TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2014

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 38 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

212 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 A little chilly. A little chilly. Yeah, both of them just fantastic. Well, Friday night did balls. Saturday was a great comeback. They won it and that's in a rally. They put an 11 spot on it by the end of the game. Yeah. Kids and I...

0:22 I'm that dad who's got kids in giant's clothes for me. Oh yeah, I told him. Dad. He said we had a little pizza party last night. The shield is not here? No, he's got it. Lights out. They're actually talking about maybe they need him on game seven on short notice. Dude, that dog is killing me. Okay. It's bad news, man. That was...

0:47 Brutal. Really? For how long exactly? It's a new dog. It's like a beautiful dog. Okay. Nine weeks. Amy is coming? Okay. Get ready. Let's go ahead and get started. You guys ready to start? Yeah. Okay. So I'll call to order a special meeting for Monday, March 27th. Step for the roll call, please, Jamie. Here.

1:11 House Member Whitworth? Here. House Member Whitworth? Here. Here. Mickey's going to lead us in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, for my nation, under God, indivisible, with the liberty and justice for all. Thank you.

1:42 So our first item is public comments if there are on any items that are not on the agenda. Seeing none, I'll turn this over to Sandra to start our workshop. Thank you.

2:08 After that, we completed a parking and snow management feasibility study that looked at ways to manage snow in part of the current town. Two of the items that were in that feasibility study were the infrastructure financing district to finance commute infrastructure and a property-based improvement district which would finance, which would pay for the services. So the council gave us direction in May of...

2:35 This year to move forward with this work item. However, they didn't provide any funding. So we've been working since then to get the funding. Actually, I think it was in July that they provide us this in June. And so they didn't provide any funding. So we've got private funding for a consultant with Jamie Lico from Centro Incorporated. She worked with us through the Main Street plan and a parking management feasibility study. So she's been working with us for about two years now. Real familiar with the town, our issues.

3:05 And so at this point, we're really just looking at the infrastructure financing district. If you have questions about the PBIC, we can talk about that. But Jamie did prepare a PowerPoint. So we'll have the PowerPoint here. Each of you have the PowerPoint on your table here. And then also this handout on the new changes to the infrastructure financing district laws. So with that, I'll turn it over to Jamie, and we can walk through the PowerPoint here.

3:33 Just a question, Jamie. As you're getting started, do you want questions as they arise or hold them until the end? Why don't you just ask them as they arise? Okay. So that would apply if the public has any questions. I'll try to keep looking over there. I'm looking for hands. Sounds good. And we will make this, I'll be happy to make this available to you electronically as well because I know the handouts are quite small and there's a lot of words on these slides, which I don't usually try to do.

4:02 I just wanted to make sure we conveyed kind of all the important information. So thanks for having me back again. And as Sandra said, we're focusing today on the IFD portion of the discussion. So I was last here I believe in May, I think.

4:27 And that's when we were wrapping up the feasibility study, which dug a little bit deeper into the IFD and the property-based improvement district. And there were a couple key takeaways from both the plan and the feasibility study in terms of answering that big question, how do we get something done here? Where do we start? And that was quite a bit of discussion about the fact that we need to establish

4:53 Some strategic tools and mechanisms now that will facilitate the vision long term. So we need to get the work done to put these tools in place. And we need to be able to prime the pump for development by investing in some critical public infrastructure in order to encourage that private sector investment. And so primarily identified, as Sandra already mentioned, were need to fund things like parking and access, infrastructure amenities particularly identified in the Main Street Plan.

5:19 As well as services like snow removal and maintenance, activation and management. And so you all decided, I think, kind of together with the stakeholders that the IFD was kind of the first place to start, the infrastructure financing district, to kind of begin to establish really those key things, the tool that was probably going to provide the most revenue for some of these big picture things. Sorry, I don't know why my...

5:48 My words on the bottom are all jumbled, but I'll explain it. So because I don't think maybe all of you are not familiar with IFDs or tax increment financing, just a real quick primer. These infrastructure financing districts are tax increment financing districts. So just very simply to explain how that works.

6:16 You can see that as revenue goes up over time, revenue collected from property taxes, there's an incremental increase that's captured in the middle. And so basically when you create a TIF district or an IFD or EIFD, you ideally would set kind of a base year. So if we started this year, whatever the property taxes we are collecting this year would be the property classes

6:44 Taxes we collected for the duration of the tax increment financing district. As those incremental taxes went up, either through new development or through general increases in the value of property, that incremental property tax revenue would be collected in a special fund to be reinvested in projects in the area. Jamie, is that only for the parcels that are in that area or is it more broad?

7:11 So it's only for parcels that would be within the designated boundaries of the tax increment financing district and we'll talk a little bit about boundaries later on in the presentation as well. So you get a chance to identify what those boundaries are where you would collect that incremental revenue. This is a very simplified thing because of course as you can imagine it can get way more complex than this such as

7:35 Determining how much of the increment goes into the project, et cetera, et cetera. So again, we'll delve a little bit deeper. But on a high level, I just wanted you to understand probably most importantly that TIF, an IFD tool, is not a special assessment. It's not an additional tax. It's not like the TBID. It is just a redirection of taxes that you're already paying. And so those impacted the most are actually the taxing authorities.

8:03 The city, county, and the special districts that receive taxes who have to agree to give up some proportion of the taxes they would receive each year to be reinvested. So when I was last working here, over the last few years I've been working here, we've been talking about infrastructure financing districts and at the same time there's been a lot of discussion within the governor's office in particular about

8:32 This tool because as you all are probably well aware, redevelopment went away several years ago, leaving kind of a gap in the state of California in terms of how you fund major infrastructure projects without tax increment financing. And so the IFD tool had been on the books for a long time but had not really been used in California because it was not allowed to be used in places where redevelopment authorities already existed.

8:59 So since redevelopment's gone away, of course, it's gotten kind of a fresh look. When we last spoke, probably the biggest issue with creation of the IFD was the threshold of support that you needed to make it happen. And so amazingly, within just the last three weeks, that has changed for the better, making this tool one that I think becomes even more feasible for you guys to do here.

9:30 So you can see there just a very, very simplified chart of some key differences between the old law and the new law. With the old law, it used to require two-thirds of the voters in an area to create a district and to bond. You had to do both a vote to actually establish a district and begin collecting increment and then a vote if you wanted to bond against those increments. Now, with the new law, it requires no vote of...

9:56 The electors to create the district and it only requires a 55% majority of those who respond to the ballot to actually do the bonding. Previously, districts were allowed to exist for up to 30 years from the date of the adoption and now districts are allowed to exist for 45 years up to date you issue bonds. So that clock only starts when you actually issue the bonds, not when you actually begin collecting increment.

10:23 And also previously the town council was the governing body. Now the new law requires that a separate authority be established to govern the district. So these are all changes that are going to make this tool a lot easier to use. There are a few IFDs, which I'll show you some case studies here in the presentation that exist that we can learn from.

10:45 Because this law, this new law just passed a few weeks ago, there are no EIFDs out there. But I can tell you in my conversations with a lot of folks around the state, there's a lot of people looking at them. So interesting time to be having this discussion. Jamie, could you, I'm sorry, could you repeat bullet item one? So there is no required vote to create the district? No, no required vote to create the district of electors.

11:10 So I'll go through in a minute. You still have to work with the taxing bodies to get an agreement before the district can be created. There is still a public hearing process, but you don't actually have to take it to a formal vote. And since we stopped, so on a bond, what's the rating agency based on? Are you based on the town of Mammoth Lakes? Is it based on these entities themselves? I am not exactly sure. I can find out and get more back to you, Mickey, on that.

11:41 I believe there's an entity in California that a lot of these districts go through to do their bonding. So I can get back to you on that. Any other questions on this slide? I have a short question. One of the shortcomings of redevelopment agencies was the issue regarding providing public housing or funds for that.

12:18 None. So that's been removed. That does not exist in the IFD. So there is no requirement, like you said, to provide that. The IFD is very open. I have a slide in a moment that talks about what you can and cannot fund with the IFD.

12:42 But it's been broadened quite significantly to include all types of infrastructure and no mandatory use of funds for things like public housing. But you can use the money to fund public housing if you choose to. But it's not mandated. Not mandated anymore. You kind of led me nicely into my next slide as well just to kind of highlight because there are a few questions on how are these tools different than redevelopment. So we did away with redevelopment. Now we're bringing back taxing and refinancing.

13:11 You know, what's kind of the difference there? There are a few key kind of highlights. First of all, you know, finding a blight in an area was required for RDAs and then the public authority could just create the district. So this one is different. There's no finding of blight required, but you do have to have the support of taxi bodies and there is a voter requirement to actually bond.

13:37 In the new EIFD, all the taxing bodies, as you'll see, you actually have to negotiate with every taxing body to talk about their increment, their involvement in the district, and you absolutely cannot take from educational uses of the tax dollars. EIFDs were somewhat time, excuse me, EIFDs are time limited, whereas RDAs were not necessarily so.

14:03 And EIFDs require a very sort of specific plan where with RDAs you could be kind of more general in what you were going to use the funds for over time. So where the money comes from, as I said, the primary participants in this who are getting or giving up some of their own revenues to put into the EIFD are cities, towns, counties, and special districts.

14:32 The EIFDs do not automatically get all the incremental property taxes where they're created. So each public agency and district must agree to the amount of tax increment they'll contribute to the district. And so those negotiations are probably what's going to take the most time to understand how much they may be willing to give up. And they cannot take revenue from school districts, community college districts, or county offices of education. So what an EIFD can fund?

15:04 I have a, there's a long list in the legislation of what it can fund that gets into more detail, but as I said, the great thing with IFD is it's pretty broad at this point, and as long as the public facilities that are being funded or the projects being funded are of community-wide significance. So streets, so, let me back up, parking, streets, parks, transit stations.

15:32 Infrastructure that supports that, utilities and things like that. All are things that would fall within the parameters of community-wide significance as long as you can make a clear case for that. It is really an infrastructure tool. So in addition to building the infrastructure, the district can fund the planning and design work as well. What it cannot fund is any maintenance, repair work, ongoing operations, or services of any kind.

16:02 Once the thing's built, there has to be an understanding of how that's going to be maintained or operated and where funds would come from to do that. Yep. Can you clarify the community-wide significance a bit? Like, for example, in a TBID, you have to provide significant benefit to the actual assesses.

16:25 What is the focus on providing specific benefit to the taxable district or the community-wide benefit? So it's primarily, it says specifically to community-wide significance. And so I think what they're trying to get at here really is it's not to benefit a person or one entity, but whatever the IFD funds are used for must have some community-wide benefit to them. And so, for example,

16:54 You could do things like build a parking structure, which was a public-private partnership, and part of it could be the IFD funds fund some public parking and the private funds, but you couldn't use the IFD funds just to build a private parking structure. But is it important to show that there's a significant benefit to the specific district, or is it more just there's a community benefit? Yep. Okay, thank you. A couple other very important things.

17:29 The district boundaries when you create an IFD do not need to be contiguous. And so we'll show you some different options of boundary areas. But you could basically circle a few key areas that could all be part of one IFD when it was created. The line doesn't need to be contiguous. And the facilities that you actually build with IFD funds do not need to be physically located in the boundaries of the district.

17:56 I think the second point kind of is important there and gets to your question a little bit. If you are building facilities outside of where you're collecting the revenue, you have to at least draw a line or distinction between why it makes sense to use these funds to fund that thing. So that's the one case where you kind of need to clarify the connection between the district and the project. And up to 10% of the tax increment generated in the first few years can be used for planning and public education.

18:25 District and outreach and engagement. An agency forming, the EIFD may loan funds to the district and reimburse itself through future tax increment as well. So there are really three primary steps to actually creating the district and then a fourth step would be the bonding. So I just want to go through these. I don't want to spend too terribly much time but I provide a lot of detail on the slides if you really want to read into it.

18:58 And again, this is a little bit different than how things were before when I last wrote the report in May. Believe it or not, the rules were actually different because we were working under the old law. So with the EIFD, the first step is actually the creation of an EIFD authority. So the legislative body of the town has to establish a public financing authority to be the governing board. And as you'll see, that authority has to be comprised of the members.

19:28 of the legislative bodies that are participating entities in the district. So if only the city is participating, then we only need city representation. If we have city, county, water, and fire, then we need at least one representative from each of those districts sitting on the board. And of the public, and basically the law just states a minimum of two people, and it just says public. So we'd have to figure out how we would identify that. That body then becomes the kind of the decision-making body.

19:56 On the IFD plan and on governing the plan. And it does become a local public agency as such. So this is the very first step is creating this authority which then drives the process to create the infrastructure plan and so forth. So that's step one. Step two is an adoption of a resolution of intent to form an EIFD. So once that authority is established, then that authority is responsible for putting together this resolution of intent to form a district.

20:26 And at this point, it's kind of general. So we look at, we establish what the boundaries are going to be, what types of things the district wants to fund, make a clear case for the need for the district and the community and set out the goals. And then there's a public hearing on that, which notices are sent to landowners and all the taxing bodies to come and comment on that. And then finally, once that is put in place,

20:55 And that resolution is accepted. Then you move forward and you actually develop a detailed infrastructure financing plan. I'll skip ahead and then I'll come back to this. So a lot of detail here. The infrastructure financing plan has to be quite detailed. In addition to a map of the district, you have to have a description of all the facilities that are proposed and a description of what portions of those might be.

21:24 You know, funded with IFD, what portions might be funded with other funds. So back to the example of, you know, public-private partnership on a parking facility. Let's say it was 30% IFD, 30% city money, you know, this 40% was private sector money. We have to detail out each of those components and how all that money is going to come together. The location timing and costs of the development. You know, a clear finding that the development does have community-wide significance.

21:55 And then a pretty detailed financing section that actually asks you to call out how much of the tax revenue each taxing body is going to give, how much money is going to be collected, how it will be financed, and a lot of analysis of the costs and the impacts of the IFD. One of the things that I wanted to highlight here is that in the negotiations for

22:23 The tax increment and how much each taxing body might give. There's a lot of flexibility in how that's structured. First of all, each taxing body doesn't have to commit the exact same amount of revenue each year. Additionally, the amount of increment that you give each year can change. So I'll show an example of one existing district in California that does that now, where you might give more increment at the beginning and over time decrease the amount of increment you give.

22:50 As the district begins to generate more value. And so you can be very flexible and it can get very complex, but you do have the ability to do that within the plan. And so once you have that plan all developed and vetted, there's a couple key steps that have to happen. It does get sent out again to all the owners of land within the district and the taxing bodies. And this is kind of important, the third bullet.

23:19 You do have to consult with each of the taxing bodies and a resolution approving the plan must be adopted by the governing body of each affected taxing entity before you can actually have a public hearing on it. So all the taxing bodies have to sign off on it before it goes to the public. And then there's a public hearing and a resolution created adopting the plan. And at that point your district then can begin collecting increment.

23:47 Without having to go to a vote. If you should choose that you want to bond against those funds, which most likely I'm assuming you would want to do, the nice thing is that you don't have to do the bonding vote right away. You can go ahead and start collecting increment and take a little bit of time to figure out the bonding and so forth. So once you decide the bonding scenario, you do have to go to a vote.

24:26 As the first bullet says, Bonds may be issued to 55% of the qualified electors voting on the proposition vote in favor of issuing them. And this is the weird nuance that's the same as before for those of you that remember. The qualified electors are if at least 12 people are registered to vote within the boundaries of the IFD, those people are the voters. If not, the landowners are the voters.

24:55 Each landowner gets one vote for each acre or portion of acre they own within the district. So that's something we'll have to look at when we're thinking about boundaries is we'll also want to take a look at how many currently registered voters you have in the area, and that's sort of a consideration as well. If the bond issue fails, you can't go to the voters again for at least a year, and the bonds are not a debt of the town, county, state, or other political subdivisions. They are only a debt of the district.

25:25 So the town wouldn't be responsible, for example, if the district couldn't pay for some reason. So there's no guarantee by the town or anything you're saying? Nope. And then this I put in here, but I don't think it's necessary. Just so you sort of are aware, because we have some questions about redevelopment. You can do projects within former redevelopment areas.

25:55 The law basically says redevelopment has to be clearly closed down before you move forward. So a couple quick case studies that I wanted to share with you. This is the most recent IFD to be established. And so in the West Sacramento Bridge District, they're using the IFD to do riverfront, parking, garages, street cart infrastructure, parks, and affordable housing.

26:26 And their current assessed value is $133 million. They're anticipating generating $144 million in TIF by 2036. In West Sacramento, the city was the only back-taxing entity to participate in the IFD. They're giving 100% of increment.

26:51 They took about six months to create, and this was under the old structure, not using the new law, so they did have to go to the voters. But they weren't able to put it together in about six months' time. Jamie, on that slide, it looks in the before picture that there probably weren't a lot of residences. It looks like a commercial area. Yep. And so it was a landowner vote. They were able to do a landowner versus a residential vote. And so...

27:25 They sort of took the approach of putting everything that they could possibly fund in there into the IFD plan for authorization, even though they know only some of it will be utilized. The voters did approve bonding of $500 million over the life of the IFD. They've gone for the full 30-year term. And the city currently is overseeing the use of those funds. So this was literally just created a few months ago.

27:52 If you're interested, if you guys are interested in doing your own research on this, we've spoken to the people that were involved in its creation. They'd be happy to share with you any insights they have on that. And I mentioned this is another case study. This is actually one where it's a good example of how they've kind of looked at changing the amount of increment they give. So Rink and Hill IFD created, what, about three or four years ago?

28:21 Primarily focused on streets, alleys, and parks. Similar property values to the other one. And so you can see there in the third bullet, what they opted to do was they're giving 100% of their increment to the district for the first four to five years.

28:43 They're going to decrease that to giving only 30% of their increment by year 8 and 14% by year 12. So as the value of the district goes up and it gets built out, they're decreasing the amount of increment they're giving to it and retaining the taxing bodies or retaining that for some of their own use. So did they hire like an actuary to calculate those percentages or was that a recommendation by it? I think, yeah, it was all based upon their proposed, based upon the development they know is coming.

29:12 How much increment, how quickly that was going to come into play. So we can do similar things here based upon some of the stuff we know is going to happen and some presumed values. The other thing that they've done here is they have limited their use of the IFD funds to projects where the source of long-term maintenance is identified. So they're building stuff

29:40 And a lot of their stuff is focused on streets and streetscapes and infrastructure. They're using those IFD funds where they know there's some sort of mechanism in place to support the maintenance and operations long term. So this is kind of the last general slide and then I'll stop for a second and then there's a few things I want to talk about just specifically in relation to Mammoth Lakes.

30:09 When we've been calling around just doing some research with some of the other IFDs, a few things that people shared with us. First of all, because you have to negotiate with all the taxing bodies about the increment they're going to give, there's a lot of comments that you have to kind of be pretty strategic now in order to be able to generate enough increment. So you have to be very thoughtful to where the district boundaries are, to what properties you're including or what parcels you're including.

30:39 Obviously, have some pretty clear discussions with the taxing bodies to make sure that you're actually going to generate enough increment to be able to do something. And very importantly, creating a package of services that are attractive to city, county, special districts that they see value and benefit in is pretty critical. So we really need to understand what these agencies are going to care about. How do we convince them to give up some increment?

31:08 to invest for the greater good and for the long term of the community. As I said, there's no vote requirements to form the EIFD, but we need to be conscious that if we're planning to issue bonds, we still need to be thoughtful about district boundaries to make sure we're thinking about that 55% vote. As I already mentioned, you can be forming the district with differing levels of increment.

31:33 And a lot of people said ultimately the EIFDs are narrow. As we said, they can fund infrastructure and they can fund the planning of that infrastructure, but they can't pretty much fund anything after the infrastructure is built. So we have to be thinking about how we leverage other sources to do some of that stuff, to do some of that maintenance and operations and ongoing programming and activation. Please. I will take a breather there for just a second and see if anybody has any comments or questions.

32:04 On the tool in general. I have a couple, and a couple, some of them are like for the next steps is that because of that comment there about the school funding, I think specifically in this place, we would need to know how it affects ERAF or if it affects ERAF, which is another money shuffle that goes on that deals with school funding. We've used it, it's...

32:33 It's something from the early 90s where the legislature changed how they funded schools, that there's this complicated formula where it's a triple flip. The money goes back and forth all over the place and somehow everybody comes out whole, but it didn't work that way in Mammoth. Also, it wasn't clear, does this kind of an agency have to go through your local agency formation commission?

33:01 I don't know. I will try to find out. And in these examples, they all assumed that there's incremental and large tax increases where so it'd be nice to see how that relates to the fact that our property taxes haven't really started to go back up again. So how does that affect your projections? So it would just be a question to answer in the future.

33:26 Yeah. Well, I've got some slides on here that talk a little bit about assumptions. I think the big thing with that is that we need to think about is, you know, there's the baseline in how much that does or doesn't go up given the strange economy that we live in. But there's also the reality that we know some new development is going to come out of the ground within the next few years and some locations are ready to develop.

33:53 And I think probably that's where you're really going to get your significant boost from the increment and might be a more strategic place to focus our discussion for the IFD is on new development. Yes? I've got a question back on the slide. I'm not sure which one it was. It's a case study of West Sacramento Bridge District. You made a comment about everything available to be funded under IFD law was written in before authorization. Was that...

34:22 Just politics, is that just putting everything in the basket so they could get voter approval to get the bonds passed? And can you talk about what kind, I mean, how broad did that list of projects get? So in terms of the why they did it there, if you're familiar, and I'm not actually

34:44 I have not been here, but so I've just I've read about it and spoken to them, but this is a massive redevelopment project that they didn't know exactly 100% what was going to end up what is going to end up being developed there. And so what they did was they took all the potential projects and I think they outlined scenarios for the uses of the various tools, everything from utilities to infrastructure to a park.

35:09 You know, Riverfront Park to the streets to all of that. And they've allocated for that in some way, shape, or form in the plan. The plan is available online. I'd be happy to share when we send around this. We can send a copy of it to you so you can dig into it in a little bit more detail and see how they've done that. Well, I'm just wondering how efficient the nexus is between the projects being identified and what gets tossed in the basket to get rid of the plastic.

35:36 The West Sacramento just came out of a lot of redevelopment planning that went on there. And so... They were changing mechanisms? Yeah, changing mechanisms. They had a lot of planning work done on some of the folks there. But the element I think they really focused on was this massive mixed-use development. And it's all just city money so they didn't have to deal with the county, etc. And so they're looking at roads, water, sewer.

35:59 Park, everything that would be a city facility. And so we knew a lot of that was based on the formative planning that that would be RDA site. And so by laying that out, they had all these projects and projections, pending on the type of development, whether it was housing, office, light industrial, a major office complex, and some of the park work and stuff that looked at putting in place. So it was in a defined boundary and already had a lot of that work done in terms of the type of infrastructure projects that are allowed in the RDA.

36:27 Okay, that's all. I'm sorry, I can't cover this. In prior discussions, the schools were going to be left alone. Does that change? No, they are left alone. By law, you cannot tap any of the property tax revenues allocated to educational systems.

36:47 Joe, what are you worried about ERAF? Well, because we're basic aid, which is a little different than everybody else, is just double checking and making sure and analyzing how it might affect it. ERAF won't. Yeah. Well, but I was just saying, let's have them check. That's fine. And then we've talked about parking districts so that we can form, will this not allow us to form a parking district? Sure. It will. It will allow us. Yeah. So that we can potentially charge.

37:18 Either per car or in an area per business. So to cover the O&M moving forward. Yep. I'd just like to comment, Tom, one of the things that was said that I think is really important is that there's one thing forming the financing district, but ultimately you have to figure out your long-term maintenance. And that's where kind of the second step, the PBID, came in.

37:44 You know, we can't do this, we don't have the long-term maintenance in place. But PBIT doesn't allow you to cover O&M? It does. Yes. Oh, he does. This doesn't. This doesn't. This doesn't. Ah. Okay, so the infrastructure financing district is just to build the infrastructure. Ultimately, we'd have to figure out the long-term maintenance of it. Okay, right. Next week. I don't think we're going to get this one. You have rates that end up paying that O&M.

38:12 And so a parking district can reinvest parking revenues and manage parking, but you still have questions of things like if we use some of this money to build the, you know, Main Street plan or improvements and enhancements and things like that, how does some of that maintain the street and grow over the long term? But ultimately that can be figured out if you can figure out how to build infrastructure too first. I think you went over this, but his question kind of sparked this for me. So in the example of a parking district, let's say, we did charge a per-car fee.

38:42 That money can funnel back into the district, correct? But that money that's funneling back into the district cannot be used for O&M, correct? It would need to be used for O&M. So he's talking about forming a parking district, a separate sort of parking district where parking revenues could be re-fenced and reinvested into operations and management in some capacity. That would be a whole different separate agency than IFD.

39:06 For example, I think the best way to show that, let's say you build a 300 space parking structure, you use this to fund it, that can fund the capital, that's a separate agency. Say the town or other property, other agency goes in and runs the parking structure itself, they collect five bucks a car, they keep that so they can do snow removal, they can do crack repair, they can do paint, they can maintain the facility based on the revenue generated from the operations of that facility.

39:33 And that can be either put together or separate in terms of how you run it. It can be a separate district. You can do that under assessments. You can do it under fees and charges. But none of the dollars generated from this can go into that operating side. It can only be utilized for the capital investment.

39:49 I have a question. Can those revenues generated from the operational facility be used to pay back debt as well? Yeah. Yeah, because that was your O&M for whatever you'd like to do on that. I mean, that's the structure. I do the O&M side, the... So you've got excess revenue, so you can put that back... You can put that back to debt if you want to. You can put that back into the IFD or back towards debt reduction. I'm not sure what Tom's asking. You can go back into debt. We don't go directly back, usually, but you can... The IFD gives you the opportunity to use multiple different forms of...

40:18 And one of the things we talked about in the plan, too, well, first of all, is how much operating revenue could you generate?

40:43 You know, after you cover your cost, would it actually, would there actually be any excess? But second, if there was excess, could that then begin to form a pot to build additional parking that could still be leveraged by the IFD on top of it, you know, over time? So that gets into, like, a more long-term complex scenario that we can get into. Yeah, no one's, like, endless because you can layer grant funding, assessment districts.

41:12 And that's what this little handout, if you guys have a chance to read through it, kind of talks about it. So it's a more high-level kind of how these EIFDs can really be leveraged to do exactly what you're saying, layering all these sources of funding to get a lot of stuff done. Would you add, as the consultant on this, that if the EIFD were formed, that we would answer some of those questions as far as your suggestion would be to develop a parking district to...

41:41 Do XYZ. And if there were any extra funds, it would go to here to here. I mean, to me, if we're going to have to sell this, we would answer those questions and form that beginning direction. I'm not saying it's in stone, but the beginning direction of parking district, revenue generated, excess revenue. Yep. So, and what I've talked to Sandra and Dan about just this morning is kind of what all...

42:10 So this is really a first step to come back and say, okay, first of all, we've got this new law that we need to account for. We've talked generally about boundaries and about some revenue. Sorry, did you miss that part? Yeah, I'm sorry. So just really quickly, they just passed September 29th. The governor just signed a new bill updating the infrastructure financing district, which makes it easier to create and more flexible.

42:35 So now we don't have to go to a vote to create the district. We just need an agreement of the taxing bodies. And we only have to go to vote to bond. And we only need 55%, not 67%. The body that governs it is also separate now from the town council. It's an appointed body. It's a governing body. It has to be? It has to be. It has to be. It depends on who's putting money into the district. So let's say all the...

43:02 The town, the county, the water district, and fire district all are giving up increment. All of those agencies have at least one member on board plus two. And the term of the district went from being limited to 30 years to not 45. So you've got more time. So there's a lot of positive changes that would help. So I forgot what I was saying to you before that, but I've seen something about moving a lot.

43:33 So, oh, I know what I was going to say. In terms of next steps, so this trip, we're kind of just coming back to that. So the next few slides, I have a few key things that I want to talk about this trip, kind of building off where we left off in May. But then, you know, to your point, we want to drill down and revisit some of the costs. So, like, parking is building a parking structure at X spot is the number one priority. Let's revisit those costs and scenarios that we have run to make sure they're okay. Revisit based upon.

44:02 Our preferred boundaries, how much increment we think we're actually going to generate, knowing what if new development is going to come online. And then we can begin to dig into stuff like that, such as, well, we think we might have an excess, if it makes sense, the timing of all of those things. So we'll get to that in this preliminary study. At least it's high level.

44:23 Jamie, one more question on this slide. Since this was only formed in 2014, I'm presuming the after is just overlaying some previous RDA plan on the area, that obviously not all that happened. No. Correct. No, no. I think this just actually was like June or something that this just went through. Okay. So it's just taking what they already had developed under their RDA. That whole West Sacramento is an RDA district. Okay.

44:53 We have a question about you. Question, are we talking about this in a vacuum, or is the county and board district already apprised of all this? I'm wondering, like, we're capturing the increments of towns where we get back, like, 6% of the property tax. So what's... Yeah, this is, the county has a lot more to...

45:18 We're basically asking to take their money. Well, Ted, you know, you're right. And what we decided was that we really, as initially as a group, needed to really understand what we wanted. And then that's going to be the next step then is once we understand what it is, what we want, and if we want to move forward, then the next step is then we really do need to start engaging not only the county but the other taxing authorities.

45:47 So nobody can't do this obviously in a vacuum. All right, second. So what type of bureaucracy comes with this, Rolls Royce? How many directors and staffers and all that stuff? I mean, there is no mandate for directors. The only thing that's set out is that there's an authority that kind of makes the decisions on how this is being done. So, you know, however, ultimately...

46:16 The monies are going to be spent. I guess that's going to determine this, but it's not recreating redevelopment agencies by any means. It's supposed to be very project-focused. I guess the question is, is there an expectation that this agency could have staff? I mean, it would have staff if they're involved in a project. I can't imagine a volunteer board's going to be.

46:38 Supervisor and managing this kind of thing, there would be a staff component to it, right? Well, I'm assuming that's a portion of the planning and development monies that you can use this for. So, yeah. I mean, it's a really good question. And the IFDs,

47:07 First of all, there's only a handful of them. Second of all, because the IFD law made the town council the organizing body, it was always city staff that were doing the work. So the new EIFD law takes it out of the hands of the town council, puts it into this new governing body. It doesn't specifically set out in any way, shape, or form staff requirements or how that is staffed. And because there is no EIFD formed yet.

47:32 You know, but it's something we'd have to look at. Okay, so it's a capacity that would have to be there. You just have to figure out how to do it. You have the option to contract back one of the agencies involved. They can hire their own staff. The idea of being over time, you just have to bring it along and let them go. You're at that problem. How much of it is contracted out? It should often depend on the type of infrastructure you would put. But explicitly it would not.

47:59 It's a function of the authority. It's a function of the authority, but I think the question is, it's not clear where the staff capacity comes from. If there's contracting issues, if there's union issues, and all that kind of stuff. Good question, though. We'll dig into it. Some of this, because if you guys decide to move forward in the exploration, you're...

48:33 Pioneers with some other folks out there that are exploring it because this is hot off the press. I'm not sure if we answered your question in whole. The question is we're learning. We'll figure that out. I guess, you know, thank you, while I respect your point, I'm surprised that there's not some sort of county supervisor or staffer here taking notes. Am I lost on that or just really silly?

49:08 Well, we did not, I mean, it's a public notice, I mean, they know what we're doing, I mean, we did not not invite them, but we didn't set up a specific, you know, we didn't set up a specific implementation. Does that answer your question? I mean, but we have, this, I think it's really important, this is, you know, just to back up a second, you know, we have this whole concept about being developer prepared, being developer prepared means

49:36 That when somebody comes to town next and wants to do something, we as a town know how we're going to react, and we're just not reacting on the fly or piecemeal. So, you know, and that was where our whole zoning code update, our whole Main Street came, and the next part is parking. And while there's a lot of this that we like, there's a lot of this as a group between council and commission that we don't understand. So the purpose of this is for us to really understand the basics of this, and then once we understand the basics,

50:05 Then council and commission and the business community can make the decision if we want to go forward. And obviously, if we think, yes, this is a good idea, then we'd have to go to not just the county, but to the fire department, et cetera, et cetera, and see what their impressions are. And let me just add on to that too, Mickey, that most of the IFB processes thus far have been city-led, so it's not all that terribly unusual coming out of some planning effort.

50:34 And our job really is to take the study we've done so far and drill it down into, as I had on that one slide, something that makes sense to participate in. So we wouldn't expect to go to the county and be like, here's a general idea. Give us 100% of your increment for the next 45 years. What we need to get to is here are strategically where we're looking at perhaps utilizing this. What were you looking at utilizing it for? This would be the return on investment, ideally.

51:02 What do those numbers look like? So if the county gives up, you know, 10, 20, 30 million over the next few years, does that gain them something at the end of the day? Ideally, if we've done our project right, it has. But we're not even there yet to make that analysis. So after this trip, we can drill down a bit further. And my conversations with, you know, with these folks, with Mickey and Sandra really has been that

51:30 Ideally, in the coming months, once we have a little bit more detail, then we sit down and understand where the county's at on this and work to refine the plan to meet, try to find something that we meet their needs. So the alternative would be everybody collects their own tax increment and then our staff and council negotiate with other governmental bodies and try to do some of these things. In other words,

51:53 You're figuring like if I can just take the money out of their pockets now to prevent them from actually making decisions? It seems like a... We're not taking money out of their pockets. I mean, ultimately, we're just reinvesting their money into the area to hopefully make them more money in the long term. The issue that we discovered in the initial Main Street plan and so forth is that it's a chicken and egg. We need...

52:24 We need public infrastructure to help spur private development. Private development brings more property tax that then ups the game. And so it's not just Mammoth Lakes that faces this issue. It's everywhere in USA that faces this issue. What do you build first to get more? And so somehow we have to make a clear case that by investing X amount of dollars, that brings X amount more in private investment. And that generates...

52:52 This percentage more of property tax that the county would get if the district didn't exist. It's kind of a but-for argument, you know, and that's the case that we have to do. That's the case any district around the country has to make to be created. The but-for, what happens, you know, without it, and what happens with it, and where's that nexus that everybody can buy into the senior return on investment. So isn't, like, if I just go to the next slide, maybe move into the next part of the presentation, shouldn't

53:22 You've got funding priorities as a third bullet. Shouldn't the funding priorities be the first bullet? Because depending on what kind of project you're doing, that's going to determine who the taxing agency partner is going to be. That's how you're structurally based on what the project is, correct? Sure. Right? So why would you start drawing boundaries, talking to tax reporting negotiations if you don't know what it is that you're doing?

53:46 Well, so first of all, we've got a preliminary list of priorities already identified from the work that we've done. So we're not necessarily starting from scratch here. The reason it's sort of down the list is it's more of a reiteration. Are we still in the same place we were six months ago when we had this discussion, first and foremost? And so I think we're pretty clear generally of what the priorities are of stakeholders. We just need to affirm that. The boundary discussion is critical.

54:16 Because of these two points. First of all, they don't have to be contiguous. So we don't have to think of it in terms of one geographic area that we have to be able to draw a circle around. Second of all, there's all sorts of considerations in creating it. First of all, well not first of all, but really the first two are tied. What are the receptivity of both the stakeholders and the taxing bodies to doing this? Because we need to understand kind of where their support lays.

54:44 And what's the revenue generation potential of each and what the taxing bodies give up in each scenario? Because that's going to make probably a big, big decision as well. And also understanding as of today, what's the timing of new development coming out of the ground? So if you look at the three different boundary scenarios that we have previously talked about, and I'm sorry these are really hard to see on this screen, but this is a huge district that

55:12 As you can see, it goes, I'm just going to outline it here. It basically covers the whole area we kind of looked at as part of our study areas. It goes all the way down here and all the way up here. It takes in that whole thing. So that would be one huge district that would collect increment from that whole district. So basically it's our commercial zones in the North Village. This is now going back into the parking lot.

55:41 Right. And then we looked at a more focused approach that was just kind of the Main Street area and Old Mammoth Road area and capturing that. And the third option, which I think might be the more interesting option to delve into, is just selecting specific project sites. So that really gets back to my point of understanding the timing of new developments coming out of the ground.

56:09 Where those are, what parcels those are that either now or in the next few years we think might see new development, increased density, and drawing a circle around those just to be able to capture revenue from those, which we can do, which would be totally acceptable. And then you've got two different cases, right? Because one is collecting all the increment from both existing property and new development, if you draw a larger boundary, versus saying,

56:38 We just want to focus on places where we know development's going to happen and capture the increment from the ground up in those and try and use that. So that's why that actually becomes a more complex discussion as the top discussion because then we can sort of figure out, again, just affirming some of those other details we've already kind of sketched out. These districts, again, we're talking about parking. Parking is the ostensible thing that we're talking about. Good point.

57:05 But ultimately, if in this discovery process, we as a group decide, okay, maybe there's something other than parking we want to talk about, also as far as infrastructure, then we can talk about it. But we started this from our work knowing that we have a huge parking problem. And the question was, how are we going to solve our parking problem?

57:30 So, yeah, I mean, I've just thrown up here, you know, this is what came out before, parking, main street utilities, main street improvements, what else? You know, but we know parking really rose to the fore and was the focus of the last sort of feasibility study that we looked at. I think the big question is where, which is the first project, what's the location? You know, we need to drill down to kind of those types of things to understand the cost factor and get to some of the stuff we were talking about, such as, you know.

57:59 How much do we need to build it and then operate and maintain it and how could that be reinvested? John, make no mistake, those three things would eat up all the money. Can we go back to the third scenario of yours, electric project sites? You'd have to presume since Main Lodge is six miles away from town that over the 45 years you'd end up building

58:30 So not only can you have select project sites for your

58:59 Projects, but you also have select project sites for the people that are investing in it. You can take dollars from the mountain, from the upper mountain.

59:08 We just have to make a case of how that has community-wide significance, exactly, what the nexus is between the two. So somehow we need to make the case for that, and I'm assuming the mountain, you know, we've got mountain representation. Yeah, would you be bringing back options that show bigger and smaller and potential in that way? Because, you know,

59:32 I realize, you know, the mountain's going to have, if you're part of it, you're going to have what they say in it, but I'm trying to figure out just from that high level first look how you're going to analyze something like parking around transit hubs or something. You know, I mean, look, from our perspective, from the mountain's perspective, the resort starts down at 203 to 305, and the experience, you know, begins beyond that, right? But, you know,

59:59 For example, you know, the summer activities and the festivals that happen in town generate a lot of laundry revenue for our properties as well as everybody else. So, you know, our view is the rising tide raises all the ships. And so there's absolutely, you know, no issue. I mean, I think what you want to do is you want to include as many of the areas that are going to have new development. As Jamie pointed out, I mean, there's a huge increment in tax. Sure. You have raw land. Yeah, right. It's just land, property tax on raw land versus.

1:00:28 500 hotel rooms in the future. I was just trying to kind of sew back the conversation and also to say that you're not doing this for just one item. You're doing it for several things over that 45 years. The West Sacramento thing where they had all that planning done with the RDA, they had all that stuff in there and they would implement it as it.

1:00:50 So all we can do at the starting point of this is... You've got one more question. Sure, sure. Just let me address that. All we can do at the starting point of this is, first of all, I just want to be clear. The project, when I say select project sites, these are actually, I'm meaning this is where we would draw the district boundary. We would try and capture project sites. This isn't where we're going to do the projects. No, but I mean the nexus...

1:01:18 To something that is a distance away. And I understand the mountain's philosophy, but, you know, that it's just the reverse, is if what if it's something up the mountain first and the people, you know. Right. You have to recognize how you're going to have to shape this. That's right. And that's why we have to go through the process of developing the plan and the detail behind it and all of that. And as you said, there's several projects. It's not just our plan is just going to be we'll build a parking structure and see what happens after that. We have to identify our kind of list and our list of priorities.

1:01:47 As well, that would be funded by this. But we can also assume that there's going to be other money coming in. There'll be grant money. There'll be money from, you know, revenue generated from these improvements that we can potentially reinvest in the future. So it's hard to know. There's no way we can forecast everything. We have to make some very general assumptions and know what our priorities are up front.

1:02:19 So there's other things besides just the parking districts or the parking garages. Right, and I wanted to make that point that it's not a we do one thing and then we're done. But I think it goes back to the original question of where's the nexus. Correct. It doesn't necessarily have to go back to the payee of the increment. It has to go back to a community-wide benefit. But if you want the votes. Sure, but it's not necessarily, in this case, it's not really a loss for the mountain.

1:02:49 If we're talking about who is impacted by this, it would be the county and the town, because those are the ones who are losing those dollars. Well, it sounds like if you can bring other projects online as you go over time, and the handoff from the state talks about the need of a strategic plan to look about what you're doing, and we may be extensively talking about parking here as kind of a framing part of the conversation, but you may want to be thinking about an authority that could handle a wide range.

1:03:13 And not to go all the way back, but if you go to the very first Main Street plan, all of those tools and its considerations for that are actually bundled in there. And so we're kind of going this direction now. We started with the big toolbox. We narrowed it down to

1:03:42 Where to start? You know, that was the big challenge last time. What do we do for second and third? We focus on the IFD as a starting point because it's going to generate potentially the most. And then I think you can build back up. Once you know what you can build with that, you can begin to do, you know, different structures to manage incremental revenues and grants and more money coming in from different sources. Two questions. One, can you, you've got Eagle and Canyon and Mainlaunch. Can you

1:04:10 And then I'll assume that at some point in time you'll have a

1:04:41 Formation vote, but then your continuing project vote as a newly created board, how will that work? Will that be then back to each property owner, one vote per acre, or does the board determine what project 22 is? I'm getting way ahead of myself, but the question will come up, especially to convince people along Main Street, Mammoth Road.

1:05:10 If there's too much square footage, acres, however you want to dice it up, if there's too much under control of one entity, then they can influence the boat and you could possibly not see improvements anywhere else. Well, so I think the answer is the governing body, I mean, based upon the plan priorities set out, the governing body would then do that, which is how most special districts work anyway, and then the governing body wants to take it forward.

1:05:39 I'm not sure what you mean by when you say one entity has too much control. Well, if you have Eagle Canyon, Main Lodge, Resort Corridor all in the district, they'll equal 100. Yeah, but that only matters in the bonding vote. It doesn't matter for anything after that. But if they don't vote to support the bonding of a parking structure on the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Main Street.

1:06:07 Then, you see my point? You're getting... Sure. But that's why we have to go through a very strategic planning process, isn't it? And engage them to understand what they will support. Well, keep in mind, too, that it's held by Mammoth Mountain now, but eventually it's subdivided and sold off, and then there's just all the other property owners that are part of those pieces of property. Well, that's my question. I don't know how that would work. In other words, the Chair 15 becomes a 100-unit complex.

1:06:35 Are there now 100 new people that have to vote to support the bonding, or is it still just the property owner as a condominium project? Jamie, why don't you go back to the authority slide? As I understand... They're confusing the authority. Because what changed, Tom, you may have missed us, is that there's an authority and then there's the vote for the bonding. So that's kind of two different... The bonding is as one piece of the findings. It's just part of it, right?

1:07:04 So there's not going to be a bond vote for every single project, I'm assuming. Yeah, but you could bundle multiple projects in one bond vote. So we could potentially, if we identify our revenue, I mean, we could potentially say we're going to do two parking structures with a roundabout.

1:07:32 Utilities, whatever, and that's all one bond vote, and we don't, you know, later, many years later, we go down and do another bond vote. We don't have to do a perfect project. We can bundle. We can bundle. However you want. And then not pull the entire bond. If you bond for $100 million, it may be in $20 million increments as projects and revenue come on bond. Yeah, I mean, we'll have to dig into the bond. I'll talk to these guys again because they...

1:08:01 For example, they approved $500 million in bonding capacity over the life of the IFD as opposed to just doing it. So I think you can do that. We can dig into that a little bit. That was an IFD, not an EA. Yeah, but it should be generally the same.

1:08:22 One more question, and it goes to, you know, everybody keeps throwing out the idea of grants are out there. It was on the additional list, and it was essentially, to my understanding at the time, more or less set aside, because if you're looking at, like, transportation grants, what goes through a local transportation commission has already committed funding out through the mid-2020s for existing projects, so I think we need to know more about, well, where are these grants going to appear for?

1:08:48 When you go into the next steps, because the reality is, I mean, it's like Alantia Cartago doesn't even start until 2007, maybe. So you're now getting into a whole different ballgame of research and identification. I think the point is that what people have said in our outreach and so forth, and if you look at some of the other work that's been done, and even this document talks about leveraging grants, it comes down to this.

1:09:13 This source of funding that you now have, which you wouldn't have before that's dedicated to building infrastructure. So you can leverage that against matching grants and programs that hopefully up the ante on your grant game. Correct. But discovering those actual grant things is something that has to happen in the research going forward. You can't just say, well, you're going to have grants to cover 30% of it because if you don't have a funding source for them, you don't have 30% of it covered.

1:09:37 Sure. It's just a reality check. And I don't think, we wouldn't put together a plan that assumed a grant without knowing that, you know, it was a reality. So I think we're looking at, you know, they sort of talk about grants in the terms of, as you mentioned, the strategic plan and some of this stuff, whereas, you know, identify the initial sources of funding and then use that over time to leverage to continue to do more and more that's identified in your IFD plan. So. Like, for example, if now didn't you obtain the majority of the funding from 30 years?

1:10:09 Yeah, but that's the money that I'm saying. We've got commitments in all the available funding up to the mid-2020s at this point. Yeah. But it's kind of saying what that other stuff is going to be. I think it's also a question, which we can get to at some point, is if the state, I've had a question in this, in the handout from the state, it talks about the administration. I'm assuming that's the state of California.

1:10:38 The third paragraph says the administration has identified the same problem or potential solution. The state of California. The state of California. So the question is, with everybody being stressed for financing and looking for creative and innovative ways to deal with infrastructure issues, is this really going to be the model going forward and what are the implications that may be for doing this? And there's yet to be any EIFD, correct? Well, that's because it was just passed on September 29th. I understand.

1:11:06 You know, municipalities are asking to kind of reconfigure our structures, our staffing, our expectations of how we're going to do things. It's going to be important to know how reliable that foundation is, not get involved in something and all of a sudden there's some court challenges or something down the way they don't think it's allowed. These are concerns. I think it's a concern with anything. I think, you know, the IFD law has been on the books since 1990.

1:11:36 Maybe even before that in some capacity I think I read, but as it called the IFD. And, you know, it was a fairly good law just because the redevelopment agency's issue couldn't really be fully utilized or implemented. So ever since redevelopment went away, the IFDs have been looked at very closely, discussed and so forth. So, I mean, you're right, but I think, you know, it was a pretty full-on discussion, well supported by...

1:12:05 The other kind of thing that Joe's bringing up is that some things may change, but actually a lot of things maybe have not changed. And I'm thinking about the issues about staffing, prevailing wage issues, contracting, all kinds of things. Are you kind of creating a parallel, you know, I'm not saying it's a bad thing, but you create a sort of parallel authority that, I mean, the water district has its own capacity and all kinds of things. Is this thing going to have its, you know, what capacity is it going to have? Is it going to be writing grants? Would it have more success writing grants because it's not?

1:12:34 Yeah, I mean, we said we'll look at the staffing thing, so I'll ask around on that, try and get some actual answers to those questions, but...

1:12:55 You know, I think on some of those other things you're talking hypothetically, how do we know? I mean, what we do know about IFDs, why people do them, why the state of California has invested so much time in trying to, you know, get this and others to make this happen, is it's a dedicated source for funding. So once the money, the increments being collected, it is dedicated to infrastructure, which right now we don't have a fund for.

1:13:22 I mean, even just at the town, you don't necessarily have enough funds dedicated to infrastructure to do everything you need to. So it's another dedicated source of revenue everybody's chipping in on. And that is, in my opinion, what gives you the leverage to get other monies and grants, right? Because you know how much you're going to get over a period of time, at least ideally. In the big picture, you know. And you know that money has to be reinvested in infrastructure. So, you know, it's there. Yeah, I just, again, I'm just thinking about it. I mean, there's a lot of federal grants that...

1:13:50 If we set up an authority like this, and the federal government doesn't even know these kinds of things are happening, it bonds, it raises, say, $50 million, it wants to go out, let's say, federal transportation grants, like that's the thing that Joe's talking about, and now you've got another body that's engaging with established mechanisms, and, okay, I guess it could work, I'm assuming it will work, but you need staff, you need people writing grants, you're going to need to be coordinating with your municipal staff, because all the contracting theory is going to go through them.

1:14:19 And it's something that we're already investing in between MLR and TBIDS and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. This government has already, has been for a while, getting into this game. So I think we've got a little bit of sophistication as far as these things are concerned. I think we know the kinds of questions that need to be asked. And so it's all interesting. There's a lot of great possibilities that it's going to take some good diligence to really figure out what the implications are going to be. Absolutely. So it's just, I mean, these are just good, normal questions to ask, but they're going to need to be asked.

1:14:48 I think, you know, John, the important thing is that when we did all our Main Street research, you know, and you go back to, you know, all our original visions of what we're trying to accomplish as far as being feet first, you know, having shared parking because of the economy of scales and what it does with the overall health of the town, and then, you know, the original report, I'm not sure you saw it because it was, you know, prior to being on the council.

1:15:14 There was various options, and out of the various options, this one seemed like the most plausible. So I think everything you're asking are like really good questions, and I think that's ultimately the way to decide today. Is this something that in theory we like well enough that's worth continuing to do with? Because we are right. We have had a lot of experience now.

1:15:36 With, you know, Maniflex Tourism, Maniflex Recreation, to know what we're talking about when we start another authority. It's a big project with a lot of good consequences and some unintended consequences. Yeah, we just have to do our digital mass. In essence, you just go down to the basic principle things. It's just giving you the ability to capture the incremental tax revenue. That you don't have access to the town government limits. So the EIF, you get you the ability to take...

1:16:06 Other questions? So I think we've kind of jumped into some of these. So we've talked a little bit about the boundaries, about how we approach the taxing authority.

1:16:42 Primarily understanding where their interests might lie in supporting this or not. Funding priorities, we'll be vetting that a little bit further. And then the last three points are just kind of more general conversations. One is just on this whole idea of the communications about the IFD or the EIFD and what it is, what it does.

1:17:10 Related to things like T-Bid and P-Bid and making sure everybody understands how those work and what those are because there are different types of revenue generation, different types of assessment, who pays what. And I think we need to be very clear as this becomes more publicly discussed that people don't get scared and real against it right away. So talking about that and the timelines that we might be looking at.

1:17:38 For creating this, what everybody's thoughts are on that. So just because in some circumstances, you know, I'm working on a tip district in Denver and we're fast tracking it because there's about five new huge projects coming out of the ground in an industrial area which we want to capture the revenue. So is it imminent? Do we want to move faster? Do we have a little bit of time? What types of things are we looking at? And then the governance, so the law sets out as we already talked about that

1:18:08 A representative of all the taxing bodies giving up increment have to sit on it and at least two public people. But just again understanding where the comfort level is of how would that be chosen, what does that look like, how does that operate and so forth. Kind of getting a feel for that. And so those are the types of things too we'll be talking about this afternoon. We're having a little workshop this afternoon and digging into a little bit further on those.

1:18:34 I won't spend much more time on that unless anybody has any additional thoughts or comments specifically on this piece. I'll just skip ahead. We've, again, already kind of talked about this. This, by the way, I haven't gone through this. This is in the Main Street Feasibility, sorry, the Snow and Parking District Feasibility Study, the second report.

1:19:05 These were the revenue generation potential we looked at. And so these are very, very, very high level. I will say we looked at current baseline assessed property values in those three different option areas. And we just made a very broad assumption on the Mammoth Mountain basis because we didn't have the data at the time and how much property taxes are collected. So we just wanted to get a sense of

1:19:33 What type of revenue would be collected from the increment in each of those options? And then over 30 years, because at that time we were looking at the 30 year time limit. But you can see at the bottom the potential impact of new development is really where you get your biggest bang and why we need to focus very clearly on understanding where those new development sites are coming up. Yeah.

1:20:02 I had a kind of question around that. So right now, you know, essentially what we've talked about is structuring this around new development or existing increment. So is there a possibility to structure this so that you could delineate between the two? So you could say that this IFD only applies to new development or does it have to fall into the increment associated with existing?

1:20:28 I don't know. I think you probably could. I think you probably could make a case that it only applied to new development. We'd have to talk to, yeah, we'd have to talk to some attorneys on what that threshold would be. If you would want to include it as product-based teaching, if the development's going to enhance things, if there's some values, why would you want to include anything? Sure, and I understand that, but I'm saying it is a point for, to be able to sell this. Right now, the county's keeping 100% zero.

1:21:00 And so if we're stimulating new development and that's where the funding is coming from, you know, looking at a balance there is my question. I just don't understand. I'm just trying to understand how flexible this is. I think we might be better off. I mean, we can look into that, like, legally, how you would do that, how that would work.

1:21:22 I think we'd probably be better off if that's what you wanted to do, just identifying where those both known and assumed development sites are or will be in the future and drawing a circle around those to include them in the district. So it'd be difficult to do that, for example, for like the commercial districts because we already have existing stuff in those districts. Presumably there would be new development there. You couldn't parcel off.

1:21:49 This is new development on Main Street and therefore funnels into the IFD. I'm just wondering how flexible this mechanism is. Well, you could, I mean, I'm not exactly sure what you're asking there, but you could say, you know, if you went down the block that, you know, presumably this site is underdeveloped right now. At some point we assume it would be redeveloped and so we could capture that. I'm not exactly sure what you're... You could say every vacant lot.

1:22:15 That was developed or need developed or something like that. And that's right. But you'd have to be very careful with your language. I think the way you get around that, you look at that going, you take the base 2% increments, you get off Prop 13 going up, and that's a straight pass through, so all the existing development, you know, and then the raw land stuff where you have a large incremental new, you get captured that, that's almost the beginning at what you're going to get what your normal growth would be anyway.

1:22:42 But the new stuff is captured for the IFD. So there's a balancing of that. You're stating it better than I was, but that's what I'm getting at. Yeah. So there'll be a continuing growth element to the county and other agencies. Right. Offer existing development. New development have a much larger impact on the IFD. Right. I think also the corollary to that is, you mentioned before about tying this in with development that's going to happen. Right. You know, we're a pretty unique situation up here. The cost of building construction is...

1:23:08 Hi, we're in the snow business, and there's a lot of variables that can come into play with that, and I'd be interested to know the degree to which private activity, whether this IFD is tied to private activity. I think the point is, well, no private activity happens at all. If we could set something up, we just have to do an increment based on just what was known, and we're not betting on, oh, yeah, well, this is going to happen.

1:23:34 Sure. Well, I think we have to be thinking about things of, well, what happens if it does come down? You know, we don't want to get the public in the situation.

1:24:03 Bonded a bunch of things and the private stuff isn't happening and all of a sudden we're building infrastructure that we can't maintain, there's not going to be a revenue to do, we have to be smart about that kind of stuff. Also to add to that, and I think there's a question at the end of this, but there's a delta there that I think Colin's trying to get to. The county gets 100% zero. You have to convince the county that, as Dan said, what does go up in the general vicinity of this improvement.

1:24:33 But you've also got to point out to the county that they're not going to have much, if any, additional cost for these projects that go in. The town has to then look at it on their basis. What will the additional cost? What will the additional requirements be? So the question at the end of the day is, can you strike a deal with other agencies that allows them to benefit sooner or in a graduated scale?

1:25:03 of this new development. So in other words, you say we projected there'll be additional development, additional assessed value of $100 million. And we'd like you to contribute all of that to the IFD the first five years. Yep. Part of it the second five years. I'm just throwing up numbers. We talked about that there's actually a precedent for that in this Rink and Hill one, where if you look at the third bullet down,

1:25:32 So they gave 100% of their increment to jumpstart investment in the first five years. And then they dropped down to 30% by year 8 and 14% by year 12. And there's other scenarios where you can, I mean, year by year you could go down, you know, 2% each year. Your pitch showing them that A, that can be like that and B, there's no additional cost to the county for this to incentivize potentially development.

1:26:01 The town's costs will be where the town's costs are, and that has to be thought of and taken into account. But in this specific example, that was all packaged together. Right. That was all packaged together. New development and existing increment, or increment on existing development. Okay. And you think about the increment on existing development, unless they're adding new elements to it, it's not a tax. So even though the value goes up, it doesn't mean you get more property tax that you want. So I'll show you what new investment you can get to drive that. Right. Yep.

1:26:30 That's an important distinction. Because the dollars are percentage-based. The increment is percentage-based. The increment is a dollar generation off of, if you're making $100 and make $110, those $10, that's the increment. So those $10 go, then the increment would be out. But that $10 is a percentage. It's not hard dollars. It's percentages. Other questions? Okay.

1:27:07 Well, just in terms of next steps, real quick, I kind of hit on this, what we're going to do with this. So again, this is just the launching point from the last discussion we had on this at May and also trying to clearly understand the EIFD a little bit more, delve into some of these specifics, which we will do. We're having a workshop this afternoon to kind of talk about some of those things on that list I just showed you in a bit more detail.

1:27:37 We will look at identifying more clear costings on some of the priority projects that have been identified and also updating our revenue scenarios based upon boundaries and looking at that. We will be talking about how we engage the taxing bodies and, again, that conversation on benefit and the but for whole analysis piece, you know, what they get doing nothing, what they get participating.

1:28:05 And kind of begin to formulate that whole part of making a case for the need of the district and the goals for it because that's something you need to move into the actual resolution of intent to create the plan. So we'll begin to outline that. And that'll kind of be our work after this trip. And then there'll be another trip to come back and work through some of those more specific details, if you will. Jamie, can you clarify who this afternoon's workshop is with? Maybe Mickey or Sandra can...

1:28:34 Tell me who else is going to be there. It was with the stakeholders that contributed funding. Okay. I think the thing that we need to know, if we haven't clarified from council, is, you know, how do you want us to communicate that with you and what's your direction to that group, vice versa? Well, I don't think we're in a position to give direction at this point. This is, you know, on a first go-around. So my next step of Sandra Dan is going to be what do you see as the next steps.

1:29:03 And is what Jamie is talking about as the next steps funded? Yeah, I guess the question would be, do you have a contract with these stakeholders that's outside of the town? The contract's with the town. It's what the town was that invited to be funded. Okay, and if there's a scope of work for that, I'm assuming? Yes. It'd be nice to maybe know the things like... You can see it. Oh, yeah, I'd just like to know kind of what that is and where kind of you're headed and how far are you going to go. I think, for me, this has brought a lot of very interesting issues, a lot of very interesting things to talk about.

1:29:32 I would look to Joe's engagement with Deanne in figuring out where this is going and to figure out when the appropriate time for council start getting involved a little bit and get some opportunities. I think getting some of the supervisors to a better next meeting would be pretty smart. Well, I think it's a focus. There's a lot of things, I think, from a town perspective, from kind of the larger question of infrastructure.

1:29:59 And demand and revenue and how we're going to maintain things. Just get a kind of sense of where we're at. So that we can, if we're going to be in the money-making, if we're going to the county and saying, look, we want to do something that you're going to benefit from. Things like airports we've talked about, all the kinds of things that we're doing. I think we want to be putting some value-added propositions to them that their buy-in's not going to be, well, yeah, it sounds like you guys are doing something good, but it's actually going to be something that we can start talking about what the value's going to look like.

1:30:27 I think that may be a conversation for us to have before we start tracking that into it. Back to before she slipped to the slide, you were asking, John, it is a percentage and it is incremental dollar. Right. So Dan was going to explain it to you afterwards. It's all relevant. You have that incremental build of a $100 million project, but that could increase the value of an existing build.

1:30:59 To a point where you get a percentage increase based on the 2% of your which you're allowed to go by. So just so that that's clear. And the part about bringing in supervisors and other people, I think it might be a little premature. I mean, you've got, there's a ton of work to be done, and I like the way she's got this outline. And quite honestly, they've been a great consulting company that has worked on Main Street with the planning department. I think they've done a great job.

1:31:27 But you've got to get some clear resolution of the intent and where and start to create some models because you don't want to, it's too big for the supervisors to, not necessarily grasp, but to agree with and she made a comment earlier that you don't want to alienate people right off the start. So putting together a nice tiny package.

1:31:58 With, not the final, but with the first part of discussion, I think is important so that when you go to other agencies. Yeah, so to kind of pull that back, so you've got a workshop this afternoon and then you're going to go off and do some things and come back to someone at some point. That's what I was asking, what are the next steps? It'll come back and work to the staff and it'll actually come back up to the planning commission. Okay. In what time frame?

1:32:29 We haven't discussed that and we talked about a return trip to do those meetings and perhaps engage with the county as well in those initial discussions. But I guess we need to sit down. We're running into this problematic time frame of Thanksgiving, Christmas. Whether or not we can wrap that up this year or it's right after the holidays, I'm happy to work with you guys on whatever timeline you need. I probably need...

1:32:59 You know, at least a month to kind of go back and do some of this stuff, get next iteration prepared. We're probably in January. Okay. And she can come for a week if she can fly out on a Saturday. Yeah, and ski. Yeah, there you go. That's right. I just, I would, thank you very much. This has been very helpful, very interesting. Good. I've gotten a lot of good information. And I think that there may be some very significant implications for this for projects beyond which we're just talking about this morning. Sure. And so I would hope whatever you guys are doing,

1:33:29 I'm just hopeful that the council, we can have a conversation at some point about this new mechanism, the EIFDA's laws council, for a lot of infrastructure things we have to deal with, and I just hope that whatever you do with what you're doing, you don't get too far down a hole, that we don't be surprised if we have more of a higher level conversation about this as a mechanism, as a tool, to address a lot of issues we haven't even thought about yet, but I think we want to make sure that we can have that conversation before we start getting too far down a hole. And we're completely open to that. Again,

1:33:58 Understanding this work has come out of a Main Street plan that I've gotten involved in, so we've whittled down to kind of our priorities through that process, but I know there might be other things outside of that that we need to be and should be considering. However that information gathering needs to happen, happy to talk about it today, happy if you guys want to communicate directly with me about it. Happy to talk further about it when I'm here next time too.

1:34:27 So we at this point, the good thing is what I'm trying to work you guys towards is giving you enough information to actually start the process of going into it, right? And so you've got that creation of an authority. That's why I want to talk a little bit about what would that mean. Then you've got the resolution of intent, which doesn't require you to be detailed. It just requires you to be fairly general on goals, need, where.

1:34:52 Kind of when and general outline of projects that you might want to fund. You say resolution of intent, is that a literal resolution for the council of intent? Yes, it is. Is that on the horizon at any time soon? You have to create the authority first. That's actually the first step. You have to create the authority and then the authority brings forth the resolution of intent.

1:35:17 And so, and again, you can see the only things that that needs to include are those four items on the bottom. We don't need to go into great, great depths of detail on that piece because that all comes in the infrastructure financing plan. Does the town need to be involved in doing initial work just to have some authority? Yes. Do private parties do it? You have to. Right here. We actually create the authority that would be in action by the town to do that, moving forward.

1:35:44 At that point, the authority goes through. So at that point, you are either a one or two member. You're no longer, it's no longer the town's project. Right now, the authority's project. But the town has to do that. The private parties can't be. Correct. Yeah, it's a governmental agency you're creating. Okay. So you, by the time I'm done with this phase of work that's funded, you should have enough information to at least go forward with step one and two or at least get some, you know, have some general guidance on that. And then in terms of the whole financing plan, you know,

1:36:13 Overview of detail, at least high-level detail on that. Because that will obviously take quite a bit of work digging into the specifics on some of that stuff. Yeah, I just think that before we start establishing things we want to have it, that larger conversation I mentioned before. Okay. And then just to kind of clarify about the stakeholder group, it wasn't some exclusive group. Basically, we went out to every business person, landowner that we could think of and said, hey,

1:36:43 We think this is an interesting concept. Would you like to fund some dollars to bring the consultant back? Some people said yes, and that formed our stakeholder group. So I don't want anybody to think, oh gosh, I didn't get my invitation. All are welcome. Your invitation was a check? Yes, sounds like it. But that's also an open meeting. Right. No, it's not a public meeting. It's not a public meeting? Okay.

1:37:11 But it's not. And it's going to be at the Grand Sierra Watch. And to everybody here, my information is on the PowerPoint, and I have cards, so if you want to communicate directly with me about questions or more on this or share your thoughts or whatever, please don't hesitate to. Well, thank you, Jamie.

1:37:36 Thank you, audience members, for your participation, and planning commissioners, thank you for showing up. Council members, you don't get to leave yet. We do have a closed session item. We need to adjourn to closed session.

1:38:07 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.