TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014

Parks & Recreation Commission Formation meeting

· recording 1 hr 31 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

201 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Thank you.

0:30 But if you still haven't come along, I don't want to have something to say. So we are live. The recording has begun. So let's go ahead and call this man for order. And Dan gets him to join us. Everybody has a copy of the agenda? No? Yes, thank you. Sharon, you want to go ahead and take a roll call?

1:07 Secretary David, here. Committee Member Herdy? Here. Committee Member Herdy? Here. Committee Member Stehlik? Yes. Committee Member Truax? Here. Committee Member Wood? Vice Chair Armstrong? Yes. Chair Stroud? Here. Thank you. Great. We'll open it up for any public comments from the public in attendance.

1:32 We'll remind you that if you do have public comment or throughout the meeting you'd like to address the committee, we'll ask you to come to the podium, but we'll open it up for any public comments from the public in attendance. And any public comments from the committee? Okay, then we will go ahead and move forward. Again, item number one was the acceptance of our notes from our meeting on 8th and 9th, and I would like to ask that we table that item until our next meeting.

2:05 That would be held on the 28th. And there's a couple reasons for that. Number one, we got them Friday afternoon, and that was a pretty quick turnaround. I know everybody had a really busy weekend. And we also want you to have moments to go through the notes. Secondly to that, we were just now in receipt of Andy's memo that he was drafting for us. He sent it over to Dan and to the town today. And so we want to be able to reconcile.

2:31 that there's, you know, information in the memo and make sure that our notes reflect that level of, I guess, reconciliation. So I would ask if the committee would be okay that we table the acceptance of those notes until our April 28th meeting. I have no problem with that, but I also am a little bit concerned that

2:54 These are not going to match up exactly whether or not a reconciliation should be done or whether or not we just say several questions were discussed because if they're not verbatim what turns out to be from the discussion or from the memo, what good are they?

3:12 Well, yes, I'm just looking at one. You know, committee members still have asked for clarification. Well, what good does that do? You know, if they weren't verbatim, my thought is we'd be better off at a summer book level so that there's not confusion between either the video that's going to be on Granicus forever or the memo for Mandy.

3:35 Well, and I think that's important. And I don't want to see one of our committees have to spend time trying to reconcile the two of them. Yeah, I agree. I think the point is that Andy's memo was intended to be the document that we will be using moving forward. And so in thinking about how our notes are put together, and Sharon, this is not reflected of the work that you did. Thank you very much. But in moving forward, I think...

4:01 What you're referencing is that our notes can be more summary basis, that we had a discussion and that we can refer to the memo for the specific questions and or responses from Andy at that particular time. Makes sense. And if you're okay with that, then we can take and have those minutes be redone just to...

4:25 Make them a little more, as we said, similar in nature and concise. And then we will spend the time going through Andy's notes and his memo at the 28th as well so that we can understand what he said and make sure that we all walked away with the same level of information. Okay. Is there any comment from the public on that?

4:46 So just so you understand, the memo from Andy that he referred to during last week's meeting is with the town at this time, and we anticipate that we will get it shortly from Dan, and it will be distributed for everybody, and that will be a guiding document as we move forward. So we'll move those notes to April 28th. Next, number two is I wanted to hear from the committee.

5:18 and spend a few moments talking about last week's meeting and kind of get a feel from you if there were any comments you'd like to share about that meeting, about the activity and the steps that we went through, the questions that we reviewed, if there were any things that jumped out at you as part of the discussion in realizing that we will be using that memo as we move forward.

5:48 I think I just wanted to hear and use this as an opportunity for us as a committee to chat about what we heard from Andy last week and if there was any theme or any major issues that you felt as we move forward as a community that we need to have addressed or if there was any implications that you were looking for. I just wanted to get a sense from you about our interaction with Andy last week. Going on the table? Yeah, I'm going to start down there.

6:20 You know, I think the only concern that I had was that we do have, and I know that Andy had expressed concern being a lawyer and having gray areas, and I think we need to get those as black and white as possible. I think that's, I think that, to me, that was a little bit of a surprise that we would either have the wording in Measure R and Measure U so vague or that we wouldn't be able to distinctly say that this is doable or it's not doable or it's...

6:47 Doable this way or doable that way. It just seemed like it was, well, it depends on how you interpret it. And interpretation is something everybody has a different take on. So I think getting it as black and white as possible is critical. But I think, all in all, I think we answered all the questions that I think were out there. One of my biggest concerns is kind of the process.

7:17 Is that, you know, it was stated that MLR could not receive monies and make recommendations of projects. And so what would that process be? You'd have, I can't see one body working here and then making recommendations to this and then moving forward. That just doesn't make sense. So I don't know how we work on that process. Unless I read it wrong, unless I heard it wrong. But I think that the process is...

7:46 Yeah, I had a question for him on the clarification for that. The question is, could MLR make recommendations on projects? MLR cannot make a recommendation to receive money itself. I think that's for the operations. So if MLR said we'd like to receive $50,000 to run MLR, I don't think you can make that type of recommendation in the body to that self-serving. That's a consequence.

8:16 I think the question I have to clarify is if the council made MLR the recommendation body is provided for in Major R, then could they make recommendations of how to spend money to council, but they could not make a recommendation of providing money to them. So how does that happen? I don't know them. That would need to be clarified because that's not how I heard it. That was my big concern because if it can't, then I don't see it functioning.

8:46 Right. And so I had the same clarification question. I had a hard time figuring that all out. I mean, I think that was confusing to me. And the real question that comes in that is that conflict of interest issue that comes in. Can you actually... And then the other element on the recommendation of the projects, if you recommend projects and basically, bad terminology, but basically the rubber stamp without substantive changes by the council.

9:17 Then that even puts you in a worse position of being able to recommend money to yourselves for that funding mechanism to make those recommendations. That's where you start to become that conflict of interest by it. So I think that's why I was getting out of it, but I had the same clarification. If they make no recommendation on their own funding, can they make other recommendations? That was my one major clarification, because if that can't be worked out, then...

9:46 And am I addressing what I think you're addressing? Yeah, I think you are. So anyways, because I think the other ones we could work with, that was the one that was... And that's one of the problems of not having the memo yet to look at is we can't figure out if we ask the right questions yet or if we have to ask another one that to clarify. Well, because that one is almost stated exactly the same way, so I need to clarify. I think we will. As a committee, we'll clarify it and get Andy to really kind of spell it out for us because I think the initial...

10:13 MLR can't be the recommending body and recommend funding to itself. That's right. This is the way I, this is the way I, this is the way to clarify that. It is to, you know, it is to kind of different things, but it didn't preclude, I remember, it didn't preclude the council from deciding to award funding to MLR. But it has to go to a recommending body of some sort. At some point, that might be. Yeah. Then the question is, if they receive money.

10:41 And then they make recommendations that aren't changed, then that's where you get more of this conflict. And that also lends right back to the expenditure plan within Measure R, which is a different document than what's in Measure U, and the ability for the expenditure plan to be changed by a majority of the council. So it's all kind of linked together. Because you can change the Measure R expenditure plan to have MLR be the recommending body for projects.

11:10 But you take yourself out of the ability to recommend for your own funding. So there's some other body that has to do that thing. And then if the council, then they can ignore that. Say they recommend, no, we don't have the funding. The council can ignore that recommendation and fund anyway. The question is, what point do you run into the conflict issues?

11:30 That's your process. Knowing that John has to leave it for... You know, I think overall it was extremely productive. I really appreciated the way that Andy will directly answer questions. So that was very helpful for me. You know, I think certainly some takeaway from that is...

12:01 I think it would make sense to have kind of whether it be separate accounts or separate accounting. I mean, he seemed to be pretty clear on that, that anything running through R&U should be accounted for in a different manner than outside fundraising. So that was pretty clear to me. You know, I echo Teri's question. I had a hard time wrapping my head around that. But overall, I thought it was extremely helpful. And looking forward to that memo.

12:33 Jim? Yeah, and I had the same thing of just people, how do we make this bigger than a bread box? And my thought was that, and maybe it's the legal subcommittee, once we get the memos, we kind of make a matrix, because there are certain things you can do without them, they're difficult with review, and actually lay it out so that everybody can understand it on a couple pieces of paper.

12:54 So I just volunteered for the committee for my work. I think that would be extremely helpful. It was so clear that, well, for R you can do this, and on several of the questions, and instead of having them mixed into a memo, is make a matrix and then say, okay, Andy, did we get it right? I think it's going to be really important moving forward that we do have that differentiation between what R can do and what you can do, and the difference. And they seem to cross in certain areas, like certain areas, R was more...

13:23 Flexible, and then other areas, U is more flexible, and it kind of like went back and forth in that respect. And we should include unrestricted in there. Do our U crossover and unrestricted, so. Well, and I think it's going to be critical for MLR success that there is that other unrestricted piece that allows it to kind of function, so.

13:48 Betsy? Well, that was a good meeting, and I agree. I like that Andy was willing to give us some direct answers while saying they're in gray areas, but the main takeaway that I came away with was that I don't think that anything that MLR has been proposed to do is insurmountable. I think he gave us some pretty clear feedback on the issues that we need to address, but I didn't hear anything that made me think that MLR wasn't going to be able to move forward with our timeline.

14:18 So I guess I have the same R&U funding issue as Teri and Dan. And I kind of thought back to the initial report and just, you know, we did talk about, you know, drawing on some of the expertise of, you know, the existing committees and how we would, you know, fold it into MLR and maybe there's a way to make that all work. John? You know, some folks have said that this review of the legality

14:48 And such a body should have been done first. And the criticism of this overall initiative over the last year or so. But I'm comfortable having a debate about the legality and the legal issues at this point in the process. Because six months ago, three months or six months ago, we didn't really have much of a definition of what MLI could be, what its structure could be, what its vision could be, or what the unique

15:19 Work aspects. Find exactly what could function in those gray areas. I look forward to reading his brief and try to form a bit. And then I guess it might be something that we want an ML that isn't, it's not so tight. We don't want to find a way around something. There needs to be a clear path. Clearly. Yeah, sorry. Two things. In our discussion with him on Wednesday, response just a little bit, but that specifically was in response to a Measure U application.

18:02 that had come forward for consideration in there was a group that wanted to retain the services of a fundraiser to using Measure U money to go pursue fundraising and at the time the both the Measure U committee and then I think some discussion among some other folks was that and a decision and a recommendation from Andy was that

18:28 Measure U shouldn't be specifically used for that hiring, that fundraiser to go out and raise money. And so there's, this is where that gray starts to come in because if you read the next sentence that he has in there, he says, but, you know, here's, you know, there's opportunity or there's, you can't say you can't. It's basically, yeah. So this is where the gray is. So that was specific to an application that had come.

18:58 Through the Measure U process, and they were looking for some clarification on it. Yeah, if you read the very last sentence, it kind of clarifies that. Yes, Sandy. Sandy Hogan, that was actually a specific response to a TRAIL request, because we'd asked a couple times. The one you're referring to is actually one where Measure U, the Red Measure U Committee really wasn't sure about the application that came from the TRAC.

19:29 Because they, their application, they were going to hire a professional fundraiser who guaranteed that return of $25,000. That was a previous occasion. And so the Measure U Committee actually kind of went along with that, and it was the council that took the fundraising off in response. And I believe probably Andy commented on that. But there were, it came up, it's come up a number of times over the years. Okay, thanks for the clarification. So John, I think there's J area.

19:59 And as Andy referenced in last week's meeting, there's gray area. And it's, you know, how, you know, the point is, where do we live within that gray, and can we get a little more black and white? Dan, I know that you got the memo from Andy today, and I think you were going through the process of reviewing it. Is there a timeline for when you can get that back to the community? Yeah, we should have it back out of the camp today. Okay. And so I'm assuming we'll have it back tomorrow.

20:25 Okay, and then we'll be able to route it. We'll ship it out. Ship it out to, route it to the committee and then you'll post it to the town's website. So for those in the public who want to see Andy's memo, keep watching the town's website. It'll be posted there when it comes back from Andy. I do, before I move on, are there any comments from the public on this particular issue relative to our discussion about last week's meeting with Andy?

20:54 You know, and I would just like to chime in from what John said is that we would not have had the questions to pose to Andy if we had done that originally. And we would have been asking Andy to come up with those questions. And so you're looking at even more time. So, you know, in the efficiency, I think that it was actually a very relevant time frame. So, anyhow. I think the timing was there. We had the 5.0.

21:22 Had given us some kind of started, you know, pleasing us a little bit. And as the work that's been coming forward from you guys, I think it gave us a good framework to ask the questions of it. So I appreciate it. I do want to go back to something, Joe, that you said. Teri, maybe you said it also, and I just want to close the loop on it. I think it's imperative for the legal.

21:44 Ad Hoc Group to take that memo and go back and create that matrix. So we'll make that an assignment to the legal committee to kind of do some more homework on taking Andy's memo and giving it some structure for us to use in how Measure R is different from Measure U, from restricted funds, and all of the items over here on the left-hand side of that matrix that we'll want to have addressed.

22:13 So that'll be an assignment that we'll make to the legal ad hoc group. Would that include him kind of calling out those policy items with that one too? I'm going to talk about that. Are they in Andy's memo?

22:26 He still has stuff identified as policy. Okay. Okay. Then we'll do that. We'll make that because that's something we did want to do. I have the fifth child. He didn't pull the policy check back. He thought that he should have addressed. Right. And so, and that's the reason we had on here next step regarding the policy issues because I think there are some policy issues that we will want to include with the report that we take to the council on May 21st.

22:55 There won't be all of them, but I think there are some very pertinent ones that we will want to include in our report to the council with some recommendation or some direction that we want to provide them. So we'll take those policy level questions and integrate those in. I think moving forward after May 21st and whatever actions takes place, I think it behooves the next group to go through all those policy questions. And there's probably some on there that should have been addressed.

23:26 You know, back in 2008, in 2009, in 2010. So now we're just, you know, we'll play a little catch up here. But I think there are some very specific ones that we'll want to bring forward on May 21st. So we'll integrate the policy into the legal ad hoc homework as well as we're reviewing Andy's. It'll be a matrix.

23:53 You know, it's almost a pause you mentioned. I think some of them can be addressed maybe a little further out. Some can be addressed immediately. It'd be kind of good to know what the recommendation from the committee is. Well, and that speaks to May 21st. That speaks to what needs to come forward. Yeah. What needs to be addressed now and what can be pushed now. We'll do that within the May 21st. Yeah. So that's 428? Yes. If you need that work program now, I think that'd be great also. Okay. Anything else from this group on?

24:22 Wednesday's meeting. I will advise this, that we anticipate that there will be some additional questions that will come through. If you have any questions that we want to ask Andy of, I ask that you wrap them through me, and then we can send them on working with Dan to get them to Andy.

24:46 And that goes for the public also. If you have any questions as we continue to move forward that you would like to access Andy and have him answer, we'll ask that you send them to me and we'll be coordinating that communication to Andy moving forward so that he can't take from a variety of folks. So we'll funnel those questions through one source and then we'll come through the chair.

25:12 All right. So with that, let's move on to item number three. And this is a discussion on our operational budget requirements. And I'm kind of going to turn it over to Joe and Betsy and John because you've been working, starting to work on this. And so we wanted to have a little discussion here about the operational budget requirements moving forward and some recommendations from this.

25:37 Okay, and actually, John and Jesse, what I did is I took our three emails and made myself a cheat sheet. Perfect. Thank you. And so actually, you know, timeline for startup review, startup costs is one of those things that we obviously have to start thinking about now.

25:57 We have formed a separate committee that would start talking about the staff cost recommendations, something to come back on that, because, you know, we can't build a budget if we have no idea what your major cost is. Connected with that is what kinds of benefits get offered, and I think we kind of informally talked about

26:27 Starting with using MLT and MLH as the examples to give us all a ballpark place to discuss, you know, because, well, what would that full package look like? Because as you well know, you have salary and then you have benefits, and by the time we have the two together, you've either added a considerable amount. I used to work for accounting where benefits were 58% of salary.

26:52 Yeah. It's not far off here. Actually, I think that's about far off. We're close. But we need to kind of deal with that whole area. Then the next big one was, so location and rent scenarios. Are we looking that we want to share space?

27:13 Do you want to be on your own? You know, those kinds of questions. And I think you called it, what, logistics or scenarios? Something like that. Maybe two of the things that have proposed are, you know, sort of, we've just heard about, you know, maybe looking at MLT offices, maybe looking at town offices, and maybe we can just come back to the group, but, you know, a couple of different.

27:35 And you guys will come back with some analysis with that. Okay, so when we come back to discuss this, we should have done some of our own homework as well about some other scenarios that you want to consider or some other ideas that you want to consider or what about now? Some additional thoughts.

28:04 I was thinking MLT's offices. Co-location, especially in short term. Yeah. Well, and our offices are restricted to the fact that we can only rent to not-for-profits. We can only sub out to not-for-profits, so that's helpful. But, you know, we've talked about this. Right now, I've got the U.S. Forest Service Inventory Unit in the office taking up a three-spot that pays me about $1,000 a month for rent, and they're there about 12 days a year, so it's great.

28:33 But, you know, reconfiguring the office and trying to figure out how we can accommodate, I think we've got space to work with, and if we needed to ask the Forest Service to leave, we can do that. You guys do have the space, though? Yeah, it'll be, we have space, we just have to figure out how to reconfigure some things. Well, and from that perspective, it's more than just space, it's the idea, does somebody have a network that we can...

28:59 Share, things like that, or are we talking that we have to build all that? Well, and that's how we've done the rental in the past. With the chamber, until we integrated the chamber into Mammoth Lakes Tourism, they paid a minimal rent, and they paid real copier costs and real postage costs, and everything else was factored in. Their electrical and janitorial, everything else was just factored into their rent.

29:28 And I, in my mind, I didn't go over there and look at it again, but I considered MLH, but since they downsized, they don't really have space to work to free somebody. I think we're also just kind of looking at the synergy, you know, MLH, you're working closely with MLT, you're working closely with the town, so, you know, that's why there's two, you know, maybe considerations, but, you know, I've also joked.

29:55 And we can talk about this in the context of an article that, you know, hey, it could be a cell phone and a laptop. It is the 21st century, you know. Right. Well, and a conference room. Yeah. Well, and then there's the, I'll just flip the other side, though, too, because the town has space out there as well, and there's thought that perhaps, you know, that there's a desk and a phone and access to a copier as well. And thinking about that synergy, whether it's with the town or with its MLT,

30:25 I also tended to lean towards MLT just because we put so much on that relationship being built and developed. But there's also town space that is sitting empty and may be able to negotiate a great rate on that as well. The clear number one for me from the get-go would have been MLT, but just to add for brainstorming's sake, I mean, the Times does rent.

30:56 Desk space, essentially, you know, and you'd have all of the stuff that you need available. They kind of, you know, they're doing that, like, kind of cubicle space. Well, I think Mammoth Brewing Company is actually planning on doing that with Whiskey Creek as well. Right. Like having some just, like, temporary office. Yeah, some little co-op type office. If you're in town, you need a phone and a desk. You mean the shared space for nonprofits that we've been trying to get ever since we wrote the general plan? Right. Okay.

31:25 Yeah. I think most of those spaces wouldn't be intended for a nine-to-five, five days a week, day in, day out type thing. So that's where I think, you know, MLT makes a little more sense in that respect. The other thing is the town office. We did what would be like a de-esta building, which is stand-alone separate, you know, which is synergy, but it's a location. Is park still over there? Is park maintenance still upstairs in that building? Oh, okay. It's at the greatest locations.

31:54 Does that have a conference room? Yeah, it does downstairs. Yeah. Yeah, I know. We bought it. Okay. I did want to talk a little bit about item number C. Okay, well, we're not quite then. Okay, good.

32:24 But I don't know if we want to go through all of the potential things to talk about and then, yeah, let's finish it. So then there is the whole question of, you know, support equipment, software, you know, if, yeah, the laptop and then they're making copies of the library or something like that. Yes, you know, that's another area. Supplies, contract services, travel, and something that

32:52 I think, you know, since this all goes together with the scope of work, is there's also a question we have to decide before we can finish a budget on some questions like, sure, we've got a couple of websites, you know, recreation.org and .net or com, I forget which one it was, maybe it's all three, but there's a whole question, and not to be decided right now, but put it out there, is

33:20 Where does mammoth trails.org end up living? It's a rhetorical question to the community when we talk about the scope of work. Because how that's handled and how it's updated, et cetera, is something that...

33:34 We need to think about. Well, I want to add to that, though, too, because there's also been discussion about the arts and cultural side of things as well. And so, you know, in your thinking about the scope, where does arts and culture fall within MLR2? So there's a trails discussion, there's an arts and culture discussion, and I think as that scope gets defined, we can dive into maybe some recommendations on that. Unless you guys have something you want to just share today, but I think that's...

34:02 You know, those are some questions. And maybe on Wednesday, maybe Wednesday's joint meeting, there might be some input that you receive there as well. But I agree. I think there's that mammothtrails.org website that is going to require some management of it. And then the whole arts and cultural space. Mammotharts.org.

34:27 Yeah, right, yeah, that kind of stuff as you move along because, of course, there is a cost involved with those, and I think it's at least 99.45% and Measure R funded, so that's, again, why we need that matrix to figure out, but I think we need to think in terms of where all the different pieces, if this is the...

34:51 Piece that's going to be dealing with the advocacy and the growth and everything, how we're going to coordinate that. And on that one, of course, there's other partners. But it is a cost. Developing and maintaining websites, as John Weld knows, doesn't come for just two cents a mark.

35:08 Nope. No, and you know what, that site, there's been a nice investment to a site that is going to require ongoing content development, updates to it, and seasonal changes to it, and it's not just a static site, and that was never intended to be a static site, it was really visitors serving and very kind of interactive, so there's certainly opportunity to grow that.

35:33 So essentially those areas were what we thought were a general, you know, what you have to figure out with your budget as your fixed costs or your growing costs. The reason timeline is down there is, you know, there was a feeling, well, moving forward when, you know.

35:57 Obviously, in your first year, certain things would ramp up. You would not be starting everything all at once, and so it was trying to get everybody to start thinking about that timeline of, sure, we identify central staff costs, well, then you have to fire them, and then you've got things happening with the incorporation where you're going to have legal costs, which I think we were just kind of putting into contract services, but we know we're going to have some legal costs.

36:22 Those kinds of things. So it was kind of a question, did they forget anything? We tried to keep them high level in the contract services and everything from accounting to hosting a website to the legal services. I mean, contract services is a pretty broad one for us, including things like audits. So I mean, it's pretty broad. We didn't get into all the line items below it, but it's...

36:47 Pretty in-depth. That was the first one that jumped out at me is hosting costs, you know, so if that's factored in there, that's fine. Anything else in this little category that I want to stop in mind, ask about for any startup?

37:10 Can we go ahead and ask the public on 3A? Sure. So are there any questions from the public relative to 3A, any review of startup costs, anything, any points you'd like to share from the public? Okay, thanks. So one of the things we will do is before the 28th is get general ideas from...

37:33 MLT, The Town, The Times, and New York City. And so come back somewhere. Then the second part kind of looks at budget from a different perspective. And I think I have a little two-column matrix on this one. But I started going through this in my brain this weekend. So

37:59 There are certain overall administrative task requirements which we can't get down to the final part on because we don't exactly know where we were on measures R and U, but there are certain overall costs that I just called administrative. We can call them any word we want, SAC. And then there would be costs that are particular project related. And I tried to make a differentiation. John already mentioned the audit.

38:24 We see the audit as being one of those things that's an overall cost because it applies to all projects, current and future. Sorry, just one thing on the audit. I think the one challenge that I see here, because we're looking at it with the TBID as well, is that we could be looking at three audits, which gets costly. Yes, yeah.

38:51 Correct. But if I remember the way that we spoke about it last week, it was not the did money go in and the checks get signed and that kind of stuff, but the how and the why. How did it get spent and why did it get spent? Or what I'm thinking of. Versus the financials. Yeah, versus the checks. We don't want to implicate. So what I did is I went back to the scope that we talked about at the previous meeting and went through the things we are identifying as being.

39:20 And within the KMLR school scope. And so I came up with Set Measure R and New Priorities, Disseminate Information, our collaboration and partnerships, which is also part of Grow Events and Find Sponsors, Recreation Trends, you know, going out and finding those new things that's in there, leveraged funding, the audits, and then

39:50 However all it works out, whatever the RMU recommendation process is, that I saw that those were more global and not related to a particular Joe's Klein wall, which of course is facetious. I never want to see Joe's Klein at all. Then, in looking at the scope, I found that programming and new product

40:18 Orr slash facility planning and implementation were the kinds of things that we might consider have been related to a particular project. So for Joe's Climbing Wall, if it really were going forward, NLR might be involved in the programming and or creating this new product pieces. And I saw them as

40:43 That something would change from year to year depending on what the projects were that came out of the prioritization, if I'm not making sense at this point. I'm looking at my chart. I'm going to chop my chart here. So that was what we're trying to focus under. When you take the scope of work and you try to make it into a budget, I was trying to make that step. So I was seeing Teri looking at me like,

41:11 I don't know what she's talking about. That's fine. It makes sense many times. No, it makes sense. As a budget then, that it tend to be more project specific, does the budget then get informed based on the project budget? Yes, as opposed to carrying out certain tasks which might be building towards a project the next year or in the next five years. I was in a local transportation commission meeting this morning where

41:40 We were all celebrating the fact that Caltrans is going to come up with the 40% for the Elantico-Tago bypass, but that's been 15 years in the making. We don't want ours to go that long, but we're trying to say that some of the other things sat up there, and that you would have things that were specific to the projects that were going on regardless of the next source on the next side. So we're trying to make a matrix out of it.

42:12 Because we have to build the costs for doing those things into the budget. It's not just that you have a space, but now you're talking about, well, what are the things that are going to do that are going to actually make up the time of these people? Okay. So let me ask this question, and we haven't talked too much about it, but where in our budget, or do we in our budget,

42:40 Start thinking about any earned income opportunities also related to the services and or function of MLR, meaning that MLR could be in the business of generating its own earned income for the work that it can provide that somebody else isn't doing.

43:03 So it's just intended to ask the question, are we thinking about an item in there for MLR that has earned income? Yes, because on the one hand, as the MLR Formation Board, am I getting that? Is that what we're saying? The Transition Board has to look at itself globally as well as what might be NAE.

43:30 Budget Contract with the Town, because there is that other piece. Yes, so we have to think in both dimensions. Okay, I just wanted to, because I think that's a potential opportunity for MLR to be looking at. It is, it's probably minimal in years one and two, and it probably ramps up in year three. Sponsors and those kinds of things might be directly related too.

43:57 They will be, but again, until we have some systems to even sell, you don't have a product to sell. And then, Dan, you said something about an audit. So as far as the, so the town is not, it has to do its complete separate own audit. We do an audit every year. It's more of a financial audit required by the ordinances. That doesn't go away as required by the town.

44:21 Okay, because the audit, the only audit that I've seen that the town has done is just to make sure that the R&U funds are being spent in the manner that the ordinance states. Yeah, yeah. So there hasn't been. So it isn't really a detailed expenditure. Okay. Okay. So along those lines. We have to do that every year. Yeah. Yeah. So along those lines, where are we in the reconciliation process to come back? There's a couple little pieces in there that you can notice. Okay.

44:48 In order to be moving targets, we're trying to draw lines instead of everything because people are still doing stuff. Okay. But isn't that also part of the kind of reporting that the town does for the R&U as well? Yeah, but that's not part of the, that's not an audit requirement. And is that, that's kind of been ongoing, the debate about what level of audit is intended, was intended to be in there. So in thinking about the deadline or the date that the reconciliation may be completed,

45:17 We actually shouldn't even have that to the Wednesday meeting. It's still in the old way. Okay. All right. So for this Wednesday, your joint meeting. Okay. Great. And is that something that can be routed to this committee as well? Well, not Wednesday, but everybody's invited to be there. It would be shipped out. Well, for those who may not be going to Wednesday's meeting, because that's not our meeting, so we're not required to be there. Anybody who wants one, then can. Can you send it out electronically? Okay. Sharon, can you just make a note of that? That reconciliation report from the town?

45:46 gets routed to the MLR Formation Committee when it comes out. Okay, thanks. So, did we forget it? You know, I think that's, to me, you guys have covered kind of at a high level. Mm-hmm. Yeah. That was the intent with the first pass. Yeah, that was the intent, yeah. It's high levels. Yeah, I mean, we went back and forth via a bunch of emails and then met last week, and I think that

46:20 Every time we went back and forth with an email, something else kind of kicked in. Just being able to put the top buckets and things like contract services, we're going to need an accountant, we're going to need legal, we're going to need... Any other thoughts from this group on 3B? Any comments from the public on 3B? Relative to our task, our scope, our task, the requirements for...

46:52 For MLR. No? Okay. So then 3C is specific to kind of an ongoing discussion about this, you know, analysis of MLR costs versus town of Mammoth Lakes costs and misinformation that's out there or just can we get the analysis done to include in the discussion? Yeah, and well, and actually that's one of the reasons why we sent around just to

47:22 get discussion going on the starvation cycle. But I need to clarify something that was answered at a meeting last week by you, Dan, is that there was a discussion of

47:40 What the town was charging on current projects that came up in, I'm sorry, I don't remember which meeting it was. It was during, no, it was during the mission. Well, because I listened to the MLG SCC and the mission you mean last week and the recreation mission. Yeah, no, it was part of, it was part of our mission at the end. So if I understood that correctly, General Fund was picking up all of what we would call the services and supplies and rent and administrative overhead, so that has not been charged before.

48:10 Correct. Which kind of puts us in a bad position because then the cost from the town, we have to include that even if it wasn't charged because it's... It's a true cost. We need to look at total compensation and total cost in this comparison and John's recommendation was to essentially just take...

48:32 $100,000. I presume you picked that because it was an easy number. It's an easy number to do math on. Thank you. None of us like the $89,000. Yeah, right. That's right. Is to work through a comparison, which means that it's actually going to show true cost for the town that's higher than what.

48:54 Measure R, or you have been charged to this flight, but if we, it's the only way we can match. I think you need to split that out, though. I think you need to say, this is what was actually charged. These are, you know, here would be the overhead cost. The challenge for the town that's going to be, some of those costs would be nice if they went away at MLR and started. A lot of those costs do not go away. There's some costs the town that may be regardless. So in one sense, if we're shifting costs to MLR,

49:24 In a way of comparison, saying, well, the town's paying, it's like, let's say, rent from the building here. You can allocate a piece of that to MLR work. That cost isn't going to go away, regardless of what MLR does. It's really not a cost to R&U, regardless of the cost we would have, whether it was here or not. Does that make sense? Yes. Well, in a way it does. But what I'm saying is that you can't say that

49:53 There was no rent that should have been charged. Right. Well, you can say that because it's already paid by the taxpayers by the service. I think, though, that what's being said, though, is that the town is absorbing that within the general fund so that it is not a cost right now to R&U. Correct. And so, yeah. There would be an ongoing cost to the town regardless. I mean, it's not an offsetting cost. And then I guess you would need to know, then we would need to know what cost would the town, what hard costs.

50:22 Not a rental space or something like that. What the hard costs might be that the town would still absorb if there's an MLR. So we see, you know, where those efficiencies are or are not. And the other thing I think that we really need to look at and where the $100,000 comes in is if we were to hire a $100,000 director within MLR and we were to hire a $100,000 director within the town of Mammoth Lakes, the difference there is...

50:49 Pretty massive. I mean, just as far as the sheer cost of why this is an NGO versus a government function. I think it's a good example. I like the $100,000 because it's an easy figure. So I think it's good to show that. Not suggesting at all that that's the staff cost. I'd love to have your benefits. But show that. No, our benefits are not great. How much of that $100,000?

51:12 Where's that $100,000 going? You know, doing this just gets so sticky and it's going to be kind of very, very messy trying to come up with an exact cost, you know, because you're going to be hiring staff at this level that will be overseeing projects where projects right now are, there's costs that are included in capital because it's part of overseeing that project.

51:37 And so you might not see that within the town. All those costs are still there. And if you have an admin cost that's overseeing that same project, there's really no way to do an apple-to-apple comparison. Right. And that's why John's suggestion of just, you know, what does a $100,000 employee cost one way or the other?

52:01 It's going to be the same regardless of the number of hours that we spent on it. We're just looking at it. Absolutely. That makes sense. Okay. Because otherwise you're never going to be able to come up with a number. At some point it becomes a, I guess it's so much a question. Yeah. A certain portion of it happens. It's in the day you're going to be too narrow down and it's like you get the point of discussion.

52:24 Right, but I think the point, though, too, is that there's, you know, a lot of perceptions out there here at our level and in the public's eyes, too, as to...

52:35 The value that somebody is getting with an NGO versus the current town costs that are incurred. And I think where we can provide that level of analysis to show here's an efficiency that doesn't exist over here and here's an efficiency that doesn't exist over here. And that way there's an opportunity to let the analysis speak for itself. Because there's just so much misinformation that is shared out there and I think we have an opportunity to at least provide

53:03 A little bit of framework and the analysis that just has never been done. And we can kind of clear up some of the misinformation that folks around out there. Yeah, both sides. Yeah, both sides. There's going to be both sides. Yeah, I mean, absolutely. So let's see it. We all say it. We all say something. Let's put some analysis behind it, right? That sounds good.

53:29 Thoughts on this part here, this 3C that we're talking about? It's core to the discussion. It's as core as the legal discussion was. And that the comparisons of cost analysis of the two frameworks is really important. Getting an idea of what that actually looks like. Because we've been saying, until now, this is what it should look like or might look like.

53:56 Yeah, it's getting down to the point of that detail. Should we ask if he has any items to add for the agenda since he's departing? Future agendas, yeah. John, anything you want to bring up? No, I think future agenda items are pretty thorough in that meeting outline. Thank you for that sheet. That's good. And that has visited with that fundraiser every weekend.

54:20 Yes, send me an email. Maybe tomorrow. And, John, just really, really quickly before you go, it turns out that that May 14th Wednesday Widdens Club meeting, they changed the time of the meeting, so I can still go and make the presentation, but there was a possibility that you might be able to join. It would be Wednesday, 5.14, 6 p.m. And if you can let...

54:46 Joe, I can probably join you. I was going to let you know today whether I can join you. It looks like I should be able to. We can figure that out. Thanks, Joe.

55:09 Joe, you referenced it, and I do want to point it out. The article that was included, I think, is intended to kind of be just a conversation starter out there about the realities of NGOs and government, and that, again,

55:34 You know, where you are trying to squeeze something, it may not be to the best benefit of that entity if you're trying to squeeze something that doesn't work. So for those in the public, it was posted on our Granica site. It was an article that came from Bridgespan through the Stanford Social Innovation Review, and it really talks about how the world of NGO, we don't look at overhead as a

56:01 As a metric, that that's kind of short-sighted and just looking at metrics in the overhead of that. So I would encourage you to read that article if you haven't already. And I think it was intended to be a nice conversation starter and to create some awareness out there about the function of NGOs and the future of NGOs.

56:27 If you had anything you wanted to share about it, you know, feel free to do so, but I think it was a good conversation. Anything else on the seat? No, but I couldn't remember if you were asked. No, I haven't. No, I was just looking here. Anything else that you guys will have on the seat for Jen?

56:46 Before I leave town. Thank you for reminding me. Any comments from the public on item 3C? Okay, great. You guys, thanks for, this is a big task, so thanks for taking it and giving it some framework for us that we can start to follow and participate in.

57:13 So I'm going to move to item four. It's review the MLR meeting schedule framework, and that is a table document. It's two-sided. I have made copies of it, so it is two-sided. This is intended to provide you with kind of an expectation for what items are going to be addressed at what upcoming meetings, and so that we kind of remind ourselves what our deadlines are and when they're going to be.

57:40 discussion on certain topics. So I just want to take a moment to go through this with you. Obviously we have today's meeting put down on Wednesday. There is the joint meeting of the Commission Measure U Committee and MLTSCC with Council Members Bacon and Wood. For us as a committee, those of us that aren't on any of these bodies, it's not a required meeting for us, but we are encouraged to attend and see what the discussion is all about. What time is that?

58:07 Three to five. Three to five. Okay. And it's here in suite Z. Colin's, he has client position. Oh, it's another one. You have another long day. I will be there. Is that meeting, is that Wednesday meeting being recorded also? Dan, is the joint meeting being recorded? I'm assuming so. So, and it's a public meeting. Yeah. Yeah, it was good. The meeting is going to be.

58:36 Yeah, because on Wednesday? Yeah. And the agenda for that has already gone out. Yes. So if you didn't get it, it is posted to the town's website, and there's several topics that they're going to be discussing. So that's that. On our next meeting, everybody's on spring break, but we're working really diligently between now and the 28th. We've got five things that we're going to be looking at on that meeting.

59:02 Our bylaws are going to be reviewed and brought forward to you. The scope of work is going to come back to us. The MLR budget is going to be with us. The MLR staff descriptions that Colin and John are working on. And then the report out from the contract framework ad hoc body as well. Just as a, as a, these are the topics that we intend to start addressing. And actually we have to move number two from today. Oh, the takeaways, that's right. Thank you.

59:33 Yeah, so we'll go through the legal real quick on that a day as well. And then we go to our May 12th meeting where we will get the final draft of the MLR scope. We'll get the final draft of the budget, final draft of the contract framework. We will also take a moment at that meeting to make sure that we've got the documents needed for the May 21st council meeting because that's the week that there will be deadlines for getting that packet out.

1:00:02 So we'll make sure that we've got all the documents that we need to. And then also on that meeting, we'll take a moment to talk about the transition board as the recommendation that's moving forward to the council. And we'll just do kind of an update to everybody about that transition board. Then on Monday the 19th, a week later, we are going to have a real quick meeting just for our own preparation purposes for the Wednesday's council meeting.

1:00:32 Make sure that we understand what our role is and go over a presentation for the 21st. And then we have the May 21st meeting. We do also have that Thursday, May 22nd, on our calendar in case May 21st the council does take action and there was any direction that we needed to address quickly coming out of that May 21st meeting. We might keep that as a tentative only if...

1:01:00 Day 21st is a boot to June 4th. If there's any delay or any decision, any delay on May 21st, we may just move that meeting. But keep it on your calendar for now in case we do come out of May 21st with some specific actions that the council would be asking us to take. Dan, I'm absent May 12th and June 2nd. Okay, make a note of that. Thanks, John. I'm absent.

1:01:28 The 12th and the 22nd, but I already emailed you. Yep, I have those. Okay. And then, again, if something does happen on the 4th, or something from the 21st gets moved to the June 4th council meeting, we will meet on Monday, June 2nd, regularly scheduled meeting.

1:01:50 Just move forward with some operational issues at that point and maybe any additional preparation that we might have to do in case the council is meeting on the 4th. So that's our meeting schedule up until basically June 4th. And then after May 21st, we'll come back and look at the calendar and see what our next meeting dates need to look like through the summer and into the fall.

1:02:15 Any questions about anything that we've got identified as what we'll be reviewing at these upcoming meetings? I think the only thing is it's your first note is that there was a conscious decision to say that we have everything else that has to get done by the 21st. Not everything on the list. You know, certain things are going to fall after that date, so that's what the three notes are about. Right. So any questions from the committee on that schedule?

1:02:47 Any questions from the public on the schedule that's been posted? Hi, I'm Karen Seibert. I'm assuming all these Monday meetings are scheduled at 3 o'clock, and I'm just wondering if there's any way to bump it into the evening so the public can attend. We work, and it's very difficult for me to make it here at 3 o'clock. Yeah, I appreciate that. I think from when we set up our times, I think 3 o'clock was kind of the best that worked for the committee as well.

1:03:18 And we've kind of gotten into a routine in doing it. I just think it's really important for the public to really deal for the public and to make it in a time where it's difficult for the public to get here. I think it makes it look like it's not as transparent as you guys want it to be. Yeah, I think that's why the meetings have been recorded also, to allow the public the opportunity as well. So I appreciate it. I think through our May schedule, we're on for that 3 o'clock time.

1:03:48 Post, maybe we can look at a different time, but we've kind of, that was the agreed upon time that seemed to work for our committee members as well. Okay, thank you. Maybe what we can do is at the beginning of each meeting, if there were questions from a previous meeting, if you had to watch it on Granicus, that those can be addressed at the beginning of our next meeting. Oh, okay. Okay. Is there a...

1:04:14 Does the library have better bandwidth? Yes. So maybe there's some other spots that have better streaming? And they have headphones, too. Yeah, they might have better streaming, too, to help facilitate that. So maybe, yeah, someone can email those questions in, and then, or, you know, then we can. Yeah. Sure.

1:04:37 You know, that's a way to, you know, if there is a question that comes from someone who wasn't able to be at a meeting, that we can certainly address it as we go through the notes of that previous meeting. So that could work. Any other questions from the public on that meeting schedule? Okay. I want to move forward.

1:04:57 Go through real quick any report outs from our ad hoc committees and for purposes of the public and for the committee itself. We've got listed here the actual committees. Not all of them will have a report each time, but we'll just keep them listed here so that everybody knows what committees are, what ad hoc committees are currently working.

1:05:22 Those that finished their work are not listed on here any longer. So we had some early ones that work was finished and they're not listed here. These are the ones that are currently active. You know, I typed up what the Mammoth Lakes Event Coalition had said. I wasn't really prepared to give that last time, so kind of we went off the top of our head. I think we covered most of their concerns, but I did type this up, so I'll give it to the group and I'll just read through it.

1:05:50 And this is part of community outreach, right? Correct, community outreach. So this is the Mammoth Lakes Event Coalition that John and I attended. So what is the plan to include fine arts and culture representation on the board? And we did bring that one up at our last meeting. They don't feel they have representation right now. Number two, they would like to see arts and culture, and they had also said and education to continue to receive monies from Measure U.

1:06:17 Do they, what does education mean? That's what we question. I don't, it. You know, I would assume that there's some programs that there's Measure U money that's being, I don't know, I don't know if there's been, maybe with an event or something like that, it's considered education as opposed to arts and culture, I don't know, but it was thrown in there. Projected overhead, what is coming out of R and what is coming out of U, they wanted some specifics and that's.

1:06:47 One of the things we're working through. Do you think it's good for our town? I would say yes. I think that was a more specific question of us when we were there. Yeah. So Measure U was not voted to support visitor-based activities. That was just a statement. And how do we justify using Measure U since it was not voted to support visitor-based activities?

1:07:12 Is that a perception? These are just questions and comments coming from the Mammoth Lakes Event Coalition. So we didn't debate them at the time. We just said we would present them. Number six, look at other nonprofit salaries and pay at a comparable rate. So for a director, make sure we're looking at other nonprofits so that we're not paying something exorbitant, I guess.

1:07:40 Anyway, so those, I think we brought most of those up at our last meeting, but since I had my notes, I wanted to make sure that we got all the points kind of verbatim, so, anyway. Thanks. Yep. Do you want one? Sure. Sorry. Any other community outreach from last Wednesday, since last Wednesday? Yes. I have to, so, with the Women's Club, is Wednesday...

1:08:13 May 14, 6 p.m. So Betsy, will you be able to go next time? Yeah, I'll let you know next time. And if you can't go, I can go. So anyways, either way. And then also, I wasn't able to get onto the Sunrise Rotary calendar until June 25th.

1:08:39 It's either my commitments or they had programs already, but it'll still be going on, so that's going to be way out there. Did you want to confirm, have you heard anything from Forest Service? Yes, I'm sorry, we confirmed for April 29th. Is that going to be like public or private meeting? That's just Rick and myself and John and John and Ed.

1:09:12 Okay. Oh, good. Ed will be there? Yes. Great. That's awesome. Any other outreach since last week? What about anything coming up in the future that needs any assignments made to it?

1:09:44 Okay, so who's on the liaison to the school district? Michael and Michael. For the mountains, so they can give an MLR to that? Okay. Okay. Any other community outreach? Nothing to report from the bylaws. We'll have our report out on April 28th. Scope of work and budget, folks. Yeah, we got our work.

1:10:12 Legal review, we just made an assignment to take the Andy's memo and create the matrix. That will be done by 428 as well. Staff description, you guys will be meeting and getting us a report for the 28th. Yeah, I think John and I are probably going to meet tomorrow, but we'll definitely have it for the 28th. Okay, great. And then same thing with the contract framework group. On the contract framework group, we have to reform that because I'm a lobbyist.

1:10:42 Okay. So currently, Betsy? No. No, John. John Urdi, you Urdi. I'm in. Well, you should be. Yeah. Okay. John, that's you and I? Yeah. You and me.

1:11:00 Okay. And of course the reason for that is Ann who reminded me after the meeting that obviously I can't negotiate against myself. Right. Okay. So we'll make that reassignment. Dan, I will replace Jim on that committee. Okay. Anybody else want to be on that? You know what? Let's talk to John Armstrong and see if he, if he, I'll reach out to him and see if he wants to be on it too. On the contracting? On the contract. Sure. Okay.

1:11:25 Just sign him up. Done it before. This is much again for being off at a month of March. He would actually be very good on it. Yeah. So let's see if we can do that. Especially since he's looking at the job description. It kind of makes sense that it might work into that whole thing. Some synergy there. Yeah. Sure. Any questions from the public relative to any of the ad hoc committee reports or activities or assignments? This is really good.

1:11:55 I didn't hear. When is your Forest Service meeting? The Ad-Hop Forest Service outreach. It's on the 29th. And that's not a public thing. I understand that. It's on the 29th. Thank you. And that was Deb Perrell. Thank you. Thank you. So those report outs will be back on our May 12th meeting. Yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Cool.

1:12:17 Okay, I want to move to item number six, and I added this just to kind of throw it out. So a couple of things on number six. I think we know that MLR in one way or another is going to be a topic for discussion among potential council candidates. And I think for us as a committee, you know, our focus is completing the work that was assigned to us. However, I wanted to just...

1:12:47 you know ask if you guys felt that this committee should be submitting any questions or posing any questions to council candidates related to MLR that would come from this body and be asked at some of the upcoming forums and public meetings that these candidates are going to be posed at and it's not

1:13:10 that we have to. Since MLR may be a topic, and we're not going to get into the public debate of that because, again, we're the committee that's just doing the work, I just wanted to ask if you guys felt that this body should ask any questions of the council candidates. I think there should be a question to make sure.

1:13:40 Not just, you know, because, you know, most of them open up and then just somebody will say, well, what do you think of? And it's not a what do you think of. It's, you know, it's a little different. But it's very difficult to discuss when four, excuse me, five of the candidates are sitting in the room. Well, but she says the first forums tomorrow, right? Correct. You know, but all of their forums are public as well. And if this committee has a question that it wants to ask any of those candidates, you know, we have every opportunity to do so.

1:14:09 If you're there individually. Sure, sure. What does it say is this committee can't formulate a question without having some but not all the candidates here in advance, so how do we deal with that? No, you can ask it. We can discuss it here. If you want somebody to present a question in the forum, is that your question? Yes. I think if you want to ask these questions in the forum that the committee puts together to have whoever's going to attend it present it, the only question there would be is,

1:14:40 Well, there's, there's, well, they can listen to it. I mean, I, if you're going to do it, you have to do it publicly so people can listen to it. But it would be, uh, which maybe three of us can meet after this meeting and come up with a question or two and then we have to speak to the people that are running that, um, to, that.

1:15:00 I think it's important because I think most of the community is wondering where the candidates stand.

1:15:30 Well, I'm just looking at the format for tomorrow. I'm not necessarily sure that you could guarantee that it's on there. And Brent's moderating, so I know that questions have been submitted to him regarding MLR, but I think it's going to be at his discretion how he handles that. So I think it would be appropriate if you guys wanted to submit questions. I just don't know.

1:15:56 in this particular format, whether it will get pulled or not. Yeah, but I think that we could submit those questions and then it's up to their purview whether they want to ask them or not.

1:16:16 Jump on that if somebody else. The Monday, April 14th. Well, we would have to, yeah. We would have to meet briefly, yeah. It's already during the future. Yeah, it'll be a process of elimination. Right after this meeting, if you guys want to meet, yeah. Okay. Dana, do you want to do it, Jo and I? Sure. How about the legal ad hoc? How is that? Legal ad hoc. Legal ad hoc. We can, okay.

1:16:46 It's to be a subcommittee. No, no, it's from the subcommittee to how does that work? I mean, the three of you get together, it becomes a question. The committee will not bless those questions. It will be coming from an ad hoc subcommittee that has not been lended by the whole committee because you're not able to do that unless you don't have the dialogue here until the meeting. So I think the three of you, the committee is saying, from what I'm hearing, we're okay committee members. I have a lot of these three to get together, develop a couple of questions for the

1:17:15 Candidates form and you will hear the questions at the same time the candidates do frankly. How do you guys feel about that? If heard at all. Yeah, if heard at all. I think it's just important for, you know, that the committee gets some representation out there also as it relates to MLR in addition to the public, you know, there's committee discussion out there as well. So, okay, we'll talk afterwards soon.

1:17:41 Any questions from the public on item number six? I just wanted to say that listening to this, this is a public meeting, so I think the candidates can hear and see it. And I don't know, if you're going for the element of surprise, that's totally great and that's understandable, but if you really want to hear what the candidates think and you pose the question, I don't think there's any reason why some forethought into it isn't a great thing, because if it's...

1:18:12 Let's express them. Or if it's, hey, what do you really think about this? That might be a differential in opinion. So I was just sharing my comment on that, and I wanted to let you know there's also the other forum that we've been invited to is at the end of the month. That's May 4th, though, right? Oh, that's right.

1:18:31 Don't follow me for the date, but it is in terms of it. And I don't think it's a matter of element of surprise. We just feel that everybody should have the same opportunity. This is a public meeting. I think they're all watching. True, true. Okay, thanks. Any other comments in the public? Okay, we'll go to number seven. Any reports from the NRLC members?

1:19:01 Anything relative to this discussion that you want to share? Just a question, Dan, is how far in advance will we have for reconciliation? Is it going to be that everybody sees it as we're walking in? I have not had a chance to check what staffs you were at on, so it may be at the meeting, but I feel we have that tomorrow. Okay. Is there a...

1:19:32 Format that has been developed for you? Some of us have some spreadsheets, but there's the detailed trick books behind it by every project or program. And so there's a summary of the detail levels. And then we do have this to build a project that says here's what the ongoing commitment is for the panel operational issues.

1:19:56 Is that like a separate category on that spreadsheet? Yeah, this is just a cover sheet. We want to break out and say we funded stuff in the past out of the measures, here's the ongoing operational maintenance side of that. So that shows the annual commitment that has been encumbered moving into the future because this is... Yeah, the recommended is your council has to approve that. We have that broken out and then the big one that's been awarded.

1:20:23 Yeah, and we have the current year awards and then the outstanding awards there. And all the previous awards also? Yeah, I see that. Those are all funded, so it's not a matter of committing any new money at those. No, but it's knowing what's committed. Yeah, where the money's been spent. And where the money's been spent also. And what is in place. So it's just an accounting thing. There's another piece that came up only as I was reviewing my...

1:20:49 Packet for Wednesday night that we need to know if there are any grants that have been received where staff has not yet requested or was planning to request ROU as the budget funds. Because what we have on the agenda is a rather robust set of applications that

1:21:19 Suggests quite openly that up to $750,000 might be requested out of RMU as the matching funds. I'm not saying that it's going forward like that, but it brings the question of is within this whole reconciliation, are there other grants out there that have been received or applied for that might also be encumbering RMU funds because of the past

1:21:46 Couple of years, Council has been doing them with the idea that, oh, well, if we get them, then we'll come back and ask for money. Well, so we don't, so are there other ones out there that we don't know about that haven't even been put into an application form? Yeah, there's only one that I'm aware of and would identify that I, that's the state roster school, one of the schools with a connector path. Originally, we had identified two different times. One, they had a $50,000 that went to the general fund and identified.

1:22:14 That the resolution that was actually poorly identified as potential measure all of the match fund. And the council approved that resolution? The resolution a while back was that. But it's not as a. It's potential for measure. Because we had. And was that a measure of replication? No, that's just it. It's that what has been the standard phrase has been that the match could come.

1:22:35 It would be like the Trails-In Park. So now the grant is being awarded and there's going to be- That's what I'm saying. Are there ones out there- Is there something out there that we don't know about that might be an impact on- That would be really important to know. An example, a good example that comes up would be the committee set aside matching funds for a state grant for Trails-In Park. Correct. That money is not awarded for that particular project because we don't have the grant money. But there was an application done for it.

1:23:05 Is that not a formal application to type of dollars in? A formal measure, our application. Yeah. So let's go apply for the grant if we get it. If we're eligible, we'll have to come up with $200,000 to match it.

1:23:19 So that's a presumption that it's going to be Measure R, then? That was identified in the discussion with the Measure R Committee that we would set $200,000 into reserves which could be utilized to match that grant. That would not show up as a currently awarded. It would not. No. So that's why I said we have to have a handle on all of that. So is that a part of the reconciliation then also? We had not had that.

1:23:39 Because it's not a formal award. Well, I know, but here's the deal. When the grant application goes in and we have to show that there is the ability for the match to occur, and if there's a presumption that that Measure R or U-Money, whichever it is, is going to be used for that match,

1:23:58 When push comes to shove and that grant is awarded, then R is the only source for that match. And that is an encumberance that has occurred. Yes, it does not encumber it. You don't have to accept the grant. I know, but that's the point there, Dan. How often does that grant ever get pushed back? And I think it would be helpful to know moving forward that those, if you will, commitments have been made that we will find the match for the grant that comes forward. But let's know what those commitments are. And that's a cumulative effect that we don't know.

1:24:27 Yeah, because they're sitting in a reserve today. Or any others that are being pursued out there that we don't know, that nobody knows about yet. So daylighting those I think would be really, really helpful to understand how much of R and or U is being looked at as the commitment for the match to those grants that are being pursued. Because those grants are important, but we also need to know how that money is being used.

1:24:54 And not be caught by surprise and throwing a corner with it. And that comes through the other process that we're going to do something big number of NLR with, if you will, at this point in the game. It goes to the council process. They're identifying the potential grant matches. Those funds have been used in the past. That's why staff identified that. So then the process, too, though, is they could be, it does not commit to the word of those dollars. So I want to be careful that it's, it's saying, yes, this is a funding. But you're telling the grantee.

1:25:24 Or the grantor that there is money available for a match in some way. We don't have a choice. If we accept it, we have to have a choice. I know. I know. You have to show it. So let us all know where that grant match is coming from. Let's just kind of know what that word is. It's not a set that is going to come from the Mammoth. We make a commitment. We have to do the match.

1:25:45 So let's just identify that's out there. Those bands are out there. I know what you're asking for. It's easy to do. I'm just saying, please don't read into that. Thou shalt use RU for these bands.

1:25:56 I think we're looking at hard costs. These are hard costs. These are potential costs that are grants that are being applied for moving forward. So anyways, yeah. That the potential is there that these monies that are maybe tapped into for these grants. And I think that would have to include the discussion from the last Recreation Commission meeting about the Waterford Bridge. I think that's a great example.

1:26:24 Yeah, the recommendation was after funding. Yeah, well, actually, the recommendation was, yeah. I don't know whether that's coming to Council or not, so I have no idea where that's going. And what was the recommendation from the Commission on that? Was to not use the Measure R. Not yet. I mean, it was $100,000 to widen the bridge and to engineer it to take emergency vehicles over the bridge. And that the original Measure R application, that was not the intent.

1:26:51 And if the intent and it becomes a necessity because the road is not going to go through to have to have that emergency access, then we felt that it either comes from the town general fund or that it comes from the fire department, but it doesn't come from a measure of our application. Or we don't construct it to that standard. No, you don't construct it to that standard. And that's where the Recreation Commission left it.

1:27:18 And so that's got to go, yeah. Now there's a council for that. Their acceptance of that. Yeah. Sorry, Dan, I just want to clarify. You got to put $750,000? It's about that in the. Oh, yeah. How much of that is generally? Let me back up. What it is, is it's a wish list of grants. It's a wish list of grants. Should staff apply for it, but it.

1:27:43 I'll be pulling it from consent to ask several questions about it because it does infer that it could be up to $750,000 worth of measure R. And because we did have something on our last agenda that named several different projects that were potential and we asked that specific question is that, you know, are you asking us for funding? And then we were just asked if you did all of these, what would your priority for these be? And that...

1:28:12 That was it. So, you know, there was no funding discussion. There was no are you in favor of funding these types of projects. It was just a completely priority question. So can I, just for clarification, so the commission was asked a priority question and then that same list now has gone to the council for their consideration? It's a grant application process under the new...

1:28:36 State and Federal, they took a whole bunch of pieces and put it into one grant application. So the question is, do we want to go apply for these grants? I'm going to say it's in six to seven million dollars worth of grant funds. There's an 11% match requirement to all of those. The question is...

1:28:52 Or you can be a match, but to do that you have to go through whatever application process gets set up and say do you want to spend the dollars on this match or not. Sure. And not to put the commission members on the spot, did you guys give a recommendation of those priorities and is that included in your packet? There is a list of ones to go after. There's not a mention of the Recreation Commission, but I know about it because I listened to the meeting. Okay. All right. Well, then that's on Wednesday's meeting? Uh-huh. Okay. Well, that'd be really important to know.

1:29:21 Yeah, well, no, there was not a commitment, you know, we made it very clear, are you just asking us, you know, pie in the sky, you know, would you like us to tell you what we could see might come first? And it wasn't even do you think this is necessary or not, it was take these, here they're presented, prioritize.

1:29:45 Anyhow. Any other reports from the MLR Committee members? Thursday, the 4-7 at the Community Center is the second phase of the Planning Parks Workshops. The firm is going to come back to us with some designs based on the feedback from the first team, so it will be really interesting.

1:30:12 to see what they bring back and to kind of see how they take the priorities for identifying and kind of putting some drawings together and getting some sort of thoughts. That's at the community center. 4-7 community center. 4-7 community center. Awesome. This Thursday. Thursday, the 17th. Thursday, April 17th, 4-7 p.m., plan your parts, phase 2 meeting at the community center. Awesome. Thanks for reminding us about it.

1:30:41 Anything else from the committee? All right. We are at the end of our meeting. If you don't have any other items, we can go ahead and adjourn ourselves. And we'll see you guys, those who are showing up on Wednesday. Otherwise, we'll see you on the 28th. And the candidates for them is tomorrow night from the chamber. What time? Five to eight. Five to eight. Is that here? Correct. Colin, you're just going to get caught for this room? Yeah, really. Set something up in the corner over here. Set something up in the corner over here.