TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014

Parks & Recreation Commission Formation meeting

· recording 2 hr 58 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

372 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Yep. Yeah, since I'm just doing numbers, is that kind of what you're looking at? Just numbers, yeah.

0:15 A few more people today.

0:45 You're looking puzzled. We have lots of microphones, too. It's almost like one of those old-fashioned press conferences. Uh-oh. Careful. Yeah. Is this going to, like, backfeed or something?

1:14 Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Yes. What did this say? Would Ed be using a mic? Okay. In fact, when he comes back, we can put that one in between. Can you turn that one around so it's racing again? We can have that black one there. Yeah, because Dan and Danny are running the meeting, so we really need to hear that for sure. Mistaken

1:43 I don't know if mine's caffeinated or not. Zen? Zen?

1:58 Whoops. Hi.

2:17 Sorry, I'm just trying to get out of town and I'm trying to finish my month end and trying to do this.

2:41 I know. It's good to be interesting. It's live, yeah. Is there feedback going on because there's so many groups? Yeah.

3:05 Yeah, so I think we're happy. I just wanted to get feedback because they want to start formatting and making it pretty. I didn't want to have to go back and tweak things. No, don't worry about it. Don't worry.

3:21 Don't want to trust me because I was in the first half of the chamber board meeting. I'm excited about where that's going for me, but it goes around. And I just really feel like I'm here. Thank you. We've got Michael Ledesma, we're going back to Mary Ellen, we've got Sandra, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, we've got Sandra, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, we've got Sandra, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm going back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen, I'm back to Mary Ellen,

3:50 Yeah. I think so. He's on the board, yeah. He wasn't able to make it today. Oh, right. Yeah. No, he's another one. So I think we're...

4:03 Slowly getting into a new creative mindset, which is great. I'm very excited about that. Oh, here he is. I guess I'm going to be a scribe tonight, so I'll be up. Start painting. I got to keep you kind of showers. There you go. I'm getting caught now. Just, yeah, do you put a refrigerator? There he is. There's stuff back there.

4:32 So, Joe, great meeting with Hans about plastic bags. Yes, I saw you. They are so supportive of... It's great. Yep. I mean, to the point where they have grant money for us to buy some things and basically buy our grants for plastic bags. I will be at Friday's meeting. I can't remember. I have a meeting with Dan either before or after that. I think it's after that. I think we're at 8. We're stacking them all up. Okay.

4:59 Let's go ahead. I'm going to go ahead and call this meeting to order of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Formation Committee. Sharon, you want to go ahead with roll calls? Secretary Bacon? Here. Committee Member Hurley? Here. Committee Member Kelley? Yes. Committee Member Turek? Here. Committee Member Ernie? Here. Committee Member Wood? Vice Chair Armstrong? Yes.

5:29 Thank you. I'll open it up to any public comments that anyone feels to share with us this afternoon on any items that doesn't show up on our agenda this afternoon. And I will ask that as you are addressing this committee that you use the podium this afternoon and that you also provide your name for the record so that we can keep track of those comments.

5:59 But we will ask that you use the podium. So I'll open it up for any public comments that you would like to share with us this afternoon before we move into the agenda. Hi, I'm Cleland Hoff. And Dana, what you just said may not – my question is very simple, I guess, or my plea to you.

6:38 I'm just waiting until maybe some people are looking at me before I continue. I'm sorry. I am running for town council. I could very well be a dark horse. I feel very confident. I have a lot of confidence in myself and what I can do for this community. I think that this is an issue that needs to be held off until there is the new council in place.

7:09 Myself, I am not up on everything. I think there are a lot of people in town that are not up on everything. But I do believe that if you put in place something that the next council, whoever ends up on council, if it's not me, still give them a fair chance to deal with what you are proposing to put before them.

7:39 because I was in the media for a long time and I do have video and notes that I've taken from meetings. I do know, and I will pull them up if you would like, some of the inconsistencies and I believe that if this is pushed forward at this point that I think the town's going to lose a lot of credibility. I did vote for both measures and I am very poor recreation.

8:10 The only thing difference I have is I have no agenda when it comes to recreation. And so I'm going to go with what is best for town. But if you have a solid plan now, I need a good excuse why it's not going to be a solid plan in two and a half months when the people who will have to answer the questions that are going to be asked. I think that is a very unfair position.

8:39 Put anybody into. And we have seen that over the years in this town. And I know that there are some people that are really wanting to get this going. But I think the most prudent action at this time is to just cool our jets, have faith in the new council, because the people are going to be voting for the council members, and let them decide. And so I hope that didn't.

9:07 Go across the lines that you stipulated, but I did want to get that on record that I have, I have not, I have no position on it right now. My only thing is hold your horses, wait the two and a half months, and let the people who are going to have to answer to the public and to the media be the ones that are backing it up. Okay, thank you. Any other comments?

9:38 My name is Sharon Clark. I just want to request that you use your microphones, please. I heard Cleland just fine, but unless you're speaking into the mic, some of us have difficulty hearing you. Thank you. We'll try. We're kind of limited technology-wise, but we will certainly try. We do have some new microphones that have been shared with us and set up for today's meeting.

10:06 We'll attempt as best we can with the constraints that we function under with our technology, but we'll certainly try. Thanks, Jen. Any other comments? Okay, so let's go ahead and move forward into our agenda. First on our, before we do that, I just want to remind the public as we go through our agenda, there will be opportunity for the public to comment on elements of the agenda items.

10:34 I will ask that when you do address the public that you will come to the podium after we call on you to come to the podium. And so that's why I'm sitting here so I can see comments from the public and I can see your hands raised. So just to advise that there will be opportunity for you throughout the meeting to comment. If you have a comment, raise your hand and we'll get to you as we get through the agenda. So with that in mind, we have the acceptance of our notes from the March 31st meeting to look at.

11:03 And I will entertain a motion to approve those. Teri Stehlik, I'll move to approve. Second. Second. Moved by Teri, seconded by Colin. To approve the minutes of the March 31st meeting, is there any discussion? Okay, all those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thanks. So, we're going to move into item number two.

11:35 And I was remiss not to introduce you earlier, but now's the time to do it. We will be chatting with Town Attorney Andy Morris this afternoon on some legal issues and questions that have been posed over the course of the MLR formation process. And Andy has received the questions that this committee posed.

12:03 Finalized at our last meeting on March 31st. He's also received the questions that came in from Recreation Commissioner Pat Agnich in an individual email, and that's in the packet. He's also received today the legal authorities document that came out of the legal ad hoc meeting that was held on Monday.

12:32 focus our efforts here today is that he's taken a first stab at, I called it sorting, he called it winnowing, the legal issues from what are perceived as policy positions and or policy decisions. Realizing that legal is specific to the laws that are in place, policy are decisions that are made at a council level and are separate from legal.

13:03 So he's taken a first stab at separating those for us. We will not be discussing the public issues today. We will be taking those and putting them into what we're calling the policy parking lots up here so that we can address those at a later date as we have conversations in preparation for our meeting with the council in May. We will take the legal issues after we've gone through the sorting and we'll go through those one by one to hear Andy's.

13:32 input, his legal opinion, and we'll be able to clarify with him before we move on to each question. There will also be a few questions that contain both legal and policy, and when we get to those, we'll put the policy part of it up on our parking lot, and we'll dive into the legal element of it. So I'm going to turn to Andy if you would like to take us through the winnowing process you want to, or provide us with your

14:00 Well, how would you like to go about it? Because we could either go through all 25 questions and sort them into legal versus policy, or we could take them one at a time and discuss them and move on that way. This was the debate. I think we wanted to get policy out of the way. I think we wanted to go that route and then come back to and spend time on the legal questions. Okay. That being the case, I'm looking at the numbering in the list of 20 questions.

14:30 that the committee generated on about March 31st. Right. And on that list. So for those of you who are following this, the first document that he's going to turn to is a, it has, sorry, it has 20 questions on it, and it's titled MLR Legal Questions Related to Use of Measure R and U Funds.

14:57 It's based on review by MLR Formation Committee, March 31st. It's a three-page document. For those of you who print it in color, it's a blue and black document. For those of us who are looking at black and white, it is black and light gray. All right. With that, the first six questions in that document are purely legal, as I see them. The seventh question is a mixture of legal and policy. Do you want to tell us which part of seven is policy?

15:29 Yeah, I do. The policy question for number seven is whether the council wants to abide by the recommendations provided by the current commissioner committee or future commissioner committee, whether the council wants to have the option of doing something different from what's recommended. The other policy aspect of the seventh question, which is kind of a series of questions really,

16:05 The question from the committee was, does the council have any authority over non-RNU funding decisions? That's really a policy question rather than a legal question because the council could decide as part of an agreement with MLR to provide funds, the council could impose some constraints and conditions on what MLR does to seek other funding and what it does with that other funding.

16:26 And the question of whether to do that, and if so how, is purely a policy question. Okay, did I just get this backwards here? Was this the legal? Yeah, question mark. No, that's the policy. That's the policy, yeah. And then there's a policy two under that. Oh, this is part two. Yeah, the other question is, does the council want to impose contractually any restrictions on what MLR does with non-R and U funding? Okay.

16:56 That's the last question in question seven. Question eight is a mixture of legal and policy, but the policy question is whether the council wants to impose financial accounting standards and practices on MLR. Does the council want MLR to follow government accounting standards, the GASB standards, or what are called

17:31 Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, or GAP. Does the council want MLR to account for things in the same way that the town itself does? Does the council care? That's a policy question, not a legal question. But the rest of that, the rest of the has to do with legal. Well, the legal question is, can the town impose stuff? Legally, yes. Can the council define a more comprehensive audit provision? Yes. The town can, legally.

18:00 Does MLR require to use county practices? Legally, no. But again, the policy dimension is, does the council want to require that? So it's really not... It's really... The can questions are the legal ones. Does the council want to or the policy questions? Number nine is purely a policy question. I mean, the answer, of course, is yes. The town can limit the amount of overheads. So the policy question is, does the town want to do that?

18:48 10 is a legal question. 11 is a mixed legal and policy question. Are there any restrictions on the use of other funds? The legal dimension is whether anything in the law says what MLR can do with non-town funds. That's a legal issue which we'll talk about. The policy question is, again, does the council want to use its agreement with MLR to impose conditions?

19:15 on MLRs, Fundraising, and what it might do with other non-RNU funds. Right, and we'll talk about that in more detail, and 11 is, yeah, really, 11 is a lot like 7B. It's essentially the same question. Which was, does the Town Council have any authority over the RNU funding decisions? Well,

19:52 7B was this council want to impose contractual restrictions over non-RM funds. Right. Number 12 is a policy issue, which is am I going to be providing advice to the committee? That's up to the council. Once MLR is formed, at that point I can no longer provide advice to it. I'm not going to be MLR's lawyer, but my role until and unless MLR is formed, that's up to the council. So that's purely a policy question. And it was probably also a

20:23 From the town's perspective, how much does this group continue to engage with you and ask you questions? Okay, number 13 is a mixture of legal and policy issues. Can fundraising be done? It's a legal issue. The question of whether

20:52 Whether the town would be the entity to issue bonds or whether MLR would be the one to issue bonds, that's a policy question. I have some thoughts on that, but I'll save them until there's a policy discussion. 14 is a legal question. 15 is a mixture. Right, and Andy, on 15, that's what that other handout you received today is all about. Right. The legal issue, of course, is can any of this stuff be delegated or transferred?

21:35 The policy question, of course, is should any of these things be delegated or transferred? I didn't quite know what to do with the 16th question. It's not really a legal question. I'm not sure what it is. What's the definition of overhead? It's a question that arises in this discussion, and so I think there was a desire to see if there is a legal...

22:08 Definition, if there's anything. Well, I can talk about it. We can talk about it, and I think we'd appreciate it. Sure. We'll keep that on the legal side, then. Thanks. 17 is a legal question. 18 is a legal question. 19 is a mixture of legal and policy. The policy question in 19 is whether the council wants to apply some of the conflict of interest requirements that apply to the town itself to MLR. That's a policy question.

22:47 There is a legal issue in there which we'll wade through when we get there. Same? Same. Conflict of interest standards. 20 is a legal question. Pat Agnich's first question is... Pat Agnich's questions occur as page 3 of the packet and it's titled MLR questions submitted by Pat Agnich and it has 5 bullet points on it. 4 bullet points on it. Or no, it's 5. It's 5.

23:34 Five bullet points for those following along. That first question is... I submitted those as a resident of the community and a community member, not as a commissioner. Oh, okay. Thanks for the communication. Oh, yeah, I did. I'm sorry. Thanks. Yeah, thanks. The first question of whether the town should change the process, that's purely a policy question. The second question about how much of R&U funds can be spent on administrative costs.

24:13 That is surprisingly a policy question because there's no real definition or limit in text it measures R or U, so it's really up to the council. Pat's third question is a legal question. Pat's fourth question is mostly a legal question, but the policy question in there is whether the MLR formation process should have an opportunity for members of the public to possibly become MLR board members. I think that was, reading between the lines, I think that may have been a question that was,

24:50 intended to be asked within there. If I'm making things up, then feel free to tell me, and we'll just scratch it off the board. Now I understand that. Pat, you need to go. I think it was mentioned at the last MLR meeting that members of the public could apply, so I understand that. Okay. And then, of course, the fifth question, which goes to what Cleland said, is should the council decide to postpone this until after the election? That's purely a policy question.

25:37 I will note that the one kind of legal aspect of that fifth question is that, of course, the current council could found or could make sure the NLR gets formed, but a future council could decide whether or not to allocate any funding to it. So nothing that the current council does is going to completely bind a future council. Nothing the current council does will be set in stone.

26:17 The third document, which is titled Sorted Authorities, it's in a table format, and it's two pages long. And these were taken from the sorting that had occurred during the 2009-10 MRRC-MLR discussions, where we had sorted authorities between town, an NGO,

26:45 Forest Service, and the potential to share any authorities. And so the ad hoc legal committee went through and took the ones, twos, and threes and put these into a sorted authorities list to ask questions of Andy. So the questions are referenced in here. Yeah, I think that... Or an opinion. We're looking for more of an opinion.

27:14 On it, as it really wasn't questions as much as does this have to be town? Does it have to stay with the town? Or does this have, can this go with somewhere else? This is subsumed within question 15 on your list. Right, it's actually the detail of question 15. So we want to go ahead and do that then. We won't dive into no difference. Okay, yeah. All right, so that's the list of legal and policy.

27:47 And if everybody's ready, we can start diving into the legal issues presented by the list of questions. Before we move on to the list of legal questions, are there any comments from the public? Sharon Clark again. I would request that the attorney actually get the mic in front of him because that's why we're all here, is to hear what you have to say. Thank you.

28:19 I will speak into the microphone. Bless you. Bless you. So let's go back to the first list of questions, the MLR legal questions. We started with number one. That was a legal question. All right. So the first question is, can R&U funds be used to fund a separate nonprofit engaged solely in the purposes identified in Measure R and Measure U? Is there an accounting of time required by Measures R and U?

28:53 I'm really trying. Can that other one get closer? It's your press conference. It's a press conference. My fellow Americans. Then the committee's corollary question was,

29:15 Does this mean that without additional unrestricted funds, that MLR would not be able to work on anything outside of what's specified in R and U? And would MLR have to track time and dollars spent on R and U projects? So you called it one question, but it's really about four. So the answer is that you can only spend Measure R, Measure U funds on the specific things that Measure R and Measure U say that you can spend those dollars on.

29:45 That's pretty straightforward. So to the extent that MLR would be working on other things that are not listed in the permitted uses for R and U funds, yes, MLR would have to find other money to do that, whether that's other unrestricted funds from the town, other funds from some other source, don't know, but obviously you can only use R and U dollars to work on R and U things. So depending on the scope of MLR's ambition and what it wants to do, yes, it might have to go find some other money.

30:17 As a practical matter, MLR would probably have to do some kind of tracking of time and dollars in order to make sure that the R and U funds are being spent only for the specific purposes that they are allowed to be spent. It's probably not going to work for the town to just hand MLR money and say do good stuff or do R and U stuff, both because there's an audit requirement and also I think because there would be kind of an issue with

30:46 with the public's perception of the process if there was no accounting for it. So my suggestion would be that any dollars that go to MLR out of R and U will need to be accounted for and there will need to be an explanation of exactly what they've been spent on and how those purposes match allowable purposes in two ordinances. Also I should point out that because R and U have slightly different lists of what's permitted,

31:19 It doesn't even work to say, well, you gave us R&U dollars, we spent the bundle of R&U dollars on these things. They have to be accounted for separately. Anybody have any questions about that?

31:45 I will provide the committee and the public with a written synopsis of all my answers. So, Teri, don't worry about taking amazing hits. So, on question one.

32:13 We've heard, yes, MLR can find other funds to do other things. We've heard, yes, MLR would need to show tracking of time and money spent by R and U, and that's based on the current requirements of our measures R and U for reporting. And then there would need to be accounting for, separately, of R money and U money and how those two were spent separately.

32:38 Right. And I would add that even beyond the language in the two ordinances that requires an annual audit, there is potential gift of public funds problem if the town were to simply shovel money in the direction of MLR without a clear list of deliverables and without a clear accounting of how that money has been spent. As a lot of people know, the California Constitution says that the town cannot make a gift of public funds. And what that means is

33:05 Any expenditure of public funds that the town makes has to have a public purpose, has to serve the public in some way. And that means that any time the town gives money to anybody or spends money on anything, the town has to be able to show that there is a public purpose involved. And I think that when we're talking about the amount of money that would be at stake here, the town would have to have more than a vague notion of how the money was spent. I mean, the courts have said that the larger the amount of money, the more...

33:35 Impressive and important the public purpose is and the more you need to be able to justify it. So just to avoid that issue and because of the language in the ordinances requiring an audit, I do think that some level of tracking is going to be required. Andy, within your response to that, you essentially said that there had to be some direction from counsel. Well, yes. Yes. But then I also heard you say that the audit should have the what and the how and what it was spent on and how it was spent, not just yes money was spent.

34:03 I think that's correct. I mean, I think that's the essence of an audit. The audit would, I think any accountant would tell you the audit would have to show where the money went and how it was expended. Are those your answers to number one? Those are my final answers. Do you have any questions for Andy, any clarifying questions for Andy on number one? Public, do you have any clarifying questions for question number one that you'd like to ask of Andy? Okay.

34:41 Let's move on to question number two was a legal question. All right, question two was can R&U funds be used to fund a separate nonprofit entity engaged in the purposes identified in the two ballot measures plus other activities that are not identified in the ballot measures? Is an accounting of time required separated by R&U-related and non-R&U-related work? Can this be resolved with separate accounts for restricted, i.e. R&U?

35:08 and unrestricted funds, and this is basically just the same question as number one. Yes, I mean, R and U dollars can go to a non-profit entity like MLR that might be engaged in a mixture of R and U work and non-R and U work, but of course, MLR would not be able to use R and U dollars for anything that's not allowed by R and U. So to the extent that MLR wants to do other things, MLR would have to find other money. And I do think it will be necessary to

35:44 to separately track R dollars, U dollars, and then other sources of funding that MLR might have. I'm not saying it has to be separate bank accounts. The town's finance department will tell you about something called fund accounting, where you keep just a separate fund, even if it's not in a separate account. But you need to be able to say at any given time how much you have in R dollars, how much you have in U dollars, and how much you've spent of R dollars and U dollars. Very doable. Any questions for Andy on number two?

36:18 Are there any questions from the public on number two? Okay, we move to number three. Okay, question number three is funding of MLR would include general overhead related operating expenses. Then which category of allowed uses in the R&U ordinance would those fall under? Then the follow-up questions were what is the definition of administration and how does perception of MLR overhead differ from the

36:48 Town Overhead Accountability. Well, R and U both allow funds to be spent on planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, and administration. Neither ordinance provides a definition for any of those terms, something that the people that put the ordinance together just didn't think of. So we're going to have to fall back on the dictionary definition of what those mean. I think that you could fit some of MLR's general overhead into

37:19 The category of administration. I think that fits within the accepted definition of what that means to the extent that MLR is working on R and U projects. If MLR is spending half of its time working on R and U and half its time working on other stuff, I don't think it would be proper to spend, sorry, I don't think it would be proper to have more than half of its general overhead paid for by R and U.

37:46 Whatever fraction of MLR's time is spent on R and U stuff, I think that's the fraction that can generally be paid for, have its overhead paid for by R and U dollars. So whatever percentage of time is being spent on an R or U project would be, you would correlate that into a percentage of that time for admin? You know, I don't know if it's time or dollars expended by MLR or what the measure is, but I think there has to be some proportionality, some way to measure what MLR is doing.

38:21 and to not have more than a proportionate share of its overhead paid for by R&U. And we have to think through what that correlation is. Correlation or that proportion could be identified in an agreement between the town and MLR? It could be and it should be. It could be spelled out in that? And thanks for bringing that up, Dana. I think that...

38:51 This is as good a time as I need to mention that I think that if the town is going to give R and U dollars to MLR, and this is more of a legal question than a policy one, I think that the town is just about going to have to have a very detailed, specific agreement with MLR governing the use of those funds and establishing deliverables and establishing things like accounting standards, if there are going to be any, and generally establishing

39:19 All the parameters of the relationship between the two and how those funds will be spent. Clarifying questions on this one? So I would like to say how do you see that differ from like your agreement with MLT and like an agreement that you would have to have MLR? Are you looking for more specific projects that would be going into MLR? It might be more specific than MLT and actually, you know, forgive me, John, but the MLT agreement probably needs to be tightened up as well. Sorry. Thanks.

39:56 Okay, and then I have another question that kind of goes back to number two. Sorry about that. Backtracking. As far as funds, do the funds stay within the town's coffers until there's a project, or would there be an allowance for a monthly stipend to be given to

40:17 and MLR to move forward with projects. And then would they need to have a separate account for R and a separate account for U, or could they be in the same account as long as the accounting separates the... Let me tackle the second one first. I think they could be in the same account as long as they are accounted for separately. As long as MLR can say at any moment how much it has in R dollars, how much it has in U dollars. That first question is really a policy question for the council.

40:43 Because there are a lot of ways that the council could decide to give money to MLR. One would be to require MLR to spend the money first and the council would reimburse it. That's one. Another one would be to dole out the funds as MLR anticipates having expenses. So if MLR says this month we're going to need this much and here's a detailed accounting for the month.

41:12 The town could say, okay, fine, here's your check for this month. Or it could be, here's your check for this six-month period. You know, go and do the things in our agreement. Okay. And really, the mechanics of how to do that is not a legal question so much as it is a policy question. Policy, and that would be taken care of within the contract, so. Any other questions? Any questions from the public on this? Yes, Sandy Hogan. And my question would be,

41:50 In reading the language of both of the ordinances and the way that the question here is presented, it's an administration, it's like we're trying to define administration by as a standalone. In Measure R, it says, and administration of all trails, parks, and recreation facilities managed by the town of Lent Mammoth Lakes. That language is pretty specific, so it's a little more limiting, I believe. And in Measure U, it goes on,

42:19 and Administration of Facilities and Projects for Mobility, Recreation, and Arts and Culture. It's a little more general there. Do you want to speak to that? Because we're talking about six items that both Measure R and Measure U were intended to be used for. And administration was one of those six. Right. And actually, Sandy, that pops up in a future question, which we'll get to.

42:49 What role the town has to have with respect to some proposed facilities and programs versus what role MLR can have. But your point is valid that it is those six categories with respect to certain things. Fair point. Joe Perino. You know, you just mentioned something about borrowing and giving back. Well, I hate to tell you this right now, but I don't recall anything ever being paid back. Excuse me, sir. What's your last name? Okay.

43:35 Any other comments or questions on number three from the public? Should we clarify that there's not anything that's being borrowed or paid back? I don't think I made any reference to borrowing. I think that what I mentioned was that one option would be that MLR could spend the money and then the town could reimburse it. But I'm not seeing a mechanism for any money to be borrowed. Yeah. I just wanted to clarify that. Thank you. Number four.

44:17 The fourth question is, can the Measure R expenditure plan be amended to allow MLR to serve in place of the Tourism and Rec Commission for taking public input and making recommendations to the council? Can the public process provided in the current expenditure plan be eliminated or otherwise modified? What is the legal process for editing or changing the expenditure plan? I'll take those in reverse order. The legal process for modifying the expenditure plan is simply a majority vote of the council.

44:46 That's all it takes. Just everybody say aye, and then if you get three votes, it's amended. Can the public process be eliminated or otherwise modified? Yes, it can. It can be amended or modified essentially as the council sees fit with a caveat, which is kind of inherent in the first question that was asked as part of part four. Could the expenditure plan be amended to allow MLR to serve employees of the Tourism Rec Commission for taking public input and making recommendations? Yes, but in my view,

45:19 Only if MLR is not going to be getting any money. Clarify that. I don't think it works to have MLR be making recommendations regarding its own funding. Go ahead. So let me ask you a follow-up question. I understand that one, but is it possible for any council to take a certain portion, just as was done with the trail allocation, and say this much is going for a specific purpose of MLR, and then have MLR

45:50 Work the process to allocate the remainder. Yes, you could do that. I mean, if MLR would not have any role in recommending how much money would be going to it, and if MLR would not have any role, even indirectly, in that. I mean, for example, if MLR said, we don't think anyone's worthy, so you should allocate nothing to anybody else, and then hoping that it would scoop up everything that was left, that wouldn't work.

46:20 And MLR can't, as I said, can't make recommendations regarding its own funding. But we could, but any council could separate it out? Yes. And then have them make the decisions on? On non-MLR stuff. Okay. Could do that. I have another could scenario, or can. If the sitting town council requests MLR to provide its...

46:46 Budget for the coming year and identifies projects that it intends to pursue in this coming year and the council asks for that from MLR and then the council then approves the budget that goes back to MLR, is that... No, that's fine. There's a difference between asking MLR what it plans to spend and asking MLR to make recommendations regarding its own funding. If MLR...

47:14 serves as the recommendation making body required by Measure R or Measure U and it's in a position to make recommendations regarding its own funding, that's a conflict of interest. And I feel strongly enough about that based on some research that I've done into the conflict laws that I think if the council wanted MLR to be in that position, we would really need to get a formal opinion from the Fair Political Practices Commission which oversees the state conflict laws as to whether that would be permissible.

47:43 Can we talk about that first scenario for just a second? I'm having a tough time understanding when MLR would recommend its own funding. Well, if MLR were to be put in the position of being the recommending body required by Measure R and Measure U to make recommendations regarding all Measure R and Measure U funds, and if MLR was then hoping to receive Measure R and Measure U funds, MLR would be recommending its own funding.

48:12 You have to modify the recommendation process because the challenge I think that was raised if the council can turn on and say we're going to give dollars to this organization but there's no recommendation coming forward to do that from anybody unless we changing that major R you could do that major you has other challenges because it requires a recommendation. But wouldn't the council be the recommending body? Only if you appoint yourself as that committee. Okay.

48:41 Yeah, as currently set forth in the ordinance, no. The council's not the recommended body. In the Measure U ordinance. Oh, and in the expenditure plan. In the expenditure plan, which has a different way of changing it. What if those two entities coexist? So, if the Recreation Commission stays in place and NLRs in place, does that impact anything?

49:11 Who would be making the recommendation? The funding recommendation. Yeah, I'm only talking about the recommendation. So the council would be restricted from sending R&U funds to MLR with MLR being the body that says how those funds are going to be distributed if MLR is making its own decision to distribute it to itself. Am I understanding that right? That's right. MLR can't be the recommending body.

49:43 Contemplated in R and U and receive funds based on its own recommendation. Okay. And I want to go back and clarify the point that Joe made. If the town council directs funding to MLR and asks MLR to disperse it among other interests or make recommendations for dispersing it among other interests or other projects, does MLR have that capability?

50:08 Well, that's a slightly different question than what Joe asked. Joe's question as I heard it was, can MLR make recommendations for how other entities should be funded by the town? What you're asking is, can MLR make recommendations regarding how it itself should fund other projects or entities? Yes, I'm asking that question. Well, that would be, that would essentially be asking for money to be funded. That would be MLR asking for money to go to it.

50:37 That it would then hand out, and that's a conflict. Okay, I'm just trying. Yeah. If MLR was going to come forward with a project, and it's going to be contracted out to somebody else, and they are just the body that oversees that contract, could they bring, could that project be awarded by the council to say, yes, MLR, here's this money, you're putting this contract out, you would have a contract out with another entity.

51:05 Would they be able to do that? I don't think so. It's still flowing through MLR. I mean, there's – basically, you can't have MLR handling the money and making the recommendations for how the money is going to be dispersed. So why is that different from what we're doing right now with the town? How is that the same? I mean, what are we doing now that you think is the same as that? Well, you have the – it is being approved by the – you know, approved by the Rec Council, but you'll have town come forward with a project.

51:34 to the Rec Commission. Rec Commission says, okay, and then it goes to council, and then the money comes back to the town. This is all town money in the first place. I think that there's been a misconception that this money is anything other than town money. It's not. It's always town money. The town can certainly make recommendations regarding how to spend its own money. Okay.

52:00 The town has authority to do that that MLR would not. So then let's look at the MLTSCC where there's $300,000 that's been given to this entity to make recommendations and those recommendations go to council. I guess I'm trying to see how that would be any different. The recommendations would go to council for approval, for final approval, and then those would come back and be dispersed. It's still being dispersed through the town. The monies are still within the town. Is that the difference? Yeah. Okay.

52:31 Multi-SEC is not handling the money. Handling the money, okay. Okay, so let me try one more different scenario. So if MLR is the recommending body, and we go into this more when you get to number 15, but if MLR is the recommending body and the town is doing the contracts, that's how you see most things would happen. That's a way to do it, yeah. Okay.

53:07 MLR is a recommendation. We'll come back to it when we get to number 15. Any other thoughts? Any questions from the public on number 4? It doesn't have to be. Okay. Number 5. Number 5 is essentially the same as number 4, except instead of Measure R, it is Measure U. Can MLR be the Commissioner Committee designated by the Council to conduct the public process and make recommendations?

53:38 And the committee's follow-up question is can this be done through a contract where the council designates MLR to serve in the capacity of a committee or commission? The answer is the same as number four, MLR can't be making recommendations on its own funding, although the council could, of course, designate MLR to be the recommending body as long as it's not making recommendations on its own funding.

54:03 And I guess I'm still struggling with that because it's own funding. I guess when I'm looking at if there's a project that is identified within something that Measure R or you could be spent on and the only monies that are coming through are monies for that project, not necessarily for an admin cost, does that make sense? MLR could recommend that the town spend money on that project, that the town administer it, the town award it.

54:31 If the town oversee it, that's fine. MLR can't make recommendations that the town give MLR money to award and oversee that contract. That's the difference. I want to clarify something. In both ordinances, there's a discussion and a requirement that after accepting input, the commission or some other body appointed by the council makes a recommendation. Right. If the council...

55:05 Wants to designate MLR to serve as that public body, and the council at the same time says to MLR, here's your $300,000 for the year. And MLR goes through the public process to receive input on what the project is going to be or what the project might be.

55:36 And it, if MLR goes back after receiving that public comment and tells the council this is that, this is what we're doing with that $300,000? Still can't do it. Okay. Because that's still MLR recommending that it receive funding. Okay. But MLR could be the body that receives public input. Yes. Okay. As long as it doesn't touch any of the money. Okay. And if MLR presents a budget beginning to the council,

56:12 for funding and has projects identified and the council says, yes, here's your funding and it's done. MLR can do that. Yes, although that does raise the question of who would be the recommending body for that expenditure. And can the town council be the recommending body? Can the town council serve as the recommending body to receive public input on projects? The town council could.

56:39 The question that I think is floating around that no one's quite asked is, can you have different recommending bodies depending on whether it's going to be MLR receiving the money or not? I mean, you might be wondering, can the council be the recommending body with regard to MLR funding and have MLR be the recommending body with respect to all other funding? That's not real clear in the ordinance. Both R and you seem to contemplate one recommending body. Measure R you can tweak because it's just the expenditure plan that the council can change.

57:08 Measure U, you can't make any changes to without voter approval. Measure U seems to contemplate just one recommending body. So I would not feel very good about the idea of having to have a split or hybrid recommending body for U funding. R funding, I think the council could do that. But the difference in the R and U has to do with that recommending body. Right. And the council. 344, 210 is U. That's it. Okay.

57:52 As designated by the Teal Council. Yeah, and it's such other commission or committee singular. It doesn't appear to contemplate multiple recommending bodies. And incidentally, if anybody needs it, we do have some copies of Measure R and U up here if anybody didn't have it memorized. There were some in back as well. There were some in back as well. All right. Any other questions around the table for number five? Any questions from the public on number five?

58:27 Okay, then we'll move to number six. So number six is for Measure U, if all Measure U funds are committed to MLR, does that eliminate or replace the need for the annual application process or review by another committee? As the amount generated by the tax changes, can the council simply allocate all the funds without setting a specific amount? And then the committee said look at the Measure A example of...

58:56 Using historic revenue generated and dividing by the calendar quarter to project quarterly allocations and then doing a quarterly trip. The council can't do away with some form of public input and recommendation. I think that, well, it requires annual public input and requires annual recommendations. There's a quirk in the language. Measure U says the council has to consider those recommendations.

59:28 Prior to expending funds that have not already been committed. So it's not really clear whether that means that the council could make a binding multi-year commitment of funds. There's room to argue that the council could make a multi-year commitment of funds, but you'd still be stuck with this annual need for public input and review. If you make a multi-year commitment, it seems to negate the purpose of having that annual public input and recommendation process.

59:55 I can't tell you for sure that the council could do a multi-year allocation of funds. It does seem clear that we still have to do annual input and review no matter what. I do think that council could allocate quote-unquote all of the Measure U funds in a given year without knowing exactly how much that's going to be. Say that again? Sorry. Well, the question was could the council just say you can have all the funds without knowing to the dollar how much that's going to be? And the answer to that is yes.

1:00:25 On an annual basis. On an annual basis. Multi-year, not so clear. And with that, in thinking of a potential project for a facility that fulfills the description of measuring the projects, would this, it seems as if your answer would perhaps

1:00:56 Tie the Council's hands in making a long-term commitment to a facility and a capital expenditure project. I'm not saying the Council cannot. I'm just saying that I cannot say with certainty that they can. They can if she's dead, and that would be a commitment to funding if you get a debt issue. Right. Measure R and Measure U were not written perhaps as clearly as they could have been. There are a lot of holes and ambiguities in each of them.

1:01:23 And so some of these questions that you're asking, they're all good questions, they're all fair questions, some of them don't have answers, or at least not very good answers. So if a council and an organization such as MLR went in the direction of favoring capital expenditure long-term projects, could other committees or the citizenry rise up after the first year?

1:01:52 and stop that project from continuing. It's an interesting question. The voters of the town of Mammoth Lakes have the ability to mount an initiative measure to undo either of these at any time, with one exception. By the way, the ability of the voters to do that is guaranteed by the California Constitution, Prop 218, adopted in 1996 by the voters. The exception to the voters' ability to undo a tax measure is if the funds have been committed

1:02:22 Essentially to repay bonds. So if the town were float bonds, and there's a question about bond funding later that we can talk about, but if bonds have been floated and the revenues from R and U have been pledged to repay those bonds, that's the one situation in which the voters would not be able to overturn or rescind, really, Measure R or Measure U. And again, I'm not saying the council cannot do that. I'm not saying the council cannot make a multi-year commitment. There's just an argument.

1:02:53 Because of the ambiguous language in the ordinance that perhaps the council cannot. But it could also be interpreted as saying the council can. Does that pertain to just a bond or could it possibly be a loan? Or if there's a larger project where you're saying you're putting a side into a capital reserve for a specific project and we're going to save this much money in five years, we will have that money with whatever grant funds and then be able to do that? Is that...

1:03:23 Can there be a written agreement for something like that? I can tell you for sure that having bond debt will protect it. Other agreements of that nature that you're describing, I can't say for sure. I need to do more research. It's a question involving a federal constitutional question called impairment of contracts. My hunch is that it's not that easy. I think if it were that easy, then I think cities all across the state would have...

1:03:51 have acted to lock up their tax revenue by doing some kind of agreement like that, but I'll look into that. I'll take a note and we'll look into that specific question. Thank you. Any questions from the public on number six? Leland Hoff again. Thank you. I guess my question is, and tell me if this is rude, but how many people were actually here when Measure R

1:04:37 Measure you were voted on. Can you raise your hands if you were here? Okay, so we're looking at four people from this. Just from experience and covering on this extensively, these were questions that were brought up at the time. The wordage, the way things were written, people came up with a lot of

1:05:06 ands if or buts and I just want to point that out to people who don't understand perhaps you weren't in town and you don't know how intensively the town took this issue with how the money was going to be spent personally I voted for it even though I knew that there were big glitches in it

1:05:35 because I do have a positive view of the future and I'm just worried that some of the things that we're talking about now are going to put us in a position 10 years from now that we are breaking laws and we are going to be having well you know this is how it was established at this point and then this is what this committee decided and I

1:06:05 I really want the people who are newer to town to realize that this has been discussed ad nauseum about the way that the money is going to be spent. So I don't know if I quite got my part, but a point across about that. But I guess I just want to let you know that these have been covered, and I'm not getting any more clarification, I guess, is my issue right now.

1:06:33 And Cleland, I'd just like to respond by saying that as a Recreation Commissioner, you know, I take my responsibility, you know, for Measure U, excuse me, for Measure R, you know, very seriously and have certainly, you know, made a lot of effort to educate myself on the history and, you know, and understand that, you know, Andy's answered questions for me in the past about things. So I just want to assure you that particularly as it pertains to Measure R, even though I, you know, moved here shortly after Measure U was voted on.

1:07:00 I guess what I'm saying is that I was flat out lied to about R and U and I had the same, not you, I mean I love everybody in this room because I'm not a politician, I'm a townsperson. We're going over some of the same problems that we had before which was how you're going to interpret the way the monies are going to be

1:07:30 Allocated and I just can't sit here and listen to this and go oh okay well this time they got it right and I don't want to see that happen again and I feel that people were now in looking back what we were promised years ago is now coming all the arguments that people had back then with what was going on is now coming

1:07:59 to pass, that this is something that I knew was coming years before, and a lot of people in town knew that as well. And like I said, I haven't even made up my mind. I want to see what people are proposing, what they're going to put out there, but I want you to just keep in mind the history of the town and what was going on at that time point.

1:08:26 Okay, that really is important. Maybe not so much to the people who have an agenda that needs to get pushed through, but you've got to go back to the town people because fool me once, shame on me. Fool me twice. I've been told to monitor my. Fool me twice. No, I realize that. Okay, my question is, what is the difference between you guys sitting here

1:08:55 Telling me all these things about how you're making, you're trying to like make promises or trying to figure out where it's going. How can I trust anybody when it comes to this matter? How's that? How can I trust anybody when it comes to this since we've already broken rules and we're having up conflicts with paperwork that was written before?

1:09:21 Okay, so I think the context that we want to put this into is around the formation of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And the questions that we're going through with Andy today is very specific to the legalities of the formation of an entity like MLR. There are certainly other issues around R&U that perhaps do not pertain to MLR's formation at this point.

1:09:48 Our context, we're talking about measures R&U related to the formation of MLR. And if there's a question about a trust, I would hope that you will continue to follow the process that this formation committee has been going through that started last summer with a much larger group.

1:10:08 and the opportunity to participate in these meetings as we move forward and the opportunity to communicate to the town council as decisions are going to be put in front of them in the future. I don't need to participate and we can certainly provide you with the historical discussion. Oh, no, I've got that and I have videotape and I have interviews with people and like I said, this is just, as far as I can see, kind of a repeat of

1:10:37 I voted I just okay good I just want to let you guys know that you really have to think ahead down the road that the decisions that are being made today could cause us big conflicts down the road and I'm seeing them now and I didn't follow up on my gut instinct originally years ago but I am now so that's just

1:11:06 Okay. Any other questions from the public on number six? You know, and I'm sorry, I can't sit here. I would like to just say that as an individual on this steering committee and has spent many hours on the rec commission and many hours on the steering committee, that there's not a personal agenda, that everything that I have done is for this community that I have grown up in and love. Absolutely. And so, anyways, I just...

1:11:35 feel really strongly that, you know, I feel that some of our integrity has been attacked, and I think this is a pretty strong, solid group, and there is not a personal agenda, and we are trying to look at what's best for this community. So, I'm sorry, I...

1:11:51 Just had to say something. So, and that's fair. I appreciate it. We're going to stay focused on it. Yeah, thank you. We've got some legal issues that we need to keep going through, so we will try and keep that as neutral as possible and stay focused on our work at hand. So, if there aren't any more questions about number six, I didn't see any. Did you want to respond? Well, the only response I have is that this group isn't making any decisions.

1:12:16 Not about how the money is going to be spent. I mean, ultimately, decisions about how Measure R and Measure U dollars are going to be spent are the province of the council. And so, I mean, after June, starting in July, Cleveland, you might be one of five votes deciding how the Measure R and U dollars are spent because that's really the group. It's the council that's going to decide. I plan on that. Okay. Number seven had a...

1:12:42 Policy and legal question. We got the policy one captured. The legal question in seven, paraphrasing a little bit, is the council bound by the recommendations provided by whoever the recommending body is going to be regarding how to spend or allocate Measure R, Measure U funds? The answer is no. The council is not bound in any way by those recommendations. I know the council has agreed.

1:13:08 here relatively recently to sort of vote thumbs up or thumbs down on the entire suite of recommendations made. Council's not required to do that. Council can pick and choose. Council can say yes to some things, no to others. The council can politely listen to all the recommendations and then ignore them. Council can follow them all as gospel truth. Council can do whatever it likes with the recommendations.

1:13:38 The Commission works hard on those things. I'm not saying the Council should blow off the recommendations. The question is, can they? Yeah, they can. You have to just think about when the process was being set up for Measure R and the personalities that were involved and the desire to keep it in one package and not let it be cherry-picked apart. There was great discussion and debate back in 2008 on that.

1:14:08 That's funny. All right. All right. Any questions here on number seven on the legal side? Any questions from the public on number seven? Okay. Then there were a couple sort of small ancillary legal questions. Does the council have ultimate funding authority, decision-making authority for R&U? Yes. Does the council have any authority over non-R&U funding decisions? I'm not sure if that means non-R&U town dollars, in which case the answer is yes. The town can always decide whether or not to give.

1:14:39 MLR, any other town money. And the council could negotiate with MLR to have some measure of control or some restrictions over what MLR can do to raise money from other sources if the town wanted to try to negotiate for that. I want to clarify on that last point. Does town council have any authority over non-RNU funding decisions? There was also, the context was if RNU

1:15:08 Is generating its own revenue, does the council have any authority to tell MLR or instruct MLR what to do with that non-RNU dollar? If MLR is generating its own money, MLR is generating its own outside source of funding, does the council have any authority over what MLR?

1:15:34 Should or could or can do with that non-RNU. It depends on whether the council wants to do that. If the council feels like it wants to have that much control over MLR, the council could presumably negotiate to have that in the grant funding agreement between the town and MLR. So that's where the policy part comes in. That's where the policy part comes in, yeah. Any other questions on number seven? Here on the table from the public, any questions on number seven? Okay.

1:16:16 Number 8 had policy and legal and we've got policy up there so our legal. The legal questions are can the town impose financial accounting practices or standards in order to comply with the audit requirements of the Measure R and Measure U ordinances? Can the town council define a more comprehensive audit requirement through an agreement? Is MLR required to use the town's accounting practices, standards or systems?

1:16:42 And then finally, can ordinance funds be used for completing an operating audit? Well, sure. The town can impose financial accounting standards or practices through its agreement. The town can define whatever audit requirements it wants to define through its agreement with MLR. All this is subject to negotiation. Is MLR required to use the town's accounting practices or standards? If the town negotiates for that in its agreement, sure.

1:17:09 Finally, can R and U dollars be used for conducting an operating audit? The answer to that one I think is yes, but just as with general overhead, I think only in proportion to the amount of time that MLR is spending on R and U activities. So if MLR is spending half of its time and efforts on R and U activities and half on other things, I don't think it would be proper to have its audit paid for entirely by R and U dollars.

1:17:40 Any clarifications on that on the table? Any questions from the public? On number eight, okay. Number nine is policy. Number 10 is legal. Number 10, and I'll paraphrase a little bit, is essentially how can R and U funds be used within the context of quote-unquote all town recreation facilities and programs, trails and parks managed by the town?

1:18:14 How is town facilities defined? What does managed by the town mean? Can third-party contracts be used? How could MLR own facilities or manage programs? Can programs be, can programs presumably managed by MLR be the ones offered by the town or by a contract with the town?

1:18:39 Can MLR enter into third-party contracts for providing services for facilities, programs, trails, and parks managed by the town? Can that authority be passed to MLR by the town? Which is about, I don't know, 59 questions in one. Well, they were all, you know, you were on a roll. Kept going. All right, spend time on numbers. Okay, so the first thing to bear in mind is that R and U have different restrictions on the nature of the town's involvement.

1:19:08 Measure U doesn't require the town to own or manage anything. It just says that the funds have to be used for certain purposes and they cannot supplant existing funding. That's it. Nothing about ownership, nothing about management. So with U, I think there's some flexibility. With U, the town has a little more ability to give money to somebody else and say, manage some programs for us. Or hypothetically, the town could use U dollars to say,

1:19:37 Go buy a facility and run it. Have some third party do that. With R, it's a little different. And this is one of those areas where the ordinance is not written very clearly and certain key terms are not really defined. And so I'm just going to be completely candid with you that there's not a clear answer to some of these questions. So, first of all, town recreation facilities, what does that mean?

1:20:06 I read that as meaning facilities owned by the town. I'm not sure how else you would interpret town recreation facilities unless you mean those owned by the town. Now, I'm aware that there is an issue where we have used Measure R dollars to do some work on Forest Service trails that we don't own. I'm aware of that. Before you move forward, where are you using the word owned in the ordinance?

1:20:35 Owned is not in the ordinance. What I'm saying is... Are you replacing the word owned or are you replacing the word managed with the word owned? No, managed is separate. We're getting there. Okay, so because I'm not tracking where the word owned is coming into the discussion. Okay. It's not part of the... No, I'm saying this. I think it's implicit. Let's talk about where that is. I just want to... Okay.

1:21:01 I'm looking at section 3.48.150, paragraph A, the last sentence of Measure R. Anybody who wants to follow along, I'll give you a minute to find it. This is section 3.48.150, paragraph A. This is in Measure R. I want to hand out to section 15. Okay. That paragraph says you can only use Measure R funds for

1:21:33 Recreation, Trails and Parks Funding as set forth in the Expenditure Plan. The Expenditure Plan can be amended as long as the funds are used for Recreation, Trails and Parks Funding. And then it says, for purposes of this chapter, Recreation, Trails and Parks Funding means the six categories, Sandy, Planning, Construction, Operation, Maintenance, Programming and Administration. And here's where we get to the interesting issues.

1:22:01 Of all town recreation facilities, which I read as one category, and the second category is programs, trails, and parks managed by the town. So the first question is, what does town recreation facilities mean? I read that as meaning facilities owned by the town for recreation. Now, there's room for argument there because it doesn't say owned by the town, but I think that that is the most logical interpretation of that phrase.

1:22:31 Town Recreation Facilities. You can make an argument that it means, maybe, facilities available for recreation by people in the town, or facilities the town has some relationship with. I just, I can't tell you with any certainty what that means, but as I said, I think the most likely interpretation is that it means facilities that the town owns.

1:23:05 I forget how long we have like that. Yeah, and that I think, I think that would work too. I mean, owns has some control over like a long-term lease. I think that's legitimate too. Then the second category is programs, trails, and parks managed by the town. So the question that the committee has raised is, what does that mean? What does managed by the town mean? Does it mean that the town has to do the management itself? Does it mean that the town can

1:23:34 Contract with somebody else, like MLR, to do the management. There's not a clear answer. I just can't give you a definitive answer. There's room for interpretation there. So I think it could be interpreted as meaning that the town has to do it itself. It could be interpreted as meaning that the town can contract with somebody else to do the management for it. The other way we looked at that.

1:24:04 Just as I've seen, it's parts managed by the town are also the facilities that we don't own, but we manage them, i.e. through a use permit with the Fourth Service. Right. And so the town's still doing the agreement they have versus an agreement the town's giving to somebody else for something they own or control. I'm assuming it can go both directions. Yeah. Yeah. So to answer the question of to what level can third-party contracts be used, I can't give you a definitive answer.

1:24:44 Under what structure could MLR own facilities? Well, with Measure U dollars, no restriction. With Measure R dollars, that would require us to interpret this, it would require us to interpret town recreation facilities as meaning not ownership, as meaning something else. Yeah, I'm trying to think of the scenario that we talked about this summer in the earlier meetings where our consultants were talking about a facility.

1:25:23 Somewhere in the Tahoe area where it was a town facility, but it was being managed and promoted and actually was making money. That was their ice rink. The ice rink. They contracted over the management of a facility. To a private entity. So that kind of a thing could be considered, you're saying, if it was you money? If it was you money or if you interpreted R a certain way. Okay.

1:25:52 There's nothing inherently wrong with the model. The only question is whether it fits within our ordinances. So the idea that the town could execute an agreement with MLR to manage the ice rink is a possibility? It's a possibility if we choose to interpret Measure R that way. And the ice rink was just chosen because that's...

1:26:26 Tahoe, that's what they said is that they have done. There's, you know, nobody needs to make an interpretation that that's what we're doing. Well, the bigger question comes up on that. It's a town rec facility and you go to a private vendor, you go to Snow Creek and say, we want to put our money in there as a public-private partnership. We don't own it, we don't control it necessarily, but we want to expand that service so people don't have to go in there. That would be a greater area, I believe.

1:26:57 Under Measure R, that would be grayer. I would feel a lot more comfortable about that under Measure R if we had some long-term contractual right to use the facility that we could then call it a town recreation facility. The other side with you we've talked about is a partnership with the college, for example, for a performing arts center under arts and culture where dollars would be given to them to run or operate or run a program. So how is it going to be that would work fairly cleanly? Yes.

1:27:26 Under U, but not necessarily under R. They can have reparation elements to it under U. Earlier we talked about there's language in the ordinance of Measure R and there's language in the expenditure plan of Measure R. And the expenditure plan can be changed with the majority vote of the council. The ordinance cannot be changed.

1:27:56 Except by a vote of the people. And that was question 14, but we'll get to that in a minute. Sorry, it was right. Any questions around the table here on this one? Betsy, you have moved the microphone around. Dan actually brought up my question about the measure you own. Are there any questions from the public on number 10? Pat Agnich again. So Andy, would you recommend that measure?

1:28:40 Would our funds be used to contract for management of town facilities? You kind of bobbled your head a little bit, so would you recommend? Here's the thing. My job is to protect the town. My job is to give advice to the town. Town attorneys sometimes fall in the habit of just reflexively saying no because it's the safest thing to do.

1:29:07 I generally don't want to be that town attorney. I don't want to just say no. I want to find a way to say yes. In this case, I think that it's a question of how much risk the town wants, truthfully. I think that if the town makes certain decisions regarding how to spend Measure R, Measure U dollars based on ambiguities in the ordinance, the further the town pushes the envelope with regards to the ambiguities, I think

1:29:37 The more likely it is that someone can mount a successful legal challenge. So if the town is comfortable with some risk, then it might make certain interpretations. If the town wants to be very cautious and conservative and be absolutely shielded from any legal risk, the town might make other interpretations. Okay. That was a good town attorney answer. Thank you. No, I hear what you're saying. Thank you.

1:30:10 If through the contract that the town would execute with an MLR, it said you, MLR, are responsible for the programming and management and function of the community center, could MLR turn around and execute a contract with ABC Company to clean that facility?

1:30:39 Could they execute a third-party agreement with CDE Company to program that facility, i.e., host dances in there or anything else? If, through the agreement, the council said, you've got to go take care of this facility, could MLR execute third-party agreements with...

1:31:04 Other entities to perform services. If we take the position that the town is not required to do all the management itself and that the management function can be delegated to MLR, I think that MLR could enter into third-party contracts for specific services. I mean, cleaning, sure, there's no management there. Programming, yeah, I think you could do that too. There's not really management there. If MLR were...

1:31:29 Sort of managing the facility and retaining that overall management authority on behalf of the town, I think MLR could do that. If MLR were to essentially try to transfer management functions to somebody entirely different, I think at that point it becomes more difficult to argue that the town is still managing the facility within the meaning of Measure R. But you could hire out the subcontractor to

1:31:59 Do the programming, like if there was a special event, you would want possibly somebody that is specializes in booking and in that type of thing for those special event facility. Could you do an outside contract or something like that? Well, this is where we run into the problem of nothing being defined in R and U, especially R. That programming contract, as long as it could be characterized as not really being management of the facility, it's something less than management, it's just

1:32:29 Oversight of one function, I think that would work. But I've seen programming contracts that really look a lot like management contracts, where you're going to program everything and you're going to essentially run the facility. Well, that might be management, really. So if they're just programming one aspect as opposed to being all-inclusive? I think that would be better, yeah. Ultimately, if you got to the all-inclusive standpoint, couldn't that just be, if MLR gets it to a certain threshold?

1:32:56 Couldn't the town then contract with a third party say it's an event venue and you want to hire AEG to run an event venue? Couldn't MLR get it to a certain point and then the town could contract directly with AEG? Oh, absolutely. I mean, the more oversight and the more direct hands-on relationships the town has with respect to any of these venues, the better. Right. Because the easier it is then to make the case that it's still the town managing the facility,

1:33:24 Within the meaning of Measure R. And if you can get AEG to run our facilities, great. I know those guys. Yeah, we'll talk to Phillip. We'll get that figured out. Any other questions, scenarios to pose to Andy on number 10? Was there anything else on number 10 that you wanted to have? No. Okay. Any questions from the public on number 10? All right. We're going to go to number 11.

1:33:58 Chad, a combination, policy and legal, and you're going to take us to the legal, which is the first. Yeah, the legal question in number 11 is, are there any restrictions on MLR's use of other funds that it might raise? And the answer is really no. I mean, there aren't any legal restrictions other than that MLR would have to use those funds within the confines of its status as probably a 501c3.

1:34:26 which is a federal nonprofit status, sorry, tax-exempt status, and within the confines of its status as a California nonprofit public benefit corporation, which is almost certainly what it would have to be. And the corporation's code has some limitations on what a nonprofit public benefit corporation can and cannot do, but as long as MLR fell within those confines, it could do whatever it wanted. And the policy question, as we alluded to earlier, is,

1:34:55 Would the council want to negotiate for any further restrictions on MLR's use of other funds that it might raise? Any questions from the public on 11? Okay. So policy 13 had a combination. The first part was legal. Yeah. Okay. So this is something that's come up a few times before. It's something that I've addressed with staff previously. The question is, can staff hired by MLR with Measure R and U funds

1:35:31 be assigned to do fundraising work. And then the committee's follow-up questions were, what does fundraising mean? What's the definition? What about grant applications? And then there's a question about bonding. So in order for R&U funds to be used for fundraising and grant application writing, those activities would have to fit within one of the six categories. They'd have to be planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, or administration.

1:36:01 of Facilities. And as I sit here, I cannot give you a clear answer as to whether fundraising fits into any of those categories. It's just not clear. None of those six categories are defined in either ordinance, and you can make an argument either way as to whether fundraising fits, as to whether grant application writing fits. I think that it's most likely that it would fit into administration. If it's going to fit anywhere, it's clearly not construction, probably not operation, not really maintenance.

1:36:31 Maybe programming, maybe planning, but you have to find a way to fit it into one of the six. And the same goes for grant application writing. Okay. Dan, I have a question on that. And I know we put it in later, but since we're on it, I think it's important to ask it now. Can the council as a policy matter come up with definitions?

1:36:59 of what programming and administration and things like that mean and quit and get to a point where the arguments over what is and what isn't would be finalized? Well, the council can certainly come up with definitions and the council can invite public input on the definitions and can debate them and can have a really transparent and thorough public process and the council can itself use those definitions and instruct MLR use those definitions and we can all agree to live by them.

1:37:31 But, that being said, we wouldn't know for sure whether our definitions of what those things mean are valid unless someone sues us. I was looking at it more of just trying to solve, like, we've all argued about supplanting for six years now without coming up with a definition. I'm just wondering if it is something that could be done. I recognize that somebody could sue over anything. Well, I mean, yeah.

1:38:01 If the question is, is it better to try to come up with some definitions than not to? Sure, absolutely. I think that having some working definitions will help us avoid wallowing around and rehashing the same arguments. Seeing that they would need voter approval then to really make those definitions valid? Well, to make them airtight, yeah. But short of going back to the voters, if we wanted to try to come up with some working definitions that we think are fair and reasonable,

1:38:29 and consistent with the ordinance, we could do that, and I think it would help, but we can't ever be absolutely sure that our definitions are valid or that they would hold up unless someone sues us, and then we get to slug it out. Or you go back to the voters. Or you go back to the voters. Yeah, one of the two. Go to voters or go to court. It's the only way to have any certainty.

1:38:57 There's that. As a big picture issue, there are so many holes in both Measure R and Measure U that at some point it might be worth the council, probably the future iteration of the council, considering whether it makes sense to go back to the voters and try to see clarification on some of these issues.

1:39:23 It's a daunting prospect and not lightly undertaken, but I think it's something that might be considered. That was unfortunate. I'm not going to take it personally. Having set at the table in drafting the communication, we were under guidance from previous administrations and legal advisors and, you know,

1:39:47 We did what we were asked to do by those legal advisors. And I'm not faulting anybody that was involved in drafting Measure R or Measure U. It's almost impossible to anticipate every question that might arise in the future. And I think that at the time these were being put together, the concept of MLR or something like it, probably nobody was thinking of. I don't know. It was very unique.

1:40:16 Okay, any questions on this one? Yeah, because you mentioned that the bonding part would be policy. Yeah. So we'll just, we'll deal with that. Yeah, I will say for various reasons it would make more sense, I think, to have the town be the one to issue bonds rather than MLR. I think the town would, even with our current credit rating, I think the town would get better rates.

1:40:45 And MLR itself might not actually be able to issue the bonds. And also there's clear authority in the ordinances for the town to do it. And I'd like to stick to the language of the ordinances as much as we can. I think MLR could issue a bond, but the question is they couldn't pledge R&U for the ongoing payment. Correct. Right, that's the thing. The town would have to do that or you'd have to have other resources. Can I go back, I'm sorry, to the fundraising question? Andy, did I hear you?

1:41:14 Fit it into administration or that you pose that it could fit in? If you're going to use Measure R and U dollars for fundraising, you're going to have to fit it into one in six categories. My thought is that administration is the most likely. Your mileage may vary. Other people may have different opinions about which one it fits into or whether it fits at all. Hey, Andy, within Measure U, there is Section 4, the 3.44.210, that talks about an annual

1:41:42 Town Council shall annually conduct at least one public hearing where it takes public testimony as to how tax revenues collected under the should be expended. Right. So that could be, at least for you, it seems that that could be clarified in an annual review as to maybe even some of the definitions or no? You're saying that we could ask, as part of the annual public input, we could ask for input on the definitions? Right.

1:42:14 Sure. To say this is how we're perceiving the definition of X. Yeah. To get public input. We could do that. Sir, I mean, you're asking if there's a public hearing that is supposed to be scheduled. Annual. Part of that public hearing. Yes. To clarify. And then that clarification could go to council and then council could decide whether they agree with those definitions or not. Sure. Well, I think that review is to council.

1:42:41 It is. Town Council conducts it. That's the allocations here. As a practical matter, I think that if we're going to try to come up with working definitions for these terms, the more we can do to get community input and community support for those definitions, the better. Right. And that's why I wonder if the annual input is the way to do it, as opposed to going back to a re-vote. That's as good a forum as any. But just to make it clear, John, getting public input is not the same.

1:43:10 It doesn't provide the same level of certainty as people voted for. I agree. It seems that number 13 certainly is in the category of more work required because one of the features of MLR potentially is that it could embark on some degree of fundraising through sponsorship or events or a variety of means and that currently fundraising

1:43:46 for recreation connected to the town is very limited. So it is a potential significant portion of MLI's future activity. Right. Its role. So it's an area that will need some understanding of the definition and it would also affect a potential hiring of the type of executive that might run the organization.

1:44:13 Should it move forward? And also, just to state the obvious, I mean, I think it's implicit from everything that we've said, but if the town decides to allow MLR to use Measure R and U dollars for fundraising, of course those Measure R and U dollars can only be used for fundraising for R and U purposes. Yes. I mean, obviously. So if the organization, and it was successful in some fundraising on its own account, not connected directly or implicitly to R and U,

1:44:42 It could raise funds and then go about a fundraising program of its own. Absolutely. And to the extent that MLR is able to raise funds from other sources, it will grant itself more autonomy and independence and latitude to do different kinds of projects. So in that respect, it would be, if it was to pursue that path and be successful in those means that you just described.

1:45:12 It could be doing something that, for example, a recreation commission. Could. Could. I mean, I think that if MLR wants to grow beyond simply carrying out the purposes of R and U, it's going to have to have some seed money from sources other than R and U to try to start generating funds from sources other than R and U. And you made it relatively clear that it's a council policy decision to determine whether they have the purview of how all dollars are spent.

1:45:45 Or just R&U dollars. Right. So theoretically, there could be a hybrid situation where council only oversees any R&U monies that go to R&U. Right. And they have autonomy with their own. That's certainly possible. Yeah, I mean, I could see where you could have, again, this came back to discussion on your board for MLR. If you've got a really strong board out there and say, we're going to go raise $200,000 to do stuff that MLR wants to do, great.

1:46:12 Go do that and those funds can be spent by MLR accordingly. I think that's what you're saying. Right. And they're not talented at that point. So they could go out and raise dollars and get a sponsorship for whatever. If it's not related, they're pretty much... But RNU funds could be used if we're saying we're going to try to get a rec center put together and you need sponsorship, you need funding, you need...

1:46:34 That money could be used to go out and find additional funding to build that facility. It could. Yeah, it could, legally. As long as it's accounted appropriately. As long as it's accounted for a measure R and it falls within that. And the big policy question that we're not going to talk about tonight.

1:46:51 because we've parked it, is just what is the council's vision for what it wants MLR to be? And not that the council has direct control, it'll only have one seat on the board, but since the council's going to be controlling quite a bit of the funding for MLR, it's in a position to control to some extent what MLR can be. So whatever the council's vision for MLR is, does it want it to be a semi-captive entity that exists only to do R&U stuff, or does it want it to

1:47:17 Be kind of autonomous and do R&U stuff, but do as many other things as it can find funds to do. I mean, that's a policy question. And the council could allocate other general fund dollars towards MLR. Sure. Absolutely. Any other questions around 13 at the table? Any questions from the public on 13?

1:47:53 Number 14 was a legal question. Yeah, and we touched on this earlier, but is there any flexibility in amending or revising Measure R and Measure U other than revising the Measure R expenditure plan? Can the ordinance language be changed by the town council after holding a public hearing? The answer is no, no to both questions. These are adopted by the voters and can only be amended by the voters other than the Measure R expenditure plan, which can be amended by the council. Any questions around the table? Any questions from the public?

1:48:36 On 14? Okay. 15. We had a combination of policy and legal. There was the legal can, and then there was the, or excuse me, the legal can and the policy should. That's a nice way of putting it. So question 15 was, well, question 15 was that a number of authorities' responsibilities were identified early on in the process that the town cannot transfer or delegate to MLR.

1:49:05 The question is, are some of these actually transferable with changes to policies or ordinances and contractual relationships, or are they well and truly non-transferable or delegable? Okay, before you move on, this is where you turn to your sorted authorities document and the table that says sorted authorities on top. It's a table format. And it's two pages long. And this is where it came from.

1:49:34 The early slotting exercise that had been done in the previous exercise. Okay, fair enough. So this list of non-transferable authorities as items 3 through 10, those are generally really not transferable. I mean, I think you could conceivably ask MLR to provide insurance for town-owned facilities that it's managing.

1:50:07 Whether MLR would be able to get that insurance or get it more cheaply than the town is another question, but I guess that one hypothetically could maybe be transferred. Issuing use permits, no. Can't really be transferred. Special event permits, no. Seekable lead agency status, no. Open and closing parks, no. Adopting the general plan, specific master plans, regulations, standards and specs, no. Approving the town's own recreation budget, no.

1:50:34 And then setting and enforcing rules of town-owned facilities, setting no and forcing, yeah, I think that could be delegated if MLR would be managing. Well, and actually what we were thinking of there is that regardless who's managing it, they're picking up the phone and calling MLPD, so. Well, but I mean, if it's, you know, hey, you quit jumping up and down on the counter. All right.

1:51:03 And then I have to confess to some puzzlement about some of the questions under the heading of tasks that could perhaps be shared or performed by MLR. So is the thought that MLR perhaps would handle the design work, would procure professional services under contract, would do construction management, project management?

1:51:29 No, the question, it was kind of, we were pretty sure that some of these pieces had to stay with the town and wanted to know which ones might be, like, in our small group discussion, design of projects up to a certain point. So, like, John, what was your example? What were we going to turn over to the town? I forgot. Whatever your facility was. Oh, yeah. But that possibly the design.

1:51:56 And possibly planning, engineering, or design services could be contracted to MLR just like they might if they had the proper qualifications, like they are, you know, like we always have somebody come in to do the CEQA work. Right. Staff doesn't. Okay. Just in the context of it, the earlier sliding exercise had indicated this could only be done by the town. So what we're...

1:52:23 The question is, can that... Could it be contracted out and approved by the town? Okay. The town is required to obtain some kinds of professional services, design, engineering, architecture, on the basis of demonstrated competence. The town would not be in a position to hire MLR and have MLR subcontract that. Correct. The town can't say MLR...

1:52:53 You go find us an architect or engineer. That doesn't work. The town could, I guess, theoretically, hire MLR to do those things itself if MLR had demonstrated competence in those areas. The town usually procures those services through an RFP or RFQ, and I would suggest that the town should continue doing that.

1:53:19 Whether MLR would ever have the technical expertise to do some of these things, I don't know. I mean, it's not really, these things are not MLR's primary functions, I think, in anyone's vision. I could be wrong about that. And for smaller projects, we do them in-house, or have our staff do it. Right. Like some of the smaller projects, it wouldn't make a lot of sense to turn out, contract that out, and then submit it back to us to review, go through the process again, and then...

1:53:48 It's like you're paying for it twice in cases. Just to give you an example, and it was, you know, forget what the source of money was, but at a point in time, MLTPA brought in Alta, I can't remember their name data, Alta, to come up with a lot of the background that eventually became the trail system master plan after it went through the town things. Right. So in essence, MLTPA did bring in a design firm. Yeah, that wasn't covered.

1:54:17 Quite by that requirement, but yeah. Yeah, so we were trying to figure out, well, is there a point where it's possible, and I agree with you, the qualifications off the top are not likely, and I think we all understand that the bidding and the contracting and things like that have to be done. The only other one that there was a question on was project management. Might there be a situation where project management, if the...

1:54:44 Whatever we're building, I'll use my facetious Joe's climbing wall. If it turned out that it was better for someone else, maybe just due to staff capacity to manage it, could that be contract? That could be, but again, it would have to be that MLR had some demonstrated competence, and even though that kind of service doesn't have to be let out to bid exactly, in the sense that the town doesn't have to award that to the lowest bidder, the town's...

1:55:11 Procurement and Purchasing Ordinance does say that it will be demonstrated competence and then lowest cost. So if MLR had the expertise and could do it for a reasonable cost, yeah. The question would be, and this is why this is a hybrid legal and policy question, the policy question is, is that a good idea? And that's something for the council to determine. And it might be a case-by-case decision of, is it more efficient, cheaper, better, whatever it may be.

1:55:40 to have MLR try to do some of these things rather than staff that has the experience and expertise to do some of these things. If it's a capacity issue where staff simply cannot get to it, the answer might be yes. In some cases it might be no. Okay, so it's kind of John's question and it's what we went through in the creation of MLT is there was a distinction between cooking something and booking it.

1:56:05 You know, that MLT was supposed to gather the interest, but they were not responsible for running an event. So in the same, in John Z, so we could go out like Mammoth Track Club did and get ASIC involved in something and then at some point turn that over to the town. Sure. At some point before, you know, and not even at final design, but maybe just at concept stage. Good. There was page two on that, please.

1:56:43 And just to explain it, what we did on the first line is there had been a single line on the 1-2-3 document, which had never seen legal interpretation, where it got to the point of implementing an adopted plan. And so we wanted to ask that question separately. If RecStrat says that we're going to have a facility, can MLR be involved in it?

1:57:14 Implementing it, finding this person who really wants to have their name on our performing arts facility so they're going to bring in money and then at some point turn it over to town or could a small project out of RecStrats or something that's been approved be implemented solely by MLR? It depends on the nature of the project. Anything that is going to be funded by town funds I think is going to need to comply with

1:57:42 the requirements that apply to the town regarding prevailing wages and competitive bidding, which cover slightly different things. Clearly, it's very clear in the law that if the town provides funds for something and it's in the nature of what's called public works for prevailing wage purposes, you've got to pay prevailing wages. It's a little bit less clear, but I think clear enough that if the town's going to provide money for something that qualifies as a public works project for purposes of construction and competitive bidding,

1:58:13 I think it's pretty clear that you need to comply with that. So if it's a construction project that's going to cost more than $5,000, the town would not have the ability to simply tell MLR, just go build that. It would have to be let out to bid following the town's normal process. And as a side note, my suggestion will be that any agreement between the town and MLR requires MLR to follow some of these procedures and requirements that apply to the town.

1:58:41 as it's spending town dollars. So could MLR go find a sponsor for a facility? Sure. Not a problem. Could the town tell MLR go install $5,000 worth of signage? No. Could the town ask MLR to develop the interpretive plan? Yes. Could the town ask MLR to develop programming for...

1:59:18 Assistant? Yes. Yeah. The only question that came up on that, like, if we interpret the science, whether or not we bid that out of professional services. So let's take, yeah. Not to put them in place, but to create the content? The content. I mean, normally the town would, for anything that's professional services like that, normally the town would float an RFP or RFQ and then award it to whoever they thought was best qualified.

1:59:57 Okay, but in that case, let's say we found XYZ company who's going to do these beautiful interpretive signs, but could MLR be the one who's assigned to oversee it and make sure that the content that goes into it is correct? Yes. And coordinates the content, develops the content. And I guess I was going to go to the track. As far as if MLR came up with this is how we're going to program it, could they contract out with...

2:00:31 Company X, once again, to run these particular programs. Yeah, I suppose so. Yeah, I think the question on that, which I think we can do probably with the fact you say a contract out, i.e. you're taking town dollars to give it to MLR, they're paying a third-party contractor to go program track, is that coming short? Yeah. Tracking the process. Right, and then the policy question, which again we're not going to talk about, but it's there and the council should think about at some point is,

2:01:09 In which cases is it more efficient to run contracts like that through MLR versus through town staff? And actually the track example was where MLT, thank you, John, has stepped in to try and bring more people in, which I call programming the track to try and get the summer stuff going more, but they're not involved in the actual contract with.

2:01:36 I don't know, let's get the, what is it, the Galaxy, the soccer team? Yeah. You know, so that MLR might go, or find this person and this group, but then turn it over to the town to actually work out the details of which days they get. Yeah. We could actually see a lot of that happening. Go out and do that footwork, legwork, bringing stuff in, and that's kind of a sudden dialogue I've heard recently.

2:02:00 They beat the Bushes. Well, and I think that's part of the conversation also later on is if there is going to be an agreement executed between the town and MLR.

2:02:13 Then there's an expectation for the performance of both sides as well. So that something might get handed off, there's an expectation of how that gets implemented in an efficient and effective manner also. So that would be defined in there as well. This is as good a time as any dimension that there's one potential storm cloud on the horizon. No, it's pink outside. It's beautiful.

2:02:39 The California Assembly has just done something kind of dumb. In response to some cities contracting out certain functions, and bearing in mind that the state legislature is, in my opinion, owned by organized labor, they've just adopted a non-binding resolution the Assembly has opposing cities contracting out for services.

2:03:07 Doesn't mean anything yet, but the League of Cities and a lot of cities fear that it could be a prelude to eventually the legislature taking steps to pass laws restricting cities' abilities to contract out for services. So nothing's happening yet, and it's sure to be a firefight if they decide to do it, but they've taken an unpleasant step in that direction, and I don't know

2:03:36 What form that legislation might take, if there is going to be any legislation, you know, obviously we'll keep you posted, but if the legislature goes in that direction, which would be, yeah, it would be a really dumb thing to do, but if they did that, it might affect the town's ability to contract out some things to MLR, or maybe even MLT, or maybe MLH. What's the assembly bill number?

2:04:06 I think it was HR 29, I think was the bill. Oh, it was a resolution. Yeah, it was a resolution. It was not a bill. And it says explicitly, basically, that when cities contract out, they save too much money. Sorry, the organized labor spin on that is that contractors just don't pay enough, which is another way of saying that cities save too much money by contracting out. Okay, but so...

2:04:35 I can interpret that as since that feeling is out there, we just have to be careful in what services are assigned to MLR if it goes forward and that there, for example, we're looking at that it augments existing ones and does things that aren't being done. Well, I don't know because it's hard to predict what the lunatics in Sacramento might do, but I just don't know what it might be. So we all have to, I don't think that this should.

2:05:04 Dampen anyone's enthusiasm. It doesn't mean that we can't proceed. It just means we should all be aware that at some point Sacramento may take some of these abilities away from us. What if the league's take on that was they're lining the votes up to be able to put a bill through once they get you to pass this resolution and you begin that process. Then when a bill comes out, it looks, you've already committed to this. Is it easy to vote for you now? That's been the discussion. Of course, the number of bills they're managing to get passed keeps dropping.

2:05:33 They'd have to get through both houses. But, I mean, this is, I mean, one of the most powerful union groups, I mean, it's SEIU and AFC, SME. Okay. Yeah, which are both public employee unions. Oh, yeah. And as you might expect, they're all fairly opposed to cities contracting things out. But if you're under contract, can it be repealed?

2:06:00 With this new one? Yeah. I guess the question is if MLR goes under a multi-year contract, call it a three-year contract, before this passes, does it at least get grandfathered for the... I mean, there's that impairment of contracts question about whether the legislature could legally do that. You're saying Mammoth Lakes Tourism under a five-year contract. Yeah. I don't know. I don't know. We'd have to see. But it's... I just...

2:06:27 Even though they are owned by organized labor, it's still kind of appalling and a little bit shocking that they've gone this direction. I think it's a great idea, and I'll tell you why. Because what that'll do is it'll create jobs. On our form here,

2:06:58 We had, we talked about programs. Yeah, we talked about programming. I think Terry asked that question. We got it in. And to make sure that we covered number one also. Well, those were just the ones that were on the list. That was just our stuff. Are there any other questions at the table with regards to 15 and the Sorted Authorities? Any questions from the public on 15 or the Sorted Authorities? Okay, then let's go to 16.

2:07:31 What is the definition of overhead? There are a lot of definitions of overhead. I think that if the question is what sorts of overhead could MLR pay for using R&U dollars, I think that would be governed by the agreement between the town and MLR. We probably want to come up with a definition in that agreement. So by that you mean that it might actually list areas?

2:08:00 that are considered, like health insurance is, but I don't know, something else is not. Paperclips are not. Paperclips are not. Paperclips are not. Right. And I think it would help both MLR and the town to be as specific as possible in defining what can and cannot be paid for with R and U dollars. Could it be percentages or dollar amounts, or does it have to be specific? Well, I think we need specific categories, and then maybe saying that whatever percentage of those categories correlates to what

2:08:30 What percentage of MLR's efforts are devoted to R and U stuff as opposed to non-R and U stuff? Okay, so, you know, the town typically does when they're looking at putting a billable rate to something. It typically includes all benefits. It typically includes whatever supplies need to be used. It includes paperclips. It includes rent. It includes, you know, whatever, you know, phone. So, you know, that's...

2:08:57 That is typically included in the town's billable hours that is currently being billed to measure R. Actually, we're just billing straight salaries. We're not doing the fully burden rate. You are not doing it fully burden. Okay. So from other pieces, fully burdened, cost of employee benefits. For everything. But not the fully burdened rate. For everything. For all assets. So plus benefits, but not other. Okay. Can you clarify that?

2:09:22 So right now for the direct charges like for the overhead work, I don't donate my time to NLR or to UNR. But if they're putting in the hourly rate that's on a time card, that picks up the benefit pieces and their hourly rate. It doesn't pick up a fully burdened rate, including rent and phones and computers and those elements. We build some of that in for different grants that we can do where you can actually build to those things. So there's a different...

2:09:50 And so for any staff that is overseeing any projects that were funded by R&U? I don't know for certain on some of the direct costs on some of the overhead if the engineering is doing that for a project.

2:10:02 I'm thinking of the discharging time, but I have to confirm now. Yeah, we could, that would be helpful to confirm. That would be a project cost versus a generic holiday. But being paid by R&U, being going, R&U funding, going to the town to oversee the project, you just want to know, is it fully burdened or is it just the salary? It would be great to confirm now. Anything else we want to add to 16? Any questions for 16? Any questions from the public on 16?

2:10:33 Okay, let's go to 17. So 17 is, it refers to the part of the Measure R ordinance that says that funds have to go into a special account to be used by the town. And the question is, can this requirement be met through the agreement between the town and MLR? I'm not exactly sure what the question is. If the question is, can funds go directly from the tax collector to MLR, the answer is no.

2:10:58 The ordinance says that the funds have to go into a special fund designated for use by the town for specific purposes. So the money flows to the town, stays in the fund, and the council has to make allocation decisions, and that's how it would have to go. Can I ask a follow-up question, Andrew? Sure. I think we're estimating it's $1.7 million a year.

2:11:25 Is it possible that the town would retain some, like if there's this idea of there's a future capital projects reserve or something like that, that the town might retain that point much until there's an actual project? Yeah. But your recommendation would be put aside, how much did we do on our $300,000? Yeah. And that would definitely...

2:11:46 Stay until needed with the town? That's sort of the question that was asked earlier, is how, what's the mechanism for the disbursement of funds from the town to MLR? And as we discussed earlier, that's entirely a policy question. I mean, it could be that the council just writes MLR a check a couple times a year for all the ARG dollars or all the U dollars or whatever it may be, or the town could hold some back. That's really up to the council.

2:12:11 Could this, okay, I don't know, I don't think they go, could those funds, if they're being directed to a specific project, be put into an account through MLR that is interest-bearing that could? Sure. I mean, at that point, you start getting into the question of can MLR get a better interest rate than the town can?

2:12:31 And I guess I'm not saying that at that point it's going towards a project. At that point if you're just saving because in two years I'm going to be able to build this thing so we're going to put this amount of money in there for two years. So you put it into an interest bearing something for two years and then at that point in time then it would be able to come back.

2:12:52 I mean, obviously, it would not be in MLR's name. But, well, it would have to be, because I don't think the town can do something like that. Yeah, we can put, we have a definite policy that's structured how we can invest dollars. Okay. We're looking at some options. Okay. Dan, what, is LEIF doing a better rate right now than just kind of a general commercial savings account? Yeah, they're only giving a couple, 0.2 or something like that right now, so.

2:13:20 There's options in terms of our investment policy, how you can put things away. If you know you're going to have dollars available and they're not going to be used, then you can put them into different elements that are raised. Real quick, too, on the charging of the overhead, we currently just charge hourly rates for the employee cost of salary benefits. We don't roll it up for other town costs.

2:13:49 On and on, on everything, so any project that is being funded by Measure R and Public Works or the Planning Department. Would you charge the person staff time as all? Staff time, no benefits? Yeah, benefits, full cost. Benefits at full cost of, okay. So, we don't roll up for phones. So, the rent, et cetera, that's coming out generally. It's not fully funded. Correct. That's okay. So, it's a full, full cost of, okay. Okay. Okay. Anything else on that one? Mm-hmm.

2:14:18 Any questions from the public on 17? Okay, 18. Number 18, we've already discussed under the heading of question 4 and question 5, but question 18 was, is there a conflict of interest if MLR receives measure R&U funds from the town and also makes funding recommendations for R&U? The answer is yes, there is, as we've discussed. Any question on that? No. 19 have combination.

2:14:48 Yeah, question 19 is asking to clarify conflicts of interest for the MLR board, specifically regarding MLR directors serving on other boards that might partner with MLR on projects or third-party contracts. So California laws on conflicts of interest don't apply to private parties. There is a Fair Political Practices Commission opinion from 1977 holding that in some circumstances

2:15:16 A nonprofit corporation can be considered a government entity for purposes of the conflict laws. That particular case involved a nonprofit that was set up by a city, funded by the city, and existed to provide services traditionally performed by the city. So under the rationale of that opinion, I think that there's a decent chance that MLR itself would be considered a public entity for purposes of the conflict laws, which is why there's a conflict.

2:15:43 and it making funding recommendations regarding its own funding. It's not clear that MLR directors who are on boards of other groups would be precluded from contracting with those other groups. We'd have to do a little bit of digging on that. We might need to get an FPPC opinion. The policy question, that's the legal side. The policy question, which we're not going to talk about, but I'll just flag it, is whether the council wants to impose the same standards on MLR

2:16:14 That would apply to the town itself. So would the council want to say, no, if you're on the MLR board and you're on the board of some other group, you're not going to be contracting with your other group on behalf of MLR. Wouldn't the Brown Act actually play out? Brown Act's purely open meetings. It's not conflict related. But many bylaws have that whole section about interested parties not participating. So if the bylaws had something like that.

2:16:42 That person would, and where I'm presuming you're going, is that person would recuse themselves? Well, there are two approaches, because there are two, broadly speaking, there are two sets of conflict laws. One is the Political Reform Act, which says that if you have a conflict, you recuse yourself, and the rest of the body can vote. But then there's something called Government Code Section 1090.

2:17:02 By the way, we're going to be doing ethics training in August. We should all come. And we're going to cover all this stuff in great detail. We get that every couple years. But 1090 says that if you're a council member, say you're a council member that has a business. Let's say it's Colin's business. So the town, if you were on the council, the town could not enter into a contract with your business. It just can't. It doesn't matter if you recuse yourself. It doesn't matter if it's a good deal. It doesn't matter if you're the only game of town. It just can't.

2:17:30 And so it would be up to the council to decide whether you would want a stricter policy like that, that MLR simply will not do business with any entity that is represented on the MLR board, or you might decide that it's just a policy of having to recuse yourself. And that would be very important to determine because that's going to determine who's going to be putting an M in for the board, so who you would be putting on that board.

2:17:54 But that's part of a contract negotiation. Right. Or MLR could decide to put something in their bylaws that was asked to purchase that. Yes, but bearing in mind that the bylaws can be amended by the board at any time. Well, there was a discussion about whether or not the council would have some right to review bylaws changes, which didn't get into this list. Well, the answer to that is if the council negotiated for that as part of the agreement.

2:18:22 I mean, you're starting to see there's a lot of stuff that's going to be in this agreement. Okay. Okay. Any other questions on 19th at the table? Any questions from the public on 19th? Okay, then we have number 20. Number 20 is, did the draft bylaw recommendations regarding the composition of the board, the transition process for the board, and nominating procedures for the board meet any legal requirements of the town?

2:18:50 This is referring to a March 31st document that had a series of proposed bylaw provisions which went well beyond just the board transition and makeup and nominating stuff. The answer is that there are no town legal requirements. The only legal requirements that really apply are those found in the Corporations Code, specifically in the bits that apply to nonprofit public benefit corporations.

2:19:18 With a couple little clarifications, yeah, those comply. Once we get the draft set of bylaws, I've already had the discussion. True, but it would be nice for being on that subcommittee, it would be nice to know what those clarifications are so we can write them in for our first draft. I can send an email about that. I have my notes on it.

2:19:49 Right. We're supposed to do them by April 28. The point was my notes. Oh, okay. All right, great. Any other questions on 20? Any questions from the public on 20? Okay. And let's go to Pat's questions. Again, Pat's questions were labeled number three, and there was one that was legal, and one that had a combination with policy. Thank you. Yeah.

2:20:19 There you go. Teri, scratch your notes up there. All right. Yeah. So number three was legal. Right. Pat, your questions one and two were policy-related. Number three was, let's see, does the language of Measure R prohibit the town from allocating funds to a nonprofit to manage existing towns, facilities, programs, trails, or parks? You know, we've kind of touched on that as part of the discussion of earlier questions.

2:20:48 Measure R says that its dollars can be spent on town recreation facilities, which there's some interesting discussion about what that might mean. Does that mean ownership or not? And then programs, trails, and parks managed by the town. And there's also, you know, there's room for discussion on what managed by the town means. So there's room for discussion, interpretation on your question.

2:21:17 Does it allow, does Measure R allow the town to give MLR money to manage existing facilities, programs, trails, and parks? It may. It's about as clear as that can be as it may. Well, I think we do that right now. What? To some degree, between the Forest Service, between the Friends of the Inu, you know, they're... If we're doing direct contracts with them, it's different. Yeah. Okay. This has that third-party piece. Okay, it's the third-party contract. Okay.

2:21:53 Give it to the NGO. The NGO goes out and is a contract. Okay. Okay. Versus a direct contract. It may go through a process. To provide a particular service. Yes. And it may, like, go through the rec commission or through MLT and SCC and say, yes, we should do this program. The town goes, great, we will go enter into that agreement directly. So it's a recommendation. The town actually does the contract. And so it could do the same thing as far as that goes.

2:22:20 Yeah, we went to make that recommendation, the contract is through the town. And we do, the vast majority of stuff is done that way, the town is not doing the contracting services, but based on the recommendations that have been put forward, we'll be able to budget adopted by the council. Pat, does that answer your question? Thank you. Okay, are there any other questions from the public on that question?

2:22:45 Do you want to talk about number four? Yeah. So Pat's fourth question was, can a temporary board take applications from its existing members, then vote on approving itself without recusing itself or its individual members during the voting process? Pat, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but if the question is whether the MLR formation committee can become the initial board of MLR, the answer is yes, if the committee members meet whatever board qualification criteria are in the bylaws.

2:23:15 This is not governed by the laws that apply to cities. It's not governed by the conflict laws. It's not governed by the things that the town usually has to comply with. Basically, anyone can form a corporation. I mean, any group of people can get together and say, we want to form a corporation, file some bylaws, file some articles of incorporation with the state, and you have a corporation and you can be the board. So there are almost no restrictions on who can form

2:23:44 Who can plan a corporation and who can then become the board? But I think the caveat is that this will be funded with public monies. So I think that's what I think is, and a lot of public money, up to over 1.7 million approximately. It's not a legal question. And I put this down as a hybrid legal question and policy question because the corollary question is, should any of that happen?

2:24:13 Should this group simply become the initial MLR board, that's up to the council, or actually it's up to this group. The council cannot stop this group from just declaring itself to be Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Right, which, you know, I think is problematic, and that's why I mentioned at the last MLR meeting, could there be a consideration of, you know, X number of slots and save some of them for new incoming members and some for existing members because

2:24:44 You know, continuity I think is important. And I must commend everybody because I know you've spent a lot of time and energy and volunteering your own time to put this together. But with all due respect, I see a lot of boards in this community and I see a lot of the same names on the boards. So I think it's, you know, important to get new fresh blood, different opinions. Everybody doesn't always have to agree, but I think it's...

2:25:15 It's good to have a variety of thoughts and concepts. Dana, could I respond to that for the people who haven't seen the detail of what we discussed at the last meeting? At the last meeting, the proposal is at this point to have this committee become the transition board with a full board with public able to apply installed in October of 2014.

2:25:49 But just to clarify, I agree with what you're saying, Joe, but this body will be the voting body of deciding who will then be on this committee. If that's what council approves, yes. As with any body that forms itself, it votes to form itself. That's how a board gets formed. Right, but with...

2:26:18 You know, if it's a foundation or something where you're getting money from other sources, that's one thing. But if it's money coming from taxpayer initiatives, then I think there's, you know, maybe there isn't a legal requirement, but maybe it's more ethical. Sure. It's a policy question. As Andy noted, it's a policy question. So thanks. Sure.

2:26:41 Thanks. So I just want to clarify for myself what I'm hearing here. So, oh, sure, Deb Perel, community member, running for town council too. But what I think I heard, and I was at the last meeting, so I understood the self-perpetuating board in some ways is possible, but I just heard something about if council approves it from Dana just now, and that kind of clouded me because I believe that the board itself can make these decisions in there as any entity can. Is that correct?

2:27:08 And then the town council has nothing to do with the bylaws of it. It only has to do with whether they feel that things should be funded the way the structure is and the information they get when things are presented. Correct. That's what we're saying is that this could be formed and if council doesn't like it, they don't have to fund it. And they could ask for more detail at any time. Right. And that's a good clarifying question, Deb. Thanks. Because really the council is not making decisions directly over the composition of the board or the contents of the bylaws.

2:27:38 MLR would probably be well advised to run some of the important points past the council since the council will be holding the purse strings. Or even just to think about it in that concept as they're doing it. Thank you for the clarification. That's it. That's it. You're at the end. However, we're going to ask the table here. Before we leave this topic, are there any other questions from the table at this point?

2:28:13 regarding legal questions that you want to share with Andy right now. Anything that was discussed earlier? Do you want to get any clarification on? Will Andy encapsulate the answers to these questions in the form of her reports?

2:28:36 I already have the memo written. I just need to make a few revisions to it, and then I will distribute it. And within this report, do you highlight areas that are those areas that are particularly gray or lacking in the definition? I do. I've presented it in my memo just as I've presented it to you, warts and all.

2:29:05 Thank you. Because I think the town council and citizens and the student committee really needs to be aware of those areas where it's hard to say. I have to tell you, as a lawyer, it's very difficult to say publicly that some things are ambiguous.

2:29:25 Very, very hard. Yeah, very, oh, it's painful. But yes, I've done that and I will do that in that version that comes to you. Okay, I appreciate that. Thank you very much. And I appreciate the work and the explanation that you've given everybody today. It's been very educational for me and it's causing me to think deeply about some areas in particular, about weighing the...

2:29:52 How the organization could operate or what difficulties it could be have or how free it may be to operate or how limited it could be to operate. Happy to help. You're quite welcome. Are there any additional questions from the public for Andy?

2:30:12 Sharon Clark, not necessarily today, but you have answered lots of questions, but you have also raised lots of questions. Will we have an opportunity to question later as we digest what we've heard tonight? I'm looking at you down on that. That's a capacity and time issue. I don't know in our process where we're bringing Annie back.

2:30:39 I think if we bring the write-up back, and Andy's clear about that, but if we have that item on an agenda discussed by the committee again, then you could have public comment on it. So whether or not it be this level of discussion would be a difficult answer. Yeah, I mean, certainly if the committee or the council directs me to answer additional questions, I'll do that. Right. I think the intent also is to include

2:31:05 to the report that we take back to the Council for their consideration and approval in May will include, you know, what you've provided us here and all the recaps and everything. So there will be an opportunity, sorry, there will be an opportunity also at the Council level to have those questions asked as well. So there will definitely be that opportunity too.

2:31:31 Sure. And also, we're hoping to have that write-up by the joint meeting next Wednesday if Andy's able to make it. No, it's already written. It's just a question of making a few modifications. Okay. That's going to be on the 16th agenda. Okay. Joe. Joe Perino. My question is, was there any media in this room? Was there any media invited to this room? They've been here before. And this is televised. Yeah.

2:32:00 Okay. Okay, then I'll save my comments for when Town Council comes. Any other comments from public on the legal issues? Can we come to the podium, please? Yes, thanks. Hi, my name is Elena Blumgren. I've had the opportunity to work as an attempt for measuring and measure our funds for a project for Stu Brown. And I just had a quick question in regards to MLR's work.

2:32:34 My understanding is that MLR was going to actually work on larger projects like corporate sponsorship events, any other type of outreach, advertising dollars. So now I'm understanding that they're also going to be working on the smaller projects and then maintaining them.

2:32:57 Is that my understanding? What are you considering smaller projects? I don't think so. Well, I think, I'm sorry, so the smaller projects, I mean like the events that go on in town, the distribution of those funds. No. No.

2:33:14 That's not an intended. And some of the questions we posed today were, well, what are the boundaries? The exact scope of work is still being worked on. I believe we've got it down for our April 28th meeting to get back to discussing the scope of work a little bit more. So if some of the questions we asked were to help us, we're trying to figure out what that is. But I don't believe, at least the council has any intention of changing like youth sports funding or

2:33:43 Because I guess that's what you're referring to, or a special... What are you talking about? But if you're talking about special events... But if you're talking about special events... Money's coming from Measure U? Is that what you're saying? As outlined in RecStrats 2. Pardon me? As outlined in RecStrats 2, that is one of the seven areas of recreation that could be considered for moving over, and I think it's the intention that it be proposed that way. And then my last question is...

2:34:09 What would be the benefit of MLR actually maintaining some of the structures like the ice rink or let's say parks and rec, things like that? Oh, sure. Sorry. I think what we've been talking about is relative to efficiency, effectiveness, leveraging capabilities, entrepreneurial in nature.

2:34:40 I think that's the discussion that this body's been having about the potential role for an MLR-type entity to play in those facilities or activities moving into the future. Looking at an entity that maybe can be a bit more nimble is the word that we've been using over the straits that sometimes government has to function under. So that's been part of that discussion.

2:35:10 The only thing that I would think is that with the budgets and the funding, wouldn't it be more cost effective to keep that in-house? That's part of the analysis that's going to take place as well. Okay. Well, thank you. If we don't have any more questions for Andy, you can stay if you'd like. Actually, I would like him to stay for the next, for number three. Okay. Oh, yeah.

2:35:40 So we are going to move on to agenda item debate. And I want to reiterate what John Armstrong just said, that the time that you took to go through these questions, the time that you gave to helping us understand a bit more what those side boards are going to look like, helps make the work of this group a little bit easier.

2:36:03 A little bit. But at least we have some sideboards, and that's very, very helpful. So thank you for doing that. Thank you for coming here. It was a special trip for you today, so thanks for coming down and joining us. You're quite welcome. We're always happy to help. Okay, good. So let's go on to number three. We're asking to look at, for this group, we're looking to do a couple of changes.

2:36:29 Yes, let me handle it. If you remember at our February 20th meeting, I think it was. Okay, I'm trying to remember exactly which day it was. We started making assignments of subgroups based on what we thought would happen. And when I went back and looked at it, somehow John and Betsy and I were crazy enough to sign up for the one that had scope of work, budget, business plan.

2:36:58 and contract negotiations. And in reality, the feeling is this, we need to split that into some pieces. In other words, we're saying, we need help. Yeah, right. Well, we could, but knowing which things we need to get accomplished before the May 21st meeting, so it was a suggestion.

2:37:24 If possible, because since then, we've actually talked about it more as a strategic plan than a business plan, is that if we could separate that one out into another subgroup, and Mr. Armstrong hasn't had an opportunity to volunteer for any of the subcommittees yet since he was enjoying himself out of the country. Oh, he's on, you know. So, and then we also, and then we,

2:37:50 And it also came to my attention, and actually since I'd had the discussion with Teri and Dana after the last meeting, I couldn't tell my compatriots, but I realized that we're not going to be able to do the budget until we have some kind of an idea of what kind of person is going to fill that chief recreation officer and what they might cost. So I was going to ask that to be split out for someone to start giving us a ballpark sooner rather than later.

2:38:18 Because we only have three more meetings before the job. You're talking job description? Yeah. Well, job description or at least even just starting with bringing in functions and, you know.

2:38:28 You know, because I don't know, you know, I mean, you could pay this person $50,000, you could pay him $500,000, and I don't know. But we can't do a budget without that critical piece, because I think we have been discussing that the first thing we need to do is start with a good executive director, and we know that's how MLT's worked out so well. So I'm kind of saying, yes.

2:38:52 So I'm kind of asking, can we split that one and get some volunteers to help with the other pieces? All of it? Was it the job description? The job description? Yeah. Okay. Potential CEO. Yes. Yes. Could you do that? And would you be able to do that in a manner to come back to us on April 28th with that review?

2:39:20 In that description, in that function? So a question, if some of us know of some examples that we want to give to John, how do we not get into a, can we just send him look at examples?

2:39:31 look at the Rose Bowl Commission, or, well, since this is a Brown Act body, yeah, um, you can't communicate more than, uh, so, so do we send them through Sharon, and Sharon can, our, our staff, okay, she can send it to John, okay, yeah, or Dan might be better, actually, okay, yeah, I've got some of myself from, uh, several, I will see threes, and, uh,

2:39:57 PSIA, National Ski Patrol, U.S. Ski Team, U.S. Ski Association. And I did some of that work projectively. Okay. Great. Do you want help? I'll do that with you, John. Okay. Thanks, Colin. Colin and John will take on the staff function description subcommittee catalog.

2:40:26 Ad-Hoc Committee. So that's one. The second one that we were talking about was splitting this out so that we've got a scope of work group and a budget group and then the framework for the contract. We want to get the framework for the contract moving with a different ad hoc group. And where does strategic plan live? In a post. Strategic plan, business plan, scope of work, budget.

2:40:51 Was all one. And contract. Because we're looking at the strategic plan to be post May 21st. Yeah, we were thinking business plan, strategic plan, we just might get agreement that that's after May 21st.

2:41:07 So scope and budget is one piece? Scope and budget still stays, yeah. And we still might be the three for business plan strategic plan, but let's be realistic. Yeah, it will. But then we need the contract framework. I'm looking at you only because of your experience with TAM contracts. That's all, Andy.

2:41:30 I know Rick does not serve as our legal advice, but he does have a lot of the legal background, so should we, since our next meeting is the 14th, and do you need to announce that before everybody leaves? Yeah, we're still meeting, so we appreciate your quiet, but just to advise on the agenda, there's an incorrect date on the bottom. Our next meeting is actually April 14th.

2:41:58 So that's when our next meeting is being held. So for those of you who are leaving, so that you could know that. But then Rick won't be back by that meeting, so I don't know. Yeah, I don't know. But we're feeling like we need to stay, especially with all the answers Andy has given us, starting to work on the contract. And I'd be glad to work on that, but I'd see that it's a separate subcommittee. Yeah, it is a separate subcommittee.

2:42:27 Some of the, what I do with the job description crosses over slightly in the scope of work. Yes, it does. So I can do something on scope of work. We've got three, so we're stuck. We've got three on scope, but what we need is contract. Oh, I see. And just while I was talking about this,

2:42:49 For the budget subcommittee, we're looking at having you guys bring an operational budget requirement. We're going to have this discussion on Monday the 14th of what's included in an operational budget. So just as a heads up to you guys, we're not asking to bring anything, but we're going to talk about it on the 14th so that we know. We have a meeting scheduled, but it's after that, right? It's the 17th. Okay. So we are still looking for an ad hoc for the

2:43:18 Contract Framework. I would be glad to be one, but I'd like a second person. I'll be with it. Okay, thank you. Did you say John? John, thanks John. So that's the ad hoc contract framework. Okay, great. And I think those were the two. The strategic plan would be held off. Yes. Well, we just more or less had a consensus that strategic plan, business plan is after May 21st.

2:43:47 There are only so many days left. Okay, any other questions about what we just did with the ad hoc? We moved it around. John and Joe, John Urdi and Joe are taking on the contract framework. John A. and Coleman are taking on the staff description function. And we've got, we moved an element off of the scope of work and budget. Correct. And that's Betsy, Joe, and John. Right. Since we're talking about it, I just want to, thinking about our future meetings,

2:44:16 And just to review this with you, on the 14th, which is Monday, we're going to talk about, it'll be quick, we're going to talk about the operational budget requirements so that we're clear on what we're going to be asking. Then we're also going to review the takeaways from today just for any, you know, our own clarification purposes and just make sure that we know what to do with information that was shared with us today. Then there may also be an opportunity, because this is on Monday,

2:44:44 Two days ahead of the joint meeting, we might be able to provide any questions to Joe and Rick who are going to be sharing or convening that meeting. Right. So that's on the floor. And that agenda has already been posted. I think everybody got a copy of that to look at the items that will be discussed. Those of us who are not on.

2:45:04 Either MLT, SCC, or Rec Commission, or... Sharon, you sent it to everyone on this group. Did you guys not get it? Did you see the agenda? The April 16 joint meeting, did that go to this home? I didn't think it came out from Sharon. Oh, okay. It came out from Pam. Okay. Did you not receive it?

2:45:22 We don't know. We don't know. To make sure that... I think it was the rec commissioner, but I don't know if it... Because I'm the rec commissioner, I can't... Okay. Yes, just send it to the whole group and then... To the MLR committee? Yeah. Actually, I think that came from Jamie.

2:45:37 Make sure that it comes to the MLR Committee. The April 16th. That came out from Jamie. I believe it came out from Jamie. So we're just asking for the MLR Committee to receive it. Because not everybody on MLR is on any of those. So just as a reminder, that's next Wednesday, a week from today, and it is at 3 p.m. in this building.

2:46:03 Yes, as Colin spends his entire day in here and then I spend my entire evening in here. And then our next meeting is scheduled for April 28th. After that. After that, after April 16th. Just to note, April 16th is not an MLR committee meeting, but we can attend it if we would like to and sit in the audience and watch the discussion. So just as a note of that. Our next meeting would be Monday, April 28th.

2:46:32 And there's a couple of things that we're looking to have delivered there. We'll have the final draft bylaws to be reviewed and recommended at that meeting. We'll have a review of the MLR scope of work. We'll have a review of the MLR budget. We'll have a review of the MLR staff descriptions. And we'll have a report out from the Contract Framework Yadlock Group.

2:46:52 I apologize. Yes, we do. She's just telling us what's on the next two meetings. 14, 16, 28. Yep. 14, 16, 28. Oh, goody. I'm not on one of those. John, we're going to be busy. And then just to confirm, we are on Monday, April, excuse me, May 12th is the next one. And at that meeting, we'll be reviewing the documents packet that's going forward for the May 21st Town Council meeting.

2:47:20 And then on the 19th we've got a meeting. That's our preparation for the Wednesday, May 21st council meeting. Then on the 21st is the council meeting. And then we have on our calendar a meeting on the 22nd to debrief after the council meeting on the 21st. And then we do have a meeting scheduled for June 2nd.

2:47:43 In anticipation if it did get carried over to June 4th for the decision. So 6-4 is a potential council meeting too. If something doesn't happen or something gets delayed or postponed to the June 4th council meeting, our meeting on the 2nd could be... No, but on one of the listings, the next Monday's meeting got dropped off. But now we know what all our due dates are.

2:48:12 So, any questions about that? Okay. I'm to number four. Any reports from our MLR committee members? Anything from the outreach group that you guys want to share with us tonight? The only thing I have to add is Betsy and I spoke at the trails meeting at the college and kind of hard to relay thoughts from that.

2:48:36 Did you want to share anything? Yeah, well, it was just an appropriate time to just bring up some of the feedback that we got. Okay, great. So some of the questions that we got, obviously it was the trails group, so that was the primary concern there. There was concern about...

2:48:55 State and Federal Grants and MLR's ability or inability to apply for or receive that type of funding, specifically as it pertains to trails. And some questions raised about the Council's suspension of measures R and U, which I believe we'll get into at the meeting on the 16th. And then just the other thing that was just brought up sort of generally was just...

2:49:24 Concerns about maintaining the trails and just concerns about building new infrastructure just given the maintenance challenges for what currently exists.

2:49:36 Was that a question about MLR or just in general that trails are being built and there's no capacity to maintain them by either the Forest Service or the town? Both. And it's specifically related to MLR just because I think, you know, a lot of discussion about MLR has been, you know, enhancing and augmenting and, you know, and looking at, you know, raising funds to do, you know, new things, not necessarily trails, but if trails, you know, is one of the items that that's just something we need to be aware of. Yeah, I took it as more a general comment.

2:50:05 You know, it's an issue that we're facing in the town right now. It's a lack of budget for maintenance. And then also just a similar question that was brought up tonight, just, you know, really diving into the finances of, you know, whether it stays within house or goes to an MLR and how that impacts expenditures. So I think that's been addressed.

2:50:36 Were there any other outreach discussions? We went with the events coalition on Tuesday. What's today? Tuesday, yesterday. And I think that they tend to feel that the events are put on a back burner in general. And they had requested that they be considered to have a standing seat with the board moving forward. We explained that right now we have a MLT seat and a council seat are the only two standings.

2:51:04 Anybody on the event coalition is welcome to apply for the positions on the board. They wanted us to go back and do a, to look at, and this probably falls into our budget conversation, but to look at other non-profit organizations and what the salaries ranges are. In this area or in general? I think in general for comparable requirements. I'm just curious, were they willing to share the

2:51:33 Salaries of their staff? Maybe just as a comparison or just to include in the conversation? We can ask. We didn't ask at that point. If we're going to talk salaries and stuff, let's talk. Well, I think even the cost of living here is a little bit different regardless of what the nonprofit is somewhere else. Yeah. Thank you. And there was just a concern that we are going to

2:51:57 Have a posted budget, so that would be publicly posted. And so, you know, that comes into the legal, what would the entity be legally required to do, and we would, you know, follow whatever legally is required. And the question was not necessarily specifically to events, but they actually kind of spelled out arts and culture. That arts and culture, they were looking for... Fine arts and culture. Fine arts and culture. They were looking for specifically that to be represented.

2:52:26 On the board. And we're concerned about the funding and how that funding would be handled as far as how Measure U funds are handed out right now for allocations. Can I ask you a question? When they were talking about a public and posted budget, are they talking beyond the requirements that a 501c3 file a 990 with all the attachments? Well, they were talking about they wanted to have it on something that was online that was reviewable. Oh, okay.

2:52:53 Which is transparency. Yeah. It's basically transparency. Okay. Because we said that we're going to follow, you know, the letter of the law. So whatever's legally required. Right. Sure. And so then if that's, that would be then a policy discipline. Right. Okay. And the other. Yeah. I have one. I did contact the Women's Club to get on there May.

2:53:21 Program, unfortunately, it conflicts with a meeting that Rick, Collin, and I will be in, so someone else is going to have to be available on May 21st, if I'm counting right, Pat, third Wednesday? What is that part? Second way, sorry, May 14th, sorry, we've got, we've got a special council and planning commission meeting about parking or something that day, so we're tied up, so somebody else will have to go on 514. And what time is it?

2:53:49 I'll forward the, it's evening, it's 6 or 6.30? 6.30 for the business part. 6 o'clock for social. Right. But unfortunately, after volunteering to do that one, I can't be there, so. Teri, did you inquire because you were interested in going, or? Yeah, I had an appointment that day, so I just was making sure what time it was. Yeah, it's evening. Anyhow, it would be an evening.

2:54:19 All right, who's the California Board of Education? Let me see, I'll come back here.

2:54:27 I can forward the information to you. I may be available to go with you. I would have to check. I think I can go as well. We'll put John just confirmed. We could probably confirm. I will be able to confirm probably by next week. So it's okay for me to send it to John and him then if it turns out to be three of them to be the ones who coordinate getting there, right? Okay. Just make sure. Okay. I should be able to say yes or no by next week.

2:54:55 John, the coordinator. Yeah. Okay. The other, I guess the other one would be, you know, we did have a Planning Commission meeting prior to this. As part of Commissioner Reports, I just, you know, read the chairlift speech, took a couple of questions from the quorum that we had there, which is, you know, Dave. But Dave didn't have much to add in the questions.

2:55:23 We also had the MLT board, sorry, we met with the MLT board last Wednesday and I think that it was good, you know, folks like Tom Cage really appreciated getting more of the detail behind it because I think there are a lot of misconceptions out there. What we've been doing, Teri and I, is actually handing copies of the chairlift speech out, you know, not only going through it but handing it out to people so that they can actually have the talking points so that they can reference it, that there were more than, you know, 20 organizations involved in the summer.

2:55:50 Kind of where we're going and the board and the oversight and all the other pieces. So, you know, not just relying on people who remember what we said, but actually to have it in their pockets. Yeah, so, Joe, any progress with the meeting with the Forest Service? We haven't gotten it scheduled yet, but we're looking at hopefully the week after the joint meeting. Getting the three of them in the room at the same time. And Rick's not back until the 16th, so.

2:56:23 So we set it up for after that. One thing that the Forest Service brought up at the Charles Committee meeting was some of the infrastructure in the Forest Service campgrounds and other things. Yes. In fact, I listened to that whole meeting. Some of that he had already put into an email, and some of it I noted that for discussion when we do meet with them. Just to make you aware.

2:56:50 Find support, help for those needs. Right. So that speaks to the relationship between partners. Yep. Right. Any other reports out from any way? John, we have any home? Thank you. May 14th, I'm back at a new scheme association. Okay. So then. Can we make that decision on Monday? Because I should be able to come back and set my schedule. I should remind us that you will bring that back to confirm the women's club on Monday. Yes.

2:57:18 Okay. Good. If there aren't any other MLR committee member reports, what about future agenda items? Anything that you want to add? We've got a pretty, or the schedule is starting to, you know, we're bringing back deliverables and such, so just curious if you have anything else you want to add to any of our committee agendas. Just the one we discussed first. Yes. Yeah. All right. Good.

2:57:50 I don't have anything else, and since we're at the end of the agenda, we can adjourn ourselves. Great. Second that. Thank you very much. John and Betsy, can we talk for just a second about... Friday after 2.30 is about what I'm available. No, I just need a second. That's about a whole...