Measure U Committee
· recording 3 hr 18 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
393 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
10:27 It's not coming up downstairs yet on the Granicus Live. So anyway, that's why I just do that question. Because I know I was on that committee, I know, you know, the grand plan, I know what we okayed last year, it was all of the final design, and it was the installation of one of ours. Yep, still here.
11:08 There's two different pulling up any meeting. Okay, wayfinding town. Did Steve have to turn the computer off last time and signing it up or just to an application? Okay. Trails wayfinding is something else. Okay, and that's under red. Yeah. Yeah, and that goes under. Yeah, maybe just start recording trails. Give me the guy. I tried to find it. Okay. Yeah, it's kind of tough because those two, we call them wayfinding. They're two separate projects. Yeah, yeah. So, and it's important to. And the.
11:37 Because the trails from, you know, the one that was Measure R has been put into the trails community, so that's fine. But the town refining, that's the big one, that we need to find out what's been going on. Is that major mobility? It is, it's mobility. Oh, no, it is. Major mobility? Yeah. Well, that's what we okay. No, we okay the last time it is. It comes under mobility. I mean, it's town signage. It's something that's, yeah. Yeah, I mean, that's mobility. It's extending.
12:06 Is this happening? It's going? Is it ready? Are we getting there? I'm not going. There's nothing happening. There's nothing on this earth. I don't have the meeting. There's no granicus. What did you have to do with Steve? Does it keep happening?
12:56 Thank you. Thank you.
13:16 The rest of us are flexible. I can't speak for him. I know. Yeah. Obviously not too flexible. His mom's been sick lately. That's right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
13:46 Oh boy. Well, yeah. It's crazy. Look at the 3 o'clock.
14:35 We should just go to roll call, why don't you just pull them in like it normally does. Okay. Let's just give it a whirl, eh? Yeah, let's get going. You're live? We are live. Okay. All right. Thank you. Does the Chair want to call the meeting to order and then we'll do roll call? Good morning. This meeting on Tuesday, September 17th, calling it to order. We'll just run through roll call. Chair, Dre Perry. Here. Vice-Chair Joyce Turner. Here.
15:20 Committee members, Bill Sousa, on his way. Committee member, Sandy Hogan. Here. And committee member, Don Salony. Here. Perfect. All right, I'd like to open this up to any public comments. Okay. Then let's move on to the approval of minutes from the regular meeting of August 13, 2013. I had only one small addition under committee member reports. I left at 10.20. I wasn't, I was absent for the last five minutes, yes, but so just no, left at 10.20.
16:00 And I would move to approve if there's no other second. I would second it. Okay. Approved. Okay. Who was opposed? Who was second? Sandy. I moved. Great. Don seconds. Don seconds. So, all in favor of approving the meetings? Aye. Aye. Great. Thank you.
16:28 So for discussion items today, first on the agenda is to review the 2013 Spring Measure U awards and events. Thank you, Chair. Probably not. Okay, so this is more of an informational piece than anything else for the committee. So what we've done is compile just our master spreadsheet of awards and expenditures for Measure U since inception and then form specifically the Spring Award.
17:01 Which was attachment B, so I can kind of run you through that as well if you need to. But you can see back on April 3rd, county council appropriated, I think the total was about $472,000, which includes the county administration funds. And to date we have funded about $262,000 worth of programs. If we just go through the spring awards,
17:35 You can see we have a couple of talks for the column on the left, which is Captain B. It runs through the Town Council of Waterford, April 3rd. And then the funds spent, you can see in the column on the right. So that's kind of what we're tracking and how we're tracking it to date. So the Town Admin Funds, and that's a little bit of a mix, that's a little bit of half years, last year's funds and what we're currently running to date.
18:04 The Municipal Wayfinding Project, you can see they've spent $350,000 but they're under contract for $31,500 currently. We talked about the Next Bus GPS Enhancement Project, that was kind of a change in scope that we approved, I think, the last meeting. But that will be essentially the same funds, if not a little bit less. Mammoth Track Club, $75,000 was payment of the loan.
18:31 And then the additional funds are, I think, some tables and some hand timing equipment and things like that. So that still has to be purchased. The Kamikaze Bike Ames, letter of agreement, was finalized. They now were just waiting on their expenses for that event. Federation of Fly Fishers, all their receipts have been received. So the check's been issued. Same as Black Diamonds Food. So that's been done. And I've kind of subtotal each of those little categories as well. So you can kind of...
19:01 See where we're at. You can see the Jazz Jubilee. So a little interesting thing here is you can see what we did was the tent application came in at a $22,000 cost. So what staff did there was just deduct the $5,000 that was built into each of the four applicants' letters of agreement, which was the Jazz Jubilee, Chamber Music Unbound, Mammoth Lakes Foundation.
19:31 And Sierra Summer Festival. So we pay that directly. And just talking with Juliana and Evan, that's probably something we'll probably do directly if we do that next year directly with the town. And then we do believe that Chamber Music Unbound didn't request sufficient funds. So they're $3,000 short of their expenses. So we still have to work that.
19:57 Issue out, they might have to request additional funds through next year's cycle just to balance out their request through that project. So that was the only one that we had some questions with. You can see everything else is pretty straightforward. You can see Mammoth Bluegrass spent most of their funds. Village Fest, Mammoth Council for the Arts Kids Fishing Festival. See the foundation in there.
20:23 $15,000 worth of, or $14,945 of their marketing expenses. And then still outstanding, you can see Sierra Summer Festival, we're just waiting on their expenses, waiting on Chamber of Commerce, their expenses for Mammoth Rocks, Hop and Sage, and we've paid the barricade. So you can kind of see where, we've paid out $164 of the $195 for the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition events.
20:53 So you can see we're about a couple hundred thousand dollars short on paying out those awards. So that's kind of where we're at. So it's good procedure. I think it's working well. It's been very intensive, tracking everybody through their awards. So with that, I'll turn it back over to the committee. Any questions? Any questions? Yes. Yes.
21:17 I just have one, so I'll make it easy. Hey, Stuart, I've got a question about the multi-use facility programming where you went over budget by $11,200. How is it authorized to go over budget? So remember that was Measure R and Measure U? So what we did, we transferred money out of Measure R to put it back into Measure U. So we balanced out that fund as well. So Measure U only?
21:46 Spent the $30,000 we authorized? Yes. Okay, and the balance is from Measure U. So we balance that out in January. Okay. And we have a balance of about $10,000 in Measure R right now for that program. So that one was covered. And that will be the performance report that will come out for the next funding cycle. On the tent, if I total the four lines in your fund balance column, it's a little over $33,000. So is there excess money there?
22:18 What was that again, Don? On the four lines that say tent, there's 7,000, 12,000, 5,000, 9,000. If you total those, it's a little over 33,000, which is a bit more than 22,000. No, we just paid out 22. Okay, so that was excess. It was 22. It was no excess. The other 11,000 is? I'm not following it. On the right-hand column.
22:51 You have a status that says tent. Coop? Coop? Coop. Coop. If you total those four lines, it's 33,000 plus. Yeah, we'd have to get into the details. I can speak to you later, but it's actually, it's 22 was, I think there's, yeah. Okay. We didn't overpay. And, you know, this is the whole issue that we just had from the beginning, I think, as you know, when this application came forward, we just, it just got too convoluted for everybody to participate, so anyway.
23:21 Okay. We've worked with the Foundation. We're right on the numbers. We haven't overpaid. But there are some of those applications, like I mentioned, with the Chamber of Music that are short just because of the way they're funding and they didn't receive sufficient funds. Sandy? Yeah, mine's... The first one is on the attachment A, I guess it is here. Usually... I found just a little bit...
23:49 Confusing because I saw, when I first started reading this, going through it, I saw in parens the fund balance, and usually the parentheses indicate a deficit. Yes, the other way around. And so, I mean, I'm going through this going, you know, and it took me a little while to realize what was going on. And is this the way it comes from fiscal?
24:09 This is my spreadsheet. Okay. It's basically funding awarded minus fund use gives you the balance left. So look at the column at the top. So it says fund balance. They're all positive. You can run the numbers. So we can switch it the other way if you want. Yeah, I know. Actually, I really appreciate the layout. I think we're trying to work on it. These are getting better and better. But I would suggest maybe just because otherwise, did you read it the same way? Usually those indicate deficits.
24:38 And that would make it a little, and then, but I do, it's good. As a negative fund balance. As a negative fund balance, exactly. And so, and here I see the status, and then on the next page also, is that also the status, do they match here, or? I kind of went back and forth trying to figure them out, but basically.
25:06 You know, I like the comments because that tells us a little bit. Yes. And if we're short, and to me, this would be really kind of a nice recurring, until the next award at least, to kind of go over each time. So if we have any questions, because I'm sure these more figures are going to come in and the status will change and that way we can kind of...
25:28 The attachment B is kind of a, you can see it started actually, and I just keep adding the columns, so I started as the recommendation table, and then you add the filter score, and then the council awards it, and then I'll add the funding spent, so it's a good tracking column, but as you know, right now, our temporary employee from Sierra Employment Services started yesterday, and they've actually started with Measure U, so they've started that fund balance now.
25:56 They're in the process of reconciling, and they actually started with that Spring Test Award yesterday, and the goal there is to convert it into QuickBooks. So probably next time you'll see it, you'll see it per award and per kind of a QuickBooks statement. So it'll be a little bit different, but it'll be a lot more...
26:15 Probably user-friendly. Okay. So kind of be a continuing, it'll be kind of a continuing report. Exactly. Yeah, I want to try and do it. I think that'll be helpful, I think, for all of us. Yeah. Thank you. Any other questions or comments from the committee? Well, I guess they'll come a little bit later into the staff report. I've got a few notes, but they'll pass the name of the continuing standing item. Yeah.
26:41 Then let's move along to review the proposed Measure U event criteria and application form developed by the Measure U event task force and provide direction to staff regarding incorporating the recommendations into the upcoming fall award. Stu, I don't have this paperwork with me. Obviously, since you had to call and remind me because my arm didn't. I'll get it down for you, Bill. I appreciate that. Thank you. I didn't know if there's any public comments on that last item.
27:11 Because I know the members of the public are probably here to want to speak on it. Sorry, I think. Sorry about that. Are there any public comments for the... I know Steve wanted to speak on it, yeah. I'm sorry, I'm late. Sorry, buddy. I missed what you're working on. This was the special event, spring award and event, so it's just kind of that recap. So if you wanted to speak to the events that happened this summer...
27:40 This would be the opportunity. Thank you again. I apologize for being late. This year I worked at each one of the special events from start to finish. I was hit at all of them. I applaud you guys and what you're doing and how you're allocating the money. I think it's great for the community. I brought in a lot of new guests and visitors to our town. And I think that's what the...
28:10 Some of the events were just so well run, I can't say enough about it. A couple of events had real issues, and one in particular, and it really upset me. I went and got somebody from the Measure U Committee, the City Council, the property owners, other event organizers.
28:38 Code enforcement, the police department, the chief of police to come out and look at the damage that was done to the property, the feeding of wildlife, many, many things that went wrong during the event. I've had a lot of time to think about it and rather than just attack that one event organizer that seems to be chronic in not being able to be responsible with the money that were given to her, I think it would be...
29:08 More beneficial to have a broader scope. It seems like my efforts and my concerns and what we saw and documented, it's not my job. It's not my duty. It seems really quick.
29:31 Quite awkward that I was the one that cried foul and brought all this to the attention of the community and to the committee. I guess my comment, to be more concise, is that if we're going to spend this kind of money, it seems like there should be someone or some way to oversee the success and failure of the events that's put on. And so, again, rather than having a personal attack,
30:00 On this event organizer, that's not my intentions, but this is an enormous amount of money, and I think that there needs to be some checks and balances so that we don't see it continue to repeat every year. And I guess that would be my comments. It was really, really just so profound to see an event on the same property done so well, with so much concern.
30:30 So much thought, and then on the exact same property, see, you know, so much destruction and so much stuff go wrong. And so I would encourage you guys as you brainstorm this and think about it, if you could think about it some way, it's such a busy summer, there's events every weekend, I don't mean to lay it off on you guys that you have to work the hours that I do, but there's...
30:57 To have the event organizers report back on themselves on how well they did, I just don't think it's accurate or beneficial. It seems to be some other way to have oversight on these events and the things that are going on. Thank you. Steve, was this, do you mind telling us which event it was? That would be helpful. Yeah, I think it was called El Caliente.
31:25 No, Fiesta Caliente. Fiesta Caliente, okay. And this was, was this a first year event? No, no. No, it's gone on before, on that same area? No, no. New venue. New venue, okay, okay. Mammoth Creek Park was the third year, I believe, first year at Samson Center.
31:44 If I may, you know, the banners were left up for multiple days on Main Street. The cones were left up blocking traffic in front of the event. The organizers went home. The decorations and all the lighting was left on. The garbage was left all over the property. It was just, it was beyond belief. And so things that we work on all the time as...
32:10 The town council, the community, all the committees that sit and spend their time, we're actually funding those violations. And so if you did it with your own money and then you messed up and you weren't responsible, that's one thing, and we work on stuff like that every day. But to actually pay with our tax money to have these violations happen, I just find it, gosh, it just seems...
32:39 Awfully bizarre. Now, I was trying to keep names out of it, but this has gone on for, you know, three out of four years. The same event organizer got somebody bit by a bear. That went worldwide to my embarrassment. That's not what we're known for. The same event organizer had a disastrous thing two years ago on the same deal.
33:05 She puts on another event on the same property. I walked it late at night. It was much better, but there was half-open beers and soda pops all over the stage in the middle of the night in the center of the venue where people were sleeping on the property. It just seems to be chronic. And I haven't been able to reel it in. The other members of our staff up for the town hasn't been able to reel it in. And so how do you get to those people?
33:35 I think it's by dollars. And so I think that you guys, again, I applaud you. You sit and spend all these hours, and it's not a shot over your bow. But if we don't have some kind of oversight on it, I just find it incredible that we continue to fund the same person that continues to do this stuff.
33:57 I'm trying to be polite. Was that the only one that you had problems with? Yes, ma'am. And the logistics on some of the other events were...
34:06 Ten and twenty times larger. The volumes of drafts, the volumes of people, the volumes of volunteers. It was just overwhelming. I can't say enough about how hard those people tried and how well they did. And so again, it's just shocking to see the difference just weeks apart on the exact same property and see it.
34:30 One of them put on so incredibly well, and one of them put on so terribly. And that's my, it's not just my frustration, but again, I want to contribute to the conversation that could we use some of those dollars or some way, or put that as one of my duties. I feel really awkward reporting to you, I have no business in this other than feeding wildlife and entrapping the bears and baiting bears.
34:57 Ms. Steve, she also has a much larger event, Labor Day. Do you experience similar things there? That's when all the crap, excuse me, all the stuff was on the stage. When that event closed down, just like last year and the year before, she left the event early because she knew I was gunning for her. Because the dumpsters had been left open every year, the dumpsters were padlocked shut. That's appropriate and a good call so that there wasn't anybody leaving them open.
35:26 Though the people were still on the property cleaning up their stuff, there wasn't anybody there. She had left town. So the people, when they walked over, they're from out of town, they don't know. I don't fault them. When they walked over to the dumpster and the dumpster was locked, we just set the bags in trash there. That was this year, sorry. Having someone responsible for policing the side afterwards is...
35:53 I know what you're asking for. I don't like to take people to court. I don't like to write people's citations. But if I have to, I will. If I can't convince them any other way, working with them, educating them, encouraging them, helping them, that's what I've done every year. I'm not breaking through. So again, finally, I have to hold people responsible. And again, you guys are the ones writing the checks.
36:15 I think I've overstated it, but I can't find any other words to tell you how frustrated I am. And again, what a great job you guys are doing, what a great job some of the organizers are doing. And then to see somebody put a black eye on the property, the property owners, all the homes that surround the property, it's a big ripple effect. It's not just me that was frustrated. A lot of people were upset about it.
36:40 This is, if I may, Steve called me and I went and looked at the site, and totally unacceptable. There was more trash the next morning at the site after Fiesta Caliente than you will find at any time during either Bluesapalooza or Jazz Jubilee, which are much, much bigger, because they understand the need to go and pick the trash up between sets and do those things. The only place where I will differ with Steve is she puts on a good event.
37:08 However, the understanding of how important the trash piece is in our town does not seem to be there. I have not talked with her personally. I know Steve has, and we have talked about it many times. She honestly, I think, does not understand the need to clean up that night. Everyone's tired. They want to go home. She wants to come back and do it the next day. Those of us who have been involved with events, and I know you have been and I have as well.
37:36 No matter how tired you are at the end of the event, you've got to pick it all up, including chairs if they aren't going to be used again the next day if possible. It seems to me that two things are required here. One, that we put in our report back for the person and that we put in our, I know we have it written in when they meet with Stu about how important trash is.
38:00 But we need to make it clear that if their events are not policed for trash, that they will not receive further funding. We operate on the wood site especially, which has become the predominant site, by the good graces of four different landowners, two different parcels of property. And a bunch of neighbors. And a bunch of neighbors. And I know some of the neighbors, and I know the landowners involved, and I know how unhappy they are when trash is blowing around.
38:30 After an event. So this is something that needs to be dealt with in a decisive way. I don't want to discourage the events. These are some really good events. But if we can't have the necessary volunteers to clean this up, and I know that's an ongoing problem with Fiesta Caliente, then professionals need to be hired to do the cleanup. And again, as I agree with Steve, probably we should not have to pay for that.
38:57 The other event organizers find a way to get it done. And to only have one organizer that doesn't seem to understand the... And I said she puts on good events. I don't want to discourage her events. But we need to make it somehow clear that this is unacceptable and will not be tolerated in the future. And I'll go one further. Steve, on his own dime and his own time, I wouldn't ask that to the town. He is. I've said that before. I'll say it again. I'm sure that if we ask him to come back with a report card on each event,
39:27 Which I would love to ask him to do for us. That he would bring that back and we would know how each event is handling its trash. He is there to monitor for the bears and to help keep away from the people. And if he's there anyway, I think that asking him to give us just a paragraph on what he sees that could be done better with pickup and trash and who is and who isn't doing well would be much appreciated by me at least. But I would just add that that's...
39:56 The trash management, yup, a huge deal, feet in a while, a huge deal, but again, Bill saw the banners hung up for days on Main Street after the event was over, that the lights had been left on all night long and aren't on. You know, hundreds of lights, light pollution, we talk about all that, that all the decorations were torn down by another event organizer because they were under the gun to get their stuff set up. They had to pay their own employees.
40:25 To clean up all the crap because it didn't get done for days later. So again, it's not just the trash that was on the ground, which was, I've never seen anything like it, but all the cones were left out in the street, you know, 70, 80 cones. It's beyond belief, but again, if you could look at it in a bigger scope, not just my concerns about our living with the wildlife, but there was many things that weren't done well.
40:53 On that event. And it seems again to be chronic. Is there any other questions I can answer? Just maybe to Stu, it seems to me like this is something in the operations plan that has really got to be beefed up. And if our award is basically to, the award would be to hire a cleanup crew, maybe that's the way, because I agree, I mean this can't go on. And no matter how good the events are,
41:22 Because that, I mean, it sounds terrible, frankly. And I'm sure a couple of other ones weren't perfect, but, I mean, this is the type of thing, especially when we have a record of problems, maybe the only awards we make are talking to a cleanup crew that works all night, you know, because you guys, what a huge event, and yours is cleaned up. Yes.
41:44 But again, I would hate to punish another event organizer that has a great track record. I'm not talking about all of them. It's doing super well. Yeah, I think we have one follow-up. I'm saying track record, yeah. That's what occurs to me. We're about to go through a new application form process, and it first occurred to me, well, maybe we do something there, but do we try to impose something on all the other events? Also, trying to get town staff adding extra to them, that's kind of...
42:13 So maybe an operation plan and emphasizing it as we review or whatever, something. They have to have one. They have to have an operations plan, I'm sure, but we maybe need to beef it up. Maybe we need to think about it. When we have a bad track record, that's where the money goes. They can hire a crew. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, Steve. Thanks, Steve.
42:36 Actually, I have a question for Steve. Steve, did you go to, were you just referring to the Sam's Woods events, or did you go down to the foundation where we had the tent as well?
42:44 I'm sorry, but I didn't attend that at all. Okay, okay, I just wanted to clarify that. Okay, so on a happy note, as a representative of Mammoth Lakes Foundation right now, and one of the four events that did the tent down at the foundation property, I just want to thank you for the opportunity to do that event, to have those four venues together in a single structure.
43:11 We learned a lot. We knew it was going to be a toe-in-the-water test to see is it viable. We learned a lot. There were a lot of positives. There were some negatives. We've already had our post-events meeting to talk about those negatives, and we have plans for moving forward. We're very excited about that. Hopefully, we'll be sharing with you later. As a member of the task force, Pat and I are here today, but I did want to tell you that one of the things that
43:38 That we talked about in our meetings when putting together the application process for the events was having the event producers being environmentally aware and responsible. I don't think we had necessarily a checklist attached to that, but we were very, Joyce, you were in those meetings too when we were talking, talking about making sure that people were responsible for what they were doing.
44:05 And frankly, I don't think that, in my opinion, if someone does a bad job of policing their area and then needs more money to do trash pickup, it should not come out of Measure U. That is their responsibility. One of the questions we ask throughout this process in the task force is, would you put on this event if you didn't get money from Measure U? And if your answer is no, we can't put on the event at all,
44:34 Then maybe you have to think about that. And if it's a matter of, oh, we can't put on the event and we can't do the trash pickup, I don't think you reward someone by giving them enough money to do trash pickup when everyone else has been doing it successfully all along. Can I have a comment? You know, I'm thinking through the whole process because I know it kind of inside and out at this point. And we do have the accountability in the
45:02 Application process. There is a whole section on wildlife responsibility. And I think maybe rather than inventing a new rule or a new accountability matrix, we just really need to hold people to the one that exists within the application. And maybe it's a report back from staff on how people did on being accountable to the application process and the application requirements. Lights and cones and banners. Yeah.
45:32 That's all in there. I don't think there's a timeline on bringing it down, and maybe that's what we need to add. There's got to be some kind of emphasis on cleanup and a timeline to go with that. And maybe relying too much on volunteers. I don't want to dictate to somebody how to operate their event. I want to hold them accountable to a standard. And you know, in terms of the volunteers, if
46:00 The community buys into an event, as it has with several in town. The volunteers are available for somebody that wants to manage them to do it. If the community does not buy into the event to the point where you can get the volunteers, then perhaps it is not a community benefiting event and the community is not supporting it and we shouldn't be putting money into it. I mean, I think about those things with each event we do. Your ability to get volunteers speaks volumes.
46:31 About communities' buy-in to the event. So I don't know if we should ask somebody to hire professionals to do trash. We should ask them to have events that the community buys into enough that they can find volunteers. I think that that's an important piece of getting community buy-in.
46:46 Pat just pointed out to me, and Joyce was saying as well, when we get to item three in the agenda, the checklist, we actually have several categories that include waste, recycling collection, and wildlife management as part of the checklist for an event producer. So they are going to have to address those. And I think it's better to be addressed in the application process, not the post-event report. Post-event, it's too late. Yeah, and I've gone over the application, and we spoke to it at the rec commission as well.
47:18 I think there was no timeline. We would need to add a timeline. So if an event organizer feels that they can come and clean up the next day, that satisfies their environmental, so it does need to be stated in a term that all sites have to be cleaned up the day of the event. Or security. Shall we try and review this when we move on to the next discussion item? Yeah, I think the only thing left here, and I don't think we can do an action,
47:49 But we could do a consensus is whether or not we saw value in asking Mr. Searles to give report back on, since he does attend every event. Most. Most events, right. Any event where there might possibly be interaction between animals and humans, that we ask for his, if you think that that's something we could do, then we could just have stew.
48:17 Ask Steve to do that at the events that he goes to. Well, if I might, Bill, I look at everything on here. Certainly we think about Fiesta Caliente and those, but the Kids Fishing Festival and Village Fest, and I see a whole number of things on here. We probably, it wouldn't be necessary. Right. So, a blanket.
48:42 No, just the ones that he feels. I know he goes to the ones at the village because they've had bear issues up there before. Or a kamikaze or things at the mountain. What do we include in this? Just the ones that he already attends. I'm not interested in asking him to go and spend time outside because I'm not interested in paying him any more than he already gets. Just the events that he finds it necessary to attend.
49:11 A report back to me would be, I get one anyway, whether I want it or not, but I think it would be beneficial for the whole committee. If staff may, I think this issue is much broader, and we speak to it a little bit in item three as well, and it's really the town's role in special events. I mean, it's really, it's quite significant. You know, we talk about just the oversight of the event here, but there's also the setup, it's the working with the application, it's working with the event organizer.
49:43 Phenomenal amount of work that goes on. And I think we could probably discuss that another Recreation Commission who talked about it last meeting and the task force talked about it considerably as well. So I really think that's probably where it comes into play. And just quickly on the permit, there is enforcement in there of up to $500 per day if the permit holder does not fulfill the requirements of the use.
50:09 Regulations as stated in the permit. So, I mean, there is that opportunity for the town to actually, you know, find that event organiser. The problem with that is who does that, you know, and it has to be consistent across all the events as well, which is kind of a little bit what we just talked about. But again, it just brings into play the role of the town and now considerably with the funding that we're providing these events of, you know, $250,000. How is it being oversight? I mean, where's the oversight? How is it being conducted? Who's doing it?
50:39 Because at the moment we're just all kind of piecemealing it. So anyway, I think it's a broader discussion in the whole role of the events. So at this point it's the town that would issue the fine. Correct. It's in nowhere is it written that the award would not be completed because of that. Correct. It's specific to that special event permit that the town issues. It's not related to funding whatsoever. Okay.
51:07 Thank you. Under the town, the things like cones and lights and banners that really aren't Steve's purview as such, we could be a bit more inclusive and try to cover all of it. And maybe we make it clear going in the $500 fine potential as part of the application, let the event promoters know that. Is that at all mentions due in there? It's on every comment.
51:37 Okay, but is it in the application? It's, like you said, it's just part of a special event permit that any, you know, event organizer brings forward, whether they receive Measure U funding or not, so. Okay. Thank you. We've never enforced it, right, because we don't really have, essentially, a process to enforce that's consistent across the board. You know, like you're saying, if it's a report card or a checklist or something, who does it? It's got to be the same person. It's got to just be, you know, a program.
52:03 So the next item. Yeah, I really think it might just be part of that larger issue in regards to, you know, town. All right. Then if there are no more comments or questions, let's move on to number three. To review the proposed Measure U event criteria and application form developed by the Measure U event task force and provide direction to staff regarding incorporating the recommendations into the upcoming fall award. Let me just record the previous conversation.
52:34 Okay, so item number three is quite extensive. It started quite a long time ago. May 1st, Town Council approved the formation of that five-member limited task force. And since that time, the task force have comprised of Mammoth Lakes Tourism Executive Director John Urdi, Recreation Commissioner Pat Agnich, Measure U Application Committee, Member Joyce Turner,
53:02 Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, Representative Sandra DiDomizio, and Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition, Representative Julia Alinka, met four times, you can see on May 31, July, August, and then finally on August 22nd. Five times? You met five times. Okay, I had four times. Might have just been in her sleep. No, we're thinking about it all the time.
53:27 The committee had a very detailed scope of work that was provided by both the commission, the committee and ratified by council. The first was to address the list of questions developed by those bodies and then the second task was to develop a specific application form just for special events. The goal was to really incorporate that event application process
53:50 With the existing award process. So it wouldn't run separately, it would run concurrently and be integrated with. So the goal there would be any event coming forward wishing to receive funds would kind of be directed to complete and submit that application form specific for events. So what we've done here is identified, we renumbered them, we went away from the Roman numerals.
54:18 We just went with alphabet. I think that might be easier. And what we did is you can see on page 3 through I think it's 6, 7 are the recommendations from the task force. And then attachment B is the application form itself. So what I would recommend the committee do is to review the questions first.
54:45 And what we've done from the recreation commission comments is just underline their recommendations into this document. So we've just kind of kept it all together so you can kind of see what their comments were. And the goal here is to bring this forward today and direct staff with whatever recommendations you bring forward.
55:11 to incorporate this process and the application form into the fall award process, which would then be considered at the next item, being item number four. So we've kind of done it this first way because it's events and then we'll consider the entire Measure U fall award in the next item. Just a clarification question, would this be...
55:32 One of our discussion topics with the Council on October 2nd. I think we have a meeting. Yeah, so again, I didn't create a separate staff report for that, but we do need to talk about that item. The primary goal of the October 2nd workshop with Council is really the funding priorities and then how the two awards sync or how they – what's the relationship between the Measure R and the Measure U Fall Award. We've got the timelines kind of –
55:59 Stretched out, but, you know, how is it really going to run, and is that the best way? And certainly if we want to bring this up, the event recommendations will be presented to Council as part of the complete packet for the Measure U full award, right? So they'll actually review the entirety together, not on its own. So it'll just be one element of the full award. As a follow-on to Sandy's question, on your recommendation on page 7 of 7,
56:27 It says we provide comments to ourselves. What we're really doing is reviewing this and providing comments to the staff as to what the final process and form should be. Okay. With that, I'll turn it back over to the committee. Thank you. Any questions or comments from committee members? That just helps a little bit. I wasn't sure if we had to have this ready by the second. I was going, it's kind of soon. Okay, so that's good to hear that it's a little bit later.
57:03 In other words, we can give a status report perhaps. I'm assuming, Chair, we're going to go through this question by question and look at their answers to which and make comments. All right. Just to fill in, so November 6th is when the Town Council will review and approve the final Measure U packet for the fall. So that's the point, that everything's tied up and buttoned up together. So there we go. So there is one more meeting on October 15th.
57:33 Okay. That we have to look at this item. Fine-tune this a bit. Correct. And the intent of this is these are guidelines for us. Correct. Right. I was a little worried when I read the article in The Times. It sounded like they were going to try to have the town council adopt it by resolution. I thought, well, there goes our flexibility. So I think if we look at it as guidelines, that's our – in other words, we would be recommending it as something that we will, you know.
58:01 Massage as we go along, but it gives us the flexibility to try these out. All right, so, Bill, shall we move through B? Is that what you're proposing? Page by page? Page three of seven, just start with A, I would think, and move down. All right. Some of these should go real quickly, and some of them we may have questions on. And we have three members of the task force here, so.
58:28 Three. Three members, yeah, which is very helpful. If we have any questions, clarification, or want to know rationale or things like that, I think. All right, so on page three of seven, A, what are the priorities and objectives of event funding? The priorities of funding for events are determined, firstly, by the mission statement, and secondly, the Measure U annual funding priorities established by the Measure U Application Committee. We did have a question. When did we develop a mission?
58:59 The mission statement for events. I can't remember. It was part of the task force. It was part of the task force. Yeah, it was up to the task force to do that. Okay, perfect. So. These are the questions we ask them. And then these are their answers coming back. Good enough. And Bill, what do you think? That I should just read everything through? No, I think everyone can read what's there and just ask questions. I think most of us should have read them already anyway. Pay to the time or pay to the time. I have a question for staff though, Stu.
59:29 Do we have, does this include the comments already made by the rec commission? Yep. Those alterations have been made in this text? Yeah, you'll see on page four, I just underlined the comments and included them in the document. So I believe I captured most of those concerns. On that first one, the mission statement, I really actually liked it a lot. I would have only made one little change.
59:58 And that was based on Evan Russell's comments where he noted that Measure U was really focused upon the locals, the residents, the second homeowners, and the fact that all of those folks are paying for, all of us are paying for the utility tax. And so the only thing I would have changed here is by enhancing the quality of life for residents and thereby enhancing the visitor experience.
1:00:25 I'd like to speak to that a little bit because even though Evan stated it that way, I think there wasn't consensus on that comment. And I was very much appreciating the committee because we did very honestly and openly and respectfully talk about all of these things and a lot of time was put into this mission statement word by word, literally. And I'm thrilled with how that came out.
1:00:52 Jillianna, you can comment, but I thought everybody was pretty happy with this, and I would hope that this committee would support and empower how much time and effort was put in by that committee on coming up with this specific wording. I have no problem with the wording on it. I think it's good overall. That was the only small change I would have made. And we're happy with our...
1:01:20 Funding priorities, we did those last time. Well, we're going to be dealing with any change in those in number four anyway. So, any other questions or comments for page three, categories B and C? In the audience? Yeah, from the audience, thank you. I think it's actually probably just a typo, but if you look under BA, it's in parentheses, it says performing arts, visual arts and arts.
1:01:51 Art-based, it should actually be arts-based education because arts embraces theater, dance, music, and art. If you say art, it looks like you're drawing or painting or doing sculpture. So I would just suggest we add an S to that. Thank you, Juliana. I do have one comment, and I have to apologize. I did miss the last one or two meetings.
1:02:13 Some family issues that were going on. And I don't know how it came out, Juliana, so I'm kind of asking as much as I'm commenting. When a lot of the conversation we had on the earlier meetings was around what's the definition of culture. And from the last meeting I left from, I was leaving with the understanding that we were looking at culture not only as
1:02:40 The arts and the performing arts and the things listed here, but also as the culture of our community and our community's culture includes outdoor recreation and all of these other things that are part of it. So I'm not sure how this got refined down to excluding all of that from culture, but my feeling and belief is culture is not only these types of cultural activities, but also the culture of our community. I just want to state that for the record.
1:03:09 Joey is here correct. We did have a lot of discussion regarding that. And at the last meeting or two, we did come to a determination that recreation component is one element of Measure U funding along with mobility and arts and culture. And we thought that culture should be kept separate from recreation because recreation events could be like kamikaze or hiking.
1:03:34 Whatever it happens to be, more of a broad term. So we thought there was a distinction. Okay. So how would then a cultural organization such as, say, the Southern Mount Historical Society fit into performing arts, visual arts, and arts-based? It really doesn't. There almost needs to be a... Because we gather... There's two categories, arts and culture, and other events. It would fit into other events. But that's culture.
1:04:04 History is culture. Arts and culture historically defined has to do with the performing arts. I can pull out some of the definitions that I have. Dan, what was the word you said? Relativism. Relativism. Relativism is whatever is relative to everyone right now, so we can all define culture as the carpet on the floor. But realistically speaking, when you look at the definition of arts and culture, it has to do with music, art, dance, and art.
1:04:33 It doesn't mean that you can have entertainment, you can have music, you can have all kinds of tastings, you can have an event, but it doesn't necessarily mean that parts of arts and culture as it's defined in arts and culture. So the consensus that was reached at the last two meetings when we defined that is we would separate arts and culture events as one category and other events to embrace everything that did not fit into that, which means technically
1:05:03 If you wanted to apply for Measure U funds for that, that would fall under other events. So it's still open theoretically, but not arts and culture as it is historically defined. I suppose because I'm involved in it, I have a hard time viewing history and the gathering of information on the culture that existed as being non-culture.
1:05:26 Certainly, I will tell you, we had a very lengthy, detailed, sometimes passionate and dispassionate discussion about culture. There's also cultured milk. You can grow a culture in a petri dish. But when you're talking about arts and culture, you're not talking, you are literally talking about those performance arts components. It doesn't mean that history isn't important.
1:05:51 Absolutely. I love history. I would love to talk about history with you at some point in time, but it doesn't make it an arts and cultural event when you're talking about arts and culture as a category. If you look at it in any way, it's divine. I'm not saying it doesn't add to the culture of town, but if you're talking about arts and culture events, they are very specific to those performance categories. And I'm totally, you know, based on my last statements in particular, I'm totally willing to support what the committee
1:06:19 I think we need to add maybe a statement to be a little more clear because if I were the general public reading this I would be right there with Bill in that history is culture. You know, it's part of our culture. Some people would not.
1:06:34 Well, and that's, but the point, the point is, is we need to be clear for the public. We have to, we need to. Well, the category, it does say other events, yes? Yes, it does. Special events? So it allows for, it allows for a wide variety. That's as broad as you can get. Other is as broad as you can get. I think what Joyce may be, what I'm kind of looking at here is if we go to the, actually the application, perhaps in there we may want to add special event.
1:07:03 Because that would be the only place, what I'm thinking about, you know, page three of the application. I was just looking, because that's really where it relates. Oh, there you go. Yeah, you're asking people to indicate what they're applying for. And I think Joyce's question is, well, where would she apply? Would it be a recreational event? Would it be arts and culture? Would it be mobility? And I think we're asking people to apply for one of those. Yeah. And just as an example, because I know it so well, if I were to apply,
1:07:33 Via Blues of Palooza and all I had was what was here. I would apply under arts and culture because I consider craft beer a very cultural event. And so all I'm asking for is clarification. I'm not challenging what you guys came up with. We just need some clarification. Well, and I have no problem with this definition as long as it pertains only to events. And we're not going to carry this definition of culture for all things Measure U. Right, correct. Because the things the historical society would apply for.
1:08:00 If they were an event, I would just stick it in one of the other categories, which is easy for me to do. I can recall having a band out there performing arts. I can, you know, so I can make, as all applicants do, I can make almost anything work. I would just hate for this to become, for anything other than special events, the definition of culture. That's right. Yeah, and maybe in our funding categories we just add something like recreational or other special event. Or other special events.
1:08:28 I mean, because the arts and culture, I think the committee has, it sounds like, has really discussed this a lot. And if we're going to defer to the committee, I think it's time to do it. And I just actually want to go on record to reinforce what Joyce said. It was, I think, a very diverse group of five people. And it was probably, and Pat, you agree, right? It's probably one of the best experiences of working with a group of people.
1:08:55 We were serious, we were dedicated, we stuck to the material, we focused on what we needed to focus on, and we reached consensus. And what you see in front of you is a huge consensus document. And, you know, there were some, as with today's review, some things went really easy, some things were more difficult, but we all took the time to reach consensus on everything. I mean, that mission statement took us a long time. No, I can, it's good. Thank you.
1:09:27 Any other comments or questions on Category C? I did have a clarification. How did you reach urban limit? I know that the, I think the Rec Commission also had that. How was that reached? I mean, it's not a big deal. I just like to know the rationale behind it rather than municipal. Because, you know, in other words, municipal, the urban limit,
1:09:59 And that's different from the municipal limit. Which point was that? Under C. Under C. And just to clarify, the municipal boundary actually goes up and includes Mammoth Mountain, the Lakes Basin. It goes out a ways. But the urban, the urban limit is the developed limit. You're correct. We did discuss it at the Recreation Commission. And I think what we decided was events that do not benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes would not be considered. We got away from what the definition of urban.
1:10:30 Urban, okay, that, I would agree with that, because. That's the rec commission markup. Yeah, although I'm not seeing that. See it right here. It is elsewhere, I think. It's on the next page. It's on the next page? Yeah, it's all part of the same. Okay, for under events. Okay, so, as amended, so we could actually. I'll just take that. Just line out, open to the public. And directly benefit the tenement folks. And direct, okay, okay, good, yeah, yeah.
1:11:06 Can I make a quick comment on that? Yes. Mm-hmm. Yeah, you'll mark. Hi, my name is Mark Deeds. Just maybe some additional discussion might be recommended on that point. Case in point with this summer's Mammoth to Bishop Ride that Lloyd put on, it started in Mammoth. It finished at Mill Pond. There was benefit to Mammoth Lakes. Did it finish in Mammoth? No.
1:11:35 Did the primary point of the event exist in the town or reside in the town boundary? No, but there was undeniably benefit to the town, so I'm not sure how tightly you want to restrict the language on that, maybe leave it open to having the event producer be required to develop and demonstrate benefit to be able to.
1:12:04 You know, maybe have part of an event out of town due to the limited number of event sites that exist here. Which is why the Rec Commission suggested changing the verbiage to events that do not directly benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes versus hosted outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes urban limit. Because there are many things that go on outside of our urban limit that are direct benefits to the town. Eventually the biathlon.
1:12:30 Could be outside the town's limits, and it's a huge benefit to the town. Bike races, motorcycle or snowmobile events, it goes on and on, things that require more space than what the urban limit contains. Anything at Canyon Lodge? Yeah. So the question is, do we need to change? No, I think you change it on the next page, so that's good.
1:12:56 Yeah, do we need to change it in the first page as well? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, Stu's going to make it. Yeah, Stu's going to make it. So, to be clear then, that would remove the urban limit and replace it with direct benefit. And we have consensus on that, right? Yeah, yeah. And so the verbiage that we read on the last bullet on page four of seven is the way we read? Yep. Okay.
1:13:25 Yeah, you would eliminate the bottom line and replace it with the underlined line. And just above that, I believe the question's redundant. So do we deal with, do we need it? And then I would like to know, because the committee recommended that nobody receives more than 30% of their budget, why it was put in that a majority of event funding from Measure U, is this where you would have actually put in
1:14:06 Whether or not it would go forward with or without Measure U, or? Are you talking about the second to the last item? Yes. The second to the last bullet, yeah. Because I think the rec commission just felt it wasn't necessary. I always try to pick out an example, and the kids fishing festival always jumps out at me. Because I know that there have been a couple of years when it's been on the chopping block, and it would not have happened without us.
1:14:38 And then one year she got the money and so we awarded her money. She got the money from elsewhere so it wasn't used. But last year I think we funded it. We did. Probably pretty much 100%. Yep. So that's one of those ones where I'm wondering, these are generally, maybe that's one that should be asterisked also, you suppose? Well, I think the asterisk just needs to put in that we are not going to not.
1:15:08 Accept any application. That the Measure U Committee ultimately will decide what moves forward and what doesn't move forward. Okay. So these are general guidelines. In other words, as a general guideline, that's fine. As long as we're not trying to set this in stone, I agree. Do you want to keep that bullet there, though? No, I think that bullet just needs to go away, in my opinion. Because it's redundant. It's redundant.
1:15:32 Yeah. It was already discussed by the recreation. The question on 30% would still apply to the kids' fishing festival. Yeah, I know that's what worries me. Yeah, and if we chose that its value was high enough that we would fund it anyway, we would have the ability to do that. Yeah. These are recommendations, not laws. Okay. As long as we remember that we do have, there's always a... There's always an exception. Always an exception. We want to maintain our flexibility.
1:16:02 Okay. And Stu, it looks as if when the Recreation Commission Committee met last week, they underlined first-year events and one-time events. And was there something that was recommended there? I mean, I understand the disaster has been there, but that has been there for a while. What is it that they recommended? That the committee consider funding first-year and one-time events.
1:16:31 The task force, however, felt differently. We felt and had agreement that first year events and one year only events should not be given consideration for funding. Let an event prove itself one year and then come back to the second year for funding. The commission felt to the contrary that at least those events should be given the opportunity to be considered.
1:16:58 So that does give you a little bit more flexibility. But the task force felt that those events should prove themselves, and if it's just a one-year fly-by-night event, then it should be funded. And I think part of that came from the sustainability conversation. How sustainable are these events and what are they really contributing to that mission? It's a risk management issue is what it is. And my issue with that was that sometimes an opportunity for a one-time event, what I used at the rec commission was,
1:17:27 What if somebody was personal friends with the Rolling Stones and they needed 10 grand to get them here and they were willing to do a show? I don't want to ever preclude us being able to fund a one-time event. I understand the need to discourage one-time events, but sometimes there are things that happen that require us thinking outside of that box. So I don't want to put it worded in such a way that would preclude us from doing that. And there have been in Mammoth's past many very good events.
1:17:55 That would not have ever gotten off the ground had they not received first year funding. So again, they require certainly a whole lot more look than an event that has a track record. But to just discount them off hand without an opportunity didn't seem appropriate. So they already had the asterisk saying that
1:18:21 They can present their compelling reasons for funding considerations. We only added the one time, the first year event the committee already had down there. Perhaps we can add some verbiage. We have things on here, lobbying, a number of things that are just absolutely we know we don't want to consider. But there are things that maybe we can find a way to cover it under the bullet that says these things, first year events are considered exceptions that will be considered.
1:18:51 With compelling rationale. First year events or one time. Or those to cover some of those. Most of the things on this list, you know, we really wouldn't intend to fund. But there are some kinds of things that maybe we consider if there is a compelling rationale. It doesn't mean we're going to do it. But it really takes more justification. I just find it to be a bit redundant, you know, to have the mission statement.
1:19:19 You know, to support events that improve the community, culture, and economy of Mammoth Lakes by enhancing the quality of life for residents and or enhancing the visitor experience, which I love that mission statement. Thank you. I know you worked hard on that. And then to have it say, we recommend that Measure U not fund the following first-year events, one-time events, but then an asterisk unless there's a compelling reason. So in my opinion, it just...
1:19:48 It seems strange to have it in there and then to say, but we can also have it. Perhaps it's a separate list? You know, I think it's a guide. So if somebody's coming forward with a first-year event and they know that unless they can come up with something way off the hook, we're not going to fund it, it keeps us from having to do the legwork of looking at it. But it doesn't preclude them if they think they have that off-the-hook event.
1:20:12 From bringing an application forward for our consideration. So basically you are asking people to go a little bit above and beyond with their first year event. Knock our socks off if you want to do a first time event or one time event in your application. That's where the event credibility and conversation and sustainability conversation was.
1:20:34 Was really focused was, you know, those are the riskiest events to fund is the first year events and the one time event. So we didn't want people to think that, oh, we're just going to apply because we can, you know, kind of thing. We wanted them to really think hard about what they were asking for and why they were asking for and give and emphasize it, emphasize that they need a compelling reason by saying we're not going to fund these unless you tell us that there's a really solid reason to.
1:21:01 And that was actually why I was suggesting that the majority of event funding the asterisk because I'm just thinking about that one. But the underlining will go away, I think, in the final. Yes. It will go away. The asterisk would stay. And then we'd have the footnote and maybe
1:21:25 Beef it up as you were saying. I think we're all saying the same thing. Perhaps an option to help clarify it would be move those two bullets down under what is currently the asterisk and get rid of the asterisk and just make it a separate line that says event funding applicants can prevent compelling reason for funding consideration at a scheduled committee meeting for the following types of events.
1:21:51 I agree. Break it apart. Get it out of that other list. At the top of the list, this is the most important, you know, that's going to be, you know, these are the most important things to not consider, get at the bottom, have it. So I agree, I'd love to see it. Pull those down there, make them separate. That's good. I have no problem with that. Replace the asterisk with a... Yeah. And just make it the same font as the rest, put those two bullets under it.
1:22:21 Yes. And move that down to the bottom. Yep. That's not the most important thing. Just to pull them out. Yep. I have no problem with that. Okay. Stu. We have one more. Yeah, does that work? Okay. He goes. Thank you, Mark. Thank you for your email. No, thank you very much again. And incidentally, the email that was forwarded to you all was intended.
1:22:46 For the eyes of the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition. It certainly wasn't my intent to even hint at any lack of cohesion among our group, but our group, as many groups in town, are very filled with very passionate, opinionated people. My individual opinions on events differ from perhaps what some of the other members.
1:23:17 do as well. So I felt that the mood of the recommendation for adoption was kind of favoring more of the non-profit arts and cultural component of events. And I don't feel as though the quote-unquote, I always laugh immediately after I say it, but for-profit events, I do not feel it was strongly enough represented in this discussion.
1:23:51 I laugh after I say for profit because an event producer, as many people know, has an amazing amount of risk whenever they bring forth any event. The leverage and finances they put forth to bring events into town is just beyond belief and the benefits of all events has been pointed out.
1:24:19 Exhaustively over the last couple years with the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition joint applications for funding over the last two years. The Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition, in my opinion, it's the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition. It's not intended to be a Mammoth Lakes non-profit coalition, but a coalition for all events. I am an event advocate in my history, I think all could attest.
1:24:49 Worked thousands of hours volunteering for a non-profit Mammoth Rocks Taste of the Sierra event. Was the co-creator and co-founder of that event and did that for three years. I was also the co-creator and co-founder of a margarita festival, a for-profit event. I've been involved and engaged with both volunteering and in a paid position for the Bluegrass Festival. With that introduction, I just
1:25:20 I have no agenda. I have no dogs in the race. I'm not going to be bringing forth an event anytime soon, although my passion for an event, don't hold me to it, I could be rubbed back in to do an event. I think that all of what you all said just now is for the most part spot on. I understand, or at least I'm trying to understand more of
1:25:48 The reasoning and the rationale behind even bringing the restrictions forward, I understand the perceived risk of loss, but within the town's mission statement, within the Mammoth X Events Coalition business plan and mission statement, has been to foster, promote, encourage.
1:26:16 events, specifically new events, front and center on the mission statement of the general plan, multi-day events. These events don't just happen. These events happen with the encouragement and support of many different people primarily and may very well be the town support. Why hold a new or a first-time event and later a for-profit event?
1:26:44 At a disadvantage and discourage them from coming forward with all of their passion and energy and time and commitment to doing a good event. I don't think there's many instances where this body can look back and say, gosh, that event bombed. We're never going to do that again. There's certainly some instances and maybe even this summer that will be looked at hardly as, boy, that was tough. But even in the events that might be determined as not as successful as it could have been.
1:27:14 The primary and immediate beneficiary is the town of Mammoth Lakes, its people, the taxpayers. I'm vehemently opposed to any restrictions on events. I don't think new events and first-time events should be underlined or asterisked, but I appreciate the direction that you're going with, acknowledging that they need a little extra scrutiny. I understand that.
1:27:44 But we have an amazing application process there in place that undeniably has been approved with the hard work and input of the task force that they've put in on these suggestions. I think that the work that's been done is fantastic with those three exceptions. Make these new event producers and one-time potential one-time event producers. This is not unrealistic.
1:28:13 The flexibility that event producers need to be able to capitalize on bands, on routing schedules to pick up bands at a fraction on the dollar, plug them in on the shorter season where we still have gaping holes in our event schedule. By maintaining a strict limitation on any events, I think it's really doing them.
1:28:40 The event producers a disservice primarily, but then just doing the town, the town's people and visitors a disservice by not encouraging these people to come forth with these great ideas. If the application fails, if the project filter is a bomb, if they fail to meet the priorities the town has set forth, then they're done. But let them get that opportunity to get there.
1:29:11 That's pretty much all I've really wanted to say with this. Yeah, I'd like to comment for a second. And Mark, I completely appreciate it and get exactly where you're coming from, especially being an event producer ourselves. I think what you have to consider is we're talking about public money here, and we have a responsibility to be good stewards of that public money, and we can't be as risky.
1:29:39 As you could be if it were private money. So I think we were obligated and we are obligated as a committee and as good stewards to the public to put some filters on there and say we're managing the risk. We're doing good due diligence and risk management of these funds. So I liked that we put some criteria on it and maybe there's a different way to say
1:30:07 You know, I think we all agree that we certainly are willing to consider first year and one time events, but they need to understand that there's going to be a higher level of scrutiny because we're not accountable to, you know, Mammoth Brewing Company's bank account. We're accountable to every citizen in this town. So, and that's, I think if you kind of turn it around and look at it from that perspective rather than from
1:30:34 We need to fill our calendar with events perspective. There are other ways to do that. And I do understand. And like I said at the onset, my agenda is really none other than being an event advocate first and foremost. But I think you've been part of these discussions too where we've successfully demonstrated that an event is limited to only receiving 30% at the maximum of their overall budget.
1:31:05 Producers are responsible either personally or through other means of fundraising or ticket sales for the remaining 70% of the event funding. And I think the risk is minimal. The investment is highly leveraged on the town's part. So I would give you some pushback on that, as you would expect. But I just really think it's among the most safest and it's proven to be the most successful investments to the town.
1:31:33 Has ever made. It's been in events. But I do understand. Now if we could find a way for the town to take the success in taxes that they gain and pay them back for the continuing events going forward, then Measure U could go back to providing what it was originally intended to. But we won't get into that discussion here. I'm assuming that your comments, and I think that about first year at one time, I think we handled that, hopefully, to your satisfaction and the committee's satisfaction.
1:32:02 By moving them down to their own little asterisk and saying they will be held to a higher standard, as I think they should be. But I'm assuming your comments are also on D about the guidelines for profit and non-profit, that you're speaking to both now. I could when you would like me to. I think you just did. I think what I just mentioned carries forth equally to the topic of the reduction of funding for for-profit events.
1:32:32 I don't think it should be limited to 10%. It's beyond my understanding of why it would be, and I'd like to hear more about that. Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to thank Mark for his comments. As a private citizen, the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition has actually been meeting regularly since the Spring Award.
1:33:00 I think, Joyce, you really dealt with the issue of us being responsible and having to answer to the whole town. The rationale behind the first year events was a number of areas, not the least of which is any kind of grant application that you can apply for in the state of California and the United States of America with most organizations.
1:33:23 Requires an event, whether it's an event producer or a theater or a town, whatever, three years of documented fiscal responsibility and success before you can even apply for money that is coming from other people. So saying a first year event needs to prepare itself by putting together a budget and proving itself.
1:33:53 And honestly, if a first-year event is going to propose, we're going to bring 10,000 people to town, I would strongly suggest you look very carefully at that proposal. Because I don't disagree that commercial producers can put on an event. Anyone can come into town and put on an event. But event growth is really what you want to aim for. You want to make sure it's viable and that it's successful and has the potential to grow. If you're going to start at the top, there's even greater risk.
1:34:22 So that was one of the reasons that this entire committee looked at first-year events, and that was absolute consensus. One-time events, again, it might be a one-time event that becomes a first-year event that leads into other things, but again, they proved themselves. The rationale behind it, again, was that a first-year event puts through a proposal to say, you know, really sorry, but I tell you what, do the event, keep your records,
1:34:44 Do your surveys. Do everything that a second year event has to apply for. And then when you come in to make your application, the first time you apply but you're a second year event, you have facts and figures to justify what you're proposing. Instead of saying, I'm going to bring 5,000 people to town or 10,000 people to town. Because it may not be that successful the first year. It doesn't mean the event is not successful. And the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition is made up of
1:35:12 For-profits and non-profits and all have been participating in the meetings. We just wanted to make sure that people who applied for funding for Measure U didn't see this as a deep pockets opportunity. You've got a lot of money. We want some of that money. We felt it was important that people be responsible when they make an application and they have a rationale and a business plan and a way to make the event work in a reasonable and acceptable way.
1:35:42 However, speaking to that, when the state and federal government looks at, they don't look at whether you've ever filed an application for money before. They look at whether you have a viable organization. And when I hand money out from up here, I look at that too. It could be an organization that has already been putting on events, that wants to put on a new event in Mammoth as a first-time event, who has proved successfully that they can do it.
1:36:10 So to preclude them because it's a first-time event, which is why the asterisk saying they will be held to a higher standard. Don't disagree with the asterisk at all. That absolutely came up in our discussions. We said if someone came in, for example, San Diego Half Marathon, it's a first-time event in Mammoth. Last year was the first-time event in Mammoth, but it was not a first time that the San Diego Marathon had ever put on an event.
1:36:33 That if they had come and applied for money, even with this restriction, we would have said, okay, we will give them special consideration because we know that the event producers have a track record, the organization has a track record, they are fiscally responsible. So we do not have, the committee doesn't have an issue with putting that in an asterisk. That was all discussed. Thank you. Thank you. Sandy, do you have any questions? Okay. With that, shall we move along through Dee?
1:37:04 What are the funding guidelines? Any other comments from? Yeah, I do. And again, this is where I go back to apologizing for missing the last couple of meetings because in the first couple of meetings, I thought, I left with the understanding that we were creating guidelines and that they would apply equally to both nonprofits and for-profits. And I don't, I completely disagree that there should be.
1:37:31 different guidelines for the two. I think that the whole process is kind of self-filtering because of the requirements of the application and for-profits are going to have a different, sorry, I'm not thinking as clearly as I'd like to. For-profits, bluesapalooza would never apply because we are not at liberty
1:37:57 Due to our fiscal responsibility to our board of directors to disclose our financials to the entire universe, which is what is required of this. I think that there's some self-filtering items here, and I think that to say a non-profit should get more consideration than a for-profit is not responsible to the mission statement, essentially. And I'm sorry I'm not being very clear, but that's – I don't think there should be a difference.
1:38:28 I had issues with this one as well. And I have flip-flopped on this innumerable times in the last week since the Rec Commission meeting. The problem that I'm having is currently all of the for-profit, if we make a distinction between Mammoth Rocks and the Margarita Festival, one is a for-profit and one is a non-profit, neither of them make money. How do we hold that for-profit just because it is...
1:38:58 Put together by a group that happens to own a restaurant and may benefit because they sell more tequila, but people who only drink so much of that stuff, believe me, to hold them different. But then thinking back through the history of me sitting on the Rett Commission, who has had to make a lot of these recommendations even before Measure U, we have had film companies come to us wanting to do a film series here, a Sundance film festival, if you will.
1:39:28 Which is no longer in Sunday. It makes no sense to me. But who wanted large chunks of the taxpayer money so that they would be guaranteed not to have a loss. Well, that's a whole different type of for-profit. So I'm wondering if we don't almost need a tier here for the non-professional for-profit and the professional. Thinking back to those things,
1:39:57 Currently, the for-profits that we have in Mammoth, I personally would not consider any different than the non-profits. The volunteers are the same group of volunteers that always volunteer, and no one's out to make a huge amount of money. They're doing it for their community. They're doing it for their area. They're doing it for the same reasons, and I don't think we should be penalizing them because they happen to do a profit. It just came into my mind in some of those sleepless moments we all have when we go over these things.
1:40:27 That I have dealt with other for-profits that were just using us as that bottomless or that we felt were. Maybe that would get hashed out in the process. I don't know. But the people we currently have as for-profits doing events in town, I don't believe we should consider any different than the non-profits. I think one of the things that will probably be further discussion as we go along and as we see is the whole payback issue, which I did not just see discussed.
1:40:57 In here, because we had one, you know, for-profit who committed to paying back, and there were a couple of others that, you know, were obviously for-profit, and we, I think, at least some of us felt that they should be paying back, and obviously a non-profit, I mean, if they are, you know, trying to fulfill our mission by putting on an event.
1:41:23 You know, at least in my opinion, that was kind of out of the question. But I think as we go through, in other words, with Bluegrass, to see if Bluegrass pays back. In other words, they committed in their application for Dawn Infort. Wasn't there a caveat that if they were, if they made a profit, they were playing? Yeah. I think that's what they said. Yeah. Yeah, I think the commitment was. But it'll be interesting to see because one of our speculations was we know that people can play with their books. I mean, we all know that. And Jim Leap?
1:41:51 Nonprofits don't because they just have to be up front. So, well, I mean. I'm sorry. I think nonprofits are the biggest risk of playing with their books as a for-profit. But, I mean, it's two separate subjects, I guess, is what we're saying. I mean, Bill said he knows how to do books. I know how to do books. I once had a business, too. I mean, let's face it. So, that will come back. And I think that's something that isn't in there. And I don't know if you talked about it.
1:42:21 I think it will come back to us. So those are a few of the things that, and also the issue, there's a bigger, broader subject, I think, that we'll probably kind of work through this whole next year, and that was the one of the pass-through. We had a very obvious pass-through situation, at least was obvious, I think, to most of us. The mountain and the town together first put in their application and wanted $100,000. This was for the Kamikaze Games.
1:42:49 But then the next thing, it was called the Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation, and it was going to be everything that was made was going to be a benefit to that, you know, that foundation. And it's a wonderful project, and it was a wonderful event, and I mean, nobody doubts any of that. But the bigger question that we have to think about, is it appropriate for us to basically donate, if we'd given that $100,000, to a foundation when it's taxpayers' dollars?
1:43:20 So, I mean, those are those big, you know, this is not something that we're going to settle today or whatever, but we've got to keep them in mind because there's some big issues here. And Joyce's point to tax being, you know, taking care of the taxpayer's dollar. That's exactly right. We have to be careful. So are you perhaps suggesting that people will find ways to get around if it says the for-profit? Well, it's something I think that we'll continue to discuss. You know, let's just look at these as our guidelines.
1:43:48 And recognize that we're going to have some big issues around this coming up. Well, the only issue... I guess that's all I'm saying. The only issue, though, Sandy, is we really do need to either approve or not approve the application that goes along with this. And the application is based on the answers to these questions. So it is something we need to deal with today in terms of approving this application. Right. And I'm saying, you know, as long as we're saying guidelines, and I think recognizing all of us that we're going to have some big issues to...
1:44:16 Struggle with. My suggestion is that the guidelines should not distinguish between foreign non-profits. That was discussed extensively in the task force and especially the last couple meetings which I know Joyce had missed. There was a lot of discussion as to whether non-profit.
1:44:46 For-profit should even be funded, period, because it is taxpayer dollars. For-profits have the ability to make money on events. They can market themselves. Maybe the tequila festival didn't make money, but it was a great promotion for Gomez's and other businesses in the village. So there are other ways that an event can perhaps make money, even if it doesn't, bottom line, come out in a positive way.
1:45:14 So, and as Juliana mentioned, there are many sources of funding for events throughout the state and the country that don't even consider for-profit events. Many of the models that we looked at, Telluride, Ventura, the different counties that we looked at that have been offering these kinds of programs for many years, many of them did not even fund for-profit events.
1:45:44 I don't think any of them did. Yeah, I don't think any of them did. And I guess if there was a for-profit event, for-profit organization that wanted to host an event, they could probably obtain a non-profit tax status and handle it that way. So that could be another option. But I think what we need to look at, I think even Commissioner Stelick mentioned this at the commission meeting that there are, in her research as well,
1:46:11 Mostly only non-profits are funded with taxpayer type money. My response to that though is that the mission statement doesn't distinguish and what this town needs and needs to thrive are events and it shouldn't discriminate against for-profit events in order to
1:46:39 Apply just because Ventura and everybody else doesn't fund for profits. I don't see the distinction and I think it's a disservice to the mission statement to distinguish between for and non-profits. One thing that you might need to consider though is that there's limited funding, limited monies that are available for funding and they might even become smaller because I think a lot of people have their eye on Measure U and Measure R monies.
1:47:02 So you might need to be more discriminatory as to the type of funding, and that's why the committee felt strongly that for-profit should be eligible for funding but at a lower percentage. And I think even at the commission meeting it was mentioned that even the 30%, 20%, 10%, maybe that was even too generous, and you guys would have, you know, certainly the flexibility to...
1:47:27 To make those modifications, maybe you don't even want to offer as much as 30% to an event. And I think at some point you need to trust this committee to prioritize and filter that money. So I don't know what that has to do with distinguishing between the two. I think that I hear you and I would disagree that there was complete consensus on the committee that
1:47:55 Four of the five people that were, four people that were there in the last couple of meetings that came up with these guidelines and this information for the application were in unanimous in their support for this. Then I'd have to ask if those four people were all involved with non-profits or not-for-profits. No. John Urdi, you know, an event coordinator. So no.
1:48:22 Actually, it might be an appropriate moment to share with you some documentation that I brought on the original intent of Measure U. It's actually a copy of the campaign committee information and flyers that were sent to voters. It's from the original Measure U campaign committee. It contains questions and answers that were used to provide voters with information about the ballot measure.
1:48:45 Includes the argument in favor and three flyers that were mailed to them. At no time was either economic stimulus. Actually, I'll go to my line two, which is support. Support of special events was never discussed as a benefit to the community when selling residue to the voters. Thank you. So part of the pitch at that time was definitely for the community.
1:49:10 But at no point did it talk about events. And that's something else for this committee to be thinking about when it comes to Measure U funding is right now a huge chunk of money is going to events. And realistically, there are plans, and I'm sure you were part of the HVS presentation. There's discussion about creating some kind of
1:49:40 Venue or venues within the town and how would those be paid for? Those actually match up with the Measure U intent as it was presented to the populace, to the people of Mammoth Lakes who voted on it. It was voted in by a slim margin. It was that additional component related to arts and culture, whether it's profit or non-profit. But that's the way it was actually pitched to the public and it wasn't about
1:50:08 Putting on events. Granted, some events are arts and cultural events. Absolutely, they are. But events was not part of that original plan. So I just wanted to bring that forward. And in terms of, just to reiterate again what Pat said, the discussion about profit versus non-profit, let's even take that out of the equation. Let's call it a commercial enterprise.
1:50:37 Versus a non-profit. Not a 501c3 because what's Kathleen's event? I always forget it. The rip cook-off. No. Okay. She is not incorporated as a 501c3. It is a non-profit event. There's no commercial. There's no profit that comes out of that event. It was originally started as a community event. It benefits the community. There's participation by people within the community in the village.
1:51:06 It's not commercial. It's not being done to raise money, raise profile, to increase anything. And there is a difference between nonprofits and commercial enterprises. Nonprofits, and I know we've gone over this, Joyce, is nonprofits within their own charter have to seek funding from multiple sources. A commercial enterprise is not required to do that. They're not required to do that.
1:51:36 501c3, and I'm not saying you have to, that there's a checklist, but survival of a non-profit organization is a direct result of its members and donors, if they have an activity that draws in ticket sales, and funding from other organizations, whether it's private...
1:52:00 Private funds or some other organization like the Shubert Foundation for Theater, Mono Council for the Arts, funds, arts and culture events. So you can apply for money as a non-profit. If you're a commercial enterprise, you cannot submit a grant request to any of those grant-making organizations because you are a commercial enterprise. It's only a non-profit. Hello. I'll try to be brave. Thank you. My attempt to...
1:52:38 It's surely not to engage in the profit versus non-profit or to differentiate and to say that one's more important than the other. I think everybody in this room will agree they're both very important. They both feel a critically important function to the town in different ways. A compelling argument has been made time and time again with the importance financially, the return on investment to special events.
1:53:07 I didn't come prepared having reviewed the language of the Measure U that was passed on the voters, but I for one was a voter. I voted for Measure U. I voted for Measure U because of the increased possibility of funding for all things arts, performing arts included, special events that I knew locals and visitors would enjoy alike.
1:53:36 As well as the amazing beneficiary of financial return. I think it could be further demonstrated and proven with just reviewing back the last two years, spending 10 minutes looking at the joint Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition's application to this body. It demonstrated quite convincingly of the return on investment on events, and it could further be narrowed down and identified by
1:54:06 The for-profit events on probably most occasions because their budget was larger drew in the majority of attendees resulting in the majority of return on investment to the town. So I just again encourage the language on this piece to be as least restrictive as possible. I know that my involvement
1:54:38 And all my time spent on the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition, we talked about the funding guidelines, and we also had continued discussion on the profit versus non-profit piece, because we knew it was an important thing to distinguish that would continue to be brought up. It was my understanding that talks were going to continue on that moving forward post-event season, but Juliana is just informing that the Events Coalition has been meaning.
1:55:07 So I wish I had been better at communicating with Juliana and vice versa regarding these communications so we could have been more involved and informative at this point. Thank you. You know, I'm willing to accept their guidelines because from my standpoint, probably in this upcoming season, there won't be any commitment that I'd be willing to make it above the 10% rate regardless.
1:55:36 So I don't know that it's worth spending a whole lot of time arguing and fighting over. I do believe that with the current, I can see in the future how that need can change because of commercial event organizers. What we have as for-profits in town are not commercial event organizers. But I'm more than willing to leave that in there at this point. I view this as a living document. If we see a reason to change it, certainly we can change that. That would be my...
1:56:06 Opinion audit. Do we have consensus there? I attended at least three of those task force meetings and sat in the corner and listened to the arguments. And I believe the way it's written as guidelines is reasonable. Again, it can be tailored in the future. Right. But the distinction does not bother me. If I may just ask, Stu, what is the intended timeline for this?
1:56:39 I mean, is it, I remember a number like for the next three years, something like that. We will review it annually. It would be reviewed annually. Yeah, it's an annual process. What we're doing now is very typical. And certainly your next item is the same. So it would be incorporated in your fall cycle. And this would be one of those items you'd come up every year. Okay. If I may too, I mean, just on that last comment, I know Joyce did bring it up.
1:57:08 And I think it was in regarding how do you guide, which is probably the right word, the allocation of funds. And I think this was the effort by the task force to do that. It was probably to put some type of sideboards on the funding allocations that are available. And again, they're guidelines, but I think that was one of the other intents of that body to do. Because looking at the process last year, everything but one event was fully funded.
1:57:40 So, I mean, the task force was very cognisant of that. I mean, how do we make sure that we're funding the right events? And, you know, there's been talk about putting caps on the amount of funding as well, and I don't know if the committee wants to bring that up as well, right? I mean, are we setting aside specific funds for events or for recreation or for mobility? The measure you process said no. The measure you process distinctly said the majority of funds should be spent on capital, with programming being the minority of funding.
1:58:06 We've seen those in some of the spreadsheets and the graphs that the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Steering Committee put together and I think you can kind of see it in the representation that we've put forward today as well. So I think the overarching guideline of the application committee is that those Measure U process recommendations that were adopted by council two years ago really are the ones that guide the preparation of funds and it's certainly what council are following. And that's probably why they're really eager to talk to the committee and commissions.
1:58:36 On October 2nd about the priorities of funding and, you know, where, what's the most strategic way we can invest these funds for the entire community? And I think that's really where they're coming from and it was certainly a question that I think Mayor Wood asked, what's the role of town in funding events? You know, I think that was the one question I think they really wanted to ask. And what is that? And I think we've tried to encapsulate that in these recommendations and guidelines and the forms, but I think it's still up for, you know, a good debate. So, anyway, I'll just leave it at that.
1:59:07 Thank you. So, Bill, would you... We just have consensus. I'll move on to E. We have consensus to leave it as written by the committee at 10% for profits and the tiered for nonprofits. And remembering that this is a guideline. That it's a guideline, right? We can alter that if we choose when we're considering.
1:59:41 All right, and Juliana, thank you for the original intent of Measure U for bringing this all to us. Appreciate that. Point E, what consideration should be applied for profit versus non-profit organizations? I would say that the same criteria apply for profit and non-profit. Staff above normal operating should be considered.
2:00:11 But normal operating staff fees shouldn't. So marketing, banned entertainment expenses, facility lease equipment, supplies, materials, insurance. I have no problem funding those for profits or non-profits. Perhaps the only thing that I would add to that is staffing that is specific to the event should be added into that.
2:00:44 For both profit and non-profit. Well, the problem I have with it, if a non-profit has a director that is already being paid for through their ongoing finance campaign, why would we want to allow that director's hours to be budgeted into this? We're not. We're excluding it. You're only excluding it for for profits. No, sir.
2:01:18 Go back to there. Okay, the first sentence says for profit. For profit organizations should not be excluded from the application process. However, they can only profit around 10% of their budget, and the events operating expenses will be considered for funding. An example of operating expenses include, so when I read that, since the first word is for profit, I was assuming that you were meaning these. It's true, I only went to refining, but I don't think that's a far reach.
2:01:46 This was intended for for-profits, meaning that for-profits shouldn't be adding in their regular staff, and I would certainly agree there. But I would agree for profits and non-profits, so. What all Bill is saying is this criteria should apply to both for-profit and non-profit. Okay, just not the way it's written. The way it's written. It's not the way it's written. It's not the way it's written. For-profit. Yeah, and I believe the intent was for those for the expenses and the operating expenses.
2:02:15 Whether or not it's for profit or non-profit. Okay. Okay. Because it's specifically worded as aimed at for profit. Yeah. I think you just take out only D. And events operating expenses will be considered for funding. Yeah.
2:02:45 It probably just needs one sentence. Only the events operating expenses will be considered for funding, and here's an example. And the rest of that can go away because it's actually part of D. Correct, and agreed. And we're not saying that they may only apply for that. Right. Before, it's presented as a guideline to say it. It also says it's an example of operating expenses. We just wanted to be clear that we're not going to pay salaries.
2:03:12 Right. Yeah. So if someone's on staff, they're not paying their salary and it shouldn't be part of the office. For profits or non-profits. Which says that in section C. It's the same. Right. So I'll just eliminate that whole for-profit part. Yeah. We're just going to say the events operating expenses will be considered for funding. Yeah. That's it. It's a run-on sentence anyway. An example. And the last line that references question three is now C. CCC.
2:03:41 Item C. We see question C. Please cite C. All right. And then moving on to F. Are there other sources for event funding that should be considered? I have no problem with that. No problem? All right. G. What required materials should the applicant provide? Budget, event plan, volunteer schedule, et cetera. A question for you two. One of the things we've talked about specifically was in events.
2:04:20 Producers credibility. And I thought somewhere in there we were putting, we were going to require that they provide some kind of organization, experience of the event. We did talk about, it's actually in the, if you look at the application process, I believe it's in there where we ask about the event producer.
2:04:48 I know we talked about it. Yeah, I know we talked about it quite a bit. I felt like I couldn't, I was reading through the whole thing and I didn't, if I were applying for the first time, I wouldn't get that. Does it? Uh-huh.
2:05:04 Yeah, it asks for the information, but it doesn't really emphasize that we're looking for people who are experienced and skilled at putting on events. We were looking for that credibility factor. We did discuss it, and there had been a suggestion made that there be an event producer to be required, but we felt that that was not appropriate to require someone to add into their budget and then ask for money to then pay for an event producer. Yeah, I remember that discussion. So we do ask about, you know,
2:05:34 What is the background? And I would think that not necessarily in the application process, probably in the review process, those questions could come up if there were some questions as to the credibility. Yeah, it's kind of like, you know, the first time event thing. I think what I, in the meetings I was in, I walked away with, you don't have to hire a professional event producer, but you do have to show you have the skill sets and the talent to pull this off. It can't be just anybody. And the way this reads, it's a little soft. For me, it's soft on
2:06:03 On that requirement. If I were a first-time event applicant, I wouldn't get from this that the expectation was I have to be a credible event producer. I think in most cases, most of the events that we're looking at that have done this already have a track record. So the issue is what is the track record of someone who comes in as a first-time person? And right now we're saying with a first-time person there's a much stricter review process.
2:06:32 So I would think in the review process, we could certainly put a line in. You know, you could have the event producer's resume attached, but the only thing I would suggest is think about how much work you require. Okay, remember in the process of putting together the application, in any application process, whether it's for a grant or fund, whatever it is,
2:06:58 The more challenging the application process, the more people tend to drop out. So we don't want to make it so difficult that people are going to say, oh, screw it, I'm not even going to ask for money, but we want to make it thorough enough so that anyone applying understands that they're being held to a standard. So we can put more stuff in, but I don't know that that more stuff will necessarily benefit. So you could ask for an event's producer's resume. So, okay, so Ken and Floss, if they were doing Jazz next year, would have to put together their resume.
2:07:27 Is it necessarily something that you need? So I think that once the applications come in, if you feel that's necessary, you could make that request. I don't know, Pat, do you think we need to put it in the process? I think whenever I look at a project as an engineer or as anything, the most critical component of, one of the most critical components of the assessing
2:07:57 The success, the potential success of whatever it is I'm looking at, whether it's an event or a project, is who's doing it and how good are they at it. And I think we need to emphasize a little more that we're looking for people who know how to do what they do, whatever it is they're doing. Do you have a bullet to suggest we add to this? What would it say? And I'm thinking maybe page four, item five, submit a proposed event budget and business plan that includes that. Either we can make it in there or...
2:08:26 Or it's about the delivery team is what it's about. Because we definitely talked about it. You know what I mean. But we definitely talked about when someone applies for money, they can just say, oh, I have this really great idea. Yeah, exactly. And it's going to cost me $15,000 from you. Let me look. And there's three of us that are going to put it on. It's not a valid application process. So, yeah, put it in there. Maybe under item five,
2:08:56 Event budget and business plan should include and that there should be background, maybe it's background on the event producer or the producing organization. On contracts in the past for the government, we had always required key personnel experience, something to let us know that there is a basis. Actually, we talked about that and I think that it's... I don't know how to...
2:09:25 Capture it. Highly appropriate. I think you want, probably, if you look under 5, it's got staffing plan and volunteer plan, and then maybe in there you put the event organized management process or something. I've got a suggestion. On item 5, before staffing plan and volunteer plan, you put, you require they include the delivery team, and they have to identify who's in charge.
2:09:54 Who's the project manager? Delivery team. Yeah. Who's the project manager? Put in delivery team and then explain it for all those people. It's pretty straightforward. I mean, it's a one-four. And frankly, the only other thing I would mention to the committee, and this was part of our discussions all along, and you'll notice, and I know we kind of jumped ahead and we're looking at page four and bullet points and so on, but what we also tried to do is
2:10:22 Level the playing field so that everyone who applies submits the same application. So theoretically you could lay out every page one, flip it, look at every page two so that everything was standardized so that no one could be ahead of somebody else by putting lots of beautiful visuals and a printed brochure and everything else in there. So when you're requesting the money. And then also that as much information as possible could be a checkmark or a one-line item
2:10:51 Rather than asking for a lot of narrative, because it's in narrative that people can, you know, start, oh, it's going to be the most fabulous thing, it's going to be in the center. Yeah, I think that's off topic, though. All I'm asking for is I want to know who the delivery team is, and that can be a half a page or a chart. Adding that in is probably a good thing, but one of the things we've always required, Stu, is a point person and what their experience is in the R&U process, have we not?
2:11:20 And that needs to be in this as well. There needs to be one person that follows this application. They make the presentations to us. They answer the questions. They are the responsible party. And if that doesn't exist in the application, it needs to, right on the face, and it can be asked there what the...
2:11:43 Page 3 at the top, Bill, is that it? Page 3 of the application, the second line. Well, I think we need to emphasize, though, that we're looking for, that's a contact for this application process. We're looking for the event manager. Who's going to drive this thing home? Well, I'm asserting that the person who's going to be doing all they're presenting is the, we can change that title there. Yeah.
2:12:16 Yeah, we can elaborate there. And I do think in item five with this budget and business plan that you just put in the delivery team and event manager above the staffing plan, and then that'll get you that person, because it could be a different person than the contact person here. And when I look at organizations and stakeholders involved, if I were responding to this, that would be like every, you know.
2:12:45 Everybody involved. I want that point. That delivery team. Those could be adjunct. So we'll add that at that point. Yeah. Yeah. So I'm just thinking, and there's nothing sacred about this wording. I'm just looking at event manager and delivery team. If anybody has a better way to say it, that's fine with me. And you're saying this is a bullet on five? Yeah, right above the staffing plan. Do they know to show experience, or is that just a list of names? We can.
2:13:17 Output and experience. I've got a couple of things if you wanted to read them to you. Yeah, okay. I've been following along. So there's two parts. So one is to identify the lead contact for the event application and the delivery of the event. And two, this event organises experience, qualifications, and recent events, while also including the event organising committee or delivery committee. I think that's kind of why.
2:13:38 It's great. Yeah, it works. Sounds good. And I think what we're missing here is which comes out in Measure R as well, and you've seen before, it's just that one-page information packet, and it's a pretty standard thing that we kind of include, and I think that's where Bill's reference in regards to the same applicant has to be part of the process. Perfect. Thank you, Stu. Thank you. The only other comment I had on G was the, unless you're at a $75,000 above level, IRS no longer requires a $99,000.
2:14:07 Are we just going to accept the postcard? I think it was an IRS 990 or copy of the IRS 501C3 letter. I think it's kind of what should be the recommendation. Well, they're two completely different things. IRS 990 has to do with your financials, which we already asked for all over the place anyway. So I'm not sure that that's necessary. A copy of the IRS 501C3 letter, that's easy.
2:14:41 Whether you're in force or not. I think the idea was to level the playing field so that you don't have, if you're not a 501 C3, that there was some other documentation. Yeah, to identify what the structure of the organization is, the IRS structure of the organization, whether it's a, yeah. Okay. Do I have no problem with it? I just, it'll be asked for the profit and loss at the next bullet.
2:15:15 Previous year's performance report, I'm assuming you're referring specifically to the event and not the organization. Not the event, the organization. The organization. Okay, I don't know that I've ever written a performance report. Can I go back those to financial stability and for the current moment? Okay. I need a little explanation because I wouldn't have been able to figure out what that was about. No.
2:16:07 I guess I'll have to start writing performance reports for my 501c3. If you want to submit. Yes. I've just been involved with several, so I'm just trying to think about that level. Okay, are we moving on to H then? Great. Yes. What metrics for event performance should be considered? Any comments, questions? You can see the underlined there, second homeowners we added.
2:16:52 From the rec commission side. So is this, you're going to have a report on locals and you're going to have a report on combined out of town and second homeowners or do you want locals out of town, a separate one for separate homeowners? In terms of marketing and stuff like that, I think it needs to be broken out into all three. I think so too. Yeah. And maybe so the plus becomes a versus. Right. Okay.
2:17:20 I think there's insight there. I think it's useful. Yeah, it was interesting to me that some of the events this year, while the town was very, very, very busy, occupancy in the condos and motels and stuff that I worked for wasn't high. So I have to make the assumption that that was primarily a second.
2:17:49 Homeowner driving event. It's nice to know those sorts of things. What is driving, what types of visitation. It's not TOT, but they are in town. Right. Moving on to I, what is the accountability of the funding applicant review process criteria? Currently it's a 60 days performance report. We've got 90 days in here, so it just depends on whether we want to stick with 60 or go with 90 days.
2:18:28 It's either 90 days or prior to the next event funding cycle. Yeah, and that should say the next event. We talked about that. The next event. Next event funding cycle, right. Stu, have you felt that people have been able to meet the 60 days? Do you think that that works, or would you recommend changing it to 90? It's up to the committee. I mean, you know, we don't want to... I think after the event, everybody just collapses and comes back later. So I thought 90 days is sufficient. But again, it's...
2:19:02 I'd be consistent with 90. You can go with 60. I've got no concern either way. To me, the important thing is that we get it well in advance of the next funding cycle so we can make decisions based on how that was done. So I have no problem with 90 days. And would this be a place where we could add something about the trash or cleanup?
2:19:29 Yeah, I think that's that last bullet. I think we could maybe just emphasize that a little bit. That's, you know, good stewards, ambassadors of the town. I wouldn't mind seeing it spelled out. She has a good point. If they're going to see this, a separate bullet saying trash management plan, just as easy as that. Or clean up. Clean up, yeah. More than trash. Trash ends. Trash ends. The combs, the banners, the... I brought this up at the commission meeting as well.
2:19:56 Complete a minimum of 50 with 100 in parentheses event surveys. You know, if an event claims to have 3,000 people there, I want to see 300 or at least 150 surveys. I don't want to let them off the hook. One of the problems I've had with events in the past is the number of people they report at the event and when myself or other people that I know that are even better at me of estimating crowd size.
2:20:25 Tells me the size, the reported size of the event and the... Completely different. Yeah, so usually you can get at least 4% of your people to respond, so I would want a minimum of 50 or 4% or 3% of your estimated attendance. I don't want to let someone off the hook thinking they only have to put out 50 surveys. I would like to see a...
2:20:55 A greater canvassing for the bigger events. Okay, so pretend I'm John Urdi. Okay. Because we had this discussion. What he's looking for, first of all, the number of surveys is not indicative of the number of people. I suggested 10%, but what John said is 100 surveys is a viable sampling from which to be able to draw the kind of information we need.
2:21:21 For tourism to look at the event. If you're trying to figure out how many people actually came to the event, that is not going to be accomplished with surveys. No, no, I understand that. But if you have a ticketed event, that's different, so it's a little bit easier to manage. The non-ticket events are challenging, and that's actually a challenge, I think, for anyone that's doing any of this funding, to determine how many people actually showed up. Because anybody can say anything. So I think...
2:21:50 One of the things we did talk about was having someone from Measure U attending all the events, not just sort of the same person, but so that at least
2:22:02 When you look at the event, so if you go to Fiesta Caliente and there's 500 people and then you get a report, I don't mean to pick on that one, just anything, even the food and wine event and you came in the afternoon and you say, well, there were only 100 people there, we'd say, well, there were 100 people at that event but it was an all day and there were different levels to it. But if we said there were 2,000 people on Friday at the afternoon event and you're there and you're going, I don't think so.
2:22:28 So that may be one way to manage it. But the numbers, it's challenging to determine how many people actually came. And I don't know how to get around that. But as far as surveys, I would suggest we make it 100. And then if it's a relatively small event, and the event producer said, look, I did everything I could. I had people walking around, and they wouldn't fill it in. I've got 54. Then, OK, maybe.
2:22:56 But in terms of sampling, 100 is a pretty standard sample, and that's what John was supporting, was 100 surveys. Yeah, and I understand the sampling size being, I just would like to encourage them to do at least 3 or 4 percent of their attendees. I don't know that we can set this in stone anyway, because some people have the capacity to have staff or volunteers go out and hand out the surveys. Personally, my preference is
2:23:25 for volunteers to go out and conduct the surveys because then we get a much more accurate sample. Actually, if you look two bullet points up from that last one, we're asking for, we suggested asking for a plan for administering the required event surveys. We talked about that, about different ways to do it. It may be possible eventually to have this on, maybe on iPads so that people, you know, with a QR code where they could just scan it and go into it and hopefully
2:23:53 We can get more sophisticated in how we manage that and get more information, but if we're doing paper surveys right now, that it's a little hard. But we do want people to have a plan. They have to have a plan. They can't just say, I'm going to leave them on a table, because that won't work. So if somebody were to, our suggestion from the committee is if somebody says, well, I'm just going to send them over on the table, say, well, that's not good enough. You have to have a proactive plan for gathering it. So that's why we did include that as one of the bullet points from the committee. Thank you. Shall we?
2:24:24 Change that to 100 without surveys? Well, if it's an event that only has 100 people, it's tough to do. So I see the need for the minimum, which is why I like a percentage more. Each event should strive to complete at least 4% surveys from at least 4% of attendees.
2:24:50 So if it read complete a minimum of 50 surveys, strive for 4% of attendance. Strive for 4% of attendance. I would like that, yeah. If you had 15,000 people, that would be 600 surveys. Yep. Okay. For an event that size. And I know John really liked the number 100. Is there a way we could word it complete a minimum of 100 event surveys for events over? I'm going to be sitting up.
2:25:24 One thousand? The preference would be up to four percent. I mean, you can expand what you hope for, but say if you don't turn into the surveys, then you haven't met the requirement. But the strive for doesn't satisfy that, Julianna? No. Event producers will wiggle and try to do the bare minimum required. And the experience that I've had with events, understanding the incredible importance of the information the surveys develop with Mammoth Rocks and, again, with Margarita Festival, we've...
2:25:54 Exceeded the expectation set forth by Measure U, but it should be a pretty firm number. Either way, if you give them 4%, they're going to fudge probably. You know why I like the 4%? Because when we ask them how many people attended, and we ask them if they got their 4%, at least they have to be able to think math-wise fast enough to justify it too. This gives us, from my standpoint,
2:26:22 It keeps them from fudging the numbers as much as they might fudge otherwise. So this is sort of a double check for me, which is why I would like to see we need a minimum of 50, you should strive for 4% of attendance. I realize that 4% is shooting high, and we're probably not going to get it. But for me, it serves a double purpose. I like it. I think it works.
2:26:58 That's only 60. That's a baseline. Yeah. But that's only 60. Yeah, but for statistical accuracy, if we're going to deal with statistics and all of those things, 60 is as statistically accurate for 1,500 as 100 would be for 15,000, if not even more so. Because your plus and minus, I mean, if we're going to deal with accurate tables. Yeah.
2:27:25 I have no problem putting 100 down there. If we add strive for 4% and there's only 500 people there, at least we've allowed them to come down from 100. And again, it keeps them from inflating other numbers, I think. I'd support that. All right, shall we remove the 50 and the parentheses around the 100 and then add strive for 4%? I like it.
2:27:54 So the complete 100 surveys for a goal of acquiring 4% of attendees? Yeah. Great. And then Stu, and we added the bullet point at the bottom for trash and cleanup management plan. Yeah, I kind of had abide by the wildlife management checklist and submittal of trash management plan, which actually should be in the operations plan, so I'm kind of including that in the operations plan. I did want to comment on bullet 3.
2:28:21 This is something that the committee felt pretty strongly about. There were a number of events this year that received event town funding, but there was no kind of logo recognition whatsoever in a lot of that material. So I think it's critical that we not only require that, but also we review any type of material that's going to be printed or distributed that has a town logo on it, because again, the town logo is very specific to what colour and size and whatnot. We saw a number of different logos.
2:28:51 And then we're actually looking at designing a logo specifically for Measure U. So it would be the town logo and kind of powered by or supported by Measure U. And that would actually be on. And then we could also look, if you wish, to look at making some banners and actually have those available for those event producers to put up at those events, right, so we can have, you know, four banners that recognises the town's involvement and the funding. Great ideas, too. Yeah. I think that would be advantageous as well.
2:29:19 I just, Ashley, I think that's great. My issue is with radio advertising because radio time is based on time that you purchase, and each block of time costs you money, so I would say radio advertising where possible, but sometimes adding that on will take you over a 30-second mark, and then the message doesn't get out about the event.
2:29:43 So I don't have any problem at all with print and even social media because a branding logo somehow can be added to that, but the radio advertising, that's the kind of time is money issue. The other is printing and it's easy. Yeah, I don't mind leaving it in there and just having to explain it to us. I just... Yeah, I agree. I think we should go for as much as we can and... Starting for it. Yeah. All right. They talk faster. Yeah. Then let's move on to...
2:30:16 Item J, what should be the role of town in funding and support of special events? Any comments, questions? No, I didn't even have any notes on this one in my original go-around with this. I think, Chair, this is an item that, you know, staff is going to be coming back to committee and commissions with at a later time. Okay. Because, you know, we have compiled a lot of information this year on the hours that the staff is committed to and funding costs and those type of things. And I think it is part of that larger discussion that we kind of previously talked about.
2:31:14 How we can better manage and improve the event experience for locals and visitors. So I think that's probably a larger discussion that we can probably tackle at a later time. On this, before Sandy left, she left me a note or two, and she said she strongly supports the bullet that talks about the seasonal special event coordinator. I would support that too. However, I differ from that. Okay. I don't believe, and I said this at the commission,
2:31:44 These events, without any dissension, produce an increase in TOT for the town. I have a problem paying for a special event coordinator to oversee the successful events that are bringing money into the tax coffers from Measure U. So if they have become successful to the point that they're doing what we've asked them to do, and evidently they are, then that position becomes needed because of the success.
2:32:14 Let's not take money away that we could give out to add more success to manage the extra tax dollars that are already coming into the coffers from those successful events. I don't know if I spoke that correctly or not. I think you did. Thank you. I can understand. General fund. Yeah, absolutely. Yes. Yeah. The general fund is becoming greatly enhanced because of the events that Measure U was never intended to fund but has funded.
2:32:44 So the general fund should step up to that task. And as a committee, it behooves us to make that case to the town council. Stu's not the one that can go and fight for these funds. The five of us that sit at this table are the ones that can go and fight for those funds. I would recommend when you see council outside of these chambers that you remind them how successful the events were and how much extra money is coming in and that we need some of that extra money to come back and help support the events.
2:33:15 Personally, I agree with you, and I think that as the committee here and the commission, we should all be fighting for something along those lines. And I think it just kind of reinforces what Steve was saying earlier, that a person of that nature could be the one to go to each and every event and make sure that the cleanup is conducted properly and that they're aware of all the guidelines that need to be followed. So, yeah, I support that. Thank you. Maybe even it's an early position.
2:33:47 And who knows where MLR is going to go. Right. And it looks like we are ready to review attachment B for the draft event application. Yeah. Any suggestions on how to review this? Same thing. I would just go through it point by point. Okay.
2:34:22 This should go a little quicker because we've dealt with most of these things already. So this is basically the wording that would be in the application as opposed to the guidelines. Perhaps we made comments back on the first part of this measure. Perhaps we just incorporate those comments here. For example, funding eligibility we made.
2:34:45 Comments about moving first year events and one time events down and reformatting that. Have we already covered most of this? So would it make sense? We have already covered most of this. Yes. Yes. Would it, Stu, would it make sense then to have you incorporate some of the feedback you've been given and we could review it at our next meeting? Yep. All right. Thank you. I think it's. Yeah, the only other thing too, just chair on part two, question two.
2:35:11 There was a recommendation there for the commission. Oh, we're on to the application itself now. Yeah, it was please identify the event goals and then tell us how you would find success for this event. It was a recommendation that the commission made. And I think this is where Joyce was talking about the principal organization stakeholders in the event. Delivery team experience or event manager. Yeah, I think that's kind of where all that's kind of identified there.
2:35:41 Yeah, wouldn't we add that with the organization's mission statement? What's the mission statement? What's the experience or events? Which is actually, yeah, I included that in question five, which was a bullet there, so that was kind of where I added that information. And on page three, there was some discussion about other special events on the funding categories. Perhaps recreational event became something like recreational event or other special event.
2:36:11 Yeah, I had special event print, as you said. Okay. You're on part five. I'm on page three of the application. Okay. And that was really it. So it's a pretty small application form. Yeah, and again, he told you the only change that the rec commission made was to add and tell us how you would define success for this. Yeah. Okay. That is on part two, question two. And again, I felt that that was another way.
2:36:41 If they define what success is for them before the event. I like that. Yeah. It's a good one. It makes it easier for us to judge the event through more than just our eyes. What their thoughts are. Yeah. Yes. Stu, remind me, is this application for events in replacing the other application or supplementing? Okay. I just want to be clear. But only for events. But only for events, yeah.
2:37:06 Okay, I have a question if you don't mind on page 4, number 1, I guess why you're telling you that you're not making priorities, check all the apartment site examples. How many more examples are you? Do you want attachments? Do you want narrative? Do you want listing?
2:37:26 I think that was just going to be an open text field. I think that came from the Commission as well. Yeah, looks like that. So not only do you have to check the box, but you have to explain why your event aligns with economic stimulus slash sustainability. So it just could be narrative in regards to...
2:37:54 You cannot exceed another space. All of the application forms that we worked at in the process of going through this task force, all of them have limitations as to how much you could attach, how much you could include, how much verbiage. The point is, I think that for all of the applicants, we want to be as fair as possible and try to even the playing field as much as possible. So you might want to think about how you want them to set examples and perhaps put a limitation into how it is.
2:38:24 So it's not a creative writing exercise? It's not a creative writing exercise. It means, you know, if you have to say in 25, 50 or 50 words or less an example, it's amazing how concise you can be. But if you're given, you know, as much as you want to write, you can, you know, praise God, whatever. And along that line, will this be, will people be able to submit this in writing or only online?
2:38:51 Has that been decided yet? Yeah, I've been looking at a lot of different formats, and at the end of the day, the common denominator that everybody can use is a Word document. Everybody seems to use it. When you sometimes create a web-based PDF, put it online, you're still going to have issues. The time out, the boxes, I mean, you know, I just did one on the weekend and had to do it three times. So it gets very frustrating. So at the end of the day, I think a web-based PDF is great, but I think just an open...
2:39:18 Word document that could help. This one here is more checkbox scenario, so we just have to look at the best way to kind of put this together and maybe you can supply both, you know, both formats. But to try to make it as easy for everybody, right, that applies for it because we have different degrees of, you know, technological grasp. Be polite. Yeah. I appreciate that. Yeah. Opening it to as many possible as people as possible.
2:39:49 I don't think we want to have people do it on their smartphone, let's just say that, so I think it has to be something that's completed. I think we do need to speak to brevity in the answers of that number one, though, or we will get that creative writing where they tell us about how wonderful the event is and I don't want to hear it. But we do need them to cite examples. They need to know we're within their own application. Maybe we can just put, because all of this is in the application.
2:40:19 Cite where this answer is in the application. If they've done their budget right and everything else, most of this is answered someplace within the application.
2:40:54 You know, you could be writing the paragraph, or you could say it's page 4 of Proposition 7, line 3. Well, because these are our priorities that we set as a committee and changing. Current plans and studies, I would expect them to say this is in the Rec Master Plan, page 5, paragraph 2, and cite the example.
2:41:21 However, for leverage, I would expect them to say, you know, you're only giving us 10%, we're coming up with the rest ourselves. It doesn't have to be huge. The only one that I could see them going on about is economic stimulus and sustainability. I don't want them to give me four paragraphs on how much each person is going to spend. Just the fact that they believe it will drive TOT and I think probably this can be handled.
2:41:49 Every applicant has to meet with Stu or whoever that becomes before they fill the application so that they understand how to answer these. And if Stu is clear that all we want is a one-sentence answer for each one of these and it should be doable, then that solves the issue. So maybe it's just in the direction, Stu. Does that work for you? We don't know if it worked for Stu or not. I know he's writing. Yeah, no, it's fine. It doesn't need to be...
2:42:29 Too detailed. We can limit the text box. We can, you know, do a lot of those things. We can say 50 words or less. But I think it's important because I have seen those responses and there have been a couple of pages. Yeah. So if you will explain to them that they are limited when you meet with them, that's what I was getting at. Yeah. And I just don't need to repeat the verbiage that's already in the document. So I think that's important. Reference a paragraph is fine. Yeah. Yeah. Yep. That's fine. Looking onto page two for funding eligibility.
2:43:03 I just have a problem with it saying Measure U will not fund the following. I know we talked about moving first-year events, one-time events down, but we talked about these being guidelines. So how can we measure U's guidelines is to fund the following? You know, and help me out here, but we did go through this in great detail on the task force because
2:43:30 We looked at several different applications, and that really popped out on one of them as a really solid way to be clear what public money shouldn't fund. And so we did go, you know, spend a lot of time talking about it, and I think it's important to say out loud public money is not going to fund, you know, lobbying efforts or events that are not open to the general public. So I'm happy with it the way it is.
2:43:58 Well, remember, we've already changed that. The first two bullet items are going to appear separate. So it'll appear separate and it'll be down below? Yeah. Yeah, so the only thing that I would have questioned, do you see anything else on? And events hosted outside the town of Mammoth Lakes urban limit will be replaced with whatever it was we said there. Right. So I think we've taken care of all of that. Unless you see anything else there that doesn't
2:44:27 That you think might have an exception at some point in time. Andrea, just to also answer your question, by saying what you won't fund, it's easier to say what you won't fund than what you will fund because there might be something you don't put on the list of what you will fund that you actually would fund and then you go, oh my God, I didn't think of that and something didn't apply for it. But if we're specific as to those items that will not be used, then people know up front, I'm wrong, and I guess I can't build that stage. All right. Thank you for explaining that.
2:44:56 And capital improvements, which could be funded with you, they list it for your specific event. Because if the event coalition got together and said, hey, we want you to fund a stage, that certainly is something that... Worth considering. Yes. But we wouldn't do... That's right. If it only would fulfill the needs of one event, we would not go there. It's basically us.
2:45:22 Adding a capital asset to that particular organization. And we're trying to avoid that. It's going to be a town asset. Yeah. Thank you. Any other comments on the application from the public or committee members? No? Any comment? Thank you. Thanks, Mark. I thank you very much for taking your time on this process.
2:45:52 I've been exposed to the committees and things I know. It's thankless at times. But I think there's a lot of people, event people, that will definitely appreciate all the work that's gone into this by the task force and this group here. My final remark would be just to really ask you to continue the discussion on anything restricting or limiting events from having the door open for them.
2:46:25 This group has done an amazing job by putting together this incredible refined application process. There's an interview process, there's an application process, there's a screening process, there's project filters, there's a number, there's layers and layers and layers of things that an applicant has to get right to get money. Don't restrict or limit a for-profit event from 30% to 10% just because
2:46:55 That's a for-profit event. I'm still unclear on where this, who's driving it or why. Why? Why are these events being asked to reduce their guidelines? The risk, I don't, is there any events that have occurred that are glaringly apparent that have lost the town money? I don't think so. I think that history will show that
2:47:23 These events, all events, for profit and non-profit have done amazingly well. And I just, I'm glad that it's a guideline and that the conversation is continuing on that piece because I know a couple are in favor of not separating the guidelines between profit and non-profit. It can be continued, but yeah, I worry about...
2:47:52 I really worry about the unintended consequences of this precaution that is being taken, this perceived risk and this protection of the taxpayer. I think the taxpayers should be thrilled with the benefits financially that the events bring. So I, again, just thank you for the process. Thank you. Thank you. All right. If we are...
2:48:22 Done then with the session item three, let's move along to four to approve the 2013 Measure U fall award process timeline and priorities of funding, review the proposed town funding applications and direct staff to make any necessary changes to the application evaluation material. So what we're looking at here from the committee today, Chair, is to approve the fall award timeline and the priorities of funding, which is important to do prior to the October 2nd workshop.
2:48:52 The application material and evaluation material, we do have a little bit of time on that, so we can kind of certainly review that and come back with recommendations for a later time, or you do wish to go through it. A couple of the changes that staff did make, which I think kind of, as we talked about before, is kind of better aligns the process with the Measure R Fall Award process. The Recreation Commission
2:49:20 Approved their funding timeline at their last meeting on September 10th. Their application period closes, I believe, November 15th, and we moved ours up to close December 2nd, so it opens November 11th, we close December 2nd, which would allow for that joint commission committee meeting to review those applications, which I think is important to probably best understand what applications should go where.
2:49:48 And which process. So there's no, you know, perceived double dipping, and everybody's getting set in the right process before the meetings occur. And then the timelines are now pretty close. I mean, they're running not concurrently, which is very difficult to do, just because we just can't staff at all. But as you can see, Measure R, you know, runs through and is awarded January 15th, and then Measure U is awarded February 5th. So they're right with each other, I think.
2:50:17 I think the timelines sync up pretty well now. And that's one of the recommendations that Council and I previously have kind of directed us to look into. So we have those two timelines to look at. So if that's something that the committee is comfortable with, we can go ahead and approve that. And then secondly, the other one was, I think, well, I know we've affirmed those funding priorities at our last meeting. This is your additional time to look at those again if you have any other comments, or we're happy to move those.
2:50:46 Forward, then that's fine. Just so we know when we meet with the council, we're all in agreement on those priorities. What we've also added here, as you can see on page two of the staff report, the town proposed maintenance and applications. You can see the maintenance cost is the ongoing cost for the Whitmore Track and Sports Field. That's the match with Measure R. That's the third match. That's the one-third, two-third match.
2:51:18 The 4% administration of cost is the $32,000. And then the proposed application is the special event trolley funding. I thought we did that on a multi-year basis. We did. It's been two years already, so this would be for the next two years. Special event support, that one in there is kind of a placeholder right now pending our future discussions on the role of town.
2:51:44 What that could be, it could be the banners, that could be the design logo, that could be some tablets for the surveys, you know, it could be those items that the committee feels warranted to better manage that program. The roller ink operations and enhancement is kind of a match with Measure R, so whatever the town finalizes that funding, it would be split 50-50 like we've done in the past, and that would be again for a two-year operation.
2:52:10 And then these two items, D and E, the items brought forward by the Community Development Department on Municipal Wayfinding and the Main Street Engineering Design Plan. Municipal Wayfinding is an extension of the plan that we've committed to right now, which is really the placement of the signs throughout town. And the $200,000 is the engineering design work for the Main Street Redevelopment Project.
2:52:37 Attachment C, I believe, is what we've included those descriptions. Do we include those in this or not? So, we've not seen these applications before? No, this is the process that we do each year. I'm being confused. Attachment C, yeah, we come forward, the town presents their proposed application before it does go to council, because before we submit applications, before we submit time,
2:53:06 We bring it forward to the application committee just to give us some direction. That's what you want to see in an application. So that's the opportunity here for the committee to review these. Prior to this, the staff was always just brought forward.
2:53:25 Perhaps sometimes even paying very close attention to what our commission committee, what we were asking for. My hope is that in the future staff will come and meet with us on these things and we will know them well before we're asked to consider whether or not they should come forward. This needs to be committee driven to a certain extent, far more than it is today. I certainly don't know, while I've been dealing with the municipal wayfinding program now for, what, five years?
2:53:53 I don't know what is included in that $334,000 or if I would even support them all. We got tied up in that and some of the wayfinding signs that we opted to only pay for a part of at the rec commission level with Measure R. I have a question, comment or two on timeline. I see that on October 15th that the staff's going to present the town funding applications. I think that's being done to...
2:54:24 Right now, if I'm not mistaken. It's both. So we actually have a presentation scheduled for the 15th, and this is just kind of our pre-filter scenario. So this is your first review of them. We're compiling all that information, and then staff would come back on October 15th, because I'm looking at the same timeline here, too. Okay, on the December 2nd, if the Measure U applications close then, you have time...
2:54:49 To get those applications to us, or to everyone, for us to review before a December 3rd meeting? You'll just have them that day is what we'll do, right? Yeah. It's the tightest we could do, Don. I don't know how you want them. You have time to get them out then? Yeah. All he has to do, all he has to do is, once they have them electronically in the computer, is just push the button for how many of them they want them to print.
2:55:15 Okay. He didn't say he was going to come forward with a synopsis of each. Just that he was going to present those to us for our purview to make a decision as to if we thought some of them belonged in R or some of the R belonged in U. It's not a pretty timeline, but it's, you know, it's something that we're just living with. So you're right, so on October 15th is kind of when we, Jessica will actually come forward and kind of make that presentation. She's got some boards and so forth.
2:55:44 I mean, we can, if you wish, we can look at a meeting directly with staff and a couple of committee members prior to that, if you wish, chair and committee members, if that's something you want to look at, we can take a couple of volunteers, we can come forward, schedule some time, run through those applications with you just to get more detail and then come forward and present to the whole group on the 15th. I don't see any need to waste the time. So it's up to you. Yeah, maybe after that. Yep.
2:56:12 You know, and on those couple of projects, if this is the appropriate time to talk about it, the wayfinding and the main street engineering, the numbers are getting pretty big. And those get to be slippery slopes. Oh, well, you funded the first phase, so you better, we're looking at Measure U to fund the next phase. And then we're getting away from our priority of looking at major capital projects. And so...
2:56:40 Staff can put those applications together, but I'm going to be ridiculously skeptical about them. Well, I do have some notes from Sandy on this, and I kind of, they were following my thoughts too, particularly on number four. Her note says, need better breakdown. At some point, knowing what the overall in town, I understand rec commission is doing things out on trails, so this is in town, what the total need is.
2:57:08 How much we've done, how much further we have to go, and when will we get there on that one? On the Main Street 30% engineering design plan, I assume this is probably coming out of that contract we have with Winter and Company and the meetings. We have stuff all over the walls in here that we've attended to help us think through Main Street.
2:57:32 And we don't even have that final report yet, but we're ready to spend $200,000 and do a design, start a design. I'm trying to understand the time phasing on this. I know we have, but the town has a plan going on, and that Ms. Morris is, we've attended meetings, and that's what's posted on the wall.
2:57:52 And we think we're ready to start a 30% engineering design plan on something. Well, I don't even know that they have buy-in from all the main street businesses. Well, I understand. And I'm really struggling with number five for that reason. Yeah, and compare it to the Measure U funding priorities. I mean, that's... Yes. It doesn't have to be a strong, a huge case. If I might mean to interrupt, but I don't understand how mainstream engineering design fits in with...
2:58:19 Yes. And so community development can propose. It seems to me like it's supplanted. I mean, it should be a town expense. I don't understand how it fits in with. And frankly, if you take all these in total amount, there's $182,000 left for Measure U for anything that Measure U feels is appropriate. And it's not just events. There are other organizations that will be making requests of the Measure U money.
2:58:49 And if we're going to be looking at potentially a capital investment in something solid that can be used, and it has been addressed, I think, at both our and your meetings, there's no money left. So I would just make a plea for thinking about what the intent is of Measure U. There's no secret that the town council is meeting in closed session to consider the buying of the parcels where the wood sites are.
2:59:17 And meeting with the owners of those sites, which is capital, which is what our prioritization is. And until we know how that's going and what council's direction is going to be towards us on that, I think that while I think both municipal wayfinding and Main Street incidentally fall under mobility, one thing our town lacks is the ability to get around it. Once you're in town, if you've ever driven to another resort that is as poorly signed as Mammoth is as a tourist.
2:59:47 Trying to even find your condominiums is an impossibility. And Mammoth fits into that category. There's no way to do that. So the municipal wayfinding I understand, but I don't know that what they're suggesting would give us that. So at this point I probably would be in favor of not moving those two forward. I would agree. I'm with you.
3:00:10 Well, at this time, we don't need to make that determination. I think what we're trying to do is have staff back here, which is that October 15th, to present, and they have some material they can kind of get to you in advance. I think it'd be helpful. As I said, staff is no obligation to saying that, you know, we expect those to be fully funded. I mean, you know, if staff met all the departments, these are the applications that brought forward. We're just seeking some comments. However, Stu, one of the Council's reasons for asking us to do this each year is to keep staff from putting...
3:00:38 Too much time into projects that aren't going to move forward, that have no chance of moving forward. And I'm not saying these don't have any chance. Maybe they've got a song and dance that will convince me. I've never seen Peter dance. I don't know. It's actually Jessica says she might. But anyway, she has that material available to you. All I'd probably say is at least receive the presentation on October 15th and make that determination. We're just trying to get it to you so you can obviously ask these questions. Right.
3:01:06 So basically this is what they propose to apply for just as anyone else could apply for Measure U funds. It's a heads up if you will. I will tell you for me personally, I've dealt with this probably longer than any of the rest of you because of Measure R and being on the Rec Commission. One of the things I struggled with initially and I think I got wrong is how the commission should go about asking for projects to come forward.
3:01:36 If, and in the beginning, I felt that if we asked for certain projects to come forward, that we were prejudicing the process, saying that this, these are, that's exactly right. However, by not doing that, we have not got the projects coming forward from town that we wanted to come forward. Catch-22. So it becomes a real sticky widget. And I'm of the belief now, after going through this for, I don't know how many times it are,
3:02:06 That the commission, and I hope that we go down that road, gets far more succinct in our priority setting as to name specific projects that we want to have come forward. Or flat out say we want an application for this. I'm not saying we will fund it because something more important may come up. So just for sake of thought today, think about that because I really think that we got it wrong in the beginning on Measure R.
3:02:36 As far as how we dealt with that. And we've gone through spinning our wheels and perhaps funding things that we otherwise wouldn't have funded had the project we were looking for actually come forward. So I just wanted to put that in your bonnets to give you something to think about. The only thing that concerns me as a private citizen but with a horse in the race, I think that's the way the phrase goes, is there's actually a workshop.
3:03:07 With the Town Council on October 2nd. And if these priorities are still existent in this document, then isn't that some tacit approval that you haven't questioned them? And then if that goes forward, then it doesn't mean that you have to approve them, but basically on October 2nd you're going to be talking about funding priorities and how you're going to be spending your money. Well, I imagine in the agenda packet that goes to Council is usually a call-out of
3:03:38 What consensus was here? So I'm sure in there, there will be mention made that tentatively we thought those shouldn't come forward. We were willing to listen to more about them. And Stu generally does a good job of that. And if it doesn't happen, it would behoove us as committee members to tell council that. And I don't think any of us are, you know, retreating into our... Yeah. So I think that that will happen regardless.
3:04:07 The other option that the committee has is to actually spell them out more specifically in your priorities of funding. Right. You can actually state, you know, what you will fund and, you know, what you won't fund. I mean, you can start to do that. I mean, certainly it's guided by the process and the recommendations. Well, yeah, because by omission, and I find this, I mean, this goes to point. We've said we want capital projects. Town Council is already working on what it's going to cost us to buy those parcels of land.
3:04:38 But you don't see any suggestion in here of an application come forward to do that. Yes. And I certainly would be in favor of that, of at least seeing what that application would look like. So should we be... Well, that's the question. We've never done that in the past. Let's do it. That's the whole question. I think that we do need that potential application. Yeah. We were reticent about putting in there because then it would be, you know, the staff then leading committee, and now the committee's understanding about leading staff. Right.
3:05:05 Which gets us back to where we are. You've never heard me specifically say, I do believe that a line needs to be held in here for potential purchase of venue. We don't need to spell out what, where, or how. But I certainly would like to see what that might look like coming forward. And I think the timeline kind of works with the committee as well. Like you said, you've got the October workshop. That's something you can discuss. We bring it back again on October 16th.
3:05:31 We actually had it on our tentative list of applications, but then we thought, well, is that not something that's appropriate? But, you know, we are certainly here seeking
3:05:39 Committee's public opinion. You were willing to put in the Main Street project, so why not put this one in? I mean, I would be in favor of asking staff to add it. There's really been no public discussion on Sam's Woodside in regards to council. But I like the way you said it, though, of just putting a line item on purchasing value. Perhaps it's a larger issue than that because we're paying HVS to do a study for us, and we probably don't really agree with some of the things they recommended.
3:06:09 But it's a thought process, I think, that's good. And at the same time, there might be a line out of Evan or someone to do something, but we need to get our arms around all of that and figure out how they play together and benefit the community. Yeah, so putting a line item in is continuing that conversation. And maybe it concludes something from Evan or whatever it is. We may just want to take $250,000 and chunk it to that regardless. Something.
3:06:37 Without the application, we cannot do that. We need something to reference. The application needs to come forward. Yep. I like that. I think the recommendations need to come forward first, which I think is October 15th. So at that point, you know, I would like this on there for the 15th. We're asking for a placeholder. Yeah. We're asking for that placeholder. I would like this to show there as well so the council knows we've thought about it. Yeah.
3:07:00 So it's actually the purchase of property and the capital improvements to the facilities. Well, that's fine. Yeah. Would I maybe suggest not purchase of property but just say some capital, a capital fund for some venue because it depends on which one it is, you may not have to buy it, okay? So that's the way for purchasing. You need to make the specific enough to that. Yeah, there you go. Maybe there's a lease to buy on the wood side. Who knows what's going to come out of it? Right, right.
3:07:29 Got that, Stu? Does that make sense? Well, and frankly, at some point, we know that site's being considered. Absolutely. At some point, we need to have on our agenda a discussion of that site going forward. There are things, and this isn't the time to talk about it, but there has been talk of selling off the density and those things, and I would like this committee's opinion on that.
3:07:57 No. Heard at council as well as our individual opinions. And if you don't have opinion, come to me later, I'll tell you what it is. Most of us have opinions. And should we move along? Yeah. We have managers report. So with the fall application plan, are we... We're on the managers. Yeah.
3:08:27 I think so. Are we ready just to do it? I mean, are we approving it? That's the question. What's the answer? I will make a motion, if necessary, that we approve the timeline and the application as amended. To include the line item for? Four and five? Including the line item for venue. Okay. Okay. One second. All in favor? Wait, wait. Ask for, sorry.
3:08:56 First and second, any further discussion? Any further discussion? So did we, in that motion, did we include the priorities of funding? I think we did that in August, didn't we? I don't know. It says, did we look at the minutes? This revised list we did up here? What are we referencing now? The top of page two of the...
3:09:23 Stuff report. That's what I thought we did before. Yeah. Yeah, it says on August 13, 2013, the Measure U Application Committee revised the following funding priorities. Took the numbers off of it. For 2013. Yeah. Follower. Yeah. There was just no motion to accept it, I think is what I'm saying. I teach this by consensus, the committee is supportive of, you know. Yeah. We did that before. I mean, if you just want to add it to that motion, I think that would be. I'll add it to the motion. That'd be great. Thank you. Any comments or questions? All in favor?
3:09:52 Aye. Thank you. So, sorry, so through was the motion. Who was the second? Joyce. Oh, thank you. So, Stu, I think we're ready then for the manager's report when your pen catches up. There's my pen on my computer. I'm not too sure. I'll just write it down. I don't know if I had anything on the manager's report. The only thing I did mention was that we, you know, we have begun work on the reconciliation of, you know, R and U.
3:10:23 We think it's about 100 to 200 hours. It's really going to depend on what we find. What we're also trying to do, though, is provide all the backup as well of the process. So it's pretty comprehensive. So we're just going to have to manage that workflow the next two months. So our goal is to have that complete in a QuickBooks format by essentially November.
3:10:46 Kind of November, December, so we need to know how much we have and what's available and what we're being used on. Measure U is not so much the issue. I think Measure R, just because it's been running for a lot longer, is really where the detail is. So that person started, they're in the office. And I think that's all I had on that so far. So I'm sure there's thousands of things. Great. Are there any committee member reports? I'd just like to thank you two in particular for being here and taking the time.
3:11:18 To work in the task force and making it successful. Thank you. It was a committee approach. Yeah. I was on jury duty once and it was the same kind of everyone was disparate, different points of view, but we were able to reach consensus because we're trying to do something that helps. I'd also like to compliment Stu because he was great in time altogether and keeping us focused on the task.
3:11:51 Stuart has a great meeting. That may be his task. We may ask to just have him funded as the... It's a job security. Yeah. As a facilitator. If I didn't have to deal with his granitas thing, it would be great. You know, it's just anyone. I would just mention that I attended the conference call with Stu and Bill Taylor and a number of other peri-on the HVS venue discussion. And to me, I...
3:12:21 I think what's come out of it is it's given us a lot of things to think about. We may not agree with everything that comes out of it, but I think it's a step that at some point it has to be decided whether or not some options are exercised and what those options would be in view of the closed-door sessions and other things going on. Thank you. Anyone else?
3:12:46 Not a member report, just request for items for future. All right, let's move on then to request for discussion items, Bill. Stu, what do we have already for next month? You'll have the HVS study in front of you. You'll also have Measure U, full award again. They're the two items that I think we have. I don't know if I'll have a lot of that special event information collated by then, but I think that's kind of a priority of that meeting. Along with the HVS, which is the venue discussion,
3:13:16 I would like to add to that if everybody else was in agreement, a specific topic of discussion on the status of the current Wood site or Sam's site or Dennis's site or whoever's site you want to call it. Since it's a part of the HVS, is it appropriate to also have a discussion on the status of the foundation site? Yeah.
3:13:46 I just, my fear is that the process on the wood side is moving right along. But I think the other maybe two is the indications I get. Yeah, so we need to be making sure we start developing. We don't have to make any particular decisions. How do these things play together? Do they play together? I would like us to all be on the same page when we make some kind of a presentation in the future. So we need to start that discussion and be proactive rather than...
3:14:15 You know, I'd rather not have to put on a fireman's suit later and just put out fires. And that's, Sandy left a list here of four items, one of which was setting up a CIP reserve. And that's what we're talking about. What are we going to do? Should I continue on Sandy's list? It's continued discussion of the Measure U awards and status of funds like we had today. That needs to continue.
3:14:41 And she also brought up, since we have two new members, confirmed day and time of meeting that some people, Sandy thinks that some people getting here at 8.30 in the morning is a problem, particularly parents. Thank you, I don't think it's a problem. Okay, that was Sandy's eye. It was only a problem for me today because I turned the ringer off. I wasn't going to get you gone again.
3:15:08 I had noted. I was sitting in my sweats at the computer when Stu called. Yep. That's, I have nothing else. Thank you. Any other comments? I'm done. I will make a motion to adjourn. Great. I'll second that. Go ahead and third it, then we don't have to third it. I think we're adjourned. We've adjourned the meeting. Thank you very much. Thank you.
3:15:40 This is turning into a rec commission meeting where it goes on and on. Well, you didn't start. We got done in three hours. Who knows? We're giving us a 10% chance for Saturday. That's a matter. Are you kidding me? National Weather Service. Oh.
3:16:49 Thanks to you. Thanks, Dave. See ya.
3:17:21 Thank you.
3:17:59 Thank you so much for coming. I caught you by surprise. What's that, buddy? Hang on, let me just record this.