TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2010

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 54 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

503 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:43 Council meeting for the Town of Mammoth Lakes for Wednesday, July 21st. Jamie, roll call please. Councilmember Eastman? Here. Councilmember Lehman? Here. Councilmember Wood? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Bacon? Here. Mayor Harvey? Here. Please rise and join Councilmember Joe Bacon in our pledge. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God,

1:16 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, we now will have public comment. This is a time for the persons to address any issues that are not on the agenda for this evening. Is there anyone that would like to speak? Tom? Okay. I'll gladly take advantage of that. Mr. Mayor, member of council, I'm here to just...

1:55 Brief you as well as the public on an amendment, a change that our board made to the fire code on Tuesday. If you're not aware of it, when the 2007 fire code was adopted, one of the items that was included in the new code adoption was the prohibition of barbecues, actually open flame cooking devices on balconies and decks, also a prohibition on propane tanks, anything larger than

2:24 One pound in size, which are essentially the small green Coleman type canisters. Anything larger than that was illegal. We sort of took a slow enforcement policy, but we started getting called by a number of people from down south wondering why it was that we were not enforcing this part of the code.

2:45 And so after doing some research, we found out that that section of the code, those particular items were not adopted by either the State Fire Marshal's Office nor by the Building Standards Commission, and that then gave us the chance to make a local modification to the code. What the board agreed upon was that barbecues are now legal on decks and balconies.

3:16 Made a prohibition for charcoal or wood barbecues on decks and balconies for everything other than single family homes. We have also made it such that you cannot have a barbecue of any sort on a high rise, mid rise or high rise. So any building greater than three stories. So a four story and above will not have a barbecue on their decks and balconies, which when you look at the existing facilities in town,

3:46 Almost all of them already excluded that through their CCNRs. As far as propane goes, propane cylinders are actually where the problem exists. It's against state law to have a propane cylinder brought inside a building if you have anything greater than a one pound, or excuse me, one gallon sized container. And so if you choose to use anything up to a five gallon

4:11 Container. Anything greater than five gallons would be against the code. But if you choose to use something greater than one gallon in size, you'll have to figure out a way of getting that propane dispenser, that canister, from your deck or balcony on the first, second or third floors down to the ground without bringing it inside. If you bring it inside, then that's a violation of code. And that's been the case for years. It's just that it's not been something that's been practiced. So, just a...

4:40 Opportunity to update you on a change that occurred as far as our board. That's enacted. It only takes place within the town boundary since our jurisdiction boundaries are co-existent, and we felt it was important. We were getting a number of calls from people that were wondering why it was that apple pie and barbecues were no longer the all-American dream, and so we've modified that.

5:07 Tom, quick clarification. So barbecues are legal at single-family homes? Barbecues have always been legal at single-family homes and will continue to be. There has been no change in that. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Tom. Gwen? My name is Gwen Plummer and staff of the Local Transportation Commission, and I'm here tonight to let you know that Transit Marketing, LLC, and Transit Resource Center

5:35 Are working on a short-range transit plan for Yosemite Area Regional Transportation System and you know it all in yards. This will include looking at possibilities for expanding the service from three counties, Merced, Mariposa, and Mono to other neighboring counties, Tuame and Madera. As part of their process, they are holding public meetings in each county to get a view of various stakeholders.

6:01 Regarding improvements to current services as well as the possibilities for future expansion of services. They will be holding three public workshops in Mono County on Monday, July 26th, 8 to 9 p.m. in Lee Vining at the Community Center in June Lake, 10 to 11.

6:21 At the Dulate Community Center. And here in Mammoth, they will be holding it from 3 to 5 p.m. on the third floor in the Board of Supervisors Conference Room in the Sierra Center Mall. I have left some flyers on the front table out there. I'm also going to leave my business card out there. You can call me. My phone number is 924-1802. You can email me at gplumbernob.

6:47 Two M's. Gplumber at mono.ca.gov. And if you need any more information, just get a hold of it. That's it. Thank you. Is there anyone else who would like to make public comment? John? Just a question. Can you tell me what the policy is for enforcement of T.O.T. and actually who enforces it? Collection of T.O.T. for people. I have to ask a problem with you to answer that briefly.

7:23 So enforcement of TOT is primarily a function of the finance department, and we do have a written procedure that lists the various things that we do to enforce TOT, but part of that is going on the web and looking for people who are not main and not properly registered. We also have the support of the police department in that effort. Thank you, Rob. The reason I specifically ask is because this morning a police officer went to the village, to the office, with a picture of a...

7:54 Condominium unit that was for lease part for sale by rent by owner. And I didn't know why the police department wouldn't go there. As it worked out, I don't know what they were looking for. I mean, it was just kind of confusing. Why, what were they looking for? As it worked out, they weren't even in the right, the right complex, it wasn't the village. But is that our policy? Would you have, you spend money to have a police department go look for something like that or wouldn't that be more of an administrative thing?

8:23 So, I mean, I don't know if there's an answer now, but I mean, it happened this morning, and I just want to bring it to your attention. I just didn't know why. I've never heard of that before. And what would you expect to find? Yeah, I think that's a good point, John. I think we'll address that as we look further into the enforcement of POT. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. Is there anyone else? Jack? How many minutes do I have? Three? Five. Five. Okay. I'll make that easily.

8:59 I'll give you some valuable information too. My name is Jack Winkler. I first came up here in 1946 and I've lived here full time since 1976. I first skied in 1952 when there were three rope tows and the horrible price of a lick ticket was $1.95 and you gave five cents to the ski patrol. And then in 1956 when they put in chair one it went all the way up to $4.50. So in those days living in Mammoth was a good deal.

9:28 Now we get tired of being ripped off with gasoline and a 65 cents a gallon, more expensive than Bishop, and tarps that are selling at, for Tom, at Ace are $200, really good vinyl tarps. If you buy them direct from the manufacturer in a quantity of one, they're $83. If you buy them in a quantity of 50.

9:54 They're $63. And I don't blame Ace, but that's just how it is up here. Okay, bulletin on the stocking of Red's Meadow, which they haven't been doing. I talked to the best fish and game person I've ever talked to in my life, Deborah Hawk, who's a wildlife and fish biologist out of Bishop, and she's not a politician. If the fish and game would listen to their biologists instead of their politicians, we'd be a hell of a lot better off, to say the least.

10:23 Anyway, they should start stocking Reds Meadows in about a week or two, and the assessment team is out there and release Saddleback Lake today for stocking and probably will release Reds Meadows for stocking in the next week or two because of the famous willow flycatcher, among other things. They're afraid the trout will eat too many aquatic insects flying around and the willow flycatcher will starve.

10:52 So the problem is they don't want to take Inyo Mono hatchery fish and put them over in the San Joaquin River because they're infested with New Zealand mud snails. So instead they're going to bring them up from Isabella where they're not infested with New Zealand mud snails and start stalking. Wildlife Subcommittee. The 310 minutes are not due out until August meeting, five months later. Well, that's not very good.

11:19 All we have to do is put them out preliminary and unapproved within a month of the meeting, and that would make a lot of sense. And we need a broader representation and a really active wildlife committee, and we should put a couple more conservation people and a couple more sportsmen members and less police and less town as either official or unofficial representatives.

11:44 The Fish and Game will not release bear kill data to the public or Steve Searles ever. And they need to release the complete bear status and not hide it in the DFG political files. My dog is teaching bears about dogs. She's working on this poor 65-pound golden retriever-sized and colored dog whose mother was shot by the Fish and Game in the last year. Steve Searles has followed that around for...

12:14 Four hours one time walking behind it and it just doesn't have a clue. It's dumb as a post and it's just trying to survive. So my dog has been teaching it about dogs and has got it up a tree three times. When I got back from Reds Meadows and had six ice chests on my roof, I put my dog in my car and a little bear showed up but my dog drove it off just by barking.

12:40 Steve Searles of Bear Whisperer fame is a great non-lethal control of bears. The fish and game just knows how to kill them, and they won't tell us why or how or how many or anything, and they don't cooperate with Steve Searles at all. So he's a great asset to this town. He didn't put me up to this. Right now he's out filming more episodes of his two-hour premiere of Bear Whisperer, and I think we should renew his contract because he's a superb.

13:10 Asset to this town and world famous and knows what he's doing compared to the fish and game. And I would appreciate it if Skip in particular could get the fish and game to release the bear data. That's public information and I'll be at the next wildlife committee meeting unless I'm going to Hawaii April 22nd. So if it's before then I'll be there. If not, I'll invite somebody else to be there. But we need to release that bear data. We think it's four.

13:40 And we've got these tremendous bear conservation groups working on this, but they can't get it out. And I'm not really a bear person, but I just hate to see them shot down dead, and particularly the mother of the cubs. That's incredibly stupid. But that's how the fish and game politicians are. Their biologists are just superb, and I wish they would listen to their biologists, which they don't seem to do near enough. So thank you. Jack, real quick, the next...

14:08 Wildlife Subcommittee meeting is scheduled today for, I think, Monday, August 16th. Is that right? Monday, August 16th. And I don't know if, is it 10 o'clock or 2 o'clock? Maybe Jack can check with Robyn. Yeah, I'll just check with, who should I check with? Robin. Robin. Robin, okay. I'll just check with Robin so I'll be able to attend. I have to go down five days early to acclimate my dog to my middle son.

14:38 Because she's very dependent on me. It's my seventh female German short hair pointer. And so I can go visit his older brother in Kona, Hawaii. So I'm going down four days or five days early. So I'll be there at the meeting then for sure. Thank you very much. Thank you, Jack. Is there anyone else in the public that needs to speak at this time? I have one letter that I received from a constituent of Rochelle Hare from the Eastern Sierra Tree Service.

15:10 I'm bringing this up just to try to get some clarification for her on town policy regarding tree removal. I brought it to Rob's attention. I believe Mark may be able to help us out with that. Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council. I received the letter, the same letter that you did, and Ms. Hare, who is with Eastern Sierra Tree Removal Service, has registered a complaint that we haven't been processing timely our tree removal permits.

15:44 So I spoke with Ms. Hare yesterday and let her know that I would look at the complaint and follow up. And this afternoon I went to the site with a planner and we saw the subject trees, or two disease trees, and we've approved the tree removal permit. There are some other subjects raised in the letter about how we process permits. And I've gone through our records.

16:13 And spoken to staff about the traditional method of how we obtain this over-the-counter permit and review it. And it's intended to be a very, very simple over-the-counter permit. The permit fee is $10 and the overall time frame can take approximately five days. And the idea of the permit and the intent is to make sure that people...

16:38 Who wish to remove trees actually use the permit process. So it's not meant to be a cost recovery permit at all. It's intended to take about an hour. We have a very simple application form. And as with all of our applications, we want to make sure that we know who's filing the application. So usually, in fact, with this particular tree service, they've done extensive work with us.

17:07 They have a very good reputation and we trust their work. So we typically have processed their applications very timely. What we do come into situations where we have renters of properties who wish to remove trees and the owners may or may not be aware of it. So we do seek to have some assurance that the owner of the property is...

17:33 Either represented or they have an agent involved. So again, it's a very straightforward process and typically the application is received over the counter. It's assigned to a planner. We go out and inspect the property and verify that the tree is diseased or it's a safety hazard. Perhaps it's a fire issue with a building too close or the tree too close to the building.

18:01 The planner then acts on the application and calls the applicant. So I think in this particular case that did not occur. And so we'll be addressing this in-house in terms of our procedures and also speaking with the planner involved to make sure that we follow our traditional procedures. We approve most of the tree permits issued.

18:30 In the few cases where we don't, the reason to deny a tree permit is substantially that the tree is being removed to create a view, so it's blocking somebody's view, and this has been a policy of the town, and its roots are embedded in, no pun intended, in the general plan. We try to avoid the removal of trees for the purpose of creating lawn area.

18:55 And we also view the sites to make sure it's not a wholesale removal of trees. And again, most of the applications we see are pretty straightforward, and there is some real issue associated with it. I think in the future, we'll make a modification to our application process so that there's a little checkoff so that the applicant can identify if they're

19:21 an agent representing the property owner. That checkoff is on all of our applications for other permits such as a use permit. So that's a really easy clerical thing to do. So again, I've spoken with Ms. Hare and her permit is issued and she made a number of valid points that will act on us as appropriate. Thank you, Mark. Was the fact that

19:50 She just mentioned that you guys were denying agents, and has that been addressed with Ms. Hare? Yes. So we've had a longstanding relationship with Ms. Hare and her firm, and as an agent, we typically process those applications. And again, this is meant to be a simple, easy, take an hour or less amount of staff time to achieve, and I think it's...

20:21 Not been done that way in the recent current situation, so we'll address that. Great. Thank you, Mark. Welcome. At this time, we will move on to Councilmember Reports. Before we get our reports, are there any items on the consent agenda that Councilmembers would like to poll? Yes, Mr. Mayor, I would like to poll 13 and 18. Any others? If not, Councilmember Reports. Rick, would you like to start us on?

20:55 I attended a couple of meetings. However, both of them are on the agenda as items two and that is they involve two items on the agenda, items two and nine. And so I'll defer to those agenda items. Thank you, Rick. John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'd like to request staff if we could agendize for our August 4th meeting a staff

21:25 I think I'd like to hear what the DFG's rationale is.

21:55 For not allowing us to plant there and maybe even talk with employees of the Mountain and the Twin Lakes store and to see what kind of impact it's had on them so far this summer. I'm going to give Rob my email on that. I was able to attend one meeting and I see Bing Hunt in the audience, Bing and I were there together up in Markleyville a week ago and it's the

22:25 Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. For me, the highlight of the meeting was an update on the status of the dust control efforts at Owens Lake. We were told that there are now 39.5 square miles, which represents 90% of the historic dust on the lake is now being controlled. So we're at the 90% level of controlling that dust.

22:54 There is secondarily a deadline of October 1st of this year for an additional 3.5 square miles to be controlled. That's not going to be met because the methods of control that were going to be used on that section of the lake were denied fairly recently, so they can't use that, so they're trying to determine what would be the best method to be used.

23:22 In place of those previous methods. And that's all I have. Thank you, John. Matt? Yeah, I attended a number of meetings last week. One was actually just today, touched briefly on it. It was a Chamber of Commerce meeting. Jack Copeland had made a presentation. I think he's going to present it to us all later. But it's basically an ambassador program whereby...

23:49 Thank you very much. Thank you very much.

24:19 We, being the chamber in this instance, will receive funding this year. I think it's very important to them. Funding's been limited in the past, and they just want to see at the very least the minimum. Moving forward, attended the Mammoth Lakes Tourism meeting, and a lot of what came out of that is things we've already heard already, but we're pretty excited about the fact that we have a new executive director coming on starting next week.

24:47 We look forward to hearing more on that, and I believe Mr. Erty, who's the new Executive Director, will be coming to introduce himself and whatnot. So that's all I have for this week. Thank you, Matt. Jo? Thank you. As Rick mentioned, most of the Town-County Liaison Commission meeting was about our item number two, but I'd also like to let everyone know that

25:11 The detailed data for property taxes, that big spreadsheet that everyone talks about, has been received by staff. So we have that information. And then also at the local transportation commission meeting, which Matt also attended, that commission did approve a resolution in support of the Meridian Project Tiger II grant. So we'll keep our fingers crossed.

25:37 Finally, I met earlier this week with the staff to go over some of the new website and ways to continue to improve it, and I am also getting all kinds of positive comments from the community about how Granicus, which is how these meetings are presented, is working very well. Thank you, Jo. I have nothing to add in the way of a report, but I would at this time like to make a note that we have been asked by staff to pull

26:06 Item number six, and it will be agendized for a meeting at a later date. At this time, we now have a council presentation. Hello, Dennis. So, Mayor and members of the council, this is a very historic procedure. Our park superintendent, Dennis Rockner, the first town employee to reach the 25-year mark. So, Dennis is in charge of maintaining all our parks.

26:44 I would also like to thank Dennis and on a few occasions we had an opportunity to work together.

27:15 Some projects on Main Street, and I've got to tell you, he and his crew both do it with a smile, and they're always going to help out, and we want to thank you very much for that. I'd like to present you with this Certificate of Appreciation to Dennis Rothner in recognition of 25 years of dedicated service and assistance of Mammoth Lakes, and the most important part, the check.

27:49 At this time, we will have a public presentation, the county election certification process, presented by Clerk Linda Roberts and David Wilbrecht. Good evening, I'm David Wilbrecht, the county administrator. I'm the opening act

28:19 With me tonight is Bing Hunt, our Chair of the Board, who's here to answer questions relative to politics. And I'm here to introduce Linda Roberts. Linda's been with us for, I think, a little over two and a half, maybe three years now. And her responsibilities include not only the elections, which we're going to talk specifically about tonight, but also assessment appeals, clerk of the board, and clerk recorder for all of the deeds and titles and so forth. So she carries lots of different things.

28:47 Wears lots of different hats, and so I'd like to introduce her tonight. She will introduce and talk about the elections process. We're here to answer any questions you might have, and happy to do as much as we can to improve the process. Thank you. Thank you, Dave. Good evening, Councilmembers. During the course of this past election in June, the question about the timeline for certification was asked and answered several times. So my presentation tonight, the goal of my presentation is to provide a thorough explanation

29:19 About the process and to put it in perspective with the total scope of work involved. So I have some introductory comments prior to outlining the certification process. What's important to remember is that all elections are different. Elections officials are governed by the Elections Code. And Division 10, Part 2 of the Elections Code addresses municipal elections. A municipality can hold their own elections. Consolidation is a choice, not a requirement.

29:55 And by consolidating, the municipality is asking the county elections official to run their election. The town council passed resolution number 1003 in which they requested the board of supervisors to consolidate their general municipal election with the statewide primary to be held on June 8th of this year. Section 2 of that resolution authorized the county election department to canvass the returns of the general election.

30:28 I sent a memo to the town clerk dated March 22nd of this year to confirm the timeline for completing the official campus.

30:58 And certifying the results. I also confirmed this timeline in a subsequent meeting with the town clerk and the town manager. This is a copy of the memo that was sent. On April 6th in this board of supervisors meeting, I did address the town's concerns about the timeline. The 28 days allowed put the deadline as July 6th. So I addressed those concerns with the board of supervisors. I did explain to them.

31:31 The process involved of certifying, canvassing and certifying an election and that it was my best judgment to be prudent and suggest that the election probably would be certified by July 6th and not earlier. The board supported the July 6th deadline for that certification. As I mentioned before, all elections are different and I've made this comparison between the June 3rd, 2008 primary and our recent June 8th primary so you can see some of those differences.

32:02 The total races, well first of all, the first difference is the date. The June 3rd election was in the first week of June, whereas this election was in the second week. The total races for the 2008 election was 12 versus 29, and the turnout was higher this year than in June 2008. There are many factors that impact the campus process, and these include the date of the election, as I've just mentioned in my comparison.

32:36 The time needed to count all of the races, and the number of races to be counted obviously increases the amount of time needed to get the job done. The random selection of a precinct for the 1% manual count, we have to figure that we may randomly select the precinct that has the highest number of votes. The process of checking provisional ballots, there is time needed to determine, that amount of time needed is determined by the number of ballots we receive.

33:07 And this year in June we had 83 provisional applications that we had to examine. Voter turnout makes a difference. The June 8 voter turnout ranged between precincts from 106 voters to 465 voters. And I think that will become a little clearer when I talk about the process of the 1% manual count, the difference that that makes. Whether or not the manual count matches the machine tally, that's a factor that impacts the canvas.

33:39 One of our counts was off this year. We had to recount those ballots. And then we have to have a reasonable cushion of time needed to solve potential problems. So other than the date of the election, all these other factors are variable. And so we have to use our experience and best judgment when we're trying to determine the amount of time that will be needed to complete the canvas and certify the election. Elections code section.

34:09 Section 15300 and following outlines the specific requirements of the official canvas and elections code section 15372 allows for 28 days to complete the canvas and certify the election. Because of the variable factors that I just outlined, I decided to base my decision on when I could feasibly get this election certified.

34:35 By using the maximum amount of time allowed, which is 28 days. This would allow adequate time to ensure accuracy and would also allow sufficient cushion of time to solve problems. And like I mentioned before, the Board of Supervisors agreed with that approach. So, the tasks of the official canvas are outlined in Elections Code Section 15302 and they include, but they're not limited to the following. We have to inspect all the materials and supplies that are returned by poll workers.

35:08 We have to organize an account for all the paperwork. We have to reconcile the number of signatures on the roster with the number of ballots recorded on the ballot statement and update voter history records. We have to reconcile the number of ballots counted, spoiled, canceled, or invalidated with the number of votes recorded. We have to process provisional ballots, and I believe you all got a copy of this pink form. This is our provisional ballot application form. And the way we have to

35:38 To determine whether or not a provisional vote will count is we go into our voter registration records and we have to check and double check and in this case we triple checked all the information on this form against the voter registration records because in effect we are determining whether or not somebody's vote will count and we have to be extremely careful that we make the right decision. And so if there's any question about

36:07 If a person is an inactive voter, we have to make a determination whether or not their vote should count, and the code specifies that we should give preference to the voter. So we have to be really careful, and we took our time to make sure we were very careful in checking all of those provisional ballots. We have to count any valid write-in votes, and then we report the final results to the governing board and the secretary of state as required. Additional tasks.

36:40 That are required. We have to prepare the election equipment for storage. We have to pull tapes off of the touchscreen printing machines. We have to take paper ballots out of the ballot boxes and organize those. And then we have to prepare for the 1% manual count. Elections code section 15360 talks about the 1% manual tally. 1% of the precincts in Mono County is 1 precinct, which is good news for us. If you'll refer to this chart,

37:13 This chart shows all the different ballot types that we were working with in this June election. And the number of ballot types impacts the 1% manual tally because each ballot type has a different race on it. And each race or ballot measure has to be counted once. And in the June 8th election, we had seven different ballot types. And in order to count all the races and measures one time,

37:41 We had to count four different ballot types. So the process of the manual count, 1% manual count, we randomly select one precinct, and all the races on that ballot type are counted. And then additional precincts must be selected to ensure that all of the races are included in the 1% count. We organize the ballots by party into groups of 20. We count one party at a time.

38:11 We count one race at a time. Four counters are required. One person reads the vote. One person checks the reader. And two people record the votes. After 20 ballots, the recorders compare their counts to make sure they match. If they do, we continue counting. And if they don't, we count the last batch of 20. In this past election, we randomly selected precinct number three, which is Bridgeport. That race had 321 ballots.

38:40 There were 23 races and measures on that ballot, and they are listed on the outline. And so this required that we handle 321 ballots 23 times in order to count all of those races. The additional races that we had to count included the Bishop Unified School District, that's Precinct 11, and that was 213 ballots, Supervisor District 1, Precinct 12, 465 ballots,

39:10 And then we counted Supervisor District 5, Town Council, Measure M and Measure U. That was Precinct 13 and that was 304 ballots. We handled 304 ballots four times to count those races. In an attempt to speed up the process, we tried counting Measures M and U together, but the count was off. So we had to recount Measure M. After the manual count is finished, we compare the manual count with the machine tally.

39:38 We print the final precinct and summary reports. We print the statement of vote. We complete the Secretary of State's paperwork, and we double-check reports for accuracy. And then we have to prepare the item for the board agenda. So some questions came up about this process in the June 8th election. One was, can the process be accomplished more quickly? And the answer is, it depends. And I've listed all the variables that we have to deal with in trying to determine when we can possibly get the election.

40:08 Certified, that includes date of the election, number of contests on the ballot, voter turnout, time needed to count all the races, number of ballots in the randomly selected precinct, amount of time needed to check provisional ballots, whether or not the manual count matches the machine tally, and building in a reasonable cushion of time to solve problems. A second question that came up was the certification was dated June 23rd.

40:35 Why couldn't the elections official put this on a special meeting agenda for board approval the following week? The answer is because the competing demands had earlier deadlines. And I will tell you what some of those competing demands were, but you need to understand a little bit about my office before I outline those demands. As Dave mentioned, my office wears a lot of hats. We're the clerk, which handles all the vital records. We're the recorder, which records all the property documents.

41:05 We're the registrar, obviously, elections official, and we're the clerk of the board. So my office has many obligations. Ninety percent of our workload is mandated, and we have daily, weekly, and monthly deadlines. So we are constantly working under deadlines to get our work done. So the work that had to be done during the time period of June 23rd to July 22nd included additional election paperwork,

41:29 As required by Elections Code Sections 15376 and 15401, that has to do with preparing certificates of election for the candidates who won and sending copies of the certification to the presidents, the chairs of the central committees. We had to verify signatures on a state initiative petition that had come in. I had to prepare for and attend meetings. I had unexpected staff issues which left my office shorthanded.

41:56 In the case of my office, our workload doesn't stop or wait. It gets reassigned. I had to meet with staff in order to organize our workloads. I had to continue preparing for the November election, complete a special assignment that was given to me by June 28th, assist a board member with preparing an agenda item for the July 13th meeting. I had to work on the July 6th and the July 13th board agendas. I had to prepare the July 6th board agenda and agenda packet.

42:25 I had to prepare for presentations to be made before the board at the July 6th meeting. I had to work on budget information requests, and I had to address phone calls and emails. So simply put, there was no time available to prepare an agenda item and packet of over 100 pages to take before the board in a special meeting the following week. Taking the certification to the board had to fit within the competing workload and deadlines.

42:51 So contrary to perception, I did need 28 days to complete the canvas, certify the results, and prepare the agenda item to take before the Board of Supervisors for approval. So another question is, why can't certification process be completed as fast as it was in the past? Well, the answer is that circumstances change over time. In this case, we've had equipment changes. This is computerized equipment, and it impacts our procedures.

43:21 A big impact is creating reports. It's more complicated to create these reports and it requires IT support. The Secretary of State imposes new requirements, more complicated and detailed reports. Population changes. More people potentially means more voters. We've done voter outreach to encourage people to vote, which would also impact the number of people who potentially vote. So in summary, I want to just reiterate that

43:53 It is the election official's duty to ensure the accuracy and integrity of the election. And when determining when the canvas and certification will be completed, we have to rely on our past experience. We have to review all the variables. We have to anticipate the time needed to resolve problems, anticipate the time needed to prepare an agenda item for board approval, and consider all of our other competing demands. So in conclusion, the Mono County Elections Office will continue to canvas and certify elections.

44:24 In accordance with the California Elections Code. And that is the end of my presentation. Thank you, Linda. Any questions for Linda from Council? I'd like to state to Linda, first of all, to thank you for your educational presentation tonight and also appreciation to you for the level of effort that you've made to complete your duties. My issue is not so much with the recorder.

44:54 In this situation as it might be with the Board of Supervisors in recognizing the importance and sensitivity of certifying the election for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We had an election on June 8th. We had two new council members elected. And because the election results were certified on the 23rd of June,

45:22 We had to wait two weeks until our meeting in July for the seating and swearing in of the two new council members. What that does is that puts us behind a full two weeks in being able to conduct business in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I understand that the clerk took the full 28 days that she has to do it.

45:49 But the fact is, is that the election results were certified on the 23rd of June. And in my mind, we lost two weeks in being able to move the agenda of the town of Mammoth Lakes forward because of that. I certainly appreciate your concern. And some of the options we've thought about and we certainly consider relative to what we can do, certainly the date of the election is always held by law, the first Tuesday after the first Monday of the month.

46:16 So in this particular situation, it was two weeks into the month of June before we could even begin doing the work to certify the election. So there was time constraints relative to that that we felt and we discussed tonight with you. So the only options we could have taken had we known this earlier, and the board did notify through the clerk, your manager as well as yourself, two months before the election of the timing of this. So you had ample notice to come to the board of supervisors and ask for something different.

46:44 That didn't happen. No one's fault. I think we just processed it as we always have processed it. So looking forward, the Board of Supervisors potentially could, at a request from the City Town Council, forego a meeting. Is that something that you would do for the county or vice versa? The only way we can reduce the workload is by reducing the work itself. One of the biggest workloads we have is our Board of Supervisors.

47:09 That we have to meet as well as your town manager does for you. So that system is in place. It takes a lot of effort and time to produce that. If we didn't do a board meeting at some point during that election certification, that would pick up a full week of work for the clerk to do election work rather than board of supervisor work. So it's really a work management kind of perspective. And I suspect and would recommend to you that you're going to have a lot more.

47:36 Clout than I would necessarily have with the Board of Supervisors if the Town Council would request the county to run the elections to request that the board do certain things, including have a special meeting to certify early. Both your board, your council, and our board can hold a special election with a 24-hour notice to the public. So that's a simple thing that both parties can do based upon understanding that it's a requirement or a request to do that.

48:03 The other thing is if there's a workload requirement, if the election comes late or if there's a problem with it, and you anticipate the problem, make a request that the board not do meetings for a couple of Tuesdays. Now, the board would have to agree to do that. I certainly can't decide to cancel a board meeting, but the board itself can. When they do that, they can give the clerk of the board time to work on other items. So for us, it's purely a time management problem. And for you, I understand the concern about losing two weeks.

48:31 In the future, I think there may be some solutions for it, but I think, and you wouldn't want us to compromise the outcome of the election. For our election, Larry Johnston won over Bill Sauser by five votes. It would be a horrible thing to know that we had made a mistake and that it wasn't five votes. It was two votes or three votes or seven votes, and the election had turned around in some fashion. So we're very careful. Obviously, there's lots of procedures and policies and processes that will follow.

48:58 But we'll do with anything within our powers to make it work for the town. But I think what we tried to do is give you ample notice of our timing, and you have the notice. And so coming into it late after the process, we can't necessarily change because everything is in motion. If I can address that, Dave. I don't think there's anyone in this room that's questioning doing the elections appropriately into law. That's a non-issue. Anything that Ms. Roberts mentioned tonight?

49:27 Not a question of that. My question is, historically, there has been a courtesy between the board and the council to hold special elections when appropriate. We saw, a number of us saw this, train wreck is too strong of a word, but we saw this occurrence coming beforehand. I personally talked to board members. Our town manager personally talked with county staff.

49:56 Before the election, during the month of June, because we anticipated this coming on, didn't expect that we had to make a formal request of the board or of the county to have this agendized to have a special meeting. We've spent how much time here tonight, of staff time, both yours and your clerks. I'm assuming your clerks spent time preparing for tonight.

50:25 Preparing for the town-county liaison committee meeting and going to that. I just think that this is one of those simple things that in the future, if we anticipate something like this, that we can resolve it through special meetings both with the council and with the board of supervisors. That's all I'm asking for. Well, I think that's certainly possible. Okay, thank you. Other questions or comments? Other questions? No. Thank you very much, Dave.

50:53 If there are no other comments regarding that, we will move on to our public hearing. Item number three, 2009 Community Development Block Grant for the Mammoth Lakes Child Care Facility Schematic Design, and I will open the public hearing with a staff presentation. Thank you, Mayor, members of the Town Council. As indicated in the Agenda Bill, the Town applied for a Planning and Technical Assistance Grant.

51:21 Thank you, Rob. Any questions for Rob?

51:55 Just a clarification that it says we are accepting this, but this is still at a conceptual level. These are not actual building drawings or anything that would be under a use permit? That's correct. At this time, we will ask for any presentation by the property or the appellate. If there is none, questions from the town council, anything additional? Any further testimony for or against or?

52:31 Comments? My only just a thought is depending on the determination of the location and the continued use of the ice rink at its present location, they might want to consider relocating the location of the center where the ice rink is currently depending on what transpires. Any additional?

53:02 It was actually a thought that crossed my mind, too. It seemed like if that were possible, assuming that it goes that direction, we'd be able to eliminate probably a need to put in a road and a few other things. I'm wondering if this concept would actually fit on this ice rink site, assuming that the ice rink didn't move forward. Further comments? Okay. If none, it doesn't appear there's going to be any rebuttal to previous testimony, since there wasn't any previous testimony.

53:38 I will close the public hearing and ask for Town Council to deliberate the matter. Discussion from Town Council? Do I hear a motion? Mr. Mayor, I'll move to accept the child care facility schematic design as proposed, noting the suggestions by Council Members Lamb and Eastman. I have a motion. Do I have a second? Second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie.

54:15 Council Member Eastman? Yes. Council Member Lane? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We will move on to Item Number 4, Establishment of a Medical Marijuana Cooperative Permit Application Fee. I will open the public hearing and ask for staff presentation. At the June election, the local measure, Measure M, was before the voters, and the voters approved

54:45 The establishment of two marijuana cooperatives. And also during June, the town approved and adopted an ordinance that established the rules and regulations for medical marijuana cooperatives. The sections of the ordinance detail that each subject will be subject to background checks, Department of Justice criminal history checks, fingerprints, DMV,

55:13 Floor plans, security plans, lighting plans are subject to review by the police chief and will be part of the police chief's consideration of which applicants are the best qualified. The municipal code also permits the establishment and collection of fees for services that are provided by the town. Right now the police is estimating that two hours is the needed timeline to complete all of the required background and business plan review.

55:45 And the police department is asking council to consider establishing the medical marijuana cooperative permit application fee of $300. And attached to your agenda bill is actually a resolution, and so if I could suggest modifying option one to approve the attached resolution that establishes the fee for a medical marijuana cooperative permit fee. Thank you, Brad. Any questions with Brad? John?

56:13 $300 figure, is that comparable with other municipalities as far as you know? I don't know. Okay. Thank you. My question is, is this an annual fee? I believe the ordinance requires for an existing cooperative to reapply each year, and so the permit fee then would therefore be annual, and that's also why the resolution

56:44 Even though it's estimated that the current cost is $300, it's based on cost accounting so that the police department, after they have history of how long the review process takes, they can adjust the fee accordingly. Any questions? No? If there are no further questions of staff, any presentation by the property owner or appellant for or against? If I see none.

57:21 We will then close the public hearing and ask for council deliberation. Mr. Mayor, I would move for approval of option number one. I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second for the deliberation. With none, roll call please, Jamie. Would council consider the modified option one that actually approves the resolution establishing the fee?

57:49 So amended. So second amended. Councilmember Eisman? Yes. Councilmember Lemon? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Porton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Moving on to item number 5, budget format contract process. Staff presentation, please. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll just make a brief introduction. At your last meeting, Deb Perel and Joyce Turner presented a draft proposal to prepare

58:21 An analysis of budget formats for your review, and they have since provided a more detailed proposal, and I think at this point I'll just turn the podium over to them, and they can describe their proposal to you. Mayor, Town Council, community members, I believe you have a copy of the contract and the proposal that we outlined. Our goal is really to volunteer our time to help come up with a better format, timeline, and process for the budgeting.

59:00 And I notice you have some options in the agenda bill offered to you, and I wanted to address a couple of those briefly. With the choices, staff recommends choice number one. And I want to outline that the cost that we outlined was a quick dissertation of as much as we could imagine that it could have cost of $5,000. We don't see it coming close to that. That would include any supplies or outreach meetings.

59:29 Meeting costs, calls, public awareness, placement of ads and papers. We don't think that will be even touched, but it's a good safe number to cover us since we're just looking for our out-of-pocket costs to be covered if we...

59:43 It's a pretty nominal amount overall, especially considering we're volunteering our time in six months to try to benefit the community with this. I'll mention our deliverables specifically, that we plan to offer up independent kickoff workshops with you, the Town Council, to understand what you'd like to see in it, as well as updates, ongoing updates.

1:00:10 Understand from the staff their current budgeting information and needs that they may perceive that we'll run into that we need to include. And the community. We're envisioning an outreach of a day or so where we hold a few meetings throughout the day or two days to get input from the community as to what they'd like to see. All recommendations by you. We will research to make sure that we're meeting government requirements and that we look to comparable communities to find best practices.

1:00:37 Our deliberables include that we will have a table of contents with all the section descriptions, that it will be a bi-department work program tied to the budget as recommended by Town Council, that we use an Excel or other appropriate budget number template, and that our budget has a monthly variance report that rolls up

1:00:58 As a year-to-date for monthly variance reports from the town to the council on an ongoing basis, all to help with the budget to make it transparent and so on. So I just wanted to mention that and say that the number one really wasn't in our proposal because we think we'll have minimal out-of-pocket costs and we don't want to spend our time coming to have staff prepare information and come to you for minimal costs. We really don't see it even hitting the $5,000 target. We just kind of covered our...

1:01:28 Our what-ifs. And you'd mentioned that in your previous presentation. Yeah. And so we're recommending that you choose number two, and we're happy to work with the community, and I'm going to turn it over to Joyce at this time. It's in the first part. I don't have a lot to add to what Deb was saying, but I do, you know, I do hope that we make this as an efficient and streamlined process as possible. You do have the option to

1:01:57 Accept or reject whatever it is we come back to you with. We will come back to you on a monthly basis if that would serve your purpose as well to report as to where we are and what direction this format is going so that you can comment and say, no, we like that, or yes, we like that, or no, we don't like that, and we can adjust as necessary. So in my experience, most towns and town managers have authorization to spend a lot more than $5,000.

1:02:25 Without having to come back to Council. And I agree with Deb. If that becomes part of the process, considering we're volunteering our time, that might get a little overwhelming. And we're not interested in succeeding. We're looking for a win-win for us, for the community, us being the community, for staff and for the Council. And we are looking to invest our time wisely. So we look forward to helping you out if you so choose. Thank you. Hang on, Joyce, if you would. Questions for Joyce or Deb?

1:02:54 I had a question actually up in the analysis discussion. I just want to clarify something with Deb and Joyce. There's mention here a contract would be managed by one member of staff in consultation with other staff members as needed. And I don't know if I get clarification from staff on this or what, but as I understand it, it was supposed to be independent of staff.

1:03:21 If we're using the term managed, I guess I just want a clarification of what that means. All contracts with the town are managed by someone at the town staff level. That is not meaning that we are involved in the process. It's just that when there is a point person at the town and they have questions, we can arrange for whatever information or needs that they may have. Okay. That was the intent I talked about. Okay. Thank you.

1:03:47 I have one question for you. In trying to kind of look down the road to completing this and being successful at this, I'm not real clear, I guess, on what it is we're going to be doing, and are we going to possibly be looking at having to purchase, say, new software to run our applications, and if so, what is the anticipated cost to that software? I know that sometimes it gets quite pricey. We've not gone to the extent of researching that.

1:04:14 That level of detail with the software. But it's been my experience that most often, even when I manage large construction projects, it comes down to an Excel spreadsheet. So we're going to look for the most cost-effective alternative. We're going to work with staff to see what software systems they're using currently to comply with all the government requirements and everything else that we have to do relative to budgeting and software. And if there was any reason we thought we were coming

1:04:43 Up with something that was going to be a high ticket item that for some reason we were just compelled to recommend, you certainly would know about that very, very early, but the intention is the most cost effective, easy to use template system we can possibly come up with that's transparent for the community, that's readable for the council in the community, and that staff can work with to help them.

1:05:07 Through their expenditures throughout the year. And so in your mind, what would you consider to be a high-ticket item? Well, if I may add to what she said, we already have input from 20 cities that we researched, and mostly in California, but in and out resort communities as well, and most of them use Access or Excel, which we already have.

1:05:29 Okay. A few people do use a budgeting software. We would certainly in our research do our due diligence, but at this point, we don't know, but we don't really foresee an expenditure on budgeting software. Okay. Thank you. Wait, don't go away yet. So if I understand essentially what you're saying is take Excel to...

1:05:52 Take the data that gets crunched in all the detail and present it in a more usable format with projections and all of that.

1:06:00 Is that what you're saying? We're researching before we commit to anything. Okay. Our research will be important to what we offer up as alternatives to get your input and suggestions. We hope it's a very transparent and communicative process. Again, we offer community outreach. We hope to have community outreach. We hope to share with you in the beginning and to see what you'd like out of it. So to answer your question, yes, a format that is readable, that you can drill down and understand line items, a format that allows for

1:06:30 I'm sorry, I do have to ask another question of staff because I'm not sure that I understand the section of the section

1:06:57 Of option two where it says that if we used part of the surplus we would have to find some other place and we haven't decided what to do with the surplus yet so that doesn't make any sense to me. Right. The issue is that obviously this has not been budgeted in our proposed budget and we're working on an operating month-to-month budget at this moment so you have the choice of funding it and that is not

1:07:24 Out of the question. The problem is where do you want the money to initially come from as your final decision tonight so that we can program it into our month-to-month budget. So at the moment the only available revenue is in the surplus category because you haven't adopted a full budget yet. And I understand that but I don't understand why that would necessarily cause a reduction if we haven't allocated any of that surplus yet.

1:07:51 You have not, but in the proposed budget, we had allocated all funds. So at this point, you have the freedom to be able to allocate whatever you wish because there is no final published budget. As a follow-up, Jo, we can budget it either on a surplus or if the council is not comfortable with that, we could budget it out of our council discretionary. Discretionary, yeah. No, I just didn't see, you know, if we hadn't allocated the rest, but anyway. Okay.

1:08:23 I understand your point. I guess in my question of view is can we look at our finance, since this is financially related, should we look at our financial budget and see if we can find it somewhere in the financial budget? They have options. Yeah. So that would be something we would probably look at. Okay, further council discussion? Does anyone like to make a motion? I'll make a motion, Mr. Mayor, and that is that the council adopt option two as stated in the agenda bill.

1:08:55 I have a motion. Do I have a second? I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Further discussion? If none, call for the question. Call for the vote. Call for the vote. Mr. Member Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon? Yes. Mayor Hardy? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We'll move on to item number 7.

1:09:23 But Jay, there's completion of Paver Plaza and other features at the Vulcan Brothers Skate Park at Trails End Park. Peter? Mayor, Councilmembers, the Skate Park facility was beginning construction in 2004 and the facility was accepted by the town in 2005. At the July 5, 2010 Council meeting, staff was directed to bring back this report after meeting with Jane Baer.

1:09:53 And the foundation to review their facilities that they would like to see completed before their event in August. And we have done that. And these are kind of the interim facilities that they would like. And then there's additional work that would be in a Measure R grant measure in the fall. This included the Dome River Plaza, which is adjacent to the existing plaza going from the eastern side of the skate park.

1:10:21 Cleaning up the entry skate wall with the rock facing. Fortunately, that now still is masonry block. Plaster coating the south face of the skate wall near the plaza. That's the rough concrete surfaces that you see from the plaza area and the bike path street side. Install some shrubs and wildflowers in the planter area between the skate park and the plaza.

1:10:47 And then connect the irrigation pipes that were previously installed with the drip system to water those plants. With that, staff put together some cost estimates and man hour estimates for various options to complete the work with some very brief discussions and we didn't get formal cost proposals from our current maintenance contracts.

1:11:14 We estimated that the paver curb, which is a retaining curb between the bike path and the paver plaza, similar to the one that's out there, an existing paver plaza, is a cost of about $5,000. The paver installation is about $3,000. The irrigation and planting is about $10,000. Rock facing is about $2,000. Plaster coat, about $2,000. And then they install a concrete pad and a beat.

1:11:41 The benches that have already been fabricated is about $1,500. With that, there's various staffing options which using our maintenance staff this summer essentially would severely impact existing parks with ongoing maintenance for field preparation mowing. August and late July are really the busiest months for our parks.

1:12:07 With that, there's significant impact. But for the paver curb, it's about four men, three days of work. The paver installation is probably about eight men, two weeks. The irrigation planning is about four men, one week. And that's also connecting the irrigation system. Rock facing the wall and the plaster coat itself is about three men a week. And then the

1:12:35 The paver, I mean the concrete pad and the benches is really two minutes, a couple of days. But as I said, there would be a pretty big impact on existing facilities. The Parks Maintenance Crew really is six people that are roaming between the parks, cleaning the bathrooms twice a day, and the other facility maintenance for that. The other option is to advertise and hire a new contractor.

1:13:07 Basically do our normal bidding process. With that, the earliest award date would be August 18th. So that really is not feasible if the intent is to get the work done prior to the event on the 28th or 29th. Fourth option is to work with Jane and try to get some additional contractors to do work at no cost. And essentially they're proposing that they would provide all the materials.

1:13:37 To support the labor that would take to install these features. With that, staff did identify at least one option for financing, which would be to allocate up to $50,000 from the street rehab fund. And essentially that could impact the spring work when we purchase materials that are really for next year's road rehab system.

1:14:08 Thank you. Peter, any questions for Peter? And Jay Berry is here to speak if there's questions. Peter, I have a question. On option one, where it says request cost for postals from one of our existing maintenance contractors, why would we not request from both and see who gave us the better price? No, we would actually, we haven't actually done a formal request until we got direction from council. Okay, but. We would request it from both. So we could at least, yeah, okay. Right. Then on.

1:14:37 Would like to do worse. Okay. On the irrigation and planting, I don't know that I understand if the paver area would require the irrigation to be done right now. The paver? You know, could the other areas be done and the irrigation and planting be held off since, you know, we're going to be looking at putting stuff in the ground where it has six weeks before winter comes? Yeah, that could be.

1:15:07 Done later. So it's not like the irrigation runs under where the pavers are going to go, so we would have to put it in now. No. When we put the, when the town did its portion of the work at the park, including the parking lot and the infrastructure, the restaurant facility, we put in a pipeline and the electrical that goes all the way around to the back of the escape park. And so for the irrigation part, we didn't hook it up since there wasn't a plan at that time to actually irrigate and plant plants since it might freeze or break.

1:15:36 Over a few years. So the pipe's in the ground, but the connections are made. And you're right, that work can certainly be deferred later. John? I'm just throwing this out. Would it be appropriate to, if we decide to fund this project at the $50,000 level, would it be appropriate to take it out of this current year $7.50 for the road rehab with the caveat that when, I think when,

1:16:07 Or if there's a revenue surplus in this budget, which we won't know until 10 months from now, which 10 months from now would still be early enough before we ordered the material to do road payment, that the first $50,000 of that revenue surplus would go to reimburse this particular fund. Before we get to discussion on where the finding keeps coming from, are there any further questions for Peter?

1:16:37 I have a question. I don't know if it's for Peter or Jane, but I'm wondering, you have an event coming up, and I'm wondering how crucial is it to have these items for the event. My reason I ask the question is if we can live without it, and I believe in the project, but I know one of the concerns that's come up is we have the park that's going to be completed next door.

1:17:07 You know, we start putting benches in now. You know, it may not be consistent with the plan we're going to have for the rest of the park and perhaps even the paper and some other things too. So that's my question. I mean, I believe in the park and I believe in the success of the event, but I'm just wondering how much it will impact the event if you don't have these right now. Well, we've held the event before with that.

1:17:33 Without them. So that tells you something. But what we're trying to do is finish the park so it has a better, it's more aesthetically pleasing. Also, we have been collecting and selling pavers. We have three orders worth of pavers that have stockpiled. So it's been two years since any of the pavers have been put in. So mainly what we're hoping for is to mainly have the pavers done.

1:18:03 Also, your concern about having uniform park benches and things, I don't necessarily know if that applies. The scaper park was the first public arts project, and the idea of the scaper park was that it was supposed to be aesthetically pleasing and be something, kind of an artwork. And so, when you see the

1:18:29 Benches and pavers that we're planning on putting in. They're pavers that are park benches and things that have been designed by an artist, the same artist that did the railings and that type of thing in the park. The event that's coming, it's two-part. The Volcom skateboard team is coming as part of the Volcom jean tour, and they're going to be doing a demonstration.

1:18:54 Also on the same day, Steve Klassen does his yearly amateur contest, which I would say has about 250 participants, and probably I'm not sure quite how many more spectators. But the idea is that we are trying to get these things completed this summer. Thank you. Other questions? A little bit of information about the location of the specific header.

1:19:25 So as you're looking at the skate park, this is the portion of all these features are really between the skate park that exists and the property line to the east with the forest service. So this work really doesn't impact the rest of the park for completion of the play area and those kinds of features. I guess my concern was just would it be consistent because I think part of a bigger plan was to have something that would flow as opposed to having one.

1:19:52 The part that looks completely different from the other, and that was my only question. This is the important part right now, and the papers are done to here, and so we're talking about putting the papers around as far as they go. Now is this where the skaters will access this area over here?

1:20:16 Versus having to go in a bowl? Yes. Okay, so what are they using now to get over there? It's dirt. Oh, it's dirt, so they have to pick it up and carry it? So basically they're going along here and they're not using these areas for season. Okay, thank you. Peter? Peter, the paver installation cost of $30,000, that would include removal of the...

1:20:43 Dirt that's currently there, bringing in sand, and then installing the pavers. Yeah, so it's regrading that whole area, flattening down, compacting the base. Okay. And that $30,000 is just for labor? Just for labor. Okay. It seems like that might be a little bit high. I thought it would be. We've got to remember it. We'll find out in the big process. And it doesn't preclude either one of them from using subcontractors. You know, they can get any subcontractors they'd like.

1:21:12 Yeah. Thank you. Terry? Councilmembers, I guess I just have a concern since the benches had came to the commission for Measure R, it wasn't something that we came up with, but staff came up with the fact that these benches may not be appropriate to be put in that park. So I don't know if something's changed with the design.

1:21:44 Or we received incorrect information to start with. But I guess that would still be a concern if you guys are looking at financing the benches. And boy, if you found some extra newfound money, there's that $25,000 that's needed to finish the other 30% of the planning so we can actually move forward with the whole part. Terry, before you go, I'm really interested in knowing because I

1:22:14 Either have forgotten if you've told me or I haven't known what involvement the commission has had in reviewing this and whether it has a recommendation as to whether we go forward without considering or without it being a part of a larger plan. And I don't mean larger plan for the park, but... Just a complete plan? Yes.

1:22:38 No, it wasn't brought to us for this part of it because it was brought to the council at your last meeting early July and it was never brought back to us. Thank you. Could someone explain about the benches for us? I believe, and this is for some memory because I wasn't actually involved in this discussion about the benches, but

1:23:13 There was a concern, Dennis had a, Rodner had a concern about consistency with our existing benches throughout our park system. We have, that have backs and the graded surface that, basically they're pretty indestructible and easy to replace. When they get damaged, they're really, okay, we take it out and we just put in a brand new bench. The benches that Jane is really talking about don't have any backs at all, they're just flat.

1:23:43 Bench that doesn't have the head entrapment features that Dennis was concerned about. So I think that is a little change and that was really because Dennis didn't, hadn't looked at the benches, they were up for a bit, but during they were, I think when they were up for exhibit, either he was out of town or something during that time. So the benches were actually funded out of public art? The artist who did the benches was

1:24:11 An artist picked by the public art, but he built the benches and built the foundation paper. Oh, okay. And the benches were temporarily installed for the last two minutes, so people could use them. So we are the purchase of the benches. And they were, I don't know if you looked at the tapes that I made you last time, it was actually a picture of the bench. So they aren't,

1:24:43 I think Del Jain basically at this point would just like to see the pavers is what I understand. Yeah, I'd like to state that the pavers have been coming in over the last two years and we physically have them. They've been paid for by the foundation and I would like to see us as a minimum.

1:25:10 Do the pavers, installation, put in the paver curb, do the rock facing and the plaster coat, and limit the price not to the $50,000 or $60,000, but to $30,000, the authorization to $30,000. And again, if for nothing else, to show good faith, certainly to the process. And then that would give us time to vet the discussion on the benches.

1:25:40 Between now and probably late winter or early spring. And also I think it's appropriate to, I mean, this was not presented last month or two months ago when it was brought before, was it measure, which measure? Measure R. Measure R committee because Jane was having an operation and wasn't able to attend to give a presentation at that.

1:26:12 I think that it's something that will eventually be approved to be done and again I would like to take it out of our road paving rehabilitation budget on a temporary basis depending upon what the outcome is of the fall discussion on distribution of those funds.

1:26:37 And also, if it stays in road rehabilitation, then again, have the caveat that that $30,000 would be repaid with the first $30,000 revenue surplus from this year's budget in the spring. Further comments from council? You know, it's always hard to say no to Jane.

1:27:04 And, John, what I'm hearing is that you want to do two-thirds or three-quarters of the project because it's important and that you don't want it to automatically come out of Measure R money. I just have two thoughts. One is, this was, this is a proposal that wasn't funded. And so it has now come directly to council. And, you know, we have,

1:27:34 We have a commission and we have a committee that decides on how the funds, or at least recommends how the funds ought to be expended. I mean, I don't oppose the expenditure of the funds, but it seems to me that this could be seen as, in effect, a backdoor way to get money when you've been denied before, and it's not making me feel very comfortable, not because the project is not worthy, but because

1:28:03 A decision was made, a process, whether it was a good one or a bad one, was completed and we're going to have a process again. This seems to me that this is driven by or because we've got a major event that brings a lot of people and dollars and recognition and advertising and so on to the town. I mean, I get all of that. I'm just really concerned about the process and specifically because

1:28:31 The only other comment I'd make is

1:28:59 You know, we've used the term, I've used the term austerity budget many times, and that means that we're going to be saying no a lot. And it means that we're going to be denying requests, and it means that people aren't going to get everything that they want. So, frankly, I'm sort of struggling with it and looking for some direction from other council members on what the right approach should be. Both your points, real quick, are excellent and should be considered, and they're totally valid. My only point, and

1:29:28 You recently personally had an operation, and it's my understanding that Jane Bear had her operation previously scheduled was on the day that she was to make a presentation for the funding. So I think that she, part of the reason that she was not given the funding in that last round this spring was because she wasn't present to give her presentation because of personal operation. Circumstances that were out of her control, if you will.

1:30:00 One of the first things I wrote down is I just, like Rick, I have concerns that, you know, what happens when we start circumventing the process? You know, we start setting a precedent for everybody to do that, and I'm wondering how we eventually cut that off. At the same time, I've been in Jane's position where, you know, we were in dire need of some funding because of an event coming up, and it did end up rewarding.

1:30:27 Not only the event, but the town in the long run. So, you know, I too am struggling with it and where we go with this. And we're in such a tight budget already. And we've already, you know, really denied our streets, you know, from what was optimum or ideal. A million dollars, we've already dropped down to $750. And now we're going to drop it down to $7. So that's a concern of mine. I do like your...

1:30:55 Comment about replenishing it immediately, assuming that there is some surplus, but again, we are assuming a surplus, so all really good points. I just need a second to digest, I guess, a little more. Jo? I actually need to ask another question of our tourism rec commissioner that's in the back, is that this does not look to me like the same as what was applied for in the spring cycle. You're correct. What was applied for in the spring cycle was for the benches and for shade.

1:31:31 Okay, so this is something that did not even get considered by tourism and rec. We are kind of in an interesting or weird situation. And the fact is, is that the Skipper Park was built with donations. And we got this park there.

1:32:00 And actually what ended up happening is we hit a time point when as the construction was going on we no longer had insurance. And so on November 1st we had to quit working on the skateboard park and turn the skateboard park over to the town. Since that time, now that the town owns the park, we aren't allowed to work on the park. And my group continues to raise money.

1:32:31 And we had done our plan. We've tried to follow the guidelines. I made a presentation to the Parks and Rec Commission. I applied for Measure R funds in the fall. I applied again in the spring. So my group has been trying to follow the proper chain of command.

1:33:00 We are not getting the chance to do any work on the park because you have very strict rules about who can work on the park. John Eastman can explain to you that when we first did the pavers, John Eastman's crew donated it and put the pavers down.

1:33:25 Our problem is is that we can't work on the park at all unless we have your approval. So each time we come to Parks and Rec for approval or come to somebody for approval and we don't get it, we have to wait again and again and again and again.

1:33:52 The only times, the second time the pavers were put in, we had to come and ask you to do it, and that you did the second group. So that's part of our problem, is that we continually raise money. We raised $75,000 last year alone. We had hoped to ask for matching funds, would have given us $150,000.

1:34:19 We were hoping to finish the park completely this year. We were turned down, and I don't know if Terry would say this, if we were turned down, not on the merit of our project, but because of the fact that we were tied to the trails in park. And what they're looking for is to complete the trails in park.

1:34:44 But the problem is we're not the trails in park. We're the skate park. And it's kind of hard for us to be turned down because we're being lumped in with something else. And if you have any questions, I'm more than happy to answer. Jo? I'm wondering, Jane, if you say you've been raising money, is there any opportunity that you'd be willing to split the cost of this? Well, we've actually purchased the pavers.

1:35:13 Which is about $12,000. We've offered to pay for all the dirt because it has to be dug out and compacted and all the sand. So that's what we were asking for. The other thing is that I'm really hoping that when you do go out for bid that this is going to come in at a lot less money.

1:35:42 My guess is she's probably wanting to use that money so they can get matching funds as well. Well, and I'm just wondering if she considers matching with us. Right. She is in the sense that she's providing materials. Right. And that's been the thing that we've done all along is that in the past four years we've provided materials and the town has provided the labor. As a matter of fact, the last time that we did this project we used the option number two where

1:36:12 Right, Peter? Right, the town workers provided the labor. Is it fair to say, and I think it's an important point, and I think Jane tried to make that point, is that it was turned down by the commission not based upon its worthiness, if you will, as a project. It was turned down because it was felt by the majority of the commission members that they would prefer to get their parks master plan done.

1:36:43 Prior to doing any additional enhancements on it until that's done. The only problem with that is when is that going to be done? Is it going to be done in six months or two years? You know, John, that was going to be my question to staff. How long have we been working on the parks master plan? When did we first start that? I don't think they were really asking for the overall master plan to be done, but the master plan for this particular park. When did we start the parks master plan then? Parks master plan.

1:37:13 That parks plan more particularly. I think it's been two years. The town-wide recreation plan? Yeah, that's about two years. Okay. Okay, then. But really what they were asking for is for this particular parks master or designed to be completed and bring it back as a measure of our grant. But it wasn't really discussed about completing this eastern section of the skate park as a specific item. Okay, thank you, Peter. Wait, don't leave.

1:37:41 So the plans that I saw when I was a planning commissioner for Trails End Park are not plans? Yeah, it's the overall, that is the concept plan is done and what the commission was looking at was to finish the design plans and then have it segmented so that as measure our grant opportunities come up, it could be funded in an incremental way.

1:38:08 It was, it made sense. Okay, but since that time, which would have been sometimes between 2006 and 2008, it hasn't risen to the surface? Yeah, the only difference, I think, between the concept plan and Jane's plan really is the Little Brothers skate park and how that fits in between the playground equipment. But the easterly side of the park where all this work is contemplated is consistent with that concept plan.

1:38:39 I think I tend to agree with John about the items that we can pick out here to address as far as trying to get it done this year. I would put the concrete pad and the benches in on it but still keep that $30,000 cap because I do think the $30,000 amount for the pavers is extremely high and we might be able to get everything except for the irrigation and planning done for that $30,000. As far as, Rick, you're concerned about the process.

1:39:09 Setting a precedence almost of people coming back to us when they don't get their money. I can fully agree with you, but I think as we fine-tune that process, I will have more faith in it than being able to sit here and say the process worked the way we had hoped it would work. It came off the way we thought it should, and that we probably at this point will rely on the judgment of that panel.

1:39:35 To make those awards and give it. And we won't be accepting any additional requests at council level. The other thing is that as far as the events go, this event, you know, a lot of times when we do things in this town, we do it based on the value it brings to us overall. And the events they hold down there, no doubt about it, worldwide, worldwide.

1:40:03 Coverage. We've got air service. We want to start bringing in. We're a destination resort. We want to bring these people in. And you see that in France and in Germany and places around the world. And those kids, when they come to California, they want to come to the number two skate park in the world and ride it and be able to tell their friends they did. So when the mountain does a large event, such as their downhill ski, very few people come to actually see them.

1:40:29 But the media coverage on things like that far exceeds the cost to put it on. And I think what we would be getting for our $30,000 in media coverage and world...

1:40:40 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:41:07 Are you to replenish that? But we have another $288,000 sitting there that we were going to go to more planning. And I am finished, I'm not finished planning, but I would like to see some projects such as the skate park, such as some other projects we've started in town, get to a level where they become maintenance issues and just maintain them. They're at a world-class level where people come and see them.

1:41:33 We can be proud of it. They see a completed project, not one that's after half-paid, and they have to work around it. So I think this is a small amount to pay to get that part to that level and get the attention from the world that we will get by doing so. If I understand, then, Skip, you're suggesting that it come from the Measure U that is the one-time surplus of the existing Measure U. How much can you consider as we go through our budget discussions in that area? So, in other words, to approve it now and decide on the...

1:42:03 Funding? Yes. Okay, I can go with that. At the reduced amount? Yes. Just as a side note, it's semi-interesting. Last weekend I was walking in Yosemite and stopped at the mobile mart and had dinner and saw a guy by himself on a motorcycle and he had his skateboard strapped to his back. And also when I flew on the airline this spring, saw a guy coming up from Southern California.

1:42:34 And had his backpack and his skateboard on his backpack. So, you know, not huge numbers, but here's two instances that were remarkable enough to me that stood out that here's two guys with skateboards coming to Mammoth. Further deliberation? Do I hear a motion? Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve an adjusted option number one and approve an amount

1:43:03 Not to exceed $30,000 to do the paver curbing, paver installation, rock facing plaster coating, and install concrete pad and benches in an amount not to exceed $30,000 and to direct council to consider taking that amount of money from the Measure U surplus of $288,000.

1:43:35 I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second. Jamie, roll call. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Now, when you started talking about the marketing, I was going to say, oh, you're going to ask for Measure A funds? No, no, no. Item number 8, budget policy decisions related to Measure A funding.

1:44:05 Thank you, Mayor and members of the Town Council. As is indicated in the initial part of this agenda bill, there's a number of budget policy decisions before you that relate to use of Measure A funds. I believe that we have translated all of those into a decision table which appears on pages 5 and 6 of your agenda bill tonight.

1:44:30 So rather than referring to specific budget policy decisions that are either in notebooks or other places, we'll be referring to the decision table when we get to that point. But first, I'd like to kind of describe this item from a higher, more philosophical level. As you know, Measure 8 is a combination of TOT, that's hotel tax, and business license tax.

1:45:01 That were committed politically to tourism and marketing over the years as voter measures were submitted to the voters approving the revenue sources. And over time, those funds have been put to uses by various town councils, which they believed were consistent with those political commitments.

1:45:27 In terms of doing things that advance the tourism cause or put heads in beds. And the current set of uses of Measure A are a set of uses that have evolved over a fairly long period of time. And some of those are uses that have ongoing contracts or are sort of an ongoing commitment of the town.

1:45:52 We have made a decision over the past couple of years to change our strategy as to how we use Measure A funds. While historically it's been done as a town department and the decisions have been made by the town council as how to allocate funds, now we have formed Mammoth Lakes Tourism for a number of reasons and are turning that decision process over

1:46:18 to Mammoth Lakes Tourism to decide what is the best use for funds. And so I think where we find ourselves is in somewhat of a transition where on one hand we have these commitments or ongoing funding levels that have developed historically and on the other hand we have a new organization that may want to be using funds differently going forward based on their perception of what's the best way to market the town.

1:46:48 The purposes of forming the DMO are several. One is to get the business community more involved in marketing the community. And what we found is these private sector or non-governmental sector organizations such as Mammoth Lakes Tourism tend to engender a lot more participation by the business community in their activities. But secondly, the experience in other resorts is that

1:47:15 Although the municipality provides some of the money for programs, the DMOs, the destination marketing organizations, are also able to produce their own money. And I need to apologize to you. I know the chart on page three is completely illegible because of the black and white copy, so I'd like to give you another copy of that. This chart is the preliminary results of a survey we've been conducting to see

1:48:00 What the municipal contributions and the total budgets of other DMOs are. And as you can see, in many cases, the DMOs have very significant sources of other sources of funding beyond the share provided by the cities or municipalities therein. And our hope is, and our goal is, and one of the reasons for creating the DMO is to get ourselves in that position where we leverage that which we provide from TOT and business license tax.

1:48:27 In order to create a bigger pie and do more things. So the DMO, as I said, is embarking on their own decisions about how to use Measure A funds. They've presented to the Town Council a strategic directions report, which they had adopted in December and outlines in very broad brush terms how they plan on moving ahead. We just entered into a letter of intent with the DMO.

1:48:59 Indicating that it's our intent to give them all of our Measure A funds and that it's our intent to enter into a contract with them that governs what their responsibilities are when they receive those funds. The letter of intent includes a couple of deliverables. Two of these are an annual destination marketing plan and an annual budget. And those are things that are yet to be done for the current year by the DMO.

1:49:26 So they're in their early stages. Their executive director is coming on board in the next week, and those will get started soon. So as we later go through the decision table that's on pages five and six, I think our conclusion was it's not really fair to expect Mammoth Lakes Tourism to continue to fund programs that they feel are not of great value for marketing.

1:49:58 And maybe to make their own decisions on what they do think are important. On the other hand, the town doesn't have the resources to just take over everything that they don't want to fund at this point in time. So sort of the broad brush general recommendation that I'm making to you is that this may be something that needs to be worked out over a year's period of time. And that our recommendation from staff is that you consider

1:50:25 Requiring continuity of some of these Measure A programs over the course of the next year with the understanding that there will be various discussions and I've outlined some ideas on how those might occur over the course of the next year to sort out what Mammoth Lakes Tourism would like to continue, what the town either would or would not like to continue, and who should fund or how those should be funded if they're not funded by one of those two organizations. So that's kind of the broad brush overview.

1:50:54 And what I'd like to do is I'd like to focus in on the decision table that's on page five and six and just kind of quickly go through these items. And I suspect that there will be public input from others on these as well. And so this is my input. And after you hear everybody else's input, then I think it would be helpful for you to weigh in as to which way you think you'd be wanting to head as we go through our budget policy decisions.

1:51:22 So one of the issues, which is in the second box on the decision table, has to do with pre-funding the building debt. And we had recommended in the budget policy decision that we pay off that debt now and that Mammoth Lakes Tourism would not have to pay for the debt over the next two years. They actually ended up making a recommendation to go the other way, and we really have no reason not to let them go the other way, so we would agree with the recommendation of Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

1:51:53 To give them the money and then let them pay the debt over the next two years as they requested. The next box and actually the next several boxes has to do with strategic partnerships and various long-standing contracts. The strategic partnerships are funding that has been provided historically and this year to Chamber Music Unbound, Disabled Sports.

1:52:22 Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center, Friends of the Inyo, High Sierra Striders, High Sierra Triathlon, Mammoth Lakes Jazz Jubilee, Moto Council Arts, Trail of the Trout, Rory Club of Mammoth, Sierra Summer Festival, and Village Fest. The discussion, as I understand it, that Mammoth Lakes Tourism had is that as this program has evolved over time,

1:52:48 They've tried to focus it on the money that these organizations need to market their programs. And their current recommendation is that Mammoth Lakes Tourism actually use the money to market these programs. So they're not proposing to give the money to the organizations, as has been the case in the past. They're proposing to use the money for the benefit of the organizations. And the thought process, and staff is recommending that we approve that thought process,

1:53:17 Is that by having a large advertising campaign that affects all these different activities, there's going to be more success than having a bunch of mini campaigns that don't reach as far. May I ask a question on that, Rob? Yes. Or do you want to go through the whole thing first? I don't mind answering questions as we go along. Okay. I guess my question on that is, MLT sounds like they're proposing to do marketing for these events.

1:53:44 On a blanket level, possibly. Okay, that's correct. But currently, isn't the money that's going here going toward the creation or the production of the event and not the marketing of it? Well, my understanding is that they have focused on the marketing needs of these events in recent years as they've approved the allocations. Okay.

1:54:08 I guess that's where I'd like some clarification because I'm sure, you know, Terry can clarify that one now or later. Okay, okay, I can wait then. Okay, the next several items are the Chamber Contract, the Fireworks Contract, the Mammoth Track Club Contract, and Fishing Enhancement. And then the last, another one is Special Events, which are allocations that we made this year in addition to those above.

1:54:41 to help a variety of different special events in the community. While you're on that one, Rob, so is that for different things than the marketing that's discussed above? I think that was generally for marketing. That may be a question of Terry. Yeah, I think Terry can also address that one. Well, I was just wondering why Jazz Jubilee is showing up in both places when you get there. So,

1:55:14 Our concern with these is that is kind of the general concern that I had stated earlier, which is that these are ongoing commitments to provide ongoing things that are of benefit to the community in terms of the tourism and marketing mission and also putting heads in beds. And although in the long run it may not be fair to saddle the Mammoth Lakes Tourism with the responsibility of continuing these programs,

1:55:40 It's also not within our reach financially with the austerity budget that we have to pick them up. And so the thought is that this may be a process that plays out over a number of years where we sit down with the various parties who are involved, require continuity of these programs during the current year, but also consider moving away from that in the future based on what Mammoth Lakes Tourism's opinion is.

1:56:08 What other funding sources we might be able to come up to fund these? Another budget policy decision that was requested, it has to do with should we be doing these on a year-by-year basis or should we be doing them on a multi-year basis because doing them on a multi-year basis provides them a better opportunity to plan.

1:56:32 And we're at this point just asking for some indication from the council as to which ones you'd like to see happen on a long-term basis with the understanding that that's probably something that also gets sorts out as we sort out how they're going to be funded in the future. And then the final one is the air service subsidy and also the fall air service, which lumped together could be in the range of $370,000.

1:56:58 When the Council approved the off-season air service, they felt that this was a marketing effort, that spending this money on air service and the extended marketing that we get through the air service contract is actually more efficient than spending on other things that we might have spent it on. So I think that's a pretty good overview of the budget policy decisions and also of the

1:57:29 Sort of general philosophy that we're working with. And I guess, do you want to wait a minute until Matt determines? What is going on right now, just so people know, is that because of Matt's involvement with Mammoth Rocks and the fact that Mammoth Rocks is one of the items on this agenda, we're just checking the conflict of interest issue with the town attorney to make sure we're all okay.

1:57:53 And could I ask a question of Rob that relates back to the budget. Under the Recreation Department budget, there is funding apparently for holiday special events. Where are the funds coming from for those? Everything that's in the Recreation budget is general fund. Okay. Okay. Thank you, Peter. So...

1:59:02 Just for the record, it appears that Matt is involved with Mammoth Rocks, but receives no income or no money from it that it's a non-profit organization, so I think that's fairly common. So Joe just has a question. Do you want to ask it one more time? Yes, I was just clarifying, Matt, that there are some holiday special events that the Recreation Department would do, and they are out of general funds, so they are nowhere on this list.

1:59:32 Along with that, for some reason, Pops in the Park is in that one, but the fireworks are on this list? I don't know. All right. And so, Terry, if you want to... Is it appropriate timing now? Yes. Go ahead. Cheryl put this nice little chart together for us here. And so that it's... This is in your packet. These are the same figures that are in your packet in the budget. It's not an approved budget that we've came up with. It was something that was...

2:00:00 Given to us from previous expenses and from the expenses that we're being asked to possibly cover. So the first page, you'll see that all of these expenses are put in there with the bottom line being what would be left over for estimated remaining funds for direct marketing of $576,000 and that's it. So if you look at your second page,

2:00:29 In the red, you can see items that have been taken out of that chart, which will give us then just over $1 million for direct marketing. And those items are the chamber contract, fireworks, fishing enhancement, and air subsidy that have been taken out. And so you'll see, and I guess one of my concerns with what's going on right now,

2:01:02 It was decided to take this organization and take the marketing outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes, but the town of Mammoth Lakes is very much determining how this marketing organization is going to function because of the dollar amounts that are already being encumbered within the organization. So Rob's made a few...

2:01:27 A few points. We have not done a marketing plan. We have not done a budget. Number one, we don't even know what the funding source is and the exact dollar amount that we're going to get. The items that are in discussion, it was just said that we don't feel it's a great value, and that's absolutely not the case. All of these things are of very great value, but a marketing organization is just that, a marketing organization. We're not here to put on

2:01:57 Any special events. We're not here to put on any type of activity. We're here to market it. And there is a distinction there that needs to be dealt with. So as far as the town and the amount of money that's coming into this, it is a new organization. So this money is coming directly from the town, and that's all the funding that's coming there. I'd kind of like to go over some of the...

2:02:28 Other areas that he's put in the chart, in the bar chart we have here. We have Telluride. Telluride was one that I had a tough time coming up with the exact figure, so there may be some extra funding. But what I came up with is they have 4.5% sales tax and a 2% air that is charged to lodging. I think there's another 2% in there, but I couldn't clarify that. It was not on a website. I had made a phone call. I didn't get that clarification prior to tonight.

2:02:58 The sales tax is on all areas of the town, lodging, food, retail, so it's not just a lodging tax. And same with the air. The air is actually just on lodging and restaurant. Okay, we move on to Placer County, and they are 8 to 10 percent, and Breckenridge is 10 percent.

2:03:25 Aspen is 10%. And all of these ones in Colorado that we're comparing ourselves with, they have, you know, taxes that go to the state, they have taxes that go to the city. They're very much segmented out. So 2.1% may go to sales tax to the state. Actually, in the case of Aspen, it's 6.9% to the state, 2.1% to the city, and one point for air. So...

2:03:52 You see that that's already being segmented out. South Lake Tahoe is 10%, and any redeveloped area is 12%. So Mammoth is already 13%. And so I guess the point that I'm trying to make is that if we were at 10%, then we would be more than happy to put a bid together and probably be very successful with that. But when we're already at a cap of 13%, it doesn't give us any wiggle room to put any other type of

2:04:22 Funding source such as a bid out there against our customer base. You know, we can only tax our customers to a certain extent prior to them saying, you know, we've had enough. And so I just want to kind of clarify that because when you're looking at it straight that says this is how much funding is going there, then it doesn't look like, you know, it's pretty improportionate. But when you look at what the other tax bases are, then what Mammoth did

2:04:52 You know, way back when, when they passed this Measure A, there wasn't a bid that was out there. It wasn't really in the vocabulary, I guess, at the time. So what was used is TOTs because that's the funding source that was out there. So there was 2% passed at that point and then another half a percent, I think it was in 2002. So I just kind of want to put that out there as a point of clarification.

2:05:19 Are you saying that basically, for example, Breckenridge is a 10% TOT? Mm-hmm. And then there's another 3% that could be... No, it's 10% period. And so their taxes is 2.5% sales tax, 2.4% excise tax, 2.9% state tax. Wait a minute, I'm going in, am I going in to somebody else's? And then a 2% summit county tax.

2:05:44 And then a .75 and a .125. And what that goes to, I'm not exactly sure. But anyways. So it's very much segmented into different, it goes to many different areas. It's not something that's just coming to Breckenridge. And so, but still with all of that, there's still a 10% cap that's being charged to those guests where we're at 13%. Okay. And then as we move along,

2:06:18 And since these are just all budget discussions, this has been given to you, I just kind of want to clarify some of these things. The number C on page 4, I guess, and I would assume that this is what you guys are going to be looking at in your budget decisions, but, you know, that the proposed budget assumes that all of these expenditures will be covered by MLT using its measure A.

2:06:52 I guess I just want to make sure that we clarify what these expenditures are when you come down to it. Thank you, John. And because I think that that would be, obviously that's important to all of us, so I just don't want to say these. And when you look at a surplus of $221,000, there is no surplus. If you look at what the income is on the budget that's in there, in your package, there's some assumptions that are made.

2:07:22 There is $100,000 as a one-time income coming in this year to help out with the hiring of the executive director and get us going. That's a one-time expense, our income. And then we have, I think there was, let me go to that page. Terry, who paid that $100,000?

2:07:42 Pardon? Who provided that $100,000? Well, the mountain has said that they will. And nothing has came to us at this point. Yeah, I just wanted to clarify that it's the mountain, not the town. No. And there's $56,000 in rental income. We have the chamber that at this time provides us with $125 per month. There is no other rental income. There is a possibility for rental income, but at this point in time, there is none.

2:08:11 There's, oh, I'm sorry, the $56,000 was DMO memberships. The rental income was $28,800. Sorry about that. And there is no DMO memberships right now. There is not a membership program. The discussion is actually still out there whether there is a straight membership or whether it's more of a leveraging opportunity and gaining extra money through leveraging of different advertising options.

2:08:40 Then sales revenue, we do have advertising that comes in, like through the insider, that type of thing. We don't actually have what we're going to produce right now. Are we going to still produce that? I don't know. The Mountain just decided that they were going to put something together very similar to the insider. So all those things are great assumptions that are being made.

2:09:04 And that is not money that would be considered a surplus at this point in time. The only thing that we are starting out with is the monies that are coming from the town. And that hasn't been determined at this point either as to what that dollar figure is. Okay. I'm sorry, Joe. And then when you were asking about why Jazz Jubilee received some different money, basically you had the $107,000 that was for strategic marketing. And that's where some of these contracts came out of.

2:09:36 And then also money was allocated to different groups putting on events. So some of it was marketing money, some it was actual production cost. No. No, no, no, no, no. Okay. Some of it was for the chamber contract. Some of it was for the fireworks. No, I meant where we're seeing Jazz Jubilee twice. Okay.

2:10:02 And so what we had is, and I'll go back kind of originally where I said this last time, is the money was originally handed out to these folks as non-profit, and they were handed out to these people to help put on their activities, their special events. But that was with general fund money. And then it started coming out of measure A money until pretty much all came out of measure A money.

2:10:32 So since measuring money is supposed to be marketing, that's when it was changed to the strategic marketing. And so we have tried to tie this into, you know, their marketing programs. And that is something that we have required of the folks. There was $15,000 in our budget for special event seed money. And that was it, $15,000. So at the end of this year, there were four organizations that came forward.

2:11:02 And one of them was Jazz Jubilee. The other one was Blue Sky. And the other one was Mammoth Rocks. And it was the Palooza. And it was the Palooza Palooza. The Mammoth Rocks was the only one. Basically, they were looking for money for the special use of the bus because the trolley was going to cost them a certain amount of money that they didn't have. And Measure U has now been passed, and we're hoping that was an intent.

2:11:30 Measure U. That process hasn't been put forth yet, so that's still to be determined. But since we were transitioning over from one to the other, one year to the next, there were some funds left over within our strategic marketing funding that we did not allocate last year. There was still some money in our special event seed fund, and we were told that there was going to be a surplus in TOTs and that that could be used.

2:11:59 For this. And that's where that $28,000 came from at the end of the season. And so it was kind of a one-time, here's some excess money, let's help you out right now, hopefully the trolley, the special events trolley is going to be resolved. And the MLT is asking that we be allowed to be a marketing organization, that it has been determined, our strategic directions report, anything that has came forward.

2:12:28 Has never said that we're here to put on events. There just isn't the funding to put those events on. We're here to market those events. And that's why your page two reflects the deletions that are in red because those are not strict or in your mind closely enough related to marketing to qualify for funding by the new organization.

2:13:02 Correct. Well, you know, air service is one of those things that's going to have to be discussed as to how we are going to fund that because it is not something that with the amount of money that we have, this marketing organization is going to be able to fund those guarantees, especially as we keep adding air service. So it's obviously a discussion that needs to be had. That's been brought up by staff and that's something that's acknowledged. Phishing enhancement, phishing is a great need to this community.

2:13:32 But these are hard costs on putting the fish in there. We want to market that there's fishing. We want to market that the fish have been planted. But we don't want to have to actually put those fish in there. We would like to see that the general fund help out in some of these ventures. Fireworks. And then the fireworks, I want to let you guys know it's not just $29,000, an additional $8,000 in bathrooms and miscellaneous other expenses that are there.

2:14:00 And then the Chamber contract is definitely one that we would say no is not marketing. Thank you, Terry. Eric, did you want to comment at this time? Probably would be a good time. Yeah, great. Thank you. I'm Eric Walshman, President of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. And I will just disclose now I have two hats on. I'm going to be wearing my Chamber of Commerce hat.

2:14:47 A board member of Mammoth Lakes Tourism on the DMO. What I want to discuss is the Chambers contract. Number one, there's four parts to the contract. One is to provide relocation packets for businesses and residents. That's something that all of you have provided to council in the past and it's available electronically. The second part is the Mammoth Value Card. That is a card, a program that is...

2:15:15 We were doing a cooperation with the Visitors Bureau where we have about 20 businesses or so that participate in discounts that when groups come to town that register, they get this card and get certain discounts in town and encourage the shopping. The third is to take the lead on the development of the community-wide hospitality training program. I'm going to have Jack Copeland is here as a chamber board member. He's going to present something on that. It's something that...

2:15:43 I will let him do his presentation and that will speak in and of itself. And the fourth is to provide a communication channel through the Monday morning emails. I hope all of you are getting those emails. If you're not, let me know. You should be on the list. What I do want to say is I feel that it's very important that we get our funding. As a chamber president, my primary goal is to make sure that we retain that funding. I do agree with what...

2:16:12 What Terry had to say as a DMO board member that we do not do marketing. We're more of a business-to-business entity, and I think that through the general fund is the appropriate place. That being said, I'll let council come to a decision, but most importantly, my goal is to ensure our funding. Without further ado, I'd like to turn this over to Jack Copeland, our board member. Eric, before you start, could I ask you a question? What other sources of revenue do you have besides the...

2:16:40 Chamber, the contract with the town. That's right. We have membership. We have roughly about 170 members, give or take. That's always changing a little bit here or there. And we get between $20,000 and $22,000 a year from our membership is what our books have shown. We do put on Mammoth Rocks. That is a revenue source. However, we have publicly stated that we are putting all proceeds from Mammoth Rocks into the future event.

2:17:09 Last year we netted $12,500 approximately. The chamber has also, for this year's budget, we are putting every last penny of that into the event. And if need be in our budget, we have allocated another $12,500. So if our fundraising doesn't go higher, I am on the hook for $25,000 to put into that event, which is a large part of our budget. But other than that, we...

2:17:35 We don't. We are in the final stages of completing a website that we will sell advertising on. As of right now, there's zero dollars coming in, but it is a projected source of revenue, but minor at this point in time. And any other questions at this point? And I'm sure there'll be a lot after Jack does his presentation. I'd love to answer any questions that council may have. So here's Jack.

2:18:07 I'm afraid that didn't come with a PowerPoint. I got to do it at the old school. Is that your typical introduction, here's Jack? Here's Jack. Here's Jack and his analog watch and his flip chart. I don't know how to do it with everybody. So Mammoth Ambassador Program, that's what I'm calling it.

2:18:36 The history of this program was a mandate for community-wide hospitality training, and it started as early as the mid-90s with Mike Vance and Lori Vance. Lori Vance came with a large IntraWest contingency at that time when the ownership picture changed at the mountain, and IntraWest and Whistler had a very well-established community-wide hospitality training program.

2:19:04 Called the Spirit of Whistler. And Lori was charged with introducing that hospitality program in Mammoth Lakes. And she called it the Mammoth Ambassador Program. So that's why I like that program. I like that title. I like it better. Why hospitality, not service?

2:19:25 Well, customer service is the job of businesses, to provide customer service. Businesses do that, and the level of service and the type of service and the way they present it is very much tied to the type of industry and the level of the service that they have. And individual business owners make a decision strategically as to where they are in the market with levels of service. The Lakefront Restaurant and Convict Lake do not have a different level of service than Carl's Jr. and...

2:19:55 And McDonald's. So if people, business owners make a very specific business-based decision on what level of service they're going to offer, we're talking about hospitality. My definition of hospitality from the Oxford American Dictionary is the friendly and generous reception and entertainment of guests and strangers. So it's much broader than the definition of hospitality.

2:20:20 The purpose of our community-wide hospitality training would not be to impose upon businesses' guest service standards. The purpose is to up the engagement level of our seasonal workforce to live up to our brand promise. And the most recent mandate for community-wide hospitality training came out of the branding process.

2:20:48 Some of you may not have been here. Most of you probably were. The branding process and the whole question of what's our brand from the Mountain's perspective, it is who are we and what is our brand in a post-Dave McCoy era? When Dave McCoy is the icon, he's the person, he's the values, he established the culture of our company. And who are we with now that he's retired?

2:21:12 From a town perspective, we cannot continue to define ourselves as the anti-Bail, anti-Aspin. And that is to say that we have a much better idea of who we don't want to be than who we do want to be. So we entered into this branding process, which is to define, first of all, what does the community think our brand is, who we are, what do we stand for, what's our reputation, what makes us...

2:21:41 Unique. And then with the help of an expensive marketing company that specialized in branding, Siegel and Gale, they went out to workshops beyond the community but with established guests and customers of Mammoth Lakes and people who could come but don't come to Mammoth Lakes. And some of the things that came back from the brand was some of the sort of tag words were play big, come as you are, do what you love, boundless recreation.

2:22:11 Mammoth is also laid back. It's unpretentious. It's authentic. And it's friendly. Are we really friendly? I'm sure all of you can think of circumstances, incidents that are entertaining. I know you can. But we're not particularly friendly.

2:22:39 You know, and back in the 70s, people used in the residence of Mammoth, used to refer in the deprecating fashion to our tourists as flatlanders. Now it seems like with the younger generation, it's gapers. And you'll often hear at the end, during holiday periods and at the end of a busy time, I'm over it. I'll put it to you that we are not always that hospitable to art.

2:23:11 To our tourists and our guests. The branding sessions in 2006 and 2007 would throughout all the workshops identify the need for a community-wide training program. So the history of the project, the town has been funding, as you heard from Terry and you know, the town has been funding the chamber to develop a program. It's had many different iterations over the last few years.

2:23:42 Dan has been very involved. There have been lots of efforts to create a good, solid curriculum. And the whole business community, the whole town supports it until it comes time to deliver it. And then nobody attends. And the reason for that is that it's pretty straightforward. There are four reasons culturally ingrained in the town that prohibit the success of this project. The first is money.

2:24:14 If you're an employer and you're going to require your employees to attend this training, you have to pay them. And the timing of this training would come in the November-December slow period, by and large after the brief Thanksgiving rush. And that November-December time frame is when every single business in town is frightened to death that they're going to spend too much money and nobody's going to come at Christmas.

2:24:43 So they are cutting back. They're in the shoulder season staffing schedule. They're not in the main season staffing schedule. So yeah, they all want to do it. They all support it, but they can't pay their employees to attend. Neither can the Mammoth. That's a big hurdle. So what that dictates to me is this program has to have incentives in it so that people will want to voluntarily participate, employees.

2:25:14 The second is, in the past, I'm not really criticizing anybody, but if you're presenting to 1,519-year-olds who have never had a job before, never had a roommate before, never paid rent, never had to go show up on time anywhere,

2:25:37 Are not going to listen to a bunch of guys like me, bald and gray-haired baby boomers preaching didactically to them about some pompous idea of their service. You've got to have somebody their age who is engaged with them in their generation culturally to present the material. The material is no problem coming up with loads and loads of material. But the presenters have to be part of the generation that

2:26:08 The third thing is the mountain. And as you know, everyone in the town of Mammoth Lakes has a love-hate relationship with the mountain. Love to go skiing, love a lot of things that happen there, but we don't want Big Brother telling us what to do. So it can't be a mountain program. It's got to be a town program. And speaking of the town,

2:26:33 I'm being polite when I say that there are other proprietary systems in place. What I mean by that is there are business owners in town who pride themselves because their service is better than everybody else. And they don't want anybody else getting a hold of their employees teaching their employees job-related service. So to me, that means one thing. Job-related guest service left.

2:27:04 Standards and procedures have to be left to the business owners themselves. That's their responsibility. That's their authority. I just think you guys ought to get a look at this because it's so cluttered. What did I tell you in the presentation class? Don't be cluttered. Oh, well. I never listened to it. So the Mammoth Ambassador Program, this is kind of my mock-up of what it consists of.

2:27:32 We're going to have two six-hour sessions for each module, for each group. The college, by the way, has already spoken to the dean of academics for Syracuse College. They have offered us the college and its facilities, and they will help to develop the curriculum and the media for the presentation. They implied it was for free. But I will be hitting them up for more specifics on that later.

2:27:59 So the events itself would start with a welcome. You know, sometimes when we bring these, it's really, it's not just 1,500, 19-year-olds. It's more like 3,000, 4,000 seasonal workers who come into town. Sometimes we treat them a little bit like migratory scum we just as soon not have. Oh, God, here, they come into town again. So we need to welcome them in a way that mirrors how we want them to welcome our guests.

2:28:27 We need to give them some idea of the history of Mammoth Lakes. I think that a Dave McCoy DVD is probably a good start to that, or cutting and pasting it to make it better. We need to spend quite a bit of time, and I say we, whoever these iconic younger people are of the right age group, need to spend quite a bit of time talking about the spirit of service. We are all in service here.

2:28:52 Ted provides a service through his newspaper. You are providing a service to the citizens of Mammoth Lakes right now. Rob provides a service by managing an office. I provide a service at the ski resort. It's not just people who wait on tables and hold lifts that provide service in our community. Everyone is in service to someone.

2:29:17 The goal of this service would be to get our seasonal employees to embrace the concept of service and hospitality. And we want them underneath, embedded in that, to one of the things that Siegel and Gail talked about a lot was engagement. We want our employees to engage our guests to the community. And the engagement I'm talking about is not in the workplace.

2:29:44 Now I'm talking the workplace engagement, the workplace job skill and guest service training, that's the responsibility of the business, not of this program. It could become this program, but my sense is that businesses don't want Big Brother messing with their employees. I'm talking more about a level of services more like the host training on the mountain. All of you know the host, those bright yellow uniforms.

2:30:12 Now the hosts don't, they don't adjust bindings, they don't load lifts, they don't cook meals, they don't sell lift tickets, but they do absolutely everything else that facilitates all of those things. The hosts are trained, the hosts know what the red line is. They know what the transportation system is, they know where it stops, they know when it goes. They know what the price of the lift ticket is, they know where the lift ticket sales windows are.

2:30:39 They know what special events are happening this weekend and where they're happening. They know, so they, they, and they are trained to actively engage the guests as they come to the mountain. That is to say when some poor guy's coming walking out of the bus with little kid skis falling out and somebody tugging at him and a bag of bottles and formula on his back looking around going like this, they go up to them without being told and address them to help them.

2:31:09 That's the kind of engagement I'm thinking about, because those people exist in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll tell you a quick story. I was driving down from the mountain. Oh, I've got to calm down. And I get too excited because I love it. But I came down the mountain. It was in May, or early May. And there was obviously a PCT hiker coming down from the mountain. He wasn't hitchhiking.

2:31:35 He was just coming down from the mountain. You know, you can recognize them. They limp a little bit. They're tall and slender. They haven't had enough to eat for a while. They are the color of gray, no matter what color their clothing started with. Began their height. And I stopped and I pulled over. They said, hey, do you want a ride? He said, yeah, sure. I said, throw your backpack in the back. I'll take you. Where are you going? Motel 6. I'll take you there. We started talking. I said, I think you're the first one. That's all I said. He knew what I meant.

2:32:04 I knew what I meant. So I took them, I showed them where the Bank of America was, where the post office was, the bonds, and I took them over to Motel 6. I'm not posing as a great provider of hospitality, but I think that's the kind of thing that people expect in Mammoth. And that's an example of just taking care of people who are around. And that's not natural for 19-year-olds.

2:32:34 They want to have their hoodie up, their earbuds are in, and they're not looking around. They need to be taught. And there's nothing wrong with that, because by the time they get through the Christmas holidays, they are going to be engaged, customer service, outgoing, communicating machines. And they're going to be great at it, because they are learning at a pace they can't help but learn. So this is the host training. Very similar, good model that exists within the host program.

2:33:03 And the content I would imagine being level one would be transportation and parking. How do you get around Mammoth? From point A to point B. Level two would be basic services. Yeah, you've got a post office here. Is there a police department? Is there a medical service? Is there a hospital? Where's the bank? Where's the market? Level two would be retail, rental, and restaurants. Do you have any Chinese food here? Is there sushi in town? Is there a Thai restaurant? Lodging.

2:33:31 Where is Chateau Sans-Nam? What's the difference between Sierra Park Villas and Sherwin Villas? And the fifth thing is events. And what I would propose to do, it's convenient that you have this on the wall here, and they're all over the place, there's diagrams of town roads. As I would say, we take that diagram, and we...

2:33:57 We have a clear one, and then we superimpose the transportation system and parking lot. And then we go to basic services and we plug in the post office, the PD, the town offices, the market, the library, the hospital. Then we have a break. Then when they come back from their break, we provide refreshments, which is why I need some money.

2:34:26 And when they come back from the break, we put out the map, and they label it. We label it, we test them, and they get a score on that test. And we do that for each one of these components. And so that by the end of there, you can see that you can start getting into detail about these things. That's why it takes 12 hours. At the end, they have passed the test, and they become certified.

2:34:59 A certified Mammoth Ambassador. They get a certificate, they get a pin. Maybe they get some other stuff. I'd like to give them some other stuff, but I've got to have budget for them. But they at least get a certificate and a pin. What's in it for them? Pay incentives. I've got to get it. Either we've got to pay them. If they can't, if the businesses won't pay them to come, what I'd like to convince the businesses to do is, let's say you're going to pay your entry-level employees, I don't know, I'll just pick a number, $10 an hour.

2:35:29 Let's convince the businesses in this period to pay them $9.50. When they complete their training and become certified, they get a bump to 10. They buy into that. That would be good for the businesses. They have a little lower training startup costs, and then everybody benefits as they go into the holiday period. Pass products. The Mountain has agreed to create a pass product for any employee who goes through this and does not otherwise have a pass.

2:35:59 That will be more expensive than the MVP, but less expensive than whatever we're selling at that point in time. So that should be something that incentivizes people. We can get retail product discounts, F&B discounts, and other kinds of discount programs throughout the business community, because we are the business community. What I can't get from them is cash. So that's what's in it for them.

2:36:26 The Mountain has said that the past product is contingent on the content being read good and the testing process. It's not just a day where you stand listening to a talking head and everybody feels good and has a nice motivating talk. You have retention. You get tested. You know something at the end. The other part is a follow-up.

2:36:49 So after they graduate and they're certified, we will have a follow-up program, essentially a secret shopper program, that's another program that was talked about in the branding workshops. And secret shoppers would go around, not into the businesses, but they would go around through the community on the streets and the sidewalks and into the post office, and they would ask, our graduates will have a pin. That could be as cheap as...

2:37:19 It could be as inexpensive as a I'm Jack, I like Ike button. Or it could be a nice metallic button that identifies them. And we would have them wear. And we'd ask them. So we would ask them questions. I'd walk up and I'd drop my wallet and then walk by and see if they picked it up.

2:37:42 Gave it back to me. Things like that. And we would reward them. We would ingrain them. We would recognize them. We'd try to convince Ted to have an Ambassador of the Month program and recognize, picture, a little bio in the paper and create some recognition and stir the program up. We might even be able to grow into business awards through the chamber for best service like gold level service, bronze level service, silver level, whatever we do.

2:38:11 We have to be careful not to shoot ourselves in the foot with it. But I can see the whole program going, growing. And so we would have this November, in the November-December lull, in the January-February period prior to precedence, and again in June, 12 hours of training over two days. Next steps, curriculum development, identify trainers, recruit and train the trainers, develop collateral and media.

2:38:42 To pledge some help in that. Buying from the business community and other people, such as yourselves. And then mitigating the hurdles that I identified earlier. So I think it's a great program. I'd love to do it. But we're going to need any questions. Sorry. Questions for Jack? Comments? Thank you, Jack. Next time, PowerPoint.

2:39:13 One more thing. Joe, you were asking about funding sources for the chamber. We did create the Mammoth Powder Guide last year. It has not yielded us money as of yet, but we are hoping that that will happen. The only money it costs us is when we market it. We hope with Jack's presentation that gave a...

2:39:31 Pretty good insight of what we'd like to do. What we're requesting is really a minimum of the same funding that we've had. It's a tight budget year. I don't have the audacity to ask for more, but certainly would take it. And really hope that the council can continue to fund the chamber. We do thank you for the support that we've had in the past. And really, if you think about the whole budget and the amount of money that the chamber gets and what the community gets out of the chamber,

2:40:01 To me, it's really a no-brainer. I mean, we're fighting for $25,000, which really helps us going. We're all volunteers with the exception of one employee in an administrative position. I know several of you that are on the DS there have volunteered hours and hours of time for the chamber, and I truly do appreciate that, and I hope you'll continue to fund us properly. Thank you. Thank you, Eric. We are on discussing the major aid allocations.

2:40:30 Related budget issues. Is there anyone else in the public that would like to speak? If not, council, any further information from staff at this time? Council of Liberation? I would tend to agree with tourism. And I do sympathize with what Rob has mentioned, just that the town doesn't have the resources. The only problem is that we just started our Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and I hate to see us.

2:41:18 Start them off with just a limited budget because it's going to be a hard year for them as well. I don't want to deny these folks their funding because I think each one of these is needed. And I don't know if it's appropriate now for us, you know, for going down and checking these boxes, but if that was the intent of this page. But I just feel that, you know, from strategic partnerships down.

2:41:48 On page five, I would put in the general fund. And I had some questions on the long-term contracts and air service I would also put in the general fund. I just don't want to, I just think by taking the money out of marketing and trying to fund these things that are not necessarily marketing, we're just doing the same thing we've been doing. I think that it was our goal of a lot of us to try to straighten the budget out.

2:42:17 And, you know, taking from one fund, it's probably not appropriate just to pay another. It's just doing more of the same. Did you say you had a question of long-term contracts? Yeah, I wasn't sure really what was being asked here, I guess. I guess just all of the above which should... Oh, you know, it's just an extension of... Yeah. Okay, sorry.

2:42:42 Okay. Jo? I'd like to suggest that we first start at the beginning and define what we think marketing is because to me that's the basis of deciding whether or not it gets funded from Measure A. And also to look at what some of the longer-term commitments we have is how we transition those. Because, you know, Matt should be wonderful to say pay it off in the general fund, but...

2:43:11 I don't think that's practical. Why is that? Because we're already talking about cutting the general fund by $1.2 million. You're going to cut it another $500,000? $500,000? Yeah. Yeah. That's what we're talking about here. We're taking it from a place that's inappropriate, and I think that we need to start evaluating. I see it as something that has to have a transition to it, though, and I will argue to the end that the air service subsidy is marketing.

2:43:40 But in general, it's not like, you know, this is a new program, definitely Mammoth Lakes Tourism needs to start, but to immediately increase the direct marketing cost by $500,000, I just don't believe we can afford that. Maybe we can't. There's a lot of things we can't afford, unfortunately, right now. So let me just make this suggestion. I mean, let's go ahead and keep trying to work with our...

2:44:08 chart that we have here, and I think that if I understood correctly, we get down the preferred, the MLT is accepting the pre-fund tourism of the building debt and strategic partnerships, am I correct? I think Mammoth Lakes Tourism would like to not pre-fund the building debt and instead receive the money

2:44:35 And that's fine. I don't see any problem with that. So, but what they're saying is use Measure A to pay the building debt. That would probably help. Okay, so the first says that all marketing and sales services, yes, absolutely, but, you know, there needs to be, you know, what that definition is because obviously there's some discrepancies in what you guys say here. Pre-fund the tourism building.

2:45:10 We do not want that pre-funded. We feel that that money should come to the organization so that it can be used appropriately, whether it goes into a reserve with Mammoth Lakes Tourism or whether it's budgeted. Strategic partnerships, we feel that that money should come to us unencumbered, that we would like to use that 55, it's actually not 47,000, it's 55, because there was 8,000 that had been, that's actually down here in the 28,000.

2:45:39 And it's $55,000 in our contract, so we probably ought to be clear on that. We would like that to come to us as a marketing program. And I'll have to tell you, kind of, you know, give you some insight on that. John Urdi, that's coming in as our Executive Director, he'll be here next week. One of the first things that he mentioned is when he started gathering all these different brochures and everything else about all the concerts that were going on in Mammoth for the summer and all of that, he's like,

2:46:08 He grabbed one here and went, oh, this is kind of nice, and grabbed one here, but there was nothing that pulled all of those together to say, gosh, you know, boy, look at this here, and maybe I want to come back in August, maybe I want to come back another time, look at all these things that are going on. And those are the types of things that we would like to do. And so with that $55,000, we feel that that can be used far better than handing out $1,000 here or $2,000 there.

2:46:33 So we would like that to come to us for the MLT to manage and to use as marketing. The chamber contract, we feel should go with the town. Fireworks, we don't have a problem with handling that. We don't have a problem handling any of this. We just feel that there should be additional funding coming forward for these activities because, once again, we are not in the business of putting something on. This is a contract that's been put forward.

2:47:02 It's kind of straightforward. It's not one of those things that we have to do a lot of work on. It's just a contract that we would deal with. The Mammal Track Club, that's a contract that's already in place. We would like to be able to work with those folks and obviously have a conversation with them and decide how that gets dealt with in the future.

2:47:27 And what that looks like, fishing enhancement. That was something that was originally funded through recreation and now is being funded through Measure A. And then the last one is that special events, which I explained earlier, was a one-time expense kind of drawn from many different areas to cover four groups that came in with some last-minute needs. The long-term contracts.

2:47:55 You know, what are those long-term contracts? I go back to what I stated originally, is that it was the intent, at least to my understanding, that the council have a contract with MLT and for coming up and delivering marketing. And there will be parameters that we're going to have to meet, just as any other job, any other business would be with anybody that you're contracting with. And so we would like that contract to be given to us.

2:48:25 Without our hands being tied, because it's very difficult to deliver something and be innovative when your hands are tied to things that have been traditionally been there in the past. And then the air service subsidy, that was originally coming out of reserves, measuring reserves that were there previously, which are, I guess, no longer there. And if that was still the case,

2:48:50 Then that would be very appropriate for that to still be coming out of there. But we would like to say, since the reserves were used for other things, that that be funded by the town. And then that's going to, as I said, it has to be a discussion as to how it's funded in the future. And Mammoth Lakes Tourism, if we're going to be taking that on, needs to have a seat at the table and have some negotiating power with that. Thank you, Terry. So, you know, we've kind of heard MLT's position on these things.

2:49:20 And I think we still need to come back and maybe let's just start. If Rob is saying that the pre-funding of the building debt, taking that on this town will not have any serious impact on our budget this year, I would say, you know, how do the other council members feel about the town accepting that?

2:49:41 I say as long as it's getting paid and they're saying it's their responsibility either measure A money, I don't care how it gets paid. Yeah, if they pay it all at once or pay it over two years. Yeah, everybody, so, okay, so we're in agreement with that. Moving into the strategic partnerships then, thoughts about that? I've stated mine. I would have it paid on the general fund personally.

2:50:09 But they're saying they want the money. They want to do it. They want to use the same money and market but to control how the marketing is done. So they're saying it's okay to come out of misery. Am I getting that right, Terry? If these are for marketing dollars, then, yeah, I'm fine with that. I'm just under the impression that some of this wasn't. But if it's for marketing, I'm fine with it. Yes, I guess the verification needs to be whether that's coming to us unencumbered or whether we're being asked to dole it out as it has been in the past.

2:50:41 So that's the question, I think, with the strategic marketing funds. So I guess my question to you would be is there's a list of people that have benefited from those funds at this time. When you say do you anticipate maybe not some of those people being scratched off your list and some of them being kept, that you're going to go through a process to somehow or are you going to try to... I'm saying that they wouldn't be handed out individual funding. It would be a...

2:51:11 A marketing effort. They would still receive some form of marketing. Yes, they would receive some form of marketing, but they would not be handed the dollars. Got you. Okay, but if, for example, when I saw South Pacific down in L.A., there was a small ad for the Felicia Trio Summer Music Concerts, they would go through you to get that placed if you guys agreed that that was a way to spend marketing dollars. Is that kind of what you're saying? No.

2:51:37 Because I think that we would be looking at the marketing as a whole, pulling people, well, that would be something that would be determined. They could bring something like that to us, and that could be determined whether that would be something that would be good. You know, are there other, you know, Sierra Summer Festival and the Cleachy Trio, something that can be marketed in that same genre, or is it, you know, those are the things that would be looked at, but it would not just be a given that...

2:52:04 That money would be handed to them. So I'm getting from this. You're looking at trying to create more of a one-stop shopping thing for all of our events and make sure that everything is included so there isn't to pick up this brochure and then pick up this brochure and that brochure. You're going to work with all of these people to try and consolidate.

2:52:24 Their marketing efforts. People are still going to have their individual, you know, marketing items, but yes, we need to actually bring that all together and market it as a whole much better than we do right now. Okay, so the request here then I think is that MLT would like to have these funds, but they would like to have them unencumbered. Except that anything, none of the new year funds have been distributed to anyone.

2:52:51 These funds were already distributed from last year. So last fall, all of the activities that are going on this summer were actually already funded. So this summer came up again until this fall. And so that would be when the funding would come forward as far as that goes with these people. But, you know, what we would like to do is get our director on board and then start looking at these things, bring all of these folks together and have that conversation with them.

2:53:20 Rick, John? Yeah, you know, this is a big change. This is huge. And it's hard to measure the implications of the bundling of monies that would otherwise be doled out individually. I've always thought in the past that the funding...

2:53:45 Of a lot of organizations, there are probably 12 listed here for $47,000. It's only $4,000 apiece. Whether it's really doing any good. You know what I mean? I don't know if it is or not because I don't know what they specifically spend the money on. But I'm supportive of that change. I think that it's worth doing it differently. In what way would you be in support of... I guess the question is, I mean, who's going to...

2:54:17 Who would pay for this is really the question. I think what we're talking about is Major A funds, but we are not telling them how to spend it. They're just going to get the money flat out, and then they're going to look at this group. So nobody pays for this, really. It's just money posted. Major A funds, yeah. Okay. If I may, I want to add one point as a DMO board member.

2:54:38 We took the time to hire a true marketing professional to create a comprehensive marketing plan, and we want to use those abilities of John. And really what we envision is he's going to be able to leverage cooperative marketing agreements and structure dollars a lot further than any of us individuals, and that's really the reason that we have set it up this way and why we're asking to control the funds, because we think it'll ultimately bring a greater good to the community.

2:55:08 Eric, before you go, I've been thinking about this question I wrote down. You know, I've heard tonight and also for many, many years a pushback against, in effect, a bid or business participation in marketing. If the approach works for the strategic partnerships by taking marketing dollars and

2:55:38 And leveraging them or spending them more efficiently. Why would we not have participation by the private sector? Why not? That's a great question. I think Terry mentioned that earlier that we really are at that ceiling where we're taxed quite a bit. I know these days that the individual business owners, from what I've seen and people I've spoken to,

2:56:04 Again, this is because of a recession, obviously, we're asking in slow times. They have cut labor forces, they are working more hours, and really don't want to put any extra dollars in anything else right now other than make their business survive. I know we could talk, and I know Councilman Lehman sees this firsthand helping us with Mammoth Rocks. We're offering people free advertising to be lodging partners for Mammoth Rocks, and we're having a hard time.

2:56:34 You know, this and with the powder gun. I'm having a hard time for things for free getting business owners to write descriptions describing their own business or their own property for something for free. So to ask them to actually pay money for something, I don't think we're going to get a positive response in this economy. When things get better, that's another story. But it's not another story because things have been good. We had good years.

2:57:00 And I didn't see any momentum at all. I'm not taking a firm position on that, but philosophically, it just seems to me that if we're trying to do better, doing better means having a larger budget. And I'm absolutely on board for devoting more town money to this effort. And I've got some thoughts on the air service issue as well a little later.

2:57:29 It seems to me that, and the model that I've seen, for example, in Whistler, it's not voluntary. It's mandatory. And I don't, frankly, buy the argument, I understand it, but I don't buy the argument that because we're taxed, because we tax our customers at a higher rate than others by one to three points, that there isn't any money left.

2:57:57 To pay into something that is going to operate under the same principle that you're describing with these strategic partnerships, which is to get a pile of money to do better for everybody. Because my view is that if you're successful, I'm not a bargain guy, but my view is that if you're successful, you're going to increase visitation, you're going to increase the dollars that are coming into the pocket of each of the people who are doing business within the community.

2:58:26 That just seems like basic fundamental economics to me, and that's why I feel like there needs to be a commitment that, you know, maybe that commitment can't be made immediately, but it seems to me that there needs to be a requirement that we get participation as painful as it might be in good times and bad times.

2:58:49 And I happen to agree with you that I wouldn't throw it out as not having a discussion in the future. Right now, as we're, I wasn't involved on the scene through the boom times. I started my business about six or seven years ago. We had boom times six years ago.

2:59:05 I was starting a new business. It started, I'm still here, obviously something went right. However, I got involved as Chamber President almost three years ago and things were just at the cusp. I wouldn't rule it off the table as having a discussion, but in this period that we're in right now, I would be absolutely shocked if any business owner was willing to put some money aside for that I happen to agree with the concept. Having a larger pool of money to marketing is right. I'm one of those people that agree with...

2:59:34 Marketing that when times are slower, that's when you focus on your marketing, and it's a hard decision to make. However, convincing someone of that that's working a 12-hour shift that cut their staff, that's another story, and that's something that, you know, I'm not saying everybody makes smart business decisions in this community, but it's a reality that some people wouldn't want to do that. Skip? John, if I may. Something that had an opportunity about 20 years ago to

3:00:03 Attend the State of California Marketing, what would you call, conference. And at that time, and keep in mind this is 20 years ago, but the statistic that was revealing is that the revenues generated from, in the State of California, from tourism, represented the second largest revenue producer in the state budget.

3:00:35 So a big revenue generator for the state of California. And yet it was 139th on the state expenditures. So we didn't spend much money to generate our second highest revenue producer. I've mentioned it before. I am absolutely 100% supportive of spending 100% of Measure A.

3:01:05 Funds for marketing to the Mammoth Lakes, you know, to the DMO. And I'm not budging from that. I don't, you know, it's a straight line to spending 100% of those monies for marketing. As Rick mentioned briefly, I'm also supportive, and we'll talk about it later, of the town funding the $370,000 for the airline subsidy.

3:01:37 For one reason, I don't think it's going to be $370,000. I think it's going to be something short of that. And the other thing is I want that money, that $370,000, to go towards marketing. And you can debate whether Air Service is marketing or not, but I want to give the flexibility to the new organization to determine in that first year if that's how they want to spend their money.

3:02:04 I think that that, in particular, and as I've mentioned before, that $370,000 guarantee, we can guarantee that with our Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, and depending on how it turns out in that 12 months, you know, if we pay $250,000, if we pay $120,000, if we pay $370,000, we can take it out of the REU for that time frame and get educated, if you will, create a standard for...

3:02:30 What that airline subsidy is for that time period and then have the whole discussion over again if we want to continue that subsidy. I also support the town paying for the $25,000 chamber contract, the $29,000 fireworks and the $60,000 fishing enhancement which those three combined are an additional $114,000 and I think that the

3:03:01 I think that the message that I'm trying to send and I think the message that this new council is trying to send is that there's a new focus in the community, that the people in the community, rather than spending the money on a, for lack of a better word, on a bureaucracy.

3:03:24 That people are, I think, more interested in spending money on things that more directly affect individual people in Mammoth. Quality of life, community activities, services, and recreation benefits. So I think that was a big reason why I supported the reduction of getting our budget back to where it was last year, the reduction of $1.2 million, so that we would have better financial flexibility.

3:03:53 In doing some of these things that are more tangible and more directly related to the people in the community. Mr. Mayor, John, I agree with everything that you said. I'm supportive and I don't have anything further. Thank you. Jill? Well, we didn't finish with Terry giving us the board presentation on the other items. Yes, she did. Or were all the other...

3:04:25 So did you guys come to the consensus to let Mammoth Lakes Tourism have the strategic partnerships funding unencumbered? Well, we haven't taken a vote on it yet. We have only discussed it and we're kind of getting the consensus before we vote. You know, I would just like to make one clarification because, I don't know, maybe I was misunderstood when I was going through this. For there to be a bid to go out for like a 1% or 2%

3:04:49 That's a pass-through tax. That would be something that definitely we would be passing through to a customer. I don't see that happening. Are we looking at engaging the business community? Absolutely. How that engagement is going to happen, though, is to be determined. Would it be through leveraging opportunities?

3:05:05 Maybe there's a smaller amount. Maybe there's a dollar per night for each room that can come through for something. So those things are going to be determined. I don't want you guys to think that that isn't something that we're going to pursue because that is one of the charges that we have in our current contract and we assume will be in the next contract. So anyways. All right. Well, Terry, maybe I missed your comments on Mammoth Track Club or did you skip over that? Mammoth Track Club is...

3:05:30 It's one of those things that was put together with the TNR. It hasn't been discussed really with our new director. I think that there's a great deal of visibility and media that comes with that. And so I think that it's definitely something that, you know, the contract's already in place. That's not going anywhere. That's the key. So, yeah. And so I think that gives us the opportunity to talk with Mammoth Track.

3:05:56 And have that dialogue so that how it's dealt with in the future. I guess those would be the things that I don't want to see something that the council's looking at tying us to a long-term contract. We would like to have that dialogue with these folks so that that relationship can be developed and what comes out of it. Okay. And if I remember correctly, there's about two more years on the current contract with them? Yeah, I think so. Okay. It's two or three, actually. Two or three. So you're saying you would honor those contracts. We give you the money, but you honor those contracts.

3:06:26 Until they're down. If the contract is in place, we would honor that. That still has longevity to us. Out of A or out of other funds? Now I'm confused. Out of A. Out of A? Out of A. Absolutely. Okay. That was just the track? Well, track. Yeah, Mammoth Track Club. Mammoth Track Club. Fishing enhancements? Is that out of A also? No, that's out of town. If you think enhancements, we would say no, because that was out of recreation originally. Okay, I'm back over here on this.

3:06:58 Okay, so I'm back over here on the page two on the red. Right. Everything in the red on page two is you want to go back to town and everything else comes to you and then you guys negotiate deal with or handle on the way you see fit. Correct. And if you would like us to still deal with it, we would, but we would like that to be funded. Okay. Elsewhere. Okay. All right. Jill? Can I just ask staff to remind me what happened between when council said yes, pay for the subsidy out of

3:07:27 Measure A reserves and those reserves disappearing, if that's the right word. So the original thought was that during last fiscal year, 2009-10, we would use reserves to fund air service.

3:07:53 Realized later on that in fact there wouldn't be any air service bill during 2009-10 even though there's some air service that occurred during that time from April through June. So all of the cost fell into the current year that we're in right now. And when the council made the policy decision to use the reserves, they also made a policy decision to use Measure A in the future for future years. So that's how we got there. We then used a portion of the reserves

3:08:23 That existed for half the cost of the EIS for the United Airlines flight, and we used a small portion for the cost of the Godby survey that we did prior to Measure U. So at the end of this year, we did provide about $250,000 to the DMO as startup money, which was the amount of reserves that existed at that time, as well as the amount of vehicle fund.

3:08:51 Replacement money that existed at that time with a couple holdbacks for some of these items here. And what was the intent or the suggestion to do with the additional Measure A that it looks like will be a surplus at the end of the fiscal year that ended June 30th? That's already been turned over to the DMO, to MLT. With some holdbacks. We held back the money associated to the un-

3:09:20 Answered questions. So there will be some money that can then go forward to them now that this is becoming resolved. Is from the staff's perspective, is there any reason that council would not be able to guarantee the air service subsidy from our REU? Well, basically what you're doing is you're not budgeting money for it, but you're acknowledging that if there is a cost, that that's where you'll get it. I mean, is that technically, is that doable?

3:09:54 Yeah, it's a policy decision. We aren't recommending it, but thank you. Well, it's kind of due that, you know, I'm glad we've had the chance to discuss some of these in more detail, but until we actually get to the point that we start balancing out every time we say the general fund's going to pay for something else, I can't necessarily commit to that until we're actually looking at them all together.

3:10:27 I think that John's idea of potentially looking at building back the REU and then saying whatever subsidy for the first year gets paid out of there might be a workable solution for the short term, but we can't count on that as the financing for air service subsidies in future years, nor do I think we should be looking at it as an ongoing expense. You know, it's like a business plan. If you have to keep subsidizing something, at what point do you say it?

3:10:58 It isn't working. So I think we need to look forward to that as well. Again, so where John is saying pay for certain things out of the general fund, I would have to say, well, let's wait until we get down to that spreadsheet and we start playing with the pluses and minuses. Just as a follow-up, I am so committed to making our new marketing effort successful and giving them a full 100%.

3:11:32 So I tend to agree. First of all, let me ask, John, you're saying as far as we will get the chamber funded and we're going to figure out how to do that. It isn't that we're

3:12:07 Looking to not fund the chamber and that we will be able to fill our fireworks contract. Chamber, fireworks, and fishing. Those three. You feel that we will be able to somehow still keep those three going. You just don't want to do it through Major A. That's correct. You're good with that. Okay. You know, Rick, I think on your comment about the businesses, your discussion with Eric about businesses participating, one of the things that the guy found about the town of Mammoth Lakes is the people.

3:12:36 Take a wait-and-see attitude before they just jump into anything new. I found that with business up here, particularly. You open a new business down south and everybody wants to be the first one there so they can tell their friends they were the first one there and be part of it and all that. I think it's the same way with new ventures, especially since we have had some very successful ones and we have had some that are not very successful. And probably if we see that the new...

3:13:04 Tourism Board is able to take this strategic partnership with these groups and create successful events and raise the attendance at them and make them successful, then I think we will get buy-in from our businesses and they may be more willing to participate. But the other part of that that I think people are reluctant about is who's going to benefit from this. Is it going to be the little business on Old Mammoth Road or Main Street or out on the end of Old Mammoth Road south end or is it going to be...

3:13:33 The properties that are owned by the mountain and the bigger guy, I think that's a big concern amongst a lot of the business people here in town as we move forward with this. So I think we'll get it. If it's done properly, we will get it, but it's definitely a concern. On the idea of the air service, I've been toying with that for a long time. I like John's solution to how we will fund the air service if we...

3:13:58 So need to in whatever amount. I can probably buy into that. Is it marketing? You know, I look at the number of people Air Service brings in, and I look at the total number of visitors through the entire season that equates to it, and it's a very, very, very small percentage. So what is Air Service? Is it really heads in bed, or is it marketing? Is it getting our name out to the world? And if it's marketing, then the marketing people...

3:14:26 Maybe you should be paying for it. We're just not going to be able to determine that tonight. Major aid funds, well, major aid funds, maybe you should be paying for it, you know, so that's, you know, my only concern about that. The other thing that kind of keeps haunting me is the fact that many, many years ago, and John, you know better than I, correct me if I'm wrong, but we bought that airport with the understanding, with the mountain, that they would subsidize air service. We buy the airport, we incur all the expenses to improve it,

3:14:56 We incurred the liabilities that come along with it, which have been substantial up until now. And my understanding is that they said they would subsidize the air service. I think you're correct. And so I question, you know, where we are right now and what has happened to that agreement and why we're not pressing a little harder to get a little more of a commitment from that side to help subsidize our air service. And it's something I think we should maybe continue to look at before we spend our reserves on anything.

3:15:24 With that said, as long as we are getting these other entities, we're going to find that money for the chamber and the fishing enhancements and the fireworks contract. I can pretty much agree with the others about the use of this money and how it should be distributed. Any further? So let me just kind of reiterate. I'll go back through the list here to make sure.

3:15:50 We are going to, the town, the general fund is going to handle the pre-funding of the tourism and. No, no, no, no. Basically this. We're back on this. Okay. So the only things that the town is going to accept responsibility for that will not come out of measure A will be chamber contract, fireworks, fishing enhancements.

3:16:20 We're going to find the money for those. Air service subsidies are going to be guaranteed with money from the REU as needed or if necessary. Everything else is going to be Major A money will go to Mammoth Lakes Tourism and it is my understanding that none of the strategic partnerships, none of it will be encumbered with any specific directions from the Town Council.

3:16:51 Sound like what we are all talking about. We're on the same page. We're pretty much, but we will be dealing with each of those as a budget policy decision. Okay. Right? The four ridges. Because we haven't done that yet. Right. We have not done it with that. Yeah, you correct the four. Mm-hmm. I just, is that enough for a motion, Peter? Well, I don't think we were doing, I thought we were just going to work cooperatively. I didn't think we're actually making any.

3:17:19 Motion tonight. That's consensus. I think you could handle this a couple ways. One thing that you could do is just give us the direction that Skip just gave us, and we'll incorporate that into the continuing budget discussions. That's probably the best thing to do. That's good. Okay, then I'll stop there. You just need a consensus. Simple as easy. Okay. So we have a consensus on that. Yeah, Mr. Mayor, one other comment I want to get back to. I raised the issue of...

3:17:48 Participation by the private sector not as a condition of my support for what we're doing but as an opportunity to begin that dialogue, to begin the discussion because I think eventually that's where we're going to be and I don't know when the eventual is but philosophically it just seems to me that

3:18:12 That has to be the way that we leverage public dollars by combining them with private dollars. I don't know how much, I don't know how, and I don't know how you handle it equitably, but I imagine other resorts do because I see it nearly everywhere else as well, and I don't think that we should be any different. So I just wanted to make it clear that notwithstanding my desire to move in that direction, I don't condition my support as John has

3:18:42 Stated on getting that accomplished immediately. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah, I just, I think that how to spend your market, for the small business man, how to spend your marketing dollars is a huge challenge. Yeah. Huge challenge in these days. And to have an association that can help you leverage that and get you out there to more people in more places could be beneficial for...

3:19:06 Everybody, big and small. And I agree with you. I hope that dialogue starts. Mr. Mayor, can we take five minutes? And we will take a five-minute break. Thank you. Absolutely. I was thinking that would be good. Thank you. Do we make a decision? Thank you for your humor, Jack.

3:19:35 At least he's dressed appropriately. Now we just have to work on that. He did look to see whether or not you were wearing a robe.

3:20:06 Council is the only way I can separate two attorneys. All right, we will continue our meeting. We are on item number nine, the recreation division and policy development. Staff. Thank you, Mayor and members of the Town Council. We've had a number of discussions recently about the need to further develop our vision for

3:20:37 Recreation and also to develop a strategic plan as to how we take the resources that we have and the partnerships that we have and leverage those to deliver as much as we can for recreation. This is a follow-up to earlier actions that you've taken on that topic and what we have is a proposal from MLTPA to facilitate a process that would work on fleshing out the vision

3:21:04 But I think more importantly, putting some ideas on the table about how we can enact that vision through a strategic plan. So unless there are any questions, that really is the gist of the matter. And I know that John Wentworth has patiently sat through a fairly long meeting so that he can also respond to any questions. Any questions for staff? Well, actually, I just, if I may, just a quick statement. The reason for the two-page

3:21:34 That was emailed to everyone. The additional information was to just essentially say where Rick and I as the Recreation Commission are kind of looking for direction and concurrence in moving forward. The first part is that I believe we should accept the offer from MLTPA that they would hire

3:22:01 The outside facilitator to work through this process. We have already begun the discussions with the Forest Service under number three of having the leadership team, and we're just looking for direction. Yes, that's the way to go to get us to these high-level possibilities, and that numbers four and five on the second page of having a steering committee and stakeholder and public engagement

3:22:30 Are the direction to proceed? That is true, but I want to be a little stronger and say that I had the privilege of attending a meeting yesterday with Councilmember Bacon and others, including representatives of the Forest Service who are in leadership positions, and we did so as our

3:23:00 Whatever we're called. I don't know what that committee's called that we're on, but I guess it's Recreation Reorganization Committee. Yeah, that's right. And, you know, I really want to report, there's purpose in my reporting, my enthusiasm, I want to report that in the hundreds and hundreds probably of meetings that I've attended over the last 15 years of public service, I can't think of one, honestly, that I was more excited about after it concluded.

3:23:27 And the reason for that is that we have a history in this town of not collaborating with, cooperating with the Forest Service, or perhaps differently, they've not collaborated and cooperated with us. I think it's worked both ways. And that's gone on for so long that it's almost, you know, institutional. And what I heard in that meeting was something pretty extraordinary because the Forest Service was reaching out.

3:23:56 We want to not only accept that outreach, but we want to reach out ourselves, and I think that we have an opportunity that we've not had before, and there are a variety of reasons for that, and a lot of credit is to be given to a lot of people, certainly not me, I was the new guy there, but what I want to be able to do is not just get direction from you guys, but to drag you along, to get a hook out if you're reluctant, and allow

3:24:24 Joe Bacon and I to participate as the leadership component on behalf of the town and move forward as suggested in this additional information item because this is, in my judgment, a big deal. Other comments? I second it. John, is there anything that you would like to add to this? I concur with, my name is John Wentworth, concur with Rick's characterization of the meeting. I think Joe probably would as well.

3:25:01 I don't have anything to say at the moment other than I think that MLTPA's resources that we're bringing to the effort are as they're stated in these documents, and you guys have plenty of important work to do. If you have any specific questions, I'll be here, but I think the effort is in good shape and ready to move forward, and we're here to offer our help and support to see it successfully concluded. Thank you, John. Thanks for all your work. Truly appreciate it.

3:25:30 Is there any further discussion? If not, do I hear a motion? Mr. Mayor, I'll move to approve option one, which is to agree to participate in the process identified by MLTPA through the Council Requisition Reorganization Committee, and that that committee will direct the town's engagement with the process, including staff participation. I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, James.

3:26:00 Councilmember Eason? Yes. Councilmember Landon? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Item number 10, general revenue, general fund revenue update. The update on the general fund revenue, I want to first of all point out to you the steady increase in the revenue surplus over the course of the year. September is typically when we

3:26:32 Bring to you the first report of the year. July and August still are looking backwards to the prior fiscal year. And even in September, we had a $45,000 surplus. And where we were at the end of June, it's a little bit shy of $1.4 million. Again, I say this over and over, but revenue and expenditures related to the next fiscal year will continue to accrue. So this is not a final number.

3:27:01 The TOT receipts through the month of May is over budget by $1,614,000, and that surplus in revenue is offsetting some of the shortages we're seeing in some of the other revenue areas like property tax, sales tax, and franchise fees. The TOT surplus, though, if Council continues to adhere to the political commitment formula,

3:27:31 Then that would mean that $558,000 of that TOT would be going towards tourism and marketing, housing and to transit. The property tax category is $109,000 short of budget projections for this particular point in time. It's also important to note, though, that the delinquencies, the county experienced in collection 10% delinquency rates and property

3:28:03 Property tax revenue, whether it's received one day after that or seven years later, will at some point be collected. And so the town is expecting a final apportionment for last fiscal year that will primarily be delinquent payments. And we should receive that probably by the beginning of August sometime. That's what the county is telling me. Sales tax projections.

3:28:28 We're a little over 96,000 short, but still it's important to note that that's an improvement of over 64,000 from the prior year. And the reason for that improvement is, as we talk about sales tax year-round, we have those important true-up payments that the state processes. And so in June, we received a true-up payment for the activity in January through March. So the state estimates payments

3:28:58 And provides those estimate payments to the town. And those estimate payments were falling short of the budget. But when the true outcomes, it makes the picture better. General fund expenditures. At this point in time, it does look like there could be $150,000 in expenditures that exceed budget. And places that we're seeing that that's coming from is the extended lobbyist cost that throughout the course of the year, the hearing cost related to

3:29:28 Police, the legal services on franchise agreement, and a significant increase in the penalty charge property tax administration fee, and also liability insurance. On cash flow, if you compare June 30, 2010 to June 30, 2009, the cash position of the town improved by $3.2 million. And that is not

3:29:54 Counting the short-term note that the general fund holds on the terminal, which is almost another $1.8 million. Looking at projections for the end of the year, it looks like the general fund could have a surplus of $1,411,000. And after taking out the commitments towards marketing, housing, and transit, and the potential overage and expenditures,

3:30:22 That leaves a net available surplus projection at this time of $687,000. That was also what you saw in the budget policy decision that was discussed at the Monday meeting. So just to point out, you have your similar attachments that you've seen in past years that give you the comparison. Since we have some newly elected council members, if I can point out

3:30:47 When you see this each month, you'll see a budget to actual, but that budget is not the year-end budget necessarily, it's that budget that we expect at that particular point in time in the year. So that's why, you know, it doesn't do any good in the month of September to look at what the total TOT budget is and compare it to the small amount of actual revenue. So we convert that budget into what we would expect at that point in time.

3:31:16 And the different revenues have different collections and receding periods related to them. Then the next chart is just a comparison of the budget and actual in a picture form and then comparing the revenues and general fund revenues and a further breakdown of separating TOT and then separating all the other general fund revenue and showing you what those are, actuals compared to TOT.

3:31:46 The next chart looks at a three-year history for each month of TOT rental activity. So the rental activity is what generates the TOT, and you can see that, like everyone knows, season matters, but there are differences within each year for each month. And then giving you a year-to-date total,

3:32:15 That is what the next chart is demonstrating for TOT. And then the next chart is, or the next table is looking at community development revenue, particularly because of the slowdown in development activity that was extreme when we entered the recession. This gives you a handle of what's happening in that important area.

3:32:38 And then the last table is not one that you've seen in your prior months because this is the projection of what things look like on July 9th of where the year-end activity might be for the general fund revenue. And so the report that you would see next month will be a further update on the projections and will give you, there will be some revenue types that will be practically final and there still will be others that will

3:33:07 Not be final because we will continue to receive receive revenues. Yes, I do have one and it's something that I'd like us to look at in a couple of months after we get through the budget is that I'm a little concerned that we're not meeting our estimates on the permits and fees which means more general fund money than ends up having to go in and back fill in community development. I'd like to have a more thorough discussion of that.

3:33:46 So that we can see whether or not, you know, how much general fund is having to support that. Because I get the feeling from these monthly reports that it's still considerable. If there are no further comments, we accept the report. And we will move on to item number 11. As we made a voting delegate to the League of California Cities annual conference.

3:34:23 You've done that in the past. Are you available? I thought last year we didn't send anybody. We didn't send anybody. Okay. We haven't sent anybody for a while, but my name is on it. You really have your name on it even if you don't go. Can you see that part out? September 15, 15 to 17. San Diego. Mm-hmm. Are we going to send somebody this year?

3:34:46 We haven't heard of any interest, but if any of the council members are interested, that would be the person to designate. This conveniently doesn't have cost on it. I think we decided it definitely wasn't cheap. I'm happy to stay on it. It doesn't bother me. If we feel something comes up, I need to attend. Let me know.

3:35:16 Good. Do we need a motion on that or anything? Yeah, if they require a motion. It's a requirement, okay. I would move that Skip continue to be our designee. A second. There should be an alternate to it. Yes. Oh, who was? You're laughing. You want to be the alternate? I'll be the alternate. I'll be the alternate.

3:35:38 Okay. I'll amend my motion to include Matthew as the ultimate. I'll amend the second. I have a motion to second. We'll call, please. Jamie. Councilmember Raisman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Parton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Item number 12 is the appointment of the airport and mobility commissioners. Last night we did interviews for all of the candidates for that position.

3:36:07 Before we actually get into the voting, are there any further comments or questions that the council would like to make? Mr. Mayor, what I wanted to bring to the council's attention is that, interestingly, maybe it's not interesting, I received two calls today from individuals who felt that the outreach was not large enough, broad enough.

3:36:33 And we're suggesting that we actually not make appointments before having yet another outreach. And you always wonder what the motive is when somebody calls you, and one could argue that it's because the person or person's calling didn't like the candidates that had applied. I don't know whether that's the case or not, but I wanted to bring that to the council's attention because we did it a little differently this year.

3:37:03 I don't actually know what the details were of the extent of the outreach, and so I don't have a strong feeling about one way or the other, but I thought the council should know. Can I just ask a question of staff if we were to advertise once again for this, what would the process be and how long would we be looking at, Jamie? First, can I address what Councilmember Wood said? Yeah.

3:37:32 Actually, this year with the Roundup process as well, we advertised more than we have done previously because not only did we have a legal notice, which is only what we normally do, I also took out ads to advertise. And at the Roundup, they did say they saw the ads and that's how they knew about the appointment and came in. In addition, I emailed all the commissions, those ads and the appointments.

3:37:57 As well as I made copies for you guys so that everybody was aware that we were trying to do a big recruitment. So whether it's a valid complaint or not, we've actually done more than we've done in the past. I don't know how many more applications will we get. The terms do expire at the end of this month, July 31st, because they're all expiring at the same time. So we probably won't have time to...

3:38:27 Make appointments before the terms expire if you do want to extend it. And I don't know how long you want to extend it. If you want two more weeks running in the paper, if there's some different outreach program you would like us to try, whatever. I guess my next question would be is that if we go past the deadline where those terms expire,

3:38:50 Do those people stay on until someone new comes in, or do those commissions work without the people? They would stay on until they're replaced, although it would be nice to have a record that perhaps the council would make a motion to that effect tonight, if that's what your intention is, just to say that, that the members continue in their positions until replaced on or before picket date September 30th. Okay.

3:39:19 Mr. Chair, my input would be that there's four commissions that we're considering tonight. And on two of those four commissions, the people that I would support on those two commissions, I can't imagine if, you know, anybody else applying that would be better than the two people that I would support on those two commissions. So at least two of the commissions I think we should move forward to on tonight.

3:39:49 As a general statement, I'm prepared to move forward on the other two commissions as well. Jamie, thank you for that explanation. You know, I agree that it was a great process to try, but I think there was an awful lot of confusion. And I have a feeling that some people didn't really understand the new process, and that does concern me.

3:40:26 I got the same comments. There was some comment, too, that with the elections and everything going on and just everything coming so close together that people just did not really get, as much as we tried to get the information out there, that not everyone got, really was aware that how we were doing and what this roundup was all about. Some people did, but a lot of people didn't. So I have a bit of a concern also about this.

3:40:57 We spent how much time last night? We did. Not only our time, but the people that came in to interview. That is true, and we appreciate them coming in. And also, Jamie, for the future, mixing the commissions up was really difficult for us, just so you know that. I tried that, too, to tell you the truth, but then people would ask for certain comments. I tried to put it together as best I could. Sorry about that. I might even move forward. Okay.

3:41:26 With that, we are ready to move forward. The way we will do this is we will each pick the two names for the commission and we will start with the art commission, the public art commission. John, do you want to start us off? Yes, there's two applicants for two positions, I'm assuming. So I would move that we appoint Sandra.

3:41:56 Peterson and Noel Denkin. Second. I have a motion and a second. Do you want us to vote on these individually, Jamie, or do we want to do them as a group? Individually. Individually, yeah. You mean commission, individual commission. Commission is correct, correct. Yeah, not people. Call for the question. Call for the question. Councilmember Reisman? Yes. Councilmember Lehman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Porton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Pass.

3:42:25 Passes 5-0. We will then move question. Yes. So when we get to the 3, are we doing a little different? Yeah. We will. We will move on to the Mobility Commission. And John, we've got to start us off again. Yes. Is this the same situation? Two people for two positions? Okay. Then I would move that the council appoint on Mobility Commission Sandy Hogan and Dana Grenier.

3:42:54 Second that motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? If not, questions? Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. We will now move on to our airport commission where we did have three people and we had two seats open. We will each pick two people.

3:43:23 And Jamie will tally that up. And your number one rank and your number two rank, correct? When you pick your two people? I think just if you pick two names. Let's go with that first. Yeah, just pick two names and we'll go from there and we'll start with John again. My two names, even though we had three great, great applicants on this, and I hate to exclude anyone, but when it comes down to it, there are two applicants that I think we need.

3:43:52 On the Airport Commission, and that's Tom Heller and Pam Murphy. Rick? Concur. Matt? You know, there were three people I thought that were great. I would go with Pam Murphy and Michael Raimondo. And Michael, just because he brought some new things to the table, and also, I think, with his extensive business background and understanding of some finance.

3:44:20 I was particularly interested in what he had to say. So I'd say Pam Murphy, Mike Raimondo. Okay. Jo? My choices are Tom Heller and Pam Murphy. Okay. While it does make a lot of difference at this point, I tend to agree with Matt in the fact that I thought that in our discussion with our mobility commissioners during our interviews, we did kind of notice that when you get to someone who...

3:44:48 Is part of the interfere or spends a lot of time around it. They bring a different insight into it. And because of the fact that Michael is a businessman and he does use the service a lot, I felt that really made a big difference. So I would have to go with Pam Murphy and Michael Raimondo. So our totals are, Jamie, do we have...

3:45:10 Two that have garnered the majority vote? Yes, Pam Murphy has five, and Tom Heller has three, and Michael Raimondo has two. It will be Pam Murphy and Tom Heller. And I'll so move. I'll second that. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eisman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes.

3:45:31 Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Porton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. And Mike Romano, if you're out there watching, great candidate. I strongly encourage you to apply again when the next round comes up. That was not an easy one for me. Right. Our final one will be our planning commissioners. We have two seats available and three candidates. And John? Mr. Mayor, I would support

3:46:00 Rhonda Dugan and Tony Barrett. And having said that, I rated Rhonda Dugan the highest of all the interviews that we had last night. I thought she was an exceptional candidate. Rick? I agree. I would go Tony Barrett and Don Baruch. I think they were all pretty strong. I thought they all brought something different to the table.

3:46:30 And, yeah, I'll just go with those three. There's nothing, no reason I wouldn't have voted for Rhonda. I think she's great. And Don was just a way to bring something new. Joe. I'm actually going to take the option of voting only for Rhonda. Thanks, Joe. All the candidates are good. And there's, I think there's a need that we are at a point where there does need to, there's some work that is in progress that needs to be carried on.

3:47:12 It is a tough decision. I like the idea of having a new face and a new vision, but I kind of would like to see some consistency, so I would vote for Rhonda Dugan and Tony Barrett. I think in this particular commission, you hit the nail on the head. I didn't mention it, but you're absolutely right. I mean, we are asking a lot of our commission and of our staff.

3:47:38 In this area over the next year or possibly more and the continuity and the background and the history and the knowledge of maintaining that continuity was my key factor in supporting the two that I did. Thank you, John. Having said that, I would move. Tally. Yeah, the tally. Tony Barrett had three votes, Ron Dugan had five votes, and Dada Baruch had one vote.

3:48:03 Okay. And Mr. Mayor, I would move that the council nominate Rhonda Dugan and Tony Barrett as our two planning commissioners. Second that as well. Motion and a second. Jamie, we'll call, please. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Do I have a motion for consent agenda items 14, 15, 16, and 17? So moved.

3:48:32 Second. I have a motion and a second. We'll call these changes. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Lehman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Porton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And we had Joe, you have pulled item number 16. Yes. 13 and 18.

3:48:56 Yes, on the item number 13, which is the minutes of June 16 on page 8, I believe that my statement, the very first line was that the line in the handout regarding measure U be removed. R was fine. It's the very first line.

3:49:23 The line in the handout regarding measures R and U be removed. I was just wanting the reference to measure U removed. I'm sorry, I'm still... Page 8. Top of the page. Top of page 8. Top, thank you. Yes, there it is. Okay. So with that amendment, I would move approval of agenda item 13. I have a motion. Second. I have a second. Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Raisman. Yes. Councilmember Layman. Oakstein. Councilmember Wood.

3:49:54 Abstain. Mayor Proton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes. Three with two abstentions. I asked for number 18 to be removed because I was a little concerned that in this agreement the $3,600 which I believed we said was for equipping the vehicle is listed both as a contribution

3:50:23 And I was under the assumption that it was a loan, a loan to outfit the vehicle, that it was one time, yeah. So we have developed some revised language that Michael can review with you. What you have before you is Exhibit B of the agreement, and if you go down to the last paragraph, we have amended the language, and really we did one addition, and that's where it says, well,

3:51:30 The whole paragraph has been rewritten. The main issues here are that it's understood that the equipment purchased by the contractor under this section shall be owned by the town and utilized for the sole purpose of fulfilling the scope of services under this agreement. Said equipment shall be returned to the town if this agreement is terminated. I did have a chance to show this language to Mr. Searles earlier this evening.

3:51:59 On Tuesday afternoon, Rob and I did meet with Steve to alert him of this issue. Steve communicated to me that he was fine with this language added to the contract, and I do believe that hopefully it resolves all the concerns surrounding this issue. Thank you, Michael. I think, you know, as a member of the Wildlife Subcommittee, my only concern is that this contract hasn't been reviewed by the Subcommittee prior to being approached. On the other hand,

3:52:33 It's kind of an interim. It's an interim. Yeah. We can amend it if needed, so I'm willing to move forward with it if that's the case. Mr. Matters, I've also got a 30-day termination clause by either party, so it's effectively a short-term agreement. That's all. All right. Okay, then I would move approval, whether there's our options here.

3:52:59 I'd move approval to sign the proposed contract agreement with the amended Exhibit B.

3:53:05 I have a motion.

3:53:09 Second.

3:53:10 Second.

3:53:11 Jamie, roll call please.

3:53:12 Councilmember Eason.

3:53:13 Councilmember Leighton.

3:53:14 Councilmember Wood.

3:53:16 Councilmember Wood.

3:53:16 Mayor Pro Temp-Dacon.

3:53:18 Mayor Harder.

3:53:19 Mayor Harder.

3:53:19 Yes.

3:53:19 Motion passes, 5-0.

3:53:21 Mr. Mayor, I don't know what the protocol is.

3:53:23 Maybe the town attorney can help me.

3:53:25 But with respect to agenda item number 14,

3:53:27 I mean, it...

3:53:30 Councilmember Lehman and I needed to abstain from that as well, and that was included in... Legally it's not actually required, but it's sort of traditional. So I think unless there's objection from anyone on the council, you could simply show that as an abstention. On the ground that we were not members of the council on June 17th, and I just missed it. Very good. Thank you.

3:53:56 With that, we will adjourn tonight's meeting, and we will meet sometime later. We have closed sessions. We do have closed sessions. Yes. We do have closed sessions. Sometime later. Sometime later.