TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 6 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

352 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:25 Is this session being recorded, even as in a training session? I see. Okay. Good morning. I call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for September the 9th, 2015. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Greick? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Disappeared on us. Commissioner Verruck? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance?

2:05 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible. Just so you know, always before every public meeting we have an opportunity for public comments. And public comments are for anybody that wishes to speak on any item that's not on today's agenda. And there are probably no public comments, so I close the public comments period. And now we have the oath of office. Commissioner Chang.

2:51 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:23 Thank you. Congratulations. Thank you.

3:50 As was mentioned by the council, I mean, we were extremely fortunate to have 11 very qualified applicants. I think the council did a tremendous job of interviewing and vetting the process, and we're really pleased that you joined us and pleased that you're here.

4:11 You know, I think what makes a good commission is a credible body, a group of people that are very knowledgeable, and a group of people that have diverse interests and experiences in town, and I believe we really have a great commission, and I'm looking forward to the next year and many years after that, so congratulations. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, and congratulations Commissioner Baruch. There you go.

4:39 I always, you know, I like to do warm-up exercises. So we're going to start with this little warm-up exercise. Do you want to introduce it? No, I just, I just think we'll let it speak for itself. Okay. Unless you want to introduce it. No. I've received them from, and as president, sir, I've been seconded. Really? When your police report says you threatened to kill your wife, and this is misdemeanor. Wow. Yes.

7:09 No, and you'll all live and die with that vote, believe me. Okay. So, the American, this is what we're not going to do, all right? Okay. We're all members of the American Planning Association and they have numerous really good webinars and training sessions. And so when I was trying to find which one I thought would be really appropriate for today.

7:38 I came across this one of world's worst meetings. And, you know, I mean, one of the things that I was, Mark Warbaugh, Sandra's predecessor, said is that, you know, we hold public meetings, but they're not, we hold meetings in public, but they are not public meetings. And I think that's a very important distinction. So that is why we have a rules of order. And sometimes you might wonder, well,

8:09 You know, are we being a little carried away about how we procedurally do things, especially during public hearings? But if you consistently follow the rules of order, then you have a basis, if a meeting ever does get out of control, to really prevent it. So today, and if that ever happened, since I've been a commissioner, we had one meeting that got a little out of control.

8:39 Quite that bad. But just so you know, if we ever do have a meeting that's out of control, one of you needs to make a motion for a recess, and another one needs you to second that motion really quickly, and we all get up and walk off the dais, because it just puts an end to whatever drama's going on. But my goal always is to have very

9:04 What I term basically boring methodical meetings, right? And that we just procedurally go down our agenda, make a great decision based off of the source documents and the findings that we have. And hopefully if somebody's watching them at TV that they find it so relaxing that they take a little nap during. I mean, it really, you know, is our role. I mean, our role is not to be dramatic.

9:31 Or DeGran stand up here on the dais. But the video we're going to watch for real, I thought, is an hour long, and it does a really great job, I felt, in summarizing the roles and responsibilities of commissioners, staff, and council, and we were going to use that as a starting point for our conversation today. Did you have anything you wanted to add to that, Sandra? I think that's it. The only thing is, I'm happy to pause it.

9:59 Oh, I think it probably should pause it. Yeah, commissioners have questions or you want to take a break. Get a donut. Get a donut. He's like, just get a donut now. So, just let me know if you'd like me to pause it. And I can turn off the lights. Everybody thinks we need to do. Might be a little bit clearer if I turn off the lights. A couple of questions. How many of you currently are a little scared out of the box? So we've got a range of different perspectives. So here's what we're going to talk about.

12:11 Joe is then going to talk about the big picture of the various hats.

12:44 And then we're going to talk about some of the specific things that you do as planning commissioners. And I'm going to focus in on development review. Those of you who were already in the planning commission probably have some experience with that depending on your tenure. And then we're going to talk about some resources that might help you with your job.

13:11 In many ways, being a Planning Commissioner, I think, is one of the more challenging citizen participation or citizen civic roles that you can take on because you're expected to know a lot about a lot of different things. And even given the high rate of pay that you all make as Planning Commissioners, it's still, you know, the expectations of what you need to know. The bar is really high, I think, much higher than just about anything else other than perhaps being an elected official where you're excited to know everything.

13:41 So it's a challenging job. So nevertheless, I think this quote is pretty poignant that if a cop needs to know the law for safety, then a planning commissioner should know the aspects of the law that apply to them. And it doesn't mean that you need to be a lawyer. You have legal counsel, or you should have legal counsel to support you in your job. You need to at least have a basic understanding of the legal framework within which you're expected to operate.

14:12 Really three, it was an interesting thing, the interesting thing about laws pertains to the Planning Commission role, it really functions or informs what you do at all three levels, federal, state, and local. And at the federal level, you probably heard quite a bit about this in the prior session, I'm just really going to cover it in a little bit, it's really all about what's legal as defined by the U.S. Constitution, interpreted by judges all the way on up to the Supreme Court. At the state level, it's what you can and can't do.

14:42 What you were allowed to do in your state in terms of setting policy and setting regulations at the local level is the specific rules by which you operate, whether it's zoning or subdivision rules or part of your plan. So pop quiz here. Anybody have any idea who was the father of land use planning and zoning in the U.S.? Anybody?

15:05 They got a great door prize on the table here for us who knows. Maybe a hint for not to become the 30, 40 plus president. What's that? Oh, it's Jefferson. Jefferson or Olmsted. Her hand, she was polite. She did what you're supposed to do in Planning Commission. So you've been a copy of the Planning Commissioner's Guide to Planning. Oh, so who's, okay, honor system number two. Who's the guy shouted out her? Okay.

15:38 Hey, it's too early for Robert's rules, so. And you can buy a copy at the bookstore. I get about half a cent for every copy that's sold. But it's actually an excellent, last year, over the past two years.

16:07 APA Press updated the Planning Commissioner's Guide, and then the Citizen's Guide to Planning and Zoning, which while it's primarily written for laypeople, is also very useful. How many of you as planning commissioners knew anything about planning before you came up? Not too many of you, and if you're willing to serve, you suddenly realize you've agreed to...

16:29 Basically choking fire hose when you start the job. So they're both excellent resources. If you have new colleagues coming on board, you can get your staff to spring for copies of those two books because you'll get a good foundation. Anyway, Herbert Hoover was, at the time, Secretary of the Department of Commerce. They created a standard enabling act for zoning, one for planning, that really led to a wellspring of plans and zones.

16:56 And zoning ordinances, as some of them back mentioned in the 1920s, shortly thereafter was challenged and on up to the Supreme Court level they ruled that zoning is constitutional. So that's really where the whole premise of federal role ever since then has been to be the place in which what planning commissions do or cities do is tested.

17:20 As to the legality. There are really two roles at the federal level, and again, those of you who were here this morning, I apologize, you've probably heard most of this, and it's really about due process, and there are two different types of due process that you need to be aware of in thinking about your role. First is procedural, how you carry out your job, and the second is the content, the substance by which decisions are made. I won't cover all of these, I'll just hit a couple of word highlights.

17:50 Substantive due process, as it sounds, is the content of what you're doing, whether it's plan making or development review, and the way we tend to look at it as planners is that there are really five things to keep in mind, five words. One is policy or regulation. Sandra, can you stop just for a second? Whether you're passing a plan or not.

18:16 I should have mentioned this. I have a PDF of all these slides, so you don't have to take detailed notes. I can get it to you and send it out, yeah. PDF. Okay. Thanks. Does it advance a legitimate public purpose? Can you say, you're doing this because this is what our community is trying to achieve? Second test, is that reasonable? That reasonable is a difficult question.

18:50 Depends on the person making that determination. So you may not be surprised to hear that this is often tested at the legal level. But questioning, it all circles back to, is it a reasonable way to accomplish, number one, the legitimate public purpose? Three, and this is one probably more familiar to you, is the relationship between what we're asking someone to do, either via policy or regulation, and the law.

19:20 So, and you've probably heard the rational nexus test. Is there a reasonable relationship between what we're asking someone to do and our policy or regulation as a community? A good example of that is we're asking someone to provide an easement. Is there a reason for that easement? Is it needed for a utility or an access? Or are we just asking for it because we want to gain the land that's not a reasonable basis?

19:45 Fourth is, does the policy regulation allow reasonable economic use of the property? This is a really important one because reasonable use of the property doesn't mean what I as a property owner consider reasonable or what I want. I really want to earn X dollars or I want to do X, Y, and Z with my land. Therefore, you have to allow it. What the courts have ruled is reasonable doesn't mean whatever the property owner wants to do. It means there's still some economic.

20:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

20:40 These five things, and you'll find these in any good reference guide to due process, whether you're being asked to evaluate a project or look at a plan, these are the kinds of things that planners look at and reports and verify as being tests for whether or not due process is being followed. The second is the process by which you carry out your business as a planning commission. And there's a lot of material here, I'm just going to go through it quickly. One is...

21:09 The public has a right to know if something's happening. Some of your communities all will have or should have very clearly spelled out notice requirements. Any person who's a party to an action should have an opportunity to make their case in front of the Planning Commission so part of the procedural due process is the opportunity to be heard. Full disclosure, I'll talk about that a little bit when we get to the application materials.

21:37 You as a Planning Commissioner or those who are before you seeking something from a Planning Commission are required to disclose all information that's available so you can't hold anything back that would have a bearing on a case. Completeness of information, we'll talk about that when we get into the materials that come to you as a Planning Commission. You have the right as a Planning Commissioner to ensure that you're given all the information.

22:02 And it's complete when an application is submitted. You often hear applicants complain, well, staff's holding me up. They haven't yet deemed my application to be complete. That's because you as a planning commissioner have the right to only get material that's fully complete and not something that's still half-baked or half-baked. Ex parte communications. Did they talk about this at all at the earlier reception? Basically what that means is

22:27 You're a Planning Commissioner, Joe comes before you seeking an action on the development project. He can't corral you with a local Starbucks and say, Joe, can I talk to you about my case and tell you what, you know, give you some information. And it's often a difficult thing, particularly if you live in a smaller community and, you know, you know somebody who's before you, you still have to basically say, I'm sorry, and we can't talk about that because it's the problem, you know.

22:55 Procedural duty. You don't have to say it's because of ex-parte communications. You just say ethically and legally, I really am not allowed to talk to you privately about a matter before you. Unbiased decisions, timeliness, I think, are pretty self-explanatory. Timeliness, particularly, it says that if a matter comes before a planning commission, the reason that timeliness are set is that people have the right to...

23:21 And finally, findings of fact. You can't just make a decision because it's kind of what I think. Gee, this is what we decided as a Planning Commission, but we're not going to tell you why. And you'll often hear about this from staff that in your resolutions, they need to be fairly clear as to we are approving this application for the following reasons. It's consistent with our plan or we're denying it because it's not consistent with the following things.

23:49 needs to be clearly stated on the record of why you're doing what you're doing. So this is a little bit of a mind spinning list of why you do what you do.

24:02 One thing that's really important to understand about being a planning commissioner is that out of all the commissions that the town has, we're the only ones that have a legal responsibility and a legal foundation. So it does set our responsibilities apart just like a notch above everybody else because of that. And the process is really important. So I just wanted to see if there was any questions about these two slides. Do you want to make...

24:31 It's probably too hard to go back to the other side of it. But, you know, our town staff does a phenomenal job of all the notice requirements and agendas. But the one point here that I guess there's really two points.

24:49 about the ex parte communication and we'll be talking about that later on. I'm sure they'll do their annual ethics training and you'll hear a lot about that when we ultimately do ethics training. But the findings of fact is a really big issue because this is how we make our decisions but even often our applicants come forward.

25:11 And they'll give you reasons why we should prove something that isn't really the finding of fact. So it's always a little confusing what maybe their reason is, but what we'll ultimately make our decision about. And one of the things I'm really hoping to accomplish going forward is that after our public hearings and then after we do a vote, that as a commission we get much better at really explaining to the public

25:41 Why, what our findings were, so that it's very clear and concise. Sometimes, you know, you read about them in the paper afterwards, and it's like, well, we all have the same meeting here. So I think if we do a better job recapping what we based our decisions off of our findings, then it just makes for a community that's more informed. But I just, was there any questions about that first part of the presentation? I just had a question with what you just talked about regarding findings.

26:10 and recapping for the media to make it clear. Is it something, I mean, is it appropriate to, to not write the article, but to submit a summary to the media so that that is what gets printed and not... Well, you know, it's something that's interesting because, you know, I thought about this, I don't think I've ever mentioned this, Sandra, when...

26:35 Roy Sari was a commissioner. He would write an article for the local papers once a month and recap what happened. And I thought, you know, there might be some good, real, positive reasons to do that. Again, I just don't personally want to write it because I don't like to write. I mean, that's my... So, if there's ultimately a volunteer, but, you know, maybe it...

27:03 It's something that we might discuss when we start dividing up commissioners and duties, if somebody wants to take that on. I think if it was kind of a group project where ultimately two or three people really participated, then the burden wouldn't be on any one person. But it probably would be a really good idea. Let me just give you an example.

27:32 When John Hooper came forward for his approval up by Canyon Lodge, we were approving it on a variance, and a variance is a very legal description of what a variance is, and it's basically based off if you have two parcels of lands adjacent to each other, and one parcel of land is at a disadvantage versus another parcel, then that parcel could be...

28:01 Entitled to a variance in the parcel of land that Mr. Hooper had before us had, I think the total slope was like 17 feet from the high point to the low point. So there was truly a disadvantage because of the grade of the parcel. But when the applicant was forwarded before us, you know, he was saying, well, he wanted higher garage doors. I mean, so, I mean, it was an interesting hearing to sit through, okay, but...

28:29 But we as commissioners did not make our decision based off of his desire to have bigger garages. We were making the decision off of the physical configuration of the land. And I think, so those are the things that if we really explain in what we base our decisions off to the public, then it makes the public really understand what the basis of our decisions are. I don't know if you have any comments on that, Sandra, or not. I think that, ooh, shoot. Uh-oh. Do we need a motion for a break? No, no, no, I'm all right.

28:59 I got it. Thank you. We do provide the media with information on, you know, the projects after the meeting, so oftentimes they'll call us to ask how, you know, how a project turned out. Sometimes they're not here, that kind of thing, so we do provide them with information on projects as well to try to clarify and try to make it clear. The minutes usually aren't done by the time they publish their paper, so, because they usually do it like the day after the meeting, so.

29:26 But we do try to respond to questions, especially on complex projects. I think it might also be smart if you do want to do a summary. Yeah, that would be good. And then since Sandra brought up minutes, because all our meetings are recorded through Granicus, so there's a detailed recording, then our actual minutes, as you know, are, you call them summary minutes, right, Pam? Summary action minutes. Summary action minutes. So our minutes, the written minutes are not detailed.

30:06 Because of that. Because it's already all completely recorded on the ground at this. Are you okay over there? I'm okay. Thank you. You need a second cup of coffee? I know. I just have a sense that these types of decisions that you make, you need to be aware that you have a lot of discretion as a planning commission in those instances, which really are pretty narrowly bound by what we can do. Starting over on the screen right, where you really don't have discretion and...

30:54 Public comment or sentiment from the community really doesn't matter very much. This is Joe's graphic, which involves administrative matters. Building permits, which some planning commissions get involved in. Interpretation of code, which may come to you from a staff level. Basically, if an application meets the requirement for building permit, you've got to issue it. There's no discretion about that. All the way over to the screen left.

31:19 If you're involved in a comprehensive plan or you're providing recommendations on zoning regulations, then you have a lot of discretion to really think about what is our policy, what should our policy be, and the public community at large has greater bearing on setting that policy framework. In the middle are those things where there's some judgment call and say it's a subdivision.

31:48 There's some judgment calls to whether or not it's appropriate, but you're still, you need to look at the requirements and what the code says, so it's sort of the middle ground. So that's a very, that's sort of, I did in 12 minutes what I think Don and Greg did in 75, and my purpose here again wasn't to say you don't need to become land use lawyers.

32:10 Good morning, everyone. I've been practicing planning in this state for about 38 years.

32:44 When you go back home and tell people it was raining nonstop, never like this. This meeting was in Seattle. I'm a planning consultant these days. One of the things I do as a planning consultant is a certain amount of pro bono work, working with our State Department of Commerce, our State Planning Association of Washington, the Washington Chapter of the American Planning Association, and a program called Short Course in Local Planning. What we do is to go out communities across the state.

33:12 Spend an evening with three speakers in panel format talking about the issues we're talking about today. There also are a number of videos that we've recorded that are on the website of the State Department of Commerce. We'll give you some links at the end of the session today. We've really tried to put the information and knowledge of how to be a Planning Commissioner in the hands of people that need to know it. If you can come to an evening meeting and ask questions and listen to the presentation, that's great. But we found a lot of people learn fast or in their bathroom or their computer in their bed at 10 o'clock at night. So the videos help.

33:42 Think of that in a way of learning and teaching people. Before I was a consultant, I was a planning director for three different cities for about 18 years. I was also a staff member in cities for about 10 years on top of that. I estimated one time that I've attended or staffed about 800 planning commission meetings. So I've seen a lot of planning commission meetings. I've seen a lot of behaviors. I've seen really good behaviors. I've seen less good behaviors. I've got a number of tips, practice tips. It's part of what I will present to you today about what, in my opinion,

34:11 What works well, where are their issues, how to think about your roles as planning commissioners, in addition to and apart from what your legal requirements are. Anybody recognize this image? No? No prize. This cover of the Saturday Evening Post. How would you describe what's going on in this image? Freedom of speech. What's the speaker doing? Do they necessarily agree with you?

35:02 The fellow with the glasses of the upper left there is probably getting ready to rebut whatever the speaker has to say. I know, right. It's the nature of this process. God bless America. People get to step to the lectern and tell you what they think. The youth planning commissioners have an obligation to listen to what they have. Respectfully, we don't have to agree with them. This is how we would like our public to look like this or feel like this. They don't literally look like this. This is actually the Italian Parliament. So there's a passion in their legislative process, too. But hopefully we have more decorum. We have more respect.

35:42 We have more control. The role of the chair is critical in making sure everyone has a chance to say what they have to say. Be heard. Clapping, cheering, jeering. That is not respectful. Listening. So how do we get to the point in your process of Planning Commission hearings and meetings? Well, let's not like that first image. You as commissioners are part of a team. You're a team at the city or the county where you're a commissioner. The other key members of your team are the elected officials and, of course, the staff. Professional staff who work with you.

36:19 Work for you, provide recommendations to you, and each of you has a distinct role. And in practice, where I see problems in systems, in cities, in counties, is where people kind of get outside to play a role and try to play the role of one of the other members of the team. But you've got a shared mission. You're all about the same thing. What is that? Well, you're all there to serve the citizens of your community, the future, you care about the past, you all share that. It has values, you want to work together to build a greater county, a greater city.

36:57 Most of your communities have some kind of mission statement. That's what you're all there for. Now you may have other agendas, values, that's fine, but what you share is this mission. The graphics that tries to summarize who the three major players in your organization are doing land use planning in your community. Council members are elected. Most planning commissions, at least in this state, are not elected, are appointed. Planning commissions are appointed policy advisors. I know in some states planning commissions actually decide they adopt comprehensive plans.

37:33 In the state of Washington, they do not. They provide a recommendation on to the elected officials. But the elected officials can't take action until they get a recommendation. And in the third group, of course, the professional planning staff who are hired policy administrators. And they do more than that. I'll go into a little more detail about what they do in a little bit here. But the point of this graphic is that each of them has prerogatives. The prerogative of the electives is we decide, at least in this state, we appoint. We announce the budgets. We enter the lawsuits. We pay the judgments. That's our role.

38:03 Thank you. Thank you.

38:36 It's kind of a tough ethic, but I think most of us are really happy with that. Well, again, elected officials make policy, by that I mean plans, regulations, they represent in our county, the citizens who elect them, many western states are hired by the council in those cities. The strong mayor for them, the mayor is the executive, he is the person, or she is the person who is the hiring, firing, administering policy that's made by the elected officials. The council members as they appoint the commissioners to the planning commission.

39:35 They give direction to the work program, what they're going to be spending time on, and then they have to allocate the resources to help achieve it. And that could be staff resources, it could be consultant resources, it could be meeting resources, it could be equipment, it could be travel, it could be training, to any places like this. Resources to get the job done that they need us to do. To take final action on all legislative matters, the graphic you saw a minute ago that Ben was showing you, comprehensive plans, regulations, capital budgets, the rules, the big pictures.

40:04 That's what they take final action on, legislative matters. Now, in many legislative matters, the commissions make recommendations. Here's what the rules ought to look like. Here's what the regulations ought to say. Here's why. Also, council members take final action on quasi-judicial matters that your local code says they take action on. In some places, in the state of Washington, quasi-judicial matters like a subdivision or a rezone or a conditional use permit. That decision can be made by a hearing examiner, sort of a specialized judge hired by the city to have those quasi-judicial hearings.

40:35 Wayfax, reach conclusions, make a decision. Many cities, though, prefer to have a council make that final decision on those permit kinds of decisions. I know there are a couple of elected officials present, but for all of you who are not elected officials, I think this is a reasonable thing for you to go back to your community and say, elected officials, here's a bunch of things we hope for from you, we need from you, your obligations to us. We'll respect and support our role. And that can mean many things. If the council has a redundant public hearing on every item that

41:07 Sandra and I talked about this beforehand. So can you legally check to see if in the state of California that there has to be...

41:30 Public hearings both at the commission and the council level. I know we talked about that. For all legislative items, yes. So items like maps, those kinds of things, the final hearing is with the commission. But for legislative items, our code specifically requires it as well. So like a change to the zoning code or the general plan, the commission makes a recommendation of the council, they make the final decision. But it was more of holding the two public hearings else.

41:54 Oh, the fact that the commission holds a public hearing. And our municipal code says that the council has to hold a public hearing as well. Okay. So, all right. Thank you.

42:41 They need to use the same facts that are in your record below. But depending on the issue, depending on whether it's legislative or not legislative, there's a lot more room for them to have a different conclusion about what the right decision is on policy, whether it's a building hide or a use district, use designations, or whatever it might be. Over time, again, if the council can agree with the commission, my advice to council members is if you can't, agree. Don't nitpick. They have a right to do, and the commission needs to understand they are not always going to view creators. They didn't listen to us. The fact is they didn't agree with us.

43:23 Just as you don't have to agree with the staff. None of you have to agree with the public. You have to listen to the public, but ultimately you're making a judgment or recommendation based on your to do is. My advice to council is when you disagree with them, take the time to explain why you disagree. You don't have to argue with the commission. You don't have to convince the commission, but you need to explain why you reach a different conclusion, because there may be other issues in the future where understanding the council's mind and why these kind of issues would be like periodic feedback, communication.

43:58 Meeting jointly at least once or twice a year. I think it's a great idea so you understand each other. From familiarity comes trust and respect. The time to do this is not always a major controversy, raging, where you have a disagreement with the council and now you have a joint meeting with all of these stakeholders who strongly disagree with one of the other sides in the audience. It really stifles an honest exchange of ideas between the electeds and the appointeds. My advice is build that relationship, maintain a relationship over time so that you know who they are, you know who you are.

44:28 There are things you can talk about outside the heat of an issue that's imminent. I think that, again, builds for a better, longer relationship. Okay, what about the Planning Commission? So, from my perspective, I think Planning Commission currently has a really good working relationship with council, and we will do joint workshops from time to time. The thing that's difficult, and Sandra can comment on this, is that

45:00 At times, we will, as a commission, review the planning and economic development department's workload, and then we establish our priorities. And then, you know, I mean, we have a very efficient, what I would term a very efficient government right now. We do not have any extra people. So sometimes, every time something, a new priority comes up for council, and then the workload has to be, you know.

45:25 Realigned. I mean, there's no new person to do that work. So it's a little bit frustrating because we'll say, okay, well, these are all our priorities. This is how we want to do this. And then rightly so, things come up for council and then the workload gets resorted. I don't know if you want to comment on that or not. Yeah, and I think that during the joint meetings that you've discussed that with council. So I think they have heard and understand.

45:51 And I think that, you know, at the last council meeting, joint council meeting, I think we presented our work program, and I think that's helpful as well. And it's for good reason. I mean, you know, as you all know right now, transient rentals is a big priority for council, so they've had to use a lot of allocation of staff time, so some of the priorities that we had currently put as A priorities are now resorted to B and C priorities. But it's not that they don't listen to us, it's just that...

46:20 Reality of the situation. Right? Yep. Plans are made. Some cases are recommended to the governing body, the electives, what they ought to adopt. And then some other plans that your community, depending on your community, might be asking you to review. Functional plans. Some places there are park master plans, fire department master plans, utility master plans. Some cities, some counties have a role for their commissions in reviewing some of those plans. Development permit review, Ben's going to talk a bit more about this shortly.

46:57 But in many places, make a recommendation on to the governing body about the permit. Again, big difference between legislative plan making, lots of values, lots of subjective judgment as to what should the plan say, what should the regulation say. When you get down to applying those to individual permit applications, there's a lot less room for subjectivity for judgment. There still is some, and it's usually prescribed, hopefully, by your code, which tells you what the criteria is for this kind of permit, this kind of decision.

47:28 Again, policy advisors, it's your role as commissioners. You solicit, hear, and weigh the input you get from the public. As citizens of the community, you have history, you have experience, you have values. You bring that in perspective to review items that come before the Planning Commission. So what the staff has to say is almost always a staff report with some sort of recommendation, certainly the facts describing what the issue is, things you should be paying attention to, their criteria that govern the items in front of you, what those are. Then, as a commission,

48:02 Make a recommendation or decision depending upon what the code says about your role on that particular idea. You have to support the council's prerogatives. The chief one is they make the ultimate decision on budgets. They make the ultimate decision on creating additional permits that the code assigns to them. Most places they make the final decision on plans and regulations. They said they don't have to agree with you. As a staff person for many years, the worst sound I could ever hear I didn't bring a problem on would be a manila envelope being ripped open.

48:38 At the beginning of the meeting, you need to do the homework before you get to the meeting. Lots of reasons for that. Give careful consideration and weight to everything you hear, public testimony you see from people. How do you work as a collaborative body, a deliberative body with your peers on the commission? Treat everybody with respect, learn to persuade rather than argue. Some of the best decisions I've seen commissions make in my career have been where there may be some disagreement as to

49:14 Preliminary inclusion is not an issue, but over time, talking things through, being able to reach a decision that most of them support, which is pretty sound, because it's been tugged on and beaten on by different perspectives for a while. So what comes out the other end of the decision-making issue is a better decision. Now, you can have disagreement, you can even vote no on it. I'll be on the loose again, and I'm sure that's happened to all of you once or twice. But I think the process works much better if you bring an open mind to the process.

49:43 Deliberate with your peers. At the end of that meeting, you haven't heard from the public yet. They may say something in the record that is important to you might shift your thinking on an issue. So keep an open mind until it's time to take a vote. Now give appropriate evidence to the staff's technical expertise. This is an important thing. Staffs are trained as planners. They study this stuff. They go to school. They come to training. They know a lot of stuff, especially technical stuff. If it's a legislative matter and the staff makes a recommendation, that's different than

50:18 The staff is saying level of service at this corner of the road is this number. Or here's the law of hydrodynamics and here's how it will affect the slope stability in this site development. Differentiate between very subjective value-lating kinds of recommendations and technical. When it comes to the value-lating, what do we think, what do we want in our community? You're an expert as much as the staff is. In fact, you're probably more of an expert than the staff is because you probably live there longer than some of your staff has.

50:49 When it gets to, it's a technical question, the level of service at this intersection is going to be X, if we put this many cars at the intersection, there's not a lot of subjectivity there, it's a fact, or close to being a fact. Staff has many roles to play, they meet the public at the counter, they give information out about everything to do with your community, land use, the process, who you are, with permit acting. So, on that part about respecting your fellow commissioners when we come to make a motion on something,

51:22 One thing that I think is a very poor practice is to try to draft a new motion from the dais. I mean, it's okay if we're just making a small phrase change, but if it starts to get pretty complicated, then it's really, I think, just better to...

51:42 Continue that item until the next meeting. And what that does is really allow Sandra to really write out the motion so that we can all look at it appropriately. But just to try to say, okay, for the sake of getting through that item at this meeting and make a two or three sentence, you know, draft the proposed motion is pretty difficult to do. The other thing that can happen is if when you review your packet,

52:10 And if you have a really strong feeling about if you thought maybe the motion can be changed and if you talk to Sandra about that beforehand, then she's like prepared. But just to be doing it on the fly up here is really difficult to do it correctly and to make sure we haven't had any unintended consequences by our actions. I don't know if you have any comments about that.

52:33 It seems like it often happens with conditions. Yeah. You know, the commission will be talking and then an issue will come up and then let's do this condition. And so sometimes as we're listening, we can draft conditions so that we can move the project forward. And it's really at the pleasure of the commission whether you want to, you know, try to do some of them, like one or two, we can try to kind of do that. But if there's a slew of condition changes or changing, you know, project changes that the commission...

52:59 And wants to see it generally is better to continue it so that the applicant has an opportunity to consider it. But sometimes it's just a minor thing like changing the color from a dark brown to a medium brown. Right. We can do that kind of thing on the fly, I think. Make sense? Mm-hmm. Did you have any comments about that, Pam, since you're so often have? No, I agree with what you said. Right. Okay. All right. So let's see what staff's going to do. All that stuff.

53:31 To the Commission, to the Council, based upon their own experience, questions from them, for them, about an issue, might come to you, you say, I need more information, staff, can you go off and bring us this information? What do other cities do on this issue? What did we do on this kind of similar issue four years ago? They have an obligation, it's a duty, it's their job, to support you by doing the research you ask them to do, to help you do your job. This is an important one, too. They carry messages, at least in this state, the Commission makes a recommendation, adopt signings of faculty conclusions.

54:04 The staff, typically, is the one that presents staff to elected officials. Occasionally, the Planning Commission will send the Planning Commission Chair or someone else in the Commission to help present the recommendation. But in many cases, it's just the staff. Here's what the Commission recommended. And the staff has to take off their advocate role. They may have made a recommendation to the Commission that the Commission didn't agree with. Well, the staff takes off the recommendation role, puts on, carries the Commission's recommendation forward and transmits it and explains it as well as they can, even if they didn't, even if they didn't, as the staff agreed with it.

54:37 The staff will carry their recommendation forward and advocate for it and explain it as well as they can, even if it wasn't what they would argue of being a staff person sometimes. That's enforcing the law. Again, the greatest pushback in local government seems to be when somebody's being told they can't do something or they have to stop doing something. And the person who's been telling them that is the staff. That administers and enforces the codes that are adopted by the legislative body. Typically, the staff doesn't adopt codes and ordinances.

55:14 So it needs to be understood that when you make a policy or a regulation, you rely on your staff to explain that to people at the front counter to carry it out in enforcement of the city's codes. Again, they're administrators, they're enforcers. Make sure your process is adequate. Take care of notice, all that sort of stuff. Maintain the record. In many cases, we'll give you a professional recommendation and take care to make sure that you're making choices, able to choose, explain what the merits or the merits of each might be.

55:58 Professional Recordations based on good facts and best practices. It's policy advising role and the council's policy making role. The prerogative not to be with staff. And then finally, when questions come up, staff has an obligation to give you a timely, complete, responsive to your question, kind of an answer. Okay, so shifting moves from staff roles, commission roles, council roles, who will I be at the point. Each of you can't succeed unless all of you succeed. Be effective unless each of you plays your role and supports one another in your respective roles.

56:47 Long-range planning, though, and implementation is the next topic here. The Royal Planning Commission in the plan making, oversight, plan development, adoption and a recommendation to the governing body. As I said earlier, we have other plans that the council asked you to look at. Just some examples of different comprehensive plans, different places. Some places are called a comprehensive plan. In California, it's called a general plan. Some states, they call it a national plan. I think I came across one state that calls it a comprehensive general national plan.

57:18 The idea is a policy document. The structure of the plan varies from place to place. Typically, they deal with facilities, transportation facilities, utility facilities, land use, of course, natural environment, open space. Many places have optional elements. The state of Washington, you have the authority to adopt additional elements. Some have a sustainability element. Some have a cultural element. So, it's governed by whatever your state statute says.

57:52 The visual suspects will show up as chapters. Vision, the front end, in this state, every comprehensive plan starts with a vision, which is a very high-level, global sense of what's the most important thing about our community, what are the values, what is the preferred future outcome, in a very general, global narrative, which helps it for what you say to different chapters, functional chapters of your plan. The language element leads to this state, you've got to actually show how obvious grapple ground is designated for some use or range of uses.

58:27 Goals and policies, most plans consistent.

59:01 The words as well as maps. The words are usually either their policy statements. This is just a quick overview. Goals typically are aspirational. They give direction. They're big picture. They may describe the desired outcome. Policies are how you get there. Policies are specific objectives you might set, specific actions you might take, directing the city or the community to do some things in the service of that goal. This is the structure of goals and policies. Now, where is the fine line between what is the goal of its policy?

59:30 Sometimes you'll come up with a value statement or something you want to have happen, and it's not clear to you whether that's a full statement or a valid statement. But it helps facilitate that discussion if you ask yourself, does this give me direction as to what I should be doing? On the top, implementation is on the bottom, comprehensive plans, vision is a big input. In this state, most states, stature requirements are going to be a big input. They tell you what must be in it, how do you do it, who does it, all that sort of stuff. That's an influence, but vision is what makes your plan different than anybody.

1:00:08 Plans are implemented basically in three ways. One is to regulations, could be your land use code, your zoning code, your subdivision code, regulations control, and then regulations to capital budgets, public projects, could be roads, could be parks, could be public buildings, could be utilities, could be surface water management facilities, could be many things, but if it's built, operated, maintained by some public agency, the city, the county, the district, it's a capital project. And then finally, the grab bag of other actions.

1:00:48 Anything that's not a regulation or capital budget project, it's a program. This could be tax policy, this could be, in this state we have the authority for local governments to have open space, taxation revenue, policy rather to encourage open space to maintain, they can exempt property taxes for up to 10 years in exchange for a certain percentage of units in a project being moderate income housing, building housing. So there are different tools, different programs, volunteer programs, partnerships with other jurisdictions, private partnerships.

1:01:17 There's a whole range of things that you could talk about in your plan that are important to you to move towards your goals and vision, but that might be something you really rely upon others to help do or in partnership with others. These are just images, regulations, shape private projects, commercial, residential, institutional, you name it. The shape, orientation, all the details of private projects is controlled by regulations. Public budgets, as I said, design, build, maintain, use.

1:01:50 Arrange facilities, transit stations, the parks, the pools, the schools, the roads, the trails, the utilities, and finally I mentioned public-private partnerships, other kinds of policies like tax policies, volunteerism, you can encourage volunteers to go out, rip the ivy off of trees in city parks to help the trees survive longer term, things that really improve the reach of the policies and goals of your plan without doing it just with the tools and regulations that have been on development review.

1:02:30 So, by now, I think it's clear, both in your experience or in the materials we've talked about so far, that Planning Commissioners have two, really comes down to two primary roles, plan making and development review. And I'm sure you all love development review, right? It's the favorite part of you.

1:02:54 How many of you, I mean, would you say that about half of your time as a Planning Commission is spent on comprehensive plan, plan making, or development review? How many of you think you pretty much balance your time between plan making and development review? Any of you? How many of you spend 95% of your time on development review? Or 90, you know, the majority of your time on development review? Okay, a lot of you. It's really interesting if you...

1:03:21 So some of our past commissions spent a majority of their time doing plan making. Where I see where we are at as a commission now,

1:03:41 A lot of that plan making is done. I mean, after all, we're basically a town of four square miles. I mean, there's only so much plan making we can do. And so what I think we're really going to now hit is a phase of a lot of a development review. I don't know if you wanted to comment on that. Yeah, I think it's gone in phases. I mean, back in the boom, the commission was meeting twice a month and seeing big, huge projects coming through. And then, yeah, we went through the kind of the planning phase. And now, like you said, we're pretty much...

1:04:11 Down with planning, we are moving forward with a general plan and the zoning code amendment for the floor-air ratio and adopting the mobility element. That will come before the commission. But other than that, there's not a lot of plans that are changing at this point. The act basically establishes the basis of a planning commission and establishes the basis of what a planning commission does. When you read the act, there's no mention in the act of development review. The primary...

1:04:40 The initial purpose of a Planning Commission was to make plans. There was no anticipation. Of course, there was no zoning yet, so they may have a good deal to do with that, but the purpose was to help a community set its vision and carry forth that vision. And as Joe mentioned, even if you read the Planning Enabling Act, it talks about the reason for doing that was so that the elected officials could get out of the job running the business of the city. But the Planning Commission, the whole notion was...

1:05:08 For citizens that come together and provide that vision and guidance. An interesting trend as a planner that may be encouraging one today is the importance of the plan is coming back in a fashion. And there's a couple of reasons why one is scarce resources. So people are taking that question where they want to go with the community more seriously. And how many of you have communities that do outcome-based budgeting for outcomes?

1:05:37 I look at Fort Collins, Colorado. They used what's called budgeting for outcomes. The staff used to call it a big, heavy ordeal. They did a two-year budget and every year council had seven budgeting categories and each department needed to basically go into their plans and turn them around and upside down and restructure them according to the council's budgeting categories. Four years ago, Fort Collins shifted.

1:06:06 Their plan, or updated their plan, is structured in the same seven categories as the budget. So now you have a very strong alignment between setting policy and making decisions about implementation. It saved everybody a lot of work, but it also really heightened the role of the plan, because the plan and policy now drives how money is spent. How many of you live in communities that have metrics, or like an indicator of dashboard, performance measures?

1:06:35 Anybody? So, other cities are also student study? Do we have that? Huh? Do we have that? Well, we have a community. We don't have the outcomes-based budgeting. I mean, when he's talking about indicators, I mean, we have, we go through projects, and when we do the budget, we do talk about our work program, how that aligns, and I think that the goal of this, the council's priorities, this kind of work is intended.

1:07:03 To align with the budget. So I think we're kind of moving towards a more outcomes-based budget, but I don't think we would move to what Collins was doing. Do the same thing, basically setting up their monitoring program or the measures of how it's really important to understand because many of you know it's just a big part of what you do. And as Jim talks about in terms of roles and responsibilities, if you understand how this is done, it can be done more efficiently. There is hope. How many planning are chairs?

1:07:48 Good, okay, because you, as Joe mentioned earlier, you guys are the key to doing this well and having it not run until 1, 2 in the morning or 3-hour hearings on a particular application. So I'm not going to spend as much time on the substance, the content of what's in a development application because it's, as Joe mentioned, it's technical, but we are going to talk about the process of how we think the development review process can work effectively for you as a planning commissioner.

1:08:18 And chairs, take notes. Hopefully you're all doing this already. Those of you who are not, might be a future chair or say, gee, we don't do this, we don't conduct ourselves this way at all. Maybe go back and talk amongst yourselves and say, what can we do to make our jobs easier and more efficient? What can we do to make the process less brain damage for everyone who's involved? Because it really can be contentious. It can take way more time than it needs to.

1:08:46 So let's talk a little bit about how the process works, what your role is in the development review process, what the role of others is in the process, and then what to do with that big envelope that Joe talked about that you will get with a draft a week before your meeting. Some of them I've seen, literally seen, planning commissioners get invited to this day every week. I don't know, you know, I see some nodding heads. It really is a daunting task. The question is, how do you deal with that in a way that this

1:09:17 Why did I ever agree to this job? And there are some ways to go about it. So, a little bit, before you even get that big hack, it helps to understand what the steps are in the process, just so you understand what's been done before it gets into your hands. Typically, Joe has property and he wants to do something with it where he represents someone.

1:09:41 He'll sit down with the staff and they'll say, this is what we want to do, what do I need to put together, how does it fit with the policies, how should I put my application together, so that's really the first step in the process. Usually it's pretty informal, there's no decisions made, it's advisory, and then the applicant says, okay, I'm ready to get my project moving, I'm going to file an application. Your staff should have, when they most do.

1:10:09 A checklist that says this is what you need for this type of application. If they don't, you really have to talk to them about that because it's very, I've seen communities that for the requirements are really not clearly spelled out and part of the problem can make this so challenging. Then the application is reviewed for completeness. Again, going back to due process, you have the right as a planning commissioner to get full, complete information about what you're being asked to do.

1:10:36 The reason that staff are often so particular about that is to make sure that they have everything that's required, that it's presented accurately and factually, in a factually correct manner, and that there are no surprises during the hearing process where there's no information that's provided to you. So all of this is done before you can get any of this stuff. They'll set it at a hearing date or a review date for the Planning Commission.

1:11:01 If the action requires a public hearing, it'll be advertised, post assigned to the property if that's a requirement, and then you get the offload. So all this stuff happens before it's even in your hands. So when do you do that? You'll get to the Planning Commission hearing. Joe mentioned having read your packet ahead of time. You don't need to read every word, but I think you need to gain some familiarity with it.

1:11:28 Planning staff, typically this is the way the process will work. Your situation may vary depending on your community, but generally it'll look something like this. There'll be a staff report, and it's for your benefit, but it's also for the benefit of the public. What is this project about? And the factual information, but then also usually they'll present their recommendations.

1:11:54 And here's the Planning Commission, they're given an opportunity to ask questions with staff, clarify what you said about this, or tell me about that, or what I reviewed through the materials, I didn't see such and such. So that's really your first instance to, and it's really a clarifying question, making sure you understand the material before you. And usually, not always the case, but usually then the proponent, whether it's the property owner or the representative,

1:12:20 They're able to then present material, present information to you about the project. One of the things, my experience, I haven't, Joe, I think you said 800 meetings, I'm nowhere near that number. My condolences to you for that. I don't know why there's any staff you can do this now. But one of, I think, one of the ways to make your job more efficient, and there's nothing worse than having a staff report, and then the applicant stands up and starts presenting the same information.

1:12:50 One of the ways that you can make the process more efficient is to provide clear direction. Sometimes, you know, it's not necessarily a thing to do at the meeting, but talk with your staff and say, gee, guys, can we have efficient presentations? How many of you have sat through an hour long?

1:13:09 Staff report, applicant report, before you even get into questions. Anybody? Yeah. So it doesn't have to be that hard. They don't need to repeat each other's information. They don't need to read the report to you. So some guidance behind the scenes of how to manage that part of it is that the meetings don't go to 2 a.m. It can often be an effective way to make the process work. Yeah. Yeah.

1:14:00 So I guess what comes to mind is just the facts, ma'am. That's the purpose of the staff who work then with a recommendation. So then this is the public hearing or the public portion of the report. So usually you'll have the opportunity to ask questions of the applicant. Again, focus on clarifying the questions. It's not yet time to pull out your soapbox.

1:14:23 Tell them whether you agree with them or not. The purpose of the question is to say, you know, you said such and such, can you provide a little bit more information about that? You're not yet delivering, you're basically gathering information. Then the public has an opportunity to speak their piece. Some communities do it if you're in favor, you'll get to go first if you're opposed. Sometimes it's just anyone can get up and say whatever they want. That's, you know, local, custom, local practice.

1:14:50 Sometimes, then, the applicant has an opportunity to rebut, and this, again, is the prerogative of the chair, typically, to say, what is not useful, in my opinion, is to say, okay, the applicant gets a shot to rebut everything that was just said. That should not be, it's not a good use of time, and it's not an appropriate role and step in the process. The role of an additional comment is for you, the chair, to say,

1:15:18 Such and such came up, would you please address that, but not to just give them the floor and let them just go at it again. That's not the way the process should work. Finally then, it's deliberation time. It's discussion amongst yourselves, and I emphasize it amongst yourselves. Once the comment portion of the meeting is closed, you've heard from the public, you've heard from the applicant, it's not a discussion between you and the audience. It's not a discussion between you and the applicant.

1:15:46 It's a discussion among commissioners. You've gathered the information you need, and now you have some deliberative body. You need to talk about it, you know, and make sure you understand it. And I think it shows that you did not argue with each other, but to understand and explain. And then, just a second, then you, then it's time at some point, if your chair is very effective, get a call for a motion and discussion of the motion in action. Yes, sir.

1:16:13 So do you want to stop for a second? So this is really, this is exactly the procedure that we follow for our public hearings. I just want to make a couple of comments. So staff presents their report, and it's really important, I will ask each commissioner if you have any questions. Those questions are for, quote, staff at that time. It's not a time to start making general comments. And then,

1:16:42 Remember, everything is televised, and especially now, we have these cameras that, you know, focus, autofocus, and so then the applicant comes up to the podium, okay, and they're going to do their presentation, and then I'm going to ask each commissioner, do you want to have, do you have any questions for the applicant? What gets to be really confusing is that if, I mean, sometimes

1:17:08 You know, you can't help, but try to be really organized about your questions, okay, because if you got, if the applicant sits down and then you ask a question, you know, of Sandra and then you got a question for the applicant and then you got the applicant jumping back up, I mean, you just got to keep in mind that this is being televised. So initially it's the questions for the staff, then it's the questions for the applicants. It's not a time.

1:17:34 I mean, unless...

1:18:00 At times we've had like a homeowners association and you have one person that's very well spoken for the homeowners association and if everybody in the audience agrees that they want that person to continue to represent what they as a homeowners association what they have I'll let that person continue but we try to really stick to the three minute timeline and I really ask that if somebody comes up in the audience and

1:18:30 You know, you want to have a dialogue with that person from the audience that is called doing it through the chair. Because in essence, it's not an open dialogue between the dais and the audience. It's a public comment period where we're supposed to be just really, you know, receiving input. But let's say, Dawn, you had some sort of confusion about what somebody would just say. You go through the chair. Can I ask?

1:18:59 So and so this question. Kind of make sense? Once the public comment period, this is really important, is closed, it's closed. So even if we continue that meeting to another date for some reason later on, we would not do another public comment period. So we always try to give people a lot of opportunity to say, is there anybody else in the public that has anything else to say? But we would not do another public comment.

1:19:27 And then, of course, part of our public comments are sometimes the emails that we receive. And you always make hard copies of the emails, right? Okay. And then, ultimately, then, that is a really good point, because I always just tell the applicant that they have any final comments. But I probably, in the future meetings, would just really say, you know, if you have any clarification on a particular point, rather, right.

1:19:58 You know, each person then will go through our comments and our deliberations before the motion. So since that is the procedure, the process that we use, I just want to make sure that we're clear. Did you have anything to expound on that, Sandra? And then just once the motion is made and there's a second, then the discussion is usually just about that motion and clarifying and that kind of thing. So at that point, it's really there's a motion on the table and a vote needs to be taken.

1:20:27 The discussion kind of moves just to the motion. Does that make sense? So the second to last bullet point is when you really want us to have the open discussion, view our personal opinions on the matter at hand. Right. So this, and a public hearing is obviously much more formal than a business matter. You know, if it's a business matter, it's a little different process because there's not usually the legal ramifications as there is in a public hearing.

1:20:59 So a public hearing, we try to keep to that process. Good? All right. You know, when we get to the question... I'm not sure if you all can hear us, I'll repeat the question. This question is, if during the public comment, I think I fine understand your question, if someone raises something, do you as a planning commissioner, is it appropriate for them to ask that person? The answer is yes, but it should be routed through the chair. It should be a free-for-all. So, you know, the way I've seen that done well is that...

1:21:39 Joe's Planning Commissioner, I'm the chair, he might say, you know, Mr. Chairman, it would be appropriate, I'd like to ask the person a question, but again, I've also seen it go handled very poorly, but then the Planning Commissioner wants to debate the citizen, well, I disagree with what you said, and that's not appropriate, what is appropriate is to say, you know, so-and-so said that there is a school within 100 feet, and that's not information, so would you please clarify? So again, the purpose of questions from, I want to make sure I answer.

1:22:16 Thank you.

1:24:56 And those usually are appealable, and usually they're appealable to the body above planning commission. So planning commission already in the site plan, the applicant has the right to appeal that decision according to specific procedures in the timeline. So your role, we've covered most of this, but just to kind of summarize, and a couple of things that I didn't mention in the formal parts of the process, your homework, and show up knowing what you're going to be asked to decide on that evening.

1:25:31 If you have the chance, the site, some planning commissions will organize tours. If you have seen some planning commissions, if they might have three or four items, they'll say, you know, if you can, the Tuesday prior to the planning board, we're going to run a, we'll give you out the van and the staff will be there answering questions you might have, which, and if the community doesn't do that, it's often useful to go out and take a look at the site, listen carefully, and

1:26:00 Do your job, which is to assess the project against your community's policies and regulations. As Joe said, there is an aspect of personal value and community value, but it needs to be done in an informed way against the backdrop of the policies and regulations that were adopted by the role of staff. I'm not going to spend much time on this. I think Joe did a great job of that, to make sure that what you get is complete and accurate.

1:26:29 And to put the staff report together for you, the applicant has responsibilities to do so in a complete and truthful manner and to provide those people, to make people available at the meeting at your Planning Commission hearing to answer the questions you might have. And at any given time, you may see four or five or six people before you on one matter, depending on the nature of the project.

1:27:00 How do you unravel, yes sir, I agree, you know, as I mentioned at the beginning, tabling, I'm sorry, I said tabling, what I meant was continuance, I'm sorry, thank you for correcting me on that. Tabling is a whole different matter, and usually that typically would be an involuntary basis, the applicant's saying, you know, we're not getting, we really have some problems with this, I want to pull it and table it.

1:27:34 But continuance is what I meant to say, thank you, and that is that, you know, we've got too much information to take in, or there's too many questions, or we have too many members of the public here tonight, and it's 11.30 p.m., we'd like to get on with the deliberations and different hearings, and we're not here till 1 a.m. So thank you for clarifying that. So, once you zip up with that op,

1:27:59 What are you going to get? What are you doing? There's a lot of material here. I'm going to cover it quickly because the purpose of this session isn't to really dive into the details on the technical matter, but I just want you to understand the context of it and how to use it. So what the application should do is it should give you a good understanding of the site and should give you a good understanding of what's proposed for the site.

1:28:22 include information about the development and what the impacts might be so that you can weigh those facts and make a recommendation. This is what I'm going to zip through kind of quickly here. What you should get in your packets in these, you call different things in different communities, a map, call it a base map or something that shows you what's there today, what's around it, how do I understand what I'm looking at, so if you go out and do a site review.

1:28:50 Got something to look at. Should be a site plan that shows you what's proposed. And, you know, we'll look something like this. Here's a building, here's a parking lot, here's the road. There's data on the, you know, the information about square footage, number of parking spaces on the plan so that you can quickly review it and see what it's about. What utilities are, where the utilities are, how the site will be graded.

1:29:15 You've probably seen, heard the term cut and fill or booting dirt around. Again, this is the stuff the engineers will look at and tell you whether it's a balanced plan. You don't need to go in and do the calculations unless you're an engineer and you really want to get into that stuff. Particularly in states like Washington, you're going to get information on the impacts of stormwater and sedimentation control during construction. The landscape plan, I think, again, is self-explanatory.

1:29:43 You often will see, particularly in urban areas, for commercial projects, lighting plans, will the project cast glare on adjoining properties, that sort of thing. You'll get building elevations that will show you what the project will look like, usually prepared by the architect, showing you the types of materials. Sometimes they'll show up with a color board or a materials board for you to get a first-hand look at what they're composing.

1:30:10 Signage, how big, what does it look like, where will it be, and then additional information according to what the particular nature of the project is. Nowadays it's not unusual. Everybody having worked on the development side loves to razzle-dazz with planning commissions because it's a little bit of insider information. So if we impress them, maybe they'll look more favorably on our own.

1:30:32 On our application. So enjoy this stuff, but don't take it, you know, don't be swayed by it. It's fun to look at computer fly-throughs and videos, but it shouldn't sway your decision. It just shouldn't be there to help you understand the case. So finally, what are the things that you consider? You've heard two hours of testimony and deliberation. The legal foundation, does this comply with our regulations?

1:30:59 Is it consistent with our plan and is it good for our community? So you're going to weigh and judge those four things in making your decision. By the way, I see some of you taking pictures. Just a reminder that you'll be able to download these presentations on the APA website. I don't know exactly how you do it. You go to MyAPA and I think if you've registered properly for the conference, you can download the PowerPoint. So it's a helpful thing to know. Finally,

1:31:28 And then we'll get to our discussion. How do you do this well? And how do you do it in a way that doesn't make you unwell in waking up the morning after the Planning Commission meeting with four hours of sleep? One is going back to, I think, Joe's excellent material about really understand what the role is in the Planning Commission, what's expected of you, and make sure that your Planning Commission is run in a matter that supports that. Learn how to...

1:31:57 Prepare for meetings so that it can be efficient and be aware of and take advantage of the resources. Learn to rely on your staff and ask them questions. That's what they're there for and then know what makes meetings effective, particularly for Planning Commission chairs and those of you who will be coming. It's your job to make sure that you conduct a three-hour meeting and everybody goes home feeling like, you know, we really got a lot accomplished.

1:32:25 So, other resources, things to look at, I mentioned the two documents that APA put out, Planning Magazine, talk to your staff, see if they get it or if they can, I think there are reduced rates. Some communities I know provide subscriptions to Planning Magazine for Planning Commissioners. Local APA chapters in my state, they do commission training.

1:32:52 If you're here at a national conference, go to your state conference. You'll learn a lot about these specifics as they apply to you. Other organizations have great resources. Urban Land Magazine is an excellent publication. I didn't list and should have the National Home Builders Association. I can't remember what their publication is called. They have an excellent magazine that really help you understand trends in planning and development. And then Joe mentioned state organizations.

1:33:20 He cited one example. Many states have online resources now that can help you become prepared and better at your job. So we'd like to end by, first of all, thanking you for doing what you do. It really is a very important job. In many ways, often a thankless one. The questions were really hard to hear. Oh, okay. So, do you have any questions? Do you have any other?

1:33:51 No, I thought this was really helpful. Yeah, you know, it's not like we don't know all the individual points, but I thought it did a good job of putting it all together, so it just gives us all the same foundation for our meetings, so. And I just wanted to say that personally, like, when I get a really big packet, what I do is I read the staff report and I read the resolution, because remember the resolution, as they proposed, is what we're voting on. So just make sure you at least really comprehend those two.

1:34:20 Bookend pieces first, and then, that's how I do this, and then I get into all the different attachments. So, you want me to talk a little bit about Granicus? I think that Jamie Gray, did she talk to the both of you about Granicus when? She had a phone, sent me an email. Yeah. So, and I'll just tell you the hint about Granicus is, just call, once you get it downloaded on your, just call them, they're really good about helping you. Okay.

1:34:49 You may feel that that's a short way of doing this, but rather than figuring it all out, I just call them, I have the number, I can just give you the number. But on the Granicus, you can make notes and you can highlight. So if it's a really big packet with like oversized printouts, then I usually ask Pam to make a copy of the oversized printouts for me because it's too hard to read it on your iPad.

1:35:18 Everything else is really easy to do. I would just say take a little bit of that. Yeah. Just navigating it. Oh. Okay, so, and the other thing. Don't know it. And the other thing I do is, so I do always, like, for a public hearing, I take a little piece of paper and I make myself key notes of what pages it's on so that you can find it here. Yeah. All right, so I have a question that I've always wanted to know. This went back to...

1:35:58 So I don't understand why in general plans you have land use and then we have zoning codes. It seems like they're both like basically the same. I've never figured out the difference between our land use codes and our zoning codes. Or maybe it just happens that in our town they're the same. I think the general plan is the policy, the guiding document. And so the general plan is kind of the...

1:36:20 These are our high-level goals. This is what we want. And the zoning code is this is how we're going to get what we want. So the details, the setbacks, all the numbers, you won't find any of that in the general plan. So really the zoning code is the implementing document for the general plan. All right. And I gave Commissioner Verruck, Commissioner Shane, your own copy of the general plan. It's a pretty interesting document. Yeah. Actually, I think I have a copy of this, so if I do have it, I'll just...

1:36:51 So you can never have too many copies. Yeah. We have a lot of extra copies. Earlier, one of the gentlemen talked about we have in some cities or county towns, they have general plans and they have zoning codes rather than general plan, zoning code, master plan, like what we have here.

1:37:27 Now, when we created the master plan for a specific district or a specific plan, if you want to, I guess it's called district? Or district plans. It's very confusing. Is there a reason why we separated in such a detail versus the way that, you know, they were talking about in a large-scale city like, you know, Seattle?

1:37:58 So I think, so we have our general plan and then the zoning code. And the zoning code, particularly for our resort areas, has very high level regulations. So it just kind of says just, it's very basic and requires that a master plan be completed. So every kind of node of our resort area is a little bit different. So each area has, you know, different setbacks, different, you know, kind of guidance. So the master plans are really implementing that, the zoning code, the resort zone.

1:38:27 And so, you know, like Snow Creek has a master plan, we have a Juniper Ridge master plan, Lodestar master plan, so kind of all these resort areas have these master plans, which really, it's not discussed in the state guidelines, it's really something that we've implemented in order to implement that resort zoning. The specific plan is a state, there are specific state guidelines on a specific plan, so throughout the state you'll find that specific plans

1:38:56 Are generally very similar. They're required to have certain items in them. And the specific plan really becomes the zoning for the document. So the specific plan supersedes the zoning code. So for example, for Clearwater, the Old Mammoth Place area, the Clearwater specific plan is the zoning for that property. The zoning code does not govern that property.

1:39:17 Except where the specific plan is silent. Then you would refer back to the zoning code. But generally the specific plan should have all of the parking requirements, setbacks, heights, everything. So you really, you don't need to refer to the zoning code for that. So specific plans are different than master plans. Master plans are more, you know, implementing and there aren't state, you know, mandated requirements for master plans. It's something we've done as a community and other communities do it too, to really kind of implement.

1:39:44 You know, areas where maybe you don't want to have a specific plan governing it. It's really, for us, it's implementing that resort zones, those different nodes in our town. And then, but we also have district plans. Right. Right. And that started back when we as a town was trying to do our general plan. There was just, there was not confusion, but there was a lot of different input. People had different visions, different ideas.

1:40:14 And we had, Dawn can come out on this because she worked on the initial general plan. So there was, we had a really hard time developing a comprehensive general plan. So they said, well, let's divide the town into all these small sections and have district plans. And then ultimately from the district plan, they will help formulate the general plan. But it is, for a town of our size, most towns don't have that many district plans. I mean, we really did divide it into pretty small increments.

1:40:43 I don't know if you have any comments on that. You want to even remember all those painful days. Yeah, I know. It was just that I just remembered that the Milwaukee Advisory Group lasted a bit longer than it was anticipated. Yeah, because of that. Well, that was one of the reasons. But, I mean, I think it turned out well. I think it was a good exercise for the community, for sure. And the district plans are really guiding documents. They weren't adopted by council. They were accepted. So they carry weight.

1:41:19 We do look at them when we're looking at projects, but they're not adopted, so technically they're not legally binding. So it's really a guidance. They're intended to be a guiding document. And what we did when we updated the zoning code last year is we took the district plans and incorporated that guidance into the zoning code update.

1:41:43 Heavily in the commercial zoning area. So we did a lot of work in the commercial zoning area with district planning. So during the district planning process, I mean, we pretty much hammered out all of the height discussion and setbacks. We talked a lot about kind of details through that process. So what we did with the zoning code update is we incorporated those recommendations that were supported by commissions, supported by council, the public, and actually went through that process to formally adopt those.

1:42:12 You incorporated those items at its entirety? We took the pieces. We didn't just adopt the whole district plan. We took the pieces that really fit in the zoning code and put them there. And so you'll find, so for projects, different projects, we will site the district plan.

1:42:34 So sometimes, like in the North Village, we haven't adopted, we haven't made any changes to the North Village Pacific Plan to incorporate the district planning work that was done up there. So when we present projects that are in the North Village, we'll compare it to the general plan and the North Village Pacific Plan, and then we'll provide information on the district planning process, so the guidance that comes out of that process. So it's really intended to inform the commission and the council, but...

1:43:00 It wasn't formally adopted, but it's still good information and it still shows, you know, there was a lot of public support for the district planning process. We did get a lot of comments and incorporated those comments, so it's good information to have as you look to make a decision. Do all of these district plans have its own committees from their neighborhood associations or is it something that the planning departments that

1:43:31 Well, at this point, you know, I mean, so far in my terms, I mean, we have only used the district plan as a very basic document because, you know, our zoning code and our general plan, I mean, have now been developed. So I can't ever remember where we've ever gone back, like, in a hearing process to the district plan.

1:43:57 I mean, I think it really helped people to formulate concepts of what areas should look like. And, you know, maybe, you know, there's this whole area down there. What do you call that? Where are the schools? The gateway. The gateway. I mean, we haven't really clarified that. Maybe someday we'd go back to that process. But now these overlying documents are pretty well, have been actually adopted. Okay, so we don't usually get down to that level in our day-to-day work.

1:44:26 But one comment while we're on this. So this came about something that Councilman Shields worked on with Mammoth Mountain. And we're working on this interactive map that's like up here on the wall. You'll have to look at it. And so it basically lists out the different specific plans, the different approved tentative tract maps. And we have some. You have to look at this. It has to.

1:44:51 Some of this has to be revised slightly, but what's really nice then when this is all done, then it ties to a website. Have you seen this? Briefly, yes. So when it ties to a website, so when we are like doing developer information or even when we're doing our work on commission, then you can actually link back to the website and say, well, for this parcel, this is the current approved tentative tract map and the status of those things. It's really going to be a great tool.

1:45:19 Finish it a little bit and know how to use it. Will that live on the Towns URL? Or is that going to live on the Towns? I'm not sure at this point. I know that all the data is on the Towns website. So all the links, any links would come back to our website. But I'm not sure where the main... I think ultimately there has to be a shortcut back through the Town. Yeah. They haven't gotten there yet. So Tom Hodges has really helped do this through the mountain. Good. Yeah, that's good. All right, what else is on your list?

1:45:49 I think that's it, unless there's no other, any other questions from the commission. Just basically, does everyone know when we meet? Today? No. We meet on a regular schedule. Yes, we meet. The second Tuesday of every, each month. Wednesday, excuse me. Try, though, to keep your fourth Tuesday, Wednesday. Pardon, Wednesday, open. Keep your fourth. Because, you know, we used to have two regular meetings, and then we decided we didn't need two regular meetings.

1:46:20 You know, we could get in a situation where we have special meetings, so I just wouldn't book your big cruise or whatever to make sure that there's not. And Sandra knows pretty far in advance if we're going to have. And the November meeting is going to be on the Thursday. The second Thursday. Right. Instead of the 11th, because the 11th is Veterans Day. So I'll remind you again as we get closer and we'll see what items we have on the agenda for that meeting. So today I just really want to make sure, I don't want to talk about what's on.

1:46:49 The workshop, but I just really want to make sure everybody's good with terminology. I mean, I think you'll all know what a workshop is, what we're being legally asked to do by a workshop. Today, this afternoon is a workshop. What was simply just an interaction with the public and just getting comments. Right, so we're not voting. Okay. And it's not the time that we express our opinion, I'm assuming, right? Well, I was going to just say, it's an opportunity to provide input on the proposals.

1:47:25 So if the, you know, commission feels that what they're proposing is reasonable, I think it's time to say that, but it's not the time to say I would approve this or I would deny this. But, you know, providing, you know, the reason that I kind of think of it is how reasonable is their proposal? Yes, it seems reasonable, but I have this concern about this. It doesn't mean you're not going to approve it. It doesn't mean you're going to deny it. It just means here's this information and the applicant can take the information that they hear, make changes to their proposal, and then come for an application that you...

1:47:55 So they can kind of give or take. But if you have a real issue with something, it's time to be honest about it because it's very expensive for them to continue on down the process. So, I mean, you need to give feedback. A good example was the Innative Village project. We came before the commission with a concept review. The commission said, we have concerns with the heights that are proposed. They didn't say they would deny the project if they kept going with those heights, but they expressed concern.

1:48:31 With those heights. And the applicant heard what the commission said and reduced the height project. So that's kind of the purpose is to really get those, you know, kind of early red flag type issues. At least let the applicant know that you have concerns with this aspect. And then they can go back and decide how they want to respond to that. Does that help? So, and I'm assuming you know what tentative tract maps are, right? So then, and you understand that

1:49:05 Tentative tract maps used to expire, but then when the recession, it was a statutory, they would get granted statutory extensions by the state of California. That's why we have a lot of these tentative tract maps that, in essence, like, well, the one we'll see later on, or later on today, was originally approved, I think, in 2007. Well, that's why it's still in existence, because of these statutory extensions. It has nothing to do with the town. So, you have...

1:49:35 The tentative tract map, and then we have conditions. So what the planning has done, they've gotten really good at this, and they take those conditions and they divide them up into sections. We try to divide them up into, you know, have like the grading conditions together, have special planning conditions together, those kinds of things. So it makes it easier for the applicant. Our standard conditions are in one section and then the special condition section.

1:50:13 What's rote, what's the standard, and what is a special condition that's different on this project than would be on? But they didn't always do it that way. So if you really need to read a set of conditions at least once when a new applicant comes forward, or maybe Sandra can give them to you so that you know what these standard conditions are, but then usually in our process we'll only be addressing whatever the special planning condition.

1:50:44 So I just wanted to kind of tell you that once you've gotten familiar with the document, you don't need to read it every single time. And we walk through those conditions with the applicant. Before we notice the hearing, we meet with the applicant. We walk through all the conditions to make sure that they understand what the conditions are and that those conditions are okay with them. Then we notice the hearing. So we don't actually move forward to present the project to the commission until we're on the same page.

1:51:13 Because the last thing we want is to be arguing about conditions at the public hearing. So we have that process. And we really, I mean, we try to make sure that they send us an email confirmation that we've read the conditions, we accept the conditions, and go ahead and notice the hearing. So that really helps to make, it's made it a lot smoother. We didn't used to do that. And so I think that it makes it a smoother process. Usually the applicant and staff are on the same. And if we're not in agreement with a condition, we can, you know, how we're coming in.

1:51:51 A term that was used this afternoon is called white box. And I just want to give you a little background about white box. This term came out of when we were doing the zoning commercial code zoning code update. And if you remember, this is the commercial code, not North Village land. So it's a little bit of like comparing apples to oranges. But what the concept of white box was is that it's very expensive.

1:52:22 We're talking maybe a million, two million dollars on a bigger project for an applicant to draw up a whole set of plans. So what we said as a town that in our commercial zone that we would establish height, we would establish a floor area ratio limits, okay, these certain limits, but that an applicant wouldn't have to actually come up and design a set of plans. They in essence would just present a white box.

1:52:51 And then if it was conceptually approved, then they could design their plan and then work with the design review. So that's the term of white box. It's really a town term. It's not a legal term like some of these other terms. So was there any other terminology? We don't want to talk about it, but just the terminology. Is everybody clear about terminology that we'll be using this afternoon? Oh, and then did you talk to everybody about using a town email address? Oh, I did not talk about that.

1:53:33 A lot of things that we do could be deemed as public correspondence. Everything you do as a commissioner is deemed as public. Acting as a commissioner. When we talk about the potluck or whatever. Right. But this is what's really important as business owners. So if there was some sort of legal action taken and

1:54:01 Somebody wanted to do due diligence on emails and you using your personal business email address, they would basically have to have access to your business email address. Just think Hillary Clinton. You should really get them to set you up with a town of Mammoth Lakes email address and do all your correspondence to the town of Mammoth Lakes. I didn't realize that was an option. Yeah, and we can set that up for you. So if you're interested, it's really up to the commissioners. Some commissioners do, some don't.

1:54:29 But the risk, you know, is that if there is a public records request, someone would have to have access to your personal email if you're using that to go through and determine which records are records that we give to the requester and which are just personal. But that means someone else is going through your information. I would like to. Best practice to have the town. And then we would coordinate and send it directly through you.

1:54:56 I think it makes it a lot easier. It's a lot easier for us when we do public records requests as well. It just makes it easy just to search that email box rather than having to go look at the other information. So is this then a web-based email server we're going to be accessing? Yes, through the town's website. Okay. So I'll put in a request to have email addresses for both of them. So is that something that we can just load it right on? I'll look. No, I have a little problem when I load. Okay, so when I was thinking it,

1:55:26 Both my business email address and this web-based out of Outlook, I ran into some exception rule. I mean, I had a lot of problems doing that. So ultimately, I just accessed the web. But it's probably user error. Okay, so ultimately, I just accessed the web base. I just think it's... But you use the... My email, my work email address is just public information. Friction anyways. Yeah, so let's move on. Do we want to talk about Brown?

1:55:57 I did meet with both new commissioners and walked through the Brown Act with them. I'm happy to talk about it, but yeah. Thank you. Anything else? Any other questions you have? So we're technically taking a recess, correct? Taking a break, yes, until meet back here at 2 o'clock. Do we need a motion for that? I don't think so. Okay. Well, we're doing at 2 o'clock. Thank you very much. Thank you.

1:56:35 Call the Planning and Economic Development Meeting of September the 9th back to order. We had a break after our morning session. And today we will do a second public comment period. Public comments is for anybody that would like to make some comment on any item that's on our agenda this afternoon. Good afternoon. I'm Shereen Sanders, co-compliance officer for the town. To our two new commissioners, welcome.

1:57:09 To briefly summarize my role at the town, I'm responsible for enforcing our municipal code. Frequently recurring issues that I address include building without permits, violations of our solid waste ordinance and feeding of wildlife, enforcement of our sign ordinances, lighting ordinance violations, dead and dying trees posing life safety and property damage threats, and nuisances such as

1:57:36 Waste, debris, surrounding properties, abandoned buildings and abandoned vehicles. I'm also responsible for annual town cleanup day. I work very closely with the Mono County Health Department, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District and Tom Heller, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Mike Braun and of course Steve Searles. If you need to reach me, my extension is 244. If you have any questions or code violations that you'd like to talk to me about. So are there any questions?

1:58:10 If not, thank you. And again, welcome Commissioner Verruck and Commissioner Chang. Thank you. I do, I, I thought, I'm sorry, I thought. Sorry. So, can you give us a quick recap where we stand with dead and dying trees? Oh, okay. It's pretty sad, but I noticed we have some very large specimen trees that are not healthy these days. Yes. So, I've received about four or five complaints of dead or dying trees on private property in the last few weeks. Okay.

1:58:38 Letters have gone out to all those property owners with a deadline as to when they need to remove the trees. Okay. Or call me if they need an extension on that deadline of a few days, maybe a week if they need to hire somebody. And then I'm working with Steve Searles. We're kind of going around and looking at everything that we see.

1:59:06 That might be in the town's right of way that we can address. So it's either private property, town's right of way, we can remove those, or U.S. Forest Service. And in that case, I get in touch with the U.S. Forest Service. So we are addressing that and going around and trying to put together a map of where these are and who we need to call. All right. And then just quickly, can you recap what our procedure is if somebody is not in compliance with a code?

1:59:35 With regard to dead trees? No, well, just in general. Oh, okay. So if there's a code violation, if someone's out of compliance with whatever the issue is, I usually call them or walk into their business and let them know what's going on, give them a time frame to come into compliance. If that doesn't happen, then I'll go to a written warning. Sometimes I go directly to a written warning, especially if they're out of town.

2:00:05 And they have about 15 days per our code to address that. And if it's not addressed, then we send out a citation. And from there, we can continue to cite on a daily basis. Will the upcoming quality of life ordinance then will also be under your purview? Is that correct? Is that correct, Sandra? Portions. Parts of it. Portions of it, yeah. So portions of it can be enforced by the finance department through their process.

2:00:36 There's trash requirements in there and those kinds of things. So it's kind of going to be, the enforcement will be split up. And like noise would be PD. PD would be noise because typically noise complaints happen after hours. Yeah. So we're not here anyway. So yeah, the noise would be PD. Okay. Great. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Keep up the good work. Thanks. All right. If there's no other public comments, we'll close the public comment period.

2:01:03 And we'll now move to business matter number three, selection of planning and economic development commission officers and committee appointments. So we need to select a chair, a vice chair. We need to select a second member for the design committee. And I was, if it's.

2:01:25 Agreeable to the other commissioners. I was thinking maybe at this time, unless Sandra, you had some comments, we would have no other permanent committees because we really, until we kind of figure out what's going to be happening with economic development and messaging and those kinds of things. So with that, we probably should have a motion for chair. I would like to make a motion that we retain Mickey Brown as chair of this commission. Second. Do we need a roll call or is it just a?

2:01:59 Aye. Thank you. Thank you. We need a motion for Vice Chair. I would like to make a motion that we nominate Amy for Vice Chair of this Commission. You need a second? I'll second that. Aye. And now we need a motion for a second person on our design committee. Design review committee. I'm assuming, well, let me step back. Who was the first person? I'm assuming Amy. Right. There's no one. Yeah. Right. Right. Okay. I would stay.

2:02:42 Okay. Sure. All right. Sure. Do we need a motion for that? No. No, I think that's fine. I was just going to explain a little bit about what the design committee does. So they review projects, you know, like design review projects, different projects that come before the commission, but they review it before it gets to the commission. So they basically take a look at the project, provide input. It's really kind of a back and forth. Sometimes there'll be one or two meetings on the same item. Provide input to the applicant. The applicant can incorporate changes.

2:03:12 That way when it gets to the commission it's really it's gone through that process and it's usually when it gets to commission it's a project the design committee generally has consensus on that it's appropriate meets all of our requirements so it's kind of a pre-review with the design focus and I don't know how often you say meet once every two months or something like that it's not yeah give or take and and it's not a scheduled date necessarily just when something comes

2:03:42 Comes up. Sometimes there may be more meetings, sometimes less, but it's not, I don't think it's a huge commitment. No. Alright, can I have a motion? You're doing a great job. Was there interest though? Did anybody express interest in that one? I'm interested in sitting on that committee. Okay. I'll make a motion that we nominate Don Baruch for the design committee. Second. Aye.

2:04:15 And just so you know, Commissioner Chang, you can always attend these committee meetings if you want to. I mean, you certainly wouldn't want to attend all of them, but maybe on some of the bigger projects initially you might just want to attend them. It would be interesting. So technically if three commissioners. Oh, no, I'm sorry. I take that back. I rescinded that. Three commissioners are present in an economic development commission meeting. So if two commissioners are present, it's not it. I need to go back to training. They didn't cover that. Okay.

2:04:44 All right. So do we have any other business matters underneath officers and committee appointments? If not, I'm going to close. The economic development community. Well, I think we're just going to leave that. Maybe table that one for now. Right now, your workload is so comprehensive and extensive, and until we're really in a position where we're doing something.

2:05:07 On a regular basis, I think there's no point in having a standing committee for that, unless you had... No, that's fine. I didn't understand. So we would eliminate the Economic Development and Community Messaging Committee, so we only have one standing committee. Right. Okay, good. Thank you. Do you want to have consensus to do that? Can somebody make a motion, other than Michael? I would make a motion that we suspend the Economic Development and Community Messaging Committee.

2:05:35 Until such time as we deem it appropriate to reconvene. There you go. I'll second. Aye. We'll now move on to business matters number four, workshop on the Mammoth Hillside Project Amendment, concept review 15-002, and our staff contact person is Ruth and Sandra. Thank you.

2:06:04 This is a workshop today to discuss the proposed amendments to the Mammoth Hillside project. The purpose of this workshop and the concept review application is to allow the commission and public an opportunity to discuss and provide feedback on the project before a formal application is submitted. The applicant will use the feedback and input received from the commission to put together their formal application, which will be an amendment to the use permits and tentative tract map.

2:06:30 After we've received those applications, then we'll bring the project back to commission for discussion and decision or a vote. The original Mammoth Hillside project, which consisted of a tentative tract map and use permit, was approved in 2006. Two subsequent use permits to allow for tandem parking and parking lifts and an in-lieu fee for affordable housing were approved in 2007 and 2008.

2:06:57 There are a total of four projects and three approving resolutions that make up the existing entitlements for the Mammoth Hillside project as a whole. Tentative tract maps and use permits typically expire after 24 months or two years. However, due to extensions filed by the applicant as well as extensions mandated by the state due to challenging economic conditions, the project's expiration has been extended to January 12, 2016.

2:07:25 The applicant or the property owner may submit for one additional extension of up to five years which would extend the expiration until 2021. The concept review application narrative has been included as an attachment to the staff report. As the applicant has described in their letter, they are requesting to amend the conditions in the three existing resolutions to more closely reflect current market conditions and changes to the standard conditions typically required by the town at this point. In staff's review of the proposed amendments,

2:07:55 Planning and Public Works staff focused on four primary issues. The first is a condition to require a four- or five-star hotel operator. We found in our research that that requirement was based off of the original application submitted by the property owner, and we recommend that if that's no longer proposed, that that condition can be removed. We also reviewed the conditions requiring a pedestrian bridge over Canyon Boulevard to connect the project site to the gondola in the village.

2:08:25 After significant research, it was determined that the pedestrian bridge was not required by the town or the North Village-specific plan, and that that condition may also be removed. We do recommend, however, that the condition be revised to indicate that if we find the bridge was required as a part of a separate private party agreement, that the developer needs to comply with the terms of that agreement. The third issue area we looked at was Resolution...

2:08:52 2007-22, which references a private parking agreement with the owners of the 8050 Residence Club. Our recommendation there is that the conditions of this resolution be clarified, not changed, but clarified to indicate acknowledgement and not requirement of the private parking agreement. It should also be recognized in the conditions that if this private parking agreement is amended or terminated in such a way that the Mammoth Hillside Project is no longer a part,

2:09:19 That it won't affect the associated approvals for the Mammoth Hillside project. Finally, we reviewed the references throughout the three resolutions to fees, development impact fees and affordable housing mitigation fees. Our recommendation is that all of these be revised to require the applicant to pay the fees in place at the time of building permit issuance. This is in accordance with conditions applied to current development projects, like Mountainside and Gray Bear.

2:09:50 Any projects that have come forward in this last year. It is important to note, however, that the payment of the standard affordable housing mitigation fees will result in the loss of the 35% state density bonus that was originally allocated to the Hillside project. The recommendation from staff to commission for today's workshop is to discuss the application and provide comments, questions, feedback to the applicant and staff. Sandra and I are here to answer any questions, and Dave Harvey, the applicant, is also here.

2:10:20 As well. Thank you. So, let's start. Commissioner Vanhurst, do you have any questions this time? Not this time, no. Commissioner, do you have any questions this time? Not right now. Commissioner Chang, do you have any questions at this time? I do have one question. What was the original, or should I address that with? You address staff. Make sure your mic are closed. Okay. Actually, no, I don't have a question for staff at this moment. I do have a really quick question. I'm sorry, I apologize.

2:10:54 Ruth, back to the pedestrian bridge, you mentioned that it sounded like you could not find the private agreement that stipulated the bridge that connected the parcel to the village. Was there any, I'm just wondering where the bridge lived, where it came from, where the thought originated from. If there's nothing in the town's paperwork, but now there's no private agreement.

2:11:23 I'm just a bit confused. So public works staff took the lead on researching that particular condition. And what they found is that the pedestrian bridge was actually proposed by the developer as an amenity to their guests and to the village and to provide access to the village. So it was never a requirement that the town put forth on them or that was a part of the North Village specific plan.

2:11:49 From our perspective, if it was something the developer was proposing but no longer is or no longer wants to see out the requirement, that because the town never required it, there's no reason at this point to condition it. But we kept the caveat that if there is a private party agreement out there somewhere that requires a bridge be built, that that be complied with. Got it. So we don't know that there's any private party agreement related to the bridge.

2:12:19 Left that caveat in place because the town's not a party to any agreement. Sure. But we don't want to preclude the fact that there might be an agreement separately out there. Does that make sense? Okay. If my memory serves me correctly on that subject, originally that bridge cost was going to be split between the owner of the Weston property. I thought I remembered something like that.

2:12:46 I also don't know if anywhere that agreement is written. All right. But my question is regarding the 80-50 parking agreement. Has our legal counsel reviewed this in relationship to this particular project? So in relationship to the proposed amendments? Right.

2:13:08 Because we're only clarifying and not actually changing the intent of the language, we haven't had him review our suggestions related to that condition. He will review that as a part of a formal application. But we're really, we're not changing, I guess, the meaning of that resolution. We're just trying to clarify the fact that the town is not a party to that agreement, if that agreement is modified.

2:13:36 The town is okay with that. The town's fine with the hillside project either accommodating those 50 spaces or not accommodating those 50 spaces. Okay. And when we had our DZA hearings for the 8050 Building C, wasn't the statement made at that time that the town of Mammoth Lakes was not a party to this private agreement? Okay. Any other questions? I do have one more, and I don't mean it.

2:14:08 Just something at the paragraph under bullet point D, it says that the public works department was suggesting that maybe there was a transit stop that could be placed on Canyon Boulevard in lieu of an area of interest. Would that be where the lake space and trolley picks up people? Is that kind of what we're referring to? I believe that's the goal there, yeah. Okay.

2:14:37 Thank you. And that will probably be discussed and negotiated with the applicant at the time, again, that we get a real application. The second round. Yeah. That's it for me. Mr. Harvey, would you like to make a statement? Good afternoon, Commission. Welcome, new commissioners. Thank you. Staff. This is strange looking. Yeah. Okay.

2:15:26 Before you start, you know, I do need you for the record to state your name and what your official role is in this capacity. Not that we don't know who you are. My name is Dave Harvey. I have been employed by the land owner, Cerberus, a hedge fund from New York. And what duties they've given me is...

2:15:58 Basically to put together a consultancy team, which we have done, and to help them get to a point to where they have a level of entitlements that are marketable so that in fact something can be built on that property. Right now we have seven acres of prime at the bottom of a gondola.

2:16:29 property that we're earning nothing on as a town. It's not healthy for the landowner. It's not healthy for the town. And staff has worked very hard to understand what these issues are. In the beginning, about four years ago, we started working on this.

2:17:02 What we continually ran into was that builder developers that would come forward and show an interest in the property because of its location were very dismayed when they went through the entitlement that has been granted to the property, the conditional use permit. There seems to be many issues with the conditional use permit. Today we're addressing, we've got four, five,

2:17:39 Major issues. And these seem to be the stumbling block for builder developers from coming forward and putting plans together in either working with Cerberus financially or purchasing the property from Cerberus and building on their own. So this has not been an exercise that can be completed quickly.

2:18:14 But it is an exercise that needs to be completed thoroughly. And staff has been extremely accommodating in understanding and in some cases helping us understand issues that exist in this conditional use permit that do need changing. Many things have changed since 2006. We're almost 10 years now.

2:18:47 We have had some code and zoning changes. We've had a lot of changes which affect this particular document. And as we go forward with the major components of this and address them through a conditional use permit amendment, we will have the opportunity both as the property owner and

2:19:19 The town to incorporate into the new document, the amended document, all three of the documents, all three of the conditional use permits will come into one document. All of the changes that have happened since 2006, as far as the code, the municipal code and the general plan, these items will also be incorporated into

2:19:50 That amended conditional use permit. So the property that we're discussing right now is certainly not alone in all of this. We have a number of properties, I would say a handful, that wound up with some level of entitlements up to and probably including 2006 and maybe 2007 was the last.

2:20:24 But all of these conditional use permits will have to go through some kind of a vetting such as what we're doing here and probably conditional use permit amendment. So I'm very happy and glad to be working with the staff on doing something that we can create a model for other conditional use permits.

2:20:56 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:21:28 We'll be coming forward from other developers. Any questions? Commissioner Chang, do you have any questions? I have any questions at this time. Is this our only chance to ask if they have questions? Dave, do you have any knowledge of a private agreement for the pedestrian bridge? No, I don't. As Sandra can attest, I have been through the records.

2:22:09 Numerous, numerous times, spent many hours going through. We have not been able to find any records of a bridge being required by the town, any type of a letter to that effect. Public Works took a look at this. They could not find any history of that. There seems to be anecdotal...

2:22:38 Information such as Weston was going to share in the cost of the bridge and things like that. I think we all agree, or at least the owners of the property and staff agrees that a bridge is probably a good thing. It's a safe thing. Typically, a public works type of product like that gets built with joint interest.

2:23:08 with the other properties in the area. So the owners of the property service are very amenable to signing on to language that allows for that in the conditional use permit. And it's the same type of language that is very common in the sense that if there was a community facilities district that was

2:23:38 established in the area such as there is in North Village and that community facilities district stated that their goal was to build a bridge. The developer agrees up front that they would be a part of that. Thank you. And I have one other quick question.

2:24:01 I apologize. This is probably a little bit more for staff than for Dave. Are there any other undeveloped sites within the town of Mammoth Lakes that are required to be operated as a four- or five-star hotel to gain their certificate of occupancy that you know of? Not that I'm aware of, no. Thank you. Commissioner Groot, do you have any questions? No, not at the same time. So my question relates to the parking agreement. Can you comment on whether or not your client...

2:24:36 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:25:14 The conditional use permit mentions a parking agreement with Fireside, which is the condominiums that are right next to this subject property. That agreement was a private agreement. It is mentioned in the conditional use permit, but it is not a condition of the

2:25:47 conditional use permit. Typically, as staff has stated, these private agreements are not conditions in a conditional use permit. If there was something that the hillside property was obligated to produce by the town, then it would be

2:26:30 The town's prerogative to put that into the conditional use permit as a condition. But the town does not see themselves as a party to this agreement. And we're in a quandary here as to exactly how all that came about and what the ramifications are for that. And it is not an insignificant condition.

2:27:07 It is a condition of many million dollars. So it becomes a stumbling block when a financial institution or a developer who wants to buy the property looks at it and wants to make a decision as to whether that's the property that they want to buy or not. So this becomes a housekeeping issue and needs to be cleaned up.

2:27:43 My client is very happy to have this not a condition. If it's a private agreement, then they're bound by the private agreement. They will deal with that with the other party to the contract. To no avail. We've searched and we cannot find anything that ties the town to the agreement. Therefore, we don't believe that that agreement.

2:28:18 Should be a condition in the conditional use permit. Did you want to add anything to Sandra? So as a little bit of addition for my fellow commissioners, back in 2006-2007, both the 8050 parcel, which is the 8050 parcel, and this parcel was owned by the same developer.

2:28:46 You know, when they originally did things, I mean, they didn't ever think of two separate ownerships. They really perceived it as one single ownership and going forward that way. I think that's where part of the confusion comes from on some of this is that things maybe were not as clear as they needed to be because they didn't think it was necessary at the time. I agree with that. And that's the current developer, the current applicant? No. So just as a little bit of a history is that

2:29:16 8050 was originally, the original developer was this gentleman named Sean Combs, okay, and then Sean Combs lost that parcel in foreclosure, originally to the company Barrel Street that did the meds financing, and then ultimately to I-Star who had the underlying financing, and then Sean Combs bought the parcel across the street, the subject parcel today, and I believe originally GM was his parcel,

2:29:45 Partner, I think, at one time. And then subsequently Cerebus, who is the ultimate applicant today, it's an entity of them, foreclosed on the property and now they're the legal owners. So where you started with these agreements with a developer up here, now here we are in 2015 and you basically have two financial entities that are the legal owners of the property. And that explains it.

2:30:13 It doesn't excuse it, but it just explains a little bit why there's so much confusion in some of these underlying documents. I have a question for Mr. Harvey. Mr. Harvey, what is the, if there are any, public impact by removing the parking space? The parking space or the parking agreement? Parking agreement. What is the public impact? If there are any. I don't know that there would be a public impact.

2:30:47 By removing that condition, the agreement stays in place and it becomes a private party agreement such as these things have been treated in the past, these types of agreements between two parties. If the town is not in basically not a signatory to the agreement, then it

2:31:17 Typically would not wind up as a condition in a conditional use permit. Thank you. So just two more quick questions on my part. I just want to double check with you that certainly you and your client understands that if you agree to the current housing fees that you lose your 35% state density bonus. I'm assuming that's acceptable or would be in our staff report. Is that correct?

2:31:50 We understand that. We understand the logic of it. I think there's probably some discussion that we need to have with staff on a couple of nuances that are involved in that. But overall, we don't have an issue with that. Okay. So it's certainly something that you could clarify before you came back to us with a formal application. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely.

2:32:18 And then my last question is, is you certainly are well aware that over the years we've really, I think, clarified and made our standard conditions more readable and certainly, you know, a lot of legal work went into our current conditions and I'm assuming it's acceptable to you to ultimately work towards having a set of conditions that are in alignment with our current standards.

2:32:48 Oh, absolutely. And this was, I believe, a very wise choice of staff, and that was to attack the four or five major issues that we're dealing with and some of the other issues that have to do with municipal code changes and general plan changes and things like that, that that kind of verbiage can be put into the new document.

2:33:17 and will become a standard conditions type of language for conditional use permits going forward. Do we have any other questions for Mr. Harvey? Thank you very much. Thank you. Very good. Thank you. So since there's no public, I'm assuming we have no public comments, and did we receive any email comments on this business matter? We did not. No. Okay.

2:33:52 All right. So at this time, what I would like to do is that in the staff report, there is four items, and I'd like to discuss each one individually, starting with the four or five star hotel operator. We're all on the same page. Commissioner Brute, do you have any comments about being a four or five star? I guess my only comment is,

2:34:35 Would be where did it come from and why is it specified that way? If we don't have any history of specifying flagship hotels or four or five star hotels, then where did that language come from? The only place we could find a reference to that language was on the original application that the property owner submitted saying we propose a four or five star hotel.

2:35:07 And so our best guess is that it was included as a condition because that's the way the project was originally proposed. And so they saw that being appropriate at that time. Okay. But it is unusual. Okay. Do you have any comments on that point? No. Other than when the project is eventually developed as some point down the road, hopefully it will be, it would be great to have it.

2:35:39 I agree completely. I think

2:36:11 We're in agreement that we would be comfortable if it came back without that condition on there. Thank you. So let's talk then about the pedestrian bridge. Commissioner Chang, are you comfortable commenting on the pedestrian bridge? I agree with staff's recommendation at this moment. Unless, especially the part about the private agreement,

2:36:49 That it's required for a developer to comply to the specifics of the agreement. And the staff have seen this private agreement, right? We don't know that a private party agreement exists. It's really just a caveat that if there is something in place, that that be complied with. But there's a private agreement on the... No, this is the parking. So this is the pedestrian bridge. We don't know about an agreement on the pedestrian bridge.

2:37:21 Okay. Just to clarify. Right. And we don't think that there's agreement related to the pedestrian bridge. We just don't want to completely leave out that possibility. Right. So I'm just curious how that even works. If we say that, put in this vague language stating that if agreement exists, then the property owner needs to honor it, but we have no way of enforcing that.

2:37:48 And we don't typically with private party agreements. Right. It's just a reference to the possibility of a private party agreement being in place. Essentially so that a private party couldn't come back and say, oh, well, by removing that condition, you've also removed our ability to enforce our private party agreement. I don't think we need to include a reference to it. It's just... I mean, I'm just thinking back on the...

2:38:19 When we had the hearing for the Inn at the Village, I don't think we made any reference to the private agreement between the Inn at the Village and Fireside. And if that's Commission's recommendation that we... So I just don't know why it might even... If the town is just completely out of private party agreements altogether, to whose benefit is it to even reference it in the first place?

2:38:43 That's a very valid suggestion, and I think what we can do is take that to the attorney and make sure that he's comfortable with us not referencing it. I think it would be really interesting to hear what Andy has to say. Yeah, I think we need to hear from the legal counsel what Andy has to say because especially when the resolution initially had incorporated the idea or the resolution had included, especially on the parking spaces, the 50 parking spaces.

2:39:12 There is a private agreement, and the resolution that included, it's almost insinuated it was because of that private agreement that we then had approved, the town, the Planning Commission had approved that particular condition or the project. So I think it's something that, you know, we just need clarification from our legal counsel. Right. But in regard to the pedestrian bridge, assuming there's no private agreement, you have...

2:39:41 I have no problem removing the condition for pedestrian bridge. And my question was only just, do we even want to bother referencing the possibility of a private party agreement, or does that just make things even more confusing down the road? Okay. Yeah. Okay. So, suggestion that it would be potentially cleaner to remove that reference, and we'll double check with Andy. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Commissioner Vanderhurst. Oh, I have no problem dropping that condition, although it'll be great to have a bridge. Commissioner. I agree. Okay.

2:40:11 So our recommendation on that is that the commission potentially would feel comfortable about removing that condition, but we do ask you to get legal advice on whether or not we should make any reference to a private agreement. And just as a footnote, for our new commissioners, one of the things that we have worked on are called infrastructure financing districts, which we'll be talking about in the future.

2:40:39 Certainly the pedestrian bridge is something that we have put on that potential list that you would finance in a different way than others than through a private development. I mean, it would be a nice thing to have the bridge. All right, is there any other comments about the bridge? And I agree with the necessity of having that bridge. I mean, if you look at the west end stairs, trying to go down those stairs and going across the avenue is something that we should.

2:41:08 But I will comment that I think that Weston has done in the long term interim here a really nice job of running their shuttle back and forth to the bus stop to get their people up somewhere. I do commend them for that. Alright, so then let's talk about the 8050E Club 50 parking spaces. Who would like to?

2:41:33 I do have a question about that. So there's 259 spaces or so proposed in the project. Does that satisfy the requirement for the hillside project if you're taking out that existing 50? I understand that the 50 parking spaces, the 80-50, was an agreement between, you know, private agreement, but is there enough parking in,

2:42:03 The existing project. Yeah, that's a good question. So the 259, to my understanding, just correct me if I'm wrong, does not include those 50 parking spaces required by the private party agreement. Okay. And that 259 corresponds with the original project entitlement, which has sort of been changed through those additional use permits. And if we are to remove...

2:42:31 The on-site affordable housing, the 35% state density bonus, that number of parking spaces would probably be substantially reduced. So when we come forward with a formal application that reduces that density, we'd put together some new parking requirements. Okay, so I guess my, I'm sorry, go ahead. No, and I was going to say, so staff hasn't included those 50 parking spaces in the parking calculations, but they can be, I mean, that can be included as a calculation with a future application.

2:43:02 So the concern is then, my concern would be that we have a repeat of what happened at the village where there's a lack of parking for people that are there that are not necessarily staying there or valeting their cars. Is there, but so you're saying the requirement will change and they might be required more parking, public parking or? So that 259 parking spaces are really specific to that project. It does not include public parking. Because there's a restaurant in,

2:43:31 In the project, or I'm assuming there's, you know, other, I don't know if there's shops, but I read that there were meetings based in restaurants and stuff. So the assumption is that people that may not be staying there might be visiting there. That's a good question. My understanding is that the parking calculations were provided solely based on the rooms and units counts. Yeah, I think the parking for the retail and restaurant is included in that. Is included. So the project will serve itself.

2:44:01 And, but you're right, there is no public parking provided. It'll serve itself and serve visitors coming, not serving, it won't provide general public parking. Well, yeah, that's what I was just, okay, that's what I'm trying to clarify, okay. So at this point, they're not proposing to have any public parking. But there is, but there is parking for those that are going to, yes, to, and to dine or shop or whatever, spa. They're not specifically allocated that way. Okay. Yeah.

2:44:38 Okay. So I think that's the key, is that whatever the future parking is, it has to meet the current North Village Pacific Plan parking requirements. Okay. My understanding of the 50 spaces was that it wasn't so much that it related to this project or that the people that were staying at the 80-50, but it was more for people that wanted to use

2:45:05 The gondola that came out of the Mammoth Mountain Center. So, I mean, it's kind of a little bit of a convoluted thing. So what we're trying to accomplish now is that you have a project, and that project needs to meet the current stand-alone parking requirements. Okay. Comments on the 850 parking? No, I don't. And I believe Mr. Harvey said they could not find any evidence that the town was party to this.

2:45:39 Private agreement. Staff agree with that? We have a copy of the agreement. But the town is not listed as a part. So again, it comes back to I think what Commissioner Greenick was saying that I have no problem losing that condition. Okay. Do you agree with me? Yes. Do you have any more questions? I don't have any questions. All right. Thank you. It's an issue that seems to resurface at least once a year. Sure.

2:46:07 Which parking or private party agreements? No private party agreements. Because parking comes up much more often than once a year. So we need to become experts on it. Okay. So to recap then our consensus is that as long as it's agreeable with legal counsel, then we would be agreeable to dropping that condition. Yes. Yes. Okay. All right. So let's talk about fees.

2:46:35 As just a general comment, when you read through the staff report, you can sure see how the history of fees since 2006 to today have changed substantially. So I think this is a really important point and maybe, in my opinion, might be the biggest condition that is keeping the property from being marketable today. So with that.

2:47:05 Commissioner Chang, do you have any comments about fees? No, I certainly believe that conformity is important. If everybody is subject to certain fee schedules at this current time, I think this certainly needs to apply to the applicant as well. This particular fee that was referenced here, in lieu fee here, certainly was...

2:47:39 It's based on a different time setting, a different economic setting. And, you know, I agree with, you know, staff's recommendation on this. I'm okay with that, absolutely. Commissioner Randall. Yeah, I'm fine with it. I agree, I'm fine with it as well. So I think we're, all would be in agreement that the applicant could use the current fee schedule. Great.

2:48:20 Do you need any other feedback from us? No, not at this time. No, and I think the only other thing that Dave mentioned but I didn't mention in my presentation today is that we are proposing to update all of the conditions to reflect standard conditions on both planning and engineering side throughout the resolution. So that applies to some really minor things throughout, and we just highlighted the big ones here today.

2:48:51 Mr. Harvey, did you have any other questions for us or need any additional feedback? I've got plenty of direction and staff to formulate a formal commission use permit amendment. Excuse me, Dave Harvey. As that comes together, then we'll be looking forward to being in front of you again with the formal application.

2:49:29 We just want to thank you for coming forward as a workshop. It really, I think, makes it easier in the application process to just look at this first as a workshop before you do your formal application. So I thank you. And I thank you, Ruth and Sandra. Do you have any other comments about this? All right. Then we'll close the business matter number four. And we'll move on to our consent agenda. So our consent agenda was for previous minutes.

2:50:00 For our two new commissioners, if you watch the meeting on TV, you're certainly welcome to vote on this or attend the meeting. Otherwise, it might be proven to recuse yourself if you haven't had any exposure to the actual meeting. That's your decision, so. I do not have any exposure to the actual meeting. So you'll just recuse yourself? Okay. I want to recuse myself as well. All right. So then can I have a motion to...

2:50:30 Approve the consent agenda. Embarrassing question. Was I in attendance? Yes. I know. Okay. I would like to make a motion to approve the minutes of the July 30th meeting 2015. Wait, no, wait. You weren't up there. I didn't. He was here in the beginning. Yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I know what. And then I had to recuse it. He had to recuse himself. Old man's place. Right. So he was here in the beginning. So I would like to make a motion to approve the minutes of the July 30th 2015 Planning Commission meeting.

2:51:00 Oh, second. Commissioner Chang? I recuse myself, yes. Commissioner Grayack? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Commissioner Verruck? I'm recusing myself. Chair Brown? Yes. All right. We'll now move on to commissioner reports. Did the design committee meet? No, he had not. Do you have anything to report? Yeah, just a couple of quick notes of

2:51:36 Positive growth in the town of Mammoth Lakes. So we, as Mammoth Lakes Tourism, received our TOT numbers for June and July of 2015. And June has come in at 14.8% above year over year, which was a record for the second consecutive year. So if it felt busy, it was busy. Good for you. July came in at 11% over last year, which again was a record.

2:52:04 Second consecutive year of record. So I'm pretty happy about June and July. And then we should be getting the August numbers probably within a month in September. Everything seems to have a delay of about 30 days, 30 to 45 days. But, yeah, it felt busy and it was busy. Great. Well, congratulations. To all of us. Right? Good job. May I ask a question about that? Please. What was the budget figure?

2:52:31 We came in at 27% over budget for June and 11% over budget for July. So it was good. And we should have the TBID numbers by our next meeting. But they'll probably be somewhat reflective of the TOT numbers. The hard thing about August now, I don't know if you know or not, is that the L.A. County School District starts school like the third week of August. Yeah, they start them early.

2:53:01 Right. So it really impacts our August. But I know for LA County, then they have the whole week of Thanksgiving off, and then they have three weeks of Christmas time on. So it's going to be interesting to see how all that rolls through. So I know it really impacts my real estate business. My real estate business now drops off right before Labor Day. It used to be hours after Labor Day. So my only commission report was that during the last month,

2:53:31 I spent a lot of time talking to new potential commissioners. And I was really happy to do it. It was really a well worthwhile process. So it was good. So with that, we'll move to the director's report. So just a couple quick things. I sent an email to all of you about some CEQA training, upcoming CEQA training. And as I said in the email, we don't have any budget to pay for the training. However, you're still welcome to go to the training if you'd like.

2:54:00 It's rare that we get training here in town, extremely rare. And the AEP puts on this CEQA training every other year. So two, Ruth and Nolan will be attending from staff, and they'll be coming back to the commission either in October or November with a summary of the training. So if you're not able to attend, we'll try to give you kind of a summary of what they discussed and some handouts and stuff like that. So that should hopefully be helpful.

2:54:28 Our FAR project, so we are updating the zoning code and general plan to change the way we calculate density from rooms and units per acre in the commercial zone to floor area ratio. So we have, we're working on an environmental impact report right now. Our consultant is writing all the sections. So we're doing a lot of coordinating right now, getting stormwater information, information from the library, just kind of all these different.

2:54:55 Pieces are all kind of coming together at this point. So we expect to have the draft out in December. But in the meantime, staff is going to be reviewing administrative drafts so that hopefully when we get the final draft, pretty much have been able to provide a consultant through this process. That's the status on that. And we're extremely busy with building plan checks. We got in like 40 new single-family homes in August because the fees changed.

2:55:28 So we got a ton of single family homes. We got a majority of the condo complexes in the mountainside projects. So a majority of those units have been submitted for building permits. Mountainside. That was John Hooper's. It used to be called the Gray Mountain. Oh, that's interesting. You ran out of gray words. Right. No. It's just not the status you told me. So building our building groups. Gray Bear is moving along full force. Yeah.

2:55:57 So it's been pretty busy. It will be busy in building. All these 40 units are all from John? Yeah, I think so, actually. What was your question? Sorry. All the 40 single-family homes are all from John? We did receive a submittal of Snow Creek 7, which is not John Hoover. That's a couple of the units where there's a pad, but obviously no... Creek House. Creek House. Just four units, I think, there.

2:56:30 So, but yeah, our building division is going to be busy, and we just, we're finalizing all of the new contracts for our outside plan checkers, so we have a much bigger range of plan checkers to pick from now, and I think that's going to be processed, that process is going to work better than it has in the past. That's good news. Yes. And that's all I have? Could you update us on the EIFD status? I remember the consultant was going to take more time to...

2:56:58 Do some more research? Yeah, we've kind of... So do you know what the EIA... Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District? No. Basically tax increment financing. It's a way to fund infrastructure projects. And it's basically, it's something that state legislation has improved and to replace the old redevelopment district. And we...

2:57:27 When we did our main street plan, that consultant at that time introduced us to the topic, and then we hired a consultant who did some work with us about how to move forward with establishing an EIFD here in Mammoth. But, as Sandra will explain, the timing just wasn't quite right. Yeah, I mean, so at this point we're kind of on hold with the process. We wanted to put it on hold to get through all the fee work.

2:57:56 But at this point, we're just kind of on hold. I'm not sure at what point we're going to move forward, but we had difficulty. So basically, this EIFD involves negotiation of tax bodies. So really what it is is the town would give up a portion of our taxes to pay for these infrastructure, our property taxes. So we collect the property taxes. We would give some portion of the increase in property taxes that happen over time to fund projects. So we would have to work with the county, the water district, the fire district. Really, it's the four.

2:58:30 So, we found that, I think we, you know, I think that the county was interested in participating, the fire district was somewhat interested, the water district was really not interested. So, I think we kind of put it on hold to, you know, give us an opportunity to let it settle, let people get more information about it, back to it. Also, right when we called Jim Letty left, so, we were, you know, individual board of somewhat support. Have they replaced him?

2:59:12 No, there's, it's out, I just don't think it'll be out. Probably, I would best guess, it takes a while to, but Linda Salcedo is on the point, so, so right now, you know, I'm not sure how we're going to move forward, I'm kind of, the town manager's kind of taking over, talking about it, and working on it. I'll let you know as soon as we do. It just strikes me as this, it's, it's a project that's a little bit time sensitive. I mean, I don't, I don't want to lose. I agree. Risk losing our window of, of making it even a functional.

2:59:53 Funding mechanism. The risk is as property values go up, we're losing that increment. We're losing the increment. So every single one of those 40 houses that are starting, if we don't have the EIFD in place prior to issuance of CFO, we lose that tax increment. So at least that's just single family homes rather than some of these larger projects that we anticipate coming through.

3:00:23 May I ask, is that money, as in old redevelopment, where the state or the federal government would step in and do matching funds or any type of, so this is just purely monies that we would be collecting? Right, yeah. So the idea is that you're collecting only the increase, the increments, so you can fund, depending on how you do your budget, you can fund what you currently have, but it just impacts your budgets, probably in that interim period.

3:00:53 But the idea is that investing in infrastructure that could create additional investment eventually returns back to us in additional property taxes. But there's that lag when we, if we say we build a bridge or something, you know, we build this piece of infrastructure in order to have, you know, a project move forward, we won't see any of that money until that project is actually operating and then paying property.

3:01:21 So there's a lag, but the idea is the investment creates, our investment creates additional investment. Okay, thank you. So just to back up a second, and this is in the most simplistic form, but let's assume the property values for the Westin 8050 and the Mammoth Hillside property, the base right now is a million dollars. So basically, wait.

3:01:48 And if those three properties were the only three properties in a district, you would say, well, if there was a pedestrian bridge, it would increase the property value. So you go to the county and say, okay, currently the value is a million dollars. We really believe that once we build this bridge, these three properties value will be two million dollars. I mean, this is all hypothetical, right? And so then you negotiate with the other agencies to...

3:02:15 Basically to commit a portion of that increase to the district. So let's assume that they say, well, we'll negotiate 25%, $250,000, but that's $250,000 a year. So then what we would do as the district, and it's not a town because you would form a separate district, you go out and bond against that and build your improvement. So where it becomes time sensitive is if we don't get this done before development happens.

3:02:43 Then the property values are already starting to increase above the baseline. That's a very simplistic version of it. And we do have some good source documents ultimately that we'll share with you to read. But what I was going to say about this is that considering our current constraints, I mean, I really just would like to see us put all our efforts in finishing the CEQA so we can in essence finish our commercial code. I mean, because we're in essence, this is still...

3:03:12 The zoning code update from the general plan. This is how long it's taken to, one, do the code to get approved and now to do the CEQA. So I think we'd all agree that's really our top priority to get that 100% done before we take on another. All right. And then I just thought at some time when we finalize our town development map, it might be just nice that in one of your director's reports,

3:03:45 Or we could even put it as a line item, maybe get Tom here to really just go through what's on that map as far as approved projects, concepts, et cetera, so everybody would really get a good overview of what's happening in the town. Well, thank you. Does anybody else have any other comments, questions? The scenario, the explanation we just provided for the economic, what is it called, EIFC? Enhanced.

3:04:21 Infrastructure Financing District. Does that only apply to certain property types? Well, you, that is part of the process, is you establish a district or districts, okay, and so you would determine, you know, where you'd want it. So at one time... So anything within that district will be assessed. Right. But it would have to be, you know, negotiated. Sure.

3:04:53 And all the county entities, you're talking about like the district, do all parties have to agree? Or is it just, so let's say if the county says yes, water district says no. Then the water district doesn't participate. They don't have to participate, but you can continue to move forward. Right, yeah. So usually you do districts like in commercial zones or specific plans versus like a residential neighborhood.

3:05:23 Because you would theoretically want to make some sort of connection or nexus between the infrastructure that you might be planning to the increase in property values in that area. Sure. So, I mean, you wouldn't create a district in a residential neighborhood that would then create funds for a pedestrian bridge across town because there's no connection between the two. Correct. Okay. Well, once again, I'd like to welcome the two of you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:05:57 Thank you very much for coming this morning. I think it was really an important part of our starting off wells and new commission. With that, I move that we adjourn to our next regular meeting to be held on October 14, 2015 at 2 p.m. in the Council Chambers of Suite Z. Thank you very much. Thank you.