TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2014

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 4 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

388 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:26 Thank you.

3:36 Welcome to the Town of Mammoth Lakes regular meeting for Wednesday, May 17, 2014. Jamie, roll call please.

3:50 Yeah, I lost another 10 days. Here. Here. Here. Here. If you could please rise and join Councilmember Eastman in the Pledge of Allegiance. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.

4:19 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, welcome everybody. This is the public comment section of our meeting to establish time for any member of the public who wishes to address the council on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. If anybody has something that they want to talk to us about or tell us or inform the community, come on forward, Terry.

4:46 Good evening, Council and Community, Chief, Andy. I'm here as the Vice Chair of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and so I just have an announcement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We have three seats that are going to be coming up to be filled at the end of this, end of June, and those seats are restaurant, retail, and an at-large position, and so I'm just up here to do a public announcement so that we can get some

5:15 Applications in, if anybody would like to apply for those positions, if they could please send a short bio or resume to info at visitmammoth.com, and if they could please have those in by May 23rd. So those seats, again, are retail, restaurant, and an at-large position. Okay? Great, thank you, Carrie. All right, podium still open. We're in public comment. Anybody wish to speak?

5:43 If not, we'll move to councilmember reports and additions to the agenda. Let's start with John. Can we start with you? I'd be happy to. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. First, just real quick, I'd like to pass this around. It's a visitor's guide for Alpine County to the north of us. And I think for a county as small as they are,

6:13 I mean like really small. That's in the Kirkwood area. I think they've done a really fine job with their brochure. I thought I saw Bill Taylor here earlier. Apparently I didn't. But we had a Great Basin Air Pollution Control District meeting on Monday of this week, a couple of days ago, up in Bridgeport. I'm on that group right now. Their next meeting is in July, and this is for staff as well.

6:44 The next meeting, I believe, is July 7th on a Monday, and that's at 10 o'clock in Lone Pine, either in Lone Pine or in Keeler, and that'll be a very good meeting. I don't know who on council will be the new representative for Great Basin. I would love to see Jo Bacon on that if she has time, because that's a really interesting...

7:10 What was the date again? I didn't get it. It's Monday, July 7th. So that's the first Monday after 4th of July. And they're actually going to offer a tour of the project down there. Oh, good. So that would be a good opportunity to see that as well. And that's at 10 o'clock in the morning. We did our budget at that meeting, but the item of most importance was that the town made an application.

7:42 Council remembers, but back in the, gosh, was it the 80s, we were out of compliance with federal air quality guidelines, and that was a major thing. We were not allowed to make, expand traffic in the community. It was a question as far as building the village, because the village would attract more vehicles and stuff like that. But the

8:12 The item before the Great Basin on Monday was to declare the town of Mammoth Lakes from noncompliance, which we were noncompliant at that time, and take us out of that noncompliant category and put us into compliance. I wanted to go into a little bit more detail, and that is that when we were out of compliance, for those that can remember, we were out of compliance for two reasons.

8:41 One reason was that we had a lot of wood-burning stoves in the community, and when we burnt the wood in the wintertime on those cold, windless days, that smoke from the wood stoves accumulated in the community and created bad air for us. The other item at that same time frame was that we used, as well as Caltrans, the town in Caltrans used the volcanic cinders to put down our roads to break up the ice.

9:11 For the traveling public. The problem with the cinders was that over time and when the air dried out and again on cold, windless days, the vehicle traffic as it went over those cinders, crushed them, created the dust, put pollutants in the air. So we had two major areas where we were out of compliance with federal air quality. I mentioned Bill Taylor. I'm going to mention him again and I'm going to give Bill Taylor a gold star.

9:42 Bill Taylor was on our town planning staff at the time, and Bill Taylor pretty much individually created a wood stove requirement in the community. New construction, whether it was single family homes or the large condominium projects, were not allowed to install wood stoves, had to be the fake log.

10:11 Gas stoves. You could do pellet stoves. There was a big debate and issue in the community at that time because people were used to burning wood stoves and no one thought that it would be appropriate to stop allowing wood stoves. Those people who had wood stoves could keep those. They were grandfathered in, but as far as new construction.

10:40 Bill Taylor pretty much single-handedly created this new ordinance, and as we've seen today, other cities, whether it's the Tahoe area or over in the San Joaquin Valley, but other communities and municipalities in the state of California have adopted the same ordinance for themselves because they needed to get into compliance as well.

11:07 Got grant money to get a street sweeper at the time to sweep up the cinders to get them off the road within a few days after a storm, within a few days after the cinders were put down, and that allowed higher levels of traffic to flow through the community without creating that air pollution from the cinders.

11:30 Since that time, since we got the first street sweeper, and Peter, I think I'm correct, but we got a second street sweeper, and then just within the last year, we've gotten the third to replace our first. So we have two viable street sweepers in the community now, and we are required to sweep up those cinders off the road. One final thing on the wood stoves.

11:56 The City of Los Angeles sued the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District within the last few years. The judge ruled in favor of the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District, and the City of Los Angeles was fined, I believe it was about $7 million for their part in this lawsuit. That money went to Inyo County, Mono County, City of Bishop, Town of Mammoth Lakes, and Alpine County to

12:25 Encourage people to remove their current wood stoves and to install a higher level EPA required wood stoves. That was a great, great program. Approximately half the people in all those communities that wanted to do the replacement have done it. There's still something like maybe as many as 700 people in the counties and cities that still want to do it, but that money has dried up.

12:55 An additional settlement recently where about $1.2 million was given to APCD, again by the City of Los Angeles. This is for staff, Peter. That's fine. $150,000 of that one point, I think it was $1.2 million. The first $150,000 is going for a project down in, I believe it's Independence, where they paved a parking lot.

13:23 By the film museum down there, and Caltrans wants them to put in curbs and sidewalks. But other than that $150,000, the balance of that, let's say $1.1 million, is going to be divided up to the communities, again, Union County, Mono County, Alpine County, in relation to their population. So if staff can check, I think that the town of Mammoth Lakes is going to be getting maybe just short of $300,000.

13:53 From that. And I wanted to make a point of that because some of the other communities, whether it's Alpine County or maybe Inyo County, might want to choose their portion of that money to do something else. But I think in talking to the two supervisors of the board and then myself as the town's representative, I think that that

14:16 $300,000 might be better spent if we continue the wood stove replacement program just because we have a backlog of people who still want to do it. And I don't mean to go on and on, Peter, but I don't know how much longer we'll be communicating on this. The first wood stove replacement program, we, the town of Mammoth Lakes, incentivized people by saying that we would pay for 100% of that stove replacement. If we paid 100%, we wouldn't have enough money with $300,000.

14:45 To replace everybody's stove. So it might be a situation where we incentivize not at 100%, but maybe incentivize at 50% to try to get people to replace their stoves. The point being, bottom line, is that the town of Mammoth Lakes, the community of Mammoth Lakes, has come a long, long ways since we were out of compliance. We've done some great stuff. Bill Taylor's done some great stuff. Jen Daugherty.

15:12 In conjunction with Bill Taylor and Duane Ono of the Great Basin, the three of them put together about a 300 page document. It's an update of our plan and the Great Basin Air Pollution Control Board at this week's meeting voted 7-0 to accept that update and what that does is after 20 years, the last 20 years we've been in compliance with the federal

15:41 So after 20 years of being in compliance and not having a single, not one, not one violation in 20 years of the air standards on the federal level, the Great Basin has declared the Town of Mammoth Lakes in compliance and no longer has any requirements placed upon us. So that's good. The air monitoring

16:09 Gauge is still installed and we'll continue to monitor our air, but at least at this time we did good stuff and now we're no longer under the thumb of the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District. So gold star for Bill Taylor and our town staff. Thank you. John, thank you. Matthew. Yes, thank you. I have two items I'm going to talk about in Councilman Reports and I'll have another.

16:37 I'll talk about it with Stu when he brings it up. But one thing I wanted to bring up yesterday, I met with the Chamber of Commerce as their liaison. I went to their most recent meeting. They have a new president, Jeremy Cueco. And over the last year or so, just like a lot of other organizations, they've had challenges financially and whatnot on how to, you know, get a lot of things accomplished that they wanted to. But I want to say that it's been interesting because

17:07 With some of the new leadership there and some of the new folks that are on the board, I really see a good new vision for the chamber, a new drive that's going to be taking place. And the board members are in the process right now of really developing a lot of new great ideas. They've broken out some different subgroups on how they're going to be working to improve financing and also how they're going to be coordinating with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on improving business in the community.

17:35 They're going to be working, I think, closely with the Mountain and hopefully a lot of the businesses on merchant programs and things of that nature. Myself and Michael Ledesma Gomez's, we're also working on a restaurant association. We've mentioned it before, but we've been bringing back progress reports at all of our meetings and actually making a lot of great strides in those areas. So I just want to let a lot of business community know that the chamber is going to be evolving. It's going to be growing and doing some...

18:05 Good, impact of things over the next year or so. So just keep your eyes open. We're going to be reaching out to you folks and kind of let you know some of the things that we will be accomplishing in the near future. Also today I met with Mammoth Lakes Tourism meeting at MLT. And what was I going to talk about on this one anyway?

18:29 I think Terry's going to come forward and talk about a few things a little bit later on, but I'll come back to that later once we talk about the seats changing and whatnot. But that's all I have right now, and I'll touch on a few other things as we get into the meeting. Great. Thank you. The only thing I have is I attended last week's MLT Open House Summer Kickoff event. Just wanted to give props to John Ernie and his team. They did a great job.

18:58 Really well attended. Probably at least 100 people were there. It was pretty full. A lot of good marketing and things coming for this summer. And it was just a really great event. And it should be one that's probably happening in the fall for winter too. So it was a great event. Excellent. Joe.

19:16 Yes, I have a couple of items. First, Rick and I met with Ed Armenta and John Ragerbrugge to follow up from the comments they had made during the February 19th discussion on Mammoth Lakes Recreation, which some people inferred as they were against MLR, and that is not the case at all. We were able to reaffirm the partnership expectations on both sides.

19:40 We were also acknowledged how to work together and I'll discuss that a little bit later when we get into MLR. We also briefed them on the MLR progress and we're able to bring them up to date that we know more about what the framework of it looks like which will be presented at next meeting to the full council.

20:01 And then finally we were able to help them understand that we're cognizant of their constraints and that we're not asking them to participate in any way that goes beyond their capacity at this point. So meeting went quite well, I think. I think we got a lot of things squared away. Was that in Bishop Hill? No, we met over here at the Ranger Station here. Then as far as MLR, we are continuing.

20:29 to meet and work. Next Monday will be our meeting where we get everything together for the presentation that comes to full council on May 21st. A lot of things that we've been working hard on. I hope you'll be surprised and pleased with the amount of details that there are that will hopefully answer any of the questions that were out there in the community from the last time because we have worked long and hard and you'll see quite a few things in that agenda packet.

20:56 I do need to let you know that there is one area that is of personal frustration to me that we've been talking about having a reconciliation of how the RNU money has been spent for several years. And about a year ago, we even said, yes, let's get this taken care of. And we allocated funding over last summer. But as of this date, we still do not have all of that reconciled. And that is extraordinary.

21:25 Personally, extremely frustrating. Is it being worked on? Yes, but I don't think any of us anticipated that a year after it was being discussed and funded that we not have the answers yet. Okay. That's it. Thank you. Well, tagging on a bit, I share that frustration, and the council may recall that that was part of the rationale for suspending R and U allocations for the next several months while

21:55 We until we get that reconciliation. So we move forward all day slowly. I also want to tag on with respect to the meeting with the leadership, senior management, Forest Service. I think that coming out of that meeting, a lot of myths about the alleged or purported

22:23 Disconnect between the town and the United States Forest Service were just really shattered. I thought it was a great meeting. We go to a lot of meetings. Some are good, some are not. This was a good meeting. And I really think that going forward now, in the manner that this council has decided thus far, and I hope will decide in May, that partnership with the Forest Service is going to be strengthened and not threatened by what we're doing.

22:52 Joe gave us some details, and my tag on to it is just that I appreciate that they, meaning Ed and John, took the time to hear us, and I think they appreciated our taking the time to come to them as well and tell them what we have on our mind, and so I'm quite optimistic going forward.

23:21 Second, as Joe mentioned, the next MLR meeting that is in advance of the May 21st meeting is on the 12th here, which is I think next Monday, and then there's another one on the 19th. Both of them are at 3 o'clock. These are really, really substantive meetings with subcommittees working very hard doing the things that have been assigned to them in preparation for putting together.

23:49 An agenda bill for the 21st. Lastly, I went several times up to the Disabled Sports Spring Spectacular, which is a skiing event for the disabled community both here in Mammoth and also from out of the area. A highly successful program, yet another one that Disabled Sports and Kathy Copeland in particular put on for those who

24:19 Otherwise, can't participate in this wonderful outdoor sport. And, you know, for those who are either cognitively impaired or physically impaired, in some instances both, you know, the joy of having that wind running across your face as you're going down the hill is the same, I think, for everybody. And the reward that comes from those volunteers in the community, not just

24:49 The staff at Disabled Sports, but dozens and dozens of volunteers. I saw Matthew up there one day. He's probably greater even than the joy of this experience by those who participated. So good for you, Kathy. Keep doing it. It's now several years old. It really is an important piece, albeit small, but an important piece in the quality of life for those people who are less advantaged than we are.

25:17 And that's all I have. Rick, can I ask you a question? Go ahead. I was just curious, what is the amount of money that MLR is going to generate, you know, on an annualized basis? Is it going to generate $500,000 a year, $1 million a year, or do we know? Well, MLR, my expectation, the council will decide how to fund MLR, and that will occur at the next meeting.

25:49 As you know, my expectation and my advocacy will be for it to assume responsibility for spending measures R and U funds, which are currently a million eight. It will also have the capacity and the directive, at least as I expect it, as this one member of the committee expects, to generate additional revenue.

26:14 From private contributions, grants, and other funding that is available to the nonprofit organizations. I brought that up only not to get into discussion and public comment, but I brought that up because I've got to think that something of that substance to be able to have the flexibility to do something with would be encouraging for other agencies, whether it's the Forest Service or someone else, to be involved.

26:43 In this process. Well, that's an important point. And if we didn't clearly articulate it, that really was central to the discussion. And that is that there is an opportunity for them to help us and us to help them in a way that hasn't existed or hasn't presented itself at least in the same way in the past. That neither of us would be able to do on our own.

27:09 Well, and we have examples of that already, as you know. So I hope there are a lot of other examples that we'll be able to look to in the future. Last question is, I was curious if anybody knew. Peter, do we know if the Lakes Basin is open as yet? It's open. The road is open. The road is open. The road has been plowed. I don't believe they've actually opened it yet, maybe tomorrow or Friday.

27:39 I brought it up a little bit out of frustration, and this goes back to the Forest Service, and excuse me after we put them up on this pedestal. Tiger Pass has been open, Yosemite's been open. I think they get a lot more snow up in Tuolumne Meadows than we get in the Lakes Basin. I'm just frustrated that we can get the road open.

28:04 And yet the campgrounds and the facilities in the Lakes Basin are not available. We had opening of fishing a week and a half ago. We get people coming to town. I just think there's an opportunity there for the community to be able to use the Lakes Basin and to promote it through marketing. And so far we're not being able to see it. So I think we're about two weeks late in opening that this year.

28:31 Yeah, we plowed it again after the storm, after the opening day. Uh-huh. They were going to let it melt out again for parking. So, you know, the Forest Service actually opens the gate. I'm not sure if that's open. Again, I'm just saying if Yosemite can be open, I think our lakes basin. And Mike hasn't been plowed up to Horsham, or up to the gate to Horsham. Okay, thank you. John, just a textbook example of how that presents an opportunity that I think

29:01 We can have some direct impact on that. One of the things that I learned in that meeting, and I don't want to belabor it, is that the Forest Service's recreation budget, it is handed down to them by the federal government, by Congress, or whoever designs their budget. I suppose it may be the administration and the Congress passes the bill to fund it.

29:27 Extraordinarily limited. I was very, very surprised. In fact, I was so startled that I had to ask a couple of times. Their budget is not much, and I'm not justifying what they do or they don't do or how they allocate their funds, but again, I just think we've got some opportunities coming up that I think will correct some of the deficiencies that you pointed out that haven't been addressed at least collaboratively up to this point. Great. Thank you.

29:56 Okay. With that, we'll move to reports from commissions and or departments. Thank you. Thank you. Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. As you know, following on the heels of the Main Street plan, staff is engaged to consult to work on a snow management and parking feasibility study. So I just wanted to let the public know and remind the council that there will be a joint workshop next Wednesday at 4 o'clock here in Suite Z.

30:28 To look at the draft, a snow management feasibility study. The draft is available on our website and I'm available for any questions. If anyone has any questions, they can contact me or Peter Bernasconi. And that's all I have. Thank you. Sandra, did you mention the time? Four o'clock? Four o'clock to 5.30? Until 5.30 and a half. And actually all morning the consultant will be here from 9 until noon here in Sweet C. So if anyone has...

30:54 Detailed questions about how any of the financing structure works, they can come speak with a consultant. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager, Evening Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, Council, staff, community. A few items on the recreation front. Today, fortunately, it wasn't yesterday, so today is the T-ball opening, so that program is underway at elementary school.

31:23 Summer Softball League kicks off just right around the corner, so team managers meeting next week as well, so that's busy. The Recreation Commission reviewed the conceptual draft plans of the four park sites from the Plan Your Parks workshop, so that went really well. We had over 120 people in those two workshops meet and plan their parks, which was great, and that also included the siting of the Recreation and Aquatic Centre. So that's moving forward.

31:50 The Commission will again review those plans on June 10th. Lap Swimming opens on May 19th, so that's pretty close, around the corner. We're flooding that pool, filling it up, getting it ready. And then the Mammoth Sharks also kick off their season as well. They've got their registration today. Hope that goes well. We're also excited to announce that a pilot program to provide transit down to the Whitmore Recreation Area will kick off on June 23rd. So we're going to be able to run.

32:17 The expansion of the Mammoth Bishop Express to get service to the pool Monday through Friday. So we work with Esther on that as well. There's no cost additional to the town. And it's only $2 a round trip. So we really think we can drive some visitation down to that pool and also to the Whitmore Track as well. Andrew's got that information. Pool's got that information. So they're very excited about that. And we'll see how that goes. That's for a two-month period, just a pilot program. If we can expand it, if it's successful, we can look at doing that.

32:47 In the future, but we'd probably need additional funding. We briefly talked about the Lakes Basin transit service to the Lakes Basin begins May 24th. That'll be on a limited schedule, midweek, 9am to 6pm every 60 minutes. And then June 28th, it'll run seven days a week on the 9am to 6pm, but every 30 minutes. So that starts as well. Also on May 20, fish stocking in the Lakes Basin gets underway. We executed the contract today, so that's in motion.

33:17 So that's $73,000 worth of fish in those lakes basin over summer. So that's a big investment for both the town and we're partnering with Mammoth Lakes Tourism as well to provide that service. And then finally, July 4 is right around the corner, as Council Lehman was talking about. Town's already meeting with a lot of our stakeholders, event organisers.

33:40 And jurisdictional partners on that event. Looks like the Freedom Isle is still at 10.30 in the morning. The parade will be 11 o'clock. That's the same time, but they're going to flip the direction of that parade. It'll actually start from Mammoth Creek Park and go back up Main Street. That doesn't kind of upset too many people. We'll see how that goes. But that's also moving forward. The Pops in the Park, the town was able to provide funding for that.

34:07 They still need additional funding, but we're moving forward with that contract. So that's going to be Mammoth Creek Park immediately following about 1.30. And then again, we've signed the contracts with the Pyro Spectacular Group, and that'll be Fireworks at Dusk at Crowley Lake. And then I do want to turn it back over to Councillor Lehman just to talk about the successful fundraising efforts that his group has been able to provide. I think it's really kicked off well.

34:34 And I believe we're going to come back in a couple of weeks with some check and support to fund those fireworks. Thank you, Stu. So just a little bit of a follow-up. It's been a group that really was initiated. I think Ted actually might have kicked it off from the sheet, myself, Stu, Alexandra from the Mammoth Times, Jack Copeland, and others. It was really an effort to try to get the funds going so we could keep this great event going, as well as...

35:03 Fundraising for Pops in the Park. I think the total is somewhere around $26,000 for the fireworks alone. The town's contributing somewhere around $10,000. We've got about $10,000 currently in private money and about $3,000 specifically for Pops in the Park.

35:24 There's been a lot of great contributions out there, anywhere from $50 up to, you know, obviously the town's contribution and one gentleman in particular, a gentleman by the name of Rick Elkis, he gave us $5,000 just because he's so passionate about seeing this fireworks show go on. A couple other larger donors were at the Board of Realtors, individual real estate agents. I believe, Ted, you got a number of

35:53 Lawyers to step up to the plate and some other private business people and owners in town. So we'd like to recognize them and we will be recognizing them as the event goes on and as we start running some ads in the papers. But we're looking forward to next, you know, May 21st, hopefully we'll be able to present a check to the community and really demonstrate the efforts of a private-public, you know, partnership and what can be done with that and just, I think, really demonstrate the importance of keeping this.

36:22 These events going. They're just so much fun for the quality of life up here. So hopefully by our next council meeting we'll be able to present some of the funds to the town so we can see us keep going forward. Thank you. Beaten up by you. Beaten up by you.

36:52 My shoulder's still sore. Well, it's just an important event, and I think that it's just important we see this move forward, and it just goes to show that our community always seems to pull together when times are tough, financial or otherwise, and just want to thank everybody that's contributed so far and all the efforts of the group, so thank you. Thank you.

37:20 Just the last thought I might have. While you're still on that, one more question. So if we're going back to the old way the parade used to go, does that mean that you'll actually start Pops in the Park a little bit later so people will have a chance to trickle back down? Because, you know, the last time was kind of you followed the parade to the end and you were right there. Right. So will they schedule a little bit later in the... I think it all depends on how fast the Freedom Hall finishes, how many floats are in the parade and so forth. I think they always say about 30 to 45 minutes after that parade.

37:49 So it will really be up to, you know, chamber music folks, but we can chat after to see if you want to. What day of the week is the fourth one? It's a Friday. Oh, it's on a Friday. It's a big day. It's a good day. Big day. And did you mention earlier in your report about town cleanup day? You got it. Thank you. I did want to say that the bags are here. The orange trash bags are back.

38:14 We think that's a big part of Town Cleanup Day. So we have those at the Town Offices. We have them at Mammoth Disposal. We have a lot of flyers. Come and say hi to Mayor Pro Tem Bacon at Mammoth Creek Park. Tell you kind of where to grab your bags and where to kind of pick up our trash. But that's a big undertaking, so we're really looking for a lot of community support and really see a lot of community pride in cleaning up our neighborhood. So that's Saturday, May 17th. We have the same stations around town. It'll be from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.

38:44 The weather looks good right now for that. I'm not even looking out the window. I don't want to know. But anyway, we have a lot of information, a lot of flies on our website. You'll see the information on Friday in the sheet and then the following Thursday in the amount of time. So there we go. Good. That's all I had. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Peter. Just to follow up, so we did plow the lakes basin again after fishing season. There's actually more snow after that storm than there was the first time we plowed it.

39:18 Forest Service is going to wait until there's not parking before they actually open the road, but it's open to admin users. We also plowed into Red's Meadows. One of the comments that one of the drivers made was that the road has actually been damaged quite a bit from all the logging that was done last year. So it could be sometime, you know, they intend to open as soon as possible, but it's pretty soft, and so until it firms up and dries out, that's probably when the Forest Service will open that road.

39:48 We'll be working on a few pavement repairs on the bike path before the half marathon. We've got a couple sections to repair on Lake Mary and we've got some sections on Meridian section to repair that were pointed out by one of the marathon runners that would get to repair those and we're working on those. Transit, so the way we were able to provide service to Whitmore is we looked at our existing resources that we're currently paying for with our contract with VESTA and reallocated the

40:18 The dial-a-ride part, which is utilized heavily in the winter with school kids, less so in the summer, and so we're really using that same bus service to augment the other bus, the Mammoth Express, to provide that more frequent route out there. There's a small charge, but primarily paid for with our existing resources that we're, with our current contract.

40:45 We'll also be working on the Forest Service. They've got some patching to do the walkway, going to the Welcome Center and the Visitor Bureau office, MLT's office, and we'll be helping them stripe a part of their parking lot, not the whole parking lot, a part of their parking lot. With that, that's it. I should have mentioned, very public speaking, that we had a great turnout. The Lions-Star Coastal College sponsored candidates tonight. Lots of people attended. We did televise it, so we'll be working to get that on Veronica's.

41:14 And the channel, town's channel to, so the public can see it in general. And Peter, you got started on canyon? Canyon work is underway. They'll finish the pajoing this week and start putting in storm drain next week. When they put in storm drains, is that, I mean, is there going to have a lot of equipment in the roads then? Yeah, they'll be closing a block section at a time.

41:40 Essentially, some of the sections of the storm drain are quite deep. Excavation will be eight feet or more in some locations. And so certainly for the public, it's not safe to drive adjacent to a trench like that if we can avoid it. We'll still provide access to homes so they're not blocked off for too long. But it will be a full summer project to be completed in September. The storm drain will take a little over a month to complete. Great. Thank you.

42:11 Thank you, Peter. All right. Anyone else who wishes to provide a report from a commission or from a department? No, of course. Going forward, Terry.

42:27 I was just going to reiterate, because I don't know if Matthew heard me, so maybe with my cold people didn't hear, that we have three seats that are going to be available at the end of June for the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, one being retail, one being restaurant, and one at large. And if whoever is interested would send a short bio or resume to info at visitmammoth.com by May 23rd, there will be an interview process that will be held the first couple weeks in June.

42:57 And I also just wanted to say that with the summer kickoff, it was well attended. Unfortunately, I was running off on vacation, so I didn't get to see it. But something that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is really striving to do is make sure that we have a better outreach to our community and to our business partners. And so there's an industry site that's being set up so that you can go on that website and see what Mammoth Lakes Tourism is doing, what current marketing programs they have going on.

43:27 What occupancies have been, what pacings look like. And so if you look at MLTIndustryInsider.com, that information is going to be on there. So it's something that we're really trying to do an outreach and get that information out there. Thank you, Terry. Terry, if I could follow up on just the importance of that piece of the website. I think it's really unique because not only are there going to be images and things like that that can offer a consistent

43:55 I don't know the expression of Mammoth, but to give you an example, a lodging partner might be able to go on there, and if there's a specific thing that Mammoth is trying to push, they can grab that and send it out to their respective guests and whatnot, and same with restaurateurs and whatnot. So I think it's important to give you an example.

44:18 You always see these images online of where our flights are going. And it's nice for all the business folks in the community to be able to say where the flights are going and there's little airplanes flying out of Mammoth. The problem is with a lot of our flights changing, people are using old information. So I think it's a good way to have a consistency across the board of what we're trying to do. And I can't tell you how many people have called me just saying, well, what are the times or what are this or what are that. And so Mammoth Lakes Tourism will have a great...

44:44 One-stop shop place. You can just go in there and grab information you need, and I think it's going to be very helpful for all of us moving forward, particularly for people doing their own personal marketing. So it's information as well as toolkits that businesses can use. Thank you. Thank you. Peter again. Just to follow up, the Lakes Basin was open yesterday. Oh, great. Thank you.

45:08 All right. Thank you very much. That takes us to agenda item number one, which is a public presentation from Steve Spidell, Mammoth Lakes Trails System Coordinating Committee, which we affectionately know as MLTSCC Coordinator regarding the current progress report for MLTSCC. Steve. Thank you very much. For the record, Steve Spidell, MLTSCC Coordinator.

45:36 One thing I'd like to do is start off by giving you a handout. You'll notice on the card that there is a QR code for smart devices to be able to immediately go to the website. And there are many pieces of information on that website. So to start with, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, Councilmembers.

46:08 Town staff and the public. It gives me a great pleasure to be able to report to you some of the progress that the committee has made since the last time we made a presentation to you. The PowerPoint that I have today will highlight from the background how the committee was formed, what our accomplishments have been over the last few months, and also will be

46:40 Going into one of the agenda items that's later on the agenda today with our proposed budget and project list for next fiscal year. So to start with, again, thanks for the opportunity. The committee appreciates the opportunity to present to council as well. This PowerPoint presentation has gone through the committee and also the recognition, and so we're presenting it to you today. First slide basically outlines our vision.

47:09 And our mission, as you can see, our vision is that Mammoth Lakes Trail System is the best set of recreational trails and programs in the country. So that's really the kind of thing that we want to keep focused on. Also, we go on to have a mission of the appointed body of recreational trail users. We encourage you dialogue and provide recommendations to partner agencies.

47:31 This ties in with your earlier conversation about the U.S. Forest Service. So that's very important to us to keep that relationship open. Well, if you remember, initially the committee was given a scope of work through a council direction, and those seven items are outlined here, and our early focus to put together our administrative policies and how we were moving forward in our strategies

48:00 We kept looking back to these seven initial scope items. So I'll quickly run through how we've accomplished those. The first two, items one and two, we were to recommend and to prioritize projects for the committee, including a five-year capital and minor projects list. We've done that and continue to update that and modernize it. We recommend budget allocations for prioritization of projects to the rec commission.

48:29 We've done that and prior to submittal to Town Council within the proposed annual $300,000 appropriation. So you may remember the last two cycles we've gone through and then today we'll be asking for an additional approval for the third $300,000 cycle. So you can see here too I've enumerated some of the things that we've been able to do with our master tracking list. We use it to give our every project has a number, a unique number. We have a process for setting those numbers.

48:59 So that we can keep track of them. They have a name and a description, a bucket list or a priority list for how we want to approach that. We take the funding from our budget and also then use that for accounting purposes so every invoice that's come in is tracked against that number and that name so we can justify our funding and understand how much is left in the budget and if we're on target or not. We have league organizations identified who's responsible for the work.

49:28 We also list our current status on the project so we know what's going on. We look to next steps and actions as well and various notes that help us to monitor that in the future. We also include in it the town's CIP list as it relates to trail projects. So we're monitoring those and understanding how to interface with those capital improvement projects that are on the list.

49:53 Incorporate the SOPA list from the U.S. Forest Service so we know what their projects are, what their environmental decisions are, and how they are moving forward. So that's how we communicate both with the Town Public Works and also with the Forest Service. Three and four, what we were asked to do is establish a regular meeting schedule and also to determine the...

50:19 Process for implementation and the funding based on the requirements, legal fiduciary relationships. So what we've done in the past is establish a framework for the tracking numbers, as I mentioned. We have strategies for funding. We have set up priorities for funding. We have project criteria and consistency checklists. So as projects come forward from the public or elsewhere, we evaluate them against that criteria prior to putting them on the list and making a recommendation for funding.

50:49 How we address items 5 and 6 is determine the staffing needs and engage entities as needed. So we've identified potential staff hours for administration as well as project-related time and also consultants necessary to help bring the $300,000 to fruition. We've established budgets for staffing, incorporated a $6,900 Measure R application, and that was from...

51:16 The little graphic on the right shows how we are monitoring those hours and making sure that we stay on budget and on task for that. Work item number seven was identified user groups that need to be included and also determine the appropriate size of the committee. The meetings are open to all.

51:42 And we have determined that a five-member committee is the most efficient, and their names are listed here and what they represent and how to get in touch with them as well. Some of our accomplishments, we're very proud of two of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System U.S. Forest Service Memorandum of Understanding. These MOUs are very crucial to our work as we move forward to have that relationship with the Forest Service.

52:13 And I think in your packet later on for the agenda item copies of those are actually included. So the number one thing is that we have a maintenance and operation agreement for our website. I handed out the smart cards earlier to direct you to that website. You'll find that there are over 300 individual pages, viewable pages on that website related directly to our trail system both in winter and in summer.

52:43 So on that site as well there are trails, there's maps and photos, there's activities for people who are interested in everything from bird washing to snowshoeing or winter over mobilized like snowmobile activities. We have again both winter and summer featured on the website and as we go through these shoulder seasons like right now we're transitioning out of winter into summer so the things that we're promoting on the site when you get on to it.

53:11 Our summer-based activities. We have experiences and we have an opportunity for people who have experiences to add to the website, to communicate with the webmaster and the group and actually make suggestions as to other experience to add to the website. An example of that was this winter, the winter grooming at Shady Rest Campground was added as an experience. Also we feature destinations.

53:40 The second MOU is the Overriding Mammoth Lakes Trail System MOU with the Forest Service that includes working cooperatively on trail system improvements, wayfinding, interpretation, and public involvement. Other accomplishments that we've made have to do with U.S. Forest Service Challenge cost share agreements. We found that these agreements work very well for working.

54:09 With funding that's available both from the Forest Service and also from the town. So we have number one is implementation of the Mammoth Lakes Trail Systems. It's an overall master agreement. We have a sub-agreement with Sherwin's Trails Editions. We're currently in the environmental resource review and planning. A lot of that work was done over the summer. And one of the challenges for the committee now is to make recommendations back to the Forest Service based on some of those environmental reviews.

54:38 So you can see the value of that work is at $215,000 plus. Town measure R with our funding from the committee is at $152,000 over a three-year period of time. So that allocates out to about $50,000 a year, and we're on that schedule. And I'm happy to say we're under budget and on time. The third thing for the challenge cost share agreement is the Sarbanes multi-use path.

55:07 Lake George Road, and that's fully funded by a FTA grant. Steve, while you're there, I thought we had seen something where we were asked to find match for that, that it wasn't fully funded by the grant. I think maybe Peter can add some detail to that that I don't have.

55:34 The Sarmagin Grant is a FTA grant that we received a number of years ago. Actually, the match that, the way we wrote the grant, the match was actually incorporated as part of our operational cost for the transit system that we provide to the Lake Spaces. So it was an in-kind match? It was an in-kind match. For the capital work itself, there's no matching. It also purchased a bus, a couple of trailers that will be in use this summer with higher capacity bikes. Okay.

56:07 Other accomplishments have to do with the website management. So as you can imagine with 300 pages with various aspects and functions within the site itself mechanically and cloud-based, there can be some problems. So we have entered into a contract with a contractor to provide management for that website. We also have meetings. I just finished one actually today.

56:34 With our partners to make sure that it's functioning properly, providing what we want and what we need. And out of that also is coming protocols for how to develop additional content and how to manage it. Also within that are the people who are technically responsible within the town and the county interface in the IT department so that if anything comes up, we can make sure that it's taken care of right away and also funding for the various hostings that go on.

57:02 for the website. Another accomplishment that we have continued to work with is the summer of stewardship up in the lakes basin and in particular the trail days. This is a schedule from last year and we want to continue this great program

57:42 That allows for maintenance of soft surface trails. It also allows for people in the community to take part in maintaining the trails that we all use. We've also found that it's a wonderful opportunity to engage guests to come up who want to be a part of the system, want to be a part of what's going on in the town. And last year, actually, there was a family from Arizona that wanted to know what weekends they were going to have trail days.

58:10 For this year so that they could plan their vacation accordingly. So here's something that starts off to just be a maintenance deal and then turns out to actually be a promotion for tourism and a little bit of family entertainment and involvement. So these programs are continuing. The other program that we have with Friends of the Yinyo.

58:32 is the Stewards Program. So this gives us the opportunity to have people out on the trails to help people who might be a little disoriented, to also provide interpretive programs at Horseshoe Lake explaining why the trees are dead. Also up at Coldwater to explain what's going on with all these old buildings from the Mammoth Consolidated Mine.

58:55 So that type of interpretive interaction as well as helping people out on the trail and identifying trail segments that might need to be included in the Trails Days cleanup projects. One of the challenges that we faced this year was that a non-profit that's been functioning in Mammoth for a number of years disband, and that was Mammoth Nordic. So we found ourselves in a position where we needed to put together some grooming program for the Shady Rest Campground.

59:26 So with the quick response and ability of the committee to mobilize, we were able to enter into an agreement with a non-profit and to actually work then with that dissolved Mammoth Nordic, be able to reacquire equipment to provide for grooming, be able to get expertise from the Forest Service and individuals who had done the grooming in the past.

59:53 And also work with the Forest Service to shape and model the agreements that were in place with the previous non-profit. So I looked at this as one of our big accomplishments, and the only thing that we didn't program was seeding the clouds to get more snow. But anyway, we had a project that was up and running, and we want to continue as well in our next budget go-around. Does that realistically, does that look like that the funding will be there for next year? Yes, sir. For this program?

1:00:21 It is a line item in the budget that we're bringing for you later on today as an agenda item. Great. Thank you. Steve, I have a question on the, you know, kind of related to the grooming and the trail system. Has there been any progress on better staging areas or anything like that for the motorized community? I mean, I've been asking this for about four years, and I just don't know if I'm getting heard.

1:00:45 I don't think so. Well, no, I think that one of the longstanding agenda items for the committee has been that discussion of winter use by the motorized. Also, what we are hoping to do is fabricate a winter summit similar to what we had for the trails master plan for summer, and it's one of the recommendations in the master plan to convene a winter summer where we'd be looking at those types of issues. But to date, with the Forest Service

1:01:13 Looking to move the staging further and further and further away from town. It looks like the current direction is to not come back to the previously located staging at 203, but to continue out at Shady Rest. And then with the recent decision having to do with the ORMAT proposal and the Forest Service environmental decision was to move another staging area, brand new, out even further.

1:01:42 So how this all comes forward, who's going to pay for it, who's, it's all unknown at this point. Well, the reason I ask, and I won't be the dead horse, but I know there's green sticker money there, and it's being used not for motorized, it's being used to shut trails down. And I just have a personal frustration with that, and I'm just wondering, as an advocacy group,

1:02:05 Instead of it working against this community, if we can try to turn that around and maybe start getting some advocacy to bring that trailhead back into town. I mean, we've lost so much business because of it because, you know, we had a snowmobile company here in town. They're gone now. And, you know, we had people, you know, going out all the time and they just don't do it anymore because there's nowhere else to launch other than you have to send them out in the middle of the forest. And I can't help but think this is intentional.

1:02:31 And I'm just wondering if we're paying for this as a trail system. I mean, I as one person, I know there's a large contingency out there that believes the same. We'd like to see that brought back in here and like to see snowmilling be brought back and integrated with our trail systems as well. And I'd just like to ask MLTSCC if we can focus on that a little bit too in the future as opposed to just snowshoeing and hiking. Personally, I couldn't agree with you more. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:03:06 Another accomplishment that we have put together is we've got funding last year in the neighborhood of around $80,000 to implement seven additional interpretive signs on our MUC system. So as you know, we do have some interpretive signs already that were part of the ARA and Lake Mary Bike Path development, and these are seven additional panels that have been now constructed.

1:03:32 The frameworks have also been constructed. And so as the season is changing now, Public Works staff will have the opportunity to install those frames and also these particular panels in those locations. I'm happy to report that all that physical work has come in.

1:03:52 Under budget and on time. We also had a provision in here that in order for these panels to be installed, the QR code, similar to what I gave you earlier, needed to be on the panel and also ready for the mobile device so that once those panels go up, you can take a picture of your mobile device. You will be directed to additional interpretive content.

1:04:17 That'll be in the form of hear it, see it, and watch it. So for some of them, there will be audio that gives you more information besides what's written in the interpretive panel that you can get to from your smart device. There may also be then some additional audio-visual video that goes along with that to supplement it. And so we're really excited about this opportunity to expand our interpretive.

1:04:45 And then also expand into the new media of wireless for our visitors so that people can use their smart devices, learn more about the area, become more excited, and then get to the trails master plan as well, I mean the website for the trail system so they can plan other trips in the area. So we're really excited to see how that program's going to go forward.

1:05:12 Also, our accomplishment last year was that we had a situation where we needed to put in some temporary soft surface signage due to some of the impacts up in the Lakes Basin Panorama Dome area from the fuels reduction project. There was a lot of...

1:05:32 Ground disturbance up there and many of the tracks and trails were disrupted and it was a little hard to find your way so on one of our volunteer trails days we went up and organized the trails made the mountain bike trail much more definitive as to its route did some great bank turns worked with some drainage and so forth got that taken care of helped segregate out the pedestrian trail that leads up to

1:05:58 The Panorama Dome. And then installed these temporary signs in a number of locations up there to let people know how to get from one place to another. And I must say that I took a person who has not been that familiar with mountain biking or being out in the outdoors to that degree.

1:06:19 Along the trail system. And they were absolutely impressed with the ability to go from one place to another and to understand how to get back to the bike path, how to go through the Panorama Dome area, end up at Old Mammoth Road. We also did a similar thing at Uptown Downtown. You may have remembered when you start at the village, there's a little confusion there by the little building across from Forest Trail, you know, just where to go and how to.

1:06:49 To negotiate, so we were able to set up some lanes, set up some signage, and then work with the mountain as well as to alert people that further on up you might need a pass. And then that integrated as well at the earthquake fault. You come rolling down off the mountain view trail. Where do I go? How do I safely get across the road? And then also when you come down across 203.

1:07:13 There is on the right then the sign saying, hey, to go further up the hill you need a pass and it's part of the mountains bike park. And if you want to continue down, you can get down to the village free of charge. No problem. You're on downtown. So we have ongoing and continuing projects and programs. You'll see them individualized later on in the program tonight.

1:07:44 A quick recap is we want to continue the funding for the sharps work out in the Sherwin's with the Forest Service, taking NEPA into consideration as well as any CEQA work that we need to do in order to bring this joint project with the Forest Service and the town together. We want to continue the various lakes basin projects that we're working on. Also, some of that interfaces with the Forest Service.

1:08:11 We want to continue funding the summer stewardship's trails days, maintenance projects. We want to expand some of these maintenance projects with a challenge cost share agreement with the forest because they don't want us to develop any new trails that we're not going to be able to maintain. So there's going to be a lot of need to focus on maintenance and having a program for doing that for soft surface. We want to continue the funding of the stewards and the interpretive programs that they provide.

1:08:40 Throughout our trail system, not just in the lakes basin, winter grooming we think is really important and keeping it going at Shady Rest Campground is also important. Continue funding of the website, maintenance, very important, content development, we want to continue to be able to refresh our pages occasionally as things come up and also to integrate the QR code use with the website.

1:09:10 Develop handouts and maps and guides to help our users and to, I guess I've mentioned this before about the soft surface challenge cost share agreement. We'll also be needing to update our type 2 and type 4-6 signs that are actually on the trail system now as we add these new projects. For instance, the Waterford Bridge is going to be going in this summer. Hopefully this summer we'll get a soft surface trail.

1:09:39 Out from Mammoth Creek, I'm sorry, Mammoth Rock down to the borrow pit. So as the progress of these new additions come to our system, we need to also set aside money to replace our fiberglass panels and our new maps. And if you may remember, that whole signage program was designed to just do that, to get, be able to unbolt one fiberglass panel, put it aside, put up a new fiberglass panel, and not have to do any other work with the signs.

1:10:07 We have at least 10 other programs and projects that are included on the master project tracking list that we want to continue working on. Steve, real quick on that area you just finished. Those are several bullet points, and you said you had 10 additional items. I'm wondering if that portion of this presentation and of what we're doing with MLTSCC projects might...

1:10:35 That might be an area where you could add or at least consider adding a beginning site for motorized out in the shady rest area. Is that something that could be discussed and possibly added as a bullet point in that area? Yeah, I think that... Or is that not appropriate for that area? No, it's absolutely appropriate. And I think if it's similar to what Matthew's conversation was, that there is an opportunity...

1:11:04 Within the other projects that we are considering that we have yet to bring forward to ask for funding to be on that list. And it is something, again, with the SOPA that we've been tracking with the Forest Service about the relocation of the staging area. But again, with no funding or no direction, it hasn't been brought forward.

1:11:30 I think we can make sure that that is added to the list if it's not already there to make sure that we can promote motorized further. One of the things that we want to do, as a matter of fact, in our next meeting is to bring forward one of our agenda items, which is a winter over snow vehicle grooming from the Shady Rast campground through the tunnel and around to the borrow pit.

1:11:59 And we think that that will help lead to what Matthew was talking about earlier that might encourage over snow vehicle users come to the RV park. They have their large RV vehicles with trailers on the back, numerous snowmobiles in them. And then from there, they don't have to drive anywhere else. They can unload the snowmobile, for instance, at the RV park.

1:12:25 Have permission legally to drive that snowmobile under the tunnel and then up into the Shady Rest area, bypass the winter grooming area that is in the old campground, get out to Shady Rest and then beyond to our Orange Diamond Trails. So conceptually that's been brought to council before in the years past. I actually had from when I worked here before a council.

1:12:53 Direction to staff to pursue that further never went anywhere. So it is an item. It's on our agenda. We're trying to move it forward. You must understand there's a lot of resistance from cross-country. Does it need a sponsor, or is that something that will come up for discussion anyway? If the council could actually make a direction to the committee to explore that further, to reiterate that previous direction that council gave to staff, I think that would be very important.

1:13:21 And it would help to solidify that this is something that has meaning to the community, has meaning to the council, and it potentially can have a good effect as far as promoting tourism and getting more people here to do more things. And the Forest Service expresses a concern over impacts. But I think with staging cross-country users at the Welcome Center and the parking lot there where they have restrooms,

1:13:48 They have a warm fireplace to go to. They have information available for them for all kinds of uses that they can stage out of that area. The motorized can stage back in the old parking lot where the sewer cleanout is and all that stuff, and they can go off in one direction. Cross-country skiers, snowshoers, whatever, can go off in another direction. They can separate if they choose to. If they want to co-mingle, there's that opportunity as well. But I don't think that we should drive.

1:14:18 Motorized out of Mammoth. Right. Okay. Thank you. And thank you, Steve, for saying that. And I think I would, if the rest of council were a favor, I would like to make a directive to do that. And I think where the money would come from is from the green sticker money. I think there is ample money there. It's just unfortunately being abducted by other groups that quite honestly aren't motorized. And I think that's part of the challenge. And I'm hoping that that can go towards

1:14:47 Towards motorized, who's actually paying for it. So if we could find a way to do that, I'd like to see it. It's something we have asked for in the past. And for some reason, it's just not getting heard. And so I thank you for addressing that. And that concludes my program. And thanks again for the opportunity.

1:15:09 The committee thanks you as well for your support. Just one more comment is I know that rather than saying that this council is going to direct MLTSCC to add that, I would suggest that you ask them to consider it because I know that the Forest Service has some specific concerns that need to be included and if we're talking about increasing our communication with them, trying to on our very first day then say, no, we just want this thing, I think it's safe. Send it to them for further study.

1:15:38 I think we've done that. You know, we keep asking them for it, and it's not convenient for them. I think it's more than just not convenient. Well, you know, we had a staging area there before, and that got pushed back, and now they're pushing it back further, and it's advocacy groups that are pushing it out of there. And I just, I'm tired of the excuses.

1:15:58 Those are our forests, too. We should be able to use them, and we've been able to use them in the past, and they're pushing business out of this community. The reason I'm suggesting, Matthew, that it go back for consideration is because the impacts of the ORMAT could ruin that area's recreation, and so maybe what you want to say is where can people from town immediately start snowmobiling and not necessarily look just at that area?

1:16:23 You and I went through that whole thing. We were talking about if they put all those pipelines in, nobody's going to want a snowmobile in that area. So why would you set up a short-term process if they're going to put in pipelines for 18 wells, 16 wells? So I would say that you send it back as a request to look at the other options because it may turn out that the options are in a different area that's accessed directly from town. Those pipelines represent way less than 10% of the area.

1:16:50 It would be snowmobiling. Anyway, we shouldn't be discussing this at this time. It's a report, not a debate. Yeah, exactly. Town attorney is looking at me. What we hear is what we've heard for a long, long time, including as long as I've been on this council and before, and it goes. It's not resolved yet, but...

1:17:13 I'll have some thoughts at a point in time about how we address that issue as well. Steve, thank you. Are there any questions, Council? Just thank you, Steve, and what you're doing, what you've done. Great job, and I'm really happy with it. Thank you. You're very welcome. Thanks, Steve. All right. It takes us to Consent Agenda Items 2 through 6. Any Councilmember wish to pull any out? Mr. Mayor, I'll move for approval of Consent Agenda Items. Second.

1:17:43 Okay, there's been a motion and a second to approve items 2 through 6. Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number 7, which is a public hearing. This is a little different from other public hearings in that the law requires that

1:18:06 I'd be very specific about what it is that I say during this public hearing, and so the staff has given me a script, and I'm going to try to follow it. So, the starting point, and I have two scripts, I think. The starting point is we open public hearing, which I will do, and make the following remarks. This is the time and place for the public hearing.

1:18:37 The town of Mammoth Lakes Community Facilities District Number 2013-3, Transit Services Annexation Number 1. The hearing is to inquire into the annexation of property into the district and the levy of special taxes for townwide transit services within or adjacent to the district. It then says, before I formally open the hearing, which I think I already did, are there any property owners or registered voters in the district?

1:19:06 Or territory to be annexed who wish to file written protests. Seeing none, first of all, if so, they must be filed with the clerk now. Seeing none, the hearing is now going to be declared open. We will first have presentation by staff about the annexation of territory to the district. After that, we will receive comments and questions and any oral protests from any interested persons. When all comments have been received, the hearing will be closed.

1:19:36 So I will turn it over to staff. Peter. Mayor Wood, council members. Staff recommends that the council conduct a public hearing for the annexation of certain properties within the CFD 2013-3. Annexation number one, conduct a special election and adopt an ordinance authorizing the levy of special taxes in the community facilities district pursuant to the Belarus Community Facilities Act of 1982 and a levy.

1:20:07 A special tax in connection therewith. With that, you have the overall procedure. Essentially, this facility's district was adopted last year beginning with the Altus Project. The current tax rate was set at $1.55.77 per unit, and these are for transient units only, not for resident non-transient type units.

1:20:40 This particular annexation is for the Stonegate project, which is a project in the South Valley, Sierra Star, Moat Star Master Plan area, and the Altus project, which is a map that is converting some of the fractional units into whole ownership units, but they're still available for transit use, and so they would be a part of this district.

1:21:08 With that, I think we have received at least one ballot from the property owners, and if Council has any other questions, I'd be happy to provide those, otherwise we can move on with the remainder of the public hearing. I'd just like to clarify the location of the properties. You have Sid Stonegate and Altus, is it? No, Altus was the first property within the assessment district, or the CFD special district.

1:21:40 And this public hearing is to annex two additional projects that have several properties within their boundaries. But one of them is the Stoagate Project, and that's the single-family units in the resort area at the golf course that John Hooper is constructing. And the other is the Tallis Project, I'm sorry.

1:22:08 Which is converting several of the units, fractional units, to whole ownership from the fractional use. And I think Stonegate's actually an existing condominium project. So this would be Greystone. I mean Greystone, I'm sorry. So it's Greystone and Talos, right? Yeah, I apologize for that. Too many, too many. Got it. So it's Greystone and Talos. Being added to Altus. As shown on Exhibit A.

1:22:37 Graystone. Yeah. So Exhibit A identifies both projects on that same map. The smallest type imaginable. Yeah, so if you look at the cross streets on the left, it's Minaret Road, Bear Lake Road, and Sierra Star Parkway, bound, that's the Graystone Parkway, the Hooper Project, and then the

1:23:03 The other one is the full boundary of the TALUS project, but it's just the highlighted parcels that are included within the district. And those are the existing units? Those are the existing units, some of which are complete and some of which are under construction. Understood. And are you going on, or is that enough? Is there any other questions? I think that covers the overall project. I don't believe I see any of the property owners here. We do have a ballot.

1:23:39 The ballot process just requires that two-thirds of the cast ballots be in favor of the district, not that everybody has to cast a ballot. Peter, it wasn't really clear in here, but what exactly does this $155.77 per unit per year cover? What does that provide?

1:24:05 What does the tax provide back as a service? So this goes for enhancing additional service from the time of the formation of the district. And essentially, we previously were collecting this through an agreement with the associations, Elmore's associations. And this program actually is a better program. It basically collects them through their taxes. It provides that same support level. It's about a little over nearly $100,000 a year.

1:24:34 Towards the transit service. But it's specifically for enhanced transit. It's not to basically supplant existing services that we're providing. So as the program goes forward in the original engineer's report that, you know, at some point may need to be amended if we get a significant increase in transiting units. But it provided for up to a million dollars in additional funding for transit. And now it's based on an assumption of about half the available units being built.

1:25:04 Okay, and then so through the budget process each year, these funds are then allocated to ESSA or something else that's considered a transit service? Correct. So each year going forward, you'll see an item in the budget for this specific assessment district that will show where those funds will be spent. Peter, I've got a question. Because it just isn't clear to me, is this $155?

1:25:34 Per unit, and you're going to raise $100,000 and $155 each? Well, so currently we're using the other method, that's about what we're doing. So going forward, we're putting new transient properties would be within this district, not having agreements with the homeowners associations. Right. But I don't see how...

1:26:00 800 units. So over time, so we have currently enough units that create, so I don't actually have the number, but I guess I could do the math. We have, we're collecting about $100,000 from HOAs that go towards transit service currently. The only project that's within this district currently is the Altus project, and that doesn't have any properties.

1:26:26 This year that are actually being assessed because they don't have completed construction of a building permit. So the $95,000 that's mentioned of financial considerations is not just from this community facilities district. It's other funds as well. It's from that other funding source, which is both of these are really mitigations from the general plan that indicated that there's an impact to transit from transient occupancies.

1:26:56 And so we're fulfilling that mitigation through payment of these fees and then providing transit service for those properties. So the bottom line for me is that is what is proposed going to generate about the same amount of money as is being generated now? Yeah, so each property would be assessed as soon as they have an occupancy permit.

1:27:23 But the way assessments really work is that you do it in June, July. We have to have the assessment rules to the county generally by about the 12th of August. So properties that are, so the occupancy is in December, they wouldn't actually pay the tax until the following year. But each property that actually has a final occupancy permit, that's the trigger that puts them, that actually puts them into an assessment role of the district.

1:27:53 In the original engineer's report that was provided for the Altus project when we initially initiated this particular special district, I believe, if my memory is correct, the assumption was about half of the properties that were available with our current density would be put into transit service, say, over the next 20 years.

1:28:17 And that would raise over a million dollars for future transit service. So with that, we'd be able to expand transit, have the purple line that goes up Minaret Road from Snow Creek development and many other routes that are within our current master plan. Does that help? So right now there's no money. It helps, but it doesn't answer. It still doesn't. So right now there is no properties within the district that are being assessed. So the income is zero. Okay. With this district,

1:28:47 There are actually all of these units we expect to have an occupancy permit by the end of say the middle of July. And so all of these properties would be assessed next year and would be paying the $155.77. I see. Okay. Peter, you just said zero. So Solstice and a lot of the other condos that are there, are they? But they're paying through the other previous method with the HOA. Through the HOA? Yeah. And we're not.

1:29:17 We're not proposing to convert everybody over to the district. We're really moving forward. We're using this mechanism to fulfill the mitigation requirement for transit services. Peter, you've actually got two different dollar figures. On page three it says 155.77, and on page four it says 157.45 in the third paragraph under financial considerations. Yeah, so when it was originally formed, the 155.77 was the amount.

1:29:49 And it would increase with the CPI each year up to 2%. Oh, okay. And that's the other number. And timing-wise, so the new ones will come into it and then everybody's at the higher level. Right. And the HOAs have an automatic escalator as well that goes up each year with the CPI.

1:30:07 So the big difference is this is attached to their property tax bill as opposed to it being some kind of a part of a common area assessment or something that HOA has. Yeah. It's not necessarily deductible to. So from the standpoint of a tax deduction, this is actually a tax versus the other one is an assessment. Okay. Thank you. Other questions first of staff?

1:30:32 If not, are there questions, comments, or oral protests from members of the public? Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing and have to read this. The hearing is closed. We may now consider and adopt the resolution authorizing the annexation of territory into a community facilities district, authorizing the levy of a special tax, and submitting the levy of a special tax to qualified electors.

1:31:03 Now is the time for Council to consider the adoption of the resolution that is attached to the agenda bill. That's on page 14, 14 and 15. Oh, no, but is that the part here that's called first order of business? I don't have that in my script. I'm just reading it. Okay.

1:31:32 My understanding is that if the procedure for us to adopt the resolution and then following that announce the results of the property owner vote? Correct. Okay. So what the resolution does is basically formally adopts the boundaries of the annex properties and then

1:32:07 And then there'll be the property vote, which will be read, and if there's two-thirds of the property votes in favor of the district, then it can be adopted. Okay, so if I understand it correctly, if I now make a motion that we adopt the resolution establishing the annexation number one of community facilities district number

1:32:28 2-0-1-3-3 and adopt the resolution calling a special election of annexation number one for the community facilities district number 2-0-1-3-3. Correct. Is there a second to that motion? Second. All right. The motion is second. Further discussion by council. I don't see anybody who wants to speak up. Jamie, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

1:32:54 Next, will the clerk please announce the result of the property owner vote. And the winner is... The envelope, please. So the Greystone developers voted in favor. They voted yes. And that's worth... They have three votes. They have three votes. Correct.

1:33:18 How many does the other half? Do we know? Those are the ballots that were received, so those are the only ones that count, and it needs to be two-thirds of the votes that count that are received. Oh, that are received? Correct. Okay, so they didn't send them their votes. Correct. Got it. And I did try to call them and email them today to see where their ballots were in response. Okay. Okay. The clerk having announced the results, the record shows that at least two-thirds, in fact, 100%,

1:33:48 The property owner votes are in favor of the annexation of territory and levy of the special tax. We may now proceed with the final actions for the annexation of territory to the district. The first is to adopt a resolution as stated. So let me try this again. I move that we adopt a resolution declaring results of a special landowner election and directing the recording of a special tax lien.

1:34:14 And further, that we waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance authorizing the levy of special taxations in annexation number one of community facilities district number 2013-3. Andy, can those be combined into one action? Or do I need to separate them? They can be combined. I'll second the motion. All right. There's been a motion and a section to second to adopt that resolution and also waive the reading.

1:34:43 And introduce by title only an ordinance. There's no further discussion. I don't see anybody. Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. It seems very cumbersome, but those are the legal requirements that we have to comply with. And so we have. All right. That concludes agenda item number 7, the public hearing. That takes us to policy matters. First one is number 8.

1:35:11 Approved, which is entitled, Approve the 2014 Youth Sports Funding Distribution as Recommended by the Recreation Commission. Stu, you're going to lead on that? Yes, thank you, Mayor. So this evening I am presenting this agenda bill and the recommended action on behalf of Stephanie Daniel, Recreation Supervisor, who as you know lives, breathes and eats youth sports.

1:35:38 She was unable to be here, so I'm just going to present on her behalf. So each year, the Recreation Commission has the pleasure of recommending general fund monies to our hardworking and extremely valuable youth sporting organisations. On April 8th, the Recreation Commission received presentations from eight funding applicants. They then affirmed their eligibility for funding.

1:36:04 And conducted a competitive review and recommendation process. The table on page 2 of 5 of your agenda bill identifies the amount of funds awarded in 2013 for the applications, for the applicants, and what the funding applicants requested in 2014. By motion, the Recreation Commission unanimously approved the youth sports funding recommendations as identified in attachment A. And for the benefit of the community and for council, I'll just read those to you this evening.

1:36:36 Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra was recommended to be funded $2,000. Eastern Sierra Nordic Ski Association, which is a new applicant, received recommendation for $700. Mammoth AOISO Soccer, $7,000. Mammoth Lake Swim Team, $3,400. Mammoth Youth Football, $5,000. Mammoth Youth Hockey, which is again a new organisation, is $1,200.

1:37:03 Monmouth County Little League, $3,700, and the Husky Club, $6,000. And that funding recommendation equals $28,800, which is the budgeted amount for this line item. So therefore, staff is recommending that the Town Council recognise the valuable service that these youth sport funding organisations provide our community and unanimously approve the funding recommendations as presented by the Recreation Commission on April 8, 2014.

1:37:34 Stuart, thank you. Questions? Stuart, the commission voted unanimously for these recommendations. Was there any public participation during this process? Yes. So thank you, Councilor Eastman. So this year the commission opened the floor up and received a pretty lengthy, comprehensive presentation from each of the applicants. And it really goes to show

1:38:03 How valuable they are, how much they provide the community with very little. You can see the numbers here. I mean, there's 1,252 participants. You know, we're only funding about $28,000, but they provide an immense amount of value to the community and certainly augment what the Recreation Department provides. We're really unable to provide, you know, in a far greater detail. So they received very lengthy presentations. They even had a little...

1:38:33 Show and tell going on as well, which is well received. So it was a good process. I think it was very difficult for the commission this year because you can see there was just under $43,000 of applications. And in the past it was roughly about $35,000. And I think you could probably talk to a lot of the commissioners and they can really see that funding is really needed to keep these organisations going and sustainable in the future because they really do struggle. They're all competing with each other in the community for funding, not just

1:39:02 These organizations, but against a lot of larger non-profit organizations in the community. So this group alone, I know they're very active. They work really well together. We partner with them as best we can. But funding is very hard to come by, and they're very much reliant upon this funding provided by the town. So I know they're very eager to get these funds and get these programs rolling. So very good question. Thank you. Thank you. The only comment I have is

1:39:33 I'd like to see this increase in time. I mean, do the math on, just picking the number on AYSO, it's 550 kids, it's 12 bucks a child. I mean, it's not very much money. Need a good snowfall litter. I just, I hope that this is something that we could, you know, rebuild back. We all do. Get some more money to these kids. Comments, questions from the public?

1:40:06 All right, council discussion. I couldn't agree with you before, Mike. I have said this from the dais before, that it's really easy for council members to do because handing out money is sort of fun, especially for these things, especially for kids. But a long time ago when I was on what was then the Recreation Commission,

1:40:30 We had much less money to work with than we do now, although with inflation, I don't know, but it was really less. I recall how difficult it was because every one of these applicants that comes forward...

1:40:43 He is coming forward with something that improves and provides additional incremental value to the quality of life of the community as a whole as well as the individuals who participate. So it was always hard. There were really hard things for the commission to do. And they still take it really seriously, as they should, and come up with a recommendation. And because it's unanimous, it makes our job easy. They haven't done work. So those are my comments. Yeah.

1:41:10 AYSO's got to be like every kid. Amazing. All right. Sure. Coming forward to the podium, please. I have a tiny question. Stu, just thinking of the Nordic Ski, why were they funded less than the hockey? Do you think that as new?

1:41:39 Organizations, they both get $1,000. Yeah, so they looked at actually, they got really specific, there were some good questions, thanks Ted, there were some good questions regarding those two applications, they're very new, the commission really strives to fund new organizations, which is very admirable, you want to kind of get them going, get them off the ground. So the $700 was actually, I believe, two summer Nordic skates, so they funded them to their request of what they requested, if that makes sense.

1:42:08 That program really only wanted two summer skates. It was two or four, I believe. And then the youth hockey program received $1,200 because that was the cost when they were looking at providing X amount of equipment for X amount of kids. That was the number that they requested. So you can see they requested considerably more, but the commission really asked the questions about what would you really need and what do you need to get this program off the ground and running. So that was...

1:42:37 That was an answer for that question. So it wasn't just an arbitrary number. They didn't just spit the difference. They really got down to really what those organizations needed. Thank you. Other questions or comments from the public? If not, anything, a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'll make an option. Council approve option one to approve the 2014 youth sports funding distribution as recommended by the Recreation Commission in attachment A. I'll second. All right. A motion and a second. Jamie, please. Yes.

1:43:08 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to... Thank you. Agenda Item 9. Thanks, Stu. Mr. Mayor, before we go into this one, I need to let my fellow council members and the public know that I am recused on this item because I sit on the Board of Friends of the Inyo and that particular agreement is being discussed tonight.

1:43:34 However, I'd also like to let you know that I am a little concerned that there are so many other important issues that have been bundled into one agenda bill that therefore I don't get to have any comment on. So with that, I will leave the dais. And John's already left the dais. Where'd he go? When he comes back, or while he's coming back, I'm going to read.

1:44:01 I'm going to read the title of the matter that's before us, which is Review and Approve the Recommended Actions Regarding the Mammoth Lakes Trails System Coordinating Committee's 2014-15 Budget Recommendations and Update of the Mammoth Lakes Trails System Coordinating Committee Work. And following Jo's comments, which she...

1:44:29 I want to have a discussion with Council as to whether we might reach consensus on what we might have a discussion about tonight. And the reason that I want to do that is that, frankly,

1:44:54 There are four matters that are before us, and she is conflicted on one of them, which necessarily conflicts her on the other three, which she otherwise wouldn't be conflicted on if we had the three. In light of her involvement in trails, in light of her commitment to this part of recreation in our community, frankly, I really want to have her participation.

1:45:22 And the only way that we do that, I think there are two, is to limit our discussion to the agenda item number two, or not agenda item, but the item number two of the four that's on page one of the agenda bill, and defer items one, three, and four to our next meeting on May 21, which would then allow her to participate because the conflict would be gone.

1:45:52 Put the whole thing off and she will be conflicted again. I don't like number two. Or I guess number three is to consider the whole thing at once. And so having stated my concern and preference, I'm wondering what other councils might think about taking up only a portion of this agenda bill, which is the part that she is conflicted on. I'm agreeable to that if it's legal.

1:46:21 Yeah, I would too. I think Joe clearly has a concern here, and obviously she's passionate about this area. Also, when I was reading this, there's so much great work that went into it, and I remember when we asked him to come up with this some time ago, my only concern is we have so many, it seems like we have a couple balls in the air with regard to recreation.

1:46:50 You know, on one hand, we've asked them to do this. On another hand, we've asked our new funds to be tabled. And on another hand, we've got MLR being formed. And I think that's coming before us the next 21st? Yes. And I'm just wondering, maybe it's a hybrid of the two. We ask this to be tabled until the next meeting and then ask that that one particular item be separated from here so Joe can at least weigh in on the rest of the items.

1:47:21 I don't know what thoughts are there. I think Steve has some thoughts. I do. If I understand what Joe's concern is, item number one here, which would be to approve our budget and master tracking that I have up on the screen, there is funding within there for Friends of the Inyo. There's also funding in there for MLTPA and also the funding for needed to get our summer of stewardship programs.

1:47:52 Implemented for this year. We have media buys that need to be made, so the commitments from the council will be helpful in putting that together. We have advertising that goes out, brochures, pamphlets, and so forth. So as far as organizationally, I think it's very important that the council vote on this tonight, and Jo would be conflicted with this no matter when you voted on it because she is a member.

1:48:21 of the board of Friends of the Inyo. The second part also then is that Friends of the Inyo Trails Day that I was talking about and stewardship. So she will continue to be conflicted with 2A and B. Three is having to do again with Trails Days and with Friends of the Inyo. Let me double check here.

1:48:51 Developing those agreements. Yeah, it's, and, so this is, again, I'm afraid she'll be conflicted with that no matter when you vote on it, but the item number four is one that she would not be conflicted on, and I still think that she can participate with that in giving us direction as to move forward with a relationship with

1:49:14 The Forest Service to establish either a cost share agreement, MOU or whatever, the special use permit or combination so that we can formulate agreements in the future. So again, I'd like to advocate for moving forward with the council on these items. And again, they are continuations of programs that have been established over the years. They're well documented and there is a need, I think, to move in a timely fashion. So thank you very much for considering that, Mayor.

1:49:43 So my thought to continue, my own thought is, first of all, it's not for me to determine whether she has a conflict, it's for her and Lieutenant Turner to determine if she has a conflict on a specific item. Notwithstanding, Steve, I respect your view of your conclusion, but I don't know what it's based upon. What I understand from my reading of this...

1:50:10 is that what's critical tonight is number two, at least in terms of time. And so as a collateral and additional issue for me personally in determining how we go forward and on what, my view is that we have an entity that

1:50:38 On its face doesn't recognize that we have another process in play. Now that this council is approved, there's an indication in the agenda bill on page two that the proposed action does not relate to any town council priorities, but it does relate to my priority, which is recreation in this community. How we fund it, how we organize it, how we manage it, how we administer it.

1:51:07 And so it seems it doesn't make a lot of sense to me for us to bifurcate this MLTSCC discussion from the MLR discussion. Not that they need to be combined into one agenda bill, but certainly as part of the recreation discussion, it seems to me they go together. However, I'm sensitive to...

1:51:34 Number two, which is that we've got these things that have been in place, and as Steve has mentioned, we've got these media buys and so on, a program that has worked in the past, a program that apparently has been, it is successful. We've proven that, and in my mind is something that is, you know, ripe for discussion now. So I don't want to get into the merits or the substance of it yet. What I'm really trying to focus on is

1:52:02 Whether or not the Council wants to go forward with all of this in Joe's absence, whether it wants to go forward with none of it, but go forward with it in her absence at a future date, meaning next meeting, or whether it wants to take out a piece of it and discuss item number two and consider either adopting or not a resolution that would authorize what's requested in number two.

1:52:30 One, three, and four can come back in two weeks, right? The same time that we have the MLR discussion. That's what I think after reading this. Yeah, I do too. I'm supportive of just addressing number two. Number two. I agree. All right, so what I'm hearing is just what we've heard, which is that we're going to take on agenda item number two. Steve, I don't know how that impacts your presentation, but Peter, I don't know how that impacts your presentation, but...

1:52:59 What I'm hearing is that we're going to take on a part of this agenda bill. That part is the part that Joe has declared a conflict on. Correct. And I might point out that maybe we also consider part of number one, which is the funding sources related to number two. So that would be items Project 511, 472, New Project 551, and 321 on page three.

1:53:33 Page 16, I believe, of your packet. 316. 16. So if you look at page 16 of your packet, it's the top four items that the funding goes along with those projects. Can you restate that again on page 16? So on page 16, code number, project.

1:54:05 511, 472, 551, and 321. So it's the $12,675, the $17,143, the $32,504, and the $20,000 for the winter snow grooming, kind of affected with agreements related to Friends of the Inyo. Uh-huh, I see. Okay.

1:54:32 So your suggestion is that that portion of number one that is required to implement or to fund number two be discussed as well? Correct. Okay. Staff reports. So we can abbreviate much of this. And Steve did a great job of reviewing the projects. What this staff report really intended to do was to kind of memorialize all the work that's been done over the last year in pretty much in detail.

1:55:05 For the projects, the project list, where the status of the projects are, and what projects are looking to fund in the coming year. There are several recommendations, and we'll just be looking at the first two. One of the, so the funding related to items 2A and 2B, and not discussed 3 and 4. For the, as far as the council priorities,

1:55:33 These are really the priorities that the council set at the beginning of the year, which were infrastructure, the three categories, not necessarily that it wasn't a council priority at all. But as we state, planning, constructing, and maintaining a trail system is certainly a council priority in general as well as a community priority. So it wasn't an attempt to say that it wasn't a priority. I see. Thank you. And this program certainly is consistent with our general plan.

1:56:03 General plan M4B1 and M4BD2, which is really to maintain and facilitate a bike system and a pedestrian system throughout the community for access and circulation for the community and users to basically reduce the impacts of automobiles. As far as the specific projects, Steve can talk.

1:56:33 And so with this

1:57:03 We'll be aligning those two, basically bringing the MLT outreach portion within the Friends of the Inyo agreement so that they coordinate, cooperate with each other and it makes it a tighter package as far as organizing and facilitate those drill days. The other component is an amendment just really to continue the existing program. It certainly does expand it slightly.

1:57:30 But it's that outreach that Steve mentioned earlier in the presentation. So longer term, neither one of those agreements really interact with the Forest Service. They actually own the trails, manage the trails. And so some type of other agreement is what we're really talking about is to make that ongoing change so that the town's involved with the management, not necessarily the ownership, but the management of the trail system.

1:57:59 The MOU talks about cooperation. We need to get into who's managing it. A use permit is problematic because I don't know that we really want to own the liability of the soft surface. We have use permits for hard surface trails. We certainly maintain them in accordance with applied standards. We've got lots of equipment to do that. And we're responsible and we take on the maintenance and the liability of maintaining those facilities. But I'm not sure that we want that for the soft surface system.

1:58:29 Forest Service has made it clear, at least at a staff level, that they look at these two projects kind of as that commitment with the town which would allow us to construct new facilities that are maybe soft surface on the forest that would be maintained through some similar program as these. So with that, Steve might want to add a few more things, but those are the two, really the 1 and 2A components of the...

1:58:59 There's a lot of other information in the report itself that we can talk about at the next meeting or we can talk about it now. Steve. Yeah, again, I'd like to reiterate the soft surface trail maintenance program here, Trails Days. This is our identifier number 511. That's the name of the project there and then a descriptor. And this is all part of what I mentioned earlier on, how we go through our master tracking list.

1:59:29 So we have our bucket or priority numbers here. We have funding carried over from previous years. We have approved funding from last fiscal year. We have available funds for this particular coming up fiscal year. This is the recommendation from the trails committee as well as the recreation commission for suggested funding for council to approve. Then this column provides us with...

1:59:57 Additional knowing what all the funding will be for those various items that we carry forward. So in this particular one we are talking about an ongoing program. You can see we have a little bit of cost increase from the town's participation from Friends of the Inyo. This is a five event proposal. One of the things that we're getting to with Friends of the Inyo is these are not all the monies that come for that program. This is just our participation in it.

2:00:26 So we feel we're getting a lot of value for our money. And the Friends of the Union have reported back to the committee that the popularity is ever increasing. So we're finding this to be a very, very successful program. The laser is dying. All right. Steve, if I can ask you on that, on 5-11. Yes, sir.

2:00:58 The $5,000 proposal is reduced a little bit. Is there a reason for that? Because you say the available funding is $17,143. I assume all this comes out of the $300,000 that we committed each year for trails? That's correct. When you look at the bottom here, you'll see the $300,000. So all of these tally up to the $300,000. So one of the things that we had a concern with here for the MLTPA and the difference in the funding was that

2:01:25 The committee is looking to be as cost effective as they can and in many areas as they can. So one of the things that came out of this was a reduction of T-shirts not included, hats not included, banners not included, and as part of the original budget, we looked at about a 10% contingency to handle if there was increases in media and so forth that would cost over time.

2:01:51 So the committee asked then the non-profit MLTPA to go out to the community and maybe go to retailers and ask them for a sponsorship so that they could participate as well and maybe those retailers would be kind enough to buy hats, t-shirts, banners, and so forth. So that's the difference in the funding that was approved last year. I see. You can see it was all spent. It was on target, on budget.

2:02:19 And then this is for, I'm sorry, this is for this next fiscal year for those five events. Great, thanks for that. So the stewards program is the next item here. Again, what we're looking for is that there is increased popularity. There was a lot of negotiation over three different meetings as to how to come to an appropriate budget figure for those services.

2:02:50 But you will see an increase, again, because of the popularity, because of the interpretive and so forth that we can add. So the committee and the recognition felt that that was an appropriate number for a 14-week program without advertising put into the proposal. So again, we're looking at ways to be cost-effective, ways of partnering, but also challenging the nonprofits to go out.

2:03:15 And do fundraising or go to corporate sponsors and so forth and have them participate in these programs. So the next one is winter grooming. I mentioned that earlier. This is a focus at the Shady Rest campground. In the past, as you may recall, I think the Mammoth Nordic came to the council requesting money. And at that time, I think it was $20,000 that was allocated from general fund money to cover that.

2:03:45 So last year, then in our $300,000 request, we asked you to approve, and you did, $20,000 to continue that program. So then when it became evident that we didn't have a provider for those services, we worked very closely with Friends of the Inyo to try and put together a program, and we were successful in doing that. So the $20,000 then...

2:04:13 was approved to go to Friends of the Inyo. The to be determined is that we hadn't received a final invoice for that work this winter yet. So you'll see that this number here is a little inconclusive, this one down here, and then it leads also to here. So what we're finding is that we didn't even spend half of that because of our low snow, but we are anticipating

2:04:42 A $20,000 program this year and that if additional funds are needed because we have more and more and more snow events, we can come back and use some of this unspent money to augment for this coming year which is going to be a banner snow year. Right. Didn't we just fund the snow grooming? That concludes then the discussion of those coming items. Okay.

2:05:12 And the fourth one is the Sherwin's Winter Egress. That's actually a separate program. These monies here were approved back in 2013-14. They're carried over. We're not asking for any more money. We feel we have sufficient funding to carry that program on. And as you may recall, it's working with the golf course to put up the signs and also make sure that the public's aware.

2:05:41 Of how to get across the golf course in the wintertime. Okay, I see. So the top item actually has two line items for the budget. The third one, 472, has the $32,000 and change. And the 551 is the winter grooming. I see. So we're not discussing the one below that. We're not discussing 321. Correct. And the winter grooming, you know, we'll be in discussions with Frenzenio as well as the Forest Service. It may be...

2:06:07 An agreement with the Forest Service kind of through their existing grooming program and maybe that's a way to tag on to be a little more efficient with that part. So that's something we have time to work on between now and when the need to groom itself. We just approved funding for winter grooming in the last agenda, didn't we? I think it was a few months ago. No, just literally like item number eight.

2:06:36 Well, that wasn't for grooming. Was it not? It was to buy some Nordic skis. It was best for the state program. Okay, I thought it was going to. Those were the summer skis for the club. Got it. A different club. The same thing, okay. Alrighty. All right, well, listen, thanks for that, because it's, I mean, this stuff is, it's hard to get through, but your explanation in lay terms is exactly what I needed.

2:07:06 Are there questions from Council of Staff, first of all? No. And members of the public, any questions, comments, anything anybody wants to say on this piece of this agenda bill? All right, well, if not, then I will make an action that we adopt the attached resolution, I'm sorry,

2:07:39 Looking at specifically number two on the first page. Yeah, there's no resolution, I don't think. And authorized staff to amend the agreement with the Friends of Inyo for the following agreements. A, Mammoth Trail Days, as indicated in the agenda bill, with the public outreach included, and B, summer stewardship program, amending the agreement that we have to increase the scope of work for the 14-15 summer, and also approve the budget.

2:08:07 Request in order to fund those projects. And just for clarification, apparently the option was not worded quite as clearly as it could have been. There is no resolution to adopt. So you're doing all that, just no resolution. Yeah, no resolution. Yeah, I apologize for that. 134 pages, I guess I missed it. Approve. Where's the same resolution? Do we need to identify the operations? Approve the MLPCC recommendations.

2:08:36 Recommend a project list and we're going to just do it for the first projects. Do I see resolution in the option one? Oh, that's right. Yeah, we didn't have a resolution. Authorized staff. So that would actually be amended with the budget resolution. So we'll have the amendments written and then they'd actually, for the budget, it would be included in the budget, the June budget resolution.

2:09:07 For the overall budget this year. All right. So my amended motion would be to amend the agreements as indicated in 2A and B. Correct. And to approve the recommended, the MLT, SEC, and Recreation Commission recommended project, funding for the projects identified on page 16 as 511, 472, and 551.

2:09:36 Correct. Does that accurately state what we've done? Okay. Yes. All right. Well, that's my amended motion. Is there a second? I'll second it. Okay. Seems easy, but it's hard to articulate. Any other discussion among counsel on this matter? If not, we'll call please. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:09:59 Yes, motion passes 4-0. Thank you. And we'll look forward to finishing this on the 21st. So, yeah, so for the 21st, we can bifurcate the information so we're not discussing the other item. Yeah, that'd be good. And if the council wants to provide direction related to the staging area, we can include that too, but we don't have that direction. I would like to add some direction to include that, if we would, please. I'm not seeing any objection to that. Yeah.

2:10:32 All right, that concludes number nine, takes us to number 10, consider changing the town council representative to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. That has been requested by Councilmember Lehman. Who's going to take the lead on that? I'll go ahead and do it. Basically, so Mammoth Lakes Tourism has some seats, as Terry identified previously.

2:10:56 Three seats coming available. One of them is a council member's seat. Another is a retail seat. Another is a restaurant seat. Another is an at-large seat. And contrary to what we have in here, I'm not stepping down from the appointed position. What I'm asking to be done is if we can consider making the change from the council member appointed position today, but to take effect once I get off of council.

2:11:25 So that would be June 18th or whatever that date is. Reason being, I want to allow Mammoth Lakes Tourism some time to basically notice these positions and try to get some people to fill the positions of restaurant retail. And if Michael were to come on, then he would be in that council position, which I would suggest since he's already on Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So basically I'm just asking that

2:11:54 Council tonight consider appointing a new council member to Mammoth Lakes Tourism seat to take effect June 18th. All right. Any other comments, questions, thoughts? Should we ask Michael? You're willing? Yeah. I've been already holding the restaurants seats. I know. I know. But it's always nice to ask. Is there a motion? Sure. Then I will. Go ahead. Public? Oh, sorry.

2:12:30 Members of the public, I wish to provide a comment on what's being proposed, which is to replace the council representation on the board now effective. Now effective when we would be doing it anyway. June 18th. But then giving MLT board a chance to advertise differently. Correct. I can speak to that if you'd like me to a little bit. Since Michael currently holds the restaurant seat and we need to...

2:12:59 Interview for these positions. It would definitely help us because then we know what positions we're interviewing for right now to get those seated by the end of June. So it would help us out. Thank you, Terry, for that. That makes sense. And I would agree that Michael is the likely or logical appointee, the next counsel around since he's got the experience.

2:13:22 Sure, I'll move that we appoint Michael Raimondo as the Town Council representative to the MLT board effective June 18th, 2014. Then all second promotion. Okay, motion a second local please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number 11 entitled Discuss Project

2:13:47 Budget Options for the Waterford Gap Multi-Use Path Project and Provide Direction on Funding for the 2014-15 Project Capital Budget. I'll announce that because I live within 500 feet of that project, I will recuse myself and I'll participate. Okay. And I'll turn it over to the mayor for a time. Okay. All right. Staff report, start us. So this item is to provide information for

2:14:17 Council to give staff direction related to funding of the overall Waterford Gap Closure Multi-Use Path Project that would be included in the 14 fiscal, 15 fiscal year budget that will be discussed in detail at the June meeting. This certainly is a project, it's not legally mandated, it's not a current year, one of the top three council priorities, but it

2:14:48 Overall, this facility has been a project that's been supported by council and a priority for council and the community as a whole. This project is also critical access, really the gap that we've had for many years that will close that gap and provide pedestrian access throughout, across the Waterford and the Mammoth Creek Corridor. In addition,

2:15:17 A little bit about the bike path itself. It'll be a 14-foot wide three-span bridge is what's being proposed. The majority of the repairing area and the habitat area around the creek will be spanned by two 120-foot bridges, which would be a 240-foot two-bridge span, which will really eliminate much of the impacts as far as mitigation go.

2:15:48 The project also includes a design that provides capability for egress vehicles during emergency situations. Essentially the bridges are being designed for an H-20 loading, which is standard highway loading for bridges or design loading for facilities within a street. It would provide that egress for the fire department.

2:16:17 To cross, but it also provides really egress for people living within either the bottom of Majestic Pines or the Old Mammoth Road area to cross and use this as an escape route if there's an emergency declared and either opened up by Public Works, Fire Department, or the Police Department. It would not normally be used by any vehicles other than maintenance vehicles.

2:16:47 In the environmental process and in discussions with the planning commission, that was an important feature within the project that was incorporated into the project and also incorporated into the grant request that we applied for and received. Town Council did approve submission of the bike BTA grant in April of 2012. Town was awarded the grant in the amount of $602,000 and the match was approved by measure R of $66,000.

2:17:17 Almost $67,000. Currently the design is complete and we've got two alternatives. One is the two span bridge with a third span to make the complete crossing of 14 foot wide structure connecting Waterford South with Waterford North and Lower Majestic Pines.

2:17:45 And the other alternative is to leave the existing wooden structure. I wouldn't call it a bridge, but it's really a wooden structure that crosses a small tributary on the north side of Waterford. In the packet, we've got plans that show each of the proposed projects.

2:18:17 They have some advantages, and obviously there's some disadvantages. One of them, a preferred option for engineering would be it costs more money. But essentially, the overall bridge project, including the additional 30-foot bridge which was spanned that last tributary, would provide the least amount of wetland disturbance and habitat disturbance within the overall construction of the project. It really provides the best solution to minimize those impacts, any impacts to the flood zone.

2:18:47 This area is a flood zone and so the bridge supports and those kinds of things or the ramps up and down within a bridge certainly could impact the overall water level in the flood area. The alignment also doesn't negatively impact the water district's two water lines and a sewer line within the alignment. It would replace the wooden structure that's currently next to

2:19:18 The Waterford North side of the street, the bottom of Majestic Pines. If you look out closely, it's certainly not a major safety problem, but it is really a need of replacement over time. It also provides that emergency address evacuation for the lower Majestic Pines and Old Mammoth area. And it really completes the overall town loop. So currently we've got a detour in the town loop that goes down Sherwin Street along Old Mammoth.

2:19:50 This facility will become that town loop, which will over, you know, in the next few years we update the overall maps to reflect that. The estimated cost for the additional 30-foot bridge in those connections is about $100,000, and so that would be the shortfall that we'd like to get direction to fulfill. Essentially, the two bridges, the double span, 240-foot crossing,

2:20:21 Is funded within the grant and the matches that we have currently. It would leave that section of path and bridge wooden structure in place. And it would increase the ramp area slightly, which impacts that flood area within the creek corridor. And certainly it would provide that connection for the town loop.

2:20:53 It's really not providing from an engineering standpoint the overall project needs, which would be to include the emergency egress as far as part of the project. You know, long term we do have a street planned through this area. I suspect the street won't be built in my lifetime or my kid's lifetime. So this could provide that connection that isn't really for normal vehicle use but for that time when there could be an emergency.

2:21:22 A fast-moving fire of that nature. With that, there are some sketches, exhibits within the packet. If there's questions about those, staff would open it up for questions or discussion with council. Questions of Peter? I have no questions of staff. Okay. I do have one, Peter. I'm looking at the options on page 8. Option 2, where it is to construct the project with a tube bridge alternative, leaves a gap still?

2:21:53 So we're only closing part of the gap? We are, the two-bridge option would be a 14-foot section with the new bridges. We would have a small section that would tie into the existing bike path where that wooden structure that needs to be replaced is located. Okay, so either option still completes what's been the gap for 10 years or so.

2:22:20 One option provided emergency access, the other one would not. Okay, the three-bridge project, which, if I understand, is being recommended because of the additional public safety issues. Correct, and it would replace that wooden structure that, like I said, it's really not a bridge, but it acts as a bridge. Okay. Because there's really a need of that. It's been overloaded at some point and is really sitting on the ground.

2:22:47 What's it cost to come back and do it? I mean, it's certainly more probably. Yeah, I would have guessed it would be more. We didn't analyze that, but it would be another $100,000 difference at least. It may be a little bit more than that because now we'd be doing the transitions twice. Then I have a question for Andy that I'm thinking of it as this is recommended that we bring something back in the budget hearings, but could we, if we did that,

2:23:18 Would that in some way, would Mayor Wood be somehow conflicted out of the whole budget hearing because of this one little item? It could be segmented. Okay. It could be that the budget item would be everything but this, and then separately there would be a budget item for this. Okay. Just as we could do with, you know, other council member conflicts. Okay. All right. Any questions or comments from the public?

2:23:48 Members of the Council, Brent Harper, Fire Chief, thank you for considering this, and I know it's gone through a lot of variations over the last eight, nine years. Obviously, we know that that Alexander area is a high fire danger. It's in a very high fire zone. Narrow streets, difficult for us to get to, difficult for people to get out to, out from, excuse me, but having one more access could be critical in a major fire in that area.

2:24:17 And I know funding is tough. Funding is tough for us also. But it's a great opportunity to get that project through, which has been kind of teetering back and forth for years. Glad to answer any questions. No. Well, of course, the obvious one. How do we pay for it? Yeah, you don't have $100,000. Obviously, you don't. No, I don't. In talking with Peter, he looked at some...

2:24:42 Different sources for that funding. Correct. And if that $100,000 could be split up, I'd be willing to go back to our commissioners, and, you know, that's above my pay grade for signing off that check, but they may be able to provide partial funding. Okay. Chief, the option with the three-bridge option, that's your preference as well, or do you care? The best option for us is that we can get some of our fire apparatus over that bridge.

2:25:09 And then also people can actually get vehicles out. Any other questions? Thank you, Chief. Thank you. Anyone else? Hi, Tim Flynn, resident and vice president of Contractors Association. From what I understand, so the reason for the kind of exorbitant amount of expense is because you've got to kind of span that wetlands.

2:25:43 Area there. And so that's correct. We're basically, you know, we either pay for mitigation at three to one or we try to minimize mitigation through, you know, good design practices to eliminate disturbance. So, you know, part of the discussion, and we looked at several different options during the design process, really the best option that really minimized are mitigation costs.

2:26:12 Which this will have some mitigation, but not hopefully, you know, it's not really that significant versus just a trail going through the wetland area. This provides that really that minimized impact to the wetland, the creek area, keeps us completely out of the creek area. And then it provides that emergency access ability to utilize this facility for those uses as well. But the cost of

2:26:41 Going through a creek corridor such as this really has a, does it cost more than you would normally have for a road out through, say, the desert or the forest? No, and I mean I would like to speak in favor of this because I do ride my bike with my child in the bike trailer and making that connection from the athletic club path to now, right now we go to Sherwin Street is to access the trail system.

2:27:08 You know, you have to go on to Old Mammoth Road, which has no shoulder, and is, you know, it's, you've got people, yeah, it's yikes. Exactly. And so, I think that as, you know, as a resident, I would be in favor of that, and I did speak with the fire department, and they explained the need for those residents on the, that Monterey Pines, I believe it is, or Majestic? I'd like to say, well, that Ministries Pines and Alexander.

2:27:39 Yeah. Both of those areas. Those areas are pretty isolated there, and so it makes sense. I always thought that that should almost just be like a road across there, but I know that that's wetlands, I mean, and that could increase property values. It used to actually be a dirt road. There used to be a dirt road through that creek corridor. Right. Right. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Thanks, Tim. Any other comments from the public?

2:28:08 Okay. I bring it back for discussion. And I do have a few points, so I don't know who wants to go first, though. It's just interesting. I've got to make a comment since Peter mentioned it. It used to be a road. And there used to not be bridges. You just drive through both creeks. Yeah. Can't do that today, can you? Can't do that today. Okay. I believe that was a mitigation when we built Creek Street.

2:28:37 Yeah. We had to block it off. Yeah, the only comments I have, I mean, obviously I'd like to see three bridges there, but for me it's just kind of the same issue we've been coming down to the last four years and it's finances. I'd be supportive of the three bridges if we could come up with an alternative funding source, maybe outside of our current means, but I think until we have the funding for it, I'd be in favor of the two bridge.

2:29:07 Okay. John, any input?

2:29:37 That it's a public safety issue. We're clearing, thanks to the Forest Service, thanks to the Fire Department and others, we're clearing defensible space around our communities, and yet the town has that one landlocked area in this area that we're talking about with dense, dense forest. And so I think that there's a responsibility on the town's part to

2:30:07 At least create a safer situation for the people in that area. I'm supportive of funding this at this time and finding funding for that additional cost and going with the three bridge proposal with the caveat that staff has an opportunity to communicate with the fire department and see what their capabilities might be.

2:30:35 Share the sharing of that final $100,000. And I agree with all those comments. What I wanted to do was take Measure R funds as an option totally off the table. Measure R has already made a commitment towards this project for the recreational part, and I don't think we'd be anywhere near meeting the ordinance to use Measure R for the public safety part. But I totally agree that we need to find it, and in fact...

2:31:00 I had asked staff to look at whether or not the REU or another funding source would be available, so I'd like to see those options come forward, but I'd like to see if there's consensus to say no to having it be Measure R. I respect what you're saying, Jo. I agree. Okay. And there is, in the financial section, there is information about what the REU balance is. Correct. And there is also the road fund that...

2:31:24 It's expecting them about a $200,000 balance. Yeah, I think this is an opportunity that if we can do it, we need to pull it together. Definitely, definitely. And when we get down to it, it would be nice to know if there can be a partial commitment from the fire department. That would be great because we already know we're heading into another tight budget year. Do we get that to come back? No, it would come back as part of the budget package. Part of the budget process. And so we've got your good direction not to use it.

2:31:53 Not to touch the measure, you measure our funding. With a also directing staff to work with the fire department to see what funding can come from that source. We'll do that. This is one of the things I get asked about in the community. So when are we getting rid of the Waterford Gap? Constantly. So I'd like to see it done. Okay. Thank you. With that, we'll wait for Rick to come back and we can go on to the next agenda item.

2:32:40 Okay. Thank you. Number 12, waive the reading and introduce by title only in ordinance amending chapter 8.30 and chapter 15.04 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code related to replacement of non-certified solid fuel burning appliances and wood stove inserts. Steve. Thank you, Mayor Wood and Mayor Pro Tem Bacon and council members.

2:33:12 Let me say this is my first time presenting an agenda bill before this council, so I apologize in advance for any lapses in etiquette on my part. And I appreciate the comments by Councilmember Eastman at the beginning of the session. Much appreciated. So this is an agenda bill. It's a proposed amendment to 8.30 particular admissions regulations in Chapter 15.04.

2:33:42 The California Mechanical Code related to use, limitations, and replacement of non-certified solid fuel burning appliances and wood stove inserts. And the primary issue addressed is the time limit for submitting, well, previously, currently is the time limit for completing the project and the proposed amendment.

2:34:12 Is proposing to have a – take the 60-day time limit to have the project completed. Instead, it would be a 60-day time limit to have the building permit submitted only. And there is a provision for a 30-day extension, too, at the request of the applicant, if that should be needed. And there's some other miscellaneous items, but that's the primary purpose of this proposed amendment.

2:34:42 I need the USA Today approach. So right now, what are the time limits? Right now, if the buyer chooses to take responsibility for replacing the wood stove with an EPA Phase II compliant stove, there's a 60-day deadline to have it completed and finaled, installed and finished. This proposes to have a 60-day time limit just to submit the application for a permit. And then what's the timeline to have it completed?

2:35:10 From that point on, it's just like any other building permit. Yeah, that's what it is. How many days? The California Building Code administrative chapter states that you have 180 days. A building permit cannot go more than 180 days without any work being done or it's considered abandoned and it's expired. So basically they have 180 days to get the project started. Just like with any other building permit, they can request an extension for that too with justifiable cause in writing.

2:35:39 And when do they have to have it completed? Isn't it like a couple years out? No, 180 days. Well, they had 180 days to start. I'm wondering when it is then they have to complete it. Two years? Well, the standard building permit, there is a, the Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code has a provision that's outside of the standard California building code for

2:36:07 Allowing extensions due to weather, but that really wouldn't apply to this because these are primarily interior unless they were replacing a chimney and a flue or something like that. So typically a building permit can go no more than 180 days without any work and then overall it would be two years before it would be expired unless they get the extension for weather provisions.

2:36:34 So that changes it from what was a very short time to up to two years? Yes, and from what I understand, the concern was that some of these projects involve not just replacing the wood stove, but a larger remodeling project, and sometimes it goes into quite a lengthy ordeal. Yet we were doing this because of the issue of the potential for fires.

2:37:02 Did this go back to your appeals body, which I can't remember their name, you know, the ones we just interviewed? Did this go back to them for review with these changes? This was primarily the Board of Realtors that we were meeting with as a stakeholder group. It did not go before the Board of Appeals, no. And if we currently have...

2:37:27 How can we have 60 days to comply if the California Building Code allows 180 days after you file your permit? I'll take this one, Steve. The difference is that we can establish a shorter period for compliance, even though the building permit by itself might last longer, we can still say you've got to get it done within 60 days. Okay, so in theory, if we allowed 60 days to file a permit, we could limit it to 180 days for compliance as well? We could. Okay. I'd be more comfortable with that within two years. Okay.

2:37:58 And then another question I had, because it's come up from members of the Board of Realtors, we have our fines that are imposed. There's something like $100 the first day, $200 the second, and day three and beyond, $500 a day for noncompliance. And there's been a request, and I wanted to, Andy, get your input on...

2:38:26 Could Council make a decision to bring that figure into something like $100 a day or $100 a month as has been proposed by that group? Sure. Council could do anything it likes just about with the fees and penalties. Okay. And so I think, and maybe we can hear from some of the members of the public on this as well, but I think some of the issue has to deal with it.

2:38:54 Primarily, I think, with a short time period right now. And it's just a matter of being able to get something done within that 60 days. On a personal level, I've experienced that where it is, it can be challenging. Going out to 180, I think, does allow some time. Maybe they don't have the right stove in stock or may not even be a wood stove. It might be a situation, and this is one where I've encountered it, where the buyer was requesting that or requiring that.

2:39:23 The existing fireplace be converted to propane in order to come into compliance. Well, in order to do that, propane had to be run up because that's the only way you can do a fireplace, and it was kind of a process, and it was actually an apartment building, so there was 12 units to deal with, and it really couldn't be done in 60 days. And so I think it's situations like that where, and many others, I mean, sure, everybody has a different type of scenario where they may run into the short time frame. I definitely see a need to go longer on the time frame.

2:39:53 And then as far as penalties, you know, I mean, I think a lot can be done in 180 days, but I'm certainly open to hearing what some of the other folks in the community had to say as far as the fees go. All right. Other questions from staff, from council to staff, I should say. If not, let's hear from the public. Mike? Good evening.

2:40:24 Mr. Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, Councilmembers, my name is Mike Martin. I'm a member of the Board of Directors of the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors, and I am speaking on their behalf tonight as it relates to Chapters 8.30 and Chapter 15.04 of the Municipal Code. First of all, let me say that we absolutely support compliance. We would like to see every condominium and every house in Mammoth Lakes in compliance. We think it's important.

2:40:51 The real estate community has worked hand in hand with Tom Butler back there. We do all of the disclosure on this. We get signatures from buyers and sellers. We make sure that they understand what the codes are and that they understand that this is work that has to be done. But we don't agree with the time frame for inspection, permitting, and the completion of the work. And we certainly don't agree with the severity of the fines.

2:41:21 So the amendment, as I understand it, allows for 60 days with one possible 30-day extension at the decision of the city for permitting. And then 180 days for completion. And I didn't realize that that could go to two years. I'm not a contractor. There are a couple of problems with the short time frame and the severity of the fines.

2:41:51 And I'm not referring to two years because I didn't realize that it could be extended that long. First, the availability of contractors and appliances. Contractors can be unavailable for a year or more retrofitting large condominium projects. An example of that would be Mammoth Ski and Racquet Club, which I understand took two years to retrofit. There are only three or four licensed qualified contractors in Mammoth to do the work.

2:42:18 It's possible, according to Tom Walczak over at Alpine Stove, who I spoke to yesterday, that the work could not be done within 180 days if that was the time frame that we were restricted to. Each unit, each individual unit in a condominium or a house typically takes one to two weeks to complete once the permits are granted, assuming mental framing. Another problem, newly purchased condominium,

2:42:46 Might be a part of a larger project with plans to retrofit outside of the time limits to comply. The buyer could be subject to fines while waiting for work to be permitted and completed. There are several projects in town where the HOAs are discussing going ahead with a retrofitting. Helios, Crestview, and Conestoga condos are three such properties. Most buyers are second homeowners.

2:43:13 And often it takes a month or more for them to get to Mammoth just to address these kinds of issues, sometimes longer. It's more difficult if the property is on a rental program and occupied. This is particularly true in the winter with skier occupancy. The fines. Fines of $15,000 a month for noncompliance. $15,000 a month. The youth program is asking for $20,000 to run all the youth programs.

2:43:42 But we're going to find some poor guy that bought $100,000 Sierra Manners $15,000 a month because he couldn't get the job done in time, because perhaps he couldn't get a contractor, because they're doing larger projects and they're unavailable. To me, that's just unreasonable to us. So what the Mammoth Lakes Board and Realtors recommended in our letter to the board, to the council, that the time frame for permitting be extended to six months from the close of escrow.

2:44:12 For permitting. That the time frame for completion of retrofitting be 12 months from the close of escrow, but it seems that maybe that's not an issue if it could go out to two years. And that the fines for noncompliance, in our letter we put $100,000 a month. Obviously that's a negotiable item. It may not be reasonable. It may be too little. I know that the average condominium last year sold

2:44:39 For about $330,000. Call it $300,000. Somebody puts 20% down, that's $60,000. They have a payment of about $1,500 a month for principal and interest. What if the fine was a month's principal and interest on a noncompliance on a monthly basis, $1,500 a month? So, you know, we're kind of throwing these things out. We don't, you know, we just want it to be fair and reasonable.

2:45:04 There are eight people running for town council right now. I've had an opportunity to listen to all eight of them several times. One of the things that comes up over and over is the quality of the Mammoth experience, welcoming visitors, homeowners, second homeowners, permanent residents, making this a wonderful experience for them. We don't want the Mammoth experience to become a mammoth disaster for somebody who bought a condominium with monies that they might have been saving for years and years.

2:45:32 Find out that because they're not in compliance and they're within a period of time that may not be reasonable that they end up with a complete disaster. So this is the thing that we're trying to mitigate and this is the basis of our recommendations. With that, I thank you very much. So Mike, you're looking for six months to permit, 12 months to complete. Yes. And a more reasonable or different fine structure. Exactly.

2:45:58 Mike, I had a question when you were talking about ski and racket, whichever it was, where the whole complex might be retrofitting, and I didn't understand what you were saying about an individual buyer in the meantime. In the time frame? Yeah. When I spoke with Tom over at Alpinestove yesterday, because I'm trying to do some discovery on this myself,

2:46:23 He said when they were doing Mammoth Sea and Racquet Club, that project, and I don't think he was the only contractor working on that, that contract took about two years to complete. So what if there were four or five or six condominium projects where the HOA decided this is the time to go ahead and do the retrofit? You could use up all of those contractors and all of those appliances. You mean where the HOA suggested to all the owners that they do it? Yes. Because the HOA can't tell the individual, okay, that's what you meant. It would be the homeowners voting to do it.

2:46:52 Okay. Yes. Yeah, that's the part I wasn't sure. And I interpreted that as there was, let's say there's 100 units at a time trying to get it done. If it takes two years, what if there's 100 buyers within a year or two that are trying to get it done? It would take that long, I think is what Mike's trying to get at. If there's 100 buyers that have to retrofit, there's just not enough manpower to get it done. Exactly. And actually, though, I know that, you know, since this time, a couple units in my complex have

2:47:21 Switched over, and one of them met the deadlines with no problem, and ironically, they were forced to sell, and it sold so quickly, and I feel it was because it had already been converted. So it's all disclosed upon escrow, right? Yes, correct. I mean, the time frame, the penalties, I mean, the only concern is 15,000 may be pretty aggressive, but I mean, if you just wait, you don't put any sort of

2:47:51 Fee, somewhat aggressive fee structure. I mean, it just may never get done. It just may just drag on and on and on. For clarification, that's the maximum it could be. I very much doubt that staff would actually seek to impose fines and penalties anywhere near that high without getting specific direction from the council to do that. And I'd like to clarify one thing for Mr. Martin that he misunderstood in the proposed ordinance, and that is that

2:48:18 It doesn't require that the project be completed within 180 days or six months. It requires that work be started within 180 days. And completed by when? Well, the current ordinance would allow it up to two years. So, in fact, a couple of quick clarifications. The building code allows for this. So we're proposing to treat it just like any other building permit. So a lot of big projects go longer than that.

2:48:45 So the way the building code reads is if they provide a written request with justifiable cause, extensions can be granted. So it's not an issue of getting it completed. That would be the same for any other permit. If there's a reason that it needs to take longer, then it just needs to be requested. The other clarification is that the fees are not automatic. It says that they may be imposed. So it's considered a last resort. I can say from personal experience in my last jurisdiction,

2:49:13 Our rules said that we had, we could impose up to $1,000 per day per violation and in six years I never had to impose that. There were, sometimes I had to copy and paste that text into a letter but I never actually had to impose those fees. So it's kind of a last resort thing and you have to have some kind of enforcement action as a last resort only. We just feel that that is too severe. That's our opinion.

2:49:42 All right. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mike. And a question to staff is the fee or the fine and whether or not it's imposed is actually not part of what you're asking us to consider tonight. Is that correct? Correct. Yeah, we're requesting it to leave that as it is. Okay. And that's another issue is that changing the fees for, you know, in specific circumstances, it gets very complicated. As far as code enforcement's concerned, it's nice and clean to leave it the same for

2:50:12 For every type of project or violation. Tom. Mr. Mayor, members of council, well, I was going to clarify the building aspect of it, so that got clarified. The reality of it is we've already in town replaced almost 300 inserts just in the time period that we have had this ordinance in effect, which is really just over a year's time right now.

2:50:43 The existing contractors are able to keep up with the work. And it is correct, Member Lehman's comment about the fact that some projects do have longer periods of time. 1849, for example, they, in their CC&Rs, do not allow work to occur during the winter months. Well, we were able to take that into consideration as part of the ordinance and built in the 180-day and the two-year.

2:51:09 Period of time in order to accommodate their needs. So the reality of it is if we wait too long with this work, we're going to end up with, and I've got some statistics for you which I'll provide you a copy of this. In our assessment we've come up with over 1,600 inserts currently in town. If we wait too long to get this work done in 10 years, or actually now 8 years, we're going to end up with a lot of units that have to get done immediately.

2:51:37 At that time, or we're going to be confronted with having to issue fines for those folks that haven't completed the work. So the concept behind trying to tie this to the sale of property was to try to get it done incrementally so that at the end, for those people who wait until the end, they're going to have to really move quickly in order to comply with the ordinance without getting fined or without...

2:52:03 Suffering some kind of consequence possibly. So we tried to build this such that it would happen incrementally over the entire 10-year period so that we wouldn't have this backlog. And the existing contractors can keep up with the work that's going on. It's just there's a lot of people who are holding off and signing contracts because some people don't think we're serious about it. Some people don't think that it affects them. And, you know, we'll just see how that plays out over time.

2:52:33 But for the ones that are currently buying new units in town, the word we have gotten from many of them is that they understand the severity of it. They certainly don't want their new investment to be compromised, and so they've moved forward. And it was never our intent from the beginning to say that you had to have the work done in 60 days. It was always that you would pull the permit in 60 days. It's always been the time frame as far as how the building...

2:53:00 The fire and building codes dealt with the time period, so we had the two years. And I have to give a lot of credit to the real estate side of things. Even though we've noticed that we've got somewhere in the neighborhood of 500 open fireplaces still in town, the real estate community has really pursued making sure that the sellers understand what the issues are and that the buyers understand what the issues are as it relates to the inserts. So, Tom, from your comments,

2:53:29 Are you saying that the two years to finish is okay with you? If that's what it is going to take in certain units in order to be able to pipe it for gas, in order to be able to facilitate getting the work done, we don't really have much choice. Yeah, I'd love to get it done sooner, but if that's what it takes in order to accommodate the work to get done, yeah, two years would work. Would your answer be the same on

2:53:58 Pulling the permit, whether it was 60 days or 180 days. And it was mentioned that, you know, there's no doubt there are some people who buy units who don't necessarily come up here a second time for another 60 days. Giving them that extra 30 days gives them a three-month period with which to pull that permit and to make all the arrangements that they need to. Okay. All right. If I can ask another question to Steve.

2:54:28 So does, does, quote, pulling a permit, how much of a detail do they have to have in that permit? There's not a lot required for a, if it's just replacing a solid fuel burning appliance. Now, obviously, if it's part of a bigger project, a remodeler, an addition or something, then it's all the standard permits to metal items. One other clarification I'd like to make, though, is it's never going to take, the way the,

2:54:56 The way the building code reads is it can't go 180 days without any work being done or it's considered abandoned and the permit's expired. So it wouldn't go two years unless it really took two years to do the project. So you couldn't pull a permit for just replacing a wood stove and not do any work until the end of that two years. So that's not the way it works. It wouldn't. It's just like, you know, kind of what we're trying to do is not reinvent the wheel here. The building code already sort of addresses all these issues.

2:55:21 So we have staff, we have enough staff to check on all these permits to make sure that something's done in every 180 days? That's a different issue. Yeah. Tim. Tim Flynn, Contractors Association. Obviously, if the work has begun, then the stove is out of commission, and it's taken the safety aspect right out of it. So, Joe, you don't have to worry. The place isn't going to burn down because the work has begun.

2:55:53 The permit's been pulled. The work has begun. It can't, you know, the stove is inoperable. So it's taken the whole safety aspect out of it. Okay, well, you know, because if it was the whole thing and they have to replace an entire wall and stuff, if they pull off the drywall as that started, you know, that would be. But I'll take your word for it that they'd have to continue. Okay. It would be.

2:56:16 You know, it would be a pretty hot fire, you know, if they pulled the drywall off the walls and the chase was, you know, open air. I mean. Yeah, if somebody starts a project at their unit, they don't want to leave it. They don't want to let it set for a year. They want to use a year. It's going to be, you know, very rare. But, I mean. Thanks, Tim. If I could clarify that. There is a clause in there that if the owner agrees to do this.

2:56:43 The buyer agrees to do this. There is a statement in there. They agree not to use the old appliance until, you know, at all. So whether it's removed or not. Comments? Discussion? I'm thinking that the fines as they exist, since it's uniform throughout our town ordinance on that, I think that we want to leave that as it is.

2:57:15 With the understanding that we rarely, if ever, find at the levels that are stated. But I would like to extend the time frame of when someone has to pull their permit and start the construction on the change out of the stove. Because I agree, I think two months is pretty short when someone does buy a...

2:57:45 A unit. So I don't know what the time frame is. I don't know if six months is the right time or if it's four months. I'd be interested in hearing from the rest of the council. I'm with you, John. I'd choose 90 days. Extend it out in one month. Have it 90 days and then with a 30-day extension from that 90 if they requested it. So that could end up, with a request, it could end up being four months. To pull a permit. To start, yeah.

2:58:14 I suppose, yeah, I don't feel strongly about it, but I think, I'm with you, I think 60 is a little light. I think 90 is more reasonable if there's good cause shown to extend it from over 30, I'm probably okay with that. Start the work with 180 and conclude it as we ordinarily would. That's where I would go. Matthew, any thoughts? Yeah, John, I think I'd be comfortable with 90 plus 30. Okay. And then,

2:58:42 I'd like to give them a year to comply, have it completed within a year. I think most people will be doing that. I think given that amount of time frame, then I think the penalty beyond that point, I don't have as much of an issue with it. I agree it's pretty high. It's very high. You know, if we go to $500 a month or something like that, I think that's more reasonable.

2:59:06 But at the same time, I think it's so steep that whether it's $500,000 or $15,000, I think they're going to get it done one way or another because it's a lot of money. Yeah, I think, too, the key word is the up to, right? Right, and I think if we can allow that time to truly get it done and give them enough time, then, you know, beyond that, I think it's on your back. So you would require a start within six months but a completion within one year as opposed to two? Is that what you're saying?

2:59:35 I'm okay with a year. I mean, I know Mike's asking for two. Yeah, and I think, you know, given a little more time to pull the permits, you know, a lot of times a person buys a home, they're just getting in there, and a lot of them don't live here. So I think just coordinating that with, you know, giving a little bit of latitude there I think would be fair. It's just I understand the burdens you can get under when you just close a house up here and watching some of these folks trying to...

3:00:04 Trying to get into their new place. And I think it's different than something like TOT where you have a person who's intentionally trying to break the law in a lot of cases. This is somebody who's just buying a new home here and investing up here. So I'd like to give them a little bit of latitude. And I think I do respect, though, what Tom's going through. I think I do think the real estate community is doing a good job of enforcing the law and wanting to comply.

3:00:28 The problem isn't so much today that a contractor can't get it done. My concern is when we get busy again and everybody gets really busy and next thing you know, the contractors are so busy they can't get to the work. That's just my concern and I think Mike's just looking forward as is the Board of Realtors. Are you comfortable in making a motion?

3:00:48 Well, can I just add one thing? As I like Matthew's approach, the 90 days, the 30 extensions start within 180 and go a year, but maybe there's a possibility of having an extension if there is a really unusual circumstance like the propane line or something like that. Beyond a year? Beyond a year. I'm good with what you've just stated. Yep. Okay. Good.

3:01:10 So in that case, I guess it has to come back to us. Yes, please. It's a little bit more tricky drafting than I want to do right here. No, we don't want to start doing motions improv. You're just looking for a consensus as to what the time frames are? Yeah. Yeah, I mean, a motion could be appropriate just to give us direction to bring something back.

3:01:36 That would be a way of making sure that everyone's on board with the dates. Okay, I'll try that. Wait a minute, let me get, let me get, I move that we approve that it'd be 90 days to pull the permit with the possibility of a 30-day extension such as already described, 180 days to start.

3:01:54 One year to finish, but with a potential extension if there are extenuating circumstances. Okay, so extensions are available to pull the permit and to finish, but not to get started. Correct. Okay. Second. All right. Discussion? Yes. So no extension on getting started, but there is an extension on pulling the permit? Yes. Okay.

3:02:19 On pulling the permit, and if within that one year they do have this propane line issue or something else, an extension there. So the extension is from 60 to 90 plus another 30 for extenuating circumstances to pull the permit. Yes. It could be up to four months, as you suggested. And the year to start. And then six months to start. Six months. What's the parameters for the extension? I'm sure they've got language they can put in there, yeah.

3:02:48 That would be the building official's decision, I guess. Can I request just one other thing in your motion, and that is within that first period of time, right now the understanding is that that appliance cannot be used. So the understanding in your revision has to be that, I hope, will be that. I'll amend my motion. Yeah, I'll amend the motion to clarify that. Thanks, Tom. It's back to your question earlier.

3:03:17 Commissioner Bacon, the reality of it is the two years is not a problem. It's just that the appliance stops being used and then they can have whatever the time allows. Yeah, I know, but there's also a difference between having it on the books that the appliance doesn't get used and the individual's using them because they don't figure anybody's going to catch them. Tell your insurance trumps it, though. So as I understand it, your amended motion is to...

3:03:45 So there's an amended second.

3:04:12 A motion and a second. And any additional discussion, comment? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. That concludes our meeting tonight. We'll adjourn to the next regularly scheduled meeting, which is...

3:04:30 May 21, 6 o'clock here in Council Chambers. Good night. Aren't we agending to next Wednesday? Well, that's a joint meeting. Just a study session or something? Yeah.