TransparentMammoth

Topics

Trails

The Measure R Trails fund (Fund 215) had an available balance of $888,061 at the close of FY24-25 [1] Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf, p. 13.

Updated

Findings

12 findings

  1. 1 Sierra Nevada Conservancy grant funds Sherwin Meadows Trailhead; $130,450 of the award was spent by Sept. 30, 2024

    Updated

    A slide titled "Sherwin Meadows Trailhead - Implementation Grant" in the agenda packet for the January 14, 2025 meeting says funding for the project has been provided by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, an agency of the State of California [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 24[2] 4.2 - SNC Grant Update Presentation 1.14.25_rfs.pdf, p. 9.

    The September 2022 MLR update also lists a July 2022 planning proposal requesting $620,000 for environmental analysis of the proposed Sherwins Area Trails and an expanded trailhead [3] MLR Activity Report 09.21.22.pdf, p. 1. The Trails Manager's report in the October 13, 2022 agenda packet adds that SNC staff indicated the applications would be recommended for approval [4] Agenda (PDF), p. 8.

    The agenda packet for the December 12, 2024 meeting says the implementation proposal was written assuming committed Measure R funds would fill any shortfall in grant funding [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 7. It says that on March 6, 2024, when awarding the construction contract, Town Council approved $82,600 to supplement the $953,400 grant, fully funding the project [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 7. The packet anticipates that deliverable extensions will be needed for both grants [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 7.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 24

    2. 4.2 - SNC Grant Update Presentation 1.14.25_rfs.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 9

    3. MLR Activity Report 09.21.22.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 8

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 7

  2. 2 Measure R Trails fund (Fund 215) available balance was $888,061 at the close of FY24-25, up from $526,758 at the close of FY22-23

    Updated

    The staff report says the fund's revenue comes from an annual allocation from Measure R sales tax and that there is a planned use of fund balance with ongoing trails construction [1] Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf, p. 13. The same report says the available fund balance at the close of FY24-25 is $888,061 with no identified carryover commitments [1] Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf, p. 13.

    Earlier documents report the same fund's available balance at the close of FY23-24 as $842,947 and at the close of FY22-23 as $526,758, each with no identified carryover commitments [2] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 13[3] Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf, p. 13.

    Why it matters

    These are the Town's reported available balances for the fund that pays for trails work, and each report says no carryover commitments were identified [1] Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf, p. 13[2] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 13[3] Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf, p. 13.

    Sources

    1. Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    2. Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    3. Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

  3. 3 Adopted FY2026-27 budget lists $80,000 for Contractual Services in Dept. 457 (Promenade Maintenance)

    Updated

    Public Utilities (account 210-457-43404) shows $2,000 in the approved FY2025-26, modified FY2025-26 and adopted FY2026-27 columns [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 26. Total expenses for the department are shown as $82,000 adopted for FY2026-27, against $50,000 approved for FY2025-26 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 26.

    The page also shows three unlabeled earlier-year figures for this line (33,727; 52,901; 85,154), which we have not used [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 26.

    Why it matters

    The page shows the Town's adopted spending plan for this department for FY2026-27 and the approved plan for the prior year [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 26.

    Sources

    1. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 26

  4. 4 Town–MLTPA agreements: a 2019 services agreement, a July 2022 restatement and a July 2023 recommendation for a three-year agreement

    Updated

    The master agreement says the relationship can be modified by amendment, with each amendment providing specific scopes of work and identified funding sources [1] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf, p. 13.

    The Amended and Restated Services Agreement says the 2022 agreement amends, restates and replaces the 2019 Agreement and extends its term one year [2] Town and MLTPA Services Agreement for FY22-23.pdf, p. 1. A July 12, 2023 staff report says the Town entered into the services agreement with MLTPA in July 2019, which allowed two one-year extensions, and both were pursued [3] MLTPA_Agreement_071719_Staff_Report_.pdf, p. 1.

    The report says scope of work, compensation and rates are to be established annually, and that most MLTPA services are reflected in the Trails Program budget supported by Measure R revenues [3] MLTPA_Agreement_071719_Staff_Report_.pdf, p. 1.

    Why it matters

    These records show how the Town's contract with MLTPA for trail-system work has been structured since 2019, including the dollar amount and hours in the July 2023 recommendation [2] Town and MLTPA Services Agreement for FY22-23.pdf, p. 1[3] MLTPA_Agreement_071719_Staff_Report_.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    2. Town and MLTPA Services Agreement for FY22-23.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (adoption date stated in document) p. 1

    3. MLTPA_Agreement_071719_Staff_Report_.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (date stated in document) p. 1

  5. 5 MLTPA's FY2023/2024 rate sheet lists billable rates of $75 to $98 and allows increases of up to 3% per year

    Updated

    Exhibit C, the MLTPA Rate Sheet, says "MLTPA may increase its annual billable rates at a rate not to exceed 3% per year to allow for annual increases to the costs of doing business in Mammoth Lakes" [1] Item 4.1 - MLTPA Contract 2023 -2027.pdf, p. 18[2] MLTPA Agreement.pdf, p. 18. The version filed with the August 10, 2023 meeting is the billable rate sheet for Fiscal Year 2023/2024, effective July 1, 2023 [1] Item 4.1 - MLTPA Contract 2023 -2027.pdf, p. 18.

    A note says MLTPA staff positions are not annual salaried positions and that projects and tasks are at the direction of the Town or other clients per executed agreements [2] MLTPA Agreement.pdf, p. 18.

    Why it matters

    The sheet sets the starting billable rates for MLTPA staff positions and caps annual increases at 3% [2] MLTPA Agreement.pdf, p. 18[1] Item 4.1 - MLTPA Contract 2023 -2027.pdf, p. 18.

    Sources

    1. Item 4.1 - MLTPA Contract 2023 -2027.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 18

    2. MLTPA Agreement.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 18

  6. 6 Mammoth Trails Committee has seven members serving three-year terms; one seat was vacant as of June 8, 2026

    Updated

    A June 8, 2026 staff report by Executive Director Kim Anaclerio says the Mammoth Trails Committee, a sub-committee of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, provides program and fiscal oversight for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System [1] Attachment 4.1 - MLR Staff Report Candidate.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 9. When a member resigns early, the new appointee fills the remainder of that term [1] Attachment 4.1 - MLR Staff Report Candidate.pdf, p. 1.

    The report says the committee "currently has one vacant position with a term ending January 2028" and recommends appointing a new member [1] Attachment 4.1 - MLR Staff Report Candidate.pdf, p. 1. Standing Rules in the February 8, 2024 agenda packet say a member may hold up to three consecutive terms, then must abstain for one year before being reappointed and confirmed by the Directors [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 39.

    Why it matters

    The committee, under its standing rules, provides governance, fiscal, work program and funding-allocation oversight for the trail system [1] Attachment 4.1 - MLR Staff Report Candidate.pdf, p. 1[3] Agenda (PDF), p. 39.

    Sources

    1. Attachment 4.1 - MLR Staff Report Candidate.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 9

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 39

  7. 7 Sherwins Area Recreation Plan: conceived in 2009; a presenter in April 2022 said the Town adopted it in 2011

    Updated

    A December 11, 2019 Mammoth Trails e-blast, quoted in an outreach index filed with the August 13, 2020 meeting, says the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan (SHARP) was "conceived by members of the Sherwins Working Group in 2009" [1] Attachment #5 - LBSAT Historical Outreach Information, p. 2.

    At that point the presenter also said there were no system trails in the Sherwins Meadow [2] Mammoth Trails Committee — 2022-04-14 15:00:00, 1:41:32.

    The FY22-23 project descriptions list a "Sherwins Area (SHARP) Planning" project to support environmental documents for the NEPA/CEQA process [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 37.

    Why it matters

    The records trace the Sherwins plan from its 2009 origin to the 2022 planning and trailhead grant work described in the Sierra Nevada Conservancy applications [1] Attachment #5 - LBSAT Historical Outreach Information, p. 2[4] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf, p. 3[5] MLR Activity Report 09.21.22.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Attachment #5 - LBSAT Historical Outreach Information

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    2. Mammoth Trails Committee — 2022-04-14 15:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 37

    4. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    5. MLR Activity Report 09.21.22.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  8. 8 A fall 2010 Measure R application expected the first phase of the MLTS Signage and Wayfinding Program to be completed in summer 2011

    Updated

    The 2010 Fall Measure R Application, filed with the December 1, 2010 meeting, says "completion of the first phase of the MLTS Signage and Wayfinding Program in the summer of 2011 will greatly enhance the aesthetics and usability of the Lakes Basin Path and the Town Loop" [1] Measure R Application #14, p. 5.

    The April 2010 FY 2009-10 Workplan Status Report lists "Corbin Design Contract Work" for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Design Standards Manual ("Fall 2010") at 5%, noting MLTPA had contracted with Corbin Design and an initial outline had been produced [2] Study Session, p. 17. A September 6, 2011 Recreation Commission Town document page describes the Standards Manual as a companion document to the Trail System Master Plan 2009 [3] RC Agenda_September 6, 2011_Part Two, p. 8. A TSMP Analysis note says the Standards Manual was "in process to be completed Spring 2021 and sent to TOML" (notes last edited January 2021) [4] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf, p. 2.

    The Office of Outdoor Recreation update also says 5 new interpretive signs for the Sherwins Trailhead were in process [5] OOR_TOMLCouncilUpdate_020525.pdf, p. 2.

    Sources

    1. Measure R Application #14

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

    2. Study Session

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 17

    3. RC Agenda_September 6, 2011_Part Two

      archive_itemno date foundp. 8

    4. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    5. OOR_TOMLCouncilUpdate_020525.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

  9. 9 Records list the Lake Mary Road Bike Path as complete; a Lakes Basin Path section opened in August 2010

    Updated

    A TSMP Analysis status table filed with the April 11, 2024 meeting lists "Lake Mary Bike Path - Complete" [1] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf, p. 13. The January 31, 2011 work program status report says construction on the Lakes Basin Path between Minaret and Lower Twin Lakes was completed and opened in August 2010 [2] Handout - Fiscal Year 2010-11 Work Program Monthly Status Report - 01-31-11, p. 14.

    The TSMP Analysis says MLTPA established consensus and documented new naming conventions for several trails, including the Lakes Basin Path (formerly the Lake Mary Road Bike Path) [3] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf, p. 21. A 2010 entry in the 2013 summary lists the same naming effort [4] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf, p. 3.

    Why it matters

    The records tie the completed path to specific years and funding sources, and show it now goes by a different name than the original project title [5] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf, p. 4[3] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf, p. 21.

    Sources

    1. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    2. Handout - Fiscal Year 2010-11 Work Program Monthly Status Report - 01-31-11

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 14

    3. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 21

    4. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    5. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

  10. 10 A 2013 summary lists a 2010–2012 gap closure project at Mammoth Creek/Sherwin Street with a bridge, parking and signage

    Updated

    The summary dated March 20, 2013 lists "Gap Closure Project at Mammoth Creek/Sherwin Street" as a multi-year effort, 2010 to 2012, to design, plan and construct an MLTS gap closure including a bike/pedestrian bridge, enhanced parking and MLTS signage, with TOML as the listed party [1] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf, p. 4. It lists funding sources as State "Environmental and Enhancement Mitigation Program (EEMP)" funds and Town "Measure R" funds for signage [1] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf, p. 4[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 105.

    The TSMP Analysis status table lists, as separate entries, "Mammoth Creek Gap Closure - Enviro on-going, construct spring 2016" and "Sherwin St. Bridge - Complete" [3] Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf, p. 13.

    Sources

    1. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis_2006-20012_.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 105

    3. Item 5.3 - TSMP_Analysis.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

  11. 11 FY22-23 Mammoth Lakes Trail System project descriptions include a Standards Manual and an Action Plan and Budget project

    Updated

    The FY22-23 Project Descriptions, under "PROGRAM (Measure R) PROJECTS" in the May 3, 2022 agenda packet, list Standards Manual, Signage and Wayfinding, Sherwins Area (SHARP) Planning and Action Plan and Budget, among others [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 37. The Standards Manual description says it "ensures that clear and consistent signage exists on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System" [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 37.

    The Action Plan and Budget project is described as "Budgeting short, medium, and long-term implementation of projects from the TSMP including drafting of an annual budget and quarterly updates for review and recommendation by MTC and MLR for consideration and appropriation by the Town Council" [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 37. The same project descriptions appear in the October 13, 2022 agenda packet [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 28.

    Why it matters

    The descriptions show how the FY22-23 Measure R trail projects were meant to feed into the budget: committee and MLR review, then Town Council appropriation [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 37[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 28.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 37

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 28

  12. 12 A 2018/2019 cost estimate lists a $112,000 MLTPA Foundation contract with a $97,000 grant request and $15,000 match

    Updated

    The line shows a total of $112,000, a grant request of $97,000 and a match of $15,000 [1] Item 4.2 - 710_01_FINAL_SIGNED_SRIC_OHV_AGREEMENT.pdf, p. 5. The page describes MLTPA as "a local non-profit organization contracted to support the Mammoth Lakes Trail System" [1] Item 4.2 - 710_01_FINAL_SIGNED_SRIC_OHV_AGREEMENT.pdf, p. 5.

    Why it matters

    The estimate shows how the 2018/2019 program combined a grant request, a Town match and valued volunteer hours to support the trail system through the MLTPA contract [1] Item 4.2 - 710_01_FINAL_SIGNED_SRIC_OHV_AGREEMENT.pdf, p. 5[2] Item 4.2 - 710_01_FINAL_SIGNED_SRIC_OHV_AGREEMENT.pdf, p. 3.

    Sources

    1. Item 4.2 - 710_01_FINAL_SIGNED_SRIC_OHV_AGREEMENT.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

    2. Item 4.2 - 710_01_FINAL_SIGNED_SRIC_OHV_AGREEMENT.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

Updates

Added after this page was first published. The summary and findings above are unchanged.

: Trails Committee reviews draft Standing Rules; MLTPA extended for FY26-27 at $44,783 minimum

The Mammoth Trails Committee agenda for October 26, 2026 includes a review of updated Standing Rules; the staff report says the current rules were adopted in 2022 and that staff was directed to bring back a draft reflecting the Committee's current functions [1]. The proposed October 2026 draft describes the committee as advisory and says it "does not independently approve budgets or funding allocations" and does not direct MLR or Town staff, manage projects, or enter agreements [2]. The 2022 rules instead describe oversight of governance, fiscal matters, work program and specific funding allocations [3]. Both versions provide for seven members: six with staggered terms and one Town designee without a fixed term [2][3]. The draft says vacancies may be filled for the remainder of an unexpired term [2].

The Outdoor Recreation Programs Manager report states that Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access (MLTPA) is working under a one-year contract extension for Fiscal Year 26-27, covering administration and operations and graphic, design, media and mapping services [4]. It says the Town has committed to minimum Base Compensation of $44,783, to be paid to MLTPA for up to 450 hours of work [4].

The same report lists summer 2026 stewardship results. At the June 6 National Trails Day at Sherwin Meadows Trailhead, 58 volunteers cut .25 miles of new trail [5]. Wednesday Worknights on SHARP trails produced ¾ mile of new trail construction [5]. The Eastern Sierra Adopt A Trail program reported 43 sponsors and $60,600 in sponsorship dollars, and Tangle Free Waters reported 22 sponsors and $9,000 [4].

A Town staff report for the October 21, 2026 Council meeting says SHARP is in implementation for SHARP 3, and that SHARP 4 is the final environmental analysis needed in the Snowcreek Meadow Area and Panorama Dome [6]. The Town's FY26/27 Inyo National Forest Program of Work priorities letter lists continued Sherwin Meadows (SHARP 4) trail planning and implementation among five items [7]. A separate staff report for the October 26 committee meeting says the Town adopted a Trail System Master Plan in 1991 and an update in 2011, and plans to update it over the next 2-3 years [8].

  1. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 6
  2. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 7
  3. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 9
  4. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 12
  5. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 11
  6. Town Council 2026-10-21: Agenda (PDF), p. 217
  7. Town Council 2026-10-21: Agenda (PDF), p. 219
  8. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Attachment 5.2 - TOML_Trails_Program_StaffReport_MTC_102126.pdf, p. 1

: Staff report says the Town will update its 2011 Trail System Master Plan in the next 2-3 years and 2 other updates

A Town of Mammoth Lakes staff report prepared by Andrew Mulford, titled "Trail System Master Plan Review – Chapter 4 and additional discussion items," is dated for the 10/26/2026 meeting [1]. The report says the Town adopted a Trail System Master Plan (TSMP) in 1991 and an updated plan in 2011 [1]. It calls the 2011 plan "our current guiding document" and says "we will be conducting an update in the next 2-3 years" [1]. The report says staff would like "this group" to review the current TSMP and provide input to help guide the creation of the updated document [1].

For the October 26, 2026 meeting, the staff report asks members to review Chapter 4, "Future Trail System Recommendations" (pages 111-166 of the plan) [1]. They include what the Town/Office of Outdoor Recreation (Trails Program) has done very well, what items have been neglected, what is missing from the current document, and what elements may be irrelevant in the current situation [1]. It also asks what areas of friction may have kept the Town from making progress on key elements of the TSMP [1]. The report adds that at the next MTC meeting, on 12/14, staff will share a Summer 2026 Trail Counter report and discuss the trail use data collection program [1].

The October 26, 2026 agenda packet includes a document headed "Proposed Draft – October 2026, Standing Rules of the Mammoth Trails Committee," subtitled "A subcommittee of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Inc." [2]. The draft says the committee operates under the authority of the MLR Board, MLR's governing documents, the Standing Rules and applicable law [2]. The draft says the committee is advisory and "does not independently approve budgets or funding allocations" [2]. It also says the committee does not direct MLR or Town staff, manage projects, enter agreements, or bind MLR or the Town [2]. It provides for seven appointed voting members: six on staggered terms and one designated Town representative with no fixed term [2].

  1. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 15
  2. Mammoth Trails Committee 2026-10-26: Agenda (PDF), p. 7