Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
22 items · 43 attachments- 1 CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
- 2 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
- 3 PUBLIC COMMENTS
- 4 ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA
- 5 INTRODUCTIONS
-
5.1
Introduce new Airport Maintenance Coordinator William DesBrosses.
-
5.2
Introduce new Fleet Manager Larry Boardman.
-
5.3
Introduce new Revenue Specialist Natalie Marrone.
- 6 TOWN COUNCIL PRESENTATIONS
-
6.1
Recognition of Recreation Manager Kat Kelly for ten years of service to the Town of Mammoth Lakes.
-
6.2
Approve the proclamation declaring October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month.
-
6.3
Approve the proclamation declaring October 21, 2026 as Support Your Local Chamber of Commerce Day.
- 7 STAFF PRESENTATIONS
-
7.1
Flock Safety Update 2026.
- 8 REPORTS FROM COMMISSIONS AND/OR DEPARTMENTS (AS NEEDED)
-
8.1
Town of Mammoth Lakes Social Media Report for September 2026.
-
8.2
October 2026 Public Works Engineering CIP Update.
- 9 CONSENT AGENDA
-
9.1
Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 16, 2026.
-
9.2
Adopt the resolution approving an amended Conflict of Interest Code.
-
9.3
Update and Request Approval for Continuing Emergency Contract Work at Mammoth Yosemite Airport.
-
9.4
Authorize the Town Manager to execute a professional services agreement with Ascent Environmental, Inc. for preparation of the Town’s 7th Cycle Housing Element update.
-
9.5
Accept Check Register 9/17/26 in the amount of $1,168,204.30. Accept Check Register 9/24/26 in the amount of $807,950.93. Accept Check Register 9/28/26 in the amount of $236,025.00. Accept Check Register 10/1/26 in the amount of $851,773.85. Accept Check
Register 10/8/26 in the amount of $918,652.94.
- 10 PUBLIC HEARINGS
-
10.1
Hold a public hearing to consider a grant application and planned activities for the State Permanent Local Housing Allocation (PLHA) Program.
-
10.2
Hold a public hearing to discuss expenditures and accomplishments of the Town’s 2021 Community Development Block Grant (21-CDBG-HA-00015).
-
10.3
Hold a public hearing under the Tax and Equity Fiscal Responsibility Act (“TEFRA”) in connection with the proposed issuance of revenue bonds by the California Municipal Finance Authority (the “CMFA”) for the rehabilitation of four existing Mammoth Lakes
Family apartment projects within Mammoth Lakes.
- 11 POLICY MATTERS
-
11.1
Appeal of TOT/TBID penalties and interest by Michael Cisneros.
-
11.2
Receive and discuss the draft 2026 Affordable Housing Impact Fee Nexus Study.
-
11.3
Waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 8.14 Solid Waste Recycling.
-
11.4
Town of Mammoth Lakes priorities for the Fiscal Year 26/27 Inyo National Forest Program of Work.
- 12 COUNCILMEMBER REPORTS
- 13 REQUESTS FOR FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
- 14 ADJOURNMENT
Notable from this meeting
9 findings-
Council hears Flock update October 21; staff to bring back policy item November 4
Flock investigation
Also in: License Plate Readers (Flock), Public Safety and Police - Year-round Bishop air service begins; summer 2026 MRG payouts reported; airport CalFIRE work continues Airport and Air Service
- Council amends Conflict of Interest Code on Oct. 21 consent agenda; Hoff appointment noted Elections and Governance
-
Council introduces ordinance amending Chapter 8.14 recycling code to create self-haul agreements
Fund 205 - Solid Waste
Also in: Solid Waste (Dept 490) - August 2026 TBID receipts run 6.0% over budget year to date; Council hears TOT/TBID penalty appeal Fund 218 - Tourism Business Improvement District (TBID)
- Council hears Access Apartments CDBG closeout; Housing Element consultant and housing fee nexus study filed Housing
- October 2026 records show CRC operating status, RecZone figures, and Dept 436-coded payments Multi-Use Facility (Dept 436)
-
Council upholds $7,854.39 in penalties and interest in Lee Road unregistered short-term rental appeal
Short-Term Rentals
Also in: TOT: Penalties & Interest (100-000-30644), Tourism and TOT - Trails Committee reviews draft Standing Rules; MLTPA extended for FY26-27 at $44,783 minimum Trails
Transcript
2523 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
6:47 Okay, welcome! We're going to bring this meeting to order. Welcome to the Town Council meeting on October 21st. We will do roll call, please, Jamie.
6:57 Councilmember Sauser? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Councilmember Hoth? Present. Mayor Pro Tem, Truex? Here. Mayor Rice? Here. And Kim Anaclario is going to lead us in the pledge this evening. Please stand.
7:09 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
7:26 Thank you.
7:30 Okay, so we are on to item three. That is public comment. If there's anyone in the room who would
7:36 like to make a public comment for anything that is not on the agenda, please approach the
7:39 podium, or if you're online, please raise your hand.
7:45 All right. Looks like no unscheduled public comments.
7:49 Rob, are there any additions to the agenda?
7:52 Yes, Mayor Rice, we are removing item 5.2 this evening. We'll be scheduling that at a future meeting. Thank you.
7:58 Okay. Wonderful. We are on to item five, introductions. 5.1, introduce new airport maintenance coordinator,
8:05 William DeBrosis. I don't know if I got that right. I'm sorry if I didn't.
8:16 Good afternoon, council, mayor, mayor pro tem, staff, public. It is William DeBrosis.
8:25 Thank you.
8:26 And I am Brian Spring, airport manager, Mammoth Yosemite Airport. And I'd love to introduce our latest full-time airport maintenance coordinator.
8:35 Will did spend the winter with us and decided he couldn't leave.
8:43 From Bishop and a pilot. Also very, let's see, I'm trying to only share your best qualities.
8:58 Extremely curious.
9:00 Right. This is this is the thing that we value at the airport is people who want to know how it works and who care about it.
9:07 And and Will is is teaching us all in those areas. So we're very happy to have you and we look forward to a wonderful winter ahead.
9:22 How's it going? I'm Will. I'm super grateful for the opportunity to work at the Mammoth Yosemite Airport.
9:27 It's an awesome team down there. Coworkers are super cool, very informative and learning a lot in the job and having a great time.
9:35 An amazing manager. So just grateful to be there. Thank you.
9:48 What can you fly?
9:49 Sorry about getting your name wrong.
9:51 Thank you.
9:52 Thank you.
9:53 Welcome.
9:55 All right. Thank you.
10:01 So we are on to item 5.3. Introduce new revenue specialist, Natalie Maroney.
10:11 Do we have someone introducing her or is she introducing herself?
10:15 Okay.
10:16 It's like box self-service.
10:18 Yeah.
10:23 Good evening, town council. Ben Manning, revenue accountant.
10:26 It's my great pleasure to introduce Natalie.
10:29 Natalie has been here for 15 years.
10:31 Before she joined us, she was working as an accountant for Altera Shared Services after transitioning from the finance department at Mammoth Mountain.
10:43 She has her bachelor degrees in business administration and a minor in accounting.
10:48 She's been here so long.
10:50 Excuse me.
10:52 And she's also worked with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the chamber.
10:58 Wow.
11:02 A lot of pressure on this one, huh?
11:05 Yeah.
11:06 Anyway, she's an avid skier.
11:07 What I would say is I've known Natalie for 10 years.
11:10 She was the roommate of my girlfriend, who's now my wife.
11:14 And so we know each other very well and we're super excited to have you.
11:18 Thank you.
11:19 Yeah, I'm really excited to be here.
11:21 Yeah, I've worked with the community a lot in the past.
11:25 I've kind of gotten away with that with my other jobs and happy to be involved again, you know, in the community, able to serve them using my background and just really excited to join the team and be a part of the town.
11:38 Great.
11:38 Thank you.
11:39 No choice.
11:48 Good to see you.
11:49 Yes, you too.
11:50 So happy.
11:50 Thank you.
11:52 Uh-oh.
11:53 Thank you.
11:54 Hi.
11:54 Jesus.
11:55 Thank you.
12:00 Okay, we are on to item 6, Town Council Presentations. Item 6.1, Recognition of Recreation Manager, Kat Kelly, for 10 years of service to the Town of Mammoth Lakes.
12:18 Thank you, thank you, Madam Mayor. Mayor Pro Tem, members of Council, staff. Ben was so anxious to leave, he left his notes.
12:30 So, tonight, I have the distinct pleasure to recognise and celebrate Kat's 10 years of dedicated service.
12:36 Alright, it goes so fast, doesn't it?
12:38 To the Town of Mammoth Lakes and to the Parks and Recreation Department.
12:41 Kat began her journey with the Town as a Recreation Supervisor, overseeing the outdoor ice rink, Whitmore Pool, summer camps, adult programs, facility user groups and facility reservations.
12:51 Pretty much everything that we were doing at the time.
12:53 Kat also played a key role in launching ActiveNet, if you remember that, back in the day, about 10 years ago.
13:00 Kat does.
13:02 That was our first web-based reservation system, which was a big milestone for Parks and Recreation.
13:07 When we hired Kat in 2016, I told Kat we would be opening a brand new indoor ice rink.
13:13 Kat, a...
13:14 One year.
13:14 Still here.
13:16 Within a couple of years. I don't know if I said the next year.
13:19 And that we wouldn't have to shovel every day just to open.
13:23 Well, seven years before we officially skated indoors.
13:27 But I'm deeply grateful that Kat never got tired of shoveling and never stopped believing in our shared vision.
13:34 Kat's strong work ethic, collaborative leadership style and her positive, enthusiastic, kind of Aussie get-it-done attitude
13:40 earned her a well-deserved promotion to Recreation Manager in 2020.
13:44 We all are continued to be impressed with Kat's ability to connect with our community, build trust and loyalty with her team, and set and uphold an exceptional standard of excellence.
13:56 Now in its fourth season, the CIC continues, as we all know, to exceed community expectations.
14:01 Thank you.
14:02 Kat's accomplishments are many, so I'm just going to try and highlight just a few more recent ones.
14:15 And that was kind of launching our expansive membership program, which was last year.
14:20 Overseeing the LA Kings Partnership and Hockey Development Programs, and managing the Youth Sports Funding Program and Tony Colisado Scholarship Program.
14:28 Kat also, if you don't know this, works tirelessly to ensure our youth sports organizations have every opportunity to thrive and remain sustainable.
14:39 You probably didn't know this, but Kat is also well-known for the Kat conversion.
14:46 Right?
14:46 I know that.
14:47 Anybody?
14:47 Yeah, curling, right?
14:50 So few, if any, facilities have converted an Olympic-sized ice rink to an NHL ice rink with a dedicated curling lane.
14:58 We're one of really probably...
15:00 You're the only one. Yeah, there you go. CAT championed this effort, and I think we can all agree it's been a tremendous success.
15:07 It is only a matter of time, as we all keep saying, before Mammoth Lakes is cheering on its first Olympic curler or curlers.
15:16 In closing, I'm excited to see how CAT will continue to elevate community recreation in Mammoth Lakes in the years ahead.
15:21 And I know I speak for the entire Parks and Recreation team today when I say we are incredibly fortunate to have CAT as part of the town team.
15:32 With that, I'd like to say, if CAT would like to say a few words.
15:35 There you go.
15:37 Thank you very much, Stu, for your kind words.
15:39 I would be remiss if I wasn't to thank Stu for his fantastic leadership and mentorship during the last 10 years.
15:45 I do distinctly remember him saying, come on, mate, it's only going to be a year before we get inside, so don't worry about it.
15:51 So, yeah.
15:52 But I also really want to thank my team.
15:56 I have an amazing Parks and Rec team.
15:58 Their hard work and their successes are what make my job really fun and really enjoyable.
16:03 And looking forward to another 10 years here.
16:05 So, we'll see what we can get done in the next 10.
16:08 We have a certificate for you.
16:16 Let's all come on down for a photo.
16:19 Great.
16:36 I'm still slow.
16:38 Are you here?
16:38 It's okay.
16:39 Three, two, one.
16:43 Congratulations.
16:43 Thank you.
16:45 Congratulations.
17:01 Okay.
17:02 We are on to item 6.2.
17:04 Approve the proclamation declaring October as domestic violence awareness month.
17:13 I do have it right here.
17:15 Do I have to read it first or do we make a motion first and approve it and then I read it?
17:20 I think...
17:21 The procedure on this is a little bit loose so you can make a motion and then read it or
17:25 you can read it and then make a motion to approve it.
17:28 I would ask do we have someone in the audience who's here to accept that because sometimes they
17:33 want to have comments as well through the process.
17:34 Okay.
17:35 Would you like to make comments first or what?
17:36 I don't know.
17:37 I'm asking for direction.
17:38 I'm getting nothing.
17:40 Thank you for supporting Wild Diaries.
17:41 I'm here to receive our commission on behalf of the staff, the board, and especially the survivors
17:54 that we helped through domestic violence.
17:56 Thank you.
17:57 Thank you.
17:58 Well, I'll...
17:59 Well, I'll...
18:00 I'll take...
18:00 Entertain a motion.
18:00 I'd like to make a motion to approve the proclamation declaring October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month.
18:06 And I will second that.
18:08 Roll call, please.
18:09 Councilmember Sauser?
18:11 Yes.
18:12 Councilmember Wentworth?
18:13 Yes.
18:13 Councilmember Hoff?
18:14 Yes.
18:15 Mayor Pro Tem, Truex?
18:16 Yes.
18:16 Mayor Rice?
18:17 Yes.
18:19 A proclamation of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lake, State of California, proclaiming October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month, whereas although progress has been made toward breaking the cycle of domestic violence,
18:29 and supporting victims and their families of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, much work remains to be done.
18:35 And whereas Wild Iris has served over 400 survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault over the last year and advocates, law enforcement officials, health care providers, court systems, tribal organizations,
18:49 and others are an integral part of the effort to end domestic violence in the eastern Sierra and must be recognized and applauded for their work.
18:55 Now, therefore, be it resolved that in recognition of the important work done by Wild Iris and all victim service providers, the Town of Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes hereby proclaims that the month of October 2026 is Domestic Violence Awareness Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes
19:12 and encourages all residents to observe Domestic Violence Awareness Month.
19:16 Would you like to, are we taking a photo for this one?
19:23 All right, let's come on down for our photo.
19:26 I'll try to walk faster this time.
19:35 Everyone's got a position, so you got a little trying.
19:41 Sweep it a little bit.
19:45 Reach it well.
19:47 Thank you.
19:48 Thank you.
19:48 Okay, so we are on to item 6.3, Approve the Proclamation Declaring October 21st, 2026 as Support Your Local Chamber of Commerce Day.
20:16 Hello.
20:17 Hi, Brianna.
20:17 Good afternoon, Council.
20:19 I'm Brianna Guayco with the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce.
20:22 And, yes, today is actually Support Your Local Chamber of Commerce Day, so that was interesting timing by the National Association to really line it up with the Council meeting.
20:31 And so I just wanted to hit on a couple of things that our chamber has been working on.
20:37 So today we're actually launching a new campaign called the Chamber Shift.
20:43 So this was, came, an idea from our VP of Communications and Membership.
20:49 So I'll be going into different businesses and working the front lines of those various businesses just to highlight the work of our business community.
20:59 And, yes, I'll be going into different businesses and working the front lines of those various businesses.
21:00 And so we just launched our campaign, I think, an hour or two ago.
21:04 We just got the video up on Instagram, so anyone can take a look at that.
21:08 My first shift was at Mammoth Lakes Laundry Mat, so I was folding laundry there very poorly earlier this week.
21:14 So that's just a way for us just to highlight businesses in our community and the important work that they do.
21:21 A couple other things that we partner on, obviously we partner with Mammoth Lakes Tourism every month on community coffee.
21:26 The next one is taking place next, yes, no, this, next Thursday, sorry, next Thursday, October 29th, 8.30 a.m. on Zoom, as always.
21:36 Our speaker will be Dawn Johnson from the National Weather Service in Reno, so should be some good insight.
21:42 Obviously, everybody's been hyping the Super El Nino, so it will be very interesting to hear what she has to say at that.
21:49 So again, that's next Thursday, 8.30 a.m. on Zoom, and our featured coffee shop this month is Cafe Crate.
21:56 And then two things, we just wrapped up earlier today our career expo program at the high school.
22:03 So we brought over 50 speakers into the school to talk to students about various career and job opportunities that are available either in Mammoth or working remote from Mammoth,
22:13 but really just highlighting all the opportunities that are available to them.
22:17 So we started this program back in 2022.
22:21 We started our career compass program with the school, and it's been really great to see it grow and to have the school partner with us on that.
22:28 Something that a lot of speakers, we got some really great feedback this year.
22:32 The students can be kind of a tough audience to speak to, talking to teenagers, but this year we had some really wonderful feedback from our speakers.
22:39 There was a break portion and students just grabbing snacks, which can be a little chaotic, 15 minutes, 300 students.
22:47 But our volunteers just communicated to us how respectful the students were and how they really kind of saw some of those that have done this year over year really saw a shift in some of the students' behavior.
22:58 So that's great to see.
23:00 I think the principal having a steady principal and leadership there is helping.
23:04 So our last thing is our 10th annual Business Excellence Awards Gala is taking place on Thursday, November 5th, so two weeks from tomorrow.
23:13 We had a record number of nominations from the community, so it's really great to hear from people outside of the chamber,
23:20 outside of the business community in Mammoth to nominate those that they feel really deserve awards.
23:25 So we're really excited about that event taking place where all of the winners will be announced.
23:31 I wanted to thank our sponsors, Limelight Mammoth, Saracosta Community College, Stellar Brew, Mammothix Tourism, Orion Capital, SoCal Edison, and Eastern Sierra Community Bank.
23:41 So a big event like this, we need sponsors to make it happen, so really grateful to all of them.
23:46 So in this week, this week and next week papers, newspapers, both the Mammoth Times and the Sheet will be putting out a list, full page ads, of everyone who is nominated.
23:58 So unfortunately, I don't know if it's not a list, but I don't know if it's not a list.
24:00 with over 200 nominations we can't get to every person and let them know so just stay tuned for
24:05 that and look out for your name or business and that'll be listed in there and a couple tickets
24:09 remaining to the gala if anyone's interested but we're just really grateful for the work that we
24:13 get to do in this community and for the support and partnership that we have with the town
24:19 we're constantly talking within with our board with our team how we can better serve our community
24:24 and you know we really focus on how we can support we have some programming coming up soon how we can
24:30 support the individual in a workforce capacity with their employment so we can have strong
24:37 businesses in town which hopefully you know contributes to a thriving community generates
24:42 those taxes we need to have everything run in town so we really kind of think about you know
24:47 the individual the business and then the overall community with the work that we do and make sure
24:51 that it kind of hits all of those things so thank you so much to the town and to council for your
24:56 partnership thank you um okay um i i would entertain a motion for this proclamation move to approve the
25:05 proclamation second roll call please jamie councilmember sauser yes councilmember whitworth yes councilmember
25:13 hoff yes mayor pro tem truex yes mayor rice yes um and then i'll read the proclamation for you
25:20 um a proclamation of the town council of the town of mammoth lakes whereas chambers of commerce strive
25:25 to address the community's top challenges and greatest opportunities through bold leadership and
25:30 innovative problem solving and whereas chamber of commerce foster stronger more vibrant communities
25:36 by advocating for priorities to promote economic prosperity enhance quality of life and create access
25:42 to meaningful employment and opportunity for all residents and whereas chambers of commerce are
25:47 champions of communities serving as a trusted resource for businesses residents and other stakeholders
25:54 and whereas the mammoth lakes chamber of commerce works to foster a business environment that
25:58 promotes business development supports established businesses and encourages new business and
26:03 investment within the town of mammoth lakes now therefore be it resolved that the town council of the town of mammoth lakes
26:09 hereby proclaims october 21st 2026 as support your local chamber of commerce stay in the town of mammoth lakes
26:15 and encourages all residents to learn more about our local chamber its support of our local businesses and the
26:20 impact of the broader community all right photo op oh boy
26:26 the impact of our local chamber of commerce is a great place for us to be able to do this
26:43 thank you
26:49 thank you
27:02 Okay, so we are on to Item 7, Staff Presentations. Item 7.1, Flock Safety Update 2026.
27:09 Good evening, Council. Dan Kasabian, Chief of Police. Before you tonight is our annual Flock Update. We did one last year. This one's going to be a little bit different. This year we prepared a PowerPoint for you. To my left I have Sergeant Daniel Hansen who's going to go through the PowerPoint.
27:27 But we're going to discuss not only the successes that we've had but also some of the challenges that we have recently been faced with with Flock. When that time comes, I'll turn it over to Rob to discuss some of the challenges and we will be available for any type of questions that you may have.
27:46 So as of now, I'm going to go ahead and turn it over to Rob. Go ahead and move it to the next slide. And Rob will discuss some of these challenges as we go through.
27:58 Can I make one comment? It looks like the screen is not working. I suggest maybe we could turn this one because, well, we all have computers to follow along.
28:08 Are we able to get it working, Jamie? Yay. Magician. Thank you. It's IT support. Thank you.
28:16 Thank you, Chris, for speaking up on that.
28:21 Yeah, so appreciate the time tonight to talk about some of the tougher points of Flock and some of the responses to things that we've been seeing in the community, questions and so forth that have come up recently.
28:35 As you know, Flock is sort of under a lot of scrutiny nationwide, I think, for maybe just the way it is as an organization or perhaps the functions that it performs.
28:46 I am glad that we have the opportunity to talk about this tonight, both from a standpoint of what we think is wrong, but also what we think is right.
28:55 And I think you'll hear at the end, we're going to have some recommendations on how we move forward with some decision points on this.
29:02 Tonight's presentation is simply a staff presentation. So there are no actions that can be taken by council this evening, aside from we're going to probably make a request for future meeting policy discussion.
29:14 And hopefully council supports that with their opportunity there. So one of the biggest challenges that we've had with Flock is with regard to our access to our data, right?
29:28 When we signed up for the contract with them, we were very specific to not grant access to any other agencies. Our contract was specifically written in such a way with clarification points and so forth that Andy had provided.
29:46 I think that would just assure that, that we had no intention of sharing. Um, we have received several requests from outside agencies to share our camera system and availability. Um, and we have not granted any of that.
30:00 those. So those requests that either unresponded to or in some cases I think they've been they've been rejected. So but irregardless the town it's not provided access to our systems. The and there's there's some specific language within the contract and I'm just going to talk about one of them one of the areas you know it basically is clarification said for the importance of doubt customer does not opt into statewide or nationwide network
30:29 network and flock shall not share customer data with any law enforcement agency or government agency other than the customer. That's very specific languages in our customer data. When we go to network lookup that second bullet point item both statewide and nationwide in that space we have a few different opportunities here to talk about it but I think really understanding the root cause of what allowed for lookups
30:59 to occur. We'll probably never know. And I'm going to go through this in a little bit of detail so people can understand and follow along what the nationwide and nationwide flock networks mean. Those networks are a toggle switch within your admin site of the system. You can click I want to search statewide or I want to search nationwide. Subsequently from our original installation to I think sometimes
31:29 in 2025. Flock removed removed the nationwide search because that one was not legal in California all the way back to 2016 it turns out. So the statewide lookup is one in which you if you would like to look up a particular license plate you would have to enter the entire license plate number. And you're looking up statewide will this where has this license plate been seen.
31:57 In order for another agency to see us or for us to see out into the other agencies that toggle switch has to be on. So we can't search nationwide unless we're in the network. But when we have that toggle switch turned on it allows for people to see. We are included in the network. So when someone says has this been seen in the state of California it would search our databases as well.
32:19 Those terms are called lookups. And the vast majority of what you know has been reported through data records requests and analysis have been lookup related. Right. They say they are lookups.
32:33 There are a number of them that say there are searches. And I will tell you Chief and I had three separate meetings with Flock last week to talk a little bit about the customer lookup function and why several of them are labeled as searches.
32:50 So those meetings went as such. We had a meeting on Monday. They had a person with.
33:00 Most knowledgeable there to answer our questions, and they did a good job of taking care of us. However, there were several questions they could not address.
33:07 One of them is the labeling of searches and the labeling of searches that were indicated to be by other agencies.
33:14 They then, we asked for more detail on that. Please tell us what the specifics are for that.
33:19 They took a day, analyzed the data, came back, we met on Thursday.
33:23 The response was, well, we found that we had a bug, and our data, we were mislabeling the lookups as searches.
33:32 So, you know, we kind of had a little bit of a concern with that because it basically says, trust me.
33:38 You know, we made a mistake, we fixed it.
33:41 We're wrong about the time you guys noticed it, we fixed that.
33:44 Both Chief and I kind of said, well, guys, that doesn't really work well for us because we have to face a community and say,
33:50 trust us, that these searches didn't occur, they were lookups.
33:55 We asked for a following meeting with an executive, which we got one the next day.
33:59 That wouldn't prove not to be as fruitful either because they didn't really have an explanation outside of perhaps the information we were provided the day before was correct.
34:11 But again, I'm going to reiterate a point.
34:13 It goes back to trust us.
34:15 The folks have a question, you know, our ability to manage the system.
34:22 One of those, one of the vulnerabilities with Flock is, you know, it's a complicated technological solution that captures images, goes through their network systems.
34:34 We don't have hands-on review.
34:36 It's not within our possession to control how it functions.
34:41 We don't see the data.
34:43 It occurs in their system.
34:45 So we're pretty vulnerable to the trusting what Flock has to say with regard to what's happening with the data, the security of it, and the integrity of it.
34:57 And you'll hear me say a couple of times in here that there are concerns about that, and there's a lack of trust in this space between both Chief and I and Flock with that, with regard to that.
35:10 The third bullet point, notification of violation.
35:15 So we were notified on, I think it was December 11th of 2025, there were a series of webinars that Flock was conducting with agencies across at least the state of California, if not broader.
35:29 We were in a group which included the state of California.
35:32 And in that particular meeting, they had a, it was a very short meeting.
35:40 I think it was roughly 15 to 20 minutes.
35:44 They indicated in that meeting that inadvertently data had been, these data switches, these network switches had been turned on.
35:54 And in some instances nationwide, there were available views.
36:00 Views of the data.
36:01 And again, going back to the lookup in those, it's only full license plate number.
36:05 You don't look up.
36:06 Other lookups, the searches, I'm sorry, that Chief and his team can do involve vehicle make, model, and color, either visible attributes on the rear of the car or anything like that, but primarily impartial license plates.
36:20 In the lookup phase, you cannot look up anything except for full license plate numbers.
36:25 Again, this is all according to FLOC.
36:27 The, basically, when they told us that, and knowing that our data, our expectation was that our data was not shared outwardly, I made the decision at the conclusion of that meeting that we were shutting the system off.
36:45 And we did that, that very day.
36:47 I sent a note to council indicating what had occurred, and what I, or weekly town manager updates that said, you know, essentially, their, their systems are not acting in a way that we're, that we're expecting them to be.
37:02 Um, and we are, we are shutting it off, uh, until further notice.
37:07 So, that, that happened, um, again, I think it was the 12th of, uh, of December, 2025.
37:14 What's it?
37:15 The 11th.
37:15 Okay.
37:16 Okay.
37:17 Um, throughout that period of time afterwards, um, and again, they promised on that meeting, hey, we were, we were, we were making changes, we're making improvements.
37:26 We, you know, we thought that this was in best interest of everyone to have access to the data and so forth.
37:32 Then, um, they indicate that they're, they're making improvements throughout the spring, right?
37:38 So, chief was getting updates constantly.
37:40 Hey, we've made modifications.
37:41 We've made changes.
37:42 Uh, things are there.
37:44 We didn't turn it on.
37:45 We didn't respond.
37:46 Um, we did, however, uh, on the 19th or I think it was prior to that of, of May, 2026.
37:56 Um, had a conversation, um, or, or a series of issues that we needed, um, tracking set up for, and again, looking at the, um, successes of their, allegedly of their work to improve the system and how it functions and the security.
38:14 Um, we had a, a series of assurances on the data retention, the deletion, they provided us with documents to that fact as well.
38:24 Um, and so on the 13th, I think we received, I received a request from chiefs to turn this, to the system back on.
38:30 Um, and I cared, I shared that with the council that, hey, I was, I was based upon the issues we were having and at the time staffing levels and so forth, thinking about re-engaging with this system.
38:41 Um, we did have a couple of feed and dialogue back and forth with council member questions, but then on, um, uh, the, the 19th, so a full five days later, turn the system back on.
38:52 Um, and, uh, basically our flock system was turned back on this week to assist this PD in the execution of their duties, um,
39:00 The system has been instrumental in a lot of good police work and support for that effort.
39:11 I think that it's what we're going to weigh, I think, in the upcoming meetings, possibly the value versus the risk that we have at stake here, but low confidence in data integrity and security.
39:24 The system reinstatement and why I went through that, partnerships with Mammoth School District and MCOE, Mammoth Hospital, I think Chief maybe addressed a request with those agencies, as well as Cerro Coso, who eventually removed themselves from the discussion, about adding the Raven system, which is the gunshot detection system.
39:53 How that functions is it has a series of microphones that are in general areas and I believe they have a minimum radius distance of a quarter of a mile in order to adequately triangulate the location of the shots fired.
40:08 Those microphones are not on all the time, they are triggered by a particular event, either gunshot, or a firework, or the sound of a car's tires squealing through a car accident or sideshows.
40:25 And once it's triggered, it comes on and activates for about a five-second clip, records that clip, sends that clip to the people who are assigned access to the system, which is all law enforcement agency members at this point, I mean, within the town of Mammoth Lake PD.
40:42 And how that works, we had an example of, I think it was maybe two weeks ago, there was one recorded as a sideshow over here by a microphone near Vaughn's and it was someone doing donuts out there between Vaughn's and Carl's Jr.
41:00 And in that time period, there were like four or five clips, I think that were shared because of the short duration of it and the duration in which that person was out there spinning, spinning around.
41:11 So the Raven system is a part of FLOC, but it's not required, I'm sorry, FLOC's cameras are not required to function that.
41:24 The school districts, as you know, shooting, school shootings are unfortunately a part of our society inexplicably and have been for some time.
41:35 I think this is a good tool.
41:37 It essentially triangulates the location of the shot and sends that over and we calculated was about five seconds from the recording of the sound until the time it was notifying the location of that.
41:48 The systems that include the Raven are all belong to the school district in joint with the hospital.
42:00 I think it's providing some funding associated with that, but MCOE and Mammoth Unified School District are, with Mammoth Unified School District is the main agency associated with that account.
42:13 That's a partnership, right, that we kind of push forward. They're doing it separately. Our team has, Chief's team has access to the alerts that come from that system, again, so they can respond to that.
42:26 And, you know, it's been functioned and successful in that space.
42:32 The camera count, that's been brought into question. Our original contract with FLOC had a count of eight cameras.
42:43 And when we were installing those, it was right about the same time we were working on emergency evacuation and other needs we had within the community and understanding, you know, volume of traffic.
42:59 And so, at the same time we installed it, there was a gap in Lakes Basin.
43:05 So, we had the eight cameras distributed in appropriate areas around town, but in that same space, we realized that having a good count of vehicles, which there's some, there's a functionality with regard to these cameras that were added that have the ability to measure number of cars traveling through an area.
43:24 So, you could get a sense of how many cars are in the Lakes Basin, if we had those cameras installed.
43:30 So, I made the decision, which is within the authority of town manager, a certain level of authority is obviously given to me to execute on.
43:38 I made the decision to add two cameras, so we have 10 cameras that are a part of our base, our base system that has a cost, the $25,000 was the original cost of the eight cameras and an additional seven for the two that were added.
43:53 With regard to the five temporary cameras that we added, so, ironically, last year and what came to light with regard to us identifying, hey, this statewide item was turned on, was when one of our sergeants was doing investigation on a series of arsons that we had up near Main Lodge, and that was August of 2025.
44:19 He was utilizing the system to search, locating hits in various parts of the state and kind of scratching his head as to how that's happening, and sort of came to the conclusion that with that system set, with that turned on, you would not be able to, you would be able to see statewide and sort of deduce that maybe they can see us too.
44:44 And so that was the first indication that this nationwide sharing that I talked about in bullet point two, you know, was statewide, yeah, thank you, not nationwide.
44:53 When we talked to Flock about this, and again, this is a little bit indicative into their development.
45:00 Developing it as they go mentality. The data logging for that switch, that statewide switch, was not tracked until February of 2025. Now our systems were approved in July of 2024. The first cameras arrived in September of 2024 and were installed. We had searches that, again, lookups that were occurring in July and August of 2024 before we had the system.
45:30 before we had cameras. We're unsure whether they came turned on. We have no record of that. We have no ability to confirm that. We have asked FLOC to provide us with a recording of the Zoom meeting that implemented the system with our police officers and we have not received that.
45:51 Our requests of their data or actions have gone unaddressed a couple of different times. I talked about that update that we received in December of 2025 where it indicated that there was a gap in the nationwide and statewide network searching.
46:13 We asked for an audit at that particular time with a number of other agencies who were on the call asking for the same thing. We never received that. It wasn't until we received public records requests which we requested of FLOC and they serviced those requests where the volume of access was there.
46:31 I made mention of a sergeant who was doing the searches for the arson time period. So when he shut that off and I think he alerted the chief that, hey, this is concerning that this may have been out there.
46:45 We turned it back on for 10 minutes in September of 2025 because we were looking for a missing person statewide. He basically turned it on, ran the search, performed a couple of other functions and shut it off. In that period of time there were 120 searches that hit our system in those 10 minutes.
47:06 What's that? Yeah, lookups. I'm sorry. I'm using searches. Apparently I'm as bad as FLOC. I'm using searches interchangeably with lookups.
47:15 So that tells you how prolific the usage is of that particular tool. And again, it's not I want to go search the town of Mammoth Lakes. I want to find this license plate number in the state of California that triggers these lookup events on our systems.
47:33 So I think I have addressed, um, everything here. I want to, I want to basically allow, um, um, Sergeant Hanson to go through the rest of the update and then we'll kind of take it back and talk a little bit about, you know, just, I'm going to tie it together a little bit and have a request of counsel going forward.
47:52 Thanks, Rob. Uh, Sergeant Daniel Hanson with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. The next few slides I'm going to go over just talks about the, uh, the camera.
48:00 So first, the ALPR cameras, it's a fixed point ALPR camera. It's fixed on an existing infrastructure like a light pole or an intersection. They're powered by a solar panel. They're activated by motion only by a vehicle. So they're not a surveillance camera like a live feed.
48:28 When the camera detects a vehicle, it captures a license plate of that vehicle. It takes that license plate and it runs it through a basically a national hot list if it's stolen or wanted. And once that, if it does get a hit, then that alert gets sent to our officers that there's a stolen vehicle or a wanted vehicle.
48:49 Aside from that, it also gives us the ability to search our database for that license plate. So if we're working in investigation, we have a license plate, somebody coming into town.
49:00 We have the ability to go into our system, run that plate, see where it's at or if it's come into Mammoth or it's left town.
49:06 It's not used for immigration enforcement. There's no facial recognition. It only takes a picture of the rear of the vehicle.
49:12 And those images that are captured are only retained for 30 days in the system and then they're automatically deleted.
49:18 So the Raven audio detection devices that Rob alluded to, there's 25 in town along with three computer boxes.
49:27 The device, if it recognizes a gunshot or a tire screeching from like a sideshow or, again, as Rob alluded to, a vehicle collision,
49:37 it takes a three to five second snippet and then it sends an alert to, again, the officers.
49:42 The device processor automatically and permanently destroys the everyday sounds of like talking or ambient noise.
49:51 There's no active listening.
49:53 And basically the computer boxes that I alluded to earlier,
49:56 those computer boxes are used to triangulate exactly where that gunshot or, again, like if there's a vehicle collision,
50:06 it's able to use those computers to triangulate the location of where it occurred in town.
50:15 So here, this is a, basically shows the searches from MLPD officers in the last year.
50:23 So from September 2025 to August of 2026.
50:26 So we've, our officers at MLPD have searched 142 vehicles.
50:32 And you'll notice in September that there's obviously a pretty big jump in numbers.
50:35 That was obviously during the arson investigation, we were running plates quite a bit.
50:41 In January of 26, you'll see that the numbers are pretty low.
50:45 That's when obviously the system was shut down.
50:47 You'll see a few searches, February and March.
50:53 The reason why there's still some searches on there is obviously the school district cameras were still active.
50:57 So we were able to search those cameras.
51:00 For obviously that short time. And then in July and August, obviously the numbers were pretty high there. During that time frame, we were working two separate stabbings in Mammoth. We were trying to identify a suspect and locate them. So obviously the numbers are pretty high there as well. Good.
51:15 So just to add a little bit onto the statistics here. So if you're looking at September 2025 through August of 2026, Rob may mention that a previous sergeant that was our administrative sergeant for FLOC had noticed that that nation, or I'm sorry, statewide, I'm doing the same thing, the statewide lookup was on when he was searching for a possible suspect vehicle for the arsons.
51:42 He shut that down in August. And from August, outside of the 10 minutes that it was on in September, the only searches or lookups that were conducted for the last 14 months have been MLPD outside of that 10 minutes that our previous sergeant had turned it on for.
52:03 So, and then Daniel also made mention to January, February, March, April. Those are school district cameras that we still had access to, and we're still getting active alerts from the hot list.
52:16 And we were able to use those cameras. They have three of them utilize those cameras in attempt to locate suspects.
52:23 So just a few success stories that MLPDs had for the last few months. May of 2026, stolen vehicles recovered after the plate was entered into the FLOC database.
52:39 July of 2026, a suspect brandished a firearm up at Horseshoe Lake and was apprehended using FLOC.
52:45 August of 2026, two additional stolen vehicles were recovered with the use of our ALPR system.
52:51 In September of 2026, a silver alert was issued, and MLPD received an alert for that plate, and MLPD was able to make contact with that individual and reunite them with their family.
53:06 October of 2026, we used FLOC to locate and arrest a suspect involved in a violent stabbing in town.
53:13 And obviously, ALPR is also useful that we obviously can be able to exonerate innocent people as well.
53:24 The FLOC system allows us to add a transparency portal, which is on the Mammoth Lakes Police Department website.
53:32 And this allows the public to go in and actually be able to pull an audit log for the last 30 days so the public can actually see what searches we've been doing in the last 30 days.
53:43 The audit log doesn't show a license plate, but it obviously shows a reason for the search.
53:48 Every search that we do on our system is required to have a case number or an incident number and a reason as to why we're conducting a search on that plate.
54:00 One of the features that Flock had enabled in the last few months is an audit assistance tool, which allows our supervisors to go in and if there's any unusual search patterns within the database, it flags that search and we can go in and do an audit on that search to make sure that it was a legit search.
54:16 We also run a monthly report in Flock and I've been doing it for the last few months where I actually am able to go in and pull an audit log for the entire month, which shows every single search that's been on our system by our officers.
54:31 I go through that log and I match it up with every single case or incident to make sure that it's valid so we're making sure that we're auditing our system.
54:38 The website for the transparency portal is on the bottom here.
54:44 It's on the police department website so maybe you can click it and check it out.
54:49 We'll say you can download, you can download, you can not only see it, but you can download a CSV file.
54:57 That's correct.
54:57 That shows that and it's possible if we retain the system that we may end up logging those each month's files out there for people to be able to see beyond just 30 days.
55:08 Yes.
55:09 I wanted to address another, are you done?
55:12 I'm sorry.
55:13 Do you done with yours?
55:14 Yeah, you're good.
55:14 Perfect.
55:15 Thank you.
55:16 Personnel access was another question that was raised.
55:19 There were a total of 25 logins created for the system, all of which are law enforcement personnel.
55:25 Currently, there are 12 sworn officers with MLPD that have access to the system.
55:31 There are 11 inactive accounts of former sworn officers and these employees are no longer with MLPD.
55:38 There's one administrative staff, which is the executive assistant to the chief of police, and Mono County Dispatch also receives alerts so there's a login for Mono County Dispatch.
55:48 That's the only outside agency, but the town does not have its own dispatch.
55:53 We rely on Mono County Dispatch, so if they're alerted to an event, they are dispatching our team to respond to that.
55:59 So real quick, just to clarify, so Mono County Dispatch has access to alerts, not search options or anything like that.
56:07 So when an alert comes through, how it accesses or how it allows the officers to know it, it tells the officers when the alert comes through, it does the same thing with dispatch.
56:16 Dispatch can then go into the collect system, run the plate, say it's a stolen vehicle, run the plate, confirm that that vehicle is a stolen vehicle, advise the officers of that confirmation of a stolen vehicle.
56:27 Or the officers can contact dispatch or run it themselves, but dispatch should absolutely be aware of the alerts that are coming through and knowing what the officers are doing.
56:36 But again, they only have access to alerts, not search capabilities.
56:40 Thanks for that clarification. So I mentioned that I would bring me back to, you know, just kind of a wrap-up of our experience here through this analysis and data gathering and review of conversations with FLOC itself.
56:56 Essentially, both Chief and I have lost trust in the data.
57:00 integrity and security that FLOC is currently providing. Unfortunately, we are dependent 100%
57:08 on what they tell us as to the value of their security and we really have no way of verifying
57:15 the statements that they're making on their own. There's been shifting stories, explanations,
57:22 the trust element with the conversation has dwindled pretty far. And just basically the
57:32 demonstrated failures of the past that we responded to appropriately just don't give us confidence
57:39 in this particular area. So what I'm recommending that we bring back a policy agenda item at the next
57:47 Council meeting 11-4 to discuss two things, the merits and the vulnerabilities that we just described.
57:55 And whether one outweighs the other, this system has proven incredibly valuable. I would say that
58:02 this might be a FLOC issue and not necessarily an ALPR and active shooter microphone system problem.
58:10 I think that our community needs this level of protection. I think it needs this level of support
58:19 for our officers. It just might not be FLOC because they've demonstrated, I'm not going to say as far
58:28 as incompetence, but something that I can't accept. So that's probably going to be the recommendation
58:34 and bring it back for further discussion. And I do want to weigh the two together because I think that's
58:39 a valuable comparison. The level of vulnerability measured against the value and that puts it in
58:48 the hands of town council to ask the questions community to weigh in on those as well and the decision
58:56 to be made. Anything to add? I don't have anything to add, no. Thanks. Any questions? I had one quick
59:04 question. I feel like I just wanted to clarify. So a few times you said the data was accessed statewide
59:12 and I feel like one or two times maybe it said nationwide. So I just wanted to clarify who had access to the data.
59:18 So I can clarify that for you. So July of 2024 we had federal agencies access the system. We didn't
59:31 even have cameras up so there's no data in the system. So 2024 I think it was ATF out of Nashville
59:38 had a few hits on our system without cameras being in place yet. That was the only one that I believe
59:48 I saw as far as federal agencies. Everything else there could have been a few outside eight out of state agencies.
59:55 I don't recall but I know there was a ton of
59:59 of
1:00:00 of agencies within the state of California. I don't even want to say that they're actually collecting data from us. They are running a license plate through the system, and if that license plate never hit Mammoth, they wouldn't have gotten any result from our system. They would have gotten it from wherever that vehicle hit, not necessarily the Mammoth cameras themselves. Does that answer the question?
1:00:24 Thank you.
1:00:27 I'd like to add just a little bit to that, and I'm going to read the TM update that I sent on December 12th. That would have been that Friday. I send these every... Town manager update is a notice that I send to council every week, mostly, that talks about things that went on for the week and just keep them alerted to it.
1:00:50 The reason I want to read this is because it has... I wrote it at the time that this occurred, so this would have had the specific experience that we had just simply the day before.
1:01:01 We attended a Zoom webinar with Flock on Friday morning. The purpose of the call was to talk about data security and protection of privacy they experienced this last year.
1:01:08 The call included several California agencies. During the call, Flock indicated there were two significant events that left most of their systems vulnerable to national searches, including federal agencies.
1:01:20 This vulnerability occurred between February and May of 2025. The main element of the problem was a security switch enabling nationwide search capabilities being inadvertently turned on for most of their clients.
1:01:30 This was done without knowledge or consent of those agencies. They did understand the gravity of the situation. However, they did not leave us feeling as though they, that we could trust their immediate actions to improve the system's resiliency or develop stronger protocols.
1:01:43 As a result, we shut down Flock license plate reader systems yesterday morning. The significant breach of trust compiled with what I perceive to be an inadequate response and notification of the main reasons for this action.
1:01:55 I do believe they will face legal challenges from larger entities that may result in better response and security efforts if they survive at all. We will pause our system for 90 days and reevaluate the situation and engage town council before anything is reactivated. There's no indication that our system was reviewed by any other agency. Um, and it would have only returned a search result and not provided blanket access to our cameras.
1:02:19 Flock indicated that they have an audit program that could tell if anything was provided and we asked for that audit to be completed on our behalf.
1:02:26 The agent Raven gunshot detection system remains active in town. The system just detects sounds and triangulates the position source of those sounds. The system is a great tool for our agency and it's been used day almost daily in cases from domestic violence to hit and run.
1:02:40 The absence of the tool will result in the reduction of our capabilities until it can be reintroduced. Um, that, that's what I knew.
1:02:48 That's what I knew at that point after that. So, you know, beyond, beyond the time when chief, we have truly identified searches, um, even before the system was
1:03:00 turned on. That was what we were told in that particular call. Thank you. Yep. Question? Madam Mayor, just real quick, do you anticipate taking any public comment on this? I was planning on taking public comment. I mean, absolutely. Yeah, I was planning on taking public comment. I mean, we're not going to deliberate. So I figured if you had questions or comments, now's the time for them. I got a question, but Bill's got a question down there. John, you were already talking. No, it was a point of order. I was asking of the mayor. So that's all. That's it. So one
1:03:30 I wanted to go ahead. I wanted to point out that because Rob just made it a little more clear. These 800 and whatever searches, those are people that were putting it into a state database, not specifically searching Mammoth. And they would have only gotten something back from us if the full license plate they entered showed on our system. They can't go into the system and live look at the cameras. They can't follow someone around Mammoth. They have to put in a specific license
1:04:00 license plate. Then they're doing a statewide search. So it's not just hitting Mammoth. It's hitting every place in the state that has flock cameras. That's correct. So lookups, the only way you can look a vehicle up is by putting a full license plate in there. If you've opted into statewide lookup, your system is vulnerable or your system allows that agency to run that license plate to see if that specific license plate hit one of our cameras.
1:04:30 And since that button was on and we were apparently opted into that, they were able to look at our system to see if that vehicle would come through. It is not a live system. You can't go into the system and monitor. And now Flock has cameras that can do that, but not the ALPRs. These are different cameras that we do not have. So you can't go into a camera and start watching that camera from an outside agency or even from
1:05:00 even with us, we can't go in and look at that camera. So that is correct. Only it will say yes or no that that vehicle is here and show the image if the vehicle actually was in Mammoth. It would show the image of the vehicle.
1:05:12 So one step beyond that, because my opinion or my, what I thought we had signed up for originally, and I believe it is, was those outside agencies could contact you and then you could do the search for them, not automatically on a statewide search.
1:05:30 And that if they have fixed their issues, we are back to that method. Is that correct?
1:05:36 That was the, that was the intended purpose. Yes. So sharing. So searches, there's a couple types of searches. You have direct sharing, which is, uh, as Rob had mentioned, we get a request onto our system from Bishop police department or anywhere in the state of California.
1:05:52 California and we get an email says, congratulations. Your network is growing. So-and-so wants to share with you or wants access, wants access, wants access,
1:06:00 I want you to share with them. We would have to hit approve on that in order for them to actually run searches, which is a partial license plate, vehicle make, model, color, any kind of specific identifiers on the vehicle. Those are searches. Lookups, full license plate, and that's it.
1:06:17 So in order to search with an outside agency, one, you can do a direct sharing with them by approving their request, which we have not done. Or two, if that statewide lookup is on, all they can do is look up the vehicle. So they cannot search.
1:06:33 So what Flock told us is, for example, let's say one month we had 90,000 lookups, and 80,000 of them were lookups, and 10,000 of them were searches, but only 80 of them were Mammoth PD, or 100 of them, let's say. So the 9,900 searches that we are showing, Flock says, well, they were mislabeled.
1:06:56 They were mislabeled as searches, not lookups. And that goes back to what Rob's saying. Trust us. They weren't actually searching it. They were just looking it up, and we mislabeled it.
1:07:05 I want to add to what Chief just responded there, because we have reached out to other agencies and requested access to their systems. And so we have maybe 20, roughly. I mean, I didn't count them, but roughly 20 that Chief indicated that we have made that request of them.
1:07:24 Can we, you know, basically share your camera system data and searchability? And we've been granted that. So we have that access to them, but it's not reciprocal.
1:07:35 It's not automatic. It's just we can look at theirs. They can't look at ours.
1:07:41 More questions?
1:07:43 Questions?
1:07:44 I've got a couple questions.
1:07:46 And one was kind of answered, because one of my first ones was going to be is, how safe do you feel the data is?
1:07:51 And as you've already said, we need to look at that whole situation. What is actually stored?
1:07:58 There have been a lot of questions to me about, okay, bicycles, people, other things are stored in FLOC versus just vehicles. Is that true? Or is, how does that work so I can get some clarification?
1:08:10 Mr. So the only information that we have of what is stored is what FLOC tells us.
1:08:16 So my understanding of what is stored, what is stored in the system and deleted after 30 days is, is photos of vehicles.
1:08:27 So, so the back of a vehicle or the front of a vehicle with a license plate, make, model, and color of that.
1:08:34 And that is what is stored. So if we want to look up a vehicle and we get a hit on a vehicle, it's going to send back pictures of this, the license plate and the make and model of the vehicle and what camera captured that vehicle driving past.
1:08:48 That is my understanding of all that is captured by, by the, by the FLOC ALPRs is just the vehicle and the vehicle license plate.
1:08:56 And usually just the back of the vehicle, there are times that we would get.
1:09:00 A picture from distance with a front license plate coming the other direction and it picked it up on the other side of the street.
1:09:09 But all of those, I've never seen a human, I've never seen a person in any of the photos, and I've never seen a driver in any of the photos.
1:09:20 You can't tell who's actually driving the car. It's just recognizing the license plate make, model, color of the vehicle.
1:09:27 So let me ask you a little bit different question. When you do a lookup, you're actually putting in a license plate for lookup.
1:09:32 You can't put in, I want to see a bicycle or a human or something else.
1:09:37 So lookup or searches, no, you cannot do that.
1:09:39 It's just a license plate.
1:09:40 It's a license plate. But if you conduct a search, so if my organization conducts a search, they can put in a green Honda Civic and it will show all of the green Honda Civics that have passed by our cameras.
1:09:53 And then we can go from there, right? If we're looking for a suspect that's driving a green Honda Civic, it will pull up all green Honda Civics.
1:10:02 But that's only the search capability that nobody should have that ability within our system.
1:10:10 The only ability that they had unbeknownst to us was the statewide lookup, which would be the full license plate specific vehicle.
1:10:19 And then the second question is, just like you label a success for the May 26th of a stolen vehicle, I'm a little confused because if a vehicle is stolen, is there a lag time between when it's stolen and maybe get it put into the lookup function?
1:10:33 Because we search for it and it would seem like you'd have an alert.
1:10:38 So there's a couple ways to get the information into the system so the Flock cameras alert to them, right?
1:10:46 So the first way is a hot list.
1:10:49 A hot list would be agency specific.
1:10:51 So if we're looking for a domestic violence suspect or a stabbing suspect, I'm going to use the stabbing suspect.
1:11:01 We put his or her information in the system with a full license plate because we had the suspect's license plate.
1:11:12 And we wanted to know if the suspect was still in town.
1:11:14 And if it passed by that ALPR, we would know where they're at and hopefully find them.
1:11:20 Obviously, there's a lag time between when a vehicle passes through and when we get an alert on the ALPRs anywhere from 7 to 10 seconds lag time.
1:11:29 And depending on where the officer is, if the officer is across town, it's going to take them a couple minutes to get over there.
1:11:34 The vehicle is going to be gone unless it hit another camera and updated a location of where that vehicle is.
1:11:41 So that's the hot list.
1:11:42 So you can do an agency specific hot list.
1:11:46 So if that vehicle went out of town and say, Bishop, I know Bishop doesn't have ALPRs, but just for argument's sake, they have ALPRs.
1:11:54 That vehicle, Flock ALPRs, that vehicle goes down there and hits, Bishop's not going to know that vehicle is.
1:12:00 Wanted in Mammoth because we specifically made it agency-specific on a hot list. If you have a stolen vehicle, an amber alert, a silver alert, or anything, any of those other types of crimes or incidents, those get put into CLTS. And what CLTS is, is the acronym, don't ask me, I knew it at one point. Do you know it? Okay. CLTS is a law enforcement system where you can put missing persons in. So if we get a missing person,
1:12:30 report, we'll, we'll do that. We'll send it to dispatch. Dispatch will put that missing person into CLTS and any vehicle associated with that missing person. So if, if
1:12:42 flock talks to CLTS, so that, and the same with stolen vehicles, if somebody reports a stolen vehicle, we put that stolen vehicle into CLTS, now it's in the stolen vehicle system, missing person system. Um, and, and if those license plates that are associated with the missing person or the stolen
1:12:59 vehicle, hit flock, hit flock, flock alerts. So that is not agency-specific and nobody, no specific agency has to, has to enter that data. It just has to be within the CLTS system. So there's two ways to get alerts. Hot list, which is agency-specific and CLTS, which is, which is statewide, nationwide.
1:13:17 That's like to be on the lookout. Bolo.
1:13:19 That's a Bolo. That's totally different. Yeah.
1:13:22 Okay. So, so just, so just, I got most of that. I'm going to say, honestly, don't quite a hundred percent, but for vehicle stolen Bishop comes up the hill, we get notified of that.
1:13:32 We would get notified of that.
1:13:34 Why isn't that already, wouldn't that trigger when they drove by a flock camera that the vehicle was stolen and notify you?
1:13:39 Yes.
1:13:40 But we did lookups for it. I just was trying to understand the difference.
1:13:43 No. So we still get notified. We don't have to do a, we don't have to do a search or a lookup to be notified by flock that a vehicle passed, that a vehicle passed a camera and activated an alert because that alert is in the CLTS system.
1:13:57 Okay.
1:13:57 So it's basically, it works kind of as a force multiplier, right? So if, if, if an officer was, was standing on, on the, on a street corner and with his computer and running every license plate that went by, and this one happened to be a stolen vehicle, he'd be like, oh, that's a stolen vehicle.
1:14:13 Get in the car, go after it, call dispatch, confirm that it's stolen. Well, the camera's doing that for us.
1:14:18 So as the vehicle goes through, it reads the plate, it runs it through the CLTS system, it runs it through the hot list system. CLTS comes back, there's an alert on it, there's a ping on it.
1:14:29 Flock notifies the officer that this is a potential stolen vehicle. And in order for the officer to stop that vehicle, the officer, one, has to get behind the vehicle, two, has to confirm with dispatch that this vehicle is actually still in the stolen vehicle system.
1:14:43 And if it is, at that point, the officer couldn't make the traffic stop.
1:14:48 Can you talk a little bit more about the alerts, right? Because you're talking about the officers notified, but you're saying everybody who's on this, this alert system is notified there was a stolen car that passed that.
1:15:00 that camera so there's there's different types of alerts one is the alerts through through the
1:15:05 flock system that is up on the officers computers within their cars and that's the quickest alert
1:15:10 that they would get so that is your five to second time frame where it passes through the officers
1:15:16 who are logged into logged into flock at the time while they're working they will get the they will
1:15:21 get the alerts if if officers aren't working and not logged in the flock they will not get the
1:15:26 alerts so only the officers that are working unless you're logged in the flock while you're not
1:15:29 working and you still get alerts that's about a five to second five to second delay the other
1:15:36 alerts that the officers get are through text message that's about a I would say about a five
1:15:41 to seven second right around the same time so it pings in the in the car then it would ping on there
1:15:46 on their phone it's alerting them in two spots in case they're in the in the station and they're
1:15:50 not monitoring their computer in the car you know ping on the phone hey a stolen vehicle or potential
1:15:55 stolen vehicle just went through this the other way that we get alerts is through email and that's
1:15:59 about a 10 to 15 second delay it takes a little bit longer for the email to get generated automatically
1:16:05 generated and sent to us so I I usually just get the email updates that there was a sideshow or there
1:16:12 was a gunshot or there was a potential there was a stolen plate that went through here or stolen
1:16:17 vehicle so there's three different ways that officers get the alerts if they're out in their
1:16:20 car and they get the alert that's usually the quickest quickest way to get the alert and respond to is
1:16:25 that what you're looking for that's exactly what I'm looking for thank you and just one other element
1:16:28 that that as we were researching this a little bit further you talk about data retention in the 30 30
1:16:35 day deletion of of general records of the system when a hit comes on whether it's clets or through the
1:16:45 hot list that sends text messages and emails to the 12 officers that are signed up and the other people
1:16:54 that I mentioned read off earlier those those images and that is captured now in a different system right
1:17:02 it's in our email system email system has two-year retention policy so those hits are going to be
1:17:09 there longer than the 30 days just a clarification of that however those those those pictures are
1:17:16 considered evidence and they go into a system system called evidence.com so it gets pulled from
1:17:23 it gets pulled from flock and gets put into into our evidence.com system however it's still on our computers
1:17:31 like the photo of it would still be on our computers through the email even though it's evidence so if there was a
1:17:37 a PRA request for any type of alerts that we received through flock we let Andy maybe talk to this a
1:17:45 little bit but not not able we wouldn't be able to give that to anybody because they are considered
1:17:50 evidence and they did go into our evidence base which is evidence.com okay questions I'm sorry
1:18:00 Other questions?
1:18:00 Yeah.
1:18:01 No, but you answered my hot list question because I was next to just one question on the Raven.
1:18:05 Does that also detect distance?
1:18:07 So, for instance, I even hit shutter just thinking about a potential shot in town, but if there was something that happened, would that not only tell you direction, but it would also tell you approximately how far from the area, basically a pretty accurate location?
1:18:20 Yes.
1:18:20 So, it'll give you a location up to 90 feet.
1:18:22 Okay.
1:18:23 So, and it's used off a triangulation.
1:18:26 So, three, minimum three systems have to pick it up?
1:18:30 Three speakers have to pick it up and it triangulates, which is why we have so many, so many cameras within town.
1:18:36 I'm sorry.
1:18:37 Microphones.
1:18:38 Microphones throughout town.
1:18:41 And let me just elaborate a little bit on the Raven system.
1:18:44 So, there's a few options that you can, that you can opt into if you're looking at Raven.
1:18:48 They have a minimum distance of, I believe, a quarter square mile, half square mile, three quarters, and one square mile.
1:18:56 So, what that means is you are, you are monitoring a quarter square mile and so on and so forth, right?
1:19:03 So, the school district, the school district went with a quarter square mile because what that does is that incorporates high school, middle school, elementary school, office of education, all the district offices, and it also goes out to a preschool.
1:19:18 So, we're a little bit further out than a quarter square mile and we have a little bit, we have a few more speakers than a quarter square mile microphones that a quarter square mile would usually entail.
1:19:32 But that is because we kind of went out a little bit further to a preschool that Mono County Office of Education is responsible for.
1:19:40 So, that's why the community is seeing these speakers not just on the school grounds but seeing them throughout town, too, because they do need to triangulate.
1:19:50 I have a question on that.
1:19:51 Is that on, excuse me, is that on town property that those speakers are, or the microphones are placed?
1:19:57 They're in the town right away, most, most, most times, and there are some private property as well associated with the school district.
1:20:08 So, yeah.
1:20:10 Okay, thank you.
1:20:12 Other questions, John?
1:20:13 Yeah, permits were issued for that.
1:20:14 Yeah, can you share with us what the current status of the FLOC system is right now?
1:20:18 It's turned on, active, and running.
1:20:20 Turned on, active, and running with various switches, disabled.
1:20:24 So, I can talk to that.
1:20:27 You don't have to get into too much detail, which is, that's sufficient.
1:20:31 The current status is everything is turned off.
1:20:34 Nobody is searching.
1:20:35 The searches are turned off.
1:20:37 The cameras are on.
1:20:38 Nobody is searching or looking up any of our data outside of Mammoth Lake's police department.
1:20:43 And that's been like that for 14 months.
1:20:45 And the cameras are on.
1:20:46 And the cameras are on.
1:20:47 We still only have 10 cameras out there.
1:20:49 We had 15 at one point for that trial period that Rob was talking about with the additional five cameras for an arson investigation in the event we, the arsons, continued into this year.
1:21:00 Those have been taken down, and they are, we just received shipping labels today, and they're ready to be shipped back.
1:21:05 Yeah, I'm going to expand on that a little bit, because we're sharing literally everything we know.
1:21:12 The, when we had the arson stuff, and I think it was triggered by, I'm going to say June 25th, like I know exactly the date, because I think that was it.
1:21:23 We had an arson go off by the water district.
1:21:28 It was a fire started in that particular space, and so, great concern, and this fires are not invested, they're on federal lands, they're not investigated specifically by our police force, but we're supporting agencies, so there's a lot of agencies that are involved in this investigation.
1:21:42 What we wanted to do is expand the envelope of ingress and egress to town, right, where do we have gaps in systems and so forth.
1:21:53 So that's where we came up with a solution that added five cameras.
1:21:58 We knew at the time we did not want to add them to our normal process, our annual sort of list of cameras, so we worked out a 90-day trial period.
1:22:11 And that 90-day trial period required us to cancel that contract before we reached 90 days, and we did that, and that was the middle of September, I believe, when that happened.
1:22:22 And then the cameras had been removed, and now the chief just indicated the cameras, we went back.
1:22:28 So it was all a part of a plan to expand the network to track this arson investigation, which is, as you can imagine, an arson in our town that takes hold is going to be absolutely catastrophic.
1:22:41 So it's something that, and these things are incredibly helpful as far as last year up by Main Lodge.
1:22:48 You know, they're picking up, there's just a lot of connecting the dots that go on with vehicles traveling through at the same time that these fires are going off.
1:22:57 And I think we had, how many fires did we have up there?
1:22:59 Were there eight?
1:23:00 Somewhere in that range?
1:23:01 Somewhere around eight to ten.
1:23:02 Eight to ten.
1:23:03 So we had a pretty good sample size of activity in a short amount of time that it proved to be valuable to track the people coming and going from the scene of a crime, if you will, at a time.
1:23:16 And that's mainly the usage.
1:23:17 Yeah, I just want to clarify, we weren't necessarily using them.
1:23:21 They don't track.
1:23:22 They don't track people.
1:23:24 They capture an image.
1:23:27 So if you hit one camera and it captures an image, and then two minutes later you hit the other camera and it captures an image, and we're looking for that vehicle, we're going to know, okay, here's this vehicle must be going this way, because it didn't again hit this camera.
1:23:40 After that, if we don't have any cameras, we have no idea where that vehicle had gone.
1:23:44 Any other questions?
1:23:49 Any other questions?
1:23:50 So if I could, just to clarify, so the system is operational, but it's hermetically sealed at this point.
1:23:55 It's not, it's, we're not, the people aren't coming in looking at stuff.
1:24:00 It's running the way that you guys would like to have it be running.
1:24:03 Yes, that's correct.
1:24:04 That's correct.
1:24:05 The lookups are off.
1:24:07 The systems are off.
1:24:11 Yes.
1:24:12 Okay, good.
1:24:12 Thank you.
1:24:13 But it sounds like Flock is guaranteeing that, which they've guaranteed in the past, and they haven't...
1:24:18 No, no, I get all that.
1:24:19 I get all that.
1:24:19 Okay.
1:24:20 That was my name.
1:24:21 Yes.
1:24:22 Yeah.
1:24:22 Okay.
1:24:23 Okay.
1:24:23 As far as Canada, yes.
1:24:25 Okay.
1:24:26 So no more questions at this time?
1:24:29 Do you have a question?
1:24:30 I guess I don't have a...
1:24:31 Oh, sorry.
1:24:34 So just judging by your body language, it doesn't seem as though you're really thrilled with Flock.
1:24:41 Are there alternatives to Flock?
1:24:45 I know that there's other companies.
1:24:47 I mean, I looked that up.
1:24:48 But is this something that in the future that you're going to be worried about with whomever is going to be providing this?
1:24:55 Because let's face it, we're living in a much different world than we were 10 years ago.
1:24:59 With cell phones, tracking everything.
1:25:02 So I'm just wondering, is there a better solution?
1:25:06 You know, it's undetermined at this time because we haven't done any analysis on that.
1:25:10 I think the biggest area of concern, and I guess I'll watch my posturing a little bit here and make sure I'm set up straight.
1:25:18 That it's Flock's demonstrated responses and what we've seen across time that give me the biggest concern.
1:25:24 I think I've indicated earlier in this discussion that having an ALPR and having a gunshot detection system is incredibly vital.
1:25:35 It's just got to be better than that.
1:25:40 Okay.
1:25:44 Okay.
1:25:45 Do you have any more comments at this time?
1:25:47 Okay.
1:25:48 So now I'd like to open up public comment.
1:25:51 If anyone would like to make a public comment, come up to the podium or raise your hand online.
1:25:57 You have five minutes.
1:25:58 And if someone else has said what you'd like, you can just say, you can get up and say I agree with their thoughts.
1:26:04 All right.
1:26:05 Do you have a timer, Jane?
1:26:06 All right.
1:26:07 Thank you.
1:26:08 Good evening, Council.
1:26:09 My name is Clayton Mundell, and I live in Mammoth Lakes.
1:26:12 I'm the author of TransparentMammoth.com.
1:26:15 For me, this all started in June when a Flock gunshot sensor went up on our street.
1:26:19 It appeared one day, and we got curious.
1:26:21 We started asking questions, which ultimately led to filing records requests with the town and its partner agencies.
1:26:28 A few thousand pages later, I built a website so anyone could read what I found as well.
1:26:32 Frustrated by the process, I've expanded that website to have indexed roughly a quarter million pages of the town's public records,
1:26:37 spanning 15 years, 17 boards and commissions, and 1,400 transcribed meetings,
1:26:42 searchable by keyword, organized by topic, summarized by AI, and linked to original documents.
1:26:47 So now anyone can follow a subject without the friction I experienced.
1:26:50 Tonight, I'm here to talk about the company whose technology we've invited into our community
1:26:54 and whether we're really in control of it.
1:26:57 Our contract, says the town, does not opt in to the state of the city.
1:27:00 It was on the computer nationwide network. Eleven days after it was signed, on the first AR logs cover, agencies from across the country, including federal agents, were searching mammoth's cameras. Over the next 13 months, that happened about 835,000 times. That same contract requires Flock to verify twice a year that our data is actually being deleted and reported to town. This May, our police department wrote to Flock that it had never received one. And Flock's answer was that deletion is part of Amazon's standard AWS storage and isn't something they actually manage at all.
1:27:30 A technology that walks this close to the line of our civil liberties has to clear a very high bar. It needs tight limits, real oversight, and someone in charge who can tell the public exactly what it's doing. I don't think we've cleared that bar here.
1:27:46 Over the past two years, the sharing, this council was told was off, was on from the day Flock delivered the system. You approved eight cameras, more were added, and the contract was renewed without coming back for a vote.
1:27:56 The system was paused, then switched back on in May after an email and five days of waiting. The audit that the town asked Flock for never came, and the town manager himself called it a significant breach of trust.
1:28:06 I don't say any of that to blame anyone. I say it because if the people responsible for this system couldn't see what it was doing, none of us could. That isn't control, and that isn't the respect this community deserves.
1:28:16 Part of the problem is culture. Flock is a venture-backed startup, valued at seven and a half billion dollars. Startups grow fast and ship features. Policing is supposed to run on restraint.
1:28:26 Flock's CEO famously said that the country shouldn't pause progress over privacy concerns, and that what we have to prioritize as a country is compromise.
1:28:36 Compromise by whom? Here, that trade was made in a contract most residents have never read.
1:28:41 And what are we getting for it? The camera itself is commodity electronics running a version of Android that stopped getting security updates in 2018.
1:28:49 We don't own it, we lease it. The real product is our data. Our contract gives Flock a permanent right to use ours to train its machine learning.
1:28:58 Flock's software isn't as good as the sales pitch either.
1:29:01 Roseville's police department checked two years of the felony alerts Flock sent, nearly 1,500 of them.
1:29:06 71% were misreads. Only officers checking every plate by hand kept those from becoming felony stops.
1:29:12 Earlier this month, a federal judge in Oklahoma ruled against a deputy he pulled up a driver's Flock history
1:29:18 and used it as probable cause to search your vehicle. The judge wrote that it becomes constitutionally problematic when police can passively catalog your whereabouts and use it whenever convenient.
1:29:27 Here's what worries me the most. Flock says facial recognition is not included and not planned.
1:29:33 But Flock itself holds a patent from 2022 with its CEO listed as the inventor for software that classifies people by race, gender and clothing and matches faces across cameras.
1:29:43 It sells a feature now called convoy that flags vehicles frequently traveling together and adds them to an investigation as possible accomplices.
1:29:51 Flock calls it a simple software upgrade. In a one road town like ours, almost every one of us drives in a convoy every day.
1:29:58 Then there are the gunshots.
1:30:00 Recently, Flock's CEO said these microphones just detect gunshots. However, Flock's own website lists gunshots, fireworks, crashes, sideshows, and a detection library that is continually expanding by, you guessed it, software updates.
1:30:14 I've heard these recordings myself, a recording from one of our own gunshot sensors, flagged as squealing tires in what Flock calls sideshow detection.
1:30:21 So the microphone is listening all the time, and the software picks the clips that go to Flock, where a person can play them back.
1:30:27 After a sensor on Main Street was torn down in August, Flock handed our police its last recording.
1:30:32 Flock called it benign and described it as environmental noise, but the sensor had kept it anyway.
1:30:37 There are 25 of these sensors in Mammoth, including the one outside my house.
1:30:41 It is my opinion that a facial recognition feature is one software update away.
1:30:45 I think Flock has already built and tested it, and the only thing holding it back is legal risk.
1:30:50 Either way, what these devices can do isn't decided in this room, it is decided in a boardroom.
1:30:55 So I ask, my ask is this, remove Flock from Mammoth Lakes.
1:30:58 Not a review, not a policy update.
1:31:00 Give the contract notice, take the cameras down.
1:31:02 Ask the school district to do the same.
1:31:04 This company has shown us who it is, and we don't have to keep paying them to find out what features they'll add next.
1:31:10 Thank you.
1:31:12 Thank you.
1:31:13 Alright, good evening.
1:31:23 My name is Alex Mundell, and I also live at Mammoth.
1:31:26 I've become increasingly uncomfortable with Flock being in our community, and I want to explain why.
1:31:31 The funny thing is, I really didn't think much about Flock until a Raven acoustic sensor was installed on my street.
1:31:37 My kids play on that street, my house is right there, and I can see it from my bedroom window.
1:31:42 Suddenly, I found myself wondering, what exactly is this thing?
1:31:46 What does it here?
1:31:47 Why is it here?
1:31:48 And who decided it should go here?
1:31:50 So I started researching, and the more I learned, the more questions I had.
1:31:54 My opposition to Flock really comes down to three things.
1:31:57 Liberty and privacy, mission creep, and trust.
1:32:00 First, privacy.
1:32:02 I understand why law enforcement likes this technology.
1:32:05 It can help find missing children and help solve crimes.
1:32:08 Those are incredibly difficult things to argue against.
1:32:11 Nobody wants to stand up here and say we shouldn't find missing kids.
1:32:15 But usefulness alone doesn't settle whether this level of surveillance is justified.
1:32:20 There are a lot of things government could do that would make law enforcement more efficient if we were willing to give up privacy.
1:32:26 And personally, I'm not okay with that.
1:32:29 I also believe ordinary people should have to surrender more and more of their privacy simply because doing so makes policing easier.
1:32:35 The burden should be on government to justify surveillance, not on residents to explain why they are uncomfortable with it.
1:32:41 My second concern is mission creep.
1:32:43 I used to think of this as a slippery slope argument, but mission creep is really what concerns me.
1:32:49 A technology getting introduced for an extremely sympathetic reason, finding missing children catch dangerous criminals and solve serious crimes.
1:32:58 But once the cameras and or microphones are
1:33:00 are installed, the databases and accounts exist, and the infrastructure has already been paid for, it becomes way too easy to find new uses for it. As time goes on, software gets updated, new features get introduced, policies evolve, leadership rotates, laws change, and every individual expansion can sound perfectly reasonable when you look at it by itself. That is what worries me. Not only am I interested in how Flock is being used today, but I'm equally interested in what we are
1:33:29 normalizing, and what capability we are creating for whoever controls the system five or ten years from now. Once the infrastructure exists, expanding what it can do is a much smaller decision than the original decision to build it in the first place. And that brings me to trust. I want to separate Flock the company from everyone else here because my concerns about Flock are different. Flock is a private company whose business depends on selling and expanding its technology. Its incentives are not the same as the interests of this community.
1:33:59 The more I have learned about this company, how it describes its technology, how it handles transparency, and even how it has communicated with Mammoth, the less I trust it. Based on what I have read in our own public records, I don't think Flock has earned that trust.
1:34:14 Then there is all the trust the system itself requires. We have to trust the town, the police department, the partner agencies, every person who has access, and the policies governing all of them. We have to trust that we are being given a complete picture of what the technology can do, how it is being used, who can access it, and how those capabilities change over time.
1:34:33 That is a lot of trust to ask from the public, especially when most of what the system does is invisible unless someone goes looking for the records.
1:34:42 My husband and I started requesting public records because we simply wanted to understand what was happening. Our intention was never to get anybody and we weren't looking for a scandal.
1:34:51 We started with a very basic question about a device that appeared outside our home and followed the records where they led. Some of what we found answered questions. Some of it showed that practices have changed and improved over time, which I think is important to acknowledge.
1:35:04 But some of it created even more questions and frankly, the process has not increased my trust in the system. For me, the bottom line is pretty simple. I don't think usefulness alone justifies building surveillance infrastructure throughout a small community and asking everyone who lives here to accept it.
1:35:18 I would rather accept some inefficiency in policing than normalizing this level of surveillance in Mammoth. And that is why I would ultimately like to see Flock removed from our community. Thank you.
1:35:27 Thank you.
1:35:52 Hello again, town council members, town staff and all Mammoth Lakes agencies and departments. My name is Misha Little Bear.
1:36:00 Barbara Bateman, a 13-year resident of Mammoth Lakes, outdoor educator, EMT, and a member of the local creative arts community.
1:36:09 I'm hoping to offer my help and encouragement to the town of Mammoth Lakes in prioritizing safety and our community's rights.
1:36:18 I would like to express my concerns about our area's use of Phlox license plate readers and live view cameras and what they mean for privacy, safety, and local control in our community.
1:36:29 I urge you to cancel our contract with Phlox, to set rules and regulations in place regarding AI surveillance moving forward, to safeguard the community before you sign on to any future contracts.
1:36:42 I believe that you all, myself included, deserve a right to due process under the Fifth Amendment rights, and that you deserve the protection from unreasonable searches and seizures under the Fourth Amendment rights.
1:36:55 Procedural and data privacy under the Fourth Amendment frameworks the law for surveillance with evolving interpretations in areas like electronic data, digital tracking, and AI cameras.
1:37:10 Phlox system doesn't just record license plates.
1:37:14 It's proven to use AI to track vehicle details like bumper stickers, roof racks, and window decals, things that can reveal political views, religious beliefs, or gun ownership.
1:37:25 A few of the 18 cameras are also placed in invasive areas like the village, the library, and the Old Mammoth Fawn stoplight intersection.
1:37:33 Recent reports show that Phlox is linking its tracking system with people search databases and data breaches, including home addresses, emails, and phone numbers.
1:37:44 Please consider that this means that your data, when you go to the grocery store, when you go to church, when you pick up and drop off your kids from school, when you drive out of town, and when you arrive back.
1:37:59 This is logged, tracked, and built into a profile.
1:38:03 I know, I know we trust our local police, but do we trust Phlox?
1:38:08 This system gives access to our personal data, to outside law enforcement agencies, and public agencies with buying power.
1:38:17 This level of surveillance does not belong in our community.
1:38:21 We deserve safety without constantly being watched and billion-dollar tech companies profiting from turning us into a product.
1:38:31 This is not a company to be trusted with our public safety.
1:38:35 I need you to consider that Phlox, or any other alternative AI surveillance with network-sharing properties, maintains the ability to build profiles on all of us.
1:38:47 And you as town council members, us as your town community, and our children, who will grow up in an emerging tech surveillance world.
1:39:00 We need to follow the precedent set by other towns and establish regulations in our town for public data collection technologies
1:39:08 prior to seeking alternative methods of community protection.
1:39:12 In sum, I urge you all to vote to cancel the contract with FLOC immediately
1:39:19 and to work with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department and with our local community to support transparent
1:39:26 community-led conversations about any future use of AI technology in Mammoth.
1:39:30 Thank you so much for hearing our concerns tonight.
1:39:34 That is all.
1:39:35 Thank you.
1:39:38 Are there any hands raised online, Jamie?
1:39:41 No.
1:39:42 Okay.
1:39:43 Come on up to the podium.
1:39:44 And just to be clear, like Rob said in the beginning, we're not allowed to take action on this item tonight.
1:39:54 Hi, everyone.
1:39:55 Chris Bubzer, town of Mammoth Lakes resident.
1:39:58 I just, I'm grateful to the members of the community who have come forward to speak.
1:40:05 And I just want to add a couple of points that we want to keep in consideration as we move forward.
1:40:13 So thank you.
1:40:13 In June 2024, FLOC came to us, or our staff came to us with a potential contract.
1:40:21 And at that time, council was queasy about this system.
1:40:27 But we also know that we want to support our police department with the latest technology and make sure they have all the tools they need, particularly with the staffing challenges that we've had over time.
1:40:38 And so I asked some specific questions and was able to get on a call with representatives from FLOC and our town attorney, Andy Morris.
1:40:50 And at the time, I was surprised at how unprepared they were to answer some of the questions.
1:40:54 But they did get back to us, and we had asked for additional assurances that aren't in their normal contracts, proof that they would delete all of our data, not just from their servers, but from the cloud, and come back to us with those assurances.
1:41:10 And then, and not, to my knowledge, we never got that information.
1:41:13 I think you even mentioned that earlier, that they were shockingly slow at these assurances.
1:41:18 But the other thing is that in our contract, we were very careful to make sure that it wouldn't be used for immigration purposes.
1:41:26 And so it did state in our contract as revised or as amended, if I remember correctly, that we, that they were not to share it with any law enforcement or government agency other than the town.
1:41:39 Now, I realize it's not our fault that settings were changed and toggles happened.
1:41:44 But I just think it's really important to just reiterate that point of trust.
1:41:50 And, you know, I'm grateful for all the follow-up that our staff and our PD have done.
1:41:55 But I think as we're thinking about moving forward, it's really important to just...
1:42:00 Highlight the points that we asked a lot of these questions up front more than other municipalities and I feel like they egregiously ignored those requests and things we have put in our contract. I have questions about, you know, their integrity in general as a corporation. So I'll be done. Thank you.
1:42:22 Thank you, Chris.
1:42:31 Good evening, Town Council. My name is Sasha Hashemipour and I am a Mono County resident and I spend a lot of time in Mammoth Lakes. I am here to urge you to immediately cancel Mammoth's contract with Flock Safety. I believe that we do not need to find alternative AI cameras before canceling this contract.
1:42:53 And every day that you delay, you continue to put residents, their data, and their privacy at risk.
1:43:00 Privacy is a fundamental civil liberty. It is what allows people to move through their community freely.
1:43:08 And when that right is eroded, it is always the most vulnerable residents who suffer the most.
1:43:14 We have had these cameras long enough. Flock Safety has shown itself to be a company that is rife with violations and misuse.
1:43:22 Every week, new stories are coming out about privacy breaches and the misuse of these cameras.
1:43:30 Flock cameras, we know, do more than just record. They track, analyze, and store data on everyone who passes by.
1:43:38 Mammoth residents did not consent to these gross privacy violations when they chose to live here.
1:43:43 Flock is not just a camera company. They are a data company, and they have already proven that they cannot be trusted with our data.
1:43:53 The documentation of misuse and abuse is overwhelming.
1:43:57 For example, earlier this year, Flock sales employees accessed sensitive cameras in an Atlanta suburb without authorization.
1:44:05 They were using this sensitive footage to sell their product to other police departments.
1:44:12 And the cameras they accessed included footage from a children's gym, a playground, a school, a community center, and a pool.
1:44:22 There have also been many instances of Flock ALPR cameras being used for illegal stalking.
1:44:29 While this may not be happening in our town yet, do we really want to maintain a contract with a company that has already shown this level of disregard for people's privacy and safety?
1:44:41 So I urge you to cancel the contract and please also develop a town ordinance for AI surveillance tech.
1:44:54 You know, this is a new age we're living in, and we need to adapt before we...
1:45:00 We just, you know, buy new cameras.
1:45:02 We need to figure out what do we want these cameras to do and really be clear.
1:45:07 I mean, I know that you guys worked really hard on maintaining that contract and maintaining the way, like, what you see on the cameras, but clearly their breach of trust has been broken.
1:45:21 So I urge you to cancel the contract.
1:45:24 Thank you for your time.
1:45:25 Thank you.
1:45:27 Any other public comments?
1:45:29 Hello.
1:45:37 Sorry for not coming more prepared.
1:45:39 My name is Forrest, resident of nine years, currently working at the emergency department, where I work with some of our police.
1:45:48 I mostly wanted to point out some things that kind of came to my attention while I'm here.
1:45:53 First off, I want to say I do think that we've done a good job here of trying to keep our information within our ecosystem, and I kind of am surprised.
1:46:02 And I want to say thank you to you guys for doing a good job of trying our best with this.
1:46:07 That said, I think it's quite apparent that the public doesn't trust Flock, and it sounds like we don't trust Flock, as our local government doesn't trust it, our police don't seem to trust that they're going to keep that data contained, I think it's pretty apparent that they're going to use the information from microphones, cameras, whether they're license plate readers or not, to train AI on our information.
1:46:30 Now, obviously, we're in a day and age where we've pretty much all given up a lot of privacy for the convenience of our cell phones, but I don't want to see our police giving up the privacy of our town for convenience.
1:46:43 There are other ALPR systems, there are other gunshot systems, there's pretty much alternatives to each piece of this technology, and I don't think that we should be using Flock for this.
1:46:55 I think that the use of Flock for this is decreasing the amount of trust between our community and our government and our police.
1:47:02 And I think that's a huge, huge problem, as you know, we really rely on trusting each other and working with each other.
1:47:12 That all said, I think that we we kind of have a choice on how we want to move forward.
1:47:19 And I think small government action like this is is where we're choosing what kind of future we want to live in, whether we want to give all of these liberties to a big company that's a startup that likely will be using this information to train their models, whether or not that's what they say they're doing or not.
1:47:38 I think we ought to choose to go with maybe a less convenient option to kind of decide that that's not how we want to move forward and into a greater surveillance state with AI.
1:47:52 Thank you.
1:47:53 Thank you.
1:47:54 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?
1:47:58 Anyone online?
1:48:00 No.
1:48:01 So I just want to reiterate that the way that this was presented to us tonight as a staff presentation,
1:48:07 that we're not allowed to take action on this tonight.
1:48:10 But you plan on bringing this forward?
1:48:14 Yes, I can bring this back forward.
1:48:17 There's a number of things that I can do.
1:48:19 There's a general consensus for immediate action that I've done before to shut the system down.
1:48:24 That's possible that you've done immediately.
1:48:26 And then come back and confirm cancellation.
1:48:32 That's the entire council.
1:48:34 I know there's no action that I can receive from you tonight, but perhaps consensus should be getting the affirmation from that affirmation.
1:48:47 Is your microphone on, Rob?
1:48:48 My microphone was off the whole time, so nobody heard what I said.
1:48:51 So do you have what you need, or would you like to hear from each town council person?
1:49:00 To what extent can I get feedback?
1:49:01 Just on the presentation.
1:49:07 Thoughts about Flock?
1:49:09 Anybody?
1:49:11 Start on this side?
1:49:13 It could be as simple as bring it back or shut it down.
1:49:17 Okay.
1:49:18 For me, bring it back, what are the solutions are.
1:49:25 If the staff has completely lost confidence in the company, then I have no problem with shutting it off either.
1:49:31 However, we will still be paying that monthly fee until the contract is over one way or the other.
1:49:36 So those are all things for us to consider.
1:49:39 I would like time to be able to consider that.
1:49:44 Brent?
1:49:45 If we asked for you to bring it back, how long would it be before we had something back to us?
1:49:50 Two weeks.
1:49:50 Two weeks.
1:49:50 I'd prefer to come back and look at and staff get an evaluation of where we are with the data and what's alternative and where we go.
1:50:00 It's easy to make a quick reaction, but I'd just like to make an informed decision.
1:50:06 Move forward.
1:50:07 John?
1:50:08 Shut it down.
1:50:11 Cleland?
1:50:11 I would also like to put this off for a couple of weeks, come back.
1:50:22 I know this is not popular.
1:50:24 I had a stalker trying to kill my husband for several years in this town.
1:50:29 Don't drive by my house if you want privacy because I am camera queen.
1:50:34 I do think that there are really good uses for some type.
1:50:38 It doesn't sound like flock.
1:50:40 Is the company to go with?
1:50:41 I don't know if there is something that I would actually be comfortable with.
1:50:46 But, again, we are, if everybody that has a cell phone doesn't think that you're not being tracked, sold, we are already a commodity.
1:50:53 And it's very tough when you have a severely handicapped husband.
1:50:58 And you can understand that you're not being tracked.
1:50:59 And you can understand that you're not being tracked.
1:51:00 You keep having to call the police station and say, you know, oh, he's coming over to our house again, or, you know, can you track him?
1:51:01 I don't know if you're not being tracked.
1:51:03 I don't know if you're not being tracked.
1:51:09 It was a very horrible, horrible situation, and I am in favor, frankly, you could put CCTVs all over town and I wouldn't have a problem with it, but this does not sound like the solution.
1:51:09 But I don't know if you're not being tracked.
1:51:10 I don't know if you're not being tracked.
1:51:11 I don't know if you're not being tracked.
1:51:23 This is not the Jetson answer that I thought, in my mind, working forward towards a future that will help protect the vulnerable people, and until it happens to you, you don't know.
1:51:38 I guess I'm interested in if they've, you know, breached the contract that we had with them, and I would love for Andy to look into that more.
1:51:44 Rob, I would be comfortable with you shutting it down, you know, tomorrow I feel like you've shut it down once before, and if our police department, you know, if we're, I mean, I feel like this summer we had some things that we were specifically looking for, you know, I would like to also take in mind, like, the staffing shortages at the police department.
1:52:08 I don't know if two more weeks of cameras, you know, I don't know if shutting it down tonight or having it on for two more weeks, if there's such a huge difference, but I would be in favor of shutting them down.
1:52:21 So, is that?
1:52:23 Thank you.
1:52:23 You got what you need?
1:52:24 Okay.
1:52:28 Shall we take a 10-minute break and then jump into housing?
1:52:31 Okay.
1:52:31 All right.
1:52:32 We're going to be back at 7.
1:52:36 6.
1:52:36 I'm sorry, 6.
1:52:37 7.
1:52:39 6 o'clock.
1:52:44 I thought it was later than it was.
1:52:46 Yeah.
1:52:47 I'm sorry.
1:52:48 Excuse me.
1:52:49 I have a situation.
1:52:55 Hey, good job.
2:08:36 All right, we went a little over five minutes. Sorry about that. So we're going to come back into session on item 7.2, housing programs update. Welcome, Marcus and Nolan.
2:08:53 Hello, and I'm mostly going to let Marcus talk unless there's any specific questions for me. I'll hand it over to Marcus.
2:09:00 All right, Marcus Sproul, Housing Manager, and here with a housing programs update.
2:09:08 See if I can get this thing working.
2:09:09 There we go.
2:09:13 So the active town housing programs can be broken down into the five categories that I've got listed here, the first being rental development, so that's apartments, and we're talking development.
2:09:25 We're basically talking creating new rental units.
2:09:29 Primarily, that's happening at the parcel, of course, so Kingfisher 1.
2:09:33 is in the final stages, should be opening up here this fall.
2:09:39 Kingfisher 2, they're just starting on that, should be a couple years for that one.
2:09:43 We've also talked about the school district, the land exchange, potentially a project for them.
2:09:48 And then the town missing middle project that we've been talking about, 130 units, we're working with some consultants on the feasibility of that.
2:09:56 So those, that's generally at the parcel, that's new construction, of course, sometimes, rarely we'll have conversion, like conversion of commercial space to new residential access apartments, a good example of that.
2:10:09 But generally with rental development, we're talking about new construction for affordable housing.
2:10:13 And then homebuyer development, similar concept, generally new construction.
2:10:19 So the small sites program that we have, 60 Joaquin was sort of the first pilot of that program, developing new affordable workforce housing to sell to local workforce households.
2:10:31 And then we've also been talking a little bit about doing some additional homebuyer projects at the parcel in the future, likely a number of years away for that.
2:10:41 We've also, we also have rental incentive grants.
2:10:45 That's the lease to locals program.
2:10:47 And that's an incentive to the owner to rent long-term instead of short-term.
2:10:51 That's the goal of that program.
2:10:52 And then we have several for-sale programs, and these programs are to support homebuyers.
2:11:01 They go and find a home, and they can either essentially, we pay for a deed restriction, so they can give us a certain value out of their home, and then they take it off the market, essentially.
2:11:11 It becomes deed restricted.
2:11:12 And then every time it sells again, it'll sell at that reduced, restricted price.
2:11:17 So we have programs like the bridge, density bonus, mitigation.
2:11:23 The bridge is a financial incentive program, basically, where we buy the deed restriction, density bonus, and mitigation.
2:11:30 It's a land use requirement for when a developer comes in and they want to get additional density.
2:11:37 Both of those are basically deed restriction programs.
2:11:41 We also have for-sale down payment assistance programs.
2:11:43 And this generally is a second loan, so there's the first mortgage, and this is a second loan.
2:11:51 It's a deferred loan, so you don't have to pay it typically for 30 years, often zero interest or very low interest.
2:11:57 Again, the goal is just to help people get in.
2:12:00 into their first home, typically it's for first-time homebuyers. There are state and federal programs, so Home, CDBG, and Begin. We also have the PLHA program. We'll be talking about that a little bit later in this meeting. All those programs have slightly different rules and assist different income levels. So low-income, there's programs that have a large amount of assistance for low-income households. We also have assistance for moderate-income households, 120% of AMI.
2:12:30 So I'll just take a deeper dive now into all of those five. In terms of rental development, we currently have about 377 deed-restricted rental units that are available to the general public. There's also 100 restricted units at a project called The Shoots, I think you're all familiar with, that's available just to the ski resort employees.
2:12:52 Kingfisher 1, we talked about, has 75 units, and that's currently in the lease-up phase, and that was included in the 377 number that I put above. Kingfisher 2 was not included. That's just starting construction expected to lease up in 28. That's 72 units.
2:13:07 We also have existing projects, Aspen Village, the Jefferies, and Manzanita. Those were built about 20 years ago, in 2006-2007. And those have 77 units. They're currently undergoing a $10.7 million rehab to fix a bunch of the building systems.
2:13:25 I think there'll be a presentation later in this meeting related to that as well.
2:13:30 And as I mentioned before, we are in negotiations for land swap with school district. The terms of that are being negotiated.
2:13:37 But essentially that would give the school some land at the parcel to develop their own rental project for the school employees.
2:13:44 We're working with the consultants on the feasibility of a town project potentially, a 130-unit middle income project. That would be roughly 120% of AMI.
2:13:56 Trying to figure out the sort of legal path, the ownership path, the financing path for that, and come back to council with those numbers for decision at some point.
2:14:08 So all of this activity, there's a lot of activity going on. We have a lot of existing units. There's a lot of new units coming online.
2:14:14 We're, you know, projecting out a pipeline here with these other projects at the parcel.
2:14:19 And that, you know, could conceivably bring the total restricted rental units to about 700 in the near future.
2:14:25 That's a significant number, especially for a town our size.
2:14:31 And in terms of for sale development, so 60 Joaquin Road, that project, there's four townhomes there.
2:14:37 Again, it was sort of a pilot. A lot of lessons learned. We're still working through that.
2:14:43 There's one unit that is still for sale. We've received an offer for that.
2:14:48 That process is taking a little longer than we anticipated.
2:14:51 But we're hopeful that all those units will be occupied by the end of the year.
2:14:56 The town does own some other small sites currently. We own some-
2:15:00 land that could potentially be developed in a similar way.
2:15:04 I think once we wrap up 60 Joaquin,
2:15:07 we can kind of do a debrief and a breakdown of the lessons
2:15:11 learned and look at the feasibility of potentially
2:15:13 doing that again at another small site.
2:15:15 And really small sites, the goal is to take a vacant lot
2:15:18 and maximize the density and then sell those units
2:15:23 to workforce households, typically around 150% of AMI max.
2:15:28 That's what 60 Joaquin was.
2:15:31 And then at the parcel, there's potential
2:15:34 for much larger for sale projects there.
2:15:38 Somewhere in the neighborhood of 80 units total
2:15:40 could be developed there.
2:15:41 And those could also be townhomes,
2:15:44 probably similar kind of a model to 60 Joaquin.
2:15:52 And then in terms of rental incentive grants,
2:15:53 as I mentioned, Leased to Locals.
2:15:56 This program was renewed last year.
2:15:59 We refunded it and we made some changes in December of last year.
2:16:06 And just wanted to give you a little bit of a snapshot
2:16:08 of what's been happening.
2:16:09 So to date, there's been 38 grants.
2:16:12 And again, that's paid directly to the owner.
2:16:15 And that's housed 99 total tenants.
2:16:18 The average grant is 9,700.
2:16:22 Average lease is just under 11 months.
2:16:25 The average tenant income is around $60,000.
2:16:28 And then we've been tracking the retention.
2:16:31 And so currently, that's around 58%.
2:16:34 So basically what happens is when a lease term ends,
2:16:38 we ask the owner what their plan is for the tenant going forward.
2:16:42 And you can see there's a table down here and a chart.
2:16:45 So these are their answers, basically, where they're
2:16:48 going to renew with the same tenant,
2:16:49 they're going to rent long term different,
2:16:51 or they're going to do short term, they're not sure,
2:16:53 or they're going to use it themselves.
2:16:55 Those are kind of the responses that we get back.
2:16:58 So 58% basically are going to continue renting long term.
2:17:02 It looks like we have a question.
2:17:03 Sure.
2:17:04 Oh, sorry.
2:17:05 We received an email from Jamie from the lease to the local
2:17:09 spokes.
2:17:10 Can you turn your microphone on, John?
2:17:11 Oh, I'm sorry.
2:17:14 Sorry.
2:17:14 We received.
2:17:15 Public comment?
2:17:16 Yeah.
2:17:16 Council received that.
2:17:17 Just if you get a second, you don't have to do it now.
2:17:19 But it'd be interesting to know that what they've
2:17:20 represented in the emails consistent with your analysis.
2:17:24 Sure.
2:17:25 Yeah.
2:17:25 I just read it.
2:17:26 You don't have to do it now.
2:17:27 But I just want to make sure we get that squared up.
2:17:29 OK.
2:17:30 Thank you.
2:17:33 Yeah.
2:17:33 So I think looking at these numbers,
2:17:37 the program is maturing.
2:17:38 We're getting a good handle on what it's doing
2:17:40 and maybe what it's not doing.
2:17:42 And the funding is about to expire.
2:17:45 So we have allocated 545,000 since the beginning.
2:17:50 And 523 has been spent or committed.
2:17:53 So essentially, in the next month or so,
2:17:56 it's going to dry down completely.
2:17:57 And there will be no new.
2:18:00 Applicants possible. So placemates requested from us basically to ask the council for $150,000. So we're going to come back probably at the next meeting, but also welcome your feedback on that. We'd be coming back next council with that request. May I ask you, that is $150,000 to go towards subsidies for leases or $150,000 in administrative costs? It's $150,000 total.
2:18:29 So each application, when it's processed, placemates gets basically $2,500, $2,200.
2:18:37 Okay, so that would be for the whole program to run longer, and that's not only administrative costs.
2:18:42 Right. Yeah, and I think they're estimating they could assist somewhere around 13, 12 or 13 more households over the next year with that amount of funding.
2:18:52 I think last year we knew that it was around $120,000 last December, and so that's gotten us here to October.
2:18:59 So the $150,000, the idea is just to get us through a whole, basically a whole year.
2:19:04 And then one other quick question on that. Are there plans, I did read the email, and in the email he, the placemate representative stated that, you know, they have not done any more direct marketing of the program.
2:19:19 Are there plans to do an additional mailer? I know we've at least sent, like, two mailers to each homeowner on the registers. Are there plans to send another mailer?
2:19:30 Yeah, I mean, I think we'll take your direction, but we hadn't thought that that was necessary.
2:19:36 I think the program's matured enough in the word of mouth, and the, you know, the applications that we're getting and the interest we're getting is pretty consistent.
2:19:43 Okay.
2:19:44 So it doesn't, it hasn't seemed like we needed to, unless there was a desire to sort of expand the program, maybe, and try to do more outreach.
2:19:50 But it seemed like it was sort of flowing at a steady clip without that.
2:19:56 Okay. Thank you.
2:20:03 Bless you.
2:20:04 And then moving on, a little more detail on the for sale deed restriction.
2:20:08 Again, these programs essentially reduce the purchase price of the home.
2:20:13 So deed restriction programs basically reduce the price of the home, and then the down payment assistance helps whoever's buying that home by that reduced price, right?
2:20:23 So for deed restriction, what we've done recently, we've tried to streamline the applicant process.
2:20:33 I think when I started here, I got a lot of feedback that it was a little confusing and it was a little cumbersome, so we've really tried to streamline that.
2:20:41 And now what we're doing essentially is partnering with lenders here in town, the first mortgage lenders.
2:20:47 This is a model used in many, many cities.
2:20:50 The lenders are essentially working with the applicants on their first mortgage, and now they can tell that applicant, hey, the town has this program.
2:21:00 if you want to participate they can help them with that application and then once
2:21:06 they complete the application they route it to the town the town looks at it make
2:21:10 sure it meets all the qualifications but it's a single point of contact for the
2:21:14 applicant it's a little easier for them they're providing the lender with all
2:21:18 their income documentation already so they don't have to provide it to two
2:21:22 different places they're just going to one office they're talking to the lender
2:21:26 so we're hopeful that that will make it easier for applicants and make it a
2:21:30 little more streamlined just a question did they get any preferred rate by doing
2:21:37 that for the first mortgage yep we we don't have any required we can't
2:21:43 require that you know I didn't know if they were if the institutions were offering
2:21:46 that some I think I know some of the lenders if your local will have certain
2:21:51 concessions but yeah I think it varies too much for us to really track but my
2:21:57 understanding is generally the local you'll get some concessions in terms of
2:22:03 your mortgage rate I don't think they have that flexibility but it's in terms of
2:22:06 like processing fees and things like that that's what I've heard and so we we we
2:22:15 have a web page now so if you go to the town web page and you go to housing what
2:22:20 you'll see there is basically information on the programs we have available how much
2:22:25 funding is currently available and you'll have access to the program
2:22:28 guidelines a snapshot you can sign up for an interest list to be updated of
2:22:34 program updates or if there's listings and then you'll have the contact
2:22:39 information for our approved lenders is there as well so we have just really
2:22:44 trying to improve the transparency and just make the process really clear and
2:22:48 help people who want to participate get that information really quickly and
2:22:53 easily and currently we have about 1.1 million in bridge funds that's the D
2:22:59 restriction program so we have that available for folks that program goes up
2:23:05 to 150 percent of AMI and up to 150,000 to buy down the purchase price of the home
2:23:16 so it's not alone it's a it's a buy down program basically we're buying that deed
2:23:21 restriction and then for sale down payment assistance these are all loan
2:23:28 programs so this is that second loan program model that we use similar process
2:23:35 right we're putting it through the first mortgage lender and so you go to your
2:23:40 first mortgage lender you tell them your situation they can offer you whatever
2:23:43 town programs are available and they can help you of course town staff housing
2:23:48 division were available if folks have questions too but that single point of
2:23:52 contact with lenders and so currently we have about seventy thousand dollars in
2:23:56 PLHA funds and 30 and begin funds
2:24:00 And so it's about $100,000 that we currently have
2:24:02 for down payment assistance.
2:24:05 And then later in this meeting, we'll
2:24:06 talk about a program application that we're
2:24:09 going to do for PLHA.
2:24:10 And that would be an additional $350,000
2:24:12 that we're going to apply for from the state for that program.
2:24:16 That program goes up to 120% of AMI.
2:24:18 It's been really successful since we started it.
2:24:25 We also have about $500,000 in home program income
2:24:28 that we want to apply to HCDE to use
2:24:31 for down payment assistance.
2:24:33 And program income is basically from repayment
2:24:35 of previous home loans or interest in a bank account
2:24:38 or something, whatever income is coming back
2:24:40 through the program.
2:24:41 So we're just intending to recycle it back
2:24:44 into down payment assistance.
2:24:47 And then of course, we're always on the lookout
2:24:49 for state or federal programs, adding additional funding
2:24:53 as it's available.
2:24:59 And just put a flyer here.
2:25:02 This went in, I think, went in the sheet this week.
2:25:06 And we're just informing the community of all these.
2:25:09 Basically, this presentation I just gave you,
2:25:11 we're just putting that in the paper.
2:25:12 And we're going to be presenting to the Board of Realtors
2:25:16 tomorrow, also similar update.
2:25:17 We're trying to just get the word out
2:25:19 that we have a lot of these programs
2:25:21 and trying to make it easier for people to find them,
2:25:25 find information on them, apply for them,
2:25:27 and all those things.
2:25:28 And so always welcome your feedback or the community's feedback
2:25:32 on how we can make that easier.
2:25:35 And with that, any questions?
2:25:37 Questions?
2:25:41 I don't really have any questions.
2:25:45 It seems like a pretty good summary of where things are at.
2:25:47 And that's the intention of this presentation, right?
2:25:49 Yes.
2:25:50 Okay.
2:25:51 I'm pretty good.
2:25:52 Anybody else?
2:25:53 No, I'm good.
2:25:54 Thank you.
2:25:55 Thank you so much, Marcus.
2:25:59 Okay.
2:26:01 So we are going to move on to item eight, reports from commissions
2:26:05 and or departments as needed.
2:26:08 This feels much later than usual.
2:26:12 Thank you for hanging out.
2:26:14 Are there any reports from departments and or commissions?
2:26:17 Hi, Kim.
2:26:20 Kim Anaclario with Mammoth Lakes Recreation.
2:26:27 Summer is over and so we have some time.
2:26:29 I thought I'd come tell you what we've been up to.
2:26:34 I started summer off with two fundraising events.
2:26:39 We did the Arts on the Fourth Festival.
2:26:41 That was a great success.
2:26:43 We had over 60 vendors, music, food, free kids activities.
2:26:49 We also took on a second art festival called the Mammoth Art Walk this year.
2:26:53 And that was an activation up in the village.
2:26:56 It was very challenging.
2:27:00 Because it was kind of last minute, but we put it together, pulled it off, had about 20 vendors, had a lot of great feedback from people, thought it was a nice new way to experience the village, a lot more family friendly.
2:27:13 So looking like we will do it again. It also spurred the local art walk that happened, kind of been something that the town has been interested in doing for several years.
2:27:23 And that took off on its own, and I know that they did a few different local art walks in the evenings and coincided with Sierra Summer Nights.
2:27:33 So very successful on that front. We have just wrapped up the fiscal year 25-26 Measure U programming grants. That's all closed out.
2:27:44 And so with the 206,525 that was allocated last year, experiences for 13,214 local attendees happened, 37,773 visitors.
2:28:03 This is all put on with 521 volunteers and 119 paid organizers and staff.
2:28:10 So, good Measure U programming year. New this year, we sponsored four Clear the Line events, which were monthly cleanups at Lakes, where volunteers came, cleaned up fishing line, and then we fed them afterwards as a thank you.
2:28:27 We did two at Convict, one at Mamie and one at Lake George.
2:28:31 In, let's see, as you know, we got the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Grant to purchase the three CD3 stations for clean, drain, dry, preventing spread of aquatic invasive species and golden mussels.
2:28:50 So we got those deployed in early July. We had one in the Lakes Basin, there's one at June Lake Junction, and one down at Convict Lake.
2:29:00 And to complement that, we started an education and outreach program.
2:29:05 And so MLR hired an ambassador paired with the town outdoor rec host, and we made 564 individual contacts,
2:29:14 just educating people about the stations, how to use them, why it's very important, and it was all very well received.
2:29:24 I'd say about 50% of the people were aware that clean, drain, dry was the accepted practice if you're going to be using watercraft,
2:29:32 and we're very appreciative of those that didn't know of the information.
2:29:35 Let's see, we did a, we called it Fishing with Friends, we partnered with Crowley Fish Foundation, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and LADWP to take 14 local school students on a fishing trip on a Saturday morning.
2:29:54 And the point was really just to, you know, we talked about tangle-free waters.
2:30:00 and the importance of doing the right thing when you're out fishing but the point was really to
2:30:03 show our local youth what they can do here in their own backyard every day just give them that
2:30:09 experience um we also met up with the high school ap environmental science class up at twin lakes
2:30:18 and talked about the tangle free waters program um educating about the stations the program and then
2:30:23 we spent a couple hours cleaning up twin lakes and last friday we hosted a volunteer and sponsor
2:30:33 social at windriff studios where we got to say thank you to all the people who've been
2:30:38 supporting the stewardship programs all year and that was really fun we had a great slideshow
2:30:44 showing everything that was played on the projector that measure you helped pay for at the
2:30:48 event space and we had about 50 people show up and we gave recognition to several people that have
2:30:57 been with us for over five years steady and right now between adopted trail and tangle free waters
2:31:02 there's 230 volunteers and sponsors combined and of that 97 have been with us for over five years so
2:31:11 very good retention rate on those and last i would like to invite you all to the mammoth trails
2:31:20 community meeting next wednesday october 28th at mammoth brewing company we will hear from the trails
2:31:29 manager and the mammoth lakes district ranger will be there giving some a recap talking about reds
2:31:35 meadow construction updates what's next for the sharp trails uh several other partners will also be
2:31:42 giving updates uh town parks and rec will be there bishop blm mono county recreation white bark
2:31:49 national park uh park service from devil's post file mltpa and tamarack so it should be a pretty good
2:31:56 informative meeting again next wednesday 6 p.m mammoth brewery thank you thank you any other reports
2:32:07 from commissions or departments oh okay um okay uh and uh item 8.1 town of mammoth lake social media report
2:32:21 for september 2026 and 8.2 october 2026 public works engineering cip update are both written reports
2:32:27 only correct that's correct are there any questions on those two items no okay uh so we will move on to
2:32:35 item nine consent agenda item 9.1 approve the minutes of the regular meeting of september 16 2026
2:32:43 item 9.2 adopt the resolution approving an amended conflict of interest code item 9.3 update and request
2:32:50 approval for continuing emergency contract work at mammoth yosemite airport item 9.4 authorize the town
2:32:57 manager to execute a professional services agreement
2:33:00 With Ascent Environmental Incorporated for preparation of the Town's 7th Cycle Housing Element Update, Item 9.5, accept check register 9-17-26 in the amount of $1,168,204.30, accept check register 9-24-26 in the amount of $807,950.93, accept check register 9-28-26 in the amount of $236,950.93,
2:33:30 accept check register 10-1-26 in the amount of $851,773.85, accept check register 10-8-26 in the amount of $918,652.92. Would anyone like to pull anything? No? Then I'll make a motion. I would entertain a motion. Go ahead and accept the
2:33:56 I've been sent agenda, agenda as is. Approve the agenda?
2:34:00 No. Second.
2:34:02 Roll call, please, Jamie.
2:34:03 Council Member Souser?
2:34:05 Wait, I can't get my green light on.
2:34:07 Yes.
2:34:08 Council Member Wentworth?
2:34:09 Yes.
2:34:10 Council Member Howe?
2:34:11 Yes.
2:34:12 Mayor Pro Tem Truax?
2:34:13 Yes.
2:34:13 Mayor Rice?
2:34:14 Yes.
2:34:16 Okay, we are on to Item 10, Public Hearing.
2:34:21 We're on to Item 10.1.
2:34:23 Hold a Public Hearing to Consider a Grant Application and Planned Activities for the State Permanent Local Housing Allocation, PLHA, Program.
2:34:31 So I will open up the Public Hearing.
2:34:37 Thank you, Marcus Sproul, Housing Manager.
2:34:41 I put up the plan on the screen here.
2:34:44 In July of this year, the California Department of Housing and Community Development, HCD, announced the release of the Permanent Local Housing Allocation Program, PLHA, and that's the 2024 through 2028 Formula Allocation NOFA, Notice of Funding Availability.
2:35:03 PLHA is funded via the Building Homes and Jobs Act, that was SB2 in 2017, and that's a $75 recording fee whenever documents are recorded.
2:35:15 So that's real estate documents, real estate transfer documents.
2:35:20 Those fees fluctuate every year, just depending on the number of transactions.
2:35:26 And then there's a formula allocation that goes to local governments for housing-related projects and programs, basically to assist with affordable housing.
2:35:36 The Town of Mammoth Lakes previously applied for $496,879 in PLHA funds.
2:35:43 That was the 2022 NOFA, and we've used $440,000 of those funds to date to assist six moderate-income households, up to 120% of AMI, to purchase a home.
2:35:58 Any repayment of...
2:36:00 Many of those loans are put back into the Down Payment Assistance Program per the approved PLHA reuse plan, so they're recycled back into the program.
2:36:10 Due to the success and continued demand for the program, we recommend that the town apply to receive additional PLHA funds under this 2024-2028 NOFA.
2:36:23 The five-year total additional funding that is available is estimated to be $355,513, and that could be used for down payment assistance.
2:36:34 120,657 of those funds are available immediately, those were from 2024 and 2025.
2:36:40 Those are fees that have already been collected through that document fees basically, so we can get those now,
2:36:46 and then any additional funds would be available after they're collected.
2:36:52 The public hearing that we're conducting is an opportunity for the public and the town council to provide comments and direction on the activities to be included in the town's PLHA 2024-2028 plan.
2:37:04 That's what's up on the screen currently.
2:37:07 In addition, this plan can be amended for future allocations to address changing conditions or needs.
2:37:16 Okay, thank you. Are there any questions? Brent?
2:37:21 Two questions. Why would we not apply? It seems simple, but it's kind of a rhetorical question, but of the $355,513, does that potentially get diluted anyways?
2:37:34 Or is that, I recognize that I've got the formula, but when we apply, what's our odds of getting the money?
2:37:40 Is it pretty much a sure thing or is it kind of an iffy thing?
2:37:43 No, it's a sure thing, just the actual dollar amount depends on the number of document transfers that occur.
2:37:49 So that estimate of $355 is what HCD thinks will be collected over that period.
2:37:54 The initial amount, the $120,000, has already been collected and we'll get that right away, but the other three years haven't happened yet.
2:38:02 Yeah.
2:38:03 And to your first question, we could apply for this money for a different program.
2:38:08 Like we don't have to do down payment assistance.
2:38:10 That's the whole point of the hearing is do we want to use it for down payment assistance?
2:38:14 We want to continue this program.
2:38:15 Are there other uses for it that we might want to consider?
2:38:19 I understand.
2:38:20 Okay.
2:38:21 Okay.
2:38:22 Question?
2:38:23 No.
2:38:24 This side?
2:38:25 No.
2:38:26 So I would take public comment.
2:38:30 Anyone in the audience have a public comment?
2:38:32 Anyone online?
2:38:33 No.
2:38:34 No.
2:38:35 Okay.
2:38:36 So now we are at deliberations.
2:38:41 Madam, go ahead.
2:38:42 Can I make a motion?
2:38:43 Mm-hmm.
2:38:44 Adopt the resolution approving a grant application to the state HCD for the permanent local housing
2:38:51 allocation program for the 24 to 28 funding cycle and approving the town's 24 to 28 permanent
2:38:57 local housing allocation plan.
2:39:00 I'll second.
2:39:01 Roll call, please.
2:39:02 Councilmember Salzer?
2:39:03 Yes.
2:39:04 Councilmember Wentworth?
2:39:05 Yes.
2:39:05 Councilmember Hoff?
2:39:06 Yes.
2:39:07 Mayor Pro Tem, Truex?
2:39:07 Yes.
2:39:08 Mayor Rice?
2:39:08 Yes.
2:39:11 Okay.
2:39:13 Thank you, Marcus.
2:39:14 And so now we're going to move on to item 10.2, hold a public hearing to discuss expenditures and accomplishments of the Town's 2021 Community Development Block Grant 21 CDBGHA00015.
2:39:28 I will open up the public hearing.
2:39:33 Great.
2:39:34 We're just waiting for the screen to begin sharing.
2:39:37 Yes, this is the closed-out public hearing for the Town's 2021 CDBG Grant.
2:39:43 This grant had a much longer life cycle than those of our CDBG grants.
2:39:51 It was over and we then pulled it back to the house.
2:39:53 It was already started.
2:39:55 This CDBG program is a federal grant program.
2:39:59 In our case, it's administered through the housing community development division at the state.
2:40:06 So it goes from the feds to the state and then to local communities.
2:40:10 It's intended to do support housing, infrastructure, economic opportunities for low and moderate income communities.
2:40:16 In point-in-point or distinction within that low and moderate, it doesn't use federal terms, so it's not quite the same thing like that it was we were used to here.
2:40:27 As a smaller non-entitlement jurisdiction, we must apply for the CDBG grants in the state.
2:40:33 So it's a competitive process with all the other small jurisdictions throughout the state.
2:40:37 And then those applications are running accordingly in the school version, so we're not always competitive.
2:40:45 But in this case, the 2021 cycle, we were competitive to get it.
2:40:53 Just going back to the housekeeping, again, this is a public hearing.
2:40:57 So if anyone wants to participate that's not here, there's directions on the screen, plus all the subsequent slides.
2:41:03 So as we talked about, the timeline for this is a much longer timeline than most CDBG grants.
2:41:23 So in August 2020, the Town Council authorized staff to submit an application.
2:41:29 The scope of that grant application was to fund a multifamily housing rehabilitation project
2:41:36 that had been pitched by Mammoth Lakes Housing to rehabilitate the Glass Mountain commercial buildings into an apartment project.
2:41:47 So in December 2022, we were notified by the state that we were awarded $3 million for the project.
2:41:54 Mammoth Lakes Housing at that time had been aggressively working to identify funding sources for the project.
2:42:00 The project, so in addition to that $3 million, the town had committed $1.5 million to the project and that MLH was successful in getting a $4 million grant from the home program.
2:42:13 So it was a lot of layering of grants to essentially fund that development of the project.
2:42:21 From 2022 on, they were working to value and engineer the project because there were still some funding gaps in their development budget.
2:42:30 And they were then in early 2024, kind of had closed all the gaps in the budget that included additional allocation from the town of an additional $700,000 and $600,000 from Mono County, as well as some other funding sources.
2:42:45 So total, they had about, identified approximately $11 million in funding for that project.
2:42:51 Right before they were going to construction, something very unique happened, and the state called us to say they wanted to give us $4 million additional funding from the CDBG program.
2:43:03 They had identified some excess funds from other grants, and the catch was that was like June 20th and had to be committed to a project by the end of the fiscal year.
2:43:13 So by June 30th, so we had about 10 days to scramble and get that committed.
2:43:20 We were successful in doing it, and the great thing was by getting that additional CDBG money into the program, it allowed MLH to forego their home funding, which streamlined the project because there was less funding coming in, less funding requirements, less programs.
2:43:36 But more significantly is it allowed for a kind of a different mix of the of the area median income that the final units would be targeted to.
2:43:50 So like I said, they kicked off construction in roughly July of 2024, took a little over two years to finish the project.
2:43:58 It was completed this spring, or I guess a little bit under two years to actually get occupancy, and then just in September of this year, the expenditure deadline expired.
2:44:10 We were successful in spending every penny of the grant, so it was about $7,100,000 in change.
2:44:19 So all the way down to the penny, we spent all those funds.
2:44:22 So yeah, here it is here.
2:44:26 So yeah, we were successful in spending $7,193,532.68 on the project, so we didn't have to give any money back to the state, which was great.
2:44:40 And what that project ultimately achieved, or that funding ultimately achieved, so it allowed the rehabilitation of those two buildings into 13 new affordable deed-restricted rental units.
2:44:55 Seven of the units are available to low-income households, so those with 80% or.
2:45:00 below of AMI, and six of those units are available to moderate-income households, so those earning up to 120% AMI.
2:45:07 This is unique in that we were able to identify and fund some moderate-income units, primarily being because CDBG requires that only 51% qualify for that low-income threshold, and the remaining can be at whatever you choose.
2:45:24 And so, we ultimately did get those 120, which then helped our RHNA goals, so the state regional housing needs allocation.
2:45:35 We've struggled to identify any units in that 120% AMI category, so it was great that we were able to make some progress there.
2:45:44 And I think more importantly, you know, I think Mammoth Lakes Housing, now Eastern Sierra Community Housing, really, I mean, they worked on this project for many years,
2:45:53 ran into many, many roadblocks on funding, permitting, I think COVID was in the midst of it from when they bought the property to when they started building it, everything else.
2:46:04 So, I think it just really highlights kind of all the local entities working together, really on this critical need for the community, you know, in addition to the town and Mono County committing money to the project,
2:46:16 they also had private donations from local residents and local businesses, as well as national corporations as well, like that, a grant from Chase Bank that went into this and others.
2:46:27 So, I think it really just highlights, you know, how we, you know, tackling that, the housing needs, it's not one entity doing, doing all the work.
2:46:37 So, yeah, the next steps after this public hearing, we'll submit the closeout reports to the state and that will essentially wrap up the project unless the state decides to do what's called a desk audit,
2:46:53 where they just kind of review finances or review any of the kind of occupancy or construction pieces to make sure you're in compliance with the federal rules.
2:47:04 With that, I think we're, as the end of our slides, we're open to any questions or if anyone from the public wishes to make any comments.
2:47:17 Any questions?
2:47:18 Just a quick one, is it, I'm assuming this public hearing is a requirement of the CDGV grants, is that?
2:47:25 Correct.
2:47:26 Yeah.
2:47:27 Okay.
2:47:28 Thank you.
2:47:29 All right.
2:47:30 I'd love to hear public comments on this item.
2:47:33 Hi, Tom.
2:47:34 Tom.
2:47:36 Good evening.
2:47:41 Tom Hodges.
2:47:42 I'm the current chair of the board of Eastern Sierra Community Housing and just wanted to be here to help celebrate this moment, really, of getting this project to a point of completion.
2:47:53 Thank you.
2:47:54 Nolan, thank you so much for all your efforts in administering the grant.
2:47:58 It was a great presentation.
2:47:59 I think he .
2:48:00 Highlighted, you know, really some of the unique aspects of this project that were, you know, we just, we kind of lucked into it, particularly with that CDBG grant that allowed us to, you know, raise the up to 120% AMI level on these units, which were the first in the community at, of rental units at that level, you know, above 80%. So, you know, that was a huge win for the community.
2:48:21 Just, again, I want to thank and recognize the contribution of the town funding to this project that Town Council voted for, the $2.3 million ultimately, $600,000 from Mono County, a number of other private donors, you know, from the banks, and I think I'll tear through a little money in there.
2:48:43 There was a lot of other, you know, smaller private donations, but again, a real testament to the will of the community to get this thing done and over the finish line, and so, yeah, hooray, great job, and, you know, I just want you to know that Eastern Area Community Housing is certainly, you know, looking for other opportunities where we can provide a, you know, unique opportunity to, you know, create an opportunity where we can come to the table as a partner that, you know, maybe where we can bring something that the town can't,
2:49:12 and we can partner again to create, you know, more housing for our community.
2:49:16 So, we're definitely committed to that into the future.
2:49:18 So, anyway, all around a fantastic project.
2:49:21 Thanks to everybody.
2:49:23 And, but I, John Stewart's here, our Executive Director with Eastern Area Community Housing.
2:49:27 John's going to provide a little insight to sort of the human aspect of the project, of the people that we've actually housed, and some testimonials here he's going to read to you guys.
2:49:38 I just thought it was important to look to that, you know, ultimately,
2:49:42 is where the road meets the road, where our residents are getting housed, and how it's affecting their lives.
2:49:46 So, John.
2:49:47 Thanks.
2:49:49 Good evening.
2:49:50 Thanks, Tom.
2:49:52 Thank you all.
2:49:54 I think Nolan did a really nice job of sort of laying out the statistical impact of the project.
2:50:03 And I'm brand new in town.
2:50:05 I started in August here in Mammoth at Eastern Sierra Community Housing, just as this project was really coming across the goal line.
2:50:12 So, it's nice to be able to help celebrate that.
2:50:16 And I think one of the things I have witnessed up close and personally is the human element.
2:50:21 Because not only do our housing navigators at Eastern Sierra Community Housing help put people in these units, but they help keep them in these units through housing retention principles.
2:50:31 And when we started talking about this presentation, our navigators said, we've got several people who are super enthusiastic about the project and would love to voice their opinions on the project.
2:50:46 None of whom wanted to be here tonight.
2:50:48 So, they've presented in writing, and I'll just share with you.
2:50:53 This is from a married couple.
2:50:55 Our housing situation was difficult.
2:50:57 We had gotten evicted and finding a place during...
2:51:00 Winter was very difficult with everything overpriced. Once moving into our new apartment it has been amazing. Very comfortable and very local to everything. Having a stable place to call home has meant so much to us even more as a newlywed couple. Knowing if we ever wanted to grow our family we have a safe place to do so and call it our home but mainly we've been trying to enjoy the newlywed part. We have made new goals. We travel and enjoy our marriage just the two of us with our dog as well as the
2:51:29 the future. We want to buy a first home and knowing we have our apartment we want to work towards that gradually. This is our very first nice apartment and that works just right with our income and falls in place with everything we have planned now. Having a safe and affordable place to live is essential because everyone deserves a stable home where they can feel secure and at peace. When housing becomes too expensive it can cause stress and make it harder for people to afford basic housing. We experienced it and many in our community but I want
2:51:59 our community to understand that affordable housing benefits everyone and help us create a stronger healthier and more supportive community. We want to thank Jarrett especially one of our housing navigators. He has helped my sister and us so much and we really appreciate him. Thank you.
2:52:14 And then another tenant wrote quite eloquently on top of this. Living in Mammoth Lakes is important to me because this is where my life is. My work is here, my friends are here and I love the outdoor lifestyle. Mammoth is the kind of place where people stay because they care about the community and the quality of life. I wanted to be part of that community long term not just pass through for a season. Before moving into access apartments I was living out of my 2010 Subaru Outback.
2:52:42 It sounds funny when I say it but it wasn't. Housing in Mammoth is so difficult to find that even people with steady jobs can end up living in their cars. I wasn't unemployed or unwilling to work. I was working hard at multiple jobs trying to build a life here but finding stable housing was a major challenge. Moving into access apartments changed everything. It gave me stability independence and a real home. Instead of worrying about where I was going to sleep or whether I could afford another
2:53:12 rent increase somewhere else I finally had a place of my own. Access allowed me to stay close to work and become a more established member of the community.
2:53:21 Having stable housing has reduced stress tremendously. When you have a dependable place to live you can focus on work, your health, your future, and participating in the community. It makes you feel like a resident instead of someone just getting by. You feel more secure and more invested and more connected to the town.
2:53:38 What I appreciate most about access is the quality of the property. Everything is well maintained, the location is excellent, and the apartments are modern and comfortable.
2:53:46 Compared to many other housing options in Mammoth, access provides tremendous value. It's one of the nicest places I've lived, and in my opinion one of the nicest apartment communities in town.
2:53:56 If access had not been available, I honestly...
2:54:00 Honestly, I believe I would either still be living in my vehicle, couch surfing, or renting a room in someone else's home with very little privacy.
2:54:09 Access gave me an opportunity that would have been very difficult to find elsewhere in Mammoth.
2:54:13 I would like to thank the town council and the community.
2:54:16 I would like you to understand that workforce housing matters because working people need somewhere to live,
2:54:22 and many of us earn too much to qualify for traditional low-income housing, but market rate housing is often out of reach.
2:54:30 Housing like Access fills that gap.
2:54:32 It helps retain nurses, hospital workers, service workers, and other essential members of the community who want to live and work here long-term.
2:54:40 Access Apartments also demonstrates that workforce housing can be done well.
2:54:43 The project didn't simply create more housing units.
2:54:46 It created a quality community where residents can take pride in where they live.
2:54:50 It shows what is possible when the town invests in housing that serves working people.
2:54:55 My experience at Access has been overwhelmingly positive.
2:54:58 I'm grateful to the community to live here, and I believe projects like this are an important part of Mammoth.
2:55:05 Was that the microwave?
2:55:10 Thank you very much.
2:55:11 Thank you, John.
2:55:13 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?
2:55:16 Anyone online?
2:55:18 No?
2:55:19 Thank you so much for this presentation.
2:55:22 Oh, if you have a public comment, come on up.
2:55:29 Hello again.
2:55:30 I just wanted to add I really appreciated you sharing all of those comments of workforce folks that have gotten access to housing,
2:55:39 and as someone who has lived here for 13 years and has been one of those people both in the medical force and with the mountain
2:55:47 and with other service jobs here in our community, the only reason I've gotten a foothold is because of other people trying to help me get housing.
2:55:57 And so the fact that you guys have this project running, trying to get housing for more of our workforce,
2:56:02 is so incredibly important, and I just want to express my gratitude for these projects.
2:56:08 So thank you so much for doing this.
2:56:11 And I just am popping in to reinforce the idea that it is incredibly, incredibly, incredibly important that we take care of our workforce
2:56:20 and we make sure that they are housed.
2:56:22 I agree that there is a big gap between working multiple jobs and not making or making too much to be able to afford low-income housing,
2:56:33 and then there's this big gap and trying to afford what is kind of rental value for homes in this area.
2:56:42 So trying to fill in that gap is incredibly important.
2:56:45 And I think that about sums up my thoughts.
2:56:48 So thank you.
2:56:49 Thank you again for supporting our workforce and getting them homed, especially during the winter, during the cold winter months.
2:56:56 So thank you.
2:56:59 Okay.
2:57:00 I wanted to say thank you for the presentation.
2:57:04 Thank you to Eastern Sierra Community Housing.
2:57:07 Tom, you've really done a lot for this project and for Eastern Sierra Community Housing as a whole.
2:57:12 So I just wanted to say thank you.
2:57:14 This project is very unique, and it's so wonderful that we were all able to work together to provide housing for our community.
2:57:23 So thank you very much.
2:57:25 Are there any other comments from anyone up here?
2:57:28 No?
2:57:29 I would entertain a motion.
2:57:32 Is there a motion or anything?
2:57:35 No?
2:57:36 Okay.
2:57:36 Then I will close the public hearing.
2:57:39 All right.
2:57:42 So then we're on to item 10.3, hold a public hearing under the Tax and Equity Fiscal Responsibility Act, CEFRA,
2:57:49 in connection with the proposed issuance of revenue bonds by the California Municipal Finance Authority, the CMFA,
2:57:55 for the rehabilitation of four existing Mammoth Lakes family apartment projects within Mammoth Lakes.
2:58:03 Great.
2:58:03 Thank you.
2:58:05 So I'll give, there's no presentation for this one, but I have a brief statement.
2:58:10 And then I know the proponents from the CMFA, Anthony Stubbs, as well as the developer on this project, Mike Kelly, are both on Zoom.
2:58:22 If there's any questions or if they want to make any additional statements.
2:58:25 So we're here this evening to conduct a public hearing pursuant to the Federal Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act, or CEFRA.
2:58:34 CEFRA requires that a public hearing be held by the governing body of the jurisdiction in which a project to be financed with tax-exempt financing is located,
2:58:42 and that the governing body approved the proposed financing.
2:58:46 West Development LLC has asked that the California Municipal Finance Authority, the CMFA,
2:58:53 be the issuer of tax-exempt financing in an amount not to exceed $30 million.
2:58:58 The proceeds of the bonds will be used to finance the acquisition, rehabilitation, improvement, and equipping of the following existing multifamily rental housing facilities.
2:59:07 That's Aspen Village at 1700 Old Mammoth Road, consisting of 48 units.
2:59:14 Manzanita Apartments at 44 Manzanita Road, consisting of 14 units.
2:59:19 The Jefferies at 312 Lupin, with 14 units.
2:59:24 And the second building at the Jefferies at 129 Dorrance, with 2 units.
2:59:28 So these four existing projects have been in place since early to mid-2000s, and they are in need of some rehabilitation work,
2:59:42 so this funding would go directly towards that rehab work on those projects.
2:59:47 The CMFA is a joint powers authority formed to assist local governments, non-profit organizations,
2:59:53 and businesses with the issuance of both taxable and tax-exempt debt.
2:59:58 The debt to be issued by the CMFA...
3:00:00 A will be the sole responsibility of the borrower, so in this case West Development LLC, and the Town of Mammoth Lakes will have no financial or legal obligations or responsibilities with regard to the repayment of the debt.
3:00:13 All financing documents will carry disclaimers that the loan is not an obligation of the Town, and also the Town will bear no cost in the issuance of the proposed debt.
3:00:22 With that, so with that, it is recommended that the Town Council adopt the resolution approving the issuance of the bonds by the CMFA for the benefit of the borrower.
3:00:32 Such adoption is solely for the purposes of satisfying the requirements of TEFRA, the Code, and the California Government Code, Section 6500.
3:00:42 Okay, any questions?
3:00:45 A couple questions.
3:00:46 Just looking for clarification.
3:00:47 So, I understand they're looking for the municipality to approve so they can go forward.
3:00:55 Is there any restrictions on these units?
3:00:57 Is this affordable housing?
3:00:58 Is there just a private developer?
3:01:00 What's the premise for the $30 million?
3:01:04 So, I'm just trying to understand their request.
3:01:07 I understand that if approved, the bond goes out and we really don't do much with it, but just understanding what the request is.
3:01:13 Sure, so all four of those projects are subject to regulatory agreements that ensure that they're affordable units.
3:01:21 So, they're all restricted at 80% or below AMI.
3:01:24 Those restrictions are in place.
3:01:28 The initial term is 55 years from when they were initially opened or occupied.
3:01:33 So, roughly 2005, 2006-ish.
3:01:37 And then, on top of that, there are additional affordability requirements imposed by the town because we had put home funding into all those projects.
3:01:46 We actually carry, we have a regulatory agreement and deed of trust in place on those for that similar term.
3:01:55 And when that term comes up, they either have to repay that money to the town or we can negotiate a longer term to push out that affordability further into the future.
3:02:06 So, right now, they remain just under those existing regulatory agreements that restrict them as all low-income.
3:02:12 Okay.
3:02:13 Because CNFA usually has some sort of public benefits required, so I'm just trying to understand the request.
3:02:19 Does that make sense to me?
3:02:19 Okay.
3:02:21 Any other questions?
3:02:22 In, yeah, in the earlier housing piece you did, there was talk about these same ones and $10 million worth of rehab on them.
3:02:32 Is this $30 million loan to pay for that $10 million worth of updates on those units?
3:02:38 Yeah, so I'll let Mike or Anthony elaborate further on that.
3:02:43 The work itself is about $10 million estimated.
3:02:45 They typically ask for a higher issuance of bonds in case there's any costs or overruns or any other unexpended expenses when they get into it.
3:02:59 It's my...
3:03:00 Understanding that, so the actual estimated cost is about $10 million.
3:03:05 But they, fine, thanks.
3:03:10 Anyone else? No? Any public comments from anyone in the room? Anyone online? No.
3:03:18 Okay, deliberation. I would entertain a motion.
3:03:24 I would move to adopt a resolution approving the issuance of bonds by the CMFA for the benefit of WDV, Mammoth Lakes LP, a California limited partnership.
3:03:32 A partnership of which West Development Ventures LLC, or a related person to the developer, is the general partner to provide for the financing of the rehabilitation of four existing Mammoth Lakes family apartment projects.
3:03:45 Such adoption is solely for the purpose of satisfying the requirements of TEFRA, the code, and the California Government Code, section 6500, and following.
3:03:56 I'll second that.
3:03:57 Roll call, please, Jamie.
3:03:58 Councilmember Salzer?
3:03:59 Yes.
3:03:59 Councilmember Whitworth?
3:04:00 Yes.
3:04:01 Councilmember Hoff?
3:04:02 Yes.
3:04:02 Mayor Pro Tem Truex?
3:04:03 Yes.
3:04:04 Mayor Rice?
3:04:04 Yes.
3:04:05 Okay, we are on to Item 11, Policy Matters, 11.1, Appeal of TOT, T-Bid Penalties and Interest by Michael Cisneros.
3:04:15 Madam Mayor, I have to recuse myself because of proximity in this matter.
3:04:19 Okay.
3:04:21 Would you like to take your computer to the box?
3:04:23 No.
3:04:24 You can be sure, right?
3:04:24 Who knows?
3:04:26 Right, Nick.
3:04:27 I'll do the other.
3:04:28 Very nice.
3:04:33 Yeah, yeah.
3:04:34 Hi.
3:04:37 Welcome.
3:04:38 Since the case is going to be great, I'll go through a little bit of a...
3:04:42 Every two hours.
3:04:42 We've got another hour.
3:04:48 So Mayor Rice, we're going to start off over here.
3:04:52 I'll go through a couple of elements and give our appellants the time to address questions and concerns.
3:04:59 I'd like Andy to kind of address counsel with regard to the authority and or process for this evening.
3:05:06 I will talk about how this procedure will go as far as count our presentation of facts and the appellants' presentation as well as questions.
3:05:17 You would have questions from either party at that point in time and we can address any of those.
3:05:23 So Andy?
3:05:24 Yeah, thanks, Rob.
3:05:25 So we haven't done one of these in a while, so I just thought it might be helpful for everyone on the dais and everyone in the room, including the appellants, to understand kind of what the council's role is.
3:05:34 The council is essentially acting in a quasi-judicial capacity, acting like a judge, being a finder of fact, and you're deciding whether to grant the appeal, deny the appeal, or maybe grant the appeal in part.
3:05:46 And in the past, when the council has had TOT appeals, the council has looked at, did staff calculate the amount owed correctly?
3:05:54 Did staff calculate the amount of the taxes?
3:05:56 Did staff calculate the penalties correctly?
3:05:58 The interest correctly?
3:06:00 And sometimes in the past the council has looked at are there any extenuating circumstances that might have justified the appellant in not understanding or not being aware of perhaps their obligations and the council has the ability to uniquely, because staff can't do this, but the council could decide to reduce the amount of penalties or interest or if you think the tax was calculated correctly you can reduce the amount of the tax as well.
3:06:24 So it's up to you.
3:06:26 I'm here to help you if you need help, if you need advice.
3:06:29 The staff is here to answer questions.
3:06:31 The appellants will make a presentation.
3:06:32 I'm sure they'd be happy to answer questions as well.
3:06:35 May I ask, since there's four of us, is it a three vote that we need?
3:06:39 You do need three votes in one direction or another.
3:06:42 Okay.
3:06:42 Thank you.
3:06:44 So Ben Manning, you are a revenue accountant now, is that correct?
3:06:49 We'll be presenting sort of a timeline of the actual activity and walk through that.
3:06:56 As soon as that's complete, then you're welcome to provide your thoughts and comments as well.
3:07:01 And then we'll go through the questions as necessary.
3:07:04 So Ben, please proceed.
3:07:06 On August 10th, an initial discovery of the unidentified ad occurred.
3:07:12 On August 17th, the property was identified as 25 Lee Road, Unit 143, owned by Mr. Cisneros.
3:07:23 Excuse me.
3:07:24 Excuse me.
3:07:24 And it was determined at the time that it was unregistered with a certified property authorization number.
3:07:30 At that point of time, there were 74 reviews going back about three years.
3:07:36 Can I just ask the year?
3:07:37 This is August 10th, 2026?
3:07:40 This is, yes.
3:07:41 Okay.
3:07:42 Thank you.
3:07:42 So this all started August of 2026.
3:07:45 Thank you.
3:07:46 On August 19th, the property was, property identification was confirmed in person.
3:07:52 So staff went out and confirmed that the listing did match the photos.
3:07:59 A notice was posted on the door as well as mailed first class and certified.
3:08:07 The very next day, Darlene Tardif, the host of the listing, reached out on Mr. Cisneros' half.
3:08:13 And via the phone.
3:08:14 And the necessary documentation was sent that day.
3:08:22 The revenue record showed that there was $79,657.70 in unreported revenue.
3:08:28 An initial notice of determination was drafted, resulting in $20,000 owed in TOT, T-Bid, and enforcement.
3:08:41 Staff asked that the Cisneros' and Ms. Tardif review the NOD.
3:08:46 And about a week later, we spoke on the phone to discuss the NOD and the factors that led
3:08:52 to that case.
3:08:52 The town at that time offered a payment plan of six months.
3:08:58 Thank you.
3:08:59 Thank you.
3:09:00 At that time, Mr. Cicero said that would create a financial difficulty, and they declined the six-month payment plan, claiming it would be a financial hardship that would result in them needing to sell their condo.
3:09:15 They were informed that only Town Council could forgive penalties and interest.
3:09:19 On August 31st, a second draft of the NOD was sent for review.
3:09:24 At the same time, all the municipal codes and the work that was done on the case was sent to Mrs. Tardif.
3:09:32 On September 3rd, Mrs. Tardif spoke with me regarding the case, and again, we cannot forgive P&I, and we could not reach a consensus.
3:09:41 Again, she indicated that she wanted to appeal P&I, and requested on September 9th, that we sent the official NOD, which with a total due of $20,111.45.
3:09:57 This includes $11,757, excuse me, $11,757.06 in TOT&T bid, $7,854.39 in P&I, and a $500 enforcement charge.
3:10:15 On September 15th, Mrs. Tardif emailed her official request for an appeal, and it was forwarded to the Town Clerk and scheduled for tonight.
3:10:26 Those are the facts that we see.
3:10:30 Okay, questions?
3:10:38 I guess my question is, how are penalties and interest calculated?
3:10:44 Penalties go back two months, and it's an additional 15% on the tax.
3:10:49 Interest can go 36 months, and is 1.5% per month.
3:10:55 Okay.
3:10:55 Based on the actual tax that, the TOT dollar amount.
3:11:00 Based on the TOT.
3:11:01 The unpaid TOT that is due, and then you calculate the whole thing.
3:11:03 So we will tack on 15% for one month, and 15% for two months.
3:11:07 And then 1.5% for every month, going back three years.
3:11:11 Okay.
3:11:11 Pretty much.
3:11:12 Yeah.
3:11:12 Okay.
3:11:13 And this, you've checked your calculation that this number.
3:11:15 I don't think they're disputing the numbers at this point.
3:11:18 I'll leave that for them, but we feel pretty confident about these numbers.
3:11:23 Okay.
3:11:26 Any other questions?
3:11:28 No questions.
3:11:29 Okay.
3:11:31 So now, we get the answer from them.
3:11:33 Please proceed.
3:11:34 Okay.
3:11:35 Thank you for that.
3:11:36 I appreciate that.
3:11:37 Now we'll tell our side of how we got to that point.
3:11:40 I'm Darlene Tardip, and this is Michael Cisneros.
3:11:43 This is my service dog, Brody.
3:11:46 So what happened that led us to this point was, I mean, now we look back, and we're just
3:11:53 like, can't even believe we got to this point, and how it happened.
3:11:56 He purchased the condo March of 2020.
3:12:00 23, when it was a rental condo. So we were already thinking it's a rental condo. And we'd use it once in a while, but because we live down south, that we'd use it for rental purposes and that it was already an established rental property with the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so when escrow closed, we got all the documentation for escrow papers and we were handed the certificate, the permit from the, I guess it was at that point, now looking back, it was the prior
3:12:29 permit of the person who was selling the property. And so we didn't know that no one handed us a packet saying or any information saying you guys need to sign up with the city for your rental. You know, we were handed this permit. So yes, kind of our bad and now looking back at it, but that's what our understanding was. So when we moved in, I called Airbnb to set it all up and, you know, took pictures, all that stuff. And Airbnb,
3:12:59 had told me that they took care of all the taxes. And I said, I don't have to do nothing with the city. And they said, no, we take care of everything. Take care of our taxes, their taxes or their fees and, and our service fee. So that's where we were three years ago. And so we've been going forward three years, not, you know, not knowing that we were obviously not correct with our procedure.
3:13:26 But no one ever said anything to us. And, and then when, when it came to that, they put the notice on the door, we saw it in our ring. And we're like, Oh my gosh, what's going on with that. So we had a neighbor come over and get it to us because we didn't even get the certified mail till a few days later.
3:13:46 So we immediately called right away because we're not hiding anything. We're not, we didn't make any money off of anything because then I called Airbnb and found out when all this happened, that they weren't taking money out for the city taxes.
3:14:00 So then I was like, Oh my gosh, we're going to, you know, what are we going to do? And so then we're just trying to work it out with, with the city.
3:14:08 And so, but he brought to our attention that in 2021, I guess you guys had a system called rentalscape and in 2021, in the year in review, the monitoring of the rentalscape in your guys is, I guess, town paper said that the rentalscape monitoring is intended to bring operators into compliance quickly and limit outstanding TOT.
3:14:36 TOT earlier identification and notice might have corrected our misunderstanding sooner and limit accumulating charges.
3:14:45 So that's, I mean, when I found that there was a rentalscape and he provided, I asked him for all the, you know, documentation that he said that it was identified on the 10th of August.
3:14:56 So then I did some research and I found that in 2021,
3:15:00 2021, everybody was saying that this rentalscape is really good because it's helping the city,
3:15:05 you know, stop the people from illegal renting.
3:15:09 Well, we're not illegal renting, but had something been in place or had we been notified
3:15:14 when we first got the property that, hey, these are the procedures of the town if you
3:15:20 plan to rent out, I think every real estate agent needs to tell the tax office or whoever
3:15:26 is in charge of, I guess it would be the tax office, that, you know, they need to be notified
3:15:33 when somebody buys and that person who buys needs to be handed like, yeah, acknowledge
3:15:40 in writing, you know, some sort of paperwork that they need to fill out in order for them
3:15:44 to rent because this was totally, I mean, a complete misunderstanding all the way around.
3:15:50 And so we're totally bummed on it because, you know, he's a LA County firefighter.
3:15:56 background. So, um, I'm a firefighter for LA County for 26 years. Um, since I was a young
3:16:02 fireman, we've always come up here. We and my buddies wanted to buy a place, never materialized.
3:16:08 Finally, 2023, we did come up here, find a little condo discovery. Um, and we went ahead and
3:16:15 purchased it. So, uh, my whole point is if you like Ben was saying, the very next day we
3:16:22 called, we didn't delay, we didn't fight. We wanted to, we were like in shock. Well, what's
3:16:28 going on? Cause we thought we were compliant. I'm a servant of the public for 20, like I
3:16:35 said, 26 years, uh, cheating, anything like that is not part of my values. Um, I'm also
3:16:43 part of the joy board, funnily enough. Um, I'm one of the directors there and, uh, I deal
3:16:49 with the fire mitigation part for a joy, making sure that discovery is good. But anyway, as
3:16:54 you can see, I, I love the city. Um, you know, I'm a city worker. I cheating the town would
3:17:01 not be part of my MO and, uh, yeah, that's the whole thing. I'm planning to retire in about
3:17:07 a year or so. And I was going to come up here and be a mountain host and, uh, maps and tell
3:17:12 people where the bathroom is. But yeah, uh, I just think it's a, it could have been avoided
3:17:19 had, uh, maybe somehow it's been notified to us sooner.
3:17:24 And another thing is when I met with Chris at the tax office, um, he had said, he goes,
3:17:30 you know, he goes, I didn't assess the 25% fraudulent penalty against you guys, because I don't think
3:17:37 you guys were doing it fraudulently. I really believe what you're saying. He goes, but I
3:17:41 don't have the power to do anything with the dollar amount. Only the council does. He goes,
3:17:47 but otherwise, if we would have believed you guys were being illegal and pocketing that, you
3:17:51 know, money that you were, you know, charging your renters, then yeah, that'd be fraud and
3:17:56 you would be, you know, liable for that. But.
3:18:00 So with all that being said, you know, we're here before you to, you know, see if there's anything that you guys can do to help us with this.
3:18:10 That's a huge sum.
3:18:11 Yeah.
3:18:12 I'm just coming back from complete knee surgery on my right leg, so income is fixed when you're in disability.
3:18:22 So we've also been able to rent the unit as soon as possible so that we can recover some of the monies.
3:18:30 So that we can pay the town.
3:18:31 Pay whatever we have to pay.
3:18:32 Yeah.
3:18:34 We're hoping that, you know, the penalties, we know what we owe for the missed taxes.
3:18:41 We're good at paying that, but it's just the amount is just a little extraordinary.
3:18:47 Yeah.
3:18:47 So we're hoping for some help for the right decision.
3:18:53 And, you know, with, I'm sorry, one more thing.
3:18:55 And like you said, with this winter, supposed to be a big El Nino winter, we know we could rent it out and pay back the town, whatever you're going to, you know, want to assess, a lot quicker than a six-month payment because there would be no way for that to happen.
3:19:10 I mean, they got the records and everybody here makes a lot of money in the wintertime, so we would definitely turn that over, you know, on top of current person that's owed of taxes.
3:19:22 Yeah.
3:19:23 Yeah.
3:19:23 So.
3:19:24 Again, there's no malicious intent.
3:19:27 We weren't purposely trying to get rich.
3:19:30 We're not like that.
3:19:31 By far.
3:19:32 It's a small little condo I still have.
3:19:34 I'm a Tundra from 2015.
3:19:36 She's got her 2013.
3:19:38 It's not about, you know, it's not our creed.
3:19:42 We just, for whatever reason, missed it.
3:19:44 And we're hoping that perhaps you guys can see how that could have been avoided.
3:19:53 John, do you have a question?
3:19:54 I have a question.
3:19:55 I have some thoughts, though.
3:19:56 Okay.
3:19:56 I know you're ready.
3:19:57 I'm ready.
3:19:59 Thank you very much for coming in.
3:20:00 And I think we, the council, I've been here, this is, I've been here for 12 years, and I think some of us have been here for a while.
3:20:07 And certainly are sensitive to the misunderstandings of these types of things that can occur.
3:20:13 Unfortunately, we've, the town and the council has done a lot of work, and the community has done a lot of work over the last couple years to get into a position where we can effectively regulate and engage with nightly rentals in such a way that are in the larger interests of the community.
3:20:33 And with that in mind, we have to be very careful about precedent.
3:20:39 And we've, as long as I've been on the council, we've, when we've entertained these types of appeals, we have not been able to or willing to engage with relief for any of these penalties or these types of issues.
3:20:51 It's been a very, very difficult issue for the community.
3:20:55 Airbnb and other platforms like this have injected a lot of...
3:21:00 chaos a lot of difficulty into the community and very much appreciate appreciate your letter your
3:21:06 sincerity and the things you've done but i'm not going to be able to support uh any kind of relief
3:21:10 for the penalties and interest i'm sorry about that but i think we have to look out for fending
3:21:16 off any kind of an avalanche of people coming up saying well i didn't know and i didn't all this
3:21:21 kind of stuff it's just it's a road that we can't afford to go down we've been down that road before
3:21:25 it got tricky uh so that's that's kind of where i'm at at this point uh a mechanism for you guys to be
3:21:38 able to find that quickly who perhaps is not uh registered in town so that to avoid this where
3:21:47 three years later four years later what if it was five years later it'd be tens of thousands well i
3:21:52 think again we're not we're we're just we're policy makers we don't get into the details of
3:21:57 the programs but i think rob was very deeply involved in helping to set that program up we had a
3:22:02 we had a housing moratorium in place for 18 months which is a very difficult thing for us to deal with
3:22:08 as a community programs came out of that on the other side to deal with this if there's any lessons
3:22:14 learned that we should take out of this i think staff would love to hear that and incorporate those
3:22:18 things into what's happening but unfortunately that's not you know giving relief on these things
3:22:23 to set a precedent is something that it's as one council member i'm just not that's not gonna be
3:22:28 a good idea for the community unfortunately again i'm i'm totally understanding paying the taxes like
3:22:34 i'm down for that it's just the penalties seem a little excessive i apologize but that's uh i'm not
3:22:41 speaking for the council i'm speaking for myself but again it's about this precedent if we found i think
3:22:46 we know if we start giving an inch on these things it's going to overwhelm the staff it's going to
3:22:51 overwhelm you know if someone thinks that they can come up here in front of the council and say
3:22:55 the kinds of things you're saying and we start giving relief to that stuff uh from my perspective
3:23:00 that's a precedent that we really don't want to be establishing thank you john bill do you have thoughts
3:23:06 um these things are always really tough i agree with john we set a precedent that we don't forgive the
3:23:12 penalties and interest um everyone should know it's required of your realtor to give you the handout
3:23:20 for what you have to do yeah um i don't know if they did that if not maybe you have a recourse with them
3:23:27 the only thing you did put in there and in my p brain which is slowly becoming um it seems that one
3:23:34 time in the past we did try to come to an arrangement to allow renting while you paid the fees and you
3:23:42 mentioned that in your write-up in your letters i just don't know what that would cost us as a town
3:23:50 in terms of staff time i don't know the legalities of it i don't know how we guarantee that those fees
3:23:58 get paid off the top
3:24:00 Ah, from the rental income, so they're paid as fast as absolutely possible. I don't know those things, and I don't know if any of the other council members would even support that. I would have to look to staff to answer those questions. I'd love to hear from the rest of council before we have staff do that.
3:24:18 Okay. I tend to agree with John. I was on town council previously, went through a lot of these. It was, we didn't know, we didn't know, we didn't know. We unfortunately can't really bend on this, because out of something like this, people will start to know.
3:24:40 It is not necessarily the town's problem when people are buying. If you bought something and then you were just like, town's, you know, crawling all over us with this. I do think that if you were sold this by a real estate agent, then you need to go back and look into that.
3:25:03 If you purchased from a single person, then that's something also. I am unwilling to move from any of the fees at this point.
3:25:15 A real estate agent was one from out of town. It was actually a broker of mine out of town. And the local one here, he's the one that gave me all the paperwork and said, here, this is the town permit.
3:25:28 And it's not like we were trying to hide anything. We got all these reviews and stuff. We were blatantly public, but we just didn't know.
3:25:37 You knew you were going into a system where you would be financially having a gain if you had purchased a business and you would just go, oh, turnkey, I'm walking in.
3:25:49 And I just feel that I've heard this many, many times in the past that we didn't know. And I am very scared, as John pointed out, we go down this road and then it just gets harder and harder to go and stand by what has been in place for a very long time here.
3:26:09 Mm-hmm. I'm sorry for the hardship that this might bring on you, but I stand with everyone up here. You know, I think that operating a short-term rental, I mean, that's a business.
3:26:22 It's the onerous is on you to figure out what rules are required when you're operating and owning a business.
3:26:29 And, you know, information is available online as to what the requirements are in town and where you can rent nightly. So I would like to keep the fees and penalties and interest and the TOT and the citation fee.
3:26:45 You know, back in some of the stuff that I had sent you guys, there are a couple of instances where the town council did reduce the penalties. So you guys do have the ability to do it. And the
3:27:00 What bothers me is the fact that it took three years. Yes, we had a responsibility and obligation too that we missed, but so did the town, you know, the tax assessor with their rentalscape, you know, not finding it when they're reporting in here saying this is going to help in the old town council or the town, you know, memorandum.
3:27:20 It says in there that the rentalscape is here to provide both the town and the public and the renters and the owners the ability to be renting legally and not go three years and then all of a sudden, oh, guess what? You know, it saves everybody. It's in the town's own words.
3:27:39 I'm sorry it took us three years to catch you.
3:27:42 It's not a catch. We weren't doing anything wrong.
3:27:44 Well, to catch the mistake that you're not collecting taxes for the town, so I apologize for that.
3:27:48 We didn't collect anything and pocket it. It was Airbnb told us one thing, which they weren't doing.
3:27:54 Well, maybe you should call them and complain to them about what they were told to you, you know, but for us, if you're operating a business in town, you have to follow the rules set out by the town, and those are publicly available.
3:28:06 You can talk to your real estate agent.
3:28:08 We didn't know the rules because we thought that we had the rules all taken care of.
3:28:13 So what about being able to continue renting while we try to pay the town back?
3:28:20 Where do we have that?
3:28:22 So Bill asked that question earlier, and I appreciate, you know, the conversation around that.
3:28:26 I'm going to ask Ben to address that real quickly.
3:28:30 I do want to kind of mention something with regard to the comments about previously forgiven items.
3:28:36 You know, the town has taken a position that if we were sort of responsible for the sort of contribution to the problem, going back to the two that you stated in there.
3:28:47 One of them was a circumstance where the person called the town, basically inquired, asked a question, was given an answer.
3:28:58 The staff should have followed up, and this was back in 2013.
3:29:01 This was before I arrived here.
3:29:03 Should have followed up with, you know, why are you asking that question?
3:29:07 Because you can't really rent a short term, rent houses short term.
3:29:12 That did not occur.
3:29:14 Subsequent to that, there was another conversation where misinformation was given.
3:29:18 So the town actively engaged with the person, gave sort of bad information, and when it did come to the enforcement time period, put the enforcement out there,
3:29:29 and council felt that the town was responsible for a portion of that, the second one was a similar scenario where we were working with an existing person who was registered within the town,
3:29:43 working on an amendment, I think, of a return, and in that particular case, there was some notification that we felt responsible for.
3:29:52 I think that second one resulted in modification of municipal code to allow for...
3:30:00 The tax collector make a modification if we had made a mistake and were involved in this particular process. However, while those things put responsibility on the town for the engagement with someone, it does not put the town responsible for finding and notifying and identifying and educating people who are not engaged with the town in that space.
3:30:24 And that's been the position that we've sort of taken throughout this process.
3:30:29 Going back to the payment plans, so we've been pretty open on payment plans. We've been focused primarily on the, especially with a person that's illegal account, not giving them the option to rent until that has been paid off as an incentive to make sure that that is paid off.
3:30:50 So, Ben, I'll ask you to talk a little bit more deeply about that, because I think you have the daily activity. I'm very far removed from that activity now.
3:31:00 Yeah, one chair.
3:31:02 I don't know why he didn't sit next to me, but...
3:31:04 One case for me.
3:31:05 When we find an enforcement case, how do I want to say this, it's legal businesses are subject to P&I. And as time goes on, that will continue to accrue.
3:31:22 For enforcement, we get a snapshot in time, and we freeze those penalties and interest.
3:31:29 A legal operator would be subject to penalties, these penalties and interest that would continue to accrue if they were illegal and they were paying this off.
3:31:37 It's very difficult to allow someone to rent when they owe taxes to the town.
3:31:45 Quite frankly, Airbnbs and VRBOs are not necessarily that profitable here, and in past experiences, you can find these people will just often give up or go away, and then it puts staff in an awkward situation.
3:32:00 We're always willing to do payment plans for financial hardships so that it's not such a burden.
3:32:07 The code dictates that this notice of determination is due within two weeks.
3:32:13 Obviously, an extreme financial hardship, we try and ease that with payment plans or whatever we can.
3:32:19 But I think that letting people rent is just not a good idea.
3:32:27 To address a few other concerns, this was a difficult one because I agree with them.
3:32:34 That this was a, what would you call this, ignorance as opposed to malice.
3:32:43 As Chris kind of was mentioning, if you were collecting taxes or things like that, we have these punitive measures that we can do.
3:32:50 Tax fraud, citations, and things like that.
3:32:52 That didn't occur here.
3:32:54 And therefore, there's nothing for us to forgive or give back.
3:32:58 These are...
3:33:00 They're just strictly taxes and penalties and interests. So it really kind of ties our hands in granting any kind of relief.
3:33:09 I want to give a little bit more on the tax fraud aspect because folks need to understand how that works.
3:33:15 We consider when someone has, in this case, as they presented, they were unaware of the tax,
3:33:22 if their advertisement had included a note that said, we collect 13% or 15% tax and remit to the town,
3:33:30 that's what automatically triggers a fraudulent transaction because you're proposing to
3:33:35 respective renters that you are collecting the tax and remitting it on their behalf,
3:33:40 and yet they're collecting and keeping it through their normal TOT.
3:33:45 That's what we consider the tax fraud.
3:33:47 I believe then if this wasn't included in this case, then they were not indicating tax percentages or anything on their website or on their advertisement.
3:33:55 So it's really just kind of more black and white than that.
3:33:58 I also would like to kind of reiterate a point.
3:34:04 You know, while our policy and process and how we run the payment processes and payment plans,
3:34:14 it's always been in the purview of the finance director and tax collector, if you will,
3:34:20 it's well within your ability to do that tonight, if that was so desired.
3:34:27 I've heard people mention the understanding and the situation that occurred and feeling that it was simply a mistake.
3:34:35 I think it can set precedence, but it's really something I want to make sure you know you have the ability to do.
3:34:49 Herman?
3:34:52 Well, I think we're fully aware that we have the ability to do that,
3:34:54 but I think trying to put the burden on a deliberative policy body to come up with policy on the fly in a situation like this is probably impractical.
3:35:05 So I think at this point, I'm sorry, I apologize, but I think we need to, from my position, we need to go with where we're at at this moment.
3:35:13 I think if staff were, you know, in a situation like this, if you wanted to have a payment plan policy or something like that that's established,
3:35:23 that's had legal review and all the rest of it, there could be an option in a situation like this.
3:35:27 I think we'd certainly entertain something like this, but I think to be entertaining and trying to do something like this under these circumstances,
3:35:33 it's just not, it's not practical, practicable, I should say.
3:35:38 Those are my thoughts.
3:35:39 I don't know what the rest of you think.
3:35:40 No, I'm fine.
3:35:41 I, I, there, there are many different ways for them to handle this.
3:35:45 Um, you know, for me, these things are always tough.
3:35:49 I understand financial hardship, yet in the past, when the town councils were more lenient,
3:35:56 uh, we were inundated with appeals, uh.
3:36:00 I mean, all the time.
3:36:01 So, as I said, holding the hard line on fees and stuff is where I'm at as well.
3:36:07 Can I just ask for a clarification?
3:36:10 I think that what the Town Manager was requesting was not development of a new policy on the fly.
3:36:16 I think what he was trying to ask is, is the Council willing to extend the payment plan that staff had previously offered?
3:36:23 And if the answer is no, that's okay.
3:36:25 But I think that was the question, I think.
3:36:27 May I ask why that was turned down?
3:36:34 They turned it down because it wasn't enough.
3:36:39 It would be a financial hardship and they would have to sell their condo.
3:36:42 There's a key point.
3:36:42 And because that's how we feel, like what we presented.
3:36:46 We felt that it was, you know, not done intentionally.
3:36:51 And six months is even going to be super tough for us, you know.
3:36:55 So, we might have to sell the condo, which will be a complete bummer.
3:36:59 So, to add just a little bit to it, because we did offer a payment plan and they could accept a payment plan.
3:37:05 The request, though, is the ability to rent while that payment plan is in effect.
3:37:09 That's the difference.
3:37:10 And that's what our practices don't allow for in this particular circumstances.
3:37:18 However, you know, that's kind of what I was offering up as far as there's an option to do that.
3:37:24 But it's, again, still a six-month payment plan, but they would be able to rent in that time period.
3:37:30 That would be the revenue generator, if you will.
3:37:32 That was all I was offering up.
3:37:33 Well, if I could just ask a clarifying question.
3:37:35 Because, Ben, you said that what I heard was that these payment plans are problematic while people are renting.
3:37:41 Because people have disappeared and the town and the staff is left holding the bag on that.
3:37:47 Could you elaborate on that a little bit?
3:37:49 It's just more about we have legal businesses that pay taxes.
3:37:54 And if they're late, they're subject to P&I.
3:37:56 If we're going to freeze this notice of determination in time and space, per se, then we're freezing it until it is paid off.
3:38:08 Whereas a legal business that perhaps had an audit and had some findings can continue to rent to pay it off because they were already registered.
3:38:18 So it's more about fairness in the sense that if we're going to freeze this notice of determination for six months or longer, if you chose, then renting is not acceptable.
3:38:36 Once the debt is paid off, we're more than happy to register them and get them up in renting.
3:38:42 Is that a whole clarifying?
3:38:43 No, I understood that.
3:38:45 I'm not understanding this.
3:38:47 It's more that a notice of determination is due immediately.
3:38:52 It's because they didn't have a certified property.
3:38:55 So they're not, they don't have, like they're not registered with the town.
3:39:00 They're not registered with the town. It's an illegal rental that's not registered with the town, and they have not been collecting tax.
3:39:05 So it's frozen because they were at no point a registered short-term rental.
3:39:11 If it had been a registered short-term rental who miscollected tax or had some underreporting, then that individual would be able to rent while they pay off their fees.
3:39:28 But since it was at no point a certified property or anything, then that's not an option.
3:39:36 I'd just like to add one element because you're exactly right with the only one key point is that they would still continue to earn penalties and interest even while they were paying that off.
3:39:47 And when we have a notice of determination, it's sort of a spot item.
3:39:51 So it doesn't continue to accrue penalties and interest at that point of determination.
3:39:56 And so that's the difference between the two.
3:39:59 A normal audit is typically where we catch people on that, and they would be paying it off over time, but they would also be accruing more and more fees associated with it at that same time.
3:40:08 And so in that situation, I would say sort of pick your poison.
3:40:12 And I think it's, yeah, I'm with my original position.
3:40:17 If the original sin was not having registered, not having a valid firm in the first place, that's where we're at.
3:40:24 And so that's, that's where I'm at.
3:40:26 Um, what if, um, because as soon as all this happened and I got the home inspection all done right away too, when I, you know, all this came to light with Ryan and I have one thing left to do is to just to buy a fire extinguisher and have him see it.
3:40:45 And then he'll be done and then we could turn in everything to the city and then we would be legal at that point.
3:40:52 Right.
3:40:52 They granted it.
3:40:53 So then we could rent for the winter.
3:40:56 So that we couldn't pay you guys back probably quicker than the six months.
3:41:01 I mean, I now we'll work closely with Ben and Chris to make sure that current and the past owed stuff is paid to him every month as we plan it.
3:41:10 You know, cause again, we're not trying to get away with anything or hide anything.
3:41:14 So I'll be glad to work with them on that.
3:41:20 Uh, it sounded like it's confused.
3:41:22 It's hard to have back taxes and be an open operator.
3:41:28 I think the current policy of the town is that if you have a notice of determination, you're an unregistered business, the taxes are due immediately.
3:41:36 We're willing to work out a standard operating of six months to pay it off to reduce the financial hardship.
3:41:43 But we don't allow rentals, uh, until that debt is paid.
3:41:47 If you can pay off that debt, we will immediately, uh, get you up and running.
3:41:52 Okay.
3:41:54 Um, do we need a motion or anything or do we, do we need to make a finding?
3:42:00 Okay. Are you guys ready? I feel like I'm ready. I would entertain a motion to make a
3:42:08 finding.
3:42:09 Yeah, I would move that the council fines the appellants, if that's the right word, in
3:42:20 non-compliance with the Town of Mamma Lakes Municipal Code, uphold penalties and interest
3:42:24 in the amount of $7,854. This total resulting from the unregistered transit rental, 25
3:42:31 Lee Road, unit 143 over a three-year period, July 2026, and the unreported gross income
3:42:38 of $80,299 generated over that same period.
3:42:42 And I will second that.
3:42:43 Roll call, please, Jamie.
3:42:44 Councilmember Souser?
3:42:45 Yes.
3:42:46 Councilmember Wentworth?
3:42:47 Yes.
3:42:48 Councilmember Hough?
3:42:49 Yes.
3:42:50 Mayor Rice?
3:42:51 Yes.
3:42:52 Thank you.
3:42:53 All right, thanks for your time.
3:42:54 Thank you.
3:43:03 Thank you.
3:43:04 Thanks for coming.
3:43:05 Okay. We'll wait for Brent to get back in here.
3:43:06 Wow.
3:43:07 That's right.
3:43:08 Okay.
3:43:09 How's everybody doing? Do we need another break or we should go a little longer and then
3:43:22 take a break?
3:43:23 We need to go home.
3:43:24 All right.
3:43:25 Let's keep going.
3:43:26 We are on to item 11.2, receive and discuss the draft 2026 Affordable Housing Impact Fee Nexus
3:43:32 Study.
3:43:44 Rob gave me five minutes.
3:43:46 So this item is to, it's no, there's no action being asked tonight on this item.
3:43:55 It's a semi-informational and more of a discussion item on the update to the Affordable Housing
3:44:02 Impact Fee Nexus Study.
3:44:04 And so the draft study was provided in the packet, which did outline how the fees were calculated
3:44:11 and established then what maximum fees could be charged for residential and non-residential
3:44:16 development.
3:44:17 So the purpose of the fee nexus study, it, the legal requirements for the enactment of
3:44:24 a development and impact fee program are set forth in the government code in section 66,000
3:44:30 through 66,025.
3:44:32 Also called the Mitigation Fee Act.
3:44:35 It's also known as the AB 1600 requirements.
3:44:38 That's related to the assembly bill that established the ability to charge impact fees.
3:44:43 So nexus studies are required to establish the maximum monetary value of impact fees that
3:44:48 a jurisdiction may legally assess.
3:44:50 Town Council has the discretion to set the fees up to the maximum amounts identified in
3:44:55 the study.
3:44:56 Fees must have a reasonable relationship and be
3:44:59 with the amount of fees.
3:45:00 roughly proportional to the impact.
3:45:00 And so the amount of fees can be used to
3:45:01 be used to
3:45:03 They also shall not exceed the estimated reasonable cost
3:45:07 of providing the service or facility
3:45:09 for which the fee is being imposed.
3:45:11 And then the next study provides an analysis,
3:45:14 methodology, and justification framework
3:45:17 for the housing fees consistent with the mitigation fee act.
3:45:21 So as discussed, the study kind of walks through
3:45:26 and establishes cost or the reasonable cost
3:45:30 for what an impact fee might be.
3:45:32 In this case, the fees are based on the pro forma
3:45:35 for developing a residential fourplex apartment project
3:45:39 here in Mammoth.
3:45:40 And so it looked at the cost for market rate fourplex,
3:45:44 also then compared to the same fourplex
3:45:47 with one unit being available at a moderate income rent
3:45:50 and one unit at a low income unit rent.
3:45:53 The assumptions in the report were based on then
3:45:56 the delta or the difference in profits of the complex
3:46:01 with the moderate unit or low income unit compared
3:46:04 to the market rate unit.
3:46:05 And then what subsidy would be needed to a developer
3:46:09 to essentially for them to earn that same profit,
3:46:11 regardless of the lower rents on that one unit.
3:46:16 So in the case of this, it was determined that market rate
3:46:20 fourplex, if they were to build it and then sell that
3:46:23 that same project to developer would earn about 690 or $688,000
3:46:31 in profits on that.
3:46:32 More than that same project with a moderate income unit,
3:46:35 would earn about 625,000.
3:46:38 And the same project with a low income,
3:46:40 would earn about 333,000.
3:46:43 The difference in those profits are really associated
3:46:45 with the lower profits on that deed restricted unit
3:46:50 that substantially lowers the rent for that one unit.
3:46:54 So when you look at the difference in profits,
3:46:56 it's 63,000 would be the lower profits on that moderate income
3:47:01 and it would be about 355,000 for that low income.
3:47:05 The study then took that and assumed, or the assumptions in the report
3:47:12 were that that cost would be spread across nine, say,
3:47:16 nine market rate units.
3:47:17 So it was then divided by nine to come up with that per unit subsidy rate
3:47:22 there on the screen on the bottom.
3:47:24 However, in this scenario, you had two different fees.
3:47:28 So there's no way to apply that consistently without then coming
3:47:32 up with a blended rate.
3:47:34 So to establish a blended rate, it
3:47:37 looked to the current regional housing needs allocation numbers
3:47:41 from the state and the breakdown for the various income categories.
3:47:45 And then applied that percentage to those numbers
3:47:48 to come up with a blended value.
3:47:50 So in this case, the blended value,
3:47:52 so the maximum fee that could be charged on a residential unit
3:47:55 was 27,216.
3:47:59 And then,
3:48:00 The state in another legislative action, AB 602, now requires that residential impact fees be charged on a per square foot.
3:48:10 So meaning if you're building a hundred square foot single family home or 10,000 square foot single family home,
3:48:15 you're paying an amount that's proportional to that per square foot price.
3:48:21 So in this case, it was determined that 2,500 square feet was the average size home based on the last five years of sales data.
3:48:29 So looking at the last five years of single family homes sold, the average size was 2,500 square feet.
3:48:35 So that was the size used to establish that per square foot value.
3:48:38 So in this scenario, the maximum per square foot that could be charged on new residential development would be $10.89 in this fee study.
3:48:51 Then to establish the non-residential fee calculations,
3:48:54 they performed a series of analysis to determine essentially the number of employees per 1,000 square feet
3:49:04 based on the various non-residential land use categories shown on the bottom
3:49:08 or for lodging, the average number of employees per room.
3:49:14 That was then converted to households per that 1,000 square feet or per room.
3:49:20 Then they calculated how many of those households earned below 120% AMI,
3:49:24 so below that moderate income level.
3:49:27 And then it was calculated to determine the proportional amount of that residential fee,
3:49:33 so that 27,000 per the households below 120% AMI.
3:49:39 So through that series of complex and confusing calculations,
3:49:44 they then arrive at the maximum that can be charged for the various non-residential use categories.
3:49:52 In this case, the lodging rate is on a per room basis because that's the standard way to apply that.
3:49:58 In most cases, it's looking at per room or per key rather than square feet.
3:50:02 Then all the other non-residential ones would be on a per square foot basis.
3:50:07 So again, these fee studies establish the maximum the fees could be.
3:50:12 Town Council then has the discretion to establish or set the fees anywhere up to that maximum.
3:50:20 They also have the discretion if, you know, our current fees are lower than these maximums.
3:50:24 So they could also leave the fees in place as they currently are and just continue to apply the CPI increases each July that we've been doing.
3:50:35 So the inflationary index increases.
3:50:38 So just to compare how these rates look compared to our last next study was from 2015,
3:50:47 and then our current fees that were adopted in July of 2026 are shown in the middle column,
3:50:52 and then the fees from the 2026 study are on the right.
3:50:56 And so, you know, the 2026 study...
3:51:00 The 2015 fee study is helpful, but it's not really relevant to what we're doing today because every study uses really a different methodology for how they establish the fees.
3:51:13 Each consultant has kind of their proprietary ways that they calculate these out, and I can attest that it's confusing, it's not clear, and it is very complicated to try to dissect how they've done it.
3:51:29 What you do see on the screen, though, is our residential fee is about, you know, $9,252 per unit, or using that same square footage would be $3.70 per square foot, so it's roughly about 30% of what the maximum recommended in the 2026 fee study is.
3:51:52 The lodging right now is about 60, just under $6,200, so it's about $2,000, give it a little less than $2,000 from what the maximum could be, and then the other ones on the square foot range, kind of more widely, those I'd say aren't as much of a concern.
3:52:11 We don't see if we don't see a whole lot of ground up or vacant construction in the retail office, industrial, or service uses, where most of our development that we're seeing is in residential or lodging categories.
3:52:25 Those I think are definitely of greater interest to most.
3:52:32 So, just kind of breaking this out further to compare how our fees compared to some other jurisdictions, both nearby and then up in Truckee.
3:52:45 So, we have the current fees here, this is strictly for residential, so our current fee is $9,252 per unit.
3:52:53 Again, that maximum in the 2026 fee study could go up to a maximum of $27,216 per unit.
3:53:01 I'll skip Truckee for now and come back because theirs is a little more complicated to explain.
3:53:07 Mono County has a 5% inclusionary requirement at the subdivision level, so if you're subdividing a chunk of land into residential lots, they'd have a requirement that 5% of those lots then be set aside for future affordable units.
3:53:24 And then on individual unit construction, they charge $4,700 per unit or approximately $3.91 per square foot.
3:53:34 Then we look to Big Bear as well, they have currently no housing mitigation requirements in Big Bear.
3:53:40 So, Truckee's is somewhat unique in that a single residential unit is exempt from any housing mitigation.
3:53:49 And then if you're building two to six units, if your developer building, you know, two units a lot up to six units, it's $20,000.
3:54:00 And then once you exceed seven units, they have a requirement that 15% of the development be inclusionary. In this case, the inclusionary is not required to be on-site. It can be on-site or off-site. It has to just be within Truckee or there is an option to pay $136,000 per unit required there.
3:54:25 And so when you kind of do the math backwards, it roughly equates to that $20,527 per unit. So that's roughly where their fee is on a per unit basis is that the $20,527 for residential.
3:54:43 I think the key point on their inclusionary is that it's not a guarantee that you could pay the fee. It's required that you do inclusionary and you have to then request to the city if you want to instead pay an in-lieu fee for that whole development.
3:55:02 It's at the town's sole discretion to then approve that in-lieu fee or an alternate plan, where in our current housing ordinance, everything is essentially established based on what that fee rate would be.
3:55:15 And then whether you pay the fee, build on-site, build off-site, convey land, or do an alternative plan, all that is then just equal to what the fee is.
3:55:24 And so it's slightly different in ours that it's kind of a guarantee that you can pick any option, where in Truckee, it's not necessarily a guarantee if you're doing more units that you can come and just pay an in-lieu fee.
3:55:36 I can tell you that the town of Truckee greatly prefers that people build units rather than paying fees.
3:55:40 So comparing with the same things for non-residential uses, again, the current fees there, the maximum fees from the 2026 study, and then Mono County, they have, for all their non-residential uses, it's just an in-lieu fee structure, whether it's lodging, retail office, industrial, or service.
3:56:08 You'll see those there, they're not overly high fees.
3:56:15 And then again, for FigBerry, there's nothing.
3:56:17 For Truckee, for non-residential, they base everything off of full-time employee equivalents.
3:56:23 So they, for all the different uses, have calculations in their code for how many employees each use would generate based on the project size.
3:56:31 So if you're building a hotel, there's then calculators in their ordinance that say X amount of employees per room times X number of rooms.
3:56:40 That's how many FTEs that project's generating.
3:56:44 In this case, if you're less than seven, the project's just exempt from any affordable requirements.
3:56:50 If your project's generating from seven to 20 full-time employees, the developer has the option just to pay an in-lieu fee.
3:56:59 Again, it uses...
3:57:00 That $136,000 as the base and then that's times the number of FTEs divided by 28 so you're paying a kind of proportional amount of that at $136,000 and then if you're generating 20 to 40 or over 40 you're required to provide a unit for the specified number of full-time employee equivalents and so I think the unique thing about this is that they've
3:57:29 more or less established what the cost of a unit is, in this case it's $136,000 and then that is then kind of mathed backwards into the various requirements or into what those fees could be.
3:57:45 I'm not saying that's the only way to do it or the right way but I think it's just a little bit clearer way of determining what that fee could be.
3:57:53 So again, tonight's item is really just kind of an introduction to the NEXUS study and any discussion.
3:58:01 So in the staff report there were kind of three discussion topics put in the report and so we'll kind of walk through each one and I'll look to council if you prefer we walk through each topic first and discuss it or put all three out there and then discuss.
3:58:20 I guess I think we should just put all three out there and then discuss, what do you guys think?
3:58:27 You tell us where to go and that'll work.
3:58:30 So the three topics were the assumptions used in the study to determine the maximum fees, that's looking at the pro form and development model, employee generation rates, or the cost of subsidizing the one affordable unit.
3:58:49 Um, the second discussion item is any recommendations on the fees, um, so again, I think the, the primary topic is, um, adoption of the 2026 NEXUS studies simply because that brings it out to a current current status for what those maximum fees could be.
3:59:08 Um, however, it's that then council's discretion as to where they, where they set the fees, they could leave the current fee structure in place that was adopted in July of 2026.
3:59:18 Those fees would then be subject to the annual, um, inflationary increases each July, or they can also, um, adopt the, the study and then increase the fees in accordance with the study.
3:59:30 I think separate from the study, town council can also direct staff to review the housing mitigation ordinance and how, um, how it outlines out what the mitigation options are.
3:59:40 Again, like I said, our, our code specifies that all options are created equal, um, whether it's payment of the fee or building units or whatever, and that, um, it's really up to the developer to choose which option, um, they prefer.
3:59:54 And so I think, um, regardless, it's recommended that.
3:59:59 That.
4:00:00 We do bring it back and adopt the study at a minimum as far as what else we do is really at the discretion of the Town Council.
4:00:08 And then the last discussion item was current housing ordinance versus revisiting a strictly inclusionary housing ordinance.
4:00:16 So this kind of builds off of the previous one, like I said, of reviewing that housing ordinance to change the structure of the ordinance and change the structure of how developers can mitigate their impacts to housing.
4:00:33 John?
4:00:34 Yeah, just one, looking at the staff report, one little point of context, page three, item number three, and it talks about prior to 2015, the town had inclusionary housing ordinance required residents, you know, blah, blah, blah.
4:00:48 This was in place in 2009 to 2015, but did not result in the development of any workforce housing units.
4:00:54 So just for my colleagues here, this, the 2015 study was in a very, very different world.
4:01:01 And there was an intention to try to incentivize some development, to try to get some activity going in that arena, and it never happened in any meaningful way.
4:01:10 So I would encourage the discussion to be looking at, as best we can surmise, what does our current environment look like?
4:01:17 What do we need now?
4:01:19 We're obviously seeing plenty of development.
4:01:21 It's not, you know, it's happening, it's coming in the door, and we have an opportunity to kind of step up into that arena.
4:01:30 But I appreciate the citation, what was going on a long time ago.
4:01:35 The fees we're currently got on the books was based on those types of assumptions, but we're in a new world now, is my sense.
4:01:41 Do you have any information about how many workforce housing units have been produced in Truckee with their requirements?
4:01:52 I certainly don't, but I'm sure we could get you that number.
4:01:56 Okay.
4:01:58 Well, may I?
4:02:00 Yeah, go ahead.
4:02:01 Regardless of that, I agree with John, we are in a different world.
4:02:03 I was not on council, but I remember the inclusionary housing being taken out, and I opposed it being taken out then, because we're a town of three square miles.
4:02:14 That's our urban growth boundary, which I disagreed with as well.
4:02:19 But that being said, it's in place, and there's not a lot of land available to build housing on.
4:02:26 So I would love to see us at least look into that inclusionary housing ordinance and what that might look like.
4:02:35 I would agree with that.
4:02:36 Yeah.
4:02:38 I also think that the fees we're currently charging, while I hear complaints about them all the time, are probably set well too low.
4:02:46 They do not produce.
4:02:47 We're still taking, you know, tens of millions out of T.O.T. to pay for housing when part of that obligation needs to be in the business community as well.
4:02:58 I have no idea what those numbers.
4:03:00 There should be, though. I look to staff as the experts to bring us something back. Those are my two takes on this. I did find it interesting that the maximum this NEXUS study says for lodging is less than what the NEXUS study said in 15. I don't know how that can be even possible.
4:03:21 But I just saw that as an anomaly there. But that's where I'm at. If staff is looking for something to bring back, I can't get any more concrete. I have no idea what those numbers should be so that we can stay competitive in the market, yet keep moving forward.
4:03:42 If I could, Madam Mayor, just to build a harp on our favorite topic of conversation. With a changing climate, I think that it actually puts us in a more advantageous position vis-a-vis the community's needs.
4:04:01 Because the people are going to be developing with the expectation that our snow lines are going to be such that we may be the last winter recreation destination in the state.
4:04:11 Well, let's maybe lean into that a little bit and maybe use that as part of how we start putting this together.
4:04:15 I would certainly support giving staff direction to come up with an inclusionary housing policy. If we have to go back to what we had before, let's do that.
4:04:23 I kind of like the fees that are being proposed here at $30, $27, whatever it is. But I think we need to be in the ballgame.
4:04:32 I missed, I didn't understand your $30 comment.
4:04:35 Well, it's $27, it's $27,000.
4:04:38 $27,000, I'm sorry. $27,000.
4:04:40 That's why I didn't get $30.
4:04:41 I'm sorry. I saw a period in there, but I didn't have my glasses on.
4:04:46 Brent.
4:04:46 All right. So I'm going to be anti to the inclusionary housing. I just have lived there. I've been part of inclusionary housing. I can tell you it's not fun.
4:04:57 Particularly if you're in hospitality, somebody knocking at your door at 2 o'clock in the morning and telling you their toilet doesn't work.
4:05:01 Or if something else doesn't work, it's a joy. Particularly if you're there with your wife.
4:05:08 I'm not going to look at it, but I'm not a fan of it because I've lived it.
4:05:12 Going to fees.
4:05:14 You know, the thing is, I look at, same thing with you, Bill.
4:05:18 I was like, really? Some of these are fees when lodging? Okay.
4:05:22 I'm not sure I support all of them going to where they are at, particularly like office and light industrial.
4:05:29 You know, I was doing math. If you take the residential units at the fee we are charging now, someone proposes a hundred unit complex, that's $1.8 million more that somebody's going to pay for at the end.
4:05:42 It may not be good or bad, I just question that. But for some of it, like restaurants, et cetera, going up a significant amount, my question would be is, do they all have to go up at one time?
4:05:54 For instance, let's just say we're at a restaurant or retail.
4:06:00 And we said, okay, it's $5. I didn't even look at the number, but I say it's $5 for two years, and then it goes up after two years. Does it have to go one-time change, or can it be stepped on any amounts?
4:06:12 No, so they can, council has the ability to set the fees, they can revisit them every year, they revisit them every two years, whatever, they just can't exceed what's in the nexus study.
4:06:24 And it's also built into the nexus study that, regardless if council wants to increase those at all, they are going to increase based on the inflationary index each year.
4:06:35 So, for example, in 2015, when the last nexus study was adopted, the recommendation was that they adopt fees, at least for residential and hotel, at roughly 30% of what the maximum were.
4:06:46 And then, for the other uses they adopted, I think it was $2 per square foot.
4:06:52 And in 2019, they increased, the town council increased the fees, most of them they just rounded up to the next whole dollar.
4:07:01 And then from there, they've gone forward with just the inflationary index since then.
4:07:05 So, it's, council has the ability to revisit them, really at any point they want, within that, this cannot exceed those maximums.
4:07:14 Right, so, just so I'm clear, how long is that nexus study good for?
4:07:18 So, if we came back in a year, if we set fee and we came back in a year, do we use that same nexus fee or do we have to do a new nexus study?
4:07:26 The nexus study is good indefinitely.
4:07:27 Indefinitely.
4:07:28 As long as you don't go over the top.
4:07:29 They're recommended to have an eight-year lifespan, but they do not physically expire either.
4:07:33 Yeah, it's just that what happens is if you don't update them, the numbers get more and more out of date.
4:07:37 And so, you end up not collecting as much as you could.
4:07:40 Because part of that 2015 conversation, which I was very involved with, was we were trying to get things to happen in town.
4:07:47 Things have happened.
4:07:48 We need to adjust the fees to reflect what is going on today.
4:07:52 And I'm just concerned about sticker shock for some of the things, but I think we definitely need to be looking at very quickly revising these fees.
4:08:02 May I make a comment on something you said?
4:08:04 Sure.
4:08:04 The inclusionary housing fee, if we can look at that, if they don't want to build it on-site, that they could build them off-site, the same number, providing the land and the units.
4:08:19 That's correct.
4:08:20 That's how a truck uses it.
4:08:21 Yeah, so that's inclusion.
4:08:22 So it doesn't mean they have to build in the hotel.
4:08:25 And let me phrase that.
4:08:27 I'm okay with certain portions of what it was, but mandating.
4:08:30 If someone came forward to us and said, we're going to do inclusionary housing, I have less of an issue of that than us forcing it to happen, but we can look at wording that may be flexible.
4:08:42 Well, I think looking at this report, you know, we had inclusionary housing from 2009 to 2015 when construction plummeted nationwide.
4:08:53 And so to see like, oh, it didn't produce any workforce housing.
4:08:58 And so to see like, oh, it didn't produce any workforce housing.
4:09:00 I don't think that that would be true today, so I would be in favor of exploring inclusionary housing, and I do like the truckie verbiage on there that it could be on-site or off-site, because, like you were saying, Brent, you know, I think some developments would work better, you know, like the Snow Creek development, I think that that works really well to have inclusionary housing on-site, but, you know, like the limelight, I personally would not want to live there, but maybe somebody would,
4:09:29 but, you know, I would be okay with having inclusionary housing on-site or off-site. I think that our fees are really low. I would be interested in looking into inclusionary housing. I don't know what your timeline would be for coming back with something like that. I would be in favor of accepting the study, raising the rates, and looking into inclusionary housing tonight.
4:09:55 Yeah, I think doing it sooner rather than later is a good idea.
4:09:58 Cleland, what are your thoughts?
4:10:00 Well, I, too, have lived in inclusionary housing on-site, and it is not a working model, and I will fight. Whenever someone brings that up off-site, I think that that is a different mindset, but since we are such a small town, I don't think anybody would be able to actually have off-site housing, be an inclusionary.
4:10:28 I'm just kind of racking my brain thinking of where that would go. So I'm amiable to whatever y'all want to do with that, but, yeah, something's got to change. But having your people that are working on you, yeah, that pretty much,
4:10:45 excuse me for saying this, but it just puts you back into the slavery where you're there, and you are on-call, and people are knocking on your door, and if you lose your job, you lose your house, that is something that is not a workable model for anyone, especially in this town.
4:11:04 So I'm glad it's working well for Turkey.
4:11:07 And then I also wanted to bring up, I do know that some communities are basically taking away the easy button, and there is no in lieu fee, it's just build the housing that you're required to build.
4:11:17 And then I just remembered we didn't take public comment on this yet before we started deliberating, so I'd like to pause and take public comment. Anyone want to come up to the podium for public comment?
4:11:28 Thank you so much. Oh, Chris Bupser, community member. So I was just curious about one thing. I wasn't clear from the staff report, and maybe I missed it, because it is late, but whether it was that you can adopt impact fees or inclusionary housing, or you can do both.
4:11:51 So that was just a point of clarification, and thank you for the discussion. I agree with everything you've all said.
4:11:58 Thank you.
4:12:00 Any other public comments from anyone in the room? Anyone online? No. Okay. Well, let's continue our discussion.
4:12:08 So to follow up on your point a little bit and to staff, what is, what are we looking at timing-wise to be moving this stuff forward?
4:12:16 So we could bring the nexus study and, you know, do some further analysis and come up with some rationale for an increase in fees that we think makes sense
4:12:28 as soon as the next council meeting. And then the study on inclusionary, you know, to really do an in-depth analysis of what that might look like, would take some additional time.
4:12:40 I think we can begin working on it and then come up with a timeline, but I don't believe it would be within the next one or two meetings that we'd have an answer on the inclusionary.
4:12:48 Okay. But we could bring back the fees in the study for the next?
4:12:51 The fees in the study can be adopted essentially as soon as the next meeting.
4:12:55 We, you can provide direction that says, let's, you know, at least study what an inclusionary or an updated housing ordinance might look like.
4:13:02 And then that basically directs us to begin working on that process.
4:13:05 Okay. So let me ask a question to the attorney. So when the count, sorry, let's say it comes back to the next meeting and we adopt it.
4:13:15 How does that affect projects that may or may not have applications pending or may be in process? How does all that work?
4:13:23 It kind of depends on the project. There are some projects that are vested, um, as soon as they submitted a complete application, um, but I think other projects, I don't think we treat that way.
4:13:32 That's correct. So, um, generally here you're vested once you've submitted a complete building permit application. Um, if certain projects like Snow Creek 8 that has a, uh, approved development agreement, that's what they're, they'd be subject to because those are vested into the development agreement.
4:13:50 Right. Um, but any other project out there would be subject to when they submit a building permit application.
4:13:55 But that's a standard, this is standard practice. Everybody just has to navigate it when it's done. Yeah. So I would really be in favor of trying to bring this back at the next meeting and let's, and let's see where it gets something on the books. Cause this is 2026.
4:14:08 We're working off of 2015 with a couple of bumps along the way. Yeah, it does have to be a public hearing. So that would be the only, um, hiccup if we don't meet the, any of the requirements for the next meeting.
4:14:21 But regardless, it could be on the next or the second meeting in November, depending just on the, the noticing requirements then.
4:14:28 Okay. And I'm just going to go back cause you, you kind of raised a portion of those assumptions. You know, this is a group of professionals that have done this. So really trying to change anything or even assuming that there'd be a better number or not is, is a whole another process.
4:14:43 We're, we're kind of better working with, okay, here's our study. Let's work with what we've got.
4:14:47 It at least updates it to current numbers and it, it it's adopted.
4:14:53 I think, you know, the fact that all the numbers are, um, at least, you know, some degree.
4:15:00 Mayor Mammoth Unified School District,
4:15:30 at least it creates a new benchmark. I think if the fees were lower than what our current fees are, we'd be having a different conversation, but since they are, they do allow for some movement, I don't see any true negative, at least adopting the current study, regardless of whether we look into a different study or not.
4:15:51 So just a procedural note, the Mitigation Fee Act says that if you're going to adopt a new next study, you have to provide
4:15:59 30 days' notice of a public hearing. So that kicks us out a little bit further if we're doing, we're adopting a new study, as opposed to increasing rates within the confines of the existing study.
4:16:10 So if we use the 2015 rates, we could raise the rates to those higher numbers and not accept the study at this point. Is that correct? Because you said there's no end date for the study?
4:16:21 Right? Nice. Yes.
4:16:26 Lawyer. Is that where we could do that?
4:16:28 Yeah, the study does not get invalidated by the passage of time unless you think that the costs have gone down.
4:16:34 I would support a scenario like that, if that's something technically staff could pull back together.
4:16:38 I kind of disagree with that, because if we get a new study, I think we should follow that process and follow the new study, regardless of portions. I think that's it.
4:16:46 But in what world is 10, 11 years later that the prices have gone down?
4:16:51 Well, but it's only gone down in the one category, right?
4:16:54 I mean, it's gone down in lodging.
4:16:57 Yeah, that's the only one.
4:16:58 Yeah, but we're going from, our current fee is $6,100. The next fee is $8,100. It could be, we adopt a study and move it to-
4:17:07 Yeah, we could, sorry Brett, we could raise that by $2,000 without, and using the current new study.
4:17:15 Yeah.
4:17:16 But there's a 30 day wait for using the current study.
4:17:19 What's that?
4:17:20 There's a 30 day wait to use the current study. You have to have a 30 day notice, is what Andy said.
4:17:24 Yeah.
4:17:25 So you could not accept that study and raise the rate, the same amount under the old study and not be bound by a 30 day wait.
4:17:33 One other little programming note. As of a couple years ago, I was not aware of this, but as of a couple years ago, the law now says that you have to update your studies every eight years.
4:17:45 So never mind. What I told you used to be true, but it's not anymore.
4:17:49 Yeah.
4:17:50 Oh.
4:17:51 So we're out of date anyway.
4:17:53 We're out of compliance.
4:17:54 We're out of compliance because it's 11 years.
4:17:56 So then it's an emergency item then to get us back in compliance is to bring the study back.
4:18:00 I can get it adopted.
4:18:11 So I think we should just expedite, I mean, Andy, I think we're sort of hearing some kind of consensus up here, but just to take it back and figure out how we can expedite this to get us in compliance.
4:18:22 And if the new study will do the trick, let's do the trick and perhaps to bring it back as early as possible.
4:18:30 Okay.
4:18:31 Do this as quick as possible because we're out of compliance.
4:18:32 We just found this out.
4:18:33 But we can, yeah.
4:18:34 But we can accept this NEXUS study now.
4:18:37 And then that starts the 30-day window.
4:18:41 Yeah, when does the clock start?
4:18:44 You have to provide 30 days notice of your intent to adopt a NEXUS study.
4:18:49 So you can't do anything tonight other than tell staff to hurry up.
4:18:52 So December 2nd?
4:18:53 Yeah.
4:18:54 We could accept it.
4:18:56 Hurry up.
4:18:57 Hurry up.
4:18:58 And, yeah, it's going to be a good, interesting agenda.
4:19:05 Well, welcome to the town council.
4:19:07 And by the way, here's the NEXUS study.
4:19:09 Well, can we do that earlier in the night before we re-seed everybody?
4:19:14 I don't see why not.
4:19:15 Okay.
4:19:16 Yeah.
4:19:17 Can we?
4:19:18 Okay, good.
4:19:19 Okay.
4:19:20 Good.
4:19:21 Good.
4:19:23 Okay.
4:19:24 So are we done with item 11.2?
4:19:26 Are we done?
4:19:27 Do you need more direction or anything?
4:19:30 No?
4:19:31 No?
4:19:32 We're good?
4:19:33 Okay.
4:19:34 11.3, waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code
4:19:38 Chapter 8.14, Solid Waste Recycling.
4:19:42 Good evening, council.
4:19:57 It's been a long night, so I'll keep my item brief.
4:20:01 Not Stu brief.
4:20:03 Not Stu brief.
4:20:04 Pam brief.
4:20:05 I'm Pam Koblar, assistant to the town manager, and I also have Emily Zajewski here with me.
4:20:10 She is our sustainability coordinator.
4:20:12 She did all the heavy lifting on this item.
4:20:15 As you're probably aware, California has a law regarding recycling.
4:20:20 That law is called AB 341.
4:20:23 It requires all businesses that produce four cubic yards or more of solid waste each week,
4:20:28 as well as any multi-family residential complex with five or more units to recycle.
4:20:35 In order to implement that law, the town adopted Chapter 8.14 of our Municipal Code.
4:20:42 Essentially, that code chapter requires businesses and multi-family complexes to make efforts to
4:20:50 separate recyclable materials from all other solid waste.
4:20:53 That can be done primarily by two ways.
4:20:56 One is to subscribe to our recycling service with mammoth delivery.
4:21:00 disposal which is our hauler here in town that we have a franchise agreement with or they can
4:21:06 self-haul those recyclables and take them to the transfer station themselves currently we don't
4:21:14 have a really good process in place for our self-hauling so while our municipal code allows that
4:21:18 there are some components of the municipal code that we don't have a program in place for and we
4:21:23 don't have any good way of tracking those businesses or multi-family complexes that are
4:21:28 self-hauling their recyclables as we desire to get a program in place for that we reviewed our
4:21:34 municipal code and kind of came to light that there are some things in there that were contradictory
4:21:38 that didn't really make the program operate the way that we ideally would want it to and so we're
4:21:45 proposing some cleanup to the code to kind of streamline this process the primary thing that
4:21:51 we're doing is that previously or I should say currently in our code self-haul is treated as an
4:21:57 exemption from the recycling requirements but it's not really an exemption it's just a way of
4:22:02 complying with the requirements so we want to change that language from being an exemption to being a
4:22:09 self-hauling agreement that those businesses or complexes would have with the town to self-haul
4:22:15 their recyclables the rest of the proposed changes are really just cleanup that kind of go along with that
4:22:23 change there was some weird language in there about what types of vehicles people had to sell Paul their
4:22:29 recyclables in we took that out we also added one thing that allows for commercial customers to
4:22:38 consolidate their recycling service with a neighboring property under certain conditions so maybe they don't
4:22:44 have room on their property to have recycling bins or there's some other reason that makes sense maybe from an
4:22:51 aesthetic standpoint to not have multiple recycling containers at neighboring properties those types of
4:22:58 requests would come to the town manager and we would approve those on a case-by-case basis just kind of as a side
4:23:04 note that's a change that we're considering making for trash service as well but that is not part of what's being proposed today we're only talking about recycling
4:23:12 recycling it's worth noting that Cal recycle will be auditing our self-hauling program as well as our compliance with all of the various state mandates
4:23:22 we're anticipating that could happen as soon as before the end of this year but it could happen at any time in the future so we really want to get this
4:23:32 program in place prior to that audit from the state to make sure that you know we're not having any non-compliance issues
4:23:39 that's really the basics of what's being proposed today i'm happy to answer any questions emily can answer questions as well so um with that i would
4:23:50 recommend that the council waive the reading and introduced by title only the ordinance amending municipal code chapter 8.14 solid waste recycling
4:24:01 I've got one question.
4:24:02 Okay.
4:24:02 Well, first of all, thanks for waiting four hours and 20 minutes.
4:24:05 But under the 8.14020 where you're saying you want an agreement, how many entities do you think that impacts?
4:24:14 I'm just trying to get a sense of what scale is.
4:24:17 I'm sorry.
4:24:18 I'm just trying to find that section.
4:24:19 Is that the section about combining service?
4:24:22 Yeah.
4:24:22 They're saying that they need a self-haul agreement.
4:24:25 Oh, the self-haul agreement.
4:24:26 Sure.
4:24:26 So I think, you know, anecdotally, I think there's a number, probably dozens of businesses and complexes in town that are self-hauling currently, but we just don't have any way of documenting that.
4:24:36 How are you going to know that?
4:24:38 Well, I think we know that because Mammoth Disposal has a list of all of their commercial customers, and we know which ones of those subscribe to recycling service, and we know which ones that don't.
4:24:51 So all customers subscribe to some level of trash service.
4:24:54 Right.
4:24:54 And recycling service is optional.
4:24:57 So, you know, we can kind of make that assessment of determining which ones are not currently subscribed to service and making the assumption that they're self-hauling.
4:25:05 But without having this agreement in place or any sort of formal program for tracking it, we don't have any way of knowing that those items are actually being recycled.
4:25:14 Right.
4:25:14 And where I was going was it's great.
4:25:16 I think it had a great direction, but only if we can actually do something with it.
4:25:19 Sure.
4:25:20 Because it's great to see it, but then if they aren't doing it, it's tough.
4:25:22 But I just want to make sure we've got a mechanism that we can actually communicate those people and bring it under control.
4:25:27 Sure.
4:25:27 So kind of what we're anticipating to roll out this process once assuming that this code update gets adopted, we have a draft self-hauling agreement already kind of drafted up.
4:25:40 We'll finalize that.
4:25:42 We'll be reaching out to any of the customers who are not currently subscribed to service with kind of an explanation as to what's required, a copy of this agreement.
4:25:51 And then they will have the option of either completing the agreement or subscribing to service.
4:25:56 Okay.
4:25:56 And then moving forward, we'll have a process in place for tracking those.
4:26:02 Because it seems the way I'm seeing it is we kind of really don't have a choice about this to be compliant.
4:26:09 So.
4:26:11 I would agree with that.
4:26:12 Okay.
4:26:12 I think there are different ways that it could be approached, but in our review of what we think is happening now and what we think needs to happen, this is our recommendation for how to best handle that.
4:26:28 Okay.
4:26:29 Are there any other questions or comments?
4:26:32 No questions over here.
4:26:34 Public comment?
4:26:36 Anyone in the room?
4:26:37 Anyone online?
4:26:38 No.
4:26:40 Okay.
4:26:40 Madam Mayor, I would move that the council waive the reading and reduce by title only the ordinance amending municipal code, chapter 8.14, solid waste recycling.
4:26:50 I will second that.
4:26:52 Wrong call please, Jamie.
4:26:53 Council member Souser.
4:26:54 Yes.
4:26:55 Council member Wentworth.
4:26:56 Yes.
4:26:56 Council member Hoff.
4:26:57 Yes.
4:26:58 Mayor Pro Temp-Truex.
4:26:58 Yes.
4:26:59 Mayor Rice.
4:27:00 yes okay um thank you so much thank you for staying late we appreciate you um we are on to
4:27:08 item 11.4 town of mammoth lakes priorities for the fiscal year 2627 in your national forest program
4:27:15 of work welcome lawson hi lawson reef office of outdoor recreation um before you today uh you
4:27:23 have our draft of the request program of work uh for the inyo national forest uh in the staff report
4:27:29 i provided some explanations of each of these although these should all look relatively familiar
4:27:34 being that we have requested these on the program of work each one of these i believe for the past
4:27:39 three years with that in mind this is a request to the inyo national forest i certainly would love to
4:27:47 have any changes that you may have to this in terms of the order or the content of this document but
4:27:55 again this is merely an ask um there is no guarantees that these will be added to the program of work
4:28:01 uh i believe again this is the third consecutive year of these asks uh to the inyo national forest
4:28:08 so i certainly wanted some some council input um on these again either the content
4:28:14 or the order in which we have them listed comments i just have a question um who who would you be
4:28:21 addressing this letter too uh that's a very good question for supervisor position has not been
4:28:26 filled all yet yet um it is being held currently by uh acting forest supervisor stephanie heller who
4:28:32 is the mono lake uh district ranger i have heard rumors they will extend her as they continue to search
4:28:38 for the forest supervisor um but i i think i would leave it as is and just leave it as dear inyo
4:28:43 national forest supervisor or acting forest supervisor along with our local district ranger
4:28:47 district ranger wong is what it correct yeah yes we usually submit this at the supervisor level as
4:28:53 well as the district ranger level okay thank you yeah just uh on your one to five you're listing
4:29:00 those in priority i kind of read it as this is our our overall list but you're saying this is a
4:29:06 priority list yeah the way the way we designed it um obviously all of these are important to us
4:29:12 um but yeah these are listed in in a priority so if that's the case my my questions around the snow
4:29:18 pit they'll actually communicate with us because while it's a priority will we actually get any
4:29:22 traction uh i have recently heard suggesting there might be a flip there yeah so currently we are
4:29:29 working uh with the lahont water district who we honestly should have been working with prior uh to
4:29:35 determine the environment environmental impact on that site i've been speaking directly with some
4:29:41 representatives at lahontan i think we do have a plan forward um i think initially the forest service
4:29:47 was hesitant to defer to the water board uh for this but the water board is the one who makes these
4:29:52 decisions um so we are currently working with them and i think we do have a a decent plan moving forward
4:29:58 to actually get some results
4:30:00 I just know we've been on that discussion for a long time and I'm not I've seen a little different vision on it, but I hope it can move some worse I'm just saying that tactically I think it's a very good idea to be bringing a little hot into this I agree that we just meant is are we going to get enough traction to get something this winter we'll see if anybody answers I mean it's been three years
4:30:18 I agree that we just meant is are we going to get enough traction to get something this winter we'll see if anybody answers I mean it's been three years
4:30:29 I mean it's been three years that's right that's my point we're asking because we are doing some other stuff that is moving there any other questions regardless of what we see as our priorities they're going to cherry pick what they want to do oh that's what and that's why I was just suggesting yeah any other questions public comment online anyone no
4:30:57 okay um I'm prepared to make a motion all right I would move that the town council review and approve the town of mammoth lakes to ml priorities for the fiscal year fiscal year FY 2627 in your national forest program of work I'll second that roll call please Jamie council member Souser yes council member Wentworth yes council member Hopp yes mayor pro tem truex yes yes yes okay we are on to council member reports
4:31:25 uh bill can we start with you um we can so I believe you've already probably all heard the league of california city stories
4:31:33 we attended that we attended that after our uh last meeting so I just wanted to say that we did and you survived and we
4:31:43 everybody everybody came back wasn't it a scooter accident a couple years ago a couple years ago it was a scooter accident this year somebody else went to the hospital
4:31:51 uh it's a dangerous meeting um last night of course I attended the candidate tonight uh I want to thank the rotary for putting that on very informational um and I believe that's going to be online for those of you out there and the one that the chamber had is online I encourage all the voters to go and look
4:32:13 so they can actually make educated decisions that's it all right thank you Brent uh uh that same meeting and uh
4:32:23 uh it's actually it's interesting because it's about building relationships and some of those I've been
4:32:29 building afterwards even meeting different people at the conference some of the stuff has just been
4:32:34 communication afterwards because you realize everybody faces a lot of the same challenges in california
4:32:39 and you're all trying to talk the same thing um I also had ltc's meeting um nothing to really report
4:32:45 there but it is interesting that uh got approval for how many buses is it rob i'm sorry how many buses were
4:32:52 approved 18 18 18 buses so new buses for um estep oh good
4:33:00 Um, attended several, uh, celebrations of life, unfortunately. It just seems to not be a good year. Uh, went to a couple candidate forums, attended the LA Kings Home Opener, and I, just because we talked about housing, I found a very interesting thing that happened in the county. Someone has built an ADU, but they have no house.
4:33:21 All right. So they've managed to get approval for an ADU, even though they haven't even started any construction on the house.
4:33:31 Well, that's, I like to meet, I like to meet these people. It's, it's technically classified as an ADU, because I did research on it, and I was like, wow, okay, and there's no house. No building next to it at all.
4:33:43 And Cleland? Correction, that's nine buses. Nine buses, okay. Thank you.
4:33:47 Sounds like a lot. 18 did seem like a lot of money. Yeah.
4:33:51 Um, let's see, I volunteered for the Moth Ballet that was performed graciously with the space that we have across the street. Um, that was a really interesting new type of art that I just haven't been exposed to, so that was wonderful. Um, on, we have had a lot of celebrations of life,
4:34:19 and we did lose this last week, Bob Salima, uh, long-time caretaker for Reds Meadow Resort, uh, stonemason, rider.
4:34:30 Uh, I did go down and visit him in the care center and, uh, gave him a little bit of Mammoth Lake's love to send him on his way.
4:34:38 Uh, there is Frankenstein play going on that I highly recommend.
4:34:43 Everybody going to see Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday, this next week.
4:34:48 Uh, that was a wonderful time, and I did attend last night's, uh, rotary, uh, forum, which was, uh, really nice. Um, I just forgot my, uh, tape to put over my mouth, so.
4:35:04 All right. I was definitely heard. That's it. John? Um, the ESCOG is going through a strategic planning process that's coming out of Jobs First, so the embers of Jobs First still kind of linger on.
4:35:17 We've got a couple special meetings coming up, I think, on the 30th and something else to try to wrap that up. Um, Eastern Sierra Community Foundation, uh, there was a meeting for that.
4:35:28 They've also just announced that, I think the Eastern, uh, Eastern Sierra Fund has now changed its, officially changed its name to the Eastern Community Foundation, which was part of that whole transition process.
4:35:42 So things are starting to, you know, some of the shoes are starting to kind of get on, on, get the, get on the various feet.
4:35:48 Uh, I attended with the mayor of the John Muir Trail, uh, ribbon cutting.
4:35:51 Oh, yeah. Thanks, I forgot. I did that.
4:35:53 Yeah, that was fun. That was a nice day down in Ritz Meadow.
4:35:56 I attended that first candidate forum. I'll look forward to checking out.
4:36:00 The second one online, I attended the Nevada County Sustainability Summit, interesting conversations around like how is, how is climate and technology and leadership going to affect recreation economies across the Sierra.
4:36:14 This is pretty interesting. Here's some ideas up there. Yesterday, I think it was, I was at the Resilient California Climate Summit. I led a panel down there about climate work going on in California.
4:36:24 We're going to be back down there on Friday. If, if, and when we ever want to start getting into how are we going to navigate climate change in Mammoth Lakes, California is the place to be.
4:36:32 There's all kinds of information, research out there. There's, I was on a panel with some folks from UC San Diego of actually looking at recreation and tourism and how, how we're going to navigate all that stuff.
4:36:42 So that was interesting. The Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board meeting today, the destination management plan is on the agenda for the 4th of November.
4:36:49 So looking forward to that, looking forward to what you'll think about that. There's a new restaurant rep, Nicole Helm, I believe is her name.
4:36:57 She's now going to be the, the rep for the restaurant association. Slocum's has been sold or has been bought locally. And there's going to be some sales this weekend from eight to two of items.
4:37:10 Bill, there might be a, there might be a little, little Chotsky in there that you might want to take home.
4:37:14 You got it.
4:37:15 Yeah.
4:37:15 Okay.
4:37:16 I've got an ashtray in there that I'm going to go pick that I had a relationship with. I'll deal with that.
4:37:21 John Morris announced his retirement. He's retiring from Snow Creek. And so he's retiring from the MOT board. He's put, he's one of the last originals when, when MOT was set up back in 2008, whatever that was.
4:37:33 So that was a sad, but, uh, interesting moment. Ski areas advising November 13th is opening day. We'll see if they get there. Um, night of lights is on the 12th. Uh, there's some free skiing for kids up at the ski area.
4:37:46 Hopefully they're trying to, um, you know, spawn up a new audience of avid skiers. Ski is wrapping up their capital projects. Uh, and they're working on a new restaurant in the Weston to be called Apricity, which is an English word for the feeling of sunlight during the winter months. Uh, they're remodeling the restaurant up at the Weston and that will be coming on board. Um, bunch of things coming up down the road, but I'll leave it right there.
4:38:10 Well, that was very thorough. Yeah. Thank you. I did forget one thing. Um, I did attend on the 17th, uh, at the mammoth waste, um, disposal. They had the E waste waste. Yeah. I got the E waste. Yeah. The E waste. And, uh, actually learned a lot about what I could and couldn't throw away. So it was, that was a good time as well. Okay. Um, well, I went to the Eastern Sierra community housing board. I know that's not one of our boards anymore, but I went to the board meeting there and
4:38:40 Um, we are trying to recruit some more board members. Um, and I went to the candidate forum last night, put on by the Rotary club and to the JMT conservancy. I'm kind of, I'm blanking on what I did. I ran in the Husky pup fun run today.
4:38:59 Ha ha ha.
4:39:00 like 16 laps yeah um so yeah i'll keep it short and brief um that's it for me for council member
4:39:07 reports uh requests for future agenda items rob are we doing a ribbon cutting for the kingfisher
4:39:14 if they're leasing it up are we doing the ribbon cutting we went left
4:39:22 okay and for the muck we're doing a ribbon cutting all right i'm really excited about
4:39:37 using that okay so like before the council meeting correct okay great right yeah i think on the king
4:39:47 fisher we can definitely look into it i don't know that we'll have as grand of a celebration as last
4:39:52 time but um we can work with pacific on what they'd like to do and see as well and put something
4:39:58 together once once we know the date okay great thank you any other requests for future agenda items
4:40:10 just as we talked about with the next study when as soon as possible and and just craft that agenda
4:40:16 for december 2nd okay any other any other future agenda items no okay and we are going to adjourn
4:40:27 this meeting to our regular meeting to be held on wednesday november 4th 2026 at 4 pm thank you all
4:40:34 thank you all very much thank you