Town Council
· recording 3 hr 24 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
436 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:32 Call to order the Town Council regular meeting for Wednesday, October 1st. A roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Michael, would you leave us in the pledge, please? Absolutely. Please rise and join me in place for our flag. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible,
2:04 Thank you, Michael. With that, we move on to public comments for items that are not on this evening's agenda. If anyone has a comment, you're welcome to come forward to the podium. Okay. Seeing none, we will move on to councilmember reports and Colin. Sure. Easy. I don't believe I have anything to report at this time. She is.
2:46 I don't have anything either. All right. John. Good evening, Madam Mayor and fellow Councilmembers. Thank you for the opportunity to provide us a couple of updates here. The first was I attended the Union National Forest Plan revision public meeting, Bishop, Thursday, September 18. Pretty interesting meeting. There were some surprises and some mapping issues, but it was a good opportunity to speak with some of the regional folks, local Forest Service staff, and some
3:15 It was a good opportunity to get a sense of kind of where the Forest Service is at with that process. I want to make sure the public is aware that due to some technical issues, the Forest Service comment site is open until October 3rd, sorry, until midnight Friday, October 3rd, the date had previously been earlier this week, but there was some technical problems with their website, so they're just extending it to the community. So if you haven't got your comments in, now is a good opportunity, a good time
3:46 And then Michael and I attended the ESCOG meeting on regional trash. Sorry, ESCOG meeting, a variety of different issues, a lot of discussions onto very interesting topics, but a good discussion about regional trash, solid waste issues, and also the desire to have someone from the town appointed to the Bono County Investment Board to start talking about this. Good representation from New York County staff, Bono County staff, and trash issues.
4:17 Finally, the final summer stewardship event was this last weekend, which I went to, which is a lot of fun, a lot of good work I've done this summer. And I attended and actually presented the Eastside Know-How Confab, or this that Tenney puts on, that was a really fun event, I had a great time. And Madam Mayor, I believe that there's a funny sound going on here. Yeah, I was just looking back there to Dan. Okay. But I believe that Supervisor-elect Stacy Corliss was going to come in tonight and make a public comment about something.
4:47 I'm wondering if I'm not supposed to have a chance to speak. Oh, okay. So you're right here when I ask you. That's okay. It was John. It was John's microphone. All right. Well, are you done with yours? I'm done. Thank you very much. Okay. Then we'll step backwards a little bit. Stacey. Good evening. Mayor Bacon. Councilmembers, I apologize for missing, it seemed like the fastest public comment period ever. I was talking to people in the parking lot, I admit. Ooh.
5:23 I am Stacey Corliss, Supervisor-Elect from Mono County. Looking forward to working with you all come January. And in the meantime, I am here as a member of the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative Steering Committee, a role I share with my fellow elected officials in the region from Inyo County, Mono County, Town of Mammoth Lakes. Councilmember Wentworth is, of course, a member of the Steering Committee, too. And we're hoping to get the City of Bishop on board as well.
5:52 So I'm here to announce four public meetings that they, I'm going to move to an acronym now, Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative, the ESRC. Add that to the books. ESRC will be hosting four meetings in the coming months in support of the Inyo National Forest Management Plan revision process. The forest plan, as you probably know, was last updated in 1988, over 25 years ago.
6:20 So this is a tremendous opportunity for us as a region to help guide management direction for the INEO for the decades to come. And it also makes sure that we're taking advantage and creating opportunities for our gateway communities here in the Eastern Sierra. So the series of meetings will kick off with a general information meeting on Tuesday, October 14th in Bishop at Cerro Coso Community College.
6:45 And we'll continue with the second meeting on Tuesday, October 28th in Big Pine at the Big Pine Town Hall. And then a third meeting on Thursday, October 30th in June Lake at the June Lake Community Center. The fourth meeting is scheduled for Thursday, November 13th back in Bishop to review and draft a recreation strategy representing the voices of the collaborative and what's come out of the...
7:12 Of all those meetings. All those meetings will be professionally facilitated and are scheduled to begin at 5.30 and end by 8.30 p.m. So the ESRC is a grassroots effort. These meetings are open public forums. All are invited. All are welcome. This is really intended to provide diverse stakeholders, recreationists, business owners, members of our eastern Sierra communities.
7:38 To get an opportunity to develop a regional voice representing the area's recreation economy to help inform local, state, and federal planning and policy efforts. The meetings will focus on identifying key recreation values in preparation for the anticipated November 2014 release of the preliminary alternatives for the International Forest Management Plan revision process. So, for more information, really I'm here to encourage everyone to come to these meetings.
8:07 And for more information, please visit EastSierraRec.org. That URL again is EastSierraRec.org. This collaborative is actively looking for willing partners with email communications capacity to help get the word out. So in other words, groups and individuals focused on recreation who have lists and are willing to help communicate what's going on with ESRC and get people at the meetings.
8:36 So, again, please visit the website, East Sierra Rec, for more information. You can sign up there to get information and to communicate with the steering committee about helping us spread the word. All right. Thank you. Any questions for Stacey? No. All right. Thank you. Thanks. All right. And that was the end of your report, John? Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Now, John, you're on that steering committee just as an individual, not as a council appointment. We didn't... No, I'm not appointed to the council. Emma...
9:06 Talk loud. MLTPA, which is a nonprofit foundation I'm still on the board of, although I'm not a compensated staff person, we're acting as a partner, as I think many other partners, Regents will do, in assisting this collaborative, getting folks these public meetings, acting as a nonprofit sponsor. So I'm not, as a board, pointing to that. Okay, great. Thank you. Michael. Thank you, Madam Mayor.
9:29 I attended our monthly air service group meeting. On our ALP narrative, we're compiling the comments from the air service group. Members expect to deliver a document to FAA in mid-October. On our terminal and aircraft apron, we're currently assessing our likely CEQA-NEPA process in preparation for discussions with FAA. We're planning to set up a town council airport workshop later this year, and hopefully we'll have that with the planning commission as well. I also attended our monthly ESTA meeting.
9:58 A ridership increase for August for Reds Meadows Shuttle was over 20%, so we had a really great growth there. Lakes Basin Trolley was up over 7.5%. We also, as most of you know, operated the Lakes Basin Trolley in September for the first time, and the ridership was very well. We don't have the final members, but we're anticipating over 2,000 passenger trips for that.
10:21 We're looking again for next year to start the trolley down to the basin early and end at the end of September, so extending that service. I also attended our monthly MLT meeting. We're going to be providing our year-end wrap-up at our October 15th council meeting, and the second annual MLT open house will be November 12th from 5.30 to 7.30 at the Forest Service Auditorium. Just a reminder in the discounted air packs, they're going to go on sale around November 1st.
10:48 Six packs and 10 packs again like the last couple years. Price is probably going to be the same as it was. We don't have the firm pricing. And this year, of course, Los Angeles, San Diego, and the new flight to Las Vegas will all be included in that pack. And lastly, Michael Redesma has been appointed to our MLT representative on the MLR board. So that was the appointment. So that's all I have. Okay. Following along in the MLR line,
11:16 Our next meeting is next Monday, 3 o'clock at the library, and we have 12 applicants for the seven open positions, so that's quite a good deal of interest, and the new board will be voted upon and installed on October 27th. No additions to the agenda, correct? So that takes us to reports from commissions or departments. Good evening.
11:56 I have an introduction to make tonight. It's the newest member of the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Officer Robin Henry. Robin was sworn in this morning, so he has all of about 10 hours' experience with us. A little bit about Robin. He was raised in the LA area. He spent 22 years in the golf business as a superintendent and a general manager of different courses in Southern California. I think the police department will be putting together a golf team.
12:25 Robin tells me that he can play both left-handed and right-handed. I'm giving you an advance warning in case you end up playing around with him. He's an 18 left-handed but a 7 right-handed. So he decided a while ago to change careers, put himself through the Butte County, Butte Community College Police Academy. He applied about a year and a half ago when we ended up hiring Jack DeWera, but he also scored very, very well.
12:53 Not wanting to wait, he joined the Susanville Police Department a little over a year ago where they did us all a favor and did a good job of getting him some basic preliminary training. And when we have an opening as a result of the soon-to-be retirement of Luke Schwarzkopf, we've hired him as of today to fill the vacancy that Luke will create when he retires at the end of this month. Robin has a couple of adult children. They live in Southern California. They're 23 and 20 years old.
13:20 It's my pleasure to introduce to the council and to the community, Officer Robin Henry. I just want to thank you, say how special this place is in my heart, having come up here as a young man, backpacking and doing all those things in the area. It's kind of, it's the end of a long journey to end up here as a police officer now and serve the community in the way that I get to now. So thank you. Thank you. Welcome. Evening, Grady Dutton, Public Works. Just a couple of quick construction updates and a couple of other comments.
14:05 On Meridian, we are completing the sidewalks by the end of next week on the 10th. The sidewalk's on the north side, then we'll move on with striping and signage and the rest. The pedestrian ramps on the east side of Old Mammoth Road will be another week or so before we complete that, so the whole project should be wrapped up before the end of October. On Canyon, as you can see, the paving is all done. We have a little bit of concrete, a little bit of retaining wall, and the striping remaining there. We have ordered, lighted...
14:32 Crosswalk signs, warning signs, they aren't the type of thing that go over the street, but they will provide some improvement to what we have. We've boarded them. They should be in about five weeks, and then we'll install them in that crosswalk on the west side. Waterford, we have begun clearing and grubbing out there in the middle of the meadow. It's going very well. The bridge sections themselves are down in Alonso waiting for us. We had to store them that far away. They're sitting on trucks, I think 10 or 11 trucks, in fact.
15:02 We call them, have a place to put them here. They'll be out of their way. A couple of other things. If you didn't see the press release, Tom Hallenbeck, the longtime district director for Caltrans District 9, has moved on to Sacramento. He finally was convinced that that was the right thing to do. For many years he's been trying to stay in this area and done a great service. So he's actually going to be the chief of the Division of Traffic Operations for Caltrans. So he's moved on to Sacramento. His first day there was today.
15:30 So we'll see how Caltrans staff responds to that and some of the changes that they'll be going through. Last week I did attend an MLTS partner meeting. We went through a lot of the detail and data from the website, and I just want to report that the visits on the site itself were up over 84% from last year. And if you'd like an additional detail on that, I can certainly provide it. But the key thing is a lot more usage of this site and a lot more interest in it. Last thing I want to report is that
16:00 A couple that I missed because they happened just when I got here and a couple of others regarding Public Works employee anniversaries. We've had three people, one in July and two actually on Saturday or Sunday of this week who have been with the town for 15 years. Lance Miller, Scott Meredith, and Aaron Willingham all celebrating 15 years with the town. And Jim Haggerty this past summer passed 25 years with the town. And in fact, if you take all the Public Works employees, including...
16:28 Myself as a very short timer and one that's been here less than a year, the average is over 10 years in public works, 26 full-time employees, and that says a lot, I think. Thank you. One more thing, Grady, is could you clarify the ending date for Meridian? The actual, most of the construction work will be done by the end of next week.
16:48 All the striping and signage might take until the end of October, but certainly it's in the next three or four weeks. The contractual date is a little bit longer than that, but working with space construction, he's been able to expedite a bunch of them. Thank you. And did you give us a date for Canyon on the end of that, when it's going to be done?
17:07 With the additional crosswalk, that's about five weeks out, so that will be a little bit longer. The striping and signage, though, will be done in the next two weeks. So it'll look complete, just the things that we added to help fix up that crosswalk, and it'll be a little bit longer.
17:24 Thanks. We've got a quick question also. So with Waterford, is Lohontan, is that stuff all resolved at this point? Yes, we got a permit from them last Friday. They had looked at our mitigation plans and they needed to go through the Army Corps' plan and Fish and Wildlife and everybody else's until they were satisfied. They were and we got the permit last week. So that's good. That's full speed ahead. Absolutely. Thank you.
17:55 Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. I just wanted to remind the council and the public that next Wednesday, October 8th, the Planning and Economic Development Commission will be discussing the floor area ratio study at 10 o'clock here in Suite Z. So that's next Wednesday, October 8th, 10 o'clock here in Suite Z, a discussion of floor area ratio. At 2 o'clock at the regular meeting time, it will be the public hearing for the end of the village. So those are my two items, and I think Jen is going to report on the wood stoves.
18:25 Hi, thank you. I'm Jen Daugherty, Community and Economic Development. Thanks to Council's action in August, the town has brought back our Woodstow Replacement Program. And so this program actually is identical in terms of eligibility requirements and funding as the CAP program, which we had in place earlier this year. With one exception, we have expanded to include a category for new homeowners.
18:53 So for new property owners that have purchased within the last three months and have applied for a building permit as required by code, they're actually eligible to get $500 towards the installation of a pellet or gas appliance. So we didn't have that before. Anyone who's interested should contact the five vendors that we have contracted. Those are Alpine Stoves, Angelos, Clean Sweep, High Country Lumber, and Batchelder. Batchelder does kerosene.
19:23 We have a press release that went out on Monday and a frequently asked question sheet. I have a few copies in the back and it's also on the web. And I guess most importantly, this funding is first come, first serve. So if you are interested or you know anyone who is, I would recommend contacting those vendors immediately and getting on their list because once the funding's gone, it's gone. So thank you very much. Do you have any questions?
19:52 Thank you. Thank you. Any other departments or commissions? Test. We'll just have to have you enunciate and project. It's working now. Okay. Seeing no other ones, we'll move on to the consent agenda. Are there any items anyone would want to poll from the consent agenda? Okay. Then I'll entertain a motion. May I make a motion? Council approve. Items 1 and 2. Second.
20:27 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to a public hearing. The first one our municipality has ever done under some new state legislation. So first I'll open the public hearing and we'll have a report from staff. Thank you, Madam Mayor.
20:57 I'll touch on this, and if you have some of the legal side of it, I'll defer to our town attorney. This is the first time that we've had to do a public hearing under Government Code Section 53083, or we call it AB 562. It came out of the legislative session, effective I think this last January, that basically said if you can do an economic development grant,
21:20 Or a grant to somebody for a purpose of economic development. Are you going to waive revenue? Are you going to lose revenue? There's a number of elements in the law that you have to hold a public hearing for this purpose. And then it lays out a number of findings that need to be made by the town council or the elected body that's giving the abatement. The element that was challenging for us is that the law was structured, I believe, to deal with agencies who go into negotiations with
21:48 A major employer or they wish to attract a Tesla gigabyte factory or something and they want to give up a bunch of money, they want to create jobs, they want to create taxes and it's something that you go and you measure but they also wanted that to happen in a regular public meeting, regular scheduled meeting, public hearing about it so people were aware of what was happening.
22:10 In reviewing it in our proposal that was being worked on to provide funding for Mammoth Lakes Recreation, this will also apply to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the whole discussion element had a lot of items related to enhancing the economics of the town. It's improving our economic base, we're inviting people, we're adding amenities, it's economic benefit.
22:32 So we believe it falls underneath the requirements of the code. The distinctive is we didn't sit there and say we're going to give X dollars here so we can create 42 and a half new jobs. Six of them will be part-time, the rest are full-time. We don't have that type of metric with this type of economic benefit. So we did not fit cleanly, I think, in what the intent of the legislature was, but the way it was drafted, here we are.
22:57 So the element we do meet, I think, is the whole idea of the transparency issue, of having additional comments that public can make regarding the potential allocation of funding for these purposes. So the public hearing identifies the element for us for providing funding to MLR. That will be an item later on your agenda as well. Walks through the dollar amounts over the three-year, not quite, about a two-and-a-half-year period actually at this point.
23:25 The other element identified in the past, a portion of that funds had gone to support town activities, about $60,000 a year. Some of that element is still elements that we would still be doing a little bit in some of the accounting work, but a lot of the work actually would go to MLRs. They'd be taken on the duties, but in one sense we've shifted that other work into the town's general fund.
23:50 We need to highlight that, but again, there's a duty shift there as well as the financial questions that come up. The legislation highlights six different areas where we have to provide a response. That is in your staff report. I'm not going to read each one of those to you. If there's a question on one of them, we can address them. But the items begin to talk about who it is, job creation, the dollar amount.
24:15 Those types of elements that walks through each of those. We've tried to provide an overview and at least information, but again, I cannot tell you and I don't think we will know how many jobs this will actually create because it's a community-based economic support structure we're putting in place. So it tries to touch on a number of those elements in here.
24:39 That's kind of a really brief overview. If we need more detail, I'll defer to town attorney if we need to walk through some of these and call out the various elements, we can do that. But let me pause for a moment and ask us if there's any questions from the council and then ultimately we'll ask you to take public comment on the items. If we need to clarify any of them in detail, we will do that as well. Again, what we'll be asking is that take the public comments, make any tweaks to the findings and accepting those and allowing us to move forward then.
25:08 To consider a contract later on the agenda. So with that all pause, I'll defer to Andy if he wants to add something and then anything else that the council may have. Okay. At this point, are there any questions of staff or council? Yeah, one quick clarification on item three. I was a little unsure. When you're talking about the town foregoing an estimated 180,000 administrative funds, is that
25:35 What it used to be is $60,000 a year, so presumably there will be a reduction in that amount of work for town staff? Or is that what you're estimating it will be moving forward with a reduced workload? Historically, we've used about $60,000 administrative funds from R&U, and that offsets some work in finance, it offsets work in recreation, and a couple other areas.
26:00 You'll have two different things. Some of that work will still need to happen. We are still going to account for our new money when it comes in and those elements. The recreation department will not be managing the our new application process and going through all of that element. So there's a piece of that work that we will still do. The other side of that is we have not forgone any costs. We haven't laid off a third of a position because of this. The general fund has absorbed those positions and, frankly, there's plenty of work to do.
26:29 In their areas responsibilities without this additional cost. Sure. So in a sense, yes, we are forgoing an estimated $60,000 a year in revenue to the general fund. We are putting it over here for economic development related purposes and others. That work moves with it as it should a portion of its days. So there is a loss and that's why we have to highlight it. Just trying to figure, you know, you read the legislation, it's one of the areas you need to define.
26:58 It doesn't really care if you lose the work or not. Do you lose the revenue? Actually, there is one thing I'd like to add just to clarify. The council's not actually required to make any finance. We don't have a resolution for you. We don't have any form of approval. We don't even really need a motion other than just closing the public hearing. The legislation says you have to hold a hearing. That's all it says. Any other questions for council or staff? And at this time, I will call for testimony from anyone in the public who wishes to speak on this issue.
27:39 I don't see anyone moving. So at that point, I will close the public hearing. And then it says, so even though it says we're going to deliberate and arrive at a decision. Yeah, my preference would be just to accept the report and move on. To accept the report. Yeah. That way we have a record that we get it.
28:02 Okay. I would just compliment Dan and Andy for offering the explanation to the public. This is kind of a square, peg-in-a-round hole kind of a situation, and I think we all are sort of aware of that, but thanks for your explanation and making sure the public understand what it is we're doing here, so thank you. Any other comments? Anyone would like to make a motion to accept the... Accept the information. Accept the information. I'll make the motion to accept the information.
28:35 I'll second that one. I think you guys are wearing out the switches. Leave them on. We have a motion and a second. Could we have a roll call, though, please, Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Next, we go into our policy matters, and the first would be approval of the proclamation.
29:04 Regarding Declaration of October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and is there anyone here from Wild Iris? There you are. Did you want to make any kind of introductory statement? I just wanted to thank the council for approving this proclamation of October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. I know that domestic violence has been out in the media a lot lately in the past couple of weeks, especially with everything that's going on in the NFL.
29:35 And we at Wild Iris are thrilled to take this month to allow the community to ask questions and to answer those questions about domestic violence. So we will be putting forth a video series this October answering questions from the community. We have a lot of questions that have come from our local high school students, which is very exciting. And those videos can be found on our website and on all of our social media.
30:03 Wild Iris has been very busy this year. In the 2013-2014 fiscal year, we had 369 domestic violence clients that we have been working with, and 50 of those were children. We spent 2,466 hours peer counseling with victims of domestic violence.
30:32 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
31:00 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0 and miracles of technology. You know what the bad arm in there.
31:41 Thank you. I hit the bad arm, yes. That moves us to policy matter number five, which is to approve the agreement with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Dan?
32:24 So I apologize for that, but it's not by others and correct me. The other element we have, I didn't have a couple of comments related to the forest service you have there. In touch on those, before I do that, I want to thank Rick Wood, Betsy Tuax, and John Armstrong, who was serving with the Division of the Division of the Division of the Division of the Division. He actually, I think, had a very smooth process, really back and forth. He came to, I think, a
32:54 The agreement really is close to us, how do we identify a couple different areas. One is, what is the long-term goal for MLR in the first sector? We'll see that explained in specific A. That's an area we'll see in a lot of changes down the road that happens. We're charged, of course, to keep in mind, we'll work in the end of the gradation to the project that can be established.
33:19 Secondly, I think we've really tried to work hard to a realistic set of deliverance for the remainder of the current district. The goal is that a three-year meeting, in fact, about 32 months, started with the first investment district for 200 years. And then Exhibit C walked through just to detail the payment.
33:42 The body of the agreement pretty much mirrors our standard professional services agreement. There's a couple of things in there. I'm trying to review through that. The goal that we've had is we have a standard agreement to try to legalize that in all of our agreements, but it's not illegal to have public things based on details of each agreement.
34:04 The agreement does set forth an eight-month plan, an estimated $300,000 per year. This was predicated upon a base budget proposed at MLR-Lynchford. I think it's a very close to the budget protections. The structure is set up for $25,000 per month. We can start paying that November 1st to allow cash flow to roll in and be able to move the organization forward.
34:31 They can additionally raise some money and continue to raise their own funds and it will be on top of a commission too, whatever time is provided to us. The funding here is coming from Major R and ties into the expenditure plan. A concept of council actually refers to the expenditure plan 2.0.
34:53 They will be tasked in a number of areas in the Rock City City, and I won't talk to all that detail and ask those questions on it. We'll have it in a couple of seconds. The 300,000 of major art also means that there are other works that they'll do, so if not, major art-related, that they're open up and able to see other forms related, raised up, and for later on the chip, the start of the town.
35:20 I think that the need of the contract, from my perspective, goes into the item B, which really starts to lay out the deliverables. We did a lot of work trying to initially start hearing a lot. Actually, there's a lot more detail here. And to all agree that that's probably not realistic. We're actually going to start an organization in short time frame.
35:43 And so we tried to narrow it down and put some deadlines and dates in there for the people to come, both in the town, the NLR, and what's happening. And then do you also make the bills? And so that was really the goal that we made that exhibit. In that exhibit, one of the partners in all of this that we worked with is the Forest Service. And they had asked for a couple modifications in there.
36:13 I did hand out a copy to the Council. I did hand out a copy to the Council. I did hand out a copy to the Council. I did hand out a copy to the Council. I did hand out a copy to the Council. I did hand out a copy to the Council. I did hand out a copy to the Council.
36:40 And also a question came up in working with a $300,000 allocation to the panelist's trail system where the question was, are we just handing over $300,000 to the review for everybody? We have not done that traditionally after the contract comes to that, but ultimately they're making the recommendation of how it's been that, and the practice counts is that those factors on the position. And so we've verified that we're directly doing the process. The other just to clean up in the...
37:11 Put down that bullet point, talking about projects under MLR, being initiated. Again, those are projects that Council have to do. We'll get a reminder in terms of the process in place for our offices, our reputation to come to Council to get back out.
37:35 Other area that may be a concern is that it's a discussion with the website where the main thing here is the action of that process, whether it's a plan possible or potential transfer open to MMR. In terms of the Forest Service, by the way, this one that came up was we have a reinstalled MOU for the Forest Service website.
38:00 So we have a planned one in there. Given the depth of the agreement, given the expectations that are out there to come back in the day, it's actually
38:29 From my perspective, you've got about three or four items that I think are discussion points. I would call that a successful negotiation process and a lot of those who have to do that as well. A broader policy question, obviously, is the overall funding structure. With that, I would be glad to address any specific questions that Council may have or if there's some of the body of the agreement, if there's something that we will expect it over to Andy.
38:57 But if not, I'll comment on it, and we'll be glad you guys have any questions at some point. Should we start? Are there any questions of staff at this point? From Council? From Council. Of staff. Actually, I'd like a little clarification. When was this current version with the changed wording provided to the MLR contract ad hoc?
39:25 We just had that today, so we'll just have it to see. Okay. The other small, minor comments were made actually came from that group, so. Okay, then I would ask if anyone from that group or from MLR would like to speak to whether or not you're okay with these suggested changes since thereafter MLR approved the contract. We are, Madam Mayor, Rick Wood. There are two good comments that I have. One is...
39:54 For the most part, they're not substantive. And second and importantly, the transition board recognizes that MLR, the town, and the United States Forest Service will effectively become partners in this recreation process. And to the extent that the Forest Service had the opportunity, as they were given, to comment on the agreement and suggested a couple of changes, which
40:23 Modify the agreement, but really only slightly. I don't think that they, and I've spoken with other, the two other ad hoc committee members, we don't think that those comments that they've made or requested changes will change either the intent of the agreement, it will not impede our ability to go forward in the manner that the agreement suggests we will, the deliverables can be accomplished, and it provides an opportunity to develop and
40:51 Maintain and then build the relationship of Forest Service. So we're fine. Thank you, Brad. Okay. With that clarification, I will just open up for any public comment on this matter. Good evening, Council. My name is Pat Agnich, and I'd like to start off by commending the interim MLR board. I know they've worked really hard and long, and they've pounded out through a lot of the issues and challenges that
41:29 I guess I just have a couple questions and a couple comments. I guess I'm wondering about the sequencing because the permanent board has not been established yet in signing the agreement and I'm sure that will all be worked out within a timely manner. But I do have a couple of concerns with respect to some of the terms of the agreement. Yes, it is a fairly boilerplate agreement.
41:58 I thought it was very comprehensive, which would complement both parties to that end. But some of the earlier drafts of the agreement had a 30-day termination date. And in my experience with government and municipal contracts, a 30-day termination date seems to be pretty standard. So I'm not quite sure why it became 90 days.
42:28 I think it might be prudent for the council to give that consideration. Also, it's a three-year agreement. And I know that the Mammoth Lakes Tourism has been kind of the model for this group to kind of follow. And I wouldn't recommend that you go to a monthly kind of agreement like MLT began with.
42:52 But I wonder why it's a three-year agreement, because that totals approximately $815,000, which I think was listed in the staff report. And it's a little bit of a leap of faith that this group is really going to perform and meet for deliverables. I would suggest, in the best interest perhaps of the community and the town, that you look at a one-year agreement with two one-year extensions.
43:23 Which ultimately becomes a three-year agreement. But it does give you milestones for deliverables to be looked at and commented on before keeping an extension. And I don't think a town manager has an agreement like this for three years. Although I'm sorry. I saw on the agenda in the first session that they're going to be talking about you.
43:53 And then some of the deliverables are good, and I know that it's not that long of a period for the first set of deliverables. But I think they could be a little tighter. For example, applying for a grant within a year. You know, that's just asking for them to apply for a grant. It doesn't have any expectations that there's going to be money coming back in.
44:22 I think anyone probably in this room could apply for grant and meet that fulfillment or that terms of the agreement. And there are a couple of others, but I'm sure the group will work it out, and I'm sure Town Council will be looking closely to make sure that the deliverables are met. So if you could just look at the duration of the agreement and perhaps some of the other terms, the determination of that would be appreciated. All right. Thank you, Pat.
44:51 Is there anyone else you'd like to speak? Good evening, Councilmembers. Betsy Truax. I just wanted to say what a real pleasure it was negotiating this agreement. Dan was really fantastic. I feel like both sides really negotiated in good faith. I think this contract is really a win for the town and for MLR. And I'd also compliment Andy for his prompt legal review of the document. If I could just speak briefly to a couple of Pat's concerns.
45:29 One of the reasons that the agreement has the 90-day termination clause is MLR does plan to recruit for an executive director position, and there was some concern, which was also expressed by John Erdi, who moved here as the MLT director, that a 90-day termination would definitely help us to attract the best possible talent. Also, the agreement is really more like 30 months.
45:56 It's not quite a full three-year term. And again, that's to help us to attract the best possible talent to the organization. And you'll note that the deliverables in Exhibit B are for fiscal year 14-15. So we'll expect that MLR would deliver on those and then negotiate deliverables throughout the rest of the term of the contract. Yeah, that's it. Then the other thing I just wanted to speak to briefly was that earlier in the day,
46:23 Someone had asked me about number three in Exhibit B, which is MLR preparing and providing to the town a prioritized list of the primary amenities recommended to be supported through measures U and our funds by December of 2015. And I just wanted to comment that that, of course, would be a public process because the MLR board is a public...
46:44 Brown Act body. And so certainly members of the public will be able to weigh in on that. Also as chair of the recreation commission, I expect that the commission will be actively engaged in that process too. Thank you. Thanks Betsy. Any questions about you? Thank you Betsy. Terry Stelick. I just wanted to kind of clear up some misinformation that was just given by the Zavage. Manplace Tourism actually started out with a three-year contract and with the town
47:21 Possibly going into bankruptcy. All contracts at that point in time to enter bankruptcy were null and void. And so at that point in time, their contract started, it became month to month. And so I was involved in the recruitment process for a director for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And I will tell you with a one-year contract, we would have never attracted the caliber that we have had in Mammoth Lakes Tourism to director John Urdi.
47:50 I'm pretty comfortable with that. Thank you, Terry. Anyone else wishing to speak? I just want to reiterate that this could have been a very difficult process, and Dan made it not so. And I appreciate that. Second, this town is really fortunate to have the caliber of talent on that interim or transition board that we have.
48:23 Joe, you know that. You serve on that board. I've served on a few boards. This is a good one. Those who are leaving, I'm going to miss. But there are, as I understand it, 11 applicants for the seats, and I'm sure that those who follow in the footsteps, John Armstrong and Betsy and John Urdi, will do well. It has been said before, I think, probably,
48:50 John said that the approval of MLR was historic. It is. What isn't historic and what is supported by precedent is the granting of an NGO, in this instance, MLR, the opportunity to succeed. You do that by entering into, that is, agreeing to have the town manager enter into this agreement.
49:17 It is true that it's nearly three years. It's really only a 90-day deal because it can be terminated without cause within 90 days. And I just want to say that I appreciate in the event this council is going to vote for it, as I hope it will, the confidence that it will instill in the current board and the new board, which will take office at the end of October. Thank you, Rick. Anyone else?
49:51 Okay, I will bring it back to Council. What's our pleasure? And we have just a couple comments. One, for the public's sake, I just want some clarity that folks understand that the formation of MLR is a recommended body to Council, and that Council still ultimately has the A&A, the change, the what have you, because there's a lot of confusion.
50:22 of really what the formation, where the ultimate decisions lie, and maybe you can touch on that. Secondly, transparency is big. I've been stating all along I've been concerned with the overhead cost, the operating cost of the organization. I'm very supportive of the concept and in whole.
50:51 I'd like to, on the deliverables if we could, I'd like to possibly add an eighth item to request a quarterly accounting reporting to council in some fashion and maybe we can start that as soon as March of next year if we can get a consensus on that. So I'm just concerned about accountability and transparency and just concerned for public's sake that some of these questions are clear and
51:22 If you could help me with those questions, that's great. Yeah, in terms of the awarding of funding, the way the ballot measures read and were approved, there needs to be a public body that hears those items that make information to you, and they bring a recommendation of expenditures to the council, which then you approve. So that process doesn't change. That's part of the law that the voters basically approved and put in place.
51:50 MLR, the recommendation is to designate them as that public body that will hear those comments. Their recommendations for funding will come to this council for approval, acceptance, rejection, modification as you see fit to the expenditure of those funds. Then depending how those projects are structured, they will help with implementation. If it's a town capital project, we will work through that. If it's a...
52:16 Partnership Project with MLR and the Forest Service or whatever that may be. Right now, the same element. They're already appointed as the Major U hearing body. So the same process you saw in that, you come in and here's a recommendation for $30,000 to support Jazz Jubilee. That would go through that process. It would come to you and they would have a recommendation of X based on the request coming forward and then you would have that opportunity to be that approval body.
52:45 You have that public meeting, that public focus, and then you actually have the council action accordingly. So I think there's plenty of the transparency element I think will be there. It's structured that way. As far as a quarterly reporting, I did not stick something in the contract initially on purpose because I figured they're going to be here on a regular basis letting you know what's happening and you have a council member who sits on that. But if it's the council's pleasure to write, you know,
53:14 Yeah, we want a formalized quarterly report. I'll have to look to the folks out there in MLR. I don't think they have a problem doing that. And starting in March would actually be good for the next year. So that gives us a couple of months to get settled, maybe hire somebody than January, February, March. Something would come forward at that point and they could give you an update and walk through those elements. There's a month of reporting back in terms of expenditures through the
53:40 Mechanism we have for the funding so we know where the dollars are going and some oversight at the staff level for that. But that's a council question. If you wish to have that quarter reporting, I'm not opposed to that and I'll assume that MLR will not be opposed to make reports. I see a head nodding yes, so if that's something the council wants, that simple to add. Okay. Is that something council?
54:03 Well, and when I'm looking at it, I think it's actually going to be more than quarterly because there's another report no later than December. The more the better. The more the better. Yeah. Well, and I think it's important that we look at this. One of our priorities is the Synergy Summit opportunity. And I think when we're talking about reporting from these NGOs, from these partners we have, I think that we can, the contract is written in such a way, and I've reviewed it with this in mind.
54:29 That we can look at how MLT reports, how MLR reports, how MLH reports, and start getting it standardized in such a way that it becomes easy, transparent for us to review, because I think your first question, we have the authority for the funding for what is going to be going on. So that we want to get things in a nice, clear, concise way, but also fundamentally for the public. So the public can have documents on deliverables, reporting, that they can see it, it's easy to read, it's easy to digest.
54:58 I think that's an opportunity going forward that we should look at. And I wouldn't do anything with MLR yet. I would look at how we line this up with MLT and MLH so that it gets standardized. It's not each one is a little bit different. It becomes kind of a standardized process. Well, I will along, though, with at least quarterly. Sure, it's fine.
55:17 Yeah, I have a number of comments, but to address that directly, that's one of the things I had written down, is I would like to see that added into the deliverables at least quarterly. I think the more the better. But I think that's a lesson we've learned as we're starting to create some of these NGOs, that the public desires to have that transparency, and that's been a good thing. And I think MLT has made a lot of strides in that kind of retroactively. So if we can set MLR up that way from the get-go.
55:45 I think that's going to be a good thing. So I would support having at least quarterly into the contract. Can I ask a question on Exhibit C? Are fiscal years July to June? July 1, June 30. Okay. I see here that by November 15th they're going to give an accounting, if you will, an annual accounting.
56:16 Is there a reason it takes so long? Assuming the town runs a 90-day accrual period, so you have usually July, August, and September, and then you're doing a month of cleanup. We actually don't get the final measure of our money, for example, until September through sales tax numbers and those elements. So the goal there was to try to tie that into where we would be working through with the town auditing process versus having something separate coming in and then maybe even having to change it based on what the town audit would be because of that.
56:46 Will our new super-duper accounting system? It won't change the deadlines. Okay. A little more real time. It should make it smoother. If I can speak to that as the treasurer of MLR at the moment, that is in line. The bylaws, MLR is set up with the same fiscal year and the same reporting because that's also the date that any IRS forms are due so that annual reporting, I think it will be sooner than that, but that's normal, three and a half months after the close of your fiscal year.
57:15 Thank you. Shields, I just want to follow up on what you're saying about integrating this reporting into new systems that are coming online. We've got a lot of opportunities here, and I think, to call on your point about quarterly reporting is fine. I would just want to add, let's get MLT in that, MLH in this also, so we really get this stuff standardized so that it's all the same. It's the best use of everybody's time. We do things efficiently. So B on Exhibit C does talk about reporting by the 15th of each month on the prior month's expenditures.
57:45 Sure. Yep. Which would be done by the firm that NMR has hired. Right. It's outside of the talent system. No, understood. And I think that, but again, from a financial perspective, so that we're getting these documents back from these various NGOs, they're standardized, they look the same. It's like people can actually do the analysis, they're not spending all the time trying to read the document, figure out what it says. And I think that's in everybody's interest to do that.
58:11 While we're on Exhibit C, I did have a question, maybe Dan or Joe, you could clarify this a little bit. Exhibit C, Section C, MLR may carry over not more than 15% of the total payments from one fiscal year to the next. If there is an excess, it basically requires town approval prior to the end of the fiscal year. I just want to make sure that's something that...
58:36 Can I get some rationale for that or make sure the council is comfortable with that? Let me speak to that. The issue comes in and part of this came up through the reconciliation work. We have a project going here and you close it, you not move any money forward. As you're dealing with the NGO element, if you go to the end of the fiscal year and say you have to drain your account so you have no money really starting that next month, we know that expenditures aren't smooth throughout the year.
59:02 And so to have some level of carryover, if you want to call that a contingency or a way to make sure you don't run into financial challenges of making payrolls, so to speak, or something, the idea there was to allow some level of a carryover, but also not to allow it to be utilized as a let's set aside a whole bunch of money and we'll figure out what we do in the future. So it's kind of a negotiated back and forth of this is just under two months operating revenue, so I don't think it's excessive.
59:31 But it also gives a little cushion in terms of the expenditure plan and work that an organization would be going through. Sorry. Go ahead. Well, I just, I think that there's a couple things here. The first thing is that because the fiscal year of the town is in, you know, June, July, so we're doing summer projects, construction, there's all kinds of challenges around that, but I think with this kind of a carrier where those things could be resolved.
59:56 I think also the fact, say, with the foundation, the work on the Performing Arts Center, and say it's heading down a track and it's getting ready to maybe come forward to MLR, but, oh, donors come forward, maybe they want to go for a bricks and mortar type of a building as opposed to a tent. So the project then, you know, they're not ready to come to MLR yet to have it vetted and start moving forward. So it's going to be important to understand that the money, the Measure U money that may be applicable or appropriate for that, would stay in the town's accounting.
1:00:23 And it would stay on the town side. So when you're looking at what MLR has to work with and what they're doing, the money that's going in here that we would approve and appropriate is in actionable projects, things that are happening. But there may be reserves that may be accruing because the MLR board may be saying, look, we're looking for the right opportunity on something. So like the balance of the funds, it's going to involve town staff, town accounts, money that's being held, and also looking at what MLR is saying. So it's different than MLT where they get a percentage.
1:00:53 Of TOT, and they hold their own reserves. Right. In this case, the reserves and the excess RNU or the MLTS 300,000 allocation are staying in the town. Gotcha. But still, the recommendation is coming from MLR that now it's time to build whatever. Sure, and so if we have money earmarked for a particular project that's going to cost more than that, that's fine. Sure.
1:01:16 Okay. And this is your carryover is just tied to this $300,000. Right. That was my second question. It's simply the $25,000 a month. Gotcha. Right. Okay. It's very cash flow capability. Okay. All right. Thanks for clarifying that. It kind of ensures that the money is being used in the things that are happening. Sure. Sure. Do you have more? I do, if now is an appropriate time. Okay.
1:01:44 So I did have an opportunity to sit down with the Forest Service to discuss the contract. I also want to thank Dan and the members of the contract committee. This is a really fantastic document that you put forth. It's really easy for us to work with. I would just like to say I think that I really appreciate your comments, Rick. I think, you know, the things that they're asking here are not major changes. It's not going to inhibit MLR's ability to be successful.
1:02:14 So I would like to see how the rest of the council feels about just making those small tweaks because it was something that was specifically asked by the Forest Service to make them more comfortable and I think we should do that in the interest of a good partnership. Yeah, I would agree. I also met with the Forest Service and I just had another quick question for Dan. Are any of their other issues? Have they been taken care of? Is there anything outstanding other than here? No, we actually had a good dialogue with them just in terms of the purpose and scope and
1:02:43 They were actually very complimentary as well to the work, I think, and their goal is to, frankly, see MLR in the town be successful. They would like to have about another million or so dollars raised every year for trail maintenance, so they can put that on their deliverable list for later. But to be able to come through that, we walked through a couple other issues and just explanations, and I think they're optimistically looking forward to the relationship.
1:03:09 Improving and growing and doing some good things for our community. I felt good about the discussion. I thought the requests were very reasonable. I mean, to look through this entire document and have a couple of kind of minute changes I thought was very reasonable. And, Michael, you kind of touched on some of the things they just wanted clarification on. They wanted to make sure that
1:03:30 You know, council kind of held some of the control of the allocation, and that would just be a recommending body, and so a couple of language things were around that. So I think we're all on the same page, and, you know, I appreciate all the work that's gone into this, but I would like to suggest that we make those few small changes as long as everyone else is okay with that. More, Colin? Yeah, I got more. Keep going. Okay.
1:04:01 You know, I just wanted to maybe just have a general discussion on the dais about some of the comments that Pat brought up. I thought, you know, they're all things that are worthy of us discussing. You know, I think for me, just going through those couple of things, I think the deliverables, you know, apply for a minimum of one grant.
1:04:24 I understand that maybe we should be hoping for more than that, but I think we're trying to put some minimums and some deliverables here, so I'm pretty comfortable with that. I think I am supportive of doing a three-year agreement. I want to see this organization be successful, and I think we need to give it some time to get its feet under it. So I think a three-year agreement is reasonable, and I do agree with the statements that that is going to be important to enticing the right director. I guess...
1:04:53 You know, the 30-day versus 90-day termination, that would be the one that I think I might be more willing to move, depending on how the rest of the council feels. I'm fine with it staying at 90 days, but I'd be okay with discussing moving that as well. I think the only insight I would offer that is I've been to many of these MLR meetings, and I'm confident that every idea of any significance in this contract has been well vetted and well gone over by a lot of people.
1:05:24 And so I don't, I appreciate someone bringing this point up, but I appreciate also that there's rationale behind why it's 90, why it's three years and all the rest of it. And I've been into discussions and I think it's, you know, I think it's. And as somebody that was very much involved from the beginning, you know, I certainly trust that this has been vetted. I just haven't been around for kind of the fruition of some of these more detailed contract points.
1:05:50 So I'm certainly comfortable with where they're at. I just thought it was worthy of discussion. Sure. Yeah, if I can comment, in previous council we went through severance and the severance packages and I'm very much not supportive of big severance packages. I'll just say it like it is. So
1:06:17 I would be in favor of split the difference on that and, you know, go to a 60-day versus a 90 just to save a little severance, just a little money. Well, it's not really severance. I know it's not severance, but, I mean, when you tie it to a director and you're looking at it that way, it really, it's kind of tied to, you know, a 90-day pay. But either way, it's not.
1:06:44 It's not a game changer. It's not a big deal to me either way. I just thought it was more of a discussion. I think Rick said it right. It's not a three-year contract. It's a 90-day contract. So I'm fine with that. And I think to entice, I think Betsy brought up a good point. To entice the right person, he's got to be able to sit here for three months and try and figure this thing out. Okay.
1:07:12 And I'll say one more thing is that, you know, we've, yes, this has been a long process. Thank you to everyone for their involvement as we've gone along. But the reality is winding it down and transferring certain things back to the town, I think will take that 90 days if it should ever happen. Fair enough. All right. I'm happy to fall in line there. I just wanted to bring it up.
1:07:32 And, you know, last thing I wanted to say, just, I spent a lot of time focusing on Exhibit A, which is the scope of services. I'm very excited about MLR. I think it's going to be a really good thing for our community. And I think Exhibit A does a really, really good job of encompassing what this organization should be doing. I'm, you know, especially excited about Items 1 and Items 4.
1:08:00 I think those are the things that really align most with what I'm interested in seeing the group do. But I just, you know, I think this is a really well done document and it's exciting reading through that and seeing what this group can do. Madam Mayor, if... Sure, I'm sorry. No, I agree with everything. I echo Colin's point about Exhibit A. I hope everybody...
1:08:32 And the public gets a chance to read it if they haven't because it does, you know, very succinctly line out what the scope of deliverables are and services are for MLR. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'd like to make a motion.
1:08:51 That the council approve the services agreement between the town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Recreation, MLR, authorize the town manager to sign the agreement to amend the fiscal year 14-15 budget allocating $200,000 in measure of funds per the agreement with the specific track changes to exhibit C, I believe, as presented, exhibit B, I'm sorry, to exhibit B as presented by staff. Would you include adding in that quarterly report?
1:09:21 At least quarterly. At least quarterly reporting. Yeah. I'll second that motion. We have a motion and a second. We'll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Just to clarify, because I'm not sure I heard it. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:09:57 Thank you all. Thank you to everyone who's worked on this. Next we go on to item number six, which is interim funding. Yes, Madam Mayor, this item is for you. It's a request for interim funding from Mammoth Lakes Recreation. It's an amount of $15,000. The reason this is coming up is, one, brand new organization. We're asking them to go forward and do a lot of things that need to be done to be up and running.
1:10:28 They've raised a little bit of funding to help offset this, but the real focus is on getting up and going. The other side of that is some of the work in the contract and some of the work that they'll need to undertake, again, probably exceeds their steps outside of the Measure R funding that is the primary funding source for the agreement. This would allow them to focus on those other elements.
1:10:52 Probably the primary example would be working on the Performing Arts Center with the college and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, which is most likely more of a Measure U type project. So we have no Measure U admin money going here, so there's dollars there to say go work on that project in partnership with the college and the foundation and others. There's other items that will need to be undertaken that, again, don't fall into the Measure R category.
1:11:19 And this provides some of that flexibility so that we're not stifling the organization going forward. It also gives them a chance to step out in the community and actually raise some funding as well, which they've already initiated. So from that element, in order to, again, kind of tie them back to the kickoff, man, it's successful. That's the reason for this request coming forward. Funding is recommended to come out of the town's contingency account, which is a
1:11:46 Just under $25,000, so this would be $15,000 of that going into this purpose. Resolution calls that out. We would be getting a separate accounting of how they're spending the funding in that area. So with that, unless there's particular questions, I'd be glad to address those or add additional information. Dan, I have a quick question. When MLR is up and going and their fundings end, is this...
1:12:10 15,000 come back to the contingency account? No. I've not asked for it to pay it back, but it's a one-shot. It's not an ongoing funding, and I could be no expectation of it in the future necessarily, but we've not structured as a grant. It would actually be an allocation for these purposes. Thank you. Michael, if I can add a little bit to that. Number four on Exhibit B, where it talks about meeting with the people who are going to measure you, it's probably going to go mostly for that. Got it.
1:12:36 And if there's another one where we as a council direct them in the future to do something that's a potential for Measure U funding, then there's going to have to be some discussion about how you fund that. Because the one piece, if you remember when we went through funding scenario 2.0, about the only way to make it work was that no Measure U money goes to... So it is a part or not a part of the 32-month? It's a part of that. Well, actually, it's sooner than that. It just would go as of...
1:13:06 Today, if it's approved. So it's one extra month, if you will. But it's one shot, one time funding. And my anticipation, it'll be expended within its current fiscal year, frankly, given the workload that MLR will be undertaking. All right, thank you. Okay, any other questions of staff? If not, I'll open it for public comment. Seeing none, bring it back for discussion, deliberation, or a motion.
1:13:42 If no other comments, I'd be happy to make a motion. Make a motion to approve a resolution authorizing interim funding in the amount of $15,000 from the town of Mammoth Lakes to Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I'll second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
1:14:07 We move on to the final MLR-related policy item, number seven, about appointing MLR to serve as the Measure R recommending body. Yes, Madam Mayor. As you are aware, as mentioned earlier, the ordinances that were adopted by the voters for this requires that you have a public committee, commission, or body that reviews recommendations before they come to you and then make a recommendation accordingly to the town council.
1:14:37 We've modified the expenditure plan and the ordinance to allow for you to appoint a body to serve in this capacity under Measure R. The original language I think called out the Recreation and Tourism Commission, so that's been modified here. And because the modification allows you to do it by resolution, that's what's before you. It was a change in the ordinance. The ordinance will actually be effective, I think it's October 17th, so this resolution is set up to take effect.
1:15:07 Following at the Fridays to take effect of following Monday on the 20th. But it would then put MLR in that position and serving as that recommending body, taking public comment and then bringing items forward to the council for consideration. Okay. Any questions again? All right. I'll ask if there's any public comment. Tim, are you going to comment or you're just changing seats? Okay. All right. And then public comment.
1:15:40 I'll bring it back for discussion or a motion. I would just, for all these items, I think that it's very important to perhaps share the observations I've had of how this is all starting to work. I'm starting to see a town staff that is actively and bringing all their skills to engage with a challenging
1:16:10 I'm seeing new relationships with the Forest Service. I'm seeing them starting to engage in a program that is going to benefit everybody. And I think it's something that's going to be benefiting the community in a big way in the long run. And I think it's important that the roles and responsibilities are starting to take shape. The authority of the town with its relationship with the Forest Service, the role that an entrepreneurial NGO can play.
1:16:35 To benefit and leverage public funds to get us where we want to go. I think all these things are really starting to grow and it's starting to take on the kind of life that I think we all wanted to do, which ties into the opportunities with MLT and all the rest of these things. So I'm just very encouraged by all the work that's going on. Encouraged enough to make a motion? Yes, ma'am. I will make a motion. My abbreviating will come to an end.
1:17:00 And I would make a motion to approve the resolution designating the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Recreation as the committee to perform the duties provided for in Section 3.44.48.150 Expenditure Plan of the Town Municipal Code. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That moves us on to policy item number 8.
1:17:31 Consider rescinding the CBIS policy. Thank you, Mayor Bacon. On August 6th, the council determined that the Inn at the Village project was not subject to the community benefits and incentive zoning or CBIS policy. At that meeting, the council also requested that staff bring back the CBIS policy for council to consider the possible rescinding of that policy.
1:17:58 For some background, CBiz was adopted by the Council in 2009 as a tool to evaluate legislative projects, projects that come before Council requesting modifications to development standards, and to evaluate lodging projects in the commercial zone proposing to exceed 40 rooms per acre. The CBiz policy requires applicants to submit financial information to allow for an assessment of the value of the benefits being proposed by the project,
1:18:27 In comparison to the incentives being requested by the project. CBIS was intended to serve as a bridge framework document until community planning documents like district planning, the trail system master plan, the parks and rec master plan were completed. In the five years since the CBIS adoption, these community planning documents have been completed.
1:18:50 And for reference, Council did determine that the Village Project was not subject to the CBIS policy since it is consistent with these now completed community planning documents. Concerns regarding CBIS have been raised by staff, the Planning and Economic Development Commission, and by Council. Those concerns really revolve around the fact that it is a policy that doesn't have a formula, so it's an open-ended process with no specific methodology.
1:19:20 Which ultimately creates uncertainty for developers. Also, there's a substantial amount of time and cost associated with implementing the CBIS policy, which may not be considered proportionate to the outcome that we achieve. Also, the floor area ratio work that is underway will supersede CBIS for those lodging projects in the commercial zone.
1:19:43 The floor area ratio work will replace rooms per acre as the density evaluation tool for commercial zones with floor area. And we expect that to be completed in July of 2015. So if CBiz is rescinded, projects will still be evaluated for compliance with the general plan and compliance with community planning documents like district plans.
1:20:08 Specifically, the general plan includes a policy that allows lodging projects in commercial zones to exceed 40 rooms per acre up to 80 rooms per acre as long as they provide amenities, services, and or environmental benefits above and beyond that required. So until the floor air ratio work supersedes that policy, that policy will still be used to evaluate those types of projects.
1:20:35 Also, if the CBiz policy is rescinded, that financial information that we've required for those projects would not be mandatory for review. That may hamper the town's negotiating leverage for those types of projects. However, that may not be council's concern if compliance with district studies and other community planning documents is considered sufficient. So the staff report raises two questions for council to consider.
1:21:04 If the CBIS policy is rescinded, as I mentioned, we will be reviewing those projects against the general plan and community planning documents. Is there anything else that you would feel we would need to apply to those types of projects in terms of analysis? And then the second question is, if we rescind the CBIS policy today and we have projects, lodging projects come forward requesting to exceed 40 rooms per acre,
1:21:32 Would that analysis be something you would like to agendize on your joint commission workshop with the Planning and Economic Development Commission? So based on this analysis and the information provided, staff is recommending that the council adopt the resolution rescinding the CBIS policy tonight. And with that, we'd be happy to take any questions. Any questions of Jen? I don't have any. Okay.
1:22:02 Is there any public comment on this? Okay. Sorry, Bruce. Bruce Woodward, local. Just do this, please. Okay. So could you make yourself clearer, Bruce? Yes.
1:22:29 Then what I'd like to do, if Council looks at page 7 of the packet, we have the two questions there, so I will just ask if anyone has any comments on what, if any, additional analysis should be conducted for these types of future applications, if anyone has any input to that. I know.
1:22:58 I would applaud staff. If we've got a planning document that's run its course and run its usefulness, I appreciate you guys bringing it forward and saying, look, let's take this out of the workflow so we're not clogging things up with what we're doing. And I would say that it makes sense to probably have any holes or gaps that you may identify to come forward in this workshop so we can start looking at these things and rather than hanging on to something that's not working anymore, let's be proactive and move forward and
1:23:28 Yeah, I think the first thing to do is rescind it, and then we'll visit the new – exactly. And I just wanted one clarification on the questions. Is nothing in what we're talking about precludes the Planning and Economic Development Commission for asking for additional information when they're evaluating this future project? Is that correct? If the commission needs additional information to be able to make the findings that a project is consistent with a general plan, they can request that information. Okay. Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion, Council.
1:23:59 Adopt the attached resolution rescinding the CVS policy. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to consideration of the single-family transient rental work program, which is number 9. We have a request for a 5-minute break. Okay. We'll take a 5-minute break before we go to number 9.
1:24:47 One team member. One team member. Yeah, I know, but he can talk. He said he was going to stop it. Mr. Wentworth, could we get you to return? Now we will go to number nine, consideration of single-family transient rental work program. And with the...
1:25:26 Concurrence with my fellow council members, what I'd like to do is get a preliminary staff report and then have us focus on answering each of the questions that are proposed on page four of the agenda. Just work through them one at a time so that we can focus. So, Sandra or Dan? Both. Thank you. The item before you tonight is a discussion, as you said, on the topic of single-family transient rentals.
1:25:51 And over the past several years, the council has discussed this topic a number of times. Most recently, it was discussed in 2012. And we have included the agenda bill and attachments from that discussion as attachment one of this current staff report. I wanted to give some information on a handout that was available in the back of the room and it was provided to the council.
1:26:16 Complete an inventory of properties or lots that can rent on a transient basis currently, either through a use permit and business tax certificate or just through a business tax certificate. We did work with some community volunteers who provided a draft inventory that we used to inform our work effort, and we pulled this information from our GIS system. Currently, this inventory is a draft.
1:26:40 We are working to get additional information related to the business tax certificates that are on our list. We will be adding additional information and providing that to the council at a later date. And additionally, just as a note, this list doesn't include properties outside of the urban growth boundary, like the Forest Service cabins and any cabins that are up in the lakes basin.
1:27:04 The purpose of tonight's item is to allow the council to provide staff with direction on this topic. I was just going to give this brief summary and then allow the council to go through those questions. So if the council has any questions of staff, I'll take those or you can proceed with your discussion on those discussion questions. Okay. And I think that we may, I think if we focus on each one, we may have questions as we get to each one of the questions that the agenda bill posts.
1:27:31 There is just one other item that I wanted to bring out there is there has been some discussion between town staff and the fire district and the fire chief is here if there's any additional considerations but it's my understanding that they're working on it and that something would come back to us a later point and not really to delve into that tonight if that's okay with my fellow council members. Sure. Yes, fine. Okay.
1:27:58 So then that takes us over. And the first question is actually two. Is there a need to make changes regarding single-family transient rental in town? Is the status quo working and acceptable? Can we address these as individual questions? Oh, you want to address it to them as individual? Okay. All right. So is there a need to make changes regarding single-family transient rentals in town? I do not believe there's a need. There may be an opportunity. There may be a desire. But I'm not...
1:28:27 Convince at this point that there's a need. Okay. Well, I'm convinced there is a need. Okay. And I think that status quo is absolutely not working. Let's just take these one thing at a time because I agree with you. I think the status quo, you know what I'm saying, I think the status quo is not working at all. Well, yeah, I mean, just going back to the need, I think the need is that if there wasn't a need, it wouldn't be widely being done illegally. And that's my point for support of need. Okay. Any other
1:28:59 Yeah, I agree with you, Michael. I think there's a need. I don't know what the metric is on what that need is. That's the big question. Sure. But I believe there is a need. I hear a lot of people that I know tell me that there's a product that we should have in town that we don't have in town. And I need to vet that out. I don't know what that means.
1:29:29 Sure. And I think that just as an observation, I think that we just spent, we looked at three very specific items about MLR. That was an 18-month process, facilitated, vetted, you know, up and down the block. You know, this is the others, this is maybe the dark side of the moon, how this is coming to us. This has probably been about a 10-year process. Yeah, but it may have been long enough for 10 years, but we haven't, and I think in our priority session, I think what we said was we're going to tackle this thing. We're going to take this thing on.
1:29:59 And so I think going through this per individual question, getting a consensus of where this is, coming out of that, we should be able to get some sort of credible direction to staff to figure out what we do next. I'm going to take the two questions in reverse. Is the status quo working and acceptable? No. And for that reason, I think there is a need to make a change. What that change is can fit into a very broad spectrum.
1:30:25 But my rationale for needing to make a change is that the status quo is not working. Okay. And I think my sense is that, well, it's okay, let's just keep talking about it. And actually, Colin, I'm going to kind of agree with what you said, but I'm going to say it's to consider changes. At this point, and I think there's a couple places in here where I will wordsmith it.
1:30:50 Because it's to consider changes. We're not deciding now tonight to make any changes. We're just saying... We're tackling it. Yes. Are we going to get into football tonight? No, I'm not getting into that. I know, we did use tackle, yes. Okay. That's fine. Consider making changes because status quo is not working. I'd like to also ask if there is anyone in the public who would like to speak to...
1:31:19 Considering changes and or is the status quo working. Hey, council members there. My name is Samantha Goetz. I'm a full-time member of this community. I've lived here for nine years. I am a homeowner. I've had one for four and a half years. I am in a residential neighborhood where there are a lot of second homeowners. Most of these properties are empty except for the one place that does get rented out on a transient occupation basis.
1:31:55 I have found that it's been nothing but positive for myself, for my neighborhood. Everyone has been respectful. It's a nice change of scenery to have different people come every few weeks, and it allows my neighbors to keep their home. The costs are offset by the renters. When I've asked, how do you keep your renters in check, they've said,
1:32:22 We tell them. We tell them when we rent this place. There are homeowners that live next door. They will let us know if there's any problems. They will call the cops. They've self-regulated. We've had no problems. My son and I have had no problems with any of the transient rentals except for one winter where they tried to follow the rules and rented the place out for an entire winter to some very not nice people, and they couldn't get them out.
1:32:51 For three months. So we're stuck with them for three months. That is my, as a full-time occupant in a second homeowner neighborhood, that is my position on it. I do feel it's a good way to get taxes renewed for our town. And I really do believe that people will adhere to the standards that we set. And if we set standards of this is a town,
1:33:19 Of standing citizens, that's who will be rented to, that's who will continue to come. And they will also come from the next few generations also. So that's just my personal opinion on it. I have a quick question. I'm assuming this is a legal rental, is that correct? Come again? This is a legal rental. It's a house. It's a house, but they can legally do what they're doing. It's not an illegal rental. At this point, they can't rent it out.
1:33:47 They cannot. They're renting it illegally. They're renting it illegally. Okay. They've had to stop for the last six or seven months because of the problems. And it's actually that, for them not to have anyone there has caused problems for me. Being the only person on my street, I keep the water going through the winter. If I go for a day or two and there's nobody else, the whole street freezes. Now with the person next to me that are there every couple weeks or so.
1:34:15 They keep the water going. I've had to have the last winter I had to have water come out three times to unfreeze the street. So it has actually been detrimental to me to not have somebody there. Right. But that's just, I don't know if anybody else in this town has... Could we keep the conversations in the back down, please? Thank you. I don't know if anyone else has come forward as a full-time member of the community that said that they really want this, but...
1:34:44 This is something that I feel is very important. No, I appreciate it. I just wanted to, we've got a lot of information to kind of gather and go through, so I appreciate you letting us know what was going on. Thank you. Is there anyone else who'd like to speak on this one? Town Council, my name is Kathy Cage. I wanted to see if I could plant an idea, perhaps persuade you to think about
1:35:16 Supporting this issue going to a public vote. The last, and I'll kind of give some background to the way I think it's important and why I think it's a good time, and this particular issue is a good one to do in this particular manner. It's not a new issue. It's been around for quite a long time. You said 10 years? Something like, it's been a long time. It started floating and then it started becoming a serious issue for consideration.
1:35:45 I think it's a well-known issue. The last town council election for a number of us, a whole bunch of us, it was the number one most important policy issue we asked all the town council candidates. It was a prominent issue in the two former elections prior to that. So this is an issue that has a lot of public interest.
1:36:05 I think it's difficult. It's kind of a close call as to where the majority of the community is going in this particular area. And I personally believe it's time to take this to a vote. We as citizens have some options, you know, in our pocket that we can do. But I wanted to suggest to you folks and to the public to consider, to maybe, you know, try to persuade your elected representatives to support this. There is some precedent.
1:36:32 In this town, for the town council, for instance, taking an advisory vote for the community. I think I mentioned it to a number of you folks, but I'll mention it to the public as well. There are two former issues that I recall. The most recent was when there was a decision about whether or not to purchase the town airport from the county. It was very controversial. It went out to a public vote. It passed by a fairly narrow margin. And it's not binding.
1:36:59 It's not binding. It's just here's what the community think today kind of thing. But since then, it has been honored. We've never had a serious change and reversal and going that direction about turning our back on the airport.
1:37:15 Spent a lot of money on it, but we're sticking with it. And the other time that my recollection, if my recollection served me, was on the original Measure A funding. You know, raising transient occupancy tax, which of course is a regressive type action, but devoting that on just a political basis to marketing efforts.
1:37:37 And even though that was done in the 80s, the political commitment that was made at that time has been honored by every town council and every, you know, the entire town government since then. So that's one particular option. To me, I think for you folks, it's kind of the most, I don't want to say honorable, but straightforward one. It would require an acknowledgement that this is controversial and the vote's kind of close.
1:38:06 For me, those are good reasons why you could put it out to a vote and do that with a straight face. So, you know, hope you will seriously consider it. I think it has merit. And, you know, I know the agenda item tonight mostly is on, you know, information gathering. You want to continue an information gather. I get that.
1:38:27 I thought it was a good time to introduce this idea pretty seriously. And just so you know, for me, from my standpoint, I'm a long-term committed community member, and I'm going to work real hard to make sure we get a chance to vote on it. Kathy, can I ask you a question? On the other ones, was there a certain amount of fact-finding done before there was the advisory vote? We were lucky to have Gordon Alper showed up here. He went to the council when they did that. Did you guys do a lot of staff work? Do you remember? I mean...
1:38:56 I know there was a lot of... Well, certainly we understood there was a great difference of opinion in the community going forward, and we took the vote... Advise you. Advise you. Okay, thank you. I'll just say, Kathy, thank you very much for bringing this idea forward. I think it's a credible one. I think that the challenge for the council is we need to divine what the question would be, and we have an enormous amount of work to get to that point, and I hope the public appreciates that.
1:39:26 You know, we're starting with raw materials here, the very raw, literally raw ingredients of this question, and it's going to take a while to get to figuring out. So I just hope you keep in your mind that when you get to those really fundamental policy issues, what's more important than what, and not really defining policy issues, that we'd like to weigh in on that. Sure. Thank you. John Walter, Advocates for Mammoth. We've left you guys alone for a couple
1:39:56 You seem to be doing fine. This thing has kind of stirred a lot of people up. We think we're kind of concerned because if the advocates had a cause, it was to have a real general plan that addressed all of the problems of the community, not just the resort, not just the workforce housing, not just the residents, not just the second homeowners.
1:40:27 Reflected everything. And we passed the updated general plan after battling it out. There are a lot of scars in this room from people that helped battle it out over a lot of years. And about 15 years, about seven years ago it passed. And since then, almost six years went by to try to get that all into a building code, updated codes. And those were published.
1:40:55 There's still parts of them being refined, but they were published about a year ago, six months ago, I think. And sort of the rumor mill says that there's a move on the foot to just toss the quality of life part of the thing into the trash can and say, let's just have transit housing everywhere. And that's gotten people really concerned.
1:41:26 And I'm just, I'm kind of, as we got involved in this, we've been looking at preliminary inventories of what's available and what isn't, and looking back at what was in the general plan. The general plan describes a real mix of resort properties that do allow, you know, they're in the area that allows transit housing. There are million dollar homes to places you wouldn't want to stay.
1:41:56 That are all within the area that allow it right now. And quite a few of them. And it will be more if you expand that to make sure you include the ones that are fancy townhouses and condos that are the equivalent of a large single family house without having to go into the area and having almost unregulated use of single family homes.
1:42:25 For transit housing. So I think you should really tread lightly and make sure you're not just spinning your wheels on something that's going to cause a lot of divisiveness and then end up not really netting you anything. You know, I think that a realistic appraisal of what could be garnered from this, and I hope if you proceed with this, you really try to get a really objective, realistic appraisal of whether
1:42:54 You're going to get any, what your net gain is really going to be, other than just, you know, my gut says we're going to bring you lots of money. And compared to what the same amount of effort in utilizing what was in the resort corridors and the commercial corridors already, maybe the problem is we don't make those places easy to rent. Maybe they are being rented and we're not just collecting on them.
1:43:23 So, you know, figure out where you want to spend your money. In a broad re-scope of a whole, you know, 20-year effort on the general plan or trying to get into making it work. I think, you know, your item, second item, Joe, that is it working? It probably isn't. Because, you know, this whole thing of trying to collect the proper amount of
1:43:51 Taxes and getting people to rent places that they should be renting them, we haven't put much effort in. What we have put in the transaction tax is paying off. So I really think maybe this effort might be as compliance we need, not more studies. But if you do proceed with this, I hope you do it following the same procedures.
1:44:18 We're used to get the zoning codes and the general plan to start with. In other words, you've got a planning and economic development commission. It's their job to, you know, handle this thing. If you think that it should be done, my feeling is you should have told them, I mean, told staff to take this to the planning commission, and the planning commission ought to be telling them what they want.
1:44:45 Because they're the custodians of the general plan, and they'll know how to amend it, and they should be directing the staff on what to do right. Then it should come through public hearings, and finally up to you with public hearings. So I really think you ought to think about this whole work effort and make sure you're spending your money where the best return is. Thank you. Thank you. Madam Mayor, before we proceed, I just...
1:45:16 I don't want to be wasting people's time. I don't want to be wasting our time. And I think what we need to do is kind of get to this list of questions and come out of this as the evening with some direction to staff. So I would appreciate if you could clarify what question is that we're taking public comment on so we're clear and focused and we can kind of go to this. Before that, can I just make a comment on? Sure. I just want people to understand that, you know,
1:45:45 Councilman Wentworth is right. We're not making any final decision. There was an email that went around that I want to read that says that in the advocate's opinion that we are trying to make this whole town a hotel, that's not the case. And I want people to understand that. That's not what we're doing here. What we're trying to do here is do what's right for the community and move this forward.
1:46:15 No decisions are being made. It's all going to be vetted. Everybody's going to get a chance to say their piece. And then hopefully we're going to take all those great ideas, meld it together and say, okay, can we come up with a solution to something that's not working right now? So I just want to make sure that everybody understands no one up here is trying to make Mammoth Lakes a hotel.
1:46:42 Thank you. So before you start, I would really like to have people at this point focusing on just the overall thing of whether changes are needed at all and whether or not the status quo is working. We will come back to all the other issues individually. So that if your comments are not directly related to that, I'd ask you to wait until we get to those particular issues. But Kathy, in your case, thank you for mentioning it because that wasn't on the list yet.
1:47:10 Does that make sense? It does, but I would very much like to speak while I'm standing here and go home. And I don't think what I would say is actually on the list of questions, so I would appreciate the opportunity. Karen Seiberg, good evening. There was a debate May 27th, and town council candidates were asked a question from a member of the community, yes or no, one word answer. I have to paraphrase, do you support?
1:47:39 Expanding transient rentals of single-family homes into neighborhoods that are currently it's prohibited. Yes or no? Colin, Shields, John, you all said no. You did not support that. The speed with which this has come before Council on the agenda makes it look very clear to me that at least some of you did support it at the time. The other words you said in other settings made it seem, I know you want to jump on me, but I want to finish what I'm saying. Fair enough.
1:48:10 I think that you guys knew if you said, yes, I support this and I want to push it forward, you wouldn't have gotten the votes. I think you were disingenuous to get the votes. I think at this point you owe the community an explanation of who you're doing this for. It's clearly not for the majority of the voters that you felt you needed to say no to. Okay, Karen, one, I did not do anything to get votes. What was the question again? Do you support the expansion of
1:48:37 Transient Rentals of Single Family Homes into Neighborhoods where it's currently prohibited. The answer for me is still no. Okay. You got that? Good. Yeah, I mean, I find that offensive, personally. You'll remember that I followed that up with an explanation that as an elected official, you are not supposed to make a decision until all the facts are put in front of you. To ask somebody
1:49:06 In a council race, yes or no on an issue where facts haven't been presented and we don't have a program in front of us is inappropriate. And what I said is that I do not support it in every single home in this community and I still stand behind this statement. So I think that's offensive. Thank you. My name is Mike Agnich. I'm a resident. And I don't know the council members personally, but I sincerely believe that you want to do the right thing, that you do care about the residents.
1:49:41 My concern is that either you've convinced yourselves or other people have convinced you that somehow more tourists, more bodies in restaurants, more people on ski lifts somehow equates to helping the residents of Mammoth. And that clearly is not always the case. The guy that goes to work every morning and has the house rented next to him
1:50:11 And they're partying and wakes them up. That's not benefiting him. The family that has small children and they have constant new renters next to them, that's not benefiting them. So my concern is there's such an emphasis on increasing bodies, increasing that TOT, that I think it's to a detriment, it potentially can be to the detriment of our community. And our neighborhoods have to come first.
1:50:39 Thank you very much. Again, Madam Mayor, I just think that this is not, I'm not sure we're going down, this is being done productively. And I think we've got to figure out, because everybody's got, excuse me, if I could just finish. I think everybody in this community has a perception of what it is and what this issue is. And to Collins point about the campaign, we haven't even defined yet what the question is. And I think we're involved in a process now that's going to, it's just waste people's time to get everybody's all riled up and we're not getting to where we want to go.
1:51:09 I'll ask a question of staff, and if you, Madam Mayor, if there's another way we can start figuring out a way to engage with this in a productive way. Can I ask my question first? Go ahead, Tim. What does the current code read now? What is the restrictions? What is the current municipal code? And is that the guiding body to this right now? What does it read now? Transient rentals are not permitted in the residential single-family zone. What is the language? In what bill? They're just not permitted. It's part of the zoning code.
1:51:39 In the zoning? Right. Okay. Is the zoning code superseded by the California Department of Community Housing and Development? No. Okay. Well, according to the HCD code, if your house is built after 2010, you can have what is called a residential boarding house up to 10 transient people if your house is sprinkler.
1:52:11 So it's in the Housing and Development Code. As far as I know, that does not supersede oil design. That's my question, and these are the sort of questions that I want to sort of open up, and I think this follows along the lines of what we're doing, because the comment came up, you know, are these homes, you know, are these homes able to support, you know, transient rentals? You know, are they safe? You know, and I'm sure, you know, Tom Heller could probably.
1:52:39 You know, speak to that. You know, I just built a home that has, you know, fire sprinklers, you know what I mean, O2 sensors. I mean, it's like a commercial property almost, you know what I mean? I spent a lot of money trying to do it. And I'm not saying whether or not I want to rent it out or not, but I'm just like trying to open up the discussion here that if people bring up their buildings to this...
1:53:04 These new ordinances and these new codes, I mean, these properties are like commercial, I mean, they're definitely a lot more safe than, you know, a 1973 condo. I mean, and so, I mean, I'm just trying to sort of bring those issues up, and I think that's along the lines of what you guys are discussing. Well, but I think that in the interests of structure,
1:53:31 And guiding this conversation to a place where we're actually going to be able to get somewhere, we've got to figure out some way to do this in a way that, look, everybody's opinion matters. And everybody's public comment is important and of value. I think we need to find a way to structure the conversation in such a way that we can start getting to some of the questions that we need to ask so that we can make some decisions.
1:53:53 And my suggestion at this point, Madam Mayor, is I think that we need to reign this in and bring some focus into this and figure out a way to do it. So what if we go through and state what all the issues are and then allow public comment? Because there are a lot of different things. So you want to close public comment. We're going to reopen it. And then reopen. We're going to stop comment right now and go through numbers 2 through 5.
1:54:21 Then open it up for comment on everything because people weren't... We'll keep everyone here late. We'll keep your guests. So the second question has to do is whether or not changes should be limited to areas where single transient rental is currently permitted. That's kind of planning person speak. It's supposed to be single family transient rental. I apologize.
1:54:48 However, the second part that talks about allow it in residential multifamily 2, which is the area where it is currently allowed. Am I correct? Right, and it needs a use permit currently. Okay, without a use permit, but that doesn't mean that there aren't any permits. There's still a business tax. It just means there's other permits but not an official use permit. Right, business tax and TOT certificate. Okay, and then also implement standards regarding trash parking noise, et cetera.
1:55:16 So really what I was asking is do we want to study whether or not it should be expansion within the current zones or broader? So Madam Mayor, as a way to maybe figure out how to have this conversation. So I would argue that the status quo is not working and is not acceptable. I would then say so in an area where it currently is legally permitted, right?
1:55:42 That we start looking at, well, what will it take to get the status quo so that enforcement is working, quality of life is working, and all the rest of it. And so I would say, okay, those two things kind of go together. And if we had some consensus among council that says,
1:56:00 The status quo is not working if we all think that that's true. Then if we start looking at where it's legally zoned, what is it going to take in the legal, current legal situation to get that to an acceptable situation? That's the kind of direction that we could give to staff that says let's start talking about that just one focused area. And I would love to have some discussion with the council about what we think it might take to make it happen. Yeah, you're getting into the ordinances and regulations. Yeah.
1:56:25 Exactly. And the enforcement mechanisms and all the rest of it, but that's kind of the heart of the matter, and that's, I think, a topic that's where there's some discussion. No question. Exactly. Okay, well then, if you're framing it that way, John, then that kind of presumes number four, which we're talking about, a phased or pilot program, which essentially, if you look at, is beefing up, I don't want to, tackling just the currently allowed areas, there's some things to study there.
1:56:54 Whether or not expansion beyond that is really part of what's down here as number five. Right. And I would say that I think that number four, the pilot project, would apply if we were to go into changing the zoning or expanding where the legal rentals happen. So I would put that sort of over in a parking lot off to the side for the moment and just look at focusing on the status quo.
1:57:23 With our legal situation, getting enforcement, getting a program in place that's going to work, whether it's for the current situation or whether it's for the whole town. But to get, what is it going to take to get a program in place that's going to work? Right, that's two different. Correct. So I'd like to split those two questions. Let's split it. Split them out, but really focus on, okay, what do we need from an enforcement mechanism that's going to work?
1:57:48 For our current situation, for the current status quo, but also if it would be the council's budget to expand it, it would work as an expanded item as well. So I'd like to focus on that question. Current status quo is not working. Correct. And so part of that question that I think is important for us to deal with is currently they are allowed an RMF2 with a use permit. So part of this question asks should they be allowed an RMF2 without a use permit?
1:58:12 Which would be the same as it's currently allowed in the resort zone. Where they don't have to get a use permit, they still have to get the business tax certificate and the TOT, but they don't have to go through the use permit process. The other part of that is, you know, do we need to deal with, in my opinion, just because you're in a resort mode or you're in an RMF2 zone, just because you can get a permit to rent your home does not mean that you should be able to completely disregard trash, parking, noise, all these quality of life issues.
1:58:41 It's a uniform. Correct. So I would support that RMF2 homes should be able to rent without a use permit. I don't see why they need to jump through that extra hurdle if they've been determined to be in an area where that's acceptable. And I also think that one of the major problems we have currently with our status quo is just because you get a permit does not mean that you should be able to run amok. So we need to look at...
1:59:04 With that permit needs to come, trash, parking, noise, all these quality of life issues needs to be associated with it. I've heard ideas like, well, if the house is going to be an SFR house, that it's identified on the exterior of the house in some way that someone can see, this is a candidate house, this house is running out, and that the enforcement mechanisms we put in place, I would like to think that if there's a problem, we're sending a police officer, or we're sending someone who's
1:59:31 An enforcement officer. An enforcement officer that says, look, these are the rules, and the rules are consistent and clear across the board, and if someone's not complying, the enforcement officer arrives, and that's a way that we can really make sure that... So this is what we're going to ask our staff to do. Staff, exactly, to start putting together a program. And the other thing which I'm very interested when I advised that tackling this program was important, you know, we are dealing, everybody in the world is dealing with the effects of technology and the internet.
2:00:01 We all know that. This is being driven by things like Airbnb and things, you know, VRBO, that we have no control over at all. But my question to staff is going to be, what is it going to take, using your creativity, your imagination, all the rest of it, to engage with these kinds of things so that our program is going to be credible in that environment, right? So it's like, it's not just, well, is it a business permit or is this and that?
2:00:27 But my expectation, I mean, I have a former neighbor up in John Muir, where I used to live, wonderful guy, he was an engineer, built his house, had a horrible accident, he was in a wheelchair, he came before this group, he got a $25,000 fine, all the rest of it, wow, that's pretty tough. His house is right back up there. I mean, it's right up there being, I mean, so we should not be underestimating the challenges of doing this stuff. And so my charge to staff would be, look, it's not...
2:00:53 Just a simple little thing here. We need a program that's really going to be something that's credible in the light of these kinds of circumstances. The good news is, too, John, is that, you know, many other towns have done this work. Sure, sure. So the idea of a plaque of some sort, you can really get detailed with that. You could put a number of cards, you could put a local property manager phone number. Occupancy. You could put two bedroom, two bathroom, you know, your license number. I mean, there's a lot of things that...
2:01:22 A lot of other towns have done very successfully. Perfect. And I think if we limit the conversation, at least for the moment, to our legal inventory of stuff and just say, okay, look, what are we going to take to get a program in place that works for what we've currently got and save that other question of new candidates, new neighborhoods, all the rest of it, I think that that's maybe a reasonable way to move forward so we can start.
2:01:45 Now, there's an added thing once we get to the single family side of things. I happen to live in a place where they allow nightly rentals. It's a townhome development. There are 36 homes available. Only three are used on a nightly basis. All the rest of the owners don't want to do that.
2:02:13 I think what we have to also ask staff to do is say, okay, of these areas that allow single-family rentals, how many are licensed? How many people are actually going to take advantage of doing the single-family rental? Because I don't think everybody is. Yeah, so just because it's okay doesn't mean people are going to rent.
2:02:39 And to follow on that, the policy that was set by council however many years back, but I know I was on council, was that if a neighborhood came to us and said they wanted it, we would consider it.
2:02:51 Which is essentially wanting to open up. And no neighborhood has come forward. And we've also got the issue of whether or not they've got CC&Rs and stuff that they have to go through. Again, I don't believe that we can supersede CC&Rs. I think there's life safety issues. I think there's a whole bunch of different things that we have to go through. We're kind of jumping all over. Yeah, so in the interest of moving this forward, to deal with RMF2, currently you need a use permit to rent.
2:03:19 On a transient basis, and RMF too. I would support dropping that use permit hurdle. What does the rest of the council feel about that? I agree. I agree. As long as we have...
2:03:30 As long as we have a way to keep track of them, because one of my concerns in the past has been until the volunteers went out and started doing an inventory, there was no inventory of what was even available to staff. And I'd like to follow up on that again and bring it back to these very fundamental kinds of things in terms of directional giving to staff. So the first thing I would, let's start with some things like this, like the inventory.
2:03:49 This is nice. I appreciate this work that's been done. But again, this is a nice internal staff kind of a document. I can't, I don't know what these head, I'm looking, I don't know what the heading means. I don't know what any of this stuff. Fine. But I think in terms of the direction we give to staff is when you're producing a set of documents as a part of this effort, that these are documents that lay people, you know, the community can have a conversation based on the information that's in here. And I'm hoping that this leads to maps.
2:04:17 Where the town with its authority is producing the inventory, is producing the maps, so we're not dealing with maps and data that are coming from advocates or interested parties or any of the rest of it. The town is the credible authority that says this is where these things are that legally happen, this is where the zones are, that becomes the basis for people to have a good conversation about these things moving forward. So I would say that's one ingredient is the baseline data of
2:04:44 Mapping and inventory that that's the town's responsibility to do that and the town produce it in a credible way that the community can have a conversation about. It's not technical. And so I think that the second direction for staff would be that, and I don't want to speak on everyone's behalf, but I think I'm hearing consensus that we need to strengthen our ordinances for those that are permitted to rent.
2:05:08 Around Quality of Life Issues. Correct. Because we haven't done that sufficiently to this point. So I'd like to see something from staff on how that would look. You know, what kind of regulations we can put in place for trash, parking, noise, etc. Correct. And there's another piece of that is we also have to figure out what the cost of that is. Because, you know, when John said it, well, this police officer, the enforcement officer is going to show up. Well, which staff member is that? Sure. Oh, for sure. Absolutely. You know, what's it going to cost us to have the roads plowed faster?
2:05:35 Residents are used to dealing with half of the lane, cloud, and if we're going to put visitors in there, we're going to have to look at those. So I think the financial side of it needs to go into there of what does it take to get the quality of life that we know we're looking for. Exactly. I think it has to be done anyway. Well, yes. Well, I think that's what number three says. Those things have to be done anyway. Right, right. So I would just say, like, with this mapping and the inventory, the same kind of thing. There are extra costs for staff to do this stuff, to produce, you know, documents that are going to be...
2:06:04 You know, useful for community conversation. Please, you know, factor those costs in so we know what those things look like. Let's talk about number four. Hang on a second. Hang on a second. Can I address you on the use permit issue? I can hear you come into conclusion on that. No, I think I would prefer not to. You're not going to conclude on that yet? No, we're kind of discussing. We'll open up for comments and then we'll go back and see what our consensus is. Okay, fair enough. So we talked about information.
2:06:32 Data and Maps. We talked about, Colin, this idea about a credible program to enforce quality of life concerns, right? What else? I would also like, you know, you've made reference to these programs in other communities. I would recommend to staff to maybe pick three communities or recommendations, you guys, of where this is being done in other places and look at the lessons learned that might be applicable.
2:06:57 Again, specifically focused on enforcement, quality of life enforcement, those kinds of issues that we could potentially apply to our program. I think then maybe the next thing is the permitting thing. The permitting, because right now, my understanding right now is it's a pretty low bar. It's a business license or something like that. I think we need to be a higher level such that when it's an enforcement question, someone can be charged with a misdemeanor or it's got some teeth behind it that we can use. Well, once you build your enforcement,
2:07:27 You know, you build all that in there, right? Well, so I'd like to see a recommendation of staff of what level of, you know, criminality or whatever you want to call it, if someone's in violation, such that we have tools that can say, look, what you're doing is basically a misdemeanor and you're going to get arrested or something like that. Yeah, if I'm not being clear, that's exactly what I'm trying to say. I support raising the bar. Exactly. So then recommendations from staff of what that looks like so we can start really looking with this enforcement program. Sure.
2:07:56 Okay. Just one other thing. I'd like to look at the communication of our inventory out to the larger world.
2:08:10 So that means like real estate transactions. So when someone's buying a house that it's abundantly clear that you're buying a house that either is or is not in this program. Well, and unfortunately because you guys are new and we haven't gotten into that level, that's already out there and required. Good. So if that's in place, great. That's part of the program and that's how that works. However, we don't really have a mechanism to know whether or not the people said, oh, what the heck in there.
2:08:34 And that's fine. But I think the other thing is the reality of engaging with our legal rental program with the Internet, with the larger world, how we would advise, you know, whoever is an interested party that, hey, welcome to Mammoth. We have a legal rental program. It looks like this. If you need your information, it's over here. But this, I mean, again, this goes to this issue about it gets beyond just like an internal kind of a staff document, but being able to engage.
2:09:03 on the Internet's terms with what these things are so that there can't be any, someone could say, well, I didn't know. It's like, actually, no, we've provided the information at a credible level. You should know this. Do we have any metrics on how many illegal single-family rentals we think are out there? I know we're starting to do. I mean, there's data. Yeah, we keep track of all of them.
2:09:36 At this time, finance has struck the so-called business license tax file. Based upon that file, we have 626 monthly remitters of transient room tax to the town finance office every month.
2:09:59 But, Dan, we still don't know. We haven't found all the illegal ones yet. This is 626 of the people who are in the legal areas. I cannot speak to the people who are in the illegal areas other than we have an enforcement process in place. We have collected a number of dollars from that group of people. Could there be more than 30, more than 100? Absolutely. I can't give you that number on illegals operating in illegal areas. I can't do it. Because I think that it would be nice if we could come up with some kind of a way
2:10:29 To get some estimate of what we're dealing with. It's anecdotal, everybody, you know, but to some way. Well, you have an estimate. You have it in our budget. That's a different question. I mean, we go out there and we do a lot of this thing we're talking about, the enforcement, we look at the internet, etc. The fact that it's legal, if we knew every illegal, it'd be easier to go out and enforce it. Of course. We have the wild, wild west today. Yeah, so it's...
2:10:54 Estimates to 100 to 150 illegal activities out there that we see. Not everybody's doing it every day. They come on, they go off, they go away. People get more creative. They do multiple term leases to make them legal but use them differently. There's a number of ways around it if people want to. We're doing those types of elements today. We're utilizing those technologies. And I think the type of form you're talking about from addressing quality of life issues, and a lot of folks, a few of these I've talked to, I think that's a bigger issue.
2:11:24 And again, I think that applies to the current legal activity, obviously.
2:11:50 It would apply different to an illegal activity because you haven't asked them to come in and comply with all those things. So you wouldn't be enforcing that. You're enforcing just the illegal activity at that point more so than you are the other standards because they have no permit to comply with those. Right. Exactly. Okay. So let me call it back to see if we've got the conversation of do better at what we've currently got. Is there a feel that we should be considering any kind of
2:12:18 Expansion at this point in time before we turn this back for the rest of the public comments. Absolutely. Absolutely not. I mean, you can't, I mean, what we're doing is not working. My issue is I don't know what we're dealing with. Right, right. I mean, we haven't talked about all the other points here that we should talk about. And since tonight is not the night to get into the detailed debate, I'm kind of hearing the consensus is
2:12:48 Tackle, to use our appropriate word. Tackle doing what we're doing now better, expanding within the areas where it is, if I'm paraphrasing correctly, without the use permit, not saying that there isn't still other permitting they have to do or licensing, and figuring out how to enforce the quality of life.
2:13:10 Yeah, that's definitely part of it. And we're also looking at lessons learned from other communities. Oh, yeah. And I think, Michael, I'm personally looking at building this thing and building the credibility before we get on to these other questions. Not that we shouldn't get in those questions, and I hope we will get in those other questions, and we'll look at those opportunities, but we're going to be looking at it from the perspective of facts and some data, and the community then, we can give them a way to focus what it is we're talking about.
2:13:40 One chuck at a time, which gets the question back from the campaign, well, what is the question that we're talking about? And we can start defining what that is as we move forward to say what it is that we're doing, what we're not doing. Yeah, I'm kind of interested in what the metric is as far as the need is intended. Yeah, exactly. And I think that goes to us having a conversation of defining the need and whether the need is enforcing for quality of life.
2:14:03 Or whether the need is because the community says, look, we've got financial pressures. We need to make sure we do everything to get TOT revenue in here. We're willing to, you know, the town has put together a credible program, and therefore we're willing to be participating in a program to do single-family rentals because it's going to help with our TOT and our budget burden. But these are questions, to Kathy's point, these are the kinds of questions that we need to focus on and clarify.
2:14:28 Sorry? Tackle. Tackle and clarify to get to a question that the public can actually engage with and it's not just... Agreed. Yeah. Okay. So then based on that general consensus, now, who was next in line? Okay. So Cheryl Witherill, I came really prepared so I hope I don't go over my three minutes now that I have to do this all at once.
2:14:54 I'm going to go through your questions really quickly. Is there a need to make changes regarding single-family homes in town? Is the status quo working? The facts are is that occupancy levels are 45%. We'd all love them to be higher. We have inventory. John, I agree. That spreadsheet that was presented, although it's a ton of work and it took a ton of volunteer hours to put that together, I couldn't read it. I don't know what half those acronyms mean. So I typed it up.
2:15:21 I typed it up in a more legible form. I'm coming up with the total off that sheet that we have 167 standalone homes and 77 vacant lots that are either in the resort zone or they're in the RMF2 zone. So 167, it's a big number. 73 of those show on Sandra's report that she handed out today that are rentable, they're in the resort corridor, or they're RMF2 by special permit.
2:15:48 So for those of you familiar with the map that you've seen around town, that's orange or pink, okay? In addition, there's 21 ski-in, ski-out chalets at Main Lodge that are not included on that inventory because they're not in the urban area. All of those rents, they're mandatory by lease to rent. There are also 35 other stand-alone cabins, homes, et cetera, up at Lake Mary, Tamarack, all not counted on that inventory.
2:16:16 There's 77 zoned vacant lots. There's 38 standalone homes with common areas. They're all new. They're all remodeled. They are the inventory that you're talking about. So 167 is the total of that number. I have a copy of that if you'd like it. So each of your questions, the facts are that we have the inventory. The facts have been verified. We verified them with town. Is the status quo working? I agree that it's not. Enforcement is needed, and it must continue. It's important.
2:16:46 I've been on the enforcement committee since the day it started. Half of the stuff you've been talking about, we've talked about. You have a TOT enforcement committee that can do some of this work for you. But this type of work is going to take them away from doing the enforcement that they do on a day-to-day basis to bring the money in. So you've got to make that decision. Status quo, is it working? Our foundation isn't letting it work. We couldn't print this report out of the system without community involvement.
2:17:16 The software that we have for the Town of Mammoth Lakes is not doing its job. That's where you need to start. So you start with a template, and you start with every single lot in town, and then you zone it, and then you list whether it's built, whether it's rentable, then you list the owner information. You've got to start from the bottom. We don't have that bottom in our system at all. You cannot produce these reports. There's no way that staff is going to be able to answer half these questions.
2:17:46 Is there a need to make changes? Should changes be limited to areas where it's currently permitted? Absolutely. We have zoning in place. RM2 is the logical next step. I would agree with that. However, there has to be a process similar to what the current remitters must adhere to. Safety of our guests, code, guest experience, it's all essential. Requiring a permit for RM2 will help build your foundation. If you don't require the permit, you can't...
2:18:16 Get the information that you need to help build that foundation. It's that simple. Noise, trash, those are all given. We need to monitor. We need to deal with those issues. We're not dealing with them now. So I'm trying to read through all my notes from your comments. Should the focus be on quality life? Quality life is why we all live here. We have chosen a community to live. A lot of us have invested here. A lot of us hope to invest here. We have a general plan that protects its growth and its direction.
2:18:47 If we first do not get under control of what we're already doing, we're never going to build that foundation. That's so important. And I've seen it in the four years that I've been on enforcement. We do not have control of these issues. A pilot program. It will not be easy to turn something on and then turn it off. It's going to cause all kinds of legal issues for the town of Mammoth Lakes. We have a pilot program built into our zoning called the RMF-2.
2:19:16 It's already legal with a special permit. That's your pilot program. Should Council direct changes beyond where rentals are currently permitted? Why? We have the inventory. We have the ability now, as we're shopping for new software, to really fix the foundation. We have zoning in place to protect our time off and our quality of life. We have a team in place that is working hard to enforce and educate and audit, and we haven't even hit the tip of the iceberg.
2:19:49 Our enforcement committee is primarily working on homes. We haven't even started on the condos. And we came up in 2007, then again in 2012. The numbers that we're reporting, the million dollars that was walking out the door, that was condo money, not home money. So staff slammed already trying to figure out what we're going to do with software, how we're going to continue enforcement. Let that be your work program. Let this team do what they need to do to get us to be able to answer the questions.
2:20:19 Before we're expanding. Can I ask a quick question? Sure. Sure. I appreciate what you've said. When you say the team, I just want to be, we're all using the same terms and we're talking about the same things. When you say the team, who are you referring to? We have a TOT task force team that was put together four years ago. It consists of the community and staff.
2:20:41 So it's Drew and Sanders, it's your T.O.T. people. And for a long time this was one, one person trying to get this all done. And if you could imagine all of us from lodging saying we need signs on the homes, we need, you know, better permitting, we need to have phone numbers and 24-7 contact and we had one person trying to handle all this. Okay, so on this T.O.T. committee, who are the citizen volunteers on that committee? It's primarily the lodging committee, Tom Smith from the mountain, Terry Stelick, myself.
2:21:09 John Urdi sits in on those meetings. Matthew Lehman sat on those meetings, Shields, you're now attending. And we have the TOT team. From the town. And who is the TOT team from the town? Right now, the finance organization department was reorganized. We now have four people basically dedicated to the business license, TOT, TBEDS function. So you've got 160 hours a week of finance personnel devoted nothing.
2:21:40 There's nothing more than TOT, TBID, business. This is all one file. It comes to a business tax. Many of you know that. So we are trying to re-look at all the laws, enforce the laws as they're written right now, and we have dedicated, the finance department has dedicated 160 hours a week to that. Okay. So this is the team that's at the foundation, as you referred to it, that's dealing with these issues. Correct. And John, we used to meet.
2:22:07 Several times a month. We're down to monthly meetings now. And I can tell you, the first meeting that this gentleman attended, it was like a new light, because we were spinning our wheels. So we're getting it done. We have a full task force, but this is new. We have not had the power, the manpower, to answer these questions. And you have a team already built with community members, and we've tried really hard to answer these questions.
2:22:32 The inventory alone, countless hours of driving around town with a zoning map, coming back home, putting the address into the town tool that was built that came out of TOT enforcement. Because you put the address in, it will tell you legal or not legal. We did find some discrepancies. We heard of those back to Sandra. She's getting them fixed. But it was countless community hours. I very much appreciate it. I've done inventory process like that myself. I think that what we need to do, though, is that the data and the information needs to be coming from the town.
2:23:02 Absolutely. And it has to be the legal documents, the legal inventory of the town. I appreciate all the work you've done, and I know how important it is to do it, but it has to get over to these guys, and that's got to be, when we're having these discussions, those are the documents that we're using. Absolutely. And I think what I would encourage is that there is community involvement in the process, and I appreciate the chance to speak on this, but so much of what you've brought up today and so many of the notes I've made.
2:23:27 We've discussed. No, I'm sure you have. So we've got information. We just have not had the means or the tools on a software level to implement anything to get the answers. Thank you very much. Yes. Cheryl, a quick question for you. I'm not sure if it's you or staff, but since you've been on the TOT Enforcement Committee since the beginning, isn't there an additional page of questions that are asked when it is for a TOT rental so we are gathering some of the information, whether we've automated it yet or not?
2:23:56 So there is other information that's gathered along with just basic business license information. Is that correct? We updated the ordinance in the very, very beginning of this process and lodging was a big part of that. Research Tahoe, research some other communities and what kind of questions they're asking on that application. So when we do a renewal, the amount of information that we can get to help build this foundation is essential to what we're talking about.
2:24:20 It used to be a very simple form. But for example, for the condo complex that I manage and the condos I manage, it's about 135. My business license is one number. So part of the reason that Sandra can't tell you how many of these homes have business licenses is because they're embedded into property management. If every single place had its own license and could tie into the property or lot, you'd have the answer to that question. So those type of things moving forward into software can be really important.
2:24:47 Those are the type of things that we talk about at our meetings on a monthly basis. I would encourage you to attend. Yeah, I'd love to. I look forward to it one of these days. Thank you. Cheryl, just a quick question. Thank you for your comments. Can you clarify where you came up with that 167 number from this report? Does that include vacant lots? 167 are the standalone homes. 73 of those you see on the report that Sandra has. She's got them numbered there. They're either in the resort corridor or they're RMF2 properties.
2:25:17 Okay. There's an additional, and this is not on Sandra's document because it's outside the rural area. There's 21 ski-in, ski-out chalets at Main Lodge that are all standalone. Right. Some of them remodeled, some of them vintage. There's another 35, what I'm going to call cabins or homes, and that includes, Sandy could probably clarify, it's Tamarack, it's Crystal Craig Lodge.
2:25:46 I'll let Sandy talk about that in her number. I guess it's not important. I just don't. There's 38 stand-alone homes that are on the back page of your report there, Colin, that are all newly common. They're going to call them common area. So like Tallis, Stonegate, that do not share a wall. Stonegate, for example, is a- Those are classified as condos, aren't they? So that's another problem that we ran into doing inventory because the program that we have right now will track hotel, condo, home. Right? That's about it.
2:26:16 We have townhomes, we have cabins, we have hotels. We have quite a variety of inventory. So part of the conversation that we had, Matthew was really helpful on this as far as the real estate side, was defining those terms. And when we're building this new foundation with the new software, it's really taking a look at what, let's write up descriptions and really classify. 1849 condos mean buildings more like a hotel, but I have nine buildings that surround that are more townhomes.
2:26:42 So we have to call it what it is in order to have an idea of what our actual inventory is. We don't know. And this is the basic garbage in, garbage out adage.
2:26:52 So we have a lot of cleanup to do, and I think that's part of what this process will be. It's not going to be easy, and the software component of this is going to be huge in how it all begins. I think the opportunity, we have a new software, we've got RFP out for this, but I think these are the kinds of opportunities moving forward. I think we wanted to take this issue on and tackle it, is looking that we've got these new opportunities coming online to start bringing these things together, and I think...
2:27:15 This foundational issue is critical. I think, just one final point, though, again, I really want to emphasize that we need to get to a point where the data and the information is coming from the town. And if the public looks at it and it's wrong and it's screwed up, great. Tell us about it and we'll fix it. But the authority for this information has got to be coming from the town as a credible resource. Agreed. And, John, that's really what we did. We did an inventory that we turned over to Sandra and she verified everything in that report before it came to you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:27:47 Sandy Hogan and actually Cheryl really covered an awful lot of the things that I was going to cover, but I do like the direction that the council is taking because from what I'm hearing, you're saying, let's fix what we need to fix before we get into anything bigger. Let's not make assumptions of need unless, you know, we can verify that there's a need. And that's actually, I want to say, the inventory that Sandra, you know, developed. We helped provide information that she could verify, but it is the town's.
2:28:16 That's exactly right. And it's labeled draft because it's always changing. Because as a vacant lot is built on, it goes into the other columns. So it's going to be draft for many years. One of the things that we talked about, and just even yesterday, when we started doing our inventory, we were basically, I'm talking about citizen volunteers, we were looking at this because we heard that there was this strong belief that we didn't have any single-family homes to rent.
2:28:45 And that's why we started doing it. And so, literally going out and counting and going out and counting and taking addresses and whatever. And then, just last night, after seeing the draft inventory, I realized, you know, what we did was really not even a complete inventory of units. All we were doing was kind of, if you really wanted complete inventory,
2:29:13 You want to know those 21 chalets up there are privately owned. A lot of people think they're Mammoth Mountain. They're not. They're privately owned under Forest Service Permit. They have an APN number that Sandra hasn't had a chance to probably get to because those are the kind of things they want to put in the database. You're right on, John. Get the data in and know what we have. I hadn't even thought about it. And, of course, we have another ski in, ski out, and that's Tamarack.
2:29:39 Town Rack is a resort permit on National Forest land, but it consists of 35 fully equipped cabins. Most of them are remodeled. I believe 100% of them are probably remodeled right now. All have kitchens. A lot of them are ADA accessible. Then, you know, I woke up this morning and went, well, you know you've got Crystal Crag, you have all those. We haven't even talked about those numbers.
2:30:02 Crystal Crag, George, and Wild Irie. There may be other ones out there. Those are the only ones I remember from my forest service experience. Those are all cabinets also. Sorry to interrupt, but these are all, we're talking about inventory of properties that all collect T.O.T. potentially, correct? Yes. And these guys, you know what? One of the columns I suggested maybe adding to your database, because this is going to be a growing and continuing, finding out what the occupancy is and reporting, and I would be willing to bet that anything on national forest land.
2:30:31 Especially Crystal Crag, I believe, is 100% occupancy when it opens its doors and closes, and I think George is the same way, and I can tell you they report. So, you know, I mean, these are kind of some of the data pieces that, even though I've been doing this for a year and a half, trying to count houses and whatever, I just remembered there are others around. So get the data first, you're right on, and build on it. We have a system that, I mean, you know, one of the things we talked about, use.
2:31:01 For those illegal ones, the easiest thing to do is slam them with a violation of the zoning code. In law enforcement, there's a rule. Stop the activity first. Don't build the case and then stop it. And that would take care of Michael's concern, I think, also. Hit him with a heavy zoning fine. Hit him. And the DA has said he'll prosecute. So these are some of the things you're right on with the, I would agree with the making the changes. Consider dropping that hugely expensive process.
2:31:31 In the RMF II, I mean, because it's expensive and it's a bureaucratic hurdle, is what I've called it. Sorry, Sandy, real quick on the reporting on the Forest Service properties, you're saying that they report to the Forest Service? They report. They send TOT right here.
2:31:50 You get more TOT from those properties because there's no underreporting there. Okay, but you're just saying that they're credible reporters. Oh, yeah. As opposed to they're not reporting to some other, they're just credible reporters. Oh, yeah. Okay. And that's information that would be helpful to the Forest Service, too. You know, I'm sure, you know, the Forest Service and its special use permits does not anymore do the types of inspections we used to do. But I know, let's face it, those chalets...
2:32:15 You know, racer families rent those, and if they don't know about them, we need to probably better market them. And once we solve this business license problem, that's what's, you know, you have to look at it kind of in a historical perspective. You have a lot of condominiums, so it made sense. One business license with a whole bunch of certificates. But, you know, I think Cheryl's right. You need for every property, for AP, you know, you need that business license. And what we inherited was a condo system.
2:32:44 That we apply to these SFRs, the single family homes, and we don't have any business licenses, so we don't really even know. A lot of them don't even know probably. Send them a free one. You said privately owned, the chalets. Yes, they are. Okay. So that is up to the owner. No. Oh, I'm sorry. The permit, specifically, it's the weirdest, and I've been in the Forest Service for many years, and I was in special uses. I'd never seen a permit like that until I came here.
2:33:13 It specifically requires, because it's a ski area base permit, a portal permit, just like you're talking, it requires that the owners must rent on a transient basis quarterly. Now, they can use it. Thank you for that clarification. Yeah, because the Forest Service did not want exclusive use of base areas. Now, the permit for Camarack, which is also ski in, ski out, obviously, 35 of those cross-country, that one is a resort permit, but, so there's just one business license.
2:33:43 But you have the 35 cabins. So focusing on product and marketing, that's going to be part of this whole big picture. The data collection? Absolutely. We need to count them, verify them. It's the town's data. We'll help. Okay. Thank you, Sandy. We can get you to wrap up. Thank you. Okay, great. Thank you. Thanks, Sandy. I wasn't going to say anything. Tom Cage. It's not too late.
2:34:18 None of my comments are collaborative with anyone else. I have a lot of these people getting up here being politically correct. I'm not in favor of single-family rentals in most areas of town. I'm just going to go through a little list of some notes as I'm making it. You realize that you're not going to change the fact that people will continue to rent illegally. So in all the work that you do, hopefully it will be done to help the town continue their enforcement, which will go on forever.
2:34:46 So, you know, if we're clear on that, if you think there's some panacea to where you're going to put in rules and implement things to where everyone's going to be legal, that won't happen. So hopefully everyone understands that so that you do help the town moving forward in the long term. You know, don't start shipping away by dropping use permit because I think the use permit, if you're talking about converting something to a commercial use,
2:35:12 We have an obligation to the person that's then going to use it under the assumption that it's passed the qualifications that a use permit requires. So I hope we consider that as far as that goes. Getting the numbers, Cheryl came up with 167 and 77 vacant, and I'm sorry, I don't know your name. This gentleman comes up with 626 remitters. It's vital that the numbers we're talking about
2:35:41 Have meaning to you guys so that you can make informed decisions. Because those 626 are going to include homes, legal and not legal. They're going to include condos. They're going to include townhouses. So you had asked, do we know how many homes we have that we're renting? He said 626 remitters. That means nothing. So having that clear understanding of what you have and what Cheryl referred to in the software that the town's working on, perfect. You're going to eat this elephant one bite at a time.
2:36:11 And you don't want to reduce your standards and have things run amok. So having a clear picture of what we have, what are the rules, you know, having a very, very clear picture with a painted, you know, the map that's on here. I learn something whenever I come to a council meeting. The parking lot at Kittredge is sewn single-family residential. It's on here. I'm moving in. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
2:36:38 So vacant, no, it's got the color of vacant SFR. Right. So vacant single family residential. Are you going into the development business? Are you living in your car now? I guess it's okay. You can develop. It's not in violation. I'm going to start developing tomorrow. Anyway, so like I say, you learn something new every time. You know, no matter what you end up with,
2:37:07 You know, hopefully you consider the fact that whether you expand the legal realm of it, you guys are going to have a tough job ahead of you, and hopefully the community supports the educated decisions that you come forth, but there's going to be an enforcement cost. The police department's already not fully equipped with people and facilities.
2:37:31 You go to a house and you need to arrest 10 people. Where are they going to put them? How are they going to transport them? So there's going to be enforcement costs. There's going to be enforcement costs when all of a sudden the town has 300 permits come in. We want to sign up for our single family homes. And the town now all of a sudden has to start processing that. Quality of life in parts of town with substandard roads. Let's not forget that. So think about that, especially in Sierra Valley sites, old Mammoth.
2:38:00 Legal questions on CC&Rs. We'll leave that to the legal team, but that's a biggie. And then the financial issue, and that's my closing comment. You know, we all hope that this would bring a financial boom, and I can't quite get the grasp of that. There are homes that people can rent. There are large condos that people can rent. We're operating at a less than 50% occupancy in this community.
2:38:30 And we open up additional houses and we say we're going to collect all this TOT. And then the person that rents their house and they report the TOT. And then all of a sudden somebody says, hey, I rented that house from you and I saw your sign-in book and your card and your owner. You know, I'm just going to be up there for two days. And the next time the owner may be, okay, no problem, just send me a check.
2:38:58 At first it might look good, but you really have to think about that long-term financial viability. It's kind of like somebody said to me when I was supporting the fact that Meridian was going to get expanded. They said, that's a dumb idea. We can't afford the repaving costs. We don't need that much road for the traffic that's there. And who's going to plow all the snow? And I said, no, no, no, Meridian Road getting bigger, that'll be great. It'll help. It's a portal to get people into town.
2:39:26 The financial aspect of what we're thinking is going to be generated, I think, follows along the same thought process as Meridian now being reduced to three lanes again. Thanks. Thanks, Tom. Thank you, Tom. Good evening. Just one more bit of comments here. You know, I just want to say, status quo... Oh, and your name is? Oh, Terry Stellick. Right. Status quo is never preferable. You know, so for us to sit up here and say, oh, yeah, status quo is fine. You know, let's just sit here and we're not going to do anything.
2:39:58 It's never profitable. That's why we have planning. That's why we have development. That's why we have redevelopment. But it should never be done without a strong foundation and a vision for the future. You know, what are the consequences of our actions? And I think that sometimes we jump that gun and we don't look at that, what those consequences are, and it's gotten us in a lot of trouble in the past. What isn't working now? I mean, we can all sit here and say status quo isn't working, but have we answered what's not working?
2:40:28 So, you know, let's figure out what can be improved. It shouldn't just be focused on SFR. We need to look at the entire picture. What is out there that isn't working? It's been brought up many, many times, and there's been a lot of effort in our staff to answer this question. What do you have out there right now to rent? You can say, I have 50 condos. What does that 50 condos...
2:40:58 What does it consist of? Are they all one bedrooms? Are they all five bedrooms? What do you have out there to rent? That question, we tried to answer it. There was an intern that was hired to make a phone call to every single rental property that you have holds a license right now. You still weren't able to get that information. There's just so much that needs to be done with that foundation. So we need to look at that foundation. I know it's been set up tonight.
2:41:26 But I think that we need to look at the entire picture. And it can include SFR, but it needs to be the entire community picture as to what is going to bring us into the future, what's going to sustain us. So as far as RMF2, RMF2, if we're going to open anything up, that would be a logical place to start. But what was the rationale for RMF2 to start with?
2:41:52 Why did we place these properties in an RMF2 as opposed to a resort? What are the requirements for a resort property? And right now, do they have to go through a safety check? What is that process that they have to go through? I think that we need to find that out. Terry, I'm just going to follow up with a statement you just made about looking at this thing holistically. I'm assuming that you're considering
2:42:20 What we do in terms of our housing, what we're talking about now, to get the kind of capital, the kind of investment opportunities possible so that properties can start being renewed. So that we're putting together a program with this stuff that, however it's going to work, if we've got mediocre product or things that need to get redone or rebuilt or reconditioned or whatever, that we're putting together a program somehow that's going to get people on the track to doing that.
2:42:48 And I'm assuming that's part of the whole equation so we can do that kind of stuff. Because if we've got a mediocre housing stock or visitor stock or whatever, we have to be thinking about how do we start putting something together that the market and the private forces are going to step up and start turning this stuff over, improve it. It's got to get torn down. They've got it rebuilt. There's an incentive in it to make all this kind of stuff happen. I'm assuming that's...
2:43:13 Kind of what you're hitting on a little bit. Well, I guess I'm looking at this conversation is looking at doing a study just on single family rentals, but there's a bigger picture out there. Right. And so, you know, how are we going to sustain ourselves? How do we sustain Mammoth Lakes?
2:43:29 So we can all live here and enjoy ourselves in the future. Our guests can come up here and enjoy themselves in the future. That we're supplying the product, we're being stewards to our area, you know, it's... Terry, you're right on. You're right on. That's what it's all about. That's the big picture. Do we have the right product? But this is focusing on single-family rental. No, no, but... That's what I want. I'm just saying... Yeah, and I'm saying that you... And I agree. It's a component, but we have to look at it.
2:43:57 As a component of a bigger picture. Yeah. I would agree. You talked about going out and studying other communities. When you're looking at those communities, how is that community made up? You know, we need to do more than just say, oh, you know, well, these guys do it, so, yeah, we need to do it because these guys do it. What are they doing? What is the makeup of that community and that town?
2:44:22 I think just to that point, on the reading I've done on Airbnb and how all these issues are coming up in all these different communities, you can look to these other places to kind of see what was the bait or what were the things they were dealing with, but the solutions for these issues are always specific to each individual community. It's unique to us. To every community. It comes down to you've got to make it work for your place. You can't take something from somewhere else and just put it on top. You've got to...
2:44:48 You've got to really dial it in and bring it to make it work for your specific place. Okay. Now, John, can I ask you? Terry, do you have anything more to say while John's using up your time? Sorry. So keep going. Let her finish. I know. So ignore that. Okay. Shields has said something, you know, that just because it's a legally zoned area does not mean that they're going to rent. Absolutely true. That goes with any property. And it also goes with just because
2:45:16 They're not renting doesn't mean they're not renting because we don't have record of it. It could absolutely be illegal activity. We have a mass amount of conditions that are being illegally rented. That's why I ask the question, do we have an idea of how much that is? For the reason that tells me, okay, maybe there is a need. If there are 150 people or homes that are being illegally rented, okay, I want to throw that in the equation and say, okay,
2:45:45 Do we have 150 units that, if allowed to be rented, let's say in a resort corridor, why aren't they being rented? Is it because the owner doesn't allow renting? I don't know why. So those are the questions. You know, that's how we came up with this first RMF2, is because it was being rented illegally.
2:46:14 They were caught through the compliance process, and now they're going through the process of coming up. I'm not talking about the enforcement compliance. That's another issue. I'm just looking at it from a pure number standpoint, saying, okay, obviously the illegal rentals are happening. And I agree with you, Tom, they're going to continue. Hopefully we can mitigate some of that, you know, through this process. So my point is they're happening.
2:46:41 In condos, they're happening in homes. Oh, yeah. It's not limited to single family. So your enforcement and airtight ordinance, those are keys. That's part of the foundation that you need to get put together. And the condos that are being rented out there haven't even been touched. And there's an education process that still needs to happen. We think we're doing a good job of that. But you have somebody that comes in and buys a property.
2:47:06 And I mentioned to them, well, if you're renting for anything, even if they're on a rental program, you still need a TOT license. Well, what's that? Why do I need that? And so there's just still such an education process for new owners and that type of thing. So anyways, I just want to make sure that we're looking at this whole thing, as John said, holistically. It's not just a single-family rental question. Agreed. And we need to make sure that we're looking at that picture.
2:47:36 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Terry. Thanks. Anyone else? I'm Sharon Clark, Mammoth Lakes, and I've just tossed out my testimony because I am so impressed with what y'all are trying to do, which is figure out where you are now. And congratulations. Thank you. Thank you, Sharon. I've got a question for staff, if I may.
2:48:11 Sandra, could you kind of encapsulate, if we don't do the use permit in RMF 2, what won't happen that is currently happening now? There wouldn't be a public notice for 300 feet around the property and a public hearing, and it wouldn't be discretionary. So the use permit is discretionary. The Planning and Economic Development Commission can either approve or deny a use permit based on the compatibility of that use with adjacent uses.
2:48:34 So that process wouldn't happen. It would just be a business tax certificate and a TOT certificate, which is not discretionary. We issue those if you meet the standards that we have. So did I hear within what I heard the conversation about this issue, about the use permit issue, that perhaps we might have something additional in the business permitting process, perhaps, if they want to do this kind of thing that says, oh, if you are looking to do transient rental in a place that was not originally zoned for that,
2:49:04 Maybe instead of the use permit thing, you would now maybe have a different kind of checklist that would send Tom Heller and make sure their, you know, smoke alarms are all working or, you know, something, whatever all those things were. Is that, would you potentially do that? It could be done through the business tax certificate if we had that. We already do, you know, issue business tax certificates for those types of uses. So that's a process that's in place.
2:49:29 But the council is discussing adding additional things. Okay. So that's – all right. So you're telling me what won't happen is the public hearing, the notification of neighbors, and the ability of a planning commission or a body to say, no, you can't do it. Correct. And, Kathy, that's exactly kind of what I'm saying, right? Okay. I think Sandy put it very appropriately. It's a bureaucratic hurdle as far as I'm concerned. And it doesn't mitigate any of those quality of life issues.
2:49:59 That are really the issue there. It shouldn't necessarily have to come before... This is why the neighbors would care. Right. You know, whether it comes before a public process, whether the Planning Commission, a five-member committee can determine whether you can do it or not, doesn't mitigate any of those actual issues that are impacting your neighbor. So I'm suggesting that we need to strengthen the permitting process.
2:50:19 You have to tick all these boxes, but you don't have to go through the use permit hurdle. You get a lot of surprising testimony when a neighbor comes in and says, hey, I got notified that they're going to do this. And, you know, it's not probably a lot of really surprising testimony about what they're concerned about. Sure. So we can anticipate that and put something in place for that. Right. Briefly, just on the permit. I believe it's enshrined in the zoning code. And, you know, I would suggest that you...
2:50:51 If you think that, you know, should be changed, the type of permit, take it out, put it in, send it back to the Planning Commission with a recommendation, get a good solid staff report that tells you the pros and cons and which way to do it and which way not to do it and bring it back, have public hearings on it and bring it back through the Planning Commission. Thank you. Yes, because Shields took some of your time too.
2:51:21 Terry Stalick, once again, sorry. One of my concerns is getting rid of a permit process is already in the RMF2 that's going forward right now. There's something that's said here in safety that the town manager and town attorney has determined that this type of use would not require a review by building division and Mammoth Lakes Fire Department, our police department. And that concerns me greatly.
2:51:49 Because it says that you're taking a process, but we're circumventing it because it might be something that we want to do to get this home permitted. And so there's a reason for that. If you have a commercial development that's coming forward, that commercial development has to jump through a lot of hoops. There's a lot of money that they have to pay up front in fees and development to make sure that they are conforming to what that commercial development is.
2:52:16 And instead, right now, you don't even have diff fees that you charge on a residential property. You can build a residential property, turn around, and then make it a commercial property. You haven't had to do any of those things to make sure that that commercial property is going to be safe for our guests and going to comply with everything that needs to be complied with. And this agenda report concerning the safety of the one RMF2 home that you have going through right now really concerns me.
2:52:46 Martin, would you mind if the fire chief went next since did you want to make any statement against to what Terry had to say? Okay, yeah. Madam Mayor, members of the council, Frank Freebolt, current chief for the Mammoth Lakes Architecture District. The comment would be very confined at this point to an element in your staff report, which was just read.
2:53:16 We are working with Dan and his staff, but on this item, the fire district would need to reserve the right to look at code requirements for these. I understand his intent, but we would just need to make sure that we go through that. We have an opportunity to go through the codes from the fire standpoint. And that's it. Okay. Thank you very much. Absolutely. Good evening, Council. I'm Martin Kleinberg.
2:53:51 On the same topic as Terry's and the fire chief, in conversations with our town building official, he feels that unless it's changed since our last meeting, that transient occupancy from a regular, you know, non-transient would be a change in use. And he says that there would have to be some building code compliance if, or at least something to, an inspection to look at.
2:54:22 To see where there is any issues. Because I know that currently if you put a condo on a rental program and you have like some illegal lofts or staircases or things like that, I know that they make you correct those. So I'm kind of surprised that there would be a comment that some of those things wouldn't have to comply. I mean it's all about...
2:54:51 What other people have said earlier about that it's about safety for the guests. And I think that's something that we can't have a different level of safety just because we want to collect more TOT or something like that. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Can I ask staff to clarify, since it was asked a couple different ways, is if we go forward with the change to say the RMF2 does not need a use permit,
2:55:20 What legislative action is needed to make that change? Is it a zoning code change or some other? Yeah, that's a change to the zoning code. And it hasn't been changed to any change to the zoning code. But most changes to the zoning code, that does need to go through the PEDC code. It goes through them and then to us. Okay. Just wanted to clarify that. Okay. All right. Anyone else who hasn't gotten up to speak? Okay. Bringing it back.
2:55:48 Madam Mayor. Yes. I am prepared to craft something to start drafting a motion. Okay. I am not. You want to do some more discussion? Yes. Okay, then hold off for a second. Sure. Yeah, I was going to say more comments, deliberation. Sure. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think we really got to questions four or five. We kind of stopped at three. No, we didn't. We didn't. And I think that when I asked the question,
2:56:20 Michael specifically said yes, he wanted to see it expanded. John definitely said no, but yeah, we didn't kick in other than I inferred from some of the other things that it seemed the consensus was to fix what we've got first, look at the RMF2, and then go off in another piece, but that was just my feeling of what I was hearing from you say, whether you said it directly. So if you have something to say, go right ahead. Yeah.
2:56:48 You know, I think kind of reviewing back through from where I'm coming from, I don't think the status quo is working. We were asked what is not working. We have people just running rampant with this product right now. So I think that is not working. I also think the fact that just because somebody is in a particular zone, let's say they live on Lodestar or Juniper Ridge, does not mean that they don't have concerned neighbors that are going to care about
2:57:16 Bear problems, trash, noise. I mean, those people have spent a lot of money for those homes. So if nothing else, I think there needs to be a change to the status quo there. We need to strengthen our ordinance, raise the bar, if you will. A lot of this kind of works synergistically together. I agree completely with Tom Cage's assertion that you will never get 100% compliance on this. That's absolutely true, in my opinion.
2:57:46 So there's always going to be a need for compliance here. We're going to need to have compliance efforts to make sure that people in condos are remitting their TOT appropriately to the correct amount, that people that are zoned to be allowed to rent these homes are actually remitting TOT, and to continue to say that people that are in illegal zones are going after them. So there's a cost to that enforcement, and I think we as a council need to consider that.
2:58:14 That right now we don't have the resources to do that. We're also budgeting about a half a million dollars right now in violations that balance our budget, and that concerns me greatly. So those are the couple of things I think I've been fairly clear that I would like to push to the Planning Commission that the use permit be stripped from the RMF 2 zone, and I'm not going to presume consensus on that.
2:58:43 I guess the last piece is, you know, you asked should we consider whether this gets expanded to any different areas or any sort of program, and I think it should be considered. We've got a number of options here, A through D. I'm sure there are others out there. I have one that stands out a little bit to me, but I'm more interested in having a conversation about that and engaging with the community.
2:59:12 I'm pretty clear on the fact that we have kind of two pretty diametrically opposed sides on this. The status quo is kind of entrenched on one side, and I don't think that's working. The other end of the spectrum, to just release 2,400 homes to the market is not a good idea to me. I think we should have some areas that this is not allowed. I think that we need to be cognizant of CC&Rs, but I do believe that there may be some middle ground in there.
2:59:41 When we're looking at stark numbers, we have 9,626 dwelling units in town from what I've read. It's hard to nail down this number of what's currently available because it changes on an hourly basis. But whether it's 73 or 167 or 200, all of those numbers are less than 10% of the available single-family home stock in town, which is 2,400 homes roughly.
3:00:10 So in a town where 70% of our revenue is generated from tourism, 70% of our jobs, and 70% of our general fund comes from our tourists, I think that needs to be considered. I'm also concerned, and this is not financially, that we may be sending the wrong message to some of our guests by saying, if this is a product you want, don't bring it here. And I think that goes to the experience that we have here.
3:00:38 We need to be able to regulate it. I am acutely aware of quality of life issues and that needs to be a major focus in this process. But I believe that if we're not thinking that people want this product, we're not paying attention because I think it's out there and people want this product. When we're looking at the amenity base in this town and the lodging options, I think this should be part of the program.
3:01:03 Whether 167, whether we're right there at the right number and it just stays that way, I'm willing to have that conversation. Whether that goes up a little bit, I'm willing to have that conversation. I will not support 2,400 homes and I don't support the current status quo. So I guess my answer to five is should we consider this would be yes. Thank you. Colin, I think you're right on. I go along with almost everything you said.
3:01:36 And I've said it even in my campaign. I don't agree with expanding single-family rentals in neighborhoods that have CCNRs that preclude it or say no to nightly rentals. But I'm more of what is our need as a community, as a destination resort. Is 67 the right number? 167?
3:02:08 214, I don't know. But what we have to do is we have to go through the process of vetting that out because we do need that product. People are asking for the product. People are using the product. People are using the product illegally. If we have the right amount of product out there, and I don't know how to go about doing that, you know, do we say, okay, the resort quarter, boy, if everybody in the resort quarter says, eh, it's my home, I don't want to rent it out,
3:02:40 We don't have the product. So we have to do some work. And I think that's what we're trying to do up here is involve everybody, trying to come to a, as Tom said, you're eating an elephant a bite at a time. It's a big elephant. And I think we're up to the task of taking some bites out of this thing and making some smart
3:03:07 A logical and thoughtful decisions going forward. Thank you. Okay. And on the issue of expanding it, I'm going to be a no vote along with John, but I think that what I'm hearing here is that I don't know, let me see if I'm understanding you guys correctly, is do we need to deal with the fix the current stuff and then move on? Is it like a phase two of a work project or do you want to see it just
3:03:36 Run-Through is all part of the same work program. Well, for me personally, I think it's in concert. I mean, I'm not saying that. I think we have to, no matter what, fix the ordinances and regulations. We need a road to compliance. We have to do that. We need a road to compliance. And at the same time, I don't want to say stop on everything else. I think we have to move that other ball forward and see where it leads us.
3:04:02 Okay, and what I'm hearing you guys say, even though it was the change I was going to make, is not, on number five it says direct changes. Well, we can't direct changes until we've considered all the options. So if we're pulling it back to a consider, what I'm hearing is the consensus, 3-2, is to also consider everything that's under number five that might be appropriate. As well as other options from community conversations, and I'm looking forward to doing that.
3:04:32 Well, I think there's even more because there's sixth vote, you know, et cetera. I think too, Joe, real quick, just touching a little bit on HOAs and CC&Rs that Colin touched on a little bit is that when you take neighborhoods such as the Knolls and the Trails, Starwood, my neighborhood, there's a handful of HOAs. I mean, I would think that in event of an ordinance,
3:04:59 If there's going to be an ordinance change, that they would supersede any ordinance change. So I would support that. I don't know the total number either of all those homes. I don't know if it's 300, if it's 800, 1,000, I have no idea. But I think we need to know that number and take a serious look at that because if an active HOA has
3:05:23 You know, does not want to participate in this, they would be out. I mean, and that takes out a lot of residential homes. That does. And that's where I think within this inventory, you need to know about Frank, because what good does it do to open it if you say, oh, we're going to get 500 pieces of product, and then you find out there's only 10. Yeah, that discussion needs to take place. But I think I'll...
3:05:50 Raise my little hand again and maybe just a little bit higher up and say, I think there's a way that we can move this whole thing forward. How many years has this been getting kicked around? The can's pretty kicked. Longer than I'm alive. So this is eight years? I mean, Kathy said, okay, longer? Longer. Longer. Longer. Okay, so we've got five questions in front of us that
3:06:16 If we could address all of this, the satisfaction of the community in one night, then we just go home and retire from councildom forever. I don't think that's going to happen, and I don't think it should happen. But I think that we can look at this and we can break this thing up into a couple of chunks. So in building this motion, I'm just going to start by making some assumptions. I'm going to assume that we're going to address the second question in number one. Is the static quo working and acceptable? No. Exactly. So I'm going to say...
3:06:45 That we're addressing specific questions out of here with the idea that like five and some of the other things, we're going to come back to those. If we can get this done in six months, I think that that would be a pretty good thing. I think it's going to take you more than that. Okay, but I'm saying if we just sort of put this into the elephant-sized bites. So I'm going to say that we're going to address that second question, is the status quo working? I'm also going to say that we should focus this around quality of life issues.
3:07:14 That we should focus what we're looking at for the items I would suggest going to staff is built around this kind of quality of life issue. So that being said, I would recommend that these are the tasks of a work program to staff to start looking at. The first thing is to provide council with an estimate of what it's going to take to provide a credible data program for this effort.
3:07:40 In terms of cost, time, whatever else, so that there is credible data that these communications can happen based on real things. That includes credible mapping. That also we look at the, in terms of the TOT committee and the staff that's working in that committee, what is it going to take to make that a sustainable capacity of the town? Right now we've got volunteers involved in this and some staff, but a recommendation that says we're going to be doing this.
3:08:11 The third thing would be the recognition that we're in an existential enforcement situation, that enforcement of this policy is going to be going on forever, and that that needs to be incorporated into the capacity we need to do these things. Also, monitoring. What is a credible program for monitoring these changes that we're talking about doing? The standardization of terminology and terms.
3:08:43 This should be, what is it to make this a pay-as-you-go system so that the cost we've been talking about to do the enforcement, make this stuff happening, what to structure this thing in such a way so that as we're enforcing it, it's paying for itself. We're not looking out, we're not going to have to make, and if we can't, you know, let's look at the cost of pay-as-you-go is going to look like it if it's crazy, okay, then we need to deal with that, but what is it going to cost to do it as a pay-as-you-go system? I think that
3:09:09 We need to address the issue of this being something we're using to build the town's budget. And I think that's part of this being an unacceptable component of the status quo. And I think that that's something that we want to address, but that goes to that second part of that first question. Standardized permitting, so that the permitting for this, if someone has a property that they're renting, it's a standardized permitting process. And what it's going to take to strengthen the ordinances so that these can be enforced at a level that's, Shields had a good term, it wasn't a...
3:09:38 Police officer was somebody in a uniform, but it's not a cop. What would you call that? Compliance officer. You know, that the compliance is coming with someone who's got some authority behind it. I would suggest that that is the motion for those two questions. We give that direction back to staff. They start working at that. Then we can have some further discussion about some of these outstanding questions in here.
3:10:05 Chunks that you want to come back for the next discussion, or do you want to wait to hear back from staff of what this thing looks like and then start getting into it? But that's the essence of my motion at this point. Okay, there's one thing that I think we need to recognize. That was truly a motion? Yes, ma'am. Or that was just direction? No, that's a motion. Okay, got it. That's a motion. Do we have a second? I'm trying to process it still. Come on, boys, let's go.
3:10:39 Well, then I will second the motion. There's one piece, I think, John, that we need to put in there that is in the staffing considerations that we didn't really look at is if staff comes back to us with this work plan that shows timeline, costs, so on and so forth, is then it also has to truly tell us whether or not it affects the ongoing work program that we've got for that department. Yes, of course. How it fits in because when you say six months.
3:11:06 It may not work that, you know, I think that's some of the things. Absolutely. I think that we're looking for direction to staff of a work program, but what is the cost of this going to be? How does it fit into staffing? And we, I look to you guys, because I know that you're professionals, you know what you're doing. You're going to say, look, pay-as-you-go is impossible, or this isn't going to work, it's going to take us so long to do this, and it can integrate into the new finance system or whatever, but I think it's, I hope it's kind of. Can we simplify the.
3:11:35 Well, and let me just say one thing is that my presumption is the seconder of the motion is that it deals with fixing what we've got and considering expansion. And, and, and it, yeah, I'm, and I, so the motion I'm making is specific to those two sentences. I'm not making any representation about, I'm assuming that we're going to respond to each one of these questions from staff in turn. Oh, okay. It may be.
3:12:04 We can do this motion, get this over with, then move on. But I think I want to get... My point is that I don't want to be conflating all this stuff into one thing. Can you simplify the motion, though? Can you say direct staff to... Direct staff to provide an analysis of the cost and timeline for implementing the various tasks that I previously outlined. Okay, but I think... Jamie, she's got it. Let's not simplify.
3:12:36 Well, there's a lot of things to do. There's a lot of stuff we can do. No, I'm just saying, if we can direct staff to say, okay, we're talking more what's not working is the current regulations and ordinances, right? Okay, so let's go back. I will withdraw my second to that motion, and I think Shields is right. We've discussed a lot of things in detail, but I think that...
3:13:02 The motion needs to be a little bit higher level of knowing that there's data, et cetera. Can I take a step of trying to summarize? Thank you. Sure, thank you. Is your mic on there? Can I hear you? Yeah, I don't know if it's on or not. It's top or low. I think that the motion was to direct staff to come back and provide counsel with quite a bit of information on various topics. I think it is provide counsel with an estimate of how much it will cost, how long it will take to produce it.
3:13:31 That's an excellent summary. The only thing I would add is the
3:14:01 The idea about the existential enforcement. That is, that we have to be in, you know, the point that Tom made, that we're never going to, this is never going to be a definitive thing, and this is going to be an ongoing effort that we're going to, and that's only, it's a minor thing, that's one thing I would add. So I think the way I would summarize that is, you're directing staff to come back to the council with some options for how we can handle enforcement. Yes.
3:14:24 Okay, then I can second that motion. But enforcement of what? Right. That's my big question. Enforcement of what? I think, not to, sorry, I'm not talking about, I think that the idea is enforcement of whatever the ordinance is going to be. Ah, okay, going to be. Yeah, if the council makes changes, then it would be the ordinance as amended. If the council decides not to make changes, it would be enforcement of the ordinance as written now. Well, I think.
3:14:52 Council's pretty on board about changing the ordinances. And I think we need some direction on what those ordinances could be. And I don't think that staff can give us the information that John wants until we understand what those ordinances are going to be. But I think they could, I mean, this is certainly something that folks could get started on.
3:15:20 I mean, there's so much basic work that's got to get done. Yeah, I want to know, I want to have kind of an outline of what we're talking about, our ordinances and regulations that might go forward. I think it would be easier for staff then to come up with, hey, this is how we do that enforcement and the cost to do that. It might help structure the discussion if the council at some point, whether dealing with this motion now or holding this one in advance for a second,
3:15:50 If the Council ends up considering questions 2, 3, 4, and 5 and direct staff to come back with more information on any, some, or all of those points, we might have a better idea of what staff would be having to take a look at.
3:16:04 I agree with that. Just one of the problems is that I think you were on Council Michael when we did the other changes to the ordinance. I was. And there were a lot of things that we wanted to do that legally you can't make a bigger bite and things like that in some of your ordinances. So there's some of that that staff can bring back to us. Great. I think to Andy's point, you know, my understanding of this is staff was really looking for some direction on these five questions. I'm not sure that the motion we're providing has done that.
3:16:33 Well, if I'd like to get this motion, I think it's a significant bite. We've got a motion and a second, and it's essentially, the USA Today approach of it is we need a baseline of more information. Well, I would just say, as my original motion stands, I think Andy Morris' summary was consistent with my motion, and we all heard that, if that makes sense. So let's just go ahead and vote on that one, and then we can decide if we're incorporating that something else or moving forward with.
3:17:03 Other individual pieces. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. I'm a little unclear, so we're just voting on whether we approve that particular motion, and this is not going to end the conversation. Correct, it does not end the conversation. No. Yes. Yes. No. Yes, motion passes 3-2. So then, Colin, do you have another way to summarize something? Well, I just...
3:17:40 I think we've pretty adequately addressed number one. I would like to, I mean, I think number two is relatively simple to address as well. Do we as a council want to kick RMF2 back down to Planning Commission? I mean, I think we're going to get the appropriate study of that as it comes up its correct channel through Planning Commission, through staff, and back to us again. I'm supporting doing that, and I don't know.
3:18:09 Well, please just make a motion to do that. So I would make a motion to send the question of whether we should allow RMF-2s to be permitted without a use permit to Planning Commission for study. I'd second that. All right. We have a motion and a second. Is there any further discussion? All right. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
3:18:39 Yes, motion passes 5-0. More? Colin? I think I'm pretty happy at this point that we've appropriately addressed that I don't think the status quo is working and that we should consider how to move forward with strict ordinances and whether that encompasses a change to the current ordinance. Shields? Did we make a motion on ordinances to ask staff to, I think we need to make a motion on strengthening
3:19:12 What we could do to strengthen the ordinances? Yes, well, or is it kind of like to strengthen the ordinances and enforcement of them, whether it's for the current area or for other, you know. Thank you. That's, exactly. Okay. That. Well, then I'll make sure. Yeah, I can, yeah. Okay. Right. That we ask staff to review the
3:19:42 Current ordinances as far as increased enforcement, especially for quality of life issues, regardless of whether or not it's for the existing areas or expanded areas. Second that. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Poor Jamie. Roll call vote, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
3:20:07 Sorry, Madam Mayor, was that, would you say that's what number? That was number three. That was three, okay. Three and kind of two where it talked about, you know, the increased standards. Okay. So I presume that the only piece that is left is essentially the five because I think four, I think John's kind of right, that's in a parking lot. When we get to this, do you decide pilot or not? Sure. What are we deciding it on? So does anybody want to make a
3:20:37 A motion around number five. I would make a motion that we've directed staff to take on a significant amount of work and that we look forward to coming back to number five, but I don't feel like I don't have the information to engage with number five and I need this information from staff.
3:21:03 Before I can really make an informed decision about this. I want to have a conversation, I want to talk about it, but I need that information before I can really engage with that issue, with all the issues in FOP. I look forward to doing it, and I want to do it, but I want to do it with information that I can do something with. It's all on the table, is what you're saying? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. I agree. So essentially, John, you're saying, consider five, but after we've done...
3:21:33 The other piece. Is that what you're saying? Exactly. Keep five and bring it back. Bring five back. It seems like a lot of extra work. I mean, if we're directing staff to work on all this other stuff, I mean, shouldn't they kind of bring back a complete report? I just, I feel, you know, back to the campaign. I mean, I thought about this a lot. And the issue that, the way I could really make sense out of this is to make sure that in the end that
3:22:02 The residential, the quality of our residential neighborhoods, the integrity of that is maintained going forward, whatever thing we come up with. And I think that before we can get into the discussion of expansion or doing different things to enhance the product, to do all the things we've been talking about, personally, I need to have more information before I can get to this. And I think we all do. I think we need to get a sense of what it's going to cost, if it's doable, all the rest of it.
3:22:32 And then, so, yeah, I'm saying let's just punt this for a little bit until we get this information back from staff. That would be my sense. So the motion was punt this? Punt. Punt number five. We're following a fine tradition. We're going to punt number five. Yeah, I think the direction on five is fine. I don't think you need a formal motion that says hold off on that and bring it back. Right. If that's kind of the consensus direction, we can...
3:22:59 Bring these issues back. They would come back in a context as we work through some of these other things regardless of sin, but I think if they defer it and bring it back, it doesn't... I think we're muddying the waters at this point. I think Joe appropriately kind of summarized whether that was our 30th motion or not. I'm not really sure, but I think, you know, we said... Just wait until you're mayor. Right. The status quo is not working. You know, we're passing RMF2 back down to Planning Commission, and we should have a focus on strengthening the ordinance, whether it stays with the...
3:23:29 Status Quo or there's an expansion associated and each of these are potential options for expansion. Agreed. I'm happy with that. I think we're fine. There's no motion. No motion. Well, he never really got around making a motion. I thought yours was good. I will stop making motions to make a motion. Yours was good. We will... Second. No. No. There was no motion to make a second. Upon. He made a motion. Did I? Yeah, that you weren't going to make any motion.
3:23:59 Thank you. Okay. Does staff have everything they needed from us on agenda number nine for this evening? It's always something to check back with. We may need to follow up with Councilmember Wentworth to discuss your items. Thank goodness for Granicus. Correct. And if not something that's going to come back, I think that's going to take a little bit of time.
3:24:27 Correct. Because it's going to involve... Take your time, and I think we all push out importantnesses to us and to the community, so please take your time to get it right. Okay. So at this point, council will be going into closed session. We have two items to discuss there. One is a property issue. The other is a personnel issue. Do we have to pack up our stuff? No. We have to pack up our stuff.