Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 3 hr 8 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
382 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
8:25 of the town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission to order roll call, please. Pat Agnich? Here. Sean Turner? I'm present. Elizabeth Truax? Here. Vice Chair Terry Stehlik? Yes. And Chairman Bill Sauser? Yes. Public comments. This is the time any member of the public wishing to comment on something that doesn't otherwise appear on the agenda. Good afternoon. John Wentworth, MLTPA. One thing from the MLTSCC meeting I wanted to talk to address, but kind of
8:57 Missed it. The standards manual for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. I think we delivered this about a year ago. It's been incorporated in the Public Works document. The Public Works is building things, signs going up, maps being built. This was supposed, I thought it was going to be in front of you guys on its way to Council in August. And I'm just wondering from the commission or staff if they can maybe give an update as when we can expect to see that. The second thing is if there's any update or confirmation on the MLR process.
9:25 If that's, I've thought maybe that was going to be going to council next week, but haven't heard anything, so if there's any information on that, it'd be appreciated. Thank you. To my knowledge, the MLR is going to council on the, what is it, the 18th? 16th. 16th, okay. The next meeting. And as far as the standards manual, I don't know. Standards manual, I believe we're reformatting it to make it similar or the same as our other standards, and so that...
9:58 is in the works to be adopted this year by Council. Okay. Sandy Hogan, speaking as a member of the public. And I think last week at the Council, I made some comments about process problems and the fact that a lot of our public has not been, you know, they've been kind of unhappy about some of the things going on and expressing the fact that perhaps we're not following our processes the way we should.
10:29 And some of my comments had to do with the fact that it seemed like sometimes, especially with the closed sessions, I think everybody's familiar with the fact that nobody's happy about that. And he commented about the fact of the Sam's Wood Project, that I was a supporter of it, but, you know, that we had a process to go through, just as Sean said, hey, there's a time for proposals and discussions and going through commissions, whatever. And in thinking about that, and then this weekend,
10:58 I was kind of thinking about some of that also, the processes, and I thought, you know, one of the ones that I did like actually was the events study. We're putting a lot of Measure R dollars in that. And that events study really came as an interim report, and I mean, I thought there was a lot of good discussion on it. I know I commented. I know that we commented in the Measure U Committee as well. A lot of good discussions. In other words, in both cases, you had your commission involved.
11:28 You had the Measure U Committee involved. And then I had the same question actually that John just brought up, the MLR, the Mammoth Lakes Recreation. What's happening there? And I realize there has been no commission discussion of it. And it really has the potential to affect commissions and the Measure U Committee. And yet there's been no talk about it here.
11:58 But it's going to council next week. And I kind of went back. As a member of the public, I was one of the many people that sat in the back. The public was not really invited. It was a meeting that was open to the public. But we had to sit there for three hours until we were allowed a few minutes to comment at the end, which is not public involvement. And a number of the public left. There were members that just left.
12:27 And so I really think before it goes to the council, my suggestion would be it comes back here so that you have a full and open discussion. It's Mammoth Lakes Recreation, for goodness. I don't care that it's a town council priority. That's been the problem. The town council jumping over or making decisions without input from its commission, from members of the public. And so that's kind of where...
12:52 I'm thinking then I started looking actually at the little bit of information we did have because, you know, I mean, I'm sure those of you that were on that committee, and all of you were, I believe, but Sean, I don't think you were able to attend. So he would probably benefit from a good open discussion too and hearing from a lot of folks. It was interesting because one of the very major, it was three sessions, the major, one of the major questions was never even answered. What would MLR do?
13:21 What would be their role in facilitating recreation in the community, and how would it exist in complementing the existing town recreation department? That was never answered. And that was, you know, I mean, that's part of the contract. This is measure our dollars we're spending. The more money we spend on these studies, let's get them at least right, as you did, I think, with the facilities, the event study. In other words, that was interim, gave them a lot of hard, you know, input.
13:49 said, go back and do your job and then come back to us. I think the same thing ought to happen here. And so my recommendation would be that, you know, maybe staff should talk to the town manager about this, whatever, but I know if it goes next week, that will certainly be my comments because I think you really want to involve the public a lot more than you did there. It wasn't fun sitting back there watching people post us up.
14:16 I mean, you know, that's not public input. RecStrats was good. We all got to put little stickies up. You know, that's fun. But this was not. So anyway, those are my comments. And just that the job was not done. I don't want to see public dollars spent on something that's really only half completed or not even well completed. Any comments, questions?
14:40 Well, I guess I would answer that just by saying that it's not completed yet. It's not that, you know, my understanding of the consensus that came out of the MLR meetings was that, you know, it's not really an all or nothing thing. You know, we're happy with a lot of things or unhappy with some other things and we're kind of going to find a middle ground and that that is the next phase of the process.
15:02 So it's not done and over with. It's just moving forward with a smaller group of people to kind of form some of the nuts and bolts, and it'll still be public meetings. But a smaller group, and is there any opportunity for public input, do you think, other than five minutes at the end of a three-hour session? I mean, those are the kind of things I think need really discussion. No, and I definitely hear what you're saying on that.
15:26 Okay, and I really do believe it should come back to the commissions. I mean, if you don't use your commissions, the council is not functioning properly if they're not delegating and trusting its commissions and its citizens. And, you know, all five commissioners were invited to these meetings, and I think all of us but Sean were able to attend those meetings. And, you know, there were also, I think, about 33 people on that group that was...
15:51 Put together that were a lot of different user groups and so to get a lot of different input and then your information, the folks that chose to come and stay and put input was taken into consideration and I believe there was opportunity to also send in emails as well, comments and all of those were put together and then put back out and I believe that they've been posted so that you can see that information. So anyways, I guess I
16:22 It is put back out. If I'm confused, if I'm confused, I do feel that it was a public process. I felt it was a public process. And what the council is going to consider is whether or not they want that to continue to move forward to the next steps. It's not whether or not there's going to be an MLR yet. We aren't even to that point. It is, are we going to fund the next steps to see what it can be?
16:50 Would I have liked to have gotten that done in the last section? Yes, but it wasn't, so. Well, that's good to know because, you know, that hasn't been reported. And I was just asking Stu and he was trying to explain it to me and I thought, you know, I've been following this and I am quite concerned. So there has not been a decision to have an MLR yet? No. No. But if you do read, I read the council packet for next week. And as a commission, I do think that we were bypassed because there will be.
17:20 Some relationship that we will have if an MLR is formed, whether it's, you know, just communicative relationship or something different. And I think out of only 22 people, according to the report, showed up for the first meeting and then it dwindled even after that. And I think I stated at the very beginning of the process from this dais that to just have public comment
17:48 For a couple minutes at the conclusion of a meeting, I don't really think that that's public comment. It was a public meeting, it was open to the public, but, you know, to give people a couple minutes at the end of a meeting. And what that relationship is, you know, is part of, as Betsy said, that's part of the next step. That's one of the questions that's going to be answered in the next step. Yeah, but if you read the report, it's moving forward.
18:17 So it's not really up for discussion because, you know, they're basing it upon the steering committee which recommended that a hybrid type of an organization be explored and that's not even really addressed in the staff report that I glanced at today. So there is something in the town council agenda is out already? It was online and it's about 40 some pages.
18:44 Staff report plus attachments from RecStrats and the minutes of the steering committee meeting. Interesting. You know, I felt that the meeting was, and we'll move on from this in a minute, but was completely open. If we compare it to RecStrats, we had as many people participating, even though it was the same set of people, which only meant that they were up to speed from the meetings that hadn't previously because they were engaged through the whole process.
19:14 We really had as many people commenting in this closed group, if you want to call it, as we ever had in RecStrats. I beg to differ because I made a point of that during RecStrats, and there were approximately 90 different people commenting in RecStrats. There were many more people that attended cumulatively the meetings, but 90 some different individuals. So I think it's certainly 90 versus 22 is a larger group.
19:44 Well, before we move on, and just so I can make a statement, just that, you know, unfortunately it was during my busiest time of year, so I was not able to attend any of the MLR meetings. I do agree that it should be coming before
19:55 Commission before going to Town Council. I'm not wanting to add layers of bureaucracy. My goodness, I do not want to be doing that. But at the same time, you're right. It probably should be coming before Recreation Commission. I know that it's already on the agenda for next week. I have not had a chance to review it yet. But we'll certainly spend some more time with it. And if it does go forward, obviously, I would support it coming before Recreation Commission before it takes any further action. And again, I think the reason it didn't was because we were a part of the group.
20:23 I think that the assumption could be made that since none of us raised our hand and said we don't want to see this to go forward, as a whole, we gave it our task approval by being in the process and saying, yes, we'd like to explore some hybrid version to see what it could do.
20:42 Again, you know, I'm sorry that I wasn't able to attend any of the meetings, and I'm trusting in my fellow commissioners with regard to their respect. I think that after this next town council, if it does go forward, that, you know, I would certainly support it coming before the Recreation Commission. Well, I think you have a much more open and focused discussion right here because you guys know recreation, and just because it's a town council priority.
21:08 Or a town council person's priority. I know Mayor Wood has said he wants to make it his legacy. You know, and Mayor Pro Tem Bacon, of course, has been involved in this. Was it in 2009? I don't think, just because it's two people's priority, and the other ones may be trusting also those two, I think it needs to have full and open discussion from you guys, too, because you guys speak recreation. You know, and you know the nuts and bolts of it, and that's really important.
21:38 And I guess all I'm saying is you know that I try to follow these things. I have a very big interest in recreation. I always have, and I've always, that's why I come to the meetings. And if I'm confused about this, you think the public knows what's going on? I mean, that's my question, and it should be right here with you guys leading it. That's the time for good discussion. The council, you know, the council is for decisions and policies, but you guys work out the nuts and bolts, and that's what's missing to me in this.
22:06 So those are my comments. Anyway, thank you for the clarifications. Tony, do you want to make a quick comment? Thanks, Sandy. Okay. Thank you, Sandy. I have a problem. Any other public comment? Commissioners, Peter Bernasconi with Public Works. Just to let you know, we do have some repair work going on at the Whitmore Track. There's a little over 100 feet of track material that's being removed and replaced. Essentially, over the last year, we've been working with them and observing some...
22:37 Areas that didn't appear to be cured quite right. And so they've done some repairs and then they agreed to replace this week's section that will be done over the next week or two. Where'd you go there? How long does the warranty now? I'm somewhat dismayed and disheartened that we were having bubbling issues and non-adherence in a product that was supposed to be the superior and the catch-all.
23:07 Do we get a new warranty period starting now on the new product so that if this happens to it again we are still covered? Or the seams where they're taking out and adding in, is that going to be an issue long term? The seam construction is basically the same type of seam construction we do with asphalt with their overlap and they do a taper.
23:32 So I don't, we're not going to get another additional seven years on top of the seven years we have. But the warranty work that they're doing currently will be similar to the, if you look at, I like to think of those north, south, east, west, but the section towards crossing road, that area we didn't have the bubbling issue. Basically they had a mixing issue that we noticed when they were doing their work.
24:01 They thought that they removed it all during the construction process initially, and we came back with them and had, you know, pointed out some areas that had some problems, and then they've agreed to replace, it's about a, I think it's about a 120 foot length of section, full width removal and replacement. So, yeah, the warranty is basically within the seven year warranty that we already have, and it doesn't, we don't get another year because it had to rework this whole section.
24:31 That answers the question. I have a 15-year track. It should last 15 years. Is that a piece of it right there? Yeah, that's a piece of it right there. Okay. So I can pass it around. If you can walk up with something, we've got to check it out. And we're pretty sure that this was just a mixing issue and it's not an elevation issue or a temperature issue or a exposure. No, it's pretty clear that it's a mixing issue and they had some moisture that was trapped in the layer.
25:05 Okay. If you squeeze it enough, you can get the moisture in the form. Oh, yeah. One concern I do have is that, you know, we need to make sure that they don't start putting it down again until the moisture's dried out. That's going to happen tomorrow and Thursday. When they laid the track, was it done in sections like that? So that's why they're only doing 100 feet? I mean, is it possible it could be in other portions of the track? Essentially, they went around and they took slices.
25:34 Around the perimeter to find where the change was. They worked on basically a day. So this represented probably a day's work of that first layer, and that's where the problem is. But having a seam, is it going to be an issue with moisture in the future with freeze? It should be fully bonded.
25:54 Once it's actually done, if you get a section, you wouldn't be able to really see the differential. Because this is five layers, and you can see the differential in the layers because of the color, but if you look at it, you can't really see the seam very easily between each layer. It should look monolithic when they're done. Would there be a coloring issue as well?
26:18 I mean, because this must be somewhat fade. So initially, there will be, this is going to look brand new, and the other is sturdy, it'll be, or, you know, it's somewhat softened with the sunlight. Oh, after a year or so, it will kill something different. So with regard to the warranty right now, you know, they're obviously paying to have it. Is there going to be any expense to town? No expenses to town. None whatsoever. So you're able to bill back 100% for your time? Fully covered by the warranty work. Thank you.
26:53 Any further public comments? Consent agenda. Any comments on consent or a motion? I would like to make a comment on the minutes from the September 10th meeting. They seem to capture my comments very explicitly as opposed to some of the other comments that were, you know, dialogue between the commission and Galwani were more extensive perhaps in just
27:26 You know, a sentence or two about it. But I would like to clarify my reference to financial gain regarding the MLR. It was more directed towards the consultants because there was, you know, a contract for up to $50,000 and if phase one was approved, then they would automatically receive up to the amount of the full contract.
27:56 That was what I was referencing, although I didn't specifically state that. I think that's unfair to them, but anyways, they were doing what they were contracted to do, and I think they gave everybody the opportunity to say yay or nay to move forward. So anyways, I think that's pretty unfair to somebody that's a consulting contractor. I do stand by my comment, though, that I think that the steering committee was swayed.
28:26 towards a certain consensus. Okay, anything else on either seven minutes? So how would you like to see the change so that it reflects what you were saying? Perhaps it could just reference that. You know, it says what she stated, you know, so I don't know. She just stated if she would like that to be reflected tonight, that it's clarified, then.
29:05 But anyways, that is exactly what she said. Entertain a motion. Maybe, Pat, would you, instead of saying that people in that room, maybe it should say that the consultants? Yeah, I would feel comfortable with consultants. I think that they are professional, but I agree with Commissioner Stehlik that that was the way the contract was drawn up, and maybe that's what's at fault.
29:30 And if I can actually support on that, because I would like to agree with Pat that I sure would like to see a little bit more detail going into the minutes. And Steve, you've been great. I know you're sitting over here as clerk, and I'm not referring to you specifically, just as much as sometimes I think that it is important to include more than there was discussion amongst the committee members. And I know we've discussed that, that Jamie has been directed by town council.
29:55 to keep it somewhat just overview, and if anyone wants to go into detail, you know, they can refer to Granicus, which is what that's all about, but at the same time, you know, Granicus is difficult to access when you're trying to read minutes, so I would just like to reflect that, and I've said this before in this public forum, that I would like to see a little bit more detail going into the minutes. I was the one that asked Pat
30:18 Before the meeting, just, hey, could you clarify who you were referring to? Because I didn't know who she was referring to specifically with regard to who was, you know, such a strong statement with regard to that people in this room were benefiting financially. So that's why I asked for clarification. You know, I don't know if that you necessarily want to change it in the minutes or just that you've clarified it here in this public forum that I thank you for. As much as I just would like to echo that I'd love to see more detail in the minutes.
30:48 However, the minutes have to reflect what was actually said. Intent cannot be written into the minutes. And I don't mean to be asking for intent. And what Jamie had said previously is that the full discussion is on Granicus. If you wanted a specific statement to be read in, just as Pat did at our last meeting, that you ask it to be, that you want it to be read into the minutes, and so it'll be.
31:17 Written verbatim. You're correct. As to what you said. Yeah. Yeah. So this is. Okay. So the minutes reflect what was actually said. Yep. So if maybe this next go-round of minutes could just be maybe approved based upon my clarification. Yes. Yeah. In the next month's minutes it will say that you clarified what your statement was and you met the contractor and we can now get about approving these minutes, please. Move to approve that consent agenda.
31:50 Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? No. See, I'm messing up already. We're only on number three. Okay. Consensus done. Policy matters on number three. Provide consensus comments to District Ranger, who is not here, of the Mono Lake Ranger District on the environmental assessment for the proposed shadier SOSV-OHV staging area.
32:26 Stu, if you don't mind, I'd like to start this one off. Stu, if you don't mind, I'd like to start this one off. Yeah, I don't know if I need a staff report on it. I think it's pretty clear in there, and I've also attached the EA to the document as well. And just quickly, Chair, I did contact the district ranger. Obviously, he's unable to attend, and maybe the suggestion is to reschedule for that October 22nd date at your workshop. So anyway, that's just the Commission's consideration.
32:54 This is a tough one for me because this was brought forward and unless my memory is completely faulty, which it has been accused of being that many times by myself included, the Forest Service came to us earlier this year at MLTSCC and said this would not be coming forward. And then I got notices in my email box from several people saying that indeed the Forest Service was moving this forward before it even came back to one of their partners at the MLTSCC. So I haven't done my homework on it completely.
33:24 I've certainly read the proposals and I know what they are. I believe as a group what we should ask for since the government shutdown is occurring is an extension of the comment period equal to the closure of government so that when they are back on board and can answer our questions and then we still have time after that to formulate individual and perhaps commission comments on it. If anyone has questions on it, I'm more than happy to have a short discussion on it today.
33:52 Without the Forest Service here, I really can't see what is to be gained because there's no one here to answer the questions from their side. I would support that, Bill. And I don't know if we're, you know, this is due on October 26th. If I can just jump right in. And I don't know if we've passed nine days or I guess it's going to be ten days to get to November 4th.
34:16 which is when our next meeting is, but at the very least I would like them to extend until at least immediately after our meeting on November 4th since the Federal Government is not present today. But I think they're suggesting that, is it the November meeting or is it the December meeting that you're suggesting? Well we have a workshop on the 22nd of October which is really a Recreation Facilities Planning Workshop so there's an opportunity there. November 4th I think
34:44 Sean's referring to her as the MLTCC and the Commission's following. So ideally, and then the other option, which we mentioned yesterday as well, is to maybe have that joint workshop with the Forest Service for the MLTCC slash Recreation Commission so we're presented at the same time and can consider all those alternatives. Might be a more efficient way to go.
35:08 So depending on the chair, if there's a consensus or we can draft a motion which might be representative of the commission, we can express that in a letter to the Forest Service making that request for the time extension. Yeah, well, I think we can re-agendize this on the 22nd, as you say, because we don't know how our request is going to go. Correct. However, I would like to see us draft that letter requesting an extension in the comment period. Obviously, they aren't working on it currently either.
35:37 I would like to see an extension of that comment period to give us a chance to respond after they can respond to our questions. Because I'm sure I know I have questions. Can we do that by consensus or do you want a motion? I think a motion is probably a little bit more influential. Consensus helps. But I think it's a motion and I've just written down a motion to request an extension of the...
36:02 I can draft the language of the EA for the proposed Shady Rest OSV, OHV staging area project for an equal time to the government shutdown to allow sufficient time for the Recreation Commission to respond. I mean, that would be kind of wordsmith, but I think you get the gist of it. Or we can actually put a date to it. We could put two. 30 days from the government coming back. Isn't the initial comment period 30 days? Yeah, it was September 24th, October 26th. So, yeah, that's roughly.
36:31 So if I was going to make, I will make a motion, in fact, and I never do that from this chair, but I will. I will make a motion that we send a letter to them asking for the comment period to be extended for 30 days after the resumption of government business to give us and the general public adequate time to have their questions answered and make their comments on the OHV-OSV staging area project. We'll second that.
37:05 I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Unanimous? Do we have a from the floor that wants to speak? I should have done that prior to the vote. But if you want to... Sorry to interrupt. John Wentworth with MLTPA. Just a couple comments. The first thing is my understanding that the Forest Service had pulled back on the motorized staging areas that were out on the scenic loop and out on 395, but I did not hear that they were pulling back in the shady rest.
37:39 That just may be a confusion. Yeah, and that's the way I understood it was, you know, pulling back on all of it. Yeah, okay. I've been wrong. No, I just, that's what I heard. MLTPA is working to get Mammoth Trails user groups together to provide some comments on this effort. The last time we did this with the Upper Irland DA, the Forest Service, stopped rehabilitation efforts on 26 roads, which I think is an important thing to build upon to get to a holistic kind of a planning effort out there in Shady Rest.
38:08 We're going to be in the paranoia business. We're going to assume that the Forest Service is going to stick to the 30-day period. They've done all the work. They've produced a draft EA. They don't really have to do any work during the comment period. So we will be getting some folks together to move forward. I think you're all on MLTPA's meeting list, so you'll know when that meeting is going to occur. I'd love to have you guys come out if you want to be part of that. And I think we'll just proceed that way. I think our initial reading of this...
38:35 Is that there's no mention of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System in here anywhere. And the town has spent and invested an enormous amount of money in a comprehensive coordinated trail system, not referred to anywhere. The bigger role in the room is the ORMAT project, which is not mentioned in here as part of a coordinated solution. And I think we all want to be looking at a holistic solution to the recreation opportunities in Shady Rest. So that email will be going out while some sort of informal meeting. If you guys can make it, it would be great to see you. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Has that meeting been set?
39:05 No, it hasn't. Okay. Did you want to delve into this some, or do you just want to hold it off? I'd like to hear some thoughts on it. Okay. I went through the whole thing, so I can comment. Fine. Let's do some commenting now. Okay. Get down to business. So, you know, am I hearing this correct? So you guys are saying that the other staging areas on the scenic loop have been pulled back? They've been pulled, yes. Okay. I didn't realize that.
39:40 There's nothing publicly stated to that. Thank you. Has it? Yeah, the Forest Service just stopped moving forward. Yeah, just to follow up on the scenic loop, basically they had the two areas that were planned to be the staging areas. It really became an issue of the money had to be expended by the end of October, as I recall, and there really wasn't sufficient time to do that by the time they actually did their environmental work. So that was the reason for basically to kind of use the money on the scenic loop.
40:12 Was it the scenic loop and then there was also something near 395? Correct. There was two staging areas. One is at the intersection of 395 and the scenic loop and the other one just past the Craters Road. Does anyone have any specific comments you wanted to or questions that maybe any of us could answer for you? Well, I was just, you know, after reading all of this, I kind of just see that number four would be
40:45 Something that I would see as being preferable only because you already have parking, you already have restrooms, you already have all the things needed. I guess one of the questions, I would either look at two or four. Those would be the only two options that I even saw that were possible. But two being that, you know, there's just an awful lot that needs to go into it to make it happen. But is there the ability for trailers to park and turn around in either of those options? Do you know?
41:16 Well, certainly at the number four option, which would be the original staging area at 203, there is a plan that the Forest Service accepted from the Old Snowmobile Group that one ways it and it creates about 30 parking spaces with, did you bring the note, Steve? About four of them are 50 footers and there's about six or seven 35 footers, 20 some single car for Nordic.
41:45 Although they're allowed to park anywhere, and an additional 20-some for regular truck and snowmobile trailer parking. Okay. It was used for a long time, so there was, you know. And so to me, when I was reading through this, it almost seemed like a no-brainer than it would before, but if I had to look at another option, the only other one that seemed remotely feasible, but there's no, you know, there's an awful lot of infrastructure that needs to be done would be two.
42:13 And those would just kind of be my comments from looking at this. And then my only other concern is there's really no, nothing that's been done for summer OHV use. So that is a concern on any of these. There's none of these staging areas that are really addressing that. So that would be my concern as well. Of course, if we read through this,
42:41 The Forest Service is saying that numbers two and three are specifically to address summer OHV use. To get them out of the paved area and move them onto the dirt. So that from the Forest Service side. Some of the things, I'll get other people's comments first. I have several. Well, I concur with Terry in that looking through this, it seemed like
43:10 Option 4 was going to be the least disruptive and the most consistent with what's happening now. And I guess just my question to the Forest Service is, I know when I made my original comments, when the comment period first opened, is I did reference our trail system master plan and wondered how, you know, this would fit into that. And clearly, you know, that wasn't addressed in here. Which, of course, they don't have to. No, no, they can, yeah, they can do what they want. Absolutely.
43:40 Decided not to play with us. A couple of the inconsistencies that I saw in a couple of the plans, number four especially, they talk about, and I'm glad that John brought up ORMAT, because ORMAT is really what pushed all of this to start. They talk about not having to rehab the road from the 203 out to the well site, which is basically where their proposed staging area is.
44:08 And the fact is, if ORMAT is going to use that for heavy equipment, it has to be rehabbed regardless. It seems to me what we're asking for motorized recreation to pay for here because the proposed paying for this is coming out of green sticker dollars, is to pay for ORMAT's road. And I do have some issue with that. I believe in my original comments to the Forest Service were these two projects needed to go along
44:34 parallel paths because they are tied together at the hip and for whatever reason it's been chosen not to go down that road. But at some point that road's going to have to be rehabbed regardless. Peter, could you comment on this because it was my understanding that the town was already going to be moving forward with widening the road. We applied for a grant to reconstruct the road and widen the road. We were not selected for the grant.
45:03 Because of our use permit, it doesn't have a 30-year life currently. So we've been requesting to get use permits extended for some time, and that's the first time that particular issue has come up. But for green sticker funds, they can build facilities, but they cannot build roads. So like when we were looking at green sticker funds throughout Sherwin area, it would certainly do the parking lot, any infrastructure related to that, restrooms, all those kinds of things.
45:33 but not pay for any road infrastructure. I thought that if it required a road to get to the proposed parking area that it would pay for that. No, that's not my understanding. Okay, maybe the trailer. Other types of funds. No park funds. Yeah, other funds might. The other big thing is the OHV piece of this, and I still believe that the OHV could be
46:07 served out of the original parking area here. If you just declare that one little section of the road to be multi-use instead of limited to licensed vehicles only, there is a way to reroute that parking area so that motorized wouldn't be in the campground but go beside it. But these are questions, I don't know if there are alternatives can be tweaked at this point or not.
46:38 Or if you have to stick to exactly what's in the alternative. Without having that question answered, I couldn't even come forward. Alternative 4 has certainly been my, I've said it all along, there's room for great expansion at that site without disrupting any other ground. The bathrooms already exist, the parking already exists, and it's close to town. It creates that nexus, that area of excitement.
47:06 that you have to have, you know, to spur people on. But without knowing if any of these alternatives could or couldn't be still altered, it makes it hard for me to move forward. Any other comments from up here before I go to the public? I seem to recall them indicating that once it got to this point that they couldn't make any other suggestion. You had to deal, I think, with what is here. That's my impression as well.
47:38 Yeah. So my problem is if number two becomes the alternative, which is the only other alternative that's acceptable to me, it still doesn't preclude them from ending up with number three and just doing away with all access from motorized back to town, which, you know, was the original intent of some. Sandy. Okay. One of the things, you know, looking at it, to me, the OHV part is really pretty essential.
48:09 Parks and Rec Commissioners, if you have been out there on a weekend in the summertime with all the children playing on the fields and people hauling in their OHVs and they're encroaching out into the forest slowly but surely, I mean, we used to worry about that for a long, you know, that used to be my worry. The park is a municipal park for kids and leagues and it's nice to have separation of users when you have
48:38 Those two kinds of activities, because they really aren't compatible. You know, so I looked at the OHV part, and that's why I chose two, and I will respond to two, because I think two, and I mentioned this to Bill, I know that Bill's concerns for many years was that the Forest Service said, no, you can't use the tunnel. Well, there was a reason, because the land across from the tunnel was National Forest, and it was closed to snowmobiles.
49:03 The land across the tunnel now is no more, in other words, on the south side. That's the town. The town has a special use permit for the trail. So I think, too, preserves the option and actually helps it along now a lot more. And, too, actually really separates the OHV users and all that traffic from kids in the play fields. You know, in the summertime, go out there on a Saturday or Sunday.
49:30 When people are out riding their OHVs or getting them ready or whatever, and you'll see what I'm talking about. You know, you don't want your kids running across the car, you know, with trailers coming in and backing and all that kind of stuff, and there's not an adequate turnaround out there. It's not good. If you look at it, the proposed one does have pull-throughs. It has pull-throughs. It's got a lot of parking. It would be nice to have. It's a good area out there to go ahead and put in.
49:59 And it's nice to have staging areas. The return trail, when I originally commented in the scoping, I wasn't thrilled with the idea of using the section of the motorized trail, or the trail as motorized, because as I say, on skinny, I may be, you know, I may be a terror on downhill skis, but I'm scared to death on skinny skis, and I mean any little slope, if I saw a snowmobile coming out, I'd probably run into a tree. So mine was a safety issue, but, you know, I,
50:27 There's ways they can work with that. You can't change the alternatives too much because all the studies you see, if you see the studies that are referenced, they're pretty, you can tweak them, but you can't really change it a lot probably. So, but you can propose in letters. I plan to propose that, you know, if there's going to be a shared use, put up some signs so people like me maybe can go off on the side and that little area will just avoid the motorized area or something like that or it can be groomed.
50:55 And I think you had some proposals also, Bill, as far as the snow plowing of the road, plow only half, and it could be used. You know, I mean, those are things that can be incorporated in a decision without changing the big alternatives. But I do think, you know, to me, I was looking at that. I remember, well, I know what it looks like out there on a weekend. You know, you want to try to separate those uses when you can. And this is a good opportunity. So anyway, those are just.
51:25 Can I ask some questions? And I need to spend more time with this. But my understanding is that this is for winter only, not summer? No, both. Winter and summer. Winter and summer. Okay. All right. Thank you. And the two locations that are being proposed here, I mean, obviously, number four is that everything is going to be out there at Shady Rest. No. No. No. No. No. Number four puts it at the new Shady Rest campground. Okay. At the campground. The parking lot right there at 203 and Sawmill Road. Okay.
51:55 And in the winter that makes sense. Prior to 2009. Okay. And in the winter that makes sense. Number two then? Yes. Sorry, can I ask you to clarify exactly where number two is going to be then? Number two is one mile out the Sawmill Road from 203. On the left-hand side, approximately, there's a well head development going on in a very near proximity at this point. Right, okay. So you can see that as you drive out. On the left as you're driving out about one mile out. Yep, I know where that's at. Okay. Yeah.
52:26 Which is one of my concerns. Who pays for the plowing? How often does it get plowed? And how much does that affect winter recreation happening out there? Okay, and you're right. Valid questions that we can't get answered today. With regard to what, Sandy, you're talking about, though, are you referring to the area there for the shady rest?
52:51 Where people are actually pulling into, you know, around the soccer fields, the baseball, the park, yep, the park. They would not be with, just to clarify, with number two, alternative number two, they would not be going through that parking lot, would they? No. That's the nice thing about it. Okay. They would be in the new parking lot, they would be created a mile out. New staging area. Thank you. And then the key is for the snowmobilers.
53:17 Two and four are very similar in that there's a return trail for any snowmobilers who might want to come back in town and park exactly in the old shady rest parking lot. Right. So that would still be accessible. They could lock it up, go across the street to McDonald's, carry a gas can across whatever, things like that. And potentially in the future if that expansion, if the town were to propose, I think the town would have to propose, you know.
53:44 Adding winter motorized use to their special use permit, but that's, that I don't think would be a big deal. Not anymore anyway. Just like they come in. In what section are you talking about that would need to be a special use permit for OHV if it was in a number four area? Well, currently on a level three road, green stickered vehicles, which would be your dirt bikes that are not multi-use, although more and more of the bikes we see on the forest today are multi-use. You cannot ride them on a
54:13 Level 3 Road. Level 3 Road. So where the paved road is. And even the dirt beyond that because that's a Level 3 Road. So to make it legal, the county can or the town can or the Forest Service can designate that small section and there's a limit to how much you can do. Actually there was a law passed in California that came out of Inyo County that even increased this amount. You can make that a multi-use, multi-purpose road.
54:42 which would make it legal for green stickers on that short section. Then they could use the parking area at 203 and Sawmill Road with very little modification so they're not actually going into the campground to come out. And you could, I believe, but again, I don't know how much you can change these plans with the Forest Services. I need those answers. Well, that you could not put in now at this point? No, no, no.
55:09 That would be a whole separate thing, and actually that type of action right now is going on in Inyo County. They're having all their public meetings on it right now to decide which of the roads can be used. And they are, I believe, dirt roads primarily, although a couple of them may be paved, but it's a whole separate process. That would be a whole different process involving the town changing its ordinances, the forest closure.
55:35 I'm not sure the status of Shady Rest Road, the paved part, that's town, right? So the town would have to change its ordinances to allow traffic, but I would just have to say if I were somebody who used to go camping in, you know, Shady Rest Campground, asking a lot of OHVs to go back and forth and back and forth, you'd probably find a lot of objections from campers. So, I mean, you know, that's a separate process.
56:03 I don't think, just because you've got a new staging area, I don't think, and you know, the issue is new staging area or not, really, and do you solve the problem at Shady Rest Park or not, and that's all I have to say, my comments. So, and Sandy, you're thinking that option two would be preferable to option four for the OHVs for the summertime? Absolutely. I mean, and all you have to do is go out there and take a look and see if you think it's a good OHV staging area. It's a park.
56:33 And most municipalities don't mix those uses. No, no, and I absolutely agree with that, but I'm asking because option two, you know, is having the staging area at New Shady Rest Campground, and are you just thinking that it's just going to get too crowded in the summertime? Option two? No, option. Sorry, option four. Option four. Yeah, you know, it worked in the past. I would agree with Bill. When the road wasn't plowed, it didn't solve the summer problem.
56:59 Yeah, that's what I was wondering. It worked in the past. It didn't, I don't think it provides as much parking and pull through as this, the new one does. I mean, it's nice to have a new area, you know, and it's nice to have separation it uses. So that's really what it comes down to me. Okay. I think in both cases, the option of, is preserved for the use of the tunnel and, you know, someday the use of it to get to the borrow pit, and I think that was one of the things that Bill always looked at. But, you know, the top, the staging area is important.
57:28 For OHVs, you know, the uses, we've got terrific OHV roads out there and whatever, and most of them want to be out there, they don't necessarily want to be in town. I think that these questions can be asked of the Forest Service, and then, just totally lost my train of thought, but, yeah, it's been a long week, actually, but, anyways, okay, I don't know, the questions can be asked.
57:57 Drive out, you know, drive out, take a look at Shady Vest Park, far end, where OHVs a lot of times are, and then drive out and look at the potential area, and I know I've driven out, I drove out yesterday, as a matter of fact, to check out, because I noticed they had modified their, I think, the use of the motorized, or the non-motorized path a bit, and so I drove out and I could see that where they're talking about using it is pretty flat, so for beginners like me.
58:24 I could probably get out of the way of the snowmobile or they'd probably be able to see me. The part I was worried about, you know, was up and over and they're talking about a little bit of new construction, I think. Okay. We can ask those questions. I just have one more thing that my little light bulb went off is if we were looking at number two, my one question would be huge. Who's responsible for the construction, operations, and maintenance? Yeah.
58:52 And those are huge. Those are huge. It costs to a mile of road. Yeah. So that's the main restroom. Yeah. You have an extremely expensive construction, then you have daily operations, and you have maintenance. Yeah, I think we'd asked before about the maintenance. I think they said that it's the town's responsibility. So currently, on some of Cutoff Road, the town does, you know, we contract with that clearing, but ORMAT does pay for all of the winter maintenance of the road.
59:23 They don't pay for any of the summer. But who would be maintaining restrooms and parking areas and staging areas? That's not discussed. I don't think in there. That's not in any of these. Do we want to start memorializing some of these questions? Well, yeah, I think that we have. Just because I said it. I like it. Yeah, you got it. Thank you. What part of the summer maintenance says using heavy equipment to plow that road is not with the pavement?
59:53 was called out for and the underlayment and everything else. So we know there's damage being done to that road that is repaired in the summertime. Yeah. Is ORMAT picking that up? No, they have not. And that was some of our comments related to their project was the reconstruction of the road and then kind of an ongoing maintenance stream to help with some risk costs. Let's make sure that question, that was going to be one of my questions too, so let's make sure that that one is asked in a way that when is winter, when is summer and
1:00:20 Damage was done in the winter, but being fixed in the summer, who pays for it? Okay, update and requested action, Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. Okay, I'd like to pass out a few things in. One of them is the initial scope of work for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, and we'll be talking about
1:00:54 I'm going to scope in a minute. The other thing I'd like to pass out is a little packet of some of our recent accomplishments that are stapled together and printed front and back. And finally, I'd like to pass out a abbreviated, adjusted master tracking budget.
1:01:25 Changes we made yesterday? Yes, sir. Outstanding. Is this the full master track list? No, it's partial. First two pages showing funding allocations. Highlighted in yellow are decisions that were made yesterday. I hope I saved one for myself. If not, you can borrow one. Which I probably didn't, yeah. How many do you want? Which one is not just this top one? Okay, so I'll go to the podium. Okay.
1:03:00 So Steve Spidell, Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee Coordinator. I passed out some things for you to review, but first what I'd like to do is go through the staff report rather quickly, and in there I am responding to some materials that were asked to be provided. So in the staff report we talk about the
1:03:32 Various meetings that we've had in the background where the committee was asked to provide copies of executed agreements and documents related to trails programs and projects. So in your packet you should have a Recreation Commission MLTSCC handout list dated October 8th. This would be in the previously supplied packet, not in the handouts that I just made.
1:04:03 That wasn't printed out. It's actually part of your attachment, I think, is what it is. Yeah. It was pretty large. Yeah. So it's on just the second page of the... That's essentially the handout list, what's in the attachment there. So it's not the... Page two of two of the staff report. All we have is a... So whatever's on the back page is the handout. Is the handout. That's it. So number one was the handout list.
1:04:33 which I just mentioned. And then on the handout list are the various items. So one of the items you should find is, as requested, the Challenge Cost Share Agreement, Town of Mammoth Lakes U.S. Forest Service for the trail system implementation projects. Did everybody receive that as requested? I don't think so. It's not in our packet. It was online if you put it up online. We didn't include any of those in the packet. That was in the MLTACC packet.
1:05:06 That's what I was referring to. Thank you. Okay, I wasn't sure what was printed out. That's where I've seen it. Yeah, so. All right, sorry for the confusion. Everything's online. So, yeah, I'll speed this up then. Everything on your attachments on the back of the staff report on page two of two have been posted on the website as indicated under attachments. Are there any questions with any of the materials that were provided? Okay, thank you. Just a comment, and I like having...
1:05:39 Having this on the website so that people know what the Trails Committee is doing and where their money is going, I think that's nice. I did have a question on the cost share agreement with the Forest Service because, you know, I don't know, I guess I never really understood exactly what they were doing. But when I read through this, it appears that they're just looking at kind of looking at traffic flow and accommodating more people for
1:06:09 Public Transportation, and for pullouts, and maybe I didn't finish reading the whole thing, but I guess I'm trying to figure out exactly what we're trying to accomplish. Are you referring to the Sarbanes? With the Forest Service. Are you referring to the Sarbanes Grant? There's several of them? Okay, then maybe that's what my problem is. Maybe this is just one section of it. She's looking at the Sarbanes Grant. Okay. Any particular questions on the Sarbanes, I may defer to Peter Bernasconi. He's much more knowledgeable than I.
1:06:38 Okay. I guess what I need to do is go back and look at exactly what that whole cost-share agreement is because I don't know that we've actually been given to spell out exactly what we're trying to, what we're accomplishing with that cost-share agreement from MLT. Because this is just one section that I printed up from URIGEN yesterday. Right. Which isn't on the trails. This is the Sarbanes, which is a different project primarily. This was pretty much transportation. That's why I was like, is that all we're accomplishing with?
1:07:08 The moneys that has... No, we have the challenge cost share that we have put money into out of our fund is for mostly the Sharp, the Sherman Area trail system. That's what I thought that I read this. And the money that we have currently put in is doing the environmental work to set the stage for actual construction. And in fact, in one of the handouts that Steve gave you today, we have moved some trail construction funds along.
1:07:38 to keep them in this year's budget so that when the environmental is done there's a couple of trails we can jump on immediately and have the money to construct. Okay. I appreciate that. Yeah, you did. We put anywhere in specific construction. Printed this off of your agenda and so anyhow it's... Because one of us had asked for the... Ah. So the Sarbanes Grant is a $2.1 million grant that we got from FTA.
1:08:05 And that's fully, the work that they're doing there is fully funded by the grant. The town receives the money. We have to pay the Forest Service to do the environmental work for that. And it is studying circulation in the Lakes Basin as well as the environmental for the Lake George Connector Path. So in the Sarbanes is the environmental work for the Lake George Connector Path? Correct. So if I go through the Sharps report, then I would be able to clarify what you guys have. Well, there's a whole other cost share agreement with the Forest Service from
1:08:35 The Mammoth Lakes Trail System, The Town of Mammoth Lakes. And within that, within our MOU or whatever, what do we call the original agreement? We have a master agreement and then we have a project supplement. So under the master agreement, you will find a project cost share that is to pay for the environmental for the whole sharps. And is that online somewhere where I can see what you have? That is online.
1:09:03 I think Steve posted that online, too. Okay. And that is being funded by the... Yes. Okay. My assumption is most of that work is probably not being performed as an essential part of government services. Teri, I'm sorry for the confusion. I should have set it up better and that, again, I was just trying to quickly...
1:09:26 Provide back to you things that had been requested. Okay. You know, I didn't realize there were several sections that you guys were looking at, so anyhow. I'm sorry for that. The next thing I'd like to discuss then is give you a little recap of our meeting of October 7th, some of the things that came up in the meeting, some of the things that were asked to be brought forward for your consideration, and some of the things that we're continuing to work on. So one of the things that came up in public comment were
1:09:55 Two requests for presentations to the Trails Committee from our NGO nonprofit partners, one of them being Friends of the Inyo to present Lakes Basin Stewards projects and presentations of what's been happening in the last year. The other one was MLTPA coming forward and requesting time on the agenda to present a website management contract quarterly report.
1:10:23 So I'd like to do one of two things. One is to invite you to our November 4th meeting at 1.30, or if you would like, we could agendize those presentations to you for your review here at your next scheduled meeting. So I'd like to put the two options out there for your consideration. Being completely selfish and speaking for myself, I'd rather not sit through them twice. Well, I think it would be appropriate to have a joint workshop with the committee and the commission.
1:10:57 What time do you guys usually meet? Like at 1 o'clock? 1.30. 1.30 is when we start on Monday, November 4th. So we could note that as a joint commission committee to make it legal for all the commission to be there together and not be breaking any brown eye? Would we still have a commission meeting the following day? Yes. Yes. But it wouldn't be presented a second time. No. Yeah. That's fine. Yeah. No, no, I'm going the same way.
1:11:28 So we'd just, we'd schedule it then as the first hour being workshop, and then we'd have our regularly scheduled, well, it wouldn't be regularly scheduled, we'd be pushing it back an hour. Right. I'm all for that. That's fine. I should be able to make that. I'm out of town. Okay. Are you out of town both? No, I'm back to the Tuesday meeting. Oh, I see.
1:11:56 So the consensus is to have a joint workshop for the first hour to allow those two presentations. Then the Rec Commission could dissolve and walk out of the room if they chose, and then we could continue on with the Trails Committee meeting. Or since Pat's not going to be here, could we do the joints on Tuesday when you guys come? On Tuesday? An hour early on Tuesday. Do we need that presentation for our meeting, though, Bill? No. I don't know. I don't believe so.
1:12:23 These are just report backs. Yeah, they're report backs to the Trails Committee and they only offer it to see if there's a wider spread interest by the Rec Commission, that's all. So we could, instead of doing those for MLT SCC, we could schedule those for 1 o'clock on Tuesday as part of the commission process. Yeah, I would be back, but I don't want to change it if it's just for me. 1 o'clock on Tuesday would be better for me too.
1:12:53 Sean, are you? I'm fine with that. So then let's do the joint notice for the Tuesday meeting. Does that work for, I mean, we have John here from MLTPA. Does that give you what you're looking to do? Well, we have Sandy here. Are you here for Tuesday? Yes. Yeah, well, obviously we would have to have him here.
1:13:22 Trails meeting. Right. To me, it seems appropriate to have a Trails meeting meeting and most of you that want to attend attend. I mean, they didn't ask to come to the recognition. Except for their Measure R funds that are being expended. Trails meeting. My preference would be talk to Paul and if he can do Tuesday and if he's willing to do that. If for some reason he wants to do it just for the MLTSCC.
1:13:51 Then we can do that as well and let that be the guide. You know, if it comes before the MLTSCC, I just want to make sure that the Recreation Commission is comfortable with essentially us hearing MLTS saying we were satisfied or we weren't satisfied. My concern would just be that MLTSCC says that we're satisfied and the Recreation Commission says, yeah, but why? We'll do it as a workshop either way. Paul can do it on Tuesday. We do it on Tuesday if he has no problem with it.
1:14:21 And John as well, because he's part of that presentation. If he prefers to do it on Monday, because that's the day we sat, then we do a joint meeting on Monday. It's that easy. Well, I'm... Pat wasn't going to be there, so it was just a suggestion. So, you know, it's... I'd say work it out whichever is more convenient for the committee. If you guys feel comfortable with it, then... I think that he has his marching orders. Thank you.
1:14:50 The other thing that we've been doing, unfortunately, without the U.S. Forest Service as our partner, we've been trying to continue working on the winter recreation map and the reprint of that, but we still need to have further discussions with the Forest Service, of course, and part of that also is the summer recreation map. The other thing we are working on and look forward to input, continued input from the Forest Service has to do with the lakes basin early opening and late closure.
1:15:18 And in specifics, we're looking at dumpsters remaining open and unlocked for a longer period of time and what some of the options might be for the town to participate with Mammoth disposal on getting some of those dumpsters either emptied or have special dumpsters put in for that purpose. The other thing we're looking at is trying to keep restrooms open longer and opening up earlier.
1:15:41 One of the options there, too, to look at is the use of port-a-potty. So we're in the process of discussing those options with the Forest Service and men's disposal. Important to note on that one that we are not sure that the MLTSCC pot of money is where that particular thing belongs. So we will want to bring that to a discussion here at Commission. Down the list.
1:16:08 Sorry. Steve, I have one question on the maps. So these maps you're talking about are the print maps. And I'm assuming they coincide with the website. Is that? The updates are going to be on the website as well as print? Or is it just? Yes. Okay. Well, sort of. MLTPA requested to bring copies today. So I went to John. So part of the packet that we handed out to the Trails Committee members
1:16:36 included the existing 2009 printing of the winter recreation map. So it is this particular map that we're discussing. And yes, Teri, the goal is that eventually when you look at a printed map and you walk up to a trail net and dual map or you go to the website with your smartphone or whatever, all those maps will be consistent in their language, their content, and their delivery. Very good.
1:17:04 This is a map originally that was paid for by Green Stickers and Cooperation of the Town. And the Forest Service, it goes back to 2003, 2004 or something. Even earlier. Yeah, it may go back into the 90s. In fact, it probably does. It's about 20 years old. Before my time. So my question was, we should have gotten an update on the summer map as well.
1:17:32 because they're both produced. There's a winter version and there's a summer version. And is green sticker dollar still paying for it? We're just doing the match. So there are still all sorts of questions out there that need to be asked and answered. Okay. Another thing that's come up that relates a little bit to the Forest Service and also to one of our NGO nonprofits is the matter of winter grooming at Shady Rats Park.
1:17:58 We've tried to be in touch with Mammoth Nordic and their board members and we're expecting a response back hopefully this week. In the meantime, we've done some research and looked at previous proposals that were made to Mammoth Nordic and also some previous draft contracts to the water district for use of equipment. So we're exploring various options.
1:18:25 With regret, Mammoth Nordic did not provide us with a measure of performance report for the work that they did last year. There was $20,000 worth of funding from the Trails Committee to Mammoth Nordic to provide the grooming services that they did do, but one of the requirements of that, of course, is a performance report. Unfortunately, we haven't received it to date and have not been able to receive satisfactory communication back as to why or when.
1:18:53 So we are looking and exploring other options and discussing that. So at this point, I just want to point out that we are looking at other things, and there are possibly some options that we can look at, and hopefully by November we'll have a plan of action. Steve, would it be appropriate once you hear one way or another from Mammoth Nordic that you share that information with the committee? Absolutely. So at least they know ahead of time before their November meeting. Yes. One more detail on that.
1:19:24 Yeah, that's, we're waiting to hear, hopefully by this week, isn't that right? That's correct. Tomorrow. We anticipate to hear this week. With the interest, because I was at the meeting during this part of the conversation, with the interest, with the gentleman that came up and spoke, would there be opportunity for other people to give, you know, a bid or a proposal to the committee? Is that going to be opened up?
1:19:53 Regardless, or are we only opening that up if we don't receive the information and acknowledgement from Mammoth Norton? I think it's safe to say that as we are moving forward, we are exploring as many options as we can, and we're brainstorming and looking into research for availability of equipment, availability of people, and so forth. So that will all be part of what we try and bring forward in November is some sort of comprehensive
1:20:21 either plan or options that are available to explore further at this point. One of the sticky wickets in dealing with this is the use permit that Mammoth Clark has with the Forest Service to groom trails. These aren't even trails that the town, only one of them exists on a town mob where the town holds a special use permit and might be able to do something anyway. So we have to find out if
1:20:51 I am pretty sure the Forest Service would transfer that over to the town because we have a working relationship already, and that's just my personal opinion, nothing written in stone. I don't know that the Forest Service would be so willing to move that to another body or non-profit because they wouldn't have had the time to do the necessary background checks. Just like when we have someone apply for funds, we want to make sure that they can have the capacity to spend those.
1:21:16 Yeah, and I have no problem with Mammoth Nordic. They've done a good job. I just was asking since somebody asked yesterday at the podium, and maybe we need to look at moving that to the town anyways so that, you know, aren't in this position. I've said it for several years. You need to get into the job of managing snow. Yeah, you have, and I think also in the trail system master plan, you know, it calls out, you know, trying to get more year-round use of all the mumps in town, so maybe there's an opportunity there.
1:21:46 If we're going to end up doing grooming at Shady Rest, maybe we can expand that to some of the other parts of the trail system. Good point. One of the handouts that I gave you is the initial scope of work for the committee itself. These next items are a discussion of the possible expansion of that scope of work.
1:22:12 As you can see, it's fairly limited and distinct, yet projects are coming to the committee that are borderline beyond the scope and that are at least causing questions within the committee as to scope creep and whether or not these are appropriate. So one of the things that I want to talk to the Recreation Commission about is
1:22:38 Kind of the attitude of how to take on these projects that seem to be larger than just a trail related project. So for instance, the U.S. Forest Service early and late closure. I mean that has to do with their facilities of dumpsters and restrooms and maintenance people and so forth. So the direct nexus to a trail system project may need to be discussed further. Same thing could be said with the
1:23:08 This Nordic grooming that we were just talking about. Some of this stuff happens on U.S. Forest Service land. It has to do with the U.S. Forest Service special use permits and so forth. So how do we incorporate that into a coordinating committee and what role does that committee play? A couple other projects that have come up to the idea has been the U.S. Forest Service proposed projects. You heard earlier on your agenda today was the Shady Rest Trailhead.
1:23:35 So, you know, how deeply involved does the trail committee get into that particular project? Is it their, would it be their responsibility to write letters and comments or is that the responsibility of the Recreation Commission or is it something the Recreation Commission writes and then kicks up to town council and has the town council deliver comments? And then the other project, of course, that's out there for U.S. Forest Service potential project is the ORMAT project.
1:24:05 How does the committee react to those proposals? So these are things that we'd like to talk to the Recreation Commission about, this expanding role of responsibility and where the Rec Commission feels is a hard line or a border line between what the Trails Committee does and what the Rec Commission does. And the final thing that...
1:24:29 We have been discussing and that we might see come forward is a need for the Rec Commission and the Trails Committee to talk about facilitation of a winter summit which might also then incorporate the discussion of grooming, the larger discussion that Elizabeth brings up of all our MUPS and where it's appropriate to groom, where we might get the cover, how we might get the machines, how we might facilitate different needs for different users at different times.
1:25:03 Let's see. The thing that I'd like to point out to you now is the 11 by 17 blow up of our master tracker. Steve, before you go on, actually, if I could just talk or just ask about the, you know, questions you just posed, essentially. What is the role of the MLTSCC? Are we going to be discussing that now or is that something that you're, that, you know, in? It is not on our agenda. Thank you very much. So it's going to be spinning our tires. Okay. Thank you. I think it would be good to.
1:25:33 You know, you posed the questions so we can come back at maybe our next meeting and then they can have that conversation. Well, I just would like to actually, if we're going to do that, let's do that because I know that at the MLTSCC ESPA, you know, there was discussion that we need to have this discussion with regard to a winter summit. We are coming up. So I guess what I'm asking then is before we actually move on, let's either agendize it.
1:25:56 Or ask it to be agendized, I should say. Well, and I agree. We need to put it on the agenda, although I think that Mr. Wentworth put it best yesterday at our meeting. The real question is, how does the town of Mammoth Lakes respond to projects that are going on within the National Forest? Is it through the MLTSCC? And if so, for what projects? Is it through the Rec Commission? Who should have been the lead on ORMAT? Should we all have had input?
1:26:24 The town did respond on a limited basis, but should there have been more involved from Recreation? So the question that needs to be on the agenda is more than just what is MLTSCC, but what piece of the town should be? Every decision the Forest Service makes has huge potential to affect the town of Mammoth Lakes, the people of the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:26:50 How is the town when you respond and stay engaged with the Forest Service is really the question. Yeah, it is. So, and it's, you know, almost philosophical in nature, but should be and can be defined. The question is, when are we going to start on that? And it sounds like, and I forget what we had decided yesterday. Was that something that the MLTSCC was going to discuss and bring a recommendation forward to Recreation Commission, Bill? Do you remember? I think yesterday we just sort of...
1:27:19 Segue into things that we felt were specific to MLTSCC. Although looking at our initial scope, I might disagree with some of the comments that some of what we were looking at was not within our scope. This is broad-based enough to cover everything in there. I just want to make sure, you know, it gets dealt with that we don't just...
1:27:42 Talk about it, and as we said yesterday, all of a sudden it's fall 2014, and we haven't dealt with early closure of shady rest out of Lakes Basin, for instance. I thought you talked about having a committee, a subcommittee maybe, of the trails committee and the commission to kind of put together some guidelines and specifics that then come back to the trails committee and then the commission and then pass on to the council for those early closure and
1:28:11 Right, but again, it's something we can't deal with today. I just want to make sure it gets agendized. You need to get it on the agenda, that's all. I think it could be something that you guys discuss at your next meeting and then it can come to our meeting which falls on the next day. Right, it should be on both agendas. And so it can be on both agendas, yeah. Thank you for being patient with us, Steve. Continue. Okay. What I'd like to draw your attention to now is 11 by 17 blow up of the master tracker and in particular the yellow highlighted items.
1:28:40 These yellow highlighted items are decisions that were made yesterday as far as funding is concerned. And if I might just run through them quickly, and then if you have any follow-up questions, I'd be happy to answer them. The first one was under governance. The $7,500 that's been added in there is carryover.
1:29:07 from funds that were not expended in 2012-13 and they are now assigned to be spent in the year 2013-14 and those particular funds are for the town staff management of the MLTPA work and the website contract to manage the
1:29:35 website management contract and also the website enhancement contract. The $3,000 was left under the 2012-13 reallocated funds so at a later date those monies can be used as a contingency to apply to other projects as listed under the current status column. And then
1:30:05 The third one down, the Sharps Trails Construction Fund. It was a combination of taking the $6,500 that was approved in 12-13, blending it with a $13,500, coming up with $20,000 that is to be available for a 2013-14 budget. So if we get through the environmental review process with the Forest Service and an opportunity comes forward for a piece of trail construction,
1:30:34 This fiscal year we have monies set aside and available to participate in that construction. Then on the top of the second page there was a need expressed to develop soft surface signage and wayfinding. This last summer we were able to put in some temporary signs, Panorama Dome and up on the Mountain View Trail. They're very effective and we're looking forward to moving to a larger more robust soft surface trail signage program for
1:31:05 Designing permanent signs. So we took $10,000 that was not spent in 2012-13, moved it forward to 2013-14 to make that money available and then out of that $10,500 was spent on the messaging for the temporary signs this year. So that gives us a balance of $9,500 to use this year for that project.
1:31:35 Down the middle of the page we have the website content and operations. The money in blue there, the $31,320 is the residual left over from funds that were not spent in 12-13 and those monies were distributed out to pay for the website contract management by the town.
1:32:00 And then finally the last one is the $500 I was mentioning for the temporary signage and that was spent in 13-14. So this is somewhat similar to what you've seen before. We still have the red highlighted projects for approved funding in 13-14 that will be coming back to you for final approval. And it's fair to say that this
1:32:29 Process is working out well for us to monitor the funds that we have signed in the past, the funds that we are carrying forward to spend in the current year, the funds that we have allocated for future years, and also it's giving us a slush fund of some monies to react to projects as they come up on demand, and it's also helping us to track the signed contracts, the funds that we've paid out, and keeping our...
1:32:59 Billing in order. Reserves. Yeah. Reserves. Slush months. I actually have a question on that. Okay. And I don't know, and it's a philosophical thing, because, I mean, obviously you're putting money towards trails in future years, but if there's $300,000 that's going towards trails and you haven't expended it by the end of the year, you are putting it in a contingency fund, basically, for future projects. But has that ever actually even been discussed as to?
1:33:28 Because basically if monies are not used for a Measure R allocated project that was put through, it rolls back into Measure R so that it can be decided whether it should go to something else. I don't know whether it should be voted upon each year, whether it's held over, or whether there's... I don't know that that discussion has ever taken place as to what happens with monies that weren't expended within that year. And, you know, it's just kind of happening, and I think that it needs to be a conversation.
1:33:58 It should be decided and agreed upon by, you know, all parties, including council, that that's how these things are done. I guess that is a concern of mine. Well, the list that you saw prior to this modified list had all that played out in it. It was presented as recommended from the trails committee to the rec commission. Rec commission approved it and it did go to council.
1:34:27 And if that's what's happening each year, I guess I would like there to be something that's firmly stated, that we understand that each year this is allocated, and if there's any money left over, that it is not going to come back into Measure R for any further future projects. It will stay in the trails Measure R allocation as a contingency or reserve to be used in further future time, and I just would really like that to be stated.
1:34:54 spelled out, it voted on at this level, and then, you know, we're looking at public, so the public knows exactly that that's what's going on as well. So I'm not saying that I would vote against it, I just think it needs to be spelled out. But I think in a way we did that, and we spelled it out even clearer probably, when we brought it back to you this year, we being MLTSCC, coming back to the commission, we talked about the fact that we hadn't expended them all, but we would like to...
1:35:23 Move them forward, and then we got a vote approving that, just like we awarded the track money and they didn't get it spent in a year, and they came back and said, here's our progress, we need the money to continue to move forward. But since that seems to be an assumption, I think that it needs to be spelled out and that it's not assumed that it's, if this is the way that we're going to conduct the funds for this trail, that it should be spelled out and that it's agreed upon by everybody and it's moved on.
1:35:52 One of the things I might add too, Teri, is that some of these projects are going to be fairly expensive. And so the idea was if we have monies that we can dedicate to those projects, identified projects, but just in a sense hold off on the spending until all that money can come together and then it can go in to pay for the construction of the project, that that's a way of doing it instead of taking...
1:36:19 All of $300,000 one year and just pouring it all into one project. Once again, I don't necessarily have a problem with that. I just think that it needs to be spelled out and the public realizes that that $300,000 is going towards trails, period. And that it's going to be there. It's going to be held over from year to year in a reserve or project, you know, specific. And that everybody agrees to that, including council.
1:36:48 And I just think it needs to be spelled out, but it's consistently reported back to us that, you know, the money wasn't spent, it's being held over, it's being held over for this purpose. And I think that's what's been happening, and I think we certainly, you know, respect the expertise of the Trails Committee, and, you know, it's not like you guys are throwing a big party with it. But I just, I do think Teri's right that we do need to just lay out that that, you know, that that is how we're going to handle that, because it is kind of a departure from how other measure our allocations. However, when the council approved this,
1:37:18 They said $300,000 for five years, which is, you know, $1.5 million. And I think it was even commented, well, how about looking at it each year and then making that decision? And they blanketly said no. They would like to see it all go to trails over five years. Once again, I don't have a problem with that. I just think that there needs to be something that's spelled out that says this is what we're doing. And I have no problem. We need to ferret out more about it.
1:37:44 How that $300,000 has been anyway, because I think we're going farther afield than what the original intent was. We are now taking everything that would have been paid for elsewhere and zeroing it in on that $300,000. While it sounds like a lot of money to me, that $300,000 really doesn't go very far. So I have no problem having that conversation, and I think we should agenda that for our next meeting and have that discussion and lay out and see it come forward.
1:38:12 Personally, I wish that we had this here list for all of the Measure R projects we've done. That would be nice. This complexity and what Steve has done, how he came to this with what we had, I don't know, but he is. And I'm not questioning that. Him and Stu working together on this have done a great job.
1:38:30 As chair of the MLT SCC, I remember bringing this budget specifically before the Recreation Commission and getting approved, moved forward with the specifics of that money was being rolled over. Steve's comment is well taken that a lot of these, for instance, that $20,000 that is designated for construction of the sharp trails, that's exactly what it's designated for. We don't know what that money is going to be since we couldn't, since the
1:38:56 Federal Government wasn't ready to go forward with that. That's why we are rolling it over. With regard to this discussion, I think that this is something that is a perfect tie-in to what we were just discussing with regard to the workshop that is between the committee and the coalition committee and commission to interpret exactly what is the sidewalls of the committee's responsibility. So let's take it up at that time in that workshop. So we need to add that to the workshop.
1:39:24 Thank you. Whichever day that workshop happens to go, Stu and Steve both. That's what I was trying to get to. And the question might be, okay, year five comes around, and if you have a surplus, then what? Do you get less the following year or more? Well, unless it's tied to a project, then you could leave it within that project. I mean, I just think it needs to make it clear and clean, and everybody knows exactly what's up. So, anyhow. We really need to move on this. Yes, we do. Okay.
1:39:53 And then finally, and I think it's clear here, but it needs to just be spelled out, so, yeah. Finally, the eight and a half by 11 packet I gave you that's printed on both sides has information in there reporting back to you on, we've come to a determination of what our mission is, our mission statement, our vision. We have in there our strategies.
1:40:23 and procedures for funding also we have in there are process steps for how we review projects and the steps that the projects go through so these are administrative functions that the committee has worked very hard on on the past few months to put into place so that it's very open
1:40:51 Very distinct as to how we are moving forward with these monies, what the process is for assigning project numbers, how we track those through the master tracker and our other lists, and then also when the projects come forward and request for funding, we have a little checklist there that will help us to understand how they fit within the master plan and the overall goals of the committee. So if there are any questions, I'd be happy to answer them.
1:41:21 I have a question about there's a line item for fundraising. Yes. And I thought that Measure R monies or U monies cannot be used for fundraising or do you mean it in a different way? I knew you had some conversation about it yesterday. There have been discussions ongoing. There has been an opinion from the town attorney. And there also, if you'll notice, on the 11 by 17 foldout, there have been monies in the past allocated for funding.
1:41:51 And so you'll notice that there is a code number in the left-hand side for that. So it's just, it may be something that we can't do in the future or we decide to do in a different way, but for tracking purposes, if a project comes forward and it's related to funding, that is the nomenclature or the code number that it gets. Now whether or not we're able to successfully go through with it or not is another matter.
1:42:18 That's the purpose of that sheet there is to help one understand the method or the codex for coming up with the code numbering system. And so this could be even a donation that somebody says, hey, I want to put money towards this project. They donate that money to this and it would be coded and such. So you're not necessarily going out and looking for that fundraising. Correct. That's a good point. Any other questions? If not, thank you very much.
1:42:48 All right, thanks, Stuart. Just quickly, quickly, Chair, so I've got an email back from Paul McCarlan. He's available to do the presentation on the 5th of November, if you wish. That was our regular commission meeting, so it won us on. And that way, Pat would be here. Let's do it. We'll move forward with a 1 o'clock workshop. 1 p.m. Great. It's going on the calendar. John? Hi. Sorry, just a couple quick points.
1:43:16 Just to be clear, the presentation that we're making on behalf of the website was, I think, requested by staff as part of the ongoing, to give you guys an update on what's happening with our ongoing contract. It's not an advocacy effort. It's a contractual update for that effort. I think that the map coordination, Teri, is something that will come up as part of that conversation. Certainly working with Steve to make sure that the winter map recreations is represented on the website, but there are maps going up.
1:43:43 On signs of the college connector, public works may be working on. Ideally, this stuff should all be coordinated. It should be one system of map making. But that's part of the role of the coordinating committee is to coordinate those things. Finally, I would offer that the challenge cost share agreements, you know, there's several of them. But one of them certainly is a very high level, overarching agreement.
1:44:05 between the town and the forest service with regards to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And I would suggest that any comments that the town makes with regards to the trail system or trail facilities should be referencing those documents. The council voted on these things to have an enhanced level of cooperation with the Inyo National Forest for this trail system. So as you move forward with your ideas about commenting on these forest service proposals, I would recommend to haul those things out and make reference to those documents. Thank you. Yeah, I would love to read the whole document. I'll find it.
1:44:34 Okay, moving on to number five, the Measure R, Follower Timeline, Funding Priorities, Application Evaluation Material in Town, Funding Application and Meetments Items. So, Chair, if I may, just before we jump into that item, we have like an hour and 15 to go. I do have an appointment that I can't miss. We've got two and a half something hours of items.
1:45:03 What we'd recommend is you do Measure R right now at this one and then jump to item number eight and then backtrack and do six and seven if you have available time. Yeah, well, let's get through Measure R in less than 30 minutes. Okay. And then go to eight and I'm sure we will not get through six and seven. Does eight need to be done today or is that something that we can do on the 22nd?
1:45:29 Well, I'll just answer that. In 8, there is a request to consideration for the Recreation Commission to either direct staff to include feasibility master plan for their parks in the request to council that goes next week, right, as part of the town proposed application. So if we don't want to do that, then...
1:45:55 You know, we could do it October 22nd, but then we don't have council review that. Package so open. And then Peter's here too, so I'd like to take advantage of our public works director. So that's kind of that reference to the item. What we have to do to measure our timeline today. We have to do the timeline. And the action before you, as I know, we've addressed the timeline, we've addressed the priorities. We had the workshop. There was no real, I believe, concern from council on the timeline or the priorities. So really what we're asking today is to review.
1:46:23 Those other items that we haven't really revised or considered being the application form, the evaluation material, and also the performance report is in there as well. And then for the package for council, just to approve a motion of packaging all those items together. I think that's just going to be the easiest way to do it. Because the package, as you know, for council has already been written. It's already on the
1:46:52 website right now. So whatever we decide now is what I'm going to present verbally to the Council on October 16th. So if that's the best way to tackle it, Chair, we can kind of just jump through the ones that you're comfortable with and then tackle the ones that you want to spend time on. Can I ask a brief question with regard to the timeline? Stu, this question came up in the events coalition meeting earlier today. Can you remind me, with the measure U,
1:47:25 Open and Closing is? It goes. Sorry, I know it's in my other, I just couldn't get back to my notes before I got to this meeting. Actually, it's in the previous factors. Two weeks removed from ours, right? It's like two weeks later. Okay. So, whenever we open, it's two weeks later. Open October 21st, so it opens November.
1:47:48 Yeah. I do remember that. I just want to make sure it hadn't changed. I think it's November 11th to December 2nd. That sounds right. Because we were going to have that joint workshop on December 3rd with the Measure U Application Committee. So that's that. Just want to confirm. That's what we talked about. Gotcha. I do want to bring back the principles again, number three, the emphasis on enhancing quality of life.
1:48:16 And actually, if you look in our minutes, it does not say for residents. It just says enhancing the quality of life. And I just, it's a, just kind of a point of clarification. You did bring up that. And so whether that could just be changed for residents and visitors or just quality of life in general? In our minutes, it just says quality of life. And I think just. Back at our minutes. And I think just quality of life because then it encompasses. It encompasses everybody. Residents, visitors. So are we all comfortable with it? Did you just say quality of life?
1:48:45 My notes have it was for the community, so I kind of look at community at large, but that's fine. So let's just put a period at the end of life, too. Yeah, because I mean in the general plan in 2007, it's enhancing quality of life for both residents and visitors. So I mean there is that kind of...
1:49:07 That roll up to the general plan, but if we're just happy keeping it general. If you want to put both of those in there, that's fine, but I guess that's the only reason why I want it to stay general is because I think it needs quality of life for, as Betsy said, our residents, our second homeowners, our visitors. It's just kind of a general quality of life. It was mentioned both, I think, in the Measure U committee, the task force. They did. Because if we go back to our minutes on September 10th, add number four, emphasis on enhancing quality of life.
1:49:37 That's exactly what it says. That's what it should be then. Just enhancing quality. Anytime we can remove words, I'm a happy camper. And just because I think it is an enhancing quality of life generally all around so that we're looking at many programs, not just things that enhance for residents, but that we're looking at everybody. Okay, anything else from the staff report stand out? So it looks like the timeline, I think we're okay with the timeline.
1:50:08 We're still moving forward with that. We're OK with the funding priorities. We haven't addressed the application form or the evaluation material. I don't know if the Commission had any comments on that. We leave it as is. It was revised from spring, so we keep making those organic changes as we keep moving forward. So it's not just static form from last fall forward. But at this point, we already approved those and commented on those changes, right? From spring, we haven't really
1:50:39 Made any comments to the application form itself yet. All the application form. I know there was some discussion earlier about the project filtering checklist. Well, we keep looking at, you know, a planning document as to a CIP or, you know, a capital project. Could you clarify December 3rd, the special meeting with the Measure U committee is only if there are applications that are going to both groups?
1:51:07 You know, applications for Measure R and Measure U? No, I think it's just to go over all the applications. Yeah. Why would we want to do that? Some applications may come in to U that are more appropriate to R. Some applications could come in to R that are more appropriate to U. Wouldn't staff make that decision? No. No, that decision would be for the two groups that are looking at those different things. So by meeting together, we can say,
1:51:35 For instance, one of these is the summer enhancement at the rink, that traditionally has been a 50-50 split. Does both groups still think that's appropriate? Do we need to alter that? You know, the council asked us to keep these two sort of tied to the hip, and this allows us to do that.
1:51:59 I can see if there's, you know, an application that could go either way, but if there's one that's specifically for R or for you, I don't know why the other committee would need to look at that application or interview. It could be a very short meeting. I think what Bill just said is pretty appropriate, that if there's something that's applicable, you know, somebody sees something, that that would be the part that would be the discussion. I don't think that we would bring every single application.
1:52:29 Well, that was my question. Is it every application or is it just some that are available? Just if there's a question, I think. Each member of both committees are going to get a full list of all the applications that are into both. And if any committee member has an issue with an application, then they can bring it forward to that group and as a group can be decided where the application would then go. And I think that's appropriate for the groups.
1:52:54 So you're not going to have to go through the entire application, but you'll have a list kind of like we just have here that says this is what's coming forward.
1:53:01 Well, I think it's nice, like, when you think back to when we had the, you know, the application for the barricades and, you know, we ended up deciding that, you know, half of it should come from R and half from U. And, you know, just that way, I think it just kind of saves another layer of meetings if we can all just make that, you know, determination at the same time. Pretty much keeps the community. And it really keeps the communication between the two groups open, more importantly. It keeps the dialogue open between us so that we all know where the others are coming from. That's communication. That's openness.
1:53:31 I guess I'm just wondering if there are ulterior motives because in the MLR report to Council, it talks about merging the Measure U and the Measure R committee. So I'm just wondering, is this a precursor to moving in that direction? Or is it something that really will be valuable and save time if there are applications that are applicable potentially to both groups? I mean, I certainly understand that. Yeah, I have no hope.
1:53:58 I hadn't even thought about it until now, so there's no preconceived notion out there. Well, it is, and it is a question, but that's still a question that's out there, and maybe this helps answer that question. I don't know. Well, I don't think, I mean, Council's been urging us to streamline the timelines for these processes, and I think even if MLR does happen, I think that's long past this fall's funding cycle. Right.
1:54:28 No, no preconceived. No, I would just say that if there are applications that could be applicable to either funding source, then yes, both groups should look at it, and that would save time. But if there's one that's just, I don't know. You know, I'd prefer it to go, you at least just have both R and U review them, and I'll tell you why, it's because we had an applicant here, and I'm trying to remember who it was, I want to say it was Sandra DiDomizio who brought it.
1:54:54 Application before Measure R, but found out after it had closed that it should have gone to U, and if there is some way at least of making sure, you know, I know staff is supposed to be reviewing this and shepherding the different applications to go to the correct, but it would be nice as R and U to just review this, and as Stu said, it could be a very short meeting, but just to make sure that we're not letting any applications get rejected because of a technicality of, oh, you should have gone to U.
1:55:23 Especially since we've streamlined the two award cycles, which I commend us for doing that, you know, and I mean that with everyone. Since we're doing that, Stu, thank you. Let's, you know, I'm not opposed to this meeting. If I can just make that statement. Just out of curiosity, I mean, we have, you know, members of the Measure U Committee in the audience. Any thoughts? Well said.
1:56:02 Didn't mean to call you to the podium there. Didn't mean to put you on the podium, sorry. You look like you need to stretch your legs. Don Zalany, there are things like the HVS contract that we're both funding, and it probably makes sense. Do you want to look at all of the event coalition proposals? I don't think so. Do I want to look at a lot of the stuff you do? Probably not, but there are some joint things.
1:56:33 that need to make sense to us, I think, and I hope it's a short meeting, but I sit through Rec Commission meetings, and they don't tend to be short, so maybe Pat's got a point. I'm just looking at something like Trails End Park turf.
1:56:49 I mean, you know, maybe that's not a Measure U consideration. Well, it's not, and we don't have to even, you know, I see it on the list and I probably won't even think about it. I was going to say, if you have a list that lists like this, then there's one that's here that's the joint consideration, then that's what you're doing is looking at a list and saying we're going to talk about this one. Stu will probably highlight those for us. Yeah, exactly. I think that that's appropriate. Yellow? Yes, there you go.
1:57:15 We can pick any color you want. Is that enough? I really hate today. Any other questions regarding all of this? We have a... I just have one question because I think at the last meeting, Sean mentioned something about synthetic or natural turf and you wanted some information. So will that be part of maybe the application process?
1:57:54 So that's right, yeah. And, you know, I went down to look at the Little Brothers Park and happened to meet up with, and I'm awful in this, I'm sorry, the gal that's doing the landscaping out there, with JLA. So anyways, I was talking to her and she had some incredible ideas about putting regular turf out there and having a solar holding tank that could be built and, you know, look like it's a rock, you know.
1:58:26 Formation, and putting regular turf, $90,000 is just such an incredibly huge number for such a small little area of turf that if there's some other options that we can look at as far as something like that goes, I mean, she, you know, there could even be funding for something like that as a grant out there, some, you know, for something like that if you're doing...
1:58:49 A solar holding tank that could do, you know, the general watering that we're looking at. I don't know whether it's even feasible, but, you know, it's an interesting concept, and had a long conversation with her, and, you know, it was kind of an interesting idea, and so, you know, there are options, and I just, just that amount of money on artificial turf for such a small area seems just so exorbitant, so.
1:59:18 But at this point, it's a matter of whether we want the application to come forward or not. Well, it can come forward, but I think that some of those things, maybe we look at some other options. Maybe they just address that question. Yeah, and I thought you requested to include in the application two options. One was some type turf, and then another option with just regular turf, and then the cost difference between operating the two. Thank you. That's exactly what I remember. And I have a couple other questions on this.
1:59:46 Ask away. Okay. So the $250,000 for the match for a possible grant, it's my understanding that that grant isn't even going to be addressed until next October. Is that correct? Well, as I recall, so we'll be submitting the grant next month. The commission wanted us to include that application so with the grant we have a better chance of getting the funding than not.
2:00:14 So the grant itself I think will be around a $400,000 grant. The two, they'll be the separate application just really to deal with the turf since the grant reviewers really indicated that they don't want to see that on the application at all and they certainly aren't going to fund it. Does that help? But that was what I recall from the last meeting was to do the application now for the grant.
2:00:44 You know, the east side has not received a grant for some time from state parks, and so we're due if we have a good application. Okay, and when does that grant come through once again now? Uh, middle of November. So, for next year? Oh, for the, yeah, so the actual money wouldn't be expended until, um, well, really 2050 at this point. Would it be valuable? No, no, no. What Pete is saying is we need to approve it now.
2:01:11 Even if we don't approve it out of this stream of money. I agree. I guess that's what I'm trying to get to. Yeah, so it could be a future allocation. It could be a future allocation. Approved for future allocation. And I guess that's what I'm trying to get to. And we could uncover a portion of them this year and a portion of them next year. And that's just because the way this is written, it's looking like we're looking to expend $250,000. So that's what I'm trying to get to. What are dates that we would actually have to come up with those funds?
2:01:40 So there'd be the two options for the turf area. One's 90, one's probably 25 or 30 or less. If it's grass, grass is much less expensive than synthetic turf. And then the other one was really just obligating some future dollars in like 2015 at this point. Takes a year to get a contract and then a year to expend the money. And then when we're looking at this $396,000,
2:02:12 Here, I would still like to see the previously held money put here so that we can see what money was held aside previously. Does that mean we have to continue to hold it aside? No, but I would like to see what we held aside in previous allocation cycles, and I'd like that placed here. So, anyhow. Good call, Terry. All for the fun notes. You're talking about the obligations maintenance items, or?
2:02:43 Well, you can make a separate line item, but I, you know, previously held monies if we put it in a reserve fund, whatever we want to put it as, contingency. But I would like to be shown that in 20, last year, 2012 fall, I think it was about $249,000. And then in the spring funding, there was a smaller amount of money, $40,000-some-odd-thousand, I think. And I would like that.
2:03:14 just be listed here somewhere, and it would not be underneath annual obligation or maintenance. Well, it would be an obligation. It's a reserve fund. And then if we choose to use those funds for something else, then that's great, but I would just like it to be shown that these monies were held aside at some other point in time. Especially because it's in our priorities, too. It's nice to make sure we know how much we held in the past and how much we can hold now. I agree, Teri. That's important.
2:03:45 And it isn't an obligation. It's just something that we did at one point in time, and we just need to make sure that we keep that. I think it'll just be a separate section, I think. I have no problem with it being a separate section. Yeah, you just identify it as a separate line item. That's fine. You'll actually see it in the next month's packet as well, available funds. We've actually got it spelled out in yellow. I think where it helps in this is that it shows people that, you know, these were already kind of set aside.
2:04:14 And I know, you know, when we look at the... Yeah, because it's a little different. I mean, we don't have this form doing too many things. This is really just talking about just what the town's proposing to apply for and then, you know, a little bit of the obligation. But I get your point, though. That's fine. It should be in both places, but anyhow. And if we're looking at, if we are looking at attachment F, is that what the council's looking at? Is that... Because attachment F does roll this form together and... Yes, F.
2:04:41 That's what I'm looking at. So we can actually address a little bit of that now. I mean, number five and number six, you know, we put in, based on your last discussion, if there's a need, we can certainly talk about it now at the next agenda item about, you know, preparing feasibility master plans for those projects. Because that would be something that town would have to spend some time researching. So we would need some at least direction.
2:05:08 Some feedback from Council if that's something that they want to move forward with. And then number six was the venue acquisition, which I believe is what Commission requested as well, pending release of the final study and the report and so forth, and then moving that forward as well. So that would just need specific time to prepare exactly what that application would include. So they're the two items that we've just added since, and then we took those items.
2:05:36 Off that were previously there. So we've got one through four I think is pretty consistent. So five and six is probably what we're seeking direction from the Commission on at this time. Today? Today, certainly. Well, because we're asking Council on October 16th what proposed applications you'd like town staff to prepare. You know, we might have a little leeway. We might be able to...
2:06:04 Give it a couple of weeks, but the longer it takes to decide whether we're doing or not doing, it's just less time we're working on them. So if you don't have any clear consensus, that's fine. We can spend a bit more time talking about maybe at the October 22nd workshop we can get a little bit further along with number five, number six. So anyway, it's just the process that we've just got with Council that we want to... I seem to recall the last meeting. Didn't we talk about...
2:06:33 Number five feasibility master plan that we were we would hold do it ourselves. I mean with the initial thing. I think part of that we're going to do our own outreach and stuff. There is going to be staff time that probably is not budgeted. So there's still a need to look at what the potential cost might be. So I would be interested personally in seeing what that potential cost would be in-house and how we would go about doing it in-house.
2:07:02 Versus the cost going out. I just like the idea of going out. I think there's a lot we can do in-house without going out in-house. We already have our master plan. You have the footprints. You have the programs. We have our list of things that we need to do and build. How do we fit those into those potential parks? I think that's what I'm looking at. Did I get that right? Yep. So I would love to see that coming forward. How do we do that?
2:07:34 What's it going to cost us to do it? Yeah, so I think that the next phase there is really determine what the outcome of the process is and whether it's satisfactory for Commission and Council, what it's going to deliver is going to be beneficial for you.
2:07:49 Right. I mean, so when we get to council, there's actually some action, you know, for that decision-making body to do something with. And I think that's what we've really got to dig down and get to maybe that's October 22nd workshop to understand what the deliverable is. So we're okay leaving it there right now as kind of that placeholder. Is it something that could be, you know, like two different options, I guess, where it's one staff or administrative cost-related and then one for a consultant?
2:08:18 I don't know how you would package it. Well, I think we just sort of needed to come back as a package from staff and how do we get there knowing that we would like to take this on as a commission and not hire it out. How do we get there? So I think we can certainly do that. We can meet with planning staff to figure out who would be the planner to help with that as well as in engineering.
2:08:46 Because it's really a combination and then facilitate discussion with the commission and the public about really just kind of re-looking at the master plan that was done in 08. The environmentalism wasn't done until the year before last. So the information in agenda item 8 really provides that. The questions that were presented to move forward with, it does identify all the facilities that were desired and the existing facilities at each park to really...
2:09:15 Put a matrix together and figure out what the final facilities are. I think having the extra time until the 22nd to actually, you know, go over that because it was a pretty big packet of information that you put together there. But it's really helpful to reread, like, the park master plan and looking at the number, the amount of acreage that is recommended that we should have and RecStrats, too. And if anybody desires a hard copy of the master plan, we can certainly buy one and provide one to you.
2:09:42 I think we all have one, don't we? Because we just went through all those plans. Yeah, that's right. We didn't want to make it redundant for you with the packet, but it was really good. It did spell out really clear recommendations. We're right there at that time. We've actually done a lot. We've done two of them. There's three more to go. We just want to make sure that there's sufficient scope, there's sufficient support, finances to conduct this type of analysis.
2:10:07 And so that's what you would be bringing back was what staff time would cost to do something like that. Well, some various alternatives probably, you know. Okay. One of the ideas might be to kind of look at a consultant, bring in a consultant and maybe just to talk about what the process could be. You know, that could be something that you might want to consider as well. It might be a hybrid. What we could do, what they could do. Okay. So, you know, I think it might be. Yeah, it's probably one, you know, we've dealt with a couple of parks consultants over the years. One was...
2:10:37 With Steve Noel and the other really is Brett Long. Both of them have a different approach. Brett Long did a great job with Whitmore Track. I've actually talked to him previously about the tennis court community center part. He had some different ideas there, so he might be a good one to discuss it with. He's also affiliated with a little bit different firm now, so he's got a little more resources if desired.
2:11:05 But I think at the next meeting we can have some bigger maps, we can put stickies on the paper so that they kind of have the size of different facilities and have a good discussion. Yeah, I think it'd be worth seeing those options laid out.
2:11:35 And I don't know, actually, without knowing what, how do we bring this forward? Are we talking about number six now? Yeah. Yep. I think it's really, you can see the description's pretty vague. You know, it's pending, really, the release of the final report. Approval from, you know, counsel to staff. So, I mean, that's moving forward. I mean, that will be in front of commission, you know, November 5th.
2:12:07 at that time, and Measure U as well. So I mean, it's coming out, it's looking at releasing, and it would be in front of Council that third week of November. So we're, you know, we're a little bit ahead of it right now, but again, it's just something for consideration, right? It's just really all you're saying is that, you know, you're recommending staff at least consider it, prepare it, and look at submitting it, regardless of the outcome of that application. But what it really comes down to at this point is there's only one event site that's up for sale.
2:12:37 And that would be what is called the Sandwich Woodside or the Pollard or whatever. Well, there's other opportunities with the foundation site as well. So there's two different things. One of the concerns is that, you know, within that event feasibility study is there was really no information on constraints as far as
2:13:05 Acquiring property, what the cost was going to be to actually put something on that property. And there were some numbers as far as operations would go. But as far as the costs of what acquiring Sam's Wood site would be or acquiring having to build a facility at the foundation would be.
2:13:30 Which Evan has, you know, brought some, is working on some information and I know he brought some information back with this brunt structure so that could come back but we really don't have any of those numbers other than this is, you know, kind of ideally what could happen at each site and what the operations could possibly be and how many events and what size events could be held at either site. Which does help us but it doesn't give us that final ability to actually put an application forward.
2:13:56 Excuse me, what agenda item are we speaking to at this particular point? We are on agenda item six. Number five.
2:14:11 We're still in order. We're talking about item six. Item six, agenda five. I'm getting a little confused. I feel that staff is being taken initiative and planning ahead and thinking that we might want to put something forward and I think that I would be okay with them.
2:14:33 Bringing that information forward would be great, yeah, because that's information. I have some comments, but I'd like to hear public first. Give us your feel. HPS has a two-part contract. They've just completed the first part, basically. There are three options, one of which is fiscal, one of which talks about recommendations, organizations, those kinds of things, and then a timeline. Those are options.
2:15:03 I don't believe we would want them to look at their huge structure, but perhaps it's an opportunity that they could look at the wood side and look at Evans and do their own independent assessment and give us some information that's usable. You know, it's already funded out of UNR. They've only spent half the money. So if that could be directed in some manner so that it considers what we think we here in Mammoth need and is doable.
2:15:34 Because they could address some of the funding sources and some of those other things they haven't looked at so far. This is kind of what Sean and I talked briefly over at the event coalition. Maybe we have an opportunity to get some of the information we need. We all think we like the wood side and the sprung structure kind of makes sense now. But how does all of this stuff fit together? Maybe the second part of that contract can be structured such that it could do that.
2:16:04 And that might provide, maybe the town submissions a little early, but in terms of the current funding cycles, it's kind of hard to make it work together. If I could make some comments, and I agree, Don. You know, I had two different town councilors say, hey, let's get a proposal, at least on the books, for the Woodside.
2:16:25 And while, you know, I continue to remain that that is a very, that's a great venue. This fund structure, the more I learn about it, has enormous potential. I think that an application today is a little bit premature for exact funds for, however, let's go to our 22nd workshop. This one I think that we really should take forward.
2:16:50 Not ask staff to prepare any specific proposal at this time. Item number five, the feasibility master plan for parks. I'd love to see what you guys come up with, with what it would take to facilitate our discussion for that review. But for number six, you know, I almost even want to wait. If Measure R doesn't even close until middle of November, I'm almost prepared to even wait until our November 5th meeting to direct staff.
2:17:20 H-Use, H-Use. H-Use. What kind of library would we look at for options and all? They're going to be months off now if they start working on those options and trying to get us information, which wouldn't impact the R-U kind of current timeline at all. They won't provide us anything that's useful in that kind of a time frame. I can answer that. Probably true.
2:17:44 True, but at the same time, I think what's, you know, what I'm actually really appreciating here with regard to an event venue acquisition is I almost want to even just run an application through the gauntlet to see what's going to come out of it. So this is going to take two or three processes. And I hope we get more of the public participation with regard to what the event venues. And, you know, as I've had a chance to speak with some of you individually and others as well,
2:18:13 There may be some horse trading that needs to happen with some town-owned properties in order to fully pay for what we are going to be considering an event venue, whether it's multiple or single locations. So again, what I'd like to propose is that let's go into our 22nd meeting. Let's perhaps even be prepared to go to our November 5th meeting without necessarily requesting a specific application come forward.
2:18:42 I would actually like to come out of the November 5th meeting requesting an application come forward. It may not end up being the final application that goes the distance, but there's going to need to be a lot of town-owned properties that I feel are going to need to be considered to acquire, actually, at the end of the day, end up with a part that the town owns that is designated for events or multiple. It seems to me
2:19:14 Oh, sorry. I was just going to say, I would like to see this kept on here as a placeholder to get it in front of council so they can give the, you know, their approval for the town staff to move forward with an application. It could always be, you know, withdrawn if we're not at that point, but I just, I think this needs to get on the council's agenda and become a, you know, and bring it before the public, and I think this is a good way to start that process. I would agree with that. And, you know, I did meet with Evan.
2:19:43 and go out and look at the site that they're looking at putting the sprung structure. I would love to do the same thing with Sam's wood site because my understanding is there's two properties there. And then with the information that we have with the special events study, I think that that will help me when I'm looking at it and talking about it and things like that. Maybe what this event acquisition, venue acquisition application needs to be.
2:20:12 is no more than an application for R and U both to determine how much this year we want to set aside out of the fund for a event venue acquisition when it can happen. I think that would be the direction to bring this thing forward as an application without an amount to give us an opportunity to say, okay, this year we're going to put
2:20:35 $400,000 aside for the acquisition of an event. The only thing I'd like to say with regard to that is that we're not going to assign a dollar amount now. However, even coming out of, and I just want to throw this out there, I don't want to lock ourselves into not throwing out a dollar amount because at some point somebody's going to need to throw a piece of pasta against the wall. And that dollar number that we throw against the wall
2:21:04 We'll dissect it from that point. I think we're all saying the same thing. Pat, I don't think you've had a chance to talk yet, but I think we're kind of saying the same thing that what we're looking for here as a placeholder. I definitely support that, and I think we should be looking towards Measure R&U funds for that. I'm really reluctant until I know a little bit more about it, of swapping property, especially looking at the master plan.
2:21:30 where it talks about how we need more acreage and not less acreage or a trade of acreage. So I fully support Measure R and U funds being set aside to start amassing an amount. And that's kind of what we started to do with the monies that we held aside, understanding that there's other phases.
2:21:51 of the track. There's, you know, there's things that we want to do with our parks and there's special event venues that, you know, so there's monies that, like, okay, look, we've got to start putting some money aside for these things. And then our goal now is we've got to, you know, decide what those priorities are to set that money aside for. And I just don't want town staff to be less scrambling, you know, when we get the, you know, final event study and all of a sudden it's, oh, we need to do this. Yeah, I would agree. Actually,
2:22:20 One of the items I was going to send to Stu, it's been on my to-do list, I didn't get to it today, was to place on the Measure U committee agenda a discussion item for how to begin setting, and it was working on a capital reserve. So I think exactly what you're talking about is we're all in line. We know we want to get these things. We want to start moving on them. What we need to do is start setting aside some sort of a capital reserve which will allow us to do that.
2:22:49 Anyway, Stu, I don't have to send you an email, right, if you'll add it to our agenda, because I do think it's appropriate discussion, and I think everybody's feeling the same way. It's like, you know, I guess personally, I look at sometimes we do a few too many studies. We've got a lot of studies, and sometimes we're looking at studies that are really not very fruitful, or we send them back for more work or whatever, and I would like to see us start thinking about things we can touch, more parks, more space, following you.
2:23:18 Following the master plan, not trading off park properties, but adding to them, and I do agree, we need that, plus our facilities, so UNR, that's what they're for, and I think it would make the public very happy. Okay, so then we're good with the comments we've made on the fall award timeline. Stu, do you need anything more than our consensus on this?
2:23:44 For the whole package, if we're okay with the timeline, like you said, we made the change to the funding priorities, the application evaluation material and town funding applications maintenance items, it could just be a motion to approve those items and we could make those changes and that's what will be submitted to council next week. That's satisfactory. Understanding that we've made the change to number six, not being event venue acquisition, but setting aside some funds for future events.
2:24:14 Capital investment. I mean, we could just be that general. It's just capital investment. I don't think we want to say that it's necessarily exactly the events. Right. I think it's just really, like you've said, you've got funds aside already, so it could just be capital, future capital investment, very general. That's what we would submit next week to... I'm not sure if I'm comfortable with that. I mean, I do want it to say event venue acquisition, because I really do want to keep it focused on that.
2:24:40 I think that may be very appropriate on the U side, and I'm not sure that that is very appropriate on the U side. Okay. Event, venue, acquisition, I thought we were going to leave that on number six, but as far as a reserve, there's not anything that's specified as far as... I think we're talking about two different things. Are we talking about two different things? Yeah, so I just want to make sure, yeah, so number six, did we change that language, which is kind of what I was saying, which is I think what Sean mentioned, to future investment.
2:25:07 Or leave it as event venue acquisition. Understanding that the reserve is going to be listed on that section. So you'll see a specific reserve. But the reserve isn't, I guess what I'm saying is the reserve shouldn't be necessarily spelled out for anything in particular right this moment because we aren't there.
2:25:27 It's just identifying that you have a reserve, or you've set aside funds. Yeah, the reserve, though, doesn't require an application. That's just however much money we choose not to spend. Sitting on $249,000, right? I mean, that's just what's there. This would be specific to, unless we pulled it later, this would be specific to an event venue.
2:25:46 I have no problem if you leave it as an event venue because you have the feasibility master plan for parks. So there's, you have both of those that are going to be. One is going to kind of speak to the parks facilities, one's going to speak to an events venue, which are kind of the two biggies that we have out there. I mean, thank you. I prefer that. I don't have a problem with that. Well, then make the motion. Oh, that we leave the event venue acquisition. No, make the motion that we accept the packet. That we accept the packet. Okay.
2:26:13 Approved the 2013 Measure of Fall War Timeline. Funding priority is application evaluation material in town, funding applications, and maintenance item. Thank you, Stu. That's exactly how I was going to say it. We'll get a couple amendments. I appreciate that. Can I just stay with the couple amendments that were given? Yes. Having the reserve shown and then the funding priorities. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion?
2:26:43 Who was, sorry, I didn't get a first and second. Sorry. I'll be first. That's a second. Got you. Steve and I doing double duty. Yeah. Okay. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Unanimous. Are we moving on to agenda item number eight now? Number eight. So we didn't do number six. We did nothing to do six.
2:27:13 And we're not going to work, we're bringing number six and seven to a future meeting, is that what we're doing? Well, it depends on, you've tackled a little bit of the priority of eight, which was that master plan and the feasibility for our park. So, you know, our understanding is that we'll put together a, you know, kind of a list of alternatives, how the best way to proceed with the feasibility. So, really what we're looking at with this item here is essentially the structure of the October 22nd workshop.
2:27:43 And Pete was a big part of this. So we kind of rifled through the master plan, which is the town's adopted document for our parks facilities. And we went through and highlighted the most relevant pages and also found, thanks to Pete digging through a lot of files, the big office cleanup, found some pretty cool stuff. But we did find that Community Centre Conceptual Plan from 2007 and that Mammoth Creek Park Facilities Project Site Plan from 1999.
2:28:12 We were able to find some site plans for the commission to review. And then we went through, which is what Commissioner Agnich referenced, we went through the most relevant documents and figures and tables pertinent to the discussion. So again, it's really trying to frame the discussion for October 22nd. I don't believe we need to take action on any other items apart from the one we've just done.
2:28:37 And I guess Pete's plan was to kind of pull some of these together, put them on some larger scale maps, do a little bit of kind of a workshop format for it, I think is probably the most productive at this point. So I think that was really that item that we wanted to discuss. I'm looking at the... The recommendation is really what we're going to look at on page 4 or 5. So review plans and recommendations from the Doctor of Parks and Rec Master Plan, which we could...
2:29:07 Discuss here, or we can tackle on October 22nd. Scope of work on a feasibility master plan, which again, I think we've got some direction and we can certainly discuss further. We've tackled number three, which was the application. Number four, I think we briefly discussed at that workshop with Council, and that was, you know, once we've got these feasibility plans done and we understand the use, how do we get them built, how do we get them enhanced, what...
2:29:34 You know, what's our strategy in regards to funding to actually implement these feasibility plans? Again, we just don't want to march on down and create these plans to get these things done, understanding that if they don't fit in to measure our application or you, then how do we get those funds set aside and how do we get general fund monies for those facilities? So those were really the action items that Pete and I felt were the most pertinent. Pete, you had any other talk about?
2:30:07 So I think it's really kind of laying out that discussion of how much kind of setting the steps going forward for the feasibilities for each one of the parks or each one of the properties the town owns or they were really laid out in the master plan. So it's not regurgitating the master plan. We've got that. We need to revisit it. It's been a few years since we really looked at it. You guys looked at it briefly last year, a few months ago. But it's really diving in and looking at the
2:30:36 The actual property boundaries, what was proposed then, what the commission feels is the right purpose now, and where those bigger facilities fit in to develop some kind of financing plan long term. Because it's not, you know, some of the projects are so big, it's not going to just be Measure U, Measure R, it's going to be maybe some grants, maybe there's some other funding mechanisms that need to be developed to
2:31:06 Engage property owners to see how much of a commitment there is to build some of those things. That was really it. So a lot of those items, you know, I think that it's more of a workshop setting. It's going to be more productive than it's certainly any, you know, policy. We have a policy direction from the commission right now, which was number three. So it's really up to commission how much time you want to spend on this item here, understanding that we'll have a good chance to review a lot of the package here.
2:31:39 Again, we just, we want to make it a little bit easier for you putting the right documents in front of you so we can kind of go through them. And my understanding, if I can just throw out there, was that specifically the master plans that I really wanted to work on were going to be the Community Center, Mammoth Creek Park, and also the Whitmore area. I do want to understand the bell-shaped parcel, but my recollection was that we were going to, the three parks that
2:32:09 There are already parks that I wanted to review, and not necessarily in this order, but were community center, Mammoth Creek Park East and West, and Whitmore is what I'm remembering. Those were the ones, but I think that we need to understand the bell-shaped parcel on what our restrictions are on there, what can actually happen there, what, you know, what maybe the constraints are so that we even know whether it's even something to even think about.
2:32:36 I agree. No, I want to throw that into the mix. I was just actually talking about plans that have already, that just need to be reviewed, that are already in existence for those three parks. I wouldn't necessarily call the Bell Street Park still a park yet. No, but we asked for the footprint. It's open space. Yeah. It pretty much makes it a park. Okay, fine. And so we do have some relative...
2:33:02 You know, the mapping itself probably needs to be updated as far as where the wetland boundary is. But we have a, you know, we've got a map that shows the wetland boundary. It was a quick look when Trey Tackleberry was here. So it's been some time ago and it was done just in the fall. But it's a good one to look at. It does require a special study to do really anything there. So we couldn't just go out and clear the space to create a venue without doing a special study.
2:33:30 because of the open space designation and the requirement for a special study that was designated by council. So the consultant recommendation? Yeah. But I think that would help us to even see, you know, if they're able to do anything or, you know. I have a question about just one specific Mammoth Creek Park facilities project site plans we have here.
2:34:00 Is this the one that has been taken out of the EIR that was started? Because the layout before that was different than the one that came out there because we included so much in that knowing that some of it would be available and some wouldn't. Correct. So the one with RBF, that one showed everything that could go there. Basically that we could shoehorn in to the five acres.
2:34:29 The other site plan was the one we did when we thought we were going to do, you know, a smaller, just basically an overall recreation facility, similar to the one at Tahoe, that's what that footprint is. Right. We had one with the rink there that was going to be six feet below grade with kind of a pair of seating all the way around it. And that's the one, the first one, the black and white.
2:34:58 Exhibit 3-3. The first one, yeah, which is the Rec Center, the Ice Rang, Quantum Hall, all the doors, yeah, it's a busy little back. Yeah, well, it's a kind of scale, I really can't tell what it's showing, that was just my question. And then there was also discussion, and I don't know where all this information went, at one point in time, this was quite a few years ago, is we kind of went through each park and said, you know, what is each park kind of best served in, like, Mammoth Creek Park was...
2:35:26 Really kind of more of a passive park and, you know, it wasn't, that's kind of what we were looking at. You had the kids play area and then they were looking at the other area that wasn't necessarily a big building. It was more of a maybe an amphitheater or something like that. So, but anyways, those were just discussions and that's what we're looking at is to see what our options are. So, anyhow. So, you know, so we're looking at bringing this, building all this and bringing it.
2:35:58 Some comments and discussions for the 22nd. Is that what we're looking at? I'm sorry. Yeah, I think that that's exactly what we're talking about. Okay. I apologize. I must have missed that date when we were talking about it because I will be out of time. For the 22nd? Yeah. So I don't know if there'll be future meetings to discuss this or should I just forward my comments? I would forward comments. We are not done.
2:36:24 At our last meeting, it seems to me, we decided it would be another three months probably before we got all the way through our prioritization process, and that's what this is part of, so no, we won't be done. And what time are we meeting on the 27th? I don't know, the 22nd, Stu, what's our meeting time? 1 o'clock right now. Oh, 1 o'clock. Because we've got that workshop that we bumped in there. Oh, no, sorry. 2 to 4. 2 to 4. 2 to 4. What Pete and I were saying, though, Pete might be able to...
2:36:54 Elaborate. It might be advantageous to, you know. It might be advantageous to have Brett Long maybe come to that meeting as well. So, you know, a few years ago we did get a grant to look at the tennis court evaluation of replacements, the type of court surface, the orientation of the two proposed courts. And so we did some soils work, we did some survey work, and we were going to do some additional work. We really didn't, I did get a scope of work from
2:37:24 Brett Long to look at that additional work. He was never authorized to do that. But we could have him. He had some interesting ideas with that. He was certainly had some good ideas out at Whitmore Track. We could have him come maybe on the 22nd as well if he's available. As opposed to paying a consultant to come at that time? Can we just get the information? Essentially, yeah, he'd be more of a time and materials agreement just to come down for the day.
2:37:53 From that we could define what his role might be, if any, going forward with the feasibility discussions of each of the parks. But he really is an expert on facilities, park facilities. He doesn't design buildings or anything else. He really just does park facilities and really active park facilities primarily. Just a thought. It might be something that happens at the 22nd, but we should really consider trying to get that third-party professional input.
2:38:23 on our efforts moving forward. I hate to see us just spin wheels and, you know, we're moving in a different direction and, you know, they could come in and I think it's probably a good investment just for the two hours just to really give us that, you know, professional information. Can we get that information? I guess that's what we're looking at to try to gather all that information. I have no problem with them being there for the two hours. For me on the 22nd, I think really helpful at this point is going to be a map of large enough scale that shows all town-owned properties.
2:38:52 and what it can or can't be used for. You know, if you look at the map in here, it's of such a scale. There's a bunch of open space that I happen to know is of little to no value to us because it can't be used for anything. So it would be nice so that we're all up to speed on exactly what it is, the town. You know, we talk about horse trading and stuff. What are all the town-run properties?
2:39:15 Yeah. Including the shop properties and all of that. So I can get a handle on that too. Is the 22nd the appropriate time to pay for a consultant to come down or would it be better for us to talk about these things first and then actually have somebody come at a later date? I just hate to spend money for someone to come down when we're not necessarily at that point. I don't know. Because that's what you're looking at getting a Measure R application through for. Yeah, it's what would probably help us and what we're looking for and what application we'd like.
2:39:44 It doesn't have to be the 22nd. I just think it'd be very valuable to help us all actually pull this together. I don't disagree with that. I'm just not sure that we're there. I'm assuming that that would come out of contractual services piece of an existing budget somewhere. What Stuart and I were just talking about was if it, so we have, I think we have about $12,000 left in that budget for community center park measure outs actually in this fiscal year.
2:40:13 Went this far. So that... A what? So we had a $25,000 measure of our award. We've expended some of that money regarding the test court surfacing. What's the best alternative which... I guess this comes back to my... kind of to the $300,000 is that, you know, there should be no money left in a previous...
2:40:41 Ramp it was given because it comes back to Measure R. And if we want to use that for something else again, then it has to be reallocated to a new project. So it's for the community center park tennis court discussion. That's what that money was set aside for. And we've done two phases of it. We've done soils work, and we've got a recommended structural section for the replacement tennis courts.
2:41:09 I guess this is... The part that we haven't done yet is to... The other part of that was to really re-look at the work that Steve did to look at the orientation of future tennis courts, the two additional courts, on how they might fit and be most efficient at that site. And those are the types of information that we would like to see for the 22nd, because I didn't see that one in here. And so if we could get all of that information...
2:41:38 You know, brought forward, but I really, truly, I'm sorry, I have a concern that we still have money that we're remarking from two years ago for something else because it's being spent at the same park. It's the same, in my mind, it's the same project. It's really looking at what do we do at Community Center Park from the, you know, the tennis court replacement, tennis court expansion, or do we do nothing there? Steve, do you have something to add on that? Yeah, I do.
2:42:06 Putting on a different hat. As a landscape architect, as a recreational planner, as a guy that's worked for the town of Mammoth Lakes in the past in a planning capacity, recreation planning, I think that Peter and Stu are bringing forth a pretty good idea to get a professional third party in early to help you to brainstorm. You've got a wonderful master plan to build off of. There are suggestions within the master plan.
2:42:34 But getting in that professional, being able to bounce off of him ideas, thoughts, and procedures, I think might end up being money well spent. How much money is that going to cost? He's probably going to charge you $100 an hour. Are we talking two hours or are we talking travel time? Travel time. That'll be a travel time for Tahoe. It's a lot better than the $100,000 that we were considering.
2:43:03 Yeah. So, you know, initially his proposal to really do the park, he wanted like 20 grand. Basically, I negotiated him down, but like I said, he wasn't authorized because he wasn't in last fiscal year's budget. He was in this one in the capital improvement program that did go to the commission. There was a line item for that work. But essentially, that's what I would propose that the funding come from. We don't have extra money with our current budgeting that we've got.
2:43:34 Town. And you're saying this is from the 25 grand from two years ago? Yeah, it was specific to expanding the tennis courts at the community center and designing a structural section for the tennis courts themselves, the replacement courts. Are we going to get any resistance for money that was, you were saying it was designated for tennis courts, but we're actually wanting to use this money for a consultant for all of our...
2:44:02 Parks, Plus, that's the discussion we're having. That's why Stu and I brought that up as an option. Well, I didn't know that money was available. Maybe we shouldn't worry about the funding part and just worry about the concept. I mean, conceptually, do you want people to, you know, I think conceptually we do. Is the 22nd the right time? You know, I guess that's, let's see if he's available. Yeah, that's it.
2:44:27 I'd like to get it going as soon as possible. And if you come back and say, you know, he's not available, you know, we decide that we really want him, then that's when we start playing around with the dates. And maybe he needs to know that this is the very beginning of the process so that, you know, if everyone's just throwing ideas out. And I guess once again, you know, I understand that we're at this point. And I guess I would even say that then.
2:44:54 I know we, I don't really want to stop this process because I want it to go forward. But we have a new measure our application that you're going to bring us some ideas forward. Who is this? What are they going to bring to the table? And how can we move this forward? Because I think that we are at a point where, you know, a facilitator could possibly very well help this process out. And I agree that we have great plans and it's a matter of how we bring it together. But what we, our conversation that we just had earlier is that you're going to bring us
2:45:23 Some information back on a Measure R application that's going to go forward. Now the concern about that is that's going to be January before something like that is awarded. You're saying that there's money from a previous allocation. If we're specifically only talking about tennis courts and doing that, then I guess that that would be possibly appropriate. But this is once again comes to my concern that we're holding monies for previous allocations. The monies weren't spent.
2:45:51 And then we're bringing it forward and changing what that application was and using that money elsewhere at a later time. I have a problem with that. So I'm not saying that this isn't a good idea. I just, you know, we've got a process that we need to look at. And part of the reason that we didn't kick him off was really because there's been this discussion about Community Center Park as a whole and, you know, what is the mix and what other number of courts there.
2:46:22 You know, I'm not one that wants to spend a lot of money on consultants doing things over again. I get, you know, I call it churning, and we've talked about that before. So, that's why he hasn't been kicked off, to finish that work at Community Center Park and the tennis court, the details on the tennis court and the additional two tennis courts, because that was part of that. So, from my standpoint, if we bring him down as the person hired,
2:46:51 to represent the potential tennis courts, and he happens to be able to answer some other questions for us at the same time on other issues. I have no issue with that. So I think what we'll do is we'll get in touch with Brett, we'll get a quote in his time, see what he's available, we'll get those details, and we'll get back as soon as we can to you. Well, I think he's going to be here on the 22nd, but you need an answer now as to whether those monies can be expended and whether you're going to ask him to be here on the 22nd.
2:47:23 So I guess there's a consensus with Bill's comments. So that's the question. What I'm saying is that I'm comfortable with that. If we ask him questions outside of the scope and he answers them, I have no problem with that. So I'm comfortable using the money for that. Do you want to do this as a consensus or do you want someone to do a motion? I think somebody needs to make a motion. I'll bring up the motion. Stu, what's my motion again?
2:47:56 Essentially that we're using funds that have already been allocated for tennis court planning planning to get him here to help us understand that. Community Center in general, I think. Yeah, it's Community Center Park. Yeah, existing measure are awarded funds for Community Center planning. And I guess the question then once again, because you just said Community Center, are we going to be able to ask about other parks and are we looking at other parks?
2:48:26 As well, are we focusing on Community Center? Well, I think we're looking at three parts is kind of what we're looking at. You know, if worst comes to worst, let's figure out what it costs. My God, if there's money somewhere, I'll find the money somewhere. But I just think we've just got to stop spinning wheels and get some traction. We do need to stop spinning wheels except for you guys, you had mentioned a couple different people. So I guess this is pretty much...
2:48:49 Whatever our option was for Measure R, we're tying ourselves into this person and this process. No, I don't think so. Just notice that we're paying for it. Oh, okay. So pose your... So the scope of... Just going back from my memory on the scope of work that I have from him, essentially it had two site visits and doing some analysis and then coming back with some products of the park itself. So this really could be the site visit commission discussion.
2:49:18 Part of that scope. And the notice perceived would just be for that element so that we're not continuing to do work that we may or may not want. Just buying us time for a couple of hours, I think is what we're trying to do. I mean, we've been doing, Teri's been doing a great job leading this effort for several months. We're at a point where we need something else. I'm just concerned how this is being laid out. But I'm just, you know, I had not realized that we have...
2:49:43 I mean, that predates my time on the commission, so I hadn't realized that we had someone engaged for this purpose. That just reminds us one more reason why we do need a report that outlines what money has not been spent. Well, that's what we're doing the whole reconciliation. Okay, I know, you're on. We're doing it. So your motion is that you use our community center consultant for two hours or three hours of his time for the meeting on the 22nd.
2:50:14 If we happen to ask him questions outside of that, well, so be it. Yeah. Is that motion? That's your motion. Okay, that's my motion. I'm fine with that. I'm glad that we could. I'm getting assistance in writing wordsmithing my motions here. I'll second it. Thank you, Pat. I have a motion and a second. Does anybody understand? Any further discussion?
2:50:41 All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Aye. And I'm not opposed to the process. I'm just opposed to how it's coming about right this moment. We're just trying to respond. I understand that. We're just taking on it. At this point in time, I'm not going to let it go past within 10 minutes. So let's move on to Manager's Report and Commissioner Report.
2:51:07 I do want to say item number whatever we skipped over. Steve, what did we skip over? Six. So one of the items on six, which was our summer analysis, was just kind of a recommendation to the staff to convene and work with our programming subcommittee, Commissioner Truax and Commissioner Turner to kind of go over a lot of our analysis so we can kind of wait for the commission.
2:51:32 Weighs in on that in November. I don't think you need to do that. We have a standing committee. We do? Yep. So anytime staff feels it necessary to meet with a standing committee, unless one of you feels differently, I have no problem with the staff calling that committee together and meeting with them. And we can forward any comments that we have to them. I do have one question since we're talking about that. You had the multiple facilities calendar, and you know, you have your...
2:51:58 The active net. Yeah, but you basically have the crib notes down here that tells us what goes to what. Can you actually do this by facility as opposed to month? Yes. Because if you did it by facility and then what happened within that facility and then dates, that's going to say a lot more to me than this is hard to read. We looked at multiple ways to do it without cutting down too many trees. This was probably the way to kind of roll. Oh, okay.
2:52:22 Yeah, I mean, we can pull multiple reports, so maybe we can show them to that comedian, maybe come back in November and show you. I guess I don't see that it should use any more paper than we have here if you're going by each facility, because the facility used, then these are the things, because I think that'll help us in our discussion later, too, because it's really hard for me to read this and then go down, okay, ID6, and let's see, what was that, you know, so.
2:52:46 We can PDF them too as well, right? Anyhow, that would be really helpful. We don't have to cut down trees. But that was one of my... But you're right, but reporting on our facilities is really, you know, and I think that's really what we're really excited about. So understanding who's there, what they're using it for, you know, we're tracking quantifiable data, which is really important, and we're really excited. So just quickly on the monthly report, that was my first item to working forward with our program committee.
2:53:12 We had two co-ed dodgeball teams sign up, so they're out there beating themselves up as we speak. We're trying to get the flag football going, so we're going to just continue off of that until we can get some people. Go ahead. I had a question on the dodgeball, but go ahead. Yeah, I'm sorry. And then the sand volleyball tournaments this weekend, so hopefully the weather improves, doesn't snow on it too badly. Roller rink, we're pretty much ending.
2:53:42 That operation on Saturday, just looking at the weather coming ahead, it's probably just fortuitous that we just kind of cut that off on Saturday. So we're not going to continue Saturday operations, we're just going to do special events. I think tomorrow night we have the Bishop Group coming up, the Bishop Street Lockie Group coming up, so we're just going to kind of do that as on demand.
2:54:00 Halloween, obviously at the rink, October 25th, that's our big one, that's Weather Committee. Yeah, and if the weather does change, boy, try and get notice out as early as possible. I remember last year there just wasn't enough notice. That's right, so the back-up is Community Centre, which will be what we did last year, so we'll try and give at least everybody a week. Yeah, I just, you know, if you're predicting weather, you know, if it looks like it's going to be clear, let's keep it there, but I remember there was a lot of confusion last year. Yeah, very typical. Yeah. Thank you.
2:54:26 Tree lighting ceremony, that first Friday in December, again, December 6th, and we already got the reimbursement check back from the county, how about that? I know we spent months with that group last year and we sent them, and I think in the same week we got the check back, so new people probably help. And what's interesting here, so I'm actually wrapping up that spreadsheet that's...
2:54:53 That we issued 37 permits. We looked at about 40 events. So we've actually kind of calculated the town's involvement with those special events. So I'm trying to put that together for November. I think it'll be a good discussion on events, what the town's committing to. So you'll appreciate that. It's 11 by 17. It's awfully small, but I might have to make it bigger somehow.
2:55:15 Measure R, Measure U, Reconciliation's going well. Elena's wrapping up Measure U, and we're kind of rolling into Measure R, so that process is going well. And then she's also, as we mentioned last night at the MLTSC, she's going to be working with Steve on that as well, so you'll have kind of a separate subgroup of those funds. So we'll get that done.
2:55:36 Will they come back to the commission at some point in the future? Yeah, so the Measure U, if Measure U is wrapped up in time for the Measure U Application Committee next week, we'll show them that work to date and then we'll hopefully show you what we're up to with Measure R. It looks really good. Thank you. Pete can talk further about the header pipe replacement, but that's complete. The pressure tested it and they're starting to put fluid through that system already, so that's going really well.
2:56:00 I think we're just waiting on some material for the hockey fence, I think that's being fabricated, kind of wrapped up in the next kind of week or so, we'll get that up. I think the trailer relocation is Monday? Sorry, Monday, then it'll take a week or so to build a ramp and get the electrical hooked up. So we cut a bid for the first one, right, to move the trailer, it was 19. So the council did reject the bids the other day, it was 19,000 plus 5,500 to paint it. We just got quotes.
2:56:31 $3,100 to move it, and then we've got some installation to do. So we'll stay within that $12,000 budget. So there we go. So we're going to make that work. Bleachers are being installed. And down at Whitmore, actually, while we're moving there, we've got a tournament this Sunday, a Mammoth Bishop tournament, and then the following Sunday as well. So we're utilizing that facility.
2:56:54 Very well utilised. The problem that we're facing down there is that we've got people there all day, so there's no real amenities, concessions. We've got two toilets, so we're inviting some local groups to come down to sell some hot dogs and drinks just to keep everybody fed during the day. And we'll probably have to look at that in the future, how we want to address that facility, you know, like we did with Shady Rest, but for right now we're just trying to make sure that we've got some cold drinks and some shade for people. Isn't that in the phase two of the tax plan? Yeah, that is correct, yeah.
2:57:24 A6 came up a couple of weeks ago, worked with the Mammoth Track Club, did some more footage for them, so that was great. We did put some signs on that facility down there, if you've been down there with a ride on the gate in regards to the field turf and who can get on the field. Event feasibility, so we've got that small group convening, Bill Taylor just kind of pushed out that scope of work, and that really identifies what Don was talking about too, like what are the next steps, I mean what are the proformers moving forward, right, we need the detail.
2:57:53 I don't know if HVS is the best group. We probably might look at some alternatives. And then that's it. And then just finally down here, you can see those meeting dates, just looking at where the holidays fall. This will come for you at your next meeting to make those changes. You might not want to be able to discuss them at that time, but probably easier during the holiday time to move those outside of those areas. So that's what I had at this time. Thank you, Chair.
2:58:21 Thank you. I can give an update on Sprint. Can I ask a couple questions, Stu? Dodgeball, is there still an opportunity for people to play? Absolutely, yes. Because, unfortunately, I've heard a lot of people say that it was canceled. Right. And so that they didn't sign up because they thought it was canceled. Okay, good. So I can still tell people they can still play? Please do. It's scheduled every Tuesday, Thursday, 6 o'clock. Okay.
2:58:48 All right. And it's their teams? Teams, yep. Okay. Yep. We'll make it as affordable as possible for the teams to get out there and just participate. Okay. So I'll let the folks at least that talk to me know because I know that there's people that did not move forward because they heard it was canceled. Sorry. Because there wasn't.
2:59:07 We never sent anything out officially that we canceled. You know you've got to love where to mouth. You know it's that telephone that goes on small town and it just kind of spreads like wildfire. So anyways, and then on the Measure R Spring Awards, the concrete stain, I thought we tested some other products last year. Did we not? No. No. So we're testing them this year and then you're going to move forward after that? Right. So you're still, are we using the chalk still again this year or how are you testing the chalk?
2:59:35 Going to test a strip, maybe an eight-foot strip on the sunny side over the yellow reflection. So if it does melt out a little bit there, then we don't have to re-chalk it. So you kind of have sections of different stuff and then chalk? It's being delivered to my son's house in Nevada, so we can pick it up up there. Okay. And then another thing about the ice rink, Sprung has provided me some information. They do have a couple different options. They've sent, they're going to send me some more.
3:00:05 Yeah, related to the overall width. Did you get that? 120 feet. Evan gave this to me. Okay, yeah. Okay. I tried to send it to you today, but I got an email. And so he emailed us all those things. Do you guys want this? You have this. He didn't give me a book, but he gave me an email. Probably the same information. So it's 120 foot width. The issue there is the height. It should be a little bit over 45 feet. If it's narrower, so less than 80 feet, then it could be
3:00:33 Around 37 feet in height. They've got a couple of alternatives where you can open up the walls sort of really the ends and have those on rolling walls. So he's going to provide more information about that over the next few days. And he hasn't provided any cost information for that side structure for budget purposes. Okay, let's move on to Commissioner's Reports. Pat, start with you. I don't have a report, but I do have a request for an agent. Okay.
3:01:06 Oh, yeah. I probably can't buy it. Go ahead and give your request since you're on the alarm. Oh. I would just like to request that we have Mammoth Lakes Recreation as an agenda item for discussion, whatever it happens to be, whatever transpired or not. Kind of like, you know, the trails. Yeah. That would be my request. I don't have anything other than I do have kind of one.
3:01:40 Question or comment? There's a group that's looking at raising money for next year's fireworks. And with that, I've asked Stu for some information from the Crowley Lake Fish Camp and last year's information. And when I was looking at all our costs of programs and stuff like that, I saw that the income from the last year's program
3:02:05 Was rolled into that. Is there any way that $4,115 could go towards next year's fireworks? And I would just like to maybe see if we can ask, pose that to council and see if we could do that. And then I, you know, Stu had suggested that maybe he and I go down and talk to the folks at Crowley Lake Fish Camp and see if we can work on something for next year.
3:02:35 Somebody mentioned to me that Rotary was involved in running July 4th. They used to be. Chamber used to be. Rotary used to be. Could they maybe? There are a lot of questions that, you know, because there's an awful lot of money that still needs to be raised, and maybe we need to look at different places because this is not really, this is not something that I don't think we'll ever achieve if the contract stays the same as what it is right now at Crowley Lake Fish Camp. So I think that we need to look at.
3:03:03 Are there any other options? Well, we did redo the whole thing with Crowley Lake Fish Camp two years ago, and they were very amenable to working with us, and actually we sliced about, what, $10,000 off of their end of it? Wow. So they have, you know, backed way off of what we were paying before. We took that way down. Maybe we need to agendize the fireworks, because...
3:03:30 Now you're getting me on my soapbox. It is one of the most successful events the town does. The town keeps saying we want to do events. The total cost for the town is, yeah, you mean for $30,000? Yeah, but after we receive our back, our cost is under $20,000 for an event that brings in 5,000 or 6,000 people. I'm sorry, that's a pretty big bang for your buck.
3:03:56 Do you intend the pun to be in there? Yeah. So you can. That would be fine. I just asked for these groups that are raising the money. Is anybody actually looking at the organizational part of it of getting there? And I got a no. So if it is not going to be something that the town is going to do, we either need to find a group that's going to focus on this or the chamber or the rotary or the lions or rec commission.
3:04:25 But we can't just let it sit out there because it's not going to happen by itself. It is time for it to be. Yeah. These contracts need to start being written. We need to, you know, gain somebody to do the fireworks. So, anyways, I asked for this information and we need to start moving forward with it. So, if the commission wants to take that on, then I'd be more than happy to have some help with that. But, anyhow. Any help you want, I'm willing to give you. Okay, well then, maybe we can all. Fireworks are a passion of mine. So, anyway, so that's my only report.
3:04:54 I just want to say, and I don't know the best way to do this, I am just immensely disappointed with the federal government closing down our local recreation areas. And as a business owner, I can tell you that Yosemite National Park being my number one customer has greatly affected me, and I just want to say on the record how incredibly disappointed I am with the politicians in Washington, D.C. I don't know if this is something that we as a town can send
3:05:22 A letter, you know, like it's going to do any good, right? But at the same time, I don't know if businesses can quantify. You know, we are a destination town with recreation, outdoor recreation being our number one commodity that we sell. And I would say that the closing of the federal recreation facilities that surround us from the campgrounds, which are now closed for the season, you know, what exactly is that financial impact?
3:05:51 That has happened to a community like us. And I just want to say on the record how incredibly disappointed I am with politicians who can't work together. I think it would be wonderful to maybe get some letters as to how it has affected a lot of different people in our community and surrounding communities. And maybe as a town or maybe just individually we...
3:06:14 Put it all together and send it to the government because, you know, I keep hearing how it's not affecting and it's, you know, it's affecting people in a huge manner. In a huge manner. And it's just, yeah, and it could potentially even put people out of business. Yeah. And I just, I don't know how to take that forward, but at the same time, and I don't want town staff to spend time in quantifying exactly how much money has been lost by local businesses.
3:06:41 But I can tell you that personally it's affected us greatly. So maybe it's something we could put in the paper and ask for community outreach in the area and say, hey, you know, we'd like to put this together to send to our government officials and, you know, maybe people can, yeah, chamber might be the place to take that on. Yeah. Mm-hmm. All right. Thank you. Yeah.
3:07:02 Because that's had a huge impact. The only thing I have is I just want to make an announcement that October 24th, it's a Thursday, it's Food Day at the Mammoth High School. It's from 515 to 730. This is the second year for this event. It's being put on by the County Nutrition and Physical Activity Task Force. And it's free. It will have healthy restaurant samples. The Health Science Academy students will...
3:07:28 Be offering some food and doing some things and also some mini health lessons. So it was a nice event last year and I encourage people to attend. Question for agenda items. I think we've got a few. I want to make sure that we are getting a report, but it sounds like that's with regard to money is not spent, but that's all part of. Okay. We're covered. Okay. I move to adjourn. I have a motion. Second. I have a second. Any further discussion?
3:08:04 All those in favor, we are adjourned.