Town Council
· recording 3 hr 15 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
399 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:01 Okay. Okay.
3:52 I will call this workshop to order for my fellow council members who probably haven't been sitting on the council side for any of these workshops. I'll just remind you really quickly that this is the opportunity for the Recreation Commission to bring forward things. I presume they'll have a presentation and hopefully some room for comments from us at the end. So with that, I don't know. Is Betsy in charge here? I think we're going to start about this. Oh, okay. All right.
4:21 Okay. Let me kick off briefly on a couple of things. Kind of one reason getting here and doing where we're at. Stu will kind of walk through some of the where we're at in the recreation world and then go to the commissioner. Part of this is coming forward out of a whole discussion, the creation of Mammoth Lakes Recreation and looking at
4:43 What does that mean for the Strategic Vision Change of the Rec Commission? So Stu and I actually spend part of their time at the staff level than through Stu up to the commission. Trying to take a look at how do we refocus, if you will, our community recreation efforts, our Mammoth Lakes Town Recreation Program, and begin to look on that. At the same time, how does the Recreation Commission interface with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and Mammoth Lakes Tourism?
5:13 As we look at growing the recreation experience and elements here in Mammoth Lakes and frankly our broader region where it reaches out in South County and other areas as well. Based on the MLR formation, the direction from the council moving that forward with staff is really to work with the rec commission in redefining the role and responsibilities and that focus going forward. So that's taking a little bit of time as we've got...
5:39 It's at least one new commission, so hopefully Clayton's well up to speed, ready to go, and hit them all cylinders. But working through that with that change going forward. And also, we actually have a contract in place with Mammoth Lakes Recreation now. That took particular elements and defined what that direction is. I still think that's going to have a little work for the next six months, nine months, and that comes on board when you work through those areas.
6:03 But given those things, we took a look at a couple of areas. One, I know the Rec Commission had a lot of discussion looking at the ordinance that sets forth roles and responsibilities. And really at this point, I think the primary thing that I was looking at there is we have the ordinance that was approved after Measure R was passed. It said the Rec Commission reviews that. Then we've had the expenditure plan come into play and say we're going to have MLR do that. So from a practical standpoint, we've shifted that to MLR. I'm not worried about an ordinance amendment at this point. We'll just assume that it's...
6:32 Kind of held in advance on the rec side. That works for folks. I'd be able to do that. But then also taking a look at the recreation strategies, the data, the work that the rec commission's been doing over a good period of time, and taking the 2010 recreation plan, taking some information out of the MLR work that come back in and say, based on that, where do we see community recreation moving to? Where do we see Mammoth Lakes Recreation as a town function going?
7:00 And so we've had a lot of discussions, kind of how do we focus this on people, how do we reach out, how do we touch more of our residents, more of our visitors, how do we enhance our programming, I think we're doing a good job in a lot of areas, in areas that grow in others, really making that meaningful to our community. And then also looking at, I'll call it the promotion of it, the advocacy of it. Again, I think that's a great role for the rec commission, is how do we champion municipal recreation through our community and people.
7:29 Which I think is a different function than the MLR side and some of the work that's going on there. So we've been working through that and then the decision was kind of to come back, run this up to the rec commission, spend some time, bring it back in this form. Ultimately, kind of, okay, this is where the rec department, rec commission is going. Council, are we on the right track? Kind of that check-in, bussing, discussion. Here's where we're charging off to, make sure we're going in the right direction.
7:55 And I think that's kind of the confirmation we're looking for from the discussion here and formal action by the council. So as we work through that, they requested the council meetings to prove kind of the vision and strategy document that we've put in the staff report. I think there's a lot that's gone into that. There's a lot of different work that the commission's involved in and will be involved in. So we want to be able to make sure that the two bodies move in the same direction. That's an important thing.
8:22 And given that, we've had a lot of different things going on. I want students to just kind of touch on kind of those, I call it, you know, people programs and promotion, what we're doing out there. And I think there's a lot of stuff happening. We won't get a chance to tutor at home or as much as we like to on some of these programs. Unless you have children, we've got a couple of employees who do that well. With that, so that's kind of why we're here, kind of working through that process to changing nature and dynamics.
8:51 But with that, let me turn on Stu for a minute just to touch on kind of the broader picture of what we're doing in the recreation program, different things happening there, and then back over to Pittsburgh.
9:03 So I like one-page stuff. I know I'm a council. I know my commission likes everything on one page. So I'm just going to briefly talk about this document called Recreation by the Numbers. It's really a summer snapshot that kind of demonstrates the core purpose of what we do, community recreation, and the key role as the commission plays in chanting and, as we said, advocating for recreation.
9:27 So I'm just going to hit the highlights here. This is kind of from mid-May through mid-September. You can see camp participants since 2010 have increased by 55%. The department connected with over 1,200 individuals this summer, ranging from 5 to 70. So you can see we're kind of reaching a good demographic there. We want to obviously CAD on either end as we move forward. We programmed over 33 unique youth adult programs.
9:57 We have 909, just under 1,000, ActiveNet registered customers in a new database, which is great. And then through that, they'll actually go and connect with us. We can communicate with them. They can buy their products online. We can have more of a two-way dialogue with those customers, which is great. And then through that system as well, we reserve over 7,250 facility hours. And that really speaks to a lot of the facility use hours of all our youth organizations.
10:25 Book those facilities for including customers. So you can see that process and that system is really enhancing our efficiency of the department. So through the connections that we make in our programs, parks and our many facilities, the Recreation Department is directly contributing to the development of a strong family in our community and rich quality of life and most importantly a healthy and vibrant community.
10:51 So the document that we're going to go through tonight that the Commission's going to speak to and what we've been working on for the last several months is this one here, which is exhibit B, is really about the value of community recreation. It's really what we do, the core purpose, the fundamental, the reason why we exist. We also want to talk about the key role that the Commission plays, understanding the role that MLR is going to play, the delineation of those functions, right? So we make sure that we're clearly focused, defined,
11:21 Very targeted, you know, going away from a shotgun approach, but really focusing on what we really want to deliver, what the council expects us to deliver, what the community wants us to deliver. And finally, it runs through the five strategies which are overlaid on top of the strategies accepted in 2010. So the 2010 recreation plan that was voted on by council, through really a lot of that MLR process, we are overlaying on top of that.
11:50 So they're still there, they're not going away, we're just further refining it, if that makes sense, right? So we're kind of building the pointy tip of the spheres. We really want to kind of build our connections to our community. And as Dan mentioned before, we're really kind of, we use kind of three words, people, programs, promotions, right? So we're all about connecting with people, providing programs that they need through the camps, sports programs, facilities.
12:14 And how we promote and communicate those programs. So it's kind of people, programs, and promotions. As we move forward, the commission will start to see the department structure our material in that way, right? So you can kind of really see what focus people, programs, and promotions. So through that, I think we're really well positioned to kind of meet and see our expectations and certainly the needs of the community. So that was really it. So you've got preparation by the numbers, kind of snapshot of what we do in a timeline of a few months.
12:44 And then our strategic document, and then moving through people, parks, and people, programs, and promotions. Parks are in there somewhere, but more to do with programs. Let's start with P's. It's really about parks, but we put the parks, project, anyway. People, programs, and promotions. With that, I'll hand it back to the new chair. Great. Well, I wanted to first of all thank everyone for coming. It was really important to the commission, because, you know, we're a new commission. We have to be with us now, and step into this chair role.
13:12 We have a new council. So we really wanted to get everyone together at the table just to make sure that they're all on the same page moving forward. And as we all know, the MLR contract is now set and we're moving forward with that. So I wanted to just briefly bring us back to when we started the whole MLR process two summers ago now.
13:35 One of the strong recommendations that came out of that process was to preserve the Municipal Recreation Program while moving ahead with further consideration and design possibilities for MLR in the context of an overall effort to augment and enhance all of our creation within the community. I think what really came out of those workshops was that everyone was very happy with, you know, what students and the department were doing, but that we had some, you know, there were some larger opportunities that could be tackled by what has now become the MLR organization.
14:04 So the way that the Commission sees it, and we'll find out if this is how the Council sees it as well, is that, you know, NLR will really be focusing on that big picture, you know, research, development, investment, while community recreation is tasked more, you know, with, you know, our operations, people, programming, promotion, you know, our local program, and parks too, because, you know, for
14:32 Our local facilities, I think that the commission is really kind of the boots on the ground. We spend a lot of time in the parks. We spend time, you know, on the in-town bucks. We kind of have a good understanding of, you know, where those amenities are and what they might be. And we see the commission having a very complementary role with MLR. We expect that this is going to be a really collaborative relationship that's really going to benefit the community and our visitors and just the region as a whole.
14:59 So with that, I'd like to turn it over to the commissioners to talk a little bit more about revision, and then we'd love to get some comments back from the council. So, Sean. Yeah, and I guess I'm going to speak a little bit just about what the Recreation Commission's role is going to be as we change into MLR. And some of the things that, you know, I like the concept of the people, programs, and parks. No, public promotions. Thank you very much.
15:24 Because really that is what the Recreation Department, what the Recreation Commission is going to continue to oversee and focus on. So in saying that, you know, it's easy just to say that, but I do want to actually read kind of verbatim what the strategies are of the Recreation Department. A, to refocus the work program of the Recreation Commission. So that's us. Maintain and enhance the town's existing recreation infrastructure.
15:53 Deliver innovative, expanded, and affordable community-centric recreation programming, strengthen organizational systems and structures, and develop team capacity and organizational culture. And in each one of those, I just want to touch on briefly, is that we as the Recreation Commission, as Betsy talked about, are really going to be focusing more on what's happening in the community, formerly known as municipal.
16:17 We're actually really focusing more on what's happening inside the community. Continue to maintain and enhance the existing recreation infrastructure. Continue to deliver innovative affordable community centric programming.
16:35 Camps, that's A&I, the parks get to, on a subcommittee, get to be involved in that. Are your camp counselors, is that funny? Little did I realize it. Continue to make sure that the structures and systems are in place and are going forward and really the team capacity and just maintain the organizational culture of the entire community recreation program.
17:02 I am going to touch on what the focuses are, and I am going to read from this list just so it's clear as well. I'm not going to read every single word in here. Essentially the tasks of the Recreation Department are to provide administrative support for the Recreation Commission, provide innovative programming, effectively signate promotions, schedule community events, as well as provide special event support, which is critical.
17:32 To some of our best similar events. Youth supports, continue to coordinate, support the delivery of those. Reporting, need to provide regular department updates. Develop rules and regulations and maintain those rules and regulations. Annually evaluate our fuse structure. With regard to our program evaluation, conduct regular performance evaluations. Disseminate customer surveys as we collect them. Provide facility operations and programming.
18:01 It ties in directly to what the strategies are. Deliver exceptional administration. Manage our financial management. Coordinate facility maintenance, which is something that we get regular reports on. Support public works in our work with them. Implement parks and recreation planning and management. Annually review capital and maintenance required. Administer parks management.
18:31 Also, bring together stakeholders for collaboration, and that needs to continue with our recreation meetings as well, recreation physicians as well. And then engage with MLR, and I think that's going to be one of the important things that we may want to discuss here, is going to be how exactly is the recreation going to deal with MLR, and I think that's what we're talking about today. So, with that, I think I've said what I need to say. Thank you.
19:01 And I'd just like to point out, I think that the commission is really excited about all the things that our staff delivers and just all the efforts. It's been really exciting going through all the successes of the past summer. We're really looking to take that great work and just keep building on it. So Terry, you want to talk a little bit about organizational structure? What really needs to, and kind of something that I've been looking to see how we're going to coordinate,
19:32 Is how we work, how the Recreation Commission works with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the town's staff, whether it be our recreation staff, our maintenance staff, and so that we're complementing each other as opposed to trying to fight for the same thing and so that we can delineate what our duties are.
19:57 In the MLR organization, it is on the board, there's a liaison from the rep commission to MLR. And it hasn't came to the rep commission yet, but it's been, you know, potentially suggested that it goes, you know, the opposite direction as well. That there's an MLR liaison that works with the rep commission.
20:21 And then the other thing that I had suggested is some kind of a round table or something, and I think it's really important for us to have that communication and make sure we keep those lines of communication open. So, you know, do we consider a biannual round table workshop with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, the Rec Commission? Do we add staff in there? Is Mammoth Lakes Tourism somebody else that we want to add into that so that we can all kind of set each year in
20:51 Be on the path that each of us feels that is going to complement the town and that we're not duplicating efforts. So I think that that's something that we should look at moving forward. So how we engage the community, the town, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and our recreation commission is just going to be really key.
21:23 Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, we just, we really see this as a very collaborative relationship with, you know, with NLR and, you know, of course anything, you know, that's built, you know, with public money has to be, you know, built and managed by the town. So there's going to be a lot of complementary relationships and I think everyone's really looking forward to the possibilities for what NLR is going to bring to the community. Yeah, because it's going to be key as we're building things is looking at, you know, what are the,
21:51 Needs that MLR is looking at for what their purpose is for those facilities. What is the recreation for the community recreation? What are those needs? And then what do we get from the community outside that we're not seeing and we're not getting? So it's just, it's getting that stool all put together. You're going to call it a three-laying. It's five or six. Yeah, I counted more than three. I like the idea. It's almost like the Synergy Center. It is, yeah.
22:21 What did you call that? The group that was here at your last commission. And we see it. Stuff like that, where all these people are going to get that. There's a common theme throughout this, and we've had that discussion, is that high level of communication that needs to be happening across, so people aren't surprised that it is complementary versus competitive in a lot of those areas. Ultimately, we'll have to clean up some of the formalized stuff with the ordinance and stuff like that. I think that can come after we get our feet under us and kind of lower-headed.
22:48 Because then we're not second-guessing ourselves and trying to write something that we think is what we're doing, and then six months later, oh, we have to change that. So hopefully we get that communication going, that's done, I don't know, I'm going to say it correctly, that's not the right term, but I guess in concert with whatever people are taking.
23:07 The element to go to. I would say we're looking for efficiency and non-duplication. We really clearly delineate those roles in the ordinance. We decided not to move forward with it until we were really at a point where we felt like we had those roles clearly defined and we think this is kind of tonight as kind of the first step in that process. So is there anything else you wanted to add about the ordinance stand? No, I think it would be something we're going back. I just think that the issue for me initially looking at it, we have an inherent conflict with two directions for this.
23:37 Two different bodies. I think we just let one be subservient to the other at this point based on the direction we received. Versus either amending it now and amending it again and that it just seems that operationally we can deal with it based on the direction we have from Council. So that seems to be the simplest and probably the most efficient way to handle it at this point in time. So ultimately, I've got to say it, we begin to work and dialogue through. I think some other changes would probably come out of that naturally versus trying to guess it at this point.
24:05 And I presume you guys want to do all your presentations and then get information from us, right? Yeah, that would be terrific. And stepping into the chair role, obviously I have literally and figuratively some very big shoes to fill. So I'd really love for Bill just to talk a little bit about where he sees the commission in the department over the next few years and what might be the best role for us to plan moving forward. First,
24:36 I hope that tonight is the last time I hear municipal recreation. I do not view, and this is just me personally, this is not the commission, that the role of the recreation commission is going to change all that greatly. If a trail gets built by MLR, it's going to be maintained and programmed probably by the rec commission. So this isn't something where we both go down different paths.
25:05 This is a true partnership. It has to be a partnership. There has to be a daily collaboration at the staff level. And if a meeting is needed, then we need to have the ability to call a meeting between the two and not move on. One of my fears in going over this is that the town would retreat and say, we are now municipal. We are going to be AYSO. We're going to be a swimming pool. You have to deal with everything else because the reality is
25:33 That Mammoth is different from most municipalities. Our recreation includes a much broader. Therefore, everything from general fund support to Measure R and Measure U support need to be spread over a broader base. So I see the commission and the board of MLR working side by side as well as the staffs to develop that plan to move forward. What is the right infrastructure to move forward with first?
26:01 The Council and this Commission have worked long and hard on prioritizing some of those things. And I would hate to see a segue now because we're moving to a board rather than a commission. So five years from now, I am hoping that MLR is running the campgrounds on the Indian National Forest, that they are doing things so far out of the box that we now think about.
26:29 That they have the capacity to be entrepreneurial in that way to help with all things recreation and that the Rec Commission is working with them as a partner and we are jointly working on the task of snow management that is in grooming the trails in the wintertime and trails maintenance in the summer because we know the Forest Service has no money for that and working on the MOUs with the Forest Service to build the trails that are necessary to increase our
26:58 Recreational capacity. If we want to move beyond a 30% annual occupancy rate, we have to build our recreational capacity. And I think the two groups working together can do that. As long as we don't define the role so closely in that you can only do this and you can only do this, and then they become competing agencies rather than siblings, because that's really what they should be.
27:25 This is a brother-sister relationship here, and it needs to work as a family. And in five years, that's what I'm hoping to see, that they have gotten off the ground and are working as a non-profit recreation organization with full-on business capacity to operate programs and to bring things in that the town on its own cannot do, and that we are partnering with those efforts, and we are programming cross-country skiing.
27:55 And maybe some hosts for the trailheads that we have and those kinds of things. Because it seems to me at this point that's programming that would be part of what the recreation department would be doing. So I don't want him to be leaning back in his chair saying,
28:22 I finally have some time to get some stuff done. I want to keep the boys plate full. And I want to see us move forward in that. So this is exciting to me if we can make it move forward in that way we can accomplish some things. If it becomes a no, this is your job, no, this is my job, then we end up cross-purpose and competing for the same dollar instead of enhancing the same dollar. So that's my hope in the next five years.
28:49 And areas of interest for the municipal recreation, cross-municipal out, collar recreation, and our areas of interest should be the same that they have always been. Just our place will be, our burden will be lessened to some by the dollar making and those decisions that we're going to be helped with with our sister organization. In their case, it will be a brother organization.
29:20 Thank you very much, Bill. I think we all recognize just the many, many years of service that Bill's put in as the chair of his commission, and I think we're all very appreciative, and we're glad that he's still here. I'm glad to hear Dan talk about the fluidity of these
29:50 Things that we're doing, the rules that we're going to operate by need to be fluid because in the next year and a half, two years, I see this changing a lot. This is not a thing. Well, I have that natural symbiotic relationship that it's hard to say what that's going to look like. Right. Well, I think we all see this as a process moving forward and we all just want to work together to make that successful.
30:16 I'd just like to turn over to Clayton now as our newest member and kind of give his impressions. As you've heard, I'm the new guy on the recreation. I have a fairly extensive history in recreation locally and has been involved in some of the recreation.
30:39 Development, Trails Development Programs for the years here. I'm actually really excited now to have a chance to be part of the Recreation Commission. For me, what I'm really most excited about is kind of what's going on here. I think really the thing that we're going to be addressing as I see it for the next couple of years is this establishing this relationship and dynamic between MLR and the Rec Commission.
31:08 How all of these things are going to sort out, and that's what I'm excited to be here for. So there are obviously a lot of things going on in recreation. It's more recreation-centric. The next phase of Whitmore, I'd really like to see that get off the ground at some point here. This stuff is going on right now.
31:39 So I think we'd like to take some comments, you know, some feedback now from the council after you've kind of heard this vision. And we'd love to know, you know, what, how the council sort of sees these two, or I mean, both MLR and the commission, you know, will advise your bodies to the council in different ways. So I think it would be helpful to all of us to hear from you, you know, how you envision that if that lines up with what we're seeing.
32:07 Okay, who wants to go first? Well, I will read Shields. And it's funny how pertinent it will be even though he wasn't able to be here in the room. Or do you want me to read that first? No, I can. Okay, go for it. It's with great pleasure that I sit here at this table with a lot of familiar faces. They've done a lot of work and a lot of things over many years. And it occurs to me that what we're really looking at now, I think finally,
32:38 We're really starting to get into the true implementation business. And I think that the way that the work that I read here and how you guys are defining the kinds of things that you're going to focus on, and I think that the term community recreation as a term of art, and I hope that, you know, it's going to be very important going forward in coordinating all these efforts that the terminology, the terms that we use are very clear, and we use them. We use them intentionally, we use them purposely.
33:07 So community recreation, what that means, what falls within the scope of that, we've got to work those kinds of things out, but so it's sort of clear, well, community recreation means this, it lives over here, this is how these things are working, wherever MLR gets up to, it still lives over here, and that's what this is, because we're all going to have to, a lot of paperwork, a lot of consultants, a lot of facilitation, we're at a point now, we've got to bring all this stuff together and start really delivering.
33:31 And, you know, the paperwork and the ink and the charts and all that stuff only gets you so far. And at some point, we as a community have to get our act together and we have our act together and to start to implement the great things that we want to do. So it's a very exciting time. It's very, it's a...
33:49 It's great to be at a point where after many years we're finally at a point of saying, okay, we're going to really start moving some of these things forward. So this term community recreation I think is important. I think it's really important to inhabit that term with the specifics of what your program are and what the things are that you're focusing on. One of the benefits about MLR is that you guys, the staff you have within the town is no longer running around running MeasureR and MeasureU grant processes. You've got the staff that you have.
34:17 The work I've seen Stuart do in the last couple of years is inspiring. I think the way, the ambition that we're seeing from that department with technology, with programming, with this kind of focus is really exciting. And I think it's going to be a great thing for you guys to be working with the staff in that world to bring these things forward. I'm particularly encouraged by the use of technology and how that's being used. And I'm looking forward to figuring out how to take...
34:42 The programming things that you're doing, working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, to getting all these things getting pushed out to the world, that the programs that you're getting, wherever these things are coming from, someone coming here, you're not, they can avail themselves of these things. And I think the liaison thing is extremely important. I think one of the priorities of the Council is something we've called these Synergy Summits, which we've been talking about, which is to start...
35:07 You know, bringing all the implementation bodies together, instead of having the conversation of, okay, now who is doing what, who needs what from whom, so we can start really building the capacity to deliver this whole complement of things we're going to do. It's huge, the kinds of things we're going to be doing. But it's going to require, you know, you put that implementation hat on, what does it take to get things done? Who's on first? Who's doing what? How do we have the conversations to get these things figured out as we move the whole ball forward?
35:36 A couple things that we'll talk about tonight, because this is on the agenda, but I'm very interested in knowing, you know, we're not going to promise anything, but I think I would very much like to know how we can get more funding into your community sports organizations. I think that that's a classic opportunity where we can get funds out to those folks who are going to leverage a lot of capacity, and that's something that I think we need to look at in terms of the budget to get some more money going those ways and to really do good things with that.
36:05 And I had a question about number B, Roman Numbers 7, support efforts to plan and construct a program and operate an indoor multi-use high altitude training facility as recommended by the Parks and Recreation Plan on RecStraps 2. And it's a detailed kind of a thing, but I'm wondering if this is, does this follow the program of high altitude training or is this like the recreation center that we've been talking about? These are the kinds of things in terms of defining what these things are so that
36:33 You know, we're all using the same terms for the same things. We're not confusing ourselves. We're churning ourselves by language that isn't exacting. So we can come back to that later, but I just kind of picked up on that process.
36:45 Well, I think the key word in that is probably support this effort, so I think, you know, we had a lot of really good feedback on the planning process about, you know, what that type of facility might look like, and so I think that moving forward would be what that reference is. Okay. I think also the role that you guys are going to play in terms of keeping an eye on the existing town's infrastructure, what you've got, where it is in the life cycle, what's needed for maintenance and all the rest of it, you know, measure R can be used to enhance.
37:11 We've all been through these discussions many times so that you guys have your eyes and ears on what that infrastructure looks like and then hopefully there's going to be more infrastructure coming your way. So my thoughts. Okay, Colin. Sure. Well, I mean, this is great. You know, thank you everyone for being here and for kind of working through this before we get too far down the road. But like most of the people at this table, you know, I was involved pretty early on in the MLR formation process.
37:40 I think most of us identify the desire to really see how those two organizations can really complement each other. So it seems like we're all pretty much on the same page here, that the important thing to lay out is what the focus of these two organizations are going to be and where the delineations lie and where they need to operate and lock stuff. And I do very much like the suggestion of kicking back a board member in each direction.
38:10 I think that's been one of the benefits throughout the MLR process is that having recreation commissioners on that formation board, having council members on that formation board, there's a very good synergy between what the necessary roles of those groups are. So I would support that. I think biannual at least, maybe even more than that. We should have those type of synergy summits where we're looking at
38:37 How Recreation Commission, MLR, MLT, the town all function together. And I think there's obviously in a lot of cases there's things that are more community based and maybe some things that are more tourism based when we talk about recreation in a broader sense. But in a lot of cases those things aren't mutually exclusive. So, you know, who's going to kind of handle each area is kind of what we need to sort out.
39:04 But I think we've all agreed that the reason that everyone lives here for the most part and the reason that everyone visits here in some capacity is for recreation and the opportunity to recreate. So it's a big enough chunk that there's more than enough work for Stu and his department and MLR and the Recreation Commission. You know, I personally, I think Shields actually said this probably better than I will, but
39:28 You know, I view MLR being very entrepreneurial, looking at funding, leveraging, and building infrastructure. In some of my conversations that I've had with Stu, some of the frustration for community recreation and the recreation department is, number one, we've been hamstrung by some of our facilities. We don't have the ability to program certain things that we would like to do because we're deficient in those facilities. And I see MLR really going out, building that infrastructure, and then allowing.
39:58 Our recreation department to program it. So I think that works very well synergistically there. The other thing is it seemed at times he wanted to tear his hair out because he was being pulled in 50 different directions. So what this allows us to do is really have a more laser focus on what the recreation commission does, how that works with MLR. Just need to have a clear focus for what they're going to do when they're implemented. But it seems like we're on the same page, you know.
40:27 Distinguishing what the focuses are going to be and how they're going to work in conjunction. I did have a question on kind of this report that we've had here. You know, a lot of this is focused around summer activity, which is obviously the focus of your department, but we do have some winter elements as well. It would be helpful for me as someone that's participated in both winter and summer activities. You know, can you talk a little bit more about your winter program as well and how that fits in?
40:55 That would be the only suggestion I have as far as a question. And I don't think I have much else to add, I think. Okay. I will paraphrase a little bit from Shields' letter, which I think is part of the public record, isn't it, Jamie? Yes. But there were some specific things. First, he wanted to apologize for not being able to attend. And what is funny is he starts out calling it municipal recreation, and by the end of the email, he's changed it to community recreation, which is essentially what we're trying to do here.
41:24 As a past commissioner of tourism and recreation, I realize while TOT is the economic backbone of our community resort, recreation is the heart. We are blessed to have the beauty and natural surroundings of the eastern Sierra. Those of us lucky enough to live here are able to walk out our back door and experience the daily wonderment of it all. We need that daily stimulation of recreation, whether it's hiking, skiing, fishing, biking.
41:47 Skating, swimming, boating, soccer, softball, running, etc. We like to be on the move, and so do our visitors and second homeowners. We as a town have recently embarked on a strategic initiative to enhance our recreational opportunities that will benefit both our community and those visiting. With the funding of MLR, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, we understand that to have an effective municipal recreation...
42:08 We need to remove the building and infrastructure components. Municipal Recreation is the operator, programmer, daily organizer, and boots on the ground for our in-town family and visitor recreation. They are the eyes and ears. They are customer service.
42:23 Municipal Recreation is vital to our, excuse me, is vital our, I guess it was supposed to be a two, our community, and to the success of MLR, working in unison to understand the recreational needs of our community and its visitors. MLR will fund, leverage, and build infrastructure. MR will then program staff, maintain, and operate. We are fortunate to have Stu Brown and the dedicated and longstanding staff at Municipal Recreation, along with an impassioned recreation commission.
42:49 I'm in support of the vision and strategic direction of municipal, parentheses, community, recreation is headed. So I think that kind of summarizes what we've been saying. There's just a couple of things I would like to add myself, and that's...
43:03 And those that are longer standing know what Ms. Clayton is. I always thank the commission for all the work they've done so far and for what they're going to do in the future. I like the round table idea. I think that, though, to get us started, it's almost maybe a working group, a couple of recreation commissioners, a couple of whatever it works out to be. So from the council side, I'd like to say,
43:29 Go out, figure out how to make that all work, and come back to us when it's appropriate with how you've worked out the roles and responsibilities. And I think that everything that's been said here tonight falls into that as well. And I don't see this next one lightly, but I see that there's a renewed energy in the commission, and maybe that is because now you've got a focus and you're not quite stretched so thin, and I know staff is...
43:54 Not having time to sit back in their chairs, but I think there's a recognition that there is a focus, and I like that throughout the vision and strategic direction for community recreation. You know, some of us still refer to some of the buildings in this town as one that used to be the Safeway or they used to be the whatever, so it'll take a lot to switch it around, and I really like that direction of calling it community recreation. And then the final thing I would say is that
44:23 I see that everything is here for us to grow recreation. And I think that is really important. So I'm looking forward to seeing some of these things that come in. So you've just got four P's. It's people, parts, programs, and promotion. Just take four instead of trying to figure out which one you're going to take out. And it's good to see, as you're discussing, we are growing as is right now. So there's obviously a need and a demand for it.
44:54 You know, as strapped as funding's been, as understaffed as we've been, and we're still seeing user increases. We are, and I think that there's also many things. I agree with you, Colin, that certain things we can't expand because we don't have the facility yet, but on the other hand, I think we can fully program what we have, and I think there's ways to be creative about that so that we're really maximizing what's in place so far while we continue to grow that side of it, the actual.
45:24 Something to do it in. You guys can come with the eyes of something to do, but the location, it's a... Yeah, I think we... It's a... Yeah, we need to recognize where those opportunities are and where we're kind of constrained at this point. So then the question becomes, how big can we make Mammoth Recreation in the long run? You mean community recreation? No, I mean MLR. Oh, okay. So the town has always had needs for infrastructure.
45:52 But also for programming that may lie outside of the Recreation Department. Guys, we can hire them, they can hire them as a non-profit. In our meeting with the Events Coalition the other day, one of the points that I brought up, being that I am old and decrepit and have been in this town all the time, is that this town has had many, many really good events in them that have gone by the wayside because when the passion of the people that start them goes,
46:23 The support for them goes and we lose it. We're probably going to lose the Jazz Festival this year. That's huge. I know it was declining over the last several years, but that's huge. Can Mammoth Lakes Recreation, MLR, grow into an organization with an event arm as well that could help with things like the biathlon, the tries, and even some of the music events?
46:49 We've seen when an event goes from one promoter to another and lasts a long time, what someone can do with it, as we've done with Louisa Palooza. I would like to see them be entrepreneurial enough, even though events can lose money, they can also make money. We all have them. Where if one of our events that is a success, that is putting heads in our bed, is in danger of going under, that they would have that event coordinator, that person working events,
47:18 Besides the Municipal Recreation, which is issuing permits for it, so that it doesn't become lost. One of the things we've looked at as a town, what I'm trying to do is get you guys to think way outside of that box, because I think that we've been putting MLR inside this box, and I don't think we need to do that. I think it needs to be outside of that. There are things that we need, and when we see those, it should be nimble and quick-acting enough to pick up on some of that.
47:47 Sean goes away tomorrow, we've got an event person residing within MLR who could then pick up that event so that we don't lose POT. It's something that's saving our vacant for three years and we've been doing that because of that. I'm not saying that's the only thing. I'm just, you haven't even heard those suggestions and I'm here to say that I think it needs to be entrepreneurial enough to do that.
48:16 And someone like Sean and others have shown us that events don't need to be money losers after the first couple of years. I think there's a couple of points there, I think, that in terms of the bigness of this, I think that when we're looking at a drought that we're in right now, we're looking at a lot of things that are changing very rapidly. And if you look at between community recreation, MLR,
48:38 Whatever's going on with the ski area, whatever the future looks like. If you look at the tools we're putting together, we have an opportunity to deliver a 365-day-a-year recreation experience that everybody's going to have to be nimble enough to adapt to a whole slate of changing conditions, and I would encourage everybody to be thinking along those lines because, you know, we're going to need that. As a community, we're going to be looking at challenges that are
49:06 That are basically existential in a lot of ways. And I think the degree to which we can work efficiently and effectively together to provide amenities that are going to make this place, this community, a thriving and going concern no matter what nature or things throw at us, that's got to be kind of a thing that we're looking at from all aspects of recreation. And I think also that I don't think we want to be competing with the private sector in terms of
49:33 Events and things like that and what entrepreneurs can bring to it. And I think the kinds of things that we can do in terms of providing infrastructure and facilities to make these things happen I think is important. But I would just encourage all of us to be looking at a very, to your point, not being big and a larger picture, a very, very big and large picture and really looking down the road at what this place looks like in 25, 50 years in terms of how we're going to be surviving up here. Business research. Whatever, yeah. Two summers ago, we wanted a really entrepreneurial organization.
50:10 That's what MLR is going to do. I'm really excited about it. I wanted to just go back for a minute, too, to talking about working with our current facilities, and I wanted to just really call it a Brady Dutton and the color works department for really engaging candidates, too, in the department in terms of what can we do to make these things work. Can we paint the sideboards on the ice rank black? Will that help keep the ice melt down until you can get a group on the thing?
50:35 A little refreshing with the community sense there, and I wanted to say that I think that the commission is very appreciative. Thank you. Any further comments? If you can add one thing, it's been kicked around the rec department's MLR and earlier discussion. As we talk about recreation, it's been touched on here, but just a reminder, I think, that recreation, and I think you all hold the same perspective, that it's not just about athletics and courts and that.
51:02 It embraces a lot of elements of our community, be that arts and culture. We mentioned music. We mentioned the festivals. It's all of that combined that makes Mammoth unique and makes it also diversified and enjoying a number of different ways, whether you're riding a snowmobile, a mountain bike, or sitting underneath a tree listening to great music. So I think you all said that in the past. I just want to reemphasize, we talk about recreation. It's not traditional recreation with little r. It's truly big recreation.
51:32 Yeah, it's bigger than... And actually, I have one point to ask my fellow Councilmembers, is there consensus to direct the Commission to go work with MLR and work out that cooperative relationship, partnership, whatever we're calling it? Yeah. So that we don't have to take that. We can do it. Go do it. I'll do it. John Luke Picard. Make it so. Is there, you know,
52:02 Thank you for kind of circling this back to action steps here. Is there anything you guys need from council at this point? I brought my checkbook. It's almost enough. Anything you need from us other than some policy direction that we just want to see.
52:27 A good synergistic working relationship and a good understanding of where the roles are focused kind of bring back to us how that's going to work itself out. I would just add one thing. I think that hopefully we're going to a new kind of an era. I know there's been a lot of frustration in the past about commissions looking to counsel for leadership and direction and counsel turning around to commissions and saying, well, what is it you guys kind of want to do? I think we're going to be, instead of flipping the switch on that, I think you're going to see
52:59 I think we're looking to lead and we're looking to establish a direction where we're going to go. And I think we're looking to hear from the commission and from MLR, from every, you know, all the partnerships that make this thing work. We're looking to hear your ideas and where you want to see things go. At the risk of we may butt heads or we may have some disagreements from time to time, but I think it's
53:26 It's in all of our interest to start bringing ideas to the surface, bringing new initiatives up, and let's bash these things out and figure out what's going to be the best ones to work. But, you know, if you see a direction you want to go in, I would personally want to encourage you guys to pursue that, follow it, communicate with us, communicate with MLR, but if you've got places you want to go and things you want to get done, let's do it. And I'm just excited to hear, you know, that Council gets here tonight express and...
53:53 Kind of outwardly acknowledge the importance of recreation and the holistic look at recreation. And so hopefully that kind of comes forward in actions and decisions at some point. And then one last question. What is your next meeting?
54:18 Oh, that's right, because of the crazy holidays. No, I was just, so that the sooner that you identify, is it possible at that meeting not just to identify who's going to be the Recreation Christian Liaison MLR, but maybe if that's how you think you're going to go forward with working with it, because MLR will have a couple of meetings before then, and Mike has some suggestions, but we want to get both sides talking as soon as possible.
54:46 Can I ask you a question, just technically, when is the MLR board seated? October 27th is the annual meeting. So at that point, that's when the new MLR board will be in place? That will be the new board and then designating...
55:04 You know, liaisons, ad-hocs, all that kind of thing. We'll start with that meeting. Okay. Just for your permission. Excuse me. That doesn't mean that there won't be continuing things that happen next Monday's MLR board meeting. Right. Of the tasks that are already in progress. Sure. And interviews are completed at this point, correct? We're still working. We're working on all the follow-up to the interviews. Okay. Uh-huh.
55:28 So October 27th at the library is the MMR annual meeting, which is mostly election board and moving forward. Hopefully there won't be too much work left over that we have to clean up with the old board. That's the MMR library? Yeah. I guess the final thought that I'd like to leave the council is that we are your advisory body and I hope that you really take advantage of that and you can really see us as a resource. If you have questions about what's going on,
55:58 I think we'd all really like to really be able in a position to give you that kind of feedback. And I think it's an exciting time for all of us to be here. Oh, and you know, and you don't have to wait for the next workshop to communicate with us. That's one of the things that I put on the council agendas when I was mayor before was, you know, when we have reports from departments, it can be commissioned as well so that items can come forward.
56:26 Because getting these scheduled is harder than holding tea. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thanks, guys. And I'm really excited about the opportunities that are here and the opportunity to work with you on your priorities. So thank you for the warm welcome that everybody's given me.
1:05:22 Great. Nice to have you here. Nice to meet you. Is there anyone else for public comment? Good evening, Council, Mayor. My name is Ron Cohen. I'm a lieutenant commander for the CHP office in Bridgeport, which covers Mono County all the way down to just south of Tom's Place. And I just wanted to come here tonight to say thank you. I'll be leaving Bridgeport a week from today, taking command at the Moorpark office in eastern Ventura County.
1:05:54 I've enjoyed my two years here, and I wanted to publicly once again acknowledge and thank Chief Dan Watson, one of my regular contacts. This is our third meeting today together since 8 a.m. And thank you for the opportunity to work with your town staff and on many, many of the events that have gone on here, and I've had a great experience. I just wanted to say thank you. The person taking my place has not been selected yet.
1:06:22 And I'll communicate that information to Chief Watson as soon as that decision is made in just a few weeks. So thank you again, and my best wishes to everybody in Mammoth. I'd like to thank you because the communication over the last two years has been wonderful, much beyond what we had seen in the past. And I've conveyed that to my chief in San Bernardino, and I know that the relationships that I've developed here with not only the town of Mammoth Lakes, but the...
1:06:50 People of Mono County that provide services is something that my division commander would like to continue, and they'll be carefully listening to the people they interview's answers with regards to those types of questions. So thank you again. And best of luck. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment? I'm giving you two more seconds. All right. Seeing none, we'll move on to councilmember reports. Colin, can you start, please?
1:07:23 Sure. Just a couple. A couple of things since the last meeting. First of all, my company, Black Tie Ski Rentals, we attended the job fair that was put on by the chamber. Just wanted to kind of acknowledge publicly that I think that's been a really fantastic thing that the chamber has implemented in the last few years. We've been there every year, and this year was no exception. Each year we've hired somebody from the job fair, so I think it's been a beneficial thing for our company and something that businesses in town should take advantage of.
1:07:57 We did have an MLH board meeting that I attended since the last meeting. Not a ton to really report from that. As far as the agenda items, we just looked at a financial overview and an audit, and everything's looking pretty good over there. We did discuss the recent...
1:08:20 Grant funding for a million dollars that Mammoth Lakes Housing has received, so that was exciting news. We've got some more money to work with there. Nothing major to report from that meeting overall. Did have an opportunity with Council Member Wentworth to tour the dump, so I wanted to thank Tony for the opportunity to go out there and see what goes on out there.
1:08:46 Place I've never been to before, and it was good to understand the operations. And then finally, I had a chance this morning to sit down with our new Chamber Director, Craig Schmidt. I just want to thank you for your time. I'm very excited about the new direction of the Chamber. I think working in conjunction with MLT is going to be a really positive thing for our community. We finally got some funding in that organization, which is critically important. And we've got a new Chamber Director and a great board.
1:09:16 That have a good direction and I think we're going to start to see the chamber really being a positive force for our community. It was pretty exciting talking back and forth with Craig. He's got a lot of experience in this field and pretty much anything I brought up that I was interested in seeing the chamber do, his response was, great, I've done that before, I know how it works and I've got experience in that area. So I think he brings a lot of...
1:09:41 Experience and professionalism to the table. So I'm excited to see where that's going to go. That's about it for me. Great. Thank you, Colin. John. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Just two items. One is the trip that Colin took the Benton Crossing landfill. Very informative. Tony's obviously not here, but thanks to him. It was a very interesting tour, very informative tour of that facility. Last night I attended the kickoff meeting for the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative, and I'll provide a bit more of an update on that in the item and the presentation items. All right.
1:10:11 Okay, I have just a couple of items. Remind everyone that the next Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board meeting is next Monday the 20th at 3 p.m. at the library, and we will have our annual meeting on the following Monday the 27th at 3 p.m.
1:10:28 At which point the new board will be seated and afterwards, at location to be determined, we will have a no-host celebration of both welcoming the new board members and saying goodbye to those that would not be carrying forward. So more details to come up on that. The other thing is I would just like to suggest to everyone not that you go and break your wrist, but that you take the opportunity to walk around town on some of our paved paths, our multi-use paths.
1:10:58 That's bike recreation that I've been able to do for the last seven weeks for the most part. But we have an incredible series of paths. They are nice. We're getting more and more connected as we go. And I think I've had just about every inch. So I'd suggest everyone is go out there and use what we've got because they're wonderful. It's a great fall color viewing tool. It's a great fall color tool, yes, especially when you come around the corner and you're face to face with a young buck deer. Yeah.
1:11:28 Added amenities. Added amenities, definitely. Well, in my case, it's don't knock me over. Then I will give a quick announcement on the action taken of closed session. At the October 1st meeting, we had two items. The first related to evaluation of our town manager.
1:11:50 No formal action was taken, but I would like the community to know that we have outlined a process for the future formal evaluation, which will be in collaboration with his anniversary date. And the second item, which had to do with real property, no formal action again was taken. I can report, though, that the town is not pursuing the purchase at this time. That moves us on to reports from commissions and or departments.
1:12:22 Just to, I was going to say, I see lots. What, you're the only one tonight, Dan? Maybe not. Thank you very much. Your other stuff, unfortunately, just fell down. What we have here in front of you is trying to spark a tuning in form. Basically, we're just informing you that after the reorganization chain approved by
1:13:00 Dan Holler, we were able to focus more on collection of the TOT, TBID, business license. What you can see here on the first paragraph or group right there, just for the month of June collected in July, we sent out 132 first notices on people who didn't pay us by the 20th of the month. Everyone here knows the returns are due on the 20th of the month. In July, we sent out 153 notices. August, we sent out 177.
1:13:30 The bottom line is what we're really happy about, and that's the second to the last paragraph. Total collection, since notices have been sent out regularly, is $84,843 in TOT, $14,422.94 in TBID, and penalties and interest. In total, we collect an additional $117,781.59 in going after low-hanging fruit. By sending out the notices,
1:13:58 We reminded people that they owed money on the 20th, and so that helped us out quite a bit financially. The last paragraph is just talking about the business license tax file. We did it in first notice a long time ago. We went out for second notices to see if we can remind people that they did owe money for 2014, and we collected an additional combined $18,174 in licenses and $3,400 in change in penalties.
1:14:28 For a total of $21,574. In total, by chasing the low-hanging fruit, we basically collected $139,356 since July 1. And we're just tooting our horn right here because we're happy we're allowed to focus on low-hanging fruit along with the big items. But by sending out the notices, we move forward. And basically we're following the ordinance as written, sending out first notice and second notice for the remitters.
1:14:56 of TOT, TBID, and the business license file. So, again, we're just happy. We just wanted to tell you that we were happy that we collected the additional revenues by chasing low-hanging fruit. We're happy you're happy. Thank you. Just a couple of quick updates. We're going to finish paving up at the Bluffs this week, and actually the week after, we're going to have a little meeting with some of the property owners up there. They've had some questions about
1:15:31 Exactly what we're doing, and we've spent 500 and some odd thousand dollars of assessment district money, so we're going to sit down with them and go through it and explain what we've done and how long we expect it to last in our maintenance program for it, so we're happy with that. Meridian, as you can see, we're almost done. We're over here doing the concrete on the east side of Old Mammoth Road. We should be striping and finished with that by the end of next week. Same with Canyon. We'll be striping next week as well. We're going to do them both at the same time in terms of the striping.
1:15:58 The only outstanding things on Canyon will be the pedestrian crossing work that we're waiting for some equipment to come in, and that'll be right after that. And on Waterford, all the clearing's done. We've actually working on the footings, and all three major footings through Mammoth Creek Air will be done by the end of this week, and we expect bridge sections to be delivered starting next week. So that's moving forward as well. Thank you.
1:16:23 Thank you, Grady. I have a quick question. Grady, on the new infrastructure, Meridian and the safe routes to school, are you familiar with whether or not there's snow removal budgeted for these new facilities? We've already talked to our snow removal people, certainly for Meridian itself and for the sidewalks, and those will be cleared. So the new sidewalk will be cleared? Yes. Okay, good. Grady, quick question on the crosswalk additions on Canyon.
1:16:48 When are those expected to be in? Will they be in by middle of November, like mountain opening? Yes, in fact, I think it's just a couple weeks out before the signs are delivered. I just don't have a precise delivery date, so everyone won't promise something. But around November 1st, they should be delivered. We already have the place for them, and they're ready to go in, and they're solar. And that would be a quick project once things show up. Yes, absolutely, well before the heavy snow hits. Okay, thanks. Thank you. Stuart Brown, Community Recreation Manager. There we go.
1:17:22 Good, thank you. Practice makes perfect. Thank you. I'm going to wrap up this evening because I don't think Dan's going to be speaking. He's sort of spoken out. But just really quickly, Halloween for the community begins Friday, October 24th. So the annual Haunted Rink Skate Party is at the Mammoth Rec Zone or Mammoth Ice Rink. Depends what season you're in. It's October 24th, begins at 5am, concludes at 8pm.
1:17:51 We've tried to squeeze it in specifically for elementary age children. Admission is only $5. Adults are free. So come along. And then following that is homecoming at the high school. So it's kind of a big evening. So we're just trying to do our Halloween festivities. And then as you know, October 31st is Halloween in the trails. So definitely go by John Urdi's house for the candy. Because we're not there. Anyway, moving along. Winter, Mammoth Eye Shrink scheduled to open.
1:18:22 November 28th, obviously weather dependent, cold, weather, all that situation. But that's our scheduled opening, which is Friday of that Thanksgiving week. New programs this year, a Learn to Skate program, so if you want to come along, you've never skated before, it's kind of a three session program. You can also join our season long figure skating program every Monday and Friday afternoon. So that's new this year as well. We also have a formalized youth hockey
1:18:51 Club, right, so they've actually been kind of more of an ad hoc group, this year actually a formalised group, so we'll be programming those days and times for those kids as well. Unfortunately a roof is not possible this season, however, enhancement said you'll see this year at the rink include a carpeted change room, right, very nice, carpeted change room, your own little cubbies, right, so come and put your stuff in your cubbies.
1:19:17 We'll have some shelving benches. We obviously have those heaters that we had last year. So definitely come along and enjoy a wonderful experience. Finally, the Recreation Commission rescheduled their regular meeting in November from November 4th, which is Election Day, to November 18th. That's all I had. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay. Any other departments? All right.
1:19:45 That will move us on then to presentations. The first is about the Information Technology Strategic Plan and Nate. Well, good evening. Thank you very much for your time this evening. There we go. My name is Nate Greenberg. I'm the IT Director for Mono County and the Town of Mammoth. And the purpose of me coming before you tonight is just to discuss a little bit about how the town...
1:20:30 He's utilizing technology, sort of what we're thinking, where we're going. I've got a bunch of slides in front of you, and I'm going to kind of do my best to talk fast and breeze through them and give you an opportunity to sort of ask questions off of them. But sort of as a way of background, Mono County began providing IT services to the town on an emergency basis last year in May, and we formally signed an ongoing contract in October. I've been on board with the county and the town since 2004 as a GIS coordinator, and when I was
1:20:59 Hired on formally as the IT Director a little over a year ago, I was asked to write the first ever strategic plan surrounding IT for the county and used the same opportunity to sort of address the talent and the technology needs. One of the things that I found really interesting in the last year in just starting to think about technology across the organizations is the collaborative opportunities that exist. And I really feel strongly about the opportunities that are in front of us.
1:21:28 Sort of the benefits that we've already realized. There's a tremendous amount of opportunity in terms of being able to leverage economy of scale, to pool resources, and to really effectively sort of apply budget so that we can get our technologies met across both organizations because a lot of the goals are very, very similar. I threw this slide in just as kind of a lighthearted starting point because
1:21:55 I've talked to my staff a lot about the fact that strategic planning is one of those things that is sort of above and beyond the work we do on a daily basis. And technology folks, especially a lot of my staff, this is not one of the areas that they really like to spend energy. They like to get out there and fix things. But this is an area that is really important to us because without a very clear sort of goal or direction in terms of where we're heading, we don't necessarily know what we're doing and we're constantly reacting to things.
1:22:23 And this is really what we're reacting to sort of on a daily basis. This is a literal dump weighted based on hours out of our time management system and sort of where we're spending the time and top themes in technology that we're working on. And it's diverse and it's extensive and it's kind of ever-changing and growing. So our basis for strategic planning other than that mess that you were just looking at is really this sort of
1:22:52 Credo to do more with less. And this is something that we're seeing across every organization and every government entity in the nation. And really what that means to technology is an impact and an emphasis that's greater than has ever been there before. As organizations look to streamline processes, automate things, find ways to provide users and constituents with more information and better access to it.
1:23:19 The demand on technology and staff that provides the support there is just greater and greater. And so what really I was looking at was how we can evaluate and distinguish our needs versus our wants and really effectively focus on priorities and opportunities such that we're putting budget and time to things effectively and we're able to make decisions as efficiently as possible.
1:23:46 What I knew coming into this position a little over a year and a half ago was that we were a fairly limited staff resource supporting a very large customer base. About 340 full-time equivalents across two organizations, four networks that were spread across 30 remote sites throughout the entire county, and that is including the town. We have a staff of 10. There's six IT specialists and three focused entirely on GIS.
1:24:15 And we have a really high level of demand from our customer base, both internal staff as well as external public constituent base. So I had some general questions kind of coming into this whole thing, which really was centered around where we're spending our time, what we really had on our plate, whether we were doing things the right way and there were more efficient ways to do them, what was really needed from a staffing and a budget standpoint, none of those things that had ever been addressed.
1:24:43 And through kind of understanding those things, could we do things more effectively and efficiently? Where could we more better or better focus our budget and how much money was really needed to do that? And finally, kind of what to start with? What was the low-hanging fruit? I started with just looking at the demands on our time. And for those that don't know, we support a high availability 24-7 network in the law and emergency services side as well as throughout all the departments.
1:25:14 We're balancing top level and high priority needs in our service level agreements with our users against daily support requests from any number of different users. A ton of different PC and peripheral and software support things, training associated with trying to get users using technology as effectively and efficiently as possible. And all of that is sort of being weighed against the project needs, which is really focused on infrastructure upgrades.
1:25:42 The needs to constantly be maintaining and improving the infrastructure and then dealing with just sort of the operational stuff that happens on a daily basis. This slide just looks at sort of how our staff is spending their time and this one I think is a little more interesting which is across sort of the department how we're spending our time and the big pie wedge on the left really goes to show you that half of our time is focused on support.
1:26:09 And one of the biggest goals that I had through this was to figure out how to get that wedge down to be less than 50% so that we're spending more time on infrastructure and making sure that that stuff is working properly and that users are trained and can do what they need without having the constant hands-on. And we're able to sort of embrace technology and really put the energy in the areas that have the biggest impact.
1:26:36 A little bit about the process that we used to sort of drive down the strategic planning road. We started with an information gathering sort of exercise. We had a questionnaire that was sent out to all the department heads and key users within the organizations. It was asking how they saw us using technology efficiently, where we were weak, what opportunities they saw coming down the road, what known projects that they had sort of on the docket and things that we needed to be aware of.
1:27:03 Through that, our staff sort of digested and really looked at sort of the key high-level items that were rising to the surface, and we really used those to kind of build some of our initiatives, which I'll talk about in a minute. Out of that, we developed the standard kind of mission, vision, values types of exercises that you would go through, as well as some top goals and objectives for the next year and three years, and ultimately used a lot of that to synthesize and to think about
1:27:32 What we needed from a budgetary standpoint coming into this fiscal year. And that will be continually refined as we go into future fiscals. I'm going to skip over mission, vision, values. If there's any questions on goals and objectives, I'm happy to answer them. But one of the things that came out of that whole process that I think is the most interesting is these three key initiative areas that we sort of arrived at. The purpose of getting to these initiatives was that, as I'll...
1:28:01 Well, basically, we have 150 active projects, or 150 projects that are identified, I should say, about 50 of which are currently active. And all of those things, they span the gamut of technology, but can more or less be focused into priorities based on these initiatives. And the things that sort of rise to the surface were in these three main categories. The first of those was the communications and broadband area.
1:28:28 And we wrote goals, objectives, approaches, and intended results out of each of these with the intention of basically being able to use this as an umbrella for how we think about and prioritize projects and sort of the value that they have. And I think, you know, Digital 395 is showing us that there's a great number of opportunities coming down the pike and that we can leverage that network and the resources that come with it.
1:28:56 To really start to help save time and money within the organizations and for the public as a whole. There's a lot of different examples of this. Just one for the town is we're looking at a VOIP phone system. Our really quick back-of-the-envelope calculations for that system after the initial investment are saving the town about $40,000 annually. And the rough cost of actually implementing that system could be paid for in the first year of operations of it.
1:29:25 So there's a number of other opportunities like that, video conferencing, which could reduce trips, better access to information from remote sites, which reduces infrastructure costs, and improved access to sort of, I guess you could say disaster recovery opportunities, various things like that. The second big kind of key initiative that we're looking at is business operations and efficiency. It definitely ties into the first, but this is really looking at
1:29:54 Kind of streamlining our business operations through policies and governance that really help us focus how we use technology and the most efficient or best practice industry standard method for doing that. And looking at sort of the outliers within that, things that we're not doing very well or things that we could improve upon. And then also as we implement new things,
1:30:22 Make sure that we're taking into account sort of our governance strategy and what those best practices are. The third is a little less exciting and fun, but it's really the infrastructure and security side. It's what keeps us running on a daily basis and ensures that our customers' information is secure, that the town's business operations are secure, and that staff and the constituents that depend on the staff have the infrastructure and the resources they need to do their job. As we all know, as we've seen through
1:30:53 Some of the recent things with Target and Home Depot, you know, more and more information is accessible out there and as big of a pain in the neck as it is to change your password regularly and deal with some of the just sort of rote security things, there's never increasing demand on that. And we're really focused on ensuring that infrastructure and security meet those standards. I already mentioned that we have over 150 projects in our queue.
1:31:20 And really what that means is that our resource allocation is incredibly important. We basically have an active project management office, and we're spending time not only on working the projects, but ensuring that we're spending the right time on those projects based on the priorities. So I guess in closing, why plan strategically in IT? I mean, at a certain point, I believe that doing more with less can turn into doing less with less. And I think in IT, that's a very, very narrow tipping point. And we have to be careful.
1:31:50 That we apply the right amount of time and the right amount of money to the areas that we can have the biggest impact. Planning strategically to me also gives us the opportunity to tell our story and to make sure that we're focusing our energy in the areas that have the biggest impact, that we're not just constantly responding to the latest trend or the next big idea or just something that somebody comes up with that thinks we should go down that road. By developing those key initiatives, by identifying projects,
1:32:20 By understanding priorities allows us to clearly communicate what we're working on and why. It also allows us to more effectively and collaboratively determine needs and priorities and to apply a budget to that, which is reasonable. So in closing, I guess our next steps really are to continue to work within sort of the construct that we have, the information that we've received. We are taking all of the feedback.
1:32:47 And turning those things into projects or looking at them as opportunities. And we are through that basically developing a formal strategic planning document. You have a very high level of executive summary that was part of the packet. I'm hoping that sort of maybe in the spring we'll actually have a more formalized document at which time we can bring back and present to you and look for feedback on. But we're basically through that process continuing to look for ways that we can redesign the way we provide services.
1:33:17 And ensure that our customers have kind of the best access to information and technology that they need. So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions? I've got some questions, yeah. Nate, thank you very much. It's a really detailed and in-depth presentation, and I really appreciate how you and the county have stepped up to help the town with some pretty glaring technology needs that we had.
1:33:45 I've got some questions, and these are questions
1:34:12 That are, that Dan is around here somewhere to just, is an ongoing nature going forward to start being clear to the community to understand, you know, kind of who's doing what and what the county's role is, what the town's role is. I might ask you to come up sort of some softball kinds of questions to sort of kind of help get the conversation started. So the town's relationship to the county, we are a customer, correct? Technically speaking, yes. We have a contract.
1:34:40 For IT services, it was, I should say, the town has a contract for IT services with the county, and that is a five-year agreement that covers IT and GIS. Okay, so we're paying for services. Correct. Okay, so when you're talking about the strategic planning process, this is the strategic plan for the county's IT department. Actually, no, we're writing a strategic plan as a shared IT infrastructure.
1:35:08 One of the first things that we did in the emergency contract was address infrastructure needs at the town. And what we saw was there was a need for about seven servers. There was also a large data need. That would have been a huge price tag for the town, $100,000 roughly. Sure. And what we were able to do by collaborating on that was to leverage some of our existing infrastructure and just add capacity to that, which by and large basically tied us together.
1:35:37 When we're thinking strategically, we're thinking across both organizations, and incidentally across Mammoth Lakes Police and Mona County Sheriff, and we are thinking about opportunities for collaboration within Mammoth Fire and a lot of the other agencies that we interact with on a regular basis. So this is a comprehensive strategic plan for both county and town. Okay, so we're one of several customers, I guess. Is that a fair way to put it? Well, the PD is really part of the town. The Sheriff is really part of the county.
1:36:07 This is a two-agency agreement, technically. So there's really only one customer, but it's one common strategic plan. Okay. And so where are you at with the strategic planning process right now? So as I said, we have feedback from all the department heads. We've produced that executive summary. And does that include Town of Mammoth Lakes department heads as well as county? It does, yeah. So we basically, we completed that process prior to going into this budget cycle.
1:36:33 And the biggest part of, or the biggest reason for doing that was determining the budget. So we're now in the process of kind of writing the actual document, which is, I would say in some respects, less important than understanding sort of the guts and the contents of that thing and how we do business, but certainly it's a product that will come out of that, and I hope to have that out in the spring.
1:36:54 And so is the town staff involved as part of the strategic planning team? I mean, is Dan involved or is the town involved? Or is that appropriate for us to be involved? Oh, it's absolutely appropriate. I mean, again, feedback was provided by all department heads and it was looked at by our staff. The next steps in that are going back out and engaging or re-engaging the folks that provided us input to look at their priorities and to determine whether...
1:37:21 Things that are being done or looked at in terms of the priority evaluation by IT are in line with what they have in mind. So there will be an ongoing dialogue. Good. I think just two things to kind of wrap up a little bit. This is going to be an ongoing conversation, and it's critical to the success of everybody in this region, certainly these agencies.
1:37:44 From a policy perspective, I think it's not clear to me how we as a town are going to be generating our sort of technology policy, like dig first policies and things like that, and how we're going to, I don't know how we're going to deal with that. That's a question that we need to address, I think. I think also it's going to be important, one of our priorities as a council is to be looking at a 21st century workforce.
1:38:09 And the degree to the relationship of the infrastructure and all the kind of things that we're talking about, how we're going to combine that into our staffing needs and all the rest of it, this is going to be an ongoing conversation. And I think, you know, you've got a very good, very ambitious program and you're working sort of the state of the art for these kinds of things. I think that it's going to be incumbent upon us as a council and probably as an organization to figure out how we're going to effectively engage with this.
1:38:33 It's going to be critically important to our future, and I don't know if we have the tools at this point to do it. I think you've stepped up, and as you mentioned, an emergency contract. I'm assuming it was an emergency kind of a situation. But going forward, we're going to have to take on our own capacity to effectively engage with this stuff going forward. Yeah, and if I may just react to that, I think that the foundation that is within, we'll just say, the document of the strategic plan is really sort of how we do business and what we sort of value in terms of
1:39:03 The role that technology plays. How that plays out, I think that is an obvious ongoing dialogue. So, you know, we make a commitment to sort of a road and then sort of what comes as we go down that road is going to change in terms of projects, in terms of opportunities. So that's where the dialogue, you're right, will be absolutely, it will be very organic in that discussion. Yeah, I think just from a council, we need to figure out how we're going to engage with that. I mean, is it a council?
1:39:31 Committees. It's something that Dan is tasked with dealing with. I don't really know yet, but I think we've been sort of safe from the brink, but I think going forward we're going to have to figure out how we're going to engage with this stuff. So those are my thoughts. Thank you. No questions, just a couple comments. Thank you very much for putting this together. It's very comprehensive, very helpful. You know, I think this is obviously step one, just putting the strategic plan together. I think that's, you know, critical for where we're going with this thing, but
1:40:04 As you mentioned, this technology is changing very rapidly. That historically has not been one of our strengths is being up to speed with those types of things. So it's exciting that we're looking at moving forward with this. Just a couple items on the goals and objectives that popped out at me that really I see as critically important would be items 10 and 8. 10 is upgrading our finance system and implementing an electronic timesheet system.
1:40:32 The second part is not as important, but that's something historically that's really held us back, so I was happy to see that on there. And then also just from kind of a policy standpoint, just talking about implementing digital 395 at all facilities, joining technology and staff to our network, just from a philosophical standpoint, I think that is a huge game changer for us as a region and a community.
1:40:59 You know, everything that we're looking at as a council priority, everything that you guys are doing, obviously, really needs to reference back to how that fits in with leveraging that new technology. So those are a couple of things that jumped out at me, but I just appreciate you putting this detailed list together and, you know, looking forward to working through this strategic plan.
1:41:22 Thanks. I'll just follow up on that. This Meridian having a dig first policy. I mean, having things like that that are basic things we've talked about through the consortium a little bit. How we, you know, just because Nate and the county are doing all these really great cutting edge kinds of things, we have a responsibility to be following up and getting our own policy kind of workflow going to get these things moving forward. These are the kind of things we've got to talk about and figure out how we're going to engage with these things. All right. And I'd just like to thank your department and the county for being willing to take us on when we were.
1:41:51 In a pretty drastic situation. It's amazing how much has been done in this first year, so I thank everybody for that input, and we're already seeing some of the efficiencies, and I know there's many more to come. So thank you in advance for all the work you're going to do for us in the future. You're welcome. It's a slow road. It's definitely a process, but I think that we're going to continue to see improvements, and it's just sort of going to build on itself, and I think the next few years will be really, really exciting.
1:42:20 Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Let everybody get resettled. Next is another presentation about the Inyo National Forest Plan Revision and Eastern Sierra Regional Collaborative. I'll kick this off briefly. We put this on the agenda to kind of give you just an update of what's going on, kind of surrounding the Inyo Forest update, but also
1:42:50 As we submitted comments, as you know, we looked at a lot of different things, but throughout that there was a common theme of the value and importance of the recreation elements and what the forest brings to Mammoth Lakes and the opportunities we have. So it was built off of that, but it also ties back to some of the guiding documents the Forest Service has put together, which I think has also stimulated a lot of discussion from a regional perspective up and down the Sierras and obviously through
1:43:19 Mono and Inyo counties. The framework for sustainable recreation came out in 2010. There's just two comments I thought I'd make out of here that kind of helps set the stage for a lot of the work that's happening. One of the issues just talks about connecting people with their nature and cultural heritage is a vital thread in the fabric of society, contributes to the American identity, and reminds people of the resources that sustain life, water, soil, food, fiber.
1:43:48 And moreover, recreation is the portal for understanding and caring for our natural resources. And I think that embodies a lot of the discussion that we've had in the town in the last year and prior to that even with the recreation elements, Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the different focus that's been there of saying we need strong amenities, we need strong visitors, but it has to be sustainable over time from an economic resource and other elements that come into bear.
1:44:15 The report kind of concludes by saying despite changes in population and fluctuations in visitor patterns, it is obvious that outdoor recreation, the national forest and grasslands is a traditional part of the American way of life and remains so in the years ahead. I think that embodies a lot of what the town has been focused on. It embodies a lot of our comments into the forest update plan. I think it's reflective of what the Eastern Sierra Regional Collaboration is looking at.
1:44:42 A lot of different elements coming together and hopefully we're able to do that on a collaborative process across our region to say we value our natural resources but we also understand they're part of our economic lifeline and how do we blend those two together to truly enhance what we have from a recreational standpoint, from a pure enjoyment standpoint, and also for the future generation element in that sustainability component.
1:45:09 Councilmember Wentworth attended the kickoff meeting. He can touch on that. But I like a lot of the stuff coming together as Shirley County focusing in on all the comments the town made. And I think where the Forest Service and a lot of their guiding documents talk to being a gateway community and some of those types of elements. So it looks like we're moving in the right direction. Hopefully it continues to go that direction and we're able to capitalize on the updated forest plan.
1:45:37 With that, I'd add if John wants to, Councilmember Wentworth wants to touch base on the first kickoff meeting which happened last night for down in Bishop. Yeah, thank you, Dan. Thank you, Madam Mayor. The meeting was great. It was a great success. A very diverse group of folks managed to make it down to Bishop last night. The four meetings are being facilitated by Michael Ward who facilitated the Mammoth Lakes Recreation process. Very skilled facilitator.
1:46:04 A lot of laughs, a lot of smiles, a lot of fun was had, which is not something you normally run into in a Forest Service planning meeting. Everybody had a very good time. And there's a real sense of camaraderie and spirit and a real expression of love and appreciation of our natural landscape and where we live. The next meetings are coming up in Big Pine on October 28th and in June Lake on October 30th.
1:46:33 Strategic Planning, Recreation Strategy Meeting on November 13th. And all this ties into what's happening with the Forest Planning Division process. I think that it's this document, I know no one probably has time to read things like this, but this is a document from the Forest Service that basically lines up with everything that we need and the communities and the region need to succeed.
1:46:59 The kind of thing that the degree to which we can see the values of this document incorporated into the forest plan revision, which I'm pretty confident that we will, that the management program with the NEO lines up with all the things we're trying to do here with Mammoth Lakes. And we're really on the cutting edge of this stuff. I mean, with the voters supporting measures R&U and Mammoth Lakes Recreation being in place and our discussion this afternoon about recreation, this is the path that we're on. And what we're trying to do lines up very nicely, very neatly with a
1:47:27 A published and endorsed document from the United States Forest Service. So we're not reinventing the wheel. We're trying to just bring things together, bring things into focus. And I would encourage everybody to come to the meetings. There's treats. There's fun. You get to leave town and go to beautiful June Lake or Big Pine or Bishop. So, so far, so good. Things are going very well. That's it. Okay. Thank you, John.
1:47:56 And that will move us to the consent agenda. Are there any items that anyone wishes to pull? Madam Mayor, if I could pull item 7. I don't. I'm willing to make a motion that we approve items 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10 with a compliment to the staff who is able to capture a very rambling amateur hour
1:48:27 Motion by myself regarding single-family rentals, and you guys did a great job, and I think it's all there, so thank you very much. So that's my motion. I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 3-0. That takes us to number 7. Yeah, just a quick comment on that. I more just wanted to pull this for the benefit of the public. There's been some discussion about
1:48:58 Mammoth Lakes Recreation, doing anything that we can to minimize administrative costs and overhead. Just wanted to kind of detail that a little bit since it was on the consent agenda, but essentially the plan is to have them move into the existing Mammoth Lakes Tourism Office, which they lease from the town. The contract extends through the end of the term of the original contract.
1:49:26 Which is essentially like 32 months. And it would be a nominal one-time lease payment to the town of $100. So if you were to break that down, it's $3.12 a month, which is a pretty good rate in town. In most places you pay that per square foot. So just wanted to make that aware that this is an area where administrative costs can balloon a little bit. This has been minimized in this case.
1:49:55 There will obviously be some administrative costs associated with MLR, but in this case, very nominal, and just wanted to kind of bring that to everyone's attention for the benefit of the public. I think also just to applaud the MLR board and MLT and other folks, I mean, what they had to go through to get to this contract is a little bit mind-boggling, and it's kind of a bureaucratic horror show, but we don't need to go there, but the folks did the work necessary to make it happen, and we're realizing the benefits for the public, so thanks.
1:50:24 Bring that to the public's attention. Another comment? Would you like to make a motion? Sure. So I'd make a motion to approve a consent agenda item 7. I'll second. We have a motion and a second roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 3-0. That takes us to item number 11, which is a public hearing.
1:50:51 So I will begin by opening a public hearing and then ask for a presentation from staff. Thank you, Madam Mayor. This is another state-mandinated public hearing regarding economic development funding. We actually worked through this a couple different ways, looking at Mammoth Lakes Tourism and how it applies there, and we believe it does apply. So in the spirit of the transparency side that I think the legislature was looking for,
1:51:18 And putting information out to the community. We've put the public hearing together. And again, as we've done this with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, I think some of the intent of the state legislature doesn't fit real well, but we've tried to accomplish what the legislature has asked us to do in this process. Basically, we're recommending that you conduct a public hearing, then to accept the report as is or if needs amending by the council or the public.
1:51:46 The report kind of walks through the contract kind of going forward with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We have a five-year agreement. We've had one year in that, so we're into a second year of that. It walks through a lot of the numbers. Basically, a lot of it's projected because it's a percentage of. It's 2.5% of tourism dollars minus an adjusted amount for the economic restructuring that the town did in that element.
1:52:14 Potentially for some admin costs are in there as well. So it walks through that. We also highlight in the staff report that MLT also receives TBID funding from the assessment on property. And it is not subject to the hearing, and there's we can tell. I prefer to Andy if there's a legal issue there. But because it's an assessment that we don't control, it's passed by the businesses.
1:52:37 For the collecting agency and we pass it through so. But we did want to note that it's in there and that that is a question that comes up out there in the community at times. It's really not a tax, it's an assessment, but it's utilized for similar purposes in terms of the promotion of tourism. But the detailed findings in the report the information provided really focuses on the TOT component and the business license tax component that the town provides.
1:53:01 There's six different categories that we need to provide information on. It walks through that. Some of it's perfunctory of name, address, those types of elements. But it begins to look at the dollar amount that we put into tourism. Over a 48-month period, it's estimated to be just over $9 million. That includes business tax and TOT money going for that purpose. The ultimate dollar amount would depend on what we actually collect. So it's an estimate at this point.
1:53:31 Also, the other elements that the legislature looked for, was trying to, for economic development purposes, usually much more focused on a business, so the question becomes how many jobs do you create full-time, part-time, et cetera. We've really tried to address that more as we're investing in a whole community in terms of a recreational-based community, so it's hard to say what jobs will be created. We have two elements, I think, looking at how do we maintain and sustain our current job base, and then ultimately...
1:54:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:54:26 Walk through any of the numbers if there's questions there from the council or the community, but we did want to, we're doing our best effort here to comply with the law that doesn't fit real well, so to be blunt, and hopefully it's good information for the community to see and understand, and we did want to be able to kind of lay this out at this point, and then obviously we'll have a presentation from MLT, kind of their overall focus and program and where they're headed and things they've been successful at, hopefully in how they're using these dollars both previously and going forward.
1:54:57 Thank you. Okay. We'll start then next with any questions to staff from the council? Yeah, I've got a question. Because this is a state-mandated thing that we're doing, is there any implication as to whether or not we do it per the state, whether we do it well or we don't do it well? Can they say we don't like your findings or you're going to be in trouble? No. That's the odd thing about the legislation. There are no standards. There are no findings. There's no anything. It's just have a hearing.
1:55:26 So we're having a hearing. Okay. Well, I appreciate that. Thank you very much. I think there are opportunities in this. I think we go back to society. One of our priorities is having these sort of synergy summits. We talk about bringing all these kinds of things together. MLR is going to have to be going through this. MLT is going through this. But this is a good opportunity to start getting everything kind of lined up on the same page for how we're reporting on these kinds of things so the public can understand, you know, this council, this government, this town is taking some pretty
1:55:55 Creative and interesting ways of building public services. And I think it's a good opportunity to start looking to use the intent and the spirit of the legislature to be accountable and be public about it. These are things we can probably turn to our advantage at some point. Thank you. Then at this point I will call from testimony if there's anyone in the audience who'd like to speak on this. Don't see anyone moving. In that case, I will close the public hearing.
1:56:26 And that will lead us back to deliberating and arriving at a decision or starting a motion. I'll make, uh, huh? All we're requesting is that you accept the information as presented. Accept the report? Yes. That's all the motion has. I would make a motion that we accept the information. Second. With a motion as second, can we have a roll of call vote, please, Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 3C route.
1:57:00 That takes us on to another presentation, the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Yearly Update. Good evening, Madam Mayor, members of the board, Brent Truax, Chairman of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. Tonight we're pleased to present the yearly update of Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the Town Council. First, I'd like to start off by introducing a few of the board members if they're present and their stakeholders. I myself represent the Chamber of Commerce on the board. Matthew Lehman.
1:57:48 Is not here. He's at large. Michael Armando for Town Council. Michael Desma representing the restaurants. Paul Rudder at large. I think I saw Kirk sitting back here representing lodging as well. Eric Forssell from Mammoth Mountain. And Sean Turner representing retail. You know, in my industry of hospitality, you know, time is really our new currency.
1:58:18 Google cites that travelers spend an average of 55 minutes to book a hotel and a flight. That includes visiting 17 websites, clicking on four different search ads per travel search, and 90% of those travelers conducting the booking process over multiple screens from a tablet, PC, computer, smartphone, etc. People are shopping for value, which is a combination of anticipated experience and price. The board is very pleased with the progress we have made over the last year.
1:58:48 I believe that you'll see tonight is a team of professionals that are successfully tackling the challenges of marketing to people looking at 17 different websites, spending 55 minutes trying to choose what's the right location and trying to choose that Mammoth is their location to come. With that, it's my pleasure to introduce John Urdi, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, to review our progress over this last year. Thank you. Thank you, Brent, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. First off, I have to...
1:59:21 Wish my wife a happy birthday. It's her birthday today, so I'm here instead of celebrating her birthday with her. Last year was my birthday, so it works out really well. Thank you, Nora. Yes. This evening we have a recap of the fiscal year of 13-14, and I wanted to start off just with a little organizational chart on Mammoth Lakes Tourism just for folks to understand who the team is. You'll be hearing from most of these team members tonight as well. We'll have each one of them talking about their specific segments.
1:59:47 Obviously myself, Natalie Post is our marketing coordinator. We just stole Natalie back to Mammoth Lakes from Steamboat in Colorado, so that was great. Whitney Leonard, our Director of Marketing. Christy Osborne, Director of Interactive Marketing on the digital side. Laura Kaler, who's been with us almost a year now, Media Relations Manager. And then Michael Vanderhurst, who is Director of Sales and International Marketing. And then below that we have Adina Ingram, who works with all members of the team to hold it all together. So you'll hear from the team tonight.
2:00:17 So we're going to go through just the same sort of thing we did last year. We're going to give you a little break out of the TOT. I think one of the big things to note is that summer TOT continues just to set records for us. So we're talking about last year, so we're talking about July of 2013 now, so you've got to go all the way back. Basically, with the exception of September, between July and October, we set new records. Now, there are a couple of things to note here. If you remember, we had a little fire called the Aspen Fire in July and August. It started late July, burned into August.
2:00:44 That smoked us out in town pretty hard for about two weeks, to the point where it closed the airport for three days. We were able to still set records in both July and August. September we saw a hit, and I think even though the Aspen fire had more of a physical effect on us, the Rim fire in September had a PR nightmare on us. When people start talking about Yosemite being on fire, we're too closely associated with it, and it really hurt us for September. Then back in October,
2:01:12 I actually think that we saw a record in October, and we were up 7.3% over the year before. The government shutdown was a bad thing, but it actually helped us a little bit. I think all the people that typically would stay with us one night ended up staying with us more nights because they couldn't stay in Death Valley or they couldn't stay in Yosemite. And so I think as you all remember, the Forest Service shut down our welcome center. We opened up our front door of our administrative building and actually had a welcome center in there. People coming into town were very appreciative. These are people that...
2:01:40 Came in from Germany, and they were driving an RV for a 60-day trip that was probably a $40,000 expense for them. We made sure they had the best experience possible. And actually, I think that helped us this year as well. I think that word got back, and people really added us to their itinerary. So, Lower Arabian Corner, you can see that during the period, we were up 2% over the year before. And for the five-year average, we were actually up 18%. Just a graphical depiction on each of these. So the darkest bar is the 2013 model.
2:02:12 Then we hit winter. November actually ended up still being strong for us where it was up year over year, and then we just really hit the downward spiral in December, January, and February. We were down 21%, 22% almost over the year before. You remember the year before, we had a ton of snow just before Christmas. We didn't have a lot of snow after Christmas, but the snow that we had before Christmas gave us momentum. And that momentum, coupled with our altitude, you know, the elevation of the mountain is a huge thing.
2:02:41 And the temperatures. So the snow stayed good. So we were able to roll through the year before. This year, unfortunately, we didn't have that momentum. We didn't get snow until January 30th after the October storm, which does us no good. So when you get snow on January 30th and you miss Christmas week, then you miss the MLK holiday, you're really struggling to recover. So as you can see, the year prior, we were down 22%. And sadly, the biggest effect is when we're down that far on the five-year average. It's a tough one.
2:03:10 March, April, May continued that spiral because, again, we didn't have the momentum. We didn't have the spring skiing. But as you can see, we were able to recover in June because we were able to get the passes open. When Tioga Pass gets open, it really opens up a great opportunity for us. So for last year, we were up 8.6% over the year before. So again, we're talking about June of 2014, just this past June.
2:03:35 Some of the things that really hit us there is, you know, motocross is doing great. We've got the half marathon came in with 1,500 people versus 1,000 people last year. So, you know, really trying to take advantage. If we're not going to have the long ski season, let's make sure we shift gears, get buses coming over the pass, get people up here for activities. We have kids getting out of school earlier in June. They're going back to school earlier, but reacting to make sure that when they get out June 9th that they're all coming up here. So overall, if you look at the comparison year over year,
2:04:07 We were down $1.4 million, 12% to the year before. The thing that I really want to give a lot of credit to Dan Holler and his team is that the town re-forecasted the budget and we came very, very close. We were down less than 1% to the re-forecasted budget. That, to me, is an accomplishment because I think in the past we've not reacted and we've not had contingency plans. This re-forecasted budget is $1.4 million.
2:04:34 Three, $1.4 million lower than what the original budget was. And that's not just making numbers happen. That's actually making decisions to say we're not going to spend money on this. So to be able to come within $92,000 of the reforecasted budget and less than 1% down, that's a huge accomplishment. The five-year average, again, sad to say it was down, but it was only down 2.9% of the five-year. So we're still trying to recover on that.
2:05:03 One of the groups that I participate in is the TOT compliance group with finance and the lodging community. And I think that, again, this has been an ongoing effort, and I think that it's been refocused, which has been great. Last year we had a budget of $500,000 in this category, and they actually collected $598,000. So in the three years that this program has been going on, we've collected almost $1.6 million in illegal TOT, penalties, interests, all those different pieces.
2:05:33 I think one of the biggest numbers on here is the fact that we have 241 new transient occupancy tax licenses since we started this effort. I think the average before this was about 30 a year. So you figure three years, we would have maybe had 90. At 241, we see a lot more people that are complying with the efforts. And then also working with Nate Greenberg and his team on the BasicGov online portal, you know, it's been challenging, but we do have 465 people that are signed up to pay online now.
2:06:02 It's a program that's working, and I think that with Dan Izzo on board and a revenue management team focused on it, it's going to make a big impact moving forward as well. The TBID, we'll talk about it briefly. We started collecting the TBID in September of 2013, and we fell short on the TBID numbers estimated as well. If you look here, really the biggest number obviously is from the ski area. You know, we have 2% on lift tickets in ski school, and unfortunately with the poor season, that number really took a big hit.
2:06:33 But as you can see, we actually were fairly close to the forecasting on the rest of it, lodging taking a big hit. And now that we have year-over-year numbers, we'll be able to show exactly where we are on that annual basis. So one thing to note here is that TBID funding, I think one of the big things that people were expecting is because we collected it in September that it was going to make a big impact on last winter. Nothing would have made a big impact on last winter.
2:06:56 Absolutely no option. So we actually had the wherewithal to put the money in the bank. We used it for the air subsidies as we had planned. But then we started spending on May 19th, we started spending towards the summer marketing. And so this summer is really the first beneficiary of the TBIT spending. Now, I know we're talking about last year, but one thing to note as a little foreshadow for next year, July was up 8.2% in TOT. August was up 8.4%.
2:07:26 Both record months. So again, this will be our fifth record July, fifth record August. So the TBID money is now in there. As you can see, even though we missed it by 500,000 plus, we still had three million bucks that we were able to bring in and put back into the coffers. Additional revenues, we strive to get out there and make as much outside money as possible, outside of the TOT and the TBID, whether it's through advertising sales.
2:07:55 The visitor guide continues to do well at about $85,000 a year in advertising sales. Our website, retail, brochure distribution around town with some of the companies that we work with and partnerships. So I'm always looking to bring in that extra money. The other piece with the retail, which Michael will touch a little bit on, a lot of it isn't to make money. A lot of it is to get the brand out there. I love walking around town seeing people wear a hat or a sweatshirt or a T-shirt. Air service.
2:08:23 You know, air service last summer, so again, we're talking about the summer of 2013, not this existing summer that we're currently just wrapping up. We had 8,118 people that flew into town. That was up 1,069 passengers to the prior year. When we look at the average spend being just shy of $600 a passenger, that ends up being about $600,000 in incremental visits, or excuse me, incremental dollars from those 1,069 passengers. So, huge piece of incremental business.
2:08:50 Our air subsidy last summer was $854,000. So if you just look at the incremental growth for last year at $600,000 plus, we're almost covering the subsidy just by getting more and more people here. So even though the $853,000 is a large number, the total economic impact is $4.7 million from those people coming into the community, spending it in lodging, restaurants, retail activities. The load factor was a great jump. We went from 51% load to 58%, and what that is is basically the percentage of the plane that's full.
2:09:21 So it's 7% real growth in that. And we were able to keep Mono County on board last year at $50,000. We've secured them again for this summer that we're in at $50,000. I'll be doing a presentation for the supervisors next week to talk about air. Winter last year, as expected, winter fell, load factor fell about 16%, so that was a big hit.
2:09:44 And about 3,100 passengers, which, again, in the wintertime, when that spend is much higher, more around $1,000 per person, that's a major hit to the community, just from an overall impact. Last year, in October, we officially joined forces with the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Really, we felt that with the TBID coming online, as Councilmember Fernie had mentioned, the chamber had not been funded well in the past.
2:10:13 We really felt that we had to bring the chamber within Mammoth Lakes Tourism in order to make sure that what we promised was getting delivered. We wanted to make sure that the experience that people had when they got here was really what they were expecting. Over the last year, the board has been very, very active. We've got a great board for the Chamber of Commerce. And we had a strategic planning session back in the spring, and we talked about connections, resources, and quality. And we're talking about service. We're talking about being a resource for businesses.
2:10:43 And we're talking about really just getting people to work together and collaborate. And so you'll see some great things coming out of that group. Through that process, with Jeremy Goiko being the president of the chamber, came on board in, I think, May, we've developed a service committee, a membership committee, and a finance committee to really look at how we should be doing things. Part of that group, we actually went out and we started a search back in, probably in May or June, we started a search for our executive director.
2:11:10 We had a lot of great candidates from around the state of California, very, very highly qualified chamber executives, and Craig Schmidt, who you met earlier, Craig joins us with more than 20 years' experience in the chamber world. He comes most recently from Morro Bay, prior to that Healdsburg, California, and then also up into Hood River, Oregon. One of the things that really impressed us was his strategic planning.
2:11:30 And I'm sure he has documents that he'll share with you as well on some of the strategic planning that he's done, some of the business incubation programs that he's done. So he's very interested in 395, digital 395, all those pieces. So as you can see also, we have a new representation logo mark for the Chamber of Commerce, which will be very recognizable as well. So I expect to see the Chamber be very, very active in the coming months, really doing a membership drive geared towards February so that we can get people into the mix again.
2:11:59 And relaunching websites and really just making the benefits of the program and the benefits of service programs available to the folks coming in. My last slide here before I turn it over to Whitney Lennon is research. So in the past we've always done research, but what we've done is we've evolved that to really be a program that aligns with industry best practices so that we're looking at things and really understanding what people are looking for with us and what they like about us, what they don't like about us, the whole nine yards.
2:12:28 What we're using that for is really to guide our strategic program. You know, one of the most dangerous things in the world of marketing is an opinion. You know, my opinion shouldn't matter. If I think we should be doing something, we probably shouldn't. So we trust facts. So a lot of people like to throw out their opinion that we should do this or we should do that. We really trust the facts that say this is where people are looking, this is what they're looking for. And the research that we've done is providing meaningful and actionable data for the community to use as well.
2:12:57 What you'll find, we have an event, another open house event coming up November 12th. That'll be at the U.S. Forest Service Auditorium right across from the Welcome Center again. The time is still to be determined, but probably 5, 5.30ish. We may extend it a little bit longer than last time. Last time we did a two-hour presentation. It might be a three-hour presentation because we want to go through this research. We want people to understand the visitor profile study that we did this summer. Who's coming here? What are they doing here? Where are they spending their money? Why are they coming here versus somewhere else? Where else do they go?
2:13:27 So this is all important information for business owners in town to really come and see. The advertising effectiveness study that we did turned out very positive for us. I think that's another piece that people really should come and see because when people say, well, why aren't you doing this instead of this? Well, the research that showed that we should do this has proven to be right. We're really using this as a national sample now.
2:13:52 Versus just talking to our own database. We're looking at it saying, okay, what do you know about this area? What have you seen for research or advertising? What does this mean to you? What does this place look like? So the visitor profiles are very, very important for us. We've also done an air service survey, which we'll make available again at that November 12th event. And what it really does is it helps us understand when we, in the past we talked about the fact that the people that fly here spend more money and stay longer. We have that quantifiable now.
2:14:21 Right now, looking at the data that we have, which is on a year-round basis, somebody that flies into town spends 63% more money than somebody who drives into town. And they also spend, on average, one to three days longer. So I think that even though it's a small portion of our business, it's a big, big spending piece of our business. So with that, I'd like to bring up Whitney Lennon, our Director of Marketing, to go through her presentation for you. And we'll answer questions at the end. Thank you.
2:14:49 Madam Mayor and Town Council, my name is Whitney Lennon and I'm the Director of Marketing for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I'd like to expand on the research portion just a little bit. The choice to go with this agency and also with this research company, SMARI, was intentional and it's because we're providing the research for our community to be able to apply and use in their marketing efforts and who they're marketing to so they'll have those resources.
2:15:17 It's also the same company who completes Visit California's research. So our local community can be well-versed in what that research translates into. So anyway, I hope that makes sense. But I just wanted to touch base on that and why that was intentional and strategic. Today I'm going to be talking about three things. I'm going to talk about the brand development that we completed for Mammoth Lakes this past year.
2:15:45 I'm also going to be doing an overall end of year recap campaign as well as talk about the highlights of each of the media categories in which we placed our ads. This year we did researching with local stakeholders as well as our guests and we conducted exploratory brand positioning research through several different tests and different activities. And there's an extended video that really goes into the detailed portions of
2:16:15 How this information was completed and taken, my goodness, how this information was disseminated and conducted and you can find that on our MLT Industry Insider. It's the video under summer kickoff. What this did through the exploratory research is it helped define what the look and the feel is for Mammoth Lakes and it helped create our creative platforms going forward. So this is what created our brand platform for the next three years.
2:16:43 And what we determined is Mammoth Lakes owns Mother Nature's Adventureland. And what this means, in the words of the people who have participated in this research, is that we're an authentic playground for today's outdoor adventures. We're unchanged and raw, remote, great year-round climate. We have scenic splendor. We're a town situated in the middle of a national forest. And our personality is dual in nature, humbled yet confident.
2:17:11 Invigorating, yet serene. Charged, yet laid back. Rugged, yet modern. Approachable, yet challenging. I think that sounds pretty accurate. And this is an example of the creative that you'll see that was implemented this past summer and that you can also see in the wrap-up and the kick-off of the one our presentation John referred to. Our brand development, our final creative came down to No Small Adventure is the brand title.
2:17:43 And we are defined as majestic in scale and awesome in its beauty, natural beauty. The adventure land of Mammoth Lakes is one of those rare places you can see and still not totally believe. Surreal storybook scenics spark the imagination, inspire endless adventure, and make every moment feel like a brush with the truly incredible. I think we can all agree that translates pretty well in that creative. We're all really excited about that.
2:18:12 Now touching on my year-end campaign recap for the marketing department, through the 69 placements that we're placed throughout the year, we had a total reach of $32 million. Value-added contracts, and this would be contract negotiations in the beginning, like when we go and we want to place an ad with someone, they say it's $5,000, and we ask what more can you do for us, and negotiate value-added promotions through that.
2:18:40 The total of value-added contracts was $597,000. The marketing department increased our consumer database by over 10,000 opt-ins, and that means these consumers intentionally want our e-newsletter and to be communicated by our agency. We distributed over 155,000 visitor guides despite the drought. These were distributed locally and in target markets.
2:19:07 We have 4,900 visitor guides as part of their fulfillment, and that's people contacting us personally wanting more information. On the industry relations accomplishments, marketing department, aka director of marketing, Whitney Lennon, was elected as board of director for the Yosemite Gateway Partners, which is a regional group, and I was also elected as the vice chair of the California Welcome Centers, which is a Visit California designation.
2:19:40 Okay, moving into the highlights, I'm going to highlight, bring up the highlighted campaigns in each of the media categories that where we've placed them, but I also want to tie into the best practices and the initiatives that we've been tasked by the town by highlighting the buying power of partnerships. The two highlighted campaigns I'm highlighting here is the NBC Surf to Snow promotion that
2:20:05 Played during the Winter Olympics in San Diego on NBC. And Next Stop TV, which featured a long format Mammoth Lakes destination feature. Both of these opportunities were brought to us by Alaska Airlines. For NBC, we had 10 different spots, 30 seconds apiece, featuring winter recreation. Like I said, this played during Winter Olympic programming on NBC. We also had 10 second spots promoting a giveaway to the area during this time.
2:20:34 This was a partnership with Alaska Airlines that we went in 50-50 and this extended our buying power by $15,000. We had over 5,800 entries, over 1,000 opt-ins, 96 spots, and this played to 1.8 million reach. For the Next Stop TV featuring Mammoth Lakes, again, this was another partnership brought to us by Alaska Airlines. This is a full, like I said, a long format destination program, which is 30 minutes.
2:21:04 And the production and the promotion value was a combined $232,000. Our contract was zero. That was through the power of partnership with Alaska Airlines. Okay, moving into radio, we placed ads in Southern California on Jack FM and Amp Radio. And this illustrates negotiating contracts competitively and aggressively to get ourselves onto Carson Daly free of charge. This is a $12,000 value.
2:21:40 And it was a five-day promotion. We were promised five mentions, 30 seconds apiece. We received eight in well over a minute at each mention. Like I said, it was live mentions by Carson Daly promoting Mammoth Lakes and then a trip giveaway. And this reached over one million people. Now, if anyone flew Alaska Airlines this summer, you may have seen this prize. We're all really excited about this. This represents the buying power of cooperative advertising.
2:22:13 We established a cooperative ad buy with our community where the community was able to purchase ads within this magazine at a much lower rate because we were going in as the bigger buy, you know, promising that we could at least fill two pages and that would be one place, one full page ad placed by us and then another page of community ads. Community ads came at 1.5 pages which was a great success.
2:22:38 And earned us 8.5 pages of editorial about Mammoth Lakes and the cover. Pretty impressive. The whole value, if we had paid for these pages as an advertisement, is $66,000. So wrap up the last category in which we place advertisement in the marketing department is trade shows. Every year we participate in the Yosemite Pavilion.
2:23:05 presents or the displays at the LA Adventure and Travel Show as well as the Bay Area Travel Show. The LA Adventure Travel Show is quite a bit bigger footprint and we were able to poise ourselves to, well, I was able to poise myself to be the speaker to represent Yosemite on the 30-minute destination stage. You can see that in that top picture. I was also the media point of contact for the morning television shows that were covering the trade shows. So the Friday before the shows,
2:23:35 All major network TVs, ABC, NBC, CBS, and Fox show up to cover the trade shows for the weekend and I was able to be that spokesman. Mammoth Lakes is also the featured giveaway for the show for their Twitter party. In addition, we were also able to negotiate two giveaways there versus one and they were also included in the show materials. Another thing I want to point out is that we did win best in show.
2:24:04 Our pavilion. So hoorah. Out of this, the result, we had over 2,300 opt-ins for the Mammoth Lakes newsletter as well. So more information about the additional 69 placements that we made is available on our industry insider at mltindustryinsider.com. All right. Thank you very much. And now we move into the interactive marketing department.
2:24:39 Madam Mayor, Council Members, I'm Christy Osborne, the Director of Interactive Marketing for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And in my recap, I want to talk about our winter and summer digital campaigns for 2013-2014. I'm going to talk a little bit about content marketing. As Brent said, our visitors are looking at 17 different web pages and they're doing a lot of research and so we are trying to
2:25:08 Provide information that will help people better plan their trip through a content marketing program. We'll talk a little bit about that as well as social media program and a few of the tools we've developed for the community this year. So winter 2013-2014, we run a digital display advertising campaign every year.
2:25:35 And basically digital display just means those advertisements that you see on any website on the internet. We partnered with Lonely Planet, Trip Advisor, Google On the Snow, and ESPN. And the way that this works is every year we take a look at what was working and what wasn't working from last season and try to optimize.
2:25:59 And so that's how we pick our partners. That's how we stay with partners. We've stayed with Trip Advisor year over year because they work. We've let go of other campaigns because they didn't work. They might have driven traffic to the site, but people would just stay for a couple seconds and leave, telling me that they weren't really interested. We also do some testing every year.
2:26:21 This past summer we ran some tests with ESPN and Lonely Planet which were very successful and we ended up picking them up again for larger ad buys for the summer. So this is digital because we have so much information coming in all the time. It's a constant opportunity to continually optimize to get more traffic to the website, to get more engagement on our ads and also to get the cost
2:26:50 Per view down. It's measured in what's called CPM. That's cost per thousand. So how much money do we pay for 1,000 people viewing our ads? And we try to keep it under about 150. So last winter we spent $125,000 on our winter digital display and that was measure A funds.
2:27:14 The digital display ran across premium content publishers and the creative, we moved from a static sort of just your regular banner advertisement to rich media which basically meant we took about four different pictures and built them into a video like experience. So here's an example of our banner ad that we triggered when it started snowing.
2:27:40 Telling people it was dumping in Mammoth Lakes. And you can see that there's four stages to that. So it's not actual video, but it plays like video, attracting people's eye toward the ad. The objectives and strategies for this particular campaign was to build top of mind awareness for Mammoth Lakes as a destination. So we constantly want to invite people to this destination and say, hey, we're up here, come join us, it's great. We also want to make sure that we're driving, for this winter campaign, driving
2:28:10 Quality traffic to the site and increasing site engagement. So you know sometimes when you're looking for something online and you Google something and you click on one of the search results and you think, oh, this isn't what I wanted, you back out. That's called a bounce. And it shows no engagement. It shows no interest. And so one of the things that we were measuring is we were measuring the average pages that people were looking at.
2:28:37 On visitmammoth.com once they entered from a display ad and how much time they were spending on the site. And these metrics are well above industry average for last winter. That $125,000 bought us 32.8 million impressions. That means 32.8 million views of our ad.
2:29:04 And we had more than 28,000 visits to the site from these banners. So once people got to our website, we saw that they were spending an average of 55 seconds on visitmammoth.com and the industry average is 30. So this was a big win for us. They were also looking at an average of 1.71 pages, which across
2:29:32 28,000 people is pretty good. So again, this shows interest in the destination. With our summer brand campaign, we started to see a little bit of TBID funds coming in, so we were able to spend a little bit more. We had $310,000 to spend, and we ran digital display ads across major networks. Again, you'll see Lonely Planet and ESPN there.
2:30:00 Also virtual tourists, tribal fusion and sojourn, which are major travel powerhouses. Now for this, what we're trying to do is we're trying to build this top of mind awareness and we've built out this brand platform and we want people to start imagining their trip here. What is it like to visit Mammoth Lakes?
2:30:26 What am I going to experience? What does that feel like? And so with the summer brand advertising, what we did was we did video and interactive display advertising. And the goal was to get people to play with the ad, right? And then any other traffic driven to the site was a bonus. We also focused on core experience pillars, fishing, hiking, and biking. And the results of that,
2:30:57 We also ran a test with SMARI Insights to
2:31:25 to show how effective the advertising was. And 29% of the travelers surveyed were aware of our advertising, which is the equivalent of over 3 million ad-aware households. So typically people don't
2:31:49 Click on a banner ad and then pull out their wallet really quickly. There's a lot of other research that goes involved in making a major purchase decision like going on vacation. And so we have developed a robust content marketing program to address questions that people might have about their trip. In the winter 2013-2014, we launched the explore.visitmammoth.com blog.
2:32:16 Over the past year, it's gotten about 30,000 page views. And we have hired local writers, including Andy Geisel, Betsy Truax, and Monica Perel to write content for us every day. And this is the type of questions that visitors ask, such as,
2:32:35 Where can I go get a great happy hour? Or what are some of the best hikes to take my dogs on? And where are some of the best places to get great vistas? These are Mammoth Lakes insiders, and it's run like a lifestyle magazine, not just a brochure. The content is also repurposed in email marketing and in the visitor guide. So the idea is to really draw the...
2:33:02 The online visitor into the story of what it's going to be like to visit Mammoth Lakes. Now we know that part of that story digitally is they're going to be on business partners' websites. They're going to be on Yelp and TripAdvisor and all sorts of places. And we know that all ships rise with the tide in this community. And Mammoth Lakes Tourism can have the slickest ads.
2:33:32 And the most beautiful covers on Alaska Airlines and the most beautiful website ever. But if the rest of our business community can't create effective marketing materials and collateral, we're all going to struggle. And so this month we've just launched a new photo and video gallery where we have hired local professional photographers to take pictures of activities.
2:34:00 And scenics in the area and that we upload it to the photo library and all of those professional images are available to every single business member in this community to use on their websites, in their marketing brochures and in their flyers. We've partnered with MLTPA to set some priorities for getting
2:34:22 Images of different recreational activities and spots around town, and you can see many of those images are already being used by that website. We also launched the Mammoth Lakes Industry Insider website, which is this community's tool to see what's going on in Mammoth Lakes at any given time.
2:34:43 We have monthly reports, occupancy reports, any kind of wins that the different departments have, as well as industry news and travel and tourism, and we're getting ready to roll out a best practices series. You can just sign up with your email on the industryinsider.com, and all of the new content will be delivered straight to your inbox every week, no hassles, for free.
2:35:12 And so you don't have to miss a thing from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And then finally wrapping it up, we have a very robust social media program. Our YouTube channel continues to grow and is now one of our most powerful social media and content marketing channels.
2:35:29 In 2013, 2014, I'm sorry, in 2012, we launched it. We got about 50,000 views the first year. We nearly doubled that the next year. And again, we're looking to double it this year, rounding out the end of this calendar year with nearly 200,000 views. And the cool thing about these YouTube videos is that, again, partners in the community can
2:35:55 Grab a little piece of code from YouTube, embed it in their own website or embed it in their own email and now they have professionally produced content that they can use to market to their visitors and their lists. We also have a great opportunity through the interactive marketing department to start to highlight individual businesses in town.
2:36:23 We've continued to grow our Facebook audience, so we've topped 30,000 fans this year. Our Twitter followers are about a little under 3,500, and I know that this isn't last year, but in August we introduced a new Instagram channel, and in the first two months we have enjoyed 1,000 followers as of today. So the digital interactive program is pretty robust.
2:36:52 Fairly integrated. And with that, I would like to introduce my colleague, Michael Vanderhurst, the Sales and International Public Relations Director. Thank you, Christy, Madam Mayor, Town Council members. I appreciate you having us here today. So I'm Michael Vanderhurst. I'm the Director of Sales and International Marketing. I'm also a recent appointee to the Planning Commission. So I appreciate the three votes. I believe I got up there. I'm also on the Mono County Tourism and Film Commission.
2:37:22 And I'm the point person for Mammoth Lakes Tourism for the High Sierra Visitors Council, which is a marketing consortium of all the CBBs or tourism agencies in the High Sierra from Lake Tahoe through Yosemite to the west side of the Sierras down to Inyo County, Mono County, Mammoth Lakes and back up to Tahoe. So it's a pretty powerful group and we do get funding from the state of California for that. So I'm also a proud Little League and AYSO coach here in Mammoth Lakes.
2:37:49 So part of my responsibilities with Mammoth Lakes Tourism are really threefold. As John mentioned earlier, I'm in charge of all the revenue streams that are non-measure A or TVID or town business license. And I'll touch a little bit about that on the end of my presentation. But the other two areas of responsibility are kind of the meat of what I do for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Domestically, I'm a little bit more B2B.
2:38:15 So what that means is I'm out there bringing ski groups in or I'm out here trying to bring boutique conferences in or small groups, professional groups that are looking for some sort of a meeting space. Internationally, I do all of it. Consumer, direct consumer, business to business, PR, marketing.
2:38:36 And I do that in a lot of different markets internationally. And it's pretty exciting stuff. And you don't realize a lot of times what you're selling and how lucky you are to be selling it until you're looking at who you're selling against. And a lot of the things that make Mammoth Lakes so special, we kind of lose track of a little bit in the day-to-day. So I'm lucky enough to be out there selling Mammoth Lakes and really preaching the gospel about it. Now to get people here to Mammoth Lakes internationally,
2:39:05 They still use this thing that we don't use anymore called travel agents. And I know that sounds kind of archaic to us. Everyone here is OTA or you just book directly online. But a lot of the international markets, they still rely on their trusty travel agent they've been booking through forever. So you have to be out there kind of educating the travel agent industry in these international markets or tour operators or wholesalers.
2:39:31 On why their clients should A, include Mammoth Lakes on their itinerary, and B, why they should lengthen their stay, their length of stay in Mammoth Lakes from one night to two nights to three nights to four nights, or in the winter to a week to ten days. So that's a lot of what I do internationally. Now, I'm going to kind of blaze through this a little bit here because I know you guys are going to have some questions for us at the end.
2:39:55 But a lot of the stuff I do, we do in collaboration with some other big agencies. As you can see at the top of the list, Brand USA is the marketing consortium that really markets the USA as a destination worldwide. It's a relatively new organization. They haven't really hit on all cylinders quite yet, but the potential there is fantastic and very exciting. And we've plugged into a couple of programs with them that have had really, really nice results.
2:40:21 We also work very closely with the state of California. I try and wrap myself as much in the California message as I can when I'm international. It definitely has an emotional touch point with people when they think California. They don't think gray skies and they don't think bad weather. They don't think an unpleasant experience. They think wonderful things. Like I said earlier, we work with the High Sierra Visitor Council. We work with the agencies here in town, our partners, whether it's lodging, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Mono County, Inyo County.
2:40:50 So that's some of the stuff that we do in a collaborative nature. The international sales effort is pretty in-depth for Mammoth Lakes now. We have in-market agencies in a bunch of those countries you've seen Bola pointed right there. We have representation in France and Belgium through the High Sierra Visitors Council. We have representation in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland.
2:41:14 Through our own contract with a company called MSI. And MSI also represents Visit California as well as Brand USA. So that gives us a chance to leverage our message on two much bigger platforms by partnering with them there. We have in-market representation in Italy and Spain with Masters Consulting. And again, those two other higher platforms are in place, Brand USA and Visit California.
2:41:41 And then UK and Australia and New Zealand, we also have in-market agencies under contract. And again, those both have that brand USA and visit California relationships. So what it just gives us a little more bang for our buck. So while our in-market contract with those agencies may not be large in the grand scheme of things, when we can parlay the California dollars and then the brand USA dollars to get the Mammoth Lakes message across, it really becomes pretty impactful.
2:42:11 2013-14 is really when we started our relationship with Italy, as well as the Netherlands, Russia, Mexico, and kind of really when our relationship with Brazil started hitting on all cylinders. Most of those in-market agency representation contracts we have are with VisitUSA, so it's a little bit smaller scale than a direct representation contract.
2:42:39 With Mammoth Lakes, but it still gets our message out there. What we're looking for for 2014-15 is just really start tapping into Asia. If you start talking to business owners here in the community, you'll start to hear that California has had a pretty sizable impact from visitation from countries in Asia here in the last two or three years. It's just now trickling in us. So we want to make sure we're there, we're hitting it, we're getting our message.
2:43:05 Front and center and really gaining the length of stay and the visitation that the rest of the state has already been seeing. How do these people get here? Like I said, you have to be out there hand-selling it. This is where I mentioned you have to talk to the travel agents and the wholesalers and the dual operators. And we do that. We're pretty aggressive in how we get the word out there internationally, whether we do it at Pow Wow or ITB.
2:43:33 Or WTM, which are all massive, massive travel trade shows around the world. We're out there spreading the message, whether it's consumer direct or whether it's travel trade direct. But you have to hand sell it because your competitors are hand selling it against you. And, you know, a lot of people don't really... To give you an example, a lot of people, when you get to other parts of the world, have no clue California has snow. They have no clue California has mountains.
2:44:01 They think Disneyland, they think San Francisco, they think Los Angeles. So when you try to explain to them, yeah, you know, actually we've got some of the best skiing in all of North America. We've got a mountain that's got the longest ski season in North America. It opens some eyes. So it's a matter of getting out there and getting that message across. I had a couple of really snazzy videos in here that I was going to wow you with, but it didn't quite make it into the program.
2:44:29 We do a lot of PR internationally, and what that means is basically we host writers here in Mammoth Lakes. We're big believers that getting professionals here to tell our message to their audiences back in their home markets is so much better than me just screaming it from a street corner. So we host a lot of writers from around the world. They go back, they tell our story, they tell their audience the things that make us special and the reasons they should come to Mammoth Lakes.
2:44:59 For example, the PR coverage we got in Australia this last winter alone was about $600,000 and that comes from maybe $5,000 in expenses in flying these riders in, hosting them. We have amazing support from our lodging and food and beverage partners in town as well as equipment rental companies. So the return on investment for that $8,000 is just huge.
2:45:26 We've also seen about $280,000 in PR return from Germany and about $84,000 in PR return from France and about $110,000 in PR return from the UK. And again, in a nutshell, we probably spent $20,000 bringing those people in, hosting them, showing them around, showing them the things that make Mammoth Lakes pretty special.
2:45:51 We are also, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we are the official destination sponsor. If you look at that second bullet item of the UK Adventure Film Festival, we replaced the country of New Zealand. So they kind of came to us at the last minute. We got a little bit of a bargain rate on it. I won't lie there, but to replace the country of New Zealand to be the official sponsor. The goal of that program is to kind of illustrate what we have to offer in the summer.
2:46:17 More family, more soft adventure to an audience that is predominantly always associated us with winter. So that's the UK and we've seen some pretty nice results out of that already. We are also the part of the California Snow sponsorship for the Warren Miller Tour in Australia, New Zealand, which...
2:46:34 It's a really nice platform. We get a lot of exposure out of that. And then the Good Life video, which was one I was going to show tonight, we'll show it on November 12th at our open house, was a collaboration between Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, MLT, and Brand USA. So it was a good example of how we were working together to get the word out there. So as John was mentioning, even though the last winter visitation was down,
2:47:03 International winter visitation was actually one of the few segments that was up. We were up about 8.5 to 9 percent. Although that doesn't sound significant, the length of stay and the average spend for somebody coming to Mammoth Lakes in the winter is significantly higher. So those are the people that fly in. Those are the people that stay on average for 10 to 14 days. So the fact that that segment is growing for us, I'm very, very,
2:47:32 And I see that growth going forward. In the summer, if you've had a chance to go to the visit center or go to Vons this last summer or anywhere in town, chances are pretty good English might have been the second language you heard being spoken. There's quite a few accents out there.
2:47:51 Kind of an aggregate number I got from a survey of lodging for this summer had international business and that being Asia, that being the UK, that being Australia, that being Italy, that being France, that being Germany, up about 25%. So that's another significant growth and really a market I only see going up. So pretty bullish on that as well. The last slide I have here.
2:48:16 is the retail sales segment of my job. And as John mentioned, this is not what keeps Mammoth Lakes Tourism afloat financially. The main goal here is to get the brand, to fly the colors, to have people out there wearing our stuff. Destination awareness is how I like to put it. Pretty much the revenue we receive from either the retail sales or the visitor guide is more of a
2:48:44 Offset for the cost we put into printing the visitor guide or in the case of the retail, we had an ambassador team out there at every single event this summer that was talking about the great hikes, where to eat, where to go to people who may not be familiar with our destination. So the retail sales kind of offset the ambassador program. So it's a little bit of a cost neutral effort.
2:49:10 I'm going to go ahead and wrap it up right there and hand it off to Laura Kaler. If you guys have any more questions after the presentation, we will all be here. Thank you. Good evening, Council. I'm Laura Kaler, Media Relations Manager for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So in 13-14, the Media Relations Manager position was created, which is why I'm before you tonight. The Media Relations Department, I focus more on the domestic side of media relations.
2:49:44 Whereas Michael takes the international side. And we really work to get that third-party endorsement from journalists who, you know, aren't being paid. We just work to get them here so they can have the experience and then write about it. So when people are researching online where to go and they have all those 17 sites, hopefully they'll remember that article in Ski Magazine talking about the Great Slopes or that article in Bike Magazine.
2:50:13 Talking about the great mountain bike ride. And it'll push him over the edge to pick me on the flakes. So some of our key strategies. Our top one, again, was to get the media here. Get the face time. It's easier to write about something if you experience it firsthand. So in 13-14, one of our big successes was having a big mountain bike media press trip in May.
2:50:41 And we brought him here and we were able to show him all the trails off of Mammoth Mountain. So come to Mammoth Lakes, go to the bike park, but then go mountain biking for free on Rock Creek, Mammoth Rock Trail. And that was a really big success. Some other FaceTime strategies that we've been using are to do desk side visits, which means I go to the journalists, I go to their offices.
2:51:08 Journalists are like everybody else. They're trying to do more with less. They have less time on their hands. So maybe being able to go to them and bring the Mammoth message is very helpful. Another big success we had getting journalists out here was a big writers' conference that we did in June. The Society of American Travel Writers came. It was about 50 people. They were here for five days. Immediately, we got about 10 articles from that.
2:51:37 And those are still continuing to be ongoing. We've had some of those writers back this fall to cover the fall colors. We have one major writer putting together some stuff right now for the San Francisco Chronicle and another major travel magazine. So that snowball effect, just keeping top of mind, keeping the journalists aware of Mammoth Lakes so they'll continue to write about us all the time is really one of our big goals.
2:52:05 Host athletes at the Mammoth Endurance Crib, which is a condo that we have throughout the summer, and we put elite athletes there, and all we ask them to do in return is to talk about their visit to Mammoth to their audiences on social media, tweet about it, take pictures, post them, talk about your great road bike ride you took. Just to, again, get that third-party endorsement, get us in front of new audiences, their audiences.
2:52:33 People that want to emulate these elite athletes will want to then come here and do the same ride that they did. That's kind of the goal behind that. Also in winter, to stay top of mind when we didn't have the snow we wanted, we were able to focus on the Olympic athletes. That was a huge deal for us in January, having the Grand Prix here, having the amazing pipe, having all the stories about John Teller, getting out there, Stacy Cook, all those people.
2:53:02 That was a really great way for us to stay in the limelight when snow wasn't cooperating. And so the strategies seem to be working. We had more than 115 placements last year, and that's up from 70 placements in 12-13. And it resulted in 330 million media impressions, which is up from 96.5 million in the previous year. We did four seasons of media coverage.
2:53:33 And we especially focused on the non-winter months. We focused on fall colors, summer, again, the mountain biking, the road biking, the hiking. And we ended up with a wide variety of coverage portraying Mammoth Lakes appeal. And this just kind of gives you an idea. This is placements by story topics and placements, coverage by number of placements. And so I just have a couple of highlights. I'll just read.
2:54:03 A couple of my favorites, some of the places we were mentioned. So a farm magazine with 26 beers on tap from around the world and a selection of more than 160 whiskeys. Clock Tower Cellars, a gathering place for beverage aficionados. Fall coverage. This has really taken off, and again, this year it's been huge. I don't believe California has fall color. Neither did a Vermont friend, so I took her on a quick trip to Mammoth last year so she could see for herself.
2:54:32 She was surprised. That was the LA Times. Mountain biking. Decline Magazine said, we've written about the riding at Mammoth Mountain Bike Park before, but that is just one small part of the two-wheeled goodness found in the city of Mammoth Lakes. This past May, we returned to the region before the bike park opened to sample a selection of all mountain and trail rides tucked away in the volcanic landscape of the eastern Sierras. And then this is just kind of an example of what we're doing with the social media. This is the idea behind the crib.
2:55:04 We also had a bunch of cycling journalists out for the fall century this year. So getting them here, getting them to talk about us on their own sites. So Peloton Magazine, Road Bike Action, and Road Magazine, talking about it on their sites to their audiences. And then some highlights from the Olympians. GrindTV.com, this tiny town has only 8,234 full-time residents, but probably has more Olympians than any other zip code outside of Colorado Springs.
2:55:34 Home of the Olympic Training Center. And that's it for me. It's short and sweet. Well, as you can see by our extended half an hour, we're very passionate about what we do, and we want to make sure that people understand what we do. So I think that transparency is a big thing. Again, November 12th, we'll be doing our open house for the fall. It'll really give a recap of this past summer and really what the effectiveness of the advertising that we did, as well as launching into the winter. So November 12th will be a big piece. I just want to reiterate the Mammoth...
2:56:09 The MLTIndustryInsider.com website will be key for folks to go to. So we had lots of stuff out here tonight. We will post this tomorrow on the Insider so that people can see it. Our doors are always open. Our emails, our contact information is all there. So people can reach out if they have specific questions or if they have ideas. So I guess with that, we will open it up to any questions that we have. Go ahead. Yeah. You go. Well, I
2:56:40 Or we can go to Clock Tower. No, no, no, no. We'll go to Clock Tower soon enough. Appreciate your passion and what you can do with half an hour, but this is a pretty passionate council up here, so thank you very much. I appreciate, I want to start by how much I appreciate members of your board being here and their engagement with this, I think, as we're transitioning into
2:57:08 A variety of different service delivery programs. I think the roles of the boards of directors of the NGOs and folks that we contract with is going to be increasingly important. Good to see you guys here. I think that there are a couple key takeaways, I think, to focus on. And the first thing is that it's clear that this is a professional operation and that you are hitting
2:57:33 And exposing this destination and what we have to offer here all over the planet and all the various media that you can possibly imagine for that to be happening in. And you're starting to do it at a level of sophistication that requires a level of engagement for the community that's important. So, Mr. Schmidt, welcome to Mammoth Lakes. I hope you can start introducing all the members of the chamber.
2:57:56 The businesses in town to responsive website design and to start, we need to get technologically literate to take advantage of the tools that Mammoth Lake Tourism is delivering. These are the kinds of things we've got to start doing. I think also that another key point of this is technology and the role of technology is going to be playing all this. We've had a very interesting presentation from Nate about the role it's going to play in the town's future.
2:58:20 But certainly technology is going to be key to the success of all this stuff. I think in terms of advising the public on metrics, you know, impressions, when you're dealing in the digital world, you've got a very nice way of being able to establish that kind of stuff. But I think that the most important thing that I took away from this is the need that the marketing and the product now have to really start talking to each other. And MLR is going to be seating a board here pretty soon.
2:58:49 The community recreation piece, Stuart is here somewhere, I hope. All of these pieces are going to start coming together, and we've established a priority of doing something called a Synergy Summit, where we look forward to welcoming you and your staff and members of your board, with MLR, with the town. The teamwork component of this is going to be critically important, and I'm looking forward to hearing things like when Laura and folks speak with, bring domestic writers here, bring international writers here, what are we lacking?
2:59:17 What are we not doing well? You know, here locally we know our mountain biking is good, but, you know, it doesn't compete with whistlers. We need to start getting the feedback from what you're hearing from these folks so that we can start going out and saying how do we start working with our product placement. So not our product placement, but our product. What are people going to have when they come here? And I'm going to make just a little plug for this Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative. The experiences that we're making, that we're delivering to people are taking place on public lands.
2:59:45 And with the alacrity and the professionalism and the technological astuteness that you guys are doing your work on the side of public lands management, forest service, municipal organizations and agencies, we've got a long way to go to start closing that gap. And I think it's incumbent upon the town and all of us to be engaged in these efforts so that we can make sure that the product that people are going to come here experience is living up to what you're telling them it is. And over time, it's going to be very important to
3:00:13 Get those things dialed in so that what we're telling them you're going to see is what you're going to see. And that's going to be a very challenging but very fun and exciting part of this. So I'm looking forward to closing the loops on those things and starting to sort of bring all these things into a good collaborative teamwork kind of approach to really deliver the best experience that we can. Thank you. Thank you. I have a few comments, a few questions, a few thoughts, so I'll probably end up jumping all over the place here.
3:00:44 First of all, I want to kind of frame your presentation with a story that I have as somebody that owns a ski and snowboard shop in a town that it didn't snow in. We showed up to SIA, which is the Ski Industries of America. It's the largest trade show for the ski and snowboard industry in the country, and it happened to coincide on the first snowfall that we had this year. It goes over that last weekend of January.
3:01:12 We showed up to one of the meetings with our reps, our Blizzard Technico rep, and they entered the meeting by putting a bottle of whiskey in front of us that had a label posted on front that said California Morale Booster. So before you were allowed to start talking product, it was mandatory that you took a shot of whiskey. So first of all, it's fun being part of the ski industry.
3:01:37 Second of all, the point of that story is that we were definitely very well recognized at that trade show as a town and a state that was really hurting based on a lack of snowfall. So I think it's really important for people to understand the tremendous challenge that Mammoth Lakes Tourism had this winter based on our conditions with bringing people here. So that being said, I think
3:02:05 This is an organization that I'm tremendously supportive. We work very closely with most of you guys, and I'm very impressed with the work that you've done in the time that I've been here. Thank you for that presentation. It was very detailed. It was very helpful. It was very informative. A couple of thoughts and questions and comments. I think
3:02:30 The things that I personally have been hearing from the community is just a continued push to get as much information and transparency from your organization as possible. And I think you guys have heard that. I think the initial presentation that you did was a great step in moving in that direction. I'm really looking forward to the 12th. I think people are really looking forward to getting a lot of that meat that you discussed, the research behind the things. Everybody has an opinion, but understanding
3:02:59 Why you're doing the things that you're doing, where the money's being expended is going to go a really long way in the community. I personally am signed up on the Insider. I get emails every week. It's a very good way to stay engaged with what's going on with our occupancy numbers, what media placements have happened, and it's just readily available on your phone. So I would encourage people to do that. I've done it, and it's been very helpful. To kind of dovetail off of, John, some of your points,
3:03:29 I had a very illuminating conversation with Michael right after he got appointed to Planning Commission. And the gist of that conversation was simply, when you go out to the rest of the country, when you go out to the rest of the world, what is it that you're promoting? What distinguishes us from our peer resorts? And maybe what are the areas where you find us deficient that you're trying to hide? So I have a list of things that we've discussed.
3:03:57 That kind of fall into both categories. And I think there's certainly some things that we as a council can do to drive change around some of those things. As we've talked about with the chamber, with MLT, we want to make sure that the experience that we're promoting...
3:04:13 Is what people are actually getting when they come here. And I think we have a very important role in that. So I look forward to more conversation on that, but that was a tremendous conversation for me as far as directing my focus for what we can do as a council to positively influence that. So two general questions I have for you, and these don't necessarily need to be answered right now, maybe for the 12th as well, unless they're an easy answer for you.
3:04:43 We've talked in the past about kind of the overall plan with shoulder season and summer was first to drive visitation and then kind of secondarily to drive ADR. So I commend you on the job done for this summer. I just, as a citizen here, it just felt busy. There were people here every weekend. There were people here all week. It just felt like
3:05:07 A very busy, vibrant community this summer, and I think a huge piece of that is due to your promotional efforts. So my question would be, now that we're starting to see that uptick in summer visitation every year, how quickly is there a plan to kind of implement driving of that ADR to follow that? And then the second question, you know, in kind of looking through the presentation,
3:05:34 You know, being cognizant of the fact that I said there's only so much you can do when it doesn't snow. You know, the starkest numbers that come out are down January, down February. Any business owner in this town will tell you that they trended the same way. But just a thought on do you guys have any thoughts or plans in the future for kind of transitioning back to how do we kind of smooth some of those peaks and valleys for the winter?
3:06:03 How do we mitigate a bad snow year to the point where we're not down 31%, maybe we're down 10%, something like that, an area that's easier to stomach? I have an opinion on that, but like you said earlier, my opinion's probably wrong. So just the research and the thoughts, if that's on your radar, how you guys kind of plan to kind of reinvest a little bit in smoothing out those peaks and valleys for the winter visitation.
3:06:31 So those are kind of the two things that came to mind. Yeah, let me answer the first one because it's fairly easy. You know, the ADR is really a, it's the byproduct of supply and demand. You know, the more we can get the demand up, which we saw strong, strong weak occupancies through the summer in the 70s, 80s, 80%, that's when you can start to see the ADRs go up. We effectively can't do anything with the ADR because it comes to the property. So what it does is it goes back to some of the discussion about education.
3:07:00 I spent 14 years with American Skiing Company, one of the largest companies in the world. We had nine resorts across the country, and we would do yield management on a daily basis and looking at what our occupancy was and can we take this rate to this rate. And so I think there's education in ticket pricing, room pricing, all those different pieces based on demand. So the more we can create demand, the more that the ADRs can go up.
3:07:24 Now, do you feel like we've kind of reached that tipping point at the summer, or do we still have more visitation to drive in order to get to that supply? I think we're getting there, and I think we're starting to see the ADRs. The good news is this summer we saw both occupancy and ADR grow. One of the challenges is if you see ADR grow but you don't see occupancy grow, then you're charging too much, and vice versa. If you see the occupancy way up but your ADR is down, you're not charging enough. So it comes back to yield management and it comes to education. I don't know that we're...
3:07:50 100% there yet. I think from July 1st through August 15th, six weeks, we might be getting close. But to your point, too, we've extended into June, really making sure that June's a big hit. We won't see the September numbers because they're not due until October 20th, but I think the September numbers should be strong. October looks strong. So I think that a lot of the ADR growth and the occupancy growth have to go hand in hand. You can't charge more if you've got 1,000 available rooms.
3:08:19 100 available rooms, then all of a sudden you can charge more. So I think that's where the ADR conversation comes in. I think we are still charging lower than we should be for the product that we offer as far as the experience, but until we get the demand up, that doesn't happen. Yeah, I think, you know, for me, that'd just be something that I'd like to have as top of mind and to look to you guys as an organization that can educate the community on that, because I understand that you're not, you know, the full piece of that.
3:08:49 So it's just something for us to think about because I think traditionally Mammoth's done a pretty good job of driving visitation. If you look at our overall year-round visitation, our winter numbers, how we stack up versus our peer resorts, our summer numbers, those type of things, I don't think we've done a very good job historically at driving yield. And I agree with you 100% that it's a product of supply and demand. So just something.
3:09:12 To have out in the universe, I suppose. And that is one of the things that we've talked about. You know, Craig's been on board for a week and a half now, and we've talked about the seminars that Mammoth Lakes Tourism has done in the past, and we've talked about the Chamber really taking the lead on that, and just even the simplest things of a packaging seminar and a pricing seminar. Right. You know, pricing is not an arbitrary number. You don't just say, okay, last year we were...
3:09:33 $129, so let's go to $139. It can't be that way. It has to have some methodology behind it. It has to have the yield timeframes. You have to know when you should be charging $69 a room because you're in May and October when we don't have anybody here. Or when you're in the middle of August, you shouldn't be...
3:09:49 Lowballing it because then your neighbor's going to lowball it and then their neighbor's going to lowball it and then all of a sudden you're going to be driving yourself to the bottom. So those education pieces and how to add value and how to add premiums and how to add benefits to packages versus discounting, those are all pieces that we need to get out there from a seminar standpoint, really, educational. Great. And then for the smoothing out of winter, it's a difficult question because we are...
3:10:11 We are a community that relies on snow because even if it's a great snow year, you've got snowshoeing and dog sledding and Nordic skiing and all these other things, but when you don't have the snow in town or on the mountain, you've got 600 acres like we did last year at Christmas and 30,000 people in town. The bowling alley is great, but there's only so much they can do with the bowling alley. There's only so much you can do with the theaters in town. There's only so much you can do with the other activities. So this past winter, like you said, we could have spent $10 million and probably not moved the dial.
3:10:39 There were people saying we should be promoting paddle boarding in January. There's no way we're going to do that. You know, that's the easiest way for us to completely put a nail in the coffin for winter. So, you know, it's a very difficult and very sensitive topic, but we do need to figure out how we diversify and at least have something that we can bring people here for. And I think that a question I was going to ask also is about nimbleness, and it's premature to be talking about that because we've got capacity, strong capacity, maybe the marketing side, but the product side we're maybe not.
3:11:06 We're not there yet in terms of what we can do and not do. But I was getting phone calls in January from people saying, okay, where do I go hiking and where do I go mountain biking? And that's not out of the question. I mean, those are easy things to do. But to be, you know, having the awareness from the product side of what kinds of things we can step up and offer, that's going to be a key part of all this. Thank you. Sorry to interrupt, Madam Mayor. No, that's all right. You can interrupt.
3:11:34 I think that encompasses my questions, comments, thoughts, but thank you very much for your presentation and look forward to the 12th as well. And I'll just say ditto to everything that has been said already since we're a little bit beyond our 30 minutes. Yeah, just slowly.
3:11:55 I realize that this was your year-end report, but I've had a lot of questions come, so I'll put you on the spot on something that's new for this year, which is can you give us a really quick overview of how you're marketing to our new air markets that are going to be coming this winter? You come on November 12th. We'll give you a full rundown. But we do have a great opportunity with Las Vegas starting on January 15th and with Denver starting on the 20th. The good news is the Denver flight did exactly what we had hoped.
3:12:24 Prior, we haven't really started the marketing program because it is too early really to get that out there. But the Denver flight is already 20% booked with ski clubs. That was the intent, was to get the ski clubs from the East Coast and the Midwest and the Mid-Atlantic and the South to fly in. Last year I flew back from SIA in Denver. I flew from Denver to Reno with the Tampa ski club. Assuming that they were going somewhere in Tahoe, they were coming here.
3:12:49 So now that we have this direct connection, and unfortunately this year we were still a little bit later than we wanted to be, so Michael, when he went to the Crescent Ski Council and Texas Ski Council and Florida Ski Council and the Mountain, they didn't have that finish to be able to sell it. So to be able to even have 20% of the flight booked, right now with 10 flights, that's what the Denver flight is, it's only 10 flights, the CRJ-700 is 70 seats. So to have 20% of those seats already booked is a great piece.
3:13:16 So, but the marketing will be, a lot of it will be really digitally based. You know, you heard from Christy that we can track it, we can manage it, we can make offers, we can change offers, we can see what's working, see what's not working and be able to get those things in there because a flight like Denver is not necessarily meant for people that live in Denver. It's for the people that live in Chicago that have 15 flights a day that connect to the flight in Denver before it flies here.
3:13:41 Or the people who live in Newark. You know, New York can hop on a flight in Newark. Or in Houston with, you know, another United Hub. So, huge opportunity. And again, it really does start to open up the world. Growing up on the East Coast, I really would never have thought to come here without having some sort of easier access. I didn't even know it existed. Honestly. Until I moved to Steamboat Colorado, I didn't know Mammoth existed. It just, it's not, you know, without the flight access.
3:14:10 It wasn't, you know, a major top of mind thing for the East Coast or the Midwest. And, you know, that's my opinion of where the future viability for this community is. If we can turn 30,000 annual flights into 100 or 150, we're going to see some major dividends from that. That, to me, is a way that you smooth out some of those peaks and valleys. If people plan in advance, if they plan for seven days, they're going to come regardless and they're not going to poach snow.
3:14:40 So, you know, I'm tremendously supportive of continuing to push with you guys around efforts on the airport. And we, as council, I think need to help facilitate making sure that our community has the amenities to keep those people busy and happy for five, seven, ten days. And I think that's part of our role. Great. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you.
3:15:08 With that we will adjourn to our next regular meeting on Wednesday, November 5th. Thank you.