TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2015

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 36 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

246 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

40:32 Jennifer's helping me with this next project with our 45 packet. We'll be looking within rent and mortgage reduction, which are tenant-based rental assistance, rental restrictions, slash regulatory agreements, and resale restrictions. So it might barely take a look. And Jen does have one more color to talk to anybody who's having trouble with the paper one. And on top of the blue, we kind of came out hard to read.

41:18 I think that Halsey had a discussion. I'm not sure. Are we talking about seeing us now? Identifying priority? Yes. I think Halsey has just all the actions. There's only one action that are basically under the client strategy. Now, if an opportunity and a developer comes forward with an opportunity to utilize one of these strategies, we don't want to say, I'm sorry, that's 20 under priority.

41:46 You know, we think we need to juggle all of those, and that's the direction that we get in our staff, is that, look, all of these are viable strategies, and we want them, or actions that we want to implement. So we have, I think there's five of them in there on pursuing grants. We want staff to work with the town staff to pursue all the grants.

42:07 And if it means working outside the area with the county or with IMAGA or wherever it happens to be, we want all those opportunities on the table because, you know, they're just an opportunity to address the issue. And, Kirk, we will get there, but I want to make sure that everybody understands what's in each toolbox before they're saying this. Do you want to be offered anyone? No, that was high level. Okay. That was high level. Are there any questions on those three?

42:39 So we're talking about ownership. Is this on?

43:07 Is this holding on the lower end of the ownership, or is this across the board? If you go to page 42, which is page 42 in a packet, you'll see that there's, first-time help writer has five different pieces. And the AMIs are called out, and they're telling me more with some of them. Yeah. Well, it's a hundred percent. Well, some definitions go higher. Right.

43:36 And we're not going to go through and read every single one of them at their levels. I'm curious if you guys are going to look at this ahead of time. I just want to make sure that we have questions before we go back and say how do we approach this. This is mine. Okay. It's based on it. It says household stay in our community. We're going to be specific, you should say, in that place. You're looking at 1A? Correct. No, it's not mine. No, that's true. That's consistent with what I'm talking about.

44:07 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So that I guess we would say that through how we want to make sure that the person comes back to this clearly differentiating when they're talking about work that will be done inside of the town limits and recognizing that there are also other issues outside of the town limits. There's opportunities. Yeah. And opportunities. Maybe we need a definition. I think they will do it through English well enough to do that.

44:35 Okay. And one, just a general question. These five aren't prioritized within themselves, right? No. None is yet prioritized. Right. We're still building some toolboxes. Yeah, understood. And as you well know from being on LTCs, we didn't have a priority, but if the money comes in for number four, it's $100. Understood. Yeah. Understood. The third piece is the development home and care program, which is on page 24.5, which is through the packet.

45:05 There are several owner-occupied rehab programs, investment rehab programs, acquisition of rehab, and weatherization. Number four on the continuum is to increase affordable housing stock and equity to eight-year event pick-out today, which is on page 48 or 226.

45:43 It includes the housing mitigation ordinance, acquisition employment, construction of new homes, development of the shared risk parcel, support shared equity development opportunities, funding, and development of a workforce housing trust, town resource, and public resource, and home fire education. So we should have increased workforce right now. Sorry, I switched over to inform already.

46:14 Pass the section? No, no, no. On number four? I guess that's a question to have staff work out is at this point are we talking all workforce or are we talking affordable rather than us getting to those speeds? I think it's workforce. I also, I don't think it's increased. I think it's usually existing. It's stock. We have a lot of existing. So I don't know if, you know, probably. Well, oh, okay.

46:41 And some of the things that are under there, so you're just wondering whether or not the title for that strategy really defines the pieces that are under it? Again, I go back to the semantic thing. It would be helpful as we're looking at where to focus energies. If staff could, whoever's doing this, maybe ripple through these things and assign whether it's affordable or workplace. We don't want any semantic kinds of challenges. Yeah, some of these are affordable, some of them are not. Yeah. Yeah. So maybe it does need to be a workforce. We'll let you guys see.

47:12 You can grab that detail. Isn't it leading with what all of your programs to be affordable to workers? Correct. But that's the language. Yeah. Yeah. So I get it in the title, but I can say overall. Correct. Yeah. Correct. Okay. And then I'm sorry, I started to read the reach out and the forum starts on the page where you mentioned 50, which says town resource, public resource, home fire, education classes, current housing work, and social media. Any questions?

47:53 Okay, before we go back and start to talk about any priority of actions out of this nice box of tools or overlapping boxes of tools, is there any public comment just on the definition or the answer included before we go back in my detail? Yeah.

48:21 Thank you.

48:59 The deficit of housing, new impacts, and then if the public health comes in, they're supposed to mitigate the new impact. And so the housing overlay over shitty rest is for our deficit in housing. So just to keep that on the table. You know, we can't even look at the fees and everything else. I'll pass. That was $500,000, too.

49:28 I'm not exactly sure what you just said. Hopefully I'm not.

49:57 So the housing need at that time was S. And new development was coming, and we didn't want to charge them for the deficit. So we looked at FTPP, full-time employees, and said we have to do different analysis to look at, okay, when a hotel comes, we don't want them to pay for a hotel like that or a condo project that came in five years earlier.

50:27 So Mammoth Lakes Housing is the deficit, trying to go back and look at all the housing mitigation that we never bothered to address, partly because we didn't recognize it, or we didn't put it on the table. And so something that is coming in now is only paying for their impacts, not past problems. So when we look at past,

50:57 Okay, Snow Creek Floor. Did they pay any housing mitigation? No. So did that create a housing impact? Yes. But the billions did they pay at 80-50? They paid a million dollars on Phase 1. They paid a million dollars on Phase 2. That million dollars was for their impact, not for Snow Creek Floor's impact. So we have past impacts.

51:24 That we've been trying to, a deficit we will, that we're looking at all the different programs. But what we're also looking at is how to reduce the impacts on new development. So one of the things historically you'll put on the table, Mammoth Lake Housing looked at everything below 60% and said the affordability gap and the performance gap is too great.

51:49 So Mayor of Lake Housing has accepted that responsibility and that was taken out of the fee schedule and that's up to us to get grants and everything else to try to meet those needs. Otherwise the burden on new development would be too great because the gap is huge when you start getting down to people that are making 50% of the income. I don't know if that explains it. No, it really doesn't. What I was interested in and what beat my attention

52:18 Was your reference to Shady Rest? Okay. Please explain how the property in Shady Rest is going to be implemented and zoned. How is that going to be implemented as we move forward with new housing element demand on developers?

52:50 Can't use, or say that Shady Rest is maybe their program? No, no, no. I guess I'm not. This is very critical. How are we going to develop Shady Rest? Yes. Is it going to be developed by possibly in lieu of fees of new development? Or is Shady Rest off of the table for a physical...

53:20 Development for new construction. Can I pull you guys back up until you're on an agenda? This is a very, very important, Joe. Very important. And I would indulge the council to really understand what is being said here. The designation also, the overlay is only for low, right? Currently. Up to 120. Up to 120.

53:52 The requirements are that Shady Ranch isn't allowed to be used. And that goes back to the history of the parcel, which, of course, is commissioning that housing was going to be paid out of the trails. And then when the trails shifted to the single family residential marketing, there was a commission with the developer to acquire the Shady Ranch for

54:28 And it was written 10, meaning the town we had at the time, but it still has been a great problem. And when the town council got the litigation regulations and the school of the city was, it was looking forward and recognizing that it wasn't that student-based on the land outside of the city, but even including the city to meet all the future needs.

55:00 I understand. That's all changed. That's ancient history. Yeah, that's right. I'm just trying to get to where we are now. Today, the reason this is reflected in the Senate code says it will not be used for what the council chooses to do with that going forward.

55:35 I understand. So that's a good history thing. That's why it is what it is today. Okay.

56:05 And what we're looking at, what concerns me very much, is we have a parcel of 25 acres that is zoned for affordable housing and workforce housing. It hasn't been utilized in all this time. And I don't know, and it's not clear to me, where the plan is, where the infrastructure is.

56:40 That's going to allow that land to be beneficial in our workforce housing and affordable housing element. And if it's the, what I'm hearing is correct, if it's the code that is not allowing this to happen, then I submit from history that property will probably not be developed.

57:11 In a reasonable amount of time unless there is a purchase of the property and or the property can be controlled by council and used to create affordable housing by new development. This is a very, very critical point. And on the committees that we would sit on many years past,

57:41 We didn't always agree with that situation. And we're faced now with the opportunity of having some more development happen, hopefully, within the near future here in the map there. And yes, you're absolutely right. There's very little land. But we've also found that there is issues, legal issues, with

58:12 Inclusionary Housing. We don't know the outcome of that as of yet, but those particular courts don't necessarily see everything that comes in front of them. So I'm sure there's some validity in getting this thing ferried out. I think the point of making some hard decisions on the council's part is

58:47 Right around the corner as to how this very key element of affordable housing gets addressed.

59:07 So it's a great opportunity and thanks a lot for bringing this up and thanks for the history and I think that

59:38 As we move forward bringing all this stuff together, it's an opportunity we're going to have to look at, you know, inclusionary is kind of on the table. A lot of things are kind of moving around. It's a good thing to be looking at going forward. Okay, so we go back to see if there are any priority actions out of the five different continuance that we counsel input as to...

1:00:05 I'd like to ask a question before we get into that. It's very useful to have this brain trust all sitting around in this nice square configuration.

1:00:34 I'd just like to throw out for discussion for a couple minutes what's missing from all this. Okay. I just, because I appreciate the rigidity reading through these documents, the thoroughness that all this has gone through, and I'm very happy here in this discussion about shady rest, that there's a history, it's documents, codified, we all know what these things are. I'd be just interested in hearing, if you want to talk about now, Madam Mayor, or later, what, you know, what are we missing from all this?

1:01:03 Jill, Jill, one quick on number four.

1:01:33 The affordable housing stock, it was added in our meeting on the 21st about a preference to move away from inclusionary housing towards a fee-based housing mitigation policy.

1:01:45 So are we addressing that at all, or it's already in here? Well, if you look at that one, you notice that the title's been changed from inclusionary zoning to housing mitigation ordinance on page 48 of the document, which is page 56. So it's current based on what we've already talked about. Right. So I apologize, Mayor.

1:02:14 Getting lost in all these age 37, 45, 42. So you did ask the question, is anything missing there? And I might be missing this. Yeah, I might be missing this from another section, but in item four, increase affordable housing stock.

1:02:35 All this to me is acquisition of land, construction of new homes, development of shady rest parts, so it's all new development. I don't see anything called out here about rehab of existing product or higher utilization. That's because it's under the continuum of developed home repair program. Okay. Thank you. All right. Like I said, I'm lost, so I just want to make sure that's there. Okay. Yeah. All right. Thank you.

1:03:03 So, Mayor, yes. And I have had a lengthy conversation with staff about it. In general, I find the strategy somewhat difficult to read, and I've asked them maybe that we could do an executive summary. Part of the reason it's difficult to read is because there's so much data built into it. But the thing that I still cannot do is I cannot take the 10 strategies that were in the element.

1:03:29 We said, okay, our strategy is to include these 10 activities and tie them over to our priority action list. So, I mean, I'm really hoping before you come back, before commission, that there is a direct tie. This is H.2A3, list 10 strategies. I mean, there's some cross, but it's really confusing because you have different categories in your strategies and that was listed in the element.

1:03:59 So, yeah. And more than what's in the table is saying housing element goals policies, like it says H2 and H3 under owner-occupied rehab. Right. Okay. But if you, if you need.

1:04:13 I mean, I can see this. I mean, you just can't track our, I mean, this was our element. This was what we said the strategy needed to include these 10 elements, and you can't track it back, so. Are you asking to have the elements listed as one of the tools to meet that element? There has to be. If we brought an element, and we said, right, that commission approved, that council approved, and said,

1:04:40 Our strategy is going to include these 10 programs. It should be very clear. Okay, so having an in-the-table as the one I just read, code is, code is H2 and H3, isn't enough for you? No, it's not, because we shouldn't have to get all the way to the table to get to the purpose of the strategy. The purpose of the strategy was to address these things. So it should be up front in the executive summary.

1:05:06 So that you're not reading through pages of documents against the table to find out how they correlate. That's my opinion. I would follow up a little bit on that just to, because at Colin's point, you know, I'm looking through objective number three. I'm looking to get something that we can start picking off here to start taking some action on, to start incentivize or do something with to move some of these things forward.

1:05:32 I think as a general comment, having a readability and consumability of this thing is going to be important moving forward. I appreciate the need to kind of put these things together, but I think as it starts coming closer to council to take action on, there are going to be things that are going to be idiosyncratic to our town and our community that are not going to be affordable. They're not going to be down in that area, but they're going to be things that we're going to want to start taking action. Huh? Low income.

1:05:58 Whatever the semantics are, but things that we're going to want to start look, this is appropriate for the council to start engaging with these kinds of things, to start getting things happening, moving, getting some dynamism into the market. I'm particularly interested personally in trying to pull these things out and move forward with those things. So the readability of the document, the efficiency of it is going to be important. Okay, so what we're asking for is the three-dimensional documents and the two dimensions? Yeah, even four dimensions. I don't mind those, but you know.

1:06:29 Okay, this is about comments. Are there any other general comments yet? Trying to figure that out. So I was asking that question. If there's a way to do it, you say, because it is kind of hard to track these. It makes sense to staff that have worked out for certain times, but is there a different way to present them as everything that's in a continuum in a...

1:06:51 Yeah, because while I'm looking at these tables as being the things, if we're looking to things to do, I'm probably most likely to be referencing these tables. So if these, as a strategy comes forward, and I'm not speaking for Mickey's concerns because I'm not entirely clear on those, but if I'm looking at these tables, and I'm looking at the semantics in these tables, the definitions, so we can start taking things out of these things.

1:07:14 Saying, let's get this done, let's get this done, what tools do we have to move forward in some of these things? Well, and that's kind of what I was leading to. So how do you figure out which are the ones that we want to say, figure out how they work? Or can't you just list a cliff note version of 31 different? Yeah. Yeah, maybe organize it to these five things. What things it might need? You hear the 31 different tools, it doesn't matter which one is not one. Correct. Yeah. But so that there's an easier way, because it is,

1:07:44 Yeah, and that's, and that's funny. All the staff work is important to me. All the rationales, I'm glad it's all there, but that's... And I think when you're dealing with constituents and you're saying, I've got a certain kind of a need if there's something that we can point to pretty easily, not directing someone to page 56, but it's here, it's here. Get them to think about how to engender some...

1:08:11 So I'm hearing that there's not going to be any problem with the tools until we've really been able to absorb it. There's no way yet to setting which is a priority action until we can see them all in a USA Today approach. Okay. Let me just quickly, quickly, to number six. What I'm hearing is

1:08:35 There's a desire to address that one, which is on whichever one of these 4A. So I think it would be incorporated in that list of the 31 since it is one of the outcomes that's listed. Then any other comment on what I just said about how to work towards getting to the priorities? Okay. Any comments from our...

1:09:06 Okay, then the other piece that we have a couple minutes to talk about, and it kind of came up, so maybe we need to just quickly do what's in the housing mitigation ordinance update. Well, we will have a draft ordinance by the end of the month, so we don't actually have the move of that ordinance yet, but the structure of that ordinance will include, calculate a toolbox for new developments, maybe housing.

1:09:36 Which will include a method for calculating a fee, what the fee would be for a residential project, commercial project, industrial project, et cetera. And then would also provide the mitigation if the developer chose to do off-site housing, if they chose to do off-site acquisition and rehab, chose to do donation of land. So right now, the direction we give the consultant is to provide kind of this equivalent toolbox of options for developers to select.

1:10:06 So the housing strategy, looking at the dates, the housing strategy will come back to us first while work is still being done, but it's like the first meeting of May and then the second meeting of May will be the housing ordinance in the field as far as don't plan any vacations. Okay, any, yes? Yeah, exactly.

1:10:36 I just wanted to comment about several different issues that have been brought up. First, let me talk about shady arrests because I've heard rumors, you know, well, we shouldn't need a sickness in there and everything else. And I heard Dave over there. First of all, we have to purchase eight acres, whether you're carrying a police facility and those kind of things.

1:10:54 And there's a relationship with the hospital about two acres and everything else. We don't know what's going to happen there. But there is any acres there. And mitigation, you know, that overlay that's on that is for, you know, deficit. And, you know, but...

1:11:12 The developer that owns that is looking for an incredibly high price on it, and so he's looking for much higher than $120 and even higher than $150 if he tries to be able to go forward. So I'm not too sure how I'm going to leave that to you guys to travel through, but I think it's something that we need to at least put on the table, that that drawer needs to be open, and after that discussion needs to just be ongoing. But it's very important, again, that our house housing.

1:11:40 Another thing that has been brought up in the past and just recently has been buying old condos and underutilized assets that we have. The difficulty of trying to get workforce into the old condos is partly is, you know, they're second homes. They're not going to put them on a yearly lease because they want to come up and they can make more money.

1:12:06 By doing weekends and everything else. So it's very difficult. And then you have that livability standard also trying to make sure they have big enough closets and insulation and everything else. So it's difficult that we've looked at that. And I think you have, actually I've heard of a couple of things. What about all this stock that we have out there? And if we have to qualify somebody to go into one of the older units,

1:12:35 And all of a sudden, they only qualify for rent at this level, and the person could go out on the market on a yearly lease and get it much higher, and our runners are going to be able to get in there. So we have a tie in some respects. Well, I'm right in that comment, new construction is so much more expensive than purchasing something that's already existing.

1:13:05 And you're at rehab. And rehabbing. Yeah. And so that's, I think, we're coming from, or at least I am. My daughters are a prime example of the workforce. They're kids, and they work in our community. They bought their first place together. And they paid $175,000 for a place right across the street here. Two-bedroom and a loft. And I think it would fit. I think there's a lot of those out there. We went and did the work.

1:13:34 Found out how many units are out there that they possibly could afford. Mom and Dad did that. When we look at those products out there, we have to look at the reserve sector. And if they get hit with a major assessment because of roads or sightings or asphalt or whatever it has to be, they're not keeping up. And being on a housing board and being at Snow Creek, I get the hint of what proceedings people are.

1:14:04 With associations, some of them are pretty far behind, and they just, they pass that on, and that would be something else that we would have to. You said that, that'd be part of the issue. I think in Home Bio Assistant is the way to get them in there, and the idea of trying to make sure that they, that we have, and for current units, the 70s, 2x4 units, and single-plane glass.

1:14:32 I have a couple of quick questions on what you mentioned or comments, I suppose. I'm not sure I follow exactly that we're taking housing stock away from somebody that would want to use it periodically because we're talking about purchasing a unit that's for sale on the market. So if they put it up for sale on the market, presumably they're looking to sell it and they've already...

1:15:02 Forgone the use of that product. The second thing is there's a lot of terms kind of thrown around out there as far as what type of money people make from renting it on a transient basis versus what type of money people make renting it on a long-term basis. I don't know if this is information that can be provided for us, but I'm not sure that we can make those assumptions that somebody can go out into the market and make...

1:15:30 10x money renting it on a transient basis because I just hear so much contrary information on that fact. So I think that would be helpful information for us as we're framing this discussion. I don't know if that's possible.

1:15:56 But I've had a conversation, for example, with somebody that their home is on the rental program at Snow Creek. And, you know, if they're telling me, well, what I'm clearing on an annual basis is $10,000, that's not a huge amount of money more than you would get if you rented that to a local for 12 months. So I just think that there's a lot of contrary information that's being thrown out. You might be able to get a higher nightly rate, but if you're only getting that for...

1:16:24 12 weekends a year. Right, but if they're selling the unit, then they don't get to use it, period. So if Mammoth Lakes Housing comes in and buys a unit that's on the market and rehabs it and puts locals in housing, we're talking about two completely different things here.

1:16:52 And I think that that's a growing, this is the kind of sort of improvisational conversation that I'm hearing on council, which is from a high level, is that, and I again appreciate sort of the rigidity of all the work, the staff work and the analysis on the data, at some point it's not just sort of objective abstract stuff, at some point it lands in Mammoth Lakes.

1:17:22 And at some point it lands in the realities that we have with our housing stock. And I think we've talked a little bit about how, you know, maybe opening up your mission a little bit or getting to things and start getting into the specific idiosyncratic opportunities that we have in Mammoth Lakes that we're going to need to exploit moving forward. Because where I'm coming from, to put this in a more tangible example, if you look at this chart, and this is the first time we've been able to see this chart, this pier resort on page 64,

1:17:48 We are the only community that's compared here that has a larger number of housing units than population by a stark amount. So this chart shows something that we're already aware of, that we are suffering from a utilization problem here. So I just think that for what it's worth, this is something that we need to address. And we know where that comes from because we have such a high percentage of the homes here.

1:18:17 That are owned by second homeowners and sit vacant for 50 weeks a year. And this issue about, Kirk, about, you know, the shaggy rugs and the single pane and two by four, all the rest of the stuff, we have to figure out a way to get some market force, if the subsidy can help, to start getting some dynamic stuff in there to start turning this stuff over. And whatever these things are and how we can do that, if there's policy stuff or things that need to come from council to get these things moving.

1:18:46 The combination of targeting these particular ones that are for sale is the way we move forward. And it's probably something that our community needs to discuss and give further direction to staff to see what are the opportunities. But again, we still need that down payment or identifying individuals at 150% level AI that we can actually transition into one of those units. But what about?

1:19:15 So, I mean, I, you know, I'm a student of housing, and I'd be really happy to kind of talk to your board anytime you'd like. But, and, and the great thing today, you really clarified to me, always a sense, I get about reading your documents, and that is your whole concept about deficit housing. But I, you know, I firmly believe that our economy has forever changed. And, I mean, I think we need to say,

1:19:43 We've got to do a reset bill, but we just can't say deficit housing. We really need to look at where we stand today and where we're going to go in the future because it's very different. There's no indication that we're going to go back to where we were in the great days between 203 and 206 as long as you and I are on these boards.

1:20:05 So I think we just need to come up with a new strategy. Look at that one table. I mean, our little income people move out of town. And I can talk to teachers and talk to different folk that moved down to Crowley. They moved down there because they were able to sell at such a high point in the market, 2005, 2006, purchased a piece of property down in Crowley, built a house and had it paid for. And so they're not coming back.

1:20:34 So we have hollowed out about 50% of our middle income. And how do we get those people back? The management and everything else. Well, the point is I don't know. They don't want to come back. They like it down there. It's a nice big one that they live in. Some of them choose to be there, but when you come to... I'm just saying, I'm saying everybody. I'm just saying. That's why I want to broaden this and say, hey, look, housing is...

1:21:03 You know, it's an Eastern Sierra issue. And, you know, Mammoth Lakes happens to be the central point of it. And true, there's a lot of people that want to live here, and we should do what we can to try and make that happen. But we should also expand it to look at other places. If people want to say, hey, I want to work in Mammoth Lakes. But, you know, are there other housing options? Because, you know, I don't want to be in a small and little place. I want to be in maybe a larger place. Are there...

1:21:31 I think we should inform them of what other opportunities. We have to. At that point, we've got to start bringing yesterday into the conversation because then we can start, you know, leveraging those kinds of tools to make these kinds of things work. I think we're coming to the end and I would like to make a couple of comments about

1:22:00 And this is at the very end of your packet. And it talks about the different aspects of the impacts of affordability. The idea of businesses being able to attract and keep workers and reduce turnover and everything else. This is very important. The employees. If employees are driving up, even for crowded, let's say 15 minutes, 20 minutes each way.

1:22:28 That, you know, their work day is longer. That they're driving up from, from, and we can have that mass transit, but, you know, a lot of people don't want to use it because of the timing issue on it. And so the idea of the employee, you know, at $30 a gallon, and that they have to spend eight bucks driving up at eight bucks back, and all of a sudden the mountain would wave them off midday. I mean, this is really devastating to those employees.

1:22:54 So that's really important. As far as community, if you look at that one page where it talks about, and this seems to be happening in our community, in Glenwood Springs, volunteer clubs can't recruit enough members. Volunteerism are people that live here. They're not going to drive up from Bishop to volunteer for the 4th of July parade to help manage traffic control.

1:23:19 If, you know, if they're beneficial, it's not going to happen. So volunteers, again, if you look at Rotary and Lions Club, you'll see, you know, that from, from, we've seen the decline in those service organizations. I think the most important thing when we talk about housing is our visitor. And it's not written here, but when a visitor comes in town, one bad incident with an employee.

1:23:48 And, or, you know, somebody on the mountain, you know, somebody at a restaurant, and that ruins their whole communication. And the idea of somebody driving up and everything, if we can get as many workforce people, we're not going to get them all, that's for sure, but if we can get them there and reduce that, 15 to 20 years ago, we brought in a consultant, and he did workshops with all the restaurant owners, and now everybody else, as to how to treat your customers.

1:24:15 And that seems to have disappeared and maybe need to be brought forward again because we're surviving on visitors. And we all recognize that. And so the idea of making sure that we have employees and that we're not turning them over and that they're not here just for one season and then blow it off and blow your customers off. So I wanted to make a couple of comments about the importance of affordable housing.

1:24:44 I think you guys are doing a good job. I appreciate the fact that you guys have provided us here and the planning commission has been sitting through this and staff and everybody has been working on it. I think that if we keep pushing forward together that we can solve this thing. It's not very easy. It's uphill like everything else. Thank you. Any other last comments?

1:25:11 We have one from the audience. Oh, I'm sorry. Yes, I'm sorry.

1:25:38 Chapter 2, page 53, that the regional housing, which is shown in the table 235, says that between 2014 and 2019, we'll have a need for a total of 7 to 14,000 units. And of those 7 to 14,000 units, only 43 of them are up to 120%. So we have the need over the next five years for 43 units. I don't know how it makes sense.

1:26:08 Reserved shaded us with 172 of this perceived existing need. That existing need, so-called existing need, doesn't exist. It's been perceived as only 43 limits, and that's over five years. So that's the reason, in part, that we'll be coming forward with an amended master plan application, which is intended to address current and future needs, as well as existing needs.

1:26:35 Now, the other thing that's not wrapped up into that thought is, Maniface Housing has done an extraordinarily good job of addressing the current needs over the past several years. So I don't think she needs to be held up for the rest of the need that we perceive doesn't really exist. One of the things, if I may, it didn't matter.

1:26:58 What has just happened in the real estate development industry over the last number of years, we all have been touched by it in one way or another. Our community certainly has been touched with it in many ways, in many that you spoke to.

1:27:30 We will not be able to recoup from the sins of the past. We have large developers that have come forward and risked millions upon millions, hundreds of millions of dollars. Unrecoverable from Mammoth. Unrecoverable. We are in a different world. It's not the same world we were in in 2003 to 2006.

1:28:06 Moll over stats and look at numbers forever. But the reality is, it's different. And it's affected a lot of people in a lot of different ways. As a community, we need to come together with our core thoughts and our core reasons for getting things done and really focus. It's not the end of the world. A lot of people lost a lot of money.

1:28:37 But it's changed everything. And we need to start looking with open eyes and looking for a bright future to build Mammoth in such a way that we can address a number of the social issues that Mr. Stapp spoke about. Thank you.

1:29:05 Thank you guys. Wednesday, March 18th. I will note that we had a workshop regarding the Mammoth Lakes Housing Strategy and that if anyone missed it and is interested, it will be archived on Granicus.

1:30:01 So we'll move into the regular meeting and roll call please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I've asked Jennifer Halperty to lead us in the pledge tonight. Allegious to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Jennifer.

1:30:41 That moves us on to public comments on items that are not part of this evening's agenda. If there's anyone who has a comment, please come forward to the podium. Good evening, Town Castle. Martin Kleinbard, local electrical contractor and resident. Follow-up on the lack of movement on the issue regarding owner-builder permits for condominiums. We're not talking about...

1:31:14 Building new condominiums, we're just talking about small projects within a single unit, single owner's unit rather, kitchen remodel, this kind of nature. Currently it still stands that there's no, an owner can not get their own permit even though they're hiring only licensed contractors. So what that means is

1:31:42 If they choose not to hire a general contractor, they're going to be stuck with paying permits for each individual trade that requires a permit for the work that they happen to be doing. I just had a recent customer just this week where she went in to get the permit because she was doing various jobs. She was not doing the work herself. She just wanted to manage everything herself and not hire a general contractor.

1:32:10 Staff would not issue a permit to her. The plumber had to go in and get his permit. I had to get my permit. And the result is almost $200 extra cost for this one person on a very small project. And I think that that's unfair, arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of power. I don't know of any other city in the state.

1:32:39 That makes these kinds of requirements for these kinds of small projects. Thank you. Polling the council, this has been brought up a couple of times. Is there consensus to have staff bring back a report on the issues to us? I'll be very interested in that. I've heard, I'm hearing this from a variety of constituents that, and just coming out of our housing discussion about the need that we have to get this low-hanging fruit stuff moving forward, I think we absolutely need to start looking into this. Yeah, I'd agree. Support it.

1:33:07 One thing I forgot to say was that I spoke in front of the real estate board last week, and it seems like the consensus with them is it's problematic, and they would like to weigh in on it, but since we've had no movement on what direction it's going, you know, all I'm doing is coming up here publicly. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Do we have any other public comment? Say you.

1:33:37 Oh, we can just say consensus. Oh, we'll bring it back. We don't have to do a motion. Okay. Okay, then we'll start with councilmember reports. Colin, can we start with you today? Yeah. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Just a couple items for me. Michael and I will be attending our monthly ESTA board meeting on Friday here in Suite Z. This past week, I attended multiple different sessions.

1:34:05 With Miles, which is the company that MLT is contracting the website with. I attended the open house, which is very well attended, very productive, a lot of good information. I also attended a meet and greet afterwards with them to kind of meet some community stakeholders. And then the following morning I attended a planning session. So I spent a lot of time with the folks from Miles that came out here with a, you know,

1:34:33 Rolling deep with a team of people that seem to be a very, very good fit for what we need. They reside completely in the travel space and destination tourism, and they seemed very, very willing to engage with the community about what we're looking to have the Visit Mammoth website do for us. So that was a very encouraging process. And then as Councilmember Wentworth alluded to at our...

1:35:02 Meeting prior, both of us did attend a meeting with Mammoth Ford last night, just kind of continuing to have some community dialogue about how we as elected officials can engage with the community on important issues. So I think kind of the next step out of that we'll try and have like a town hall style meeting and really engage a lot of members of the community on what's interesting to them. Thanks.

1:35:32 Yes, Madam Mayor, I attended a LTC, which is the Local Transportation Commission, meeting. A lot of interesting information came out of that. What I'll share with is we are looking at the roadkill, if you will, along in Mono County, and it is pretty substantial down by the airport.

1:36:02 Deer fences are being considered. We're looking at that hopefully in the near future. We also talk about the 15 and 395 coming up to Mammoth and the road projects that are going to be going on in the next few years. When we get a, I ask for a diagram, or not a diagram, but a time sheet on that, and I'd like to share that with the community when I do get it.

1:36:32 I also attended a TOT enforcement meeting on Tuesday. We are actively, the town is looking for a revenue specialist. So that will make the revenue or the TOT enforcement group full. And we have some pretty good ideas on

1:36:56 You know, what we need to do to make enforcement that much better going into the future. It's going to be a lot of help from the lodging industry. The other thing on that is that there's a bill out there right now, and hopefully, Andy, you can give us a little update on that. It's AB 1220.

1:37:26 Put up by an Assemblyman out of Huntington Beach that would actually take away quite a bit of the income that the town gets through T.O.T., our town, but it would be a statewide. Andy, can you give a little update on that? Yeah, absolutely. It is AB 1220 introduced by Assemblyman Harper out of Huntington Beach. He's a Republican. He's a freshman Assemblymember, so it's not clear how much cloud he actually has. The bill appears to be aimed at Airbnb, VRBO.

1:37:54 Thank you.

1:38:20 Who want to oppose it can certainly write letters to the bill's author or to our Assemblyman, Assemblyman Bigelow. It doesn't look from what we're hearing right now as though this thing has much chance of passing, but if it makes it out of committee or if it makes it all the way to being considered by the Senate, then I think it'll be important for everyone to step up their letter writing and phone call campaigns. The League of California Cities has not yet come out against the bill. They're taking a watch position instead of an opposed position.

1:38:47 If the bill starts progressing, then you might think about trying to contact the league and getting them to take a stronger position against it. I have been in contact with South Lake Tahoe, Big Bear Lake, and, of course, Truckee. They're all opposed to it, and they're all thinking about ways to register their concerns. Great. Thank you. Yeah, just to add to that, our lodging industry has just stepped up real quick in the last couple days in MLT, so we're writing letters as we speak.

1:39:15 And to continue with the alphabet soup, first it was LTC, then TOT, now it's TCL, which is basically the town-county liaison. I'm going to be in that meeting tomorrow, and that meeting talks about how the town and the community work together, so I will report back to you at that time. Thank you.

1:39:38 Do we want to have staff bring back some kind of a proposed opposition to 12-20? Absolutely. Council consideration? Yes. All right. Thank you, Shields. John? Thank you, Madam Mayor. Shields, one question for you. Is this deer, is this a new pattern of use by the deer or is this nothing? No. Okay. Never mind.

1:40:04 Well, but they have counts now. Okay, they have counts, okay. Well, and since I was also at the LTC meeting, they have some counts, but they're, the data collection has been more than sporadic. Okay. So they do have some information, but they don't have consistent information. Okay. So we're not talking about changing patterns or any of that kind of stuff yet, because no one has the data to know. Well, there's... Yeah, they are.

1:40:28 You know, but the data that's available shows exactly where you would expect them to be trying to cost $3.95 based on water and forage. Okay. Okay, thank you for that. That's interesting. A couple things. The National Forest Foundation has awarded a Community Capacity and Land Stewardship Program grant to the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative. So that means that the collaborative that was working over the fall will continue to be in place through the life of the INU National Forest Plan revision.

1:40:58 Which is a good thing. So there will be notifications about the meetings. I would encourage you and the public. Everybody come on down. The good thing is happening with that. I also attended the MLT website open house. It's very cold in that room. But it was a very interesting presentation. Very encouraged to hear the technical acuity of those folks and also their putting responsive design as being a front and center kind of an issue, which was interesting.

1:41:27 Also worked with convenience of Mammoth Trails meetings to work with representatives of the town, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Mount Ski Area, Disabled Sports, the Sierra Club, and Interested Citizens to draft about a nine-page letter of comment on this Lake George Maltese Path project, which everybody agrees to support. That's a very important, interesting project because there's a lot of things in there that we have opportunities to get right. And just to encourage a district ranger to engage with that conversation.

1:41:55 And with Colin, I attended the Mammoth Forward meeting last night. Thank you. The only thing I have is just going off of the Bill 1220 that MLT is writing letters of opposition as well as Cal Travel. So that's definitely, and now what I think with council, opposition letters is a great thing as well. And then just quickly on

1:42:19 Our flight, we've got our numbers back for total flight cancellations for this year. We've only had 29 total flights canceled. 18 were weather-related, 6 were crew issues, and 5 were mechanical issues, which is considerably less than last year. Though we'd like to see none, this is much improved from last year, so that's all I have. Michael, do you have any update on, it was March that there was some change to the night service.

1:42:49 Right. Night restriction. Night restriction. Right. And that's through. That's in effect now. And going forward with planning with departure times and arrival times, that'll help us. Okay. Thanks. All right. I will also be attending the Town County Liaison meeting tomorrow and obviously attended the LTC. The other meeting I attended was the Great Basin. Air pollution. Air pollution. Unified air pollution. Yes. Unified, et cetera. That's why I just call it Great Basin. Right.

1:43:20 We were in here Monday morning when town had the power outage, and we got the first experience, I think, with the town's generator. We had the different lights when they came back on kept all flashing on, so we were calling it the disco meeting. I don't know why it went like that, but just so staff knows that different panels would come on and off for a while there.

1:43:41 It's kind of interesting. Okay, I believe we have no additions to the agenda. Madam Mayor, if I could. When the power went off and when the round fire happened, I'm not sure if we're our role, whatever role we should be playing in emergency preparedness, I've never had any, I don't know what we're expected to do. And I don't know if that's something that...

1:44:02 We should do nothing. We should, I don't know. We have a full emergency operation plan, and as that was not an incident that the town was engaged at because somebody else was running that incident, we let them know we would provide resources if they requested them so we were available, but we didn't have a formalized role because it really wasn't a town incident as we were dealing with some of that, but we did offer services and we helped coordinate through that. Is there any training or any stuff you need that we need to know about when these things happen or no?

1:44:31 Sounds like something that you can work on. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, there's a piece there. I will let the community know that our communications with Edison have been much better in the past few years where we get notice ahead of time when there's going to be a planned outage for maintenance and things like that, which is much better than getting all the calls. Right. Sure. So, but I don't believe that they've ever done a, oh, it was off Monday because of their fixing it and going on to the next thing, I believe. Yeah.

1:45:02 Okay, we did have closed session at the last meeting to discuss the evaluation of the town manager. It is continued over to tonight. You'll see it at the end of our agenda, so there's nothing to report at this time. That takes us to reports from commissions or departments. Okay, Al's got one. Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, I just want to remind everybody tomorrow night is the town hall meeting for the Mammoth Lakes Police and Community Advisory Committee.

1:45:39 So it starts at 530 at the Grand Sierra Lodge, still remembering that, at the Emerald Room. And it's three different immigration attorneys. We also have representatives from the Mexican Consulate to talk about the immigration issues and also answer any questions and go from there. Thank you. Thank you. Anything else? Commissions or departments? Okay. Then we have a presentation from Melina Francis of the California Joint Powers Insurance Authority.

1:46:11 Thank you. Good evening, members of the council. Yes, I'm Melaina Francis. I'm the regional risk manager assigned to the town of Mammoth Lakes for Region 1, and Region 1 consists of western LA County and the eastern Sierras, including Mammoth Lakes, Bishop, and ESTA.

1:46:31 So some background about the Joint Powers Insurance Authority. It's one of the largest municipal self-insured pools in the state with 117 members consisting of cities, towns, special districts, and joint powers. The authority was formed in 1977 by 33 cities who found it difficult at that time to find insurance coverage. It was just very costly. So unlike an insurance company that's motivated by

1:47:00 Market, Share, and Profit. The pool, the Joint Powers Insurance Authority, pools all of its risk. And so the goal of the pool is to reduce the cost of coverage and risk to public entities. So the town participates in all of the JPIA's coverages, including liability and workers' comp. Those are both pooled coverage programs.

1:47:30 And the authority purchases some insurance, which includes excess liability, excess workers' comp, pollution, crime, and also earthquake and flood, mechanical breakdown, and special events. And then as of January of this year, we also started purchasing cyber liability. So that's like a new emerging risk for everyone out there.

1:47:59 The formula, this is always a tough one to explain, but the formula for allocating costs in each of the pooled programs uses experience, which are your losses, and then also your exposure, which is payroll. So it differs for every member based upon their payroll, which you don't have a lot of control over your payroll, but you do have control over a lot of time, oftentimes, your exposures.

1:48:25 Funding estimates are calculated separately for agencies with police and non-police, and that's for both the liability and for the workers' comp program. And just so you're aware, there's 35 members have police departments and 26 members have fire departments. Some of our authority partners include Carl Warren is one of our third-party administrators. They manage the liability claims on behalf of our members.

1:48:54 And York is the third-party administrator that manages the workers' comp claims. And they both work closely with your staff, town staff, and with authority staff. About a year and a half ago, the authorities changed its structure for the risk management program, and they separated the membership into five regions. So that's when...

1:49:22 I took over for Region 1. And part of my role is to work with town staff to reduce their risk of exposures and liabilities and help them through what we call the loss cap program. And so there's various action items that come out of that loss cap evaluation. And town staff is doing very well. The last one was in 2012.

1:49:49 The next one is coming up this year in August, so I'll be back to visit Mammoth Lakes again in August to conduct that risk management evaluation. And just to let you know, too, the top two costly exposures to the pool include slips, trips, and falls, vehicle accidents, and then also some of the greatest exposures now include ADA exposures. So those are the things that I...

1:50:17 Work with city staff, town staff to help develop plans to address those. So that concludes my presentation. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have. Any questions? If I could add one comment to her presentation, we're talking about working with staff and do it. We end up with this risk kind of a development of programs and stuff to look at. We actually have a safety committee that meets regularly throughout the year.

1:50:47 What things can we implement? How do we begin to walk through those things and start? You get a list of half a dozen or so items and start checking those off and working through those. One of the large ones this year we'll be working on is the replacement of the police station. It in itself has a number of potential challenges, so plug for later on the agenda.

1:51:09 It has really been good to have that working document to be able to focus people and work through and say, let's fix this, let's fix this, let's fix this. And a lot of it's small dollar items, so it's been very effective. I'll make a quick comment. I just, I attended their conference, and there's a lot of great information that you guys give your partners, and they can act upon that, and, you know, it's very, very cost effective, so it's a good program to be a part of. Thank you.

1:51:40 Yes, thank you, Melina. Thank you. Okay, that moves us to consent agenda. Are there any items that a council member wishes to pull from consent? John? Number eight, please. Number eight, okay. Anything else from council? Anything from the public? Okay, then I will entertain a motion for the remainder of the consent agenda. Madam Mayor, I make a motion. Council approves item three, four, five, six, seven, and nine. Second.

1:52:11 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. John, you pulled number 8. Yes, Madam Mayor, I want to thank you and staff for getting this item into the consent agenda. This is something that has to do with supporting regional broadband consortia, which are working across the state to help implement broadband.

1:52:41 Those kinds of technologies. I'll be, I'm a member of that board. We'll be meeting tomorrow down at Ridgecrest. I'll be leaving after this meeting night to drive down there. But I think as we move forward with digital 395 implementation, and I know that SCOGS is going to be talking about this on Friday, this is going to be a very important part of the toolkit that we can use to start really implementing and getting digital 395 fully integrated into our communities and our region. So I wanted to thank you for your consideration of this. Thank you.

1:53:09 With your interest in it, would you like to be involved in creating the letter? Sure. We can send it out. We have a draft that staff's working on. Right, because we do not have the letter here tonight, but we're authorizing to sign something that you haven't seen yet. Sure. We trust you. I was working through the timing issue. It came in late to be able to get something through, and we would be patterning off of some other agencies that have taken support positions. So it would most likely, presuming we approve it, be in the next town manager update. Okay.

1:53:40 Do you want to make a motion? I'll make a motion that we authorize the mayor to coordinate the town manager to submit a letter of support for Assembly Bill AB 1262, Wood Telecommunications. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to policy matters.

1:54:08 The first of which deals with the stormwater management plan consultant selection. That's you, Grady. Thank you. On your agenda sheet, the one small change I want to point out is that the total grant amount, $80,000 plus a town match of $33,000, added up to $113,000. We didn't name the consultant in the agenda sheet. We did put MCE in the staff report because the same afternoon we were finishing up, we were meeting with them on the scope.

1:54:41 We were actually able to negotiate their agreement and got all the scope items that we needed to take care of the grant for $103,000, which freed up $10,000 in that share for staff time that we need to administer that, some of which has already been charged. So that was positive news and we're confident we'll get the work done in time. The two things I want to mention that may not be mentioned in here is that we actually have a GIS

1:55:06 Expert, if you will, on for a couple of weeks, and we'll be using that person to do some of that work along with the consultant to fine-tune the existing storm drain. And the other thing is we, in the program, is an operation and maintenance manual when we're done. We met with Public Works staff again this morning, and they were actually very excited to hear that because the storm drain maintenance over the last few years has been kind of hit and miss.

1:55:30 With the addition of this technology, the consultant report, and the Vactor truck that we purchased last year, they've actually been able to make some great headway this year. They've probably done more on storm drains in the last 12 months than they have in the five years before that. So we're looking forward to this. The consultant is ready to go, and we're confident we'll meet the timeline. Any questions of Grady? No questions. Oh, go ahead, John. Talk to me, or talk to us about the extent of the GIS work.

1:56:00 And how much new data might be developed? I'm assuming that all this data comes back to the town's GIS library. That's correct. And some, again, is from the consultants. Some of it is from the part-time staff we have on here for a couple of weeks. But in addition to this, and it's actually layered into the county system as well. We're working with Nate and making sure it all works together. Right now, we're actually interviewing all the town's science. You name it. We have somebody out there doing that. In fact, we actually spent...

1:56:29 I think $500 on an iPad and a little piece of software where that individual can walk around and plug in the sign, what's the type of sign, what the condition is, its exact location. So we're making some great headway in the next 60 to 90 days. We expect we'll have a really good catalog of all the signage in town, and then by the end of August, the storm drainage as well. And it's all tied in, again, with the county system as well. Okay, good. Thank you. You bet. Okay, I have one question. Does the motion need to be amended in any way to name the person?

1:56:59 Okay. It's fine. It's open. All right. So any comment from the public? Seeing that, I'll bring it back for a deliberation or a motion. Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to authorize the town manager to negotiate and execute an agreement with the top-ranked stormwater management plan consultant. Second. With a motion and a second, could we have a roll call vote, please, Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:57:25 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us to policy item number 11, which is our opportunity to provide comment and direction on the voter initiative regarding transient rentals, and I presume this is Dan and maybe Andy. The item before you is kind of outlined within the election code that

1:57:49 As these items come forward, the town council has the opportunity to request to refer the proposed initiative back to an agency, or in this case town staff, or others that can actually prepare a report for you to digest and work through on a variety of items. The items that are in the code are listed out in the staff report. Then it has any other matters as well, so it's quite broad in terms of what you can ask it to look at.

1:58:14 We put this on here for two reasons. One being, do you want that level of report and that work done? And if we do that, we're probably out to the first meeting in May coming back to the council. Also, just in general, the other dialogue and discussion that would help us in terms of framing some of that or other concerns that you would want to see addressed as we bring that forward or a little bit of general discussion as well. And again, it's kind of following that outline that's provided by

1:58:42 The Elections Code will be able to do that. So that's why it's on your agenda to be able to look at those elements and Andy can speak to the other legal side. There are other policy issues that we may have to as we work through the process. I think the app. Yeah, it's pretty self-explanatory. I mean, essentially the Elections Code says the council can ask staff to report back on anything relating to the initiative. There are those specific categories and then number eight is a catch-all which says anything else that you're interested in.

1:59:11 I don't think we have a staff recommendation. It's just whatever the council's pleasure is. Okay. A little bit like the workshop we just have, I would first ask before we go to public comment if there are questions from any council member about what any of these seven things mean and or if there's anything we feel should be added so we can get public comment on a full scope of the study. Do you have...

1:59:40 One question on item one, fiscal impact. So Dan and Andy, I suppose both of you. So my understanding is depending on the amount of signatures, it can kind of trigger two different options, one of which would be a general election, the other would be a special election. Can we get some information about the costs associated with both of those, at least ballpark? Yeah, certainly.

2:00:09 Does anybody else have anything? Real quick, on this initiative, does it, I think it does, outlive our general plan? This initiative would restrict future changes to the general plan. It makes some changes and then it has some restrictions on how the general plan could be amended in the future. So no matter how often the general plan is updated or amended for the next million years, these restrictions would stay in effect unless the voters changed them. Right.

2:00:40 And, Dan, are you presuming that would come underneath number three, that whole discussion on use of land? Yeah, it would be an element in there. We'd end up in one of these. Or two. Yeah. There's a couple places it may fall just in terms of it talks about the general plan consistency issues. And then, you know, if your general plan ideally was a 20-year document, it would outlive that document. Assuming it's updated, it would continue in effect and force unless the voters change it. Okay.

2:01:07 So Andy, you mentioned that there would be some changes associated with that, so potentially in the short term we would have some inconsistencies with the general plan, is that right? No, actually the initiative proponents did a really good job of drafting this in a way such that there won't be any inconsistencies between the general plan and the zoning because what they've given us in the initiative is kind of a suite of changes that work together. What the initiative would do is it would prohibit

2:01:35 Okay. Dan, maybe following up on that a little bit. Based on the boundaries of the restrictions, could this initiative entice

2:02:03 Can you entice the commercial moving into residential areas, I mean, so to speak? I mean, can there be, is it based on the. Yeah, if I'm understanding it. Go ahead. I'm sorry. Yeah. No. If I'm understanding the initiative correctly, you could do a zone change, like say in a residential area next to commercial, and it would come forward, go through the normal processes. Let's say I want to do a hotel, but I know I can't do it.

2:02:30 So I'll keep that out where it's already legal. So that could have an impact on the edges where it butts up to different places.

2:03:00 You know, if somebody wanted to get creative, they could obviously, again, that would go through the whole process, so there would be a full council discussion, community discussion on such a change. Right. But it wouldn't prohibit that type of change. Right. Okay. All right. Then ask for any public comment on this item? Seeing none, I'll bring it back. And so based on the comments, I see that the yes, no is that yes, we want the study.

2:03:30 Madam Mayor, if I could, I'd like to maybe say something about this. I wanted to wait to hear some comment from the public, but I wanted to... Well, I guess there is a creepy ending today. Okay, so... I think there will be when we come back with the study. I understand, but I think that it occurs to me that it's unfortunate that we're perhaps all heading down a road that I'm not sure we need to go down. And I think that there's a...

2:03:56 I've never served an elective office before. I'm unaware of sort of how the pace at which government works and all the rest of it. But I think I'm concerned that there are significant misperceptions as to the motivations or the intentions of members of council based on what happened during the campaign or whatever. And I think that I'm looking to find a solution. I'm looking to find a way to work with the proponents for the initiative. And Mike, I see you in the audience this evening. Excuse me.

2:04:25 Because, excuse me, I'm going to drink some tea. Back in the campaign, I sent a letter out at my own expense to all the constituents in the community, advised that I was committed to preserving the integrity of our residential neighborhoods. And I still stand behind that. I don't see any compelling need to change our zoning to accommodate single-family rentals at this point. And Kathy Cage was here at our last meeting and stood up and kind of...

2:04:58 Pointed at me and said, John, well, gee, maybe, you know, maybe, maybe you want to do this. And I, I just think it's important to make it clear for the record, for the community to understand, I can speak for myself, but also that this question has not been before this council.

2:05:12 This council has not weighed in on what our opinions or our legislative recommendation is to more of a single family rentals. And I think this enormous gap is opening up between, I think, what the public perceives we might be interested in doing, what our agendas are one way or the other, and there hasn't been any public, we've never taken a vote on this. And we are all bound by the Brown Act. We can't, you know, we're, there's good reasons for that law. We can't talk amongst each other about these kinds of things.

2:05:42 And so I would like to suggest, Mike, if it makes sense to you that maybe I could wrangle one of my fellow council members, and Colin, you're at the far end of the dais over there, that maybe the two of us could come meet with your committee and start talking about this and engage in a good, productive dialogue about what is really the best way to take on these challenges. And I'd love to hear if you're interested in engaging with that dialogue. I'd love to meet with council and talk about

2:06:21 You know, our motivations and this gap that you, you know, believe is a possibility. You know, it's just, and I can't speak for them in terms of, you know, we're a diverse group that came together to do this. You know, personally, you know, it was just a couple weeks ago that you removed the permit process for the RMF-2s. To me, that's almost a, that's a disservice to the people who are renting because now they can have tranches coming more easily without addressing trash.

2:06:51 Fire and things like that. It wasn't too long ago that you removed the height restrictions in North Village for one section of it. To me, that's a disservice to the people that live here. You're not recognizing our quality of life. You're thinking more about, I guess, building. And then there's been changes with the restrictions in density over by

2:07:21 Was it Rafters Area? And so if it weren't, you know, this town council may never make those changes in rentals, but someone down the road could. So that was our motivation. But still, I think we would love, and I'll facilitate that if you want to set up a date and we'll put it together for like next week or the week after. Sure, that would be great. And I think it's,

2:07:48 The one thing that impresses me about single family rentals is there are two things. One is this council's priority was to tackle it. That's kind of a vague term from a legislative perspective. The other point is that this is a rapidly evolving and very complex and dynamic issue. And I think it would be great for us to meet with you and to start figuring out a way that this community can really strategically address these issues in a way for the benefit of all of us. I'd be happy to join for that as well. So, you know, maybe...

2:08:17 How do we want to facilitate? Next week, well, we can meet afterwards. How can we do it legally so that we can? You can invite two at a time. Right. Right. Right. So, you know, I think that's, yeah, that satisfies that. There's two of us and, you know, maybe we, John and I can reach out via email and try and set up a time to meet. Great. But individually, you can approach all five throughout your process. Right. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. So I'm hearing that with the additional questions, yes, go forward with the study.

2:08:47 Go ahead. Sorry. I might add, because in their notice of intent to circulate a petition, one of their big, and Mike just brought it up, was the quality of life matters. And I think, I mean, that's something we're going to get into as a council. Staff is working on that now. Yeah. And so if they could give us, when they bring this back, an update where those...

2:09:14 I was just getting to timing. So this is sometime in May. It was my understanding that the quality of life might come back sooner than that, but Dan's writing things down, so I haven't seen the head nod as much as it can nod at this point. I would also ask that when this particular report comes back, if at all possible, can we schedule a workshop first and then take action during the regular meeting so that we don't get bogged down?

2:09:43 If that works on whichever May date. I know we've got other workshops coming up, but that's an easier way to interact when we're sitting down there and the public is closer to us. Sure. That's a good idea. Just to clarify, Dan, you had mentioned we'd be looking at May if we have the scope stays as it is, right? All eight items we'd be looking to report back on? Yeah, we're probably not going to have something back at your next regular meeting on April 1st.

2:10:12 Unless you only want one of these, we would not be back on April 1. Right. So it'd be into May, and May 6th is what we looked at. I think, I can't remember, I think one or two of you are going to miss that meeting. So if we need to move in, please let me know if you have a preference. So, you know, I think we're hearing consensus that we want to have some of this information brought back, but, I mean, do we need to kind of work through, do we want it to be that full scope of all, bring all eight items? I think some of them kind of overlap, and when you get down to it, there might be.

2:10:42 I would hope, Colin, that the work we do with Mike and the committee, if we've got specific questions that may be added to this, we can report back and maybe add that to your burden. That's your choice, Dan. Again, to help illustrate and draw some of these issues out and really get some focus on how to be most productive.

2:11:09 Okay, so that's adequate direction? Yes. All right. That moves us on to number 12, which is to approve the release of reserved Measure R funding for the completion of Volcom Brothers Skate Park. Grady's going to do a real quick introduction. Absolutely. This item was before Council previously when you looked at all the Measure R requests and the recommendations from MLR for the interim funding cycle. The direction on this one was to place it in a reserve account or the reserve account.

2:11:39 Status, if you will. And that MOR and those folks had a couple of questions about the project and how the $60,003 was going to be spent to complete the Volcom Brothers skate park part and not the entirety of that. We did go to the Recreation Commission first on this issue.

2:11:58 We made a full presentation, and at the end of that meeting, Recreation Commission agreed that the questions had been answered. Then this past Monday, we took it also to MLR to see if there were any outstanding questions. Terry was there and went through each question for the entire MLR board, commented that she believed all of them were answered. It was discussed, and the MLR board voted unanimously that

2:12:21 They do also agree with staff that this could come out of the reserve and become a real project. To follow on on that, if you do support that and take it out of reserve, staff's ready to meet out on site with them as soon as next week to get it going so this work can be done this summer. And I will add one thing is that the actual motion from MLR was to release the funding with the understanding that no Measure R maintenance dollars would be used for this portion of the project at any point in the future.

2:12:53 So I think I just made a motion. I do have a motion. I know, but we'll come back to that. So go ahead, questions. Just a couple of quick questions for staff. I just want to make sure that I'm clear that this is essentially a wrapping up of the project, right? So, you know, we're going to expend this $60,300 and we're done.

2:13:21 That's correct for the skate park portion again. Okay. Partially two spaces, one trail end one. This wraps up the skate park, this wraps up JLA's projects. Right. Commitment to getting that done. They'll be involved long term in terms of maintenance along with Vulcan, but in terms of the project, that would completely be correct. And so both the town and JLA have maintenance obligations long term?

2:13:45 Actually, what the commitment has been from, again, JLA and Volcom as a team, I'll call it, is that they've been funding, I believe, $7,500 a year where they reimburse the town staff for work that we do to maintain certain things out there. And they have stated they want to continue to do that. In fact, Volcom wants to get even more involved with the suggestion that they might want to put a monument out on Meridian as well. So there's a long-term intent there. We haven't wrapped up the contract, but that's what they've stated.

2:14:13 Okay. And there is one more piece that within the further discussion and the questions by the Recreation Commission and MLR, the length of the path was reduced significantly so that it's not a path that wanders to nowhere. It's a more direct link in to the town MUB system. So there were some adjustments made. Okay. Is there anyone in the public who would like to comment on this? Seeing none.

2:14:44 I will move that we approve release of reserve measure R funding for completion of the portion of trails and park described in the measure R interim funding cycle application with no use of measure R funds for maintenance of this portion. Second. Yeah. Can I just make a couple of comments? So I just want to say that, you know, I know MLR is still in its infancy, but I think this is already showing the value.

2:15:17 Thank you so much.

2:15:46 You know, I think it's particularly exciting to be able to, you know, finalize that portion of the product and to see that things working as we hope they would. So I'm excited to approve this. And I'm sorry, there's one more question. I'm presuming that should this be approved, then at the next meeting the actual financial release of the money happens in a separate resolution. Am I correct? We'll bring a budget amendment forward. Okay, a budget amendment. All right.

2:16:15 I just wanted to echo Colin's comments. I was just sitting here anticipating how these projects are going forward and the idea that Measure R and UDollars are out there. There's an active group of people who are really working hard vetting these things out. I was at a portion of the meeting where JLA is there and there's questions about who's doing what and all this stuff gets really worked out and it comes back here and I think it's a good harbinger of things to come.

2:16:43 Okay, any more comments? Are we ready for a vote? A roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0, which takes this on, which takes this on to policy item number 13. Madam, excuse me, I'm going to recuse myself from this item, so I'm going to go into a little corner. All right, you need to go into the little room.

2:17:10 This is to approve the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Key Agreements for Implementation of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordination. Dan has a quick overview. Yes, let me, a real brief one on this. We've been working through this between the town, MLR, and looking at the trail system coordination and how does that come together. We've had discussion with some of the MLTPA board and having them involved in it, that's...

2:17:39 One reason, Mr. Wentworth has stepped down, he's on that board, so we don't want to have any conflicts there. The element that has come to that is how do we, one of the deliverables for MLR was to focus on implementation of our trail system, the coordination work that happens there. And so trying to get that refocused and redirected has been a key element that we're working through. In order to achieve that, kind of the process that came out of that from the MLR discussion was to come back and say, let's look at some key areas.

2:18:08 Not having the full MLR board involved in every little element of the trail system. The council has committed $300,000 a year for a period of time. That continues for another few years. And so it appeared to be more efficient if we came back and said, let's let a committee kind of do this. The town would come back within those dollars and have a separate contract with part of an implementation strategy piece, which at this point the recommendation is to work through MLTPA.

2:18:36 And to really nail that down and say, here's our deliverables, here's what we want to have happen, we would continue to have oversight through the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board as well as the town holding the contract responsibilities for the deliverables that would actually be done. And a lot of that builds off of the MLTCCS, what was it? MLTCC. Thank you. Who mentioned it?

2:19:04 To really kind of nail those projects down, we have some that are coming up relatively quickly, so if we don't move as this, we'd be bringing those back at a staff level to make sure that stuff continues to happen, such as the stewardship days going forward. There's been some questions raised regarding why MLTPA, and that's somewhat addressed in here, but that could work through some discussions with council here if there's additional questions related to that. The elements that we've clarified, too, is if we have that contract and there's elements out there.

2:19:33 This is a Measure R funded project. Therefore, if there's other work that's outside of that scope, that funding has to come from a different source versus these dollars and to be able to keep that clean, similar to what we've done with MLR as well. So kind of a brief overview. I was going to walk through all the key agreements. You can read through the staff reports. It's there. There's representatives from MLR here to speak to it as well. If there's other questions or process questions the council has, we'll be glad to address those.

2:19:59 Let me add just a couple of things from the discussion at the MLR board meeting on Monday. In number two, on the second page of the key agreements, this would be the first time that MLR also takes the step of establishing a committee that has non-board members in it in order to get something accomplished and move partnerships forward. So that is extremely important.

2:20:20 Also, there was a letter to the editor in the sheet this weekend about the contract being between MLR and MLTPA. It is not. The deliverables in the contract are still the responsibility of MLR to make...

2:20:35 For example, make the recommendations on how the fiscal year 15-16 allocation of $300,000 would be done and to actually work at the detail of doing the implementation. But the contract is truly between MLT EPA and the town. We're talking about a very close relationship, including the idea is to have the person hired under the contract actually coexist in the MLR offices over at MLT, which is also another partnership we're building.

2:21:07 That said, I don't know if there's any member of the MLO Brewer that wants to add anything else or if we go into questions. Dan, I have a question. So was there, there was a comment in the paper that you're referring to and from some other people, citizens. Was there, was there a bid, was this sent out a bid for other people to bid on this or was it not?

2:21:33 And is it used to it? No, it was not. Normally it would be like a professional services type contract. So if you did a competitive selection process, you would use an RFQ request for qualifications. You can put something out like that, have people respond accordingly, and then you would select the best qualified firm or group or, in this case, association to be able to do that work. And then you would negotiate with them in terms of the scope of the actual cost of that contractual work. At this point, most of the folks would know the cost.

2:22:03 Capped it to what's already been allocated and discussed, but a formal RFQ is not utilized. It's more of a professional service negotiation. We could do that, frankly. I mean, we do that all the time for engineering or other type of services. The stormwater item heard early in the meeting, we utilized the process for that, similar to that, kind of a quick little RFQ and then negotiations. I'm just curious why that

2:22:29 Why that process was skipped or was it not needed? I mean... That discussion did come up in some of the MLR meetings as well in terms of do you have a firm out there that has the capability, has the knowledge base, it could step in quickly and timing seemed to be critical to move it forward quickly versus waiting another, say, probably 30 days to do an RFQ and get responses back. So you could do that again. It would push timing out, obviously, but...

2:22:58 I think the discussion at the end of the day was that they had a lot of the base background information. They still have some, I don't recall if it's direct employers or contract relationship employees doing work with MLTPA and stuff of that nature. So that history and that focus just on Mammoth Lake seemed to be a high priority one. I'll let Dana speak to it as the president of MLR in terms of kind of that same dialogue and discussion. They had some of that.

2:23:26 Those options can be you can negotiate directly on a professional services or you do the RFQ. Thanks. I'll add if you would like addition, I think Dan covered it extremely well. There was a significant discussion at all steps along the way in this process about how best to get something going immediately and also utilize existing.

2:23:52 And as we looked around, Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access has it in their mission that their focus is Mammoth Lakes Trail System. That's their area of focus. They have been at the forefront of establishing Mammoth Lakes Trail System from the very beginning. They have been actively engaged in helping to bring forward the

2:24:19 The concept of expanding our trail system, of taking care of our signage and wayfinding development, of looking at the nomenclature for that signage and wayfinding, of working on summer stewardship programs, of helping pursue grant funding and outside funding to help enhance this Mammoth Lakes trail system. And as we were looking at an entity that has all of the needs that we were looking for, MLTPA fit that mold to a T. And for them to

2:24:48 Have that intimate knowledge of the trail system. All elements of it is going to help MLR and the community move very quickly into more implementation for our Mammoth Lakes trail system. And I actually have another piece to add on to that. In this role, MLR is actually involved in the contract negotiation from the standpoint of us having the ability to

2:25:16 Make sure that the scope of work will help MLR meet its deliverables that are in the MLR contract. So there is a third party looking at it as well. It's, again, a partnership. And this is something new. Right. Well, my concern is I may know what you said and you may know that as well, but I think for the public's sake and I think for transparency that we keep talking about and we keep talking about a level playing field, I just, to me, it would seem like it would be prudent to

2:25:44 For staff to do a 30-day RFQ, I mean, and we may have the same outcome, but I just think it's a transparency issue. So that's just my comments. Any other comments? So in that case, does it make sense to split the motion into two pieces, one to accept the key agreements and then one to talk about executing a contract? I'm looking at my fellow members here.

2:26:19 That makes sense. Does someone want to make a motion about the key agreements? At a mayor, I make a motion to accept and approve the key agreements as provided by the MLR board related to the implementation of the Mammoth Lakes Trails Coordination Work Program and... No, stop there. Stop, that's it. Point. All right. Okay, do we have a second on that? Second. Okay. Two seconds on that one.

2:26:49 All right. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Then, Michael, do you want to craft the second? Sure. I would say we'd make a motion to authorize the town manager to draft and execute a contract with the contractor for MLT as coordination services is outlined and defined in the key agreements with staff doing a 30-day RFQ.

2:27:21 Second. So basically, sorry. If I could dive into that, what you're asking us to do is to select the consulting group or the implementer based on an RFQ. Correct. And try to do that in a short time frame. Right. Yeah. Within 30 days or less or whatever it takes. Yeah, 30 days or less that we can put something in. And then, so it doesn't have to come back, you could name it the contractor and it could be very well be MLTPA. It doesn't have to come back again.

2:27:46 Can we do that, Andy? Say to run the RFP and award all in one piece? Yes. Okay. And that's the gist of what you were saying? Okay. Do we have a second? Second. I'm comfortable with that. All right. We will call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Motion passes 3-1.

2:28:11 That moves us on to item number 14. Yes, Jamie will get him as we're working through this. This is regarding refunding certificates of participation and funding for a police station project. Yes, Madam Mayor, as I kind of outlined in the staff report, I won't spend a lot of time, a lot of the financial detail, that's just particular questions on it. One of the council's priorities this year was to try to be able to move forward with their

2:28:39 Police Station that replaced the current lease facility that we are in to move in something that we actually own and I think having it designed as a police station from day one probably creates some enhanced efficiencies and operational issues that we can utilize versus a leased facility that's been gone through a variety of remodels and work. The challenge on that has been looking at the scope and size and funding.

2:29:02 As mentioned earlier, we actually acquired property next to the courthouse and one of the designs was for a police station there. It actually went through the planning process and a use permit was approved for this type of usage there. The previous one was much more substantial in nature and so we're looking at really scoping that down to meet our current operational needs and the idea of current staff, maybe a couple more officers being able to work through a facility.

2:29:30 And also trying to get it down into how can we finance this in a way that makes economic sense. A lot of the staff report walks through that. The basic element would be refinancing current debt to take advantage of lower interest rates, looking at a couple of pieces of debt that are expiring and rolling those costs together in order to issue basically a new bond issue that would both refund the existing debt, pay off that over time, the same element for the bell-shaped parcel that was acquired.

2:29:59 And it also provided an estimated $2 million to go into the construction of a new police station. Assuming all that finance works and every day you're looking at the stock market or the treasury bonds, these things move around a little bit. We actually first started this work, the estimated interest cost for a bond was 3.25%. It's ticked up to 3.5%. So it's a moving target until you actually get a bid and lock it in.

2:30:27 That's why a lot of this stuff, it's plus or minus because we don't know until that happens. If you give us the approval to move forward tonight, we would be looking at trying to secure a negotiated placement or a private placement bond with a local, let's say a regional or national bank that is interested in these types of issuances. If that's not achievable, we'd come back and move through a competitive public market sale and see where we'd come out in that.

2:30:57 Trying to move it relatively quickly just given the time frame, the current lease expires in December of 2017. While that seems a long ways away when you start to look at financing, design, going through some planning processes and actually bidding it and constructing a facility, the timeline, I think it's very doable and I'll put that on Mr. Dutton's shoulders to make sure it happens. But that would be one of those elements to be able to move it through in that time frame.

2:31:23 If there's particular questions on what's being proposed, I can address those. Ideally, we'll be back in May with bond documents that would spell out, again, the final estimates that we have at that point in time for the debt. I can see Sheila's getting ready to ask. Yeah, well, timing is the issue right now. I mean, you saw what happened with the Fed today. Just a question on our bond rating went up.

2:31:49 Yes. That was a positive tick up. Incrementally. Yeah, I mean, it's good. Yeah, we're moving the right direction. All right. Do you have any idea, had we stayed where we were, the difference in rate? Well, I can tell you a year ago a little better. We looked at just refinancing the certificate of participation to take advantage of the interest rates. It was shopped out to four or five banks and none of them.

2:32:17 We're interested in financing something in Mammoth. With the bump up, we've had another discussion with Umpqua Bank, actually the group out of Reno, they're regional out of Oregon. They've expressed that they would be very much interested in looking at debt from the town. Part of that was I think our financials are better and also the fact that they did see us go from a BBB minus to a BBB. They're seeing us make incremental movements in that direction. So yes, that was a positive.

2:32:47 The reason I asked the question, I'm trying to illustrate how important it is that we keep moving in the direction, because this is how we get things done in our town. So, anyway, thank you. Any other questions? Madam Mayor, I have one, I apologize, I'll get you off.

2:33:09 That's okay. You go first. Well, let me ask my question first. Dan, when we did our strategic plan last summer, we said have the regional solution for the buildings facility by December 2017. Is actually having it completed even realistic by 2017? Yes.

2:33:30 There's already been an entitlement process and a planning process for a much larger station on this site. We will have to go through that. Again, take a look at the reductions, making sure everything works on site. I was actually involved with, as a construction manager on a design-build project, to do a police station, one that was quite a bit larger than this, and this is very doable in this time frame. The key thing is I already started talking to Chief Davis about adjacencies, the things he needs to look at.

2:33:57 Thank you. Thank you.

2:34:24 And he goes through planning commission and all the other approvals, etc. It's just a question of whether or not when you come back you say, we can't afford it. The rest of the council wasn't here, but I was here one time when a previous finance director was trying to convince us that 8.125% was a really good rate. Yeah. Okay, Andy, you had something. Yeah, one thing that you may be wondering about is whether our settlement agreement with Mammoth Lakes Land Acquisition and the airport litigation

2:34:52 Prohibits us from doing this. And the answer is it does not. We're required to make efforts from time to time to see if we can refinance or actually finance our debt to them to pay them off early. But the settlement agreement specifically says that if we do any financing and we have proceeds for a specific purpose, we're allowed to use them for that purpose. It's not that every dollar we manage to finance has to go towards prepaid and settlement. So we can do this. Thank you.

2:35:15 Even though I dream of the times when it is good enough that we can make the extra payments against that. Yes. Okay. Any other questions of Council? Any comments from the public? Okay. So you're looking for a motion to authorize the staff to initiate to look for money, essentially. Madam Mayor, make a motion to Council authorize staff to initiate the process for the potential issuance of bonds for the...

2:35:43 Refunding of the current certificates of participation and new debt for police station project release revenue financing structure. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And as I previously mentioned, we will be going into closed session to consider, where is it here? Consider evaluation of a public employee of the town manager. If we can...

2:36:17 Get ourselves over there.