TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2014

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 26 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

559 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 There we go. Okay. He's not here tonight? He's not here now. I don't know if we can get the five-minute John warning.

0:35 Yeah, that's true. Turn this one off. No, it's up to you guys. You know how to do it. I know how to do it. So, you know, it's really... Listen, if you have no questions, I'll have no answers.

1:05 Okay, here we are.

1:53 Classes. I mean, we had a LAFCO meeting, but we didn't do the magic show. LAFCO. I just got back to Chicago after you. It was a big food show. Restaurant show. It was really fun. Good time. Great restaurants. You can go there?

2:13 Music, food, art galleries.

2:42 John, thanks for making it.

3:03 We appreciate it. Hey, I'm going to meet you in the office. How are you doing, Michael? How are you? Good. Good. I'm smelling some stuff. That's all right. All right. Here we go. We will begin the workshop.

3:32 to discuss the fiscal year 2014-15 tentative budget. I think you just turned it off. Dan, welcome back. Thank you. I don't see any parasites coming out of you or anything. No. Days and nights aren't quite lined up yet, by the way, in good shape. 11-hour time zone difference. Yeah. Working through that.

4:05 Thank you, Council, in terms of taking a look at the tentative budget for 14-15. Hopefully walk through about eight slides here to give you a brief overview of about $36 million and how to spend it. Eight easy steps. A lot of the information will kind of follow through the staff report. I don't plan on hitting every item in there, so if you do have questions, we can address those.

4:33 If you have get into some detailed level questions, I'm going to defer that to Cindy. She did a lot of the input and the line item work and has that detail with her. So I'll provide the overview. We'll run from there. The direction to the department heads and to put the budget together, we're really looking at a relatively, basically a rollover budget or a flat budget in terms of looking at the initial revenue projections. Overall, when you compare to last year's adopted budget,

5:01 Not that's been amended throughout the year, but was actually adopted. Our operating revenues would be down just under $550,000. Part of that is due to some grants that we had last year that we don't have this year, and we've offset that in the budget through the expenditure side and those issues we've had to deal with. 14-15, the tentative of just operating revenues, which is basically net of transfers to $36.3 million, and last year about $36.8 million, so your difference there.

5:30 Same thing, the operating expenditures are down $112,000. As we balance out the general fund budget, that would move closer to $300,000 as we balance the budget. Again, last year, and this is in the total funds, $35.12 million for this year and $35.2 million for $13-14. I'm sorry, what's the significance of the $300,000? Right now, just in the operating budget as presented,

5:55 You're $112,000 less than last year. We're going to ask to balance the general fund, which will reduce another $180,000. So it'll be, that will go up. This is if he adopted the budget as is with no changes, which is not recommended. And the $35 million is a reflection of both our operating budget and our capital. All the restricted funds, general fund, capital fund, correct.

6:25 It's net of the transfers. When you add transfers in, it adds about another $12 million. I don't want to count it twice. That's why the net numbers here. We'll touch on that in more detail shortly. Overall, the employee costs are down about $170,000 from last year to this year. That's reflective of a couple of reductions in benefits I've accomplished, for example. It also has a net reduction. I meant that last bullet point should be the overall employees were down.

6:55 About four FTEs. Some of that is through the calculations and over part-time allocations, more so than full-time. The budget does incorporate the changes, though, that were presented from the organizational change a few months back that the council approved, which did put into the budget as a permanently funded position the police officer, code enforcement officer, and then the public works and finance director positions. So those are incorporated into the budget.

7:24 Fully funded. So they would have a base collectivity. So quick highlight overviews, that's kind of what's sitting there. Dan, while we're on employees, are there any significant increases coming out of any of the MOUs this year? No. So those that, they'll be up for this next year in the negotiations, but there's no significant impacts this year coming out. Just normal.

7:52 And when you build that in where people have room for a merit increase, there's no COLAs or other elements built in. And the 170 is a net number. You have some different issues between PERS, some increases there, but new employees have a lower rate. Medical costs went up a little bit, so there's some offsetting throughout that process. But it was interesting looking at adopted to propose about that $170,000 differential. This here is kind of a...

8:25 Tough to read chart from the distance, but this is kind of a snapshot of the total town budget on an all fund comparison. If you walk through that and look at that revenue column, it's broken out by the primary funds, the first one being the general fund that gets most of our discussion and debate. Gives you your total resource column, which includes transfers in and out, and then the same thing with the expenditure side, and that'll

8:51 End up with total appropriations. And there's a change there is just if you do the math, you get a change in what the fund balance would be. And the example now would be the general fund. It shows that $537,000 use of fund balance. Right now that would be reflective of a carryover of $350,000 for the planning department work, the council authorized for the completing the zoning code update. And so we're assuming that use of reserves is in place in the budget.

9:20 It's not a negative in that because it's not even allocated and set aside for that purpose. We allocated $400,000, we're assuming $350,000 carryover. We'll carry over whatever the actual is left July 1. And then the other differential is $187,000 we need to reduce to balance that budget. So the goal will have the general fund will be balanced with the use of the carryover funds as approved by the council in this current year.

9:48 And then that walks through each of the various funds with that analysis. And I can spend a lot of time on detail there or not. So bottom line, you'll end up with total resources of about $43.7 million with the transfers, with total appropriations of about $42.6 million. So you talk about what's the total town budget, you end up with a net number. But from an appropriation approval standpoint, you talk about $43.7 million total revenues.

10:17 Including our transfers for that number. New revenue, $36.3 million in new money coming into the town. Most of the debate that we have and discussed deals with the general fund. Little different presentation this year than last year in terms of looking at the department structure there, looking at the operating department's administration, which is basically council, manager, clerk, finance.

10:48 Personnel, those types of operational issues. And then you get the operating departments, police, parks and rec, community development, parks maintenance, engineering. And I've left public works a lot of it over with the snow and street maintenance. It falls into that. That also helps us in the calculations and we do reimbursement to the state. So that's why you'll see a large transfer to public works. And the transfers out of $2.4 million. It's really going back into...

11:15 Most of that is snow removal related and some of the other street board. And then you see the normal, the political commitment transfers, tourism, transit, housing, those are in there. And maintaining those commitments based on the prior year budget. Housing has an additional allocation for

11:36 Smoothing out their debt for next year. I can put more detail on that down the road here to explain that. And then we got the airport support out of the general fund of the others, and then debt service support is in there as well. So our total budget, $18.9 million. Again, if you back out the $350 million for the work in community economic development, we're looking at $18.5, almost $18.6 million as a tentative budget. Again, looking at reducing that.

12:07 To balance the budget, which would be the net number on the chart here, takes a look at our revenues. This basically follows the plenary numbers we presented a couple meetings back, looking at that TOT of about 11.6 million, property tax just under three, sales tax 1.8, and that kind of starts to round out. The fees and charges incorporates the admin side, police department, community development, public works are all in that fee number.

12:36 For that 18.3 million in revenue. There's a transfer in to the park side, which comes from the Whitmore track payment and Major R that comes in and offsetting some of those costs there. If you look at that net appropriation number and the revenue, that's where you come up with this $187,000 basic budget gap to balance out the general fund. Any question on the revenue? This is a very broad picture on the revenue side. There's a lot of detail to that.

13:06 Yeah, just on the TOT, I mean, the 11 million, that includes the estimated 500,000 in illegal activity income, right? Enforcement revenue, yeah. Enforcement, okay. So that's in the 11.6. That's in 11.6. If you just looked at pure TOT, it'd be about 11.1. It has that half a million on there. This year, we're sitting at 520.

13:35 25,000, 525? 525 in TOT enforcement, a little bit over, and that doesn't count nearly $100,000 in, that we're trying to collect on, that we've already been through all of the revenue processes and the appeals processes and to council, and so we've got close to $100,000 in collections on top of the 525 we've collected so far this year. So that's where that is, I mean, you're hitting the target at enforcement revenue, the question becomes, are there other ways to...

14:05 Not have to rely on people doing stuff illegally to generate a half a million dollars. Right. I mean, I guess that's my point. It's kind of, I mean, we're banking on, you know, a legal, we're banking on half a million dollars. More illegal assets. More illegal assets. Part of that is that enforcement includes getting people that are legally zoned to remit T.O.T. Right. That is part of it.

14:30 The enforcement effort in addition to the illegal rental. I think when the original group came to us and they had a large number, we knew that was over several years, so I think we've still got a few more years where we can count on that $500,000. Yeah, I guess that was my question. Is it realistic that we're going to collect at the same rate as we had in this past year? Yeah, I think there's more revenue there, and I just think that we need to tackle that at some point.

14:55 I think we just scratched the surface of it, honestly, based on what feedback we're getting from lodging. I think what your point is is that it's a legal activity that we're banking on versus it's like drug money or something. But, yeah, I mean, just based on the work we've seen in... No, it's not illegal. It's helping them to comply with the laws. Well, yeah, some of it's education. You're right. Education can be painful sometimes for some people. Yes. But, yeah. So you think that's a conservative aspect?

15:25 Well, I think the 500 is, I think it's attainable. I think a lot of it depends on staff levels we have and enforcement capabilities. It's, we're fine, and I'm going to touch on it in Councilmember Reports, but I think a lot of it has to do with the fact, you know, we're just getting our computer systems in place now where we can really rely on them. The more dedicated staff we have towards that effort, I think.

15:52 The more we can collect, and we've proven that this year when some of our staff got pulled away and then put it back, we saw a pullback in revenue collection, then it came right back, so I think that, I think it's worth the money to spend on staff time to collect that because of illegal, and a lot of it is legal, too. A lot of it are people that just aren't paying, but honestly.

16:20 As I mentioned, it's probably general judgment of the rollover budget that's reflected in that. And I wanted to, we included in the staff report kind of an overview of the 13-14 priorities and objectives. I wanted to touch on those briefly because the majority of those end up carrying forward into the current budget unless there's changes from council. I mentioned earlier kind of those political commitments in housing and transit and tourism is continuing. One thing I should note, in fact, we had

16:48 Put in the budget $4.7 million on the TBID. In discussions with John Urdi, the recommendation is to move that to $4.1. Ultimately, you pass through whatever we collect, but it does change the numbers in terms of did we hit or miss a budget number, plus for planning purposes, it puts it out. So that will be an adjustment we'll end up making. But we've held steady in terms of our commitments in those areas.

17:14 The other side of that was looking, one of the providers of council was looking at the economic development side of the house. Some of that came through the change in staffing in the organizational structure. We have the budget retains dollars, about $30,000 or $40,000 for ongoing work in economic development, consulting-based versus hiring the body that was originally looked at. And as I mentioned earlier, we have the dollars continuing over to complete the zoning code update in there.

17:42 As you just had the discussion on what went to, the TOT education enforcement is up and running and moving forward. One of the other priorities dealt with the MLR process, and you'll have a lot of discussion a little bit later on that, so it's proceeding again based on the council's priorities to move that forward. And then that may result, may not result in some budget amendments now or else later into the fiscal year.

18:06 The other side of that was a lot of the management work, IT funding. Last year I think we had about 60,000 going into equipment. There's about 45,000 committed to equipment and software this year. So we're continuing that investment in our equipment. The finance system replacement, I haven't put it in the budget yet, depending on the new finance director getting here. We've set aside about 130,000 for that at this point. As we get through that, that will come back to the council ultimately for

18:34 Direction to proceed. The question will be a full system or a phased in, depending on selected system and final cost on it. But that is dollars that are set aside and reserved for that purpose. That's $130,000? Yeah, about $130,000 is what we have currently set aside for that. And we probably need to push it to $200,000 ultimately, I think, to probably get full-scale system.

19:00 But again, we won't know until we do a little more research. And we've looked at a couple different systems. One of them is probably in the 300,000 range, and I've seen others about in the 125 range. So it'd be nice to have a little stronger integration across some of our platforms in the town. So a little more money there may be beneficial. Overall, with the organizational structure everybody touched on, we've modified that. We've done a fair amount of work just internally, like on the IT side, the other one you're aware of, we work with the county.

19:30 Frankly, getting located into the facility here I think is beneficial to us and to them, so it's been a real plus for us. And then also just our employee engagement program has been, I think, well received and some of the stuff we'll do with employees. Most recently was a bike today, lunch in the park, bike to work day, I think. I was out of town, so. But anyway, it went well. We're doing some stuff that way. I think it's enhanced a lot of the communication across departments.

19:56 And then lastly, probably the one area that we haven't added as much dollars to was hoped was in our road maintenance budget. Originally it was $750. It got reduced to $590. There was a goal as we have additional dollars to try to push that back up to the $750, even up to a million for road maintenance. We're not there yet. That's, again, a funding issue for us. One of the options we are looking at this year is to the extent that we have savings in the roadside of the current budget is not to let that fall back.

20:26 Basically to the general fund side, but to leave that in the road budget side so those dollars that are saved there continue to be utilized for purposes there. Do you think there will be savings unless they get the low snow year? I believe right now, brief discussion today, probably in the $100,000 range, maybe a little more. Part of that would be one of the methods that we would look at to not have to come back if we have some contingency challenges. I know the Canyon Boulevard project has some interesting findings.

20:56 Underneath the existing pavement, they've run into some stuff that you don't know until you start digging. So there will be some stuff there. I don't think there will be substantial overruns, but there will be some additional costs, it sounds like. And then the other piece, obviously, you had a discussion before, the Waterford Bridge, the gap closure, looking at funding for that as well, a complete project as a complete project would be a goal.

21:23 So I think we will have some dollars left there. The idea is to keep them in that fund and committed to roads versus having it fall back into the general fund side in the REU, for example. So based on that, those policies, I think good guidelines, I think we've made great headway in all of them, if not achieving some of them very well. And so those changes or opportunities, I guess, are embedded in the current budget, I guess, is what I'm getting at. So it's kind of rolling those.

21:53 Forward with the one area where he didn't hit the target would be in the road maintenance side. Any questions on that? There was a task at the end of the staff report that kind of highlighted those priorities and where we were at on them. I thought that was a good status update, just kind of where we were at. I'd just like to commend Cleland Hoff and Shields Richardson for being here this evening. We've got eight candidates running for town council. We've got two of the eight.

22:24 Here, reviewing the town's budget for the next year, and, oh my gosh, if you're a candidate for town council and you don't understand the town budget, you're starting off a bit behind the curve, so thank you, Cleland and Shields, both of you, for being here. The last piece of the general fund was really trying to look at basically balancing the last piece, the last 187,000.

22:52 My goal was to have a balanced budget where if your operating revenue, operating expenditures are equal to the extent possible revenues are a little higher than your expenditures. Hats off to the staff. Push them pretty hard to put in a budget that was realistic and, you know, well, can I ask for X or X, Y, and Z? The answer is no. It's that rollover concept in the budget. I think that allowed us to get to a...

23:20 Option to be able to balance the budget without a lot of consternation or, frankly, a lot of pain in the organization. One of the other goals was to be able to do this without having to go back in and reduce our staffing levels in terms of layoffs and reductions in those areas or give back from employees. We've achieved that. The recommendation to, this is kind of an outline of kind of, I guess, my priorities of looking at how I would balance the budget out for the last couple hundred thousand dollars.

23:50 The number one priorities there deal with we have one current and maybe a potential. We have vacant positions that we can look at. I think we can have some savings there just in some additional restructuring. The interfund charge for our comprehensive leave, we've gone through that a couple different times. Depending on past actuals, I believe we can reduce that charge by $25,000 without really impacting that fund or the issues there.

24:19 Going back to the budgets, I think we can cut another $50,000 in operations. There's a couple areas there that I think are very doable. And then lastly, it's discussed in the staff report, but we get a payment for a land exchange from the hospital. There's a fund balance item that comes in. A chunk of that is offsetting the payment to our...

24:45 Vehicle Fund from the loan that was made, but there's $56,000 that would be additional there. A recommendation would be to use that. Those four categories, about $150,000, can be done, in my mind, without really having an increased significant impact on operations or current programs. The second grouping of potential reductions, mostly doable but some questionables on it, the debt service refinancing, we've been working on that.

25:14 I talked with the financial advisor yesterday and based on the current market moves and stuff, that may get pushed out further, so that one's less likely at this point. Increasing our sales tax revenue is a potential in reviewing our consultants' review. They have a higher projection than we use. I don't mind being conservative. They're looking at a couple different factors, and the hard part for us was really looking off of the current year, knowing it was probably low because of the low snow year.

25:44 Still would rather be conservative in that area, but there's probably some revenue tweak there we could do. As far as reducing our contingency funding, it's currently at 100,000. The last couple of years, I think it's been zero, so anything you put there would be a plus. Reducing it by 25 is, I think, a doable thing in terms of leaving at least 75,000 and unknown at this point. And then the other piece dealt with the smoothing proposal we have for the

26:13 Potential payment of housing loans. We have two HELP loans from the state. One is due in September of 2015 and then the other one is two years out from that. It's about a $400,000 payment that would come up in September. The concern there was not next year but the following year having to have the full $400 if we don't get any loan payments. It seemed to be a lot easier to put $200 years aside over time versus...

26:41 Taking these big swings where one year you need 400 and the next year zero, then you're back up to 300 or 400 again. Trying to smooth that makes budgeting a lot easier. I think it makes planning for the future easier and it lies in there much simpler. We can reduce that. There's 200,000 recommended for the current year. If you wanted to reduce that down a little bit this year, we can. It pushes that issue to next year again to have to deal with. So the extent we don't have to do that, it makes life easier next budget cycle.

27:11 But it's an option there we wanted to throw out because it can be done. And then the last two elements there was either just taking everything out of reserves and calling the budget balance, which I don't recommend. And then the other one would be go back and have the departments just cut everything out of the operating budgets also, which would probably get into positions, which we don't recommend. So as we start to walk through this again, we're talking less than 1% of the total budget, so we're not big numbers here.

27:39 From a staff recommendation side, I would say do the first four items. Reduce your contingency by the $25,000 and tweak the revenue side by the remaining few thousand dollars and you would have a balanced general fund budget. We'll do another round through the budget to make sure that we've hit everything correctly. I guess on here a couple of things I have for council would be is if there's something on here that you want off the table, then we ought to hear that.

28:09 Changing in those priorities would rather feel more comfortable with the different piece being utilized. We'd be glad to do that as well. It's not a lot of debate there, I don't think, but it allows at least for a little bit of dialogue in terms of closing the final gap in the budget. Can you answer any questions on any more of the detail on those that need be? If not, got a simple solution, I think.

28:33 We had the debate where we just give you a balanced budget and not have to make any decisions. Well, you've almost done that. Yes. How was the goal? Yeah, easy. Close. Well, we spoke about this slide. To me, the using one-time funds for ongoing operations is a little bit tough. I would almost put that at a 1.5 that, you know, because...

28:58 If we put the excess hospital payment in there, then we're short that money the following year because it is one-time money. Is there a way to structure it in such a way that it would be the last thing that was actually applied? Because, you know, a budget is an estimate. And when we get around to, you know, actual expenditures, if we can achieve the savings, which often happens just because of the time it takes to get the next person in a job, et cetera, I would rather see that one.

29:27 Not that that not be actually implemented or the money not transferred until a later point when we know for sure that we actually need to do it. And what you could probably do on that is you could show it because it would actually show the use of reserves that's where it hits the fund balance when the money comes in. You could show the budget having that $56,000 deficit with the idea of closing it through other means.

29:51 Versus actually spending it out of the reserves, yes. But then on the other hand, if that $56,000 went into the REU and at the end of the year we were the $56,000 short, it's going to come back out to cover it. That's essentially what I'm saying. You just show it as a budget gap that would be balanced out of reserves regardless. Rather than up front say that we're going to fund ongoing costs with one-time money.

30:21 And that, yeah, that's a viable option. Last year, I think the whole amount was utilized to balance the budget, so it's there for that. And then when we get through the next iteration of the staff, that that may be reduced on how much we need as well. It may work. What's the council's thoughts on that? And also, what about the optics of it? We have a really unbalanced budget. Well, I would say,

30:51 Put it there, but not actually pull the trigger to transfer the money. It would show it as being appropriated. It would show it appropriated, but that's what we're saying is that it's not just an automatic, yeah, go ahead and spend to that level. Because, no, I'd want the budget to look balanced, but wouldn't want to pull that trigger. I'm also okay with some reduction to contingency.

31:18 Which is actually down in the second one as maybe, you know, something else to hold back on because if we have a better winter, we'll have a little bit more and we wouldn't need as much of the contingency that's there for who knows what. But I'm also okay with leaving that in the second grouping. I kind of think, I don't have a problem with it the way it's laid out because it's just a one-year budget. If it was a five-year budget, I'd have more of an issue with it.

31:51 I know we've done that in the past where we didn't use one-time funds looking out for a longer period of time. So I think there's probably some one-time expenses that are probably built in somewhere in there as well. I personally am okay with it the way it's presented. Yeah, I think if it were just longer term, I would have the same issue, Joe. And maybe, as you said, if we use it as a placeholder, if it's used as a last thing, that's probably a good way to go about it.

32:18 I don't have a problem with using all the first four as presented. Yeah, your other option in that, if you wanted to, I mean, you could turn around and say that 56,000 can stay in REU as a contingency and cut your contingency accordingly, knowing if you need it, we come back and pull others. Yeah. Yeah. That's the other. Mm-hmm. So you'd go down to 25 or 30,000. Yeah. Yeah.

32:42 Kind of six to one half. Yeah, I want us to show a budget balance, but I wanted to have, you know, I just don't want us to, everybody to presume that they've got every single penny in there to spend. Right, I like your ultimate idea. I do too. So we could show that adjustment that way, that way it would still show, we can get to a balanced budget and kind of like we did last year, mid-year, hey, we're going to have to use some REU, so come in and. Yeah.

33:08 The contingency is nice that we have an immediate need. It's appropriate. It's authorized and they'll spend it. But it would still leave some dollars there, obviously. So for clarification, are we reducing the contingency line item by the $56,000? Yes. Yeah, plus I'd say we use it by that plus to $25,000 and then we'll just have a smaller amount. Yeah. But we'll have dollars in the REU then. Reduce contingency for $25,000.

33:37 Yeah, give a little less than that. Reduce it to that amount. Okay. Because you take the 25 as recommended plus the 56. Got it. Right. And if we squeeze a little other dollars out of budget reductions, we'll add to bump up the contingency a little bit. Dan, I was looking at our budget in the year 1989-1990. So it goes back, what, 25 years? So 25 years ago, approximately, our budget was 6.3 million. So it's basically tripled.

34:06 In 25 years. And that's not bad. And because it was a growing community, growing town, growing services, and so forth. I think TMT triple two. Exactly. Yeah. Sort of cost a living. So I did experience for something. Yeah. But the kind of consensus to do that, we'll utilize that, to balance that, we come back to the plan of adoption June 4th, that would then be incorporated. I just need consensus. I don't necessarily need a...

34:34 Motion or something. Yes. Yes. Okay. Yeah. It was not to give you really, you know, heavy debate issues, but we're glad to take on any other items here. One other question, Dan, is, you know, you mentioned that hopefully there's $100,000 to roll over on the road work or the other capital projects. And you didn't mention exactly, but are we going to be able to fund it at least as road at rehab at least at the current year budget level? Yeah, $590,000, yes.

35:04 It's not where we want it to be, but it's correct. Okay. It's, yeah, it'd be nice to see it at $750 or better, but at this point. Okay. So if we get the $100,000, I'll bring it to $690? Yeah, it'd push that up. Some of that may be utilized for a couple of the other capital projects, one being the bridge gap work, and we need contingency dollars for, but I'd rather try to target that out of additional savings versus using we have a listing budget for those other projects, so.

35:33 So just so everybody understands, essentially what you're saying is reserving some funds that would not be part of fund balance when the current year is closed out, they would already be allocated into something else. Yeah, they'd be sitting over a gas tax fund for these other projects and we would do that as part of a final budget. That way it doesn't drop back into the general fund to an REU of not coming back and say unless you use these reserves and move back. Correct. John, is that all right with you? Absolutely. All right.

36:04 Because, I mean, I know that that's a focus, has been a focus of yours. What did we do in 1989? Did we have an REU? And that'll kind of tie into some of the final budget preparation work. I know we have some minor adjustments I've seen in the budget, nothing that's substantial. I've got one like a $600 adjustment. But there's a couple little things in there. I mentioned the T-bit adjustment.

36:33 We will have to do some update on the major RU budgets, just cleaning those up with the allocations that were already made for 14-15, that other stuff is on hold. The one discussion there I had in the staff report looked at, I think we had $15,000 allocated in the parks allocation with staffing. Normally that comes in the second allocation down the road.

36:55 If we don't utilize the funds, that would come back into the general fund as a cost. So at this point, I've left that in the budget. We'll highlight that more on the fourth. But what we haven't put in R&U is any administrative budget. We've held that zero pending final direction from the council ultimately on those. So we've absorbed some things in the general fund, that being one of them, the other being some of the grants we had last year we don't have this year. So there's been a lot of other juggling throughout the...

37:25 General Fund has made it quite tight. So you're speaking of the 4% from the... Yeah. Those are, yeah, those are, that's, we have... $75,000, $80,000. Yeah, we have not budgeted that. It's zero. Right. So. But we do have the work allocations for some of the park maintenance and things each year that's come out of those funds that would be over and above the 4% normally. That's the...

37:54 Other piece of that. We'll walk through that in more detail in the fourth, but just a heads up. Some of that was pending what happens this evening. So those budgets will need a little bit of work on the R&U budgets. And then we mentioned the road work target, and I mentioned the T-bit adjustment. The other thing that we're bringing forward will be a master fee resolution. I think the last few rounds have been piece milled fees, so we're trying to get one resolution to come in.

38:23 There will be adjustments, some ups and downs. There's not a significant change in terms of increases there. We are looking at some modifications in how we calculate some of the fees, building fees in particularly, looking at going to the international code building valuation table versus the current system we have. I think it simplifies the process and makes it more consistent with, I'll say, other communities, even the code itself.

38:52 A couple of the others were looking at that question of does it make sense to cost accounts. Some of the projects would just go to a flat fee based on where we're seeing the averages and simplify some of our paperwork. The other question will be dealing with the impact fees. We currently have a waiver in place for a number of those fees based on the project size. I think that expires in July, so looking at the policy question, obviously I'm continuing that. We're in the process of looking at the impact fees in total.

39:22 One of the options, need to spend more time on it, there may be a recommendation to actually waive or suspend a number of the impact fees for a period of time to complete a recalc on a few of them. There's some valid questions on a few that need to get addressed. We'll need to bring forward the continuation of the parcel fee for solid waste. We've been working with the county on that as part of the overall waste management plan.

39:49 Some elements there. Mentioned the capital project funding through the Waterford Gap one in there, but also we'll have contingency needable lead and I'll come back to some policy items for the final budget. And if there's anything else the council wants to see in the final budget, I'd be glad to bring that forward. If there's anything else, I'm trying to make this painful as possible. Painless.

40:14 Yeah. It was painful a year ago. Yes. Yeah. And again, you know, putting it together in terms of the department. It's been painful for six years. Yeah. I think it's not. I guess with the departments working through it again, just in terms of kind of rolling those budgets over and people obviously not getting everything they want, but I think not having to go backwards has been a big step.

40:39 So unless there's other questions for myself or if you need some detailed questions, Cindy has a lot of information there, we can address that or we can address any type of public discussion and comments as well. Any more questions from Council? Dan, I can't, this isn't a question, just a comment and, you know, I have to take the opportunity and that is, I like this, the way that you want to handle those HELP loans, loan repayments.

41:07 From housing, that smoothing proposal. And second, just in a related way, I see that housing has been funded at $554,000 as opposed to $730,000, which is about a 30% reduction from what has been...

41:30 Politically, previously politically exempt funds. That's consistent with the last couple of years, but can't help but say it because housing is still not getting those voters that indicated it should get even with the $200,000 or with what would have been $400,000 next year to repay those health loans. Last but not least, those health loans, as we know, I'm just saying it to reiterate it, is actually an investment because

42:00 We loan those funds out and get those funds back to reloan in the future as the workforce housing turns over. Correct. Yeah, yeah, last year those dollars, there was a debt service payment of about $272,000 last year that was made. That was paid off, and that actually helps the smoothing factor, keeping that. Yeah, it makes a lot of sense to me.

42:23 A little clarification on these particular loans for housing. We're not using that program, or housing isn't utilizing that program anymore because of the structure of the loans. So when that money comes back, it's coming back. We won't re-loan it. But we won't? But we could. We could. The period of those loans were given out for like a 30-year period, but we had a 5 or 10-year period to pay it back. Right, that's the gap. Yes.

42:52 Thank you. But we're not utilizing that same program. Got it. But the funds can't hold you. Right. Policy question. Yeah. Yes. All right. Other questions, comments. How about from the audience? Questions or comments? Now is your turn to ask or provide us with some direction or advice. And I don't see any languages.

43:22 I can't tell you what a difference a year makes. Just, you know, just leave it at that. Wow. We'll go in line by line down every single department. I think the department had to appreciate that too. Well, we had to at the time. I mean, it was trying to find every penny. Exactly.

43:46 Yeah, well, I'm, I guess we're fortunate in that it seems to be, there seems to be no opposition to having a flat budget. So, you know, in a way, we have really very much to talk about. Yeah, it is. Because we already have. So, all right, anything else? Flat is the new up. Yeah. Flat's better than declining. There you go. All right, well, thank you. No, from staff, so.

44:13 Appreciate the presentation and we'll adjourn. John's ready to go home or go get a tie on. Talk to Cindy. You've got 14 minutes to put your tie on, John. So we'll reconvene at 6 o'clock. They're coming. The bus is outside.

45:58 All right, good evening, and welcome to the Town of Mammoth Lakes Council meeting for Wednesday, May 21, 2014. Jamie, roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. If you would please rise and join Mayor Pro Tem Bacon in the Pledge of Allegiance. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic which it stands.

46:28 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, welcome everybody. This is the time for public comment, which is the established time for any member of the public who wishes to speak on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. If you've got something to talk to us about or the community about, please come forward, John Urdi. Hey, good evening, John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We've got a couple of things. This Friday evening from 5.30 to 6.30,

46:59 At Jimmy's Taverna, we have Congressman Cook from District 8 is going to be in town. Public meet and greet, everyone is welcome. More the merrier, we'd love to have people come out and meet the congressman. He's coming out of his first year, first term. I had an opportunity to meet with him back in February when I was back in D.C. He's very well versed on our issues with sage grouse and frogs and toads and all those great things. So that's 5.30 to 6.30. Jimmy's, Friday night.

47:29 John, before you go on, real quick, I just wanted to reinforce what John is saying and to remind us all that we had a similar congressperson that was in that position, Buck McKeon, who got the town two transportation grants, one grant to purchase buses for our transportation system and a second grant.

47:58 So that we could purchase the transit facility down the industrial park. So here we have a representative coming to town to see us, and it's an opportunity to build that relationship to see if that representative can get us something that we need. Absolutely, and the support in Washington is fantastic, and he's, like I said, he's very well versed. District 8 is a huge district for the state as far as land, you know, sheer mass.

48:26 There's probably not as many people as most, but he's got a lot of ground to cover, and so to have him here is a great opportunity. He's actually, I think, the Grand Marshal for the Mule Days Parade on Saturday morning, so we've got him here Friday night. Great opportunity for folks to come out and meet him and get to know him. He's a wonderful guy, a retired colonel, just a very, very easy guy to chat with, so I look forward to meeting back with him in D.C. as well. Thank you. That's exciting. Secondly, just wanted to make an announcement. I know that it was announced at the last council meeting.

48:54 Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board of Directors is looking for three new positions. We have an open seat for restaurant, we have an open seat for retail, and we have an open at-large seat. So interested parties need to send information, basically just biography, kind of a quick letter of interest as to why you want to be on the board, to info at visitmammoth.com by this Friday, and then we're going to start setting up interviews for the first week of June, I believe.

49:22 Those interested, info at visitmammoth.com. Just write us something as to why you want to participate with the board and what you've got for history in town. Good. Great. Thank you, John. Thank you. Pudding is still open for members of the public who wish to speak. Sandy. Sandy Hogan. And I'd like to make some of the same comments that I made to the MLR committee on Monday. They have nothing to do with the agenda. It has to do with the fact that I sent out

49:53 An electronic flyer that was sent to me with a request that it be sent out anonymously. And I did. It isn't like a chain letter or anything like that. I don't send those out. But it was one that was thoughtful. And we live in a small community. And I've lived in a lot of sizes. This is probably the smallest one.

50:19 A lot of our neighbors and our friends and our business associates have different opinions from the ones we do. And so while they may express them to you personally or to a few friends, they really are reluctant to share them, you know, with everybody. And so this one I looked at and I realized the reasons why this person had to not want to put a name to them and I sent it out. And actually I've had very few comments that were, you know, they said, oh, it's anonymous.

50:48 Because it was a thoughtful thing. Whether I agree with all the points in it or not, I was asked to do so, and I did so. So anyway, I do want to say that, and I do want to also thank the fact that the MLR folks have really made a lot of progress, even though sometimes our comments I know haven't been graciously accepted. But that's okay. You know, we understand that. Hopefully they've been constructive, and I've seen a lot of good progress. So I did want to mention that. Okay, thank you.

51:18 Thank you, Sandy. The podium is still open for public comment. Leah? Good evening. My name is Lee Gosh. I'm here this evening to speak to you about the emergency cards that I started back in 2011. I'm very proud of these cards. They are extremely successful. I have passed out over 20,000 of them in the last three years.

51:47 My guide dogs and I, Jamin, Flana, and Filbert, have had a blast going to every store to make sure they're there. We monitor them. I know exactly how many are in each store, which stores they work at, and which stores they don't. And the stores really liked them because there was no advertising on them. And I'm here this evening to let you know that I thank Brent Harper, our Mammoth Lakes fire chief, for helping me out on this.

52:15 He was a big supporter of this. But I don't feel it's right for the fire department to be helping out on this one now because they have fire dangers coming up. It comes from the Fire Safe Council. And they've got a lot of education and outreach to have to do this summer. So I am unable to do this and would like to pass it on to the town. I know the town very much wanted to do it when I first started it.

52:40 There's a lady that works for the CERT that wanted to be involved in this also. She talked to me about it in the last six months. Maybe you can partner with her. But if you make it too big, people aren't going to read it. They're not going to pay attention to it. And so I just wanted to let you know that. There was an anonymous person that paid for half of it last summer. But again, it's time to pass it on to the town as it is education for the town and it's something for the town to do.

53:07 You can do it any way you want to, but it would be nice to partner with the CERT if you could, and that's what I need to tell you. But Brent Harper, I thank you for your support on this through the years. Thank you. Lee, real quick, curiosity, did you see the recent article on the Chinese lady that was training her four adult dogs? No? Okay. What is it? I'll have to forward it to you. Okay. It's about training and how she...

53:37 Trains them to sit at the bench before they feed, and then she feeds them individually, and then when they finish, they pick up the bowl and come around the bench and give it back to her after they finish. They're just really well trained. I thought maybe you'd seen it. Another person you might think about talking about this is the parking, or not parking recreations, but the tourism department. John Urdi might be a good one with the town and John Urdi to look at this also. But I thank you very much.

54:04 I thank all the businesses because each one of them really liked it. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Point is still open. Larry. Good evening. I'm Larry Johnson. I'm chairman of the Mono County Board of Supervisors. And I'm also on the Treasury Pool Advisory Committee. And I'd just like to give you a brief report. We had a meeting last week about that. Right now, we have about 30 local...

54:38 Agencies involved with us. They include the June Lake Fire District, the Long Valley Fire District, Bridgeport PUD, the June Lake PUD, Lee Bining PUD, the Southern Mono Hospital District, the Mammoth Community Water District, the Eastern Sierra Unified School District, Mammoth Unified School District, Office of Education, and others. And in that pool, we have about $65 million that we manage.

55:08 And we get not very much interest, but we get .86 in the last quarter, .86% interest on that. We would like to invite you, again, to join us, because you get .23%. And I have a little handout for you that shows that you're now getting the lowest ever in the local agency formation ever.

55:37 Since 1977. And we can... I'd love to get .23 on my savings. ...quadruple that for you. How do I jump? Well, if I remember, we deferred this to the new finance director getting here. Yes. For staff to reveal it. Yeah. Right. So if you had, for example, if you had joined about a couple months ago,

56:04 I would have been able to bring you a $5,000 check because it's about $100 a day that these agencies are getting over what LAF pays, which is a local agency investment fund, which is a state-operated fund. So it's a grand opportunity. Again, I'd offer to have Leslie Chapman, our finance director, and Rose Glazier, who's the person who manages our fund for us, come and speak with you.

56:33 Certainly invite you to one of our next meetings that we would be discussing this. It amounts to about $30,000 to $40,000 a year, and all you have to do is change your checking account and come with us. So thank you very much. On the back you'll see the differences between what LAF is getting and what the county investment pool is getting. Mary, this is something that you, my choice of words, schooled us.

57:04 About at a meeting two or three meetings ago under public comment, the third time you repeated what you had said, I said, Larry, we got it, and you finished up. So you said the same thing three times, and now you're coming back again and saying it for the fourth time. I think we got your message, and I think that we indicated what our plan of action was.

57:30 So thank you for your input. I'm glad to hear that. And again, we welcome you to join us and take a look at it. Set it for an agenda if you like. Have Mr. Holler talk to our group. Got it. So, okay, thank you very much. Larry, thank you. Putting them still open. Public comments? Seeing none, we'll move to councilmember reports and additions to the agenda. John, can we certainly agree? Yes, I have none, Mr. Mayor. Thank you.

57:58 Yes, I do. Just one second here. I had two items. One, I attended our TOT enforcement meeting the other day, and as we stated in our workshop earlier, our TOT group has been given the challenge or goal of really trying to obtain, you know, half a million dollars in uncollected funds, and I wanted to report that

58:27 That group did meet that. It worked with our finance department, some folks in the lodging community and whatnot. To date, there's $521,000 was collected for 2013-14 year thus far, and they have about $144,000 in notices of determination, which is essentially pending or potentially pending funds for folks that were not compliant in TOT.

58:55 I just want to say good job to those folks for the work they've done on there. I know that there's been a lot of hurdles in the midst of trying to collect these funds. They've been trying to get a computer system up and running or really a new program for enforcement. And amidst all that, they've done a good job. So I want to say thanks to everybody involved on that. And then the other item I just wanted to throw out there because we have one more meeting left, I think three of us do.

59:22 And just a real quick note, I wanted to say that, you know, the last four years has been challenging. The last year, you know, we've had a tough drought, and I know that can be challenging for a lot of businesses out there and a lot of folks in general. And I think with the coming of a new fiscal year, it's really just a good opportunity for us all to reset. And, you know, I think we have a good summer, something to look forward to. The weather's...

59:48 Typically pretty predictable in the summertime and we've got a lot of new events growing events that are going to come so Hopefully we have something to look forward to and you know God willing we have a good snow year I think it's gonna it's gonna be a good positive time for us so Just wanted to throw that out there and that's all I have mr. Mayor. Thank you

1:00:09 Just one item. I'd like to thank the community for Town Cleanup Day. There was an awful lot of orange bags passed out and filled up. And for the staff who worked the stations, I had the easy job. I just sat at Mammoth Creek Park and handed out information. But yes, thank you. Town looks great again, and especially with that little sprinkling of snow on top. Yes, we did. All right. Thank you, Jo. I have no report either. It takes us to...

1:00:39 Reports from commissions and or departments. Any commission members or department heads which to come forward? Stuart. Evening, Mayor. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. I'll always come and say something. So just to reiterate and to compliment the community for Town Cleanup Day, it was a great effort. We saw a lot of people come out. We took away about 16 roll-offs out of the Surro Valley sites, which is pretty big. They're coming and going every 45 minutes, I think.

1:01:13 Those roll-offs. So I do want to thank a lot of people. The town's putting together a big thank you letter. So that'll be in the papers hopefully the following week. But a great success. And as you said, the town is much better for it and ready for our summer next week, hopefully. Tomorrow. That'll be nice. Lap swimming has begun at the Whitmore Pool. That began on Monday. Swim team has also started their training. Although they weren't able to train at the pool. It was a bit cold. But anyway, that program is up and running. Tennis.

1:01:44 Tennis Lessons is also back at the Community Centre Tennis Courts. We've secured a pro for the season. We haven't had a tennis pro for a couple of years now, so we're excited about that. That will commence in June, late June, every Tuesday and Thursday afternoon. Tennis courts are also open, and the restrooms will be open tomorrow. A little water issue up there, so that's all good.

1:02:09 Fish stocking began in the Lakes Basin on Tuesday. Obviously it snowed, so that's when we started to stock our fish. Don't figure it out. Fish don't care. So maybe we should do fish stocking in November. I'm not too sure. But anyway. 1,200 pounds or approximately 340, 3.5 pound rainbow trout was stocked, which is some pretty big fish. I had one in my hand.

1:02:35 So we stocked in upper and lower Twin Lakes Lake Mary and Lake Mamie. We couldn't actually get up to Lake George because of the snow. Our next load, we're going to add a load actually to make up for some loss of loads later in the season is on June 10th. So we'll be stocking over 1,500 pounds on June 10th and we'll get all those lakes again. So we'll get that for the July 4th and then we'll be another one I think around that time. So we're back on schedule. So that's exciting.

1:03:04 And then just want to let you know that all our summer camps and programs for the community are online, mammothrecreation.com, so they can be reserved at any time along with our many facilities. So that's all I had. Here we go. Summer. Tomorrow. Hopefully. Stuart, thank you. You're welcome. Yeah, great job. You're welcome. Good news. Chief Watson. Yes, good evening. I'd like to announce that the Police Community Hispanic Advisory Committee is hosting another town hall meeting. It will be on Friday, June 6th, starting at 4.30.

1:03:37 At the Grand Sierra Lodge, our presenters this time we'll have a representative from the Mexican Consulate who will talk about some program services they're providing the next day in town. Mammoth Lakes Housing will be discussing the results of their housing survey. We have a representative from the Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which at the last one we had a few months ago, we asked the crowd if they felt comfortable in having somebody from ICE come.

1:04:06 This wouldn't have happened three years ago. And there was a resounding affirmative response that they wanted to hear somebody to come from ICE to talk about their enforcement policies and answer questions. And the last presenter will be an immigration rights attorney from Fresno who's been here a couple of times and has been very informative. After we have a break, we'll have questions and answers as we always do for the sheriff and myself. And that's going to be the program.

1:04:35 Something else that is recent, the Hector Gonzalez from the Superior Court presented our program, what we're doing with our outreach program with the community and has received official recognition from the California trial courts as a model program for community outreach efforts and is included in their innovation and knowledge center website for other communities to learn from our experience. So I think that's a nice positive indication that what we're trying to do here is being recognized by others.

1:05:05 So that's all I have. Great, thank you. Peter. Council Members, Peter Burns County, Public Works. Just want to let you know, we did finish the Whitmore track, or Whitmore Park barbed wire fence, so we shouldn't have any more problems with cattle as we've had in the past few years. That was plundered by a measure of our project. Ten on cleanup day, we collected over 50 tons of garbage.

1:05:33 And we'll get the breakdown of the recycle, but really we made a good effort to divert as much trash from the waste stream as possible. And CalRecycle will be here again in July for another process review to see how we're doing with events. Peter, if CalRecycle comes in July, will we have anything new to report as far as communication working with Mono County?

1:06:04 The trash facility to update Cal Recycle on making progress? And our ordinance. Okay. Well, ordinance updates for sure. Okay, good. Okay, good. Thank you. All right, thank you. Moves us to consent agenda items 2 through 6. Any member wish to pull any item? Yes, Mr. Mayor, I'd like to pull item number 6. And I'd like to pull number 3.

1:06:37 All right, six and three is a motion with two, four and five. So moved. I'll second. Jamie, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to three, which is entitled, Accept and Update, Regarding Old Mammoth Road Conservation and Landscape Modification Efforts. Dan, I apologize for not talking with you about this this morning, but

1:07:06 I think it would be relevant for the community and council members and so forth if you could give just a brief update of what communication you've had with the water district on this issue. Sure. As you know, the water district has been to the Planning Commission and the council regarding our water use and excessive relief water use on our landscape areas, particularly on Old Mammoth Road, not so much on Main Street.

1:07:38 We're still over on Main Street. So this project, what we're looking at is to reduce our water use and eliminate the grass, most strips on Old Mammoth Road. Essentially, the water district told us that if we don't change our habits, they'll shut the meter off and so we won't have any water. We've had several meetings with property owners and the planning commission, we gave them an update.

1:08:05 We have another flyer we're putting out for the property owners again to see which ones want to assist with an implementation of maybe expanding their existing landscape into that street area, so bring people a little bit closer to the street curb. And then other areas will be changing the irrigation to more of a drip, sub-drip system, so it won't be completely eliminated as far as landscape, but we're...

1:08:34 Looking at alternatives to putting in grass. And we've had this communication with the water district, so they're aware of the efforts we're trying to make? Correct. Okay. Thank you. So in the meantime, have the water patterns changed? Or is the water shut off? I wasn't clear from this what the status is. Yeah, so we are going ahead currently.

1:09:00 Turning on the system, testing the pipes and repairing any leaks that occurred over the winter. We'll be transforming that system into a drip system on the areas that are going to continue to be irrigated this year. We don't have a budget, sufficient budget to really redo the whole street in one season. We'd need, you know, three to five hundred thousand dollars to really do that. So we've got twenty thousand dollars in the, that

1:09:26 In the assessment district budget that we'll be using some of this year and then there'll be another 20 or so in next year's budget which is some of that savings that we won't be paying penalties on in the future to transform that irrigation system and landscape. The other question I had is the water district does give a has a rebate program on toilets and I'm thinking that

1:09:51 And that does save a substantial amount of water, plus it meets the California requirements for toilets today. And I think they get them on shower heads as well, I'm not sure on that. But I just think there's an opportunity, and I've expressed this before, for the water district and their water conservation program that they're trying to implement community-wide. I just think that this is an opportunity for them to incentivize the town.

1:10:21 In our water conservation by directing some of their funding towards changing that water usage out sooner rather than later. Have you had discussion with them on that? Not on the toilet replacement. On financial incentives? We did, you know, briefly in our pre-meeting when they first presented our water use information to us, we had discussions about

1:10:50 Rebates and related and also rebates maybe for or at least assistance with trails in park synthetic turf installation and They currently don't have a program for transformation basically eliminating grass Key words currently don't have a program. I'm not involved in the negotiations, but I would highly encourage the town to make it clear that this is a

1:11:18 an opportunity for both agencies to work together to solve a problem that is probably the biggest and highest water usage problem in town. And I think the bang for the buck for both agencies is there to cooperate and to get an incentive to make the town. In other words, without an incentive from the water district, we might resolve a tenth of the problem this summer because that's all we can afford. But if we get incentivized,

1:11:48 With a rebate program from the water district and they contribute whatever the number is. They're already contributing the large number for the toilet replacements. But I just think instead of solving one-tenth of the problem, maybe we could solve one-fourth of the problem this summer. So currently the plan is not to irrigate any of the grass this summer. Very little of it. And just let it die? And then remove it.

1:12:12 To replant it in some other method. So it may be dirt for a while for some of the areas. Yeah, dead grass or dirt along Old Mammoth Road is probably not. And painting it green is an option. We have had a discussion about removing the grass on Old Mammoth and maybe using that as a credit towards putting some turf in it at Trails End Park where that's prepared. But that also would take a board action at the water district.

1:12:40 If you need, if staff needs, I would suggest that you choose maybe the mayor and mayor pro tem or the mayor and myself to be involved in negotiations with the water district and see if we can't get incentivized at a higher level of what we're currently planning. I would agree with that. Okay. Thank you. So is that sufficient direction to move that forward and we'll participate as we can? Mr. Mayor, I'll move.

1:13:09 To adopt consent agenda item number three. Second. Okay. No motion and a second for the discussion. If not, yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number six, register of demands. I did, Mr. Mayor. And I just really wanted to pull this more for common commentary and public knowledge. It's just...

1:13:39 Something that stuck out to me, I was going through the registered demands, and it was quite honestly just a little bit frustrating, and the town manager can correct me if I'm wrong, but we have an item on here where the law office is Paul Rudder getting paid $7,041.20 for legal services, and I was just curious what that was for, because since we had a town attorney, and as it turns out, it was actually for legal services for somebody that,

1:14:10 We thought was not in compliance with their banners. Is that correct? And as it turns out, they came in, they appealed it, and per our own appeal process, we lost. And as a result, we ended up having to pay the attorney's fees. And to me, it was just something that was really frustrating. It seems like we have a pretty cut and dry policy there. And as a result, we ended up having to pay for something.

1:14:39 Somebody else really wasn't in compliance on. Yeah, I can provide a little bit of clarification on that. State law used to say that we could require someone to pay our attorney's fees if we won on an appeal, but that we didn't have to pay theirs if they won. Then the law changed. So now the state law says that we're allowed to go after someone for attorney's fees in a code enforcement case, but if we lose, we pay their fees. State law also says that you can't have the same lawyer representing the prosecution and advising the decision maker.

1:15:08 So on this one, I advised this decision maker, the hearing officer, Sarah Vigilante, our HR manager, and someone from my former firm advised staff as the prosecutors. And that attorney and the staff thought that we had a pretty solid case, and they decided, well, because it's such a solid case, we're going to go for attorney's fees. Hearing officer found against the town, and so we ended up having to pay Mr. Rogers' attorney's fees. I did talk to him and try to negotiate his rate down, try to negotiate the number down a little bit.

1:15:37 He declined to do that, and we're on the hook for his attorney's fees. Okay. And I just wanted to bring it up for public digestion, if you will, or indigestion. So that's all. That's all I have. Matthew, I wasn't going to pull it, but I was thinking of it for a different reason. Did you notice the spelling? Yes.

1:16:02 R-U-T-T-E-R? I did notice that. That was correct. It was correct. Okay. Thank you. I had a circle, too. Yeah. With that, I don't have any other comment. I just, something that popped out at me, and that's all. Popped out 7,000. Yeah. Mr. Mayor, I move that the Council adopt the Register of Demands as presented. Second. Motion to second. Welcome. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:16:31 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That's the risk of litigation. Policy matter, item number 7, award bid for the publication of legal notices for fiscal year 14-15. Jamie, is this the one that you're going to take the lead on? So since we have two adjudicated newspapers in the town of Mammoth Lakes, each year we have to go out to bid to award for legal notices.

1:17:04 We received two bids, one from the Mammoth Times and one from the Sheet. If you guys have any questions, their bids are attached, and it's up to you guys to choose who you want to go with. All right. That was brief. Questions? Questions or comments from members of the public, including the two bidders? Good evening, Council. As I looked at this, it appears that both papers bid

1:17:49 Exactly what they bid last year. And the bids work out to, on the legal publication side, I'm quite a bit higher. On the display side where you do most of your spending, I'm a little bit lower. Overall, that would be about a wash in terms of overall expenditure. Last year your findings were, because I had higher circulation, the paper was free.

1:18:16 Those were findings you made to award me the notices, and I would hope that you would do that again. Any questions, Dr. Carlton? Thank you. Thanks. All right. Any other members of the public wish to speak? If not, what's the pleasure of council? Mr. Mayor, make a motion. Council approve option one and award the contract to the sheet. Second. All right. The motion and a second. John? Bad discussion?

1:18:46 There's probably a handful of town council candidates in the audience this evening, and just a heads up that this is one of the annual agenda items that you'll have that's a no win. We have two quality newspapers, and it's really, really difficult to choose between the two without, to choose one over the other without hurting the others.

1:19:15 Feelings, so it's one of those things that's not particularly fun to address. We have a lot of those. We do, but this is one we have every year. We can count on every year. All right. Seeing no further comment or discussion, we'll call kids to it. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:19:42 Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to policy matter, again, item number 8, waive the reading and introduced by title only, an ordinance amending chapter 8.30 and chapter 15.04 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code related to replacement of non-certified solid fuel burning appliances and wood stove inserts. Dan, you're going to... Yeah, Mayor, Councilmembers, if you will, I think this is coming back for the...

1:20:11 Second, first reading, incorporating changes directed by the council at your last meeting. Unless there's changes to the wording that the council requested, which has been incorporated into the proposed ordinance, there's no other changes, I don't believe, to the proposal. The only question we had, discussion that I had raised coming back, was related to the one-year time frame, and then also that we can still grant additional time under the building code.

1:20:41 No questions? Nope. Yeah, I don't know about other council members, but I've not heard...

1:21:11 Anything else from the stakeholders or interested parties or groups. And so I assume that the discussion, which was pretty well vetted in the last meeting, it took us some time, solved the issues at least, not necessarily to the complete satisfaction of everybody, but satisfied enough to not raise the issue or raise any official complaints. And I'm not seeing anything from other council members that would...

1:21:39 Differ from that. And the building department had no other comments as well. That's great. Members of the public wish to comment on or have questions about this agenda item relating to the time to comply with the replacement of wood-burning inserts upon sale of residences here in town? If none, pleasure, counsel. I'll go ahead and make a motion, Mr. Mayor, that the council

1:22:08 Adopt option one, approve the waiving of the reading and introduced by title only an ordinance of the town council and town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, State of California, many chapters 8.30 and chapter 15.04. Second. All right. There's been a motion and a second. No further discussion. We'll call. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:22:35 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Now on to the main event, agenda item number 9, which is entitled Approve the Recommendations of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation MLR Formation Committee regarding the formation of a Mammoth Lakes Recreation Entity. This was initiated by the members of the Formation Committee who serve on the Town Council, Mayor Pro Tem Bacon and myself.

1:23:03 As well as Recreation Commissioners Terry Stalick and Betsy Truax, who are here tonight. I understand that unless, Dan, you're going to make an introduction, we're going to lead this off by the chair of the formation committee, Dan Estroud. Yeah.

1:23:31 Good evening, Council and interested public. My name is Dana Stroud, and I have been serving as the chair of the MLR Formation Committee that you appointed back in February 19, 2014. Your action that evening in February was to have the MLR Formation Committee come back to you at a certain time with an organization structure and a scope of work.

1:24:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:24:26 We were staffed by Sharon Giudice who joined us about a third of the way through and she was able to quickly pick up and provide us with excellent administrative support in helping to keep our meetings flowing and our information posted in a public manner. In May of 2013, we began this MLR process. Back then you had a large steering committee that was formed. That group had three public meetings.

1:24:58 In July and August and September of 2013, we came back to you and you formed phase two of this MLR process that narrowed that large group into a steering committee and that steering committee had five public meetings that occurred between November of 2013 and January of 2014. And then in February, you formed the formation committee.

1:25:27 And since February 20th, that Formation Committee has held nine public meetings that were all recorded and posted on Granicus. They were posted as public meetings and the public was invited to attend and participate. Public comments were received during those meetings.

1:25:45 That's a grand total of 17 public meetings that have occurred since May of 2013 related to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation discussion. So I wanted to give you just a little bit of history on that so that we know that there's been significant public time spent on discussing this issue and bringing forward to you a recommendation of an organizational structure for Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

1:26:13 I'd like to draw your attention to a few key overarching items for your consideration as we go through this. During the entire MLR process, we've had a discussion about the definition of recreation and what does it include, what doesn't it include. The formation committee narrowed that down to include those elements that made up rec strats 2. And rec strats 2 was delivered to you a few years ago.

1:26:43 So to remind everybody what was included in that definition, it was winter recreation, non-winter recreation, municipal sports and recreation, trails, special events, high altitude training, and arts and culture. For the purposes of Mammoth Lakes recreation, and when we refer to recreation in this document, we are including all seven of those elements.

1:27:12 As we refer to recreation throughout the document. Tonight, I really would just like to take you through an update on all the work that has been delivered, and I'm going to provide you with a very high overview of each of these sections that are included in your staff report. We do have members of our ad hoc committees that did all of the work, and they are on standby, ready to answer any specific questions that you might have relative to these areas within the document.

1:27:41 So let's go ahead and get started and provide you with this big overview. First of all, Mammoth Lakes Recreation was really intended to place a focus, high level focus on recreation in Mammoth Lakes. More importantly, it was really intended to help create a strategic implementation opportunity for all of the plans and projects and processes that we've gone through in the last umpteen years here in the community. This really was intended to be able to provide the focus that allows

1:28:10 The MLR organization to leverage the dollars that are available for recreation implementation as well as growing some additional outside revenue sources and bringing a level of leadership to the recreation effort in this community that perhaps we haven't seen as collectively as we would like. During our MLR formation process back in the spring of last year, we went through a gains and foregoes exercise.

1:28:40 And I just draw your attention to your packet that includes that gains and foregoes document. For the public, it was included in the packet, but it's also listed up here on the wall. And those gains and foregoes document was really intended to help us understand why we want to pursue an MLR. What would be the purpose? What would be the outcome? Why would we want to go down this path of trying to form something that's going to take some of our time and some of our effort?

1:29:10 The whole idea behind the gains and foregoes exercise was that we could gain a lot more out of the dollars that we have available to us than we're currently using at this time. We have our ad hoc committee available to provide us with updates and specific questions you might have about the gains and foregoes document. But I would just draw your attention to the fact that that was a...

1:29:33 Public discussion about the difference between what we're currently doing and what opportunities might be available to us as we move forward with an MLR. And it appeared that the gains were much greater with this idea of moving forward with MLR. I would like to make this caveat throughout the entire process. There was never any discussion about eliminating or doing away with the town's municipal recreation department.

1:30:00 And in fact, during the entire exercise, it was noted many, many times that there is a significant role for municipal recreation to play in this community. In fact, municipal recreation isn't even being referred to that anymore. I think we've gone down the path of calling it community recreation. And it provides a tremendous service to our residents in this community. But we were also talking about wanting to grow outside of just the recreation that we provide the residents. And we're really talking about using MLR as an economic development tool.

1:30:30 In order to grow the outdoor recreation product that we offer in this community and use it as a way to take the MLT marketing effort and provide a product that MLT can go out and market for us and help with our grow our local economy. So I just want to make that note that there was never any discussion about doing away with municipal now called community recreation, but rather considering MLR as an opportunity.

1:30:58 To enhance what we're currently doing and develop additional outside funding opportunities. So the gains and foregoes document was in front of you. We spent a lot of time talking about the structure of an organization. Very specifically, we invited our town attorney to come to one of our meetings to help guide us through some of the legal hurdles that an organization such as MLR may encounter as it's being formed.

1:31:26 We took a few different stabs. We provided him with a few different scenarios. He provided us with a few different legal opinions. And we've come down to what we're now calling MLR Funding Scenario 2.0. And in your packet, there's a graph that you can follow along with. And for this part of the presentation, I'm going to ask Councilmember Bacon to lead you through that MLR Funding Scenario 2.0.

1:31:53 Okay. One of the biggest questions we had still out there in February at the 19th meeting was exactly how can RNU's funds be used. So if you look at page 15 and 16, which is attachment C of the packet, you will see that we've been able to split out where they're the same and where they're different. So we finally have kind of a cheat sheet of how RNU can legally be used. Thanks to our town attorney who spent

1:32:23 I think that was at least a three-hour meeting, if not longer. We've had several three-hour meetings, so it's hard to remember which. We were able to work that out, and as a result of that, it's in the packet on page 5, but there's also a graph on page 14, is actually a funding scenario that would meet the requirements of both measures. R and U are different, so I'll speak to each of them separately. Measure R contains an expenditure plan.

1:32:52 Which Council has the authority to change. And what is recommended here is that a portion of the Measure R money through the expenditure plan be allocated off the top, if you want to call it, for contract work with MLR on a contract to be negotiated. The remaining funds from Measure R, MLR, would become the recommending body for those. And by changing the expenditure plan, we can accomplish both of those.

1:33:22 The way it is written, it would be Town Council designates MLR as the recommending body. So Measure U and the remainder of Measure R would go into a one pot for consideration.

1:33:38 MLR would accept public input on those projects and programs, and in the graph, that's, you know, the town. If Public Works has something where it's appropriate to ask for funds to leverage a project, it could come that way. The Recreation Commission would have items to bring in, and other departments might possibly as well.

1:34:00 You'll notice that there's also the recognition that the Forest Service is part of the priority-setting process, as well as the community. And the community is there in the sense of, in the past, we have the allocation to trails because of a small group that got involved with that. We have the Mammoth Track because the track club got involved with it. So that MLR would then take the RNU priorities. We'd get one.

1:34:27 Prioritized Strategic List that would be submitted to Council and Council still approves the RNU allocations and is the final authority on RNU. This is actually slightly, it's simple but you've got lots of arrows going there so it's kind of like running through the pieces of it to show you how this could work and accomplish the goals where we're trying to get and stay within the requirements of both ordinances.

1:34:59 Back to Dana. So for the public to remind you this is the scenario that Joe just walked us through. We will advise that it was reviewed by the town attorney. He provided the input that helped frame this and shape this. I would also like to remind the council and the public that while we are proposing these various scenarios and these various

1:35:25 Draft working plans and these various bylaws that there is still many final details that are going to be determined during contract negotiations that we are recommending a little bit later in this document. So while we have everything very complete, there are still a few decisions that have to be made and some opinions that have to be received in order to finalize the document. So I would just ask that

1:35:53 You keep that in mind as we continue to go through this. We had a draft working plan ad hoc committee that spent considerable time taking the legal opinions and the legal matrix that we just talked about and looking to turn that into what we were originally calling a scope of work but what we've now called a draft working plan. That is attached in your packet as well and that draft working plan really is intended to give you an idea from a strategic standpoint.

1:36:24 What it is that MLR would be delivering and would be working on and what its responsibilities would be. And we identified that MLR would probably serve as the lead on many issues and initiatives and ideas to move forward. Certainly realizing that MLR...

1:36:45 Doesn't accomplish its scope of work without fully established partnerships with the town, with the Forest Service, and other NGOs that might be able to provide us resources throughout the entire process. We have our ad hoc committee standing by to help answer any questions that you might have relative to the draft working plan as it was presented to you. Next up, I'd like to talk to you a little bit about the draft bylaws. And I would like to start off first.

1:37:15 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:37:34 Secondly, there was significant information that was being shared in tonight's agenda bill, and we felt that in order to focus your attention, we wanted to pull out those pertinent areas within the bylaws that previously you had expressed some interest or had some questions about, as well as information that we had received from the public during our process, and so we wanted to pull those out and highlight those for you. We do have the draft available for you to look at the entire document.

1:38:03 And I would like to address a comment, communication that has been recently received relative to the bylaws and perhaps clear up any confusion that there may be regarding the bylaws themselves. First of all, the draft that was posted on the town's website, it was an April 28th draft that was brought forward to the MLR committee. The MLR committee had the opportunity to review it, provide some comments, and gave feedback to the

1:38:34 Ad hoc steering committee that was comprised to deal with the bylaws. That steering committee and that ad hoc committee took that information, went back and created its revision. The comment that you received is related to the April 28th version of the bylaws that have since, through the entire process, been updated a few different times. So there's a few things to answer to that.

1:39:01 There's a reference specifically made to section 4.6 that talks about a restriction on interested persons as directors. And it references something that's not even in the bylaws any longer. And so that comment about 49% of the board members may be compensated by the corporation is no longer included. 4.6 does not look like that. But I would also draw your attention to 4.5, which is right above 4.6.

1:39:30 Where it clearly states that no board members may be compensated for serving on the board. So there's a misinformation that is being sent around out there and I would just like to draw your attention to the fact that 4.5 says no board members will receive compensation for serving on the board. Secondly, section 5.14 has been brought up to your attention and this has to deal with members of interest or what is being called financial interest. And I'm going to

1:39:59 Turn over to our town attorney in just a second. This is one of those hurdles that we want to have addressed and get an actual opinion on how to deal with this because we have to engage with the Fair Political Practices Commission, the FPPC. And to date, up to today, we, the committee, you, the council,

1:40:28 Dan, the Town Manager, we've not given our Town Attorney any direction to go pursue a written legal opinion from FPPC on this issue. And so perhaps tonight there might be a consideration by the Council to provide such a direction to our Town Attorney so that we can get a legal opinion about persons of interest and how we can address it in our bylaws. And if I might, I'd like to expand on what the issue is just a little bit.

1:40:57 The bylaws that have been presented to you are fairly typical of nonprofit corporation bylaws. Nonprofit corporation bylaws typically don't, in my experience, prohibit all self-dealing transactions, which is kind of the focus of the concern. In looking at the FPPC opinion, which go back decades, the FPPC has previously reached the conclusion that in some circumstances, a private corporation like MLR would be, can be subject to the state conflict of interest rules.

1:41:25 They usually apply only to public entities like the town. Because MLR, as it's currently envisioned, would share some traits with the private organization that was found to be subject to conflict rules by the FPPC, I think it would be a very good idea for us to ask the FPPC for a written opinion as to whether the conflict rules would apply to MLR. If we know that up front, then everyone can govern themselves accordingly.

1:41:54 Prohibitions like that are in the bylaws. If we get the opinion from the FPPC, the bylaws can be amended. MLR can choose to govern itself that way. The council can make that a condition of receiving any funding. But it's a fairly key issue, I think, for MLR board members that we need to know about going in. Andy, that, if we were to obtain an opinion, would be very useful for Mammoth Lakes Housing and Mammoth Lakes Tourism as well, would it not?

1:42:21 We could certainly include in the scope of the opinion, or in the scope of the opinion request, that we get opinions as to those two organizations as well. I think up until now, we haven't thought of either of those organizations as being subject to the conflict rules, although they are maybe subject to the Brown Act. Okay. Which is slightly different from...

1:42:48 Being treated that way formally and officially. But, yeah, we could certainly make that request and get it completely cleared up once and for all. Well, I say that because one of the templates, if you will, that was used by the bylaws subcommittee was a recently updated version of Mammoth Lakes Housing's bylaws, which had recently been amended, restated, and approved by its board.

1:43:17 And so that's not something that the public really much cared about as they do in this MLR discussion, but it seems to me that it would be useful for us as a town to have an opinion, if you think it's appropriate, that would...

1:43:39 At least address the same issues that may exist with respect to the two other organizations. I don't know whether ESTA would be included in that. Probably not because I think it's a slightly different type of organization. ESTA is a joint powers authority and it's already subject to all those because it is a public entity. But I do think it would be a good idea to make the request and ask for clarification regarding all three entities. It's not really much more work to ask about all three. It would be to just ask for one and that way we will all know.

1:44:08 Thank you. With that, I also want to address what was brought out, Section 7.10 relative to the bylaws that states that the bylaws may be amended or repealed and new bylaws adopted by the vote of a majority of the members of the board. The question that has been addressed

1:44:31 The point that has been brought up is that this gives the MLR board the right to change the rules by which they are governed at any time without oversight by the town council or the public. And that's true. MLR is not governed by the town of Mammoth Lakes. MLR will have an oversight by the town council as it relates to the measure R and measure U expenditures. So the MLR

1:44:59 Board of Directors has every ability to function as its own stand-alone organization. The council has direct oversight as it relates to the expenditure of measures R and measure U, and we wanted to provide that clarification for you. As with any NGO that you might enter into any type of business relationship with,

1:45:21 They themselves also have the ability to change their bylaws without oversight by the council. So it is perfectly acceptable for the MLR board to make any changes to its bylaws as it sees fit. I want to reiterate, the town council has oversight through the Measure R and Measure U expenditure. Anything beyond that is governed directly by the MLR board.

1:45:46 With that, I would like to draw your attention to the makeup of this MLR board. There seems to have been a lot of interest on how the MLR board may be seated and who might be sitting on it, et cetera. So I just want to make sure that we're clear on this. The bylaws, the proposed bylaws, again, that still have to be approved and adopted by the MLR board, indicate that there will be nine board members. Of that nine, seven are going to be at-large members.

1:46:16 Two will have existing seats that will be appointed by the respective organizations. Those two seats include the town council who will appoint somebody to be on the MLR board as well as Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We also have recommended in our bylaws that there will be two liaisons invited to participate in the MLR board meetings. They are not voting members but they are serving as advisory to the MLR board.

1:46:42 Those two include the Forest Service, the representative from the Inyo National Forest, and a representative from the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission. I want to spend a little bit of time talking about the qualifications for MLR board members. We're looking to create large interest of recreation providers, users, organizers, promoters, manufacturers, retailers, those who have at large interest in recreation.

1:47:11 We also wanted to make sure that they have a demonstrated ability to work within a group setting to reach consensus and make some decisions. We're also talking about that six of those nine directors at any time shall be permanent residents of Mammoth Lakes. That means that potentially three of those members may not have to be a resident of Mammoth Lakes. They could live outside of the community. And I will say that the committee spent some time talking about that. What does that mean?

1:47:38 Really the intent was to think beyond ourselves, and if we're starting to think about leverage opportunities, if we're starting to think about investments from outside entities, perhaps expanding beyond ourselves might be a good idea to bring some new perspectives to an organization such as this. I want to make sure that we are aware that MLR will comply with Brown Act requirements. That was a discussion that we had with our town attorney, and they will function under Brown Act.

1:48:04 Which means there's going to be some extra meetings and some extra efforts, but they will function as a Brown Act. With the formation committee in place and moving into what we're calling transition, MLR has to form itself. And in order to form that itself, a board has to meet to approve the bylaws and a few extra steps in there to formally create MLR.

1:48:31 What your formation committee is recommending is that the current formation group become that transition board for MLR and that with your support, the MLR formation committee would meet, adopt the bylaws and become the transitional board. With the intent that come fall, there would be an opportunity to recruit and pursue additional interests, interested parties to serve on the MLR board.

1:48:59 And that by the fall there would be a permanent seating of the MLR board. Your current formation committee members have all indicated an interest and willingness to serve on the transition board with your support. There is one caveat to that and it has to do with a council candidate who is also serving on the MLR committee and if perchance the election results in, you know,

1:49:29 Turn out a certain way. He may not be able to serve on the formation committee because the bylaws indicate that there's one representative from the council, so not two. So we just bring up that caveat to you. MLR staffing in your document. We talk about job description for a staff person and the idea that we would have two entities to start off.

1:49:55 The first one would be an executive director who would basically be our champion and be our administrative leader. The second one is what we're calling a recreation coordinator slash trails coordinator. That definition and job responsibility to be determined. But we are looking to start off with two staff members. In your packet, you have a staffing job description. You also have some salary comparisons. You also have a proposed salary.

1:50:24 And at this point I would like to just point out that a budget for the MLR is still to be determined and there is not a specific budget that has been identified nor adopted nor proposed, but we are starting off with some funding scenarios, excuse me, some budget scenarios for our staffing levels. And those are again just some recommendations. The ad hoc committee did some extensive research on like organizations out there.

1:50:53 I will say this too. We heard from the committee, or excuse me, from the community that there was really an interest in thinking large as far as what this staff person might look like, this executive director. And, you know, coming out of the box realizing that who we're looking for and the quality that we're looking for is maybe going to command a certain salary. And so we want to make sure that everybody's clear on that, that we are going to be going after some

1:51:21 You know, major qualified folks to entertain this idea of coming and serving as the MLR Executive Director. So we put that out in front of you so that you can see what we're talking about. There's nothing hidden in there. It's really a discussion about what we're willing to compensate someone for coming in and taking on the leadership of MLR. We talked a little bit about contract framework. Certainly, this funding scenario that Councilmember Bacon described

1:51:47 Indicates that the MLR organization would need to have a contract with the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and so there would have to be an execution of such a document. We've provided in the attachment an outline of what elements would be included in a potential contract, things such as deliverables, such as specific projects, such as specific responsibilities, and certainly that is a framework to work from, but it's not the entire contract, and I just want to make

1:52:15 As they're all aware, that those are suggestions for what goes into a contract, but it's not the only thing that goes into a contract. And we have our contract ad hoc committee here who is able to speak to any specifics that you might have relative to the contract. With that, we kind of start to move into a transition mode here. And what we're really starting to think about is...

1:52:41 With the formation of MLR, what happens to everything else that has currently been in place and that has currently been functioning? What does it look like? And we recognize as a committee that there are several steps still to take in getting MLR organized. We want to point out a few key things here. Tonight, later on, you're going to have a discussion about MLTSCC specifically and the budget that they're recommending.

1:53:11 MLTSCC starts to change and maybe comes absorbed into MLR because MLR would take on the function of managing, operating, implementing, overseeing the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And so we recognize that there's got to be a discussion there and we identify that it would be helpful to have MLR committee members, MLTSCC committee members.

1:53:37 Town staff and other interested parties start to meet and talk about what that transition looks like if that's the route that we're headed. We certainly want to acknowledge the work that MLTSCC has done in the last two years and also identify that there's an opportunity to grow from that. In February, you suspended Measure R and Measure U, which kind of put a different spin on the Measure U Committee. We believe that moving forward with the funding scenario that we've outlined for you,

1:54:07 The Measure U Committee role changes and in many cases disappears. And I say that very gently because there will not be a need for a Measure U Committee with the scenario that we've outlined with you tonight. We would certainly want to acknowledge the work that the Measure U Committee has done as well as think about how we could integrate some of their input and their observations and their experience with Measure U into

1:54:35 The MLR recommending process for R&U into the future. We believe there's great experience from both MLTSCC and Measure U for how we can address measures R&U moving forward. I do want to note that we have currently received and we're in receipt of communication from the Secretary of State that we are registered with this state as a non-profit.

1:55:05 We also have a number, an official number from the franchise tax board. So we are official that way. We've also received communication that tells us how to start our withholding tax issues as it relates to any payroll type thing.

1:55:28 We are official in that regard that we have done the work to have our articles filed and we are on record with the Secretary of State. I really don't think I have much more to add to the overview that we have for you tonight. I want to close with this. And then, as I said, we've got our ad hoc committee members who are able to answer any specific questions you have about elements. The formation committee went into this.

1:55:58 Based on appointments that you had made. And I want to represent that they took their work very seriously. They were looking out for the best interest of the community as well as keeping in mind the legal issues that we wanted to make sure were covered so as not to create any unnecessary exposure or vulnerability for the town. Our town attorney provided us with some great guidance and provided us with some input.

1:56:28 But never did we ever take this as a let's just do it anyway scenario. The committee spent considerable time and discussion and debate about what would be best for the community and how could we make this work to provide a benefit back to the community in a way that perhaps we haven't seen previously. And so I just want to acknowledge their effort and the sincerity by which they took the charge that you gave them to deliver this product back to you.

1:56:56 And I want to thank you on behalf of the community. Thank you for the opportunity to have gone through this exercise and to have brought this forward to you for your consideration this evening. And so we're happy to answer any questions that you might have with regards to the specific elements that you have in front of you tonight. Hannah, thank you. Also, thank you.

1:57:23 Mayor Pro Tem Bacon for putting this agenda bill together. In 16 years, I've seen probably thousands of them now, certainly hundreds, if not into the thousands. I can't overstate how impressed I am and was when I first read this to be able to synthesize a year's worth of work.

1:57:50 Thousands of cumulative hours, and you know that from all of the 32 stakeholders down to the nine formation committee members, the ad hoc committees, the subcommittees who've invested in this. It was really a pleasure to read because there's a lot here, and you did it in a way that was, I think, understandable.

1:58:15 I hope it was understandable to members of the public. It certainly was to me, and I want to acknowledge you for the effort that you've put in. So with that, first of all, let's start with questions of the Formation Committee or of Dana Straub from or by any council member. Well, I can start off, I guess. I'm not sure if I should wait until after public comment because maybe we'll get some better feedback or not. I might have a number of questions, but also...

1:58:49 A number of comments as well. I think Dan addressed a good number of them. I guess I'll just start off asking some of the questions and making my comments now and maybe the public will answer them as they come forward. But the first thing, I guess I'll start with the agenda item. Sorry, it takes a second for this to load.

1:59:19 One, Dan, maybe you can answer this. I was reading something, I think, when you were addressing it, but as far as parts of these, I'm referencing Karen Seibert's letter. Concern about the board members getting paid. Can you clarify that they are not getting paid? Right. In 4.5 of the draft bylaws, it clearly states that the board members will not be compensated for any service on the board.

1:59:49 And so her comment, I think, is an interpretation for what she read in 4.6. But I would just guess that the interpretation is a bit off because 4.5 clearly states that there is no compensation for board members. For clarification, can the board members represent the board and be compensated outside of their role as a board member?

2:00:19 That's part of the, isn't that part of the FPPC role? Can you give me an example of what that would be? Well, I don't know myself because I'm, that's what I'm reading in here, but I'm guessing if somebody were, and I'll use an attorney and it's not because you're on the board, it's because it's the one that comes to mind and we've already talked about it tonight, but if somebody were an attorney, could they represent the board as an attorney and be compensated for it? Yeah, it's exactly as Dan has said, that that's one of the questions that we,

2:00:48 We'll know more about if we get an FBPC opinion, because if the FBPC says that it's subject to the conflict rules, then no, no member, well, actually, it's a little more nuanced than that, but probably no member would be able to do that. Okay. And I imagine we could probably just trump the conversation if we just said you couldn't do that, right? Yeah, and again, the council doesn't have direct control over how MLR operates, but the council can certainly say, unless you do things our way, we're not giving you money.

2:01:14 Okay. And then a couple other items I wanted to address. And I'm addressing this letter that Karen wrote. Two reasons. I mean, she's written it as a resident and as a council candidate. But some I think are valid, particularly if somebody has an opinion or a legitimate concern. But some of the other things that kind of bother me with it are, you know, it says there's no oversight required by the town council or the public.

2:01:44 Pretty clear that we have all the oversight, or council has all the oversight of all the funds being spent. Correct? Yes. So, I mean, I don't know if that's accurate. And it's just, to me, it's sometimes frustrating when I hear stuff like this. And if it's somebody just misunderstanding, I can appreciate that. We all do that. But another thing was, you know, the comment, you know, saying that I don't believe there's enough sufficient community engagement. I think after 17 meetings and the number of, you know,

2:02:12 All the hours that have gone into it, I can get it if we haven't vetted it out all the way, and I'm waiting to hear also more from the public on that because maybe there's something I'm missing, but just something for me that's a little bit frustrating to hear that without really being backed up very well. On the other side of things, I'm concerned a little bit. I think we're looking at about, what, $118,000 salary for a director. Is that right? And I will...

2:02:42 I will defer to our compensation ad hoc committee to dive into some specifics for you. Okay. And I'm going to point to Betsy Truax, who's going to answer very specific questions about the compensation, comparison, the analysis that we provided, and the recommendation for the salary. Okay. Good evening.

2:03:06 What we are proposing is a salary range for the Executive Director of from $90,000 to $110,000 of base compensation plus benefits equal to approximately 17% of the base salary. And the benefits are the result of a comparison that we did between a private organization, an NGO, we specifically used Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and town staff.

2:03:34 So that's how we came to that number. We also looked at a number of local organizations. And I just want to clarify that this spreadsheet with the nonprofit salary information, it's not meant to be a comprehensive salary survey.

2:03:56 But we did just pull out from the publicly available IRS Form 990s that are available for free online just some local comparable organization salaries and looked also at their operating expenses relative to their executive director salaries, which are also publicly available. And I think ultimately our goal is that we would end up falling within the range of regional nonprofit executive director salaries, which

2:04:26 As a percentage of the operating expenses, the average for our region, the Pacific West, which includes California, Oregon, Washington, Hawaii, and Alaska, is $95,804. And that is a percentage of operating expenses ranges from just under 3% to just under 10% of operating expenses. So that's how we came to this number. And we've heard both concerns that the proposed range is too low to attract

2:04:57 Thank you for clarifying that.

2:05:27 And I just want to offer my two cents on it. I'm probably the latter of the group you talked about. I mean, I would tend to think that I would shoot for the lower end only because, not that I want somebody qualified, but I want somebody that's hungry. And I want somebody that's going to go out there and I want them to be unemployed until they earn that money. And, you know, effectively, I mean, $90,000 at the low end is probably really not too bad. And then throwing in a percent compensation in there on top of it.

2:05:57 I think that really will give an incentive and, you know, that's just one person's opinion. I mean, you know, there's a lot of theories in there. That's just one. And then another question I had, if we were to end up in a contract on MLR, and I don't think this is very likely, but what if the funding source were to go away, public rescission or...

2:06:24 Or, God forbid, there were, you know, a situation where we had to use the funds for some other reason like Chapter 9. No, we can't. We can't. We can't. Okay. And that goes for in either case. Okay. So, those are all the questions I had right now. That's it. Thank you. We say we can't even if a judge says we could. They're restricted funds. I know. But judges are judges.

2:06:57 Well, I heard the terrible word, Chapter 9. We've been there. Yeah. Well, and I know we're not going back there, but I'm trying to throw out the what if, if something were to just come up, and I just hate to be locked into something that we, you know, as long as we give ourselves some sort of caveat that if some unforeseen circumstance were to come up. And maybe I can ask, I was saying that we didn't go into the details yet, but, you know,

2:07:24 There's a, whatever the contract structure is, and there's a recommendation from the committee that it start with a three-year agreement, but that's reviewed annually, and at any point in time, a council who is not satisfied with the performance or the deliverables not being met can, of course, not extend a contract or not create a new one. Well, I guess in the worst case scenario, too, council could just not fund something. Correct. Correct, yeah. Right. Okay, that's all I have. Thank you, Matthew.

2:07:54 Michael, John, questions? I'd like to hear from the public. All right. Do Joey have any questions? No. Hannah? I just want to provide a couple more points as you move forward. In the options analysis that has been provided to you that has letters A, 1 through 7, and letter B,

2:08:19 I just want to point out that there's some timing issues here. And I point this out to you because tonight you might be giving some direction to staff related to moving into executing an agreement or moving into changing an expenditure plan or moving into a process to change who the designated recommending body is for Measure U. I think we should all note that that's all going to take time to complete those steps.

2:08:50 The current council is probably not going to be the one to potentially execute an agreement. This current council is probably not the one who's going to have to approve a revised expenditure plan. And this current council is probably not the one who's going to have to change the designation for Measure U because of the timing that it's going to take to get through these next few steps. So I want you to be aware of that and also for the community to be aware of that, that you have a

2:09:19 You're going to take some steps tonight, but a lot of the execution of it is going to happen with the next council, and we want you to be aware of that. The other piece that we spent some time talking about relative to our budget and relative to MLR's future budget is this desire to move into a revenue-neutral territory for administrative costs. And, Matthew, to your point about having somebody who's aggressive and hungry and wants to

2:09:46 Really go out there and make its mark. That's certainly going to be one of those early areas to focus on in trying to identify some additional funding sources that will help remove the overhead that we're talking about for MLR as it moves forward. And so there is a desire and an intent to make it revenue neutral very quickly. Thanks. Okay, Dana, thank you. Now's the time for members of the public who wish to provide

2:10:18 Input to the Council on this agenda item to come forward. Sandy. Sandy Hogan. Actually, Dana's last words were kind of reassuring to me because I was reading through this and it's, I read fairly carefully and there's a lot of information in this packet and I felt like, oh yeah, okay, it's not too bad. Really, since there's a lot of draft information still,

2:10:49 Basically, you have a steering committee that is asking to continue working as a steering committee. And that makes sense to me. But then I read the following recommendation. It says approve funding scenario 2.0 and direct staff 2. And it goes 1 through 7. And I went, okay, 1 doesn't sound bad because I can see continue the suspension until we get the reconciliation. So 1 and 7, logical to me.

2:11:18 Some of the other ones I had questions. But then about 3.45 this afternoon I went, wait a minute, it says approve funding scenario 2.0. And I think I and most everybody else thought we were approving that little chart. Nice little chart. But if you go back about five or six pages, what it says is the funding scenario is the measure our expenditure plan is amended by council.

2:11:47 Two, A, fund a contract with MLR for tasks and deliverables negotiated by both parties, and B, designate MLR as the recommending body for all Measure R allocations other than count allocations to MLR. To me, and I asked Andy to read that, it sounds, there's a two, three, four, five, six also, but it sounds to me like we're not approving a spreadsheet or a little, you know, flow chart, which really I have seen.

2:12:17 Get improved. I still have a few problems with it. But you're actually asking this council tonight to amend the Measure R expenditure plan. Is that correct? Well, let me jump in. Good. The ordinance, the Measure R ordinance is not real clear as to whether the expenditure plan is part of the ordinance or not.

2:12:39 But the section of state law that governs transactions and use taxes, which is what measure R is, says the expenditure plan is part of the ordinance. So the council can't amend the expenditure plan tonight because it has to be done with an ordinance. So two readings plus 30 days. Ah, good. That makes me feel a lot better because I was afraid that that was being proposed to be approved, in other words, modified tonight. So that's great. So we have two readings and 30 days. So that part, so the rest of it, actually, that was one of my big questions about 2.0.

2:13:06 In other words, in the transition functions, I do have some questions on those, but this was the 2.0 part of it, so I'll get to those later. Thank you. Thank you, Sandy. Other members of the public? Sharon, you look like you want to speak. I'm Sharon Clark. My concerns about our democratic process, my concern is the lack of public participation.

2:13:50 And, Councilman Lehman, it sort of speaks to you because the decisions I'm concerned about happened in the first three meetings. These meetings were to consider transferring $1.8 million R&U dollars to a private corporation who would then recommend to town council allocations of public money. Last May, you approved appointing council members Wood, Bacon,

2:14:16 Ray, Recreation Members, Dalek, and Truax to an MLR Steering Committee. They invited about 30 people representing various stakeholder groups to attend a July 22nd meeting. You have the attendance, you will have the attendance list before you. However, two stakeholder groups intimately involved in recommending allocations of these funds measure you and Mammoth Lakes Trails Committee

2:14:46 We're not invited. This was interesting since the entire recreation committee was invited. The list left out many stakeholders. Representatives from Sierra Classic Theater, Felici Trio, events groups, and the community was not invited to the first three meetings. All these stakeholder groups should have been at the table at the very first meeting.

2:15:16 I saw no media ads like Plan Your Parks or Main Street that would have invited the public. At the last meeting of these three, the attending 15 stakeholders determined that a hybrid organization should be formed. That didn't happen. When asked if the existing group should continue, the consultant said something like, the more input, the better, or similar words. That didn't happen.

2:15:46 At your October meeting, last October meeting, in your agenda bill, the consultant said a smaller committee should proceed. The original four member steering committee asked five people to join them, making a total of nine. The die was cast after three meetings with only invited people participating. To conduct Mammoth Lakes business in this manner,

2:16:14 I ask you tonight, give all Village in the Tree citizens a voice in this process.

2:16:44 From the very beginning, a seat at the table. If you believe in government of, by, and for the people, involve our community to arrive at a fair, democratic, and credible decision. Thank you. Could I ask Dana to speak to how the public was involved in all 17 of these meetings?

2:17:22 The first three meetings that were held back in July and August, Sharon is correct, there was an invitation that went out to interested stakeholders and interested parties to come participate in those meetings. Those were facilitated workshops that were held here in Suite Z. In addition to the invited participants, the public as a whole was invited. And in fact, during those three meetings,

2:17:51 We had interested parties that were sitting around the perimeter of the room while not a part of the initial third group that was invited. They actually participated in the meetings because the consultants who facilitated those meetings solicited their input. So the exercises that occurred in those three meetings were not just members of the folks who had been identified to participate but also those folks who showed up.

2:18:20 Set in the audience. They were also able to participate. So those were publicly noticed meetings. They were noticed through the town's process. Then in October when you went from the larger group to a smaller steering committee group, those two were publicly noticed and the public had those who chose to show up and participate were able to provide public input to that steering committee as they went through their exercise.

2:18:47 And then for the last nine meetings of the MLR Formation Committee, same process, they were publicly noticed, and each agenda item that the committee went through at each of their meetings, the public was invited to provide input to each of those agenda items, not just through public comment, but as the committee went through each of the agenda items. So there was significant

2:19:15 Opportunity for the public's participation and input received. And through the July, August, September meetings, the public's influence was felt as that document was delivered. Through the steering committee, the public's input was felt. And in February, you received the recreation, what we call Mammoth Lakes Recreation 5.0.

2:19:41 That had significant public input as to how that document was completed and brought forward to you. And the influence of the community was heavily felt as that document was brought forward to you. And it was that document that the steering committee, or excuse me, the formation committee used as it began its process here in February. So I, you know, I would like to point out that the public had every opportunity to participate and the meetings were publicly noticed. And when they did show up,

2:20:09 Their input was solicited and was received. And then, Stuart, could I ask you to verify that on the Measure U Committee, Bill Sauser is on that as a Recreation Commissioner? Yes. Bill, yes, thank you. Oh, Bill, actually, Bill, you're on both Measure U and MLTSCC? Yes. Okay, thank you. And you were at these meetings? Yes. Thank you. One of the things, Sandy Hogan, again, that I did want to thank, because I know it...

2:20:40 The February 19th meeting, I did speak about public process and how disappointed I was in it. And ever since then, and since Dan, basically, and his staff took charge, and with also the committee, their participation, the steering committee's participation, there's been huge improvements. The agendas have been posted. The packets have been complete. Committee members have put their things together. In other words,

2:21:07 So I do want to thank that. I know that on the 19th, $5,000 of the general fund was committed for staff support. I hope it was. Sarah Njudici did a great job. Dan did. And the committees. I'm going to give a little history also because I've been around for a while and I wasn't one of the invitees in 2009, 2010 when this first came up. But that's okay, you know, but the public really wasn't invited. It was a select group.

2:21:35 There were 33 people, and this was headed up by Dana, Joe, John Wentworth, and Wendy. And it was a number of meetings, and members dropped out, because it was kind of vague, it was a great idea, this wonderful concept, but very vague. Went to the rec commission, spring of 2010, and they said, no, we want a director. We don't need this great, wonderful idea, we just need a director. Unfortunately, that position wasn't filled. Bill can vouch for that.

2:22:04 Because he was one of the ones that spoke up and said, we need leadership, we need a director. This time around, the original invitees, a lot of them had been moved out of town. There were a few new ones. Some fell by the way. $50,000 of Measure R was spent on the facilitators. And it was made a town of Mammoth Lakes priority. There were never any real alternatives looked at. Only the one proposal and what we have now. That was it. There's no hybrid.

2:22:33 Because that hybrid didn't happen. Hybrid means mixed. Steering committee is now down to eight members. It's renaming itself at each step. Very thorough, I have to admit. I mean, the agenda packets are a lot of reading for most of us. And so I can see why a lot of people haven't. But it hasn't been advertised as you're planning your parks that had people turned out like crazy. I loved it. That was great.

2:22:59 The next step, they want to name it transition, but as a matter of fact, it's still draft as far as I'm concerned. It's still a steering committee, and if the proposal tonight is to continue the work on that, I don't have a problem with that because I've seen it get better step by step. But let's not call it transition if it's not ready to transition because I don't know what that looks like. So I don't even know what the town council is being asked to do, but I am glad that you're not being asked to amend that expenditure plan without public hearings because that was frightening, absolutely frightening.

2:23:29 Lots of draft and working documents. Lots of good ideas. Could be a great thing going forward. But I think maybe what you want to prove is that this committee continues to work. I wouldn't call it transition. I don't think it's ready for transition. A lot of work to be done. Especially because it's really not quite official. Why would you? You created the Recreation Commission. You created the Trails Committee. You created the Measure U Committee. Why would you dissolve these?

2:24:00 And have them taken over by a steering committee. You know, steering committees are those that get things ready for the real thing to come someday, which is supposedly fall, is what I hear. So, it is a steering committee. No final bylaws, no final work plan, no final board, no draft contact, only a draft framework, no executive director. And so, my question is, why, at this point in time, give it oversight and really make some major changes?

2:24:30 You know, you do have an awful lot of people, good volunteers, working at no cost. If you're saying that they should provide the staff, well, maybe they should to keep it moving forward. But oversight, I don't think they're ready for that yet. There's no contract. That's not going to come for a while. So anyway, that's basically my, I don't know what a transition looks like. Is it the full board providing oversight? Selecting members of the oversight? Does it take the running of the committees? Do they run it? Does it replace the committees?

2:25:00 I mean, I don't think those answers have even been approached. So I would say, tonight, continue the steering group. If you want to give it general fund money, do. Please don't give it Measure R at this time. You know, and that's your decision. Finish the formation. Get the draft documents together. Put it together right. Do it right. This could be a great thing. I'm not saying it, maybe, but I'm just saying right now, it's very vague. And I think if you don't do it right,

2:25:30 You know, he could be in for another mistake. We don't need that. Thank you, Sandy. Terry? Terry Stellick, REC Commission, and I have been involved from back in 2009 and then in the current MLR Steering Committee. I'll start with the discussion that we had at the REC Commission. There was a discussion about MLR. There were a couple of commissioners that didn't know what MLR was.

2:26:01 Bill Sauser and I were involved in the original possibility back in 2009-10. That was actually something that was started by Mike Schlaffman at the time. And I won't go into all the reasons why, but he brought a lot of stakeholders to the table and said, you know, this is something that could be good if there's money from any of these NGOs that could be used for regional recreation because we started out on a regional basis.

2:26:30 From the Forest Service. From the Forest Service. This would be a good thing. There's a lot that went to that. Unfortunately, with bankruptcy, that really is what ended that discussion, nothing more. It was very hard to move forward when you had no idea what kind of funding there was going to be, what the town was going to look like, or anything else. So as far as this current process goes,

2:26:55 The rec commission as a whole decided, yes, we want to move forward to see what this MLR might look like. And with that, the two council recreation representatives, which is Mayor Wood and Mayor Pro Tem Bacon, got together with the two appointed people from rec commission, which was myself and Betsy Truax, along with the then town manager, Mariana, and Stuart Brown, our recreation manager.

2:27:25 And that's where that initial list came forward. And it did come before the council, and the council approved that. So it was actually an appointed list from the council, which originated from rec commission, town manager, recreation manager, and council recreation representatives. And that list actually was originally quite larger, a lot larger than we ended up with.

2:27:53 And the then town manager is the one that actually asked us to reduce it and not have duplication. And so since all five recreation commissioners were invited to the table and all of us sit on one of these different committees and then we tried to touch base with all of the other committees that they, because everybody in this town, as we know, wears multiple hats. So we tried to make sure that we touched special events, the schools, the county, the mountain.

2:28:22 I don't have that list in front of me. But anyways, so we tried to make sure that we touched that at least once. And all of these meetings were hosted. There's nothing that changed on how we did things. And it's been very public. So it isn't a group of people that got together that appointed ourselves and decided to move forward with this. It's been quite a process. Thank you. The podium is still open for members of the public who wish to speak. John.

2:28:57 Hi, good evening. My name is John Wentworth. I'm here tonight as a citizen, as a candidate for the town council, and as the chairman of the board and the chief executive officer of MLTPA. I support option one in your proposed action this evening. And I believe that the board of MLTPA can speak for them as well. They support this action as well. Fundamentally, we support it, I support it for several years.

2:29:27 Very specific reasons. The opportunity for accountability for public funds and the projects that these funds will implement. So it's accountability on two fronts. Not just for the money, but for the projects that these funds are going to be implementing. That's critically important. People have talked before about we can't afford any more mistakes. We cannot afford any more mistakes in the implementations of our plans and the things that we need to do for our success moving forward. The opportunity for a strategic implementation of the town's adoptive plans.

2:29:55 Including rec strats, the parks plan, the trail system master plan. Innovative solutions to the community's opportunities and challenges. If we're making a $2 million annual payment for a while, we need to innovate. We need to find new ways to deliver the critical services and programs that this community needs to succeed. There have been candidates in this election who've talked about how wonderful innovation sounds. This is innovation writ large in flesh and blood right here. These are the kinds of things that we have to do.

2:30:24 We have to have the focus necessary for success. The town, municipal government can do a lot of things very well, but a program like this requires a specific level of focus to be able to succeed. I believe MLR offers that opportunity. It's been stated many times that the opportunity to enhance and leverage Measure R and Measure U funds is a critical part. It's in the DNA of what MLR is all about. And I think that those opportunities are not coming forward.

2:30:53 How we're doing things in the present. Those opportunities are not becoming available to us. We need to be able to do that. And that goes to building on the opportunity for, on the success of Measure R and Measure U to date. For the last six years for Measure R and however many years it's been for Measure U, the community, Sandy has mentioned the volunteer citizens who've served on the Measure U and the rec commission committees like this have done an excellent job vetting, managing, and running a grants program.

2:31:21 With a significant amount of investment of town staff time from the general fund that's never really been truly acknowledged to date. We've done a good job with that. I think that we've, you know, all the moving parts, all the things that are involved in a program like that, things have gotten done. The money is mostly accounted for. There's still some issues of reconciliation with the town staff. We've done a good job. We can do it better. We can do it better going forward. And I believe that MLR gives us the opportunity to do that.

2:31:48 Just a couple things about maybe sort of rewriting history a little bit. The first measure, MLR process, produced recommendations for a recreation director for the town and it also produced, I'm just checking my notes here real quick, it proposed a restructuring for the town's recreation department, a very detailed road map going forward to restructure the town's recreation department. That did not happen.

2:32:16 It provided a recreation director job description to hire a recreation director for the town. That did not happen. Recstrats came forward because a non-profit organization working with, in collaboration and partnership with the town, funded that. That's how that moved forward. There was a contractual service agreement between MLTPA and the town for issues having to do with the trail system. That agreement no longer exists. So perhaps people need to look at a certain level of disappointment.

2:32:41 With folks who've been involved in bringing Measure R and Measure U and the opportunities forward to this community, a certain level of disappointment that we went through that entire process. There's a 250-page document, if anyone wants to read it, documenting all the things that happened in 2009, 2010, and to see so little of that come forward and become tangible to the community. Perhaps that's why we're going back to MLR again and trying to bring this thing forward again because there's a need for it. And I think if people have questions about the why, you know, why would anybody want to do something like this?

2:33:10 You can ask the California State Parks, who's in a very traumatic reorganization process, why do they want to have an outside organization to provide strategic planning coordination, enterprise functions, fundraising and finding solutions, land acquisitions, communications, marketing, digital information tools, organizational capacity and effectiveness. Why does the state of Utah have a state of Utah outdoor recreation vision that states we want Utah to be prosperous, we want Utah to remain beautiful,

2:33:39 We want Utah to be healthy. We want Utah to be accessible. We want all of Utah to share a sense of community. I think these are exactly the same types of values and goals that MLR is aspiring to. And I think that we're no different than any of those other places. We just got a great opportunity in front of us to make these things real and tangible and to build into our future the opportunities for success. So that's why I support it. Thank you. Thank you, John. Pat. Pat Eckert. I'm one that got involved in this.

2:34:15 The tail end of the whole thing. I've kind of been involved in things before and I'm tired. I got tired reading the documents. I had one complaint about them is that there were no real specifics. It was all grandiose planning. It might be really good. I did write a letter to the board or the town council on February 19th.

2:34:39 Thanks to Sharon and her article in the paper kind of alerted me to something was going on. I didn't know the details. I still hadn't read the documents. I questioned the legality of it. And over time, Sandy got me in a ball and I just immersed in all the documents. And I don't know why, but I just got really angry. Or maybe because I'm tired of 30 years.

2:35:08 of living here when it was incorporated and going through one after another after another problem. So I did question the legality. I'm kind of in the process to set it aside. This might be a really good plan. But I'd like to ask the council, why could the town not do in five years what this might be a wonderful plan do?

2:35:36 Why does it have to go outside and use an NGO to do it? That is the thing that stays with me. And a couple of nights ago, I took 30 minutes off my time and got online and I looked up NGOs and voter approved tax, vote for taxing on themselves as we did for recreation a bunch of years ago.

2:36:04 And guess what came up apart from Africa and NGOs, which I spend a lot of time in Africa, so I know about what all the wrong things are about NGOs, so I have a negative view. Well, guess what? The first thing that came up was California. And I forgot to bring that page here. But it lists three propositions. Going back, I think I'll miss maybe 20 years. Some of them, I think one was at Parks.

2:36:34 The article was misdirected tax monies. And it's the same topic about voters voted for it. We do. Voted for propositions in California. You vote for something and you want it to be done, guess what? At least in these three examples, one of them turned out to be a negative. One of them, nothing was done. And another one,

2:37:02 The money went into an NGO and disappeared. Something to that effect. I should have brought it with me. But I look at this and I just think, you know, the recreation in town has been pretty good. I've seen a big difference. I can hardly walk up a trail in the spring, summer, fall without having to step aside. I can't get up to the top as fast as I used to, not because of age, but because of having to step off the trail for all the people running. Okay?

2:37:33 So if somebody's been doing something right, I just want to express my concerns about this in using taxpayers' money, which will involve with the high overhead monies that were not intended, like with the propositions that at one time in the future it will be illegal. Thank you. Thank you, Pat. Another Pat.

2:38:53 You know that you couldn't be discussing this without me having something to say. So thank you for listening. I think the concept before the Council tonight has some merit and is a commendable approach to maximizing some of the taxpayer dollars to fund recreation projects. And I acknowledge the efforts of the group, the Formation Committee. I know they've put a lot of work into it, albeit a smaller group.

2:39:23 And, you know, I support change. I'm not afraid of it. But I want to make sure that it's done for the right reason and it's done properly. I think other members in the community feel the same way, and I think that I just want to make sure that change doesn't result in mistakes that can be very costly. I think you know a little bit about my background, that I've been working in the recreation profession for over 30 years.

2:39:52 I've been on the Recreation Commission for four years and recently was appointed to the State Board of Park and Recreation Commissioners. So I'm really passionate about recreation. I really have a strong interest in making sure that it's the best that it can be in this community. There's been a lot of dialogue. Dana did a great job of making presentation about the process.

2:40:17 But early on in the process, having participated in those summer meetings, the very first meeting, people in the community had to sit for three hours. They had to endure three hours of dialogue without any comment. And at the very end, they were able to make a couple of statements for a couple of minutes. Fortunately, that did change. I guess the consultants heard that and maybe the steering committee as well. So I do applaud comments being made.

2:40:46 Taking seriously and making some adjustments. And as was alluded to earlier, I think after the February presentation to Council, I think that things were definitely much better communication for those of us who are interested. I mean, it really didn't get the promotion like Planning and Clarks did or anything along Main Street, no ads were taken out and things like that. But for those of us who are interested, the notices were certainly there.

2:41:16 I think you need to think about the intent of the voters. I mean, do they really expect that Measure R and Measure U money, or I guess at this point Measure R money, would be spent primarily for administrative costs, which I think is what will happen with something like this. And it's great that it will be revenue neutral in a few years. Why couldn't it be revenue neutral sooner rather than later? And let's see.

2:41:47 And I know that one point the town attorney had mentioned that he thought that the intent of Measure R and U was to be spent on tangible facilities and programs. And so if $300,000 of Measure R is already allocated for trails for a five-year period, and I think we're in year three of that, that's great. I think it's resulted in many improvements, as have been noted. And if another...

2:42:15 $300,000 is set aside for this NLR. That doesn't leave much money left to leverage or bond. I think the Recreation Commission, even the Measure U Committee, have done a great job in setting aside funds from the allocations for capital improvements and reinvestment back into the community. But that doesn't leave much money to work with.

2:42:42 And then in the agenda bill, it wasn't really touched on, but it mentions that the Recreation Commission, in redefining its roles and responsibilities, should wait until there will be two vacancies on the commission in July, myself and Betsy Truax, that redefining the goals of the commission should wait until the new members are appointed. I think that's a great idea.

2:43:10 That's why I also think it's a great idea for this body to give consideration to letting the new council make the decision because there will be a majority of change on this council. So I don't know why it's suggested that it be one way for the Recreation Commission and something different for the town council. And then also it was mentioned that the MLR should guide the commission in setting their priorities. And I'm kind of wondering, well,

2:43:40 Who are they to be saying what the commission's priorities and responsibilities should be? Shouldn't that be the town council's responsibilities? So I think that's something that needs to be considered. A couple of other things that have been mentioned a couple times that the community during these formation committee meetings mentioned that we need to think large and I'll try to wrap it up. Beyond

2:44:09 And a position something similar to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism. One person mentioned that, and obviously it was latched on to because it seems to support an interest in assessing a large salary for an executive director. But looking around, there are other community nonprofit organizations that don't even offer benefits. They don't offer pension plans, things like that. It's all included within the salaries.

2:44:37 And I think that you could probably look to find somebody, as Councilmember Lehman mentioned, that's hungry. And a couple things. The Formation Committee, as I mentioned, I think has done a good job. It's getting closer. But there's still so many unanswered questions. And it was even pointed out by Dana and others. So I just want to leave you with a couple questions that I have.

2:45:06 As a businessman and women in this community, would you spend your personal funds to establish an organization like this that doesn't have a business plan, that doesn't have a budget or specific tasks and deliverables? Think about that. Would a bank loan money to an organization that was trying to get structured in this fashion? I know that all these things are forthcoming, but that's what keeps being mentioned. It's forthcoming.

2:45:35 The formation committee will select a permanent board, and I know legally they can do that, because the town attorney has mentioned that, but is it really an unbiased approach to take the, or isn't it ethical for them, current members, to vote themselves onto a board like this? And bottom line, I guess what I'm suggesting is that all of the homework be done before this comes back to the town council to really make, you know,

2:46:06 A definite decision regarding this. Make sure that all the T's are crossed, the I's are dotted. Let's get it right and why rush it. Thank you. Thank you, Pat. Other members of the public who wish to speak. Good evening. My name is Drea Perry. I am the chair of the Measure U Committee since August of 2013. And I support MLR because I see this as an amazing opportunity to make things happen.

2:46:43 I am passionate about arts, special events, recreation, mobility, and I feel that with this money and finding somebody and a team who can help leverage funds, we have the opportunity to build places that we wouldn't be able to build with just the $1.8 million a year.

2:47:11 I see the possibility of a recreation center. I see the possibility of an aquatic center. For those of you that have been participating in the Plan Your Parks, you know that this can be a reality, but it costs a lot of money, and $1.8 million a year is not going to cut it. So if we can find someone who can help us find more money, then we have the opportunity to

2:47:41 Thank you.

2:48:07 That is available for different special events to use. And I think that will be a much wiser use of our public taxpayers' money. And in addition to just a special event site, to having some type of an enclosed building for perhaps at the college or in another part of town where we can have classical music concerts and continue not only the education

2:48:37 Thank you, Andrea. Others?

2:49:10 All right. I don't see anybody else who wishes to speak. Do council members have any other questions after hearing public comment of the chair of the formation committee, Dan Straub? I think some of the questions that I have will be answered when we walk through the pieces of the option. All right.

2:49:39 I've got one, Rick. It's pretty general, and I think it's appropriate now. I'm not sure if Dana is the one that answered or not. Do we have an example of another community that has a similar – is there another prototype out there as to what we're trying to do, either in California or elsewhere? John Mammoth, we do things differently, right? Yes. However,

2:50:11 There's been some extensive research done. I don't know that there's any entity. In fact, I'm pretty sure there isn't any entity out there in the state of California that has passed tax measures such as R&U to the extent that we did here in Mammoth. And so that creates a little bit of a different scenario. But I can tell you that across the country, there have been organizations formed outside of government to provide support for the recreation amenities and facilities and services that are provided.

2:50:39 There are places such as St. Louis. There are places such as Roanoke, Virginia. There are places such as Oregon. There's Pasadena that has the Rose Bowl operating company that has a direct contract with the city of Pasadena to operate and oversee bond money to improve the Rose Bowl itself as well as the Brookside Golf Course. So we have several examples of organizations that have been formed.

2:51:08 I would submit that

2:51:39 The big mistake, of course, was the airport lawsuit. But if you look at things other than that, we didn't make a mistake on Mammoth Lakes Tourism. That was innovative. We didn't make a mistake on Mammoth Lakes Housing. That was innovative as well. And we didn't make a mistake with transportation, Eastern Sierra Transit Service, ESTA.

2:52:06 I think we have other examples in the community where we have been innovative and those innovations, I think without exception, have been successful. Thank you. Other questions? Well, now's the time for council deliberation, but before we do that, Joe Bacon and I were talking and thought that it might be helpful for the public as well as the council members for us to walk through.

2:52:37 The options analysis and in particular option one, which is the option that the committee, the formation committee has recommended be presented to the council because it seems to me and us that this is first of all several parts that should require a little bit of explanation, comment, or thought as to why they showed up as they did in the manner that they did.

2:53:07 There are two options. A, with a number of suboptions or subdivisions, and it starts with the approval of funding scenario 2.0. You know, you saw the chart. That chart is the latest and last iteration of several that the committee considered because ultimately,

2:53:37 This is about funding something. This is about what the Council wants to do with the funds that we have such a wonderful and unique opportunity to not only receive but expend. And because without the funds, this organization doesn't get off the ground. Now as Dana has stated, it is designed and will be expected to

2:54:06 Thank you.

2:54:23 Before us is because of RNU and because of the thoughts that a number of members of the community, members of the recreation commissions, members of the council have felt is a couple of programs that perhaps could be administered and implemented more effectively than they have been in the past.

2:54:46 That's the foundation. So as a subpart, the request is to continue the suspension of RNU. We've already explained when we originally asked for that, and this council approved it, why that was. It's not that we don't believe that funding for the things that we have previously funded should not continue, other than those things that are ongoing and other than emergency items.

2:55:10 It is because the process for the funding has not worked as well as it could have. Reconciliations that were required as part of funding have not been completed, and that's a process that should run concurrent or concurrently with the transition that's been described.

2:55:29 Two is begin the transition of MLTSC functions to the MLR Transition Board. This was pretty painful for us, I'll tell you, because we've got some hardworking folks, and I know members of the committee who've done an extraordinary amount of work made, in fact, some budget recommendations that, frankly, are productive. However, one of the purposes of doing this is to...

2:55:57 Pull everything into and under one umbrella, one organization, so that we don't have the disconnect or apparent and sometimes perceived disconnect between and among the various committees. That transition essentially means that MLT SEC, at least as I envision it, is going to go out of business. But that doesn't mean that those participants

2:56:24 And those who make recommendations are not going to be making a recommendation in the future. It simply means they're not going to be reporting directly to the town council, would be reporting directly to an MLR, at least as I envision it, that will then report to the town council, make recommendations with respect to funding, including those things that MLTSCC has recommended.

2:56:47 The third is to begin the transition of Measure U Application Committee functions to the MLR Transition Board. Well, that's an obvious and it follows number two. The fourth, and I think, and I can't remember, it might have been Pat Agnich who made some comments about the guiding the Recreation Commission in redefining its roles and whether that should occur after the board members are seated. This agenda bill doesn't suggest that. This agenda bill suggests

2:57:15 That the guiding process begins now and that it continue and it specifically states that the including ensuring that the upcoming application information for two members shows the intended changes. That's pretty important because we want to know, we want new members who may be applying to know what it is that this commission is going to look like if it is going to change and I expect that it will. Its role and responsibility will change.

2:57:43 So I see that as a process that begins now and will continue. As we've stated in the agenda bill, we expect that a permanent board would be seated in October and essentially we've got June, July, August, September, four months, perhaps five, to work through that transition process. It also reminds me of something, which is that I believe that MLT took the better part of a year to get through transition.

2:58:11 I don't recall the public was particularly concerned that it didn't have all of the decisions that needed to be made permanently done at the time that it was authorized to form itself and hire a director and hire staff and begin expending the money that otherwise would have been expended directly by the town. Rick, while you're on that one, I also want to make sure, because you kind of blurred over it, is the main part of this,

2:58:41 Option is staff would do these sub-numbers. So staff would be guiding the Recreation Commission. All of these are directing staff to do things. Which means the town is going to have a role. Staff obviously reports to the town council and town council will provide the requisite oversight. We spoke about preparing the measure our expenditure plan to assign MLR as the recommending body for all funding other than the

2:59:11 MLR Contract. And as I understand it from Andy, our counsel, that's something that is required to be done in order to meet the legality of getting the funds from the town to the NGO. That's obvious that that's something that needs to be worked out or completed, I should say, within the next four months.

2:59:40 Next is prepare the appropriate documents to designate MLR as the recommending body for measure U funds. This is not dissimilar, at least in my mind, from the, or to the role that Mammoth Lakes Housing currently plays and has played for a decade.

2:59:58 Which reminds me, the process that we went through as compared to the process that we went through to form Mammoth Lakes Housing is astonishingly different, at least in terms of the exhaustive level of input, participation, meetings, and so on. Councilmember Stapp and I, a decade or more ago, put together Mammoth Lakes Housing after we passed an ordinance that allocated, made a political commitment to funding it. I can tell you...

3:00:27 That wasn't a particularly public process. We tried and it went for a while and we finally got it done in a very awkward, unfacilitated way, much, much different from what I've seen in this. But the point is that the idea is for this body to consider R&U and make recommendations to council.

3:00:55 Tell the council what its priorities, which come from the community, are. And ultimately it's the council that decides what to fund, when to fund, how much to fund. And then finally, under this subsection A, number seven, complete the reconciliation of measure R and U funds to date. That's an important piece and relates to the suspension of funds. That's something that is important to us. And that relates to accountability. And I've heard in past comments, I don't think I really heard it tonight. I was kind of pleased.

3:01:24 That we've got an accountability problem. That somehow these money, well, it's kind of hurt. I heard it from Pat Eckhart who said, you know, money is going to be misdirected. Well, I didn't see anything in here that suggests that anybody is intentionally going to misdirect any funds. We're directing funds. And we've got the opportunity and the authority to do that. But having said that, I would expect that the accountability that we require of our staff now and which

3:01:53 For any number of reasons that I can't state, because I don't know, has not been forthcoming, at least in a timely way, I can't imagine that we would not do better. John Wentworth said it, we can do better. And I think that's one of the things that we can do better of or with because the community is going to demand that we do better, just as we have done better with MLH.

3:02:19 which presents to the Council each year its audited financial statements. We happen to have one because these came out and were approved by the MLH Board last month. MLT is no different. They present deliverables to the Council and request that the contracts that they have entered into be renewed and that the funding that they...

3:02:45 Have either previously received or are requesting now is going to be given. And so that brings us to the second option, which is B, direct staff to begin negotiations with the MLR Transition Board and bring back a proposed contract with MLR for council consideration. Frankly, I would love to have seen that happen tonight. But this task has been so thorough and so exhaustive that, and quite frankly,

3:03:13 Paced very well that this is something that a new council is going to need to consider hopefully with if this council approves what we've requested a recognition of the strong commitment that this council has made now three times before and we're hoping for a fourth tonight.

3:03:39 to this organization and moving it forward in the way that is proposed. It is true that there are, as it is put, unanswered questions. I would characterize it, quite frankly, a little bit different, and that is that we're simply moving through a process. We are at a stage where we're asking the Council to give it another push forward.

3:04:02 And the details as they will come forward will fall into place just as they did for housing, just as they did for ESTA, just as they have for MLT. And I'll have some more comments later, but that's the rationale, if you will, and the explanation of the seven or nine matters that we're asking the council to approve tonight. Jo, do you have anything else? Well, I do have something, and I realize that based on the discussion we've had, this

3:04:30 Evening. I think under A, there is probably an 8, which is to direct the town attorney to ask for the FPPC ruling. I don't know what kind of wording we want to put there, but I think there's now a... Regarding the conflict potential? Yes. And I heard discussion that it be on MLR, MLH, and MLT, so I think that may be part of our discussion. But I was thinking that would be.

3:05:01 Little Roman numeral eight. Yeah, that makes sense. So those are, those are, that's the rationale for having come up with the recommendations that are made. With that, other council comments, I'll hear from anybody. Anybody? I'll make a couple comments, just a couple quick comments. One, just, I think some comments about community engagement.

3:05:38 I'm not being transparent, and there could be more and more and more. I mean, 17 public meetings, three council meetings, numerous sub-community meetings, and I think this has been thoroughly vetted, and I commend all involved for the outstanding work and time and effort and energy. I think at the end of the day, it's pretty simple.

3:06:08 It's the responsibility of the town council to hold MLR accountable. And, you know, when you get into this, MLR recommends funding allocations to council and council approves or not approves the recommendation. So, to me, I mean, I've been very concerned since day one on the expenditure side, the final decision-making side, and I think that the work that's come forward

3:06:37 It really speaks for itself and speaks volumes. And again, I just commend that there's been a lot of great work done with this. I think leveraging our resources is key. And I think we can go to the next level and leverage those resources and get some things done. So that's all really that I have right now. Any other comments? You know, I want to make a couple of comments that are important to me to make.

3:07:08 First of all, I want to start with where I started a little while ago, which is the extraordinary opportunity that Measures R&U has provided for this community. And what I didn't say, but what I expected that I would have the opportunity to say is there's a guy in the room here tonight who is...

3:07:35 I wouldn't say single-handedly, but almost single-handedly responsible for the passage of RNU. That's John Wentworth. We would not be here. We would not be having this discussion if we didn't have RNU, and we wouldn't have RNU without John Wentworth's extraordinary effort that occurred twice, the second of which I never thought would pass, and it did. I was a skeptic, but he brought me on board, and this community said,

3:08:04 We want to do something different. And so we did. We did something different and pretty extraordinary. And the members of our division of the League of California Cities are so envious of us that we've been able to put together something that unless it is overturned, either one of those measures will go into perpetuity, a funding stream into perpetuity that is...

3:08:31 Going to be available for bonding things that we've not been able to have in this future, but we've asked for for a long time. And the second thing I want to say is, you know, as many of you know, I was originally elected in 1998. That was 16 years ago. And I was elected on a recreation platform. And it was reported in the papers at that time that the reason that I won that election was not because I had the business community. Dan Wright had that.

3:09:00 But because I captured the soccer moms. I don't know if there are soccer moms anymore, but whether I did or not, I know that people voted for me because of the positions that I was taking promoting recreation. I'll tell you, once getting on council, I became pretty

3:09:21 Well, recreation sort of took a back seat to all of the other huge issues that were before us at that time because you may recall that was the beginning of the last development cycle. But I never lost, I never came very far from my roots and so this idea, if you will, is not mine.

3:09:45 Terry's in the back of the room. She's been at it for a long time. Joe has been at it for a long time. And I'm fortunate enough to have been able to tag onto or latch onto what I thought was an extraordinary idea initially, and then the funding came along to actually make something happen. And so the question is asked, well, why can't the town do this? Why can't in five years the town achieve that which what we propose

3:10:14 to be formed could achieve. Because it hasn't. And it's had that opportunity. And we can do better with more focus, with expertise that we don't have time, that we don't have the ability to put into place in a way that's more efficient, that's more economical, we will get better and more bang for our buck. I was convinced of it when the idea began to gel and I remain

3:10:43 Much more convinced of it today. The problem that we have, I think, and by the way, I've got to also say something about those faithful people who attended the various meetings and were critical of the process all along the way. This has been very, very helpful.

3:11:06 Some of them tonight, some of the speakers tonight said we've come a long way. Some of the ideas that have come out were much better than the ideas that existed or were bantered about when we started. This is a democratic process. Sorry, Sharon, you think that it wasn't, but I've got to tell you, the comments that were incorporated into what you see here, in some instances, were excellent and changed

3:11:36 The end product. And I expect that the watchdogs, those are the people that ought to be, those who are critical of the process and perhaps aren't supportive, will keep the transition committee on its toes and will require this council to assume its responsibility for the oversight that is required of all of the NGOs that we have in place. So I commend you guys.

3:12:03 Sometimes in the heat of the moment, it may not seem as though I'm appreciative or that the committee is appreciative of comments, but we've had a real divergence of views and those views have been put forth. And by the way, the committee has not been homogenous either. There have been a lot of different views and opinions, people representing different constituencies and points of view with different perspectives who have brought something to the table in these 17 meetings.

3:12:33 And so, you know, I love the democratic process, and this worked. Now, the problem is, let me get back to the problem, is that it's become politicized, because we're in an election season, and we have a candidate out there who has staked her candidacy on opposition to MLR. And what I saw from Karen Seibert, which was pretty much beaten back, factually, factually,

3:13:00 Is something that I would expect during the election season. But I will tell you this, those who've been there from the beginning, and I saw Karen once at the end for about 30 minutes at one meeting, she's not here tonight. But those who've been there from the beginning, Sandy, you included, have been involved in that process. Agnich, God bless you for standing up every single time and providing input. But I'll tell you,

3:13:27 If you put something out there as a council member and politicize something, then you're going to get it back because there are facts, there are truths that have been put forth today that essentially beat back what I consider to be misinformation that's been put out there to the public. Now I think this council understands that because we get that from time to time.

3:13:53 From those who are either late to the party or misinformed or intentionally uninformed. Frankly, everybody's got a right to speak, as they should. And we should listen to each one of the things that is presented if it happens to be different from what we might be individually promoting.

3:14:13 But what I saw in that letter suggested to me that a person is in a very uninformed way essentially raising flags that shouldn't be raised. And so I would, as council members, discount that letter. And I'm sorry to be so harsh, but I didn't write the letter. I'm not running for office. I didn't politicize it, but it's out there now. So with all of that, you can see from the committee members.

3:14:41 From the council members who participated and the commission members, there was a lot of passion. I see this as just an historic opportunity. I can't articulate the reasons as well as John Wentworth did extemporaneously. Well done, John. I asked the council to move forward with the items that are presented in the agenda bill with the addition of subsection 8 as presented by Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon.

3:15:06 Mr. Mayor, I'd like to hear from either Matthew or Pat if they have any further comments at this time. I know Michael spoke, didn't. Do either of you have any? Matthew or Joe? No, you mean Matthew or Michael? Who? Matthew or Joe. Sorry. That's a Freudian. Sorry, Joe. You know, John, I don't have a whole lot. I think I said what I had to say. I really had just a couple of questions. I share some of the frustration that Mayor Wood spoke of. I just...

3:15:37 You know, when I hear that this wasn't a democratic process, it's a little bit frustrating because I think we did go through the steps. I think the bottom line is there's just people that disagree with the outcome. And I've seen that in four years up here. Sometimes people disagree with the outcome, and I can understand being frustrated over it. But I think people should be cautious of which stones they cast because it's, you know, I don't get my way all the time, and I think you just have to accept that.

3:16:07 Is it perfect? Probably not. I mean, I don't think anything we do is, but I think that a lot of good work's gone into it. I think it looks like we're ready to move forward and continue with some hard work, and I think that there's a lot of people, whether you're for or against it, that are going to look after the process, and I'm going to leave it at that right now. Joe, comments? Thank you, man.

3:16:37 Well, I think you all know that I have poured my heart and soul into recreation since I've been on council. And I totally believe in this and that it can be accomplished and that this transition period is there to get it to the point of up and running. We're so much farther along than we were even in February. And I'd like to thank the other committee members and the public who attended our long meetings.

3:17:02 One of, in fact, one of them being three hours and 40 minutes, and believe it or not, we didn't cover everything. I'm just totally behind this, but I think you all know that. I wanted to, Mr. Mayor, if I could, I wanted to talk a little bit about history in the town of Mammoth Lakes since we incorporated. I don't know the exact year. Someone in the audience might know, but it was approximately 19...

3:17:29 1989 that the Town of Mammoth Lakes purchased the Mammoth Lakes Airport from Mono County. Kirk Stapp and I brought the argument forward at the time that the Town should not purchase the airport unless the Council at that time created a funding source or a revenue stream to pay for operations and maintenance of the airport as well as to pay for airline subsidy.

3:17:59 This was roughly, let's say, 1990. Pat, you worked with Kirk and I. That was 25 years ago, roughly. But our point was that don't do something new, like purchase the airport, unless you have a revenue stream to go with that purchase. And our argument was that it's not just the purchase price, which was just under $300,000, but it was...

3:18:27 It was to create a revenue stream to pay for the operations and maintenance as well as airline subsidy. We actually went to a vote of the public at that time to see if the public supported that. I don't know what the numbers were, but it was 55, 45 or something fairly close. The council members at that time and the leaders in the community said, oh no, we don't need this.

3:18:56 It's going to cost no more than $15,000 a year to pay for operations and maintenance of the airport, and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, by the way, would pay for the airline subsidy. We know what happened in that interim, but my point is that none of those were true, but the point is that you don't create something new without creating that funding source or the revenue stream. Since then,

3:19:27 We now have a tax measure.

3:19:55 Have subsidized air service in our shoulder seasons in summer because of the T bid. So again, when the community wanted something, they created the funding source. Mammoth Lakes Housing, that was a tax measure passed by the community. ESTA, Eastern Sierra Transit, our free bus system in Mammoth Lakes today, whether it's Mammoth Lakes going up to the ski area, going up to the lakes basin, going to Reds Meadow.

3:20:26 That's all free, and it was free because the citizens of Mammoth Lakes passed a funding source, a tax measure, because we wanted that transportation because we knew we needed to compete against other ski resorts. The people in the community passed that tax measure because, not because, but when they passed it, I mentioned Buck McKeon, our congressman at the time, he saw that.

3:20:56 And it showed good faith back in Washington, D.C. And because of the good faith it showed he got funding for us to purchase our buses and also to purchase our transit facility down the industrial park. So all of these things that we've wanted we've created a funding source for. I would argue that the funding source that the community created this last time, and I had the same impression that Rick did, I thought, no way.

3:21:26 John, no way could you get a supermajority to get R and U passed so that they were a permanent funding source. But the fact is, is both of those are a permanent funding source now. And again, the community passed those with a supermajority so that we have those monies. And now, where we are now, is transitioning into another organization to administer

3:21:54 Those money for recreation projects and arts and culture and special events and things like that. So I just see this as a continuation or an extension of things that the community has done in the past. And it's tough for some people in the community to have confidence or faith in taking this step because it is the community's money.

3:22:21 But I would point to the other examples where we've done this previously and had very successful results. Thank you. Thank you, John. All right, other comments? None. What's the pleasure? Jo, would you like to make a motion? I would love to make the motion. I just want to check with Council and see if I have to be more specific on number eight. I have clear enough direction. Okay. I know what you need.

3:22:49 Go ahead. Yes, okay, then I would move approval of option one as amended. Second. Two seconds. Before we have further discussion, although it's a little out of order, Pat, you're standing, I want to hear from you. And tell me if I'm wrong, I just wanted to respond to a comment that you made, Mayor Wood. Go ahead. So I don't know if it's appropriate or not, but...

3:23:17 I'm not on Karen's campaign. I have nothing to do with it. I haven't gone to any of her meet and greets. But I think to suggest that her comments be disregarded is really public freedom of speech. And maybe she misunderstood some things, just like maybe I misread that one comment about the Recreation Commission and setting their roles and responsibilities. But at least I was here and I heard the response to it.

3:23:45 And her not being here, you know, I think that that's maybe not fair. But that's just my comment. Thank you. Politics isn't fair. But I appreciate your comment, Pat. And by the way, just as an aside, I'm not connecting anybody to Karen's campaign, yourself or anybody else. I don't know who is on her committee or for that matter who her supporters are. I was speaking directly to the comments that she made as a council,

3:24:17 Candidate, Councilmember, Candidate. Is it appropriate to take a... Oh, we've got to vote first. I'm sorry. Can we take a little break? Can we vote first? All right. Hearing nothing further, we'll call for the question and roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Mr. Eastman has requested a little break. We're going to take five minutes and reconvene at quarter to nine.

3:24:46 You and approve the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee's 14-15 budget recommendations. Let's see. Thank you for the larger print version. You're welcome.

3:25:39 Peter, you're going to lead off on this? Yes. Okay. Thank you. And you're here, council members. This, I don't plan to go through the whole staff report in detail, but just kind of the highlights, and then if you'd like, we can go through the project list by detail. But, and I have a modification on the recommendation. So this item is a continuation of discussion from May 7, 2014, where the council did approve

3:26:07 Budget Tracking List Items 472, 511, 551, and those related to the stewardship, trail days, and the project to do trail grooming. In addition, staff approved, or I mean council approved item two, which was to work with Friends of the Endure on the Forest Service, MLPTA, to modify the agreements to perform that work activity.

3:26:38 So the staffs recommended recommendations to change the option one is to approve the MLTSCC and Recreation Commission recommended project funding for each of the projects shown on the MLTSCC 2014-15 budget tracking list except for items 472, 511, 551 which have already been approved.

3:27:09 Item 2 would be deleted because that was previously approved at the May 7th meeting and then recommended direct staff to work with the Forest Service to develop the overall maintenance program to find the scope and responsibilities for hard surface and soft surface facilities. This may be through a cost share agreement, MOU amendment or special use amendment permit or combination thereof. With that, staff did provide counsel in the back room.

3:27:39 The same table that you had previously with the bigger font. I deleted all the column, or I just hit all the columns related to previous expenditures and just have the highlighted columns that were asking for approval at this time. With that, counsel has questions. First, I need to, I forgot to make the statement up front, but I need to explain that on this last agenda item, I was recused from the discussion.

3:28:07 Because there was a consideration of a contract with Friends of the Inyo and I sit on their board. However, I am not recused from any of these discussions. And I forgot to make that clear. I do have a question of staff. Is that option two says direct staff to make changes to the resolution and return them. But we don't see a resolution tonight. Is that correct? That's correct.

3:28:39 Essentially, if the funding is recommended, that would be incorporated into the budget resolution that you'll see next month. Okay, so when we see the budget on June 4th, it would incorporate. Correct. Thank you. Other questions? I do have one comment when we get that far after public comment. Yeah, as do I. Members of the public who wish to speak to what is before us, which is to approve

3:29:13 The, well, essentially the funding for the 14-15 year, and that specific funding is the $300,000 that this prior councils have committed to on an annual basis to, for lack of better term, trails. Anybody wish to speak? If not, Jo, your comments, please. Sure.

3:29:41 I had no problem with number one of option one of approving the project and funding and putting that into the budget for 14-15. However, I think that based on our previous agenda items direction to start the transition of MLTSCC, I would suggest at this time that we do not approve numbers two and three of that option and request that

3:30:11 MLR and the staff work together quickly on the transition so that we know we do not hold up any projects for this summer but that we do not direct the staff to work with the partners who MLR will be working with. Right. That seems logical to me that with respect to the funding itself that it be approved and it's really good work by this group. And I state that based on the fact that

3:30:41 MLR will be meeting again tomorrow and one of the things that would be on the agenda would be setting up a committee to be working on those transitions and probably focusing on MLTSCC first because the town staff support is only here for one more meeting of theirs so that that would be a sooner rather than later transition.

3:31:02 I would expect that as well. So what you're suggesting is that in option one, the subsection one be approved, but two and three not be approved because essentially it will transition to MLT. Yeah, not be approved tonight so there's an opportunity to...

3:31:19 See how it all works together. If I may, item two's basically has already been approved. That was the agreements for the funds of the INEO. Well, on this version now, that was number two last time. So it was what was three and four is now two and three. Yeah, in the current bill. Don't do it to us at this hour. Yeah, what I'm suggesting is on the version we're looking at here is that we approve the budget, but we don't direct staff to do anything else.

3:31:46 Knowing that the MLTSCC transition is going to happen sooner rather than later. John, in light of those comments, I see you standing up. Do you have a comment? No. Very quickly, I support what you're saying. I think that I appreciate the staff's effort to keep it moving in that direction, but MLTPA hasn't had any conversation with the Town of the Forest Service about the proposed actions.

3:32:13 There's nothing going on with that right now. So I think in the interest of efficiency and good management going forward, I think Joe's recommendation makes a lot of sense. Okay. Other comments or thoughts from Councilmen? I just want to make sure that given Mayor Pro Tem Bacon's comment, if items two and three are removed, there's an item, number 11, that's proposed here. And I want to make sure this won't trump any potential outcome of that.

3:32:44 Basically our... You mean 111 down here? No, our item, our next agenda item. Oh, no, no, no, I'm just speaking in relation to agenda item number 10. Right, no, I understand. But you're saying approve everything except items 2 and 3. 2 says direct staff to work with U.S. Forest Service, MLTPA, Frenzy, et cetera, on partnerships for overall strategy on trail system. And then 3 says direct staff to work with U.S. Forest Service to develop an overall maintenance program.

3:33:12 And I just don't know how closely those will tie in with the next agenda item. I want to make sure that we can still discuss that. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. No, no, no. I was just saying in relation to putting a hold on these, which I consider is a short-term hold, and it was our understanding that nothing is impacted by taking the time to figure out

3:33:39 You know, which pieces go where and who's going to be working with whom. Okay. And just to comment so that it's clear, one of the things that from the beginning, I and many others had hoped to accomplish is to, well, I think I said it earlier, to bring it under one umbrella, to get everything in one place.

3:34:00 So that the things that are being considered are not considered independent of one another. And this provides us with a really good opportunity and really also a test of the ability of the transition board to begin the work that we say we're going to do so well. Any comments from staff on that proposal? Well, I think item three relates to a couple of things. One of them, you know, several work items within the

3:34:30 Thank you.

3:34:54 Right. And it's not saying that staff wouldn't still do that work. It's taking the moment to step back and figure out, because I fully understand that there are certain things that will still be directly between the town and the Forest Service, but to have MLR now be a partner to it, an understanding of it, and so on and so forth. And then the other item was the soft surface trail standards is something that's been discussed for a while, and our understanding is the Forest Service isn't going to

3:35:24 Allow the town to continue or to build additional sharp trails in the sharps area until we've developed those standards and understand who's going to maintain them. Yeah. So those are the, those are really the. No, and, and, and I'm also not saying that things that are on here that staff is already working on are going to change it all, but we just have to understand who's on first. Bill. You know, none of this is written in stone.

3:36:00 If we take out part now, we risk perhaps alienating some of our partners, and I don't know, I have not had a chance to talk to them. But the work that we're doing with the Forest Service and how they're willing to work with us in the future depends on how they view what we're doing today. I would like to see it passed in total so that they understand that the commitment to work with them on the soft service trail maintenance

3:36:27 And on maintaining our hard surface MUPS that we have special use permits for is going to go forward. If at some future time we decide to move that from town staff to MLR staff, or if the decision is made that it has to stay with town staff, we could even appoint someone else in the staff. But by moving it forward now, it gives the reassurance to those of us on MLTSCC, and John, you can correct me if I'm wrong, I'm only one member, and to those...

3:36:55 Partners that we were already engaged with, that regardless what happened with MLR, we are going to follow through with our commitments and continue down the path of maintaining the soft surface trails and the hard surface trails that we're finally getting in partnership with them to do, if that makes sense. Sorry, I did not intend on speaking, but, Jo, you scared the heck out of me, so I had to. No, no, no, and what I was saying is not that it's going, I was just saying that

3:37:23 I understand where you're coming from, and we're not saying that these things aren't going to happen. We're just saying give it a couple of weeks to do the transition and have it come back where it can clearly be stated which, if any, of these things might be handled differently now that MLR is a part of it. All I'm saying is passing it today doesn't preclude you from doing that. However, passing it today passes the strong message that we are going to continue to do it.

3:37:53 If we do it differently, that's fine, but we are still moving forward in that vein. I don't see any derogatory in passing it today. I don't see how it's tying your hands as to who you allocate to do the work at a later date or through recommendations of MLR who they choose to do at a later date. But by saying we're going to continue it today, we are at least...

3:38:21 Telling our partners that we intend on following through with this. I don't think we need to know exactly who it is that's going to do it. It doesn't call out a specific staff person. It just says staff's going to work on it. And I just tried to read it real quick. I could be wrong. Well, and it does say that, but see, Bill, that's what I'm saying is it says direct staff to do it, and we don't know if it's staff and MLR or if it's MLR. Yeah. Yeah, but if we direct staff to do it and they continue working on it.

3:38:50 And we transition it over to MLR. There's no problem transitioning from staff to MLR. But there is, Bill. Staff. There is a problem. Okay. What's suggested is that the staff is going to work with partners to develop an overall strategy for the trail system. But that's a function that I envision. A strategy for maintenance, I believe, is what it calls out. For maintenance. Yeah, sorry.

3:39:16 But that's something that it seems to me ought to be once again under a single umbrella. And one of the things, the opportunity for collaboration and cooperation is there now as we move this forward. That's why I'm supportive of putting a hold on it. But I don't think that we send a message by...

3:39:44 By not adopting this at this time that somehow we're going to either discontinue what has been started or disassociate from the partners that are identified here. I just don't see the problem with approving it and then if we change players, we change players. There's going to be a lot of educating that's going to need to be going on between what staff has been doing as it transitions to MLR anyway so that we continue going down a...

3:40:14 Productive path. MLR can't just immediately stand up and take over without knowing where we've been and what the plan was. So I don't see how it hurts us. Thank you. I see John is about to climb on your back.

3:40:34 Not that back. My interest is very, very narrow and specific. I appreciate Joe's sentiment with this, but in reading this agenda bill now for the second time, I don't want to speak on behalf of Friends of the Inyo, but we've been going through a very elaborate contracting process just to get the summer stewardship program up and running, and we still don't have signed agreements yet. I mean, this has been interesting. I don't understand what the expectation is for MLTPA or Friends of the Inyo.

3:41:03 Per the language that's in the current agenda bill. So if, to Bill's point, keep things going with the town and the Forest Service, you know, and Joe, I think, spoke very well with it. That's not being put at risk. I just don't understand what the expectations are of MLTPA and Friends of the Inyo to perform as part of that language. There's no money allocated for it. I don't know what our expectations are going to be. And going through the contracting process we've been going through just for some stewardship program, it's been onerous. And I'll just kind of leave it at that.

3:41:33 Do you feel that by not directing staff to work with our partners, there aren't some time-sensitive items on here that could be missed if we don't work on them sooner and later? Well, no, I believe that by adopting all of the projects in there, which option, which the number one will do. Right. Everything gets funded. That makes sense. That you should do. I'm just not sure.

3:41:58 Numbers 2 and 3 in there, developing the maintenance program, and I'm speaking very narrowly now to MLTPA and Friends of the Union. I'm not sure what our role is in all that. There's no money for us to do anything. I don't know what the expectations are of the town, the Forest Service, what role we're supposed to play in it. So if that, if it makes sense to leave that out of there for now, if that's not going to threaten the relationship with the Forest Service and the town, which I don't think it would. I just, I hope that no one's going to expect us to show up and put in.

3:42:26 You know, 100 hours worth of work that we're not funded to do and we don't have any authority in any of this stuff anyway. So those are my thoughts. John, thanks. I guess I'm just curious. Let's pull something out, for example, winter grooming program. If we can fund that, but is that going to fall under a maintenance item? Real quick, the item there that 511, 472, 551, that's already been approved by the council at your last meeting.

3:43:01 Move forward, though, with the friends of the AO. That example. We're not going to have one of the other ones. If we didn't have any other one, I mean, couldn't that fall under maintenance? We would approve the funding for the program, but then I guess I'm thinking a partner might say, well, if there's no maintenance attached to it. I'm not the expert on it, but from listening to the last couple of the MLTSCC meetings, what they're talking about there is

3:43:30 Whether or not summer of stewardship work on the trails counts towards maintenance of the trails commitment. So if I got that anywhere near correct. And so it's an ongoing discussion. I don't believe that it in any way affects projects this summer. Two and three look like planning exercises to make.

3:43:56 So two, maybe just to clarify a little bit. So two was already approved at the last meeting and that is the agreements. No, no, no. We're talking about the two on this version, which is the strategy for maintenance. On page nine. On page nine, yeah. What was three is now two. Oh, I see. Yeah, so that's the. So you're moving up. Yeah. Okay, so you just deleted it. So that's two. Okay. I'd like to hear.

3:44:29 Yeah, essentially those, so we have a overall cost share agreement with Forest Service to perform different projects. We currently have two agreements from that, amendments for that cost share agreement. One of them is for the Lake George work that we're doing in Lakes Basin.

3:44:57 And that circulation program a review. And then the other one is the Sharps review for the NEPA. And then eventually we'll do CEQA in coordination, cooperation with the NEPA exercise. So what these really are is developing the new agreements for some of the other work that would be in partnership with the Forest Service, which is like the over snow vehicle NEPA review that they're going to begin this summer.

3:45:25 We're putting in a $20,000 contribution as part of the program. It's to develop those agreements so that we can continue to work with the Forest Service on the programs. And I think that's where I was trying to head for the next item because if... But if that's in the budget right here and we approve that, doesn't that happen? Well, the number two now gives us that specific direction to work with them to develop those agreements. So that's approved as is.

3:45:51 It can't be folded into the transition? That's my thought is that you've got the funding to work on that, whatever number it is. Yeah, and my thought is that instead of I somehow want to see it start to incorporate MLR into it rather than not incorporate it. I just wonder if some of these aren't going to take time, though, to, you know, like I said,

3:46:19 Go back to the NEPA review. Oh, that's a three-year project. That's ongoing. Okay. This is a new project. Oh, I'm sorry. You're looking new 146? For the over-snow NEPA process the force is going to undertake this year. And I just think that there's going to have to be some sort of maintenance item tied to that as well. Well, the point is that if you look at number two,

3:46:47 The cost share agreement that Peter is speaking of, at least as I read this paragraph, is for a period that begins for the 15-16 year, which is over a year from now. The objective is to have MLR participate in the process and how that's going to ultimately shake out, if you will, as to who's got primary responsibility and what the...

3:47:16 How to essentially set up a relationship between town staff and MLR should be sorted out in the next couple of months. These are planning exercises that obviously will take time. And so the point, I think, Jo, correct me if I'm wrong, that you're getting at is if that's the case and if we've just approved something that says let's move forward,

3:47:38 Then moving forward means having MLR involved in this as opposed to this simply being a town exercise that doesn't fall within the umbrella or under the umbrella of MLR and may involve a duplication of effort in the event that that's something MLR should ultimately take on, which I think it probably should, in collaboration with the town. So I don't want to beat it to death, but it just seems like...

3:48:05 One is distinguishable from two and three. Two and three are something that are planning that go out into the future. I think we're splitting hairs on this, and I've heard from staff, and I've heard from a member of the MLTSCC Committee, and so I'm going to go with what I interpret from them, and I support proving one, two, and three to see option number one in its entirety.

3:48:31 I'll go ahead and make a motion that the town council approve option number one as stated. I'll second. All right. Give me a motion and a second. Further discussion, council members. Dan? Let me just make one comment on that. I think moving forward to that, I think we're hearing what council is saying. We'll be working with MLTSCC on these types of items as we go forward. It sounds like that would be transitioning to the MLR discussion. So I don't think the approval bifurcates that process.

3:49:02 We would continue to work with that committee, but it sounds like the committee's functions is going to transition to MLR, so we will be engaging MLR through that process. It's going to be that transition time of the committee to MLR and what that looks like. So to the extent that we would be working with the committee, that same work would go through with MLR, so I don't think we lose that connection. So I think we can accomplish what's been requested and what I'm hearing that wants to be done.

3:49:31 Without having to necessarily slow down some of the work processes and agreements that would have to be put in place regardless. Then can I get a clarification? Is the work that's referred to in 2 and 3 funded through measure, the measure R-300,000? Or is it funded through, is it part of... That's part of the projects that we're just approving. Part of the budget work that you're... Part of this budget work? Yes.

3:49:57 And you can see, like, for example, MLTS data library collection maintenance, collection and maintenance of GIS, which, so we're talking about maintenance, then the next one down, MLTS image library, maintenance and management of, so, I mean, it's really, we're saying we're funding it, but then we tell them you can't do anything. And I can appreciate duplicating efforts, I know what you're saying, Mayor Wood, I just, I don't want to tie our hands on some of the other projects, though, that could potentially move forward.

3:50:26 You know, in collaboration with MLR. So. No, I get your argument. I'm reading this gender bill a little differently. In fact, much differently, but I appreciate the argument, certainly. Okay. Jo, it sounds like you're having to say. Yeah, I do. And as long as it is understood that

3:50:53 This, especially if you're talking about a strategy for the next year, that that does include staff, but it's my understanding that this kind of maintenance is actually a little bit different than actually the maintenance that might be listed in some of the other items here, so that as long as it's clearly understood that staff understands they'll be working with MLR in the future on these items, I can live with it, yeah. I think that's very clear.

3:51:27 All right. Thank you. There's a motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Motion passes 4-1. Thank you. That takes us to the last agenda, item number 11, which is discuss potential change to the town of Mammoth Lakes U.S. Forest Service Special Use Permit, adjusting the use of

3:51:56 OSV on areas between the Mammoth Lakes Industrial Park and Shady Rest Park, something that is being reprised from about a dozen years ago. It was very familiar. It was more than that, Rick. Well, I was on the council in 2002 and I thought we settled this. So did I. But here we are. So with that, with that preamble.

3:52:21 Let's see. This is, I see, written by Councilmembers Lehman and Eastman. Does one of you want to take the lead on presenting this, or what would you propose? Okay, I'll go ahead. Basically, I wanted to bring this forward and appreciate Councilmember Eastman working on me with this. I think we both, I think, recognize that

3:52:47 Some of the over-snow vehicle and motorized vehicle have kind of really seen more limited access over the years, particularly out of the shady rest area. And this agenda item is trying to address that. What we're really asking for and trying to present today is, you know, with the opening of the tunnel and the ability at least through the town to have access to and from, you know, either side of the road through that tunnel.

3:53:16 We really wanted to also really solidify access into the forest and public lands areas from the Shady Rest parking lot out into the forest and also heading south even using the MUPS to access the industrial park and open space areas going in that direction. And that's really where it falls. I know that there's some

3:53:44 NEPA, we have some NEPA review on the MLTS worksheet here, item number 146, which addresses some larger concerns and, you know, basically for over snow vehicles, groomed and non-groomed trails. And I just really wanted to make sure that while we're enhancing access to our public lands, I wanted to make sure that certain groups, excuse me, were not left out.

3:54:13 We seem to do a very good job of grooming our trails for cross-country skiing, snowshoeing and all these other activities, which I think is wonderful, but somewhere in the process, snowmobile access just seems to be getting cut off and more and more challenging. So with that, we're basically asking that in addition to this NEPA review moving forward, that some of the funds allocated for

3:54:43 Allocate an item 441 for Capital Reserve Fund be used to cooperate and coordinate with the Forest Service to see if we can't gain access snowmobile over snow vehicle access from Shady Rest all the way to 203 along Sawmill Cutoff Road. Understand that ORMAT's planning on coming in and if so, they're going to need access out to those areas as well.

3:55:09 If they end up plowing, then there's no way for anybody really to get out there if they plow the entire road. So one of the suggestions was to plow half of the road and perhaps leave the other half open for snowmobile access. This would provide safe access for snowmobiles. It would allow cross-country skiers and snowshoers and walkers and everybody else to have an area that's groomed for themselves and keeping them separated from the snowmobile access.

3:55:35 And in addition to that, we're also proposing that access along one of our MUPS issued through Forest Service Special Use Permit and cooperation with the town to gain access from 203 under the tunnel past the RV park and upward towards the industrial park area so people that are storing their snowmobiles there can also gain access to shady rest lands and also

3:56:04 Thank you, Matthew.

3:56:34 We've driven further and further out, further and further away from the community from logical, what I would consider to be logical staging areas for over snow vehicles within the community. I don't think Matthew and I would have brought this up if we hadn't had our recent experience with the further pushing out of the staging area for over snow vehicles.

3:57:03 Further and further out into the shady rest area, making it much more difficult for people that use the machines to access other parts further to the north. I feel that the desires to recreate on over-snow vehicles of the individuals that use them has been discounted and not heard in recent years.

3:57:33 And that now's the time to bring this forward. We'll see where it goes. We'll see what we can do. But I, for one, do not want to sit as a council member and not address this at this time because it's going in the wrong direction. The town of Mammoth Lakes and any recreation plan that is established in the eastern Sierra or in the community of Mammoth Lakes should be inclusionary.

3:58:02 to all recreation users and not exclusionary. And I feel that the current situation is exclusionary. So this is my attempt to make it more exclusionary. John, I have a question for you. Please. So it looks like there's four things, really, that you're asking for. One is coordination with the Forest Service. Following that, number two, to return to council with

3:58:36 For further direction. Three is to make this a top priority of the MLT SCC. And four is to allocate funds. But what are the funds to be allocated for? Well, I think has been stated that we have to do with the four servicers of NEPA process.

3:59:08 And I think it's really up to a certain amount of money to allow staff the time to coordinate with the Forest Service. And it may not be this entire amount. It may be a much lower amount. But it's really to try to just initiate the process so we can

3:59:36 Try to amend any use permits and any other coordination with the Forest Service so we can get this changed, quite honestly. The NEPA process looks like it's already going through with a $20,000 funding source, so that'll be part of it. But we understand that there may be some other needs for funding, whether it be staff time or otherwise. If I may on that,

4:00:06 I think for this here we'd have to coordinate with the Forest Service on updating our use permits for those trails because right now they don't allow motorized. We have two issues. One will be a town policy question because we don't allow it on our current MUPS. So we'll need to modify that to make sure it's okay from the town perspective on the trails that we control. Those that are under the special use permit, we would have to modify the use permit which would require a separate NEPA work which this could then fund.

4:00:32 To make that happen, it wouldn't be incorporated, I don't believe, under the broader NIFA process that's being done, this would be specific to our use permit. So this would be an update to a town use permit process that we have on those trails. We'd have to coordinate and work with the Forest Service if it's a part of the town to allow that motorized or the non-motorized area, and that would be the real focus of probably more of the expenditure side, and John is here from the Forest Service and speak to that as well.

4:00:58 We did have a good conversation about this yesterday in terms of process if it's part of the town to work together to move that through. Same thing here as in the previous item where we have the MLTSCC item there. You may want to put a slash MLR. That would be a coordination effort as this goes forward because it probably won't be done in a couple of months. So it would be a coordination between that transition body as well.

4:01:23 The dollars that are identified there are in the budget worksheet as being in a reserve right now, so that could be allocated for these purposes. And what number is that? It's 441. Page 2. And I think the idea there would be we have to meet the Forest Service and have that discussion on it. If we want to update that use permit, what would that require? What would it take? Look at the timing and the cost and come back.

4:01:52 Again, as a recommendation to the council on do you want to then go ahead and move forward that work and sound like the direction here would be to move in that direction. Okay. I'm getting confused now. Okay. Because on the one hand, you're saying that the – can someone explain to me what's in new number 146 over snow vehicle NEPA review? What does that encompass? That's the $20,000 plus the – No, but I mean what does the $20,000 do?

4:02:20 It's a cost share with the force. No, no, no. I'm saying what do we get for our $20,000? You get to participate in the NEPA process. Bill might be able to press some. Get our MLTSCC person up here. Yeah. Due to some lawsuits that were filed against the federal government for over snow vehicles, they're now required on all the western forests to do a NEPA process to justify the OSVs.

4:02:42 And the OSV grooming programs. So the Forest Service has limited funds and at MLTSCC we have allocated, and correct me when I'm wrong here, we have allocated $20,000 into a fund to help with that process so that we don't lose the ability to snowmobile and lose those tourists even further. Is that for existing trails or for all OSV? That is...

4:03:08 For all of OSV, as I understand it, and for the OSV grooming program that we currently fund through what is called Green Sticker Funds, or OHVMR Funds, through the state. So that was a threat to the sport as a whole. The funds that I think John and Matthew were talking about are funds that we have allocated in the Capital Reserve Fund, which would be for any environmental review that is necessary.

4:03:39 to change the special use permit on the MUPS that we currently hold special use permits for with the Forest Service. We don't know what that amount would be, if it would be more or less. Before I get any further into this, I want to thank these two guys for coming up with this. I did not push them into this. Bill, while I have you, another reason that I brought it up is because the difference, the striking difference between Inyo County and Mono County,

4:04:08 As it relates to motorized vehicles is black and white. In Inyo County, with the help of the Forest Service, the Highway Patrol, Inyo County Sheriff's Department and others, they have put together a trails program for motorized in Inyo County.

4:04:34 They were told going in that, oh, you can't cross the road here, you can't do this, you can't do that. Well, I don't know if it's approved yet, but if it's not approved, it's getting pretty close and with all the agencies working for them. So they have been able to overcome many, if not all, of the obstacles that they have going in. On this specific, and John is right, there was state legislation that allowed them to make multi-use roads.

4:05:03 Although that was legal going in already, but they got special legislation which is now under lawsuit. Yeah, thank you. What's exciting about this is we now have MLTSCC. If you go back several years, the tunnel was being poached on a regular basis, whether it was legal or not, by snowmobilers. And if you looked at the RV park, that one whole section was filled with snowmobilers. By enforcing the closures and the ban on that, we've told those recreationists, those tourists, we no longer want them here in our town.

4:05:34 If staff had followed through on two different occasions where the council has passed resolutions asking us to go down this line, we wouldn't be there. But frankly, nobody's on staff is, it's not like the rec commission was given the task or the MLTSCC. So at least we have an area that now with MLTSCC and MLR that can carry this work forward and perhaps stop alienating that group. A lot of us spend a lot of time and money.

4:06:03 To make this a great snowmobile destination. At one point we were in the top ten destinations in the west. We aren't even in the top 99 anymore because we have alienated that group. If we're going to function as a resort then we need to attract legitimate recreation and this group is a legitimate recreating group and they spend a pass of money. So I want to thank you guys for bringing this forward and this is important. It is extra important now because the forest order

4:06:33 On the new staging area is going to disallow riding back to the 203 area. So the only way I can see to keep that open would be to open them up to alter our special use permit or to see if we can work something else out with the Forest Service. This is not my favorite alternative, believe me, as an MLTSCC member.

4:06:55 It appears to be our only course at this point. Another question of staff is you threw out there really quickly, Dan, something about how we have an existing policy that says no motorized on our MUPS. Is that correct? I don't think we allow the motorized on the MUPS. Well, I think it relates, if I remember oh so many years ago, to the conditions of the grant funding.

4:07:19 Thank you. I thought there was something. I can answer that question as well. We had an interpretation and I remember that was a gigantic debate. We had an interpretation from the town attorney that said we could possibly be sued and lose and have to pay back those grant monies if we went down the path of opening the tunnel to motorize. And there was a big debate about conflict. I want you to see how many non-motorized recreationists are using the tunnel today.

4:07:47 Then we had a recreation director come in, Mr. Wilbert, if you will, and he went online and he looked up the legislation that created the T-grants that we use for those trail systems and very plainly in the legislation. It is called out that in the wintertime if it is covered with snow, if you put up a sign closing it to bicycles, that snowmobile use is an authorized use. So we have already dealt with that and that's why in 2002 the council voted again.

4:08:16 to pursue this. Good memory. Everything but me, Jack. John. Thank you for staying up, John. Yeah, good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. John Regalbrugge, Inyo National Forest. I just want to speak specifically and briefly to the point Bill was making about the

4:08:47 $20,000 than the other line item. There have been some lawsuits nationally that have challenged Forest Service operation of over-snow motorized trail systems. We had believed that we had discretion to subject those to planning and analysis under a National Environmental Policy Act or not if they were existing programs and we weren't making changes to them.

4:09:14 The court cases ruled differently. A new regulation is being worked on and we believe it will be required in the future that to maintain existing or historic motorized uses we would have to designate the trail system through a National Environmental Policy Act process similar to what we did for our not over snow or summer roads and trail system.

4:09:38 That was we had made a presentation to MLTSCC probably six months ago suggesting that if motorized recreation in the winter was an important part of the town's recreation portfolio, so to speak, that we would appreciate assistance with that upcoming environmental process that we're also seeking other funds for. So that's what that's all about. And the tunnel was...

4:10:06 Prohibited to over snow when I got here in 2006 and I don't believe in that time there's ever been a serious look at doing it. I think a lot of the discussion that Councilmember Lehman and others have put forward is accurate in that the special use permit would need to be modified. That would require a National Environmental Policy Act process to get our approval. You know, we're certainly willing to take a look at a proposal to amend.

4:10:33 Any permit that the town has and consider where to go with it. So that's sort of our position on the thing. If the town decides this is what they'd like to do and made a proposal to us, we'd be willing to take a look at that. And again, that would be a separate National Environmental Policy Act or NEPA process with public involvement, et cetera, to amend the special use permit.

4:11:01 Than the one that we had discussed about for our overall system. They potentially could be done in the same NEPA process, but it's a, you know, a change is different than what we were already anticipating in the one for the overall over-snow system. So, hope that helps. Thank you. Thank you. Another question. Thank you, John. Thank you, John. So, this proposal did not go to MLTSCC for consideration and prioritization. Is that correct? Nope.

4:11:32 They have not discussed it at all. And on 441, where we have the, let's say, 19,000 out of the 300,000 that was set by as a capital reserve, has MLTSCC put any other money aside in other years into a capital reserve? And you agree with that, Sandy, that there's been some money? Okay.

4:12:08 Okay. You know, and just as I may, so that would leave $21,000 still in the reserve from the previous year. So over three years we've put $21,000 into a reserve? We had a, in the current year we have $21,000. Okay. So over the last two years. Correct. Okay. Well.

4:12:46 I guess I've heard several things. One is that the Forest Service will entertain proposals, and I'm really pleased to hear that because it's consistent with what we want to establish, with the kind of relationship we want to have. Second, when I read the agenda bill, I thought, you know, this is precisely the kind of project that an MLR should take on.

4:13:15 And with direction from the town, with prioritization by the town, and I just hate to bifurcate these things and have some stuff handled by staff, whoever that might be, whether it's Steve who's leaving or putting on Peter and his staff.

4:13:43 Or this is something that ought to be folded in because I voted on that in 2002. I may have voted on it twice, Bill. I don't remember, but I remember the arguments. And, you know, obviously we are where we are, but one of the other concerns that I have, well, there are two. Joe mentioned one of them, which is that this hasn't been vetted by MLT SEC or through them. And two,

4:14:14 I'm a little concerned that, you know, it says what we approved is in the last item was a budget that says capital reserve fund is to be used as capital investment for the benefit of infrastructure and programs. And I've got a little bit of argument about that because that's not what we've...

4:14:43 Designated those funds to be used for, which apparently would be to partially fund a NEPA process that has not been initiated by the Forest Service, and we don't know how much it's going to cost. I see the other NEPA process is $86,000, which are contributing $20 to it. So, I mean, I get it, and I get the approach that the council members wish to take, but is this something that ought to be handled by the NGO that we've approved going forward?

4:15:14 Well, I think my argument would be, we've been asking for this for years. Why isn't it on the MLTSCC list? It should, I've personally been asking for this before I got on council. And instead of seeing the snowmobile community being embraced and incorporated into a better access, they've been pushed out. And I guess, you know,

4:15:43 We want to be included in this. You know, our green sticker funds, the snowmobile community's green sticker funds were the ones that initiated the grooming going out there. Before that happened, there really wasn't a lot of cross-country skiing and hiking and snowshoeing out there. It was once the snowmobile community used their funds to do that that the rest of the community started to benefit. Well, as a result of that, the snowmobile, the rest of the community said, this is great. This is a wonderful place to be. We don't like these snowmobiles here.

4:16:13 So, I'm sorry. I mean, I appreciate it. I think that it would have been nice to see that on here and, you know, I don't know any other way to be heard. No, I understand and I don't disagree with you. I'm just speaking about the process. Yeah, I agree. I like to, you know, I want to honor the process as well. It's just that...

4:16:37 It doesn't seem like the process is honoring this particular group, unfortunately. It will be. The process will be followed because it's going to go to MLTSCC or MLR. It will be folded in there. It's just being asked to be a main priority now. Just to note that the project actually is in the overall list. What do you see here is just the things that are being requested to be funded.

4:17:04 It just wasn't a priority at the time and hasn't worked on. I was going to say I was pretty sure it was somewhere. Of course, that is a really long list. And that is my concern is if the majority of MLTSCC as a full body of is it five did not make it a priority, I want to respect that. I also want to I understand exactly where you're coming from, but I'm not sure that

4:17:31 Cherry picking one piece that may or may not be the actual solution. What I hear you saying is you want to have close into town access. What if it turns out that the other side of town is the better place to have that access? That's why I would like to see it vetted and discussed in line with the other priorities instead of an end around which is exactly what we were in the previous item trying to say we didn't want to have happen again.

4:18:00 Well, I think this has been discussed amongst the Snowville community. We've been to a number of meetings at the Forest Service Auditorium, and that particular community has expressed what they like. We keep trying to be sold on the fact that, well, maybe it's better for you to go out on the scenic loop road about five miles out. That's probably better for you, don't you think? Well, no, it's not. It's better to be right there where we were. We liked it where it was.

4:18:27 And I think to be sold and pushed out of town is not fair. And I think that they need to be more included in this. I mean, we could go through agenda item after agenda item, and rarely do you see anything addressing over snow vehicle issues. And it's not that people aren't speaking up. They're tired. They're frustrated from asking. Mr. Mayor, I think we could debate this for a while. So therefore, I'd like to...

4:18:56 Go ahead and make a motion and move that the Town Council adopt option number one as presented. Second the motion. All right, the motion is seconded. I'm not finished debating it. Matthew, what I'm hearing is the argument, the debate. I participated in that debate. My position on snowmobiles was very clear at the time and remains unchanged.

4:19:26 I agree that over the years those interests have not been represented as vociferously as they otherwise could be. We tried to balance so many years ago. I think, in fact, I was on the Recreation Commission with Bill at the time this originally came up before I was on council, and we tried to find balance, and it was a heck of a fight.

4:19:55 But we have a partner in this, which is Forest Service, and we have a committee that this council formed that made some recommendations and prioritized its work, and this didn't get included in it. And so what appears to me to be happening is that now council members are unhappy about the fact that it wasn't included after the fact, after we've passed.

4:20:23 An agenda bill that approves funding for specific items, and I'm just scratching my head going, well, what the heck happened to the process? It furthers my argument for why it is that I think that government has not done this recreation thing very well and why an NGO can do it better. This is precisely a precise example, but this council has not given any direction to MLT, SEC.

4:20:52 That I'm aware of to prioritize this. And so they didn't. Because apparently nobody was there to do so. And I wasn't there at those meetings. But if you're going to have a committee, whether it's MLTSCC, which is under the direct jurisdiction of the town, or whether you give it to the NGO to work with the Forest Service, it seems to me you ought to honor it. And what I'm hearing is that you don't like the outcome.

4:21:21 And that you therefore want to backdoor it. You're saying stuff that you're pulling out of your rear end, Rick. I don't buy your argument at all. I understand, John. At all. Rick Wood and Joe Bacon are anti-motorized. No, that is not. Yes, you are. You absolutely are. Look at my record, John. Yeah, I'm looking at it. Look at my record. I've seen it.

4:21:42 So Matthew and I are, and the last I looked, the town council is the body in the town of Mammoth Lakes that makes policy decisions. I understand. So Matthew and I would like to make a policy decision this evening. And I'd imagine that Bill Sauser has mentioned snowmobiles somewhere in this, and it's not in this document. Is that right, Bill? Quit smiling what word. But that's because it's a consensus of a committee.

4:22:07 My biggest concern that Rick had not stated is that I'm not in the position of thinking that we should be giving any kind of an ultimatum to the Forest Service at this point on what's been a long, controversial issue, has not been vetted in the community again, has not gone through the committee. Process. More process. I think there's a sector that's not being heard, and the reason if Bill's brought it up and it's not on here, it's because it's not been, because it's a lot of the same group of people.

4:22:37 That have the same passions and this particular group is just not being heard as part of it and they don't want it to be part of the recreational community. And I disagree, I agree with John, you know, it's being brushed off. Let me finish my comments. John, I respect you, love you, but you interrupted me.

4:23:02 I didn't know I interrupted you. If I interrupted you, I apologize. There was no intent. Let me make this clear. In four years, no one has brought an agenda bill on OHV, OSV to this council. Now, I left the council in 2006, and I voted twice when I was on that council to open that tunnel. My position on OSV, OHV has been clear. I served on the OSV, OHV.

4:23:32 The liaison committee or coordinating committee that Bill served on as this council's representative for eight years on that committee. I know very much about the issue that you have described here. And my position hasn't changed and it hasn't changed tonight. The issue that I have is only that the council is effectively overriding what the MLT-SCC has done.

4:24:01 And this council has the authority to do that. Don't get me wrong. We're not overriding. We're giving them our, we're making a policy decision that we're forwarding to them to discuss. It doesn't end here. It doesn't end on a vote tonight. I can see that from the bill. So it's a process. All I'm saying is, now Matthew, you want to debate the merits of it. And you don't have to have that debate with me. I'm on your side.

4:24:30 Doesn't make sense to me to pass this as it is if we're going to continue to have an MLT-SCC meeting. Now, you see it differently because I take it that you see it as providing direction as a matter of priority to that committee to consider it. Absolutely. And I understand that. And I don't think that we're on a different plane at all. I'm simply addressing the process. That's all. That's fine.

4:24:56 You know, I'm okay with the first part of the option about asking to go back and come back to council. I'm not okay with the idea that you're going to make it a top priority, you're going to allocate the money and ignore the committee. Well, of course not, because if we return to council, we'll be off of it and you'll get to shoot it down then.

4:25:16 That is not at all what I said. You don't have to say it. It says, option one says to discuss it with the Forest Service and come back for further direction. Mr. Mayor, I would state that we have a motion and a second. We've had additional discussion and therefore I would call for the question. The question has been called for. Well call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. No.

4:25:46 No, motion passes 3-2. Thank you. That concludes our meeting and we will be adjourned to the next regularly scheduled meeting to be held on Wednesday, June 4 at 6 o'clock here in the Council Chambers. Good night.