Town Council
· recording 2 hr 16 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
279 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:34 Thank you, Jamie.
5:03 Thank you.
5:31 Okay, good evening everybody. Welcome to the Town of Mammoth Lakes regular meeting for Wednesday, September 18th. Before we take roll call, as can be seen from the agenda, we were in closed session today from 2 o'clock on interviewing, among other things, interviewing candidates for an interim, and I stress the word interim for those who are interested in that town manager position.
5:59 We do not have anything to report out of closed session. We have actually not concluded closed session, so when we adjourn from the public meeting, because we didn't get to all the items, we'll go back into closed session, and if there is anything to report out tonight, that will be done later, but at this time there isn't anything to report out. I do want the public to know, however, that we are in an interview process. It is ongoing for an interim town manager position. That's all I'm prepared to say at this point when we have something to announce.
6:29 We will announce it out of the next closed session, which is currently not scheduled. So with that, we'll go to the regular meeting and call for roll call, please. Councilmember Eastman? Here. Councilmember Lehman? Here. Councilmember Raimondo? Here. Mayor Pro Temkin? Mayor Wood? Here. If you would please rise. Actually, we've got two members from the Contractors Association, Jesse Baldwin and Tim Flynn here, and join them in the Pledge of Allegiance.
6:59 To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, thank you guys for leading us. This takes us to public comments. This is the time for members of the public who wish to address the council on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda to do so.
7:40 Come forward to the podium. State your name. John. Thank you. Good evening, members of the council, members of the public. Two quick, one update, one upcoming event. This last weekend, the Mountain Film Film Festival of Telluride, Colorado came to Mammoth Lakes for two nights of really wonderful, inspiring films about mountain culture, very aggressive recreation, a lot of birds I've never seen before.
8:06 Very interesting, entertaining event. Everybody broke even. A lot of people had a really good time. And this was to benefit MLTPA, Mammoth Medical Missions. Special thanks to Mammoth Brewing and Community Skis who gave away two free pairs of skis. So it was a great event, a lot of fun. Nice to kind of regroup, reconnect with other mountain culture, other communities of the rest of the world. I know Mammoth Lakes Recreation is coming away in October. It's a nice way to kind of check in with those kinds of things.
8:32 Second thing is the final event of the 2013 Summer of Stewardship Trail Days events. MLTPA Deserts, the Friends of the Union. We've got a lot of sponsors, a lot of hosts. Meeting up the Horseshoe Lake Trailhead Saturday. The weather is going to be chilly. Probably be prepared for some cool weather. But the co-host will be Mammoth Track Club, the Sierra Club, Kittred Sports, Mammoth Pet Shop as an international. We've had sponsors all summer long who've helped out with Mammoth Brewing.
9:02 Old New York Deli, Sunrise Rotary, we've made this whole thing possible. We've had the best attendance we've had that we've had in the last four or five years. This is the fifth year. Great series of events, great way to get some community capacity connection to our trail system. So hope to see you all Saturday. If you want to make it, it's going to be chilly. Come dressed. Thank you. Thanks, John. John, thank you. John. Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor, Council. John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to give a little bit of an update now that we're two and a half weeks into the implementation of the Tourism Business Improvement District.
9:36 While we have a very strong compliance, we also have some that are still not necessarily aware that they should be collecting or they're aware of it and just not collecting. And so one of the things that I wanted to announce tonight is just to make sure that people know that regardless of collections, if it's not something that we see on a receipt, we're assuming that the business will be taking that assessment on their own. So that's something that has been made very clear that if...
10:01 If the companies or the businesses do not decide to collect it, that they will be responsible for that revenue. So we are looking forward to our first collections starting, basically it's due before October 20th, the month of September. We've been out just really trying to audit as many businesses as we can just to see how people are presenting it. And it does vary across the board, and we have discussed that in prior conversations that some people are passing along the entire amount, some people are passing along the partial amount, and others are.
10:30 Deciding that they're going to absorb it in their costs. So unfortunately, we can't mandate how that goes about. So it's really going to become something that we need to do on a monthly reconciliation basis and also audit folks down the road. But the other piece that I wanted to mention was that there are still a number of businesses that probably qualify for some of the Tier 2 appeals to pay the $500 or the $50 annual fee. Those businesses still need to contact us. There's no automatic appealing.
11:00 So just because you think that you fall into a category, until we see the paperwork that says that, that we need to have that taken care of. So the appeals can come through the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Office. We have an appeal panel that meets every Thursday at 1 o'clock. We've probably seen 20 appeals at this point. And for the most part, they've been people that are appealing down to the Tier 2 or Tier 3 based on either their gross annual revenues or being able to prove they're more local business than they are visitor business.
11:29 All important stuff. So if we have businesses out there that are thinking that they fall into one of those categories, they need to contact us and provide us with that verifiable information. Any questions? Questions? John. John, real quick, my wife and I had the opportunity to stay at Squaw Valley last week for a couple of nights for an interesting reason, but we were there. They charged us at our lodging.
12:01 $35 a night resort fee. Are you familiar with that at all? Yeah. I went to Squaw a couple times this winter with my daughter for ski races, and the lodging bill is confusing, but the food bills in the village are even more confusing. I took a picture of it because it made zero sense to me what they were charging civic fees on, what there was an assessment on, what was a tax. It was very bizarre. But yeah, there are a lot of hotels, even hotels here in town and condo complexes that charge a resort fee.
12:28 And that covers everything from use of the pool to transportation if they provide it. So it's not uncommon. And I think that you'll see that North Lake Tahoe is looking at trying to pull a tee bid together as well, really on the lodging side. So that may or may not replace some of that resort fee or maybe just act on top of it. Is included in that $35 a night, is that a...
12:50 Part of their TOT or their bed tax or is it strictly a resort fee? I think it's strictly a resort fee. Typically it just covers some of the costs that they have maintaining pools and hot tubs and other common area. I was startled that I was paying, in addition to the room fee, I was paying $35 a night just for a resort fee. Did you use the pool? No. And they're not going to give your money back either for not using the pool.
13:18 We added those up in a few resorts I was going to, whether it was Reno or Grass Valley and whatnot, and it was coming out about 25% of my bill, the fees. The resort fee? The rural resort, the TOT, everything was about 25% of the bill. Okay. It's like parking in New York City. It may be only $20, but with 300% tax, it becomes $60 a night. So I think that there's still some education that we need to do out there, and we're continuing to do that, but I think that the biggest challenge is that ignorance is not going to get folks to...
13:47 Not be part of the assessment, so we just need to make sure that we, the next couple of months will be feeling our way through it. Good. Great. Thank you. Thank you, John. Anyone else wish to address the council on a matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda? Jane. Mayor Wood, Town Hall, community members. I want you to know, I hope you'll bear with me a little bit. I'm a little bit emotional. I have a feeling that this might be the last time that I come to speak with you for
14:23 For maybe ever for a really long time. And so I wanted to let you know that I'm leaving the skate park in good hands. I wanted to introduce you to Mike Leary, who's back in the back, Mike. And he's going to be taking over some of the buildings and maintenance operations. And Don True is back in the back. And Don's going to take over and do all the...
14:50 Landscaping and finish up the park in the spring when that can be done. So I hope you'll bear with me just for a minute. But I wanted to tell you about when I very first moved to Mammoth, I was kind of a lost person, literally and figuratively. I came to town and I had a hotel room at Mammoth West and nobody knew where it was. And so here I was in town and we didn't have a police department then and I went to the fire department and the fire department was all locked up.
15:20 And luckily a guy came out and he said, oh, well, I'm a volunteer here. And I work at the fire department. And then the next day I had never skied before and I learned to ski and there was a volunteer ski patrolman there and again volunteers. And that night they asked me to go to the tavern where I met a group called the locals. And I was really impressed and I loved the community so much I went home, packed up and moved back to Mammoth. My first year in Mammoth I saw
15:50 Unbelievable community service. They built the high school and Dave McCoy donated the gym. And Don Sharp and Florence Sharp with Chip Van Natten were working on the hospital. And John Sweeney was working at the fire department. And the fire district had bought a rescue mine, our very first rescue vehicle. And it came to town. And it was a vehicle, but it didn't have anything in it. And it was the woman's auxiliary that...
16:18 Sold baked goods and rummage and all sorts of kinds of stuff and outfitted that vehicle. And over the years I've seen unbelievable amounts of community service and sometimes we forget it. John Newbauer built Whitmore Pool. A lot of people don't remember that he did that for time and material. And Rich McAteer did the library and Reagan Green did the baseball fields and Clifford Manns practically moved dirt on every single project that we've ever had in town.
16:49 And we have a college and the Rotary and the Lions Club and the Women's Club have all done these things. And this is what I think makes our community great is the community service that people do. And like you, last week, John, I had an experience and I ended up in North Star. And what I realized, it brought back memories when I used to travel a lot with the boys, and what I realized is our village really isn't unique.
17:16 Inner West did a lot of cookie cutter type villages. And our village isn't that special. But what is special is that, and makes it different, is that our village is in the center of our community. At North Star, it's up the road, there's no community. Stratton, Vermont, village, no community. And so it is our community that makes it special. And we see all the time in the newspaper.
17:44 People who write letters that are tourists that come to visit and say, Carl Teller helped me at the gas station, or somebody helped me in the taxi cab, or somebody helped me in the restaurant. All of our community people are really important in what makes us unique. And so what I would like to say is that I was really disappointed and surprised that when I went in to sign the contract in order to build the skateboard park,
18:14 I was expecting a short maybe one or two or three page contract and instead I received a 22 page contract that made me responsible for air quality control, water and all sorts of kinds of things. I took the contract to my attorney and my attorney said, Jane, you are nuts if you sign this contract. And I was really taken back and I thought, wow, what?
18:44 What am I going to do? And his comment was, Jane, you are a benevolent donor. You have no interest in whatsoever in this project. And that you shouldn't be signing away and making yourself liable for all of these things. So I went back and I thought about it. And Peter called me and he said, I've made a few changes in the contract. Do you think you could come down and sign it? And again, I was really surprised because it was still
19:15 15 pages. And I made a choice. I decided I didn't even read it. I signed my name on the dotted line. And I had enough confidence in myself and my group that we could pull off that building that skateboard park. We could do it. We could do it in a safe manner. We could do it in a cost-effective manner. And we could do a good job. And we did. So, um, um,
19:44 We have a skateboard park that's bigger and better than we ever imagined. It has a half pipe, a mini pipe, a quarter pipe, a rail, a ledge. It's remarkable. It is not only that, it's a work of art. And when Don gets done with her landscaping, people are going to come down there and say, this is an artistic sculpture.
20:11 It is just so fantastic, and we're so proud of what we did. And I'd like to thank a few people that really went above and beyond the call of duty in this project. And the first one is John Eastman. John gave me the courage and just enough support that I said, okay, I'm going to go ahead and do this project. And he's volunteered to help finish up the project with the pavers. I went to Mammoth Mountain, and I've got to tell you,
20:40 Came to you guys on Wednesday, and I went to Mammoth Mountain on Thursday and said, I want to start on Monday. And Rusty said, Jane, I don't think I can do it this quick. And he called me back two hours later and said, we want to do it. He goes, but Clifford's going on vacation, so you've got to give us another week. So a job that I thought was going to take one Bobcat, Mammoth Mountain showed up with five pieces of big equipment, two dump trucks,
21:08 And worked with nine people for a week. They did a fantastic job and I'm really pleased and proud that they would help us. The other person is Peter Bernasconi. I think as a town sometimes we don't appreciate and really realize the gyms we have in our employment, but Peter is wonderful. He's helped on so many projects. He's worked with a group of people that
21:35 This last group has young people building a park and Peter hung in there and we all worked together and we got it done. And Peter, I really appreciate what you've done. I can't even say enough. Cliff and Man again down there working for a week, doing a great job. We also had a person that I didn't know show up. His name is Mitch Nowacki. He's a kid. He showed up and he goes, I want to help you. He stayed for three weeks.
22:04 And what he did was he moved rocks. Never any complaint. What do you need done? Well, we need those rocks moved. And he moved rocks for three weeks. And then, in the end, he said, I want to do something a little special. And he said, mammoth rocks aren't that pretty. And he went all throughout Mona County, and he found some beautiful rocks. And in the entryway to the skatewear park, there's a small rock wall. And he found those rocks and built that wall, and he did it all the time.
22:33 Donated labor. Also, Pete Del Giudice did the metal covers and we thank him so much for that. And then the last one is on Friday before Labor Day, we had a little problem with the skateboard park. We needed a welder. And so I got in the phone book and I first called Mammoth Welding and they said,
22:58 Hey, we're busy. And I called Pete, and I couldn't get a hold of him, and I called Brent Allen, and Brent Allen says, Jane, I'm on my way on vacation. And I said, oh, okay, I just need some welding done. He goes, wait a minute. I got an employee who was done at noon today. I think I can call him and get him down there. He came on Friday afternoon with no notice, worked for three hours, did the welding on the skateboard park, and allowed us to get the job done. Who was that, Jane?
23:26 I just know he works for Brent Allen. And then Brent, I said, Brent, make sure you send me a bill. And he goes, Jane, if it's a couple hours, it's for years for free. But if it's really difficult, I'm going to charge. I said, great. But anyway, I just wanted to say that I really do think that it's the community and our true community spirit that makes Mammoth Lakes so great. I've lived here for 39 years. I've loved it every minute.
23:53 And it's been the greatest place ever to raise my kids. And I think I wouldn't be surprised if someday Billy comes back up here and then I start coming back here again. But right now my kids, my Billy's in Vermont and the grandkids are in Vermont so I'm going to be headed in that direction for a little while. But thank you for letting me do my community service and I hope you guys all enjoy this Gaper Park. Oh, and the last thing is our opening is Saturday at noon.
24:22 And we've got hot dogs and soda pop. And we hope you'll all come down and watch the kids skate the new park. Jane, real quick while we have you here. Some people are thinking, well, we've already had a skate park for a number of years. And that's true. And it's a great skate park. But what Jane's talking about is the new addition to the skate park. And it's a new addition that allows the younger kids to skate something more.
24:51 To their speed and to be able to learn in a smaller park before they go into the big park. I went down and viewed it I think Saturday or Sunday this last weekend and what I found that was interesting is some of the older kids, some of the really good skaters, they were checking out this new park that's built for the kids and they were pointing out different aspects of the new park and how cool they thought they were.
25:19 And these kids are, you know, in their late teens or in their 20s. And so I thought it was really nice that they related to this new park for the kids. So when you get kids down there, I think they're going to really like it. Well, they're now saying they're calling it the kids in the old parts. Okay. The older guys are all looking forward to getting in there too.
25:42 And it's added a whole new dimension to the skateboard park. We have these bowls. You go into the street skate and into this other section. And it really has completed the park and made it a multi-use, multi-age. It's just a wonderful facility. I'm really excited and really proud of it. One final thing, Jane. And Jane spent some time tonight thanking different people. But without Jane's and Kenny Bear, who's in the audience, without Jane and Kenny's,
26:11 Efforts over the years and Jane's vision. And I see Elizabeth Tenney, another lady in the community who has visions and gets things done. This is a credit to Jane Bear and her efforts to get this park done. And thank you, Jane, for an absolutely wonderful amenity for our community and something for our kids to do. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Jane. Well done.
26:49 Putting is still open for anyone who wishes to speak to the council. Good evening, dear Woods, town council, the community. I just want to introduce myself. I'm Mike Larry. As Jade said, I'll be stepping up as the face of the skateboard park. And anyways, I'm sure I'll see you back here at some point. Very good. Very good to have you here. Thank you. All right. We're still in public comment. Seeing. Whoa.
27:30 Seeing Paul. Seeing Paul. That's going to be a tough act to follow, but I'll make this very brief. Good evening, Councilmembers. Mayor Watson? I mean, I'm sorry, Manager Watson? Manager Watson. Very briefly, we have the issue of a recycling facility coming up, which involves the potential of a 30-year contract.
28:01 That will be a contract that will live on perhaps beyond the lifespan of some of us here this evening, certainly myself. I'm hoping the Council will consider appointing a commission to look at that, people who have an interest in environmental people, business people, and so forth, because although there will be some benefits for the town as an economic, town government as an economic entity, there will be burdens to be paid by members of the community.
28:31 With that in mind, it seems to me that the best result can be accomplished by a great deal of transparency and by having appropriate people take a hard look at this thing and be able to discuss it. Right now, the discussion has largely been at the staff level and at the council level. And, of course, there have been closed session meetings, which you're obligated to do under certain circumstances. But it seems like before that final decision is made,
29:00 Thank you.
29:27 Thank you, Paul. Thanks, Paul. You can rest assured that that process will be very public and very transparent. I appreciate that. Thank you. Okay. Anyone else? Any updates, Stephen? Are you okay? Okay. All right. If none, we'll move to Councilmember Reports and additions to the agenda. We'll start with you, John. I have none, Mr. Mayor. Matthew. Just a couple comments.
29:57 The Mammoth Bike Games in the fall century took place last week. And I think, again, there was a lot of changes to it. As we know, the century was brought into town and started at the village. I believe there was about 800 riders somewhere in that neighborhood and several hundred mountain bikers that came off to help end a series of biking events. And I just wanted to say, you know, myself, Councilmember Raimondo,
30:27 I had the opportunity to work with Bill Cockroft, his staff, John Anderson, and a number of other people. And I'll tell you, these guys worked all year to do an incredibly professional job to make this event successful. And I can see it really growing into something even bigger and better than it already is. It's already an incredible event. But really watching how all those people, Bill and his staff and the volunteers, stepped up, it was...
30:55 Quite amazing. And Mammoth's really, I think, making a name for itself, especially this summer, the last couple summers, has really made a name for itself as a destination for summer events, whether it be outdoor riding activities, whatever, music. We've done a good job. I wasn't able to attend the Hop and Sage event, but I just wanted to say thank you to the Turners for putting that on. That's always a good end-of-the-year event for the musical scene. Myself,
31:26 Ted Carlton, Jack Copeland from the Chamber, and I believe now the Mammoth Times has jumped on board. We've started a fundraiser to try to raise money for the fireworks for 2014, and so far that effort's going very well. We had a gathering last week, and so far, I have to double check the numbers, but I think we're somewhere well over $5,000 already.
31:53 Raise to get that effort going. And so for some of the business community out there, particularly those that aren't paying into the T-bid, we're certainly looking for any people, volunteers, second homeowners, whomever, that really appreciate the fireworks show to step up and maybe talk to either me, Ted, Jack Copeland, or even Alexandra, Mammoth Times, about helping us with this effort. And any word you can get out there would be greatly appreciated.
32:23 That's all I have for this evening. Thank you, Matthew. Michael? I have none this week, Mr. Mayor. I've got a couple of items. One is that just for the benefit of the council and the public that the Mammoth Half Marathon, which had its inaugural start in June to open the season and was, as we know, a highly successful event, is coming back next year, June 22nd.
32:50 Matthew, as you were mentioning the bike races as the closing sporting event, it's interesting that we had a very successful closing event and a very successful opening event, both of which are outside the traditional opening and closing of the summer season. I'm very pleased about that. But they're pretty excited about it. They put together a proposal to change the route to include...
33:15 A loop around Lake Mary Road to provide an even more spectacular course for those who ran it. There were 1,100 runners last year. They're expecting 2,000 this year. I think this is going to be pretty extraordinary. And because it's associated or affiliated with San Diego Half Marathon, which is run in March each year, it's already being promoted. The registration is open, and they're pitching it pretty hard to those folks who are going to run San Diego.
33:45 Second, for the benefit of the council, the Mammoth Lakes Housing, whose monthly meeting I attended 10 days ago, and then a special meeting also on Monday of this week, is conducting...
34:04 It's strategic planning session all day Saturday. Sorry, John, it won't be up there. I'll be in an office somewhere. I hope there will be windows. Strategic planning is the only excuse. Yeah, well, I've got one. So if there are things council members wish to have me as the representative have on my agenda for Saturday,
34:29 Drop me an email because I want to hear what your thoughts are. I want to be able to express them instead of simply expressing my own. In addition, at a special meeting, the Mammoth Lakes Housing has voted to purchase back one of the deed-restricted units that is available for sale.
34:53 We have exercised our option to do that. We're doing that with funds that the housing organization has and are not coming to the town for either reserve funds or general funds. It is consistent with the program that we've been on, which is to repurchase and then resell those units. So the expectation is that we'll be able to flip that and keep a deep, restricted unit in the community. And then last but not least,
35:19 I just want to make a couple of comments, not in response directly to emails that we have received over the last couple of weeks, but it certainly isn't any secret that the town is in a state of transition. It's been an extraordinary couple of years. We've faced down the worst economic crisis in this town's history, and we have made some very tough and also
35:47 Politically controversial decisions. What I want to say is two things. One is that this council, despite the fact that we, and really thankfully that we don't always vote five to zero, has five thoughtful members that come from different perspectives, see things differently, but ultimately come to a conclusion or a decision, and each of us thinks that we're doing what we think is in the best interest of
36:17 The town, and I say that without exception. It's a good group, and we've made some difficult decisions over the last couple of weeks. We will continue to make difficult decisions, and we will continue to do what we think is in the best interest of the community. There's a guy sitting in the audience tonight, one of the people who has done community service, public service, volunteer service.
36:46 Been here for, I don't know, about 30 years and was bold enough, had the temerity to actually suggest that he might be able to help in some way in a position of leadership in this community. And this is a guy sitting over there whose name is Tom Cage.
37:08 He got blasted pretty hard by a number of people in this community for volunteering, for doing what he thought in his heart, in his head, could be something for this council to consider. And I'll tell you, I appreciate that because he didn't have to.
37:26 There are a lot of people in the community who will take shots and their glass is half empty instead of half full and will criticize people for stepping forward. It's a shame because people who step forward just as Jane has for 39 years and others that she has brought along with her.
37:47 It should be commended, and I do commend them for contributing to what we have here in this community. For the record, this council did not vote, notwithstanding what you might have heard and what rumors are out there, to replace a town manager with another town manager. We've not voted on anything at all.
38:14 We are considering and have considered a whole number of options. And, Tom, I just want to thank you for stepping up. You didn't have to do that. You didn't have to take the heat. There wasn't anything in it for you. I just hope there are other people out there like you, and I hope that you will continue to contribute as you have in innumerable ways in this community for the past 20 or 30 years or however long you've been here. 40.
38:37 So stay with us because your input and the thoughts that you bring, the ideas that you bring, the energy that you bring to this community makes us a better place. Thank you. That takes us to reports from commissions and or departments. Sandra.
39:07 Good evening, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. I just quickly wanted to update the Council and the public on two of our major work programs, the Main Street Plan and the zoning code update. The draft, staff has received a copy of the draft Main Street Plan and we're working on comments on it and the draft will be presented to the Council on October 16th for the joint workshop with the Planning and Economic Development Commission.
39:34 That will be published with your packets the week before, and so it will be available to the public that week as well. Also, the zoning code update, we are working hard to finish all of the loose ends on the zoning code update, and our goal is to publish the public review draft in mid-November and start public hearings early next year. So we're very happy that we're moving forward with those two major projects. Thank you. Thank you. Sandra? I have one quick question. So on the zoning code update, I understand there's...
40:04 One piece left dealing with the density and that's within our general plan. And I know it's a critical piece, but it's a small piece, but a critical piece. And for the public, what will it take if we were to go in there and change that?
40:26 What type of process would we be looking at? So we'll be bringing that item before the Planning Commission on October 9th, and we will be discussing it with you on your October 16th meeting as well. But it would depend on kind of the decisions that are made, but likely more environmental analysis than we're doing right now. So we have some options that we'll present to the Commission and to the Council, and hopefully we can get some decisions made or some direction on October 16th.
40:55 And we can move forward with that. Okay. Thank you. Anything else? Thank you. Thanks. Peter. Councilmembers, Peter Wernescoe, Public Works. I wanted to give a couple of updates on the projects we're working on. We're completed with the micro-seal projects that included Old Mammoth Road, Chateau, Upper Murty Boulevard, and Beaver Trail. And really, this is a new process that we're using in town.
41:25 It's a micro seal and it's got a high polymer mix. It's gooey, fills all the cracks, fills some of the bigger voids and has a real small aggregate so it's suitable for bikes and that kind of thing. It's also got a hardener that's a cement hardener so that it should last a while. But, you know, a lot of comments that we've been receiving are related to it's not going to last. All the aggregate's going to be scraped off first winter. And even if that happens, the surface is sealed.
41:54 And it'll increase the life of the pavement by three or four years at least. So, you know, we're confident that from that perspective as wanting well spent, certainly much cheaper than an overlay would be, and that's what we're trying to do is extend our maintenance dollars more wisely. And so it's experiment locally. It's been used in other cities, you know, Truckee, Tahoe, Reno. So we'll see how it works here over this winter.
42:22 The other project that's ongoing, as you see, is over on Minaret Connector Path. It's called Mammoth Creek Metal Lane Connector Path. That project's ongoing. There's a retaining wall being built next to the creek along that, which will make way for the Class 1 bike path. And then just an update. So Cal Recycle was here this week doing their annual audit. We'll get a report in two to four weeks. Hopefully we stay in the best efforts.
42:52 Versus the compliance realm for the program and we'll be giving an update to Council on that in future. Thank you, Peter. Questions? Peter, can you give us a little more information on the connector path on Minaret as it goes into Old Mammoth Road by Mammoth Creek there? That's a pretty extensive wall that's being built. Is that just for a path or is there a second lane going in there as well?
43:20 That's for a 10-foot-wide bike path. It's a class one bike path. It's a BTA-funded grant, so it's a 90% grant-funded project, 10% measure R. And essentially, we've got a couple of projects. That was one that we're building now. It connects to Mammoth Creek Park. There was a dirt trail that a lot of people used, and so we're paving that section. It'll be a class one bike path.
43:47 On Middle Lake itself because it's a pretty low volume road. And then this is the first piece that will be on Meridian, I mean on Minaret. And really there's a, in our master plan we've got Minaret Road having a class one bike path all the way up to the village. So this is the first little small link for that project. Good. Thank you. Thanks, Peter. Chief. And acting manager. I'm the police chief right now.
44:15 Yeah, I just want to give you a quick update on police staffing. We, as you're aware, and thanks to the action from the council, we have a new position in the department that is going to be filled real soon. September 30th, we will be swearing in new officer Jack Loera. His first day will be October 1st. Jack comes to us from Southern California. He's been a police officer for about 20 years.
44:42 He's with a couple of different departments. He's got a wealth of experience. He's currently working as a homicide detective in the Southern California Department. He was previously a sergeant in another agency. He's bilingual. He's really excited about coming here. He's already leased a house, and we're just as excited about having him join us. So you'll see a new face in town starting next month. Chief, can he hit the road running, or is there a training?
45:09 Probation period? No, he's required to go through a training program, whether he's required to or not by post. He's experienced, but every department does procedures differently. He needs to become familiar with the town. He's not from here, so he'll spend a fair amount of time with another partner who will be serving as a training officer. For two months? Something like that. Something like that, okay.
45:34 But hiring somebody with experience does accelerate the time that it takes to get the person out working on their own. Great. We're really happy to have them. Thank you. Thanks, Chief. All right. Other departments? Commissions? Carrie? Mayor, council members, community. I'm here, and I struggle whether this goes to public comment or commission, but it really affects our commission. And, you know, whether I should even say anything or not. But I'm going to, because it's a great concern of mine.
46:07 It was something that I had an issue with at our last commission meeting. And I'm here to express concern about the town's ability to reconcile and measure R and measure U within the finance department. And I'm not here to point fingers at anybody. I realize that the town's short-handed and financially strapped. We don't have a town manager. We don't have a finance director. But basic municipal principles and reporting shouldn't be ignored and need to be corrected.
46:37 Finance has been working on BasicGov, which is going to be very helpful once it's completed, but it doesn't help with the reconciliation of Measure R and Measure U. The commission's been asking for a long time for that reconciliation of at least Measure R, and we've been told that the finance department was unable to reconcile that and give us that reconciliation, so it's gone out to the temp services.
47:05 And they're going to be pulling information from the town's finance reports, financial reports, and putting it into QuickBooks so that we can have that. You know, in that manner, that's great. We're going to get the information, I guess, that we've been asking for. But it's truly a Band-Aid. And I just, this is just one more thing that shows the archaic. And once again, I don't know whether it's personnel, if that's because they're shorthanded they weren't able to do it, or whether it's an archaic program.
47:33 But as opposed to just continually not being able to do something, we need to ask the questions of why. And what do we need to do to make that happen? And, you know, this is kind of really a basic service that this town should be providing. And this shouldn't have to go out to create a second set of books to get that type of information. Thank you. Terry, thank you. I can assure you that this finance...
48:00 The issue is a top priority for this council having been through interviews for an interim town manager position and so it is squarely in the middle of our radar. If that helps. I appreciate it because this only truly puts a band-aid on it. We'll probably have to duplicate the efforts once we have the system, the people, whatever it is that we need to have to make this happen within the town. So we'll be paying for the same service twice.
48:27 But it's something that obviously if we have tax money coming in and grant money going out of that, it needs to be reconciled within the ordinance. Thank you. Any other commission report? All right. Seeing none, we'll move to agenda item number one, the introduction of TOT Compliance Specialist, Suzanne Falco. Shannon. Good evening, Mayor, fellow council members. I would like to introduce you to Suzanne Falco. She's the newest member of our TOT.
49:08 Compliance Team. Suzanne is glad to be working back in Mammoth again and be part of the Mammoth family. She's really proud of her accomplishments. She helped to open the Crowley Lake Library. How do you say that again? Sleuthing? Sleuthing. She has sleuthing skills that she's developed over the years trying to find out about her ancestors' genealogy.
49:36 Ancestry. Which has really helped her in the TOT compliance effort because you pretty much have to be a detective to find out how these people are renting illegally. In the short time that Suzanne has been here since July, she single-handedly has billed over $10,000 in back TOT of people that are existing remitters. So we are super glad to have her and we want to welcome her to our team.
50:05 Suzanne, welcome. Thank you. Thank you. I am glad to be here in Mammoth very much. My history is here and I enjoy the mountains and seeing old friends and putting forth good effort for the community. I don't know how many children you raised. I have three step sets. Two are in the area. Okay. Yeah. The high school, the games, all that stuff. Yeah. Well, we enjoy your children.
50:40 Thank you. Good people. Thanks for joining that team as well. They've done a lot of work over the last three years that we've all seen, and I think put together a good group that's, I think, over the next month, we're going to see all the work come to fruition, hopefully, with the completion of the Basic Gov system and everything else. So thanks for doing that. It's such a critical part of everything that all of us need. It is. It's a good program.
51:08 Yeah. It's good. Well, thank you. Thank you. And good luck. Agenda item number two, introduction of personnel and risk analyst, Sarah Rosler. Yes, I'm back now as your acting town manager. It's my pleasure to introduce our new personnel manager and risk analyst, Sarah Rosler.
51:33 Sarah originally came from, was born in Philadelphia, but was raised in Virginia Beach. She got a bachelor's degree in international relations from William and Mary, then went on and got a master's degree in international administration from the University of Miami. She formerly worked in Washington, D.C., and most recently in Ridgecrest for the last six years, where she was a human capital consultant with the Navy. Sarah met her husband here in Mammoth.
52:00 And she's been living here part-time for the last two years, will now be here full-time. She enjoys snowboarding, trail running with her dogs, backpacking, hiking, and many other activities of the eastern Sierra. And I think it's important to note, you know, she comes to us with a lot of background, a lot of experience, a lot of education. We have a bunch of people working in the town with master's degrees in relevant disciplines.
52:27 She's a great addition to the town and we're really glad to have her here. So, Sarah. Councilmembers, Mayor, I'm just really happy to be here. I'm happy to be a part of Mammoth full-time and be an active member of the community now. And I think I'm stepping into some big shoes with the town and there's a lot of work to be done and I'm excited to help do it. Thank you. There's a lot of work to be done. Thank you for being here. Part of the rebuilding effort, I'm just really pleased to have you here.
52:58 Thank you. I think the chief said it real well. It's just amazing all the people they've been bringing on, just how many people have their master's degrees and the education behind them and the experience is wonderful. So thank you. We appreciate it. All right, that's great. Consent Agenda Items 3 through 7. Any council member wish to pull any items? No, but I have a question of the town attorney, if I may, Mr. Mayor.
53:30 Andy, the question has arisen, and I've heard it both ways. On approval of minutes, I've heard that even though you weren't in attendance at a meeting, you can still vote on the minutes. Can you clarify that for me? It's really more of a custom than a hard requirement, but the custom everywhere, really, is that if you weren't there, that probably you shouldn't be voting on the minutes. That's a custom. At some point,
54:02 You might have people not in attendance who, to get enough to get a majority vote on a minute's approval. Oh, certainly. I mean, if that's the only way you can get a quorum so that you can approve the minutes, then yeah, by all means. Okay. So, specifically, I'm not sure if, Matthew, were you at both meetings as well? I believe so. Oh, okay. So we're good then. There's three, actually.
54:33 Let me just, I'm double checking everything here. Okay. Yep. Is there a motion? Mr. Mayor, I'll move for approval of Council Consent Agenda Items 3 through 7. I abstain, number 4. I'll second. It's been a motion and a second in light of the fact that there may be an abstention. Roll call, please. Council Member Eason? Yes. Council Member Lane? Yes. Council Member Ramon? No. I abstain.
55:02 On number four only. Number four only, yes. Mayor Wood? Yes, as to all of the items. All right, it takes us to policy matters, the first of which is number eight, code compliance efforts and funding. Thank you. The purpose of this item is to allow the town council to discuss options for funding code compliance efforts.
55:27 And to allow the town council to provide direction to staff on these options. The town has been absent a code compliance officer since 2008, which has resulted in compliance issues regarding signage, outdoor sales, property violations, blight, as well as other issues. In order to resolve these issues and develop and staff a code compliance task force, which was a recommendation by the council in June, staff has developed a plan to use some salary savings.
55:55 From our vacant public works director, community and economic development director, and assistant building official positions, which would allow the town to provide code compliance support over the next two years. Staff has outlined the salary savings for the vacant positions on page three of your agenda bill, as well as the recommended expenditures to provide code compliance within the town for the next two years. This would include hiring some short-term help immediately.
56:23 And then funding a full-time position for two years. If the Town Council was supportive of the staffing a code compliance officer, staff would complete the budget amendments as necessary. Staff is recommending that the Town Council choose option one and direct staff to proceed with funding for a temporary and interim code compliance position while recruiting for a permanent position. That concludes my report. I'm available for questions. And also Commissioner Tenney.
56:52 And Vice Chair Kearney from the Planning Commission are here to speak on this topic as well. All right. First question is for Sandra. John. Sandra, can you share with us how the salary structure was identified for this position? Oh, it's just step A. It's a standard. It's our adopted salary structure. So it would be step A, the lowest step for the code compliance officer. Is that what you're asking?
57:19 It is. I just was asking the question because I didn't know if there was an opportunity for additional fine-tuning of the salary for this particular position or if it's already been advertised at a certain salary. We haven't advertised anything. This is the lowest step for the lowest of a Code Compliance Officer. Code Compliance Officer 1, Step A. So this is the bottom.
57:42 For a full-time position. If the council wanted to consider part-time, we would have to go back and take a look at that. But this would be a full-time permanent position, well, two-year position. Okay. I just wondered if there was any follow-up questions from any other council members. So it's 182.311 for two years, is that accurate? Correct, right. That includes salary and benefits. Okay. And then would this code compliance officer be, it would,
58:10 Would it be helping replace some of the duties that Johnny was doing? Yes. Johnny was doing a lot of building life safety code compliance, pretty much all of the building and life safety. We've continued to respond to those issues. So this person would be able to do that.
58:25 As well as add on some of the non-life safety issues like signage, outdoor sales, those kinds of things. Okay. So we'd be replacing that position and adding on the code compliance piece. They would be taking that piece. So the position, so Johnny's work is now being handled by Ron Fansler, one of our inspectors. Okay. So this would, so everybody's kind of been shifting. This would allow Ron to get back to public works inspections. Got it. And would relieve him. Perfect. Okay. Thank you.
58:49 This position would have a certain level of requirement to qualify for this position. I'm just curious if we start at that bottom step, somebody that's experienced, which we're looking for, might not be interested if they're starting at the bottom? Could be the case. Okay. 90,000 a year? Yeah. 91 a year? That's with benefits. Yeah. Okay. I just wanted to bring it up for discussion. Got it.
59:21 I'll reserve my comments for discussion because that's worthy of a discussion, John. So if there are no other questions of staff, let's go to members of the commission who wish to speak. Colin, do you want to? Evening, counsel. Thanks for the opportunity to speak to you guys. Speaking as a member of the planning commission as well as one of the two appointed members of the code compliance task force, so I just want...
59:54 To address a couple things, answer any questions you may have. Sandra, I appreciate you kind of clarifying some of those issues, but we do have unanimous support among the Planning Commission. We feel that we've put a lot of time and energy into code compliance, zoning code updates, and I think that without the code compliance officer, without that piece, it's a little bit more of just an academic exercise.
1:00:21 I think the timing right now is very appropriate, especially with the passing of the T-Bid. We are going to be putting a lot more money as a community into marketing ourselves as a destination, and I think it's really important that as those visitors come here, maybe for the first time, that the product that we're offering matches the perception that they have.
1:00:45 You know, we really need to think about our competition, and I was just recently on a trip for our business retreat in both Telluride and Crested Butte, and it reminded me of how stiff the competition is out there. You know, most of us know the ski industry is not growing. It's kind of stagnant at this point, and there's a lot of resorts out there that are competing for those same dollars.
1:01:10 So I think it's really important for us to make sure that our guest experience is the best it can be. And I think the current, you know, I think it's important to think about this issue, including property issues and blight, because there is a big piece of this that hasn't gotten a lot of discussion just on safety.
1:01:31 And those kind of things. But a lot of this discussion and a lot of what we've been diving into just deals with the signage and outdoor sales and those kind of things. So, you know, I really think that it's an important piece of the guest experience. I think a lot of us would agree that the look of the town right now is not what we would like it to be. I think that lack of having a code compliance officer for a number of years has really gotten out of hand.
1:01:57 And I think, you know, part of what I was reminded of on this trip is Mammoth actually does a very good job of driving visitation. You know, we seem to be pretty good at bringing visitors to our community throughout the year compared to our peer resorts. But I think the area that we're struggling a little bit is in driving revenue, which is really what's the important piece.
1:02:26 The type of look that we have right now is I think impacting that negatively. And I think the point that we're at right now, which I think is important to note, as part of this task force, we've spoken to a lot of important business members in the community. And I think the point we're at right now is that a lot of them just feel like it's kind of a free-for-all. And the thing that we've heard loud and clear...
1:02:51 Is they just want a level playing field and they want to understand what the rules are. And I think without a code compliance officer, it leaves it up to the individual business to just do as they see fit. So I think it is a really important piece of making sure that everybody's operating on the same playing field. And I think we've got some businesses right now that have been vocal about the fact that until we take this step, they're going to continue to act in this manner as an act of civil disobedience.
1:03:19 And I think that that's unfortunate that we're at the point right now where businesses that want to comply have decided to take the route to just fall into line with the non-compliers. So I appreciate you guys taking some time to listen to this. I know you have a lot of stuff to deal with, but I think as a planning commission, we do feel this is really important to the efforts that we're putting forth. I think it's going to be very important to the future of our town that we're not...
1:03:48 It's not a, well, I do, maybe it's a,
1:04:16 Question for staff. I was looking at a town manager update that the council received in July, and there was an indication that the recruitment was going to be for a part-time person. Is that something that you, as the commission, have discussed? Can you address that part-time? And the reason I ask the question, of course, is that funding for this comes from salary savings because of a missing director, which means that we're going to have to
1:04:44 My discussions with staff revolved around the fact that the intent of this being a two-year position is that we do have current funding because of the savings. So you're absolutely right that in two years we would have to evaluate if that continues to be a priority, and I hope it would be.
1:05:13 I think from our standpoint, there are a couple of options that we can take. I think we would be certainly receptive to a part-time position that was supplemented with some volunteer effort. We do have some people that have volunteered their time for this effort, including myself. So I think personally my feeling at this point, since we do have the savings, which in my meeting with staff I was pleased to hear that.
1:05:40 That this would be the best route to go, but if the council feels otherwise, I think we would be receptive to looking at some other options as well. I just think we're at the point where we feel like all the effort that we've put in is going to be wasted unless we can have some sort of teeth at the end of it. So whatever you guys feel is best, you know, we're willing to try and work with. Thanks. Mr. Mayor, what I can see here too, the savings really for those positions are through February 1. It's not for the entire two years.
1:06:10 Correct. So it's just the savings for between now and February 1 would be enough to get us a person for two years. Correct. And we'd still have the ability in February 1 to hire back to all those positions. Correct. I mean, there is pretty significant savings at this point due to some high-level positions that have been vacated. And those were all budgeted and allocated for. So, you know, I think obviously we'd...
1:06:36 Have to reevaluate in a couple of years, but, you know, the savings is there just based on the lag time right now. And I do think it's an important priority for using some of those available funds. Thanks. Thank you. Elizabeth. Elizabeth Tenney, Mammoth Lakes Planning Commission. What we really got here without a code compliance officer is we're devaluing the product that we're offering our visitor. We're devaluing the whole experience.
1:07:05 An example of that, just one small example, and I'm just talking about, you know, signage right now, there's so many aspects of the code that have to be dealt with, is 40% of our winter guests, Rhonda Dugan told me, don't ski, 40% of our winter guests don't ski, and yet outside this $1 million investment that Vaughn's made to have a showcase store in Mammoth because of the setting and because of where we are,
1:07:30 And they did all this extra stuff in the mall that the mall owners wouldn't pay for. There's still a 12 by 8 banner, tattered, dirty, ripped. It's been up over two years, right over their sculpture garden and their water feature that they put in, you know, to upgrade their store. And with the code enforcement officer, that wouldn't have happened. What my personal preference would be is to hire somebody as soon as possible.
1:07:57 A temporary employee, a clerk, clerk level, because almost every single flutter flag, portable sign, you know, banner that you see around town, they're violations of our current code, not violations of the draft zoning code update that we've been working on very, very hard. And so all of them are out of compliance, and all of those letters could be sent, and then seven days later, you know, are they in compliance, and then that's that. And that would be at a clerk level. I don't know how that figures in.
1:08:25 Sandra with the finances because I haven't been privy to that. I haven't been following that. I do want to tell you a story. You know, we're the Planning and Economic Development Commission, so this is all in terms of economic development and reversing this phrase to the bottom. And I read the most interesting article called Clawback, written by an economist who writes in a weekly magazine, and it's all about lobsters, and I'm going to digress very briefly about lobsters. This is really good.
1:08:55 He made some very interesting points. Right now, lobsters are incredibly cheap. Supermarkets in the Northeast are selling lobsters for $2.20 a pound. You can't buy hamburger for $2.20 a pound, and that's what lobsters are going for. Lobstermen are, you know, afraid they're going to be out of work. And lobster has always been perceived as a luxury, so restaurants aren't putting lobster on sale. They're not saying, you know, big markdown, lobster's on sale this week. And they're offering amenities to support
1:09:23 To promote that image of a luxury. And the reason they're doing that is when you have a product like a meal, or in some cases they're retail purchases you can make, you can't evaluate it objectively. So you equate quality with price. And the lobster stays expensive also because it makes the other menu items look more reasonably priced. And there's research that supports this. They did a study and he recounts it in this article. And it was such a good article. I made copies for you.
1:09:53 Where they had people buying microwave ovens. And the first group had to choose between a low-priced oven and a moderately priced oven. The sales were 50-50. The second group had to choose between an expensive oven, a moderately priced oven, and a low-priced oven. Moderately priced oven sales were up 40% because they had the high one in comparison. And what we're offering with this discount mentality, with this 70% off, 80% off, I'm waiting for 100% off.
1:10:22 What we're offering with this discount mentality with Mammoth on sale is, you know, we're the discount capital of resorts. And as Colin said, and as we've said before, it's a race to the bottom, and this just isn't working. So we could learn something from this logical article. That's why I'm going to give it to you. Last April, as I think we told you before, we did interviews with many business owners in conjunction with the Chamber of Commerce. We did a survey and had 56 responses.
1:10:48 What we heard over and over and over again, customer service and word of mouth are the most important things for a successful business, and only a few responses said, we need more signs. So we only have one chance to make a first impression, and we are determined to stop this race to the bottom. We've got to improve visitors' first impressions. So what we would like to do is have a clean sweep, get ready for the best winner ever, as soon as possible, hire a clerk, and I don't know if a clerk...
1:11:17 Do clerks have to be paid benefits or is that just a temporary position? Well, we included in this plan to hire a temporary person immediately. Temporary person. So it would be someone through like a temp agency. Right. A temporary person who could just send out the letters and then do the follow-up. And by Thanksgiving or mid-December at the latest, have the town cleaned up. And then when we can find a co-compliance officer on the level of Alex Hackman.
1:11:44 Rick, do you remember it, John? Do you remember Alex Hackman? He was great. Find somebody on that level who could do a comprehensive cleanup of the town with all aspects of the code, we'd be much better off. That would be terrific. So that's what we're after, and it really does matter to our economy. There are a bunch of things that we've recommended. I'll be really fast. Recommended in the zoning code update that will also improve visitors' first impressions, but I won't go into those now. But I do want to give you this article.
1:12:13 Elizabeth, your request is what's agendized as our recommended option. Oh, wonderful, thank you. Thank you. Sandra, do we know the estimated timing on filling the temporary position? Do we have any idea or not really?
1:12:36 No, we could hire quickly. We could hire someone through Sierra employment relatively quickly. Oh, I see. A week or so. Someone who's qualified. Well, we would talk to them and find out, but, I mean, depending on what we're looking for, if we're looking for someone who's at, like, a lower level just to send out some letters, do some, you know, kind of administrative stuff, that would be pretty easy. To hire an interim code compliance officer, someone who's going to go out and deal with them. Might be more difficult. That might be more difficult, yeah. Okay, good.
1:13:03 I just wanted to state that thanks to Colin and Elizabeth, Steve Claussen, you know, there's a lot of people in the community who have, for lack of a better description, put pressure on the council over the last several months to take seriously the filling of this position. So thank you, and we're getting there. I'd second that, John. And Elizabeth, Colin, that's just the leadership, I think.
1:13:32 Everybody wants out of the Planning Commission, so thank you, and thank you, Sandra and staff, for helping them get all this together. Appreciate it. Members of the public wish to comment. Tom Cage, real quick, Colin and Elizabeth have done huge work on this. I don't want to see it go to waste. I hope that the town attorney can look at the existing ordinance and the new changes that are planned, meld that into whatever letter goes out to the business community because you're going to have people looking for loopholes.
1:14:09 We're going to have people looking for ways around it or to slow it down or to upend the process completely, and we don't want that. So as much as we want to rush to this and clean it up, which we all do, and there needs to be a little bit of planning prior to that I think legal counsel can help us with so that whenever that letter goes out, it's precise, it's defined, and it gets us where we want to be, which is where...
1:14:36 The Planning Commission, I think unanimously, is supportive of. So I encourage you to take a breath and give it an extra week or two depending on Andy's schedule and make sure that part is done correctly. Thank you. Tim. Hi, Tim Flynn, resident business owner. My question, I guess, to staff would be,
1:15:08 With the recent kind of privatization of the building inspection services, have we looked into privatizing the code compliance service? Is that something that we can hire an outside business for so we're not looking at paying all the benefits, paid time off, CalPERS, all the stuff that goes along with having a public employee?
1:15:37 The building inspections, we contracted with Sierra Geotechnical Services just as an interim, as a stopgap between until we hire a building official, and that would be what we would do as part of this plan. So we could hire a temp until we hire the permanent person. Can I just mention that I think it's working just awesomely. I mean, I think it's brilliant. I think we should keep it. You know, a building official, yeah, great, but I think that, you know, this...
1:16:06 The public-private partnership effort is really working out. You know, I've had great experience with the new inspectors that have been coming by my job sites. And so, you know, I'm just, I'm looking at it from, you know, a business standpoint and saving money standpoint. And I've been talking about the money that we've been saving from these salaries for months. And I've never heard anything until you just said something.
1:16:35 You know, with, you know, using that money to do other things. And until you guys just said something about it, I mean, it was kind of neglected to be talked about. And like that money was just there, and that now it's being used to, you know, fund this other position. It's just a little lack of transparency there, I think. And so I'm just, you know, I'm, you know, me and just me so far, but I definitely want to push for it.
1:17:04 Some sort of investigation into, you know, businesses or other, you know, members of the community, private citizens, private people that could be hired to do this job. I mean, I totally agree that we need this, you know, but, and in the interim, I know that Sierra Employment Services isn't, you know, funded under the union structure and that sort of stuff, but I just definitely think that that would be a good,
1:17:34 Option to look at. It's something that we can take a look at, but the town is under some limitations that state law establishes. There's some things that we can't contract out. There's some things that we have to do, we're required to do with employees. So we'll have to take a look and see if code enforcement is something that could even be contracted out if we wanted to. But at least take a look at it. You know, I mean, that's all I'm asking. Yeah. And just, and give us, you know, option A, yeah, we can't. Option B, no.
1:18:02 It just makes sense to me since we don't have a lot of money. We'll take a look. Thank you. This 10-minute item I can see is going to consume us, but there's some important issues that are raised. Any other member of the public wishes to speak before we deliberate or discuss?
1:18:37 Go ahead, Tim. You know, also recently we just had the California or the Contractor State License Board visit our community and wrote some citations to some unlicensed contractors and I discussed this, you know, the district attorney's been informed and this is something that the local enforcement, I mean, these are misdemeanor offenses.
1:19:04 That are being committed and there are heavy, heavy penalties and fines that can be issued. And so, you know, I had talked to Dan and he had said, yeah, this is something that the code enforcement could, you know, take care of and issue these business and professions codes violations, which, I mean, to have employees on your job site without a contractor's license and without workman's comp is $4,200 per
1:19:34 Employee. So, I mean, we're talking huge fines. And Jesse and I, being on, we see it all the time. I mean, it is just, it runs rampant in this town. And so, I mean, I think that, you know, on another note, I mean, if this is something that they could, you know, run around with a citation book, you know, and issue these fines, I mean, it's great revenue. And so, that was another
1:20:01 The question that I have is if that was, you know, going to be wrapped into the job title of a code enforcement officer. Thank you, Tim. Hi. Well, I want to hear from Council members. What I'm hearing among the whispers are a number of issues that are raised and they relate to money, actually. And so I'm happy to take the lead, but I'm happy to hear anybody else speak as well.
1:20:36 On whatever it is that you have either objection to or in support of the recommendation. I'll go ahead and start, I guess. As far as the funding, one question I have. So we have it for two years. Is there a reason we selected two years versus one? That was the limit of the funding. I mean, we went through and we spoke with the commissioner, Tenney, and vice chair Ferney, and thought that a two-year time was a better kind of interim time.
1:21:06 You know, it could be one year, but it doesn't give you as much push, I think, to have a short term. Okay. All right. That was my only real question there. Other than that, I'm supportive of it. Tim, you mentioned the money just appeared and came up. It's actually because of the lack of other employees that the money's there now through February. So it didn't just appear. It actually, it's there because we're not paying it out to somebody currently for other positions.
1:21:36 It's not in there. Yeah, that's not in here. But when we did, that was allocated to some other position somewhere else that was, or other expenditures in last year's budget. Yep. It's in the budget. Yeah. So anyway, it's not like we just magically came up with money. It's actually money that's in our budget currently.
1:22:06 Because we don't have the positions, that's why we're able to fill it. So I just wanted to clarify that for you. And other than that, I mean, I think Colin, Elizabeth, staff done a great job. I do think it's very important that if we can do this to help them out, I'm supportive of it. I mean, I'm definitely supportive of it. I'm just concerned about the money side. I'm concerned about the public works director and the CED director being...
1:22:35 Pushed out until February, even though I know it's going to take a little time to fill those positions. It just seems pretty expensive. Would you, if we had a shorter term on the two years, I mean, for example, if we were to get a public works or a CED director in sooner than that, would you be in favor of shorter term than on the two-year person?
1:23:07 Yeah, I mean, I'm in favor of this. I'm just not sure as far as on the cost and, you know, and the delay on those other positions. John, your comments? I just wanted to second Tim Flynn's comment, and I don't know if I'm guessing that the job description does not fit with this particular position to have someone check out people that are in business in the town.
1:23:37 You know, there are people who don't even have business licenses that are working workers' comp. I pay $1,000 a week for workers' comp, and I've got five employees. And, you know, whether I have work, whether they're working or not, and yet there are other people in the community that are soliciting my clients who don't have, that are not paying workers' comp or don't have a business license, and they're undercutting me.
1:24:05 In most cases it doesn't make a difference, but 10, 20% it does. So I agree with Tim that everybody that's in a certain business in town should be able to compete on a level playing field. So I don't know, Tim, I don't know how that's answered with this particular position, but I just wanted to state it because I think it's an important issue for in particular contractors and people in business in town. Chief, do you have...
1:24:36 Yeah, let me just add, I don't know whether that can be done either as far as enforcing those laws with local people. I think it's worth finding out whether we can or not. I do know, and this goes back many, many years, I worked with a state agency, and I forget the name of it, but it dealt with employee records and workers' comp insurance. And we would go into certain businesses, ABC license locations, and we used their investigator. We went in and worked with them.
1:25:05 And they had the ability, as Tim was saying, to write some very large citations that were difficult to have overturned. The revenue went to the state. We never got anything that I know of from that. But that's only – I don't think you want to do that primarily to look for another source of revenue. But to address the issue you're talking about, that you have people complying with all the laws, including workers' comp, and you have others that don't.
1:25:35 Provides an unfair advantage. But I believe it probably requires somebody from those specific state agencies. I think it's something we can look into. Yeah, good point. Thank you. It would require, it would almost require someone making a complaint to one of those state agencies to have them look into it. I know a lot of insurance companies are doing that now, private insurance companies. We've even gotten calls in our businesses to verify that we have a lot of these
1:26:03 That we're paying, you know, for our employees as well. So I don't know if there's an insurance thing on the back end, but it might be another avenue. Thank you. I'm supportive. You know, I, well, first of all, it's hard not to be for a variety of reasons. I mean, one is that, you know, we've stated as a council that one of the priorities is to rebuild the organization. This is consistent with that.
1:26:29 I don't have the answer as to why part-time was in July on the table, at least at staff level, and we're now at full-time. Second, clearly the violations of our codes have increased over the last four or five years because we don't have an enforcement officer, and we know that the public wants one.
1:26:57 So all of those are really good reasons, but I think if this council votes to adopt option one, it has to, one, accept the assumption that we're not going to fill the Public Works Director until February 1st because the savings, substantial savings, comes from that vacant position. And two, that we're not going to appoint the Community and Economic Development Director position until the same date. And that takes us to...
1:27:27 You know, one of the discussions that we will have as we deliberate on the hiring of an interim and permanent town manager, and that is, you know, what comes first? Does the manager come first and the hires come second? Or does the interim manager, in addition to recruiting a permanent manager, also go about hiring directors that we've budgeted for and we know we need because there are vacancies?
1:27:55 So I'm just saying so long as we know that. And then the second point is that, I mean, this absolutely runs out in two years, which means that something, I mean, I don't know what the financial circumstances are going to be. I don't know what the budget's going to be in two years, but that causes me a little bit of anxiety because it's only a two-year position. I know that a lot can be accomplished in two years, but it's like everything. Once you add it, it's pretty hard to drop it or to get rid of it.
1:28:25 The third issue, it seems to me, is the one that Tim alluded to, and that is, you know, are there private organizations out there that should do that, that a town employee, a town hired person would otherwise do? That takes us to, you know, the broader issue, and that is, and we've talked about this for months, and it's going to be central in this next six or eight months.
1:28:55 Is whether or not this is an area where we ought to be outsourcing. Matthew and Michael have talked extensively about outsourcing. One of the things that's going to be coming forward on our agenda in the coming weeks and months is whether or not we should undertake a compensation and job classification study.
1:29:19 That's something that's promoted by more than one council member. And so, you know, I don't know that all those things ought to get in the way of hiring somebody, but I think the council has to know that if we adopt option one and then hire an employee as opposed to doing it differently, that we are, in fact, committing ourselves to a couple of years in a way that is extremely traditional. It's the traditional that we've been talking about not doing.
1:29:47 In the future. And so, I have to tell you, I'm conflicted on it. Notwithstanding that I recognize that we need a code enforcement officer. I'm conflicted because this is something that we're doing because we happen to have these savings now under extraordinary circumstances that exist in the future. So I've just laid out the issue, but I don't have the answer. Well, and it falls into the wage and compensation study. I mean, it goes right into what we've been talking about.
1:30:17 How long does that wage and compensation study usually take? A few months? I don't know. Andy, I know that you've got some experience in other cities doing compensation and classification studies. I realize that's not on our agenda, but that's something that may impact this. How long does that take?
1:30:46 It depends on how extensive you want it to be. It depends on the extent to which the consultant you use can build on work they've done for other people. If you find a consultant that has done a similar study in a similar community relatively recently, then it won't take them as long. I think you're looking probably at a few months. Yeah, that would be my guess, too. What I'm wondering is, you know, Michael, Councilmember Romero, have brought up, you know, that we're
1:31:15 Taking every dollar here pretty much and spending it with a two-year person and then you're concerned with going against, I think, what a lot of beliefs are of council. I'm wondering if the solution might not be just looking at one year for that position. And then the other ones, they're temporary anyway, right? Interim, building official, contract, planning services. I mean, these are shorter terms. Is that correct, Sandra? Yes.
1:31:46 So we're really looking at one person, and if we're looking at that one person, I mean, could it be, you know, could it be for a year-long period? I want to help them get this done, because I think we do have a problem that we need to fix, and I think it's only going to exacerbate itself while we make a decision on it. So I'm wondering if there's not a solution to help them achieve their goal without trumping our efforts. Was the thought of it part-time, is that...
1:32:15 Still on the table, or was it not? Mayor Wood, just in response to your comment, I believe the July memo from, I'm assuming Mariana referenced part-time, I think that was before Johnny put in his notice, so it might have been without considering the salary savings from his position. Thank you. Just to be clear with where we're coming from, we would certainly be receptive to a one-year position, or even a part-time position, I think.
1:32:49 A lot can be done in a year, and I think really there's going to be an education piece to it that I think will be critical, and I think really just a lot can be done in a short period of time. The only thing we wanted to stress, and as far as working out the finances and the time frame, that's not really necessarily where we need to direct this, but I think the one thing that we did want to stress is
1:33:17 You know, we do have winter approaching quickly. Most of these ski businesses will make a lot of their decisions, you know, by mid-November at the late end. So I think having something done sooner rather than later will do a lot to change the look of the town for this winter. And I'd hate to see, you know, I feel like we've lost a couple of summers and a couple of winters recently, and I'd really like to have something done prior to this winter.
1:33:45 Anything that's put in place after December 1st at the absolute latest is probably too late for this winter. And I will say that's why I was in favor of the temporary employee just writing the citations, sitting there on the computer, writing the letters, sending them out, and then going to check to make sure that they've been complied with. And this is just for one narrow part of the code, you know, signage and outdoor sales and stuff like that, just because of that visitor's first impression. And something I didn't say before, but I think it might be relevant here.
1:34:18 Is you realize, well, one thing we're going to be asking you is to raise the fines substantially for code violations, and we will be making some revenue from this, from the fines that come in. There was an example on the sheet last week of the firefighters in Blaine, Idaho, where they just had that huge fire, you know, by Ketchum. They have a $1,000 a day fine if you don't keep your property cleared 30 feet away from the building. $1,000 a day, but there's nobody to enforce it.
1:34:46 So it's, you know, it's sort of where we are. We're just, we're shooting ourselves in the foot with this. So if a clerk could do it, a temporary clerk could do, could really clean up this town in terms of how it looks for that visitor who comes and make things a lot better this winter. Excuse me? Elizabeth, you mentioned signage as well as outdoor sales. Do you believe that there's more than enough work for a full-time position?
1:35:16 to address on code compliance? I think once, personally, I think once we get the town cleaned up and get people educated about this, because the businesses have just complained so bitterly about, you know, this is not a level playing field and that everybody's trying to compete in the race to the bottom. But I think once we get things cleaned up, I don't think it would be a full-time position if someone were efficient about it. I just, I personally don't see that.
1:35:40 I mean, if something I were to tackle, I can't see it would be a full-time position. But to do a comprehensive cleanup in addition to safety and public health, you know, violations, you know, and the things that Tim was talking about, that's a lot more work. But I think we need to have the reputation that, you know, we've got these rules, we've got them for a good reason, and we enforce them. And right now, people are just thumbing their noses, you know. It doesn't matter. So theoretically, a temporary.
1:36:10 The temporary code compliance position. Sandra, do you have any thoughts on that? You're in a position to know. And also thoughts on part-time. Yeah. I think that code compliance is kind of an ebb and flow kind of thing. So a lot of times you can get people in compliance and then if you let the heat off then people kind of start getting back and doing their... Kind of like TOT compliance? Kind of like TOT compliance, yes. So I think it's important to have, to be consistent with code compliance.
1:36:40 And I think that with all of the items, because we don't just do signage and outdoor sales, we do life safety, we do nuisance, we have spent a number of, I mean, lots of hours on simply one code compliance case that we've dealt with this last year. So that's Mr. Morin, who you heard from last week.
1:37:02 Last meeting. So, I mean, there is a lot of time that someone could spend doing that. Maybe in five, ten years, you know, we could reevaluate it, but I think that in the next two years we could, staff, we could find work for a full-time code compliance officer. Second question, do you think that, as Tim mentioned, that the Sierra Employment Agency could find someone to fill this position to our satisfaction?
1:37:30 We could ask them. I mean, they have a pool of people to choose from. It's typically administrative type people, but we could ask them if they have someone along these lines. We didn't, we haven't pulled them before. I'm thinking take that shot first and see if that's realistic or not and maybe re-agendize this issue for our next council meeting after we have that information. Just a thought. Colin.
1:38:00 I think what's important to consider is how comprehensive you would like this to be. I mean, I think if we want it to be really a comprehensive look at code compliance in the full sense of the position, that's a totally separate issue. Then, you know, a lot of this is really focused on signs and outdoor sales and those kind of things because as a Planning and Economic Development Commission, that's where we really see the nexus there is how that relates to economic development of this community. So I think...
1:38:28 You know, if we want to have people looking at public safety and those kind of things, that's a totally different animal than if we just wanted to have a temp, say, from Sierra employment come in to just clean up the look of the town. Anecdotally, I did just get back from Telluride and Crested Butte. They were both dead at the same time of the year as us. Not one banner, not one sale sign, not one tent anywhere. So, you know, I think...
1:38:54 That is an expectation that a lot of our destination clients have is that, you know, they're not going to come to a cluttered community. So I forgot to mention that before. But I think you really just have to think about the scope of what we're looking to do here because I think it can be separated or it can be thought of as one comprehensive compliance effort.
1:39:16 I've got a couple of comments. First of all, I really admire the enthusiasm of both Colin and Elizabeth. Oh, there you are. Because, you know, there's this assumption that's sort of made that if you just send out letters, everybody's just going to be so happy to comply. You know, I've got to tell you, some of those people are my clients, and I know them. And you're going to, in some instances, have to push.
1:39:46 Real hard. And that is just the nature of that compliance business. My sense from what I'm hearing is, one, it needs to be full-time. Two, I don't know whether you're going to be able to get somebody from an agency. Three, we go forward with the classification and compensation study when we're ready to do that, and it could very well be that if we don't happen to like that salary, or if you don't think it's right, or the salary and benefits, that we change that.
1:40:16 To the extent that we can. I don't know whether it's the right number, whether it's too high or too low. But I think most of all, if we're going to say that there is teeth in our ordinances, then we have to show it. I mean, we have to show it by hiring somebody.
1:40:38 You know, I've raised all the issues, as did others, but in the end, it just seems to me that this is something where a statement needs to be made, and to the extent that we can do it for two years, I think it's probably better than one year, because I think there's probably two years' worth of work. Compliance, if somebody wants to resist, it doesn't happen by December 1. I mean, we'd love to see it, and I would like to see 75% compliance, and we're only dealing with only 25%.
1:41:09 I don't know. I guess I'm persuaded by what we hear to adopt Option 1. Other comments? I'd just like to add, if we end up going that direction with Option 1, I would like to take Mr. Cage's comments and add that whatever letters we end up generating and whatever ordinances we address, we consult our legal counsel. And much like I saw when we did the TOT compliance efforts, I'd like to
1:41:42 Find out if there aren't some other ordinance we can implement that can add some more teeth to this. Only because, I hate to use the term, but sometimes you've got to put heads on stakes in order to get people's attention. To Elizabeth, that's over time. It's heads in beds. So do we need to commit to the 182.311, or can that be...
1:42:12 To be discussed, or? Still discuss it. We can discuss whatever you'd like to. There's not a motion yet, and even if there is, we can still discuss it. I'm just concerned with the delay in the PW and the CED and more on how it works, by the way. If you end up hiring and filling one of those positions before
1:42:42 February 1st, I think all it would mean is that instead of having 24 months, you might have 22 months of funding for this position. So, you know, you can adjust it after you make those hiring decisions. And realistically, by the time we, what's the word, solicit people for that position, interview, background check, and they leave whatever job they're in currently, February 1st is probably an optimistic time frame that they would be on board.
1:43:11 February 1st doesn't scare me. I'm just suggesting you don't need to delay a decision until February 1st. If by chance you can get somebody on board before then. Yeah. Well, I think the concern was if we hire somebody for two years and we do bring them on board earlier, then we don't have the funding for all of it. Okay. And frankly, I don't know whether to be concerned about that, but I think it's important that the council understand that that's an assumption that's being made in order to generate...
1:43:40 The money for that one, for this new one. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to go ahead and move that the Council adopt option number one, direct staff to proceed with funding for a temporary interim code compliance position while recruiting for a permanent two-year code compliance position. I'll second. Okay. A motion and a second. Any other comments or discussion? If none, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:44:10 Mayor Witt? Yes, motion passes 4-0. Takes us to number 9. I just wanted to know for the record there was Councilmember Lehman that said, says, on sticks. Who's head? I stole that term. I won't say it from who. I think there's some constituents out there that would have some heads on sticks.
1:44:37 All right. So we'll go to number nine, which is Mammoth Lakes Tourism Year-End Review. John Urdi. You've heard that term, John? Yeah. Did you get this working? Yeah. Good update, though.
1:45:33 Good evening. I never thought that my presentation would be shorter than the compliance conversation. Thank you again. John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. This is our annual year-end wrap-up. Just to give everybody an idea, this will cover the time period from July of 2011, no, July of 2012 to June of 2013, the fiscal year.
1:46:01 What I did was first off here, I broke down the year into a couple of different segments, this being the summer segment, which I considered July through October, just to show the growth of TOT. And I think, you know, last year was our second record summer in a row, so 2011 was a record, 2012 was a record as well. And so if you look down the line there, July, August, September, and October all broke records.
1:46:30 And as a cumulative group, it was up pretty substantially year over year, 15%, and 56% to the six-year average. So it just shows you that the shift in summer business is definitely something that's taking hold now. Again, just a graph to show you the growth. So the six-year average is the far right, and then the gray bar on the far left is the 2012 number. So you can see that we've seen even just 10 to 11 to 12. Those three years, the 11 and 12 are records.
1:46:59 And the six-year average was fairly low, actually. Going into last winter, we had a little bit of a slow start because we had the hangover from the poor winter the year before. So November was actually down 6.5% in TOT year over year, but it was still stronger than the six-year average by almost 14%. So even though it didn't start off as strong as we had hoped because people weren't booking, and actually a lot of the reason we were down in the revenue
1:47:28 It was because a lot of the lodging properties were concerned that people weren't going to book, so we ended up seeing a lot of lowered rates, and people booked, but we made less money on less people. So the good news is that we were very, very fortunate to get that snowfall in December and keep cold temperatures throughout the year. So starting in December, December, January, and February ended up being our second best for each of those months in the history of the town from a TOT standpoint.
1:47:53 So we definitely had momentum from the snow that we had in December. That carried us nicely through at least February. As you can see at the bottom, the comparison to the previous year, up 32%, that's exciting and all fine and good, but the year before was absolutely tragic and terrible and horrible. And so what I've done is I've compared last year to fiscal 2010 because that was the big snow year.
1:48:18 So we were only 2.4% off of that big snow year for those months, which is pretty fantastic as far as our TOT collection. And again, on the six-year average, it's up almost 10%. John, can I ask you, why are you using a six-year, why that average? It's the information that I had on the grids. I just went back as far as six years, and typically I just like to try and, I typically use a five-year. I had six to work with, so I kept the six in there. So again, the growth over the years,
1:48:48 You can see the bad snow year is that orange bar, and 2010 was just slightly higher. Going back into the spring COT, we liked two years ago when we came out of a poor winter. We hit stride trying to make sure that the early summer, late spring was as productive as possible. As you can see, March was not super strong, but it was actually our third best March in history as well. April, we tanked. That was really where the momentum stopped.
1:49:19 You know, most people think of April as spring skiing. We had it, but I think that the fact that we hadn't had the snow over the months of January, February, and March really hurt us there. But looking into May of 2003 this year, it was a record. You know, we were up 22% year over year in May and almost 20% in the six-year average as well for that month. The biggest one that I've been impressed with is June. So in June of 2010, we were doing something along the lines of $311,000.
1:49:48 In 2011, we saw that spike by about 18%. I told my team if we could keep that flat for 2012 would be happy. And we set another record for that up 14%. And not to read ahead in the book, but this past June was up again another 18%. So 2010, the June TOT was actually about 311,000. This past year it was up over 600,000.
1:50:15 Massive increase for that month. So we talked earlier, or you mentioned earlier about the book ending of the events, really picking up the June numbers, really picking up the September numbers. I anticipate both of those will be strong. And I think that that June number will continue to rise. So I think that's really the big piece that we get to look at there. So spring and early summer, which closes out the year, has been very strong. Again, you can look at just where we were even two years ago. No, that's not right.
1:50:46 Some reason that didn't calculate right, but that orange bar should be up higher as well to show the growth there. So finally here is just the year-over-year comparison. So when we compare 2012 and 2013 to the fiscal year of 2011-12, which was the poor winter, it's all fine and good to say, yay, we're up $1.8 million in TOT, up 18%, but that was over really probably the worst year in the town's history. The real comparison that I look at here is the
1:51:14 2012 versus 2010, which was the big snow year. You know, that was really the benchmark. And the difference was almost $500,000 over that year. And then very, very sizable growth in the last six years as well. Excuse me, John. I just wanted to – it's easy to go through the numbers you've been through, but I think there's an opportunity to emphasize a couple things there. First of all, the –
1:51:46 The winter of 2012, December 2011, January, February, so the three months of the heart of the winter, all three of those in a drought year, in a drought year, were the second best TOT revenue generation for those three months. And then you followed that up with a summer, four months in the summer, July into October,
1:52:16 That were the best ever, summer months, and then this summer, you haven't gone past June, but you've got May and June this summer that were a record above the previous year's record, and these are numbers that happened in either a drought year or in the second year of a drought. In a recession. In a recession. In a recession. Yeah. Three years running, too. We've got three-year records in three years. Yeah, huge, huge numbers, and so thank you.
1:52:45 So that, so you bring up a good point. So that June through October time frame, the last two years have been records. This year was pacing towards that. It's going to be interesting to see what happens with the end of July and into August when we had the Aspen fire, and just really to see what happens there, as well as getting into August and even September with some of the motor coaches that we lost because of the tire of a pass closure. So I think we're going to have some anomalies, but I do think that even the one thing that we have seen this year, which is great, is that
1:53:12 Not only is occupancy up, but average daily rate is up. So you have more people spending more money, which gives you a bigger total revenue. So that could be a saving grace there where we may be flat, we may be down slightly, but because we had higher occupancy and higher ADR at the average daily rate for a room night, that we're going to finish out strong as well. So I've still got my fingers crossed for this year to be a third record in a row across the board. And FYI, when I was in Lake Tahoe, they experienced the same thing as we did.
1:53:41 from also from the Tahoe Fire and the Rim Fire and they were saying that they were affected but with the smoke for three weeks during the heart of their tourist season and that people were because they already had reservations would come but instead of staying the full seven days for seven nights they might only stay for a couple
1:54:02 And then left because of the smoke. So we weren't the only ones affected. We saw some of that here, but I think that we were able to, especially with the Rim Fire, when it was really starting to affect different events that were coming up on the weekends, we were making sure that we were showing the photographs of how crystal clear we were going into Labor Day weekend. We were crystal, crystal clear. Of course, waking up on Saturday morning of Labor Day weekend, I was kind of annoyed because we had all these great pictures out there and I woke up and said, uh-oh.
1:54:27 But it lasted for one day, and then we had a day the following Sunday that was a little bit of smoke as well. But I think we convinced at least the folks that may have even been going to Tahoe to come here. So if you look at our weekly occupancy numbers, even during those times, we were still up. So I think that it's going to be very interesting to see where that comes from. Just talking a little bit about the TOT compliance efforts, we've been very involved with that. I think that when you look at the growth of this past fiscal year,
1:54:55 We had a budget of $500,000 for the TOT compliance effort. If you look at the comparison between this past fiscal year and the 2010-11 big snow year, we were up $494,000. So basically the TOT compliance efforts are really what kept us from being even flat about two years ago. We did end up at $551,000 for the fiscal year.
1:55:18 Almost 740,000 for the life of the TOT compliance efforts so far. So, you know, this has been a big thing. I think the idea of heads on stakes really has got a lot of people. If you look at the 150 new transient occupancy licenses, there are a lot of people that complied because they didn't want to be part of the statistics that we have on the board here. So those people are in the system now, and they're going to be paying TOT moving forward, and it's a fantastic thing to see that. I know a lot of people have said, well, the compliance efforts aren't going to continue to grow.
1:55:47 I think they will continue to grow, but on the flip side, these 150 licenses may account for $500,000 a year moving forward, so they've definitely done what they were supposed to do. Additional revenues, we've really been tasked with trying to bring as much money in from the outside as we can, not just the DOT and the business license tax. The last fiscal year, we did still get our air subsidy from the county at $85,000. Our advertising sales in the visitor guide, when I got here, I think the sales were about $36,000. Last year, we did $74,000.
1:56:18 Again, reading ahead a little bit more, we did $85,000 this year. Our website sales have gone up. We make money off of brochure distribution as well throughout town. Our retail sales, which I'll talk about a little bit later, we had anticipated doing about $5,000 worth of official logo wear, and we did more than $15,000 for the fiscal year. We've got it in almost every shop in town. We've got a welcome center. We sell it direct through our website, and that's been a great thing.
1:56:46 Also, renting space to other not-for-profits, the U.S. Forest Service, their inventory management group, works out of our office there, as well as the Chamber of Commerce. With the Chamber being integrated into Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we'll lose the whopping $150 a month rent that we were charging them, but we'll get by. On the air service side, last year we saw upwards of 30,000 enflamements, almost
1:57:15 We have 10,547 of those came during the spring, summer, and fall. So with one flight, we were able to track that many folks in through here. And the economic impact of the flyers that came in was really about $6 million. It was $5.8 million in direct spending in the community. So that's lodging, restaurants, retail, the whole nine yards, which also could amount to about $315,000 contributed to TOT. Load factors were both up.
1:57:42 For summer and for winter. Summer was up fairly sizably, almost at 10%, and winter was up almost 8%. The last button there is that we were talking about developing a new strategy for air service funding, a thing called a TBID, and that took about eight months out of last fiscal year or more to put in place, and that came into this fiscal year. Research.
1:58:09 Last year when we were looking at the numbers, we ran a study with Leisure Trends, which is a company out of Colorado. They're out of Boulder, Colorado, and they ran an ROI report. So a return on investment report basically showing for every dollar that we took in from TOT and business license tax what we were able to return to the town. Again, that was $136.16 in direct spending. So again, that's people eating at Gomez and staying at the West End and going other places.
1:58:39 And the more important part is for every dollar that we took in from the town via TOT or business license tax returned $4.02 to the taxes to the town. So again, TOT and sales tax. We run quarterly reports with American Express. It's called Business Insights. I forward those to you with the monthly reports when we get those on a quarterly basis. And really what it does is it shows domestic spending from American Express cardholders. This isn't a survey. This is exactly what they spent.
1:59:09 It tells you how much of it was spent on a business trip, how much of it was spent on a leisure trip. It shows you all the comparison year over year, month over month, quarter over quarter, by business segment. So you can see which places are growing and which aren't. You can also see where your people are coming from. So this is a very valuable tool for us. Each quarter it's in the, I think we're typically seeing about $10 million worth of the spending coming through American Express. So it's interesting to see where that goes. Visa View is a new program that we started last year.
1:59:39 And because American Express is not as strongly used internationally, Visa came up with a program that tracks international spending, so we discontinued American Express on the international side, and we went with Visa on the international side and said. We're also running that ROI report again as we speak so that we can have that. Unfortunately, our Leisure Trend guys got a little flooded out in Boulder this week, so they're going to be a little bit fine.
2:00:04 Are you using the same company? Yeah, we're using the same company this year to get the apples and apples comparison so that they're asking the same questions to the same people. Moving forward with our new agency, Marion Carson, we may adjust that and use some different metrics with them. But at least we want to have a comparison to the same information. They did a great job on the last one. I was able to share some of that information with people. And there was just some shocking statistics in there, I think, for people just by how much, just for example, how many people come.
2:00:33 Through here, as a result of Yosemite versus skiing was, I mean, it was like double, triple. It was a big number, whatever it was. It was a huge number. I didn't know it was that big. Yeah, and even the visitation standpoint, even though the revenues are much lower by the spend in the summertime. But, you know, we're working on that as well, and I think Tim Flynn brought that up, or someone brought that up, or Colin brought that up about the fact that we need to make sure that we keep increasing the value that people are getting here.
2:01:03 From a marketing standpoint, we'll just cover a couple of the promotions and different programs that we're working on. Joint promotions that we've done in market, these are things that really don't cost us anything. The Counter, which is a gourmet burger restaurant all over California, we did a program with them basically to enter to win a trip to Mammoth Lakes. They had collateral all over their restaurants.
2:01:25 They included us in all their social media. Same with all these other partners on here. So Visit California is a huge one. We team up with them quite a bit, down to Sports Chalet, working with Extreme Pizza, which is another statewide chain that we worked with, and then Adventure 60 in Sports to really tie in and get folks aware of what we have to offer up here, mainly summer-focused, but some of them were winter-focused as well.
2:01:51 Consumer shows, we still maintain a lot of consumer shows within the state of California. We don't really branch out too, too far outside of that. But we do partner with the Yosemite Gateways. So we are obviously the eastern gateway. And there's a gateway partnership that we team up with them for a lot of the travel shows for exactly what you were saying, Matthew, is we want to ride the coattails at one of the most visited parks in the country. And we want to make sure people know that we're just out the eastern entrance.
2:02:18 The Federal Fishing Shows in Long Beach and San Diego, we've been a major partner with them for the last three years now, again, really focusing on the fishing side as well as the International Sportsman's Expo up in Sacramento, which was a great piece. We teamed up with the NBC affiliate up there and really, really drove traffic into the show for what we were doing. The Eastern Sierra Fishing Coalition is, again, something that is now in its, I guess it's its third year, really focused on getting folks to come back up to the Eastern Sierra and our dominance, regain our dominance in the fishing world.
2:02:48 We did start with just Mono County. This year we added Inyo County. So we've really partnered up with them as well to make sure that we're selling the entire Eastern Sierra experience. The poster on the right-hand side is a promotion we did this year called the Trout Law Roundup. We planted five-plus pound Alpers trouts in all of our lakes as well as...
2:03:10 Throughout the county, they were planted, and they all had tags on them. So the tags were related to prizes you could win if you caught these fish. So not only you catch a five-plus pound trout, but you also get airline tickets or logo sweatshirts or stays at hotels or restaurant gift certificates, etc. So there are a few of them still left up in, I think Lake Mary has a few left in it. The rest of them have pretty much been captured. I think there's one still in Silver Lake, and I talked to Andrew Jones over there the other day, and it's becoming mythical.
2:03:38 So it's great. So they've got the one fish that hasn't been caught. So everybody comes in and asks if, you know. Walter. Yeah, Walter, whoever he is, has been caught. So last year we were able to supplement stocking $10,000 from the boat raffle that we did and then also work with the county to add another $20,000 in stocking. The county will be stocking fish this week in the lakes in Mammoth, really with the intent that it'll help our fall business but also be a good opportunity to winter over some fish.
2:04:06 We've got a lot of good opportunities there. Trout Law Roundup got a ton of PR. I was actually out fishing with the editor of Western Outdoors News just yesterday, and he thought it was the greatest thing. They put it on the cover of their newspaper twice, which is great. When you have a 14-year-old kid in a float tube holding a six-pound trout on the cover of a magazine, it really gets people fired up to come back up here. So a lot of this is just the collaboration that we do throughout the county.
2:04:31 Our visitor guides, we were able to expand 16 pages to fulfill information that we felt we didn't have in the visitor guide before. You know, this really needs to be the one-stop resource for people when they're coming here. So the visitor guide is up to 16 pages. We're able to do that because we are selling more ad space in it. So with the additional money, we can add additional pages and really make sure that that has everything that everybody needs. The pad maps, which we have in all the hotels around town and gas stations and anywhere else that they'd like to have them.
2:04:59 We did add some marketing to those, so we've got a push for events, air, and then our website on the bottom of those, so it really is just another advertising opportunity to get the word out. Industry collaboration. Whitney is the chair of the Yosemite 150th Anniversary Committee. So this is pretty impressive. So next year is the 150th anniversary of Yosemite. Whitney stepped up and took the lead on the marketing piece.
2:05:26 And so she runs a committee there that has been very impressive. So next year with the big 150th anniversary, we're making sure that we're tied into that as much as we possibly can by being involved. On the interactive marketing side, we launched a new app this past December. And if you don't have it, it's the Visit Mammoth app. You can get it in the Android store or the Apple iTunes store. It's free. If you were to bring it up right now and you were looking for a restaurant, it will tell you exactly how far you are from...
2:05:57 You're .24 miles from Grumpy's, and it'll give you directions if you need them. It'll bring you to their website if you want to go there. We have also added, it's not in the picture here, but down at the bottom there is a bar for the mammothtrails.org website. So if you can click on it right there, it'll take you to the mobile site for the Mammoth Trails site, and it'll bring you to trailheads. If you want to go to Duck Pass, it'll tell you how to get to the trailhead. It'll show you the elevation gain, the whole nine yards. So that's another huge piece that we added there.
2:06:24 We added an itinerary builder this year so people can go in and plan their vacation so if they're going to be here for a week and they can spell it out for them. And then also just really packaging on the website has been very good. Vacation Roost, which is our online booking engine, we booked almost $350,000 worth of lodging through our website last year and that continues to grow. There you go. We've got $344,719 worth of lodging on the Vacation Roost site.
2:06:54 Our Facebook audience has grown up to over 25,000. As of today, it's about 27,500 people. One of the biggest things that I think Christy did with her programs this year was we developed this past winter a video series, and it was a combination of live recorded spots on snow reports on a weekly basis, really to talk about what events were coming up, what the weather was looking like, but also just hiring Colin Farrell in town here to shoot some...
2:07:21 High-energy video content that we could put onto our Visit Mammoth YouTube channel and got a tremendous amount of visitation through that as well as pickups from our friends at Visit California and other places that can help get our content out there. So our click-through rate on pay-per-click campaigns was a fairly astonishing 35.7%. That's a huge number. And our display advertising impressions, we're very picky about where we go.
2:07:50 Where we put our display advertising because display is not always the best return, but with Visit California, TripAdvisor, we do a lot with CBS Radio with their stations and it returns a fair amount to us. So retargeting banners on Facebook ads and really being able to target the folks that we want to get in front of. If somebody's looking for Heavenly, we want to make sure that they see us. Domestic sales efforts, we've got a lot of, again, collaboration. So Visit California, Visit California has over a $50 million budget.
2:08:19 We ride that coattail as much as we can. We want to make sure that when they need something, we're the first ones to raise our hand and get it to them because then they call us when they need it because they know that we can return it. High Sierra Visitors Council, which is more of our regional wing, so that's from the west side of Yosemite up to Tahoe and down to us. That's a regional group. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, we work very closely with them. A lot of what we do with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area is make sure that we're not duplicating efforts.
2:08:43 We don't want to be spending money on an advertisement or a campaign here if Mammoth Mountain is doing the same thing because all we're going to do is compete for the voice. We work very closely with Mono County, partnering up with shows and marketing, and then, like I said, this year we just started working with Inyo County, mainly on the fishing side of things. Domestic travel trade shows, Ski Tops is a huge one, Mammoth Travel Symposium, those are really two shows that we're seeing a lot more response from. Those are really the winter-related shows. And then on the internet,
2:09:15 On the national side, we've expanded our marketing, and a lot of this has to do with the proximity to Yosemite National Park, but also our proximity to Las Vegas, San Francisco, and to Los Angeles. So we have representation in a lot of those markets up there. Some of them we're just starting to, in fact, we're just signing on representation in Germany this week, and that's a major focus for really summer and fall.
2:09:41 But the agency really feels that we have an opportunity to get some German skiing as well, which is very difficult when you get the Alps as your competition. So key shows that we attend on the international side, Pow Wow is one of the largest events in the world, and that's an industry show. It's been very fortunate. It was in San Francisco.
2:10:03 Los Angeles and Las Vegas the last three years, so it's been right in our backyard. Next year it moves back to Orlando, so it's not necessarily in our backyard where we can invite people over to play with us, but it's still a great opportunity. And again, a lot of the sales missions that Michael Vanderhurst attends on that sheet as well. Again, we talked about the visitor guide being up to $74,000 last fiscal year, and again this year I think we're about $85,000 or $86,000. The retail gear...
2:10:34 Again, we budgeted $5,000 for this first year, and we did well over $15,000. So it was nice, and it's great to see people wearing our gear or even the sticker on the back of their car. From a PR and communication standpoint, our agency helped us place 70 placements out there with 96.5 million media impressions. The majority of those, as you can see from the pie chart, are feature articles. So it's something about hiking in Mammoth Lakes or fishing in Mammoth Lakes or skiing in Mammoth Lakes.
2:11:01 A perfect example of this is last year we had the Outdoor Writers Association here. David Roberts, who was the keynote speaker for that group, he's a very, very well-known writer and very, very well-known climber. And last year at the event, we invited him back to come back and climb because he hadn't climbed this area. David was here in, I think he was here right around the Rimfire. And I think he may have missed some of the smoke, but he came in and immediately...
2:11:30 Once he left, we had three big placements, including National Geographic Explorer. So he's a great asset. He doesn't typically go back to a location two years in a row, but he wants to come back here again. So if he keeps writing articles and gets them published, we'll take them. These are just some of the impressions that we had out there and some of the big articles. You know, top five fall hikes and sunset. Those are things that are really just important things for us. You know, the fall colors right now, that's a big focus for us. Last year we had a number of hits.
2:12:00 Again, it goes back to John Poimer who runs California Colors site and disseminates a lot of information. And our big push this year is to make sure that we send him the best pictures so he has to use ours instead of somebody else's. And it's working so far. Again, just a few more media highlights just to show you where we've been. A lot of Mammoth Track Club focus. In fact, I've got a writer in Sunday, Monday from the U.K. who's interested in our high altitude training.
2:12:29 He also wants to catch Sunday Night Football with me, so go watch a game with him. And then staff participation, I think this is important for people to know really what we're out there doing. With U.S. Travel Association, the National Tourism Association for the country, I'm on the annual meeting conference board as well as a moderator and a speaker at those events. The event that I did this year was entitled, If You're Not at the Table, You're on the Menu, and it was about having your budgets cut and alternative funding. That was fun.
2:13:00 National Destinations Council, again, I'm a board member there. That's fantastic. I'm on the board with people like the CBB from Chicago, Las Vegas, some great destinations around the country. And then most recently joined the California Travel Association and a number of local pieces. The one that I don't have on here for Whitney, so she just, it says she's a Visit California Welcome Center representative. Whitney is now co-chair of the California Welcome Centers for the state of California.
2:13:29 And that just happened last week. So that's a great honor to have her there, as well as being on the steering committee for the Yosemite 150th anniversary. Landerhurst represents us on the Mono County Tourism and Film Commission, as well as High Sierra Visitors Council. And then Christy Osborne runs all of our marketing and educational series. So a great team in place. With the TBID, we are looking to add a dedicated PR coordinator because we just want to really get that third-party endorsement again.
2:13:56 It really means a lot more when someone like David Roberts comes and writes about climbing versus us telling people it's great. So the more we can bring on in that earned media, the better off we can be. And that's the year. Good year. It's been a good year. And this one's starting off pretty well, too. John, quick question on air service. When are we going to know what the flights are going to be for this winter? They're on our website. They are on the website. They are. There's two from San Francisco, two from Los Angeles, Orange County.
2:14:30 And then San Diego. We did change San Diego this year. It was United Airlines. We changed to Alaska. Right off the bat, that saved us about 30% just because of the operating cost. So it saves us 30% and gives us 10 more seats in the market because of the plane size. So that was a good move. So Las Vegas? No, we didn't have Las Vegas because in working with Alaska Airlines, they moved all their equipment out of there, and it just seemed at the time that it was cost prohibitive for them to really run that. But I don't think it's a dead conversation. Okay. We are going to meet with United.
2:15:00 November 14th in Chicago to talk about the next year. So we're starting to really get as far ahead of the game as we possibly can. So six flights a day in the winter? Six flights a day, yep. Okay. Are any of those flights certain days or are they all seven days a week? Orange County is a four-day-a-week flight. Four-day? Yep. San Diego? San Diego, seven days a week. Okay. Yep.
2:15:22 And San Diego will likely, once we launch the 6 and 10 packs that we did last winter, that will include not only the Los Angeles flights, it will include both of the Los Angeles and San Diego for Alaska Airlines, so that's going to be a great package for people. And they're putting a lot of effort. Alaska Airlines now has 71 flights a week.
2:15:41 We've got a great team. Thank you. All right.
2:16:10 All right, with that, and especially on that up note, we'll adjourn to our next regular meeting to be held on October. Actually, no, we're going back in closed session, so we're not ready to adjourn, but when we do, we will adjourn to October 2nd.