TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2010

Town Council

· recording 5 hr 0 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

543 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

28:14 I'll call to order the Town Council meeting, regular meeting for Wednesday, April 21, 2010. Call Jamie, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Please join me. I pledge allegiance. Okay. Public comment. Now is the time for comments on matters not appearing on the agenda. Dana. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Council. I wanted to advise you and the public of two.

29:11 This week about a survey that they are putting forward for the public to participate in specific to the Olantia-Cortego four-lane project that they're proposing. They're looking and they're realizing that many of the users in that section of 395 are probably on their way to Mammoth or they are living in Mammoth and they're on their way back down to Southern California. So they realize that it's important to reach out to our community and to our visitors to participate in this survey.

29:39 I wanted to advise you that we'll be noticing this on our website at visitmammoth.com, but if you are interested and you'd like to go and start to take this survey now, they've posted it at four, the number four, fourlane395.com, and everyone's participation and input is greatly appreciated on behalf of Caltrans. This is a four-lane widening project between Olantia and Cartago.

30:04 I think our input is going to be extremely important to this, so we encourage everyone to get out and participate. Number two, tomorrow at 11 a.m. over at the Welcome Center, we will be going through an official designation ceremony for the California Welcome Center designation that we have secured from the state. Carolyn Beteta, who is the President and CEO of the California Travel and Tourism Commission, will be here for the ceremony and will be the one...

30:30 Providing the designation for us. The festivities begin at 11 a.m. and we will go until about 12.30. There will be some light refreshments served and an opportunity for you to see what a California Welcome Center might look like. To allow any fears, there's really no change to the building other than we've changed out our brochure racks.

30:51 And there will be additional state information in there as well as local and regional information. So again, tomorrow at 11 a.m. at the Welcome Center, California Welcome Center designation and Carolyn Botetta from the state will be in attendance. And Mayor McCarroll will be speaking. Thank you. If you give me something to say. That's at the Forest Service Visitor Center. Yeah, at the Visitor Center. Yeah. Any other public comments?

31:19 Hearing none, Council reports, additions to the agenda. Skip, you want to start? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I just have one report. On Friday, April 16th, I attended the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority Board of Directors meeting, and we have really great news on the agreement with the Forest Service going down into Reds Meadow. They have concluded the contract with that, so it will continue this year with additional buses.

31:47 Thank you.

32:14 They will be used on the Reds Meadow route, and then in the winter, ESTA can use them to begin to expand our route. ESTA and the town will be able to use them to expand our routes within the town and provide better bus service within the town. I think it's worth noting that John Helm, the director of ESTA for all of his hard work on this, was actually presented a belt buckle.

32:37 As a special partner, deeming him and ESTA a special partner with the Forest Service. And I understand they don't give these buckles out lightly, so it's quite a generous reward. And it shows what hard work John has put into ESTA in helping to build that transit system. The Forest Service also announced that they have a new grant-funded full-time transit planner.

33:07 We'll be looking at not only the Reds Meadow Bus Service, but ways that they can possibly extend that type of service up into our Lakes Basin, over into Yosemite, the Whitney Portal area, possibly the Rock Creek area, and other trailhead areas where the public would like to have mass transit service it for people who don't have vehicles wanting to access those areas. So that's all very good news.

33:35 We also approved a contract with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to once again this year have the mountain handle the ticket sales for the Reds Meadow bus service and they will be handling that both up at the main lodge area and in the village so guests can get our transit in-town transit system up to the village, purchase their ticket and then begin to get rides from there and not have to drive up.

34:03 to the main lodge in order to go into Red's Meadow. The one thing that the mountain has asked that we share the cost on, which they paid last year, but ESTA is going to share the cost on this year, is what they call a boarding pass agent. And this was really a very successful program that they started in where instead of having a long line of people simply waiting in line,

34:28 for the bus up at Reds Meadow. As you purchase your ticket, you also are able to at a point receive

34:35 A number that you get. And that kind of tells you when your bus will be queuing so that you can then move on about the grounds, of course shop in their stores and or get something to eat, just hang out in the sun on the grassy area up there by Main Lodge. And it seemed to really put a relaxed feeling in there of not having a lot of people trying to rush for a bus each time it came in. Someone with a PA system would announce

35:03 What number bus was loading and the people as it was coming up and the people that had that number would then come board the bus and it was smoothly going off. And I bring this up only because as we look at trying to move people out of large events here in town when we have something where there's going to be a lot of people trying to board transit at one time, it might be something we would want to consider and see if something similar to that might work out for moving people on to mass transit as we

35:32 Have our big events and something that we would want to work with event organizers on. And I think lastly, but definitely not least, with our summer bike service coming, we have four trolleys that will have hitches on and we'll be able to pull bicycles and with the Lake Mary bike path coming up.

35:55 Opening from the Twin Lakes down into town, we anticipate that being a fairly heavily used area with people wanting to move on their bikes up to the top. And one concern of our drivers at ESTA was the safety area directly behind the bus where sometimes their mirrors were not able to see if there was someone who had maybe loaded a bicycle late and was in between the bike trailer and the bus.

36:21 Before they've moved out, so we have arranged, the town has arranged to purchase four rear view video monitors for those buses so that prior to the drivers pulling out, they will be able to scan the entire area around their bus and make sure that it's safe for everybody before they leave. And that is all that I have. Thank you, Skip. Joe?

36:45 Yes, two things I'd like to report on. Wendy and I have continued to meet with the staff about the recreation reorganization and the reconciliation. At this part, our involvement is nearly at the end, and the Tourism and Recreation Commission will be taking over and then bringing forward to Council some different proposals at a later date. So it's still working, but we're kind of leaving it.

37:13 The other thing I'd like to report on is something I'm doing as a citizen, not as a council member, is that I am part of the grassroots collaborative planning effort that is working with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and the College District to put together a business plan to get what we are calling in working title the Mammoth Art and Culture Center.

37:36 Business plan done and soon to give people an idea of how to get that performing arts center and culinary education going forward. Great. Thank you, Jo. Wendy? I have nothing to report. Thank you. Real quick, I just wanted to add on to what Skip mentioned about the Reds Meadow route. A couple of things are important. I just wanted to reaffirm that the grant money that Skip mentioned, the $1.6 million, that's going to buy four

38:06 Brand new buses that we can use on that route. And the additional grant money that we're seeking would allow for eight more buses. So it's reasonable to think that within the next two or three years we'll have 12 new buses for that route. The relevance is currently we're using the older Mammoth Mountain Ski Area buses. And you could imagine from two or three years from today what condition those older buses might be in at that time. So it's really an important grant.

38:36 That ESTA has initially received and looks like we're going to possibly receive the second one. Also wanted to give credit to Vicki Bauer, Mono County Supervisor. It's due in large part to Vicki's efforts back in Washington, D.C. with our local representatives working back there to get their attention to help Mammoth apply for these grants and to have us receive them.

39:05 Finally, on the Reds Meadow route this summer, keep in mind last summer was the first year that ESTA took over that route and we learned some things and ESTA is going to add two to three additional buses to that route this year as well as additional drivers and additional scheduling of in between times. So I think as good as the service was last year down to Reds, this summer it should be even better. Oh and

39:34 Speaking of ESTA and the Town of Mammoth Lakes transportation system, I think it's also important to point out that in 32 of our transit months in the first three years, 32 out of 35 months, our ridership has increased within the community of Mammoth Lakes. And just our last month that was calculated, which was March of this year,

40:02 So March of 2010, we were up 16% over March of 2009. So our transit within the Mammoth and ESTA within Inyo and Mono counties is doing a good job. Thank you. Thank you, John. I just had a couple of quick things. On the 12th of April, I attended the LTC meeting, and I believe it's next summer. They're going to be treating the bridges down at 395.

40:30 The bridge over 203 and the bridge over Mammoth Creek with what they call an aesthetic treatment. I voted for the bridges of Madison County, but they turned that down quickly. But what it's going to look like is they're going to put river rock on the sides of the concrete abutments and a bicycle railing across the bridge. So when you're bicycling, you can get...

40:53 Hit by a gust of wind, you don't end up in the creek or somewhere. What were those three bridges again, Neil? Two of them. One over Mammoth Creek and one over 203. So you're on 395 headed north and south. So it's two bridges down there. So I think it, you know, bit by bit, but I think it should be very attractive. And then today I attended the Mammoth Mountain Town liaison meeting.

41:19 I think the principal thing of interest that was brought up was that, you know, we talk about summer air service, which commenced April 12th, and I think there are a lot of people out there that can't wait for the summer for air service to begin, and of course it began on April 12th and extends all the way through September 30th. So, you know, anybody that can get the word out that they're very much catering to locals. I think there's a $49 fare.

41:48 From Mammoth to Los Angeles. And it's a real convenience and a terrific addition, but Howard Pickett, their marketing director, is going to do some, in conjunction with the new DMO, some marketing for this service. So, I mean, it should be called extended air service, not summer air service, because it's spring, summer, and fall. That's all I have.

42:16 Additions to the agenda. Anybody want to pull something from consent? Yes, if I could, I would like to pull item number seven, please. Seven. And I would like to pull number eight and number nine. And on number nine, I would like to ask that we deal with that item immediately. Okey-doke. Any other? Nobody going for six? Clean sweep. Okay. Well, we'll entertain item number nine.

42:44 On the consent agenda, which is approved letters supporting the naming of a local peak in honor of Andrea Meade Lawrence. Somebody want to give a staff report? I think it's pretty self-explanatory. Bing, did you want to say something? I think Bing Hunt is here to introduce Adam. It feels good being this side of the dice for once. Be nice now. Be nice.

43:20 On behalf of the Lawrence family, I'm here to urge your letter writing and submission of letters to our congressmen and senators federally to support the naming of a local peak in honor of Andrea Meade Lawrence. We all know Andrea and what she meant to this community over many, many years, and the family feels it's very fitting to have something named after her.

43:47 The peak that's been kind of labeled as the peak of choice is peak 12,227, which is a peak directly east of Donahue Peak. You know where Donahue Pass is. Donahue Peak and what may become Mount Andrea Lawrence will be on the border between Yosemite National Park and the Ancelandum's Wilderness. It sits at the headwaters of Rush Creek, which feeds Mono Lake.

44:15 So it's very fitting, I think, as recognition of what she's meant to our community. Vicki McGee-Bower, you mentioned that she's been in Washington, D.C. on transportation issues. She's going back again next week, and she'll be carrying letters of support for this proposal with her, so hopefully if you can get a letter of support prepared and ready by that time, she can carry it back there, and we're going to present these letters in person. And hopefully this will mean that we can actually...

44:45 Move this process along, which these processes, I don't know if you're familiar with naming peaks in the Sierras, but sometimes it'll take 10 to 20 years to do it. Hopefully by doing it this way and getting across the board local support, it'll happen very quickly. We just found out that the county of Tuolumne has supported it with letters to all three representatives in Washington, and we have letters of support from Mona County.

45:14 And many, many individuals throughout the area. So hopefully the town council will find it okay to support it also. I just want to thank you for your consideration. There are letters of support as kind of a recommendation in your consent agenda packet so possibly you can work on those letters and see what you can do.

45:40 We just received a letter of support from the mountain ski area signed by Rusty Gregory. Yeah, Rusty Gregory supported. Okay, thank you Bing. Real quick, so this is just an easy day hike for you Bing? Easy day hike. Easy, okay. I understand, and I think it's true, that if you go up to Minaret Summit,

46:05 And if you know where you're looking, that you can identify the peak and see it. You can go up on Chair 3, Chair 5, top of the mountain, look across and see that. You know where you're looking. It's a beautiful place. It would be a great trip. Thank you. Any other questions? Discussion?

46:27 Anybody want to make a motion? Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion that we authorize the mayor to sign letters to our congressional representatives supporting the naming of a local peak in honor of Andrea Mead Lawrence. I'll second. We're about to have two seconds. I think we have two seconds. No, I didn't say it. Wendy got there first. Wendy. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Cianimus. Thank you for coming, Bing. Okay.

46:56 The next item is a public presentation regarding Shady Rest Trail Grooming Project from representatives of Mammoth Nordic. Phyllis. I just have a few little papers here for you. Nice to see you walking around. It's so frisky. Oh, thank you. Yeah, I know. Doing the best we can. No. Thank you.

47:29 I was handing out testimonials in support of our green program, which is Mammoth Nordic. And I am Phyllis Benham and have been very lucky to be the facilitator for Mammoth Nordic this year. We have a cost share agreement with the Forest Service and a partnership with the town. And first of all, I want to thank all of you who made it possible for us to get Measure R funding so that we were able...

47:57 To use that funding for grooming of the Shady West area. And this enabled visitors and townspeople, kids, old people, people walking, people skiing, people snowshoeing, to, sorry about that, to easily get a lot of exercise.

48:20 And a beautiful area, which is your Shady Rest Park. And I hope that we will continue to get your support next year when that request for funding comes in. We had, I think, a wonderful year. And I am going to act like a school teacher. How many of you availed the Shady Rest area for skiing this year? Well, that's not bad. And the rest of you on town council? Shame.

48:50 We're always working. You can still go out there. No. Anyway, our grooming crew did an absolutely superb job sometimes going out there twice or three times during a storm in order to get the track, a very fine track set and corduroy set. As far as activities are concerned, we had an opener at the museum. We had a closure, a full moon ski up to Poconoby.

49:19 Just a couple of weeks ago. And in between, we had joint ski sessions with Friends of the Inyo and with, let's see, who else was it? Eastern Sierra Nordic Ski Association just last Sunday and had a wonderful group of people out there. Brian is going to show a PowerPoint that will describe

49:44 The hours and the program that was out there so that you could understand what was done. We hope that next year will be just as successful and that we have just as much snow so that we can start again in December as we did this year and just finished grooming today. So the rest is up to Brian and thank you very much and hope we have all of you out there next year. Thank you, Phyllis. Brian? No. Hi guys, Brian's with Mammoth Nordic.

50:28 First, I'd like to really specifically thank Phyllis Benham for taking on the role. I just found to be more than I could apply myself to. She was our president. She did an outstanding job of alleviating a lot of the administrative responsibilities from me so that I could focus more on the daily operations. And it's something that we couldn't have accomplished in the field had we not had.

50:56 Phyllis, specifically, and the rest of our board, Mary Kay Prentice, Henning Jensen, Jim Louie, and Marshall Genevieve. So I'd first like to acknowledge that the things that we were able to accomplish this year would not have been able to be accomplished if I didn't have their wholesale support, so thank you, Phyllis. Things that took place this year were born out of, effectively, our passion for

51:28 Winter Recreation and Nordic Sports. And we just thought we'd come and share with you how we pulled that off. Does everybody know more than that, but the Nordic Trail System is? And you had good snow, huh, Brian, this year? Yeah, more than good snow. Excellent snow. I think it's going to be self-evident where we're going. So there is the trail system we groomed this year.

52:16 That's the Rancher District Office, but it's off of the Mammoth Lakes Welcome Center. The fire station is over here, and one of the letters you receive from Phyllis is an exceedingly supportive testimonial from Brent Harper, the chief of the fire department over there. Both he and a lot of the staff have been taking advantage of the groom drills just out the back door, so they've really appreciated the work we've done.

52:54 That is the map that we made available to folks for the trail system that we groomed. It was somewhat modest this year, but we did the best job we could every day to make sure it was enjoyable for the people who were out there taking advantage of it. And we're not done. There's a bit of an ongoing debate about how soon we should stop, but we're enjoying the work we're doing so much that we're trying to kind of curtail the schedule right now. We're trying to do Thursday, Fridays, and Saturdays.

53:26 Good reason to be out there today, so we set track this morning also. We're having our best season most definitely. We began grooming trails December 6th, and we were grooming 6 and 7 days a week this year. As Phyllis mentioned, there was a thankfully relatively brief storm cycle where we ran out 2 and 3 times a day just to make sure that the bench that we established with our grooming equipment was not lost to the winds and the drifts.

53:57 But it was all well worth it. Another thing that was of extreme benefit to us this year was establishing the designated Mordick Trailhead over at the Mammoth Lakes Welcome Center. We really liked that. It was a huge success. One of the letters you received is from Penny Custer, who's the administrator of that welcome center, and she's pretty happy with the response that we were able to create in terms of new visitors to the welcome center. It made the place feel like it was actually alive in the winter.

54:27 We also initiated a host program this year, and a host program's sole function is to make sure that people know what they're about to experience and make sure they have a good time while they're doing it, and we felt like we did that pretty well this year. As far as grooming operations go, we're a non-profit, and since 2006 we've invested about $75,000 into equipment, tools, and other things to make sure that we can

54:58 Maintain at a professional standard your community north trail system. As I mentioned earlier, we groomed over 100 days this year, totaling over 350 hours of saddle time on the Nordoni, which is our affectionate name for our grooming equipment. We have four guys that have been putting in some time out there, Keith, Dan, Scott, and myself, and we're really happy that we were able to...

55:27 Commit that kind of energy and effort to this particular program. The Welcome Center, again, as I mentioned earlier, was something that, to us, was a perfect starting point for a Nordic Trail adventure. Earlier in the winter, we put together, with the invitation, I should say, of Dan Stroud and Stuart Brown, the Tourism and Recreation Department, a public service announcement that's been playing.

55:58 On Channel 51 and Channel 72. It's also posted at the visitnammoth.com website. This is not the exact PSA that's playing, however, it's basically from the raw footage, and we're hoping to find somebody who has a palatable enough voice to help us with voiceovers, or we can actually utilize it on our website and possibly others with the town and the county.

56:28 As you can see, as Phyllis mentioned, this is the kind of recreation that we feel is a lifetime sport for people. It doesn't matter if you're young, old, confirmed, fit as a horse. It's something everybody can do together. And starting at the Welcome Center has been a place that we feel like is a perfect fit for that. That's the Nordoni. Is that custom or is that typical?

56:57 Well, it's not typical in the States. It's something that's widely used overseas because it's made in Italy. It's actually powered by a Peugeot four-stroke engine, and it's cleaner than any car you can buy in California. That's how stringent the emission standards are in Europe. So it's not the primary reason I picked that piece of equipment in 06, but it was one of the factors that made it the most appealing thing we could afford at the time. So it's definitely done its job.

57:27 Very ably. We're very happy with it. As I said, the Welcome Center is a perfect starting point. Now the Welcome Center staff can direct people directly out the front door to the Blue Diamond Trail System or the Mammoth Lakes Nordic Trail System when they want to go to snow shield or cross-country skiing. And, of course, the local folks like to be able to get out there before work or at lunch or on the way home. The host program, again.

57:53 It was something we felt like was the best way we could introduce folks to the trail system. So we were out there on 15 weekends this winter. Our hosts provided information about the trail system, if people needed help with their equipment, we could do that for them. And we also had a hot chocolate and cookies for free. So that would have a pretty mile. We had 11 different hosts who volunteered over 135 hours to make sure that the visitor experience was something that people would remember.

58:24 Big plans for next year. We have a special use permit, as folks mentioned, at the Forest Service. And we've asked and they've approved our request to expand the trail system from this year. So a lot of these routes that are new are preliminary. They're things we're just trying out this spring, but we anticipate that.

58:49 Working to get paid for the Forest Service this summer will allow us to add some kilometers and increase the level of service we're providing out there. So that's the existing and new trails that we're proposing, and that blue, again, will be what we have currently. So it's a significant increase in the amount of kilometers we're going to put out there next year. Another thing that we've been anxious to do for a number of years is actually room on campus for the kids. And Rich McAteer of the school district,

59:19 Just accepted our proposal to do just that next winter. So our game plan is to actually groom right out the back door of the middle school, which is this building, and take advantage of the terrain. It's a school district property and put down a modest but very functional trail system so that the kids can get reduced to motor sports at PE or in after school programs. And also...

59:47 We've really enjoyed the work we've done this winter. It's been our privilege and we look forward to doing more next year. I think that's somewhat self-evident also. The summer and the fall are going to be the times during which we continue to try to

1:00:20 We knit together stronger relationships with both the town and the Forest Service, the mountain as well. We're actually getting together tomorrow morning with the mountain at Tamarack at their request and Mike Karcher's request, who is the gentleman who's solely responsible for biathlon that's been so successful in the last three years. So we're actually going to begin planning tomorrow. And we'll definitely have more to share with you at some point. And I appreciate your time tonight.

1:00:50 Certainly wanted to answer any questions if you have any. Questions? Wendy? Thank you, Brian, and congratulations to you and your Mammoth Nordic team for such a job well done. On the expanded trail system, is any of that going to be available to have dogs off leash? Do you know? That's something that we're discussing with the Forest Service. There's a reason why that's been a difficult thing to accomplish, and it's called the current law. Sure. So the areas that we're looking at are both

1:01:19 In the town boundary currently, near the Shady Rest area, but those are things that are policy-based that we can only participate in in good faith and do our best to try to accommodate those users in a way that is safe for them, healthy for all of us, and another fun way to get out in the winter with your dog.

1:01:38 Yeah, and absolutely, and I completely respect all of those reasons, and because I don't use the trail system that you guys have in the groom doesn't diminish its value by any way in my eyes, but to be perfectly honest, that's why I go elsewhere. So if that was something that was an option for next year, you know, I think that would be great, and it would certainly, I think there are a lot of people who would be appreciative of that if there's any option for that. It's entirely dependent on how the town and yourself and everybody else who's involved in...

1:02:07 Either addressing the current laws that are in place or providing a new area, and we're willing to do either. Great, thanks. Any other questions? Well, it's not really a question. I just wanted to thank every single one of those volunteers that put in those 435 hours for what they did in this past year. And I would hope that you are definitely considering continuing to apply for Measure R funds. Yes, that would be the case.

1:02:34 Great. Any other questions or comments? Just a comment. I've followed Brian and this whole adventure from its concept. It's been a long time coming. This is definitely a great opening and a great season that he's had, and I think we all owe Brian and all of Mammoth Nordic a big round of applause. Thank you very much. Thanks for all your hard work, Brian and Phil. You're very welcome. I'm going to take just a moment to unwind things here.

1:03:17 While you're doing that, I'll lead into, oh, okay, we've got more. Yeah, hold on. Item number two on the agenda is a public hearing, an appeal of the Planning Commission approval of Old Mammoth Place.

1:03:47 Mr. Mayor, I will be recusing myself due to owning real property within 500 feet of this parcel. Thank you, Joe. Before I open the public hearing, I have a couple of procedural matters that I'd like to tackle. There are five separate issues that are being brought up on the appeal, and I've had conversations with staff, and we feel that to present all five issues,

1:04:20 A presentation of all five issues by the appellant and staff's response is going to make things extremely confusing. So what I've decided to do is tackle each of these issues one by one so that the appellant will make a presentation and then staff will respond. And then if the real party in interest, the applicant,

1:04:48 Has any comments or questions. They'll have a chance to make themselves heard. And then we'll call for comments or questions from the public. And it's just a question of raising your hand and coming up to the lectern to speak. It's not a question of being for or against or neutral. We'll just take whatever testimony people want to have. And hold on, John. My request is that

1:05:18 Throughout this presentation this evening, just keep in mind that the council has had an opportunity to thoroughly review the appeals materials in our agenda packets. So we would really greatly appreciate it if you keep your remarks as brief as possible so that they're meant to inform the people looking in on TV and the people that are members of the public here.

1:05:45 You don't have to educate the council on each and every point. Okay, do we have a comment? John Walter speaking for the appearance. Neil, we have not organized it that way. We wanted, we also were worried about getting through this thing quickly. And what we thought we would do is try not to duplicate things too much. And we wanted to, in our,

1:06:21 Section to introduce and do a discussion of why we were making the appeal and what we were really asking for, then go into the technical detail and then summarize it. So we're not really, you know, set up and I'm afraid if we, you know, do one at a time, we're going to have, everybody's going to get up and want to talk to each point and we'll be here all night. We just weren't organized that way. Staff never talked to us about this. We were following the normal

1:06:50 You know, approach, we had a presentation ready, and we thought, well, if you want to make a, if you want to make an introductory statement, that's, that's, that's fine, I haven't opened the public hearing yet, but the point is that, wouldn't you be prepared to, I think we might, you know, be able to go halfway on that, if we could, you know, after the staff, if we could have a chance to introduce, whatever you want us to, and to summarize, and,

1:07:19 Summarize at the end what we're asking for. Okay. Fine. Thank you. Okay, with that, I'll go ahead and open the public hearing, and does staff want to make a brief presentation, sort of set the stage for what the Planning Commission did? Yes, we would. Yes, can you hear me? Yes, but keep them out there. Okay. I'll crane. So,

1:07:47 This item is the Town Council's consideration of an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of vesting tentative map 09003 and use permit 09003. This is the Old Mammoth Place project. At your last Town Council meeting, you considered the related zoning amendment for that item. On March 11th, the Planning Commission approved the Old Mammoth Place project, which included these use permits and tentative map permits that I've listed.

1:08:16 The application request was for a condominium hotel mixed-use project with up to 488 hotel rooms, 24 rooms of workforce housing, several outdoor public plazas, approximately 17,000 square feet of restaurant, 19,500 square feet of commercial, 9,500 square feet of conference area, and a spa and underground parking structure. This appeal is filed according to Municipal Code Section.

1:08:44 1768010 and this public hearing follows the procedures required by the Municipal Code. The appeal has five reasons or five points of contention. Failure to meet the general plan requirements for identification of community benefits and approval of density increases. Failure to make and support the detailed findings required under the community benefits incentive zoning policy. Failure to make appropriate findings under the project impact

1:09:13 Evaluation criteria. Failure to identify community benefits as required under the Clearwater Specific Plan. And finally, failure to comply with the analysis required under the California Environmental Quality Act. Our staff report is their own complete to you, and we've identified an appropriate response to all of those points. And our recommendation to you is that you uphold the planning commissions.

1:09:41 Approval and action. We found nothing in our analysis of these five points that would suggest that we failed to meet the policy's standards and conditions. I would like to note that recently two additional documents were submitted. One was an April 20, 2010 letter submitted by Mr. Bill Taylor. I believe you know Mr. Bill Taylor.

1:10:08 And also a letter dated April 20, 2010, prepared by Chute, Mahali, Weinberger, LLP regarding Old Mammoth Place Redevelopment Project, Appeal of the Planning Commission Approval of Vesting Tentative Map and the Use Permit. The essence of the Chute-Mahali letter is pointing out CEQA deficiencies. And because of the law and case law associated with CEQA, we're prepared to respond in detail to those comments.

1:10:38 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:11:02 Eddie Torres with RBF is our environmental consultant who prepared our conformance review as well as the environmental impact report certified for the Clearwater Specific Plan. We have Walter Kieser with EPS who is the town's economic consultant who peer-reviewed the Kaiser Marston financial analysis prepared by and for the applicant.

1:11:26 The applicant team is here as well. And then finally, our special legal counsel, Mr. Kevin Ennis from Richards Watson Gershon is here. And we want to make sure that we've covered some of the legal issues that have been filed with the appeal, with these documents submitted, and some of the comments that have been made in the public record through various newspapers, emails, and et cetera. I think

1:11:53 Our staff report is thorough and we're probably best able and more suited to answer your questions and following the statements that you'd like to have made by the appellants. But I will say one thing before I close. The Planning Commission's evaluation of this project has been excruciatingly thorough. It has been built on a very, very solid formulation of policy, starting with the general plan.

1:12:22 Proceeding through the policy formulation that Town Council directed us to complete, development of the Neighborhood District Special Study for North Old Mammoth Road, which is a planning document, was formulated with some of the top consultants in the country, Kathy Garcia with Wallace Roberts and Todd, who covered planning and urban design issues, and Mr. Bill Lee with Economics Research Associates.

1:12:51 One of the top real estate economists in the town. Fundamentally, the design program and concept presented in that study was this idea of a town center, and it included detailed estimates of retail square footage and program criteria. The specific plan followed this work. The planning commission worked on all of those documents. The town council considered those documents.

1:13:20 And accepted our policy. The recent work and evaluation of this project is also performed by an accomplished team of consultants. Jerry Kaiser and Reed with Kaiser Marston are top flight, top of the line real estate economic consultants who have worked for redevelopment agencies across the state, as well as Walter Kieser, who does that same work and is our peer review entity.

1:13:50 Those three firms are the top economic real estate firms in the state, and they have all contributed to this project. Their work has been done professionally, thoroughly, and is not half-baked. The design review, impact evaluation, and goal attainment has all been thoroughly documented and presented to the Planning Commission.

1:14:14 The Planning Commission held extensive public meetings, providing extensive public opportunity to participate in this, as well as the legally required notice public hearings. The Planning Commission's review was thorough. It resulted in changes to the projects. And that, of course, was after detailed staff analysis, negotiations, and required changes to the project that was submitted by the applicant. So all in all, this has been a really thorough evaluation.

1:14:44 I think the essence of the appeal is one, it's chipping around the edges of analysis and how policy should be formulated in the long run. I think that some of the concerns are expressly related to density and height. Some of the issues that you see are also rooted in financial opportunities and alternatives.

1:15:11 Considering in terms of this incentive zoning program is what is the best program for that site? Is more affordable housing more appropriate or is the program as presented more appropriate? Should impact fees be assessed or should they be fungibly exchanged for those other amenities and the cost and risk associated with those with retail, with conference space, and with open space? So those are policy tradeoffs.

1:15:40 They're not fundamentally about height and density. I think the impact evaluation and CEQA issues are fundamentally about program and density. So with that, I'd like to close my presentation, and then if you'll have appellants speak, we'll make notes, and then perhaps rely on questions from you to then answer. Does anybody have any questions now? I'm going to wait. Wait? Okay. Presentation by the appellant.

1:16:46 Oh, because of the change in the format, we're not going to try to use the PowerPoint, and that would probably take more time anyway. This appeal is, you've probably never seen such a strange cast of characters in front of you before. And nobody, I don't think, really was the key person in this thing. There were a few keys, but there was a lot of talk back and forth.

1:17:17 We talked about what was bothering us about this project, and it grew into an appeal, kind of at the last moment. And you have a copy, I think, of the appeal, and you can see the signatures, and it includes a lot of citizens, young and old. It includes business people. It includes real estate people. It includes council people and would-be council people.

1:17:44 Because we had sort of the basis of an organization. The advocates for Mammoth were not the key in this, but we've been kind of helping out and trying to pull it together because we strongly support it. Why are we appealing? Well, many of the things Mark said we agree with. Many of the things the project has talked about we agree with completely. There's been a lot of process. There's been a lot of give and take.

1:18:11 I've read Mark's things, Carney's things, all the changes that have been made as we went along, but what we're really talking about is things that have happened really within the last year, and this project has had the unfortunateness of being the first one along, and so of course we've been kind of inventing things as it went, and there's been a lot of meetings and things settled, but we just don't think are settled far enough. We think this plan...

1:18:40 It violates the general plan. We think that it violates the unfinished CBIS. We think it violates the population impact evaluation criteria. We think it violates CEQA. It's close. I mean, these things were all kind of in work, but they got pushed together at the end, and we think we're left unfinished. And we think that part of the things that came up that

1:19:10 We're worried about the most you're going to be addressing in your item three, too, is that we think this is giving away too many of the town's resources. These things have not been discussed over a couple of years. These things just appeared. This final use of CBiz is something quite new, and we think that it really needs to be finished up before we can go ahead.

1:19:35 We're also concerned that it was just recently that the project got to the point we saw things like economic assumptions. We're very concerned about the occupancy rates that were used. We're very concerned that we don't see an analysis of how much of this business that's going to go into this area is actually going to be taken from other areas. We really think that a very objective look at the economic stuff should have been done. We think it's kind of a sales job of what's been done.

1:20:05 You know, you've talked and we've talked to the water department. They're concerned about that this thing is looking at just the current project, not the water at build-out. And same with the air. Our air quality is getting worse and there's new data and it wasn't considered. So we think that this thing needs to be finished up right. So what we're asking to happen is that this...

1:20:34 Project be returned to the Planning Commission, and, you know, they need to finish the analyses that were not done, and Bill Taylor's going to specify more of those, and they're also in his letter, and that, you know, the list of community benefits is just, you know, it was supposed to flow from council down, and these things just don't exist.

1:21:02 And we think they need to be finished up. You know, it seems like it says you should look at incentives other than density. You haven't. You know, it should look at enhanced profits as well as land values. It doesn't down all the environmental work to build out. You need to use the up-to-date water supply. But what really needs to be done is that the council

1:21:31 She needs to finish. It's the CBiz, the lists of approved amenities and things like that. The council never finished. And so the planning commission is working with an unfinished CBiz policy. And we think you need to finish your work and then tell the planning commission to finish up the analysis, do the evaluations they were supposed to do.

1:22:01 And then bring it back, and it probably won't come to you then. It'll be, you know, an approved project. Bill Taylor is just, he's the guy that understands this, the planning documents and things like that better than most of us. So Bill has been digging through all the details. He's also then responded in detail to the planning staffs.

1:22:33 And so Bill has probably the most direct contact with the environmental questions and the detailed questions. Kirk has been looking at how we use the diff part of it and the housing.

1:23:02 Steve Schwinn wanted to make some comments about how this public process is really incomplete. And for all the meetings we've had, it is still an incomplete process. And the same Rick Wood wanted to make some comments as part of our appeal. And we had about a two-minute summary, and we're going to ask for our money back. Now, see, I don't know how that fits into what Mark's... Well, let me make a suggestion, John. Yeah.

1:23:32 Of the five points, you've just given the introduction and you passed out a PowerPoint and a summary of your thoughts. And my suggestion is that there are five appeals points, and I think that the way you've outlined things, it kind of fits pretty well into response to points either one, two, three, or five, four or five.

1:23:57 Why don't we just try that? I think it'll work out. Okay, let's give it a go. But I would like, because some of these, well, you know, some of the other comments maybe would have been better to, you know, appear in public comment because they're broader. But that's okay. That's okay because if these comments by the various different speakers that you've outlined here,

1:24:25 If they're not covered throughout the five points, then we can address those at the end of the five points before we close the public hearing. Okay. Okay? All right. We've got a chance, Rick. Questions? Okay, no questions? How about issue number one, Mark? Am I on PowerPoint issue number one? No, you're on your staff report. Okay.

1:25:03 What I'll do is, in our staff report, I'm going to cover the point, and then I'm going to hit some highlights in our staff response, and then... You know, I'm sorry. I should be asking for the appellant to present issue number one. Who wants to present issue number one? That works. Good evening, counsel. Good evening. As John mentioned, we had sort of choreographed our presentation a little bit differently, but I think we can respond.

1:25:49 What I'd like to do, though, is start with a response to Mr. Wardlaw's introduction, if I might, Mr. Mayor. Sure. And I just would like to touch on three things quickly. He had indicated that we were sort of chipping around the edges. And actually, I think that the issues raised by the appellants go directly to the heart of this approval. And that is, was the fundamental analysis required by you, the council, provided?

1:26:17 And ultimately long-range planning.

1:26:47 And finally, that there's a gap in the analytical process. There's a lot of work that was done to get to this point. We started with the general plan. We went to a North Old Mammoth Road district plan. We went to a Clearwater specific plan. We went to the CBiz. And each one deferred some decision to a later date. Suddenly, we leapt over that final policy decision and went right to an implementation phase. And it's that gap.

1:27:19 It is the heart of the concerned with this process. So having said that, give me a moment to find my notes here. So the first of the five points is the general plan. And specifically, the general plan has two policies and four actions directly related to community benefits and density bonuses. And I won't read the whole deal letter and the follow-up letter.

1:27:52 We'll point specifically to the requirement to develop and maintain a list of uses, facilities, infrastructure, programs, and services for use as community benefits. That is Action L3F3. And Action L3F4, which is develop size, space, and program characteristics and criteria for uses in facilities deemed as community benefits.

1:28:22 Those actions were never taken by the town. Again, this was a gap. This was the final part of the analytical process that was leapt over in order to get to the Old Mammoth Place approval. There's an integration between the general plan and CBIS that makes it hard simply to focus on that, but I'll simply say that CBIS should have been the final implementation phase.

1:28:58 But again, CBiz deferred that decision to some later process that was supposed to have taken place prior to the approval of the conditional use permit. And so ultimately I think that's the appellant's point with regard to the general plan. It does have consequences related to effective long-range planning, assurance that the community is getting the benefits they really want, and that they are not essentially overpaying for those benefits.

1:29:29 Thank you. Thank you, Bill. And Bill, if you want to take time at any point in this process to confer with the other five speakers, please feel free to do so. Or any of the speakers. Mark. Thank you. As we have mentioned in our staff report, overall the staff analysis and then the Planning Commission's action on this is based on

1:29:57 the evaluation of the merits and the impacts of this project. It's evaluating the extent of goal and policy attainment to the adopted documents, the general plan, the population at one time analysis, which is forefront in our staff analysis, the PIC evaluation, the CBiz, and also CEQA evaluation, as well as our traditional design review. We feel that that was very thorough, and the Planning Commission

1:30:24 Considered all of that information as well as the public comment that was provided or could have been provided through that public process. The information is not disparate. It's combined and coalesced in that staff report and the analysis of the project. The planning commission had that full information in front of them. They were engaged and enjoined and they considered all aspects of this project.

1:30:53 It is indeed a cohesive analysis and it knits together and weaves together these separate policy documents. In the writer's opinion, the appellant's, the old Mammoth Place application is not consistent with our policies. We would have pointed that out and we would not have brought forward a project that was inconsistent with our policies. The extensive analysis, changes, revisions.

1:31:22 And the extensive negotiations that occurred as this program was brought forward, the design and project review, the Planning Commission's deliberation is part of that review process. The analysis is focused not on one aspect, not on one entity, but on the triple bottom line and meeting the general plan vision statement. We've thoroughly reviewed in the staff report its...

1:31:49 Attainment to each of the major policy items in the general plan. That's our general plan goal attachment in that report. The project impact evaluation criteria is thorough and extensive, and it looks at in detail the social capital, the economic capital, and the environmental capital. And as I mentioned in my introduction, it is based on a

1:32:18 Broad framework and foundation of strategic planning that has been public and has been transparent. The CBIS policy is not actually left incomplete. The town council, when you first discussed the general plan, this council and predecessors,

1:32:41 The Town Council had the ability to consider various changes, land use district changes, density changes, and you chose not to. You chose to establish and proceed with more of a performance-based method to regulate these kinds of projects. The population at one time policy is completed, and we use that in our analysis of these projects. Stemming from that, and population at one time is only an analysis of units and people.

1:33:10 That same committee determined that the PI-C evaluation should be developed so that we were being more sophisticated and being able to identify impacts and identify where density is appropriate and acknowledge that something that might be located in the bluffs has a completely different impact characteristic than something that was located in Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. So we feel these town policies have indeed been

1:33:40 In terms of the incentive zoning program, we noted that it is a bridge policy document meant to be ultimately completed through the zoning code update process, and we're working on that and we'll get to that. We did not ever infer that no project could come forward or be evaluated without total and finite completion of that CBIS process. That's why it's a bridge document.

1:34:06 So that's why we're here. I can understand people being concerned with

1:34:33 What looks like different incremental pieces that may to them not look woven together, but it is the staff analysis and that comprehensive report that ties them together. I think we'll hold on our detailed comments about the financial evaluation. I think that might be more appropriate to when we get to DIF and housing.

1:35:02 Unless you'd like to hear from Walter at this time. Questions? Help me if you would here, Mark, because there are two specific accusations, if you will. L3F3 and L3F4. It says specifically that the town has never taken action on either of those. Is it to be my understanding that the reason that we haven't taken action on those as of yet is that that's still in

1:35:32 Evolving CBIS policy determination? In part. When the CBIS program, when that policy was formulated, one of the items that it included was a list of amenities, and the town council struck that list of amenities with the direction that those should be developed through the district planning process. There was recognition that an equestrian facility perhaps is not most well suited in North Old Mammoth Road.

1:36:00 Our policy struck that particular list and you directed us to develop that more fully through district planning. The North Old Mammoth Road district study included the list from the general plan and the town council proactively modified that list. That list was then incorporated in the Clearwater specific plan and for all intents and purposes and it was the knowledge of that time that that specific plan and that list

1:36:27 was what we would use in part, but not exclusively, to guide any future incentive zoning program. That specific plan also included reference to the to-be-approved incentive zoning program, and it has since been improved in this stage of the policy development. And I think it's important to note that policy development is not, it doesn't just end. And I think in this case, there are good points that are being made, which,

1:36:57 We do want to test and improve and refine the incentive zoning program. But I think there is no paradigm of perfection for policy. Conditions, circumstances, needs will all change and evolve over time. And so as we initiate and then refine, you will always modify these efforts. You're considering modifications to diff in housing later this evening, which is...

1:37:26 That very issue. Conditions change. So we believe that L3F3 was met specifically through this process, through the specific plan and the technical analysis of financial analysis conducted by KMA and reviewed by EPS. L3F4, which was developing the size, space, and program characteristics and criteria and uses in facilities deemed as community benefits, we used as guidance

1:37:55 The information developed through the condo hotel criteria. So we presented that policy to you and we had consensus. We did not try to push it through to adoption by resolution. It was tacitly understood that that would be incorporated in projects as they come forward and it has been done so with the Mammoth Crossings project. We used those characteristics of

1:38:18 Conference space and hotel operations in the approval of the Holiday House project. So those policies are being applied. They are included in this specific plan and part of this particular project. I think we also recognized in incentive zoning and with condo hotel, it is not to the town's best interest to precisely define an amount of retail that might occur on all projects.

1:38:45 We felt, we took from Council that we needed some flexibility to develop the appropriate program to the appropriate site and appropriate location. It is not our understanding from where we left standards that we were going to list in detail an exact square footage size for each and every project type. It would not be practical nor feasible. And so developing some standards, we have done that.

1:39:13 A range of square footage, for example, for condo hotels. But for a hotel, I think that discussion that was held with condo hotels, what do we do with a small boutique hotel? How is that different from a major conference type hotel, which you might see at Sierra Star? And how is that different from this project? So we applied more flexible standards, and I think it would be very difficult if not

1:39:41 Practically impossible to come up with a finite and discreet list of all amenities that would be associated with a project and apply it uniformly throughout the town. Mark, can I, as a follow-up question, can I quickly ask legal counsel to see if he shares your interpretation of whether or not we have addressed these two action items? Yes, and I've read the staff report that's presented that analyzes

1:40:10 I would say if you get to the comments on the financial valuation of the community benefits, I think you'll have some more information that responds to that. I think in total it does then adequately respond to those two criteria of your general plan. Thank you. Any other questions? Mark, so what you're saying is that we really don't have any kind of a list or anything.

1:40:38 That would tell us what the required public facilities, in regards to how this project fits into the North Old Mammoth Road District plan. We don't really have a list of public facilities and amenities that are needed to fulfill the goals of that district plan. No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying that list is contained in the Clearwater specific plan that was adopted by the Town Council, and we used that to guide this evaluation, and the applicant used that to guide their programming and design.

1:41:08 Okay, and I guess my other question would be, you refer a lot to policy. Who actually makes policy in the town? The town council adopts policy. Okay, thank you. Mark, I had a kind of a procedural question. You've now seen a major project go through the planning commission, and you're witnessing this process unfold this evening. From those two processes,

1:41:34 They're going to become, you know, concerns are going to be listed. Are you keeping track of those concerns and will you take them to the Planning Commission so that this can be revisited by Planning Commission and then recommendations made to Council? Or are you expecting direction specifically from us on that? No, absolutely. We're making lists. It's your last Council.

1:41:55 Meeting joint session with the Planning Commission. He specifically agreed with the Planning Commission that we should have a follow-up study session on incentive zoning and also on the PI-C. And so we're taking notes. And in fact, the comments by the appellants are very useful and helpful. Thank you. Let's see. The appellants, do you wish to add anything further on issue number one? Issue number one, because Mark Kirkstaff, one of the appellants,

1:42:23 On issue number one, Mark mentioned CBiz in the beginning of his remarks, and although this isn't a hearing on CBiz, CBiz has been applied to this particular project. CBiz has multiple inconsistencies in it, and that is part of what this whole appeal is about. If you look at B for the bullet points,

1:42:49 And it mentions the municipal code three different times. And it says that these include, but are not limited to, these are supposed to be applied. So on one hand, we can exempt fees, and the other hand, the language in here says we're supposed to apply fees. That's just one example, not counting the fact that this particular policy uses the word shall 26 times. You shall do this, you shall. It's not.

1:43:17 Some may, you know, some maybe or that it could be looked at later down the road. It's saying do it now. And it's saying apply it now. And unfortunately, the Old Mammoth Place, you know, project got caught in the middle of this crossfire. If you want, and it's not CBiz that's on trial here, but the fact is that CBiz has multiple consistencies in it. It requires very specific things in it.

1:43:47 And guess what? That's what this appeal is about. So when Mark is mentioning CBiz and saying that, oh, look, you know, this culminates all the different activities that we have been slowly going through, the district plans and everything else. But again, I can read it to you. You know, one place it's saying you can exempt the fee. Municipal code is enforced. And the last thing I want to say is that

1:44:13 It wasn't until March 11th, the day that Old Mammoth Place was approved, that you got, or that the Planning Commission got a legal opinion that says policy doesn't trump municipal code. And that's why they changed the use, the conditions of approval, they changed the language because the code has to be changed later on.

1:44:40 So those are the kinds of gaps and the inconsistencies that have flourished in this whole process. And I think that the planning commission did an excellent job dealing with the tools that they were doing, but the tools are incomplete or inconsistent. Thank you, Kirk. Neil, I'm not sure how Mark's outline goes here, but the one thing I think that if we're talking specifically about the general plan right now, it's one thing good to keep in mind.

1:45:14 You know, the CQA mitigations and things like that, they were, the things that are in the general plan, are to mitigate it to make it to the number three alternative. And selecting that alternative and the impacts associated with that alternative, which assume certain things that build out, is something that's supposed to flow down from the general plan. And almost all the analyses done on this project

1:45:42 Did not consider build out. They just considered what the current situation is. So that's our major comment under the CEQA part, but it really flows to all of this analysis. And particularly when you're talking about the general plan, because the population analysis, the impact analysis, and these things flow down from the general plan and the CEQA documentation. And there's no cumulative analysis to...

1:46:11 That should lead you to the conclusions whether in the long run we're going to just come on a first serve, first there basis and then quit when we run out of air and water or we're going to go back and look at our general plan and work to it as we go along. The analyses just aren't there to show what we're doing. Thank you. Bill? Bill Taylor again.

1:46:43 On behalf of the appellants. And Mr. Wardlaw touched on a number of issues that I think we'll actually get to later. He spoke to Triple Bottom Line, PI-C, CBIVs. Those are items that will come later. So I'm only going to speak to two points that directly address the L3F3 and L3F4 policies of the general plan. Mr. Wardlaw said that the list is in the Clearwater Specific Plan.

1:47:12 And that the requirements of L3, F3 are met through the Clearwater Specific Plan. And I'd just like to read what the specific plan says. There is a list, and it includes indoor meeting and conference space, outdoor public events plaza, commercial retail and restaurant uses along Old Mammoth Road, underground parking, pedestrian and vehicular mid-block connectors, dedication of property,

1:47:39 For achieving, for the purpose of improving public rights of way and sidewalks and achieving complete streets and public access to the events plaza and the block connector secured two easements. However, the preface to that list is the final community benefits will be determined pursuant to future policy. The implication then was that PI-C, or excuse me, that CBiz was that policy, yet CBiz goes on.

1:48:09 To say that the Council will adopt a list. So one of the points that Mark Stewart-Law made that I think was important is this was intended to be a bridge policy, and it was not the intent to imply that no project had come forward. I don't think we're disagreeing with that. What it was suggesting is that as part of the analysis of this project, the analysis necessary to build a sound bridge,

1:48:42 With firm footings and a good superstructure should have been included. And it was not. Okay. Any comments from the applicant? No comments from the applicant. General comments from the public on issue number one. Issue number two. Yes? Come on down. Following the next item is, I presume, community benefits incentive zone.

1:49:48 It's failure to make and support the detailed findings required under the CBIS policy. Detailed findings, I think. Well, we've already touched on this, that the CBIS policy includes numerous lists of findings where they're required, and we have everything from policy B2, policy D4. I won't go through all of them, but essentially, I'm going to get right to what I think may be some of the critical findings.

1:50:24 Policy B4 requires that the project does not result in unacceptable environmental or other impacts as assessed through CEQA and the PAOT and impact assessment. Because PAOT or CEQA and PIC analyses were incomplete, this finding can't be made. The policy B2 we've already discussed, it requires that the town council adopt a list of allowable community benefits.

1:50:58 Does not defer that to the Planning Commission, does not defer that to any other source. And you have not done that as of this time. Requiring that benefits be limited to items in addition to any items that are or would be required under other provisions of the General Plan or Municipal Code. A lot of the benefits could or would flow from other planning processes. We cited the North Village specific plan.

1:51:36 And its implementation. In fact, during the Planning Commission hearing, the applicant's team cited development in the North Village as an example of setting policy that was applicable to this project. So I think that's in fact appropriate. Most of these or many of these items could have been achieved through procedures other than CBIS. There's discussion of marginal cost of community benefits.

1:52:11 And I'll just pick on one item, which is the public events plaza. The marginal cost is not the cost of building the plaza. The marginal cost is the cost of providing access to the plaza, providing the public use of the plaza. That space was going to have to be developed for something, whether it was buildings or some other open space for the project. So the marginal cost is that incremental cost. Likewise with...

1:52:42 The mid-block connector. The marginal cost is what was necessary to provide the public benefit, not the full development cost of the mid-block connector. That kind of analysis wasn't done. And in the rebuttal provided by staff, they said, well, that's not the customary way to do it. That may or may not be true. But it was the policy that you adopted. And if that policy was not going to be followed,

1:53:15 They either should have come to you and said, you think it should be done differently, or at least the analysis should have said, here's what the adopted policy is, here's why we're doing something different, and here's the change. I think those are sufficient to make the case. I'd like to go back to one other comment, the prior one, which had to do with the community benefits and establishing thresholds, and Mr. Wardlaw referred to the

1:53:49 Condo Hotel Policy. Earlier he had referred to the Bill Lee Report. And I was interested, one of the things that has been hard, we haven't established as a community what our priorities are. The project's proposing 20 square feet of conference area per room. The Bill Lee Report for this size project was recommending 80. So which is the right threshold? What should we be using? How do we reconcile those?

1:54:21 That's the work that either should have been done ahead of this project or in the detailed project analysis. Let's see. I think I'll just close with the Planning Commission CBIS findings, which says the proposal will be consistent with the accepted list and prioritization established in D2 of CBIS policies adopted with the Clearwater Specific Plan. As I pointed out earlier, the Clearwater Specific Plan

1:55:06 Deferred to a future policy which would have been CBiz. CBiz again deferred to some future action which never occurred. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Staff. Thank you. There are a number of points in this. I'm sorry. You want to be heard? I mean, since we changed the format, I mean, this is the issue that I was focused on. So let me put my comments into the records and then...

1:55:34 I'll sit down and shut up. Have a cookie? I don't know. Again, my name is Kirk Stapp, one of the poems. My comments focus on CBIS, and there was a lengthy introduction about this particular policy. According to the staff report, CBIS, and I guess the question is, you know, what are its mandates and requirements, CBIS,

1:56:03 And how were they applied or misapplied to this particular process? According to the town staff report, CBIS is the outcome of two years of research, 14 meetings, a non-binding meeting with you, and two meetings with council. According to staff, CBIS is not only the outcome of the research and public meetings, it is a cumulative document with which

1:56:31 To evaluate projects. And what it states in D5 in the CBIS policy is major project application in process at the time of the adoption of CBIS policy recommendation shall be evaluated against the policy frameworks and criteria outlined herein, outlined in CBIS. So here the developer comes forward and he's caught in between this. And if there's inconsistencies in CBIS, it even makes it worse.

1:57:00 And it makes it that much more difficult for the Planning Commission. The staff report for you on page 6 states, okay, assessment against these adopted CBIS criteria alongside the financial analysis provided by the applicant and peer reviewed by the town's consultant were the basis, were the basis for the findings made by the Planning Commission in its approval of Old Mammoth Place.

1:57:29 Use Permit and Track Map. You know, first of all, he refers to a peer review. Well, according to the financial consultant, there was a collaboration that was going on, and that would be an interesting debate to have. Again, what are the CBiz mandates and requirements, okay, mandates, and how are they applied or misapplied to the old Mammoth Lake project?

1:57:55 CBiz mandates B2, and this is the one, and we just confronted the fact that, oh yeah, they were approved, or if you read your agenda bill real carefully, they were accepted by council. But B2 says that the town council adopts by resolution a prioritized list of allowable community benefits for which incentives may be granted.

1:58:21 So we go back to this question, did the council actually adopt by resolution, you know, this list of community benefits? How was this applied? It wasn't. It wasn't in the list. You know, staff failed to carry out CBIS policy B2. Bring before council for approval by resolution a prioritized list or a list of allowable community benefits.

1:58:46 Didn't say it had to be accepted or identified in the Clearwater Specific Plan. It said, you guys need to do this. And staff did not do that, carry that out or make sure that was done before they brought this project before the Planning Commission. CBIS further mandates D2A that the Planning Commission find that the developer proposal is in conformance.

1:59:13 With the accepted list and prioritized established by the town council. Well, it was never adopted. There was no resolution. So, again, staff and planning commission worked through 50-some, you know, meetings and everything, but when it came down to putting the final nail on this and resolving it, some things weren't done. CBiz A2 and B2 requires a community business to be limited.

1:59:42 To items, and I quote, in addition to any items that are or would be required under other provisions of the General Plan or Municipal Code. In other words, above and beyond those that would be otherwise required through the application process. So staff, you know, if you read this, and I read it at least four times, it seems to provide a meandering response, you know, mixing community benefits.

2:00:11 With mitigation required. So what I mean by that is that, again, wait a minute, would this have been required? Just say it, you know? And what I mean by that, yes or no was a right-of-way required if they went through the regular process without CB. Yes or no, was it required that they had to provide the connector tree? Yes or no?

2:00:34 Don't give me all these explanations about, you know, well back we did this and this was accepted and this was, look, it says you can't do this. Just give us a yes or no. Tell the planning commission, tell the developer yes or no that they do this. CBEDS requires that, this is C2, CBEDS requires that the review of discretionary development incentive density increases. And again I quote,

2:01:02 Shall evaluate the scale of the community benefits provided compared to the scale of incentives provided. Incentives will be granted, again this is quoting, incrementally commiserate, I'm sorry, commiserate to that relationship. Based on that evaluation, any single amenity or combination of amenities may not qualify for maximum discretionary development incentive available.

2:01:31 In the town's staff's agenda bill, they claim, and again I quote, the planning commission did explicitly consider, quote, explicitly consider the issue of incremental density increases rather than the full double density requested by the applicant. Staff quotes a March 5, 2010 memorandum from EPS, the town's financial consultant,

2:01:59 Provided to the Planning Commission, notes that a decreased density, and this is another quote, from your consultant, a decreased density or additional cost of any sort will simply make financial performance worth, delaying the time when the project could be constructed or precluded altogether. The town's consultant goes on to note, and again, I'm quoting staff now,

2:02:25 The note and the consultant, the notion that there is a linear relationship between density and profit is illusionary. But there is no, well maybe there's not a straight line, but certainly it can be calculated. First, explicit condition by the planning committee are considered, explicitly considered by the planning commission is not an evaluation. And that's what it says, you shall evaluate.

2:02:53 And that's, again, this is the problem with the policy, but it was a policy that was put on the developers back as well as, you know, put on the commission to try to figure out how to implement. I don't believe. Second, what was explicit considered by the planning commission was the response of your town financial consultant in response to Mammoth Lake Housing, Mammoth Lake Trails and Public Access.

2:03:22 A letter was written by both of those groups that said, we question giving away these DIF fees and housing fees. And here's staff using this as a document to support, supposedly, an evaluation, and they cherry pick one sentence or two sentences out of it. That's not the way the planning commission or your staff should be functioning.

2:03:50 Other, these are other, and I can go on, but I'll be as brief as I can. Other misapplications of CBIS. Misapplication D2A. CBIS mandates or requires an assessment of the economic value of the proposed development incentives to the applicant. Based upon, again, policy A1C, they should have considered both, and this is what Bill was referring to, the residual land value and development profits.

2:04:19 From the density increases, yet only residual land values were evaluated. Misapplication D2B, CBIS requires a marginal cost. And again, that's what Bill was pointing out. You know, getting in and out is the cost to a plaza area. All right? And to do all of that, you're beginning to say, well, wait a minute. And maybe that's a judgment from the staff's part or the consultant's part.

2:04:48 Misapplication, D2D, CBIS requires, okay, that the reasonable nexus between benefits provided and incentives granted be explained. In other words, why the 244 additional rooms? So you have this incremental question, and you also have...

2:05:10 Okay, this requires nexus is not simply an economic argument, and it goes to your social and environmental benefits as well. And this is the biggie. This is where it really breaks down. Misapplication is my last one. Sorry, I'm being so windy. Misapplication D2, CBiz states.

2:05:30 Applicant submittal of sufficient financial evaluation analysis information and evidence to allow for a reasonable assessment of the value of benefits offered in what was put in the papers, $26.2 million, relative to it being sought. What were they seeking? Increased density of 244 rooms, including proposed community benefits and conformance with the accepted list.

2:05:59 Oh my God, we don't have a list, but it's the accepted list and prioritization established in B2. So the financial analysis should have looked at the community benefit and what the developer was receiving, 244 rooms.

2:06:20 If a list exists, but if we want to play that game and go down that road, if a list exists, the financial consultant for the developer clearly understood the next step in the CBIT policy would be. Here's what the financial consultant, the developer's consultant said. He understood the policy. The developer's consultant states in his December 18th CBIT financial analysis report, and I quote, as, and this is right on this front page,

2:06:50 As specified in the CBiz policy, the owner of the property requesting density upgrades must submit a financial analysis to the town that estimates the value of the community benefits generated, open plaza, regardless of how you analyze it, the community benefits generated by the proposed project relative to the potential economic benefits.

2:07:18 Accruing to the owner as a result of density upgrades. So the financial consultant, how did this get changed? How did it get changed from we're going to do one analysis to now we're just going to look at the benefits and the construction costs and we're going to present that and then look at the EIF fees that were exempted. So how did that happen? And that's something that I think you as a council needs to be talking to staff about.

2:07:48 Bottom line, the developer financial consultant knew what he was supposed to analyze. The town staff knew what the language in CBS required. The town consultant admits he can't integrate the variables of density to profit. And if you look at the March 5 letter that Mark quoted in there, that the consultant says you can't find a linear connection between density and profit, or he can't find a...

2:08:18 A calculation that integrates the variables of density of profit. Town staff failed to take the policy conflicts in the community of benefits and increased density back to council for clarification. Somewhere along the line in front of these 55 meetings, especially the last one, somebody should have raised a red flag and said, we've got to get a clarification from the council. That didn't happen.

2:08:49 The developers in a limbo, certainly the planning commission is angry with me for bringing all these up, but the fact remains that there are problems and there are gaps in our policies, and this has created this appeal. I'm sorry for taking so much time. Thank you, Kirk. Response.

2:09:14 Yes, a number of points have been raised that are separate and discreet, and I'd like to ask Ellen to summarize the payout analysis. So this is our population at one time, density, and its conformance to the general plan and the general plan FEIR. Well, I think quite simply put, the POT analysis that was included in the staff report to the planning commission concluded that

2:09:45 Even counting the additional units in the Clearwater Specific Plan, the Old Mammoth Place Project, that the overall build-out of the general plan remained, or the overall build-out projected remained consistent with that previously projected in the general plan. So there was not a discrepancy or a substantial change upwards in PAOT as a result of the

2:10:11 Would be as a result of the adoption of the Clearwater Specific Plan and the maximum density allowed for in that project. So ultimately, the density build-out fits within our parameters. And for those comments that have been received about water capacity, air quality capacity, our approach is that we have left the maximum

2:10:42 Land use densities in place, and rather than going through extensive downzonings across the community, you chose a performance-based analysis, and that's what, in part, the incentive zoning process is, and that's what the discretionary review process results in after evaluation of CEQA, the identification of impacts.

2:11:05 And their mitigation measures. And the more complete view provided by the project impact evaluation criteria. I'll ask Ellen to also provide a synopsis about the force of the project impact evaluation criteria and how we use it in this evaluation and how we originated it. Thank you. The PISC framework is, as Mr. Taylor suggested,

2:11:35 A comprehensive analysis, a broad analysis that looks at triple bottom line impacts and as that policy was being formulated that was very much the emphasis of the committee that helped to develop it that we wanted to see all three of those parts evaluated equally and that broad assessment done. There was an assertion I believe that a consideration of those cumulative impacts relative to

2:12:05 The adopted or the accepted alternative three of the general plan that they were not incorporated into the PISC policy, that's incorrect. Quantitative thresholds where they could be established were and are reflected in the PISC framework and an evaluation provided against them. Those quantitative thresholds are not the entire basis of the PISC framework. The PISC framework includes a number of qualitative considerations that go beyond.

2:12:32 Environmental Concerns, which are extremely important, but also do look at the social and economic benefits that a project would provide, things like jobs, building our recreation capacity, and accomplishing really a very broad range of goals in the general plan. And the Pisces Framework Policy that was adopted by resolution by the Council is quite clear that

2:12:54 It's not intended to replace or supplant other analysis. It's intended to be informed by it, to incorporate things like the CEQA review that was done, to not require additional analysis, and later, Eddie Torres and Kevin Ennis will be able to speak to the cumulative analysis that was done in the CEQA, but that cumulative analysis, which the PISC policy does not call for to be redone, to be included in the framework.

2:13:19 Was incorporated into the PISC and was reported to the Planning Commission as one of the bases for their decisions. So I think there's some perhaps misstatements about the intent of the PISC policy. I think in reviewing that framework you'll see it is a very broad range. It does balance each of those impacts. Water quality and air quality are certainly an important consideration of that PISC policy, but they are not the only thing that's being considered in that.

2:13:48 In that broad framework assessment, it's the balance of all three parts and pieces, economic, social, environmental. And by summary, that is the best tool we have to quantify and qualify how we're meeting the triple bottom line. CEQA does not deal with economic issues. Design does not deal with economic issues. There's nothing we have that actually deals with implementing strategic plans, which...

2:14:17 which this specific plan is designed to do versus just the historical zoning that we're working within. Particularly if you go by its title, most of us were under the impression that, you know, the price analysis was to evaluate impacts. Yes, that, after you evaluate the impact, somebody looked.

2:14:40 The council is going to weigh off those impacts versus community, solid, community benefits, jobs and things like that. But I was certainly under the impression that it's spelled out in Pisces that it's going to evaluate those impacts against what we'd said we were going to have as our goal in our master plan and our master EIR for the town. And how you can add 240 rooms and not...

2:15:10 I just don't understand. I don't think that we've done the thing.

2:15:36 That our CEQA analysis, which looks specifically at those quantifiable factors, that that's complete and that's accurate. And we'll discuss that in one of our next bullet point items. Once again, I'm a little lost as to where we are in the sequence because I thought that the next item was supposed to be failure to identify community benefits under the Clearwater Specific Plan, and we instead have been talking about PI-C. But I would suggest that that's fine.

2:16:06 We really covered the Clearwater Specific Plan under the CBIS discussion. This gets to the interrelatedness of all these. And so my – I think what I would do is suggest that we are now on PI-C. And just speak to staff comments and – Hold on, Bill. You're talking – you're saying we're now on number three. We've still got a couple of steps to go before we hit three.

2:16:34 Which order were you taking? I was working off the appeal. Our next point that we wanted to address was the specific financial evaluation associated with the Incentive Zoning Program and Mr. Stapp's comments. Okay, well let me then just speak. Would you rather hold Pisces? Okay. I just make note that that was extensively discussed and we'll do that. Okay. Okay.

2:17:03 Comments from the appellate? All we've covered so far, the last appellate conversation brought up payout, PISC, and the financial analysis. And so if you want to hear any rebuttal or comment about payout or the introduction to PISC, do that. There's extensive information that requires addressing about the incentive zoning analysis, the financial aspect.

2:17:33 Can I ask a question? When are we going to do that? Under three? Now. Now? Now. Okay. If you're amenable. Sure. Just one quick question. Kirk brought up an explanation of marginal costs, specifically the plaza area, connector road. Did we do that analysis? Yes. That's next. Okay. Thank you.

2:17:58 I actually had a quick question too, Mark. When we adopted the Clearwater-specific plan, we did that by resolution or ordinance? Ordinance. And the ordinance in this case supersedes the effect of a resolution. And so I think, you know, you can reasonably debate that, but it's more difficult to modify an ordinance than it is a resolution. One quick question before we go to the financials. If I recall, I'm pretty sure about this, I just want to confirm that we

2:18:26 Passed the Clearwater Specific Plan prior to developing and passing the CBIS policy. Yes. Thank you. Financials? Yes. Okay, so to introduce this, we are not perfect. We acknowledge that. We have had a heavy caseload. We've carried a lot of work forward in this short period of time. And we acknowledge that there are going to be some inconsistencies. Also, however, as directed, we're still required to process these applications.

2:18:54 And we are not cherry-picking from policies. That is not what staff does. And I don't want you to be left with an illusion that there are errors and omissions and staff is directing something. We are not. We are only here to provide the analysis and recommendations to the bodies that work on this and to the public that can opine. In the Resolution 0955, which is that adopting the community benefits incentive zoning policy,

2:19:22 We're working within that policy structure, not making it up. Item number four, which is item A number four, says in order to balance the desire to achieve benefits described in this policy with the cumulative impacts of growth, impact fees, including affordable housing, development impact fees and public art fees, they are not applied to square footage or density provided as community benefits or granted as an incentive. So that's a policy statement that we don't have a lot of flexibility to interpret.

2:19:51 That was completed through that very exhaustive process. That item was specifically identified in the staff report that finaled this resolution. And then it goes on to say in A5 that this community benefits incentive zoning policy is intended as a bridge framework to be applied to all pending project applications and plan documents until the town has completed community planning, which is also

2:20:18 Synonymous with neighborhood district planning documents and codified them. Once codified, the town will have substantially established land use and development policies, including clearly specified limits on height and density that implement the town of Mammoth Lakes general plan. That tells us, and as your work program has directed, it is important to complete neighborhood district planning. That information and process sets policies. In this case, we completed the neighborhood district plan.

2:20:47 Plan study for North Old Mammoth Road. Its overall codification is pending, but your action on the Clearwater Specific Plan codified those standards. They were heavily debated for that particular block. We've simply applied those standards. This does not say it is a bridge document and no projects shall be processed. It says until. So the intent of this policy is to be the bridge until it's further evolved. It's not meant to say stop.

2:21:15 Go no farther. A number of comments have been made about financial methodology, and I think there's a lot of information that needs to be provided about financial analysis and what it means and how it really happens. It is not practical, nor is it the intent of any of these policies, for an applicant to come into the staff and say,

2:21:42 The base is picking number 40. Here's a project, and I'd like to come back next week at 50 units per acre in a different envelope. And then after you say that's good, I'll come back with 60, and then I'll come back with 70, so forth and so on. This analysis is typically done through a project proposal. We're looking, and embedded in this action is the financial analysis and the merits of

2:22:10 The amenities to costs and financial feasibility. And also, it is the design review. The planning commission specifically considered the height associated with this project. These plans that we've showed you before represent some of the iterative steps that show far greater lot coverage and lower building heights. So the intent of this policy, which is to look at incremental development standards as well as incremental programming,

2:22:39 And with that, I'd like to ask Mr. Kieser to explain or respond to a host of the comments that have been made in writing and in this presentation about the financial analysis, because we think that we have completely met the intent of this ordinance, and if there were, and we acknowledge that there are some incongruities with them that need to be corrected, but that should not

2:23:07 Have a merit or bearing on this analysis because we've met the intent. Walter. Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. My name is Walter Kieser. I'm managing principal with the firm Economic and Planning Systems, an urban economics firm. It's a pleasure to be here tonight. My first question to Mark is exactly how much time I have. How much time does he have? Well, you know, keep in mind, Walter, we've...

2:23:35 Thoroughly reviewed the materials. I understand that. And I'm saying I'm making that comment somewhat in jest because this is a topic, of course, that we've placed to put a lot of work into on your behalf as well as Kaiser Marston, Reid O'Hara here with us tonight. And so we could talk about this till midnight. And we'd be happy to. Trust me.

2:23:59 It would make me a happy camper. How about, you know, five minutes or so? What I want to do is try to hit some highlights here that I think are very important, and I understand that you have looked at carefully the work that Kaiser Marston has done as well as our work, and I don't want to repeat that, and frankly, we have responded in writing repeatedly to a number of the comments that have been here tonight, and none of those responses

2:24:28 Have been addressed. So it's a little interesting that we keep coming back to these same things and the very efforts that we've made previously to respond to these important and valid questions have not been acknowledged. But I want to start by making, so I want to just quickly go through some of these points which I think I can't get kind of highlights on with respect to our analysis. First, I want to talk about this process of peer review. What we did.

2:24:55 is entirely consistent with professional practice. Kaiser Marston and Economic and Planning Systems and ERA before us are the premier urban economics firms in the state of California. We have a very good and well-earned reputation working for public sector clients, private sector clients, etc., etc. We do not mess around. We represent our clients' interests. We follow very precise professional standards. We have dozens, tens,

2:25:27 Hundreds of years of experience between us. And I think it's very important to understand that one can certainly question what we've done and how we've done it, but I think it's very important not to question our integrity or professionalism. I think that's very important, personally. The peer review process was done in the normal fashion. When we're doing peer review, we typically sit down.

2:25:51 With the person that we're peer-viewing to understand what they're about to do and how and talk about it and then let them do it and then go through our review. We follow the exact process that we normally follow. Very, very important. And I think that the process went well. I think there were changes made to the analysis. I think the information that was presented is a very reasonable given context. So I want to talk a little bit about methods used. We came to this, the CBIS process.

2:26:21 And it admittedly, from the discussion tonight, does have some complexities and things that are unusual and unique to the situation and issues about policy and who approved what and when. What we need to do from what we did, we, both Kaiser Marston and herself, need to do from the start standpoint, start is to normalize this, to put this in some context that we can actually analyze. And we use methods that we are accustomed to using.

2:26:49 In development agreement negotiations, development and disposition agreement negotiations, transactions that we've used throughout California and the rest of the western United States for the last 30 or 40 years. So what you have available to you is a lot of experience in us trying to bring our professional experience working with these kinds of arrangements in many other places and trying to say, well, given what they're trying to do, what should we do here? What's the proper way of doing this?

2:27:17 And we made a series of decisions that are reflected in the technical work before you. And I think that's very important because we're trying and a part of this process, and I think the word that sometimes we use is heuristic. It's a learning process. Sure, we're developing and evolving this policy. We knew we were doing that. And the benefit of what's been done is that we have hopefully raised the standards and provided guidance as to how these kinds of analysis should be conducted.

2:27:48 Now, in some cases, that's going to vary or question certain aspects of the CBIS policy as written as policy because those things may not be reasonable in our opinion or useful or relevant to the cause or purpose that you're trying to achieve. So that's what we're trying to do with our work. Now, so we're trying to, again, normalize this process into something that we think we can analyze. I want to talk a little bit about first this issue of why we chose this.

2:28:18 And stuck with this residual value analysis. Knowing all of these different methods and deploying them repeatedly in many situations, we always want to pick the method that we think focuses on the right issues. One of the first things that Reed and Jerry and I did when we sat down and we looked at this situation, we had 15 different ways of doing this, which way is the best way of getting to the point? And we chose that one. We rejected

2:28:48 Discounted cash flow analysis for about six reasons, which I can talk about all night, but we rejected them from professional standards because we did not think that that would produce information useful in this case. And it is true, and consistent with what I said in my written work, that there isn't a linear relationship between density and profit. In fact, this analysis, the static analysis has been conducted, suggests quite the opposite, which is kind of interesting.

2:29:17 So the point there is that this idea that just because a project is larger and has more retail value suggests that it has more financial capacity relative to its size is not true. It turns out that in looking at this project from that kind of standpoint, or if you even think about it in that context, all sorts of issues arise.

2:29:41 That might produce, like I say, information that would be not useful in this context. So that's why we stuck, and we by the way recommend for future CBIS analyses to stick to something that is like residual value analysis that produces clear information about what a land use decision imparts back to the land in value. And that's why we chose that. And again, I could go on and on and on and talk about this. Now, with respect to this issue of linear relationship between

2:30:11 Value of a project saying, well, let's go from 40 units to 44 to 48 to 40, you know, like that. That's not the way the world works. That's not how projects are built. That's not how you attract the operators and the retailers or whoever else you want to do this community. Projects come as wholes. They're wholes. They're vital, living, interacting things, and they come in units, not in incremental parts.

2:30:40 And they're related internally and externally to other things. That's what we do as urban economists. We figure those sorts of things out. And in figuring that out, we're referencing the market, we're referencing what investors need to have to make things work, et cetera, et cetera. That's just the way the world works. That's the way investment occurs. And as it turns out, if there were a project, there may be a project.

2:31:08 That is some incremental density, but when we're looking at this particular project, it seemed to us that, and knowing what we know about resort development, that an 80 unit per acre density was kind of like a good number from that standpoint, having nothing to do with ZBiz or your code or anything like that, but rather for that prototype, to make that kind of prototype work, to create the intensity and value and synergy, you need those kind of densities to make it work.

2:31:37 Period. And so this idea that you can kind of just play around with this, you know, like in some theoretical or intellectual way is wrong. It's just not correct. It's not consistent with what happens in the real world. So we start with validating that that project is validated by the mere application that it's somewhere in the range of what could work. And so that's why we did not think it was appropriate to even attempt to try and say, well, geez,

2:32:07 45 units breaker, you get this, and for 48 units, you get that. That is not something that we would ever recommend that you do in the context of the CBIS analysis, because I don't think it would produce valid information. It would not produce valid information. Now, with respect to this topic of the, well, let me just come back here a little bit to see what's another topic that I wanted, a major point I wanted to make.

2:32:38 Well, I think another one that I wanted to make has to do with the overall project economics and this whole topic of trading one thing for another in relationship to existing codes and standards and all. Now, again, you have your own policy and codes and legal requirements and all of that, but typically in the context of development agreements and these sorts of things or density bonus situations, what happens?

2:33:06 Is that that increment, whatever it might be, how the existing codes apply to that is based upon the terms of the codes. It's normal that those density bonuses are basically increments that are on the margin. And they may, in some cases, or may not meet requirements for inclusionary housing.

2:33:33 Or impact fees. Or they may be exempted through the process of negotiation, depending on circumstances. But in this case, given the fact that, again, this was us normalizing the situation, looking at the SEVIS blog and saying, well, given the circumstances that there's this very high standard for getting these benefits, that is to say, creating these broad community benefits, that it seemed to us reasonable.

2:33:59 The position that the staff took that we did not need to apply those ordinances to that increment of development. Again, that's your call and your policy, ultimately. But what we did was consistent with the way that we thought the CBIS policy was written and what we used to see normally in other locations. Now, at the end of the day, and the final thing I'll say,

2:34:27 At this point, unless Mark points me to some other thing, is that the bottom line here is you need to figure out ways to make sure that your land use code is consistent with economic reality. And that when you say you want to have this kind of use there, that you've got a set of policies that allow that to happen economically. That's what we're talking about with DIF.

2:34:53 Looking at the housing mitigation, looking at CBiz, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. We're trying, I think you're trying, to incentivize investment in this community. You can't do that if you are at the same time creating requirements that basically frustrate you. That's a delicate balance, and the kind of work that we often get involved with is figuring out that precise place where you need to be on that. How many feathers can you pluck out of that goose before it dies?

2:35:23 And we need to do it. But we know that if you killed hoops, there will be no feathers or no golden eggs. And so it's very, very important that we look at this project and all these projects in that context. And we'll talk more about this, I think, later in the diff conversation. But I just wanted to make that point, that there's a lot of things going on with this. But at the end of the day, what we're really talking about is incentivizing

2:35:51 And creating a situation where private investment consistent with general plan policy and your other policy goals can occur. And if you have other policies that basically make that impossible, that raises questions about the sincerity of the first policy. And you have to really question that. So that's my high...

2:36:12 Level response to some of these comments. Mark, is there something else you'd like me to mention? No, we have one last comment from Mr. Ennis about the CBIS and some of the questions that were raised. And you can stay there. Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor, and I know this has been a long section, so I'll be brief. I just want to point out that this comprehensive and ambitious CBIS policy, as you know, has many aspects that require further implementation.

2:36:42 And I'd like to say that in applying that policy, the Town Council has to be mindful that if aspects of its implementation require extensive further community consensus building and development, that the policy cannot be applied in a manner to be in effect a de facto moratorium until all of those elements have been implemented, particularly for those projects that require review within specified periods of time under state law.

2:37:12 So one aspect of the policy that needs to be implemented, as the Planning Commission has discovered and conditioned, is to reconcile the issue of the grant of incentive densities and the exemption from development impact fees for those increments of development. And so conditions were imposed to, in essence, require that there be implementing ordinances

2:37:42 Two, the development impact fee ordinance, public arts program ordinance, and workforce housing ordinance to expressly exempt those densities from the calculation. That's just one example of some of the things over time that will need to be further implemented. There are other provisions that we will be monitoring over time, again, to reconcile with your code. The point of all of this is is that you need to reasonably interpret the CBIS policy.

2:38:11 And make sure you applied it consistent with current ordinances and state law timing limitations. So I think in the event the commission went through this, had to deal with this rather quickly after your August 9th adoption of your policy, and I think in reviewing that you can reasonably interpret your policy towards its goals even if every single aspect of that policy has not been fully implemented.

2:38:39 In evaluating this particular project. One of the conditions of the use permit is that the ordinance be amended before the building permit is issued? That's correct. Yeah, okay. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, comments from the applicant? What response to the economic and the second? Yeah.

2:39:13 You know, I don't think we have a lot of arguments with, because, in fact, I think that is, in a lot of areas, our argument is that this analysis and everything has disregarded CBIS, which was the council policy. Now, if the council policy is wrong, then it should have been brought back to you to change.

2:39:39 But they've said, well, you guys didn't know what you were doing when you asked these things, and therefore we did it right for you. But, you know, and we, particularly as a bridge, I think one of our problems with this is that you established CISBIS and sent it down to the Planning Commission and said, now you know everything, you know what you need to know, you can make the decisions. If this were a development agreement or all these other things,

2:40:10 People deciding how much affordable housing and things like that. It would come back to you to make the decision. So I think, you know, this is just another point that the developer and the economic analysis folks need to come back to you and say, you know, you've done the policy wrong and straighten it out first and then we'll do it right.

2:40:32 I don't think that Mr. Kieser was suggesting the policy's wrong. I think Mr. Kieser said that we have reasonably interpreted its application and completed an extensive and industry reasonable analysis. Did you have something for the bill? Bill Taylor again. Just briefly, a couple of points have been raised that should be responded to. We go back to the question of this being a bridge, and CBIS does say that it's a bridge. There's no question.

2:41:08 But, again, you know, the bridge still has to be sound. It still has to logically connect from one side to the other. And ultimately, I hope that we will see codification, we will see simplification, and we will see a policy that, you know, a developer can pick up off the shelf and understand, the public can walk in and understand. We're not there yet. There's sort of a circularity that I point out, and it was touched on again.

2:41:40 The Clearwater Specific Plan refers to a future policy. The future policy was CBIS. CBIS then says there will be yet an additional determination, yet in this staff report, in this analysis, it's circled back to the Clearwater Specific Plan. So we wind up not actually getting closure on that issue.

2:42:12 I wanted to just point out one thing Mr. Kieser said that we hadn't responded to his responses. And actually the main response that came back was his March 5, 2010 letter that was written in response to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Letter and the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Letter. And that's the first time that the notion of a linear relationship is raised. It was not raised in the Mammoth Lakes Housing Letter.

2:42:42 It was not raised in the appeal letter. It was not raised in the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access letter. We don't disagree that there's no linear relationship. And in fact, depending on the project, the curves can get quite complicated. But that's not what CBiz requires. CBiz does say to look at the profitability.

2:43:11 Compare it with the costs. And it does say look at the marginal costs. Those are your adopted policies. And again, if we're going to deviate from them, great. But make it clear, make it explicit, and do it up front. Finally, let's see, I'd like to, Mr. Ennis spoke to what really is the Permit Streamlining Act. The requirement is you have to process a tentative track map application. You have to process.

2:43:43 A use permit application. And you only have a limited amount of time within which to do that. And that is all correct. But you have certain mandatory findings that you're required to make. And those include consistency with town codes, policies, and general plan. If you can't make those findings, you can't approve the project. And our contention is you don't have the evidence to make those findings. Thank you.

2:44:13 Just a very couple quick comments. You've talked about a de facto moratorium. There's no way that we want a moratorium. That's not the issue whatsoever. But CBiz is so important because it is precedent setting. We are setting the policies and everything else. So that's why we're here, I think.

2:44:41 Or at least one of the reasons I'm here. Mr. Kaiser Kieser, we need policy. I agree with you. I totally agree. I think that some of our policies are breaking down and slowing down my entire system. We did respond and unfortunately we addressed it to the commission. So I apologize if you didn't get that. And here's another breakdown. Here's where CBiz is saying that this is the policy.

2:45:09 And yet, municipal code, you know, on the housing, we pointed out in this letter to the commission that, look, are you working under municipal code? Are you working under CBIS? Because code takes precedent over policy. And this was dated the 9th, the day before the hearings that were taking place on this project. And guess what? We didn't get a letter of legal opinion until, guess what? The 11th.

2:45:39 So we were scrambling, and I do apologize if you did not receive this. Thank you very much. Thank you, Kirk. Mark. On behalf of the appellant. The applicant. On behalf of the applicant. Applicant. It's the second time. Good evening, Mayor and members of the Council. Mark Carney, attorney for the applicant, Jim and Nancy Demetriotis. I want to take a moment just to dispel this notion that there's no list.

2:46:09 I've heard it a few times tonight. I've heard it from Mr. Walter. I heard it from Mr. Taylor. And I heard it from Mr. Stapp. And I fear that if we keep hearing that enough in enough times, we're going to start to believe it. In particular, you might start to believe it. So I'd like to dispel the notion that there was no list. I'd like to start off by talking about the foundations of the CBIS policy. The genesis of the CBIS policy was actually in our general plan.

2:46:35 And Bill Taylor and I have specific recollection of this because we helped craft this policy L5G of the general plan. And I'm going to quote a couple sentences from it. And it will become clear that this is really what you were thinking at the time, which was going to be the beginnings of your formation of a CBIS policy. And what L5G says in the C1, C2 designations, which are the commercial designations along Old Mammoth Road and Main Street.

2:47:02 Density may be increased to no more than twice the density for hotel, motel, and similar transient lodging projects that specifically enhance the tourism, community, and environmental objectives of the town. This enhancement must be through the provision of amenities, services, and or environmental benefits above and beyond those required to meet the incremental demands of the project. These amenities, services, and environmental benefits include, but are not limited to those listed under the Community Character section on page 24 of this general plan.

2:47:33 If you look on page 24 of the general plan, you find your first list. That's the first list that we were dealing with. And so when we set out for a specific plan, we looked specifically at the list in the general plan. And then the next step we did is we went into district planning. And we looked at that list in the general plan. And we thought, which of those in the general plan can we apply to our district? Which ones make sense? What can we provide this community in our district? And as Mark alluded to, there was a town council. First of all, that was a...

2:48:03 That was approved by the Planning Commission. It was sent to the Town Council and accepted by the Town Council District Planning Study. And what the Town Council did at that time is pared down that list because nobody thought we could do equestrian center there. And at the time, nobody thought that we could do golf there, but it turned out that we could. So we could pare down that list, but it was a list nonetheless. It was a list in the district plan. What happened next? We went to the specific plan.

2:48:32 What do we do with them? We paired down the list again because we're getting more specific to the site, not just the district. So now we've had three lists. What do we do next? We ask for approval of the specific plan. We ask for approval of the specific plan with that list. That list was approved, recommended approval by the Planning Commission. Town Council approved it, thereby approving that list through ordinance. So next we do, next.

2:49:00 We said, by the way, in the process, we wanted to get our density tied up. But the council said, no, we can't award you your density yet because we haven't gone through CBiz yet. We haven't even crafted that policy yet. And we haven't gone through PAOT yet. And we're not going to assess the proper density for this project unless and until we learn what the community thinks about CBiz and POT. So we waited. And we waited. And then CBiz policy got underway.

2:49:28 And then when CBIS policy got underway, it was finally approved in August of 2009. Two months later, we came back to the council with another list, with a list on October 21st. We said, okay, this is the heat check. We now know the policy. We've seen the list before. We're getting down to refining this for our use permit application. What do you think of this list? Again, the town council said, it looks like a pretty good list. Go with it. That's what we did.

2:49:56 So then, after that, we implemented the CBIS policy. In the financial analyses, lo and behold, more lists, more lists of what we really plan to do and the economic costs associated with those amenities. Then we get to planning commission stage. What's in the staff report? Another list of the amenities that we plan to provide. And again, tonight, the list is the list. So we've heard it so many times that we didn't have a list.

2:50:24 But we've had seven different occasions where we've pared down the list that started out in the general plan through district planning, through specific plan, through CBIS, through the heat check with the town council, to the planning commission, and back to the town council with the list. And those are the amenities that Jim Demetriatus and his wife Nancy have decided that are appropriate for this site based upon the input that we got from the community all along the way. So for us to hear that there's no list and we're not filing a list is just hard to take.

2:50:54 Hopefully we've dispelled the notion that we didn't follow the policy because we didn't create a list. The problem was, and what I guess they're alluding to is, we already had the list before the CBIS policy came in. What we did is refined the list, we refined the list after CBIS came in. And Jim gave the community what he believes and what's basically been validated by the planning commission thus far, exactly what the community envisioned way back when when we adopted the general plan.

2:51:24 Now, in addition, I'd like to make a respond to the assertion that we didn't analyze the marginal costs associated with the project correctly. To be honest with you, I didn't really understand Bill's comment when he said the marginal cost is not the cost to build the plaza. I don't know what that means, but I know what we were getting at is the community in all of those lists we just talked about said they wanted plazas.

2:51:55 So we decided to go forward and plan some plazas, three of them, in fact. Well, those have costs. Those are costs to develop. Now, there was no charge for the land associated with that cost, and in fact, there was no charge for the public's access to those plazas. The only cost.

2:52:18 That was included in the SEVIS analysis was the cost to develop those plazas with hardscape and landscape and water features to make them the kind of plazas that people want to go to and recreate in. So that's what we did. And we could have added to the equation, wait a minute, easements to the public have value. They did in the development agreement with North Village. It was actually one of the community benefits that the town attributed value to.

2:52:46 The public easement, an overhaul of the plazas. Mr. Demetriotis threw that in. It was not even assessed any value in the city of his analysis, nor was the underlying value of the property. So that's what happened. I don't know how we square that with the claim that the marginal cost is not the cost to build a plaza, but the marginal cost is the cost to provide public access, because we didn't do that. We didn't even charge for that. So in closing, I want to make one comment.

2:53:16 In response to something that Mr. Staff said, which is that we had some kind of mandate in the CBIS policy to determine the value of the benefits juxtaposed against the financial incentive conferred to an applicant in the form of additional land value and development profit. What CBIS says is we have an obligation to assess the

2:53:47 Additional value to the developer in the form of additional land value or development profit, not and development profit. And Mr. Kieser has given you all the good reasons why there was only one way to go on this, and it was incremental land value. And that's what the CBIS analysis says. And it's fully in compliance with the CBIS policy. Thank you. I'll be happy to answer your questions. Any questions? Okay. Comments from members of the public.

2:54:17 Good evening, greetings, Mayor McCarroll, Councilmembers Harvey, Eastman and Sugimura, Town Planning and Staff, Alan Bloomer, Town Council Candidate. I think I was asked by Ted Carlton from the sheet to, in 20 words or less, say what I felt the Town Council needed to do. I think the main one is cut down through this alphabet soup of the developments. I think there was a reason why we went back to the Village in the Trees, Councilmember Harvey.

2:54:58 Had a great, back on the April, the last April meeting of this, when he stuck to his guns on the fact that what I'm running through on the community is they're not against this development. My platform is enhancing our community and preserving our heritage. That being said, I have to absolutely laud to what he's done with that property.

2:55:22 Roadway Inn is now the Sierra Nevada Lodge. Rafters is back open. The golfing is going on. I was looking forward to seeing what was going to happen with the old ocean harvest. And I'm not running across anybody who's really against development, but they're really against the over three-story height and the excessive density. Also, I had a big question about the units, because obviously workforce units aren't just rooms.

2:55:53 As was mentioned earlier, I think this is a faulty tool. To be able to mitigate it down to only 30%, how long do we keep passing that along to the next developer, to the next developer, to the next developer? With the way CBiz is being handled, I don't think it's necessarily too faulty of a tool, but I think the way it's being implemented and it's taking away too many of the development impact fees. Because at this point in time,

2:56:22 There really isn't a whole bunch on the horizon for development in this town. There's nobody coming through where it's not like you're sorting through a whole bunch of plans. You're not being swamped. And that's why I think we really need to be careful about how much we give away because there's not going to be that much backfill coming up. We can always hope for the future. We can always plan for the future. And in that planning, we need to look at stuff like water use mitigation. For the next further developer, are they even going to have an option?

2:56:51 And I just, not against any further development on the property, I just think the density and the height is just a little bit over, and I would like to see, as Councilmember Harvey said, they knew back a few years ago what the village language was starting to change to, and it just seems like this extensive development has been pounded at us.

2:57:18 Plausas are fine, but I really think that the major disagreement in the community is the height and the density. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Alan. Any other comments? Steve. My name is Steve Schwind, and I'm part of this group, but I don't know where I fit in, but I have an opportunity to make one of my comments now where I think I fit in.

2:57:47 And I was listening to Mark saying that part of the general plan is to enhance tourism of the community. And I agree with the previous fellow that the comments I'm hearing from the tourists, I am in the tourist business. They are outraged at the height. Comments I've made before, I have to repeat them again. We do not want to come to a high-rise town in Mammoth. We want to get away from LA.

2:58:19 We don't want to come to another LA. This does not enhance tourism in this community. Hearing those comments and also in the branding that we have dropped like a hot torpedo. The focus groups and everything said in branding, we want a town that's genuine, unpretentious, and authentic. I've said this before, they've picked out websites. Telluride.

2:58:51 Park City and Steamboat. Skip used it and it was fraudulently presented that it was a 55-foot town. It was only 35 feet when you used the car and everything. These towns are 35 feet and what appealed to them is that what appealed about these website pictures to the focus groups in this branding that came back and it was dropped.

2:59:16 These were genuine, unpretentious, and authentic kinds of towns, and they were only 35 feet. So we're not enhancing tourism. We're shooting ourselves in the foot. And my comment is, if the community envisioned this project in the general plan, if they envisioned it, why did over 500 people sign a petition?

2:59:45 And try and get this on the ballot saying, what are you thinking? We want to overturn this. And I agree, it was not done dotting every I and crossing every T to get it on the ballot, but you have completely disregarded the message 500 plus people tried to send you. What are you thinking? This is not the project we envisioned in the general plan.

3:00:15 So this is where I fit in a little bit, talking about the general plan, and the message is clear. It is not what the community envisions. Thank you, Steve. Actually, this is a de novo hearing, so comments on the project of any sort are welcome. I think we're on number, any more public comments? I think we're on number three.

3:00:44 On number three, it has been discussed, I guess, if the appellant wants to make additional comments on PISC, we can. And then in terms of number four, identify community benefits, I think that has been thoroughly flogged. And you cannot call us listless. On number three? PISC. Okay.

3:01:13 I got them out of order. Yes. In fact, PI-C is probably one of the most critical components of this. It becomes, it is the thing, as was correctly stated, it is the thing that addresses the triple bottom line. But it was stated that it wasn't intended to be a cumulative to build-out analysis, that it was only intended to be the incremental impact of the project.

3:01:42 Were that true, we wouldn't need PI-C. Incremental impact analysis is covered under CEQA. PI-C was intended to be the thing that replaced the PAOT cap. So instead of worrying about whether we're at 52,000, 53,000, or 51,000, we would look at the cumulative effects and say, as long as we don't exceed the cumulative effects at build-out of a community of 52,000, as described under the general plan,

3:02:13 We can add density or move density or shift density. I agree. PIEC is the best tool for the triple bottom line. But as it's applied, it ignored air quality impacts and it ignored water supply impacts. And those are critical components to this community's bottom line. And really, I think with regard to the PIEC, that's quite frankly all I want to say is that Mayor McCarrow,

3:02:48 And Councilmember Sugimura, you were on the committee that helped develop that. We had discussions about this at great length. And I came away from that with the understanding that this was supposed to be a build-out plus bonus units analysis. And instead, it's simply the standard CEQA existing plus reasonable foreseeable future project, which is a much lower threshold. It deprives us.

3:03:18 I have a long-range view. Let's see, let me go to my notes again. By using the build-out plus bonuses approach, Pisces assures the project's causing the increased impact potential. The project that increases the density above the general plan baseline participates in the mitigation of the ultimate impact. Otherwise, it's simply deferred to some later project. You don't know what that is.

3:03:57 If that project can't be built, you've essentially engaged in de facto down zoning of some property you haven't even identified yet. If it can be built but additional mitigations are required, those either have to be carried by the community as a whole or burden that other property. Long-term PI-C review protects the community's vision and ad hoc incremental approach.

3:04:28 Quickly lose the sight of that vision. Pisces was intended to be the thing that kept your eye on the horizon, not the thing that kept your eyes at your feet. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Kirk? Two real quick comments. One, you know, so what is the list? The whole point of CBiz and the idea of a resolution...

3:04:53 I mean, seven different lists that have been floating around and modified and everything else. But what is the list? It's seven of them. That's the point of CBiz and the resolution to finalize that, not just keep having another list coming forward. The other thing that I want to point out is the criteria, the financial criteria.

3:05:15 Again, the criteria and a framework for evaluation of proposals. This is, again, I think it's B2A. Advocates submittal a sufficient financial evaluation and analysis, information, and evidence to allow for a reasonable assessment of the value of the benefits offered relative to the incentives being sought. Okay? And the thing is, if you do the wrong analysis, you don't look at the incentives being sought.

3:05:44 Which are 244 additional rooms, and you're not doing the analysis. And it's nice to say that, you know, that we changed the criteria. Well, somebody should have brought it back to council and said, this is an unrealistic criteria. That's just one more flaw in, those are two more flaws in the whole CBIS policy, and it needs to be rewritten or dealt with again.

3:06:16 Thank you. Anybody else for the appellant? Not public comment yet, Lee. Anybody else for the appellant? Mark? This one's easy. The project impact evaluation criteria relies on CEQA analysis, so those relevant snapshot elements from our CEQA analysis, including cumulative impacts with water and air quality are referenced in that document. We'd like to hold the conversation about

3:06:46 True CEQA impacts till we get to the CEQA section. So we don't have anything else to add on PI-C, so that was thoroughly evaluated, remembering that it's a summary snapshot document. In terms of the comments that were just made, it is not a circular list, and it's not a circular effort. It is sequential. So we went through the neighborhood district planning process. We completed the Clearwater specific plan, and on page 16 of 40, an item section.

3:07:16 3.6 Community Benefits are explicitly listed for this area and they're repeated on page 2440 under section 5.2.3. There's no competing lists. It is very clear and discreet. So there is a list to work from. The reason that...

3:07:35 It developed and evolved over time is that we completed one effort and we moved on to the next. And then finally, I think there's some confusion about what the intent of marginal analysis was. As you recall in the formulation of this process, a number of applicants, when we set up the analysis and what we're trying to learn and evaluate, they did not want to necessarily have to disclose their financial returns through a normal pro forma review.

3:08:03 And so the word marginal analysis in that policy was explicitly acknowledged by the Council and adopted as the Council as the analysis that was intended here. So you're not looking at a confidential rate of return perform a review in this process. That's what the marginal analysis was intended to mean. And if you wish, we can reopen that record in a subsequent time. That completes our comments to Section 3.

3:08:33 And again, on Section 4, we think we're done on that. The applicant. Any comments for the applicant? Okay, any further comments by the appellants? So just in response to the last staff comments, you know, I've already made my case on Pisces, and I just think I will let that stand in terms of what I believe and the appellants believe its intent was.

3:09:19 The articulation of the list in the Clearwater Specific Plan. I think I read to you earlier some of the qualifying language out of the Clearwater Specific Plan that goes with that list. And I guess we need to do it again. The above-mentioned community benefits are optional, and the applicant may choose to include some or all of them as part of a future use permit proposal. And it says,

3:09:47 The Clearwater Specific Plan may provide numerous benefits which may include but are not limited to the following. And again, it goes on in the next section to say the final community benefits will be determined pursuant to future policy. This is not the definitive list. By your ordinance, it's not the definitive list. Finally, on marginal cost. Obviously, there's some confusion, and I will use the mid-block connector as the example of what

3:10:20 I'm suggesting. Mid-block connector is the one and only way to get into and out of the garage, into and out of the port cashier. It is an essential component of the project. With or without public access, it has to be constructed. The full construction cost of that mid-block connector was assigned as a public benefit. Now, arguably, there may be some additional costs.

3:10:49 Associated with allowing the public access through that street. Those are the marginal costs of the public benefit. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Bill, real quick to clarify your last statement. It's my understanding that the mid-block connector was where it is today was required because they changed the entrance from one part of the project to the other and therefore there's an incremental

3:11:17 Much larger cost in doing it that way. Is that fair? That is fair, but what you would have to compare is the cost to develop the accesses to the garage in Port Cashier alternative location with the cost of this. And if there's an additional cost, certainly that would be legitimate. Thank you. Nothing from the applicant? Comments from the public? I have a few questions.

3:11:55 One of them is with 488 units of pensions at the planning meeting, where's everybody going to park? I know they've got parking underneath, but there's a place up at 8050 where you can't even get a place to park sometimes. North Village doesn't even have enough places for people to park. There's no guarantees, and I'm feeling that all the people that live around them, all the complexes, they're going to be inundated by these people parking in their parking spaces.

3:12:22 I'm really concerned about that because it's an issue up there. With the workforce housing, I've mentioned this before, the working people are an asset to our town, and there needs to be 27 units on the project because if they put some off, it's going to be impacting certain areas, and these areas don't have a district plan yet, so how can you let anything built in these areas without a district plan? I mean, this is like snowballing into other areas. Sierra Valley sites is going to be impacting.

3:12:51 The drainage system, they need to pay these monies like law enforcement up at North Village where people drive through Sierra Valley sites so they don't get a ticket drunk driving. What's going to happen when all these developments and this one come forward and the law enforcement doesn't have enough money to be giving out tickets for people that are drunk driving? It's going to impact everybody that lives in this whole area. Those are the things I'm concerned about, law enforcement parking and the workforce housing.

3:13:19 And then when it comes to the conference area, I think every project should have it. It's something that I think a project would want to have on their project. It doesn't need to be an incentive. There's always somebody around the corner waiting to take your business away from you. I would think you would want that so that people come to your project instead of the other project. So I think every project should have a conference room and it shouldn't be an incentive. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Any other public comments? Okay, moving on to

3:13:49 Issue number four. Mark says we flogged that to death. Do the appellants agree or do you like? Failure to identify community benefits. Failure to identify community benefits. Okay, we flogged and beaten the horse to death. Yeah. Okay. We will move on to issue number five. Failure to comply with the analysis required under CEQA.

3:14:20 It's Office 9. Thank you. This analysis was prepared for the appellants by the law firm of Shute, Mahaly, and Weinberger. And locate my letter here. And basically it raises four points of deficiency in the environmental review. And most of these have to do with the time that has elapsed since the adoption of the Clearwater Pacific Plan and EIR.

3:14:54 The significant increase in exceedances of state standards for particulate matter is a changed circumstance necessitating subsequent review. You will recall roughly two months ago Ted Shady from the Air Pollution Control District was here and presented you with information regarding the increase in the numbers of days of state exceedances. That was improperly reflected in the PIC analysis which said that the project in fact applied with state and federal standards.

3:15:26 And it represented a change in information, new information since the publication of the original EIR that should have been addressed. Greenhouse gas emissions. This is an evolving field in CEQA, and again, this is something that's new regulations have actually been promulgated since the adoption of the Clearwater Pacific Plan and EIR. Those should have been addressed.

3:15:56 Substantial changes in the proposed project leading to an increase in severity of impacts to water supply, and I think you've seen some of the correspondence from the Water District regarding that. And finally, substantial changes to the project having significant impacts to land use, housing supply, and community service is not considered in the UIR. And that actually gets to the adoption of CBIS, the recommendation for the waiver of the impact fees, and the waiver of the housing mitigation requirements.

3:16:27 If the housing is not going to go on site, it has to go somewhere else. CEQA should at least look at the potential effects of that. Likewise, if police services, parks, trails, transit, streets are not going to be mitigated through DIF, how are the impacts going to be addressed? Those were not covered in any supplemental environmental document. So those are the four points which shoot Mihaly and Weinberger.

3:16:56 Determine that the CEQA analysis was deficient. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Any other appellant wishing to speak on this subject? Mark? This is complicated, and we want to make sure that you understand the actions of the CEQA analysis, you know, your certification, that you feel comfortable that the analysis is complete. And it doesn't relate to the tentative map, per se.

3:17:22 I'd like to have Ellen give a brief overview, and then Mr. Ennis and Mr. Torres will speak specifically for the record. Very briefly, and some of these points are covered in the staff report, which specifies the ways in which, particularly with regard to air quality, which was the major point brought up in the appellant's original letter, are responded to in terms of

3:17:48 Thank you.

3:18:17 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Members of the Council.

3:18:45 The four points that were raised in the Chute-Mohaly-Weinberger letter, that letter, by the way, was dated yesterday and received by the town, I think, yesterday, and we've had a chance to review it and analyze it. So I'm going to hit the main four points. First point was that the lawyers contend for the advocates that an increase in the number of days that the town's error exceeds state PM10 standards.

3:19:14 It means that the project is creating new or additional impacts or creating impacts that are more severe than previously disclosed in the EIR. As you know, the EIR for the Clearwater Specific Plan was certified in January of 2009. In that EIR, mitigation measures were imposed to reduce the impacts of particulate matter to a level of less than significance under CEQA.

3:19:40 New information about changes in circumstances, such as changes to the levels of particulate matter occurring in the community only triggers a requirement for additional review if those changes would make the project's impacts more severe or create new impacts. As I said, the ERR already mitigated PM10 impacts of the project to lessen significance, and thus, even if the conditions have changed,

3:20:06 Those change conditions do not make this project's PM10 impacts more severe because the project's impacts have already been mitigated to lessen significance. In summary, new environmental review of PM10 conditions is not required by the increase in the community-wide PM10 conditions because the project is not making those impacts more severe.

3:20:31 Second, greenhouse gas emissions. And on this point, we'd like to note that we regard the conformance review that was prepared by RBF to qualify as an addendum to the Clearwater Specific Plan EIR and that these comments and the comments of Mr. Torres will be included as an appendix to that conformance review and referred to on page 3-27.

3:20:57 The EIR for this project, as I said, was certified in 2009. With respect to the project's impacts on greenhouse gas emissions and recent changes in statutory and regulatory requirements for evaluating those emissions, CEQA does not require subsequent environmental review of those issues unless the issue of greenhouse gas emissions constitute new information of substantial importance that show that the project

3:21:27 Will have new significant impacts not previously disclosed. The EIR already contained mitigation measures to address sources of greenhouse gas emissions. Those include mitigation of traffic and air quality impacts of the project. In addition, the project as proposed and conditioned requires the project to achieve a LEED, SILVER, or equivalent certification. Those measures to obtain that certification include a variety of construction and operational requirements.

3:21:56 And those have been imposed as conditions. With those mitigation measures and the project requirements, greenhouse gas emissions will be reduced, and there is no evidence that further mitigation is necessary to mitigate potential impact. Lastly, the advocate lawyer refers to the fact that in March of this year, after the conformance review is prepared, and certainly after the EI was certified,

3:22:21 A new secret guideline was adopted providing guidance as to how greenhouse gas emissions are to be addressed. However, pursuant to secret guideline section 15007, amendments to guidelines are perspective only. If the document meets the guideline requirements at the time it was circulated for public review, and this EIR was circulated for public review more than a year prior to this new guideline.

3:22:50 The document does not need to be revised to conform to the later amendments. The third issue has to do with water impacts. The change in the project may or may not affect the planning assumptions of the water district in terms of when the town has reached its development capacity with respect to long-term water supplies. However, the change does not mean that this project cannot be provided adequate water over the long term.

3:23:22 The RBF Water Demand Estimate Memorandum dated February 18, 2010 showed that the revised plan would require substantially less water than previously analyzed, and Mr. Torres will give you the specific numbers. The fact that the subdivision of the property is pursuant to a vesting mat does not change the project's requirements to incorporate mitigation measures, LEED silver certification,

3:23:49 or equivalent standards or to conform to long-term water supply measures imposed by the district or the state. The vesting map law does not provide immunity from complying with state standards on water use and operational limitations that may be imposed by the water district. In fact, the vesting map law contains express exemption that allows changes in development standards to address changes required pursuant to health and safety factors and considerations.

3:24:19 Lastly, the issue of development impact fees. The EIR did not rely on the payment of development impact fees to mitigate impacts to the various resources arising from the incentive units. For example, various park and recreational facilities are included in the project as described in the staff report. Conditions have been added to address impacts on law enforcement services. For example, on-site security for late-night operations have been imposed as a condition of approval.

3:24:50 Conditions of the project include dedication of property for on-site pedestrian walkways, bike lanes, transit shelters, shuttle service, new mid-block connectors, and other requirements to offset the project's impacts on transit and trails. Therefore, the exclusion of the incentive densities from the impact fee calculations will not result in unmitigated impacts to those public facilities and resources.

3:25:17 And with that, I will now turn it over to Mr. Torres to elaborate on some of the technical rationale for these conclusions. It will be a very succinct elaboration. Thank you. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. It will be very brief. I will touch upon a couple of the points mentioned by Mr. Ennis in regards to some of the technical data in the EIR. I participated in the preparation of the EIR and the CEQA conformance review.

3:25:48 And to touch upon a couple of the issues starting off with air quality. And first of all, my specialties at RBF are air quality, noise, and climate change. The data that I downloaded this morning actually from the ADAM database from the California Air Resources Board which monitors the network, including Mammoth Lakes, shows that over the past nine years of monitoring data, the state standard has been exceeded by three to six times a year.

3:26:17 With the exception of 2000, 2003, and 2007, in which it was exceeded only one time. So we see a trend that has been fairly stabilized. Exceedance is between three to six times per year. We happen to show a significant exceedance in the number of days exceeded of the PM10 standard for state standards. The federal standard has not been exceeded. Additionally, I'd like to note...

3:26:41 That the difference in the particulate matter concentration between the old Mammoth Place project and what was analyzed in the EIR is 0.7 micrograms per cubic meter. Touching upon the topic of water, RBF conducted a detailed water supply assessment in consultation with the Mammoth Community Water District with their factors. To give you a couple of numbers from that water supply assessment, the project would result in a net water demand of 17,866 gallons per day.

3:27:14 Which is approximately 10,543 fewer gallons per day analyzed in the draft EIR, which considered 28,409 gallons per day. To touch upon the topic of greenhouse gases, greenhouse gases have been around for a little while. The topic is highly debated. The issue of greenhouse gases has become fully vetted within the amendments of CEQA guidelines effective on March 18th of this year.

3:27:44 The guidelines do spell out a couple of different criteria for projects. The analysis does not have to be quantitative. The analysis can be qualitative. There are no defined thresholds at this point. The defining guideline is AB32. AB32 requires a 28% reduction of greenhouse gases from a business-as-usual condition, a condition meaning that the project would not install any lead efficiency design standards, any water design features, or any energy efficiency standards.

3:28:13 Design of the Old Man Multiplaced Project is much more efficient than what was analyzed in the EIR. And this project would highly exceed the 28% reduction in business as usual conditions and be in compliance with Assembly Bill 32. That concludes our presentation. I'd like to touch briefly on the environmental issues as well. As many of you, I woke up this morning to an email, sort of a 43-page document from Chute Mahaley.

3:28:54 Ten pages of concerns with respect to the EIR. My firm, for the record, has prepared a response, which I'd like to distribute to you, so it's part of the record. I'd like to touch briefly on the air pollution issue. The Shoup Mahaly letter essentially argues that new information of substantial importance, which was not known at the time the prior EIR was certified,

3:29:46 Shows that the process will have significant effects not described in the EIR. Since they say it wasn't described in the EIR, then we have to have a subsequent EIR in order to disclose, discuss, and mitigate the potential environmental impacts associated with that. The reality, however, is that this isn't new information. It's clear that the exceedance has been going on since well before 2006. And so this is not new information, and it's not information related to the project.

3:30:15 In fact, the representative from Great Basin that came to talk on the 17th of February wasn't here to talk about exceeding standards solely. In fact, I looked for the agendized item that night was the presentation on solar panels for dust control at Owens Lake. So he wasn't here to talk about the project. He wasn't here to talk about how this project would impact air quality.

3:30:41 And great people have had ample opportunity in EIR or subsequent to that to make those comments. And they have not made comments that in any way reflected negatively on this project. Secondly, the representative made clear that the pollution that we're concerned about is really primarily from two sources. One has to do with the way that we contain our ice with the...

3:31:15 With the shavings, I forget what the word that we use. Cinder. Cinder. Cinder. And also, unfortunately, the pollution that flows with the winds from the central valley. That's the focus of the concern, not the development of this project or any other. In fact, if you look at the trend over the past several years, the trend is actually a downward trend.

3:31:44 However, the trend has gone up from 2006 to 2008. Well, it's impossible to blame that on new development. There hasn't been a new development between 2006 and 2008. Yet, we see this particular pollution go on the rise. So it clearly is unrelated to this topic. And if it were related to this topic, I have no doubt that the good professionals at Great Basin would have come and expressed that at the Planning Commission, or they would be here tonight to make that clear.

3:32:14 So it's speculative in the extreme for Shute Mahaley to come to this conclusion that this rise in particular pollution over the past couple of years is in any way related to the impacts of this development. Secondly, with respect to the greenhouse gas issue, Shute Mahaley just gladly got this one wrong as well. They're saying that based on determinations by the EPA in 2009,

3:32:46 On greenhouse gas emissions and California's 2009 climate adaption strategy, the CEQA guidelines were amended to require analysis during the environmental review process of the potential effects of climate change. Now, the new guideline that they're referring to took effect on March 18, 2010. Mr. Torres did his conformance analysis, completed that a month earlier, yet they appear to be saying that Mr. Torres' analysis should have taken into consideration this new guideline.

3:33:17 It wasn't even effective at that time. But there's another guideline section, which is alluded to by Mr. Ennis, which specifically says that amendments to guidelines apply prospectively only. In other words, this amendment, this 2010, March 18th amendment, applies in the future only. It doesn't apply to this project. Section 1507C of the CEQA guideline says, and I quote, if a document, meaning an EIR,

3:33:46 Meet the content requirements in effect when the document is set out for public review. The document shall not need to be revised to conform to any new content requirements in guideline amendments taking effect before the project is finally approved. Thirdly, with respect to the water supply issue. At the specific plan stage, the Water District commented on the specific plan EIR and said that there was ample water for this project to be completed.

3:34:17 Now, they did another water assessment, but in the meantime, we also changed our project to make it much more efficient. And what Ms. Torres alluded to is the fact that this project will use between 2% and 18% less water than the previously approved Clearwater project. And if we can assume that additional efficiency credits are pursued through the LEAD process,

3:34:45 Which is something that Mr. Demetriotis is committed to. Then the assessment that was done in association with the project says that we can expect to see as much as a 30% total water use reduction as compared to the project that was analyzed in the Clearwater Specific Plan. So in sum, there is no requirement under California law to provide a subsequent EIR to disclose to the public that your project will have less impact on the environment.

3:35:14 Thank you, Mark. Anything more from the appellants? No, thank you. When we talk about the EIR, we seem to only be talking about the EIR for the specific plan. I think we cannot forget that we've got the analysis for the EIR for the general plan.

3:35:54 And whether the addition of the number of cars associated with the extra 240 units on this project stirring up the road dust will result in more incidences of road dust than were the impacts originally analyzed in the EIR for build-out, not for this project, but for build-out.

3:36:24 I don't think that's been done. We may have done a lot of microanalysis and we may save a lot of water on this project versus what it was a while back, but what's the effect going to be on the town at build-out? Is there going to be enough water left at the town at build-out? We understand there won't be. And I think that has to be analyzed. Thank you.

3:36:56 Could I respond to that? Yes, please. I'm going to ask Mr. Torres to respond to this also, is that the cumulative analysis completed in the EIR, which was done several years ago, was determined, is entirely consistent with the CEQA guidelines and the parameters that it establishes for completing such review. It meets those parameters in terms of

3:37:22 Considering, in particular, both the project and reasonably foreseeable future projects in a reasonable time frame of analysis. CEQA does not require that build out of the general plan be analyzed. It sets forward those standards for what that cumulative analysis ought to be, and the EIR adhere to those standards. I don't know if Eddie has anything to add to that requirement. I'd just briefly like to read from the CEQA guidelines, which...

3:37:58 Governed our approach to the analysis. And in the approach we looked at, we looked at every single topical issue addressed in EIR in detail. In some instances, did detailed studies. And the tiered approach defined by CQ15152, subsection F1, defines the relation of a cumulative effect and says, where a lead agency determines that a cumulative effect has been adequately addressed in the prior EIR, the effect is not treated as significant.

3:38:28 For purposes of the later EIR or negative declaration and not need to be discussed in detail. The analysis we did under the project showed that the impacts were equal to or fewer than what was analyzed in the EIR. No additional mitigation measures were required. No significant impacts were discovered beyond what was analyzed within the EIR. Based upon that, the cumulative increase and the contribution was not determined to be significant and need additional detailed discussion within the conformance addendum. Thank you.

3:39:01 Mark, I had a quick follow-up question on number four, the DIF, as it relates to park and recreation facilities at the project. Can we share with the public and the council what some of those facilities might be? Sure. The project, you mean what's included in the project? Yes. The project itself, in addition to the conference space and spa, which

3:39:29 is directly related to visitation and seeing higher occupancy in the hotel and then the other aspects of retail. So in addition to that, this project includes three separate plaza features. One plaza is dedicated to an active plaza event space and that's intended to be for active use during the summer, such as special events. And as you know, the

3:39:59 Jazz Jubilee, for example, is held on that particular site, and then in the winter the applicant intends to hold winter appropriate activities. So those are the types of activities that you see in the general plan parks and recreation element, and it includes, and those are the types of facilities you see embedded in the master facilities list as well, which are intended to be funded by DIF. So in essence, those features are

3:40:27 Meeting some of the intent that's directly meant to be implemented by the general plan and by our parks and recreation elements and the diff program. Thank you. And Mr. Mayor, I have just one point of clarification if I might. I've been informed that the on-site security for late-night operations at the project is actually a term and provision of the applicant's project as distinguished from a condition imposed on the project. So I want to make the record clear that that is.

3:40:56 Is a element as proposed by the applicant rather than a condition. Okay. Anything further by the appellant? Anything further by the applicant? And I'll call for public comments on anything to do with the project, the process, or the appeal. Yes, Rick. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you. I'm going to be uncharacteristically brief because

3:41:31 It's hard to imagine that at 9.15 we still have a full house. People either are just fascinated by this or they're afraid to leave. You know, I'm here not as part of a group or an organization. I'm here as an individual, a guy who's lived here for 20 years, somebody who is doing my best to make a living, raise a family, enjoy the quality of life that we have.

3:42:07 A council member in 1998 when I first became a member of council told me 99% of the decisions of council are of not much importance. This is one of the other one percenters. You might wonder why I am standing up here as a person who for a long, long time have been a strong advocate and a promoter of good development and growth in this community, why I have indicated publicly that I'm supportive of the appeal.

3:42:41 Well, there are a number of reasons, and I'm going to be very brief because I think that there will be some redundancy in what I say with respect to my reasons as compared to what has already been said. But really what it comes down to for me is that we're halfway there, and the reason is that I believe that it is the council and not the planning commission that is charged with making policy.

3:43:09 I believe that it is the Council and not the Planning Commission that should make the ultimate decision on a project that is second in size and scope only to the interwest development in the village which was proposed and partially constructed many years ago and over the years. So we got here. The filing of the appeal got us here. And the reason that I think that it's important is not to dismiss or denigrate the efforts of staff.

3:43:39 The work of the Planning Commission, 56 or 7 or 8 meetings or however many there have been, but because it is you who must ultimately be responsible to the constituency, accountable to the voters and the members of the community who are not voters for the decision that you make. I stood in the back and, quite frankly, even having read the packet, the appeal, the staff response,

3:44:11 And I thought to myself, I'll never get this. Somebody makes an argument, sounds pretty good to me. Then I hear the response, sounds pretty good too. Then I hear the reply, that sounds pretty good too. So it's not for me tonight to say whether or not I think that the project should be 36 feet or 64 feet. It's not for me tonight to say whether I think the project should be...

3:44:37 40 units per acre or 80 units per acre. Those things have been argued for the past three and a half years. The thing that has concerned me and the reason that I'm standing here is that I believe that for a variety of reasons there has effectively been at least the perception of a failure in the process. And stating it with nothing else is not terribly important.

3:45:04 Because you're almost to the end. And you may be to the end tonight, depending on the decision that you make. But in the future, it seems to me that the horse has to come before the cart. The unfortunate thing is that Mr. Demetriatus bought a piece of property before the general plan was adopted, got caught up in the adoption of a policy, CBiz, at least in my view, that

3:45:33 It wasn't followed, whether because of lack of time or for some other reason that I'm not aware of, with implementation language that would provide the kind of direction, specific direction, with one voice from the council to the planning commission so that their job would be easier, so that his job would be easier. And it seems to me, secondly, that what has occurred and what I see in these various technical arguments that I've seen or heard tonight is that instead of the town,

3:46:03 Going to the development community as a whole and to this developer in particular and saying, look, this is what we want as a community by way of amenities. What is it that you can provide us in exchange for a bonus of density? It's backwards, which is that the developer has come to the town, it appears to me, and said, this is what I need in order to make my project work and my consultants and experts tell me that that is so.

3:46:34 And what is it that we can work out by way of amenities to satisfy my density requirement? I just think it's backward. I don't think it has to be in the future. And I think that this is a lesson for, regardless of how this project turns out, for doing it differently. Because I believe that notwithstanding that the public has not come forward in some sort of rage about whether this project should be built or not,

3:47:01 There is an undercurrent of dissatisfaction with the way that it has gone down. We've heard things about height and density because those are flashpoints and those are key or catchwords that resonate. But really there's this uneasy feeling in the community, at least that I talk to, and as you can imagine, maybe you can't imagine that I'd be talking to people who'd be opposed to the project, that I'd only be talking to people that are supportive of the project. But there's this uneasy feeling that this

3:47:31 is not yet complete, that this is not yet done. Now, one would think that the public process is satisfied, that is, the public outreach is complete if you have 58 meetings, but I don't think you can judge the success of outreach by the number of meetings that you have. And so, my remarks specifically, or requests specifically of you is this.

3:48:02 And it kind of goes back to the statement I made earlier, which is that some of these arguments, depending on who's presenting them and how they're presented, seem pretty good to me. And then I hear the other side and I'm not sure. If you have any doubt in your mind, any doubt whatsoever that the process has not been finished, that the findings that are necessary to be made in order to avoid a challenge or in order to not appease, if you will, those who are not

3:48:31 Happy with this project, then it should go back to the Planning Commission with specific direction from you with one voice telling it what you want, what you want to see, because ultimately it's your decision, you own it, you will own it, and it will become your legacy. I believe that the Planning Commission has gone, has done an extraordinary job committing not hundreds, thousands of hours of time put into this project.

3:49:02 I don't believe that because you haven't gotten to 57 meetings that you don't deserve or get to have a seat at the table. I think the community gets that seat at the table. And I'm simply speaking for people who think that this process should be fair, that the perception should not be that the game is rigged, and that this elaborately orchestrated defense, and I'm not suggesting it's inappropriate, but this is pretty daunting.

3:49:29 Check this out. If I were sitting on the other side of a conference table, a negotiation table, and I had eight people, all of whom are experts in one way or another facing me, I'll tell you I'd be pretty intimidated. But that should not be the reason why a project should be either dismissed or whether it should be upheld. I think each of you needs to search your heart and make a decision as to whether this thing requires...

3:49:58 More work in effect to have the Planning Commission develop the findings that Bill Taylor has so thoroughly and carefully challenged or has stated are not there in order to convince the public that in the end the process worked and the project is the very best.

3:50:24 That we as a community can have and it's the best that you can do as well. Thank you. Thank you, Rick. Yes, John. John Baruch. I did not plan on speaking because I have actually no notes. This is not my intention. I definitely am not part of a group, just a small taxpayer in town. But I'd like to say just a little bit different light on what's been said. You've got all the experts, you've got all the books. That's not what I'm going to speak to.

3:51:02 It seems like even the people who brought this appeal are in agreement with the project one way or another. We agree with this. We don't agree with that. We think it can be better. And this is what we've been doing for 20 years in this town. It always can be better. There is no such thing as being perfect. I think that the incentive zoning is a phenomenal tool. It's a very powerful tool to use if it's done properly. It needs to be very, very flexible.

3:51:31 DIF is a failure. It's a colossal failure. There was some discussion about $6.5 million that we're trying to recoup. That $6.5 million, if you recall, the town council that did that, they spent the money before they ever had it. That's where the $6.5 million backfill is supposedly going to come from. Plus the $3.5 million that we were supposed to put on the tent. So we've got $9 million that we have borrowed or used that we never had.

3:52:01 To me, diff is not working. Whether or not we ever get that money back in a diff, I don't know, but I think with incentive zoning or the CBiz, whatever you call it, you can get as much, if not more, than you can with diff. You also, I think, and I'm not really sure, I'm trying not to see where this thing was going tonight, but it sounds like it's maybe a protest vote more than just we don't like the project.

3:52:27 And are we ever going to, if you vote to go back to town council, are we ever going to have enough meetings or enough information? The other thing that I would like to do, and this is the whole person coming up here, is maybe have a whole different perspective on when you vote tonight. Maybe, yes, you know, you've got the legalese, and like the last speaker just said, depends who you listen to, depends who you believe, and you guys have to make a real tough choice on legalese of this. But how about if you look at the applicant?

3:52:55 We're looking at the project. You have a gentleman who came into town four or five years ago, Tim. He has put millions of dollars into this process. When we talk about return on investment, there's not, you know, there's many millions of dollars in paperwork to get this far in his 56 meetings. He has proved to us that he's a player, he's a community member. He has put, probably done,

3:53:23 Over millions of dollars in the building. Two years ago, nobody in this town felt that that building would be anything but a blight for the next five or ten years. In fact, there was some discussion in the planning commission about making them tear it down, making them paint it. He has put millions of dollars in that building, and yes, it's a business plan, and maybe he'll make money in it, I don't know. But we as a community, we're going to have tourism, we're going to have TOT, and we're going to have sales tax. And we have a project.

3:53:52 That looks very, very nice. Plus he put a golf course in. Not only did he pay for that golf course, but he's going to maintain it. And that's the other thing with the incentive zoning. If the developer does these projects, and that's one of the big problems with DIF, is yes, you get the capital. Who maintains it? We the taxpayer.

3:54:13 And we're not going to build a $44 million rec center. We're not going to build a $22 and a half million performing our center. We're never going to have the money. But you can get that out of the developer. So I would like to have you just look at who the applicant is, what they've done for this community, what Jim and his family have done, and what they plan on doing. And I think that's a real good example of working plans that are going from now. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, John. Any other public comments? Hearing none, I'll close the... Oh, good.

3:54:44 I take it all back. What we're, you know, not disagreeing too much with what John said or certainly not with what Rick said. What we're really asking you to do is send it back and get it right. That now it's really the time to finish the CBiz, do the right Pisces analysis to find out exactly what the trade-offs are, you know.

3:55:14 It may not change this project one iota, but it'll set the proper framework for what are literally hundreds of millions of dollars of projects coming down the pipe that we don't want to go through this again. And it really has got to be done right. And I really think you've got to look hard at basing these analyses on the general plan and the...

3:55:40 The EIR and the alternative selected in the EIR and the mitigations of where we're going to be at build out. Otherwise, somebody's going to come in the door and there's not going to be a water connection. I do think you have to protect your diff. You know, I'm not talking about diff for art palaces or opera houses.

3:56:06 You've got to find out where the diff's going to come from to put these storm drains. You know, we've got parts of town are flooding, and where's the money going to come from from that? You know, a big part of our triple bottom line is making sure our transportation system keeps going. This, as proposed, would take away a diff from those projects. Our streets, our roundabouts that aren't here.

3:56:34 Those are the critical infrastructures to meet our triple bottom line that have to be, you know, funded by DIF. And they're not glamour projects. They're hard to get grants for and things like that. So I don't think you can just say, well, gee, you know, find money for the Opera House somewhere else. I don't think we're talking about the Opera House. And I think this minuscule amount of affordable housing that this project...

3:57:03 Ended up showing, we haven't even discussed that tonight, but it's very low, and I think that whole thing has to be looked at hard. I think, you know, we've got a strong commitment to affordable housing in this town, and we should keep it up. And, you know, I do think that adding 240 units above what was in the base before is going to be cars, it's going to be cinders, it's going to mess up our air, and it will use water.

3:57:30 Now, by analyzing things properly, we can either medicate them or, you know, maybe find out they aren't important. But unless we finish the analysis, we're not going to know. And then, even worse, we'll go through the fight again. But I think you ought to send it back and do it right. Thank you, John. Kirk. Again, I applaud the Planning Commission and the applicant for all the work they've done and everything. But words mean something.

3:58:01 And I'm talking about CBiz. And when CBiz uses the word, you know, shall 26 times, you shall do this. And then it says the numerous, you are required to do this, you are required to do this. And I listen to the gentleman speaking here and they're talking about, you know, well, yeah, I might say that. They don't even address it. They say this is what we've done. But what do the words say?

3:58:30 You know, when Mr. Kieser was up here, he said, you know, because I've looked you up online, it's a phenomenal organization and, you know, company, but the analysis is very clear what you were supposed to have done, and yet they took the, you know, the prerogative to go ahead and say we're going to analyze it in this fashion, and it should have come back to Council.

3:58:57 Because again, I say that words mean something. And it's not just the words on the financial analysis. It's very clear about a resolution will be adopted. That's what it says. And then on some of all the other areas in there where it says, you shall do this, you shall do this. And staff is over there, we did this, we did this. Yeah, but is that what it asked you to do? So, you know, I did.

3:59:27 I hate to say send it back, but it has to because the fact is they didn't follow the words. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any other public comments? Any other comments from anybody? Are you yielding your time? Is that the deal? I want 15 seconds. You got it.

4:00:01 You got it. Rusty Gregory, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, one of the four people here tonight that isn't running for election, actually. I'm guessing that based on the text messages I've been receiving across the room here tonight that there's a lot of sentiment that, oh my God, we're getting punished again through one of these long meetings on details and, you know, when is Mammoth ever going to get its act together?

4:00:29 And, you know, tonight we're actually taking the general plan,

4:01:00 Which was finally approved. The policy that's been promulgated, associated with the general plan, including for the very first time in our history, I think, the application of incentive zoning. And we're actually trying to put it to work. That's happening tonight for the first time. The roadway in, or whatever it was called before that, when Jim Demetriatus was still in diapers, when those of us that were real locals here were drinking Jim in those days.

4:01:31 You'll have to do a little of that as well if you want to be a local here at Mammoth. You got it right. Ted, make sure that you get in that. So the roadway in has been replanned into Clearwater. A specific plan was created. All sorts of other things went along with that.

4:01:55 Because of significant public comment, and almost everybody in this room was very involved in those public comments at one level or another in the 58 meetings or whatever that has become now, that exhausted public comment has turned into the replanned Old Mammoth Place that we're talking about tonight. So our planning process that we so abuse the process itself and the poor leaders that try to actually get some progress made on our planning process

4:02:24 You know, it's starting to work. It's very difficult to see the forest for the trees because of all the acrimony and activity going on, but there is significant progress represented by what's going on in this room tonight. The project is dramatically better, as I think Alan pointed out, and somebody else, and John Baruch, that this was a project that certainly qualified for blight.

4:02:47 In its earlier days, and now is a great revitalized project on its way to being even a better project because of the public comment and the effort that's been put into this. And not surprisingly, we now have a difference of opinion. It is Mammoth Lakes, after all, and that it's a tradition with us that we're going to have a disagreement. And by the way, before I forget, my opinion, and it's just one of the opinions that we have differences on tonight.

4:03:16 But my opinion, and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area's opinion, is that we fully support the full approval of this project. I think it's spectacular and absolutely represents the kind of activated space that Old Mammoth Road should be, will be, in the direction that the neighborhood district plans are going in. We fully support the project as proposed currently and also support the Dimitri Ottisans.

4:03:45 We also support the proponents and the great job that they've done. It matters, particularly in times like this, who the developers are that are proposing things in the community. And I think that it doesn't make up for a bad project, but we've got a great project and a great proponent, I believe. So how do we progress beyond this?

4:04:14 Difference of opinion. And this is where Mammoth always gets stuck. We love our area and our landscape so much that we don't get beyond our differences of opinion. We get stuck in that and it goes around and around and around and we get to be good friends over it, some of us, and some of us get to be enemies over it, but it goes around and around and around and we never get to a damn decision. So how do we do that? And that's leadership. Judgment and leadership.

4:04:40 And you have the unfortunate task tonight, which you've been elected for, to handle that. And we often in this community mistake outreach and collaboration and consensus for leadership. And that's not leadership. That's just a bunch of people talking and we'll all keep talking and we'll all have opinions until somebody calls a question and makes the decision.

4:05:04 And by God, some decisions have been made. The project's been replanned. The planning process is dramatically different now, and now we need to apply it, and somebody's going to have to take some risk in that. So tonight, I would strongly suggest and urge you to approve the, to not fine for the appeal, which would allow the project to continue. So that's number one. And number two, I equally strongly

4:05:32 I encourage you that while you have time in office that you continue to work on the policies that you're trying to implement tonight. They clearly still need work. They clearly need a lot more public input. Those are not mutually exclusive, as counsel for the town has indicated so eloquently this evening. These are reasonably decided issues this evening, and I think that you can make both those decisions.

4:06:02 And I'd like to take two more seconds before Kirk stands up and rebuts for his 19th time. I think everyone should get equal time, by the way, except that that would take us into, well, tomorrow morning, I think, Kirk. So I'd like to suggest to the three wannabe leaders in the audience here, and the two used to be leaders in the audience, all of whom are running for election and want the very difficult job that the people in the front of the room have now,

4:06:30 That number one, we're making progress, but number two, we absolutely cannot be in the position we're in tonight when the market returns, which we have always been before, and that is we're trying to figure out what we want when there's the opportunity to get it. We need to figure out what we want and what we don't want now while it can't happen, and tonight is part of that, but unfortunately we have a project in the middle of that that makes it very difficult, both on the

4:06:57 And all of us in the community that are trying to get this right. So those people that are running for election need to make sure that when the market returns, we're not in this position for the third time in my life here in Mammoth Lakes. And ask yourself, why does North Star, a very nice area, and with a lot of great people and a beautiful town, you know, Truckee adjacent to that,

4:07:21 Why does North Star, a nice resort, but at least five levels below what Mammoth offers, below the people that we have visiting now, why do they have a Ritz-Carlton? Now some of you say, it's God forbid that Mammoth have a Ritz-Carlton, but how do we avoid having a Ritz-Carlton if that's what we want to have in the future, right? How do we avoid having a Ritz-Carlton? And ask yourself, why do they have a brand new rec center? How do they get that done?

4:07:48 Considering they're five notches below us and don't have anywhere near the capability that we have. And why is that replacing an old rec center that's going to become a performing arts facility now? We can't even pay for the one we have here, John, that we're trying to get in the hands of the town of Mammoth Lake. So why is that? And that's because we cannot get past our differences of opinion. We don't have to put our differences of opinion aside. We can hold them as vehemently as we all do.

4:08:17 But you and those of you that want to replace the people up here need to make sure that you're prepared to provide the leadership that this community needs when we need it, like tonight. So the markets are returning now. There's money flowing back into the debt markets at a somewhat frightening pace. We're not going to have a bubble in the next, you know, 10 minutes. Rest assured, we'll have one again. It'll be in some different area.

4:08:47 But the market is going to return, and we better be capital ready for that. Now, in my book, that means that the things we want to build, we better know what those things are, have them clearly outlined, agree to it, and we take our differences of opinion, apply leadership to them, and have the decisions in place when that capital is ready to flow into those projects so that we have small arguments up here, not five-year-long arguments.

4:09:14 So that we do, again, what Mammoth has always done, which is to miss the first half of the market. We never get our act together until the market is at its peak, and we try to get a few projects done before the end, and we wonder why we don't have all these public facilities. And that's because we don't have the leadership at the right time, and as a community, we don't support the leaders to give us the leadership that we need, but we're not smart enough to specifically ask for at the right time.

4:09:42 So those of you that are running for election, take heed that we cannot be where we are now. Otherwise, we will not get the projects that we want and need, and we will get the projects that we don't want, because the only advantage that's gained during not being prepared for the bull market is capital, out-of-town developers that can come in and take advantage of the fact that we don't have our act together and build the things we don't want.

4:10:10 Go back and look at history and see the four shopping centers that none of us wanted that all got built. Look at the birdhouses on Main Street that got built, right? I apologize if anybody owns that, but that's the funniest project I have ever seen in my life. No, the bank's not here tonight. Yeah, that's right. I'm sure the FDIC is happy about that transaction. So we're making progress tonight. Make the decision tonight against it.

4:10:40 For it, let's move on and make this happen. And those of you that are standing up, and I applaud you for it, even through your six speeches tonight, Kirk, for those of you that want to take the job of leadership, please remember that and make sure that Mammoth isn't as unprepared as we've been in my lifetime here at Mammoth to deal with the realities of what we as a small community need to survive. Thank you.

4:11:04 Thank you, Rusty. Before you rebut, is there anybody else from the public wishing to speak? Lee. Lee? And I'd like to let Mr. Rusty Gregory know that I agree with you it needs to be done, but I disagree with two things with you. One, you need to increase affordable housing. You cannot have aid on the unit. You gave them the hype. We need affordable housing for the working people. We should be respected in this camp. We are an asset to this camp. The second thing that I worry about is taking away the development impact fees.

4:11:40 People do not understand. Eventually, you will have to pay the piper, and the piper is the people. They will put it on to your property taxes. If you cannot pay your property taxes, the assessor can put a lien on your house and you can lose it.

4:11:54 I mean, the people in this town do not have that kind of money. We need the development impact fees. The drainage system needs to be fixed. I agree with this project. We do need it, but I think the developers need to pay the development impact fees. If there's a problem, figure out what would be a good price for them, but we need the development impact fees. And the workforce housing. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Any other public comment? Kirk.

4:12:26 Rusty, this appeal is all about what you said two years ago. Ambiguity is the enemy. And this appeal is about all the ambiguity in CBEDS. And so, you know, with all this lack of follow-through and the misapplication of CBEDS, you know, it's also the enemy. And that's what a big part of this is about. Thank you.

4:12:50 Okay, I'll go ahead and, unless you wanted to wrap up, Mark, or anything to say, I'll go ahead and close the public hearing and call. Yep. Oh, he's getting a drink. He's getting a drink. Call for council deliberation. Do you want to go first? Do you want to try to wrap this up tonight? It's 10 to 10. While we're thinking real quick, in an effort to address Lee's concern about development impact fees, which is really not, that's our next agenda item.

4:13:21 But Lee, one thing to keep in mind, in lowering of development impact fees, or whether they're for housing or whatever they're for, there is a theory that by reducing the development impact fees, you can incentivize a development to occur before, years before it otherwise would occur. And if that happens, a development generates

4:13:50 Bed Tax, or TOT, and as a matter of measures in the town, the community, the town of Mammoth Lakes as an organization receives bed tax, and I believe it's 1% that goes to workforce housing of the transient occupancy tax. 1% of the 13, yeah.

4:14:16 So even though you're not collecting development impact fees at the level that you would otherwise like, by getting the project to come in earlier, you're starting to generate the bed tax, which will do the same thing that the impact fee will do. That's not having any further. Okay. Okay. Wendy? Did you want to continue even though the time is pretty late? Yeah. Yeah. I think we need to.

4:14:46 How did you want to do this, Mr. Mayor? Do you want to take them, do you want to have council discussion on each item one at a time, or do you want to just try and blast through them all? I think that this is cumulatively. So I definitely agree that the policies need more work, that there are things that can be clarified about them. You know, one of the things that we chose quite some time ago was to develop policy concurrently with

4:15:12 Processing development applications and that inherently in and of itself is a very messy process. It doesn't, I think for the level of clarity that some people are seeking, it doesn't provide for that. Trying to determine what it is you want and develop those policies and set those standards at the same time that you're trying to make a determination on the application is very difficult and I think that's some of what we are seeing tonight.

4:15:40 So because I am sick and just struggling to stay upright, although I want to assure everybody that I am not medicated, which doesn't affect my decision making, I'll just try to be very brief and go through the issues. So on issue number one, which has to do with the general plan requirements for the CBIS policy, I think that the appellant has different expectations about what some of these

4:16:09 Actions mean. And I think that when we went into the development of the CBIS policy, I think that I and some of the council members had the same expectations, that we wanted to come out with a very regimented, formula-based policy that says for X amount of square footage of this kind of amenity, you would get X percent of density increase or setbacks or whatever the amenity may be, and that it would be a very

4:16:37 It'd be a very clear-cut policy that's based on some kind of almost a mathematical formula. And as we went through our discussions, we found that that just wasn't really viable based on a couple of things. And so we decided not to have that kind of formula, and we went with a list of uses instead. And the formula-based part of it is actually the financial evaluation, is my understanding of how we are applying the SEBUS policy. On the list of uses that we decided,

4:17:06 To have and as it is related to these policies and how it's applied. I think the confusion is that, you know, what Bill Taylor brought up is that in the Clearwater Specific Plan, there's a reference to that list being solidified by future policy development. Well, the Clearwater Specific Plan was adopted before the CBIS policy was adopted.

4:17:34 That statement in the Clearwater Specific Plan refers to the CBIS policy. And then in the CBIS policy, we said that it's more appropriate to do it district by district because not everything in an entire list that we would put in CBIS that would apply to the entire town, we've cited equestrian facilities, is appropriate for every district.

4:17:57 So what we should have done probably is gone back to the Clearwater Specific Plan, amended it and taken out those few words after we adopted the specific plan because now that policy had been developed and those words didn't need to be in that preface to the list anymore. And I think that's what's creating the confusion because as Mr. Carney pointed out, after we adopted the SEVA's policy, we did go back to the Clearwater Specific Plan list.

4:18:21 And ask whether or not these were appropriate and ask whether or not these met the intentions of the SEVIS policy that we had adopted. So I think that we did follow the policy in that respect. And with regards to program characteristics and criteria, again, I kind of had the expectation at the beginning as well that we would be able to develop specific square footages for particular amenities that we would want in particular places. And as we went through the discussion, we just found

4:18:50 That that wasn't really going to help us meet our objectives and meet our goals and that wasn't going to necessarily provide for the best product because you cannot, we don't have a crystal ball that can tell us what is actually going to be appropriate on that specific site, you know, based on what kind of development is going to come in.

4:19:10 So I think that that's some of the confusion on the CBIS policy. The Planning Commission has asked us for a workshop on that and a review on that, and I think that those issues can be addressed at that time. I think that the CBIS policy certainly needs to be worked on. It certainly – and there's a time and a place to do that, and we tried to do our best with that prior to going into this application, and we can continue to refine it afterwards. As far as the financial analysis,

4:19:38 Which kind of goes into point number two, issue number two, as far as the financial analysis, you know, I'm not a development economist. It's really outside of the realm of my expertise and any kind of training that I've had. And I know that not everybody tends to agree with, you know, what the expertise is in the field and what the best practices are.

4:20:04 I think it's pretty clear that I do tend to follow professional practices and I do tend to agree with those kinds of things. I think the logical and rational explanations that I've given have substantiated those claims. But I also think that there are valid points that were raised, especially for me personally, I would have probably tried to require more amenities.

4:20:29 I would have said that they were required by our general plan policies, some of the things with the plazas, the mid-block connectors and things like that. So I actually took those and I went back and I did the math on them. I thought the analysis by Kaiser-Marston was very clear. I could actually replicate the analysis by taking out the amenities that I thought we could require. And at the end of the day, it didn't change the outcome.

4:20:54 And it's at a point that I think needs to be debated tonight because it doesn't change the outcome of what that financial analysis was and the value of the community benefits versus the value to the developer. But the only reason I bring that up is because I want people to know that I did look at that and that I would like to let staff know that at least from my perspective that I think we should be very, very strict about

4:21:19 What it is that we require from the developers and that if there is any substantiating language in the general plan, then we should require it. But again, in this particular case, that doesn't change the outcome. On the PIEC, and Neil, you can jump in on this part and help me out if you want. You know, I'm sort of disappointed that we're having this discussion because I thought that was the one piece of policy that we developed this year that

4:21:49 Actually had a very broad stakeholder interest that we had true consensus on. So I'm kind of disappointed to see it come back to this point, but it is what it is. My understanding of PIEC and the PAOT analysis was that we were still running a PAOT analysis and calculating the numbers in order to address

4:22:11 That full build out scenario and what the incremental increase in density was going to do to affect those numbers and that would give us a ballpark idea of what that meant. So we're still running those numbers and those numbers are contained in the staff report. Now the PIEC itself was intended to compare the incremental impacts of a project to the thresholds that were set in alternative three in the general plan EIR which is the 52,000 PAOT number.

4:22:41 Because what we were concerned with was we wanted to say that it's okay if we go over 52,000 people in terms of counting individual people if we don't exceed the thresholds of impacts and quality of life issues over 52,000 people.

4:23:04 And so what PIEC was intended to do, help me if I'm not explaining this right, what PIEC was intended to do was to look at the project and to say, does this project exceed the thresholds of 52,000 people? So that we could create a relationship between that density increase and the 52,000 PAOT quality of life threshold, not just a numerical mathematical count.

4:23:33 And my recollection is that, Neil helped me out, cumulative impacts I thought were to be dealt with through the PIR and wasn't specifically necessarily related to PIEC because the focus was on the 52,000 PAOT impact. So that's my recollection on PIEC. So I don't think that this analysis has violated that. I think I already covered failure to identify community benefits.

4:24:02 Under CEQA, I think the air quality issue, and on this I'll look to a nod from Ted Shady from, I think that the air quality issues really come down to an issue about needing to discuss the air quality management plan and potentially updating that. Because we're talking now about needing state

4:24:20 Standards, which is not explicitly in any of the town policies that we intend to meet state standards. We have policies while we have regulatory requirements to meet federal standards. There are no regulatory requirements to meet state standards. In our general plan we say we'd like to. That's not explicitly stated in our air quality management plan, which is the regulatory document for air quality. Those are things that need to be revisited but through the air quality management plan and don't seem to me to be substantiated in the CEQA challenges.

4:24:50 I think the water, greenhouse, gas, and diff issues have been substantially discussed. So it is my feeling that, you know, I actually would have really liked to get into the project a little bit more, but given the time, I'm just going to address the appeal itself. And my personal feeling is that I would not uphold the appeal. John. Let's defer to Skip if he's ready.

4:25:20 The project at Old Mammoth Place, in my opinion, is consistent with the Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. It's consistent with implementing the strategy for North Old Mammoth Road. Additionally, the council has already adopted the Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report on January 7th of 2009.

4:25:49 This project also meets the intent of the Clearwater Specific Plan and meets the intent of the town's general plan. Additionally, the approved district zoning amendment achieves the goals which the town desires for both this particular site and this particular district. This is a good project that has matured and improved through the public process. For someone to imply

4:26:21 in public that the process for this project was somehow rigged is both grossly speculative and irresponsible to say. If nothing else tonight, we understand that the amount of public outreach, the number of public meetings, the number of years involved to date with this process, the patience, in particular of the applicant,

4:26:54 The amount of professional expertise involved in this five-year process clearly and simply tells a totally different story. I would submit that some of those who spoke tonight will not be satisfied with this project under any circumstances. This process has tested and beaten the applicants' submittal greatly. This is a body of work

4:27:28 That has lasted over five years. It is time now tonight to move this submittal ahead and not further endlessly delay its approval. Skip? Just want to make sure I'm not sitting over here under the cone of silence. You know, I probably am, but I'll go for it anyways. You know, the people throughout this process tonight have been very specific that this is not about

4:28:08 The project. It is about the process that we are going through. And it's a process that right now you can't connect the dots on it. It isn't completed. CBiz in itself is a promise that was made to the community that has not really been fulfilled. It's mentioned how a number of places in CBiz, you know, in places where

4:28:36 It clearly states that the list they speak of shall be reviewed and adopted by resolution by the town council. It hasn't been done. It can be done. It's not that hard to do. It could be done. It could have been done before this, and it could have been checked off. There are other places in here that has been brought to our attention that have not been executed properly.

4:29:05 If you come into an area where it talks about incentives will be granted incrementally commensurate to that relationship, when that was written and when CBiz was discussed and even prior to CBiz, that issue was talked about. What are these benefits worth? What is it that we should be getting for increased height, increased density, reduced parking?

4:29:33 What should we be getting? When the developer, rightfully so, speaks about some of the cost of their amenities or the cost of their project, people in town will come back and say, well, yes, it costs a lot to build underground parking, but hey, we've reduced your parking so substantially that if you multiply the cost of a single

4:29:59 Underground parking space by the number of reductions of spaces we have taken off of your project, you're saving millions of dollars, millions and millions of dollars. And so that has to be weighed as we look at the incentive. When you do underground parking, according to our current code, you get that extra 10 feet that takes you from the base density. So right there is your incentive.

4:30:25 For building underground parking, you're getting an extra 10 feet right off the bat. People wanted to be able to have a chance to talk about those things, and they expected council to weigh in on that discussion and make that policy decision as to what these incentives are worth, what the value of them is. And we did not do that. If you look down at the hotel condo policies,

4:30:55 When I asked, you know, about this agenda item, what I see is that the last time it was discussed was at the Planning Commission on July 8th. And the very last paragraph in that...

4:31:09 The minutes of that meeting says, following this meeting, staff will summarize and report the commission's comments to the town council and seek direction from the council regarding development of a hotel ordinance. Staff will frame and present the major intent of such an ordinance based on work to date. Has never been done. Has never been received. Haven't seen it. So I think that at this point, you know, in my mind, leadership

4:31:38 respects and abides by the words of the documents they adopt. That's what leadership is all about. We are close. We are this close to approving this project and getting it through. If we go back now and check off the dots and finish the CBIS process as it was presented and as it was adopted, we probably won't have to do it for the next project because the next project will, from the very beginning,

4:32:08 Go back and make sure that every piece of CBiz is properly checked off. I think the people in this community expect an issue to be heard by this town council, and they expect us to establish the policy before that is implemented. And I think the other thing is that there's enough people in this community that feel the process is flawed that this will not be the end of tonight. We can go ahead and reject the appeal.

4:32:37 But I don't think we're going to hear the end of it. And what we're going to end up with are months and months of more discussion. If we go back and take another month maybe to do it right and to finish this off, then from there on out, I think we will flow smoothly, not just on this project, but all others. But I have concern that this is not the end of it, regardless of what

4:33:02 Our discussion is unless we go back and just take care of a few of those little points. It's just we could do it. We are this close. You know, the other thing that struck me the other day is that the Tellurides and the Solvangs, the Truckees and all these places, they have character. That's what draws people to them. You know, without a lot of work, they really have character. And I believe that to maintain that character

4:33:31 The leaders in those towns work harder to follow their codes, their ordinances in the process as they are intended from the time they are developed instead of looking for loopholes and ambiguities in the documents so they can get around them to move something forward a little easier without really following.

4:33:53 The process the way it is intended and the way it was brought forward to the people. So as you might expect, I would support the appeal. Thank you, Skip. Let me begin by saying that I concur completely with Wendy's comments, her technical comments regarding Pisces and the CBIS policy. I support the Planning Commission decision.

4:34:21 And the reason why I do is I'm thinking about what Alan Blumer said, the alphabet soup. Let's just disregard all of the CBIS and PISC and all that, Dr. Seds and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. But this sounds like an LTC meeting more than anything else. But if you just take a look at the work that's been done on this project, if you take a look at the staff report to the Planning Commission,

4:34:49 That is an eloquent statement of how this project fits into our vision, our general plan, the district study, the Clearwater specific plan, the work that's been done by staff and the work that's been done by the planning commission, and in particular, well not in particular, but also the work that's been done by our economic consultants.

4:35:17 This just gave me a picture of where this project fits within the vision of what we are now and where we're headed. And that's why more than anything I support it. Let me also say that I also support refunding the appellate appeal fee because I believe and I think that, Mark, you said this a little bit earlier in answer to a question I asked you.

4:35:45 I believe you made note of some issues that need to be amplified on, how perhaps CBiz needs to be changed, the policy, and that you intend to bring that to the Planning Commission for Recommendation to Council. I think for, frankly, the amount of money involved is very small compared to the amount of money that's spent on this project, and I think that the appeal has brought out issues that are important to be considered.

4:36:14 I am not saying that that is pointing to some deficiency in the process. I don't mean to say that because this tonight was a de novo hearing on the issue and a decision or a lack of decision by the town council is based upon all of the issues that were discussed tonight and are made part of the record. So I am not saying that the process is flawed in any way.

4:36:44 So with that said, Kevin and Peter, would you watch me like a hawk? Because I believe that I'll call for the question, but this is an appeal of the Planning Commission's decision to approve the vesting tentative track map and the use permit. Therefore, because it's an appeal, it's not like the district zoning amendment we heard at the last meeting. It's a different process.

4:37:14 And therefore, I will call for the question and entertain a motion that the appeal has merit and that the Town Council reverses the Planning Commission's decision to approve the map and the use permit. Is there a motion to that? Say that again? Yeah. I'll be happy to. What did he say? An appeal is a little bit different animal.

4:37:44 Thank you.

4:38:13 I guess to put it another way, the shoe is on the other foot. The people that need the three votes are the appellants. Correct? That's correct. Okay. So, because the situations are reversed, I believe that the appropriate motion is a motion that the appeal has merit and that the Town Council reverses the Planning Commission's decision to approve the tentative map and use permit. Or, in other words,

4:38:43 I move to uphold the appeal. You're not making a motion. I'm not making a motion. That's an example. What you would say if you wanted to make a motion. Okay, I think I get it from you. Is that true? That's correct. You're asking for a motion first.

4:39:12 From those who want to accept the appeal, approve the appeal. So I will make a motion based on the language that Neil has just said. Is there a second? Okay. Hearing no second, the motion fails. Now I have a second question for you. Is it now necessary to make another motion to uphold?

4:39:41 Planning Commission's decision? Yes, I would recommend you do that to clarify the record to be clear what the Council is deciding this evening. Well, then I will entertain a motion that the project is consistent with the Clearwater Specific Plan EIR Guidelines and to uphold the Planning Commission's approval of vesting tentative track map 09-3 and use permit 09-3. So moved. I'll second.

4:40:09 Motion and a second. Any further discussion? I'd just like to make one comment in response to what Skip said, and it kind of relates to what Rusty said, is that, you know, I think that it's important to move forward from this, and I'm concerned about the same thing that you are, Skip, that we won't be able to move forward from this, because history tells us that we have a hard time with that.

4:40:32 And I think that the way to move forward with this, because there isn't, there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of debate, there are a few things about the project, but it's really about the policies and the process, and I think that we do need to address those, and the way to move forward from this decision is to address those issues with those policies and get those things straightened out. So that is, I don't expect anyone to necessarily agree with what

4:40:57 I said necessarily, I was just trying to explain my rationale, but I suppose that is my olive branch to say that we need to continue to work on these policies and get that level of clarity that we all seek and desire, because I do think that's a common goal. Thank you. Any further discussion? Roll call vote, please. Councilmember Harvey? No. Councilmember Stephen? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Eastman? Yes. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. Now there's one final matter.

4:41:30 I would entertain a motion to refund the appeal fee. I would make a motion to refund the appeal fee. Is there a second? No, I'll second it. There's a motion and a second discussion. Is that agendized? Yes. Yes. It's part of the package. I generally am not in favor of that, but I'll vote for it because I think you made some good points, Neil, and I agree with it.

4:41:58 These are issues that need to be talked about. I agree with the point you made, too. And I won't be supporting it. Okay. We'll call vote. Council Member Harvey? Yes. Council Member Stevie Warren? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Easton? No. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. Okay, that concludes item number two. Mr. Mayor, just to clarify. Short break. Procedural matter and housekeeping matter. Yes.

4:42:23 Staff will be bringing back to the council at its next meeting a resolution that will be memorializing, confirming your action tonight and containing some of the CEQA of references that we've included in the testimony today. Okay. Thank you. Oh, Jim. Thank you, Mayor. Ladies and gentlemen of Mammoth, I want to say thank you for being so patient.

4:42:53 Over the last five years, this is, I think, a momentous occasion and one that I trust will be ultimately satisfactory to all of you because, as many have pointed out, it's not about the project, it's about the process. We've now, being the first, have broken that ice to identify those areas that can be improved and we will do so. But more importantly, in our partisan world, I think that we

4:43:21 Have to make an extra effort to heal these types of rifts in a small community such as ours. To that point, I want to invite everybody that stayed up late and watched this and everybody that's here to rafters for a party on me. Free beer, free food, and wine. Come and join us to celebrate and heal those rifts. Thank you, Jim. Thank you. We're going to take a five-minute break.

4:43:51 No, two minute, two minute break, two minute break. Okay, I'll call the meeting back to order, and I, for one, am not in the mood for another public hearing in the next three minutes, so let's try to get done what we absolutely have to get done. Rob? I would suggest that we start with the urban greening planning grant. Okay. That's item number eight. Yeah, Pete is pointing out. I pulled number eight.

4:51:34 Okay. Because I wanted some clarifications. Excuse me just a minute. Yeah. Pete pointed out that the DIF hearing is a notice public hearing, and so you should open the hearing and continue it to the next meeting. Before we move to item number eight, it's item number three. Open the public hearing for the impact demitigation fee schedule for all new development, and we will continue that public hearing until May 5th. Okay. Back to item number eight.

4:52:06 Well, my first question is, is this one time sensitive enough that it cannot wait? Okay. There are some comments in here that this would essentially pay for part of the work that's being done on the downtown neighborhood district plan. I'd like some more specifics on that. We are still in the process of developing the scope for the urban greening project grant, but essentially one of the directions of the...

4:52:35 Main Street plan in particular was this idea of a median as part of the project. And I think overall looking at having a more sustainable downtown as part of one of the ideas. So it's a way to really articulate and expand upon some of those downtown ideas. These aren't necessarily ideas that are completely encompassed in the downtown plan, but it will let us do, I think, a very much better job of expanding and having a really

4:53:04 A really green downtown plan is by using these grant funds. And we're going to take that further in our scope as we develop it. And I see that it does not require matching funds. Was there any attempt to try and leverage other funds so that the application would be more competitive? To my knowledge, no other funds were available that could supplement this. That doesn't preclude other funds from being applied to this that could...

4:53:35 Could potentially replace some of those, but right now we are looking for an application in the region of I think $125,000 to $175,000, which is about half of what the maximum grant amounts are, so we're not really close to the maximum amounts that the grants do allow for. So relatively speaking, this would be a small amount. Okay, and then the second resolution that's on page 9, number 3, certifies that we have the funds to operate and maintain the project.

4:54:03 And where's that funding coming from? One of the things about the green actual project portion of the grant application is to put in plant material that's sustainable for the area and has limited water use, limited also maintenance. And so our thoughts were that we have, you know, quite expansive grass. Some of the areas have actually been narrowed such that grass really isn't appropriate in those spaces anymore. So that, those areas would be replaced with some other material which requires less maintenance.

4:54:39 Do you mean some of the existing grass on Main Street would be replaced with something that's not green but is greener? Well, shrubs that require lower maintenance. Currently, you know, we have significant level of effort that goes into mowing the grass, edging the grass, and those activities. So it would be reducing that area in an equivalent manner that would create the lower maintenance sector.

4:55:05 At work that would be in the median space. And that difference would, it would even out so that there would not be any increased cost? It would be knowing that increasing cost for meetings. Anybody else have any questions on it? Anybody else? Motion? I'll move for adoption of consent agenda item number eight. Second. Motion to second. Any further discussion? Roll call moved. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Sorry.

4:55:37 That's all right. Councilmember Raikin? Yes. Councilmember Sugimura? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Eastman? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Eastman? Yes. Other items? I'll be quick, just push back and hold yours. Who pulled it? I pulled that, and I only pulled it because I just went to vote. I didn't approve it the first time. I'm not going to approve it this time. Oh, yeah.

4:56:07 Further discussion, roll call vote. Motion. Motion. Motion. Motion. Motion first. I'll move to adopt consent agenda item number seven. A second. Motion and second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Harvey? No. Councilmember Seguimura? Yes. Mayor Pro Temesman? Yes. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. Mr. Mayor, why don't we just approve item number six as well?

4:56:28 Nobody pulled it. I'll move that we approve consent agenda item number six. I'll second that. Motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Unanimous.

4:56:37 Okay, six, seven, eight, nine. Do we have time for scheduling of budget? Registered demands. Any questions? Any questions on registered demands? No. No. Scheduling the budget? Yeah, we have 20 seconds. Is the schedule acceptable to Council? Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Council approve the proposed budget schedule as presented. I second. Motion to second. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Anonymous.

4:57:06 We're adjourned to May 5th. Close session. Close session. Sorry. Oh, okay. Oh, okay. Oh, we're good. Oh, okay. Oh, that's right.