TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015

Planning & Economic Development Commission Special meeting

· recording 2 hr 4 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

266 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:02 Good afternoon. I now call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. It's a special meeting for July 30th, 2015. Roll call, please. Commissioner Grayack? Here. Commissioner Tenney? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand in joining the pledge of allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God.

0:34 Indivisible, and with liberty and justice for all. At this time, we'll take public comments. Public comments is for anybody in the public who would like to make a comment that does not relate to today's agenda items. Do anybody have public comments? Okay, then I close the public comment period. So today we have a business matter and a consent agenda.

1:09 Commissioner Vanderhurst is going to have to recuse himself from the business matter due to the location of his personal resident to this applicant's property. So I would ask, if you wouldn't mind, we're going to switch the agenda just really quick and move to our consent agenda. And I'm going to recuse myself from the consent agenda because I was not present at this meeting. I would like to make a motion that we approve the minutes from the July 8th

1:39 2015 meeting? I'll second. Aye. Aye. Commissioner Vanderhurst, it was nice seeing you. Oh, no Commissioner Report? Thanks for doing it. Does he have a Commissioner Report? I don't. Oh, okay. Other than you've been traveling around the world, right? Other than a bad piece of jail. Okay. We'll accept that. Just for further clarification, Commissioner Harvey resigned.

2:14 last month due to a conflict of interest with his work and so we currently have had a filing period for applicants for commissioners and then the town council will report appoint new commissioners in August and this will also just as you know be Commissioner Tenney's last public meeting so with that then let's move to the business matters of our agenda and on our

2:40 Agenda is the workshop on Old Mammoth Place Amendment, concept review 15-001, and our staff contact person is Jen. Thank you, Chair Brown and Commissioners. I'm going to try doing the presentation from here with this wireless keyboard, so hopefully we don't have any technical difficulties. Fancy. Okay. So the purpose of a concept review application and this workshop that we're having today

3:07 is to allow an applicant to obtain feedback from the commission, from staff, and from the public at a very early stage in the development of a project proposal. This allows an applicant to prepare conceptual or preliminary plans rather than going through the development of detailed and comprehensive plans which would be required for a formal application.

3:30 The benefits of this process are that any feedback or revisions requested are much easier to be incorporated into a project and that likely major issues are identified early on which can then be addressed before a formal application submittal which allows the process, the formal application process to be much more streamlined.

3:54 The project site is the Sierra Nevada Resort property. That is about a six-acre site that includes the Sierra Nevada Lodge, rafters, jimmies, Red Lantern. It also includes the Frosty's mini golf course and the surface parking on that site. The project site is surrounded by residential condominiums, by apartments, some vacant parcels, and some commercial properties as well.

4:25 The Clearwater Specific Plan is the regulating document for the site. That means it functions as the zoning for the property. It envisions a pedestrian-oriented mixed-use corridor along Old Mammoth Road with uses including condo hotel, conference, workforce housing, public plazas, and underground parking.

4:47 The Clearwater Specific Plan went through an extensive and lengthy public process for adoption that included the development and council acceptance of the North Old Mammoth Road District Study, which was informative in establishing the development standards for the specific plan.

5:06 This specific plan includes three height zones with height stepped from lower heights of 35 feet at the perimeter to 45 feet as you move inward and then up to 55 feet in the center. The base density allowed by this specific plan is 40 rooms per acre and with community benefits being provided a density of 80 rooms per acre can be achieved.

5:33 The Old Mammoth Place project was approved under the Clearwater Specific Plan in 2010. It's the current entitlement for the site, so if the applicant or owner wished to develop that project, they could move forward with construction permits today. That project includes 80 rooms per acre, with community benefits being provided that include conference, the underground parking, restaurant and retail space, and the project also includes a pool.

6:02 Ice rink, a spa and wellness center, and also a vehicular mid-block connector that connects Old Mammoth Road to Laurel Mountain Road at the northern end of the site. This is a massing view of that approved project. I don't know how easy you can see my mouse, but...

6:24 Here is one of the restaurants along Sierra Nevada Road, another restaurant towards the interior of the site. Here along Old Mammoth Road, there would be ground floor retail beneath the condo hotel units above, and then the height would step from as low as one story along the front to three stories, four stories, and up to five stories or 55 feet in the center of the site.

6:54 So the concept review proposal that we have before us today in this workshop is a conceptual reconfiguration of the approved Old Mammoth Place project. And that would maintain the density still at 80 rooms per acre, but incorporate some two and three bedroom units.

7:15 That would be accommodated through a proposed increase in building height, some expansion of building footprints, and the elimination of onsite workforce units.

7:28 In terms of sections that have been provided by the applicant team to help visualize the additional height being proposed, we really see an additional floor added on to a majority of the buildings on the site. So here you're looking at Old Mammoth Place, the mid-block connector going up from four levels to five levels. In the center of the site, this main portion of the hotel building going from five

7:58 floors to six floors or 65 feet and some additional mass added to the southern end of that wing adjacent to the Market Commons. These other sections give just a little different perspective on the site. Here it shows a, let's see, that would be a section going east-west and, excuse me, I expect that some.

8:25 So along Laurel Mountain Road you're seeing a height going from 35 feet to 45 feet or four floors and again here you're seeing the 65 foot height in the center of the site and then a section just a little bit farther north again east-west basically an additional floor added to the buildings there.

8:50 Just to help visualize this in plan view, considering the three height zones in the specific plan, here we've tried to highlight the portions of the buildings that exceed the 35 foot height limit within the specific plan, and so in that case you really see the buildings along Laurel Mountain Road which are proposed to increase from 35 feet to 45 feet.

9:15 On the fifth floor here, what's been highlighted is the areas that exceed the 45-foot height limit as you move inward on the site. And so that generally encompasses a portion of the building along Old Mammoth Place. That's the mid-block connector. And then lastly, here highlighted are the portions of the building that exceed the 55-foot height limit zone going up to 65 feet.

9:46 And there's a very, very small portion along the southern end of this wing that is actually in the 35-foot height limit zone that would be, that is proposed to go up to 65 feet. And in looking at the expansion of building footprints, considering the whole site, they're relatively small. Those are shown in this red hatched plan for the ground floor. You see a little bit of

10:15 Building footprint added along the southern end here along Old Mammoth Road next to the Grove area and a unit space essentially added along at the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Old Mammoth Place. What you still see here is that the programming and the community benefits that were approved with the Old Mammoth Place project still being provided really in their form and configuration and size that were originally approved.

10:46 In reviewing the concept review, we look for consistency with the applicable zoning, which in this case is the Clearwater Specific Plan. Excuse me. And we found two places in that specific plan where the concept review would not comply. Those two are building height and workforce housing. We just kind of went through.

11:10 The areas where the buildings would exceed the height zones contained in the specific plan, and so those exceedances range from about 10 feet to up to 30 feet in a very small portion. And then workforce housing, the specific plan includes goals and objectives to include on-site workforce housing, so through the elimination of on-site housing it would be inconsistent with those goals and objectives.

11:35 And when we review amendment to a specific plan, we also require findings that it conform to the general plan and that the required environmental review or CEQA is completed before an amendment is adopted. Another finding is that the amendment not be detrimental to the public interest, health, safety, convenience or welfare of the town.

11:59 And the process for an amendment would be a public hearing at commission, making a recommendation to council, and then ultimately the decision would be made by council.

12:10 In looking at general plan consistency, at the level of plans we have for concept review, we haven't been able to make a determination of consistency in particular related to some of these community design policies, specifically some of those that relate to district character

12:33 Related to sunny streets, plazas and sidewalks, preserving public views, and that the building height, massing and scale would complement neighboring land uses. So as we proceed with review, those would be items we would look for in review before making a decision on the amendment. Before we get into the questions for discussion, I just wanted to run through next steps quickly.

13:00 For a process like this, after this workshop is concluded, the applicant will take the feedback received and incorporate that into a formal application to be submitted to the town. And then the process after that would be to hold a commission workshop. As Chair Brown mentioned, we will be having two new commissioners being seated. And so we would have, for this scale of project, a workshop to familiarize the commission with.

13:26 the information, go through that required environmental review analysis and then conduct the commission and council hearings. After that entitlement process then we could get the process for initiating construction underway and that includes going through the final map process and then developing the construction plans to obtain a grading, building permit and starting construction.

13:53 In the staff report, we've identified three questions to help facilitate discussion. The first question, question A, is based on the conceptual plans, do the proposed building height requests appear reasonable? And to help with this question, the requests are that there is a 10-foot height increase along Laurel Mountain Road, so going from 35 feet to 45 feet, a 10 to 20-foot height increase along Old Mammoth Place,

14:20 That's the mid-block connector going from mainly 45 feet to 50 feet, a very small portion going from 30 to 55. And just for reference in terms of discussion, the surrounding commercial zones include the Old Mammoth or are the Old Mammoth road zone and the downtown zone. And those zones allow

14:40 20% of a building face along the street to be 45 feet tall but has exceptions that do allow up to 60% of a building face along a street to be up to 45 feet tall and then step backs, 10 foot step backs to the floor above that maximum building face height. The other height increase request is the 10 to, again, 30...

15:05 Foot increase in a very small spot for the height at the center of the site to increase the height up to 65 feet. And again, for reference, the surrounding zones allow a maximum height of 55 feet in the downtown zone, 45 feet in the Old Mammoth Road zone, and 35 feet in the residential multifamily two zone, which is the condominium property to the south of the project site. Excuse me.

15:34 So I think it would be really helpful at this time if you went back to your PowerPoint graphs, which actually demonstrated those heights so everybody knows exactly what buildings we're talking about. Okay. The sections or the plan view? The sections, I think. I just want to make sure everybody in the audience understands. Not so much that one. I think it's the next one. That's probably one more. I just, these are the sections? Right. Well, probably it's really, I think it was the one to demonstrate your sequel, right? The plan view? Okay.

16:06 So here the request above 35 feet to go to 45 feet would be these two buildings along Laurel Mountain Road and on the corner of Sierra Nevada Road. This is the small portion that we talk about that is actually in the 35 foot zone but is proposed to go up to 65 feet. And here

16:34 Along Old Mammoth Place, this mid-block connector, Mammoth Mall is here to the north. This building is proposed to increase from 45 feet to up to 55 feet with a very relatively small portion here that is actually in the 35 foot zone, so 35 feet to 55 feet. And then here at the center of the site, this portion, this

17:04 This building here is within the 55-foot zone, and so the proposal is to increase that entire building up to 65 feet. And then I'll just run through these other...

17:26 two questions and I'll wrap up. So the second question or question B is that based upon the conceptual plans do the proposed building footprint increases appear reasonable? And in this case there are some

17:41 So this is really a design question, I think, for the Commission to discuss.

18:09 And then the last question, question C, is does it appear reasonable to eliminate the eight on-site workforce housing units? And although the specific plan includes goals and objectives for on-site housing and the specific plan doesn't count,

18:26 On-site workforce housing towards density. Our recently adopted housing ordinance does not mandate on-site housing, and therefore the applicant could request to amend the specific plan to allow for the current housing ordinance to apply, which would allow the developer to pay fees rather than incorporate housing on-site. And that concludes...

18:49 My presentation, the applicant does have, I think, a brief statement to make, but I'd be happy to take questions now or later, at the Commission's pleasure. Do you have any questions, actually? Yeah, it's just information questions. Jen, there was a previous applicant before this applicant who owned the property and then he sold it to this applicant. Do you know what year that was? When did the whole Clearwater Specific Plan process start? It started in 2005.

19:15 2005, okay. And not to put you on the spot, but can you remember, maybe Sandra can, when did the Westin process start? I'm thinking in 2003 maybe? Somewhere there. And does anybody, can anybody remember how old the Westin is now? Ten years. Okay. Okay, so 2005 is when this process started. Good, thank you. Thank you. Did you have any questions at this time? Not right now. Okay.

19:49 I think it would be helpful if you would review for all of us what source documents we'll be using ultimately to make our decisions. So for reviewing an amendment to the Clearwater Specific Plan, we would look at the general plan, which establishes vision, goals, and policies for the entire town, including some district-specific guidance. The Clearwater Specific Plan, which is the regulatory or zoning document for the site.

20:19 The North Old Mammoth Road Special Study is really an informational reference document for the site, but I think it's an important document that can be referred to when evaluating a change that's being proposed and the town's design guidelines we would also look at. Can you just give us a quick recap about the actual approval process for the specific plan?

20:47 What was Commission's recommendations and then what was ultimately Council's recommendations regarding height? So the specific plan when it came before Commission for a recommendation, it included a maximum height zone of 65 feet. That was recommended to Council for approval. When Council...

21:07 adopted the specific plan in 2009. They adopted the plan as proposed with the exception of the maximum building height being reduced from 65 feet to 55 feet. And so that is the current maximum height allowed in the specific plan. Okay. Thank you. One more question, Jen. I was surprised to read in the staff report that even though the original EIR was for a 65 foot high building, you know, highest point,

21:34 and a 97-foot-high architectural feature, an additional EIR or addendum or subsequent EIR would be required to go to 65 feet. I don't understand that. It's actually not the issue of going to 65 feet, really. It's that the EIR analyzed height limits consistent with the height zones of the specific plan. So by increasing

21:59 The 35-foot height limit to 45 feet, that actually wasn't analyzed in the EIR. It was a maximum height of 35 feet. I see. So it's actually not the 65-foot height that would really need to be addressed through a subsequent EIR or subsequent type of environmental document. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chair Brown. Any questions? No. Would the applicant like to make a statement? Good afternoon. Sorry.

22:39 Madam Chair and Board, I just want to thank you for arranging the time today to review the Old Mammoth Place project and potential modifications to existing approved development. I also want to stop, and you recognized before, but this is Elizabeth Tenney's last meeting, and I'm very honored that she's part of this process, and I thank you for your service to the community, because I know you and I have done projects in the past and appreciate all the work that you have done. But I don't think I mentioned, I think, is this Jen's last meeting, too? And just want to thank you for everything that has done, I think, 10 years? Yeah. Oh.

23:08 Goes fast. But thank you for your time as a community. Just very quickly, we are here today in recognition that the town has changed over the last 8 to 10 years. The expansion plans of the airport, the needs of the community, the increase of summer visitation, impacts of animation, and other things have brought us back to looking at the Old Mammoth Place project and the potential for modifying the project. We employed a consultant, PKF, to see what modifications we need to make to make the project a viable development.

23:36 The conceptual plans that we have given you today reflects this input and reflects how we will plan to be consistent with the zoning changes that have promoted pedestrian-oriented development, encourage high-quality building design, support economic growth and sustainability, increase activity and animation, create public gatherings places, reduce the role of cars, and with larger projects development just to provide public spaces to encourage pedestrian activity and small-scale events. We look forward to your feedback.

24:04 And so we can submit a formal request after we hear and answer any questions that have been discussed today. Thank you. Commissioner Chaney, do you have any questions of the applicant now? Would you like to do public comments first? We'll have a lot of questions later, but that's fine. Questions right now? No, we'll wait for you. All right. So at this point, I'm going to open up the floor to public comments. So anybody that would like to comment on this proposed amendment is welcome to come forward to the podium.

24:41 If you have to go first, you might forgive what I have to say. I'm Tom Moody, and I'm representing Sierra Park Villas, and frankly, my own concern as well. As a part-time resident in the community, I wanted to make sure that this project fits with the character of our community. I was a planning commissioner in Orange County for 15 years, and I kind of volunteered to get involved in this, and I had no idea it was going to be as involved as it was.

25:08 I hope you all have the handout that I put together and concise response to what's being applied for here. I've been involved in the history of this project and there's a number of important points that I need to point out. First of all, the architectural design has changed considerably thanks to the architects that were brought in. I think you were brought in.

25:39 I remember meeting with these gentlemen. Originally, the project was called Urban Mountain. And believe me, it was more urban than it was Mount Whiskey. It was cement and glass. And I made a copy of the town's design guidelines. And I took them to the architect, the original architect.

26:04 And Rick Rosenberg. And I tried to show them that this, what you're doing here does not fit. And to their credit, they changed it. And a lot of it is stone and wood, which belongs here. And I want to emphasize, we're not opposed to the uses here at all. Condos and retail belong here. We just want to make sure that it fits with the character of the community and it's consistent with the documents, the general plan and the clear water specific plan.

26:33 Our primary concern along the way, all this time in 59 hearings, was the height that was proposed. And the ultimate height was 65 feet as proposed. And that's what we're dealing with again now. The specific plan requires that massing is consistent with the neighbors. We're the neighbors on cross Sierra Nevada Road.

27:06 We're at 35 feet. 65 feet does not mix with that. The general plan, you have the sheets in front of you right now, C2, requires the project to complement, not dominate the man-made environment. C2-1 requires that the project act as stewards of preserving public views of surrounding mountains, knolls, and ridgelines. C2-V...

27:34 Calls for the applicant to preserve views to the surrounding mountains. Right now, the project as it is, as it is approved, already impacts the views of our residents of the Knolls, and it impacts the views of people who are on Old Mammoth Road trying to look at the mountain, okay? Fortunately, the town council, after many hearings before the Planning Commission and the town council, and height being the main issue, fortunately the council,

28:04 As far as I was concerned, compromised at 55 feet. But here we are again. We're going through the same issues. And I don't totally understand it. The applicant obviously has a right to bring his project in for an enhancement. But we've been through these issues before. And so I don't think it is reasonable, no. I think ultimately one of the things the commission has to look at is

28:33 Of what benefit are these revisions in height to the project, particularly weighed against the impact on our town, on our town as it's called the village and the trees? Are we going to still end up with a village and the trees? Or is this going to be something that's more urban? In terms of the revision to illuminate workforce housing, I have no problem with that.

29:01 I think that it would be very legitimate for the applicant to use those sites, those other units to provide some expanded living area perhaps. It's not in the housing ordinance any longer so I don't think that's unreasonable at all. I hope the commission can be very candid with the applicant because as you can see the process is going to be very involved. It's going to involve a lot of permits.

29:33 Some amendments to the district zoning, tract map, a permit, use permit, and it's going to be very costly. So, and we've been through these issues before. So, if the commission has any doubts about this, I hope they're candid with the applicant so they don't waste their time and money and our time as well. Thank you.

29:59 Before you sit down, sir, so I just want to make sure, because of a comment that you made in your letter about what part of the amendment they were proposing a 65-foot height adjustment, so you understand now from the staff's presentation about what building it is that was proposed at 65-foot height, so it's not the whole entire perimeter. Well, I understand where it is, yes. Okay. Yes. I just want to make sure we didn't have any. Right. I understand it's not the whole project. Okay. There's certain segments of it.

30:29 But also the 45 feet increase as well. Okay. The area that we're going to increase is the 45. All right. Thank you very much. Are there any other public comments? Board Tom Cage. I really have a question more than a comment on the FAR work that we did for Old Mammoth and Main Street. Is this going to require us to go back and re-look at those height limits? Because I believe those height limits were 55 feet max, 35 feet at the street line.

31:03 So if this increases in its, what do you call it, separate zoning, so to speak, would then we, to be fair to other people on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street, would we need to go back and modify the work? I don't think we would go back and look at it because this is a specific plan, so they would be modifying their specific plan, their zoning. We went through considerable work to update the commercial zoning districts.

31:32 So I don't think we, unless there was a request from Commission and Council to go back and look at it based on what ultimately gets approved for this project, I don't think staff would be looking to go back and review that. So then the other properties on Old Mammoth Road or on Main Street would be limited to 55 feet without a specific plan like this? Yes. Or an appeal or an amendment? Or a variance. Or a variance. So let me just clarify. So the height?

32:00 Limit for Old Mammoth Road, according to the commercial code, is 45 feet. And on Old Mammoth Road, it's 55 feet. Main Street. I'm sorry, Main Street. Okay. And the floor area ratio is, as we currently have it proposed, is 2.0. Right. And this project, as it's being proposed, the amended project, is under 2.0.

32:26 So it's not an FAR variance, and I get that. I'm just trying to think ahead on Main Street and the rest of Old Mammoth if you have an adjoining property, a kitty corner across the street to it, but you're going to limit them to 45 feet, and this is going to be at 65 feet. I'm just trying to, now would be the time to change the work that is going through the EIS for Old Mammoth and Main Street.

32:54 If you want to avoid these other requests from other developers. Right. That's a great point. Thank you very much. Any other public comments? Hi, Pat Eckert, long-time resident. I went through. Excuse me, do you mind putting the mic down? Just because it's being televised and then they won't be able to hear you. Okay. Thank you very much. Pat Eckert, long-time resident, and I've gone through this before on another situation exactly like this. I live at Mount Shadows.

33:31 I've owned 42 years. I've lived here 30 years. And I live on Sierra Nevada Road. And I walk. I don't have a car. I walk everywhere. And I also, on Laurel Mountain Road, on the ice, shattered my wrist. Only surgery I've really ever had to have. And I'm concerned about additional ice due to a structure.

34:00 As described. I don't know if it will increase the ice or it will just be another problem. I'm also concerned about I don't know where the traffic comes out, whether it comes out on Sierra Nevada Road as it once did in the plan. Schoolchildren walk down Sierra Nevada Road to the high school. And if you could tell me later or now.

34:26 Where the traffic, the vehicles enter, what road they enter on. That would help one of my concerns. The other one is the most important one is the change to the community. We are a residential community. And I know I walk it all the time. And a lot of people walk it. It's not a commercial district. And so it's going to be taking something away from us.

34:58 And so that is one of my major concerns. I think I appreciate what the gentleman said. I think he had a lot of good major points, and I agree with him. Thank you. So I just think it's really important in a workshop that we address issues as they come up, just so we know what we're talking about. And so that you understand.

35:27 The applicant already has a specific plan that gives them the right to do certain things. And in that specific plan there was a CEQA that addresses shadows. Okay. Okay, so if the shadows impact the road, and maybe Jen can remember this verbatim, but basically then there's mitigation impacts that the applicant has to do. So, I mean, that is really important. We never want to have.

35:53 Our sidewalks iced over, especially when people are walking them and school children are walking them. So I do know that part is addressed in CEQA. And then can you address the traffic, just as Ms. Eck, goes? Sure. It's a little difficult to see, but on the screen in front of you, there's the site plan. And access is...

36:17 Coming in off of Old Mammoth Road onto Old Mammoth Place, that's this mid-block connector, so Mammoth Mall is here to the north, and then, thank you, John, and then, so folks accessing the site would come in off that mid-block connector, and then, is it okay to see on that screen? Can you see that? I can see it. Okay, this is my problem, not yours.

36:47 There is no, there is only a loading access for the restaurant if you look at the screen where my mouse is. There's only loading there. Vehicles will only enter the site here along Old Mammoth Place and then they can exit here onto Laurel Mountain Road. Okay. Thank you. Chair Brown, could I add something about the sidewalks?

37:13 Jen, it's my recollection that the applicant with the approved project was going to drill a geothermal well and very seriously explore as part of the LEED certification geothermal heat, and if that's the case, then it would be geothermal heated sidewalks. I mean, we're not going to be throwing salt on them, so as I recall, the original application, that's what they were going to do for just the problem that Pat Eckert is talking about.

37:42 And also that would be on Old Mammoth Place, the cross connector, because that's a north exposure, but it has a three-story building right next to it, so it will be shaded in the winter, and so ice melt there would be critical. Okay, could I just add one additional thing, and that was, I marked on my town map here, right where the project is, and on almost every side of it, every single side of it, timberline, wildflower, Sierra Park villas, mountain shadows.

38:14 Sierra Manor is across the street. It's residential. This is, you know, for, there's nothing wrong with the idea of the project. It's just that it looks like a city. We're a town. And that village and the trees, it'll be gone for us. Thank you. Thank you very much. Are there any other comments? Hi, Tim Flynn.

38:59 Resident, I'm really excited to see it go. I think it's something that this town really needs. I do believe that it's very well planned. The finishes look incredible. You know, the surrounding properties, you know, we're looking at, you know, 40 to 50 year old condominium projects that are, you know.

39:28 They're old, they're dilapidated, they're, you know, this, if anything, I think would increase the property values around those neighboring communities and it would actually make sense for those property owners and those

39:48 Those homeowners associations to, it would just pencil out for them to increase their homeowners association fees, maybe look at updating their exteriors to sort of keep up with the Joneses. I mean, this town is just in dire need of updating. And I think that this project is something that will definitely give the town the needed kick in the pants. So, thank you. Thank you. Additional comments?

40:24 Did the applicant have any formal response they'd like to make? Hi, Chair and Commissioners. My name is John Ashworth. I'm our principal with Bull Stockwell Allen Architects. I'd also just like to thank, I wanted to say on behalf of somebody that's been before you guys in several instances, both with Commissioner Tenney's leaving and also with Jen leaving, I just want to say as a professional in the industry, you guys are losing real professionals that have had an incredible interest.

40:59 in your town and have served you admirably. I just want to say from my perspective you're posing a couple of superstars so I just wanted to make that statement. A couple of quick comments because I think that one of the things that we took very seriously in coming back is we didn't take this at all lightly and really tried to kind of understand where the town was trying to go in terms of its

41:25 Additional review of its regulations and its work and look at how we could make this project both viable but also still keep its character and its intent in terms of providing the community those open spaces, providing the pedestrian scale and actually providing a project that can actually happen and provide those benefits to the town. And one of the things we really looked very carefully to in the very beginning and I think through a lot of great work between the applicant

41:54 The commissioners, staff, was to really create a project that did have a series of key public spaces, a real variety, and really did take very seriously the concerns of step backs and neighbors and those kinds of things into account. And so one of the things we've looked at very, very hard is how we felt we could come back and ask for some additional accommodation.

42:24 While still maintaining the very heart and soul of what we were all trying to achieve and do that in a way that hopefully we can make these things happen. So for example, you know, and I hear very clearly some of the concerns along Sierra Nevada Road. As Jen has pointed out, we don't have any traffic or anything coming out on that particular location, but we were also very sensitive in the original plan and we've tried to keep that in terms of this current request of not adding

42:51 You know, maintaining that low scale element and pushing the massing and development towards the center of the project. So we've tried to basically illustrate, and I think the sections that Jen showed do a good job of illustrating, for example, that it's really the Old Mammoth Road street front that really determines the overall viewshed, if you will, of the project. And you can see in these diagrams where we're illustrating the red.

43:20 Standing on the street, across the street on Old Mammoth Road, you won't be able to see that additional requested 10 feet in height. And so we've really been trying to illustrate how we have tried to be very sensitive to show that this additional area we're proposing is generally outside of the view shed.

43:42 If you go to Laurel Mountain, for example, and you'll see we're not adding massing on Old Mammoth Road because we know that's an important and critical thoroughfare for the town. And if you look at Sierra Nevada, you'll see that the viewshed is really still generated by the lower scale structures. And so that, again, that additional mass, the two-story restaurant, for example, will be what is defining the viewshed as opposed to the proposed taller portions of it.

44:11 So I just wanted to make that as a general kind of statement and clarification that we've really tried to consider very carefully where we might be able to put this additional massing in a way that we think has very minimal impact and will allow us to move forward with a lot of the, I think, the public benefits and the pedestrian components that I think we all found compelling with respect to this project. Commissioner Cheney, are your commissions, your questions, both for staff and the applicant?

44:47 Well, I have some comments and some questions. Okay, we'll do comments for playlists. Later, okay. Because I think it might just be easier if you wouldn't mind just standing at that podium and then that way when we ask questions that they'll all, we won't be jumping up and down, we can just address them back and forth if you wouldn't mind, so. Yeah. All of us? Yeah, however you want to answer the questions. Now, Chair Brown, are you looking for general questions or questions about? Any questions you have, then we should use.

45:15 Okay, okay, good. Okay, I'll start with the lesser of the two issues I have. The face of the back of the house, which is the restaurant, the back of the house of it is on Sierra Nevada Road, and the loading dock is there. And I've never seen a loading dock with a pull-down door that doesn't look like a, you know, well-used dumpster after a season or two.

45:39 I didn't notice that. I'm the only person up here who was on the commission when this project first came forward. So when it did and it was approved, I don't think I paid enough attention to that. What are you going to do to be a better neighbor, considering that's a street side that the neighbors at Sierra Manor will be looking at, yeah, Sierra Manor will be looking at, and the people on the street, and also driving down Old Mammoth Road, you're going to see that.

46:07 So what are you going to do with that face? That face troubles me. Commissioner Tenney, I think that's a good question, and that's something that we really tried to address in the original application. A number of things that we really tried to do in order to be a good neighbor on Sierra Nevada, as we talked about, was to keep the lower scale, either to have no building along Sierra Nevada or keep the lower scale elements. As you point out, we do have a restaurant on that location, and it became

46:36 You know, a challenge to be able to create kind of a low-scale restaurant and to address the servicing, which is not realistic to be able to bring down through the garage. So at that time we... Oh, of course, yeah.

46:48 So at that time we developed what we felt were a series of facade type moves in order to try to really minimize and mitigate that because you're right, loading docks are not usually very pleasant places. So a couple things that we did. One is we, a lot of times the truck will just pull up and block the roadway. We designed this so the truck would be able to move in so that there wouldn't be a blockage along Sierra Nevada. So the street itself would not be blocked.

47:14 We also created a very strong landscape plan to really try to buffer that so that you wouldn't be able to, as you're driving down Old Mammoth, you wouldn't be able to look in and see other than, you know, the restaurant structure itself, which we tried to make very handsome, the landscape, and then we created a very nice pergola structure to also sit up above over that loading dock area so that a truck could pull underneath that.

47:37 And kind of shield that in shade with the landscaping in order to mitigate that look. Okay. Thank you. It is hard, I know, for the public and for us, since we're at the conceptual review stage, we're just looking at floor plans. And except for the old information, we don't have elevation. So maybe you could demonstrate on the approved elevation there. Yes. This particular piece would be identical to what was originally reviewed and approved. Again, we have...

48:10 Essentially a two-story restaurant along Sierra Nevada. And that would be the only built structure directly along Sierra Nevada. There would be basically a public space to the left here as we move towards Laurel Mountain. And again, the grove, which is the open corner on Old Mammoth Place. So here is that structure which has a series of kind of wood timber elements. Here's the landscaping I reference.

48:40 So that it would shield the view as you're looking from old Mammoth. And then this is the pergola structure that went up and around so that it would help provide a little bit of articulation to the location where the trucks would be. And is that large brown, I'll say garage door, is that below grade or is that at grade? This is at grade. At grade. Okay. I'm sorry. Would you just be so kind as to turn around so everybody can see? Yeah, let them see too. Maybe can you just show a quick bit? So again, here we are at Laurel Mountain.

49:08 Thank you.

49:41 And then my larger or more important question for me personally is I know there's been a market study done on this project which was approved five and a half years ago and the market has changed and what was originally going to be all individual conventional hotel rooms is now going to be a mix of units. Is that correct, Brent? Yes. Yeah, it's going to be a mix of units.

50:04 That's one reason that you're asking for additional height so that you can get the number of units because that's what the market is demanding now. I understand that as a business decision. Well, it's not so much the number of units, it's the size of the units because when the project was first designed, the units were at 406 square feet. Right. When PKF reviewed that, they say, in this case, you need market.

50:22 The 406 square unit is not really sellable. You have to have more space and reflecting of that in the market. And they studied like 9,000 other hotel projects and said this is really what is needed. And we followed their advice in saying we need to figure out how to have a larger size unit is really what's driving that. That's an informed business decision. Okay. So I'll make comments later, but what troubles me is not only asking for an increase in height, but an increase in building footprint.

50:52 What's happening with the additional, with the larger units and trying to find a place to put them, in fact, let me back up for a second. I don't know how many people in the public know this, but we have an advisory design panel, ADP, which was organized by Mike Vance back when InterWest came to town, and we realized we really needed professional assistance in looking at these.

51:15 projects and proposals and designs and it wasn't that staff wasn't capable of doing it, but this was the big leagues and we really wanted some backup. And so this panel was formed and what happens with this panel, it's designers and architects, is the architects come to town and Mr. Ashworth from Bullstockwell and Allen has been one of the most effective users of ADP. You've really

51:40 Use them very well. But they come to town with all these great ideas, you know, innovative, state-of-the-art, and they think they have a concept of Mammoth. They've done their research, and I totally understand that. But then we have a principal at Design Workshop at South Lake Tahoe. We have an architect based in Truckee who does a lot of Tahoe work. We have a local designer, and we have a local architect, and then a layperson, and these are the people who know the territory. And so they can look at these proposals and say,

52:10 Well, yeah, that's great, but did you consider this? And it ends up being a very collaborative process, and we end up with actually a much better result because of that collaboration. And what I'm concerned about is I'm talking about where do you put these larger units, is I saw that there are going to be units over the entrance at the northeastern corner, which is on Old Mammoth Road, and what the inspiration for that corner was, was this. This timber and glass.

52:40 Lighted entrance, which would really make a statement, and there are two roof lines. It goes, I wish you could see this, you can't see this. I wish that we had this up on the screen, I was hoping it would be included, but it sort of steps back, so you've got one slanted roof, and then you have like a clear story window, then you have another slanted roof.

53:02 And it really makes a statement for the entrance. It shows you this is where Old Mammoth Place is, the physical place where you turn in to go to the hotel. This is placemaking because this is Old Mammoth Place and instead of announcing that, this is very distinctive. Well, according to what I've been able to discern from the floor plans, you're talking about putting units on top of this. And that's where I really have trouble with. Here's some beautiful architecture.

53:29 And something similar to this is what you were planning, and that was based on discussions with ADP, and you revised some of your designs, and it was great. But if you're going to put units on top of that, I'm very troubled by that. Can you tell me how you propose to do that and still maintain the character of an entrance like this, which is the kind of thing we need on Old Mammoth Road?

53:54 I think, and this section begins to kind of show what we were thinking in terms of that particular area. As you mentioned, there were essentially two steps, two roof elements. Yes. And so our thought would be that would we be able to, you know, again, try to be sensitive. And I think we also were looking to try to find those right spots. And I think to have a good back and forth and a dialogue is very helpful in that respect.

54:20 What we were thinking might be possible would be, for example, as what's being shown in this section here, where that second roof component is, would we be able to add some additional residential component there and still maintain that feel of the first roof in terms of that corner and still maintain that corner as a low scale and an iconic component. Okay.

54:43 I'll believe it when I see it. This is an example, and there's no way you can see this from back there, but this is all I've got. This was their response to the comments from the advisory design panel, and what you'll see, what was originally proposed, is just a row of units, you know, nicely designed, but just a row of hotel units. And what they did after ADP said, no, you need a significant entrance, you really need to make a statement. Then they came back.

55:08 Where they eliminated some of those units, and that's where they came to this entrance here, which is stepped back, like this picture, and you're just going to have to bring binoculars when you come to Planning Commission, like this picture, where we have a real statement. So that's what I was troubled about. Well, the only thing I had to add, Liz, I was not part of the original process. Oh, I know. And that's why we're doing this conceptual review now, to see what do we...

55:38 Get these things out. So we know what's history, what's part of past, so we get some of the background, and that's one of the reasons why I wanted to have you hearing before you left the Planning Commission, so we could get your input in terms of things that were relevant and part of the project that we may not know about, or at least I don't know about. The work with ADP is so valuable. It really, we always end up with much better results, especially when you have an architect come before you who's, you know, willing to work with ADP. We've had some very resistant.

56:04 Architects and things didn't turn out so well, but when we work together, it's really, it's impressive what the outcome can be. Those are my, oh, I do have one more question. What happened to the community center and the supervised daycare? It's in the key, but I didn't see where it went. Couldn't find it. Most of the. Not sure what the community center is. Yeah, the community center was in the original plan located along Sierra Nevada on this.

56:33 Upper left component of the project, and that has been primarily converted to additional residential space. Okay, how about the supervised daycare? The supervised daycare, the intent was to basically take where we had originally shown kind of more of an ice rink.

56:48 And to convert that to much more of a year-round venue spot where we could have everything from bouldering to rock climbing and have a dedicated indoor-outdoor play area. So we still have kind of the lockers and the components around that square. And rather than it just, for example, being an ice rink, the thought is that it really becomes much more of a

57:11 multi-use space, for lack of a better word, that can have a variety of different activities throughout the different seasons. And it could be everything from, you know, an antique car show to a concert to bouldering and climbing and playing with kids and really dedicating that space to that daycare piece. If I recall correctly, the daycare was really for the guests.

57:33 I believe, just as it is now at Sierra Nevada Resort, you have a room with, you know, not a teacher, but, you know, a supervisor. And there's still those kinds of spaces that would be available within the hotel as well for guests if it were a rainy day or so on. But the thought was to really take this square and really activate it even further. Okay, well, it's number 22 on your keys. You might want to delete that then. Thank you. I think those are all my questions right now.

58:03 Commissioner Freak, do you have any questions? Well, just one thing I noticed while we were talking here, you had mentioned that the first floor along Old Mammoth Road was meant to be retail, ground floor retail, but it looks to me like it's listed here as residential hotel. Is that? No, on the ground floor along Old Mammoth Road, the entire ground floor is proposed to be retail.

58:32 So if you look at the previous sheet in your packet, the garage and ground floor, because of actual the grade change across the site, actually that ground floor of retail is one floor below what's identified as the first floor. Like in Europe? Well, it's a little confusing because that corner piece. Oh, okay. So our garage floor plan is also our ground floor. Correct. Old Mammoth Road street front. Correct.

59:02 I see. Thank you. Okay. No, not right now. So when we talk about height, we're talking about part of the height change would be for a fourth floor, part of it would be for a fifth floor, and part of it would be for a sixth floor on various aspects of your project. So can you give me some indication in your total change of square footage how that breaks down between the various fourth, fifth, and sixth?

59:44 Yes, we put a summary together and we've done some additional calculations in order to kind of make sure we're all clear on where that is. The original project roughly on the third floor, for example, had 56,000 square feet. The current proposal is 69,900, so a delta of about 13,800 square feet. The fourth floor,

1:00:13 It was approximately 37,000 square feet. The new request would be approximately 61,500, or about a 25,000 square foot difference. On the fifth floor, roughly at 26,000 square feet, the new request is 44,500, or a delta of about 18,000 square feet. And then previously we had zero square footage on the sixth level.

1:00:42 And the request would be for $34,800. Okay. So going, you know, back to the order of our source documents, you know, we have our general plan, we have our specific plan, and then, as you know, we spent a lot of time and effort recently adopting our commercial code. And when we adopted that commercial code for Old Mammoth Road and Main Street,

1:01:16 A key component of that was what we termed retail frontage, where we really wanted this very active retail district. And as it currently lays out in our commercial code, that active frontage road is immediately adjacent to you on Old Mammoth Road. And I really would like you to just comment if you feel that your design guidelines then would be compatible about what we have currently specified in our commercial code.

1:01:45 I think one of the exciting things for us from the very beginning was the real desire to make Old Mammoth a really active and vibrant pedestrian-friendly commercial road. And if I'm correct in reviewing the plans, I believe that the Old Mammoth place piece is kind of exempted from that, but our intent was

1:02:07 from the very beginning and has not changed would be to continue that commercial component all the way as you move down the road towards Sierra Nevada. So that has not changed and in fact we've worked to kind of enhance that by maintaining all of the commercial components.

1:02:25 Along Old Mammoth Road, keeping that a vibrant thoroughfare, actually adding a little bit more retail at the ground level there, and also then creating that internal market component that would be dedicated to small scale retail and local artisans and local shops and things, so that we really have a very active and pedestrian friendly component along that. So I think that's something that we felt very excited about in terms of the original proposal. It's something we really worked hard, along with the other major public spaces, we worked hard to...

1:02:54 to try to hang on to. Okay. And then do you have any comments about on the Laurel Mountain side of your project? Which is pretty interesting because, you know, on that Laurel Mountain road is probably the side of the project that someday would change from the existing use. And I was curious how you saw the back facade of the Laurel Mountain side.

1:03:23 Well, I think that's an incredibly good question because I think from our point of view, I think we have a win-win opportunity there. As we understand where the town has gone in terms of thinking about the kind of the old Mammoth area, as we understand it, in the future, Laurel Mountain Road would be able to develop at approximately a 45-foot height.

1:03:42 And I think that's limited by a percentage, but up to a 45-foot height. And that's essentially what we would be asking for as well as part of this amended proposal. So I think the win-win aspect of it is, as we kind of went through the original proposal, and if we're kind of all at 35 feet, I think we all were struggling to try to create some variety along Laurel Mountain. And if we were allowed to kind of

1:04:07 Bump up to 45 and step back to 35 and basically we have an opportunity I think to create

1:04:15 Thank you.

1:04:44 Thank you very much. All right. What we'll do at this point is that we have three discussion questions. The first one based on conceptual plans.

1:05:35 Do the proposed billing heights requests appear reasonable? And then it details what those requests are. Who would like to? We'll give you the honor, Commissioner Tenney. You can start commenting. I have to start with a question. I can't do a context. I'll make a few comments first. Is that okay?

1:05:59 If it's the last one, I'll do anything I want. That's right, precisely. How did you know? That's great. We can't fire you. Okay, a few. After the recession, our name was changed from the Planning Commission to the Planning and Economic Development Commission because Mammoth is really hurting and we really need some economic development. This is the first big project that's been before us since the recession. That's how long it's been. It came, it started in 2005, I think you said, Jen?

1:06:29 And we worked with it. It was very complicated. There was a lot of public input. In fact, I never throw anything out. This was all the public input from back in that I probably left out some. A lot of public input, a lot of concern. This particular project is second only to the village in terms of how important it is to Mammoth. It makes me think of San Diego.

1:06:57 I understand that after they built Horton Plaza at the other end of town, they built the convention center, and that triggered investment between those two anchors like you wouldn't believe. And we need something like that. We don't want to be San Diego. We don't want to be urban. But we really need to do something to jumpstart investment in this community. We're going to be at full employment next year. I heard on the news this morning.

1:07:21 You know, because you consider the people who are not unemployable. You know how the statisticians figure those things out. But we really need to start investing in our community. Right now, I feel, and I've talked to John Urdi about this, talked to other people about this, based on what I've seen at our peer resorts, either in personal travel or on our peer resort tour back, you know, maybe six or seven years ago, we are looking at our competition with binoculars through the windshield.

1:07:50 We should be looking at our competition in the rearview mirror. I mean, the competition for visitor dollars is huge. We have the best mountain. We have an urban growth boundary, so we can't sprawl like Park City. You go to Park City, the first thing you see is Walmart. We're surrounded by spectacular scenery. We have these resources that are just incredible. I've been doing this for 14 years, and we have so many good plans. They're in binders on the shelf.

1:08:16 You know, this is the first one we, that a big project that's come before us since the recession, and it's a very important project because of its location. It's also a very unique site which gives it a lot of advantages. It's 6.1 acres. It's in the geographic center of town. It's essentially flat, even though there is a slope to it. And because of where it's located,

1:08:42 And it's contributing, you know, retail, and I'll say novel retail because this marketplace concept like Pike's Place Market in Seattle and other markets like that, we don't have anything like that. We're going to get much needed conference space, not that little tiny room that they have at the West End where, you know, you can't have a luncheon, much less a conference. And amenities and public gathering spaces all with a southern exposure, but we're going to have critical mass to make our general plan a reality, which is feet first,

1:09:12 Transit second, cars last, right in the center of town. It's really going to change things. The thing about the parcel size also is it's square. And so you can take these features, and I wondered, I mean, I was in favor of the higher height back in the day. You know, I thought 65 feet, yeah, it's in the center of the parcel. You're not going to be able to see it when you're a pedestrian. You know, looking up, you just won't be able to see this.

1:09:40 And so I didn't have a problem, but the public did. And the thing about height is we've always been, you know, Southern California drive-to market, you know, come up and ski for the weekend. And we've been trying since I moved here 22 years ago to really build midweek visitation. And we've done a lot of stuff at the airport, but it still isn't happening. We're still focused on that. And many of our second homeowners are from Southern California, and they're used to

1:10:08 This lower model, you know, that's how things are. And then we also had the issue of village and the trees because we're trying to provide a different visitor experience. That's why visitors go places, so they can go some places different from home. Well, a survey was done of the trees on this site and other mature trees around town, and we found out that the average height of the trees was 65 feet. So if you want to really be a stickler about village and the trees, you know, it's

1:10:36 Right on, right there. Unfortunately, some of those trees have died with the drought, so that's pretty sad. I think the reason the height was such an issue is people were really stirred up about that, and I can understand because, number one, it was changed, number two, it was big, and there were some things that happened all at the same time which were really unfortunate. The original applicant, the man who sold the property to Mr. Demetriatus,

1:11:05 Had an architect come here who designed this urban, blocky, high, crowded, it was just industrial. What's that hotel in Los Angeles that looks like a spaceship put it there? The Bonaventure? What is the name of that hotel? You know the one I mean? It's all concrete and it just looks like a spaceship plopped it down. Anyway, it was not Mountain Village in the trees.

1:11:31 And he showed us his concept. We were at a workshop just like this. And in less than an hour, we found 50 major things that were wrong with it. I mean, he just didn't know the territory. You know, he didn't realize what things were like up here. It was not going to work at all in Mammoth. Then at the same time, the developer of the three corners at Lake Mary and Minaret, or I could say, yeah, Minaret and Main Street, Lake Mary, you know, the intersection we all know about, he

1:12:00 We had come up with plans. We worked hard on that. And then he put a crane on the corner to show how high 90 feet was because that was where his building would top out. Well, the public saw that and you can imagine they went ballistic because 90 feet is really pretty high. Yet on the other hand, the Westin is 94 feet. It's not on a flat lot that's sort of down in the center of town. It's up on a hill.

1:12:25 I don't see any pickets outside the Westin saying, uh-oh, 94 feet, you know, you're too tall. If it's done right, with the right design, in the right place, it can work. We also have to consider that there is a business model to this where economic development and, I mean, my comments, I got started, I'm sorry. It's economic development, but it's got to...

1:12:49 Give the investors a return. I mean, they're not doing this as a charity. They have to figure out what the market wants, what they can do, what's realistic, and they have to be able to get a decent return on their investment. And we're trying to – I beseeched the council when we got our certificates of appreciation for our service. I said, please, seek out, encourage, go after sustainable, well-done investment in our community. We are desperate for it. We are dying. That's how I look at it.

1:13:18 Another thing that happened, and this is where the previous proposal really went sideways, is one of the advocates for the Clearwater's specific plan suggested as a community benefit, a 97-foot tower would be a good idea, and people could go up there in the elevator and just sort of look around at the scenery. Well, you can imagine what the neighborhood thought of that. I mean, whether you're into nude sunbathing or not, you know, that just a 97-foot tower, just, you know, my goodness, that was not good.

1:13:47 I also think it was difficult for people to visualize what it was like to have a 6.1-acre square with a height in the center where the pedestrians aren't aware of it. It's very hard to visualize, but the pedestrians aren't going to be aware of it. And then my last point in terms of the problems about the height would be the project's already approved. I mean, it's going to be essentially, you know, this. It's just what they're asking for is 10 feet more.

1:14:16 But it's already approved and they could build it tomorrow and get their use permit. What was the question? All right. So we have underneath height. Okay. Okay. So we have a 10-foot height increase along Laurel Mountain. So how do you feel about that? Which would take us to 4-5 feet. Do you want me to do the bullet points? Yeah, that would be great. Good. Okay. 10-foot height increase. What they originally proposed was very uniform. It was wooden soldiers lined up.

1:14:45 And we said, no, we need some variation, we need some articulation. Articulation is everything in design. And so by raising the height, that makes sense to accommodate the units that they want. But they've really made an improvement with the previous plan for how it would look from the street. I have no problem with that. The increase along Old Mammoth Place, I had a problem with that, but we haven't seen elevations yet. It was absolutely uniform.

1:15:13 No variation. I'm also worried about balconies on the north side. And I don't know what the roof, I guess your roof is going to be flat. Is that the idea, John?

1:15:25 Yes, I think, you know, we wanted to kind of get initial feedback. We haven't looked at that from a specific massing point, but the roof would be flat. Yeah, okay. We had angled the balcony so that they faced primarily, so they weren't facing directly north as part of that scalloped front. And I think we would want to, our goal would not to be, and we had it broken.

1:15:47 in terms of the facade so it wasn't one continuous wall. But I think our goal, you know, as we continue to get feedback and study would be not to create a giant mass. It would be to articulate it and to break it down and to... I would, personally, I would revisit balconies because before the four-year drought, you know, we had 56 feet of snow and it's on the north side and there's not particularly a view. You're going to have your street.

1:16:12 And then you have some landscaping, then you have the back of, you know, Mammoth Mall is what you've got. Well, and that's why we angled it. So the balcons didn't look out straight to the north to the back of Mammoth Mall. They were covered and then actually turned and faced towards the balcons. Yeah. So you've got a diagonal view. Perhaps in the summer that will be desirable, but my preference, if I were looking at a unit to buy, I'd be thinking about cornered windows or something, you know, two windows that came together rather than a balcony. Okay, that's... Well, now you can skip two bullet points.

1:16:40 And then go down to... Now don't cheat me out of my turn here. Okay. Okay. Okay. Then the 10 to 30 foot height increase in the center. Oh, absolutely. No, I thought from the beginning it should be there. In fact, it looks sort of chopped off. This is something we saw on our Pure Resort tour too. And that's why I like how they've done the step backs is that buildings like the Ritz Hotel in Aspen built right to the height limit. And then they put these little squatty...

1:17:07 Dormers on it, you know, to have some architectural variety and what it looks like is a building built to the height limit with little squatty dormers on it and it just doesn't work. And so the articulation I think is very important but they have this opportunity because they've got this 6.1 acre square to do that. What's the last one? Is that okay? Is that what you need?

1:17:29 So you're saying that you're okay with a 65-foot height limit for the center of the project? Yes. No problem with that at all. In fact, I think it will be better. Okay, that's just height? Yes. Okay. Okay. We'll comment on height and then we'll go to the rest of the questions. Okay, good. All right. Commissioner Gray. Okay. Commissioner Brown already brought up the provisions in the recently updated zoning code.

1:18:04 which govern the adjacent commercial districts, which I think, even though it doesn't particularly apply to this parcel as this is governed more by the Clearwater Specific Plan, I think it's really important to take into consideration those adjacent parcels and adjacent governing documents. This site has a unique position of being adjacent to both the downtown and the Old Mammoth Road zones.

1:18:36 So keeping all of that in mind, I don't think it's completely out of the question to consider the 45-foot height along Lower Mountain Road. Everything that was previously discussed about the possible future redevelopment of properties along old, no, not old, Lower Mountain Road makes a lot of sense.

1:19:05 I think it's fair to consider equal treatment or, I don't know the word exactly that I'm looking for, but compatible treatment of the two sides of the road there. I like the idea of the extra height adding flexibility to the articulation of that side of the building. I don't think anyone wants to walk down that street and just see a blank wall.

1:19:37 That goes straight up to 45 feet, and that's not exactly what we're anticipating here. And I think that extra height gives a little bit of a cushion to make a more interesting project, for sure. Have we talked about the whole wedding layer cake concept yet today? I don't know the history of that discussion as it pertains to the Clearwater Specific Plan and how it was changed when the

1:20:11 Commercial code was adopted, but maybe Mickey can explain a little bit better. So when the town hired Noray Winter to help us design our concept for Main Street, he did a sub-conversation one day, and I believe Tom Cage and some others in the audience were present, and he said the problem with, at that time, our height and mass policy

1:20:38 was that we were going to have a whole town that looked like wedding cakes because of the way we had done our setbacks and stepbacks. So Noray Winter was very encouraging that when we wrote our design guidelines for Main Street and ultimately Old Mammoth Road that we really considered what we wanted along our frontage roads. And so this is what we jokingly refer now to as our wedding cakes.

1:21:07 As a design policy for the town, we're trying to get away from that look and really give our street sites more variances, interesting architecture and articulation. Yes. Thank you. So I think that given an opportunity to move more in that direction is something that we should favorably consider.

1:21:39 So I guess that covers Lower Mountain Road. Old Mammoth Place. I think I would echo some of Commissioner Tenney's concerns there about shade and shadow. I do understand that the direction of your balconies not being due north makes a lot of sense. I think as we see more information and more renderings and more elevations of what that could look like, we'll have more information on that.

1:22:17 But again, with that property line being adjacent to the downtown zone, which has a stated height limit of 55 feet, is that correct? I don't think it's unusual for us to consider a comparable treatment there.

1:22:38 The height increase towards the center of site, I think, when we were looking at this earlier, I think it's important to realize that the 30-foot height increase really only affects a very small percentage of square footage. I don't know the exact number, but it's... So the majority of the height increase that we're talking about towards the center of the site is a 10-foot height increase. Again, not out of the question, I think. With it being towards the center of site, it's...

1:23:09 I don't really have anything else. I think the height discussion

1:23:49 for this project is very interesting, and it's especially interesting when you go back and you look at all of the original documents. As we know, we've talked extensively in the past about the general plan. I think the general plan is very clear about what we're trying to accomplish. And so then the next really key source document is the Clearwater Specific Plan. And originally, Commission approved that plan.

1:24:18 with a maximum height of 65 feet. And what subsequently happened is the council at that time, I believe, based on public input, then ultimately reduced it from 65 feet to 55 feet. So based on what I have heard today, I would have really a difficult time

1:24:46 Not listening to what the previous commission said as far as the previous height. I believe that, you know, the Laurel Mountain, increasing it to 45 is very appropriate because certainly that's what the adjacent landowners are entitled to on the other side of the street and I certainly am comfortable with the 55 feet on Old Mammoth Place because that's compatible to that adjacent landlord. So, the 65 feet

1:25:16 It's not a clear that our role as planning commissioners is to say what was the community vision or what is the community vision and to measure this project against the community vision. And we're given a community vision that's a little foggy because you have a specific plan that says 55 feet.

1:25:42 Now we have a commercial code that has 45 feet and 55 feet and then you have North Old Mammoth Special Study that said 65 feet and you also have an EIR that said 65 feet. But as I sit here today when I line up the priority of all those documents I would have to give most weight to the existing specific plan and how that height limit came.

1:26:11 So that's my comments about height. And I just really want to make sure that, did staff have any other comments they'd like to add about height at this time? Or did the applicants have any questions about what we've stated about height? Pardon me? No, no. Okay. All right. Any other thoughts about height? No, just tell me when I can talk about footprint. Okay, you can talk about footprint now. Oh, now? Yes. Oh, good.

1:26:41 Okay, she's a tough chairman. I have to go back to this. The whole idea of Old Mammoth Place is it's a place, it's special. And this sketch, John, is this your sketch? You came back with that. This was really something because we're going to have conventional, whatever conventional resort vacation retail is on Old Mammoth Road, but this marketplace area was going to be for artisans, farmer's market, that sort of thing, and the size of the

1:27:11 Stalls, if I can call them stalls, may vary in size depending on what the business is, but it was beautiful the way you did this because it steps back in two sections and there's an entrance over here off Old Mammoth Place and an exit here or vice versa, you know, so you can go around, but it draws this wonderful light.

1:27:30 Thank you. Thank you.

1:27:58 But just the light and shadow and how it would be illuminated at night, that's why I'm so concerned about building on top of this because otherwise you're just going to have a hallway with, you know, some people with cash registers and stuff, you know, that kind of stuff. If you're not careful, I'm really afraid you're going to lose that. This is very, very important to me. Don't mess this up. Okay, so then I'm concerned about encroachment.

1:28:26 The beauty of this project is this 6.1 acre parcel faces south, and also you were trying to be good neighbors to the condo project across the way, but you're now adding units down here, which is making the grove and the entrance that sort of funnels people in. That bothers me a lot. You're adding a unit here next to the entrance or the exit, depending on how you go in and out, and I don't know.

1:28:55 I tried to measure the scale, but I'm not quite sure how wide that entrance is, but that's encroaching to me. I worry about that. You want the scale of this, this entrance, to really make a statement. You don't want it to look like a conventional lobby, you know, and then there are these units up above. The unit you added here on Old Mammoth Place in Laurel Mountain doesn't affect anything, really. It's just there was room for it and it was a good place to put it and it can go up the

1:29:25 Four stories or five stories there. And I understand why you added the units here. They don't encroach. But encroaching on this space really concerns me. Now, Brent, I have to ask you, is this River Terrace area, would that be accessible to the public? Yes. That's completely accessible to the public. Well, John, can you tell me how wide that entrance is? I don't think it's changed from the original, but five years or six years ago, I can't remember. It's exactly the same as the original. It's approximately about 30 feet.

1:29:52 30 feet, okay, so it's good size, that's good, okay. Encroachment, what else do I want to say about encroachment? Okay, then, these units that you show here, this would be the second floor, these units that you show here on the end of the east side of the hotel, those are over the Market Commons, right? What would be underneath those units? Because you don't show anything on the first floor.

1:30:25 What's underneath those? No, it should show, I mean, what we had, what we thought we were proposing, and it would be, I'll go back and check as well, would be that that would be units, there would be the commercial on the plaza level, and then there would be units all the way up. Oh, so there's retail underneath. Yes, so there's kind of. I couldn't find the, because it said 563 square feet were relocated to the plaza, and I couldn't find it. You have to go back to the garage level.

1:30:54 Is it at the garage level? No, it's on the same page. No, he's saying plaza level. No, he's saying. The intent is right here. It would actually, what's currently diagrammed, Commissioner Tenney, is that there would be. Which floor are you on first? This is the piece right off the Market Commons. Yes, yes. Where you would be entering in. Yes. So at this level would be commercial. Aha. Okay, that wasn't clear. And so this was, we did add some additional commercial.

1:31:27 In the areas that you're referencing, we did add some additional commercial here as we moved towards the grove and then with residential above. And then at the plaza level, we also extended that just a little bit. So at the plaza level, it was officially, I think, is listed as the wellness component for the residential above that. So things just kind of slid forward just a little bit.

1:32:02 I think what's complicating just the conversation is the change in elevation from the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Sierra Nevada up to the plaza level. I think that's just creating some confusion. Some confusion. Yes. Because this was a double height residential. Right, and it confused me earlier until you mentioned that the retail that's shown on the garage ground floor plan is all at street level.

1:32:25 And though the plaza steps up from the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Sierra Nevada to what we're calling the first floor plan, even though that's the outdoor common space. And I really ask if you wouldn't mind. So it's really important that everybody sees what we're talking about. So let me kind of reiterate. So I think one of the things that is confusing to folks is that the ground floor retail along Old Mammoth, because there's a slope in the

1:32:58 This is all at grade level here. So if you move through what was called the Grove and move up to what we were calling the Plaza level above, whereas the ground floor level along with Mammoth, you're basically getting this level of 15-foot retail. And then this corner piece here, we're also showing additional commercial area. It then continues to show up on the second level because

1:33:27 It's still part of that plausible level. It's a double height, basically. And so at this plausible level, we come up under very fourth grade. This is where we extruded out some additional commercial area here at this level. So we added a little bit of commercial element in place here. We added a little bit of additional commercial up here at the market commons. And then this piece, which is very confusing to folks, is still considered to be a double height.

1:33:57 So we did maintain the retail component there, and then what we had proposed was to bring, on the next level, on the third level, bring a row of units over the top of the portion. You can see that on this level here. So the two-story corner piece is still here and out to here.

1:34:27 And this is where, on level three, we did show some additional residential. So on this corner piece here, this is that two-story retail level, grade and on level one, and then on level, sorry, grade, which is one, plus level two, and then three. Can I ask a question? Would you still keep that sort of reverse-pitch roof as a high-brow? To block off that unit, is it just sort of parasitic conditioner sitting the same?

1:34:59 That was our intent is if, you know, if you began to look at it, what we had kind of imagined, and we haven't fully studied it either, we were looking for the feedback, but we imagined we'd have that double height space, the initial brow would be the double height commercial space, and then that second brow would be residential. Okay.

1:35:26 That's the thing I'm concerned about is you've designed a beautiful project. I mean, the details and the architecture. There'll be another meeting with the ADP when it comes time to do materials and colors, which will be very helpful. But I just don't – I understand the market analysis, and obviously you can't build something there's no market for. You know, single hotel rooms aren't where it's at these days. But I want to be sure that in adding units, you're not taking away from what you had because it was so fine. It really was.

1:35:56 It was a long, complicated process, and it came out with a very good result. And thank you very much for that. I mean, I think we also felt it was a very, very good back and forth. We did bring along the materials board and the colors board because our intent would be to, again, maintain everything we worked so hard to achieve and, again, get feedback and discussion so that we can, you know, nip and tuck where it makes sense. But our intent...

1:36:20 Would be to maintain the overall look and feel, to focus the efforts on maintaining those public spaces, maintaining the details, maintaining the overall color palette. So this is an overall board. This was the original submission that shows that variety and richness of palette and detail. The intent would be to maintain that, be able to achieve that. And so for the audience, this is, again, one of the material boards.

1:36:48 Here it shows the variety of combination of heavy timbers, native stone, really the intent was to really use a mountain architecture, a mountain auricular, mountain materials, but at the same time give it a kind of crispness and neatness that would really take place. And just from my perspective, I wouldn't want to lose that either. Yeah, I won't be here to vote on the final proposal, so I just got to get all my, you know, make it as good as you can make it points in. Okay, that answers that.

1:37:28 Commissioner Gray, question B. Footprint. I don't have any major concerns. I think we've addressed most of them already. I think it sounds like you're keeping and taking into consideration the design guidelines that were previously discussed. I don't think we need to beat a dead horse. I also have no major concerns about the building footprint.

1:38:02 Especially if you look at it in light of our new commercial code standards, it falls also on the same guidelines as being under a FAR 2.0, which we hope will be adopted next year. So I'm fine with that. And then let's go to question number C. Does it appear reasonable to eliminate the eight on-site workforce housing units?

1:38:27 And I just really want to make sure, I mean, that people understand we're not just eliminating housing units. I mean, of course, they'd have to be paid a fee that was been established at the last housing ordinance. So the question is really to substitute on-site workforce for the in-loop fee. Right. Right. According to the new housing ordinance. Do you want to comment? Yes. We have new policy, so.

1:38:57 That's a moot point. And I never understood, I understood the ideal and the principle behind inclusionary housing, but, you know, who wants to live at the village and send your kids out to play kind of thing. So I think I'm glad they changed the ordinance. Okay. I agree 100%. I also agree with that. So I just would like to, since this isn't a

1:39:25 Formal hearing, we can take a little leeway and I just want to make sure that we've answered everybody's questions or concerns in the audience. So I will give you one last time to ask any questions that you may have either of us or of the applicant or staff. If anybody would have any additional comments or questions at this time. In terms of the entrance to the restaurant for supplies and so forth, at one point,

1:40:04 You designed it so that access took place from Laurel Mountain Road and went underneath and the actual delivery took place on the bottom floor beneath the restroom. I thank you for it because that took away a major impact on our community at Sierra Park Village. What happened to that? Is there some reason you can't go underneath? That's a very good question and I probably didn't.

1:40:34 I wanted to kind of clarify that enough earlier when Commissioner Tenney asked the question about that. The intent is to still do kind of what we all worked out together. So what we have found, particularly as restaurants are more and more interested in local food and, you know, farm-to-table type of products, they can take a lot of their deliveries with small vans because they tend not to be the giant Cisco trucks that kind of used to pull up to these restaurants.

1:41:07 A better end restaurant is going to have fresher goods and other kinds of things that are typically delivered in vans or by farmers themselves in many cases. So what we had envisioned is that for much of the draw for this restaurant, folks would be able to come right into this loading dock, sorry, right into the garage level, the lower level, and be able to draw off goods in a van.

1:41:35 We did on the next level up in order to make sure that we had a viable

1:42:08 Project and a viable restaurant pad, we did provide some additional loading on Sierra Nevada with the major loading dock though being off of Laurel Mountain. So the major loading dock is off Laurel Mountain. We're anticipating a lot of the local deliveries and the smaller vendors and the trash components.

1:42:34 Will be able to use the garage and be able to come out via Laurel Mountain. But we did want to make a provision for those basic staples and other kinds of goods that are going to arrive in a slightly larger truck that they would be able to have access to the restaurant back at house. I assume that the use permit levels are going to have those regulations on the shelf at the time. That could certainly be... For that location.

1:43:03 Does everyone want a quick review of what we just did? No, I was following along on my plan. I will. Could you go over it really briefly? Sure. I think one of the things that I kind of short-circuited as we began to talk about the loading along Sierra Nevada is I didn't really explain the overall strategies that we had all worked together as a community. So, for example, for the restaurant piece that's up here on the upper level. Yes.

1:43:32 We actually anticipate that many of the deliveries will be coming via smaller vehicle. And so the intent is that those smaller vehicles will be able to come directly into the garage level and drop off to this loading location here and be able to bring up smaller drop-off elements up to the restaurant from that location. We're also assuming much of the trash.

1:43:55 Could come down from this location here and transfer over to potentially over to the Laurel Mountain side if that were desirable. But in order to kind of make sure we had a viable project and there would be some cases where you are going to have deliveries in bigger trucks, we did provide some loading opportunity off of Sierra Nevada.

1:44:25 I would say typically those that are going to be in any larger than a van. So a lot of the smaller vendors, whether it's fresh fish or fresh vegetables or fruits, they tend to be in smaller van type of areas. And this garage would have approximately an 8'4 to 8'6 ceiling height, which can accommodate those kinds of vans. So it would really be more of the basic staples, things that are coming in via Cisco truck or those kinds of larger deliveries that would be on.

1:44:53 Excuse me, but because it's being televised, we need to carry this conversation on with the mic. I'm assuming if this 10-foot thing goes on, that

1:45:23 You can consider maybe eliminating that one-on-seer Nevada because it will have an impact on our residents. You know, Cisco is a pretty big truck and it depends on when they come, of course, early in the morning or late at night. Anyway, if you would consider that. The way it looked out before, worked out before, you eliminated that voting zone. Well, we had never eliminated it. It was always there and it was part of the...

1:45:55 We had tried to mitigate it, definitely, in terms of both smaller vehicle growth models as well as landscaping. Thank you. Can I make a comment? I'm glad you're giving such serious attention to trash and delivery issues, because a mistake we made at the village was the restaurants were at the opposite end from the dumpster, and there was a grease track all the way along the plaza as the, you know, workers would take the trash and stuff.

1:46:25 To the dumpster. So, you know, I mean, it's little things like this. This is the kind of stuff that we just tear our hair out trying to keep track of all these details, but they really make a difference. And at the Westin we saw that challenge when you got loading the dock right in front of your main entryway. It just doesn't work either. I can't believe we missed that one. I'm still embarrassed about that. Right next to the front door. Okay. Okay. Any other comments on this project? Are we doing the general plan consistency? Or, oh, we're...

1:46:54 What page are we on? We're through their discussion questions. Oh, okay, I'd like to make a comment on general plan consistency. Okay. Okay. Are we all going to comment or should I just go ahead? Go ahead. Okay. You know, the goal of the man-made shall complement, not dominate the natural environment, the way I've always interpreted that, and I guess we can use our discretion to interpret the general plan because people can see words different ways.

1:47:24 Is we're not going to have bright garish colors, we're not going to have a lot of plastic, we're not going to have things that are unnatural. But that doesn't mean to me that if it's going to complement the natural environment that it has to be invisible. No, it has to be really good design. It has to be like the mountain vernacular, the term that Larry Walker coined so well. It's got to be rugged. It has to be timeless. It has to be excellent, high-quality materials.

1:47:52 So it's worthy of the natural environment. So that's how I've always interpreted that and I have no issue at all with this possibly being inconsistent with that goal in the general plan. The other one, the other four, actually I'll just talk about the last one. Because we've got the sunny streets and plazas and sidewalks and it's already been approved and some public views are going to be blocked because any kind of building is going to block a view from somewhere. It does, however, frame the view.

1:48:20 Going down to the south on Old Mammoth Road, which is a good thing. She'll complement neighboring land uses. I think that's really unrealistic that before the town was incorporated, condo projects that were built in the 70s, maybe in the 60s possibly, Mountain Shadows has

1:48:38 done a redo, you know, with the paint and I don't know what other work was done there, but it was definitely a makeover and it looks very good. And the Summit and other condo projects have done, you know, makeovers so they can be more updated. But projects that are well maintained but still look like they did the day they were built, I don't see that as a valid

1:49:00 A valid criticism. That means we would build more 70-style condo projects if we're going to complement what's there, and that's not what we're after. We really need to goose our economy, and that's what we should be thinking of. And by the same token, this project is going to improve their property values, so I think we need to look at it that way. So I had no problem with a section on is it consistent with a – it may not be consistent with a general plan. I think it is completely consistent with a general plan. That's all I want to say on that.

1:49:33 Anything else you're going to say on this project? Very glad to see you here, and I think you're still going for lead silver, is that right? Okay. And the geothermal, that's really important, because the village put all that burden on the end user and its electric resistance heaters, and aren't we proud? You know, so that's really important to do that. And maybe we can get some cooperation with some other entities in town to help us out with that. Excellent. Excellent. That's good. That's good.

1:50:04 And I know you have another session with ADP for sure. Oh, you've got a lot more to do. Jen, just a point of information, just because I'm curious, since they have to do additional environmental work, how big a project is that? I mean, I just had no idea that would have to happen. Is it something that's going to take, you know, three months, six months? I mean, is it a deal breaker? What do you think?

1:50:30 Well, I think it could vary. If we just have to do an addendum to the EIR, that would just take a few months. If we need to do a subsequent EIR, that's the process we went through with the Inn at the Village, and that ended up taking us over 10 months to do that. So I think it really varies, and I think we'd probably want to get a CEQA expert to give us their advice to be able to make that decision. What does our town council, SEL, say? Andy Morris, what does he say? We haven't asked him yet. Haven't asked him yet. Okay.

1:50:58 Because I think it is important, this is a big project and it's going to take a long time to do, and I think it's important if the commission and the council decide they want this in Mammoth Lakes, California, that, you know, with all deliberate speed, I always like deliberate speed because it means move right along, but pay attention while you're going, so that's why I like deliberate speed. I'm sorry, I won't be here. You can come as a public comment, that's what I'll do. I'll be here in the summers, but just not six months I need to be here.

1:51:28 I just wanted to make a question or an observation. I think the architects did a great job of showing the building sections and the view impact or a lack of impact that the change in height would have. But the one sort of view area that we talked about or looked at at one point that could be

1:51:56 More noticeable is that southeast to northwest sort of cross-section that goes through the Grove and the Market Commons and the swimming pool open area. I think that maybe is just a view and a perspective to take into consideration. And I can't really tell from here if any of your previous renderings give us that view of the project, but I think that would be one that would be useful to have for future workshops. Did anybody?

1:52:31 Do you have any additional comments on the project? I just want to sincerely thank you for coming forward. It's very exciting. We'd love to see you have the sticks in the ground and we'd all show up for your ceremony of doing that and I hope we gave you some valuable feedback today and please let us know any additional information that you need. I just want to say thank you for...

1:53:05 The board's time and the staff time, we appreciate that very much. And before she leaves the dais over there, so I figured out that if I've worked with Jen for the last four years, I've worked with her for 40% of her time, and she was a senior planner for the town of Mammoth Lakes, and I have to say

1:53:28 That you represent the ultimate of professionalism. I have never seen you in any other situation or any situation that you weren't very professional, you're certainly very knowledgeable, and you've always been very dedicated to the town. And I personally wish you good luck in your new endeavors. Thank you very much for all your hard work. And I don't know if you'd like to. I would agree. It's only been a year. And for me, working with you.

1:53:55 But I've learned a lot. You've been very helpful for all of us. And I'm excited for you and your new path. Thank you so much. Jen, I think you're unflappable. And I'm flappable. The fact that you are unflappable is just amazing to me. Your quiet competence is just, I don't know how they're going to replace you. I really don't. So you will be missed. We didn't need to do that.

1:54:38 Okay, well, so that concludes our business matter, and we'll move on to our commissioner report at this point. Commissioner report? I got a quick one. Do you have a commissioner? I do have a commissioner report. I've been attending the Black Rock Design Institute series of lectures and films in Reno at the Art Museum, and they are just excellent. It's a...

1:55:15 An organization that was formed by three architects in Reno and they're all, it's also associated with AIA, the American Institute of Architects, is that right, Annie? And the last one was just fascinating. It was two people from Las Vegas who patterned a project after something that had been done very successfully in San Francisco and that is they created Parklets and it's called, their website's called Park, L-E-T-S, Parklets Vegas.

1:55:44 And what they've done is in the space of a parking place, 10 feet by 20 feet, they've made little miniature parks. They're not necessarily permanent, but by putting up planters, by putting up activities like oversized checkers, you know, that sort of thing, places I had never heard of this before. But I'm thinking about our four square miles. We're not going to expand, which is one of our biggest assets.

1:56:09 But we could probably find, if we were creative, this is smaller than pocket parks. This isn't like the little parks we talked about in the past. This is really no bigger than a parking space. I think we'd be amazed at what we could do in Mammoth. And, you know, every summer when I come back, I'm going to want to see all the new stuff you guys have done. So I would look forward to maybe seeing some parklets. So I will pass this on to Mickey, and then she can give it to Amy and Sandra and check it out. That's all I have on Commissioner Reports.

1:56:40 Any commission reports? No, I'd just like to say thank you to Elizabeth for your wonderful guidance and expertise on the design committee and on the commission. It'll be a different place without you there, that's for sure. Oh, thank you, thank you. I think the biggest perk of this job is being on design review and especially working with ADP. I have learned so much.

1:57:06 You know, I have a history with my husband of flipping houses, but that gets down pretty much to paint colors and what kind of plumbing fixtures to pick out. But, you know, architects, that's big picture stuff. And I have learned so much. I feel like a very well-informed layperson now after 14 years of it. So I hope, Amy, you'll be able to continue. I hope so. Because it looks like with all the trucks I see on 395 going back and forth, the economy is back.

1:57:35 Can't forget about us, especially if we go out and seek investment. And so I hope there's going to be a lot of design review in a very close near future. Oh, everybody left. Okay. Well, I'm sorry that our public audience left. But, you know, while we're on the subject, Commissioner Kinney, one of the qualities that makes a good commissioner is people that are passionate about the town.

1:57:58 And I have to say, I have never seen you non-passionate. I mean, you're always passionate. And I just really appreciate that enthusiasm. Thank you. Thank you. In 14 years, you've seen a lot. Oh, I've seen a lot. Wow, wow. I have to share this. I read a long time ago that work, any kind of work, to be satisfying, has to be challenging, you know, intellectually. And is there anything more challenging than this job? It has to involve creativity.

1:58:27 Which, of course, is problem solving. And you have to feel you're doing some good. And Planning Commission fits that to a T. I mean, it has all three characteristics, and that's why it's so satisfying. So it was very, very exciting to see a project come before us today. And the people who are doing it, you know, this firm and John Ashworth are just excellent. And they're very collaborative. And so I think the outcome will be a very good one. If you can work it all out.

1:58:56 I'll come back, if there's a groundbreaking, should there be one, I'll come back for that, and I'll definitely come back for the ribbon cutting, maybe they'll let me hold my hands over somebody's hand, scissors or something, you know. Will you make a note of that? Yeah, just because this is a really, this is such an important project, and I think this is, well I didn't use the words catalyst site, have we used that word up here? Right. Because this is definitely a catalyst site, and having the village at the other end, and then this, everything in between, I think we'll get off the dime on Main Street, so that would be a good thing.

1:59:25 Well, I've had a great time. I really have. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra. Sandra. You've done such a good job, Sandra. I mean, Mark just left, and there you were, and you've just done a fantastic job. You really have. You really have. Thank you. Yeah. Just wave a group hug. No, we're not hugging Sandra today. No. Do you have a director's report, Sandra? Yeah, I would just like to kind of echo what the other commissioners have said.

1:59:55 We will miss you. You've been a great commissioner to work with, a great chair, a great vice chair, and your shoes will be difficult to fill as well. Thank you. So thank you for all your service to the town. And the only other thing I had was that we may be canceling the August 12th Planning Commission meeting.

2:00:17 Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. We will send out a notice if we do decide to cancel that. But at this point, we don't have anything on the agenda. So we're looking probably to cancel that. Okay. Just heads up. That's all I have. Okay. And then, so I just have a comment about logistically how we work. You know, I love the new screens. I love the fact that you can sit.

2:00:43 Over there at the dais and use the remote control. But now what doesn't work is when they bring their own boards. So I think we really need to encourage applicants to put all this on the PowerPoint. Okay. Because it's really important that, especially when you have, you know, 30 people or whatever here that they can see what we're talking about. So that should be overly difficult, right? No, it's easy to put that up. Okay. And then if somebody's speaking at that podium,

2:01:13 Is there a way that they can use an electronic pointer at that podium? I think they would have to have the keyboard over there. So a lot of the keyboard is at the podium. But the mouse, I mean, I'm the closest person to this, and the mouse did not work. You really need a laser pointer. We were thinking, well, the problem with the laser pointer, what Jen pointed out, is that it would only be on this TV. It would be on the TV that the audience sees. Oh. But what we were thinking is maybe we could make the...

2:01:39 Mouse a different color, like a red, it's probably possible. Yeah, why can't you do that? Is that doable? Yeah. It's just like a laser. It's such a great improvement from what we have. Oh, wow. Nice. Right. So we just need to fine-tune it just a tap. Yeah. Thank you. And then the only other, you know, comment is, Commissioner Gregg, that sometime, probably it'll be our September meeting,

2:02:07 Right. That we will do a new commissioner workshop where we'll spend time reviewing an APA webinar on different roles of commissioners, town council, staff, talk about key source documents, talk about our roles of order. But I think we had tried at one time talking about doing that as a special meeting, but that probably won't work, I would guess. I don't think it'll work at this point, but we can still look at that.

2:02:36 But the only thing we have on the, possibly on the agenda for September is a final map, which would just be consent. Okay. So that would be a great time. It's a really light meeting. It would be good. It's the first meeting for the new commissioners. And you're anticipating interviews for the new commissioners by council in August? August 19th. So they'll conduct the interviews, which are open to the public, but they'll be held in the closed session room, which the public is welcome to.

2:03:04 Observe those, and then they'll actually appoint the commissioners that night. So we'll have the new commissioners on August 19th. The last time we had new commissioners, Commissioner Harvey and I sat in on the interviews, which we were permitted to do. You don't say anything. You don't ask any questions. But it was a good thing. You weren't at my interview. What? You weren't at my interview. It was before that. It was before that. No, I wasn't. That's right. But it was useful. It was definitely useful.

2:03:33 Okay, are we adjourned? No, I'm going to adjourn right now. Okay, because I've got to talk to Amy. Okay. Okay. Good. So, there's no other business. I move that we adjourn to the next regular meeting to be held on August 12, 2015 at 2 p.m. in Council Chamber Suite Z. Amy, I think you need to have this. Everything else I'm giving back to Sarah. Everything else I'm giving back to Sarah.