Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 1 hr 31 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
187 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Yeah, I mean, how about 1849? 1849 has a ban. Yes, and they get one pass. Sell them another pass at 150, right? And they got two VIP passes, I guess, at the time. Makes sense, I think, considering how it goes, you just kind of roll it out. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I think so. Yeah. There's a comment period for the shadier-esque audience VOA chain.
0:26 Runs out, I think, before our February meeting. Did we submit a comment? They did. Remember what I told you going into the process of what they were doing? They did exactly what I said they were going to do. Why go through all the frickin' meetings if they have a pre- and I promise you that was a pre-determined outcome. When Kazimirski hears me say that, he's going to get mad with me again.
0:57 Absolutely the truth. The snow community just gets hosed very hard on it. And the town in the long run, debt precludes us from going to the trail through the top and down, connect the Sherwin riding area to the rest of the riding area, as he suggests, their preferred alternative.
1:25 is to move the staging area out past the Shader's Park, build a whole new staging area, and not allow us the trails to ride into town. Don't be so negative, Bill. Wait, wait, wait. The problem is I'm waiting for you. How many of these processes?
1:48 The outcome was no different to the outcome of the Sharp Project. I could have told you going into that project once I saw the people who were participating. The snowmobiles would be closed out at that as well. I'm really the best one here. Well, no, today I'm not the last one. Well, I know.
2:17 Did all your teams win over the weekend? I wasn't rooting for any in particular, so. I was. Actually, New Orleans won, and I didn't expect them to, but I was rooting for that. So that was big. The Colts come back. One defensive player on the other team went down, and
2:47 As soon as he went down, boom, boom, boom. Yeah, one player. I have somebody's notebook here. Probably Don Zelney's. It is a Measure U. There you go. Okay, I will call this meeting of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission to order roll call, please. Mr. Eddich? Yes. Mr. Joax? Here. Mr. Turner? Hello. Vice Chair Seller? Yes. Chair Selser? Here.
3:25 Wait, my phone's talking to me. I don't think you can do that. It makes me want to check mine. It's turned off. It's public comment. It's trying to leave a public comment. Okay, someone needs to teach me how to get out of here. Look at all I've heard what you have up there. You need to clean that all out. Yeah, well, I was in meetings all out. My husband's going to have to clean his voicemail up. I can't get the phone, but it's gone.
4:09 I called the meeting to order and we've done a roll call. Public comments, this is the time of any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Good afternoon, Steve Spidell, MLTSCC Coordinator. I'd like to take a few minutes to kind of give a recap of the types of things we've been working on in the committee. Due to the holiday schedule, your meeting will precede ours, so we'll be having a meeting on the 13th.
4:41 And I did want to at least report to you what we've accomplished in December and what we're looking forward to doing in the new year. So number one, it was brought to our attention that Patagonia catalog, there's a picture of John Kazmierski wearing a Mammoth Lakes Trail System hat. So in strange ways, our marketing is getting out there and we're getting exposure. So pretty soon we'll be as recognizable as Coca-Cola.
5:09 1.5 million catalogs, I believe. That's a good number. The other thing I'm happy to report is our winter grooming program at Shady Rest Campground is in place. So now it's your job to vote for snow. Number three, the website management meetings have been ongoing and very encouraging. Our numbers are ever increasing as to more and more people are being driven to the website.
5:37 We are in the process of finalizing the new webpage development. We'll have approximately 180 maybe or so pages. Our final coordination efforts are ongoing. We've been working very closely with MLTPA and as a consultant to put that together. Our anticipation is within the next two weeks those pages will be ready to post and prior to the posting we'll probably take those to the trails committee.
6:07 and ask for the recommendation for approval for posting and they may then finally ask for the rec permission to approve that as well. That remains to be seen. In the meantime, we are going into the production of about 2,000 smart cards, little cards that will be distributed around for people to take their smartphones, as Bill Sauser has, and be able to take a picture of the QR code and it will drive them directly to the site on the back of the card.
6:36 is some text explaining that it's not an app and all the benefits that can be derived from visiting the website. The other thing we've been doing is trying to coordinate with the U.S. Forest Service on a number of projects. One of the ones that's come up that is new to us is the over-snow vehicle NEPA environmental assessment work that needs to be done on the forest. There are other forests in the area that have been part of a lawsuit. The local
7:04 District is trying to avoid being caught up in that, but they're looking at possibly $75,000 to $80,000 worth of needed funding over the next few years in order to meet those demands. So we're continuing to discuss that with the Forest Service. Draft assessment report has come out in regards to the forest plan. Town of Mammoth Lakes has made a comment to that plan and a letter was issued.
7:31 December 16th from the Town of Mammoth Lakes to the U.S. Forest Service speaking to the matters within the draft assessment. So if I can recap that, the comments basically have to do with recreation and specifically pointing out things such as the website memorandum of understanding, the trail system memorandum of understanding, and then
7:57 Over time, the capital improvement projects that have been going on, the need for continued over snow vehicle and off highway vehicle use, collaborations between the communities. So it's a two and a half page letter. I think it's very well written and that'll be part of the MLTSCC package that'll be going out this week. There is the next phase of that forest plan is the
8:30 Phase that's termed need for change and there will be a public meeting on January 30th from 5 in the evening till 9 o'clock in the evening down in Bishop at the main office where public comments can be taken in regards to the need for change. Currently there is a draft preliminary need for change.
8:54 And I would have to say that it's a somewhat generic document that's covering more than just one forest, but that also will be part of the committee package that will be going out this week for them to take a look at and review. There's ongoing efforts to work with Forest Service up in the Lakes Basin for restroom use and signage, making sure that people understand when they go up there.
9:22 What's open, what's not open, where they can use pit toilets, where the water toilets are closed. Also, there's ongoing effort for trash removal and making sure that people understand what dumpsters are open, what are closed and how to do that. The SHARP Environmental Resource Assessment has been completed over the summer and it's our understanding that that work was all taken care of within the summer. So the next phase, which
9:51 It has yet to be fully figured out by the Forest Service will be to start looking at the proposal itself and if there is a need for additional trail realignments. So we're monitoring that as well. The Shady Rest Saging Area, a decision that's just come out in regards to that. The Alternative No. 3, Modified, minus the Ride Back Trail for snowmobile and snowmobile parking.
10:20 is the preferred alternative. I'll be putting together some information again for the trails committee in regard to that and the process that's open at this point is the objection process. So if you are of record making comments earlier, you have the right to make additional comments through that process. So I think at the time the committee elected individually to make those comments.
10:48 And I think one committee member did make some comments at that time. So it remains to be seen what other avenues are available for making comments to the Forest Service on the Shady Rest staging area. The other thing that's unknown at this time is funding. So whether or not it actually happens is a whole other story that we'll have to be monitoring. The future work for the Trails Committee includes looking into a winter summit.
11:15 which hopefully we can identify various issues and come up with solutions for winter use and moving forward with the winter summit process. We'll also be looking at grants, grant opportunities and how we can maximize funding. Our 2014-2015 work program, we're going to be consolidating our project list that you've already seen and approved.
11:41 And we'll be incorporating projects from the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan recommendation list within that. So the format that will be coming forward in probably three months or so will be a little bit different than what you've seen in the past, a little more inclusive. We'll also be looking at our budget development and our priorities. And then finally we'll be tracking our various construction projects via the Public Works Department.
12:08 So that summarizes basically what we've done in September and in December, excuse me, and what we look forward to do in the future. Any questions? Go. The Forest Service over snow, the NEPA, if we're going to do that, when does our current contract end? Or when does the Forest Service, because isn't there...
12:33 Aren't we having to do the NEPA because of this lawsuit, but we're protected right now because of the current contract? Is that what I read and is that correct? Yeah, I think the full detail on that is probably better described to you by the Forest Service, but my understanding is that we currently have agreements or there are agreements in place with the state of California for the funding of the grooming and that we are covered this year.
13:00 for the grooming, but then it's a question as to beyond that. So the over snow is just the grooming. I guess I'm misunderstanding what the... There's two over snow projects. Okay. One is to build a new staging area for winter and summer past Mammoth Creek Park on the Sawmill Cutoff Road. Okay. And he spoke to that, and I will have some comments on that in a few minutes. The second one is a lawsuit that the Indian National Forest is not involved in.
13:30 And that is over their entire OSV operating plan and the grooming. It's a two-piece, actually two different lawsuits pretty much by the same organizations. One of them is saying that they need to do the same level of planning for OSV that they did in the travel management plan for summer. The other is saying they need to do a full NEPA process on grooming because a full NEPA process was never done.
13:59 Even though it occurs on existing roads, to determine the effect of inviting snowmobiles basically into the forest. Both lawsuits intended to reduce the number of snowmobilers ultimately, my opinion only. That's the crux of the two lawsuits. The third is the OSV-OHV staging area. Okay, so with the, currently there's a contract for OHV use. For one more season.
14:29 Okay. That's not for use, that's just for the grooming. Just for the grooming. Right. Okay. There's a land management plan from 88, I think is when it was finalized, that lays out where snowmobiles can go and what they can and can't do. Okay. And the second lawsuit is trying to nullify that and force them the new land management plan to do their own travel management for over snow vehicles, as they did for the roads.
15:00 And so is that what this NEPA is? Yes, the NEPA is for oversnow vehicles, both on groomed trails, they'll look at that environmental impact, and they'll also look at off-trail impacts by snowmobiles. And that's a two-year planning effort, $75,000 to $80,000 worth of work. And there may be, this year we don't necessarily
15:29 I shouldn't say that. This year we are covered under existing permits and exemptions, categorical exemptions and SEPA and so forth. So I guess that's when does that contract end? Is it just calendar year? Is that what we're talking about? Again, these are details that Forest Service can probably better answer. And it's not really a contract. It's my understanding it's an environmental decision. Okay. And that the contract portion is a contract with the state of California.
15:59 And my understanding is Forest Service's ongoing discussions with the state of California in regard to those grooming contracts. So I guess I'm just trying to figure out where that puts us as far as usage on our trails and on the snow and given what we need to do. Right. And the answer to that is we need to work hopefully with the Forest Service to resolve this situation and hopefully go through the environmental review so that we don't have a hiatus of a year or two of snowmobile shutdown in the...
16:27 Inyo National Forest. Does this affect motorcycles too or just snowmobiles? At this time it's snow. Okay. The motorcycles were affected it hugely and you still hear people complaining about it every day by the travel management plan that was done. Yeah. That's what they're saying now is that they need to do a travel management plan type document for snowmobiles. For snowmobiles, okay. Sorry, I'm just trying to understand these things. Okay. And then the...
16:54 Sharp Environmental Resource Assessment that you said is complete. What did that exactly entail? It had to do with biological resource assessment. It had to do with both flora and fauna. It had to do with archaeological as well. And I think at the same time they were looking for wetlands and hydrological impacts.
17:25 or sensitive resource areas. So this doesn't take into, this doesn't complete their NEPA process? This is just a... This is a starting point with understanding how sensitive the environment is and then with that base information they overlay the proposals that have been made out of SHARP and then see whether or not those proposed routes conflict with sensitive resources, be they biological or historical.
17:53 And then if they do, then the discussion needs to follow then of how to come up with an alternative route or an alternative method of mitigation over that impact or around that impact. So if it doesn't do that, then it goes to the next step, which would be the NEPA? That's correct. Then the Forest Service would come up with a proposal. Then that proposal would then be reviewed through NEPA and alternatives if it went to a...
18:25 an EIS or an environmental document, then it would have alternatives just like the SEPA state or the shady rest staging area we were just discussing and then from that and the comments and the public hearings and so forth then a preliminary decision would be made and then after that a final decision and then we can
18:50 Then you can make a trail. Then we can go out, then we can design it, then we can go out to bid, then we can construct it, then we can enjoy it. I love that. What it really does is, it helps define what level of NEPA you have to do on the project. That's what it's for. Do we need an EIR, do we need an EA, do we need a, this is this assessment by these specialists.
19:13 Help inform that process. What level of NEPA is required. Is it a million dollar EIR or is it a $30,000? Or if it has to move, then you start somewhere else and start doing it. Yeah, okay. One last question. So it was just said that, you know, the snowmobile staging area, whether we agree with what happened or not, and I know Bill has some comments and I disagree with what they did as well, but...
19:41 If there's no money for that, then what happens? Is there any staging at all? What's the alternative? Very good question. I don't have a definitive answer. All I can imagine is that grant opportunities would be looked at by the U.S. Forest Service. U.S. Forest Service may turn to the town of Mammoth Lakes and say, hey, we've got a great idea. Would you like to participate financially? It's unknown, Teri. Okay. I don't know.
20:11 That would be good information. Maybe you guys could find out what options there would be if this doesn't happen. Unfortunately, looking at the, and we find ourselves in this position over and over again, which is why John and myself and others have stressed the towns need to review everything the Forest Service is doing, which they come out with a monthly list. In terms of the Regulation Commission, the comment period ends before our next meeting. So we're not going to be able to
20:42 Input on this phase or what our opinions are. Well, it sounds like we can't anyways unless you put a letter in to start with. Right, although I think the town did initially. That's a town, did they not? I don't think so, no. Who is the committee member who did? Sandy Hogan, as I recall. And then there was some other individual, a resident of the town named Steve Spidell or something. Spidell and the Money family, and they made a personal
21:13 Comment, list of comments to know about. Which means they can comment. Which they have standing in. My frustration as a user of the forest is just, you guys heard me say when this first came about what the end result was going to be and I got told that I needed to be more positive and you got to think and this is going to go right, we're not going to make those decisions and it came out exactly as I indicated it would have in the first place.
21:42 As far as I'm concerned, this was an effort to move snowmobile and snowmobile staging out of the town of Mammoth Lakes, and in the end, that's the decision that was made. I could not be more disappointed in how the Forest Service went down there, and the fact that they are expecting the Green Sticker Fund to pay to move us out of town to me is just an insult to injury, and probably I will oppose that grant, which is someplace we have an option to go to. So as individuals, we could make comments?
22:14 At this point, you can only make a comment if you've submitted a prior comment. So now it's done. So, yeah. But there may be individuals in town that you could write a letter to and reflect your opinion. Whoever they are. Well, John, did MLTPA comment on that? Yes. So it could be outstanding to write.
22:43 There you go. There's another avenue. Okay, so we could give you a comment as well. I have one more question. You said the next phase of the forest plan, the need for change, is going to be on January 30th? Correct. In Bishop, is there any meeting that's going to be in Mammoth? No. Or is it going to be videotaped or televised or anything anywhere? No. You have to go Bishop. You can make a written submission, but there is a public workshop to receive comments in Bishop.
23:11 Okay, and so their whole forest plant, I'm assuming, is on their website then? That's correct. You know, and I found the 270-page document, and I scrolled through it and looked in the index, and I could not find the need for change section. Did I just miss it? Good. You got a copy of it? I'll take it. I'll be in your packet. Ultimately, that's the...
23:39 It's going to be in their packet so we can pull it off the internet once the agenda's out. Okay. Be eager to read the town response? Because that's, yeah, hopefully the town is going to respond more. Yes, absolutely. Yeah, the town has got a fellow named Carson who's been monitoring this and who was instrumental with Peter Burtisconi and putting it together, the December letter. And as I said, it was very well written and so they'll be monitoring that as well. Does the MLTSCC see the comments that the town's making prior to it going into?
24:09 I don't think so. I think the timing on that, Terry, was such that it needed to get out right away. And that's why it was dated the 16th, which, as I recall, was about the shutoff date for getting the comments dated. So, you know, in order to meet standing and meet the dates and so forth, that was done. It kind of felt like it came out suddenly, and I'm glad that actually you were able to make comments as it was. I'm sorry we weren't able to see it, but it was frustrating that, yeah, you know.
24:42 Can't be too critical because thank you for at least making comments. Okay, that was all my questions, I guess. Any other questions for Steve? Comment, question. I have gone on the Shady Rest tracks out there and when there was snow, it was wonderful. So, very happy with Friends of the Inyo and what they've done and the Trails Committee for making that happen.
25:11 And then recently I saw one of these catalogs that are out about Mammoth. I'm not sure if it's entitled Explore Mammoth, but it's sort of like a comprehensive guide for all seasons. And just glancing at the trail section, it didn't appear very extensive. And I'm wondering, is it possible to maybe work with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to make sure that the website email address or, you know, the website address is
25:38 Listed on that page as opposed to having to go to Mammoth Lakes Tourism and then try to search for the website. I know they actually, in the summertime, they actually had a banner on the top that was for... On their website they did. Yeah, on Visit Mammoth Beach. After I visited John Urdi. But this printed catalog would be nice. Yeah, actually it was there. In the future. Yeah, once the Mammoth Lakes trails went live, it was, they had a banner there and accessed through Mammoth Lakes. Okay. Once it was actually...
26:09 functioning properly. So anyways, but yeah, so I can bring that up to the whatever Mammoth Lakes Tourism as well. Was the catalog produced by Mammoth Lakes Tourism? I don't know. I believe so. I think it was just one of the sponsors. I'll track it down and bring it to me. Okay, thanks. Yeah, let me know. One of the things we're in our website management meetings, we're working very closely with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Good.
26:36 and getting their input and they're helping us too to understand how to develop the site to push it out there and get it to as many people as possible. Also exploring other ways and technologies, new evolving technologies so that people can find it, use it more friendly and so forth. So we are having that dialogue and close relationships. It's a terrific website so the more people that can be exposed to it the better. Thank you. Along the same line, Steve,
27:03 What's the plan to distribute the 2000 cards with the QR codes on them? Actually, John Wentworth is here. He can address that for you. Okay. But, yeah, it'll be a desktop. The primary point of distribution is to the Mammoth Lakes Visitor Center. We've been working closely with the Forest Service to identify partner page opportunities. This is something that was available several years ago when the site was constructed.
27:37 The Forest Service has had some concerns about businesses and private and public and all that kind of stuff. So there will be a partner page built for the visitor center in the coming months. But the cards that we, MLTPA, manufactured a year or so ago, we gave all those with the town's blessing, the forestry's blessing to the visitor center. They've been handing them out. And so the bulk of these are going to go to the visitor center initially. And then if there's other opportunities, certainly Mammoth Lakes Tourism, other places like that.
28:03 Yeah, I was going to say, if lodging, if we wanted to get some of those, could we go to the visitor center? Yeah, just check with Steve, and these are the town's properties, however, there'll be 2,000, they'll be here next week, so if you want to pick them up and distribute them. Thanks, John. Yeah, sure. Any other questions for Steve? Okay, thank you very much. Thanks, Steve. If Dennis doesn't mind, I'll follow Steve just because he really eloquently summed up all the stuff that's going on. Sandy Hogan.
28:44 and the Trails Committee. And I also was kind of surprised and disappointed a bit with the decision on the, because I also supported the Ryback Trail. And so I was a little bit surprised. And then I started thinking about it. Just the other day, I guess, I woke up and I thought, well, I wonder why. And sometimes there are strategies for not concluding that in a decision.
29:12 It could be, to me, it left open that possible use of the tunnel and the trail, but the fact is, in the NEPA, all of that was surveyed and looked at. Perhaps in the grant that they're going to put in for the OSV staging area, maybe it's something that the state didn't want to touch. Sometimes there's little strategies like that that we're not aware of. And so, in other words, it's not, maybe it can be a separate decision later.
29:41 That's a really pretty simple one. If the town were to approach after the summit that we talked about or saying we wanted to have a staging area or a parking area closer, you know, involving the RV park and out to the barrel pit. So I don't think it's dead. You know, being an optimist, I try to look at what it didn't shut it. It shut it off for right now. The town, maybe the state would not have paid for that. But the key is you can't ever put in for a grant unless you have the NEPA done.
30:11 That's the key. And the Forest Service used an opportunity base because they'd done a lot of the resource surveys because of the geothermal. They did that, put in some more time, more effort. They did the whole NEPA for the area. So the resource surveys and whatever, that's done. And it's just the decision part for that one that hasn't been done. So that's not dead. Realize that, you know, you can, we could make some lemonade out of that lemon maybe in the future.
30:40 So, and a second thing, the SHARP. I was talking to somebody and they did not realize what the SHARP Resource Surveys in NEPA means. It's thousands of acres, 100% surveyed, at a cost of a three-year project that's going to include, you know, the alignments, the realignments, the mitigations, the everything, the NEPA decision, the appeal period. It shouldn't be an EIS. Trails are generally what we used to call a white hat project.
31:10 People like them. But for $215,000 is the total. Our part is only $152,000. And it's NEPA and CEQA. And once it's done, that lays us, I mean, that puts us in position to put in for things like the Lakes Basin Trail, but over there behind Snow Creek, ADA Trails, a lot of good stuff. It's a capital investment because, again, we can't do anything without that NEPA.
31:37 I think we need to talk about these things a bit more in public so that I mentioned to Matt Lehman, I said, as I recall, the town council just voted to spend $400,000 for a CEQA zoning code amendment. We're getting thousands of acres for $215,000 and our share is $152,000. And the Forest Service is picking in one-third of this. So, you know, a few little things like that I think we need to, I mean, the rest of them, I mean, Steve just wrote.
32:07 It's very complete, and I think we need to keep summarizing what we're doing, because our trails committee, we can be proud of it, I think. We're moving stuff forward. Sometimes it doesn't seem like it goes at the speed of light, but that's NEPA, that's CEQA, you know, that's planning. But we are making it, and that's a capital investment, when you put in NEPA or CEQA, because that's the foundation for all our grants and all our planning. Anyway, I just wanted to add those comments. Thank you. Thanks, Cindy. Good afternoon. Dennis Rodner, Parks Superintendent.
32:43 So, kind of a slow winter. Parks are all closed November 1st. We pretty much open things back up. Not really, but kind of. Put some portable restrooms out. We pick up trash. We kind of take care of things the best we can. Ground is frozen. It's not really the safest place to be. We're going to keep signs up that do say playgrounds are closed. Skate park is closed. But we're not going to stop people from using them. Ah.
33:17 We swept most of the trails down low the last couple of days. We cleaned up a little bit of ice. There's still ice out there. There's still some dangerous spots. People could slip and fall and get hurt. But, yeah, they're open. Some of them are completely wide open and clear. So we're doing what we can there. And we swept all the sidewalks. Everything's in pretty good shape. Whitmore, same thing. Whitmore's closed. It's not open. There's temporary restrooms down there.
33:47 Soccer field's being used. We still have runners down there occasionally, but we're not going to disturb a lot down there because it is wintertime and the ground is frozen. But we'll just kind of switch gears and keep things somewhat open and user-friendly. Hopefully it does snow soon. Ice rink's running awesome. Can't ask for any more than what it's been doing. We've had 50-plus degree days and we've had...
34:18 How many thousand users? We could be slammed. We could be discussing the ice rink. I see these here, but is that part of the consent agenda? It's part of the manager's agenda. Okay, thank you. But it's working great. We're going to do a little bit of work. We had a hell of a time painting this year because it snowed every time we tried to paint.
34:46 We're going to try it tomorrow, so maybe we can make something happen. We've got to touch up the edge. The one edge still gets abused, but it's held up. All that new piping's in. It's all re-insulated. All the glass is up. Hockey players are happy. Everybody's using it. That's more than we can ask for with the weather we've had. So that's working out great.
35:14 We're probably going to do a little work down at Whitmore in the next couple of weeks if this doesn't change. We've got some things to fix down there, so we're going to go ahead and get a jump on it and do what we can do. We don't start our summer season until May 1st, and that's when we bring all our folks on board, temporaries. Baseball does start in the middle of February, so we could have baseball going. It started last year in February at Whitmore, so it could happen again.
35:47 Let's hope not. Other than that, everything seems to be working good. Like I said, most of the trails down low are open. We're not going to try and scrape ice off. Trails aren't designed to take that abuse. We threw a little bit of ice melt out there today and just kind of keep things clean and get people on them. Did you guys do anything on the lower part of Lake Mary?
36:13 We looked at it, it's got a lot of ice and it has a lot of shade. I've seen a lot of people walking in the road. Yeah, and you know, that's one of those things, you'd have to do it after every snowstorm or not at all. Because once it thaws and it freezes, now we have clear ice out there. We took a look at it last week when it was warm.
36:37 And it didn't, our little blower didn't touch it, so I was like, stay away from it. We don't want to invite people to go up there and have it too dangerous and have somebody go down. At some point it would be nice, you know, and I know that, you know. We've discussed it and we've talked about putting lights out there and, you know, I'm sure that discussion will come back up again here real soon.
37:01 Just even that, you know, short stretch between, you know, the Hidden Valley. We'd like to go all the way to Kelly Road. Yeah, that'd be a good idea. There's a cost involved. Yeah, it's so dangerous, especially, you know, in the evening when it gets dark early. Get them off the road. Yeah. I agree. Questions? Get a groomer and groom it. Get a groomer. I think he threw that back at you. We'll do it. I'm hoping the county has one of those. All right.
37:33 Thanks, Dennis. Thanks, Dennis. I will say I have driven by the park, that little park down there several times. Each time I've gone by it on a weekend day, there have been at least 10 cars in the parking lot. Half of them are in the skateboard park and half of them are in the little park. So the little park is still getting a lot of use because it's lower elevation. It's warmer and there's less snow. It's working out great. Once we have that astroturf in there,
38:03 I'll see if there's questions later. Let's look at more and more positive, by the way, with less and less water. Yeah. That's our option. Yeah. I don't know if now's time to talk about the water district's involvement. Should we save that for... We'll save that for me. Thank you. I think there'll be more and more in favor of it with the way things are happening this year. Got it. Could be a good deal for us. Okay. Just wanted to...
38:35 If anybody said, MLTPA will provide a comment back on the, on the summer cutoff situation. I think our concern is primarily about the fact that the town and the Forest Service have this MOU. The trail system is supposed to be a partnered effort. There's a very long, lengthy section in the trail system master plan about nodes, identified nodes. This is certainly one of them. It's, I think, that the, you know, the shadow of the ORMAP project, I think, looms over all this stuff.
39:04 And I think as long as someone's got standing, I think we should be pursuing this. So again, the town, I guess, can't comment as an organization, but certainly if you guys are individuals, just get in touch and we'll get together and put some comments together. John, thank you for doing that. Sure. Any other public comments? I will close public comments and move on to consent agenda. Anybody want to pull something from consent or you want to give me a motion? I wanted to pull one of the dates.
39:35 From the calendar. Okay. July 9th is a Wednesday. I think that probably needs to be changed to July 8th. Ooh, gosh, gosh. Actually, since that's been pulled for questions, I know that we've got a workshop scheduled for next Wednesday. Are there any other current, do we have any other dates? I just misplaced my calendar. They're currently scheduled. I know that it says that they will be listed separately, but I was just curious if...
40:05 Since I'm entering dates into my calendar. I don't see any on here other than that they all are on the 27th. Do we have something in the workshop that's coming? The 15th. Okay, but there's no other dates at this time for master planning or anything scheduled. And then also November the 4th is election day. Does that matter? Because sometimes this room is not available or?
40:37 Good catch. The 11th is Veterans Day, so that probably won't work either. We could probably, can we move it? The location? The location, maybe go to the town and county conference center or something? Oh, okay, so we can't do that? Okay. Can we do it? Can we go to the week prior? Prior to the council on Wednesday? Look at that and come back.
41:22 Make sure the room's available. So that would be the 5th? Mm-hmm. Okay, let's look at that. I'll confirm that in the next meeting. Is Veterans Day always on the 10th? I mean the 11th? Well, it's always that Monday. It's different. Monday, but our meeting's on Tuesday. Right. So maybe the 11th is available, which would be the following Tuesday? Or the day after the council meeting, or before the council meeting, whatever. The Veterans Day was always observed on the day. It's the 11th, yeah. Yeah.
42:01 So you're going to come back with those proposed dates for November? Yeah, we'll shoot for the 5th. If there's any change, we'll let you know on the next meeting. 8th is obviously Tuesday. Yeah, Veterans Day is observed on the 11th Monday. So I move to accept the consent agenda with the corrected dates of July 8th on the calendar and for the November meeting to come back at our February meeting. Second.
42:36 I have a motion to second and further discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? You guys have it. Policy item number three, finalize the agenda for the workshop. We held at 5 p.m. on January 15, 2014. I'm going to be here. You're not going to be here? I might not. I have a doctor's.
43:09 After being in a meeting in Arizona on the 14th, I'm not sure if I'm going to be back yet. Yeah, and I can see how that could be an issue. I'm not planning on being here on the 15th as well. So this is something that has come up. I can make some arrangements, but how short are we going to be then? I'll be here. I'm sorry, Pat, did you say you weren't going to be here? I said. This is Stu, correct me if I'm wrong, this is only a workshop. Correct. Primarily to present the...
43:39 Measure R applications and answer any questions they may have. And I think that Betsy and I can probably handle, well, I don't know. There's quite a lot of stuff on there. Is it possible to, is it too late to reschedule such a, because there is a lot on this agenda. Could we do it the second meeting in January? Or with it being Measure R or is that being, is that a problem? It is the second meeting. Oh, that's the only meeting in January. Oh, sorry, yeah. It would have to be February, January, you're on.
44:11 There's some workshops already? Yeah. I have to look at the calendar. Right. Well, frankly, with Stu and the two of us, I think the Measure R and the HVS event study, which are the two biggest issues for me, could be handled regardless. Well, I can speak to the MLR process, too. Right. And you're on the MLR, so we can talk to that as well.
44:41 We need another meeting with them for something else. We will simply ask for it. And HBS, I mean, we haven't even discussed that. We haven't discussed that. I know. That's, I think, why it's on the agenda, because it hasn't been discussed, and we're looking for it to come back, and where's it at, and what's it saying? Where is it? I would think it should come back to the commission prior to the process. That's the question we're going to ask, I think. That is correct. Okay. We're trying to just move this along a little bit here, so we'd like the commission to request it.
45:10 Council in this discussion item to at least understand where this thing is at and when's the time to move forward. Right. Okay. So I think we can probably handle that. And if one of you can be here, that would be great. But we certainly don't need a quorum. We're not making any decisions. Okay. I'll be here. Stuart, does the Measure U Committee have a workshop scheduled with Council prior to the U recommendations? They do. Okay. Would that be a more appropriate time for the HVS?
45:41 That study, or are we just asking for it to live along? We haven't thought about that yet with that measure. That's scheduled for mid, I think that's February 14th, I think is when that workshop is scheduled. No, and I'd like to put some heat on. Yeah. So let's do that HVS thing in our workshop with it. Okay. Remember, it's only an hour workshop, so. And then Parks Master Planning, what were you planning on bringing forward as far as that goes? That's kind of part of the measure R, isn't it?
46:13 Well, we have the design company. It has an application. Yeah, so staff just put these forward. It's really up to the commission to determine what items you want to discuss with council. I thought this was very relevant because, you know, pending approval by the council, we're going to move forward with this pretty aggressively to get this done within the next several months, right? We want to try and get this done by mid-year. So I think it was a good opportunity to at least wrap up where we were and where we ended with our discussions.
46:45 What we kind of got to with our prioritization tables, and then the recommendation of why we're moving forward with this consultant at this time. And that ties into the event study too. It does, right. It's all kind of linked. I think that we're at that point where we just want to get stuff done, right? We want to move forward. Yeah. Place items on our parks. Yeah, Stu, for my part, the only thing that I would do different is I would start with R, then go HVS. Okay. Then MLR, then park master planning.
47:13 Depending on how much time we have, that would be the, if that's all right with the rest of you, that would be the order I'd like to take them in for that meeting. Maybe the Parks Master Plan first because if that's tied to Measure R, I mean, chances are you're going to have time to discuss all of these items. It'll kind of be a conversation within them if there are because it's an application within Measure R. So it could be kind of a part of it. They want them to really understand why we are putting it forward. Yeah. So that's kind of like a 1B, 1A.
47:43 And then we'd do HVS and then we'd finish with MLR. Okay. You got it? Thank you. Okay. Any other questions on the workshop? Moving on to an MLR update. So, again, this is a standing item we've had on the agenda each month. It's really an opportunity for the commission to receive updates. We have two commissioners that are on the steering committee.
48:28 And I'm sure they can kind of update the group on the progress to date. There was a draft report presented last night that we were hoping to present to the Commission today. A lot of changes. We asked for a lot of changes. It was, we think, you know, changed, I think, for the better. So that report is hopefully going to be available, we think, the week prior to the 27th of January. So as soon as we receive that, we'll post it on that website. We'll get it to Commission.
48:57 And we can look into that a little bit more diligently as a commission. The progress from there is to actually present that draft report to council, I think in that mid-meeting in February, so I think it is the 14th of February that we'll go to council at that time. And in that will be the recommendations of the steering committee and also the next steps in the formation and then probably as part of that.
49:26 SMG's role in that next phase as well. I'm not too sure if that's something that the committee's going to be addressing at that point as well, or if they're needed at all. We're not too sure. So that's what we have. You can see that I've updated everything on that town's website. So if you get to the Recreation Department page, you'll see Mammoth Lakes Recreation as a tab. You can click on that. All the agendas and meeting minutes and all that reference material is online, excluding this last report. We haven't received that.
49:54 It's probably a bit premature to get out to the public as yet. So with that, I'll just turn it back over to the Chair and perhaps Vice Chair or Commissioner Truex can update the Commission on the detail. Stu just kind of went through exactly what we did and I did ask if we should present the report that we did last night. Actually, Pat was there so she was able to go through and walk through it.
50:20 They just really felt that it was premature because there was so much discussion and changes that happened that without having that full conversation again that it really wouldn't do any good to give you guys that information right now because it would kind of have some, you know, false leads type thing in it. So anyways, so we really look forward to it. I think there were some great changes that were made last night, some great suggestions. Some of it was just in verbiage.
50:46 How the information was being presented or what the information was and what the process was moving forward. So I think that's going to be a great document for everybody to look at when it comes out prior to our January 27th meeting because that's hopefully going to be where we make the final document to go to council. So it would be really important for this commission to take a look at that and then we can have it on our agenda.
51:15 at our first meeting in our meeting in February because that will still be before it goes to Council. So anyways, and then it'll be determined whether we need another meeting, whether there still needs to be any other changes or whether that document on the 27th is going to be accepted as the one that goes forward to Council.
51:37 And I would just add that, you know, I just, I felt very encouraged because I felt there was truly consensus within, you know, within not only, you know, the steering committee but just, you know, within the audience. I think people were sort of very, were feeling pretty good about the direction the report was going in. So I thought that was really exciting. Something that was added last night is Rick kind of took RecStrats and took something that we had the diagram from our original Mammoth Lakes Recreation, regional recreation, I think is when we were doing that.
52:07 that it had where we had the town, Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the USF, how they kind of integrated with each other. Then he took some categories and put some potential things that MLR could do. So it took the high level that the report that SMG has put together, because they have kept it at a high level because they wanted MLR to be able to, you know, kind of create their own organization, but took the
52:33 High-level items on that and gave it some life so people could actually put maybe an action with the item within the report. So that is going to be something that's added to the document last night. So I think it was really helpful and I think that's kind of where a lot of the consensus came from and kind of the affirmation that we're moving forward possibly in the right direction there. So anyways, it was a really positive meeting.
53:02 It was very good. And then as far as the next steps moving forward, they did line it out, basically took kind of the same steps as we went through with Mammoth Lakes Tourism in creating a new organization, what the next steps are. So here's the roadmap of everything we need to do to have that organization up and running. And so the conversation will happen at our next meeting as to how we move that forward, what kind of support is needed.
53:31 to move that forward. It was determined that the same formation group right now would be the kind of the nuts and bolts, the steering committee in moving the next step forward, the transition board. Yeah, not the transition board. They said it's a transition committee as opposed to the transition board. So because it would not be the official board.
53:58 Once the organization comes forward. But it is the one that's going to start moving the organization forward to formation. One thing I would just comment on is that I think you're right, Terry. I think there was more consensus. And I think as more specifics were addressed in exactly what an MLR would do, it seems to make more sense as opposed to just being somewhat nebulous.
54:27 However, and I know there's a lot of parallels with MLT and some other similar organizations, but I think this group is going to be rather unique, and I think that, you know, it would be beneficial to keep some of the parallels, but then to also kind of think a little bit out of the box, too, as to how this organization could be structured, because it will be unique, and whatever has...
54:54 Been done in the past with other organizations doesn't necessarily mean that that has to be followed precisely for this group. Well, and it will have a very different mission from MLT, so I think that's, and I think that's been one of the concerns is that, you know, one of the reasons that I think MLT is successful is because they do have such a defined, you know, role, and I think the formation committee, I think, will really nail that down. Those are the next steps.
55:21 My concerns about it are, as always, that O&M will take so much space out of the budget that the money needed to actually get the projects on the ground goes away by having the secondary organization. I haven't had the time to pay that close of attention to it, but the 15% was being thrown out there, I understand, and 15% O&M and any non-profit is a lot.
55:50 You know, if you're going to donate to a project, the first thing they tell you is make sure the O&M isn't exceeding 10% of their budget. So I do have some concerns there and whether or not you've looked at whether we could accomplish the same thing by moving house over to one side or by moving this over to the house side so that we're not duplicating those steps. And the feedback I've been getting from some of the people that have been in the audience...
56:21 He said that that really has not been looked at and that the savings there have not been looked at. So I have my concerns keeping an open and positive mind and trust you as both. So I'm just giving you my concerns to carry forward to the rest of the group. Two different organizations very rarely make sense to me.
56:40 Well, and that was definitely something that I think that we did address yesterday, you know, that while we're hesitant to put a timeframe on it, the idea is that, you know, MLR would, well, first of all, anything built by MLR will be, you know, owned and operated by the town, essentially. But also just that, you know, the goal with MLR is, you know, is very strongly to make this, you know, to make this, you know, revenue neutral in terms of overhead so that we're not, so that we're, you know, so that, you know, we're
57:08 A lean and mean organization is what we're looking at. So do we put a, most of government says they're going to do that and then it doesn't happen and then we keep doing the same thing into perpetuity. So has the thought been put out there that we would give this a finite life and if it couldn't live up to what we thought it was going to do that we would then revert back or change structure to make it, you know, are we going to keep agile enough so that we don't create something that doesn't work and then leave it in place regardless?
57:38 Well, you know, while we're talking about having, you know, sort of a dotted line, the way that MLT does, you know, to the council is that, you know, the council will still hold the purse strings for this organization. So, you know, they will certainly have the ability to say, nope, this isn't working. If it isn't living up to expectations, then, yeah, you always have that. There will be some reporting structures. There was not a timeline put on it. Just with the new organization, it was like, okay, this would be the, you know, ideal thing.
58:07 to have is that we're going to, it would be revenue neutral, but there was not a timeline. Then, you know, also understanding that there are monies that are going out there right now that go towards O&M. Oh, yeah, absolutely. That would, you know, that just move over as opposed to being additional monies being spent, so. Yeah, well, right now we allocate 4% to the town. Just for the administration of process. Right, and then we pay each organization.
58:36 Who gets a grant from R&U their own amount of money for their overhead and structure as well. But unless we cut them off and do everything as MLR, which I have no problem with, I support that in fact, we would still be paying their overhead as well. So we have to look at what that total overhead looks like in the long run. I just want to make sure that that's being. Yeah, and it is a sensitive area and we understand that that's a sensitivity.
59:04 that the community has, and it's being looked at, so very closely. The council members that sit on the committee are very eager to be proactive. Excuse me for asking, because I haven't been paying attention to the MLR specifically. Is there going to be any other oversight besides directly reporting to town council? There will be a board. I'm sorry, the board is reporting directly to the town council.
59:28 Well, the organization is reporting directly to town council, but the board is overseeing the operations and actions of the MLR. Okay, similar to MLT. But Bill, I think you bring up a very good point about using taxpayer dollars and where they're actually going, and I know that there was some discussion yesterday on the committee level about, you know, whether to put some of the financial information in a chart form, which was...
59:56 Proposed by the consultants or to just kind of make it more of a paragraph text kind of version. And I, you know, I hope, I don't remember what the exact outcome was, but I think that there will be some. There was going to be a range. There's going to be a chart as opposed to just having narrative about the overhead. And because I think that's important that people know that from the beginning.
1:00:23 And I think it's important, too, that there be milestone dates and whether the organization is achieving their goals or not. And I think that's something that the formation committee will definitely be looking to do. And that was something that was discussed last night. There could be a six-month, this is what needs to be accomplished in six months and 12 months and what our goals are.
1:00:49 So anyhow, those were all discussed. And it will definitely be discussed in a lot more detail moving forward. So just to clarify, Teri, so this will be coming, assuming that the report is approved at the January 27th meeting, it will be coming to the commission for review before it goes to council. It should be on our February meeting, so, yeah. Because I would have liked to have this time, but with as many changes that were made that it was suggested not to bring it forward, so.
1:01:19 Giving you guys as much time as possible to review. I thank you for that. Anything else on MLR? No, just that, you know, I'm very encouraged with the direction that it's headed in. I had some skepticism at the beginning, and I think I'm feeling pretty confident. Moving on then to manager's reports. Have you all read the student's manager's report? Do you have questions on the manager's report?
1:01:49 And he has some extra info here that he's handing out himself. Yeah, so I just updated, Dennis actually gave a little brief update on the ice rink, and we actually just took our lunch, took our staff out to lunch today just as a recognition because it was a very busy time for the rink. It wasn't a record-setting time. Actually, two years ago we did about 2,000 people more, but this year we did about the same amount of money but 2,000 people less.
1:02:18 You know it. We're pretty close to our yield and actually increased our yield by about $2 per skater. But we did around just under 4,000 people from when we've opened from November 29 to December 31. You can see that we've bought in about $39,000, just under $40,000 of revenue. The updated sheet that I've given you is part of the packet that was updated from the original staff report.
1:02:43 Shows our revenue finished in December and then the six days in January. And you can see we're at 81% of our revenue target for the season. Obviously, we'll, I would say, exceed that number looking at the forecast, unfortunately. But we do, and we did bring up some interesting discussions with our staff and some needed
1:03:12 Improvements at the rink. We're looking at updating our larger size skates. They've been pretty old. They've taken a complete thrashing, so to speak. So we're looking at updating, bringing in about 30 new skates, probably about 35, 40 new adult skates. Looking at replacing some speakers that are not really working correctly.
1:03:39 Replacing the phone. If you've called the ice rink, the staff can't really hear you. It's a pretty old phone, so we want to update that. But a lot of the positives. I mean, the point-of-sale system was just fantastic. It really expedited a lot of the lines. It was very expeditious in regards to getting people in and out and processed. So we're happy about that. So a lot of good success stories. So I provided that. And also the detail you can see that the point-of-sale system provides. And this can be pulled at any time.
1:04:08 Far more efficient method than what we were doing in the past. So I've provided some overview of our product mix. You can see on that one page with our mammoth ice rink stats. And the other page was kind of our concessions and retail. And you can see we do a lot of hot cocos. And that's actually a good deal. I'll tell you about that. So that's actually a trade with Grumpy. So that actually is part of that banner program. We receive all that.
1:04:36 Powder Mix is trade, so we don't have any cost to that at all, so that goes straight to our bottom line, so it's a very efficient little program, and we do trades also with Mammoth Times and the Sheet, and the Sheet's actually going to sign up and get a board out there as well, so we'll be able to trade advertising with them, so I think that's a good way to do it. But anyway, so you can see, hockey's about to start to pick up, it'll get quite aggressive now that it was...
1:05:01 Excluded in the holidays. So they're very happy about the glass. They're happy about the changing room. I mean, they love that addition. So we'll see the hockey numbers really elevate both in adult and youth as well. And we actually started a great program with Sierra Nevada Roadway Inn and Spa. So Brent came in and I think it was probably Betsy's idea.
1:05:23 So thank you. Pleasure. But during the holiday period, so, you know, have a tremendous amount of guests. So, you know, Brett came in and said, well, can we buy six VIP passes, you know, hand them out at their guests that they can use at any time? We said, wow, what a great idea. And then we also tried a little, which we'll do throughout the season, if they bring in their little resort card, we'll give them, you know, complimentary rentals just to see if we can kind of drive some numbers. So we'll try that program and see if it works, and if it's a successful program, that's something I think for all lodging properties.
1:05:51 I think it's quite advantageous. What a great benefit, certainly, a year like this. So we think that's a great way to go to get upfront commitment, much like the Skiri does with their MVP passes. So you can really kind of lock that down. And with that, they receive that banner as well. So there's your banner, there's your promotion, there's your passes. You know, it seems like a win-win. So anyway, so we've got a great staff. We're really thrilled. The rank asset has done great. I mean, that header pipe replacement was, I think, crucial.
1:06:19 I think if we lost that pipe, I think that would have been disastrous, I think, for the town. So I think that was a good investment. So that's the ice rink. Any comments on the ice rink? I know Sean wants to... Yeah, I had just a couple questions. With this 50-degree weather we're having, that's not posing any problems? It is. Okay. Yeah. So if you've been out there, they do rope off that side. They've got actually a shade structure they'll put on there as well.
1:06:45 During the morning, and they'll take that off for rink. So we've got that protected. And that's why we're closing tomorrow. Actually, we're going to resurface all those corners in that exposed area. So they're going to repaint those areas and then reflood the ice and try to get it back to a better shape. So it does. But again, that was running at 50 degrees ambient temperature. The chiller was about 19 degrees. But the integrity of the ice was actually pretty decent. I think everyone was reasonably happy with the way it operated.
1:07:15 Like I said, I think the biggest day we had was 414 people on New Year's Eve, December 31. That was our biggest day. It was about $4,630-something. So, again, it was... Anyway, so we're thrilled at how that went. Have we been having issues with people taking skates off the rink to skate? Yeah, the real sheet article, there was, I think, three skates that went walkabout but came back. We knew the people. They actually paid...
1:07:45 Fool them out. They took the $10.50 and off they went and bought them back. So, you know, we looked at that. They come back. We looked at that and I don't know if it makes sense to create a whole process just for, you know, that we don't rent skates off-site. So that's something that was, you know, we ask them, you know, we tell them, but people rent them and off they go. So, disappointing. But it's not a big problem, let me just say. That was three pairs of skates and they came back. That was going to be a question.
1:08:15 Are there liability issues? Yeah, we don't want them to leave that facility. We don't want them to leave that facility. And actually, with these replacement skates that we're purchasing, we're probably going to turn around and sell probably 20 or 30 of our older skates as rentals, just for 20 bucks or something, and see if people want to come and take them away, because they're in basically pieces. So if there's a market out there that people want to get some skates to go and use them on our lakes, then here you go. Yeah. Super. So we've got our money out of them well and truly. I think they're probably 10 to 12 years old.
1:08:45 A couple of other things here. Can I ask one other question? The $1,200 we got in facility rentals in November, was that just one rental or was that several? That was for the season. So that's actually a group that comes from Bishop. That's the youth Bishop group that comes up every, I think, Sunday morning. And we rent them the ice for an hour and a half. Okay. Yeah, that was a season-long rental. Great. Good to know that. Thank you. That's it.
1:09:11 So when you see the board advertising program at 400, we'll try to actually trade out if there's value before we take that money. I just think there's a better opportunity for us. It keeps our costs down. I did want to point out the indoor soccer league. I think the holidays beat everybody. So so far we're looking at about three teams. We need one more for an indoor soccer league. So that'll start actually this Sunday. If we only get three teams, we'll just do a pickup soccer.
1:09:41 Programme, and then hopefully as soon as we get the additional 14 we'll get them going. John's very active with our Hot Shots Basketball League. You can see there we're giving a little update so they're still going. We're revising the Gymnastics Tumbling Programme. We've got two people basically staffing that program now. It's that popular. So we're moving those dates around and some days for them.
1:10:08 And then we're also looking at our summer camp dates and programs. So we'll probably come back in February, I think with some probably fee schedule amendments, I think is what we want to probably recommend with our group. We want to make sure we get that back to you as well. Reconciliation for Measure R, that'll come back in February, so we'll have that. Susan Cash, our finance staff, is kind of overseeing that program now, so she'll be...
1:10:39 here on February 4th, so we'll run through that program with you. And you saw the update on the office closure for Fridays. Stu, on the reconciliation, so we will get a copy of the reconciliation and then how it's moving forward from there? Well, we're really going to be bringing it forward to seek some direction from the Commission on how you'd like to handle a couple of the accounts, right? You know, there's money that's been left over, hasn't been used, so that's really kind of that policy that we'd like to bring forward to you.
1:11:09 But will there be an accounting, itemized accounting? Yeah, there is. And is that on the website or will we get a copy or where is that? We can get that to you. I think it's done. So, you know, we can get that to you at any time. We can send you the updated spreadsheet. I mean, the QuickBooks pages is, you know, a gazillion pages long. But do you just want to see the page, the summary? Are you putting that information up on the website or is it not? It'll be a new packet. Okay. It'll be a new February 4th packet.
1:11:38 I'd like to see the P&L on each individual year. And that's real easy to do. Not the detail. But in QuickBooks, you can just go and do a quick P&L. But for each calendar year that we've given the award, so I can see what's been left over each year. And each grant. That should only be about a three-page report. It is. We've done it by award. Because it crosses calendar years and fiscal years, it's a little difficult. So we've done it by award. So you'll see it by spring award, by...
1:12:09 Fall Award. So it's that three-page summary report like the Measure U one you'll see. So you see what was awarded, what was spent, what the balance is. And if there's, if, is there anywhere that anybody can look at the detail or is it just we're not going to get the detail, we're just getting the high level numbers? We can absolutely give you the, we can give you the QuickBooks detail for each one of those if you need to, but that's going to show every expenditure. Yeah, I guess I would, if there's a question that's available, we could ask for something. We'll have that available, absolutely. Yep, yep.
1:12:38 And is this being put out there for the public anywhere, or is it not? It's a public document. People will request it. The sheet requested it a couple of months, a month ago. So, yeah, I mean, it's available. So, anyway, so it'll be part of the packet. So you have to go to Finance to ask for it? Is that what we're... Well, Finance control it, but I manage that spreadsheet, so I do the summary spreadsheet, and they just basically summarize the detail and reconcile it to AS400 and QuickBooks.
1:13:07 Well, I think it would be appropriate to get every member of the commission the short P&L, the three-page P&L report, because that will show a total income to date and total expenditures to date, and I think that's, and it'll show it by project, right? Yeah, so I think, unless one of you doesn't want it, I'd like to see us each get a copy of that. Before the next meeting? Yes.
1:13:35 Before end of business today. Okay, send it. And then the other item was towns hosting the annual employee slash commissioner, council appreciation lunch, which is next January, sorry, next Wednesday, sorry, January 16th. I think you did receive an email. Thursday. 15th. Sorry. 15th. The 15th is Thursday. 16th. 16th is Thursday.
1:14:04 I'll write down the 16th. Thursday. I think the email says the 15th. I have it on my calendar for the 16th. Because I have to be in Arizona at the meeting on the 14th and it was the next day. No. Let me just pull it up. Okay. Employee, appreciate your luncheon. 1-16. Thursday, January 16th, 11.30 to 1 p.m. in Sweet Z. Food from Toomey's will be served with prizes.
1:14:34 Oh, you know what? It does say that the 16th, because I might be back for that. There you go. I'm sorry. My error. I'm sorry. I hope you can join us. That's a letter. I think I've been to each one of them. Yeah. So far. Yeah. It's good. It's good. It's a good event.
1:14:56 Can I ask, because there is a special event permit, and I know this is not the town anymore, and I know I'm going to ask some questions of a few different people that are putting this together, because we need to move on this, but financially I don't know where we are moving on it as the fireworks. Is there any, has there been any conversation with council that there's any monies within town that can go towards that? There's $10,000 still in that budget.
1:15:26 But that was for other activities. It wasn't for actual fireworks. It was for the fireworks or pops in the park, whatever. Okay. But there was $10,000 in that budget. This is what I still have working on. I met with the group probably about a month ago before Christmas. And the town is still going to be the permit authority for that event. So we'll still be working through with DWP and Crowley and Fish Camp and all those entities to basically put that on. That's our commitment to the event at this time.
1:15:54 They believe they'll have sufficient funds to fund it completely. Okay, so, but we have to, we would have to have a contract with the vendor, like it should be going on right now. February, yeah, February is when I usually get that contract from Pyro. So at that time, my intent was to basically take that to Dan, our town manager, and say, okay, so we've got this contract, we need a commitment of...
1:16:18 Essentially $26,500 right now to commit to this contract. And then if we'd receive those funds from that organizing group, then we'd go ahead and move forward with contracting that event. Did the county definitely say no? The county said that if you wanted to file an application for their special events funding, then they would do that. They said that they actually, I guess, tell me if I'm wrong, because I'm just reading bits and pieces here and there.
1:16:47 That they're giving money towards the security? Because from what I understand and what I read on that, the county isn't contributing anything to it. But they're saying they're contributing to security. They do provide the sheriffs. They do provide the sheriffs. And they provide the mobile command unit. So they have six to eight staff. Except for when you gave me the Crowley Lake Fish Camp budget, there's money that's being paid out for that.
1:17:17 Within that budget. Yeah, we pay security just to have security, KRA security just usually overnight next to the fireworks. So they're not really security for the event. They're just making sure no one takes off with the fireworks. That makes sense. So the law enforcement is what the county says they're contributing. But likewise, the town is also contributing.
1:17:41 We contribute with our town, public works, our police force. I mean, my time, I mean, you saw my time. It's probably 200 hours into this event to get this thing permitted. I was very disappointed in the county's response. I won't say it any stronger. Yeah, no, I thought it was pretty disappointing. So, you know, maybe when is their application period up that we have to file a special event permit to gain money there? Because maybe that's what we want to do. By the 16th.
1:18:12 of January. But the people who have been collecting money, and it's not special events, it's their non-profit funding, the people who have been traditionally getting money and created that lot of money have already seen $40,000 of that, if it's the fund that I believe it is, get pulled from that fund and moved over to marketing. So they're pulling from product enhancement to get rid of the product, and then I'm not sure what they're going to be marketing with anyway.
1:18:44 It was disappointing. And the way they handled it was disappointing. But we have until the 16th to send in our letter of request to the – and probably should, Stu. I know Dan said the town was not going to jump through that hoop. I think probably that – I can pull the application and see what it – That organizing committee probably should. I mean, that's Ted, Jack Oakland, and Matthew Lehman. I had an MLT meeting tomorrow, so I was going to actually ask, because there's going to be a couple of those folks that are working on that tomorrow. So, anyhow.
1:19:15 I only know the deadline because I believe it's the same pot that we apply for as a historical society. Okay. So I didn't realize there was still any action going on with the town here. So that's good information to have. Because I knew deadlines were coming up. So if we needed to act on something else, it needs to happen now. But you're still following through at this point. Correct. Stu, I have it on my computer. Off the top of your head, what was the total of last year's monetary commitment?
1:19:47 From the town? From the town. After income was taken off of that. Yeah, I'd have to look at it. Because that includes Pops in the Park as well for us. No, I would limit it just to the fireworks, not the Pops in the Park. I think the fireworks, $28,000, $29,000, it was $26,500 for the fireworks, and it was about $3,000 above that. So $29,500 was probably about our cost.
1:20:12 Right. And then we got gate fee, sorry, Commissioner, we got gate fee revenue and then we also got the $5,000 from Rick Elkers. So we received about $8,500 back. So the net was probably $22,000, $23,000. I know you guys worked on this last year, but I would love to go back to Valley Lake Fish Camp once again and renegotiate that if absolutely possible. And I would be willing to do that. And if we can call DWP, because I think their permit was about $2,400.
1:20:41 We don't pay for it. Well, that was on the budget. I didn't pay for that. Must be different. I think that's the part that Polly Lake Fish Camp pays out a certain amount of money. And that's part of what they have to pay out. But after they paid out their money and actually still received the gate that they did, you know, there's a decent profit that they're making. So, anyhow. The fire department down there charges us a fee.
1:21:11 750. We should certainly ask for that to be waived. It started at 1,000. We got it down to 500 and then went back to 750. I just think there's some wiggle room there that if we sit down and talk to all the folks, it might be worth having that conversation again. Anything to make it happen. It needs to happen. It has to happen. So I would be willing to do that, but I just think we would need to set up some meetings and appointments. And getting back to the application for the county, the town's not going to follow through on that?
1:21:44 I was reaching out to that organizing group. If the town needs to submit something, we'll certainly submit something. I think it would be better coming from the organizing group than it would be from the town. Yeah, that would be more appealing to that. And so I'll ask that question tomorrow, and Stu, if you're going to follow up again. Maybe between the two of us, if we follow up. Great. Okay, Stu, anything else on your report? Not unless there's any questions from the commission. Why is there no snow?
1:22:14 I do have a question. Okay, let's move right on to Commissioner Reports. Pat, we'll start with you tonight. I'm pleased to announce that I've been appointed to be the Northern California Representative for the California Association of Commissioners and Board Members through CPRS, which is California Park and Recreation Society. And so...
1:22:41 We'll be attending the statewide conference, which is in Southern California this year, which is beginning of March. So hopefully we won't conflict too much with the commission meeting here. And I'll keep you guys apprised. And I'm going to be participating in a conference call tomorrow evening. So I'll learn a little bit more about exactly the projects that this board is working on. Great. Wow, wonderful. Congratulations. Thank you. Nothing.
1:23:12 Ice skating on the lakes and salt marshes has been great. If you own your own skates. I want to be clear on that. If you own your own skates. The other thing that I just want to report on is that, you know, talk about growing an event. This is, you know, kind of business oriented, but also just from a perspective as far as growing events.
1:23:35 You know, when we took over Bluza Palooza in 2007, it was only 1,500 people that attended on Saturday only. And last year we did get permission, albeit only three weeks before the event, to go to 6,000 people by using that site. And the goal of that event has been to try and grow an event in this town. And, you know, I'm not bragging, but I'm just saying that over the course of the last seven years,
1:24:04 We have grown this event such that as of January 1st, we had sold over 1,100 of the 6,000 tickets available without headliners announced yet just because our patrons and 90% of them are coming from Southern California. We're still getting so many from Southern California who know the reputation of the event is going to be successful. And I only report that just because as we go into the HVS study that's about to be released.
1:24:33 Granted, this is the 19th year of Bluza Palooza. That we're able to get a reputation of this event such that we can pre-sell so many tickets eight months in advance without a headliner. Average ticket price for the three-day ticket price is about $150. And I just, I honestly believe that this town has so much potential for our summer events. It takes time. This is the 19th year.
1:25:00 For its seventh year that we've been really concentrating on growing it over four days, and we've got a lot of great new components that we're going to be adding this year. The one thing they all announced that actually hasn't been announced on the website is we did secure Buddy Guy for Sunday, which is a great headliner. We're still working on some headliners for Friday night, Robert Randolph for Saturday night. But we haven't even announced that to the public yet.
1:25:25 And that, you know, we've got that many tickets. I think we're already over 1,200 tickets sold just as of today. So, again, as we go into the reports that are going to be coming forward from the HVS event site, you know, again, I just want to stress that this town has so much potential for being able to grow events of this magnitude. It has great potential. And, you know, if you look at, you know, kind of where we are even for winter, you know, we may want to diversify a little bit. You know, you look at, like, South Lake Tahoe just had snow globe that has just grown.
1:25:55 Huge. And so it's outside with a tent in the middle of winter. You know, it's not that it's warm. So, you know, there's potential in the wintertime to, you know, put some stuff on too. So it'll be, maybe it's something as we're moving forward. On the same note, however, I hope that the MLEC grows to the point where we have an arts community.
1:26:22 Who can say, you know what, this event on this weekend isn't being as successful as it could be. Maybe it's time to get this event in favor of, here's what we're missing. You know, it's a hodgepodge at the moment, and Bluza Palooza gets hit on a very popular genre at the moment. But everybody in Mammoth tries not to compete with everybody else, but at some point, all of our weekends are already from the 4th of July on. Every weekend has a special event in it.
1:26:53 And I think there needs to be some cohesion somehow between all of those. And hopefully the events coalition is the one who can do it. So that we're tapping into the right crowds for Mammoth. I won't step my toe too far. Yeah, I won't. At some point it's going to be important. There may be events that could serve us better than what we currently have in some places. And hopefully we can work that out.
1:27:24 Somehow, or get the organization who can work that out. That's it. Thank you. Let it snow. Let it snow. Let it snow. I will go with that one. I have no reports. Agenda items. I don't have anything additional to requests. We've already got the MLR report.
1:27:58 Do you need to do the HVS? I think the HVS should probably be on there. MLR, HVS, and the Measure R Recreation. R and U. And then I think we need to talk about July 4th just so we can have a report because that's going to be pivotal at that point as to where we are and what's going on. Parks Master Planning.
1:28:26 Are we moving, yeah, we need to decide whether there's any other, and we'll know by then if we're doing any further with our priorities that we're, we started in sort of a little ways on but haven't gone any further as to what we might want to do. Probably a standing item, we don't need to come up now because we'll be talking about the schedule with the consultant and whatnot. The only other one there was this Measure R Spring Award if we wanted to start talking about that in February. It'd kind of bring forward a tentative timeline maybe.
1:28:59 It's February. Yes, we should. Absolutely. Because that's usually warded in June. Right. We should start to set up for that. Not knowing where MLR is going to go and how that's going to affect the process. We've got to move forward regardless. Well, we have to because MLR, you know, the goal is for, you know, June. So we still need to conduct a spring award probably. What about the aquatics program? Is that in jeopardy at all for this coming summer or?
1:29:32 I don't believe so. I don't think so. It's budgeted in, right? It's in the budget unless they take it out of next year's budget. As of right now, it's funded through June because the town operates on a fiscal. I know. So at least the startup is in this year's budget. A couple days, yeah. Yeah. And then pending the council award next week of the Measure R recommendations, you know, we'll move forward then.
1:30:02 Putting the contract in for the point of sale and, you know, start moving forward with those products too, so. Something's around the corner. Is there like a mid-year town council budget review? I did hear that, so. Is that something just FYI for us to be aware of? Because there's still like this $100,000 out there that is a resource. Yeah, although right now if I was a council member, knowing that our biggest
1:30:32 Two weeks of the year just came in probably a good 15% below the norm. I'd be nervous. I think it's just important for us to be aware of the overall town budget. Absolutely. Okay. I'll make a motion to adjourn. I'll second. I have a motion to second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Aye. What a great way to stop the new right now.