TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013

Parks & Recreation Commission Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 42 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

216 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Thank you.

0:42 Okay. I'm going to go ahead and reconvene this meeting of, special meeting of the Parks and Rec Commission or the Recreation Commission. Bill Sauser had to leave after the field trip and so I'll be taking over the meeting from here. So we'll go ahead and open public comments once again. If there's anybody that has public comments that do not show on the agenda. Okay, we'll close that again and we'll move on to the

1:11 Our consultants that are here today. Welcome. Is this on? Thanks for having us. Again, I'm Brett Long. I'm with Verde Design, Inc. And this is Derek McKees, the principal and owner of Verde. And we're landscape architects and engineers. And I've done a little bit of work with you before, so I'm glad to be back. And thanks for the tour. It was very informative. We've prepared just a little bit of a presentation to go through, first, the community center.

1:40 Park and Tennis Courts to kind of hash out some of the thoughts on that because there's been some work done preliminarily in the past and there's some thoughts on what that might be able to become. We can talk about some of the feasibilities here today and then we're also going to talk about the opportunities that are the broader picture of the community center and parks in general throughout the town of Mammoth Lakes. Before we start, were there any questions you guys had for us?

2:09 in general about what we do or where we're coming from. Again, we're landscape architects and engineers, and we specialize in parks, and particularly parks and sports and recreation throughout northern California, into Nevada and the west. So, we'll keep going. So, our site walk, this is basically our agenda from the site walk today. What we'd like to talk about is

2:43 The Community Center reviewing that and review the Parks and Rec Master Plan just a little bit and go through what it told us about that site. We're going to look at the existing site opportunities and constraints and then potential improvements at that site. We can also discuss within the opportunities and constraints as to the opportunities of it hosting those courts as well as maybe the constraints that are part of that site for having the courts.

3:12 So we can look at a larger component to that park. The potential improvements and then additional programming and park elements that you may have interest in for that site. So we can talk about a broader piece than just the tennis courts. I just wanted to review your goals for the Park and Rec Master Plan. I think this is pertinent to the courts as well as what you're dealing with for...

3:45 Other improvements. Maintaining in parks an open space within adjacent town for outdoor recreation and contemplation. Provide additional parks within the town, and that's an important concept when we talk about these elements and where they are in proximity to everything. Create a master plan for an integrated trail system that will maintain and enhance convenient public access and park lands. So you have a lot of that underway. We want to make sure that whatever we do is connecting to those.

4:14 to those trails. Provide and encourage a wide variety of outdoor and indoor recreation, federally accessible, and that's important because we'll be looking at the tennis courts in general. You only have one set right now, and when we look at your level of service, you probably need to have at least that much for a town this size. I think you'll see that there's more when you hit 2025, you're going to be projected to need more than you have now. That's a different discussion.

4:44 And then we have link to parks and open space with well-designed year-round network of public corridors and trails, provide parks and recreation facilities and programs that foster a sense of community and nurture emotional connection people have with each other and Mammoth Lake. So one of the things I want to just bring to the front is the importance of those tennis courts, the importance of that community center, whether it's in that location or not.

5:08 There are definitely things that you have required within your own master plan. I just wanted to refresh your guys' memory. You're probably aware of these goals, but I wanted to bring them to the forefront as that's what we use to help us define what's going to be priorities for design. This is from the master plan. This is for the community center part. The center is reserved for use a majority of the time, although there are occasional openings during weekly.

5:39 Weekdays, especially on Fridays and select weekends. And I'm asking, is this comment from your master plan still hold true? The tennis courts are well used from May through September and the most difficult times to access court during tournaments and other special events such as free social doubles. Staff estimates that the courts are used about 60% capacity during the tennis season. And so we can talk about

6:08 Is that still the case, that this is taken from the master plan? Probably generally the case. It's probably a little less than that currently with some of the shift of the Saturday turns. Okay. Sure. Well, and the fact that here it is in November, you had...

6:26 Two, you had four people playing tennis, and actually sweeping off the courts, that was a good sign for the use for tennis or at least popularity. So this is the level of service and recreation need, and you can see the dates on this. Basically, you have, this is your recommended size. You would have currently just a little less than that, so you're pretty close on your acreage for courts. Existing number of facilities is six.

6:55 And then to meet the 2006 level of service, you would have needed one more to bring seven. And then by 2025, your projection is for four additional courts to what you already have. So some of the discussion we've had in the past was to add two more courts to bring it to an easier tournament play so that you had the ability, because you don't have lights, to have a certain match numbers during daylight hours that would allow

7:23 In combination with some of the private courts, certain tournaments. And that's been the direction that we've heard over the last, or at least when we've been getting information about this facility. So it would seem that as you move forward, additional courts for the town are recommended, whether that's the priority or we just improve what you have, that's a different item.

7:52 There's our courts. There's our nice aerial of the site. You can see that we're pretty much in the optimal alignment of north-south for tennis. We'll talk shortly here about the opportunities and constraints, but you have parking, you have a restroom, and you have easy access to the courts at this point that can be brought to ADA compliance pretty quickly if it's not.

8:19 And you have other facilities that are adjacent. And the proximity to users is also very good. So the site itself, like I said, you're very close to the town or the Mammoth village. And so you have a large user base already in that location. These are, I'm going through the, right now I'm going to go through the opportunities. And we'll talk about the constraints here shortly.

8:50 But you have a lot of use that is coming not only from the town but also from tourists that are nearby. And that's very good for this type of facility for recreation for the tennis courts. You also have existing courts that are functioning well, so that's a very nice opportunity. You don't have to rebuild anything. You're able to, if you make improvements, have a lot of cost benefits to that. So if you were to start over somewhere else, there's a considerable difference.

9:19 Price that you're probably looking at. It's not only through the design, but also through the cost of developing a new site. Think about all the things that are provided here. You have parking, you have facilities, and you have the area graded out, and you actually have space for two additional courts without too much additional grading and effect on the neighbors. And you also have a very important constraint is that you have

9:48 Neighbors that are accepting and happy with the current use. So as you've seen in other developments, when you move or put a new port somewhere else or you put facilities somewhere else, you have challenges. And because this is an existing use, it's a much simpler process to expand what you have versus relocating to another area. The other benefits in this site condition are that they're

10:17 There's pretty good wind protection, and you have a reasonably good layout for courts, and you can get a lot of courts in this little area, which is a pretty nice setup. The constraints are you don't have too, too much room to expand any more than a couple of courts. You do have neighbors that are close by, so your limitations probably would have a difficult time.

10:47 Doing Lit Courts in the future, if that was something that was of interest. You have a higher elevation, and you have some shading, and that causes probably a shortened tennis season. This is a good year for this time. Oftentimes, what do we have, two, three, four feet snow right by this time?

11:13 It just happens to be clear and warm, and more importantly in the spring. So we know how it is here. You may not be able to, without clearing them, get out there until June, depending on the year. So that's an important consideration based on that location, whereas some of the areas lower or in full exposure can melt off much, much quicker. We haven't talked about heating courts at this point.

11:40 Pricey option, or covered courts, but there are alternatives that go beyond maybe what we've been thinking about as standard recreation court system. Beyond those tennis courts, you do have the lease agreement that we've discussed that basically keeps the park in somewhat of its current condition, or you at least keep one of the buildings as is for the next eight years. Am I correct in that? That's one of the limitations.

12:10 Opportunity or constraint could go either way. And then one of the other opportunities I didn't mention, you do have a nice little play area as well. So it's always nice to have that tot lot or playground whenever you have an active or passive use because you're providing for families, a secure place for the younger ones to do something while you're doing the adult or older children's activities.

12:40 If we go back. We have the community center park. I'm just, you know, I don't know. Because you've said that, you know, we have courts right now and they don't have to be replaced. But that's not what we've been told. We've been told that they absolutely need to be torn out and replaced. That's not, that's, yeah, I apologize if that's the way it came across. It's not that they don't need to be replaced or that they don't need improvements. It's that their current footprint is already there. So whatever you do.

13:09 is less expensive in this site than if you put them somewhere else. So replacing the existing quartz is, it's really a non-option to have usable quartz. At some point, there's a lifespan. You have asphalt quartz out there, the asphalt shrinks over time, and you can continually battle the cracking, replacing, patching, and you can do that for extended times. One of the alternatives now, and it's becoming more and more common for these types of facilities, is to

13:38 Do a post-tension structural steel and concrete system where you have a lot less cracking, a lot longer duration, and you're really just doing surface dressing for a longer 20-year cycle. So there's no question tennis courts need to be replaced. It's a maintenance item. It's not a construction item necessarily. At some point, asphalt tennis courts need to be dug up, rebased, and replaced.

14:08 And with that probably comes a lot of the other things, fencing improvements, pathways. So you make, oftentimes, those improvements make other improvements a lot more affordable. How many times have they been resurfaced? Well, currently we do a crack repair every year, and that's about $7,000. We've done total resurfacing four years ago, I think, and that was about $5,000.

14:39 The courts themselves were constructed prior to town incorporation, so they're at least 30 plus years old. And so the shrinkage, the asphalt shrinkage curves were on the higher end of that, and so we'd get, you know, an inch of shrinkage a year. We did it when I first started with the town, about 1998, we did a major.

15:08 Right after the skateboarders had taken over and the net put something cut down. They were really in the nets there. That was when we put in the nets. Since then, I don't know if maybe a couple of them resurfaced once, but even far between, mostly it's been repairs. Right. It was evident you can see the normal cracking, particularly in these, you know, we have much more.

15:35 At first weather conditions up here, the extreme cold and hot temperatures are hard on the asphalt because it causes the cracker faster. Do we have the root problem? Do you have root intrusion from the nearby trees? That can be resolved with removal of some trees and may actually help the overall quartz by reducing the amount of pine needles and debris as well as providing more open sun. So you want to be careful. You want to balance. You want to keep the same, you know.

16:03 Proceed in doing the improvements and you can remove trees. You want to have the same aesthetic, but you also want to provide the best opportunity for the snow to clear and to have uninterrupted sun. Peter, how difficult would that be? Would we need any permits, besides just a tree removal permit, but would we need any special permits from town to remove those trees to, as you said, reduce the amount of damage to the quartz, pine needles, and give more sun?

16:33 No, essentially, and I've started working on that this summer with the fire department. They just, with their crew this year, they weren't interested in taking on that risk. So next summer, we do plan to take out some of the trees. Okay, so you've already been thinking about that. And it's those ones that are, the 24, 30-inch trees that are within a few feet of the fence. I'll flip back to this.

17:01 This was done by Triad Homes a few years ago, a brief conceptual study. They've got a nice survey of the site, but there's a look at the potential use of the space just to the east of the quartz to add on. And this one's kind of unusual. I'm not sure why this was showing a detached system. From our walks and my experience in looking at it and having a brief discussion with Eric earlier, it would appear that simply attaching another set of quartz

17:30 and would create the least amount of cost, be the most efficient, and particularly if you're going to be redoing the other courts, you could have the six here attached and then have a nice kind of terraced situation next to that hillside. And it's fairly flat, so you'd have a pretty good balance of cut and fill.

17:54 I'm not sure why, without knowing all the details as to why that concept has come up, we, just in our initial exploration, it looked like a fairly, a reasonably simple process to add courts onto the side and do an overall improvement to that footprint. That's a very, this is, and the reason we're bringing this up, this is very cost effective. Whether or not it's the best thing to do, there's a lot of information that you have that

18:20 We're thinking about as far as larger components that we can start to incorporate. But as far as this site, it does very well for this type of facility. And there's a lot of opportunities that outweigh the site constraints.

18:34 That's just where we are with that.

19:00 Just on our walk, it seemed like there was a reasonable buffer between the existing courts and the property lines. When we talked about it, you have some good forest land in between.

19:28 Biggest benefits of that is that, not necessarily for improvement, but that it does provide that buffer and that you have happy neighbors. So that's an important thing to look at if there were to be changes out here. The other opportunities that are there are for improved parking. If you look at this, that's a considerable amount of parking for just tennis. You know, obviously we have the buildings down below, but there's...

19:56 There's opportunities to improve the parking and make more. Whether the city uses that for other uses remains to be seen, but there's some really good opportunities to make more efficient the spaces that are out there, but still maintain the footprint of the things that are more expensive to move.

20:15 Can you even talk to me earlier about the entry, when the entry was on forest trail, meaning to be renovated in business? Was it the tennis court entry, or was it more than? Tennis court entry, because it's very, when you try to pull, come out of there, there's a hill on the curb, and it's not a safe under site. So that was the relocation, that's why I think they've shown the relocation, that's pretty much the concept. Okay, yeah, this is where you're thinking the courts have moved down, and the entry to the...

20:45 Talking about the entry on this side. The existing entry's over here. Yeah, it's over there. And this was actually, would be, this court would move down, that would move down. So you give up a little bit of parking, but you move the entry to there, which is safer. Were they not given the conceptual plan? So the conceptual plan actually had two alternatives. One was done, and this was the other one. Right, because we talked about one. Because Red Star has this kind of thing.

21:11 The other thing is they incorporated it onto this plan. And basically what tried to do was cat eye to see if they just seized by elsewhere. And so now the geometry is. It also provides the sidewalk. When we create a condo project, they were responsible to pull the sidewalk on their front edge. Rather than build it on their side of the road, they agreed to put it on the north side of the road.

21:38 But that's the property that's in bankruptcy now. Yeah, so basically it goes with the frontage now. It's not in bankruptcy, is it? Or it was, no, it's foreclosed, isn't it? The Golden Creek? This project is not in bankruptcy. That one's not, oh, okay. No, it's... How much more parking could we get with more efficient? Well, that remains to be seen. You have to start to do the design, but it may be, you may not gain a lot of parking, but it may be a lot better.

22:07 Layout, Easier Access, and I think when you look at it, there's the opportunities that we're also in the lower section that we're partnering up with. One of the things that we would like to know is the need for those, we saw what your LOS was and your projections for need. Is there strong desires of the commitment to two more courts? Is that a really important thing?

22:37 to have for tournament play or for otherwise the high school using them? Is it getting impacted so that the six is not enough regularly? And then secondly, if so, is one of the opportunities to relocate two courts elsewhere to another area where they would have a smaller footprint or might be cost effective to build just two courts in another area that would get more use because

23:05 People can quickly access them from a different direction. So that's a great question for you to determine because there are, like I said, there's good opportunity in the side there. There's enough room, but you will have to do some grading. And there are some constraints with the property lines. So there may be other sites that, say, Mammoth Creek Park, maybe the two courts could go there that satisfy.

23:36 They're part of the tournament match play, but that are closer to those homeowners as well. What are you typically seeing as far as a tennis facility goes? Do most people look at having a tournament site, so having all of those courts there, or spread throughout town so it doesn't impact one area? You see actually quite a bit of spread out. Tennis courts are...

24:04 People will go where they have to. So I've seen there are quite a few places, particularly in the mountain towns, because they're going to be a destination to play. People want to come up, they want a vacation, and they're going to want to set up tournaments. And so there's a realization that probably they're all going to be clumped in the same spot. That's kind of an unusual condition. However, oftentimes the high schools, there's a joint use condition.

24:33 If there's a lot of courts around, alternatively, then that's balanced out. And so six courts is a fairly typical, when you look at these mountain towns, you see six courts is not an unusual thing. But it depends on oftentimes, usually more often, the size of your high school is how big your, and what that program is. Here you have a...

25:02 In fact, tennis court use has been dimensioned. There's been less demand for tennis courts. Typically what we're doing in communities is just renovating what they have. But for high schools and community colleges that we work on, we are seeing those courts typically get to the one of eight if they didn't have eight. We probably do about eight to ten courts a year.

25:30 But typically most of those are high schools or community colleges where there is definitely more competition and then there is a community use agreement for those schools. But in the community uses, there are some communities that do have a large tennis demand and there are some that definitely, and they're taking out tennis sports and repurposing for other reasons. But the original proposal was, and I think that was why, because

26:02 I know Gale, I thought I was in tennis experience playing a little bit, but this was a proposal of a similar to, I think, the early commission, but it was for eight because of Gale said that that was the standard tennis center that you could run tournaments out of whatever. And conditionally, in the old days here, I mean, boy, in the 80s and 90s, we'd get down something like 700 tennis players playing for a man's program, and every quarter of town was a program.

26:32 And that's when Mammoth actually, where Snow Creek actually got another four or five courts. And the other thing that we were having conversations with and we would like to continue and start again, but we have a new superintendent, is the school has some property and looking at having some opportunities and what might

26:54 Work if there's any partnerships that can happen. And so kind of with you guys talking about, you know, is that something that would be better served maybe over in that area? But that's a conversation that we need to start having again in our school. No, they used to, and they let them deteriorate and go away. And that's one of the things you'll see, consolidating the area where they are helps them in maintenance. So if you have too many, then they just become deferred maintenance items.

27:25 Don't serve the purpose that they were intended to. So you want to have that perfect balance of just always thinking you could use one more, but finding other ways around that. And I think the reality of, it brings up another question, is the private courts that are available for those tournaments, that count wasn't provided to us. What is the total town number that would be included to that? I'm not sure that everybody's kept their court.

27:52 Courts up so that we have as many as we used to have. Snow Creek has, how many does Snow Creek have out there? Five. So Snow Creek Athletic Club has five courts. Sunshine Village still has, I think, their court that's one. Cornish Village? Cornish, no, or Crestview has one. Cornish Village has at least.

28:20 Tennis Village has four courts. Are they still in use? Two to four. There was one next, right in front of Mammoth, or Kanyanski and Racket. But I don't think they've kept those ones up at all. I believe they're in. No, they're not public use, but if you were going to do a tournament.

28:41 That's where they did pull those up during the tournament that they were talking about. The numbers that you presented earlier that we were going to need four more courts by 2025? That's from the town. That's the park and rec master plan. That's the level of service that was indicated from your strategic studies. And that can be reevaluated in 10 years, I'm sure. Right now, it showed that you needed one more to meet the level of demand.

29:10 And I think we have to look at recreation trends. You know, you have this level of service and when it was put together, you know, that was a little higher usage. And like you said, the recreation trend has came down. So, you know, is six courts, that's a great question. Are the courts that we have sufficient or do we need the extra courts? Well, typically when we are putting forward new courts and there's a demand for new courts, you would have

29:39 A specific tournament, you have some specifics that are going into, we need this because we're not having it for this. It has been a problem because of this. At this point, we're just getting that it would be nice for tournament play. However, it appears that there are considerable number of courts when you take in the five and the private courts and this for that tournament condition. And like Derek said, if you have...

30:05 We're careful about diminishing use and putting in a new cork tour and using that money to something with diminished use, whereas you could potentially use that money to make that footprint really, really spectacular as far as those corks. I think that that's a decision that sounds attractive when you think about the money to adding corks to how nice these could become or if they needed to go somewhere else.

30:35 Aside from tournaments, though, I know that your Sunday socials, there are times, I think, as Sandy mentioned, where all the courts are in use and you do need to wait until you're able to play. So that's in addition to tournaments. Another thing to look at in consolidating courts together is that if at some point in the future a fee was to be charged, then at least you could have, you know, there's an access point for... Sure.

31:03 For that to occur. Sure. And I think your programming, how you're going to maintain those courts, how you're going to schedule them, those are other cost items that start to pop up. If you have high demand, then I actually did that as a teenager. They paid me just to sit and make sure people didn't fight over time at tennis courts. And it was a great job. But it wasn't a moneymaker. It was just to cover the cost and to make sure that people had equitable use.

31:32 That's, those are processes that are also thought in this. I think we're, what we're mostly looking at is the constraints and the opportunities within the site that is there. Those broader ideas may come as part of the master planning thoughts as well. And there's also, sorry about this, you said about Pickleball. Right. Pickleball. Pickleball. So we've got some users that, you know, we're actually looking at, you know, painting, you know, Pickleball in those courts next year.

32:01 You might see tennis diminishing, but you've got some other users and some other sports, you know. Right. Yeah, they've taped out the strength. Well, yeah. Oh, sure. Yeah, and that brings up another point of, well, potentially, then, if you're going, you may want to have courts that are separate, that are mixed use, that are tennis, roller hockey, that allow they're a little more acceptable that way. Maybe it's like a tennis court set that's

32:30 at a different park, you may not want to bring that use up to this facility. So those are two different directions. But you can still have a very nice tennis court that also has a basketball hoop somewhere on it or has another use component so that you are getting the maximum use out of that. The school set those up for that use. Have you seen the actually, do you design the shared use?

32:56 Pickleball and Tennis, I'm not really sure, Pickleball, but I know that Bill had brought it up, and he said that that was something that, I've heard that from a bunch of people. And it actually seems to be kind of a rising use right there. So that's very compatible with this? Yeah, we haven't done, I've done Pickleball with Volleyball, and essentially, you're just sitting in sleeves, because the posts are different dimensions for tennis, volleyball, and football.

33:25 They're all in the center. And then you can do basketball. If you're playing roller hockey, you have a little bit of a problem with the sleeves. We have a roller hockey. With the layout of the land, is there any other, you know, things that you would see that could... In this facility, I think that you have opportunities for a lot of other past meetings.

33:54 We've talked about watching. Other recreational uses that include smaller children or not overly active recreation. You could potentially fit a sand volleyball court out there if you wanted to. I don't know that the demand would be there for that spot because that's kind of a high visual area.

34:15 Sand volleyball, you're going to get multiple people there for it to really be, or multiple ports there for it to be used a lot. I don't know that you have a demand for that, but I think creating a more complete park with connected pathways, drinking fountains, sitting areas, and a place that a family would go, not just because the transports are there, but because they can utilize that as a neighborhood park that's going on.

34:41 Or access from the village. I think those are the things you want to look at. You can see there's some ideas with paths. You can see that there's a top lot already there. And I think improving those and really making this a really high-quality neighborhood park is one of the biggest opportunities along with that, as far as recreation goes. The other thing to do, too, is make sure Playground is probably more of the preschool age.

35:11 There's a lot of nice terrain around here. We could view some other things around the outside of the courts as well. Because right now, you know, and I don't know whether it is the shading, because, you know, the park could get cold where the playground is and everything. You know, our other playgrounds are definitely used, like Mammoth Creek Park.

35:40 It may get windy there, but, you know, with the exposure, it's definitely used. That and shade rest are probably the two heaviest used. They're more visible, too. They're also more visible, yeah. When you talk about additional quartz, if you're thinking, you know, this, that may be one of the constraints of this, is if you're adding a quartz here, or quartz here, you're adding quartz to a place that's going to have shade and cold longer, whereas there may be wind in some of the others, but at least it's...

36:10 Maybe you can still play when it's going to be debatable, but you can't play when there's snow. So for sand volleyball courts, two or three, we used to have sand volleyball down at the old Grumpy's site. And they were actually really used, they haven't been used for a while, but this is kind of an active node, so that might create more activity in the area of kind of the mid.

36:40 Late teens to mid-twenties. And a good volleyball court requires a certain level of maintenance for the sand and having the right nets and having high-quality use. Otherwise, it becomes something that they're not needed. Those are specific use. And if you don't have any, and people are looking for it, then this might be an opportunity for them. I think I'm looking for black and actually with the marketing of this to the village.

37:11 Right, and I think part of that is...

37:38 The access to it and the pathways and trails to it are not quite defined at this point. And know that people are using it for parking because the adjacent parking is there. So that's always been an opportunity. But it was pretty apparent that there was not a connectivity between the two that was intuitive. Yeah, there's no crosswalk to get there. There's only so much signage will do. Is there a park sign on the front?

38:04 It needs to be replaced. It's pretty old. You know, we're just, the community center park is one of those that isn't being utilized the way it should be utilized. So we're trying to figure out, you know, what should be there. Our community center isn't sufficient for what we need it to be. And so,

38:33 You know, the question is, is, you know, what can this park be? You know, what would the best uses be? Can it be built to something that will make it more user-friendly and more use happen? I think that Derek can speak to this really well, particularly, but the providing family use, which is playground systems, that's a big component of a good park these days.

39:01 Having a trail system and opportunity to gather, eat, enjoy the site with the appropriate shelter, whether it's wind block or snow block or whatever, potentially providing some sort of system that people can use for the winter, whether it's pretty small for...

39:23 Cross Country Skating, but you know, a few laps, right? If you groomed it, it may be there. I would think that you want to start with updating the, assuming the tennis courts stay here. My opinion, and I'm going to let Derek talk about this and say that, I think that really providing high quality courts of the existing footprint or somewhere close to that, providing ample children's play to the park.

39:52 as well as a few other passive recreation components and seating, benching, and good pathway systems. That's your basic components that would get you to a point. And then providing the access to it that is clear and defined from not only the neighborhoods but the village. I think when you start there, you can add to that.

40:19 One main room, and then a kitchen on the side, and we have some storage. And your plans are to renovate that building. The roof was an issue. And the plan is to keep that building? How many square feet is it? Well, that's what we're trying to figure out. How many other community buildings do you have? We don't.

40:50 Are there other things from the master plan as part of the recreation elements that are missing that could be incorporated in here? Snow play area was something that came up time and time again, especially during RecStrats. And, you know, we're a little bit nervous because of the liability that goes along with snow plays, my understanding of that. That doesn't really have a...

41:17 Slope. Anywhere where we can do. So kind of, you know, what I'm hearing from you guys is that if we were going to use this and try to make it more active, bringing in additional play equipment that would, you know, help older kids, you know, unfortunately the community center, and what's something that I'm struggling with personally, and I don't know where everybody else is, but is that we are looking at having to put $500,000 to $600,000 into that building just to make it exactly what it is, which is inefficient.

41:46 For what we need. Even after we do that. Even after we do that. Because all that is going to do is, you know, fix our roof and bring it up to our ADA. But we have a gymnastics program that doesn't have anywhere to live because the ceiling isn't tall enough. And it just is, it is wholly inefficient for what we need. So really looking at something and replacing it is kind of, we've been looking at the rec center type approach, where could that live.

42:16 I have a hard time putting $600,000 into a building when it isn't going to be sufficient for what your needs are. But that's me personally. A new building with a community room would run, you know, with fresh rooms, community room, maybe a kitchenette, we do these in other parts. And they're currently running brand new, $500,000 to $600,000. And that's not a prefab building either, that's a site built type of facility.

42:46 And the lease for the Head Start program there, it was eight more years, is that right? 2022. Well, I think we could possibly also have a conversation with them, you know, would there be something that we could supply them?

43:06 If there's construction, is the construction going to go there or does it go somewhere else? I don't know. That conversation could be had. Could you take over the footprint of those two buildings and make it into one larger building and then give them some space in that building for their program? I mean, that's another way of looking at it as well.

43:24 I guess I'm trying to figure out whether that footprint is even large enough to do what we would want to do. Well, it depends on what's involved in a recreation center. I mean, it could be as elaborate as an indoor pool and a rock climbing wall and, you know, jogging path and, you know, it could be that or it could be something scaled down at this particular site and then a larger facility at another location, which we know is years off. This is the five-acre site and...

43:51 I think five acres was your minimum requirement for that level of community building and some of the other components. And keep in mind that maybe half of that, maybe close to two-thirds taken up by the tennis courts. So that constricts it as far as a larger, long-term community center. This site. What you have...

44:21 I think when we're looking at this as far as the tennis courts, what you have is a lot of service elements that are great for just an outdoor active park. But as far as a community center, I think that that's going to take a considerably bigger effort as far as the building to service this town. There's a lot of expectations when you're in Mammoth, so you're going to have a certain level. And so a community center will provide for a lot of people in the longer term.

44:48 If this is the only building, this is a small site for relying on everything to be in that one building. Well, and we've already run into an issue where, you know, just, you know, the uses that people would like to make of that building just aren't compatible with all the things we need to do there. So, you know, we no longer allow people to hold, you know, family parties there because then there's just issues with cleanup. I think it's important to make the comment that tennis courts don't necessarily have to be part of.

45:17 Community Center. I think they, stand alone, they're fine. They're not like, you don't need to have a soccer field next to them, you don't have to have a lot of other, people will go there for that use, so they're unique in that element from some of the other mixed-use sports facilities. Any more discussion on the Community Center? Minister Parcel, we do.

45:42 Not necessarily. No, I mean, the only thing that I would say is just, you know, because, you know, the way that the town is laid out in that part of town, that is, you know, that is the only, you know, real parkland, it's the only playground, you know, the other ones are, you know, down at Shady Rest and Mammoth Creek and Trails End. You're saying that's the only one that's up in this part of town? In that part of town, yeah, so I think that's an important consideration in terms of parkland. One of the other discussion I, as I recall, on the new courts versus rehabbing owners,

46:11 Was to kind of keep over a series of years, basically have two under construction for that four-year period, so then there's always six available for use. As I recall, that was part of the discussion that Gail gave. It was a five-year period. Right. Replace courts five and six the first year. Replace three and four the next year. Replace one and two the next year. Do CEQA for the next two courts and the parking lots.

46:40 And then the last year, what would you add to? It was basically asked, and it's been asked by their tennis community, which is, you know, plausible, is that if we're going to redo these, to please keep at least two in play while we redo the others. And so it was kind of a plan to do over a few years as opposed to all at once. Peter, did you have a question?

47:10 Well, it's not within the five-year plan. So one of the questions I think we'd like to know is do we want to do more analysis on the park to look at how the three might work together? Are there some other uses that might be at the site rather than having eight courts? I'll try to refine this. So for the next steps for the project, we've got...

47:39 Read on, and he's going to refine his scope for that, so this part was kind of the concept discussion and getting Commission input, and we want to give him direction to either do more work. Well, it's my understanding today, because I guess I don't necessarily, this is me, and I'll ask the rest of the Commission where they're at, is we want to look at master planning or conceptually planning all of our parts and where kind of would things fit best.

48:08 And what would the uses be at each of those parks? Is it a passive park? You know, what are those uses? And so I think that's kind of what we were trying to is, you know, what are our next steps as far as doing that? My personal first question would be, what do we want to see at this park? And, you know, do we see the same buildings that are still there and the same uses?

48:35 Or what is, you know, how is that going to change? And that would just be me. Maybe the question, maybe we ask the question again after we go through the next section of the discussion. In the end, we want to try to, for this particular part, since we've got some funding to do some additional planning or design specs or something, you know, get some direction. We don't actually have to have that today.

48:58 We could have it at the next commission meeting over here. But I think if we talk more about, you know, where we, you know, alternative places to site a community center building, we'll have a better idea, you know, what direction we'd want to pursue with this property. And I guess as to what degree are we spending money on, you know, moving forward with this park. So just because of money, does it mean that we're moving forward with that at this park? I don't know. We want to make sure the money, if we're spending money that we're spending, something's going to be used.

49:26 Yes. I know that this would be certainly significant cost, but is it possible, because you said 60% of that site is taken up by tennis courts, and I'm not sure what percentage is parking lot, but is it feasible to then just shift the courts over to where those two new locations are mentioned, still maybe keep six courts, and then free up that other space in the middle for a building of some sort, which could even be a two-story building that could accommodate

49:56 Gymnastics or, you know, some other uses. There's no question. You can, because you've got larger leveled areas that are plateaued, you can definitely mix the, you can definitely take a section out. It's flat. Hey, you know, put a building there. But the question would be, how much do you want to redo or remove the tennis courts? How big?

50:24 Yeah, yeah, you start to get rid of a couple of courts and you're going to open up a considerable amount of space for a different use, the community center, other recreational activities. It's maybe just something to keep in the back of our mind. Yeah. That's options as we go forward. Do you think there's any need for like a championship court down here? You know, with bleachers? There's some bleachers out there right now.

50:49 This day and age, no, and Snow Creek does kind of have that stadium.

51:07 I'm just going to ask if the commission's Sean, is there anything else you'd like to say prior to moving forward? Yeah, you know, I want tennis. I think the town needs tennis. I'd like to see some tennis courts closer to the school. I would like to see the high school and the college have tennis courts closer to it. And I don't want to pay to renovate the community center building at the cost that would

51:36 Take to replace it. And with regard to the Head Start, folks, you know, that's only eight years away. Heck, that could be as long as it takes to, you know, build something new. Anyway, so I think our timing is right on that. And, yeah, you know, you can always ask them, hey, let's find you another place if they can work with us if we are able to do it. So those are the only comments. I'm not saying I want to move the tennis courts away as much as I'd like some closer to the school.

52:04 Yeah, and I would just say that, you know, I like the idea that if we build additional courts anywhere, whether it's on that site, whether it's, you know, down closer to the schools, I just, I like the idea of making them more multi-used because, you know, we know demographically that, you know, right now tennis doesn't seem to be, you know, on the upswing, so we want to make sure that whatever we built, you know, that we had those, that we could incorporate those multi-uses. Any other comments, Pat?

52:29 I would almost echo what Betsy said earlier, that I think it's important to have some sort of parks spread out throughout the community, and I think it's great to have some opportunities there at that particular location. And I support other enhancements as well throughout the community. Okay. Is there any other public comments before I move forward? Okay. The other thing about this particular site on that paper, Pat, those are the courts that are in the worst condition. Which ones?

53:00 These cores. Because they're in the shade? No, the other ones that are in the sun? These cores have some major adjacent surface areas. Okay. Because they're in the shade and that's where the freeze is. That's the root intrusion area. And it's more from the root intrusion as well? So, okay. I almost think the whole park should have been flip-flopped. Parking areas would have been better for tennis and, yeah.

53:29 Yeah. Okay. Let's do that. All right. Okay. Do we want to take a break or do we want to just keep going or? Well, you take a break if you'd like. It's new. You'd like to have some lunch. Get some sustenance. I can yap while you're eating, too. Yeah. All right. You know, just one question is kind of with us moving forward. What do you see that we need to do?

54:00 As a commission to kind of bring this. Well, I think that that's a good segue into the next conversation. Yeah. So let's have lunch. All right. Thank you.

54:35 I love jelly bellies. I love my sugar. I'll eat the cookie. Thank you. Goes great with my coffee. Alrighty. Let's go ahead and read the meat. Thank you.

55:06 Yep, I switched to Brett. So one of the things to take a look at is how this process can unfold. And what we have for you today is our typical steps in doing master plans or conceptual plans, whatever you want to call them. Sometimes master plans isn't the right term, so it can be a final conceptual plan, whatever you want to.

55:37 Call it, it's fine. But typically in our process we have four steps that we go through. We do investigate, listen, understand, and recommend. And some of the components in these steps that we have for you today may not be necessary. You recently completed a park master plan. I think that there's a lot of information in there and I think one of the first steps would be to go through and validate that and bring some of those things forward based on those recommendations. But typically the first thing that we do is

56:07 is in a master plan processes. We investigate. We take a close look at the site. We look at the existing conditions. We look at the opportunities and constraints on the site. You know, the bell-shaped property has the wetlands. The Mammoth Creek Park has the creek there and setbacks for that. You know, those are obvious

56:35 Elements to take a look at, but there may be some other ones at the other sites to also take a look at that can affect development or renovations on the sites. The next step for us is listening. And really, that's program development. That's where we, that's a lot of, I think, what we're doing today. Some of the tasks are also related to investigation. But listening is about building program. And I think that can be streamlined because of the existing Park and Recreation Master Plan.

57:04 And then once we have a good understanding of program needs and priorities and kind of separating out needs from wants, we move into understanding phase. And usually in that phase we're coming up with concepts and alternatives and we bring those to you for evaluation. And then we typically narrow it down to a single design and give you a draft and then we will give you a final draft. And during this process,

57:34 The procedure is usually we have community meetings. Sometimes there's a steering committee involved. And then you can also come in front of the Park and Rec Commission or other commissions for like study sessions to provide input as the project moves forward. So if you're looking at multiple sites here, and we can talk about the sites maybe after this. I go through this process explanation.

58:04 This is going to take a little while to do. It's not something that's done overnight. It is a process, and it's worked very well for us. So we have some other terms up on here. This is from one that we completed in the community in the Bay Area, but this process is pretty typical for us in this type of planning work. So we do a lot with graphic communication. Typically, we start out with hand drawings, and early on,

58:34 And one of the things that we do in meetings when we do the options, which I don't have on here today, is with the conceptual alternatives in the community meetings, what we'd like to do is print them out, and then we'd like to break up in the groups and have the community members, and it could be commissioners or whoever's in the presentation, just sit down in groups and make comments on the plants, point out the things that work, and then those groups come up and present.

59:02 The things that work well for them are the things that don't work well. And essentially we come up with the initial designs based on the programming info we hear and then we give them the alternatives. And then in the end the graphics are refined and we start to add more detail to them. Along the way we're also doing cost estimates. Typically now they're all electronic. At the end we're doing everything in AutoCAD. So you can have a graphic that works very well in presentations, convert.

59:32 Very well on your website. And it's all done in typically in a two-dimension or plan view. It's done in CAD and rendered in CAD. We also can do three-dimensional drawings. This is the bleach beach chalet soccer field we're doing in San Francisco right now. Four-field renovation up there. And part of that was doing lighting studies. We can actually turn off lights within these now, which is...

1:00:01 For some of the environmental studies, important to take a look at. So investigation, essentially what we like to do is get the site information, topo, we can use aerials for that as well. You might have some meets and bounds plans and we can combine it with the topo. And nowadays we have access, we pay for a special thing through Google to get up-to-date aerials. So there's really no cost for that, it's just if you want.

1:00:28 Topography, which can be important on some of the sites we're looking at here. We go through site access. We've been through some of that. There may be some more that we want to take a look at. And generally we come up with a site analysis type graphic that talks about, again, the main things are the opportunities and constraints out there. And then listening, sometimes in the listening phase we do a community survey. We did a

1:00:57 A needs assessment survey in the park and rec plan, and I think we can utilize a lot of that and not have to redo that here. But the community surveys are very easy to do on the, like Survey Monkey and those online ones now. We do them on a regular basis, and you could also do it to present to the community and get their input on a specific design as well. Sometimes it's more program-based, like what's a priority for them, like do they really need two more tennis courts,

1:01:28 Or they have something else. But you can also do it for site-specific plans or concepts that have come up and solicit feedback that way. For the community meetings, really what we like to do is typically we start off meeting with them to gain their input on program. That may not be necessary here because of the Park and Rec Master Plan you did. So it could be that we come forward to them when we have some initial designs laid out.

1:01:59 And then typically you come back to them for a draft master plan. So minimum two community meetings, and you could do it so that if you have the multiple sites, we're presenting all the sites there during those meetings. And then we would present to the Park and Rec Commission and Town Council for the final plans and acceptance. Some other things as far as a need assessment goes.

1:02:28 This is something we typically do, and I don't think that we may need to do that here because of your Parks and Rec master plan. But there are some things, I think, to take a look at that and move those forward as far as identifying priorities and conflicts and seeing what could fit into the project sites we're looking at. And in an understanding phase, usually what we're doing is we develop conceptual alternatives.

1:02:55 Present those to staff, refine those. If there's a steering committee, typically we meet with the steering committee first before a committee meeting, and then we'll have our committee meeting. And then again, we can also have study sessions as necessary. And then in the recommended phase, we usually set up a draft, a single preferred design, and then we would set up a final design. And one of the things that's not mentioned in this is any kind of SQL process. Sometimes that can go

1:03:25 Hand in Hand with this process. And they can take a look at the designs. Sometimes we include secret consultants to flag any environmental issues that there might be on the projects early. And that helps us kind of massage the design in an environmentally friendly way so that it limits any hurdles we might have from a secret process later on. And then there's final designs.

1:03:55 Different graphics of how to do that. We have several different ways of doing that. But the project sites that we heard, the main ones are the Community Center Park, the Mammoth Creek Park, and then what was the other one? Bell-shaped person? Yeah, the bell-shaped. And then I don't know if there's any interest in the Minaret Road one, the privately owned property, but...

1:04:25 Typically for community, Peter, as far as a city or a town doing designs on a private property, you can go to some extent, right? What's the limitations on that? Yeah, because you end up with an inverse condemnation problem if you don't, in this case there's a willing cell order type issue, but usually you don't do very much other than what could be done.

1:04:57 And then you might lock it up into some type of escrow and then do the sequel to make sure that you can do what you want to do before you actually do the loan purchase. But yeah, the inverse condemnation laws come into play if we look at private property too early in the process. That's why you usually have multiple sites. You know, if you've got a huge facility, like for a big rep center.

1:05:26 We might look at three or four sites, some of them are private, some of them are public, but in that context, there's no commitment for any one site. Once you've got sort of a commitment, you need to make a commitment with the property owner to keep out of that legal arrangement. There's some big penalties that go along with that. I think it's triple damages. So is that why the HBS study put so many sites in? Even though they weren't lodged? Yeah.

1:05:57 Yeah. So, Peter, would that also relate to the Mammoth Creek Park and the areas to the east there that are Forest Service? Those are Forest Service, and we have a current use permit, so that wouldn't apply. You would? We have a current use permit for that property, so that wouldn't apply there. And there may be some other, more flexibility with that Samson Woods site because it's up for sale. They want it used.

1:06:26 They want to sell it. So we have a willing seller certainly on those sites. One of the other options in this process is also just to do what we really call a feasibility study and to come up with some options. Maybe it's just two options for each park area or city-owned land and develop options for what could fit on those sites, what could be accommodated there. You would incorporate

1:06:56 You know, like the community rec center elements, whatever else the laundry list may be, parking, and then you can also do preliminary cost estimates for that so you can take a look at that. And then that's also a good step where you're looking at the options and from there you could decide to move it forward or hold off on one of the project sites. That's another way of doing this as well.

1:07:24 Do you want to consider Whitmore? Yeah, I was going to say, we have Whitmore that we would also want to be looking at, which is where our new track is. We have our community swimming pool is down there. So that's one of the other ones that we would be looking at. And you had a photo of that on one of your previous slides? Yeah. This one over here? Yep. What we have is a lot of facilities that are in...

1:07:57 State of deferred maintenance that are going to be looking at having put into a lot of money to bring them up. And so we're looking at if we're going to do that, is that the right place for that facility? Is there a better place for it to be? What does it need to be? You know, what needs to be included in the facility? Those types of things.

1:08:23 We also need to make sure that things aren't moving, that there is maintenance moving to the end. Yes. That's a missing link. That's a missing link all the way around. Well, and I think it's great, too, that, you know, that you can reference our Parks and Recreation Master Plan, you know, for, you know, what our level of service needs are. And then I think also in your scope of work, I think you're also going to maybe review our RecStrats plan, which had a lot of public input into what amenities the community is looking for.

1:08:53 Let me say we have our RecStrats, we have a lot of, we have a lot of planning. We're very good at planning. Yeah, so we have the studies, so we have the RecStrats because, as Betsy said, the master plan is kind of more a level of service plan. RecStrats is more implementation, community-based, and then we also have the new room that's just coming out that's our special events venue, and that's why we're looking at Sam's Woods.

1:09:21 And there's also arts and culture of opportunity possibly at the college down there. So there's a lot of different things that are out there. So the four, the sites, again, running through them were the community center park, the bell-shaped property, the Mammoth Creek Park, and one more. But at the same time, considering, because there's a Williams cellar,

1:09:52 the wood site, because something that is called out everywhere is for an outdoor events site venue. So yeah, we are looking at four currently owned and one that... Okay. And then nothing with Shady Res Park, right? Well, it's at least with the Forest Service, so... We've been told it. It is what it is.

1:10:21 I mean, I think it's important for you to understand what's there, you know, what are existing, you know. We do have sand volleyball courts down there. We do have a big pavilion. That's where baseball fields, soccer fields. Playground. And frankly, I think that would be the perfect events venue. It's far away from people and that kind of thing, but at the same time, we've been told that don't even think about it.

1:10:45 I have a question regarding the site. Like, for example, if we decide that the sand volleyball court is no longer needed, could that be replaced with something? Anything within the boundaries, because I know I operate the skate park right about the time that they were taken out of tennis courts. And we've got a planned parking lot expansion that the Forest Service has agreed that would be useful and needed to park.

1:11:14 Has anything been done with the winter staging areas studies? Has anything been done with programming the rec center or community center needs? You know, it's coming up with what the facilities are that are needed at that facility? What we want in it. Yeah, what you want in it. Why we have the constraints that we have and why we aren't able to program. Is that what you're looking at?

1:11:41 Well, what are the needs for a community center or a rec center? And, you know, have you gone through and identified what those are? There was a plan that was part of that stuff that way that included pretty detailed conceptual plans and needs of a rec center. So there is that document out there. I think the main part that happened with that particular study, and we can get that also for you,

1:12:09 Is it didn't have a lot of community and commission discussion. Right. And so that part would need to be kind of rethought through and a little bit maybe more community outreach to determine what facilities are really included in that. And I think some of that is... Because I recall it didn't have a lot of... And I think some of that is called out in RecStrats in terms of what the community is looking for. Okay. Like, you know, year-round indoor aquatic center is one that comes up and...

1:12:40 Okay. Well, that's something to look at and that definitely needs to be identified as far as spatially what that is, you know, and what needs to be accommodated because those facilities can be different sizes and can be large. So one of the things that we talked about as a commission is that we really weren't looking at going with a consultant to start with and talking about that with the community.

1:13:11 and just our recreation commission as a consultant. What do you see those pitfalls are as far as being able to move this forward? And how do you feel you could help us as far as making that happen? Well, the big thing that we help with is doing graphics and putting the input down and figuring out how it can be arranged on the site.

1:13:39 You know, again, some of that goes back to looking at the site and the opportunities and constraints of the site, but that's mainly what we typically do. I mean, obviously, we're involved with facilitation and, you know, we like to start with programming and go through it with designs. But if you're doing that, you would need, I think, staff time or somebody's time to help you with the plans to be able to come up with those.

1:14:10 The other thing that you do with the plans is you can be able to come up with costs for those or what the improvements will be. And then usually what we do is we can kind of work backwards and come up with an implementation plan for those and develop what the phases could be based on the priorities. You know, it could be that, like, the Bell Shave property has, you know, five phases over the next 20 years for it to be built out.

1:14:37 So that's where we come in. It's more of the graphic presentation components that we do. And, you know, but if you were to move forward with programming and meet with the community and get their input, you know, and then we could come back later after that's done, that would be fine as well. And feasibility. Yeah, exactly. And I guess that's kind of what we were looking at is right now as we're looking at

1:15:10 What could we have at each of these parks? And that's, you know, kind of been our stumbling block is how we feel about that. So we were going to look at having some community meetings and see if we can get some of that information program. It would be a programming question. You know, we do have rec strats. We do have some information. I guess it's how we put it down and move forward.

1:15:35 From there. And so, I don't know. Yeah, I mean, I guess, you know, I think that, you know, and the commission went through and evaluated our existing plans and kind of tried to cull the things that, you know, rose to the top in terms of what the community is looking for. And I think now we're trying to get from sort of, you know, a planning phase into a doing phase. But first we've got to figure out exactly what it is we want to do and where could we do it. So. I think that would be pretty easy with community meetings.

1:16:04 However many you have for that. Essentially what you would do is show them an aerial and then I think as a commission you can come up with obviously a list of things that exist there and then things that should be you think preserved there and then what other elements could be added and that could come from your various planning documents that you had. One of the things I see that really would be a benefit is as architects

1:16:36 They know the shapes. They know what uses are compatible with each other. They have a good understanding with what uses are compatible with neighbors. And so I think that's a big help that would be, you know, the depth of the assistance, you know, in creating those graphics, that's really an important part of engagement with the community. I don't think anything much more than I've already said.

1:17:02 Other than one of the component that I saw today that I guess I hadn't really thought about before was being able to connect the Lake Mary bike path with so there's you know also some transportation components here that I want to make sure that we're looking at as well you know as I go through the list of what I know has been called out for recreation tennis courts events sites and looking at you know how I talk about I'd like to move

1:17:32 I would like to not necessarily move, but have some tennis courts closer to the school and the community college. The recreation center, I want to make sure that that is accessible to non-school age kids, but at the same time have it be, I think it will have more participation if it is closer to the school. The pool component, I know we've talked about it, being able to teach swimming in town.

1:17:57 Rather than out at Whitmore, which frankly I see becoming almost a high altitude training facility more and more. And since we've already got a track out there, Great Road, you know, we'd like to look at Whitmore as more of perhaps even high altitude training. So there's a lot of components that come from our RecStrats and other plans, but the master and individual plans that, well, that's, you know, that I would like to tie into all this. There's so many considerations.

1:18:29 I agree with what Sean has mentioned. I know we talked as a commissioner about how important it is to have some aquatics program and one that's accessible in the community. As you know, Whitmore is about 10 miles away. Yeah, and there's no public transit. Which doesn't seem like much, but small communities. I still do kind of get bogged down a little bit on the maintenance. I know we need to really talk about that. And when you asked about some of the programming needs,

1:19:03 And I would imagine if he's not just new and his staff, he would find that they probably have grandiose ideas of what could be done, but the funding is just not there, or the personnel resources are not there to offer a lot more of the programs. So I think if we have a facility, and once again, resources for staff, for the community and participants. So I think that's kind of a different component of

1:19:33 Once we know what the costs are, then we can have that community engagement of if we really want this bigger facility, there's several different mechanisms to finance that and also finance maybe long-term maintenance, most of which require property taxes. You know, to engage the community to have a ballot to implement that or some type of recreation card system like they have in many other resorts. It's probably a combination of those.

1:20:05 I guess where I'm struggling is, is, okay, we started this whole thing because we needed to come up with our priorities and how, you know, what our priorities are moving forward, is I think that the service that you guys are bringing forward is going to be critical at some point. My question, I guess, is are we at that point yet, or is there more work that we need to do prior to enlisting these services?

1:20:30 Because I bring back the conversation that we need to have, the conversation with schools. Bring in Mammoth's ski area. You know, what is it that we're looking for and what can be combined, possibly, as a public-private partnership, possibly, and moving forward with that? And I don't know whether that's done prior to or that's done in conjunction with a contract that you guys would be looking at.

1:20:58 You probably need to have some sort of concept that we're presenting it to. Maybe, like you said, it occurs concurrently because we're going to see what the interest is with different partners and concepts. Well, and I think along with that is just the feasibility component that I think is something that we're getting closer and closer to really needing a better understanding of. I mean, just the information that, you know, because, you know,

1:21:29 When we talked in the past about tennis courts about, well, if we're going to spend all this money, should we put them somewhere else? But, you know, it's good information to know that just from a, you know, design and orientation standpoint that it's going to be much more cost effective to keep something, you know, where we have it now. So I think those are, you know, those are valuable pieces of information that will play into this.

1:21:56 One of the things you want to do as a town is direct what you want. You've got to bring in other partners, whether it's the Mammoth Village or the Mountain or the County or anyone else, the Forest Service. They're going to provide what we provide is to direct what you want, put it on paper, get your scope defined, get these parks to some level of the time so you can present that to your partners and say this is the direction the town wants to create.

1:22:25 It's sort of like the mainstream design. I mean, what got together, came up with a concept, presented it, and maybe there's modifications along the way, but at least it's a speaking point.

1:22:56 Yeah, I guess that my question is, are we at that point where we have the concept of giving them enough information that we aren't just spinning some expensive wheels to get there? You know, do we have those conversations with our other partners first and kind of put some information down to get to this point to come back to?

1:23:25 I think we've done a lot of talking. We have. We need to see what's the next step. We need to see what's the next step. We need to see what we need to see what's the next step. We need to see what we need to see what's the next step. We need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we need to see what we

1:23:54 How to kind of tie this process together. I think we're at that point. I think we understand that. We're asking some really questions. The measure of our application is due on Friday next week. So are we ready to submit something in the process? It doesn't have to be immediate. It can be something that because, you know... We can hold a couple. We can hold a couple meetings, but we know we need to do something. And I think what we're trying to work at now is...

1:24:18 The final parts of that element is exactly what it is. I think the partner engagement will be very wise and that's the way to do it. But again, before you, when you do engage the partners, you won't actually have them engage on something. That feasibility phase I think is actually quite critical. And I think when you look at that Main Street plan, Rusty put that together and put the whole thing out in the community, it was like, oh my God, the sky's falling, right? So look how much engagement that poured in. And I think that's a spur.

1:24:45 It's going to spur the interest of us. I think if you want to get something out there, we know what we want. We prioritize our facilities. We've looked at our CIP. We just need to kind of put them down on paper and have people engage with us on. Is this really, you know, what you agree that we should get on, where we should put them? And then just start, you know, acting on. It's kind of like the events report. It really identifies what's needed for a facility, but it doesn't actually locate them on a piece of land.

1:25:14 This component, the feasibility component, conceptual plan, orientates that on a building so that people can comment on it and react and provide information. And then we can develop good cost estimates. I think this can kind of dovetail into those two studies because that's going to come out, you know, we'll get into that in January. But that's a big part of this. I mean, you kind of see this time in regards to these are our parts or these are our properties. This is kind of what we want. Where can we go? What makes the most sense?

1:25:41 Do we have some type of cost or timeline that we're looking at to do something? So, yeah, I threw out some numbers early on. I don't know if you guys had some additional thought about it. It really depends on the amount of detail and the amount of effort. If we're going to do every part, that's one thing. If we're going to try to focus on a couple, that's a much less costly, much simpler process. Yeah, and...

1:26:08 What generally we do with the scope is we set up what we call a fee test estimate. So it has down our tasks or our meetings. And then design-wise, you know, we're doing two options, three options, four options. Those will take some time to develop. But we usually kind of rough out what our staffing needs would be for that and what we need to provide you.

1:26:31 Well, one thing that I really appreciate is your willingness to engage with our current, you know, with the work we've done so far and then to, you know, build on that to bring us back some graphics and some feasibility. I think we would need to work that out, Peter, and get back to you. If we could frame maybe what you think you would like to see, if it's just doing a couple concepts per each site and then maybe one cost for each site, we can work that out and get back to you.

1:27:01 Yeah, actually, that would be helpful. So if it's, and then it's broken now, we can basically authorize by phase or figure it, so it makes our budget. Yeah, we could put some other things down as optional services as well. Right. Should we consider we can be some of the facilities that are easier to do with, you know, like, I don't know, big parts, one of them, or the county center part as opposed to, like, bell shapes, things like this.

1:27:30 Further out there. Well, actually, what they just suggested sounds actually good, because they'll take each part as, you know, what the cost would be if we wanted it. If we don't want to take on the bell shape right now, maybe we take on the other ones first, and then the next days would be taking on the bell shape. That sounds good.

1:27:55 Well, this is doing a 360 from what we spoke about earlier, so I guess that's why I'm trying to see if this is... Well, this is... It's not so much doing a 360 as it makes me sort of feel like we're further down the road than we realized we were, which is kind of nice. I think so, too, because of the engagement. What's the 180? Well, because we've... There was a great feeling that, you know, we can take this on, that we didn't want to spend more money on more, you know, planning.

1:28:24 And, um, but, you know, I have to agree. I think that we're at a point that I'm not sure that this isn't the next step. It seems like a transition from... You can put up the concept right here. I agree. Derek, put the concept, kind of what the early concept plans look like again. Yeah, those previous ones that you did for... These are showing a lot of athletics in some of these and, uh... No, the early one that basically is showing general ideas. The hand rods.

1:28:57 Like these types. Yeah. Was that your conceptual that you would come up with, your graphics? Yeah. Generally, what we do is we do some background in the computer, and then we would do hand graphics over the top. And whatever is kind of set in place, we would set up in the computer. We'd also do our labeling in the computer. And then,

1:29:26 Then we scanned in our hand graphics and we set it up in Photoshop to create a composite graphic. The hand graphics work well. The hand graphics give a feeling of it not being finite, you know, that it's a work in progress and they have a nice conceptual schematic, you know, type of impression, which is good, especially dealing with the community.

1:29:55 Which is exactly what we had for the Main Street Project, so that people weren't feeling overwhelmed that, oh my God, we're going to complete demolished existing buildings. That's what happened 15 years ago when the whole discussion happened on Main Street. So this time it was a much better outcome, everybody was engaged, and most of the community likes that. What the end product, it's not adopted yet, but...

1:30:24 The other option you have on preliminary designs is you have one level that's called a use relationship diagram and then you have another one that's more defined and so a use relationship diagram is more like a bubble diagram especially you're putting bubbles representing program where they could go it could be existing and proposed elements but you're putting them down on the site

1:30:51 Those are faster. They're definitely much rougher and conceptual. And then you can also do a more refined conceptual plan, kind of like what this one's showing here. This is a playground we did over near Modesto with basketball courts. And it just has more detail in it. It's still conceptual, but it's showing the actual sizes and layout of elements. So that's another...

1:31:19 Type of level of graphic option you have, too. It seems like that's more of the level that we need to get towards for each of these facilities. I think at the end, too, I think if we work this backwards, we're trying to get to a point on taking the budget cycle, you know, June next year and hopefully earlier, that we have something that we know we can act on so we want to start planning and setting aside these funds that we're starting to do with our framework, which are measures.

1:31:49 We have a little bit of plan on what we're maybe working towards. So I think that makes sense. And I just, I think that will probably get us to that point. I think that's maybe the deliverable that people are looking at, that right from our planning process, right? We're trying to get something down and we can describe what we want, where it's going to go, conception, who's going to use it, what it's going to be used for, potential costs, right, for the development plan. So I guess to answer those questions. Yeah.

1:32:12 To help Council and certainly Commission move forward with committing funds to it. And then we can kind of prioritize those based on what we've got in our community and what makes the most sense. So I think that's probably a good phase. It doesn't seem to be too much, but probably enough to fulfill what we started out to achieve. Well, we have the matrix, you know, that shows what our priorities are and if they can take that. We'll look for different plans. We just need to make sure to advocate. So anyways, is there any other public comments I can hear?

1:32:42 So what is the pleasure of the commission? Basically today what we're looking at doing is asking if there's an application that's going to move forward within Measure R so it can be looked at in this funding cycle. To do specifically? Specifically this planning. Yeah.

1:33:12 Well, except for if they're, you know, if they're looking at doing that in certain parks, then we can also pick and choose what we need to do within the application. And if you just want the use-wise, you want the second feasibility, or if you want to look at the whole feasibility of the master plan, you probably look at some others. And they need to know what they're going to be doing. Yeah, I mean, I think we need to decide on three parks.

1:33:44 How far we want to go. So I guess the question is, since the time is somewhat short, is could you do a full-blown proposal that would include schematic all the way through feasibility analysis by Wednesday? Maybe it's a typical for one park and then kind of a general for the other. We're working on Monday. We don't have a holiday.

1:34:15 Because we need time to actually put together an application. Actually, we'll probably do it on Monday because I'm leaving on Tuesday for a conference. Okay. I'm heading out, so I'll be, so yeah, earlier. This would be kind of a general, not a contractual ready scope. I don't think we'd be looking for that at this point. Yeah, we can work on a proposal and give you some options. Just so we've got some good budget numbers.

1:34:44 And then will that give you enough information to write the Measure R application for us? So one of the questions will be how many community meetings do you think that will need? And some of that's the commission's question because you've got kind of the pulse of the community generally. And we had a lot of meetings early on. I'm sure we need at least two. I was going to say I'm not sure that we have an awful lot of...

1:35:17 We've had a lot of community meetings. We've had a lot of community meetings with all our plans. So I'm almost thinking that we had a couple. I think two is sufficient. Sufficient. With making all the information that we already have and having that for folks to come to those two meetings. Because we're trying to act on plans that already had a lot of community. And then as we start doing detail about a particular part, then there can be a couple related to those.

1:35:45 Particular parks with those particular neighbors. For each one of the parks. Well, let's talk about what those are, too, because aren't we going, because we're going to talk a little bit about what the scope is that we're asking for studies on. Yeah. We have the community center, Mammoth Creek, Bellshape, and Woodland. Yeah, and we want to consider the wood site. I think the wood site is pretty much going to be a decision whether we want to

1:36:17 We're forwarding discussions on even purchasing that property. I don't know that this would be coming to play. It might be premature. Well, the event study will come to us in January. And, you know, I think then, you know, after that, we make a decision on making sure we put a measure in our application. We don't even know. Maybe we should have a broader school, but then we can narrow it.

1:36:40 I'm wondering what the cost is going to be, you know, because again, I don't want to over plan. We have made that mistake before. There's one other component, though, that I mentioned earlier that, you know, I think is low-hanging fruit, but I might be wrong, and you guys should probably tell us, is, like I said, connecting the Lake Mary bike path with the bike path down there at Old Mammoth Road.

1:37:06 You know, I've been told that bike paths are a million bucks a mile. So maybe it's not worth it. But at the same time, I would like to find out. That would really be the jewel on the crown? Something like that. So that is in our current master plan, our bikeway master plan. Okay. And it's also in our general bikeway plan. It's also in our bikeway plan. So is that appropriate to be putting in here? Well, we've already got...

1:37:35 We already have a master plan that shows. Okay, so it's not needed. Yeah, it's not needed for this study because it's already part of our capital approval program. Okay. We can get you.

1:38:05 I think that's the first thing. Is it even something that would be something that we can acquire? Yeah, especially knowing the history. Is that part feasible? And I think that's the question that has to be answered. This is completely different than, I think, that. The town-owned properties, you know, existing uses already in place. I'm just trying to understand that the existing uses still active, current, and what else could there be used for? Now, priority-wise, when we're looking at, you know, what comes down, we have all of these.

1:38:34 You know, plans and this is what each park would look like. That's when we have to set, you know, there's only so much money. Yeah, that's when we have to choose. I mean, I guess the three that I would choose right now would be the Community Center Park, Mammoth Creek Park, and Whitmore with the understanding that, you know, depending on how those look, then we might want to look at the bell-shaped parcel and we might, if we pursued a partnership with the schools, want to look at that property. But I think for right now it makes the most sense to look at

1:39:04 You know, our most developed existing facilities that, you know, that are really the most desperately in need of master planning. That's what I would take. I don't know about the rest of the commission. I agree. Well, we know. We want to look at trails in the park. I don't know if we already have.

1:39:34 Well, it's pretty well done. I mean, it's pretty well done. And I guess I would say Whitmore, partially knowing that, you know, I mean, we have the track, but, you know, where are we going to go with that facility now? Yeah, the pool is falling apart, and, you know, one of the big things that was asked for was high-altitude training, and really I see, you know, the best use of that being out there. And I think that if Whitmore becomes something that is...

1:40:03 Desirable for a lot of these things because of whatever reasons, you have to look at transportation. I mean, you know, there's a new transportation that goes down there so that we can, you know, it's not probably the best, most desirable, but it's definitely a possibility. Does that give you guys enough information? Yes. Okay. So, do you, would you like to

1:40:37 Motion, or do you just as consensus do? I mean, basically, we just wanted to come back, and then we'll evaluate the measure. The agenda just says discussion, so maybe we should just need consensus. Do we need to get the planning? Not for the concept.

1:41:01 So once you start going into a feasibility stage, then we need to have another meeting, especially with the neighbors, at least invite them, so that they can comment on what they foresee as a benefit. Yeah, but for their proposal, that will give us a budget kind of going forward, beyond maybe what's approved initially, just so we have an ongoing idea of the cost.

1:41:34 Because we can always update it with the spring, which might be where the event site application comes in. Okay. All right, thank you guys. Thank you very much. Thank you. What are we done? Whoa.

1:42:07 Pretty good. Is that one o'clock? What else could we do? What? Do we have a motion to adjourn? So moved. I'm still in shock.