Town Council Special meeting
· recording 5 hr 38 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
632 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:44 Good morning. Good morning.
1:08 Thank you.
1:24 You never know. I know.
2:22 Oh, I just missed one word. I cut all the rest of my file. This is setting deposits, so this is the right page. Yeah, exactly.
2:37 What's that? I think there were six other places.
4:26 Okay, we're going to call to order our special meeting for town, Lankstown Council, Thursday, August 27th. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Yes, here. Here. Here. Here. Please rise and call me for the pledge, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.
4:55 And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
5:25 So we have a little Gordon up here reminding us of what's going on. Great. Thanks, Joe. Any public comment on today's meeting? You can sit on your lap. Hi, I'm Craig Schmidt from the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I'll be unable to attend on Monday's meeting, and also my board president will not be able to attend, so I came today to reaffirm our commitment and our partnership with the town with all things regarding economic and workforce development.
6:00 So I want you to know that we want to be a strong partner with you in whatever you decide here this next couple of days. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else want to comment? Okay, seeing that, I'll turn it over to Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. The workshop today kind of continues the work we started about a year ago in working through goals and objectives with the town council and looking at kind of helping set forward a plan that goes beyond the fiscal year and actually extends out.
6:31 This year we're building off of the work that you did a year ago.
6:56 But also expanding it in a couple of different areas. One, this kickoff workshop is taking a look at what we've accomplished and where we've been. But also a stronger engagement with the town staff, some of the activities there in that process. We're also kind of titling this and working through a strategic alignment. But it's not just the success of the town council and staff work to bring things together for our community.
7:23 And also looking at looking at
7:52 Our process has been in line with those. We also have a number of other partners out there, be it the county, the Forest Service, the schools, others, but the focus and the workshop is set up to really focus on those that you have more of a direct relationship with funding-wise and ultimately some level of responsibility and authorities in working with a direct relationship. Last year we had Bill Davis do the
8:18 Facilitating with us. He was actually recommended by Michael Ward, who will be the facilitator today, so I'll turn it to him in a moment. Most of you know Mr. Warden. He's worked with Mammoth Select Recreation, the Eastern Sierra Collaborative, and other work. He's also a long-term partaker of the recreational experience in Mammoth, so he knows the community very well and has done a variety of
8:46 Facilitated workshops throughout the area here and frankly around the world. So very well versed in the process. And he'll be taking us through the process today and ultimately four sessions as we've worked toward, again, setting forward another set of goals, priorities, and vision for the council and for our community as we look to the future. With that, I'll throw to Michael if you can add any additional introductory remarks and we'll dive in. So that's good. Good morning to everybody. Thank you all for coming.
9:15 And especially thank you for giving me another reason to come and visit Mammoth. Although my preferred approach is to come and hit the trails. I'm not committed to do that today, but I thank you. Members of the public, we are going to offer, we're going to do a workshop in eight hours today, seven hours today. We're going to do this in four segments. Kind of a morning segment, take a mid-morning break. Don't call me to the time, somewhere around 10 o'clock. It's a long morning. We have a lunch.
9:44 Around noon, noon-ish, something like that will take 30 to 45 minutes. By agreement with you, we're out of here in three days, so no afternoon break. We'll offer comment opportunities at the end of each of the segments. Maybe 10 minutes, we'll try and allocate that so we'll provide everybody an opportunity. I apologize, we did rearrange the room. We changed from the front there to the front here because it's just a more facile space to sort of collect.
10:12 So that's by way of layout. You have a couple of handouts.
10:42 You already received an agenda in advance. You should have something that looks like this, which is page four of last year's strategic planning documents. I think yours are, if you don't have one, Brady, do you mind? You got one, okay. Anybody appear to not have one? Has some extras? Yeah. Out here? Yeah.
11:12 That is page four of last year's strategic planning document, and it was the summary in one page long bullet form of what was called a practical vision. Instead of forming a vision statement, you have a vision that is comprised of
11:43 A half dozen seven elements or so. And those elements I've kind of enlarged here. I can't read that. This is not a traditional strategic planning workshop. You should actually breathe a sigh of relief about that because we're not going to go through the ponderous process of developing mission, vision, values, goals, objectives, strategies, and so on.
12:09 Because in a sense, a year ago, you all did a pretty good job, in my view, of putting that framework together. You've got vision elements in the near term, three to five years. You've got some very practical strategies. Some of them, I think, are functioning objectives. Some of them are already complete. We're going to take a look at that in just a minute. Some of them are true strategy frameworks. They're ideas about where you'd like to go.
12:38 And how you might get there. So we're going to try and elaborate on that and build on that a little bit. But why do all of that? So I'm going to call this kind of a strategic plan tune-up exercise in the sense that we're going to take a look at what you've already decided a year ago, see where you are in the process of implementing and make the smallest number of revisions necessary to keep you going. I'm a big believer in momentum.
13:07 In strategic planning more than the process of continuous planning. It's damaged. I've had the privilege of doing this around the Sierras. I was the statewide director for economic development in California for seven years. I worked in all 58 counties. I did regional collaborative projects, public-private, in every county. I worked with higher ed, economic development, the chambers of commerce, the business community.
13:36 And what I've observed, particularly over the last 15 or 20 years, is a process of continuous planning that's exhausting, expensive, and not translating into practical, functional results. So in working with Dan and thinking about this event today and the meeting on Monday and a couple of meetings to follow, and the reason we laid out four is we thought, let's
14:05 Create a strategy that aligns the town with its functional partners and its critical, close to the best partners. We'll call those MLT. You guys have the acronym soup here to death. More than any community I've ever worked with. MLR, MLT, MLH, ESTA. Do I have that all right? Yes. Okay, so I have some background with a few of those.
14:31 So we're going to see if we can't create some functional alignment, and we'll talk about that. I've got preliminary graphic. And at the end of four meetings, by October 8th, I hope we'll arrive at some place like this. So the purpose, did this go out? Yeah, you guys came out here. So I think I put a copy of that. So the purpose, I'm going to read this out, is to...
15:00 Define, and this is me actually translating back from extensive dialogue with Dan. This was me giving it back in proposal form. Define and activate a strategy-driven process that clearly aligns and integrates the non-governmental organizations in the law, MLT, MLH, and STA, perhaps another, if you suggested, with the town of Mammoth Lakes to achieve
15:28 Sustainable economic security for the community. That's a lot of words in a long sentence, kind of a vision statement for the process, if not for the talent. What are the words in that purpose statement? You have it in front of you, it's at the top of this sheet. And I have a few more of these. What are the words in that purpose statement that stand out to you?
16:02 I think the center of gravity here is...
16:43 is the outcome framework, which is a sustainable, economically viable community now in the near term, in the mid term, and over the long term. My hope is that over four meetings we'll actually get to that long term piece, but in a little counterintuitive move, instead of doing visioning work today, I've planted that in the third session.
17:11 So that we have a really strong foundation for understanding what the strategy is, how you will align and integrate all these functions, and then we can capture a vision for sustainable economic security. So we'll do that in the third session, which I think is September 10th. Today it's really about the town and staff, town council and staff.
17:40 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
18:11 Direct stakeholders in the community. Part-time itinerant residents, and I live in Tahoe, we just refer to second home owners. It's just become our shorthand for that. So people who are stakeholders in the sense that they're property owners, but don't live here all the time. In fact, live here seasonally, or live here for two weeks at a time. And of course, your visitor-guest framework. And from my experience,
18:39 And then today what I hope we'll walk out of here with is
19:09 Kind of one year review of progress. That's just for the purpose of establishing where you are, basically where you planned to be a year ago. But Dan's already provided, I believe, an update report in June, so we're going to take another quick slice look at that. We're going to look, we're going to surface out some contradictions that might fit in the way of the strategy, the aligning and integrating part before achieving this kind of outcome.
19:39 Let's see if you can tell some of those a little bit. I like to turn, contradictions are just sort of the nagging suspicion you have in the back of your mind that something won't work, or the words are fancier than the outcome that is possible, and I like to take all that and convert them into how-to statements, future-focused, positive kinds of outcomes.
20:05 And then we're going to look at what this strategy alignments, strategy driven process that alignments, what does that look like from your perspective so that we can invite your NGO partners, Frank and his folks, John and his folks, MLR, all of those groups on Monday and scan in their perspective to start to pull you together like a little centrifugal
20:34 We're going to be a central force. We're going to be a central force, I guess. It's the opposite of pushing out. It's pulling in. So we're going to try to pull to the center and have you be that center of gravity. That's our theory of change here, by the way. And then we're going to get a multi-stakeholder profile after we're going to help inform this process. And we're going to walk out of here today. You should have a pretty good idea of what it is you want to accomplish, what you want from your partners.
21:04 So that's the process. I've kind of tried to lay out the meetings as I've had preview agendas and laid out the outputs from those meetings with the caveat that that's all subject to revision on the basis of what you decide.
21:35 So that's the framework. Does that work for you all? That's a lot of work. That's a lot of commitment on your part, and you're already making this great commitment, so thank you in advance for that. So I wanted to start with a quick little exercise. Given this purpose in your focus on achieving sustainable economic security through the mechanism of allowing and integrating, and as you think about where you are today,
22:05 I am certain that we can, just want your top of mind reaction to that, I'm certain, given our purpose, I'm certain that we can, or I'm not sure
22:36 It does appear comfortable. I'm worried that. Give me a second to think about that. The person who looks most ready will start. If you're smiling at me, that would be you. So, I am not sure your name is... Hey, Sarah. Nice to meet you. Sarah, I am certain that we can, but I'm not sure. Michael, I apologize.
23:12 Given this purpose on where we are today against the plan that you drafted a year ago, what I'm looking for is your gut coverage. And certainly we can do anything with the right resources. How about on this side? So am I saying anything specific or at least general? It's up to you. It's top of my gut. You don't have this.
23:57 I'm not sure we can have economic security without compromising the environment. Who wants to go next? John. I'm certain that we can compel people to come to Mammoth Lakes. I'm not sure what they're going to find when they get here. I'm not sure what they're going to find when they get here. I'm not sure what they're going to find when they get here. So you're certain we can attract, yes? Yeah.
24:51 I'm certain we can achieve our vision. I'm not sure we can achieve our vision. I have a different way to say that. I would say that I'm not certain that we can focus to actually pick from this group and have more successes. We've gotten some so far, but we have this tendency to not focus and to get pulled in too many directions to actually commit.
25:43 And I'm certain that we will accomplish some of this, but I'm not certain that we really know which ones are the important ones. The certain side is that we will make progress on some of these, but even last year it was too much to get done in 18 months, and I don't think we've ever been realistic and focused. So a little bit got done on a lot instead of some good successes. Not that we're through the 18 months yet, but...
26:22 Great insight. This is actually a really common problem in strategic planning, why I made a comment about continuous planning. There's a huge tendency because of the way we do these kinds of processes and workshops to capture everything. Try to prioritize, but the prioritization really becomes everything is high priority.
26:46 And we can actually focus. The ability to focus and prioritize and I'm just an enormous believer that less is more. Who would like to go next? I think we certainly will continue to build our summer visitors. I'm not certain that we will continue.
27:18 Kind of along those lines,
28:00 I'm certain that we have the capability to make the paradigm shift to a year-round market expansion, which is like one of those specific topics we have up there. I'm not certain that we keep our eyes on the prize. I'm certain that we can create a premier destination resort.
29:11 I'm not sure that we can create the same premier destination community. You just moved through the continent down for us. That was good. I'm Ruth. Ruth. Michael. I'll take that. All my comments about continuous plan. Okay. I think mine's a little in line with Dan's. I'm certain we can improve the relationships and productivity with NGOs, but I'm not sure.
29:57 If we'll be able to, since it's going to be a little long, how we do that in a way that adequately addresses the issues and the problems we've outlined for both visitors and long-term residents. Call all constituents. Perfect. So I'll capture it later. We're going to redefine that. Green, are you up? No, I'm certain we can accomplish some of the policies in the direction of council in terms of projects. I'm not certain we can do that if we try to please everybody.
30:39 There's so many diverse interests. Another insight from strategic planning, the attempt to please everybody causes groups and leadership councils to compromise and adopt laundry lists so that everything becomes equivalent in terms of its value and its impact and importance. Nice to meet you.
31:27 I'm certain we'll hire a police chief, like you said, that's a joke. I'm certain we can build upon our current collaborators and create new ones. I'm not certain that they'll always have a shared vision. I was going to ask, Clark's been busily working capturing this so people can read it, but I want to make sure that she doesn't do it.
32:20 Too busy working and not engaged in the process. Yes, and we met earlier, so sure. I'm certain the squeaky wheel gets greased, and I'm not certain the squeaky wheel is where we should be focusing our priorities. So I'm going to treat, I'm not certain the squeaky wheels are our priorities as the segue, the other segue.
33:13 to the next piece of this. I got one final one. Okay. We're going round two here? Mayor gets two. Mayor gets two. I'm certain that we have tons of opportunity in Mammoth, and I'm not certain we can get out of our own way. So we'll conclude this exercise on that. Now, any insights just from, I don't know, you probably can't read all this, but you've got them off on the screen if that's helpful. Any insights, quick insights?
34:01 Well, I actually have this kind of pulled up on my screen right now, but my insight around this is there's a quote from Mark Cuban that we reference a lot, which is, sales cure all, and this idea that as a
34:30 As a council, as a community, we have very limited resources. And so, in light of us, I think, so I think that's, that's, I would say that's true in every community, everywhere. And the question is how to shift out of a resource-intensive mindset to a resources-we-have mindset. And then again, to disconnect between what you have to get things done with and where you want to go can become a chasm that's too,
35:40 I have enough insight about this community having worked here a few times
36:10 The big strategy here is not a magical way to convert resources to more settings, but the theory that
36:39 So we're going to see how this works. So I want you to be confident.
37:09 I want you to, anybody that was operating here, I want you guys, because we're sitting next to each other, I want you to suspend this belief that we can't get this done and embrace the idea that we're the right resources we can. And this is the second highest year of TOT revenue ever on town record. So how we're so stretched maybe has a lot to do with that squeaky wheel. Well, you guys have hinted at other things. You've got...
37:38 You've got some seasonal fluctuations. You've got some environmental fluctuations where we're going to have a Godzilla El Nino or a Godzilla bust. And so maybe we continue to have this pattern of episodic environmental conditions that are or are not conducive. You actually have to plan and execute through all that variability.
38:03 I live in Tahle. I do a great deal in community where people complain about this stuff all the time. And I say, to what end? It is what it is. Our job is to execute with what we have and call it a good day. So that's what we're going to try to do. So let's take a look at where you are today versus where you said you wanted to be a year ago. So I've just kind of blown up.
38:31 I just took this sheet that you have, but I just enlarged them. You may or may not be able to read them. That's the biggest font I can get on a six-foot wall. But I wanted to invite you to, and I know Dan has provided a report on this, so I wanted to invite you to consider a quick status update. I wanted you to use four ideas. Either the strategic objective has been completed,
38:59 And we'll check it off. Or it's in process and you want to keep it as is, as currently stated. Or you want to revise it. If you want to revise it, I'll capture that over here. We're not going to wordsmith these. Just want your general idea about how to revise. And if it's no longer relevant, if it wasn't a priority to begin with or for any other reason, you just want to drop it.
39:28 So complete, keep, revise, or delete. I have in my hands here a copy of the answer for it, so I have some updated information. The very first one was, this is the category of enhancing community amenities. We all have this in front of you.
39:54 The first assignment there was groundbreaking for the new shoreline trail and first amenity. The actual trail is still in the deeper process. We're working on that, so it's in the process in that respect. The other thing we are working on there that would add to that would be some parking and enhanced parking facilities into the trail, minimal amenity created with that. So if the groundbreaking, what was the first
40:31 The second half of the first amenity relates to B and D, and it was intended to be by the 18 months, not by 12.
41:06 So I'm going to say you keep it if it's in process because to your point, it's either done or it's not done that you want to keep going on it. If you don't want to keep going on it, let's take it out. So any debate on this one? So we're going to keep... The other first amenity component there to tie together is with the abundance.
41:37 Next summer schedule potentially would be the Muppet Lake George, that would be actually a trail amenity that would be a new construction item. That's just the connector point there along from Pocono Beach to Lake George Trail. So are you proposing that we... I think that's still tactical, but that's an amenity that will be constructed next construction season.
42:06 Next one was enhanced community amenities and strategic plan, use of measure, food, and farm resources. I think that was a reminder to you to do this book. What's your disposition? You bet it's in progress. It's in progress. Do you be combined? Well, I say we leave them as they are and we just indicate they're in process because there's a slight difference between
42:36 The use of the RNU and then the list of amenities because the amenities are going to take other funding as well. I still see that they're separate. So let's skip to these since we're talking about it. Maniflake's recommendation to finalize and prioritize list of operational amenities projects. Definitely. I think B and D are very long track. We've got a strategic due in December.
43:08 That's within the 18 months. I think B and D are very close to being checked afterwards. Okay. How about C then? Successful engagement with the International Forest Plan? Well, when we had the review of it, we did identify that that's more of a staff line. When we, that's continuing, but it needs to be kept, it's in process. It may not be moving as fast as...
43:35 Little A, little B, and little D aren't, but it still needs to be there. Yeah, we are, it's in the hands of a federal agency who may not be having the next draft until December, so it's engaged. We're engaged, but it's not. It's on our hands in case we don't know much about it. I go back to some of the partnership meetings that earlier. We had a partnership with the Forest Service, but we don't control their processes, so timing and other elements, or engaging with them, or trying to comment where we need to be.
44:05 I don't know if this is an add-on to that, but I have some concerns about, from an operational partner perspective, our relationship with our local district and with our forest. Right now it's in the rubric, it's under the context of the forest plan revision. I know the staff has been doing a very
44:34 We can't steward those lines properly.
45:03 Was preventing it? I'm not sure. I don't know if any preventing it. It's just, it's kind of an existential concern I have that if we don't keep in sync with our promotional and our marketing capacity, we're not on the same page with all of the resources we give. And part of that, frankly, is one is the individuals that are there and how we work together. Another one goes back to what Sarah starts in the beginning with the right resources.
45:45 They have no resources, and we have limited, we're improving those. We have Joel, we have a trails coordinator now. They've just hired somebody to fill a spot that was there before, so if we can get the staffing levels up to where they need to be, we can move forward better. Right now, it's real tough that even if we send something to them, they can't get to it for three months, and I can't blame them for that. They don't have anybody. I absolutely agree. If we get the resources up, we can get started.
46:14 So Dan and I, Dan made a comment, but he and I were talking about this last night, that we're going to refer later this morning to kind of above the line and the local line partnerships, and we're going to say above the line are all the MTOs that are close to your vest with whom you have a functional or contractual or a very specific relationship. The local line are all the necessary partners, like the Forest Service, with whom
46:40 You cannot ask them to align their strategic plan with yours, but at the high level, but at the practical process, resource expenditure level, what gets prioritized level, you can begin to observe more direct influence and proactively. So I know the SRC is trying to do that as well. So we're going to try to make those distinctions here without dismissing the need.
47:09 And defining a practical way to do that. I think we're going to capture that. How about the fifth item under, this was all into enhancing community amenities, that was the original element. The fifth item was enhance and expand transit services to meet the goal of being a first community. It means the South Hollywood Museum of pedestrian funding. First community.
47:40 I think certainly that falls in the keep category because we have a long way to go to achieving a feet first community. But there has been tangible enhancements and expansions of our transit services like the Lake Space Central.
48:01 So I think that's been pretty well executed. So this sounds like pretty positive progress to me. Any different views on this?
48:36 I think the other element there, again, it goes to that secondary partnership. We have a direct relationship with ESCA for a lot of the town elements, but they also have contracts with the ski area and services in the area. It would be much more congested, transportation modes, and so the use is going up. One question to kind of bring reliable, and I'm wondering, this is an old one. Do we have the tools of decision-makers to stand? In some cases, probably not as much. I think ESCA has that. ESCA does, yeah. But they're shipped off.
50:21 So you're getting ridership data? Yeah. And so how about for a public safety system? Well, it's definitely a improvement to have more services later and anecdotally gone down. Also, we have a better increase, and not even just drunk driving, we've just been intoxicated in public safety-wise, you know, people potentially going to follow the snow and passing out.
51:10 So your citations are down, your lists are down, independent of jobs and visitors?
51:23 Jobs and visitors?
51:26 In other words, are your rate of citations trending with the volume of the citations?
51:34 It's the best I can tell you, it's the same as Stephen and in compared with him.
51:39 Thank you.
51:48 I might suggest a revision if you want to consider to this, and just because I don't, I don't recall a lot of time talking about bicycles. You know, we have the mumps, we have things, but the old man with drone doesn't, you know, the old man doesn't work for bicycles. It's just one don't work. It's not really addressed here, so maybe we can expand the transit and be first to bicycles. That's something the longer range we can do.
52:13 So the question, you look at that multi-mortal concept, it's walking, be it right, be it transit. That's true, but I think the transit was made with the recognition that ESTA is the important extension of us, whereas our ability to control the individual bike riders is limited. I guess the question there would be is if we deal with our public infrastructure, do we have a focus in
52:42 I think it'd be important to be cognizant of it. Every other person that's up here in the summer is on a bike, and the utilization of something like the Lake Mary Path.
53:10 The proposed revision is a simple semantic adjustment to, it sounds like not just an ad, but.
53:45 Okay, so the next big functional area was improved air service and we have three
54:22 Three functional items there. One was an air terminal plan to accommodate future growth in air service and to define the magic plan for the terminal. That's in practice. Well, we've had success there with the ALB.
54:37 I think, yeah, really the piece of that is laying out the defined financial plan, but ALB has been approved, which is good. So ALB has been approved.
55:04 Any comments on the financial plan that we should add to this planning document since we're taking a moment to report return? Does that make, does that, that's clear to you? It's been, it's just very strongly in progress. We're very focused on it. We're working with FAA on a weekly basis, so. It's been beyond the current time horizon. And I think it's also that that is important, that detailed financial plan. We've seen some signs of life with potential regional partners.
55:31 So the degree where that financial plan is kind of getting daylight and coming to the surface, it becomes useful to helping out with you and see. So it's not so much a terminal that we get to ask God and things like that. Let me also just clarify, because I've put your comment a couple times, I'm not actually trying to drag your 18-month targets to a 12-month time frame. I want to simply reaffirm your targets because in the fourth workshop, we're actually going to
56:03 So the next one was
56:31 Airport may have an alternative to keeping care of reliability. Yeah, we have some new version alternatives now in place. We did a couple of those last year. So we're continuing to do that moving forward. Does that mean that it's completed? No, we just did a couple last year, so we're going to continue to work on that.
56:58 And what's the process for determining... Right, but determining those... Right, but how do we determine which flights do get that treatment versus others that don't? Well, right now, while we're working with Alaska, we don't have it.
57:20 We did United last year. We're working on Alaska and San Diego. We converted two United plans to San Francisco last year during Christmas week. We wanted to make sure they got here. And we are doing the same thing with Alaska this year, probably because of the distance and probably just San Diego.
57:48 I'm still, so you said there were a couple of flights that were diverted, I'm just not. Right, so what made those fall into the category of they received diversion treatment versus another flight that didn't? I think United was willing to do it.
58:17 I mean, a lot of that, a lot of that had to do with the fact that it was timing, that it was a holiday week, that there were full planes, that there were probably people going along the period. You know, we have talked about having certain levels moving from San Diego this year. If a plane was more than half full, you convert it. If not, it's just, it's, it's, it's, it turns out to be a cost to us, so it's something that we have to take all that into consideration. And really, it's, you know, we had 34 and a half cancellations last year, but 0.2 for weather.
58:43 One other thought with this, which is, again, to go back to my parent of mine, is the T-Bid and the subsidy. And when is the T-Bid up for, when is the date on that? I mean, that's way beyond this horizon, but it's part of the foundation.
59:16 The other thing, the other success we had there real quick was we used to have a night restriction in terms of some of the times. That's been lit in the window for, they've actually used that in terms of the use of adding to flexibility in that time. Yeah, that's another restriction. We used to be able to only take out to the. Yeah, so that helps a little bit in terms. The other thing I need to mention, and it's longer than 18 months, but it's related to alternate air reliability, is at our own, you know,
1:00:08 Interest and from FAA perspective, they want us to continue to talk to Bishop about longer term things. So it doesn't need to change anything. I just want to mention that. So again, we do it every time. And we always tell FAA that we're at least working on it. We're looking at regional issues. So just keep that in mind. That, which is B, there's one component, which is going to John was talking with the airlines we have, but continuing that regional dialogue.
1:00:35 B is the shorter term 18 month and continual, I would say, thing. The longer range with Bishop, we're going to continue those conversations to the regional air service. Again, it's an ongoing, much longer goal. When we get to that fourth workshop, I'm actually hoping that we will not just cast you out 18 months ago on a practical, tactical action plan, but we'll set some longer term targets so that you can point Bishop.
1:01:04 Correctly. The last piece on the air service was Yogan Mark expansion. Could be essentially, are you talking about that or not? Well, it really comes with our, you know, with our thermal expansion. So it's kind of the summative goal of A and B are executed? Yeah. So a lot of these are not completely different.
1:01:38 Isn't this supposed to be like a really tangible thing for people to say, yay, we did? Well, I think part of it was, you know, because you get it started, you know, the idea was to get it started. Maybe you're not going to achieve it in 18 months, but then I think you can do a period of the process and then you kind of get that spark. So it's not necessarily a conclusion, you can have 20 minutes. So I think it's just to remember the council, this community, as far as I know, has never done something like this. So the idea that you talk with Dan is about,
1:02:08 Getting the larger idea of doing this kind of getting it rolling. We're going to be transitioning some of these things. There's going to be five-year things or things like that. We'll get to more annual things we're going to get done this year, specifically specific 12-month kind of goals, things that have a long horizon. John, you were shaking your head. No, I'm just going to say on this one, we did expand, based on this being October 14, we did expand in Denver last year. So we did expand the market.
1:02:36 So does it make sense, again, from a semantic perspective, rather than
1:03:04 I mean, there is market expansion because we added markets. But as far as right-sizing, we have right-sized the other markets too. We've cut back on some of the flights. We've gone some peak days. We're still offering service, but we're not offering it on a, you know, we've got San Francisco that we had a conversation yesterday. We're probably going to fly one flight seven days a week. We're not going to have a second flight.
1:03:32 I'm just thinking that that idea of the right sizing of optimizing things and getting things is something for a lot of these things that we're doing. It's a good way to be thinking about how we do this or do anything. You know, I just have to throw in that when we're talking about the right size, that's a bigger issue that hopefully we'll talk about in this next meeting, third meeting, fourth meeting, because there's right sizing and there's
1:03:56 I think that when we talk about it, right-sizing is a decision-making criteria.
1:04:24 It's not necessarily part of the strategy. Everything we do better have right size and quality. So to me, it's a criteria, not a strategy itself. So I've added it over here on this margin list, and we're going to essentially append kind of your suggested votes to these strategies. These aren't just us in that exercise. I think we're trying to figure out, is this a vision statement? Is this a qualitative improvement? Are you trying to get tactical about how?
1:04:53 The last thing I'd add in response to Sarah's comment is that, you know, you're right, these are much longer term, but what I'm hoping is in the fourth meeting we say, okay, but in 18 months we're going to have the environmental, we're going to have a milestone type of thing. A lot of things we do are much longer term, so if we want to set a tangible milestone, we can't build a terminal in 18 months, but maybe we can do X. John, you had kind of specifically called out summer as a subsidy that you don't see going down.
1:05:22 In the short term, and therefore market expansion for the summer is not necessarily on the horizon. Can you take that second piece in there a little bit as far as is that subsidy dropping? What are your short term thoughts on the winter? Subsidy, it's all weathered in the wintertime obviously. Last year, December, LA gave us. Right. Unfortunately, the rest of the season went back down too from the pain.
1:05:51 So what we've done with the right-sizing there is we've gone and said, okay, we've always had two LA flights during the peak part of the season. We've knocked that second flight down to four days. So Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday, peak days, and then we're going to get a higher load factor. So what you're going to see is you may see that the number of flights aren't as high as they used to be, but the actual load factors, the capacity of planes, so 76 passenger planes, if there's 76 people on it, 100% load factor. Right.
1:06:18 So, we've really gone to try and make sure that we're offering the service as much as we can during the peak times, and then we're going to fill it, and we're trying to make the planes, we're trying to get the planes as full as possible. And then what we can do is we can ratchet those back up. San Diego is a perfect example. It was seven days a week. Two years ago, last year we went four days a week, and the four days a week was far more successful out of San Diego than we've done in seven days. You know, basically you're looking at...
1:06:47 And as the business comes back, we'll look at adding, you know, either back to San Diego, we may look at going seven days a week, or we may have a second flight, four days a week, so that will be better.
1:07:15 And then that has to be balanced against Michael's previous comment about if you're going to build mid-week, well, if we end up not being able to afford to have a plane flight to get them here or let them leave on next day instead of Sunday, we're going to have to play that balance again, too. Well, I think the idea is that with both airlines, we have seven days a week. So even though Denver is only a Saturday flight.
1:07:37 People can fly into the front range on Saturday, and they can stay until Tuesday to fly back after San Diego. So we've got options. We'll be able to L.A. seven days a week, so even so many flies up from San Diego on Tuesday, and we'll fly back to San Diego. They can still connect through L.A., which a lot of people do, which is bizarre, but they fly to San Diego through L.A. Yeah, I mean, our goal is to reduce the low-revenue guarantee to the subject cost of COVID-19. That's the goal.
1:08:05 But I think Shields just pointed out that the ultimate long-term goal is expansion. I see that as part of that paradigm shift that I was alluding to. Yeah, my comment about... That's the long-term goal. Yeah. Okay.
1:08:28 We'll use the words expansion and growth interchangeably throughout the course of today and the next three sessions because they're directly the keys to this outcome. That's what we're trying to get to. Two good comments. We're not only going to look at the use of alignment as a way of bringing you and your partners close together. We're going to actually look at alignment within and across these kind of vision elements so that we're not...
1:08:56 So, if the first two pieces were about community amenities and air capacity, this third piece was about municipal capacity, and Mammoth Lakes made six of these, and the first one was to fill the
1:09:18 So the status is chief hiring. Obviously we should just quit now. We've got a few things in this area that we checked out, which is great. So that one's done. Regional solution for any additional permits. So we can drop that. So anything that's in the complete or delete, unless you want to revise it and update it,
1:09:49 Another, maybe there's another step for some reason. Anything, anything we can do to shorten this list is part of my goal. If it's too long for the board, it's too long for life. A regional solution for a police facility needs to be implemented by December 2017. Are you activating? December 17 will have a new police facility construction.
1:10:18 Is that regional? Is that local? That's local, but we've had regional partner discussions in terms of how does it fit with the courts and future planning processes. So, you know, we haven't gotten to the point where we're relocating to jail or something. Yeah, but don't be a holding facility which has a reading. No, no. We will not have a holding facility. No. We'll have a legitimate. We'll have a legitimate. Shorter term. It's going to be a bridge port alternative. No, no.
1:10:49 What you will have is the right process and code itself so you can actually process them. So you've heard that it's not a whole intent where you put it in the night, it's a two or three hour just a place to save and manage your processing. And then you just get there. You don't understand what I'm saying. What's the regional solution for police to save?
1:11:16 Well, that was the idea of talking to the sheriff, the CHP, and the reports, and making whatever the solution was fit in with their strategies as well. But we will have the facility and we will have, it'll be... That's right, that's right. I think it's, you are going to have the facility. Yeah. We are going to be in our conversation. There's a great, great information in the sheriff.
1:11:46 So we're going to put this key for the best units.
1:12:23 How about a new functional conventional system? Yes. That's an unknown.
1:12:52 I would say you're never going to have it finished. Getting rid of the old one has to be completed. Right. And so there's a transition point there where is it a council strategy at that level or this has moved down to a tactical staff level to work out the bugs, complement it, do the work. Yeah. And if they're reporting whether it stays at the council level, I guess would be my question at this point. At the end of the 18 months,
1:13:22 Well, that's kind of what I'm saying is, you know, the funds have been allocated, it's been purchased, there's been training, there's been transition going on. I don't believe that we needed that. I think it's complete and then for our next 18 months we'll... Well, so yeah, it's a non-based process. Yeah. Continue supporting. Right. Yeah. Or continuing integration of other systems, that kind of stuff. Yeah, I think to Jo's point, from the council perspective, there's a degree in which other things aim to...
1:13:51 It's an ongoing process with technology. As Joe mentioned, I think it's... I think your fiduciary function is to steer the ship. So you want to provide direction. You don't need to tell manager gets to own this with this. Next one is negotiating staffing and organizational plan. This is huge. The 21st century municipal government knows his plan come down.
1:14:44 Let's talk about this one. Yeah, what does that mean? Yeah. I mean, it's big. It sounds great. I like stuff that sounds great. But what does it mean? Is that translatable? Well, I think you know the outcome that we can focus? I think why you're highlighting this is this is essentially the framework of this process. We were talking about how we are shifting the way that our government functions.
1:15:15 And a big piece of that is that we have specifically gone down these track NGOs and delivering services in a different manner. And now that we've kind of put them on a separate track, it's about, you know, realigning everybody's main goal. That's mostly what we're talking about. No, that's exactly what I agree. It's definitely a key. And there's also another piece of it is that we, as council, have to recognize that we will be negotiating something.
1:15:50 So, in a sense, this is a two-part strategy here. The first part is to negotiate, say, on an organizational plan. The second one is, through that process, to achieve the 21st century, is there any qualitative piece or note that we want to add?
1:16:20 I would say, I would throw out an idea, which is to maybe break this into two pieces. The first thing is to Collins' point, the work that we're doing with the NGOs, this is exactly what we're doing. We need to figure out, from the town's perspective, what are the key vital core services that we have to provide, so that we're working in a contracted partnership. This isn't just like a partnership with a new centrality.
1:16:50 Contracting relationship with these NGOs. What do we as a town, what are the things we really got to be able to do right so that they can succeed at our direction so the whole thing works symbiotically? I mean, they work with staff so often. Exactly. But in terms of, you know, who's got to have what capacities? I mean, we don't want to be duplicating capacities. We don't want to have three of the same things we want to figure out. Okay, what are the things the town legally has to do that we have to do really well to consequently get that stuff figured out? Right, the idea that Grady needs to maintain.
1:17:19 Right. And there are things that...
1:18:27 It's tough because it's very broad in that, but the other side of that you're looking at, I look at that as we're dealing with the other partners
1:19:20 We actually have, so we have different structures and we also have small steps, but how do you move, how do you actually do, it's shifting out, I have to be more, on the other hand, we still have, but we're also doing more out to the customer, on the building side, in terms of our outreach, we're at the expertise side and outreach, and so there's a different way of providing services versus out, a facilitated process versus policy, procedure, legal process, react to cultural shift advice.
1:20:30 That goes, and we do a lot of it well, but that goes from everything from a set person in Canada. The broad sense of that, I think when you look at, you know, a lot of Roddy's unsuccessful company, you see where people are doing. Some of it applies directly, some of it doesn't, but I think there's a lot of shifting in terms of, at the same time, letting our customers drive some of that because their expectations still are set. I can show up at town hall and find. And that's a key part of how the expectations of our car provide better services than everybody's expectations. Yeah.
1:21:34 It ties back to the practical vision on enhanced community pride. I think if we have really strong customer service skills, employees are happy in providing the customer service, people that come in and leave happy, then we're going to have enhanced community pride. Oh, our town rocks. They're so awesome. They helped us so much. So there's not a lot on here about customer service.
1:22:01 The other side of that I see from an employee base is we are part of what makes a great community, how we engage in events, how we engage in activities, both internally and even more so externally. We have a lot of employees that are involved in various civic organizations and stuff like that, and highlighting that as a value. So the town is seen as part of that community engagement in a real sense, not just like volunteer over here, but to even all the town employees.
1:22:31 And I think also the flexibility, using this 21st century model, how we can start using some of the 21st century tools to integrate the town into the vibrancy and the culture of the community, I think it's going to be really good. And also the name of the environment for the staff, to get you guys, you're not just sitting in offices all day long, but this way we create more dynamic and more compelling and attractive work environment, I think that's definitely the goal of mine.
1:22:59 So I'm going to suggest by way of just summarizing your dialogue with one another that Dan has just done a great job of kind of fleshing out what the components of a mammoth-centric 21st century approach to governance would look like. To build on Colin and John's comments, I'm going to suggest that this idea of
1:23:26 Aligning with the MGOs and working in a different organization structure, we've already said it's going to be one of the keys to success. It's actually the underlying point of this whole workshop and Monday's workshop. And to Jo's point, I think we won't get to any language about do we want to shift how we frame where we're going until probably the third and fourth workshop so we have a very clear long-term vision and a very clear short-term vision.
1:23:55 But I will just offer this, because I get to work in a lot of communities and a lot of organizations, that this euphemism about 21st century government and governance is getting used everywhere I go. And I'm going to give you the shorthand version of this. It's really about aligning and integrating functions and being service first. In the last century, everything was funded in silos.
1:24:24 And structural governance. We operated off work charts. They were vertically structured. They had layers and layers. And then we had to invent all kinds of communication tools to keep the layers from screwing one another up. Now, in this century, because of technology, because of the insight from kind of just-in-time communications, we've flattened all that out. We've desiled the functions.
1:24:52 We haven't said you own these dollars and you own those dollars and you own those dollars. So you own just those functions, you own just those functions. We look at integration and alignment. And really what we're trying to do over the four workshop days here is read real life into that. So and then the qualitative dimension is a service-centric, qualitative, customer-focused process. We're going to get to that already today. So I think you're right.
1:25:22 On target, I thought that might be kind of a good place for us to have these conversations. So we're going to put it under revised, but we're not going to worry about revising it today. It's not really stupid. So the next one was updated for Anacus Council Chamber Technology to the other town technology systems. Current? Jamie. Jamie?
1:25:45 Completed. Completed. And I'm going to argue that the keeping others that current is completed because we have adopted a strategic plan for the IT, and so I think this one is completed from a council perspective, yes. Staff will carry on, you know, this may be only 87% complete, there might be something else that has to be changed, like better microphones. But anyway, you know, I think that from a council perspective, we call the whole thing complete. And I just want to say, from the perspective, we had a state commission,
1:26:15 Meeting in our chamber. Five percent of the way there, but this microphone, I mean, it's just embarrassing. Okay, good. I think we've got a plan, it's fine to get good. I think we can say from a council perspective. At this point, we haven't seen a date. I mean, in Casey, Kate, we're down in system, they'll be in there. Fix the microphones. Dan will tell us. The realm of this governance process, but I think it's a continuous improvement, and that's not the realm of council. I think it's sort of for...
1:27:14 So that's a really nice outcome. When I came in last night, Indiana, I was setting up in here. I was instantly, I hadn't been here since February of 2014. So I was able to offer instantaneous compliments. But wow, nice job. Everything's indicated. Wasn't the last time you were here, we were like bunch of tight whiteboards? Yeah, remember, no, we got the whiteboard before the end of that.
1:27:43 But we were having to put tape on the floor so that we didn't walk past the camera and stuff like that. So it's a nice one. The last one under municipal capacity is financial stability and of course reserve account of $3 million and an aid bond rating. And your note is you achieved $3 million in reserve account. And reserves are...
1:28:10 Yeah, Triple B. And then recent financing, we actually did it, we got a decent rate without having to go through the bond rating. So when that goes through, we'll actually have no rated bonds out there at this point. So we will not know what our new rating would be until we issue new rated debts in time in the future. So in one sense, I'd say that's completed because you don't have a practical time when you're going to see that update.
1:28:40 Until we actually go as you get in the future. It's still a goal we have out there to move our rating up when we do it. We may want to revise this because some of these, like this idea of reserve account at $3 million, that is a short-term goal that's been completed. Financial stability is a very different thing. I would say we're complete on doing $3 million. And then the next $18 months.
1:29:07 Financial stability is... No. Progress.
1:29:39 Sorry. It may, as you see here, not necessarily through these workshops, determine that there's another metric for assessing whether or not you are creating financial stability that's consistent with this. And it may be that time frame, that short term, mid term. You want to move to mid term, which I would call five to seven years as your framework instead of 18 month, three years.
1:30:10 Yeah, we've definitely got some wins there, but I think we just, well, we do. Yeah, yeah, definitely. So the next part of this was to implement a comprehensive community plan. Every community I know is doing this. And you referred to something called Synergy Summits. And at the time, your note says three complete, fourth walk upcoming. And your status as a first Synergy Summit held on...
1:30:42 I would keep it, and I think a second one would be a follow-up to this. We can integrate it into this process, see what comes out of this. This next couple of meetings, all of the work at Center for New Summits, the concept. In one sense, this is helping us complete that.
1:31:10 I would probably put there, it's kind of a revised, how we're going to find out a little bit better as we go forward, depending on what comes out of this, does that make sense? At this point, we've had a technical synergy summit, but also had a technical community conversation. I would view this very much as typically the same thing. We're kind of working through that, so I would revise this statement as you look at it after we come out the back end of the process. The statement was that by June of 2016, three were completed.
1:31:42 So definitely. I agree that when Dan and I talked about this, I saw a synergy summit as being, and Dan always envisioned that I'm in fact strictly public. So the second part of this was a comprehensive community action plan, an elevation, a conceptual plan, bringing to life in a visual way what the future town may look like. This was Mr. Councilmember Richardson's whole brainchild, and people were trying to figure out what does that mean. Yeah, what the hell does it mean?
1:32:26 So, well, there's a map up there. So, do you want to, shall we take a couple minutes? Sure. Take a quick look? Yeah, not everybody has seen this, so it'd be a good time to take a little break and let people take a look at the map. Yeah, yeah, let's do that. So that's why we have the map. To get a feel at least what's been worked on. This is our first field trip. We're just going to take a couple minutes here. Basically, this is the town.
1:33:16 There will be a key note here that will identify like some shading colors so you can reference plans that are specific plans, master plans, approved experiments, for example, and then there's other community municipal plans such as the landscape.
1:33:44 Improvements that don't read very well right here. And then in addition to this, we're going to create some subset maps that will blow up particular areas to identify the detail a lot better. In particular, like with the Main Street plan, it's really hard to get the scale of what exactly it is. So there's things like that that will have a lot more. Is this a town document in the sense that I'm thinking also in terms of this goes live. Is this going to be available on a web? Yeah, yeah.
1:34:42 Great point. Right. Sure. Yeah. Yeah, you'll see what, you know, what we do. Yeah, what we do, like, this is a, well, this is the, it doesn't show too well, but that is actually a, it's hard to, yeah, it's hard to read well. Yeah, it doesn't read well. So we're going to, we're going to try and prove, that was one of the three things we were making, make all these, so on the, on the web map that you work at is, and then the intent is that it's dynamic, that it's speedy updated, hey, what about that, I forgot about that, or, hey, what about the, the, um, part, you know, what, you know,
1:36:26 So I think we're probably safe to assume that we can then later integrate other overlays to this. Absolutely. This is development focused. Maybe we overlay trail plans for this and how they analyze them. And then when MLR completes their strategy of amenities,
1:37:02 You're also going to show potential...
1:37:31 Yeah, yeah, our master plan, all of the management plan, those positions are great.
1:37:36 You know, a new list, that, that, that, so. So you're going to see the whole picture.
1:37:40 That's the beauty of that, and as this lightens up, because the main street plan here doesn't really show well,
1:37:48 but you'll be able to drill down and be able to get to elevations and be able to see what the future of Mammoth may look like,
1:37:53 and, you know, I think that's exciting to a lot of people.
1:37:56 When InterWest first came, their strength was...
1:38:00 They have a vision, and they're able to show that vision in actually 3D. They actually have a vision. And people got excited about that. And that's what we're missing right now, Michael, is, you know, we have a lot of these individual projects that people say, okay, that looks good, but, you know, I want to know, what's the big picture of that? How does it all fit together? And I think by doing this, you know, it will really help with our
1:38:32 How transportation works, how trails work, how the connectivity of all these different developments work. So, I think it's pretty powerful. Is there a, in terms of, with all any of these things, keeping them current, keeping them up to date, is there a, if you guys work with the town, the town, the town, the staff, we offer up our time to develop it, to get it initiated, and depending on how much it is, I guess.
1:39:03 There's another piece that we talked in the SFR discussions about being able to publish data about where legal models happen. It's something that came out of the Colorado report. It's an interest we have in terms of keeping data current using contemporary tools, doing a bunch of different things. This may not be the way we're packing for it.
1:39:32 And I think to start, we plan by individual development. I don't think that's the best way to plan. I think the best way to plan is by doing master planning.
1:40:01 The first step is starting to do that. You know, what we see here is what we have on the books right now. It doesn't mean it's going to be exactly the way it comes out, but, you know, it shows that we are planning all of man. And I think that can be very exciting. I mean, you know, I think you tie back to the general plan. Right. There's all delays in our neighborhood district plans. Right. Right. And because if you try to explain it to somebody from outside, an investor.
1:40:28 You have to start an area.
1:40:29 Here's the general plan.
1:40:31 Here's the neighborhood district plans.
1:40:32 This is every north corridor.
1:40:34 This is every north corridor.
1:40:35 This is everything integrated onto the mountain, et cetera.
1:40:37 And so you can fairly quickly explain to somebody
1:40:42 so they understand what it is and have a visual.
1:40:45 If I'm going to build up a little property here,
1:40:48 how's that going to work?
1:40:49 Right.
1:40:51 Okay, good.
1:40:52 Let's reconvenue.
1:40:53 Let's talk face both minutes.
1:40:58 Thank you.
1:41:04 So a couple of quick comments on this, just to build on things I heard and said there. I'm a long-time RGIS aficionado. It's a whole separate story, but I've got a 10-year history. Putting this together, and Dan and I were talking a lot leading up to these meetings about the need, as you nicely emphasize, to create the story of you.
1:41:30 And create the visual representation of what the story of you is. And what I've learned over time is if you don't have, if you can't, if the community cannot visualize where you're going, then the process of development starts to look like the Winchester Mystery House in San Jose, if you're familiar with that. You guys know the story of the Winchester Mystery House?
1:41:52 Ah, that's so true. If you haven't, Winchester Mystery House, if you haven't been, go to San Jose, it's this very eccentric older woman who built this incredible mansion one room at a time and just kept adding on and adding on and adding on. There's like rooms to nowhere, rooms that are dead ends. You can't actually, in terms of like a living maze. I see communities do this all the time, not for lack of desire, but for lack of...
1:42:21 An ability to see it more clearly. And so when we use the word vision, we often translate vision into a set of descriptive sentences. And those words don't work as well for everybody in the community as pictures and images in particular when you start adding the technical ability to layer those images so that you can drop in and out, you can zoom in and out.
1:42:50 In a sense, you used the phrase story map. I think that's perfect. This map should become the centerpiece of the fulfillment of your strategic vision, and it should look like this is feasible. The map should actually, people should be able to look at that map, zoom in, zoom out, and say, okay, I get this. I get this. So I'll support
1:43:19 The incremental actions necessary to produce that will resolve whatever gaps or discrepancies we have. So I really like that. I appreciate it. Anything about the task that you've assigned to this that community action plan and the elevation of the social plans brings to life in the visual range of the town, the future town, I look quite active.
1:43:44 Do we need to keep it revised? Keep slash revised. I think we can make the statement a little stronger. Because I think in the process, we've kind of fleshed out the idea. I know when we did this a year ago, we thought of what does that mean discussion. Coming back to that, I think the work that's been done, I think we can probably restate it a little more clearly. I'm looking at Shielson. Well, I mean, I think we've started the process. Now we have the visual.
1:44:13 Now we can start. We can work through it. Yeah, that's fine. Can I help you a little bit? Can I help you a little bit? If you just take a little plan out of the substitute story, then, and take the paramedical, that's just a piece. What you're born here is a public as a community action story. I'm kind of listening. Yeah, I think it needs a little bit. I would say we keep that. Keep it, but I think it's a big lie. There's going to be consequences. Nothing revising the documents, but the statement itself, I think.
1:45:11 Okay, so from StoryMap and Community Vision to the Monday World of Solving Parking Challenges, something that goes down for communities, we have the first one here is working plan for village in place short-term solution implemented. That is your 18-month.
1:45:46 So that's in the process right now. We're hoping to have agreements in place. It's really in the property owners' hands at this point.
1:46:14 Is this important enough from a council perspective to keep it? You know, from my point of view, well, the buildings now have a piece for this close. But that's, when we really detail what that is in Lehman's terms, it was to get the blight down and clear those lots as potential short-term parking solutions. We didn't intend.
1:46:37 I don't have the agreement in my hand yet, but we're working on it. I think that, I was going to say something, I was going to say something, is that B, if we keep it in a town like Parking Solutions, it fills the village, then really the short-term one is done. A, if you please, from a council perspective.
1:47:09 But I still think the 18-month goal to really start to solve these challenges, we need to stay on the task. I don't think we're going in the right direction. We're going in the right direction, but I think, you know, we have a couple town-owned pieces of property, another village that we're having dialogue about. I think it's, you know, it's funny because just last week I was in the paper from 2004.
1:47:39 And all it's been is dialogue and talk. And I mean, this just needs to really step up and we need to get serious about this. And Bill Park starts for 18 months and it could be doable if we can.
1:47:57 I think the focus on this solving of, you know, in place and just dialogue and just keep getting patented. We need to really discuss this.
1:48:26 I completely agree with you, but I think either we need to revise it, because what we're talking about here, when we said short-term solution implemented, that was simply to bring lighted buildings down on the corners. That's what we've done. I don't think it's written correctly or articulated, because at no point in EA, but that's actually...
1:49:26 That point is that we're talking about too many things and this needs to be revised because we had a short-term goal that's been completed. We'll have other short-term goals. One piece of the short-term completing is we'd be able to utilize whether it's still at this level on the terms of the staff level. So let's put it in revise then. Yeah, I think that would revise. But I think that parking advance is also a problem. So that's why I'm, you know, 3B is almost just as important.
1:50:18 Yeah, we addressed that. One of the planners told me that one of their plans for this part of the art is to have alternative work schedules to have the American spaces in place. We did that. So we did that. We did that. So is it correct then that does it meet your expectations that we would take?
1:50:39 I just think there needs to be some sort of acknowledgement that really what that meant was to get buildings down, which is done. Right, but then we have other phases that we need to do in order to do that.
1:51:08 I mean, maybe it's really just more blight removal. I mean, we're still working on the plan. Yeah. No, no.
1:51:40 Sorry, Michael. I think we're good with EA being where it's at.
1:52:11 Yes, I'm considering very low calories. So I can't even count it. But I think what you need is a policy level of dialogue about addressing what you focused on here is solving parking challenges. And you've got a couple of incremental pieces in place for 18 months, and you need a policy level of dialogue about where you want to sit together. And so we don't need to do that. Thank you.
1:52:41 Is that something that I'm going to complain about? Ultimately, there's some policy questions that I'm just talking about. Yeah, for the, you know, reconciliation. It ties back in. And Sam, if I may get a little off track, can you talk to us about where the town is leveraged as far as bonds and debt and those type of things? I mean, at this point, it's pretty minimal, right?
1:53:15 Police Station, that's the early only bonded indebtedness there. Our challenge on debt issuance is really, from a general fund standpoint, that goes back to the financial stability and the initial, just trying to get a bid on refinancing debt a year and a half ago, we had zero people invested. We're able to do the other deal with the police station, weren't too bad, we actually did it as an unrated deal.
1:53:42 I think if you look at other bonding and elements, what you really would have to tie that to you is revenues that are restricted, that you can actually dedicate that revenue to it. So it's not a, if you do a general bond debt, you want to restrict general bond funds. General funds, that requires voter approval. So most of them are the leases, the fact, the least revenue type debt. So if you want to bond, maybe a new money, mobility, or something for transit, if that works, you could do something like that, or gas tax funds, or
1:54:11 Where you have a restricted revenue source and it meets the requirements we can most likely do relatively decent debt issuances. But that makes a commitment of dollars to that purpose versus something else and that's where the policy discussion comes in. But we don't have a lot of that going on. We do not. We have a state water bond loan, a state loan loan that we paid out a couple of years.
1:54:42 So I assume by your question that it offers you some scale of flexibility in terms of what your vision is, or it's not that you want to hit that, tap into that too hot, too hot. Because it starts to mitigate against some of your experience. So now we get to the big, so we saw a parking lot, just like two foot gardens, that was a five minute dialogue, I love that. Now we get to the big,
1:55:11 So you had to implement an economic development strategy.
1:55:37 So you must have a report on that. Where are we today? We've started to redraft what used to be referred to, as Dr. said, the destination resort between the economic and public planning. That is in the process of going through a massive revision. It hasn't been completed. Maryland made it down. A lot of this tidying stuff here. So that really hasn't come forward for the Planning Commission or the Council of New York's plan.
1:56:05 I think that sounds sort of right to me. I think out of the first synergy, there were a series of meetings that happened close to now.
1:56:33 I think we need to revise this because you've got to implement an economic development strategy. We don't have one, so how can we implement something we don't have? Yeah, so we've got to generate one, and I think how we go about generating that economic strategy, I think hopefully we can do something that's not going to just sort of come out of staff and go through the usual process. I think this goes to this new way of doing business and looking at our partners and we want to get everybody
1:57:02 Yeah, we all need to work together to figure out what that looks like. Is your SEDS document a local original? It's not the Community Economic Belmont SEDS from the state perspective, it's what the locally generated. It's called Dr. SEDS. That's a SEDS equivalent.
1:57:31 If they all had a non-development plan, don't use those terms interchangeably. It wasn't a SEDS. It wasn't a Department of Commerce. It was not a SEDS. No, it was a first try at an economic development strategy. To me, an economic development plan, but it was a destination resort, so we just called it that, but it wasn't a SEDS. And again, way too many things that could have been accomplished in the time period.
1:57:54 Okay, second part of this was coordinating with partners on enhanced offering to residents and visitors during May to October, summer of 2016. So, 10 months from now. I realize this was the product of a particular kind of exercise. I know the exercise well, Bill and I have done it together.
1:58:21 I recognize sometimes the language gets fuzzy, and this one stood out to me as one of those, but I'm not thinking about what your language is offering. What's going on here, and where are we? Well, the idea was to have Suite 16 be...
1:58:40 We've been talking all these years about more events, coordinating everything together and all of that, so it was an attempt to say, okay, the summer of 16 would be a great time. I think it's definitely one of the things that we talk about in conjunction with the NGOs, but I'd say we probably need to revise exactly what it is to be expected. The last point we were just thinking it would happen, and the reality is it needs to be driven to happen.
1:59:05 And I think to your point, I would very much want to revise it, but I'd want to revise it based on the success that we've had over the last summer, certainly the success of this summer. One of those things that we've got to do is we have to, Mammoth maybe doesn't want to acknowledge what is actually successful and good at doing things. We do a lot of things really well. We've got some gaping holes, but this is something that's really standing out in terms of what we're doing with our summers. And I think it's a synergy.
1:59:34 So the synergies would be a great opportunity to put some specific desired outcome, sets of goals, other than just getting a lot of people, experiences, yeah, can we program and plan in a way that's actually maybe somewhat predictive? Can we do things like, you know, we've got places where the resources are being damaged, can we actually, sure. John was saying that you want to build and promote a capture of success. I'm thinking that even in Monday's workshop,
2:01:05 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:01:42 We have a five-year agreement in place for the county. Yeah, but that's only a small piece of whole regional salt waste. Very small steps there. We have a five-year parcel fee agreement going. That's a funding source for ultimately helping to flow our current landfill. We'll be working on a flow agreement. Again, we'll give them security for the landfill closure process.
2:02:10 Part of those agreements that that will come back and we're looking at how does that help us structure some financial partnerships so we have the funding in order to go to a larger implementation strategy. The two pieces that we will be, that we haven't got done yet that we need to keep on here is going to be the long-term franchise agreement elements with the waste power, but also as that current landfill closes, where does our trash go to?
2:02:38 Long-term looking in terms of where does that trash go for the next 20 years and 30 years, and we've kind of missed an opportunity. Whether that's the idea would be regionally, working with Mono County, Ineo County, Bishop, and us and others in terms of a regional landfill. If not, we're more on our own, probably moving trash to the back. So getting that addressed in the short, within the next five years is kind of a critical element for us.
2:03:03 Also having stronger capabilities internally to manage our ways to meet recycling goals, mandates that we see coming forward that we currently do not meet on a regular basis. Some years we do, some we don't in terms of those. And so it's really an integrated management strategy that I would say from our perspective becomes a mammoth kind of century, but we won't be successful without a regional solution.
2:03:29 The second two parts of your update statement are still accurate. So this is a... It's a key. Is it a revised, it needs to be revised? No, I don't think so, because I mean, the explanation of what are all the pieces might change, again, because it's phased, but no, we still need it. No, no, no, it's good for you, it's good for you. Yeah, good, yeah. D, was a plastic bag band implementation complete? Actually, yeah.
2:04:00 We can probably put that down as complete. I believe we'll have an ordinance coming forward. After we put ours in place, it'll ultimately be subject to the statewide ban that was challenged by a state referendum. State laws would feel successful in our... We've slimmed by four. Very nice. How about E jobs? E? Yeah. Oh. I know some of your predictions here, so be a gigabyte community with strategy adopted for regional consortium.
2:04:50 Which is a year ago, so where are we? It's a keep. We have work to do. We've put a broadband task force together. Regional conversations are underway. I think it's got the focus and it's a policy priority of the council. Are there suggestions, comments, keep? It's a keep. It's just wrangling all the cats. Can I send you a video on cat wrangling? Please. Please. I'd like to do that.
2:05:28 So FF was a blight removal starting to focus on commercial corridors, including four properties unnamed, a dental permit, an issue for ragged stag,
2:05:54 So maybe at a minimum it's a revised and it may get
2:06:27 And I think, Joe, to your point, I think what has been accomplished so far, good. But I think the issue of light rule is a much larger topic. And I think that it goes to things we talked about with that Synergy Summit with the
2:06:57 Mountain folks at the main lodge. Well, that's, we're not going to pick on anybody. But the idea of a vibrant community, and we have a lot of folks in this community that want to update decks, they want to work on their houses, they want to fix up their properties, we've got a lot of infrastructure, public lands, that it's sort of, my background in the art world is kind of unique and ironic and doesn't decay look really beautiful, but at certain points I don't want to get into irony anymore.
2:07:25 We need to start cleaning all the stuff up. And that may be kind of a sub-topic out of this that we can get to, but what can we do as a community to start cleaning up a lot of stuff around here? So we can leave that to revise at this point. I made a margin note about green weapons.
2:08:09 Sitting on the shelf, ready to go, just need some money. Can you give us a $300,000? Pardon me? Can you give us $300,000? Thank you. That's like, you know, I think it's an $800,000 program, but it can be implemented in phases, and it can make up. So I'm going to make note of that. I mean, it's much of an initiative.
2:08:40 I can say that did come forward as discussed on that. It was a major U-funded mobility element. At the time, the price tag was substantial in terms of major U. We had to come through the strategy process for R&U, which was discussed up above. So that would be one of those questions coming back through the strategy with MLR and saying what priority is that type of mobility element.
2:09:06 Tie into those funds versus some of the other competing projects for the same dollar. It's a very significant dollar amount. Yes. I mean, it's a little back to it, but I think it's one of those things that you can hang your hand up to the back to that, and I said, we just talk about, especially when we have a plan to prove it. Yeah, in my experience, every community I've worked in has made a wayfinding actually a strategic level element, a taxable level element, costs aside.
2:09:36 It's an essential component. It's this on the ground. It's the story map on the ground. So we want to add that in somewhere here? Make the community navigate. So we'll add that in the revised section of this piece? Yeah, I've captured it. It would be a new thing, but it's there. It's captured here. And I'll carry it through the meetings as we go forward.
2:10:05 Okay, are we good so far? A couple more and we'll take a break. G, is the development impact fees, a master facilities improvement plan updated? I would say from the council level that's done, from the staff level it's an ongoing update of our ongoing capital improvement program. I don't think it, this year was driven more by the fee side than the actual project level side. He was talking about the CNP.
2:10:31 Yeah, that's an ongoing effort for us, but the whole fee program and everything here, I think. Yeah, exactly. And from a program perspective, do you guys have any special focus on that? No, I think that's our... We have compiled all the lists. We want to put it into a report format that we can present. I think it's here to be a lot of our fee program and what that would look like and achieve those goals. Okay. Is it slimmer still?
2:10:58 And the Customer Service Academy in partnership with the Chamber. Craig? Last but not least. I'd like to tell you about a couple programs that the Chamber's involved in. One of them refers to A, with an economic development strategy and partnership with town staff and also Long Island County. We're going to be doing a business retention expansion survey. We're going to randomly survey businesses all throughout the county.
2:11:27 I'm happy to say that we received a $50,000 grant.
2:11:56 So the cost of that is already done.
2:12:23 We're working on developing the tool right now in conjunction with this company out of Jackson Hole. And another portion of that grant funding is going to a technical assistance program in partnership with the county and the Small Business Development Center out of Bakersfield where any business in Monroe County can receive free technical assistance that will be subsidized by this grant fund and SBBC funds.
2:12:52 So any business that has any business issues that they need help on, and we have currently four consultants in the Mammoth Lakes area, but we can also tap in to 15 consultants in the Bakersfield area to help businesses educate them and help them grow. So those are things that the changers are doing that I think will fit nicely into some of the things we're doing on the side.
2:13:19 Very nice, that last part, we call it telemedicine for business. Yeah. That's nice. So you've got funding, the programs in place, the town staff have received the training? We've done some training internally for on customer service. It hasn't had the PEAT program yet. So is it a PEAT? No.
2:13:46 I mean, this is going to be one of our partnership issues, I think, to have to do what they're doing. I'm not sure it stays on this list to say we need to, at the minimum, it's revised because they have a different program in place they're running, but whether or not we need to have it on our list saying, yes, to do what you're doing. I'm just concerned that it's nice to kind of hear things coming. I'm hearing a lot of countywide, Bakersfield.
2:14:12 That's what's great, sorry, yeah. And that's nice, but I don't know if it gets the kind of, when we talked about this, the kind of customer service perspective of this unique community, keep an eye on it, it's kind of, okay, good, we're moving forward, but I don't think you can kind of say how it's done. I mean, you might come up on the revised side, then, and say, how do we help drive our community, how it's created. Yeah, so I'd say doing a wise thing, if that makes sense, and how to start, you know, I understand myself, and I appreciate that very much, I appreciate it. Leveraging this kind of resources is very important. I'm thinking also, though, and I think also for this something great that,
2:15:55 This gives her the opportunity of having her employees go through and take the training, receive a certificate that hopefully is secure with that preferential hiring, but we're also working with the mountain and businesses incentive packages that we can do.
2:17:12 So certificate is one piece that's definitely in place. Employee of the month would be another one that's definitely in place. You're still in development on what might be this potential benefit package, right?
2:17:43 I'm most interested in that. So if you could just kind of keep. I think that's a very... Since you guys aren't going to be with us on Monday, I've made note to myself a little of bringing forward some of what you're doing into our strategy session. Okay. All right. Thanks. So are we... Gene. I was wondering if I could have a couple of suggestions in the category. Okay. I think that are on the list that are important. We've had a lot of discussions here in the past, a bunch or so.
2:18:20 Thank you.
2:18:40 A lot of these initiatives, a lot of these strategies. I think that's... No, I understand, but I think it's what we've... With EIFD stuff, and I think we at the League of Cities Convention, we're all pretty well versed in what that is now. It came forward as kind of a... It came forward in reverse order. So it came forward, okay, parking, and then there's this tool. I think we're all very aware of the tool. I think what we need to do now is to line up a need.
2:19:09 That's going to work with that tool. And so when we led with the parking idea, we went out to the partners we needed to talk to to make it work, and we weren't hitting the sweet spot. I think we're all very aware of it. I think when we started identifying what a need is to use that tool for, I think we're going to find a way to bring it into place.
2:19:34 Thank you.
2:20:04 But I think, again, I think it's important for us to identify from a prioritized perspective what is it that we want to do. And I think getting the NGOs, I think Mammoth Lakes Housing is very interested in getting them involved in conversations. So if we have a need for that, if we have a technology need for it, we can put together an incredible set of things we need to do and then take on what we've got to do to make the EIFD happen rather than saying let's just do an EIFD because then we're back.
2:20:33 To where we were before, we don't know what we're trying to do with it. So, John, why don't we put it under a revision of that way? Why don't we put it in that piece? Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, exactly. We have three or four of those types of items that you drop under there and on implementation side, you have one of those, other types of tax agreements and stuff with agencies and other things. I think it is a council initiative as much as I can take council.
2:21:01 Right. The question's going to be is what is it funding? Yeah.
2:21:31 So it's part of the revision for FAs?
2:22:00 I don't know if it changes the timeline or the priority of it because it's kind of, it's in our hands but it's out of our hands in terms of the EIR work. I'm looking at planning a little bit for this. Tom's just calling some things out to keep on the horizon.
2:22:30 So I've made one appear, I think it's right, it's more that it can be part of your FA, I think it's, these are, these are post-redevelopment tools for economic development, but John's right, they need to use space, not I have a tool, it's kind of a project, I think we don't want to do that kind of thing. All right, last, anything else on your path?
2:22:58 I think it's, I think, first I think it's a keep at this point. Is it a revise or a keep?
2:23:26 While we have some things coming up on the second next week, but I think, you know, as much as broad and as strange and public sector setting the word, as weird a word that is, I think it's way of, yeah, bias. Two-part debrief, but I want to give you a break first, and I'd rather do the break and then do the debrief so that we have a first set of bias. Back to this, then we're going to move to the next part of the work, and we're going to look at the town.
2:24:41 The community's perspective and some of their needs and strengths and lots of desires. I tap into that a little bit. Before I do that, we've been sort of taking comments as we've been going, kind of incrementally here. Any additional public comment on this review and the vision that we've done so far? Thank you. Well, I just wanted to add, we're the transit services under AAP. I think it's important, and you guys kind of get on this,
2:25:12 You're talking about the roadwork number? Yeah, the state process program. Yeah.
2:25:43 Thank you.
2:26:11 Yeah, and I think, you know, Safe Routes is a school, which you called out, has been a program that we've had success with, and there was, you know, a change to that program that very much benefits our community that I think will allow us to continue to leverage that program. We definitely have a long way to go to being considered a big first community, but we've made some significant strides recently.
2:26:44 Some of the successes, they know, the Sierra had received a general statement for 25% of last summer across the board in those buildings, and bicarbation, lodging, scenic rides, et cetera, et cetera. So even though we had, you know, we had done a whole lot of capital improvements ourselves, we had a lot of development, et cetera, et cetera, yet we're seeing some growth, we're seeing the cemetery growth summer to summer.
2:28:11 I just think in terms of putting that somewhere, I think the economic development strategy, the seasonal, the nature of how all those things are moving around, that's, I think it would lead to that. Well, we have to understand, as we're in a competitive world, we went on our little motorcycle ride, we went to other ski resorts and saw their center business, and their center business is, you know, and they have amenities in place, and so, you know, when people come up here, they're having a great time, they're doing a great job,
2:28:43 I think that's something that we should all as a community understand. If we want to have every number of sustainability here, we have to understand our competitive world, not our other schools.
2:29:10 I'm going to frame that a little bit further when we come back from the break.
2:29:35 And the reality of customer service, the visitor issue, quality of life, we start talking about quality of life, integrating with the reality of the way the business is going to be community, trash, parking, noise, rental enforcement, all that stuff, it doesn't work if there's no waiting here after the product line, it might work. So, you know, all of us in business, all of the lines in all restaurants, we all, we stagger ourselves, we have to do work in seven days a week. And I just really think we're really truly wanting to move into that customer service over
2:30:04 What we're focusing is to look at who's here on the weekend. I mean, we go from 5,000, 6,000, 7,000-person community to a 3,000, 40,000-person community sometimes on the weekend. Well, if we don't have government infrastructure to help us out in, too, then we're really kind of on our own. Obviously, police and fire in our environment here, and that's fantastic, but we need more help. Not necessarily all of these great positions, but...
2:30:32 Thank you. Thank you.
2:31:04 Thank you.
2:31:33 So on the basis of, let me cap,
2:32:03 What were a wonderful series of very positive comments there. I lead a community mobility group in South Tahoe and facilitate the Tahoe Transportation District governance process. And this is what we say when we get to the program level in planning our food first, pedestrian, friendly, multimodal community. We say, more like Mammoth. So on that, we're going to take a break. How about 15? Is that it?
2:32:32 Good. Fifteen minutes, we'll be back in by this plot. Thirteen minutes. Nice work.
2:33:56 So, do you need to clock the same amount of each? Do you want to do this before I have two breaks? Yeah.
2:34:30 So if I miss something critical, I just love you. Yeah, tell something. I love to implement the mic. All right. So I want to ask just two kind of quick debrief questions about the exercise we did so we can move into the next part of this. We've got one, maybe two more parts that we're trying to do here today. So as you look at just our kind of updating of the status of this plan,
2:35:00 Is there anything that stood out for you from the dialogue that we had, the revisions that we've made, just any thoughts or comments based on what we've done? I actually think we did a pretty good job in the first place of putting together. In the first place, yes. You framed up those and put this. And you've made some progress. So you've got a lot of stuff in the keep. And the keep and revise column would go together.
2:35:32 So it's key with revision. So you've got, these are really kind of richly populated with tuna. Tom, that's good. Michael Eats, interesting. So in other words, you've got, you're not second guessing the judgments about a year ago. We did remove some things, so we streamlined it a little bit, a little ruster. But we also practiced the process of deciding
2:36:02 What's at your level and what's at staff level and execution level? Have you applied that screen? And we're going to keep applying that screen as we go forward today and particularly on Monday. Anything else that stood out? Did a good job last year. About to do a good job this morning. So here's a little harder question. If you look at this complete list of initiatives,
2:36:33 The only thing I'd say is that this looks to me like the first time.
2:37:04 To me, the common...
2:38:46 All successful destination resort, it goes the way it goes. It's this idea that we talked. 71 is strictly tied. We should make some revenue. We start to look at those other revenue sources, but that's still reliant on the share. One theme that I see is improved experience. Almost every line item to me seems to be driven towards improving how people feel when they're here, are treated when they're here, what options they have. It's improved yesterday.
2:40:08 And I think often those things are not mutually exclusive. We provide a better experience for locals that live here more and maybe to enjoy. It's going to translate to a better guest experience. There are things that certainly are in one bucket more than the other, but this idea that tourists and locals are mutually exclusive is something that I certainly don't subscribe.
2:40:37 Well, you know, and that's a great point. You know, that's a great point. Because we're in our little peer resort room that we just went to. I mean, you know, towns all have really vibrant economies, and you can feel that with the experience, you know, with the people working there. And they're happy to see you. Thanks for coming, come again. I mean, it's that, it's the administrative, it's really relevant to things, you know, the people that are living there and working there.
2:41:02 They're making money and they're surviving. They're surviving, you know, 10, 11 months a year versus six. They have a little different attitude. Well, I think it's an acknowledgement and an attitude more than anything. It's the attitude of, well, don't actually come here. Don't clog up my bonds. Don't be on the ski hill. Don't make it difficult for me to take a left turn. Just send a check up every month. Or to recognize that, hey, this is our life flood. And, hey, we want you to experience this place and love it as much as we do.
2:41:32 Anything else? Insights on the thread. That was beautiful. Thank you for that. We've actually teed up our next exercise. Any other threads that connect these elements together? Are they, is it just a list of 30 component projects? I think the, I'll go toward, I'll say to take the thread one side or the other, I think it's a redefinition of the town as a theme.
2:42:04 It's redefining who we are through all of these processes, terrifying that to who we are. I was telling the camera when I drove, I just came south last night on 395, that I've come here many, many times, and for some reason I never paid attention to the last sign for the off-ramp 203, and suddenly I was, I was hyper aware I was coming to meet with Dan, and I looked at the sign and it said, Mammoth, a Mammoth?
2:42:38 A village, a year-round resort. And my comment to Dan was, that sounds like just a way station on the way to somewhere. My experience at Mammoth is that it's a community. It's a city out in this resort environment. But it sounds like just a resort. And the fact you have a place in town that you call the village.
2:43:06 And so it's a little confusing. So I was suggesting maybe some way-fighting. Finding our son. Yeah. Count a mammoth walk with you. Yeah, the community, what kind of mammoth community walk with you. So these are the kind of insights I was actually looking for. In a sense, instead of you starting with a vision and then drilling down the projects, we started with the projects. I'm trying to lift it back up to a vision level and say, what connects?
2:43:33 All of this stuff together. I think you're exactly right. They're components of how you thrive as a tourism-driven economy. They are pieces that facilitate this improved experience by all, and they're experiential. They're how we feel about it. We don't live in our heads. You know, the planning process is a left-brained, head-driven process, but that's not how we experience it.
2:44:01 And that there's a lot of options. Half of what we've talked about here are more options across interest groups to access the community more ways. And you imply, and I'm paraphrasing, there's no tension between local and visitor interests, in which a lot of reserve communities struggle with, including the one I live in. And then the town has a community. This is kind of evolutionary thinking. It's really important that we go there.
2:44:29 So I had an activity designed to tap into just that. So I wanted to distinguish between the interests. We're going to kind of build this out today. And this is just kind of a rough initial sketch. I'm going to suggest that full-time residents, including the businesses that operate here on a full-time basis, are the center of gravity.
2:44:59 In this centripetal force that's driving your planning, your visioning, your investments, the choices that you make, the policies that you put together. And those are surrounded by residents who are here part of the year, maybe have a part-time stake in the community, or they have a full-time ownership in the community. So they're property owners, part owners, full-time owners.
2:45:28 What is the percentage of total residency that is part-time or second home over here?
2:45:37 Fifty-two. Fifty-two percent of the homes.
2:45:40 So, where are just 52 percent?
2:45:43 If you look at our housing stock, is that second?
2:45:47 Fifty-two percent is all about second one.
2:45:49 What about the renters, what about the population basis?
2:45:54 So, what about 8,200 people here?
2:45:57 Thank you.
2:45:58 So they're either renters or owners, but theoretically they're 48% of the housing stock represented by full-time residents. So by comparison, in Tahoe, in South Tahoe, it's now 70%. Think about how difficult it is to build community support for policies.
2:46:28 Two out of every three people that are actually living in a couple of weeks a year, their investment aren't committed to someone else. But that 52 to 30 percent is out in stock. It's represented. When you're talking about people, that's a whole different number. People might have worked 8,000. Well, 25 is the part that I can't visit. That's two different things. Yeah, sure.
2:46:58 And then the full-time residents yourselves, people in the audience here today, the business community, have certain interests and expectations and requirements for the community that they live in, that you live in, that you want to live in, and where the community is going in the future. Part-time residents, as property owners, have a financial stake in
2:47:28 The decisions that you make have less direct influence and maybe just less active participation. But nonetheless, on an individual-by-individual basis, they can participate on an important level of full-time residence. Visitors have a different lens in the community. They're not property owners. They don't have a financial state. They have an experiential state. They have an emotional state. They have a loyalty.
2:47:57 Stake. Part of your strategy is not to get them here a long time. My family is coming here for 20 years before I ever came down here. We loved the community. We liked it before. We like it better now. But visitors have different expectations, different requirements.
2:48:28 Some of the same things draw all of these groups together. So I'm going to end my preamble by saying what I've noticed in resort urban communities that have strong tourism-based economies is to make the primary focus of the investment in amenities, the resources, and policies of sale tourism-centric, visitor-centric, and work on that towards the middle. And I'm going to suggest that we flip that.
2:48:58 So here's what I'd like to do. I've laid out another group here on all about 2x2 grids here today.
2:49:26 We've got full-time residents, part-time residents, and visitors, like it was, as three columns. But I've got some indicators that we might look at. We don't have to look at them all exhausted. We don't have to feel everything in there. So the first intersection here might be full-time residents have some expectations or requirements that are just based on needs and wants.
2:49:52 Some of those may intersect with what we talked about here, about, you know, feet first, foot first, a multimodal access in and around the town. It might be an access to air service, and I think any number of things. So what are those needs and wants for full-time residents? Do you want us to specifically tie it to the strategies or just help in general?
2:50:20 This is a, this is, we've done our, our updated scan, now we're going to scan for it. So I want you to look out for the next one to three years. I don't want you to talk yourself out of your input by telling yourself things like, we don't have the money, we can't afford it, I don't know how we would do this. I want to simply get a scan because we're trying to create some side bullets here that will draw our NGO partners in.
2:50:49 So, specifically, we're looking at needs and wants of full-time residents. Full-time residents. You're going to work all the way down this column and say, well, for full-time residents, what are the kind of assets or attributes or other strengths? Maybe they're psychological. Maybe they're customer service that whenever they go in town, I'm going to plant some ideas here.
2:51:19 Wherever they go in town, they're met and greeted as though they are visitors. So when I, in Tahoe, I have worked on so many projects over 13 years. There's so many community groups. It's a burden to me. I can't go to the market. My wife says, you go. No, I go. You go because I can't get through the aisles. I know too many people. Everybody thinks it's a good...
2:51:47 Just a time opportunity to negotiate something. I don't want to do that. But they'll say, hey, at the next health meeting, can we work out? And they're going, let's send me a email. So, but people have very strong feelings about this. I'm not treated like a visitor. I'm treated as a resident, so I actually get a lower level of service. A lower level of service. That's what I call it.
2:52:16 Full-time residents are looking for the strengthening of existing resources or new resources. One thing that I think is not talked about at all, and I don't have children, so it doesn't answer me a lot, but they're like the right blood of the community. And that's something that full-time residents need is resources for children.
2:52:42 So you two are doing such a good job of creating the segue to the next part of the exhibit. I'm just going to expect this now for the rest of the day. You have these three by three post-it pads and you've got the marking pads. I'm going to ask you to write that down and tell me where on this grid
2:53:11 You would put a focus on the needs of children. And if you want to be more specific in that, child care, something along those lines. I have kids, this doesn't enter my mind, I don't really know. So what I'm looking for is non-euphemistic language. I want you to use descriptive language as much as possible. So if you've got an idea in your head, write it down. All ideas are good. One per sticky? One per sticky, if possible.
2:53:40 If you're just bursting with ideas, full-time residents are looking for certain capabilities, but the town is able to execute certain ideas. It could be recreation programs, so that's something we talk about a lot in the process. It may be the timeliness of responding.
2:54:12 I was talking to Craig about this on the side from the chamber. How are we, if we're going to grow the existing businesses as an economic strategy, how are we going to grow the existing workforce or recruit the workforce?
2:54:42 And who are the partners?
2:55:11 What are the barriers that full-time residents think holds the town back for accomplishing or addressing all of this?
2:55:42 And what I'm going to ask you to do on a future question is I'm going to ask you to work straight down through full-time residents, come up and post them. Then I want you to work down through part-time residents and give me just what is different. What's different about part-time residents? You don't have to give me the same exhausting list. Give me an exhausting list here. I'll move these over and create space if you want to. Part-time residents, what's different about their expectations or requirements?
2:56:10 At least as you understand it. None of you, to my knowledge, are part-time residents, so you're going to extrapolate a bit from your experience. And then last but not least, what's the same or different for visitors? So we're going inside out. Does this make sense? Are my explanations adequate for each one? So is this specific to town and a place as an organization? It's a community.
2:56:41 I'm going to use Dan's reference to the community, not the town. Not the town. It's a community. But one thing I can mention, under full-time residents, it's sort of a subset that we're all aware of that it's not listed. I don't want to add another category. But don't forget everybody that lives in Raleigh or Bishop or, for gosh sakes, Big Pine, that come here to work every day. And there's a number of those who wouldn't live here year-round if that opportunity existed.
2:57:12 And for various reasons, they live in different places. So it doesn't mean a category, but just don't forget about them. So where would you like to put them so everybody applies the same lens? Dan, talk to me about that. I think it would just be full-time residents slash workers. Eastern Sierra. Exactly. Just don't forget about it because they have certain needs and areas and things like that. And they take advantage of our programs at the schools and it's great. I think our full-time residents.
2:57:39 Don't even say live in Mammoth, but they're still full-time residents. That's fine. Just don't forget that. Some don't well in here. Exactly. By analogy, in South Tahoe, we have just, I'm giving you Tahoe's just analogous references. We have 25,000 full-time residents in the city area, but our churn of workers
2:58:06 Who go over a mountain pass down to Nevada for employment in Carson City in Douglas County is 10,000 every single weekday. And the reverse is true that the service sector jobs in South Tahoe are being filled by people who live in Douglas County because they cannot work in the South.
2:58:31 This is an enormous problem. And we can take 26 people in public where 74 of them live in town. It may conspire against a sustainable future. And Michael, just to clarify, the percentages we have up there, the 52, what you referenced in Tahoe is 70%. That's second home owners. So our 52 and your 70 are analogous. Yes. Okay.
2:59:00 From the north shore of town where it's about 64%. Okay. It's still very, very high. Yeah. Okay? So I think that the way this works best is don't keep working the costs like this, but work down. Give you all your full time. You don't have to handle it until you just come up and post them where you think they'll go. I'll move stuff around and create some space. Let's take a little bit of time to do that. And then we'll be brief what we get up here.
2:59:26 And remember, all ideas and input are welcome. All ideas are good ideas until we battle them around a little bit. And as specific as possible. Yeah, that's a good point. So if you've got one that you think will require explanation, put your name or first name or initials or something. Otherwise, as I go through them,
3:00:07 What I do is I'll just go, whose is this? Could you explain this to us? What are we meaning by resources? Resources that long-term residents bring to the town? What to see grow in the town that maybe aren't present or aren't strong enough or aren't as available child care could be one of those. I'll let you decide. I just tried to create some striation here.
3:00:38 Don't worry too much about the categories. Put up what you think is important.
3:01:45 Thank you.
3:02:53 If you finish the full-time residence, move to the part-time residence, give us some insights about what might be the same difference.
3:04:00 Thank you.
3:04:34 So part-time, what's different? Part-time, seasonal, occasional, whatever.
3:06:12 If I were you, I wouldn't just be thinking about when I hear from the dais up here at council meetings, I'd be thinking about the conversations you have in the market, on the ski slopes, around town, planning commission meetings, public comments. What are people talking about?
3:08:47 Okay, great.
3:09:11 Thank you.
3:09:40 Anything else? Down to a couple more.
3:10:28 Thank you.
3:10:59 Guest experience out of measure.
3:14:13 Anything else?
3:14:33 Michael!
3:15:02 So, just to confirm, what did you decide on lunch? Yeah, we'll be bringing stuff in and it'll be here a little bit after 12.
3:15:15 We'll take a little break just to get everybody to get their lunch. Okay. Okay. Anybody else got other contributions? That's pretty rich. Is that enough? Yeah. Yeah, it's a pretty rich data set. So,
3:15:45 First impressions. Just from looking at the board here, we've got a two-by-two matrix, we've got full-time residents, part-time visitors, we've got all of these kind of ways of looking at the needs, wants, hopes, expectations of those groups. I mean, one thing that struck me is I find personally the same reason. You're basically saying we can create all these striations and separations, but...
3:17:01 And to think of similar moments. I think the same amenities, everything, they want to be accepted as a full-time. I think the visitors just really play and do the thing and enjoy it. Certainly not as deep as long-term. Certainly do just want to play, but some of their, but they want to be in, I think you said, a great. Yeah, I think a lot of times, too, the visitors want to experience that. Yeah, and they come in, they, you know.
3:17:55 Yeah, and that's kind of my point about like it's to what degree you feel like you need to immerse yourself in that because all locals live on the trails.
3:18:37 I'm going to come back to your comment. Hang on to the trails piece because I'm going to suggest a counter idea. I think the distinction just in response to
3:19:06 There's a lot of the same topics, but I think the primary distinction between full-time visitors is we want things in a more affordable level. We want more affordable housing opportunities. We want more affordable child care. There's child care for visitors. There's child care for residents. But it's not affordable. That's a good distinction. We want a lot of the same things. We're not on vacation.
3:19:35 I see that same thing with the part-time residents. That seems the cost of being here to be part-time seems to be a lot less of a concern than full-time. They're invested here in the way they come up, they enjoy it, but it is still a getaway. It's interesting to me just in terms of talking to folks, some of them
3:20:00 It's quiet and peaceful in their mind. They want to come up here. They're getting out of Los Angeles or a similar place. And again, for that part-time resume, I meet both types. Some are here. Yeah, we're up here to ski and play and goof off. Others are up here. We're getting out of that. We can just sit on our porch and enjoy a nice sky that you can actually see the stars. And they have a great time relaxing here, not necessarily doing. And it's kind of a different, I always think of the mindset.
3:20:31 And also it goes down to the affordability problem because
3:21:43 And so that job thing,
3:22:14 However you want to define it, that job thing has got it lined up with it. And it makes it, for people to see authentic local experience, it's stressful. I was saying, and directly, obviously, but one sense of the community, like tension, I think, community, it's a balancing act. I would say it's not just a balancing act. It's in addition to being, it's a central question that has to be resolved in your economic development strategy. Otherwise, you get what you get by setting the bar here and trying to staff it here.
3:23:33 You end up with a focus on visitors. So here's my insight about trails. So we have a program in the Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit in Tahoe, the forest service there. You guys know Jeff Marcelli, right? So Jeff has a program there called Generation Green. And the Gen Green program targets taking Hispanic students from the high school ages 16 to 18 and putting them into
3:24:04 A summer's worth of seasonal internship jobs. They put them through a big training program. I'll tell them a long story later. But what they do is they spend eight weeks doing campground, backcountry campground decommissioning, trail building, carrying backpacks in the backcountry, learning about conservation, learning about the forest, learning management techniques and so on. And then they learn public speaking and they give testimonials and all this stuff. The great insight that comes out of this,
3:24:34 Is that our, your Hispanic population is 50%, our population is 38%, projected to be 43% this time next year. All of the students in Generation Green were born and raised in our community. When they enter the Gen Green program, it is the first time they have ever been on the trails or accessed any of the amenities that the rest of us spent all our time talking about.
3:25:05 Tremendous insight. Tremendous insight. It completely flipped our mindset. We looked at this, we looked at five years of data and went, wow, have we been talking to ourselves in a really narrow way for a really long time. How do we get out of that trap? So when you're building your economic development strategy and we're building these partnerships and we're looking at the NGO role, how you brand,
3:25:34 The community, all the things we're going to talk about on Monday, it's an eyes wide open approach that I want to help pull you in the direction. Make sense? Yeah? So just kind of counterintuitive insight, but now that we know that, we want to look at it. What else do you notice? You're able to really populate the full-time resident expectation side, right? I mean, I had you start there and
3:26:05 They just do differences, but there's a lot of barriers, a lot of needs and wants, resources. So these are all things that get addressed in this kind of planning. Talent is not directly under your purview. We don't have a workforce NGO sitting at the table. You're not the hiring group.
3:26:35 Thank you so much.
3:27:04 On Central Coast, Tom is another good example, is that we are aging out our leadership base. Everybody's my age and older. And we're about to leave the process. And we're not, there's not, there's a huge hole behind us in terms of the future stewardship of these communities. So you want, you know, business retention is a great way of doing talent. It's very difficult.
3:27:35 As we all talk about. And I share with you on kind of the old guard here. But for me, I've seen in the last five years, I have seen the influence of young 30-somethings starting to come in and starting businesses going. But I see that rebirth happening.
3:28:09 Which is great. So, you know, the future of Mammoth can have a very bright future if we're able to keep these young guys and gals coming into town and starting a business. The biggest problem we have is we are only in an economy that really is only maybe seven months max at full time. And it's very difficult. They can't work for seven months.
3:28:40 I would say all of that. You guys commented on pieces of that under the barrier side here. And these are legitimate barriers. I mean, you have the economy that you have. We can't paper our way to a different economy. But we can open up our eyes and say, how do we make sure the columns, the target demographic that are sitting at the table here, not only want to stay, let's just assume that's on them, but they can stay.
3:29:09 How do we put in the systems, the infrastructure, the opportunities, the progression, and so on? And one of the best ways is to get everybody working together to build the same community, which is the strategy, I think, that's underpinning this whole process. What did you notice under part-time residence? How did your thinking shift? Most of it's loaded up here under your needs, wants, strengths, resources, funding, because you were doing that. How they aren't thinking so much about these things and that they're engaged.
3:29:43 I noticed that a lot of your comments were about not really having much voice in the process. Of course, that's self-selection, right? You just don't hear often enough to do that. But how do you think you should report to your residents? Really the one for me, like I put it under full-time residents as the idea of self-sufficiency, but what that means to me is that we're a community on an island in the middle of nowhere. In the sense that if somebody,
3:30:14 Breaks their glasses and needs to go get a screw for it. Can't be done here. Somebody needs to buy underwear. You can't do that here, right? So that matters. Too much information, but it doesn't apply to me. So this idea that if you're a full-time resident, you need to have a DMV that can serve your needs.
3:30:41 If you're a part-time resident, I think that's where things change. You don't need to take care of some of those full-time resident life business things because you'll do it elsewhere. So I think that to me is where the shift occurs. Same with visitors, obviously. This idea of kind of registration thing. Yeah, it doesn't really do anything. Yeah, so it's like those, sometimes we lean on Bishop for some of those things. Or a lot of people lean on, you know, some city.
3:31:24 So that to me is a major difference between them. So your idea about self-sufficiency is that the more time you spend here, the more full-service access to the things you might have been accustomed to. Well, I think to back to Dan's point a little bit, I think that I would assume that all of us live in this place, live in this place. We make sacrifices, we make trade-offs. I've lived here now for, so I can remember before there was an internet, before we could.
3:32:08 But you start to say, okay, that internet thing, I can buy things, okay, that fits into my strategy. And I think that, I don't think any of us here would want, I mean, you want it, but I don't want to, I certainly don't want to say, yeah, I want it to have ease of consumer. Well, I think what you're saying, and I, Steamboat, it's three and a half hours. They've been, there's self-sufficiency there instead of having to plan a trip to dent that. So, I,
3:33:19 No, and we've laid that commitment, which is also what makes us unique. This place, in that respect, is different than Steve. I mean, I understand that we have differences. I'm just trying to... I think those are business opportunities that should be reflected. In a sense, what you're saying here is there's trade-offs living here just by virtue of coming here far from someplace else. But the question is, in 20 years, will you have a sustainable economic security for a community?
3:34:12 That's what you're trying to get to. Is this easy? No. Are you artificially constrained by geography place?
3:34:41 Lack of diversification, et cetera, et cetera, of course, but that doesn't mean you can't be super creative and innovative about it. Well, yeah, exactly. I mean, to me, very much like it's a great little community and everybody wanted to live there. Well, the reality is the constraints not everybody can live there. And this little town of Haley, which I remember 20 years ago, now it is this great little community. It has, you know, there has a
3:35:22 In their hierarchy. In their hierarchy. It has the shopping centers. It is where the workforce of Baffle Valley in New Hampshire lives. And it's only, you know, it's 15, 20 minutes away, but they've built this up. Ketchens decided to invest their monies down here because they think it's going back. And it's the trade-off. They've also figured that out. That's their equation. Yeah. And I thought, you know, in a sense,
3:35:55 What I'm hoping we will drive towards over four sessions is to create your equation. I would like at the end of four sessions that you will say not we have 25 strategies connected to a vision. We have one strategy with a bunch of component initiatives that are going to move us there. And that strategy becomes the story of who you are trying to become.
3:36:23 And everybody knows the same story. And your NGO partners know that story. And your visitors learn that story. And it gets parroted and parroted and parroted until it becomes fully internalized. That's what we're trying to get to. Which of the, what was different about how you thought about the visitors' needs, wants, expectations or problems to solve them? What stood out for you guys there? Any particular insights?
3:36:51 I think they're coming for that particular event or activity, whether it be skiing or hiking, you know, fill in the blank of why they're coming, so it's much more focused, and hopefully they have a greater experience. But in terms of what they need, they much, here's what I'm doing to get me to the moment, whether I need a good meal, whether I need a place to stay, or whether I need a good, you know, experience on the mountain, versus full-time, part-time residents tend to have a longer view. I'm here for a week, I want to get all this in. You know, I think most, a lot of this are tied to.
3:37:55 Because up here, Amanda, as you said, it's specific amenities. It's about parking, the airport, bike paths, events, et cetera, et cetera, all the things we would expect. What about... Is up there any time to think is something about information? Yeah, yeah. Because we talked even in the synergies that we had here at the exhibits, there's all this information, but I...
3:38:23 I consider myself a tour guide every day because I see somebody running around and we all do, we always help them. It's not as easy as we think. We're here, we know where to go online, but I see people running around all the time. We can do a better job of that. Full-time and part-time residents have a knowledge base, but the visitors are coming here and they do not know. And that's something that you can't punish them for, they do not know.
3:38:52 And we invest a lot of money in them being able to have the information they need to come here. I think also it's a scary place where nature's pretty terrible. Yeah. Mountains, bears, fuzz, all kinds of stuff. You guys have, you guys have like the best guides for restaurants and that kind of fingertip they're distributing everywhere. But yeah, I have people tell me that it's quite confusing here.
3:39:20 In South Island, we have this thing about everybody's a concierge. So we've been sort of training. We built it into our guest worker academy, our customer service academy, so that every point of contact person becomes a concierge. We've been teaching the people, the checkers in the markets. We have one in one market, and that helps. But the checkers in the markets and the gas stations and so on to say, are you visiting?
3:39:49 And if the person says yes, they say, what are you looking to do? And those are the simple two questions. So then whatever answer they get, then we teach them to say either deliver a suggestion or point them where they can get the information. So when everybody's a concierge, that's one of our strategies for us. You guys can do some things along those lines. Anything else on the visitor side?
3:40:16 How about barriers? We have a lot of stuff around barriers. What was the burning bridge barrier issues that you guys put up here? For visitors? For visitors? For anybody. Housing. Housing, of course. Isolation. Isolation. Financial resources. Yes. Someone mentioned earlier getting out of our own way, our culture. Language.
3:40:46 Yeah. Meaning lack of equivalence in the Spanish and... Yeah, both from a local standpoint, that issue and then just for our amount of foreign visitors, at least that I've interacted with, it gets to be interesting in how do you help them. Yeah. Isn't Vons the place you go to tell how many people from Europe are currently... Yeah. Let's see.
3:41:15 I think in the visitor category, similar to what you were talking about before, it's like direction. People have the options, but they don't have the direction. There's not... I don't know if it's a personnel issue, if there's not enough people saying, okay, you're interested in how you can go here. Yeah, go here. How to help you figure out. You have visitor services out there. Were there any other, kind of just to wrap this up, any other burning bridge or on the other side,
3:41:47 Something I noticed, and I don't know if it's because you had us work on that tonight, but
3:42:20 We certainly know a lot more about how to define our full-time residents than we do with part-time residents. We see them much more narrow, I think, in looking at what's up there. We sure know that a lot of our full-time community. Yes. So what insight can we draw from that as it relates to creating a vision for the community or working with your partner organizations that are branding and creating new amenities and so on?
3:42:49 I think part of it is really making sure that we have some idea about if we are properly identifying the part-timers and the visitors. We're making presumptions. And here, you know, I've had that same experience you did where I've taken groups of our local kids out to Mammoth Creek Park and asked them where the water comes from and they point to the water district. They don't know it's coming out of the mountains. And so we know that, but we don't really highlight that kind of thing as much.
3:43:19 And so are our presumptions about our correct families and visitors off? Well, I think we need to know a lot more. I would say we need to prioritize knowing what a lot more about our business is. You talked earlier about our economy. It's all predicated on that. To be able to have ideas about things like trends, you know, what is it that people are experiencing as visitors are on the road? How are we competing? How are we offering to have specific questions that we want? How are they changing?
3:43:47 How are they changing? And I think that this, again, the alignment, the integration, like MLT, the kinds of things, information that they're getting, that information needs to get integrated back into policy probably. We need to know we need to have a much more reliable way of being tracked back. And the other thing that Kyle mentioned about something like STIBA where other communities were able to sort of get to where they could sort of be somewhat more sustainable from that perspective. And it just reinforces it to me that I don't think.
3:44:17 Just because of our land use, our land tenure situation, we're probably not ever going to get through. But it reinforced to me this idea about the internet that we can start really integrating that even deeper into what we do now in the business. Yes, because it de-isolates you in a tangible way. It actually connects you to the outside world. Actually, that's the conversation I'm trying real time. So I'm going to come to comments here in just a second.
3:44:47 In a sense, what I want to go on your point here, Joe, what I'm hearing you say is we know more about the needs of people who live here because we are them, and we are more emotionally connected, more intuitively connected to those needs, but most strategic planning and most visioning work tends to focus out here.
3:45:13 As the source of the inputs that will drive the future survival of the economy. And somehow we need in this collaborative process to bring these into sort of healthy balance. Make sure this abuse bad thinking about what we think we know. Make sure we're connecting in a meaningful way to visitors.
3:45:38 Thank you. Thank you.
3:46:06 So I'm kind of paraphrasing and pulling out saying that if your strategy is to achieve long-term sustainable economic security through growth, we later will parse this into targeted growth, focused growth, initiative-driven growth, blah, blah, blah, blah. He says there's really three things that are required. These are paraphrased. A value proposition that resonates
3:46:36 For your customers. And this exercise is meant to illustrate that you have at least three different customer segments. And you have segments within these because within your full-time residence you've got different cultural groups, you've got different language groups. We could break this all down horizontally. Secondly, a system of distinctive capabilities. What you do well combined in an array that competitors can't match.
3:47:06 This is the conversation we were having on the break. So your ability to compete on amenities, service, experience, lifestyle, and all the small things in addition to the things people expect like the transit runs on time, you know, there's kind of cool ways to get to things.
3:47:29 Hey, there's sidewalks from here to there and I can walk everywhere. Whose idea is that? This is great. What a great town. What a great community. And then last but not least, a portfolio. This is MLR. This is the town. This is what partnerships come in. Products and services aligned to these two requirements. So any strategy for growth, in my mind, needs to
3:47:59 Address these components. So that's what we're trying to do. That's what we're trying to get to over the couple or three days. Thoughts or comments on that? Too much? Too much? You're getting a daring headlights look. So it must be time for lunch. So I'm going to go to comments.
3:48:34 We were asking ourselves internally, what do we do with that? You know, we were at our time that, you know, I think, you know, maybe some of them were seeing some of the fruition of the T-bit potentially, you know, the market better. But then I can cite a very specific example of what our CEO of Hospitality thinks had a lot of driving power of working on Hospitality was we were successfully able to get
3:49:04 Thank you.
3:49:34 To your point, this is a really wonderful point. It's not just little things that make a big difference, it's insights coming from multiple sources.
3:50:00 And they help sharpen up the focus
3:50:30 On which amenities when, which strategies how, and so on. That's how you compete. That's really what we're trying to get to. Are there comments? I know you guys can't read all this stuff. I wasn't reading all that. Any comments on this exercise? One of the challenges I think, too, is in terms of the program has always been a kind of a battle between the PD.
3:51:04 People that are here because we like living here and we like people. And there will always be a percentage of people who want to live in a community like this because it is far away from other things. And that group is not really as willing to want to be hospitable because they are purposely distancing themselves. And I think you need to remember that. I mean, I don't know what the solution is. It is a barrier, though. You know, there are people who are here who...
3:51:32 I think that's a really good point. I think it's bigger than we have. It's a challenge.
3:52:00 So in terms of education, you know, in the chamber and some of these things, that's something, there's a little massage that has to happen. And I think part of it is educating some of those folks. I mean, for people like myself right now, I get it. But for people who...
3:52:23 are kind of on that fence. It's kind of explaining to them what the benefit is, really. What is the benefit to me of being a nicer man of a resident of other people? How does that help me? And making it something that's worth something. And I don't know exactly how you do that, but it is something that it's going to have to be inside, because there's that element. And it's a bigger lead than you want to admit.
3:52:47 Thanks very much. So it's not only a great point, let me give you my insight from, I'll try not to keep doing the self-talk. I've taken such a deep dive on this. Same problems, same issues, same array of concern, same economy, same everything in many respects, just magnified by volume of people. And the served populations only gets to be 100,000, they're quite large. So the impacts on the environment are huge.
3:53:15 There's an enormous segment of what I call the live free or die folks who are, they were anti-social in Marin and now they're anti-social at all. And so we have this kind of bell curve of early adopters, adopters, people who live there and just resistors. I just don't think you spend a lot of time on the tail. I think you spend your time.
3:53:42 You know, and you don't need to help the early adopters. You spend your time in the middle of a great middle of people who you are attracted to be to your service-based economy to work here, who want to live here. You've got part-time residents and visitors who are all engaged in what I call lifestyle sampling. They're coming here and they're going, wow, this is great. I'd love to do this more, but how would I make a living? I couldn't afford to live here all the time.
3:54:11 So you've all figured it out. But there's just a limited number of those opportunities. And that's true in all of our rural resort environments. It's just our basic truth. So I think what we want to do is make sure that we're developing strategies that address the needs of all of those segments. And the resistors, thank you for commenting. You know what I was saying. All right. So we're going to stop.
3:54:41 At this point, we're going to come back and as we get food, we think... Yeah, there's pizza next door, actually. So pizza's next door. This is time, Steve. Thank you. Perfect timing. So let's take 15 minutes, get the food, get started eating it, and then we'll get into the next piece. Yeah, bring your food in here if you can.
3:55:13 It's the town.
3:55:39 Thank you.
3:56:08 All the service workers in Telluride drive 25 miles down the mountain to where they live.
3:56:39 Pretty much to a tee for 19 days. I had a couple of cheap days up in Tahoe for the hockey tournament.
3:57:11 Just more energy with my body of 31 years of pizza on wings. I'll put it back in, but I feel good. All right, so we're going to resume our session here. We've got one public comment that Steve wants to address.
3:57:40 Thank you. I know all of you, and thank you for what you're doing for this many hours. I've been to these other kinds of meetings before, and I'm not a little bit out of my league, but with your permission, just maybe some local advice. All these super hard things, all these different moving targets, all the decisions that we've been working on since we incorporated our town, and many of them still are up here.
3:58:10 Fellowship and talking to many of you and being around town so much that possibly something you should stir into the soup is, like Donald Trump said yesterday, the spirit. You know, people that are my colleagues that study bears, how many teeth they have, how long are their intestines, how long is their gestation period, all this stuff. I really don't block my head with that. I know that information, but it doesn't service my day. It's how people feel about it.
3:58:38 Do they care enough to make it happen? Do they want to make it happen? How they perceive it? So with all these bullet points and everything you guys are working on, we don't see the anxiety, love, hate, fear, anger. It's intangible. You're working on things that are real things that you want to accomplish. Those other things that I work with every day, we can't scientifically prove them, touch them, put them in a calculator, but I think it's a driving force in all of your goals.
3:59:08 It's how we feel, why we don't have construction. It's because of how people feel before they cut that check. I'm just using that as a random example. So, excuse me for interrupting, but if you can't do it on paper, I get it, but if you could help move the ball that way, and you guys are all on the streets, you know as many people as I do, you can tell sometimes they don't feel good. I think it's a block to some of the goals that you have.
3:59:35 So I have to get back to work. My boss is here. Thank you for lunch. But I think it would serve you well. As I've told the community many times, I'm a lazy man. And so I look at the easiest way to accomplish goals. I don't want to work as hard as I do. So if I can get people to do it willingly, then that's how I do it. I'm a car salesman. So the same thing with you. These are incredible challenges. Many of you have stepped through a lot more hours of meetings than me. But maybe that would serve your goals is how our community works.
4:00:07 That's actually aptly stated in a sense. We started this morning taking a look at what you were certain could happen and what you were concerned about, and we ended with things like get out of our own way, and that was kind of talking about planning and stuff, but so much of our dialogue all morning was really about the intangibles of what people's expectations and hopes are.
4:00:43 And how they think about what it's like to live here. So it's really this kind of qualitative assessment of is the community vital? Do we measure that by bus stops or by happy places? You know, which of those? What's the story that we're trying to create? So you guys did such a great job of filling up the whole center around a sticky wall. And I'm left with a squeezed area to work.
4:01:13 We just said start with the council's view.
4:01:42 And the staff's view of what's working, not working, strong, weak, absent, needed, and so on about the town. And let's start with a full-time resident framework. So we've tried to move the town and full-time residents to the center of this collaborative process because it's community building by many other names. We're using fancy terms for that.
4:02:10 Into the process, into a process with you that's maybe more refined, more specific, more specifically aligned, we used the word aligned earlier, and more functionally integrated. And what I think, at the end of my conversation, I think we've had a kind of meeting of the minds on this. What we mean by integrated is not that you have a bunch of NGOs, but they have strategic plans over here.
4:02:40 And you have a strategic plan and you communicate to one another what your plans are and you agree to agree to work on stuff. Right? That's kind of what we have. And in many cases you're contracting with those NGOs and you're actually establishing terms and conditions for investments that you make through them, not just to them, but through them to achieve certain outcomes for the community.
4:03:10 One possible outcome of this process, particularly after Monday, may be that we would conceptualize how you would shift your contracting mechanism and the strategic planning mechanism on the other side to bring those goals and objectives, actual strategies and investments into not just casual alignment but clear alignment.
4:03:40 That's what we're trying to accomplish here. On the recognition that the town doesn't live apart from the NGOs. It's in fact an integrated scheme here. So that's what we're trying to steer towards. To create this. So when I use the words functional alignment, I don't just mean we talked more clearly, but that we actually lined up.
4:04:07 The documentation, the investments, the work plans, the talent acquisition, the focus areas, and so on. So that you're literally, to use your rowboat analogy earlier, you literally are rowing in the same boat, right? Not in separate boats, all rowing in the same direction, because that starts to become a race, right? It has implicit competitive features. So we get that out.
4:04:35 So the last two things I wanted to do with you today for sidewalk purposes were to get an initial sense of, from a council staff perspective, what do you think you have to give or would like to get from each of these components? I'm just kind of squeezing the space here, so ignore this overlapping. From Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Lakes Housing, Eastern Sierra Transit Authority.
4:05:05 What's the give and get relationship? And this is just a quick screen that we're going to use as a placeholder and take into a much deeper exercise with the groups on Monday in that workshop. And the third piece I want to scan in, by scan I really mean we're just sketching this, is how do you see their roles?
4:05:31 Because I've had a chance to talk with those groups a little bit, but I have a sense of how they see their roles, and I want to get a sense of how you see their roles, real practical language. So that's the exercise, and so my little quote that I've dropped in this piece is from Peter Drucker, who says, the task of leadership is to create an alignment of strengths, making the system's weaknesses irrelevant.
4:05:59 And that's what we're trying to do. We're trying to take these partner organizations, or these could be stronger partner organizations, and turn them into a system of strengths. Easier described than done. So rather than have you construct a series of posters for this, I'm going to ask you to give it to me, and I'm going to do the organizing here.
4:06:30 Let's, I want to work from here down and then work back to just for a particular reason. I want to look at just give and get. What is it that you think Mammoth Lakes Tourism has to offer this and this? What is it that Mammoth Lakes has to offer? What can they give? Well, they've got the expertise. Expertise and singular focus? Yeah, local focus.
4:07:12 Yeah, both of those are the same. But then, of course, I think that applies on board. Airport. City? The airport. You mean on the sub-city? Yeah. Air service. Yeah. They've got funds.
4:07:39 That we get the money. And TV funds and they get mail. Yeah. What else? Yeah. We're getting some of the marketing dollars in the other states or bigger than some of the other states. What would they say? John's not in the room right now, but what would they say they have to give information? Contacts.
4:08:10 We had a conversation about, a big conversation about the data and information piece. It was really,
4:08:52 In fact, they took that to another place, which was data information and analytics. So the analytics piece was key there, because now that we've collected all this, what's the story map, right, that we're trying to create? So analytics, just to have that insight about that. Another try that fits there, it's all sometimes like if we were over-dated or when we missed the stuff that Steve was just talking about.
4:09:21 I really don't care how you felt when you were here, the data said you don't matter, or just the opposite. If we rely too much on that, then we miss that intangibly. So I'm going to put that. I'm not sure how to put that, but. The qualitative piece, can you speak very well? Do you guys talk about that? We didn't discuss it too much. No, we haven't. I think a lot of those points, yes. Is it appropriate for you to say that
4:10:03 MOT's efforts literally deliver visitors. Well, yeah, and that ties back to the strategy of we are acknowledging we're a resort community, and that's the economic drive. Right. Yeah, we can go to it. Yeah. I just think the semantics of that, again, from
4:10:35 From a town's perspective, you know, our capacity and our resources, 71% comes out of that dynamic. And so we have a vested interest in working together to ensure that that happens. We want people to come visit, have a nice time when they come here, but from a selfish and self-interested perspective, the revenue that goes to fund the organization, almost three-quarters of them comes out of that process. So, in order, let's call this
4:11:07 Since I put up here, the strategy for growth would arise on a value proposition that resonates with customers. So the way MLT delivers upon that promise is through expertise, singular focus, external partnerships, formating those, vendor relations, investing funds strategically, tapping into data, collecting data and information, doing analytics around that.
4:11:36 And all of it resulted in driving visitation. What does MLT need to get?
4:12:02 That's all still give, right? Yeah, still give. So what do they need to get? What do they need to get from you or other partners in order to continue to deliver on this value? I'll get that fast. I think all of us can get one that's important on the community buying because we hear the pushback, say, on a T-Bid or something else, that that community isn't committed to saying...
4:12:30 This market is working. That's what I'm trying to get to. They need to get that community by a better third. Which goes to basically the council, it goes to oversight and accountability of ownership of the program. So the council can't say there's someone else doing something else. We have to own it and provide feedback that says go direction and leadership so that they're doing what ostensibly we're telling them to do.
4:12:59 We own it when we tell the community. I think leadership's the best word for that. The other thing they need from a functional perspective are there are technical staff capacity things that they need from the town. If the town collects a lot of the dollars that they use for their program, you can just make a little, you can fit in wherever those things are. There's things that the town has to provide.
4:13:30 Yeah, actually, that's better for the new financial system. Yeah, I'm just saying that those are things that... They need to get that data. They need to get that data, they need to get the money, they need to... Whatever role that we have to play technically, we've got to make sure we live out... You mentioned volume. I think it's more of a regional solution. Yes.
4:14:06 So, community out of that region. What would happen, let me just say that's the whole universe of give and get from MLT, it's not, but we'll flesh this out a little bit more. Now that John is in the region, we should talk about the CEO, right? Oh, we're done with that, didn't we? Yeah, we already covered that part of that. Let's imagine this is the whole paradigm for the relationship between MLT and Town Hall and Flakes.
4:14:38 So, in a sense, what we're saying is, if you collaborate effectively, if you work together with the same end goal in mind and the same local understanding, external understanding of needs, lots, resources, you know, and so on and so on, that you can drive a higher level of efficiency, a tighter return on investment for the dollars that are allocated.
4:15:08 Thank you.
4:15:36 To sharpen up the give and get focus. But the point of the exercise, I hope it's clear, it's not just what do we need, but how can we enable, help, be more clear, for example. Leadership is just a fancy word for be more clear. Say what we want, say what we need, and say what we want. So we're clear about that, and then drive that.
4:16:06 What about MLR? MLR is the newest component, the newest piece of your portfolio of interventions in your own interests. I can use this kind of language. What about MLR? What does MLR have to feel? What are your expectations?
4:16:37 As experts, again, with expertise and focus. So expertise... Focus, in this case, definitely. I mean, yeah. And what is the expertise? We call MLT expertise as marketing. Expertise in recreation opportunities. And I think to be in a crass way, you can refine the word, but it's a product focus. So marketing is marketing the place. MLR is...
4:17:06 Looking at those things that the word recreation encompasses, which is very large spectrum, but has an accountability or responsibility to the product, a component of the product, a significant component of the product, the market is right. Okay. Are you talking about these? Yeah. Yeah. Although from Dan's point about being able to look and see a nice clear star,
4:17:34 Start with Sky, all the way to Public Lands Experiences, to Municipal Facilities that can serve both local constituents and visitors. Coordinating all the special events. Well, I mean, it's the same concept that we talk about, like the tie between MLT and the Chamber for his job. Leverage funds in kind, whatever. I think experts wrote them.
4:19:00 Anything else? What is your greatest, what's the breakthrough capability that MLL offers? I would say actually implement. Implementation, actually getting them on the ground. Strategy and implement. Yeah, I think it could actually be that. It's delivering on the promise that's been made to our community to say, you're going to give us a bunch of revenue via taxes.
4:19:44 And we're going to deliver these things back to you. At this point, it's been more about thank you for the dollars that delivery is coming. Does that make sense? It's the strategy, it's the construction, it's the building, it's the investment. But I think it's that delivery. It would be a true hard deliver on that promise. It's benefits across full-time, part-time business. What do you think is holding Camilla back from realizing that?
4:20:19 Well, if you look, if you go back to when council was debating what it would do, they identified, I think, four or five program areas right out of the box. They were tied right back to the tax measures. So there was the performing arts center, there was a trail system, there was recreation.
4:20:47 The infrastructure that now is being worked on, multi-use facility I think is a very good example of the role that MLR is playing, whereas before you had a public works department recognition, and that was that. I think through the process of MLR's sort of intervention in that to some degree, it's enhancing what those facilities look like, and it's setting up a way to leverage funds and dollars back to those.
4:21:15 Yeah, and I would refer to the program areas for MLR. Right now, I think they're identified as the performing arts center, the trail system, the recreate, the... Well, and a list to be developed. Yeah, it's coming out of the strategy that they're preparing that we're going to see on Tuesday, Wednesday next week, on the second, we're having a workshop. And those program areas will be detailed.
4:21:44 And, John, I think the piece you forgot to mention, and I know we talked about leverage before, but really active. Right. And also, they've got people. The oversight coordination. Not just coordination, but also coordinating. Well, and some of that, because they're in the midst of the strategy, it's not totally defined, but, sure, things like, I mean, it's been.
4:22:14 How long have we been at this process? We know that there's not coordination, and so it's how does that, how does that entity, how do all these entities or others fit into that coordinating thing? You know, we've been talking about one calendar for a couple years. At least the 14 I've been here. They're more of the build it. Correct. Correct. Correct. Correct. To do that, they stretch them on that. Is this going to be...
4:23:08 So I'm happy to hear you have not strayed too far from that. I'm going to say that you kind of segued us into what they need to get on the other side, which is clarity about how to coordinate with the other entity. So if they're doing much of what MLT's doing in a different space to leverage, taking some fixed financial assets and leveraging more inputs to dollars, corrections, and so on,
4:23:41 How to clarify two things. One, their role is to be for town in terms of the asset development side, so the captured asset development. The second is how to deliver valued assets that are, quote, valued by the community, disagreeing towards each state. Is it going to be visitor focused or resident focused? Both. Both. There's no distinction. That's that talk of not having that mutually exclusive in between.
4:24:15 I guess it's like they want to come up here and recreate and we want to live here and recreate. So they're driving community building and experience building for locals and visitors alike. I think it's been really helpful that Lance and Colin talked about at the beginning of this thing this morning about looking at the local part-time visitor experience. You start, whoever we're going with all this stuff, to bring that lens back in to survey and specific to say how can one project or one effort
4:24:46 How is it going to look at each, you know, those three sets of points, and so. And that informs how do you, it informs the kinds of things you build, it informs the kinds of things you do, it informs how you put a program together, so we can be responding to the needs of all three audiences. And we're not looking at one and saying, let's just take care of this another year, where we may be cutting off opportunities to be engaging with folks in either residence, full-time or visit. So we're not doing things that are just like for a visitor that the locals are going to go out.
4:25:16 The very last piece, just to, since you put it to it, I've been scanned.
4:26:38 How you will communicate with, amongst one another, we're going to take a deeper dive again on Monday, but how you'll communicate across organizations and with the community, A, to foster that by, and B, the effectiveness that you want. I don't want us to get lost in efficiency and effectiveness. Is MLR, so, to your point, captured as a get that they need to maintain clarity about focuses on both businesses?
4:27:24 They don't, a channel loses that. Is there, is there something else that MLR, and this, you're a small community, so you're cross-fertilized on everything. We could've, now that I, if I had thought about this, you know, we could've just said, we already have all the organizations in the room right now. But is there something else that MLR either has been struggling with or aspires to?
4:27:57 I think I'll go back to my earlier statement. What was needed was
4:28:29 Having the staff, having the trails coordinator, because MLR is also responsible for the implementation of the trail system, and working all those things out took, you know, we may have hoped for that last fall instead of really having it up and running now, but other than that, I believe that from a resources standpoint, they've got what they need to move forward, and after we get through the next six months, we have them.
4:28:56 I think you've made the jump of what they really need to get side is if you said they need that communication, need that clarity direction, need that element that's being built on what we're doing.
4:29:25 And so they need to get that, but that's going to take another three, four minutes. To me, the word you brought up that I think sums it up best is clarity. Because it is the most recent organization we've put together, but I think MLT and MLH and ESTA have a very clear focus from the community and from the council on what they're supposed to do. Because MLR is new and
4:29:54 Sort of so all-encompassing. I think they definitely need some direction for the council in order to be successful a year or three years from now. Yes. What they're supposed to do. Yeah. I think also the integration of MLR, because I think MLR is more, I'm probably not sure, but with existing capacity within the town, it's, you know, we've got to sort of straighten a lot of those things out, which again is the purpose of this exercise, what is the town's got to do, what capacity the town's got to have.
4:30:29 What capacity they're going to have, so the rules, exactly. From our view, we've given the vast changes in the next few months in terms of focus, and as an example, we could talk with MLR, we would have a meeting of nine people in the room, and we're sort of supporting and giving information, that's about it. But as we move forward, we could have more focused meetings with the executive director to town manager. We're on the same page, let's make sure, then we go up and down with the information. But the way it's working, that multi-use facility, we put it together in ad hoc group.
4:31:19 M.O.R., Rec Commission, Town Council, Public Works, Town Recreation Staff, and we got through nine to six months' worth of work in three weeks and focused it. I mean, a lot of the information is already there, but the focus of that, and to respond to Sarah's comment, is that group very definitely looked at people who live here, part-time visitors, and, you know, and all that at the same time because it has to be programmed for everybody. We're going to get revenue that's going to be from hockey tournaments or other things.
4:31:48 You want to keep the cost down for the people who live here. That's working, but I think just getting the staff on board is a huge difference because that will help so much. So is that convening and implied leadership function part of the gift? Is that an additional feature of MLR that's distinctive that you want to tap into?
4:32:12 Ad hoc doesn't mean make it up. It just means we don't have to over plan the process. And then MLR thinks of Joel as the trails coordinator is also essentially MLR staff, even though it's not a direct paid relationship.
4:32:40 Functionally, it's a staff relationship. But as a town employee, people will work with MLR, much like the public works in the rec department. But Joel is carrying out some of the deliverables that were given to MLR in order to meet their contract requirements, so in that way, it's an extension of staff. Yeah, it's a great example of having with the town staff. Right. And that's exactly, you've had on exactly the thing, but how do we use all these capacities we've now got in front of us, how do we start...
4:33:08 Weaving and putting together capacity to deliver things. And it's going to be opportunistic. This is good over here. This thing, MLR can probably, in this multi-use facility meeting, talk about a community center. Well, gee, it's a 10,000 square foot house with no furniture. Okay, well, MLR, we've got a lot of builders to do. We're going to need some help putting together a 10,000 square foot house. There could be an expectation that someone from MLR is going to go out to.
4:33:37 Our builders, our construction folks say, hi, we've got a great community project here. We need some help from you. You can make it, you know, you can donate time, cash, services to a 501c6, you know, you can get a direct contribution to the council. And how do we find the best capacity to deliver all of it? Because we don't, our budget. What I've captured here in MLR, the ability, needs sort of passive support for being, for having convening before. That it can convene on an ad hoc basis and groups together. It needs support for opportunities.
4:34:38 The corollary to that is you do not have to use conventional methods for anything.
4:35:08 Frankly, you, and I'm not suggesting you ad hoc make it up. I'm saying, you say, what's the fastest way, best way for us to work together to get from here to where we want to get to? You just agree by consensus to do that. When you're structured with separate organizations, performing separate functions that look like they're similar, but there's not clarity about prospective roles and so on, you're mirroring that 20th century
4:35:39 Government process and you're not embracing your version, the mammoth version of 21st century government. That's why we should add to that, to revise the mammoth version, not the LA version, not the every rural small town version. Okay, is it fair to say, but I think when it gets a little bit, I mean, your point about that maybe there's some transcendent needs across all these organizations that they need to get from the town.
4:36:09 Yeah, so clarity, fiduciary stuff, oversight, technical assistance, things like that. I mean, as we go into each relationship, we dive in and we'll figure it out specifically. I'll carry those through in the notes without taking the time to rewrite them all now. I think that's easy to put together and do it right after the meeting. Anything else that stands out on MLR? Pretty rich array of give and needs. Most of the needs...
4:36:39 What about MLH? What is MLH? Given everything we've talked about, residents' expectations,
4:37:12 Part-time residents, visitors. We talked about housing affordability. We talked about workforce implications. We've been hinting at all kinds of implications for housing. Four-star, five-star target for the visitor. Tough housing stock mix in terms of trying to get to that middle wage housing capacity and so on.
4:37:42 People are driving, you have 26 employees and four live in town. A lot of reasons. Yeah, I get it, I get it. They'll live for your diet group, right? Yeah. But, so you've got all these confounding, very complex economic variables. You can't solve them better than the nation can solve them. And trust me, as a country, we're not solving these problems. So you can feel a little bit less pressure.
4:38:12 But we have your notion of these issues. What does MLH have to give as it relates to all that context and where you're trying to get to? I think they help us maintain a focus on the full-time resident and that perspective, which isn't reflected, you know, like housing's not listed as a priority for 18-month commitments, and it's their number one priority.
4:38:42 One of the most important things they do is remind us continually that that is a priority and that is a need. Keep it all on the radar screen. They provide expertise and the, you know, the, you know, they have leverage funding, but they continually remind us that that is a big unmet need that continually needs work. Well, actually, I'm going to disagree that they do leverage funding because look at all the grants and everything that they bring in.
4:39:07 No, I said they do. Oh, I said they do not. Sorry. They definitely put leverage coming in. No, they definitely bring expertise, singular focus, leverage coming in. That definitely ties in that knowledge as well. I'm looking at that broader sense of housing solutions. You talk about the mammoth version. Yeah, completely. That...
4:39:33 I'm not as familiar with MLH as I should have given a couple more opinions on a sense of what's going on. I appreciate this focus on the workforce. But I think the idea of needing to have recommendations and ideas, creativity and solutions for the particular problems that face our community. And it's an enormous need. And it's going to be needed. And I think that's the gift that they can provide. Creativity is specific to what the Mammoth Lakes
4:40:15 The focus has to be solutions, creativity, expertise
4:41:07 They help individual residents, families, et cetera, through horrendous paperwork challenges and actually get them into it. They actually have a lot of time spent with individuals, not groups, partnerships, high level, and I don't want us to lose that.
4:41:43 Right. We have to have the strategy and all that, but we have to recognize that they spend time with your neighbor or mine. They're probably one of the most direct contacts with our full-time residents that are providing services than the other needs. Right. So is MLH a hidden, or maybe it's not, a hidden source of not just data, but qualitative insight about
4:42:11 The needs, hopes, expectations, workforce requirements, lifestyle requirements of families. I wouldn't say they're a hidden source. I think Jennifer is super present at meetings, really involved, at least for my opinion. For that point, though, I think that that's, again, one of those transcendent things. I think that from each one of those NGOs, their representation based on their activity and what they do, they have unique insights.
4:42:42 But I think to Michael's point, they maybe are a unique informational source for local stuff because MLT has to go out there and say, what do our visitors want?
4:43:12 How do we deliver that? MLH, we have surveys, conversations. And you're saying also that MLH maybe doesn't get as much into the program. They get inside of that. So we definitely have good data needs. And see, some of that, if you start, you don't have that same level. So it's there, but not definitely a powerful tool coming in for that. In the form of a question. So what I was, let me use less consultant-speak type language. What I was looking for is, are they through
4:44:23 I think that sometimes that happens. We try to always share our insights.
4:44:58 Thank you.
4:45:27 Yeah, I'm just thinking that the next steps we're doing in this process, how we institutionalize the sharing and transmission of information from all these NGOs is going to be, I'm looking forward to that.
4:45:59 I think we get all this stuff, so it gets right into work plans, it gets right into policy development. That's a huge opportunity. It's a huge opportunity to take advantage of it. And personally, we're always looking forward to really getting into that. So the point about public buy-in, you know, how important these things are to what we're doing, there's no daylight there. It's like we're all working together on these things. Yeah, from my perspective.
4:46:26 Yeah, good. So, let me build on that. So what does an employee's housing need to get, not just from the town, but from the other?
4:46:53 What does MLH need to be most effective in leveraging their expertise, their funding, their qualitative data collection, their quantitative data collection, how they help individuals, knowing when they're informing versus advocating? What do they need?
4:47:21 I mean, are you, because I'm, we haven't really talked yet, but how these things started talking to each other yet, have we? No. Okay, so I'm just, but I'm wondering, how does, how does the, how does the community communicate to MLH, or does MLH communicate back to us where our housing needs are for the community? I mean, how do businesses, if you've got problems hiring people, it's too expensive, I don't, I just don't understand how the communication works. You mean specific to,
4:47:46 Housing needs? Housing needs, say, from a business perspective. MLH can look at it from demographically and census-based and income-based. How do the other components of, say, in the MLT or the MLT or the MLT visitation world of what businesses need from a staffing perspective? I just don't know how we communicate this. I mean, maybe this is too specific, but, like, you know, one of our comprehensive planning happens with the housing element. So that was a plural of number between.
4:48:15 I'm assuming how MLT and MLR are going to start talking to each other, that's maybe what we're obviously doing.
4:48:51 At MLT, we're seeing trends out here at MLR, where we got the ground that can support it. So those conversations are also happening. But from the business sector, from the employee, from the HR perspective, in terms of hiring folks, we've got people we're trying to hire that need certain things. Like how does that two-way conversation happen with MLH such that... Yeah, I agree. Right. Employees coming in. Right. Yeah, I'm looking at that because I'm looking back to this manic-centric solution.
4:49:36 So they're scanning and their focus is on business retention. So that's a focus on this call. It's full-time residents.
4:50:21 We have been working with the chamber very recently on the questions that we would find beneficial.
4:50:53 So this is what we're talking about is making sure that information is not held, remember the work chart thing that got flattened out? That it's not held either in some layer or in some vertical and doesn't find its way to informing a collaborative way so that their vision, you know, the MLR vision,
4:51:28 Chamber vision, MLTs, growth vision, and so on are synchronized in the most efficient way possible. So I think I've captured that in consulting shorthand. Okay, anything that we're missing, any big insight about what MLH needs to get that it's not getting, we'll take a deeper look at this one day.
4:51:56 But from your perspective and understanding, just waiting for this moment to put forward. Let's go to the ESTA. So these ones here are transit forward. What I'm hearing is everybody gets it. Everybody understands it. What does ESTA have to give? So it's expertise, singular focus, leverage funds, yes? Yes. Okay. And this is your big win. It needs to give liability.
4:52:35 You know, that's a really critical piece of transit in Germany. It's not reliable, and the whole system breaks down. Is that happening now? Some days. Yeah. I think for the most part. For the most part, yeah. But, you know, it's definitely something that can always be improved upon. We're trying to be replaced with us. Yeah. Somebody replaced it.
4:53:06 That's a good problem. That's a good, yes. I mean, it's with services. It's own success is driving as a man for more. So you have to be careful if you're going to get successful, and then that brings a bad experience. So how do we continue to do a lot of that? So then you can scale the quality of that. Okay, so I'll capture that. And one of the things we're doing, they're doing real well with their flexibility, which is very much related to that.
4:53:36 Exactly. Because we can call them at two days' notice. They show up. They're really flexible. One of the things that people might not realize about ESTA, and they're not in the trenches with their budgets and those type of things, that to your point about flexibility that ESTA does really well, is they have an incredible ability to scale based on visitation and snowfall.
4:54:01 The way that they're set up with their contract with the mountain is basically a cost recovery basis plus incremental revenue based on them. So they've come up with this very unique... This example I've heard was today when you actually have an innovative business model operating and actually in an environment where you're having, is that a data-driven model? Is it a digital framework? What enables them to do that without the details?
4:55:03 I think a lot of it is that, you know, the requirements are such that they're keeping track of low, you know, percentage of fullness in the annual times, and they're very responsive to changes like in the low snowfall years, even before and obviously immediately after President's Day weekend, they've already got in place what reductions they're going to do. They're still going to provide an adequate level of service. It's just there.
4:55:34 Definitely on top of it. When was it formed? Hmm? When was Esther formed? Sandy, when was Esther formed? Thank you. They're also very cognizant of, as Steve addressed earlier, the field, because the council gets to come back the field with 2 a.m. buses. That's not about all the numbers. It's also serving the community in a different way.
4:56:00 They're very responsive. We're paying for it. Yeah, they're really responsive to service levels. But then the other thing that if you ride it, you start seeing and experiencing is they are the best ambassadors of the town. They are the ones that somebody's going, I'm trying to find the such and such store. Those drivers will tell them where to get off. They'll tell them how to get to it. They'll tell them how to get back, et cetera. I think that could almost be...
4:56:28 They're a critical concierge point. Yeah.
4:57:08 I think it's important to say, to look at each one of these things in terms of these opportunities. It's not a question of who's doing something better or worse, but from the higher level of things we're trying to do, for all of us to use our creative minds and say,
4:57:45 Just like you say, that's a great concierge point. That's a great information sharing point. How do we start blending these things together so that systemically we all add up to something that's delivering the kind of capacity of a lot of time? So just, yeah, keep your eyes on yourself. How can this work? How can that work? Because I have the community buy-in so much at Colin's site. Sure. The community loves us. So maybe it all builds from that, you know. If it's working for the community members and the residents, the full-time residents, then it will bleed over to the rest.
4:58:16 I also think it's this regional transition. Oh, yeah. Centric. So all the employees who look at Bishop, Kelly, whatever, this is a solution for all of the services. I think it's Arena. Yeah. As opposed to NLT, M, M, M, M, M, this is SF. So it's a little more broad, I think. So maybe that helps with the bottom as well. Yeah, it is the one that is truly regional. The ridership that may not take a big jump is last year.
4:58:45 One thing I need to mention, Mike, that they talked about your lives earlier. Yeah. We've had a lot of discussions out of the shop and with John Held, Vested Director, just the last few weeks. And we get, you know, because we always plan on the 600-inch winner. That's it. Well, if we do that and we have a snowblower go down and a blower go down, which one do we fix? That or the bus? And because the town maintains all those things.
4:59:14 So as we talk for the next four days, again, because I get pressure every time we go down there, you know, we're short one step, we're certainly, you know, the mechanic, we need these things, we need to be flexible. That's a big part of it because we have to balance.
4:59:26 It's the bus, the blower. What kind of day it is? How do you work this? How much overtime? It's just something to be aware of because it's really, that's where the program is. So that get calm, that's capacity that the town is providing specifically to that program. And each one of these programs has those kinds of needs. And these are things I think from the council perspective, we need to know what those things are.
4:59:48 So we can make sure we're making decisions that will support these things. Because they can't go anyplace else. Yeah. There's nobody else certified in Bishop that will work on certain buses. They have to, I mean, we took control of it today and put it on a trailer and sent to Reno for something. We couldn't fix it. Nobody there could fix it. So it's something we deal with all the time, but, you know, you guys need to be aware of it because it is, you know, it's really key. It comes out in budgeting and everything. It works. No, no, no. It's not a big winner. You have to be aware of what do we, you know.
5:00:18 So I have two insights from everything that Paul just said. One is that their natural ambassadorship, or their developed ambassadorship, is leveragable as a core competency for a concierge-like function. So that's the kind of thing we want to pull out of this process. And the second is, on the get side, because they're so kind of algorithm-focused,
5:00:48 In terms of contingency planning, there are all these different scenarios, they need an effective, in the equivalent of an algorithm where you set up priorities for maintenance, given the competing issues there. I don't want to put you on the spot and have you tell us how you answer that question. Every day it's different. You can balance things in a bus versus not.
5:01:15 It's a constant boundary.
5:01:43 Given the regional nature, which is kind of the third insight, the regional nature, in fact, maybe the insight here is they regionalize you in a way, and they give you the regional roots. What does Esther need to get to completely deliver on that function, the regional and also the local? Does that cause them to...
5:02:14 They're very good at using the resources. Yeah. And they're also a much more mature organization than you are.
5:02:42 They've worked up from the basic transportation to being able to get to a regional level, expanding yards and other kinds of things like that. So they've actually, they're more mature on the scale. But you're right, Shields, they're, since they have a single, very easy to collect data on focus, they can react quickly. Now, as I said, maybe there's a whole bunch of stuff, you can get it. If there's not, they start producing.
5:03:11 They need that information from us, like saying, yes, we want another trolley going up to Lake Spacer. No, we don't need that service. Yes, we do have this coming to town. But they need that real-time information so they can respond to it. And then they need the resources to go with that.
5:03:30 All the requests come with the request for payment. That ain't funded. Yeah. That's a great point that that communication is improved. This trolley service was not sufficient to handle the 4th of July fireworks in the village. They need to get that on-the-ground experience from the community saying, hey, you're overwhelmed. We need another bus. We're willing to pay for that.
5:03:55 Well, and that really goes back to the coordination we talked about much earlier, is that if there's going to be an event like that, they're realizing that you are going to be more in advance. Yeah, and so that's a challenge on the front end notes. They need to get that data. Yes. And we need to get the requests out at an adequate time. Usually they do real well because they have their S4 itself and then LTC for those of you who are now on LTC.
5:04:21 You can see in this experience, there's a lot of discussion, they come and get reports all the time, but I think there's a good communication, that's where they talk about yards. And they're also quite successful within grants. Grants? Just like the lights. Yeah, all of them. Yeah. New stock, new goods. It's nice to use a lot of grant funds.
5:04:50 They're very good at getting them, but there are dollars out there that are targeted to transit. And they're very good at identifying those and going after them. I don't know if this is related, but maybe it is. ESPA has really similar benefits to town employees. And so their staff benefits are really good. Maybe it helps them to hire workers. Sure. And retain them.
5:05:25 I think the other thing is that ESTA, these other ones are very, they're coming out of, you know, I mean, marketing certainly is a regional opportunity. Talking about it, haven't gotten there yet. Recreation, MLR, these are regional opportunities. Trying to get it there, haven't only got there yet. Housing, same thing, we're always talking about housing, how housing integrates into the region. ESTA is a very interesting model because all those dollars that come from the federal government coming down that way,
5:05:55 You can see how if it can tie into funding sources, you can really start optimizing a lot of stuff. That's a great insight. I'm going to come to comments here in just a second. So behind even the specific example you gave is I think you've got, you're very happy with this. It sounds like by consensus, but it's in part because of their service, in part because of their innovative business model, and it's through that model that you can channel.
5:06:24 Like, we take care of, we get Caltrans improvements for water quality improvement projects. So we get our roads improved because we have to manage TMD elders of the lake and that type of thing. So we're able to leverage dollars we would not have otherwise had access to and we could never afford to fix those roads. So that's the kind of channeling of expertise through the Fish and Businesses Mall of MLH.
5:06:52 So what's the what's the what's the what's the
5:07:24 Give to the other NGOs or to the community? To the collaborative process. Okay. Forward. Funding. And along with that a way to... Well, a direction of how important it is to spend. Yes. Right. That's right. I mean, summarize that as contracts. Yeah. Just leadership. Leadership. Add anything to that? All these other pieces have parts of the community, but...
5:08:02 I'll say preach to all of our staff and civil forces. Every decision we make is for the town. And we expand that to the region as well in a lot of discussion. And that's what I think the town can provide. You know, what are their different visions and priorities and how do we pull them together? That's the town's job. I'll go back on this as a great term. I'm also legitimacy because it's coming out of an elected body where this is going to.
5:08:33 So this is extremely important. When Dan and I, the very first conversation we had about this process, we talked about, I remember saying,
5:09:04 Let's start with the Council, not start with the NGOs in the room, because the Council in our democratic process is the elected voice of the people. So in a sense, this is a community-centric collaborative that we're talking about, and it's through the Council's governance and legitimacy that sort of underscores our democratic process, and it's the leadership and acting part of that authority that...
5:09:33 We are representative of people. And to the extent the process is, I think we also said, transparent and fully public, now you've got a sustainable, at least, governance system beginning to the future that you want. But whereas the individual NGOs operate from a different organizational premise, have boards, have non-profits, they meet all the IRS requirements.
5:10:04 So you talked about...
5:10:36 Joel has issued these to the email for MLR, about data. For the whole Venus, they increase our reference to... Okay, there's a whole lot of list of this. I didn't work on the Venus in Housing. Right. Okay, perfect. You want a sweet spell, let's go to the E, too. Remember how you want to spell that? V. Um, what else?
5:11:01 What is, what else, anything else? Because I, we're using kind of big bullets. We just really give the, the, the public infrastructure for all this to happen. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Public safety, you know, a few pieces of that. Yes. And it's just like roads and works as the shorthand for, I'll say, so in a sense. In fact, I think that public infrastructure, there's hard infrastructure, there's a soft side, everything planning and engineering does.
5:11:43 The building side, the development side, those elements. Without that, a lot of this stuff isn't going to happen. And the understanding of how all those pieces fit together, too. Keeping that broad perspective of, if we do this, how does it affect this? That's our responsibility. To figure out how to solve it. We have nothing to do with sewer and water until they want to come up the street we just built. That's right. I know.
5:12:14 Okay, so a lot of big stuff. It's hard infrastructure, it's coordination, it's communications, and so on. What does the town need to get? We've been sort of drilling it through this other process. What does the town need to get from all of these partners? Transparency. Ah, yeah, we took. Just accomplishments. Right. Yeah, they have to deliver.
5:12:46 I think it's the other side of that, it's harder to write down maybe, but it's that translation between what the NGOs will go out, there's a lot of stuff happening, going on, how do we translate that from a council perspective to the rest of the call that says, I don't understand why you give dollars for housing, I don't understand
5:13:22 Why I have it. In fact, the call was out yesterday. How do we give it a T-bit? I don't understand why we did that or why the council did it and explaining what that is. I think we have a huge legitimacy slash informational piece in town. You've got to have information coming in so that can come back out of the way that closes that gap. Yes. I think you have teed up the last piece of our process very, very nicely.
5:13:51 But here's where, Sandy, if you'll indulge me having waited all this time. So I'd like to get public comments on this kind of give and get framework that we're using to, this is kind of positioning the roles discussion that I think we're going to have. We're going to try and get these roles down to clear, focused, and functional statements so that the operating boards of all the partner entities
5:14:20 I know what you're talking about, and then I have to read through all the rest of this. So, comments on the give and get? Mine was only on repeat on ESPA, in that it is a totally different model, because it is a government itself, the JPA, and the government's participating, and town contracts, in other words, is actually a contract.
5:14:49 So there's some insights in that too. So we can learn, we can cross-learn and cross-pollinate
5:15:18 This is models and approaches, whether they are originally on the private side, non-private side, or the government side. I think what stood out for me is that the end act government model has a lot of innovative mechanisms, and they've matured to use. Well, there's something very unique that happened actually when, you know, the mountain ran a solo transits system for many, many years, and the town had a small transits system, but the mountain wasn't ready.
5:15:48 And so basically they assigned it over to ESTA and used that for the mountain contract in the winter.
5:16:16 So I mean, there is some real intergovernmental coordination that is obvious. Okay. So does, is, does the, does the, does the, they have a contract with the county as well? Pardon? They have a contract with the county as well? No. They provide, they're a transit provider, period. And that funding that comes through the local transportation commission.
5:16:39 ...provides the hookup for Lancaster to read them. But is there any funding along the way from any of those other communities like that? Yes, that and Bishop, you know, they run the dial ride. The dial ride here we have also, you know, which is fair. We're fair-free only because that was 2000, I think, or way back when, when we passed the key, which said we will have free friends here.
5:17:07 And we did. It was a very limited basis. At the beginning, until Esther took over the mountain system, which was all received. All right. A lot to be learned there. Any other public comments? Yes. I have a question on the, to be right, but the MLT get the technical capacity. I'm assuming that's the town giving MLT technical capacity gap.
5:17:37 Yeah, I think that's, I think it was data and funding information. That's just critical because obviously before John is able to market the data flowing in as far as adjusting budgets, you know, if it's three months before we get COT data, then that's three months, you know, we may, I'm not going to be exactly explaining, I know it's gotten better, but it needs to improve.
5:18:02 So the point I'm hearing you make is not just to
5:18:31 I think that's exactly, we'll get into this, that's exactly the role that we're going down, and that's exactly the concept we all need to know, how everybody plays a role to make this whole thing work. What we'll do on Mondays, we'll actually, we're going to translate all this into
5:18:59 We're going to add some qualitative features to those roles, and they'll be essentially how you will assess whether or not the roles are being executed, not just technically proficiently from a competency standpoint, but there's only four metrics, cost, quality, and quantity, and timeliness. Those universally, those are the only four metrics that matter.
5:19:24 So we're going to try to add those dimensions to all of these rules to see if there's an actual trackable, quantifiable metric that's available to you so you as a council in particular can monitor this effectively without having to go through exercises that we just went through. At this point, we can't do that month in and month out.
5:19:47 I just wanted to add that MLH works regionally as well. We don't work just within the town. We have contracts with the city of Bishop and the county to provide services for homeownership opportunities. Can you go through the floor real quick? We can hear the people. Cost, quality, quantity, and time. Cost, quality, quantity, and time. If I had time, I would give you the holding service centers, but trust me for that. Hey, Michael, we should have to know more.
5:20:24 My apologies, I don't wrote your presentation today, so I missed the analogy, so I'll say, you can give me an update on this. Yeah, yeah, okay, good. And you'll be with us on Monday? Absolutely. Yeah, we'll go for it today. Good, good. Other observations, comments? We good? Okay, so we're, I was going to pull out some kind of,
5:20:51 The last piece I wanted to get to was, I want to build, the key word is communications.
5:21:20 But everywhere I go on planet Earth, the word communications is used as though everybody knows what that means. And what I find is that everyone has a different set of expectations about what communication means. So I find it's a word that actually obscures our intentions instead of shining a light on our intentions. So one of you used the phrase transparent.
5:21:50 So that's sort of a dimension of communicating. You used the phrase earlier of kind of a story map, which I would translate into telling our story. And I find that communities that are really good at talking to one another about what they're working on, where they're going,
5:22:19 And how it's going are really good at sharing narratives. They're really good at focusing on the clear story. The communities that really struggle with this over metricize themselves. They assign themselves dashboards with hundreds of indicators and they abandon them after about six months because the sheer weight of the effort to sustain it.
5:22:48 This overwhelming and the staff time, and you end up becoming a different organization trying to count everything. In a sense, I'm going to start with a theory that you're already collecting most of the data that you need to inform your decision making quantitatively and qualitatively. MLT specializes in this, plus analytics. The other partner organizations
5:23:16 Are evolving or have that same kind of capacity, the town's collecting and monitoring, the ESTA's collecting and monitoring, so you're already collecting all the data. The real question is, how do you secure the community's body, which you said was the universal, so what is that, what is the story that brings the whole, every neighborhood, every partner organization,
5:23:47 All of the givers and all the getters into the process. So we're not going to craft that narrative today. We are going to craft that narrative next week. At least we're going to craft the short-term version. We'll do the vision version in the third meeting. But I have three pieces I wanted to ask you about. The first is, what...
5:24:29 In terms of communicating with the general public and amongst yourselves, what are some examples of key elements, now that I just badmouth indicator reporting and so on, I don't need to do that, but some indicator reporting is useful, it's just when you turn it into a second job. What are the elements that are required in order to promote buy-in? Michael mentioned transparency.
5:24:59 What does that mean, John? So if a stakeholder wants to get access to the information. So it's kind of just in time, right? Not, we'll get that to you in a month. Because the questions arising out of the need of the presence, not future needs.
5:25:35 So we could say availability is a guiding criteria, or a guiding principle, if you will, for communicating, because we want to satisfy the need when it arises. So let's not make the system so complicated we can't deliver it. Let's take time. So how this might work. What else? What's another element? People have to know where to go. Where to go? And it has to be where to go.
5:26:07 Available. This is an enormous problem in communications. It's not enough to say it's on our website. It's on our website and it's 18 clicks. And you have to know how to navigate. What are the elements? Well, there's a different kind of availability. It's not just that this stuff exists, but that it's accessible 24-7, which is, I think, for each other. Accessibility. Yeah.
5:26:41 Well, yeah, the fact that, you know, what good does it do you if you've got a problem that you'd really like to get an answer to on Saturday morning? So this goes to the comment that Proponga was made earlier about John Worsen. Yeah, seven-day-a-week government. I think he was specifically implying that the offices are open to seven days a week. No, but there's some way to get it. Dan's wife will object.
5:27:10 Successful 24-7. Anything else about key elements to promote and support buy-in? Let's not use buy-in in the sales concept. We're really talking about attracting people with similar belief systems. Proactivity. Being proactive. So I'm going to call that a deliberate element.
5:27:43 What would proactive look like in terms of communications? Up to date, it's relevant. A staff member, a council member looks at where people are being convened and anticipates they're probably going to ask about this. Show up there and be ahead of the information you'd rather than waiting for people to join.
5:28:13 So I'm going to put the word anticipatory there to after that. So what I've noticed in communities that are really good at this is basically they set an achievable bar for disseminating information and they deliver it on the same day of every month and create the expectation. And people hold the questions and wait for that day. And if they're still not answering, then they come back. But you get a lot of questions, a lot of confusion out of the mix.
5:28:41 And I'll go to John next. What's the problem with clarity in communications, particularly
5:29:07 I was going to say, it's framing it in the terms of the person that you're talking that's trying to get the information from you, not in the reference of how you think it should be. Exactly. So we're going to just call that common language, and out of the realm of planning speak, government speak, consultant speak, you know.
5:29:34 990 reporting speak and all that kind of stuff. Yeah, that's an excellent observation. So in a sense, I made the comment that it's one of the lessons more in communicating and what I really mean by that is don't make people have to interpret the data, say what it needs.
5:30:12 Just a speech on our experience. Everything you have listed there, we have. We're proactive. We go out and tell people we've done our monthly report. We do people's website. We do open houses. We do all these different things. Whether people choose not to pay attention or don't go for those sources, that's the biggest challenge that we have. We provide that. We've got a website that has 10,000 pieces of data on it.
5:30:42 I mean, just, it's, it's how do you get people, so it's, it's great to tell them where to go, how do you get them to go there? Yeah. And that's our big, and to, for me, that's our biggest challenge in town. People like to, like to say, well, we don't know what's going on. Well, there are 50 different places you can find what's going on.
5:31:08 I think also that that goes to maybe just setting expectations. Yes. That can maybe come back to the leadership saying, look, we're going to set your expectations for what it is. And beyond that, I missed the start of this, so I apologize if I'm off base here, but the word continuity, the idea that... I'm going to parse this a little bit next week in terms of what are the three or four rather than 30 or 40?
5:32:11 Thank you. Thank you.
5:32:44 Yes, I like that.
5:33:11 It builds on, I think, Joe's comment, a couple of yours up here, and I'll put these together where they go, about speaking in the language of the listener, not the speaker, so that you're communicating, and you're communicating in value terms.
5:33:36 Not valued from a planning standpoint, but from a living standpoint, and so on. These are the kinds of things we're going to drill into a little bit more clearly next week. My last question for you. Why, beyond buy-in, why should you communicate efficiently, effectively, proactively, in common language, openly, transparently, seven days a week?
5:34:09 Easily accessible so the customer is informed. The customer here would be finding the public. And what is the theory of benefit for public being informed? That shows leadership. I would say it also sets the expectations. So it's strength in numbers as well.
5:34:48 You know, if you have an informed citizenry that's providing the same message that the council is providing, that's the same message that MLT is providing, you know, strength in numbers. Strength in numbers? On the trust? Yeah, accountability. It instills community pride. It will stay longer and stay longer. People will have to find solutions. And ultimately, the efficiency and social efficiency. From a physical standpoint, people will stay longer and stay longer.
5:35:24 Okay. I'm going to, you've been really good at, you're very quiet, but you keep contributing these wonderful insights. And I like when I find that person in the room. So I'm going to end on this last piece where I was trying to steer you and you went was it's, the why is not just what you push out. It's what you pull in. And our whole concept here is centripetal force, not centrifugal force.
5:35:54 So if you've forgotten your lessons from high school, go look at that tonight. And you'll realize that what we're trying to do is pull to the center and not push out. We're not selling here. We're trying to promote engagement. So you've captured it up here with active citizenship. You've captured it here in the sense that it's not your intention behind getting people to support or buy in.
5:36:22 Their engagement with it and a willingness to share the role of leadership, stewardship, promoting the future, creating this economic security. Because you cannot do it from the dais. You cannot do it one non-profit NGO at a time with limited funds working in silos. You just can't. You could try. You've been trying. It won't work. There's a better way, and it's by leveraging the whole community.
5:36:51 And that's really where we're trying to get with this whole strategy. Put that if they're engaging. They call that the collective genius of the community. Yes. It is the collective genius of the community. In fact, there's a great book called The Eden Conspiracy written by a colleague of mine, actually, who said that the role of education and higher education in the United States is not actually to prepare people for work and to create literacy and so on.
5:37:23 It's to promote accomplished citizenship. And accomplished citizenship is made evidence that the community leaders have the wisdom to bring people into the process. So communication is not something you do to be accountable or transparent. It's a way that I want to leave you on that thought today.
5:37:46 Give you back your day 45 minutes early, which we took out of your lunch. Is that fair? I think we've had public comment throughout. Are we good? I'm turning it back to the mayor.
5:38:13 Nice job everybody. Thank you all very much.