Town Council Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 52 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
230 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 I think it said 1.30, but we've never gone that long, because the reality is you take us up and you do three hours of hard trail work, and you're ready to be done. So, yeah. So, we meet at Footloose, right, at 1.30? No, up at Coldwater. Oh, at Coldwater. Why don't we use personnel items, public safety? There's no much more than personnel, is there? So many people to visit with until this time. Well, if you started sooner...
0:31 Uh-oh, he had to bring his own cookies. We're in trouble. I brought an extra one to share with you. You guys ready? Yes. At this time, I would like to call to order the Town Council of Mammoth Lake special meeting for Thursday, July 29th. Roll call, please. Council Member Easton. Here. Council Member Layman. Here. Council Member Layman. Here. Council Member Bacon. Here. Mayor Harvey. Here. If you would please rise and join us in the pledge. Please join me.
1:10 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, the podium is now open for public comments. The public may comment on any items that are not on our current agenda. Is there anyone who would like to say anything? Terry. I have someone that I would like to introduce.
1:46 To the council and community, this is Donnery, the new executive director of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And so, I don't know if you'd like to go around the room and say hi, as we have Brad, finance director, you know him, Rob, John Eastman. Welcome again. Thank you. I appreciate it. Congratulations. Thank you so much. This time the tape's running. Very nice. Very nice to meet you. Welcome aboard. Nice to meet you. Nice to meet you.
2:20 I'm excited. I'm looking forward to the opportunity and really just getting in the community. My family will be here in about a month. They're probably about a three weeks, maybe a year old, a four-year old. So they're both very much outdoors kids. My daughter is six years old. She's skiing about 15 resorts and probably has over 100 days on her. So she's pretty well spoiled at this point. So I'm looking forward to getting them here and getting started. I've been on board since Monday. So a little bit of whirlwind so far. I hope so far so good. And this will be the opportunity to continue.
2:51 John, what was your last area that you moved here from? I was in Green Target, Wyoming. Okay. Yeah, prior to that, I spent three years in Colorado working for all 26 resorts. Uh-huh. And then I was in New Hampshire for 14 years with Americans. Oh, okay. Yeah. Great, thank you. Excited to be here. Good. Thank you. Bye. Thank you. Sandy. Sandy Hogan, speaking as a citizen. Tonight, I'd like to comment a little bit more about something that came up a couple of weeks ago.
3:28 If you remember, it was the work plan for the Community Development Department and Public Works, and it was a very ambitious plan. At the time, I was not very articulate. I was kind of taken aback. I admit I hadn't read the agenda item thoroughly. And I'm hoping to present kind of an alternative tonight, and I will give you something to take home and take a look at. It's a little more in-depth to think about, and we'll probably explain
3:55 A lot. I was going to read it, but I found out I would far exceed the five-minute timeline, most likely. But anyway, the idea of this is I would like to help Council focus on how to set the priorities and how to look at the timeline and to understand why maybe there may be alternatives, ways to go at this. I found the goals in the timeline and the narrative, because there is a narrative also. This was on the July 19th meeting. It's very ambitious. But I do think it's overly complex.
4:24 I think it's overly optimistic. It comes from my background. I was with the Forest Service. We have NEPA, very similar to CEQA, planning processes, whatever. During that, my 30 years, almost 30 years, I served both as a person that wrote environmental assessments and conducted the NEPA, similar to CEQA, conducted the whole process. That was pre-management days and then later as a planner. But also, I was the line officer.
4:54 I'm the San Bernardino District Ranger, and here's an assistant forest supervisor who directed the focus of the NEPA, how broad they should be, evaluated the risks, just as you're asked to do, and Rob is asked to do, and Mark, so that projects could move efficiently through the system without waste. So anyway, in looking at this timeline, I'm offering kind of an alternative perspective.
5:18 Because I think one of the important things on this timeline, and I've circled and underlined a couple of the places where I want you to focus, understand the difference between a study and a plan. A plan is something you can adopt. It becomes part of the general plan through policy, like zoning or some other enforceable policy or regulation. And that's important. We want to get to those because you want developers and public and the council, everybody to understand that this is something
5:47 That must be followed. A study is a precursor. It's one component of a plan. In other words, studies are visions or ideas or concepts, but they are not plans in and of themselves. They form a plan. And so generally, we have a number of studies proposed, and we have a number of plans just kind of hanging out there that could be part of our general plan very quickly, actually within this next year, I would say, in this timeline.
6:17 So what I'm trying to do here is explain the difference, because some of these plans may not even require CEQA. In CEQA, and I've done a little bit of study on it, I'm not an expert, but I'm just, as in NEPA, there are general things that exempt some plans from even requiring any kind of CEQA. Then you have other ones that are categorical exemptions, I think, or exclusions. I always forget which one is CEQA, which one is CE, anyway, we call them all.
6:47 Which require the minimum amount of CEQA, which can be done in-house. Some of these lead to a negative DEC, which is minimal, minimal. And then, of course, others require EIRs, which is similar to a Forest Service EA or EIS. And these can be either broad or they can be focused. So I've tried to kind of point some of that out in here so that you guys can maybe evaluate this a little bit better. What worries me about...
7:16 I mean, it's a wonderful concept to be able to put everything out there, work on it like crazy, get to the point where you put it all in one document and analyze it. That's very risky. One controversial item or one thing that gets one group hung up on it can result not in just appeals but litigation. And at the end of a couple of year period, we have no plans in place. We have no zoning code update. We have none of this. And that's what worries me. It's the risk part of it.
7:46 Whereas a lot of these little plans, cultural arts, that's probably not even going to require any amount of CEQA. The mobility plan, we've got so much there ready to go. Let's get it done. I'll talk about the park and rec plan later. You've got, of course, your trail system master plan's going on. Thank goodness. But you've got the...
8:13 Also, I think your resort investment and public facilities plan, again, that one's almost done. And what happens is, get these done. I guess my message here, as you'll see, is to get these done now. A lot of them aren't going to take a lot of investment. And then go ahead with your district studies, because all of these are still in the study stage. There is an integration time. I think it's looked at for about the next year, this time, ending up, when you put them into one great plan. I believe that's the concept.
8:42 And I think that could be the appropriate time to handle all those. It'll still be a big problem. And that's going to be a big EIR. That won't be a little one. It'll take a while. But then maybe you can handle them all. Or you could even choose to do those separately if you want. But I guess what I'm saying is don't hold all of these other plans hostage to completion of this ambitious district study, series of district studies, because it's going to take us years.
9:12 It's just like doing the general plan all over again, which is really frightening as a citizen. I'd sure love to see some of these other ones knocked off. Anyway, so I think that's all I'm trying to do is give you some ideas to think about, and maybe some combination will work here, but I wanted you to be able to take these home and think about them, because I think the best thing with priorities and budget and long-range planning that you're doing is to be able to sleep on it.
9:39 I found that a long time ago as a district ranger. Emergency things, yeah, you've got to act on. And things aren't emergencies. Think about them. Analyze them. Ask those questions. And, I mean, it's a hard job for council. I know a lot of times you can't talk together outside of council. It's very difficult when things are presented to you to make a decision that night. And I'm saying, well, maybe there are other ways to do some of these. Anyway, thank you very much. Any questions? You can hand those out if you are.
10:08 Give some to Jamie and she can pass across or however you want to do it. Skip it. There's no one else in public comment. Can I speak real quick? Is there anyone else that has anything in public comment? John? We didn't have anything on the agenda that I have for Councilmember before. Thank you. I just wanted to report to the Council that I did have the opportunity to attend the Children's Fishing Festival at Snow Creek last weekend.
10:38 It was really well attended, lots of kids, people were actually out there for the balance of the day. The reason I mention it is the town normally contributes financially to that event and it was my understanding as recent as the week prior to that event that they were short on funding somewhere in the range of $3,000 to $5,000 to Alpers Trout to
11:06 Pay for the number of trout that were planted in the two ponds out there. So I just am requesting staff to agendize at our next council meeting, council discussion, if in fact there was a shortage from this group that put on that event to outburst trout and council to consider reimbursing the sponsors of that event at some level possibly to pay for the trout that were planted. That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you, John.
11:36 Is there anyone else that has anything to say in public comment? If not, we will move on to our first agenda item. It is a workshop to discuss official year 2010, 11 proposed budget and budget policy decisions. And we have been provided with an agenda here that I believe we're going to try to work off of. But before I get into staff report, I just want to go across the council and see if there's anyone that has any comments or suggestions as we move forward tonight.
12:08 I believe there's two additional items after F that in our previous packet we were given a handout page starting with C1 about the Measure R awards and I think we need to discuss that and I'd also like us to discuss the information we were provided under H1 and the following pages regarding special events also relates to the special events that are in the recreation budget
12:38 So you would like to see the major R awards added to this list and then H would be the special events. Is there anything else from anyone? If not, we will move into staff report. Thank you. We've provided you with an updated budget review and adoption schedule. And on that schedule tonight, we indicate that we're going to review
13:08 The recreation-related budget policy decisions, which there are six of. The police department section of the regular budget. And then we have an opportunity, if it is the council's desire, to go back and review the budget policy decisions that you've looked at before. And then finally we have a closed session on labor relations to end the evening this evening.
13:36 Then next Wednesday at the regular council meeting we have a public hearing on the budget and at that time the council will have the option of either adopting a budget or extending the working budget for an additional period of time. And we also have a closed session regarding labor relations and a discussion of the town administrator or council administrator form of government.
14:07 So then we've also indicated that if you're not ready to adopt a final budget tomorrow night, you could continue the hearing to September 1st and operate on the working budget until that period of time. So that's the game plan as it stands right now. And unless there are any questions, I think we would just move right to the recreation-related budget policy decisions.
14:38 The first budget policy decision number seven to be just to be discussed tonight is the utility user tax revenue funding of parks development debt service and parks recreation and trails this is the last fiscal year that the utility user tax will be a general fund revenue and the utility user tax has been used to fund the debt service that primarily funded some of the
15:08 Parks Developments that we enjoy today. And $589,000 or almost $590,000 of the utility user tax revenue projection is channeled to go fund that last year of debt service. The remaining amount, which is $327,747, has been programmed in the proposed budget to help fund the Parks, Recreation and Trails Department.
15:37 In addition to that, at one of your prior budget discussion meetings, Council added $30,000 funding for the skateboard park enhancements and stated that that also should come out of the utility user tax money at that time. This funding should be considered one-time funding.
16:05 Starting July 2011 it is a special tax it is levied at the same tax rate that this one is but the special tax will be restricted on what it can be spent on and those restrictions include recreation mobility and arts and culture so the the recommendation is to use the portion of the utility user tax revenue not needed for
16:35 Funding the Debt Service to fund the operational costs in the Recreation Parks and Trails Department. Questions of Brad? My question is actually of my fellow council members is I remember that we talked about funding the skateboard park for $30,000, but I do not remember saying it would come out of the UUT balance. I thought my notes said general fund. No, I remember John. Okay, UUT, that was what you said? I was thinking general fund, but it could have been UUT.
17:08 I thought it was, I kind of got the impression it was. We'd have to check on the tape. Okay. Well, if everybody's okay with it, it was just the clarification because my notes were slightly different. I'd just like to enhance, point out what Brad was saying, and correct me, Brad, if I'm wrong. What Brad was saying is that it's his recommendation that we use $327,000 from leftover UUT monies.
17:39 To one-time fund operations of a town department. So if we do that, if we make that decision, then what do we do next year? Where do we find that $327,000? The reality is we would know today that we already have to cut $327,000 in next year's budget. So my point is I would rather use that money for reserves or something else and make the necessary cuts.
18:09 This year to pay for that $327,000. Other comments? Yeah, I'd like to say that we know this is a transition year because of the Measure A, the DMO splitting off, and I do believe that it would be appropriate for the transition year or the gap year, if you want to call it, to use something that is one-time money as long as we are going into it knowing that we have to find a different source to continue the funding of the department.
18:42 That also gives us the opportunity to do that vision and strategic planning and know which direction and what recreation would look like going forward. I thought we had discussions on this already. I think last time we had already, or at least some of us had, discussed that that money would best be placed in the reserves. I think that was kind of a goal. In addition to dealing with the transition, we have a
19:19 A goal to try to get this REU brought back up. Well, I believe that the other sources that we discussed would bring the REU back up without affecting this pot of money. But until we go back and work our way through them one by one, we can't be sure of that. My concern is, in this case, of putting a whole bunch of money in reserves and cutting services below a level that we actually have to. You know, let me just make sure we're both clear on that. Maybe you and I are thinking the same thing.
19:49 Different sources of money we're talking. There was a 588 that was going to split half into the RU and then half into you guys going to go to community development, and I thought that is where the $30,000 was going to come out of, to be honest with you. That's the pot that I thought the $30,000 was coming out of. But this is a different amount of money. Yeah. So that's where I think I got a little bit confused. There's two sources of money coming out of the RU.
20:19 UUT tax. Right. Isn't one the return, isn't the, the 588 was the return of the deposit, and then this 327 was the leftover funds after the certificates of participation are paid off. Correct. Correct. Okay, just so everybody's clear on that. But I was also in agreement with you that it was, that the 30,000 was supposed to come out of that release from the bank or whatever we're calling that. That is where I thought the 30,000 was coming from.
20:50 Yes, Rick? I think you're right on the 30. But my... How long ago was that? Only a week? It seemed important to me at the time. I can't imagine. We can't remember it. But I actually think you're right. With respect to the 327, my notes from long ago indicated that I did not want to...
21:19 I did not think that it was the correct policy to use found money as I had described it to fund the operations of a department and that we need to put it somewhere other than in that department. And I had in my mind reserves consistent with what John had said, but I don't hear anything that changes my view. I just think it's fundamentally not right
21:48 We're not good planning to, whether it's a gap year or not, use found money to finance ongoing operations when we don't know what's going to happen next year. Bill, would you like to provide some insight on this? No. Anyway, I got the short stick. We had a commission meeting just before this. It was a workshop to go over somebody's policy. And the position of the commission tonight was that the
22:17 Found money or the measure you money would be inappropriate for funding a department for several reasons. One being if we use that to fund the department this year, then first we're not making a commitment to recreation in general fund dollars. And next year we come back with the same fight. We don't want to come back with the same fight. We don't want to have to justify director and all of this and come back with proposals to cut those positions so that we can save money because we haven't found the money. We would prefer that you would make the commitment to recreation.
22:46 Got to look at those found dollars. There are other things. Hopefully we aren't going to make a decision on the ice rick tonight for us to talk about later. But as that decision is made, we have a $500,000 grant that's going to have to be used. Maybe this found money would be appropriate to add as the town's share of that. Don't know. But it's a possibility. And find regular general fund dollars to run the apartment. Thank you. Thank you, Bill.
23:15 You're going to go through this with a case-by-case, so. Correct. Yeah. Thank you. Yes. Do you need a consensus, Brad, or do you need a motion on this? No, we're not, we're not ready to vote yet. This would be a consensus, I think. And I think what I'm hearing, at the two ends at least, is the consensus and, to my right, is the consensus is that we not put this into a department, funding a department, that we
23:47 Put this into our, you want to put it into our reserves, is that correct? Well, for the moment. I was going to say as a placeholder. Yeah. As a placeholder. So I'm hearing that, Jo, you were sort of going for the... I was feeling that we're going to end up with a whole bunch of money in reserves and we're going to have a problem providing the services that our citizens expect. So I'm just going to reserve that until we get down to this figuring out what's going where.
24:15 Because we've had so many different versions handed to us that, you know, once the REU is at 25%, I am hoping that there's additional money that gets freed up that does go to some services. Okay, and I think it makes sense personally that we do put things into reserve and then at some point after we have made all of the changes both in our spending and...
24:37 Our revenue figures that we know how much we actually have in the bank to spend rather than spending things that might not be available next year or taking on funds for another year ahead of us and that type of keeping. So I like the idea of getting the reserves built up as much as we can. If we come up above 25%, then we know we've got real money that we can deal with. So I would go with the consensus of putting it into the reserves.
25:06 You may, Bill. You have more reserves than just the Reserve for Economic Reserving. There's the Parks Reserve and the Insurance Reserve. So you may want to consider found money for more than just the R&D Reserve. You could also go into the Parks Reserve and pay for future park projects. And that's probably a good point, Bill. And maybe that's something we need to look at is what percentages should those other reserves be at, you know, and are they all up to the...
25:32 Level that we want them? Or do we need to spread some of this reserve money into the different accounts that maybe we have borrowed out of over the years? John? Again, correct me if I'm wrong, Brad, but I think that I asked for something along those lines at a prior meeting where we would have all the reserve funds where they were five years ago, where they were two years ago, and where they are today. Yes, the five years has been provided earlier.
26:01 But in your budget is the projected reserves. Let me find the page number for you. Page number one. On page 85. Thank you. This doesn't reflect where council might have consensus but haven't voted on some of the policy decisions. And this is based on the projected revenue way back end of April. So there will be changes. But this is what was known at that time. Okay.
26:41 It would be relevant to me and I think the rest of the council if we saw this single page breakdown of the different reserves where it was and I don't know what the years are but I would go back where were the reserves six years ago where were they three years ago and two years ago and this shows us where they are today.
27:18 It shows us the fluctuations in all of these reserve accounts, and I think it addresses what Mr. Sauser, I believe, was that said that there are other reserve accounts in addition to the REU. Mr. Mayor, one last comment. One of the things that is supporting my thinking is the discussion we had last time about, I don't know whether we reached consensus, but at least there was discussion about not
27:48 Allocating the air service guarantee funds to a particular department, but to have them come out of the reserve for economic uncertainty in the event that we need to draw upon them. It's for that reason that I'm real nervous specifically about making sure that fund has adequate funds if the council goes in that direction. Otherwise, there's, I mean, we've provided an opportunity to free up $325,000, I think is what it is.
28:16 By not putting it somewhere specifically, but having it in reserves. But that's fueling my thought as well about why those reserves ought to be higher than they might otherwise be. Good point. So do we have consensus then that this money for the time being will go into the reserves? Not complete consensus, no. I'm still looking down the line at how do we pay all this. So it's a four or five consensus that we're going to...
28:48 Move this money into reserve for the time. But then I need clarification is whether or not you all are considering that the skateboard cost can come out of one-time money, the skateboard park cost. Is that what you're saying? It's a one-time. I think that is a one-time funding. It's not something we need to look at in the future. And I would say yes on that. We're going on to B, I guess. Well, yeah, so we dealt with the additional skate park cost.
29:23 And we'll go to B, number 12, the Measure R Administration. And, Jo, how does that differ from your awards? This is the part where staff is working on something, and they're charging their time against Measure R. It's that. The ordinance allowed up to 8% for administrative costs, and I was just wondering if we have any kind of an update, because unfortunately at the time we were given this, it said this year's charges had not been processed, so the historical data is available, and I would hope...
29:54 By now there would be some kind of an idea of what percentage was actually charged in this last year. So, yes, that question was asked and time was not charged to measure our administration. You know, that was something that we asked the department to do and that the department did not follow up on. So last year there were no charges made to measure our for administration. But it is an appropriate charge to make and we think that this is a reasonable estimate of what those charges would be.
30:23 That the 4% is the reasonable? Yes. Okay. One of my concerns about, I mean, 4% may be a great place to start, but one of the things that has not happened, and we've already awarded funds three times now, is there's been no audit as is required in the ordinance that's been presented to us. You know, one of the things where the community gave this was because the funds would be audited and there'd be reports of how the money was spent.
30:58 And we haven't seen any of that. When could something like that be produced? We'll follow up and give you a time frame for that. Okay. I briefly commented on this a few years ago. It seems like a few years ago. A few years ago. And 4% is really minimal. Even 8%. Because staff does spend time on this. And that's not just recreation staff. That's your administrative staff. The audit, as Jill pointed out. In other words, I think the 4%.
31:30 It really isn't going to cover much. It won't cover actual time spent by staff. I know that administrative costs in other governmental agencies run as high as 18%. It's pretty high. It used to blow my mind, but this one is minimal, but necessary. Thank you, Sandy. We're learning how to streamline and be more efficient. Well, and if once we get some baseline data, the reality is that
31:58 Actual cost could come off of a later distribution if it exceeds the 4%, but we do have to start doing something and being accountable. So we will provide a time frame for the audit. Okay. Bill? Uh-huh. So sit up front. Yeah. Look, you got to make an effort, you know. Um...
32:28 So actually we were told as a commission that last year's actuals were going to be somewhere between $9,000 to $12,000. Where that was lost in translation, I can't tell you, but we were given that figure. And we think that that's probably an adequate figure to start with. I will say that while there are certainly administration costs, this again is found money. This is money that people of Mammoth voted to spend on completing parks and building trails and facilities in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
32:58 If it takes so much staff time that what I just told you was the commission's take. I'm now going beyond that and giving you my own take. If it takes so much time that it requires an extra person to be put on, then it would be appropriate for us to charge it back to that fund. If, however, the staff we currently have on hand is able to deal with it in their day-to-day activities and it doesn't push them over the top,
33:26 Then I would recommend we do the same thing we did this year. The people are already in place. They're already being paid out of the budget. Let's use this money as the people intended it to build product instead of paying for staff time. Again, the staff is already there. If it doesn't require an additional staff person, if they can do it in their day-to-day business, why wouldn't we continue to pay them with the same source?
33:55 Instead of using that money to pay staff someplace else, why would we not allow Measure R dollars to pay for product on the ground rather than staff time? But again, it was my estimation, to be fair, that 9 to 12 was the amount of hours. Whether that didn't get translated to the finance department or not, I don't know. But that's what we were told the actual hours that had been counted by the department would have been for this year. To do the administration? To do the administration of Measure R. We were told by our staff
34:24 Our staff, 48 Commissioner, sorry, but I consider our staff, that that would be what the actuals came out to this year on the hours that were counted by staff in the department using what, you know, hourly rate, I can't tell you. That is just what I was told the actuals would have been for this year. Can we get some idea, does anyone have any idea what's entailed in doing this? I mean, 9 to 12 hours of, what only is it? No, I think he meant 9 to 12,000.
34:55 $9,000 to $12,000. If you take the staff time out and break it down, I was told that that is approximately what this year's bill would have been. Again, I can't tell you what that was based on. I just asked the question, and that was the answer I was given. But again, if they can do it in the hours that they currently have, it's not adding extra staff requirements, I would suggest that we continue to use our paper
35:24 Infrastructure and not for staff time. Thank you. Well, my only concern with that is that we just took $327,000 out of that budget. If we don't add it all back in, my feeling is if you have a project and you have a steering committee that's giving you specific conditions to do the administration, the contract monitoring, and the auditing, that it is appropriate for that to come out of the fund of money so that it would be appropriate for Measure R.
35:57 I think that we have no idea what it would be, and if it's not this amount, then that amount would roll back into the fund, but I think it is very important that we properly manage those funds, we can show it to the community, and that it is appropriate for that to come from Measure R. Do we need to look at this $33,400 figure that appears, am I reading it correctly, that is what we're putting as a cap on this?
36:24 That says they will not exceed. Is that figured maybe too high? I don't think it said that in here, actually. I think it said just a baseline. Proposal only changes will not exceed 33. It's estimated. Okay. Estimated. Estimated, yeah. A suggestion I have is that we are now tracking the hours that we put into measure our administration. Maybe we can report those out to the commission.
36:50 And then they'll be, so they can monitor them at their regular meetings. And if there's a problem, they can address it there or bring a recommendation to you. John. I just wanted to clarify for Council that what I'd asked for earlier on their different reserve accounts, Brad has already supplied that to us as of April of this year, April 26th. So there is a document from Rob Clark to the Council.
37:19 Related to fund balance reserve history. So we have this. I would just like to request staff then to republish this and hand it out to the council so that we could refer to it. Thank you. You know, I'd like to get to the policy question on this irrespective of the 33,000 and I, you know, I am conflicted. I don't know what's necessary in terms of
37:47 The administrative costs or cost of administration. But we've said tonight that $300,000 or more that was projected or proposed to be included in Parks and Recreation is going to be found somewhere in the budget. We've reduced revenues. Well, we've not actually made any decisions yet, but there's a general consensus that the
38:15 Revenue projections are going to be reduced by a million two. This is an austerity approach, and it just seems to me that from a policy perspective, if we want to, you know, the million two is punishing. If we want to, you know, add a little pain, we have staff go find the $33,000.
38:42 Bill, you're right in that the people want all of the money spent on building stuff, but the fact is that we're spending a lot of money on planning stuff right now, not building anything. And I don't know. I see this as a necessary expense. I don't know if it's the right number or not. If times were really flush, this wouldn't be much of an issue. You'd say, well, take it out of the general fund. We've got plenty of money. Put as much money as we possibly can into recreation.
39:09 But the fact is that we've said to staff that times aren't going to be flush. You've got a million two less than you want to spend, which I'm supportive of. But I think the implication of that is that we probably ought to deduct from the measure of our funds a reasonable sum for the cost of the administration. I would agree with that. One problem I have is it runs along the same lines as Bill, and that's that we're already paying staff.
39:41 A certain salary. I've always had a problem with pulling out of other funds to keep paying for them. And I'm wondering, is this something that's going to be ongoing year to year? I'd be okay with it this year because we are in a transition year. But certainly next year I would like to have further discussion on whether we keep pulling out of different departments and what not to pay staff if they're already being paid out of the general fund. So something to think about for the future. And I understand it's for purposes of trying to
40:11 Keep track of where are our times being spent, this, that, the other, but I'm wondering does it have to be done with dollars or can it just be done with a tracking system? So for this year I would be okay with seeing some funding go to that as part of a transitional period. John? I'm fine, I don't have a good sense on this. I think Rick is right with the policy is that it should be
40:39 Charged to the fund. It's no different than if you have a state grant and you're charging your administrative percentage to the state because you're not doing the process unless you had that money. I agree that we have no idea how much it really is, which concerns me, and that we didn't get data in this last year also concerns me, but as the measure our steering committee is going back and looking at the whole process, maybe they can make an estimate of what they think it's going to cost.
41:09 Instead of just having these guesstimates in here. But I believe the policy is correct that this process should fund all the pieces of what our community is expecting. And I agree that that's taking a little bit of money away from putting things on the ground. But if nobody's managing those contracts and nobody's auditing them, we could be in a much worse shape down the line. And if we don't fund it with a specific fund, it's going to disappear because there isn't general fund to fund it.
41:39 So, Sandy. Yeah, if I could just, I know this is, it's something that's very hard for, I think, for recreation folks, and I'm one of them, I love it, to say, you know, we've got to take some of these funds and pay staff. But when you create more work, the work has to be paid for. And while people are saying, well, people are already being, they're on staff, well, that's general fund money. And so you, by, you know,
42:08 Creating more work and tapping what's allowed because administration is in the ordinance, you pay for that work and you free up a little bit of general fund money to go a little bit farther. In other words, that allows the general fund money to stretch. And it's common practice. I guess that's all I'm saying. It was really hard when as a manager I was first faced with that and I had partners coming in and wanted to give us money and we said, okay, but we're going to charge you 18% administrative. But those are real costs because more work,
42:37 Is created. That's the theory behind it. And I agree with Sandy on that whole idea that these funds are actually creating more work. And that general fund money, not every, you know, the bulk of our community believes in the recreation element of what we do up here and how we are building our community. But there are still those folks that may even debate what recreation we should be putting our money into. So to have funds.
43:05 These funds helping to pay for the administration I think is the proper way to do it. I also think, though, that Rob's suggestion to have regular reports to the commission as to how much is being drawn out, how much time is being spent, and detailed enough that you can understand if it's being effectively applied or efficiently applied is a necessary item, and the audit is absolutely a must that we need to get done. So I think we have a census on this to leave these funds in.
43:35 As is. Bill? I never said it wasn't appropriate to spend the money that way. I was just hoping to put it on the ground. However, when we first came to you with Measure R as the committee and the commission, one of the things that a commitment was made to and I didn't follow up on and council didn't follow up on was at what rate this would be billed out. So if we're going to actually start billing this out because we use a true cost accounting method, we were hoping to drill that down.
44:04 Not have our pay for its share of the paper and copiers and manager that a committee, and I don't remember who was appointed, but there was a committee appointed for the council to go back and find out what that was, that we reconvene that and come up with a billable rate for the different staff level people that are going to be doing that outside of that true cost accounting thing so that we're not paying cars in the carpool or printers in the offices, if that makes sense.
44:30 I think that's what I was trying to allude to when I was saying it needs to be detailed enough that you know exactly what you're being billed for. Item C is number 23, the EIR for Parks and Recreation Master Plan. Mayor, members of the council, this budget policy item number 23 discusses whether or not we should pursue a measure R grant to fund preparation of the required environmental analysis
45:09 of the draft Parks and Recreation Master Plan. Although there is a number in this report, we don't know how much it will actually cost to conduct the environmental review, so this is simply a placeholder. The Trails Master Plan EIR is about $140,000, which we negotiated down through a very competitive process.
45:34 This funding is not currently in the budget and that's why one of the options is to pursue measure our funding. The staff requirements for us to do this, we don't have the funding now and we have not included it in our work program or the sequence of work and we did that for two reasons. One reason is that we don't now have the funding and the second reason is
46:04 This master plan was prepared over two years ago, and the work started even longer than that. And since that time, we have gone through the community facilities funding committee work. We've completed an audit of all of our plans through that effort and found a series through all of our documents of issues that we ought to address so that the plans that you're considering for approval
46:32 Are correlated, they're linked, they relate to the resources that you are more probably going to see in the future. And for example, it's very difficult for you right now to assess whether a dog park, an ice rink, a recreation center, or a civic center by any kind of policy document is of a highest priority.
46:57 We're certainly happy to conduct that environmental review with the funding that you direct, but we think at this point in time, in the sequence of work that we presented you about 10 days ago, that there is a rational process to complete this work. Ms. Hogan made a number of very good points. The CEQA process is unique. It's different for every project, every plan.
47:25 Every plan you adopt will probably have some form of a CEQA analysis. As you know, categorical exemptions are for very simple, straightforward projects like a sidewalk that will be built within a resisting right-of-way. Trail System Master Plan is a program master plan and a program EIR. And by the contract that you saw come forward, it has a complex scope of work. Some of it includes
47:55 Field Studies, Biology, Archaeology, and many of those skills are just not available through most municipalities. That's why we rely on consultants. The program that we presented, we certainly gave you a very, very high order of presentation of how it works, and Ray Jarvis and I, and if you have questions about mobility plan, feel free to ask Mr. Jarvis.
48:22 We have just been discussing the best way to discuss with the Council more details, if you want, on our program, the sequence, and discussing with you, should we bring our scopes aboard, like we have with the zoning code update, which was an attachment to your report 10 days ago. Does the Council want to...
48:46 See that we have a scope and a method with milestones and target dates because we do internally establish those. We typically don't share those or present those to you. On our district planning processes, we come to you after you've gone to planning commission and we present the study area, the detailed steps. We discuss how many meetings we're going to hold and we give you our overall timelines and then you give us direction and then we treat that as our
49:13 Contractual scope of work to conduct our services. So I'm giving you a lot of information. One, you have options on this. You can direct us to seek funding to conduct the environmental analysis. Two, you can ask us to do that but hold the completion of the master plan. The master plan is a very good start, but it is nowhere near the detail.
49:43 This is $40,000 for an EIR. I'm assuming this is more of an update.
50:14 Master Plan updates the 1994 Parks and Recreation element of the General Plan, and it makes general recommendations, and it substantially changes the park open space requirement numbers that are associated. Our planning number would drop from, I believe it's 10 acres per 1,000 population to 5 acres per 1,000 population. And what's important,
50:43 And it results in a statement that says the town should acquire 13.88 acres of parkland. And so what's important and what we learned through our planning audit is can you afford it? Do you already have those acres? Are they sited? And this draft master plan speaks to a lot of additional work that needs to be done, which would, a lot of that would be done through the district planning process and through the investment program.
51:12 And as we talk generally about the CFFC program, and we're very aware that Measure U and Measure R are before you, and there is a sense of urgency to implement some items. Some items are very long-term, and in a way, some of the themes in the master plan are maintain what you have, finish what you've started, and plan for the future.
51:37 And it needs some work to be what would normally be a master plan or provide general plan element information that you'd get in a comparable municipality. So your recommendation is no? My recommendation is you can choose to fund it, but don't start it until you get some of that other work done. Questions from Mark? Thank you, Mark. And one other thing I'd like to address, if I could. We're not creating a mega plan.
52:14 So that's not on the table. And Sandy, we're happy to meet with you and go over our sequence and program in detail so that you can see how that we've spaced and staffed our efforts. Thank you. Thank you. Council, comments? Well, I think I'd like to hear from Bill. Bill. Presuming he's speaking on half the commission. Yeah. I'm going over what we talked about in our meeting. Mm-hmm.
52:44 So the question we had in our meeting was where'd the SNC grant go? Originally when we did the trails plan and the parks master plan, there was an SNC grant applied for us and measure our dollars were allocated if necessary if SNC didn't come through. And we were told at that point in time what it would take to complete both of those. And we assumed at the time that both of those environmental processes would be happening together for some cost savings and doing them both at the same time rather than separate.
53:14 Our feeling at the time, what we were told at the time, I'm stumbling on the words today, sorry. What we were told at the time is the SNC grant would cover both processes. I don't know what that amount was. I don't know what the current ask is to complete those. I don't know if $40,000 is for work. Beyond the scope of the original master plan, I suppose what we need to do is ask Mark to come to the meeting and give us an update on where the master plan is, why the master plan was presented.
53:43 Is it adequate? As every town department had an opportunity to speak to that at every juncture of that process. And the report here from my standpoint isn't complete because it doesn't speak to the funds that have already been allocated, the SNC grant and the original R grant and why they are now $40,000 short. And we were told there was reserve money and other dollars that had already been allocated to finish that.
54:11 Projects without having to come back to art. So that was our take, and those are our questions. So the next time we can agendize that to get those answers and complete where the SNC money went or if it was allocated. If I could, through the chair.
54:42 I can answer some of these questions now, and we can come to you because you've got a workshop on this related item. The SNC grant is a grant by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, and their grant award was for the Trail System Master Plan. They explicitly, as the granting authority said, it can't be used for the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. So it was simply denied and not allowed to be used for this other effort. And, you know,
55:10 Whenever we look at EIRs that are related to various master plans, there's some degree of overlap. And SNC and we found that there wasn't a tremendous amount of overlap between parks and the trail system. And the trail system was certainly a critical path, so we ended up being funded for that effort. And I can't remember the total of the grant, but it's more than the CEQA contract because it covers $185,530.
55:40 Five, yes. Very good memory. So with that, that's why the trail system master plan is moving forward. And you recall that it was delayed because the state in last year's budget cycle froze the SNC grant because it comes from proposition money. So we're on track there, and we're happy to come to you and talk to you about this overall work program and the master plan.
56:13 Yeah, I'd like to speak a little bit about this. I referenced it in what I gave you earlier. And there was something that we used to call white hat projects. Remember the guys in the movies that wrote the white hats? You know, good guys. And white hat projects are ones that generally the public supports. They want to see done. You're not going to run into a lot of bad stuff and controversies and whatever. And this one, you know, along with cultural arts, whatever, is likely to be what we would call a white hat plan.
56:42 What's been done here already and hasn't been mentioned is the cultural studies have been done, the archaeological studies, and the biological studies have been done. This is CEQA ready. It's ready to, without those, you don't even need those. This is the type of project I frankly think could probably be done in-house, meaning using existing staff. You have a CEQA expert planner on staff. You have a recreation planner on staff.
57:11 The recreation planner led all of the public meetings on this, and there were a lot of public meetings well attended because I and folks in the Knowles went to a number of them. There were a lot of interagency meetings held. The document is a pretty good document. It was also followed by a huge survey that was mailed out to, I believe, over 12,000 people, including first and second homeowners. It had a pretty good response rate.
57:40 As far as surveys go, like over almost 700, I think, over 650 responses giving, you know, so there was a lot of input into this plan. Now, there's never a perfect plan, and the longer you wait, something else needs to be added. That's just a fact of planning. And I guess what I'm saying is, get this one over with. You've already got 130 days programmed on that timeline to do it. Well, program it to be CEQA, not just additional tinkering and toying and adding.
58:09 From things that have come from studies, not plans. In other words, do finish the plan, and then as the studies materialize over the next year or two, all you do, and as they're adopted by the council, then they also amend your plan, and they add to it. That's how it's done, at least in the, I think, most planning fields. You have a plan, there are living documents,
58:36 And as other things have come up, or, you know, whether they're from the private sector or from one of these other plans, the district studies, then you amend this one, and you just have amendments. That's my suggestion. This one, I think you have a couple of plans that you could use. Staff that are programmed for work, using the experts in-house. Now, obviously, cultural and biological studies do have to be usually contracted out because you don't have those on staff.
59:05 Some of these don't even require much because they really have, a lot of the programmatic documents do not have huge physical impacts to the ground, and you don't really analyze those until you get ready to put them on the ground, such as the Whitmore track, which is already disturbed. Anyway. So you're saying you think this could be done in-house and we should not move forward? You know, it may not even need an EIR.
59:30 That's what needs to be evaluated in-house. Does it need it? Or are we thinking that this is so big? I mean, you know, it's not rocket science is planning. I did it when I was way below management. And CEQA has the same type of benchmarks and standards and timelines. It's just a matter of following processes. And if a project is complex, then you better hire a contractor. You better get, you know, plenty of specialists, whatever. But if it's a simple project and has public support,
1:00:01 Go with it. Evaluate the risk and do it. And if it's a risky project, then you better spend money probably. I wanted to just hear what Mark's response was to that. The way you determine the scope and the cost of an environmental analysis is first we have a project proposal. Then we would go through the environmental checklist that is a standard checklist where you use to scope the analysis required. And then
1:00:32 You either do it in-house with support and back to what's very simple. Tiny little projects are usually can be categorically exempt and you just write a letter and say it's exempt and that's the end of that. Then the next level is a negative declaration where you're declaring there are not potential negative impacts. The next degree of complexity is the mitigated negative deck wherein
1:01:02 You identify just a few items that can be reasonably mitigated, and you document those as actions. And then finally, an environmental impact analysis or report. And those can be really complex, depending on the project and its impacts, or they can be relatively simple. So in our staffing program, we can do some of that work in-house for sure.
1:01:29 But you don't know what the analysis will be until you've completed the initial checklist. We also, from a staff perspective, this is what we did last fiscal year. We had funding set aside to complete the housing element, and then the contract was approved. And then as budget worsened, we ended up insourcing that work and using those monies not to pay the consultant but to complete it.
1:01:59 And the point is, we can do a lot of this work in-house, it just takes more and more staff time, which takes it away from other projects. And so we've been very careful in setting up the staffing allocations to cover that large work program. And so if we do it internally, and if we're using measure R funds, and it becomes a new revenue source, we should balance and weigh
1:02:27 Whether you're using that to replace general funds or if you're using it in addition to general funds. And to the extent that we can keep our talented staff and we can outsource this work, it gets done a little more quickly along with the other work. In terms of the analysis, I think there are two issues to really think about. And either way works and it gets done this fiscal year.
1:02:55 One of your considerations is you could certainly go through this process and consider and adopt this document. Nobody's going to die. It's not a fatal flaw. And then you'll have an update to essentially the general plan. We'll change those standards. And we can do that. We'll just shift some of our resources and sequences. The reason that we have suggested we look at it a little more holistically is not to delay.
1:03:26 But to have a better overall product. Either method works. And, you know, of course, we're happy to follow your work program priorities. So we could go either way. Thank you. Council? Jo? If you remember, Skip and John, about a year ago as we started in the recreation reorganization, I...
1:04:01 Mentioned the fact that the policy items that were buried in this park and recreation master plan should have come forward for discussion. That didn't happen. It's still floundering on the shelf. For example, it says we need to have an outdoor venue, but it doesn't say where or anything, which makes me question, well, how are you going to do CEQA if you don't even know where it's going to go yet? But I am so concerned that it's just languishing out there. It's now another year older.
1:04:28 It's actually costing us money because if a particular project like Trails End Park comes up and then you have to stop and do CEQA if you want to pull a single project out and work on it, I think there's a real advantage to getting it done and then having the basis for Measure R and potentially Measure U allocations for anything that's going to affect Parks and Recreation Master Plan.
1:04:55 Since it precedes Measure R, and it's really not Measure R's fault that it's out there, I would propose that we use some of that one-time found UUT money to fund this rather than saying we want it to come out of the Measure R allocation and just get it done. It's saying it's direct staff to apply for funding. Right, but we could also say take it out of the released UUT money and not.
1:05:28 Take it out of Measure R. Again, it would be more money going out of Measure R to planning instead of something on the ground. And my logic there is because this has been hanging on before Measure R even got passed. But it is affecting the ability of each Measure R project to be considered because everybody has to run around and figure out if it needs CEQA because this plan didn't get done. What's the dollar amount roughly that we're talking about? They've got an estimate in here of 40. 40,000? 40,000. Okay.
1:05:59 Well, you don't even need that estimate because you have 130 days programmed already. If you accept the timeline, that would be general fund most likely. What worries me about Measure R is, one, then you're planning your budget on something that hasn't been awarded yet, which I think everybody said they wanted to avoid because the Measure R awards don't happen until the fall again. And so you would be planning a work program, you know, saying, yeah, go ahead with it based on Measure R, but Measure R...
1:06:25 You know, the commission is going to recommend things that will come to you in the fall. So again, you've put it off. You keep putting it off. If you've got somebody pro, if their staff hours programmed, 130 days programmed, well, for something exactly that is not site-specific and is not meant to be, it addresses levels. It's a programmatic document. It addresses levels of service and what we should be in certain years compared to other communities and things like that.
1:06:52 It's a very valuable document, and right now, Measure R, the Commission, is using this document to decide whether projects, you know, are included. It's a draft document, but it's a draft ready to go. Not perfect. Never will be. Well, my only concern is that if we're really talking about the $1.2 million cut in general fund, then there may not be money in general fund to get it done. And so I was looking at one-time money for a one-time option.
1:07:25 I think the question that's going through my mind right now is that is there a way that we say let's don't apply for the major of our funds, but yes, we want to get this done, and yes, we want to get it done in-house. And the amount, you know, how many bells and whistles do we want to put on this thing? You know, do we want it done with all the bells and whistles that are going to require the extra $40,000, or do we want it done within that time frame that's already been allotted?
1:07:52 to this and use the staff time that we currently have available to us. It's just a function of identifying the priorities for that department and I think that you've hit on what I was thinking as well. If we think that it is of a higher priority than, for example, the zoning code update or equal priority, then...
1:08:13 We direct staff to do them both or to do one ahead of the other, but I think we have to give direction, and I think it should come from us in a unified way so there isn't any question about later, when something isn't done, about why that is. So what we need to do at this point is we need to decide that whether we are or are not going to pursue the major R funds, and if we are not,
1:08:40 Then we will put this into a category where it's going to later be prioritized on other workloads within that department. Yeah, and that would be my suggestion. I would agree with your suggestion if that's what it is. My only concern is that at our last meeting we were talking about whether or not we could afford that work plan that was 19 staff and a million dollars. So before you just say, well, it falls under that one, I think that
1:09:10 We have two questions. Do we want to get it done this year, yes or no? And then if we want to get it done, what are the potential funds of money when we actually start figuring out what we have in our reserves and balances and things? Mark, was this a critical component of that schedule you had laid out to have this done? Can you explain that a little bit for me?
1:09:38 The overall schedule that we developed shows completion of the master plans, making sure your standards, you can afford the standards that you're setting, that you've gone through the general process of figuring out where your events and venues should be. You know, we recently went through a grant process where we – where does the grant go? Does it go to Mammoth Creek, the bell-shaped parcel, the Civic Center site, the –
1:10:07 It's a little challenging to proceed with capital improvements if we haven't figured out this physical development plan of where you want to see your facilities and why. So the overall program was sequenced to finish up the parks plan and have those discussions about where those facilities should go, complete that with and through the neighborhood district planning process.
1:10:35 Which is also linked to the mobility plan, which is moving forward. You know, we've just completed the traffic models and we're moving into the traffic analysis. So we're moving ahead on these projects. And at the end, because we did not have money to conduct a CEQA analysis, we didn't show CEQA analysis in our work program. So if you direct us to complete the CEQA of this, you know, in whatever time frame you think is appropriate, we won't do something else.
1:11:03 Sit down and go through that CEQA process, determine if we can do it in-house and to what extent, and then just complete that process. And with CEQA, then we would complete also the public hearing, public review and public hearing process of the master plan. So you'd be adopting a master plan and certifying your environmental documents.
1:11:24 So, Mark, just to make that in 25 words or less, the work plan you showed us at the last meeting that had time in there did not include working on the EIR for the Park and Recreation Master Plan. Correct. That would be something that was in year fiscal, year 11-12. So it's not funded in his work plan. No, I get that. I understand. You said that at the beginning. Yeah, I think this is coming back around to where we were on an earlier discussion of
1:11:52 We put this into a category and into a place where we are going to come back and look at it later. But until we know what that reserve fund looks like, how much extra money we have, and where the cuts are being made, these are tough decisions to make, but we can't make these decisions right now. So at this point, I would say, you know, see if I have consensus on the fact that we're not going to go for the $40,000 major ARG request on this, but we are going to...
1:12:19 Put it into a staff work plan that we will prioritize at a later date when we know what our funding sources are. Does that sound logical? Yes. If I could, there. Yes. We're already 1-12th complete with the fiscal year, and so if there's anything that we can do, perhaps with our workshop format, whatever you want or don't want, let us know because
1:12:47 As the time slips away, we're not sitting idle, but how we plan what we do is going by. So we're anxious to receive direction from the council. Quick question, Mark. Have you already started the Sierra Valley Sites District Study? We've started working on the scope of work that we'll bring to you to review and approve. Yes. How would exchanging that
1:13:17 Work plan with the park and recreation master plan. How would that adversely affect your staff process? In other words, can we interchange those two? Yes, we can. So it really depends. So those two are interchangeable. So it would depend upon which one of those two council thought was the higher priority. Yes. And there might be some.
1:13:41 Edge work we do to figure out. I want to just pass those down to the council because we're not, we're talking to, currently we're talking about not starting the park and rec master plan until when, November? Yeah, it was in October, October, November. Right, we anticipated doing some quick fast workshops with all of the commissions on facilities and priorities to get the guts of the
1:14:09 The infrastructure program, facilities infrastructure sketch so that that could roll into all of the master plans for computation. Okay. So I would just suggest to council that that's something we might want to consider exchanging those two on the work program, exchanging the priorities on those two. And I think based on what I've heard, that is something we – I think you're something to consider before we begin to prioritize and decide how we're going, what we've got left.
1:14:38 We may find out so much money left over that we just go the way we want. Someone want to pinch Scott? Wake him up. What have you done in that bottle? Okay. Real quick, but I think what Mark's telling us is do you need direction from Council sooner rather than later? Yes. Like, what, a week? Tonight? Yes. Yes. Okay, so therefore, I'm just saying to Council, instead of postponing the Day of Reckoning,
1:15:07 I'm prepared to give direction to staff tonight instead of postponing that decision and putting them further behind. Terry? I have a quick question. You know, I have no idea. Obviously, I'll ask the question. I'll have to answer it. Can the parks plan be piggybacked with the trails plan so that we're putting that in with the same CEQA? I don't know if there's something that's
1:15:35 Specialized that they can't be put together. Transplant has been started. Yeah. It just started, though. Yeah, but they would coincide if we did. How many could it say people will be doing the first plan that is doing the transplant to save money that way? I don't know. Only if you gave us money to fund it. Okay. Well, would that save money? If they gave you money for that, would that save money for you?
1:16:08 Yeah. We don't know. I don't think it would – we don't expect that it would be a significant savings because it's just different information. You know, the introduction – Mammoth Lakes is a community located at approximately 8,000 feet. You know, that will always be in there. But it's a different kind of – it's just added scope of work. But we can certainly look at that.
1:16:37 And I think that's one of the first things we do if, you know, if this is your consensus. We'd actually sit down, write the initial checklist, see what it looks like, and then we'd talk internally about what it will cost us in terms of time to do it. And then we'd talk with that consultant. I guess that was kind of what I was thinking, is that's an outside contract, so it wouldn't be taking this staff's time in, you know, I don't know what the whole process is, so I don't know.
1:17:07 Sounds like that's the purpose of it, because they've allocated their hours already pretty specifically. And one last question. I believe Sandy was correct in saying certain elements of it were done with Measure Our Money already. Right, but some sections of the EIR have been done. My only concern is that.
1:17:32 You know, until we know again where the monies are and what the budget actually looks like, I don't want to alarm any members of our community to think we're putting them somewhere further down the list until we have a chance. And if that takes another week to do that until our next council meeting, if we can get more information at that time, we want to make our final decisions. I'm fine with the week so long as we commit to making a decision in a week. I'm okay with the week. I hope we could do it. Yeah. Okay. Okay.
1:18:02 So I think what will happen, we will be distributing the agenda for next week tomorrow, and it will have a hearing on the budget as part of the agenda, but I don't think we'll be able to give you written material on this particular topic, so we'll be bringing material to you at the budget workshop to address this. Thank you, Rob. We will move on to item number 27D on our agenda. It is the sidewalk snow removal. Good evening, Council, Mr. Mayor.
1:18:35 The budget policy decision addresses the addition of sidewalk and path snow removal for the upcoming winter. In addition to what we performed last year, which was North Village and Old Mammoth benefit assessment districts, sidewalk snow removal on Sierra Park adjacent to the hospital and the high school, paths along Meridian between Sierra Park down to Commerce, the path behind this building from the library to Chateau.
1:19:03 And the path on Old Mammoth Road between, essentially between Waterford and Snow Creek Athletic Club. What we're proposing is that we would conduct sidewalks snow removal on Meridian between Old Mammoth Road to Azimuth. That's a route that a lot of school kids are taking to get to school. And then also we're proposing that we would add snow removal services for the new
1:19:33 Lake Space and Path, also known as Lake Mary Road Bike Path, from Minaret up to Kelly Road. And that way we could potentially get visitors that are staying south of Lake Mary Road that could access that path from Kelly and from Hidden Valley. They could potentially use that path to get into the North Village or elsewhere. And then also we could potentially get folks on the north side of Lake Mary Road
1:20:03 Coming down Lakeview that they could potentially get on that path also. The cost that's proposed for this additional work is $19,500. If you thought maybe you just want to include the Lake Mary bike path, Lakes Basin Path, that's estimated to be about a $12,000 cost to do that next winter. And the balance of that would be for the sidewalk along Meridian.
1:20:31 Yep. Ray, if our stated cost here is $19,500, and we get reimbursed from the state of California on our snow removal costs, so is the true cost 50% less than that? Right. Good point. I forgot to mention that. Okay. We get that reimbursement in the following budget year, but that's right about 50%.
1:20:51 And can you restate for the council and the public what the town manager and town staff was able to accomplish in the last month or so with the state of California as it relates to that reimbursement? I'm not sure what you're getting at, but I think... Yeah, what happened is that in one of the prior state budget cycles, the budget proposed taking snow reimbursement money away from most cities.
1:21:17 In that particular proposal, there was an exemption for small cities, and we met that exemption, but there was certainly a fear that they may come back at some future time and take away the gas tax money that goes for snow reimbursement. So we, with the city of Truckee taking the lead, got legislation passed and approved and signed by the governor that protects the money now. So the bottom line is that, in my mind, is that that 50% state reimbursement is guaranteed. It's no longer questionable, if you will.
1:21:47 And that was guaranteed through state legislation? Correct. Okay. So it's pretty solid. Any questions for Ray? Comments? Thank you, Ray. Yep. Bill? Comments as a commissioner on this one. We're not so much in why to remove the snow or how to remove the snow. It's a great idea. I love the meridian snow removed. People are walking down that street in snowstorms all the time. My question is, why in the world is sidewalk snow removal of the recreational budget?
1:22:23 Gas tax, reversible, special assessment districts. It looks like we're spending a lot more on recreation, but we add that to the rec budget. I understand that, but it would seem to be that Public Works is the home. Not that it makes any difference. It's just moving items around in the budget, but that was our question is why is the, if it's a multi-use, or multi-use path, certainly that's appropriate, but I'm not sure the sidewalk snow removal is a,
1:22:51 The Park Department. Peace. No matter. Okay. Thank you. Sandy? Speaking for the Mobility Commission, the Mobility Commission definitely supports the North Side of Riding Boulevard from Sierra Park to Azimuth, the school route. Our focus the last couple of years has been if we do snow removal, let's do the ones that lead to school. So I just wanted to let you know that the Mobility Commission definitely supports that.
1:23:24 I think we all support it, but as you mentioned earlier, Skip, we have some T's to cross and I's to dot before we allocate additional monies, so we might want to postpone this until we get to that point. I'd like to put it in the same pot you've been talking about of the things that if there is funding that we... I'm also hoping, you know, since as we build more sidewalk, we're going to have this as a continuing process that...
1:23:52 There's hopefully, and it was one of the reasons why I fought to have it read mobility and not transportation in Measure U, is that that might, in the long run, be a source of funding for getting more and more of our sidewalks cleared, because Bill's right, and I have to say, I live on Meridian, but I talk to Peter, and this is, you know, it's a public benefit for the entire town, so I don't have to recuse myself, but you don't want to know what people are doing walking down that road in the middle of a snowstorm with five-foot snow banks.
1:24:22 Okay, so I think we're in consensus that we're just going to, yes, we want to support this, but we're going to hold it over until we know what we've got. Item number E, item E, number 28, the ice rink operations. Thank you. The proposed budget assumed that the ice rink would be operated in the coming season, and so...
1:24:47 If the council were to choose not to operate the ice rink, there would be a $55,000 saving in the Mellow Roots district and a $76,000 saving in the general fund. And so I know there are ongoing discussions, some of which are closed session discussions about lease negotiations on this topic. And so you may choose to decide now or to wait until that plays out a little bit further. Questions, comments?
1:25:16 I'd like to hear from Bill. I know that his commission has had some discussion about what he thinks ought to be done. Actually, we didn't talk too much tonight about the operation of the ice rink. One of the things that I'm going to tell you personally is stop calling an ice rink. It was intended to be an ice rink. It was intended to be a year-round multipurpose facility. Good for you. That's what it is needed to be if it's ever going to be successful, regardless where the location is. So please, let's...
1:25:45 Call it a multi-use facility of some kind and quit calling an ice rink. You heard me already talk about perhaps the leftover U money to help with the cost of the slab. We have a $500,000 grant. If we don't use it, it goes away. Unfortunately, we've had it for six years and have sat on it. We were told that there was funds in the budget to cover the town part. There isn't. We should have dealt with placement issues some time ago.
1:26:14 So that we weren't under the gun as we are now, because now to use that grant and not turn it in, it has to be used at that site. I think you've already heard us on the lease and that if we're going to continue to spend money on the facility there, we'd like to see some control of the land with the town. And I think we're working on that already. Maybe don't run it this year. Form a committee. We have the recreation commission.
1:26:42 Form a committee of interested individuals to look at the rate in its potential future. The facility. The facility. The multi-use facility. Absolutely. Year-round multi-use facilities. Which may or may not operate as an ice rock this winter. Right, right. But we've looked at a lot of things. You know, there's a problem with the height and the library with the lease.
1:27:09 We keep saying we have to have a cover over it because we can't keep the ice solid, but there are other solutions to that as well. We can add compressors. You know, you can have an ice rink outdoors at 80 degrees if you've got enough refrigeration. So there's a lot of things in that multi-use facility that needs to be looked at besides this lab and the location. Other potential options to keep it operable instead of building it, you know, a 44-foot tall cover over.
1:27:39 But I think that it needs to be dealt with. We've waited six years, and the grant's been there for six years, and we've waited until we were in a financial quagmire to do something about it, which is a shame. We've come through the highest high Mammoth has ever seen, and yet we haven't managed to finish one park, which is why we keep suggesting to you that perhaps we haven't put recreation on a high enough priority. Thanks. Thank you, Bill. Comment from Council. I like a suggestion.
1:28:10 I'd like to clarify that a little bit because the recommendation here is we consider the recommendations of the Tourism and Recreation Commission. I do not want to be in the position we were last year where it came back to us one week before the opening date and saying, hey, do you want to open it after they'd already done all the prep? So I would think that...
1:28:34 We need to make the decision sooner rather than later on whether or not it operates this winter as an ice rink. I think the other issues are the ones that we are working through, but I would hope that we can come to a decision on whether or not it operates sooner rather than later. I'm going to beat this horse. I think until, one, we don't own the land.
1:29:05 We don't know where the money's coming from. I just, again, I think it's poorly placed. It's operating at a loss. And, you know, there's still the threat of possibly having another rink in town, which may serve another type of a purpose. I understand it's a multi-use facility. But, you know, quite honestly, I don't think we even know what the plan is. And, you know, how do we make a decision on how we're going to spend millions more dollars without really knowing?
1:29:34 What our direction is. And again, I'm not comfortable on spending millions more on property we don't own. So as far as I'm concerned, we don't operate this year, and I think we need to start considering about putting old yeller down, because it's just, it's not a very viable project. I just don't care for it. I'm happy to make that decision now. I'm not operating it for this next year and exploring options.
1:30:06 I don't think we should. I don't think we can afford it. And I will tend to agree with you on that. I mean, as much as I support the rink, I do think it is, as much as I support the multi-use facility and occasionally using it as a nice rink in the wintertime, I do agree that looking for myself, looking at the bigger picture in the long term to do it right and to save that money this year, if that little bit of money can...
1:30:32 Go towards making a better project out of it in the future, and if we can resolve some of the issues with the leases and all that kind of stuff, and we're being in a better position, I could live without it for one year if I decided to do it. I think it would be the best option for us. Further comments? John, are we in consensus on that? I think we are. I think we're in consensus on that. Okay. The Mammoth Nordic Operations, 31. Mr. Mayor, my...
1:31:12 Look, my recommendation on this would be to postpone making a decision and have the applicant reapply for the, this is the fall cycle, funding cycle. May I agree? I agree. I will agree with you. I will agree with that also. We should go all that easy. And we now have added two more to this. We have the measure, our awards. Joe, you asked that.
1:31:47 Yes, I did. And in the packet that we received on July 7th on page C1, I had specifically asked for what funding was in the budget for Measure R. That was pending approval. And we did receive that information, but I wanted clarification of which of the
1:32:11 55,000 for the ice rink, 30,000 for the tennis courts design, or the 20,000 for the community center park were awarded because this is not matching up with the other documents we received in the other packets. And if those three were all pending approval, I would recommend that they be taken out of the budget. Bill, can you help us out on that one?
1:32:41 Well, there's a $55,000 and then there's a $20,000, so I'm looking to staff to ask them, you know, because there's $105,000 that is in the budget, balancing the budget, that probably wasn't awarded, and that's what I was asking for clarification on. There was an addition to the original Measure R awarded funds to the Community Center Park.
1:33:12 In the fall process. And then in the opportunity process, we awarded another, I think it was $20,000. Yeah. Well, there is a $20,000 figure here. Yes. So that was awarded because it was necessary to complete the original project. And actually, that bid award is on your agenda for August 4th? Okay. But the $30,000 for the tennis court design, that was awarded?
1:33:38 But the $55,000 for the ice rink improvements was not. It was contingent upon lease moving forward, the town controlling the lease before we were to spend more money on it. And I think there's some confusion because we then came back and said the price was less than that. We originally applied for the $55,000. This was for the fencing and for the other related improvements. And do you recall what the number was, Ray?
1:34:09 It was a lower number. I think it was roughly half, though. 28. 28? That sounds right, yeah. 28. Okay. So that, you know, what we, as Bill indicated, that was kind of awarded on a contingency basis with the requirement that it have to go back to the commission in order to be finalized. And then in a subsequent agenda bill that we actually removed from the council agenda,
1:34:37 We had suggested another source of funding for that $28,000, and I think it's all part of the ongoing discussion of where do we go with the ice rink lease and the ice rink multi-use facility improvements. Okay. I just wanted to make sure there was no money in the budget that had not actually been awarded or that we were not expecting to have awarded to us. So that $55,000 is a questionable figure.
1:35:10 Well, yeah, I think we came up with the lower figure. No, it's in the budget. It's going to have to come out. That sounds right. Okay. I understand what you're saying. And then special events? There's two pieces to the special events, and one of them is in our budget book on page 29, and the other one was a Measure A discussion, but I don't think we really got through
1:35:44 In the recreation programs on that page, one of the things it says is that the town pays for and produces the Halloween carnival, holiday tree lighting ceremony, and Fourth of July pops in the park. And the tourism and rec, when I asked for more information, was given page H1. That was the special events that we had the discussion about last week in Measure A, and we said some of those should be general fund and some should be general fund.
1:36:14 Stay where they were. My concern was that in the Mammoth Region Recreation Council discussions and in the townies subgroup of that, we had made a distinction between events that essentially were resident-related, like Halloween and the tree lighting, and yet the 4th of July, we had discussed that as being a visitor time, you know, because that's the start of our summer.
1:36:44 And so I'd like to ask that to go back to the commission to clarify which things should fall in which pot, you know, which things might be considered as a special event that's related to visitors and may be eligible for measure A versus those that we feel are a true recreation extension for our community. That's a good point. I support that, Jo. Thank you, Jo. More work for the commission.
1:37:19 Item number three is a general budget review on personnel items. A is public safety. Okay, so as you recall, we went through the various departmental budgets at one of our previous workshops, but we held back public safety so that Chief Watson could be present. Chief Watson obviously was not here at the time of the development of the budget, and his
1:37:46 assignment over the next six months is going to be to go through a whole variety of different issues relating to the police department and how it operates. And so I think one potential purpose of this particular review is just to receive input from the council on things that you would like the chief to review going forward. And then if there are specific questions that we can answer, we'll answer them, and otherwise we'll research them and bring back the answer at the August 4th budget hearing. So you're just being
1:38:18 for some direction and or questions that council may have. Is that correct, Chief? Yes. I've been here for a total of six days, so obviously I don't have my arms all the way around the budget and staffing issues. I've got a basic understanding and my learning curve is still real steep, but I'm sure I can answer some of the questions regarding staffing issues in the budget. And I guess that's, I'll reiterate what the town manager suggested that I'm looking for.
1:38:48 Areas that you would like me to take a look at regarding the budget and staffing and whatever concerns there would be. Maybe I can start with John, if I could. Certainly, we would like you to take a look at your organization and see what your needs are. Obviously, that's what you're going to do anyway. I would like for you to do that with two things to consider for myself. One is an analysis of
1:39:20 Considering that we're in a tight budget situation, whether or not the school resource position is a position that you would recommend to be funded as a separate officer position in the budget. It's my understanding that the City of Bishop is no longer funding their school resource position at their schools, and I'd like to know if that's true and if it's true what their reasoning was.
1:39:50 for not funding that position. Additionally, I'd like for you to keep in mind when you're comprising your organizational structure or your organizational staffing to keep in mind that typically officer positions are more costly, if you will, to the overall organization and that the council has instructed the town manager to reduce our
1:40:19 budget projections for this coming year by 1.2 million to see if there's any opportunity within the department to help in that area. And I noted that the proposed budget does have two sworn positions cut from what the authorized strength was last year. Good. Thank you. We're going to meet tomorrow morning, and I think what I wanted to say tonight is what I've
1:40:53 I've been saying for the last several months, and that is I think really what I want is an objective, credible analysis of what the sworn officer needs are and as a subset of that during what periods. I think that many people in the community feel that the
1:41:23 Information that has been presented in the past has been presented in a way that simply justifies the existence of an existing structure. And it may be the correct structure. I don't know. I'm not looking to critique or provide an opinion as to how many officers we need and when. That's a level of management that I'm not really interested in. But what I really am interested in is having the community as a whole have a sense that
1:41:54 What's recommended is what is objectively needed for the community. And I think the fact that you have been here only six days provides you with a unique opportunity to do that, given that you've got so many resources within the department itself to draw upon. I think that's the main point that I would make. Yeah, I think what I've heard really just some public concern has been
1:42:27 Is with staffing levels as well. I too would like to have somewhat of analysis, but maybe even also a breakdown of, you know, what officers are on when and, you know, is there overlap and things of that nature. You know, we have officers on salary. In the last analysis that I saw, it basically broke it down in how many days an officer was working and whatnot.
1:42:54 And it was a little bit hard for me to get my head around exactly, you know, how many hours a particular officer was working. Was it a 40-hour work week? Was it a 20-hour work week? And, you know, so, yeah, just basically get an overview of, you know, where some of our officers are and when and how that's going. And just listening to a lot of folks in the public and, you know, I've heard both sides of the story. I've heard some people saying, you know, they live in Sierra Valley sites and we need more officers.
1:43:24 The other side of the story is, you know, I can't tell you how many times I've heard, you know, we see somebody pulled over on Main Street and there's two more officers there. So, you know, it gives the impression that we have too many. And I think that type of analysis might help us out. Thank you, Matt. Chief, I think the only thing that I would probably add to this is that we're somewhat unique up here in that I think every...
1:43:54 This community probably has some fluctuations in what they anticipate in their scheduling, but for us, quite often you may see Thanksgiving coming into play as an example and anticipate a busy weekend with a lot of tourists, and that might be a decision that's made early in the month, and by the time Thanksgiving gets here, there's no snow on the ground, and there's no skiing or very limited skiing, and all of a sudden the holiday that should be quite busy becomes very, very slow.
1:44:23 And is there a way, working with unions and the requirements you have about scheduling to make changes quickly, to be able to adjust a schedule within a matter of a day or two and reduce staffing needs if the demand isn't really there? And I think that's something that we as a community, the business owners in this community, particularly after a few seasons of being in Mammoth, learn to do
1:44:53 Rapidly, because they realize that payroll can kill them, and they make those changes on almost a morning's notice. Sometimes when people walk in the door, they adjust schedules according to the needs of that day. Jill? I would add to that in another way and say I'd also like to see you look at some different work schedules and see whether or not 312s and some of those other options would work for us.
1:45:21 And I think that's kind of what some of the other people have been saying is, you know, look at some more creative ways of meeting our peaks and valleys. Also, I'd like to let you know that at the last school district liaison committee meeting, there was some discussion about the DARE program. Regardless of whether or not we're funding a full-time school resource officer, which is a question I have as well as John, is whether or not we should still be completing the DARE program. Ms. Jordan.
1:45:51 Chief, I had one more thing that would be helpful, and that is that considering our limited funding, if you could look into some possible grant funding opportunities that we may have missed that might help us pay for positions. I had one other thing. Just to add on to what Mayor Harvey was saying, you know, with our peaks and valleys and trying to adjust
1:46:22 Just our number of officers. There's been a lot of discussion of working more with the county and perhaps Sheriff Scholl, maybe we can have discussions with him on, you know, instead of staffing for full-time tourism and this and that, if we did, in fact, have lower staff number of officers, could we bring in the sheriff during those heavier peaks when Mammoth is really getting hit where perhaps the rest of the county is not?
1:46:53 Something more to consider, so we do have the public safety in place, but at the same time, we're not burdening our budget. One final thing. I feel like we're beating up on you, Chief, but we're not. We're communicating. That's the way I have to interpret it. Okay. And you've probably already been exposed to it. If you haven't, you will be, and it's a very common and obvious theme, and that is that we
1:47:24 And I'm generalizing. Generally, we have seven months of the 12 months of the year that we're busy. And then we have five months, which is almost half of the work year, one month short of it, where we're not so busy and there's not much going on in the town. So it's difficult for you and for the department to staff with that kind of fluctuations within the department. But as a result,
1:47:51 I think it's what Matthew said earlier, is that what the public sees is they see a car, you know, parked on 203 at the fire station and they see another one up at Whiskey Creek or Novato's sitting there in, or two of them together in day after day after day in the slow time and it just, it doesn't give a good presentation of effective use of manpower.
1:48:18 So you're saying you wanted to go undercover, John? No, because then John will get more tickets. I'm kidding. I'm kidding. Okay. Well, thank you. Yes, Chief. Many of those issues I'm aware of, I could respond to some of them now, but I think the best thing to do is to wait in at the proper time. I can respond back with some specific information on, I believe, all of them. Just a couple of comments. I bring experience from...
1:48:47 Three departments now, and I've worked different schedules, I'm familiar with different schedules, the advantages and disadvantages of them, you know, and that, along with the structure and the organization of the department, I'm not prepared to say what's the best way to go. I can tell you, after this brief time I've been here, I don't think under any circumstances that we're an overstaffed police department. In fact, I'm, you know, I've got concerns about at peak times.
1:49:14 Thank you, Chief. All right. We will move on to
1:49:45 The continued review of budget policy decisions. So really I have a question as to whether the council wants to at this point in time go back and review some of the budget policy decisions that we reviewed but didn't make any decisions on or whether you'd prefer to go ahead and go to the closed session.
1:50:06 And then come back at next week's budget hearing and try and address more comprehensively those which are not left. In this particular slide in the green and up there in the yellow, depending on what you're looking at, we highlighted items which we think that you have either voted on or given clear direction on, which is about a fourth of them. And the other three quarters,
1:50:34 We will still need at some point in time to get direction on. That handout is different than what you gave us for the closed session? It is, yeah. The one for closed session was included proposals that... I'm sorry, it's impossible for me to read that from here. It doesn't do... I can't tell you what's up there other than those green and purple. That's a good start. Can you read it? No. No. So I would not want to... And I think that there's some...
1:51:01 Some of the closed session discussion that has to happen before we, that would inform those decisions. But, yeah, I think we need to. What is it, Councilor? Well, at the risk of delaying the process, I'm not prepared to do that comprehensive look without first having taken what I have with all these sessions and sitting down with it and having
1:51:28 Working my way through it. I think that would be a lot more efficient for me than it would be for us to try to fumble and stumble through. I also think Joe makes a very good point with respect to the matters that we're going to be discussing in closed session as to how they might impact the budget. And so it may make a later meeting a little more difficult or longer, but it just makes sense to me to take now what we have.
1:51:55 And figure out individually what we, what our positions are with respect to all of these. Okay. So I think we have a consensus to move into closed session at this time? Mm-hmm. Very good. We move into closed session and afterwards report out any decisions that were made. Figure out the new state graphic or... Yeah, we need a whole lot of... Oh, yeah.
1:52:33 I'm sure that'll get straightened out.