Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 3 hr 15 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
404 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:40 Yeah, Bill's at the light, so we'll wait for Bill, just be a couple minutes. We don't want him running any lights, so he gets here. Oh, nice. I'll order this meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission roll call, please. Mr. Agnish? Here. Mr. Truett? Here. Mr. Turner? Present. Vice Chair Selleck? Yes. Chair Selleck? Yes. I'm half here anyway.
7:55 Public comments. This is the time any member of the public wishes to make a comment on anything that is not otherwise on the agenda. I have a point of clarification on one thing here. The website calendar shows this meeting starting at 2 o'clock, and you have to dig down into the agenda to find out if it started at 1, number 1, and then when you look at the agenda, you go down to the note part of it.
8:23 It says the comments will be limited by the mayor and that the meeting won't go past 10-30. Yeah, the agenda is attached. It's the first attachment under the rule card. It's the formal agenda. That's just the template that Grannicus uses for every meeting. So if you click on agenda, though, that's the real actual agenda. Well, that's the agenda I printed out. I mean, you just print it from Grannicus, but if you click on the attachment, that's the agenda. Okay, I guess I'm just saying if I read it, I don't understand that it's the...
8:52 Commission that's doing this. It seems to lead me to believe that there's American people. That's interesting. So it prints out different from Granicus because it's a... If you just print the page that Granicus shows you, it's just a template that seems to get popped into. But if you click on the link that says agenda, then that's the real agenda. Is there any way of making that clear? Yes, sir. I missed a layperson that doesn't go that deep into the system. Is there any way of making that more clear?
9:18 For users? Because I attach the agenda, and that's always the real agenda. Grannicus is just a template. If we wanted to pay money and have a different template for every single meeting we do, otherwise it just takes the language, and that's why I always attach the agenda. Okay. And I wasn't here last week, and I didn't get to comment, but I guess I don't understand how with Measure U applications, the town can submit applications that can be approved.
9:47 Before anybody else in the community's applications can even be heard. It's actually not the way it happens. What we do is review the potential applications that the town will put in. So if there are too many or any that the committee, and that would be the Measure U committee, feels that they didn't want to come forward at this time, they wouldn't come forward. The applications then go through the same process, the same vetting process as all applications.
10:17 So the approval at the Town Council tomorrow night for Measure U is the approval for the Town to submit those applications? That's correct. Not to approve those applications. That's correct. Thank you very much. They just wanted to avoid staff time if there was an application that had no chance of moving through. The same process is also used with Measure R. Yeah, we do the same thing. Yeah. But there's no approval. It has to go through the same process. And then when it goes through the process, you'll determine whether it actually qualifies for Measure U or not? Yes.
10:46 There should be some of that vetting up front, but yes. Because it appears there's a couple of items, particularly in the Main Street planning, that I can't see how that qualifies at all for Measure R. That'll be the part of the conversation. And it may well get kicked in the first meeting that we have when we go over that exact thing. And council may not move forward tomorrow night as well. Yeah, I'm hard to say.
11:11 Evan, do you want to state which ones or not that you've got concerns about? I would say I would agree with you if you want a public comment. Yeah. Well, Sean, I'll wait and go through the process as these things go along, but certainly the Main Street stuff, and I know you guys have some ideas about this capital investment fund, but traditionally when you look at municipal projects, people bond.
11:40 to do capital projects because they know that usually the cost of a capital project costs more than you can make it on an investment by putting that money away. And we found that very true with the college bond as things that they projected they wanted to build. In seven or eight years, we'd already exceeded what that investment money had made from the tax base that it created.
12:10 We have found, though, with trying to go out to a bond that you do have to have the funding in the bank to, you know, apply for that bond. With municipal bonds? I didn't think that's the way the two parks got funded. I thought the town brought those projects forward. They passed the measure and then staff went out and bonded to build those projects. It was about $100,000 per million dollars or something. Isn't that what it was?
12:40 Yes. Okay, and I may be wrong about that. It's the income stream. How much can the income stream bond? So we've been told with Measure R, we've never asked the question with Measure U specifically, but if my memory, which is incredibly faulty, serves me well here today, we were told that on everything Measure R brings through, if we dedicated the whole stream, we'd only have enough to bond about a $5 or $6 million facility. And that would tie that money up then.
13:10 Through the whole life of the bond where if you put it all aside for five years you would have the five million dollars. So there are different strategies and ways to make that. And the philosophy there is if you put it away then the cost to the project is going to be that much more when you get ready to build the project. Plus I think people are willing to invest tax dollars when they're getting something more immediately in return from it instead of waiting down the line. And I know we've had a lot of criticism on the college bond about
13:40 Things that we all thought were going to be done, you know, up front when it first passed. Just my two cents. I know this is public comment. Thank you for the... Any other public comments? We will close public comments. Move to the consent. I'll move to approve the consent agenda. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Consent passes.
14:21 First order of business is a presentation from MLTPA on the website update. If I may before, John just jumped in. I did have a handout and a statement I presented to the commission. The clerk has got it. So this is just in response to the minutes that were previously presented by the commission. So staff just did want to clarify that. We don't need to technically read it into the record, but it'll be attached to those.
14:50 I have no problem reading it into the record. That way everybody in the audience knows what you're talking about as well. It's completely up to you, Chair. If this is, I didn't say that it was, I took a quick look at it and thought it was on one of the other things coming up, but I can read it. So this has to do with the minutes of the last minute. The town staff would like to read the following statement into the record. The town is very happy with the consultant facilitating the current Mammoth Lakes recreation process.
15:20 The Strategic Marketing Group, SMG, has conducted a very thorough and engaging process with the community with the goal to elevate and advance recreation of Mammoth Lakes. Commissioner Agnich's comments on September 10, 2013 during the regular commission meeting do not represent the views of the town and were expressed as a member of the commission, not consensus views or opinions of the entire commission. The town selected the consultant largely based on their exemplary reputation and extensive experience with Mammoth Lakes.
15:49 And above all, the personal integrity of both Carl Vibrato and Michael Ward. Thank you. Moving on now to MLTPA's presentation. Thank you very much and good afternoon. I'm going to give a brief presentation on the management of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website. Hope you guys can see all that okay. And we'll just get started. So there's three things I'm going to try to touch on. One is the...
16:23 There's an update on the management contract itself, the quarterly reporting and seasonal transitions process that we go through with the partners and some program recommendations. I'd also like to introduce Nicole Montano who's kind of hiding in the back. She's the webmaster for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website. Hi, Nicole. Thank you. There will be questions you will have that I will not be able to answer and Nicole will be lickety-split. So just a little bit of background. The management contract
16:51 The website itself went live on September 9, 2012. The MLTS website content management agreement between MLTP and the town went into effect April 23, 2013. It has a very comprehensive scope of work that was developed by MLTP and the town. The Forest Service and the town have an MOU that governs kind of the overall operations of the website.
17:17 This is not the website enhancement contract. This contract has nothing to do with Bill's phone ringing in the middle of the meeting. It has nothing to do with content. It's purely about the management of the site and the content that's with it. There's no content development or creation as a part of this contract. So here's some bulletin lists. These are the various things that are in the scope of work. I know the MLTSCC, Sandy Hogan, I think Sandy requested it.
17:45 Staff provided the full copy of the contract. It's a fairly detailed scope of work. There are two things that are in place. There are several things that are in place, but the technical team certainly is in place. This is with a MLTPA as a consultant with a technical representative from the town, as well as an administrative and financial person. This team is in charge of making sure that all the technical operations of the website are fine and the site is working.
18:12 Perfectly and just fine right now, so there is no need to call this group together. But the more significant team is the MLTS website partner content team. And this is a team that includes the consultant, MLTPA, and the webmaster, a representative from the town, a representative from the Forest Service, and a representative from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And this is the body that meets, that's really responsible for managing the content that's on the website. This is a partnered effort of the town and the Forest Service. So all these people are involved.
18:41 Can I ask you questions? Sure. Of course. Or would you like to wait until the end? It's probably best if I get, just, if you want me to slow down or just take a note, let me know, but probably best just cover them all at the end, I think. I mean, that's up to you. If you'd like me to answer questions, I certainly can. I absolutely would like to ask some questions as we go, John. Okay, fine. Whatever you'd like. Well, my question on the partner content. Yeah. So who is our person who decides
19:10 How do we decide when to change from spring to fall to winter? Campgrounds are now closed. Here's what's open. Here's what's closed. These trails are in this condition. These trails are in that condition. There is enough snow to cross country. There isn't enough snow to cross country because the daily maintenance and updates is a huge part of this and a time-consuming part. And I have been looking at how we do this with all the different partners.
19:38 And while I understand the need for it to be that way, it certainly seems a bit unwieldy to get current information out there in an economical and expedient manner. I heard about nine questions. I was going to ask six or seven of them. Well, I'll tell you this and then we'll move on. The transitions to the various seasons.
20:07 The dates have been decided by the partners, and it's based on relatively common sense kinds of things, like summer's going to start sometime before Memorial Day weekend, fall's going to start after Labor Day, winter's going to start, we're actually having a meeting tomorrow for the winter transition that will happen tomorrow, going into the winter season. So those things are relatively set, they move a little bit. When conditions come up, when snow hits the ground and those kinds of things,
20:34 The website has a relationship right now with the Forest Service to provide conditions updates for things that are happening on the ground. That information is only as good as the information that's coming into the Forest Service. Paul and Fentonino are going to talk about the Lake Space and Stuart's program, which is potentially a great way to be feeding more information into that. So that's how the conditions on the ground information comes to the webmaster. Lawson Reef down at the Visitor Center talks with Nicole, at least on a bi-weekly basis to move those.
21:03 conditions back and forth. And the website is actually, it's very easy to change the featured pages and the photographs and all that kind of stuff for the content on the site. That can be done almost instantaneously. And the partners have now all agreed to a set of information and data sharing protocols whereby Nicole now has the authority to make those kinds of changes. It took us a couple months to get all that stuff figured out, but that's now in place. So the partners will now only be meeting on that quarterly transitional basis.
21:32 But Nicole, right over there, has a discretion to make the changes in terms of photographs, in terms of what's being represented on the site once the partners meet in that quarterly basis to decide what the featured content's going to be. Say some idiot drives their truck out on the A-Trail and then calls a private contractor and plows the A-Trail making it non-usable. Right. That needs to go on the website. How does that content, does that have to be vetted by all the partners?
21:59 Or does the webmaster, is there a contact for her and she can just put it on the... Well, we work under contract to the town and the town has a partnership with the Forest Service to manage the site. Any of that kind of information, we don't have the discretion as a contractor to start doing that kind of stuff. If the town and or the Forest Service wanted to give it to us, we could easily do it and it could be done in a matter of seconds. But the information the Forest Service has made it pretty clear that they want to be the vetters
22:29 of the information that ends up on the site. They want to make sure that they're in that loop. Now that loop can be tightened and made very efficient. It can happen very quickly. We can make those changes instantaneously. But again, we're working under contract to the town. The town has partnership with the Forest Service. It's getting better. Things are kind of getting up to speed. But I think your expectation that the site should be able to do those kinds of things is reasonable. And over time, that should be expected. But as of right now, it's going to have to be vetted by the partners. As of right now, something like that gets vetted by the partners.
22:59 The Forest Service, for example, when the file alerts came out this summer, we had to go through some stuff with the protocols to figure that out, but eventually it's like, okay, the Forest Service has now put a file alert in place, that was on every page on the website, that information was made available. But it does have to go through this partnered process initially. And that can be improved, it can be made more efficient, but it is in the hands of those partners.
23:22 Yeah, how can that be made more efficient? Because that is a good question, you know, with the fires that came out, for instance. How long would it have taken, and I don't know because I wasn't following it at that point, for the partners to decide that we need to put up a posting that says that air quality is reduced? You know, what's the timeline for turning to the Raleigh? Well, the Forest Service, when the Forest Service put out their memo in the summer,
23:45 Their alert, advising that these fire alerts were in place. They sent a copy of that to Nicole, and I think that day Nicole turned around and put all those alerts all across the site. If we get specific direction from the agency to do something, we'll do it right away. The question is the information that's flowing into the Forest Service, and then as quickly as they get it to us, we can put it up, but we don't control them. Okay. I have a question. John, I'm happy to see Mammoth Lakes Tourism represented in this group.
24:15 Could you just briefly explain what they do? Yes. This is the best way to kind of understand this. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System website is, should be, and is the repository for the credible information that relates to what people are going to find on the ground. So conditions, the trails, the lengths, all the information you see on this page is the responsibility of the trail system site to maintain all that stuff. What Mammoth Lakes Tourism then does is take
24:44 The content of the pages that are produced by this site and does their marketing stuff with it. So they take, if it's a fall color viewing season and they want to promote that, they can link all the pages on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System site as part of their marketing efforts, driving people to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System site, which is nice, but more importantly, helping visitors have good experiences when they come here. So do they take that initiative to do that or do they hear it from direction from the partners?
25:15 Well, they're one of the partners. They're one of the partners. So they've been doing a good job. I mean, it was a little tough for them in the beginning because the content on the site wasn't as robust as they would have liked. And they don't want to be in a position of sending people to a website if the content isn't there where they might have a bad experience. But some of those things have been figured out. So now they're very, you know, they put banners on all their pages. If you look at the home landing page of Visit Mammoth, there's this dedicated window that's just for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
25:42 That relationship is getting better, it's getting more efficient, and I'm sure it will improve and get much better over time. Thank you. Anything else? Ready? Okay. We'll go to the next page. Next page. Okay, so that was the team. Now we've got the teams in place. And so what the partners have spent a fair amount of time doing over the first, say, quarter of the contract is establishing the information and data sharing protocols.
26:13 And I won't go into all the details of that. If you want to know, I can certainly provide it. How do people communicate with each other if the Forest Service has an alert? Who does it go to? How do all these various things work? It took a while to get all that stuff figured out. But it is now figured out such that, again, Nicole has a discretion to do the kind of work a good webmaster needs to be able to run the site properly. And the partners will now meet on the seasonal transitional basis, which means it's a lot more efficient. We're not spending a lot of meetings trying to develop this stuff, and things are working out pretty well.
26:43 So, to date, we've established these information data sharing protocols. I took about eight meetings with the partners. We're only going to meet now on this quarterly seasonal transitional basis. And the ongoing tasks that the contractor, MLTPA, Nicole, that we work on, the daily operations, preparing the seasonal transitions, the quarterly content updates, all these various different things. We don't have to consult with the partners now to do all that kind of work. That all just goes on in the background.
27:09 I'm now going to share with you, this is the first presentation that Cole put together for the first quarterly seasonal transition meeting between the partners back October 3rd. This is transitioning from summer to fall. And the first thing that we did was we took a look at the Google Analytics just over the very, since the launch of the site, since the management of the site back in June or whatever, or May, this is what the visitation numbers are basically looking like. About 20,000 people visited the site between May and October.
27:37 There are about 100,000 page views. If you have any questions on this stuff, technically let me know and I can try to fill it in. But this is the stuff that's coming out of Google Analytics. How many unique visitors? 20,000 unique visitors. Again, the page view is about 100,000. About three and a half pages per visit, three and a third pages per visit. The bounce rate is 50%, which is an industry standard. That's about normal. The average duration was about three minutes. So the site is attracting...
28:06 Definitely attacking traffic. The relationship with new visitors and returning visitors, about 9,000 returning visitors and 20,000 new visitor visits. And the sources of the traffic, and Pat, to your question a little bit, we'll get into where Visit Mammoth comes into this. The first thing you'll see on here, these first two lines is Google and Direct. This has been an issue with Google in the last year or so when, for privacy concerns, they no longer publish
28:36 The sort of the highest and most direct references of things coming into any website. So you have to kind of guess where exactly those people came from. But if you can see down number three, there's Visit Mammoth. They referred to about 7,000 people. The town was about three, is that 800, Stuart? I can't really see that that well. And Yahoo and Oregon, you can see where the bounds of people came from. But Visit Mammoth drove a lot of traffic to the site. It's about, I guess about...
29:02 You know, about a quarter of the site came from Visits Mammoth, three quarters came from just organic Google searches, people searching on the Internet. The keywords, again, I can't really quite see that far, but these are the words and terms that people are using to search to find the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. This is how they're getting to the site. And this is the kind of activity that goes on every day on the Internet. And these are the top ten pages. That forward slash right there, that's the home page.
29:28 Trails, Pages, Activities, Destinations, and all that kind of stuff. This is the places where people are going. You can dig a lot deeper into all this stuff if you want to, but that gives you a basic kind of overview of what's happening with the site. Another interesting statistic is the relationship with the desktop computers that are accessing the site versus the mobile and the tablet computers. As you guys know, the website was built and it's designed to work on mobile phones and tablets and all that kind of stuff. It's responsibly designed.
29:54 This is a pretty interesting breakdown just initially where we're at with this kind of traffic. About 16,000 from desktops, 12,000 coming from mobile phones and tablets, which is reflective of current trends in the world these days. People are using a lot more of their mobile devices and their tablets. So now what we do is I'll just go to the webpage for a second. We have a discussion with the partners about, okay, we're going to transition from summer to fall. What content are we going to use on the homepage?
30:21 For the current, the featured activities, the featured trails, the featured destinations. And this is the current content that was listed back in October and then the proposed, proposed content. I'll just show this to you guys real quick so you can, just in case you have any questions about this. So here's the, here's the homepage and you can see this is the featured, so these are featured activities, featured trails, featured destinations. There's about three opportunities for each on the homepage.
30:53 And so for each season, if we're going for summer into fall, okay, we're going to change the summer stuff out, put the fall stuff up. We go from fall to winter, we'll change the fall stuff and go to the winter. And as more content gets added to the site, there's just that much more stuff for Nicole and the partners to choose from to make this stuff happen. Do you change the homepage photo every season too? Yeah, we can change the homepage photo certainly every season and certainly every two weeks. Nicole now has the discretion from the partners to be changing that kind of content on a regular basis.
31:21 So once a pool of content is established, say for the fall or the summer, she has a discretion to just from that designated pool, swap out pages, swap out images, do all the rest of it. The photo management aspect of the site is actually very strong. It all lives in a third-party vendor. It's very easy to move the photos around and change them out. So it's a great tool of the site. So these were the suggestions for the...
31:48 For the trails, and these were swapped out. This also gives the partners a management opportunity. So the Forest Service has concerns about, well, this summertime we have a lot of working on saying the lake space, we want to send more people maybe towards Inyo Craters or to Red's Meadow or something like that. This gives everybody kind of a sense of what is the best way to be directing traffic. If Visit Mammoth has identified that they're getting a lot of people who are interested, say, in...
32:13 In mountain biking or something like that, that can kind of be pushed through this site. So it gives all those folks with an interest in managing this content how to kind of use it, do the best job they can with it. Same with the destination landing pages. These are the current feature ones in the cold. We work together to come up with the posed sites. The activities, same thing. Just as every season we rotate through this stuff and swap these things out. And so that's basically a review of what happens in these quarterly content meetings with the partners.
32:39 We decide all together, they decide what the content should be, Nicole makes the changes, and then we go into the next season and we're managing these things in the background. I wanted to add just a couple things in terms of for managing the site, the kinds of things that I think would be helpful for the MLTSCC, for the reclamation, anybody interesting who would be interested to know, the kinds of tools that are perhaps could use some improvement as we move forward to really make this thing as successful as possible. The first thing is to talk about content.
33:07 Content, the site is up. It really is a good, strong, reliable website. But any website is only as good as its content. That is the mother's milk of the digital age. Tomorrow, coincidentally, MLTPA is going to deliver about 190 new web pages for the site. These pages come from a Measure R Spring Award back in 2012. It's taken about 18 months for a variety of reasons to get all this stuff done and get delivered. It's finally here. That's a very good thing.
33:37 But there is needed, a need for a reliable, timely content delivery system for this website. Currently, there are no funds allocated from the MLTSCC to put any new content on the site. Once the delivery happens tomorrow, these 190 pages, there are no more resources that we know of to put new content on the site. I think that's something that probably needs to be addressed. There needs to be established a best practices program for delivering website content to the site, and right now there isn't one.
34:05 So I think that's something to be paid attention to. The second thing is a photo library. Photographs, as Pat brought up, it's an excellent value for the site. Infrastructure in the ground doesn't change, but the seasons do, and you can represent a trail or an opportunity or an experience with as many photographs as you have because that infrastructure isn't going to change. There is no relationship right now for the website with a photo library. That's something that probably should be addressed.
34:34 The, um, wait. Sorry. We do have a photo library that the town has taken control of, right? Not that I know of. I thought there was 5,000 images on the photo library. Yeah. Yeah, those images still live on MLTPA server. There were, you know, providing custodial services for them. Right. But there is no management of it. There's no relationship between the town and the MLTPA photo library. They've been sitting there since you asked those questions a couple years ago. Okay.
35:04 So it's an important opportunity. It's a great program, but it's probably something that really needs to be paid attention to. How come that has not been transferred to the town? How come the town hasn't taken possession of them? The town has never requested the photos. Okay. I'm making a list of things that we're going to need to ask for. Yep. Thank you. Yep. Another thing that's come up, which is interesting, are naming conventions. When we were building the new pages for the website,
35:32 We were working off of data, the GIS data from the town on the Forest Service, and it became clear that the naming conventions on the ground are different than what's actually happening in the GIS data. So these are some popular trails, Superior Lake trails, Summit Meadow trails, and the Forest Service, when they provide permits for people going out in the wilderness, this is particularly in the Reds Meadow Valley area, the naming conventions are completely different. So we did some work the last couple of weeks for the Forest Service trying to figure out, okay,
35:58 What should we be calling these things? Should we call them by the official GIS name or what they're actually calling them on the ground? And this, we're going with the names that the Forest Service uses in that handout they just provided. But there are some implications for the mapping of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
36:14 This is the Superior Lake Trail, which on the map that's published around town says Superior Lake Trail. The Forest Service refers to it as the Beck Lakes Trail. And on the website, the page on the website is going to say the Beck Lake Trail because that's a common name that everybody's using. But these are these kinds of things that are going to have to get coordinated and figured out so the information system that's going out to everybody is consistent across the board. And you can see right here, this is I think, there's the Beck Lake Trail right there.
36:41 which on the MLTS maps is now called the Superior Lake Trail. Fortunately, there are not a lot of names on the maps of the MLTS right now, so it's not a huge deal, but it's one of those things that everybody needs to keep their eyes on. We delivered to the town a consensus naming convention list. It's very easy to get the partners together, just sit down for a little while, forget those consensus names, add them to the pool, then whether it's a map or a website or whatever, everybody's working off the same.
37:06 Same information. Where did you come up with the Superior Lake Trail? The Superior Lake Trail, we were told, and we worked with the partners to make the map, to use the naming conventions and the GIS data. And the GIS data calls it, that's what the official, probably historic name from the Forest Service is, Superior Lake Trail. And these were all vetted and blessed by the agencies when it went out. But as it turns out, the Reds and Meadow Valley area, they've changed for a bunch of reasons. They've changed a bunch of these names. So that's just the kind of ongoing kind of coordination needs to be going on.
37:36 This is another interesting one where the Deer Creek Trail, where the GIS data from the Forest Service indicates that this trail goes all the way through. In fact, the trail stops right about there. And there really historically never been a trail from Deer Lakes down to there. This is represented on the maps. This is the kind of thing, again, to get with the agency saying, look, does that trail really go there or does it not go there? Again, so the information that's coming out of the website and the maps and everything else is going to be consistent across the board. And that's what's up on the website right now? This is what's up on the maps.
38:06 So the maps that are all the trailheads around town, that shows that trail right like that. On the website, what we can do is we'll show, we will say in the narrative, trail doesn't go all the way through, it's a used trail, you know, it's probably not recommended, there's no signs there to tell you how to get on it. It's a Forest Service system trail, it's a beautiful trail, it could be rehabilitated or maintained. I mean, this is the PCT, John Muir Trail and the PCT were...
38:33 Hundreds of thousands of people all summer long going right by Mammoth Lakes would be a great way to get folks to come up to Mammoth. But these are discussions that need to go on with the folks responsible for the infrastructure on the ground. Well, a question for you on that. I mean, so you're telling me that the partners exist, but can't the partners correct this situation, or is that something that we need to be involved in? Yes, exactly. We do, or the partners, the content team can fix this? Well, no, the content team cannot fix that, because the content team is...
39:01 Just focus on the website. What the content team can do is can say, we'll go to the Forest Service and say, look, this trail doesn't go all the way through. Let's put a conditions update on the trail page that will advise people, just so you know, this trail does not go all the way through. It's a lightly, whatever the terms of art the Forest Service wants to use, those can be used. So it can be addressed by the, so the website can give as accurate articulation as is appropriate from the website perspective.
39:28 We'll get to a couple other things in a second, though, through the maintenance programs on the ground. So what people will find on the ground is going to be analogous to what the website is telling them. Okay. Right? So everybody's saying the same thing. So how timely is this happening with the partners meeting quarterly? Is that enough, you know, is it ongoing okay? Well, for this kind of stuff, I mean, this is a big content push that's happening right now. We'll talk about this in our meeting tomorrow. And Steve and I have been talking already about how to put some provisos.
39:57 Do some stuff with the website as a tool to advise the public as what they can find out there. It's going to work out okay. But I think over the long term, the coordination of what's happening on the ground from maintenance, signage, the summer stewardship program, those kinds of things could be used to maybe fix some trails up and clean some things up. These are decisions just to be made over the long term. Some of these trails the Forest Service isn't maintaining. Maybe they have to be decommissioned. If the Forest Service formally decommissions a trail, well, then the maps have to get updated and the website has to get updated. But this is just an ongoing.
40:27 Part of the process of maintaining a big ambitious trail system. Can we get back to content? I mean, how often does the content need to change other than certainly seasonal changes and if there's, you know, some maintenance issue or something like that? It seems like once it's established, there should be minor tweaking. Actually, that's not best practices. If you look at any website that exists anywhere, you're constantly looking at
40:56 How to provide a visitor who's coming back to a website, the sense that there is an intelligence or there's someone behind the websites providing you new things to do, new opportunities, there's new stuff every time you go there. That's what successful websites do. But the content itself, I mean the trails don't really change much. That's correct. So you're talking about experiential activities or something along that line. Exactly.
41:21 Exactly. And that's an excellent point. Once all the infrastructure, all the trails and the destinations and all that stuff is in, that's not going to change. What will change is activities. I mean, recreation trends come and go. I mean, we talked about the snow biking, the fat biking thing, that kind of stuff. Those kinds of things are going to change. And the kinds of experiences you can have on this trail system are going to change. And different combinations of things can put together to provide people more experiences. But I think also using things like the photographs where you change the look of the site.
41:46 So someone comes back and says, oh, there's different photographs, it looks different, okay, what do you got new for me, what can I do in this season? And to Bill's point, as this thing is truly reflective of what's happening, the conditions on the ground when someone comes up here, that's the challenge is to get it so it's very, it's timely, I think is the best way to put it. Do you have people putting up experiences, doing any blogs or anything like that on?
42:08 A daily, weekly, monthly basis? No, the site was designed specifically so that it would not be like a social media platform because the management of that is really intense. We didn't want to build or provide the community with something that's going to take a lot of management to do that kind of stuff. So it's not designed to do that.
42:26 And any experience or thing that goes up on the site, it's blessed, it's going to be reviewed by the town, the Forest Service, it's blessed, they vet it, they sign off on it, and they're all good with it. So it really is the authoritative voice of what's going on on the ground. But that was a recent agreement, right, with Measure R monies for $25,000 or something to add those experiences to the website? Yes, that contract started back, that was the spring of 2012.
42:53 So those pages that we've built from that contract we're delivering tomorrow. That's the 190? 190 pages, yeah. Thank you. Yep. Okay, so a couple other things are, these is more about set of conditions on the ground, which are things that, again, the summer stewardship or other capacities can help with. One is a trail called the Rim Trail, and this is a trail that goes from, this is Red Cone right up here above Horseshoe Lake. It goes right along a very beautiful trail along the edge of the Mammoth Crest.
43:22 It comes down here and it kind of disappears and gets braided and then peters out. And then you get right to the Mammoth Pass Trail and this is where you come out of the woods. It's literally right there, but there's no sign. The hundred feet of trail between here and where the trails on the other side of the woods get you up to the crest doesn't exist. This is on the maps. I was doing a lot of work this summer going down the backside of the Deer Creek Trails and those kinds of things.
43:49 Every time I came back, I ran into six different parties who asked me, hey, how do I get to this rim trail? Where is this thing? I want to go on this rim trail experience. And all it would take is a sign here telling you where it is and to work with the summer stewardship crew to put like maybe 100 feet of trail in right there and you have a complete trail and complete experience. You don't have to change the maps. You don't have to do anything crazy. You're just maintaining and rehabilitating the things on the ground that people want to do. There was a couple this summer that got very bent out of shape. I think back in June, a doctor,
44:19 and his lawyer wife who went up there trying to find this thing and said it's on the map. They couldn't find it and they got very ugly with the visitor center staff and some of the friends of the Inyo staff. And it's, you know, these are the kinds of things we want to avoid. And they're easy and quick fixes for a lot of this stuff. However, there are a bunch of trails that we've found, certainly the Reds Meadow area and down by the PCT, where there's still a lot of blowdown, where there's a lot of the trails that haven't been maintained in many years. Again, these are things that could probably be brought up to speed fairly quickly.
44:48 But I think we'll work with the town, the Forest Service, when these pages go live on the site to put a conditions report on there that's going to say something like still plenty of blowdown, lightly maintained trail, those kinds of things so that the visitor experience is not going to get compromised. We'll match their expectations of what's on the ground. That's an important thing to do. Are they still looking at getting into these areas or is that something they don't maintain? For the Forest Service? I don't know. You don't know. These are questions. They're system trails. They're on the map.
45:17 You know, I went down, looked at a lot of these things, and you can find them. A lot of them are really hard to find. A lot of the signage isn't there, but these are questions to have with the partners and say, okay, what do we want to do about these kinds of things? And so with existing infrastructure, these are the important things to kind of keep in place. Maintain the naming conventions, implement maintenance of the summer stewardship program, and rehabilitate existing infrastructure such as trails where possible.
45:42 Or if the Forest Service chooses to decommission some of these things, they're not going to bring it back. Some of the blowdown out there is so bad, they may not bring back some of these trails. In which case, okay, let's formally decommission them, and then we'll update all the information systems accordingly. And a couple things just with new infrastructure. This is new things being built by the town or the Forest Service. The town has recently, I think, completed a really beautiful part of the town loop. And it goes on a Class 2 bike lane over to Mammoth Creek Park.
46:09 We would love to be able to update the website to reflect this. We haven't had any communication from the town one way or the other. We don't feel it's appropriate for us to be chasing people down to see what's going on with these kinds of things. And again, the content, we don't have any funds to do these kinds of things. And it's great that new infrastructure is being built. I hope that maybe they put some money in their budget to do this work and we can get it updated. We just haven't heard anything about it, so we just bring it to your attention. So why isn't this discussed at the trails community meetings? Yeah, it's going to be.
46:39 Okay. I mean, I just, because I'm making a lot of notes here, and it sounds like, you know, what I'm hearing here is that there's just a lot of small, as you said, easy, quick fixes, but what I'm writing down here is that they just need to be categorized and they need to be taken care of. Yeah. And this was going to be presented at the trails committee meeting, but we asked it to come here because I think you weren't able to make yesterday, so. Thank you. Anyhow. Yeah. So, so that, so the town loop, and this is.
47:08 You know, this is a pretty important little intersection. If they look at the website, if they're going to go out into Old Mammoth Road, which is dangerous, and we've all known that for a long time, now there's a great, beautiful new section of Mupp. We'd love to be able to update the site and tell them the route has changed and, you know, get that kind of work done. So that type of general updates that might happen, you know, two, three times a year is not included in the contract? It is not currently included in the contract. And they're not necessarily expensive. Because it's a new trail.
47:35 Because it's a new facility. I think the MLTSCC has talked about when new projects get done, putting some money into those budgets so that to do this kind of stuff. I'm just not sure where that's at right now. I guess what I would be seeing is when you're looking at a website and you're trying to keep this up, there should be some monies within that general contract so you can address these things as you're moving through the year without having to come back and have a whole new contract written. Exactly.
48:02 So that's that little section there. Then there's this other section, the beautiful new college connector path. I'm not, again, we don't know exactly what the status, I mean, it's there, people are using it, we're building a web page for it, but all the maps are going to get changed, I'm just not, I'm not sure what's going on with that. So this is to Sean, to the point we were just talking about a second, allocating funds to update all the information systems, website, maps, all the rest of when new infrastructure happens to make sure that everything
48:29 Wherever a visitor or local is getting information from, it's all going to be the same stuff. And finally, so the QR codes, again, is an important part of, it's something that we manage theoretically through the website. And, you know, you can go to the signs, you can scan your QR code, it tells you the nearby trails, where you are, the nearby experiences and activities, and people smile, they get kind of a kick out of it. There are these two new signs going up the college connector path.
48:55 And again, no one asked us for QR codes or they're not integrated into the website. I'm assuming these map panels are going to go up. I don't know. We just don't know what the status is of those QR codes and how they're going to tie into the website. Again, these are relatively minor things. It's not hugely costly. But I think we want to make sure that all this infrastructure is working together as one significant unit. And it would be great to see the signs, the frames up. It would be great to see the panels up there also. And it would be interesting to see what the information is on all those signs.
49:25 So just a summary for that is to budget and allocate funds for updates to all the information systems when there's new infrastructure and coordinate the QR programs for new interpretive signs or new trail system signage to make sure that the QR codes, the request for the QR codes gets integrated into the website. That's one of the things that the website manages. And that's it. How often are you in communication with Steve as the coordinator? I mean, don't you guys talk frequently?
49:56 We talk as needed, yeah. As needed. So I'm sure that this information of the needs, even though somewhat minor, have been communicated? Well, again, they've been communicated. We talk about it back and forth. We talk about it all the time. So it's not a secret. So I'm sorry, I probably went on to one. Does anybody have any questions? Yeah, I've got a couple.
50:26 If I can jump in. You know, I honestly think that this is one of the most important things that MLTSCC can provide, as important as the trails themselves. And, you know, my concern is that it does sound like there's a lot of just little things that are still missing that unfortunately are creating some expectations, some missed expectations. You know, there's
50:53 Some of the biggest problems I've ever had in business is just missed expectations. Somebody expects a trail to be complete, they get up there, they find out that it's not. So these are the kind of things that we need to get fixed up. The naming conventions, I was not aware that there's missed naming between what's on GIS and what's on national forest maps. It sounds like there's just a lot of little things
51:21 that need to be just cleaned up to make the entire experience that much more seamless. How, who, you know, it's like I see various things when I'm riding my bike up or taking my kid for a hike up to McLeod Lake and such, but how and who, what kind of systems are in place to get these small fixes fixed? Well, I think I went over this list with Steve last week.
51:50 And we're going to have our partner meeting tomorrow. So this is all just coming up in the last couple of weeks as we finish putting these 190 pages together. 190 pages is a lot of pages, covered a lot of ground. We'll be on our agenda tomorrow and we'll start talking it through and come up with solutions. If there's funding needs or the capacity needs, it'll come back to you in some shape or form. So it's not like this is a house on fire. These are just the kinds of things that come up and we'll just be communicating. Hopefully tomorrow we'll get some things worked out.
52:19 Figure out some directions to go forward with this stuff. Yeah, I get that. Yesterday, you know, the issue came up that we were aware that we're changing some trails. We've got the college connector path. We had not set aside funds to go change the existing maps and panels to now reflect that the college connector path is in existence. So note to self, we're going to need to make sure that in the future those funds are allocated at the time that the project is being
52:48 So I get that, but I just want to make sure that with little things like this that come to the attention of the partners, that we need to make sure that we're giving the partner content team the resources, whether it's funding or other decisions, the ability to make those changes as quickly as possible so that the users are
53:12 Getting a good experience. And by the way, just one other thing before I move on or let other people speak is that I saw in one of your slides here what kind of education or promotion we give to mobile apps when people are actually out there on the trails. Again, one of the best things we've got going for us is that you've got signal for frankly even a lot of the backcountry trails that we've got right now. These devices are incredible.
53:40 and need to be able to let you drop a pin wherever you are, wherever the case may be. Something that I would actually like to see happen, Bill, you're going to have to get a smartphone one of these days, especially you and your snowmobiling. If you have the ringtone, just get a smartphone. Yeah, there you go. But, you know, that's something that I know that MLT would do a great job in helping us promote it. Yeah, yeah. And something that I'm aware that we need to give a little bit more emphasis. I was surprised the proportion
54:10 of how many people were accessing the MLTS website from their desktop rather than their mobile when really we want an experience that people are able to be able to look things up when they're out there on the field. I use my QR codes fairly regularly. I'm looking stuff up more on this thing now than I am even my desktop. And especially when you've got signal on most of our backcountry trails still that you're able to access that.
54:37 Well, it could be that people are planning their trip, too. I'm sure they are. But at the same time, I would like to really promote the use. We've got a really stellar website here. I mean, this is congratulations to all of you who have been involved. And that goes to town staff as well. Absolutely everyone who's contributed content to all this. I mean, it's a stellar, stellar website. And as I said, almost as important as the trails themselves. We just need to make sure that we're cleaning up these little issues.
55:06 That's my comments for now. Should there be representation from the coordinating committee with the town partner contractor meetings? Perhaps. Who are the team members now on that slide? Stuart and Steve. That's what I thought. So, Stuart, you're representing MLTSCC as well as the town. Is that accurate? Okay. Okay.
55:39 I mean, I defer to what Steve or Stuart would say. I mean, anybody's welcome. I mean, it's interesting if you wanted to come and see what's happening. It's interesting. I think the other thing that's important to note here is that this is an evolutionary process, and I think, as John mentioned, when we started quite some years ago, we didn't go out with GPS to reset.
56:05 Forest Service System Trails. We relied on the Forest Service to provide us their data for their trails. So I think one of the beauties that we're finding out now as we evolved through that and made those signs with those trails and showed those routes, that was Forest Service information that was provided to us. We had every expectation to believe that it was as current as possible. Now with some of the work that John's done and his team lately,
56:31 We've done some ground truthing. And as you can see by the slides and by the experience, these things don't seem to be as true as we were led to believe. So through the partners then and through this process, we're actually able then to do that ground truthing for the Forest Service and then remind them or point out, here's some problems. And so now it's just a matter of working through them and getting them fixed. So I don't see any long-range difficulty, and I think John said it well.
57:00 It's not a house on fire. It's just house cleaning and housekeeping. And it's just going to get better and better. So we've got good dialogue. We've got our meetings set up. We've got our protocols figured out. We've got places in the contract for quarterly updates and stuff. So we're not coming to you with any great major problem that we need to have a fix for. So I think we're on pretty good track. I think a lot of the problems where he's saying trails show on the map as existing and they aren't really there, the trails are there.
57:30 They are getting used so infrequently and they aren't being maintained that they almost disappear. I would hate to see the Forest Service decommission them because the process they would then have to go through, the NEPA process and everything else to recommission them is something that would never happen. However, a lot of this can be fixed on the website through the experience pages. You go and you look at that trail and the experience page says trail hard to find. When John was talking to me about snowmobile experiences, we rated trails.
57:58 In terms of beginner, intermediate, advanced. Some of these trails are advanced trails. People who have walked them before and didn't know how to hike in the woods can probably find them and find their way through. So on the experience page, we need to have the money and have somebody with the knowledge to walk the trail to explain that this is an advanced trail and you're going to have to do some sage hopping or trail finding to get it done.
58:28 Show as trails that don't exist. I've hiked at some point in my past life. It's just an experience thing. There are hikers that come to Mammoth that don't want their trails having rocks lined on both sides of them with a sign every 15 feet saying, you are now in the wilderness. They want the trail experience of almost no trail there and finding their way through. So those are important trails.
58:58 I don't want to encourage anybody to decommission anything. Through the experience pages, we can deal with them and make it whole. It's also just, if I could interrupt, sorry, but it's a great opportunity, as Steve was saying, to get out on the ground and see what's actually out there. I mean, the United States government has built a lot of, and the town has built some great infrastructure over the last 20, 30 years. The maintenance dollars aren't there to take care of it. This community has the resources through volunteer efforts and leveraging some public money to
59:27 Go out there, clean this stuff up, get it to the level of the vision coming out of the MLTSCC to be the best trail system anywhere. Well, these are the kinds of things you've got to do. I'm a little more jaded than that. In the last hundred years, we've built a lot of trails. In the last 30 years, we've managed to let them go to sea. I haven't been around that long. I know that you guys talked about some funding for redoing winter and summer maps. So are those maps going to be the most current information available?
59:58 Which maps are you talking about, paper maps? No, I think a meeting or two ago you were talking, the MLTSCC, we had dedicated what, three grand? Yeah, I think. The maps you're talking about started out as motorized maps, they also show non-motorized experiences, and the trails that are highlighted on those maps are specific marked trails, not all the trails by any means that exist out there, just the specific marked trails and routes for those mountain bikes, motorcycles, snowmobiles, cross-country ski.
1:00:26 But whatever is there is accurate. Whatever is there is accurate. And we have talked with Steve about on the website because we've added a bunch of winter trails. All the trails on the winter map are now going to be on the website with this content update. And we're making sure that the look and feel as you see on the website, it's not a major thing, but it sort of matches what you'd see from the paper map to keep all of these information systems from one data set. It's all the same information being articulated in different ways. Sounds like a great coordinated effort and you guys...
1:00:54 As Steve has mentioned, are evolving and really honing in on exactly what needs to be done. Yeah, it's just, it's where everything's been brought together now. It's just, okay, let's make it better. Let's keep working it and just make it better.
1:01:06 Well, and this has been a lesson for me, and to back up what Steve was just saying, just how many different organizations there are out there that we need to pay attention to the information that's coming before us. I mean, we're looking at changing some of the maps on panels right now, and if some of the trails are being changed throughout the summer, how often are we changing the panels? You know, that was a discussion that came up yesterday. We probably only want to change them once a year.
1:01:32 And I think at the most. But at that time, you want to make sure that you've captured as many of the changes that happened in the last year or say are about to happen so that we're not having to constantly change the panels every three months. Well, and I think we're going to learn something about the types of signs because on our big signs, what are the big ones called? What series are they? Type 2. Type 2s. The map is an integral part of the entire page. We can't just take the map out and replace it.
1:02:00 And that's something I think in the future we're going to want to work on. Yeah. Because that three grand a piece, we can't just plop a new sign. I think those type 2s are designed to have, you should be able to take the maps, I think the maps just come right off. Oh, before the last panels come off. So the panels are designed to be interchangeable. And updated. I'm going to have to go re-look at it. The last time I looked at it, it didn't look that way.
1:02:25 All right. Thanks, John. You know, it's a great base, and I'm glad you brought up these issues because I've been trying to figure out where we are on the website. There's so much information that kind of keeps coming back and forth that it's hard to keep track of what's actually happening. Thank you. Just briefly, Don Zeleny, I wanted to reinforce what he said. I first programmed an IBM computer in 1962. Over the decades, I had a rule of thumb. If I budgeted...
1:02:56 To implement a hardware or software system, I knew that for a number of years I needed 10, even 20% of that value to keep the thing going because it was going to change. That's the world we live in and we follow these websites. We have to plan on those things. Thank you.
1:03:18 Good point. Yes, they're promising of making everything less expensive and less paperwork. They made everything more expensive and I have more paper generated. Absolutely. I think so. So, that's it for now. Steve and I and the partners are meeting tomorrow. We're going to, the town's going to get 190 pages tomorrow for a two-week review period. And hopefully we'll have those things up for winter. And any questions, feel free to call. I assume you have no more questions now. Any other questions from any of the commission?
1:03:50 John, thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. 20,000 new users, what do we call that? Projects. New projects? Unique. 20,000 unique visitors is huge in the first official partial year, basically since April. What's the definition of a unique visitor?
1:04:20 Somebody knew that has not came to the paper previously. 29,000 visits, which means 9,000 people visited more than once. They weren't unique. Okay. I thought that's what happened. I probably count as one of those non-unique visitors. Got it. Okay, moving on to the Friends of the Inyo Lakes Basin Stewart update. Pardon me one second while I get this rolling. Thanks very much. Well, he's doing it. We'll talk about that in the...
1:04:56 MLTSCC update. Steve, in the update, you're going to talk about the potential grooming things and... Yes, I have a handout and also... I'll bring it up now then. Yeah, we'll do it. It's good thing you didn't say anything. Yeah, thank you. All right. Thank you very much for allowing us to come today. I'm Paul McFarlane with Friends of the Inyo. I've been before your cousin council many times, the MLTSCC, and now I get to sit at the big kids table, so thanks.
1:05:26 And what we're going to talk about today is our Lakes Basin Stewards Program, which is a program that we actually started quite a while ago. And for the last two years has been generously funded by the out of the MLTSCC allocation of the major R funding. I'm going to turn most of this over to Drew Foster.
1:05:55 Eastern Sierra's newest professional balloon pilot. Caught in some winds today, which, if anything's rough, that's why. So he's here now. In 2008, Drew showed up to work for Friends of Inyo in the first year we had this program. And with that, I'll turn it over to him. Hello, good afternoon. Welcome. My name's Drew Foster. I've been with Friends of Inyo since 2008.
1:06:30 I have a personal investment and background with this particular program because this is how I came to the area and was introduced to this place. So as Paul mentioned, before 2008, there wasn't any real program up in the Mammoth Lakes Basin.
1:06:56 Many years prior to that, the Forest Service had regular staff, but as funding got cut, they were reduced to regular maintenance staff to clean bathrooms and take care of the campgrounds, and that's now through concessionaire. So Paul really put this program together because of that lack of presence. Who's been to the Lakes Basin before? We've all been up there. It's the greatest backyard that one could ask for.
1:07:26 in Mammoth. It's a phenomenal place with a lot of the trails that John talked about earlier. And it's one of the most highly visited places and used places on the Inyo National Forest, probably next to Mount Whitney, but also one of the highest visited places on any national forest across the U.S. There are a lot of visitors. You all know this. I don't need to explain that. And the lack of presence there was
1:07:57 There was a need there. So in 2008, through 2011, we developed a program funded through the National Forest Foundation through the Ski Area Conservation Fund. And it was really great. I got to come in and learn about the place and develop programs like interpretive programs, leading walks out at Horseshoe Lake up to Heart Lake, did a lot of trail maintenance, just basic.
1:08:26 Trail Maintenance to keep trails open and comfortable and accessible, doing sign inventories, just kind of basic needs taking care of the place. That funding ran out due to various reasons I won't go into right now, but at the end of 2011 we were seeking new avenues of funding and in comes the
1:08:50 MLTSCC and the opportunity to get some Measure R funding really gave the program a new life and in many ways kind of expanded it and broadened it. So over the last two years this program has been more focused on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System part. And the Mammoth Lakes Trail System within that partnerships are really integral. And so I listed some things down here.
1:09:20 But really you have the Inyo National Forest. They are the land manager. It's their land. And so they have the decision, the authority to identify which trails remain open. Many of the things John was mentioning in his presentation. Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, Devil's Post Files, this neat little rectangle that fits in there, all the partner organizations.
1:09:49 Over the last five years, we've really built this program, developed the relationships and built trust and improved the way the whole program works. Where's the clicker? So our scope of work, you can see this is right off the website, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website, and this shows the scope of work from Convict Lake to the Sherwin Lakes Trail.
1:10:21 Sherman Valentine Lakes, the Mammoth Lakes Basin, Minaret Summit, Inyo Craters. It's this big scope. And here's the Trail System Master Plan, a little clip from that document. And that orange outer boundary is the planning boundary that's defined within the Trail System Master Plan. So that is just another view at the same map. So to talk about, I just want to give you guys the best.
1:10:52 Description of what exactly we do out on the ground there. Paint a clear picture, as clear as I can, of how we're engaged up there and what we've been doing since 2008 and what we've been doing over the last two years, particularly with Measure R funding, because that's probably what you're most concerned about. One component of our Mammoth stewards that are out there every day in the summer from about May to October, kind of the bookend.
1:11:21 Months, the busy months obviously being June, July, August. Soft surface trail maintenance. This is what I was talking about before is keeping trails open, keeping them comfortable to walk on, doing things like keeping the brush back, maintaining drainage control so that water's not running down, eroding a trail, removing fallen trees. Every winter trees fall down and then some winters we have
1:11:51 Catastrophic Wind Events that knock lots more trees down. We clean up illegal campfire rings, which reduces the fire risk up there, keeps the place cleaner and safer. We removed 80 just this summer. Now, to give you some perspective, that's a number that is, oh, this is over the last two years, sorry. These numbers in bold are the last two years of work.
1:12:17 So 80 over the last couple of years. So if you figure an average of 40 a year, that's come way down since when I started in 2008. I was cleaning up well over 100. What constitutes an illegal fire rate? The Forest Service has over years. They change it every year. But they have fire restrictions on their land. So they have areas where you're not allowed to have fires at all. And that's changed in the last few years before they...
1:12:47 Had more areas available to fires, and now there's fewer. For a variety of reasons. One's wildfire risk, and another is at high alpine conditions, vegetation just doesn't grow as fast. So if more people are burning more wood, then you have less trees and dead logs, which is important for the environment. Does that answer your question? Yeah, because I actually hadn't heard of an illegal firing, because if I'm camping and I'm below the 10,000 foot mark,
1:13:18 I'm allowed to have a fire, and if there isn't a ring, I can build a ring, so it's not illegal. It's a negative term, so I was looking for the definitions so everybody understood that these aren't where people are going and burning illegally. These are existing fire rings that are now in non-burned areas that you've pulled out to keep people and use them. Some of them are, but actually a lot of them are new. I mean, many of these would be on the shore of Horseshoe Lake.
1:13:43 In an area where you're required to camp in a developed area, not a dispersed area. Because we're focused in the lake's basin, you have people building fire rings in the parking lots. I mean, that's what a lot of these are. It's not so much that we're going in and removing some from the shore of a lake where there's one fire ring. But oftentimes, when we started this program, we'd go up to a place like Skelton, and there were 20. Now there's two.
1:14:11 So that it actually, rather than having a whole bunch, you clean them up, you begin to manage for a number. But a lot of the, where the illegal comes from is mostly places where the firings are in unauthorized areas. Not so much because of elevational closures, but because you're not supposed to camp there because it's a closed recreation area. You're supposed to camp in the campgrounds. So, but it is an interesting term of art, and over time, the nice thing is, as Drew mentioned, we've really seen the numbers decline in the place.
1:14:39 Clean up and people begin to self-please. So that's a little more background on that. Thank you. Thank you. So that's a good point. It's become manageable. Over the last few years, we've had regular staff out there getting to know the place, getting to know the area and the type of work. And things like signage and wayfinding, inventorying, fixing, creating new signs.
1:15:11 24 signs over the last couple years and it's become a manageable system that we've built over these last few years. Removing trash, there's luckily not a lot of trash in the backcountry and the more we keep it that way the less people are inclined to litter. Repairing structures, keeping the tread passable and really the stewards that are out on the ground every day on a day-to-day basis.
1:15:40 These are the people that are, you may not see if you're just driving around up there, but they're out in the backcountry looking at trail conditions, looking at projects that need to happen. If there's a big project that they can't tackle between one or two people, we actually have paid crews that will come in and we'll schedule a week of time or however long that takes to do a bigger project, say building rock steps up Duck Pass Trail.
1:16:10 Weekly or at least regular trail patrols just for visitor contacts, for trail maintenance, all that sort of thing. Talking about trail patrols. So these are our stewards going up there. Outside of the visitor center, these are the information specialists. So these are the people that know what's going on on the ground, you know, hopefully have some idea.
1:16:36 About what fires are going on, what trail conditions are like, where you can and can't camp, where you can and can't have a fire, how far is it to the next lake, things like that. And that's really important for the user out on the trail. There's a lot of people out there that maybe it's their first time out there or they haven't been in 20 years and they want to know, well gosh, I remember this was way easier when I was 20 years younger, how much further is it to the lake?
1:17:05 And so our stewards are out there helping to answer those types of questions. Also, we've developed a really robust interpretation and education program over the last few years. Some of them are listed down there. The Mammoth Consolidated Gold Mine is one of the most popular tours we've found. It's a great spot, great to talk about the history of the area, both Mammoth and Eastern Sierra.
1:17:34 A geology tour, wildflowers are great all summer long, natural history, night hikes, campfire programs, and we've come back and done this year after year, so it's really gotten to be a great program. And one thing I've said to people in the past is that the demand continues to be higher than the supply, and we're offering programs Thursday through Monday in the busy summer months, and they're
1:18:03 Very well attended, but we can offer more programs and they will still be well attended. People love it. And the next thing as far as our stewards on the ground getting out there, we provide a lot of volunteer coordination. So this is the capacity to work with a variety of volunteers and groups. So some of them are listed up here. The last couple of years we've gotten a really great program established with the Mammoth Ski and Snowboard Teams.
1:18:35 Going out with Nordic kids, Alpine kids, and now with the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation established, we've got a secondary set of funding to help improve this overall program and get volunteers out there working on trails, groups that call us up locally or out of the area, some of them listed here. We have those projects identified because we have those stewards on the ground.
1:19:05 Looking at what's going on, identifying needs, and saying, oh, we can get a group of 10 people for two days, we can put them to work up in the lakes basin, and that's volunteer hours that are translating into work that's getting done on the ground, which is invaluable. And then, of course, you've heard about our Summer of Stewardship Trail Days, which is a separate program that we're talking about today, but...
1:19:32 It really ties into the work that these stewards are doing on the ground because, as I said, they're out there identifying projects, seeing what is appropriate and meaningful for volunteers to go out and do. So there's a lot of planning going into this. There's a lot of historical knowledge. And these are the kinds of things that, you know, we're out there developing these programs of work. Do you want to go over this?
1:20:05 Interspersed through the last few slides, but just to recap, over the last couple summers, we had 967 unique participants to our interpretive tours. As I said, the gold mine tour is the most popular. And that's essentially, the busiest times are really from 4th of July to Labor Day. So that's essentially four total months of programs, and you had nearly 1,000 people coming out.
1:20:34 Over 1,400 visitor contacts, those are the interactions between users of the trails and our stewards out there, collecting trash, removing logs and boulders, repairing structures, cleaning up campfire rings, making the place pretty, and just regularly maintaining and regularly patrolling over 30 miles of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
1:21:02 Can I ask you a quick question on that? So this is over the last two years, is that correct? That's correct. And you said from June to September? That's for the interpretive programs. We do have interpretive programs in June as well, and oftentimes after Labor Day, but I would say the bulk of our regularly scheduled programs Thursday through Monday happen from Fourth of July weekend through Labor Day weekend. Okay.
1:21:30 The visitor contacts, that's where somebody actually approaches a steward on the trail and says, hey, how far to the next lake? Yeah, so it's more than a hi and walk on. It's asking a question or why do you have that shovel? How far is it? Yeah. And I guess that just seems low for, and maybe I'm mistaken, just as far as contacts with people asking questions.
1:21:58 Maybe just the days that people are on the trail explain some of that? Do you have any comment about that? As I qualify, it's more than just a high. It's the number of people that you actually engage with and are answering a question. And I would say that for the most part, the stewards aren't going out of their way to
1:22:26 Track somebody down and get, you know, information out of them. They're going about a, you know, a daily work schedule. And so, but they're there as a public face if people wanted to come to them. You know, I think that number would be a lot higher if we had somebody on the Duck Pass Trail, for example, every day. And we only have somebody on that High Use Trail one day a week. Much the other, you know, days of the week, they could be...
1:22:55 On Valentine, or Sherwood, or working on Mammoth Crest, or Crystal, somewhere where they're not always going to confront someone, not confront, but run into. And one of the things that you find when you're out there, when you do this work, is that people are trucking. They want to get to their destination. If they're generally either not lost or new, they just keep going. Because they're just like, oh, somebody's going to walk right by.
1:23:23 You know, as Drew said, that's really a quality public contact. It's more than two or three back and forth until we count. Okay. Fair enough. Thank you for that. In the future, one of the things we hope to do is up that number by potentially modifying the program, but to actually station people on high-use days in parking lots rather than roaming, because now the travel system is to a place that it's easier to maintain.
1:23:49 Invested now for five years in bringing them up to a level of maintainability. You can now afford to lock the trail every day and put them in a trailhead to sit there and talk to folks. And I think that's going to really blow those numbers up and it also adds a lot of value to the residents. I think we talked about doing that for this coming summer is that, you know, whether it's in trailheads or parking lots, something that is either a vest or some kind of
1:24:17 Identifier that the volunteer is wearing, that can say something, you know, not necessarily, but, hi, my name is, ask me a question. And we did go back and forth on that, and our folks did have our identifiers on, so you could tell they were not just some crazy person out there. Yeah, yeah, I remember that. So, you know, one of the things we wanted to wrap this up on,
1:24:43 is really discuss how this ties into the Trail System Master Plan because really that's what drives the funding that has supported this program for the last two years through the MLTSCC. And, you know, from beginning from the general plan vision statement for the town, you know, the idea of stewardship and supporting people who come here as well as locals who live here to enjoy this place.
1:25:10 has been key to what I think underpins a lot of this community. The goal of that Trail System Master Plan also talked about the economic benefits, the environmental and health benefits of getting people outside and improving their overall experience. And that has been the driving goal behind keeping this steward program, having paid people regularly on the ground out there and funded. And some of the direct elements that these folks and this program achieve
1:25:37 Are listed down there, element four through seven. Establish a trails-related education program. The interpretive programs that we put out there, you know, Drew is right. We constantly have people requesting specific trips for their family reunion, for their group, in addition to the limited number of regularly scheduled interpretive programs, you know, we offer. The demand far outstrips what's there.
1:26:02 Trips for Kids, the volunteerism that is done by the stewards is overwhelmingly with youth groups rather than with adult groups. This summer we actually had a few families call us up from Southern California who have second homes here. They wanted to do a project for all their high school boys. We put together a full weekend of different stewardship projects working on Panorama Dome, Valentine Lakes for their kids for free, getting their kids out on the ground.
1:26:31 Funded by the town. You know, element six, establish trail patrol. These people are out there. They know what they're doing. They're trained in first aid. They're trained in using a tool. They're out there with their eyes and ears. Oftentimes, they're the first people to find problems on the trail and report them back. And they help a lot of people not stay lost. And then element seven, you know, support nonprofit capacity to foster trail stewardship.
1:26:57 You know, that one's kind of obvious. The combination of this program and our partnership with MLTPA and the many, many other people that have come out before the SOS days has really, I believe, established a culture of public lands stewardship on the ground for this soft service trail system. That's an overview of the program and I would love to entertain any questions. Thanks very much. Questions? Got it.
1:27:28 Two things I forgot. Trails-related education program. For the last few years, we've produced a weekly trail report of conditions, and that trail report's been used by Stu and others, passed around, talking about what the conditions of the trails are. And over the last year, it's really evolved into highlighting a trail that we know if we send people on, they're not going to get lost and they're going to have a good time. And we provide a back story for what they're going to see in terms of wildflowers, wildlife, everything else. And how do you integrate that into the trail system website?
1:27:58 Exactly. That's the meaningful daily content that's going to keep people coming back. Yeah. And also one of the things perhaps why you saw a lot of mobile users out there is because that's our stewards were driving people to the website. Do you have a smartphone? Oh, you do. Let's go to this page. Here's where you are. Oh, I can look at the map on here. It became a great tool. So thanks for the reminder. Yeah.
1:28:26 Laura Beardsley, our Executive Director. Hi. I want to close. There may be questions, but we've got an amazing note in our office this summer, just a postcard, just a thank you, from a couple who has been coming to Mammoth regularly in the summers and has
1:28:50 begun to incorporate the interpretive programs that are offered through the summer through the Lakes Basin Stewards program as part of their regular visits and I meant to bring it with me but since I didn't I just want to convey what they said they've really started to plan their visits around this opportunity in the Lakes Basin.
1:29:13 They go on multiple programs when they're here for the week. They bring their grandkids with them, and they're really trying to instill that experience and share that experience both with their families and with their friends, and I think it's a real added value to what is available for folks to experience in the ice basin. Thanks. I have a couple questions.
1:29:41 Congratulations, I think. Friends of the Inyo do an incredible job with different partners in making the experience for guests and locals alike very valuable. The programs, interpretive programs, are they, is there a connection between Mammoth Lakes Tourism or somehow to get that word out? No, not yet. Not yet until this summer when
1:30:11 Mammoth Lakes Tourism was actually forwarded our trail report by Alicia from Mono County, and so began talking with them about how we could work together to market these programs. We have all of the content and work that we do goes through the Forest Service vetting process, so we've been largely working through that to keep these going, but I think that one thing we risk is over-marketing them and beginning to...
1:30:39 Decrease the quality of the experience, because on many of these trips, when you get upwards of 30 people showing up for a free hike to McLeod, you've kind of changed the experience that you were hoping to provide. And so if we were going to heavily market them that way, one thing we'd want to ensure is that we can provide the volume of trips so that we're not piling a lot of people on. And, you know, we've marketed them mostly through traditional summer means, which is...
1:31:10 Flyers and in the paper and in the website, kind of, you know, the more historic way, but I think that's the next step. Maybe that's something that could be considered by the Coordinating Committee. Yeah, thank you. For future summers, because I do hear that they're very popular.
1:31:29 And I know that that sometimes occurs too with the Forest Service programs up in Tamarack during the winter. I know sometimes there can be three people or 20 people showing up for snowshoeing or cross-country skiing and it can be a challenge. Yeah. And then also I know that the Sierra Club, because I received their newsletter, they also have some trails that they maintain or clean up.
1:31:54 Is there a coordinated effort? Yeah, there is. We've actually, for the last, I think, five years, worked in partnership with the Sierra Club on our closure event for the season, which is the Horseshoe Lake Cleaner. And then the Sierra Club also does backcountry outings that are multi-day with the Forest Service PAC supported, all your food. And we have staff that help provide technical expertise and guiding for many of those. Great. Terrific. Thank you.
1:32:23 Well, one of my questions was, are you pointing people to the website? And so I appreciate that you guys are actually doing that. It's good to explain where they're going, but then to be able to say, well, you know, you can go here for more information, and this shows exactly where you are. What partnership do you have with the Community Foundation? And there's funding coming into the same program, or is it a different program? No, the Community Foundation Partnership actually funds our engagement through this program with the Mammoth.
1:32:53 Nordic and Downhill Ski Teams. So what they do is basically pay for those kids to come out and do a day's worth of stewardship. We have a multi-day program that spans the summer so they get to see different parts of the project. And they come in and we use that to literally extend the season and keep people on the ground longer. So that program was beginning funding last year and I believe this year we did four.
1:33:21 Trips with them? Three trips with them last year was two. So this gave you the opportunity to do more work than you would have otherwise? Definitely, yeah. It allows us to offset and extend the Measure R dollars that are coming in. Originally, one thing to consider, when this program was originally started, it was funded at $80,000 a year. Eight-zero? Eight-zero. And we had a cadre of people out there. We had a coordinator. We had vehicles.
1:33:51 When we lost that funding from the Ski Area Conservation Fund through Mammoth Mountain, the program went from 80 to 32 is what it's funded at now. But I believe we've been able to maintain a level of presence on the ground that has not seen resource conditions or public interpretation slip in the Lakes Basin.
1:34:14 With the interpretive programs being as popular, is there an opportunity to charge a nominal fee to do something like this? There will be, but because they take place on public land, we would need to have a special use permit with the Forest Service to charge for those, and currently all of our activities are free, and so we don't go into the special use permit.
1:34:36 Arena. It would change our activities to one of guiding. So once you begin to charge, you change the nature of how you can work on public lands. Okay, I guess I was looking at that as being an opportunity to be able to expand the program. I know, it's something that we've thought of and discussed as well, but one more permitting process unfortunately takes away time, as you all know. So right now we're still focused on free, but it is something that we've...
1:35:06 We've looked at that fee-for-service opportunity could really help. Is there any opportunity to bring in volunteers to help with some of those interpretive programs to increase those? Yeah, actually this summer for the first time we had, well in the past there's been volunteers that we've helped coordinate that have largely focused on consolidated mine through the historical society. And this year for the first time we actually trained up volunteers to also do geology and McLeod.
1:35:36 Cloud Lake is geology. So Horseshoe Lake, McCloud, and Heart Lake, as well as the mine. So we expanded our one paid interpreter 400% by training new volunteers to come out and do it. One thing that was not originally built into the program, though, was that volunteer coordination and training piece. And so it's something that we hope to revive and build in, because I think you're right. I really think we do have a lot of passionate people we could pull on to...
1:36:04 Increase the amount of programs we offer up there. We just need to build that into the program and make sure that it's sustainable. Thanks. Terry, to get at what you were asking about, we have been able to use the support of Measure R funding from the town to leverage that to win grants to help augment what that funding enables us to do with other.
1:36:35 Through other sources. So we are actively looking at how we can do more by sharing the cost, I guess. And I wish I had my major R report for me because it actually showed, I think we brought in almost a 30% match in cash to this program last year that we submitted to you all in August. That has the detailed cash amounts in it. Maura? No, I'm good. Thank you.
1:37:07 Thanks. Thank you very much. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. Thanks very much. Okay, moving on to... Oh, we have another comment. I just wanted to add, Sandy Hogan, one of those who formerly carried that shovel in 1975 and 76, and that was one of the most frequent questions. What are you carrying that for? I was an alternate wilderness ranger up in a rich forest up in...
1:37:32 Lake Tahoe Basin. So it brought back some great memories to hear and the passion that people feel and it's really something. I also wanted to say, excuse me, brought back good memories. When I first, I don't know if I first met you, but when I first came here on the Inyo National Forest, the Friends of the Inyo, Bill would know this, but probably nobody else would know this, the Friends of the Inyo was not
1:38:02 in such friendly relationship with the Forest Service. As a matter of fact, there was a lot of this going on in the past. And I have to say, when Paul took over, you put your money where your mouth was by doing exactly this kind of work, which is really, you know, something that too often in the past I had as a district ranger elsewhere and here, not here so much, I think, at that point, but it experienced, you know, a lot of controversy from environmental groups who
1:38:32 All they wanted to do was complain. And that was when Bill and I were working together to make things happen. So the motorized community was working. And I have to say, when Paul took over, and that was about 2005, 2006? When you first shut up, I can't remember when you turned up. But he turned the program around and really, 2005, yeah, and really made the Friends of the Inyo into a friend of
1:38:58 Our resource, our public lands and whatever, and I mean going out and just starting programs and I don't know if you know that history, but I remember it, you know, and so, yes, Bill would know that and Paul, probably not too many other people. But anyway, they do a lot of things. The Forest Service over my years, you know, I saw a lot of budget drops and this and that and cuts, but we always managed to have some wilderness rangers, but when I came here was when really the cuts started happening. There are still a few, but, you know,
1:39:27 Organizations like this, they are the rangers anymore to the people on the ground. And that's, and that's, I just really want to say, you know, having come from that background, been retired for a long time, but seen all the progress here, it's really very impressive. And, and with John's presentation brought back a lot of memories also because I worked those GI, before GIS, right, we used topo maps, Bill knows.
1:39:52 That's all we used. And, of course, those are USGS maps, which I'm sure is what the Forest Service still uses. And, you know, for a while they used to be done every 10 years. And, of course, I'd be running into trails that, that's not here. Or, there's supposed to be a trail here and it isn't. And it's exactly, nothing happens fast in public land management. You know, trees grow slowly and management changes slowly. But the website opportunities that we talked about, especially the conditions reports.
1:40:20 The information that can be put out so that people know, yeah, if you're looking at a topo map, that section of map isn't there, but it helps provide that information and really bring them up to speed. You're never going to change USGS and their mapping or, you know, the long term, you know, maintenance isn't done daily or monthly or yearly or even sometimes every 10 years, but we can now have the technology with our website and everything to really bring that information up to date for people, and that's wonderful.
1:40:49 Anyway, just a few comments. Thanks, Paul. Thanks, Paul. Any other comments from the audience moving forward? I keep forgetting that we have to kick you on that. Moving forward, we will take a two-minute break. Two-minute break. Thank you.
1:41:29 Thank you.
1:41:53 Yeah. Hey, Bill.
1:42:22 I'll talk to them first. I'm glad you got the trials updated.
1:42:49 Thank you.
1:43:13 You're on pause, aren't you? Thank you.
1:43:42 And the end that you can drive to or walk to or drive to here, they have a first trailer that goes the same way, they have a course, the resting stations and quiet stations. It's a pretty incredible deal.
1:44:09 Okay, if everybody would like to take a seat again, here we are with agenda item number five, Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee update and requested action.
1:44:37 from yesterday's meeting. Thank you. Steve Spidell, MLTSCC Coordinator. I've handed out to the clerk as well as the commission and staff a recap of our meeting from yesterday with attachments. So if I might quickly go through our November 4th meeting. We talked about the Town of Mammoth Lakes MLTPA Spring 2012 Measure R Award.
1:45:06 which was the website enhancement development of the new pages. So as John alluded to, we're looking forward to receiving draft 190 plus or minus new pages. That delivery is scheduled for November 6th. The website partners have a review period of 14 days, which carries us to the 20th to make our comments. We'll be consolidating those and then passing them on to MLTPA with final posting onto the website prior to December 18th.
1:45:37 Also we discussed the spring 2012 Measure R Award for the website enhancement QR code development. So attached to this package is a letter from the town basically terminating that portion of the agreement. We had ongoing discussions or we had discussions regarding ongoing discussions with the Forest Service, ESEA and other potential consultants to carry that work effort forward.
1:46:05 The coordinator will work with the Public Works Department to ultimately develop an RFP for that scope of work. We also talked about the Lakes Basin early opening and late closure. That included... Teri? I have a question on the QR codes. So are the QR codes just the production of the QR codes or is it the content that it's pointing to as far as the QR code? It's the content on the eight existing interpretive signs. So it's additional...
1:46:35 Information that will come through the QR code to the smartphone device and will have explanations beyond what's written on the sign in front of you highlighting and basically adding more information about what it is that you're viewing at that particular interpretive station. Now will that live on the website as well or is that just strictly going to be an informational?
1:47:02 Yeah, that's how it connects through is through the website. Okay. So there'll be a landing page that goes to that. Right. Okay. We talked about the Lakes Basin early opening, late closure. We discussed dumpster unlocking. We discussed trash pickup. We talked about the different types of restrooms, the pit toilets versus the ones that have water and the opportunity to leave the pit toilets open longer with maps to the
1:47:35 I'm sorry. Yeah, have the pit toilets open longer, and then on the other toilets, MAP's directing you to the pit toilets. Vice Chairman Bill Taylor and Member Bill Sauser are going to be working with the Town of Mammoth Lakes Town Manager to draft a letter to the Forest Service in regards to these issues and see how we can work together to extend the season up in the lakes basin. Also, Friends of the Inyo and Mammoth Nordic talked about winter grooming at Shady Rest Campground.
1:48:05 Those discussions and processes are moving along very well and I'm pretty excited that we've had a very short period of time to focus on this and we've been able to get very positive results. So Mammoth Nordic will be notifying the Forest Service via a formal letter as to the transfer. Mammoth Nordic has transferred equipment over to Friends of the Inyo.
1:48:30 There's an opportunity to use existing Forest Service agreements and gain Forest Service approval. The committee yesterday recommended funding of not to exceed $20,000 for a period extending from December 15th to March 15th. There will be limited grooming this year compared to the past and it will mostly focus on the outside loop.
1:48:55 And then finally we're pending at this time Friends of the Inyo board approval for the concept and the details within the program. Also I've attached a portion of the master budget and tracking project list for fiscal year 13-14. And there are items in there that require Recreation Commission approval. So if you remember when we came to you earlier on with our budget.
1:49:20 We had certain items that were colored in red with an asterisk after it that needed additional discussion within the committee and then final funding approval was given to the Recreation Commission by Town Council for those items. They include the 221A Sharp Trail Alignment, $913, Project 551 Winter Grooming at Shady Rest Campground, the $20,000 that I just mentioned. Also 441 Mammoth Lakes.
1:49:50 Trail System Grant at 7,500. And then finally, project number 490.1, Wayfinding Mapping at 3,000. So if we can refer to that attachment that I've sent, provided to you, I reduced it down to 8.5 by 11. And it's a little hard to see, but that's all part of my master plan. Just like another bright yellow.
1:50:19 So, yeah, glasses, magnifying glasses. Trust me, you'll like it. So if we look on the first page, there's a yellow box there, and believe it or not, there's $913 in that space, and we're looking to get that approved funding for 2013-14 fiscal year, and that is to augment any construction or re-
1:50:51 Design of Trail Alignment for the Sharps Project that's ongoing. So we already have $20,000 allocated for this year. So this would be an additional $913 to that effort. Any questions on that? Why did you come up with $913? That particular number was a number that would carry us in our budget to exactly $300,000 of the allocated monies.
1:51:22 For Measure R. So it's a bit of a makeup number. But it was put in there to help fund a trail alignment that isn't needed. So the proposal is to move it from there into the cost, not cost share, cost share agreement with the Forest Service, which is going to need money for each of the next three years. And this just will preclude us having to put money in at a future time. So that's...
1:51:53 I just thought it was odd amount, so thank you for clarifying. So you're moving money into a cost share agreement where it's not been asked for and it's not needed at this point because they may need it at a later time. We know the cost share agreement is for $150,000 and every year we've been allocating about $50,000 for that ultimate project. And then within that we know that we are not going to be so lucky as that every trail alignment that came out of Sharp,
1:52:22 Doesn't need to be realigned. You know, there's probably an environmental impact out there somewhere, a habitat issue. So we may need those funds to help with the realignment of that trail. I find the way you guys do this so confusing and I think it's so convoluted it's crazy. I'm sorry. I think that somehow it needs to be addressed. Something like that, I'm sorry. I think that, you know, if you want to...
1:52:51 I guess to sit there and put it, we're doing the same thing. You put money into a reserve. So if you put money into a reserve for a certain thing at some point, but just because there's money left over to spend to tag it, just, I don't know. Because it seems like a huge shell game. I'm sorry. I've been listening to this and I've been trying to figure it out and it's, well, this is, no, we don't want to do this anymore, so now it's moved over here and now we've got to go over here. And, you know, I know budgets are fluent.
1:53:18 Fluid and you move them around and maybe it's because we're trying too hard to keep them tagged to a specific project and maybe that's what the biggest issue is because it's a moving target. So to try to track that target has been very frustrating. And the target gets moved on us as well as on you. Remember when the initial allocations came out.
1:53:45 There was no cost share agreement and we did not know what those costs were going to be. They were allocated per an MLTPA application and others to do the trail alignment and then the Forest Service comes back and says, we want to use our personnel, we need to do it this way and here's how it needs to go with a budget and it caught, correct me if I'm wrong on this, with a budget saying this is what it's going to cost us to do the job. So now we have started moving money.
1:54:14 that was allocated for those trails over into this cost share agreement with the Forest Service to satisfy the needs of the project. So it may look convoluted, but it's actually going for the same thing. It's just the game plan on how we can get there has changed as information flows from that agency to this one. And why is it changing so much where they're able to say, now we need this much more money?
1:54:43 When you've started with a specific project and this is what that project is going to cost. The original cost estimates didn't come from the Forest Service because the original project was not something the Forest Service was pushing and is still not something the Forest Service is pushing. But it's on Forest Service land and if it's a project we want and we have said yes, this SHARP specifically is a project we want.
1:55:07 So we are now moving that along within the guidelines that the Forest Service is giving us to move them along. And it appears as though the money that we have allocated in the previous budgets, if we continue to allocate it correctly and move it into that cost share, will cover all costs. This little 913 for trail realignment,
1:55:33 We had not moved into that yet, but since we know for the next two years we're going to have to add money into that cost here at better than $50,000 apiece. It was $50,000 this year and $50,000 next year and something like $85,000 in the last year. And I don't remember the exact numbers. I'd have to go out to the truck and get my list. That's about right. So it may look like we're on target. It is just the rules on how we're going to get there.
1:56:02 And, you know, I'm sure it's because I haven't followed absolutely every step, but I don't know. If I was, and I am the public in this situation, you know, I sit there and I listen and I'm trying to follow what's going on and it is very difficult to follow.
1:56:17 Well, I think it's just the nature of it is just so different in how we handle other Measure R allocations, and I understand why it is that way, but it's just, you know, it does kind of seem like, oh, well, you know, this project didn't, you know, ran into some hurdles, so we're moving this money over here, and I'm glad that we have the tracking sheets that we can see. And I didn't have this yesterday when you guys were going over everything either, so it makes it really difficult to follow things, but you don't have the tracking sheet.
1:56:44 I'm sitting up behind the counter and he's cheering and it's tough for me to fall on sometimes. So anyways, it's just a comment and it's an observation and I don't know, you know, how to fix it, but I think it's maybe something that we need to be cognizant of and maybe see how, I don't know. I think maybe what you suggested that it is so stringently defined in each project area that doesn't give you the flexibility you need to shift money around.
1:57:11 And so maybe there's just, you know, an account or something or you just know that at some point there's going to be a plus or minus, a contingency of sorts. I think if I might add that some of these projects that we are working on are time and materials not to exceed. So even though we have a budget allocation for, for instance, there's one on page two where we had a budget allocation of $12,200.
1:57:37 But we've been invoiced for the final product and it's only $11,113. So yes, yeah, we saved a little money, we can put it somewhere else. And so I will take the criticism that it's highly detailed and that maybe it's too much information and it can get confusing and I'm the first to admit because I've got to follow all these numbers. I don't think that's the criticism at all, actually. It isn't a
1:58:01 I'm not trying to criticize. I'm trying to figure out how we could make this so that it would be easier for somebody to follow. And I'm not sure that the QuickBooks isn't going to resolve that. Because if I'm going to take a project that you're looking at, I can then look at, here's the start of this project. This is where it's gone. This is where we're at. We're three quarters of the way through this project. This is what's been spent. This is what's left. And you don't get that detail here. This is detailed. But you're not getting that type of detail.
1:58:30 You know, something like that is going to give us, and maybe I'm asking for too much, but when I'm looking at something that makes it a lot easier for me to track and say, okay, I see, we're three quarters of the way through this project, this is what we've done, this is where we're at, and this is how we can move forward and what we're going to need to move forward, and we're good or we're bad or, you know, it's either plus or minus. So, anyhow. And I think it's clear, I mean, especially from our discussions earlier about the maps and the website is, you know, there are going to be things that, you know,
1:58:58 That do need contingencies. And so, you know, I think it's more a question of when money does come up like that, you know, what's the best thing to shift it to? And, you know, I guess that's where we really rely on that committee that you guys know what you have to deal with. Yeah. And it's just kind of, it's an observation. And I know you're tracking it and you guys are, you know, doing your thing. I'm looking forward to this whole QuickBooks thing because I think it's going to answer a lot of my questions. Sure.
1:59:25 Okay, on page two then, I've got another item identified in yellow, and this is number 551, Winter Grooming Program at the Shady Rest Campground. So you can see in the past we had $20,000 approved from 12-13. We signed a contract for $20,000 in 12-13. We were billed $19,880. There's another place where we saved a little money and we're under budget. Yes.
1:59:52 And now we're asking you to approve $20,000 not to exceed for the Friends of the Inyo effort taking over from Mammoth Nordic. The next item down, 441 has to do with trail system grants. So we used that line item there to provide us for matching fund opportunities for grants as they come along.
2:00:19 We had $8,500 scheduled for the fiscal year 12-13. We did not spend that. We did not sign a contract for that. No funds were paid out for that. So we have a carryover to this year of $8,500. And then in our budget for this fiscal year 13-14, we're asking for additional $7,500.
2:00:42 and the committees suggesting that it stay in that category so that we again have funds available so that if opportunities for grant matching come forward and we're going to have further discussions about researching grants and so forth that we have those monies available to participate in those programs if they should avail themselves. And then finally
2:01:07 We have 490.1 Wayfinding, Signage, and Mapping Updates and Repairs. This is an example where in the past we had no money set aside for the repair for new updates that might be necessitated by completed projects or projects that are in the CIP that we can put down as future projects on the map.
2:01:36 So this year in our budget we were suggesting a $3,000 allotment to cover those costs and so we're asking for Recreation Commission approval to have $3,000 in our budget this year to replace the fiberglass panels on the type 4-6 and also the larger maps on both sides of the type 2 if it should become necessary to use those funds. So that concludes my presentation for our request for
2:02:05 Your approval for recommendations for finalizing our budget for fiscal year 13-14. Thank you. Questions? Does this eventually go to council or are we just the body that receives this information and says, you know, thumbs up or... It's this commission. And by the way, I actually want to clarify just a couple things that Steve said is that these monies, the $7,000 for the MLTS grants,
2:02:36 and the $3,000 for the wayfine mapping were already approved. We've just chose to keep those in their respective line items. And Teri, to your point, what's that? We've changed the line items. What's the change? I would have to go back and read how we originally, the wayfining and maps was for a specific project. That's correct. And we altered that yesterday to go into a fund for design.
2:03:05 Maintenance. Yeah. And installation. I'll put them back on. Design, manufacture, and installing. While it was for a specific sign or sign, we talked about allocating this in a fund so that when the maps need to be changed, there would be funds available. We wouldn't have to start it out as new. So that was the change on 490.1. Did I get that right? Yes. Correct.
2:03:33 I thought you had already approved that. Well, and I guess that's the point that I'm trying to make. You approved it. Do you have the version before was that you could read to them, Steve? I've got it in my files, but I think if you look down at the bottom of the page in red, it says that the asterisk in parentheses projects, those are subject to review, discussion, and require a motion with a vote by the committee and the Recreation Commission for final funding. So we've had our recommendations at the committee yesterday.
2:04:01 And these dollars in these spaces and projects are requiring your final approval. But I guess the point that I was trying to make is that we're not spending these monies until at least January, that we were going to be bringing these back for review. So it's not like we're moving them. The point that I was trying to make was that these have already been approved, which is why it doesn't need to go before town council. It just needs approval from this commission.
2:04:29 Well, in town council, to carry that further, town council gave you the authority to make the final decision on those asterisk numbers. You know, I'm all for, you know, queen of transparency, and I appreciate all that you've done, but it seems like to expedite things or to make the process flow a little bit better, you know, you have $300,000. I think if you make major changes to shifting money around, I think maybe that's when it needs to come back to us, but if you're just...
2:05:00 You know, it seems like a lot of extra work. That's what council said. They said, hey, if this is minor stuff, as you've noted, we had seven, if you recall, that had the red asterisk in parentheses, and we've come forward to you before for approval on the others to make a total of seven. And council said, yeah, hey, we don't want to see this stuff. This is micromanage. Go ahead and do your committee work. Make a recommendation.
2:05:28 Why don't you take it then to the Rec Commission and get them to approve it, and that's fine. So now I think I'm hearing that... Well, there were other members of the Recreation Commission that specifically asked for these to come back to the Rec Commission. So there was not a consensus. So I believe we decided to keep bringing them back since some wanted them back. I like seeing this, and my question is just in these categories where things are allocated towards certain things but they're not totally committed,
2:05:56 Like, for example, on the $3,000, you know, to update the maps, you know, if there's an opportunity to use some of that money also toward, you know, updating the maps on the website, I mean, could you guys just go ahead and do that without bringing it back to us, or would that have to be a new allocation? Well, actually, within our budget, we have some additional funds that the committee has the power to move around in that don't need approval, and so some of those are related to the website.
2:06:25 So that's where that money could come from if needed. Or let's say, for example, we have a really banner winter, and I would just like to thank Friends of Inyo, by the way, for stepping up and, you know, taking on this grooming project at Shady Rest. I know they're... They haven't done it yet. I know. I know they're forest laws to approve it, but I really do appreciate them, you know, making the effort to...
2:06:48 You know, to make that happen this winter. And so let's say that, you know, everything does move forward and we have a phenomenal winter and, you know, they need a few more thousand dollars to groom into May, you know. We don't interfere with fishing. We can't let that happen. But, you know, like the $7,500, you know, could some of that, you know, be reallocated, I guess, is my question. Well, actually, again, there are places.
2:07:16 There are places within our budget where we will have that ability to react to that if need be beyond these particular ones that we're asking you to review today. Unless the commission has changed its collective mind, it was my impression that the commission wanted to see those changes. So that's what we are doing is bringing them back so the whole commission can see those changes.
2:07:43 And I would say yes to that because I think there was a time where, you know, we're like, what are you guys actually doing? You know, we want to see what's happening and because we're not sitting at each of those meetings, we wanted to report that to everything else. But I would have to agree with Pat. I think that what you guys have going on here, I would like to see this report, but does it need to come back, I think, to us as far as a vote goes?
2:08:08 Because these were already voted for. It's not a major change. If there's a major shift in what you guys are doing and where money is going, then I would agree. I would like to see these. I would like you to explain, okay, this is what we've done. This is what we're going forward with. And I think that's what we're looking for is information and, you know, what's happening, at least in my opinion. That's it. All these items here were approved.
2:08:37 At least to some extent, they're being shifted a little bit as to what their purpose is, I think, without seeing the original and then seeing here's your budget and then here's how it's been changed. I think maybe that's where my problem is. Here's what your original was. Here's what's been changed. Here's what's been moved. And that way, you know, there's a beginning report. There's an end report.
2:09:03 This is what we originally approved. This is how things got moved around. This is what was quite accomplished. You know, maybe that's... So do I have consensus then from the commission that what you're looking for is informative and not necessarily voting on the changes within that $300,000 unless it's a major change? I would say maybe...
2:09:27 I hate to put a specific dollar amount on it, but there's a difference between shifting around $30,000 and shifting around $150,000. We did vote on these before, and these are sort of more minor changes, and I don't know how we can quantify that we don't need to re-vote on minor changes. Maybe it's just an FYI kind of thing, and then if there's something that there's a comment about.
2:09:55 Question it for him. But I would still like this to come forward. I mean, I think it still needs to come forward. It's great information. Yeah. I think what staff can suggest is it be in a consent item. Yeah. Right? So it's coming forward for approval if the commission feels it. Yeah, if the commission feels I want to, you know, talk about it and review it, you can open that item and discuss it. But otherwise, it'd be in consent, you'd still see it's very transparent.
2:10:18 We still like the opportunity for the Trails Committee and Steve and the group to come forward to the Commission and provide that verbal update. I think that's very important because we do want to keep that dialogue going back and forth. So maybe that could be what we would do. I think it's very difficult to quantify, like you said, to reduce the ambiguity because we don't want to have these two committees trying to think what each other's thinking. So I think if we just move it in consent, we'd still provide a verbal update and kind of move on with this type of thing.
2:10:46 And I think also what Commissioner Stehlik was talking about is a bit more of a policy in regards to, you know, allocating funds and ability to move or awarding funds to a specific project and requiring additional, you know, monies or, you know, those type of things, which is kind of a larger policy discussion in regards to how we're dealing with these special use taxes. And I think it's something that we're moving and talking about a little bit more often. I think Council's, you know, having that chat. I know we're going to have that chat. Measure U's going to have that chat. I mean, MLR's going to have that chat. You know.
2:11:14 About the best way to kind of, you know, structure these funds and, you know, so we do this in policy definition. So anyway, so I think that was more of a policy discussion and I think what we're saying here is, for this item, let's just bring it in consent. So it still keeps the hierarchy of approval, but in a probably less, you know, forceful manner maybe. Yeah. That's a good solution. Fine. So do we still need to vote on these?
2:11:44 We're putting an agenda to vote, so I'll make a motion to approve the allocations presented to us from the MLTSCC. I'll second it. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? I would like to bring up that I'd like to talk about the Nordic grooming, but it's not saying that I don't want to approve this, but I want to have a conversation. We will have that conversation after the vote. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed?
2:12:14 On behalf of the committee, thank you very much. Thanks, Steve. But did you want to ask about the grooming? Mr. Chairman, if I could, this is not a matter related to your vote you just took. But I'm wondering if and when there will be a report from the Forest Service on the progress that they're making on the sharp environmental work. It's a significant amount of money, and I'm concerned that
2:12:41 on behalf of all the participants in the Sherman Working Group and the very specific rationale that was provided for the various trails that the community does not get in the situation that the committee was in where the Forest Service kind of delivered a fait accompli and said, well, this is what we're going to do and this is what the trail is going to look like and you're just going to have to kind of live with it. And I think if this is going to be a three-year project, I think it's appropriate, you know, after the first summer season is over, the specialists have done their...
2:13:08 Their business, maybe the next meeting or two, there could be some sort of a public reporting on progress and where that project stands. Thank you. And that's the type of reporting that we definitely need. Yeah, I think that's just, I mean, we've, friends of Inyo and us today, we gave a report on the projects and things we're doing on. That's a very significant, very important project. A lot of dollars from the MLTSCC going that way. I think it would be great to have a public reporting where they're at with that project. Thank you. Good point. Would it be inappropriate to ask for that, Steve,
2:13:36 Well, actually, I think we probably would have gotten that had Mr. Recalbrook been able to attend the entire meeting yesterday. Okay. We did get a report, though. Yeah. We did get a report because that question was asked. The question was – and, John, I don't think you were here for that – but the question was asked the status of the resource surveys. And I think Patrick McGurby said that they were 100 percent done because, you know, it was one of these –
2:14:03 Early summers and everybody was a little bit worried about all the plants, you know, not getting to them in time. And just for information on the challenge cost share, the Forest Service started work before any of our town money was put in to the account. So the Forest Service money paid for because the
2:14:23 Forest Service personnel cannot work on a project until there's money in an account, so they use Forest Service money. There's no way to repay it. In other words, so that's part of the challenge cost share. So therefore, all of the surveys were done, which was a great question. I was glad to hear that, and it was actually 100% of them were done. So that was the status. So now the next steps in the process, okay, are that the specialists are all in the wintertime writing their reports and this and that, and then they will convene the...
2:14:52 Actually, the NEPA team. So those are the next steps. And when they do that, you know, they'll be using the challenge cost your dollars. But at least we know the resource surveys are done. So that's great. They did them in time. Is that, I just, thanks, and I couldn't attend the whole body of the meeting yesterday, but is that, I'm wondering if that's documented somewhere. Is there a, is there a work product or is there some, is there some physical things? I think that the, on what they said was,
2:15:26 Correct me if I'm wrong again here, guys. The on-ground work had been done. Now they are putting their reports together, which they will do over the course of the winter. And those reports will inform next summer's scope of work out of that cost share agreement. Did I get that right, Steve? It would be nice to see something tangible that says we've gone out and realigned trails based on what we've seen.
2:15:53 You know, Sharp Proposal 9, based on what we saw on the ground, now looks like this. It would be nice to have tangible, physical things. Yes, they need to get the reports written and then make those decisions. Okay, so that information will be in those reports? Yes. Okay. And they're not going to be realigning new trails without discussion. What they're doing now is just the environmental surveys to figure out what are the alternatives, are there any impacts. Yeah. Let's move back on to that normal discussion until it's more dramatic.
2:16:23 Okay. I sat through the whole conversation yesterday, and I do appreciate, because I know in the short time that, you know, Friends of the Inyo has stepped up and is looking at taking this on. But I just want to make sure as a commission that we're looking at the larger picture. And I know, Bill, you brought up yesterday the Nordic group that's out there, Eastern Sierra, Nordic, I believe it is. And we have a biathlon feasibility study.
2:16:50 I think that we need to look at the whole Nordic program as a whole. What is it that we're trying to accomplish? Who are the partners that we can partner with to make that happen? And what does it look like? So I know this is kind of a fire that we're looking at putting out right now. And I appreciate that you're stepping up to put that fire out. And I'm all for moving that forward. But it is just a discussion that's kind of like with our priorities.
2:17:15 It's one of those things that we need to sit down and have that conversation. We continue to band-aid it and put the fire out every single year, but we haven't resolved the problem or answered any of the questions. And I think that's something that we absolutely need to move forward and do. And I would just add to that that, you know, the Trail System Master Plan lays out some pretty specific recommendations in terms of, you know, winter grooming, you know, or, you know, snow management of the mumps, and I think we do need to be looking at it, you know, in a holistic way.
2:17:45 Well, and we really need to, and I really thank you for saying that because for two years I've been saying we need to, if we're going to manage snow, we need to be looking at the best, most effective way of doing that. Is there NORDONI and the tow behind the adequate piece of equipment? One of the reasons that in Paul's presentation they're talking about the outside loop only is because what a horrific job it is to groom the inside loop.
2:18:11 With that piece of equipment, people get it stuck, it doesn't make the turns, you can't back up. So, yes, we need to look at all of this and determine what it's going to take to make that class thing happen out there. The amount of time it's taking to groom the short number we have, to me personally, is not acceptable. But if that's what that piece of equipment can do, then we need to move beyond that and find a better solution.
2:18:38 Steve, do you want to speak to the concept of the Winter Summit that we've scheduled for discussion after the first of the year? Right. One of our future agenda items is to look at a larger program beyond grooming it, Shady Rice Campground, beyond grooming on the MUPS and title it a Winter Summit. If you recall from the
2:19:07 Trail System Master Plan years ago, we had a summer summit. A lot of great information came up through that process. There was great conversations between the Forest Service, Public Works Department, and other interesting parties, and we came up with some great ideas. At the time, we didn't have the time to put together a winter summit, and so it's always been, to your point, Teri, there's a need for a larger discussion.
2:19:36 That goes all the way from sidewalk grooming, you know, how this place functions for the pedestrian, for the recreationalist in the winter. And that is on our future agenda items for the Trails Committee to look at. Thank you. Snow management. Yeah. Yeah, I agree with you both. I just want to make sure that we don't lose track and we just kind of fall back into the same thing and, you know, this is working so let's just keep doing. We need to.
2:20:08 You know, look at the whole picture. Yep. Okay. Moving on to the MLR update. Thank you, Chair. So this item is at the request of the Commission placed on the agenda. It's at this time probably more of an informational item versus an actionable item for the Commission today. Essentially the staff report before you is the presentation made to Town Council on October 16th.
2:20:39 You can see it identifies the scope of work that the smaller steering committee is going to be undertaking, which commences on Tuesday at 1 o'clock for that small steering committee. We've scheduled about five meetings, about 15 plus hours of additional work on the process. So the scope of work here is in four steps. Again, it's just an informational piece.
2:21:05 Step 1 is what the group's going to be reviewing on Tuesday, essentially. Step 2 will be following on from that. Step 3 is an interesting discussion on both Measure R and Measure U in regards to, again, more of a strategic perspective on investing those funds, and that's the discussion probably where it would be relevant to have kind of a policy discussion on those funds.
2:21:35 And the Town Manager and I are kind of working on a little piece right now to kind of help that discussion. And then also, you know, the discussion about a joint or a special use tax advisory body. So that's something that I think both the Commission and the U Application Committee would benefit from discussing for that process. And then finally, integrating everything into RecStrats, because ultimately that's really where we want to kind of fill the loop.
2:22:02 You can see on bottom of page 2 it identifies the steering committee. Page 3 talks about the meeting dates. They're all scheduled here in suite Z. And then public participation was referenced at the meeting. And a strategic marketing group have identified kind of four points here that they'd like to include in that process to more effectively or to provide the opportunity for public comment during those meetings.
2:22:32 So you can see here we've kind of listed those as well. And then finally, after the four or five meetings, you can see the next step there has those five points. And again, the results and the recommendations of the smaller steering committee again would be brought back before council, before moving on to either forming an MLR or not. So again, this step is really trying to complete phase one of that process, or what we call step.
2:23:03 2A. So that's really the recommendation here before you. It's again just an informational item, an opportunity for the commission to discuss the process or to provide any recommendations to council or strategic marketing group. And in the staff report I've attached, which was posted to the town website when we posted the town council agenda, which was the report to town council on October 16th. So that's the attachment that includes that information as well, if the public want to review that.
2:23:33 Document. That's all I have. Questions for Stu? I have a comment. I'm glad to see that there will be public input after each agenda item, so I think that makes it a little bit more responsive. And I know that we've looked at all of the different plans that affect recreation in this community, and certainly RecStrats was the most recent documentation, but I'm wondering where does the
2:24:04 Park and Recreation Master Plan fall into any of the discussions because I look at that as being maybe, you know, it had a different approach and the consultants really, you know, had a different twist on it as opposed to just, they looked at other standards as opposed to RecStrats which was, you know, 95 unique people commenting on recreation.
2:24:34 So does that, the master plan, does that fall into this discussion at any point? And maybe Betsy and Teri being on the committee. I actually asked the consultants the same thing because, you know, an understanding that, you know, they were, you know, helped to form RecStrats. And so the response is sort of that RecStrats is really, you know, the strategy is to get us to some of the things that are in the Parks and Rec master plan. So, you know, I think that it will be important for that.
2:25:02 Steering Committee going forward to understand the executive summaries from each of our documents, the Trail System Master Plan, Parks and Rec Master Plan. So we won't be solely looking at RecStrats, but RecStrats has some of the strategies to get us toward implementation of the things in the adopted plans. And I think any time we're working with anything within Parks and Rec, you're looking at the Master Plan, but the Master Plan is kind of a level of service and what the items are that are needed within a population of such and such.
2:25:32 And the RecStrats was kind of more of an implementation plan of things that came up that the public had desired. But I think you're going to be looking at both, along with every other plan that we have, trails, system, master plan. And so I think all of those are going to come into play with municipal recreation and Mammoth Lakes recreation. I think it would be an absolute. Well, I know, obviously, you and Betsy are...
2:26:01 Very much aware of all of the plans, having just gone through it in a workshop kind of format for the last several months, but I don't know about the other members of the steering committee and how, you know, maybe as mentioned, if there's a summary of it, but how much in-depth information do they really, or background information do they have? So I guess we rely on the two of you to make sure that that is conveyed. I think that's a good point. I'll just jump in quickly, Chair.
2:26:32 You know, step one of the scope of work next week is to review current municipal services. And, I mean, within that, you know, I was just writing down notes. You know, that's a PowerPoint that I put together previously for the Commission Council. That'll be kind of presented. I'll also kind of attach the Executive Summary, the Parks Master Plan, Trial System Master Plan. We also did some work previously on stated deliverables and the role of the Recreation Department.
2:26:58 So I'm trying to provide that smaller steering committee with kind of, you know, that informational packet as much as I can on the role of current services we provide. So that was good because I actually was able to add more to my list of what we need to talk about. Again, I think that's really step one to really understand what we're currently doing and how we're delivering those services. So thank you. The only red flag that was thrown up for me is step three. We put together a huge committee that looked at
2:27:27 Whether an MLR was needed and the determination was that core was very important and that there may be room for an MLR and let's look into that by furthering going down into it. However, the scope of work to discuss how Measure R and you can be more strategically invested. R was certainly looked at a potential funding source for any entity that has come out there. I'm not sure where.
2:27:54 Looking at how R&U are allocated came under the scope of work of this smaller committee and the... So maybe I missed something somewhere. I believe this item was actually in the original scope of work that was drafted and they just didn't get to it that first round, Chair. So all this information was part of phase one. It was never completed. So this is really the detail that this group and that smaller committee has to really evaluate.
2:28:24 I believe this information has been in front of the commission, and it's certainly been in front of the committee previously, so I'm interested to get your thoughts on that, and that's kind of why it's here. Yeah, I just, I'm very nervous about those two things as staff in the past, and then others in the past have tried to shift how that is used to free up burdens someplace today. Ah, right, you're talking about that. Ah, right, yeah.
2:28:48 And I think you have a lot of company in that, so it's going to be a lively discussion. I didn't think they should look at it. I just said, for me, that the big red flag started waving in front of my face when I saw how that was worked out in there. The commission and the ARC and the U committee and the original committees on both need to be consulted on any major changes in how those allocations are going to. And I would think they will be. Yeah.
2:29:14 I think that was the policy discussion. Other than that, I was very comfortable with our representatives on that committee at any rate. And I think, too, Chair, that was the reference that's being made kind of several times by the mayor in regards to, you know, we wanted to make sure that the money follows the strategy and the goals of the town, not the other way around. I think that's really kind of that reference. Any other questions? Okay, moving right along then.
2:29:46 Item 7, approve the public donation recognition policy for product and services to the town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Department. So this item was a carryover from the previous meeting. The only revision that staff made, if you didn't notice that, was on page 2. We actually went in and put in some funding-level recommendations, which is the top of page 2. And again, for the public that might not have been present at the last meeting. So this was...
2:30:17 An agenda item to really discuss how the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Department can recognise in-kind donations or donations made to the town. And what we currently do, we had that kind of long discussion, so we've included some recommendations, we've done a little bit of research, you can see from other organisations and how they address it. It's kind of a fascinating process where
2:30:45 We're probably in the Level 1, Level 2 phase. I know we did receive, I think about $80,000 of funding for the plaza at the tourism, which was kind of rare, right? And that's why Level 4 is really on a case-by-case basis. So that's something, if someone really comes forward with that amount of money, well, let's talk about it. But Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3 are pretty straightforward as far as we're concerned. So what we're really looking for here is...
2:31:14 Just a review by the Commission. Any other suggestions you might have or recommendations? But this is something we can certainly implement and move forward with. I just had a comment. I was surprised on page three to see that very few persons or organizations that make financial donations to the town seek deductible contributions. Maybe people don't realize that the town is an entity for which they could receive a tax deduction or is it just that they're...
2:31:45 Really super altruistic people in our community, which wouldn't surprise me. Right. Yeah, so you can see the letter I provided to the swim team, I mean, it doesn't have any reference to, you know, claiming that deduction, but, you know, they certainly can use that letter, I would think, and maybe use that as their, you know, tracking the funds, but that's from a non-profit to a government, so. Yeah, I mean, I would think for an organization it would be different, but certainly for, you know, an individual looking to make a generous donation. Yeah.
2:32:14 I kind of had comments about I thought it might be nice if the mayor also sign communications to the groups. I don't know if that lends a little to that. So even at level one? Yeah, sure, why not? Yeah. Good to see that the commission chair would also be involved. And I was kind of concerned about a donor must request recognition for an accepted donation. You know, I think they should just automatically receive it.
2:32:39 Unless they ask not to. Unless they ask not to. Or maybe that's a question as opposed to them asking, we ask. We would like to give you public recognition. And there are some people that say, no, I don't want that. And so as opposed to them having to ask, we can ask them. And it's clarified. And then I thought for, I guess you mentioned level four case by case basis. But I think for naming rights, I think
2:33:08 There should be a more significant donation than $10,000. You know, I think a name on a plaque or something at the building or up in the park or whatever, but it's a name of a building or a trail or, I don't know. It could just be a shelter. I mean, a little. Well, maybe it would then vary, you know. And, you know, most of our, well, not most of our, but a lot of our facilities are actually on.
2:33:35 Forest Service Land with the Use Permit. And so the amount of recognition, you know, may be limited with their approval as well. In this case, at the Welcome Center where that family, initially they were just talking about you need a batch or you need something else. And the discussion was, well, really, we need to finish the plaza area. He said, okay, well, how much is that? He just wrote a check. Which is, you know, pretty good. It covered all the costs, staff costs and everything.
2:34:03 And so there is a plaque there for in memory of his son and for service to approve that. That's not normally what they would do, but it was a large donation and it's got a benefit to the facility and the community as a whole. So a plaque as opposed to naming it the so-and-so plaza. Yeah. Okay. And I think that, you know, we had this discussion years ago, but we need a policy as to
2:34:31 How something is named? And, you know, I think it would clarify then what your concerns are there. It's just another whole layer. But there needs to be a naming policy. You know, one of the other ones that we were working with the track club was ready to Whitmore. And that part really never got off the ground. What the Department of Water and Power wanted to see was kind of that overall strategy of how you were going to have.
2:34:58 Different sponsors and how they'd be recognized. And so when we're doing it, we ought to try to integrate something that includes that type of naming as well. That was my one question on those four levels. One other thing I was wondering, should there be some continuity in the uniformity of plaques? And you might, maybe it's the...
2:35:22 The wording or the text is about the same, but maybe the look could be different because you might want something maybe more whimsical at a park versus a building, but maybe the same kind of wording. We do actually somewhere have a policy on plaques for benches and buildings. In my mind, I've seen it before because it was brought forward for us to look at once upon a time.
2:35:50 But I don't know what that is. Finished it, though. I know we have talked about naming conventions and coming up with appropriate historical names and things so as things come up they could be the, you know. We've only talked about also if somebody was donating something, what, you know. Right, size, scope, where it can go, those sorts of things. And what the policy would be on the naming of those things. But I don't think it was ever finished. I don't know where that information went, but I don't think it was finished.
2:36:21 No, it was never finished. That I do know. But in the staff report from that was some information on the town's current policy. So there is something somewhere on that. With our computer system, it may not exist anymore. I don't know. But I know I've seen it in the past. No, during when Dana was here.
2:36:47 In terms of the Level 1, Level 2, Level 3 recognition, and I'm sure staff is well aware of this, if a Cub Scout group comes up with 400 bucks, that's worthy of a piece of the paper, even though it's only a Level 1. So we still sort of have to look at these things individually and not just pigeonhole them. A small group like that making whatever small contribution is a press release is great positive PR for the town and the town can certainly use.
2:37:16 All the great positive PR can get. So while I agree in principle to most of how this is laid out, I would hope that we would be looking at all of this in terms of, you know, if it's a bazillionaire and he gives us $600, he doesn't need as much as a Cub Scout troop who gives us $300. So there is, there's got to be that gray area, that leeway, in my opinion, anyway.
2:37:43 I think what you could do, Chair, if you want is to combine level one and level two, so just eliminate. So level one is from one dollar to two, four, nine, nine, which kind of includes Commissioner Agnich's point and maybe your point. So there's just three levels, so you've obviously got that, you know, lower level. That might be the best way to kind of move that forward. I would love to put level one and two together. Is this also for in-kind services? It is. Services.
2:38:13 Yeah, okay. I just see the word tangible. Yeah, services. Yeah, I think that's going to be defined as tangible. Yeah, so it's financial in kind. So it's, you know, the pool supplier that comes down and donates his time working with Dennis. So he's, you know, he's sourced that equipment and he's down there with Dennis donating his time, putting together those type of things. Yeah, anytime someone spends that kind of time, even if it doesn't come up to a $2,500 level, they deserve a little. Yeah.
2:38:46 Recognition in front of council or in front of this body. The only other thing that I put a circle on, and I realize this is intended for large donors who want their recognition to be a plaque or something that we don't want to have to pay for. But depending on the level of recognition, the donor will be responsible for the payment of all costs associated with the recognition. Well, you know, if somebody chips in 100 grand towards something, I'll buy the plaque.
2:39:14 And I had a problem with that one, too. I went, really? You know, somebody's giving you something, and this is when you're going to put a plaque, so it has to be a significant enough amount of money that you're receiving that I would think that the town could foot the bill for the plaque that we have to put out there.
2:39:34 I was like, oh, thanks, but you have to pay for a C-Quota. Yeah, so if you want to donate that $100,000, you've got to give us $100,000 and $250,000 so that we can buy your plaque. And that goes along with item C as well, where the donor will be responsible for maintenance or replacement of any recognition plaque related to the item. That kind of goes along with B, I think. Yeah. Well, and I put there in my notes, benches.
2:40:05 One of the things that we do is we allow people to donate benches for the trail system and have done it and there's a memorial plaque on those benches. So when the bench has reached the end of its useful life, I'm assuming we maintain those benches once they're put in. We do maintain them once they're put in. Yeah, we don't. So we bill the donor, the cost of the bench, they purchase the plaque, we certainly give them the...
2:40:34 The sources they can get it. And then we billed for the installation. So it's a net program for the town. So A through E, these were just recommendations that I just kind of identified. I wasn't particularly going to attach them to those levels, but if that's something you want to amend, we could. So that was really up to me. No, I just think because each one is different depending on what the donation is. Correct.
2:41:03 It's only case by case. The plaques, if they need replacing because the bench has reached the end of its life and they want the plaque to stay there, then they need to donate another bench and another plaque. But if it's a building that's going to last for, you know, as long as the building's there, we should be replacing and maintaining that plaque.
2:41:25 Well, there's a note here that the recommendations above reference large contributions per facilities. So I think we're talking about something a lot bigger than benches. Recreation Senate. Yeah. I would almost ask that we scratch B, period. You know, if we feel that the expense is going to be too much if we're trying to put something in the paper, maybe we put something in quarterly. Maybe it's not something you put something in every single time somebody does that. So we take out one ad.
2:41:54 Every quarter or every six months or something like that and you can list everybody so you're not, you know, taking out an ad every single time something happens. I think the intent there was just like that's our town bulletin. Okay, so the recreation this week or your townie news, yeah. It's really not cost so I wasn't, yeah, it wasn't conflict. So I guess I would scratch fee. I don't know if there's a reason not to scratch fee. I just really think that that's...
2:42:22 I think what we could say there is the town is, you know, willing to include a recognition in existing, you know, communication, you know, channels and sources, you know, for the donor. But I think that was included in Level 3 anyway. So, but we could scrap it. I mean, I don't know if we need to. Yeah, that would just change the donor may be responsible. You said that you had checked in with other municipalities, that you had collected precedent.
2:42:51 For these levels? Well, that's what we're looking at here, actually. So this was from the Central Region Parks and Recreation. So this is actually a governing body that oversees a lot of them. And this is kind of their recommendations that they prescribe to municipalities. So again, they kind of collate a lot of the donations or the processes out there and their policies and kind of put this forward.
2:43:17 This is from the article that you've included to the Parks and Recreation? No, not actually. That article is actually in our, you know, we get that as a monthly magazine on Forward, those two commissions, you can look at those. But that article is quite interesting because it talks about it, you know, when you read it, you know, the influence that the donor can have on those parks and, you know, what they expect with those funds, which mightn't be in the public's big interest. You know, so I think there's caution there when somebody comes forward with a...
2:43:43 A large donation that comes with expectation that might be in the best interest. Or it's not congruent with the Commission's mission. I was going to say, if the strings attached are not something that's beneficial, then you don't accept the donation. Exactly right. I think you really should reconsider it. So I'm happy to either move forward with the revised Level 1, 2, and 3. It's really up to Commission if you want to attach these other guidelines below, or if you just want to amend them.
2:44:12 Completely up to you. Again, those were really for discussion, and they're really more relevant towards larger facilities. Probably not common that we're dealing with here on a monthly basis. That's something that we'd come back, obviously, with the Commission and say, look, a family wishing to donate X amount of dollars. Let's go through this process and come up with some recommendations. So completely up to the Commission. What we really seek is just approval to move forward on Level 1, 2, and 3.
2:44:41 Yeah, and that's what I would do. I think the ABCDE is more of a staff guideline than it is something that we would show to prospective donors anyway. And part of these may go into a naming convention or something like that, yeah. I think it's good to know, though, that a donation is only good through the useful life of a product because, you know, what if you...
2:45:09 Do they know that when they're donating so that somebody knows at some point the benches know at least that the plaque would only be good for the useful life. I think the benches are there for eternity. Those are pretty sturdy. They're pretty sturdy. They're not wearing chairs to the weather. A bit more susceptible, yeah.
2:45:29 Okay. So that's all. I'd really be seeking a motion just on approving, you know, the level one, which is now kind of one and two. Do you need a motion or can consensus work for you? Well, I'll make a motion to move level one, to combine level one and level two, and to accept then level one, two, and three as presented. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion?
2:45:59 All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? So future agenda items, we need the naming policies. Let me heat it up and see if I can find it all. I'll go back and forth with the chair and we can kind of get that in the schedule. Probably typically, it might be next year, obviously, only because December's looking pretty busy. Thanks for bringing this down. We can always move it up if someone... You've got some meetings. Okay, moving on to number eight.
2:46:24 Review the Consultant Scope of Work and Provide Recommendations to Staff on the Facilitated Parks Master Planning Workshop, scheduled on November 8th. Slide. So this is a continued discussion from our last month meeting related to kind of focusing the commission on reviewing the master plan and doing a detailed workshop reviewing the previous recommendations and also
2:46:56 Looking specifically at the tennis court project, which Measure R. funded in 2010. From that project, the town currently has completed a soils report, recommended foundation requirements for the tennis courts, and we surveyed the site itself. We have had a scope of work from Brett Long, the landscape architect, to do additional work related to laying out
2:47:24 Reviewing the existing concept plan and laying out two additional courts for that facility. So a big portion of the discussion on Friday will be looking at the park and facilitating discussion of where do we go from here for that, any additional tennis courts and maybe a timeline of when the replacements might occur.
2:47:52 The other part of the scope, which would be paid for out of our contractual services budget, is to look at the overall parks, Mammoth Creek Park, re-look at Whitmore Park, and the bell-shaped parcel. Yeah, Whitmore. To look at the long-range strategy of those parks, what facilities, what feasibility study would help, you know, maybe that would help facilitate
2:48:23 Overall Park Improvements. And, you know, just help the commission basically go through those questions that were asked before in the master plan and have some actionable items when we're done with the discussion on Friday. So initially we'd have a field review of everything except for Whitmore. Since it's out of town, we all pretty much know what's out there. And come back and have a working lunch with the discussion of
2:48:55 These facilities. So there is a scope of work, two scopes of work, one for specifically Community Center Park and the other one really to look at the other two parks. There will be two, Brett Long, let's also bring in a principal along whose specialty really is in recreation facility development so he can answer those kinds of questions and help facilitate.
2:49:27 An overall discussion of what actions we want to take from that, moving forward from that discussion. And what the scope, if we do have a scope of work for a major application to do further planning on the parks. So we're meeting at 10 o'clock in the morning and we're going to tour all these things and then still have this conversation in an hour and a half. We're going to meet at 10, back at 11, and I kind of put the meeting until 2. Oh, okay. That's okay. So we'll be here for...
2:50:00 Essentially three hours, but we'd set the tables up in a workshop format, bring some food, I know the chair has to get out of town at some point, so we're trying to keep it early and keep that discussion. We're trying to probably leave before that two o'clock, because I will stick as long as I can. We could mix up that order, too, if we really wanted, so we could do the facility planning first, then the master planning discussion, and then
2:50:30 The end of the discussion, or the second half, could be the Community Centre Town School discussion, and it's up to the Commission on how you want to really begin the discussion. I think the premise of it was to really kind of get some strategic focus in regards to what do we do now? We've got the prioritisation, we've done all our work through our facilities. This is kind of potentially the next step from the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, and it's triggered into a Measure R application if that's what we want to move forward with. So I think...
2:50:56 From staff's point of view, we're really eager to kind of get into that discussion and see what the consultants kind of recommend. I think it's a great, the way we're trying to set up is a great dialogue between the commission and the consultants to really understand, you know, what the scope should be and where we should go from here. Let's get something done. So there's two deliverables we'll get from the consultants. One is some detailed information about Community Center Park and then the other is really a...
2:51:25 Synopsis of the meeting for the general discussion of the other and direction from the looking at the other parks. One of the things I will have him do when he's here is, as you know, we have problems with tennis courts with the undulations, which are really related to root, you know, which trees do we need to remove and I'm going to try to facilitate that next summer so that we, you know, Cal Fire maybe will help us remove some of those larger trees at a lower expense.
2:51:55 And so this is only going to be $3,000 to do all of this? For this one-day exercise. And the $9,000 that was previously spent is what you just said, the soils report? And the survey. And then from that, we want direction, you know, what's the next steps at Community Center Park? We want to go ahead and complete the design and some technical specifications so we will be ready to bid.
2:52:24 Any future resurface, basically reconstructing or the new courts themselves. That question still lies out there. They go there. And then the other thing you had in here is, you know, what is the community center? And so I think when we're looking at a rec center, do we have a rec center and a community center? Or, you know, they one in the same kind of type thing. And that'd be part of the decision that I ask them to prep for so they can answer some of those questions.
2:52:52 We did reference it in the second section there. And we're meeting here at 10 o'clock, right? Yeah, let's start here and then we'll work out vehicles. I missed the fact that we were going to be there until possibly 2 o'clock, so I need to do some employee gathering.
2:53:10 We probably can't start any earlier because we have the consultants left and start at 10. We'll have an LTC meeting that actually goes a little beyond 10, so. But the consultants we could have. And you wanted the consultants to go with us to the parks. We could have them come. You may have started at 9. That's easier on them. Are the consultants here? Because I thought you wanted them to walk with the parks. No, no. I think they were going to drive down Friday morning, but we can.
2:53:38 Do it from time. So if you want to say 9, you can maybe go to 9 on 30, we can get back to you on that. Wherever the consensus is on good, we can maybe wrap it up by lunchtime then. I mean, I'm not good. I can start early. 9.30 to 1.30 would work better for me personally, but I can go either way. Is it the only plan I'd be in here? 9.30, yeah. Okay, I just wanted to make sure. So we're shooting for 9.30 or 9? Let's go for 9.30. Let's go.
2:54:06 I don't know, I already wrote in 9 o'clock. Let's go at 9 and then we'll be done by 1. We're shooting for 9? Not at 1. Okay. We've got the meeting until, you know, the group starts here at 10, so we'll go back to 9. We'll still provide lunch. How about that? So if you can make it to 12, we'll have snacks, sandwiches.
2:54:32 Is there any comments on the scope of work? I mean, anything that we want to get back to the consultant now in regards to, I mean, because this is really an opportunity. We want to make sure we're maximizing their time. So what does the agenda look like? So we haven't actually, so they need, they'll be sending us an agenda tomorrow, which we can email out to everybody. And is there anything that we need to do prior to the meeting to brush up on?
2:55:04 Yeah, it's really looking at the parks plans and those next steps that were in our last staff report. So they're going to help us with this matrix that we've kind of put together and they're going to... They're both experienced in resort recreation areas and so they can speak well to what facilities our competition has.
2:55:33 Why they have them, what they see, what their benefits are. I think it's really good questions. Maybe the commission spend a little time on the questions you might want to praise to the consultant. That might be helpful too. So if we have that in advance, maybe that's something you can email us after the meeting and get to us. So they're very focused on what your question is going to be. They can kind of prepare. I mean, kind of everything. There's some here that you have or you can get to us. People can get it to the consultant before they travel down on Thursday.
2:56:05 Maybe the commissioners could just send us those questions just to make sure we're covering them. I think one of them is coming down for the weekend of vacation. The other one is going to be going back. So they'll probably be in two cars. With regard to the tennis court designs, what has the $9,000 been spent on so far? So that was SOAS report and foundation recommendations for the court surface itself. At the current location? And surveying the property so we know.
2:56:35 It was done, I think, in 2010 when the application actually went out. 2010, 2011. Okay. I just want to understand, and it says here, understand the opportunities and constraints of the current site. You know, so I definitely want to understand that component. So one of the questions I talked to him a little bit about was there had been discussion about whether or not we want to try to have a covered court at that location or not.
2:57:02 You know, be prepared to talk about what the benefits are of that and how it might fit with the existing court orientation. He did have some initial ideas about a different court layout, slightly different than the concept plan. Okay. Okay. Any more questions? I just want to make sure that I'm not going to call Peter Brad. What was that? On, um, the...
2:57:39 On page three, I'm going to say Brad, just make sure. Oh, the first one or the second one? Both. Oh, Brad, if this proposal meets, you know, that's Brad. That's Pete's middle name, did you know that? Your alias. That's their kind of middle name. Gotcha. Okay, moving on then to manager's report. So, yeah, my first thing there was that wind kind of really hit that...
2:58:11 Rink pretty hard. So we're submitting an insurance claim probably for about $8,000 to $10,000 of damage. So that's what it was, it was wind. I was wondering what it was. Remember that? Yeah, we got that wind event Sunday. It was fine on Friday. We didn't get it. They didn't know. I mean, it's all strapped. So they've got a lot of the bracing in place. They strapped it, but we're still getting the supports in place.
2:58:38 As I said, our deductible's five, and we'll probably, you know, reclaim the additional glass that was broken, and the other parts are coming in, and then we, one of the scape rams flipped over, and that was cracked and shattered, so we have to replace that as well, so it was a pretty, pretty damaging event, it really kind of. It took a very healthy tree down. Yeah, it was savage. I didn't think it was that strong, but at least mine. No, it was. It was brutal. Well, it looks like in that area, and that probably talks to a structure.
2:59:07 Or awning or something over the ice rink. How strong it would have to be. So kind of put the wind out of Dennis' sails. He was actually on schedule there for a while. Actually, I think it was ahead of schedule. Now he's behind schedule. Is there any way to put it in holes or something in the glass so that it can take some wind and go through it? Well, what's the full structures up around for it to hold in the glass? It'll support the rim.
2:59:35 Yeah, it was under construction. So close. Yeah, close. So it wasn't completely fastened out. Uh-oh. We didn't have everything in place, but we'll get that done. But we have moved additional staff. So we have two staff working with Dennis utilizing those Measure R dollars to try and get that thing, you know, completed. And we've still got to complete that trailer refit too. We've got to run power.
3:00:03 Lights, and we're trying to build out some boxes and shelving for the guests to use that facility. The Horned Rink, we talked about, that was very successful, so thanks everyone for coming along. Tree lighting ceremony's coming up, I don't want to talk about this too much. We met today, we're going to try and bring back an indoor soccer league at the high school gym, so it's a great program again, it'll be kind of an adult co-ed program. And then we did want to finalize some meeting days and times with Commissioner Turner.
3:00:33 Truex on getting the subcommittee together. So I thought maybe at this time we could look at some calendars and know about that. And I have a couple comments to that. No, just on the Rec programming. Yep. And because I think that's great. But this was in our packet last month that we didn't get to. But I would have loved to have the conversation still. I do have some comments. I'll get them to you guys before your meetings. But it would be nice as a commission to be able to have.
3:01:01 A conversation. We said we absolutely, they can move forward with all of that, but I think it's still good to have that conversation as a whole commission. And I'll say, you know, and maybe I'm missing something, but kind of in the community, something that I've heard that is missing are toddler programs. And so it may be something that we can look at as we're moving forward. And we do have a new toddler program at the community center, right?
3:01:29 Yeah, they were going for a month just to see how it went, but they did do that every, I can't remember what day it was, but we did that. And we have a market that come in and do those programs. I think we're a little bit limited. We really kind of focus on the 5 to 12, just because of some laws regarding day care and those type of programs and what facilities we can use.
3:01:51 It's a good discussion, so we're happy to have that. What we'll probably do is when we meet with the subcommittee, we'll bring that back to the commission and we can... And I guess if that's the case, then that would be good. So at least if that's why we don't have those, then I know what that answer is. But with licensing, you know, you can have classes that don't require licensing.
3:02:09 Well, and there are some other organizations in the community, like First Five, Mono County, does some playgroup programming, and then the library also has a pretty robust, like their story times are twice a week, they're oriented toward five and under, so, you know, even though we're not doing it, you know, it is happening. I think John actually put together about a page and a half of this, because Marianna actually at the time had the twins, and she goes, what can I do with these three-year-olds? And John whipped out a page and a half of activities that parents can do, so, you know.
3:02:39 We certainly maybe are not providing everything. There is, I think, a lot out there for that community. So maybe it's more of a kind of informational list. And maybe it is. Hey, look at all these things you can do. And if there's some holes there, maybe we can fill it. But again, we're really geared towards that high elementary, middle school age. So I don't know if Betsy, you did reply to what your availability is like. And I don't know what Sean's like.
3:03:09 Yeah, I'm doing a lot of traveling these days. Maybe after a meeting we can just... Yeah, let's talk about it after a meeting. I'll pull out my calendar and we'll go from there. And then just quickly, so December we'll be bringing back the reconciliation and everything for the commission to review. So did you guys actually meet on October 21st? No, no. For the event market feasibility study? Oh, we did, yeah. We're right here on the other side. Oh, right there you go.
3:03:38 Okay. Yeah, so we did that small review group, so that was... Which I'm supposed to be a part of, so I guess I'm wondering why I wasn't called for that. I've only been called for one meeting, so I had that whole process. I'll check with Bill on that. No, I made one meeting. That's the only one I was called for. Got it. I wasn't given any information for it.
3:04:01 But anyway, from that we received a direction that they'd like to bring that. Council would like to bring that back to the commissions and communities in January after MLR. They just want to kind of complete that process and then get that back on schedule. So I think that was the feedback we had. I apologize if we weren't invited. Is there anything in that report, the preliminary report, that would help us on Friday?
3:04:26 It would actually be nice to have the report, if it's done, and if it's, it would be nice to have to review. Yep. I mean, we talked about actually visiting Sam's Wood Site to specifically see that area that was cleared for Blueza Palooza. You drive by, I mean, you're on the way. Yeah, I mean, heck, at this point you can drive all the way in, which is kind of nice. We wanted to walk that site, and I went down and walked the site for the foundation.
3:04:53 And I wanted to walk the wood side as well. So we can maybe get together and do that separately? I don't know. Well, I mean, it's on the way. I mean, it's two, three blocks away from the community center. It'd be great to... We can do that while we're... The bull-shaped parcels, right? Yeah, come right past it. And I mean, literally, it's so close to the road, we can pull over and get out long enough to look at it. I would like to do that. Because that was part of what we were going to do. Yeah.
3:05:22 So can we include that? Yep. Yeah, is there any reason why we can't get this event feasibility study now? No. So that we can look at that and possibly see what's up. I sent you one version already, didn't I? I'm sure I've sent it. Yeah, you have. Okay. If there's anything that's changed to get a final version. I'm assuming you've made some changes. I would assume so. I'll have a look and make sure you've got the right one. And then, because we kind of passed this, so I'm going to go back to the Measure R Spring Award.
3:05:49 And the ball field fence is being contracted. Was there any monies that came from the county? Did we get anything for that? I did talk to the county about that, and the new facility person basically said they don't have any money to help us with the cattle guard. And I let him know the fence was actually being provided by the town. They said no on the cattle guard. That's too bad. Yeah. Did we put that in writing, or is it just a verbal? That was a verbal.
3:06:20 I can certainly send them a letter and have them respond. It would be nice. If you wanted to sign the Rec Commission's name to it, I'd have no problem. I talked to him a little bit about some long-term needs that we're going to need out there, which is the waterline replacement. Our pumping system with a well supplies water to the parks as well as the animal shelter. And then all the water that they utilize at the dump comes from Whitmore Park.
3:06:49 I let him know that we're going to need to replace that line at some point within the next couple of years, and we expect that to be budgeted through their capital program. And so that was an eye-opening for him because he didn't realize that they were responsible for half the maintenance costs, including capital costs. Yeah, so then maybe with that clarification that they're responsible for that, maybe we can go back to the calendar again. So, you know, because that is something that...
3:07:21 Every little bit helps. Yeah, definitely. Okay, sorry. Yeah, I'd like to move this on. Thanks for keeping us on. I have another meeting when this one's over. Good. I have one, right. Stu, did you have anything else? I just had one more question on the...
3:07:35 The Reservation Policy for the Community Center. Do you guys collect any type of a security deposit and do a check after these folks leave so that they're charged for any cleanup or anything else? We do. The issue was, you can see, though, it was happening Friday night, and then we had programs that set them in line. Saturday. It just killed us. And they keep, you know, you've got little four, six-year-olds doing gymnastics on carpet that's, you know, got alcohol and doodle of it. Yeah, that's not good.
3:08:02 So that was really where we put the limitations on. So we have a security deposit for other things. For instance, the Jazz Jubilee, so that there was, you know, bad carpet that was damaged, so they ended up paying, actually, for the carpet. And then the vacuum cleaner broke, so we kind of worked that out. So, you know, we have those agreements. Okay. And then staff does provide oversight, or they come back at the end of the event, or...?
3:08:30 Yeah, I mean, I think now that we've kind of reduced those type of events, you know, the oversight's a little bit easier, you know, it's really just for meeting space or the venues used for, you know, non-food or, you know, beverage and alcohol, you know, a little oversight's needed, but they collect that key deposit.
3:08:47 You know, with that group, and it's all through ActiveNet. So it's all there. There's a deposit. Anyway, so it's all policed, and Derek's in that facility all the time. So if we have a reservation, he's up there checking it out. He let us know about the vacuum and the carpet and so forth. So when we're looking at a facility, you need a floor in that's appropriate for stuff like that. Yeah, not carpet.
3:09:09 Would that eliminate a lot of revenue? I mean, were there a lot of groups that were asking for that kind of use? There was a handful of events that we had those. It was really quinceañeras, you know, which are really big events. And they go to more applicable venues, you know, like Canyon Lodge or restaurants, you know, you can host them. Crowley. Crowley, exactly. You know, the community, we're not really set up for that type of event, right? No. I think that's all we've tried to limit is really for recreational meeting purpose. Yeah. That was kind of...
3:09:38 Yeah. It isn't set. Yeah. Thank you for explaining that, Steve. Yeah, I appreciate that. And then just to let the commission know, we did remove the railing, the avalanche rails along Lake Mary Bike Path today, and so there'll be the signs out that we say, you know, that section of the trail is closed, but certainly people can utilize it until the snow falls. The policy is when we expect snow or the first week of November, we remove the railing. Okay.
3:10:08 I have one question on the track. You put up signage about proper use, which I think is great. Is there something more interior to the park? It's on the gate. On the gate entering, like off of the highway? No. When you walk in the facility to the track, there's two signs right there. Obviously, we need a lot more because it's still kids and kids, right?
3:10:34 I don't know that another sign's going to make any difference, though. Right. It's coach education. It's coach education, and it's just there. Fortunately, I was there for a lot of those events, and I was able to police that, but it's stringent. You have to be on it all the time. Those kids are cool. They've got a lot of stuff on those fields, right? Anyway, but it worked really well. I mean, we had two good tournaments there. It was all day. Everyone was, you know, it's phenomenal. And one of those days is when we had a little bit of snow here at Shady Breast in the cold. You walk down there, and...
3:11:05 Stunning, you know, it was blue, it was a little protected. Different world. Different world, and, you know, it didn't matter what it was doing. Even got rain on it, it was actually great. And we'll try and keep that as best we can, that's available for the boys and girls soccer teams, as best we can. Like I said, you know, anything more than a foot just gets a little bit challenging, but, you know, we had some volunteers in AOSO went off and shoveled that field last week.
3:11:32 So it's, you know, pretty impressive. People are very eager to use it, so. Okay. That's all I have. Is the repair to the track surface, is that complete? The repair to the track surface is complete. They've striped it. They did a very good job of blending it. You know, next year you won't, right now it looks brand new in that section, but after a year of a little bit of sunlight, it'll both look very close to the same. Okay. Okay. Any other questions for the manager on his report?
3:12:03 Moving on to commission reports, Sean. None from me. No, I just attended the town Halloween party. I thought it was nice to have it at that venue. Nice to see some people out using the rink. Good. Nope. Okay. None here. It's the request for agenda items. I always forget this one. I put this up before reports next time.
3:12:29 So that workshop is Friday. Then the next scheduled meeting, according to your calendar year, is December 3rd, which is your joint meeting with the Measure U Application Committee to review any joint planning applications. And then we're back again on December 10th for the first applicant presentations. And then December 17th, if necessary, again.
3:12:58 So we're pretty full. So if we want to add something, let us know. Oh, you're going to have programs that are coming up. Programs will be coming up. Yeah. We want to put that in there somewhere. As long as it's done. Otherwise, if it can go to January, then that's fine. Yeah. I'd recommend if we could push it to January only because we've just got a crazy month. But that's okay. Yeah, that's fine. I can get the comments to the commission as a whole on what we're doing.
3:13:29 Staff's going to be pretty, I mean, we've got this, and we've got Measure U, and we've got MLR going on, so we're just... I think we're good. We're kind of here. I'll take a motion. I have a question, though. When are you going to start preparing the budget for next fiscal year? Like February, March, something like that? I think December, January. Yeah. Dan's actually working on an item with the council. I think it's...
3:13:56 Mid-November, I think it'll be 20th on kind of an organizational structure that he wants to propose. And then following that would be kind of a, and there's a mid-year budget review, end-of-year budget review actually by finance at that time as well. So we'll be able to get the wrap-up of last year, and then we'll be looking at a mid-year, I think, in January. January. For the mid-year, and then after that they'll get going on the budget too. I think as a commission, I think you've...
3:14:21 Talked about it. Bill, I know, has suggested that we try to make a push for more maintenance dollars to come forward. So if there's any little bit of funding available. And what can we do as a body to help push that forward? Same thing we always do, beat on council. Try to have a workshop with them where we make that one of our agenda items. The crisis state that we've gotten into because we have not allocated proper funds to recreation.
3:14:51 Well, and also I think as Council sets their priorities for the next fiscal year, I mean, this year, I think that it's sort of distressing to hear, you know, road maintenance gets such a higher priority than parks and recreation facility maintenance. That's something we just need to be better advocates for. I think collectively it would be good if we could push something forward as opposed to just going up to the podium and making a presentation. Yeah, I think that's a great role for the Commission to be.
3:15:20 The strongest advocate. And we will be having workshops with them or we can request workshops. Anytime. To deal with this. Absolutely. I'm still looking for that motion. I move to adjourn. Second. I have a motion and a second to make further discussion at risk of life. All those in favor. Aye. Aye. Opposed. Unanimous. Thank you all. Thank you. Thank you. Good job. Bill?
3:15:49 He's not going to be able to attend a partner's meeting. He's not going to be able to attend a partner's meeting.