Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 3 hr 18 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
427 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:13 I think that there's a couple things that just, you know, we need to say we received them in this packet and they need to be brought back. It'd be my best guess. Yeah, that's one of them.
1:04 And that's what I've put most of my time on. I've got much time to get through. Well, that's why it took me so long, because I have to be back to go to the town's website, and go back to the town's website, and it's not even all up there, so. Well, we have something. Anything's better than it was important, because we never had anything, so. It's a start. It is a start.
1:57 Good, they have them MVP gates. And she's so funny because she keeps saying, well, I don't really want to raise. She loves them on MRC. So we'll see. And what's really interesting is that she's going to have her hand.
2:58 Thank you.
3:35 Excellent. As soon as I can breathe well, I'll call the meeting to order. Okay, actually, you're already turned on there. It is. I will call the meeting to order at this meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission. Roll call, please. Commissioner Agnich? Here. Commissioner Schroeder? Here. Commissioner Schroeder? Present. Vice Chair Schroeder? Yes. Chair Schroeder? Here. Fairly. Public comments?
4:37 This is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that doesn't otherwise appear. Good afternoon. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. I'm going to leave here and run over to the teleconference suite for Mono County having to do with the Mono County grants. I probably may not be able to be here for the balance of the meeting. I hope you all got a copy of the letter that MLTPA provided having to do with the accounting for the Measure R stuff. Bill Taylor, who is MLTPA's treasurer, is here, I think, on an unrelated matter. You can answer any questions you might have.
5:08 It just seems that there's some sort of technical regularities. Anything that we can do to be of help or to be of service to get some of these things resolved, we're more than willing to work with staff or work with the committee or whoever to help try to get some of these things figured out. So I appreciate hearing from me if you have any questions, and I look forward to coming back to the meeting if I can get away from Morrow County. So thank you. Thanks, John. Thanks, John. Any other public comments? We will close public comments.
5:42 Then go to consent. Does somebody want to pull something from consent or can I get a motion? I move to approve the consent agenda. Second. I have a motion to second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Okay. Policy matters. Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. Good afternoon. Steve Spidell, Trail Assisting.
6:19 Trail System Coordinating Committee Coordinator. I'm sad to report that we could not meet quorum yesterday for our meeting, but we are in the process of trying to put together a meeting for next Monday. In the meantime, we did want to move forward with the appointment of Peter Bernasconi, Public Works, to sit on the Trails Committee as the Town of Mammoth Lakes representative.
6:48 Stu Brown has been filling that position, and I'll editorialize and say it's been an extreme pleasure working with Stu on the committee, very insightful, very dedicated, and personally I want to thank him for all the work and effort that he's put in in this last year. I just realized the other day that I've been coordinating the committee for a year now, and it's been my pleasure to work with Stu. But now, as the Trails Committee,
7:16 As you know, we're moving forward with more fiscal-type capital projects, projects that are going to require more interaction with public works. So we feel it's a natural fit for the town manager then to appoint Peter Bernasconi to sit on the committee. So we'll be bringing the matter forward to the committee and asking them for their acceptance of that appointment and moving forward.
7:43 At this time I'm available to answer any questions that the Recreation Commission may have on the constituency of our committee. I guess the one thing that I would ask, I would say is I know Stu's been sitting on their, you know, committees typically don't have a town staff member as a sitting member on the committee. That was kind of an unusual situation for Stu. So I don't know if there would be another individual that would be put on that with Peter being the town's.
8:15 You know, support, you know, or if that's truly how everybody wants it to be. I mean, I don't know, because it's typically, like I say, usually committees don't have a staff member sitting on that committee, but usually more support, so I don't know. And if you recall, Teri, the original composition was that the town manager was sitting on the committee, so now the town manager is delegating.
8:44 Dan is here if he wants to add anything more to it. And I don't necessarily have a problem with it. It's just not typical. As a voting member of whatever committee, it's usually just support. And it was an odd thing to put together when we first put it together for the manager to sit on that. If we're changing things up, I don't know if this is the time to change it because there could be more changes with MLR, but, you know, I don't know. So it's just a comment. Thank you. Okay. Great.
9:14 Wait, could I have a comment on it as well? Going back to the history of it, remember the previous town manager volunteered to be a board member representing the government end on the board and put together. And he told us at that point that he would not be charging it. As a sitting member of the committee, it was not staffed, so we were not going to be billed for those hours out of the fund. So I just want to make sure that that, regardless who the town representative is,
9:42 And the council approved a town representative on this, so council would have to change that. But as long as we are not charging a rate for that town member sitting on there as a committee meeting. That was my concern. I think you have been being charged. Hasn't your time been charged? I've been charged meeting with Steve. Okay, but not for sitting on the committee meetings? Actually, this way, all those stewards are a valuable member of the committee.
10:10 This actually cleans that line up because Stu will be charging as he is needed for staff support. No, that's just a comment and I, you know, have full faith in the committee to make that decision. It's just a comment as to, you know, typical make-ups of committees. So, Stu, will you be attending any more of the MLTSCC meetings just as staff support? If needed. Okay. If needed. You know, again, a lot of it was just looking at...
10:40 So as a way of an update, too, on what we've been working on,
11:12 You may have noticed that now this snow that we are experiencing has enabled us to actually start the grooming program out at Shady Brass Campground. I was out there yesterday, as a matter of fact, and I put on my tourist hat, walked into the welcome center and asked the staff person, hey, where can I go cross-country skiing around here? Is there some winter grooming?
11:40 And she was sharp enough to say yes, as a matter of fact, right outside the door by that little cabin over there. And I have a map here for you to review if you'd like. So we talked a little bit and I thanked her and she said, but don't you want the map? And I said, well, no, I've got copies. You've passed the test. So now we know that when our guests do come and arrive and ask that question, they will be directed then to our winter grooming at Shady Rest. So it's really it.
12:08 It was exciting to see that it's in place and ready. So all we need is a little more snow. We got our base set down and track is set as well. So encourage members of the commission as well as the public in general, go out and enjoy it. It's yours. Have fun. Thanks. Our next big push and what we're going to be talking about a little bit later on today is trying to get another meeting together for the committee because we
12:35 Missed our last for lack of quorum. So we're trying to push for Monday the 10th at 1.30 in Suite Z and we'll have enough time to do the proper noticing and so forth if we get a final commitment on that date. And one of the reasons for moving this forward is we want to get out ahead of our list of projects that we're going to be looking at for the next fiscal year and also the budgeting.
13:03 allocations, recommendations for those projects to bring again forward to the Recreation Commission and then finally to the Town Council. And then my hope also in March is to have another PowerPoint presentation as I presented, I think it was in June, that again talked about our background, talked about our mission, talked about, this time it'll talk about our processes and the projects that we're moving forward with. So you can get a pretty good overall
13:31 idea of the progress that we're making and our vision for moving forward. The other thing that we want to make sure that we don't lose any momentum through any transition that may or may not happen between MLR and that work and that effort and the committee's work. So we are trying to keep things on track and moving and hopefully if MLR does.
13:57 Materialized, and the desire is to pull trails in, there'll be an easy transition. If not, then we'll still stay on our track and provide what we're doing. So we're hopeful that there will be no interruption through the committee's work through that process. And again, the main focus for us in our next meeting, probably next two meetings, is going to be looking forward to the next fiscal year, the list of projects that we're going to focus on, and the funding allocations for those projects.
14:28 Any other questions about our progress or our process? I think the only conflict we might have is we have a meeting here at 3 on Monday the 10th. So maybe the committee could meet at 1, go to 3. I don't know if 2 hours would be sufficient.
14:46 Well, I think, too, that we're sending out a lot of information for homework, and so it's not as though it's something new and different. We've also had a subcommittee, I failed to mention that, I'm sorry, where two members of the committee got together and started evaluating against our criteria so that they can bring that information forward, and hopefully that'll speed the process up. So, yeah, I would hope, Stu, that we could do it then from 1 to 3 and then transition into that follow-up meeting.
15:13 We could probably follow up with that. You know, again, my concern was I just didn't want to go a full month without having a meeting. So that's why we're pushing for Monday. Bill, you said you were available. Bill Sauser, I haven't had a chance to check in with you. As far as I know, there are no doctor's appointments that Monday. I apologize. I'm the reason they could not meet. I should have been there, but the doctor didn't. Yeah. The doctor was an appointment to be had for my mom and there was no getting around it. So, yeah.
15:39 I could not be there. And I don't know when Sandy Hogan is back and if your Bernice goes check. I don't think she's back until like the 17th or so. I think she's back next Monday. Oh, is she back next Monday? But I think she's coming in. Coming in on Monday. Jetlag, I think. But, you know, we could probably make two hours work. It's just I really want to make sure that the budget process specifically with the checklist is going forward. Is the town and county office available or is that something we want? Oh, we can't do Brannicus. We can do Brannicus soon. Yeah.
16:10 So we just have to be done by three. Well, at the very least, then we should do it. Bill, you good with a one to three start? Okay. Bill, does that work for you? As far as I know. Good. Let's plug it in and go from there. I do keep forgetting to hit the save button on my calendar. It's an important little button. Well, I'll endeavor between now and Wednesday evening when I fly back to Seattle to get all the proper noticing and get everything coordinated with the town.
16:42 We might have somebody as charming as Jamie helping us out for that meeting. Thank you very much. Thanks, Steve. Thank you. You notice he's from Seattle. His feet aren't quite hitting the ground. Okay. Okay. Measure R, Reconciliation. Stu, I'm assuming you want to lead us through this once and then we'll go back for questions. Or Dan, whoever's doing this. I shouldn't say that. Town Manager, sir.
17:15 The team tag a little bit, but I can have Duke and kick it off, and I'll go into some of that. Yeah, I mean, you probably had a chance to read a little bit of background, so really the goal with this to, as you know, is that the town performs the annual audit, but as you know, this audit is really only regarding the compliance with the stated ordinance and the municipal code.
17:38 This work effort essentially started several months ago. It really actually started probably a year ago when we were looking at a Recreation Program Administrator. We were looking at hiring someone to really perform a lot of these functions regarding Measure R, Measure U. And a portion or a large portion of that work effort was regarding the financial oversight of those funds. As you know, we didn't end up hiring that position, but we did contract with an employment agency to...
18:06 Have a consultant come in and essentially reconcile each and every account that we had and pull all our receipts and checks and try and balance each of those accounts. They're also able to incorporate that work into QuickBooks and then reconcile that against the AS400 or our accounting software. Dan will probably walk you through a lot of the detail that we've provided. The six-page
18:35 Attachment that kind of identifies each of the awards. And then Dan and Susan. If you know, Susan Cash is our accountant. Oh, is she? Yeah, Susan was right there. And then Susan maybe can speak later or during the meeting if you wish, but Susan's now kind of tasked with overseeing Measure R, Measure U. Before, I think it was just generally the finance department and Cindy, so...
19:02 Handing this off from the consultant to Susan, and we've got some good recommendations moving forward, so maybe Susan can talk about that later, but essentially Susan's here to answer any questions, and at this time I'll turn it over to Dan, who essentially compiled a lot of the spreadsheet and the detail for the Commission this afternoon. Thank you, Chair and Commission members. A couple things as walking through this, obviously, looking at it.
19:36 Freshly, if you will. Dive into RMU both a little bit, but one of the challenges in walking back through the reconciliation work is really the multiple handling of the dollar share we do, because with the dual award cycles creates a challenge. It's on a cash basis that runs kind of on a calendar year, but it's...
19:58 Not a true calendar year because of the way things are accrued forward or backward with true ups from the state activities. We also have a fiscal year process and when we actually have the town audit come forward, they're looking at everything on a fiscal year basis because that's the town's set fiscal year. So when they look at R&U, they're looking at it from a fiscal year basis, not a cash basis nor a award cycle basis.
20:27 So they do a different type of audit. Really, they're going to have these monies come in, been accounted appropriately with the right funds, and have they been spent according to the proper activity. So if you look at a town audit to this type of reconciliation to what you actually do under award cycle to award cycle, those numbers will not line up because they're looking at different time periods and different accepted counting practices for what we do to manage the town's funds.
20:55 Note in here that this has been ran on a cash basis, not a modified accrual basis. And even the cash basis doesn't really track a calendar or a fiscal year directly because of the way the cash flows come in on how sales tax is collected and reported. So you have your budget estimates, then you get actuals, you get true ups, and the end true up can be a plus or minus. So given that issue, that creates its own challenges in terms of the accounting work that gets done.
21:24 So part of that was part of the challenge, taking a look at that and trying to get the numbers at some point in time because it's an active account, so any given day you may have charges coming in or you have an invoice coming in. So at some point try to draw a line and say we'll go from this point forward. So the numbers here have pretty much tied in to kind of what we're shooting for end of December. We know there's been stuff coming in December and some additional adjustments that will still happen because of the timing of invoices that have come in.
21:52 And I think there's one or two payrolls that get accounted for, and the charges go back. Like on Stu's time, he puts into that. Following month, they go in and do adjustments, and then that gets charged back to the accounts where time was actually spent. So it's not an instantaneous charge, if you will, because of the way the system has been set up to be more of a cash basis type of operation. So to say that, that there will be, again, the numbers are...
22:18 The goal was to have them good through the end of December. There will be some additional adjustments in that. We think we've captured that in the way some of the information was laid out. The other elements that come into play on that, trying to structure it and looking at it, getting a handle on what's the actual fund balance available at the end of this time frame, where we're sitting at today at least with the last award cycle. Staff report, there's a brief chart in there. We did two different aspects of this, starting with
22:49 Here's a whole bunch of detailed records, and I think they're in Susan's office. If you go in there, you've got a banker's box full of each file for each project that's sitting there with all the receipts and invoices in it. Taking that information, rolling it up basically into the spreadsheet that you have in your packet, and then trying to take that up one step further and saying, if you look at the fund balance over time, how is that currently allocated?
23:13 So the chart, take a look at that kind of since inception if you look at what's the revenue received. And I think we got through, there's a piece of a January payment there, that $4.8 million just over that in total revenues. And then we actually dealt with funds expended versus funds awarded. And so we've actually expended just over $3.5 million. So you've awarded more than that, but the actual expenditures.
23:40 Through the time frame it's been $3.5 million. Again, that leaves you with the $1.3 million that would be in the bank, so to speak. That then gets allocated across how much of the projects are in process where the funds need to be encumbered. You think of capital projects, it's nothing for a capital project to extend over three years. I forget how long it took to complete the track, for example. Or you'll end up doing studies and you'll end up doing...
24:07 Engineering, then you end up doing a bid award contract and the contract might extend over, again in this case, multiple funding cycles, multiple fiscal years and multiple calendar years. So you'll see that encumbrances, some of these projects going, okay, we need to tie these dollars up so they don't fall out until the project is actually completely closed out. And so that encumbrance column becomes very important in that.
24:32 Saying over as we close out projects, the estimate is we'll spend another $741,000. Now that number again when we close out projects, that'll move from that encumbrance to closed out projects. So some of those dollars may end up being available for future use if projects come in below that. And then based on the previous actions, there was $440,000 put into the capital reserve account. So that is
25:02 And this analysis shows that it's committed to that. Ultimately, it's committed for capital projects that can be awarded accordingly if it goes through the process for things. And then what it drops out into is looking at all those projects and going, are they actually closed out? And if everything walks through kind of the spreadsheet on that and says these projects are closed, there are $60,000 that falls out to the bottom that was in excess, if you will.
25:31 of what was awarded, what was expended, what's been encumbered, and what's remaining at the end of the day is $60,000 that is uncommitted through the process. Based on the action, the council's last resolution on that, those funds would roll into the capital reserve as policy-wise. Then if there's a project that comes forward exactly, come back through the commission, go back through.
25:57 The awarding process to go into that. But it would tie it up versus have it sitting back there to automatically roll into the pot next year. It would start off in the capital account so it's not necessarily automatically available for award in a future cycle. I think that was the goal of trying to tie that up into that capital reserve. Now that doesn't mean a request can't come in and say we want to spend like we have, I think it's R the $200,000 potentially for trails in park at RU.
26:27 R. So, sorry, every now and again, got a couple other funds to get in the way too, so. But anyway, so like ideally you'd come back in and say, let's say we have it actually an item going to the council this week to go after that grant from the state. We get that grant, we'd come back in and say, receive the grant, the matching funds were identified as Measure R for $200,000 requesting those dollars to move out of the capital reserve up to an awarded project. So you'd go through that process and other elements could hit that as well. So the,
26:59 Challenge on this was trying to do it in a summary fashion and initially try to look at one other consolidation in a summary, but then it just got more confusing, I think. So you've got six pages of small print. And so we tried to walk through these and say, what was the funding award, the one column there? What was that funding used? And you'll see the term transferred there, too, because some of these actually go to a capital project fund.
27:25 And then they're spent out of that. And to the extent they're not completely expended, those funds then would be transferred back to Measure R into the account and fall out again as that ending fund balance. And so even going back to the 09 one, you had a couple projects there. One of them, just to use as an example, you've got one just in terms of a CEQA consultant work. That work is completed. It's closed out. There was $1,700. It wasn't spent. This is on page one of six of them. That would fall into that fund balance column.
27:55 We're in the process still of trying to nail out all of the Whitmore track project. There's still, I think, one standing invoice and some work with the contractor. And so that project technically has not yet been closed out. And so when that ultimately happens, there's been some battles back and forth on grants and invoices. And yes, we understand you did that, but you're going to do it for free and we're not going to pay that. So there's some back and forth on some issues on the track. So once we close that project out,
28:25 I don't know if this $5,000 will be committed in that final accounting or if it will be available. If it is, then it would follow that fund balance column. That was one of my questions. I don't know if you want to take questions right now, but I guess when I'm looking at 2009 and the track project has been completed for at least two years. It hasn't been final, the accounting hasn't been finally closed out. There's been, I don't know all the details of it, but I know we have some accounts receivables.
28:55 and issues that we're dealing with from the contract originally, some grant awards, some Cal Recycle Dollars or something was in that. The company had a grant program as well as the funding program. Until that gets resolved, then we had one failure piece on the track, I think, that had to go back and they had to go in and patch it. They had to go back and fix it as a contractor. But that shouldn't affect that. It should not. It's in the total project. The project hasn't been completely closed out. That's why it's sitting in this encumbered column. It may end up.
29:24 Moving over to that fund balance column. But until we close the project out, we didn't move the money out of the encumbered column. I guess my question is if we need to have some kind of a safeguard to make, I mean, I understand that some capital projects are naturally going to go over years, but I want to make sure that we're not encumbering funds and then they're just kind of hanging out there. That was a challenge in working through it. Should we use later for something that's...
29:50 In addition to what was originally contracted, I guess. The idea isn't to say, oh, good, we have more track work, let's throw this dollars into it. It's still tied to that same authorized project that there should be anyway in terms of closing out the overall construction track. And you can walk through a number of these, and it's like the MLTPA process. And I'll address a couple of John's comments. There, because of the way that ward goes, there's a ward in one cycle, then there's another partial ward, another cycle, then there's another ward.
30:20 If you actually start to reconcile those out, I didn't go through the last couple years, but you start to reconcile what's awarded and what they spent is down to like within $1,100 or so. And that flows because of the award cycle, but the work necessarily doesn't follow. If you do a $200,000 award and there's another $50,000 award coming, you hit that $200,000 award. They don't stop working knowing the other one's coming, so some of the billing gets, and then timing of billing comes in.
30:49 So it's not as clean as it could be from a pure cash issue because you'd say, okay, that award's done. Please do not bill us until there's a future award cycle. Yes, but we're working on this project, and you've already said we would put that in the other award, so they're working on it. There's $300,000 set aside. Do you want questions now? Yeah, let me finish one with a couple comments, and then dive into it. So just trying to use that first year as an example of where you get this reserved column, this encumbrance column.
31:20 And then the fund balance column. And as projects are closed out, those will be cleaned up. And hopefully these older years, as we get a couple of these done, they will get cleaned up relatively quickly if that falls out. The newer years, if you will, you go to the most recent award, for example, you've got obviously a lot more of those that haven't been initiated yet in the projects and that. So you're going to see a lot of that just sitting in the...
31:52 Kind of the awarded column. Showing there the funding being utilized because there's just been no activity there. So we just committed it all there to say it's committed until you actually begin to have activity of what would happen. The other option was to show all that as encumbered, but kind of that 13 followed work. So the question is how to handle part of that. Then it drops down. It does the fund balance information on the sheets. And to try to get a picture just of what the fund may look like.
32:22 There's another column there that takes a look at what the fiscal year might look like. Again, the committee doesn't work off the fiscal year process, but we're trying to take a look and say what does that begin to look like. Well, we know sales tax will actually be down this year from what was budgeted, so that will impact ultimately the actuals that come in, those projections to that. But it gives you a feel of what the fund may look like in the fiscal year. We do that because we'll be comparing that to our audit reports.
32:53 from a town element that walks through those. And real quick on MLTPA's comments, the Fall 2009 and the 2010 Spring Awards, again on page one of six, if you see the second entry under the 2010 Spring Award MLTPA that mentions wayfinding and standards manual, there's 17.5 there.
33:20 They were working on that project with the town, but they actually weren't the awardee the town was, so that would make a town award there, which that wouldn't be part of their contract, but because they were working on the standards in their other projects, just in terms of the labeling, they got labeled into that column. Actually, I hate to say it, it's not correct. For that piece there? For the 17-5 that John was...
33:47 Asking about there? Asking about. Right. Because your fall 2009 award is $283,500, and if you look at what was awarded, it was only $266,000, which is that $17,500. Difference, and that got pulled down to another category. No, because then that should have been stuck still there, and then there was another one at the $17,500 there. So it's just that one needs to be reduced down to the $266,000.
34:12 For the MLTS one there in terms of the... For Fall 2009 Award for Mammoth Trails, or for... MLTPA. Not Mammoth Trails, I'm sorry, MLTPA. Yeah. Where it says Contractual Services for MLTS. Yeah. You have $283.5. If you go back to the awarded amount, it was the $266 and then the contingency for the next spring award of the $55.520. So it's just that that amount was...
34:41 Incorrect in what it was supposed to be. There may be something else in that account then we'd have to go back and check. Just if you look at the award, I have it here. Yeah, I mean, if there's something else in terms of the project work that was done. But I can, we'll check it. Yeah, if you have it, the award is probably clean there, so we'll, I did not go through all the funding awards list, but I know the one down here also looks to be, we'll make sure that that, because that's a capital project account down at the bottom.
35:08 Generally, which then we don't have MLT paid out of the capital. I think it was just an oversight. Yeah. So we'll work that and clean that up. I think the ultimately accounting came out to the right numbers in total. So it may be order to pull two in front. Some of the other detail requested wasn't the purpose of this report. We're talking about was the information on the various projects. We've actually in turn of it looking at how do you do a little.
35:35 Write-up on each of the various projects that's been completed, and that'll come forward the next couple of months to the commission in terms of the projects completed in the town. I'd like to see that myself, so I want to bring something back that talks about each of the projects. The ones you may not get much of a write-on would be admin time. We'll just put a picture of stew there and call it good. Mom, would that include the MLTSCC allocation projects as well? Actually, there's a whole...
36:02 Massive spreadsheet of those if you want them. I was looking for the town project versus the committee's project. I have the spreadsheet. Yeah, we haven't asked them to do that on that level yet, but they could do it. There's extra work there. It's beneficial to do it. I think from the town projects, I wanted to get an overview of what each of those projects look like, and part of that's just for our capital process and planning and things that we're doing internally.
36:31 On record keeping in the CIP side of the house. So you can go back a couple of years and say, what did we accomplish? And then looking forward and starting to track that in our way that I think would have a little more input to the community if they look at it too. What does this mean? You know, it's talking about playground equipment. Well, what was that? Was that a teeter-totter or was that a full-blown little kids play area with fall protection, et cetera?
37:00 That was one of my comments. I think we really need a checklist. These are completed projects. These are, here's a project that's not complete. This is what percentage is complete. This is what the expected, you know, completion date is. Yeah, because a number of these are multi-year ones, and so you're walking through that and say this part's done. Most of our capital projects will have that. You'll go through and say plenary design is done, plans are done, we're at 50% construction, we're at 60%.
37:28 We're in a punch list category. It's now closed out. So you can walk through those. That would be good to see as well. I think it would be really good to be presented all the time and that's kept up because I think that's something we've been, as a commission, really remiss on asking when I'm looking at these. When I'm looking at this, we've been very remiss on what we've asked for. Yeah, so you start to work through those. And that was good for us to try and reconcile through these numbers by project. And what we initially looked at is do you take a project?
37:58 That goes over multiple award cycles and multiple years and you just consolidate that into a single project. But then the challenge there is, well, what award cycle did the money come out of? That was one of the other initial analysis looking at this going, let's take all of the same, like all MLTPA stuff would be one line item. But that's problematic too in terms of what year and when or so. That was one more of my comments and I don't know if maybe instead of it saying that it's a multi-year contract.
38:28 If we could get the year that the funding cycle that it was funded so that if you want to go back and say, well, why is this, you know, $30,000 in the red, you know, we can go back and say, oh, okay, well, it started here and then you can actually track it as opposed to just doing a multi-year contract where it's very difficult to track what goes where. And my knowledge of the past years, I don't know which one of those tied to what, but I know it's been a multi-year process and there's a lot of individual projects.
38:56 In that category, for example, that have been completed, checked off, done. And again, that data is available. It just started to consolidate. That would give you another five or six spreadsheets probably in terms of just that level of detail. I guess I'm just looking at where you have here where it just says whether the project's completed or it's over multiple cycles. If we could have just a reference as to which cycle that's referring to. It all rolls down.
39:24 And then the MLTPA one, or the trails-related one, the other question was, is that a $1.5 million five-year project with a whole bunch of stuff being done along the way? You can handle it either way because those funds are committed as far as I'm concerned to that project, so ongoing, making that assumption. Anyway, you can work through that. There's half a dozen different ways you can kind of slice the pie here. The question becomes,
39:53 What do you want to see and the benefit of seeing it gives you comfort or understanding or knowledge in terms that's beneficial to spend the process of working through the detail levels. So that can be done. Like I say, we tried to roll this up and to make it really today was trying to come in and say, here's where we stand with the finances. There's a separate one to come back in and say, here's where we stand by the projects related back to those.
40:23 I was trying to get this to you versus saying, wait a couple of months until we get the other piece done. I'd rather try to get information to you. Absolutely appreciate that. Given the comments you're making, that'll help us also build the next piece. Hopefully. Why don't we go through all of Terri's questions. If she doesn't...
40:41 We'll cover it all. May I just ask you a quick question on the staff report first? Because I know Teri is probably going to go into some detail. It's probably going to mirror mine. Just a quick question on page three of the staff report, where it says that the ending fund balance will be allocated to the capital projects reserve. I thought we were calling that the capital reserve account. And the reason that I'm asking this is just because I don't want this to be confused at all with CIP.
41:07 No, it's definitely, and it's more of a nomenclature within our own accounting system, otherwise you end up with multiple categories. You're correct, it's not part of the town's capital improvement program. It is a designation within the major R fund balance for capital, and designating it that way, frankly, again, if it goes through the process, you'd come back and say, we actually want to put that up.
41:35 Operational of something, and that would be a process that you would have to go through as any request would come in. I just wanted to make sure we were clear on that because I think there were several concerns expressed. This is not part of the city's, the town's capital improvement program funding. If they want a project, they've got to come in and do the same process.
41:57 In fact, it's restricted Measure R funds, which actually can't be utilized unless it comes through the Measure R process and approved by the council. So yeah, those two check. And I understand that. I just wanted to make sure that that nomenclature wasn't too close. And that's fully the intent of that as well. So it's on the record here for that purpose. Thank you. But yeah. We can label in a staff report. We can label whatever we want. When you start to get into your accounting records, you try to be consistent across the council or else it messes people up.
42:28 Okay. Thanks. So those elements that come into play that way. I can start with just a couple questions of, you know, kind of reporting what you guys can do and what you can't do. So understanding that, you know,
42:44 Measure R works on a cash basis, and you're working on an accrual basis, which is why, because when I first looked at this, I just went, phew, what? Because there's so many numbers that are just, you know, out there. Until I sat down and finally went year by year by year and looked at what the allocations were that were awarded and then followed that allocation through.
43:03 You know, over the years. And then I still have some questions on that. So I actually would really like to kind of come back and maybe sit down and talk kind of more in detail on some of these. But as far as the reporting goes, can you run a report over multiple years? So if you took, you know, three years or a five-year period and instead of actually breaking it out into spring, fall,
43:29 It could be identified where it was funded in a column that this was a spring 2009 or fall 2009, but then your account would actually, you know, show all your income, all your expenses under that one grant award so that you're not having to follow it over three pages of, you know, financial documents. And I don't know if that's something that we could possibly do.
43:56 You know, otherwise the other part would be to, on a situation like that, is to then to have the attachment that here's this award and now here's, you know, follow through and that's separate from this so that people can follow it. Because I will tell you, I've been involved in this process the entire time and it still took me a long time to figure out what it was, what the allocations were, and to track it through how you guys have it here.
44:22 So, you know, for somebody just to go on the website and to look at something like this or to look at this reconciliation, it really doesn't bode well for some of these folks that got the money. It's kind of MLTPA, for one, a biggie, because you're looking at, you know, well, why is there $10,000 that they spent over what their contract was supposed to be? And that's not the case. It's just the way that it's put together here. That's very much what it looks like. So it's, you know, I don't know.
44:52 If we can resolve that in some manner, but if we can, that would be great, and I don't know. We can add that little detail. It's not just printing a report to give it to you. You'll be printing multiple, and it'll be a manual feedback into it like a spreadsheet. You can't put a date range in and say, I want to go. Because, again, we can do that, but you'll get it right now, and you'd end up on a fiscal year.
45:15 It won't be what you're asking for. Well, even a fiscal year, if you put two to three fiscal years in there, will it combine those numbers or does it still keep them separated? It keeps them in the columns by fiscal year so that you've got to do the... Our financial system is pretty limited. You can have the current month or the current year and there's nothing in between there. So that was part of the thought of moving, of trying to get a translation into QuickBooks.
45:44 I'm going to go with the disclaimer that all of this work was done by a consultant, and I haven't had the opportunity to review the work in detail. But the thought with QuickBooks was that it does have the flexibility to be able to do that any time frame you want and parse out the numbers a little bit better and describe a little bit better. But that work was just done, was just completed within the last couple of weeks, and I haven't had time to really showcase the...
46:13 Abilities of QuickBooks. My preference would be that you would not be looking at the spreadsheet. You would be looking at QuickBooks printouts that we don't have to translate for you because they've already been translated. And so then that kind of goes back to my other comment that I already made that instead of saying project over multiple years, if you could put the year that it was awarded and then put, you know, CE, whatever, over a three-year period or something, so then you're going to at least try to track back.
46:43 You know, there's a few things that I could suggest, but that's... Yeah, a couple of these will roll into each other, so it won't be clean until you get ultimately completely done on a couple of them, so even that process. But initially, I started to look at it, too, as can you do it by project and list out, and it got messy, so... So this is just all kind of clarification and cleanup stuff. When I was trying to go back and match awards to what was presented here...
47:10 As of, I think, Fall 2010, there's nothing on there, on the website, as to what was awarded. There's applications on there posted on the Measure R part, so this is just kind of a cleanup thing. We ought to put what the actual awards were, so that somebody can kind of track and make heads or tails of what was awarded, because once you get to a certain point, all I can look at is what the applications were and go by memory, which...
47:41 That's all scary sometimes. So anyhow, we need to update. I know that there's been a lot of things going on, but we need to update that just so that we have all of the information there for people that are looking for that. I'm not going to go through all of these because I would really want to sit down with somebody to kind of go over all my questions. But one thing that I've brought up at a meeting because it was with the roller rink and kind of put within.
48:09 The last application that came through, there was monies that was left over at the end of operations last year. So there were monies that were still spent for the operations, for the roller rink, but they're going to be used for this next year. And the way that Measure R was put together, if there's monies left over at the end of the cycle, and I'm looking at, like, you know, town...
48:34 Admin, that's the same thing. I mean, town admin, I can't imagine that you can't close out 2009. You know, it's only $263, but it should roll back into that account as opposed to being held in the project balance account. And just for clarification on the administrative portion, when I looked at this, received this from the consultant and went into QuickBooks where these numbers are generated, she hadn't put benefits in them.
49:03 So that's why we chose to keep it at least for the next couple weeks until I can add those costs. So admin benefits haven't been put in there. Yeah, so those numbers will be cleaned up fairly shortly, but I didn't have a chance to do that. Okay. You don't want to show it available and come back and say, whoops, no, sorry, it goes. So if you encumber it, at least it's identified for that at a minimum. It's utilized appropriately or it drops back into the fundamentals.
49:32 Yeah, and like I said, I'm not going to sit here because I have two pages of questions that I have there, but there's a couple of those things that are in here as well, and I just want to clarify because, you know, I'm seeing that there's monies that are still being held over that should have been a completed project, so I don't know why it hasn't been completed, and those are going to be some of my questions, and so, you know, those monies should have been moved over into the fund balance reserve section.
50:01 And I just think that we need to keep that really clean unless we go to a different type of allocation and award process because I'm sure if the state gave us a grant award and we went over $10,000 that we certainly couldn't go back to the state and say, gee, I'm sorry, we went over $10,000. Can you give us some more money? And I see this as the exact same thing.
50:27 I think that we need to be really careful and clear on that. And I will go over and I'll put all this down because I still haven't finished it completely. And I would love to sit down and spend some time with someone and go over it. But I think you need to show the actual cost. So if a project did go over by $10,000, it doesn't necessarily mean that you go back and ask the grantee for more money or the grantor. You know, it's just that was the cost of the project. And it went over and monies came from.
50:56 From Measure R. From what this is showing is they're coming back out of Measure R. So that's my concern is, you know, if it went over and you came back to the commission and said, hey, this is going to go over, we need an emergency allocation, you know, then that could be accounted for, and then that would go back to council, could be approved, to be accounted for.
51:24 From what I'm seeing, it is not. So there's a couple of them. And so that's why I'd like to get it cleaned up, and then you can come back and present it and say this is why it was. I think just quickly, are you looking at that event equipment, one that's over by 10,436? Because remember, the additional event equipment is below it that they asked for 8344, so that was awarded. So if you see if you minus those two, you're off five hours, was it?
51:54 2,100. 2,100. So that was really the difference with those two accounts. So that's kind of where you see, remember they came back and they said, you know, we need additional event equipment. But we've posted all the expenditures in that one line item. We didn't post them down to that additional one.
52:09 So again, that's just what Dan was explaining to you guys, where it was posted. And that's the problem, is you're trying to follow that, but there's still some discrepancies in that. And so I would love to sit down with somebody instead of sitting here tonight and walk through a lot of these. I know you had some small adjustments down again. We had some order of equipment, for example, where the allocation doesn't include shipping costs. To come back and go through a process for a couple hundred bucks is...
52:38 Doable, but you kind of... You know, I guess it's not really going through a huge process. It's putting something down, it's presenting it to the commission, and then that goes to council just so it's staying clean and saying that this is what was spent. And, you know, and asking for those monies instead of just assuming. Well, it's still spent because you've got to pay for the...
53:02 Well, but then I guess if that's the case, then it comes out of general fund. I apologize, but it comes out of general fund unless it comes back through. Well, I think those are the sorts of things that should be noted in, you know, performance reports. Yeah. The other option of that is you just don't buy it. You come back and get the money. You don't buy it. You come back and, you know, I don't think it would be a lengthy process, and I don't think we have to sit and have a huge meeting and a workshop and everything else for something like that. But come back and just be clarified.
53:29 Well, you know, Measure R monies, I think the whole process has evolved, so I guess my question would be, is this still happening here today, 2013-14? And if it is, then there's an issue, but you're going back to 2009 where, I mean, you were giving money to people who shouldn't be receiving money for tennis court repairs and, you know, things like that, so it's gotten cleaned up quite a bit.
53:55 Yeah, no, it's happened a little bit all the way through. I'm just looking at this report, and as somebody who is not a bookkeeper, it looks to me like we have overpaid for projects where we set a limit on it. I understand, beginning, the light's starting to come on that that's not the case because it appears someplace else, but somehow we need to find a way to report that back on a project-by-project basis or something over multiple years so it's just the project not laid out.
54:24 So the public can understand. Because I promise you, if some of the people that really look at this stuff are going to come back to us and say, you only awarded this. They shouldn't have been able to do this. So the other phase of backup behind this is you can do a project-by-project accounting, which is going to give you a different look by different time frames. It's not going to be over. Some stuff is one cycle, boom, done.
54:53 Other stuff will be over multiple. And then some of these projects have other fundings, too. So you end up, well, you want to see that or not. But you can do, I know, like the wayfinding stuff. There was other dollars from other agencies of town, et cetera, that go into all that. So the project itself might be substantially more than what's listed here. But we can clean these up to show that project by project, allocation process by project.
55:18 That can be done. I would like to bring up two specifics because it would be wonderful to have an answer to. So 2009, there's the Tannum Amphlet Gap Closure Alignment. And so that's still in there. There was $1,954 spent. There's still $8,000 there. It was a $10,000. I'm sure it was a grant match. I'd have to go back to my notes to see. It says, but I guess, why hasn't this project been done?
55:47 Why hasn't it been completed? Because if I'm looking at something that was awarded in 2009, what the cost to do that today in 2014 is going to be substantially more than what it was in 2009. At least that would be my thought. And so if it hasn't been done, and if it's not going to be done, I don't know why, but then those should come back. But these are the types of reports that should be coming back to the commission so that...
56:14 We can keep track of these things, and I think that's where if we have that checklist, then we'll be able to keep track of things a little bit better. Yeah, because I know that project is not completed, but yeah. You know, but like I said, if it hasn't been, you know, the cost that it's going to be in 2014 compared to 2009. Yeah. One other one that I would really like to, because it concerns me, because the way it came forward was it was in a spring award, and it was an urgent application that said urgency there.
56:43 on the application that it had to be done, and that's the $70,000, $807 for the phase three wayfinding. And, you know, because, and I guess my concern is that it was brought forward in a spring award as an urgent issue, yet none of the money's been expended. Yeah, we can address that. I think that one has been done. That one had multiple funding sources to it, and so I left it in the,
57:14 Encumbered Column, because we're going through all of that. Some of this money may be left over, but because of all the different funding parts, that's going to close out on the project. I couldn't tell you if this has been 100% used or 99% used, but because of all the other pieces of the funding that's going through that. That particular one, I think I remember, we had to allocate the money so they could let the contract. Correct. Which is fine. That's 2011. This is 2014.
57:38 Well, and I don't want us to have to rely on our institutional memories. No. And there is a project sheet for that that's in the process. I know Hayes is working through that because I think we had four service money, this money, and something like there was one or two other pieces. We had five different funding streams, I believe, and we, so how our capital projects happen is they extend through the year, through the year, through the year, and at the end of the year, then we start looking at what needs to be, which projects need to be charged.
58:07 And certainly the more lenient a funder is, the later we charge them. We want to get those costs to the Forest Service and the cost to the state of California and the federal government first and foremost, and then backfill with anything that's local in case we don't use it all. And then we can return it to a local funding source rather than to the state. So the costs on the project have only been accrued through June of 2013. Hayes is in the middle of...
58:34 Looking to see if the project can be closed out and the last of the revenues brought in to match the expenses. So this is one award that we have been talking about a lot. And he's investigating whether or not he's actually expended it. Okay. Because, yeah, because that doesn't actually, you know, it would be nice to have some type of information into something like that because it just looks like it's just kind of hanging out there, nothing's been done. So I don't know how we...
59:01 Reconcile some of these things so that we get some information and you're not putting, because you know, like I say, you put this information out here and it could cause more problems than not and so we need to figure out how we can clarify some of these things a little bit more. We're hoping to get a little more timely too on capital projects.
59:21 That's the work in process. No, and this is a great start, and I appreciate it, because this has been, you know, a long time coming. My goal on this one was to try to get a snapshot, at least as of X date, this is where we are in the current numbers, the information that Elena was pulling together, basically. Yeah, so I completely appreciate what you guys have put together, and that's why I say instead of going through all this, I'll sit down with somebody and set up something. Be good.
59:50 I have a broader stroke question. On page four, you're kind of talking about town administration for measure our expenditures, which is 2.8%. I appreciate having the summary there. I think it's great to give a big picture. You look at the staff report or the chart. The staff report table one. So town administration, and then the next column down, it talks about administration.
1:00:20 3.5%. So my question is, is 2.8% the town administration of all these projects, and then when you combine them all together with administration from other elements of these other projects, then it becomes 3.5%? We just added the MLR facilitation number into that number there. So, you know, I consider facilitation administration, so that's the only .7 that we added to the 2.8, the 3.5, yeah.
1:00:50 All right. And then that comes... I just tried to group it in categories just to give you some... Yeah. But that's my other question, too. On page five where you show the chart, which looks great, and I think Bill's probably very happy to see this with 75% of the money is going towards capital projects. But is there some way to define what percentage of some of this work really went to planning and administration as opposed to shovel-in-the-ground projects? And I kind of think about...
1:01:20 MLTPA, and a lot of the work that they've done is more behind the scenes, report writing, administration, things getting us to this point, but not construction projects. So is there a way to extract that money so it's a little bit more accurate instead of lumping it together? This is like more project work but not physical construction.
1:01:45 Well, when I look at it, I see 75% capital projects. Wow, that's great. We're building all kinds of things. Trails. And we are, which is terrific. But I think there's a lot of administrative costs that go into that 75%. Yeah, and I don't know if we have a clean break of that to say when you do a capital project, it doesn't just happen by itself. So you have costs associated with it, which is charging part of project costs.
1:02:12 Whenever we do something at the town, I'm asking, okay, what's the capital project cost? And I'll say, it's a million dollars. And then I'll go, well, why is your budget a million two hundred? And I'll go, well, you got ten percent for inspections and you got permits of five percent and you got staff time of x percent. Of course. So your total capital project is much larger than... But I think it would be helpful if you're going to the next phase to kind of look at how you could break that down a little bit more. What's actually a physical...
1:02:41 Capital and what's planning capital? Is that kind of what you're looking at? Exactly. Because you have a lot of, yeah, there may be a way to break some of that out. It'd be like the track work. We'd still count all that as a capital project. I'd hate to have to go back through and do the work to say, well, that included $5,000 of staff time managing the project versus just the, maybe to break that out, it was tough. Are you asking for it on a total measure or basis because the difficulty with that? Multiple projects.
1:03:10 would be when you have a contractor like the Eastern Sierra Dog Agility Group, we would have to be asking them for that information split out. But I don't think groups like that were charging. That was actually a purchase of equipment. I'm just using them as an example that we would have to ask every one of our contractors to break that out. And quite frankly, you can see we're struggling trying to just get the real hard numbers and to parse that out.
1:03:36 Would be difficult. Certainly on a commission level you can set a limit on your awards, but to gather that information without that limitation, first of all, having been set and the grantee being expected to report it to us, and I don't know how we, it would be another spreadsheet and the accuracy of those.
1:04:01 I think that we know that there will be staff costs allocated to any kind of construction projects, so that's a given. But I look at High Sierra Striders and groups like that, they didn't, none of their planning or administrative time was put into this Measure R money, but staff time was. But just by virtue of the MLTPA organization, you know, I think that a large percentage of their time and effort was more administration or planning.
1:04:31 As opposed to some of the other groups that are just a little bit more straightforward. For the large ones like that, MLTPA for example, there is a subsidiary element for that. You could have a chart component, but you could probably pull out multiple funding sources, maybe problematic, but you could show out contract awards for the actual construction of projects. It would give you a feel of how much of that 75%.
1:05:00 Went into the ground, and that wouldn't include the staff admin time, you'd just be doing contractual awards for actual construction, which would be a different number. Yeah, maybe, it doesn't have to be down to the minutiae, but maybe there's some abroad kind of guesstimate. I understand what you're after, some of the calculations, because then you're going back and doing extra work bifurcating out.
1:05:27 Different pieces that aren't all Measure R at the time. So that's the other challenge. But I see what you're asking for. We'll be able to pull some of that would help. Yeah. I think the other point, too, that Pat's trying to make is that, you know, certainly with MLTPA, they brought a lot of additional leverage, you know, to the awards as well. And that doesn't kind of, or it's not reflected in here, too. So if you look at their resource, their in-kind, and what they're going to provide on a dollar basis. So on the other side of the fence, that's not included either. And that could be far more than what this 1.3 indicates.
1:05:56 You know, anyway, so it's, you know, so it's, like, say you have a lot of other funding coming in. Forest Service dollars coming into a project wouldn't be recaptured here either, so. But the bid that we have would incorporate that type of, so part of that question becomes the benefit of having it versus the staff time going in to create it, I guess, and I'll weigh that a little bit. But I think some of the base information you're asking for can be pulled together probably more in a text format that may help address your question.
1:06:26 And I do agree that as I report back to the public, you know, it's nice for them to see that, you know, how much their measure our dollars were leveraged, you know, both in, you know, in money and even in, you know, volunteer hours because we count those on, you know, when we make the, when we review the applications. And maybe that could be in part of that checklist that we put together. I'm just concerned because even internally I have no way of knowing when I look at a payroll code.
1:06:51 I have no way of knowing who it is and what they were doing without going back to the actual timesheets. And now our admin, 4% is growing because I'm going back to timesheets and manually calculating whether someone was shoveling or someone was writing a report. Well, maybe that's something for the future for consideration, you know, as of, you know, maybe not going back to 2009, but in the future because it shouldn't be that hard to track staff costs.
1:07:20 It shouldn't be, but we are working with a probably 30-year-old financial system that can't give me May 5th through May 10th expenses. I can have May, or I can have the whole year. Well, maybe that's less in reconciliation than it is in, you know, in performance reporting. I think you might be looking at that because I guess I don't mind getting the information pulled out, but I also want to manage how much staff time we put in and pull in the data for me. Yes, it's great to have, but...
1:07:49 I kind of asked this, so what question at the end of the day on it? I don't think you have enough to be able to come for where you're at right now, but if it's too level of detail, I can take half of Susan's time and charge it to Measure R, which doesn't make any sense either. No, but I guess just looking at the chart, it says administration 4%, and that's probably what people will see, the layperson, and that's what they'll think, and it's probably more than that.
1:08:12 A little bit different, that's all. Yeah, that question, I guess we're trying to show here is general admin that's not committed to a hard project. Town administration of the Measure R funds is what that is, basically. My time, Susan's time. I think we all know that. Yeah. So maybe we can just label it better? Yeah. Okay. Because there's, I mean, there's right, for instance, Steve's time in administration that's actually captured in.
1:08:36 Capital. Capital in the trials project. And I think that's kind of a project specific versus general administration funds. So that's, you know, so you're going to get some movement in there too. But his time is broken now because he gives us records of that. So why not record that? Some of it's probably easily broken out and others. Yeah, you can break a little bit. Right. Anyhow. Really more important for me to push the fund is.
1:09:04 The breakout, which we can't do, I don't think, of what the actual hard cost was of each project and how much of it was paid for by Measure R. Because that's the important thing, the leveraging thing you're talking about. It would be nice to say that Measure R put...
1:09:19 What is it? $800 and some thousand dollars into the track. Actually, it comes to more than that. I think it's like $1.4 million or whatever it is. But the track's a $3 million project. That's something we can hang our hats on. And I didn't think about it until this was just confused me and gave me a headache. That was part of the goal. You succeeded.
1:09:43 That's a good point. But in terms of going back to the public with a report, if there was some way to go back to... We think that's important, too. Yeah, because that's huge. The MLTPA projects, okay, they got $1 million. However, we got a $2 million product. You know, they all go on and on. We've pushed it really hard. So to me, that would be... Yep. Any more questions, Pat? No. Thank you.
1:10:12 And once again, great start, great beginning. Yeah. Thanks for giving us. It's better to have more information than less. This helps you figure out what you're looking for from my perspective. Yeah. Again. Yeah, thank you. Well, and I appreciate Susan's comments, too, in terms of, you know, how, you know, that she's just looking at this. Well, Dan will promise you anything and so will Sue. I'm the one that's going to have to do it and I'm trying to figure out how exactly I'm going to get that information because it's not parsed out in our system.
1:10:40 But when you said earlier, though, that you would have maybe presented this a little bit differently, I appreciate you. I'm assuming with your program that you can't put anything into Excel and upload it into an Excel spreadsheet? No. It's all manual. So everything that the consultant has done to translate this into...
1:11:02 QuickBooks is very much appreciated because it was all manual entry and I'm hoping from there I can massage it into something that will be useful for you because I can give you a project by project. Here was the award, here were the expenses in whichever categories we paid them out and this is the bill. Oh, you can do that. Okay. Yes, I didn't give those reports to you because I haven't verified the numbers. So, soon.
1:11:27 Can I ask a question along those lines then? So it's being entered into QuickBooks or into Excel? I'm sorry, I missed that. QuickBooks. Into QuickBooks. It's already in QuickBooks. Okay. But once you get it into QuickBooks, you're able to export it to Excel. You can export it to Excel, but it already makes pretty reports. Okay, I just wanted to reiterate that I think what would be really nice is some kind of cross-referencing so that, and I know dealing with Excel myself fairly regularly, that you are able to pull up different reports when you're able to sort the data. And once we get all the base data, this is...
1:11:55 Okay. But it sounds like we're in good shape. You're going to be able to give those reports. Yes. Okay, great. I hope so. Okay, any more questions?
1:12:09 On this subject, we need to be moving on. Just real quick. We just talked about performance reports. Are we going to create a column that says yes, no, date? What was it? What I heard? Or when a project is closed, then we should. Well, actually, I want to see a little paragraph write-up on that, too. Just here's what the project was. Here's what, you know, I think you need a little more detail than just, you know. I'd like a performance report, but I would also like just that simple list that says here's what was awarded. Here's.
1:12:37 The percentage is completed. Yeah. Here's, you know, and so that we can kind of keep track of things that way because there were a couple trails things that I thought had been done, you know, so anyhow. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Moving on then. Town of Mammoth Lakes Board of July Celebration. All right. So,
1:13:03 Agenda item number seven. So what we're really saying here is we're giving a brief background on what the town has contributed in the past. We've also attached a spreadsheet at the back that we could probably go through. Another spreadsheet, sorry. I think it's a little bit clearer, though. So we can go through that, but really what we're saying here is that...
1:13:23 We have a fundraising group out there that's kind of formed. You can see we've identified the members doing a fantastic job, great effort in raising private funds for the event. So that's moving forward. You can see there on the second paragraph, we're looking at approximately $7,000 still required, and we're still trying to find the $5,000 for Pops in the Park.
1:13:47 Although talking with Chamber Music Unbound and their recent Measure U award that was not related to Pops in the Park, they've identified additional monies that they're able to contribute to that project. So they have an amount of $2,500, so they're really looking for that match of about $2,500 to $3,000 right now to make that work. So we think with the fundraising efforts we can make that happen. Brian's come forward and we're pretty close to looking at trying to contract that event.
1:14:15 In regards to the fireworks, interim town managers made a decision to commit to that fireworks contract right now. So we're going to work with Pyro by Sousa. We'll get that contract. We're just trying to finalise the amount. Hopefully it's the same. So at this time we're committing to those fireworks. So the staff report then goes on to talk a little bit about detail about what the funds have originated from for the events.
1:14:44 It talks about your pops in the park that we just briefly talked about. So I kind of gave you an overview there. So really what we're looking at here from a commission's point of view is just to discuss the event and provide any recommendations for staff for council. You can see the spreadsheet provides the detail in regards to what's required, what the town has contributed in the past, and what the net cost of the town has been. You can see this year's event looking at that spreadsheet, which is Attachment A.
1:15:13 Our budget for this year's event is about $28,850. And that does not include Pops in the Park, as you can see there as well. Our revenue that we're forecasting, you can see that we've budgeted $10,000 from the general fund. The vehicle gate fee, we receive $5 from every vehicle. It enters the Crowley Lake Fish Camp. They charge, I think it's $20. We get $25. We get $5.
1:15:40 And we're estimating this year for about 850 vehicles. So that gives you that 4,250. We've secured the financial support from Rick Elkis once again, which is probably, I think, our fifth year now, fourth or fifth year from Rick. So fantastic contributor. Who's that? Rick Elkis. Is it Elkis family? Oh, that's for the 5,000, yes. Yeah, no, that's very much appreciated. He's been a lifesaver. Wonderful man, yep.
1:16:06 And then you can see that we've identified $9,600 of community sponsorship in addition to, as I talked about, that $2,500 to $3,000 for Pops in the Park. So we're looking for approximately $12,000 from community sponsorship. And I haven't touched base with Matthew and that group recently, but I think they're doing quite well, so I think they're optimistic about funding the amount. And then if we need to...
1:16:33 We try and commit those funds from the general fund for that event as we go through the council discussion. So with that, I'll turn it back to the chair of the commission and see how... I would still love to hold that meeting with the Crowley Lake Fish Camp and see if we can talk about that $5 and talk about some of the other things that are, you know, required and that they have to pay and I'll make some phone calls.
1:17:02 You said you wanted to be involved in that, so I haven't moved any further from it. Okay. But I would love to sit down and see if we can work something out. And then I was, I think the chair and I sat down with that group last night too. The chair was a pretty fine-toothed column, but if he's willing to have another meeting, I'm more than willing to sit as well. Okay. Okay. Do you think that there's any latitude for an additional percentage of money to the town per car?
1:17:32 I would think so. I'm looking at what I was given as the expense list for last year. So I don't know that this is public because that's a private entity, but I think that there's probably some wiggle room and maybe there's some guarantees that you can make and then anything above that maybe comes back and goes towards the project. You know, I don't know. I don't know if we can contact EWP and see if they would waive their fee because that's something that...
1:18:02 Crowley Lake Fish Camp has to, hard costs that they have to pay out. You know, I don't know. It's worth the phone calls. The LA fee and the Crowley Lake Fire Department, the Long Valley Fire Department, because they did give us away one year, and now they're back in charging us 700 bucks for a permit for a county fire department, county event. It seems to me we should be able to get something there.
1:18:29 But other than that, the cost of the trash and extra maintenance and extra people he has to put on. So he made last year. Yeah, $9,300. Yeah, for the amount that he does, I wouldn't say it's a great return on investment. It's not. Nevertheless, it's money that's going from the town, you know, down to Crowley, and I think it's worth the conversation if we're going to continue to be able to hold this event. So, you know, I mean, it's, you know.
1:18:54 And maybe they can be guaranteed that maybe the Anglic Fish Camp can take care of all the vendors and maybe if they get any income from any vendors for anything that's being sold. You know, I know that takes away from us bringing people from town and being able to go down there unless there's a cut and that would be something that they can do. I mean, there's things that we can possibly look at, but, you know, I don't want to sit here and presume what their issues are. You know, I would rather have that conversation with them.
1:19:23 Okay, that's fair. Good. And I do just want to commend, you know, the people that have been, you know, out fundraising privately to, you know, make this event happen. Yeah. I think that's a great job. Has this Mr. Elkis ever been recognized for his contributions? He pretty much has not been recognized for his contributions.
1:19:47 He is going out on Granicus as we speak, so there is a certain amount of recognition. I'll give him a hand. He contributed over and over. I'm sure his initial hope was that $5,000 would actually create a larger show rather than prop up a piece of the show, but without him it doesn't happen, so maybe someday we will get to the point where the money we raise can actually go to creating a larger show. That would be a wonderful thing, and the town and county can pick up the rest.
1:20:16 We'll see. Can I ask briefly, we're estimating 850 cars this year. That's the most of any year. I'm just curious where we're getting those numbers and concerned it might be over-optimistic, although it represents such a small portion of the income, it probably doesn't matter anyway, but I just want to ask where that estimate came from. It looks like it's partly because it's on a Friday this year. Yeah, it's a Friday. I just increased, I think it was 820 cars last year on the Thursday, so I just bumped it, I think, probably by 5% is all I really did.
1:20:46 I actually think that's actually pretty low for a Friday event. I'm pretty optimistic that we'd probably do a little bit more about that. Do we have any records before 2006? Because we charged differently before 2006, too. In 2007, we started charging by cars. Prior to that, we charged $10 a head. Not we. I was never part of it.
1:21:09 But that was too much work for the people at the gate to count the cars, but now you have people parking. If you've ever seen them parking outside the gate, everybody shows up, stuffs as many people as they can in the back of a truck and hauls them across. It might be nice to actually have a community meeting with Crowley, too, and see if we can get some monies from some of these houses that are having backyard parties and then maybe have somebody that's going along the street and collecting at least...
1:21:37 Five bucks from those cars or something that, you know, contributes towards the show. I don't know. Let's ask the Highway Patrol if we can ticket all those cars parking legally and get a portion of the funding back. It's worth some of those conversations, you know. Is there a community group down there that we can talk to? Well, there's the RPAC, Regional Planning Advisory Committee, that meets once a month. They don't have a budget.
1:22:09 Maybe CSA 1 would have money to put towards it. I don't know. And I guess I'm not looking for any entity. I'm looking for, you know, individuals. Say, hey, here's a community. We took up a pool so that we can continue to have these fireworks down at Crowley because I know that those people that live down there like it. Yes, we do. Yeah. And so, you know, to contribute.
1:22:36 Five bucks towards something, you know, is helpful. Anything is helpful. So, you know, if nobody's asked, then nobody's going to probably step forward. So, you know, I don't know. Maybe it's something. It's worth asking, but when I was on the RPAC, they wouldn't even put money towards putting a sign that says, Welcome to Crowley Lake. Yeah, it's tough. On your numbers, Sean, I think if you look back at 9 and 8, Friday and Saturday,
1:23:06 In 2006, we lost momentum. If you go back before that, I think you'll find that there was 700, 800 cars there. Is that right? Okay. The show is big enough. I talked to the people to go to it. The show is a big enough success and a big enough show that people come down to see it. It is a draw, just as your special event is a draw. Okay. So I would expect if we had 820 last year, I think that 850 is probably an easy number. Okay. Thanks for explaining. You'd be wrong.
1:23:34 As you can see, it is growing in momentum. As long as the publicity from last year doesn't hurt us. So we are having a show, and that needs to get out there. Yes. Yes, we do need to advertise. We got hurt last year by that. I remember. Well, and I commend the town for moving forward with it so that it can't be marketed. Absolutely. So, yeah, so, you know, still would love to sit and, you know, talk about how we can maybe, you know, I don't know if there's a flyer that we can put around down in Crowley, if there's...
1:24:01 You know, if we've been and set up a meeting with Fish Camp and, you know, if there's any phone calls that we can make on their behalf for some of these other, you know, entities that are charging them so that Ben can come back and help us out. So, you know, anyways, I'll make those phone calls. Great, thank you. Okay. I have just one quick question. Pops in the Park, 45-piece orchestra, fantastic.
1:24:32 However, are they already in town for some other function? Could there be fewer? Then it would be a little bit cheaper? I know that their costs have, you know, what we've paid them has gone down. And then is there also a Measure R award that could go to them? An opportunity. Or Measure U. Well, it's recreation. It could be R or U.
1:25:01 But I think R has more of a... There was nothing that was put through on the last go-round, so... But the oops-utunity. Well, there was in U. That's right. And we made the determination that we could not fund specifically Pops in the Park. And could they, if they got that award, was there leeway in their budget? And I think we were sort of told that there was. Right.
1:25:29 So they got, we awarded them, I think they're full ask. So, no, we aren't paid for pops in the park because we can't, that would be supplant because the town has paid for it in the past. Well, from Measure U, but Measure R could. No, it's about, you can't supplant facility maintenance. Yeah, technically. I'm just saying it's a last ditch effort if you need it.
1:26:01 But I'm pretty sure it's going to happen almost regardless at this point. Okay. And I just think that, you know, sitting down and kind of try to have some conversations with some folks. Yep. Absolutely. And like I said, like if I can call DWP, I may not get anywhere, but I'd be happy to make that phone call. So if that helps him out, I mean, that can come back and help us out. So anyhow. Talk to John before you make that.
1:26:28 That phone call, yeah. No, I don't want to do anything until I talk to some other folks. I don't want to ruffle any feathers. Okay. Moving on to agenda item 8, 2014 youth sports funding. Steph. Good afternoon, Commission. Stephanie Daniel, Recreation Supervisor. Just am bringing this year's application for the 2014 youth sports funding.
1:27:09 To your guys' attention, it's that time of year again, so you guys have the application and all the other pertinent stuff with it, and I'm just asking if I can move forward if you don't have any questions. I think the application's gone pretty smoothly. I was going to ask if anything's changed. It says it has. Something has changed. I always put that on there, just so they read it. It's kind of like our notice at the ice rink.
1:27:40 Thank you for noticing this notice. You've been notified. Well, I have a change for you to make. It's sort of a wordsmithing nature, but it counts as a change, so, you know, I just wouldn't want you to be dishonest putting this out there. On the fourth, where it says instructions and tips for completing the funding application? Yes. The fourth bullet point, after the word pertinent, I think you just need to add the word which. Which is pertinent.
1:28:15 Which would aid us, yeah. Yeah. It makes it flow a little bit. Yeah. Oh, which would aid, okay. Class, yes. So, yeah, nothing steps, there's no change to the application form. We've also attached the rating sheet at the back. And then, just for your interest, we included on the front page there, previously board, who's applied, and what the request was, and what our recommendation was.
1:28:46 We also have the same amount of money available. So that's really a little goal. That's great. I have a question. Don't we kind of value volunteer participation in running the program? And I know from the front page of the application it talks about activities outside of their organization that benefit the community. I mean, is adult participation?
1:29:18 Is participation in the organizational structure important? It has it on the application. Yeah, I was just looking at the bullets. Oh, okay. We're happy to make any changes that you'd recommend because consensus with the commission, we can certainly do that. Oh, I see. So these are kind of just being called out because it does ask for the volunteer hours on the application.
1:29:48 Actually, the last two bullets there could be combined into one. They kind of seem a little bit redundant, but maybe I misunderstand what we're trying to communicate. The public benefit and then community events outside of it. Whatever. Maybe it's not that big of a deal. Or maybe you merge those two together? Well, if you merge those two together, then you could add the bullet point for the volunteer hours, volunteer time.
1:30:18 Because it seems to be a criteria that we seem to be concerned with. This is events outside of their program? Right. And this, to the application, speaks within their program. So, anyhow. Although there is a question about what type of programs or projects does your organization... It's all in the application. I mean, it does spell it out. But like Pat's saying, this is kind of...
1:30:48 You're kind of bringing your attention to what the criteria are that we're going to hold up the highest. If you'd like to change, I have no problem with it one way or the other. We're going to get the same applications with the same information. That's right. Pretty much the same groups every year. I don't know that it's worth wasting any town staff on making any further adjustments, but I leave it up to commission, of course.
1:31:16 I think that it spells it out in the application. I don't know. I thought it worked well last year. I didn't think it was a... So do we have consensus we're good? We're good. We're good. I'm good. But thank you for that. Just make it feel a little grammatical. Yeah. Thanks, Stephanie. See, then you can say, see, it's changed. Yeah. Maybe next year when we're putting it together, then you can do that one instead of having to change everything else. All right. I'll take this one back to the board. More budgets.
1:31:46 Thank you. Recreation Department Fee Schedule. So you can see the Municipal Code requires an annual review by Town Council of Town Fees and Services charged by the departments. This is being conducted, but as you know, the Recreation Department, big, big,
1:32:13 Big initiatives are really in summer and they happen now. We've got to get these fees in front of Commission and then in front of Council to get these into ActiveNet and then to get them sold and to get them moving. So what we've done here is we've put together, this is kind of an annual production. We've brought this forward, you can see several times in the past. So what I probably really want to do here is just, per the Commission, just walk through each of the categories and just to go through the changes with you.
1:32:41 Just kind of the big changes. But initially, when we looked at the fee amendments, primarily the facilities have not been changed over several years. The only changes have been really to the camps, to the ice rink and to the pool. But a lot of our fees that we charge for our fields haven't been touched in, well, I think over 20 years that I could kind of go back to.
1:33:04 So what we did is we just looked at the CPI over the last decade, which was approximately 20%, it was actually 23.6%, but we looked at kind of averaging that to about 20%, which gives you about a $2 increase to a lot of our facilities that we rent on an hourly basis for. So that was the change there. Just going through youth camps, we'll just go through by category.
1:33:33 And then we'll finish, we'll start with our youth camps and we'll finish with our special event permit fee. And then if there's any comments, just jump in maybe each section and we'll kind of go through those. So our youth camps, two years ago we revised those fees. We went resident, non-resident. We went to seven day advance prior. So that hasn't changed. And if you book greater than seven days in advance, you receive a 20% discount. So there's no change to that at all.
1:34:00 We still offer the family 5% discount for siblings. Got a question already? I was just going to say, I'm sorry, and I kind of probably interrupt you with your flow going through your report, but have you guys seen people doing the advanced booking to take advantage of that discount? Yes. That's been popular. You can speak to it, but I think once they did pick up on it, there's kind of a manic rush to get in before we shut it off, and ActiveNet does it automatically, so we can't adjust it.
1:34:30 Yeah, but it is very, very popular, and we just talked about it briefly today at our staff meeting, and we can actually, with ActiveNet, we've actually built a coupon, so once these are loaded, we can actually send that email to every one of our participants last year, and the first 50 people that, you know, reserve their camp.
1:34:45 You know, gets $5 off, you know, that camp if they're booking it, you know, that way as well. So we've got a lot of opportunity, you know, with ActiveNet to really reach out and sell these in advance. So really our goal is to get these sold before the seven days. I was going to say, if you're already giving them a discount for early, you might not want to give them another $5 off. But I'm just saying, so there's, you know, we have those. At the same time now. We have those opportunities, so. But again, it does really help, you know, if we can get a lot of advance sale, it really helps out.
1:35:10 Staff and Planning. So if we're seeing that we're going over the numbers that we're actually able to based on our staffing, we've looked at putting a couple of interns on this summer from our school program that would help us manage an increase in demand and provide our campus with additional ratio of instructor to students.
1:35:32 So the more we can sell in advance, the better it's be, I think, is what we're trying to say. And if I could just quickly make a comment about the sort of double discounting. I have no problem seeing facility rentals increase after so many years, but I do think we really need to be sensitive to the fact that this has been a very tough year economically in our community. And so I think that anything that we can do to incentivize people to book early and to book through ActiveNet, I think also if we can provide an additional financial incentive, then I'm more comfortable reading.
1:36:01 Thank you so much. Thank you.
1:36:30 So we'll supervise those children before the 9 o'clock start time, and then we have that post-camp cool-down, which is that $10 fee for two hours, and we're still running that program. That hasn't changed, and we think that's actually a pretty good deal. We didn't get a lot of usage from that last year, so hopefully people can really pick that up and take advantage of that. And not necessarily to create competition for Husky Club, what's their price and how does this match with that for the summer? I don't know if you know, are they changing their prices for the summer?
1:36:58 I haven't talked to Barbara about that. Yeah, I haven't heard anything different yet, if they were going to have any price increases either. Okay. That was more of just a question. Good, okay. No, no, we'll certainly get that from Barbara. Thank you. Anyway, so moving on, so the daily rate, we have a drop-in fee of one day, which was $40, and we're trying to raise it up to $45, and you can see that the goal there is that, you know, $6 an hour, still great value.
1:37:27 But at the same time, we want to actually get people committed to the entire camp. So it's hard if they just keep buying this one day at a time. It's going to get very expensive and it's hard for us to commit. So that's the really only change that we really looked at. You can see we've just increased a dollar a day our multi-day camps, so $5 a week. And a lot of the rationale when we went through this, I know a couple of years ago, was to try and just take this up.
1:37:52 You know, little by little instead of big jumps at a time. If the Commission feels we want to keep a hold on the pricing, we can keep a hold on the pricing at this time, but I thought that kind of that philosophy last time kind of made sense. Otherwise, we're going to get to a point where we have to really kind of raise it by a lot. But we think this is fair and reasonable, and there's a lot of demand in those camps as well. It's not like there's no one joining the camps. They're filling up and filling out.
1:38:17 I think the only one that I might call out is just the $40, you know, the $5 increase for the swimming lessons. And thank you very much for adding the swim lesson camp. I really am hopeful that that will be successful. But just because, you know, I think it's tough for people to have to transport their kids, you know, down to Whitmore and back, you know, five days a week. So you've jumped ahead of that.
1:38:41 Oh, I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. I think I get to the – I wasn't quite focused on that. We're just trying to see how you can – I apologize. You know? Okay. Well, if I could – I will rest in my comment. Before we get to the poll, there's any comments on the youth camp, so I just want to maybe get through a bias section, and then we'll address the commissioners. And I appreciate, you know, what everything that you guys have said, but, you know, we haven't increased prices in 20 years. We all know what –
1:39:04 The actual expense of the facilities and the staff have been, and those have gone far more than what we're doing right now. So, you know, I think that what we need to do is still look at what that subsidized number is, and then I don't know, is there any way to, you know, help kids out and have some type of a program that if there is a child that wants to be involved that they can't afford it because we've had to raise our prices to, you know, keep, because really in all reality,
1:39:34 Is either we need to raise the prices so that we can function and we can have these programs, or we need to cut back on what we offer so we can still offer a quality program at a lesser cost. And unfortunately that's just reality. And, you know, as much as I would like to say that everything's free, we all know that that can't happen. So I guess that's kind of the happy medium is where do we come up with that? And I know I'm, you know, the one that keeps going, what are we subsidizing these programs at? Because I don't think we really truly have that.
1:40:03 number as to what we are. And, you know, so I don't know. Is it better to raise the price and then have money set aside from something? Maybe it's a category even within our youth sports program.
1:40:17 That we can help out kids that, you know, can't afford to be in the program. I don't know. It's just a film. And I think my hesitation is just to, you know, I want to be cautious if we're raising prices of programs that are popular and programs of prices that are less popular because I think that we want to be cautious and not make our less popular programs increasingly less popular. I think it's important, too, for children in this community to have structured activities to participate in.
1:40:47 It's still a small town, and there's a lot of great things for them to do, but there's a lot of ways that they could probably get into trouble if they weren't a little bit kind of focused. So one thing you might look at if you want to increase revenue is the percentage maybe for future instructors that you have. Instead of doing an 80-20, maybe you do a 75-25 percent, something like that.
1:41:15 You know, the town's getting a little bit more money. Not that it's passed on to the participants, but that's a way to make them look. And that was the idea, too, with the gymnastics program. You know, we've taken that back under the town, right, so we don't have that 80-20 split. Because that's a big program, and I think less risk for the town taking on something that's new when we have that split.
1:41:35 But once it is or does become successful, I think it makes sense for us to kind of, you know. It is more financially advantageous. Right, correct. To put them on salary. And it's almost similar to how we're starting Kevin Warden on the drama program, too. So he's going to start on the 80-20, and depending on how that goes, you know, it might work out more effectively for the town just to manage that program. But until, you know, that develops further, it's hard to see how effective that's going to be. So anyway, so I think that's kind of why we use that program. We're kind of using it less and less.
1:42:03 Another thing, too, looking at the summer camps that are going on, like the Valentine programs, I think are cheaper than what we offer through the town. So that's a little bit of competition there. That's true. And I guess I think my overall comment is just that I want to make sure that we're practicing good yield management and not just looking at the CPI and, you know, applying sort of a blanket increase. I would agree. And until we really know what we're subsidizing, we don't know that.
1:42:31 Of course, I'm not on the committee for programs, but if a program is dwindling, I don't know that the fee reduction is the way to increase it, the way to me seems to be to create a program that the public is looking more for and replace the failing program with a new...
1:42:52 Something, whatever it is, that will bring the people back. Well, that's what we're looking at, like, this swimming lesson camp, you know. Right, that there are changing trends, and we have to follow those trends to keep people happy. You either reduce your programs or you have to increase cost to have more. It's probably not fun to be in a camp with one or two other people anyway, you know, so.
1:43:15 Not meeting minimum expectations for attendance. Yeah, if you guys do look at the camp numbers, I mean, pretty much every camp is full. Camps were pretty popular. I mean, everything, you know, we did pretty good overall last year as far as all our programs. I think I would just like to see a little more, you know, stuff go on over at the rink, which we've already talked about. But, I mean, there were, you know, we had a couple waiting lists and stuff too, and like Stu mentioned earlier about the...
1:43:42 You know, making the one-day drop-in more expensive because we want to capture that. Get that kid in there the whole week because some stuff, you know, like wilderness camp, they're kind of learning a little bit every day and then, you know, they get to have their camp out at the end of the week. I mean, there is a goal at the end of most of our camps. And I know we got off the subject a little bit when you were asking about scholarships. You know, some of the camps we are able to kind of just scholarship kids in if it's our own camp.
1:44:11 And then, for instance, with our soccer camps, I get, as the camp administrator, I get, or camp coordinator, or whatever I'm called, I'm the one who books the camp, so I get a scholarship. And there's also other scholarships available to families who can afford it by hosting a coach. And, you know, there's other ways, you know, for our contracted camps that we can still provide that. Sometimes it's just hard finding the people that need us.
1:44:40 They don't always want to come and say that. I need help. Because the couple times it has, we were both sitting there in tears at the counter, and I'm like, I'm going to help you. Don't worry about it. So we get them in. We get them in. No one's really turned away. No. They really need to get in there. We get them in. Okay. Anything else on youth camps? We can go to the pool.
1:45:05 Commissioner Truex. Sorry. Just concerned on the, so really for the emission fees, we're just rising by 25 cents, which is really, I don't know, it's quite normal, but we, like you said, we do have costs that keep increasing, we think that's, that's quite realistic. And I think that my fellow season pass holders at the pool would have no objection to. Yeah. Yeah, $5 for the season, it's fantastic value. Again, we worked out that fee, it's actually $25 per visit if you wanted to break even, so.
1:45:31 Or 25 visits to pay for itself, right? Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Trust me, some people have paid for their pass three times over by the end of the summer. Yeah. And then some. But we love them all. Yeah. So swim lessons. So the proposal was a dollar per day increase. Is that something you want to discuss? I mean, because it doesn't see a lot of demand. We see it as good, still affordable value. I mean, we're happy to leave it where it is to kind of grow that program. But again, we just kind of went across the board.
1:46:00 I did hear from a lot of people last year who thought that was expensive because they were also incurring the cost of driving their kids down to the pool every day. $8 per session? $8 is with the increase? Yes. Yeah, historically, I mean, ever since I've worked there, it was $35.
1:46:20 Dollars. One year we made it $40 and then I don't know whatever reason because that was still before it came to this job that it went back down to $35 and then that's where we've been at since well over 10 years. The price has been the same and with the revamp of our swim school that we're going to introduce this summer and some of the more programming that we're going to have I still think that even if we left it at $35 it's still a good value you know in spite of the fact that people have to you know
1:46:50 Carpool down there. I think it's still a very good, a good deal. Okay. We're happy either way. Okay. And we are pretty, we are also pretty competitive with our competitor, Bishop, so. And they only do it four days a week at the same time frame, you know, 30 minutes, four days a week, we do ours for.
1:47:12 And I think we just want to make sure that we're communicating, you know, that value added, you know, make sure that we're letting people know, you know, what a quality program it is. And it's only going to get better for this summer. Yeah. And I think maybe, you know, also, too, now that we'll have, you know, the ability to access ActiveNet down at the pool team, maybe we can do better manage those numbers so we're not ending up with one kid and, you know, in the class. I don't know if this needs to play into the cost, but as I recall, this is the most highly subsidized facility we've got, right?
1:47:42 Yeah. Apart from the rink in wintertime, but this summer it's pretty high. Yeah. All right. We just need to express that value then. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And you can see that we've introduced this new water safety camp, and that was a good recommendation from our little subcommittee we worked with Betsy and Sean there. So it's a pretty unique kind of camp. We think there's a lot of demand for this type of program in so many individual pools.
1:48:09 In town, but there's really no way to teach those kids to swim and be water safe. So this is a program, like you said, for 5 to 12, we're going to include transit, so we'll bus them down with our vans, and if we go over, we'll do a couple of trips, but we'll get the kids down and we'll get them back. It includes lunch, includes activities at the pool, and then they can kind of buy that post-camp cool-down for the $10 and turn it into a day, if they'd like as well, because at this time it's only four hours per day, but we can make it.
1:48:38 You know, six hours at least. So it's very affordable. I don't know, I think it was a $60, $65. So what was the cost? It's $60 and $72. $60 and $72, there you go. So $60, so you can see it's very affordable. We think everybody should be able to kind of contribute to that. It's well subsidized. So let's see how that goes. We're pretty excited about that camp. We'll try and offer it maybe once or twice. I'm going to try to offer it kind of at the beginning.
1:49:06 Like maybe beginning, middle of July and then one at the end after swim team is done to try to capture those kids because, you know, sometimes those guys get left out a lot of stuff. But that's up to them. But I want to try to offer it at least twice this summer. And I think that will be a good response too to parents that, you know, don't want to be driving their kid down for half an hour. Yeah, but this could just...
1:49:29 Be so popular, we'll be looking at, wow, we really need to get some transit down there to get some transit. Y'all better get me a bus. That's definite. I have nothing to do with prices, but I really think we need to look at maybe measure U dollars to get a bus going to Whitmore Pool on a daily basis every hour or two hours or something. It is a distance out of town. If you have teens or tweens or young adults.
1:49:57 It seems to me you may go down to Whitmore if the transportation is available. It's a really underutilized facility. It's used less now, I think, than when I was a kid. It could even be something that's a recreation bus pass or something like that that you could do. Because even swim team, I mean, as a swim team parent, it's hard to get your kids down there all the time. So there's many a times that I would have put the kids on the bus. I think we can't do it for this summer, but I think for next year, I think we...
1:50:24 You know, I try to hold off that they measure you. Transit was for special event buses, but I see no reason if it is a mobility thing that we could not put that application in and see where it goes. That facility down there, because it's not just the pool. That's right. Ball fields and everything else down there. If I was a runner and I wanted to go for a run and I could take a bus down and do an hour run and an hour soak in the pool and get the bus back home again.
1:50:53 How perfect is that? So I think it behooves us to... That's where I say even selling some passes because there are people that might be able to do something like that. Right. You know, that's a reasonable pass. I think that transportation now is critical to the success or failure of the track and...
1:51:11 When we have a driver, we just need to find a bus. If you guys can, you know, I've already kind of picked the brains of ESTA and Lon, you know, if we could get just one of those little mini, but I've been asking you guys that since we first saw them. If we can get our hands on one of those, we've got Class B drivers that can drive it, and we can train and hire more. It's just a matter of getting the vehicle to get the kids around, and that's...
1:51:37 Yeah, we need someone going back and forth on a regular basis. Which is not Steph. So, that's not Steph. No, Steph's got other things she needs to do. No, but I mean, you know, if it's a week-long camp, maybe I'm the one that's going to be doing the aquatic camp with one of my staffs down there, so I'll be the driver. I think that goes into the business plan for Whitmore Track, and then we incorporate a pool, and I think that that's a conversation that we have to sit down in. I mean, ideally, it would be nice if ESTA could make a, you know, more frequent laps down there, but until we can get enough people to start demanding it.
1:52:07 You know? Remember that the buses that ESTA uses, a lot of them are owned by the town of Mammoth Lakes. They aren't ESTA buses. Yeah, so my idea was finding out if we can purchase one of those when it's, I don't know how that works, once it's served its time with ESTA, what do they do with those buses? Well, why can't we have one? And that's a good idea for all of our programs, but in the interim, I think for next year, it is important that we put that application in whenever we need to.
1:52:36 to start that bus service. That's just my point of view. I can't speak for the entire commission, but I saw a lot of nodding heads here. I think that's maybe, maybe that's a subcommittee that we get to put together to see what are the timing, what would the timing be of a route that would look like that, you know, what are the needs, and talk to some people in the community and see what we can put together so that we actually can have a plan. I think it's a great idea. It's too bad it has to wait another year and a half.
1:53:06 Yeah, well, we just awarded all of our money except for capital reserves, so otherwise I'd say let's do an emergency thing. I mean, there will be money, I'd say. So let's put this on our works program, Stu, for early enough in the spring that if we decide we really want to do something, we can pull that trigger if necessary. I think it's part of that business plan for Whitmore Recreation. I think that's what we're starting to put our attention to now, so I think that comes in that whole discussion.
1:53:30 And it will be good to see, you know, how that camp goes because, you know, the pool is very well used by swim team. It's very well used by lap swimmers, especially in the morning. It's just, you know, that time frame from the end of morning lap swim until, you know, the afternoon usage that is, I think we, you know, we have to have staff down there anyway. So, you know, the more we can fill the facility, the better. Any more comments on the pool? So the ice rink, you can see the stats at the back.
1:54:00 Eclipsed our budget this year. It's gone quite well, actually really well. We're good staff. Great weather, unfortunately. But anyway, we did an analysis of our staff. Staff actually went online and looked at how the other rinks are being charged, and we're very affordable. So what we've done here is we've just increased the adult by a dollar, the youth senior military by 50 cents, and the skate rental by 50 cents. So we think they're pretty conservative.
1:54:29 But you can see, you know, we are seeing demand, so I think that's quite fair, and it's an expensive operation. So that's the change there. We didn't make any change to the school fee. That's actually part of that contract that we have. We bumped the Fivescape Pass by just a dollar, and then Season Pass products just increased by five dollars, which is about a three, four percent increase. So again, that's something we can kind of look at each year to kind of increase accordingly.
1:54:59 I just have a quick question. The seals, the learn to skate aids, those are really awesome. But I'm just wondering about what the policy is. We're charging to use those now? Are we going to continue that until they're paid for? Are we going to continue that so we can buy more? I think we'll probably always rent them. Right now we're renting those two for $5 per use.
1:55:22 I don't have to call him John C. anymore because there's only one John left. John today just ordered some more other type of skate trainers that are, yeah, they're like, yeah, and we don't know, maybe after this year, maybe the SEALs, I think they're fun, but they're more of a novelty, we're kind of finding out, whereas these other skate trainers that we'll get are going to be a little more easier to actually help little kids hold on and learn to skate than just.
1:55:50 Yeah, so we don't want to not have something that's available to help us escape, and the aluminum ones were just destroyed. Yeah. So we found some nice plastic ones. We're actually using five-gallon buckets upside down, right? Somebody from another rink told us that, and I'm like, you know, Derek, go get me some chlorine buckets. But the seals are very cool. They are cool, but. And I think the other thing is we have to make sure we're consistent, because, you know, one time we went and they were free, and then another time we had to pay. The seals? Yeah.
1:56:20 Yeah, they're supposed to be renting those. There's a button. They've got to press that button. Just say it. My only comment on your man with ice rink fees is that I've never charged 50 cents for anything. Raise it by a buck and a half, make it nine. Oh, you're talking about the adult one? Yeah. Or all of them make them all even dollar amounts? I would never do an odd amount that would change. It makes no sense. It's like me charging a buck and a half for a key. It makes no sense.
1:56:50 Well, the same thing with the pool prices then, too. Yeah, I agree. I would like to see us keep them at around a year. Although we'll have POS now, so I don't know if that's as much of an issue. I don't know. They've been doing pretty good counting that change. Like I said, the philosophy is just a little bit each year. I mean, otherwise we just do it now and not do it next year. You know what I mean? So you take the big jump and then, no. It's up to the commissioner. We're just working up a little bit each time. Is it nine bucks to go skating?
1:57:17 So it's $9 plus, so remember it's $8.50 plus the $3.50 for the skate, so it's $12 for an adult. So it's $12 with the skate, so down south it's about $15 for ice rinks. That was just my comment. It's up to you. Whatever you guys want to do, you're handling that money. Having the change there is a bit of a...
1:57:41 You know, predominantly, Bill, they're all, sorry, Chair, they're all credit cards. Let me tell you. I mean, we're processing, it's probably a 60% credit card, and a lot of those families over the holidays, it's faster with a credit card, they don't even see, they don't even notice. So, look, I'd have to have a pricing policy based on, you know, rounding up or ending down. But also, this is the money that you receive when you do that, because you're having to pay a commission. Right. Just a suggestion. I think that $12 a state is damn cheap.
1:58:11 Why aren't she? Well, it'll be more next year? It'll be more the next year? I think, once again, we need to do the subsidy. We need to sit down and figure that out. This one's, yeah, this one's on a, I think when we looked at those numbers, this is, you know, we have that assessment, Melrose assessment, and it's actually quite, I would say it's probably at about 50% cost recovery right now, right? We've generated $67,000 right now from revenue, and with that, we have to pay out that.
1:58:40 37,000 lease fee. So that's a direct cost that we have to bear. The roller rink, so really no changes to that fee schedule. All we're really introducing is a fee for non-skaters. So again, we really see that as kind of an entertainment center. So we're really just looking at a fee that we can just charge folks to come in and just use the facility, get the kids in and engaged, keep them entertained. So that would be to use the horseshoe pit.
1:59:11 Horseshoe Pit, Basketball. Volleyball, skate ramps, you know, bean bag toss, things like that. So that's the only addition to that fee. Everything else, you know, stays the same. Softball league teams went up by $25 to $600. That program, as you know, we subsidize that by only 20%. So that's kind of on a pretty low subsidy, you know. So we're really looking to maximize that fee.
1:59:38 We dropped it down several years ago, and now we're kind of bringing it back up based on demand because we're actually at our limit. We don't really take any more teams. We're kind of done. John seems to think that's reasonable, and a few managers thought that was just fine. Because we are actually, if you look at that, we have that full-time adult sports coordinator out there now as well, four times a week. So Rob's there all the time, so we are providing, I think, good value for that product.
2:00:01 So this was the one here when we look at facility use fees. These haven't changed in a long, long time. I don't think we've touched these at all. So these are just going up by $2 from $10 to $12. So that would be picnic shelter, field, Mammoth Creek Park, you know, those type of things. I have some questions along that. And that's a per hour rental. Okay. Boy, that's a great deal for the...
2:00:22 She Rest Picnic Shelter, and it's $12 an hour there. The group picnic area at Mammoth Creek Park, and I'm actually not sure where that's at specifically, but that's $38 an hour, and that seems like a heck of a discrepancy there. Which one? Well, I'm comparing the picnic shelter versus the group picnic area rental fee, and I'm just curious if you can speak to why the Mammoth Creek Park is three times the price of the shelter at
2:00:54 Shady rest. Probably not. That is definitely a residual fee. You can see that includes, you know, that grass area and restrooms. I don't know why, that's a good pickup. Like I said, that's been a fee for a long time. Yeah, you know, I almost want to say that the picnic shelter can go up a little bit or Mammoth Creek Park can come down. Yeah, right. No, that's good. Because I sure would like to encourage the use of Mammoth Creek.
2:01:23 Park Mall. A little bit more. So you think the fee is actually inhibiting the use of that area? I don't know. Actually, that was going to be one of the questions. But I would say this is that, you know, again, for looking at these, I think that you pointed to. Yeah, it's just a grass area and a restaurant. That's all they're really renting. You know, we see weddings there. I mean, that's really what we're using it for. Yeah, occasionally people have called us up and they want. I mean, it's not like a park that we, you know, promote.
2:01:50 I mean, it'd be nice once down the road when we get more stuff over there to rent, you know, designate, like the picnic shelter or the barbecue area or a baseball, well, not a baseball field because I don't want, you know, probably baseball fields over there, but you know what I mean, until there's something tangible to actually rent, you know, it's just kind of like an open area and we're just kind of being able to reserve that whole space for them and most of the houses has been like the larger, like, we had a couple weddings, pops in the park, stuff like that.
2:02:17 Whereas, like, the picnic shelter, in the past we rented it for $40 per use. So, you know, even if a person was there for an hour, they were paying $40. But now we've put it back on an hourly. But what we found was $40 per use, but they were there for, like, six hours. Yeah. Right? So the problem, we... Or all day. ...per hour, but it's a two-hour minimum. So they're at $24 for two hours. And that's that whole picnic area? That's the shelter. That whole covered... It's the covered shelter area. And then that's...
2:02:45 We actually have two reservable spots within that area. You've got the covered picnic shelter and then right next door the group barbecue area. And they usually rent them together. So they do the shelter and the barbecue area. It's a huge area for just $12 an hour. So it's $24 because you do them both together. So it's $24 for an hour or $48 for two hours. That's how that usually gets booked.
2:03:09 So $48 for two hours, and they're easily booked for four hours, so they're at like $96. It's $100 basically. Well, how many people, I mean, because you're talking about a large group, so that's... But it's a community park, and that's why we haven't had the discussion, you know, it hasn't been changed for long. We went up quite conservatively, but... I think we can get a $15.
2:03:27 Well, we're not trying to gouge anyone here, but I just kind of want to make it a little bit more... And they are still on their honor system when they're there, you know, to be there only for their allotted time, because we might have two rentals that day. What's the cleanup? I mean, is there a deposit? Is there a cleanup? I mean, I guess this kind of goes back to what is our actual cost for people to use...
2:03:49 That facility and to do that. A lot of costs. We just have one trash guy and then we have one out there. So, you know, the trash comes every morning and afternoon and that comes specifically during the event. But if it takes him 15 minutes to a half an hour to clean up somebody's space, that's actually probably more than you just rented your space for. Why don't you add a cleaning deposit and then... Those spaces are used outside of them.
2:04:14 These rentals as well. Right. They use just as much. Most of the time they probably don't get rented. That's right. People just show up. Capture that rental, right? Yeah. So the trash guy is going to be spending the same amount of time regardless whether it's rented or not. Correct. The people who are good enough to reserve it so it'll be theirs. And then we have to understand that we're not closing the park. All they get is the right to use that shelter in that area. They can't shoot people away.
2:04:41 Can I ask a couple other questions? The Mammoth Creek Park, that is exposed, that's not in shade? No, that's right. Okay, whereas both those areas at Shady Rest, you know, are under shade, trees or the shelter. So it seems like, and alcohol is not allowed at either location, correct? Unless you get a one-time permit. You can get permits. Now, I thought Shady Rest was in, permits weren't even available.
2:05:07 Well, you know, like the Fireman's Picnic, they get a permit. Okay. That's a good point. Women's Club had an event. Women's Club. We'll get a permit for our 30th anniversary party. We're actually doing a 30th anniversary party out there on August 15th. Okay. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count. We're on the count.
2:05:35 For who do we rent along those lines? And, you know, that was something that I think we talked about discussing at this commission. And just to kind of throw it all out there, you do not, to have alcohol in the community center, one does not need a permit. Is that accurate? No, typically what we've done just on our own accord is we've pretty much just not, we've let people know we don't.
2:06:00 We don't rent the community center out for parties or baptisms, birthday parties or anything like that. If you want to have a meeting there or, you know, maybe your Bible study or something like that, sure, but we've pretty much tried to get away from those type of rentals because of the use that we're using it for our programs for, you know, gymnastics and the drama and the...
2:06:26 The first five that's in there and my other little programs because of the wear and tear on the place. And also, too, because people were not being honest to us and said, oh, no, we're not going to do that. And then we get complaints from the neighbors saying, oh, yeah, they had this huge rager. There was people out there. So we just decided to squash those type of rentals at our community center. So currently it's just our programs, meetings, stuff like that. So I want to try to keep that.
2:06:55 The same and not, because it is an aging building and it does kind of have a funk to it, you know, and. Which we talked about too, remember, because we had these functions on Friday night and then the gymnastics were there first thing Saturday morning, no one was there cleaning it up and it was. That's why you need to have staff to supervise it, to make sure that people are complying with whatever their permit is.
2:07:16 And then there's a security deposit for cleaning up your draft. Absolutely, and there has been in the past, but the person going to check the community center would be me after their event, and if I found anything, sure. We've held deposits or not given back their entire deposit, but after just some of the issues that we had and plus trying to program more of our stuff into that community center, that became my priority over rentals, so I wanted to, you know, preserve it for our programs.
2:07:44 More than letting people have their baptisms in there. I mean, they are paying to be in there, but on the other hand, it's our only facility that we have. Do you see there's a lot of demand? Is that why you're asking the question? Or is it just more of a policy for... Yeah, it's more of a policy, and I guess I just want to make sure that there was some kind of written policy just so that it can be pretty clear and not arbitrary, and I don't know if that's been written. We do. It's been in the rec guide. It's been online as far as the information. We can make sure it's...
2:08:13 Doubly in there. But when people do call to ask about reserving it, we always ask, well, what kind of event are you having? Well, we want to have our, you know, our 30th wedding anniversary. Are you going to serve alcohol? Yes. Well, I'm sorry, we don't allow those kind of events. But you have a fee here for that.
2:08:30 Yeah, but we don't let it. Communities that are deposit with alcohol. I know, because it's still written. I know. We can take it out. We're happy to take it. Well, I think you should be consistent. So either you do it or you don't. And I guess that's what I'm looking for is just some kind of written policy. That was the one thing that I think caught me off guard last year. Which we wrote down on that stock report. So maybe that really is the policy that we want to look at. Okay. We want to. We can bring it back to you at the next meeting if you want. You can look at that again. It brings up an interesting question in the alcohol area.
2:08:56 If I may step on you for a minute. Please do. You mean an alcohol garden? I'll take it. You said that the fire department gets a permit, but if it's a private party, no permit is necessary. So do we allow, when they make their application, to rent that from town, do we allow alcohol for private events that don't require ABC permits? Because that would seem unclear as well.
2:09:22 Right. In the past, you know, I'm not the risk management expert, but based on what we were told when we were answering these questions was that they could serve alcohol if you had it. You can get a supplemental thing on your homeowner's insurance. Or they could book, because this is when Noreen used to be with us, they could buy the one-day event insurance. She would broker it, and they could have their alcohol.
2:09:52 Like at Shader S Park or whatever. So my goal is to... Now you're talking about an insurance issue. Right. And we don't require insurance of people who rent. But when people would ask us on the phone if they could have alcohol at the park for their party at the shelter, yes you can, but you have to do this insurance, you have to buy this or have the insurance, naming the town as additional insured.
2:10:19 On their homeowner's policy. But again, that was just what I was told to tell people when we had it with our old risk manager. And that's been the town's policy as far as how it was interpreted back to us and what we were telling potential renters. I think we need a more concise. We need a more concise. I believe so, too. Either we let it in or we don't. We need a more concise plan.
2:10:45 Right on what we do and don't allow it. Should we just let this go as is because it needs to go and get approval? As far as the fee schedule we're discussing, we should probably. We have no problem with the fee schedule. I think we should. But in terms of alcohol in the parks, because if we allow the fire department to do it, we don't require them to get any additional, but we allow them to do it because they have an ABC license, which doesn't require any insurance either, then it seems we would have to allow it for a wedding.
2:11:12 Who's going to serve it for free that doesn't require the ABC license? So I think that we need to put on our agenda the rental policy for all of them. If we don't want it at one and one at another, if we see one appropriate and one not, then we can do with that. But I think that that's something that we need to deal with. Okay. We'll put that on the next agenda. Yeah, that would have a better written out. I think we're actually required to have a liability insurance for everybody that rents a facility.
2:11:41 I mean, ideally. So even if they're coming in for a meeting, we're actually required to receive that liability insurance. We haven't been. So for a two-hour meeting, you know, it's a meeting. So, you know, how far do you want to go? And then I just don't know if we're going to be renting those facilities because people aren't going to get the way of this. But that's, you know, if the joint powers requires us to have that, then we need to have that. So we need to ask that question of, you know, somebody of importance. I don't know any of those types.
2:12:11 Now that we have a HR director, we can get some stuff done. Yes. Yeah, sorry, I don't mean to create more work, but I'm just, I was aware, especially after that conversation last year, that we just. Yeah, but that's a good thing because, again, because we haven't had certain key employees within our organization, it's been falling back onto us to try to manage all of this stuff. So this has been something that I have been wanting to talk to you guys about because, you know, as far as the community center.
2:12:40 Yeah, I really don't want to have parties over there, you know, with alcohol because, you know, I'm trying to keep it nice. But at the park, if they have the proper whatever we're supposed to let them have, why not? Just charge them more. Can you talk about just the fee schedule? Because I know we need to move on, so let's keep it to the fee schedule. Yeah, I would like to either propose raising the Shady Rest Area or lowering the Mammoth Creek Park Area.
2:13:04 And then also with regard to fee schedule, the only other question I wanted to ask was what is the security deposit for the community center? Or is there any more? The community center, the deposit is a $150 deposit and a $25 key deposit. Okay. And that's all we're requiring right now, but we haven't been really doing the insurance. And affecting it, so you've really got to put the credit card in. Okay.
2:13:33 So what was the, any action or any consensus on Mammoth Creek Park? Like that fee hasn't changed at all. We've only increased it by $2 for the grass area and restrooms. You want to leave it as is or as a consensus to make it the same as Shady West Park? You mean make it the same as Mammoth Creek Park? Yeah. What, no, make the, you want to lower the $32 fee for Mammoth Creek Park to the shelter or raise, or the other fees to, was that?
2:14:01 Yeah, that was my question. Is that mostly just weddings? People wanting to have... Look, it's rented so infrequently, we really don't take that many. If I could run active, that would probably take us like five. Five rentals at that amount. Versus the picnic shelter you're doing, probably two a day, all over the summer. Well, in that case, I'd raise the picnic shelter, shading rest, to something closer to being equal to what we charge for Mammoth Creek.
2:14:28 Or even if it's not equal, because if you're looking at a wedding that's going to take over the grass area, it's kind of two different types of activities that are going on. So maybe go up to the 15. I think that's still even cheaper. I mean, because we were kind of saving that Mammoth Creek Park for those people that need that big space to set the tents up and stuff. And I think that's still kind of crazy cheap for that large area. The least expensive place in town to do a wedding right now outside of those town facilities.
2:14:57 is asking for a donation of $1,000 per wedding based on your ability to pay. So $40 an hour for weddings is ridiculous. So do we just become wedding planners too? I'm just kidding. I think at the very least we should go to $15 for the picnic shelter and the group picnic area each.
2:15:24 And, you know, let's review it again next year. We could take it to $20. I think $20 or $25 is pretty reasonable. We certainly have needs in that park. Remember, it's per hour, it's a two-hour minimum. So if it's $20, it's $40 for two hours. Oh, it is a two-hour minimum? Now we're back to our old rate. So if it's $15, it's $30. Who do we see using mostly? Families.
2:15:48 Our local families, you know, booking it for their events. See, I don't want to take it too high. See, maybe in the future it should be based upon numbers of people. You know, family versus a large number. Can you split it in half? Can you split it in half? We don't. You don't, Eric? You could. We just rent it as one. We have to go through and make two shelters.
2:16:08 I think with the two-hour minimum, you get two hours. You can split it at a table, you know, you can do this price for this, this price for that. You're from 12 to 2, you're from 2 to 4, 4 to 6, I mean, that's... Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And most of the ones you get weren't too little bit left either. I think 15 is good because I think Bill makes a good point that there are people that, you know, that just show up and it's not being used and they can just use it for free, so...
2:16:27 Sounds good with $15 for now. It just still seems really cheap to me. We'll go $15 for now. It's primary use as families, and I know the families are frequent out there. They can't afford more than that anyway, so I don't want to preclude them for usage. I'm sorry to keep asking questions about this one, but this was the one. Skate park, well, the softball field, skate park, volleyball court, basketball court, and soccer field rental. What's the use on those been as far as actual rental? I know a lot of people just show up.
2:16:55 So the only reason we'll reserve them if it's for exclusive use. So if you want it for your use only, like the Whitmore Track, then you reserve it. But if you just want to go out and use it, there's no fee. Have we had many people who are reserving it? We do the soccer rental fee. That's a pretty popular one. Because we get these camps coming up like we're working with right now, that people want to make sure that that fee is just there for them. Typically, I don't think we've seen a reservation for the basketball, volleyball, skate park.
2:17:22 We do it for the soccer field, softball, obviously for the teams. Yeah, and sometimes people will rent the picnic shelter and an hour at the closest softball field so they can have a little hit around or we might rent them the soccer field right in front of the shelter. Yeah, I would almost propose keeping those at 10. I don't know if raising the price is going to slow it down even more than it already is. We don't think so. Okay. Maybe we just do the
2:17:54 Picnic Shelter and the group picnic area at shitty rest, bump it up to 15 instead of the 12. Keep it there for this summer and review it next year. Again, approve the rest of these fees as shown on the thing. That's what I'm proposing. Was that a motion? I was just going to nod my head in consensus, but if you're looking for one. Make it a motion, it's money. Okay, I'll make it a motion. I'll second. You got the motion?
2:18:18 Yes, to accept the changes, the only amendment was the $15. Right. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Just that we need to do the substance. Yeah. All in favor? Aye. Oh, wait. Are we still talking about special permit fee? No, you made a motion as... Okay. I'm not going to complain. Shut me up.
2:18:44 We thought just that item was quite reasonable, Sean. I am not going to fight that. So we're actually eliminating the $5.49 because really no one was going to pay that. So one flat fee. So we just took it up by 20%. I think it's excellent value. I mean, you can see it costs about four hours per permit, $3.20 is the cost. So why are we reducing it then? We're not. It's actually $1.58 was the permit fee we were charging.
2:19:10 We have not been enforcing the 549. We've got so much. But if it costs $320 on average for an employee to issue a permit, why wouldn't it at least be that plus? As you said, we're just taking it up now by that 20%. We're just going to see how we go. Yeah.
2:19:29 I don't know, I can speak. You're nickel and diming people to go to the pool and stuff, but yet when there's events where people have to take out a permit and we're not even covering our staff costs. Yeah, but I will say this, we do make it up in TOT and as an event organizer, you know, it's so much work as it is just to put on an event. I'm, you know, would even recuse myself from some kind of vote on this if I needed to, but I can take both sides of this argument.
2:19:58 Like I said, we just did the 20% across the board. Well, maybe we'll be looking back with the whole subsidy thing together. Yeah, I need my motion. Take back my vote. So I'm going to move on to item number 10. Is that right, Chair? So all I did here, Chair, was put together the proposed timeline for the spring award. You can see it's actually mirrored exactly the same as what it was last year, if you remember. But when I pulled up the dates, they aligned. They're very similar.
2:20:28 You can see it's actually unfortunately bumped into July 2nd for the award. Anyway, that's the only change last year was that end of June, now it's July 2nd. If we do have that council meeting, council might change, I'm not too sure. But anyway, that's where it's sitting right now. So it's scheduled to open March 31st. It'll be open for that month, close April 30. You can see I've scheduled in two of those special hearings if needed. And then it's really on that same.
2:20:58 Program as the Fall Award for the workshop and so forth. I'm wondering, just in light of the fact that our Fall Measure R Awards, with one exception, we're all Town Awards, do we need to have a Spring Award? I was just going to say the same thing. And we've talked to this before. My feeling is we can dump the Spring Award right after we create a vehicle for any emergency and underfunded things.
2:21:29 to come through us so that that funding can be awarded between cycles. I mean, that's what the reason for the Upsertunity was. That's what the committee thought. That's how we drove it. If we're going to get rid of the Upsertunity, I have no problem doing that after we have created the protocol so when the trail and then park doesn't have enough money in its award to complete the grass, and unfortunately that didn't come out in the spring so we weren't able to fund it.
2:21:57 There's a way for them to come back to us and get that funding so we can complete the project and the cycle as it was intended. And I guess I would actually kind of, you know, mirror what Betsy's saying, and I think that maybe that is a very good thing. Maybe we don't have this, and instead we put that program together so that if something goes over, then there's a vehicle for them to come back and not have to wait for one of these funding cycles to move forward. Because I'm just thinking about, I mean, this is a lot of staff time to, you know.
2:22:25 And I guess on top of that, my last thing is in the last couple of years, I hate to say it, but I almost feel that the applications that have been coming forward in the spring are not necessarily oops or tunities. They're kind of going around about the process and they're not filing with everybody else. And so I almost think that that actually is a better idea that we come back and this is just my opinion, so I'd love to hear what everybody else thinks. Let's put that program together.
2:22:53 If there's a project that goes over, what is an easy process so that it doesn't have to go through, you know, so many hoops and processes and five months worth of meetings to get that to go through? And I would love to, you know, sit on a committee to, you know, let's put that together or, you know, instead of putting the spring process through. Without making it so easy that we end up awarding monies through this emergency process.
2:23:21 And running ourselves out of dollars for the major fall of the war. I have no problem with that. Yeah, and I think that that can be put together. From an administration point of view, we take out the 3% in the fall and we take out the 1% in the spring. So the 1%, whatever action's taken, would still need to come out of that amount. That's the only thing I can see right now that would need it.
2:23:50 Good recommendation. You can take that out whether there's a spring process or not. How that comes out of the award. Bring it to the commission. It's still the process, so we still need to have that consideration. But if you look at the last spring awards, it was a lot of town projects, but the header, pipe replacement, MLR, the track club.
2:24:14 The Community Garden Project, you know, so I think there are things that were not necessarily thought of when the first award was going through. So it wasn't an emergency, but it just gave another opportunity for some garden project. I think the header pipe was an emergency. And the garden project is one that just could have waited until the next fall. Yeah, because it's still out there. It wasn't going to hurt anything not to. She was trying to get funding to do it for that very same year, but without planning, we didn't fund it for a reason. Yes, sir.
2:24:45 I mean, I like where you're headed with it because it does save a lot of staff time on that. And whether or not we do something at Marshall that says if there's a project, if there's really a concern, bring it forward. But we would take a look at, especially the town projects, and say, no, no, no, okay, admin time if you want to see that. That doesn't need to go through five hearings to do that. I think it would be one hearing before you and one to the council and that would be done.
2:25:09 So I'm not sure you need to full-blown process at that level. Now, if there is something that comes forward, I think we could put a note out there that says, if there is a project that we're not aware of and someone wants to bring it forward, great, let's take a look at it and bring it forward for you to consider. But for the most part, you'd be saying there's not an anticipation of a formal program to go through all the steps. I think we could get it down to a much simpler process, given that we're not asking for a lot of stuff to come in at this point.
2:25:37 I think that if we had, because I mean it's been brought up because Measure U only has one cycle. You know, it's been brought up if something is an emergency, how do you bring that forward? And that's not been put together. And I almost think that we could make that policy and, you know, that could be brought forward that could be used for Measure R and Measure U. And yes, it has to be looked at because otherwise we're going to be having things brought to us every single month that, you know, somebody wants us to. I think that one or two.
2:26:05 If you had a couple time frames, that's it. And that needs to be clarified in what the criteria would be, what would it truly be an emergency item, because that would be the only way that somebody could bring something forward, is it's a true emergency for whatever that is, otherwise they have to wait until the fall process. And I guess that's one of the reasons why I brought that $70,000. I was like, okay, if this was such an urgent thing, why are we sitting in 2014 and it's still there? But anyways, I almost think that that would be a better...
2:26:35 Policy and Process than having our spring award. Well, I'm also just looking at this and seeing that, you know, that council would, you know, wouldn't, you know, wouldn't make the awards until July 2nd. And, you know, I mean, that's quite a ways into the fall award cycle. Right. Yeah. Yeah. You're almost into your fall award cycles. I don't see it. And from a town project standpoint, I don't see anything out there at this point in time saying it's an emergency to come in and get it now.
2:27:03 The header pipe blows up at the ice rink, yeah, that's an emergency, but we'll deal with it. Oh, Jesus. Can you put that steering committee back together with Measure U and Measure R and actually have that conversation? I don't think that the steering committee is necessary for this. I think the intent of both, when we went through the Measure U cycle, the need showed itself that we have to find a way to fund emergency projects by not having the opportunity. There is a...
2:27:33 A problem there. And I said we would get there. So I would like to see us, if we don't approve this timeline, then what I would like to see us make is the commitment that we are going to create that protocol by the 1st of April so that we can get through the process. So if there is that project, even if it's a new project,
2:28:00 But it is so time sensitive that it has to come forward. We need to create the protocol so they can come and ask for it, and if it's a new project, have them fill out a whole application so that we can judge and determine whether or not we're going to, you know, I don't want to use this as a way for someone to say this is an emergency fund to be without them having to do the paperwork for that. And I don't know that it's the steering committee. I guess I was looking at maybe we have a committee.
2:28:27 Made up of a subcommittee, made up of the commission, as well as the Measure U committee, and that we put this together. Stu, let me ask you, the way this is, I'm sorry, go ahead. I was actually going to suggest that's, I think, this is opening up a can of worms, the Measure R process, I think, is a little cumbersome, and maybe there's a way, if we have an internal committee, we could even look at that, too, because it's, you know, we go to these great lengths.
2:28:57 to coordinate and make sure that we're all okay with a different numbering system, and then we ignore the numbering system and award money how we see fit. And so I know it kind of helps to kind of prioritize in our minds, but maybe there's a way to streamline it a little bit so we don't go through that.
2:29:18 The numbering system I agree with you on totally. The first award cycle we went through with Measure R, we didn't use that. And frankly, I thought it went much smoother. Oh, okay. That was the request from the council to do some sort of a judging thing. And that was a lot of staff. And our time went into trying to solve that. Good job. You heard me say over and over again. You heard me say over and over again. It's a subjective difference. It's so subjective. And even if it scores high.
2:29:46 Doesn't mean that it's the best use of the money for that cycle. So we end up awarding monies based on what the best use is. So maybe the subcommittee could look at both. They could look at what could be done during a non-rating period and then maybe take a look at the rating a little bit. Now my question for Stu is, the way this is written on here, can we take the action that we are not going to have a Measure R spring award?
2:30:16 But starting with March meeting, we will look at creating the emergency funding cycle for R and pass our recommendations along to the Measure U committee for their perusal as well. Yeah, I think you just take no action. And at that meeting, we could set up, we could either do it all ourselves right then, or we could set up a committee for it. You know, ideally, you could just take no action on this, and then we can re-agendize it for the next meeting. It's really the same subject, so you can... Right. But don't re-agendize it as the Measure R spring award. Right.
2:30:47 Agendize it as funding or whatever. Measure process, you can just keep it quite general if you want. And I guess that's why I would say you and Art can work together, so why have two separate processes? I agree. But being a member of the Measure U Committee and knowing everybody on the committee, I don't want to be the one to suggest that they should follow our recommendation. Well, that's why I would include them. Include them in the meeting.
2:31:14 I'm not excluding. I'm including. And they've actually got a meeting scheduled next Tuesday, so there could be something you'd bring up. Put on that agenda, yes. Convene a kind of subcommittee from both and work towards assimilating the funds. If we work together, then we can come up with the same process. Or perhaps in the March meeting, we can just have a workshop dealing with that with the two committees together at 1 o'clock or 12 o'clock. Sounds good. And then if we feel it's necessary to move it to a committee, because it should really be pretty simple. Just a 1 p.m. workshop for an hour. I've said that before.
2:31:43 Okay. That sounds good. That works. So do we need a motion or are we just not taking action? Just not taking action. No action. You've sunsetted and you moved the sprinkling smile. Well, hell no. We made Dan so happy. He's going to get up and do a jig. What else can we do for you, Dan? Chair, can you ask a question with regard to just our timing? We've got three more items as well as reports.
2:32:13 I know I need to walk out by 520 at the very latest. I'm not sure if anyone else does. Are we going to need to move anything looking at the rest of the agenda? I would imagine if the Mammoth Lakes Recreation update is going to take 30 minutes that we would need to leave the Parks Master Planning and the HVS Special Event Venue Study for another time.
2:32:37 I would actually like to at least, you know, I don't know whether we'll get to the master planning. I think we might want to try to get to that one. But the HVS, since it just came to us, I would like to move that to another meeting. Okay. And we probably should have did that earlier because Bill's probably been sitting here this whole time for that. And I think we need to deal with the MLR because that's going to council. So anyhow, and parts class master planning, they need to probably look at because you have a contract that you're going to. Yeah, so we just have this item.
2:33:06 Chair that I provided to you, this was the latest update we just got yesterday. Let's see how fast we can get through the MLR update. Maybe while Bill is here, because I know he kind of just did sort of a one-sheeter, I don't know if you just want to give a quick commentary on it, or just go ahead. On the HBS. On the HBS. Because I know Bill had just sort of spilled it down into one page, so I don't know if you wanted to sort of give a quick bullet point thing, or if we should just move on. It's up to the Chair.
2:33:37 If that's what the commission wants to do, I promise. We don't have to. Okay, let's see how bad where we are on our agenda with the time to get there. And you've got a problem. I just wanted to recognize the time. I'm doing that well lately in a lot of different ways. A lot of different areas.
2:34:08 Okay, so item number 11 is the MLR update. So a couple of things working here. You can see that the steering committee has completed their work. Members of the committee representing the Recreation Commission is Commissioner Truex and Vice-Chair Stelic. We're going to jump in immediately after I finish condensing the staff report. But where we're at right now is the steering committee recommended the final report, which was version 4.0, be presented to the council.
2:34:37 for their consideration and review on February 19th. Staff is currently working through an agenda bill. The steering committee is going to meet once again on Monday, February 10th at 3 o'clock. They're going to review the agenda bill. And then we're also going to, with this meeting here, provide any comments as a collective commission to town council regarding the MLR report. So if that makes sense,
2:35:07 I know we're running out of time. I think all I did was kind of provide a little overview here. And in your report is the version 4.0. Since that time, the 5.0 version has come out. So since this time, this has been outdated. But as again, I think Vice Chair Stille can run through whatever changes we've made to that report and seek any consensus comments from the Commission. And we're looking for any questions that you guys might have. And then I also just want to bring up that the bylaws should not have been
2:35:37 Included in this packet that we want to completely disregard those bylaws, that they were kind of put together briefly with other entities, and there's many issues with that. So that's going to be a complete revision, and actually not even a revision. Those are not going to be used. We will be starting over with different bylaws.
2:35:58 Creating those as far as the MLR goes. So I just want to clarify that because there's some major issues with just reading through any of that. So I want to make sure that it shouldn't have actually gone out. It's not a public because that was determined at the last meeting that it wasn't even worth going through that we need to start all over with us. So that's kind of the first thing. I want to make sure we get out there. So and then there is the revision 5.0. So the last one, the 4.0 that you guys have was the cleanest document that we had.
2:36:27 Kind of going into the agenda. The new one came out yesterday. Yeah, so the new one just came out. So basically there was just a few clarifications on some of the verbiage. Kind of probably one of the biggest ones that we want to make sure, and Betsy can correct me if there's some others that we need to deal with, is when we were looking at the MLR functions, they're more strategic.
2:37:03 Imperatives, so make sure that that's, you know, that this isn't completely black and white. And then the MLR scope of work, that these are possible projects or scope of work for MLR, that this is not, you know, the etched in stone because we were real concerned about what was on here on the capital facilities, number one, is that there hasn't been any, this is just projects such as that are on here. We want to make sure that that's clarified.
2:37:31 And that the Mammoth Lakes Recreation, when you look at the budget scenarios, it's exactly what it is. It's proposed allocation scenarios that they are not... This is basically what would be addressed if the council opts to move forward with the MLR process, then we'll be hammering those out. Yeah, and the next step is actually delving into the actual method. So we come up with, you know...
2:38:00 All of the detailed information that you would like. So this is more of an overview as to this is what MLR could accomplish and could do. And so the nuts and bolts are what's coming forward. And that would include, we've talked about milestone dates. I know one of the people's, a lot of people are looking at
2:38:22 Where it says on the assumptions on page 17, outside leverage should at least match overhead costs so as to be revenue neutral. Looking at milestone dates, what is a recovery period? What are our incremental target items that we're looking to accomplish? So anyway, those are some of the things that we're going to be delving into. Yeah, and that's kind of the more than one year but fewer than five. You know, one to five years kind of type thing.
2:38:55 And so we're looking, you know, kind of, do you guys have any questions on what's moving forward? It's going to council on the 19th to see if they agree to move forward with the final process. So the final process is putting the organization together. And that is where the organization, the bylaws, the board, the funding, the duties, contracts. And so it is the final stage of MLR.
2:39:26 Having gone to attending most of the committee's meetings, it's really a dedicated group of people, and I compliment you for all your efforts. There are, in my opinion, a lot of flaws in this report. There are things that need to be corrected, which were discussed with the consultants, and I guess this 5.0 version hopefully has those changes. But part of it, I was concerned that
2:39:55 To some degree, it seems a little bit like the commission is being bypassed in that if there's going to, because this is really a rough draft that we're looking at right now. It's more high level. I'm not sure rough draft is, yeah. Well, it's not a final draft, I guess is what I'm saying. And my suggestion was why not give it the time that's needed so that our group can really look at this because a couple of you have not been to
2:40:27 to listen to some of the meetings and some not even during the summer process. So why not just take an extra month to kind of look at what a more final version is and then there could perhaps be more buy-in to it and go to council. But that's not the case. And so some of the comments in the report indicate that
2:40:50 There was public participation that wholly supported both phases of the project. You know, there's wordsmithing, terminology that's in this report that's really not correct. And the consultants acknowledge that. And then there's also references to different, it talks about trying to consolidate efforts and have fewer advisory groups, but yet they're talking about having the MLTSCC committee.
2:41:21 goes by the wayside, but yet the board might come in with other recommendations for a group to handle the trails project. Another concern that I had is why is trails to be part of an MLR? Why was that selected? So in my opinion, there are different facets of this report that are very good, very comprehensive, although it
2:41:50 Did detail that there should be a comprehensive business plan that really wasn't provided. So it's a good report. It's a good beginning. I would recommend that we just accept the report. I know that my fellow commissioners have really had the time to really study it fully, except, you know, certainly Teri and Betsy are very aware of what's going on. So maybe just accept it.
2:42:19 Goes on to counsel from here. Yeah, I'm going to comment that unfortunately I have not been able to attend any of the MLR meetings and would like to spend more time with this as well. So with regard to the timeline and the process, I have some questions myself that I just haven't even been able to truly formulate. So especially if we are talking about MLTSCC going away, you know, I would like to understand it a little bit more as well.
2:42:50 The timeline that we are proposing, this is going before Town Council on the 19th, is that what I heard? Yes. So by accepting this report, does that delay it going to Town Council? No, no. And if I could just respond to the conversation about MLTSCC, my understanding, and Teri or the other committee members who are present, it's my understanding that, you know,
2:43:15 When the MLR organization is formed, should council choose to move in that direction, that they would look at the MLTSCC as a committee that they could convene with that expertise, or there would be a transition, but I don't think that it's necessarily been decided. It's just it's decided that trails in general would be under the umbrella of MLR.
2:43:40 And so you have MLR that's taking on things that are not generally your municipal activities. And so trails fall within that. And so how that is going to be integrated and moved over and how it's going to be handled is actually going to be determined by the organization and probably in conjunction with the director that we end up, you know, hiring.
2:44:08 How do they see this moving forward in the best possible way? Is it still MLTSCC or is it some other form of movement? And so, you know, this is just, you know, this is one of the activities that is a resort activity. It is a community activity as well as a resort activity and trails fits completely within what MLR.
2:44:36 has been discussed all along. But that's a key, I mean, that's called out and measure our language. The town is involved with gathering money, applying for grants for trails. So to say, to section that out and to say that that's not part of recreation, it's not part of the town, is convenient.
2:45:00 We're not saying it's not part of Recreation or not part of the town. There's going to be some very close working relationships within the town of Mammoth Lakes and MLR organizations. One other thing, too, is that the town attorney was asked about use of Measure R and Measure U funds. And he specifically says, and this is why in the report it says that you need to change the expenditure plan of Measure R, that the language of Measure R prohibits the town from giving funds to MLR to manage facilities.
2:45:29 Programs, Trails, or Parks. You know, so some of the advice that's been given, you know, has perhaps been ignored because Trails is a very big portion of this report for an MLR. Well, I'm not sure that it's been ignored. I think that there's more to come from a legal standpoint. If I could just speak generally to this report.
2:45:57 When I got involved in MLR, things I'd been hearing about it, I did have some concerns. I feel like as a committee member, just personally, I put in a lot of time. And I've spoken to people in the community, and their response has kind of been, well, we don't have time to go to multiple.
2:46:16 for our meetings, but we trust the people who are involved. And I think that some of the processes as we have now, as we just discussed with the Spring Award, are not necessarily sustainable. And maybe the town manager could speak more to that. But I think there's a lot of passion behind getting something built. And I think that for the first time, we've really laid out a framework, a roadmap, so to speak, for making that happen.
2:46:43 And I think there's still a lot of questions to be addressed. I hope that there wouldn't be so many by this point in the process after all these hours, but there are. And I feel really passionately about it. My comments are pretty simple. We tasked a group to get together and to come through all this, and they've done it. I have some huge concerns. However, I didn't sit in any of those meetings, and they have. I hope they've heard those concerns, and I hope they're coming to the...
2:47:15 Forefront. My concerns are overhead at almost $300,000 and $300,000 is set aside, leaves $300,000 left to do things with. MLTSCC, what happens to the efforts of building those trails and doing those things, does in fact that money end up being the overhead for this group.
2:47:44 The other is, I hear grumblings back that perhaps, and the Forest Service has told us in MLT SEC straight out, and I don't know if this group has met with the Forest Service to see what their consideration is, that if a third-party group gets put in charge of the town trails, that the Forest Service is pretty simply going to tear up the MOU and chuck it out the window. Is that fair? No. But at this point, it's sort of their basketball.
2:48:14 They're dictating. So before we go down too far into dedicating trails into this, we really need to find out about that MOU and the Forest Service's concerns if that hasn't already been done. Other than that, I really trust you guys. If you think this is the way we need to go and you guys have put in the work and all of that, it's a good group of people.
2:48:38 I know how I feel sitting up here after I put hours and hours into something and somebody comes up and says, well, no, that's all fine, thanks for your work, but here's what we're going to do. So at this point I am not, you know, raving saying, yeah, oh boy, this is the next best thing to Mammoth Brewing Company, but those are my concerns and they've been written down.
2:49:04 I would like to hear a report back on how we're going to deal with those things. And if using that 300,000, I would like to see back how that 300,000 in two years, if it's revenue neutral, that's fine. But if it's not, where's our performance standards? When do we decide this thing isn't working and dismantle it and go back to another mode of doing something? I'm not outside the realm of trying new things, obviously. That's why SAM measure R.
2:49:31 Measure U committees and sort of help put together the MLTSCC thing because we need to try new ways to be successful. So I'm not against that. I just have some concerns and I've noted that when I'll show you. So you're raising good questions, but the timeline is such that those questions are going to go to the group on the 10th and then they're not going to come back to the commission. They're not going to come back to you as a chairperson asking these questions because it's going to go then straight to council and then it's going to go on from there.
2:50:02 So that's what I meant about the process. What is an extra couple of weeks to get the answers to some of these questions? It's almost like a rubber stamp. That's actually the next process is to answer all these questions that you guys are raising right now. And so I guess when...
2:50:23 We can sit here and put off and put off and put off. I'm not suggesting that. But it's just as one of those things that this has been identified and it has been a public process. There has been public participation. And I guess I'm concerned about the comments that there was wordsmithing of people's comments. I mean, there was a whole room of people here that gave a thumbs up to move to the next.
2:50:48 Step. The next step has been done. So now this is, you know, do we move to the next step? And this commission, you know, what this commission is going to be looking at, and from what we're looking at right now with the MLR process, would focus more on programming and the facilities and that type of thing, more of the municipal recreation. There would be another board that's going to be looking at the MLR activities.
2:51:17 Yet another group that's not necessarily going to be just another committee. None of the facilities go to this organization. No, I'm not suggesting that. So, yeah, they are still owned by the town. Well, and I think that we have just proven in our discussion about, you know, the, you know, about, you know, fees and, you know, for our programs that there's still, you know, the Recreation Commission will have plenty of...
2:51:41 Work to do, you know, even with another organization looking more to enhance and augment, you know, what we're currently offering. We're just yet another layer. Taking money from Measure R and Measure U that maybe it should go to the voters. I mean, because looking at that overhead, that kind of money is maybe something that the voters, is that really what they thought when they were voting for Measure R and Measure U? I'm just suggesting that the process has been...
2:52:10 such that why not do it right? You know, why not go through the process? Well, and I would respectfully say, too, that, you know, that the examples are not, you know, are examples. They're not a budget for an organization that, you know, that the council has to decide to move forward with, you know, creating an organization and then, you know, we'll have, you know, we'll have yet another say on what comes out of the formation committee and whether or not to go forward.
2:52:40 This will come back to the commission again, but it has been, you know, we as a commission said, yes, let's move forward to this. It's been said, yes, let's move forward to the next step. So I don't want to start going backwards because unfortunately if we look at every single report we've done and every single plan that we've done, we never move forward with anything because of a fear of something new. And so, you know, we have a group of people that are going to do their due diligence.
2:53:08 on the next steps, taking this high level and putting in the actual work plan and business plan and then bringing that back to council and the community. And it is going to be a public process. We're moving forward to the rest of this. I would just like to comment. I'm going to deflate some of the argument, I think. The way this is written, Mammoth Lake Recreation update, this is not an action item. It has been given to us. This is an update. We have not been asked.
2:53:36 And by not being asked, I don't think we actually can do anything but comment to council. So if we have individual comments for council, I certainly suggest calling your five councilmen and telling them how we feel or how you feel. But other than that, the council has not, and I'm not even going to, other than that, we were here to hear an update. We've heard the update. So it's five to five.
2:54:00 Unless somebody has something else outside of an argument. I'd like to just move this forward. We've heard the update. Call your councilman. Make your feelings known. Okay, because council would like to know how we feel moving forward. So your rec commission, you know, so if you want to individually call your council members, then that's... I think that we're looking at a general consensus if that's...
2:54:30 I take it to Council. Council needs to decide whether to move it forward. I'm not prepared to say move it forward, and I would not give that recommendation yet without having read this whole thing. I'm saying that you guys have done your work, and it's going to Council, and Council now needs to make that decision. The only thing that I'd like to add to that is, Bill, you've asked some very important questions, especially, unfortunately, I will say, with the stance from the Forest Service that...
2:55:00 They just, you know, are refusing to even consider working with this is what I have heard as well. So I've got some concerns. It sounds like we're not taking action as much as just passing on comments at this time. Is that accurate? Yes. So unless I'm mistaken here and someone can correct me if I am, this is going to go to the next phase. The next phase is creating the organization.
2:55:24 The organization doesn't get created until the council pulls the trigger at some time in the future, however long that is, to say, okay, now we're going to go forward. At that point in time, if we really don't like it, as a commission and as individuals, we'll be able to say, it won't be the first time that we've spent consultant fees and then not used their work. We will then be able to say, thank you, but no thank you, or wow, this is really exciting, I want to move it forward.
2:55:50 There are so many things in the offing right now, including whether or not we're going to buy potentially some land for event centers. If that happens, has this group looked at what that does to the potential R&U dollars and how that may affect their overhead? There may not be money left for overhead for this group. The tech council's got to take that into consideration if they want to buy those properties as well. So I don't want to politic one way or the other.
2:56:18 If Council wanted to move forward, I don't think this is the time to either argue for or against the project. That will be the time when they decide whether or not they're going to pull the trigger on this thing. I would just like to respond to Commissioner Stehlik's comment about, because this has been mentioned previously on numerous occasions, about a fear of something unknown. And I don't have a fear of something.
2:56:44 Unknown. I think we should be thinking out of the box. We need to be more creative. But I just think that there's a process that should be more involved with us and thinking about what is the best thing for the town. I appreciate your comments. I think that has been taken into consideration over the many meetings and many hours that we've been working through and will continue to be.
2:57:15 at the forefront of the many hours and many meetings that we'll be having to form this organization. And I've been right there with you guys. Yes, and I really appreciate your... So, unless there's any more specifics, and when I read this, if I come up with more specifics, believe me, you guys will be hearing from me. Is there anything that Dan or Joe you wanted to add? Yeah, I'll just say one bit.
2:57:45 Bill, your concerns are there if you – when you have the chance, if you look in the appendix and you see all the things that are next steps, all the legal issues are there. That includes permits, how we use R&U because of what the voters approved and all of that kind of things. Sean, as far as – it does not necessarily get rid of MLTSCC. It says that there might be a better way to organize and manage that kind of work. So it specifically says that –
2:58:11 implementation of the trails, which in my mind was the prioritizing of it.
2:58:16 Would go to MLR. The actual building of a trail is still going to be a town function. MLR isn't going to be laying asphalt. That's a town facility. So there's a whole bunch of information that you both haven't had a chance to. And if you want to meet with me over the next week or so, I'd be glad to go through it with you in the detail that it should have. I'm just sorry that with the meeting management, we're running out of time here. And I have to dash off because I have to teach in a little bit. Thank you. Thank you.
2:58:47 Dan, did you have anything you wanted to add to that? Thank you. So moving on now to the Parks Master Planning, we need to do that, right? Yep. So just quickly, Chair, I provided the latest version from Verde Design, which is February 1, 2014. They've revised that scope of work that you saw in the Measure R application. And they've also revised the project timeline. You can see the...
2:59:18 Schedule is to begin March 13th with two charrettes. So the first charrette, and both charrettes are not mutually exclusive. We'll actually incorporate all four of the parks in both of those charrettes. So we've got a charrette March 13th, April 10th, and looking to present to council June 5th. You can see the revised compensation package. So remember we were not to exceed 50.
2:59:49 They're right at $49,999. And then there's also additional staff time. And then also in that packet we've included kind of an overview of really the advertising promotional schedule that's required to encourage our community to be engaged in this Parks Master Planning effort. So you can see I've put in a tentative budget, I believe, of the $5,000 we've put in, I think, is about $2,500, I think, between the newspaper, radio and...
3:00:16 That informational postcard and box drop, we think that's probably the best way to reach our community with an informational postcard. We'd also overprint and have those throughout the community. We can give them to our lodging partners. Wherever we can get them, we'll try and get people to. And that also is in addition to the social media and free channels that we currently use for advertising and promotion. So with that, what we're really seeking is a direction to move forward.
3:00:43 with contracting Verdi Design and any changes to the timeline or scope of work that you see moving forward. I have a concern about the amount, number one, because I think the award was for $55,000.
3:01:08 We added an additional pack, remember? Yeah, no, I know, I'm not concerned about the award, but their contract is coming in basically at $50,000. You're saying that your advertising is, you're looking at about $2,500, so it leaves us $2,500, and, you know, their travel expenses are reimbursable, so for them coming down for these charrettes, are we going to be looking at additional travel expenses for those charrettes, or the charrettes?
3:01:38 Accounting for their travel, because it does say it's in a reimbursable expense. So if that's the case, then we're not going to be within our budget for... Okay, I'll have to clarify that with Peter. Okay. That's a good question. Okay, that was on page... That's on the very back. ...page five. That was on page five, right, just below the compensation, I think. The above fee includes all reasonable reimbursable expenses that are outlined. So I guess what they're saying is that we're including those...
3:02:15 Reimbursable expenses. But it's a good point to clarify. I don't know. When it says reimbursable, I... Yeah, because then on the last page it says... But a charrette is $7,300, so that seems kind of high even if you look at their salary level. Mm-hmm. I guess I would just clarify it, so anyhow. Yeah, so if you have any questions, we can certainly clarify and send some clarifying emails back to the commission. And so basically they're going to be taking all of our plans that we have and then...
3:02:46 Kind of putting something together to start with? Yes. Or are they just taking information from the charrettes? One of the town responsibilities, they want an initial list of program elements for each park site. They're looking for priorities and program elements. So we're really going to be handing over all the work that we've done in that last year. So everything in the prioritization, all our comments and notes. And you can see what we're required to provide as well. I think it talks about. Yeah, it does. I just want to make sure that that's...
3:03:23 It's not spelled out completely. Right. My only question on it is the timeline, and it's not a big deal, except I really want to be part of this process. I've been wanting to master plan our parks now for the last 16 years. I will not be here for the March 13th meeting. So I would love to see that, if at all possible. I'm not sure if I'm here for the 10th, but... And the only reason why we have it for June 5th is because I know there's a desire from Council that can't have this one.
3:03:55 Wrapped up. Wrapped up, right. And I think that was what we were trying to do. But, you know, we can go back to the consultant and have them look at some alternative dates if you wish. Is it, is March 13 and April 10, are they just the day or is it the week that you're out or is it? Well, for me, the whole week from the 8th to the 16th of March is a traditional, my whole family.
3:04:20 Takes, and that's locked in stone because several family members have jobs that require them to actually get time off. Since our regular meeting's on the 4th, could it happen that week, or is that too soon? We're good right now.
3:04:37 We pick mid-March only to give us additional time to get all this material. That kind of squeezes... The following weekend would be better. So March 13 is a Thursday. We could maybe push it to the 20th. Maybe we can give them the 20th.
3:04:58 And what about April 10? Would just bump that a week as well? You know, I may be here. I'm not sure yet. So I think I'm going to be leaving. So I could probably be here for the 10th. I would probably leave Friday. We're still here because I don't know. I have a meeting in Arizona on the 12th. 19th of April. April worked for me. I don't know about everybody else. April or more? April. The week of April 20th. When's your spring break?
3:05:22 The week of it, yeah, that Easter week is not going to be good for Sean or for me, but prior to that would be fine. So the 17th? Yeah, Easter week is the 13th through the 19th, right? The 20th, so Easter's very late this year. Yeah, it's late. The 10th is probably fine, too. We should probably leave it, too. Okay, so we'll look at March 20th. Are they going to be in the mornings or afternoons? It's up to you. It's really for the public, too, right? So we're trying to get the most time for the public to be, so they might actually be towards the end of the day. You know, I think there may be 4 o'clock or 5 o'clock.
3:05:52 An evening type of thing? I mean, we're really trying to get public here, isn't it? So it might be a five to a seven type of thing? Like we did with the RecStrats, remember? Any comments on that? For the public, probably evening is best. For me, you know, not being home in the evening, do I get in more trouble? Yes. But if it's necessary, of course, that's a good thing. Okay.
3:06:26 That's fine. So we're looking at March 20th and then April 10th? March 20, April 10th, and we'll just hopefully keep that timeline the same if they're okay with that. Yeah. Look at meetings from 5 to 7. I'll get clarification on the reimbursable fees and any other charges that might be impacting that amount. You know, we do have that 5,000. We're allocating half of it right now for advertising, half of it for staff time. So you might have a little bit of wiggle room in there that we can, you know, if it goes over by 1,000, we can pull it out of our time and adjust accordingly.
3:06:55 Are we looking at the community centre for the Shirets? I haven't picked a venue, but that would probably be the most logical. Yeah. That seemed to work, you know, reasonably well for the last workshops we did. So the commission review meeting May 1st, is that to be done prior to our May 6th meeting? Is that the intention? We could actually put that on your agenda. That might make sense to actually do it on May 6th if you prefer. We can give them that date.
3:07:30 I just don't know how much time they need. Yeah, I'd almost like to see how that meeting is shaping up for us because that's getting to be a busy time of year as well. And I want to give this the time it deserves. Not if we're not doing Measure R. Yeah, well, but that'll be long after that. Well, yeah, spring, yeah. Measure R, sorry, to be clear, Measure R Spring. Right, the parks are starting to open and decisions are being made. That's a couple months off, so.
3:08:01 We've got some flexibility there. Yeah. I guess if there's that final presentation on the 1st, it actually gives time that if there's any questions or anything that needs to come back to us on the 6th, that could actually happen. That would probably be favorable to me. Here's your presentation and then... Yeah, so any clarification could come back to us on the 6th. Okay.
3:08:26 Pretty much that's the last opportunity. Yeah, and then we don't have to have them here. Oh, no, there's the final design meeting on the 26th. Okay, are we good with that? It's Memorial Day. We'll follow up. Okay, moving on. Special event as your study. I'm sure, and again, I'm sorry that I'm going to need to walk out at 520. Do you see my calendar ringing? Okay. Okay. Bill?
3:09:05 I'm sorry. It's all right. So assuming you still want to talk about this, we can do this really quickly. I assume you've looked briefly at the staff report. So let's just jump to the next steps, which are on page three of the staff report. Oh, by the way, for the record, Bill Taylor. Really, at this point, there's a series of decisions that need to be made with regard to where we go forward.
3:09:36 If you look under what are going to be the town council decisions, the first question the town council is going to have to decide is whether or not they want to move forward with further evaluation of events facilities and events sites and whether they're interested in investing at all. I'm assuming the answer to that question is yes, but if for some reason the council were to say, you know, we don't want to use town funding that way, whether it's Measure U or Measure R,
3:10:06 or General Fund or whatever, then this is a done deal. So I'd like to just walk you through the same set of questions because your recommendations would ultimately go forward to Council. So the first one is, does this even move forward from here? The second one is, if it does move forward, is it going to be conducted by the town or should this be moved on to MLR, assuming that MLR in fact does get formed?
3:10:37 Obviously, if it's delegated to MLR, then the process is theirs to develop. Finally, if it's conducted by the town, is it handled, essentially is the process run by staff, by you, the Recreation Commission, by a Blue Ribbon Committee, or by some other process? And honestly, at this moment, those are probably the questions that would be worth
3:11:08 Speaking too quickly so that there can be some direction going forward to council. So I guess I'll ask the first one, and that is, even though I think I know the answer, would you like to see this continue and would you like to see further research into the sites that were selected by the, or not selected, but preliminary, identified or prioritized by the consultants?
3:11:38 I would say, yes, we need to look at the report and move forward as to what the best recommendations are, and then... Right. I mean, I'm assuming that you all still would like to see... Town has talked about having events venues, events facilities, and so on. I'm assuming that's something that everybody would like to continue with. Yes. Yes. Okay. The second one is, do you think that this process is best conducted by the town government, by the municipality, or...
3:12:08 By MLR, should MLR be created? I would say MLR. But I think that there's possibly a blue ribbon committee that maybe could actually even convene and go over the information right now. And then that could then move into MLR because we're looking at MLR is not going to even be formed. Yeah, I would hate to see this. Yeah, so I think there's an interim process that could possibly happen right now. That would be my thoughts. Right now, MLR is just still big picture.
3:12:39 Even after seven months, it's still kind of pie in the sky. So to delegate it to an MLR, I think, is a little premature. I agree with what Terry's saying. Yeah, I think that there's something interim. There's an interim process that you put a group together that can look at the information that's here and kind of formulate those next steps and we start looking into those. So there's some answers that are already done by the time.
3:13:09 And MLR is even formed. And forgive me, I really have not had a chance to delve into this at all. I'm just seeing this copy of this for the first time. At this point, I would think that it needs to come back to the Rec Commission in our next meeting to make our comments on the whole process. I think we all want it to move forward. But whether it needs to be a Blue Ribbon Committee or Town Staff or Rec Commission.
3:13:37 I've got a lot of ingestion to do first. Okay, and that's fine. I don't think the point of this was to force any kind of decision, but to lay out a process and a decision-making path so that it can continue to move forward given that you do want to. Right. And I guess if there was ever, if there's a committee that's formed, I think it includes rec commission. Right. I think it includes staff. And, you know, I think that's, you pick those folks that are in there. Well, and certainly initially if,
3:14:07 You're going to start this Blue Ribbon Committee. It's going to have to have town staff support. There's no way that this is going to happen without that. I was hoping we would have the time tonight with you here to go through this whole report and for you to tell us how these things were achieved and others. Since I'm timed out now, and so has Sean. What can I do for you for the next meeting?
3:14:37 What would you like? Or do you just want time? Your presence. Okay. For questions. And opinions so that after I read this I can ask those questions and I mean you're prepared tonight. I'm the one that's not. That's great. Well, I think that if we read the report with these items in mind that maybe we can put something together that, you know, we can ask you questions and we can put something together. And maybe it would help both of us if we have some.
3:15:06 Real big questions. If we email Stu with him and he can pass them along to you in the interim, that will make our next meeting that much more productive. That would be excellent. Yeah. Oh, excuse me. And any recommendations as well? Yeah. Super. Thank you very much. With that, I, unfortunately, unless it's really... Thank you, Bill. Thanks for staying all this time. Yeah. I was interested in the other parts, too. Okay. Thank you. So let's quickly run through manager's report.
3:15:36 I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions for Stu? It was well written. Good job. I don't know if I had any questions. I didn't have any questions. 400 skaters, that was impressive. Yeah. And the lacrosse tournament thing is exciting. The numbers are, have you guys talked about with anything with like maybe the bowling alley and our roller rink, if we can do anything that's in conjunction with each other? There's cross-tees too, right? Yeah, cross-tees, okay.
3:16:04 And actually, I do have a question, but I kind of got it answered by Bill.
3:16:22 With regard to the January 30th meeting that was down in Bishop, I kind of got that answered by Steve and John Wentworth, but I don't know if you want to speak to that, or if we even have time. I didn't attend. Okay. Because we had Peter Carson and Steve Gutierrez. Okay. I already got that answered, Joe. I don't know if we want to do it here or not. Just due to lack of time. Okay. The lacrosse coming to Whitmore, that sounds enticing. That sounds great. Hopefully that works out.
3:16:49 Yeah, that's not the issue. It's getting them into the school. You're getting them into the other fields, yeah. The school says it's open, so I'm getting that facility use agreement in. That group is completing that right now and walking in to get it to the school and get them to hold it. And I think we should be okay. So we're trying really hard to make that up. They're actually going to try and come up for a field visit, which is what we really need to do and walk them around and show them what we actually have is going to exceed or at least meet their expectations. Yeah, great. But it's big. It's a lot of potential. That's two weekends. That's a lot of people.
3:17:19 Pretty exciting. Maybe it will spark interest in having a lacrosse league here. Yeah, absolutely. It's hugely popular. We have that down south. It became very popular north. Commissioner, report. Sean. Go ahead. A lot of time at MLR. Good time. Now, where did I put that before? I will entertain a motion. I move to adjourn.
3:17:49 I'll second. I got a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye.