetings because they'll know exactly what they're allowed to build in that location that they're looking to purchase. Thank you, Don. Matthew? It would be nice to have a lot clearer vision of what we're supposed to be doing and planning. I like the idea of having neighborhood or district plans because every little area of town is a little bit different. I like that we're incorporating...
1:48:31 Things such as resolutions such as PIEC, PAOT into our zoning or into our plans. The only problem is if you look at PAOT at 52,000 people and you look at our zoning, if we were to potentially build every property out to its full capacity, we'd be exceeding these. So it gets a little bit ambiguous as to where we're going.
1:48:54 On a wish list, I would like us to see us incorporate a large events venue somewhere. I think this is going to be a very important key issue moving forward. If you look at Coachella and areas like that, these are aspects of their community that will largely drive tourism and drive their economies. Thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? I agree with Kirk.
1:49:19 That our district plans are absolutely necessary. I wish we had done that immediately after our general plan. Then we would know what goes where. Our developers would know, and they wouldn't have to waste time, energy, and money trying to figure it out. But we have so little land left to develop that whatever we approve, whatever we build, should be what we need, be really unique.
1:49:48 Spectacular and distinctive for our little remote village in the trees. It must fit with our small town character. Together we can do this, but only if you, the public, are involved in the process and only if the new town council will listen to you and work with you and act for you. Thank you, Sharon. Erwin?
1:50:15 Yeah, it's getting the general plan finalized with zoning, the district zoning. Any future construction definitely needs to be LEED certified, LEED. We have to look at our energy consumption. Dreams, yeah, we need to get that rink covered. We need to find out where the rink's going to be. We need to make that decision. We need to get that thing covered. I'd love to see a 3,000-plus person amphitheater, having been a part of Earth Dance and Reggae on the River, and seeing how much that did for...
1:50:45 Little community towns. I'd like to see the Mammoth Motocross Track open once a month from Thursday to Sunday all year long. We should be doing professional snowmobile races out there. ESPN would be here. It's only, you know, not 24-7, 365, but one weekend a month from Thursday to Sunday. Again, I'm looking for a grant to get this year at Wildlife Sanctuary.
1:51:11 Bears and Coyotes and Cougars, oh my, more family oriented venues, including a 3D IMAX theater. Thank you, Alan. Tom, real quick on a brief rebuttal, if you will. Okay, okay, thank you. I just wanted to clarify for the community and those people present. On the one hand, the town of Mammoth Lakes are planning, we get criticized for not getting zoning.
1:51:38 District plans, whatever it is, accomplished in a timely manner. And then on the other hand, as been mentioned several times tonight, it took us five years of a public process to get our general plan through. And it also took Old Mammoth Place five years and 60 meetings to get that application through. So we can't really have it both ways. We have to allow the public
1:52:06 To have a full vetting of whether it's the general plan or whether it's an application like Old Mammoth Place. Since I've given John a rebuttal opportunity for our vision of the future of Mammoth, anyone else care to? Tony? Yeah, you know, I just want to make clear to you, when I just mentioned about the current council, I want to exclude John from that because I tell you, John's been on the one vote for one vote on most of the work programs coming forward.
1:52:34 For Planning Commission, and I just want to give him credit that he saw the value of what we need to get done for Planning Commission, so. Sharon? While we're rebutting, you must remember that four of the people up here spent five years trying to get the last general plan done. I don't think that's necessary. I really do not. I think if we are listening to our public and we are acting on their behalf,
1:53:03 We will get things done in a timely manner, including the district plans. Thank you. Thank you, Sharon. Anyone else on the vision? Only three years for me on the general plan. Thank you. And myself also, only three. All right. I think, Sharon, you were part of the public on that, too. Moving into planning and community development, Rick, you're going to start with this one. Do you feel the current general plan is being implemented in the spirit that the community expected?
1:53:34 Or adhered to at all? Could you repeat that, please? Do you feel the current general plan is being implemented in the spirit that the community expected or adhered to at all? Well, you know, that's an interesting question because we've had one major development project since the general plan was adopted and that was without changing or updating the zoning regulations or completing the district plan.
1:54:01 It's difficult to know on a town-wide basis whether the spirit that was envisioned at the time has been adhered to. I made a principled objection to the Old Mammoth Place project. That's the only project that has come forward since 2007. And it was because
1:54:27 And not because I was specifically unhappy with height, density, traffic, water, but simply because I was unhappy with the fact that it took 60 meetings, unfair to the community, unfair to the planning commission, unfair to the developer to get that project done. And in the end, I didn't like the deal that was cut. Thank you. Rick. Kirk? Could you read the question one more time? Do you feel the current general plan is being implemented in the spirit that the community expected or adhered to at all?
1:54:58 There's breakdowns, and I'll still look at PISC. PISC is his project impact. PISC was designed to look at the entire impact of the community. The way it was implemented is that it was looked at Old Mammoth Place in isolation. If it's implemented that way, what happens is that whoever comes in first with an application for development, they're the ones that are going to get the density.
1:55:26 You look at density or they're going to get the, you know, whatever it happens to be. Pisces is a tool, you know, looking at impacts that is supposed to look at the whole community. Where does the density belong? Not, okay, can the town handle this density in relationship to this single project?
1:55:46 There are breakdowns not only with PISCES, but there's also breakdowns with CBIS and other public policies that are in conflict with each other. So they're not being implemented correctly. And just for our viewers out there so they don't have to call, PISCES stands for, help me out because I can't remember. Let's see. Evaluation criteria. Thank you. Tony? Well, folks, you know our general plan, we...
1:56:17 Got it all completed. We thought we knew we were on the right track. Then we started developing district plans, PISC, CBIS, all of the other solutions that we're trying to bring to the table with it. And what we did is we made it very convoluted, just like we've done with our budget. So what we need to do is we need to go back with our community and do our jobs and the staff needs to do their jobs of working with the community to educate and be able to understand every part of the general plan and how it relates.
1:56:46 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:57:15 And the spirit that was adopted. Thank you. Tony? Dawn? To answer the question, I would say yes in using Old Mammoth Road Place as an example. The Community Development Department along with the Planning Commission did their due diligence. And I believe that in this case, our general plan was implemented well, but that's not to say that the process itself could not be a little bit clearer. Thank you, Dawn. Matthew? I think generally speaking, the spirit is being followed. Certainly there's going to be some flaws.
1:57:45 Along the way, we have a number of different tools that we have been using to use at our disposal for the various projects, whether it be PISC, PAOT, or otherwise. From what I can see, it seems as though those tools were used to the best of their abilities to accomplish our most recent development, but certainly there are some disagreements. We did exceed height of what we really wanted to see.
1:58:13 And there were a number of other areas. But again, we're going to run into folks that just are not going to – there's no perfect development. There's no perfect project. So I think essentially, yes, we have followed it. And I think we also need to keep in mind that things change over time. Our wants and needs will change and evolve as we as a community evolve. So I think these need to be living documents that can evolve for our wants and needs. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? No, I do not think.
1:58:41 We have followed the spirit of our general plan. We do not think that the community thinks so. Or we wouldn't have had 500 people sign a petition well over a year ago that the Clearwater, aka Old Mammoth Place, was out of order, that it was too high, that it was too massive. All of those things they said and that fell on deaf ears on our town council.
1:59:08 So no, I do not think the general plan spirit has been followed. We have and want a village in the trees that is supported economic and try to support the triple bottom line, which is the economic health of the town, the social health of the town, and the environmental health of the town are very important to all of us. Thank you, Sharon. Ellen?
1:59:34 Well, if I do get elected to Town Council, I'm glad I won't have to go through the last five years. It has been an arduous process, and I think one of the reasons it has, the general plan has come down to what it was, was because there was a serious amount of the community that does not want to see anything over three stories tall. Our village and the trees to maintain our rusticity. As was mentioned, and I said in the final appeal,
2:00:02 There is, at this point in time, there is no other development on the horizon. They're not knocking down the doors. And people, they're not necessarily against development. They're just, like I said, it just seems a lot of the people that I talk to in the community, they look at the Menash and they say, we don't want another thing like that. That one's done. We realize that four stories can be hidden in the trees.
2:00:27 From what I gather from the community, they do not want to see things over three stories tall. That doesn't mean we can't develop. That doesn't mean we can't go forward as a world-class destination resort. But I don't think we need to do it with big, tall buildings. Thank you, Alan. John? A portion, a large portion of the general plan that the town has today has a point in it, and that's the triple bottom line, and you're going to hear more about it, and you're probably already tired of hearing that phrase, triple bottom line.
2:00:55 But the triple bottom line, if you can visualize, is a stool that has three legs. And those three legs of the stool are social values, economic values, and financial values. And in the general plan, it instructs us as a community to balance those three values. The problem is that some individuals may balance economic value more than they value something else. Someone might
2:01:25 Value, environmental values, more than social or financial values. So, again, it's not a black and white issue, it's a balance of those three, and therein lies the conflict of balancing those three, and the challenge. Thank you, John. The next question I'm going to group together, since it's part of what you just all answered. PAOT has been discussed for years as part of our general plan number in the 52,000 range.
2:01:56 PAOT stands for people at one time. How rigid do you think the town should hold to this number? The other part to the question, how would you feel if the town built to 62,000 but that number only was exceeded or met, say, eight days per year, the main holidays? I think we have to hold to the PAOT very, very tightly, and the reason being is air quality and water availability.
2:02:23 If you talk to people that are sitting on the water board, the person that's sitting right over there, he might have a few things that he wants to tell you about the limited capacity that we have to provide water. When you start going 500 rooms above that, then you are now beginning to impact the quality of life of the rest of the community. So there is some limits unless we're willing to spend about $20 million, maybe $30 million to go over to Dry Creek.
2:02:53 And fight a 30-year battle, environmental battle, to bring that water over into Mammoth Lakes. So we have some limits. So the PAOT was designed partly to address the water and air quality issue. And so it's really important. The other thing, I compliment John for bringing up the fact that when the bell-shaped parcel was zoned open space,
2:03:20 He was the one council person that says, hey, we need to talk about POT. What happens to that POT? Do we just leave it float out there, or should we drop it down to 51.5? Thank you, Kirk. Tony? You know, folks, for the time period we're in, and I would say for the next five to seven years, we're going to see very little development happening. When we get the investment market back, when the markets turn around and folks start looking at that, it's going to be a very good question at this time.
2:03:49 I think we need to hold it to 52. It's what we stated. It's what we've been working with on Planning Commission. The issues that are coming up are because you have so many other developments down the line, and is it a first come, first serve? So I think at this time, we stick to the 52, and at such time in the future, when it would come up with a future council, then we need to readdress it and look at what the best opportunities are and what direction we should take. Thank you, Tony. Dawn? It seems to me the PA...
2:04:18 PAOT at 52,000 is established based on resources, water, sewer, things that build out this community might be taxed on. I think we need to keep it at the 52,000 at this point. But it is kind of a weird question, I think, and I've always thought it was very strange.
2:04:39 Because I don't know that there's ever going to be a day and there might be just like maybe five days out of a whole year where we'll even have that many people in town. And I think people need to not be as fixated on 52,000 people because it's not 52,000 people here 24-7. It's going to be a very, very short period of time if and when that ever happens. Thank you, Don. Matthew? I think it's important to try and stick with a number largely based on our infrastructure and our water capabilities.
2:05:08 And our other environmental needs. Another thing to consider is, let's say we have 62,000 and it's only for eight days a year. If we build out to accommodate those people, what does happen the rest of the days of the year? If we don't have those people in town, if we have a larger, more spread out town, we may miss out on the synergy that we are supposed to try to accommodate when we have a development project. If you look at the village, if you don't have the synergy of...
2:05:36 All the other restaurants in place and whatnot, you have something that's not really working. So if we spread our town out too much because we're trying to accommodate too many people, we may run into a problem later and we may start running into other issues, you know, missing out on our feet first. We may have to start traveling further distances to reach another retail store or our shopping needs and things of that nature. So I think it's important that we try and stick with a certain number and try to build our development plans and our district plans around that number.
2:06:06 Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? I'm going to try this mic. Yes, 52,000 is an absolute number as far as I'm concerned. We have 35,000 in town now, maybe what, seven, ten days a year, top? And I don't know about you, but the trails are crowded in the summertime. The mountain is maxed out on those peak days. I've been told it's sometimes dangerous.
2:06:32 On the mountain, I'm not a downhill skier, I don't know that for certain, but I have been told the mountain is maxed out. Have you ever been to Vons at 3 o'clock or 4 o'clock in the afternoon? And we've never had more than 35,000 people in town at one time. If we have an appropriate transit system, those people won't be in their cars, and that will help, but I definitely think...
2:07:01 We need to stay at $52,000. Thank you, Sharon. Alan? Yeah, I'm definitely in agreement with that. We'll forbid that we should ever hit consistently up to $35,000, $40,000 because I don't know if I'd ever go shopping at Vaughn's again. When it gets up to that level, town is just, it's not town anymore. And for those of us that live here consistently, boy, when we hit those days, those are the days I don't go skiing.
2:07:28 Because it's just, it's too crowded. Traffic on certain days in July and around President's Day between Christmas and New Year's. I just prefer to stay home. At this point in time, I really don't have that much of a complaint about our transit trolley system. That's one of the reasons why I decided to stay in Mammoth because you have a very viable transit system that can get you all over town.
2:07:57 I am concerned about big developments because I don't want them to preclude a monopoly so that others that come in won't be able to have that water, won't be able to build what they'd like to build that would increase our destination resort. Thank you, Alan. John? I believe that 52,000 people at one time is a legitimate and appropriate number for us to adhere to and to gear all of our environmental, social,
2:08:27 And financial values towards. The number 52,000 is somewhat arbitrary, yet at the same time we need a number, and it's 52,000, because it creates stability for those people or those organizations to work towards whether they're providing the appropriate air quality for us, the appropriate
2:08:57 Traffic levels within the community or the appropriate amounts of water and sewer infrastructure facilities that we'll need. So, yes, 52,000 is an appropriate and stabilizing number. Thank you. John, Rick? Tom, Bill Taylor, who was formerly with the planning department for many years has often said to me, the number doesn't matter. It's not the number, it's the capacity.
2:09:25 My two cents worth on the 52,000 is, one, it's a political decision that was made. The community made it, and the council should adhere to it unless conditions change. Two, and it's important to remember, it's arbitrary in the sense that it's based upon an assumption of how many people are going to stay in a unit or in a room, in a hotel room, in a three-bedroom condo, a two-bedroom condo.
2:09:49 We don't actually know how many people. We think we know, but that number is based, in fact, on capacity. And so the bottom line is that, yes, I support the 52,000, but on the other hand, I would de-emphasize the reliance on this absolute number that seems to have controlled the conversation over these years. Thank you, Rick. Tony, you'll be first on the next question, and it'll be the final question on town planning and community development. And I really am going in order.
2:10:19 Old Mammoth Place has had 50-plus meetings at the Planning Commission and Town Council. The developer has spent huge sums of money and presented countless options for his project. We just finished an appeal to the Town Council. Is this how the process should work for large projects? Do you see any flaws in this process? And if so, what would you like to see changed? You know, first of all, it was a very long process, as we've all stated, many meetings.
2:10:49 But it was necessary. This was the first project that we had our feet on the ground with, getting our feet wet, if you will, of the new general plan, district planning, CBIS, PI-C, and every other policy that went along with it. Many of the beginning meetings started over the general plan and district planning. So for the future, we have learned so much from going through this process that we know how to streamline it. We know what the questions are to ask now.
2:11:19 And we know how to proceed. If you look at our town and you look at what's left to develop and what has to come forward with approvals, unless we have a complete remodel of Main Street and we do take everything down and go by the Hart-Howerton plan, you're not going to see very large developments like this coming forward. There's really not the large capacity of land for that. You have the three corners at the village, which has already gone through the process.
2:11:47 You have the shady rest track, which is going to be affordable housing. It's already been defined as that. So was it long? Was it something that was just kind of uneasy and costly for the developer? Yes. But it was necessary for us to understand how to get through the process. And now we understand it. So now we can move forward with it. Thank you. Tony. Dawn? Yeah, the process was really long. And I commend the applicant for having stayed in it.
2:12:15 As he did and followed through. While there were that many meetings, those meetings were not all 100% about Old Mammoth Place. They had to do with Old Mammoth Place in the outcome, but there were issues, as Tony was talking about, as Tony was saying, there were things that were related to this project that had never come up before. So it was hashing out, you know, CBiz and other things that this project being the first one on board.
2:12:44 After the general plan was complete and having to make some decisions, policy issues, decide on policy issues is what I think made that such a long, arduous process. Thank you, Don. Matthew? As far as how the process should work, I think that the steps were appropriate that were taken. We put it before the public.
2:13:11 We get public input. The developer addresses the issues. We bring it back and try to hash out a lot of the items and the issues that affect our community. So in that sense, yes. But I think that the process was far too long. It should have been far more efficient.
2:13:28 And to say that we are going to learn from this experience effectively at the cost of developer, in my opinion, is also wrong. Because when it costs a developer in the long term, it ends up costing us as well. Those people are there. There's a bottom line that they're trying to meet. And if we drag it out for five years, we're not doing ourselves justice because they're certainly going to start fighting for more density and more rooms to accommodate all the losses that we have forced them to accumulate.
2:13:56 So we need to be more prepared. We need to be more efficient in our process. But as far as taking the steps we have and implementing a lot of the various tools at our disposal, yes, the process was affected that way. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? I don't think the fault was the town's. This particular developer changed partners, changed architects along the way.
2:14:24 Building and will build eventually a fine product. But he asked for a specific plan. In that sense, we could have asked him to wait until we, the town, got ready with our neighborhood district plan. But that didn't satisfy him. He still wanted more. So he came back and back. And not only did he get a specific plan, but then he got an amendment to that specific plan.
2:14:54 So I don't think you can lay the blame at the town's feet for 55 meetings. Granted, we were going through things, but we should have gotten our ducks in a row and then ask him to bring his project forward, and money would have been saved all around. Thank you. Alan? Well, as I mentioned, I came on board late on this.
2:15:20 It sounds to me like it was a very arduous process. I think a lot was learned. I don't think that should ever have to reoccur again. I'm very thankful that Mr. Demetriatus did stick with it. He had a lot of patience. I think a lot was learned for the town council. Also, I hope other developers paid attention to what happened. It's really helped bring the general plan to...
2:15:49 Getting close to finalized, I think there's a little bit more work to be done on it. I'm thankful that he was, in one way, he was the only developer, because if somebody else would have thrown another hat in the ring, I don't know how much more confusing that would have been. But since he did stick with that, and a lot of stuff did get finalized and focused,
2:16:08 That process, the way that went down should never have to reoccur again. I think it's definitely helped streamline things so that the next developer that does come, I believe the next town council is going to have it much easier because we'll be able to say, no, this is what we want and we've already been through that process, we're not going to do it again. Thank you. John? Tom, in answer to your initial question, yes, I believe that the process for the Old Ameth Place project was appropriate. As Kirk Stapp would say,
2:16:38 Or maybe it's President Woodrow Wilson. He wasn't around then, by the way, just for clarity. I remember it well. I'll let you say it. Democracy is messy. And this was a good example of that. This was the first project that had to go. This applicant waited for the conclusion of our general plan update process. This applicant waited.
2:17:07 For the neighborhood district plan process and this applicant waited for an update or revision if you will of the specific plan for the project based upon the neighborhood district plan. The point being is it was no win for this individual. He stuck it out and based upon our workload over the next 12 months with the planning department and the planning commission
2:17:32 The next applicant, whenever that may be or whoever that may be, will not have to go through this lengthy of a process. Thank you. Rick? You know, John, you and I agree on a lot of things. This one we don't. Uh-oh. You don't measure the quality of public outreach by the number of meetings. You don't leave it to the planning commission because you haven't spoken as a council with one voice after development of consensus to make policy. That's what's happened here.
2:18:02 And that's why the process went bad or wrong. What I think happened in this process is that it was backwards. Instead of the town going to the developer and saying, this is what we want, here's our list of amenities that this community has said it wants, and this is what it's going to cost, you tell us what you're going to put in in exchange for additional density. Instead, the developer comes to the town and says, this is the density that I must have, this is the only way this project can work financially.
2:18:32 And I'm willing to give you this that is an amenity in exchange for that. I would reverse it and never go through that process again. Thank you, Rick. Kirk? The appeal, which I was a part of, I signed the documents and everything else, the appeal was predicated on two things. One is the breakdown of the different policies from the specific plan to PISCES to CEQA to CBIS. So that was one part of it. Bill Taylor.
2:19:04 Went through systematically and pointed out where the policy was not implemented or followed or just simply ignored in the case of the economic analysis and that was the first part of it. The second part of the appeal was CBiz and that is a council policy to create community benefits for incentive zoning, the 244 rooms. Well, the CBiz policy trades away
2:19:32 DIF fees, affordable housing fees, and art fees in exchange for these community amenities. That policy needs to be revisited. And that is, you know, that's the starting place. The Council is meeting with the Planning Commission over a lot of these policies, and CBiz is one of the policies they've got to go back and review. All right. Thank you very much. I know this is a hot topic, but we do need to move on to DMO because we're running out of time.
2:20:01 Dawn, you'll be starting with this one. Do you support funding the DMO, Destination Marketing Organization, with Prop A money, or should this funding option be looked at? Well, back in 1986, Measure A money was voted on by the community for the council to put 100% of that money into marketing.
2:20:28 And so therefore, yes, that money, 100% of that money should go to the DMO, but that's not the only funding source that the DMO is going to need. They're going to need more money than that. And it should, in part, maybe with TOT, which is what currently the town is doing, is combining a percentage of TOT with Measure A money that is going into the tourism department. But there will need to be another funding source. Thank you, Dawn. Just to repeat the question, just so I make it clear, do you support funding the DMO?
2:20:58 With Prop A money or should this funding option be looked at? Matthew? Yes. Sorry. A little slow. Yes, we should be fully funding the DMO with Measure A funds and in addition to that I think we need to further find additional funds to add to the DMO and I think where those need to be found as I stated earlier is look to
2:21:29 The million to two million dollars that I believe that our town is missing out on based on TOT revenues that are not being captured properly due to folks that are renting their properties out online and not going through the proper process of paying taxes and whatnot. So I think it's very important that we get behind this DMO, as I stated earlier. It's critical to the livelihood of our town and I think the long term.
2:21:57 It will really add to the health of our community because we will further be able to fund other needs and wants that we have. So, yes. Thank you, Matthew. Sharon? Yes. I appreciate the short answer so we can get more questions in. Alan? Yes, that's what the voters voted for, and I think that's what Town Council needs to listen to. That's why the restructuring is happening, where tourism and rec is shifting away. We can have all the tour and rec we want, but without...
2:22:26 Seriously focusing on marketing our town, we're just going to go on business as usual and we'll never reach that number of 52,000 PAOT. Measure R and Measure U and also the American Recoveries and Restructuring Act monies that we'll be able to leverage with the Measure U and Measure R's. We'll take care of the tourism and rec and we'll be able to take care of our infrastructure.
2:22:51 Yes, I fully support Prop A for DMO, and if we have any other funds that we can pull in to help them achieve that, we definitely should do that. Thank you, Alan. John? I thought Don answered it well. Yes, 100% of the Measure A money should go to the DMO, funding the DMO. This is an ethical question. It's a black and white issue. It's Measure A, by definition, 100%. And it should not be looked at. I agree.
2:23:21 Thank you, Rick. Thank you. Tony, I agree, and then I want to take 30 more seconds of my time to clarify. And the last question, when we went through and we approved district planning, district planning was predicated on an applicant coming forward, they would start the process. So I want to clarify what Sharon had said. The applicant did not ask for that. It was what the town directed. The applicant...
2:23:46 Was a new owner. The process started with an original owner. Mr. Demetriatus outright purchased the property a couple years into it. Not as a corporation, as an individual. He asked to do a specific plan. That's an entitlement that he's allowed to ask for under state law and under our local laws. And it's what he should have done. We did not force him to do anything. He changed his designers because the community did not like, through public comment,
2:24:14 The way that that property was developing and the way it was proposed. So he brought in a new architect. So I just want to be clear. I don't like misinformation. It becomes factual. It's important that you know the true facts of that. Thank you. Thank you, Tony. Matthew, you'll get the next question, which is the DMO is projected to start with a budget of approximately $1.8 million from the town. Would you support giving the DMO more money, and if so, where would it come from?
2:24:42 Following up on the previous question, I would support giving additional funds, and I would support getting those funds from uncollected TOT monies. I'll leave it at that. Thank you. Sharon? I think I agree with you. Alan? Yeah, I definitely would like to, before we jump into any more funds, I'd definitely be watching and see what they do for this first bit of time with this restructuring.
2:25:13 Yes, we're definitely missing out on some monies that could be used for that, but I'd definitely like to see what they do here at this first phase and see how they do at this 1.8 and see how many people we start bringing in. Thank you, Alan. John? No, I would not support additional town funding from as yet unidentified funding sources. Thank you, John. Rick?
2:25:39 The 15-minute version is on my website. I would restructure government. There will be savings. And to the extent that it's a priority, and I think everybody up here says it is, additional money would go to the direct marketing organization. Thank you. If there is extra money, then it goes back into the REU or it goes back into the funds that were supposed to be set aside for capital projects.
2:26:03 And I do agree with Matthew that illegal renters need to be addressed, that whole issue, and there finally needs to just be a foot put down and say, hey, look, we've got to really look at this in depth. And if we have to look at it in parts of town, because we do have CC&Rs all over town, and each one of those would have to be evaluated. But illegal rentals, the mountain was up 10%.
2:26:29 In skiing, and yet our TOT continues to remain flat. So I think it's a big gap there and a huge funding source for the town which might go back to marketing. Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Yes, the answer is yes. And if you go to my website, you'll see we're under restructuring of town government where I also explain where that money can come from. You know, we are very low compared to funding for the DMO of any other DMO.
2:26:57 Okay. Thank you.
2:27:27 I started with Matthew on that one. Sharon, you'll be the next one. For 35 years, we've been talking about midweek and shoulder season business to stabilize the economy. Can any one of our candidates give us a clear idea of how to do this? Or a suggestion? Well, I think our DMO will help greatly. But also, as we develop our trails, and this, of course, is Measure U and Measure R, we develop opportunities.
2:27:58 For people to do things. This will help our midweek and shoulder season. I'm excited about the fact that Sierra Star opened their golf course this year for cross-country skiing. I think that kind of activity for the people who aren't on the hill, like me, who really will use the opportunity to use the trails in town and Mammoth
2:28:28 You know, it is doing the one out in Shady Rest. These are the kinds of activities that will help us. We've got to develop more of those, and I think we'll do it in the summertime with our trails. Thank you. Ellen? Again, this gets back to more than just skiing and pub crawling and trail running. Pub crawling? Pub crawling. Drinking. Cocktails? Getting that ice cream covered so we can have you around skating.
2:28:57 An amphitheater where we consistently miss great acts that go from Las Vegas, Serena, from LA to Portland. We don't get them because we don't have it. We don't have an amphitheater to stage them. With Billy Graham Productions and NES West, if you can't provide 1,500 in ticket sales, you don't get the security. If you don't get the security, you don't get the ban. Opening the Mammoth Motocross Track more than just once a year. Getting this here at Wildlife Sanctuary up.
2:29:26 More family oriented things like the 3D IMAX, biathlons, many things that we can do to create tournaments and cross country Nordic races. We should have more marathons this summer and just more things other than skiing and downhill BMX. Thank you, John.
2:29:48 This direct this relates directly to Measure U because Measure U by definition creates additional new amenities that we don't have might not have for a long time so measure you the passage of that would be a huge jump forward in increasing the seasonal not seasonal the the off times and weekend or midweek visitation
2:30:12 Another item that would increase those visitations would be expanded air service, both in the sense of expanding air service on a year-round basis as well as expanding to additional locations, whether it's Phoenix, Las Vegas, San Diego, etc. Thank you, John. Rick? John, you stole my line air service. In 2000, we went on a peer resort tour, a number of us. Rusty Gregory was there, was standing at the airport.
2:30:41 At Vail, Eagle County Airport, and the guy who developed air service there said it started with one flight. It went to two, it went to four, it went to eight, and so on. Prior to that, Vail was a weekend resort only, so I'd add air service to the mix. Thank you, Rick. Kirk? When somebody goes on vacation, they're looking for an experience, you know, skiing or whatever it happens to be, and so they want to be able to take that experience home and share it with other people. So I would start with a little different approach.
2:31:13 I'd take all the poor experiences that our guests have here. A family wants to go to the ice rink and it's broken down or there's snow covering it. That's a poor experience and they take that home. A family wants to go down to the skateboard park. There isn't a small skateboard park for young kids. So again, I think the council or the tourism or DMO that's going to be developed needs to look at
2:31:42 What are all the negative experiences, and we need to start checking those off and getting rid of them before we do anything else? Thank you, Kirk. Tony? Folks, first, you know, we need to revitalize our current business community, our restaurants and retail, so that they have a healthy year, so that they can't afford to stay open in those slow times. Then we need to take recreation, and we need to compound on that. We need to build up our recreational tourism.
2:32:11 Thank you. Don?
2:32:41 The first thing we need to do is realize our tour space is not limited to skiing. If I point out just one example, I would look to the fishing industry. Fishing is one of the largest economic engines that fuels the entire county. Year after year, we overlook this industry. We overlook this visitor. The fishing season begins right now at the end of April, which is pretty much when ski season winds down.
2:33:07 Fishing season goes through mid-November, which is just before ski season ramps up. I spoke to somebody this morning, totally unsolicited, and who used to run Sandy's Sports, I guess, and he explained to me that this time of year, his shop was open 24 hours a day for the fishing industry, or for the fishermen, fisher visitors. In any case, I think that that's just one example of
2:33:35 of capturing an audience that already does come here. Thank you, Don. Matthew? I think one thing I would start with is thinking outside the box a little bit. Tourism isn't our only business here. I'll give an example. First, I'd like to start by saying I'd probably work with the Chamber of Commerce, our business community, even our real estate community on this next one. There was a client I was working with and hoped to bring in here a little over a year ago.
2:34:03 They were a fraud detection business, and they were an international company, and they wanted to come here just because they liked Mammoth. This company's revenues would have dwarfed Mammoth Mountain. The revenues, over a five-year period, they were hopeful that their business would have had about 80 employees with prevailing wages at $125,000 plus.
2:34:27 These people, these were the types of things, the types of businesses we can bring here. It's a very low-impact type of a company. So that might be a start. Another, driving, really encouraging more larger events in the shoulder seasons. They're not dependent on weather. They're not dependent on season. And also encouraging more with the Mammoth Track project. Thank you very much, Matthew. Just a couple quick comments. I have one question from the audience in claiming a town surplus.
2:34:56 Aren't you ignoring the potential loss of the Hot Creek Appeal? And the $500,000 that the town may be in excess of their budget this year wouldn't make a dent in a $30 million appeal. So I think hopefully we won't lose the appeal and we'll see what happens. In regards to Sandy's in 24 hours a day, that did happen.
2:35:15 Believe it or not, Thanksgiving weekend 1979 and fishing opener 1981 and then I got too tired. So, Tom, I need to clarify something there. The lawsuit down there, the judge can declare the town...
2:35:31 You know, acted inappropriately or whatever it happens to be. But there is a separation of powers. The judge cannot tell the council how to budget. And that is one of the reasons that, you know, there probably will be a negotiated settlement because the judge isn't going to say, oh, by the way, you're going to stop funding, you know, community development or public safety or parks and rec.
2:35:54 So there is a constitutional issue that separates the judicial process from the legislative process, and the judge can only go so far. And that is the biggest tool that the council has for actually resolving this thing without saying that we're going to get rid of or take $3 million out of our budget for the next 60 years. It's not going to happen. Thank you, Kirk. Very good point. All right. So I'm going to try and get one question in with each candidate.
2:36:24 I had said you'd have two minutes to answer that, but we have to start closing statements in about six minutes. So I'm going to change the rules on you. You get one minute to answer the question. I'm going to try and throw them out to you. We have our little scrabble cubes here. So I'll start with John first. And John.
2:36:44 I have, you speak about serving another term with new direction and new majority on council, so you must have a hope for change. What do you think the first change would be if you are re-elected? I think the, I think there'll be many changes depending upon who the candidates up here tonight are elected. I think a change will be much more scrutiny with the town budget.
2:37:11 Much more scrutiny on expenditures, much more scrutiny on reorganization of the town staff. And that's really the main one. Thank you very much. Alan, I picked you second here. You speak of establishing Mammoth as a world-class destination without high-rise, high-density. Not that I'm a world traveler, but I don't remember a destination resort without some density and height. How do you suppose we can do it here?
2:37:39 Well, right now we have just scads of empty space. We have retail spaces. We have empty condos. We need to infill the structure that we already have existing. And three stories is actually quite a lot of building. Three stories spread out in through the trees does give you quite a bit of capacity. I look forward to a convention center.
2:38:08 Convention centers don't need to be six stories tall. We do need some larger open spaces, but they don't need to be in increased height. I think we can definitely keep under the three stories and still build out our structures and create more space. Thank you, Alan. Rick, you're next. Where'd you go? Rick, you speak about fundamental restructuring of town government to allow council to take back control of government. What does this mean, and how can it happen?
2:38:37 Since your only two employees are the town manager and the town attorney. Well, the perception is that the government isn't running well in part because the council doesn't function well. And I think that's because over the last few years there has not been a single direction developed after consensus. So you start with firm, absolute discretion, I mean direction to the town manager. You tell the town manager what to do.
2:39:06 Second, you get rid of the furlough. The furlough doesn't work. It's the easy way out. It's a cop-out. It's something that rewards unproductive employees, discourages and reduces the morale of productive employees, and does not address the basic question, which is, how many employees do you need to actually deliver the services that the community either wants or you think you can afford? Third, you develop a pay-as-you-go budget.
2:39:34 That is fundamental restructuring from the budget process that we have now. And, of course, there are many, many others, all of which are going to take consensus of counsel. It can only happen if there is leadership. Thank you very much, Rick. Sharon, I drew you next. You speak about quality versus quantity in preserving land, water, air. Are you the no-growth candidate? Absolutely not. Growth is not a four-letter word.
2:40:03 It is, I'm concerned about quality of growth. And all that means to me is that we get what we want when we build. We don't necessarily need more condos, more rooms. We don't fill them, but what, five or six days out of the year. So by building what the town needs is what I mean by quality, not quantity in terms of.
2:40:36 Thank you. Matthew, you talk about bringing a spectrum of viewpoints. What viewpoints are missing? Are you speaking to those that sit on town council, show up in public comments, or sit on other boards? A spectrum of viewpoints I'm referring to are the spectrum of viewpoints that I have in this experience of my living here in Mammoth. I've seen Mammoth through the spectrum of viewpoints. I've seen it as a child.
2:41:04 I've seen it as an adult here in Mammoth. I've seen it as an employee, an employer. And I've lived in this town through growth periods and very harsh downturns. So those were the spectrum of viewpoints that I was referring to. And I think having lived through and seen a lot of these different facets over my life, I think I will be able to apply these moving forward.
2:41:34 Need such as a recreation for their children. I know what it's like to be in this community and have recreation be a very important part for a child here. Many other people, many other candidates may not know what that's like here in this town. Thank you. Dawn, you're next. Dawn, openness and government and transparency. Does this mean that you think things are not being done in the public view? And if so, how would you affect change to fix this?
2:42:02 Yes, I definitely do not think there's, I think there's a lot of things that are not transparent right now. I would affect change by, I mean, there's obvious, there's certain issues when it comes to employee relations that obviously are private, and those have to be held in closed session. But the amount of closed session that we have is seemingly inappropriate and excessive.
2:42:28 However, you know, in saying that, having not sat on council, there may be sensitive issues that I'm unaware of, but just as a citizen, as a business owner in this community, that's the way I see it. So I would be as open as possible and have less of that backroom discussion and decisions and focus solely on what is important in this community. Thank you, Dawn. I have so many to pick from. So many to pick from. I'm special.
2:43:00 During your years on Town Council, I saw two different Kirks. In the early years, you were more conservative to growth, and in the later years, you were more supportive of growth and development. What Kirk are we voting for this time? That's a very good question. At this particular point in time, I would say that our construction industry has slowed down.
2:43:23 You're going to be voting for, if I am successful, you'll be voting for a Kirk that is going to try to actually promote more marketing and trying to sustain the businesses and the community that exists now. There's two different issues that I have opposed, and that is CBiz and this proposed reduction in DIF fees. So you're going to be seeing somebody that...
2:43:51 Appears to be anti-growth, but the reason I oppose those is because those fall back on the town budget. So, you know, growth is important. Quality of the growth is very important. Where density is located and everything else is important. So I don't think I think of myself as either, but my emphasis will be on, if I'm re-elected, will be on trying to get support for our existing businesses right now.
2:44:20 That's what I'm focused on right now. Thank you, Kirk. I hope this is a T. Tony, where did you go? You speak about job opportunity. Since the development community is paralyzed until the market returns, how would you suggest we build jobs townwide? Well, first of all, we need to have our Chamber of Commerce be an integral part of our town government. We need to work with the Chamber to promote job fair workshops.
2:44:53 We can bring in the retired service corps of executives. It's a great group that comes in and they work with folks to start up business. They work with them free of charge to come up with business plans. We need to look at our current businesses and how they can be revitalized. We also need to look at our fee structure. We need to drop those fees for a period not less than six months. Our construction trades have been hit hard. We're not going to have large-scale development, but we can have remodels going on. We can put our trades back to work.
2:45:21 Simply by lowering or not even lowering, getting rid of our fees for a period not less than six months, incentivize folks to do remodels and put our construction workers back to work. Upon doing that, you can also start with small industrial. As Matthew mentioned, the gentleman from last year, we have a great community that's environmentally safe that we could do small industrial, whether it is putting little pieces of equipment and...
2:45:48 You know, electrical things together. We can do that. We have places in town that can be rented for that. We also need to encourage our youth and keep our youth employed, and we also have folks that are going to reenter the job market. That all can be done through the chamber and the town. Thank you very much to everyone, and I'm moving this along. Our closing statement is three minutes from each of you. The first person is Dawn. Mine's not quite three minutes, so somebody else can speak longer.
2:46:16 I'm running for Mammoth Lakes Town Council for no other reason than I love this community, and I would like the opportunity to help move Mammoth in a positive direction. As a small business owner in this community, I understand the many challenges the business community faces. As an employer, I understand not only those challenges, but the sacrifices families and individuals make in order to live here. I'm not a lifetime politician, nor do I have an agenda. I'm a responsible member of the community
2:46:44 Who believes in transparent, inclusive, and fiscally responsible government. I've worked with various groups within our community over the years and understand the concerns of development, tourism, transportation, public safety, as well as the issues facing our environment, the arts, and our schools. The primary reason I'm running for a seat on Town Council is to help bridge the gap between our business community and the town.
2:47:08 I'm a strong community-minded leader and consensus builder. These traits are essential in working with fellow council members, town staff, and the community in which I hope to serve. As a council member, I will focus on the necessity of balancing our town's budget, realizing affordable housing, reclaiming our tax dollars from the county, and leading Mammoth forward in development of our community, our airport, and tourism industry. Mammoth is at a crossroads.
2:47:37 And it's imperative we choose leaders who are unbiased and without agenda. Leaders who understand that success of Mammoth directly relates to the success of our business community. In order to effect change, we need leaders to bring new ideas, new vision, and passion. The future of Mammoth depends on this. Thank you. Thank you very much, Don. John, three minutes for your closing statement. Thank you.
2:48:02 The most important aspect of the June 8th Town Council election is that members of the public, you the voters, exercise your right to vote and actually make the effort and to get out and do the voting, either by absentee or by going to the polls on election day. This is one of our most basic of individual rights and it is important for us all, regardless of which candidates you are supporting, to please vote so that we can hold these elected
2:48:32 Officials accountable. Often during election we hear someone say something like change or new blood. These are only words. Yet change is a word with many outcomes. I would submit that we have experienced change on the town council in Mammoth Lakes for the past four years. And that the change we have experienced during the last four years
2:49:01 Was not necessarily always positive. Does Mammoth need change again? I would submit that the answer to that is yes, we do need change. That change is a majority of the five members of town council who can get things done, a council that can start making decisions from the first day of being in office. Many times, almost universally, newly elected council members come into office and they are
2:49:33 Inexperienced, naive, hesitant and don't become leaders until after their second, third, fourth or even fifth year in being in office. I would submit that the community of Mammoth Lakes does not have the luxury of two, three, four and definitely not five years to wait for that to happen. It is clear that we as a community have been treading water for the past four years and cannot afford
2:50:04 To have a continuation of hesitation, inactivity, and a basic lack of knowledge of how to run a municipal organization. Town staff will run the town if the council lets them. It is not a dig on town staff, it's a dig on the town council. And it's just a reality of what will happen if the council lets it happen. Mammoth needs a majority of the council members who are leaders
2:50:34 And who have the confidence in that knowledge and will make the decisions and not follow town staff like a lamb. When you vote on June 8th, please consider if you are voting for a lamb or a leader. One final piece of good news is that the town has just received notification from the state of California that the California legislature has passed legislation that will put in perpetuity
2:51:01 The reimbursement of the town of Mammoth Lakes for approximately $1 million a year in snow removal costs. That's great news. Thank you, John. Matthew? John's right about a few things. I am going to say new blood. New blood, new thinking, and new leadership. Now, these aren't my words. These are words that I've heard from a number of you that I've spoken to when talking about what it is you want to see on your town council.
2:51:34 It's been said that politicians are like diapers. They need to be changed regularly and often for the same reasons. I am a new candidate, but I'm not new to Mammoth. This is my home. I grew up here and I've seen this town, as we talked about earlier, through a spectrum of changes. Some candidates are hopeful that you will side with them on one or two issues. Other candidates will rely on their political experience and are hopeful that you will have
2:52:06 Have forgotten about the follies of their past. I'm hoping you don't. Did these candidates represent you the way that you wanted to be represented in the past? Do zebras change their stripes? I often take advice from people that are smarter than me. A good friend of mine likes to quote Albert Einstein in his definition of insanity. Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. I'm not here tonight to tell you what you want to hear to pander votes.
2:52:41 I'm not here to see economic gain or popularity, but I'm here tonight to tell you that I love my town. I love my community. As far as leadership goes, I think I've demonstrated myself in this town as a leader. I've operated several successful businesses in this town for more than 15 years. I've had to make harsh decisions. I've had to adapt to change and use proactive thinking in order to do so.
2:53:12 At the end of every week, I have to meet a payroll. I have employees I have to look at with families. So to think that just because you're a new candidate that you're not going to be capable of fulfilling the shoes of this town, I think is inaccurate. And to suggest that staff is going to run the town if you get new people in here, you're very, very wrong. When you go to the polls on June 8th, I hope you'll consider me. Recently, and I hope you look at all your candidates, what have they done for you lately?
2:53:44 I've been busy. I've been working with the Chamber of Commerce. We work very eagerly to get a new event up and running, an event that drew somewhere between 6,500 and 9,500 people in a single day. I've sat on the Assessment Appeals Board for Mono County, and I've worked very hard with others. I think it's very important to work with others on revitalizing the village at Mammoth. No, I don't take all the credit for that.
2:54:16 But I'm going to take some. So on June 8, ladies and gentlemen, I hope you will consider a new candidate and I hope you'll consider me. Thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Alan? I'd like to thank the Chamber of Commerce and MPG Cable for allowing us to have this candidate's forum. Thank you for facilitating this, Mr. Cage. I think some new blood is needed on the Town Council. I've just come over the mountain from Reading and...
2:54:44 I look at what got me to stay, what got me to look at this community and say, I don't want to go back to the city. That's what I hear from most of the people. We're not against development, but I really think it's the village and the trees, it's the rusticness that is here that caught my heart again, the beauty, the environment that we have here. I do not want to see that spoiled. I want to maintain that as much as possible. I think every candidate who is up here is very literate, very eloquent.
2:55:15 I think everybody has excellent and good intentions for our town. I think we all have ideas that are outside the box. I don't think it will be business as usual. I definitely would like to see us go forward with things that have been talked about for years and years, getting that ice rink covered, making sure it's going to be there for quite a while, getting an amphitheater, getting Mammoth Motocross Track open more. When that track is open,
2:55:45 Shady Rest and Sherwin Campgrounds are full. The ladies go shopping. They go to the movies, the gas, just the camping. A few more fishing tournaments. Of course, my pet projects here at Wildlife Sanctuary. Bears and coyotes and cougars are my. It's a very family-oriented type thing that would help us deal with Steve Searles and problems. We wouldn't have problematic animals.
2:56:13 And it would create revenue rather than have DFT spending money on sanctioning animals rather than providing them sanctuary. 3D IMAX theater, something that's a little bit bigger than what we have. It would be the only one between Carson City and Las Vegas. Things like the Mammoth Lakes Jazz Jubilee and Bluza Palooza. I hope the destination marketing organization starts to...
2:56:43 Put in more awareness, especially to our neighbors that are over the hill. I think we keep looking to the south and the north too much, LA and San Diego, Portland and Seattle. It's a 45-minute flight from Sacramento Executive Airport. A little tag that I'd like to put out is, come see what the bear, come find out what the bear sees on the other side of the mountains. When it's 110 degrees over there, it's only 78 here.
2:57:08 I think we're ignoring our neighbors to the direct west. Sacramento, Davis, Woodlands, Stockton, Tracy. It's a huge group of people that we're not paying attention to. Trader Joe's. I'd love to see a Trader Joe's. And I am staunchly, I believe we can do development without going over three stories tall. I am committed to maintaining Village in the Trees. And I hope you vote for me on June 8th. And I'll definitely stand up and listen to what you talked to me about. Thank you, Alan.
2:57:38 Rick? Thank you, Tom, and thank you for those who are in the audience who have stuck this out for the last three hours. I announced early, I think first, in January, and people, of course, came up to me and said, why on earth would you do that again? And, you know, it was, I'm not particularly introspective, at least not very often, but I actually went through a process and determined or thought in my own mind,
2:58:08 You know, if you don't have passion for something, that life isn't worth living. And if you have passion, you better go after it. I think what I've demonstrated in the service that I've provided to the community for nearly 20 years in a variety of capacities and positions is that I bring a variety and wealth of experience to this prospective job. And by the way, so do...
2:58:35 Many, many other people on this panel. I think when times are hard, times are tough, when people are not feeling good about government, you get a whole lot of candidates out, many of whom, perhaps all of whom here, are qualified to do this job. You don't hear a lot of differences up here, so why would you vote for one over another? Well, in my instance, I think that what many people thought that I was able to do during the time that I was sitting here was to
2:59:05 assist in bringing consensus to the council so it did speak with one voice. You may not have agreed with it, but we spoke almost always with one voice. Secondly, I think one of the greatest experiences that I have is not just raising a family or raising two kids who are now gone. Actually, I have a third who's the perpetual child who will never leave, but the fact is that I've effectively
2:59:30 Experienced what people who live here do and have experienced. And I think I can bring that to this job. I don't represent as a lawyer, that's my business, developers, big corporations, big money folks. I represent ordinary people, people who employ people in this community and people who are employed in this community. And as a result, I think I have my ear pretty close to the ground.
2:59:59 So why is it that you would vote for somebody? Because he has passion? No. It is because he is able, I think and I hope, to assist in getting something done in a way that the community is satisfied. What we have seen over the last four years, I don't know, I've sort of called it an experiment, but what I really think is it's a lack of or a lost focus because we haven't seen an individual.
3:00:27 Or a couple of individuals on council come forward and take a leadership role. You can't quantify leadership, but you know it when you see it. I think I have it, and I hope that you will vote for me on June 8th. Thank you. Rick, thank you very much. Tony? Thank you, Tom. Thank you to our audience and the community for participating this evening. You know, I have things written here, and I'm going to set it aside because I'm not going to give you rhetoric or any of the stuff that we could write down and spiel off. I just want to talk to you from the heart, and that is...
3:00:58 I've been in this community over 20 years. Many of you know me. And I feel like my entire life here in this community has been very rewarding for myself and my family, and I thank the community for that because they played a role in that. I want to be of service to this community because I do care about it. And it's not a passion. It's the fact that we can make a difference. My tenure that I had on council was a very rewarding experience to me, and I learned so very much. And I also made some mistakes.
3:01:28 And I've learned from those mistakes, and you won't see me make those again. If you choose to hire me and put me in place as your council member, you'll see a council member that listens to you no matter who you are, whether you're the advocates, whether you're a mammoth mountain, whether you're an individual, whether you're a visitor. I intend to listen to you, hear what you say, and make judgment and base decisions on that best judgment of what we've heard. I may not always agree, and those decisions may not be what everyone expects, but it's going to be what...
3:01:58 Community-minded and what we look forward to our future. When I served on council before, we had a lot of development going on, as you all know, and that took up most of our time. And I got wrapped up in that, as I think all of us did. But I learned so much from that, and we don't need to have all the development that went on at that one time. It was a boiling pot of it. It consumed everything we did. What I took joy in and what I look back on and reflect on is working with Jane Bearer and the community and getting the skate park built.
3:02:27 I'm working on a public art ordinance that took many, many years to get passed. It's got its flaws now. It needs to get fixed. It's something I want to see, too. But what I've learned, too, is recreational activities is what is at the heart of our community. It's what drives tourism. It's what drives marketing. And it's what we need to get back to. And what I intend to do, if you choose to hire me for that, is to work on bringing those recreational activities back. The development that we have coming forward is going to be minimal.
3:02:55 But we need to get our zoning in place to match our general plan. That will be a priority. The restructuring of our town government, it needs to happen. Our police, our public safety, the chief is now retired. We need to hire a new chief that's going to take us in to the coming years. We need to revitalize our businesses, our youth to come into business in our town and stay here. And we also need to get our construction trades and those industries back alive again.
3:03:27 I'm a person that's in the same boat with many of those people. With my business, I closed my business. I'm working privately now. But I'm in the same boat with a lot of the folks right now through this economic times. And who better to help you than somebody that knows the pain you're feeling? So I respectfully ask for your vote. I look forward to the future, and I thank you. Thank you, Tony. Shelley? I thought you'd never ask. Thank you, Chamber of Commerce. Thank you, audience. And thank you who's at home watching.
3:03:57 Mammoth is a complex town of business owners, tourists, families, and retirees with conflicting desires and needs for the future. I've talked to many of you and I've heard the following. Our community development department is not small business friendly. Entrepreneurs are required to jump through too many hoops and they simply give up and leave without investing in Mammoth. Two examples stand out.
3:04:26 A security company wanted to purchase the Edison building. They left discouraged. A local restaurant wanted to expand but lost interest due to cumbersome requirements. I propose we review our building regulations to be small business friendly. We need to finish our district plans, redo CBIS, and bring our codes into compliance. All of this with
3:04:54 The community engaged. Developers deserve to know exactly what we want, and they need to know that we intend to get what the people want. I will continue to push for high-speed broadband internet connectivity to Mammoth, which is necessary if we are to diversify our business base. When President Obama approved stimulus funds for rural areas, Digital 395 was born.
3:05:23 This high-speed, state-of-the-art service would be a hundred times faster than what we have now. We need to pursue that dream. We're blessed with renewable energy, solar, wind, and geothermal. To be energy efficient is an important goal. High Sierra Foundation has partnered with Edison to help us. Between 2005 and 2009, our community saved almost $600,000 in electric costs.
3:05:53 Mammoth Community Water District hopes their new solar farm will offset energy costs almost $200,000 a year. Ladies and gentlemen, we need to get our house in order. Systemic change in our town government is necessary. Together, we'll find balance between the social, environmental, and economic needs of our little remote village in the trees.
3:06:21 With 23 years of government service under my belt, I know what to do to bring people together to make our resort tick and to provide a quality life for everyone. If you remember nothing else I said tonight, please remember these two things. Lincoln's quote that applies to me, I am not bound to win, but I am bound to be true. And Sharon Clark works with you.
3:06:49 We are a government of, by, and for the people. I am candid, concerned, and committed. Thank you. Thank you very much, Sharon. Kirk Stapp. Well, I had written comments also. First, I'd like to thank you, Tom. I think you did an excellent job. I think the candidates did an excellent job. And I thank you people for sitting through three hours. Three hours, and some of you probably have a sore. laughter
3:07:20 We've got policies that are in conflict with each other. We've got language that...
3:07:49 You know, that leads nowhere. And those are some of the things that I really do enjoy doing. I'm not so good at glad-handing with people, but the technical parts and doing the homework to make sure that our policies line up together is something that I do a lot of homework on, and I bring it to staff before it gets to council. So that is something that I feel is an asset.
3:08:19 If I am fortunate enough to be elected as an asset that I would bring back to council. My decision was also motivated by two council policies that I strongly disagree with. The first is CBiz and how it was applied to Old Mammoth Place and the fact that CBiz reneges on measure R and measure 2002A. CBiz has very specific language in it.
3:08:47 And during the appeal hearing, what happened was that language was ignored. Well, if council wanted to ignore that, then it should have been brought to their attention sooner. And so I think I could, I think, I know I would have picked up on that language. I just, it's just something that I do. The second policy is coming before the council on May 5.
3:09:11 On May 5, they're going to look at reducing the DIF fees, the development impact fees. And if these are reduced, it's going to be reduced $95 million. And if that is put in place, the council has got a budget problem. Where is the money going to come from? The consultant has put together a funding fantasy list.
3:09:35 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:09:58 All that being said, if you do decide to support me in this election, I'll do the best I can. I will do my homework. I will certainly look at the issues and the implications of words and how they not only mess up the developer but the planning commission as well as the community. Thank you. Kirk Stapp, thank you very much. I'd like to thank the audience. This is a pressure cooker for these candidates. It's hard to go after these questions one right after a time when they don't know what's coming.
3:10:27 I'd like to thank all the candidates. I think everyone did a great job. I appreciate it. On May 11th, the Chamber of Commerce is going to be sponsoring a county panel of a lot more people than this, believe it or not, for all the seats that are up. And the esteemed Jack Copeland will be moderating that. He's in the audience tonight. I'd like to thank everyone from the Chamber that helped me, Channel 51 for helping, and I'd like to turn it over to our Chamber President for closing statements. Thank you very much. Eric Wasserman.
3:10:59 I would like to thank everybody in the audience that came here to observe this. I'd like to thank everybody that Tom just did to make this possible, especially the town of Mammoth Lakes for allowing us to use these facilities and broadcast this live on the internet as well as it will be archived. Thank you very much to our candidates. I wish you all the best of luck and feel free to communicate with the chamber for anything that we can do. And most of all, our membership. Without you, we wouldn't exist.
3:11:28 And thank you all for your time. Have a great evening.