Town Council
· recording 2 hr 51 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
368 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 ... ... ...
0:02 Thank you.
0:31 Thank you.
1:00 Thank you. Thank you.
1:30 Thank you.
1:59 Okay.
2:27 Thank you.
2:54 Thank you. I was going to say, uh, I don't know.
3:17 Thank you.
3:47 Thank you.
4:08 Okay, is it cold? It is a little cold. I was going to go put my jacket over there and claw it twice. All right, are we all ready? Yep. We're ready. And Jamie, you're ready? Okay. I will now call to order the regular meeting of Town Council for Wednesday, March 4th.
4:37 I will first note that there was no reportable action taken in a closed session, and we will be continuing that discussion at the next meeting. Then I will move on to roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. And Sandra is going to lead us in the pledge. To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.
5:10 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Sandra. That moves us to public comments for items that are not on tonight's agenda. If you have a comment to make, please come up to the podium. Good evening, Maya Bacon and Councilmembers. I'm John Morris. Before you tonight is Chairman of the Lodging Association. Forgive the casual attire I've got.
5:45 The reason I'm here tonight is that it's come to the attention of the Lodging Association that the TOT enforcement position with the town that is currently vacant may not be filled in the near future, partially, I guess, due to a concern over a potential budget shortfall for revenue. I want to speak to two things briefly. One, regarding the revenue shortfall, we, the Lodging Association, do not believe that TOT
6:15 Which of course makes up 65% of the town's operating revenue will fall well short of budget for this year. Fiscal year to date as of January 31st, TOT revenues were up $375,000 versus budget, which is good. In comparing the town's budgeted revenues for February, March, and April against the occupancy forecasts from members of the Lodging Association and also the forecast seen and looked at by Mammoth Lakes Tourism,
6:44 It certainly looks to us as though TOT will be very close to budget, if not even maybe ahead of budget for this year. One thing to have to understand is that the early December snowfall that we had really generated a lot of momentum and a lot of early reservations, and the recent snowfalls that we've had have restarted that booking engine and really have prevented cancellations. So while we are by no means having a good year, the sky is not falling.
7:13 And, you know, this information comes to you from all of us in the lodging associations who literally have hundreds of combined years of experience lodging in Mammoth. Going back to the larger concern about the vacant T.O.T. enforcement position, regardless of the budget deficit or surplus, this position has proven to be a revenue generator and not a financial drain on the town. Members of the lodging association's T.O.T. committee
7:42 A couple of whom will probably speak after me, which banded together to assist the town with TOT enforcement, have spent countless hours proving the need for and the value of TOT, a value of TNT enforcement staff. In fiscal year 2012-13, the enforcement effort brought in over $725,000 of new incremental revenue to the town.
8:07 And approximately $600,000 in fiscal year 2013-14. So that is not a small change. And unfortunately, there are still countless numbers of homeowners who are either renting their properties illegally and or who are not properly remitting their TOT. Now many of these homeowners are in legally zoned areas. And many who were successfully stopped from performing this activity in the last couple of years have begun again.
8:36 Because the enforcement effort simply is not adequate. We're dealing with the age of VRBO, HomeAway, Airbnb, Craigslist, on and on. It is extremely easy for any homeowner to list their property for rent on any of these search engines or even develop their own website. It's very, very simple. So it takes a lot of diligence, vigilance to catch the cheaters. And to be blunt, the enforcement effort...
9:03 That we have is still really in its infancy. It's only been a couple of years and it's been kind of off and on as far as what the staffing level's been anyway. We have a very long way to go. So in closing, we ask that you please fill the vacant TOT enforcement position as soon as possible, keep the team at full staff, and further, please don't pull them away from their TOT efforts in order to help with other town tasks. We can't afford to keep leaving so much money on the table as we have been.
9:28 If any of you, anyone has any questions for myself or for any of the TOT members, excuse me, the TOT committee members, that's Cheryl Witherill, Terry Stalick, Tom Smith, please seek us out. Use our free resources that are available to you. Our only agenda is to keep the revenues that are due to the town in the town coffers. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, John. Dan, could you speak to the recruitment timeline?
9:55 Yes, we'll probably out, I'll say out probably two weeks to put the announcement out on the street. We'll look at a short recruitment process. Most of the folks that we have applying are generally from the area, so we'd be out, I know, 45, 60 days at the very latest, depending on who comes in and what their timeline is and what, you know, some folks have other jobs, they give a notice, etc. But we will be moving forward filling the position. So. Thank you. That is in the works.
10:33 My name is Ligosh. I'm here this evening to introduce you to my new guide dog puppy. Her name is Eliza. I got her on January 28th at eight weeks old. She's 12 weeks old now. I'm very excited. So I'll have her for the next 16 to 18 months. And I also have her. Gilbert did not make it. He was dog distracted and whined when dogs walk by him when they're walking down the street. And I feel very blessed and very honored I was able to adopt him.
11:01 And he doesn't know now that he has another job and it's to help me raise a life. So this is the last time you'll be seeing me hold her because she's getting rather heavy. She's 28 pounds. And I can't walk her together yet. And I wanted to give you some calls here. Amen. And anybody who would love to be a puppy raiser or a puppy starter, we have a puppy club in Bishop. It's called the Eastern Sierra Guide Puppies.
11:24 And if you're interested, you can call our puppy leader. Her number is 760-258-1189. And it is one of the most rewarding things you can ever do is to help somebody else out in their life. Thanks. Thank you. Thanks. Bye. There's treats in those bags. Yeah. Two of them. Yeah. Treats. Good evening, Council.
11:59 And staff. Terry Stelick, I am on the TOT Compliance Committee, and I'm sure that you all saw the postcard that went out to all the property owners within the town of Mammoth Lakes. And I did just get an updated number today as to how many new business licenses came in since February 13th. We have had 15 new licenses come in.
12:26 And so from something that can be as simple as reminding people as an education as to, you know, what TOT covers and how important it is for them to do this legally in renting their property, we've already had a nice addition to the TOT business licenses. That's an ongoing income that comes in. I would just like to reiterate.
12:53 That this is something that was paid for by Manflakes Tourism because the town's budget did not have the money in it. And so anyways, I think that it's something that probably needs to be addressed and possibly budgeted, that there's some type of a budget for education that goes out each year because this isn't something that should just be done once every eight years. It should be done more often.
13:17 And so that's my personal opinion. So anyways, I just want to say thank you and let you know. And then as a member of the TOT compliance group, I would like to say thank you to Cherie, who is taking on a new position within the town. And congratulations for that. But I'd like to say thank you. She's been great to work with all this time. Terry, just real quick, do you have an estimated cost for that? I believe it ran about $4,000. Okay, thanks. Bye.
13:47 If I may on that. It's just under $4,000. We actually just received the bill from MLT that we'll actually be paying. Yep. So it'll process through there, so. Can I just add a point? Everybody's talking about the budget, and I want to make something very clear. When we were talking budget at the TOT meeting, it was at a time when we didn't have January numbers, and at the time, we were looking at a possible shortfall of quite a bit of money.
14:16 And so that's why things were put on hold until we could figure out, you know, we all had an idea that it was going to be a pretty good January and we're going to meet budget, but we didn't know. And in the last 45 days, a lot of different things have happened. And as an example, the mountain is back up to their full staffing levels. And so things have happened very quickly. So money-wise, we're able to...
14:45 To replace Shireen, I don't know if we can ever replace Shireen, but somebody will be taking her place, so we're pretty excited about that. Thank you. Thank you, and we do understand that. I guess lodging had a little bit of an insight as to where things were for January, and so, you know, maybe we have that benefit coming forward. But we just want to make sure that TOT compliance.
15:11 It's just, it is so important. It's money generating when we do little things like this. Good evening, Town Council. I'm Martin Kleinbart. I'm here tonight as a resident and also a contractor in the community. Recently, the last, I think it was probably two, three weeks, came to a surprise attention to me that no longer at the
15:46 Time being, the town would issue a building permit for an owner-builder of a condominium unit. And being in the industry for probably 30 years now, that's been quite a surprise to me because it's pretty uniform California law that sets the permit guidelines unless the town decides to have their own particular ordinance and restrict things or add things or things of that nature. So what I want to do is
16:16 They're currently working, staff is working on some sort of decision, but in the meantime, I want to, since it's going to be two weeks before the next town council meeting, I want to discuss some of the issues that maybe people don't realize. The immediate one for maybe a general contractor would be, oh my gosh, now we're going to have all this extra work because if the owner of a unit that's doing maybe a kitchen remodel or something like that can't get their own permit,
16:43 Therefore, oh, they'll hire me the general contractor. Well, the person that's going to do that anyway is probably not going to want the general contractor anyway and is probably going to want to do it under the table and not get a permit and then we'll have even less compliance as we have today that probably brought up this decision in the first place was to try to get some sort of
17:07 Better workmanship, some more inspection, and some compliance because single family dwelling or multifamily units such as a condo always can affect the person next door up or down. And, you know, there's certain things and merits for those kinds of reasons to implement some kind of restriction. I'm for possibly doing something. I think we have to have that discussion. You know, maybe there's a certain competency level.
17:37 That's another administrative issue, but to just have a blanket, no owner builders, that means that if somebody is doing a remodel that's involving some carpentry work and some drywall over a certain amount that needs a permit and some electrical and some plumbing, that would mean that they can't get their own permit and then decide who their subcontractors and do their own sweat equity on projects.
18:05 Talking to the real estate community, they're upset because they feel that that could devalue some of the older inventory that's not been rehabbed and is in dire need. If somebody picks it up cheap, they're going to put their own sweat equity into it, get a permit, be in compliance, try to do the right thing. They won't be able to do that. And, you know, we have to look at the larger picture and not just the absolute immediate.
18:31 Picture, because there's consequences from just a blanket decision like that. Anyone have any questions? Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. And go ahead. Good evening, Mayor Bacon and members of the council. My name is Stephen Osterman. I've been a Mammoth Lakes resident for 35 years. I'm retired from Verizon Communications in 2000, and today I operate a sole proprietor fly fishing guide service from my home. In 1998, my wife,
19:10 Roxanne and I purchased a mobile home and see our holiday mobile home park. I was planning my retirement at that time and one of our main concerns was our housing. At that particular time we were renting and we wanted to kind of get out of that rental trap so owning a home was a big step up for us. Since the time we purchased that home our rent's been increased nine times. Today our space rent in the park is $760 per month. When we purchased the home it was $450 a month.
19:40 Last spring, it was increased from $700 to $760, which is a 9% increase. I don't know a lot of people who've got a 9% a month increase in their salaries. According to figures that I obtained from the Golden State Manufactured Homeowners League, the average space rent in California in a mobile home park is between $375 and $575 a month. So it's $760, way above that high-end average.
20:09 We don't get anything in return for these rent increases. They simply raise the rent because they can't. And I was told by our on-site manager that that's why they do it. All they have to do is service a notice and say we're raising the rent. For example, the perimeter fence behind our home has been falling down for the last six years. It's still falling down, even though my rent's been increased three more times since that point. Something else to think about is that
20:38 That $70 increase that I was assessed last year, or $60 increase I was assessed, is strictly right out of my pocket. Being on a fixed income, I don't get a $60 a month increase to help cover my rent increases. That $60 is $60 I don't have to spend around town anymore. A couple days out, maybe having lunch with my wife or dinner or something like that. That $60 came right out of the local economy as well as my pocket.
21:06 There's 80 plus spaces in our park. Times 60, that's over $5,000 a month. Straight out of the local economy. The property owners live in Southern California. They don't spend their money here. They spend it in San Bernardino. $5,000 a month equates to $60,000 a year. That's straight out of the local economy. It goes right out of town. That could be two jobs, if you think about it.
21:34 And I don't know a lot of people that got a $60,000 a year increase in their salary. Our park's one of the few places in this community where the average person can still afford to own their own home. And home ownership brings a lot of pride. We were really happy when we were able to purchase our own place. And pride in your home equates to pride in your neighborhood. Pride in your neighborhood equates to pride in your community.
22:04 I've talked to a lot of people who every time the rent goes up in the park, there's a lot of for sale signs that go up at the same time. I've spoken with people who have looked at homes because there's been times where they've actually knocked on my door and asked me if I knew who owned the place across the street. When they find out the amount of space rent, they're discouraged. So by discouraging home ownership, in a way, we're discouraging pride in our community. Mobile home ownership's a bit unique.
22:35 We pay our own maintenance. We pay our own utilities. We pay property taxes on that unit. The only thing we don't own is the dirt that it sits on. My neighbors are regular Joe bag of donuts. Plumbers, roofers, electricians, Vons employees, just regular old people. We're the grease to keep the wheels of this community turning. We help to provide the services that attract the tourism.
23:07 That we all live on, that we all need for our lifeblood. But we're being beaten down by greed, and it's simply greed. Because there is no control over these people, they can do this as much as they want. All they have to do is send us a 30-day notice by mail, and they can increase our rent at will. There's a lot of communities throughout the state of California that have addressed this issue. I brought along a copy of the statute that was
23:40 Adopted by Riverside, California in the early 90s. It's very simple, straightforward. It bases any rent increase on the CPI, which is a lot more fair than just an arbitrary figure, which is the way things go today. So the CPI being a standard throughout business. It also requires the property owner to petition the town manager or whoever, in this case the town manager, to prove that
24:12 Those increases in rent are necessary. So I would hope that the council would take some of this under consideration because we have nowhere to turn but to you. So we're being priced out of our homes today and it's not good. Stephen, if you want to provide the town clerk with that ordinance that you have, I'm sure staff can take a look at it and see whether...
24:44 They might recommend anything to us. Thank you very much. Thank you. Hello, Council. My name is Kathy Cage. I'm just here, first of all, to thank Andy Morris. He worked really well with us. As you obviously know, a number of local citizens and I put together an initiative.
25:15 Submitted to the town during February and worked a couple of rounds on it with Andy who helped us clarify some language and he did a fine job of putting a very nice neutral summary of that together. So we wanted to compliment you for that and that was great and it was a pleasure to work with Andy on this so that was a really good thing. And the notice, the official notice to make it official that it's out there and we can start gathering signatures will show up in the papers this week.
25:39 And I wanted to let the general public know that we will be starting to gather signatures and we've got some volunteers that are going to show up at Vaughn's on Saturday.
25:48 Because we're legal to start gathering signatures at that point. So for those people who would like to support this and if you're not familiar with it, this initiative basically is one that if passed will restrict the ability of any alteration of the zoning requirements in residential neighborhoods from allowing nightly rentals in residential neighborhoods.
26:14 Passes, then the only way changes could be made to that would be if it came back to a vote of the people with certain provisions in it. And it was funny because I was thinking, sir, you kind of queued up one of our main drivers here locally had to do with rents. And so just to the general public, if you're a person who rents in Mammoth, now I will tell you sadly it probably won't affect your space rents. I was trying to think back there how this might affect that. I don't think it will. But for everyone else,
26:42 If you rent and you should support this initiative because with the basic laws of supply and demand, which is basically what you've got, you have a fixed supply and, you know, you've got a market where it's going up.
26:56 You know, people can charge whatever they want. Our sense is if properties that are currently being rented on a monthly basis now are allowed to go into nightly basis, if you're a property owner, it a lot of times makes a lot more sense to rent only on weekends. You can make as much renting your property on weekends as you do renting on a monthly basis and you have way less wear and tear on your property. Our strong sense is if this is allowed to happen in Mammoth that the supply of rental
27:24 Properties available to people to rent on a monthly basis, locals, will dry up very quickly, and we all know how those rules of supply and demand go. Rents will go up way up, just like you found in your space rents. So if you are a renter, please support our measure. We don't have a measure yet, but we're going to start gathering signatures for our initiative this week. Thank you very much. Thank you, Kathy.
27:52 I certainly understand that there's a lot of variety in rental properties in our town. There's short-term rentals, transient rentals, weekend rentals, things of that nature. But in the park, we're permanent, fixed homeowners. We're not weekenders. We don't come and go like that. We live here. We reside here. And that's the difference, I think, between what Kathy said and our position, our situation. Thank you. Thank you.
28:20 Are there any other public comments this evening? I've got it. Okay, then we will move on to councilmember reports. John, can we start with you? Yes, good evening. I don't have anything to report, but I would like to follow up. It sounds like Kathy is, the initiative is complete, and Andy, it's blessed and ready to go hit the street. And I'm wondering if this is something we might want to agendize. This is a,
28:51 An effort that people pull out time and effort and resources into, and I'd like to, if you want to bring it back to Council and start taking a look at this thing. Yes, as soon as possible. Okay. That's it for me, thanks. Colin. Sure. Thank you, Mayor Bacon. Just a couple things for me. Since the last meeting on Thursday, February 26th,
29:17 I met with the Raise the Roof Hockey Group. We've been trying to do that on a weekly basis. Basically, you know, a lot of the fundraising efforts are in place, and they're kind of just waiting to see how things go as far as negotiations with the school district. But, you know, a lot of the efforts to get the CrowdRise page set up and mailers and those type of things are ready to go. They're just kind of waiting to hear how those go.
29:47 I also met that day with Elizabeth Tenney from the Planning and Economic Development Commission and Craig from the Chamber to discuss the whole idea of the Mammoth Market. I'm not sure how aware people are, but that was kind of a change in the zoning code last year. You know, really this past summer was the first kind of
30:14 Test we've had with that, but the Chamber is now kind of aware of that and is going to be promoting the Mammoth Market concept, which is basically just an open sale where businesses, you know, we've got a couple of dates where businesses kind of have an open permit where they can liquidate product at the end of the winter, end of summer, and over July 4th. So we're really trying to promote
30:40 A festive atmosphere where people can come up here and have a lot of animation and kind of street sales. Later that day, I attended the joint meeting, which we were all, for the most part, in attendance on the EIFD. I think we've got more coming back to us on that. On Friday, February 20th, I attended the ESTA board meeting.
31:07 I was appointed Vice Chair of the ESSA Board, so I'll be doing that moving forward. Not a ton to report from that. We did approve as a Board of Directors a letter of support from the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority for the town's ALP, so that was something worth noting. And then this past Monday we had our monthly Mammoth Lakes Housing Board meeting.
31:35 I think something that I wanted to report to the council was we did discuss and are starting to form the middle income home buyer assistant program. That was some direction from council that I know I was really excited about looking through. So staff of MLH has already done some work on that and we've laid some groundwork down. So I'm looking forward to our joint meeting with them coming up here soon, but I think I wanted to let everybody know that that is starting to come to fruition.
32:04 That's it. Thank you. Mayor Bacon, I also attended the joint meeting with the planning group, and I was a public, part of the public, in the Mammoth Lakes housing meeting they had a couple nights ago. I was only able to spend about an hour there, but these guys are doing good things. Sure. I attended our monthly air group meeting. We just had a positive meeting with the FAA.
32:37 In San Francisco, one positive note is that as of tomorrow we'll have our night restriction lifted at the airport on one of our runways. So essentially it basically allows us to take off and land in the darkness using both runways. So if we have wind issues or so forth and so on, we have two runways to work with. So to help us with our scheduling, getting flights in, possibly bringing in flights later, leaving later, I think Grady's going to touch a little bit more.
33:04 In his comments about the meeting in San Francisco. I also attended our monthly MLT meeting. And as John Morris, who had left, had stated, July through January, I had a budget up to $375,000. So that's through January, has January held much stronger than projected. So that's really positive news. We're also up over $900,000 year over year to previous year through July through.
33:32 January, so that's really positive. February's looking strong as well. We haven't got those numbers in yet. March and April, we're anticipating to grow. Silver Wild Card at this point. We're optimistic with the recent snow and potentially some heavy snow coming our way. Also with early Easter, that should help out. Currently, we're down at the Fred Hall Fishing Show. Today through Sunday in Long Beach, it's a big show. Great event launching our fishing season opener on April 25th.
34:01 Also this weekend we are going to be down in San Diego at the San Diego Half Marathon and we're going to be promoting our Mammoth Half Marathon that's dated for June 21st. Lastly, just a reminder, the San Francisco, San Diego, Denver, Las Vegas flights will run through April 6th. That'll be the last day. After that we resumed our once a day flight out of Los Angeles for the spring and summer and we're already working on review and service options for next winter currently so we're well ahead of that so that's all I have.
34:31 Michael, you said June 21st? For the half marathon? Yeah. Okay. I believe I have that date correct. Didn't last year. That's all I have. I'm writing that down. Not that I'll be running in it. Okay. The only thing I have is just to clarify that any discussion of the transient rental initiative will be on a future agenda, so if someone was thinking that part of number nine this evening regarding the single-family rental work program,
35:06 Related to that, it does not. Just wanted to make sure everybody understood that. Then as far as announcement of items from last meeting's closed session, on the first one regarding the ice rank properties, staff was provided direction on options and to report back to us with recommendations in a future open session.
35:31 As far as the town manager evaluation, that was not conducted due to lateness of that evening, and as I mentioned earlier, it will continue to the next meeting as well, although we started this afternoon. And finally, on the, I'm trying to read sideways, the anticipated litigation, there was no reportable action. Next, we will take reports from commissions or departments. Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers.
36:19 Just a few things from the HR and risk side of the house. We did an employee opinion survey, and I think you guys recall a conversation about that over the summer. We did it finally, and there was 100% participation. We should have the results in the next couple of weeks. We had to do it all paper.
36:45 There's a new workers' comp program that we're going to be utilizing called Company Nurse, and that's in conjunction with the return to work program, and I'm hoping that these will save the town some money on workers' comp cases. We are working through various administrative policies, as you can see on the consent agenda. That's something that Dan and I are going to get through, and we are chugging away at that.
37:14 We did conclude the compensation classification survey where we were compared with 12 other cities. And so I'm sure you guys will be hearing more information on that. That has come to a conclusion. In the recruitment side, we are recruiting for a police officer and seasonal rec positions. And as soon as Dan gives me the thumbs up, we're going to go ahead and recruit for a revenue specialist. I'm ready to go on that. And on the risk side of the house, I'm working with the public works guys to
37:43 We do a closer review of our property schedule, and it was looking like that's going to result in some cost savings as well in our insurance rates. Great. That's it. Thank you, Sarah. Thank you. Just a couple things. First, I'm happy to report that our snow removal crews got to remove some snow over the last couple of weeks that haven't very much, but they were out there, woke me up at 4 o'clock in the morning. I was very glad to hear them going by.
38:11 The rest of it has to do with the airport. First of all, one thing that was kind of under the radar and appropriately so when the fires occurred in the weeks past was we actually had a fire at the airport. I don't know if everybody even heard about that, but I wanted to pass on with the fire crew at the airport, Vince, and everybody did a great job.
38:31 Preparation for that, not necessarily for fires, but we've been working mowing down the grass out there, knocking it down. So when a fire started right next to 395 and jumped the fence, it slowed down immensely. With 70 mile an hour crosswinds, it was very likely it would have gone right across the airport into the hangars. But because of the preparation that the crew out there did and the quick action in putting it out, it...
38:54 Didn't even show up in the news at all, which was, again, appropriate with the other things that were going on, but I wanted to give them credit for the good job that they did, so you guys could hear that as well. The other things at the airport, I attended an American Association of Airport Executives and Airport Council conference in Denver for three days, and while often those things aren't
39:17 Always as valuable as you'd like them to be. This one was actually very good. I was able to reconnect with some people I've worked with in the years past. I think when we get our RFPs out on the street, we're going to get some great interest from some nationwide firms. FAA was in attendance. TSA was in attendance. So we made some great contacts and learned a little bit as well. I didn't spend a lot of time with the exhibitors because we don't need blast fences or control towers.
39:40 It was a good conference. Lastly, the meeting we had with FAA in San Francisco was attended by Brian Picken, Jen Daugherty, and myself. We went there with an agenda to walk through our ACIP program in detail and talk about the environmental assessment and everything. I would have to say that the meeting changed in a very positive manner because it happened that Mark McLarty, who is the manager of the entire western division for FAA down in Los Angeles over Hawaii, Nevada,
40:09 All of California and the like happened to be in the office and sat in with us for the entire hour and a half or so of the meeting. It was very positive. He knew a lot about Mammoth. He was very supportive of what we're doing. He recognized that we need the terminal. We need the ramp space regardless of whatever else is happening in the region.
40:26 What he did ask us to do was to reach out to our neighbors, reach out to Mono County, reach out to Inyo County, and just have a discussion about the long-term impacts of the airport. He's very happy with where the airport is, believe me. He recognizes our immediate need and is very supportive of that. But he said, look, as long as you're doing this, you are the only airport, frankly, in the eastern Sierras in California.
40:50 You know, you have to go to Reno, which is in Nevada, and you go south, there's not another one in this entire congressional district, and he just encourages us to think regionally and talk to our neighbors. So again, it was a very positive meeting, and we look forward to talking to him again. Thank you. Any questions? I just, I've heard, I think we've all heard of the interest and the need for regional.
41:12 Approach this site. I just very much encourage you to do that. And if there's anything we can do to help, I know the ESCOG folks, other kind of meetings like this, if we can do anything to help facilitate that. A real quick question. How did the ARF or whatever the firefighting machine, did that help with the fire? Absolutely. In fact, Vince, Maniachi are...
41:34 One of our airport guys was standing out on the ramp, looked across, and saw some smoke, and frankly grabbed one more guy, jumped in, drove around, and they had it out within a short period of time. It worked very well. Push the button. Again, the happenstance that he happened to be there looking at, and also the preparation made all the difference. That's great. And the ARF performed fine. Great. Thanks. Thanks, Gray. Good evening, Council. Betsy Truax with a report out from the Recreation Commission meeting. We met yesterday at our new time of 9 a.m.
42:10 The Commission reviewed the staff presentation that you are about to hear and is pleased and excited with the direction that the Enhanced Community Parks and Recreation Department is taking. We also engaged in a discussion with staff regarding proposed improvements to the Volcom Brothers Skate Park and addressed questions raised by NLR about the project for which measure our funds are currently held in reserve. We understand that this will be agendized for...
42:36 The next MLR meeting on March 16th for their recommendation to then come back to you. The commission also began to identify our preferred elements to complete Trails End Park and we'll finalize those at our April meeting for a future recommendation. The commission will also continue our work refining overall recommendations regarding facility priorities in order to provide input to the MLR strategy process.
43:03 And we also accepted an updated meeting and work plan calendar, and we will be requesting a joint meeting with MLR. We have also directed staff to schedule spring and fall workshops with town council to discuss our work plan, facilities, and overall strategic direction. And last but not least, the town's youth sports funding program is currently accepting applications. Over $28,000 is available for appropriation.
43:30 And the commission is eager to present those funding recommendations to you in April for these valuable and essential nonprofit youth sporting organizations. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Betsy. Stuart, do you have anything to report, or Betsy did it all for you? I'm going to do a big thing. You're going to do the big thing. Okay, I didn't know if you had anything like on the sports funding or anything. Okay, then.
44:00 Seeing no more commissions or departments, we'll move on to staff presentation by Stuart. There we go. I just thought I'd just roll it into one. All right. I did this in 16 minutes yesterday. I'll see how I do it today. No guarantee. Good evening. So thank you for the opportunity to speak with council and the community on the value of community recreation. Let me just start my timer there. I know Jamie's got it running.
44:29 So this opening slide represents a broad selection of our brochures that we produce annually. Just looking in the top right there, we also facilitated the Plan Your Parks process. And this July, on the top left there, I know it's a little bit hard to see, but we'll also be celebrating 30 years of Park and Recreation Month, which is a national program. And the Parks and Recreation Department will be celebrating 30 years of Parks and Recreation in Mammoth Lakes. So we incorporated 1994 Parks and Recreation.
44:59 Began in 1985 in our community. In Mammoth Lakes, our tagline here is never have a slow day again in Mammoth again, so that's in that middle section there, and we use that in all our marketing material and our brochures. As several national studies have validated, recreation is an essential component of our community. Keywords in this slide is high quality, diverse, accomplishment, and all leading to an enhanced quality of life.
45:34 Established from rec strats in 2010 to be the best alpine recreation community in the country, represents a universal vision for the entire community to aspire to and rally behind. As stated in the 2007 general plan, this mission statement represents a call to action for the department to deliver for the community and parks make life better, there's that little tagline right there, is a national branding campaign promoting the value of parks.
46:06 And how they enrich the lives of our residents and visitors. And you'll see that logo in all our marketing material as well. The three P's, people, parks and programs, are the Department's important and lasting belief shared by our employees. Our goal is to live and breathe these values each and every day. Approved by Town Council in 2014, these strategies are the Department's roadmap for long-term success. Under each strategy, specific goals, tasks and deliverables,
46:43 Ensuring accountability. The Recreation Commission, led by Chair Betsy Truax, who was just here, Vice Chair Terry Stellix in the audience, as you know, is a very effective policy advisory body for Town Council in all matters pertaining to parks, recreation facilities, special events, and all other associated activities as prescribed by ordinance by Town Council. The Commission also provides strong, informed, and passionate advocacy for the Recreation Department. And we met on Tuesday at 9 o'clock.
47:23 By connecting with our community, the department is directly contributing to the development of strong families, social equity and enriched quality of life, and most importantly, a healthy and vibrant community. The department has an impressive array of parks and recreation facilities that encourage social connections, human development, therapy, the arts, relaxation, challenge, and lifelong learning. In this slide alone, there's over 30 facilities that we maintain, reserve, and program.
47:59 In and around Mammoth Lake. So it's a very big small sport of activities. So there you go. There's a lot. I just added it up this afternoon. Recreation by the numbers. We presented this to Council in October of last year. I think September, October. We'll just briefly go over this slide. We've just got a couple of slides. And these are really the highlights of 2014. Just right off the top there of the 23 youth camps that we provided for the community. UK soccer.
48:29 Wilderness Camp, Waybro Concrete Commandos were the most popular. We have about 70 plus kids in those programs. Since 2010, we've experienced a 55% increase in camp participants. But also the Rec Department is not specifically focused on the kids. As you can see here, 800 adults participated in softball, soccer and dodgeball leagues and tournaments. So we serve the entire community and we're expanding on those program offerings.
49:01 Popular facilities of the 7,250 reserve facility hours, which is really no surprise, is our Shady Rest Pavilion and Barbecue Area, the Community Centre, Shady Rest Park, and the Whitmore Track and Sports Field. Other pertinent numbers in here, you can see we conduct an annual survey, it's a customer satisfaction survey with all our guests that participate in our programs. The number there, 4.32, is represented out of 5. 4.25 was the metric last year, so we're increasing our overall satisfaction.
49:30 What's also interesting is 75% of our customers reside in Mona County. That also means that 25% do not. So we're really reaching a lot more of our guests than just regional recreation. And 22% were first-time program participants. So these are great numbers. Whitmore Pool, 5,600 visits. Mammoth Ice Rink, I put that on, 7,300 visits. Mammoth Rec Zone visits, 670 visits. So we're growing. And all those numbers are going up.
50:00 Community events, we proudly partner with our community to produce fun and family friendly community events and we've listed them there for you to look at. So moving on, what's next? We have three initiatives that the department's working on with the commission. We have a parks and recreation reorganisation, we have parks and recreation planning, we have new summer and full programming opportunities. I'll just firstly address the proposed reorganisation.
50:32 So what we're looking at doing here and beginning July 1st is to merge parks maintenance with the Recreation Department and the goal here is to create a more effective, community-centric, innovative and responsive 21st century Parks and Recreation Department. This reorganisation is essentially triggered by Council's commitment to enhance capacity, to enhance our municipal capacity. That was a highlight from the 18-month commitment. But also strategy number four of the recently adopted Recreation Plan.
51:00 Which is to strengthen organisational systems and structures. So it's a very strategic commitment that we want to implement. Benefits. We have five benefits that we've identified here. Key words, if you're just looking at this slide, is stronger leadership, more effective oversight, improved delivery of services, increased productivity, delineated staff responsibilities, and all with no increased cost to the general fund.
51:34 The benefits of this synergistic relationship is to deliver superior levels of service for our community. Really, that's the bottom line. That's why we're doing it. The merger will also continue to expand on the positive and valuable relationship that we currently exist with Public Works and their staff. To deliver these superior levels of service, we identified six core functions that we've identified here. Right off the top, recreation programming, facility operations and programming, administration, parks maintenance,
52:07 Public Works Support and Parks and Recreation Management, Planning and Promotion. I'm just going to quickly go through each of those, give you a bit of an overview. Recreation programming, a goal here with this deliverable is to connect with each and every community member through our diverse program offerings. John Connolly will lead our expanded and affordable community-centric programming efforts. So this is really to connect with everybody from ages 1 to 100. So this is Stephanie Daniels' responsibilities here.
52:43 And this deliverable here is to oversee facility operations and programming. So the goal with this deliverable is to operate each facility under similar procedures, utilizing best practices, and incorporating our web-based software to maximize reporting, accounting, reservations, and operational processes. And you can see this one position is going to oversee the pool, the rink, the rec zone, which is a multi-use facility.
53:09 Community Centre tennis courts and all the programming that takes place on our parks. Administration, delivering exceptional customer service is a pillar of our core values and one that is expected by our residents and visitors. Providing dedicated staff to this position will enable our supervisors to be far more productive and effective in their daily responsibilities. As you can see here, the deliverables include office management, facility reservations, running ActiveNet, which is a big part of our operations right now.
53:41 Financial Management, Database Management, our CRM tool, communicating with our guests is a big and a major priority for our department. A lot of programming facility support for both parks and recreation. And this person's also going to assist in our role of special events. We permit over 32 special events, which also includes Mammoth Health Marathon. Parks Maintenance. So this section has really led so far and for the last 31 years by our park superintendent. As you know, Dennis Rotner is retiring this July.
54:14 So the plan is to replace, which I'm not sure is possible, but to hire a parks manager responsible for more on the ground versus behind the desk responsibilities. So we really want this person out there maintaining and enhancing our recreation infrastructure, which is a critical element of our strategic implementation plan. Public works support. So the department provides several services for public works, including winter sidewalk snow removal, summer trail maintenance,
54:47 And we also hang our many seasonal banners on our lampposts. We do all the Christmas decorations. We also dress up the trees. And we manage those landscape maintenance contracts. So the final core strategy here is Parks and Recreation Management, Planning and Promotion. And this departmental function provides leadership, ensures accountability, delivers results, and is responsible for collaborating with user groups, stakeholders, jurisdictional partners.
55:18 And Mammoth Lakes Recreation to ensure a seamless recreation experience for both residents and visitors of Mammoth Lakes. This is our current organisational structure and this has been in place since the separation of tourism and recreation in 2010. The structure is solely designed to only deliver recreation programs and activities for the community. It unfortunately is designed for minimal and direct engagement with parks, maintenance and public works staff. And that's something we really have to fix. We want to be more effective in delivering services.
55:52 We need to do it in a better way. The proposed structure that we're looking at right now is more representative of traditional parks and recreation organisations, but with the addition of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, it's structured to be more effective and community-centric, built under one roof to deliver both parks and recreation services. This structure includes six full-time currently and 38 seasonal employees, so it's a large department.
56:20 They're all delineated by function but all working together towards a common goal and that is to exceed our residents' and visitors' expectations. So you can see here you have essentially delineation between programming, parks maintenance, with a director overseeing both those responsibilities. There's some positions we're not going to fill at this time. This is all pending our budget and as we move forward. But we believe that the three different budget and, sorry, organisational structures we've looked at, this has been the most effective to date.
56:52 Recreation planning, this is our second initiative that we're working with the Recreation Commission on, and this is to support ongoing efforts by the Recreation Commission that Betsy spoke of a little bit earlier, and that is to identify and prioritise major facility maintenance projects and capital improvement projects for the community. As you can see here, it's also going to connect with Mammoth Lakes Recreation as they move forward prioritising projects supported by Measures R and Measure U. Finally, new summer and slash...
57:23 Full programming. Highlights of this slide include our new mini signature camps. We really wanted to reach out to our younger audience, our three to six-year-olds. We have a new aquatics camp. We wanted to get more people down to the pool. We're enhancing our transit service to Whitmore Recreation again. We have a new girl power camp. We've enhanced our adult and our tennis programs, which you can see here as well. What else have we got here? We're opening all our facilities this summer on June 20th, so everything opens together.
57:49 We've scheduled a recreation open house at the middle school on April 14th. And the goal with that program is really to bring together all our recreation providers in the community from trails, arts and culture, recreation, schools, ski area, to provide a one-stop shop for recreation this summer. So if you're a parent looking for what to do, where to send your kid, this is the place to be. So this is a new initiative we're kind of putting out there for the community. Really hope we get a lot of support. And all our summer camps and programs right now are available online. So we're actually selling summer.
58:19 In February. It's actually March, but we do that in February. There's our tagline. You'll see that. That concludes my presentation. I just want to say it's an honour to be able to present this amazing array of products and services produced by our entire recreation department and commission. Our community is fortunate to have such talented people, and the town is fortunate to have them working for us. Our recreation future is bright. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Stuart. Questions? Thank you.
58:54 No questions? I guess you covered everything. You have a question. Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Thanks, Stuart. Well, as some of those things come back to us for action, then maybe that'd be questions. Yeah. Okay, that moves us to the consent agenda. I have a request to poll item number four. Are there any other items? Yeah. Madam Mayor, we'll need to poll item five to deal with recusals on the RNU items. Thank you.
59:29 Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to approve consent agenda items 3, 6, and 7. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Number 4, Kathy. Thank you, Madam Mayor, for pulling that. My name is Kathy Cage.
1:00:08 I asked to have this agenda item pulled because I wanted basically to make a statement about it, mostly for the general public. In the agenda materials for this item, the staff report had indicated that in the RMF2 zone, there are 25 single-family homes. So I kind of quietly watched, and a number of people in the community quietly watched as it went through planning, commissioning, council to see what comments and how the council would want to address.
1:00:36 The single-family homes that happened to be in RMF II. There was virtually no discussion in either body about those particular 25 homes. And a number of us were fairly dismayed about that because particularly for the three who were recently elected to town council, there was a lot of discussion about the single-family homes and nightly rentals during a campaign. And one of the things I wanted to bring up today is just kind of remind a couple of our council members of some statements they made about
1:01:05 Their interest in dealing with issues related to nightly rentals of single-family homes. Shields, one of your written statements indicated that you were interested in seeing maybe that they possibly have a management company as an overseer, dealing with potential occupancy maximums, trash and snow removal, parking restrictions.
1:01:30 John, you talked a lot about, let's see, how did you word it, enforcement in education, that kind of thing relative to potential issues, relative to trash, parking, snow removal, that type of thing. And there was no discussion about any of these issues from either the Town Council or the Planning Commission.
1:01:51 And so right now, the way this ordinance stands, if you pass it this tonight, it means that previously there was a use permit required to be able to do nightly rentals in a single-family home in this particular zone. All that was discussed was the fact that whether or not this was an appropriate zone for nightly rentals, and it is. No one really disputes that. However, single-family homes were not developed
1:02:13 For nightly rent, so for instance, they won't have dumpsters there like a condo project would or an apartment complex would. Generally, a single family home has enough parking for, you know, the people that live there, that kind of thing. Not to have the, you know, the USC water polo team come and rent the house and have all their, you know, parking around there.
1:02:31 In a lot of these zones, RMF2, they're up and around condo complexes. So the folks I know, my friends at Thompsons, who manage Mammoth Estates, are constantly dealing with the single-family homes in the neighborhood who are nightly rentals. And they come and they dump their trash in the Mammoth Estates trash dumpsters. And so they have to deal with extra dumps there.
1:02:53 These are not new things. These are things that have been discussed many, many times. And I just wanted to let the general public know that this passed through the Town Council and through Planning Commission with no mention of any of these subjects. Nobody talked about it. There's no staff direction to make sure we handle this when it comes to permitting. None of that.
1:03:10 One of the things you lost by taking away the use permit is the ability to put conditions of use. I was dismayed that in the staff report, none of that was discussed. What was discussed was what you lose by not having the use permit is you don't notify neighbors. That was the big extent of what you lose by doing that.
1:03:31 I was dismayed to see there was no discussion that said, oh, now you won't be able to put conditions of use on it. I mean, we sent Dana Severy away with a laundry list of conditions of use for him to put a hotel in an appropriately zoned area in North Village, but nothing for a single family person who probably, you know, built their house 25 years ago, and now they get to run it like a little business, like a little hotel in that area. So, one of the reasons...
1:03:58 That, you know, a number of us local citizens decided to do this initiative is, frankly, we didn't trust that the town council would protect these interests, you know, protect the neighbors, the neighboring businesses and that kind of stuff from the impacts of changing a single-family home, which is designed for a family to live in, to a business with kind of nightly rentals. So, you know,
1:04:25 We wanted to see what the Town Council would do on their own, and we did. Thank you very much. If I could just... Andy, is it our Dan, or maybe it's even Sandra, is it possible to explain the difference between conditions of use and what kinds of conditions of use, like with the Dana Severy Project, as she said, and the kinds of conditions of use that would have been...
1:04:53 Done on the switchovers from single family homes. Yeah, so typically, actually the Planning Commission, the Planning and Economic Development Commission recently approved a transient rental use of a single family home. They didn't place any operational conditions on them. However, that is an option as part of the use permit process. So that is something that the
1:05:15 We won't be able to do. However, if the project goes through a map or a design review, we can place conditions on it through that process, but they wouldn't be operational conditions. Just another comment on the quality of life issues that were raised. We will be discussing that as part of Item 9 tonight. There was direction from Council to consider that, and we will be giving a report on our findings on that item. All right. Okay. So, John?
1:05:46 Yeah, I just, I think this was an issue of the campaign, and I think I, each one of us who ran addressed it in a way that they felt appropriate. I spoke in terms of making a commitment to the quality of life of our residential neighborhoods. And I think all the members of the council appreciate what a complex and multifaceted issue this is. And I think one of the things I'm becoming increasingly aware of is how,
1:06:16 In reading the national press, this issue changes daily. The implications of it, good, bad, it is an ongoing moving target. And I certainly look forward to working with the sponsors of this initiative to see if there's a way to identify some common ground to make sure that as we move forward with this extremely challenging and complex issue,
1:06:42 That we're finding a way to do this and tackle this, as we say in our priority, to tackle this issue in a way that's going to really benefit this community. So I'm looking forward, I would assume my fellow council members are looking forward to working with the folks behind this initiative and finding a way to maybe drop the rhetoric a little bit, maybe not play gotchas so much with you said this and you said that. I think we all have shared the values for this community going forward. I look forward to having those conversations. Thank you.
1:07:13 Yeah, I would agree with John. That's why we're going through the process that we are now. That's why number nine on the agenda tonight is going through that process. It is not just an easy fix like that. We have to know, you know, what are the options out there? What works? What doesn't work? So I think we've tried to make it, you know, very transparent to the community that we are on a process no one's made up.
1:07:44 I see that this is just one of the steps in the many that we will be taking. Right.
1:08:19 Further discussion under number nine. Yes. Yes. Good evening again. Terry Stellick. Sandra. So you just said that an RMF-2, if that goes through now, if this is passed through tonight and approved, that there are no operational conditions that can be put forth on those?
1:08:45 Properties? So they would still have to go through the business tax certificate and the transient occupancy tax certificate process. So basically the conditions that Kathy was referring to, like requiring a dumpster or requiring some sort of something beyond what you would typically require, we wouldn't be able to require those types of things. Okay, but if you move forward with your item number nine and there are items that are put through with that with trash and that, will those then be?
1:09:15 Kind of retroactive to any other homes that have been approved for the RMF2, or are they just not going to have to go by those rules because they received a permit prior to those being in place? Let me see if I can tackle this one. The council could at any time adopt rules that apply to transient rentals generally regardless of the zone. It would just go from being a use permit set of requirements.
1:09:43 That are kind of ad hoc for each permittee to being a global set of requirements. Instead of being found in a use permit that's connected to the zoning, it would be potentially, if Council decides to do it, requirements that apply townwide, which is what other cities have in place. So those would even be retroactive to properties prior to these being in place? It's not a question of retroactivity. They would simply apply to all properties regardless of when they started renting. Okay. Thank you. I just have a quick follow-up to Sandra.
1:10:14 If the use permit stayed in place, for instance, could we say, okay, House A came forward and through the use permit process, you know, someone goes out and looks at the property and said, oh, well, they're fine with everything except they don't have enough parking and, you know, we want to see where the snow storage is. And they could say, oh, you are approved to be a transient rental.
1:10:40 Once you have demonstrated that, you know, where you're going to put the cars and that type of thing, is that an appropriate condition of use if the use permit remain on? If we had standards that said transient rentals, single family homes that have transient rentals are required a certain number of parking spaces and it didn't meet that, I think we could require those types of conditions, but that would only happen in a use permit.
1:11:06 So basically the intent of putting conditions on a use permit is to ensure that the use is compatible with adjacent properties. So if there was something that wasn't compatible with adjacent properties and the commission felt that putting a condition on it made it more compatible or made it comply, then we could do that. And it could vary from property to property depending on the specific... It is on a case-by-case basis. Thank you. Okay. Any other comment or questions?
1:11:38 I have a question for staff. So just to be clear, in what we're doing, we are not compromising the ability of the council or the town to extend conditions. My sense is we're heading towards getting to a more consistent and uniform program, and I think it may be important for people to understand that we're going at about one mile an hour up here. That's the nature of the pace that we have to go at.
1:12:08 And if we're building towards a good comprehensive enforcement program, it's going to take us, we'll have to do it one step at a time. But we've not, you know, we've not sort of compromised any ability we would have down the road to establish regulations and those kinds of things globally. I think if the council were to adopt the ordinance tonight and then later decide once to have rules that apply to everybody, yeah, the council can do that. So the action tonight...
1:12:35 With this agenda item, it's not taking away the town's ability to regulate transient rentals. Thank you. I think it's a very important point of clarification. It would simply be a different vehicle for doing that. Correct. Thank you very much. Well, you know, I think those are going to be my comments, and, you know, I appreciate the way that you turned it, Andy, because I think it was very well said. I find it interesting that it stated that we're not dealing with it at all when two inches down the page, that's exactly what we're doing. But, you know, I think...
1:13:02 Dealing with use permits in RMF 2 doesn't have anything to do with dealing with quality of life issues if somebody's in a resort zone. So, you know, just because somebody's in a resort zone does not mean that they should just have carte blanche to act however they want. So what we're looking to do up here is address the quality of life issues for both illegal and legal rentals across the board.
1:13:28 I don't see that a use permit helps us to achieve that, but what we are trying to do with item number nine is look at all of the legally permitted homes and try and address some of the quality of life issues. So it's, you know, if we can continue to move this forward as we've tried to do and get some of those regulations in place that will apply to RMF 2, that will apply to the resort zone, et cetera, et cetera. So, not really. Evening again. Martin Kleinberg.
1:14:03 Pardon me if I seem a little confused. I'm Kathy Cage's point about parking. So if one of these properties that currently would have to get a use permit before today or before this passes and they don't have adequate services, how would, if there's no use permit, what would be the process that the town would have to go to ensure that a substandard property conforms with?
1:14:32 Such things as parking. The Town Council could, if it wanted to, adopt a series of requirements that apply globally to all transient rentals within the town. And there are examples, we're really kind of talking about Agenda Item 9 at this point, but there are examples from other jurisdictions of requirements and restrictions that apply globally. You don't need a use permit, but in order to be able to rent your property, you'd have to get maybe a rental permit under one potential way of doing things.
1:15:02 Which is separate from the zoning and the use permit department. So it is possible for the town to have, to require that if you're going to rent your property that you have adequate parking or you have provisions for notifying the owner or a responsible on-site manager if there's a problem. There are ways of doing it other than through the use permit. But I think that would be very problematic for a property that's already been approved in the conditions that they have that may be substandard to a new rule and this should probably be
1:15:31 A can of worms that's going to be open. I don't know how many properties are involved in such a situation, so I don't know what the effect is. I haven't seen the city map that shows all those different properties, but I think that, you know, that's only one thing that was brought up that stirs my mind, but I'm sure that there's others, the more I would think. That's all. Okay, so, what's the pleasure of the council?
1:16:05 I'll make a motion. It's actually on your, yeah. Which item is this? It's on, it's number four, and look on your blue paper. Okay. I would make a motion to waive the first reading introduced by title only in ordinance making the required secret municipal code fines approved zoning code amendment 14. Is that the right one? No, no, read it off the blue paper. Oh, off the blue paper, okay, sorry.
1:16:36 Waive the reading and adopt by title only in ordinance making the required secret municipal code findings and approve zoning code amendment 14-002 removal of use permit requirement for residential multifamily RMF-2 for transit rental amending municipal code title 17 zoning. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:17:04 Yes, motion passes 5-0. Then moving to number 5, I understand that we can all be up here for the Measure R resolution, then you'll explain to me how we're going to work our way through the Measure U. So are we making a... Okay. Yeah. Yeah, so we need a motion for the Measure R. Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to adopt the resolutions approving the Town Council recommended Measure R funding allocations. Second.
1:17:36 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. On the second one, is it okay for us to just say yes with an abstention on, or do we have to do, we have to break them into pieces? Unfortunately, it can't be done that way. Okay. What we'll actually need to do is have both, I think it's,
1:18:02 Councilmember Richardson and Mayor Bacon abstain from the action on the resolution. From the action on the resolution. So you both need to step out, and the other three members then would vote on the resolution. Well, where's the resolution? So it's basically the same resolution, just on the U portion. Yep. Might I see some further discussion? What's that? Some further discussion. Sure. Would you guys like to have some discussion? Further discussion? Sure. I just want to emphasize that as part of this process, there is a...
1:18:41 Motion at the end of discussion to move forward with working with the special events folks to find alternative financing and to reiterate the council support of special events and to find alternative financing mechanisms. I just want to make sure that we're all clear that that's of value and importance and that's part of what we said we were going to do. Yeah, I'm wholly supportive of that and we've already had some of those conversations moving in that direction so I think we all appreciated that
1:19:11 This particular interim funding cycle was something that we just needed to pass and move through as we start to, you know, develop that strategic vision moving forward. So I'd be prepared to make a motion unless you have anything else. Any public comment on this? Seeing none, I'll entertain a motion. Mayor Pro Tem, I'd like to make a motion to adopt the resolutions approving the Town Council recommended Measure U funding allocations. I'll second. Roll call, please.
1:19:43 Yes, yes, yes, motion passes 3-0. Somebody tell them. Oh, they knew, how did they know? That will move us to our policy matters, the first being item number 8, resolution authorizing 50,000 from housing in lieu fee account from housing ordinance and fee update contract. Thank you, Mayor and Councilmembers.
1:20:25 As directed by Council on January 21st, staff is proceeding with the housing ordinance and fee update. AECOM technical services is being retained for this work. A preliminary scope of work from AECOM is included in your packet. That includes a $50,000 budget and a schedule that allows Council approval of the updated ordinance by the end of April.
1:20:48 This item also includes Council's initiation of a general plan amendment to the housing element, which would allow any necessary modifications to the housing element as a result of the housing ordinance. Now, we did receive some comments from Mammoth Lakes Housing on this item, and so I'd like to walk through and summarize those for the Council. There was a concern that the ordinance may be confusing.
1:21:17 As directed by Council, the intent with this ordinance is to have a clear, easy-to-understand mitigation ordinance that is fee-based. That would allow developers to pay a straight fee for mitigation. However, if a developer elected to mitigate in an alternative means, the ordinance would clearly specify those alternative means such as off-site housing or land donation.
1:21:46 Another question was asking why only California peer resorts were included in the scope of work. And since housing laws vary by state and council directed us to be on a pretty strict timeline for this effort, staff suggested California peer resorts to be used. However, this is a preliminary scope of work and if council wants AECOM to look at other peer resorts, we can include that in their final scope.
1:22:15 A suggestion was made that we review the background data before starting the ordinance update. And again, because of the short time frame directed by council for this work effort, that was going to be done concurrently by AECOM as they work through the ordinance update. However, if council would like us to segment those and look at the background analysis,
1:22:42 First, before working on updating the ordinance, we could do that. That, I think, would probably push out the schedule a bit, but we haven't asked AECOM for that information yet. And then lastly, there was a concern about the fee being established based on the affordability gap. And staff noticed that in the preliminary scope of work, and we've already talked to AECOM about including the production cost gap as well.
1:23:11 And so that would mean that in the fee analysis that they conduct, it will include documenting the calculation of housing unit production cost as well as the affordability gap for the purchase of a market rate unit versus an affordable unit. So council will be presented with both of those numbers during your review of what an appropriate fee would be.
1:23:34 And then in that scope, it does reflect Council's comments from January that did mention that it was desirable to have a fee that could be absorbed by developers, and so that's why that's mentioned in the scope. So this is a preliminary scope of work. We'd be happy to modify it however Council directs, include any modifications in our final scope.
1:24:01 And with that, I'd be happy to take any questions. Any questions? Janet, I just had one quick question. What's the estimated time for this to be completed? So there is a rough schedule at the end of the item in your packet. The target is the end of April for Council to take action on a draft ordinance and then have the fee come to Council for adoption in May.
1:24:31 Yeah, I guess what I was referring to is, I guess, how realistic is the schedule. It's very, very tight. It's very, very tight, but AECOM has committed to that for us. Okay, thanks. Sorry. As I recall our discussion, we talked about the inclusionary being part of a toolkit. And I'm assuming that's reflected in your direction to the consultant, correct? Yes. Okay. And the second question was,
1:25:01 There's some discussion about perhaps some recommendations about a new or enhanced or slightly changed rule for housing authority based on the work that they will be doing. Is that still part of the scope? I'm sorry. I don't think I understand the question. We talked about the idea that if a developer would have the option of paying a fee for mitigation. And the question was the challenge of how do we as a community translate those dollars into housing?
1:25:31 And I think the discussion, there was part of the discussion said, well, that may mean that we start looking at the role of our housing authority, that they may need to take on different responsibilities, different capacities to make that happen. And I want to make sure that as we, I think that I certainly felt comfortable moving forward going into a fee option, but we still have an obligation to deliver the housing. And I don't think we want to be in a position when the developers are going to show up in April or May and say, you know, we need to talk about the fees.
1:25:59 We need to be able to reliably say if we do it on a cash basis or they can mitigate with a check that we are confident that we can deliver the housing product out the other end. And, John, I remember that discussion very clearly, but I'm wondering if that's a staff effort as opposed to the consultant effort. Yeah, and that's my question. I just want to make sure that doesn't get lost because that's going to be very important as we go forward, making sure that if, you know, if we're going to...
1:26:23 Be making a more efficient way for developers to work. That's fine. But we still have to make sure that at the end of the day we can deliver the housing. Right. I think as part of the discussion when you're determining what the appropriate fee is going to be, we're going to have to understand what methods and programs we anticipate utilizing that fee for. So that will be part of the discussion. Okay. So as long as we all understand we need to, that's got to be part of the discussion. Jen, I want to go back to the question of the timing of it.
1:26:50 So the draft ordinance is just to identify what's in the toolkit and then the fee nexus study is what gets to the actual dollar amounts and the data is needed for both of those but would not actually get pulled together. I mean, even if there is a draft ordinance, we're not going to do anything with it until we have the other information. Is that correct? I mean, just in terms of the
1:27:19 Timeline requirements for an ordinance to be effective. The ordinance, if we do follow this schedule, the ordinance would be effective likely until after the fee is adopted. But for example, the ordinance would include perhaps the calculation of how the fee would be calculated and then the fee itself would be dictated through
1:27:44 Your resolution approving the fee based on the fee study and nexus study. So we would be actually approving a draft ordinance not knowing exactly what those fees will be? Those fees or those calculations would be something like the appropriate fee times the square footage of the use is, you know, it wouldn't limit the fee itself. It would just provide the skeleton.
1:28:11 So it would provide the methodology, is that? Right. Yes, thank you. And Jen, just one other quick clarification. I know kind of the discussion we had in the past was, you know, inclusionary was kind of option number one, and then there was an AHMP that was proposed. My recollection of the discussion was dropping that to say that inclusionary is not necessarily position one, but is part of the toolbox.
1:28:38 I know a lot of the developers had expressed when they spoke that, you know, they would prefer to pay a fee, but I also want to make sure that that's kind of, that we're clear on the fact that that's not necessarily elevated to a higher level either. It's just part of the toolbox. Right. Right. Okay. All right, so I just want to make clear that we're not, you know, saying that's the new position one. And I appreciate you saying that because in reading it I sort of had a sense that maybe we were going down that road, but I appreciate you clarifying that. Okay.
1:29:07 Is it, Madam Mayor, is it all right if we hear from you? Well, I was going to ask our other staff, Jennifer Helfody, to speak. Right. First. Yeah. I have a question as an example for the Peer Resort, why you think that you should have others in there besides California? You're asking me? Yes. Yeah. Come on up. Come on up. Well, I think, you know, based on the discussion we had at our board meeting Monday night, yes, I think
1:29:36 We as a ski resort community or just a resort community, we're competing with resort communities not just in California but all across the nation. And so if we're competing for those same developers and the same capital, why would we not want to look at how the other resort communities are handling their inclusionary or their housing mitigation?
1:30:04 To see if we are on par or are we way off because we hear that a lot when developers come in the door. Oh, well, I'll just go over there because they've got a better deal or, you know, we hear that a lot that we're competing with these folks for these fees and we've got to get them down so that they pencil. And so if we're not looking at other resorts such as, you know, the ones in Colorado or Wyoming or even in Utah, then how do we know where we fit in the scheme of things when we hear those comments?
1:30:36 And Jennifer, did you want to make any other comments? Well, I think the, you know, the, I do want to let you all know that today the California Supreme Court announced that they will hear the CBIA versus San Jose case on April 8th.
1:30:52 And I know that we had been holding off on this to try to figure out what that was because that could have huge ramifications on where housing mitigation, inclusionary housing, whatever you want to call it, goes in the state of California. So they're going to hear arguments on April 8th. They just made that announcement this evening. Probably, even though they'll hear arguments on April 8th, I don't expect we'd have a decision from them until probably the fall.
1:31:21 Yeah, and I didn't say, yeah. Who knows? Who knows? But that is action on that, and we haven't seen any action on that in a long time, so that's something to report, I think. You know, I just want to say that we hear a lot from the development community that the town fees need to be reasonable, and they must allow development to pencil. But I want to look at the other side. I think we owe it to the community to look at the other side of the equation. And what does the community need?
1:31:50 To pencil in order to be a place that we can all want to live, that we all want to live, but we can also afford to live in. That's the other side. And I think this is our opportunity to make sure that those two balance. And I think, you know, the question that you raised, John, was...
1:32:12 You know, what happens to Mammoth Lakes Housing? How do we, if we're getting these fees, how are we using? I don't think that can be a question we can wait to answer. I think it has to be part of this process because otherwise we're not solving the problem. We're just kind of putting it to the side and saying, well, we have money, but we don't really know if it works. And so we need to make sure we're looking at the cost of land, the cost of development. We're also looking at
1:32:39 How does that money truly translate and does it translate into what our objectives are? Or is it just meeting one niche of the workforce? Or does it hit everyone and how well does it do that? I mean, it really, we want to make sure that the consequences of this action are intended and that we're not left holding a bag later that we don't know how to solve for. The only other thing I want to say is
1:33:07 That language under Nexus study that says that it is anticipated, it is assumed that council will adopt a fee that's less than the maximum is troublesome. I don't know how we got there. I don't know why we're assuming we'd adopt a lower fee than what's necessary to fill that gap. But if we are, that should be part of that equation. Okay, so now we've just created a gap.
1:33:34 Within the gap. And how do we fill that? And what does that mean to us actually now providing the housing? So that's probably my only other comment is that that language still bothers me. And I think that we can't make those decisions ahead of time. Any questions for Jennifer? Yeah. Are we looking at housing, affordable housing? Does MLH just look in Mammoth proper?
1:34:05 Or do they look at housing other places that would be within driving distance, short driving distance to Mammoth? So Mammoth Lakes Housing works with Mono County to offer programs such as down payment assistance. So we don't work just in the town. But when we work for the town, we work just in the town. Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying. Thank you.
1:34:35 And Jennifer, could you speak to the data question for a second? About the prioritization of the data, why that matters, why that's important? The data, why? Well, I think that we're talking about setting up an inclusionary, housing mitigation policy that's going to have a toolbox. But how do you know what you want in the toolbox? Maybe you don't want everything in the toolbox because then we don't,
1:35:07 We're not in the driver's seat to lead to where we want to be. I think it's good to have a preference, and maybe we have a couple of preferences, but I think that that data helps drive what you think your preferences need to be. If you're looking at other resort communities, you're getting a sense of what they're doing. If you're looking at what our 10% means today.
1:35:27 And so then we can compare it to where we're kind of headed. I think it makes us more productive in getting to that end policy that really meets what we want. Instead of spending time developing policy and then getting maybe some information, examples of other ordinances later, then we're reworking it. I just think it might be more efficient and it makes you all better informed to decide what the policy should look like rather than just going off of what I say or what developers say.
1:35:57 And is it the understanding from staff that the data and the recommendations would come to us all at the same time? Is that right? Are they going to come in phases? They will come all at the same time. Same time. Okay. Thank you. Thanks. Okay. Is there anyone else you'd like to speak? I did want to address the peer resort issue. You said that right now we're looking at California peer resorts. And so one thing I wanted to maybe ask council to consider
1:36:28 Just has to do with the fact that Mammoth is very unique. You know, when we set this housing ordinance up way back when and did all our peer resort tours at the time, we went all over the place. Just remember, Mammoth doesn't really have down valley options like a lot of other resorts do. So when, you know, when we're comparing like apples to apples, please try to take that into account because it's been a longstanding value of our community to house the people who work here, to be able to house the people who work here if they want to.
1:36:56 We have very limited down valley options. You know, we've got Crowley and June Lake is about it. And it's not similar, you know, very similar at all to too many other California places. So I just wanted to emphasize that. I don't know which resorts you're looking at, but to make sure that whatever comes back, we can see clearly what's apples and apples compared to us. Yeah, thank you, Kathy. I think that's a very valid point. If we are going to expand...
1:37:24 This to other peer resorts. They should be like Mammoth. Any other comments? You can spring back for some deliberation or adjustments or whatever we've got going here. I guess I'd like to ask staff if we added a couple more peer resorts, what would EECOM, would the fee be the same? I don't know.
1:37:55 We haven't asked them yet. That's maybe just to qualify that a little bit. I'm assuming if you look at the California peer resorts, there's a common legal basis. Correct. It's all in the state. Correct. But if we're looking at other peer resorts without maybe the same level of, because the legal stuff's not going to match. Well, and cost is certainly going to.
1:38:17 Yeah, the cost could be different, but in terms of goals or aspirations or tools that they use to address it. Yeah, and I would be looking at it, and thank you, Kathy, for mentioning Down Valley, because my thought is that many Colorado resorts are more like us in how they deal with that fact of being Down Valley than any California one, so it may not be that it's on the legal basis, but I think that it's important to have some others, since I'm not sure there's any other California resort that's quite as isolated as we are.
1:38:46 So I'd like to have them included, but from a standpoint of how did they deal with remoteness and not having everybody live down valley. Right. So it's more of an experiential piece, not necessarily a legal piece. So I would ask that you do include some others. Because we may find that they have tools that they use that could inform what we're doing. Right. That can help us with our issue. Right. Yeah, I think...
1:39:15 Those are going to be my comments, and I'm glad to see that some other people are on the same page. I think I'm comfortable with most of the things, but those were a couple of the comments that I wanted to make. I do think it's important that if we do this, we do this right, and I think having that analysis of some of our other peer resorts is important to really seeing all the facts and making an informed decision. Looking at California peer resorts, I don't think Tahoe is very akin to Mammoth.
1:39:45 Whereas if you were to go to some of the Colorado resorts, they are much more of an apples to apples comparison. Obviously we have differences in state. But I think we've all probably done enough traveling to our peer resorts to kind of see the ones that have done it well and see the ones that have kind of missed the mark as far as building a community. So looking at some of those ones that have done it well.
1:40:12 And some of the policies that they have to make that the case I think is important. So what are you suggesting? How many other peer resorts would we want to look at? Well, I think that would be up to staff and the consultant to work out which ones are the appropriate ones. And we could consult with Maniflix Housing to determine those.
1:40:34 Just a couple off the top of my head that would be helpful. I think Steamboat would be one. Telluride would be another one. Telluride's a very constrained landmass. It's very isolated. And they don't have a lot of down valley options there. And they've done a very good job with their affordable housing. So those would be a couple to maybe consider. And I'm sure you guys will have, you know, and Mammoth Lakes Housing will provide some good insight into that as well.
1:40:59 That was some of the conversation that I had had after we finished our meeting on Mondays, just looking at some resorts that have really done a good job of kind of trying to build that community, and those are a couple that came to mind. I would also be interested, if someone can find a community that's got an urban growth boundary, that's got a hard line like we've got, I don't know if there is such a place. In a certain case, Telluride does.
1:41:24 They've sprawled a lot of the mountains. Oh, that's true, they did. The majority of their land that separates historic downtown and the mountain village is all into a protection easement, so it can't be touched. So, you know, it is similar to being surrounded by Forest Service in the sense that it's non-available land for development. So I think Telluride is actually a very good comparison point for us to look at.
1:41:52 And, you know, the other comment that I thought was valid is, you know, I think, and we can work through this as we're doing this. I'm comfortable with most of the other things kind of working concurrently, but I don't think we want to necessarily off the bat presume that we are going to look at a less than the maximum. I agree with you totally on that. Yeah, I think, you know, obviously it's on the table for consideration, but I don't think we want to presume that in advance. And I think in all these things,
1:42:19 Even like, say, with the SFR discussion, that we are taking a deliberate approach, keeping it apples to apples until there comes a point of decision that we have to actually engage with those kinds of issues. So as long as we keep it apples to apples, let's keep it that way. Okay. And then the other one that I was hearing some discussion on was having a strategy for if we collect all this money in lieu, what are we going to do with it? Yeah. Oh, yeah. That's part of this discussion.
1:42:50 Well, I'll just make it quick. I just wanted, because I actually, it wasn't the last council meeting when you talked about this, but I watched it.
1:42:58 On TV. And I didn't hear a discussion about this particular aspect of it that I hope you keep in mind when you talk about the fees and the levels, is the public sector can't develop at the same price that the private sector can. When we put this ordinance in place and had this inclusionary zone, that was one of the reasons. It was our thought that, you know, look, a developer can come in and they have a fixed cost on their, you know, on their development and their land and all that sort of thing. So if we get a fee, I mean, that's fine. But the Mammoth Lakes Housing can't develop at the same kind of cost that
1:43:27 So just when you talk about, okay, we get this fee, what does that get us? I'm pretty sure it has to be a prevailing wage type, yeah, it has to be prevailing wage work, and I don't even know how it goes with acquiring existing stuff. I suspect maybe a developer could negotiate some existing units, maybe at a better price than a public entity can, I don't know.
1:43:52 I would feel gratified if that's part of your conversation when you talk about this in terms of what are we getting with the fees we get. Yeah, I think that's exactly the point. That's a very valid point, I think. And that's exactly the point. It's like if we're going to go to that basis, we've got to make sure it's going to work. We've got to deliver housing. And I've made some comments in the past that I would really like to see our focus on rehab of existing stocks. So I didn't think it was appropriate to necessarily elevate that to a different tier, but
1:44:20 For me personally, that's where I'd like to see a lot of those dollars move towards. Again, and that goes to discussions we've had ongoing about housing challenges in this community. Aging stock. Aging stock. We just heard from a gentleman tonight. Rent's, you know, arbitrarily going out of control. I mean, these are issues we've got to deal with. Okay, so then I'm hearing that essentially the...
1:44:45 One of the adjustments that we recommend in the scope of work is to include peer resorts outside of California that are like us in experience, to not presume that the fees would be lower than the maximum needed, and to include a strategy on what to do with the funds, if it's cash. Exactly, yeah.
1:45:12 The only other thing is this question about the data, and I'm assuming that from what I'm hearing from staff, we're going to get it all at once, but I think that it's, and I would assume that the consultant is going to be astute enough to know that they have to design their workflow and their project and how they do it to get the data in the order that they need to get it so they can, their decisions, their representation will be informed by the data. Exactly. Okay, so I'm going to assume that that's going to be taken care of, and then when we get it.
1:45:41 The data and the recommendations, we've got everything at once. Okay. Anything else? Mr. Hollerhead. And it's fine where you're going with that. Just two elements to that. One, I would ask that the budget probably be moved up. You're going to add some additional cost. So probably another five or ten grand contingency. And also the timeline probably needs to move out another 30 days to 45 days. It was very, very tight based on the previous direction given.
1:46:11 What you're asking here will most likely bump out that timeline. Just in terms of data gathering and some of the other information coming back in, I can't say exactly how much of a timeline bump, but what you're asking for will probably require that. So just heads up, I don't want to give you a false expectation. We can deliver something in the next days and we can't. So you're recommending an increase in the motion, you're recommending that it be more than $50,000? Yeah, I would say if you did a $10,000 contingency amount.
1:46:39 That gives us flexibility. And the schedule goes through June 2015? Yeah, you're probably out until end of June then to get potentially. I mean, I have some concerns with that. I mean, we have several developers, I mean, that are in escrow right now that are looking at this and trying to get their pencil and do their math. You know, I'm concerned with that. That's why I asked first about the timeline. You know, I'm concerned with trying to push it out.
1:47:10 Because I feel if another month is added, that could be two or three or longer. Well, I'm just thinking that the, I think what we're asking to do, and correct me if I'm off, but we're asking them to do an analysis of potentially two or three different peer resorts. The question about not making, the other two items, I don't think they'll affect the schedule. So I'm just thinking, I'm not hearing anything that, from my perspective, my Dan's providing note of caution, and that's nice, but I don't see.
1:47:39 I don't know. I don't think it would be more than maybe a couple weeks. We would continue to push hard, but I think what you're asking for, you know, the other peer resort work will take more time because you're going out and you're researching out into other areas and you'll be looking. They may have some great options that, frankly, aren't legally available in California. Sure. So you'll have those types of issues you'll work through. The other side of that will be in terms of the timeline we were talking about, if you want a full development and schedule of here's what
1:48:06 Here's how the funding can be utilized and here's the data behind that in that Nexus study. That will add time because that is a key element of it. That will take a little more work to lay that out and put that together from a staff level work and from the AECOM work. So I do want to be cautious because I don't want to commit to the timeline with the changes that says, okay, we can meet those and then we don't. So to be cautious, I would add some time to this and add some additional cost to it.
1:48:32 Just to clarify, though, they haven't already done any legwork on the California resorts, right? That was just presumed in the work program. Right. Actually, I would guess because I think this is a group that's out of Oakland? Sacramento. They probably have data. They've done this work before. Okay. And is it safe to assume we're talking Tahoe and Big Bear?
1:48:55 I certainly appreciate the need to move this forward quickly. I want to have these developers that are looking to be able to finish their pro formas, but for me, I'd rather see.
1:49:20 Let's do a thorough analysis and have this done right if that means pushing it out a couple of weeks and adding, you know, a little bit more to the contingency. I'd prefer to go that direction. Are you ready to make a motion? I have no idea how to craft this motion. Can I summarize what I think? Sure. What I'm hearing would be the idea would be to approve the agreement with AECOM to move forward with the modifications to the work program, including looking at the additional resorts.
1:49:53 And then our request would be is probably to add a month to the timeline and additional 10,000 in contingency to the 50,000.
1:50:23 So moved. Classification. When you're adding peer resorts, I think we've got a limit. A couple. Yeah. A couple. Yeah. I mean, okay. Yeah, because it's good. You could go on and have, right, you know, multiple. And we had discussion about the nature of the scope of that investigation, that analysis. It's not. I don't understand. Okay. I would just urge, I would just. Well, before we go too far, can we get a second? Yeah. I'll second it. Thank you.
1:50:52 Okay, go ahead, Michael. I would just like to urge that time is of the essence and not to drag this on and make, you know, two weeks or three, turn into three months. Yeah, maybe for the extra $10,000 they can go a little quicker. Yeah, that's a nice bump. There's always incentives out there. Yes. And Jen and Sandra will drive this bus and so they'll get it done on time under budget.
1:51:22 No vacation. Okay, so we have motion of a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to policy matter number 9, update and direction regarding single family transient rental work program. Thank you. Before I start my presentation, I'd like to...
1:51:51 Reintroduce Shireen Sanders to you. She was the TOT Enforcement Officer and now she's a Code Compliance Officer. So she's moving over to Community and Economic Development Department, but she's here tonight in her former role as TOT Enforcement. She'll be providing some background data on some of the items that I have in my report. So thank you. Welcome, Shireen. Thank you.
1:52:16 So on December 17, 2014, the council directed staff to move forward with a work program to study changes to existing regulations and provide data regarding transient rentals and the town's TNT enforcement program. Tonight we would like to provide an update on the progress of steps one through three of that work program. And I wanted to ask the council if you would prefer for me to present all three, my information on all three items, and then take comments and discussion or go...
1:52:45 Through each one separately. That's a pleasure. Go for it. Okay. Thank you. Step one of the work program was to examine quality of life issues related to transient rentals. We researched four comparison ordinances and found that they have similar regulations, and those regulations included requirements for trash removal, noise, snow removal, parking, as well as 24-hour point of contact.
1:53:13 Of the four comparison ordinance that we reviewed, we found that the recently adopted Mono County ordinance was a good model, and it included a lot of the provisions that the town would likely include in our quality of life ordinance. We provided a copy of the Mono County regulations as attachment two of your staff report, and if the council provides direction to move forward with our quality of life ordinance, we would likely use the Mono County ordinance as a starting point and include other pertinent information from other comparison documents as we move through the process.
1:53:43 Step two of our work program involved collecting data related to transient rentals in town. We've collected a fair amount of the data requested. However, there are instances where we may not have all the data requested due to incomplete responses from remitters or issues with our current financial software. The first item that was requested by the council was the total number and locations of units in town with TOT certificates.
1:54:10 We reviewed our most recent data and found that we have 4,830 current TOT certificates, which are under 591 business tax certificates. We're working to put that information into our current software, and then we can provide more information on the locations of all of those TOT certificates. The next item that Council requested was rental statistics of current remitters, current single-family home remitters.
1:54:37 We did provide the rental statistics of our nine licensed single family remitters and found that they were rented on an average of six days per month and an average daily rate of $550. That is out of only nine, so it's a small group. We aren't able to provide the rental statistics for all TOT remitters at this time, but when we have our new financial software, we will be able to provide that information to the council.
1:55:04 The Council did also request information on the total number of single family homes or like product in rentable zones. For the purposes of this discussion, we've defined a single family home as a detached structure, sits on its own lot, does not share a wall with any other unit, and has a lot large enough to accommodate parking both within a garage if a garage is included and or outside of a garage. All other types of single family homes.
1:55:30 Housing, such as Stonegate, is considered like product, like a single family home. We found that we currently have nine single family homes, as I stated, that have TOT certificates out of a total of 74 homes within zones that allow single family transient rental. We also have 76 lots that could be improved with a single family home, which could be rented on a transient basis. We've reviewed the data for our like product.
1:55:56 And we found that there are 11 TOT certificates for units, which include units in Stonegate, Mammoth Gateway, et cetera. In addition to those numbers, there are approximately 121 cabins in the Lakes Basin and surrounding areas that are available for rent, either on a seasonal or year-round basis. The final item in the data collection piece was statistics for single-family home rentals. I apologize that the actual statistics were left out of the report inadvertently.
1:56:26 But we did find that based on 42 assessments that we've performed of illegal zoned properties, they were rented on an average of 12 nights per month with an average daily rate of $960. So almost double of what the legal single family homes are rented for. And please note these numbers are generated based on assumptions included in the assessments that the town prepared. And each assessment for each property is for a specific time period.
1:56:56 So they vary for each property. So as no two assessments include the same exact date range, we would want to consider this data anecdotal. The final step of the work program was to analyze our current TOT enforcement program reporting and how it would change if there was an expansion to allow single-family transient rentals. Because we're currently transitioning to our new financial software,
1:57:22 It's assumed that the amount of staff time dedicated to processing TOT returns is going to go down due to the automation incorporated in the new financial software. And based on discussions with our finance department staff, we anticipate the addition of new TOT certificates would result in a somewhat proportional reduction in the enforcement efforts as legal rentals take much less time to process than enforcement of illegal rentals.
1:57:51 As this point is difficult to predict the exact staffing needs, I'm sorry, at this point it's difficult to predict the exact staffing needs of the Revenue Collection Enforcement Program until our financial software is implemented. I think once we have that financial software implemented we can really take a better look at it and see how much time we're saving and how many staff we would actually need for that. The financial software system will also assist our town in item 3.
1:58:19 B, which is to create a monitoring reporting program to accurately capture TOT revenue. And the finance department is continuing to work to collect our baseline data, which would be more easily maintained through the new software. As stated in your staff report, the finance department is going to be providing a presentation to council on the TOT process, how someone gets a permit, how they go through that process, and it will be this summer, likely.
1:58:48 As I stated previously, we've proposed that the definition of a single-family home, I already stated that, and that's a proposal. Council can make comments or change as needed. And finally, we are continuing to work with the Town Attorney and the League of California Cities regarding enforcement of TOT requirements of the VRBO, Airbnb, and other similar rental companies.
1:59:13 So at this time we're asking Council to review the status update on single family transit rental work program and provide direction as needed. And this may include direction to move forward with a quality of life ordinance as indicated in step one of the work program. And that concludes my report and I'm available for any questions that you have. Okay. Let's start with questions of Sandra. John. I want to just open by...
1:59:41 Reiterating, I think, what Mayor Bacon said at the beginning of this, that we are not, this item, just to mitigate any public confusion, we are not talking about anything to do with changing any ordinances, correct? We're talking about an enforcement program for, I don't want to put words in your mouth. Well, we may, well, we have the option to say go forward with the quality of the appointment.
2:00:05 Exactly. But that has nothing to do with changing zoning. And I think it's important for the public to understand that my reading of the Council's priority to do this was to take on these kinds of issues. We have to have good data. We have to have an inventory of what we can do. We've got to have good enforcement. These are necessary steps that have to be taken.
2:00:26 You know, what happens with zoning and that kind of stuff. This is work that it's our obligation to do. And I think we're doing it. I want to make sure that's clear to everybody. So a couple of things. In terms of the data, kind of the data part of this, I appreciate how important the new software is to this. And I think it's, for meeting a staff report, we should not underestimate how important that new software is going to be to the success of this program. Is that fair to say? Yes. Okay.
2:00:56 I'm wondering if you could give an idea of hard data that I'm assuming is kind of GIS related in terms of units that are available for rental. Are we closing in on getting hard numbers for that or do you still have some more work to do for that? I think that that's what we were getting through the business tax certificate process and I think we would be working towards a GIS based system that would show us where the rentals are occurring.
2:01:26 What types of rentals they are? I don't know, Shereen, if you want to add on to that? Yeah, so currently with the software that we have, we have the capability when we get the business tax certificate renewals for TOT certificates broken out by unit. It's only just in this current renewal process that we have asked every single business tax certificate holder to
2:01:55 Delineate each unit, and then we're going to be entering that into the software system and then be able to separate that as far as how many units we have in town that are actually licensed. As far as whether they're, if they're not licensed, they don't have a business tax certificate, we're not capturing that at this point. Okay, because I think we're going to need that data. Yes. I think we're going to need to know, I think there's an issue about
2:02:21 In a condo situation where maybe it only had one ID number but there might have been 10 or 15 units they could rent, I mean, that's the kind of foundational basic data that I think we need going forward. So I would encourage you to keep moving forward with that kind of discovery. And I'm wondering if we could get a little bit of an update if you have one, maybe Dan or Andy up at the League of Cities stuff. And I go back to, you know, I'm following this, I'm tracking this and what I read on a daily basis.
2:02:54 You know, this is just moving every week, every day. There's another, Washington, D.C., I think, in Chicago had all, you know, they're making, they're now making deals with Airbnb and VRBO to remit taxes and things like that. I was wondering if you guys have any of an update on this stuff. The league had a conference call about how to deal with this issue a couple weeks ago, I think it was, and there wasn't anything really concrete that came out of it. Airbnb and VRBO are assuming kind of varying degrees of cooperation.
2:03:23 They are continuing to strike kind of ad hoc deals with big cities. Neither company has shown any real interest, although they say they're interested, in grappling with the issues statewide. So the league is looking at what to do. They're considering trying to find someone to sponsor legislation that would establish some rules that Airbnb and VRBO would simply have to comply with.
2:03:46 But we don't have a resolution yet. Okay. And I've heard that there's stories in, like, the Sacramento papers about some of the challenges that are happening in South Lake Tahoe. And I'm thinking there's got to be some lessons learned coming out of these communities that may help with our quality of life ordinance and those kinds of things. And I'm hoping that you guys are tracking that. Those things can be shared because there may be more information coming out of this stuff that we need to start thinking about integrating into this. I'll be talking to the South Lake Tahoe City Attorney, who I know.
2:04:13 Probably next week about what they're doing and what options they're looking at. Okay. Those are my general questions. So on the quality life issue and the work, the time, is it like a 16-90 day completion or what are we looking at? I think we could bring it back within that time frame. We do have a lot of projects that we're working on in community development and we do have one staff member who's out. Right. So, but we can,
2:04:42 Definitely try to work to bring the quality of life ordinance back quickly. A draft ordinance, at least so the council can provide some comments and we can provide additional background. So, yes. I think you have a pretty good outline. Yeah, we do. Woodrow County has a good outline. So, what's the timeline, so you have that, what's the timeline on the full work program to be completed and brought back? I think we could bring that work program, I mean, we've already started, we've already done a significant amount of work.
2:05:10 I think we could bring that back to you in late summer maybe, mid to late summer. It is, like I said, we're down on staff at this point, but our staff member will be back next month so we can kind of ramp back up and continue working on this at a higher level. So I think it could be, you know, mid to late summer. Thank you. Any other questions? I'd just like to make a comment. I thank you guys, staff, for doing a lot of this work.
2:05:39 It's very helpful. I think we're on the right road to, you know, making informed decisions going forward. So thank you. Okay, so I'll ask if there's anyone in the public that wishes to speak or provide comment to us on this. Sandy Hogan. And actually I want to commend you guys on your program of work and echo John Morris' earlier comments about the TOT enforcement, the staff.
2:06:16 The task force that you have and the importance of filling that other position. And I believe this first step that you're about to take is really key because it was something that was really worrying me and I think it was worrying you, Shields, and also, John, I heard it from both of you that, you know, we were lacking a few teeth in a few places. Our enforcement, when we sent out that card, I loved seeing that. That was a great mailer, but I looked at some of it and I thought, hmm, is that actually in our ordinance?
2:06:45 So I think this is the appropriate time to actually work on the quality of life issue. And I would suggest, I am a property owner in South Lake Tahoe and have been since the 70s. And I am quite familiar with that ordinance and some of the problems because my property managers up there, I don't do short-term rentals. I provide workforce housing. But my property managers do handle a lot of them. And I have heard some of the issues.
2:07:13 That South Lake Tahoe is undergoing. So I like the approach that you're taking to look into different ones and talking to the town attorneys good, talking to the property managers is also very worthwhile because they can tell you, you know, having been in law enforcement, you don't want to overregulate because you drive them underground. You want practical, logical, easy to enforce stuff, easy to track. That's a personal thing.
2:07:43 Okay, just Sandy Hogan. But that does come from my property managers because, boy, they're trying to hew to the letter of the law and what they're seeing is a lot of problems. So I'd be happy to share some of those with you and some names to investigate. I would also suggest that you probably look into communities that are similar to ours because all of the ones that you're looking at, none of them have what we have. And I'll say it again, a great general plan.
2:08:11 With zoning that allows for legal single family home rentals and legal, you know, rentals and areas that are protected, the residential areas. So the only two that I know of that are quite similar, Park City is one, and that would be a good one to look into to see how they deal with the legals and the illegals. And also the other one is Jackson Hole. I'm not familiar with that one as much. But those two would be worth, and there may be others like ours.
2:08:40 But we are very fortunate in that we had some good planning back in the 80s. We have some good zoning, a good general plan. In 2007, it was all updated again. And so comparing some of those, but I definitely agree. I've been very worried about the enforcement part. I do think our TOT task force, we're so far ahead of most communities. And that's what I think you will find out. Even though it seems like we're moving so slowly, we are far ahead of a lot of the others.
2:09:10 Because the other ones, they're just being hit with all of this stuff. And I will give you one little anecdote, and this is only something that kind of was really strange to me. I know that John Urdi had talked to Airbnb about, oh, nine months to a year ago, something like that. And I don't know, I think he may have made them aware of our zoning and some of the issues, whatever. One of my neighbors sent me a list of 141 or 146 Airbnb advertisements in Mammoth Lakes.
2:09:39 And it looked like every one of them was legal. So I don't know if there's a nexus there, but maybe John said, hey, you know, just take on the legal ones for now because we do have this issue right up in front and we are leading in a lot of areas. So you're right. And I do appreciate your comments about this. If I could just ask you a question. When you're making reference to looking at other peer communities, is that specifically around the quality of life?
2:10:07 Issues or what was your... Yeah, in other words, right, I think it's good you're investigating a lot of them and then find out, ask, what are the problems you've run into? Are you driving more people underground or not? In Tahoe, that's what's happening right now. Only because I spent a Father's Day, last Father's Day, driving around Tahoe Keys and let me tell you, there are a lot of underground rentals going on there and they don't know what to do about it. They have other problems with their ordinance. I can, you know, I mean, I can list them.
2:10:37 From my property manager's perspective also. But anyway, just you're on the right track. I totally support it. The task force fill that position. John Morris is right on and Terry. Those are great comments. So I think taking this on at this time is appropriate. I just want to reiterate the value because I know that you and the folks you're working with did a lot of work with inventorying and doing all this kind of stuff and how important it is from the staff perspective, from the town's perspective,
2:11:06 That we up here as a council have a reliable inventory of the resources that you guys are working to track, it's critical that we have that information. And we very much appreciate the efforts of folks in the community to do this kind of work, but ultimately it's got to become, you know, a legal data set that we need to make decisions that it's coming from this effort. Exactly right. And, you know, perhaps we focus too much on the single family home issue because really the sustainable legal revenue that's there.
2:11:35 In the condos that are underreporting and the legal single-family homes that are being rented that are underreporting, when you compare the illegals to the legals, the income, I mean, it should tell you right away, one, we don't have enough business licenses for all those legal ones that we have, and two, they're underreporting. That's sustainable. That's the stuff that will come in year after year after year. So you're suggesting audits. Well, sure.
2:12:00 Yeah. It's money, right? And I hope you appreciate that the work that we're trying to do is exactly to get to these kinds of things. And I do appreciate it. We've got a ways to go to get there, but that's the specific focus of the work that we're doing. I do appreciate it very much. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Cheryl Witherell. I just had a couple questions, Sandra, and I'm sorry I didn't get a chance to ask before this meeting.
2:12:30 But in the example of Mono County alone, and there's a lot of things in here that we've already changed, the 24-hour contact, we've already done some of this groundwork, so this, I agree with you, is a good foundation. But in the end of enforcement itself, and Shereen, this is going to be a big, busy job for you as I read through this packet, but there's no research on consequences and then the enforcement process. So when we're looking at
2:12:59 Coming up with the draft that's going to work for Mammoth. I would encourage there to be some sort of reporting on the process it's going to take for one code compliance officer or the enforcement team to follow up on some of these items. So if there's not a 24-hour contact, what is the consequences? Is there a penalty? Is it simply they're going to pull the license to force them underground? Or can we build teeth into this now, ahead of time?
2:13:24 Especially on the items on the TNT enforcement side that we already know are problematic. So that would be my suggestion. The only other suggestion would be on staff levels for enforcement. And, you know, we did a big plea today from the lodging to get that third person hired. I don't know if the effort would decrease with any changes in this direction, but I think a shift in exactly what you're saying, Michael, a shift to audits. We've talked on the enforcement side.
2:13:55 That that is our next step. We haven't gotten there. We did four, five maybe last year. So I think it's a shift. I think it's a shift in what we're looking at. But I think to build that into the draft now, to really sell this and to be able to know that we're capable and that we're staffed for it will be really important. Thank you. Anyone else?
2:14:22 I feel like I've become the gadfly of the evening. Sorry about that. Two things I wanted to mention, and I haven't had the time to really look through the Mona County ordinance you're using as a base, but off the top of my head, my sense is that when I originally looked at when Mona County was doing it, they have kind of some different issues. They don't have the sort of density issues that Mammoth has and the people interacting so closely together in close spaces that Mammoth does. So when you look at the impacts of the quality of life things,
2:14:52 Just if we could just make sure that, you know, we're taking that into account and maybe addressing some things. I would say things like, you know, I've got a neighbor that developed five, you know, got a house five feet off the property line, and when they're using their hot tub at 2 a.m., you know.
2:15:07 Who you call. And so my second thing was just about our new chief of police, he's left now, but you know, you guys are going to have budget numbers coming through again in June, you know, that sort of thing. The last I knew, our cops are pretty understaffed. So if we're trying to put together some enforcement stuff, the calls that are going to come in for those people in their hot tub at 2 in the morning are going to go to the PD.
2:15:30 So just understand that it will be an implication in terms of staffing and your enforcement if you're serious about being effective about some of the quality of life issues like that. Thank you. Thank you, Kathy. I'll just address Kathy's point about the county not being a perfect comp because of the density. That's one of the reasons why the Big Bear Lake Ordinance is on there. Big Bear has fairly high density and has dealt with a lot of the same issues that I think the Mammoth sees. So we are going to look at that aspect of Big Bear and maybe even talk to the staff down there.
2:16:00 And I think we've had some... Oh, I'm sorry. Yes, okay. Do we have anybody else who wants to comment? Okay, then we can bring it back for deliberation and things. I just want to say to Kathy, I think that I remember... I don't know if there's a decision that's been made yet as to how the enforcement, whether it's a cop or whether it's someone specific to this... Well, I think that's part of the thing that I was going to say needs to come back within this is, yes, who's the neighbor to call?
2:16:30 And I think it's important, again, to reemphasize how we're starting this from the ground. And there's a lot of assumptions flying around out there about maybe what's going on and what we're trying to do. And I hope you appreciate what we're trying to do is really build a foundation to put a credible program together. And I think that we need to be careful that we're going to take it one step at a time. I'd like to see it come back within the 60 to 90 days. I think that...
2:16:57 It's a combination. It's not just the Mono County ordinance because it doesn't talk about noise. It doesn't talk about impact on neighbors and who you're going to call. We may have the equivalent of Ghostbusters. I think that idea of who does the enforcement, it's a 24-7 enforcement and that's not all just Shireen. And then I think that what Cheryl said about the consequences is very important.
2:17:27 You know, because the Mono County one is very much based on safety, which is important, but that's only part of it. We have to know about that impact on the community and the next-door neighbors in the whole place. Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, all this data is readily available. I mean, there's a lot of, you know, Big Bear is a perfect example. They've already went through this process, and they've done all the checks and balances, and I think I look forward to seeing that data.
2:17:57 Any other comments? Are we more or less, I'm just saying, are we hearing consensus to say go forward with the quality of life ordinance? Continue with the work program, yeah. Yeah. You said one comment as you're kind of drafting that, looking through some of these comparisons, I thought it was very peculiar that South Lake Tahoe put in.
2:18:20 An occlusion of a limit on the traffic trip generation of the vacation home rental and that the city requires that vacation home rentals generate no more traffic than typical residential use. I don't think I'm hearing anything of including that in there, but I would strongly suggest we don't. I have no idea how you would regulate that. I also...
2:18:44 Can't ever imagine a scenario where you would call the cops because somebody that owns a home, rents a home long term or in a short term came in and out of the driveway too many times in a day. Exactly. So that would be one I definitely want to throw out as we're pursuing that draft. But I think a lot of the other stuff we're looking at here as far as signage, 24-hour point of contact, safety prevention, trash removal, noise, all those things make sense for us to look at.
2:19:14 I think when we're looking at this issue, which we all recognize is a very complicated issue, we kind of have three different things we're looking at here. We've heard some things regarding TOT enforcement tonight. I think that's really a separate issue here. You know, looking at having a task force that goes out and collects the legal dollars that should be coming to the town is something that we've got to continue to have a priority on.
2:19:44 You know, and I think regardless of any further conversations, you know, as John, you know, you mentioned at the beginning, like we are not looking at any sort of zoning or ordinance change at this point, but just because somebody has a home in a resort zone, I don't believe they should be able to run amok. So I think regardless of any future conversations, we do need to be looking at these quality of life issues in our legally zoned areas.
2:20:12 That would include resort and RMF2 and those type of things. I think regardless, moving this forward in the next 60 to 90 days is something I support. I would just add one thing. I think it would be valuable to us, I think it would be very valuable to the community to have a draft. It's one of those things where we can take all this stuff and put it into a first draft kind of a structure.
2:20:37 A lot of people are spending a lot of time and energy on this. I think it would be useful to have something we can get out to the public that we can look at to start really developing something to... So John is saying to circulate a draft widely. Yeah. Yeah. Have a draft ready. I know you've got a lot of things on your plate, but... I was going to say the work program shows us going to Planning and Economic Development Commission before coming to Council. Yeah. So that would also... That's it. Have something we get out to folks, people start reading it, beating it up, and see what they like, what they don't like.
2:21:05 So are we making a motion on that? I don't know that we didn't really need a motion, right? You just want a direction? Or do you want a motion? I don't think we need a motion. I think consensus is fine. Yeah, I don't think a motion is required. Yeah. I think we're okay with just consensus. Okay. That takes us on to your financial adjustments, number 10. And for the benefit of everyone, we were given an additional sheet that I presume Dan is going to explain.
2:21:37 Yes, Madam Mayor, the budget information basically tears off through the last discussion. If you recall, we were really looking at potentially some larger drops in revenues than we've actually experienced, so we did back off some already in the proposals. It also allowed us to do a lot of work through here without really impacting the current operations and still end up with some savings, some adjustments accordingly.
2:22:06 So in Muster's particular questions, I wasn't going to walk through each line item adjustment. I think it gets us where we need to be, and even if we end up doing a little better in revenue, those are dollars that you can allocate into other areas at the end of the year, obviously. I know we'll have some additional expenditures coming up and some other elements that we'll have to work through as we walk through that.
2:22:28 Cindy, my role, our finance manager, is joining me as well with this particular detail and some of the light items. She may have more information than I do. The other handout that I did provide really ties back to the sections of staff report that walked through a lot of our fund balance structure. One of the questions from the last meeting asked,
2:22:48 How do we track or where is like the reserve for economic uncertainty numbers? And so what the sheet does is kind of walk through a series of fund balance sections, and I don't need to walk through every one of these. I'll go to sleep in the process. But I just kind of give you a feel for this. When you look at the sheet, you'll see like the general fund, and that's an 01 number, and each of the numbers relate to a fund.
2:23:13 As you go down through that, you'll see on the bottom down there, there's a committed REU number, just over $3 million. That's what that reserve for economic uncertainty is that would be sitting in there. The unassigned $85,747 actually at the beginning of the year when we brought this forward, part of that was allocated into the general fund for uses in the current year, both contingency and some carryover expenditures. And so each of these fund balances, we go through the audit numbers and stuff, will be called out and they're
2:23:43 Different reserve levels, there's different commitments. Some of those are committed more by policy than by legal restriction. Others have a legal restriction to what that money can be spent on. And so both of those elements work through that. And the adjustments for the year we wanted to touch on, and I may have Cindy touch this a little bit, was I believe a couple years ago we wrote off some loans between the airport and the general fund. Yes, like over $3 million.
2:24:13 Over $3 million that we wrote off for the airport. Right, but that's number four on the resolution? Correct. So what we didn't do is write off the interest that was associated with those. So we've been carrying that in our fund balance as it's receivable that, frankly, unless the general fund wants to give the money to the airport to pay us back, we'll probably never receive that interest in a reasonable time frame to consider it a true loan.
2:24:40 So we're making some adjustments that way to try to clean up our fund balances. I think as we go through this each year, and we just saw this recently in our discussions with Standard & Poor's, who does an annual review of our debt, trying to walk through the fund balances the way some of the reporting is and some of the detail was a little cumbersome for them, and then Cindy provided some additional information back to them, which I think helped move our rating up that notch. We went from the BBB minus to the BBB, so that was a nice move.
2:25:09 From that perspective. So a lot of, I can speak to any of the detail in here, but I just wanted to kind of highlight that, that a lot of things we're trying to do, it builds off of some past actions Council's taken, but to clean up our fund balance so it actually presents, I think, a more accurate picture of what our status is, is the town. Also make sure the Council's aware, the dollars are aware. And then the only other one I wanted to highlight, and then I'll open for questions, was
2:25:33 The back side of the sheet shows other fund balances, and for example, Fund 210, which is our gas tax fund, that has both general fund dollars that go in and gas tax dollars come together. Gas tax funds, to the extent they're sitting there, are restricted in their use. But we have a $340,000 assigned fund balance. That includes, for example, $150,000 for the ice rink. It includes $75,000 for the Waterford Bridge, which has been used for the bridge.
2:26:01 And then $115,000 in contingency dollars for capital projects. We often came forward, we had awarded a capital project with a 5% or 10% contingency, but those contingency dollars weren't necessarily identified or allocated, so that's a little problematic in terms of sort of the process. So we put in some things, I think, that help us address that. It makes our financial position stronger. Again, that was recognized by S&P. And I think it allows for
2:26:30 The diversification of the town's funds and stuff and how we're working through these to make us have a much stronger financial footing than just focusing on the general fund REU or just one particular piece of that. So I can walk through the details. Cindy has a lot more of the background on some of the history and some of this than what I have. So if you have questions, either a particular item in the resolution or on the particular light item amendments and or
2:26:58 This fund balance overview sheet, I'd be glad to address those or have Cindy address the detail. Okay, any questions? Probably more questions. Okay. Any comments from the dwindling public audience? Okay. Told you they'd go to sleep. Yes, then we'll bring it back for discussion and or a motion. Madam Mayor, make a motion to Council adopt the resolution.
2:27:25 Amending the Town of Mammoth Lakes fiscal year 14-15 budget and providing for payment of certain interfund loans and write-off of uncollected deferred revenues. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0, which takes us to item number 11.
2:27:52 Richie is accepting the Mammoth Lake, the Lakes Basin Special Study. Yes, Madam Mayor, this item is coming to you via Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I heard the item a week ago, approximately, in terms of looking at the three kind of, we ended up looking at the primary focus on two documents with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, what dealt with the executive summary from the lab's work and then the community
2:28:21 Comments and restatement based on the community comments that came in. And then staff is also recommending you consider acceptance of the, like Mary Loop Road, the multimodal transportation concept alternative study that was done. A lot of that work really ends up feeding into the work that we're doing around that area through the Sarbanes Grant. And so it's a nice tearing off and building off of past work leading into future work, hopefully leading into future projects that benefit the basin area.
2:28:50 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:29:19 Add additional information and same with Grady Dutton joining me here in terms of there's information there as well. Any questions? I'll just add on that Mammoth Lakes Recreation did make this recommendation as in reference and informational documents. Yes. Yes. So is anyone, I don't know that anyone was planning to speak to that, but do we just want to go directly into deliberation here? There's no public comments. Yeah.
2:29:53 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Deliberation, if that's your pleasure. Well, I have a comment for deliberation. Yeah. Go ahead. Oh, go ahead. Go ahead. Okay, so I appreciate what? I said you're keeping this up. I'm sorry. I appreciate that MLR focused on the executive summary and the public outreach component for the alternatives.
2:30:20 And I appreciate also the staff has found a kind of a study analysis, not an analysis, kind of a data collection alternative propositional kind of a thing. And it has occurred to me that I was involved in the lab's process, I worked on that, that there is an enormous amount of data. I mean, the big focus of the lab's effort was collecting a lot of data, parking data, traffic data, recreation, all the rest of it.
2:30:48 And I'm wondering if we could consider accepting not just the documents identified here, but all of the deliverables that came out of the project, so that if you find something down the road that's of use, we don't have to be worrying about making a distinction. Well, we didn't accept it back on March 3rd. If we just accepted tonight everything that was produced that was delivered to the town, that might be a more efficient way of dealing with this. I'm just thinking if...
2:31:18 I think there's enough in here that you could infer that any of the appendices were part of it without, but I'm just wondering that, yeah. I am looking at like a traffic study, parking counts, traffic study, turning movement counts, all this data stuff. It's all part of this, right? It's part of the appendices and other pieces to it. And then if we get to the point of having to do any kind of a CEQA or NEPA, then that.
2:31:45 And all that would be updated. I was going to say from a staff perspective, certainly accepting the labs document, we want you to do that. That would be appreciated moving forward. But when we are working with...
2:32:01 The Sarbanes Consultant, which is in the next item, we are turning over everything we have. I mean, we're telling them this is accepted, this is adopted, but this is base data that we've collected, this is a box full of stuff that we had. We want to make sure that we take advantage of everything that we have out there. So whether or not it's formally accepted by council, we have, you know, we have stuff in the files that, you know, may be even older before that that we use for informing documents, so we want to make sure they have everything. I bet there's even a box about the controversy from, Sandy would remember it, 20 years ago?
2:32:31 I just want to make sure that there's by accepting some things and not addressing other things or not making a distinction in terms of the data and writing. I don't think that's the assumption at all.
2:32:50 I think the comment, if I can come back to clarify from the mayor, was a lot of that data was used and rolled up into these. Okay. So when we get to the detail and we want to go back down, we would go back down to the source data to be able to confirm that. I was assuming if it's referenced, it's there. I think it gives us what we need for working from. Okay. Sorry, I thought you guys were still on the budget when I came back in. But, yes, talking...
2:33:16 You know, these studies are all valuable. And just what Jill was talking about, a little bit of the history behind the Lake Mary Loop. The data, exactly, the file that I know that the Forest Service maintained on that came, a lot of it from a three-year effort in 1998 to almost 2001. And our facilitator was Joby Brown. A lot of people weren't around during that time. She was our public affairs officer in the Indian National Forest as well.
2:33:43 I led that effort. The Forest Service led that effort. And the reason we, people ask, well, why wasn't there a decision? I remember Jessica Morris, when we got all that information to her, why didn't you have a decision? And it was very interesting because Joe referred to the controversy that was going on because to get the stakeholders of the Lakes Basin to the table, we had to promise there would be no decision because they were just sure that the Forest Service
2:34:12 Me, was going to impose a Red's Meadow solution on them whereby no cars would be allowed in the basin and only buses and we charge money and all like that. I mean, you know, Forest Service is always accused of all sorts of things like that. And so it was a great effort because everybody came and we just said, hey, we're going to brainstorm for as long as it takes. And we came up with, like, I think in that file's 27 or 29 options to solve some of the problems of the Lakes Basin. One of the most fearful things was transit.
2:34:41 We do not want a bus up there. No, no, no. You know, and it's amazing looking back now because you have to talk about these things and explore the options and actually one of my rules I think that Jovi came up with was if you're against it, you've got to explain it.
2:34:57 Each alternative that came up, but it was really kind of a fun thing. And Bill Taylor from the town was one of our main supports. The town provided us with vans to take people up. We did walks all around Lake Mary, you know, looking at all these alternatives. And so when you see a document like this one, I was really thrilled to see it finally because I had been asking Peter for a couple of years, where is this? I think that second document is funded by Sarbanes because we put in for two, Sarbanes.
2:35:24 Had two major deliverables. One was the Lake Mary Loop study, which I knew there was no way the forester was going to take on, NEPO-wise, but this was a great alternative. And the other, of course, was the construction of the bike path. But when you look back, you know, 15 years back, and you see we've got buses running up there, the permatees are thrown, the traffic counts probably are less now than they were then because
2:35:49 Whoever was our Public Works Director at the time, he got traffic counts for us too. That's all in that data. It's really wonderful to see little pieces of those ideas, including the Lakes Basin Path, all the pieces of that, and now going up probably to Lake George, and looking at this document actually lays out some alternatives for analysis. And as other little pieces are finished, some of those kind of go by the wayside. So it's really nice to see.
2:36:18 From somebody who's been here for a while and, you know, kind of went through those controversies and we had a group of, some of them were pretty outspoken, but at the end, you know, everybody was really kind of thrilled, walking around, just talking because we weren't going to force anything on. So that's why there were no decisions in those days, just for history. All right, thank you. Any other public comment on this item? Okay, then we're back for discussion or a motion.
2:36:50 I'll make a motion to accept the Lakes Basin Special Study Executive Summary and Final Reports as reference and informational documents. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0, which takes us on to item 12, which is an update regarding proposed
2:37:17 Projects on the Lakes Basin and authorized the Mayor to sign a letter and I want to point out that we have a revised draft letter to consider. This is Grady. Thank you. Yes, the action we're requesting tonight is that you review that updated letter and consider asking the Mayor to sign that and send it on to the Forest Service. They've basically done their beginning NEPA process for this work up in the Lakes Basin.
2:37:46 We anticipated that this would occur when we started the Sarbanes work, the Sarbanes study, which I've updated you on before, but I'll give another one tonight, that deals with the first part of the path from Lake Mary Road to Lake George Road and, frankly, the Around Lake Mary study. I wouldn't say complicated, but what they were able to cover in addition to that is due to the fact that we now have a
2:38:12 Special Use Permit that gives us the opportunity, authorization, to maintain the roads in the Lakes Basin, not the obligation. And we're talking about the second part of the path, and we're talking about Lake George Road. What the Forest Service has done is lump some of that together in that NEPA process, which is appropriate, but this is our opportunity to comment. I want to go ahead and go through the three pieces. First, the lab study, which we just covered. I won't go into any more detail on that. Second is the Sarbanes Grant.
2:38:41 And again, some time ago we got a grant for over $1.2 million, one which bought a trolley and some additional stuff up there. The second part was to do the Around Lake Mary Loop Road study, which is, again, informed by the previous lab's work and the other planning document that was prepared mostly by town staff that followed up on that. In the NEPA document, however, is that first part of the path from Lake Mary Road to Lake George Road.
2:39:08 As I reported before, everybody is pretty satisfied with the alignment for that. There are still certainly some things to work out about the nodes, about the potential conflicts with the other users up there because those of you who have been up there during the summer and winter, frankly, but especially the summer, there's equestrians, there's mountain bikes, there's bicycles, there's pedestrians, there's everybody. Staff right now is actually reviewing.
2:39:31 We finished our review of the 30% drawings, and they're updating those to give us a new set. We've already identified some of those conflicts, and they're working on them. We pointed out signs as necessary. So again, that's preliminary drawings. The second part of the surveillance grant, though, or the next part, is actually what was supposed to be a conceptual look or the preliminary drawings from Lake George Road up to Lake George.
2:39:54 And very frankly, until about three or four weeks ago, we didn't know what the alignment was going to be either. We're frankly, we were cooperating with the Forest Service in getting this Sarbanes grant, and it was a great thing to do. And we are certainly the tool by which we will get this thing built. But in terms of the actual alignment, very frankly, it's a Forest Service alignment, and we actually have had some comments ourselves about where it should go and when and how it should link back in. We're in the middle of those discussions now.
2:40:21 So now is the appropriate time to make comment on that. So that's the first part of the NEPA process. The second, and I'll update you on the special use permit and the flat grant application. We did submit the application on time. We're not going to hear back for another 45 days. We anticipate. They did not have any specific questions about our application. They said it was complete and they accepted it.
2:40:45 With the exception that about a week afterwards they called us with one thing and started asking Jamie Robertson questions about San Francisco Bay. And they had mixed up some paperwork and were going to toss ours because it said they had mixed it up with San Francisco Bay. So we fixed them on that and they're back. We're back on track. We still have no indication of whether they're going to approve it or not. But one thing I will mention again is that in that process, if we do get shortlisted, the first thing we'll do within 15 days of getting notified,
2:41:15 We'll be required to basically sign an agreement with them whereby we will spend up to $10,000 reimbursed by them to enhance that study. I didn't think about putting that in the agenda sheet tonight, but I want to let you know that if we get notified, we'll have 15 days to do so. I don't think we need authorization to sign a reimbursement agreement such as that, but just so you're well aware of that. The special use permit itself, there's a copy of it in your packet.
2:41:44 It states that it will expire within one year if the town no longer needs the roads for any reason, and that was intended to state that if we didn't get this grant, we don't need the special use permit, we don't need to be authorized to maintain the roads in the Lakes Basin. Having said that, if at the end of that year we don't get the grant, and there are ongoing discussions, and council has some reason to support us continuing on with the special use permit with modified language,
2:42:10 We can talk about it, but right now it's actually set to expire in one year if we don't tell them we need the roads. That was the intent. No financial obligation from the town. If we do get the grant and if we do say yes, we'll move forward with projects to maintain a portion of the road, such as rebuilding Lake George Road, then it would be extended for a minimum of 10 years over the life of that project. And again, I want to reemphasize that there's no obligation on the town to do so.
2:42:38 Opening paragraph of that special use permit states authorizes the town to do the work. The basis for the framework for that agreement was a typical one that Forest Service does for mining and logging whereby somebody's going to have a mine up on Forest Service land and if they damage into the roads on the way in they're required to fix it. That was sort of the framework. So if by some chance while we're doing a construction project we cause damage.
2:43:04 Certainly we have to fix that, but we put that on our contractor. Other than that, there's no obligation on the town's behalf to do so. They did, however, the Forest Service did include that comment that we would be, you know, authorized to maintain eight and a half miles or so of roads in the NEPA document, so that's out there. They also put the first half of the path and they also included the second half of the path in that NEPA document. We've provided a draft letter.
2:43:32 After meeting with our own staff, with MLR's MLTS subcommittee, just asking others that have been involved in this area, we talked to the groomer out at Tamarack as well, got some good information from him, and we think this letter is an appropriate level, if you will, to send to the Forest Service. It doesn't get into excruciating detail about every connection point. It basically says we want to continue to work with you to refine it and lays out some of the important background documents.
2:44:03 Okay. Questions of Grady? No questions, just a quick comment. I think it's great that you have a lot of options in there. We talked about this a little bit before. There was a little bit of concern not tying us financially or obligating us. So I think you did a great job in cleaning that up. Just want to say thanks for doing that. Okay. So I'll ask if there's any public comment. Okay.
2:44:37 Seeing none, bring it back. We do have, I think we'll start with John since I'm sure he'll have the most comments, but we do need to decide which version of number 8 on page 3 we want to submit. I mean, Mayor, the other modifications are what's been underlined in the letter. Correct. They're not intended to be submitted as an underlined. Those are the real lining of what's been added. Yes. He just wanted to show you what was changed, so clarify that. Well, thank you, Madam Mayor. I think
2:45:08 I appreciate the opportunity to kind of go first. Grady's done some important things in the staff report. The first time we saw this, we were talking about the FLAP grant. I've had an opportunity to work with Dan and Grady at length, clarify a lot of issues, and what you're seeing presented to you are three different things. Opportunities for construction, going to Lake George, things happening around Lake Mary Road. They're all sort of intertwined.
2:45:37 I have confidence that in our staff that they have a handle on this and they kind of understand what we're doing here. So I'm significantly reassured about that. In terms of this letter, I want to point out something I think which is very interesting, which is on the first page in italics, there's something that says recreation and there's some text there in recreation. Dan and Grady have started to kind of look at the
2:46:03 The documents that are the binding documents of our district range, our district, which is from the existing current Indian National Forest Plan from 1988. And I really appreciate the fact that they're looking at the language that is used to inform his decisions and tiering what we're doing here to these kind of larger things that he's bound to be working from. And this to me indicates kind of a larger picture of the opportunities in the lakes basin and how we're going to get involved with that.
2:46:31 So I think it makes sense to be moving forward. I think also that we had a Mammoth Trails meeting on Monday where some folks had a chance to show up. There'll be another meeting before the NEPA comments are due. They'll probably take these comments from the town and then get into that kind of that excruciating detail that Dan was talking about. I'm meeting with Ron Cohen and Roy Moyer on Thursday.
2:46:54 Because there are significant issues with TAMRAC and winter operations to get them aware so they can provide their own comets. And my understanding of how the Forest Service looks at comets in these kinds of projects is a diversity and unique sets of comets. So we don't have to get everything into this letter. I think that these are appropriate. We've got a decision to make about that Lake George Connector going up to Lake George. I think the idea that if we're going to be supporting building something up to Lake George and staff has identified the need,
2:47:24 To analyze and mitigate the soft surface trail opportunities around Lake George, which right now we're in pretty bad disrepair and need a lot of work, that this is a way that we can maybe move this thing forward to start getting some improvements on the ground with that kind of stuff. And I support that strategy. I'm glad that they pointed that out and added this to the letter.
2:47:44 And so I would just, I look forward to your discussions and your thoughts and would just add that again there's a Mammoth Trails meeting. If you're interested for whatever reasons happening next Friday on the 13th, the comments are due on the 17th, but if you want to be involved in that process, you get a particular concern that maybe isn't reflected here, there are going to be multiple opportunities for a lot of people to provide input into this process.
2:48:08 I was initially concerned because this is a very big thing that we might be starting to get involved with up there, and I think we need to make sure that we understand that we know what we're doing. There are issues about ownership. There are issues about maintenance and this whole thing about roads, and maybe there's issues about, well, who does own that lakes basin path? Is it a town or is it a forest service facility? These are things that we have to get nailed down going forward, and if we're going to start taking those things on,
2:48:34 I'm confident that Grady and Dan appreciate these matters and these issues and that as we go forward, they're going to keep a surprise of that. So I'm feeling pretty good about this. Okay. Any other general comments before we deal with number eight? I just wanted to kind of echo Michael's comments. I mean, having staff come back to us as we requested and have the follow-up be exactly what was requested is really...
2:49:02 A nice thing to see. And, you know, I think it gives us a lot of confidence moving forward that, you know, you guys are taking care of things and that it's in good hands. So, you know, I really appreciate, as, you know, we've all alluded, there were some concerns because that kind of was pretty much fast-tracked towards us. And so to have this, you know, come back and have this second crack at it and to have it, you know, be nailed down to the degree that we asked is really encouraging.
2:49:32 So, thank you. Any other general comments? Okay. I think we mentioned this at the last meeting, but John and I met with staff, and at that point in time, there was a concern, which is why there's two versions of number eight here, one of which says we'll work together, and the other one is not put it in at all. So, and John, that was your concern that you had raised, so I just wanted to get your input on whether or not eight should read as it is written or if it should read as the bold part.
2:50:04 I'm comfortable moving forward with the understanding that we have to be very actively engaged with this. And I'm confident that staff appreciates what that means. I'm confident that the other stakeholders, TAMRAC and other folks, need to show up and be participating in this as well. So for doing the NEPA, the environmental analysis, which is, you know, all we're doing now is providing comments on the letter.
2:50:33 I feel confident moving forward with that. I think that there are more opportunities moving forward than not. I was concerned previously because I didn't see how staff appreciate the whole big picture. I feel better about it now. So you're saying non-bolded? Non-bolded version. As recommended, right? Yeah. May I make a motion that Town Council authorize the mayor to sign a letter in response to and in support.
2:51:01 Vino National Forest, seeking comments on the proposed Mammoth Lakes Basin Bike Path Construction Project, United States Forest Service, NEPA Process. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And with that, we will adjourn to our next meeting on Wednesday, March 18th. Thank you.
2:51:31 Nicely done. Nicely done.