Town Council Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 12 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
147 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 It is not policy, right? Yes. That looks like it'll work. But if you give me some important information, make it come true to me. Yeah. Well, you know, he's not prepared for me. Right. He's quite pleased with me. I haven't heard. Yeah. I don't know. He's a family story. He's telling me stories. But that's stuff you never know. Yeah. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.
0:28 Yeah, I just wanted to show that actually. Sure, I think that will work. Yeah, I think that will work. Well, because I know there was a banner trails meeting on Monday, so there may be some input. Yeah, well, you get some input. Yes.
1:02 John's not coming. John is not coming. Michael's not coming. And Michael's not coming. Okay, then we've got everybody.
1:35 Okay, shall we go ahead and comment?
2:21 Thank you, Chief. We will begin with public comments on matters that are not on the agenda, seeing none. I'll next just turn this over to Mickey Brown for intro or whatever.
3:20 There you go. Well, good morning, everybody, and thank you for coming. I appreciate it. Thank you to the members in the audience. I thought it would be appropriate just to do a quick recap about how we got to this point this morning. Interestingly enough, this started back in 2007 with our general plan, and every planning document the town has approved since then has talked about how we severely lack infrastructure
3:49 In various aspects in our town. And in the, for example, in the 2011 district planning document underneath the North Village, it said one of the key facilities that the North Village needed, but this was back in 2011, is that we needed a parking structure. And as many of you know, we spent two years working on our Main Street document, and that Main Street document even had a whole separate section, a feasibility section,
4:19 On parking. And then in our 2012, Dr. Sedd's document, it went one step further underneath economic recovery. And one of the objectives was that we really needed to, quote, explore different sources of revenue. And typical revenue sources could include bond measures, facility assessment districts, maintenance districts, business improvement districts.
4:47 This has been a topic that has been around for a number of years that one, we needed infrastructure, two, we needed to come up with sources about how to fund it. The commission initially was introduced to this economic tool of infrastructure financing districts during our work on Main Street. As you know, we had a meeting with council about that last fall. And then subsequent
5:15 To our meeting with council, Governor Jerry Brown then passed state legislation which really took that vehicle and even made it better with their enhanced infrastructure financing district. So commission feels strongly that it's an economic tool that at the minimum everybody needs to understand what the tool is.
5:44 Both all the different taxing authorities and governing bodies that are associated with Mammoth Lakes. So it's not a Mono County issue. It's not a Mammoth Lakes issue. This is an economic tool that can be used for infrastructure. And, you know, I think as all the commissioners, we don't believe that we necessarily have all the answers about the tools. But what we really want to do is our goal has been
6:13 Along with members of the private sector is let's really just understand what we can do with this tool and then see how this tool can dovetail into what we want to accomplish at Mammoth Lakes. So we would like to accomplish three things today with council. First of all, Jamie, our consultant, who I think everybody's met, is going to do a relatively brief slide presentation.
6:42 On what has changed since the last time she was here with the tool. If anybody has detailed questions, we can spend more time on it. That's your prerogative of what kind of background information. Still amazing to us after numerous meetings, some of the misconceptions out there about what it does, what it doesn't do. Then Jamie will summarize her meetings. She's met, how many meetings have you had? A dozen meetings this week? That's right.
7:12 Private sector, public sector, she met with Mono County, she met with the fire department, she met with the water district, and then last and probably the most important is that we really need to agree on next steps. So that's on our agenda. I didn't know if you had anything else. Nope. Is that good? Okay. Sounds good. All right. With that, are you going to? I'm going to turn it over to Jania. Okay. Take it off. All right. Great. Thank you, everybody. It's good to be back.
7:39 I'm going to apologize in advance. I'm fighting a cold, so I've got cop drop in my mouth, but I'll do my best to make it through the presentation. It's been a really good and really busy week here, talking about the EIFD with lots of different folks. And as Mickey said, I've only got about a dozen slides here or so, but I just kind of want to walk us through how we've gotten here.
8:09 Again, just some background on the EIFD tool. And then I want to talk a little bit about kind of the key themes emerging from the conversations this week and what that means in terms of going forward. Alluded to, well, I think, you know, she stretched the work back to 2007, which is certainly true in terms of looking at some of the opportunities and challenges here in Mammoth Lakes. I've actually been involved here since, well, really 2013, I guess.
8:43 When we started work on the Town of Mammoth Lakes Main Street plan, which was formally completed in February of 2014. And this plan really looked at how to really create the downtown as a destination and transform the Main Street corridor, really looking at the pedestrianization, making it a year-round destination, and encouraging
9:11 New investment and new development to happen here. It's stimulating the local economy. And so it addressed a wide range of issues and really took a lot of the broad-based concepts that had been identified before and brought them into kind of a phased implementation strategy as well as looking at how do we actually do the work? How do we implement it? Where does the money come from to do that?
9:38 And, you know, how do we manage that change here going forward? So that plan really addressed a whole variety of things. Obviously, it addressed the Main Street, actually, character or core, but it looked at parks and open space. It looked at what the character of new development might be if we encourage new investment here. Accommodating all modes of travel from vehicles to pedestrians to bicycles. Creating a real identity.
10:09 And solving some of the challenges here of development, including but not limited to parking and the cost of development challenges here and how we might overcome those, as well as ongoing maintenance and dealing with things like snow when we actually have snow here in better years. And so it was a pretty thorough and comprehensive plan in that regard. The outcome of that work, the council and commission looked at that and said,
10:43 We don't want this to sit on the shelf. How do we keep things moving forward? And the first big hurdle was finding money to tackle those challenges. And so immediately following the completion of the Main Street Plan, I was commissioned along with another team, parking consultant and so forth, to come in and look at the feasibility and more detail on
11:11 In particular, the parking and snow management issues because we kind of identified that we needed to address some of the underlying challenges of developing and doing business here and deal with those before we could put some of the enhancements in here. And so through that, we looked at primarily four key funding tools, all of which had been initially identified in the Main Street Plan. And our charge was really to dig into those tools and say, which is
11:41 Most likely to work here. Which is most likely to address our challenges? And if we were to look at this kind of toolbox that we have, which kind of comes first? And so the key findings from that study were that there were some serious financial barriers to good development that were in line with the vision of the plan. Again, as we talked about.
12:06 It's some of those things that are really about closing the gap on development here. Developing in Mammoth Lakes is expensive. It's more expensive than the average place because of location, because of geography, et cetera, et cetera. And so we looked at everything from fees and so forth, which the town has been looking at. But also there's bigger issues like the cost of parking and the need for parking in a development, utilities, et cetera, et cetera.
12:37 And we really identified that we needed to overcome some of those financial barriers to development and be able to, quote unquote, prime the pump for development here. Because without private sector investment, we lack kind of the stimulation to the economy and to the tax base that we need to actually do more things here. So we also have good opportunities are emerging. I mean, slowly we're still coming out of the recession, particularly here in Mammoth Lakes. But there are projects out there.
13:06 And people looking to invest here. There's definitely a desire to think bigger and move beyond a more weather-dependent economy and diversify and strengthen the year-round economy. And that the only way we're really going to make anything happen here is to be coordinated and cooperative looking at all the public sector entities and all the private sector entities really working together to leverage their interests, to leverage resources, to make some additional
13:35 Funding tools. The infrastructure financing district really emerged from that work as their most important tool. Shortly after we completed that work, the private entities here contributed some resources to continue researching and looking into the feasibility of an IFD here.
14:21 In Mammoth Lakes. And so that work began kind of in late summer, that process. And then, much to our surprise, in September, as Nikki alluded to, the governor approved some amendments to the infrastructure financing legislation to create this new enhanced infrastructure financing district legislation. And there were really positive changes that took
14:50 A pretty good tool and made it a really great tool and even gave it more potential for Mammoth Lakes. Just to kind of understand what those differences were, the IFD law, which had been on the books since 1990, but rarely used because of redevelopment and because you couldn't have an IFD or a redevelopment agency already had a boundary, was also a bit onerous in terms of its creation. And so the new EIFD law opened up more potential
15:21 And more potential to actually make a district happen. Previously, for example, it required two-thirds voter support to actually create and bond a district. Whereas under the new law, the taxing entities themselves that may participate in the EIFD could agree to create the district themselves and only required a vote if there was to be a bond against those funds.
15:46 Previously, districts were only allowed to be in place for 30 years. Now, districts can be in place for 45 years from the date of issuance of bonds, which gives us a lot more time and flexibility in terms of repayment, and therefore a lot of more opportunity to fund upfront projects and spread the cost over a longer period of time. And previously, the town council was the governing body, and now a separate authority becomes the governing body, and that separate authority is made up of representatives of the taxing bodies participating.
16:15 As well as members of the public. And so it's more accountable to the actual districts that are giving and resources. The EIFD and the stakeholders that have been participating in continuing this study as the most important first step for Mammoth Lakes to really make things happen here. As we were looking at how we overcome some of these funding hurdles, one of the things that's been very clear to us is that
16:48 There is no real capacity right now for us to assess or tax more through some sort of special district mechanism on the commercial and residential entities to be able to fund some of these big projects. They're pretty tapped in terms of special district assessments and things like that. There's only so far you can push with the cost of doing business here.
17:14 We needed to find some leverage bonding capacity to be able to expend dollars now that will stimulate investment to add more to the property tax base and the sales tax base, DOT base here over the long term. Collaboration and creativity are going to be important. And the EIFD's flexibility, which we'll get into in a little bit, really allows us to do that. It brings partners from the entire county together to help fund some improvements.
17:44 And we can be very creative in how we structure that participation and also how we structure bonding and things like that over the long term. And through EIFD, the potential for return is great for everybody in the county, for all the taxing districts, for everybody that's here, particularly if we have projects positioned to build relatively quickly, which we do. So just to give a little bit of background again, as Mickey said, the tool itself is still one that
18:16 People are wrapping their heads around. So just to bring some clarity to how the tool actually works. In simplest terms, EIFDs are TIF or Tax Increment Financing Districts. So TIFs are not an additional special assessment or an additional property tax on anybody. Rather, they redirect future incremental increases in property tax revenue to be reinvested in a place.
18:45 The partners in this, the primary partners in this are really the existing tax entities because in order to make an EIFD happen, they have to agree to look at some of their future potential tax revenues and take at least a portion of that to put in a pot of money that can be reinvested, collected together, and used to make some things happen here. So this only applies to property taxes, yep? So where does the money come from?
19:21 Well, as I said, the primary participants are the cities and towns, counties, and special districts that are already collecting that property tax revenue. What's important to note is that when you create an EIFD, those districts do not automatically collect all the incremental future property taxes. Every public agency or district must agree to come to the table to participate, and they can also negotiate the amount of tax or increment they will contribute.
19:51 And this is a really important note that it's not a given that 100% is going to come into the area. And so those discussions are critical, that they have to happen up to the creation of the district, and everybody has to make sure that, you know, the increment they're getting in, that they're going to see some return on that as a district. Also important to note is that the EIFDs cannot take revenue from any type of educational or school district.
20:27 First of all, important to note here that a finding of blight is not required. And previously in redevelopment agencies you had to go through a study to determine blight. Right now you can use the EIFD tool without having to do that step. So there's really three primary steps. There's a creation of an authority, the separate authority that I talked about. And kind of interestingly, the law requires that the authority be created as a first step.
20:56 Where the taxing bodies that are going to participate and those members of public agree to come together as an authority to oversee the district. The second step is an adoption of a resolution of intent to form the district. And this is really a high-level preliminary step where you identify the goals, the need, the boundaries for the district, and what the district would actually spend its monies on. And there's a public hearing process that happens before that resolution is adopted.
21:26 Once that happens, that's when you get into the details, this detailed infrastructure financing plan. And that would identify really some very specific details on each project, where it's located, what the financing structure is, what the bonding plan would be for that, and what each of the legislative bodies are going to actually put in, in terms of their participation of their increment. And I mentioned before that all of the taxing bodies can negotiate their participation.
21:58 You can be very creative in this structure. We've seen some other infrastructure financing districts in California that have done things, for example, where for a set period of time, maybe the first five to ten years, districts would put in, the taxing districts would put in 100% of their increment and then after a period of time drop it down to, you know, for example, 50% down to 25%. And so they slowly
22:26 Are able to recapture some of that increment into their general fund. And ideally, during this time, of course, the property values and therefore the property taxes are rising as well. So the infrastructure financing plan becomes a complex plan to put together because you're figuring out all those details. How much increment is going to go in from each district to start? Will that change? What are the triggers for the change? How can you bond against that? All of that will have to be figured out in the up front. All the legislative bodies of the
22:56 Taxing bodies participating must actually pass a resolution of support before there's a public hearing and the district is actually legally created. At that point, the district can start collecting increment into a fund. If you want to bond against those funds, you have to go to a vote. And the voters who would be able to vote in this, the state legislation kind of has an interesting way to qualify those electors.
23:30 So depending on where your boundary lines are drawn, if there are at least 12 people registered to vote within the territory of the district, they're the qualified electors. Otherwise, the landowners of the district are the electors with each having one vote for each acre or portion of acre they have. So this is an important point to think about because it kind of changes your whole strategy in terms of the election. And you obviously want to be able, if you're creating a district, you want to make sure on the upfront that you're
24:02 Being considerate to the fact that at some point you're probably going to want to bond against those funds. So making sure your voter base understands it and you've taken in consideration who they are is going to be important. You have to get 55% of the qualified electors voting on that bond vote to vote in favor of issuing the bonds before you can move forward. If the bond fails, the good thing is you can go to the voters again a year later. And during that year you can still keep collecting increment.
24:34 And so that's why you're going to have to have good bond counsel, somebody who can
25:04 Figure this out up front. The good thing is that your district's allowed to be in place for 45 years. It's highly unlikely anybody's going to sell you 45-year bonds. So if you get into a position where, as we've heard questions this week, you have a year where property values go down, that will be a case in which you'll have to go back to your, you know, and renegotiate those bonds in some capacity. But they don't become an obligation of anybody else but the district. So with the EIFD discussions,
25:40 That discussion really kind of has to begin with a boundary and understanding, you know, how you draw those boundary lines. In an EIFD, the areas don't have to be contiguous. So you don't have to have one big district with a line drawn around it. You can have several little bubbles that can all be one district, all collecting money to go into one pot.
26:07 Also important to note is that you don't have to spend the money that you collect from the EIFD district within those actual boundary lines so long as there's a tangible connection between the project and the place where the increment's being drawn from. And that tangible connection is really up to us as we create the plan to define. But there are boundary considerations that you want to think about. We already talked about the receptivity of stakeholders because you're going to want that voter support when you want to go bond.
26:37 The receptivity of the taxing bodies to different approaches. So the taxing districts may feel very differently about one big district versus just focusing on some core specific areas. We need to take a high level look at the revenue generation potential from the areas and also the timing of new development coming out of the ground because really the way we're going to get the biggest
27:06 The contribution to the EIFD is from a new development project. That's where you're going to get most of that new increment, from a project that is coming out of the ground and putting a whole new tax base into the area. And that's where we're going to give you that ability to bond and leverage bonding capacity to build some of these projects. So I know this map is hard to see. You have to look very closely, actually. But don't worry too much at this point about the specific lines.
27:38 As we were looking at the boundary and having conversations, when we did the last study, the feasibility study, looking at the IFD, we looked at three different boundary options. Some very large boundary options that took in pretty much all the commercial areas downtown. A smaller, more focused option that really looked at Main Street and Old Mammoth Road. And then option three was really identifying and drawing circles around select project sites.
28:07 Including areas on the mountain. And these select project sites at that time were identified as areas that were ripe for redevelopment or potentially have been identified as new development projects to be coming out of the ground relatively quickly. Now we are updating this map and this list right now because this at this point is a bit old, about a year old. And so that's kind of what we're working on looking at and digging into and I'll talk a little bit more about that in a minute.
28:40 You also have to be looking at what an EIFD would fund here. What are the projects that we're actually talking about building and what project comes first? So by the statute, an EIFD can fund any type of public facility or other project that has community-wide significance. And really important to note, the district can fund the planning and design work as well as the construction of that project.
29:10 However, it cannot fund any routine maintenance, repair, or ongoing operations or administrative costs. And this is a really important note here because there were a lot of concerns previously in the redevelopment era that a lot of money was being spent on administration and overhead and operations. And the EIFD tool really is a very specifically focused tool to build infrastructure, not to maintain it, not to operate it.
29:38 But that also means that anything we're building with EIFD, we have to keep in mind that there has to be some way to take care of it once it's built. As I said before, the facilities don't need to be physically located in the boundaries of the district, but we also always have to keep in mind that there has to be some connection between where the money's being collected and where the money's being spent. So what would an EIFD fund here? Well, we've already identified through all of our engagement and work through the previous planning efforts that have been done that
30:10 There are some very clear projects and needs that have been identified. And we've been talking about these all week, too, within our stakeholder meetings and testing body meetings. And really, the projects kind of fall into two separate categories. The first one I call the prime the pump projects. I'm not sure that that's the right term necessarily. But these are really the projects that are kind of the fill the gap projects for development. So...
30:39 We've got some development opportunities that are emerging that are in the planning processes here. A lot of those, most of those have some gap they can't close to make the project actually pencil from a development perspective. Again, that's due to the cost of doing business here in Mammoth Lakes. Some of the things that can help fill the gap are looking at shared partnership opportunities in terms of building parking.
31:05 That could also have a public benefit as well as help make that parking project happen for private development. Things like digital 395 that help encourage different types of business here. Utility upgrades, et cetera. That help lower the actual cost to an individual developer to do their project. And then there are enhancement projects. And these are a lot of the things that have been identified in the Main Street plan. Things that actually improve the image and make it
31:35 Make this a place where people are encouraged that public investment is happening here and ideally help them make the decision to make their private investment here. So sidewalks and accessibility matters, parks and open space, wayfinding, gateways, lighting, street improvements and medians, roundabouts, all those other types of things that, as we said, were really laid out very clearly in the Main Street Plan in terms of the priority projects that are needed.
32:06 Ultimately, the EIFD can fund both of these types of projects and could eventually fund all of the projects on this list. But the big question really becomes what's the first project that it funds? And our considerations for that need to be very strategic because ultimately the first project that the EIFD funds should be something that really helps bring new property tax
32:34 Onto the tax rolls as quickly as possible. Because that creates a turn where we can capture that increment and continue to reinvest it in other projects. So identifying those first project or two is going to be really critical to the EIFD's success. So just a couple more slides. As we've been talking this week to the taxing districts, to property owners and developers, what we've heard, we've heard a couple key points really clearly.
33:07 Generally speaking, I want to say I think there's an openness to this tool. We haven't gotten any doors slammed in our face, or as I said, I haven't had any tomatoes thrown at me yet in terms of proposing the tool, and I think everybody sees the potential upside to it. But of course, there's a concern. The cost of doing business for all of you as taxing districts and so forth is tight, and so the idea of giving up future
33:36 You know, tax revenues is hard without a clear case. So some of the key points. First of all, very loud and clear I've heard most people out there are not interested in the kind of build it and they will come projects. In other words, the first project shouldn't be something like a huge investment in Main Street beautification that we hope at some point will bring a development here. The first project
34:05 Should be looking to find some sort of development out there that is already almost shovel ready that we can help fill the gap and make a yellow light become a green light in terms of coming out of the ground. And being able to tie the creation of the EIFD to a project like that would immediately show return into the EIFD coffers that we could then bond against to do some of those beautification or softer touch projects going forward. So there's not a disinterest in doing things like
34:35 The main street project improvements. It's just that people don't feel that should be the first, maybe the first investment without a clear return. Districts won't be interested in long term waits for returns. This really ties into the first one. The first projects must have a real tax impact. The cost benefit analysis is going to be critical to getting a green light from all the districts. So we'll talk about in a second our next steps. But we really are going to have to build a clear picture for everybody.
35:07 What happens if we don't do the district and we don't have money to fund some of these infrastructure projects or to help make some of these private investments happen? And what happens if we do? Can we create that clear picture? And we're starting to work on that right now in terms of what that looks like and how quick some of the taxing districts might see return. Really interesting point that I think has kind of bubbled up that I think we should hold on to really tight is
35:40 There seems to be out there a great interest in creating a compelling community case that the EIFD could be something different that Mammoth Lakes does. It could be a new approach. It could be a very collaborative approach that brings together tax amenities, the public and private sectors to actually work together and solve some challenges. And that by everybody pitching in a little bit into this district, you know, the more we can put in on the upfront,
36:10 The more we can reap the rewards on the back end. And we've heard nuance of that throughout all our conversations that we have to do something different and maybe this is the different. So what's next? What's next? Create that kind of picture. And so we need to do, we've done kind of a surface in our feasibility study. We did a high level look at revenue generation potential. We need to dig a bit deeper into that. So we're working on
36:46 Refining some potential boundary areas, actually looking at the tax base now, and identifying some of the potential projects that are out there, some of those potential shovel-ready projects, and what the gap is for those. And so we're going to try to begin to put the whole puzzle pieces together to identify what if we did this now? What's that cost to the district? How much would we need to bond?
37:17 How quickly could we get something out of the ground? How quickly does that come under the tax rolls and reap and return? And what does that look like in terms of a time frame and actual numbers? So that's kind of a big next step. Talking, you know, we spent this week talking to all the districts and primarily talking to staff and a few board members of those districts. Going forward, and we've kind of targeted April for this, we need to come back with those numbers, with that detail, with that picture we've created,
37:49 And actually make a formal presentation to the boards to say, you know, to make the case for the district and see if there is truly appetite to move forward. And beyond that, really, we need either a red light or a green light to move ahead with the creation of the district. And the creation of the district itself will require more financial resources to put into, when the legal counsel and bond counsel, for example, to help create that
38:22 Detailed Infrastructure Financing Plan really understand in depth our capabilities to do some of these projects. It's clear to us that some of that detail in terms of that infrastructure financing plan, while the legislation puts that detailed plan at step three, probably here, in order to get the authority formed, we're going to have to put resources into creating that plan and that very definite picture before
38:50 We get the authority formed and all the taxing bodies to 100% agree. In all, in terms of a timeline, if we continue to sort of move ahead at a steady clip, you're still looking at at least a year to get it all done. It's feasible that by this time next year you could have a district in place if things keep moving forward as they have. And what I would say to that is you're moving into a place where, I mean, slowly you're seeing the economy move into an uptick.
39:22 And eventually some sort of development is going to occur. Some changes are going to occur. And the big thing about this district is you're going to get the most benefit out of it if you get it in place before some of those values start to go up or any new development occurs because that's where you see the biggest opportunity to use that is by capturing the increment of that new development. So with that, I will stop talking at you and let you guys ask questions.
39:57 Jamie, I'm not clear considering consistency or stability versus flexibility. If the plan comes forward and then you get the authority and the authority is a representative of each taxing body, many of those representatives will be elected people and with every election, you know, the composition of the authority will change. So can the plan change with the composition of the authority? Where's the consistency?
40:26 And yet, where's the flexibility as conditions change that you don't have to be locked into something that's no longer working? That's a really good question. So I'll say that the legislation itself allows you to be as flexible or as specific as you want in creating the plan. And we've seen looking at other infrastructure financing districts in the state of California, some that have gone the route of putting everything they can.
40:54 into the plan to say we want to be able to fund all these different things as the time is right. To some who have been very specific in saying, you know, we're funding sidewalks, parks, and streets, period, that's it. My gut feeling here is that you're going to have a mix of that and that maybe the approach here is more about those first handful of projects are very, very specifically identified in terms of one, two, three, and the details of that are there.
41:25 And then you have another section of the plan that says once those are funded and in place, additional increment can be used for ABCD as prioritized by the authority. So that gives you the balance that the things that are most critical, most important going in will definitely be the first ones funded in the priority projects. But that as time goes on, because of course you've got 45 years and who knows what could happen,
41:54 That you have the ability with that additional increment that might come to respond to other opportunities that may emerge in that time. I do have one. So when the authority is formed and there's like one member from each acting body, does that have to be like an elected official? Is that like a council person or is it a representative of that? I believe it's an elected official. I believe it says a member of the legislative body.
42:30 Body of that taxing entity. Well, and I'll follow up on that. So then within, I understand that if the funds cannot be used for administration, does that mean they cannot have staff that keeps this consistency going? Or the staff cannot be paid from the EIFD funds? So this is one of those questions, and we've been talking to legal counsel about it as well. It's one of these nuances that falls in the
43:01 You know, the gray area of the legislation. Because the big thing they wanted to protect against is turning these into redevelopment authorities again. So there is money that can be used on staff to the extent that that staff is working on the management of a project, the development of an actual project. It doesn't appear that there's resources there to actually create a whole new staff that just staffs.
43:32 The EIFD and keeps it moving forward. And however that management of those projects goes, whether that's a consultant you hire or a staff person you hire for a period of time or you contract with one of the government bodies, that can be done. But it's one of those nuances we have to work through. Nobody has a clear answer on it just yet because nobody's gotten to that point with the EIFD. But I think there's good points. One of my meetings, somebody said, you know, who takes care of things like
44:01 Minutes and posting agendas and all of that stuff. I mean, does that then become a volunteer responsibility of the board? Those are all good questions. I'm sure that there's some way you could have money to pay for that out of the EIFD, but I think it'll just be a delicate balance of making sure this doesn't become its own kind of behemoth organization that's putting a lot of money into full-time staff year-round. Okay, and then the EIFD finds the money and builds whatever this is that we've just built.
44:30 How do you then, where do you find the funds for that maintenance and all of that? I'm thinking if it's a parking structure, is it okay if someone else manages it and they charge a parking fee and those kinds of things? So this is like a build it and somebody else will manage it approach? Again, there's a lot of nuance in that, so it kind of all depends on a parking structure, for example.
44:56 The EIFD funds can be used to augment a private parking structure. So let's say there's a private developer who has to build parking and the EIFD fund, EIFD comes in as a partner, helps to pay for some of that and there's a public parking component to it. That would all have to be negotiated. So does the EIFD retain ownership for some of its portion and charge parking and use that parking as an ongoing administrative expense? Does it give that
45:26 Does it say we'll pay for the infrastructure but the private owner has to pay for the ongoing maintenance? That would all be kind of figured out. Similarly, if we're putting in Main Street improvements and there's now medians that have plantings in them and things like that, when we did the feasibility study and the Main Street plan, we said there would have to be consideration for probably some sort of ongoing special assessment district like Old Mammoth Road has now to do snow removal and year-round maintenance.
45:54 To get that paid for. So, you know, as each project goes forward, you'd have to make sure, in some districts we've seen, you know, have a policy that before they put infrastructure, pay for infrastructure anywhere, there has to be an agreement that a special district will be created to maintain it. And that may just be a policy decision that the EIFD puts forward to determine where it spends its money in terms of those types of public enhancements. Audience, any comments?
46:36 There's a lot of people getting tired right now. There's a lot of properties that are in escrow that fit on the properties. And the opportunity to put this in place is critical to get it in place before the improvements are completed. Then you lose the increment, right? And you allude to that. So, you know, any of the developments in Sierra Star, in the village, for example, you know, I don't think anything's going to come out of the ground this summer. There might be some small stuff. But, you know,
47:07 There's definitely potential that some big stuff will hit the ground next spring, summer, coming out of the ground, and having the district in place is going to be critical, because if it gets in place after the stuff's built, the increment is lost, right? The stuff's already there. So that's going to be key with some of these bigger developments. So I'm going to take an example of, say, East Village.
47:34 You know, could potentially be a couple hundred million dollars in even on property tax, or tax base, that's, that's, that's not, that's, so, but, uh, well, property tax is about two hundred million dollars to invest in capital. So, um, so that's, that's, that's the thing, so, you know, people who are here, probably guys that are on these positions that we need to keep pushing forward here.
48:01 We need to make sure we're making progress every day on this. So that, like we said, if the year now is in place, I think we'll be in good shape. If it drags out for two years, we may miss the bonus and get incremental. I think until you actually look at what the incremental increase in income would be available, you know, the gorilla in the taxing agencies account, you know, you guys get 5 or 6 percent.
48:34 The fire district gets three. You're taking 16% out because the school districts can't participate. And so you need to actually understand how much income you might generate. And then if you want to go back 10 years, look at the history of our income from property tax and try and guess how you're going to do it in the future. You know, if we hit another recession 10 years from now, you've already
49:03 I think as a taxing agency, the town, if you set priorities, and this is a priority, you can fund whatever you can fund part of it.
49:33 The real is, the county, if they don't participate, you're not going to have very much money. And so we met with the county staff this week and had some initial conversations. And you're absolutely right. We need to run the numbers. And that's exactly what we're working on. We've started pulling all sorts of information. We've met with Barry Boyd, right? Sorry, Barry Beck, the assessor. And he's pulling a bunch of information, including historical.
50:02 And we're also looking at some of those projects that Tom mentioned that people are kind of kicking the tires to talk to those folks and see how real, how soon, because clearly we know the ebb and flow of existing property is going to be hard to bond against. It's really that new development. Even one new development coming out of the ground gives us opportunity.
50:30 If we're all working together and if we can get all the taxing districts to participate, gives us opportunity to make some investments now that are hard to fund on a piecemeal basis and really make some big investments now that ideally will continue to bring more tax revenue to the town. So we have to do our due diligence. We've done our high-level estimates. It's time to dig into the details. And over the next two months before the April meetings,
50:58 That's exactly what we're going to do and try to come back with in a much more clear picture. But just so you know, that was one of my questions very early on. I mean, where we are in the economic cycle, you would assume now we're having some either flat or appreciation of value of property taxes. But what happens if you have another 2008 where property taxes take a dip? And in those areas, and Jamie can expound on this, where it happened in 2008,
51:26 Remember, it's a debt of the authority, so then the authority has to go back and renegotiate the bonds. Exactly. And so, you know, you have this 45-year life, but in reality, nobody who buys municipal bonds is likely to buy a 45-year bond. You're more likely to do a 25 or 30-year bond. And so that then gives you the capacity that if you hit one of those tough cycles, you have to go back and renegotiate those payments and see how you figure it out. But it gives you that.
51:56 That's why I say, you know, if this is going to move forward, we need to bring bond council on, because they're the ones, ultimately,
52:32 You know, those are the people that are going to tell you we're at the mercy of who's going to buy the bonds and what they're going to see in our numbers. So we'll have to make some as real projections as we can and then see, you know, what the bond. Will the bond rating be tied to the towns or how? Nope. In other words, how many ratings are working their way up to it. But any clue on that as far as what interest rate we might be assessing?
53:09 It's not tied to the town, and I'm not sure what the interest rate assessed would be, but, you know, I'll try and come back to you with that, looking at some of what the other IFDs have been able to get in their bonds. But, you know, it's all going to be based upon the security of the ability to repay.
53:47 So two more quick questions. I would assume you've spoken with Tom slash other
54:16 People that may or may not be interested in development around the resort corridor that would kickstart this pretty well to find out what would incentivize them. And then full circle to the town to what part will the town play in incentivizing that kickstart. The first guy in gets a bonus, right?
54:42 The town and the infrastructure that the cost is going to be TOT rebates. There are all sorts of different things. And then if it's a parking structure that we charge for, where does that money go as we collect funds or do we create a parking district?
55:11 And think about the first parking structure being the village, and the second one being on Mammoth Road, where we have a parking area, but we build it three stories up. I think we're getting, you know, in the specifics right now that we really don't know any answers. But when she comes back to us. Oh, yeah, exactly. This was discussed six months ago, and I'm glad everybody's here, but basically this was already hashed out six months ago. You know, I'm all for...
55:38 You know, continuing this conversation. But I think we have to get into due diligence and metrics now and say, okay, what are we talking about? You know, I mean, how much can we raise? How much can we bond? I think these are all questions that we have to get answered. But I think, well, at least I would vote for, you know, continuing the process. And Tom, to specifically answer your question, yes, we have been working with the town, spoke to Tom this morning and talking with Dan, looking at those
56:07 Projects that are in planning phase right now. And identifying that gap, as you say, what's the need? And you're right, there's some that the town, some need that the town is working to fill and all of that. So it's really about, okay, we're starting to put some real numbers to that. And we'll be having further discussions with those folks going forward on how real it is. Timing, we need to understand timing. Like, are they six months out, one year out, three years out?
56:37 So where does that put them in the rank? And then we'll build that all into kind of our model that we come back with. So we're getting, I know that some of this stuff you've seen before, and part of this is just, there's still misinformation out. No matter how many times I've talked about this, we just want to keep pushing the message about what this is, what it does. We've gotten a lot deeper into the weeds this time than we have before, because we've actually sat down with all the taxing bodies and talked real, you know, talked,
57:06 Real detail about it. And now we're going to come back with real impact, I think, or the real impact assessment. And that's kind of the numbers piece that, you know, this is very much more art than science. This isn't as specific as creating assessment district, because in an assessment district, we pretty much can say, oh, that's going to generate, you know, $300,000 a year or whatever, pretty clearly. In this, we're kind of, we're
57:32 Betting on some things that we're not sure of in terms of timing, so it's a little bit more of a nuanced process, but I think by next time, we should have a much clearer picture. I just do want to go back, because you talked about this before, that EID is a tool, to use the word, in the toolbox, and so this is where the really creative process comes in, okay?
57:57 We build this parking structure. Is it a paid parking structure? Are we going to fund it in a parking district? Or how do we offset the TOT? So we can't just look at this tool for what we're going to accomplish. We have to say, OK, this is just a piece of it, and how are we going to work everything else together? And that kind of answers.
58:17 But we acknowledge that. We know that. On the next go-round, we have that full circle. The town's got a level of participation. The other taxing agencies have a level. I'm assuming the first name's department structure. Then that adds another question. And really, the whole thing centers around pitching the county to get the county to become a player.
58:45 To convince them that this doesn't happen without this kind of a structure in place. Not structure of parking, but structure of funding and bonding. And if we can convince the county and show them the numbers that says, if we play, everybody wins.
59:03 Because they're the biggest yes or no. And I'm not saying we ask them for 100% of the increment. I don't know what that number is. But that's your obligation. That's the first guy you've got to convince. Right. And we will say publicly, the meetings this week with the county were very productive. They were very open to it. The county's very realistic. They realize that their current tax roll is flat.
59:31 It's just as important for them to increase their taxable basis as it is for the town of Mammoth Lakes to increase their TOT basis. So Jamie can comment on it, but I think that all the conversations we had this week were very productive. Well, but what I'm hearing from Rich and from Tom is a little bit different. It's not staff. It's the political will of the supervisors. It doesn't matter how well the conversations with staff are going. So who and how are we approaching?
59:58 Talking to the five political bodies that will make this decision. And that, at least that's how he's interpreting your comments and Rich's comments. That goes, that goes. Because how many other things does everybody thought's great, staff takes them forward and they just go, nope. Well, I mean, look, I mean, I will be, because you know I'm very upfront blunt. We were asked by the staff to do a presentation to them first. Okay, without.
1:00:24 Doing a formal presentation to the supervisors, although we have certainly talked to supervisors. And so then the staff, after now that they fully understand it, has said, well, we really would like you to come back and present formally to the supervisors. So we felt that it was only appropriate to follow their staff's wishes about how they went through.
1:00:44 Okay, so is that set? Is that something that happens before April? Not until April? The plan is that Jamie would come back in April and make presentations to those boards where we could get kind of the buy-in that they want to move forward with this process.
1:00:59 Do we have the funding set aside to do this work between now and April, which I know is only a few weeks away? Jamie's going to include it in her current contract. Okay. So, yes. All right. Do you have a small cost just to get a common claim? Right. Jamie, how much does this make some really good points about potential sources of revenue that could be coming online? Do you think you're going to be able to, with the numbers, come up with...
1:01:26 Accurate numbers that show that even though this may look like a negative to the county in the short term, in the long term, it's very much a positive. You see the numbers going that way. Yes. Because that's what we have to have to make the pitch. Yes, I absolutely do. And so the question then becomes, that's where we have, I mean, the great thing about the tool is that we do have flexibility to say, you know, as Tom Page said, it may not be that we go in
1:01:52 Guns ablaze and ask them for 100% from the county knowing where they're at or 100% from any of the districts for that matter. But we say as increment comes up, you know, as the property values come up, you need to, you know, give us more, your increment goes down, but it's still going up. So we have to find that intersection of where a little bit now gets fed back relatively quickly. And that's the big case that we have to make in drawing that picture of where is that intersection, is it?
1:02:23 Is it a three-year wait? Is it a five-year wait? Is it a ten-year wait? And how can we accelerate that to make it as not painful as possible for all of those taxing districts? Yes.
1:02:50 They fund their parking district operations through the ongoing revenues they generate from the daily parking lot on the parking lot. So if the EID builds it, likely based on other three-four examples we know of, the funds, the revenues generated by that parking lot support ongoing operations for those types of projects, which from a developing community standpoint,
1:03:15 That if you can provide, if through the IFD we can provide, as a community, we can provide for the commercial parking, for example, that's going to be required for the downtown plan that we contemplate as that gets built out. And for the village in particular, which is real right now, we know that there's demand for parking and that that's critical to the continued commerce of the village. And if that's not a burden on...
1:03:44 Those developers, that's going to incentivize that private site development, which is where the property tax income is going to come through. So the whole idea of this thing is that this is funding these infrastructure elements that aren't going to become a burden on developer impact fees that are then just going to be another roadblock to this stuff to knock the ground. Because when I made my presentation to both you bodies at the economic discussion we had back in, I'm not going to remember that, you know,
1:04:13 To build the stuff like the Weston Project, you know, that's over $800 a square foot to build it. And you can't even sell property to that price, you know, high comps in the village are in the 500s. So we have to make a political commitment to get this stuff done and make these projects work. You know, we need to be a partner in it and we can kind of make this stuff happen and these things start to come online and, yeah, I mean, that's going to start reasonable for everybody.
1:04:43 And Jamie, just to clarify, in terms of the creation of the EIFD, that would have to be in place prior to completion of a project in order to glean the benefit from that project? That's right, before it came on the tax rolls. Okay. Yep. So what are we looking to do today? That was just going to be my look to. Well, I mean, I think this is really important. We need counsel.
1:05:11 You know, you don't necessarily have to do it today. But at some point, Council has to make a very definitive statement that this is a tool that you want to continue working towards. And does that happen before Jamie is back in April? Or is it...
1:05:29 Well, statement at that time. Okay, well, because we're playing a little bit of a chicken and an egg game, all right? So we've certainly now, I think, accomplished our goal of educating everybody about what the tool can do. So council, one of the things that's going to be really important to the supervisors is to know how strongly council then feels that this is on their priority list. And so there's going to have to be some sort of commitment, both.
1:05:58 From a supportive standpoint of view that this is important and then, you know, the big issue is going to be going forward someday, then is the town going to be able to make a financial commitment. Because after April, if we're going to move forward, there will have to be some sort of financial commitment to do that. Okay, now that's a little different than I read the first steps on Jamie's slide. It was essentially that, well, first of all,
1:06:30 You know, once we know the revenue generator, but you said a lot of that was negotiations, so we can't necessarily commit, we can commit to start negotiations. Right. But I think that there are several things that are on our 18-month priority list, Dan, that would fall into things that it could help to fund. So I don't know if you're, you know, maybe...
1:06:52 Commission needs to work with Sandra to work with Dan to bring something forward that's just a general statement because obviously we can't do anything today. There's nothing standardized. Right. No, I know. As to how it might assist in meeting some of those priorities possibly and bring it forward that way as a start. But until you've got your parties agreeing to sit down, then you really start the negotiations. So I'm not saying, yeah.
1:07:16 We would commit, but we're not going to say what we would commit. And can I just, sorry, I'll just add on top of that that we're going to do as close to kind of numbers crunching as we can with information we have right now between now and April and come back and present to the boards in April. And ultimately at the end of that trip, when I'm back in April, come back to you guys and say,
1:07:46 Here's the numbers. Here's what the boards, how the boards have responded. Likely you're not going to have at the end of that trip, you're still not going to have a we're in, a definitive we're in, but you're probably going to have a pretty good sense of we're close or you're totally far off. And I think the big thing is if you're close and there's a general consensus that there's something there that can be figured out, you need the resources to move forward. And my contract will end at that point.
1:08:14 And in order to continue, there'll be more resources needed for my support, but as well as, you know, we'll need legal and found counsel to come and help us get to that nitty-gritty detail, which is actually probably going to be needed to get a definitive handshake agreement to move this forward. I think the big thing is if you don't have the resources sort of thinking about that by April, that to spend time kind of working to find that money,
1:08:40 Sets you back. And you're going to need probably at least a good solid six to eight months to get all of this done and moved through. So I told Sandra and Dan that within the next few weeks, we'll probably get a definitive estimate. I need to speak to legal counsel based upon where we're at now and see what their thoughts are in terms of the cost. So I will be providing that to you within the next few weeks.
1:09:10 Well, then it sounds like that, you know, at some point staff will bring it forward as a package. Right. But, you know, keep in mind, it's... I'm counting that April is only five weeks away. Yeah, yeah. But I'm just saying that the future commitment of some support is the private sector put in... But still, we need one right now. Yeah. But nobody's going to commit without knowing how big the bread basket is. Understandable. Understandable. Yeah, yeah. But that just might want to be...
1:09:47 Don't get short-sighted and say, oh my God, we can't come up with a hundred grand to point us down to get it done. We're not there yet. Yeah, we're not there yet, but one of the potential is, like, it's really the best one. I can't remember the name of the spot in the Pacific where there's absolutely no wind. You know, you're just completely becalmed, and I feel like Mammoth is, the last few years, and for a lot of different reasons, many of them beyond our control, that Mammoth is on a raft in that spot.
1:10:16 Watching all the freighters go by. And when I think in my 14 years of doing this, the talent of the
1:10:40 And the commitment of elected officials, appointed people, consultants, experts, locals, the public. I mean, this is such a unique community because there's just such a concentration of smarts here. And we have such good planning efforts and so many good things to do. And we've got to get off the dime.
1:11:00 And I always go back to my father's economic philosophy, which is if you want to have money, you have to save money. If you want to make money, you've got to spend money. And Tom makes a very good point. Let's not get bogged down in the, you know, the cost of trying to get this off the ground when you think of the long term. I think everybody wants to.
1:11:18 Continue to move forward. Oh, of course. And I wasn't criticizing anybody. I'm just saying I have a sort of malaise. Sharing my malaise. It's all the cold medicine. I know. I've been sick for three weeks. That's what it is. That's cold medicine. It's cold medicine. But I would ask council that when you do put this on your agenda, that perhaps part of that agenda is that you can give some sort of back direction to commission of what
1:11:48 For the work you'd like us to do on this, because I think pretty well when it gets to April, we see our current role has been completed. Well, and if the EIFD is starting to form, then yeah, your role would be finished because the EIFD is going to take that over. Okay. Any last questions, comments from anybody?
1:12:12 Okay, then we will adjourn this special meeting. Remind everybody, the next regular meeting is March 4th. Thank you. Thank you, Jill. Thank you very much. Thank you. Very good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. We have a lot of meetings. I can't. Oh, and I've got a lot of classes, so I can take a lot of classes, so I can't.