TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2026

Town Council

at 15:15

HousingTransit and MobilityBudget and Capital ImprovementsTourism and TOTPublic Safety and PoliceLicense Plate Readers (Flock)Downtown and Main StreetElections and GovernanceShort-Term RentalsAirport and Air ServiceParks and RecreationTrailsMeasure R and Measure UPlanning and ZoningSnow Operations and WildfireWater and UtilitiesRegional (ESCOG, Mono County)

Agenda

14 items · 23 attachments
  1. 1 RIBBON CUTTING CEREMONY
  2. 1.1

    At 3:15 p.m. the Town Council will participate in a ribbon cutting ceremony for completion of the Minaret Multi-Use Path (MUP) to be held at the corner of Main Street and Minaret.

    Downtown and Main Street

  3. 2 CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
  4. 3 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
  5. 4 PUBLIC COMMENTS
  6. 5 ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA
  7. 6 INTRODUCTIONS
  8. 6.1

    Introduce new Fleet Manager Larry Boardman.

  9. 6.2

    Introduce Police Officer Timothy Gordon.

    Public Safety and Police

  10. 6.3

    Introduce Police Officer Nicholas Howe.

    Public Safety and Police

  11. 7 REPORTS FROM COMMISSIONS AND/OR DEPARTMENTS (AS NEEDED)
  12. 8 CONSENT AGENDA
  13. 8.1

    Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of October 21, 2026.

  14. 8.2

    Waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 8.14 Solid Waste Management.

    Elections and Governance

  15. 8.4

    Accept Check Register 10/15/26 in the amount of $1,875,707.63. Accept Check Register 10/22/26 in the amount of $1,607,533.96. Accept Check Register 10/29/26 in the amount of $809,128.89.

  16. 9 POLICY MATTERS
  17. 9.1

    Appeal of TOT/TBID penalties and interest for William Larwood.

    Tourism and TOT

  18. 9.2

    Discussion and decision on use of Flock – automated license plate reader (ALPR) within the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

    License Plate Readers (Flock)

  19. 9.4

    Discuss the Mammoth Crossing Development Agreement application.

  20. 9.6

    Town Council discussion and decision on use of Town reserves generated from political commitments to Tourism, Housing, and Transit.

    HousingTransit and MobilityBudget and Capital Improvements

  21. 10 COUNCILMEMBER REPORTS
  22. 11 REQUESTS FOR FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
  23. 12 ADJOURNMENT

Notable from this meeting

8 findings

Transcript

3078 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:36 I'm just waiting until 4 o'clock. Let's see. We have two more minutes.

1:13 Okay, we're going to go to the Mountain this weekend? We're going to go up to the Mountain this weekend?

1:17 They're opening Friday.

1:23 How is it opening Friday?

1:24 Mountain Mountain. No, is it tomorrow? Thursday.

1:26 They're opening Thursday.

1:27 Tomorrow. I don't know if it is.

1:29 My nephew is coming in from the Bay, but I'm not here in Sacramento.

1:33 Okay.

1:34 So that he can get the first ride.

1:37 That's exciting.

1:40 Bill?

1:41 Big storm next week?

1:44 Ended next week?

1:45 Really?

1:47 It's coming for my birthday.

1:48 Are you a Scorpio?

1:51 Yeah, I am a Scorpio.

1:52 What day is your birthday?

1:53 The 19th.

1:54 Oh, okay.

1:54 Ryan's birthday is November 18th.

1:56 Oh, okay.

1:57 Yeah.

1:57 Oh, so we'll have one more meeting and we can wish you happy birthday.

2:00 Yeah, the day after my next meeting.

2:04 My sisters and I were all in November.

2:06 Oh, my darn.

2:07 November 7th, 10th, and 19th.

2:09 My parents have four kids and had a spring, summer, fall, and a winter baby.

2:14 Oh.

2:15 And I just didn't realize it until I just said that to you right now.

2:20 Do you share the birthday with any of your siblings?

2:23 We usually would separate them, like, separately.

2:25 No, but does your birth date fall on the same?

2:29 No, there's the 7th and the 10th.

2:31 Oh, I have the 17th.

2:35 All right.

2:36 That's a lot about your parents.

2:37 Valentine's Day.

2:39 All right.

2:40 It's 4 o'clock.

2:41 We are going to call this meeting to order.

2:43 Roll call, please.

2:44 Jamie?

2:44 Council Member Souser?

2:47 Yes.

2:47 Council Member Whitworth?

2:49 Yes.

2:50 Council Member Hough?

2:51 Present.

2:51 Mayor Pro Temp-Truex?

2:53 Here.

2:53 Mayor Rice?

2:54 Here.

2:54 And Cleland Hough is going to lead us on the Pledge of Allegiance this evening.

2:57 I say, ready to go?

2:59 Ready to go.

3:00 Okay.

3:01 Ready?

3:01 Begin.

3:02 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for

3:09 which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

3:15 Okay.

3:22 We are on to item four, public comment.

3:24 If any member of the public has wishes to address the town council on matters that are

3:30 not otherwise on the agenda, please come up to the podium now or you can raise your hand

3:34 in Zoom.

3:41 Hello.

3:41 I'm back.

3:43 Hi.

3:45 I just want to say thank you to town council members who have advocated for the unhoused

3:50 workforce and to those that have been on town staff working on our parking program.

3:56 I'm looking forward to hearing what plans are going to be made tonight.

4:00 In order for this program to run effectively, I believe there needs to be opportunities for

4:04 open communication, feedback, and input as those of us living in our vehicles best understand

4:10 the needs of our community.

4:11 I received an email at 7 p.m. last night that this was on the agenda.

4:15 Fortunately, I was free to come and listen, but most could not make it because they didn't

4:19 have adequate time to ask off of work and prepare.

4:22 Since September 9th, I've made several attempts to connect and communicate.

4:26 Proactively, while in advance, hoping to be part of the conversation before decisions or

4:30 discussions reach the agenda.

4:32 As this is a new program, I believe our input would be very helpful.

4:36 And as adjustments may need to be made to ensure safety, I would greatly appreciate

4:40 more proactive communication in the future, earlier notice of upcoming discussions, and

4:45 an opportunity for many other unhoused workforce folks to participate in these conversations

4:50 before items are brought forward.

4:52 As community members, we do want to be involved, we do care, and we do want to be involved in

4:58 the future of our town, and we hope these opportunities are extended to us in the future.

5:02 Thank you, and I'm looking forward to hearing the plan.

5:05 Fortunately, I have to run, so I'll be watching the rest on Zoom tonight, but I just wanted

5:08 to say a big thank you to all for working on this.

5:10 Thank you, and just to be clear, this is for public comments for something that's not on

5:15 the agenda this evening.

5:16 Oh.

5:17 Yeah, I mean, you said I let you go.

5:19 Oh, sorry.

5:19 You can't stay, so thank you for your comments, but it is for things that are not on the agenda,

5:23 so is there anyone online that has a public comment?

5:30 With the number ending in 7-2, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

5:46 It doesn't say their names, so.

5:47 Hello, downtown, this is Misha Little Bear Bateman.

5:49 Can you hear me okay?

5:50 Yes, we can hear you.

5:53 Hey, I just wanted to wish you all a good evening, and I wanted to bring up a non-agenda item.

6:02 I noticed in the newspaper a notice of a public hearing.

6:07 I just wanted to make y'all aware that we are paying attention, and we would like to see

6:13 low-income housing and multifamily residential low-income housing be priority.

6:20 We don't want to see the redesignation of interlating condominium parcels into commercial lodging,

6:27 so I just wanted to make y'all aware that we are paying attention, and we will be showing

6:33 up on November 10th, 2026, just to make sure that we can keep our employees and our low-income

6:41 families here and our locals taken care of and housed, and it's a high priority to make

6:47 sure that we take care of our community in that way.

6:51 So, thank you so much for your time and for your attention to this matter, and that is

6:55 all for right now.

6:56 Thank you.

6:57 Thank you.

6:58 Any other public comments from anyone in the room for anything that's not currently on

7:02 the agenda for this evening?

7:03 Can I ask a quick question?

7:04 Yeah.

7:05 The woman referenced November 10th.

7:06 Do you know what meeting that would be?

7:08 Is that planning commission, or?

7:09 I'm not sure what she's talking about.

7:10 Okay.

7:11 This is not a council meeting, so just thank you.

7:13 Yeah.

7:14 I'm not sure what she's talking about.

7:15 Okay.

7:16 Anyone else online?

7:18 No.

7:19 No.

7:20 Okay.

7:21 Okay.

7:22 We are going to move on to item five, additions to the agenda.

7:26 Rob, are there any additions this evening?

7:28 No, Madam Mayor.

7:29 There are no modifications to the agenda this evening.

7:31 Thank you.

7:32 Okay.

7:33 We are on to item six, introduction.

7:34 6.1.

7:35 Introduce new fleet manager, Larry Boardman.

7:37 Good afternoon, Council.

7:43 Hays and Pays, Director of Public Works.

7:44 I have the pleasure of introducing Larry Boardman as our new fleet manager.

7:49 The Public Works Fleet Department provides important services to the town and its partners.

7:55 The fleet is responsible for maintaining Town of Mammoth Lakes loaders, blowers, plows,

8:00 administrative vehicles, as well as vehicles for Mammoth United School District, Round Valley

8:06 Schools, Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, and our

8:12 ESTA buses.

8:13 Provided critical services for many partners.

8:15 They also have the pleasure of running plow trucks, 12 hours a shift, seven days a week

8:21 throughout storms and snowstorms.

8:23 Larry comes to us from Caterpillar.

8:25 He says he's always wanted to live here and he got that opportunity in 2024.

8:29 He worked as a CAT resident tech.

8:32 We all knew Larry from his work on town vehicles and it's a pleasure to bring him on board as

8:37 a permanent member of our staff.

8:39 Larry, do you have any words to say?

8:41 I'll be real quick, but it's an honor to have worked for the town of Mammoth Lakes.

8:45 Yeah, like you said, it's always been a goal to live here, so I'm living my dream now and

8:50 to work for the town is just icing on the cake.

8:54 I'll only share one more observation.

8:57 There's so much work that goes on and the dedication of all of the town employees and

9:03 everything, it just blows my mind.

9:05 So I'm tasked with living up to that.

9:09 But thank you very much.

9:11 Thank you so much.

9:12 Thank you so much.

9:19 I think I've seen you in the pre-dawn hours.

9:24 Congratulations.

9:27 Okay.

9:30 And so now we're moving on to item 6.2, introduce police officer Tim Gordon.

9:35 Good evening, counsel Dan Kasabian, chief of police.

9:45 Tonight we're going to introduce Tim Gordon.

9:47 Tim comes from LAPD, has come up here throughout his entire life.

9:54 So when I talked to him initially, he's like, hey, look, I've come up here my entire life.

9:59 I love to hike, I love to fish, came up with my family.

10:02 So this is kind of a dream job for him.

10:04 I'm going to go through a little bit here on what he did with LAPD and his experience is invaluable.

10:10 So I'll go through this real quick.

10:12 So during his career he worked patrol LAPD.

10:15 The SPU unit was just a special problems unit which conducted crime suppression along the metro transit system in LA.

10:22 Prostitution enforcement detail which dealt with prostitution related crimes and undercover advice which also dealt with prostitution, human trafficking of adults and minors, illegal gambling, illegal casinos, liquor, ABC and tobacco violations.

10:38 So with that experience, with his experience he brings, it's going to be huge for the organization.

10:45 We're happy to have him and I'm going to let him say a few words.

10:48 Council, sorry for my back being toward you guys, but I really appreciate the chance to be able to become part of the team.

10:59 You know, on the way into town there's a sign that says, coming home is coming to the mountains and truly, you know, it feels like coming home.

11:08 Everyone I've interacted with, citizens, people I work with have been nothing but, you know, helpful, very accommodating and just very warm and friendly.

11:19 So I appreciate it.

11:20 If I ever run into any of you guys out in the streets, pleasure to meet you now.

11:25 Thank you guys so much.

11:29 I'm so happy to have you.

11:41 Welcome.

11:42 Welcome.

11:43 Why is his uniform?

11:44 Yeah, you know, Chief, his uniform looks really crisp.

11:47 Yeah, it does.

11:48 It does.

11:50 It does.

11:51 There's nothing at risk.

11:52 Go ahead.

11:53 Okay, thank you.

11:56 So we're going to move on to item 6.3, introduce police officer Nick Howell.

12:01 Good evening, Council Dan Kasabian again.

12:08 Introducing Nick Howell.

12:10 Nick's got seven years experience.

12:12 He comes to us from Riverside County, which is an area that I came from, so I know kind of what he dealt with back there.

12:21 So he started his career with CHP.

12:23 He worked CHP for about seven years, serving in Los Angeles as a DRE, which is Drug Recognition Expert, which is also some training experience that we don't have up here that he is able to bring up here.

12:39 He was also an FTO and advanced officer safety instructor.

12:44 When he went to Riverside, he spent two years in Riverside as a deputy sheriff out of Lake Elsinore Station, which is a pretty tough station to work.

12:50 We are definitely happy to have him and his experience is huge.

12:54 He has a bachelor's degree in criminal justice.

12:58 Some hobbies of his is one is working out if you can't tell, and the other is spending time outdoors.

13:04 Favorite TV show is The Office.

13:06 He loves Parks and Rec.

13:10 He loves Parks and Rec, yeah.

13:13 And one kind of funny thing about him is this man absolutely hates cheese.

13:19 So, so.

13:22 There you go.

13:23 Here he is.

13:24 Go ahead.

13:26 Counsel, thank you guys for bringing me along.

13:30 I am super blessed and excited to enhance the community that you guys have already made what it is.

13:35 And, um.

13:37 Is this the public right now?

13:39 I look forward to meeting each of you on the best terms as possible.

13:44 And, um.

13:45 Yeah.

13:46 I'm just super excited to be here.

13:47 So, thank you.

13:48 Welcome.

13:56 There are 5,000 people watching online.

13:57 Oh, perfect.

13:58 Yeah.

13:59 So excited to have you.

14:00 I know the cheese is good for you.

14:03 I hear that.

14:04 Oh, good.

14:05 Just a second.

14:06 We'll start walking.

14:07 Cheese.

14:08 Yeah.

14:09 Okay.

14:10 Um.

14:11 So, we're on to item seven.

14:14 Reports from commissions and or departments as needed.

14:22 Any reports?

14:23 Stu, are you rushing the podium?

14:24 No?

14:25 Thank you.

14:26 Okay.

14:27 Okay.

14:28 Well, we will move on to the consent agenda.

14:30 Item 8.1.

14:31 Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of October 21st, 2026.

14:35 Item 8.2.

14:36 Waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 8.14,

14:42 Solid Waste Management.

14:43 Item 8.3.

14:44 Approve the resolution terminating airport emergency contract work.

14:48 Item 8.4.

14:49 Accept check register 10-15-26 in the amount of $1,875,707.63.

14:57 Accept check register 10-22-26 in the amount of $1,607,533.96.

15:06 Accept check register 10-29-26 in the amount of $809,128.89.

15:13 Would anyone like to pull anything?

15:15 No?

15:16 I would entertain a motion.

15:18 Move to approve as presented.

15:20 Second.

15:21 Roll call please, Jamie.

15:22 Council Member Souser?

15:23 Yes.

15:24 Council Member Wentworth?

15:25 Yes.

15:26 Council Member Hough?

15:27 Yes.

15:28 Mayor Pro Tem Truex?

15:29 Yes.

15:30 Mayor Rice?

15:31 Yes.

15:32 We are on to Item Number 9, Policy Matters.

15:33 Item 9.1, Appeal of TOT T-Bid Penalties for Interest for William Larwood.

15:38 Thank you, Mayor Rice.

15:40 I will be taking this item tonight.

15:42 Mr. Larwood, if you're in the audience, please come on up to the podium.

15:47 If not, then we'll work through that.

15:51 So, Ben Manning, our revenue accountant, is on vacation likely tonight, so you're going

15:56 to get to hear from me with regard to this particular agenda item.

16:01 Jamie, is Mr. Larwood perhaps online or do we have any indication of that?

16:06 Okay.

16:07 Should we ask him if you're online to raise your hand?

16:10 I did.

16:11 You did.

16:12 Okay.

16:13 All right.

16:14 Thank you, Jamie.

16:15 We'll go ahead and go through this.

16:16 Essentially what, and I will go through it in a little bit of detail, and what happened

16:24 in this particular case, you know, the town requires every operator to file a tax return,

16:30 whether there's activity or not.

16:32 And so, when there's a missing tax return, we'll send notification to the operator saying,

16:37 you know, please file your return.

16:38 Please make payment of your collected taxes.

16:41 Because what happens is people sometimes close their business, right?

16:45 And they just go silent and they go away.

16:47 So, after three months of doing that and again sending notification, the town initiates a process

16:53 by which we close the account.

16:54 It just keeps things clean.

16:56 In this particular case, we sent those notifications monthly to Mr. Larwood, letting him know that

17:03 this was due and to please make payment.

17:06 After the third month, the town initiated a process to close the account.

17:10 This process includes sending a notice of intent to close, providing 15 days to respond, and

17:17 then executing on that closure.

17:19 In this particular case, Mr. Larwood was given 21 days from the issuance of the notice

17:24 before the close of the account was closed.

17:27 The day after the account was closed, Mr. Larwood contacted our revenue team and indicated that

17:35 he had some information to provide us.

17:38 And at that point in time, the account was closed.

17:41 It's sort of an enforcement process that we're going through.

17:44 In this particular case, Mr. Larwood had outstanding amounts from February, March, and April of 2026.

17:53 When I say an enforcement case was started, that means we're going back, you know, like three years' review of audit of their activity and provided that.

18:02 So on June 24th, an enforcement case was opened due to Mr. Larwood's actively advertising the Airbnb for a closed business.

18:11 Mr. Larwood was notified via email and provided information to us on June 20, the same day, 224th.

18:19 Mr. Larwood emailed town staff with revenue records from June of 2023 through July of 2026.

18:26 Staff sent a first and second notice of determination to Mr. Larwood.

18:30 So a notice of determination is something that we prepare that outlines all of the rental activity, calculates the penalties and interest associated with that,

18:39 and if there's any citations that are also due.

18:42 In this particular case, there were no citations issued because Mr. Larwood was very responsive from the time the enforcement case started.

18:51 In that case, I think there was a desire to hurry up and get this process completed.

18:57 Staff made a mistake right out of the gate with the first notice of determination because when someone sends us a list of,

19:05 here's your total receipts for the calculation, we consider that to include a portion of tax,

19:10 and we take the tax portion off, therefore reducing the gross transaction so that we're not charging tax upon tax, right?

19:17 So that's a standard process.

19:19 In this particular case, the numbers Mr. Larwood had provided us were just the revenue.

19:25 So he corrected that, and we sent a second notice of determination with that correction.

19:30 Throughout this process, I think Mr. Larwood had been requesting, you know, what else can we do to make this number lower, if you will, through the process.

19:42 There's one other aspect that the town engaged in, which was we look at accounting errors.

19:49 And again, this is not necessarily an error, but it's different in accounting practices.

19:53 The town uses departure date as the date of the transaction, and sometimes operators use the arrival date as the date of the transaction.

20:02 So at the close of the month, you can have some discrepancies in the numbers the way we calculate them.

20:07 So we went through that process, further reducing the amount that was owed by Mr. Larwood.

20:12 And so we kind of did everything we could to sort of get it down to the numbers that were appropriate.

20:18 In this particular incident, the actual revenue was $62,949.

20:26 The amount reported was $46,483.

20:30 So we had unreported revenue of $16,465.

20:35 Of that, we had TBID and TOT due of $2583.

20:39 Penalties in interest of $1,812.

20:42 An enforcement charge of $500.

20:44 Total charge is $4,896.

20:47 So as we went through that process, there were a couple of dates in which Mr. Larwood had overpaid, for unknown reasons, overpaid TOT.

21:00 And based on the interaction of sort of us scrunching down those connected months, his request was,

21:05 well, can you take an overpayment that I have above, maybe a couple of months prior, and apply it to an underpayment that was made, therefore reducing my TOT.

21:14 That's not a practice that the town has done.

21:17 It effectively would mean we're paying penalties and interest on the overpayments as we are allowing that to be netted down.

21:23 So we disallowed that, which is pretty much our standard practice.

21:28 In this particular case, if those were included, the differences in P&I would be $122.95.

21:36 That is the request of Mr. Larwood is to have this P&I reduced by $122.95.

21:43 That we find that that does not consistent with the practices of the town's enforcement because we have not made those connections before.

21:51 So if Mr. Larwood has arrived in the room.

21:56 Okay.

21:58 Or online, if we don't have anything.

22:00 Okay.

22:01 So we don't have any.

22:02 At this time, typically, I would invite him up to the podium to provide his side of the story and any comments that he would like to make and any requests of counsel.

22:10 I think we're at questions from us to you.

22:12 You are at questions now from me, yes.

22:13 Questions from the town council and the town staff.

22:15 Anyone have any questions?

22:16 No.

22:17 Just one question, Rob.

22:18 So when someone overpays, do we typically then just pay them back money?

22:21 Yeah.

22:22 So we definitely, they got credit for the overpayment.

22:25 We just don't calculate penalties and interest against that or therefore net it down to reduce those in later amounts.

22:30 But yes, we give them credit for that.

22:32 Okay.

22:33 Any other questions for staff?

22:35 I'm assuming if an appellant doesn't show up for their hearing, then we can still proceed.

22:40 Yeah.

22:41 Go ahead.

22:42 Right.

22:43 The hearing continues and they just essentially have given up their right to make any arguments regarding their case.

22:48 Great.

22:49 Thank you.

22:50 Any other questions for staff?

22:51 Well, the actual issue here is a hundred.

22:53 Turn your microphone on, Bill.

22:54 Is it a question?

22:55 No.

22:56 Is it a question or a comment?

22:57 Because comments come later.

22:58 I have a question.

22:59 So what he's really asking for is just forgiveness of $122.

23:01 $122.95, yes.

23:04 Yeah.

23:05 Okay.

23:06 Any other questions?

23:07 No.

23:08 So we're on opportunity for the property owner to address the town council and William Larwood,

23:13 it appears that he is not in the room or online.

23:17 No.

23:18 Okay.

23:19 Questions from the town council to the property owner?

23:22 None.

23:23 Nobody has one.

23:24 Are there any public comments from anyone in the room or anyone online on this?

23:27 No.

23:28 Seeing none, come up to the podium if you do have a public comment.

23:34 Now we're on to deliberation.

23:37 Madam Mayor, prepare to make a motion.

23:40 Anybody want to say anything first?

23:42 No?

23:43 Okay.

23:44 I would move that the town council make a finding of noncompliance that the town of Mammoth

23:47 Lake's Municipal Code uphold the Notice of Determination, NOD, total of $4,896.43 for Mr.

23:54 Larwood, including penalties and interest in the amount of $1,812.69 accrued by Mr. Larwood

24:01 for the nonremainance of $16,465.84 in gross income and earned in the July 2023 through July

24:10 2026 period.

24:11 I'll second that.

24:12 Roll call please, Jamie.

24:13 Council Member Souser?

24:14 Yes.

24:15 Council Member Wentworth?

24:16 Yes.

24:17 Council Member Hough?

24:18 Yes.

24:19 Mayor Rice.

24:20 Mayor Rice.

24:21 Yes.

24:22 Okay.

24:23 Thank you.

24:24 So we are on to Item 9.2.

24:25 Discussion and Decision on Use of Flock Automated License Plate Reader ALPR within the town of

24:30 Mammoth Lakes.

24:31 Thank you, Mayor Rice.

24:32 I'll kick this off and then I think we've got some elements to add to that from Chief

24:38 and Sergeant Hanson.

24:41 So as you remember, last council meeting we had a pretty lengthy discussion that talked

24:47 about the highlight of the last couple of years or some of the inception of the use of

24:53 Flock.

24:54 The sort of, I'll say, missteps with regard to application of what we expected within the

25:01 contract and the sort of lack of trust that we had for the ability of the system to, or

25:08 the integrity of the system.

25:10 You know, we've talked to Flock quite a bit through that process.

25:14 They're obviously a technology provider to the town.

25:18 We as staff don't have the ability to confirm what goes on behind the scenes in any electronic

25:24 systems that we really have.

25:26 I think that what we wanted to do here, since that was a staff presentation and did not allow

25:32 council to make any action on that discussion, is we brought back this particular conversation

25:39 tonight is a policy item which allows you to provide us feedback on direction and what

25:44 you want us to do with that system.

25:46 What I do want to do is spend some time talking about the value of the system because that is

25:53 in opposition to the challenges and concerns that we have with it.

25:57 I think that we've had actually, even within the last two weeks, a really strong demonstration

26:04 of the value of the system, that it has proven to be sort of the sole source of information

26:11 in certain cases that we've had within town.

26:13 I'll let Chief talk a little bit about that.

26:16 But the concerns with the quality of the provider and flock itself remains as a point of concern

26:26 for staff, right?

26:27 We talked about all the missteps.

26:29 I won't go through all those in quite detail as I did last time.

26:32 But they still remain.

26:33 And conversations that we've had with them haven't really sort of cleared those up, if

26:38 you will, for me anyway.

26:41 And so I'd like to turn it over to Chief and kind of go through some of the positive aspects

26:45 of it.

26:46 And we can go from there.

26:48 Good evening, Council.

26:49 Dan Kasabian, Chief of Police.

26:51 I'm going to go through some of our success stories.

26:55 But before that, I've had some questions.

26:57 And I just kind of want to clarify some of the questions that I've had.

27:02 The cameras that we have, the Falcon cameras, the ALPR cameras that we have are not live.

27:09 You cannot monitor those cameras live.

27:12 Those are what they are.

27:15 They're cameras, right?

27:16 They take still pictures like our old Kodak cameras.

27:18 They take still pictures.

27:20 They're not old.

27:22 They're very intelligent.

27:24 But they just take pictures.

27:26 So we can't log in to the system and watch as cars go by and pictures being taken.

27:32 We're only notified of a picture that was being taken when it hits one of the hot list

27:40 or one of the collect systems, like a stolen vehicle or something like that.

27:44 That's when we're made aware of it.

27:45 Or if the officers are looking for a vehicle that was involved in a crime, they can type in

27:50 the vehicle and then it'll either appear or it will not appear.

27:53 But we cannot sit there and actually look at it live.

27:57 We can't even log into the camera and watch the camera.

28:00 None of that can happen.

28:02 And also the requirements for the officers to get into the system and actually do a search

28:08 or a lookup.

28:09 So what the officers need is they need a case number.

28:13 They need a reason to do it.

28:15 And with that reason comes a case number.

28:17 So if a crime has been committed, it could be a hit and run.

28:21 It can be a murder.

28:23 With a vehicle description or a vehicle license plate.

28:26 Before they can run anything, they have to go through and they have to put the,

28:30 either the description of the vehicle and they have to put the license plate.

28:33 And the reason why they're doing it, it's because of this case number.

28:36 And what that does is that allows when, when the administrators for FLOC, when Sergeant Hanson

28:43 goes through and he does audits, he can look at the case number and then he can look at the

28:48 case and then find out, make, just make sure, checks and balances to make, make sure that

28:53 that is what it was actually happening.

28:55 So, so that's kind of, that's, that's kind of the requirements to go through it.

28:59 And we also have that transparency portal that we had discussed last time that the community

29:04 can go in on our website.

29:06 They can, they can look at the last month of lookups or searches that the police department has done

29:12 on the cameras and the reasons for it.

29:14 Some of the stuff is blocked out like case numbers and stuff like that, but they can still see the reasons

29:19 and how many we've actually done.

29:21 I'd like to make some comments on that.

29:23 Sure.

29:24 On thus far too.

29:25 And just really quick, the corrective thing that may be misunderstood.

29:30 When you say you can't go onto a camera and see it live, it's not like a camera that you would go

29:35 on and look at what's going on on the mountain, you know, and you can control it and like that type of stuff.

29:39 However, you can go in and look at a timeframe and see the cars that traveled through or see the license plates

29:45 that traveled through in that timeframe.

29:47 Yeah.

29:48 If you, and that, and what happens in that space is if, if a crime is committed at some point in time,

29:54 we can go through, not we, Chief and his officers can go through and see the vehicles that traveled in that particular space.

30:03 And that's one of the valuable items for that.

30:05 I think one of your good points you're going to make later is in that space.

30:08 And so I just wanted to make that clarification that from a time period, you can, you can see the cars that traveled.

30:14 But it's a still photo.

30:15 Correct.

30:16 Of the vehicle's license plate.

30:17 Yes.

30:18 It's not a live photo.

30:19 So you can't go in and watch anything live, but you can put a timeframe in there and it'll show you the

30:22 vehicles that have passed through that camera within the timeframe that you, that you indicated.

30:27 So, and that goes into some of the success stories.

30:30 So, um, here's a great example of it.

30:32 So yesterday we, we had a pursuit.

30:35 Um, the sheriff's department, um, initiated a traffic stop.

30:38 The vehicle fled, um, vehicle fled into Mammoth.

30:41 Uh, the pursuit went through Mammoth, went up Meridian, came up 203 up Meridian Boulevard.

30:47 And ultimately, uh, the, the officers that were involved in the pursuit lost the vehicle.

30:53 Um, the, the officers, uh, knew it was a white vehicle, um, believed it to be a Kia, believed it to have disabled plates.

31:03 Um, so the officers lost them, uh, the suspect got away and everybody's looking for a white Kia with disabled plates.

31:11 Our officers were able to go into flock within a timeframe of when the pursuit happened and, and, and find the vehicle that was involved in the pursuit.

31:21 It showed the vehicle on the wrong side of the roadway at Meridian near the schools, traveling inbound towards Old Mammoth Road.

31:28 Um, so it was in the oncoming lane of traffic, passing another vehicle with a clear license plate.

31:33 The officers were able to use KLETS, which is a California law, law enforcement telecommunication system, to run the plate.

31:39 Um, to find out who the registered owner is, to, and then ultimately, um, identified the suspect that, that was running.

31:47 Um, that would not have been able to happen if, if, uh, if, if we did not have flock.

31:53 We would not have been able to locate that subject.

31:55 We would have been looking for a different vehicle, um, at the time.

31:59 Um, another one is, um, not going, I'm not going into too much detail cause it's still under investigation,

32:06 but we did have a fraud case in town, um, with a substantial amount of money, uh, taken in that fraud case.

32:13 Um, all we had was a vehicle description and no license plate or anything like that.

32:18 We were able to run the vehicle through flock using the vehicle, uh, um, description and find a vehicle that matched, um, the suspect vehicle and ultimately able to, um, identify a possible suspect.

32:36 Um, which would not have happened if we didn't have this technology.

32:40 Um, we had, uh, uh, threatened Bishop a couple of weeks ago that our entire community knows about as well as council, um, down in the Bishop area at the schools.

32:49 Um, within that threat, um, there was some additional threats made by family members.

32:56 And Mammoth had a direct correlation with those threats, um, specifically the CRC, um, which brought a lot of fear within the community and brought a lot of fear within employees for the town of Mammoth Lakes.

33:10 Um, we were able to put the license plates into flock from the individuals making the threats for precautionary reasons, knowing if those individuals came into town, um, and to carry out those threats,

33:24 we would have been made aware that they were coming into town.

33:27 Um, nobody came into town.

33:29 We didn't get any hits or anything like that, but that's an example of, um, the use, the use of flock.

33:35 Um, we had an assault with a deadly weapon as stabbing, um, which is still under investigation.

33:39 And I won't go into detail on that.

33:41 We were able to locate the suspect vehicle by using fly, identify the suspect and make an arrest.

33:47 Um, we also had a hit and run most recently, which was, I think, uh, the 1st of November.

33:53 We had a hit and run on town property, about $8,000 worth of damage.

33:57 Um, by using flock, we were able to put in the vehicle description.

34:00 The officers were able to locate the vehicle.

34:02 The officers are able to identify a suspect.

34:04 Um, and that, that just happened today.

34:07 And all of that is within the last month.

34:09 I reached out to our detective who is no longer with us and, and got some of the information that he used flock for as well during his investigations.

34:17 I'm going, I'm going to go through a list of these and I'm going to tell you that these, these, uh, cases, um, would not have been solved without the use of flock.

34:26 We've had multiple stolen vehicles either coming into town or leaving town.

34:31 Um, um, vehicles stolen from within our community or coming into town, um, that we were able to recover.

34:36 Vandalisms, attempt murders, uh, attempt murder, just one attempt murder, not murders.

34:42 Um, but we were able to locate, um, locate a vehicle, locate a suspect.

34:46 Um, assault with a deadly weapon, shoplifting, domestic violence is both felony and misdemeanors.

34:52 Um, brandishing firearms or deadly weapons, um, statutory rape.

34:57 We're able to, uh, close out a case on a, on a rape case using this.

35:01 Um, child pornography, sex acts with a child.

35:04 Um, stalking, evading, uh, grand theft, violations to DVROs, which are domestic violence restraining orders.

35:11 Um, those are just a few of them that he was able to give me that, that, um, he can confirm that they assisted in the investigation.

35:19 So those are just some of the, some of the things we have used it for.

35:22 Um, it, it's very telling within the last month on the amount of things that, you know, I went into detail with, with you guys.

35:29 And, um, it's very telling on how useful this tool is within the police department.

35:37 And it, and it also, I believe it, it, uh, keeps our community safe.

35:42 So, um, I'm going to leave it at that.

35:45 Um, I, I did think it was important to address the positives.

35:49 I know last, last council meeting, we addressed the negatives, but I also think it's important for council to know in our community, know the positives as well.

35:57 So I'll talk a little bit more about some of the action and conversations that we've had, um, you know, with flock and, and sort of the reality about the missteps.

36:07 So I think, um, through the conversations we were able to determine that the system was delivered to us turned with the, uh, nationwide, was it nationwide or just statewide?

36:17 Just a statewide lookup turned on.

36:19 Um, and so that's what allowed for these lookup functions to occur.

36:24 Um, and again, I went through the detail of how that function for probably, um, a full year before it was recognized and, and disabled by, um, Sergeant Highland at the time, who was our administrator.

36:37 Uh, and again, to show the, the prolific nature of the use of that, that product, um, we turned it on for 10 minutes.

36:43 We had about 120 lookups that occurred in that.

36:47 A lookup is not, you know, someone saying, I want to know what, you know, is this happening in the town of Mammoth Lakes?

36:53 It is, where is this license plate in the state of California?

36:56 And it just happens to touch our system if we're a member of that statewide network.

37:01 Um, once that was shut off and through the demonstrated data that was collected, you know, we, we haven't had any more discrepancies in that, in that space of time.

37:10 And that's been 14 months now, uh, since that, that occurred.

37:14 So in the last 14 months, we have not had, you know, any issues associated with that.

37:19 Um, with regard to, um, the transparency portal that they've created and put together, uh, I made a recommendation to them the other day that in addition to just providing the last 30 days,

37:33 they should provide historical, um, snapshots of that data.

37:37 I'm asking them to provide that. So it's not something that's flock to provide that because it's not something that I want, you know, our, our folks to be involved in creating and generating.

37:47 We want it to be pure produced by the system. Here is the utilization. Again, that goes back to, if you haven't seen that, I would encourage everybody to take a look.

37:55 You can go in and download, um, the, the actual log and it shows you every time it was used and some of the details that were included in that exactly why it was used and so forth.

38:07 So I'm asking them to create not only the current last 30 days, but a historical log that shows you, you can click on, you know, what happened in June of 2026 and it would show you that same download.

38:19 Uh, hopefully if, um, if we remain with them, they would be able to put that into place and further provide transparency.

38:28 Um, and so I think at this stage of the game, I'll, I'll pause and ask if there are any questions from council.

38:35 I, I also agree with chief, you know, the, the, the people that are responsible for the safety of the community are sitting at this table.

38:41 Um, we do need two tools, uh, to support us and help us in that space.

38:46 I think this thing is, has been valuable, um, and I also think that it's got some risks with, um, but data integrity and, and actually company integrity is more, more like it.

38:58 Um, if it were to be removed, I will tell you that I will strongly recommend that we find an alternative for this system and that we do put another alternative system in similar to that.

39:09 So, um, that's something that is, it is a valuable tool that's out there in the world.

39:16 Also remind folks that, you know, we're talking just about the town's, uh, system, which the town system is these 10 ALPR cameras, um, that are around town and does not include.

39:28 I think it's three more cameras that are associated with the school district and the Raven system, which is a gunshot detection system that, uh, is, is around the area.

39:37 So, um, I'll open it up for questions from council and see what you have or need.

39:43 Questions.

39:44 Right.

39:45 I just have one question.

39:46 Um, chief.

39:47 So my understanding is the only times our database gets searched is when it's turned on and we're going to look up outside of our locality.

39:55 And that's what, that's when it's available to the general public.

39:58 If.

39:59 No.

40:00 No.

40:02 Say that once.

40:03 So, so the only time, the only time that an outside of the area.

40:06 Is that an outside agency can, can look at our system.

40:11 Right.

40:12 There's two, two ways they can do it.

40:14 The statewide lookup tool being turned on, which is what happened with the 835,000 lookups that we had discussed last time.

40:21 Or direct sharing with an outside agency.

40:25 And we, we do not direct share and we haven't accepted a direct share with an outside agency.

40:30 So the reason, the reason for the lookups were because of the statewide lookup tool that was turned on.

40:36 And as, as Robin mentioned, that got turned off in, in August of 2025.

40:41 And the only time we had lookups out, lookups or searches outside of our agency is when Sergeant Heilman turned it on for that 10 minutes and turned it back off.

40:51 Right.

40:52 And then my, my question goes to the point of, we turn on in order for us to search.

40:55 If we don't turn it on, do we have ability to function and do searches without turning that on?

41:01 Can we contact?

41:02 No, we don't.

41:03 So if we were to turn, no, because the example is Sergeant Heilman once again.

41:07 So if we turned it on to search outside networks, that leaves our networks vulnerable for other organizations to look at.

41:15 Okay.

41:16 But that's a little bit of clarity to a couple of statements you've made.

41:20 We cannot search for a light, a full license plate in the state of California unless we have that network thing turned on.

41:27 However, we do searches through our own system to support our law enforcement activity, which is where these sort of recent successes have been occurred.

41:36 But you also said earlier something about, you know, for general public viewing or something like that.

41:42 And no, in no way does a system allow for anyone other than law enforcement, people who have logins, to even do the statewide network searches that were conducted.

41:52 This is not something that's ever available to the general public.

41:55 And, well, let me continue on because we answered part of that where I was going.

41:58 But the second part of that is, let's just say we never turn it on to do a statewide search.

42:03 Do we have agency cooperation with other agencies that we can do a search if we needed to?

42:09 We, we could.

42:11 If, if another agency allows, allows for lookups and stuff like that from outside agencies, yes, we can.

42:18 So in the event, a fraud case, the individual's from out of the area.

42:23 Right.

42:24 Right.

42:25 So we can reach out to that police department where the individual is located and have that, that police department assist in the investigation of the fraud case that occurred up here.

42:36 And that assist could be looking at their own ALPR cameras to see whether it's flock or not, looking at their ALPR cameras to, to attempt to locate the vehicle.

42:47 Yes.

42:48 We, we do have, we, we work closely with other law enforcement agencies.

42:51 And if, if they're involved in the investigations, what they would be, because that's where the suspect lives, they would be able to assist us in that.

42:59 Yes.

43:00 Okay.

43:01 Other questions?

43:02 Um, I have a few questions.

43:05 I've gotten a few emails about this.

43:07 So, um, I'm, I'm sure we've all seen the number where there's 838,000 lookups.

43:13 Um, do we have kind of an idea of how many times our local police have done, I, I, I don't, I don't know the difference between a lookup and a search or, but do we have the number of times that our police department has done a search for a vehicle with either like a full license plate or a partial license plate?

43:35 Like how often is our police department using this because the emails that I've gotten, one of the, one of the issues is, uh, you know, it's, there've been 838,000 searches.

43:45 So do we have an idea how often our local police department is using this, uh, compared to, um, you know, you, you've said that essentially when we've been part of the network, other entities in within the state of California are able to, um, search or look up on our.

44:05 Using our data, but how often are our officers performing searches on average?

44:12 So I can't really add all of these.

44:20 Yeah.

44:21 I will go.

44:22 I think it's something we could provide.

44:23 We could provide.

44:24 We want to see that.

44:25 But when we went through this, uh, this exercise of analyzing the data that was, that was brought out, basically the differentiated between the lookups that were done under the statewide network and the ones that were done by Chief Kasabian's teams internally.

44:37 So we have literally every one of those for the entire duration of this period of time.

44:41 Okay.

44:42 But I mean, like if you were to give me a ballpark number, is it like about 10 searches we're doing a month or a thousand or a hundred or, I mean, cause, cause 838,000, that sounds like we're all being surveilled every day.

44:54 I mean, that's alarming.

44:55 So I feel like if our police department is using this 10 times a month to look things up, that feels very different to me than hearing 838,000 searches.

45:04 Yeah.

45:05 So I'll just give you an example.

45:06 Uh, July, July of 26, 132 searches.

45:09 Mm-hmm.

45:10 Uh, total 63 lookups, 69 searches.

45:13 Um, August, 138, 98 lookups, 40 searches.

45:18 Um, and that's all I have.

45:20 I have up to August.

45:21 So, and we had shut it down.

45:23 Remember the timeframe?

45:24 We had shut it down between May and December, I believe.

45:27 Or, no, it was December and May, I'm sorry, excuse me.

45:30 Um, we, we don't have, uh, much there.

45:33 But just in July and August, you're looking at 132 combined lookups and searches and 138 combined lookups and searches.

45:40 And so then my next question is, do your officers sometimes perform multiple searches or lookups for, um, like the same criminal investigation?

45:49 They, they do.

45:50 Okay.

45:51 Yes, that's correct.

45:52 So 132 searches could be for far fewer crimes.

45:56 Uh, yeah.

45:57 And a good example of that is the hit and run.

45:59 Um, they, they had to go through, um, different, different steps in order to eventually locate the vehicle.

46:06 And that could have, that could have constituted five to five to 10 lookups or searches, however they were, they were using it.

46:13 They had to look it up because all they had was a vehicle, was a vehicle color and, and, and make.

46:18 And then, and then once they looked it up and got a potential, then they would take that potential because now we have a license plate, um, photo from flock, put the license plate in.

46:28 And now it's, now it's actually a, a, uh, I'm sorry.

46:32 They had to search for a vehicle that matches description.

46:34 And then they put the license plate in and for a specific vehicle.

46:37 And that is a lookup.

46:38 Okay.

46:39 So, so that could have been five, eight different times that they had to go through some steps to eventually find the suspect vehicle.

46:45 Okay.

46:46 Thank you.

46:47 Um, and then another question or information that I'm hearing from people is that, uh, agencies outside of the state of California have been able to access our data.

46:58 Is it true that agencies outside of the state were able to access our data for the whole time or how, how is that true and for how long?

47:07 No, so, so that, so yeah, so yes and no.

47:10 Okay.

47:11 So yes, they were able to look.

47:12 No, it wasn't the entire time.

47:14 Um, so in July of 2024, when we initially, um, got the system and, and the system was up and running.

47:21 Uh, the system was up and running, not our cameras.

47:24 Um, there is a nationwide lookup tool that flock in July of 2024 flock, flock would distribute this system with a nationwide lookup tool and a statewide lookup tool.

47:35 And both of those were turned on.

47:38 We didn't have our cameras yet.

47:39 So yes, at that point we had, um, ATF out of Nashville that, that searched our, that searched our, that searched our July of 2024, that searched our system.

47:48 We didn't search our system where there were no still photos of any vehicles because the cameras were not installed.

47:53 That is correct.

47:54 So they weren't, they weren't particularly looking at town of mammoth lake system.

47:57 They were typing in a license plate nationwide to try to find it.

48:03 Anybody who had that nationwide toggle turned on, um, their system got hit.

48:08 And that was, that was one of them.

48:10 And some out of state, some out of state, um, organizations also were able to hit our system at that time.

48:17 Before we had cameras.

48:18 Before we had cameras.

48:19 Before, before we had cameras.

48:20 So that was, that was July and August of 2024.

48:23 Um, September of 2024, starting September of 2024 through current, there is no outside agency.

48:34 There is no out of state or federal agency lookups.

48:39 So, so it was only the first two months that this, that this was in, that this was in effect

48:44 that outside agencies were able to look.

48:47 For two months outside agencies, outside of California were able to access still.

48:51 And I can, if I can.

48:53 Go ahead.

48:54 So, so Mayor Rice, I think what you're referring to is what I, I mentioned at the last meeting,

48:58 um, where we had that meeting in December of 2020, where they had indicated that, um, these agencies,

49:07 federal agencies had been provided a, and again, to back up just a little bit.

49:11 I'm sorry I'm bouncing around a little bit.

49:13 But we were notified by Flock that they had a webinar they wanted to sit through and talk

49:18 about, um, what they, they had deemed to be a, a problem they needed to notify us about.

49:25 Um, this was the one where I, I shut the system down immediately following that meeting

49:29 and it was shut down for five months without use, without usage.

49:32 That, the message that was delivered in that meeting was that the system was turned on to

49:38 allow, uh, many agencies to allow for this nationwide search.

49:42 And at that same time, there were agencies in the federal government who were utilizing

49:47 this as a, as a test period to, to test the Flock system.

49:51 And that they had access at that period of time to do these nationwide searches.

49:55 Um, so that's the, that's the thing I think that you're hearing about.

49:59 And that's the thing that I talked about.

50:02 Um, however, the data searches that chief just went through, you know, don't indicate that,

50:06 that we were searched at that point in time or that we were a part of that process.

50:10 However, that's the, the data.

50:12 And that was from February of 25 through, I think it was may of 2025 when those agencies

50:17 had access to that and that was shut down.

50:20 Um, but again, when that, we were notified again in December of 2025.

50:24 We immediately shut the system down notified town council.

50:28 That's the notice I read in the last meeting.

50:30 Um, and that, that was provided, but I think that's what you're referring to.

50:34 And then can you reiterate, I, we approved eight cameras initially, and then how many cameras

50:41 did we bring on?

50:42 Why did we bring on more and what have we done with them?

50:45 Yeah.

50:46 So we had, um, initially eight cameras were authorized in the first contract.

50:50 Um, when we went and installed that and in this, at the same time, we were doing, um, the,

50:56 we were doing emergency evacuation planning and exercises.

51:00 And we added, we recognized we had a gap on Lake Mary road where we couldn't see trap vehicle

51:05 traffic traveling up and down Lake Mary road.

51:07 So I authorized two additional cameras at that time.

51:10 So we have 10 cameras total.

51:12 Um, during the, uh, when we turn the system back on, I think it was June timeframe.

51:18 We had an arson in, uh, around by the water district, um, that we were concerned about

51:24 in this tying to previous year arson activity.

51:27 So we, at that time we did a temporary installation of, I think was, was it five additional cameras

51:33 at that point in time?

51:34 Um, and that was always planned to be a short term.

51:37 There was an opportunity with flock where we could say for 90 days, we would have a, uh,

51:41 basically a test of the system.

51:43 We would have these additional cameras in place.

51:45 We placed them at egress points of the town that were currently wide open to make sure

51:50 that we captured vehicles traveling out of that space.

51:52 That period of time ended in September of 2026.

51:55 And the cameras have been removed in our, and we didn't pay a dime for them.

51:59 So, um, that was all part of a planned investigation.

52:02 And that was the process that we had.

52:04 Okay.

52:05 Thank you.

52:06 You have a question.

52:07 Go ahead.

52:08 Um, I'm noticing a big change in demeanor from the last town council meeting.

52:13 So I just wanted to know, um, if not flock cameras, have y'all looked into some alternative

52:21 to flock cameras, but y'all don't seem as ticked off as you did last meeting.

52:27 So, um, can you elaborate why that now you're feeling more confident, please?

52:34 Wouldn't say confidence, the number that I was looking for.

52:37 Um, I would say that, you know, last, last meeting, we had a lot to tell the council and the community

52:44 with regard to the history of what happened in the space.

52:46 Um, and we're fully transparent a hundred percent of the time with the information that we provided.

52:52 And I think it was the, the depth of information that we had to provide and clarity and walking

52:59 through that, that, you know, gave us that, that sense of pause.

53:02 I will tell you that personally, um, my feelings about flock have, as a company have not changed.

53:08 Um, however, in, in even the last two weeks, chief went through the last month and the last

53:12 two weeks utilization has been phenomenal as far as helping us.

53:17 So when you, in this entire equation, we're weighing the value to the community and the

53:23 safety against the risk of a company that has proven to make questionable to bad decisions

53:30 on the rollout of their product, right?

53:32 When I talked to the, the owner and I, we did talk to the owner of flock and the, and the

53:37 developer that originally developed the concept, he, um, he was just trying too quickly to

53:44 provide a tool that he felt was valuable without ever considering the, the negative impacts that

53:50 people would feel in this particular space.

53:52 So missteps in calculation in those processes absolutely occurred.

53:57 Um, and there's no guarantee they won't include or occur in the fruit, in the future, right?

54:01 And things that they may do.

54:03 Um, so to answer your question, I think about alternatives, I've not looked at alternatives.

54:07 I, I'm adamant that we do need a tool similar to this.

54:12 It may, it doesn't have to be flock necessarily.

54:15 Um, but we will be recommending something.

54:18 And so we would have to start and go through that process, um, to determine what, what that

54:23 alternate would be.

54:24 There are many different alternate, uh, automated license plate reader systems in use.

54:28 Um, none of them are in the crosshairs that flock is as far as nationwide concerns and

54:32 issues.

54:33 Um, but they are, they're in existence and they're utilization even within the county of Mono.

54:38 Okay.

54:39 And my other question is, I mean, I, I know I have cameras in my car.

54:43 I can tell if you're picking your nose and you're sitting in a car behind me, but this

54:47 is only taking a picture of the license plate.

54:50 It captures the back.

54:52 It captures the car.

54:53 Um, it does not capture the occupants of the car, but it will be enough to tell you

54:58 the make, model, color, uh, key attributes.

55:02 Like if there's bumper stickers or other challenges or anything like that.

55:05 I don't know what I'm hearing.

55:06 I'm sorry.

55:07 I can't.

55:08 Please don't interrupt.

55:09 It's not your turn.

55:10 Who's talking?

55:11 Okay.

55:12 Um, but yeah, the vehicle attributes, because that's one of the things chief can, they

55:15 can search.

55:16 If you're in full search mode, you can search, um, a either color a vehicle or make

55:21 model color a vehicle, or if there's damage on a particular vehicle, you can, you can search

55:25 for that.

55:26 So it does capture some attributes about the vehicle alone.

55:28 Um, and then the license plate, absolutely.

55:31 Um, but that's only utilized when in the full search capability function, which was,

55:38 is, has only ever been allowable at the town of Mammoth Lakes for our staff.

55:42 The lookup function that is the vast majority of what was described as 835,000 are lookups,

55:49 which require full license plate numbers.

55:52 And again, this is an agency somewhere in the state of California saying, I want to see

55:56 if this license plate has been seen anywhere in the state.

55:59 And then since ours was at that time was, it was in that statewide network, it would return

56:04 or record as a lookup at the town of Mammoth Lakes, but we were included in a lookup across

56:10 the state.

56:11 Hopefully that answered the question.

56:13 That does.

56:14 I, I'm just so confused that we have so little privacy in this world.

56:18 I, I don't see why this in particular is what people are focusing on when they have cameras

56:24 in their cars, on their phones, everything.

56:27 So, so questions.

56:28 Yeah.

56:29 So deliberations.

56:30 Any other questions?

56:31 Um, no, I, I have one more.

56:33 Oh, Cleveland, hold on.

56:34 Cleveland has one.

56:35 With, uh, so I think the initial output was what?

56:37 $53,000 for this.

56:39 Do you think that, what, you've just made a face.

56:44 Well, it's.

56:45 What was the original output for it?

56:46 Um, the, the camera system is $25,000 plus another $7,000 for the additional two cameras.

56:51 So it's, it's a total of $32,000 per year.

56:54 Oh, okay.

56:55 So I'm even over going there.

56:57 So would you say that the, um, benefits that from cars being stolen from other things have

57:05 saved the community money, time, and anguish?

57:09 Yes.

57:12 Okay.

57:13 I do.

57:14 Thank you.

57:15 No more questions.

57:16 Do you have some questions?

57:17 Yeah.

57:18 Rob, when does our current contract expire?

57:20 I believe it's, um, either September or October of 27.

57:24 We, we have two separate contracts.

57:26 We have one for the initial eight cameras for the $25,000 and we have the second, uh, contract

57:31 for the, for the additional two cameras at Lake Mary for $7,000.

57:36 August, um, August is when, um, August of 2027 is when it expires.

57:43 And then maybe a month later is when the two cameras expire.

57:49 So they, they didn't merge the two contracts, the two separate contracts.

57:52 So one expires in August, one expires in September of next year.

57:55 One more, if I may.

57:56 Yeah, go ahead.

57:57 Um, because the concern here seems to be a privacy concern.

58:02 I want to reiterate once again, unless I'm getting it wrong, those 850,000 lookups or whatever

58:10 they were, those were people putting a license number into a statewide system.

58:15 They didn't get back any license plates from us unless their vehicle was found here.

58:20 And I'm assuming none was.

58:22 So all of those looks ups resulted in someone outside getting zero information from the town

58:27 of Mammoth Lakes, right?

58:29 Uh, yes, but I can't guarantee the fact that they didn't get any information from the town

58:35 of Mammoth Lakes.

58:36 If the vehicle that they were looking for happened to be in the town of Mammoth Lakes at some point,

58:39 yes, they would have gotten that back, but I do not know.

58:41 But only if that vehicle had been here.

58:43 That's correct.

58:44 Not if Cathy Cage went through Minaret and, uh...

58:48 Yeah, that's, that's correct.

58:49 Yeah.

58:50 Any other questions?

58:52 Got to poke you some, Cathy.

58:53 Questions?

58:54 John, you have any questions right now?

58:56 No?

58:57 No questions.

58:58 Okay.

58:59 Let's take public comment.

59:00 Public comment from anyone in the room.

59:02 We can, um, you can make a line.

59:03 We can make a line in the aisle if there's a lot.

59:07 Good evening, Council.

59:08 My name is Brianna Gonzalez.

59:10 You can call me Bri.

59:11 I work in Mammoth Lakes and travel these roads daily as part of my commute to and from Levining.

59:17 I'm urging the town of Mammoth Lakes to terminate its contract with Flock Safety.

59:22 This system costs taxpayers tens of thousands of dollars, undermines public trust, and raises

59:29 serious concerns about individual privacy and government surveillance.

59:34 Our taxpayer dollars should not be spent funding intrusive surveillance systems that threaten

59:39 our civil liberties, provide little transparency, or accountability.

59:44 Our town is facing far more pressing challenges, including an escalating housing crisis, limited

59:50 access to affordable healthcare, pharmacy services, wildlife management concerns, aging

59:56 infrastructure, just to name a few.

59:59 At the same time, the town continues to approve resort-style hotels and new amenities without

1:00:05 adequately addressing other existing infrastructure that can support that growth.

1:00:10 We should be prioritizing the needs of our residents and investing in the services and

1:00:14 infrastructure that keep our community functioning rather than spending thousands of

1:00:19 dollars on surveillance of the very people who live and visit our town.

1:00:23 There are also serious concerns surrounding Flock's data collection, storage, accuracy, and oversight.

1:00:30 Reports have raised questions about incorrect data, wrongful detentions and arrests, and the lack of

1:00:36 meaningful controls over who can access the information collected.

1:00:40 Concerns have also been raised about how this data may be shared with the outside agencies,

1:00:45 including the Department of Homeland Security and ICE, potentially facilitating immigration enforcement

1:00:52 activities beyond the original purpose of the system.

1:00:55 These are not insignificant concerns.

1:00:58 When license plate data and travel patterns can be collected, stored, accessed, and shared with little

1:01:03 public oversight, the privacy rights of everyone in our community are at risk.

1:01:08 At a time when civil liberties and individual privacy are facing increasing challenges nationwide,

1:01:13 we should be taking steps to protect our community, not expanding surveillance without clear necessity,

1:01:19 transparency, and accountability.

1:01:21 I urge the town council to end its contract with Flock Safety and redirect those taxpayer dollars towards

1:01:28 priorities that genuinely benefit our residents, including youth programs,

1:01:33 infrastructure management, wildlife management resources, and essential community service.

1:01:38 Public trust is earned through responsible leadership, transparency, and putting the needs of residents first.

1:01:44 Let's invest in our community, not surveillance.

1:01:48 Hello, my name is Lena Martinson, and I am a resident of Mammoth.

1:02:01 I'm a software engineer and such.

1:02:04 I've been dealing with the digital privacy questions all my career.

1:02:09 I would urge the council to cancel its contracts with Flock immediately.

1:02:15 The Flock surveillance cameras track every car that comes into view, along with additional features, as stated,

1:02:21 including things like bumper stickers, expressing political opinions, and the places you go.

1:02:28 Unlike traffic enforcement cameras, they track all vehicles, not just those that have done something wrong.

1:02:36 Flock has consistently proven themselves to share this data far and wide, and much more wide than they tell their customers, as you have experienced.

1:02:49 Or what is potentially legal and exploiting gray areas and lack of regulation.

1:02:55 And they're exploiting this for their own profit and at the expense of our safety and privacy.

1:03:07 For example, there have been police officers stalking excess all over the country.

1:03:13 That is pretty awful.

1:03:15 And according to the ACLU, there has been no proven change in case closure rates or crime trends with Flock.

1:03:24 I hear that it has been used in a bunch of cases.

1:03:28 Just because it's been used doesn't mean that it couldn't have been done without Flock.

1:03:33 I don't think that is proof of its usefulness.

1:03:37 For example, I'd like to point out the awful case in Bishop a couple of years ago with a murder and Brian Stanch being found pretty quickly without the use of Flock.

1:03:53 You can solve these crimes without Flock.

1:03:58 There have also been many false positives with people being chased for crimes that they haven't committed.

1:04:05 There's an example of a mother and a child being held at gunpoint due to their car being erroneously reported as stolen.

1:04:13 This is not keeping us any safer.

1:04:16 I would also urge the council not to set up a new contract with a different provider.

1:04:22 Many of them are working on increasing their offerings to be more on par with Flock.

1:04:28 And they're also lobbying against ALPR regulations and tech transparency laws.

1:04:34 There needs to be an important distinction between keeping us safe and having some privacy.

1:04:43 And the only way to there's no balance here.

1:04:48 We should get rid of Flock.

1:04:49 Thank you.

1:04:50 Thank you.

1:04:51 Hello.

1:04:57 I'm Albert Benson.

1:04:58 I am a resident of Mammoth Lakes.

1:05:01 I just wanted to add that Flock as a business has proven to be untrustworthy in that it has opened up municipalities to nationwide access including ICE and Customers and Border Patrol who have done some very unfortunate things nationwide.

1:05:22 As well as provided police departments with wrongful hits resulting in citizens being dragged from their vehicles and having canines deployed upon them.

1:05:34 This technology has been rushed out and it's not in the company's best interest to provide safety but to prove utilization so that way they could sell more cameras.

1:05:45 Thank you.

1:05:46 Any public comments from anyone else in the room?

1:05:53 Hey, welcome, Dan.

1:05:54 Well, I was just wondering, can we see what it looks like?

1:05:59 Can we see the picture so that I understand what it looks like?

1:06:04 And I don't understand, can you just zoom in on a license plate and take a picture of the whole car and then squash it down or what?

1:06:14 Why don't we wait until the end of public comment and if there's any questions you'd like to address, you can address them then.

1:06:19 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

1:06:21 Hello, my name is Miley.

1:06:25 I also live here.

1:06:26 I have a question directed at these police officers over here.

1:06:30 You said that they can answer later, not now?

1:06:33 You have five minutes to make public comment.

1:06:36 Right.

1:06:37 You can state some questions, but it's not a dialogue between you and them.

1:06:41 I'm just wondering why you don't think that you could have caught any of those people without those cameras?

1:06:48 I'm sorry.

1:06:49 That's really my only question.

1:06:51 It seems like there have been cops forever who catch people doing crazy things without these cameras that directly break our Fourth Amendment rights.

1:07:02 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

1:07:10 Hi, my name is Lee Gosh.

1:07:11 I've lived here since 1977 and I don't understand why people are upset about these cameras.

1:07:17 Come to my house and see cameras on my house 24 hours a day.

1:07:22 They know when I come.

1:07:23 They know when I leave, who comes to visit, when I do my gardening.

1:07:26 They know my whole life history better than I do.

1:07:29 I want these cameras because they will help our community.

1:07:34 And somebody mentioned how they worry about the politics of the stickers.

1:07:38 That's called a freedom of speech.

1:07:39 You can do whatever you want with stickers on your car.

1:07:42 I'm in favor of these because I have them on my house.

1:07:46 But I've got to let people know one thing.

1:07:48 If you have cameras on your house, you have a right to fight the night lights.

1:07:51 They cannot put a light on your house.

1:07:53 So remember that.

1:07:54 Remember the code.

1:07:55 So no lights on your house.

1:07:57 Thank you, Lee.

1:07:59 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

1:08:04 Anyone online?

1:08:05 Any hands raised?

1:08:06 Okay.

1:08:10 Ms. Bateman, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

1:08:14 Hello again.

1:08:22 Can everyone hear me?

1:08:23 Yes.

1:08:24 Awesome.

1:08:25 Thank you.

1:08:26 Hello and good evening council members, town staff, and all Mammoth Lake agencies and departments.

1:08:32 My name is Misha Little Bear Bateman, a 13-year resident of Mammoth Lake, outdoor educator,

1:08:37 EMT, and member of the local creative arts community.

1:08:42 I'd like to begin by first welcoming Nicholas Howell and Timothy Gordon to the team.

1:08:47 We're excited to have you here.

1:08:50 So thank you for joining our force and keeping our community safe.

1:08:54 I'd like to address that we all prioritize our public safety.

1:08:59 I know we want to support our police force in keeping us safe.

1:09:02 I'm pleased that we have more folks on the team, which will hopefully alleviate some of the stress that has led us to the use of Flock in the first place.

1:09:10 However, you all need to understand that the general public feels less safe with Flock and AI surveillance, not more.

1:09:19 We're achieving the wrong results here.

1:09:22 I'd like for us as a community, a town council, and a police force to come to an agreement on what systems make us all feel safe and supported.

1:09:32 At this time, that is not AI, it is not ALPR systems, and it is not Flock.

1:09:40 I want you all to take a peek into a dystopian future with me.

1:09:44 A future where Flock and other AI surveillance and ALPR systems market AI-powered search across video and LPR and audio products that explicitly link sounds with LPR and video.

1:09:57 Even if today's configuration is narrow, the architecture and commercial incentives are for expansion.

1:10:05 Flock isn't just the cameras. It's a platform designed to expand video searches, audio detection, cross-agency lookups.

1:10:15 And this is all going to occur unless we lock it down now.

1:10:20 The issue here is not whether the cameras are good or bad.

1:10:23 It's whether the town of Mammoth is authorizing or expanding an ecosystem that can become a permanent surveillance substrate through network sharing, integration and API, feature surveillance from plates to video search to audio and voice analytics.

1:10:40 I'd like to bring your attention to two documented incidences of official government statements or audits against Flock and ask them questions that follow.

1:10:49 The first case is an Illinois audit finding U.S. Customs and Border Protection access ALPR data in violation of state law.

1:10:57 And secondly, with a North Carolina licensing issue and statewide all stopped to Flock.

1:11:03 Federal access is documented with the Illinois Secretary of State announced an audit finding that CPB gained access to Illinois ALPR data in violation of state law.

1:11:16 This shows that federal access, the idea that federal access won't happen is not a safe assumption.

1:11:25 Governance can fail or be bypassed.

1:11:29 So what blocks federal agencies from accessing mammoth collected data directly or indirectly via partners?

1:11:36 Secondly, a judge in North Carolina orders a company to stop and selling ALPR cameras statewide as a preliminary injection over licensing issues.

1:11:45 This demonstrates how regulatory fragility can disrupt deployments and contracts and create operational and legal uncertainty.

1:11:55 What is mammoth off ramps if a court or regulator action halts work or undermines evidentiary reliability?

1:12:04 The patent provision for Flock is a dynamic surveillance network that ingests unrelated video sources and makes them searchable by attributes, objects, license plates.

1:12:19 This is the blueprint for a future where disparate cameras become once searchable database including classification of cars, humans, attributes.

1:12:31 Will the town of mammoth prohibit any movement towards person attribute searching or cross camera tracking features?

1:12:41 Ultimately, I believe that you all deserve the right to due process under our fifth amendment rights and that we deserve protection from unreasonable searches and seizures under our fourth amendment rights.

1:12:53 This means that you have a right to procedural and data privacy under the fourth amendment as its framework for the law of surveillance with evolving interpretations in areas like electronic data, digital tracking and AI cameras.

1:13:08 This system gives access to our personal data outside law enforcement agencies and public agencies with fine power.

1:13:16 This level of surveillance does not belong in our community.

1:13:19 We deserve safety without constantly being watched and billion dollar tech companies profiting from us turning into a product.

1:13:28 Your five minutes is up.

1:13:29 Your five minutes is up.

1:13:30 This is not.

1:13:31 Okay.

1:13:32 Well, thank you so much for hearing my concern tonight.

1:13:33 I appreciate you.

1:13:34 Thank you.

1:13:35 Any other public comments from anyone online?

1:13:38 No.

1:13:39 Anyone in the room?

1:13:41 No.

1:13:42 Okay.

1:13:43 We are onto deliberations.

1:13:44 I would like to start.

1:13:45 Okay.

1:13:46 I'll just, if I could, I'll just maybe follow up where we left off at the last meeting.

1:13:50 And I appreciate Cleland you're pointing out kind of the change in the tone from the staff.

1:13:54 I don't take that one way or the other.

1:13:56 I think that, and I appreciate all the documentation of the incidents and how this technology was useful

1:14:02 and needed a lot of these crimes.

1:14:03 But I really don't think that's the problem.

1:14:06 The problem are the human beings and the companies behind this technology that have demonstrated not only sort of basic sort of contract management incompetence,

1:14:17 which led to your own levels of distrust.

1:14:20 And, but it's, but it ripples out into a larger national awareness.

1:14:25 We've seen in the elections, the role that data centers, that kind of thing.

1:14:29 It's, there's connectivity with all this stuff.

1:14:32 And so I can't see it.

1:14:35 I mean, no one's debating the whiz bang tools that are in this stuff.

1:14:39 It can do the things that is needed for law enforcement, all the rest of it.

1:14:42 The problem is the culture of the companies behind this, and the concerns of this,

1:14:46 and the concerns that the public have articulated here this evening, and I hear all the time,

1:14:51 that the data and the tools are not safe in the hands of these corporations, which may have other kinds of interests.

1:15:01 So I would, I would really urge us to cancel this conflict, the contract with Flock immediately, as soon as you can.

1:15:08 However, if you find another provider that you would want to bring back to a council for consideration, I think that door should be open.

1:15:17 I don't know which members of the council were here when we went to this Flock last time, but, you know, we were skeptical.

1:15:24 We asked all the questions.

1:15:25 We had got the reassurances and it turns out that they are not trustworthy.

1:15:30 The corporate culture behind this stuff is not worthy of our trust.

1:15:35 And I think the community is sharing those concerns.

1:15:37 And I think on behalf of what I've heard from constituents, I think we need to find a better screwdriver for all this.

1:15:43 So those are my thoughts.

1:15:44 So you're in favor of finding an alternative?

1:15:46 I'm not in favor of finding an alternative, but I'm in favor of canceling the Flock contract.

1:15:51 But if, if staff based on what you hear from the councils and aggregate this evening, if you think there's, there is a trustworthy, a company that's worthy of the community's trust that can, and can address the types of concerns we're hearing this evening,

1:16:07 want to bring it back to another council, I think, sure, bring it back.

1:16:10 But, you know, we've been through this once already and look what this has turned into.

1:16:14 So those are my thoughts.

1:16:15 Okay.

1:16:16 So start down here.

1:16:17 Yeah.

1:16:18 I'm feeling a little different than John on this.

1:16:20 One, we do have a contract that goes through August of 27 that we're going to be paying for regardless.

1:16:26 There were issues up front.

1:16:28 The company has shown not to be completely reliable, but any company that produces these is in it for profit, not for the fact that it can benefit us is just a plus on that.

1:16:40 So what I would like to see us do is to keep them on, keep the contract going, because we have to pay for it regardless.

1:16:50 Brought back in maybe June of 27 with a report as to, or if something else egregious happens, bring it back before then, so that that gives us time to then look at this contract and look at other possibilities and go from there.

1:17:06 Okay.

1:17:07 Okay.

1:17:11 One question.

1:17:12 I thought at the last meeting, Rob, you thought that you had the, based on the violations of the contract to date, that we are in a position to be able to cancel the contract for cause.

1:17:28 Is that true or?

1:17:29 If, if, if the decision by council is to, to, to shut down flock immediately, the first thing that I would do is we work on a breach of contract discussion with Andy to try to get out of the contract.

1:17:39 Yes.

1:17:40 And, and, and, but you feel you have, you have the, the substance behind a breach of contract argument with these folks.

1:17:45 Is that correct?

1:17:46 Or just trying to.

1:17:47 Potentially.

1:17:48 Um, we flock has taken the position thus far that it was user error rather than configuration errors on their end, um, that allowed federal agencies to look at our data.

1:17:58 So something we have to sort through with them.

1:18:00 Who, when you say user, what user are we talking about?

1:18:03 Uh, flock has said that it was, um, town staff who improperly checked boxes or toggled things.

1:18:09 Um, I think we would, I don't, I'm not weighing in on whether that happened or not, but I think we would say that.

1:18:15 Any user error was because it was not explained how this works and the toggling something would open up searches to nationwide agencies.

1:18:23 Okay.

1:18:24 Thank you.

1:18:25 Sorry.

1:18:26 No, that's fine.

1:18:27 I, I, you know, I'm being told by our police.

1:18:29 I'm seeing the effectiveness that most of these issues are at least under control.

1:18:34 Uh, if we have the contract, I see no reason not to have that contract fulfilled.

1:18:39 And I understand we have a bunch of very passionate people and I thank them for coming as I always do.

1:18:44 But I've also been contacted by several people outside who have a different view.

1:18:48 So, uh, for me, this is the money's there.

1:18:53 It's being spent.

1:18:54 It's being effective.

1:18:55 Let's live through the contract, reassess it long enough before the end of the contract to then make a quality decision on it at that point in time.

1:19:06 Thank you.

1:19:07 I mean, I would also just like to state our police department is not on 24 hour service.

1:19:12 Our police department is short staffed at the moment.

1:19:15 Um, you know, that that's concerning to me.

1:19:18 I know when we went off of 24 hour service to me, when we made that choice, it was, I felt like it was going to be like a six month kind of a chunk of time.

1:19:28 And that has been much longer than it would was anticipated.

1:19:32 Um, so I think that another factor in looking at all of this is understanding how short staffed our police department is and that we don't have 24 hour curve service currently.

1:19:43 Other thoughts?

1:19:47 Yeah.

1:19:48 So, you know, it's tough because I agree with everything everyone said here tonight and you're trying to weigh what's best for this community.

1:19:55 And that's where I'm at in terms of, you know, a week ago, I probably felt differently.

1:19:59 But if you've talked to the staff over at CRC with what happened in Bishop and their concerns, I mean, really legitimate concerns.

1:20:07 We sit up here and we don't really understand when someone's working and they think someone may be coming to a place of work and doing something really extreme, it impacts you.

1:20:15 And I, I lean more the other way and saying, keep it at this point in time, find an alternative.

1:20:21 I don't think this is a system that we want to be longterm with.

1:20:24 I think it has many errors.

1:20:25 I think people have started the system and they have different intentions that may not match with ours, but it does provide a tool for us at this point in time that provides.

1:20:36 Um, I would say reassurance and I'm not sure it closes cases any faster, but I actually saw the chase cars yesterday overall and listening to what was going on.

1:20:47 The person running around, I'm like, you don't understand what happens in this town from a daily basis that certain things can escalate very quickly.

1:20:54 And it's a tool.

1:20:55 I may not be my best tool that I want, but I think it's a tool that we keep until we've got something else.

1:21:00 Um, whether that is cancel in June or cancel sooner, I'm more like, let's find something else that will work and then move it away and move to something else.

1:21:12 When do you expect our police, um, to be fully staffed?

1:21:16 That's a really good question.

1:21:19 So the, the staffing challenges continue.

1:21:22 Um, we, we, we're allotted.

1:21:27 So the police partners allotted 19 sworn staff, uh, budgeted, budgeted for 19 sworn staff.

1:21:33 Sorry.

1:21:34 Um, that includes myself.

1:21:35 So right now we're at 14.

1:21:40 So we have two coming out of the academy in December.

1:21:45 Um, if they're successful on the academy.

1:21:47 If they're successful on their field training in four months.

1:21:50 So that puts them in April, May timeframe.

1:21:52 There's an additional two.

1:21:54 So now we're at 16.

1:21:56 We have two starting the academy in November next week on, on Monday or Tuesday.

1:22:01 Um, there it's a six month academy, another four months FTO.

1:22:04 So a year from now, 10, 10 months to 12 months from now, that will add another two.

1:22:09 Um, a year, about a year from now, maybe sooner, hopefully sooner.

1:22:16 And the 14 include the two that you brought in this evening.

1:22:19 Yes.

1:22:20 Okay.

1:22:21 And I, the recruitment efforts continue and our recruitment efforts are pretty, um, pretty impressive

1:22:26 with the amount of things that are offered, right?

1:22:28 We're, we have a bonus both for the people coming in.

1:22:31 We're seeking laterals.

1:22:32 The people that you introduced tonight were not fresh brand new police officers.

1:22:36 They were seasoned officers from other areas, which are very, very, very valuable.

1:22:41 Um, so we're, we, our recruitment efforts continue on that.

1:22:44 So when she said maybe sooner, it's just because we're continuing to offer that program.

1:22:48 And we're continuing to seek, um, staff to, to add to that.

1:22:52 But I, but I do want to assure that that is my number one priority is to get back to 24-hour

1:22:57 staffing and get, and get the, uh, the staffing and that we need to do that.

1:23:00 Okay.

1:23:01 Thank you.

1:23:02 Cleveland, what are your thoughts?

1:23:03 Uh, my thoughts, uh, it's just kind of strange.

1:23:06 I feel like maybe I'm missing some point of it.

1:23:09 I've received so much AI information and letters from people on a variety of subjects, just not this.

1:23:17 So obviously it isn't a problem with people with technology, this specific technology.

1:23:23 It just floors me that this would even, um, how could people could think of how this could

1:23:30 be used for bad ways, even if those were the lookups.

1:23:33 And I know that there are people long story short, I'm, I, I can actually go ahead and

1:23:37 make a motion right now.

1:23:38 Well, you haven't heard my thoughts, Cleveland.

1:23:40 Oh, I thought you did.

1:23:41 I'm sorry.

1:23:42 Well, and I would like to say, Jamie, I did receive three public comment.

1:23:46 Emails right before the, at three 55, three 54 and three 56 this evening that were, um,

1:23:53 in favor of terminating, uh, the relationship with flock.

1:23:57 Um, I, I mean, I feel like there are definitely concerns that I have with that corporation.

1:24:07 Um, I feel like at this point with having a, our police department short staffed and we're

1:24:15 on, um, a shortened schedule, only 20 hours of service instead of 24.

1:24:20 Um, I think that I would be in favor of continuing using the clock clock cameras while searching

1:24:28 for alternatives.

1:24:29 Um, I don't know if there are other companies that have a better track record of doing exactly

1:24:36 what they say they're going to do.

1:24:38 Um, and I do, you know, I understand that something was toggled on that we did not intentionally

1:24:44 want toggled on.

1:24:45 And I don't know who's responsible for that, but I do know like there are, uh, there's a

1:24:50 learning curve when you're using enough new technology or doing something new.

1:24:54 So I would really hope if we're going to continue using flock that we, um, we need more

1:25:02 public transparency as to what your officers are looking up, um, or how many lookups are

1:25:08 happening, uh, and things like that.

1:25:10 So, you know, I think making that making, um, kind of like the, the type of search or some,

1:25:18 um, well, I'm not sure exactly what information you can make public, but, you know, allowing

1:25:22 the public to see how it's being used, you know, would help with, uh, transparency.

1:25:30 So I just have to ask a clarifying question.

1:25:33 So, um, I think it's important if, if what you're hearing from this, I'm not sure what

1:25:38 you're hearing from this, but, um, is to continue using the service, but I would hope

1:25:43 that the council saying look for an alternative vendor because the vendors certainly prove themselves

1:25:47 to be untrustworthy.

1:25:48 Uh, but I would also hope that if and when you find an alternative vendor, that that contract

1:25:54 comes back before the council in a public way.

1:25:57 So it's not a town manager discretion thing to say, oh, we're just going to go off with

1:26:01 this other company.

1:26:02 Because I think some of the comments made this evening are really, are really important.

1:26:05 We feel less safe.

1:26:07 And the incidents is fine.

1:26:10 Clearly the, the, the technology has real effectiveness and is a very good technology.

1:26:15 The, the challenge is what's, who's running that technology?

1:26:18 Who's managing it?

1:26:20 The companies are on the other side of that.

1:26:22 And we've seen that this experience with flock, that these people are not trustworthy.

1:26:25 And it's making, it's raising legitimate concerns in the community.

1:26:29 So, fine.

1:26:30 If you all want to keep going forward, great.

1:26:32 But I think it's, I hope it's to be looking for an alternative vendor.

1:26:36 But if you find something to bring it back in a public session for council to review and

1:26:41 improve it.

1:26:42 I mean, ideally, I'd like you to find a different vendor as soon as possible.

1:26:45 But in the meantime, continue to use the flock cameras if our police department feels

1:26:50 that that's necessary.

1:26:51 I think I can put this in a way that would be good.

1:26:54 You'd like to make a motion, Cleland?

1:26:56 Yes.

1:26:57 And this is going to be kind of a change.

1:26:58 It's a direct the town manager to continue the use of the flock ALPR system.

1:27:05 And upon the end of the contract, seek an alternative provider to provide the ALPR functionality

1:27:17 for police and switch providers at that point.

1:27:25 So.

1:27:26 Would you like to add something while continuing to develop transparency and monitoring tools

1:27:31 to the public?

1:27:32 Oh, yes.

1:27:33 Just for clarification, there were, there were in recommended motion, since this was an open-ended

1:27:50 discussion, we provided three different options.

1:27:54 And so what, um, council member Hoff read was one of the options.

1:27:59 Um, there was, with some slight modifications did you make?

1:28:02 Exactly.

1:28:03 That's that I'm, I'm, I'm looking at third option, but changing it to go to the end of

1:28:11 the contract that we now have.

1:28:13 Okay.

1:28:14 Okay.

1:28:15 And that at point actually, well, I've already said it, but I, you know, I would reassess the

1:28:20 situation because maybe flock will be a great company and everybody's flocking to flock.

1:28:24 I don't know.

1:28:25 Okay.

1:28:26 Just as a question that I mean, what if, what if the staff finds a better vendor next week?

1:28:32 Why will we wait to the end of the contract?

1:28:34 Why won't we bring back a proposition?

1:28:35 Because I will tell you the time and money spent for our town attorney to have to go through,

1:28:42 figure out if that's money is just going to get written off or if we're going to have

1:28:47 to, if we're going to have to have some kind of, uh, flock saying it's our problem.

1:28:53 And we're saying that's just going to be a fight time money spent that we don't need.

1:28:58 All right.

1:28:59 I just, I just, I think that if we could, if the staff could identify a better alternative,

1:29:04 and again, if there's a dis, if there's a legitimate dispute between us and flock about

1:29:10 who's at fault with this thing, I don't think we should just surrender and say,

1:29:14 oh, okay, flock, you're right.

1:29:16 You know, you did everything right.

1:29:18 If we find a better alternative vendor and we have to have a little discussion with them

1:29:21 about what's in the contract, why wouldn't be for sure?

1:29:23 What you say there is really important.

1:29:25 If we find a better vendor.

1:29:26 Yeah.

1:29:27 That's why I said, bring this back two months at least prior to the end of the contract.

1:29:31 Yes.

1:29:32 Look into what it is and is there a better vendor or not?

1:29:37 We don't know who flock will be then.

1:29:39 We know flock is fairly new.

1:29:41 Every new company goes through, you know, growing pains.

1:29:44 They've done some stupid things.

1:29:46 Maybe some of us up here have done some stupid things in our past as well,

1:29:50 but we haven't been cast aside.

1:29:52 Um, so that's where I would really still like to go.

1:29:55 Uh, bring us back a full report.

1:29:59 Can we get out of it?

1:30:00 What does it cost to change?

1:30:02 Cause there are upfront costs as well.

1:30:04 Um, with a full report so that we can make a good decision at that point.

1:30:08 So done.

1:30:09 So I'm still a little different on that one because to me, it would seem like we'd want

1:30:13 to start searching right away.

1:30:14 And then we, I think really have a public forum.

1:30:16 Let's talk about what's going on.

1:30:17 Let's make sure whatever we bring in people understand what the capabilities are.

1:30:21 Why not start searching sooner rather than later?

1:30:24 I mean, I got the contract.

1:30:25 I mean, we may not be able to take action for five months, but at least let's start that

1:30:30 search now.

1:30:31 Okay.

1:30:32 I'd be in favor of starting the search.

1:30:33 I don't have a problem with starting this search.

1:30:35 What I do have a problem with and switch providers as quickly as possible.

1:30:40 Um, after appropriate.

1:30:42 So that's and make sure there's transparency before we move forward.

1:30:46 Yeah.

1:30:47 Um, just to clarify, the town could simply tell flock to turn off the cameras.

1:30:52 Even if we can't get the money back that we've prepaid through the contract term, which is

1:30:56 still up in the air as to how this happened.

1:30:59 But even if we couldn't get the money back, the town could simply say, turn off the cameras

1:31:02 or we're done with you.

1:31:03 Um, and could enter into a contract with somebody else.

1:31:06 So, um, we could wait until the end, um, to start with a new provider or could start sooner.

1:31:12 And just to clarify that, if we say turn it off, they're no longer collecting data.

1:31:16 Okay.

1:31:17 So that's, we could make that transition sooner, assuming that, um, we find a better provider.

1:31:24 So I think Brent, I'm kind of with you on this.

1:31:26 Let's start looking now.

1:31:27 Mm-hmm.

1:31:28 Why, why wait till the end of the contract?

1:31:30 Let's start looking now.

1:31:31 Well, I can withdraw my motion if you, if somebody wants to, um, change, change some of

1:31:38 the wording on that, um, because going back to it, I do want to keep what we have for

1:31:46 right now, find, um, another provider.

1:31:51 But at, at this point, I don't see how anybody at this is in the mindset to even be accepted.

1:31:57 Well.

1:31:58 Acceptive of any type of change.

1:32:01 Can I offer a different?

1:32:03 Absolutely.

1:32:04 I want to direct the town manager to continue use of flock system and study alternative providers,

1:32:13 bringing us back a report as, to which make a decision.

1:32:19 I, I don't want to tie us into having to change providers as quickly as possible.

1:32:24 I don't know that the new one's going to be better, worse, or indifferent.

1:32:27 Yeah.

1:32:28 Um, but I'm anxious to hear, in a few months, a report as to how we think things are going,

1:32:34 and whether even the police have changed their mind on the use of flock.

1:32:38 Huh.

1:32:39 I, I mean, I also think that it's important if we are going to continue using ALPRs is that

1:32:44 we also develop transparency and monitoring tools for our public.

1:32:47 I will, I will add that to it.

1:32:49 So, added to my motion would be while continuing to develop transparency and monitoring tools for our public.

1:32:57 Do you want to give a timeline?

1:32:59 You just said they'd bring a report back.

1:33:00 Do you want to give a timeline as to how important this is to us?

1:33:03 Um.

1:33:04 Not being the person in town making the schedules up for our employees and knowing how busy our employees are.

1:33:09 Yeah.

1:33:10 I think in the best possible time would be what I would want, but I would not want to dictate a specific timeline, um,

1:33:18 that just puts an extra burden on our staff.

1:33:21 I, I, I, again, I'm, I'm, I'm hearing repeatedly from the public having this thing open and not pursuing this,

1:33:33 not, you know, irresponsibly, but to be pursuing an alternative vendor, an alternative toolkit,

1:33:41 an alternative vendor that we could at least have some representation that they're responsible,

1:33:46 that they're credible, uh, they're not, they're not the subject of nationwide suspicion and court actions.

1:33:52 I think we can do a little bit better than a report.

1:33:54 I'm just saying I don't know that.

1:33:57 So I don't want in my motion, I would be very uncomfortable saying we are going to change providers as quickly as possible.

1:34:04 I want to, in that motion, I want to look at all potential outcomes so that I can make an informed decision and not a knee-jerk reaction.

1:34:14 Um.

1:34:15 Well, I would, I would, I would offer to maybe modify that a little bit to just direct staff to start pursuing alternative vendors,

1:34:24 bring those alternative vendors back, uh, rather than just a static report,

1:34:30 but bring back some alternatives that the new council could look at to say,

1:34:34 oh, look, we have some alternatives, and then they can consider switching vendors.

1:34:38 I would offer that modification to the motion.

1:34:41 As long as we're not setting it in stone.

1:34:43 And we are continuing to look at how Flock is performing.

1:34:46 Yes, they have failed in the past.

1:34:48 That doesn't mean that's going to continue going forward.

1:34:50 I have no confidence in Flock.

1:34:52 So I, I, I am not, I'm, I'm, I know, hearing from the public, I'm not, I'm not interested in sort of giving Flock another chance.

1:35:00 I think Flock has proven they are what they are.

1:35:03 So let's maybe actively start looking for alternative vendors and bring that back to a fresh council and see what that looks like.

1:35:09 Please stop, uh, speaking for everyone.

1:35:11 I'm speaking for myself.

1:35:12 And I'm speaking on behalf of the public what I heard.

1:35:14 I know what you're saying on the public.

1:35:15 What you heard here.

1:35:16 What I heard here.

1:35:17 What I heard from constituents in written communications.

1:35:18 And you didn't hear one person in, but you're saying we as a whole.

1:35:20 So please just refrain from speaking for everyone.

1:35:22 I'm speaking on behalf of the constituents that I've heard from this evening,

1:35:25 and what I've heard from in written communications that I've heard in the public.

1:35:28 That's what I'm speaking on behalf of.

1:35:29 Okay.

1:35:33 It's been positive towards ALPR, CCTV, and Flock.

1:35:38 So I'll put that out there.

1:35:40 Do we have a motion on the floor?

1:35:42 Do you want to clarify what motion is on the floor at the moment?

1:35:45 Council Member Hoff made a motion and then I believe withdrew it.

1:35:48 I withdrew my motion.

1:35:49 At the moment there's no motion on the floor.

1:35:50 Council Member Souser made a motion and then John tried to modify it.

1:35:55 Council Member Souser said direct the town manager to continue to use the block ALPR system while continuing to build transparency and monitoring tools and direct staff to study alternative providers bringing back the report to town council to make a decision.

1:36:11 I'm good with that.

1:36:13 And I will second that.

1:36:14 I mean, I thought that bringing back a report is different than bringing back options.

1:36:23 I see it.

1:36:27 I think staff listening to us has understood our direction and where we're going.

1:36:32 So I will stand with that motion.

1:36:34 We have a second.

1:36:37 Do you want to make any more comments, Brent?

1:36:38 I would prefer the motion to be that we look at options and come back with options.

1:36:42 Yeah.

1:36:43 A report's going to be a little, it's an open end and I recognize staff time, but I would like to see where we go and recommend it.

1:36:51 Options doesn't necessarily mean we jump on that day, but we need to be transparent and be open to everybody and see what options are.

1:36:58 Would you like to modify your motion?

1:37:00 Okay, Jamie, where are we going to stick in there?

1:37:05 Instead of reports, you're going to bring back options for the town council.

1:37:09 Yeah.

1:37:10 How about report and bring back options in this?

1:37:12 Okay.

1:37:13 Do we have a second?

1:37:14 Are you okay with that change for the second?

1:37:17 I'll continue with my second.

1:37:19 Okay.

1:37:20 Okay.

1:37:21 Roll call, please.

1:37:22 Council Member Souser?

1:37:23 Yes.

1:37:24 Council Member Wentworth?

1:37:25 Yes.

1:37:26 Council Member Hough?

1:37:27 Yes.

1:37:28 Mayor Pro Tem 2x?

1:37:29 Yes.

1:37:30 Mayor Rice?

1:37:31 Yes.

1:37:32 Okay.

1:37:33 Thank you.

1:37:34 Thank you.

1:37:36 It's Marcus.

1:37:37 Just teeing up his presentation.

1:37:38 I'll let him present that and I'm just here for moral support.

1:38:06 Thank you.

1:38:07 Thank you.

1:38:20 We're about to run out of funding.

1:38:21 So we're here tonight with a request for an additional $150,000 to continue that funding

1:38:27 for approximately another year.

1:38:31 The program started in July of 24 and had an initial allocation of $425,000.

1:38:37 In March of this year, council approved an additional $120,000.

1:38:42 So that's $545,000 total.

1:38:45 And as of this meeting, $523,463 have been spent.

1:38:50 So there's, I think, enough for one more grant left.

1:38:53 But if we don't provide more funding, the program essentially will end next month.

1:39:00 The program, I think you all know, is designed to incentivize property owners to switch from

1:39:05 short-term renting to longer-term leases.

1:39:09 We've had 38 grants to date.

1:39:12 Those are grants to the property owner.

1:39:14 And that has housed 99 tenants in those 38 properties.

1:39:22 The average grant amount to the owner is around $9,700.

1:39:25 And the average lease term is just under 11 months.

1:39:32 The individual tenant income is around $60,000.

1:39:35 So middle income.

1:39:38 And the retention rate, so basically once the grant ends, how many landlords are continuing

1:39:44 to rent long-term is around 58%.

1:39:48 I have a little chart up there on the table.

1:39:52 It's also in your report there.

1:39:54 So you can kind of see the breakdown there.

1:39:57 And the $150,000 would come out of the Housing Now initiative as it has before.

1:40:03 And would continue the program.

1:40:05 And Placemate would continue to administer it.

1:40:08 That's all I have.

1:40:14 Any questions for Marcus?

1:40:17 Just if you could maybe give a quick summary.

1:40:20 I think I've seen gradual adoption of this program over time.

1:40:26 And it seems to be proving its effectiveness.

1:40:29 Is that a consistent, is that consistent with what you guys are seeing with this program?

1:40:34 Yeah, certainly.

1:40:35 You know, I think in 2024 when it started, there was outreach.

1:40:38 There were some mailers that were sent out to property owners.

1:40:41 There was marketing.

1:40:43 But really that's ended and it's really word of mouth at this point.

1:40:46 I think the success of property owners and they just tell their neighbors or, you know, their friends.

1:40:51 And so it's very consistent.

1:40:53 I think it's operating in a steady clip, you know, one, two a month.

1:40:57 It sort of fluctuates throughout the year.

1:40:59 But I think it's matured.

1:41:00 And we've also, last year we amended the contract to go to a pay for performance.

1:41:05 So now it's $2,200 per grant.

1:41:08 So it's, I think it's stabilizing and it feels like it's a good place.

1:41:13 It's fitting into the Housing Now initiative.

1:41:14 It sort of serves this niche area for middle income where we just have a chronic under supply.

1:41:21 And it's helping in that area, I think.

1:41:25 Good.

1:41:26 That's it. Thank you.

1:41:27 I'd just like to add something real quick.

1:41:28 So as you know, throughout this year we've been involved in sort of a lengthy discussion around missing

1:41:35 middle approach, right, and the town's opportunities to do that.

1:41:38 Missing middle is very, very difficult to address because it involves a group of individuals

1:41:44 that don't yet qualify or don't qualify for state level grant funding that provided for, you know,

1:41:49 low-income housing like the parcel project that, you know, is 238 units that were recently produced

1:41:56 or in the process of being finished.

1:41:58 Those are really dedicated based on state funding.

1:42:02 Missing middle is labeled that because there are no programs statewide to support that.

1:42:09 So anything the town would do would require us to invest in that completely.

1:42:13 The town has been very successful in the higher income brackets of 150 to 200 percent AMI

1:42:20 with programs like the bridge program or our small site development.

1:42:24 We're building units to be sold to these individuals.

1:42:27 The missing middle is still a rental market.

1:42:31 And when you look at that project, even if something like was developed and built on the parcel,

1:42:36 that's about a $60 million building that was put together.

1:42:40 And then you would have rents that would have to be paying for those debt service costs across time.

1:42:46 That's the discussion that we've been having.

1:42:48 That's a very lengthy, a very sort of protracted process by which that would be accomplished.

1:42:53 And in the meantime, the only tool that we have functioning in the middle income class is this leasing to locals.

1:43:01 So I think to that end, I wanted to kind of accentuate the point that it's really our only game in that space.

1:43:08 Yeah. Great. Thank you.

1:43:10 Any other questions? No?

1:43:12 Well, any public comment from anyone on the road?

1:43:26 Anyone online? No? Okay. Thoughts?

1:43:30 I'm prepared to make a motion.

1:43:32 No, I can just make one thought if I could.

1:43:34 I'll end up supporting because it's the only thing that we have,

1:43:37 but I would rather see us building or acquiring units so we can control those long-term.

1:43:41 I know we're talking about that down the road, but that would be my preference because long-term,

1:43:45 that makes much more sense to use of money.

1:43:47 Without that, though, we don't have another tool.

1:43:49 I still don't have a unit, but it provides a useful and meaningful situation right now.

1:43:56 For me, it's very similar.

1:44:00 We need a permanent solution for housing.

1:44:04 The more money we spend on temporary solutions, the less money we have for a permanent solution to the problem.

1:44:12 If we adopt this now and we spend another couple hundred thousand next year and whatever,

1:44:17 how much longer down the road does that put us before we can actually pull the trigger on our own missing middle project,

1:44:24 which would provide many more homes and make them permanent?

1:44:29 So I still feel for the people that need a place to stay, but I still feel like the best solution for our money is to try and create permanent solutions.

1:44:46 I mean, looking at this, 525,000, and we helped 99 tenants, right, Marcus?

1:44:53 Your numbers were pretty small, but I think I read that part.

1:44:56 Yes, that's right.

1:44:57 We helped 99 tenants.

1:44:59 You know, through our bridge program, that would have purchased two units.

1:45:03 You know, I think that there is value in this.

1:45:06 I hear what you're saying.

1:45:07 I also would like to have a long-term solution for middle-income rentals.

1:45:11 This is our only product that's a middle-income rental product.

1:45:15 And, you know, while it does feel like we're spending this money on a short-term plan, 10 units kept their long-term renters, right?

1:45:30 That's what your chart said.

1:45:31 That's what your chart said.

1:45:32 10 units kept their long-term renters.

1:45:33 So we paid for a subsidy for one year, and hopefully they continue to rent to those people for a much longer time.

1:45:42 You know, and hopefully we can convert all of these empty units that we have around town into long-term rentals.

1:45:51 So I'm in favor of funding.

1:45:54 I would just add to that.

1:45:55 I mean, we have, you know, we've had several presentations from staff about a missing middle program.

1:45:59 And I think the mayor points out a very good component of this, which is a question of scale, because the kind of commitment that a council is going to have to make to get into the missing middle world is many, many millions of dollars.

1:46:11 It's a very creative financing.

1:46:13 It's a big leap.

1:46:14 So, but in the interim, we've got something.

1:46:16 It seems to be adopted.

1:46:17 It seems to be doing something.

1:46:18 So it's part of why I come back to supporting it, at least in the short term.

1:46:22 Something you said made me, I do have a question.

1:46:25 So once they have somebody in there for 11 months, are they allowed to, is this in perpetuity that they're getting this allowance?

1:46:35 It's one time per property.

1:46:37 One time per property.

1:46:38 So even if that property change owned or something, that would keep a record of the actual property and then it's just one time.

1:46:43 Okay.

1:46:44 And have there been anybody who has kind of taken advantage of this in a way that you are aware of?

1:46:51 Like applied more than once or?

1:46:53 Well, that or just knowing, oh, wait a minute, I can get this money if I do this with my property.

1:46:59 And because when I was going through the, through the note, I mean, they still are getting a percentage from the renters, correct?

1:47:09 Right.

1:47:10 So there's rent limits for the program.

1:47:13 So there's a certain amount of rent they can charge.

1:47:16 And then in addition to that, they get this grant, half of it's paid up front and half of it's paid at the end when the lease ends.

1:47:22 So it's an incentive.

1:47:24 It's true.

1:47:25 The amount of the grant is basically trying to compete with what they would get from short-term renting.

1:47:29 So kind of the goal is so that a short-term rental property for someone who lives out of town, they can try out long-term renting.

1:47:35 And hopefully it works out well, they have good tenants, they have good experience, and then they just continue that.

1:47:40 So we're trying to sort of create some vacancy in a very tight market.

1:47:44 That's kind of this program.

1:47:45 It's a niche program.

1:47:46 It's not a huge program.

1:47:47 It's not a huge amount of money.

1:47:48 But we're trying to create some movement in the rental market and especially with the short-term rental kind of shift some of that away.

1:47:54 And I guess my other question, because I have missed a lot of this discussion throughout the last few years, but it would be, have there been any complaints from other people in neighborhoods or where these places are, where the people who we are, our taxpayer dollars are going to help them have a place to live, that they've inadvertently

1:48:18 caused trouble for other people, whether it's with parking, neighbor disputes, anything.

1:48:24 I've never seen any report on anything about that.

1:48:28 I haven't heard yet.

1:48:29 Nothing has come across my desk.

1:48:30 Okay.

1:48:31 That's all.

1:48:32 Then I'm good.

1:48:33 Okay.

1:48:34 I'd entertain a motion.

1:48:36 Thank you, Madam Mayor.

1:48:37 I would move that the Town Council adopt the resolution to provide an additional $150,000 in funding for the Lease to Locals program.

1:48:44 I'll second.

1:48:46 Roll call.

1:48:47 Roll call.

1:48:48 Council Member Souser?

1:48:49 No.

1:48:50 Council Member Wentworth?

1:48:51 Yes.

1:48:52 Council Member Hawke?

1:48:53 Yes.

1:48:54 Mayor Pro Tem Truex?

1:48:55 Yes.

1:48:56 Mayor Rice?

1:48:57 Yes.

1:48:58 Okay.

1:48:59 You guys want to go through this next one and then take a break?

1:49:03 Okay.

1:49:04 We're on to item 9.4, Discuss the Mammoth Crossing Development Agreement Application.

1:49:09 Great.

1:49:13 Thank you.

1:49:14 So for this item tonight, there are really two components of what I'd call a very preliminary discussion on the Mammoth Crossing Development Agreement Application.

1:49:25 First is that pursuant to Municipal Code Section 17.104.030 is that staff is to provide notification to the Town Council once the Development Agreement application has been submitted.

1:49:38 So first off, this completes that component of it.

1:49:43 For this project, the development agreement has been submitted to the Town, I'd say prematurely, at least in the process, and was largely submitted as a component of the larger entitlement application for the overall Mammoth Crossing project.

1:50:01 For this project, there are components of the project that the applicant is proposing to be addressed through a development agreement and therefore they felt compelled to submit the development agreement in order to have their application deemed complete.

1:50:15 Being deemed complete is really just the necessary first step to accept an application to begin the review process under the Municipal Code.

1:50:26 It's not saying that the application is approved or that everything is accurate.

1:50:30 It's just that they have submitted everything required to really begin processing that application.

1:50:35 Based on initial review of the development agreement, staff feels the development is missing some critical items, with the biggest missing item being what the TOT revenue sharing component is that they are seeking, such as how long, what percentage, how much.

1:50:54 None of that information is included in what they submitted.

1:50:57 So really, we just have what they are proposing as the public benefits and also what they're proposing as components of their project that are being addressed through the development agreement.

1:51:08 So the second item that staff is looking for direction on tonight is whether to begin formal negotiations with the applicant on the development agreement.

1:51:17 The prior direction from town council in April of this year related to this item was that they wished for the financial analysis of the TOT revenue sharing component to be completed prior to agreeing or even commencing negotiations on a development agreement.

1:51:35 So that item is still outstanding.

1:51:38 The two financial consultants are working on that and reviewing the financial numbers, but they have not provided a final report or really even a preliminary report to town staff on what that might look like.

1:51:51 So based on those two elements, one being the town council direction to wait until the financial analysis was complete, and second, that the development agreement does not currently include what the proposed revenue sharing ask might be.

1:52:06 Staff's recommendation would be to wait to begin negotiations until that analysis has been completed and has then been presented to town council.

1:52:14 So at that time staff would be looking for direction from town council on whether to then really move forward with negotiating a development agreement and whether there is at least interest in learning more about what a TOT revenue sharing agreement might look like in the case of this project.

1:52:31 So with that I'll-

1:52:33 So Nolan, just real quick clarification, you indicated with those sort of financial analysis efforts that are going on right now, those would culminate in a report to council within a decision point being made as to whether or not to move forward with anything associated with this project, at least within a development agreement, because that information is critical in providing that knowledge.

1:52:55 But that would be sort of even in advance of deciding to pursue the development agreement discussion.

1:53:00 That is correct.

1:53:01 Questions?

1:53:03 John?

1:53:04 I have two questions.

1:53:05 Andy, in my experience with development agreements, typically a developer pursues entitlements, gets entitlements, and then will come back to the council and say, okay, I would like to pursue a development agreement to perhaps lock in rights or things that I have.

1:53:25 Is that-

1:53:26 Uh, it's more common for the developer to ask for the development agreement upfront, um, and not, not have it granted upfront, but the idea is that usually they want to know that there's some chance that they're going to get a development agreement as they're asking for their entitlements.

1:53:40 So that the whole time, um, they're asking for entitlements that include the benefits that come with the development agreement, which are typically locking in landing standards, sometimes impact fees, um, vesting a project for some term of years.

1:53:54 So it's usually the development agreement discussions are happening all along.

1:53:59 Okay.

1:54:00 And once the entitlements are given.

1:54:01 But in terms of satisfying the needs of a project application, is what staff is bringing for tonight, is it, is it simply sort of a check the box exercise?

1:54:12 That this developed, this draft development agreement needs to be considered at this time?

1:54:17 Well, I mean, the developer could change their application a bit to kind of work around the fact that we don't have financial analysis.

1:54:24 I mean, certainly nothing's preventing them from saying, you know, we're not even going to ask for a TOT rebate.

1:54:31 And then the town can simply process the, the application, um, without that being an issue.

1:54:36 Okay.

1:54:37 Yeah.

1:54:38 Cause it kind of begs questions.

1:54:39 I don't know where the, I don't know if even here tonight, but I just find like a third question.

1:54:43 So Nolan, you're, when you say there's an option for the town to start to negotiating a development agreement,

1:54:49 I'm just a little curious why that would even be suggested when the council has made it very clear that we want to see this financial report first before having those conversations.

1:54:58 Is that, do you have an obligation to ask us if we want to do that legally or something or?

1:55:03 Um, so we felt since they had submitted at least the application with the current council,

1:55:08 we at least wanted to bring it forward that yes, an application has been submitted.

1:55:12 And we didn't want, um, this council or a future council to say that we were just sitting on it and not,

1:55:18 not bringing it forward at least to acknowledge that it's been submitted.

1:55:21 Okay.

1:55:22 But the staff recommendation is not to, is not to start negotiating anything.

1:55:25 Is that, do I hear that right?

1:55:26 That is correct.

1:55:27 Okay.

1:55:28 I do want to, I do want to ask Nolan to add some comments that were specific to,

1:55:32 um, the recommend or the notes that, that, um, Andy provided.

1:55:36 And that's that this particular, um, application, I think there is a direct correlation to a development agreement component.

1:55:44 That's sort of abnormal.

1:55:45 Correct.

1:55:46 So in this case with their application, um, with their entitlement application and with this unique project,

1:55:53 um, with the mammoth crossing sites, um, through their, um, certified EIR for the site,

1:55:59 that addressed, um, the workforce housing component for the future project,

1:56:03 they are proposing to address their, um, workforce housing, um,

1:56:08 they have kind of three different options laid out in the development agreement, which differ from what was certified in the EIR.

1:56:14 So they are proposing to satisfy that component through the development agreement,

1:56:18 but they needed to provide what they were going to do for workforce housing in order, in order to be deemed complete.

1:56:24 So it was unique in this case in that we needed at least a draft of what their kind of ask would be for that component,

1:56:30 in order to satisfy that completeness item of their application.

1:56:34 Okay.

1:56:35 But just, I'm sorry to go on, but there's that, the draft of development agreement is not in the agenda packet.

1:56:40 Am I right?

1:56:41 That is correct.

1:56:42 So we don't even know what they're asking for.

1:56:43 So, okay.

1:56:44 Thank you very much.

1:56:45 That's my questions.

1:56:46 Questions?

1:56:47 One question, sort of rhetorical.

1:56:49 Is there any other information that's not in your report that would make us think that we'd want to change our decision

1:56:54 and not wait for a financial report to decide where we want to go from there to do any negotiations at this point in time?

1:57:01 I'd say no, because we're in a position where we don't have any clue what we're negotiating against,

1:57:07 since we don't know what their potential TOT sharing ask might be.

1:57:12 And I'll just say, I mean, I've negotiated a bunch of development agreements,

1:57:16 and the negotiations are always kind of holistic.

1:57:19 And the more the developer asks for, the more we will ask for.

1:57:22 And it's hard to segregate out different things.

1:57:25 You're kind of looking at the whole thing in its entirety.

1:57:28 So since we don't know what the ask is on this huge piece,

1:57:31 which is a striking departure from anything the town's ever done,

1:57:34 we don't know what we might want to ask for in return.

1:57:37 And I will say also that negotiating development agreement is a very time-intensive effort.

1:57:42 It's going to require a fair bit of my time, a fair bit of staff time.

1:57:45 And if the ultimate response from the council is, we're not doing revenue sharing,

1:57:51 the developer certainly is posturing at this point that without revenue sharing,

1:57:55 they don't want to do the project.

1:57:56 So that would mean that we could have wasted a lot of time negotiating a development agreement that's not going to proceed.

1:58:02 So, I mean, I would agree with Nolan that it doesn't seem maybe like the best use of staff resources

1:58:08 to start negotiating something that may not come to fruition at all.

1:58:12 So are you asking us to weigh in if we'd be supportive of a TOT revenue sharing agreement tonight?

1:58:19 No, absolutely not.

1:58:20 I think we're just looking for some direction on, do you want us to start negotiating this thing,

1:58:23 or are you perfectly happy to direct staff to wait until we have all the financial analysis back?

1:58:30 I do have a question about the DA.

1:58:32 Is this something that will say it goes through the whole process, we spend all this money,

1:58:37 they spend all their money, all their consultants do things.

1:58:40 Is this something that's transferable when they end up just jumping that hurdle so they can just sell the property to someone else for more money?

1:58:48 Yeah.

1:58:49 Okay.

1:58:50 Development agreements by their nature go with the property.

1:58:52 Okay.

1:58:53 You know what?

1:58:54 And we have had some similar things, but it was a while back.

1:58:59 So I don't think this is totally the craziest thing I've ever read with the DA with the council.

1:59:06 So maybe I'm missing that portion, but okay.

1:59:10 I do want to clarify the town is not spending money on this financial analysis.

1:59:15 Well, you would end up, what are you saying, with the staff time?

1:59:19 Well, yeah, the staff time.

1:59:21 I have to pay these people anyway, unfortunately, but they get to work on that.

1:59:25 But the financial analysis and hiring those consultants, those dueling consultants that are working on that,

1:59:30 that's strictly on the dime of the applicant.

1:59:33 Yeah, and my time as well.

1:59:34 I mean, even though I work for everyday low prices, we typically can ask the developer to provide a deposit that we can bill against so the town's not paying me, or at least not ultimately paying me.

1:59:46 Is there a timeline when Cosmont is going to have their report finalized?

1:59:51 We do not.

1:59:52 I know the Cosmont consultant and the applicant consultant are in touch and trading emails and numbers back and forth, but we do not yet have when we might have that report.

2:00:04 So it's not a hurry up and wait.

2:00:08 It's just a wait.

2:00:10 Okay.

2:00:11 Any other questions?

2:00:13 Do you really need anything from us tonight?

2:00:15 If we don't make any motion, it just keeps going as we originally directed.

2:00:19 Is that not the case?

2:00:21 Yeah, it's not a, not a formal motion.

2:00:23 It's more of a, as council, if there was a strong desire to do something different than that, we'd be looking for that.

2:00:29 But if council, you know, based on consensus is good with waiting for that, that piece to come back, then that's enough direction for staff.

2:00:39 Okay.

2:00:40 Any other questions?

2:00:41 No?

2:00:42 Public comment?

2:00:43 Anyone in the room?

2:00:44 Come on down.

2:00:45 Hi, my name is Kathy Cage.

2:00:52 I'm here primarily as one of the council members who agreed to the, one of the most impactful development agreements in this town.

2:01:00 The one with InterWest up in North Village.

2:01:02 And, and I've been dismayed in the conversations where I went back and watched the April meeting.

2:01:08 And, um, most of the conversation has been directed about the finances.

2:01:11 Like, oh, assess the finances.

2:01:12 It'll be worth it or whatever.

2:01:14 Um, that's not really the biggest question though in terms of impact of the town and assessing the public good, which is, you know, what you're supposed to do.

2:01:22 Um, the biggest impact is the development agreement will fix the development standards for a period of probably a minimum of 20 years.

2:01:29 The one with InterWest was 25.

2:01:30 The one you just did with Snow Creek was 20.

2:01:33 You already have a specific plan that's 35 years old and staffs right now going through a process with, you know, people in the community trying to address the problems that already exist up there with congestion and traffic and parking and all that sort of things that are caused.

2:01:51 Because that was an aspirational plan done at a different time that, that, for which there are things that don't really exist that never materialized.

2:02:00 One of the things that underlie that plan was a level of parking that developers are required to, to, to put in there.

2:02:07 Um, presuming we'd have a great transportation system that, for instance, employees would take to go to work.

2:02:12 So, of course, they have no employee parking there.

2:02:14 You work in the village, you can't go underground and park there.

2:02:17 There's no parking for you there.

2:02:18 You know, we, the, um, the first phase of the village that way, Weston's that way, 8050, limelight.

2:02:24 They're all that way.

2:02:25 Their employees don't go underground and park.

2:02:27 They're not allowed to.

2:02:28 That's one of the impacts of that aspirational plan that really is a fantasy.

2:02:34 So, if you agree to a DA for which we have an underlying plan that's 35 years old, woefully outdated.

2:02:41 Parking's just the first thing.

2:02:43 Housing, all that kind of stuff is, is woefully outdated.

2:02:46 To think that someone could, could give you a fee enough to build enough housing to, um, mitigate their housing impact off site anymore, I think is delusion.

2:02:59 We don't have enough, you know, landed down anymore.

2:03:01 The fact that we don't have required minimum inclusionary housing in our development is, is, is wrong.

2:03:08 We shouldn't continue that.

2:03:09 There's no way we should continue that.

2:03:10 If you agree to a DA for crossing or anyone else who owns that property based on old standards that don't meet today's needs anymore, that's wrong.

2:03:21 That's not in the public interest, not in the public good.

2:03:24 I don't care how much, you know, whatever benefits they think.

2:03:27 And, and in the staff report, it showed, and I might be interpreting this wrong, but the last time that there was a sequence statement of overriding consideration was 17 years ago.

2:03:38 So, we're basing on some presumed value that town would have, or they assessed it 17 years ago, and part of that was some presumption we might do revenue sharing.

2:03:48 Like, which one of you is holding your hand up and saying, I absolutely would consider revenue sharing just because we can get the benefit of three more corners that look like Rock Spring.

2:03:59 You know, are you hearing a human cry from our community?

2:04:02 That's what we want.

2:04:03 You should give us some of our future revenue so that we can make that happen.

2:04:07 I mean, I don't know what town you're living in, but I don't live in that town.

2:04:10 So, I think you could help the developer by saying today, like, no, under no circumstances would I consider revenue sharing.

2:04:18 That would help the process, but it would help everybody.

2:04:20 Save some money, save some time consideration.

2:04:23 I like market rate development.

2:04:25 Like, you put some zoning in place, even these horribly outdated standards.

2:04:29 If they want to do a development to our horribly outdated standards, which really are a gift, basically a gift, and they still can't make it pencil, then it shouldn't happen.

2:04:38 I mean, that's a market rate development.

2:04:40 To think that you would be acting in the public interest by, you know, giving them a little crumb and saying, well, I might consider some revenue sharing under whatever.

2:04:50 I think it's disingenuous.

2:04:51 I don't know which one of you think you're going to get reelected by having that kind of platform.

2:04:57 Oh, we need more development in that North Village with inadequate parking and all that stuff.

2:05:02 Anyway, so, one of my big points is, also, this is a lame duck council.

2:05:08 I can see why staff wants to bring it back to the same council and going, okay, are you still on board?

2:05:13 But I mean, Cleveland wasn't even here in April.

2:05:15 And two of you aren't going to be here to vote on it.

2:05:17 The truth is, it'd be more productive if you brought this back to the newly seated council, who would be the ones who would act on it.

2:05:23 You guys giving direction isn't really that helpful because you're not going to be there to vote on it.

2:05:27 So, anyway, my suggestion is that you ask staff to wait and bring this whole thing back when the new council's seated, have a chance to take a breath,

2:05:36 so you can take the temperature of the new council and we can give the community a chance to give all you guys, the new council, some input about whether we might be on board under any circumstances for future revenue sharing.

2:05:48 And secondly, do we feel like we want to extend these 35-year-old outdated standards for another 20 years?

2:05:55 There you go.

2:05:56 Thank you, Kathy.

2:05:57 I'd just like to clarify a point or two.

2:06:02 There is a lot of wisdom in what Kathy is saying, but just a couple little clarifications.

2:06:07 The term of the development agreement, like everything else, is subject to negotiation.

2:06:10 It doesn't have to be 20 years.

2:06:11 It could be 10 years.

2:06:12 It could be five years.

2:06:13 It could be whatever we negotiate.

2:06:14 With respect to parking and housing and other aspects of the specific plan that may be out of date,

2:06:19 one of the things about development agreement is the town is not constrained by nexus or by our current standards.

2:06:25 So the town can negotiate for more parking than would otherwise be required, more housing than would otherwise be required.

2:06:32 Anything that the council and the community feel is a good thing to negotiate for, we can negotiate for.

2:06:37 So valid point about the specific plan maybe being under review and maybe not being the set of standards we want,

2:06:44 but if the direction is to negotiate for something different, something better, we can do that.

2:06:50 I'd like to clarify another point too with regard to the decision to bring it to this council.

2:06:54 This council is the one that authorized the processing of the financial analysis to understand what even the ask could be.

2:07:03 It may be zero.

2:07:04 It won't be, but it'll be something.

2:07:08 I felt as the town manager that if I receive something and I sit on it and hold on it and wait for another council to be there,

2:07:15 I am in absolute violation of what I'm expected to do.

2:07:18 And it looks like I'm in collusion with something else.

2:07:21 So there's a reason it's here tonight before this council.

2:07:24 And knowing that, you know, likely the answer coming back to us would be don't do any negotiation.

2:07:31 Wait until we get the financial analysis that we've asked you to complete done, make a decision on that,

2:07:36 and then whole conversation will begin about whether or not revenue sharing is something that we even want to entertain

2:07:42 and that will be fully with the new council.

2:07:44 Sandy, welcome.

2:07:48 Sandy Hogan.

2:07:49 Good to see you.

2:07:50 And I just want to thank you guys for your questions, Cleland and Rob, the clarification, Andy especially,

2:07:59 because I was thinking, you know, I think I went to an original public planning for this crossing between 10 and 15 years ago.

2:08:13 You might have been there, Bill.

2:08:15 I don't know.

2:08:16 But I was there and I just can't remember how big it was, but it was obviously a public meeting.

2:08:23 And I'm thinking, well, why are they bringing this forward, this incomplete, you know?

2:08:30 And you answered my question there because I thought, are they trying to get this concept plan finalized,

2:08:38 wasting our time, your time, your time, everybody's time?

2:08:43 But I'm glad you brought it forward because maybe we can, how can I follow Kathy?

2:08:49 But exactly, these are good questions to bring up.

2:08:53 It's been on the books a long time.

2:08:56 And we've seen other plans, I think, or accepted applications turn around and be sold to the next developer.

2:09:06 And do they come in for, who knows?

2:09:09 So, yeah.

2:09:11 You answered a lot of the good questions.

2:09:13 You had a good, some good questions.

2:09:15 And these guys answered it.

2:09:17 And so, yeah.

2:09:19 If there's a reason to bring it forward, to give a little history.

2:09:23 And maybe now's not the time.

2:09:27 There's another council coming in and you guys are going to be there.

2:09:31 And you can give them the background, maybe not opinions.

2:09:35 You know, just give them good objective facts because you're going to be the experts on this.

2:09:41 And, or with staff.

2:09:44 And let's mull it over and ask for that, a better application for sure.

2:09:51 Not an incomplete one.

2:09:53 Thank you.

2:09:54 Thank you, Sandy.

2:09:55 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

2:09:58 Anyone online?

2:10:00 Okay.

2:10:01 Chad, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments?

2:10:05 Hi, this is Chuck Phillips, local resident and business owner.

2:10:10 I just wanted to say that I agree with most of what Cathy said.

2:10:14 I think allowing developments under this specific plan that is so outdated

2:10:20 and doesn't align with our current economics and demographics and everything is kind of a mistake.

2:10:26 But, you know, at the end of the day, I think you don't have all the information you need.

2:10:30 And I think that you should wait for that financial study.

2:10:32 That's all.

2:10:33 Thank you.

2:10:34 Thank you, Chad.

2:10:36 Anyone else online?

2:10:37 No.

2:10:38 Okay.

2:10:39 Any other deliberations?

2:10:40 Thoughts?

2:10:41 Well, I just, I don't know how the rest of you all feel, but I think my original skepticism

2:10:47 of this development agreement, I voted against even doing the financial analysis.

2:10:53 Cathy Cage has brought forward, and Sandy, you know, real historical perspective on all this.

2:10:59 And I think that the work that staff is doing with the North Village Pacific plan, I was able to attend that meeting last week.

2:11:07 We've got a much more significant and glaring set of challenges in front of us with the North Village, especially given the fact that the mountain is now making it pretty clear they're not developing anything else.

2:11:21 And as Cathy said in a letter to the editor, you know, so the North Village is going to be the only built environment access to the ski area?

2:11:30 Is that kind of where we're landing with this?

2:11:33 So I, again, I think, and again, hearing from constituents, people come up to me and say, do not go anywhere near that thing.

2:11:40 Don't even talk about a revenue sharing agreement.

2:11:44 And that was my original instinct to say, look, we shouldn't even be entertaining something like this.

2:11:48 So I'm where I'm at.

2:11:50 If this comes back with the future council as a member of the public, I would certainly be advocating of that and be very, very careful of the situation.

2:11:56 But Cathy and Sandy, thanks for coming forward in your comments, and they were spot on.

2:12:00 So I agree with what we'll say.

2:12:01 That's where I'm at.

2:12:02 Thank you, John.

2:12:03 Cleland?

2:12:04 I think historically when we have had such things, I have been someone who has said, yeah, no, no sharing going on whatsoever.

2:12:13 And I have seen things, entities, they can just get in a little bit of what they want.

2:12:25 It puts their value for selling whatever they're having.

2:12:29 This doesn't mean these people are developing it.

2:12:32 In the past, I have been, hey, let them bring their request to us.

2:12:37 We'll make that decision later.

2:12:39 But now I realize I probably have cost some developers a heck of a lot of money in the past, knowing that they are not fitting into the Mammoth Lakes area.

2:12:51 What they're asking for, what they want is not going to happen.

2:12:54 So, yeah.

2:12:56 Thank you so much for the public comments.

2:12:59 Rick?

2:13:01 No.

2:13:02 She called your name.

2:13:04 From my standpoint, what's being asked tonight is it's actually very good timing because I think we stay the course.

2:13:13 We don't negotiate until we have analysis.

2:13:16 And then at that point in time, it comes back to the full council of who's here and decide what, if, where, when, if not.

2:13:23 At that point in time, I've got a feeling we're still going to be a few days before that comes back.

2:13:28 So just stay the course.

2:13:31 Yeah.

2:13:32 I absolutely do not have enough information.

2:13:34 There are things beyond even the financial reports that have crossed my desk anyway.

2:13:40 So I don't want to waste this council's time dealing on a DA that is an illusion.

2:13:50 Yeah.

2:13:51 No thanks to an incomplete application.

2:13:53 Okay.

2:13:54 Do we need a motion?

2:13:57 No.

2:13:58 Yeah, I think I do.

2:13:59 Okay.

2:14:00 Great.

2:14:01 Let's take a little break.

2:14:03 Five minutes?

2:14:04 You guys fine with that?

2:14:05 I'm fine.

2:14:06 Yeah?

2:14:07 Okay.

2:14:08 Five minutes.

2:14:09 Okay.

2:14:10 We're going to come back in session.

2:26:14 We've all got our snacks.

2:26:17 Okay.

2:26:18 We are going to give this a few more wax.

2:26:25 We are moving on to item 9.5.

2:26:28 Discuss the overnight safe parking plan for winter 2026-27.

2:26:32 Great.

2:26:37 Thank you.

2:26:38 I had to swallow my, my wasabi peanuts here.

2:26:41 Thank you for the snacks.

2:26:42 So staff been working on various concepts for the, the safe parking program or safe overnight

2:26:48 parking programs for the past few years.

2:26:51 This includes potential kind of public private partnerships with private property owners.

2:26:58 We spent a number of years and staff time looking at a partnership program with Mono County

2:27:03 for use of county owned property.

2:27:05 And most recently in winter 2526, we operated a 90 day pilot program that allowed for locally

2:27:13 individuals who resided reside in their vehicles to obtain a permit from the town to park over,

2:27:19 to legally park overnight and sleep in their vehicles.

2:27:22 The pilot program was operated in the upper community center parking lot off forest trail from February to May,

2:27:29 2026.

2:27:30 And it was really, you know, stood up fairly quickly to address the immediate need that was caused by the significant snowfall during that period,

2:27:38 which then limited or eliminated overnight parking options on adjacent public lands.

2:27:43 I think despite that program being stood up, you know, quickly by staff and really was spread and communicated via word of mouth to those participants.

2:27:54 So, you know, the, the program was a success.

2:27:57 We had, I'd say minimal issues that were really more just kind of, you know,

2:28:02 could be addressed by just a simple, hey, like, you know, think, think where you are.

2:28:07 You're kind of in within a generally public area.

2:28:10 You're not out in the woods.

2:28:12 It just more kind of simple, simple basics for how to, how to operate there were, you know, kind of, I think addressed most of the issues that we saw there.

2:28:22 And so that program did end in May, 2026.

2:28:25 And also really coincided with kind of the, the seasonal melt off and when other public lands opened back up.

2:28:31 And so it really, you know, the, the need became much less during the, the summer period.

2:28:37 For the upcoming winter staff is again proposing to operate an overnight parking program.

2:28:43 The upcoming winter, the program could operate for up to 180 days and is currently being considered for the dog park parking lot off college parkway.

2:28:53 The actual start date for the program would be based on snowfall accumulation in both in the town and outside the town.

2:29:02 And that's really in order to maximize the operating period for that site to coincide with when those public lands are inaccessible.

2:29:11 And also to minimize conflict between dog park users and then the program participants.

2:29:17 Similar to last year's pilot program permits would be required and permittees would be required to acknowledge and adhere to the rules for the program.

2:29:25 Different from last year, um, the site would have access to, uh, a winterized bathroom facility and trash receptacles would be provided on site.

2:29:34 On the site would also allow for slightly expanded capacity from last year's program.

2:29:39 Last year we kept it at, uh, I believe 20 permits on this site.

2:29:43 We estimate could, um, accommodate at least 30 or 30 vehicles, um, at this site.

2:29:49 And then also, um, different from last year is that town staff would engage with Eastern Sierra community housing staff to provide supportive housing services and general housing navigation services under the town's contract with ESCH.

2:30:03 Uh, those services aimed to provide information and access, um, to the, the program participants on potential permanent stable housing solutions.

2:30:13 Um, so in that sense, they would kind of engage directly with the program participants on opportunities and different programs that might, um, get them into then permanent housing options here in the community.

2:30:26 Uh, with this type of program, it's important to point out that program, program participants are not being granted exclusive use of the site or a lease of any kind.

2:30:36 Um, they're instead being granted permission by the town to sleep in their vehicles within a town parking lot overnight at that site.

2:30:43 Um, also this type of program participants are expected to adhere to, um, the statement of rights responsibilities and rules.

2:30:52 Acknowledge that, um, failing to abide by those rules may result in revocation of the permit.

2:30:57 Um, you know, the, the rules aren't meant to be, you know, extremely onerous.

2:31:02 More just meant to be how to, how to be a good neighbor, um, and kind of coexist on that site where it's, you know, a use that others from the public might not expect to encounter there.

2:31:12 Um, so with that program participants would, um, coexist with the public who may use the site during daytime hours.

2:31:18 And it'd be, um, expected that they're not hindering or obstructing, um, others from using that parking lot site during those hours.

2:31:25 You know, we, we anticipate that use would be minimal since the dog park would be closed.

2:31:29 Um, but you never know when someone might just want to park there and go walk along the path or other use.

2:31:34 So it's again, it's not exclusively closed, um, for this use.

2:31:39 It's just more that participants are allowed to then legally park at that site overnight.

2:31:44 Um, so the action being requested tonight is for the town manager to be granted authorization to designate town owned property for overnight safety park.

2:31:52 Overnight safe parking facility use as needed, uh, staff have continued to review the specifics of the program.

2:31:59 I think with this type of program, it is, um, somewhat of a fluid process and we're, we're learning as we go as to what additional elements might be needed.

2:32:08 What, what else might be helpful?

2:32:10 Um, and so we're, we're adjusting as necessary with that.

2:32:14 And with that, um, for any, any discussion from council or anyone from the public on it,

2:32:20 I'd like to add a couple of things that may, um, so, uh, you heard earlier tonight during public comment, um, a comment specific to this item.

2:32:30 And it was sort of challenging the town's outreach and engagement with the, with the group that's involved there.

2:32:35 You know, I will say that I've, I had two scheduled meetings with Emily who provided that comment.

2:32:41 Um, both of which I had to, uh, cancel.

2:32:44 And so just based on just either issues, emergent things that were going on at that time.

2:32:50 And I did not connect back with her.

2:32:52 And, and so that's on me.

2:32:53 And as far as that goes, I will also say that town staff has been putting this together.

2:32:59 Um, and as you, as you've just heard Nolan go through this process, there's sort of a narrow band with which we can get things accomplished.

2:33:06 There's a lot of rules, regulations, processes, and things that we have to fit within.

2:33:10 And so we're going to focus our efforts on making sure that we can thread that needle and continue to enhance the, the services for those, for these, um, for these folks and improve the, the quality of that.

2:33:23 Um, so while we haven't engaged directly with what the needs are, maybe specific to the users, um, we've been continuing to improve the program.

2:33:31 I want to accentuate a couple of the points, um, that were very significantly different in what we're proposing tonight versus what we did last year, which was something last minute put together around the village.

2:33:44 You know, it was, there was a lot of suboptimal elements to that.

2:33:47 And I think the work that Nolan has done to identify this dog park site, um, and at the same time providing minimal cost as well to engage that.

2:33:57 I mean, the, um, winterization of that bathroom, uh, was a couple thousand dollars, but in, in the end it will benefit like the entire community, uh, who may need a restroom and so forth.

2:34:06 So it's not really specific to that.

2:34:08 Um, but I think that, you know, I want to acknowledge that there's a lot of heavy lifting going on to get this accomplished in sort of what, what is, um, a series of constraints that, again, the expertise Nolan brings to the community and brings to my team, uh, is solving for those problems.

2:34:26 So I wanted to kind of add a little more to that.

2:34:29 Okay.

2:34:32 Are you ready for questions?

2:34:33 Nolan, are you ready for questions?

2:34:36 Yes.

2:34:37 Um, I, I have, I got a few emails, um, please don't interrupt.

2:34:42 There will be first.

2:34:43 We do questions, then public comment.

2:34:44 Yeah.

2:34:45 Um, I had a few emails, um, asking about why we are not charging for permits or charging residents for the spaces there.

2:34:56 Would you be able to address that?

2:34:58 Um, primarily it's, you know, looking at just trying to, again, stand this up relatively quickly for a relatively short period of time and figuring out, you know, is, is there a reasonable cost that, you know, we wouldn't be incurring otherwise for these services.

2:35:15 I think, as Rob pointed out, winterizing, or allow, I don't know if that's very, winterizing the bathroom, um, I think is a benefit to all and for the future.

2:35:25 It's not really limited just to this specific use.

2:35:28 Um, there's already existing trash services there.

2:35:32 So that's not really an expansion there.

2:35:34 And then really the only minimal, um, element would be actually clearing snow.

2:35:38 We already clear snow along college parkway, as well as then the future adjacent, um, McCoy theater site.

2:35:46 So it's really just an expansion into the, this area here.

2:35:49 Mm hmm.

2:35:50 I'd like to add to, and I'm probably, I promise I'm not gonna add, add to everything that Nolan has to say in this particular space.

2:35:56 But I mean, essentially everywhere in our housing programs, we're subsidizing, um, and supporting the community.

2:36:04 And I think in this particular case, we have also, you know, an opportunity to do that in the, in here, that the cost of entry is low.

2:36:12 Um, we've got a few things that we have to do that we wouldn't have to do.

2:36:16 However, it's supporting workforce, uh, mobile workforce housing.

2:36:19 Um, and I think it's, it's sort of justifiable, um, that we're contributing in this aspect as well.

2:36:24 Thank you.

2:36:25 Um, do we have, do we have, um, some sort of plan for, uh, snow.

2:36:33 Uh, snow removal, like having vehicles out of the way during snow removal or getting the parking lot cleared.

2:36:40 That's really one of those elements that's, uh, is part of the fluid one.

2:36:44 I mean, the, the plan would be that, you know, the snow removal would occur, um, kind of, I'm gonna say extremely early morning hours, but in the, you know, first thing in the morning.

2:36:54 And so there would be expectation during storms that they would have their vehicles out of the way so the plow could effectively clear the area there.

2:37:00 But that's, uh, a, to be determined element working with the, the snow removal crew.

2:37:05 Okay.

2:37:06 Thank you.

2:37:07 Questions?

2:37:08 Should we start on this side tonight?

2:37:09 Um, just one question.

2:37:11 Um, it doesn't say particularly in there, but are you good if we move forward, uh, we can continue the discussion with the mobile, mobile workforce individuals to make sure if there's other items we need to address.

2:37:22 We have addressed that.

2:37:23 There is.

2:37:24 So we did email.

2:37:25 It was, uh, a bit, a bit late to them.

2:37:28 Um, but we've contacted everyone who was at least a program participant last year through the emails they provided.

2:37:34 Um, you know, I, I welcome any, any engagement and outreach from, from those who received the email as well as others on, on how this might work.

2:37:41 Okay.

2:37:42 Thanks.

2:37:43 Questions on this side?

2:37:44 Uh, question, uh, being someone who did 35 years ago live in my vehicle for a while.

2:37:51 Uh, because I had a dog and frankly finding a place to rent in this town when you have a vehicle was very hard.

2:37:58 Um, I do think that we should consider some money for, even if it's a nominal fee, people have got to buy in, in some level.

2:38:13 Um, filling out a piece of paper with information.

2:38:16 I do see that there is Megan's law that, you know, there won't be, that you can look at that.

2:38:23 Um, I guess my first question is, does it cost us money to process on the application the, um, for, uh, where was it on the form that Megan's law?

2:38:37 Um, oh, it's, it says 290 slash Megan's law, the action taken.

2:38:46 That's at the town use only at the bottom of the sheet that you have.

2:38:50 Um, employment verification.

2:38:54 Um, I mean, if, even if it's a nominal fee, I think people will take things a little more seriously if they're actually invested in it.

2:39:05 Um, so, um, certainly 35 years ago we didn't have the problems that we have now.

2:39:12 It wasn't that I wasn't making money.

2:39:14 I could pay.

2:39:15 I just couldn't find a place or, you know, transferring.

2:39:18 So, um, I guess my question would be, uh, even though it was just brought up, is that something that we can consider?

2:39:26 Five dollars a day.

2:39:28 Um, just anything that makes it so that people have to invest.

2:39:34 We have to invest something.

2:39:37 And into our community somehow.

2:39:40 Yeah, I mean, to answer your question, yes, you guys can make decisions tonight on, um, aspects of this program.

2:39:50 Right?

2:39:51 That's, this is what we've got to, we've, we've teed up to you what we think is, is appropriate for the program.

2:39:56 Um, but again, it's, it's in your hands to make those determinations when you get to deliberate and come to the conclusions of this group.

2:40:04 John, do you have any questions?

2:40:07 Um, I don't have any, sorry.

2:40:10 I don't have any questions, but I do have some thoughts and comments when you're ready.

2:40:13 Okay.

2:40:14 All right.

2:40:15 Public comment.

2:40:16 Please come on down to the podium.

2:40:17 If you're online, please raise your hand and we'll get to you after the people in person.

2:40:20 Hi, I'm sorry I interrupted.

2:40:23 No worries.

2:40:24 Um, I have sat there and I had a comment once and public comment wasn't called, so I got a little nervous.

2:40:29 So I apologize for that.

2:40:30 And thank you everybody for being here.

2:40:32 Um, I wonder if we ask for money if people who are living in their vehicles will find somewhere else to park that is more dangerous.

2:40:46 Um, I think that's something to consider.

2:40:49 I don't think that it's out of pocket to ask for money either.

2:40:53 Um, but I think that trying to determine whether we're going to keep people safe or we're going to make money, you know, that's just something to think about.

2:41:04 Um, and I was wondering also, like, I would assume that we have more than 30 people in the wintertime living out of their vehicles.

2:41:14 So is there a possibility of having that forest trail parking lot and the dog park open for that kind of parking?

2:41:25 I, um, I know a lot of people who live out of their cars, they come here after the season starts, after all the jobs start opening and when housing is so expensive that they can't afford it or just not available.

2:41:42 Um, these are just things that if I was living in my car, I'd probably be thinking about I'm, you know, I might not pay to for a parking spot and I might find somewhere more dangerous to park.

2:41:59 Um, based on what I know, some of those people are making per week or per month.

2:42:09 That's all.

2:42:10 Thank you.

2:42:11 Thank you.

2:42:12 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

2:42:15 Sandy Hogan, a little more history.

2:42:23 I was thinking $5 a day.

2:42:26 You know, when I, uh, relocated to South Lake Tahoe to be a ski bum back in 56 years ago, $5, that would be $200 almost a month.

2:42:39 And that's a lot.

2:42:40 So I chose to live with five, uh, four other people.

2:42:43 And we shared the rift.

2:42:45 But I wouldn't ever live in my car.

2:42:48 It's too cold.

2:42:49 But, um, you know, I do understand that a lot of these people are workers.

2:42:55 You know, I read Dawn's comments.

2:42:58 And, uh, some are my choice, I'm sure.

2:43:01 And, um, but I know that a lot of them are workers.

2:43:05 And, um, but I, I've been here long enough to see there are some problems.

2:43:11 I think the dog park is a good choice.

2:43:14 I don't think the village is because what I see in the, you know, the tennis courts lot, parking lot, is that it isn't overnight.

2:43:24 They're living there 24 hours a day.

2:43:27 Some.

2:43:28 Some people.

2:43:29 Not everybody.

2:43:30 And when you have an event at the community center, um, you don't want the parking lots filled up.

2:43:38 Because then, you know, I was at the, not too long ago, at an event there.

2:43:44 And we had to let people know to park up in the Knolls.

2:43:49 Because, you know, the parking lot isn't being controlled there anyway.

2:43:55 For a lot of people.

2:43:57 Not just, not just these folks.

2:43:59 So I do think the dog park is a good selection.

2:44:03 And I think, on a nominal fee, maybe one dollar a day.

2:44:08 I do remember those four days.

2:44:12 Um, and, you know, a little history on this.

2:44:16 As I recall, I thought it was a really good solution, um, when we came up with it last year.

2:44:22 Because it was temporary.

2:44:23 Remember?

2:44:24 It was supposed to be temporary.

2:44:26 Solution.

2:44:27 Transition.

2:44:28 Until we could get that old sheriff's station.

2:44:32 Outfitted.

2:44:33 John, you remember that.

2:44:34 Yeah.

2:44:35 Well, it sounds like we're taking on, now, something that's going to be permanent.

2:44:41 And I may, you know, and I know the church has tried to look at it.

2:44:45 And the bishop has tried to look at it in different places.

2:44:48 And it's, it's not an easy problem to solve.

2:44:51 Um, so, I think as a pilot program, it's been good.

2:44:57 It has little problems like all pilot programs do.

2:45:00 And I think the dog park is solving some of them.

2:45:04 Um, because, you know, those dog lovers are going to run people out.

2:45:09 They're going to do the enforcement.

2:45:11 Um, um, so, anyway, I think it has, you know, goods like everything, like all pilot programs.

2:45:22 The good parts, uh, you know, we don't want to forget about the history.

2:45:27 And this is, again, when we have a new, you know, uh, you know, we, we have a new council up there,

2:45:33 new members, you guys are going to be the history.

2:45:36 Bill especially.

2:45:37 But, um, you know, to make them aware that temporary problems or temporary solutions,

2:45:45 or both, a mixture of both, you know, um, can become permanent if you don't know that this is supposed to be temporary.

2:45:53 We're supposed to try to find, you know, whether it's working with the churches, with, who knows.

2:46:00 But there's gotta be some better solutions down the road.

2:46:04 You don't want this to go on forever, this way.

2:46:08 Um, even with a dollar a day minimum, maybe some.

2:46:12 So, anyway, um, I'm glad you're working on some of the costs.

2:46:17 You know, minimal.

2:46:19 And, um, but, and it is supportive workforce housing, I know.

2:46:25 In some cases we are so short.

2:46:28 So, anyway, in that, since I am supportive still.

2:46:32 But keep working on the problem and don't forget,

2:46:35 it's supposed to be temporary until we can figure out how to do it right.

2:46:40 Thank you very much.

2:46:42 Thank you, Sandy.

2:46:43 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

2:46:45 Come on and approach the podium.

2:46:47 Okay, I'm not very good at this, so bear with me.

2:46:56 Um, I want to say thank you to all of the points that have been brought up already today about this topic.

2:47:02 I'm coming to you today as someone who was born and raised in Mammoth Lakes.

2:47:06 I have a lot of buy-in into the community.

2:47:08 I love it and it's where I want to be.

2:47:11 I want to remind you all of the beginning of the issue and why we brought it to you last winter.

2:47:18 It's, I guess there's two points I want to say.

2:47:23 First of all, there's very few places that are legal to stay overnight in a car when there's snow on the ground.

2:47:31 There's like maybe four and they get filled with people who don't live here.

2:47:35 And so it's really hard to get off work at 10, 11 PM, have to find somewhere to sleep at night,

2:47:41 wake up at 7 AM and go to work to work a double the next day.

2:47:46 And then maybe to share my personal experience, it also feels virtually impossible to be an employed person in this town pursuing higher education and afford housing.

2:48:00 So I just really would appreciate passing this and making sure that this is a program that continues because it is really helpful and really important.

2:48:12 Thank you.

2:48:13 Thank you.

2:48:14 Thank you so much.

2:48:15 Any other public comments from anyone in the room?

2:48:17 Hello, everybody.

2:48:24 My name is Sydney.

2:48:25 I work here at the library.

2:48:28 I just, I've never made a public comment before.

2:48:33 So I just wanted to express that I am for this, for this motion and would really like to see it pass as well.

2:48:47 Thank you.

2:48:48 Thank you, Sydney.

2:48:49 Any public comments from anyone else in the room?

2:48:52 I just wanted to ask about the questions that were actually on the application form,

2:48:59 whether you're using that as a gather, a way to gather data on the people who are using this program.

2:49:04 I noticed that there is one to ask whether the person already lived in Mammoth or lived in a residence in Mammoth before they moved into their vehicle.

2:49:14 Where did those questions come from and are they being used for a reason or is it kind of just to make it a little bit more challenging to fill out that form to get some investment there?

2:49:26 Thanks.

2:49:27 Thank you.

2:49:28 As far as challenging, it's kind of a yes, no check box.

2:49:33 So it's a fairly simple low barrier question.

2:49:36 It's really just general statistics on where they, where they reside before as we're looking at the program and looking at expanding how the program operates.

2:49:45 You know, is this, are we targeting those who did live in a structure and that might not anymore for various reasons?

2:49:52 Are these people who have just come to the community, this is their first winter here?

2:49:56 Really just to get more background on, on where, where this, everyone's coming from that's getting a permit.

2:50:02 Are there any public comments from anyone online?

2:50:07 Yes.

2:50:08 Okay.

2:50:09 Ms. Bateman, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments?

2:50:17 Hi, can you hear me?

2:50:18 Yes.

2:50:19 Awesome.

2:50:20 Thank you.

2:50:21 Hi, Ms. Bateman again.

2:50:23 Popping in, I just would like to say that I think that this motion is cruel.

2:50:30 Um, I come from a stance where I believe that we need our workforce and our workforce is, they are suffering from a serious, serious housing shortage.

2:50:43 Um, we need people to run our restaurants, our shops, our lifts, our mountain.

2:50:50 These folks come in to bring the town revenue.

2:50:54 And, and I don't believe creating an obstacle, an extra obstacle is the way to get more employees to fund all of the operations that bring us revenue as a whole.

2:51:07 Um, if you are hoping to get people on their feet and you want to ensure safety, then we need to address the housing issue.

2:51:15 The housing is the issue, not the people.

2:51:19 If you really wanted to support our employees who are living out of their cars, then we need to create social programs that feed them, educate them on the economics and housing programs and really, really just support them from the ground up getting back on their feet.

2:51:36 If you want a functioning community that brings revenue to the town as a whole, we, it just, we need to support these folks.

2:51:45 In summary, if all you need is revenue and we need revenue that badly, let's just do some fundraising.

2:51:54 If you need assurances of safety, let's do some creation of social programs, programming, charging people who are braving winter weather, freezing their bodies during the dark, cold months, working multiple jobs because, and sleeping in their cars because they do not have a roof over their head.

2:52:12 And they can't find one here locally.

2:52:17 Asking to charge them more is just creating another obstacle.

2:52:19 It's cruel.

2:52:20 And it's going to push more of our employees away.

2:52:25 And we already have a staffing shortage town-wide.

2:52:29 And I just, I don't agree.

2:52:31 I don't think this is the way.

2:52:34 So let's keep our community safe.

2:52:36 Let's keep the revenue coming in.

2:52:38 Let's support our vulnerable people of our community.

2:52:43 And let's work together.

2:52:44 Okay?

2:52:45 Thank you.

2:52:46 And I just want to clarify, the staff report, you're not suggesting that we charge anything.

2:52:53 Rob said that most of our housing programs, there's a subsidy involved.

2:52:58 The issue of should we charge came from a few emails from other members of the public.

2:53:04 So the staff is not requesting that we charge for this program at all or suggesting that we charge.

2:53:11 Are there any other public comments online?

2:53:14 Okay.

2:53:15 Emily Markstein, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

2:53:20 Am I allowed to say something else?

2:53:22 I wasn't sure because I accidentally spoke earlier.

2:53:24 Oh, of course.

2:53:25 You can talk again.

2:53:26 Oh, okay.

2:53:27 First of all, thank you so much.

2:53:29 And thank you, Rob.

2:53:30 I know we've been trying to get in touch.

2:53:32 But I just want to say one thing and that this conversation shouldn't be about our character

2:53:43 and the character of those of us that live in our vans.

2:53:46 And I welcome anybody to sit down and have a coffee with me and ask me about who I am

2:53:51 and how I contribute to this community.

2:53:53 I have a master's degree at the age of 23.

2:53:57 I have run the Hot Creek Mine for six years for those who are unpaid.

2:54:01 You know, I can contribute it in numerous ways to this community.

2:54:05 And I think I can speak for everybody else that lives in their car that is dealing with housing issues,

2:54:11 whether they've lost their housing, they can't find housing, whatever it is.

2:54:16 I would like this to be not a conversation about our character, but a conversation about the logistics of housing

2:54:24 and the issues that we're facing in our town.

2:54:26 Thank you.

2:54:27 Thank you, Emily.

2:54:29 Anyone else online?

2:54:30 No.

2:54:31 No one else in the room?

2:54:33 Okay, deliberations.

2:54:34 Thoughts?

2:54:35 Bill, should we start with you?

2:54:36 I can.

2:54:37 The very first thing I want to do is to commend staff on the last two years and how creative they've had to get to find these programs.

2:54:49 The negative side is I am incredibly disappointed in the people in other government entities in this county.

2:54:58 You're not naming names, Bill, are you?

2:55:00 I'm not.

2:55:02 Because right now we should have a program going at the old sheriff's substation.

2:55:06 Most of you haven't been here since it was a sheriff's substation, but it's down at 203 and 395.

2:55:12 That should have been done.

2:55:13 Our staff has had to do incredible work just to create something.

2:55:18 On charging a fee for this, you know, we buy condos and we subsidize them at $150,000 to $200,000 apiece for people who can afford a whole lot more than these folks.

2:55:33 Some of them live in nice vans.

2:55:36 You know, two years ago I did a lock call for people living in their old Datsun.

2:55:40 Those of you who remember when Nissan was Datsun.

2:55:44 These are great cars.

2:55:45 They are, yes.

2:55:47 But this is a necessary service.

2:55:49 Eventually it has to be a permanent service.

2:55:52 But again, I want to commend staff for the work they have done and the ingenuity they have shown to create this program.

2:56:01 Now I'll shut up.

2:56:03 If I may, I'd like to address something that came up a couple of times this evening, and that was with regard to the permanent site that we were seeking with the county.

2:56:10 And not to throw our brothers and sisters at the county under the bus because I'm not going to do that.

2:56:16 The issue lies in the fact that that facility needs quite a bit of capital improvement to be functionable for what we have in mind, right?

2:56:23 And it will be expanded.

2:56:24 It will be larger.

2:56:25 It will be more of a permanent site.

2:56:27 And that ultimately was the plan.

2:56:29 We were working closely with the county on that.

2:56:32 The process we had outlined was a five-year lease with an option to purchase at the end of that.

2:56:38 So the town's investments would be maintained in a long-term process.

2:56:43 The county is currently working through an assessment of their open land, and they don't really have clarity on exactly what they need or don't need.

2:56:53 And so they haven't undertaken that process.

2:56:56 They really cannot commit to, you know, divulging of that land to the town until they complete that process.

2:57:04 So what I would consider this to be is a bit of a pause, a temporary solution, continuing to be temporary.

2:57:11 Highly improved over last year's process out at the village because that commingled a lot of, you know, people who were partying at the village and coming out.

2:57:23 And I think some of the people living in their cars were getting blamed for some of the activities that were going on by the visitors and vice versa.

2:57:30 But I just kind of wanted to reiterate, we're still talking to the county in understanding they have legitimate reasons why they can't sell that property to us right now.

2:57:40 And so I would like to prefer to continue to work through that and understand if we can come to a more permanent solution there with county's help.

2:57:50 Thank you for clarifying that.

2:57:53 Brett?

2:57:54 I agree with Bill in terms of I appreciate staff efforts to find a solution.

2:57:57 As you know, I've pushed on this for many times and a couple of the solution.

2:58:02 It's nice to see that we have something to work with versus sitting here trying to figure out another solution.

2:58:07 I also believe that it's doing the right thing and this take care of our workforce.

2:58:11 I don't think we need a charge for this.

2:58:13 I think this is something we can well absorb.

2:58:15 We do many other programs.

2:58:16 I think this is the right thing to do and to manage it and highly support the direction we're going in.

2:58:22 Thank you.

2:58:23 Cleela?

2:58:24 Well, again, I lived in a 85 Jeep with no insulation whatsoever.

2:58:31 I am not disparaging anyone who has that type of lifestyle because I think it makes you tough 35 years later.

2:58:41 I'm sitting up here on town council.

2:58:44 These are and I'm trying to think back if I was charged what would be equivalent of $5 a day.

2:58:53 I don't think the dog park is going to be a bad place for people to live there.

2:59:02 I'm just going to go back to my statement.

2:59:04 I do believe that people take things more seriously.

2:59:07 They're going to take more responsibility.

2:59:09 If there is something other than them just putting their information down.

2:59:13 Oh, and before anybody goes, oh, well, job wise, I was working three jobs.

2:59:17 One was I worked for the town in an after school program back when we used to take after take care of our local kids at that age.

2:59:24 So if I have my druthers, I would like something.

2:59:30 People are not going to move their vehicles necessarily with the snow.

2:59:33 I do think something needs to be included by there.

2:59:36 Maybe work out with the snow plow that between this time and this time you have to have your vehicle.

2:59:43 Because if you have 30 spots, all it's going to take is one of our good dumps, which is going to totally a two people move their car.

2:59:53 The person in the middle of doesn't the people come back.

2:59:55 They're not going to have room for their cars when they get back.

2:59:57 I think y'all are missing a really important part with the snow removal capabilities, particularly given what we may be given this year.

3:00:06 And I do, with this, I don't see why I don't move back into my Jeep, take my dog with me, different dog after all these years, for free live somewhere and rent my room out.

3:00:20 I mean, it's a, well, we have a lease to locals program if you'd like to turn your, I'm just kidding.

3:00:29 Yeah, I share the sentiments of some of my colleagues here.

3:00:39 This is an important program, but I also want to, certainly staff has done an excellent job with this.

3:00:45 But I also want to commend the members of the community, the folks who are living in these things, who've worked with staff to develop this program, developed, demonstrated responsibility,

3:00:56 demonstrated a real community ethic and really happy to see this happen.

3:01:00 It's obviously not a permanent thing.

3:01:01 This is, it's a year by year kind of a thing, but also just reminding us the need for the housing thing, the price of entry into a community like this has now gotten to be impossible.

3:01:12 There is no ski bomb culture here anymore.

3:01:14 It doesn't, that's long gone.

3:01:16 So this is, this is a way in and I think it's important.

3:01:19 And one distinction I want to point out is as mentioned in the emails that this is a van life thing.

3:01:27 The staff report identifies a mobile workforce, which is appropriate.

3:01:31 And Rob, as you mentioned, this is, it's a mobile workforce.

3:01:34 And when we first set this up, we talked about the semantics of this.

3:01:38 And what these folks in the mobile workforce are also competing with are the people in the $100,000 plus sprinter vans that are skiers,

3:01:48 who, I'm not disparaging their incomes, but they got means.

3:01:52 And they show up and they compete with the spaces that these folks are trying to live in.

3:01:57 So I think having dedicated, I think you found a great real estate solution for this.

3:02:01 Commend all parties.

3:02:02 This is a real great community effort and I certainly support it.

3:02:06 Thank you.

3:02:07 I, I think that, you know, I understand why we have this application.

3:02:12 I feel like then we have everyone's information.

3:02:15 We can contact them, you know, with Eastern Sierra Community Housing, they go out and collect data on how many individuals are unhoused and living in their cars.

3:02:26 So this helps us make informed decisions on, you know, the housing problems that we're having and with how many unhoused people we have.

3:02:35 So, um, I think that having this form and, you know, having to jump through the hoops of getting, um, a permit that, that satisfies, you know, you're saying that people have more buy-in when they pay some money for it.

3:02:49 I think that this to me is enough is having them get a permit for it.

3:02:54 Um, I do think that it should be free.

3:02:56 Um, so I, I would like to thank town staff for putting this together and for coming up with a creative solution when our first plan didn't pan out in the timeline that we wanted it to pan out.

3:03:09 So, um, thank you.

3:03:11 Uh, and I would like to entertain a motion.

3:03:13 I would like to make a motion.

3:03:14 I would like to move to authorize the town manager to designate town owned property for overnight safe parking facility use as needed.

3:03:21 Second.

3:03:22 Roll call please, Jamie.

3:03:23 Council member Souser.

3:03:25 Yes.

3:03:26 Council member Wentworth.

3:03:27 Yes.

3:03:28 Council member Hoff.

3:03:29 Yes.

3:03:30 Mayor Pro Temp-Truex.

3:03:31 Yes.

3:03:32 Mayor Rice.

3:03:33 Yes.

3:03:34 Okay.

3:03:35 Uh, we are moving on to item 9.6, town council discussion and decision on use of town reserves generated from political commitments to tourism, housing, and transit.

3:03:45 Thank you, Nolan.

3:03:46 Thank you, uh, Mayor Rice.

3:03:52 Um, this is my item.

3:03:55 I promise it's not controversial.

3:03:58 So there's no numbers involved either.

3:04:01 I could make one.

3:04:03 Associated with the rest of them this evening.

3:04:05 So, um, basically this kid, this question came up, um, from council recently when I went through the fourth quarter budget review.

3:04:12 I had a recommendation at that time that some of the allocated funds that go to tourism transit housing also therefore contribute to our overall reserve for economic uncertainty.

3:04:24 Um, and this is based on sort of a, a bit of a complicated calculation, right?

3:04:29 So when we go through the reserve processes, uh, and the staff report, um, provides quite a bit of information if someone would really like to understand, uh, the specifics by which, um, we had, we arrived at the current TOT rate.

3:04:43 And that was important to go through those components because at each of those steps, there were sort of expectations established in why those funds were going up and what they would be committed to.

3:04:54 And ultimately that came to what we now call the political commitments, um, which is every dollar of TOT collected goes automatically into certain locations, right?

3:05:04 So, um, those are tourism transit housing and, um, and then most recently with measure L we dedicated a hundred percent of those funds, um, to housing.

3:05:15 So those, that's how that, those numbers are contributed.

3:05:18 When we go through the budget process, I'll, I'll take the TOT that's necessary for the general fund to, to, to provide revenue for the services we provide.

3:05:27 And I'll automatically, uh, put them into their buckets.

3:05:31 At the same time, I am looking at an overall, um, calculation that we use for our reserve for economic uncertainty.

3:05:41 And what that does is that looks at the entire revenue stream for the general fund, which is our operating budget.

3:05:47 And, and designates 20% of that, um, really as a, as a target.

3:05:52 So I've set this targeting system based on, on full revenue and then saying, okay, REU is 20% of that number.

3:05:58 Um, at the same time, when you look at the way I have to take each of those dollars of TOT and, and separate them out into tourism, transit and housing.

3:06:08 They have not been contributing any funding to, uh, to that.

3:06:12 So I've got them as, as a, as a benchmark, but then there's no contributing factor.

3:06:17 And so it overburdens in my opinion, the expectations from the general fund to cover all of our reserves.

3:06:23 Um, so I wasn't looking for any sort of undue pressure on those allocations, but more that they were contributing their fair share.

3:06:32 Um, I went further than that in the, the staff report to provide, um, some of the details of how we've been utilizing these reserve funds.

3:06:41 And I'm not now talking about the reserve for economic uncertainty.

3:06:44 I'm talking about the reserves created for housing, tourism and transit.

3:06:49 Um, and so then you'll find them outlined in the staff report.

3:06:53 I have been modifying those across time.

3:06:56 They've, they've been a little bit, um, so dynamic since they were created back in 20, 2019, I believe.

3:07:03 Um, where, you know, at some point council dedicated all the funding from tourism, excess funding from tourism to go to housing.

3:07:11 Um, that lived for a while, uh, there was at one point where this was a joint account with Mammoth Lakes tourism today.

3:07:17 It's, it's Mammoth Lakes tourism can request funding from the tourism reserve, but not necessarily direct traffic on how we utilize that.

3:07:24 That's solely in the, in the hands of council.

3:07:26 Um, but I've been migrating a little bit more recently in the last couple of years to include things like, um, fire, wildfire mitigation.

3:07:34 Um, to fund the additional ambulance for, um, Mammoth Lakes fire protection district as a, as a partnership.

3:07:42 And those things, the reason that I've done that is they, they contribute to our success as a destination and recreation economy.

3:07:50 Um, if, if our, if our facilities burned down, we really have no game, right?

3:07:55 If, um, if we're not servicing the people who are becoming injured for whatever reason, who are visiting us or even our locals, um, augmenting those services are sort of a moot point.

3:08:04 So, um, I do think that there's a, a, a limit to that.

3:08:09 I, I, it is not everything under the sun can be considered for those particular areas, um, those particular reserves.

3:08:16 Um, but I, I laid it out in the staff report exactly as far as we've gone today.

3:08:21 And by doing so, and the request that I have here is to basically approve that as the list, it sort of locks that in, right?

3:08:28 It, it prevents, you know, additional scope creep, if you will, on utilization of those funds.

3:08:34 And I tried to capture everything that, um, I think is necessary that those funds should contribute to.

3:08:40 And, uh, and I also, you know, really would like to understand from council how they want to go about either having these reserves contribute to the REU or not.

3:08:51 Um, and I'm, I'm looking forward to the deliberations on that.

3:08:55 So I'm happy to answer any questions.

3:08:57 Questions?

3:08:59 No questions.

3:09:00 Who wants to go first?

3:09:01 Bill, no questions?

3:09:02 Brent?

3:09:03 I'll wait until the deliberation.

3:09:04 No questions.

3:09:05 No questions.

3:09:06 Only comments.

3:09:07 Okay.

3:09:08 John?

3:09:09 Uh, deliberation.

3:09:10 Okay.

3:09:11 Uh, Clayla?

3:09:12 I guess my question is, why does no one have any questions?

3:09:16 Okay.

3:09:17 No questions.

3:09:18 Um, I don't, I kind of have an unrelated question.

3:09:24 But, um, I know we were taking money, um, using, using tourism designated funds for housing.

3:09:31 Do you have like a ballpark money, a ballpark number of how much money we've put into our housing funds for like the last four years?

3:09:38 Um, I, it's, it's many millions of dollars.

3:09:44 I, I would, I would hate to hazard an absolute guess to give you a definitive number, but it's, it's tens, tens of millions of dollars.

3:09:52 Okay.

3:09:53 All right.

3:09:54 Okay.

3:09:55 Public comments?

3:09:56 Anyone in the room?

3:09:58 All right.

3:10:01 Sandy, welcome back.

3:10:03 Well, with this one, um, interestingly enough, I, I do, I was here when we passed measure A, the, the 2002 one.

3:10:20 And before that, but I didn't, 1996, I probably was too, too new.

3:10:26 But in those days, we didn't have a transit system.

3:10:31 We had a mountain transit for the winter, but we really didn't have anything other than Inyo Mono transit.

3:10:39 And I think they gave us a dialer ride, but we didn't have ESTA.

3:10:42 We were still working on, you know, trying to plan for a future transit system, which we initiated in 2007.

3:10:52 Not till then.

3:10:55 So, um, it, you know, transit was a really conceptual idea for us, because we had, you know, the important time.

3:11:04 And we just didn't care if people drove that much, but we were beginning to talk about it.

3:11:10 And housing has always been a problem.

3:11:12 It's always been.

3:11:14 But in those days, our, um, priorities were tourism.

3:11:21 We said transit, but that meant planning.

3:11:24 And housing.

3:11:26 And, um, and I looked at, you know, the, the last, or the other page, where we, we still seem to be putting most of it into, um, tourism.

3:11:40 You know, 18%.

3:11:44 And transit gets six and a half, and housing gets six and a half.

3:11:49 Other than, you know, measure L, which was later.

3:11:53 And, uh, tourism has the T bid, which has to be renewed every 10 years.

3:11:59 I think it is 10 years?

3:12:00 It's five years.

3:12:01 Five years.

3:12:02 Okay.

3:12:03 Couldn't remember.

3:12:04 But, um, so that ups tourism even more.

3:12:09 And, um, it just has bothered me that this ratio is still in place.

3:12:16 Because it seems like it's housing, transit, and tourism, in my mind.

3:12:23 And the other, you know, I attended last week a meeting of, um, the North Village plan.

3:12:29 And the whole issue there was transit.

3:12:33 That's the missing piece.

3:12:35 Not more parking.

3:12:37 Not more cars.

3:12:38 Transit.

3:12:39 Expanding.

3:12:40 And we discussed microtransit, such as you'll find up in, uh, Tahoe.

3:12:45 Um, you know, that's called Lake Link.

3:12:48 And they, in Olympic Valley, Squaw Valley.

3:12:52 And they have microtransit also.

3:12:54 It's expanded.

3:12:55 And, um, that's time for us to do that.

3:13:01 Because we're never going to get condo folks out of their cars and have them leave them in

3:13:08 their parking places unless we have some sort of microtransit.

3:13:13 And that's funded by, would be funded by ESTA and by us.

3:13:18 And so that's why I'm saying it's time to really, that meeting last week really drove it home.

3:13:25 Because, um, that was what people, John, you were hearing it.

3:13:30 It was there.

3:13:31 Transit.

3:13:32 Transit.

3:13:33 Expanded transit.

3:13:34 And, um, because getting people out of their cars is, you know, it's Southern California people.

3:13:41 We've got to get them out.

3:13:43 And how are we going to do that?

3:13:44 And we've got to stop just kind of, oh, well, we can't do it.

3:13:48 Start planning.

3:13:49 And, um, transit hub.

3:13:52 That came up.

3:13:54 You know, transit hub elsewhere for the people who just, um, you know, drive in for the day or whatever.

3:14:01 But, uh, anyway, so I'm just, I'm just thinking, you know, reading through this.

3:14:07 I, I know it's really complicated for you, Rob.

3:14:10 I'm sure it is with all of these measures, whatever.

3:14:13 But I just remember Kirk Stapp out on the parking lot of the post office passing out, you know, the measure A.

3:14:22 You remember, you remember that, too.

3:14:24 Um, he was trying to get us to vote for tourism, transit, and housing.

3:14:29 And I think it's time to revisit our priorities, not because you guys in tourism were doing wonderful jobs.

3:14:37 I mean, you are.

3:14:38 You've done it over the years.

3:14:40 And mammon.

3:14:41 But, um, you know, it has other helps.

3:14:45 But, you know, Bishop and the Mountain, they're all contributing to marketing also.

3:14:50 And so maybe, I know, probably not this council, but I think the discussion time has come for that.

3:14:59 It's probably off the topic of reserves.

3:15:02 But, anyway, just had, when I saw this was here, I thought, well, I'm coming for this other stuff.

3:15:08 And Pat, I know you're on the board.

3:15:11 Oh, okay.

3:15:12 Hi, Betsy.

3:15:17 Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council.

3:15:19 Nice to see you all.

3:15:20 I wanted to just start out by, I actually think I have the answer to the mayor's question.

3:15:26 So, between the end of the 2017-2018 fiscal year and the 24-25 fiscal year, $39,603,196 was allocated to housing now by various town councils.

3:15:48 And then probably another $5 or $6 million in the most recent fiscal year.

3:15:52 So, I'm actually going to have that number for Rob pretty soon here.

3:15:55 MLT likes to include that in our annual report.

3:15:59 So, that's how I have that number.

3:16:01 Also, I just wanted to mention, because I think it's sometimes important to distinguish with the T-Bid, that the T-Bid is not strictly tourism marketing.

3:16:09 We are capped at and just about at 45% of T-Bid revenues actually fund air subsidies.

3:16:16 So, I just want to, you know, make sure that everyone understands that, you know, tourism is very broad.

3:16:21 Also, the three categories, and you know that I love transit as well as certainly housing, huge priority for our community.

3:16:29 But tourism is the only one of those three categories that drives the revenue that funds the town.

3:16:34 Thanks.

3:16:35 Thanks.

3:16:36 Thank you, Betsy.

3:16:37 Comments from anyone else in the room?

3:16:40 Anyone online?

3:16:42 No.

3:16:43 Okay.

3:16:44 Are you allowed to talk on this?

3:16:48 She works for MLT.

3:16:49 This is the reserve.

3:16:50 Let's see, until Andy raises his hand and says,

3:16:55 Just don't make any decisions or have any discussions about funding MLT and you'll be all right.

3:16:59 Okay.

3:17:00 Thank you, Andy.

3:17:01 No, I appreciate the start because I'm kind of the reason why this came to issue because

3:17:05 we voted before.

3:17:06 Council did to take certain of these monies and reserves and put it to our economic uncertainty fund.

3:17:12 I felt we should have waited until we had a policy.

3:17:15 And that's what I'm really looking for today is just to cement a policy so we understand where it is.

3:17:19 We're transparent to the public.

3:17:20 This is what the fund is.

3:17:21 This is where the money goes.

3:17:23 This is what's available.

3:17:24 I have personally different ideas of how to handle this but they actually come to the same number because I kind of question why are we putting money into a reserve and then also reserving money off that reserve if that makes sense.

3:17:37 On the other hand, that same money would come back into the reserve if we need it.

3:17:41 So it's really just kind of a numbers game on that side of it.

3:17:44 So it would be basically my original thought was we don't need to fund as much on reserves and put that into our economic uncertainty.

3:17:52 It's basically the same amount of money.

3:17:53 I'm not against either one of those.

3:17:54 I would just appreciate that we have a policy say that these reserves are available to contribute a certain amount into our economic uncertainty and we acknowledge that as a council and formalize that.

3:18:09 I have a question that I came up with.

3:18:10 Can I ask a question real quick?

3:18:11 Sure.

3:18:12 Rob, so you laid out different things that these different, you know, tourism, transit, and housing reserves pay for.

3:18:23 In the event of severe economic uncertainty, would these things get paid for or are these things that would be on the chopping block immediately?

3:18:32 Like some of these things I look at them and I think that we would still have to pay for and then other ones we would maybe cut.

3:18:40 Yeah, so there are actually two different kind of conversations going on here.

3:18:44 I didn't do a deep dive on the REU and that function.

3:18:47 We talk about those reserves when we adopt the budget and I go through.

3:18:51 There's actually, when you look at our reserve funds, there's a reserve for economic uncertainty which is very strict.

3:18:57 It's like a replacement of revenue that doesn't exist.

3:19:00 And that's for a catastrophic event that would prevent people from coming to town and the town operations need to continue.

3:19:07 There's certainly at the same time would be very difficult questions about what we, to continue to provide and what we have to scale back on, which we would be, we would be doing that.

3:19:16 That's REU.

3:19:17 Operating reserves and other fund about 5% of that, that target number, which is really for council direction on, hey, we want to accomplish something.

3:19:24 We don't have a bank of funding to get that done.

3:19:26 This operational reserve can be employed by the town.

3:19:29 So think of that as a tier down in its availability.

3:19:33 The other one being, you know, a catastrophic event has had to occur to get into the REU.

3:19:39 And then we have a contingency of $100,000 a year that we can spend on things just to give us an opportunity.

3:19:46 We have a debt reserve.

3:19:47 So we've got a fair number of reserves and right now in reserve around $10 million, right?

3:19:52 So those exist for various reasons and it's outlined in our reserve policy, which is a very formal policy we do annually.

3:20:00 What we don't have a policy for, which council member Truax is referencing, is for how those, how that is really funded from these other allocations of money.

3:20:12 And so that's what we're trying to kind of establish tonight.

3:20:16 And I, and I had that as part of the staff report.

3:20:18 What I put in these is a limiting factor of what those reserves, tourism, transit housing can be used for.

3:20:26 And so, um, that's the extent of what we've used them for to date.

3:20:32 So it's really kind of locking that in as, you know, no more modification to that, Mr. Patterson, just, this is what you get to do with it.

3:20:40 I also have the question about whether or not the town should fund those reserves.

3:20:44 And I make the recommendation that, um, their contribution, um, or the amount of funding that is contributed to them.

3:20:52 That's also included in that target should be the amount they have to contribute to the overall REU.

3:20:58 That makes sense.

3:20:59 That was a very long winded answer.

3:21:01 I apologize for that.

3:21:02 Yeah.

3:21:03 So if I could, um, many years ago, um, uh, Colin Ferney and I worked on, uh, some modifications of the allocations of these funds.

3:21:19 And for council members, I'm sure you already know this, but these are not legally restricted funds.

3:21:25 Technically the council could decide we're going to wipe out all these commitments, all this stuff and do with it to Sandy's point.

3:21:32 If we wanted to start putting this into mobility at the council's direction, honoring the political commitments that could happen.

3:21:39 So, um, it can be, to your point, it can be a council's discretion.

3:21:45 You can put this wherever you want to put it.

3:21:47 It's not like RNU, which are legally restricted.

3:21:50 They cannot, they can only be used for the purpose that was on the ballot that the voters approved on.

3:21:54 Um, with all that in mind, it's, it's reassuring, Rob, to have you sort of lay out the purposes for which you would be using the money.

3:22:03 That has not been done before with this level of specificity.

3:22:06 Right.

3:22:07 Okay, fine.

3:22:08 It's, it's, these seem to line up with the voters intent, with, uh, measure A and those other measures.

3:22:13 So that's good.

3:22:14 The, the contributions to the reserves is kind of a new idea.

3:22:18 I, I, I, I appreciate the rationale for that.

3:22:21 I don't have a problem with that at this point, but that from a council perspective, I wouldn't go any further than that.

3:22:28 And I think Rob, you've acknowledged that this is as far as he's recommending that we go.

3:22:34 Okay.

3:22:35 I think we're okay with that.

3:22:36 But keep in mind that the count it's within the council's prerogative to allocate these funds as council sees fit to this point.

3:22:44 It's been how many years, Sandy, since these past 20, 30 years, whatever it's been, the council has honored these commitments.

3:22:50 And these measures were passed back before the state of California had weighed into, uh, what you can do with a revenue measure and how specific you can be for what it's for.

3:23:01 Today, you could not pass a general fund measure and identify what you'd use it for.

3:23:07 It's like, you can't say that it's just going to go in the general fund.

3:23:10 And then we have to do what we do with measure L and make that commitment to say, we're only going to put it into those funds.

3:23:16 So I'm good with this. Rob, thanks for your work putting this together.

3:23:20 But I think this is consistent with the political commitments made a long time ago.

3:23:23 There's no deviation from that.

3:23:25 If it's being asked to make a contribution to the reserves, okay, that's not, that's not a hill to die on for me as far as I'm concerned.

3:23:32 Thanks, John.

3:23:33 Yeah.

3:23:34 Bill?

3:23:35 So, I think we've made a few mistakes through the years on these.

3:23:40 One of the mistakes we've made is calling them reserves in the first place because they really aren't.

3:23:45 They were intended as funding buckets for these issues, tourism, transit, and housing.

3:23:51 So when you say, why are we putting money into these reserves and taking money out of these reserves and moving them there?

3:23:57 These aren't true reserves.

3:23:59 They don't come close to what my definition would be of a true reserve.

3:24:03 I would love to see us redefine that so we understand it.

3:24:06 Tourism funds.

3:24:07 These, as John was saying, these are political commitments only.

3:24:11 We can do anything we want to with the money, and in fact we have.

3:24:15 After the airport lawsuit, we took transit and housing from one point to .85 points because we needed to financially to pay that suit.

3:24:27 We've never taken them back to their one.

3:24:29 We also, the tourism at 2.35, and you know, I don't remember, oh, the pit's getting old.

3:24:35 I don't remember what the original percentage was, but it was much higher than that for tourism.

3:24:40 Yeah.

3:24:41 Um, so that's where our political commitment ended.

3:24:43 We changed them all at that point.

3:24:45 Uh, and then we said tourism after the T bid was done, you're no longer getting that.

3:24:50 We're going to take it and you can ask to use it.

3:24:53 I agreed with that.

3:24:54 I agree with it today.

3:24:55 It was the prudent thing to do and we use it.

3:24:58 But they aren't true reserves.

3:25:00 Uh, and we haven't exactly held the line on all of our political commitments.

3:25:05 Because for the betterment of the town, it was necessary to do that.

3:25:08 That being said, I believe, as you alluded to, but Amanda, I think anyway, um, if we had a massive issue, yes, these would have to be funded out of those reserves.

3:25:23 So I believe that for whatever their percentage of the total budget is, and whatever we have to add to reserves in that year, they should take their percentage to go into the reserves.

3:25:36 Um, remember the reserves are set as a percentage of what our income is for that year.

3:25:42 Um, and I don't know, Rob, are we, what, a million dollars behind actually?

3:25:46 And so when we did the budget this year, we were just under $1.3 million unfunded.

3:25:52 Um, and then I believe we funded all but 500 and some thousand.

3:25:58 Right.

3:25:59 Um, so we're about 550,000, say, behind full funding at this point in time.

3:26:03 Yeah.

3:26:04 I know you've got the numbers there.

3:26:06 Uh, if we would have taken the appropriate amount out of each one of these funds, that 500,000 would be much less and our reserves would be funded in a much higher level.

3:26:17 So I am in favor of doing that.

3:26:20 Um, I believe that the day is coming when we're going to have to go back and look at some of these financial commitments, especially for transit and housing, because pretty soon that 0.85% or whatever it is, is not going to meet the need that they have.

3:26:38 Um, but the two things I would like, I like the idea of helping fund that percentage of reserve from this.

3:26:44 And I believe we need to stop calling them reserves because they function as a pot of money.

3:26:51 As you know, we have how many different accounts that we put money into, and we've got little three number, uh, designations for them.

3:26:59 Um, and I would be much more comfortable seeing this set up in that fashion.

3:27:03 Just if I had just one thing to that, uh, on the mobility question, there is a component of Measure U, which is headed to mobility.

3:27:09 Yes.

3:27:10 So there's another pot there that we could use.

3:27:12 Yes.

3:27:13 No.

3:27:14 And I get to thank you for that, John.

3:27:15 No, I remember we put that in there.

3:27:17 Yeah.

3:27:18 Cleland.

3:27:19 Um, uh, I'm flashing back to previous years and things that are in here.

3:27:26 Um, I would just have to say, um, I have great respect, Rob.

3:27:33 For your financial brain here.

3:27:37 Um, I've always, I was on council, what, 2016 to 2020, uh, worked in the news before then.

3:27:48 For some reason, these numbers still scream to me that, um, we're woefully behind in housing.

3:27:56 Transit, the transit, we're doing pretty good with that.

3:28:01 Uh, tourism still, uh, I, I think we've, we've got tourism.

3:28:05 So I, you know what, I just have a little, I think a little bit different issue with this,

3:28:09 but, um, and I do agree with you that we should stop calling them reserves.

3:28:17 Um, so, uh, I'll just leave it at that.

3:28:22 I don't mean to bag on MLT, but I think that that is a kind of a bloated, uh, organization.

3:28:28 I'm not a big NGO fan to begin with.

3:28:30 And, uh, I think it's so funny that, you know, here 20 years later, we're still talking about the same thing that we need housing money.

3:28:38 And, uh, no, it's to bring more people in.

3:28:40 So, bye.

3:28:42 Um, my thoughts, I know Rob, you and I have chatted about this.

3:28:46 I've been in favor of changing these, uh, allotments to tourism, transit and housing.

3:28:52 I know since I've been on the council, um, in various budgets, we have taken money, uh, spent money that is going into the tourism fund on housing.

3:29:03 Um, and so I think that, I mean, we don't get a great turnout at our meetings anyway.

3:29:10 I don't think there's a lot of people that are reading the financial reports online.

3:29:14 Um, but when people see this, it just makes it look like our values are putting, uh, that the tourism is the most valuable thing.

3:29:24 So I think that, you know, I really appreciate that we're putting all of measure L funding into housing.

3:29:31 Um, it's, it's convoluted to me that in the past we've, um, you know, instead of changing these rates that we just, uh, pay for some housing things out of the tourism fund.

3:29:44 Um, in the event of a catastrophic, catastrophic event, since, you know, these, these different things that we would have to pay for, for tourism, housing and transit would still exist.

3:29:57 I, I am in favor of, um, you know, some of those funds paying for a share in the reserve for economic uncertainty, which I think is the question for tonight.

3:30:07 But, um, I do think that it would be prudent of us to revisit those, um, allocations of measure A, just to make sure that it's, that's right sized.

3:30:17 Yeah. And I would just say that, um, we've had those discussions, uh, and that I would caution, uh, political, you know, the leadership saying, Oh, look at these numbers.

3:30:27 And it tells story A because I think what we found in those deliberations is it does not tell that story.

3:30:34 Uh, it's a nuanced story. There's a lot of components that go into this.

3:30:38 I remember we had a lot of discussions about what we should take, take all that tourism money, just put it into housing.

3:30:44 And, and there's a lot of unintended consequences come out of something like that.

3:30:47 I think we came to the right decisions along the way.

3:30:50 It's, it's free for a council to go in there and have those discussions, make those allocations.

3:30:55 But just so the public understands, we had many, many, many hours of discussion of that.

3:31:00 And this is where they've ended up. So.

3:31:02 Okay.

3:31:03 Just, just a small follow up. Um, cause I talked to Rob about it before writing, as you brought up, Bill.

3:31:08 Um, I do support changing names. I tried to push on that several times.

3:31:12 And, uh, I think that name change would help in what it's categorized because now that you're defining what they are, it's not a reserve.

3:31:20 And I, I would support the, the, the semantic confusion.

3:31:24 Yep. It just, it just creates a whole.

3:31:26 Yeah.

3:31:27 Litany that just carries down in my mindset of what it is.

3:31:29 Yeah.

3:31:30 All right.

3:31:31 I do want to make a little clarification just for, for the audiences that are, the legions that are listening.

3:31:36 Um, there, there, there are, I have legions that follow me.

3:31:41 I don't know about you guys.

3:31:42 Um, up tonight is not a discussion on re, re deciding those percentages, right?

3:31:50 I just want people to understand that that's not what's before you.

3:31:53 It's not what agenda that is not, is what is agendized.

3:31:56 So you really can't even make those decisions tonight.

3:31:58 So for folks that may be thinking that you guys are sort of skipping over the obvious that you've been discussing.

3:32:04 Um, that's really not what the question is tonight.

3:32:07 It's just about, um, this particular very narrow question about these funds and our reserves.

3:32:14 So I just wanted to make that point.

3:32:16 I appreciate that.

3:32:17 It is a much bigger thing to get into reallocating the funds, which can be done, but it's your point.

3:32:21 It's, it's a whole different thing.

3:32:23 Yeah.

3:32:24 Any other comments?

3:32:25 I'd entertain a motion.

3:32:27 I don't think, do we need motion this or is this just a consensus?

3:32:30 No.

3:32:31 Do we need a motion, Rob?

3:32:32 I'm blessing.

3:32:33 I think, um.

3:32:34 I'm blessing.

3:32:35 Well, I think, who wants to get people up here?

3:32:37 Yeah.

3:32:38 I think, yeah.

3:32:39 You took it wrong.

3:32:40 You don't want to go down that road.

3:32:43 I've heard consensus, right?

3:32:45 There's really, I wanted to hear your comments about the things that I put in here in writing, um, the limiting factors that are now in, in writing.

3:32:55 I can put that into a, a, a more of a formal policy and, and bring that forward.

3:33:02 Uh, I don't yet have consensus from council on what is expected with contributions from these funding sources to the reserve for economic uncertainty.

3:33:16 Um, so if that's one thing I, I would like to get is if, you know, you want to go down the row and say, yes, make it a percentage of their contribution to the overall, uh, operating or, or not.

3:33:31 Can I just say yes?

3:33:32 You can.

3:33:33 Okay.

3:33:34 I'll say, I'll say yes.

3:33:35 Yeah.

3:33:36 Okay.

3:33:37 Yes.

3:33:38 Yes.

3:33:39 I'll say yes.

3:33:40 I appreciate us having that discussion.

3:33:41 Thank you.

3:33:42 Okay.

3:33:43 We are on to council member reports.

3:33:46 Cleland, would you like to go first?

3:33:48 Um, well, I worked at the polling station yesterday and, uh, we actually had a fabulous in-person showing.

3:33:58 Uh, it was at the county offices.

3:34:00 And thank you to everyone who came out and voted.

3:34:04 Um, and then in the last two weeks, um, nothing is coming to mind.

3:34:13 I'll check my calendar, but, um, been doing a lot of reading and just trying to catch up before I have, what, two more meetings to go to.

3:34:21 All right.

3:34:22 Thanks.

3:34:23 Brent, would you like to go next?

3:34:24 Sure.

3:34:25 Uh, has a number of different meetings from LTC, North village, uh, meetings, CPT meeting, MLR meeting, um, nothing significant to report those.

3:34:35 I just want to take a moment and thank everybody who ran for town council.

3:34:38 Win or lose.

3:34:39 It takes a lot of effort.

3:34:40 And I appreciate everybody stepping forward this year and putting a name up and wanting to be part of it.

3:34:46 For those that will most likely be here, um, I hope you're ready because we have a lot of things to discuss this year.

3:34:51 All right.

3:34:52 Thank you.

3:34:53 Bill?

3:34:54 Uh, let's see.

3:34:55 I attended an estim meeting, nothing too critical there.

3:34:59 Uh, the Mammoth trail seasonal transition yesterday morning, uh, as we transition our, uh, website from summer to winter activities.

3:35:10 Uh, attended the ribbon cutting for the minaret MUP and I attended an ESCOG meeting.

3:35:17 And John's going to give that report.

3:35:19 Okay.

3:35:20 All right, John.

3:35:21 Okay.

3:35:22 So while I pull up my meeting notes from the ESCOG meeting, um, I attended on October 23rd, a meeting of the ICARP TAC.

3:35:32 Uh, this is a state, uh, lives in the land use and, uh, climate innovation, uh, body of the governor's office around climate issues.

3:35:41 Capped off a long week of a huge climate conference that happened over in Sacramento.

3:35:45 Uh, climate's a big deal.

3:35:47 The fifth climate assessment for the Sierra Nevada region has been published.

3:35:50 Uh, our region's well represented in that.

3:35:52 So that was a, that was a very interesting set of meetings.

3:35:55 Very interesting week.

3:35:56 Uh, attended the North village Pacific plan residential group number three, the Knowles meeting on October 30th.

3:36:01 And I think I've talked a little bit with staff.

3:36:04 Brent and I have sort of tag teamed a number of these focused meetings, but I think it would be really helpful at some point for staff to come back and provide to the council in a public setting.

3:36:14 What you guys have been hearing, uh, to kind of get council up to speed, get the public up to speed.

3:36:19 These very significant challenges that Sandy, that you've mentioned that we've all kind of were dancing around these things.

3:36:24 What are we hearing?

3:36:25 What are the kinds of things we're going to have to do to make that, that neighborhood, a, a, a success, you know, with a 35 year old, uh, specific plan.

3:36:34 Just, just saying, um, and then, um, attended the ESCOG meeting.

3:36:39 I'll get those notes in a second.

3:36:41 Uh, we had elections on November 3rd, big night, big night.

3:36:46 Uh, but I want to just add what Brent said.

3:36:48 Thanks to all the candidates, everybody who ran locally, those who I know the, they're not certified yet, but congratulations though.

3:36:55 Those that appear to be in the, in the lead for that, but, um, it's going to be great to have a three new council members up here.

3:37:02 Uh, looking Brent, you're going to be the mayor.

3:37:04 So looking for your leadership and bringing these folks along and bill for your institutional knowledge,

3:37:10 the historian, historian, the vast institutional archive.

3:37:14 That's going to help guide us into the future.

3:37:17 So we're all looking forward to that.

3:37:19 Um, and today I attended a meeting of the Eastern Sierra wildfire Alliance on a Bishop,

3:37:24 a very interesting regional, uh, effort.

3:37:27 That's going to help us deal with a lot of wildfire stuff.

3:37:30 And the ESCOG meeting was interesting.

3:37:32 I think the big thing coming out of that is ESCOG really getting into the lane that it really should be pursuing,

3:37:37 which is to pursue an economic development district for the Eastern Sierra region.

3:37:41 Right now we have some folks up in, you know, aspersions being passed here, but up in Truckee,

3:37:47 up in sort of, you know, places to the north that like to speak, uh, for the economic destiny of this region.

3:37:54 But they don't perhaps live here.

3:37:56 They don't perhaps really understand the, the rhythm and the shake and the yabba-dabba of what we do down here.

3:38:03 It'll be nice to be able to, uh, put something like an economic district in place for the three counties.

3:38:08 They could leak over to the west side.

3:38:10 They could work with the economic development agency of the federal government,

3:38:13 which seems to be in friendlier hands perhaps as of yesterday.

3:38:16 Um, infrastructure investments, water systems, sewer systems, airports, things like that.

3:38:21 Um, so congratulations to everybody who ran and who won, but who ran.

3:38:26 And the pledge of allegiance took on a whole new meeting this evening.

3:38:29 I'm very happy for that.

3:38:30 Okay.

3:38:31 So thank you.

3:38:32 Okay.

3:38:33 Um, so I attended, uh, the haunted ice rain put on by Stu and his crew.

3:38:37 Uh, it was fabulous.

3:38:39 It was very well attended by members of our community and the kids.

3:38:43 Um, they had a wonderful time ice skating and, uh, doing a little carnival game.

3:38:48 So thank you, Stu and team for putting that on.

3:38:51 Um, I also went trick or treating in the trails and, uh, the police department had a nice

3:38:56 station there.

3:38:57 They were giving out popcorn and candy.

3:38:59 Um, and even though it was sleeting and snowing a bit, uh, the mammoth kids are tough.

3:39:06 My kids trick or treated without their jackets because, um, I wasn't going to fight that battle.

3:39:11 Um, and, uh, on Monday I went to the Eastern Sierra community housing meeting.

3:39:16 Um, it's the first Monday of every month in the Dana room in the county building from

3:39:21 6 to 8 PM.

3:39:22 Uh, we've had a little trouble updating the website with a Zoom or a, uh, Microsoft Teams

3:39:28 link, but we're hoping to get that taken care of in time for our next meeting, uh, the first

3:39:32 Monday in December.

3:39:33 And, um, John Stewart with ESCH is hoping to, uh, give kind of an update to the town council

3:39:41 about the deliverables for ESCH and kind of where they're at for, uh, meeting those

3:39:47 deliverables this year.

3:39:48 Okay.

3:39:49 Uh, good.

3:39:50 Uh, we are onto item 11 requests for future agenda items.

3:39:55 Anyone have any requests?

3:39:56 I actually do have a request for an agenda item.

3:40:00 This, uh, came from some people in the community who were asking me why the town council meetings

3:40:07 started at four and, um, I, they said, well, how does that get on the agenda for people to

3:40:16 go over that?

3:40:17 So on behalf of people who were thinking that perhaps a four o'clock time is not convenient

3:40:23 for people leaving their work to get here in order to make a public comment.

3:40:28 Um, so I think maybe, uh, the time we did use to start at six, uh, now, and we would be

3:40:36 here until midnight.

3:40:37 So I, I understand the four o'clock, but I think that that would be something that maybe

3:40:43 the new council will want to revisit.

3:40:46 Yeah, just, uh, for background, the council made that change in 2020.

3:40:52 Um, it was an ordinance that I think took effect in July of 2020.

3:40:56 Um, and certainly the new council could make that change.

3:40:59 It would just require adopting an ordinance, um, to change the times of the meeting.

3:41:03 Um, and people who are unable to attend the meeting and would like to make a public comment

3:41:08 can email the clerk and she can read it out loud or, um, they can also email the council

3:41:13 directly.

3:41:14 Unlike tonight, I got some of those emails last minute and were able to, was able to read

3:41:19 them.

3:41:20 Yeah.

3:41:21 Yeah.

3:41:22 Unfortunately, I got those emails a little bit too late for the four o'clock start, but

3:41:27 again, no skin off my back, but I thought I would just, if that's something that maybe

3:41:31 the new council needs to know that it has 2020, I, that's when I got off.

3:41:36 So I guess it changed.

3:41:37 So yeah, no skin off my back, but Andy probably appreciates it.

3:41:42 The drive.

3:41:43 Oh yeah.

3:41:44 The drive.

3:41:45 Oh no, we're going to make it at noon for Andy.

3:41:48 Are there any other requests for.

3:41:50 My only request would be if, if it's possible, it may not be possible to get a little update

3:41:54 coming out of those North village Pacific.

3:41:57 Thank you for that.

3:41:58 We, we do actually have that plan for the 18th and it's, it's really just an update on exactly

3:42:04 the process, you know, that we, that we've been undertaking and really to provide some clarity

3:42:09 to the fact that the work that we're doing now is data gathering and listening tour.

3:42:13 It's, it's not, uh, the, the, the major public outreach that would be involved in an amendment

3:42:18 to the North village Pacific plan.

3:42:20 The goal here is to bring forward, um, what we're hearing from the community.

3:42:24 We, we would tee this up with what we know as the town, as some of the problems, but we

3:42:28 want to hear things to understand the gaps.

3:42:31 We'll be coming to council with, um, these are the, these are the understandings that we've

3:42:36 received from this.

3:42:37 Do you want us to do an amendment to the North village Pacific plan?

3:42:41 Um, that process would be a two, three year process with extensive community outreach,

3:42:48 um, environmental analysis, the whole nine yards.

3:42:51 Yeah.

3:42:52 So it's a formal sequel process.

3:42:53 It's a very, very formal sequel process.

3:42:55 And so, um, there's some misunderstandings in certain aspects of the community that that's

3:42:59 what's going on now.

3:43:00 And that's absolutely not what's happening right now.

3:43:03 Um, so I think we felt the need to bring that forward.

3:43:05 Um, and so there's going to be a staff presentation on the 18th of November where we just introduce

3:43:11 the concept of what we've been accomplishing and sort of almost the, that, that aspect of what we're trying

3:43:16 to get done.

3:43:17 And again, we're not quite ready to bring the full boat back to council because we have

3:43:21 a, a consultant who's working through, um, what that looks like and assembling all of this

3:43:27 information for us.

3:43:28 And so it'll be a little bit later than that when we actually come forward.

3:43:31 Um, and we're also doing a little bit more outreach right now, just to make sure we've got everyone's, everyone's input.

3:43:36 So thank you for that, John.

3:43:37 Yeah.

3:43:38 It'd be really helpful just for maybe to dispel some ideas of what, what's being heard and,

3:43:43 and also hopefully sort of underscores the need for the work that's going to need to happen

3:43:47 up there to make that thing successful.

3:43:48 So thank you.

3:43:49 Um, I had had a request from some members of the PEDC that we have sort of, um, a public outreach

3:43:55 or kind of, um, some sort of, uh, informational meeting about what they do and what their limitations

3:44:02 are.

3:44:03 Yeah.

3:44:04 And we, uh, no one, no one can remind me what we, what we have in that space, right?

3:44:09 We, I had intended to have two meetings, one with as soon as possible, um, with PEDC to

3:44:16 talk a little bit about, um, their processes and really also what's happening with, you know,

3:44:21 mammoth crossing because there's some expectations within the community that decisions have already

3:44:25 been made, all these things have happened and that's not true.

3:44:28 So they really wanted to get that out there.

3:44:30 The second meeting I wanted to have is I really am trying to get all of the ancillary groups

3:44:35 that are associated with the town, um, before the new town council so they can sit down in

3:44:40 a joint meeting and understand what processes each of them perform for us and how that works.

3:44:45 And so, uh, I know Nolan and I met with a couple of members of PEDC and we kind of, I thought

3:44:50 at that point had two separate meetings created, but that's in Nolan's hands.

3:44:55 We're aware of that.

3:44:56 And, um, I think that really does need to come forward, um, potentially in two spaces.

3:45:00 Uh, and I thought that maybe it would work well the evening that the new council is seated

3:45:05 is that if we, if that was sort of a presentation earlier in the night before the council changes

3:45:10 that maybe everyone would be here.

3:45:12 But you guys are turning a, what is a very small ceremonial meeting into a thick and chewy, um, process.

3:45:19 I'm not sure.

3:45:20 I'm not sure the first night's the best night for that one.

3:45:22 No.

3:45:23 Yeah.

3:45:24 I just thought that everybody would be at the meeting.

3:45:26 Like they would be all excited and just sit there and listen to it.

3:45:29 All right.

3:45:30 Okay.

3:45:31 Uh, so we are at our adjournment.

3:45:32 The town council will adjourn to a regular meeting to be held on Wednesday, November 18th,

3:45:36 2026 at 4 PM.