TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 3 hr 59 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

486 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 We've got a few things going on, as you might imagine. Okay. Yeah, no, glad you did. That's what she said.

0:29 Thank you.

0:54 And Stu, this afternoon's meeting, was it scheduled to be done by 4? No, that sounds like a great goal. Actually, my 4.30 appointment canceled, so I guess I don't need to be up by 4. Were we scheduled to be done by 4? Yeah.

1:18 I would think so too. I know. Sorry. No, it's okay. Hey man, you see me. I try to speed it up. I do. It should be fine. MLTSCC does. Yeah.

1:46 I will now call this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission to order roll call please here

5:44 Yes, public comments, this is the time any member of the public wishing to comment on something that doesn't otherwise appear on the agenda. We will close public comments. When am I supposed to catch my breath if there are no public comments? Come on. Consent agenda in the minutes of February 4th meeting. Can I have a comment? Okay. If I could. If we could pull number one to discuss. One and only item on the consent agenda. If you want to discuss number one, let's discuss it.

6:21 The only suggestion I have is under the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Update, there maybe should be consensus that no action was taken. I noticed on some of the other items when nothing was taken. Except it wasn't an action item, it was just an update. Right. I have a problem. We took no action. If you want that notated, that's fine with me. It's fine. Yeah, it was just an update, so there was no action. So with that particular piece out of the way, do I have a motion?

6:53 So moved. Second. A motion to the second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Carries unanimous. Number two is a workshop with the Measure U Application Committee regarding the proposed R&U Opportunity Award Process. Are we all going to take our seats around the big old round table or are we going to have them just stand here in front of us? We're going.

7:40 What's the consensus here? Okay, so let's move ourselves down to the, should I take my microphone with me? No, there is not.

12:58 Process

12:59 Okay

13:07 Okay

13:21 Okay.

13:51 It doesn't mean you're going to have it.

13:53 And our potential is to suspend this criminal work process and to come up with a funding process to do those diversity work, not to suspend the entire process of RU while we're waiting for the launch of MLR via the encounter for that. It's not productive. I think even in those six instances where staff is bringing it forward, we would like to request that.

14:26 for the discussion when it comes up in the fall. Yes, but without a full process. At some point, there has to be a process to access it. Or you have public law from the funds. You've made a piece of general funds. Only for town CIPP projects. I don't think any of the cities in the state wanted to see them. So I think that what I'm asking is the council to come back with some assurance that the process is going to stay in place. Who manages the process may change.

14:57 But to change the process itself without reconvening the Measure R and the Measure U organizing committees in the first place and saying, well, yes, we're fine with this change, it doesn't make sense. So I process very kind of action. We all know that. However, in this case, a lot of time was spent to create a fair and unbiased process. We went out of our ways to get a bias to the point where we weren't suggesting the project's coming forward, and we should have been.

15:27 I think the process needs to stay in place. Not just say, well, okay, now you're NLR, now create your own process. Are you? That would be taking it out of the scope of the process that's been done.

15:59 What is being recommended is that that go back to the entire community, and that is what goes through the process it's supposed to be.

16:10 I'm not sure if you want to do this.

16:12 You're right.

16:13 Well, if you're saying this is the way you did, if you have any on the other, you don't know what the people are, and if you aren't often found out, you don't know what the other thing is outside of the scope of the people.

16:25 I'm detracting our greatest example so far that if you change the rules to what I'm sort of seeing sway through right now, a project like that wouldn't be able to work as a project because it's not part of our priority.

16:40 I don't know where the mindset of council is right now.

18:42 You know, this becomes an issue, and all of a sudden there's a danger in the corner. It's like destruction. You know, so we need this kind of thing where it's a kind of issue. The committee can really think about carrying it on with some side things so that we don't have to destroy it. One of the other things, you know, since I'm really well on a tangent right now, but just take it to you being off the tangent. We had discussed the idea of perhaps the better even community

19:13 and whether our recreation commission is basically coming together with the ML, meeting together with MLR, and forcing our concerns, and helping be a part of the process to ensure that all this hard work that the strengthens have done are, and they are, and they're doing them to make sure that it is still, you know, preserving these additional events.

19:43 So I think speaking of the NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN

20:47 Go back to Council and name it a lot. One is, are we all in agreement or consensus that we would like to see any emergency come forward as we have made it out for the record use tomorrow? So I'd like to hear from the Recreation Commissioners on that so that there could be a unified voice for students to hear that. That would be an emergency process by which at any time when the emergency comes over, they can bring it to staff.

21:17 And I'm okay with that because I think that's what we had said in our last commission. As opposed to having this weird process, we just need to have that emergency because we can't have it. So that was, you know, what we had supposed to do.

21:47 I think that, you know, five-year cyclers, which you're calling them, are key and needs to be put in a place that still haven't been served, but there's monies that were put towards a pocket two years ago in the trail, but I guess we needed it at time to bring all the money up for a grant. And, you know, it's supposed to be all the other money we're going to pay to spend first before they need that time to buy.

22:17 Maybe not need it. I don't know. I'm not quite sure where that took something like this. I guess when I'm looking at an emergency, you have two, three years ever go, but it's still sitting there. Well, it becomes, in that case, it becomes an emergency if the guarantee of that money is standing between us and receiving the grant. Then I would be doing that important enough to call the commission together or to come in together.

22:47 And actually, I think a measuring R layout, whether it continues to be a commission on MLR, similar to what Steve has done for our project tracking list at the MLTSC level, would help us unlock that, because it would list all the projects we received first.

23:16 and what their current status is and how much of that has been used to the point of completion. At any point, they wouldn't drop off the list, they would just drop off the piece of the list to complete because it would be a finished project. But anybody that then wants to read what it's all off, or anybody that's wanting to go back and read the whole thing, they have an opportunity to see what projects have been funded and what would be more possible. And that's what the opportunity turns out to be.

23:42 Thank you.

24:23 We'll see ever within a month or two for another $80,000 worth of construction. But this out-here O&M issue is going to come up. Kind of like that grant issue, the commitment, so the city college district will say, okay, you can use their $2.5 or $3 billion or whatever it is. These things kind of back up with respect to NLR.

24:58 These are on the table now, and they now are, I don't know, the way some of those kinds of things are involved. Well, that's a little bit, Chris. It is. The Forest Service, because some of that, it was committed, based on the five-year, to the project by the town. These are served. And the Forest Service would have been making some of these new projects, and they would have charged new projects, which has been three-yearly since the first step of the capital project, and we'll have that with every three.

25:30 Yep.

26:09 It was a previous Measure U funding recipient. It has to be a compelling project. Now, compelling obviously can be defined further. And then the project is experiencing a funding crisis, is time-sensitive, and is ongoing. Those were kind of the three carryovers. And then the funding priorities were recommended to be carried over from the Fall Award, which is kind of a discussion for the Rec Commission, too, if you need to consider revising the priorities, or are they just kind of carried over from the Fall Awards?

26:40 Can you read those games as a compelling funding crisis, experience a funding crisis? Project is experiencing a funding crisis, or, you know, needs funds. I mean, I don't know what you want to pick a different word there. Is time sensitive? So the funds are kind of required in an urgent, emergency manner. And is ongoing, so it's kind of an existing project, requires funding. You know, an example we've talked about could be the structure here, or an example could be, you know, the Waterford project, which is ongoing.

27:10 That might need additional funding. So there's projects that would kind of fit into that criteria. But I mean, Teri's point is fine. We thrashed around that this morning in our committee too to make sure that these are very clear, very black and white. So if it does come forward, it's a very clear yes or no.

27:38 So if you're a new project, and we probably should call it out just this way, if you're a new project, and you're so nonsense that you can't wait for the process, then we would hear you, not necessarily grant you, but we would hear your applause. If you are an existing project that has been funded, that has a funding shortfall, and that probably ought to be worth it, funding shortfall, because of overages on construction or design or whatever it is, you can't have to do it.

28:08 Well, I think that if there is a question that we would, if it is something that is truly emergency,

28:43 And if Stu called Drea and myself, when we come in and we talk about the project, if it's a gray area, then we would call the joint meeting of the U and Rec Commission in order to make a determination if we're going to split the project or what's on the same notion. I think that's, I think that's, as chair, to me, that's pretty easy. I don't think anyone's sitting in this position. So that being said, I will have Stu prepared, and we will have Stu prepare that.

29:16 And bring it back to the next regular meetings with both of you and our committees to vote on. We can't vote on it today. This is a workshop. Although these will be confirmed to go back to Council. And they will be voting on a regular application? Yes. They will fill the regular application out? Yes. The other part of today's workshop that I'd like to get to, I believe that

29:45 We had pretty much consensus on the Youth Committee about our concerns about suspending the process. I can tell you from personal and real experience out in the real world that this is a huge PR problem. People come up to me every day and say, ah, so council suspended R&U and they're giving it to MLR. Well, we all know that that's not the case. If they're suspending it, it just causes that perception of the public.

30:14 I would like to see them put RU back on a process schedule so you already have the timelines written up. And if they need to be amended, amended. I'd like to hear how to recommend whether it is these groups making the decision or whether it is another group. I don't see the time between now and June or July when MLR comes into fruition or residence to create.

30:40 I have the public time to create a new process for our issues. So I would like to see the new process go on. I don't care where we're with the hearing or some of the materials. It has been established through open meeting process, through public input process, and that works in heaven and faith. I saw what we were just saying. We all have maybe students that are being certified or something. Well, I think it's a standard effort.

31:21 And if they want to set aside funds for the operation of MLR from that, then that just needs to be included in regular housekeeping where we set funds aside for maintenance and for the CIP and for the trails. That money would have to be taken out in the same way.

31:48 I'm not sure how council is going to come to an understanding of how much they're going to take from each fund or if they're going to only get one fund or eight of them.

31:57 I don't know whether they're a club that's four out of them.

32:00 I don't know whether they're a club that's four out of them.

32:01 I don't know whether they're a club that's four out of them.

32:02 I'm just going to be aware of that process.

32:05 I don't know if it's for a family.

32:08 Why do I come to say a club that's four out of them?

32:11 I said the teams are, if they are open, they are called meetings.

32:15 They're very wealthy.

32:16 I'll be sharing.

32:18 And, you know, I guess, from my standpoint too, there is one thing that you need to recall

32:29 and that's that you need to be aware of what our major publications are from these ones.

32:35 So, you know, I have a chance, you know, I think NLR will have enough of those things.

32:42 and I think it's got time

32:45 and it's not so much that I know

32:47 or not have

32:47 and they can probably go back to

32:50 what the process is now

32:52 I think

32:53 I think we're

32:55 proposing

32:57 assuming that a

33:01 group of people

33:01 have certainly

33:02 made it successful

33:04 Thank you very much.

33:31 Because, you know, transitions, at least I've been doing it after the federal government, I'm sure it's probably more of a state or whatever, you know, you just don't stop and start something new. I mean, there is this period of passing knowledge, it's continuity, and that's what we've done, it's continuity. And all this work that's been done, all this taxpayer dollars that's been spent, all this volunteer time, it should go for now. It should be, you know, honored, tweaked as you needed.

37:05 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

37:30 We put more money into the special events than probably we ever intended. But, you know, looking back, it helped the town, and we met the council, those are council presidents, too. And I know, especially, and others. So, you know, I think, looking back, it was pretty attractive. And those pie charts showed, shows in both cases, most of the stuff, they're just more established.

38:00 But to refresh your concerns, you should know that I don't deserve it.

38:31 We have the reason that I try to keep the commission from asking for a specific project because we're the ones giving out the money. So if we ask for a specific project, going forward, we look biased towards that project. I have a safe concern with MLR. Hopefully we'll figure that out. If they're the ones putting the money out there, then they're the ones setting the priorities and asking for the product. It's going to look biased. However, I'm over that. The current process...

39:01 Allows us as a recreation commission and as a manager, you can call out and ask for a specific project. There's nothing in the end of the process that precludes us from doing it. So I would like to see that process continue. And that's why I was sort of asking for consensus here so that you could relay it to council. I'd like that process to open back up. But we feel as a commission we want to call out for a specific project. Well, I have no problem. I have several of us. I can call out.

39:28 But the process, I think, works. I think the process works well. Recreation. Overall, overall, we've done the right thing. The application works. What has gotten funded works. The only difference has been perhaps Trail Sand Park would have been finished five years ago instead of now. And Parks Planning would have been done. And we've called that out specifically in advance. I have no problem with calling up the city. I'm asking for a specific in the next.

39:58 Under our priorities. I just would like to see it move that forward. After MLR is formed, we have them up and running. If they want to re-look, if they're tasked with that, to re-look at the process, to see if the process itself needs change that they find. So let's not show the data out of the bathwater right now, and let's keep the public trust rolling. Who do you have? A lot of public trust. I think so far the public is...

40:27 I'm very appreciative of the recognition and the recognition that you've gone through to make it fair in our lives. And I'd like to see even some people in town continue to have that value. We had an interesting discussion this morning about this whole issue of health. What is the role of our community to bring to our children? And we've already talked a little bit about this initiative yesterday as well, because we did it.

40:55 Thank you. Thank you.

41:24 We don't know what the values are. We don't know how to do it. So we need to really look at it. And that's what the APS study kind of says. You know, look at some of these things. We want us to be trying to plan. And so we're saying, I feel like that's our job to kind of start talking about this as we're a public over the top. You know, we don't feel this. I feel that we are the ones for the public. That's our job.

41:52 And ideally, you search some topics, things, the pros, the cons, here, where people have to say that they like it or not, and then you even move forward up to the council if they're not. I believe the one reason why sometimes we work with the public is because the council is going to come over. You can't live. You know, if it comes top down, the question is, well, why have the missions in the midst? You know, because I'm firmly here. Because I'm firmly here.

45:01 I'm operating only. That was a big commitment type of thing. I mean, that's been understood by everybody involved. Business plans and, I mean, talk about research. Talk about, you're putting back on it. And you have a whole brain injury report you can read. It talks about how those requirements, what they really work on. But we have a free site. You know what I mean? So there are some reasons.

45:28 I didn't mean to have this whole conversation, sorry. But I understand that many of you was put together and it was definitely $1.40.

45:52 Cultural Center. Okay, so I have not been involved in recent conversations since the last conversation that we brought forward was that he was looking for money to find the ability for this. That's changed, but that's great. I know that I was just said, isn't it? I'm going to try to pull us back in here. We're not bringing consensus on the suspension.

46:21 We will catch you down again. We're close. Yeah, I think we're close. You know, I have a problem with not, I think what Betsy has said is that the MLR is supposed to be coming forward in May, in the very beginning. So if you're looking at a fall, maybe our new application.

46:47 Thank you.

47:17 And what I'm saying is I think I would like to see it move forward regardless. If there's time for MLR to come up with how they're going to move forward, because when we're going to pull them, MLR, they will not get up that time to figure out, in a open fashion, how it's going to deal with the members of the MLR.

47:44 Thank you.

48:14 Thank you. Thank you.

48:42 Allocate. So what do we charge for doing here? And it's essentially coming up with the consensus. Share the right deal. We cannot act about anything here. But we can't come up with the consensus. For Stu's notes, so he can report that back. No.

48:58 So I think that we have consensus for the emergency, which possibly answers your concern, because if you have an emergency possibility, it doesn't suspend something indefinitely right now. If there's something that comes up that meets these

49:28 Sidewards, then it can possibly move forward. I think if I made a Jew, we're going to have enough information otherwise, and hopefully everybody is involved in that conversation, and then move forward for fall. My issue with that is, if something comes forward because it's time sensitive, and we don't have a place to fall fund, we can tell it to tell you.

49:52 Then we are directed to deal with it now out of context with any other applications that may come in. So by thinking we're going to solve everything through the emergency process is allowing certain vector items to get in there without the daylight.

50:09 and in all potential priorities coming forward. That means that I'm going to close this workshop and we're going to continue on with the recognition meeting.

50:37 I can say it. I can say it. I can say it's waiting until May or June, and I can respect their attention. Actually, I come back to it. What's on our agenda is the emergency, and I think we have a consensus on emergency, and I think that needs to be stated in the plan. And we need to have that consensus stated because that's what's here. And, you know, beyond that, I think that we do have...

51:02 State, if there's concerns to the council, as you might probably say, there's concerns to the council, because each of them can do, yeah, and as the end to MLR, that you have these concerns.

51:13 ...side boards, we have this emergency, or some things that are already in process.

51:20 But, you know, I think we were a step further to say, our suggestion is that we're running the process that we're going to do with the superintendent.

51:31 And then all of a sudden... So the application process, the workshop was the opportunity reward process. And you know we are not going to be all agreeing on the other side on the way to the CSEC conversation and move it back to back. Thank you.

51:57 Stu, is it really hot in here? I'm hot. Well, the girls may not be. I don't know.

53:07 I just ate a huge lunch.

53:36 How are you? Oh, how are you? Good to see you, good to see you. How's every little thing?

54:01 Good boy.

54:29 Thank you.

54:54 I apologize, I am going to run and then hopefully I can come back.

55:18 You know, and I'll have to, that's partially my fault, because I, you know, I always know I have this meeting, but I didn't put it on the calendar when a month ago they were going, oh, let's do this. And so, anyhow, I just, yeah. He's married to, very important person there. That's too funny. And I know when they are, too.

55:49 Okay, we will reopen this meeting or reconvene this meeting of the Rec Commission, Recreation Commission, and continue on with the presentation from MLTPA on the MLTS website enhancement performance report. Good afternoon, members of the commission, members of the public. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA.

56:19 And I'm going to give you a pretty brief overview of what the website enhancement contract originally funded by Measure R Spring 2012 award. There's a fair amount of material in your packet. A lot of that is germane specific to the performance report itself. Happy to answer any questions you might have. I'm just going to give you an overview of the work that got done and what's currently the situation of the website given all this work that just happened.

56:44 And John, I'm going to apologize and excuse myself because I don't want to do this in the middle of your presentation. I have another meeting that I have to go to and so I apologize. But like I said, I don't want to kind of interrupt your presentation. I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Yeah, I figured as much. Can everybody see everything okay? Is it okay out there? Okay.

57:16 This project was from the Spring 2012 Measure R Award. The contract was executed between ourselves and the town in January of 2013. The scoping to build these web pages was completed in August 2013. I want to take a second just to commend the efforts of Steve Spidell who came in, sit in the middle of this project and did excellent work to bring everything into focus along with Stuart so we can really get moving forward with this project.

57:44 And it was determined that 190 webpages would be built, and they were constructed between August and December of 2013. The webpages went live in January of 2014. The original award was for $25,000, of which $21,979 were spent. Dollars leveraged, $6,000 in cash and about $4,000 or $5,000 worth of donated time photography that was used to match with some funds from Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

58:14 So dollars back to measure all was $3,092.21. These numbers are confirmed with Steve because we like to confirm our numbers together. And the interpretive content of this original application was not pursued. So there were 57 new trail pages produced, 12 new destination pages, 9 new activity pages, and 112 new experience pages. And these lists, these are the final drafts, kind of our internal working list.

58:42 that document all the individual pages that were produced. You'll see on somebody's list, some of these pages were retained in inventory. This had to do with some clarifications from the Forest Service for pages that had to do primarily with wilderness experiences and trails, and they clarified things a little bit after these pages were produced. So these pages are in the inventory of the website, although they're not currently live on the site itself. And these are all trail pages. You can see a lot of stuff was done.

59:13 Destination pages. These are the new activity pages, all listed here. And then these are all the experiences. And all the experiences and experiences defined on the website is a combination of a facility, a piece of infrastructure with an activity creates an experience. And so this is a nice long list of all the pages that got done. If you have any questions, I can answer them now. I was going to take a look at some of the web pages themselves. If any specific pages you guys would like to look at, I can look at those. I've got some queued up.

59:42 Can I give you a preview of what's happened, what went on? So I'll just go ahead. Let's start. Okay, so this is a good example of an activity that prior to this contract, there was an activity known as paddleboarding that exists, people do around here. And through this contract, this page was developed, photography was completed for the landing page itself, and then three individual experiences were produced through paddleboarding. So we've got a stand-up paddleboarding in Convict Lake, stand-up paddleboarding in Horsley Lake, stand-up paddleboarding in Horsley Lake.

1:00:32 And then these experiences are listed down here. Well, each one of these individual pages flows very nicely into the mantle of the tourism promotion and marketing effort. It's a great way to bring people to a really beautiful pathway to the topic lakes. This is an example of a snowfall, which is a vital winter activity for visitors and folks. And as you can see, these photographs, this is an MLTPA photograph.

1:01:00 who were being used as placeholder images because we didn't have snow on the ground to actually get this stuff shot. With this last storm, we're working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to get these photographs made for these specific experiences. It's been a challenge, as you all know, with the snowfall. But we've got three experiences to do with placeholder images, and at least people can say, well, I want to go do some snow play in the scenic loop, and there's a snow play in good directions, all the things that you can build, all the usual content that goes with these pages.

1:01:30 Another one that's interesting is Fall Color Viewing. This is now a complete activity page, again, including things for the shoulder seasons and all these kinds of things you can do. Again, we have the activity with three individual experiences of joy. Snowmobiling. This last weekend, we went out again with the help of Steve and some other volunteers and shot what we could on the Orange Diamond Snowmobiling System.

1:02:02 And there's a fair amount of language that we hear of the Forest Service. We emphasize how it's called out of the property of the Forest Service, that specific language that they wanted to work for the description of the trails, what the name of the system is, how it's described in terms of its relationship between sticker farms and all those other kinds of things that are to the jurisdictional background that needs to be accounted for.

1:02:29 Instructions to go to the Welcome Center for Mammoth. I want to give you an example of what it looks like. One of the changes that was made going through this process in terms of how basic fundamental protocols for the website were updated and changed to participate and to comply with the needs of the Forest Service. So the Forest Service has a specific issue of how experiences were credited in the past.

1:02:55 You see snowmobiling, shade of the rest of the whole mountain, and you click on a link, you go to whoever was the source of that experience. The forester has felt that this is perhaps prejudicing one group over another, one business over another, so the change was made, we worked together with the town to accommodate that change. So now the language reads for any activity. So let's go to photography. So we go to photography.

1:03:25 And here are three photography experiences that have online, and photography have been read at Vista. Now the capture means, do you have photography experiences you'd like to share? So if you have a photography experience you'd like to share, you click on this, this takes you into the site, which describes what an experience is, how you can contribute, and all the folks who contribute to the site are now listed on this contributing page. There are no links from this page out to the individual sites that have contributed. This is just something for us, just a second.

1:03:54 They don't want it to be doing that kind of stuff. I would anticipate over time this may evolve, but this is occurring comfortably. Excuse me, John. Does that mean – because I did go into the site and did look for experiences, as I think you've mentioned, that would occur in the past. So because of Forest Service concerns, so individual comments are not mentioned or –

1:04:21 Because I noticed that there was a site where you could make comments. Oh, no. The review function is still in place. That hasn't changed. So if you go to a trail, you have an experience, you want to tell everybody it's a great experience or it's a terrible, whatever you want to do, that capacity is still in place. This was specific to if...

1:04:40 You have a favorite hiking experience and you come through the process, spend an hour or so with the website folks. It all gets developed. In the past, we would link directly to your website or wherever place you want to link to. But now there is no link. You get a contributor attribution, but there's no direct link out to any of the folks who help contribute and make the experiences happen. Thank you for explaining that. Sure. That's what's changed.

1:05:05 There's been also some clarification about experiences in wilderness areas. And this one is a good example. This is a equestrian trail riding experience up the Valentine Lakes. And the current protocol, which we're currently updating into the website handbook, will mean that if an experience starts outside of a wilderness area but goes into a wilderness area, on a case-by-case basis, these are considered acceptable.

1:05:32 It means that there's limits on the photography. There's only three pictures assigned for each one of those kinds of experiences. The Forest Service did say that if an experience happens only in a wilderness area, it's a trail that only exists in wilderness, that's still something that they don't feel comfortable putting up on the site. So a lot of this information going through a process like this with 190 new pages, it's a very useful exercise to focus the needs and concerns of the agencies, get all this stuff documented, put in the protocols so for future content development efforts,

1:06:01 You know, the playing field and the rules are very clear, which would make it easier for the town to develop new content as things go forward. Any other thoughts or questions on these pages? I really like the activity checklist. I thought that was really thoughtful and very informative. Overall, I thought the photographs that were used were great. Looks like you've made some upgrades since the last time I looked at it.

1:06:30 One question I did have, though, is I think it was a destination and it talked about Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, which I thought was terrific because there are a lot of hiking trails and different recreational activities from that particular location down to Reds Meadow and things like that. But then there was something listed on the village and I wondered, and I know it mentioned transportation hub and some other things, but I was just wondering out loud to myself,

1:06:59 If there might be a better location to focus on as opposed to a commercial interest like the village. Yeah, I think the village is identified in the trail system master plan as one of the designated nodes as part of the trail system because there's so much transportation, public transit sort of intersects there. I would defer to staff a little bit, but I think it's a point of departure to take your bike up to the...

1:07:25 to get on the mountains, trolley system, get up to the mountain. I think one of the things we have to do is we probably have to build a destination page for what's called the Adventure Center at Mammoth Mountain Ski Area because that's now an identified node where all the buses it leaves under Red's Meadow depart from and that's one of the things in the content suggestion list we'll be working with Steve to bring that forward to the MLTSCC in terms of new destinations and new page content that we need. That's probably one that we need to develop. Right now if you'll notice all of the

1:07:53 Experiences and Trails that leave out of Reds Meadows. Reds Meadows, the directions, advise you to go to the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Main Lodge. Technically, you should probably be going to this Adventure Center, but that's a Park Service, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Forest Service node, and there's going to need to be some conversations with those agencies to get that kind of stuff figured out. Great. Another question. I know that somebody knows the answer to this, but we haven't received that back. Like the number of hits that have

1:08:25 been obtained on the site, and is it calculated annually, so you can kind of judge from year to year? Like any enhancements that are made, you know, tend to generate more interest. And I know for a period of time, this website was not really linked to MLT, and I know that that has subsequently happened. Yes, and I think what we've been doing with our partner meetings on the website is on pretty much a seasonal basis,

1:08:53 doing a website traffic analysis on a seasonal basis that we've been sharing internally and we've shared it with the MLTSCC, I think. And going forward, that traffic data is being tracked. It's knowable. It's complex. There's a lot of variables to it. It needs a certain amount of sophistication to really understand what kind of information you're getting out of it. Mammoth Lake Tourism was pretty confident in promoting the site over the summer because we had sufficient content.

1:09:21 But they weren't sure going into the fall season or even the winter season. We didn't have, you know, this content that was produced wasn't live in a timely fashion that they didn't feel comfortable pushing it because there wasn't anything there really to push. But, you know, slowly but surely we're getting there such that I'm confident that this summer season, MLT feels they have good representation of summer activities that they'll be able to use it as, you know, in full blossom.

1:09:47 to really push it, promote it. We're doing things under our contract, linking opportunities, linking possibilities, to really integrate the site into the community in all aspects of the community and visitation and tourism. Yes, and just to be, I know we've had this ongoing confusion, that is, to Steve's point, that is a separate, that's a website management contract, and this is specific just to build these 190 web pages. Looks great, thank you. Thank you. It's great to see this come to fruition, and my understanding is that the town holds the copyright on the images.

1:10:21 On the pages? Yes, all of these photographs are, the copyright is to the town. There's some MLTPA pictures in here just as placeholders because there aren't any town images yet. We're working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on a digital asset management photo library program, which is a little bit off of this topic, but that's all being managed and it's moving forward. Wouldn't MLTPA want to donate any of those photos? I think it would be good.

1:10:49 I mean, we could. I think from a digital asset management perspective, it's going to be cleaner if everything in the library is the towns or Mammoth Lakes Tourisms. And certainly, you know, we could, I mean, they're there for now, and it's, you know, we don't have any problem donating them to serve their purpose. Hopefully, there'll be better images taken. Some of our images are just enough to kind of tell the story of what's happening there, but I'm sure we can take better pictures, or somebody can. The automobile picture that's there is the placeholder's outdated equipment.

1:11:20 Yeah. And all the sleds we used this weekend were current, top of the line. Sort of. Well, we... So those images are shot. They're now being processed through the library. The next week or so we'll have all those up. But those that you shot this weekend would be in the towns. Yes. Oh, yeah. Right. So they would be available for you. Oh, yeah. So I'm just going to go back and finish it with the PowerPoint. And...

1:11:49 So as I mentioned, through this process, important protocols for the management of the trail system website are being drafted and updated. Experience pages, we talked about those, wilderness protocols are being updated. The photo library, I think what we're finding is all of the infrastructure for the trail system gets documented, all the trails and destinations, those things over time aren't going to change, but the value of photography to freshen up those destinations, what they look like, is really important.

1:12:17 And again, we're working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to really set up a very robust digital asset management program. They're working, again, I think through the TBID to set up something so that every business or any person in town could get access to first class photography and video to use for the promotion of businesses and things like that. These things will probably conflate. There'll need to be some conversations with the town about how those photos move over and all that kind of stuff. But that's moving forward. And it's important to keep in mind the coordination of infrastructure.

1:12:47 The winter grooming snowmobile system, there's existing infrastructure out that needs to be coordinated in with the site and making these kinds of things happen and coordinating that with the conditions on the ground. We went out, looked at a lot of trails that due to blowdown or Forest Service deferred maintenance, we talked about this, the MLTSCC, we've allowed for that in the descriptions of the trails where, you know, no maintenance has been done in a while, you're not going to have a super maybe friendly experience here, but it's out there. So that's an important part of this.

1:13:14 And the content development moving forward is very important. I know the MLTSCC is considering allocations for funding is moving forward. There's no allocation yet for content development, but it's the mother's milk of these things, and hopefully that will come forward in the coming months. And MLTPA and MLT is going to work with the other partners of the website program. We've got a whole list of recommendations for content development in the short and near term that can be dealt with in the coming seasons that should probably be considered by the MLTSCC going forward.

1:13:44 Okay. So, that's it. Any questions? I'll be happy to answer them. Otherwise, thank you very much. Good job, John. Thank you. Thank you. My comment is when we got into the original application to develop the website years ago, I wasn't thinking about just how much it was going to take to manage it afterwards, and good or bad. I think it's a great website. Now, after looking at it and viewing it,

1:14:14 The importance of those pictures being updated almost annually to keep people coming back to the site, the importance of adding new experiences every year has been drilled into me. I think that these are important things that MLTSCC and in the future, whoever is handling the measure of our dollars needs to remember that it's only as fresh as what we've done lately. And if you don't keep it fresh, people stop going.

1:14:43 That's the nature of the web. And when the pictures get too old, you can donate them to us over at the Historical Society, and we can use them in all different contexts. Can't wait. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions for John? I'll follow up with you on some other questions later. Nothing that needs to be asked now. Thanks, Steve. Be sure to get a cookie. For being so good, you can have a cookie.

1:15:35 And then Terry already has it. Oh, okay. Thank you. Steve, this is the report on the MLTSCC and current statuses and issues. Thank you for the opportunity, Recreation Commission, members of the public. My name is Steve Spidell. I'm the coordinator for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. And on a monthly basis, the committee reports back to

1:16:23 the Rec Commission on our activities, and occasionally we ask for direct action. Today we will not be requesting any direct action, but did want to give you a recap of our last meeting, actually our last couple of meetings. This last meeting we had a great presentation from Mono County about some of their trails planning efforts, so it was very helpful for us to communicate with them and get an idea of the types of projects they were working on,

1:16:53 the areas in which they are working and hopefully over time we can have closer working relationships and when Mono County projects come from outside the area into the sphere of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System we'll be able to coordinate and put together a robust package in those regards. Also at our meeting the seven interpretive panels that the committee had approved funding for earlier

1:17:23 have been delivered to the town. They are ready to be installed. The holdup at this point is as required by the approval of the funding. The QR code needs to be developed for each one of the signs and we are in the process of working with a contractor to provide that. And so our anticipation is that once the snow melts, we'll be able to install the framework.

1:17:52 Then install the panels on the framework. Once that's done, the smartphone can click on the QR code, and it'll take you to a landing site that's integrated with the website, and you'll be able to get additional experiences. Some of those will be audio, some will be visual, some will be a combination of the both. So it's going to be a pretty exciting program. Also, I'm led to believe from the Public Works Department that we are under budget for the project, so that's encouraging as well.

1:18:23 The main part of our last couple of meetings have been to identify projects of priority for funding for the next fiscal year. And at this last meeting we started to look at those budgeting dollar amounts and got partway through a rather long list. So we have at least one other meeting.

1:18:49 that we will be looking at those projects, those priorities for moving forward, the appropriate funding levels to bring to those projects, and once that list is created, we'll bring it to the Recreation Commission under a recommendation, ask for approval from the Rec Commission, and then that will go on to Council for final approval for the next fiscal year's $300,000 expenditure by the committee.

1:19:21 One of the things, too, that we ended up working on was the fact that the snows have come late this year. We had a contract with Friends of the Inyo to carry on winter grooming for the cross-country ski trails out at the Shady Rest Campground. And part of that approval was a time period that it would happen before March 15th. So the wisdom of the committee...

1:19:48 Decided to remove that limiting language of March 15th and to just continue on a time and materials basis. And again, we're way under budget because of the snow, unfortunately. But hopefully we'll have additional snowfalls and be able to consume some of that and provide those experiences for the users. Steve, can I comment on that one if I could? Please. I would like to commend Friends of the Inyo. They have actually groomed out there three or four times this year.

1:20:16 When there really was not enough snow, and they've done a great job of getting the tracks set. They have gone above and beyond, you know, moving little rocks off the trail and everything else so they could groom with less than four inches of snow so that we would have an experience out there. So for a good deal of the winter, even with no snow, there has been at least a modicum of cross-country experience at a shady rest. I just wanted to insert that for your...

1:20:41 Also along that same vein we actually had a public comment period for our meeting and there were a number of positive responses to that winter grooming program so everybody was very encouraged with that. One of the things that we look for in our future agenda items will be a report from MLR committee. We're hoping that in May possibly they'll be able to come and address the trails committee.

1:21:14 with the progress that they're making. So at this point what I'd like to do is enter into a brief rundown on our progress report. This was presented to the committee yesterday. Some feedback was taken and corrections made. Our ultimate goal is to present this to the town council again to show them and the public what we are doing and how we are

1:21:44 Tracking projects, how we are spending the $300,000 allotment per year for trails programs. So, Steve, this serves to serve as our required Measure R report back for the monies being spent, correct? I'll defer to Stu on that, actually. I don't think. It could be. Yeah. Say it is. Okay. I thought I just said that. Okay. So, this is our

1:22:20 Pseudo measure our report. This slide is representational of our final vision and mission statements. So we have gone through that process and established them. We also have been directed by council to have initially four, I'm sorry, seven various and distinct scopes of work. One and two are

1:22:51 Illustrated here the creation of our tracking system. We have tracking numbers for all our projects, names and descriptions, bucket lists that help us understand prioritization. We have funding, accounting, lead organization, current status, next steps, actions. We also include CIP lists from the town projects and U.S. Forest Service projects of scheduled proposed actions so that we can track those efforts as well.

1:23:21 Items 3 and 4 off of that original scope. We have established our tracking framework for our tracking numbers. We have strategies for fundings that were developed in October. Also our priorities for funding established in October. And we have project criteria and consistently see checklists so that we have those abilities to look at projects as they come forward, run them through these systems to make sure that

1:23:49 Indeed it is appropriate to fund those projects. Five and six has to do with progress reports and determining processes, I'm sorry, has to do with staff needs and engaging outside entities as well as documenting and the incorporation of a previously funded Measure R from 2011-2012.

1:24:19 LTSC has established a budget and a method for tracking staff time and outside entities to assist the committee in their work. I'll be talking about that additional handout that I made which details that accounting and that will follow this PowerPoint presentation. Next last item on our initial scope of work was to identify user groups that need to be included and determine the appropriate size of the committee.

1:24:51 So our meetings are open to all to attend, and we have decided that five is the appropriate number for committee members. And just recently, Peter Bernasconi from the Town of Mammoth Lakes has filled in for Stu Brown as the Town of Mammoth Lakes representative. Our accomplishments include a couple of MOUs with the U.S. Forest Service.

1:25:22 Probably the most important is the maintenance and operation of the website. And again, there's 300 viewable pages on that website. As John pointed out, we've added additional content. So we have trails, we have maps and photos, activities, both winter and summer. We have experiences and destinations on this very vibrant website. Also, one of our MOUs has to do with the trail system itself.

1:25:48 So we have this agreement with the Forest Service then to implement trail system improvements, wayfinding, interpretation, and public involvement. And I might say that to date these MOUs have been functioning well and we have a good working relationship. Another accomplishment that we have is that we've set up a couple of challenge cost share agreements for implementation of the trail system up in the lakes basin area with the Sarbanes project.

1:26:19 and also with the Sherwin's area. Just to give you an idea of how we're leveraging those funding to do the work in the Sherwin's area, it was about a $215,000 project, and of that, $152,000 will come from Measure R and the committee over a three-year period. Up in the Lakes Basin, the Sarbanes grant.

1:26:45 Park portion is a total $115,000 and change and the town through a grant application was able to come in with $89,500 and change for that project. So we can see how with cooperation, with funding opportunities taking advantage, we can start to get some real work done and it's a pleasure to be part of that.

1:27:14 Another accomplishment that we have is again the management of the website which is as we mentioned earlier a separate contract and in those management meetings we actually go through and look at Google Analytics and others to see how things are trending we can see how much time people actually spend on the website in total how many pages on average they view

1:27:38 and then how many minutes or seconds they spend on the pages. So we're very interested to see now with this new edition, with this new content, switching over to the new seasons to see what those analytic numbers will be and we'll be meeting on April 4th, Friday actually, April 4th to go through that. Steve, is that something that at a future commission meeting you can just give us a copy of that information without having...

1:28:08 to go through all kinds of gyrations. I'd be happy to. Okay, that would be great. Thank you. A couple of projects that we have been successful in continuing also has been the Summer of Stewardship Trail Days. Last year we had, what, a total of six days where we got people in the community. We had tourists come as well and participate in maintaining and

1:28:41 Picking up trash and working on the trails. Friends of the Inyo has done a great job working with the Forest Service to provide the tools necessary. MLTPA has done a great job in advertising, getting people out there, getting them bagels in the morning and a nice lunch and then usually their T-shirts and things like that to keep people stimulated. So it's been a lot of fun working on those projects.

1:29:05 A recent accomplishment for us again is switching over for the winter grooming out at Shady Rest Campground Loop. As you may recall, this work used to be done by Mammoth Nordic, another non-profit, but unfortunately they couldn't continue. And pretty much at the last minute we were able to cobble together a program and a situation so that if the snow had cooperated, our visitors would have had a seamless encounter out there. So I want to thank Friends of the Inyo again for that and their efforts.

1:29:35 Another accomplishment, again, are the panels that are out in front of you. These seven interpretive panels will be going on them up. Also, we ran into a situation this winter, over the, I'm sorry, this summer, where it was necessary to come up with some temporary signages up in the Panorama Dome area, as well as uptown, downtown, and the earthquake fault. So this photograph is representational of that effort, and one of our trail days,

1:30:04 People painstakingly painted the individual letters on those signs and we were able to use Friends of the Inyo Labor Force and get them installed and you'll notice too that our logo for the trail system are on those temporary signs. The last slide I have here is again where we've proposed to go in the future and continuation of our project. So we continue to desire to fund the Sharps project with the Forest Service, Lakes Basin,

1:30:35 Projects with the Forest Service, Summer Stewardship Trails Days with MLTPA, Nonprofit, and Friends of the Inyo Nonprofit, Lake Spirit Stewards Program with Friends of the Inyo, Winter Grooming, Shady Rest Campground, Friends of the Inyo, Funding of the Website, Keep It Going, Provide Handouts, Maps, and Guides, and then as our trail system increases, we need to update our Type 2 and 4.6 maps showing those improvements. We look to do that in the future.

1:31:02 And other projects that come forward on the master project and tracking list as determined by the committee. So thank you for your interest. And I'm here to answer any questions and be happy to provide you with an update on our management of the website. Questions? I think the committee is doing an excellent job. And Sean and Bill and the rest of the committee should be commended on all your efforts. It's very educational.

1:31:32 to see this in a comprehensive kind of fashion to see what you've tackled and what you have planned for the future. It's really very helpful. Very thorough. Thank you. So the last part is just one of the pieces that came out of our meeting yesterday was a need to make sure that we are fully transparent and up front with all our project costs having to do with the

1:32:04 Project costs themselves as well as administrative costs. So these three pages here are an attempt to show the various areas of the consultant billing. There are nine different categories that those billings come in from the master tracker list of meetings, preparation for the committee meetings, general research, preparation and presentation at the rec commission meeting, and then finally number nine is the actual administration of contracts.

1:32:33 and Invoice Review. So one of the things we've found is that really when doing this work there are certain amount of time hours that are spent on a project specific basis. For instance these interpretive panels right here and there are other hours that are spent just in general administration of preparing those things, filing them, making photocopies, things of that nature. So this

1:33:02 attempt here is to show then for the consultant time period from February of 2013 to March 2014 total hours, total expenses and the interesting thing is when you look at the bottom line the project specific versus general administration is just about a 50-50 split. There were extra services asked by the consultant

1:33:30 In regards to the website project management which entailed both website enhancement work as well as the management contract of the website. So all those hours were project specific in nature and were not general administration. So that is on the second page as well as the consultant expenses for cell phone, internet and remote. The final page is the town staff

1:33:58 Support that we've had over this long period of time from January 11, 2012 to March 3, 2014. Over that entire period there's been approximately 273 hours of staff time developed right to this project of the Trail System Coordinating Committee. That relates to about $23,000 worth of expense. So that's an average of over a 26-month period of only $895 per month.

1:34:27 of staff time billed to this project. So I think, from my perspective, the town is getting one heck of a bargain. It's great to have these numbers. Thank you so much. You're welcome. Any other questions, Christine? Well, one thing, though, it kind of reminded me when you talked about the Shady Arrest Project that I don't, John Wentworth, I don't think I saw that in the website. It talked about cross-country skiing,

1:35:03 At two other areas, but not Shady Rest. Sure. At the direction of the MLTSCC and with some additional funds, we are developing three experiences specific to the Shady Rest website. We shot photographs for that Sunday morning before the snowmobiling, putting together the narratives on that they should be up in life in a week or two. Excellent. Thank you. The cross-country skiers were willing to get up earlier than the snowmobilers. Any other questions, Tristee?

1:35:33 Well done, sir. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, next is the 2014 Measure R Opportunity Reward Process, which we just hashed out down below. So the question is, do we want to send something specific? Are you comfortable with the notes taken by Stu in our workshop with Measure U and sending those together? Stu, do you want to give us a different direction on that? Yeah, the option is to

1:36:11 Certainly we've got these notes summarised. We do want to obviously get it in front of Council. We can put it in front of Council April 2nd. It depends if you want it to come back to Commission prior to that time. If so, we can discuss it at the April meeting and then take it to Council two weeks later. So it's really the Commission's comfort in regards to the recommendation that would go forward.

1:36:39 You know, I don't know if there's any rush right now. We can certainly document it all, get it back to you. We can get a little bit more of a kind of a defined criteria. I know we, during the discussion, added a few conclusions to what the Measure U Application Committee talked about. And that was kind of a new project has its own little criteria too. So a new project that is compelling and is time sensitive can also come forward.

1:37:05 And then all we added was that the pre-screen or pre-filter was that the joint chairs of each of those advisory bodies would kind of pre-filter those applications and then determine which kind of route they would best go and then it would come into the regularly scheduled meetings of both those bodies and then they'd go through that public process like they're doing. And I guess what we're really saying here is really any project at any time can come forward. And I think that was the distinction we made in the committee.

1:37:32 This morning with Measure U that it's not one set timeline, it's just any project at any time that fits these criteria is able to kind of bring it forward for consideration at any time through this year. I mean, there's no time frame. I guess that's what we're saying. Typically, we have the spring period. Measure U doesn't have a period. So, I mean, this is kind of an open process. And as you can see in the notes that I've included, I think that was already included in if somebody...

1:38:00 If you can correct me, but I think there was in Measure R already an opportunity award process set up, which was kind of on... Well, that was the spring hand... Well, no, it was actually... Yeah, because I did go through that and I wanted to clarify that, Chair, that in that tool, which was adopted in 2009, there will be a spring review and award process each year in recognition of an anticipated program opportunities, there will be an opportunity fund process.

1:38:30 And then I think there was also something else. So I think there was, you had some latitude for the spring, the opportunity. The only distinction was that it just had to follow the process. It still had to be a public hearing. It still had to be reviewed by the committee, so forth, and then recommended to councils. Which is what I think we're still holding to, unless I must interpret what we talked about a few minutes ago, that we would like to see that opportunity award continue. Yeah.

1:39:01 And we have not actually sent a consent. We've not phrased that yet, have we? Because that was, you know, I think what came out of the workshop is fine. But I think that if we could, as a commission, say something via consensus that says that we would not like to see it suspended the way it has been. Is that a motion? Yes. Okay. I'll second that. Whatever it is. I have first and second. And if I understand the motion, it is...

1:39:33 That we would like to see a opportunity award process as defined in the workshop and that we are uncomfortable with the suspension of the overall process. Is that your motion to send to council? Uncomfortable. I'm not sure if that's strong enough. I think that I would actually like to say something a little bit stronger. Okay. We're disappointed. Give me a strong word. Disappointed. Disappointed that it's been suspended. We would like to see the process continue until MLR has...

1:40:05 Established a more, has really taken it up. I don't think you need to define it beyond you'd like to see it continue. I don't know. I don't have a problem with saying something that until a better system has been established, and that might encompass MLR or what would, I don't know. Can I get some opinion from the commissioners? Well, I agree with the first part of your motion. I think we definitely need to have this, you know, this emergency funding, you know.

1:40:35 With the, you know, contingencies in place, you know, emergency, you know, once in a lifetime, you know, funding crisis or whatever we decided to call that. You know, I'm still pretty comfortable with the, you know, with the current suspension of the process and I realize I'm probably in the minority simply because I think that, you know, we'll have the up or down vote on MLR, you know, by... So, you're on the committee. What I'm looking for you...

1:41:00 to at this point in time is tell me why you're comfortable with the current suspension and what you think that gains us. What is the purpose of the suspension if not to just change the way the funds are awarded through the MLR process? That's what I'm not understanding. What I'm hearing is that there was no reason to suspend it, but you're very comfortable with the current suspension

1:41:21 I don't see the reasoning behind the suspension in terms of MLR, so that's what I'm looking for you to answer. Well, I think one of the reasons for the suspension is to try to get a grasp on, you know, these ongoing maintenance obligations that we have, you know, for these funds. And I'm going to disagree with you there. I think we have a great grasp on that. We bill on what the application says the maintenance was going to be, and after the first year of operation, we bill on what actual maintenance expenses are. So I think in terms of maintaining the...

1:41:51 Current things that we have funded, we have a good grasp and handle on that. In fact, have held out more for maintenance each year than what the actual expenses have been. Would that not be true, Stu? Yeah, I mean, we're at about $130,000, I think, from, you know, existing obligations, and we've identified the only obligation for maintenance, I think, at this time, who I know, is Whitmore Trails in Park. Right, but what we have held out for maintenance has been more than what we've actually spent on maintenance.

1:42:19 That's great. Yes, in each year. So I don't see the disconnect with the maintenance there. I think that has worked fine as we laid it out. Okay. And I think it's more of a concern just over the long term of the funds. The other reason is that my understanding from the two council members who sit on the MLR, now Formation Committee, is that

1:42:41 The council is not precluding bringing forth something. One of my questions was, what happens when we hopefully get the California State Parks grant? Will we lose that grant because this process is suspended? Their answer was no. That's why I'm comfortable with it for right now because I think that we'll know by the end of the spring. I certainly am respectful of the concerns that the U committee brought forward in terms of

1:43:10 You know, the foundation side and other things. But see, you've illustrated my concern. What you just told me was that council is going to now take things out of context and out of the process and make unilateral decisions about where the money is going outside of the process that was set up by the people. I'm uncomfortable with that. That's why I'm uncomfortable with the suspension of the process. Okay. If the process is in place and the match for that grant comes forward, either as an emergency or otherwise, we've already established a route for it.

1:43:40 to go through and get daylighted and get approved. What you just described to me is my worst fear come to reality that the RNU are going to become part of the general fund to manage and maintain a system outside of the scope of what the electorate... Sorry, I'm on my soapbox. No, it's okay. And you know I agree with you on that. Yes. No, no, no. And my understanding was that, you know, it would still go through, you know, through the process.

1:44:07 But if it was going to go through the process, why suspend the process? There's my level of discomfort. If they planned on it going through the process and being daylighted with any other potential application, there's no reason to suspend the process. And maybe in my speaking to counsel, I just haven't made myself clear into misunderstanding there.

1:44:24 So I'm just, you know, to me, I don't mean you'd be picking on me. Oh, no, no, it's okay. And I think, you know, from my perspective, you know, and I can only speak as a commissioner and, you know, not to the U committee, but, you know, since we agreed that we would, you know, that we would not conduct, you know, the spring oops-ertunity, and, you know, from my standpoint as a commissioner that, you know, because, okay, so we won't hold a spring award unless we have, you know, some emergency situation, but that by May or June we'll know

1:44:52 You know, about MLR, and then I would expect, you know, things will either, either change or, you know, or not. Battle lines will be drawn. Yeah, so, but I, but I, you know, I definitely heard what the U Committee was saying in terms of, you know, they have, you know, some other, you know, they have this, you know, the foundation site coming forward and that they made their, you know, their fall award based on that. So, you know, I understand the concerns. Yeah, and I had no problem with suspending the spring, you know, recall that that was. Yes.

1:45:19 We all seemed pretty enthusiastic about it at the time, so. Yeah, I had no concept that suspending the opportunity was going to suspend the whole process. Is that, did Council, did they accidentally hear us wrong, or? I don't know what happened there. And, you know, in some ways I actually would even like to amend my, and I'm not doing that yet, I'm just talking, we're discussing this. We're discussing this. I would like to provide some kind of out to Council. I mean, if we could perhaps include in the motion that it get reinstated.

1:45:48 Because the public perception, that's my biggest concern, is that town council is, or the perception out there is that town council just grabbed UNR, and if anything, I think the best thing that they can do is put it back into the process that we had in place. The best thing they can do is show that that process is still in place until MLR or

1:46:14 Another process that's better defined. Right now they just took it away without a better solution. It would behoove them to continue the process and allow that process, even if they're going to change who hears the applications, whether that is MLR or a U Committee or a Rec Commission, is irrelevant to me. The fact is a process has been established and I'd like to see them until they have the time. And I know it took us three or four months to establish the process for each one of those. It was not a simple task.

1:46:44 MLR is not going to get put together in May and instantly have them in process unless it is to use the money in ways that I would disagree with. So I would like to keep it as strong as you're willing to. And perhaps, you know, talking about disappointed is not the right way to say it, and I'm looking for some wordsmithing advice from my fellow commissioners here.

1:47:05 on how to create a safe face here for the Town Council, but at the same time highlighting the public perception problem that we now face. So perhaps we can send an option to Town Council that just allows them to reinstate the process as it was until a better system comes up to play, or am I taking it too far? Do we know the actual verbiage of whatever it was that Council voted on? I have just been told they suspended the process. Did they actually do that?

1:47:36 They did. It was part of the MLR. Thanks, Sandy. It's in the MLR update staff report here. So it's not in the discussion item number five packet? It should be discussion item number eight, and it's on page two. I'll just read it for you here. It just says, direct the town manager to take the following actions.

1:48:08 In assisting the MLI Transition Formation Committee, and this was one, suspend the measure R&U award process, complete the financial reconciliation, define current maintenance obligations without limiting the completion of all current funding awards. Then it goes on to speak about other formation issues, so that was the reference. Yeah, so I would want to work this in the strongest reference possible. Okay. If I was a member of the public out there right now, I would think the council just decided to take R&U and do it.

1:48:39 So could you work Smith over there? Yeah. Do you have any idea of what his motion is? I'm not sure I do. I've got the first part of the motion. It's really just getting the second part. Yeah. And I think what I'm looking to do is actually even leave the judgment out of that, say something along the lines of we would like to see

1:49:14 Measure R and U award process reinstated. Strongly would like to see R and U process reinstated. I don't know that we need to give them an out. I mean, if they approve the recommendation, then that's their change of heart. I mean, I'm hearing two concerns. I mean, I'm hearing the concern that, you know, the immediate suspension, particularly as it pertains to, you know, Measure U,

1:49:43 And then I'm also hearing, you know, I think, and I think the concern lies with, you know, with the indefinite suspension because if MLR does not come to fruition, which I don't think any of us expect to happen, but if that does happen, you know, then, you know, R&U are still suspended and what happens then? Well, my concern is that all the work that has been done on figuring out R&U is being thrown in the can in favor of allowing a new

1:50:10 Group of people who were not part of that process in the first place come up with a new way to allocate those funds. Seemingly without a process or priority system in place, it's a brand new organization. Even if they are given the purview of R and U, I would like to see the process stay in place until there is such time as to replace the process with something different. That's where I'm coming from. I'm not trying to put brakes on MLR. I'm not trying to... Oh, no, I hear what you're saying.

1:50:40 I mean, it's possible, too. I don't know that the town attorney has totally weighed in on all of the legalities of R. and U. So it's possible that there might still be some murky areas with respect to the oversight of Measure R. and U. So maybe… By MLR? Right. And maybe that, you know, will take a while to resolve, and then maybe that does go into effect, or maybe it doesn't. But, you know, that's discussed here in Measure, or the I.I.

1:51:08 portion. Okay. Perhaps as far as the motion goes, what I'd like you to do is number eight is update Town Council action regarding Measure R, which is really where this discussion belongs. So how about just amending your current on the opportunity award process to put forward the award in the sideboards, leave it at that, and then we'll do a new motion for

1:51:39 The disappointment and reinstating with number eight, which is where it belongs. We can't take that action in number five anyway. I should have been looking at this closer. Oh, sorry, we can't even do a motion? We can do it later. But we can do it at number eight. We got it. Okay. So your motion at this point would be to do the opportunity award process with the sideboards and such that we agreed on in the workshop. Not quite that wording, but yes. Okay, well.

1:52:06 Word it for me. Okay, well, are we moving on from policy matter number five? No. It's two separate issues. Right. Okay. If we're going to take action on number five, I would need someone to give me a motion to take action with. Okay, I think the way that I'm understanding this is that I want to amend my motion, thank you very much, that calls for reinstating of the measure R and U award process.

1:52:36 Is that good enough? You want to say that you want to cry. I will make a motion. I withdraw my motion so that you can make your motion. This is a first. I've never made a motion as chair. I've stayed away from that. But it's allowed. I will make a motion that we request an opportunity award process for Measure R, as that's the only purview we have at this point, to establish the opportunity award under the sideboard's

1:53:06 And rules that were put forth in the workshop of the UNR committee. That's my motion. Make me sound better, of course. That's my motion. The way I heard that, I will second that. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion on this new motion? Could you rephrase it? Yeah, let's re-back one more time at least. So the opportunity to be awarded process for Measure R that was defined in the workshop. Right. Yes.

1:53:38 Yes. This will create the Opportunity Award. So there will be a process. Yep. With the sideboards. But it also reinstates the... No, no. It does not. I see. That's coming in number 8. You got it. Thank you very much. That was split. And if I would have known my own agenda better, I would have realized that up front. So that is my bad to waste that much time, although we would have wasted it later. Anyway.

1:54:10 Then it's not wasted. But are we, are we sure that item 8 will cover that topic? Yes. I don't think Sean's going to forget. So I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Then I will call for the item. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? 4-0. The next item on the agenda is item number 6, the HVS

1:54:44 Consulting Entertainment and Cultural Event Facilities Report. And we have Mr. Taylor with us to cover any questions that you may have on the report. You know, Bill, I know that Terry really wants to be here for this. I must admit when I heard her comments at the workshop. Yes. And then she departed. I was hoping she would be back before we started. She should be back shortly.

1:55:16 Do you have time enough to wait and we'll go to the next agenda item, hoping for her return? Yes. Thank you. So with your permission, Commission, we will move on to number seven, use of town, park, and facility. Save out number six. Okay. Okay, so this item was requested to be agendized for this meeting. Staff spent quite a bit of time and it's really, the time spent was one,

1:55:51 Putting that appendix together there, which was the attachment A, Town of Mammoth Lakes Parks and Facilities, that firstly describes the parks itself, identifies the fee schedule for each one of those facilities, and then it talks about the reservation information process, talks about the insurance requirement, indemnification, and so forth, and also I've attached the waiver to that as well. So that, in a nutshell,

1:56:18 is all our park and facility process. What I want to address, and we'll probably go through it individually, is that we want to look at the reservation process, if you have any comments on that, the use of alcohol on town parks and facilities, the liability insurance requirements, facility use agreements, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Unified School District Joint Use Agreement, and the topic of inflatable play structures or bouncy houses.

1:56:45 So what we've determined is, if you look at the reservation process, that's really the integration with ActiveNet. So that's what the online reservation system has enabled us to streamline. Remember we put that in place prior to last summer. So this year will be our first full summer of operation with that online tool.

1:57:09 Our feedback right now is the fact that I wouldn't say it's kind of drastically improved the department's facility management process, but it's certainly enabled the customer to kind of have a more streamlined process or at least understand the process. It was very cumbersome and time-consuming in the past, just the amount of paperwork we had, the integration with an Outlook calendar and so forth. So I think the streamlining has been very advantageous for us and also the guests.

1:57:35 So I don't know if you had any comments on that process right now. So I'll probably turn it back, Chair, if that's okay, we can maybe take these in chunks. If that's okay, then I'll kind of speak to each kind of those. Well, the reservation process stands on its own. Well, I got a couple of questions, if I could. There we go. Is this on the reservation process? I believe so. Okay, good. Okay.

1:58:03 One of the fees down there is in addition to the rental fees, special events may be required to pay an hourly supervision fee of $25 an hour. How do you determine that when it requires supervision? Yeah, that was a reference that we enabled at the Whitmore Track, so if it's a large event, for instance, that somebody's there all day, that we kind of put that in place.

1:58:30 It's somewhat subjective. So for instance, if we believe there's enough supervision there, you know, from the organising event producers themselves and it's probably not going to be implemented. If that we feel that there's not enough supervision and the town facilities need to be supervised, then we would put that in place. And that's actually in place for, it's actually factored in right now with ActiveNet.

1:58:57 If someone books that facility for a daily rental, so we knock that reservation fee down from 25 to 15 per hour if you're there for like a full day event or a track meet or so forth. So that's when that would get kicked in. So if you rent it for a day, we charge you a lower fee, but we're going to require that we have someone on site supervising that facility. Okay, and that's only on town-owned properties? That's great. So for instance, what we don't want to have, Commissioner, is for instance, if we have the...

1:59:25 Bleachers in place of Whitmore, and all of a sudden, you know, we disappear, and they come back, and those bleachers were either put over the fence, dragged around, moved. Bathrooms, you know, bathrooms, you know, have problems, which are put down there. So if no one's there supervising those bathrooms, all of a sudden, they're out of commission, and we've got problems. Or if people are bringing on alcohol, you know, food, you know, sugar drinks, you know, any, like on those track surfaces, nuts, you know, sunflower seeds.

1:59:51 We're not able to kind of, you know, supervise and then take the appropriate course of action. So that's kind of why, as opposed to a two-hour rental, if they're there all day, we enact that fee. Okay. And I think that's more a fee process than our reservation process. That's a good question. I would like to see a harder criteria, I know, in a nonprofit I'm involved in, if a group that is using our facility goes over X number of people, we require that they pay for staff.

2:00:19 Or get an acceptable volunteer from the group to be there because there are problems that arise. A break of breaks and they've got a sound system doing BA. Bathroom goes bad and they don't have the common sense to close it. Having staff there on a group of events of over a certain size. So the only thing, personally, Stu, the only thing I would say there is I'd like to see a hard and fast number of people. You know, if you exceed 30 people.

2:00:48 Or whatever it is that we think that number should be, we're going to charge that staff time and we're going to hire somebody to be there. Or we could do it by hours rental too, which is currently how the Whitmore track is set up. So that fee was adopted last year. So if they booked that fee for eight hours, then it triggers that $25 fee. That could be something that you could apply. But the staff supervision is a fee on every facility.

2:01:16 I would almost like to see it added to the community center because I know that that was another question I had. Are we losing revenue because we're not renting the community center because we're not allowing food? And I know the food thing got back because you have programs the next day and we don't. But I want to pull us back because I don't have anything to do with the reservation process. That's true. I'm very comfortable with the reservation process. Stu tells me it's working fine and saving everybody time.

2:01:44 And if we're comfortable with the reservation process, let's go through to the next one, which would be use of alcohol. So the use of alcohol is pretty clear. You know, it's current ordinance that we have. So it essentially prohibits any use of alcohol, drinking whatsoever, on our parks and facilities. The only way to get alcohol on is there by concession. So a concession is an ABC permit. You know, so you'd go through our special event permit process.

2:02:11 You'd request, I think, a beer garden permit from ABC. You'd get that signed by the chief. And that's the only way you can really do it. But it doesn't have to be inside a structure. I mean, the way beer festivals work, for instance, is that a booth is created and boom, that's your concessionary. Right, correct. And I believe that's where ABC defines it. So that's what you're saying. You could put it in the middle of a park. So we can do it on the parks as long as the Recreation Department agrees with it.

2:02:38 And then, of course, it gets signed by Chief of Police. So there can be alcohol on, but it has to go through the ABC process. I just want to be clear. Unless, you know, the Commission feels like they want to change that amendment, but, you know, we've been pretty strict on that. Back in the day when we first fired up the adult softball leagues and stuff, the ordinance was in place. It has not changed. But we pretty much turned our heads and didn't enforce the adult softball.

2:03:06 Alcohol rules. Every once in a while there's an idiot. But those idiots happen whether you have it legal or illegal. And I'm just wondering in circumstances like that if, and I don't know, maybe the liability of doing it is just too great. I know I sure enjoyed a cold one while I was playing softball. What? It's tough. Root beer, of course. Yes, you were talking about that. I do want to say it is, I mean it is an issue.

2:03:32 But at the same time it is enforced. The police do come on. There's an issue. We do call them. Let me just say we do the very best we can without kind of upsetting the apple cart of that program. But one, it's signed. Alcohol and actually tobacco is prohibited on those parks for that matter. But anyway, I think the other concern is liability. But I think for this perspective here, the other issue we have is if someone brings in and they're rented a shelter,

2:04:01 And they're bringing on alcohol. That's also a concern. And that's something that we struggle with enforcing, right? And we do tell people, you know, about this when they reserve. Yeah. And it seems like the softball situation got better with the adult sports coordinator last year. That was my... But it changes. Can we get more, you know, one of the places that there's a lot of people wanting to do and not enough space for in town right now are weddings, outdoor weddings.

2:04:30 I know, thank goodness that's going to help us at the Historical Society. And to say that you can come and have your reception here but you can't have alcohol is certainly going to put the kibosh on weddings coming forward to use our facilities. Now, I don't think that Shady Rest Park would be used so much for that because the setting isn't natural to it, but certainly Mammoth Creek Park, if they're having a tent set up and they're doing a... And I don't know that that's not something we should look at.

2:04:59 Is a fee that, you know, helps offset the... But they still have the option to get the license. Yeah, but... Only if they're selling. Yeah, the license, though, makes certain sales. I don't know, this is a tough place, and you're talking to an alcohol guy. Yeah. You know, it's the liabilities, the biggest thing is you. Yeah. Bugaboo. Quick question, though. U.S. Forest Service doesn't allow alcohol at Shady Rest Park. Is that correct? And since they're the actual owners, isn't that the...

2:05:28 Primary situation. Forest Service has no rules about alcohol. Okay, all right, I wasn't sure about that. So what we're talking about really is a town policy. Yes, you can still drink Mammoth Brewing Company in the woods. Okay, well, I just, but I was just checking that as far as that Shady Grass Park, it's a town ordinance, not a U.S. Forest Service. It's a permanent facility. All right, thank you. So you can walk off the parking lot and consume alcohol outside the park. Okay. So you can, which is what happens.

2:05:58 Because there's an open container along the way. We don't have an open container along the way. I don't know if there's an easy answer, because, you know, the nice thing about a wedding is that it's a private party. We are not getting complaints at this point, so do we just leave it as an answer? I think we're going to have to. Okay. I just wanted to, yeah. But your point is well taken. Unfortunately, we may be losing wedding reception business. But this does seem in line with what other municipalities do. So I think we should just leave it.

2:06:25 Well, when I worked down south, we allowed people to have weddings and receptions and to have alcohol. And they had an ABC license. What kind of ABC license? And proper insurance. There is no ABC license for getting alcohol away. That's the issue. You can get an ABC license for selling, which we do for events at the Historical Society. But the weddings and stuff that happen out there, because they aren't selling it, there's no ABC license. Nothing.

2:06:53 I can double check on that, but I think we still require them to obtain something from ABC. Does staff have any insight? We could just turn our heads from things like that, but with liability issues being what they are today,

2:07:23 I don't know that we can get away with that. I can't get back. I was just there about a year or so ago at a wedding reception, and there was plenty of alcohol. Yeah. Oops. Nothing. Okay. In that case, moving on to liability insurance requirements. Thank you. This one does have some questions that the town attorney identified. One, so if you read the municipal code, all persons, I'm just going to paraphrase it here, to use a facility.

2:07:54 or actually receive a permit from the town, let's just say that, must agree in writing to hold the town harmless, which is just our waiver, and identify the town from any and all liability. What they're also required to do is to provide liability insurance. So, say for instance, when an association organization which carries public liability insurance requests to use town facilities, they must provide that to the town

2:08:21 Proof of liability and also an endorsement naming the town as additional insured. So when I presented this town attorney, you know, he did say you can read this question, you know, his statements here. This was his response on page three. He believes it's quite ambiguous in nature. So, because what it really means is that we're required to, if we issue a permit, everybody must present their liability insurance and name the town as additional insured.

2:08:47 So if we're holding a meeting for two hours or one hour in the community centre, we're going to require that insurance. If someone's booking the Shady Rest picnic, we'd require them to provide us insurance. You can see, one, it's not really, and it's quite problematic, and it's not really suiting the needs of the town. Where we do require insurance is certainly at Whitmore Track or our sporting fields or any of those events that have that high degree of assumed risk.

2:09:16 In regards to, you know, soccer players, baseball, you know, softball, whatever it is, we get those all from our facility users in those agreements with soccer and money count and little league and so forth. But for the infrequent user that's just coming at, you know, one or, you know, several times, it's not really the alcohol issue, it's really this liability insurance and at this time, you know, we require it. So, you know, his recommendation is to, you know, present a revised

2:09:47 Ordinance that might satisfy and provide us a little bit more flexibility in regards to that that says should be revised to refer to just general liability insurance and not require, you know, the full additional insured endorsement. So what we have to do there is, one, keep it very general, but two, state with some criteria who was actually required to provide that higher level of, you know, liability insurance with a certificate.

2:10:17 So you can kind of see, you know, that language. So again, it's an older ordinance. It doesn't really suit our needs at this time. I would recommend that we move forward and maybe come back with a revised, with some revised language in the form of an ordinance. We're working also with CJPIA, Joint Powers Authority, and Melanie on this issue, and also the Bouncy House issue as well. So they would be able to kind of provide some kind of template.

2:10:47 If you wish, general liability insurance, it's probably more specific to 2014 than when this was drafted back in the day. So that's what we would recommend here and it would give staff and it would give the town certainly better clarity when we're talking with events, organisations, groups and what they're specifically required because at the moment we tell, we say we have to have it all and we certainly, you know.

2:11:16 Restricted with our facilities. So it's more of an issue than certainly alcohol. And this is for liability if somebody gets hurt rather than damage his property. So, yeah, so for the moment, you know, they certainly sign those waivers, you know, we certainly get the release of indemnifications that the town's covered. It's waived, but there's no financial assurance behind that, if you will.

2:11:44 As far as the additional, let me just ask this question, is that something that would be an addendum, if I wanted to have a private party there, my kid's ninth birthday party, the bouncy household questions I'll ask later, is that just a rider that I can get from my homeowner's insurance policy? Yep. And what's the general cost to the individual? You know, I'm not too sure. $50.

2:12:09 Thank you. I just did it recently. Did you? Yeah. I know that that's something that, you know, we require at Bloozapalooza, that each brewery provide that, and it's $25 to their company policy, which is a heck of a lot lower, and we run alcohol insurance. Of course, the majority of people using our parks and own houses. Well, and that's what I was about to say, is that I'm just saying that it's available to get. It is. Which we recommend. It's 50 bucks for somebody who already has a homeowner's insurance policy, but, you know, that still seems...

2:12:39 A little difficult for those that we want to encourage using our parks. Could the town consider offering that insurance and charging a fee? We have insurance that we can provide, but it's more for camps and programs. And I don't know if we really want to get into that business. I'd really like to see the town attorney go over this and come up with something new. My problem here is, first,

2:13:05 Signing a piece of paper holding the town harmless does absolutely nobody any good. Ask any attorney, that's the first thing they'll tell you. It doesn't mean anything. The town still owns all the equipment. They own the grounds and everything else. If somebody gets hurt out there on town equipment, regardless who holds the liability, guess who the first person that they're going to go after is? So I'd really like an opinion on whether or not this insurance requirement is actually keeping the town from any liability. I don't believe it is.

2:13:35 and what the best course of action is to go there. And if it is something that we want to pursue, I'd love to see us talk to some agent out there that can help the people, that we can refer people to to solve that issue. Because most of the apartment dwellers in Mammoth who might have their kids' birthday party out there because there isn't room at Meridian Arms to have them, or whatever we call that place, anyway, they aren't going to have homeowners.

2:14:06 Policies that they can just add on to. So I'd really like to have that come back with the... Could we ask the town attorney to make a recommendation for... Well, I think that's where we're kind of going with it. I think that's what I'm going to ask him to do. I think he's provided some pretty good language here, so I think what we would do is just come back with a further defined ordinance or the language that would kind of help clarify the ambiguity of that's the issue. Yeah. I know that the attorney is...

2:14:38 You know, this all seems about CYA more than anything. So, what do other municipalities do? I mean, do other towns require this kind of insurance? Is this just standard practice in the state of California? In New York State, too. I think so. Okay, well, I think I've got direction. Yeah. Facility use agreements. So, we

2:15:10 Entering Facility Use Agreements with, you can see the organisations identified below. And the advantage of a facility use agreement with an organisation is that essentially we have a very defined schedule that we're able to program at a facility and in return or in exchange for that community service they're providing, you know, for instance, we provide them with that use of that facility for a very nominal fee and it depends on the usage. So, for instance,

2:15:39 You know, AYSO Soccer, Little League, you know, their fee is a dollar. Swim Team, on the hand, is pro-rated on the use of that facility prior to our opening date. You know, so we have that arrangement with them, and it's agreed upon rate. We meet them every year. They're all coming in right now to review that. Each and every one of these organizations is required to provide that certificate of liability, the endorsement, and also we produce waivers specifically for those activities. So we get everything covered here.

2:16:08 That's how we kind of manage these other groups. For instance, the Mammoth Youth Hockey Association are going to be becoming more formalised. They want to kind of establish their non-profit. Then I said, great, we can enter in a facility use agreement with you for use at the ice rink. It would kind of lower your fees, get you a better scheduled rate. And then they would be able to apply for youth sports funding. So for instance, that's how we can kind of benefit these youth groups that provide a really valuable service to the community.

2:16:36 So that's our current facility use agreement process. Any comments on those? No, it's worked so far. It's worked so far. And you can see we went through that a couple of years ago with Mammoth Lakes Women's Club when we updated their agreement. We went through that whole use policy for the snack shop. But, you know, we reevaluate every year with these groups as well. No, I was just curious as to why, for instance, the fire department isn't there since they use it once a year for the...

2:17:05 Do they just do a special permit every year? They just do a special permit, yep. This one here, so the Town of Mammoth Lakes Mammoth Unified District Joint Use Agreement. So currently, the most current document is from 1991. And I believe when I did all the research, I've got the copy, I've actually got the physical document. In 2009, it came before the Tourism Rec Commission, so you might remember that chair. And it did go through an extensive revision.

2:17:36 It went through the school district board, went through our town attorney, risk manager. However, the agreement was never executed. So what staff's recommending is we're going to dig that one up again, bring it back to you, and see if we can kind of get that revised. Yeah.

2:17:56 More and more need for use of school facilities, and in turn they have more and more need for our facilities, so we just want to make sure that both of those, or that one document is fair and representative for both entities, so bring that to your attention, and I believe I attached it to the staff report, so you can actually read that document. That's the 91 verse.

2:18:21 That's the 1991 document. Like I said, I'll put this on the agenda again and we'll talk about it and I'll bring back that 2009 document and we'll kind of go through that one again. But I'll also get that push back out to our term attorney, CJPIA, and go through that process again. So I think that's a good direction there. So the last fun topic of conversation is our bouncy houses. So I've pulled up some information here. Recently the Hercules City Council

2:18:51 They went through quite an extensive process to update their ordinance and they actually approved a ban on inflatable play structures. They also directed staff to begin working on an ordinance that would allow the city to attach monetary fines and penalties against violators. So obviously they have more issues than we do. Currently right now if somebody asks us to put a bouncy house on one of our town parks we say no. That's kind of where we're at at the moment.

2:19:19 But we don't have an ordinance and we don't really have a way to enforce it. So the town attorney again would recommend drafting an ordinance if we feel strongly about it. We did have a conversation with CJPIA as well. And they're in the same position as well. They also provide us with a broader, and this is kind of a good way to do it, so the supplier of bouncy houses, we can actually attach

2:19:48 You know, the language, have them sign it, but the town attorney wasn't too optimistic that they'd actually sign, you know, a lot of their liability away. So I think that was a concern, but there's certain layers that we can actually jump through to get this a little bit tighter if you wish. We're just coming forward with a recommendation that we would probably think this is probably a good thing to consider. I think we probably should bring...

2:20:16 In order to fall, we can certainly bring language for you. We can certainly tighten up a lot of our risk as it pertains to the use of these structures. I don't know if Commissioner Turner's got one. I don't know if we want to go there. But anyway, so this is one of those issues that, you know, doing some research and some trends and where municipalities are going, but this is one area that they feel that they want to kind of tighten up. Is this coming from our town attorney then? Or is this town staff?

2:20:45 It came from me just because I was doing the research, and I pushed it out to both these groups, the town attorney and CJP, and I went, yeah, that's probably a good idea. And I'm like, ooh, okay. So if they're recommending it, I think it's probably prudent and wise for us. A good idea to tighten the ordinance or to eliminate the use of bouncy houses on... Well, it's really eliminating the use of bouncy houses on... Yeah, so here's my issue with that. I just, man, I've seen them in use. The kids love them. It's a great play thing.

2:21:15 Anytime action is involved with kids or adults, people are going to get hurt. Now I understand that Hercules probably lost a big lawsuit because they allowed this thing. But if we close down everything that is action oriented, we close out all the fun for our kids to have. The next will be softball. Kids get hit with balls. They get hit with bats. They get hit with... I'm having a huge issue with the whole problem.

2:21:45 Injuries and bouncy houses so prevalent that it has reached this level of, or is it poor supervision, or is it, um, just one more thing that's fun for the kids to do that we're going to tell them, no, you can't do it, you'll poke your eye out. We've got to look at a structured league as a little bit different than potentially an unsupervised bouncy house, so it's an interesting analogy, but I don't know. I know, but in the past we've

2:22:15 Gotten the bouncy houses ourselves and paid for them ourselves for special events in our own parks. Do we have that many people putting bouncy houses up in our parks, Stu? No, because we don't let them. You know, I'll just comment here, so I'm just reading the response from Melanie, who's with CJPIA. She says, if the town chooses to allow them, then the facility use agreement requirement, which is...

2:22:40 Just kind of our liability insurance. For the applicant to obtain $1 million of general liability insurance, naming the town as additional insured is the acceptable requirement. So, you know, we can, you know, go through that layer if you wish. Again, we were just going a step further. And this was the other comment. So for added assurance, the town may elect to draft a master service agreement with one or more suppliers of inflatable amusement devices. So anyway, so again, look, I'm just here.

2:23:08 We're currently in kind of a no man's land. We don't have a policy. It's not in an ordinance. We're just not recommending anybody put them on our parks and facilities just because we don't want to expose ourselves to the risk. So I think it has to be addressed one way or the other. That's why we're kind of bringing it forward. I guess my question is that when I'm in San Diego and I visit a public park in San Diego, you see bouncy house after bouncy house. They're set up just all over the place. I don't know if that's just because

2:23:35 Larger cities have, you know, more of a capacity to slide on to those kinds of insurance policies, but, yeah, I just, I'm with you, Bill. I mean, I've got a kid who's about to turn seven. She loves bouncy horses. And loves being active. Yeah. And wouldn't we prefer them being active to being obese? Sorry, I'm not calling Kel Black, if it were, but...

2:23:58 Sean, do you have something you were going to say? No, yeah, Mammoth Brain Company owns a bouncy house, and we set it up on the last day of Bluza Bluza, and it is one of the main attractions. Yeah, absolutely. You've got to have somebody, we assign somebody to stand to it to make sure that there's no more than the recommended number of kids in there and that they're not doing the WWF, you know, drops, but... But you understand that there's going to be a town park probably, and you won't be able to do that. Well, that's the problem. I will agree with you that it's...

2:24:28 You know, I mean, activity is better than obesity, and I don't know where you draw the line. I know it's another CYA issue, but where does it stop? One thing I'll just say here is, so if you're, do you rent your bouncy house out? We have to private, you know, people who are having their kids' seventh birthday parties, yeah. So the option here is what?

2:24:56 What Melanie said would be that if we have a master service agreement with you, the rental of that product, the indemnity agreement, which would have to be signed, and evidence and insurance are in place and would not have to be requested each time a facility use permit holder decides to have a bounce house at their events. So it means that you're really covering...

2:25:17 Well, see, and that's the danger, too, is that I rented to Betsy for $25 to put up in a park, you know, and somebody gets hurt at yours, so they're coming after me. And you're right, that's going to tell me, sorry, Betsy, I'm not renting. That's an exposure that, you know, you're going to have to consider waiting, and that's why, you know. And there's no way that we can make Betsy pay for the, you know, she's going to be getting liability insurance.

2:25:44 So I'm saying, so she could do it either way. So we could do it where you as the renter would cover that as a master service agreement, or Betsy would just have the $1 million of general liability insurance to present to the town to cover the use of that bouncy house on the property. So that's the current option we have if we don't want to consider revising the ordinance. I want to make sure we get every kid that runs on our fields to have a million dollar liability. This is why lawyers win. So I attended the CJPIA.

2:26:18 They recommended no softball beans. They recommended no bakeries. They recommended nothing. Right. But what is this town willing to risk? And that's the decision that we're asking, is what are we willing to risk, I think. Not, we don't want kids to play bouncy-lossies, but, and probably this town, like you said, what are we willing to risk? So I think that's the question we're looking to answer. Because I think we are going to risk the softball teams and the bakeries make us run.

2:26:48 We literally went up and said, what do you mean softball teams? And they literally said, we recommend no. And our insurance provider said, look, honestly, if the town chooses to allow them, then the facility use agreement requirement, you know, to obtain that insurance, naming the town additional insurance is the acceptable requirement. So, I mean, there you go. I mean, if we're willing... What about if we go back to the insurance provider and say, we want to allow bouncy houses, what's it going to cost us to get a liability policy to cover us?

2:27:19 in the use of bouncy houses. That seems like the direction I'd like us to go in. JPIA is an insurance group that's jointly funded by a multitude of cities. What's it going to add to our policy to be able to have action sports on our fields in bouncy houses? That would be my question. We already have an ice skating rink, which potentially is pretty dangerous, too. And a swimming pool. Yeah, skateboard parks. Yeah.

2:27:48 I think we're already there. Because I don't want to, I don't want to preclude, I happen to know people that own their own bouncy houses. They aren't very expensive, the small ones. I don't want to preclude someone setting up a fun bouncy house for kids at a birthday party. So if that's the direction, then we would just enforce that $1 million of general liability? I would like to ask our insurance company what it would add to our policy to have a

2:28:16 Liability coverage that would cover us if somebody gets hurt involved in an activity on one of our parts. And maybe we could point out that it does seem inconsistent to have an, you know, have unsupervised, you know, skate parks and put on a lot of bouncy houses. But I think it's better liability-wise to have an unsupervised skate park. Right, yeah. So that would be my question. If it was my homeowner's insurance, that's what I would do. Go to them and ask, am I covered, and if I'm not covered,

2:28:44 What do I have to do to gain that coverage? Would a person need to obtain a permit to bring a bouncy house into the park? Yeah, that's what we'd say. I mean, they get the permit when they rent that space. So there's a way to obtain revenue that could offset some of the costs. So are we good with asking him to do that? We are, and I think we also need to keep in mind that, you know, our...

2:29:14 Potential bouncy house season is not that long, really, so it may not really be worth it in the end. Maybe we should only allow them when there's soft snow on the ground. Then we get into the whole snow management thing. That's all I have. Thank you. Would that satisfy your request from the last meeting, just to clarify a lot of these points? Yeah. Yes, Stu, thank you for doing that. I know I was a proponent of that.

2:29:43 Getting that policy in it. Thank you. I'd just like to follow up on a couple things. The Health and Safety Code actually has some statutes that limit liability for public agencies related to ice rinks, skate rinks, and those kinds of things, as long as they're signed properly and the rules are posted. Correct. Yeah, but wouldn't that be the same thing if they're signing a contract and bring their bouncy house on? Then that would be a contract. Yeah.

2:30:13 And it would be specified in the contract that the town is... Identified. Yeah, which means absolutely nothing, as do the signs. Unless there's insurance. Yeah. No, the others by statute, California state statutes. This would be a contract between the town and the user. So it's a little, there's a difference. But the user's contract is backed up by the million dollar policy. That's... You know, at this point, I think we need to go...

2:30:49 I can give you a quick update on the Parks Master Planning Update. You want to go through that? Do you want to wait? Well, I don't want Mr. Taylor to have to wait until 5 o'clock. You already waited through the whole last meeting. Did someone want to try and reach out to Teri? I've got her number. I think the Parks Master Planning Update is pretty quick. I think we'll text Teri while we're talking. We can kind of just knock that one out.

2:31:20 So that is item number nine. So what we've done is provide you with a revised calendar, essentially, of the meeting dates. So if you look at page, if you get there, page two of your staff report. So we've confirmed the kickoff meeting for March 11th at 1 p.m. At the moment, that's just with, I believe, Commissioner Stelick and Commissioner Agnitz, I believe. You know, did I overlook this and maybe...

2:31:49 Said I was available, but I'm not. No, we haven't. We haven't done it yet. We just set that time, so. Confirmed. Yeah. Because I'm returning into town that day. Okay. So. Yeah. At March 11, I definitely am not here. The next day. There was only, there was only Terry and Pat at this time. It was just that little committee. If you wanted to nominate someone else there, they're pretty tight. Did you want to look at a later date? I mean, a later time. In fact, if one or three or. I could be available at three, but not at one.

2:32:18 Like at the moment, we're only looking at two of the commissioners, so it's not kind of everyone, or if we, well who, who from the commission is about on that date back at all? Well, I'm coming back from Carmel, so I guess it depends on whether the passes are open. I could stop and make a conference call. Let me tell you right now, the passes are not open. Well, I mean, it's Tom. Yeah, well, yeah, Tom.

2:32:44 So late that day would be fine for me on the 11th? We'll have to check. And I don't know about Terry's availability? We could look at 4 o'clock maybe. You want to try 4 o'clock? Okay. Could we set it at 4 o'clock and then add an alternate if she can't be there? Yes. Betsy could? Yes, I could do 4 o'clock. Okay, alternate to Betsy, great. That's pretty important to keep up means. So what we want to do is just make sure that we're satisfying, you know, Commission's concerns and we're covering all our bases.

2:33:15 So these are the confirmed dates in the following schedule, apart from the presentation to Town Council, which we are bumping to July 2nd. June 18th is a pretty hectic time. That's probably when they're going to approve their budget, so I'm not for sure they want to be... I don't think we'd get an adequate representation at that time to be able to present, so we want to move that to July 2nd. But the March 20th and April 17th charrettes, hopefully firm dates for everybody. What are those dates again, sir?

2:33:47 March 20th and April 17th. They're both going to be at the Community Center, which is a larger venue, from 4 to 7 p.m. We'll have light snacks and refreshments available. Those are, I've gone both those days myself. And these will be noticed as rec commission meetings as well, so we have no issue with the Brown Act? Yeah, both of those days I'm unavailable. I am here both of those days as far as I know.

2:34:22 Is that your availability? I'm available. I may have my daughter with me, just given the time. We'd all love to see her. I'm sure she hasn't put on the parks. She can tell us about bouncy houses. What we've also included there is just an overview of the communication and marketing. So we've investing, you know, we have that $5,000 of funds, which is kind of the staff costs. We're not anticipating a lot of that. The other cost there would be any associated printing costs. And then we're investing about $3,000.

2:34:54 About $3,000 right now in regards to promoting the event, which I think is really important. So what I've just handed out there, this part to the meeting was kind of that 8.5 by 11. That's actually going to be a printed poster, about 11 by 17. We've got postcards coming out as well, a couple of thousand postcards. We have the newspaper ads normally. We have radio. And really the biggest part of this is really the underground network. And I think what we're trying to do is get it all to our...

2:35:23 Use Groups, Facility Use Agreements, we're going to send it to each Commissioner, we'll have basically a little verb and then the PDF, so if you can just send it to your groups as well. So I think that virally I think is really important and then certainly your endorsement of the event, you know, as you're speaking to folks that, I mean this is it, right, I mean we really want to come out and finalise these parks master plans for these four facilities. It's really important that we hear from you, get involved, I think it's pretty condensed, it's pretty short, it's not just

2:35:52 10, 11, 15 meetings is just two meetings, you know, hopefully that's enough time, but I think it's really important that we engage that community as much as we can. We're also, we'll have Spanish online as well, we just got the translation, so that'll be up on our website probably tomorrow, so if someone comes in they can read it all in Spanish as well. So anyway, so not only that you see the regular kind of channels, we'll also use kind of the viral promotion as well.

2:36:20 Sean, are you out of town that entire week? No, just those days. I'm gone the Wednesday and Thursday, I'm gone the third Wednesday and Thursday of every month. Do we want to have any flexibility in changing one of the dates? Well, because they're set by the consultant and they can do it. I mean, I can. The odds are good that one of us will not be available for. Yeah. Yeah, but for him in this program, yeah. Yeah, it's just.

2:36:57 You know, essentially the third Thursday of every month. I've got a group up in an event up in Reno. You know, the only question I would have, Stu, but it messes up with our own staff. It would be awful nice to have one of those meetings on a Saturday when the public can actually attend. Betsy made the comment that 4 to 7 is a tough time if you've got kids, too. Well, they...

2:37:35 You know, the way we figure, I think we talked about this last time, this is not new, we have the dates, we have the times. We're pretty much rolling with a lot of advertising, it would be hard to kind of spin it back. I think we agreed that we couldn't get everybody there, and I think 4 to 7 was a time that wasn't taking away from the evening time with kids. You know, kids are out, hopefully there's an activity. I don't think there's a good time, I think weekends, people, you know, I don't know, they come and go. So I don't know, I think whoever's...

2:38:03 Well, I think it's great if kids come too. Whoever's engaged, I think if you're really willing to come along, you'll come along. I mean, it's not an extensive process by any means. I appreciate my commissioner's concern about me being there, but this may be something where I'll just need to read the notes afterwards. Okay. Or provide comments beforehand. Right. Is there a method where people in the community can comment? Yep, there's a, you can.

2:38:27 Reply to the webpage right now. And then remember, it comes back to commission for review at a presentation on May 6th, which is our regular meeting. So, you know, by any means, that plan that's come forward is just your plan. And then we have a final design meeting again in June, so the commission gets another stab at it before it goes to council. So you can see, I think we've built in some pretty good layers there for... But really, and this is really more for community input. I mean, we've spent the last year on it, so I think we've probably provided what we...

2:38:59 Needed to provide it to get to this point. So from a Commissioner point of view, I think at this time we're really just handing it back over to the community to see, you know, how they respond to it, how they engage with it, and what their real needs and priorities are. So I think we're okay. You know what I mean? This is a process we've been going for quite a while. I think we're okay too. Yeah, I think so. And I'm sorry, how big will these be? 11 by 17. Like I said, we'll PDF you that, and you can just print that in that size. So it would print on any piece of paper.

2:39:29 I was thinking this might need to be a slightly bigger font. Yeah, like you said, it's 11 by 17, so it'll be big. So we're working with it. The postcard's easier, radio, so anyway, we're just trying to fill up that room and get around there. I'm still really excited about it. Yeah, it's a really good process. We're pretty excited, too. And then, I mean, so by July 2nd, we'll have, you know, these facilities planned. We'll know what we want. We'll know where they're going to go.

2:40:01 I think that'll trigger, like we just talked about in that workshop, you know, our capital investment strategy. So here we go. That's great. Yeah. I think that's an advertising thing. Teri Stehlik replied saying she'll be here in 10 minutes about six minutes ago. Okay. Keeping Bill sitting longer, moving right back to number eight, Mammoth Lakes Recreation update and Town Council action regarding Measure R. This brings us back to your motion since we already discussed it.

2:40:38 wanting to see the process reopened or continued. I think that's where we were at. Well, this is just an update, so is my motion going to... Were you able to take action on this? We can take action on this. The part about redoing the process, this is the time to take action on that. Okay. Is there anything else, if I can start asking questions if my fellow questioners...

2:41:14 Was there anything else of concern in this or commendation on this staff report? One thing that staff did, thank you, Commissioner, was that we included some of the recommendation from that 5.0 document was that the Recreation Commission would be or have the opportunity, let's just say that, to maybe refocus their efforts towards, you know, municipal community recreation. So what we've done here is we've attached, which is Attachment A,

2:41:45 Your current chapter ordinance that states your powers and duties. And it's something we don't have to take action on now by any means, but it's just something that I think would be good for consideration if the commission desires to review, further refine, bring something back to council. So that's kind of why this was included in that packet. So I'm not really asking for any action, so to speak, right now. I think it's going to be a process that will move in tandem.

2:42:13 With the MLR process, if that moves along, like I said, there's still this up or down vote, you know, coming along, but I just think to be proactive, here it is, this is what our powers and duties are, and our charter by the town, so if you do wish to consider revising it, maybe have a look at it, and we can bring it back at the next meeting and talk about it then, or if you have any comments now on that. And I can give a brief synopsis, too, of some of the items from yesterday's formation committee meeting as well.

2:42:44 The committee set meeting dates, which I could just email out to all of you if you'd like. The meetings will be held here in Suite Z. I think the town manager is just checking to make sure about conflicts. But they will be on Granicus. Dan Holler is also asking that anyone who wants to be included in the distribution, the agendas, and the minutes, send him an email, which I would encourage. I think Pat's already on it. Teri and I are, obviously, but I would encourage.

2:43:13 You just stay abreast of, you know, the process. I think it's a, you know, pretty ambitious work plan. And, yeah. But it's, you know, we're definitely, definitely moving forward. Pat, do you have anything you want to add out of yesterday's? It was a well-run meeting, very organized, and a lot of, delineated a lot of tasks that need to be completed between, in a short time span. Several,

2:43:47 Prior to your next meeting, and then, you know. Yeah, and Dana Stroud is chairing that committee, and she's in the process of, you know, coming up with, you know, a solid work plan for which items will be addressed at which meeting, too. So, should be pretty succinct. And I think the idea is that we'll meet, you know, every couple of weeks on Monday is to try to keep the meetings short and focused. That's very organized. Good afternoon. I thought it went well. But as I look at,

2:44:22 What's still attached with the Recreation Commission responsibilities, I see a lot of overlap. And I don't know, and maybe it's something to look at for the future, but I don't know that we really need to delineate more so what's already on here. I think it's good to have it more encompassing, and then maybe as the process goes along, modifications are made.

2:44:48 Well, you know, the scope of work is still, you know, being hammered out, and I actually volunteer to sit on that subcommittee since I'm familiar, you know, with, you know, with what the commission does and handles currently so that I can, you know, have that input and sort of see how things will be structured going forward. You know, I have no problem with any of that. I have no problem with MLR moving forward. I still have a huge problem with the suspension of the RU award process. And reading this over, I understand even more why people are coming to me saying, how do you feel about RU going to MLR?

2:45:22 suspend the measure R&U award process, complete the financial reconciliation, the maintenance obligations without limiting the completion of all current funding awards, develop with the town attorney the appropriate legal structure for the allocation and use of measure R&U funds by MLR, which tells me that we are throwing out the process and MLR is going to allocate the funds based on a new process that hasn't even been thought of or is going to be thought of.

2:45:52 I don't see that in here. And it's just, for me, it's a huge red flag on how those funds are going to be rolled in and used in future years. Weighted heavily for whatever MLR is going to be doing with no consideration of the previous rec commission and its wishes or anything else. That's what it says here to me in black and white. So that's my concern. Sorry.

2:46:24 Well, one thing that did come out of the meeting yesterday, although I think it still needs to be vetted out, is the 501c3 funding aspect, whether it's a foundation versus a public charity. And from what I understood from the meeting yesterday, and correct me if I'm wrong, Betsy, a public charity is a 501c3 that receives public funds from, like, a governmental agency, as opposed to a foundation that isn't structured that way.

2:46:52 Funding from outside sources. So it looks like there's an emphasis in perhaps going towards the public charity element, which would then tie into the use of Measure R and Measure U funds. Yeah, that's, yeah. Clear definition there. Yeah, that's correct. And then I think that the hope would be that, you know, that eventually there would also be, you know, the 501c3, you know, private foundation arm, you know, because there's more benefits to donors.

2:47:21 to donate into a private foundation versus a public charity and that, you know, the hope is that NLR would eventually, you know, have both and not, you know, as it becomes... Well, to be revenue neutral. Revenue neutral, exactly, and not dependent on R&U. In some undetermined length of time. Well, three to five years, I think, is the consensus. Yeah, and of course, we're all hoping that that ends up the case. Yeah. That still doesn't alter the fact that this eliminates the process of how R&U...

2:47:53 Awards are considered, regardless who does the process, and that is my concern. Well, and, yeah, and, you know, MLR is, you know, in the process of, you know, developing its, you know, budget to present to council, and, you know, I mean, you know, council has, you know, has again voted, you know, to continue the MLR process, but they have not voted to adopt, you know, there is no MLR right now, so. No, I understand that. No, I do.

2:48:25 But that goes back to what I said at the last meeting that we only saw version 4.0. We didn't see version 5.0 of the SMG report. That could have been a time when we talked about some of this, and we didn't have that opportunity. So maybe now, you know, in retrospect, this would be a good opportunity for the Commission wants to weigh in on the decisions that were made on the 19th of February.

2:48:57 No, I think that's a good idea, and I did bring forward to council the concerns that we did raise at that meeting, so they are very aware, I think, of the commission's things that need to be considered, and definitely the committee is planning on some public engagement to address those issues, too. John? Okie doke. Let me make this motion, and I will seek wordsmithing, perhaps.

2:49:29 that the Recreation Commission supports the ongoing discussion of MLR, and we can change some of these words, however, strongly requests the reinstatement of the Measure R and U award process to provide continuity of a vetted process and reduce public perception of Measure R and U funds misappropriation. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion?

2:50:07 Can I ask it to be read back? You'll have to read it back. You're typing really fast, though. You wrote it down. Yes, I did. Well, most of it I filled in where I wasn't sure. The Recreation Commission supports, what did I say? Thank you. That's pretty ambiguous right there. However, strongly requests the reinstatement, the Measure R and U award process, so as to provide continuity.

2:50:39 I think you said which has been vetted. Well, I'm getting that. So it's to provide continuity of a vetted process, which it is, and reduce public perception of Measure R and U funds misappropriation. No further discussion. Last chance to try and talk this out or be convinced. I think I've said my piece. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? No. 3-1. Okay.

2:51:22 There she is. It's just in time. Back to the HVS Special Event Study. Oh, it's fine. It worked out. The only person who owe cocktails is Mr. Taylor. Thank you, Farina. So, at this point, Bill, do you want to make a little presentation or you just want us to break in with questions? Well, I'm assuming, fine, right? Yeah. I'm assuming that you have all read the staff report and skimmed at least the study. So, all I'll

2:52:02 say in opening remarks is that this is the final study it was revised from the draft that you saw some time ago in response to comments received by the consultant from you and from other parties and it represents their recommendations and analysis of events facilities and potential sites in Mammoth Lakes it is not

2:52:31 Meant to be directive or definitive. It's information provided to you, to the public, to the council, to the Measure U committee in evaluating proposals going forward or in setting priorities. So the first part of this, and this was also presented to the Measure U committee this morning, the first part of this is just accepting the study and then talking about how

2:53:02 Potentially to go forward what next steps might be with regard to identifying facilities for use of measure R&U funds and whatever information you might need to make those further decisions. And that's really, in terms of the study, that's where we are. Then the discussion of next steps, of course, would be something else. So I guess

2:53:33 What questions, if any, do you have pertaining to the study? I thought it was extremely comprehensive. I think you looked at all the different angles, as many sites as you could envision, and I thought it was a very comprehensive, objective viewpoint. I want to thank you for that. I just want to ask for some clarification. So essentially what the study is recommending is that the – maybe actually I just need to ask.

2:54:12 The event site is proposed to be at the foundation site. I guess that's what I'm asking. It's for two different sites. To say that it's specifically recommended, the sites that rated the highest based on the criteria identified were foundation site and, of course, for an outdoor venue, Sam's Woods. So was it recommending the indoor site be at the foundation?

2:54:45 Well, what it was recommending was, remember, its recommended program was essentially a merged facility where you have both an indoor and an outdoor, and that was clearly at the foundation. That rated the highest. Okay. And then, but the Canyon Lodge site sports slightly higher than Sam's, but you still feel that Sam's is the better. You're asking if I do or if they do? They. They. You know, it's an interesting question.

2:55:16 I think the consultants, just in terms of the rating and ranking, yes, it ranked higher. But we also know that it's not compatible. But a wind study was not done. Or the wind study was done, but it was only one through five? No, there was no wind study done. That was, depending on other decisions, that was a further step that they included as one of the next analyses. Now, you know, obviously things have

2:55:49 The very fact that this study was conducted sort of kicked off some discussion and some actions. And so, in fact, there's been a proposal for a sprung structure at the foundation site. There's been further discussion of potential acquisition of Sam's Woods, although as far as I know, nobody's actually brought forward a proposal on that. So, basically, you can use this study

2:56:18 To evaluate what comes, it's told you and it's told the community already that a facility like this is feasible. And it's given some criteria for narrowing down site selection. And that was what it was supposed to do. It was not going to be the final word on which site or sites the community might choose. In fact, its most important function may have been simply to say, yes, you can do this and it will work.

2:56:50 And it also then eliminated a number of what I'll call a peripheral sites from further consideration for town investment. One thing it also points out too though is what other communities, peer communities are doing and it seems like we're really far behind in that sense. May I start asking questions? Okay, I'm sorry. I mean you guys can... I have some conclusions at the end but my questions for the facilities study were handled this morning. Okay.

2:57:26 You know, as the commissioner, I would say, yes, I accept the study. I mean, obviously, it's been done, and I accept it as being done. You know, when I'm looking at the points, I guess one of the places that the foundation scored really high was because there's nothing else around it that it's going to interfere with noise and that type of thing. So, you know, that's, you know, I need to look at all the different scores and where they scored high and where they...

2:57:54 and then possibly a rec center can handle.

2:58:23 Any meetings or any lectures or anything like that? Or is it better suited to combine the two? Because we are still looking at erect facilities. There's only so much money we have. If this becomes a private facility, then obviously the conversation changes. And the way it's looking with the foundation, and I will set up a meeting with Evan because I'm under a little bit different, I didn't realize that the foundation still had the funding to build the

2:58:50 Structure itself. I thought that that had changed just a little bit. So anyways, I'll speak with Evan on that. A concern of mine is that, you know, I understand we talked about Measure R, Measure U, when Measure U was put out there, is that this was one of the main reasons that Measure U was put out there, is the O&M of a facility like this, and I was involved with that, and I understand that. But when I'm looking at these numbers,

2:59:16 You know, we're looking at year 2025 and we're still significantly in the red. And so I guess that would be something that, you know, prior to building something and agreeing to something, you know, those things need to be looked at. And then as far as prior to ever accepting this and saying yes, I think the foundation could probably be everything, but I think the wind is huge.

2:59:44 I think access and visibility is still an issue when you're looking at an event site. And so I guess I would be looking at that there needs to be further evaluation prior to saying that we're putting all our eggs in one basket, that everything's going in one place. And by the way, I don't think the study was suggesting that the community would put all its eggs in one basket. In fact,

3:00:10 The choice might be to invest in three or four different baskets, but it would be strategic, understand what you're getting. With regard to the O&M, and I don't want to necessarily, I'm not trying to support or any particular site at this moment, but discussion that did come up this morning is that for the most part, regardless of which site, we go after the wood site.

3:00:40 The operational and maintenance costs of any of these are probably going to have to be subsidized in perpetuity. And that's just the nature of public facilities. Shady Rest Park hasn't turned a profit yet, no matter how high the fees are. And we do it for other reasons. We still need a business plan to understand what the potential and probable

3:01:10 Long-term costs are so that we know we can afford them and that we still that we want the facility enough that we're willing to pay it. Exactly. And so from that standpoint, yes, you need a pro forma, you need an idea of what the potential is and probably even a sensitivity analysis. If things go really well, how is it? If things don't go really well, how is it? And so anyway, I think that you can get that information.

3:01:39 And your decision, your choice is really going to be going to figure out how you weigh. You know, I was looking back at, you know, when I was sitting back there just sort of scraping through the bottom of my memory, which is kind of a murky spot. You know, over the years and the time we've been incorporated, we've talked over and over and over again about the things we want. We've got a list of about 10 that we've come up with.

3:02:08 You know, we started actually with a conference convention facility. I don't know if you remember those studies. Obviously, public parks, pool, rec center, an ice rink, trails, performing arts facility, event site or sites, an amphitheater, more recently a track, and a field house have popped up on the radar as things we want. We can't afford all of those at once. And

3:02:37 So the process to say, okay, how are we going to pick? And do we, is it first come, first serve? Which one gives us the best leverage for our money? Those are things you're going to have to wrestle with. And this report is not intended to answer those definitively, but to give you some meaningful information about things that work and things that don't work. Yeah. And it goes back to my comments earlier that we need to finish that.

3:03:08 Prioritization as a commission. That's something that needs to happen. But I think this is a priority, and I think one of the things that this study really demonstrated to me was just, you know, that this really helps achieve the goals of generating, you know, shoulder season, you know, visitation and revenue, and that there's so much potential. And, you know, we talk so much about leveraging funds and, you know, the fact that we have, you know, a partner, you know, who has, you know, funding and is willing, you know, to...

3:03:38 To work with us, I think, you know, I think we should move forward with further evaluation because, you know, I think that this has emerged as a priority. If I can switch hats for a moment. When I was on the Measure U Steering Committee, I did ask the question just that way. If you hadn't done any other prioritization, all you know is the list of things that the community has said that it wants over the year.

3:04:04 One of them walks in and says, we can go today, we've got the money, we've got the plan, but we need potentially $200,000 to $300,000 a year of ongoing subsidy, what would we do? Because there was the, how many out of it, eight, ten of us on the committee? And people said, you know, if we can get something, get one thing off the list, you know, and like I said, this list has been hanging around, how long have we been incorporated now?

3:04:33 My concern is we did that with the ice rink. And where are we right now? I'm sorry. So I don't want to jump and make... I understand. You know, you have to do your due diligence. So I agree wholeheartedly that this has been on the radar. So, you know, I would say that it moves forward with the further evaluation. And keep in mind that all of these facilities have been on the radar. Yeah. I would say the same thing if somebody walked in and said...

3:05:04 I'm willing to help put a roof on the ice rink. Okay, well now we need to jump in and start evaluating and do we want to do that? But if there's something else floating out there that we haven't discussed or hasn't moved, and I'll say let's pick on, what do I have here that's actually a, how about the field house?

3:05:29 It really hasn't been a proponent yet. There's nothing that's come forward to say this is what it's going to be. This is how we're going to program it. And that includes, you know, this commission, town council. Nobody's really taken it that far. I don't think you'd want to wait on roof on the ice rink or evaluation of a roof on the ice rink or evaluation of an events facility pending that. And I'm not saying that. I'm not saying that at all. So maybe I wasn't clear on what I was saying. So anyways.

3:06:00 Well, I think there's some great opportunities in front of us, whether it's this site, ultimately potentially Mammoth Creek Park, and I don't think it has to be neither, or Sam's Woods. I think there's a lot of opportunity there. We have the bell shape, too. We're going to be looking at master planning. There's options out there, and maybe some of them are on smaller scales. More questions?

3:06:31 What is the cost, what is the estimated cost of the next steps that are outlined here? I think that would depend on how we define the next steps. Before I go to that, Sandy wanted to speak to the last point, I believe, so I'll ask public comment on the last. Thank you. Sandy Hogan, member of the Measure U Committee, and under which purview the Performing Arts Center does fall. Just a little bit of background. A lot of people have forgotten about Measure C.

3:07:00 which was passed back in the year 2000. This was the Bond Act for the college, which authorized, and there's still, is it Pat, you would remember, we worked on the grand jury report together. It authorized eight or $13 million worth of bonds. I can't remember, I think there's eight remaining right now and probably more that can be sold. One of the things that that is for

3:07:24 has been the construction of a performing arts center with a lot of strings attached, and the grand jury report will give you that information, but the fact is the construction funds are there. Let me give you the background before you. Can we read the grand jury report anywhere? Certainly, it's online. It's on the county website? Yeah, on the county, yeah, last year. It's a complete report on the status of, in other words, we did a report, not an investigation, we did a report on the status of the funds of the

3:07:53 Measure C, because it had been 13 years since any of us had heard about it. We wanted to know what was going on. And because this issue of the Performing Arts Center came up. And so you will see there that there are a lot of strings attached. We interviewed the financial officer down in Bakersfield. We interviewed the dean of the college here, who's actually the director of the campuses for Bishop and Mammoth. And we interviewed Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

3:08:23 And you'll find a great history of how they've been working together over the years because some of the strings attached to Measure C by the college have always been, we could build it. There are certain things we can build. We do not have funding to operate these things. And we'll talk about a whole bunch of programs, but this is one of them. And so what's been happening, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation over the years, and we have a business plan actually that was given to us, wasn't it?

3:08:52 that you helped put together several years ago for Measure U. It was the repertory theater one, most likely. But as a, in other words, to achieve these various steps that are required by the college, they want a program, you know, they want programs in place, things like that, or things leading to a program, and that's one reason why the museum was converted from a museum to a small performing arts center. It's the next step.

3:09:20 Along the way, because what you do, and Shira will tell you it's whatever, you have to build a man. And so you build a man by showing, and so we funded in Measure U, I believe in our very first go-round, I think we funded Shira at 50%, and she started developing programs, and so slowly but surely, in other words, the funding has been directed there because we have been following the intent of Measure U, which said real clearly that, you know,

3:09:48 Performing Arts Center is something the town wants. So this is not fly by night. There's quite a good business plan. Every step that has been taken along the way, I mean, if anything, you've got a lot of reading to do when you meet with Evan because it'll give you a lot of history. This hat, we've got business plans, he's got studies, he's got, and our discussion this morning was that actually the second site

3:10:12 Sam's would benefit by at least the barest beginnings of some of this because we don't even know where the four acres are, where's the line, it's two parcels, what's the cost of each parcel, what's a business plan for it, does it operate just as an event center in the summer or are there park facilities and sliding opportunities and things that could be done in the winter, you know, it meets the

3:10:38 One of our general plan goals, which is to acquire more park space, open space. So, I mean, there are a lot of, we discussed it in terms of, here are two projects. Dan Holler, I think, presented to you guys, but he presented to us how we could have it all if we just used our funds wisely. We could even have that rec center, too, and he talked about that at one of our meetings. I think he did it this one, didn't he? Rec center? I mean, rec commission? Maybe not. He did it the MLR meeting. Oh, he did it the MLR, exactly. So the key is,

3:11:08 is how to move forward. And, you know, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation site, one, land is there, no cost to the town, money is potentially there, and Evan was meeting in Bakersfield yesterday to try to tie some of this together, so if the money to build is there, and the land is there, and there's no cost to the town, this is the ultimate partnership, and what is being asked is the funding for the operations.

3:11:36 Which, you know, as this goes on, will it ever be self-supporting? Probably not, but the subsidies will go down. The studies that he has given, and I know he passed out a booklet to this group about what's been going on in other towns, you know, the wedding facility, all the stuff that can be done. There are great reasons for having it on the foundation site. But lots of information there. So I think if anybody wants to look into it,

3:12:05 Go back and look at Measure C and the fact that there's a lot of money, but that the college cannot build things without operating funds or without programs. And so if they have programs, then they can start getting some state funds as well. So, you know, I mean, there is information there, and I'm sure Bill can tell you. You looked a little further when I referred to one of those things. Maybe I had it misnumbered in my mind. What I was going to say, I think...

3:12:34 Everything you said is accurate. I wanted to clarify for the commission that the grand jury report is on the Mono County Superior Court website. If you go to Mono County, you won't find it. That was on it, too. I'm sorry, Bill. I forgot you. So it's a minor detail, but having initially tried to find grand jury reports on the Mono County site,

3:13:03 Yeah. I think it's monocourt.org. Is that right, Pat? Something like that. We just do superior court. Yeah, yeah. Don't say superior. It's monocourt. But anyway, I think, generally speaking, it's fine. And again, the purpose of my being here is not to lobby for any site or program. I will say that the next steps outlined here are more or less. Whatever site gets done, it's important.

3:13:30 Now when this was originally written we were thinking well we'll sort of do a comprehensive comparison but now that there are now that there are actually specific proposals from or it could be there's one proposal in front of you now and really no competing proposal in terms of an indoor facility but potentially other sites for outdoor to start running through this the indoor one probably doesn't need wind testing yeah

3:13:57 And you have to decide, depending on which outdoor site or sites were coming forward, whether you really wanted to take the time and money to do that. But in any evaluation, you're going to want to have a conceptual plan, you're going to want to have a budget. Most of these things, I don't know that you actually need a fiscal impact analysis. You know, those tend to be a little crystal ball-y anyway. But certainly a business plan,

3:14:29 Potential program so that you can understand, yes, this is what it's going to cost us, and yes, it's what we want to do. Which is fine, and I understand this was from Measure U, I understand it was in there, so I obviously have, you know, I look at the grand jury, but just because doesn't mean that it's a slam dunk. We have to do our due diligence and make sure that everything's in place.

3:14:57 Prior to pulling that final trigger. I don't think anybody's been suggesting otherwise. Yeah. And that's all I'm saying. So anyways, you know, so obviously when there's the land and the money and everything else, if this is what we're looking to do, then that's a great place to start. But we need to look at everything. So anyway. Well, I think that's what we're being asked. Exactly. And I guess that's the only thing I've been saying. So there's, you know, I'm accepting the study.

3:15:25 You know, I accept that, you know, this is what we're looking at, and I think we need to make that decision. And I think changes were made based on the public input to the draft system, so I'm appreciative of that. And one point that I made to the Measure U Committee this morning is that the spreadsheet, the analysis table, we have that in Excel so that

3:15:52 It's available for any of you if you want to look any deeper, change any of the assumptions, it's doable. I think that what the consultants did certainly represented the consensus, not unanimous consensus, but general consensus of all the groups that they met with.

3:16:20 It's a good summary overall. I think you can go in and tweak numbers and you won't change the outcome substantially. You should note that no site was perfect. No such thing. Yeah. I mean, out of whatever, 180 years. Yeah. Yeah. Wouldn't have needed it. No site was perfect. So there are going to be trade-offs no matter which one we pick. Any further questions for Bill? So, yes.

3:16:54 I gotta have you, I know, Wendy, I need you to come all the way up to the, because people need to see you and hear you. It's Wendy with the Mammoth Times. What happens with this study next? I don't know what happens from here, and that was my question. Does it go to the council? Can somebody explain that? Thanks. From my standpoint, it gets accepted, and it gets used as a basis to move forward with specific sites.

3:17:30 It gives us answers to some questions we needed to move forward, helps us to better understand what our options are in terms of recreation and event sites, not recreation, special event, and art sites. Anybody want to add anything to that? You know, it just narrowed the focus as to where we start looking so that we can answer the next questions.

3:17:59 So instead of having, you know, 10 sites that we're still looking at and trying to decide where we're going, it kind of pinpoints it so we can start looking at these and focusing on the next steps and the next questions on these individual sites. And then I think the report also indicates, you know, several steps that we should maybe look at and consider, you know, if it moves forward, then who's involved and how do we go from there and make those recommendations to town council. I do have a question.

3:18:30 Ballpark, do you know how much it might cost to make some infrastructure improvements to the Sam's Wood site? Because you're talking about a 60-foot stage and, you know, things like that. It was in there. Did I overlook that? It seems like we did some back of the napkin analysis a year or two ago. It's in the $500,000 to $1 million range to do electrical.

3:18:58 Infrastructure, a stage, a permanent stage, and that kind of thing. It wasn't, if we're just going to do electrical, significant less, but if it was a permanent facility with a bathroom set up that's permanent and those kinds of things, and that was kind of the back of the napkin. Okay, because I, yeah, because that's, that's for absolutely everything. Yeah, that's for all, that's for,

3:19:21 The thing that I would say with regard to Sam's Woodside is that it is certainly something that could be staged, you know, bite off little chunks that, you know, Mammoth Brewing Company, I've said before that we would be willing to contribute, sign an agreement with the town saying that we contributed a certain amount of money every single year to, if the town acquired it and then we had Palooza Palooza there on an ongoing basis, that we would

3:19:49 contribute, donate some money to that site as long as it went into infrastructure. I can tell you the electricity to that site is very dirty. We must use generators. If I could cut out my budget for a generator to know that I have clean power, there's how I would justify it right there as an events producer. On page 1-12, there are some development cost estimates.

3:20:15 It doesn't specify what those are. Obviously, it's not acquisition. So I'm assuming that's the stage in your infrastructure on the property. Since we're just generally talking about Sandman Woodside at the moment, and I think that's the only current space we have for an outdoor venue. Before we talk about, personally, and this has nothing to do with today's discussion, I'm just bringing it up. Before we talk about putting in a...

3:20:47 Permanent Stage and bringing in clean power and everything else. That site has been developed by people that are in the event business, not by sound engineers and landscape architects. I would love to see a rendering of that place and what its capacity is by professionals in those fields. Because I think, and Sean and I differ on this some, which is a good thing, I think with a slightly different configuration, the one parcel of land can handle his

3:21:17 Project and still keep it at six or seven thousand people by just moving some things around. But again, I'm an amateur as well. So if we're going to move down that road, it would behoove us to first make it a priority, which we have not done yet, and then spend the money if we decide that the town is going to buy that on the necessary planning of the site by people who are in the business of planning for concert venues.

3:21:47 Where do you locate the bathrooms? How do you get your emergency egress? Where does the stage go? Should it be where it is? I don't know the answers to those things. So my next steps on that site would be just that. Are we going to make that our next priority? And then how do we thought that? Who do we get? Where does the RFP go to? So that we can best stage the site. Then we would talk about putting on the permanent

3:22:13 Structures, to build a half a million mountain and a half, to build a stage, it's going to be a couple of hundred thousand dollars at least, with sound systems and everything else to go with it. I would want to make sure we were putting it in the spot where we can accommodate the most people. And I'm not sure that where it is today is that spot. Well, then I think that's why this is asking us to move forward with it further. I think we're getting a little bit ahead of ourselves. Yeah, we're getting ahead of ourselves. I mean, basically, this is saying you

3:22:40 Like Bill said, they want us to accept, you know, do we accept this? You know, I would say yes. Here's the next steps, and this is on anything that we're going to do. And the next steps are spelled out here. Conceptual planning of proposed building programs, wind testing of sites, construction cost estimating, economic and fiscal impact analysis, strategic operating and organizational recommendations, funding planning. And then the question is, is who does this? Is it done by the town? Is it done by staff, rec commission, blue ribbon committee?

3:23:09 Other, and you know, maybe those are the comments and the suggestions that, you know, because I think we do need to look into these, but we, you know, the first next step is as the Parks Commission priorities to determine if buying a piece of property for events is our next top priority with the funding available, be it R or you, I don't care. We have not made that decision yet.

3:23:42 Or looking in a broader spectrum, maybe that site is, is not just a summer venue. Maybe it could be used during other times of the year, it could be just a park. Yeah, yeah, yeah, absolutely. Because the master plan and probably the general plan too says that we need to apply a more parks area, could it be anything like that? Absolutely. First, someone in the town has to decide that we're going after that property.

3:24:07 Now, does this go in tandem with the Verde design effort that we're moving forward? Because we are looking at Sam's Wood site, and we are looking at Sam's Wood site. We won't check, so we had it on our floor, but it is not one of the five parks we're looking at. We've locked it so we can see them. You're right. They isn't available as a park. Lot lines. Okay, moving on from there, Bill, thank you, sir, for your patience. Thank you all very much. Well, just to clarify, you know, it

3:24:38 Our recommendation is that staff is looking for consensus direction regarding the next steps. Do we want to provide any direction with regard to what the next steps are as outlined here? Because if these are them, I'd actually like to make a couple of changes. Okay. Okay. I'm not sure if we need a conceptual planning of proposed building programs at this time. The wing testing might be great just so that we do have some kind of...

3:25:05 Proof that Sam's Woodside is less windy than Canyon Lodge or other locations. I don't think we need that. To me, the question here is, what is the town-owned and operated venue going to look like? From my own sensibilities, that precludes it from being a mountain facility. Because that will never be town-operated and it will never be town-owned. If it's going to be mountain-controlled, they're going to decide who goes there.

3:25:35 And they are going to have all food and alcohol concessions. That keeps it from being such an attractive site to me. Maybe I'm wrong. So, I mean, you kind of stopped me during the wind testing, but just because I brought up the Canyon Lodge location, and I don't know, you know, I can tell you right now just anecdotally that Sam's is probably going to have the lowest of the wind testing.

3:25:59 Okay. I don't know if we need any kind of proof of that, just so that if anyone ever questions us. So you're right, I don't know how expensive a wind testing would be. I guess the things that I really wanted to add or change with regard to next steps is finding out what the acquisition and cost estimating would be. Because in the case of Sam's Wood Site, and the second location is owned by, and I'm

3:26:27 Blanking on the guy's name right now, but it is two different lots. And I would like to find out there is a strategic way of acquiring that property if we choose to go that way. Sam has said that he is willing to be creative. It's not that we would need to outright go and buy it. So there is some opportunities there to work with the current owners, and I'll leave it like that, to come up with a cost structure that the town can afford on an ongoing basis. Yeah, I'm going to...

3:26:56 Hold us up here for a minute. I'm sorry. Good. So the conversation we're now having is how to move forward with this, which isn't on our agenda. No, it is. It's asking us for a consensus on the next steps. Yeah. He's suggesting some additional next steps. I am. And, you know, I'll say that I like the last three bullets there. But the last thing that I would like to include there is that, and I'm not sure the best way to phrase this, but...

3:27:25 The Lake Mary Bike Path terminates right there at Main and Minaret. I sure would like to see it turn south and run right down in front of Sam's Wood Site. So if we're talking about acquiring Sam's Wood Site, wouldn't it be great to connect the Lake Mary Bike Path all the way down with Snow Creek with where the bike path starts up again? And that would be... We'd finish the town loop. We'd finish the town loop. So I guess what I'm proposing here is can we look at other benefits in acquiring that?

3:27:54 Location, I don't know, maybe Peter can speak to that. But can we look at other benefits that would come along in acquiring that site? In that particular segment of path is in our current plan and the proposed plan to have it a class one bike path between Snow Creek and Lake Murray. Okay, so it's already in the plan. Well, that's in the trail system master plan too, isn't it? Is it in the trail system or is it in the bike?

3:28:25 Wade. It's in a bikeway and pedestrian plan as well. I mean, talk about that would add quite a bit of the transportation element to elevating the feasibility of Sam's Wood Site being an events location. So we have the indoor events facility as a priority and we have an outdoor events facility as a priority. If the outdoor event facility is going to look to be at the foundation,

3:28:55 Then I would say you absolutely need a wind test. If there's going to be any food vendors or any vendors outside of the indoor facility, I think you need a wind test. Because I know that I was out there at the Jazz Festival and it was pretty miserable trying to eat or deal with any type of food outside, out there. Where it's being proposed is more down in a hole, but I don't know. So maybe wind testing is still beneficial either way.

3:29:24 Maybe there's some area that it'd be better to put your vendors in than another. I don't know. But I have no idea how expensive a wind test is. I don't think the issue with a wind test, I'm not sure the issue is so much cost as it is time. If you have a proposal in front of you that's time sensitive, you aren't going to have the answer to a wind test.

3:29:54 until probably sometime in September at the earliest. I guess if that's important, that's still, you know, I have a hard time. You know, you've got the proposal in front of you, but you jump off that cliff just because it's in front of you. You need to make sure that you're jumping wisely. And I think what you need to look at comprehensively is you're going to win tests every site, even the ones that are, you know, score lower for other reasons.

3:30:26 Or, for instance, if we're talking about one outdoor facility and we're only looking at two sites, and let's say that we're only looking at the foundation site and Sam's Woods, we already know which one's going to have lower wind speeds. There isn't anybody who has... On the other hand, if we were looking at multiple outdoor sites, and let's say one of them is Mammoth Creek Park East, there's no empirical...

3:30:56 Experience there because there's been no activity there. We can guess, but if we were trying to weigh, say, the foundation site against Mammoth Creek Park East, then you might want to do a wind study because you've got two sites that are potentially both windy. So, this list, I don't think you should assume that every item on the list applies to every site and every development proposal. If all you're talking about is a small outdoor

3:31:27 Festival site. Maybe you tolerate the wind. If you're looking at something larger that's going to be running in the evenings, maybe you don't. So I think try to step back from the list and look at it and say, okay, given the proposal in front of us, do we need this information? Rather than just going out and getting it randomly. So for instance, when you look at the proposal coming

3:31:54 forward for the foundation. So you might look at it and say, well, maybe we want to fund this component, but we're not sure about that component until we've tested the wind. That's what I said. If it's an indoor, then you're not having that issue. If we're looking at that as being the all-inclusive and outdoor as well, then that wind study would need to be done. Is it tolerable? And that's why I said what you need to do is look at the proposal and weigh the options that you're looking for right now.

3:32:24 Given the size of the site that they're talking about outdoors and the kind of capacities that Palooza Palooza needs, you're not talking about one site, you're talking about two. Keep that in mind. This wasn't supposed to be a one-size-fits-all solution. Yeah, I view the college site, if there's an outdoor piece there, it's going to be a small piece. Outdoor theater kind of piece. The land isn't available and the windward will have it.

3:32:56 For that to be a big outdoor site. I'm looking at that tent, that sprung structure as an indoor primary facility with a stage that faces the back as well so that they can have small outdoor plays. This is what I'm saying. Even if it's indoor, then you don't need to do a Wednesday. If it's going to be outdoor, then that's when you need to. I think it's two different facilities. So the next steps to me are,

3:33:24 We're going through and have gone through a prioritization process. When do we stand up and say this is or isn't our priority? And what step is it appropriate for us to tell council and staff that we'd like to see an application come through for the wood site or we have decided that the rec center is a more important piece and we want to see that come forward first?

3:33:57 You know, both of those, you need more information. I mean, we can say this is a priority, but before it floats to the top, you need more information. Well, we do, and I'm just, I'm wondering, Bill, if this group of people on page two, you know, would be willing to continue as sort of, you know, a panel to delve more into these questions. You're talking about page two of the study? No, I'm talking about page two of our report that, you know, just lists the people that, you know, met initially and really delved into this.

3:34:29 Well, that's another question I had, too, because the Recreation Commission is not represented on that committee, which maybe was an oversight. Well, Sean and I were supposed to be on it. I don't know. I don't know how much Sean, I was invited to one meeting. I don't know how much Sean was on. I don't remember even getting that invite, but I know you attended one of the meetings early on and then met with the consultants separately.

3:35:02 As far as the second meeting, I think that basically your input wound up coming from this body to the consultant rather than in the other group. But we made sure that both at their initial visit and at their second visit that they had the opportunity to try to touch everybody that was affected, whether it was in the subcommittee or elsewhere. Thank you, Bill. I'm confusing my meetings.

3:35:34 I guess I'm just thinking that, you know, maybe, you know, do we think it's worth, you know, convening, you know, a group to, you know, to delve into some of this? If we have a question for you, I'm not sure until I know whether or not this is going to be our priority, that I'm willing to go much further down. I mean, the next steps here are fine, but we keep taking the next steps and we keep gathering more information. At some point in time, we have a stop and say, here's our decision. We want this site or we want a rec center.

3:36:03 Or we want to put in the bank. At some point, we just have to stop and make that decision. I don't know when that point is. We need to finish our priorities. We need to finish our priorities. Well, and I think it would be helpful, too, because we'll be talking about, you know, slating a rec center through our parks, you know, master planning process, too. So if those two things happen concurrently, that might help us make that decision. So at this point, I think we need to get through that process and then come back and revisit our prioritization process.

3:36:33 And determine what we can afford, can't afford, and make the hard decision to move it forward. And by that time it may not be us making that hard decision, it may be MLRs. It's kind of ironic, though, that we've been hinging all of our hopes on this study, and now we have it, and now we're still, you know, stumbling through this. There's just a lot of information that's not there. I mean, as far as narrowing down a site, it's done that.

3:36:59 Beyond that, there's, as far as numbers and as far as, you know, there's some other information that's needed to move forward. For me, this gives me enough information to move forward in my mind with my own, you know, knowledge or lack thereof to make a decision on entertainment and cultural event facilities. To me, the question still is, in our prioritization, does this come before a rec center? I know how I feel about it, but...

3:37:30 As a group, we have to make that decision. We have to prioritize out for recreation, which this is part of. Well, we need some numbers, because, I mean, I want both. But, you know, we need more information. We don't have enough information. We need to certain, you know, I don't know. Go back to what Dan said. Dan Holler, our manager.

3:37:51 You know, if we work strategically, we could maybe have it all. And maybe not all ten things on that list. But, you know, we can... And dance comments were great, and we've heard that from town staff before when we were being presented with a $30 million rec center. The fact is I'm a lot more skeptical than that. Yes, can we find ways to build this all? Absolutely we can. But here's what I know. A $30 million rec center is going to cost a couple hundred thousand dollars a year in subsidy.

3:38:17 Each one of these arts centers is going to take another $100,000 a year in subsidy because they do every place else. The ice rink is going to continue to take $100,000 a year in subsidy because they do everywhere else. At what point? And so how important is something that it reaches the top in terms of how much subsidy? The town can afford to build them because we can go out and get loans. We can do a lot of things. I don't believe the town, unless we grow a whole lot more, can afford to...

3:38:46 Operate all these different structures. So we have to decide which is more important for the people and the economy and set our priorities based on that. Because we can't operate them all. Nobody can be all things all the time. I understand that, but maybe even Measure R and Measure U monies don't necessarily all have to go towards the operation. It talks about the maintenance of facilities.

3:39:12 So maybe it's not the operation, the programming, the staffing, things like that, or maybe it's a percentage, or, you know, there's still, you know, lots of what-ifs. Those are the questions that need to be answered before you... I agree. No, I'm not saying that, hey, yeah, look, tomorrow we're going to, you know, buy the wood site and make that recommendation, or we're going to, you know, have a sperm structure built.

3:39:33 But I think we need to get off the dime and move in some direction instead of just saying, oh, let's study, let's think about it a little bit more. Let's move. And I think that's where, you know, this commission needs to get its priorities finished. And I think what Betsy was saying, and that's maybe this is the Blue Ribbon Committee, and it includes Measure Review Committee, it includes Rec Commission, and it includes, you know, the folks that are going to be dealing with those facilities.

3:40:02 And maybe that blue ribbon committee answers some of these other questions and actually looks at the center information and brings it back. Well, and one thing I think you do need to keep in mind is that there may be pressure sooner rather than later to make a decision on performing arts facility. So there's two things you'll want to know. One is obviously what it's going to cost you and what it is. And if it's consistent with

3:40:32 The goals and policies you've already set and if it looks like it works. The next thing is, what can you still do? You probably aren't going to have a pro forma for a rec center in front of you when the proposal for the performing arts facility comes forward. You aren't going to have a pro forma for Sam's Woods. You aren't going to have a pro forma for the field house.

3:41:03 There's going to be a decision that has to be made before you have the details from the others. So you're going to have to say, what's the comfort level? How much information do I need to have with regard to other funds and other possibilities in order to be comfortable making this decision now? Because if you say no, it goes away. But then you leave the door open for something else. If you say yes,

3:41:33 You may, in fact, foreclose some other option. Absolutely. And so recognizing that you won't have full detail on everything, how much information are you going to be able, are you going to need to make a recent decision? That's going to be the challenge. So let's go back to our NLR discussion. What's the gain and what do we forego? And that's, you know, that is something that we need to look at. We don't have enough information in this.

3:42:03 And then just to frame what the town manager was discussing about the rec center and having it all, essentially the rec center that he was kind of conceiving was a smaller multi-phase project which is a 15,000 square foot building that has kind of a gym area and an adjacent meeting room area and then another phase that has more meeting room area and another phase that has a pool. So it's the incremental

3:42:33 Approach, because we can never afford a $30 million facility without doing another bond issue. But doing it incrementally, you get a piece, and then you get another piece. But my question is still the same, and the question never gets answered. What is the carrying capacity of the town of Mammoth Lake in terms of overhead maintenance? Even with R&U thrown into the mix, with what we expect our final population to be and everything else, and what the tax situations are, and what it costs to run a government,

3:43:03 I don't know that I see the town of Mammoth Lakes ever having the money to operate all of these facilities. So we have to prioritize which one of these facilities is going to be the biggest bang for the buck, not just in terms of money return, although that's very important, but in terms of sense of community, in terms of, you know, kids and the whole nine yards. At some point, those figures are more important to me than the cost of building it, because we can always build something.

3:43:29 I can go tomorrow and buy a brand new car. I just can't make the payments. Well, how about this? Because Verity Design, they're bringing their presentation to council on June the 18th. Why can't we concurrently finish up our priority exercise? And in the meantime, we're listing it during these charrettes to what the community is saying. And we're compiling it all together in our minds. And then we kind of come to fruition.

3:43:59 As we get into early, and maybe our June meeting, to figure out kind of what our priorities are, and then they go to council on the 18th. And then so at least then we kind of know, and it's going to be something that's maybe in black and white, but it's going to change. It could evolve. It could be, you know, something new could come along that's... You can have your priorities, and maybe arts and culture is fifth on the list, but if somebody comes forward with that, then you have to say, okay...

3:44:29 Does that float to the top? And if it floats to the top, what are we not going to be able to do because we're going to say that it floats to the top? There's always going to be that what if. You just kind of have to take it as it comes. At this point, I guess we say, I don't know, I still go back to we accept this, knowing that a proposal is going to come forward. We do our due diligence in finding the information that's out there, I guess, and read that so that we're

3:44:59 You know, knowledgeable when it comes forward. And then we work on our priorities. I really do need to finish that priority thing. Seems like we're really close. I don't think it's going to be that difficult, really. I know in my head. So I guess what staff would be seeking is a motion to accept, obviously, the feasibility study and any recommendations for next steps, right? Because when this goes to council, you can accept it. And then these are the reparations commissions.

3:45:28 Recommended next steps for this physical study. There we go. I think that's a good way to kind of move it forward, showing that you're proactive. And so far we've got acquisition costs for Sam's Woodside. We've got the Town Bike Path connection, which we've talked about. And then we've also got those other items that we talked about as well. And if there's a recommendation to kind of form this or continue to kind of have this subcommittee meet or whoever that composition is that meeting, that might be a good way to kind of keep it going too. But it's going to get to a point where

3:45:57 Council are going to probably, you know, lead this and hopefully seek some direction from Commission. So if you're being proactive with that, I think that'll be a good first step. And if I could just comment, our action this morning was to accept the report and to agendize for discussion the, actually, it was the next steps involving acquisition of the Sam's Wood site or any other site because the Performing Arts

3:46:27 Application is, has already been accepted, 25,000, and we know that another 80,000 will be coming up, depending on time frames, discussions with Bakersfield, whatever, so that is something that is in progress, and that's within the purview of the Measure U Committee. So basically, our discussion may help, you know, inform you guys' discussion too, but it gets really kind of hard to think about the next steps, you know, and you're...

3:46:57 The meeting keeps running on and on and on. And so we felt like, let's accept the report, realize there's time to agendize and discuss the next steps. It doesn't have to go to council. I mean, we've waited this long. It doesn't have to go to council next month, you know. It gives you a little more time to think about it. But that's all. I think there's general consensus that we accept the report. So if you need a motion to that, then I would make a motion that we accept the report. Correct.

3:47:26 I will second that. Can we just add that we will accept the report, and yes, we want to continue moving forward without defining what those steps are at this time, so that we know we tend to continue moving this ball forward. Well, if you're going to do that, then I would like to also add that we will be reviewing our priorities currently. I think that let's kind of keep it clean right now, and if we accept the report. Because we're going to do those other things anyway. We accept the report.

3:47:55 And, you know, as far as, you know, moving forward, I think we do need to make those, I guess I'm still not comfortable, yes, I know that Measure U was put forward to pay for these things, but until I have numbers, and I have a business plan in front of me, and I have, you know, something in front of me that tells me, yes, we can do this. I mean, we can say that Measure U was put out there to do this, but if it's unreasonable and it's something that we can't do, then...

3:48:21 You know, I don't know. Then we need to look. Are there other partners? Or, you know, what are our other options? I don't think anybody's disagreeing with that. Yeah. So anyway, so I guess I'm willing to accept this as the study that comes forward. I have a motion and a second still. More discussion? Well, could we have the motion say that, you know, we move to accept the report and simply to move forward with further evaluation? That's what I suggested. Sure. Oh, sorry.

3:48:54 Are you amending it to say that? Yes. Are you amending your second? I have an amended motion and second. Any further discussion? Do we want to put a timeline to that? I don't think so. It's kind of nebulous. It is. You know, I guess that, you know, I was looking at doing in this too. Say, accept the report and then let's decide what the next steps are. Are we looking at putting this committee together to, you know, pull some of this information? What are, you know?

3:49:23 There has to be something that brings this information back in. This is step one, and I think you're already on step four or five when wanting a business plan and things like that. I think step two is for us to formalize our priority exercise and where we think that we should be heading so that we're all on the same page and then certainly more steps are needed beyond that.

3:49:48 My understanding that we're already beyond that in steps with the Cultural Center. So I guess I would like to have some more information since it appears to be beyond step two. And I would say that the next thing that we absolutely need to do is finish our priorities. That's number one step as far as I can see. Yes. Maybe there's actually two motions. That's what I was thinking. The first one would be focused on the report and simply say accept the report and you could, if you want to elaborate, say,

3:50:18 to be used as background information to inform further deliberations. Something like that. So it's just about the report. It's not about anything else. And then if you want to say anything more about what you want to do next, that's a separate question. That's what I was trying to do originally. So anyways. Okay.

3:50:42 I still have an amended motion and a second. Do we wish to re-amend the amended motion? No, I'm okay with how it was stated. Do we have any further discussion? So we're accepting the report or we're adding the report? We are accepting the report. No, you have a little bit more. With further evaluation. We're accepting the report and moving it forward. Forward to the next step. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Aye.

3:51:14 Do we want to do more on this subject? Now, there was talk about perhaps a second motion. And I think we can agendize the master planning of the parks and this in our next agenda. I think that I would like to say that we need to, in our next meeting, bring our priorities back. Yes. Absolutely. We've got to bear it down and make some

3:51:45 Decisions. And if we need specific information, then we need to be very specific about what that information is and work with staff to get it. And I'll call Evan and I will make a meeting because I still think that this has moved beyond and it's already in motion. So it sounds like it's a foregone conclusion. It's not a foregone conclusion. We don't even know if the college is going to allow the money from Measure C to be used.

3:52:13 He was meeting, I think, yesterday with him to try and get some determination. So we don't even know if that doesn't happen, then it dies for a second, if you will. Okay. Well, and I guess that's what I was referring to probably earlier is because he did state that. Right. No, he's still looking to see if Measure C will fund it and what those parameters are, and then he's going to bring us back that result with a request for whatever funds would be required for Measure U to carry it forward.

3:52:42 If they will fund it. If they won't fund it, it just dies. Okay. Okay, so I'm moving on to manager's report. You all have the written report. You've all looked at it. Stu, do you need to further entertain us with the report? Are we good? No, but Pete does have some entertaining voice. Okay. Pete, entertain us then. Well, first, before we go to Pete, any of you have questions on the manager's report?

3:53:11 I do want to say that the ice rink, all those details for the ice rink will be in front of you in April. So that will be on the agenda. If you have no questions, then I'm going to let me entertain us with his manager's report. So the MAP-21 legislation now is within California and it's called the Active Transportation Program. There will be several rent opportunities coming up and so the Commission can think about those and we'll bring an item back.

3:53:43 for recommended projects at the next meeting, or at least better support for the projects. One of them is the Recreational Trails Program, which might work to construct a trail between Minaret and Meridian. That would be one option for that. The Safe Routs to School Program, they've increased the radius to two miles within the school, and so there may be some opportunities to do some sidewalks on Main Street, the gaps that we've got in Main Street.

3:54:13 And then the BTA grant program is another one. And that one, we're looking at, you know, finishing gap closures. Essentially, we've got most of those done, but there'll be some opportunities for that. There really isn't funding for townwide wayfinding and that kind of project. Essentially, what we're finding is there really isn't grant funds for that kind of a

3:54:42 Overall signage system. There's certainly signage programs for bikeways and pedestrians are available, but not for overall traffic. So, some, you know, just a little information so the commissioners can think about projects that they might see that are needed, and all these projects will have a funding match of 10%, so. Yeah, you know, maybe I missed this when we first started speaking because I was looking at something else. Okay, we already...

3:55:12 Receive these grants? Or these are grants we've applied for? These are grants that we'll apply for. Essentially there'll be a double. There wasn't a cycle last year because it took so long to get to legislation. The rules written regarding the legislation. So there'll be two cycles they'll be funding. We think that we are poised to compete well. We're just finishing up the bikeway plan, pedestrian plan. And most counties are behind that curve, counties and cities.

3:55:41 So the projects on Main Street essentially would be partnering with Caltrans for those projects. We've had initial discussions with them and they're supportive of gap closures. And when will we know whether these are? So we bring back an item, a staff report for the next meeting. They'll be due, I believe, at the end of May.

3:56:05 For the application. For the actual application. When would they be awarded? They'll be awarded by the end of the fiscal year, which should be June. I don't know if they'll actually get them awarded by June, but I think that's our goal. It'll certainly be done by September. That's great about the Safe Routes to School increasing to two miles. Yeah, because we were basically built out of all the Safe Routes to School projects within the half mile.

3:56:33 Is the bikeway plan online that we could take a look at it? It is online. We've got a little link there. We're receiving comments on the bikeway plan, the pedestrian master plan, so if you just want to click into those links, it will take you to that page, and you can add your comments or review the plan. We're kind of fast-tracking it so we get it adopted before the grant period's while it's still open. Any questions for Pete? Anything else, Pete? No?

3:57:06 Moving on to Commissioner's Reports. Pat? I'll just remember we're going to the state conference tomorrow, and I'll be on the lookout for things for the department in the town, and there's actually a workshop on the Los Angeles Parks Foundation, which kind of is a similar structure to MLR, and I'm going to try to connect with them to learn more about it. I've looked at them online, and it's kind of interesting.

3:57:34 What's that one called? Los Angeles Parks Foundation. And then there's also LA County has a Parks Foundation. But this one appears to be more viable. So I'll give you guys an update. That sounds great. Putting together an auction package that Mammoth Lakes Tourism has contributed merchandise for, hopefully, Mammoth Lakes Brewing Company to. And just to kind of promote it to all of the, I think there are a couple thousand,

3:58:03 Delegates that will be there. They'll bid on it and then come up to Mammoth and experience it. And no report. It was really great when I was over at Mammoth Lakes Tourism yesterday for the MLR meeting. I've updated you all on that meeting. But it was really great to see so many people going out to use the trails at Shady Rest, and I'm hoping to get out there for the next day or two. And you ate.

3:58:34 Thank you for the cookies. Remember to go on the Mammoth Trails website and look for all those new trails, the new 190 different pages. I'm sorry, that's good. It's good. It's just adding. It's a good thing. With that, I'll accept a motion. I'll move to adjourn. I'll second it.

3:59:04 I got a motion, a second, further discussion. Those in favor? Aye. Aye. And I wish all a motion to vote to be that easy. And if it's you and I... So it's going to be a focus? So it's...