TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2014

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 37 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

186 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Thank you.

0:22 So, anyways, the, uh, we have the middle here.

0:54 Oh! No!

1:30 Sure. Everybody, sorry for the delay. We're still waiting for Councilmember Eastman, but we're going to get going. So we will open today's special meeting for Wednesday, May 14, 2014. Roll call, please, Jen. Here.

8:28 Here. Here. If you would please rise and join Councilmember Lehman in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the States of America. Okay. This is the final meeting, so we've got public comments. Any member of the public who wishes to address the Council on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda, now's the time to do so. Seeing none, we'll move directly to consent agenda, which is entitled to award the contract for the 2014 Tennis Court crack ceiling

9:12 Does any council member wish to pull that item for discussion, or is there a motion? I do not wish to pull it, Mr. Mayor, and unless there's comment from the public, I'll go ahead and make a motion that we waive the regularity and award the contract to Black Gold Asphalt to Mammoth Lakes, California, and authorize Public Works Direct to execute the contract. Second. All right, we're in a motion and a second. We'll call, please, James. Yes. Yes. Yes.

9:42 Yes, a motion carries or passes three to zero. That takes us to agenda item number two entitled joint workshop with the Planning and Economic Development Commission to discuss draft report of the parking and snow management district feasibility study. For those members of the public who are here, Joe Bacon is unable to attend. John Eastman is late. We're going to start without both of them, but we're going to go right down here to the table and get going from there. Thanks. Good afternoon, Mayor, Council.

11:03 Commissioner is really happy to be here today. We've all had some days where we've had to deal on some heart issues, and this is a terrific day because we get to be proactive, look at the future, and really discuss, you know, what we could possibly do to make Mammoth a little different, better town, and solve some of our problems in the future. We feel that we have probably received one of the better reports ever from a consultant,

11:33 And the work that Winter and Company has done on their feasibility study for our parking and snow management district. And with that, what we thought we would do, if it's okay with you, is we would let them do about a 15-minute overview of the report. We would then ask if council had any questions. Commission and the public has had a lot of questions. And then we would just really go into a general conversation.

12:02 between everybody and the members here in the audience that wanted to participate. So does that work with you? It does. All right. Sure. And Sandra? Nori Winter of Winter & Company. We're the lead consultants on the Main Street plan, and we're helping to coordinate the work by two of the experts in the country in their fields for looking at feasibility of setting up some of the kinds of implementation mechanisms

12:45 That would be needed to realize the vision of the plan. So with me this afternoon are Jamie Lyko of Centro and Dennis Burns of Kimley-Horn. Jamie has experienced internationally of helping to set up improvement districts and management districts of various forms and Dennis is the nationally recognized expert in looking at parking as a system and how that supports economic development.

13:10 The Main Street study had a variety of recommendations, one of which required a reframing, restructuring of Main Street, and a key part of that was that it had to happen with management, in particular with snow removal, and a very holistic, coordinated approach, and that triggered to some extent the studies for the feasibility of setting up some form of district that could address

13:36 Snow removal, but also that opened up other opportunities for what an improvement district of some form could do along the way. To make it clear for those, because there are so many things revolving around Main Street that the town has been engaged in the past few months, this study focuses on implementation tools. It tests the feasibility of those by looking at some potential costs and revenue sources for those tools.

14:04 This is not the Main Street plan. That's already been adopted. This is not the zoning project. That's already been adopted. This is not the FAR project. And this is not in and of itself a specific district formation proposal. This is mapping the way in which that process would occur. The plan identified, as I mentioned, snow management as an issue. It also looked at the feasibility of redevelopment with the potential

14:37 And we found that in fact that there was a sort of a zero-sum game that the cost of development didn't justify, at today's value, didn't justify the increased level of parking in some cases. And therefore a parking system that can help to share those costs and to share the benefits of that parking drove the interest in looking at a parking system to complement that that would deal with snow removal.

15:07 So in a brief summary here, Jamie is going to walk you through the four key tools that we have been looking at. And the punchline is that some combination of two to three or all of these tools is needed. One tool does not fit all. But that it is feasible. It is possible.

15:32 Looking at the projections and the potential costs to set a package together that can help to move implementation of the plan forward. Jamie? So there's a lot of information contained on this slide and the next and a lot of detail coming up as well just about the digging into these a little bit. I'm going to try and go fairly quickly through it and we can always come back and answer questions so I just want to hit on some key points.

16:07 In terms of how this is organized, the first two columns there, the Property Based Improvement District and the Infrastructure Financing District, are the tools that we think are in the short term most critically important to helping achieve the goals set out by the Main Street Plan and helping set the stage for positive growth and development in Mammoth Lakes.

16:32 The third tool, the Community Development Corporation, we think can be a complementary tool that can benefit the first two. And I just wanted to highlight that the last tool, the Community Facilities District, of which you already have these here, you have one in particular in the North Village, is another type of tool that we have on the table for consideration. It's still a very viable tool, but we believe that the first three might be a better combo for getting the things done that we're talking about.

17:01 The property-based improvement district, very quickly, it's a property-based assessment district that would be funded by the property owners in the proposed district area. Basically, it's an additional assessment that is put on the property tax bill. The assessment can be based on any number of variables, whether it's a characteristic of the property or the value of the property. It does require stakeholder support to put it in place.

17:30 Property owners have to sign a petition of support, and that petition has to be signed by at least 51% of owners representing the majority of the assessment to be paid. It also has a legal process to put in place beyond that, which requires council approval and a Prop 218 vote. The great thing about the PBID, it's a bit similar to the CFD or also to the BID, which you may be familiar with on Old Mammoth Road.

18:00 But it's a lot more flexible. It allows you to pay for a whole lot of things, including but not limited to, I'm gonna go to the next slide, including but not limited to management, maintenance and enhancements, infrastructure, special events, marketing, and parking management as well.

18:21 So it provides a great deal of flexibility and it really puts management of an area into the hands of the private sector but with a strong partnership with the public sector. So it's a great tool to utilize to actually really bring together the management of a place. PBID is limited in its creation to a five-year first term and after that initial five years it can be renewed for up to ten years afterwards. The PBID tool we think is the best tool to help

18:50 To help from, again, as we said, some of the snow removal that will be critical to helping the Main Street plan get implemented, but also doing other types of maintenance and so forth, which we'll touch on in a second. The IFD is the other really critical tool which we feel is important to funding infrastructure. The IFD is not a special assessment on property. Actually, property owners don't pay anything more for it. It's actually funded by tax increment financing.

19:20 Tax increment financing, you may be familiar with. It is how redevelopment agencies were funded. Redevelopment, as we all know, has gone away now, but the IFD is a tool that's still been on the books for quite a while, and it does a similar thing, but with more controls on it. It's a great tool. Basically how, just to primer really quickly for how that works. Essentially, if this is, as we said, sort of tax revenue over a course of time,

19:50 An IFD can be established for up to 30 years. We would consider it kind of the baseline year, starting year. So let's say this was 2015, or the baseline year. We would look at whatever property tax revenues were being collected at this point in time. And the taxing bodies, the taxing entities, would be guaranteed that revenue over the course of the life of the district, up to 30 years.

20:19 Any incremental increase in tax collected over those 30 years would go ideally into a pot called the IFD pot really. And this can be increment that's raised through just a general increase in the value of property or through new development coming online. So this increment is really what we're looking at here, the incremental increase over 30 years. And that's what we would negotiate for at least a percentage of

20:47 To go to the IFD, to be reinvested in critical infrastructure such as parking, public realm improvements that we believe could facilitate more development and growth and in the end return more property tax to the taxing entities in the long term. So IFD is a really great tool. Just real quickly, you can bond against it so you don't have to wait for the increment to come in. You can bond against it for up to 30 years so it allows you to do investments now and pay for them over time.

21:20 The Community Development Corporation is really sort of a separate tool, but really is not so much a state legislative tool as it is the creation of a 501c3 nonprofit entity that can help augment and manage resources and do additional things to help redevelopment occur in the area. We think it's a complementary tool to the first two and creates a nice full package.

21:47 Again, the CFD is a possibility, but we feel like the property-based improvement district might be the better tool for this area. And it's just important to note as well that the IFD and the PBID and the CDC, for that matter, can all occur in the same area. Their boundary lines can overlap each other. You can layer them on top of each other and they all work together really well. And this chart starts to demonstrate how they can work together. So this pulls it all together.

22:16 These two boxes right here, the really small bullet points that you can't read on the screen, identify the things that we are trying to attempt to fund here, including parking infrastructure, other public realm infrastructure, and then the snow management and maintenance, parking operations, other enhanced improvements, coordinated trash and recycling, a whole menu of things to really improve the area.

22:43 And this basically shows, the bubbles show where the money would come from. So the IFD would help build the infrastructure, while the PBID and revenue from parking operations would help cover the cost of ongoing maintenance and operations over time. In doing our analysis, we wanted to look at a couple different options of what the PBID could do. So you see the three options and maps highlighted there on the screen.

23:11 The downtown option would really just focus on doing primarily probably snow removal and maintenance in the core downtown area, the area that's designated to get the highest level of improvement through the Main Street plan. Option number two covers all of Main Street and really connects the two existing districts, maintenance districts that I've talked about, kind of fills the gap. Whereas option number three covers the entire study area. So I mentioned before that North Village has an existing

23:40 Maintenance District on it. Old North Row has an existing maintenance district on it. And so we are looking at an option three potentially creating one large PBIT area that would cover the whole area. And as a result of that, if this PBIT was put in place, we would turn off the assessments on the existing maintenance districts here. So everybody would be being assessed through the same mechanism. All the monies would be managed and governed through the same mechanism.

24:14 The revenue, the service assumptions and what we wanted to try to cover with the PBID. Again, we are looking at these three key bullet point areas. First and foremost, trying to figure out how to cover public realm snow removal, primarily in the Main Street area, which has no mechanism in place right now to take care of things like the berms and the removing some of that more detailed level snow removal, as well as some general maintenance and landscaping, much like what's done on Old Mammoth Road right now.

24:43 We also have interest from property owners, particularly on Main Street, in looking at private net snow removal and coordinated trash recycling as part of a special district. So we've looked at that as well. And then additional services because there are some additional interest in things like looking at perhaps actually having staff to manage some of these things, being able to do marketing events and other things over the course of time to improve the area. In order to get to the P-BID assessments, we pulled existing data from the assessor.

25:12 So this chart simply shows the existing data we have on the property in the area in these three study areas that we've identified. And we looked at three categories, linear footage of the frontage of the properties, the land square footage, and the assessed value, total assessed value. So this chart breaks down, begins to break down, help us understand how much potentially could be generated by the PBID. Again, we've broken it down by these three study areas that we identified on the map.

25:44 And then we've also broken the potential areas of service into the buckets identified in those bullet points on the initial slide. The public arms snow removal maintenance, private lot snow removal and coordinated trash recycling, and any additional services. For each of those, we've put an assessment method to it. So I mentioned at the very beginning that you can do a PBIT assessment in any variety of ways. The only rule, really, is that you have to make a clear correlation between

26:13 What you're assessing for and how you're assessing it. So you have to be able to make an argument that it's fair. So we've done, you can see here for something like public room snow removal, we used linear frontage as the assessment mechanism because it being a linear service, it makes sense to correlate that to a similar assessment rate. This chart right here essentially becomes kind of, we set it up as almost like a menu of services really. So, you know, if...

26:38 If you were to go with option one, just the main street area, and just look at public realm snow removal and maintenance charging in this capacity, we believe we could raise about $70,000. If we just wanted to go with option one, but they wanted the full package of services there, they really wanted to do it up right, we could look at generating just under $300,000 a year. If we looked at combining all the districts for the full package of services,

27:06 We could look at generating up to $1.5 million a year. This is highly viable obviously based upon where at the end of the day stakeholders would want to see the boundary lines drawn and what services that they would want within those boundaries. What's important to note is that the PBID law allows for something called geographic benefit zones to be created. Just go back to this map real quick. We could potentially have a PBID that looked like this.

27:36 But we could have three, let's say, three different benefit zones. Zone A might just want snow removal. Zone B might want snow removal plus marketing dollars. And zone C might want snow removal plus marketing dollars plus trash recycling, just as an example. You could do all that within one district tool, create different assessment rates and different levels of service delivery in each area. So it's a very flexible tool and mechanism to use. This just shows an example of

28:10 We just tried to pull a very basic example of what a pivot assessment might look like in real dollars for a property owner. So this is an example of Main Street property if they were to go for the full package of services we noted there. This property we've said has 100 linear feet, is about a half an acre of land, and is about half a million dollars of assessed value. They'd be looking at paying just over $5,000 a year in assessment.

28:37 But what's important to note about this is that it replaces, if we're doing this, including private let snow removal and coordinated trash recycling, it replaces out-of-pocket costs those property owners are currently paying for those. So ideally, if you look at what property owners are currently paying, we'll actually feel that we can deliver the same level of service, if not more, for a better cost because we're able to leverage

29:01 Resources from everybody in the district paying into a central pot and negotiate better contracts for the whole area. So moving on to the infrastructure financing district. So again, the IFD is the one where we leverage future tax revenue. This is not a special assessment on property. We also looked at three different study area options for the IFD. One of the things that's very different, as I believe I mentioned earlier on,

29:33 Is that for the PBID, wherever the money is collected, that's where the money has to be spent. So whatever district boundaries you set up for the PBID, you have to use those monies within the boundaries. The IFD is different in that you can actually use the monies outside of the area where you're collecting the increment. So we got a little bit more creative here. We've looked at one contiguous option where we would have an IFD overlaid over the whole area, collecting increment from the whole area. A small focused option, focused on the core Main Street area and perhaps Old Mammoth Road.

30:02 And then the third option, actually because of that unique rule that allows us to use the money outside of where the increment's collected, we could potentially just identify select sites that we believed were ripe for redevelopment in the near future and just put them within the FIFD in order to be able to maximize the amount of increment that we could collect.

30:26 We would still be able to deliver services perhaps to these areas if service was desired and that was set out in the management plan. There's a lot of flexibility obviously in how that's set up. In terms of IFD revenue generation, a lot trickier even to identify how much could be raised through an IFD than through a PBID. We wanted to make a lot of assumptions. So there's two key assumptions set out in the IFD revenue generation piece.

30:56 First of all, we looked at the taxes being collected today, the property taxes being collected today in each of the option areas, excuse me, and we made an assumption that if new development were to take place, that property values may raise by about 3% per year. So that's the 2% cap plus an additional percentage to cover perhaps change of sale of property, handle over a property. We also have assumed

31:26 Because going back to that chart where I talked about having to negotiate with the taxing bodies about whether you can take all the increment into the IFD or a portion of it, we've made an assumption that we are, these numbers assume only taking 50% of the total increment over 30 years into the IFD. So this is only half of what the IFD would really be generating potentially. So given those assumptions, if there were to be, this chart, this box here shows, if there were to be absolutely no new development and just assuming 3% growth

31:55 In the value of the property over 30 years, here's what each of the options could generate in tax increment. So not a huge, huge amount, certainly not enough to fund everything. It's a good start, a good base for what you could get. But what's important to look at too is added on to that, what the additional impact of new development is. So you can see here, if over the, you know, in the short term you believe that you can bring on $60 million of new development, you can see

32:25 That new development is where it's at in terms of gathering the increment. That could bring an additional $15 million on top of, say, $2.7 million over the next 30 years. You're starting to talk about real numbers that can build real things and really incentivize development to happen here. So pretty good revenue projections. So with that, we have referenced building parking, we have referenced operating parking. Dennis has some details on what the numbers look like for that component. Just going back to the Main Street plan,

33:01 And the zoning code update, several of the things that we promoted in the plan was placing parking underground or behind buildings, allowing for shared parking arrangements to promote joint use and cross-access in lieu fees and future on-street parking that could count towards parking requirements and eventually creating a parking district that could manage all those assets. In terms of revenue generation, we looked at several things. The IFD is looked at as the primary

33:32 A mechanism for generating the capital costs for generating or for developing parking facilities. The PBID could help with the management of those facilities in lieu fees or another option for revenue. But in terms of parking operations, we looked at off-street parking revenue that could be generated from parking lots or garages, future off-street parking revenues, parking enforcement revenues, and special event parking revenues. And we really promote a kind of a systems approach to managing parking.

34:02 This slide was just an interesting slide that talks a little bit about parking. People want three things when it comes to parking. They want it to be cheap, preferably free. They want there to be plenty of it, and they want there to be it to be convenient to their destination. The problem is you can generally only have two of these. So if it's inexpensive and enough, it may not be convenient. You may have remote parking lots with shuttles. If it's inexpensive and convenient, you may not have enough of it, which may be okay if you're trying to promote

34:30 Alternatives to transportation alternatives instead of everybody driving. But most places, especially resort communities and downtowns, tend to want to go for enough inconvenient parking, which means it's not going to be inexpensive. So you're generally looking at parking structures. And parking structures by themselves, unless you're downtown San Francisco attend not to pay for themselves, and so that's why municipalities get into the business of building parking structures. In case we're looking at the IFD as the funding mechanism for that capital.

35:01 We looked at several parking management options. The key element for all of these, I mean, the consolidated city department or parking authority or even have it contract the management out to a downtown association or in this case maybe the PBID or creating a parking district. The key element there is the vertical integration of the major elements, the on-street and the off-street and enforcement components. We also looked at operating methodology so you can self-operate or you can outsource the management to a private parking management firm.

35:29 Concession agreement is another option that some cities are looking at, but we don't think that's a good option for you. To the right there, I'm not going to read those, you can just scan the list. When we're looking at these various management options, those are some of the criteria that we use to evaluate what it is we're trying to achieve with the parking program. So supporting economic development, improving customer friendliness, being focused on the vision, all those kinds of things. That's what we would consider.

35:58 Potential facility locations, there were a number of them identified in the plan. Preliminary site evaluations were provided for some of them. Assumption was to start with a multi-level structure at the village. We got some interesting feedback on that option. But there was an interesting element of that, that because that's where the demand is, it could actually generate enough positive cash flow to possibly generate the funds to bond for a second structure, perhaps down in the main street area.

36:28 But that's not locked in stone. There are several options to be considered in terms of where we might start with infrastructure development for parking. We did some numbers crunching here. Annual operating and maintenance expenses were in the $150,000 range. Potential revenues were about $628,000. So there was some potential improvements, about a half million dollars from a

36:56 A future more evolved, more mature parking system, but it could generate about a half a million dollars a year for reinvestment back into some of the district improvements that we're looking at. Where are we transitioning? You or Jamie? Real fast here. The punchlines are that while there are lots of numbers to discuss in detail that the PBID can

37:28 is doable in terms of reasonable assessments. It looks like it can actually add services at, and in some cases, at a savings over what property hunters are spending to date. That the IFD would be a viable tool in terms of numbers generated. This, of course, requires a lot of conversations and everyone understanding who benefits. And that

37:55 The key concept here of sharing, not necessarily from a, you know, I'm a good guy viewpoint, but that it will make good business sense to all partners involved, whether it's the taxing entities or the property owners or those engaged in doing it. So there's still a lot of conversation that has to occur for people to come to agreement on these. And so, as we said at the beginning, this is a study on the feasibility.

38:20 To indicate that yes, these tools are possible to use and that when used strategically in combination they can help to achieve the plan's objectives. What needs to happen next is more engagement, more discussion. Many people have been raising good technical questions and that they want to know how does it work for me and how am I effective and how do people benefit. Those are all very legitimate questions that have to be addressed in more detailed discussions.

38:47 More refined testing as the alternatives become more focused, and certainly discussions with those taxing bodies in terms of the IFD. In particular, the report outlines some of the very specific steps that are needed to implement these tools. They don't happen overnight, and as I mentioned earlier, they're not created by this plan, by this report.

39:12 The PBIT itself requires a formal operations plan that defines which services are going to be provided and to whom, how is it governed, what are the boundaries for those areas of benefit, and what are the rates being paid into it. There's a petition that has to be assigned, a Prop 218 vote, and then finally council authorization. So there is work to be done there.

39:36 A similar series of steps as Jamie outlined for the IFD development, a formal operations plan, a vote by the qualified electors, council authorization, and sign-offs from the taxing bodies are all going to be required as a part of that. We recognize that while this is a technical report in some respects, it also poses several policy questions.

40:01 for the community at large, and it's going to be based on people making decisions, realizing that there will be shared benefits for all parties, some benefiting in the short term more perhaps than others, but everyone benefiting in the long term, that some sub areas will benefit to different degrees at different times, and how the benefit to the community at large will accrue over this, and realizing that there are direct and indirect benefits for everyone.

40:30 Involved. And those are all, those will all come out as those more detailed discussions proceed forward should you wish to continue pursuing implementation. At that point, Hattie, we are ready. Okay. Questions? So, let's see, because we're being televised, so I'm trying to, maybe just counsel at this point when I move in front of the mics and then they can hear you or, because I don't think we have our temporary mic. I'll switch places.

41:02 That looks like, clearly looks like redevelopment to me, and redevelopment has different agencies, whether it's Mono County in our case, or a variety of special districts.

41:22 Would it require their approval for us to use the tax increment? Yep. Yep. And that would be, may be difficult to get. That is, I think that's going to require a lot of discussion and figuring out how that will work. That's why when I said we've been, I think, fairly conservative in our assumptions there, we've assumed that, you know, in the numbers space, only 50%

41:49 We've taken 50% of the total increment over 30 years, total projected income, because we're assuming that's going to be a negotiation that takes some time to figure out and that not all the taxing bodies will want to give up all of their increment over 30 years. So again, I think Norah has made the point at the beginning and I tried to reiterate it that the case that has to be made for that is what's the return on investment for those taxing bodies giving up a little bit now.

42:17 And the truth is that giving up a little bit now will spare, ideally, development that brings more tax to the table in the long term. I see that at the same time I'm trying to be realistic in the sense that whether it's Mono County, whether it's the fire district, the water district, not the water district, excuse me, the school district, whatever special district it might be, I would argue all but except for the water district are hurting.

42:45 with their revenues today, including Mono County, so it seems like it would be extra hard to convince them to set aside any tax increment, even though we realize that if there is development, you know, they're going to be getting more at some level anyway. Yes, it will be hard. Looking back at the slide again here, the

43:14 The gray area is the revenue coming in to date with existing value. If you were to assume an increase in value as development does occur, but in an uncoordinated way, it might be where that dash line is. And you might say that that's the increase in revenue that all of those taxing entities could realize. And we will point out that the IFT specifically excludes school districts. Oh, good. So they might get 50% as a...

43:44 Example. So part of the reasoning here is that there is added value created by the improvements in the district that otherwise those entities would not see that money because that value would not be there. Ten percent of something is better than ten percent of zero. Fifty percent of something is way better. And it's a negotiation. And so there's a lot that has to be worked through there in terms of reaching a level of comfort.

44:14 For all of those entities. But this is their community too. They benefit from the value being generated in this community. And so ultimately it's a business decision for everyone. Great. Well, thank you. Excuse me. I had one question on this subject from our previous meeting. And during, quote, our Great Recession where sometimes property values were devalued, what happened to those districts?

44:42 If a property has lower value, isn't it? So if the values actually drop, go below the base? Correct. Right. Have you seen that? A little bit. I didn't actually. I think there was one example in Colorado where they actually just went ahead and dissolved the district because it was brand new right when they created it. I don't assume right now you're going to have those issues.

45:08 You're going to get enough increment over time that you'd have a cushion built up to protect you from that. But in those cases, it's just that the IFD wouldn't get any money. The taxi bodies would get what they get, and the IFD would not likely get any money those years. Is there a guarantee that as a base? Along the same lines, and I know you guys are already aware of it, but we're in competition as a resort with other resort areas in the west.

45:38 Many of them, if not the majority of them, don't charge a fee for parking because they want to encourage their visitors to use it. So in that case, the parking facility, whatever it turns out to be, would not be a revenue generator. Well, actually, many of them do. I think the ones that you want to be competing with do actually charge for parking. Maybe the Tahoe area doesn't.

46:06 But when I think of Park City and Vail and Aspen, they do charge for parking in their parking structures and they also have metered on-street parking. Now, they do cycle with the seasons. In off-season, sometimes it's free or the rate is much lower. So it's all adjusted to fit the market that they're dealing with. But they are charging. Thank you. John.

46:36 If we don't charge for parking and charge, you know, somewhat high rates for parking, I think in San Francisco is about the highest there is, how do we encourage people to park once and get on transit, you know, walk, the whole, how do we encourage the whole fee first thing? Yeah, no, it's an issue. The other thing, of course, obviously, is that someplace like the village where if they're staying there, then there's, it's a non-issue. Exactly.

47:06 I just wanted to point out a couple things. Because there are so many variables in the charging for parking arena, what we did was we created models for you. And you can see on this one here, this is for on street. Let me jump to the, this is the more detailed one for the off street. This would be for a garage. So what you've got here is you've got all the assumptions that were built into the model that are, they're now variables for you.

47:34 So if you want to, so we've got 330 spaces at the top, we've got 12 months we're going to charge all year, that's a variable, you can change that if you only want to charge during the peak season. You've got a 90% utilization rate, this is assuming garage up by the village. You've got rates for how many of those 330 spaces would be transient spaces or monthly spaces, reserved or unreserved valet spaces. So you can change any of these assumptions as you go forward.

48:03 And it'll all fold down. And then there's an operating expense category at the bottom that says what we are expected. So it actually comes down to a net operating results at the bottom. So changing any of those, you've got lots of flexibility if you want to question or change, you know, how many months we charge, what the rates are. So you've got a really flexible tool to help you figure out what the revenues might be under any scenarios. Councilman Raimondo. I think Councilman Raimondo had a question. I think it related to the marketing. Yeah, I mean, I think there was...

48:39 There was a, there was a, on the presentation talked about marketing dollars in some of the districts. We have, you know, a T-Bid now for marketing. How does that, how does that affect, I mean, how does that come into play with the suggestion of utilizing some marketing dollars? Well, you might not choose to spend a near PIVA dollars on marketing. That's,

49:07 When you go, as Nora kind of covered, there's a whole process to create a plan. It takes about a year really to get through all of that detail and how this PBID would be structured, why the monies would be spent, how it would be governed. And as part of that process, you would determine then how you wanted to allocate the revenue that would be generated from the PBID. So I just put that up there as an example to let you know that there's flexibility in that. You know, you may choose not to use it at all or some places that even have tourism districts still.

49:37 Allocate a small percentage of parking just to market their own downtown specific things or downtown events or things that you're doing. So that would be totally up to you guys to determine at the time of the business plan creation. Thank you. To some extent, I think what we felt was the T-Bits promoting the product were helping enhance the product. And we went through and going through here, I looked at a lot of different costs you had. And I think we asked this at the last meeting, so I pretty much know the answer, but for the public.

50:10 For the cost of construction, I'm assuming that's strictly infrastructure and improvement costs, right, not land? Yes. Okay. There are several development costs that are not in those numbers yet. Those are still just raw. That's a raw shell of a parking structure. That's not a fancy screen or wrap or anything like that around it. Okay. Right now, look at those for the relative costs between a cost per square per space for a surface line versus a structure.

50:38 We'll beef them up some more to get them a little bit more realistic, but nonetheless, there are so many factors when you get into doing a case structure. Okay, yeah, I know there can be different ways to acquire land or the town can own land or whatever that case may be. Some of it might be a joint venture or a partnership with a private entity and all of that. Got it.

51:11 I just wondered if there's grant money available to come up with the plan and go through that long, complicated, probably tedious negotiating process and all of it has to be done. We've started those conversations with staff to sort of think about some of the funding sources that might be available for the next step because, yeah, the next step is going to require some financing just to help with setting up these decisions. And the other thing I've wondered about with the T-Bid because

51:38 I'm not sure if I was here then, but there was a resort association here at that point, and the person, there was this management of funds by the staff person, I don't know the exact story, but there is that history, and therefore that baggage, and I wondered what the oversight, how you build in the accountability and just all the rest of it, what are the protections for setting up a PBIT? Well, I don't know what the, I'm assuming it's just a voluntary association?

52:05 Wasn't a PBID. I thought you said John, you know, the Resort Association? Wasn't there embezzlement involved or something? Yeah. I don't know the details of that, but I'm saying that the PBID, where are the protections, where's the oversight, where's the economic liability? How do you set it? Well, because it's developed by state statute, there's quite a bit of, you know, safeguards and controls that are, excuse me, inherently in it.

52:31 I think the first and the biggest of which is that the state limits you to an initial five-year term before it sunsets automatically. And then after that five years, you have to go through creation of a new business plan and re-petition and all of that to create it, which I actually think isn't necessarily a bad thing. It forces accountability in those first five years and for the people to really deliver in order for people to want to re-sign up. So you have that as kind of the worst-case scenario, I guess, if you will. But in terms of the governance and the other...

53:00 Sort of mechanisms by which you could potentially, you know, control, manage, and secure if anything were to go wrong. You can build that all into the governance plan. There's quite a bit of detail that goes into that and how funds are overseen, how funds must be accounted for and reported on every year. There's a lot of detail. Those things have to go to city council to be presented an accountant's report. So, you know, we build in a lot of security because it is at the end of the day.

53:30 Representative of the dollars of everybody in the area, so you want to make sure it's fully accountable and transparent in its management. It's accountable, it's open records and all of that, so it's Sunshine Laws, it's all part of that. There might be periodic reporting requirements. There's a yearly reporting requirement, actually, yearly accounting and financial reporting requirements, but those have to be filed with city or town council. I didn't hear an answer to the question.

53:58 If there's grant funding available, possibly. Well, we think there is. We have not identified specific grant programs, and both to help with moving forward with the creation of the districts, but then also certainly to enhance several of the actual construction projects. I mean, the town's been pretty successful about getting planning grants, obviously, and some infrastructure grants. So they're not to be discounted, but what you want...

54:28 Certainly wants the system to set up as a system that can sustain itself and look to grants as enhancements as opposed to being dependent on them for the plan to work. Mr. Harvey, did you agree? No, I've asked one more. So just to recap, we've really talked about how we can use these different funding mechanisms.

55:01 It's mentioned in the report briefly, but we haven't really talked about how future development impact fees could be used, and so that was, it's just two-part questions, I really wanted to kind of talk about that a little bit, and then two, so let's take a hypothetical scenario while, you know, we're in the process of forming our districts, and if a developer comes in and, you know, wants to build a significant project,

55:28 Do you have any recommendations or thoughts or have you seen anywhere else where basically the town could negotiate some sort of transaction with the developer to not only provide the parking that's needed but perhaps additional parking for either like the downtown district or the north village district. Who wants to take it? Okay, so we...

55:56 Well, I mean, the development impact fees, yes. I mean, I think that's something that we could look at, we can continue to look at as part of this. And we talked a little bit about that in relation to the parking, so the next phase of understanding the parking operational piece and component of that. Maybe one of those two wants to talk about that further. The second question, so you're saying, okay, we're in this process of creation, but a developer comes along and they want to go for it, like, tomorrow. They're ready to go.

56:25 But we really want them to build parking. How do we do that? I mean, have you, okay, so we have all these great mechanisms and probably, you know, between the PBID, the IFD structures, all right. So, you know, I mean, we as a town, because we're such a small town, I think have to always

56:49 We want to encourage development. We want to treat our developers really well, but we really want to make sure that we're negotiating a fair transaction because we only have so many shots. I mean, it's not like, you know, maybe we're San Clarito or whatever, which is a very large area. So the question is, is if somebody comes forward, wants to build a substantial project,

57:13 What could we possibly do to develop a win-win situation for that developer and for the town to help solve some of our parking issues? One of the tools that we provided early on to staff, which I don't think has been circulated as widely, is a little white paper on parking as an economic development strategy. And what that outlines is kind of a new approach to parking infrastructure development.

57:38 Let's imagine that the IFD generated enough for you to generate, say, a thousand spaces of parking, structured parking somewhere. In the old days, you would have done supply-demand study, identified an area where you had deficit of parking, and that's where you would put your money into a structure there. The new model that we really like is this public-private partnership model where if a developer comes in and has, say, across from the village, there's a new development opportunity there.

58:03 He's going to need to put a certain amount of parking based on code for his development, say, 300 spaces. I have no idea what the actual number is. But the mechanism that we like is the idea to say, okay, we see a need for some public parking in this area as well. So what we'd like to do is partner with you. So instead of building two separate parking facilities, one shared parking facility that may have, you know, 300 spaces for his condo units or whatever, but 300 public parking spaces.

58:32 Let's say 250. We do it four times because we've got money for 1,000 parking structures. Now we have, we've shared the cost with the developer on foundations, stair towers, elevators, all the big ticket items. Real tangible benefit to both parties. And ultimately we end up with four public parking sites and four different development sites and we've helped incentivize those developments to actually occur. And so that white paper has a lot of information on that. It's got sample development agreements.

59:00 That were done in various communities, and so I think that would be an interesting one that might help answer some of these questions. And just out of curiosity, in these public-private partnerships, then how does the public component fund their piece of it? That would come out of the IFD. That's an important point. Now, that's to fund public parking. Public parking. Right. But you could, in essence, have a public-private partnership and then have an IFD for part of that parking structure only?

59:30 Is what you're saying? And I think you'd want to retain ownership of the public part of that, and you'd want to manage that, and it would become part of a larger parking management system that would generate revenue over time. There are lots of details that can be worked out about. But what that does point out is there is a timeliness factor here where if development is to be occurring, ideally the acting would already have been in place so that you could be in that position right now to be cutting those kinds of arrangements.

59:59 And so there is some sense of urgency to try to get it in place so that you're in a position to be that kind of partner. And if it takes two years to get that done and all the new development happens within that two-year period, you've missed out on that increment. And then I just have one more question. So let's assume just hypothetically that our taxing authorities aren't willing to participate. Then what would be your second option?

1:00:29 to fund the actual structure. We've put the, there's a couple options. I mean, you could attempt to fund the parking through a PBID, which would take ages. You couldn't get very far because you could only do components of it at a time, you know, because the PBID's time limited. The other option is to look at forming the CDC and trying to

1:01:01 Leverage resources from a variety of different places through things like grants, transportation grants, but also public money is being invested, maybe private money is being invested and doing it through that capacity. That's really your next best tool here unless Dennis has some other magic ideas. But the IFD is really the best resource for the bulk of the revenue to do that.

1:01:32 The IT was on the books when redevelopment was there, but this is the essentially the tax increment financing tool with new limitations and restrictions that kind of govern some of the things that went wrong with redevelopment. So it is really your absolute best option and I would say there's a lot of urgency and you don't have really any very good options beyond that. So I think it's your best option.

1:02:00 You can use noise, right? You can use something like the Melaroos district to do that, but again, that's an assessment. You're assessing properties to pay for that facility, so you're asking your stakeholders to actually pay to do that wholly. The IFD, is that strictly for capital improvements, not maintenance? That's right. That's why you need the two in partnership.

1:02:33 There's already in place 501c3 with the Chamber of Commerce, the Mammoth Community Foundation, and it was formed to be a pass-through for community projects that people who donated to it would, you know, have tax deductibility. Do you see any way an existing 501c3 could be used as the CDC that you... Totally depends on how their bylaws were written and what they were approved for because the feds are getting ever so...

1:02:59 So we would have to see what, you know, how exactly that was written. It's possible. Yeah, community-based foundation probably, but yeah, you blame it. Yeah, I think there's a good, but community foundations have a lot in terms of the language and how they get their status and usually it's as a donor or a pastor to other

1:03:31 Recipients, but the CDC is we're talking more about actually funding projects of community benefit where the CDC actually does them. So it's a little different. The nuance is there enough that the IRS would probably take issue with that. And the other thing, although, you know, like the experience of what it's already in place, is you want one whose mission is this. That's really important. Are there any other questions at the table? At this time, is there any members of the public that would like to ask questions?

1:04:06 So I have a specific question and you had a an example of the parking structure in North Village and I don't know if that was on the IFD or if that was or I see if that was on the

1:04:38 Pbid, but you said we built the parking structure in North Village, then you would pick up whatever the dollar amount was. Would that, if, for instance, if the, if the district was Omana Thrill and Main Street and the Village, would the, would everyone then benefit from the income from that parking structure? And could we build a parking structure somewhere else at a future date? Or is it just central to that one location?

1:05:09 My assumption is the IFD would cover all three areas. If it did, of course, yes. And the beauty of that scenario was that's where the demand for the parking is. That would potentially be able to generate revenue. And so if that was built, and if the revenue assumptions that we made in that model came through and generated the half million dollars or so, that would be net revenue according to the projection, then that gives you half million dollars to

1:05:39 It could be debt service for a 200 or 300 space garage along Main Street or somewhere else. That's why I think that has some real merit to it. Anyway. Because right now we have two districts that really don't have a problem with parking. We have a district that doesn't have a problem with it. So if we combined all three of those, we could do that then. And the other benefit of that is now you've paid for structure number two, which probably isn't going to be able to generate as much revenue as any revenue.

1:06:08 You're just not ready to charge at that level down there because you don't have the level of development or interest. But it could help stimulate additional development because now you've got the infrastructure in place to support more density. And so more increment coming in through the PFD. I just have a comment, and it was said before, and I've been on pretty much here. I've been on every committee that we've had for zoning, and I do have to agree with Mickey that this is by far the best consulting firms that we've had.

1:06:38 You guys are very professional, extremely informative. And also I'd like to thank our staff. We've got three people primarily in the community development that without them, even if we had, in my opinion, if we had good consultants, it would be useless without the staff that we have. And I think we've got the best staff we've ever had and they really, really do do a great job for us. I think the town should be aware of the fact of what they're doing. Thank you.

1:07:08 Are there any other questions from the audience? Okay. Now, so then, the big question now is where, what are we going to do with all of this wonderful information that we have? And so I just want to clarify. So the plan now is you're going to come back one more time.

1:07:42 With your final? Are you just going to submit your final? Unfortunately, we're just going to submit. We don't have in our budget to return again. So we will make refinements based on what we've learned this trip and send back a final report. We can participate in a conference call. We'd be happy to do that. But this is the last time you get to see us.

1:08:02 Okay. Until our next grant money, right? Yes. Okay. All right. No pressure. No pressure. I would just add, Mickey, when I read through all this material, and there was quite a bit, it was one time that really gave us a clear vision, I think, of how to get from A to Z, you know, whether it's achievable or not, or whether the participants will go in or not on any of these items. It really helped answer the questions of how are we going to pay for it.

1:08:30 And I think that was really helpful for a lot of people because I think for a long time it's just been a pipe dream of, well, what if this or what if that? And he laid it out real well. Thank you. Thank you. So, you know, I think we really, I mean, the worst thing that could happen now is that we take all this wonderful information, put it on the shelf, and because one, it would be tragic to do that. And the other thing that's very obvious when you read this is there's such a lead time.

1:09:03 To all these different funding mechanisms. So, I mean, we kind of talked about this a little bit in commission already, and I almost hate to use the word, but I really believe that this is probably one project where we're going to have to quote form that stakeholder group. And maybe we can put, like, council can direct that they can only meet X number of times or something. So, because, I mean, it needs to be vetted. I mean, it's clearly...

1:09:32 There's great information. It can be really used for where we need to grow as a development community. But there's a lot of unanswered questions about how we're going to bring it to the practical. So I'd like to have some feedback from Commission and Council on that. And, Mickey, may I interrupt for just one moment? Because it sort of relates to a question that Elizabeth asked earlier, too, and that's are the grants for the next baby steps. There could be.

1:10:00 to do a little bit of a commercial for Jamie because she would be a key person in implementing some of those next steps. And I'll let her explain it, but I want to introduce it, is that the idea that you can front load some of those early consultant costs that can then be repaid to whoever finances that out of the PBED once it's created. So I want you to sort of explain that. That might help you in your thinking a little bit.

1:10:28 So, yeah, I just want to be clear, because when you talk about next steps in terms of getting from here to where that, you know, the, I think, you know, we've made a clear case from our perspective that certainly moving forward on the PBID and IFD as soon as possible because they do take anywhere from 12 to 18 months to really get up and running and for revenue to start generating is critical. And, you know, there's generally three steps in the

1:10:56 Creation of these districts. There's kind of this feasibility stage, which you guys have gotten from us. You've through kind of stage one. And then there's a whole stage that takes the longest amount of time, which includes this engagement and the development of the plan. And that formal operations plan, we outline in the report what kind of stuff goes in there. It's mandated by state statute as well. It details everything. You have to put revenue projections for the life of the PBID. You have to put

1:11:24 The assessment structure, governance, all of that. But that takes time. All of that takes time and negotiations for both types of districts. But I would say engaging people, you know, if you're going to start to go down that route to actually start thinking about moving into the, at that as part of a creation of a real plan to begin looking at what it looks like. That's the second stage. The third stage is once you have a plan that you think has been well vetted,

1:11:49 And you've got the details all together. You then take that plan and you go out to petition to vote and to the formal council hearing. So that next phase where you're going is the biggest bulk of the work, really. And the one that I would say the sooner you can get started on, the better for both districts. As Nora mentioned in terms of funding, at least for the PBID, there is a case to be made where places, communities have

1:12:19 Have had either the public sector or private sector or a combination of both front the cash for the development of the actual district. And then the business plan actually states that those entities could be repaid out of year one PBID revenues as a way to get it up and running for places that don't have the cash on hand to go right away. So that is an option for part or some or all of the next steps at least of the PBID.

1:12:47 There's a potential you could do that with the IFD as well, but I'm lily to commit to that unless we have legal counsel on that because the IFD is just still, it's changing so much all the time right now. It's under such scrutiny that it might be a little bit tougher, but certainly for the PBID, that's something that could be explored. And you could do it in chunks, mind you, also. It's a 12 to 18 month process, so it's not like you need the whole money tomorrow to get started. If you can find pieces, it's, you know, doable. You know what my next question is going to be. How much does it cost?

1:13:17 Just ballpark. The PBID process probably from start to finish costs about $75,000. That would include your legal fees and your engineer's report which are mandated by state statute and the election that you have to do for the Prop 218 ballot. RFD process, probably somewhere similar to that. So we told staff earlier with, you know, a couple hundred thousand dollar budget you could have both in place including all the legal fees and so forth, realistically.

1:13:50 And then my third question is, have you ever seen an incident where somebody's fronted the money and then the PBID or IFD was not approved? I have not, actually. I have not. So, and I, you know, I think Fresno is the most recent one I know where the city actually fronted the money and requested it got paid back. Or it was actually a combination of public-private sectors, my most recent example. But I have not seen people, I have not seen it not get done once the money's been fronted, in my personal experience.

1:14:20 Any questions? When do we start? Jamie, were you suggesting getting stakeholders together to start talking about this? For instance, I read this report and I thought this is so clear and so well done, but then so are physics textbooks. I think there's a lot of stuff to get your head around in here. And so people have to start becoming familiar with it and start developing all these questions.

1:14:52 Would that be the first step? Then you get into the plan with all the technicalities that the state requires. You know, usually, if I'm totally honest with you, we do that all together. You guys are ahead, and I think you've done a great job. I mean, you've come out of the Main Street plan, gone into a full-fledged feasibility where you looked at parking and you've looked at a lot of different components all at once. I think that's why this feels overwhelming to people, maybe because of the amount of information we're throwing at you.

1:15:20 And I feel overwhelmed after giving this presentation like eight times today. I don't think I've ever done so much explaining of so many different things all at one time all day long. So I think you need to break it down in bite-sized chunks. But I wouldn't necessarily feel like, you know, if you feel like there's general support, and I would say from our meetings, there seems to be a willingness, an openness to explore.

1:15:44 The PBIG creation process naturally whittles down. You start big picture with the ideas we've laid out. We have a general numbers. That creation process would, with a consultant's help and with some guidance, there'd be probably a steering committee we would put together. We would nurture that process by looking at every possible in and out and really honing down over the course of several months a business plan that worked. And the thing with that is you

1:16:10 You create a draft plan and you test it. And then you create a second draft plan and you test it. And you create a third draft plan and hopefully that's the final. And you really just keep testing it until it makes sense to everybody. But I think these concepts are hard to get until you actually get down to the real tactics. I think you could talk about them all day long conceptually and unfortunately I think a lot of communities do and they never get down to the business of doing it. So I'd say if you feel like there's support there, why not move into the next phase? You can always get down the road and say, say,

1:16:40 You know what? Whoa. This is way, we're moving way too fast. We don't want to go, and you can halt the process there. You don't have to commit to going to petition and vote and all of that stuff if you feel like you get halfway there and you can't do it. And that would be the recommendation. It seems to me that maybe I work critical if you could fast track one simply because you don't want to lose the potential for development. Would that be your assessment? Well, you know, actually what I'm thinking is if you think these are both tools you want to go for,

1:17:18 Why not figure out a way where the process could facilitate the development of the plans together at the same time so that you had assistance doing them on parallel tracks and that you actually use one to leverage the other and vice versa. I think probably there could be some cost savings in doing that if you felt like you were ready to go for both, certainly from a consultant's perspective like me who would be responsible for the stakeholder engagement.

1:17:47 The financial question about saving money on lawyers and all that could be a little more tricky with IFD. But I think you could probably do them on parallel tracks and use them to complement each other in the process. I absolutely agree with you. I really think the conversation needs to move forward on the toolkit and how that is put into place as opposed to one. Because each person we've talked with today has their own individual interests.

1:18:13 And they don't fit into the silo of the PBIT or the IFD. They fit into, you know, I need snow removal, I want parking, I want streetscape or whatever. And so those conversations need to happen that way. It is more complicated, but I think that's going to be the best way for you to move forward. Absolutely. And it helps make informed decisions. People have a better understanding if they understand how these tools are going to come together or not.

1:18:48 Council. So do you think this has to wait until after the election? Do you think council can start giving direction now? And how do we approach the taxing authorities? Well, this isn't scheduled for action. No, I know. I was just trying to get, like, general chit-chat. Well, because we can't, you know, I mean, this is our opportunity to talk about it. So we're not asking for action. We're just asking for input.

1:19:19 I think, well, I think that we've only got three of us have had, what, a meeting, possibly two left. Three or four weeks. So even if we put it on the next agenda as fast-tracked, it, I mean, it wouldn't, it wouldn't, I don't think it could develop from it, really. The only thing is, is that, you know, we're just talking, right? Yeah. But if we did put it off until after the election and the new council sworn in, then...

1:19:46 At some level you would have to re-educate the three new council members. You've got two meetings, assuming that the changeover occurs on June 18th. And the next meeting's agenda is set. Yeah, we have one meeting to set the agenda. Next week's meeting is set. And I have no problem addressing it, but I do have a problem in addressing it without hearing from whether it's the stakeholders.

1:20:16 In the community, it's probably too short of a fuse to have a steering committee, but there's a lot of stakeholders, particularly on Main Street and Little Mammoth that we need to hear from. I also think, too, in regards to the North Village parking issue, we have potential development that may take place.

1:20:44 I think it's pretty, it's critical that we start those conversations now. Yeah. And see if we can, you know, if there's a bunch of partnership that can be had and not wait, you know, not wait to happen. In fact, if there's. Oh, no, clearly. If there's potential that, you know, I'm interested in all of this and we can start that as soon as possible because it's really an ideal situation for us.

1:21:12 Is there a possibility that we could coordinate and hear from, in particular, the Main Street, Mammoth stakeholders? Well, you know we've been publishing these meetings and they've had workshops. So how many individual business owners and land owners have you met during the course of your engagement?

1:21:35 A couple dozen. I mean, certainly the key ones, a good majority of the bigger owners have been very engaged. We've been meeting all day with folks. And I would just say, I mean, I was in the first part of this plan and then this part. We've met with a lot of people. We've talked to a lot of people. Everything that we've heard is reflected here. We're not...

1:22:01 We're not saying by, you know, by you guys looking at support. I mean, there's still a whole lengthy, a year process that goes into creating these. So really, I think where you guys have to look at what happens next is are you willing to get behind supporting that and or however the money comes together to do that, are you ready to say, all right, let's see where this leads us? Because I wouldn't go through another whole stakeholder engagement process.

1:22:29 Philosophically looking at the what ifs. I think people are done looking at the what ifs. I think they're ready for real stuff. Our only problem as a council, and it's good in a sense, is that in our next two meetings we'll be discussing our budget. So we have to find somewhere to commit whatever the dollar amount is. It could be up to $200,000. In our budget discussions we have to decide where that money's coming from and where it puts into our priorities overall.

1:22:59 And it's not easy with where we are financially right now. Yeah. Well, I wonder, too, I mean, if we do engage stakeholders and if there are private-public partnerships, if there wouldn't be some participation from those entities, even if they're a larger group, let's say the village, where there's a huge demand for parking up there, maybe as an organization they might be willing to say, okay, look, we'll go in as a group or as an organization. And at the very least,

1:23:28 Contribute something, whether it be legal or financial or whatever that could be to move the process forward, it might be a good way to start the ball rolling because I've gotten so many emails and calls in the recent months just on issues up there, whether it be business owners, existing business owners having problems with, you know, just more and more parking problems, having a problem with the pay parking that's going on.

1:23:53 Community Center and all these different things. I think it's worth the ask. I mean, believe it or not, I've seen it several times where the private sector pitches in for the creation of these districts. Well, our Main Street plan was paid for privately, so. So, I think it's worth an ask. The first one was, the second one was a Caltrans grant. Can we open it up to public? Yes, can we open it up to public? Tom, you're going to have to use the mic just because somebody's a homeowner wants to hear you. Because you have a really weak...

1:24:22 Tom Cage, so the comment about paying for it and to council, this is going to benefit business, property owners from Old Mammoth Road potentially to the village. So I would submit to the council that I don't think you should pay for it. I don't think the town as a whole should

1:24:50 Have the pressure to pay for it. If this is going to be something that's going to work, and as Mickey said, a stakeholder type of workshop like you conducted on Main Street, look, that's what's going to benefit. Have these people get together. There's enough of them, certainly, and maybe it's in stages. Maybe it's, okay, let's

1:25:21 Find $20,000 to do a very preliminary if everyone can sit in the room and hammer out some things and pay for some staff time and pay for, you know. And then if that works, then you have a little bit more that you add to. You eventually get to $200,000. It can be refunded upon creation of it. That's all fine. But have the people that it's going to benefit. It seems like government shouldn't try to do too much here because this could be a great windfall for

1:25:51 Areas, whether it's parking districts, whether it's savings and snow removal and trash and so forth and so on. So I would advocate to council, present and potentially present, there's some candidates in the room, that maybe the town shouldn't feel so compelled to have to pony up the dollars on this. Joe, do you have any thoughts? Of course.

1:26:25 Tom's going to talk, I'm going to talk. Another soft-spoken individual. Very quiet. John's work again. Yes, I agree with Tom 100%, but I do think it should be a combination of funds with the private sector and the public sector. And specifically, let's forget, we're all done with the, what are we going to do, and we're all done with all the paperwork. So...

1:26:53 To me, it's up to town council in the next two meetings to possibly to appoint a very small committee. The last one we had, I think, was nine people. That was David. We worked there for a year. My personal opinion is, based on what I learned today, I mean, it was really amazing. I mean, I went to three meetings with these people. They really explained it very well.

1:27:23 To me, it's a lot simpler today than it was yesterday. And I don't think it's going to take a whole lot of time to put something together and then come back to town council because I don't think town council can really make that decision without the information. And within 30 days, 60 days, I think town council, the new town council, Michael, will definitely be able to, we could come back with a plan. And you need to have somebody from the village, the three different districts because we all are different, but in thinking about this and

1:27:53 What they've done, because it's really great, because they don't really see who the individual people are, and we know who they are, so it's a roadblock for us, but they're saying, hey, this is what the districts are, this is what we see it. We all have our individual concerns, but on the other hand, I think that we can get together and make something as a town that in the next 10 years, we definitely will be happy we did that in 2014. What size committee? You said small. Not more than nine. I picked a number.

1:28:24 You know, I mean, we never have a very seldom nine people ever show up. But, Dave, I know, you like committees. What do you think of that number? You like that number? You point them and then, you know, their cash is coming back to Town Council with recommendations. I mean, actual dollar recommendations, where we're going to do what we're going to do. I like the idea. I didn't think we could do that. I like the idea. Because we're all, you know, most of us are opposed to putting money into the village.

1:28:54 If we're an old man of throat or main street. Nothing personal, just a fact. But if we could put money in up at the village, for instance, and we get a parking structure that's saving badly, and that money then can come down there, I think it's a win-win situation for us. I have a question for Jamie. Jamie, if the infrastructure financing district, the IFD, is town-led, we need a budget thing to think about the next meeting, and the council does.

1:29:23 Then wouldn't that have to be public money or what are the rules on that? In terms of how the setup is funded? Well, the PBID is stakeholder-led and the infrastructure financing district is town-led, so who pays for what? We'll take money from anyone. In terms of the setup, it doesn't really matter. The only thing that matters is if you're talking about repaying somebody for the startup costs out of that fund once it's set up. Because you talk about parallel tracks. Yeah.

1:29:52 Yeah, and the only thing we mean by town-led is that the IFD at the end of the day really requires more, it doesn't require like a stakeholder petition. There's an election, there's a vote at the end of the day, but it's really the town sort of leading the discussions with the taxing bodies and things like that. There's still significant stakeholder engagement in that. I just want to be clear. Can the IFD be private? It can, yes. It can be managed by a private body. Okay, yes.

1:30:22 One of the things that I would hope to see out of this is that the tremendous amount of work that's been done by our consultants and by staff and the engagement that they've had with the public, that we take this information and pass it along with the baton. We've got a new council coming in.

1:30:53 And they will be drinking from the water hose, from the fire hose here for a while. But by giving the new council solid information and direction, I think we would be doing them a service. And I believe we would be doing the community as a whole a service.

1:31:22 Comments like John was just making about doing something up at the village where the need is so dire, the parking, and then understanding that by doing that we're benefiting our whole commercial district at the end of the day. So it's this kind of collaborative thinking that is going to make something like this a reality and a possibility.

1:31:53 The comfort level that our consultants have brought to us I think is pretty exceptional for Mammoth and for the consulting world in general. So I'm very encouraged and I would hope that the Council would move forward in passing the baton to the new folks and giving them the encouragement.

1:32:24 Yes, indeed, here is something that it seems that we have a tremendous amount of public approval for, and if nothing more than the approval to go to the next step, the approval to, okay, let's start building these blocks and see if we can achieve what has been brought to us in a very, very comprehensive form.

1:32:53 How ironic would it be if a parking facility gets built in the village with an IFD, which is redevelopment, when the original village had redevelopment, building a parking structure. Exactly. And redevelopment is taken away from us. Yeah.

1:33:21 I thought you were going to say that was your first discussion on a council. How many years ago was it that the village was built? The village was 10. 11 years. Okay. Your suggestion would be starting a steering committee? Yeah. I think starting the steering committee and then making sure that it transitions in with the new council. Yep. And that we don't have to restart the process over again.

1:33:51 Okay. I think this council is strong enough to do that. So we have a... So it would be on the meeting on the 21st if we were to do that. It would be... Or the 4th. It would be the 4th and 21st and 21st. No, if this council were to do it. Or the 4th. Yeah, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. 21st. Correct. Or the 4th. I guess I'm thinking... I don't think we need to wait for the final report.

1:34:22 To recommend a steering committee. Yeah. So yeah, the fourth would probably be more appropriate, right? Possibly. Well, the fourth is as early as we can do it. So what I'm hearing is that we need to develop an agenda bill to move this forward in some fashion, whether it's the appointment of a steering committee or a stakeholder group or a council subcommittee or a combination of...

1:34:52 Community Development, or Community and Economic Development Commission members. I don't know what that is just yet, but I think we need to think about developing an agenda bill to move it forward. So Sandra, because I don't ever like to commit you to something without asking. So we have a Planning, Commission, Economic Development meeting on May the 28th? Yes. So would it be possible to...

1:35:22 Develop that agenda bill for that meeting. A staff report to your meeting. Right. Or a consultant. Right. That would recommend that we could then approve as a commission or vote on as a commission and then it could go forward to council that basically would recommend a stakeholders group to start doing the preliminary.

1:35:46 Research on the development stage. Yeah, we can put that together. I mean, it would be a brief report, you know, kind of following on this extensive discussion we've had, but yeah, we could do that. Does that work? Yeah, that makes sense. Okay. So long as there's sufficient time between your meeting, whatever you pass, to get it into a staff report and a bill for us, because that will be due.

1:36:10 Monday before the meeting. We'll just do it. We'll be brief. Okay. Thank you very much. So I just want to give one more opportunity. Does anybody else have any questions, comments? If not, I just would once again really like to thank our town staff who, Sandra and her group have worked on this. You've done a tremendous job.

1:36:41 Once again, to our three consultants, Nori, Jamie, Dennis, I mean, you did a fantastic job. You've been really patient in answering all our questions, giving us a great input. And on behalf of commission, to our three retiring council members, we really seriously appreciate the hours and hours you've put in.

1:37:07 We're very grateful for it and you've done some great things. So we just want to publicly thank you for that. Thank you. I appreciate it. Thank you. Compared to the hours that you guys put in. Yeah. Yeah, but we could put fun hours in. A rain of sand. All right, so we'll adjourn to the next regular. We'll adjourn.