Measure U Committee
· recording 2 hr 24 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
267 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
19:18 And that's where the $3,500. So each of the audit services would just go in the annual administration. So that was an audit service. That's right. It's a performance audit, not a financial, actually. Yep. Yeah, that's in compliance with our ordinance, you know, so. Okay. And then the other question I had, once again, has to do with our tents. If I go over to the fund balance line and I start totaling numbers,
19:44 If I have 7,000 for the Jazz Jubilee and assuming by the other agenda bill item we have today, 5,000 for the Mammoth Lakes Music Festival and 5,000 for Food and Wine and 9,000 for Sierra Summer Festival, that totals something over 26,000. But I see a line 22,000 for Tim and Vince and Reynolds. What's the, what am I missing there?
20:13 We can talk about that at the next item. Okay. Is that that other? That's really what that item's about, of how that package was put together. But if you total what was on the other item, which is basically 5,000 for, I included the 5,000, not the 12,000 in that total, and the numbers still don't quite work for me.
20:38 So essentially it was 7,000. Assuming their bill was 5,000. Yeah, 7,000 from Jazz Jubilee and then it was $5,000 each from each of the other event organizers. So the 9,000 for Sierra Summer Festival. 5,000 of that is actually for the tent cost. Okay. Yep. So that's where it is. Yep. All right. That makes sense. That was the question. Perfect. And then, because that was the mix that we had last year because they just came forward and asked for four and then we ended up adding five for the tent, which was the problem with the...
21:07 Chamber of Music, I'm in. That's the answer. Okay. All right, then we will move on to agenda item number three. I'll move to approve. Here we go. Thank you. I move to approve. Oh, I'll second. Second. Thank you. Okay. And vote.
21:27 Thank you for taking the time to explain it. Normally, under consent, they don't, but I appreciate taking the time. Thanks for putting up with us. It's all right. Since all I do is balance my checkbook. Yes.
21:47 All right, then the third discussion, or the first discussion item, third on the agenda, the Chamber Music Unbound request for supplemental 2013 Measure U Spring funds for their rental obligations for the Edison Theater. Brian and Rebecca, thank you. Morning, I'm Brian Schult from Chamber Music Unbound. Rebecca Hung, Chamber Music Unbound. And you have the staff report in front of you. There's three recommendations, and I guess we're hoping that you strongly consider recommendation number one.
22:15 The festival, while it was very successful, you have the performance report also as part of the agenda packet. We are in the red. We do have bills to pay, including some rent for the Edison Pavilion. It says in the agenda Edison Theater, so that should be corrected to the Edison Pavilion, which is the tent. Also, some bills from the college.
22:41 For facility rental and piano rental as outlined in our original Measure U agreement and application. We're certainly happy to answer any questions about the oversight. It was not really discovered until a post-event, so just about a month ago. The CR7 Festival did come across this sort of discrepancy during the funding meeting in the spring.
23:10 We were not present for the entire meeting, so we didn't realize it until after the event. And it's a shortfall of $3,000. And like I said, happy to answer any questions about timeline and finances. Any questions? Did you want to add anything to do before? I think it pretty much clearly spells it out. I mean, I'm happy to answer any questions. I think where the disparity came was there was...
23:40 I think it was the last application period and, you know, we're going back and forth about the tent costs. And at one point, you know, we were kind of considering having the tent pulled out and had a separate Measure U application, but in fact it was rolled into the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and then we were then assuming that each of the event applicants were discussed and were, you know, pulled into that discussion and each of the funding allocations were appropriately added to the applications.
24:09 And we picked up that discrepancy, I think, right on that last day when we were doing applicant presentations for the Sierra Summer Festival. At that point, they only had 4,000 they were applying to. So we added that 5,000 to cover that tent, but inadvertently missed the additional $3,000 for the chamber. So it was a very, you know, as you know back then, it was a very kind of confusing thing to understand how this tent was going to get paid for with the different applicants. But really, it's just an oversight during that process.
24:39 That's all I could probably say. We worked with Brian on the agenda bill. We tried to make it as clear as we could. We put some recommendations forward. So happy to talk about those with you and kind of walk through any questions you might have. Thank you. Well, I do have a related discussion, I guess. It's about 10% for our older events.
25:03 The original application was 12,000 out of 120,000, and we've now built the event coalition guidelines into the whole application package. Do we start ignoring those now? Well, I think if you look at the Sierra Summer Festival's award, which is 9,000, that also exceeds the 10%. I think, looking forward, we will have a separate application for the pavilion.
25:30 This was sort of, you know, was coming down to the last week or so when we decided is it going to be a separate application, is it going to be pulled from our individual applications. And it really had to do also with events attending the meetings and we did attend all the meetings and we thought we were privy to all the information that we needed to have.
25:50 As things go and we were not responsible for contracting the tent. We had just signaled our general desire to collaborate and we had given from the beginning a very clear number which was between four and a half to five thousand that we could responsibly budget into our event budget. And that was the number that I think was somehow mistranslated or misunderstood because we thought
26:18 Chairman Music Unbound would be responsible for half of this and Measure U, if it came through, would take the other half. In the case that Measure U would not have come through, Chairman Music Unbound would have continued to present these events in our other facility, which we rented as well. So it was a very complicated situation and I think...
26:39 All we can say is that on our behalf, we thought we had responsibly budgeted the amount we had promised. It turned out that that was not how it was understood. So that's all. And I guess in my mind it sort of raises a question for the event coalition in the future. What do our guidelines mean? Now to support food and wine festival, there's this other expense. And are we now assuming
27:07 A tent will be above that, 10% for Food and Wine Festival or for Sierra Summer Festival or for, so what do our guidelines now mean? Because now we have other separately, separate line item amounts that are specifically for the benefit, it would have been in this case for events. And Juliana, if you want to, it's something a little
27:37 Different than we thought about in the past. Thoughts? I think one of the driving principles, if you will, behind Measure U at the time it was voted for was for facilities. And the tent is a facility, so it would be requested as a separate entity in the future. And then this spring exercise came up.
28:09 Relatively quickly, and I think we all tried to make it happen. We tried to do the joint facility, and we weren't sure whether we should do, honestly, recommended it be a separate entity, so he was right. And it should have been addressed as a separate component, and then it would not be part of those 10% or 20 or 30% budgets for the individual entities. It would be an actual facility. But then...
28:33 I think Sean, he was sitting back there. He doesn't have this kind of, does he submit something separate for something over there? Or is he now required to comply with a 10% kind of number when now to the benefit of, no, food and wine and the other folks, we have this separate line that also helps them out.
28:59 What do our guidelines mean to me is really the question. I can't answer that one right now. It's very convoluted. Oh, no, you saw them. So I'm listening to all this and thinking, okay, so there was a miscommunication, there was a budgeting issue, there was basically an accounting problem. Yes.
29:29 And, you know, we don't want to, from my perspective, it's like, okay, there was a counting problem, let's just fix it and move on. The lesson learned for me is that your, the MLEC or however we're going to move forward with events needs somebody who's, and you guys need to decide how you're going to do this, but you need some way to have confidence and present in confidence.
29:54 Budgeting and accounting practices accurately. I would say, you know, and just knowing how we work and how I work, you need a linear accounting person to process that kind of thing on your behalf. And this group that was collaborating on the tent was actually not the MLEC, it was some
30:18 Groups. Yeah. It's like a subcommittee. It's like a subcommittee of the MLEC. Four organizations that present like events that could use this venue. Yeah. So it might be a little separate than the MLC as a whole. Yeah. Yeah. So. I do recall it. The whole tent discussion was being pretty confusing. It was confusing. It was. Yeah. It was. At the time, I know Joyce and I were there and Bill and trying to sort it out. I think we all thought it was a great idea, but it was, you know, the.
30:48 The exact hows and who was paying what. I remember I did have trouble sorting it out myself. I think it just raises some questions for us to try to understand how we handle these kinds of things as guidelines. I think your request to that 10% issue is very interesting because exactly is it counted against their request? Because if you don't otherwise Jazz Jubilee, for instance, pays for other.
31:17 Tents elsewhere. Yes. And, um, yeah, so it's very easy. We use a Palooza doesn't get any benefit from this kind of things. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, so that's an interesting. What's a fair way to handle all of the events? Yeah, yeah, this whole, our whole process keeps evolving because we do learn things like, but that question, that question's a very, um, solid one that we need to follow up on and be thinking about. Yeah, and again, it's a lesson learned is, you know,
31:45 It's like Sean and I in our business. He's the creative guy and I'm the linear person. You need a linear person to support all of the creative people. So, you know, maybe that's the lesson learned from moving forward. Next year, let's not let it happen. Or have some way to handle it. Understand what we're doing.
32:08 Well, yeah, I think they're two separate issues. So I think ideally, like you said, we understand with the next phase of the sprung structure potentially for that facility will be a separate application. It's going to be a much larger one than what we've considered just for $22,000. So I think in this situation here, it's just of the, I was just adding it up, of the $195,860 of awards, you know, within $3,000, it's pretty good, you know, to get everybody funded and supported and you can see the benefit they provide.
32:38 So, yeah, I mean, you know, we listed three options. Happy to discuss those recommendations with the committee on how you'd like to move forward. That would be great. If we could discuss. Stu, the options, please. Yeah, so the option one is to recommend Town Council award additional Measure U funds in the amount of $3,000. So, you know, we have a fund balance currently that we're running because we're coming into the full period.
33:07 Council really at any time can award those funds. It doesn't have to go through a process. If it's recommended by the advisory body, they can take it into consideration. So that's really our number one option to kind of get this taken care of now, just due to the costs that the Chamber Unbound are going to incur, because they're already running at a loss, as they said. The other option there is to encumber those funds in the upcoming fall award, or the third option was just to
33:34 Request Chamber Music Unbound and the Mammoth Lakes Music Festival include those funds in the next award period. The problem there, though, is that you start to, you know, you're not really solving the problem. You're just putting one problem in and the next one. Anyway, I'd like to kind of keep those clean moving forward so everyone can stand on their own merits with what they need specifically for that event. I'm sorry, Stu, what? How much money is in the bank right now? I'm looking for that number. I haven't got it with us, but
34:03 Yes. I'm thinking the award's about seven, eight hundred thousand. Okay. We have. So it's not really a funding issue. And looking at this reconciliation process over the last, you know, two amounts, there's money that hasn't been spent. I do like to point out that the Chamber of Music Unbound and Mammoth Lakes Music Festival last year didn't spend all their awards either. Right. So I think they were, actually they came under their award, I think, by that.
34:31 $2,000. Yeah, that's right. That was because of the marketing. Exactly. They've just made up the difference. Yeah, they've made up the difference of $1,800. Then I think there was another award, I'm just trying to find that, of about $1,200. So you can actually find that some previous awards didn't actually, you know, expend all their funds. So, you know, once we get through this reconciliation, there's those overages and there's those fund balances available that wouldn't incur any other additional cost. So that's probably what we'd recommend if that's...
35:01 Anybody move yet? So, would somebody like to make a motion to approve option analysis number one to recommend the town council? I'll move so. So, to recommend option number one. So, Joyce has recommended option one. Do we have a second? I'd second it. Sandy, second it. Do we have a vote? All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Great. Thank you. Thank you. That's the simplest. Putting up an accounting error. And just on, to respond to it, I think all the organizations that put on events will only
35:30 The benefits, the stronger the guidelines are that you set for us. So we thank you for doing that work and we'll do our very best to avoid any kinds of oversights like this. Thank you. Thank you, Rebecca. We keep learning. Can I just ask a quick question? Sure. Yes. Will there be any other events, do you think, that are going to come forward and say, hey, we didn't budget in use for the tent? I'm just curious. It sounds like it will happen.
35:59 Okay, I just wanted to ask if there were any other events coming up. Yeah, there's one payment still needs to be made to Sierra Summer Festival for $4,000, but the tent cost has been paid, and that's really been the issue. I mean, we've paid those funds, we've already pulled them out of the award, so...
36:30 And if you remember, back in the first Spring Test Award, we went around the first time and then we came back and actually did it again and kind of backfilled those amounts that those applicants requested. So there's... Anyway, we're doing the best we can. All right, and the next agenda item, number four.
36:54 Approve the 2013 Measure U Fall Award application evaluation material, including the event application process, and provide direction to staff regarding the proposed town funding applications. Is there anyone who would like to discuss this at this time? I'll just give you a brief staff report, if I may, Chair. So, just going through the staff report, so we, as the committee, have already approved the timeline and the priorities of funding.
37:25 So we've kind of done that process. The next phase here is to approve the application evaluation material which includes the event application process. And then the opportunity which we missed last time and it's probably more appropriate today to go through the town applications in a little bit more detail and we have Jessica from the town here to kind of present those two items that she has. But you can see we've
37:53 We haven't changed any numbers. They've been in the background, I think is the attachment A, so the special event trolley fund, special event support. That one still is a little bit of an open number. We do want to kind of spend a little bit more time trying to firm up what we really want to apply for there. So we'll kind of address that as we move along this process. The roller rink operations enhancement is again a split with Measure R.
38:25 Previously we asked for $30,000 each. With our limited operation plan now, we've kind of really cut that down from seven days a week to three days a week. You know, we think we can run that more efficiently. So we're only asking for $15,000, which is half of the amount from previous awards. And then Jessica will talk about items number D and items number E. And I would probably recommend after that that...
38:49 Either the committee kind of address each of those items separately or you can kind of package them all together. But if you do have a consensus on the town applications, we can kind of take that as an item and then check that off the list and then we can kind of tackle the application forms and the evaluation material and maybe address that because there might be some people who want to speak about that. I did have a question, however, Stu, because one of the things that we're supposed to set aside a little time to...
39:15 Discuss is site acquisition. What? Set aside. It's on this list. It's on the list, but you know, as you go through it, it's not on the list. And so I would suggest that after we have hit the, you know, we put that in just before we start on the application form. Seems like the logical place. That's a good, I like that. Does that sound right? Yeah, you noticed it too. Yeah. Yeah, I was on the list and I got, but where is it?
39:42 I go a little further. I know we've had studies for both an event venue and for Main Street. These are kind of future projects that maybe we need to set money aside for, and I sort of consider the two of them together. We both have very soon some final reports out on some work, but to me they're sort of in the same pot.
40:12 On this future planning capitalization. And I would be kind of hesitant to say, yeah, we're ready to go on Main Street because I'm no more comfortable with it than I am with the event. We're not there yet. We're not there yet is the thing. Wayfinding. We've got.
40:32 Beautiful graphics down there helping us understand what's going on. And we see it around town, but these others are future things that I think need a lot of discussion and a lot of open vetting in town. Back to just our kind of our process here. When does this event study the final come back? So we have a scheduled meeting I think on October 21 just with a final review group to go over that study. But I would believe it would be available November.
41:02 To review. So that could be something we could add to that other workshop or the regular meeting. Yeah. Well, and Don, I respectfully disagree. I think that the event venue thing is more real and current than a future item and study. And so I think I would recommend and prefer that we tackle this the way Stu suggested in listening, you know, taking on the two.
41:28 Town application concepts and then discussing the event venue item after that. Exactly. Just wanted to talk as we do it. Yes. Because that's when the comments are appropriate. I'd say the same thing. But definitely, I think we'll want to start our discussion at least about site acquisition today. Absolutely. I mean, we need to start with that. We need to give guidance on what that application looks like from the town. And to me, that's another reason for having a November meeting, frankly. Yeah, good point. That'll be a topic.
41:57 The study coming out. And especially with that study coming out. Yeah. Exactly. That would make it really appropriate. So and then at that point, we start in on our application form and the filter checklist and all like that. That works. Yeah. I just didn't want to see that get lost. Great. So Jessica. Okay. So I am presenting to you today two applications. I'll start with the wayfinding application first, if that's okay. So just a little background.
42:29 We started the planning process for this back in 2010, had an eight-month community process for development of the wayfinding plan, and we resulted in a final design, which I brought a couple of examples. This is a pedestrian sign example, and this is the whole hierarchy of wayfinding signage.
42:53 And we were awarded $77,250 in the Spring 2012 Measure U cycle to complete the remaining pre-construction tasks. And we are currently under contract with a design firm to finish the engineering specifications for the entire signage project so that we will have shelf-ready designs as funding comes forward.
43:19 And then also part of that spring 2012 award was funding to construct the district identification monument that will be located on the corner of Main Street and Old Mammoth Road. And that is expected to go to bid in the spring of 2014. So we're moving ahead on those items. So the funding request you have before you today is to further
43:47 Further our progress on this project overall, we're asking for $334,250 to complete the next two phases of the plan, which consists of phase 1B and 1C in your attachment, and that would be to do the pedestrian signage, not including the kiosks that we have planned in different locations through town, but the whole signage that would be.
44:15 What you see here would be mounted on existing light poles or traffic signal poles. And that phase 1B is 15,750. Phase 1C would be to do all of the vehicular signage in town. And it is quite a big ticket item, but staff feels that it would be best to knock that out in one.
44:44 One swoop, so to speak, rather than trying to piecemeal it in different areas of town. You don't have a functional system if you just have a few streets done and not the whole town. So the total request, as I said, is for 334-250 and that would put us significantly on our way towards completing this project. Any questions?
45:11 Have you explored other funding options as we requested the last time you came forward? Because it seems like exactly what we were concerned about happening and is happening is that we started down the path of Measure U providing funding and all of a sudden we're the only source of funds. You guys are a big source of funds. What other funds have you explored? We have had conversations in the past with John Urdi regarding Mativa, but...
45:39 I haven't talked to him about it in a few months. There's a possibility that that could be a funding source as well. And then there's always grants. But in terms of concrete availability of funds, this is probably the best option for us, just to be perfectly honest. When you bring this application forward, I would strongly urge that you show that you actively pursued other grants and other options.
46:08 It really bothers me that we're being used as the convenient source of funds. I don't think that's appropriate. I think we've really got to be out there looking further. Leveraging is a huge item, is a huge priority in our list of goals. Along those lines, there is a line on your business plan here before us. It says credit sign panels from private potential contributions, lodges, golf courses, etc.
46:37 And for $56,000, and I think what Joyce is saying is, is that real? No, it's not real right now. It's not. So maybe one thing you think about, or option, think about that leveraging priority, and maybe you use this to say, hey, Measure U would be more likely to support us if they knew we were getting money from another.
47:03 Place as well. Some grants look for matching options. Some private entities, if you're looking at them, tell them Measure U is more likely to step up if I can get some money from you guys as well to make this happen. Because I agree with you on knocking all the vehicle signs out in one contract because I'd be much more efficient and much more logical and make more sense for the project in and of itself. But I'm...
47:30 hesitant about Measure U being considered the convenient source of funds without using them as a leveraging option. There's a lot of opportunity there. Get creative about this one. Oh, I'm creative. I know you are. Yeah, I had some similar, I have, I can see jumping ahead with the pedestrian, I think that would be great. It's a minor sum.
47:55 I think we'd see it all over town. Mine were kind of looking at the other signs, and I hadn't really thought about the economy scale awarding them all together. I can understand that. That makes a lot of sense. It's just that it's a huge chunk. And is there any way, I mean, do you have like a phasing plan in case you were only granted, say, a quarter of what you asked for the vehicular?
48:24 We could, Hayes and I could probably look at that, but I don't see, I don't really see how it could be done. I mean, possibly just doing Main Street would work, but if you put, you know, six signs in the ground on Main Street and they're pointing to things, and then people turn off Main Street, then you're not leading them to where they need to go. So it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me to do it piecemeal that way.
48:53 Exactly, yeah. It is big. Yeah, it's a huge chunk. It is. It's a very big chunk, and I think that's what we're looking at because we're looking at a whole bunch of other. It may suggest is what you're doing by trying to look to us for all of the money is risking not getting any of it because there are other very large priorities, and this may not be the highest priority.
49:20 Has this, like, gone to LTC at all? Have they investigated any of the potentials for LTC? I believe we put it in your priority list that you're looking at on Thursday amongst many, many other priorities. So, I mean, potentially it could get put into a future stiff cycle. That's what I was wondering. A stiff cycle would be appropriate. No, I don't know how.
49:48 I'm not familiar with the frequency of that, but if it gets put into a stiff cycle, I would assume that it wouldn't be completed until a very long time from now. And, I mean, I personally think that this is a priority because, you know, we need more revitalization on Main Street. Right, right. And, you know, we're trying to put things in the ground that show progress towards that. And, you know, you're not going to get an event facility.
50:17 15 years, 10 years. You can put these signs in the ground in the next year or two and show the public, show the community, show the developers that Mammoth is not dying. Right. So I feel very passionately about it and, you know, I think mobility has sort of gotten the short shrift of this process. There's been a lot of money that's gone to events.
50:45 Events are great. I think they're great. But I don't know that there's been a lot of focus from this committee on mobility. So I wouldn't just pass it off as not being a priority. Thank you. Any other comments or questions? I do have a few more questions for, first of all, for Jessica. Have there been any thought to, in other words, going first with pedestrian, which is something that we can...
51:16 Easily knockoff, I think. And then I was looking at if you went to phase three with a potential pot of money to leverage district monuments as contributors came forward. In other words, with some of these, I'm assuming you guys probably do have a list of folks that might be contributors to...
51:41 Say, District Gateway, Downtown, West End, South, you know, District Gateway, the Village. In other words, if we were to set aside and cumber a pot and call it the Monument Match and then pursue, perhaps pursue all of your vehicular signage through LTC, something like that. Is that logical? Because it seems like that, you know, the pedestrian ones would be helpful, I think.
52:07 And I think we're going to see next spring or summer that first district monument. So maybe, I don't know, that's just an idea. I don't know if that's been discussed or thought about. Does it sound logical? I guess my feeling is that there's probably little likelihood of going through LTC for construction.
52:29 These are construction funds. We're finishing the design. We're not in planning anymore. We're finishing design. This is money to put things in the ground. And I don't know that just the way the LTC functions, that's going to be a...
52:47 It's not going to be a short-term thing. It's not going to happen in a few couple years. And the whole thing may not happen is what I'm saying. I mean, it may need to be stretched out a little bit more because our, but does the idea of a match fund for at least, even if we get one or two monuments a year. Right. Well, the face on your packet, phase three, is that just the other district identification monuments, those have been noted as private contributions.
53:15 Those would not be funded by the town. They would not at all? That is not my plan. I mean, I don't see how the town would, why the town would help fund district monuments for Snow Creek, Sierra Star. I don't feel that that's the town's responsibility. So to me, that's where the matching comes in, is to help complete the whole package by having partners from the private sector put up their own monuments.
53:44 Okay, so basically there's no counter-confrontation there at all? Not on that, basically. We've separated that out specifically. Okay. And they could be constructed any time when, you know, if Rusty wants to come in and...
53:59 And put up a monument somewhere, I've got the design now for it. Okay. Okay. If Chuck does, you know. So, and we have talked to some outside entities about that before, and they had expressed interest. Well, and as to your comment about that being the match, I agree with you that those are monuments that would be nice for the town, but they do directly benefit the private, so I wouldn't necessarily consider that a match to vehicular signage.
54:28 So I'm looking for those, that leveraging opportunity to support that vehicular signage. Thank you. Jessica, any other questions, comments? Sean, turn around. It's interesting sitting on this side and watching what you guys have to go through. I'm getting a lesson myself. I'd like to thank the committee for really pressing town staff to look for other funds, obviously, because unfortunately,
55:02 It is too easy for, I think, town staff to come before either R or you and say, hey, this is the number one priority. And this is, this is very important stuff to be sure. But I want to thank the committee for pushing town staff to really look for other funds. And then the question I just want to ask is you made the comment about we're not going to get an events venue for 10 to 15 years. And I'm just wondering if that's something, you know, how that comes from this podium or why, how that comment was made.
55:28 All I'm saying is that an events venue is going to cost multi-millions of dollars, and you know, so would a Main Street project, and all I'm saying is that it's not shovel-ready, and there would have to be a lot of further planning, design, environmental, permitting, you know, you're not going to have an events venue built.
55:56 Next year. That's an interesting comment coming from a staff perspective because what I'm asking staff to do because I've been staff. I've been staff in cities and for Caltrans for many years and I'm not even going to tell you how many. What we're challenging you to do is not think about the big Cadillac version. Think about how to grow these things organically and think about how to fund them creatively.
56:25 Our community is a business as much as it is a government agency, and we all need it. The government, along with every single individual business, needs to think creatively. We could have an events venue next year if we grow it organically. We don't need the Cadillac tomorrow. I don't need to wait 15 years for a Cadillac. I want an events venue next year. And think the same way about this and about, you know, the other projects you mentioned. Main Street, they can happen faster.
56:53 If we think creatively and work creatively. This is true. Okay. Next. So, Main Street projects. Do you want us to do a motion? Steve, did you want us to do... This is just a feedback, isn't it? Or do you want us to submit a formal application, I guess, for... Well, yeah, I was just wondering, do we do it one at a time before the next project? Or... We could do the whole... We could just... Do them all. Okay. Do them all. I think we could just... Yeah, we could do attachment A.
57:24 You know, once we've kind of reviewed that piece and then make your recommendations and we can mark off, you know, yes, no, move forward, not. I mean, it might be easier. I mean, it's up to you, though. Okay. Yeah. So, go on to Main Street. Go on to Main Street, then. Okay. So, the request for the Main Street project is to complete the 30% engineering design plan. The funds requested are $200,000.
57:54 And there's, this is basically our next incremental step to taking, I know this is kind of awkward because you probably haven't seen the draft plan yet. I just put it on the website earlier this week. There is a great workshop tomorrow night for tomorrow afternoon at 4 o'clock. Winter and Company, who's the consultant lead, will be presenting the draft Main Street plan.
58:23 Tomorrow to the council and planning commission at a joint meeting. So, you know, the timing is kind of awkward because I'm asking for something that furthers what you haven't seen yet. But the engineering department and I worked on this coming up with what we thought would be the next most logical step towards actual implementation and that would be moving into design. And the design phase for
58:53 A project that's so large scale would be quite expensive. I've heard numbers from $1 million to $1.5 just for design. And so we are asking for a lot of money just to get to 30%. And so I can definitely understand hesitation that you might have for that, especially given that you haven't seen the plan yet.
59:21 You know, this has been a process that we've been working on for, well, as long as I've been here. And everything behind me up on the wall is sort of a testament to the planning process that we have gotten to now, which we think is a pretty solid, very solid, not even concept, it's further than concept. It was a concept, it was at concept level when we did the downtown concept for Main Street back in 2010.
59:50 This took that, refined it, did more technical analysis, looked at more specifics of phasing and cost, and now we're at that point where we could take this and get to at least a 30% design. We do have some funding through LTC for
1:00:20 Further level of service and technical analysis. So I had $30,000 for that budget in this overall work program this year. So that can be one leveraging thing that we can use for that. But basically what we would get out of the 30% design is they would do an aerial topographic survey. They'd fly the corridor.
1:00:47 And map the whole thing, so we would have a full topo of Main Street Corridor, which is, you know, hugely advantageous for the future. We would get engineering estimates of probable costs, which is just a more detailed cost estimate, building off the cost estimates that we have in here, which are more preliminary.
1:01:16 I mentioned the level of service analysis, so that would be looking at the specifics of driveway operations, intersection operations, turn pockets, because part of this plan includes a median with turning lane, turn pockets, and so we have to look at the specifics of that. Phasing plans and recommendations and coordination of utilities, so diagnosing
1:01:44 Exactly where all the utilities are. You'd think that we would know, but we don't always know where they are. Identification of subsequent studies, so it would be looking at, it wouldn't be doing the environmental, but it would be looking at which environmental studies would be necessary. I don't think that the CEQA process for this project as a whole would really be
1:02:14 Very complicated because we're not really changing. It's essentially an infill project that went forward. We're not changing the cross-section of the road. We're doing things and transforming things within the frontage roads is basically the concept behind this plan, which you'll see when you...
1:02:38 Get a chance to look at it more closely. So I don't think overall environmental is going to be an issue. And then we would get a 10%, 20% intermediate designs and then a 30% design. Then after that would be more detailed design plans until you finally get to 100% design. So it's not super exciting because you can't get all of it
1:03:12 You know, super quickly and get everything you want, but I think it's the next logical step to moving this towards reality. That's my pitch. When you bring forward this application, could you do some kind of budget? I would highly suggest you do some kind of budgeting like you did for the wayfinding. It's very helpful to see.
1:03:35 All the pieces and how much they're going to cost and where you anticipate getting funds from. It's all in here. Okay. Yeah. Um, it's all in here and it's, it's, um, it's very detailed, like, down to the, you know, linear foot of sidewalk. Yeah. Yeah. I like, I like this, how you summarized in this, though. Yes. Yeah, the way finding or whichever is left, we're helpful. Yeah. But this one in this, this guy.
1:04:04 Are there opportunities for additional LTC PP&M funds on this one, the project planning? Because LTC is a great source for planning and design. Not design. Not design, okay, but planning, project planning. Yeah. Programming and design. That's always our problem is we can get funding for design and planning, or not design, but planning easily. It's what's always difficult is finding.
1:04:34 Capital funding and operational funding, maintenance funding, you know, none of that is as easy to get. What kind of discussions have gone on with Caltrans about this? They have been engaged since the 2010 DCMS. We met with them in April when we had our four-day community outreach process for this, and they are
1:05:02 They are supportive of this concept, and I think that somebody from Caltrans will be at the workshop tomorrow as well. But one of the key things for them is that this concept doesn't actually change the curb lines of Main Street. It's changing everything on the outside, so everything in the frontage roads. So they're...
1:05:27 More happy, more supportive, because it's not actually changing the state highway portion of Main Street. Are we considering taking over Main Street and having Caltrans relinquish it? There's money from Caltrans to do things like that. That's been a conversation that I think has been happening for 20 years. Do you have a technical advisory committee supporting you on this? Any kind of TAC that's supporting you? There is none. Okay.
1:05:56 I was going to say the relinquishment talks were going on. I came in 95 and Caltrans would love to get, but they'd also like to get rid of everything right up to Minaret Summit and of course the Forest Service has said in the past. No thanks. Jessica, does your report give us a feel for the kind of buy-in you have from all the businesses on Main Street? We had several meetings in April.
1:06:23 Where we met with specific property owners and then we had open house sessions where people... I attended a number of those. And then the workshops. Yes, the workshops. And I think at the first workshop we had that week, the concept that has emerged as the preferred concept was really the one that seemed to come to the forefront with the public. And we did have...
1:06:50 A number of one-on-one meetings with some of the larger property business owners on Main Street. And, you know, they have probably not had a chance to read the plan yet either. Okay. But it seemed like the preferred concept that's in this plan, it seems like there's a lot of support for it. But there is some plan to get vetting before them?
1:07:15 Before we go out. Oh, it has. Actually, the public process in this, I've been very impressed. This has been one of those public processes that really has. Has worked. Yeah, I mean, public and businesses and very good consultants, I felt. Oh, they were. Yeah, they really are. I attended the workshops and all. I think you'll see that tomorrow. Yes. And this will be out for public review for the next 30 days at least. Well, yeah, probably just 30 days because.
1:07:44 This process has been funded through Caltrans Grant, and it needs to be completed by the end of February. So we need to complete the public input period, come back with a final draft, and then it would go forward to the planning commission and the town council for acceptance, for consideration and acceptance, similar to the downtown concept for Main Street process. I just have to say of the...
1:08:15 I know this is a big project. My preference is if we were to bite off a chunk of money would be to go with the wayfinding because it's tangible. Right. I mean, I just, and just looking at the numbers, Jessica is correct that mobility of the, all the funding that we went through last spring, mobility received 12.6% of all funding.
1:08:45 Recreation got 62.09% of all funding, and arts and culture got 25.31% of all funding. So mobility has been on the short end of this. Remember when we formed all of this, we said we weren't going to look at it like who gets...
1:09:09 Each segment gets... Not thirds. Yeah, exactly. Not exactly, but five years. Community priorities, not... We were to use this fair share. This matrix, we were supposed to do this annually to kind of figure out what we were doing. Yeah. It's good to know. It's good to know, but it's community priorities over fair share. It is. It is that, but, you know, just keeping in... Well, and, you know, going back to what you were saying, Joyce, you know, I think maybe...
1:09:37 Maybe the staff hasn't done a very good job of showing all of the other ways that we leverage funds that you guys don't even know about. I mean, all the paths that were built this summer.
1:09:49 Were grant funds that we went and got. So we don't just come here because it's the easy thing. We go to the thing that makes the most sense is the most feasible. If I can get a grant for a safe route to school, I will do that. I won't come to you and ask for that money to build that $1.5 million college connector path. I'll find it at the state. I shouldn't say I. I should say the engineering department. So I can't go to another funding source.
1:10:17 To ask for these things, that's why I'm asking for them. Thank you. Any other comments, questions from the public? A couple of things. I would ask the question, I'm really not sure how this project fits in with Measure U, which was? Mobility. But you can drive on Main Street. Main Street is mobile. That would be my comment. I would also ask the question, 30% now, how much later?
1:10:58 Last year, last allocation period, wayfinding was 77,000, now it's 334,000. You're asking about that percentage that's now being asked to come out of Measure U, so the potential is there will never, ever be anything else for
1:11:18 Arts and culture, which has short shrift. And even when you look at those percentages, a lot of that was for events. Those events are not all arts and cultural events. And I do thank you for asking for everyone to be looking for matching funds because every arts and culture organization, nonprofit that I know does that religiously because otherwise they would not survive. So those are more questions rather than comments. Thank you. Any other?
1:11:49 I don't have any more questions or comments. Thank you. Thank you. Well, before Jessica goes, I would like to say how much we're going to miss her. She has just accepted a promotion in the town of Missoula, Montana as the transportation manager. I've worked with her. I had the pleasure of working with her when I was with the Forest Service, and she was a Ford Foundation transportation scholar that worked on Red's Meadow issues and a lot of things like that. She's a consummate professional.
1:12:22 And we are really lucky. A little less so today. No, never, never. But I just have to tell you, they are really lucky. And I'm really going to miss her. Because mobility is transportation planning, how you make it better. Not just how you can drive it down the street. Because a lot of people think maybe, you know, we did the wrong thing when we added seven lanes over there in 203 years ago. And, you know, people complain about sidewalks. Why don't we have them?
1:12:52 You know, year-round, well, we have them six months of the year. If you can't get the snow off them, well, we try. But, you know, transportation planning, when you look around here, mobility is everything having to make it a feet-first town. Transportation planning, we have no, I mean, I mean, so anyway, having a transportation planner, a professional, is something that is really a luxury. I don't know what's going to happen to us now. For a while, we'll be kind of thrashing in mobility, but you've left us a lot of good stuff.
1:13:21 Thank you. And we will miss you a lot. Yeah, sorry. I just, I'm very passionate about these projects. I know you are. That's what makes you a good planner. Yes. That's what makes you a good planner. And I want them to, I mean, I'm not saying that because I'm leaving that I will go, that nothing will happen, but the town has a tendency to leave things on a shelf. I know. I'm hoping that they won't get just left on a shelf. Because this has been a real effort that
1:13:49 I know that she has taken part in and has really moved it forward and they're both big efforts. The wayfinding, I attended, I was part of both of these groups and, yeah. Thanks for being such a drag. Thank you. Thank you. Stu, what do you recommend that we do? So, I think at this time you maybe address item number six, which is the event venue acquisition, discuss that item and then collectively as a committee make your recommendations in regards to the town proposed applications and we can kind of wrap that.
1:14:21 Section up of the Measure U process and move on to the evaluation forms. Do you have a three-minute break? Okay. Okay, I'm going to take a little break. All right, so we will take a quick recess. Quick recess. There you go. I will pause the meeting. Okay. Officially paused. All right, so we are returning from our recess, and Stu, should we start with A, with a special event trolley funding, or what would you like to do?
1:14:52 We can tackle six and then we can kind of wrap them all together. Six, okay. So I think we introduced this award, this application at the last meeting. It's really pending the HVS study. We've built the same application into the Measure R application award period two. As I said, the small group's going to meet on October 21. It'll come before the committee and commissions again in November.
1:15:20 I still think there's a second phase of that whole report in regards to, okay, so now we've got the recommendations, okay, what's the next steps? I think there's a lot of work to be done. I think everyone agrees with that. So maybe that could be a portion of it, but we just have to identify what those are, what they could be, and what community and commissions want to see out of those reports. Specifically, if you do look at a site like Sam's Wood site,
1:15:50 Who would operate it? How much do we charge? Is the council going to offer a subsidy? Is it going to get put out to a tender for a lease to someone to operate it? How would the town be part of that? What are the fees, structure, concessions? I think there's so many questions. And what capital improvements are required? How long does that take? Where would those funds come from? So I think there's that second phase. So I think a little bit of this application could be a lot of that in regards to
1:16:19 Okay, so we've identified that this is probably a priority if council makes that determination and then staff would really be looking at that phase of the projects. So from my perspective where I'm coming from on this particular item is that, yeah, I get it. There is a lot of things to consider. But there's an opportunity before us.
1:16:47 And I'll just speak to that specific one, which is Sam's Wood Site. There is an opportunity before us to take on something that is so natural for this community to own. And we need to be prepared and ready to move with that. So rather than sit around and wait for a bunch of studies to be done, let's at least show good faith to the sellers.
1:17:16 That there is genuine interest from this community. We don't have to commit the money to them. We don't have to sign a term sheet. We don't have to do anything. But if we're showing good faith that we're setting aside money and that this is a priority for us for an events venue and, yes, we're going through the process and we're going to be smart about how we pursue it because we need to know how we're going to pay for everything, that's great. But to not move forward with
1:17:44 With setting aside money, like we've talked about all this time, for a solid capital investment that's a solid asset for this community would be a mistake on our part, I think. Because that goes to the balance sheet. If we were to, say, buy Sam's Wood Site in the next year, that's a huge asset on this community's balance sheet that I think is a sound investment. And we will figure out how all of this works.
1:18:14 I guess what I'm looking at from staff relative to an application is an application and I think Sandy talked to me about this because I think this is what I heard from you as well. If we can say in this application that we want as a community want to set aside funds for the purchase or acquisition of an asset for this community that's an events venue.
1:18:44 I think that would go a long way. Because that's something tangible. Not another study necessarily, but a tangible asset that's an events venue for this community. That's what I'd like to see. Which I think is consistent with what the Recreation Commission was recognizing too. I think that was setting aside future capital investment funds for those purposes. I tend to agree with Joyce. I think we need some sort of wedge.
1:19:17 And that's probably an RNU. I do think we have the opportunity. We've already paid for the second half of a study from HVS. But if we some, it's in the budgets. We just have to authorize them to. It's in the budgets. We have to authorize them to do it. But if that can address some of these issues about how you manage it, who manages, is some separate entity set up, and it should also include a sprung structure.
1:19:48 But so we could have an apples to apples look at those two things. What do they give us? What do they cost us? Because, you know, I think we're all in favor of them in terms of what I believe we're still going to see out of HVS, that large single thing. That's not Mammoth. But we do have two opportunities. And if we have a wedge in here and we can have some sort of independent look.
1:20:15 At the way we finance these things, at the way we manage these things, perhaps that's a way to use the remainder of that HVS contract, too. Well, and frankly, when you look at purchasing any asset, whether it's, you know, a building or a property or anything else, the first question the seller asks is, where's the money? Yes. And if we can show that good faith that the money's sitting in the bank waiting for the right opportunity, I think we've created it.
1:20:41 We've created a sense of credibility to this town. But we need some things like maybe an independent appraisal. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, you go through all the good faiths. There's a whole bunch of things. Yeah, you go through all of the. But lay out a time schedule for us. There are three options. Absolutely. That could be exercised under that HVS contract. Absolutely. One of them is fiscal. How much money is it going to bring in and when? It talks about what is the management structure. And then the last one.
1:21:08 Allows you to look at some short-term, mid-term, and long-term actions the way these things would happen. And that's what we need, I think. So as I understand it, we'd be looking at probably phase, that would become, a lot of that would be in phase two, is what Stu was talking about. But phase one is our, in other words, discussion today, discussion at our November meeting as well. Hopefully the Recreation Commission might be picking up on this as well.
1:21:37 Because I think what we've been hearing is that we do want tangible, tangible capital stuff. This is a reserve. Yeah, and that's why I think all of us kind of, at least I know I did and we had the hesitations about the Main Street plan. I know all the work that's gone into it, whatever, but it looks to the public like it's more studies. Yes. And if we're saying we're creating a capital reserve so that we know we want...
1:22:07 Event sites, performing arts site, and this money is targeted for that. And I think there's always the general worry of sometimes the town tapping in. Yeah. But frankly, Sandy, that's a good point because if we do already have money set aside for that tangible capital asset, then we're not beating up Jessica so much on the Main Street things because we're not...
1:22:34 Trying to protect that money without being able to protect that money. But we get to the point where decisions will have to be made. Yeah, yeah. But I think one of the things that we can come back with maybe and have a structured discussion, Stu, you think at our next meeting, you know, allowing time for this, especially the general discussion, and then outlining the steps that we would see, like you mentioned in the following, but maybe have an action item that we would actually decide at the next meeting to...
1:23:03 Set aside money. Well, some way. Or recommend, I should say. Well, I guess what we, Stu, we're doing is we're asking staff to put forward an application for this specifically. And last meeting we threw out the number 250,000, you know, and I think, I think that's a reasonable number to put out there. So I guess what we're asking is can you start outlining based on this creating an application.
1:23:32 From town staff to Measure U for a set-aside or, you know, a bank account or whatever, capital reserve for the purchase of fixed assets to support for an events venue. For events venues, because we have two, and I said, I'm forgetting, I do think we can have them both.
1:23:56 I think it's figuring out the strategy. I think we need them both. I agree. How to get there. That's what we struggle with. Yeah. And frankly, I agree. 250, I apologize, I wasn't here at that last meeting. But the 250,000, I would say 300. Yeah, okay, I'm good with that. Is that 150 for me, or is that? No, it probably wouldn't be mobility-related. I would say, but I could see, SAMS is a wonderful winter site. There's a lot of opportunities on both.
1:24:26 Oh, oh, no. They're also going to R. Is that $250 to U and $250 to R? Oh, no, I would say, no, I would say $300 from you. And it's a bank account. We don't have to spend it all. No, okay. Just put $300 from you. And ideally, I would hope the Rec Commission would do the same thing because there are winter rec opportunities on that site. I mean, that's open parkland acquisition. Follows the general plan. Follows the general plan. Exactly. And, I mean, that could be, let's face it, each year if we were...
1:24:55 Putting that in, then I think that's how we go about getting both of them. I can see sleds there. Well, a mini sleds, yeah, exactly. I mean, you can session out a site like that for the wintertime, the first three or four or five years, and that's where percentage of the gross starts paying for itself. Yeah, yeah. Does that make sense, too? Yeah, the option that you have is also, you know, we're taking this to commission as well. Does it make sense to have a joint?
1:25:24 Workshop meeting with Commission, with the Recreation Commission on this item. I mean, is it that productive for the committee so you can all engage in the discussion on the final report and the study or you want to do it separately? Bill Taylor is going to be presenting. We'll have the items. It might be beneficial to kind of hear their thoughts. I think for this, just to...
1:25:46 In the interest of keeping it simple, if we just say as Measure U, let's set aside that 300,000. Which I've got. And then all of those conversations, yeah, it's brilliant to have them all in a joint workshop and all of that kind of stuff, but let's not that, let that convoge up the simplicity of what we're asking for here. Look at this. Yeah, because too often what happens, then it gets so, you know, we forget about, yeah. So in terms of what's going before the council.
1:26:12 So they know it's a capital reserve, that we need to do something. And they can say, whew, okay, we know Measure U is supporting. We're doing something. Well, and let's face it, the council set aside of Measure R funds $300,000 per year for the trails. It goes towards the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, and that money is targeted for trails. So I think this is reasonable to be able to say, hey, we're building this one up so that we can...
1:26:42 I like that. You've got a good comparison there. I think we've got the rationale. Yeah, and this is a very simple request, and there's no risk to it. It's a savings account. Yep. We're not committing to spending it or anything. And once, let's face it, that's the kind of thing when if they okay it, they're going to keep their word on it. And that's important. Keep it simple. Yeah. Stuart, do you like your idea of...
1:27:11 Bringing together R and you sometime in November to discuss the report findings and as you mentioned what Bill Taylor is planning on presenting. Yeah. And that would help us maybe provide some guidance for options too, how we might proceed and what they might do for us. Could we invite our committee to sit in at our November meeting? Yep.
1:27:38 If that is when they present the report. Can they show up at 8.30 in the morning? I know some that can. We could poll. We could schedule it. It depends. At the moment, we've only got that one item to talk about. So we can schedule a joint workshop at like a 9.30 time or something like that. Gives you time to get through that item and then the additional item.
1:28:05 You have that hour to talk about that joint workshop. I think it's more efficient for staff, certainly, instead of doing it twice. And the public can engage once in the process as opposed to multiple times. So I think that's very productive. November 5th could be a little bit early. So I think November 12th would be a good opportunity, I think. Yeah, so I'll contact the commission and see if we want to do that. It could be...
1:28:31 November 12th, 9.30 here, and then we can just do that one presentation. We can present it on the PowerPoint there and have the public comment. I'm sorry, what date did you just say? So that looks like the 12th of November, which is kind of our next meeting. If you do decide to add that agenda item, that would be the day. So it would be... Would we have our regular meeting first? We'd still meet at 8.30, do that agenda item, and then 9.30, do that.
1:28:58 It'd just be the policy item. That's kind of nice. Yeah. But we can talk about that if you wish, you know, when we look at agenda items. But I think that's probably a productive way to go. Because also, you know, council are very eager for both advisory bodies to, you know, work more concurrently together on those items. So certainly this one, because it is such a big number, you want to make sure that both committees are understanding, you know, what each is asking for, where the money's going. It works.
1:29:30 It would be helpful for our staff as well to put those applications together. Yeah, that's a good idea. Is that an issue at all for the town that it follows Veterans Day? No, the packet would be out that following Thursday. We'd have that report available. As I said, after October 21, we're pretty much ready to go. But I kind of like the idea of not overloading the Recreation Commission schedule. They usually go for a little bit long.
1:30:05 So I think we can host it. Hopefully in the morning it would still allow the public to participate. That's the only concern. If we wanted to look at having an afternoon meeting on the Tuesday, that might be a way to encourage more public input if we so desire as well. So it's up to the committee. We could meet at 2 and then have that workshop at 3. We'll start later and involve the public a bit.
1:30:32 Because I think it's a really good opportunity for the public to kind of see that presentation be presented, weigh in on it before it does go to council as well. So we would be seeking council's acceptance of that report and certainly be interested in what the committee and commission's recommendations are moving forward. As Don said, there's a whole next phase that really needs to be addressed. A lot of really detailed thinking, trying to understand what this thing is. Right. How we want to eat the apple.
1:31:00 When would this go before council? So if it was November 12th that we looked at, it's probably going to be that first meeting in December. Okay. Yep. They would go, their first meeting, oh, in December, I see. The council. Oh, yeah. Yep. They do have a meeting on the 20th, but it wouldn't happen then, huh? Yeah, we couldn't turn around the staff report. It's staff reports. The agenda bill is usually due that Monday previously, so if it's the 20 means it has to be ready on that 11th.
1:31:33 Which is now Tuesday, so we wouldn't meet until Tuesday. And I think we need a little bit of time to put kind of that package together for council. Yeah, so it looks like it's probably the 4th of December that we'd probably go to council. So let's do rec commission meets on the 5th? Correct. And then we would meet on the 12th. Do you think, as you mentioned, the public would be more likely to be able to attend if it were an afternoon workshop rather than in the morning? What is your general feeling about that?
1:32:04 So that we are making this... Yeah, most workshops, you know, certainly meetings are always later in the day, a little bit easier to get people to, so it's the end of the day for some, and before folks have to go to work, maybe for their night shifts. So, I mean, that 4 o'clock period is always pretty good, or 5 o'clock, you know, for an hour or something like that. So maybe we would meet at 3, could be, or 2, I mean, that's up to you, and then maybe we could start this workshop at 4 o'clock on the 12th.
1:32:34 Do you have a feeling another way on what would be best in the morning? We actually haven't talked about other discussion items yet either for us. Right. Yeah. You know, I don't have a feeling for it. I think either works for me. Yeah, I mean, yeah, personally, either one works for me. I think for the public. Yeah. We've had some pretty good turnout here. Yes, we have. You know, we usually have. In the morning. In the mornings. I would think especially on these topics we've had pretty good turnout.
1:33:06 I think we will. We can ask you, public. I would think so. Public, do you have a feeling on when would be a better time for us to have an open session? Whenever you meet, I will. So that's a great answer. What about you, Mark? I'm also thinking about all the people that don't show up that would like to. It might be easier for them in the afternoon. Is it?
1:33:33 It's also a holiday weekend. Yeah. Oh, and people getting back. Tuesday morning will be like a Monday morning. That's my one worry that everyone's going to get back to. That's a good point. And it might be a good idea to try doing it in the afternoon because then see if we get a different turnout or more turnout. We know Julianna's going to be. Yeah, yeah. Well, maybe meet at 2 and have our discussion items because I do have a couple of other things. Okay. Just move through two hours. And then note the workshop for 4 o'clock. 4 o'clock. There you go. So if you finish it, you get a break.
1:34:03 So we're starting 2. 2 o'clock. November 12. And that would be one you'd have to make sure that people notice that our regular meeting has this change later that day. Okay. And then. So proposing 4 to 6 joint workshop. Yeah, I think that's a good idea. Yeah. Just on this one study, I think that'll be great. Beautiful. Yeah. Very productive. We can publicize it.
1:34:32 Yeah. Now, one of the things we'll be having before that would be that discussion of... The advisory bodies. The advisory bodies, yeah, the taxing advisory bodies or whatever. So I don't know that we'd want to invite to measure our folks in for that too. I don't know.
1:34:55 I mean, you know, if our efficiency would work. So this becomes a larger workshop. It just becomes a larger workshop, and it gets kind of unfocused that way. That's the only thing where you know when that happens. But that's still something we probably need. Yeah. Yeah, we still need our... But I agree with you on separate workshop. Yeah, I haven't even talked about that with the Recreation Commission yet, so I'm not too sure. But I think it's...
1:35:21 I think it's relevant for each committee to discuss it first in their own context. Okay. So we would go ahead with our discussion. And if they wanted to sit in the audience, they could. Yeah, but I think, yeah. All right, then. So I guess... Yeah, so Chair, I think what you could do now is if you look at attachment A, we can kind of go through each of those proposed applications. And if there's consensus, the committee can kind of, you know, indicate that if you want to...
1:35:53 Make a motion. That was probably, I would think, probably the best way to go, I think, for these items for Council. So we could go through each item, understanding that the numbers are still, you know, TBD. I mean, they're probably the best estimates right now. I think they're pretty close. But we're looking at one special event trolley funding. You can see how much we've spent previously.
1:36:25 Which I think is about $14,000 to $15,000 I think on that consent. So we're asking for a consistent amount of money. And what we're trying to build in there is something that the, say for instance, the Mammoth Half Marathon utilised those funds for those supplemental trolleys, which is good. So we're building in additional funds for those reasons. The special event support, so that's really looking at probably
1:36:49 Purchases of items, you know, whether that's going to be those tablets for the surveys or whether they're going to be other items that we can kind of consider, that may or may not come forward. We just have to really kind of dig into that a little bit more. So that does not include staff support at all? Staff time? No. What we discovered from the analysis I've done so far, we collect just under $6,000 of event permit fees and it costs town staff just under $60,000 too.
1:37:17 That's what I figured. I was going to say because my comment here was enough and I was thinking it was staff support, so obviously not. That's a bigger question, yeah. So we're not really asking for any supplemental funds for that program because, you know, in that whole discussion, you know, do we look at having an event coordinator? Is it something, you know, larger? I mean, that's a bigger discussion. So this may or may not, you know, come through at this time, depending where that goes.
1:37:42 The role of rink operations and enhancements, so that's a two-year application, so R would balance the other remaining funds, so a $30,000 application would cover two years of operations. And what we've put in here as well is the umbrellas that we have at that rink isn't really kind of working too well, so what we're looking at is just kind of erecting a shade structure or some material just over that kind of
1:38:11 Seating area where the chairs are currently right now. You know, pending where that whole big process goes for the rink, the whole shade, you know, that's a separate one. But this is just a smaller cost that we can kind of make that a little bit more amenable for our summer visitors. It's really hot and there's just no shade there at all. So that's all that would be, just a material we can kind of string up. We can frame it ourselves, nominal cost. So it wouldn't be something that would stay during the winter? No, we'd pull it down.
1:38:40 So just be for summer only. So not designed to handle snow load? Nope, not at all. Okay. Yep. Just a shade structure. And that's really it. Just be additional costs for amenities and things like that. And is there a reason that they wouldn't just request all the funds from Measure R? Well, historically, again, it could be a discussion you can have with the R, you know, but we're going to make $15,000 application into R as a recreation and then into U as those recreation funds.
1:39:07 That's how the previous application came before you two years ago because it's both a recreation facility. But we are planning on having a joint workshop to go through all of the proposals, particularly the joint ones. No, I don't want to read about all of the trails and park stuff and all the rest. I don't want to go through all of those, but we're going to have a joint one and we could discuss some of those kinds of things then.
1:39:37 Where it's appropriate. But, you know, actually, Drea's question's a very good one because it looks to the longer question of maintenance. Yes. And because that means we're going to be splitting 50% of the maintenance of each of any. Those kinds of things. Of any recreation project down the road, which means that if you just carry this out to its logical conclusion, pretty much.
1:39:59 80% of our money will be going towards recreation someday. So that's actually a very good question you've asked, I think. Just for your background, I believe that we are assuming, I don't think we ever made a decision on it, but I think we've kind of accepted the measure, the way the measure our committee does it, that whatever the maintenance is, we accept that cost as a future ongoing cost. Isn't that correct, Stu?
1:40:28 Yeah, and that's included. So the only obligation you have so far is just your Whitmore track contribution, which is a third of that maintenance cost. There's no maintenance cost built in for the ice rink that Measure U or Measure R is incurring. So that's all Melloruce and general fund. But I think the question's a good one because maybe there is at some point in time, as we evaluate our matrix each year and trying to figure out where our money's going, if it's all going towards recreation or a lot of it's going towards recreation, and especially if they end up being.
1:40:57 Maintenance cost, as soon as the track is going to be, that's a pretty big one. I think we funded the majority, a huge part of that track, didn't we? 450,000 of the 1.4 million. Okay. So, about a third. And I think that is a good conversation, because I don't think we should assume that we're taking on maintenance. Taking on maintenance of those things. Yeah, I think, if I recall, and I'm trying to dig back to when we were...
1:41:25 Talking about all of this originally, I don't think we were assuming maintenance, I think we were, but we were looking for as part of the applications, they needed to define and identify how are they going to pay for maintenance and not necessarily assume Measure U was going to do it. Right, we never had that discussion actually carried to its end and make it. Yeah, so we should. You're right. We should. But I'm afraid the assumption has been there. Yeah, so maybe we need to jump up and down and say.
1:41:52 Wait, we're not assuming maintenance just because of this. We want to know how you're going to pay for maintenance. And that could be, that could influence, that's a leveraging. If you come to us and say, we've got maintenance covered, we may be more willing to invest in the upfront cost. That's good. No, you're absolutely right. Because it's worrisome. Yeah, I agree. We could be swallowed up. And that's kind of my fears about this other committee, you know, handling.
1:42:17 The mixture of the two committees all of a sudden, you know, you and mobility, I mean, the arts and culture and mobility might all of a sudden just kind of go away. Yeah, agreed. Which we don't need to see. Okay, so that's a good future discussion too. So clarification on how maintenance costs are handled. And you'll see that in the application if there's any. Like I said, for these ones, we're not building in any maintenance, ongoing maintenance costs. Okay.
1:42:44 We talked about the wayfinding. We talked about Main Street. We talked about event acquisition. We talked about the, just briefly, the annual obligation for the track. And then that's the annual administration cost for that fund. And that's really it. So... Administration cost of the whole fund. That's correct. So it's 4% of the $802,000 is what we use. So that would include... That's my time. That's also the reconciliation and the compliance audit. Okay. So this time...
1:43:15 So I'm trying to understand the committee's recommendations. So the trolley is moving forward, I understand. The event support in some format will move forward. The rink operations, municipal wayfinding, is it committee? The real rink operations, what? That was number three. That was number three. Yeah, answering Drea's question. Well, there's no maintenance in there, so it's just operating. No, no, no. Her question actually was, is this something that maybe should...
1:43:46 Be going to measure our committee. Directly to measure our. Yeah. Well, it is. All of it is what your question was, yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I think that's what you'll probably discuss on December 3rd. Because you're putting something on the town. The town this time is just applying. We can't obligate the Recreation Commission to consider all those funds. So that's the problem, right? You'll have to meet with the commission.
1:44:15 On December 3rd. So when the applications close, that's when you'll meet. That was the purpose of the meeting. Then you can decide, well, if you collectively agree and say, well, I really think all these funds should just go to Measure R. You're going to discuss it then rather than make a recommendation to the town. Right. Yeah, so what you really do is, yeah. And the application will be the same for both. It's just, right, one's 15. It's a total of 60. I think that's up to the committees to decide.
1:44:43 Municipal wayfinding, I believe there was consensus to move that one forward, is that right? Probably in a modified form, I don't know how modified. I think we gave her enough feedback that we'll see what she comes forward, what she can create and come forward with. I don't know what all tools there is. There is a way to split that big phase. Main street, I don't believe there was consensus for that, is that right at this point?
1:45:13 Again, she can bring forward the application, but there's no promises. Okay, so you're okay moving forward the application. Okay. Bring it forth. And then we have the council know it's there. Right. Yeah, that's probably true. Well, and that gives us the opportunity to give feedback to what we think about seeing that and have it be part of the public process. Exactly. So at this point, we don't suggest that they change it or anything, but we've given the feedback that at this point, we're not one of them.
1:45:41 Yeah, don't count on it, but this is our opportunity to publicly give feedback on this after we get all the information from them. I think our message, it sounds like we're all kind of saying, you know what, we want some tangible stuff. I know that these are, you know, these are part of a capital project planning that has to happen, but right now we're thinking the public wants to see tangible stuff. And this is a good way for us to put out
1:46:07 We can think about this before council or somebody else comes back and says, Measure U needs to fund that. I think we all agree we would like to do something with Main Street, but we would also like to have some event venues, and we would also like to, and that's what it gets down to. It's our opportunity to prioritize. And then number six, we talked about setting aside $300,000 for future event asset acquisition.
1:46:35 Does that sound? I think that's fine. I think that's a very reasonable. Well, and I think because we can compare it to the trails. Yeah. It's exactly kind of a straight comparison there to the trails. And I think it's comparable. Uh-huh. And the council can kind of, they won't forget. Relate to the number. They'll relate to the number. Relate to the number. Exactly. And I think it works for the other side, too. It's our version of trails. Yep. Yep. Exactly. And then hopefully measure our will.
1:47:02 Make the same type of recommendation. And then we'll have a popular one. We'll see. So as we said, so this is really the first filter. So really what we're saying here is that the motion from the Measure U Committee is to recommend town staff move forward with presenting these applications for consideration in the upcoming fall awards. That's really all we're recommending. And then the council will review this on November 6th. And they might tell us otherwise.
1:47:30 That's the motion that we want to put forward at this time. And you might, I don't know, can you notice or put a little note in there that we would like to see maybe four and five kind of modified somewhat? Yep. Because I think that's a good point. And we talked about leverage of funds. Yeah. Yeah. Otherwise it just seems like a waste of everybody's time that we're saying. Yeah. Just the way you've got it. Because she got the message that we weren't that thrilled with it the way it was.
1:48:01 So does any committee member want to make a motion on that request? So it's a motion to recommend the town council direct staff to submit the applications as identified in attachment A. I'll move. I'll move. Okay. So move. Okay. So member Hogan, motions. I'll second. Second. 20 seconds. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Thank you. So let's vote.
1:48:29 So the next step is the application evaluation material. So we have two application forms. So the traditional form that we've used previously would be used for anything other than events. That's how it kind of stands right now. So I don't know if there's any comments on that. So we can kind of go through that application form if you desire. We also have the Measure U project filter and checklist. The question that staff are bringing forward is how are we evaluating
1:49:02 The event application forms, are they going to be filtered against the project filter and checklist, or how do we want to make those evaluations? We do have a little bit of time, obviously, at least a couple of meetings, to work on that, which to me, I know in the past, I went back and found old notes on it, and it's really kind of an awkward form, period. It's the filter? Yeah, a bit of the filter. We spent an hour and a half.
1:49:33 Going through, I think, on that second part of it, and then all we did was ranking for discussion purposes. It's like, there's a better way to do it. We can flip coins, we can pull straws, we can do a lot of stuff. So that one, maybe, if we could look at that maybe the next time and go home and really make some notes on this. I like the idea of having the filter and checklisted. I think it just needs to be overhauled a little bit. Maybe there's two.
1:50:03 Two different ones, one for the events application, one for the regular application. This was a carryover from the... And I've watched them do the same thing, kind of go in and just waste time. You know, our committee time and the public's time is worth something. So maybe, I just know that the filters... Yeah, that probably is appropriate for a separate conversation, though, because I don't know that my brain could process all this. Exactly.
1:50:34 Yeah, also for the meeting and maybe even December. We don't need it until what, January? Well, that's a good point. When the applications show up. We have a little time on that part. That's a good point. Yeah, the application part, I did have a couple of notes on it. If I could just touch on this, Stu has a measure. Are the committee thought at all about revamping this as well? I mean, is there any...
1:51:05 They chose not to at this time, probably due to more time restraints than anything else. I mean, if we were to create something that is obviously something that we could invite Measure U to use as well, if they found it helpful, rather than trying to reinvent the wheel on two different sides. Yeah, that packet of information is in front of Council tomorrow to be approved, which is part of that filter and checklist, so as far as the Recreation Commission understands.
1:51:37 That, you know, Council will authorise to approve. That's how they're going to evaluate the application. So if we want to say in our recommendations to Town Council that we understand that the filter and checklist is a carryover but would still like to consider revising it for the, you know, upcoming process, we can certainly say that. We just have to get it back to them again. Is ours being okay tomorrow? No, yours is November 6th. Oh, I see.
1:52:05 Okay. So, remember. So, we could do everything but the project filter and checklist, and then we can consider that on the 12th, and then take it back to them in December, which is still before. Yeah. Before we'd actually need to use it. Correct. Yeah. So, that would probably be how we'd present it. And I'm sure they would understand. That sounds. Yeah. I like that. Okay. Yeah, because it's kind of. Juliana. I actually have a question. It's on Measure U event application form page 5, at the very top.
1:52:34 So looking at the event applications, I think it's the last item. I double-sided this, so it kind of came out weird.
1:53:04 But the fall event application, but I don't see a template for the budget, and aren't we, isn't this opening for, in November? So we should have that template as part of that, because when we meet with the town to go over the application process, we need to have that. And I don't know that the task force developed a template. The only template that we would use is the one that we had last year. I don't know if that's satisfactory to use. We haven't.
1:53:31 Actually started discussing the event application. I know we're going to get there, Julie. Sorry. You're just super-duper efficient. The only reason I ask is because we did make some changes in the event application that may need to be reflected in the budget template because of what's allowed. What page was that? Fourth. That was page five of six. It's just at the top. It's the fourth bullet down from the top, yes.
1:54:05 Yeah, because I remember we wanted a template, yeah, yeah. And the template we used last year, I mean, that was a form that we pulled off an Internet as a template. The other option is to actually just say, you know, provide in a QuickBooks or we can provide in, you know, something like an Excel spreadsheet, but we just wanted to try and get something to them to use. Just trying to try and standardize something. I think you should leave it open.
1:54:30 That way, as far as what the format is, because QuickBooks can roll that out for you easily, I just think you should give them basic categories of revenue and expenses, rather than defining what they are for them. So basic categories of ticket sales, bar sales, of revenue, categories of expenses, marketing, talent, infrastructure, whatever. So maybe we'll just identify that as kind of a template.
1:55:00 Just identify all revenue sources, historic expenditures, separate pages, and a final page would be your net of the event. Because, you know, we do, you've seen some of those applications and they don't really come through. I couldn't force the Hop and Sage budget into the exact template you have. Okay. Yeah. So, and I think other people probably have the same problem. Okay. So you're okay just to kind of leave it open as long as they identify all their revenue, all their budgeted expenses?
1:55:28 I'm okay with that if it's a very basic P&L look. And say in a P&L format. Okay. You can do that. Got to go back to the application. We just got out of order. So we're out of order, yeah. So I don't know. So it looks like we'll any changes or any recommendations to the current application form, I guess is kind of where we're at. Yes, I have a number of them. On attachment B. Yep.
1:56:01 It looked pretty good to me right to section B. Yeah, on the San Diego area in the general Measure U application? Yeah. Yeah, that looked a section. I would just suggest just to make it a little more efficient or any of the ones that are in this not applicable for programming, capital requests only, maybe be put together, lumped together.
1:56:26 You know, whether you put bars on top and bars below. So in other words, 3, 4, 5, 7, and 9 are all capital requests only. So that for ease of anybody that's just doing it for programming, I'm sorry, page 4 and 5 and 6, maybe even 7. But any of those, you see what I'm saying, just kind of, you see us do just kind of lump them together to make them more than anybody that's going for programming has a whole maybe a page or two they just skip. Yeah.
1:56:56 Okay. And then I would say anywhere, let's see there, anywhere it says event, I would say line it out. Oh, yep. Yep, because we have events. Usually it says project, program, project, but once in a while it's project, program, or event, and we're going to get rid of the event issues. Yep. Okay. Because we have, yeah, you know, just to. Separate application. Yeah, because we have a whole separate one now. And then section C, I think all I did was just say delete.
1:57:28 Any of the ones that said event again. Yeah. And on the next page, Project D, Section D, I did have a question because I don't know if large special events should be in there or not. You know, on line two, you can see you can get rid of event. Yeah. Okay. So it's just top two projects. Kind of a question. Do you think we should keep that in there or not?
1:58:02 Just even the large tier events go in the other application? Well, for instance, Mammoth Motocross, I mean, or sorry, Kamikaze, yeah. Would they go through the traditional event application form, I'm assuming, or would you request they go through here? I mean, staff would need to know that when we meet them. That would be my question, yeah. And then what's that threshold for an application? Well, you know, that was kind of my question. That's a good question. That feasibility study is a good template.
1:58:31 For the business plan we're requesting out of the event application. And I agree it should only be for the large events, but maybe we use that as a template for the, or a modified version of that as the template for the business plan requested for the large events in the event application. So it can serve two purposes, but it should be, does that make sense? Yeah, I think you're.
1:58:58 I think getting what I was trying to do. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But we just need to simplify for the applicant's purposes. So maybe you just modify the feasibility study so it's a...
1:59:16 It's an attachment or amendment to both applications. Yes. Or a section of both applications. It's just modified for the events. Or just stick that one line. Feasibility studies will be required for large special events. Yeah. And then give them this as the template for the feasibility study. Ah. I see what you're saying. I see what you're saying. Yeah. For consistency. Well, in the special event application.
1:59:45 I think it asks for a business plan. It's just kind of the same thing. Does it? Okay. Who would apply using this one? Kamikaze. What threshold would you be looking at? For instance, $50,000, $100,000, when you say Lodge? When they're asking, you mean for the ask, relative to the ask? Yeah, because it's going to have to be some... $5,000.
2:00:06 I was bringing it down. I was exactly bringing it down because I've been thinking about a couple of them we had that were awful big. Are you suggesting a new bullet under five that is a feasibility study for events above a threshold? Yeah. Yeah. I like that. Is that the way we would handle it? Yep. So it's a new bullet on page five perhaps? Of the? Two.
2:00:32 Of the events. Five, submit a proposed event budget business plan, that includes. Yeah. So is that a bullet there that adds a feasibility study for you? I'm on page five here, or. You know, I would leave that, I would leave that as is, but add an additional four events over X, over 25,000 or whatever number, provide a feasibility study. So perhaps this is number six.
2:01:01 Sure, yeah. You're on page five of which one? The event application? The event application. It starts on page four, submit a proposal at budget and business plan. And there are a number of bullets under it. Feasibility study could go under there, or perhaps there is a number six that is feasibility study for events over. Yeah, okay, yep.
2:01:25 I like that. I do too, because it spells it out very clearly. Yeah, and there's been so much attention paid to this application, I wouldn't want to mess with anything that's there, but adding a line is okay. Yep, I would agree. I'm sure Juliana and the task force would approve.
2:01:45 And if it's $24,999, they still got to do it. What do you think, $25,000? What do you think, $25,000 or lower? I think $25,000. $25,000 is reasonable? Yeah. Considering what we saw in the applications that came in last year. I would go, yeah, I would agree. Make them think twice. Okay, yeah, exactly. Well, now,
2:02:12 Brian and Rebecca are certainly over 25. We don't need a feasibility study out of them. These are new events. This is for new applications going forward. Their application, I think, was for 12. That's right. This is for applications going forward. I think any application requiring 25 is needed. I think that's the threshold. That's the threshold. I think that's easy. And use the same project feasibility section D that we have. It probably needs a little tweak in just to...
2:02:41 Yeah, I'm just going to say the heading would be feasibility study, applicants requesting 25,000 and over are required to complete, you know, section, whatever will happen, part three or whatever is in appendix, but it will be section D of the application. No, that's good, I think. Am I correct in understanding that this other, the basic fall application form is not revamped because we don't have as many...
2:03:14 People applying for the funds and it just didn't need. Well, because it actually seemed to work pretty well. Yeah, it works pretty well. For capital especially and for some programming type of stuff. You know, some of the town applications and things like that. I felt like it. But what happened was all of a sudden the events went from, I don't know whether it was 8 or 10 to 15 or 20 or whatever. And we realized the application was just very.
2:03:39 Clumsy. It was also a different animal. So for special events. Yeah. But this one I thought.
2:03:46 Pretty well for me. You know, it's for the reviewers and for the people that apply. You know, there's probably a little bit of duplication in parts. But I think Joyce was suggesting perhaps we ought to look at the feasibility study because would we expect to see architect and planning costs and acquisition costs? There's a number of things under the current feasibility study that probably doesn't apply for events. So in other words, page 10 would have to be really tweaked.
2:04:16 We'll page 9. 9. 9. 9. 9. 9 cost analysis. I think question 1's fine. I think question 2's good. I think question 3's good. I think 4's great. I think 5's fine. I don't know about 6. That's where I think we start looking at. So I think 6 is not relevant. But a cost analysis probably appropriate. These are just not the appropriate items to be in it. Yeah.
2:04:48 So there's a revised version of this that's an attachment to the events application. Is that something we can do on the fly here? Well, Stu will probably come up with a draft. Yeah, let's ask Stu for a draft. Yeah, I can do it. Do you want it to go into the packet for November 6? Because it's the application form, so it really has to. So I'm okay. I'm okay revising. I mean, we can quickly go through it. I mean, land acquisition costs. I mean, hopefully that's not going to be the case for... Well, and that's part of...
2:05:17 No. We don't fund in. Absolutely. Equipment acquisition. That's right. Probably no because it's owned by the town. Site prep demo. That's it. No. Entitlement cost no. Architect no. Construction cost no. Is everybody going to be operational costs? Yes, because I think we said we accepted operational costs. That's it. Yeah. That's it. Maintenance costs. And programming costs. Yeah. Those two. That's it. It's basic. Plus other.
2:05:43 Operation programming another. Yep. So there you go. That was done. That was easy. Good. That's pretty forward. Feasibility analysis. Don't mind those. Multicenario. I don't know. I don't know about this one. I don't know if that's too much detail for the scenario. What are you looking at? Number two. Multicenario. Multicenario platformers. I think that's. I think the assumptions is probably pretty good understanding what could happen and what variables exist with their budgeting through events. Risk analysis.
2:06:16 I think that's almost the same as assumptions. But it's good to have that, I think. Yeah, I know, at least risk analysis. Makes me think through it. Yeah. Project schedule. Project schedule is probably okay. Because the risk is a big conversation. Quality of life analysis. For events, yeah. So really, I'm just taking out, you know. And that's a good place to start. If we overhaul it more later, that's fine. That's a good start. I think it may scare everybody off from asking for more than 25,000. Exactly.
2:06:44 So that brings you to E. So now we're back to, I don't know if you had any comments on the performance report. It's been a pretty standard form. I don't know if we really need to change that too much. It seems to be working well. It's very generic. Ten questions, I think that's pretty reasonable to ask. Yep, I didn't have any notes. I think it works pretty well. Yep. And then our homework will go over that. Yeah.
2:07:19 Filters. Just start making some comments and kind of figuring. So we'll add the filters to the next meeting schedule. Yeah. It'll be November 12. Yep. So we're up to the event application form itself. We did change, modify page 5 already. So we added the, that kind of template that we talked about and we also added that feasibility study we just revised. Any other comments? Yeah, there's, like I said, there has been so much time put into this and.
2:07:51 Changes and recommendations made, I'd like to see it run for a cycle and see if it works. I agree. We need to do that. Because they did a good job on it. I do believe. With those two little ads. I like that. Any comment from the public on those items at all? Chair, or? I just have a public comment. I applaud the work that the committee's been doing and carefully looking at.
2:08:28 the at least preliminary proposed applications and setting aside money for a venue. However, you at this point with these numbers are operating in the red like the federal government. So you have to think very carefully about and I'm sure you will about how money is allocated. At this point there is not much for events and there's also not much for arts and culture and I just wanted to share
2:08:55 Some quotes with you about arts and culture, because arts and culture is not always an event. A season of music, a season of theater, an arts program that runs over a period of time is not necessarily an event and would not necessarily apply into those restrictions in Measure U. I would just like to say that in my own philanthropy and business endeavors, I have seen the critical role that the arts play in stimulating creativity and in developing
2:09:25 Vital communities. The arts have a crucial impact on our economy and are an important catalyst for learning, discovery and achievement in our country. That statement was made by Paul Allen of Microsoft. Lyndon Johnson on signing into existence the National Endowment for the Arts said, Art is a nation's most precious heritage for it is in our works of art that we reveal to ourselves and to others the inner vision which guides us as a nation and when there is no vision the people perish.
2:09:58 And last, Maria Shriver, artist fundamental, unique to each of us. Even in difficult economic times, especially in difficult economic times, the arts are essential. Mark Deeds, speaking as just a member of the public. I too applaud the efforts that have gone into the entire application process.
2:10:35 The project filter process, the efforts of the task force in providing the recommendations that they've brought forth. I do understand the importance of oversight and guidelines and the concerns of preventing the major U funds being spent not to the best uses.
2:11:06 I get that. As you know, I spoke previously in opposition or out of concern of the restriction of first year, one-time events not getting any funding and then the restriction of quote-unquote for-profit events funding guidelines being reduced from 30% to 10%. And I understand the reasoning behind those restrictions.
2:11:34 I just would ask that in the continued discussions and deliberations with, you know, adopting the revisions that not to overcorrect the application and its checklists, town council and its recommendations to the then assigned eight member Measure U application steering committee who created the document that's in front of you now.
2:12:02 It was their job to arrive at this document and a big piece of their job was to interpret the voters' intent and I think they did a pretty good job in acknowledging that. I would hate to see a process that has worked in large part get corrected to a point where you might be missing some unforeseen unintended consequences of the restrictions. I think that
2:12:32 When you have a passionate, committed person or group of people that want to bring forth an event, and what is the signal or the message that's being sent if we're not going to fund you because you just happen to be a first-year event or that, yes, you're leveraging.
2:12:52 $75,000 of your own money, either personal finances or through sponsorships, but we're not going to contribute anymore 30% because that's what it says. And I do understand that what will be arrived at is only a guideline, but I would like to see additional conversations being given, and I realize this is probably as much as I could hope to achieve.
2:13:20 Put an asterisk next to the for-profit funding criteria similarly to what you've done with the first time and the one-time events by saying no funding, but if you have a compelling presentation, then we'll consider it. That, I think, is fair. The onus of a special event has is pretty amazing. This application,
2:13:50 Process is not a flimsy one, as I think you can all attest, but the checklists are pretty stringent, and the committee still, I believe, has to reach a unanimous opinion to move it forward to council for approval, so just continue doing what you're doing, but I hate to see the door closed on these opportunities. At least leave the door open a little bit and make the event producer
2:14:19 You know, do a, complete a solid, strong, very strong application and presentation. Let them, let them prove their, you know, the value of what they're bringing forward. And then say no. But my fear is that if we close the door, then you'd be limiting a lot of, you know, passionate, potential, very creative and successful events from coming forward. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Any other questions?
2:14:49 No comments from the committee? It's always good advice, don't overcorrect. Good driving. So do we have any, Stu, should we move on then with a motion to approve? Yes, I drafted a motion, Chair, so the motion would be to approve the 2013 Measure U Fall Award application material, not the evaluation material, including the event application form and town funding applications. Would somebody like to make a motion?
2:15:23 Would somebody like to approve? I'll make that a motion. I won't repeat all those words. I'll second it. Okay, there you go. A question there is that takes out the filter? That's correct, yes. I took out the evaluation. Yeah, because we're going to work on that ourselves. So all in favor of voting on the motion, approve the motion? Aye. Great.
2:15:53 Approval automation. Good job. Good. Thank you. So shall we move on then to the manager's report, Stu, please? I didn't really have anything. I spoke briefly about the reconciliation process, which is kind of our big item right now. I invited the Monon County Group to speak forward, and I think this is a great little program that we can also communicate with our funding applicants as well.
2:16:22 That's all I really had. As I said, Measure U, reconciliation is kind of being finalised. We're now just kind of working through the fund balance, so we'll have that at your next meeting, understand what we're looking at funding or the amount available. And as I said, all these items will go before November 6th in regards to Town Council, and then when we get to request for discussion items, I've got them listed down, so we'll be able to get through that when we get there. That's all I have. All right, thank you. Any committee member reports?
2:16:56 I did sit in the corner at one of Juliana's event coalition meetings, mainly to hear about the sprung structure, which certainly has potential, but at the same time I learned that they're wrestling with structure for that event coalition, and if they happen to have fees or money or anything, how do they handle it? So they're in a growing process that's needed, and it'll become a stronger organization, I think.
2:17:27 It's maturing. All right. Thank you. And I know we have some requests for discussion items and proposals for our November meeting. And I even have some for beyond that. Okay. Should we begin the November meeting? And we have tentatively set the time for 2 p.m. on November 12th? So I had the advisory body. Yeah, discussion.
2:18:03 The consolidation of the advisory body discussion. The HVS presentation would actually be at four with that joint presentation. Okay, so, okay, the HVS is at four. Yep. Okay. And then the other item there was the project filter. Yeah, the project filter. We were talking about, what was that first one you said? We had the advisory body. Advisory body. Yep, the advisory body. And that was November. Property filter form. And I might have that information available on the special event.
2:18:35 Kind of review. It's kind of, it goes through the 40, 39 permits that the town reviews annually, and then the costs incurred from the town to produce those. That might be a bigger discussion. Anyway, I'm just going to see if we can kind of get that ready for that time. If not, we can push it along. Now, with the capital reserve, the site acquisition, we will be discussing that and taking action. Will that be an action item that we will, before we go into our meeting?
2:19:06 I thought we were just asking staff to bring it forward as an application. Do we need to do more than that? Hmm. No. I don't think so. Okay, so bring it forward as an application. Yeah, bringing it forward as an application and keeping it simple and just saying. Right. Creating the reserve. But we would make, this would be in our regular meeting, and we would make a motion to.
2:19:32 We've already, I believe, recommended it today. Okay. Yeah. The town will make the Measure U application for it. Okay. Yeah. Staff review it with the other Measure U applications. Okay. So still bring that forward and that'll be at our 4 o'clock meeting then more, huh? Well, no, that's going to be a Measure U application from staff to create that reserve. Okay. So that's, so any discussion about how all that gets managed or, you know, everything else we could have separately, but that piece is already done.
2:20:01 So we don't have that at November meeting. Well, that's just setting up the wedge. But that's not all of the management. Exactly, but just to see the... So there's a placeholder. That'll be December 3rd, I think, when you'll kind of meet collectively to kind of look over those. Okay, okay. A couple of things that we're kind of hanging out there for future, whether it's November or other meetings, we may not have time on November, nor maybe they...
2:20:31 Are they pressing? But I would say, like, one of the ones, Joyce, would be that we talked about the maintenance considerations. You just made me think about that, yeah. And I don't know if that's, you know, is that something we need to talk about in November? Can we put that off till anywhere? I just don't see any big maintenance costs in this upcoming fall award that the committee needs to address. I think it would just be a policy discussion in the future. That's what I need, a policy discussion for the future. Okay, so it's a future policy discussion. That's a good way to look at it.
2:20:59 And I would say one of the things that also is kind of hanging out there, and I heard that question, there was an assumption that we might do spring applications just like Measure R, and it's like, oh my. You know, I just don't know. You know, personally, I, but I think we probably want to settle that, have that a policy discussion too. I know that we talked about it before, and I think this is before you guys were on. Well, the conversation was the
2:21:28 What does Bill call it? The oopsertunity? Oopsertunity, yeah. Or, you know, or something comes, an emergency. Well, I heard that kind of being pushed that we should do it. The measure our meeting or the rec commission is like, well, wait a minute. This is kind of a discussion we need to have. Yeah. A policy discussion. And we haven't talked about it. Again, I would say maybe call that a future policy one. Yeah.
2:21:55 One thing we haven't talked about and it's probably more appropriate once we get all of our reports back is this whole issue of seed money and the repayment issues to see if that money is repaid. We had a big application that their pledge was to repay. And so that's kind of like future also. And then one of the things that kind of came forward out of that report was just a suggested item, maybe again for future discussion.
2:22:23 Your event coordinator, how that's funded, suggestions for funding, but, you know, and that probably goes with your permits. Okay. What is that a part of MLR? Is that... Well, no, it's... That whole discussion is... It's tough.
2:22:43 Yeah, it's tough. Yeah, so a lot of these things are going on, but I think these are things we want to keep in mind. Yes. Because I know you guys, it's kind of hanging there in our mind, but sometimes it slips in mine. Yes. So I think we want to not, they may not be pressing this time, but we don't want to lose sight of them. But I think you need to keep, since Drea and I haven't been part of those past discussions, you need to keep them before us, too. Yes, I'm thinking, yeah, because it's nice to have new eyes and new thoughts. Be aware of it. Yeah, yeah. Okay. Thank you. So those are just futures.
2:23:12 Any other requests for discussion items for the next November meeting? And Stu, do you think we will have enough time if we start at two, then to the joint workshop at four? Or would it behoove us at all to start a little bit earlier and have a break? No, I think you're okay. I think it just encourages a very... Yeah, I think it... Feel free to nudge me under the table if I... You're doing an excellent job.
2:23:42 Very good. All right, then, so we'll adjourn to the special meeting with the Recreation Commission to review the 2013 Measure U funding applications on Tuesday, December 3rd. But, of course, we've now added the November 12th meeting at 2 o'clock, followed by the 4 to 6 joint workshop with RNU and presentation of the report.
2:24:12 Do we have a motion to adjourn today's meeting? So moved. I'll second. All right. Motion by Sandy Hogan, seconded by Joyce Turner. Is that all in favor? Aye.