Town Council
· recording 3 hr 56 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
505 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Nice. Interesting. Yeah. Back in the day. I want to see it. Yeah.
1:03 I'll move right along. I'm excited to see it.
1:22 Hey Jamie. How are you? He's in the back. Oh, he's in the back. Okay.
1:51 Just give me a second. I've got to see if I can connect to our Wi-Fi here and see what's going on. Did you just fly in? Of course. Is the Wi-Fi not connecting? It is, but it's just going slow. Yeah, all right. All right. Are you ready, Jamie? Okay.
2:18 I will call to order the Town Council regular meeting for Wednesday, September 17. Roll call vote. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Colin, would you lead us in the pledge, please? Yeah. Would everybody please stand and join us? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation,
2:50 Under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. We will now move on to the public comment section of the agenda. This portion is for items that are not on tonight's agenda and are generally not discussed, but it's an opportunity to ask to be heard. The way we do this is that you go up to the podium and state your name and make your comment. So, whomever I see, I see Rick is already approaching.
3:29 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council. My name is Rick Wood, and I received today, and I understand that the council has received as well a copy of the Mona County Grand Jury Report for the 2013-14 year. And the reason I'm speaking tonight is that there is or was an investigation of the
3:58 Based upon a couple of complaints that were made of the town's handling of closed session items in particular with respect to the proposed materials recovery facility otherwise known as the MRF down at the industrial park. And the report includes findings. It also includes recommendations which I would hope that this council would consider.
4:28 And I'm not here to comment on or to advocate for or oppose any of the recommendations other than the fact that they are worthy of this council considering with respect to how it manages closed session matters, including property negotiations as well as litigation. But one of the things that was very clear to me from this report is that the
4:55 Subcommittee of the Grand Jury that conducted this investigation deemed this council or last year's last council to be a monolithic body instead of a body comprised and composed of five individual members with individual views and individual votes. And that is significant because they believe that the council has not been as transparent.
5:21 As it should have been and perhaps could have been in connection with the negotiations for the purchase of property for a potential MRF down at the industrial park. That concerns me because as members of the last council and two of you are members know I was a member of the council and recused myself from those discussions, those closed session discussions including the negotiations.
5:47 And as part of that recusal, I had no discussions with town staff, town council members, the town attorney, or for that matter, anybody else regarding the matters that were discussed by the council over the years in closed session. But the report doesn't say that, and the report should say that. A grand jury report should say, when they are critical of a council, whether the entire council or the council as a whole is
6:17 Either engaged in activity or conducting things that the grand jury doesn't think are transparent or appropriate. As some of you, or at least two of you know, the nature of my conflict is that I'm a lawyer in this community and I represent interests that would be and will be impacted by the placement of a MRF on land that might be purchased by the town.
6:42 And I don't represent the landowner, nor do I represent the town, but I do represent other interests that put me in a position of conflict. I honored that conflict by recusing myself. The other thing that the report stated was that the council as a whole held discussions relating to the MRF and other solid waste issues enclosed.
7:07 Sessions purportedly under the Brown Act exception for real property negotiations. Well, the fact is that's not true. The council as a whole did not do that because at least one member of the council was not present during those discussions. The other comment that I would make is that I had the privilege, I suppose, of being subjected to three hours of interrogation by a subcommittee that, in my view at the time, had reached a conclusion.
7:37 Without having investigated the facts. And I know from other council members who were interviewed that the process was not particularly pleasant because it was very accusatory in nature. That's fine. An investigative committee can be accusatory if it wishes, but it can't be biased. And in my view,
8:03 That subcommittee was biased, and looking at the makeup of it, one can imagine why, because some of its members have been longtime opponents of many of the things that this past town council and other town councils have done in this town. So I'm critical of the grand jury report. The grand jury is critical of the council with respect to this.
8:29 I'm going to make my comments known not just to the foreperson but also to Judge Eller who convenes and presides over the town council and I wanted this council to know that although it certainly performs a valuable service and its recommendations ought to be considered, they shouldn't necessarily be adopted. Thank you. Thank you, Rick.
8:54 Since the issue's been brought up, Andy, would you like to provide just an update of what happens with the report? Certainly. Now that the grand jury has issued its report, the town has 90 days from the date the report came out to respond. The town is required to address each of the findings and decide whether or not the town agrees or disagrees or partially agrees with those findings. The response has to come from the council. Typically it's signed by the mayor. It's approved by the entire council. Dan and I have talked about
9:23 The report and a proposed response today, we will be bringing back a proposed response to the council that you can then take a look at and direct us to make any modifications you like. In the meantime, if anyone would like to talk about the grand jury report, it's certainly something that we can talk about in open session. You can't really talk about it in closed session, not a way to do that, but if the council would like to kick around the grand jury report and the recommendations and findings, we can put that on the agenda for any meeting you like. Thank you, Andy.
9:52 Is there anyone else that would like to speak in public comment? Good evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. I just want to make a brief comment back in regards to a letter received from Stan, I hope I pronounced correctly, but Kowalski. I represent the Sierra Nevada Resort and Spa as our general manager. And I just wanted to comment about that, you know, we as a business, like many businesses in town, want to give back to those people in need. And we try to find ways to do that.
10:22 And we believe that the Gimme Shelter Carnival was a great success.
10:26 It brought out a very diverse group of individuals locally that took advantage of such a situation and supported a great cause. We look forward to working with the process to having the event again back on property. It's a gimme shelter permit for the wood request, but as a property representative, we would greatly support them being back on our property and continue on a tradition that we started this last year. This town has not had a carnival really, truly, in the past 35, 40 years, and for me it was great to see an activity that supported both adults and youths.
10:54 It was something that was a fun environment that was a great cause that we could all support. Secondarily, I just would like to follow up. There's a lot going up in June Lake right now, and on Old Manoth Road, the restaurants have agreed to do a 30% discount for any June Lake residents that comes down within the community. I know that there's people in need there as well, and we want to be a supportive effort wherever we can be. We try to bring food up.
11:18 There, but they didn't have power, a way to cook food. So we're just looking to give back to the community and support our fellow neighbors and hope that others in the community can do such a thing as well. Thank you. Thank you, Brent. Is there anyone else that would like to speak? Thank you, council members. My name is Jeff Posey. Some of you guys are new and don't know me, but I'm a big advocate for the Mammoth hockey rink. And I've heard rumors going around town that there's money available to put a roof on it. And I think it's time to finally finish that project.
11:51 It's been going, what is it, 14 years now? It's going to be the 15th season? Minus the couple that we didn't have when the rain didn't go up. But, you know, the ice, it would be way more efficient for you guys to run the chiller and to keep the ice in better shape if it was covered with any kind of shade structure. Obviously a metal roof I think would be the best, but whatever you guys come up with I think would really help out the kids here. We all share about stand-up kids.
12:21 This is the future of the town here. It's no longer just about the adults playing hockey. We have an incredible youth hockey program that myself, Bill Van Camden here, and Patrick have started. We formed ourselves a non-profit organization. We are affiliated with the AAU, and it's time to finish the project. I know you guys are selecting bids and thinking of other ways to keep the ice good, and I just...
12:51 I don't think we should waste money on a shade, like a little shade structure, shade netting, or like Stu said, paint the boards black. I don't think that's going to help. I think it's time that we cover the entire facility. And also, if you cover the facility, the chiller won't have to run as hard. So your huge electric bill would probably be cut in half. And it would also make our season a lot longer, enabling you guys to generate more income. And when the time would be here, like when it snows, it's puking, and the mountains shut down.
13:20 That's when the facility would make the most money. And right now we can't do it because it gets covered in snow. I mean, an inch, two inches of snow, the rinks, it's horrible. You can't play hockey on it. You can skate on it, but then little nicks and ruts and stuff like that that you can't see if it was free of snow. You catch that, you're done, you break your leg. And I know last year, either way, I think it's time to finish the project.
13:48 You know, to get these kids a permanent facility where they can go out and skate and not be shut down by the weather or shut down for two and a half months when they finally start hitting their strides, like, we're done. So that's all I have to say. Thanks. Appreciate it. Thanks. Before anyone else speaks, oh, a Kings fan. Could I ask staff to explain what the process is right now? Because that is truly a rumor that, quote, there's money.
14:18 Yes, Madam Mayor, thank you. For all the same issues as expressed, we have been looking at what are the options to look at covering the ice rink with the initial discussion being how do we extend our season because of the melting of the ice along the west side. So we're looking at options to try to do that. A roof cover would be ideal. The initial proposals that we've seen on that, though it's a million plus dollar project, we do not have that type of money available. We have...
14:47 Some park development impact fees that could be utilized in the 200 to 250 range looking at options to do that. So we are continuing to work through different options that we could bring forward. Direction from the council goes to the park and rec commission and then if that's a capital project to move forward with we could do that. We would really love to have something in place this winter but again it's going to be financially driven in terms of what the actual cost is and also
15:15 The initial issue was could we protect that melting area on the rink and be able to extend our season out for the exact reasons of as were earlier stated. But there's not a pot of money in the large dollars amount sitting there. And we do want, though, to work through an option that as we address these issues also is probably going to be a multiple phase process to get the full scope of what has been envisioned for the ice rink. But we would like the first step to be how do we extend the season? How do we reduce the melting of the area?
15:44 And then go from there. And where will the obviously interested citizens, where will that meeting be, where will those meetings be, what's going to be discussed? Do we have a timeline yet? Not definitely. Actually, we're waiting for some quotes back on some of the potential options. If we do that, it would come back through Park and Rec and to Town Council. Ideally, it would be done in the next 30 to 45 days. We'll have those meetings out there. So be watching for the agendas for those two bodies, and you'll see the items coming forward.
16:14 Okay, now it's your business. Good to see the hockey players here. My name is Devin Cole, and I am on the Mammoth Youth Hockey Team. I am here to say how important it is for us to get a roof built for the ice rink, because right now we are only able to play about two to three months a year. Having a roof will increase the ice time so we can invite other teams to play, and some of the NHL teams might even come for high-altitude training. Hockey has become huge in California, so this will be a great...
16:46 Opportunity for our team, town, and visitors. Thank you. Thank you, Devon. Hi, my name is Lainey O'Terry-Need. 2012, Mammoth Times came out with an article. That article said 12 simple words. At this time next year, a roof will span the ice rink. That was written on May 25, 2012. It is now September 17, 2014. Another thing in that article that caught my eye was that you had plenty of money for the roof.
17:21 Where did that money go? That is how slow Mammoth is at building stuff. I play hockey and I love it. Thanks to the ice skating and Patrick, I am pretty good, I think. But two and a half months isn't that much time to learn new stuff. If you have a roof, I think more people will notice it and have an awesome time on the rink. Also, the word might spread and people will come up for the rink instead of just the mountain. I am not a big fan of skiing.
17:50 And if you get a roof, then I will be able to play a different sport for six months to a year. Why is there no roof? What happened? Thank you for your time. Thank you, lady. Great job, kids. Mayor Bacon, Councilmembers, Patrick Bernard, President, Commissioner of Mammoth Youth Hockey. Jeff Posey and I have worked really hard the last couple years. This program was started by Greg Seamus at Grumpy's. I know we've had a long history with the location. You know, the ice rinks moved around.
18:28 But really, it's a time right now, you know, in the last couple of years, Jeff and I have had a couple of kids come out, and we've really grown the program. We were very fortunate to receive some money from you guys, which we're waiting to get the check, and we really appreciate that. We're going to have $1,200 from the city council to help form our youth nonprofit and get the program going. But one of the things that's really tough for the kids, and
18:55 For the adults as well is not having a roof. It's a beautiful program. It's a beautiful rink. It's very special to not have a roof. I mean, we staged, the NHL staged quite a few outdoor hockey games this past year. The Kings played the Ducks at Dodger Stadium. But the main thing, and I'm going to reiterate what the head of the NHL said, is the sun is a killer for ice. I had a hockey rink in my backyard that I built for my daughter.
19:22 And my backyard rink that was on Lupin and Dorrance lasted longer than yours. And you guys have a beautiful chiller, but the sun kills the ice, and so does the snow and the weather. So whatever we can do, we form this Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and I've gone to the Plan Your Parks, and Dan's done a great job, and Dan wants to get something done, but I think it's very important to finish the job. And before we go in to build other things, we have to realize that this is an amenity.
19:50 It creates revenue for our town. It employs people. And it's truly an amenity that a lot of places don't have. When you come up to the mountains and you can't go skiing or you want to have some fun, you want to do an outdoor sport and ice hockey's it. There's seven professional hockey organizations in California. There's three in the NHL and four in the East Coast Hockey League. The Bakersfield Condors were just purchased by the Edmonton Oilers, which is a big deal. We have seven professional hockey organizations.
20:19 Two Stanley Cups in the last three years. Southern California is the new market. Southern California is our market for Mammoth. I know we want to have everybody here, but every kid, every adult that comes and plays here has a great time, and it's amenity that we need to embrace, and we need to put a roof on and finish the job. Before we go build these other things, and Dan and we've done a great job, we've all got our brains together.
20:43 Come up with ideas for the bell-shaped parcel in every other place, but we have a beautiful rink that creates revenue, employs people, and we have kids here that want to play, but we have to finish the job. If you're going to build a house, it has to have a roof, and an outdoor rink's great, but it's more of a novelty, and we need more of a novelty up here, and people appreciate it, and whether we have a full enclosed roof.
21:07 Or a large steel structure similar to New York. There's a place, thinkrink.com. If you go to thinkrink.org, it's in Buffalo, New York. They have a very similar situation to ours. But it's amenity that we need to embrace and that I think adds value to this town. I've never heard a complaint at the ice rink, and I've been a volunteer there for four years. And we've never had any problems. Just the main thing is the weather and the snow.
21:36 And the sun. And at a certain point it becomes dangerous. And we want our kids to have a good quality playing surface. And when you start having soft ice or inconsistency in practice schedules and the parents don't know if it's going to happen, it really becomes disheartening. We're trying to, you know, create and build something, but battling the weather, which we do. And, you know, these kids already play out there at 6 or 7 in the evening. You know, I have 8-year-olds playing in negative 10 degree weather.
22:06 You know, the guys in the NHL are out there playing in 25 degrees in New York and they've got face masks. I've got 8-year-olds, you know, playing in negative 10, having a blast. And the only thing they're complaining about is they can't feel their fingers. You know, so let's get the job done. We appreciate it. If it takes time, that's okay. Rome was not built overnight. You know, it took 12 years to get it here, but let's put the money together. Let's invest. Let's figure out a way that we can finance it, whether it's MLR.
22:34 But let's make something happen because it's an amenity that we should all embrace and it's a great thing for our town. Thank you very much. Thank you, Patrick. Good afternoon, folks. My name is John Bruske. I'm a five-year resident in Mammoth Lakes. I've been coming up here since I was two years old. Councilmembers, thanks for everything you guys do. We appreciate it. As well as Posey and these guys. They do a great job helping out the youth as well as parking wrecks. Posey's been an advocate for the ice cream for a long time, helping out.
23:13 Many different venues. And the need for a roof is just paramount. It's got to be done. It has to be completed. Better sooner than later. Not only for the wintertime to keep the ice in good condition and in safe condition, so there's not holes along the board, but also summertime as well. Right now, it's just pretty much a desert out there. You can't really use the facility. If we have a roof, even for the summertime, there's going to be a lot more opportunities for other recreation to pop up. And I think once we...
23:43 We do get the ball rolling. When it comes to fruition, we do get the roof built. We're going to see a lot of recreation opportunities pop up for that as well. So I think it's exciting to get a roof over our head. It's going to be great. I think it's something we should all take pride in doing in getting this built. Thank you, guys. Thank you, John. Good evening, Council. I am not going to talk about the ice skating rink, but I think that...
24:13 That it's going to maybe impact the users of the ice skating rink is the new sidewalk that's going in on Meridian because then all the kids can safely get there in the winter from Sierra Valley sites. I know it's kind of a headache right now because of all the road closures and then Mammoth Community Water District is also in there, closing roads, but I look forward to when it's done and having a safe route to school for my kids and for us to use our bikes on that road. And so thanks. And thanks town staff for doing it too.
24:43 Thank you, Jennifer. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak. My name is Chris Niebuhr. I work for the Friends of the Inyo. And my position this summer has been Mammoth Lakes Trail System steward. There's two positions, me and a co-worker. And we're there five days a week, Thursday through Monday. And our job this summer has consisted of doing basic trail maintenance,
25:22 Patrol is on the trail, a lot of great public interactions. We lead a whole intert program based on education. We've had good turnout for that. And then also volunteer days for an opportunity for the public to come out and contribute. So a big thank you to the town for making that possible. Our job is funded through the town.
25:50 And it's a collaboration between Friends of the Inyo and the town and the forest. And so what I wanted to talk about was this coming Saturday we have our last volunteer day, which is going to happen at Horseshoe Lake. It's our sixth one. We've had record-breaking attendance this summer, which is, you know, attributed to so many people in Mammoth who care to come out and get their hands dirty, so it's been awesome.
26:19 This coming Saturday, we have the Lakeshore Cleanup in the Lakes Basin. We're going to meet at Horseshoe Lake at 8.30. It's going to be Friends of the Ineo. It's going to be MLTPA and a lot of really great local sponsors who every Summer of Stewardship event has been sponsored by local businesses. So a big thank you to them as well.
26:48 It's going to be a Lakeshore cleanup. We do it every day. I invite everybody. I thought this would be a good opportunity to announce it. Everybody's invited. It's really family-friendly, and there's great prizes, and at the end of the day, there's a huge amount of trash that you'd never know would be up there, but we find it and we pull it out, and it's great. I'm not sure how many years we've done the Lakeshore cleanup, but I know we did it last year and the year before.
27:14 And so, yeah, everyone's invited. We want to keep the attendance up. We're trying to break 100 this Saturday. And, yeah, thank you very much. Thank you, Chris. Thank you.
27:55 It's like, oh, let's go have a snowball fight. Nah. Oh, no, let's go have a snowball fight. And then you have it, and then you're like, I don't want to go play hockey. Oh, yeah, I forgot it was done. And, and, um, and, um, I really think you should get one so then we can have hockey, and, um, it would be really fun to do it. Thank you. Thank you, Cole. Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you.
28:36 All right. Any other public comment? It is so nice to see you standing up there. Thank you for coming and talking to us. Just one question. Could we get the name of the non-profit that they've put together for the hockey stuff? Mammoth Youth Sports Club. We're a DBA Mammoth Youth Hockey. We're actually non-profit under AAU, and we're doing multiple sports clubs. So to start, we're starting hockey. But AAU is a general amateur organization, so we're hoping to bring in a couple other.
29:04 Great. Thank you very much. You're welcome. All right. Anyone else for public comment? Seeing none. Yes. Did you want to speak? We'll wait to get over there so we can hear you better. So you need to speak loudly and speak to the microphone. My name is Victor Saus, but you can call me Joey.
29:37 And I want to say something about the roof. It would be great to have a roof because when I get on it, the snow is really slippery and it would bring more shade so we could get on the roof better and get off better because I felt falling a lot and it's like you.
30:08 You want to go sit down. If you fall, you have to get up with all that padding in its head. Thank you, Victor. Hi, I'm Sam Boyer. I've done ice skating almost my whole life.
30:42 I started skating when I was six. I had hockey skates, so I went out there, and when I first tried it, I was scared because of all that snow that fell on, I'd keep on slipping and hit those walls. I remember one time for my birthday we had it there, almost every kid broke their nose or something like that. What's this about masks for them? No.
31:11 It was because probably because of the snow. All the kids kept on slipping because they're new skaters and they kept on slipping because of that snow. I just want to try and get a roof on it because I don't want anybody getting injured on the rink or hurt. Okay, thank you, Sam. Okay, last call for public comment.
31:44 All right. We will move on to correspondence. We have two items. And actually, the first one is an email from John Armstrong about customer service. And Michael, since you're our representative on the MLT board and the chamber, and it's also one of our priorities, would you mind following up on this? We'll be delighted to. Great. Is that okay with everybody? Okay.
32:11 Our second piece of correspondence happens to be from the Sierra Park Villas Owners Association about some of the impacts of the Wild Iris Carnival this summer. And if I could just ask you, Dan, to give a quick update on how that permit might be looked at this next year? Yeah, as the permit comes forward, we'll take a look at it to look at addressing some of the issues that were created last year.
32:38 Looking at options, how do we mitigate those? Worst case, we look at maybe a separate location if need be, but trying to accommodate both the non-profit and the growth and the event, but also taking into consideration the concerns that the neighbors have expressed. And so we will walk through that, and if we end up with some challenges on it, it may come back to Council, but I'm hoping to be able to address it at the staff level. Okay.
33:06 All right. Next is Councilmember Reports and Additions to the Agenda. Can we start with you, John? Yes, Madam Mayor, thank you very much. August 22nd, way back in August 22nd, the pleasure of escorting Dan and Grady. We went out for a tour of the Sherman Area Recreation Plan, the Sharp site, to get these guys up to speed on that very beautiful opportunity out there in the Sherman's.
33:34 On Monday this week, Madam Mayor, you and I attended the meeting of the Water District Forest Service in the town, and you can probably give some more better detail on that. Interesting kind of a cross-purpose conversation. It's interesting to have all those parties in the room at the same time. We may want to think down the road of maybe realigning that a little bit, but at least for now it's good to have all those parties in the same room at the same time. And then yesterday I attended the Chamber Board meeting and had a wonderfully spirited conversation with members of the Board Directors of the Chamber of Commerce about
34:04 The opportunities of Digital 395 and integrating that into our community. It was a great kind of initial conversation. A lot of work to do, but I think a good recognition from that board of what those opportunities look like, and it was a lot of fun. So that's it for now. Thank you. Thank you, John. Colin? Sure, just a couple items. I just, about an hour ago, got done with the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board meeting, which was very productive.
34:29 And I believe the item that we were discussing is going to come before Council at some point, so I'll kind of save further comments for that. But mostly we looked at the alternative housing mitigation plan for the Inn at the Village. And so there was kind of a follow-up discussion that was pushed at the last meeting. And I think we made some progress with that. Councilmember Richardson and I went with Dan down to the California League of Cities at the beginning of September.
34:59 That was interesting. That was the first time I've done something like that. It's a totally different world. But we got to attend a lot of really interesting seminars where people were talking about things that certainly impact our community. So it was a good learning experience and got to meet a lot of good people. So I'm sure you'll have some more comments on that, but it was a cool experience for me for the first time.
35:30 Okay, yeah, like Colin said, we attended the California League of Cities Annual Conference, MNLA. That's why I missed the last council meeting, by the way. Going down there, quite honestly, I didn't know what to expect, and I was pleasantly surprised. They have a lot of great seminars. You get to do a lot of interacting with different city personnel, mayors, council members, managers.
35:59 But the one thing I noticed, and we'll talk about the different things in the future about the seminars that we attended, but there were seminars that I think would be very beneficial for other members of our community if they wanted to attend. Anyways, it was a great conference, and I look forward to getting together with those people that we made friends with down there.
36:27 I also attended yesterday the Transit Occupancy Tax Committee, the TOT as we call it, committee, and it's moving forward, getting better and better information and results, which is exactly what we need. So I think we have a really good group of people working on our behalf in the TOT enforcement. So I was very pleasantly surprised. That's all I got. Thank you.
36:54 Nothing to report this week other than I'll be attending the quarterly ESCOG meeting this Friday and ESTA this Friday and report back at our next meeting on that. Okay, great. And I have just a couple of items. On September 4th, John Urdi and I traveled up to Bridgeport for the Sierra Nevada Conservancy meeting at which we supported a concept called the Eastern Sierra Recreation Coalition or Collaborative.
37:21 Sorry. Collaborative. Yes. That would pull together recreation interests of Inyo and Mono County, essentially related to the whole Forest Service. John can provide more detail at some point, but that was quite interesting to see that board in action. Also, I want to remind our community that the board member applications for the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board are still available, and the filing period closes this Friday.
37:53 I believe we have no additions to the agenda, so we won't move on to reports from commissions or departments. Madam Mayor, Council, thank you. Steve Searles, Wildlife Management. Just wanted to give a quick update on what's going on with the wildlife here in town. When we went into the spring, third greatest drought in our lifetimes, I was really, really anxious. It was obvious what was going to happen. No food, no currents this year, no grasses.
38:30 As I tell the people around town, if I was starving to death, I'd steal from you. And I'm not a wild animal. I have morals. So we really were on high alert and tried to prepare the council and the police department that I work with, the community, that there might be multiple animals put down for good reason this year. Going into it without mindset, I just wanted to give you the latest update.
39:00 There's been zero depredation permits issued. There's been zero cars with bears locked in them, two bears locked in dumpsters, little cubs, but it's very slow out there. People are getting a few bears in their garages. If you leave food in your car, you will have a bear, but it's just incredibly low. What's going on in the north, the south, all the bears are being put down, all the stuff we're seeing on the news.
39:26 We're not seeing that here in Manhattan. I'm really grateful. A lot of questions about the bear that came down from Incline, from Nevada. He hasn't re-offended, and we haven't had any more issues with him. A lot of people still ask about the Bonds bear. There was a likelihood that we were going to kill that bear, and the bear hasn't re-offended and is living here in our community.
39:49 On the roadkill report, kind of morbid, but I keep count, this year we have one porcupine, two coyotes, two raccoons, seven deer, and zero bears that have been killed by vehicles in the town of Mammoth. That's incredibly low. I don't mean to be jaded, but seven deer, we've done seven deer in ten days here in Mammoth. We all remember all the accidents that occurred.
40:10 Some of this is for different reasons, different dynamics that are going on with the wildlife themselves, some other nature things that are out of our control. But I like to believe a lot of it is because of our community. We care to do this and we're doing an amazing job. The dumpster report, over 400 and some dumpsters that are here in Mammoth. We're running three to four that are left open per night.
40:32 I don't think we'll ever get to zero, but it's incredibly rewarding to see where we came from to where we are today, and we'll keep working on those three or four.
40:42 We have maybe 45 days left if we get a little help from the snow. And so I just encourage everybody to keep doing a great job that you're doing. We're setting the standard in the world for what's possible for co-optation with wildlife and not just the bears who are treating all the animals good. So I'm super proud of that. I wanted to share that with the community tonight. If you have any questions, I'd answer them if I could. Any questions for Steve? Thank you for your time. Thank you, Steve. Thank you.
41:15 Good evening. I'll give you a little bit of an update on the fire from June Lake. This is as of about 4.35. I got a message from Fire Chief Freevault. As you know, it started yesterday afternoon. It was a pretty scary situation last night, early into the evening. Overnight, they worked on it. They got some air assets on it before it got dark last night, and they hit it real hard this morning.
41:43 As of 430, the comment that he made was all control lines are currently holding despite strong winds over the fire. They had a ton of equipment on it. I was up there this morning. And between the Forest Service, our regional fire districts, hot shot crews from all over Southern California as far as San Bernardino and Little Tujunga, they had a lot of people up there working it.
42:11 I couldn't tell you the number of helicopters. I was concerned they were going to be running into each other. And, of course, being close to water sources made it quicker. It's been taken over as of 6 p.m. tonight. It's a Level 3 response from Cal Fire. There are crews coming in from Nevada. There is still power out that was turned off at the request of the fire department in parts of it, in parts of June Lake.
42:40 Cell coverage is also intermittent. I believe the evacuation area south of 168 is still in effect. I don't have an idea of when that will be released. Because of all the equipment in the area, even though it might appear that the fire is well under control and it's knocked down, although there's still an awful lot of smoldering activity.
43:03 There's a lot of equipment in the area, and I think that's the number one reason why the fire department doesn't want any extra traffic on the roads, because they need to be able to get in and out. But it appears to be headed towards a good ending here fairly soon within the next few days, but they no doubt will have people on it for several more days. Questions of Dan? Just a quick question. Any home structures, anything like that that have been affected at this point?
43:30 Apparently last night some got close on the very south side of June Lake. If you're not familiar with where it is, the fire area is basically east of Chair One and south of the residences on the south side of 168, and it burned up the hill. It got close to some residences, but they had structure protection overnight.
43:55 Bulldozers that put fire lines in, and I've got to say, when the fire service all gets together, they really orchestrate those things well. They know what they're doing, and it's impressive to see. Great. Thank you, Dan. Grady Dutton, Public Works. Just a couple of brief updates on construction. The bluffs, we have actually completed the paving up there already. They'll be working on the shoulders and replacing some survey monuments and be done completely by October 1st, and that went very well.
44:27 We actually were able to recycle some of the base that came off that project and did an exchange and sold it to another of our contractors down on Meridian. So we kept it here in town and repurposed it within just about a half a mile of each other. On Meridian, I really appreciate the comments I heard earlier. We don't hear enough of that, frankly, because that contractor and our staff have worked very hard on that very visible project to make it move very quickly. The whole thing is going to take about three weeks.
44:53 All the curb and gutter is in this week. Paving will begin on Monday, and we expect all the sidewalks to end on the week of the 29th. So it will be there and available and ready for the kids to get to school for the three-week period. On Canyon, just to back up everything else we've said, Canyon will be closed on Thursday for paving that area next to the village. We've notified them. Of course, we've worked with ESTA.
45:18 Everybody knows, but that's the last part of the paving down there, so that lower section of canyon will be closed on Thursday. We'll be installing street lights next Tuesday, and about two weeks from now we'll be wrapped up on that project out in the field as well. Waterford, we're actually meeting with Lahontan Water Control Board.
45:36 Tomorrow morning in the field, they wanted to see exactly what we were going to do for mitigation. We expect that they'll release us at that point and we'll be able to get to work on that next week. Even if it takes another week or two, we have provisions ready to finish that project this year regardless. A couple of other things. We've been working with the Forest Service, as you all know, and have heard more and more and more closely all the time. One of the things we discussed not too long ago was trying to extend...
46:01 The season's out there. They have closed three of their campgrounds already. We've worked with John Kazmerski and out in the field. We've actually gone ahead and placed some additional portable restrooms out in that area, and we've worked with them to use some of their dumpsters that are available by unlocking them and adding some of our own. In a true measure of cooperation, they have a map that shows where those are placed, and they're going to have them posted out there. By cooperation, I mean their color printer broke.
46:31 So they called us. We printed 30 maps. They came by and picked them up, took them out, and posted some of them. So we're down to that level, borrowing each other's printers. The other thing I want to mention is we do have on our website now a grant as part of us, our Baines grant we got a number of years ago. The total grant is about $1.4 million. What it'll do is study the area around Lake Mary and that roadway and the potential paths to Lake George.
46:58 Part of the project will plan the whole area, but another part of it will actually design the first section from Lake Mary Road to Lake George Road, which everyone that we've talked to has confirmed they like the alignment for that piece. Once the study is complete next spring, we'll confirm that alignment. We're 99% sure that's going to be the alignment before we go out to bid, of course, on that. The Forest Service has encouraged us to get moving because they want to see some winds out there as well.
47:25 The other portion of the path that goes from Lake George Road up to Lake George, although the exhibit that we sent on the RFP shows an outline of a path, I just want to assure everyone that that is not defined as yet. That's just one of the options. We probably should have put a bigger blob on there, if you will, to do that, but we're going to look at two or three different alternative alignments and come back before we do the final drawings for that piece. So the first part is pretty well set. Again, we'll confirm it with the study.
47:52 The second part we'll look at during the planning process. Thank you. A question for you, Grady. During that planning process, how does our community get involved in commenting on alternatives for where the path might go?
48:05 Part of the RFP has some public outreach in it. That's part of what the consultant's supposed to do, working with the Forest Service and has to schedule some of that to get public input. Obviously, we don't have a consultant yet. Those dates and anything aren't set by any means. But there will be notices for that. There will be an opportunity for people to provide input. Great, real quick. Is there been any progress on the light at the bottom of Canyon, the crosswalk area? Any more dialogue with doing something there? We have to signal for the...
48:36 Pedestrians at the intersection of Lake Marion Canyon, we are going to go ahead and fix those so that the pedestrian signal will get you safely across the street. But I might add that further up from that at the crosswalk where the buses are. That's what I'm talking about, yeah. Yeah. There's two pieces there that impact pedestrians greatly. On that one, I actually gave direction to staff earlier today to finish off a proposal, get it back to me, get a price from the contractor. What we're thinking is to...
49:06 And in both directions, coming down the hill and going up the hill, first go up a little bit and add a pedestrian crossing warning sign further up just to give an additional impact, but then down near the buses to go ahead and put another sign, a little flashing blinker, actually flashes in both directions at the actual crosswalk. So coming down the hill and going up, you'll see that same thing.
49:27 That's going to take about $25,000 to $27,000 out of other parts of our budget, but we've looked at it and think that it's a critical piece that we've been hearing about and I've been seeing as well for many years, so we're going to do that. We wish, frankly, we could do more, and as there's more things happening in that area, you know, the real answer is to redesign the whole thing and change the way the buses come in and out, but we think this is an important step and will be of great benefit during the winter. All right. Thank you.
49:55 Any other questions? Yeah. I got a question. Go ahead. I was just going to make a comment, Ray. I'm impressed on Meridian, how fast they're putting that in. I mean, it's impressive. And that, again, I can only credit the staff and the contractor. He's, that company, as you know, has done a lot of work in this community for a number of years, and he knew the time constraints, and the bottom line, of course, is the quicker he does it, he also makes a higher profit margin, but he really doesn't want to do it right by the community, and he's doing a great job. Impressive.
50:23 Thank you. I think it leaves in seven-day work weeks. Yeah, right. So, Madam Mayor, just a couple things. I think I wanted to also follow up with Shields' saying and to applaud you and the contractor for all the quick work you're doing up at the Meridian. But I want to connect that back with this discussion about the Mammoth Lakes Basin. And I think I've talked with Dan. There's a study called the Lakes Basin Special Study, which I think you may or may not be familiar with. A significant collaborative effort, about a $200,000 investment from the state.
50:52 That starts laying out a vision for where that lake space is going to end up. And I'm hoping that in subsequent council meetings and through MLR and other capacities, we're going to start really focusing on where we're going with all that. Because I think we need to be cautious in that once we turn these hounds loose, they can build things in a week. And I think we need to be very sure that the things, greyhounds, yeah. Once we start getting in the business of actually implementing and building things and constructing things,
51:21 I think on behalf of the community, we all need to be very sure what it is we're putting in the ground. So I look forward to those further discussions. And one last point is that the trash can effort that I know Dan has been working on that is, can we expect Grady to be reporting on these things going forward, these kind of things with the Forest Service? Is that, yeah, that's, we start to get these things working that, he's going from here, he's kind of handing over towards Grady. Correct. Okay, great. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay, any other departments or commissions?
51:52 Part two? Okay. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Councilmembers. My name is Officer Mike Brown from the Police Department. I'll be very brief. I lost my audience. I was going to talk about hockey, but the effects of fighting, and if you have to fight, make sure you pull the jersey over. Anyways, I'm sorry. I just want to talk really briefly. Chief Watson has given me the...
52:13 The ability or gave me the blessing to talk or tackle small community issues that may arise at the police department. As you know, we don't have the amount of officers we'd like to go out and do community-oriented things. And one of the things I just want to talk about really quickly is our recreation manager and public information officer, Stuart Brown, last month did a press release on the new law that went into effect, the California Vehicle Code, that prohibits motorists from driving within three feet of a bicyclist when they're passing.
52:43 If anybody knew that was coming out. But it's very important, especially in our town where our summer recreation is driven so much recently by bicycles in the mountain. And it's just, it's something that really is long overdue to be addressed. And I've taken it upon myself from the police department to more or less educate both motorists and some of the, not some, but hopefully all of the bicyclists in town. And we need to do a better job, frankly.
53:12 With educating the mountain and the shops that rent bikes. Some of you may have been driving wrong times, people riding on the wrong side of the road, on the sidewalk. I couldn't believe some of the things I've seen while I'm working for the police department. So we're really going to take more of an active role and try to educate the public. We're not going to be running around and writing tickets and do that. That's not the way. The way is actually, from our perspective, law enforcement, when we have time.
53:40 The shifts that I work, I've stopped countless people and just tried to explain to them that you need to obey the rules of the road. You need to ride with traffic. You need to stop and stop and stop and red lights. Use hand signals when appropriate. Unfortunately, we don't have a town ordinance that prohibits bicycles from being on the road.
53:58 Maybe that's something you can do down the road because it's getting to the point where... Sidewalk? Sidewalk, I'm sorry. That's why he's the chief. Anyway, it's a sidewalk and it's getting to the point where we have such an influx of downhillers that come out of the village and bomb down the road, Canyon Boulevard, Forest Trail, and I've seen some near horrific accidents with the vehicles and other bikes.
54:22 During this winter, they'll be in a platinum phase. They'll be working with the local Eastside Bellow. I will be assisting them, and we'll probably launch this in the spring when we get going again, and just try to really create an educational process for bikes in the road and the new three-feet law that went into effect yesterday. So it's very important, provided a bicyclist is on the right side of the road or riding with traffic.
54:51 One comment I just want to make. I want to really appreciate
55:21 Bringing the level of this kind of activity into the basic vernacular of our conversations when we talk about what's going on in this community. Bicycling is a very huge thing, a thing we want to be very much encouraging. I just wanted to point out that in the trail system master plan, those interfaces between the ski area and public streets, there are specific nodes and recommendations in there to deal with those points of interface. So as you're getting into your engagement of having to solve these problems, I'd refer you to that document. It may be some opportunities for some
55:51 Public Works funding and kind of bringing some of those kinds of things together to help kind of mitigate some of those problems. So I just point you in that direction for that. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. A couple quick reports on the Planning and Economic Development Commission. I had reported previously that we were going to have a September 24th meeting to discuss like an economic roundtable. That meeting has been postponed to November 12th, the regular meeting of the Planning and Economic Development Commission.
56:23 So the next meeting for the Planning and Economic Development Commission will be on October 8th, and they will be having a special meeting starting at 10 o'clock to discuss the floor area ratio project. So that's coming forward. We have the consultant coming out October 8th, 10 a.m. here in Suite Z. Their regular items will begin at 2 o'clock, so we'll take probably a break at 12.30 or so. Another item I wanted to report on is that our building plan check turnaround.
56:49 Pretty much gotten caught up on all of our building plan checks. It was an issue over the summer. We've gotten some consulting firms on board. And our goal is turning around the first plan review in 30 days. And we've been doing that in about two weeks. So we've been really getting the first plan reviews done quickly. The second plan checks are even quicker. And all of our inspections are being done pretty much the day of. If you call in that day, you can get an inspection. So we've really gotten caught up in the building department.
57:18 Any questions? Can you go back over that schedule real quickly, Sandra? Yes. The 12th at 2 p.m. would be the economic round table. Yeah, we haven't figured out the time yet. It kind of depends on what items are on the agenda for the Planning and Economic Development Commission that day. If it's a heavy agenda, we'll probably do it at 10. Okay. If it's a light agenda, we'll do it at the regular time of 2 o'clock. Okay. And then October 8th is 10 o'clock for area ratio. Okay.
57:43 Two o'clock for all the regular items. Can you notice us for that? Yes. Okay, thank you. And just one other thing, I've heard something about there's a joint council economic planning commission meeting workshop or something in November, is that, do you think about that? I think it's on November. It's the 19th, I think. 19th, yeah. And is that, is that sort of tiering from this, are they related? Or is that a whole different thing? It's, separately to have a larger discussion between the town council and the planning economic development commission on
58:12 Broader policy issues where we're going in a lot of areas. Okay, so not specifically related, but okay. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Any other commissions or departments? So next is introduction of a new employee. Thank you. I would like to welcome and introduce you to Diana Jacobson. Diana is our new permit technician. We're really, really happy to have her here.
58:50 She has 10 years of permanent experience, very, very experienced, and she's here from Wrightwood. So she understands snow, understands bears, she's got it down here in town. She's worked for a variety of different cities. She's worked for the city of Victorville, the city of Big Bear Lake, and most recently the city of El Monte. She really enjoys the Sierras, hiking, fishing, skiing, and she's really excited to be here, and we're excited to have her. Great. Welcome. Welcome. Welcome. Welcome.
59:23 Nice to meet you. How are you? Next up is a public presentation about the gym floor campaign. Who's running this off? Starting this off. Good evening. I am Lou Margulies, and I'm the newly elected Mammoth High School Booster President. Unlike most of you, I did not run a campaign of election.
1:00:06 Rather, I'd be similar to Michael Raimondo in that I was considered an unopposed candidate. Fortunately, my esteemmate, Stu Brown, came aboard as vice president, so pleased for that. Mammoth High School Boosters helps to promote academics, athletics, and the arts. We manage a budget of about $75,000, and we provide college book awards. We help fund all Mammoth High School sports and clubs.
1:00:36 We provide money for teacher requests, appreciation lunches, sponsor assemblies, and fund legacy projects such as the new scoreboard in the gym, recently remodeled snack bar, and that awesome electronic marquee on the corner in front of the high school.
1:00:54 But I'm happy and pleased to announce that in a cooperative partnership between Boosters, Mammoth Unified School District, local contractors, and the general public, we are spearheading a campaign to replace the lovely plastic Lego gym floor. And without further ado, I have a short video to illustrate this endeavor. You may need some technical support from your vice president.
1:01:42 Eastern Sierraes. My parents nurtured my love of sports, and I had the great fortune to be a basketball player and coach of both the high school and collegiate mode. I came home to coach my alma mater, Bishop High School, then worked my way up the hill to Husky Land to be a teacher and a first-hit basketball coach at the brand-new Mammoth High School in 1974. The new high school facility, including the gym, was not completed when the school year began.
1:02:25 Mammoth Mountain Ski Area founder Dave McCoy graciously offered temporary school housing for grades 7 through 12 at the warming hut, now known as Canyon Lodge. Talk about a wonderful school. The mountain staff, local contractors, school administrators, teachers, students, and local residents pitched in and we moved into the new facility shortly after Thanksgiving in 1974. I was then asked along with our athletic director and new school contractor,
1:02:55 To design the interior of the gym. However, due to budget constraints, we were unable to install a quality wooden gym floor at that time. The school buildings have aged gracefully, but the gym floor is in desperate need of replacement. In all of my years as a basketball player, a coach, and a college recruiter, and all the cities and schools of all sizes throughout the United States that I visited, I never came across a plastic floor.
1:03:25 In a cooperative partnership between Mammoth Unified School District, the Mammoth High School Booster Club, local contractors, and public volunteers, we have formed a fundraising dream team. Our goal is to raise $125,000 to install over 10,000 square feet of beautiful maple gym floor by summer 2015. By way of background, this multi-purpose gym and auditorium has hosted a multitude of activities.
1:03:54 The old gym floor has witnessed some banner years, taking CIF championships on a number of occasions. If that old floor could only talk, it has hosted volleyball and basketball games as well as cheer competitions. Due to our high altitude winter conditions, football, soccer, softball, and baseball use the gym floor for practice as though it were turf or grass. Gym floor tables are not limited to athletics, concerts, community events, assemblies.
1:04:24 And even the annual high school graduation ceremonies are held in this multi-purpose space. As a homegrown athlete, teacher, coach, business owner, and currently one of your Mono County supervisors, I am hopeful in support of this project. I am so excited about our new gym floor that the first 150 donations of $100 or more will receive a copy of my new book, My Sphere of Influence. Additionally,
1:04:54 I will personally donate $10 for each of these contributions. It's time for all of us to step up and upgrade our year. I ask you, the community and school supporters, on this 40th anniversary of the inaugural year of Mammoth High School, to once again come together to help us achieve our goal. My father used to tell me, son, when you live in the mountains, the impossible is standard operating procedure.
1:05:23 So let's roll up, actually, and get to work. Hope you enjoy that fun little
1:06:17 Video. I apologize that the sound wasn't quite synced up for some reason, but the actual version is not that way. My intent in coming here this evening is to basically create some awareness within the community. We've had a great deal of excitement already in our first week of really getting started here. We're open to ideas. We're open to any suggestions.
1:06:45 In fact, very quickly, Stu Brown is going to construct an opportunity to donate online. And you can do so by visiting our website, which is mhsboosters.org. And I'm wondering, does Council have any questions for me? Any questions for Lou? No questions. The only comment I would make, I've seen this video online and it's excellent. The production value is good and I know that
1:07:16 There's some professional expertise in this. Once upon a time, I was a post-production supervisor in the motion picture business, and it kills me to see when people come here and present these beautiful productions, and our facilities here don't do your system justice, so I'm sure we'll get together and talk and figure out a way to make sure the work that you guys do is well presented here, and you have to apologize for anything that's our bad, so thank you. Thank you. Questions or thoughts? Thank you.
1:07:49 That moves us to the consent agenda. Oh, I'm sorry. I would just like to kind of piggyback on what Lou had to say. And I'm here tonight to support the Boosters Club and the Margulies because this is obviously a great thing, supporting the youth of our community. I don't think anybody could do that. And I saw the phenomenal donation that the Margulies have made, and I thought that was pretty terrific. But what could I do personally to help?
1:08:17 As Lou said, we need to get knowledge of this campaign out there. And I thought, how can I help to do that? So I brought a little mock-up to show you. I had a kind of an idea, and Mark is going to help me with it, because it just came off the presses, and I haven't seen it yet. But I am going to propose to the town, with the town's permission, through an appropriate application to the town, which is completely legal, to use a very large version.
1:08:45 of this banner on the side of the Sierra Center that will let everybody in town know this is something that they need to get involved in. And I hope it will meet with the town's approval, and I promise I will do everything I'm supposed to do to get that approval. All right. Okay. Thank you, Paul. Thank you.
1:09:16 Okay. Can I just add, I'm the one that sleeps with that beautiful woman, and she recruited me to shoot that. You can go on YouTube and find that exact production by looking up Tim Alper's gym floor, and then you'll see it in sync. So hopefully everybody will tune in on that. Thanks. Great job. Thanks, Mark. All right.
1:09:44 Now we'll move on to the consent agenda. Are there any items to pull? Any requests for items to be pulled? Hearing none, I'll look for a motion. Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion. We approve items 3 through 8. Second. Motion and a second in place. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
1:10:17 That moves us on to a public hearing on customer rate increases related to refuse fees. So first I will open the public hearing and ask for a staff presentation. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Just before Peter dives into the presentation, I just wanted to remind counsel that this was continued from your last meeting regarding the proposed rate increases under a Prop 218 hearing, so this is a continuation of that hearing.
1:10:51 To have that here with the full council. So I will briefly review the staff report with council since two of you were present last week. So fees subject, so this item is our proposed rate increases in, consistent with our existing franchise agreement with our disposal hauler, Mammoth disposal. And
1:11:27 Staff would recommend, after reviewing the report, conducting the remainder of the public hearing, approving the attached resolution, approving the consumer rate increases related to the refuge fees pursuant to Prop 218. Just to review, on July 2018, 2014, the town sent out notices to all the property owners regarding this particular hearing that began at the last meeting.
1:11:58 The rate increases do reflect the current franchise agreement which expires December 31st, 2019 with the parent company, Mammoth Disposal Waste Connections Incorporated. The fees subject to Prop 218 must meet certain substantive requirements including revenues so the fees exceed the cost of providing the service. The amount of fee on any parcel be proportional to the cost of service attributed to the parcel.
1:12:29 As provided in the franchise agreement, staff has been having ongoing discussions with Mammoth's disposal regarding improvements to increases, diversions to solid waste. And I'll provide a few examples of that in a minute. With that, at the last meeting, there were, I believe, three protests that we've received. I think we've received one more protest. So there has not been
1:13:04 Majority protest of the fee increase proposed. Some of the improvements that Mammoth Disposal has implemented which has helped the town meet some of the state requirements as far as waste diversion is implementation of the cardboard recycling program. That's a secondary route that's provided to any customer with a second bend. The only issue really is it does take up additional parking spot or area.
1:13:34 That must be maintained by the property owner. And that's included in the current rate base. They also have the recycling station that's been there for many years, but they're the ones that maintain that recycling station at Vaughn's. They do provide additional services beyond their franchise agreement related to town special events that we may have and need additional services provided for that.
1:14:03 In general, they do provide all of the services for the town facilities at no cost, but that's as part of the franchise agreement. They also provide the town cleanup day in cooperation with the town and the county with that particular item because the county also waives the fees for that program. This year, we had significant amount of diversion that was included with that.
1:14:33 Probably the most we've ever had as far as diverting waste that would normally go to the landfill to other uses. The other one is pretty prominent, and Steve Sewell is appreciative of the bare mist cleanup that NAM Disposal has taken on to help with the cleanup related to people leaving their dumpsters open. And we had an update of the ordinance a couple of years ago.
1:15:03 Which required everybody to have the bare proof dumpsters and waste, Mammoth Supposal has been implementing that program. With that, if there's additional questions for staff. Peter, just for the council that weren't here on the last meeting, can you just update when the last increase was implemented? The last increase was, was a five year increase program, some of this public hearing, and I think it was 2009. Any other questions?
1:15:40 I have one, and I'd like whomever to explain. Being the longest tenured council member, and I still feel like I'm new, we've had this agreement in effect in one former number for how many years? Since about? Well, the current agreement was... No, but I meant originally. It's just... Originally... It's just been kind of cobbled together, and pieces have been added to it over time.
1:16:11 Since 92, I'm aware of, but Mammoth Disposal, Waste Connections bought Mammoth Disposal, so they rented it as a DBA for a while before it actually went into them, so it's been around for a number of years. I've drafted, if I might, I've drafted about, I don't know, two dozen solid waste franchise agreements over the years, and this one looks like a lot of older agreements that have been kind of incrementally
1:16:37 Modified in small ways over time without ever really going back and starting over and kind of implementing current best practices. So the current franchise agreement is not really a model of how these are supposed to look or how they're supposed to work. And the next time that we get around to negotiate an extension or a revision to this, we should start from scratch rather than just kind of tinkering around the margins. Can we do that before the five years is up? We certainly can. I mean, Mammoth Disposal is going to want an extension.
1:17:06 And I think we would need to be prepared to give them a little more time. They might want an additional five or seven or ten years tacked on to the five years they've got as the price of agreeing to kind of overhaul and modernize it. But, of course, that discussion about overhauling the franchise agreement is tied into the discussion about what to do with the trash in general, which is an ongoing and evolving issue.
1:17:28 And then, Andy, could you explain the catch-22 that we're in that if increases are not approved as we're kind of, shall I say, forced to do by the current franchise agreement? Yes. This is one of those odd situations where the council kind of has the illusion of choice. I mean, you can say no to this agreement, but the way it's written is that, sorry, you can say no to the rate increase, but if you do, Mammoth Disposal just takes that money.
1:17:55 Out of our franchise fees. So they're going to get their money one way or another. It's just a question of whether it comes out of our hide or comes from the ratepayers. Okay. So meaning that if increases are not approved, then we have less revenue coming in that's at another cost. That's right. And again, not really the example of how you put one of these things together. Right. Okay. If there are... Yeah, I do have a question. I just want to make sure.
1:18:24 There is a floor and a ceiling on the CPI increase, correct? Correct. The minimum is 1.75 and the maximum is 5%. And the actual number then between those two is based on 85% of CPI. Okay. So, I mean, the max it could go is 5%. Correct. So inflation goes... 85% of 5%. Well, it would be 85% of whatever to get you to 5% would be the cap. So 5% is the max. 5% is the max. 1.75% is the minimum.
1:18:53 And we've currently been operating around three? Yeah, a little less. Okay. A couple years back it was .2. Yeah. So it's been in the 2% range, so they've been at the minimum. And when is the next opportunity for a substantial renegotiation with this agreement? This deal has five years yet to go, and as Mayor Bacon was inquiring, we can start negotiations with man with disposal at any time. Actually,
1:19:22 About a year ago, we got as far as I see from the draft. They've looked at it, they've had it, but the problem with that draft was that a lot of the key deal points were missing because we don't yet know what we're going to do with the waste stream. We don't know if it's going to continue to go to the county facility, if it's going to go somewhere else, and that has a big impact on the price. Okay.
1:19:43 The length of the extension that the council would be willing to grant, perhaps, is going to affect the price as well. Because if you're a waste hauler, what you care about more than almost anything else is how much time you have guaranteed in your franchise agreement. To spread costs and that kind of stuff. Exactly. I mean, if you have not very much time, then it becomes harder to finance equipment and facilities and things like that. So there are a lot of moving pieces with solid waste in Mammoth, as there have been.
1:20:06 The entire time that I've been the town attorney, I think we're getting a little bit closer on some of them, but it's hard to really have meaningful negotiations until some of those moving pieces settle. Okay, and I just want to say I'm encouraged by conversations I've had with staff that the issues during the campaign about regional solutions seem to be embedded.
1:20:28 into the philosophy going forward. And so I'm eager to, well, I mean, there's issues we need to address in this thing. I'm eager to get to the future and be looking at those opportunities to renegotiate and do all that kind of stuff in the context of hopefully a regional solution to a lot of these issues. Mayor, if I may? So, Andy, to dovetail off of kind of John's question there, we can enter into negotiations in order we feel we're ready, but... Sure.
1:20:55 Really no chance for implementation prior to 2019. Well, no, I think that if we can strike a deal with Mammoth Disposal on the, probably they'll want a longer term deal. I mean, we can get it implemented and we can have new terms going just as soon as we can agree on them. Okay. So what would happen is we would, we would do maybe a new deal of some term, maybe 10 years that would replace the last five years of the current deal. And that would supersede. So if that got into effect in 2017, that would be the new norm. Okay.
1:21:22 Okay, if there are no more questions of staff, I'll call for testimony. Does anyone wish to speak on this? Okay, seeing none. Oh, we have somebody. Oh, oh, here we go. Oh, you have to move faster. My name's Rick Voll, Manager of Mammoth Disposal.
1:21:41 Last time when this came before the council, I went first and I wish I would have gone last because a few people did make, I think, real valuable comments on how we can continually improve, you know, how we operate as a company and as a town. Three things were brought up. One was offering smaller dumpsters as we get towards a point where we're recycling more. You know, we had a gentleman with a five-plex who felt a two-yard dumpster one time a week was too much.
1:22:08 And then with the cost, you know, how could we now get a smaller dumpster? I mean, that was an awesome creative idea. It wasn't really a cost issue. It was, I'm just not getting the value out of the service that I subscribe to and have to. So, great point. Look forward to following up with them and the town staff on how to improve that. Secondly, extra charges for getting out of our front-and-loader truck. It was a write-in comment that was made.
1:22:34 And the individual made numerous comments about all the extra charges that we would ping her with for the services we provide. And after reviewing her account, there were no charges over the last four years. So it was really interesting to me that those allegations were brought up. We do charge $7 and I believe $0.25 if you have your dumpster locked. And that was one of her main points because my driver gets out and unlocks it every time. Reasonable.
1:23:02 From my opinion, I think it is. You know, a lock dumpster, you guarantee that just your tenants use that, and my driver goes around with the same key at dumpsters. We buy a lock that's universally keyed, so it's a little more expensive. We weld it onto the chain link so it doesn't get lost, and they can just put that on instead of a carabiner. But my drivers do not charge any extra fees for getting out of each dumpster, and as you're aware, they're all locked with carabiners.
1:23:28 So we have to get out every single dumpster. We monitor the site. We look at how the use is. Is it unlocked or locked? So there are no additional fees for that. And thirdly, a nice woman stepped up and she gave some compliments about our transfer station and the cleanliness, the traffic flow, and really appreciate that. We're trying to continually improve. One thing she did request was that we increase the outreach.
1:23:52 To visitors coming in there and our customers and greet them and engage them. What's in your trash? Do you have any recycled material? Well, that goes over here. And that's definitely right in line with our mission. And after working with Peter, our diversion numbers are increasing at the transfer station just by a few small changes. And so her point was extremely valid and we're trying to do that. We have transfer attendance there seven days a week, 365 days a year from 6.30 a.m. to 9 p.m.
1:24:20 So we're there at all hours to try to reach everybody in town. We look forward to continuing the talks and the discussion with...
1:24:30 What's going to move forward with the MRF? What are we going to do with our waste stream? We hope to be partners in that and contribute. The current agreement with the cost of living and tied to the CPI, I think it's a very common practice in a lot of franchise agreements and I agree with Mr. Morris on maybe it is a little outdated and we have patched it over time so we look forward to probably revisiting everything and is it going to be a cost plus structure? Is it going to be like this but just different and maybe a little more concise?
1:24:59 So I'm available for any questions and the public if they want to come by and talk about how things are working at the transfer station and the recycling. One thing I do want to note that's real positive is that the commercial recycling program that Peter discussed
1:25:17 We offer a free cardboard recycle bin to any commercial business in town. We service those two days a week on Wednesdays and Sundays. We have 42 customers signed up for that program currently with 51 dumpsters, so some customers have more than one. And just last week we added high country lumber. So we continue to see growth in the recycling and we don't necessarily make specific money on that, but it's just kind of what the town wants and how we want to partner with everybody.
1:25:47 Thank you for your time. Just a quick question. I've lived here now for 14 years, and I realize that I have significant questions about how I as a citizen can use a transfer station or use the center at Vons or some of these programs that Peter's been talking about. And I think it would be useful and helpful to try to get some piece of material that's easily distributed that makes the public aware of what these opportunities are.
1:26:16 Because I don't know anything about it. And if I've got people coming into our dumpster that are dumping things that shouldn't be dumping it, I don't know if I can tell them to go to the transfer station. It's my own ignorance. It's my fault. But I think it would be helpful and useful to have something to get that kind of information out into the public so we can direct people to these opportunities. Just a thought. Yeah, and one opportunity I think the town did a good job. They created like a little tent card. One side talked about fireplaces, the other side recycling, tried to really hit the multifamily homes.
1:26:45 And get that there because if they didn't have Sierra Conservation Recycling there, they could always come to the transfer station and recycle at no charge during those hours of operation. Sure. Yeah, I was able to, Rick, thank you very much, take a tour of the facility down there. And quite honestly, I was impressed. They have it together. It's a damn clean facility. And so I was very impressed. And thank you for...
1:27:15 Taking me around. I think it would be good for all council members to go down there and check it out. Yeah, and I'll just add on to that, Rick, that the way you reworked it so that it's easier to drop off recycling, it's great. You're not having to dodge pylons and things like that. All right, then is there anyone else who would like to speak and provide testimony? Seema and I will close the public hearing.
1:27:44 And bring it back for council deliberation. Anyone have comments to make? I just have a couple quick comments. As you know, at the last council meeting, I voted no on this raise and received numerous concerns in the community, a lot from property management at condo complexes that the costs are just getting out of hand. It's disappointing that we have this type of agreement.
1:28:15 It's an automatic deal. If the taxpayers don't pay it, then it's going to come out of our budget. So I'm looking forward to renegotiation in the future. Some more comments? Anyone else? Yeah, I think it's an interesting situation. I feel as if, you know, sitting up here, we're kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place. I think, you know, I also...
1:28:41 You spoke about this last meeting. I toured the facility as well. I'm very impressed with the improvements they've made out there over the years that I've been going there, which has only been five years. I think some concerns about the cost are very valid. I think some things were brought up in the community that we definitely need to address as far as being a better community around our recycling and diverting some of our waste. So I look forward to all those conversations.
1:29:12 A renegotiation sooner rather than later. I understand we need some things that are in place, but it's 2014 now. I don't see that's encouraging to hear that we don't have to wait five years to make that change. I think we need that to happen, but for now, I don't see that we have much of an option but to approve. I'm supporting the comments I'm hearing here. I'm thinking also that it's going to be very helpful to Council going forward to see this agreement in the context of
1:29:43 Regional discussions about how we'll be addressing this regional problem and making sure that all the pieces come together so that whatever information you need from us going into a new franchise agreement that's coming out of policy regional agreements that are going to move this whole thing all ties together, yeah. Actually, along that line, I'll ask staff to do another update when it's appropriate but sooner rather than later because three of the council members here were not on the dais the last time an update was done.
1:30:13 And the community might be paying more attention now than they were then or whatever. But just to talk about the options and the progress. And it is complicated. It's beyond an octopus of trying to pull all the pieces together to make this work. But I would hope that we can have something worked out and agreements in place. I can't remember if it ended up on our final list of priorities, but I know I did bring it up during the discussion of solving our solid waste.
1:30:39 Issue to me is part of being ready for reinvestment. I think it's in there. It is. F, regional solid waste plan implemented. So that's by early 2016. So hopefully we'll have an agreement in place by then also.
1:31:01 Would anyone like to make a motion? Oh, let me make a really quick check. Does the resolution have to say as amended because of additional protests or anything, Peter? I think we made the amendments in your back. It's updated? Okay. Then I would look for a motion on approving the resolution. I will so move.
1:31:23 I'll second. Is that good enough, Andy? Yes, all right. I'll second. All right, thank you. With a motion and a second, roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Farney? Yes. Councilmember Farney? Yes. Councilmember Woodward? Yes. Mayor Mundo? No. Mayor Mundo? Yes, motion passes 4-1. That moves us on to our policy items, and the first being a discussion about CalPERS retirement contract.
1:31:53 And Town Councilmembers. I'm not used to this. Good evening, Councilmembers and Mayor Bacon. This is a proposal to amend our CalPERS contract to allow Councilmembers to become members of PERS. And this is actually just the resolution of intention, so it's not even the saying yes to this doesn't even say yes to the amendment to the CalPERS contract. This is just saying...
1:32:28 We have intention to amend the CalPERS contract. And then we have to wait 30 days, and then we can amend the contract. So are there any questions? I think it's pretty straightforward. Okay. Are there any comments from the public? I have a quick question of Dana, actually. Oh, I'm sorry. No, that's okay. Moving quick tonight. I don't want us to be here all night. Yes. As somebody that has not been on town government in multiple places as you have,
1:33:01 Is this something that you see as fairly typical in most communities that council members can opt into CalPERS? Yeah, my experience is that things I've worked in is the option is there for them. Some exercise it, some do not. As some agencies have little larger stipends than you have, that tends to be pushed a little stronger to be participants. So it would not be unique at all to have the council having the option. Thank you.
1:33:27 And Dan, this is just for public, this is after two consecutive terms, correct? Well, you'd have to have five years of service would be the requirement, so. You'd start paying in right away, but you wouldn't be eligible to get anything out on retirement unless you've been on for five years. I think just in my discussion with staff, it was clear that any potential burden to the public is pretty insignificant. This is a...
1:33:52 I'm going to disagree with that. Okay, good. Then I look forward to hearing from you. My understanding at this point is that we're not putting any unsound burden on the public, but I look forward to hearing what you have to say. Well, first we will call if there's anyone in the public that wants to speak on this. Well, then I'll start it out.
1:34:16 There is a small cost because you're then going to have a requirement to pay the employer portion and maybe the employee portions going forward. So there is some cost. My concern, though, and the reason why I will vote against this is because this is giving ourselves a benefit at the time when we have not been giving benefits to our employees and, in fact,
1:34:41 Have negotiated delays and deferrals of benefits, and I just don't think it's appropriate to pull ourselves out and deal with this to give...
1:34:50 Ourselves a benefit rather than included in any negotiations for the next MOUs with all the employees. And I will also make the disclaimer that I am the one member here who is approved retiree, so it doesn't affect me directly at all. It's just a question of I don't see it as fairness to the employees who have taken some huge hits the entire time that I've been on council. This would not affect council today, it would affect councils in the future, correct?
1:35:20 Correct. Which is why I would suggest saving it and doing it as all the MOUs are being looked at. And if there are changes made to their benefits, it might be appropriate that time to have similar benefits for the council. The impact, if I could clarify that, the impact, current council members could opt in to be a PERS member. You would have no benefit from PERS until you have five years of service, but you could begin as a participant. From this point.
1:35:49 Yeah, once it's approved. 30 days from when this is approved. Yeah. You can immediately start contributing. And the amount, most of the council, I think all currently, but if you came in, you'd be under PEPRA, the new regulations where you're mandated to pay your share, the employee's share now, new employees must pay that under state law. And currently, you all participate in PARS, which is the employee contributes to.
1:36:19 Six percent of their wages and the employer contributes two percent. So with PEPRA under CalPERS, it's six and a quarter for the employer and the employee. And so it would be a four and a quarter increase. Okay, so I would, you know, as part of a recent campaign, I think the understanding of the public is if you run to be a town council member, there was some debate even then about what the stipend was.
1:36:48 But also, while the big benefit is you're going to have a relationship with CalPERS. And so I look at this, rightly or wrongly, I think, as an administrative issue to address something that I think you found out about relatively recently that actually, well, this isn't in place. So I'm inclined to want to support it just from an administrative perspective to get the house clean so that we're good going forward and the expectations of whatever the public was thinking were consistent with that. Joe, if you think this is something that would be of value,
1:37:17 Even if symbolically as part of the employee negotiation process, I would be willing to consider deferring it until, if that could be a useful part of those negotiations, that might make sense if that's practicable. But otherwise I would be inclined to support it now, but if it makes, if it could be useful for those kinds of things later, then maybe we should consider that. I think another thing too that's useful is, just as in the last campaign, I mean we're trying to
1:37:44 Get the best people up here as possible going forward, and I think it's another, you know, it's like Dan said, if it was a lot higher, you know, if there's a paid mayorship or some other situation that we don't offer, it'd be a different conversation, but I'm supportive of it. I am supportive of it. You know, we need some more guys like Colin, and I'm not going to be around long enough to really enjoy it, so.
1:38:16 You know, I know it's a big incentive for Colin. Be a lifer. I mean, we're talking six and a quarter of your stipend, so, I mean, yeah. Right. I guess, thank you for that. I'm kind of torn on this one. I think, I don't intend to make a mountain out of what I view to be a molehill. I think when we're talking four and a quarter percent on council's monthly stipend,
1:38:48 It's not going to be a huge burden one way or the other. I hear the argument that it's one more incentive to entice people to enter into this role. I mean, I'm not sure that the stipend really does it. The health care benefit is significant. That's the other piece that people talk about. I'm not sure that I actually heard a lot about the retirement PERS benefit throughout the campaigning process.
1:39:16 I can see the value of enticing people to enter into this position, and if that can help to do it, there's a value to that. I'm also very sensitive to Joe's comments that we've been in an environment of take, take, take, receding the type of benefits that we're offering. I'm also cautiously supportive of this, but I think I'm
1:39:45 Very comfortable as well with deferring this to a later date. I'm pretty torn on this, to be honest, and I don't have really strong feelings one way or the other, so I'm kind of willing to fall in line on this one. So what is the practicality of delaying it, just for purpose of discussion?
1:40:04 There's no significant impact there. I mean, just in terms of if we brought it back or not, it's not something that we would bring into a negotiation meeting with employees, frankly, because it's not a benefit for them. They already get it. So we would not utilize it in that nature in terms of their MOUs or those types of elements. If you feel there's an impact one way or the other that way, I don't want to say it's easier to put it in place now versus during the middle of that, but that's Council's call, obviously. If you wish to delay it out, we can do that or?
1:40:33 Again, it's an option for Council to consider. If it were delayed, because the current MOUs are up in 2016, if it were delayed, any member still has the right to buy back from their first date of service, right? Yes. I believe that is correct, but we're not a member at that point. I think you can go back if we allow it at that point, as long as you're still an active member in the Council. If you have to leave the Council, then you would not be eligible. I would just...
1:41:04 If it's okay, Madam Mayor, I'll make a motion to approve. Approve the resolution of intention to amend the CalPERS retirement contract. Second. We have a motion to second. We'll call vote please, Jamie. I was looking for more discussion. Well, if you want to have more, you can. No, that's okay. We can just go in circles. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Motion passes 4-1.
1:41:34 That moves us on to policy matter number 11, which is to accept the Home Investment Partnership Program. It will be presented. Oh, there you are. Thank you, Mayor. I am pleased to announce that the town received a $700,000 home grant for first-time homebuyer assistance and rehab. And I would like to thank Mammoth Lakes Housing for helping us put together a complete and competitive application so we were awarded these funds.
1:42:06 And so the purpose of this item is to accept those funds, to amend the fiscal year 14-15 budget to reflect those funds, and to authorize the subrecipient agreement with Mammoth Lakes Housing who will be administering this program for the town. Additionally, the town is recommending that $5,000 of the administrative funds for this grant be allocated to town staff because of our
1:42:34 Oversight, Coordination, and Approval of the Loans from Mammoth Lakes Housing. The rest of the administrative funds, that would be $12,500, would continue to go to Mammoth Lakes Housing, along with the activity delivery costs that they get as a percentage of each grant that they process, or each first-time homebuyer application that they process and issue. And the town would continue its annual commitment of $3,000.
1:43:02 $129,000 and $329,190 to Mammoth Lakes Housing annually. And if the $5,000 administrative costs are not directed by the town council to be funded to town staff, the town staff's costs associated with administering this grant would come out of the general fund or the housing fund reserves. With that,
1:43:31 We'd be happy to take any questions you have. I know Jennifer Halfordy from Mammoth Lakes Housing is here as well. Are there any questions? I have a quick question. Just real quick, is this 100% a grant? Is there any loan tied to it, any payback, any liability for the town? No, there's not. Okay, thank you. Jennifer, did you have any comment you wanted to make? Good evening again, Jennifer Halfordy.
1:44:08 I guess I just have a couple of things in response to Jen, and then I would like to just talk generally about the program. It would be my recommendation not to use reserve funds to pay for administration costs, just because that's a little pool that can build up over time that hopefully would allow for housing to be produced outside of administration.
1:44:38 Attention that the general fund is also receiving a portion of the 1% that goes through the political commitment to housing. Not all of that 1% of 13% goes to housing. So it could be seen as housing funds, if you will, that are in the general fund. Okay, so that's it on that. I want to talk about the program because it's a lot more exciting.
1:45:08 Potential here for $1.3 million in purchasing power in real estate in the town through this program. That's about $64,000 in income for real estate agents through commissions. There's also escrow fees, title fees, appraisal fees. So we're talking about a big influx of money through this.
1:45:34 Because these are just matching funds for bank fees or bank loans. It's not 100% financing. Then I also want to just talk quickly about the benefit of affordable housing and how when we put these people in a home ownership situation, these are locals that now have a stable home. They don't have to anticipate their rents going up.
1:46:01 When you create a stable home environment, there are community benefits and social benefits, such as increased health, better education. Kids do better in school when they have a stable home. I think there's a greater chance for financial mobility for families that own their home. And lastly, I think...
1:46:24 But there's two more things I want to say, actually. It creates a stable workforce for employers as they go out to look for employees, and that's a real big thing, I think, for the town of Mammoth. And then lastly, it reduces potential for greenhouse gases by way of long commutes for people living down in Bishop or outside of the town when we create homes here in Mammoth. So I think that's way more exciting than talking about the reserves of the general fund.
1:46:53 Jennifer, a quick question. So of the 682, just to round it off, that would be available, can you estimate how much goes on each particular home? I mean, does that buy us, you know, 10? Does that help on 10 homes, or does it help on 5? Right. Well, I think it's been a while since we've done the application. This application was submitted over a year ago.
1:47:24 I think we said we would help roughly four households. It really depends on how big a home they buy, how big are their families, and how expensive are the homes. There's been some new rules put into place in this program that now require the primary loan, because this is a secondary loan that goes behind the bank loan, the primary loan.
1:47:50 It can, the secondary loan that the town does, that provides, cannot be greater than the primary loan. And that's how I got to the roughly doubling to the $1.3 million in purchasing power. Any other questions for Jennifer? Okay, you said it's a loan. I'm sorry, I don't understand it that well. Okay, so it's a grant through the federal government to the town.
1:48:22 Administered by the State of California. But they're administered as loans to households. So they're deferred payment loans to households that then come back to the town once they're paid off and they go into a revolving pool and then they get distributed again later on. Can I ask you, okay, when they come back, do they have a term to them?
1:48:48 There's 30 years or as long as the primary loan. There's a minimum of 30 years on the primary loan. They would come back if the property was to transfer. Right. If they were to take out a home equity line of credit or anything like that where they're taking cash out, the loan becomes due and payable at that point. Transfer that. Or if they paid off their primary loan early, it could become due earlier.
1:49:16 Is there any interest rate on those loans? Currently, we do not charge an interest rate. All right. So in 30 years, that $100,000 you gave somebody is going to have very little purchasing power then? That's right. Okay. That's what down payment assistance does. It helps currently. It doesn't create long-term affordability. Okay. So when we get it back...
1:49:45 Yeah, it is what it is. It is what it is. Okay. Have we thought about that? I mean. Which is to. You know, putting a nominal interest rate, maybe not payable, but upon sale. We can charge, the town can charge up to 3%. Up to 3%. Okay. Great. Appreciate it. Thank you. One quick question. What happens in an event of default?
1:50:09 In the event of default, well, you'd be like any other lender. You're left scrambling to get what you can. But again, I mean, just going back to my point, I mean, is town liable? No. No, what will happen, like on a short sale or something, if somebody had to sell the home, we're in a second position, so the extent that that sale covered the primary lender but not us, we would lose the payback of that loan to the town from these grant funds, but there's no obligation to the town to make up any differences of that.
1:50:40 But we just wanted to have the revolving dollars coming back into the town at that point. Unless the town purchased the first. That's true. Yeah, there's options you could go into that. Right, okay. Just a straight standard foreclosure or short sale, then we would be out. Right. The payback, but nothing obligated back to the grant. Nothing obligated, right. We don't have to pay anything back. Right, thank you. So it's structured different than some of the agreements that we had in the past that we're now in the hook for. That is correct. Okay.
1:51:12 And yes, so the idea is there's a pool of capital that goes forward, that goes in and out to provide this second home, this mortgage assistant in a secondary basis. Who manages that pool of money and where's the accounting for that and how's that publicly? That's a good question. Mammoth Lakes Housing tracks it because we do, we're required to do annual monitoring that the folks are actually living in the home and they're compliant because that's a requirement.
1:51:37 As long as well as insurance and those sorts of things. But we're working with the town to make sure that it's set up on the town's accounting side accordingly as well. Okay, so there will be, what, an annual statement of the fund balance and where it's at and that kind of stuff? That is correct. One of the elements for bringing the item forward to you this evening, and part of the structure it was, is in the past, I don't think you've done formal budget amendments.
1:52:05 To put that in there, but that's a process for us to put that in there, track it, creating a separate fund for each of these, for us to be able to track that in. We know what the balance in is, we know what the balance out is, we know what the annual elements are that falls into it from a town account. Okay, so the management of that is certainly something I would imagine we're liable for. Yeah, we have to manage it between what Mammoth Lakes Housing does in terms of the program management inside of that and the financial management and coordination of the town.
1:52:32 We do have that. Right now we have all those numbers from previous grants and loans. It's a broader pool, so sometimes to manage which pot is which right now gets a little complicated, but we're looking at streamlining that and making it simpler. Okay, as part of the financial efforts going forward? Absolutely. Okay, so we are liable for that pool. The town is responsible to report on a, let's see, on this grant they have to report quarterly.
1:53:00 If they're having activity to the state in that revolving fund. So will all 682.500 be allocated? Only 17,500 will be administrative total? 17,500 is a direct admin, and then there's a piece of each loan that can be used for directly called activity delivery. I forget the percentages on that. Six and a half percent. Six and a half percent? Can be utilized for the actual loan activity.
1:53:27 The direct cost, if you will, of the loan processing and work that Mammoth Lakes Housing does. Is there any deferment period on these loans? I know you said you're in second position. Yes, they're deferred for 30 years or as long as the primary loans. So primary loans can be 40 years. We've never seen that, but it could be deferred for 40 years. But right now they're 30. And if the family or person sells their house, it's at market rate, right?
1:53:58 Is there any? Yes. All right. Thank you. Okay. Any more questions of Jennifer? Yeah, just one question. Am I reading this correctly, that town currently spends about $25,000 annually in admin associated with this housing program in general, not necessarily with this program here? Right. Just $25,000 in general. Okay. For overall housing work out of community and economic development. Yeah, that's the planning side. Okay.
1:54:30 Okay, thank you, Jennifer. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on this? Okay. And I'll bring it back to us for a discussion and or a motion. I would make a motion. I would make a motion. I'll second his motion. I like this guy. Is he motioned? There's more than one option. Yeah. All right, all right, all right, all right. Look on page four of the... This is how much, you know, trust I have in you.
1:55:05 I am going to read, put my bifocals on, option one, which I believe is the recommended option, approve the attached resolution accepting $700,000 of home investment partnership program funds for the first-time home buyer program, including home buyer acquisition and rehabilitation, 13-home-9016, allocate $5,000 of administrative funds to the town staff, amend the fiscal year 2014-2015 budget to reflect these funds, and approve the sub-
1:55:35 Recipient Agreement with MLH. I'll second that motion. We have a motion. Yes, you will. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Yes, motion passes 4-1. That moves us to number 12, this is Reconciliation Report for Measure R funds.
1:56:14 Major Law will have some additional work coming forward as part of that is the revenue side. We're just getting the last payment in September from sales tax. We're trying to support behind. So the revenue number is getting finalized. The other side of this, there's a lot more activity in Major R, especially in the area of capital improvement projects that tend to extend a little bit more. The report walks through.
1:56:38 The CIP measures that are still to be completed and or reconciled as we are working through those. The list of important brought through each of those. The one that I would note would be our track project, which is one of the most substantial projects out of our NU that we'll end up hopefully having finalized out here in the next 60 to 90 days as the latest to be able to bring back a final reconciliation regarding that project.
1:57:05 A number of the other projects are in there, trails related and other elements. The other component of Major R that is significant is what has been a political commitment to do $300,000 a year for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. So we're working through that. The very first year, we lost $300,000. We've had a lot of projects on both sides and closed.
1:57:30 We've actually closed about two, just over 10 and a half million, almost 2.6 million projects. Through those projects that were closed, it was $38,000, $63,000, $63,000. It will actually go back into fund balance for future allocation. The closed Mammoth Lake Trail System projects was $143,013 going back into fund balance. That will go back to still being restricted for the Mammoth Lake Trail System purposes.
1:57:59 So we want to make sure we don't lose track of the commitments that have been made there for the purpose of dollars we're allocated for. And then we have a number of open projects we're going to do. The spring and fall awards and then into 14-15, the staff report touches on those. The majority of that is sitting in the Amalfate Trail System with a number of carryover projects and ongoing, again, that we're tracking. The total cost is just over $900,000.
1:58:29 Work to date, really it's focused on trying to close out those projects that are completed. The process historically hasn't really come back and said a project started in 2011, boom, the suspend, now that project is closed and either it's an over, under, and the dollars account for accordingly. A lot of projects have carried from year to year to year on purpose or by accident.
1:58:55 And some of the expenditures obviously extend over those years as well on project areas. We will be coming back and looking at additional reconciliation work and also really been working through a set of policy discussions that the council will have as it deals with some of the new funding issues as we move forward with what the town is doing with the implementation of Mammoth Lakes Recreation and some of the controls that we want to have in place for the accounting process.
1:59:25 For future discussion and policy direction. At this point, we are asking that you approve the reconciliation work to date. We approve the closing out of the projects with just over $38,000 going back to the Measure R fund balance and $143,133 going back to fund balance restricted for the Maniflex trail system and then authorize the continuation of the work.
1:59:53 Also want to compliment both Mayor Bacon and I think Terry Stelling for the work that they put into this in various spreadsheets and late-night phone calls and e-mails that have gone into getting this project at one where it's at today. So with that, we happy to address any questions from a staff perspective. I'd also prefer both to Terry and the Mayor who have been intimately involved in some of these areas more so than they probably ever anticipated.
2:00:23 Any questions? Dan? I would echo the hard work that just Terry has done, and I just want to ask if she had any comment to make at this point, or... No. No, I'm glad. I would just like to thank Dan and the staff, because I know there's been a lot of time that's put into all this, as well as Joe, so anyways, and unfortunately it's not...
2:00:49 I'd also like to add that one of the things that we have discussed that will come back in the policy is the fact of doing this reconciliation annually, not waiting until six years have gone by and then trying to backtrack and work it out. So there will be several policy discussions that will come back to Council as we work.
2:01:16 Through the rest of the reconciliation, and then it will be an annual report to Council and the community on how the money's been spent. Excellent. If there's no other public comment, is there anyone, if you're on the diocese, who wants to make a comment? Madam Mayor, I'm like. Do you have a comment? I do. Just real quick. I'd like to stop my tracks. We all have to work on peripheral views. Yeah, we got it. Yeah, I got it. I want to thank
2:01:48 The mayor, Terry and staff for getting into all this stuff. I think as we go through all these things that it's of critical importance, as we all know, to maintain the public's confidence in these funds. They could, you know, say, look, you guys aren't managing this stuff properly, we're going to take it away. I wouldn't know why they want to take it away from themselves, but that's a possibility. So the work that we do to maintain the public's confidence stuff is critically important.
2:02:12 I think also there's a cautionary tale in that over the years where Measure R, where applications were being awarded and things were happening, there was from the original intent of Measure R and committees and folks to do an annual true-up of these funds. And for a variety of reasons, that never really happened. And to Joe, Mayor Bacon's comment about looking back six years and trying to get things all figured out, we need to put in place a standard that says we're all happy with it, staff's happy with it, the public's happy with it, and I think we're getting there.
2:02:42 And I think that that's all very good and very important. And I think also one thing that would be very helpful, I think, is as projects come off the list, they are completed, staff has said, these are good, we're done with these things, that some kind of a letter of a notification that goes out to the applicant that says, it's done, thank you very much, you know, we're all good. And I think that would be useful for the public's confidence as well to have a list that say all the projects are done and we're all good with this stuff, but we're moving on.
2:03:07 I know that as an applicant we would fill out a final performance report and we would turn it to the town and assume, well, we've turned in our performance report and we're done, but there's another step, which is the town looking at it, making sure that everything is good. When that letter would come out that say, well finished with these things, I think that would be a good sort of a confidence booster with all this stuff. Other than that, I appreciate the work being done, but there's more work to continuing on, and so I'm happy with where we're at. Make a motion that council approve the recommended motion as stated.
2:03:39 You got to read all that. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to agenda item number 13 about cautionary agreements with the Forest Service.
2:04:06 I would like to make one statement as we go in here. One of the items we'll be discussing is a contract with Friends of the INYO. I am a board member, but as we learned in our recent Ethics Training and Fair Political Practices Commission, I do not have to recuse myself from the discussion. So, that in mind, we'll start with a staff report. Thank you. Before this evening are five separate agreements or items, if you will, with U.S. Forest Service. Most of them are cost share agreements.
2:04:40 We've been meeting regularly, as we've said several times, with U.S. Forest Service. They are very encouraged and excited that these are moving forward, both John Regalberger and Kaminsky, excuse me, were actually going to be here tonight, but they're up in June dealing with their issues related to that fire as well. They apologize for that. They did pass on that through Peter that they do appreciate your taking a look at this and considering these agreements.
2:05:08 One thing I would like to mention is there are five of them. They are very different subjects. So what staff would ask is that you would consider them one at a time if that's okay. Peter will go through the technical details of each one. If you could consider them one at a time, we think that would be more appropriate. Some of them are approval to move forward with agreements. Others are to authorize the town manager to sign an agreement. I want to mention that if any of the things that we talk about tonight, even if you authorize it, changes in any substantial way, we'll bring them back to you.
2:05:37 In short order, before they are executed, we won't go off, negotiate with them and then not report back. We'll come back to get authorization at that point in time if anything changes of any substantial nature. One of them is an example where we are working closer together is updating our trails maps. We talked about that earlier today as well. One point of that I want to say is if this moves forward,
2:06:02 We're not necessarily tied into how that gets done. This is really an opportunity to work with the Forest Service, update the maps. It may be where they have considerable input. We do the work. Staff might do the work with the aid of a consultant. Staff might manage the work with the aid of other outside parties, MLTPA, MLR. Somebody else might do a portion of it. We're not set with that, and that's not part of the related discussion tonight. We'll come back to you and report how we're getting these things done at a later date. But it's September.
2:06:30 Not that we need a lot of stuff to do over the winter, but we'll be busy anyway, but this is something that's a great opportunity for us to do that, so we're prepared for next summer season when it gets here. And again, we just really ask that you consider these one at a time. With that, I turn to Peter to start into them unless you have any general questions. Actually, I just want to see if there's agreement to deal with them. Just take again. Yes.
2:06:54 Go through them one at a time. And will you vote on them one at a time? Well, try to form a consensus and then the motion. Yeah, actually we'd like to, if you just do a vote on each one, it'll be very clear. And then if there's, you know, distinctions among the council, that's great. It'll also be cleaner for us as we work back through the Forest Service as well, that we've got authority from the council to work through, update, bring back each of these various agreements. And we know that some of the agreements will need to be, I think all of them will need to have some.
2:07:23 From a typographical standpoint, some of us aren't that talented. We should be on a type capability. And a couple others may come back with more modifications in terms of dates and scope and things like that. What we did not want to do is spend hours and hours of staff time getting these completely done prior to having the council say, yes, we want to move forward with these projects. The other thing I would highlight is that each of these were approved as part of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Steering Committee.
2:07:52 Work that they were doing. They were all built into those programs. And so this is that next step forward to move forward. The projects each kind of tier off of an MOU between the Forest Service and the town. A couple different ones actually as it works either a cost share agreement or a permit update process. So a couple highlights there working through that. But having a specific action by the council on each agreement is a very positive step. And you can also have public comment then.
2:08:18 If you wish on each one versus trying to package everything. And Dan, I will make one slight modification to your comment about, yes, these have all gone to MLTSCC, but they really have not been discussed in an open public forum and so that's why they're in front of us at this point. I appreciate the fact that these are being brought forward in order to have the council and the community understand what's going on and working towards as much transparency as we can possibly have.
2:08:47 So with that in mind... Mayor Bacon, may I make a comment before we get started? So also in the interest of full disclosure, I've spoken to Town Manager and Town Attorney about this. I'm in some very, very, very preliminary talks about a potential business that may involve over-smow vehicles. So wanted to just make sure that that wasn't an issue, you know.
2:09:16 In speaking to Andy, we believe that, you know, it's not even close to far enough along to make that a conflict of interest, but in the interest of full disclosure, I wanted to make that aware. Thanks. Thank you. I better say the same thing. Yeah. Healing and dealing. Literally we do. Okay, Peter, can you give us a quick overview of number one, the winter recreation map and summer recreation map?
2:09:49 So this one, currently, the Forest Service does have two grants. One grant, the total of which are the $3,200. One is for preparing a summer map, and that particular map is very outdated, particularly with their roadless and road decisions that they've made recently. The other one's the winter map. There's only about 100 of these left.
2:10:17 There was an update a few years ago, but there does need some additional updates, and the idea would be to have this completed so that the maps would be for the winter use available in this season. The scope of the work, there would be a designer involved in this project, a discussion with the Forest Service that all of the consultants within these agreements would really work for the town and be managed by the town.
2:10:46 Forest Service would be providing the input approvals necessary to implement anything on the forest and provide that staffing that's necessary to get this work done. So this one's really two parts. There's two maps. And there's some GIS work that they've got that can be integrated into our maps so that they would be also integrated into the overall website. With that, is there any questions?
2:11:15 So it's essentially an update of the most recent map for whatever has changed. It's the graphic work to get those maps done and the printing to have them out by the time snow is falling? For the winter map. And then the summer map is going to take a little bit more time because it's got significant changes from the previous. And how is the public involved in discussion of what these new maps are going to look like?
2:11:42 As the maps were done before, we used to take them to Recreation Commission during the process for a review slash comments. And in this case, it would come back to MLR if they're formed and functioning. We bring them to them for discussion as well. Okay. Anyone else have questions?
2:12:02 I do. Comments, John? Yeah. First is a question for you, Madam Mayor. How do you anticipate integrating public comment into these five, six items? I presume that we ask our questions, we ask for public comment, then we come back to deliberation just as we do on the other ones, but we take it number by number. Okay. So if there are folks here in the audience, they will have a chance to comment on the items as they come forward. Okay. I have a couple comments on this. Okay. And I want to start with
2:12:30 Kind of some over high level review comments of all these efforts. Obviously I think the council thinks that we feel this is all important going forward. We've invested a lot in this system and these are important things to do going forward. I think also that we need to understand that we are entering into a new era and we have the opportunity to establish expectations of the public, of the various partner organizations in making this work happen.
2:12:57 And I think working with MLR that we're heading down a new road of delivering these types of projects and endeavors. And I think that it's important that we start setting some expectations of how these kinds of things are going to work. And I've had some personal experience working these kinds of projects. I've got a sense of maybe, which I'd like to share with the council, maybe sort of a recommended way to proceed in this is going to be that we can be setting everybody up for success. We're not going to be repeating any mistakes of the past. We're going to be getting into a kind of a...
2:13:27 A work method with this that's going to be accountable, that's going to reinforce the public's confidence in these public funds. And so I'll just go right to the first project. And I would recommend, and I hope to have the Forest Service, you know, here. We're not, we could speak with them and speak to these issues. But I think that what really is needed with these things is that the Forest Service, which is a beleaguered federal agency, I don't think it's...
2:13:57 Inappropriate to say that. They repeatedly revise that they have financial pressures, they have staffing pressures. They don't have the ability to do a lot of these things. And I want to make sure that we're not putting the Forest Service in a position where they don't have any graphics people on staff. I don't think they have any expertise in that area. But they do have the authority as the Forest Service to approve products that get made. So I would recommend that we give some direction to staff that significantly reduces the amount of money.
2:14:26 That's being required for this. So that we would say to the Forest Service, we need a sufficient amount of funds or time from you guys to review mapping products that the town will produce. And I want to make it very clear that when I say town, I'm including MLR in town. We're talking now about contracts between the town and the Forest Service. MLR is an extension of the town's capacity to do things and to do projects and take on these kinds of things.
2:14:52 I'm not sure that we have internal graphics capacity to do these kinds of things, but that's a future conversation. But I would recommend that staff come back to Council with a recommendation for a dollar amount that is consistent with the amount of time and effort needed for the Forest Service to be involved in initial project development, perhaps, and then the approval of the final product, the product that's produced by the town and probably through MLR. Let me address that. We've actually had some conversations with the Forest Service related to that.
2:15:21 The dollar amounts we're putting in are what we're going to need to get the project done. Okay. Not necessarily dollars that go directly to the Forest Service. For that $7,500, for example, that could cover part of town costs. That could cover an outside designer cost. If we went to XYZ to work on that, that we can actually hire consultants faster and simpler than what the Forest Service can. So that may be a town element. If we're going to do a public process with MLR or in the rec commission if they're involved.
2:15:49 Then if there's costs associated with that that we have to incur, then these dollars can be used for that. So as you mentioned earlier, the $3,200 from the Forest Service for their contribution going this, which they probably didn't actually pay for the printing and that oversight, there may be a portion of the $7,500 that would help some of that management side of theirs. But the way this would end up being, the $7,500 wouldn't necessarily just be, here's a check to the Forest Service. It is a cost of the project, and we're doing it jointly.
2:16:19 And the way that it worked,
2:16:49 Was to draw upon the expertise of the town and the Forest Service for their fiduciary legal expertise of naming conventions, what things should be called, where lines should be drawn, and that kind of stuff. But that the actual production work, producing drafts of these maps, came from a third party outside of the two agencies. And we would anticipate that same process. Okay, so I think it's important that that's understood. And again, the language in here is very vague.
2:17:16 Which is, okay, but I think it's important that staff understand that it's not the expectation of council that either the town staff or the forest service staff is actually doing the work to produce this stuff. And I think that down the road we're looking for something like MLR to be the body that's taking on these things. Well, this may actually be a more professional designer outside of any of our bodies. There is a review process through those other, to the public agency side of the house, including MLR.
2:17:44 But it may be a contract with John's designer that whoever that agency is that actually has that technical skill to do the actual mapping work and that might be under the direction of Town slash MLR to have that done. Exactly. So that's the concept that we're going forward with the Forest Service and we've had that. Okay. So I would recommend if that's clear to everybody that the staff come back with something with a recommendation that is consistent with
2:18:14 The kind of policy direction that we're talking about. So that the burden upon our staff, which is under pressure financially, and the Forest Service staff under pressure financially, is for their legal and technical review of draft maps that are being produced.
2:18:29 By an outside, someone who has a specific expertise to do those kinds of things. They'll have a little more oversight over the summer because of the green sticker program they administer. When you say they, more service because of the road closures and stuff, they'll have more input. Okay. Because this also goes to the, it has to be a very specific integration with the existing branding of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website, and all these other kinds of things. So it's very important that this stuff be integrated into existing programs.
2:18:59 Wintermap, was that produced by a third party? Yes, that was produced, actually MLTPA, produced under contract to the town of the Forest Service. We were the responsible party. We had GIS technicians, we had graphic technicians that could produce these drafts, and so the Forest Service or town staff isn't running around trying to do this stuff. It gets produced by a third party. You put it, you give it to them for their review to make sure it's legally correct. So I see two parts to this. We're doing the same thing.
2:19:26 I see two parts to this. I see a winter part and I see a summer part. Winter part, you're just trying to get more maps done. There's an update, but there's a minor changes to the existing map. In the summer, there's major changes to be made. Correct. And that's where we need a third party to come in and... You need a third party for both because... To do the... If you open it up, even to make a little change, it's a third party that's doing it. But I think your point is very valid in that the maps...
2:19:55 Need to be consistent. It needs to be a winner and a summer map of the same system. And these existing summer maps do not have that same graphic consistency. But again, these are the kinds of standards. And I would mention also that these standards are in the adopted standards manual that the town's adopted as part of the public works manual. The guidelines, the colors, a lot of these things are already in place. And so you can give something to a third-party person doing this and say, these are the guidelines, this is what's adopted by the town, and we expect you guys to follow this. Lizard.
2:20:23 Is there a time constraint on getting these done for the winter? Yes, certainly. One comment I'd like to make regarding the Forest Service, you know, I appreciate the fact that you're right there. Belieger might be the right word, but we've told them many times in different forums that we are here to help, and we have ways to get things done that they don't. And along those lines, we've spoken with John Rogelberger, especially if we're doing this, we need you to not dedicate a lot of staff time, but when it's time, show up at the meeting, be prepared.
2:20:52 Work with us on it, get that, and you make your reviews timely, especially as an example for the winter map. And they've committed that, no, they've assigned staff, they're going to figure out who's going to do that for them, they'll be able to help us move this forward. Not a lot of time, but focus time to get it done. It's not just going to be...
2:21:09 And again, it's their legal review process. That's what is needed from them. Absolutely. And that's so we need to structure these things going forward that that's the expectation going forward. They're not going to be doing this stuff, but they're going to be reviewing it and approving it and make sure it meets their legal standards for what we're doing. And in this case, the funds, the $3,200 is the actual green sticker between the two grants.
2:21:37 They'll have additional staff time that's not included in the numbers here. And much of the money will actually be buying the maps from the vendor that's going to produce the maps. So there's two parts. There's two. Yes. There'll be two vendors. One is the designer that's going to help prepare and develop the maps themselves like MLPTA did last time. And the second part is hiring a print shop that will actually produce the maps. Does that go out to bid to numerous?
2:22:07 Folks, or how is it structured? For consultants, the town, this would be a relatively small contract. If we've got parties that we've used before in that previous experience, we can hire them that way. For the print shop itself, we'd get three quotes, at least three quotes from print shops to prepare those drawings. And does that include some of these online services? The online services? We can get quotes for those, whether or not...
2:22:36 You know, that would be the most expeditious way would be part of the quoting process. I don't know. I've gotten some within four days. Yes. So, I mean, that is an area we, in the town's purchasing process, we do the quotes and that definitely could be one of the alternatives. From the work standpoint, you know, it's probably a day of work or so is what John was thinking for the designer on the winter mat. It's not a lot of changes. For the summer mat, pretty significant is it might take them a week. Well, again, I...
2:23:05 I'm looking at this from some personal experience that if the Forest Service can reliably advise you that if you present us a draft, we will give you comments, there's back and forth. It takes time and it takes effort for this third party to coordinate these things and come up with a coherent product. So I would think that if staff is clear on what the direction is,
2:23:31 That we can, I would make a motion to bring this back to Council based on the discussion you've heard here, and then we can look at that before we approve it to move forward. Yeah, if we could ask the direction in terms of getting the cost share agreement put together with that direction.
2:23:53 We would bring that back for approval versus going back and having just a general discussion about what we may do, if I'm not saying it correctly. And that's what I'm thinking. I'm thinking the cost share dollars would be significantly less because the time that we're asking from the forester. Yeah, that's not the issue. The cost share dollars, a lot of these, that's our time, that's going to be the third party time. The $7,500, for example, is not dollars we just hand to the forest service. That's for the total project. That's the outside vendor. That's staff time.
2:24:22 That's the Forest Service time. This is the total project cost, not Forest Service cost. Does that make sense? It does, but it's still, I would like to see reflected in what you bring back, the understanding about how these things should be structured and how they should work. Whatever you guys think is appropriate to do it, just bring it back that way. 7A does not have much detail to it. Because it's very, it's disappointingly vague, and we're trying to, we don't want to be going through any more efforts.
2:24:49 Where, you know, I'm kind of from Vermont. They talk about good fences making good neighbors. And I think that good contracts and good agreements make it possible for things to succeed. The way this is presented, it's, well, yes, I think the element here would be, is, again, we did not spend a lot of time redrafting agreements until we got to this point with the council. If you want us to go forward with this project, then we would come back, in this case, with a
2:25:17 Challenge cost share agreement. They would incorporate these things. If you don't want to go forward with the project, that's fine. We don't have to. So we're really getting direction, go do this. In this case, I think this cost share agreement would come back with the elements in it that you're talking about, and then we would go forward accordingly. So I guess it's two pieces. It's going to come back. It's going to come back regardless. Correct.
2:25:38 But if the motion is don't go forward with this, we're not going to go spend a bunch of time with it. No, I think I would be proposing to go forward with it, but please bring back something for the council's review that's getting to this level of specificity about how these things are going to work. We can do that. Okay. Okay. I just want to make sure that we're going down the right page here. Yeah. Yeah. Recognizing that those winter maps will be needed soon, and I think some of you know that I have.
2:26:04 Spent winter weekends in the Welcome Center handing out these maps and they can go out in 20 in an hour if there's snow for people to ride on. Now are we making motions as we go? Right. I'll make a motion. Public comment prior to the action. That'd be great. I thought we'd ask that. We really did, yeah.
2:26:26 We will be making motions as we go. Mayor Bacon, Councilmembers, my name is Dana Stroud, and I'm the chairperson for Mammoth Lakes Recreation. We did not see and have not had an opportunity to review this document, so my comments can't come from the board.
2:26:43 But I think they do represent the sentiment of our organization. And also from personal experience, having been overseeing the 2006 production and the 2008 production of both of these maps, I can speak with some experience. I have a couple of questions with regards to the figure that's being used. It's the $7,500. And Councilmember Wentworth just talked about some specificity.
2:27:11 I don't know the number of maps that are being produced. I don't know the size of the document. And so I'm just wondering if when you come back with the revised challenge cost share, are you able to include that type of information to let us know what's being printed, how it's being printed, how many are being printed, the potential shelf life of these as well.
2:27:39 Remind us that when we developed these first winter maps back that many years ago, we actually had the Forest Service at the table with us. Rick Laborde, who was the groomer at the time, came and literally, you know, drew it with us and made his points. So that's a long time ago and things have certainly changed, but I think there's an expectation on behalf of the public that through this challenge cost share agreement, the Forest Service will be engaged in the process.
2:28:08 So I don't know if you can provide us with
2:28:29 Thank you. The final number of printing will depend on the quote we get, but we can probably have a range of... Yeah, and I just look at this, I think the numbers is kind of low for the project you're trying to do, so I think Dana's point is well taken to, you know, for this dollar amount, you're going to get this amount of project time, this amount of final deliverables in the end, and that would be great to have that information.
2:29:01 And the 7,500 actually just came from the budget that was adopted by the MLTSCC group. Correct, but I don't think they had not done any kind of analysis. It was just that. It was kind of a placeholder number. I think last time the expense was like $15,000. Yeah, it was a dart. It was a dart. So. We'll hold on a second. Is there anyone else that would like to speak to the winter and summer recreation map cost share agreement? Okay, then.
2:29:29 I don't know. I had the two people who looked like they were wanting to make motions. No, I guess discussion first. Discussion, if that's what we want. Yeah. My only point is that I think that we're heading down a new road. And I think that we have to, all these things are, all these projects as minor as they may seem, and we're kind of talking about things that may not seem ultimately that significant. But we're talking about building trust.
2:29:56 I guess my question would be if the funds aren't adequate, what happens?
2:30:28 We come back to Council for request additional funds or we produce a lot less maps. Yeah. There is money after the reconciliation that sits in the MLTS fund balance part of Measure R so that if there were to be some significant issues like you can get it designed for $7,000, up to that point you only have $500 to print, there would be ways to ask for more money.
2:31:02 But I would anticipate that, given this discussion tonight, you're going to bring back something that's reliable. Even if it's only 10 maps, you'll say, this is what you're going to get for 10 maps. 10 good-looking maps. 10 good-looking maps, and they're going to get done, and this is what they're going to cost. But again, it's about establishing a culture of confidence in how we're doing these things, and I think that's almost more significant than the maps. Got it. You've got to come up front, Terry. Sorry. Terry Stelick. I just...
2:31:37 I'm concerned about what I just heard, that if the $7,500 is not enough, that there's money in the reserve, that that can come back forward. Because the conversation still hasn't taken place as to what are our priorities, what do monies need to be spent on, and so to me, if we move down that path, we're doing the same thing that we've done all along and kind of just cherry-picked instead of actually put a solid path together. So I just want to...
2:32:06 I want to be careful as to, you know, that if we're taking these projects today that haven't been vetted, they were vetted by MLTSCC, I don't know what that conversation was, hasn't gone any further. Right now it's kind of in a limbo state as to who's reviewing what's going on and what that discussion is. And so I have a concern that we would say, oh, but there's money over here. I want to get that back. And I understand too, and I didn't mean it that way, it's just that, you know.
2:32:35 The other thing we have to ask is, well, how many are printing and how many are you just putting it on MLTS's website and people are looking at it electronically? Because, you know, not everybody needs it on paper anymore. So I think that's some of the stuff we need to have come back to us. And presuming at the next meeting, if the contract with MLR is approved, then they would be recommending to Council on those strategies and then on how funding has been. Yeah, but this is a relationship that we have with the Forest Service right now, right?
2:33:05 That's what's kind of driving this? Well, I think it's important. Terry makes a very good point, which I would like to have said, which is this is kind of an interim, we're in sort of an interim situation. I would anticipate that MLR, that these kinds of things are MLR projects. This is living within the world of MLR.
2:33:24 They're doing it. They're contracting. They're getting these things done. However, the role that the council and the town has to play is in that relationship with the Forest Service and establishing the expectation of who's going to be doing what. Once we build the sandbox, then we have now a capacity through MLR to be able to do a lot of this stuff, but we're in this interim period right now. And so that's why I think why we've got these very granular six projects in front of council and we're talking about these very granular things.
2:33:50 Going forward, I'm assuming this is going to get over to MLR and they're going to be dealing with all this stuff. Ultimately, it will come back to you with the agreements and these types of elements again. Yeah, okay. So I would make a motion if we're ready. Okay. So on this first one, I would make a motion that staff return to council with a proposal to update this challenge cost share language per...
2:34:16 The discussion in the language that you've heard, which I couldn't recite back to you, but it sounds like... Yeah, because you have to. I have to? Okay, go to Granicus and watch the conversation and take notes, I guess is... I'll second the motion. Okay, we have a motion to second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
2:34:45 That takes us to number two, the over-snow vehicle NEPA review and decision making. So this is the NEPA review that they call Part C. This is really the overall review of snowmobile use, OSV use on the forest, in particular our area, which is where the contribution comes in. But it's going to look at the overall snowmobile program in a holistic way to look at staging areas.
2:35:17 Where the routes are now, what they've been doing, and come to some decision in the end that will hopefully stem to any court action that is the reason that actually had to do this work. The grant was a green sticker grant. It's primarily focused on OSVUs. Talking to CAS, it would provide an opportunity to discuss
2:35:44 Other types of uses that might be utilized on groomed trails such as fat bikes and those kinds of things that are currently prohibited on the forest that could be looked at on a different decision level. Not this one since it wasn't included in the overall grant that they're going to be moving forward with. With that, the scope of work is detailed pretty well within the grant. That will be converted into a cost share agreement. All these cost share agreements will end up
2:36:14 Having the format similar to the one that's included, and they have a template that's required for use of all the agreements, cost share agreements nationwide, and the template, certain things, what you can't do if you don't have the password is clean it up to print a version that doesn't have all the comments. So that's why the other version has it. So what you'll be seeing at the next meeting for the ones that come back,
2:36:42 Will be kind of that formal format of what the cost share agreement is. Include the scope, the hours, cash that's included, and staff time that's included in the agreement. With that, if there's additional questions. Let me start with one question. It's because you keep saying snowmobiles, but over-snowed vehicles can be all kinds of things, right? OSV. So it's an OSV grant. So my concern is that the way it's written right now is it...
2:37:12 Doesn't look at emerging trends like fat tire bikes and things like that that might also be there. And when I look at it, I'll keep saying motorized. And you said snowmobile several times. I want to make sure that it's broad enough that any kind of an over-snow vehicle can be included in the analysis. If we may, on this one here, we're asking them to try to get to that level.
2:37:41 Because this is primarily a green sticker grant funded program, we've got to be focused on those motorized vehicles that pay for this grant. The green sticker grant is just over $200,000. The other funding is matched to that. So there are some legal restrictions in terms of the grant and what this is a problem with the green sticker program. It's a very great program, but it also restricts some of the review of what we can do. We've had the discussion with the Forest Service staff that
2:38:10 Does this set us up to be able to move forward in looking at the fat bikes on here, the snow bikes and those types of elements? The preliminary conversation back is yes, it will, but again, the primary funding for this, and our match then is tied to that, is this is the green sticker program, so we're a little bit limited on how much we can put into a grant that is non-motorized, it's paid for by motorized funding.
2:38:36 Well, I disagree with that a little bit, Dan, because the existing maps also show the cross-country ski trails on them, so that the green sticker money can be used for non-mobiles things. Some of it can. We're also being challenged. I know the Forest Service is being challenged, say, for, we'll talk about later, but the snow grooming, because the machine was purchased for those things, it can't be used to groom the cross-country ski trails, for example.
2:39:03 The State of California is getting much more critical in terms of its use of those funds and how broad a reach we can make with those. Well, I would just hope that there's a way to be creative that if you're going to spend over $300,000 that you can include emerging recreation trends within it. We absolutely want to. And we've had that plenary discussion with the Forest Service to try to get those pieces incorporated.
2:39:33 If we call it specifically out, it may be a violation of the grant. We'll pay that money back. So we don't go that far. Well, I think that there's a couple of things here. I was in all the MLTSC meetings where this was being discussed. And we have a – there are emerging trends for Groom Summobile Network. We've had some very effective advocates for this program. And, frankly, the process that they've been engaged with with the Forest Service has been frustrating and disappointing.
2:40:03 And they've been put in a position to have a burden put on them that was impossible for them to be able to meet that challenge. In terms of the expectation of the Forest Service that advocates go out and perform NEPA analysis or conditions analysis and the cost would be on the advocates to do this work. There's no promise coming back from the Forest Service saying we'll incorporate it, we'll do anything with it. And it added to just a culture of frustration around our recreation opportunities which really shouldn't be there. And I think that...
2:40:32 In the language that's provided here in Exhibit B, and when the MLTSCC was discussing this grant, there was never, and that was a while ago, and it's too bad that those things didn't get to this, but there was no discussion about what the limitations of the framework within which the town's participation in this grant would happen. The language mentions the force order, which is in effect, which defines what activities take place upon this groom network. I would think that
2:41:02 We're very inclined to want to go forward with this thing, but I think we need to have, to Joe's point, some consultation with the Forest Service about what does this mean. If we're investing in this process, what specifically are the limitations of it, and what are the opportunities if we're investing in this for the emerging trends of recreation that we need to have as part of a, if it's a future effort with the Forest Order, will this environmental review support that? And I can't imagine that
2:41:28 If you're growing things in the forest, you're looking for all types of uses that would happen on top of it, but I don't think we have enough information to know what's going on here, and I think it would be very important to be able to have a conversation with the Forest Service. We're having that conversation with them to get those incorporated. I don't think you'll see them right in the grant that they're going to look at the non-motorized stuff heavily, because that will kill the green sticker program piece of it, at least to what we're hearing from the Forest Service. I don't think we want to jeopardize a larger project.
2:41:57 But we are getting down with the local folks going, yes, we need to be able to move forward to incorporate these other elements for exactly the reasons that you're... You've had a lot of green sticker money shut down motorized trails too. Right. And there's a lot of concern in the community about that. I think the language in here, I mean, if there's a commitment to go and work on it, I mean, all these new things that are coming, I mean, certainly we should try to incorporate it.
2:42:26 And I think to Joe's point about being creative, I mean, I think it would be helpful to hear before we go down this road to say, okay, if we're investing $20,000, which I think is important to do, what exactly is coming out the other side? And what should our expectations should be about our investment in this program? And we're making those comments on that. Remember, our investment, too, looks, here's a stretch because we're looking at just at our, trying to tie it to our incorporated area, if you will, for our dollars.
2:42:50 The question in terms of the other emergency activities that are non-motorized, yes, we want to have that element. If that's a high portion of the grant, we put the whole grant at risk and we would not want to go down that road period on that component. But I think we want to be engaged in the process so we can have the exact conversation that we're having here. So do you think it's, does it make sense to have staff come back to us with maybe an update?
2:43:16 Given these types of questions before we make a commitment to say, to have a better sense of exactly, you know, I don't think so. I think we have to continue that work. I think we move forward. We will work with them in those areas. I think at some point, our other elements on these is the board service putting their work program together, et cetera. If we keep pushing out too far, some of these will drop off of the program. Right. But, and again, we may not, that may be okay from our end too, but.
2:43:43 I think there's an element here we do have to work with them and trust what they're being told. And as you mentioned earlier, we are really working hard to reestablish that trust relationship on both sides of the equation between the town and the Forest Service on making these types of things happen. Yeah, we're not worse off by approving this and then going back to them. The fat bike deal is an example, right? Right. We're actually ahead. I would say yes, it's moving in the right direction. Yeah, I agree. We're actually further down the road. Right.
2:44:13 Because we're going to have to have that discussion anyway for new uses, no matter what, right? Well, I guess I'm just looking at technically what are we buying here in terms of participating with this environmental analysis. What exactly are we getting out of this? Without any promises from them, but what is going to come out of this and what is it going to mean to these things we're talking about?
2:44:38 And it's just, unless, I don't want to put the burden on you guys to make the representation, but maybe the Forest Service, they can make their representation. We should probably hear from them because it's their grants, their authority. You know, one of the, this is actually for preparing the NEPA document. Part of the NEPA document has a public scoping portion of that work. So that's where those kinds of comments can be incorporated at least into the discussion. But the grant really was specific and just reading through it, it's specific really to motorized.
2:45:06 And it's funded primarily by motorized V-sticker funds. The match that we're providing is some crash. The Forest Service is providing significant staffing. Because I just, in reading this, it reads, technological advances, but also introducing new types of over-snowed vehicles, including snow bikes, tractor HVs, and various forms of snow cats. So I don't know. I think they're in there. Again, it says...
2:45:32 Soft sell on the non-motorized side, and that's what we're pushing for. If you understand or recall, this was driven out of some other legal actions taken on other forests. Oh, sure. So we're getting out in front of it so we don't close our forests down to over snow activity, motorized or not. That's, I think that's the bigger concern from the Forest Service side. All right, so, oh, I'm sorry, yeah. Any comments from the public on the over snow vehicle NAPA review?
2:46:04 Under Council, my name's Alan Jacoby. I own two snowmobiles. I pay my green sticker taxes, but I'm here on behalf of Fat Bike Mammoth. That's my passion, I ride bikes. And I'm just stoked that I've heard at least four people up here say the word Fat Bike, or the words Fat Bike, much better than two years ago when I first started talking about this with Kazmierski and John Regalbrews. Anywho, you guys talked a lot about
2:46:32 What I wanted to bring up, I just want to make sure that when we're thinking about our measure, our funds, that fat bikes and emerging trends on the groomed trails are brought up because the forest order that's currently dated from December of 92 is antiquated. You know, it says no-wheeled vehicles and it specifically states bicycles in the verbiage, which is a death blow to us. So anything that can be pushed forward to help amend that.
2:47:02 Is what we're looking for. Obviously, we're not going to get that done overnight, but if somehow we can keep this dialogue going with the Forest Service as we push it along, constantly reminding them, hey, hey, you're doing this NEPA slip-in analysis on fat bikes and other stuff, because if a 500-pound, you know, two-stroke motor that churns up snow to make forward propulsion can go on snow, my bike that...
2:47:31 Makes it tread like my croc. Should be able to go next to it. And we ride those same trails in the summertime. Blah, blah, blah. You all know this. So, yeah, that's pretty much why I'm here. This could be our only chance to push that forward. And hopefully, the next set of maps that you guys work on will have bikes on the maps. With big tires. Yeah, so. It's pretty much it.
2:48:01 Thanks for letting me talk. Thanks. Thank you, Alan. Okay, thank you, Alan. Dana Stroud, Mammoth Lakes Recreation Chair. I have a couple of questions and clarifications. Attached to this document is the grant application that the Forest Service submitted, and in there it goes into great detail about the eight steps or the eight...
2:48:26 I guess the eight deliverables that they're going to be funded through this grant. And very specifically, the first one says, engage the public and stakeholders in dialogue regarding over snow vehicle use on the Inyo National Forest. In our challenge cost share agreement with them, do we get to encourage a level of expectation for what that public engagement looks like and how the town may be able to assist with helping to pull together stakeholders?
2:48:54 And encourage this public participation because I go back to a couple of winters ago when there was a discussion about OSV staging and there were a few big public meetings that were held over in the auditorium of the Forest Service and then nothing really ever came back out from that. So I'm just wondering is there an opportunity in our challenge cost share agreement to
2:49:17 Advise that we are able to help with this engagement and that we encourage a very robust and big outreach to allow all the users to come in and participate in this discussion. So that's my first comment on that. Then underneath that on number, it says number three, excuse me, sorry, number two, identify high value, publicly important, motorized and non-motorized winter recreation opportunities throughout the Inyo National Forest.
2:49:45 That, to me, is an opening for Fat Bite to be included in the discussion. And it says it in their grant application, and so I would hope that we have the opportunity, even with green sticker funds, to show that there is an intention here to include non-motorized. Then another part that I would like to bring up, earlier this year, in June of 2014, the U.S. Forest Service released
2:50:09 Over Snow Regulations that came out as public comment period of 45 days that ended in August. These regulations were intended to provide direction for how the Forest Service is intended to manage over snow vehicle use.
2:50:26 The regulations that came out gave the local authority to the Forest Service, the local forest, to make decisions about how they manage over snow vehicle use. And so I'm just wondering in this discussion can we ask the Forest Service about how they are going to take these regulations that have come out and integrate them into this planning process.
2:50:51 Because it does give the flexibility to the local authority to make decisions moving forward, including a look at that 1992 forest order, and they have the ability to make a change. So I would just encourage us to think about the new regulations that are coming out from the Forest Service at a national level and how we can apply them here. Thank you. Any other public comment?
2:51:21 Okay, go ahead. I'd make a motion that we approve number two. I'll second. Okay. I would like to add two things to that motion. One is to encourage the Forest Service to do as robust a public outreach effort as is possible, given the constraints of the grant. And the second thing would be to encourage the Forest Service that once this environmental process is complete, that the standing forest order
2:51:55 Be changed and updated to accommodate the widest use of recreation opportunities on this groomed system. Are you willing to accept that amendment to your motion, Michael? I need a little more clarification, I think, in the second part there. Okay. And from Dan. If I may make the comment, I think we can take that from the whole dialogue as a consensus to go do that. If we actually make that a condition of the grant.
2:52:24 And what we're writing up, I think that may be more challenging. So we can definitely take that. Consensus-wise, we know what you want. I think it's better if we work that through discussions with the Forest Service. I think Dana read that. It's in the project description. We'll just help them be creative. Yes, exactly. By including it, yeah. You know, I think I'm just encouraged by this dialogue. You know, I think staff
2:52:53 Has a good sense for how the council feels on this. I mean, just want to keep a broader perspective that our focus is to be the best alpine recreation community in the country. And that doesn't, you know, that doesn't distinguish summer, winter, that doesn't distinguish fat bikes, that doesn't distinguish snowmobiles. I mean, we're really focused on looking at this in a broader sense because right now the focus is talking about an emerging trend of fat bikes.
2:53:18 Ten years from now, who knows what that's going to be. We want to be open to those types of dialogues. Super fat bikes. Sure. Super fat snowmobiles. I think they're kind of in the super fat already. Sure. We're not talking about other people that operate them. So, you know, I just...
2:53:44 I think we just want to make that, I mean, the way I read some of the documentation, it doesn't close the door to having those uses coexist peacefully. So that's just a focus for us moving forward. I think you've heard that loud and clear. Okay, so then we have a motion and a second. A roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us to...
2:54:15 Number three, which is a trail maintenance strategy for multi-use paths and soft-service trails. And actually, maybe number six would be appropriate to talk about because it's the other snowmobile one, which doesn't actually have a number. All right, yeah. I added six on mine. Okay, so at the bottom of page five, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Special Use Permit Modification. Talk about that one next. Okay. It relates back to the same over-snow issues and lump them together. Okay.
2:54:45 So this particular one is we have an existing use permit for the trail system that we own and operate throughout town. And so this one is at least having the Forest Service requesting them to have a limited use corridor for motorized snowmobiles from the Shady Rest staging area parking, which has moved to various spots over the years, currently at Shady Rest Park, through the tunnel.
2:55:15 To, through, around the RV park, through Meridian, and then out to that open area really which just is east of, or south of Meridian Boulevard. The way, since it's a special use modification, a cautionary agreement, is the town would propose a, this limited use, they'll review it, they'll make a determination if they will accept the request for them to look at that or not.
2:55:43 If they say go ahead and we'll pursue the request and they would prepare a collection agreement for the town to pay for the NEPA process going forward to review the process and make a decision one way or the other. The timing of this one would be desirable to have in conjunction with the other NEPA process. They may or may not incorporate the two.
2:56:11 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:56:37 I somehow heard that NEPA would be done and it would look at alternatives because back when the trail system master plan was put together, it promised that there would be a winter summit that would talk about that whole area and that hasn't done and yet here we have, well, this is the way we're going to do it. I'm just concerned that that doesn't really get into the strategy of saying, well, what if that's not the best route or those kinds of things or it's kind of like a tunnel to nowhere.
2:57:07 What, you know, those questions and the alternatives that I would expect to see discussed in a NEPA document of, is that the place to do it or, you know, is it somehow related to the new staging area that they're talking about right past where some of the cutoff goes into Shady Rest Park? I was just a little bit concerned that we seem to be jumping the step of asking the question, is this the best way to accomplish and what is it that we're trying to accomplish?
2:57:37 And, Madam Mayor, if I could maybe help with that a little bit. I would suggest that we make the proposed route through the tunnel to the new staging area that John Regenberger has made a decision to say that that's where the staging area is going to be. There's already been this full NEPA process, which, whatever it is, that was his decision to put the staging area up on Salmon Cutoff Road. So I think that we should be looking at it connecting through the tunnel.
2:58:07 Only to that new staging area that he's made a decision about because we don't want to just have things going through the tunnel and wandering around and maybe reigniting all those issues from the past. The second thing I would say is I have a question about making any kind of a nexus or a linkage between the previous thing we just talked about, which is the whole system. It's a system-wide analysis being driven by environmental concerned folks.
2:58:35 Way outside of our area. I don't want that to be potentially sucked up into what might be a local concern about a very, you know, specific local issue. And I would hope that we could keep those things very separate. And I don't, and I think that that's important to do. I think if we can look at those two things with an addition of one other item, which is the Forest Service came back, the MLTSDC and others last year were talking about snowmobile staging areas.
2:59:03 On the scenic loop, and out on, I think there's two of the different proposals, that all of these get put together into one process, all of them with the intention of being Mammoth Lakes Trail System, motorized staging areas as part of an enhancement of our trail system, but all this stuff into one basket, and I think it would make sense to move forward so it becomes one coherent project. He jeopardized this by trying to put all that together into one big project?
2:59:32 I don't know, but that would be the question before. I'm just concerned that they came forward with those staging areas and they were heading into a NEPA process and then they mysteriously went away for some reason. I just think it's long overdue that we utilize that access from one side to the other. Just to follow up on the NEPA process that was going on on the Cine Club, really they didn't finish that because they knew that they had to do this overall NEPA project for the forest. And so...
2:59:58 That became ahead of this other problem that was occurring in the other forest. Well, what's troubling, though, is to say we did trail system master plan, a lot of involvement, said we would do a winter summit to help with the discussion about what happens in the shady rest area. The Forest Service then put in the temporary one, if you want to call it, right by the ball fields, and now they're saying they want to move it to a different location.
3:00:25 You know, can we not do this once instead of, you know, because it just got a concern that if you say that this is the only alternative, because underneath it you're supposed to have alternatives. And I think that that might be a way to involve some of these other locations and get them to get the Forest Service to commit to the one and have the public be able to respond to the alternatives. What would be the alternative to the tunnel?
3:00:55 There was a previous one about doing a staging area, well, let's see, out by the craters, there's the temporary one that's near the ball fields, there's the new one that's over there. Well, you're talking about staging areas, so I think Shields is talking about getting from one point to another. The path, yeah.
3:01:13 There is no alternative. There is no alternative. There is no alternative. There is no alternative, but I guess the purpose is, especially since it says in there, you know, they're going to decide on a minimum snow depth. Well, in all the years when Mammoth Nordic was talking about grooming the whole, we could never do it because we never had snow. So it's kind of like, well, I can see that there might be some value to this, but I don't want to say it's the only option before we've looked at NEPA alternatives because
3:01:42 On the other hand, under number five up here, if we're going forward with that, we're also spending $20,000 to groom some of the same area for cross-country and snowshoe and dog walking, which is not necessarily compatible, so how are we pulling these things together? And I think also, this is following up on council action at the end of a previous council where they made a very specific recommendation to look at this. And I think that we should look specifically at this.
3:02:06 But I think we should look at this as it connects to that staging area that John Buckley was in front of. No, agreed, agreed, totally agreed. And then the question becomes, to the degree to which we can take these other proposals that were out on the scenic loop and bring that in as part of it. If you're saying that that would be a bad idea because that gets into that other process, okay, we can leave those out of it because that's subject to this larger system-wide analysis, fine. But I think we should be pretty clear that we're going to do that. No, I like your direction.
3:02:34 John on that. I mean, it makes sense. But just saying, okay, does it, I mean, can we get it, you know, at the same time as this? I think they can work together and we don't want one to blow the other up. And to Joe's point, one of the questions we would have for the Forest Service is, as far as a corridor element, are there other routes that have less impact on the snowshoeing on the cross country? We know we may have conflicts there. We want to avoid that.
3:03:04 You know, is it found to be incompatible completely? That could happen, and then you're looking at a route that I think goes up to, down to 395 and across, but there's issues that way. So I think they have to look at some other alternatives in this process, but the focus is more on this corridor and say is, is that a viable option? And if not, or in that analysis, here's one or two others.
3:03:29 I think you want to be careful if it gets too expansive. You do have to roll it into the other item. That's fine. I'll take that. But I think it is important that we connect it to.
3:03:39 The staging area was already made a decision about. So we're not just going through the tunnel leaking all over. It's truly a corridor look, but I think you have to look at other options in that process. Yeah, there'll be alternatives getting from here to there for the other alternatives. I think that if I could, if that's what the mayor was after, I believe, in terms of, it's not just, here's the only alternative, yes, we'll look at it. I think there has to be. Sure.
3:04:05 You have to, you know, you have to have a couple of alternatives, and I think it's, it's not clear in the language, it needs to be clear that from parking staging on north side of State Route 203, Shady Rest Area, well, is that the really old one up front? Is it the temporary one? Or is it the actual one that John Ragerberger has said that's where it will go? So I don't think it was...
3:04:27 Claire, so it has to be the nexus. And I find it interesting that we're calling that one a parking staging area because if we truly do have this other corridor, then you don't need the second parking staging area, you just need the staging area. Well, these are things because this is a request that's coming from the town. Right. And we're asking the Forest Service to do environmental analysis of something that we're asking them to do.
3:04:54 So we get to say we would like to consider going from through the tunnel to this staging area. All the way up. And so we're asking, can you please take a look at this? So I think if we're clear that that's what we're looking at, I think, Joe, I think the alternatives, if we're saying get us from here to there, there would be alternatives. Yeah. Because we know it isn't going to be the road because that gets plowed for Armat and everything else. So it's got to be, yeah. So give us alternatives that make it work.
3:05:23 So I would make a motion. Yeah. Public comment. Public comment. Yes. You're too far away. Sorry. Dana Stroud, I have a couple of questions with regards to the NEPA on this. Today is September 17th.
3:05:44 What's the timeline for NEPA to begin? It certainly wouldn't be completed before this winter, so there's not an opportunity to use it. Is there the chance to put some time constraints to ask to have it done so that next winter NEPA will have already been finished and there's the opportunity to utilize the tunnel as so desired?
3:06:06 I'm just asking that question because whoever mentioned it, it's been a long time coming and so here's the opportunity to now try and do something so that we can access that tunnel. I have a second question relative to the snow corridor may or may not be groomed. So again, because it's not this winter, but in thinking about the future, where's the funding for that grooming to come from? What budget is that going to live in? Who is going to do the grooming? And so I'm hoping that
3:06:36 Through this process, we'll be able to identify those. The third question has to do with signage. It's referenced in the description that the path, again, may or may not be groomed, but it will be well signed. So my question is a budget for signage to go into the ground. What type of signage are we talking about? I'm presuming it's going to adhere with the standards and guidelines that have been set up for our signage. But I'm just wondering if we can...
3:07:03 Include that in some of this discussion in this description so that we can clarify that. And same thing applies where does the money come from for the signage to be put into the ground. I do want to acknowledge, and I apologize for not saying it earlier, this is very exciting. This is exciting that we have these agreements coming forward for consideration. It's very exciting that we have this opportunity to work, you know, collectively with the Forest Service on advancing some of these interests.
3:07:33 And I'm very encouraged by what we're seeing through this process, and I just want to thank you guys for bringing it forward and thank the Council for encouraging this. But I think it's also exciting and very important for us to clarify as much as we possibly can so that there's not any misunderstanding and that we are able to manage the expectations of everybody who's participating in this and that we all clearly understand what our obligations will be as we move forward. So that's why I'm asking the questions. Thank you. Thanks, Dana.
3:08:02 And, you know, I know that staff said, oh, well, we'll tie this in with the number two, except that doesn't have an implement decision until November of 2016.
3:08:13 I'm hoping because this one is more of a, number six is more of a local issue that maybe it's got a shorter timeline and doesn't have to wait in line for number two to happen. And by time, we didn't mean time together. We just meant there are similar subjects. Okay. So there's no vehicles. We thought we'd address them at the same time. Okay, I just want to make sure that. No, we don't want to wait because. No, separate issues. You know, that'll be 2017. Right, right. Don't forget this one done sooner, but they both must know. Correct. So I would make a potion.
3:08:43 Okay. I will attempt to make a motion for number six. For that the council allocate funding appropriate for a discrete NEPA analysis of an over-snow vehicle multi-use roomed corridor from the south side of the tunnel of Highway 203 to the staging area as approved by District Ranger John Oliver.
3:09:15 Second. Can I ask for one modification to that? Because I believe that in the original idea, the south side of town near Meridian Boulevard was to mean the Commerce Drive area? Correct. Right. And you were saying just south of the town. Do you mean all the way to Meridian? Yeah. Let's include it. All the way to Bishop. You're going to really have problems with more. Okay.
3:09:43 We have a motion and a second. I'll pop up, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. You know, you guys can leave them off. I don't like you. No, I don't. That's all right. Okay. So now should we go to number three? Yes. Which is the multi-use pass and soft surface trails maintenance strategy program? Correct.
3:10:17 So this one really, you know, initially it was actually three different programs within the MLSTCC budget work program for this fiscal year. And in discussions with the forest and really what we're trying to do is implement the overall MLTS and really the purpose of the MOU that we have with them was to create a strategy and a mechanism so that
3:10:48 Town and others, meaning volunteer groups slash volunteers, as well as the forest, have a common goal, a common program to maintain soft surface trails and then kind of integrate that with our current program that the town manages, which is the hard surface trails that we've got, the program that we've adopted and kind of integrating them into one document, which is the overall MLTS.
3:11:17 In the end, it would create, because currently what they figured out for two of these projects is that they really don't have, the town doesn't have authorization to do work on outside the permit areas that we have. We've been working on things cooperatively, although they actually haven't given us specific approvals or Friends of the Yanyo, those kinds of things. That's what this will create. It's kind of the town's ownership, management, assistance.
3:11:45 for the overall MLTS. So there will be a more refined scope of work that will be completed. In discussions with John Kazmirski, there's probably, the budget is probably higher than we actually need. This is really a staff time for each of our parties. And so the additional
3:12:14 Funds that may be available could then be used for doing some maintenance project with the forest. With that, if there's additional questions. Well, yeah, I'm going to rephrase your last statement. If the town contribution is less than the 12-5, then the remainder is returned to the MLTS fund balance for reallocation. Correct. It is not just used for something else. That's one of the policy items.
3:12:40 We'll be talking about later. So if I understood you, Peter, we already have the one for the multi-use paths, the paved paths. We have a portion of that. So what we have is what the town performs on a regular basis to maintain a safe and operable path. The little guy who goes brushing along and things. And it includes sweep eat, it includes our winter closures that we have in Lakes Payson, it includes most of the things we do, and it probably needs an update and a review.
3:13:09 What we really don't, and the forest does have standards that they use nationwide related to trails. What they really don't have, and certainly locally they don't have, is how often do they do maintenance on some of their soft-server trails, and what trails are suitable for multi-use, meaning bicycles and pedestrians, and what trails are not. So it really is identifying those, sets up agreements on how
3:13:36 To parcel out maybe some of the work versus having a volunteer group do certain things that they're capable of doing and they're suitable for them to do versus work that needs to be done by basically a professional crew, either a force crew or some other group that's trained and able to either build a trail or do significant maintenance, meaning moving more than you can move with a couple of people.
3:14:05 So it's really setting up that overall strategy agreements for the overall maintenance going forward. And in the end, it will make them comfortable in completing and constructing new trails within the system, which I don't think currently they're comfortable with building new soft surface trails that they might be responsible for. If I could jump into the point. Go ahead, John.
3:14:36 I'm still trying to get my head out. So I think, and I appreciate the need for this. It's important and it's something that we need to move forward with. I think that what we need very specifically is the approved set of standards from the Forest Service and from the town that establish level of service for every trail type listed in the Trail System Master Plan, winter and summer. We need those standards. And I think that's all we need at this point.
3:15:06 And I think that if that is the specific deliverable that's identified and you can look at, I think you can probably reduce the number here somewhat to deliver that. I don't think the strategic implementation of those standards is necessary yet. I think we need to get the standards in place first. And I think if we can do that, once they're known, then we can start getting to the next step of, okay, well, how do we deliver these maintenance standards to these trails? So I would suggest that.
3:15:34 And I'm going to agree with that, especially because in something that Peter said is that, you know, we have to be really careful every time we turn around and use measure our money that it is in some way town owned and town managed. And this one, if we can get that first piece done, then that conversation can happen about how you deal with it going forward. Because to me, it sounds like...
3:16:02 The Forest Service is looking for somebody to pay for maintaining their trails and take on the liability, and I'm not so sure we necessarily want to do that, since I'm the one who... As a bill for Dr. Karch? Yes. Yes, my expensive permanent jewelry. I think your idea is to break it into a smaller piece, deal with that, and then have the other discussion, because I'm concerned that...
3:16:31 The Forest Service is just looking at Measure R as a way to have them not pay for anything in the future. And I think that what we do with this, this is something that the town would manage, is this would be a compendium for the standards mantle. Public Works already adopted. This is the specific technical expertise that the town of Forest Service have to do this. No one else can really do this. So I would recommend we do this and get it done. And then once that's in place, we can start talking about these other things. Peter, you said there's already standards.
3:17:01 That the Forest Service has? Well, they have some national standards that probably need to be tweaked on how maybe they're implemented locally. Would it be a good start for us? Correct. This will be the start. Yeah. The other piece of this, though, that there's, and this is one of the ones that, we'll talk about the other ones, the snow grooming, but currently the town really doesn't have an agreement, nor does Friends of the Inyo to do the work that's happening in the Lakes Basin. So this project is to help.
3:17:28 Create that program slash cost share agreement with the Forest Service so that we can implement that going forward. What they're, what they have done really over this last year is really look at what's happening in the forest. They're being critical to make sure that whatever's happening, they've actually got an approval and approving whoever it is that's doing whatever it is they're doing. I'm sorry, there's a lot of pronouns in there. Who's they? The Forest Service,
3:17:57 In order for anything to happen on the Forest Service property, the Forest Service lands, they have to give permission to do that. You just can't go out and do trail maintenance because you're a good guy. Okay, so these will establish standards for what happens in any trail that then if the town through MLR or whoever is contracting to have something done, we've got a standard that says we are hiring you to do this work as identified in the standards manual of maintenance to get something done. And include a draft.
3:18:26 Cost Share Agreement going forward. Instead of having to negotiate the scope every time, it will have, these are the bullet points, you can fill in the trail that will be done and the amount of work that will be done. Okay, and the other thing is this will go to the sharp trails, I'm assuming, that when we start talking about a level of maintenance that we would be expected to provide when those trails get built up there, we've got something we could point at and say we will provide number six.
3:18:52 And the foreshippers will then be able to sign off on it and say, okay, we agree to that, and then we can get that problem resolved. Can you clarify again, I'm lost on your thought of breaking it up and not. Let me go back to that. When we looked at the forest service real quick at this, there was a potential for this to have some savings out of. We'd actually talked about doing a, we'd come back to the approval, but it would be almost a demonstration project for a maintenance project.
3:19:17 That will depend on the total cost of getting the manuals in place and the standards in place and what we've just been talking about. I leave the full amount allocated. If we don't use it, grade it, as it was mentioned earlier, it would roll back into the fund balance for MLTSC work, MLTS work. And it would be good, I think, and this is a dollar we've been having with the Forest Service in a broader scope of.
3:19:45 What is the maintenance partnership that we can have on these and do some demonstrations that here's how this is done, here's what they can do, here's what we do with our partners? Probably, as Peter mentioned, the most concern of getting something in place here is actually to continue some of the work we're doing now with our partnerships. That is probably right on the edge of whether or not it should be allowed to go forward under the current Forest Service permits.
3:20:13 We can bifurcate it from a project and standards, but I think we'd go for the idea of the standards, next step we'd come back and get approval for that process, if that, there's funds to do that. Right, so we just did the standards now, see how that goes, and then, yeah, and then we come back, but I definitely don't want to end up with a problem down the road where we end up with a debate over, we can't do our summer stewardship program because
3:20:40 It's not managed, it's not controlled, it's not under the town, it's not under a permit, therefore, you can do the program, we just can't use any major R funds to do it, and friends of the INYO, MLTPA, somebody else would need to go get the permit with the Forest Service to actually allow that to go forward. But we start with these standards, that's the first step. Yeah, and that's the work program that we're trying to move forward. Okay. And the goal would be to actually have this done January, February? Yeah, very quickly. Okay.
3:21:08 Well, now, when you say the goals, but until we actually do the applications, the Forest Service isn't going to commit to any timelines, right? Right, so we have to come back and do the agreement here and come back and say we want this done by X date as agreed upon time frame. Okay. Is it motion time? Mm-hmm. Public economy. No, no, wait, wait, wait, no, it's not. Shields has something up here. No, no, I was going to say public economy.
3:21:36 So we're losing our public. Thank you for that. I've got to rein you in. Sorry. Bad counsel version. Okay. If there's no public comment on this item, now would you like to make a motion? Yes. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I would like to make a motion on an item as identified, which is number three, correct? To proceed with the creation of a draft manual.
3:22:03 For standards of maintenance of trails on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System to be produced by the staffs of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the United States Forest Service. Second. Second. He's bad, but he's good. He's bad, but he's good. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And number four.
3:22:35 So number four is development of a soft surface signage wayfinding prototype design and prototype design, which really would then fall into the standards. This would entail engaging some type of designer. You know, we've got some early work that was done by Corbin. I think the forest, based on conversations, they think we need a little bit something a little bit more rustic that's in the forest as far as wayfinding.
3:23:05 They would agree that it needs to be something that would follow the MLTS program as far as look and feel, maybe the color scheme, those kinds of things, so that people can feel like they're on a seamless trail or system, but it would certainly be a little bit different than the urban type that we have on the hard surface trails. The overall project would be managed by the town. The Forest Service would commit to doing reviews.
3:23:37 It would be brought to the MLR group for discussion and review of the design alternatives as part of the project. This, since it has those types of reviews, it probably would take, you know, most of the fiscal year. Our fiscal year should be done by next summer, at least have some prototypes built. But they are interested in working with the town to develop those standards, which is good news. Peter, do they,
3:24:07 Since on those stewardship events, Friends of the Inyo has created signs already that get put in place and the different things that I presume are to the forest standard, do those standards already exist? I'm not sure what these do. So this one would be really for the MLTS. So right now we have a certain color scheme for all the signs. Yeah. And we use a certain font and those kinds of things.
3:24:37 But they do have a little bit of modern look. They're steel and they're durable, although I've noticed some fading on some of the signs that we'll have to work with the Forest Service on warranty work. But I think what they're really looking for, and that's part of the development of the standard, would be something that's a little bit more rustic. It would look similar enough so that you would know that you're on the system, at least in my mind.
3:25:06 It wouldn't necessarily look exactly like our signs we have on our surface. So is it kind of like a bridge between ours and the wilderness? Because there's not any standards for the wilderness. And the wilderness has a separate standard that we're, you know, it's a national standard. But I guess what I was asking you is, does the Forest Service not have any standards right now? I remember finding the Emerald Lake Trail sign stuck next to a tree because it had fallen over. Yeah, so they've got their standards, which is the green and white types.
3:25:37 But that doesn't really flow with the overall MLTS. So there's not the MLTS logo on it. And it doesn't have that same feel of gear on one single system. You transition maybe from a hard surface to a soft surface trail, but you're on a totally different sign version of that trail. So this is kind of developing that standard that would go throughout the system.
3:26:08 Well, no problem we've had with them in the past on signs of all different kinds and what they like and what they don't like. Is that really what this is going to be about? It's trying to come up with a compromise that they'll accept? I think the answer is yes, and that helps brand our system and retain that branding of the system, but there is a distinctive between our urban and...
3:26:31 Well, no, because the monument signs had to be argued. They weren't going to accept it. They were too modern, et cetera. So it will be some give and take in that design work probably coming again through the town via third-party partners and then for the Forest Service to sign off. But they will definitely be given input on what they will or won't accept in terms of going out on their system with this. Our main concern was that we retain, as Peter mentioned, this branding element.
3:26:59 That you know you're on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, but you're not in the urban core, you're now out in the... So going up duck past, there will not necessarily be a QR code because you're not going to get reset. But I think the real need for this is in areas like Inyo Craters, the mountain biking community where people get lost all over the place, in the shore winds. I think we do things up in the shady rest area. There's a need to do this. I think I would suggest that we go back to the model we adopted for the maps.
3:27:29 That a third party consultant be engaged to do this. That the time of the Forest Service staff and the town staff is not in the design coming up with a look and feel of these kinds of things. But we're relying on the agencies to provide necessary regulatory approvals and that kind of stuff. Yeah, they'll have more input on the front end. Yes, and I think it's also very important to understand that
3:27:55 When I say town, I'm always kind of thinking about MLR is involved in this process. But I think that a real challenge is going to be the information technology part of this. Because you could put what's all really needed out there is maybe just a carcinite sign. We don't need anything more sort of complex than that. But to be able to integrate the naming conventions, the numbering, the information that's on those things, this goes back to the wayfinding logic.
3:28:22 There was a lot of time went in between MLTPA and the Forest Service and the Town to come up with a wayfinding logic for this stuff. This is all soft tissue stuff, which is very complex and time consuming. So engaging a third party that can come up with some basic physical alternatives for review by the Forest Service and the Town that might be the appropriate thing that's going to be out in the landscape, the challenge is going to be putting the information on that thing
3:28:49 It's going to make sure that people know where they are, they're not getting lost, and all that stuff is going to work. So it's a relatively modest exercise, I think, to come in with something that's going to be acceptable to the Forest Service to put into the ground, but to have the analysis of the cost of putting them there, buying them, maintaining them, but then to start bringing some cost estimates together for what the information, that back-end part, is going to cost. That's a totally different... And that's the lift. Exactly. So this could be a relatively modest thing to come up with some...
3:29:16 Things that are good to put in the ground that will allow the information to be on there. So it's a relatively modest thing to do. It's something that's needed, but all the other stuff is going to be much more important. And this would go into our signage program handbook that we have adopted. We're going to that. And I think, again, I would say that the public involvement in this is incredibly important. Because when we did the first round of the trail system, I'm Peter Potter. I remember the meeting we had with Mammoth Trails where...
3:29:39 The Corbin basic stuff was there, but you go out to user groups who bring the public involved, they come up with really good ideas. Like I said, Alan Jacoby, what are you going to want to see out in your craters that a fat biker or someone who's never been here before is going to give them the information that they need, the ties into the maps, the ties into the website, and all the rest of it. Just to clarify, you said, obviously the Forest Service is going to review the design, make sure it's...
3:30:08 It works for them. The body on our end that makes sure that it kind of fits in with the design scope of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is MLR. Is that right? That would be our intent is to use that body in that hearing process. And I think the Forest Service will have some comments on the front end too of we don't want this, we don't want that, so there'll be some side boards that we're working with. Yeah, I mean, as long as we're ever cognizant of the fact that we want it to feel like you're on a seamless system, then I'm comfortable with that. That's the goal. That's important.
3:30:38 Okay. You want to do another motion, John? Public? No. Public? I'm sorry. Public comment. Sorry. I'm learning. Sorry. Dana Stroud. Having been involved at the front end of the initial signs that were developed for our trail system, there was considerable time spent with the Forest Service at the table to talk about the design, the color scheme, the look, the materials that were being used.
3:31:07 So I'm a little disappointed that they perceive that what is being called urban signs don't seem to translate very well going out onto some of the soft surface trails. So I don't know how to reconcile that. And I'm kind of bummed about it because Corbin came up with several different types of signs that could be used at all different types of applications.
3:31:36 I have to express a disappointment to hear that. However, with that said, I want to presume that we're talking about signs that are going to go onto the trails that are under the special use permit that we're managing right now, that the town is managing. Is there also the expectation that those signs that are going to be designed for use on soft surface would then be integrated by the Forest Service outside of
3:32:02 The trail system that we're managing. So that in speaking about a seamless transition, when somebody goes off the trail that we're not managing anymore, will someone encounter the same type of sign that the Forest Service will put in on their system? And I'm just wondering if that's something that can be discussed with them or have a level of expectation that signs will continue to go a little further out than just on those that are under our special use permit.
3:32:31 And then finally I would encourage public participation in this. There was significant public input as those initial signs were developed. And I think to continue the momentum that was developed with the new signs that came on, it's going to be really important to have the public's involvement in all of this. And so I just encourage that to be a part of this agreement with the Forest Service thing.
3:32:59 You know, Dana, I think that you're right, and I remember those other conversations, but since then we've done the Lakes Basin Path and we've done all these interpretive panels that are a little bit more modern. Maybe we'll get a little farther with them this time. Well, hopefully. I mean, because even on the Lakes Basin Path, our signs are on there.
3:33:22 I would, maybe my other comment that I forgot to add to this is, is there an opportunity to re-engage potentially with Corbin because they were the ones who came up with the concepts and they were the ones who had in mind all of the uses of potential signs and perhaps we can go back to them to come up with an interpretation of a rustic sign or a non-urban sign as the Forest Service is calling it, but maybe there's an opportunity to re-engage them as well.
3:33:52 Just a couple quick comments. One is I think that there's an ongoing discussion about what exactly is the physical extent of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System to Dana's point. So we're representing all the orange diamond trails of the snowmobile trails. Those are all being represented as part of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. So I would posit that all of the trails currently being represented through the website and through the maps constitute components of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. So Dana's point about
3:34:21 Who exactly was being managed? The cooperative agreement with the Forest Service is that all that stuff is part of that system. The second thing is I think that this particular brand or genre of signage, maintenance is a real concern because a lot of these things are going to be out in areas that people don't see a whole lot and they may not be seen for a year or two. And so the durability of these things and the maintenance concerns I think are going to be important. With that being said, I'm prepared to make a motion.
3:34:50 And, you know, with this item, we're more specifically talking about signage that's deeper onto the trails, right? This is the soft surface trails. So we don't have any soft surface trails that we have a use permit for. So this is really that MLTS area that's beyond what the town has a use permit for that we'll be developing these standards on the previous item and for the overall assistance and management of them.
3:35:13 Those signage that we currently don't have. Because we have a lot of urban signage at the entrance to soft service trails. Yes. So we're just talking deeper in here. Right. So where the fork is. Yeah, just imagine when you're riding a bike out in your craters. Sure. And you miss that tiny little, you know, brown sign that tells you which road you're on. Right. Okay, would someone like to make a motion? Yes, Madam Mayor, if I could.
3:35:40 Did you want to? Just let him go. I would make a motion that a third-party contractor be engaged by the town to produce alternative prototype designs for appropriate physical signage for soft-surface trails for use in remote, non-wilderness areas of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
3:36:11 Component of the contract would be for the ease of integration of these signs into existing Mammoth Lakes Trail System information technologies. I just need to clarify that we're not going out and just hiring a contractor to do this. This is through a cost-share agreement with the force service to have this happen. Okay, but I understand the third-party issue that's what we're going to be doing, but I just want to wait. I'm sorry, the motion read is we go higher as a third-party person, but there's actually a cost-share agreement that would incorporate a third-party. I appreciate the technical clarification.
3:36:39 Would you like to, are you done? I hope so, yes. Would you like to second? No, I'm done. Second. Thank you, Carl. All right, we have a motion and a second. I'll call vote, please, Jamie. Yep. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Now to number 5, which is the Cross Country Skiing Winter Grooming in the Welcome Center Shady Rest Park area. And this item, um,
3:37:10 It's an ongoing area just north of the Welcome Center that's been groomed for cross-country ski use between the Welcome Center, Shady Rest Park, and I think many people probably in this room have used that particular route. It's pretty good. When there's snow. When there's snow, yeah. Essentially, in discussions initially, we thought it was going to be a use permit. Came back, really is appropriate to have a cost share agreement.
3:37:39 Currently, they do house the Nordini in a Forest Service facility. They do perform some of the maintenance on the groomer itself or the track setter. And then they, the Nordini really doesn't work unless they're doing compacting the snow prior to the Nordini going in to set the tracks. And they would continue to overall manage that program while the town would
3:38:09 Provide the funding and have a contract and it's proposed that we continue to use for this season at least Friends of the Inyoke since they own an Ardini that will be utilized to set the tracks for this route. With that, if there's some questions for discussion. Just a technical one is that on number five it says it would not be managed under CCSA but then when you get down to the bottom it says CCSA. So is it or isn't it? Yes, we started with the idea of
3:38:40 It's a CCA, then it went to Noah, it's a permit, and then it was back to CCSA, so our conversations did not get caught up with the typing. Okay. So it is. So it will be. So take the knot off. Take the knot off. Okay. What happened to Mammoth Nordic? Um. Oh. Brian kind of went away. I know you went away, but I'm just saying did Mammoth Nordic go away. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yes. They actually donated the Nordini to Friends of the Union. Oh, nice.
3:39:08 Was the estimated budget for the grooming last year $20,000 as well? The budget last year was $20,000. They spent about $6,000. About $5,000. A couple years ago it was almost $20,000. So it depends on the snow. And that extra funding went? It went back to MLTS for the balance. Okay. And this is a time and materials contract, so...
3:39:35 If it's a really heavy snow year, then we may be back before MLR to talk about additional money and council. When it is. That's this year. This year. As this one goes forward, just a front on it, we're looking for not just the approval with the Forest Service and the cost share agreement, but also the authority to enter into the extended contract with Friends of the Annual for the work as well. Okay. Public comment?
3:40:08 Dana Stroud. There was a time when we didn't have Mammoth Nordic and we didn't have grooming out there, and having been able to witness the growth of activity that takes place out there at Shaded Rest because of this grooming is exciting, and it's an opportunity to branch out with our Nordic activities in this community.
3:40:33 I would like to just wholeheartedly support this idea of extending the contract, and if I'm understanding it right, it's for one year, so does that include, does that end September of 2015, or is it, what year is it that we're talking about? It's for this winter season. This winter season, so after this winter, so sometime in the spring of 2015, we're going to have to start to look around and see who else, or if that.
3:40:59 Contract continues to extend with Friends of the Union. Or if we didn't need to actually do a formal bid process for it or RFP for it or something. Okay. But the mere fact we've got somebody in the community that was trained on the Nordini on how to operate it and is able to get out there and do it is very exciting. And we need it because snow is going to come this winter and we're going to want to have that access and we want to have those guys poised and ready to go. So thank you for considering it and thank you to Friends of the Union. I did want to take the opportunity also, I forgot to say it last time.
3:41:29 On item number three that we just discussed about the signage on the soft surface trails, the mere fact that we're having a conversation about signs on soft surface trail by the town of Mammoth Lakes is extremely huge. And if we remember during the trail system master planning process, there was a lot of focus and emphasis on the mups, as we called them. But in the background, there was always this
3:41:52 Is the town ever going to get into the business of soft surface trail management and development? And here we are tonight talking about that, and I want to acknowledge this moment because it's a significant step forward in how we look at our recreation product and how we are branching out. So thank you to the council, thank you to staff for bringing it forward, and certainly thank you to the Forest Service for having these conversations with us because it really speaks to where we've come from and what's ahead for us. So thank you.
3:42:22 Thank you, Dan. Would anyone like to... I'll make a motion. Oh, thank you, Shibs. To accept number five. Second. Motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And we will now move on to number 14. Town comments on the draft general management plan for Devil's Postpile.
3:42:52 Yes, Madam Mayor, we've prepared a draft letter, both the staff and actually Councilmember Whitworth provided some of the input as well on this. This evening we're requesting the authority to make any tweaks to the letter as may be requested by the council in authorizing the mayor to sign the letter and for us to submit it in a timely fashion to the Park Service with the town's comments for the post pile.
3:43:20 Staff report letter, I think, walks through the various issues, so I won't read those to you. But we'd like to get any comments or modifications, and if there's none, then we would move forward with the preparing a final letter for the mayor's signature. Well, I have no additional comments. I actually reviewed and made comments before the final version went into the agenda. You already have? Mm-hmm. Okay. You did a good job. John did a great job. I see Mr. Wentworth all over this.
3:43:52 Nice job. Thank you very much. Looks good. So would someone like to make a motion? Sure. Like to have some public comment? Oh, sorry. Oh, look, there's... Dana, why did you just sit in the front? I just, first of all, thank you for the town to consider submitting comments on something this important. The depot effort has been extremely...
3:44:17 Long time coming and I know that Deanna and her team has put in a lot of effort into this and it's a significant asset that we have in our community. So thank you to the council for your willingness to submit comments for consideration. Also to be advised that MLR is drafting comments as well and we'll be reviewing those at our meeting on Monday the 22nd in order to submit them in time for the
3:44:45 Deadline that the Park Service has put up there. But thank you for your consideration. And we, MLR, has not reviewed your comments collectively as a board, but as an individual, I think they're spot on. And thank you to the team for putting it together. I'll make a motion that Council authorize the Mayor to sign the comment letter on the draft general management plan for double spills file. Second. Further discussion, please. Discussion? Just one point I wanted to make to the Council. I think it's important.
3:45:17 In going through this document, there is significant language in there from the park service about reaching out to the community of Mammoth Lakes. And it happens repeatedly. And I think it's consistent with policy coming out of the Interior Department. And I think it's very important, I think these comments reflect that we're responding to that invitation from the post pilot to be a partner with them. And I think that's something that we should put away somewhere we can build on that.
3:45:46 There could be opportunities for federal funds, grants, other kinds of partnering opportunities going forward, but I think it's very important that we, in these comments, I think we acknowledge that, but I think we acknowledge the partnership is having reached out that way. Agreed. Yeah, agreed. And I think the other part, John, that you forgot to mention is how much the post pile wants to become part of the community and have some kind of year-round presence, even though many of the years we have to tell people, well, sorry, you can't get there right now.
3:46:12 But to that point, they want to establish a presence in the plaza over by the Visitor Center or by Mammoth Lakes Tourism. But that's a great, it's another thing we can add to our... Maybe people can fat bike there. You'll be able to fat bike. Yeah. Well, you just can't get there because you have to go through the forest to get there. Yeah. You want to put a roundabout around here? Okay. It would be exciting. Okay, guys. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
3:46:40 Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us to number 15, which is comments on the NU National Forest Plan revision and wilderness inventory and evaluation. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Same element here in terms of staff working through this, and again, Councilmember Wentworth provided a lot of information, initial draft that we were able to work from. A couple different modifications to this one. We've asked the fire department to comment on the fire management plan. Apparently they got tied up in...
3:47:10 Over by June late in a few days, so they have not been able to get back with us, so at this point we'd recommend it just taking out the comments on that, and then hopefully the fire department may have comments, they would submit them subsequently, but prior to the comment timeline. The other element on this is I believe they've actually done some responsive work of cleaning up part of their website interactions, so we'll need to
3:47:37 Tone down a couple of comments in terms of their website and some of the frustrations we've had in trying to review things for comment. The other elements on this one is we would like to also submit some additional mapping work that is being done. A sample one here showing the town boundaries and some of their wilderness areas and other elements here as those are being completed.
3:48:03 We'd like to have the authority from Council to continue our staff work with John and his team in terms of finalizing the map for submittals. To go with our comment letter, it'll help, I think, pull together a lot of the comments that we're making. The other thing to note that there are two comments in the single letter, one related to the wilderness issue, and that has a different timeline than the actual forest plan revision. There's two different time frames, but we'd be submitting one comment letter that combines our comments on both items together.
3:48:33 So in terms of approving this, we'd want approval in terms of authorizing the mayor to sign a final letter and also authorizing staff and rely on Councilmember Winton's background a little bit on this to finalize up a couple pieces in here related to the mapping and the corrections they've done on their website so that we have a correct letter going out. But that will take a little more finessing to get the final letter out.
3:49:01 But again, the timing is very important. When do you want to get this letter out by? Well, one dates the 22nd and one's either the 27th and 29th. So we'll be wrapping up. John and I are planning on meeting tomorrow to finish up comments. And then we'd obviously have the mayor review those prior to signing. So moved. Wait!
3:49:25 Yes, Dana Stroud. Two things. MLR will also be submitting comments for consideration. The last round of public comments that were submitted, both Town and MLR submitted comments.
3:49:57 We changed in your letter in areas that aren't specifically relative to high level interest, so things like some of the habitat and vegetation management, the comment is made in there that you concur, that the town, we concur with this.
3:50:19 MLR had that in some of our original communication, but we changed that, and we changed it to have no comment on it, and the reason is we didn't have enough expertise in some of those areas to be able to say whether that's good or bad or strong or negative, and so we changed our language, and I don't...
3:50:44 I profess to know that you guys know everything about all the items that are in there as well, but you might want to consider changing that language a little bit, that it's not you're concurring with it, but rather you don't have an opinion on it or you don't have the expertise to comment on it, so as not to line yourself up with something unintentionally in the future.
3:51:05 And so I would just encourage that. And then also as a reminder, for those that are interested, tomorrow night at 6 o'clock at Bishop at the Tri-County Fairgrounds will be the Forest Service public meeting on this plan, revision, and wilderness. If you have an opportunity to be there, I would encourage you to attend. The regional office interdisciplinary planning team will be there. So there will be representatives from Vallejo as well as the
3:51:31 Inyo National Forest Leadership Team and all the planners will be in attendance. And if you have a desire to want to talk a bit more about any of the issues that are in there, I would encourage your participation and attendance if you can make it. And then finally, I appreciate the effort that has gone into the discussion about the wilderness inventory.
3:51:52 As we all remember, in 2008, 2009, when we were going through the original bill, there was a lot of anxiety and some concerns that were expressed, and I think it's really important for the town to be actively engaged right up front on this issue, because I think there's really, through the planning process, there's going to be an opportunity to have a potentially better plan because of the involvement and even the discussion about wilderness.
3:52:19 There will be potentially better opportunities for us down the road. So I appreciate your willingness to, again, engage in this process because it's that important to us. And as we all know, these planned revisions don't come around every year. And we're talking about 27, 26 years ago was the last time. And so it's that important. So thank you for your consideration and for submitting the letters. Okay. Thank you, Dana. Any other public comment? You already made your motion.
3:52:51 I already made my motion, but I want to go back. Now you want to comment. Okay. I just want to comment on, you know, again, Councilman Wentworth, great job putting this together, especially the sustainable recreation and wilderness pieces, very well done. Thanks for taking the time to do it. Oh, my pleasure. You're welcome. Yes? I'll just add two things. The first thing is that
3:53:21 The wilderness thing, it's complex and it's complicated, but I think these comments put the town in a very good position with these maps that Dan's been talking about to make it very clear that we have some concern about that. The second thing, there's an initial recommendation has to do with the idea of the development of a recreation alternative for the management plan for the Forest Service.
3:53:45 That's going to be in the agenda for the ESCOG meeting on Friday. And I know you and I are planning to be there. Maybe if we wanted to get together and talk about that a little bit just so you know what that's going to be. But I think there's going to be a significant opportunity for a public effort to line up a variety of partners to put some support behind that. And we'll be talking more about that in the coming days and weeks and months. Who else is going to be submitting? Comments?
3:54:13 Lots and lots of people. I'll say one thing. Do you want to talk about the Mammoth Trails meeting on Friday? There's a Mammoth Trails meeting on Friday where it's open to all user groups to come and provide and we'll be able to help them navigate kind of a complicated technical process and has been some very significant technical kind of concerns from the Forest Service side. But I would say like the Mammoth, the Fat Bite group that Alan was here a little while ago, they've put together just incredibly thorough, good comments.
3:54:43 Across the entire forest that look at the future opportunities for mountain biking, fat biking. I really need to applaud those kinds of efforts. So I know that at least that party's done an excellent job with this. And I think staff, and now that we've been sharing these comments with Mona County, with Inyo County, with other parties, I think the people who are engaged are benefiting, hopefully, for the kind of work that we've done to try to get kind of a consensus from the region of what really needs to be in this plan. Okay. Done. All right. Roll call vote, please, Jamie.
3:55:14 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. The motion passes 5-0. That takes us to number 16. As if Mr. Wentworth isn't busy enough, a nomination of John Wentworth for consideration to serve on the California Broadband Cooperative Board of Directors. And that is the item.
3:55:35 It's pretty self-explanatory what's going through there. There is no conflict in terms of timing issues, so we're looking just for direction to submit the letter as proposed. Okay. So moved. Second. We have a motion and a second. Yes. Vote or comment. Do you accept the nomination? Yes. We've lost our public. That's right. Roll my vote, please, James. Yes.
3:56:05 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And I presume your previous yes was accepting the nomination. You're late now. All right. Yes. No, we did not break the record. No. We have went to the end. We have gone to. I believe the last meeting was extremely short. I'm not sure if that's dealing with the number of...
3:56:33 Some present companies. Thank you.