Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014
Parks & Recreation Commission Formation meeting
· recording 2 hr 55 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
416 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Those boys were heroes. Here? All right. We'll open it up for any comments from the public. Any items on the agenda today? Any public comments? I'm looking at the public. Any comments? Okay. Just as a reminder, this meeting is being recorded and will be able to be replayed and viewed via...
0:32 Grannicus on the town's website. So just a reminder to everybody, when you are speaking and you are addressing the committee, I encourage you to speak up loudly so that the microphones can capture the comments and that we can do very clearly. Yeah. Come on and off as you need to. No, this one's on in the opposite direction.
0:56 So let's move into item number one, the acceptance of our notes from the meeting of March 3rd. Are there any comments or discussion about our minutes from March 3rd? We want a motion? Move to approve. I'll second that. Terry? Move and second to accept our notes from our March 3rd meeting. Any discussion? Okay, all those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Great.
1:26 Number two on our item is an introduction of Sharon Judicy. So we've had a change in staffing for this effort and for the town. Missy needed to change her priorities, and so the town has retained the services of Sharon Judicy.
1:47 who will be staffed for us as well as for the town's recreation department as the summer ramps up. Unfortunately, Sharon's not here, wasn't able to join us today. I'm sure she's thrilled and excited when her time comes. She's actually very excited. She was in last week for a couple days doing stuff. She's had a brace, one knee, her scheme, so she's in there for, I think she went in for physical therapy this weekend and now it's like...
2:11 We can speak for her level of excitement. So she'll be joining us. She will be who we will receive our agendas from and any communications. So she'll be our admin staff support as we move forward. And Judacy is how we pronounce her last name. Any questions about that? Yes? I just have one question. I know that the council should have come from the contingency fund.
2:41 But then the notes as before said it was coming from the rec funds. I'm just wondering if it's coming from the contingency fund. It's contingency. And their budget is way of tracking it someplace in the town. But it's still the same dollars from the contingency fund, just where we placed it to actually charge it. Good. You put $5,000 in the record. Got to move up. Great. Okay. We'll move to item number three. This is going to be a report from the most recent Recreation Commission meeting that was held.
3:09 Where apparently MLR was on the agenda or became a topic on the agenda or they're moved into some additional discussion. So we're going to turn it over to Betsy and Teri to provide us with an update on that meeting and any issues that were brought up or addressed as a part of that meeting. Well, MLR is a standing agenda item for us to provide updates and to just discuss what's going on.
3:36 The last Recreation Commission meeting, probably the primary focus was that a lot of the commissioners are very unhappy with the suspension measures R and U, and they're not totally convinced that we'll have NLR up and running by what would have been the fall cycle. So just a lot of concerns about that. I think just maybe because not all the commissioners have been at all these meetings,
4:06 I think just a little of some misunderstandings. And one of the things that the commissioners asked for was to maybe have a joint meeting between the commission and our committee. And then I see today that there's going to be a meeting between Rick, Joe, the commission, MLTSCC, and also the Measure Review Committee. Do you want to address that at this point? Or as this is a part of the conversation that this recommendation came to be?
4:37 Sorry. Yeah, she's addressing the committee. I think it might be better addressed under outreach. Okay. But, or we can talk about that now. What do you think, Rick? Either way. You can mention it now, I think, just in terms of the, one of the issues coming back, some concerns and where we're at and status of that coming out of the Rec Commission and the request has been to bring all the commissions together and do it one time versus doing it three or four times, so.
5:00 And essentially since the comment, you know, since we are the council members, it wasn't, you know, everybody else is obviously welcome to come, but we thought it was our responsibility to help them understand what council direction had been and answer any of the questions they've got. And I have to apologize. I actually had two meetings at that time, so I wasn't at the Rec Commission when that was being spoken of. I was at the workshop with the Measure U Committee and the Measure R Committee earlier. And, you know, there's just a,
5:30 I think that there's just, they would like a little bit more definition and explanation as to why it was suspended, and I think that that can be done at that joint meeting, and I thank you guys for doing that. Well, we hope it's going to be productive, and it will be informative. So, can I just, let's add a little bit of protocol for this meeting as we move forward. The committee and...
5:57 Correct me if I'm wrong. The committee, when we get to an agenda item, we will have a discussion about the item and debate and discussion among ourselves. And then I'll turn to the public to get some asked questions or any comments you might want to share. But as the committee is going through its effort, I'm not going to break away for public interaction at that point. I'd like to allow the committee to do its work, and then we'll come back to the committee.
6:23 Public? So is that okay with everybody so we understand the protocol, how we're going to conduct our business here? So if there's no other conversation about this among the committee, Teri and Betsy, was there anything else that you wanted to share about that meeting? Unless you guys have questions. Unfortunately, I was there. I actually realized, found out later, that there was even a vote that was taken because it wasn't on our agenda to do anything like that. It was just actually an MLR update. So I was surprised that there was anything that was even voted on.
6:50 Kind of taken back. And I, you know, so I don't know, and I wasn't there. I think the other major concern that was expressed was just sort of a fear that, you know, that what could happen, especially in this sort of interim period, is that, you know, council members or town staff members could potentially, you know, bring forward applications, you know, for measures R&U, and then the public wouldn't necessarily have that opportunity.
7:16 I think that was just a concern that was expressed by some of the commission members. Kind of a go around it. But if everything's suspended, then nothing's coming forward, whether it's from the town or anybody else, is my assumption. And can we maybe clarify that a little bit? And obviously you're two of the five council members, but the action that was taken by the council, I believe in what we received, is that they were suspending the application process for R&U.
7:44 As MLR was moving to formation. Well, it was part of one option, and I'm sorry, I didn't bring my old notes today, but it was suspend, get the reconciliation done, and a couple of other things all went together. Right. So I'm just, and I'm not remembering the exact wording off the top of my head. Right. And we continue to make clarification that some of the ongoing projects that have funding pieces would continue. Right, yeah. And you've got three or four projects out there that have. So if you look back to the agenda building. Thank you.
8:13 Well, I think that's an important point, which is that we didn't arbitrarily suspend. There was a reason for the suspension. There were two that come to mind. We had a discussion about it, first of which is, just as Joe has explained, that is to provide the opportunity for, in essence, accounting, reconciliation of that which has been spent and what we've received for it. And the second is that we saw a council
8:42 From my perspective, saw no reason to have parallel processes. If we're going down a road here and the committees are going down a parallel road, it didn't make a whole lot of sense. I also think it's a great opportunity for us to, you know, consider it important enough to hurry it along so that we don't get bogged down in this process for a year or two, such as has been the case with other committees.
9:07 So I have that language really quick. Just to reiterate, it was to suspend the Measure R&U award process, complete the financial reconciliation, define the current maintenance obligations, and without limiting the completion of all current funding awards. So I think there was a lot of leeway in there, but the whole idea was that there was a lot of work that needed to be done, particularly on the reconciliation side, so that if there's going to be a discussion,
9:36 about the funding of MLR through RNU, it would seem to be very helpful to have what balance is remaining based on the reconciliation of what has already been awarded, what has been completed, and what the balance actually looks like. And I thought that that was pretty prudent of the Council to make that recommendation and decision.
9:59 It seemed to be pretty clear. Well, the last thing I'll say about that is that I don't and didn't that night expect that those who would be impacted by the vote would be happy. Change is difficult. Fear is rampant. So I respect and recognize what the reaction is. Joe and I have talked about it and have decided that the best way to address that is for the two of the five council members who voted on it.
10:28 Go to those groups and the great thing is that it will be all at once instead of three times and explain our vote and let everybody know what the process is and what we expect as the two council members who are driving this particular agenda. We'll give people an opportunity to ask questions if they still have questions. And that's why I said outreach. It's just we know that under outreach there will be several questions that are going to be from those groups so we do approach it as outreach. I have a question.
10:58 You mentioned something about a vote that the commission made. Does somebody have to address whatever that vote was as far as rescinding whatever the action was of the council? I wasn't there, so I don't show them at all. And I tried to listen, and the microphones were bad. You couldn't hear it. So I hope they did take a vote on something that wasn't agendized.
11:25 Recall the precise wording of the motion. I think it was something along the lines of being concerned with the council's action and just wanting to make the council aware of that, but I don't remember the exact wording. I'd have to go back and watch. As you said, it's almost impossible to hear. Any other questions for Betsy and Teri about the Recreation Commission meeting?
11:55 Okay. Is there any public comment about that? Pat, you had your hand in. Thank you. The Commission was concerned about the process and how it does not. And so I do have actually a copy of the motion. And it says the Commission supports the ongoing discussion of the plan of rights recreation. However, the Commission strongly requests the reinstatement that shows our annual award process.
12:23 So as to provide continuity of the vetted process and reduce public perception of measures, view and arguments, misappropriation. And I think some of it resulted from the earlier workshop that I had with the measure review committee. And actually in the recommendation that came that was endorsed by the council, there was really no time frame associated with that particular meeting.
12:51 Pat, could you speak a little bit to the Recreation Commission's thought that a suspension is parallel to a misappropriation somehow? Can you just kind of explain that a little bit further?
13:30 That the suspension would cause the spending not to be used? But if it's suspended, there's no expenditure going on, so I'm not sure how that happens, and I certainly wasn't there, so I don't know what the intent was.
14:14 Thanks. No, I'm just going to say is that Pat, would you please make sure that staff has a copy of that motion? I'm the note taker today, so. Oh, of course. I got it from Jamie. Okay. So we can get it from Jamie. Oh, sorry. She has it. She has it. Okay. If Jamie has it, okay. Okay. Any other? Yes. One extra. We have the one extra.
14:45 Any other Terry, Betsy, anything else you want to report from the Recreation Commission? Well, I think just a big part of that concern came out of the workshop that we had with the Measure U Committee because they have been
15:13 They acted on a Measure U award request from the foundation potentially moving forward with an events site. So I think they were just concerned because I think they were maybe expecting to have some additional requests for funding coming from that particular project. So I'm just curious, is there a stopgap in place that is, I guess, taking...
15:40 Taking the suspension to heart and that nothing is happening, is that? If it's an ongoing project, the project is out there, we will bring that forward accordingly. If it's something brand new, then that would not be brought forward through that process. What's the definition of an ongoing project? It's like we have the funding for the trails group that has $300,000 a year going to it that gets allocated in two different pieces. I don't think there was any intent to say you only get your first piece and the second piece is not going to be awarded.
16:10 We have a trail project. It's under construction. It's probably going to be short funding. It's an awarded project. Do we not build it? Or do we come in and say, hey, it's short on funding. Two examples off the top of my head. The performing arts program has the first set of dollars that have been allocated. They haven't been spent yet. I doubt that piece of the project would be done by the next round of wherever this is up with MLR or down the way.
16:42 And I don't think there would be anything that prevent that type of any of those moves coming in the city council, town council asking, hey, can you take a look at this? And I've got to go back through the process. Okay, so the protocol is that if there's a current project that's underway.
16:59 And it has run into a situation that it needs additional funding and it feels that R&U is the appropriate place for that funding to come from. They have the ability to come to the council during the suspension and ask for... But it would go back through the commission process because the commission has to recommend stuff and review it. For example, the commission set aside dollars for trails in park for a grant match. And the council agreed to add sitting down and observe it. So it's not appropriate or allocated for that purpose. It was identified as a...
17:29 Potential need, I would suggest that would need to go back to the commission to say, okay, we do have the grant, we need the match, are you still recommending the use of that? But that wasn't approved use of reserves already, but it's not formally allocated. That should be identified within the reconciliation that they're doing. Yeah, we'll have that, it'll be highlighted in the reserves, but because it's not an approved project by the commission, the suggestion would be that we would take it back through that process.
17:57 And just for the openness of that and saying, yes, we got the grant, yes, is that still the wish of the commission for that approval? Yeah, but through the reconciliation process, we should identify anything that's there, you know, because we have applied for the grant and that was, you know, that was identified and the grant was put through that that money would be available. So anyhow, so even though it hasn't been...
18:21 I would say that's an ongoing process because the way it was defined. That should be determined with, that should be labeled within the reconciliation that this is a possible use of. So you have that type of process. Okay, but even still, the Commission and the Measure U Committee make recommendations to the Council.
18:39 for funding approval. So would that still happen also? Because under the current ordinances, it has to have that review and there's a recommendation. Now the council doesn't have to accept the recommendation, but there's a recommendation. So you have to follow the process. I think the goal was there, you don't have a whole bunch of other folks coming in or new projects coming in or things, hey, we want to tie up a bunch of funding.
19:03 Putting now the whole process in kind of a... So that's my question. Where is that stopgap occurring? It's not. If there's something brand new coming at this point, we have to set up a process to address that. Anybody can come in a public comment at the town council and say we want to do X and we can take direction for it. But there's not a formal process to take something on to submit. There was the discussion with the Measure U and our committees at the workshop, and the workshop was specifically for...
19:33 What that might be is if there was an emergency that came up, that there was funding, that there was a project that was short or something happened, what that process would be moving forward since everything had been suspended. And so there were some sideboards that were put up on a suggestion that I believe was going to come to council. Is that like a definition of what an emergency is?
19:58 I haven't seen anything come forward. My issue would be if it's not an existing project that's going forward that would have to go through a different... Yeah, and I guess I could just ask for it, what is the definition of existing project and then what is an emergency? I mean, I think that's two criteria that needs to be identified. And that's what we were looking at, like the trails that were short of funding, if that were short of funding, then that project could come forward and ask those additional funding, yeah. So is that going...
20:27 Yeah, okay. So, but I guess that's my question. What is approved? Because is it a project that's already received Measure R and U funding, but what if a project hasn't been approved? Then we wouldn't bring it forward. We would not bring it forward for this funding at that point. If it's a town project and the town just said, if public works comes in and say, hey, we've got this great idea, we want our bill request funding, right now I would tell them, no, the project is processed, it's suspended.
20:56 You don't have a process to go ask for a brand new project, brand new funding. It's not a hold at this point. And I think you also have to be careful about the very fact that that doesn't mean if someone's got an idea that there's seven phases and we approve phase one, we approve two through seven. I think that's a key piece right there, too. And so for the purposes of this committee, we're going about our business with the understanding that the suspension has occurred.
21:25 and will remain in place until such time the Council makes a different decision or not, and that that reconciliation that has been requested and was a part of that action will be coming forward shortly or as soon as possible so that this discussion can be informed by what that reconciliation is. Yeah, that reconciliation will go to the...
21:48 Committees and the Council. Right, okay. Sandy, you had a question? I want a question. Speaking as a member of the Measure U Committee, since we don't have anybody on the committee, I can give an example of a project that we consider to be in progress and that we gave our approval on. Your recommendation to approve? Is that right? And the Council approved our recommendation. And that happens to be the Performing Arts Facility. The Mammoth Lakes Foundation brought forward
22:17 Their application for $25,000 to finish up a lot of the, I think, engineering stuff, whatever, put in place so that they can take the next step forward to be able to pour concrete potentially this fall. But that depends upon a number of things. And one of them was coming back in approximately April with the request for about $80,000 to take the next steps forward.
22:42 Now this is something that we have been working with them for a number of years, and so the committee approved that and said, yes, we understand that more is coming through. Another request is coming through because this is a project that the community, as a matter of fact, has been working on for many years. Part of it is based upon agreements with the college and measure C, which was passed in the year 2000.
23:09 Bonds from the college that allows potentially the construction that the college has always said that they will never have funding for the operations. And that's one reason why all of your campaign stuff going along with Measure U talks about operating facilities for the performing arts center. Never capital. So this has been in the work for a long time. Mammoth Lakes Foundation has had.
23:40 A number of requests, and they have been approved by the Council, so that we went from half-time performing arts, share, full-time. In other words, that's why they're building the demand first. Once the demand builds, and you go to the larger facility, we tried to fit that tent last year, we approved that, and there's portions of it. So it's a long process. It just didn't happen this fall.
24:08 So this is one we consider a continuing one. And the committee has said bring that forward and the council approved the original $25,000 knowing that I believe. So these are the examples. No, I don't think you should presume what the council knew. I think you should look at what was in their application and what was approved as that's what has been approved so far. I'm just saying we consider a continuous project. Okay. That's a great example to share.
24:38 What the committee's presumptions are and what the council's actions may be and where the various phases might be. I think that's part of this whole stock gap discussion, like where those definitions are occurring and where those decisions are being made. Who has the authority to make those decisions? And from MLR's perspective, we don't really have a dog in that hunt at all.
25:04 But we are looking at what that reconciliation looks like and certainly what those decisions are during the suspension period. That would be in reconciliation. That's why I gave it an example. In other words, that would be one of these things that is ongoing, a step in progress, as we saw it. You say something. Yeah, what we have, and there's a $25,000 committee. We'll be spending that. Partly not, I don't think we've engaged anybody to spend it in those dollar checks. So time-wise, that is still proceeding.
25:31 Foundation is still having a dialogue with the college and those types of elements. Is Major C even available in those types of dialogues? So whether or not they'll need additional funding now or six months from now, I don't know. But it seems to me that you guys have a pretty clear delineation between what is a brand new, never-been-discussed project and how that is treated versus something that is...
25:58 A good example of an ongoing process. I don't know. It's an ongoing process, but let's not mix up what is an ongoing process with what was before the council at the time of the approval. And what was the other one said? Sure, I'm just saying those go down different processes. Sure. I mean, we've got plans to finish trails in the park, but there's how many more phases that haven't been in the application here? Sure.
26:23 Actually, there's just one more phase. That one, we're really just waiting on funding it. We're waiting on a grant statement for that one. But, you know, and I spoke to Evan. I actually did sit down and we had a nice conversation and I had a whole bunch more reading from him to do. But there's a lot to still go into that process before there's any type of facility.
26:49 And any type of agreement. There's just a lot that needs to go into that prior to making any type of commitment. You know, Terry, on that one as well, I spoke to Evan after that Monday night meeting before the council meeting, I think maybe three weeks or so ago, came up with the same impression. There's a whole lot to do. The $25,000 is nearly, I consider it to be stand-alone.
27:14 And depending upon what the outcome is of that, there may be an application for more money. So this doesn't seem difficult. But if things come forward, the council will either modify the resolution that was passed and take something up or not. I don't think the water is muddy with the suspension and how that treats a pretty good project.
27:44 Well, I think you'll have the opportunity also to kind of explain that to the three entities who, particularly the Rec Commission, who expressed their concerns. Sure. And that this discussion you can share with them and appease their concerns. Yeah, that's good. Any other comments, Teri, Betsy, from the MLA or from the Recreation Commission meeting? Thanks for bringing that forward and discussing that with us.
28:15 The next item was homework preparation that we all had. And this was the development of a set of legal questions that we want to submit to and discuss with the town attorney relative to the formation and scope of work for MLR. Let's make a note here. We had proposed April 2nd to have a discussion, an in-face meeting.
28:39 Face-to-Face meeting with Andy, but unfortunately he's not available that time, is that right? Is there any other dates that we want to propose and is it feasible that he calls into one of our meetings that we have regularly scheduled that he can be on that agenda for that or is face-to-face? Face-to-face is better but a call-in can work.
29:01 And what I was looking at is come back to Hamless after this meeting is if one of our regular meetings appears to work like we try to do on the 31st, I can ask them if that's available. And if we have one alternative, so I can give them two dates.
29:14 Okay. And then we can get that coordinated. I don't want to wait too long on it, so you have to do something special. Yeah, we shouldn't wait too long because his sideboards are going to be very helpful and important to us. Correct. And we need it for scope. Does that mean we're pulling the meeting on the second? Meaning we're not going to be meeting with him on the second. That was a...
29:32 But, well, we were meeting with him. That was just a workshop meeting with him. It's not one of our regular meetings. So the 31st, he was available on the 31st? Potentially, I told him I'd have to confirm with this group of the next, I want to get two days, it would work, and I would give that to him. As opposed to the second, if we possibly do the 31st. Great. What time did the meeting be?
29:56 It would be the same three to five. We have a regular meeting scheduled at three o'clock on the 31st. Sometime between three and five, we would have Andy on the phone. Yeah, I would think he could come up for the meeting, it would be the best, and then if not, we would set up for a conference. Yeah, because I hate to wait until my next one on the 14th, because then that only gives us a month, because the scope of work subcommittee needs those understanding of the legal stuff before we come back.
30:24 with the sliding exercise for everybody to do. So I don't want to leave it too much. So for now we're canceling the meeting on the 2nd entirely. So for now we're not having a meeting on April 2nd with the town attorney. We don't have that scheduled. Rick could call in on the very first. Is there another time in the early part of April that we would call a special meeting?
30:53 Do you meet with Andy? Um, maybe that. You're not back until the 15th. I'm available by phone. Oh, okay. Um, maybe the 7th. That Monday, the 7th. Monday, the 7th. Excuse me, that works for me as well. Possibly.
31:11 Okay. We have technology. Okay. Okay. So can you... But with a preference to do it on the 33rd. The 31st would be preferred because that's a regular meeting. So Dan, 31st is our first option for him and then April 7th is our second option for him. And it would also be an afternoon meeting, like a 3 o'clock meeting on the 7th. Okay. So then, Dan, you'll get back to us with what looks best for him.
31:39 And what Andy can participate in. Okay. So with that said, we need to look at drafting some questions that we want to ask Andy. I'm going to kick this off. If you take the attached documents that were in your agenda, and it's item number 5A, it was MLR public comments. It looks like this. This document? From the top right hand.
32:07 Part of that table, it says, or excuse me, the third table from the left, it has legal. These were notes that Teri and I took from the public comments that were received at the 219 Council meeting, and perhaps this is a good way to start what questions need to be asked at the end.
32:25 And the first one had to do with a general statement about developing the framework within which MLR can function. This really speaks to very basic legal sideboards that MLR has to function within as related to the town. Very specifically, there was a question about the use of restricted and or unrestricted funds, and that general, but it also was tied back to fundraising issues.
32:53 and the flexibility or ability for MLR to go about fundraising between using unrestricted funds versus restricted funds and getting clarification from the attorney about the ability for MLR to fundraise.
33:10 and what those requirements might look like. Yeah, because I think the question wasn't so much that they can fundraise or can't. The question is, can you be subsidized or utilize our new money for that purpose? Sure, and that's the track. Sure, and that's the track program. Hire a sponsorship company to bring in more money. Right, and that was unrestricted funds that they brought in. That was unrestricted funds. But you're using our dollars to go hire somebody to do fundraising. I think the answer was no. But if there is unrestricted funds that may have accessibility to.
33:40 That there's the ability to use that for fundraising. But we just want to get that clarification from Andy on what it means to MLR. Starting and pulling some of the information from those types of things, one of that is how do you set up the accounting structure to save time spent on money, time spent on money, time spent on non-ROG dollars that are coming from some other purpose.
34:02 Another comment that was made that night had to do with the perceived conflict of interest because the question was asked, can MLR receive RNU funds and at the same time make funding recommendations relative to RNU? And so how does that perceived conflict of interest? What's Andy's legal opinion on that?
34:31 And then certainly compliance with ordinance language, which then I think led into a discussion about any potential changes to the ordinance or the expenditure plan. Yeah, the expenditure plan has to happen. And he has to advise if there are any changes that he would recommend that need to occur in order to establish the framework for MLR to function.
35:00 So that's kind of a way of thought to kick it off, kick off this discussion, and I'll open it up to you guys now to start asking what questions you would like to see asked. I have another one, and it's in an area that...
35:15 It follows over from the chart that everybody's seen, the ones, twos, and threes. When that was done, there was never any official legal input as to what the sideboards were for those things which are non-transferable authorities from the town. So that needs to actually get reviewed. We came up with a lot of discussion, but there was never legal input or an understanding, and I think that this committee needs to have a basic understanding of things like that.
35:43 So are you calling that an opinion of non-transferable? Yes, an opinion on the non-transferable authorities. Just making sure that before we start to slot, we understand which things are and should always be town versus what might be looked at as being provided in a different way.
36:12 Some other legal questions that you'd like to see asked abandoning. Well, one of the things that Dana, Joe, and I have been talking about, and actually John and I as well independently, is what the role of the attorney should be during this process as reform. For example, we're going to present...
36:38 What we think are the issues to be discussed for the bylaws. We're not going to have this committee work through every word and comma in proposed bylaws. But, you know, the question becomes, well, gee, should we not have counsel review a document that we, as lay people, and recognize that I'm a lawyer, but on this committee I'm a lay person, come up with.
37:05 There's not what I would consider to be rocket science, and I know that from my experience in this area, but we don't have a lawyer, and the question is whether the town attorney should be providing some, at least giving a stamp of approval, either generally or specifically, on things that are going to go forward. A second area John and I were talking about is the 501c3 discussion.
37:34 The materials that you provided, Dana, were really quite helpful, very clear, easily understood, and the conclusion that I drew from them was pretty easy for me. And I have some experience in that area as well, but I'm not this committee's attorney, nor am I the town attorney. The question is whether the town attorney ought to weigh in on, in particular, those two issues, and there may be more as we go along.
38:03 We had an attorney that we hired and we have an attorney that we work with, but we also had a separate funding source. So the question is right now there is no funding source for MLR that's been set up as of yet. So it would be a question whether it would be appropriate to use the attorney or you would have to then appropriate funds to hire an outside attorney. The question I can propose to Andy quickly is how much of that he feels he can do as a town attorney versus ultimately if it's a separate entity.
38:33 He's not their client. He's the town's client. So there's a, the town's the client. So there's a little bit, I think getting there process-wise, I don't think he would mind. Obviously when it comes time to negotiate that first contract, there's going to have to be an attorney. Well, because the town attorney's going to be looking at the town, MLR's going to need to have their own representation. But I think Rick's right as well. Do we have to start looking for someone now?
39:00 Cleaning them up so they're up to speed when the board is formed. Or do we wait? And if we need someone now, is there some reason why it wouldn't come out of the up to 5,000 of this contingency? You can't adjust to your date. It wouldn't burn through it all the fast. It wouldn't last long, but the other issue there is to be getting a formal contract with them. Right now, MLR doesn't have to be fully the contractor service, so the town would have to go hire another attorney to represent the town. I speak at odds.
39:28 I'd rather work it through Andy, unless he feels uncomfortable providing advice. Well, if we get our recommendations together, you know, Rick and I have been talking about the faculty seat status, and once we get all these recommendations together, can we get just general... Yes, it does. Yeah, really, exactly, are we on the right path of these, or is this really, you know, is the public charity not a direction you want to go down because of X, Y, and Z? You know, I think that we feel it's a fairly cut and dry direction, but there may be things that we're not necessarily seeing that we should be seeing, you know.
39:57 It may not, as long as we do all the legwork in advance, it may not be as costly to have that review. By Andy. Right, review by Andy to have him just let us know whether, you know, yeah, this is moving in the right direction. You know, John shared our bylaws from Maniflox Tourism, which are fairly straightforward. It's a very similar situation with a few exceptions. But, you know, I think that we have some of these things that give us...
40:24 I think the question that you asked about confirming with Andy, at what point does he separate himself from being
40:50 Both sides. And he says, from now on, I'm the town's attorney. You need to go. I'll tell you. On a couple weeks' notice. He's done that with me a few times. And the idea here is this is a committee that was formed by the town council, working out the town's direction at this point. So I'd say this is a town functionality right now. That's where I see it. So at some point it'll make a transition where it's not. But at this point, I think it's a town.
41:18 Functioner there. He has to be careful on legal devices, setting up another non-profit maybe that he feels there's a conflict. Well, I guess it's right up into the point of reform. I mean, I think that it's almost he leaves us at the door and then we move on. We can ask him. The beauty of it too is that at least I perceive by him providing us with this legal opinion as we move through this and thinking about the future contract and a few other issues.
41:47 He's able to continue to create the sideboards by which the town is going to part or work with MLR. And so we'll know what those sideboards are as this continues to evolve. And we don't get too ahead of the town in this effort because he can serve as that eyes and ears for both sides. Okay, so those are, I add those to my list. I think any
42:15 Recommendation that we've made or approval such as last week or the name and some of the decisions we're going to make today, we'll add that to a list that we want to have him just review and provide his approval. Yeah, I know. As far as the name and stuff like that, he's going to tell you. Yeah, that's fine. He's going to say, why do you want to spend money on asking me if I like your name? That's fine, yeah.
42:41 There's some things that he wants to look at that we need to leave an opinion on. What other, are there some other questions that people have thought about? There will be more detailed questions we'll need to ask regarding the RNU measures and a lot of the details of the ordinances, the voter approved language, a lot of that came out of the public processing discussion. We'll try to work through those and lay out questions that way to him to kind of specifically walk through some of those.
43:07 They've been brought up in various contexts. Would it be, you know, we're putting these subcommittees together, would it be beneficial to put a committee together to actually go through R&U and pull these questions out? Because right here we have compliance ordinance, compliance with ordinance language. And so, I mean, but that's pretty broad. So if we want to pull information out, then maybe that's something that we want to kind of have an ad hoc committee.
43:35 just specifically go through the two ordinances to pull out anything that they might see, unless we have those questions today.
43:43 We've got a lot of them pulled out. The staff have pulled out some of them just because of the input we've got on some of the stuff that's already gone forward. Some of the older DBK work that Andy did, I was trying to put all that together. Well, so if we have all the information and we can look at it the next meeting, then that would be sparks. Because sometimes it's easier if you have actual questions to say, well, that isn't really what we're at and we need to ask. We need to ask it this way or something. Because, you know, close your ears for a second. The attorney will answer exactly what you ask.
44:14 That's why Andy wanted to have the dialogue versus here's a real question. So what does that mean? That's what you have face to face. Well, is there a way? If it works out, though, that the 31st is when we're going to have their meeting, then we've got to see that list in this next week so that we have a chance to be ready for the 31st. So we're not duplicating work? Would you be able to share the list that you have already created? Yeah, I can share it.
44:40 Fill that together pretty quickly. If you want one or two to look at, I can ship it to you. I don't have time, but before 31st, honestly. I don't have a minute. I know both of those ordinances pretty well.
45:07 Okay, is it possible that you can have them back? Can you guys finish that so that we have a couple days before the meeting to see them? Yeah, we'll get them out in advance of the 31st meeting with the agenda. So, Dan, if you'll get to, Terry and Dan, if you'll get us a list of the...
45:23 The list that you started internally, and we can pull through it and add to it. And a copy of the ordinances as well. Yeah, there's a copy of the ordinances as well. Yeah, there's a copy of the ordinances here. We have it. I've got so many copies of that. I thought you just recited it at will. So, Teri and Jim, our goal would be to, what's today, the 17th and 24th, our goal would be to get this done before the, get it out to you guys.
45:52 We'll get it done and back out. Get it to Dan on the 24th. Our commitment is we'll have it to Dan on the 24th. A week from today. And then we'll get distributed to everybody. I'll ship everything to you. To the committee. That'd be great. Thanks. Any other legal questions that you are thinking about right now that you want to share with the group at this stage?
46:21 I think the compliance for the ordinance language is going to answer a number of the questions that people have. So do you think we'd have this discussion in our email exchange among the three of us about the funding issue? And that goes to this language, the statement of purpose. That's sort of a subset of, I think, the second box, don't you think? Yes.
46:54 Whether or not MLR can fund projects. We'll get into that discussion, but that may flow into another question. One of the questions that will come up for MLR will be, are they the recommending committee to the council for an award, or is there a broader dollar amount that they award that MLR is allowed to spend? In that process, we have to work through. Well, and if MLR is...
47:22 As it's unrestricted, has access to its unrestricted funds and has its projects that it would like to do on its own, who has to approve that is a question. Can MLR expend its own unrestricted funds? Yeah, and a discussion briefly with Andy on it. If it raises its own money, if the nonprofit does its own thing, do whatever you want with your money, account for it accordingly.
47:46 True, but if there's a maintenance component or there's something that comes back to the town. You can't commit our project that you've committed to. It'd be great. We may or may not. But our money would be the question that could come up. Well, there's another wrinkle to it also, Dan, that let's say they have raised money and they finally found someone who wants to pay for a cover over the ice rink.
48:10 How does it work when what they want to do when non-restricted RRU funds come in but they might be used on town property? So it's not just... No, I understand. Yeah, there's a lot of wrinkles there as well. And it's a donation to the town. And so I guess that has to be a question at this point, yeah. Not that it necessarily has to be answered right now, but as long as we're asking the legal questions, even if the funds are raised by this organization because...
48:40 I was joking, the Zamboni family decides they want to have it in memory of our former resident, you know, what are the sideboards on what they can do based on whether or not it's town-owned or managed or leased or whatever the property could be.
48:59 I think that that has a process for accepting donations and moving through that process. Yeah. Well, obviously, if a project like that comes forward, there's going to be an ongoing, you know, you can look at the maintenance or you can look at the operations of what, you know, strings are attached where and who takes care of it once you build whatever it is that you're building. Right. But that's a question we can ask. Good. Any other questions you want to add at this time? Does the public have any questions that you'd like to add?
49:28 Yes, if a member of the public has any other questions, would it be appropriate to forward that to Dan to maybe add to this if it's not a very long list? Let's see why not, because we took these comments here from the public comments at the council is where we pulled this information. So, anyways. Okay. All right. We have a commitment to get some things in by the 20th. Yeah. Yeah.
49:59 Moving on to item number five, we have some ad hoc subcommittee recommendations and reports. And the first one, since this is in front of you, we'll just continue with it. The ad hoc subcommittee that went through the public review, or excuse me, the public comment, or review of the public comment from the February 19th meeting.
50:19 We went through the notes that we had received from Stuart. John Armstrong had shared with us some notes. Dan provided a couple of notes. We had our notes. And so we went through and this is Teri and Dana. We're the ad hoc group on this. We went through and categorized what we had found most of the comments to fall within these seven categories.
50:47 And so what we did is, as I said, we categorized these. We did not come up with what we perceived to be the responses for them because we felt that that would be integrated into the outreach effort and what that, you know.
51:16 Any responses that need to be developed could live with the outreach. But this is what we kind of categorized from that meeting. And if you have any questions, we think this is a helpful document to use as we are going out to respective meetings, the one with Rick and Joe, you guys are going to have, and any other meetings, so that we're aware of what the issues were that were raised and that we
51:44 We can start to draft some responses as needed. Any thoughts or comments about this document? Boiled down to these categories. We had the transition issue and what to do with the existing commissions, the committees, and others that may be involved in the transition. Forest Service had specifics relative to the existing MOU and specifically a commit.
52:17 issue. Then this is more of a comment, but we felt it was important to understand and know it, that the Forest Service has expressed their lack of capacity to be able to engage in something because of their workload at this time. Then also a comment from the Forest Service relative to a desire for government-to-government relationships. But at the same time, they also had a comment of supporting the role of partnerships. And so just understanding that this is what the Forest Service, their thoughts were.
52:46 Relative to the RNU funds, again, these are just general, you know, a lot of comments, but they kind of fell into these statements. If they're encumbered funds, are they still encumbered relative to RNU? What is the discussion relative to special event funding obligations that may be current or upcoming? Consideration for the voter intent for RNU, and then the future allocation process for RNU.
53:15 And what does that look like? Then the fourth one had to do with the business plan. What are the operations going to look like? What's the funding and revenue generation? Is there a long-term, short-term strategy for MLR? We added timeline and benchmarks that need to be addressed, obviously budget, certainly an overhead discussion. And then is this capital projects focused only? Is that what MLR is?
53:44 We talked about legal. Then there was comments from the public about the public process. Continue to invite community to engage in the process. Again, this was more of a comment back to the outreach group, but developing messages, you know, what makes MLR different? You know, the question has been raised, what is it?
54:05 MLR, what makes it different. Perhaps referring to the GAINS and FORGO documents that were developed last summer with everybody's participation. Education about leverage opportunities, what does it mean to leverage and so people understand because that term's going around a lot. And then any impact to the town's current recreation partner.
54:30 And then for the governance side, there's a question raised, several questions raised about the board makeup and the appointment. And then is there any interest in an advisory committee as part of MLR? And then kind of the ultimate accountability, which boiled down to the relationship between the town and MLR. So I think this is a document to just use to kind of refer back to that captured the essence of the commerce commitment.
55:00 Basically we felt that, you know, as we were doing outreach to each of the individual groups, that if we have what has already been identified as being questions, and I think that probably we need to put some answers to some of these so that as you're going out, we start putting together kind of a Q&A document. So do you see this as something that's going to happen over a long period, a several month period of time? Or is this something that happens between now and the end of May?
55:32 I've been answering that. I think it's long term. I think there's some immediate, like you're going to go to the committee, because they're the commission, and they express some immediate needs, and so there's got to be a response and an answer to them. But at the same time, a lot of these are a part of what MLR is evolving into, and a lot of these answers don't exist today, and you can't make up answers if you don't have them.
56:02 And looking at MLR's process, where we are right now is very specific to bylaws, which speaks to governance, so we'll have some answers there. But I don't know that tomorrow we're not going to have the business plan in hand. That's going to be evolving over time. So I see that there are going to be responses back to these that are going to come out at various times as MLR's evolution is occurring.
56:27 Well, the reason I ask that question is, and that makes sense to me, the reason I ask the question is that I've been asked by Moon Rotary to give a presentation on the 27th, which will be 20 or 25 minutes. And in having, you know, a brief discussion with Tony Taylor about what that would be, they really, I think, for those who have not been to meetings over the past nine months,
56:53 Not been to the council member, not read the materials. The questions are going to be much broader. It's going to start with the why. Why are we doing this? I agree. I just highlighted that. And so I have in my head how I'm going to approach that, but I think that's going to be the starting point. The questions are going to be broader.
57:21 A bigger picture answer needs to be developed if it hasn't already or articulated from what we presented to Council and what Council has stated. So on that, I guess, Joe, Betsy, and our scope of business and business planning process, do we need to develop
57:38 Pretty high level FIQ at this point? Well, maybe not because let me answer it a different way. I was looking at it as is there anything on here that we didn't include in one of our subcommittees that we know somebody's going to address this. That subcommittee can come back and then make recommendations on which pieces.
57:58 which is number eight on the agenda, when they're getting addressed. But, you know, if we're responsible for doing the, I can't read sideways while I'm talking, you know, we've got the scope of work versus plan and budget, you know.
58:12 We know that certain things are going to have to be done, and as we start working as a subcommittee, we'll bring that out and bring the recommendations back, but no, when you speak to Rotary next week, no, there's still not budget. That's something we know we need to have. So I'm afraid that if we spend the time writing out a whole bunch of FAQs, when if you create the document that's the scope of work, then you've got the same stuff you might have put into FAQs.
58:36 I'm just trying to look at the fact of how much we've got to do and how little time. And I think as our subcommittees are working, what, you know, you need to look at is these are the concerns that people have. So we need to make sure that we're addressing them as we move forward. And so that then those can be brought out. That's okay. Here's, you know, we have taken into consideration your concerns. This is how they've been addressed. And this is the outcome. And so then people can...
59:02 Yes, and so there's certain things in there. Now, like, the future of the Recreation Commission is not for this committee to decide. I mean, that's a town function. So we recognize that it's out there, and we recognize that in the discussion and the scope of work and things we might discuss, and in the slotting exercise we might discuss that, but it's nice to know what's on here, but we won't ever address that, not as the MLR Formation Committee.
59:27 So maybe the more appropriate time for an FAQ document would be as MLR is being launched versus... You know, and it may be something that you put together as you're going along. Right. The completion of it goes along with... But, you know, do you have a business plan? Yes, we have a business plan. Instead of just saying, here's, you know, just posting a business plan. That's what I'm trying to say. It's trying to make that we don't get stuck because...
59:52 I've seen other FAQs just go through 47 different versions because you keep changing one or two words, and I don't think we have the time to get into that level of detail if we're focusing on getting a business plan out there. Now, it won't be the final business plan. I think that's what you were saying, John, is that we know we have to talk through a lot of things and bring things back to the full committee to discuss that result in a business plan.
1:00:18 I'm afraid to spend a whole bunch of time on FAQs. I think we need less an FAQ than an elevator speech. It's a talking point. I think there are some of those pieces that we need to just all be on the same page. Like you said, it's FAQs or whether it's just bullet points of the skeleton of the scope. Right, right. It's an outline. No, it's an outline, yeah.
1:00:47 So let me, I'm returning to our community outreach group and you guys will give us a report next and about groups that you've identified I think for who we want to reach out to but is that a work piece that you guys can take on is looking at that elevator speech and kind of sharing it with
1:01:08 The rest of us, because Rick, I appreciate you bringing up the fact that Rotary asked you to speak. Before there was a discussion about going to the Rec Commission or having that joint meeting, Steve Spidell had put in a request for a discussion at an upcoming MLTSCC meeting. And I was kind of doing the same thing, going, well, I'm not certain what I would say because of the phase that we're in right now. And I certainly, you know, you can't answer.
1:01:35 Something that you don't have the answer for, and I'm not one to make this up at this stage. And so if you two can kind of take on that development of that elevator speech, it kind of encompasses where we are in the process, kind of the why that we're doing it, then we can share that, and that's a tool that we can start to use, and it can grow and evolve as we continue to get more answers to bring forward to the folks.
1:02:04 And just to clarify, when we were talking about the joint meeting, it's also including LTSCC. Right. I think when we'll get to that, I think there are going to be three entities involved in that. And that's, when's your rotary meeting? Thursday. Is that something that you might be able to do before then, just to help? The 27th. Yeah, it's his meeting. Yeah, I think we could maybe say it later this week. Yeah. Okay, perfect. Yeah.
1:02:30 So any other thoughts about this public comment document? We're not going to go back and adjust it or edit it. It's what was captured. We've got the categories. Use it as a guide when you're doing this. As people are doing outreach, this is just something that we take and it's a guide. And then what you guys come up with is also, I think, the gains in Pergo is huge. And then as we're moving forward, we're taking in these items into consideration as we're moving forward.
1:03:00 Any other thoughts on this? Public? Any comment from public, Joanne? Okay, anything else? All right, let's move to B, community outreach. Kind of review a list of agencies, organizations, and others that we might think about MLR to meet with or reach out to. So what we decided to start with was
1:03:43 To look back at when we put together the list of people to invite to the initial summer workshops. Are there more copies of that? There are not. Helen and I sort of just did this this morning. We can get a copy out to everyone, but it's kind of a working document at the moment. Okay, great. Thank you.
1:04:05 But what we decided to do was to go back to look at the whole list of people we initially invited and organizations we initially invited to participate. Whether they did participate or not, we wanted to try to make sure we reach out to even the organizations that didn't send anyone to our meetings over the summer and to kind of start with that list and then maybe add in some additional entities, things like the Water District and, you know, the Rotary is a good one. If you had any more that you're thinking of.
1:04:35 But yeah, and I think, you know, another piece of this was kind of prioritizing as well. And so, you know, I think that was our intent more is to kind of put together a more comprehensive list knowing that it may grow a little bit, you know, per your suggestions, but also to really hone in on, you know, maybe a top five or a top ten as far as the priorities go. So I actually started prioritizing, but it's gone. But, you know, I think some of them are obviously pretty clear.
1:05:05 You know, engaging the Forest Service, and then they say, you know, Town of Mammoth Lakes, as far as municipal rec and all that kind of stuff. Those are obviously similar to our own. So when that comes back, we can talk about that a little bit. But I think that was more armed for the discussion today is to kind of get some consensus on what groups prioritize. So in other words, because knowing that we don't have much time, so it's a list of...
1:05:34 A whole bunch of potential organizations, but prioritize the ones that need to be before the board as far as well. Okay. To get some input. As opposed to us speaking maybe for that board. Yeah, and I think that's a very helpful kind of differentiation that this isn't a road show discussion to go tell as much as it is a road show to go out and gather to get.
1:06:03 Get some input from those prioritized entities as this group is going through its process and to solicit any feedback or suggestions or thoughts. Which takes me to, are either one of you on the Town County Liaison Committee? We both are. So on your agenda on Thursday, there's an M.O.R. update. Correct. And so I just kind of, being the way I am, I'm just curious.
1:06:33 What's intended to be discussed at that meeting and what you're sharing and is that an opportunity for you guys to ask the county for them to share their thoughts or gather their input? Is it appropriate for you to do that on that Thursday's meeting? Ask them for their feedback since you're going to be in front of them and we can check them off the list.
1:06:55 Well, let me answer this. I think so. And in the interim, while this has been going on, the school district's liaison committee that I'm on, and so that gave them an overview of where we were, what was happening in the next steps, and answered questions. They didn't have any particular input at that point other than an interest because, of course, the schools are going to be interested in what's provided. And I guess, you know, kind of on...
1:07:25 What Dana had said there, as we're reaching out to these folks, I mean, the Forest Service, we have some, you know, comments and things that people look at here, obviously, but as we're meeting with these folks, is, you know, what do they see? What do they want to see in MLR? What could it help them? What could it provide to help them with whatever, you know, it is that they're looking for? How can there be partnerships that can be gained? And, you know...
1:07:52 How can the two work together to maybe, you know, move something forward within Mammoth? And as opposed to just someone sitting there, and I think this is what Dan was getting at, as opposed to you sitting there saying, this is what MLRs would be, what would you, you know, how do you see that partnership? What would you see that working relationship be? And how can we, you know...
1:08:14 Yeah, and I think the more we talk about it, it shows the importance of having that elevator speech drilled down relatively quickly because, you know, that's the way to start those conversations is you go to an MMSA meeting and say, hey, this is kind of the elevator speech on what MLR is. How do you see it? What are your concerns? How can it augment what you're doing, et cetera, et cetera? And actually that whole thing, you know,
1:08:44 Getting the interest, yes, right now. Delving in and how it's actually going to work is something that I expect is one of the things that happens in the first year of the actual organization to really get down into that. I guess it would be nice still to understand what they see, you know, how they can see themselves, you know, working within.
1:09:03 We have an M.O.R. Because that will definitely steer the direction. The direction of where, you know, where you are. Well, one of the great things, too, about this list is that so many of these people did participate in, you know, in the workshops over the summer, and, you know, and were part of the games of 4GO exercise, and, you know, so they can kind of see where, you know, that we've taken that, and this is the direction, and... So that's the elevator speech. Ask we both. And I agree with you.
1:09:33 Joe, do we have a ski area meeting coming up? We should be. We probably do. Wait a minute, boys. So, and also we have... You guys are going to get to do all these a little bit. Yeah, just that's one of the things you get. You know, we don't have one set, but I'll check with Pam and see if we can get one set. Probably a good idea. And maybe late April or something. And we're going to, Joe and I are going to meet with Forest Service as well.
1:10:03 on a variety of type of topics, but I'm sure primarily this. So that is likely not to occur until after the middle of April. So we've got time to sort of develop this, but those are three obviously pretty important outreach recipients. Then as we're still waiting to come back, then
1:10:27 Does someone who, presumably, if someone does outreach, then they'll report it back at the next meeting, so we need to have an agenda item on feedback each time? I think that's, I would just request, yeah, we put it in standing, but we request that you advise that you've been invited and that you're going out, that there's not a surprise or that we don't know what each other is kind of doing relative to
1:10:56 This outreach out. Well, I think that we need to clarify who's doing what outreach. Otherwise, we're all going to be... Well, I think we get action steps and we get to put it back. Yes. We have almost a template of thinking more coverage. Yes. Correct. So we can pull it back. Yes. So I think we're going to do that. Yes. Is that...
1:11:17 Is that something we could ask you guys to kind of work on also? Is this kind of setting up that, I'm using the protocol, but that checklist of, you know, what did we hear back from? What did we hear back from? Managing the spreadsheet. Yeah. Yeah, but not, you know, but don't make it stupid. No, not cumbersome, because remember, you know, we're kind of, we've got a balancing act here. There's a lot of work that we need to be doing while at the same time.
1:11:43 The public engagement part of it. And it's falling to this group right here. Yeah, so I think, you know, once we have some time to kind of come to consensus on priorities here, you know, we could put out an email like, hey, these are the top five, the top ten priority groups to reach out to. Do any of you have some overlap with this stuff? Who's going to be handling these things? And then check back in afterwards for feedback. Right. But then even before you do that, you can put Rick in.
1:12:13 Maybe down for Forest Service and Mammoth. Okay. Because we have the regularly scheduled meetings. And technically, for an initial contact, Stacey was at the school district liaison meeting, so she would be covered for just the initial, not for, you know, not for the super detail that might come on. So you already spoke to it. Yes. On the county supervisor, did you choose Fred as the contact with the other side of the panel?
1:12:43 Is he on the liaison? Is he at the liaison meeting? No, but
1:12:49 We haven't met in so long, I don't know. We're actually meeting on the 20th. So Rick and I will take care of the county, whomever it is, and then we'll let you know. No, so there is the chair. Yeah, but Dan just said chair and vice chair. No, it hasn't always been the chair and the vice chair. It's been longer standing than who's in their rotating seats.
1:13:19 But we haven't yet. He might be now and wasn't before or whatever. But anyway, so we'll take care of the county as well because we've got that meeting next on the 20th. Yeah, this week. Two supervisors meet with two town council members to talk policy. Yeah, I just wasn't sure why he was the league. Because he was the one that was invited to participate initially. Yeah, we didn't. Yeah, that was kind of the same thing.
1:13:48 Yeah, correct. Greg, do you have a comment? Oh, I was just going to say, you know, I have served, I don't know, now, but I have served for many years on the DSCS Board of Directors, so I'm happy to take that one, and also Mammoth Track Club, of which I remember. Okay. And I didn't organize, like, the 1-3-7 in actual numerical order. I was just kind of going through it.
1:14:19 And, you know, I don't know, Mammoth Trails, let's see that one on here. Mammoth Trails might actually encompass quite a few of these user groups. Are these still meeting? No, Mammoth Trails. Is there still an email list for them? John?
1:14:49 Because that gets fellow and try and a whole bunch of other things, right? So will you make sure that this group knows when those meetings are happening? Yeah, those meetings haven't been scheduled yet, so wherever your representatives are, if you want to meet those meetings. Let us know when the meetings are, and then we can assign someone to come to them. Yeah, we have the Belflix Foundation, but we don't have CERCOSO.
1:15:31 Correct. Are they part of Mammoth Trails, John? Okay. Yeah. I was going to say, if I remember, there's like 20 organizations in Mammoth Trails. There's going to be quite a few of them. And actually, it would be nice maybe to get a list from you as to who that would encompass if we're going to do a Mammoth Trails connection. That would be great.
1:15:58 Because some of the, if we can, you know, get as much of that together as possible, that would be awesome. Yeah. You know, again, it's like having the joint meeting of the two committees and the commission so that you have a, you get the weird in and out, more people at once instead of lots of little units. Yeah. So we added Mammoth Trails then. Is there anything that needs to be elevated in priority status? Well...
1:16:20 I don't know, because, you know, some of it is that just back and forth as opposed to developing partnerships and things. I think a lot of that's going to go past the term of this committee and should be done by the actual board. Well, yeah, but I don't think we're looking at joining partnerships right now. No. It's just an outreach. Yeah, it's just an outreach and gathering any more questions here and then looking to see how we might partner so that it's informational as we're moving forward. And I think from the
1:16:50 Priority perspective, we're taking advantage of some scheduled meetings that are coming up, so that makes them a priority. So on the Planning and Economic Development Commission, do you have a commission of reports where you can do an MLR presentation to yourself? Yes. I'd like to do that. You said the MLEC? Uh-huh, yeah.
1:17:19 To add that? Yeah. And then, I don't know, the Events Coalition, I guess we're looking at the same thing. Does the Events Coalition, will they cover, like, Chamber of Music Unbound? Yeah. And then, would you be able to supply us that same list as to who is?
1:17:56 Would be involved in the Mammoth Lakes Against Coalition, so if there's somebody else that we would need to do outreach to that isn't involved in that, but we could. Okay. Awesome. Thank you. Guys, for doing that. Send that to Dana. Send it to me. Yeah, thanks. To Lynn? I think we add it to the list, and where priority shows up is when we have information that...
1:18:35 is ready to come forward to those types of groups.
1:18:37 Community groups is up to service clubs, service clubs.
1:18:40 Yeah, service clubs.
1:18:41 You set the agenda for lions also?
1:18:47 In terms of I want to move them up to one and six.
1:18:49 So, in the situation, if you'd like to speak in the state,
1:18:52 you should be in the town.
1:18:53 Mine is going to be in the seven seconds.
1:18:56 So, community service clubs, so we'll look at that.
1:19:01 And, you know, Rick's going to be speaking to the roadway.
1:19:03 I think that once we put this other information together, that's what we need to start doing.
1:19:08 Yeah.
1:19:09 You're at Newton, right?
1:19:11 Yeah.
1:19:12 Well, there's going to be a joint meeting. So do we have something, looks like we've touched on most things except maybe Chamber of Commerce, MLT.
1:19:52 John can handle the chamber. Okay. And then John will take the chamber. Under ESEA, we have an item on our board meeting, so I'm constantly giving that update. And John Armstrong, Eastside Velo was a part of the Mammoth Trails at one time also. See, I think the Tri-Club and Eastside Velo will be taken care of under that. Sure.
1:20:22 And I have been giving updates to Friends City, you know. Okay. Okay. So you have Mammoth Lakes Foundation in Cerro Coso. The problem, you were, is that something that would be for mine? I think so. I would presume to pick. And we had to pull, you know, whoever else. We give them a staff and we meet with some of the cool folks on the staff. Do you? Yeah, with you, Dan, and who else is involved with that? Right now, just myself. Right now, I just meet with them, with Dina.
1:20:55 Stacy. Is that something that if you were going to do that, you could have one other person come meet with you? I could get a call maybe. With MRR? Yeah. Is that a standing meeting that you have? Yeah, we try to meet. Obviously, we're just kicking one off this month. Every month is ideally to try to meet. Okay.
1:21:12 And would somebody else be able to meet with you possibly with that? Yeah, if you want to set up, I'll shoot a note and see if someone else has an interest in you. Okay. And that's NUSD also, so it's Stacey and... Stacey and Dana's invited to those. And then NUSD is also the part of it? Yeah, Stacey is part of it.
1:21:30 And then the foundation can be included in that? I'd keep them separate. This is a different discussion. Okay, so we're going to, so the foundation will be separate, and then so if you don't need a physical district and Saracossa will be together. Okay, so you'll advise when you have that meeting? Yeah, absolutely. We'll give that piece of the agenda if it's good to staff in the meetings. Perfect. Any others at this stage?
1:22:02 I think our youth sports system is going to be something that the Recreation Commission is going to be working with. And we'll see most of them for youth sports funding. Stuart, does that sports group that you had, do they still meet the sports commission or sports council? Yeah, does that still meet? Okay. They're only youth sports funding. Right. Correct. We'll go to the Recreation Commission.
1:22:31 Because I think, I'm just thinking ahead, all those right there, that whole youth sports side of it, they're a great spot for input.
1:22:47 because there's going to be a lot of partnerships with them being formed also, but I'm not sure if it's right now or if it's as we're working on that. I think that might be more down the road. Maybe that's a special, maybe it's like we're doing with some of these other entities, have a special meeting of those youth sports groups to come in and get advice. And I guess that's where I would kind of see the rec commission is one of the things that we need to put on our agenda is, you know, what do we see our role being as we're transitioning?
1:23:14 And I would see the Rec Commission should be the one that would pull the youth sports together and see, you know, how that can benefit each other moving forward. I don't know. That is something that I perceive the Rec Commission should be their purview. Okay. And then they would work with MLR. I mean, do you see it different? I don't know. I think down the road, that ongoing role for the Rec Commission is dealing with that. Yeah.
1:23:40 Yeah, and then that becomes the, you know, from there, then that would be the part where the Rec Commission can communicate with MLR and have that partnership. And maybe that can be solidified at the special meeting that you're going to have with the three entities that you two are going to have. We really talk about future duties and roles. Yeah, but maybe this can just be that and start that dialogue. Well, I think that's something that as a Rec Commission, we should start talking about.
1:24:08 looking at what our role would be in a transition. There was a question MMSA liaison meeting. Is that when coming to that degree? Do you have a schedule? I thought it was in April. I thought it was April 15th, but I don't.
1:24:21 That might have been among the other megas. I was just going to say, I don't see it on my calendar yet. We do have one. We have one. I don't think it's set. I don't think it's set yet, but I'll send, I'll send. We had a note on the last agenda for the next one, and everybody said that. They brought that date work, so they go back. Okay, here's the deal. We don't have to worry about the date, except you guys will know when the date is, and it'll be your assignment to carry the.
1:24:45 Yeah, we'll add that to the agenda. Right. Rick and I will tear up that one, too. You got it. Okay. Yeah. Teri has MLT. John has MLT. Okay. Anything else you want to add to this list right now? Are we clear? Are you clear on what you're...
1:25:00 Colin and Betsy, what you're doing next. Yeah. Yes. You're coming back. We're going to write the elevator speech. We're going to write the speech together. We're going to write the elevator to arrive. Yeah. Well, we need it before a week from Thursday. Right. Before the 27th, it needs to be done. Okay. And we'll kind of organize this into who's doing what. Okay, perfect. Otherwise, there will be a rogue speech again. There you go. And as we get this. Well, you've got your speech.
1:25:29 Juliana and John. We'll get this from Juliana and John. We'll send to you guys also. Anything else? Any comments from the public on this? Okay. Looking forward to number C. MLR implementation. Synthesize the final report and define next steps. Betsy and Terry. That's right. And it's in the packet. Yeah, there was a handout for that.
1:26:01 It looks like this. It's stapled. It looks like this. And it says at the top of it, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, next steps. So what we did was we went back through the report and pretty much just cut and pasted and pulled out the things that need to happen next.
1:26:30 There were a couple of things early on, a couple of things that are kind of left out hanging from phase two, like creating a vision and mission statement, you know, bylaws, you know, which are one of our subcommittees, and we just wanted to make sure that we didn't miss anything, and I think one of the, part of the discussion that Teri and I had was how much of this, about some of these things.
1:26:55 Will we do as a formation body and how much would be left up to a director once hired and, you know, and the board of directors once they're seated? So you mean what has to be done before? What has to be done now? What would be done? You know, and I apologize because I had put some things in red because that was, those were some of my questions and maybe I can electronically forward those to you so you can see what my comments were in red.
1:27:22 So, because like the final plan was one of them, this formation or first year board, and then, you know, what is left up to a director. You know, MLT, we left a lot of the things that we're going to have to do up to a director, but that's because we were in a different position than we are with this board. This board is going to have to come up with a lot of this information and as far as, like you said, a business plan.
1:27:48 But it's going to be a working, breathing document. It's not going to be that we're going to hand something to somebody and say, here, this is, you know, this is carved in stone and this is what you're going to do. But we have to at least put that information together where we actually didn't put a business plan together. We hired a director and allowed that director to do that. But I think there's some of these things that are going to be able to handle exactly the same as we did previously.
1:28:17 So anyways, and so I think that, and I guess a concern of mine would be, is with this being brand new and we're putting this together, there needs to be kind of a working document that somebody has as a guideline when, number one, they're hired, and then number two, a new board. So it doesn't mean that the new board is going to be carved in stone, but there at least needs to be that foundation that they have to start working off of.
1:28:47 Because this formation committee is not going to be the first board. It could possibly be a working board maybe six months into this organization's life, and then the new board comes on so that there's, you know, the director's brought on, that foundation is set, and then it's handed off. I don't know. I just...
1:29:09 I don't want it to be all of a sudden that boom, it's done and here, make this happen, but what are they making? You know, they've got to have that foundation as to what they're making happen. Well, the one thing that we did have, though, with MLT was a strategic plan. Yes, we did have a strategic plan. And a strategic plan kind of helped answer some of the questions, Teri, that you're posing about what it's going to do, what it's not going to do, what its emphasis is going to be, and that...
1:29:37 That was a good guiding document, I think, for everybody to understand what the role of MLT was going to be. Well, I think that's our scope of work. Yeah, I think that's a huge piece of that to say where we feel that this organization should be going. Now, that doesn't mean that it's not going to more of a change or be different than what we're saying. And there may be different paths to get to that. So I think the idea of writing a business point forward, I think we're better off providing a scope of work since.
1:30:06 And I think that goes to this where we put in the, within the original document, the 5.0 MLR, where it says refine the strategies and scope of work, is there's a very high level in that document, and I think that that's part of what, you know, we're talking to, and that's one of the things that needs to be kind of dove into.
1:30:35 Worked on in a little bit more. Would it make sense when you have, because in other words, in your red copy, you put around the questions of was it before or afters? There were some of them, and so like, you know, when it says adopt a final plan, is that a formation or first year board? And then there was another one, there's a couple other of them on here. What if each subcommittee reviews this for their tasks and then...
1:31:02 comes back with, you know, because some of these we know are on our list of what has to be done before, and if each group looks at it from the pieces that are there, because this just gives us another reminder that we don't forget anything, because, you know, select a bank and secure the paperwork. Well, that's not going to happen with this committee, so we just have to do, that's an after.
1:31:23 It might not be, though. The thing is, you know, that's where it is. Where's the chicken? Where's the egg? And, you know, so which one? Well, but if you don't have officers to sign, how are you going to set up a bank account? Well, right now with a formation committee, you do have actually officers, but so this is, you know, where does this all jump off? But this is our delineation. Make sure we don't forget anything. And that's what we were supposed to do, is just what are the next steps? This is a checklist to make sure we don't forget anything.
1:31:53 And let's acknowledge that's what this tool is. This is a tool for us because we all acknowledge that the MLR report as we received was very thick and had many elements to it. What you guys did, you pulled it, the key pieces that we need to keep track of, you pulled it and put it into this document. So this now becomes a guiding document. So one of the things I added under the town of Mammoth Lakes relationship and then what we're supposed to do, page two.
1:32:18 Is the first bullet point, you can see it's a little bit more bold, it's reconciliation of current commitments for Measure R and U, which are ongoing and which are not. So that goes to our conversation earlier, but that really wasn't specified anywhere here. I had some comments up here as far as the Board of Directors creating a definition, because that first bullet point basically said that the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board members should be representative.
1:32:47 of Recreation interests within the community. One of my clients, and then that's all mine after that. Just user groups. What talents should board members bring to the table? See page 11, which are, you know, some of the strategies that, you know, that we need to have people on there that can...
1:33:03 I mean, work towards some of those strategies. Because as we went through the report, there were just a couple things we were kind of able to flesh out. And I think, though, so that as we get to it a little bit later, we've already listed that as one of the things as bylaws that has to be determined. So this just really helps us make sure we haven't forgotten. This wasn't, and this was just a question since that was kind of in there, and then, you know, board makeup, you know, is it larger? Do you have your executive board and then is it larger? So those are just
1:33:32 So we can use this document as a reference document and instead of going back and forth to this document. It works and it captures everything that we need to cover. So I guess what people would need to do is look at it and make sure there's nothing that we missed, you know, as you see something.
1:33:56 With your respective ad hoc committee hats on and the assignments that we all have on our ad hoc committees to go through and identify those that are relative to what we're doing, to what each of us are doing and make sure that we agree with this or add to it as needed if there's anything that we think that we're focusing on that doesn't show up on this to make sure that it's added in there. So I can send that out to everybody electronically.
1:34:24 We need to make comments. No, we're not asking for comments. We're not asking for comments. They need to be able to review it so they can. They're going to review it. They can bring their comments back. Right. To the next meeting. We want to see. Let's just use the example of the bylaws group. We might say that there's two other things that have been added that we want to see added to this. So those comments need to be added.
1:34:46 for that person and brought back to our next meeting so that we can keep adding on that document if we need to. Since this is the one that's been brought to this meeting, then I can email this one out to everybody so that they can send it to you. Yeah, if I can email it out today, I'll get it out to everybody. And it's in color. It is in color. So anyways, yeah.
1:35:09 No problem. And the only reason that I think that's important is because I think the group needs to know what was actually within the 5.0 document and what's something that you may not agree with what I added. That was just, you know, my comments that I added to the document. So we know how to use this document. We know when we receive it from Dan, we're going to put on our ad hoc committee hat, see if there's anything missing, and bring it back to our next meeting to add to it. This is a guideline. Questions from the public on this?
1:35:39 Thank you.
1:36:11 That's going to be part of, if you look at all the comments and the business plan, yeah, so that's all going to be within the business plans. And then the, you know, what are the strategies, long term, short term, we're part of the MLR business plan, public comments that were on there, as well as timelines and benchmarks. So those are all going to be, that's clarified under the business plan.
1:36:37 I understand, yeah, but that's one of the ad hoc committees is that business plan, so that'll be coming forward. One person has all three. Okay, thanks for sharing. This needs to be a unique board. Yeah, and that would be addressed in the board governance discussion. So we know what to do with this document? Yeah, let's move on. Thanks, Teri, Betsy, for pulling that together, and I think John Armstrong had some, he shared some thoughts on that too, so I'll thank John and his.
1:37:26 In his absence, yeah. All right, let's move on. Item number six, discussion and possible action relative to 501c3, charitable or private foundation? John and Rick. Easy call. Public charity as opposed to private foundation. I realize that they both fall under the same subsection, but private foundation is really one that normally has...
1:37:54 Typically has a single source of funding that then is formed to fund other public charities or 501c3 organizations or charitable organizations. And so many of the prohibited activities of both the private foundation and public charity are the same. For example, you can't engage in lobbying. You can't engage in political activities and so on. You know, we're doing this for the benefit of the public.
1:38:24 That's what it is. That's part of our mission, part of our purpose statement, and it seems very easy to me. There's a point in time where you could actually create a subset, a private foundation within the 501c3. I don't see the need from that, so the question that might be asked is, well, gee, do we have a single source of funding, which is the town of Mammoth Lakes? Well, we do, but that's not the intent. That is that we only have...
1:38:53 a single source of funding. So without presenting a legal opinion, which I deliberately didn't do, I, it's, it's, and, and, and all of you can read the, the information that is readily available from the Turner Revenue Service on, on this. And we got last, at our last meeting. It's, it's pretty easy. But that reminds me, you were going to send us off the next, Dan, and I didn't see that. Yeah, the, yeah.
1:39:17 Can you still send us? You didn't get the hard copies at last? Correct. Oh, okay. Yeah. I thought we had enough. We had enough. Yeah, we should ship those out again. I actually have the documents. I can share those. I can ship it to them. Okay. John, did you have anything you wanted to add to?
1:39:40 I appreciate you guys. No, it's pretty clear. It is clear. I think just in making the decision, we wanted to make sure that everybody understood why we're making the decision in the direction that it's going. Teri, you have a question? I was just going to say, would we want to add the, and it would go with the chamber, having the conversation with the Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation, because this is going to be a charitable 501c3.
1:40:03 And, you know, and this is a down-the-road conversation, but maybe it's at least something that every chamber that you talk to, the Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation, would there be any possible... I think so, but there's several foundations in town, so that at some point, you know, if NLR at some point decides to do it, you've got people to talk to. Now, Rick, was this one of the questions that you wanted Andy's input on?
1:40:32 Well, I think that he, I think we ought to charge him with the task of agreeing with us. Yeah. This one. Can we do that one? I will just do it. Yeah, I'll just do it. This is the decision that we have. Yeah, and it's not complicated, but he is the town attorney. We are a town committee. Right, yeah. And it is a legal question, and we don't have outside counsel, and I think he ought to weigh in.
1:40:58 either disagree or confirm what I think. So let me ask a protocol question on that. It would be appropriate to make a motion and approval by this group today to follow that recommendation. We're going to take it back to Andy to get his approval on it. I would just do it subject to unless the attorney says no. Yeah, because from a timing perspective, this little piece.
1:41:25 There needs to be a box that needs to be checked on a form, and we don't get to advance with that form without checking the box. So if we can entertain a motion to accept this recommendation, and then we can run it by Andy if there's any questions, then we would change it at least. Well, I'll move that we form the organization as a 501c3 organization, Public Charity.
1:41:54 And that is subject to... Confirmation. Yeah, I would say confirmation. I was going to say affirmation. But confirmation from the town attorney that that is the most appropriate form of our entity. Second. Is there a second calling? Any further discussion about this?
1:42:18 All right, moved and seconded to form Mammoth Lakes Recreation as a 501c3 public charity subject to confirmation from the town's attorney. All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Thank you, Rick and John, for doing that one.
1:42:33 Okay. Question as far as timing, if it's approved by the town attorney, then is that something that we actually need to file? Yes. Because that takes time. It's part of the document. It's part of the document that has to be filed specific to the state of California with our articles of incorporation. Because we need to get to that point first. We want to get that confirmation quickly because...
1:42:56 We don't get to do anything without this. This is the first thing that has to be done. So when we get done with number seven, will we have all these questions answered? Yes. Okay. Yes. Thank you from the note taker. Yes. No, we will. We will have these questions answered. Because on this form, there's really only a couple that we have to answer.
1:43:22 The rest of it are just statements that we are either, we acknowledge or we know. That's what I meant. We have all the, we'd be able to fill it in. So yes, we're able to fill it in with the confirmation from the county attorney. All right, let's then move on to item number seven, which is a report out from the Ad Hoc Committee of Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws. And I'm going to start with, Rick, I'm going to turn it over to you. Yeah, so there's a, if you take a look at this,
1:43:51 set of articles you'll see that the language is a little different under California law than it is under the rules and laws that are prescribed in the Internal Revenue Code and we will be a public benefit corporation.
1:44:11 It's a non-profit corporation. There are two forms, private benefit and public benefit. We will be a public benefit corporation. Obviously, we have charitable purposes and we have public purposes. And so, with respect to number two, my recommendation would be that we check both boxes. That's what we do. And really, it is defining what you do that determines what you are. So, what happens is you form these articles. I mean, you form the entity by filing the articles.
1:44:38 You have a first meeting. You then apply for tax-exempt status with the feds and the state. And there are some very specific forms that relate to that, but you want to make sure that in your articles you've got language that will qualify you as a 501c3 charitable organization as it's described in, or public charity as it's described in the Attorney General Code. So, again, this is pretty stock stuff. It's pretty easy.
1:45:08 And given that there isn't a debate about what it is this organization is going to do, I don't really have anything else to add on the articles. Since we're on the forum really quick, can we just identify under number three and number four the service of process listing in recommendation or thought about who that might be for us while we're doing this? Who's your agent, John?
1:45:38 for service of process, for MLT. Well, you have one. You have to have one. So, actually, you might, there are entities out there, there are corporations out there that will serve as agents for service of process. Many times, many times the attorney does. It probably was then, because we had time. I didn't find him.
1:46:01 And then am I right later that you can change it? Change it every year. You either reaffirm it or you change it. You can change it, yeah. So often it's the incorporator who's the agent or in the case of a single member corporation, for example, somebody incorporates their business and he or she's the sole owner, he's his own agent or she's her own agent or its own agent or the attorney is the agent. I just did the formal murder and it didn't give me anything to update.
1:46:26 Yeah, it does, because I just did the one for the Friends of the Library. Anyway, for us, agent of service. I think, and I think maybe, we probably had Jim's name down there to serve because he was under retention at that point. But in thinking about, for us, we can't list MLR, we can't list ourselves. No, it has to be an individual with a physical address to receive papers. Right. So is there a thought as to who that should be on this form?
1:46:54 And do you want to raise your hand on this? Well, I was going to say, since I agreed to be secretary, I'd be glad to do it. I think, Joe, I appreciate that. I think that'd be perfect. I think that'd be great. And then can that, can Joe then be the incorporator? Mm-hmm. As the, as the secretary? Mm-hmm. He can be the incorporator also. You could sign. Yeah. Yeah. Perfect. And then if you want to get somebody or an agent or something. Down the road, we can do that. Okay, perfect. So we have filled that out.
1:47:24 And then the corporate address. You need a street address. Yeah, I'd be glad to use my home street because it's going to be changed. When we set up the bylaws, there will be, you know, you have the same issue. You know, the main office is. The other office is used to tell. So you need a mailing address too. It's a street and a street. Because this is just an interim. Well, it's not really an interim. I mean, it's it unless you change it.
1:47:52 This is on file. This is going to be on file with the state. Correct, correct. And this is legal with the state, and they are going to process off of this. Well, then, do we want to use a different address? The question is, could you use a town address? Do you receive mail at the town? Yeah, as it comes in. Joe will still be a council member. Joe.
1:48:18 Sorry, did I say Joe? Joe will still be coming the next couple of years. The question is can you use that for the initial attitude address of the court?
1:48:30 And if Joe sees mom there, can she do that? I think so. This is where we conduct our business. Yeah, right. That's just simple. Yeah, because come to think of it, I don't want to get in trouble with my CCNRs if all of a sudden I'm conducting the business. Yeah, we don't want you to have to do business. We don't want you to have to move. How big is your kitchen table? Only seat six. I just want to point out under additional statements, this doesn't require action.
1:48:54 By this group, but it is a part of the document that is being signed, and if you have any questions about it, it's all pretty cut and dry. It basically tells us what we're required to do, but in case you have any questions. So just for comparison, MLT is a 501c3c6, which is not a public charity. It's a mutual benefit corporation as opposed to a public benefit corporation. That's the distinction of California.
1:49:24 Both are tax-exempt non-profit organizations. The differential I think is here.
1:49:32 Somebody donating to this one gives a better tax write-off. That's correct. And the other one is not a taxable donation. Correct. You get a tax write-off with a three. And along that line, at any point, if this organization disbands, the funds have to be given to another 501c3. That's correct. So it's just so everybody understands that.
1:49:54 Identified as charitable if this organization ever goes away. That's 5D. Although I noticed in MLTs they've got the same language for theirs as well. And so their assets can't be for the... My guess is their assets were that way because they're primarily town.
1:50:13 So that as this group's out there raising lots of money, it holds some kind of a public benefit. So with that, making those decisions on the document, let's move into a discussion about under number two on that document. While we select in both boxes, we have to identify the specific purpose of the corporation. So Rick and Joe, if you want to know.
1:50:40 When we sat down to talk about this, we actually spent a little bit of time realizing that we had to drill down to what this organization would be and what it would not be. And I think Dan has actually got the notes on it that there were certain things that one of the things is timelessness. You don't write it as of now. You write it what it is and will be.
1:51:05 Also that, and you'll go through that list specifically, right? The things he wasn't. My most important one was to make sure that we were given a purpose that recognizes the fact that they'll be out there raising their own money and doing their own things with it in addition. So we didn't want to write anything into it that made it sound like all the money only would ever come from the town for her.
1:51:28 Jenny, you've got the rest of them there in your notes. Thank you. So here's a couple of the comments that, again, in thinking about what it would be and what it wouldn't be, we thought relative to this statement and then obviously to MLR. MLR wouldn't usurp town council authority for approving expenditures of Measure R and U. Doesn't it usurp their authority for making that decision? MLR's decision making is a public process. It will engage with the public as it makes decisions.
1:51:57 MLR has the ability to make its own decisions for expenditure of unrestricted funds received. That was taken into consideration. The formation of MLR shifts responsibility for developing ideas and priorities to an NGO in order to get things done. That's the context for that. And then we discussed enhance, promote, develop, and invest strategically. And in thinking about this, coming up with this language, that's the context that we talked about.
1:52:28 So, let's take a look at it. This is the proposed statement of specific purpose, and this is what goes to the state of California for our articles of incorporation. And to the feds. And to the feds, yes, that's right. It goes to the feds when we get that. When we are incorporated, that goes back to the IRS and to the California Franchise Board, too.
1:52:47 The specific purpose of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to be responsible for identifying and prioritizing Mammoth Lakes Recreation investment opportunities, including development, enhancement, and promotion of our recreational product. At the bottom of the page is the same statement, just with spaces in between so that you can make your notes as we're discussing this. We liked it.
1:53:13 Well, we drafted it. It took an hour to come up with 20 words. Yeah, exactly. My only question would, would you add into there, like, our public recreation product or something to us, public versus private, curating and funding a private? Well, MLR, would you both want it? Well, I don't know, but I mean, the questioner becomes, do you lose the charitable status if it's not a public purpose? It's not.
1:53:40 If it's truly a private for-profit site you're funding, you run into any challenges. I don't really answer that question. I don't believe so. Not if you've said because everything you do is considered public benefit. Well, it's public benefit if you're truly giving money to a private sector that doesn't have a public benefit. Let's say you're funding Snow Creek Athletic Club. And it's a private for-profit organization.
1:54:03 I don't know if you need to have the word public anymore. I don't know. Because I don't know that by putting the public in there does it restrict it. Would you put public slash private? We don't need it. I think you leave it undefined. Mammoth Lakes is capital. I don't know if that's a town or if that's a region or if that's an area.
1:54:33 Do we want to put programming anywhere in there? Yeah, I just wrote that in between development and enhancement programming. Because I guess that would speak specifically to the track to me. You know, the track is one of those things that I think MLR needs to take on as far as... Well, as far as enhancing it or actually programming it? I think partially enhancing and programming it goes hand in hand. I think they're both. I think that the...
1:55:04 You have community recreation that's programming some parts of it, but when it comes to high altitude training and, you know, camps, outside camps and stuff like that, that isn't the purview of community recreation that would be. So those are some of the just kind of things. I would agree with having that after enhancement, development, enhancement, programming, and promotion. That's good. I think even just on the music side of things, we can get the point where we're programming Tuesday night activities.
1:55:33 I mean, it's the programmatic side of it, not just the development. Okay. So, at the risk of displaying my ignorance, can we have a discussion about whether that apostrophe ought to be in it? Oh, out of Mammoth Lakeses? Yeah, thank you, because it was put in there to recognize, you know, ownership of, you know, Mammoth Lakes. Is that town? Is that...
1:56:02 Community, what does that mean? So, good question. Who's the ownership of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Park? It's funny because when we were talking about it, I never saw the adoption. Yeah, when I came back and routed it and tied it up, I was like, okay, does that show ownership? Do we need to show ownership?
1:56:23 Or not? What we discussed was, I think we'd be better off without it because what we discussed, it's kind of like what MLT ended up doing is it's a mammoth recreation investment opportunity but it does not necessarily say whether it's inside or outside of any kind of a particular limit. So in that case, I think it just refers to, I would take it out because I think the ownership
1:56:53 Is there any way, and, you know, let's say the South County Recreation District discussion comes up again, we don't want people to think that, you know, because I know you guys actually had to say, this doesn't mean it all happens inside the town.
1:57:09 No, and that's when you're going to reach out to Mono County, and I'm not sure that it doesn't even, it can't even go to any county. No, it could, yeah. I think that, you know, those are broader discussions as you go down the road, but. So, that's why we didn't include, so, to me, it's better off without the. Well, I agree. We're not going to just stop.
1:57:31 No, we're not. As I say, we've got all those different boundaries and limitations, but we're trying not to. Yeah, and we actually, and then again, to make it straightforward and simple, we didn't put in or outside. We just said, well, if it's... So what about the... I have two others. What about the word... I'm sorry. I mean, we had this discussion. We spent an hour or two on it. But we also slept on it, too.
1:57:59 The question is whether in the last, second to last line, the word hour, what does that mean? Does that mean? Promotion of recreation products. Okay, so let's be very honest here. It was added because, Teri, what you just said is how we had it. And promotion of recreation product.
1:58:19 It didn't leave. That doesn't feel right. What does it mean? So power was added to represent the M&A law. Should it be promotion of the Eastern Sierra's recreation product or the recreation product of the Eastern Sierra? I'd like us to be broad, but I don't want to set us up to be broad because then all of a sudden it's going to call and say, well, we want you to do X. I don't want us to set up to be the organization for everyone. Like Mimic Lake Stores, and we're funded by TOT and now T-Bit.
1:58:48 But we recognize that we fill our beds by trying to send them to the podium, and proudly, and all those other places. But, you know, so we don't want to limit ourselves to, you know, we're only going to promote what's going to be in Forest Browns. We're still the hub. But I also don't want to say we're the Eastern Sierra Tourism Office. You could have a promotion of such recreation product. Or what if you just say promotion of recreation products and take out the...
1:59:15 I think the hour is tough. I don't know what hour we prefer, who it is. That's right, that's fair. If we just change the recreation products, that also will be more open. And I think you're right, if we start putting in Eastern Sierra, then we start getting, yeah. But, because if it's not stated, if there's something that comes up, and somebody wants to do something, and they've got the money, and they just need somebody to make it happen. So the other thing that I had, and some of that's regulated by our ordinances, too.
1:59:45 Well, you know, you're taking the money, that's the question. And restricted funds. Restricted funds. Yeah, unrestricted funds outside. Sorry, I'm just making notes, but so formation, promotion of recreation products. Products. Is that kind of the R? Yeah. Well, we'll make it to recreation products. Yeah. Okay. Well, so, you know, I wasn't thinking about this the other day, but we had an email exchange among the three of us today, and the question is whether the term funding should be in here.
2:00:13 If so, in what context or capacity? Because, I mean, we do these things, but if we want to go out, if we, if it wants to go out and do something with money that is, for example, not our or you monies, does it have the authority or should it be included in its purpose that it will fund, directly fund projects that it wants to do? Isn't it part of development?
2:00:47 I think so. And let me ask you a different question. I don't know. I'm asking. And I ask the question, too. I ask the question because we spent time reviewing this and we came up with these two verbs, identifying and prioritizing. But MLR also is going to have funding responsibilities and or opportunities and or responsibilities. And if we don't have it in there as a verb, does that...
2:01:15 I like it. I like it because I think that's one of the core purposes of what you've set up to do is the fun things. Except that on the other hand, let me give you an example of the Friends of the Library. Since it was established, broke off in the county, and essentially it was a very simple one, essentially it's to support the branch library and the community. We've actually ended up with two separate endowments that have been set up.
2:01:40 Where we have long-term things. And we didn't go back and change our purpose because those two endowments still support whatever. We didn't specifically, you know, have to say that, you know, because we're obviously able to fund things out of them that we wouldn't have funded out of membership dues. How about if you put, so for identifying and prioritizing and raising funds to move?
2:02:09 Manifest Recreation Forward By
2:02:14 through investment, opportunities, development. You just doubled the purchase. I was just saying opportunities included. Let's be really careful. You did. Let's be really careful. We started out with a longer sentence, by the way. Let's be certain. This is not a mission statement. This advises the Secretary of State what it is that this organization is going to do. I don't want to confuse people because
2:02:43 Depending on the source of the money, this group is not the one who makes the funding decision. And that's, you know, so that... We don't say it's responsible. We're not making the decision, we're saying it's responsible. But the goal is to actually raise funding, and you're telling people that that's part of our purpose to go raise money as well as... Well, but then I see that as that's what you spell out in your mission and goals and objectives, that no organization exists without fundraising.
2:03:11 Is this a question for the Secretary of State? I don't care. Two things. I would vote to leave funding out of this, personally. And the second thing that I identified is whether the word responsible is the most appropriate word there. We can maybe look at engage in identifying because the idea that it's solely responsible for all of Mammoth Lakes Recreation investment.
2:03:42 I don't think it's the intent. So that would just be one suggestion of mine that you would rethink the sole responsibility. And how did you leave funding out? I just, I think that that's encompassed in development. I think it's understood that that's a piece of it. You may be right on that one. I'm not sure about your first point because it really is my intention to have this very clearly move away from how many structures.
2:04:15 I agree with Colin on the responsible part, because the thing that I don't want to see is I don't want to see these side of the aisle saying, we're done, you guys do it. I mean, because I do see that as a, I mean, it's just like, it's just like being a chamber where people call you and say, why don't you fill in my purse? You know. I just think we've talked a lot, we've talked a lot throughout this process about the necessity of having synergy between Venus Perrette and MLR.
2:04:46 I think there's a lot of entities that are going to go into the pod with controlling, development, enhancing, promoting recreation product here, so I think to say that this is responsible for it. What about saying it's a leading resource? I might not make it even simpler to say the specific purpose of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to identify and prioritize. There you go. I mean, this is obviously some analytics, but that's...
2:05:18 Who likes words? No, but it's important. Yeah, sure. Okay, so now the one thing I need, before I read it through for everybody, is where did we stick programming? Did we stick it after enhancement? Okay. That's right, that's what I heard. Okay. Yeah. And I'm sorry, I'm an all-time grammarian, I think you need to have the comma before the end. Yeah. So what I have, is this what we've got so far?
2:05:45 The specific purpose of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to identify and prioritize Mammoth Lakes without the apostrophe recreation investment opportunities including development, enhancement, programming, and promotion of recreation products. Kind of there.
2:06:16 Well, I'm going to try to. I'm trying to figure out which pieces have been scratched out. Okay, well, and the specific purpose is only there, George, because that's what's on the form. So we were just pulling, we don't get to change that word, because that's on the form. He has. The purpose of Mammoth Lakes Creation is to identify and prioritize Mammoth Lakes Recreation opportunities. And I'm not sure what goes in.
2:06:45 Yeah, I know, but I'm not sure. Is there something, is that including got something with it? Comma. Comma. Oh, okay, thank you. Including development enhancement and promotion of recreation, period. So you suggested take out the product and take out investment. Essentially, right? I think investment goes to the role that MLR is playing. I think investment relates back to the funding discussion.
2:07:15 And you don't have to say specific. You can take out specific. No, no, no. Let's understand this. If you look here, all we did was copy what it says here. The specific purpose of this corporation is to write. Fill in the blank. Okay. However, on the bylaws, it will read the purposes. Yeah, okay. We're talking about it because it's on the form already. Okay. I'm fine with dropping this. Makes it broader.
2:07:45 Okay, what about taking out just any Mammoth Lakes Recreation? From an editor who can't write very well, George. No, I can't read who's writing. To your point is the specific purpose of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to identify and prioritize Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Yeah. Yeah. No, enhancement of promotion.
2:08:12 Including Development, Enhancement, and Promotion of Recreation Period. He's saying take off. Yeah. So take off of recreation period and take products off. Okay. Did I catch all of them, John?
2:08:37 Less is more. Is there any other thought here from this group? Because I'm going to ask the public if they have any additional comments. Okay, so we're taking investment off as well? Yeah. If you read again, Joel, as proposed, kind of. Okay. For the forum, the specific purpose of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to identify and prioritize Mammoth Lakes Recreation Opportunities Colony, including development, enhancement, programming, and promotion of recreation.
2:09:09 All right. Are there any public comments on this? We put in promotion because this speaks to how we're engaging with ASICS and REI and anybody else out there that we can tap into to partner with this and to promote Mammoth as that recreation
2:09:42 place that they want to bring their product into and that they want to develop their product and they want to test their product and they want to have their product be here. And it also implies advocacy. Yeah, advocacy. It also implies advocacy on recreation. That's another way of promoting recreation is to be an advocate for it. To be the voice of recreation. No, I want it broader. This is the voice of recreation. Broad as it can be.
2:10:12 It could. And it might. It could. And within. Well, I think we want to talk about even just the high school running groups. Yeah. If we're talking about promoting the high school running groups. Yeah. That is something that we want to do. Right. So I don't think we want to study that. No, and within, again, within the.
2:10:32 Goals and Objectives or the Strategies, you would find exactly the definitions for that. Because no matter what word we put in there, well, any of these words you get, we could say, well, what is enhancement? Yeah. I think it's important because we have to have the advocacy. Did you have another comment? I think we need to be broader as opposed to narrower in that. This is a broad statement. Is the management of recreation programs or things covered with us? If you say program, yeah.
2:11:03 Programming encompasses that? Is there a need to? Development would encompass the management. Programming would encompass the management. You want to give an example? I just, it seems like it's an area that MLR might get involved in. I just want to, it's online programming, ongoing capacities. What's that, Dan? I just want to go a little careful on it.
2:11:35 I like the idea of as the MLR starts to look at the best of things, there's a management structure there, but if it's our new side of it, you're managing town funds, which the organization says it's town managed, and so I wouldn't want to run in front of it like you're walking over there, but for MLR to be able to do some things, I think it's interesting. I think that the development would actually, yeah. Are there any thoughts about management?
2:12:01 Development. I agree with Dan because I think it goes back to the whole MLR is not going to be the entity mowing the grass in the park. Again, and within a strategy because this is just you try to make your purpose statement broad so you're not in trouble later with somebody saying you're not following what's in your purpose or you can't get out. Thanks for the comment. Pat, do you have a question? What's that again?
2:12:43 It's used to fund things that are managed by the town versus managed by the town. Correct, but remember, this is the purpose for an organization that will have other funds to manage as well, and we need to leave it open enough. One other comment is that it seems to me that this organization is going to be that the fundraising, or I don't know if that's still a question, but the funding is going to be. Again, this is not a mission statement. This is a statement of purpose.
2:13:24 It's not specific. Except for when you're talking about development, then you're going to have to, if you're going to develop something, there's going to have to be something like a fundraising to do. Enhancement would have to be fundraising. Or funding. I mean, development is pretty broad.
2:13:51 A pretty broad definition in that regard. Most NGOs have a development director that's in charge for developing money. Yeah. You know, so it's pretty broad, pretty broad based. I think these are captured. Yeah. Is there any other? John, to be clear, you'd leave management in or out? Out. Out. Nobody included it.
2:14:16 Do you want me to read it once more? Yes. The specific purpose of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to identify and prioritize Mammoth Lakes, no apostrophe, recreation opportunities, comma, including development, comma, enhancement, comma, programming, comma, and promotion of recreation. So moved. Check. Let's entertain that motion. Is that you, Rick? Yes, it was. Is there a second? Second.
2:14:43 John. Did I hear that? I'm sorry. I think that was the last one. I think so. I think we had several. We need to have a specific person. John. I had John. I heard John. I didn't hear Colin. I'm sorry. I heard John. I don't think it's a promise. Okay. Move and second to approve the statement of purpose as read by Joe. Any comments? All those in favor. Aye. Any opposed?
2:15:13 Okay. Thanks for taking it. Thanks for your comments. Thanks for editing. Okay. Then there's the second half of number seven, which Rick alluded to earlier.
2:15:24 But that there are several cases of the bylaws that deal with, you know, the California Code on notification and meetings and things like that. And we do not expect you to all, you used the blog, but I would call it slog through that. But there are certain things that we just wanted to bring forward that we see are issues that the full committee will discuss. So that's the half sheet with a bunch of bullet points.
2:15:49 That would include board composition, board qualifications, board powers and authorities, board terms, board nomination procedure, which oops, got too many easing, what officers are needed, the discussion on the fact that it would not be a membership-based organization, relationship to town, like...
2:16:09 You know, there were previous comments about the bylaws had to be reviewed by the town, etc. The executive director or CRO duties and authorities. And then the last bullet is something we talked about that I'm familiar with other organizations is you don't clutter up your bylaws with a whole bunch of your procedural items. You have a set of rules that the board may change at time. Everything from, you know, your records of retention, specific duties, reporting requirements, so on and so forth.
2:16:39 That you do not put into your bylaws, you put them into a separate document that's referenced in the bylaws saying that the procedural or operational issues are handled outside the bylaws. So that you don't have 47-page bylaws. So what we're sharing today is these are the topics that we will come back to you with recommendations on for what the language is going to look like and what the...
2:17:06 Bylaws you're going to include. So your ad hoc group will continue to meet on this and come up with recommendations to bring back to you to look at, review, consider, and comment on and approve. But if you're also on any other boards, yeah, or if there's something that you think we didn't find in reading through a bunch. You have board powers and authorities. Do you need officer powers and authorities? Well, yeah, that was kind of, well...
2:17:33 Kind of encompass that some of your board members under those powers and authorities are also officers who have specific duties that in the bylaws you just say, you know, like, the president will convene the meetings, but over in your standing rules, if there are certain things your president has to do, usually all that falls on your treasurer, but, you know, that you list those specifics elsewhere so that every time you might change them, you're not having to go through bylaws changes. But do you see that there would be
2:18:00 A power assigned to an officer that wasn't assigned to them as being a board member, other than things like presiding over the meeting? Signing. Signing authority. Signing authority. You need two. You need two signatures on something. Like in my case, I need two signatures over $500. Okay. And now that can actually be handled in the standing, these separate rules. That can be handled in your separate rules.
2:18:22 Or you can put it in. Well, those are pretty standard, though. I don't think they're going to necessarily change. But the amount might change or things like that? Not if the council doesn't allow it. Well, here's the deal. Let's take it into consideration. Let's go back and look for John. I appreciate you bringing that in. Because if you remember, the reason for putting that in for MLT very specifically had to do with the public's perception from many, many, many years ago.
2:18:48 about whatever was happening with them. So this was to assure that there was... But it's not a bad thing to do, and as opposed to just having a rule that can be changed where it doesn't have to go through a process, a bylaw has to go through a process, and it has to be adopted, amended, and so that should still be... Well, I'm just pointing out, it's kind of like, you know, we all say that, you know, in the future when we're making that final payment of $2 million...
2:19:14 It won't be as much money as it is in today's market, so that if you put certain levels or things like that. Yeah, and I mean, that's just like, you know. We're pretty specific. Yeah, and I don't think that's a bad thing.
2:19:27 When you're talking about public perception and public comment. So since we're talking about that, you know, most of these organizations are non-member organizations. I would expect to be a non-member organization, which means it would be board of directors and planners. So you amend bylaws by either a majority or supermajority of the board, but you also change rules by a majority or supermajority of the board.
2:19:50 Board, so the process is always public because board meetings are public. So we'll come back with what we think is the right thing to do on these bylaws, whether we include the degree of specificity. I mean, normally on the officers, as opposed to providing power and authority, which you would for the board of directors, you're prescribing duties. And so, you know, we could be as...
2:20:19 Brief or as extensive in that description. From you guys, anything else you want to say, based on your experience or interaction, groups that you've engaged with, bylaws that you've corrected, that you've seen for you? With the board composition, you'll deal with the recommended size? Well, the full committee will, yeah. Composition is, yeah. And in fact, just to give you an example, in the MLT bylaws, one of the ones we reviewed,
2:20:54 They actually have designated seats, if you want to call it that. So that whole discussion. As does Mammoth Lakes Housing. Right. And in fact, Mammoth Lakes Housing had a really interesting salesperson kind of. I'm not using the word right, but it has an extra officer that does sales. So I think to answer your question, size is included in composition. Yeah, that's my question. Yeah, but that was part of them. Yeah, right.
2:21:20 I'm having a little trouble wrapping my head around qualifications. Is that going to be something that's going to be extremely broad and shorter? I don't know. Yeah, what are your thoughts on that? What do you think? You know, that's where I have got my comment is to look at the strategies. We're not going to define the qualifications right now, but any feedback that you might have. I just think the more level of detail you put into a qualification structure, the more you pitch it for yourself.
2:21:50 Well, I think some of them were listed in other places, like, do they have to be a resident of town? That's what I'm talking about. In our case, they have to be business license owners. They have to be representatives. There's got to be some basic qualifications. Well, and that was a conversation I'm trying to have. That rudimentary versus... They own a business, they have three kids. They're like the color purple. Yeah.
2:22:14 Do they have to be a resident within the town? Is it 10 miles outside of town? 20, 30, 50? Can they be a second homeowner? You know, what type of... Those were my comments that I... And in a way, Colin, board qualifications is also a bit of a job description so people who apply know what's going to be expected of them. You know, like...
2:22:39 Discussions of, you know, is it a working board or those kinds of things that we'll bring back for the discussion. Yeah, it's essentially a mini job description. Yeah, and you want certain, you know, someone to fill different qualities or qualifications within, you know, your board. You don't want to have ten people that really all kind of focus in on the same thing. And it includes, yeah, and it kind of includes what Juliana said earlier about the wisdom, wealth, and work, you know.
2:23:07 There's, yeah. It needs to be broad enough that you can gather those people and have that input, but it needs to, you know. Okay. But it's not so broad that it dilutes. Yeah. I think you're right, though. Is that? Yeah. You know, you can't find a way to serve in the seat because nobody needs to call it. Yeah, right. Yeah. Okay. And I think that's also part of composition of it. You know, are there special seats? You know, are there assigned seats as well? Assigned seats, yeah.
2:23:36 I think composition should have a higher level of detail. I think the board composition should have a higher level of detail. Than the qualifications. Okay.
2:24:06 And actually I would say that's what MLT has too. Yeah, board composition is specific. Yeah, sure, sure, yeah, exactly. Whereas, I don't know what the qualifications are. You would know better than me, but it seems to be.
2:24:28 Those are some pretty amazing stuff. Living, breathing. It is more composition. I mean, this goes without saying, but if you're going to sit in the lodging seat, you're representing lodging. Even on the composition side, I mean, we just went from 7 to 9 to 4. So I mean, that's composition. It's not just the positions themselves. It's the actual. Right.
2:24:53 Okay, good. Any other thoughts about this? So, I've got it. Yeah. So, we look at more detail on the board composition, the board qualifications, a little more broad-based. And then we also talk about officers' duties under rules or under the bylaws. And then, Rick, your comment about...
2:25:14 Because we're not a membership-based organization, or because MLR is not a membership-based organization, changes are going to occur to bylaws by the majority of the board. And I'm not sure that the duties doesn't fall more under the board qualifications as well. I mean, you're going to be looking at that. Well, but see, that's an issue that will have to be discussed too, is whether, you know, because the board will then appoint the officers.
2:25:38 Well, you're always going to have your standing officers. Every board has to have your standing officers. And then what you do beyond that for whatever you're looking, is it a fundraising person? Is it a person that's going after certain spectrum of programming? I'm laughing because I remember MLT, there was a lot of discussion before the whole group. It was just an ad hoc group talking about...
2:26:04 The length of term for the president and how much time you had to be on the board in order to be the president and to be the vice president. I mean, it was a chase. And I think that's actually causing us some trouble. It does make it difficult to put oppositions. Yeah, it is. It was a wild chase. It was a wild, crazy chase that we had to do. So, good lesson learned. Yeah, lesson learned. Yeah, yeah, it's very good. Any other comments from this group on this?
2:26:33 Public comments on this? Okay, great. All right, so we'll come back to you. This group will continue to come back to you with drafts for you to respond to and provide comments on it. Okay. Can I ask just a quick side question at the end? Are we going to review what, because I know number eight is part of it, but the only thing we put a date to is the elevator speech so far, right? The elevator and then...
2:27:01 I think everyone wouldn't remember what we're supposed to be doing. Well, we're just sending out. Oh, we have to do. That's pretty bad. We have to do the, Terry, you and I have to do. Refresh my, Dan and Terry, legal. We're going to go through. Right, sorry. We're going through the two ordinances. Yeah, yeah, okay. There you go. I've got to refresh my, Dan, what we're supposed to be doing. Yes. All right. So let's move on now to agenda item number eight.
2:27:31 And that needs to be back. So in thinking about here we are on March 17th and May 21st is around the corner. I'm thinking about the action that the council is expected to take that night. What is it that this group needs to have in front of the council for that decision-making process? And it was thought about
2:27:58 Can we identify that today or can we give it some definition today so that it helps guide this group's work also, that we're not, we don't end up on May 20th realizing that we don't have something that the council is expecting to have or needed to have in order to make a decision, but we're not sure what that decision is. And so I'm looking at the two council members here, and Dan, I'm looking at you also to see if there's any definition or thought given to what action the council is going to be taking on the 21st.
2:28:28 Sorry, I was just going to go over to Fran because apparently it's not available. Just to give you an example is, you know, we set up a few tasks for this meeting, but I know we haven't met yet on this plan, scope of work, etc. But in my mind, I started thinking, okay, to do that, we have to confirm the slotting exercise to know what's in the scope of work. And to do that, we needed the legal questions. So it's almost like doing, you know, that...
2:28:55 Got off a Microsoft program called Project Rehab. But my thought was that there are certain things that we know we need to have a scope of work that goes to council because otherwise they won't be able to do it. And I was trying to pull up that page out of the agenda bill. And I don't know, is somebody going to write this stuff up? I mean, on the board. Where's the agenda bill? Okay.
2:29:27 So we're supposed to take, in essence, our job is take the necessary steps to create MLR and then we get to the detail, that and the options. We have a bunch of things to do, some of which, again, it's like your questions of timing, which comes before and after. But, so we have to
2:29:58 These are on here. It's the one we already talked about in the whole business of the short-term suspension. The second one was developed with the town interpret the appropriate legal structure for the allocation and use of Measure R. So I think we've got that under legal questions. But we have to have the use of R and U.
2:30:22 Well, that was up there. Do you want it listed out separately? Yeah. But we won't be doing the reconciliation. I was just pulling out the pieces that we have to do. Oh, what MLR is supposed to do. Yeah. Engage partners. I'm just making it. Engage partners? Engage partners, yeah.
2:30:41 Well, the town manager is going to assist us in that. So here's my question. Is there an expectation by the council that this group will come back with a report out that says we met with this, this, this, and this? Okay. So is that... Let me jump in a little bit on this and maybe get joined with a little bit. The actual action by the council on the 21st would be it's accepting the formation that's been set up, the 501c3 process. It's accepting that stuff. And I guess the key element for the town council at that point...
2:31:11 Would we be entering into a formal or draft agreement at that point for recreation services? That would be the key action. In addition to scope of work, it's also contractual structure. I think if you have those things, is the council actually approving at that point a draft agreement or a final agreement to move this into the next fiscal year, for lack of a better term here, that we're now under contract with MLR as currently formed?
2:31:41 to do these services. Yeah, but I know, and I agree with you, Dan, except that since it says the structure, it doesn't mean that the actual contract has to be done when we go back. My question is what are you going to approve that locks it in, I guess, to move it forward is kind of what I'm dialoguing. And it may be two different meetings to get that done.
2:32:06 Based on other ones where concepts have come before it, and I will go back to MLT, is when it was presented, when that level of scope of work and structure was presented, that council turned to staff and said, make it so. Correct. Now, the one piece, though, that isn't in there, but I think is going to be expected, is what's the board going to look like? Yeah.
2:32:31 I think that's in the formation document. Yeah, you know, the recommendations on how that board is actually established has to be part of this. I'm assuming that's something that the council is accepting. So that when we get through all these things, and oh, you know, there were things like that we would, so that the bylaws themselves incorporate a lot of the things that I think the council will want to know. The council is not going to really care about.
2:32:54 How many people sign checks and how that all works, but they are going to worry about the governance questions. Can I ask a clarifying question to you two?
2:33:08 The Council is going to want to know the board. Are they looking for names that are on the board? No, I think they're going to want, I think they're going to want, it depends on how we write the section, but I think they're going to want to know composition and those kinds of things and the structure for a nomination of that board. Okay, so there's not an expectation that there will be any names attached to that board on May 21st? Yes. You think there are? Yes. And you think that we can get there? So, how do we... I'm going to get, you know, within one foot of the...
2:33:37 I don't think so. My expectation is that we're going to move forward and allow this council that made this vote to form, authorize the specific formation, authorize or weigh in on the bylaws, authorize the, not weigh in, but appoint the first board, and that may be a transition board.
2:34:07 It likely will be. Maybe it won't. We'll have to have a discussion about that. And direct it to have its first meeting and begin doing business. I also think, I don't think you need a contract just yet. I think you need to get pretty close by having the council approve the scope of work and, as you have said, make it so. It seems to me if you can accomplish that, you've accomplished the objective that was set out nearly a year ago.
2:34:37 I think that's the key. All right. Well, and if we are going to get that far, then we're going to have a lot of work to do in here. We are. This is, we are. But look, we've been at it a long time, too. That's true, we have. How do you guys feel about that in understanding? I've got three things up there. You know, our scope of work that is intended to inform the future contract of the town and all.
2:35:07 Legal Definitions that the Council was looking for, and then also MLR Board Composition to include names or nods. Yes, and also, you know, entity formation. We've got... I mean, we've already authorized that to occur, but... Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Yeah, and to say that it's been done. Right. Yeah. Yeah, the blessing of the debt. Yes. You won't have feedback from the IRS at that point, but it will be...
2:35:39 No, but we should have feedback from Secretary of State. Well, the articles will be filed, and they're running only about four days behind right now. I just looked on the website today. So you can file articles, and four days later, you get them back. Six days later, you get them back. So the delays that we had a year ago are gone. And that's all you need, because formation occurs not when the articles are filed, but when the board has its first meeting. And I think the council ought to say,
2:36:05 Go get that done. And by the way, we think that the board members ought to be, the composition ought to be this, and the board members ought to be that. Because it's the incorporator that actually nominates the initial board. And then the incorporator resigns, the incorporator moves away.
2:36:31 Although that may be the same person. The point is, it abandons that position because there's nothing left. Right. And then you have your first board meeting to follow the bylaws? Yeah. Adopt the bylaws and then obviously adopt the scope of work. So then, presuming that those are the things we need, then that's all we're going to need. The focus is going to switch. Some of the subcommittee's work is just going to be filed for now.
2:37:02 We really only have three more working meetings for our big body. Yeah, for the big body, and we've got a lot of things to talk through. Well, we do, but I think that we can get through that stuff, because although I know that we want to make sure that we have this grand opportunity to have multi-hour meetings in order to have input, but this is very stock stuff. It's not that complicated.
2:37:32 What I think the most important thing to do now during this period is to begin that outreach program. Get the input from the community. Educate the community as to what it is that we've been doing because we're assuming that we know it all and I think it's a false assumption or wrong assumption and those are the things that will ultimately culminate into whatever the council is going to authorize at the last meeting in May or the first meeting in June.
2:38:04 So you would add after analog board composition and names? I would identify the first board, yes. And those are the four things that we think are going to go to the council to make a decision and approve. We're asking them to approve this. Then your structure is formed. We'll spend the next year, six months or a year, doing what MLT took a year to do.
2:38:34 Do you think they're going to expect to see anything on a description of the CRO or executive director or whatever it is? I don't think so. I think in the context of the work that the MLR board will have in front of them, that's one of those assignments, and they will be defining and coming back with, here's what the...
2:39:03 CRO will do. Yeah, yeah, that's the way I see it. Because it was listed in there. There's an interest, but does the council approve it? No. The council doesn't approve the CRO. No, as it's saying, that that's part of the scope of work. The scope of work may be to have work. No, right. Well, that's part of the board's code, just to hire them. Exactly. You don't have to keep going back to the council. Yeah.
2:39:31 Just to clarify, your scope of work will include a discussion about the relationship between the town and the MLR, because that kind of speaks to the contract discussion. That'll feed into that legal definition requirement in some cases. So when you guys went through this one that we haven't had a chance to read yet, did you list out those things that were under the formation part at the end, the next steps?
2:40:02 The relationship with the town, is that in there? Yes. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Pretty comprehensive. No, I didn't. I wasn't going to stop to read it. Yeah, no, no, but they pulled out of the classroom. Dan, are you? I can't pull it all down. Anything else? Well, I think that as we go into our next, as more information comes forward, that may adjust a little bit. But that's a start.
2:40:32 There's something that you said in the outreach part of it, and POM has been referenced also, that we're going out to the public to solicit input, get some feedback, or input to helping to inform some of these decisions here. I'm just thinking about the schedule for that, and kind of turning to you guys, you two, when you're coming up with that elevator speech, you're going to take this that you provided us and put it in.
2:41:01 Kind of prioritize it a little bit. Right. And identify those that we've already in place and we'll just plug in where we can as we get lists from folks and as we get meeting advisements. Yeah, the way I was thinking of structuring it is basically, you know, breaking it down by priority level, by establishing times that we already know exist, establishing who's going to be there, a calendar, and then as those times come and pass, we add feedback to each of those sections.
2:41:31 I'm kind of, sorry, I'm just thinking, in receiving that information, how we're receiving it and how we're getting it right back out to you guys. And Deanna, you and I should probably clarify this.
2:41:45 If it's coming in, I think it should come here to the chair and then we can route it out to you guys and that way we've got, we know what's coming in and we can follow. Yes, and so that we're not missing or skipping over something or I thought you did it or I thought you, you know.
2:42:01 But we'll get back out. Okay. Sounds good. So we all know where we're going and who's got what responsibilities with that. Sounds good. I can get on that. Okay, perfect. I appreciate you guys doing that. All right. Any other comment about the council meeting on the 21st? And we're still on for the 21st, do you think? Yeah, both. Perfect.
2:42:22 Good. I mean, it could slip to the first meeting in June. Or it might have to be carried over if there were more questions. And that's really where I want to be so that if it becomes, because that's going to be our budget meeting as well. That is the 21st has budget on it? Well, at least I have a budget. Yeah, I assume. But it's going to be a pretty big meeting.
2:42:50 All right. Any comments from the public on that? So you understand what's going on on the 21st? What was that comment? That's not paid? As opposed to who's not paid? The board itself. It's not compensated. Not compensated? Yeah, it's not going to be decided. I'm just saying. Are you talking about this group right now?
2:43:19 Thank you.
2:43:50 Great. Any other comments from the public? All right. Moving on to item number nine. I added this just as an opportunity for this body to share among itself any other comments or thoughts that we don't address during the agenda items. And if there's anything that you think is pertinent for the rest of the group to hear, I wanted to just put this on there so that you have a chance to share it with the rest of your committee members publicly. So I just put it on here. Roundtable, if you have anything.
2:44:20 Green that you want to share, and here's the opportunity to do it. Well, I have a question, and then I also want to say, is this where we also figure out what we're doing at the next meeting? Or is that number 10? I've got a request for future Jedi. All right. I didn't see it in the notes, but did we obtain the mammothlakesrecreation.org domain name? Yeah, I just pronounced that. We've got mammothlakesrecreation.org and .com.
2:44:46 .com we had, .net and .org.
2:44:50 .net and .org was retained.
2:44:58 Yeah, we looked at MLR.
2:45:00 No, no, no.
2:45:01 We did not ask for MLR.com.
2:45:04 I went to check and see if it was written.
2:45:05 I went to check and it's already taken.
2:45:07 Was there a .net or .R.org?
2:45:10 You don't want MLR because it's like 8,000 bucks.
2:45:13 there's too many things that are related to it
2:45:16 it came up
2:45:18 if you google MLR you'll get
2:45:20 Got it. Mammoth Lakes Recreation has a domain. We've got three. We've got three of those domains, com, net, and org. Well, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, we utilize .com, so you would have .net, .org. But I think that our discussion was that .org works much better if you're going to be doing practice. Do you have another question? No, my second one was figuring out what was for the next agenda. Okay.
2:45:50 Terry, anything, Colin, John, anything you want to share? Dan, did you have anything else you wanted to share? Just quickly, you got that in place, it'll come kind of the next, ready to look at notes. Andy can meet on the 7th by phone, April 7th by phone in the afternoon, or on the 9th he can do it in person, April 9th in person.
2:46:19 April 7th, that'd be Monday or Wednesday of that week basically for the night, the 7th of the night he can meet. He's going to be up here on the 9th? 7th by phone, on the 9th he can come up for the meeting. And how much time, what time on the 9th? I told him 3 to 5. 3 to 5 on the 9th? It's on for any of these meetings. Does it make a difference? I could make it work.
2:46:41 So which one? I think in person would be better, so I'll adjust my schedule. I think in person's better. You'll be on the phone. I think there's a planning condition. You've got a 3.30 to 4.30. Hold on a second. Let me go back to the town website and see. Just whenever she can get up here is a problem. Yeah. I think there should be planning conditions. Can we change the...
2:47:11 What time do you guys plan and commission at 9? On the 9th, I believe, at 2. But do you know what kind of an agenda you've got? Or if you have a meeting? Yeah, I'm not positive, but... So, could you, like, if the meeting ends at 4, could you come in and join us for the last hour of discussion with Angie? Or wouldn't we be in here as well? We'd have to move it somewhere, yeah. Certainly.
2:47:40 You know, usually we're two to five. Two to five? But if it's a short agenda, we might be done by four. How about a five o'clock meeting? I was going to say, if we could do a five-hour, we could do a four o'clock meeting, or a five o'clock meeting. We could do an hour. You don't need more than an hour. If we give our general comments to him in advance, and questions, he can be prepared to answer them, and we have to do more boxes. I didn't mean to nail down the time, so. Let's do five o'clock.
2:48:08 Well, he said afternoon, but he's driving back, back and forth that day. He's used to it. He would drive up here that day and then head home after.
2:48:22 He has home at 11.15 now. Okay, so we're at 4.9. Can we say 5 p.m.? I'll confirm that. And if it needs to be earlier, advise us. If it needs to be earlier, try to move it to 4 at the earliest. And that'd be sweet.
2:48:42 Yeah. We have to. We can always hold it. Yeah. Well, but we could also ask the Planning Commission to only just, you know, to only have action items on that one particular agenda if that's appropriate. Okay, that's good with us. So 5 o'clock unless we need to change it to accommodate his schedule. Yeah. So 5 o'clock on the night. 5 o'clock on the night. Okay. Okay. And we'll plan for speed. He'll confirm that with us. So basically we've got, right now we've got the 31st and then the 9th. And then the 9th. Okay. Exactly. All right.
2:49:12 Okay, thanks Dan and Dad. Just to have on everyone's radar, we're doing the Plan Your Parks session at the Community Center on Thursday from 4 to 7, which I think would be a great place for if you guys are available to come and get some community engagement with what people are looking for. Thursday the 20th, March 20th from 4 to 7 p.m.
2:49:41 Planning Parks, Community Center. And then actually I do have a question. Since we're putting so many dates and things into the notes, is it, you know, when I have draft notes, can't those just be distributed to the whole group so they can review them and stuff, you know, because one of the things that really bothered me is there was no reminder of this, you know, of everybody, hey, don't forget you guys have got such and such data. Okay.
2:50:07 Yeah, we can get, yeah, I didn't get the notes until. I mean, yeah, I wasn't doing ours since last week. No, I meant the meeting notes. I meant the meeting notes, because this is going to have the dates, you know, everybody's reminding us and stuff. Yeah, we can ship it on. Okay. Okay, so we have the 31st at 3 o'clock. 31st at 3, and then April 9th. 9 o'clock. 5 o'clock. 10 or differently. Right. Both at Sweet D. Sweet D at this time. Yeah, because we have a conflict, it looks like we're moving. Good.
2:50:37 So you have a phone in here? I'm going to make that assumption that I do have a phone. You know what? We have a phone in here for a lawsuit settlement. I would assume that they have a voter settlement. And we have commission, red commission, there's emergency, this is the EOC, so there's a phone. I just got to make sure we get it set up for a conference.
2:51:03 Yeah, so we'll have to give you the number. All right. Dan, we have to get the numbers and we can have a graph called and then come in. Anything else you want to say? For next, for our meeting on the 31st, your bylaws, we'll come back with some draft bylaws for you to look at.
2:51:32 Wait a minute. It would be a report out on anybody that's had a new outreach. I think you need a report out on each. We'll have all each. Yeah. I was just going back to the committee's page, and I've got some new pages here. I mean, yeah. We need to add hogs, but we'll report out on any, like, where it's going to be speaking to the Rotary. Should we start talking about board composition at that point? I think that's part of the time. Yeah, that's what we're going to come back with. Okay. Yeah.
2:52:00 Do we take another shot at finalizing our legal questions since Andy is meeting us? Yeah, and I'll get them to task stuff out that I have out immediately. And then we're going to have whatever we put together as this committee, so then that'll all come back. So we can just make sure we've got our legal issue. The 31st, you can review that. John and Betsy, would we have anything yet from scope of work, et cetera?
2:52:30 Or do we have to get the legal questions first before we even start to talk? We can start doing some framework stuff. I'm not available until next week. I could be available this Friday a little later. Maybe you could do with the scope of work what we're doing with bylaws. These are the things that are going to be in it. We don't need the specifics. That way it can be adjustable. Maybe we can calendar coordinate.
2:52:59 I like that. Thanks for doing that. Anything else? Whether on the committees, I don't have any. No, because the way it gets...
2:53:12 Six, seven, and eight are really just one. Yes. 501c3 is essentially done except for the legal confirmation of it. But we're going to go and file the papers before then, aren't we? We don't actually need to. The processing time is so short now.
2:53:39 All right, anything else you want to add to the agenda? Thoughts on it? Okay. All right, I will thank you all for your work in between this. This is kind of grueling, but it's very important and very helpful. So thanks for your efforts on this. Keep it going. And we will adjourn. Sorry, I'm sorry.
2:54:06 How is it going to work and make out the community event? That's going to be a part of the recommendation for composition and how the board gets seated, so that's going to come forward to this group to decide, and then it'll go out, but this group has to decide what that is first. We're not naming names at our next meeting, so, no. No, that's for the May 21st. We're just starting to have that conversation as to how that would be formed and how that would be done.
2:54:33 Yeah, no names next week. Okay, any other comments from the public? Okay, great, then we can adjourn. Thank you very much, you guys. Sorry.