TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2015

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 6 hr 33 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

700 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:44 There's no assigned seat. How about right here, John? You guys come close.

2:12 How far can you throw? Let me try.

2:29 Thank you.

2:58 John, you can sit with your mic, okay? John, you want a call? John, you want a call? John, you want a call?

3:24 My preference is the closer to the front, the facing this way, and also those chairs.

3:46 Until we have to. Until we have to. Until we have to.

4:13 Okay, I'm going to order our Town Council of Mammoth Lakes special meeting for Monday, August 31st, 2015, 806. Roll call, Jamie. Here. Here. Here.

4:41 Here. Here. Please all rise. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Any public comments for items that are not on today's agenda, please come forward. Evan Russell with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

5:22 And I just want to keep you aware that our Performing Arts Center, Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center project is moving forward. We're working with Rich and some of his board members, and Rich is taking that process along. It's been a lot more complicated than we thought it would be to get it to the next stage. There's about five agreements that have to be put in place. But we think the key agreement with the college

5:52 Is just about done. And sometime hopefully before the end of the year we hope we'll bring this to the table for you. And we'll do it through and with Rich's group through MLR. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, seeing none, we'll start our workshop, item agenda one, workshop to discuss the town councils. Thank you all for coming on Monday morning with us all day last Thursday.

6:27 So for those of you who don't know me, my name is Michael Ward. I'm a professional facilitator, strategic planning, consultant. I do community and organizational development. I work, I live in South Lake Tahoe, so I have some familiarity with alpine, rural, resort-based communities. I also work with a lot of the TBID organizations in California, so I have a deep familiarity with the tourism recreation side of local economies. Just for point of reference,

6:57 I work all over California. I worked internationally for a long, long time. I've worked in nearly 30 countries, coming in November, nearly 30 countries, and I've worked on the corporate side, doing training and development, strategic leadership development and planning, a great deal of government work and non-profit NGO integration work, which is kind of what we're here for. And for seven years, I was a statewide director in California for economic and workforce.

7:26 Development and led a large number of regional collaborative initiatives and that's kind of become my mission in life to help communities and regions self-organize, reorganize, synthesize the resources, make collaboration a verb, not a noun, which is what I find happens in a lot of everybody in the country has adopted the mindset.

7:53 Thank you.

8:23 The town of Mammoth Lakes from a town for the council and staff and a series of orbiting satellites. I'm going to refer to the non-governmental organizations as orbiting satellites, each performing strategic, useful, and value-added functions and maybe not as fully aligned as they might be or could be.

8:51 So our purpose was, A, last Thursday, to clarify where the town is with respect to the strategic plan that was developed a year ago, August 2014. We did that through a pretty elaborate exercise. All those findings are included in the package that you have in front of you. I have three extras, by the way, if somebody would like them and if nobody occupies these seats.

9:18 And we tuned up that plan. We did a little performance tune-up. And we said, if the purpose of these meetings is to define and activate a strategy-driven process that clearly aligns and integrates Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Lakes Housing, and Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, at least that's the NGO mix that we selected.

9:47 with the town of Mammoth Lakes to achieve a sustainable economic security for the community. These are fancy words. It's consultant speak, which is how I speak, so I'll try to fix that in front of you today. They're buzzwords, but they actually mean something, and my experience is they mean different things to different people depending on

10:14 What role you perform, where you sit in the organization, where you sit in the community, what your particular history and belief system is, your vantage point and how well you are informed by current data, and the extent to which you have a clear forward vision. My personal experience is that communities like yours are extremely well-intentioned, committed citizens, leaders.

10:44 are often vision impaired, often struggle to see a clear path. And so what we tend to do in the absence of being able to predict the future, I'm not suggesting we should be able to, but in the absence of being able to predict the future and actually navigate a straight line from here to there, we fill our lives full of activities, projects,

11:14 Initiatives, campaigns, data gathering, sort of endless question asking, measurement, and so on. And I actually say all of that with respect and love, because it's how we live, it's who we are. And one of the reasons we have to do all of that is because there's not one person steering the ship. You have a mayor, you have a council, this is your elected body.

11:41 Organizational leaders and board members supporting volunteers committed to the missions of the support organizations. But it can be very, very challenging to find that not straight line, but at least the straightest line. Many people would say the shortest possible line because most of us who envision the future envision it better than today, worse than today. So we want to get there as quickly as possible.

12:12 But we'd like our own aging process to go the other direction. I want to get younger and get to a better community faster. How realistic is that? Maybe not later. So I asked the council and the staff that participated, and thank you all the staff for coming back today, your role is key, to kind of underline the words that matter most to them. And so I'm going to read this again. Activate strategy, align and integrate.

12:43 Achieve sustainable economic security. And so that was the through line that we created in the dialogue, and then we took Council through a pretty elaborate process to tune up last year's strategies that resulted, if you have the document in front of you, just by way of quick orientation, first page was an exercise, second page, third and fourth pages, we took the existing priorities from August 2014,

13:14 And the commitments associated with them, they were what I would call the A through G priorities and a series of action items. Some were task oriented, some were initiatives, some were objectives and so on. Healthy myths. And we decided which ones should be designated as complete, which ones should be kept because they were in process or in progress, which ones should be revised.

13:43 And to the extent they should be revised, mostly we captured input and notes about how to shape those revisions, so those are in the right-hand column. And we had a fourth category, which was delete, or it's no longer relevant, and no one offered any of that. So mostly what we had a mix of was five or six tasks that were completed. The lion's share were keep and revise.

14:13 So this is kind of our tuned up plan. We haven't re-authored the document. This is just a direct report out from last week. So we're going to build on this. I'm orienting you now to the agenda. We're going to do a quick exercise to start with this morning, kind of a what is, what could be exercise. Because while this is a council-led meeting, this is a partnership workshop.

14:42 It's a strategic partnership workshop. I'll say that a few times today. We're going to take a look, a second look at these A through G priorities, and we're going to see if we can't align in and integrate the respective contributions of our core NGOs that we provided to participate. That'll take us somewhere near a morning break. If you guys are going to predict the time, I'll just say when we're done with that, that's break time.

15:13 Whatever time that is. Now when we come back, before lunch, we're going to go through an exercise. One of the things Dan and I talked about doing as an organizing frame for all of you is to come to some very clear agreements on what are often called core values in strategic planning. I'm going to call them community core values because I want to help you get to a community center.

16:36 The word, or maybe it's a short phrase, I don't know if buy-in is actually a word, I think it properly has a hyphen in the middle, so it's an idea about something. I think that something is how you get people to support you who don't currently or might not otherwise unless they can see value for them. So we're going to do a buy-in.

17:04 Value for the Community Exercise instead of a Communications Exercise. As I heard loud and clear from you last week that buy-in was an area in which particularly NGOs may be struggling. And I don't want to keep dancing back and forth between Tahoe and here and leave you struggling, although I do want you to struggle a little bit. So I'm going to have you struggle here this morning, and then we'll get to the buy-in pieces.

17:32 So that's the agenda. Last week we negotiated with Michael, Mr. Mayor's urging a shortening of the lunch, which we translated into shortening the day. And if we're bringing food in again, if you guys want to do that, I'm open to negotiating that. So that's kind of how we'll proceed. We'll do public comment. I think what worked well last week was as we complete each segment.

18:01 But if there is a burning platform of a light under your feet as we go through this, if you do this, I'll say, wait to comment, if you do this, I will probably call on you because I'm drawn to that. Alright? That was a heads up for the audience. Alright. Does this all make sense? This is still our purpose. This will be our purpose every one of the meetings. At the end of the day, we'll talk about

18:31 The third session on September 10th, which is a major goal-setting and visioning workshop. Let's say more about that at the end of the day. The fourth session, which will be a go-to-market rapid action plan. Then you will take your current 18-month plan commitments and roll them forward 18 months. We'll do that in one session, and then hopefully we'll have a real celebration.

19:00 Thank you. Thank you.

19:36 Thank you so much.

20:04 And John, do you have four members that are going to come and go today? Michael and I are, but we were just talking about who's going to be. Okay. John. Colin, you're with? I'm going to be with ESTA, no longer, now with MLH and MLR. And MLR, so you get to decide. Split the difference. You could go to the group that's having the most fun. They look really pained, I would avoid that.

20:35 Anybody with you today? Besides Colin, Larry Johnson. Larry, okay, Larry, welcome. Larry, did you serve on the board? Yes. Do you want to participate in the main workshop here? If I came up there, I might not be able to exit it easily. And we'll need to move chairs and create spaces. So when we do the small group work, we'll bring you up. Thank you. Okay. And so ask the gentleman one.

21:03 I'm looking around. Well, two of our board members are also council members. Okay, so you guys are going to decide. So I'll get John Morris as our chairman, and Michael's on our board, and then I've got three of my staff members here as well. Okay, so feel free to bring them into the process, and I do have a few extras. And then who did I make out of MLR? So, Rich, you have staff in the back.

21:30 Leslie, come on down. Hey Leslie, come on down. Come on down. Joel, you're split, so come on down. Yeah, you guys are participating, our trust coordinator. Absolutely. Joel, Leslie, don't be bad. Come on down. Monday morning, I'll wake up. Joel, you're the guy that sent out the cool self-reportation via MLTPA. I'm on the mailing list, I like that. You guys come and...

21:57 Sit wherever, but then we're going to have you work with your group. We'll have you self-organize as we get into the group. Just preferably not with your back to me. All right. First opening exercise, I'd like to just get us started because I have an exercise I've come up with that's designed not so much for data collection but for debriefing. So I'm going to put you into a little data collection exercise.

22:28 A different form of two-by-two matrix here. This is a matrix where we look at opposing tensions. So the first tension in black vertically here is from your perspective within the organization that you are most strongly affiliated, or if you wear multiple hats, I'll let you kind of take a larger, more expansive community-wide perspective.

22:56 At the top of this continuum, we would say, we always get the priority done. Not the task, the priority. We always get the priority done. And at the bottom of this continuum is, we never get the priority done. And in real life, it's usually not true that either extreme is the reality, but I have to create a continuum, so that's it.

23:30 On the horizontal axis, in blue, we always feel great about our results. We always feel great about our results. On the opposite end, we rarely feel great about our results. So I've come up with a key, a green dot key that says, what is working? What is working that reflects the degree to which we get things done that's our priority and how we feel about it?

24:03 So each of you has in front of you on the yellow cards here a series of red and green dots. Each one of you gets a single green dot. This is your morning exercise. You can count six calories for this exercise. You're going to be able to get up and you're going to come and post one green dot where you think your organization is on this continuum of getting priorities done,

24:34 I'm feeling good about the results. And you have a red dot. And we normally have you do this twice, but this is a little difficult. So we're going to have you come up just once. The red dot is what could be or should be working better. What could be or should be working better in terms of getting priorities done and how you feel about the results. So you're going to plot your red and green dots.

25:08 Anywhere on this map that reflects your personal view, what I would like you to do is not look at how your colleagues are posting dots. There is a form of, I've observed dot moving that happens. Like, if Mr. Mayor don't go first, so if the Mayor posts, the Council start to post and people start to affiliate, their perspectives don't do that.

25:36 Decide before you come up here where you're going to post your dots and come up quickly to do a guest. Sorry to ask the question, but I'm kind of struggling on how a red dot could be anywhere but the lower left quadrant. So could or should. So what could or should be better? Where would you like to see? The green dot is where are you today? The red dot is where would you like to be?

26:05 Presumably the red dots will start to migrate here. Green dots may be all over the map. Not what could or should be working today, but in the future. Could or should be working better tomorrow. Could or should in the future. If we were, we'll be brief, but if we were more collaborative, better organized, have more money, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. So green dots live in the present.

26:37 Red dots live in the future. Does that make sense? And Michael, where has our other entity not as? I'm going to let you decide which hat you want to help focus us. John, did you have that? Okay, do you want us to identify who we are on each other? No. I care who you are, but not on the back. Any other questions? Green dots live in the present. Red dots live in the future.

27:12 Any more questions? I see puzzle books. It'll become clear as you come up. You have three minutes to get through. One dye, one rain, one red each. Oh, here. There, right there. You each get. Each table. No, each table gets one. Each table.

30:32 Okay, I think we have everybody back. Let's get a short debrief. What do you notice about the distribution of dots? We're optimistic.

31:02 Your optimism, what does it say more about that? Well, you know, overall, it looks like the results that we're doing right now are good, but we mostly as a group feel that we could be and will be doing better in the future. It's a good thing. Other reactions or reflections on what you see just as it is? What were you thinking about? What kinds of factors were in your mind?

31:34 Images were in your mind as you were deciding where to place either God. What was going on in your head? How did you decide? I don't think it was possible to have any single head on. We progress back to just the larger kind of community picture of trying to sense of where the community things were as opposed to saying, hey, I think that's useful and helpful to today's exercise. Who else? What were you thinking about? How did you decide? As a new member of the community. Joel, right? That's right. Okay.

32:11 You know, I walk into the community in this present time and I see a vibrant community with a lot of people that care, that are passionate and having lived in a number of different types of communities in the past, I think a nice fresh look to say this is an amazing place and I know if you're in a place for a long time you start to feel like, you know, results aren't happening.

32:40 But I can certainly say that this is a wonderful place and I can see that results have occurred. So were your, I would surmise from your comments that your green and red dot were fairly close together? Yeah, reasonably. Yeah. Who placed their green and red dots farthest apart? What bridge? I did. MLR, two months in with staff. We're still trying to define our roles and responsibilities. I like to think at the end of the day.

33:12 Red, top right core, top quadrant. You know, at the end of the day, we'd like to think we're focused on the right stuff. We feel good about the work. We're working on the right stuff. But at this point, we're still trying to find roles and responsibilities. Who, what, what, and where. So that's kind of a reflection of the fact that any time, whether you do an exercise like this, you're just kind of puzzling this out in your head. It's always a snapshot in time where we are versus where we want to be.

33:38 And in our minds, the gap between where we are and where we want to be really drives our sense of motivation to engage and work harder, work with others, find solutions, solve problems, find resources, and so on. Who else, anybody else with a thought or comment about what caused you to place your dots the way you did, John? Well, I think, you know, ours is, you were asking what we thought about when we put them up there, and I thought about frustration, because I think we do get our priority done.

34:08 And I think we do feel good about our results, but I just feel like we're always getting smacked down by Mother Nature. You know, at this point, we had one of the worst winters ever, and we finished only 2.5% behind budget. So we're pretty proud of that, and we achieved the visitation and the revenue to a certain extent. But it's just, it's the what could have been had Mother Nature cooperated at all. So I think we're getting the visitation, and we're happy about the fact that we're not 30% behind or 20% behind where we easily could be right now.

34:37 But it's just frustrating that we're not talking about numbers ahead. So I want to draw an insight from that, but I want to see if I can draw it out of you first. What insight can you draw from the tension between how productive you are and how you feel about your results versus what part is under your control? Well, I think that's the hardest part is that we are doing what we think is right and it's showing us the results, but we're not...

35:07 So I'm hearing both ends. In one sense, you're making the big investment, you're being productive, you're getting results, but you're being artificially constrained. There's a barrier there, which is environmental factors that are episodic, they may be, who knows what's going to happen.

35:36 This coming winter. Somehow over the course of today I want to help you and encourage you all to get to the vision of the red dot future that is possible collaboratively within the scope of what is under your control and the adaptive capacity to respond to what is not. Well and to that point my red dot is not that far up the line from the green dot but it's something where I think even

36:06 Without Mother Nature cooperating, I think that our efforts are going to continue to get us towards that red dot. It'd just be nice if Mother Nature cooperated and the red dot went off the chart. Yeah. So in a little while, maybe later this morning, I'm going to talk about two things. Accelerating results, moving you faster in the direction of the future you want. Because I started the whole session talking about that. Our pent-up desire is to get from here to the future more quickly.

36:36 And how to magnify those results so that the leverage from each one of your activities, initiatives, campaigns, projects, programs, and so on produces bigger, better results and faster. That's what we're trying to get to. Why is that necessary? Because you have limited resources. And so we have to take advantage of the resources. What else might explain the difference between

37:06 How do you see yourself today and where you would like to be in the future other than weather? What's another barrier issue or constraint that might be impacting green dot red dot distribution? Yes? I feel like on an individual level, results are awesome. We have so many small people in this room and staff that are just getting things done on a daily basis.

37:35 But on an overall level, sometimes it feels like priorities are not super clear. So a barrier issue, thank you for bringing that up, is a lack of specific focus, clarity, our very next exercise. Didn't you guys do this last week where you kept teeing up my next exercise? I think you just did that again. I've been up since 5, but I feel like I'm still just waking up. I don't know about you guys one day.

38:05 So clarity about priorities is absolutely essential. In my personal experience, fancy wordsmithing isn't actually the solution. Writing things in longer sentences doesn't actually always help. Being clear about what it looks like when you're done might. So we're going to try and do a little bit of that. What's another barrier issue or constraint?

38:36 So are we not talking about who we are, where we want to go, and how we want to get there? We define a sustainable economic security. Is that what the exercise did on Thursday? If we hit all those benchmarks based on this template, that is sustainable economic security? Is that who we are? That's an underlying theory of strategic planning. So there's a difference between strategic

39:04 Planning and Strategic Thinking. Yes, thank you for teeing that up. So we're going to revisit that question as we do each piece of this process. Strategic planning is wonderful because it helps a community or an organization or a group of organizations decide where you're going, how you're going to get there, and what actions you're going to take. But the conspiracy underlying strategic planning is it becomes very tactical and not very accelerated.

39:35 So it's the projects in front of your nose that you want to get done because there's some urgency about them. And maybe they're not the most important initiatives that would get us more quickly. I mean, I think Sarah would have said to you that I'm more of an actor and commonality equal. So thanks for keeping that one up. When Dan and I talked about this, Dan had about a six-hour extremely energy.

40:42 And we talked about whether or not we should leave the vision or extract the vision out of the process. And we decided to put it in the third workshop and extract it out of the process and see if we couldn't build the collaborative structure a little more effectively, get some surrounded with some values and principles and some initiatives and then pull that vision.

41:12 Before we go to the action plan. And you brought, you know, I understand that this is part of the third meeting that we're talking about. Yes. Where we want to go. You're exactly right. In the third session, we're going to take a circle around this and go, what is that? What does that look like? Who's doing what? What do you notice when you walk down the street, et cetera, et cetera? We're going to do a rich vision of the context of science. Can I just ask a question? You may.

41:52 You can always ask a question. Yeah, just thinking about the visioning, how does the general plan fit into the visioning? Because the general plan has a whole visioning section for our future of our community, and that's still an active document. Is that irrelevant to our visioning, or does it have to, or need to align to the general plan, or do we ever consider that in this process? Well, I would say, of course, to the last part, but Dan, do you want to respond to that?

42:20 Yeah, I don't think it's a broad vision for the built community almost because there are elements in there in terms of general plan and that puts a big picture out there because that's kind of like a map on the floor up there looking at that. As we begin to look at what are the start drilling down the things that we're going to accomplish and how does that integrate the various nonprofits as well as it's got together, it's casting a different type of vision. It's not in lieu of.

42:49 But I think it's direction for work product more so than for what a general plan is designed to do in terms of age. But you have to make sure they're aligned, right? Ideally, it would be a concept. I think just to add that a little bit, I think we all know what the struggle that we went through as a community of the general plan process last week. I mean, it was pretty telling. And I think that we should all look at this exercise as a general plan is designed to be.

43:16 Yeah, so that's, whatever we're doing here, let's be using, taking advantage of this process and start teeing up. When we start getting into that process later, hey, maybe we want to start going over here. But I think the legal thing that Dan said is entirely appropriate, but I think let's use this as a way to maybe think about articulating users appropriately.

43:40 Whenever I do this in communities, I'm either right on time or poorly timed with respect to the cycle of normal updating. It sounds like in this case, I'm not sure I've ever even asked that question, it sounds like we're probably on time. So this is probably algorithmistic. I'm also thinking that the vision we end up with here and the goals and the detail will be a broader brush. Even I think that's what Dan's suggestion.

44:08 Is that responsive to your question? Yeah, that's great. I just want to make sure that we're at least having that conversation where we're all understanding how this all, the puzzle comes together, these pieces. Otherwise, it feels like we're maybe not in sync. I feel like one of the other big barriers is community buy-in. Yeah, say more about that. Because we can, just for example, for MLT, we're doing a lot of

44:38 Nuts and bolts marketing. And we see good results. But again, the feeling sometimes is that the community at large doesn't necessarily understand or, you know, say, well, yeah, that's great, but you could have done this. You could have done this. So that's, and I think that goes for a lot of the different entities that maybe we're not doing the best job overall making sure the community knows where we're going so that if they do and we show a positive result, then they'll feel good about it too.

45:07 Because if they feel good about it, we feel good about it. We can feel good about it, but if they don't, then it kind of brings, it kind of bursts your bubble a little bit. So that's part of it, too, that making sure that the community at large understands where we're going with all the different things we're doing, and that to the extent possible, they get it. There's always going to be people, obviously, that are going to be on the negative side. We talked about that last week. And to an extent, you just have to say, okay, that's that pile. There's not much you can do about it. And that's always a little frustrating.

45:36 So I think that brings down how you feel about your results. Absolutely. So thanks for bringing that up. So the reason we're going to end the day on this issue of buy-in is I think we want to take you out of the mindset of planning from the inside out and think about buy-in from the outside in at the neighborhood level, at the market level, at the bus stop level, and so on.

46:05 Our community from citizens to active ambassadors for the vision that you're trying to create. And sometimes a flip in mindset is necessary. I think I observed enough of it last Thursday that I want to do this exercise with you today. And that's how we'll end the day. So that will set us up for the vision we work that we'll follow. We'll be well positioned and ready to go there. So I think you're exactly right on.

46:32 One last question, and then we'll go to this exercise here. What, just top of mind, what, if anything, do you think is necessary to overcome the barriers that might be blocking you from getting from where you are to where you want to be?

47:04 Response? Shields comment, the collective vision of the organization. Who are we? Where are we going? What are we willing to do to get there? And still we see that. We're still kind of distracted. A collective vision. So as opposed to an organization, set of organizational visions. Don't each of your organizations have a vision statement? No? So some of you are nodding yes, some are nodding no. That just answers my question.

47:35 An inside out vision of the future you believe you can make manifest through your efforts, but it may be aligned, it may be misaligned, might be tangential, might even be contrary in some form to the vision of your partner organizations. We're trying to resolve that here in the next piece. What else? What might be blocking you from

48:06 Why are we not already here? I think there's one component which is not known in my mind is capacity for resources. I'm not quite sure whether we don't have it yet or not. I think this exercise is figuring out what we all got to bring to the table and tell them. There may be a point of saying, hey, we actually need support. We've got ourselves aligned, we're going to the same place, but we've got some deficits on the resource side. I'm not there yet, but it's good.

48:37 So capacity and resources are always limiting factors because they are what they are. It's an economy of scarcity unless you view it as an economy of richness and resources. Sometimes it's just a different way of looking at the same set of capabilities and capacity to get to a better result. You mentioned the mindset shift. I'd like to see could be, should be, to just must. It has to work.

49:06 I mean, every day we come to work, it has to work. Because we talk too much about what we'd like to do and what we don't. No, we kind of get there. There's no choice. We have to. So if we change that mindset, I think that could break down that barrier, too. So we move from kind of want to be to plus. Yeah. I mean, we talk about this is what we'd like. This is what the community wants. No, we have to do this. It's not a choice. We want to be successful. I think that's the challenge of leadership.

49:32 So this is the

50:04 I always think about two sets of areas that impact communities in the macro sense. One is environmental fluctuations in communities that are sensitive to that, like a resort community, for which we have very little direct control. And then there's normal economic cycling or business cycling that takes place at the macro level. It's well beyond Mammoth Lakes. It's well beyond even...

50:32 Even the regional eastern Sierras, it's well beyond even resort communities. It's statewide, it's national, it's global. I mean, how many of you watched your 401ks or whatever investment vehicle that you have with stocks in the last 10 days? Anybody lose any money?

50:58 My wife was already retired to ask me if this was going to delay my retirement by another couple of years. And I said, well, that's my current excuse. So those things happen, right? So is this an window or is this not a window? What's your assessment? I believe, well, there's lots of different windows. I believe we have a window box.

51:28 And if we don't in this period of time, and I don't know what that is, I think we're going to have to wait for the next cycle. So let's assume that the window is always shorter than we want it to be. So we want to be opportunistic. I think it's your message. On the path of time, I think it's also a process, whether it's dealing with the forest service to get something done or permitting for the town or developers.

51:58 So I think process is something that's keeping us from getting into that red dot. I think we're analysis paralysis in a lot of things. The other side of that is to be ready. Correct. So it kind of goes to some initiatives are better timed in different phases than others. And we'll try and build that as a limiting or a motivating factor into a fourth session and do that action plan.

52:28 One thing I try not to do is leave a community with a bunch of tasks that sounded good, but weren't ill-timed, ill-prepared, or just a long sequence, don't have to be multiplayer. Dan, what are you going to say about that? We tend to be caught up on the urgent or the crisis of the day, and therefore we lose sight of this important national privacy. Yeah, so...

52:50 This is a great way to frame one of my pieces I had up last week, which is the difference between strategic thinking and strategic planning. Strategic planning is mission, vision, values, guiding principles, major goals, strategies to achieve those goals, objectives to implement, incremental versions of that, some system of measurement and accountability, some system of communication and reporting. That's the whole net.

53:18 Strategic planning and sometimes environmental scanning and so on in front of them. Strategic thinking is what leaders do, and that's why you're all in a room together. We're going to suggest, this is for Rich Horfath, so I give proper credit, or we'll call it Elevate, a whole series of other books on strategy development. He said, strategic thinking leaders focus on the important, not the urgent. And yet, as council members, you guys can all testify that even though you want to get to,

53:48 Bigger issues. Often you are forced by the urgency of the now in the form of an agenda and a compelling community problem or concern. Maybe it's been voiced in a newspaper or some other venue. So you're often having to shift from important to urgent and that can undermine the rate of progress in the direction of where you want to go.

54:14 And you want to focus, to your point, on longer rather than short-term outcomes, not because we have more control over the future than we have over the present, we don't, but if we take our eyes off the horizon, we are sucked back into the urgency of the now, and we become project managers. I'm not dismissive about project management, I do a lot of it.

54:42 But it's not how we lead. It's not what's going to give us to the future. And the last thing that good strategic thinkers do is they factor all the pieces together, not cherry-pick components. They say, how do we take care of our community, build the equity in our community, yes, your role and function, build the economic viability of the community, MRR, MLT,

55:12 Take care of our physical environment, infrastructure, public works, and the natural environment through strategic partnerships and so on in ways that can make our economic security actually sustainable and that's what we have to work with. So that's strategic thinking. Alright, so we've teed up a whole bunch of, I'll stop using that expression, it's annoying. I've got one hour at least or like four times.

55:42 We've discussed where you are where you want to be, some of the enablers, some of the constraints on knowing where we're going, some of the barrier issues that are or are not under your control. Now we want to take a look at the existing planning process that is town-centric and determine the extent to which our four-part organizations are

56:12 We're going to keep using this word align. We have it up here. Strategy driven, aligned, and integrated. What does alignment mean to you? What does the word mean to you? What's your top of mind response? We're all going in the same direction. All pointing in the same direction. I think we used the road road. John, we used the road road to study last week. Same page. Same page. What else? What does alignment connote to you? Joe?

56:42 Well, to a certain degree, it also means because you're going the same direction, but there's unique individuality in each piece. Otherwise, it would be combined, and aligned to me is different. So there's still individuality of an organization, but alignment with a common goal. Alignment with a common goal, maybe even common process, or maybe the process is actually allocated between the organizations.

57:10 Right. Different contributions for the same process. What else? Anything else? What does alignment mean to you? Synchronized. Say it again? Synchronized. Synchronized. What do you mean by that? That everybody has a role that moves fluidly towards the same direction. You know, roles based on what we've heard earlier should be clear. Right. Oh, yeah. Very clear. What else? Talk?

57:42 Alignment. When you go to get your car aligned and they charge you $85, what do you think you're paying for? What are they actually doing? Efficiency. Pointing the tires in the same direction. Pointing the tires in the same direction. Do they do that individually? To agree. Yes. So, in a sense, they actually align each tire separately, right? Toe and camber, right?

58:11 And then they align the front wheel or rear wheel. I don't want to take the two front wheel. But they align them together. So they can be aligned individually. That's through separate organizations. Each tire has to function effectively for the whole car to move in the same direction. But then they have to be aligned together. When I think of alignment, I think also what happens if you don't align. You have a very powerful engine.

58:38 That can drive that thing forward. If your wheels aren't aligned, well, gee, one tire gets worn down. It takes a disproportionate amount of abuse, while the other side of the tire doesn't get worn at all. At some point, you could have a blowout, which the whole thing stops. It's really important to get your wheels aligned.

58:59 Let me just assure you, your roads are better here than they are in town. If you live where I live, you can get in your car aligned about every three months because we're in Pothole Hill. So sometimes the best way, I'm going to build on your point just as a last piece of this, sometimes the best way to understand alignment is to think about misalignment, to flip it.

59:28 What does misalizing look like between four organizations and a town with a council and staff? What does misalizing look like? Working toward different goals, different directions. In a different direction. I mean, to follow the analogy, as time goes on, there's a tendency for those individual attires to maybe lead astray a little bit, to get a little bit off course. So this idea of having consistent check-in to make sure that...

59:58 We are still, I think, pulled away. This is where I'd like to share a little quick story. How many of you have flown to the East Coast recently and then flown back? So you probably didn't know this, but if you flew from Florida or anywhere, I just came back from New York recently, and when you're flying from the East Coast, particularly nonstop, and you're not doing a hub, you fly nonstop from the East Coast to the West Coast, what percentage of the time do you think your flight is off?

1:00:35 If you're flying from New York City to San Francisco.

1:01:09 They don't do it in direct line. They don't fly in direct line because the flight is buffeted by headlights from a jet stream. So the flight plan that is filed is the average of the course corrections. The average of the course corrections. I want to plant that idea. So in effect, your collaborative strategic plan and your monitoring for

1:01:40 This scope creep and so on being buffeted by the headwinds of economic variability, weather changes, leadership changes, you're not all staying in your jobs forever, personality, community pulls, local policy issues, conflicts that emerged that you didn't see coming, all of those are headwinds that are buffeting you all the time.

1:02:08 The average of the course corrections is your flight plan so you can think about the strategic prime of those terms. The next time you're flying from the East Coast to the West Coast, you'll be incredibly nervous now when I tell you this. It is the average of the course corrections, and that's what we're trying to get at. So now I'm going to ask you with all of that framing and preamble, I'm going to put you into an exercise in which we're going to attempt to align you, and I like these grid frameworks,

1:02:38 The NGO critical contributions with the A through G strategic priorities of the town. Because if that's not our center of gravity, then the town doesn't have a plan that pulls you in. Remember we talked about the difference between centripetal versus centrifugal force. Do you want to explain it? No.

1:03:04 You did a great job last time. Centripetal is what pulls us all together. Centripetal pulls us in. Centripetal flies apart. Centripetal forces, all this motion and activity and energy and projects and programs and initiatives and all this stuff flies out and it finds its way into contracts and agreements for NGO funding and things like that. You convert the town to citizens' investments.

1:03:32 The issues are in you and so on. Stop me if I go out of school too far here. And they get channeled through an organization, that's centrifugal force. And a contract gets framed and says, please do this, do this, deliver that by then, and bills accordingly. And that's all centrifugal force unless there's a center of centrifugal gravity pulling you all back to the center. Share a vision, share goals.

1:03:59 Shared process, even shared values and purpose. Okay? You guys still with me? All right. Now, I want you to reorganize yourselves into working groups based on the four NGOs. So we're going to have an ESTA table. We're going to have an MLR table, an MLH, and an MLT table. I guess that's probably back there. We're going to have a Town of Mammoth Lakes table.

1:04:28 I thought about this coming down here. I'd love if the council members who serve on boards go ahead and go with your boards. How many would be left? So a couple of you guys and maybe one or two staff, maybe Dan. So Dan, if you'll stay with the council side. And I'm going to ask staff.

1:04:57 To distribute yourselves one per NGO. Okay? And it's not necessarily the NGO you work on or that you have the most affinity for. I just want you to bring a town perspective to that process. So go ahead and reorganize yourselves. Choose a table.

1:06:05 Okay.

1:06:32 So this is a, somebody can join us. Hi. Thank you. You have a big table. So we have four, three, five.

1:06:49 We're going to have three over here. Four, five, seven. All right. So even though some of you have your back to me, I'm going to have you kind of look up here. So we're going to begin with A through G.

1:07:19 Strategic priorities that were enumerated by the Town Council in the planning retreat in August 2014 and reaffirmed and refreshed last week in our workshop. There were a whole bunch of component tasks. You know what those are. Dan, did we have that handout? While Dan's distributing that, we have all of the component projects and you all received this.

1:07:56 I'm going to suggest that alignment is the simple process of figuring out how you will work effectively and efficiently together in the direction of the red dots. We're going to use red dots for the rest of the day. And the question for you is,

1:08:31 As a separate organization, what is it that we are doing that is aligned to these priorities? What are we doing that's aligned to these priorities? Now John mentioned to me, John Wentworth mentioned to me that solving the parking problem may not be a big MLH objective, but I could be wrong in assuming that. In fact, it may be that

1:09:00 The steps in solving the parking problem are actually a leverageable aspect of getting to housing needs. I don't want to make assumptions about that. So we're going to stay with these priorities because they are the plan for the town. I'm not going to make any Johnny conclusions about whether we're going to keep or modify further any of this. We simply want to invite you to offer up what you're doing

1:09:30 It will help deliver on these priorities. So that's your task, and I'm going to give you four ways to think about it. I've got a quote here from David Norton. How many of you are familiar with balanced scorecards? The Kaplan and Norton scorecards? Really? Only two or three of you? How many of you have heard of or seen or used balanced scorecards in your professional life? I am shocked. How old are you all? Hmm. Okay. Okay, so 30 years.

1:10:03 Where did the balanced scorecard work? The idea of a balanced scorecard was to look at the fiscal security of a community or an organization, the customer value, the operational process, and whether or not the company or organization is a learning organization, and take all four of those and bring them into alignment, harmonious balance.

1:10:29 So that you don't measure your success on whether you make money or you have $3 million in your bank account, you know, for security. You say, well, if we have $3 million in our bank account but our roads aren't good or our citizens' health needs aren't being met or we don't have the staff to keep delivering as an organization or we don't have a way of tracking our results and learning from it.

1:10:59 We're not very balanced. So the idea of a scorecard, this is my entire workshop on it, was to bring all of that into alignment. One of the authors, David Norton, said, logic says that we have to manage strategy. We develop a strategy and then we manage it, right? That's what we do. We've got a bunch of strategic priorities that roll up to this big strategy over here.

1:11:26 He says, but in many organizations, you could say many communities, there's no process to manage it, and the need for such process hasn't dawned in the minds of the executives of the leadership, because they never had it, you can't miss it. So the idea here is, what would it look like if we actually missed it? Right? What would it look like if we actually missed it? The only way I know to create a visual image of this is to start

1:11:56 I'm going to suggest that there's four ways to look at alignment. There's practical alignment and practical alignment. About simple awareness. So let's say each of your organizations

1:12:38 Commits to read the strategic plans of all the other organizations in the room. Now you're aware of what their leadership and board's priorities are, what they've committed to work on, where they're going, what investments are going to be made, and that awareness is practical in the sense that you know about it, you can think about how your work connects with it.

1:13:06 So that's simple practical alignment. There's not much leverage there, but it's a good idea, and I would say it's the minimum bar, minimum threshold. If that's practical alignment, what would functional alignment look? What might it look like? The results coming together. Yes. So let's say shared projects or initiatives. It could be a campaign. It could be a marketing campaign. It could be an outreach strategy. It could be a conjoint branding.

1:13:48 It could be any kind of one-off, isolated, but committed process. We'll call that functional. So that moves us from just knowing about it to actually working together on something. If that's functional, what would be purposeful, or even we could call this intentional? Prioritize projects. So prioritize projects, which is the point of this exercise. Anything else? I would say purposeful would be timing.

1:14:29 Why would that be important, Colin? I guess for me that's what shifts it from a functional to a purposeful. Yes, it's not the old, you guys know the Sisyphus proposition that it was bad and you had to roll the rock uphill and every time you got to the top the rock rolled down and you had to start over and do this for eternity. You have to read Robert Graves and the Greek Myths. So in a sense, it's not enough to work on stuff and keep pushing forward. You've got to know where you're going.

1:15:09 So you get very intentional and purposeful alignment is where you get very integrated in your approach. You start really now overlapping plans. If that's, we went from awareness to shared projects to prioritized outcome-driven projects. If that's practically, functional, purposeful, what might be powerful? On the priority. What kind of results? That sounds like...

1:15:53 That sounds like board speak or something. What does that sound? Results on a priority project. Share business. Intended results. So intended results, that's all here. We've already got results. You're outcome driven. It's purposeful. It's connected to your vision. It's intentional. I would like to propose that power comes from outside the organization. So when your community has so much buy-in that they're picking up the ball and running with some of these projects,

1:16:30 Supporting them with money, their spirit. For example, disabled sports, Easter Sierra, I used to volunteer, help me try to figure out this concept. An RV is parked in the disability spot from Starbucks this morning. And I asked who it was, and only so is mine. And I graciously said, we have a large disabled population here through Disabled Sports Institute in Sierra.

1:17:04 Next time you're going to park your RV, could you please consider that? Now, Kathy Copeland wasn't there. I haven't volunteered for disabled sports in 10 years, and yet it's still in my heart, and I'm speaking and advocating for that. That's Howard. Yes, so you have a, so I'm going to extract the part of that that connects to the message I'm trying to get to here, and I think what you're calling out here is the other side of our matrix here. All of these alignment things were focused on this axis.

1:17:34 So far, everything that we've talked about is focused on do we get the priorities done? Is it outcome-based? Is it methodical? Is it integrated? Is it cooperative? Can we measure it? That's all leadership speak for something. I want to know, do you feel good about it? At the end of the day, can you foster community engagement around?

1:18:03 Your results. Can you drive community pride? Yes? How about joy? Things like that in the functional area. And then in Purposeful, that's the project. It takes all of the parts of the community to the project. And then, you know, the powerful part comes out the other side when we put dirt for very low cost.

1:19:23 And communities like this really celebrate those projects. And then they really take ownership. They get a sense of pride through beautiful rooms of dirt. I've seen it. You know, where big trail projects that are built well instill such community pride. People are out there with their dogs, with their bikes, with their kids. And I've just seen the power of dirt. And it's a good analogy maybe for this.

1:19:48 I love it. So I want it to be, because we're recording this, I want to go on the record and know that I did not coach Joel offering this elegant testimonial. That's his new slogan. The power of dirt. It was an elegant testimonial. He just, you notice, he just kind of skipped right past here. He started here and he walked us through for trails what this would look like.

1:20:14 So he just saved me five minutes of time and illustrated what I want you to do in your groups. And here's how I'm going to propose you do it. You've got some yellow cards on your table for you to take notes. You've got some marking pens on your table. I'm going to ask you to have a discussion within your organizational groups like this. I want you to look at these A through G strategic priorities and decide

1:20:44 Where do you want to start? Don't go A, B, C, D, E, F, G. Choose the priority that is the center of gravity as you see it for your organization. Take a look. Maybe it implements a comprehensive community plan. I can think of a couple of them. MLR might be in the enhanced community amenities. MLT may be

1:21:14 So I want you to choose on this axis where you're going to start and then I want you to think about practical, functional, purposeful, powerful alignment. What is it that you are doing and plan to do going forward that is aligned with each of these priorities as an organization? I'll get to the council piece in a second.

1:21:45 Counterintuitively, I would like you to start out here and work your way back. I want you to start with practical and do what I just took you through because we'll run out of time and you'll go, well, we didn't get to powerful. And I'll go, hmm, let's reverse that. Let's start with powerful and work our way backwards to practical. If you don't get to practical, I don't care. So I want you to go, choose the line here, start with powerful.

1:22:17 Answer the question, what are we doing or planning to do that's aligned with that priority? What are we doing or planning to do? I want you to write it. I'd like you to turn these yellow cards just for space reasons horizontally like this, okay, landscape view. I'd like you to print large enough that we can read it, at least these folks can read it where they're seated. And I'd like you to use descriptive

1:22:47 Language, please try really hard to take the jargon and buzzwords out of it. Don't say, please don't just say communicate. We're just going to assume you're going to communicate. Say what that means. Everybody clear on the assignment? What are you doing as an organization that aligns with these priorities with its powerful, purposeful, functional network? For the council team,

1:23:23 Dan, for your team. I would like you guys to think about what it is. This is the give-get piece taken to a different level. What is it that you need the four NGOs to contribute? You're going to have a big stand here. So choose the ones that stand out for you. You need NGOs in terms of contribution. We'll see how closely those line up. Okay? Staff, you guys are distributed amongst the groups.

1:23:56 Participate actively in the discussion. Don't be quiet. Everybody clear? You have, is that the clock accurate? So I'm going to give you, I'm going to give you 20 minutes. 20 minutes and we'll do a time check at quarter to 10 and see where you're at and then decide if you need to negotiate. Everybody clear? One person writing at each table. No handwriting, just printing.

1:24:29 All right. First of all, we should figure out a change where we are. I've got it. I just want to get a chair for you. I would say the most powerful to me is Dean.

1:24:59 Thank you.

1:25:23 I think, obviously, I mean, I think MLH policy is about halfway. Yeah. I think this is sort of a great way, this is super inclusive, but overall. Okay, so, and I tended to go towards community amenities.

1:25:53 Thank you.

1:26:27 I mean, but to, to, to Bruce's point, like, if you look at, like, if you look at

1:27:55 Thank you.

1:31:24 What's the, what would cause people to say?

1:31:54 Thank you.

1:32:06 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:32:36 Thank you.

1:33:05 I think MLH facilitates.

1:33:34 Thank you.

1:34:03 Okay, so we're still on D. Yeah, we're running D.

1:36:29 Thank you.

1:39:12 Thank you.

1:41:46 Let me do an early time check. How many need five more minutes, seven more minutes? Okay, it's not necessary that you have to have alignment across every one of these A through G. Only focus on the ones that are priorities for your organization. Okay, so we'll go until 10 off.

1:42:11 Thank you.

1:42:40 So, is there any other place where you feel that MLH is for you?

1:42:59 No, I don't know.

1:43:09 Thank you.

1:43:27 Okay, so what are we doing?

1:43:57 Thank you.

1:44:26 Powerful.

1:44:55 So how do we describe what MLH does? This one is really hard for me. Yeah, I know, it's big. I'm just having a really good question. What is it MLH does?

1:45:24 Thank you.

1:45:54 Yeah, I mean, yes.

1:46:23 Thank you.

1:46:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:47:21 Thank you.

1:47:51 How many need five more minutes?

1:50:25 Thank you.

1:52:30 So one more minute. Unless you negotiate.

1:53:44 Let me call a brief timeout. Brief timeout. Let me change the agenda here. I'm going to give you all five more minutes. At 10 o'clock, we're going into break until 10.15. You can choose to work through your break or take a break.

1:54:12 But at 10.15, we're going to report this all out. All right? Take five more minutes, then a 15-minute break.

1:54:21 Thank you very much.

1:54:51 Thank you.

1:55:20 Which is cool.

1:59:03 Thank you.

2:09:50 Yeah. How are you? Hello. Doing well. Are you guys? You've been all worked out? Yeah. All right. I'm excited to really be optimistic. Good. As a leader especially, you have to be.

2:10:20 Well, and what I thought was so interesting on the dots is we all say, we think we're doing, and I've been looking at the great ourselves, we think we're all doing well, but we're not sure if we're like the results, yet we're much more optimistic about being able to get to get results. You know what I, I didn't say this, but I think being part of that, and to be sort of said, is seeing get some issues.

2:10:49 Thank you.

2:11:18 So you're going to come up, post them, sorry, didn't you go? And then I would post them powerful back. Are we doing this like we're not? Because we'll do it or no? Yeah, we can take it. I'm going to say who wants to go first? I know. And then we'll be powerful back with the back. Yeah. And then we'll get them all up here. And then we'll ask what he brings the whole thing, not all the time, because it'll take it to all the time. So you're going to post them up until you start.

2:13:44 I got my, I got my truly.

2:14:13 And then you hit, you know, apply, and it basically searches everything that falls into a category, and then you have your save time, so you have, like, a handful of combos, and then a handful.

2:15:41 Okay, let's reconvene. We took an extra long break. Okay, we're going to have...

2:16:06 We're going to have five. Here's what I want to happen. We're going to have five individual team reports. Who are going to be our reporters, our presenters, by show of hands? Rich, John, Jennifer, Joe, Dan. Okay, so we don't care what order you go in. In fact, any random order will serve us well.

2:16:36 Here's what I want from presenters. I would like you to assume you only have two minutes, right, to tell the story of the discussion that you had in your group. I'd like you to post powerful in, powerful alignment piece first, tell us why you chose that, and then give us just a quick sketch of the rest of it. You don't need to read them all.

2:17:03 Don't read them all out. Give us the powerful piece. Give us a sense of what is important to your organization. And then just plot the rest. Then we'll go to the next group, the next group. After 10 minutes, then we'll debrief all of it together in context. Okay? We're going to save questions and comments until everyone has reported. We're only posting powerful? You're posting all of them, but talking about powerful. Give us your end game.

2:17:35 Your big-ticket game goes to RASC. You can comment on them. Just don't read them all because you don't have time. During the lunchtime, I'll invite you to come up and scan them. All right. Who wants to go first? MLR. Jump up. Good morning. This is a baby and the staff's been on board for two months. We're in the process of putting our strap got together. We'll make that presentation to Town Council on Thursday, excuse me, Wednesday, Saturday at 4.30 as a workshop.

2:18:12 My concern right now is that what I put down on paper has just become a history of the world. See, I don't want to get too far in front of my board because some of this stuff is set at a minute that hasn't come to the surface just yet. But the big question is, what is MLR? What do you do? How's it different from recreation? How's it different from what Stu does with recreation? So we went through and began to look at not just the whole Strat document, which really is enhancing community amenities, which we think will enhance...

2:18:48 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:19:18 With location, shape, due diligence, so they can make a decision to give us some direction. We know we need to move to this because the town decided not to move on with the lease agreement with the school district. And we know this is practical because we need to do a better job of communicating who MLR is, what we're doing to leverage R&U funds at this point in time, and the whole public trust concept of how we maximize those dollars and create and enhance some great community facilities.

2:19:47 We went through two others. One was the Performing Arts Center, which Evan gave us a conversation to public comment. We're looking at this maybe October of 2018. We backward mapped this. We're also looking at the public provider and public aquatic center. You know, some kind of conversation, a collaborative conversation with maybe a partner in town. High altitude training, all the great work of trails. We have a list of these, but we just focus on one because I think my two minutes is up.

2:20:16 Take 30 seconds more and go ahead and post them. Post them. Yep. Any additional comments you want to make? No more comments. I think I've summarized them. Okay. Are we going to have to overlap these? Yeah. Okay. And some of you have coded them by your group names. Thank you for doing that. If you haven't done that already, just put your acronyms or initials.

2:20:43 Jo, do you want to go next? So now I'm just speaking at our top. Okay. We focused on ESTA's ability to be powerful and did not work backwards. We just went first to which areas could we be powerful. So the first is community amenities. Okay.

2:21:13 A community amenity is not going to work if we have not also at the same time implemented expanded reliable service that everybody uses. Plain and simple. That's our vision. Then we went on to air service where there is also a definite goal for ESTA is two of them. Delivering riders to their lodging and then once they're in town making sure that they don't need to use a car. They can get wherever they need to.

2:21:45 This is the one area we're not following the directions. The practical part of that is we know we have to balance what's provided as a public service and what's provided as private services for air service expansion. Then we move on to the comprehensive community and that powerful is that, or excuse me, purposeful that we've been able to include transit.

2:22:15 In the planning, not as afterthoughts. So a development has a way to deal with transit like, you know, a next bus equivalent in the lobby and things like that, not saying, oh, well, there's a bus stop a half a block away, so that's okay. It's a totally different way to look at it. And then finally, on solving the parking problem, we also went with power, because if we create a transit system that makes people understand that they don't need a car at all, then that's one of the ways of solving the parking problem.

2:22:46 I'm sorry, where does this one go? E-functional. Oh, but on functional, we said at least that supporting the parking solution with effective service and facilities will make that parking solution work better. So whether it's you're picking up from their lodging or they're in a parking structure, those kinds of things, that's where SD can be purposeful. Great use of functional. Functional, excuse me, functional, yeah. Very nice. Who's next? Housing. Yeah, but the... Okay.

2:23:44 So Mammoth Lakes Housing, we create housing where an integral part to enhance the overall community. We're a part of the general plan. So we, and it's part of our mission statement that we create a viable community. So we help facilitate a viable community. We implement comprehensive creation of homes for the workforce. We have resources, community outreach.

2:24:20 And then I thought we might, we create amenities, but we're going to stick at our amenities, homes, amenities, under diversified economic development because it's an amenity, but you can't have a diversified economic community without housing for those people. We enable economic diversity. Participate actively in the direction of local, no, no, no, no.

2:24:59 Sorry. It is. Enable economic diversity by providing homes for local workers. That is powerful. Yes. Yes. Provide housing and amenities to those that seek them, participate actively in the local community members, organizations, and that's an amenity, but it's an essential for diversifying engagement.

2:25:29 Very nice. Very nice. Good distributor. Who is next? MLT. We touched on three different sections here. The biggest one being improving air service. I think on the powerful side is to secure the subsidy funding, working with town council, working with the town to collect the funding, partnerships on air service with town as well as the mountain and the county.

2:25:58 And then as well as the development of the ALP, the facilities, the future routes, et cetera, and then our relationships with the FAA and the airlines. Just to continue on here for now, on the purposeful side, increasing inflamements, increasing new markets, increasing ROI, air travelers spend 63% more than the driving, and then also increasing funding availability. On the functional side is to educate the community on cancellations. We don't cancel 50% of our flights. We canceled seven last winter.

2:26:28 Business buy-in to promote packages to impacts and all the connectivity that you can get here from anywhere in the world. And then on the practical side, it's access both for locals and for visitors. Increasing the reach worldwide. Destination credibility versus our competitors. It makes it a far more credible destination. Business attraction because you can get out to meetings or appointments that you have. And then community education.

2:26:54 We have one on the enhancing community amenities because without the success of tourism, we work with MLR on things. Visitation, increased visitation increases Measure A, R, T, and U, and then support all the efforts via marketing, so whether it's bus service or new facilities and infrastructure from MLR. And then on the diversifying economic development.

2:27:22 We have collaborating. Collaboration and agreement on event sites, brand, place, and image. I think that there's a big concern that the town doesn't really know who they are, that they're not a tourism destination. So it's getting that brand, place, and image out there. Eliminating roadblocks to people that don't want to see development or growth in town. Cultivate our federal partners to enhance the experience.

2:27:53 On the functional side, work with all of our partners, our involvement, myself and my staff in leadership and participation, and then defining the common goals. And then on the practical side, visitor needs, year-round activity, weather-proofing ourselves, access opportunities, the town brand and image again, and then maximizing the place. Yeah, boy, encourage your group to think about taking that last one and moving it from practical purposefully.

2:28:30 Those were, that's an adaptive framework that you just laid out for us. I think we were kind of on the, we were talking about it. Yeah. A lot of crossings or something. Yeah. There were a lot of things that went over multiple categories. Yeah. Well, we'll leave it there for now, but I might take some editorial licensing notes. Dan, you are going to bring us home. We need to rearrange? Yeah. I'm going to pick it up.

2:28:57 We just figured after everybody else got up and put this up there, if you all do that, then we're going to be successful. So, thanks. So a lot of that is, we didn't break it quite as a close. Most of our stuff is kind of balanced between the powerful and purposey various partners. And we kind of went through each of the first one just in terms of, you know, really getting that list of meetings out, bringing it forward, get the community dialogue going, you know, we're talking dollars time from that amenity base and through that.

2:29:39 I think this is kind of a crossover on air service as we're dealing with. We have partners in place with the mountains, with MLT, with the airlines. How do we grow that final life-defined project, such as terminal building? But also, do we lack some level of shared purpose in terms of air service? How much of that is winter versus summer? How much is that midweek versus weekend?

2:30:06 And so there's some work in that area where we have to think that direction can go out. Continuing with that, we talked about just needing more people in seats. The expanded flight issue, the expanded destination earlier. You can get here if it's a hop, skip a jump in the hop. Is there ways to work through that? How do we get our community committed to the fact that we subsidize air service for a good return? Why are we doing it? Oh, here's why we are. Growing the outs. Enhancing our inside just goes to what we're doing.

2:31:04 How many things it can, or if we could do it, how do we leverage that back internally, back inside and work, it equals five or six. Item D is one of the first things there, D was the first of our story map completed, so we can actually tell the story visually and we're getting there. And so we need that from the other partners. And then how does that go into the community? So when someone talks about Mammoth Flakes, there's a list of different items that everybody kind of, folks to visit with.

2:32:16 And we're talking about the experience on the trolley going up to Lakes Basin. Tom was saying he's on the trolley taking the family. And so a whole new conversation happened. Also building those communications that tie the town together. How do we really work on that conversation that ties? But it's also that amenity base. And then the building was painted. So people won't notice. Physically as well, football helmet cars are about this way. Part of that is to get back in and really the integration with transit.

2:33:50 Parking hubs. How do we make sure if you park your vehicle? One, you can leave it more than three hours without getting a ticket. Parking issues. How do we all get the buy-in of being a real destination resort? There's a lot of different communities in particular that are actually building things. Is we're not sure we're ready? Or is it? And so part of our, again, we want to center who we are, and as our groups come together, it's what is the value of the trail system? What is the value? Communicate that internally and then take that externally for investment. And lastly,

2:35:56 I didn't see a lot of people deal with the, and part of what I was doing with that is just that need for that community conversation, that it's being engaged in two levels, the town's engaged in it from process and things that work for, the community's engaged in it from election. And so one of the concerns there is that the impact of that election, what does that foretell for us, both in terms of nightly rental with that means for our community, but also does that set a standard up for more initiative-based government? But to have that discussion out there, here's the value.

2:36:44 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:38:08 So you just exhibited a third element of strategic thinking. Just to say, how do we as a collective make sure that we're factoring all the elements of powerful impact when considering each incremental project or activity or initiative as opposed to saying, each of you go do your own thing, send us your results, and we'll figure out later whether they went together. See what I'm saying?

2:38:41 So this is what we're trying to do. These cards are populated with a whole series of ideas. That's all strategic planning is. It's just a bunch of ideas about how to determine green dots into red dots. Because that's where our aspirations lie when we want to feel good about our work. So as these were being posted and reported out, what were a couple of ideas that stood out for you? What caught your attention? Yes. Can I just back up a little bit?

2:39:11 So one of the things that struck me when everybody was reporting, because we all have the same stakeholders. Correct. But the stakeholders. No, I'm going to, I'm going to, I think I've anticipated where you want to go. We're actually going to spend most of our time after lunch converting the conversation from what you all want to do on behalf of your stakeholders to what they want you to do. Right. So, no, no, no, you're, this is, what is it, GMTA, right?

2:40:33 Great minds think alike, yeah. But you said something else, and that is you said we're the actors and we're looking at the agency relationship with stakeholders. I'm going to suggest that it's actually in between. You are also stakeholders. The thing that really sets this community apart from a lot that I work with is your isolation from the rest of the world guarantees that you are active stakeholders in your own.

2:41:02 Process creation. You're trying to create the future, not because your organization has a mission statement, but because you want to live in that community. I live, I haven't mentioned, I've been purposeful about not mentioning South Tahoe today. I live in South Tahoe. I got there 13 years ago. My youngest son graduated from high school, went to college. My wife and I waited about 12 hours and moved to the mountains as soon as we got him in a dorm room.

2:41:31 No exaggeration. It was not my intent. I was working internationally. I just wanted to be by an airport. And I thought, Reno, okay, 63 miles, I can get there in an hour. That was my deal. But we started driving around. I met with the city manager the other day, Nancy Carey, and I said, Nancy, on Friday, in fact. I said, Nancy, she said, why did you? And I said, well, you know, I started driving around the town going, what is wrong with this place? You know, and then we started investigating the education system and the college and the...

2:41:59 Health System and all these other things and said, wow, this is the land I want to live in. This is not yet the community I want to live in. So I've been working for 13 years to create that community and I think that's who you are too. So we're going to go to that other place right after we... Okay, so can I keep this going? Yeah? Did I sell you on that? So what ideas stood out? Quick debrief. What caught your attention?

2:42:34 What did you hear? And you're going, yes, John. It's all about how we understand what we're doing. That's our biggest challenge. So this builds on the comments that we were just exchanging. So here's my observation. Most communities that I work in, the level of understanding about how an economy works is about that large. And so how you're all paid to connect dots.

2:43:15 This is just a framework issue. People don't understand how addressing air service fosters the community outcomes that folks desire or contribute to diversified economy. This sort of vertically and horizontally connected relationships are not well understood. So is it your job to first understand it yourself and then to educate?

2:43:44 That is, in fact, your job. But we could start getting lost in the buzzwords of saying, yeah, we have to educate the public, which, to use your phrase earlier, I would say, what does that mean? What does that actually look like on Monday at 4 to 11? What's going on that's educating? How does that happen? We live in this little world. I think I'm really struck by bringing this back to the focus of what it is we're trying to do here, which is this a lot of process.

2:44:55 And it's very interesting to revealing to hear the difference they're reporting out and getting kind of sense of what kind of universe we're all relatively living in. And I'm hopeful that we can take this information, tease it out, and start taking what I hope is the next step of figuring out how we're going to integrate and align these things. I had a conversation with the town staff member, with the board member of the NLR, with the most fundamental questions of what are you doing and how does it, I don't understand the communication, not about

2:45:25 Not just externally out to the community, but internally amongst ourselves. I'm pretty sure we're on the right track. We're having the right kind of conversations. But there's a lot of work here, a lot of good work to do to start getting these lines so that we can all be on the same page with them. Yes, for council purposes, if last Thursday was sort of tune-up level one, we did the complete keep, revise, deletes, this is tune-up level two.

2:45:55 Which is, what's the complementary contribution of the partners in this centripetal set of relationships? One thing that struck me, you know, Dan made the comment that for this to all work, 2 plus 2 has to equal 5 or 6. And that's something that I'm very cognizant of, this idea that as we are aligning all of our different NGOs, one of the common purposes and threads is that since we have limited resources,

2:46:25 So it's not simply a great insight. I want to double down on what you said. Dan said 2 plus 2, I'll paraphrase, should equal 5. That's the theory behind the relationship between the town and these NGOs. Let me be really

2:48:05 Bold and blunt about it. If you were a larger urban center, wouldn't all these NGOs be functional departments of municipal government? They would be. So let's flip that and say, what is the relative advantage that a series of specialized focus, what did we do in the give and get last week? You said expertise, singular focus, remember? It's all in your notes. Expertise, singular focus.

2:48:40 And leverage, multiplier effect. What is the competitive strategic advantage that you have when you utilize these NGOs to advance tourism, housing, recreational amenities, transit? What is that advantage? Beyond leveraging dollars. Responsiveness. Responsiveness. Yes.

2:49:12 Do you want to say more about that? What does it look like? Why would you be more responsive? Yes. So what's taking place in the private, specialized NGO that can't take place at the same speed, the same time to market, time to development inside the town process that's trying to manage sewer, water, streets, cell removal?

2:49:44 Building, zoning, the list goes on and on and on and on and on. I was on your website, a list of departments, even for a small community, it was quite large. How much time can Dan allocate on a percentage basis to every single one of those functions in the course of a week? Not nearly the degree of focus. I'm looking for a word here, responsiveness and one other thing. Accountability.

2:50:17 Maybe accountability, but that's about the money. That's all about the money. We get stuck there. What's taking place in the creation process and solving problems and inventing the future, moving from green to red dots? What's taking place in the NGOs? We've expanded the people who are engaged. You've increased the number of people who are engaged. So you're moving the stakeholder community indoors, right? They're part of the partnership.

2:50:50 That's what I'm looking for. You're actually creating a model for innovation. Why innovation? Is that another buzzword that's being overused in the public sphere today? You cannot go on cable news or anywhere and hear every single politician talking as though everything is innovative. Everything is not innovative. Unless you design for innovation. You are, in fact, designed for innovation.

2:51:22 You've got specialized singular focus entities that can craft business models like ESSA that we were celebrating last Thursday for its algorithmic approach to scaling and adaptive responses to changing environmental conditions, to delivering a free public transit service, for goodness sakes. We can't even get the community to agree to agree on that in Tahoe.

2:51:50 And we all agree, but nobody wants to fund any part of it. So it's the capacity for innovation that's taking place here, and that was evident in most of the ideas that were put up. How encouraged are you adding this method and capability to town's vision for itself? Right now, the town's priorities are a set of tasks and projects, hire a police chief.

2:52:30 You know, improve air service and specific tasks under that. Diversify the economy. These are really, really big ticket issues. Every community I've ever worked in has five of these goals, five of these priorities. They don't mean anything unless somebody's executing at the policy funding approval level and somebody's executing at the innovation.

2:53:01 Problem-solving design level. And between you, you're bringing your community along to pull them in as active partners, not as voters, but as engaged ambassadors. That's what we're trying to do. So, John, to your point, what I envision would go is this is tune-up number two. I would like to pull this. We're not going to attempt to do that with 30 people in the room.

2:53:30 I'd like to pull this back into an adjusted framework. We'll keep your A through G strategic priorities council, but take your list of projects, and we're going to really focus on the powerful and purposeful goals. Everything else is tactical. You guys will do that within your own plans. But I think if you want the NGOs to align with the town, the powerful and purposeful contributions,

2:53:59 The powerful column is the key to the communication issue because

2:54:32 This is why you exist. This is how you do it. These are some of the what's. That's the tactical stuff. But it's why you exist, why you collaborate, why you work together. That's what we want to get to in the afternoon. Now I would like to shift us, unless somebody else has a closing observation on this. Any others? Are you good with this? Okay. It wasn't completely exhausted because

2:55:02 It was constrained by the amount of time that I gave you. You don't have your full boards here. But Dan and I kind of envisioned this process. We're going to send you away with a homework assignment today. We're going to send you with another homework assignment after the September 10th meeting. And that's for you to, I'll tell you now, engage in some debriefing within your own groups on your normal discussion cycle. Your boards may or may not meet even.

2:55:30 Be meeting between now and September 10th, but you certainly will meet between now and October 8th, which is our final action plan session. So you will have a formal homework assignment to come back prepared to participate all in. Not, you won't be constrained by, well, we only have two board members here. You will have discussion with this process. A year from now, you'll go, that was nice. And I will be proud of that.

2:56:06 So that's our performance tune-up that begins to integrate and align the NGOs in powerful, purposeful ways. Now we want to take a look at, we're going to look at our community in two lenses. Core values, we're going to call them community core values, and then we're going to look at buy-in, or the process of converting citizens and neighbors into active community ambassadors.

2:56:39 Sounds good, yes? So every one of you has a handout from last week's workshop. Joe, if you'll hold that up so you can see the blue on the front. If you don't have one, I think I have three more over here. You can sit wherever you like or go back to your original seating or if you like your new arrangement, that's good too.

2:57:36 Thank you. All right. So I'm going to have you turn to

2:58:10 I think it's page five maybe. Yeah. Starting on page five, six, seven, and two-thirds of the way down eight. Here we go. We did an exercise last Thursday. We started off by looking at the needs and differences amongst full-time residents, part-time residents, and visitors.

2:58:41 Fairly elaborate dialogue. And we did a kind of charting exercise. We used the small post-its, if you'll recall. There were about 300 of them up there, I know, because it took me from 3.30 to 6.30 to type them all up that night. And I asked you to provide input about your perception, this is perception, of the needs and wants of

2:59:10 We looked at partners briefly.

2:59:40 You contributed a lot of stuff on barriers. What are the barriers that would need to be resolved to move us from green to red on the scale of desired results? I would like you now to use these four pages as a reference document and individually by yourself. Here's your assignment. I have just a couple minutes to do this. I want you to think about which of these

3:00:09 These are listed in the way that they were presented by you. Which of these words and concepts represent deeply held beliefs or values in your community? Things you hear your neighbors talking about over barbecues. Things you hear during your, yes, 30 minute wait in the Bonds store line. I have that experience every time I come here.

3:00:38 One of you listed more grocery stores in here. I should have capitalized that. What do you hear people talking about? Maybe church, on the ski slopes, on the bike trail, on that trolley that we heard about earlier. In community meetings and in settings, as council members, when you're sitting on the dais and people are, and you're asking for a comment and you're hearing,

3:01:07 Many of the same comments over and over and over again are often about policies or tactics or funding or some initiative or some measure, but what's the underlying value that's being expressed? What do you take home that night and go, well, that's very annoying, but I get what's going on here. What is it that you get? What's the deeply held set of values or beliefs that you think are being expressed?

3:01:35 So I want you to go through it very quickly on your own. Just circle the elements of these four pages that you think point in the direction of a key community value. Which pages are? Pages five through eight. And we can use, I'm sorry. Go ahead. A full-time, part-time, and we're doing all of them. Use any. Okay.

3:01:57 We don't care what the perspective is. We're going to say full and part-time residents are one and the same thing and visitors are temporary residents. Okay. So we're just circling the words that you think signify a value. I've watched this activity. This is an individual contribution, so we're not really concerned with you sitting with your organization. So we have a team of three here. Three here. You three. You three.

3:07:41 Okay. Now, bottom up, we started with needs, strengths. We did a scan for one kind of thing, but you've gone through there and you're detecting where there are strong beliefs or values.

3:08:19 Now I want you in your team of three to do a quick review within your group of what you settled and why. And at the end of your discussion, let me give you the end point. At the end of your discussion, I want you to settle on six to eight, six minimum, eight maximum, strongly held community values if you're more comfortable with beliefs.

3:08:54 So that's six to eight for your entire team, not individually. And when you're done with that, I'm going to give you all the instructions all at once. I want you to write one value per card. I put these white cards on your table in front of you. One per card. So there will be six of these for each one of six different groups. And your specific instruction is,

3:09:25 One value per card, three to seven words, no more, two small words, and print big. You can read it from where John sees it. Everybody clear on the assignment? A? Six to eight. Everything? No. Six to eight total. Between the three of you. Everything you circle, not everything's equal. You all have to sign in your room. Six to eight. That's clear? Everybody clear?

3:13:49 What's the why behind the issue of the threat?

3:20:38 As you guys produce your cards, they should end up looking like this, large print, a few words, nice job.

3:21:03 So you guys sit? Okay. No? I have a whole method.

3:22:51 March print, March print, please.

3:24:48 Wow.

3:25:46 Thank you.

3:26:23 Okay, anybody need more time? All groups are done? How much time do you need? Ten minutes? No, no, no. You never get to lunch. That's where we start negotiating. Okay, how about one minute? How about two minutes? Two more minutes?

3:26:53 At 11.30 we're reconvened.

3:27:22 Thank you.

3:27:45 Clock's kicking. Settle on your values.

3:28:12 Thank you.

3:28:35 You need six. Anybody still need more time? Okay. John, you guys done? Hang on to him, hang on to him.

3:29:04 Okay, you're not going to post these. You're not going to post them. Now, within your groups, while they're finishing up, within your groups, think about values now. This is, what does the community care about that you should care about too, right? What do people care about in the town of Mammoth Lakes? We're sort of tapping into identity, sense of purpose, belief system, the stories we tell one another.

3:29:33 They get repeated over and over. I have friends that come back and forth between Talo and Mammoth, and they say, yeah, when I'm in Mammoth, we X, Y, Z, right? That's who they think they are when they're here, right? I hear the same thing in Talo all the time. So here's our framing question. What are the core community values, not organizational, community values that will inform this partnership?

3:30:00 What are the core community values that will inform this partnership? Within your group, I want you to lay out your six cards or eight cards if you have that many in front of you. And as a team, choose the two cards that you think represent unequivocally the clearest values. Clearest values.

3:30:31 Yeah, don't go with what you'd like to see. Go with the value. Value is a positive. Value is a positive. You have negatives, so we're going to have to turn them. We're going to have to flip them.

3:30:53 Thank you. Thank you.

3:31:22 Thank you.

3:31:52 Okay, clearest, your two clearest, when you're ready, hold them up and I'll come gather them. Two here, two here, two here, two here.

3:32:13 So, as I was telling this group here, it's what people want today, but they also want tomorrow. It's not an unmet need.

3:32:39 So I think I'm missing... Rewriting this fine. These two.

3:33:09 And you guys got it? All right, hang on to your others. I'll leave this in a second. So are you giving me three? Yes. No, you can only give me two. There's four of us. There's four of you? Yeah. Okay, I'm negotiating. You're good. We didn't get ten minutes. Okay. Now I'm going to need everybody's attention because I am standing between you and lunch.

3:33:39 Right? I'm standing between you and lunch, so I'm going to need your help to do this exercise. It's going to take us about 30 minutes to put this together. I'm going to post these. I'm going to read them one at a time. As I read them, if you don't understand the card that I'm reading, I'm going to ask the authors to clarify it. If you think there's a story behind the card and you want to hear the story,

3:34:08 Brief story. 30-second story. Then call it out and we'll do better. Open this and invite real town. What is his name? What is this? It's a real town. It's supposed to have been gravitated. Disneyland. Yeah, right. Cookie cutter. Can we build you off to contrast it? Yeah. As opposed to Jacksonville. Yeah, they did that. Great. We can contrast it to truth.

3:34:44 Expanded hospitality options and recreation experiences. Can afford to live and work here. Very important values. New experiences. New in quotes. Place. The place.

3:35:18 is defined by natural resources, community needs to deliver a quality guest experience, sustainable recreation, the big playground, community pride, outdoors, community, safety, wages, careers, etc. equal.

3:35:52 Cost of living, is that divided by change or is it... Scales. Scales, so wages and careers equal the cost of living. So family wage, living wage. Yes? Okay. Thank you for the first use of a graphic. Enfranchise the local community. Anybody want explanation or clarification? New experiences. New experiences. So who is the author? That's Oscar.

3:36:22 Okay, what did you do? It's keeping things fresh from all categories standpoint. So it's not just the same old, same old, but there's something new happening, whether it's events or activities or innovation. We had that. It can be innovative. The whole idea is you're doing something fresh and new. Keeping people coming. There's a demand and excitement around that, right? Demand. We want an ice skating rink, we want an event center, and then excitement when it comes into the community.

3:36:52 Any others requiring clarification, explanation, or a story? I have a question. So it's expanded hospitality options, I mean, is that a core community value? Yes, is expanded hospitality options and recreation experiences, is that a core community value? Good question. Is the author? We are. What did you think? Yes. I mean, I think it ties very well to delivering a quality guest experience.

3:37:23 So, hold that thought. Yes? One thing that we talked a lot about, and when doing this exercise the other day, it really struck me, we know so much about the full-time residents, and the list gets shorter as we move to the right, to the visitors, and then going through this with all the NGOs, if we're taking care of our people that live here, we want the same things that the visitors want, but the people feel like they're second-class citizens, the locals.

3:37:53 Like that the, you know, development is more important than the schools or things like that. But if we take care of the local residents, then the visitors will feel that in the customer service. It's a basic HR tenant too, right? The employees are happy, they're better employees. Yes. So this is a central tenant of this entire workshop experience. Thanks for calling it out. That in fact, if you design for the community, you collaborate for the community,

3:38:23 That you want to live in. Others will want to sample the lifestyle with you. But they come here not because you're cool, but because your amenities are cool and your assets and your natural environment is cool. But they will not find the natural environment enough to keep coming if you're not cool. It's a tiger chasing its own tail, right? Right. I'm wrapping, I was using cool to assume.

3:39:05 That you're economically viable, the streets are well maintained, it's a safe environment, it has all of this powerful stuff that you can execute. There's a lot of stuff there. Absolutely. What was the last point? Enfranchise the local community. Enfranchise the local community. That's kind of what I was just trying to say. If we take care of our locals, then they're going to, it'll all bleed over to the visitors. It'll be better.

3:39:35 Experiences, because the locals are loving that, creating them, like Joel, with the trails, that kind of thing. That's what we do by that. The locals feel better taken care of. Dan, does that make sense to you? Yeah. So in a sense, Dan, you and your small army don't have to take care of everything if you can foster a community collectively in which everyone is a steward of the place.

3:40:05 I was just going to say, because the most powerful thing we have is with our ambassadors. And if we don't have ambassadors, then everything we do is going to be jacked, to tell you the truth. And if we don't have a buy-in from the people here, because that's where, at least from my experience, you get so many people that ask you questions on the list and very simply don't digress too much, but that's where the more that we, everybody in the town, and not just we, but everybody in the town is feeling on board.

3:40:32 And a new restaurant opens up, yeah, I went there, it was great, you know, blah, blah, blah. When that happens, that's when we become good. And that's what excited for me exactly is the buy-in. Because the community buy-in is great as the Festa. And that's what we talked about the other day. Because if the community believes in it, they'll succeed because they'll make it happen. Yeah, so you have a model that shows a name of your job. Yeah, I get to talk to a lot of people in there. And for the most part,

3:41:05 Their experience after their guest experience is actually really, really good. They're in a lot of places. So we've got to have ourselves on the back. We really have a great community back. So I don't want to decide that. My biggest problem is keeping people employed full time. And when we can't keep people employed full time, you know, it's very difficult for them to live here.

3:41:35 They'll become transient and they'll leave. The economics are what they are and they're challenging and difficult. I think what we're getting at here is the part that's directly under your sphere of influence and under your control. But you do need an economic strategy. And I think, to your point, it is under our capabilities to increase visitation.

3:42:07 I think we're about that because it's our visitors that come and enjoy the Eastern Sierra and our community that makes our engine run so that people can live here. So I don't want to lose that side of that. I mean, I agree everybody should be happy, but I think most people are happier if they have the money to put it. I would be a lot happier if I could employ people full of money.

3:42:37 So yes, we're not just focused on happiness, we're focusing here on the conditions that

3:43:05 Produce the highest level of satisfaction. It is along that Maslow's hierarchy. John? I just wanted to point out that especially now more than ever, we talk about local ambassadors and things, you know, with the whole digital experience, you know, it's very powerful now more than ever if your citizens are, you know, sharing their...

3:43:32 Yes, this is what I was sharing with John in the MLT group one day ago. You can design a brand strategy and you can attempt to brand your community.

3:44:01 But your brand is actually the sum of your Yelp posts and the Facebook posts and so on. And the sum of those posts becomes your brand. Now you can either love it and live it or you can try to correct it. But you end up with a brand somewhere near where you want. So let's brand this value piece a little bit. What's useful when we start

3:44:27 We started with individuals, and then I had to work in teams of three. We started with a scan that we did last week, and we extracted from behind that the values that you think are most compelling, and I ask you to give me two most clear. Which of these go together? There's probably some pairs up here. They have similar ideas, same words, same notion. Where do you see pairs, just pairs? Safety.

3:44:56 Safety and safe community. So those come together. Who else goes together? Place. Place. The natural resources. Place. Place and the place. The natural resources. Where was it? Oh, it's right. Right there. It's hardest to see. The community's pride could be an umbrella. I think it goes for Realtown and Great Outdoors. Try not to do that yet. I think Realtown and Great Outdoors is going to replace. Realtown.

3:45:25 And Great Outdoors, everybody ready to do that? No, I think Real Town goes with Enfranchise. Yeah, I do too. Enfranchise. Enfranchise goes with Real Town. Is that what was intended by these two groups? Great Outdoors. Great Outdoors goes under place. Great Outdoors goes under place. Great Outdoors. Great Outdoors. John, you okay with that?

3:45:54 So let me slow you down. Do all of these go together when we read them? Community pride. Community needs to deliver quality guest experience, expanded hospitality options.

3:46:28 The recreation experience, is there a thread? No, I think the beauty of pride goes under real town. That's what I think, too. Pride goes under real town. So please, who's the author of the group? Is your intention more like their intention? I just look at community pride as the umbrella. We do a lot of things that support community pride. The great outdoors, the natural environment, hospitality, sustainable recreation. We take great pride. I live in a place called Mammoth.

3:46:57 I can easily say, we can call that the sum of the values, but so that we don't lose it, let's embed it, let's see if it pops out later. I think openness and inviting goes under quality guest experience. Put that at the top. Put community at the top. And so that's...

3:47:26 New experience. The same concept? The authors of these two cars? Is that what you intended? Yeah. Yeah? Okay. Does this belong here? Expanded hospitality options, direct experiences. So is that? All those go under. No, they're out there. All four under there. We may not want to do that. One's a feeling and one's like amenities and options.

3:47:51 Yeah.

3:47:52 Yeah.

3:47:52 Yeah.

3:47:52 Yeah.

3:47:53 Yeah.

3:47:54 Yeah.

3:47:55 One, one's, one's tactical and the right.

3:47:56 Right, right.

3:47:57 Yeah.

3:47:58 Yeah.

3:47:59 Yeah.

3:48:00 Yeah.

3:48:01 Yeah, that was, yeah.

3:48:03 Yeah.

3:48:04 Yeah.

3:48:06 Yeah.

3:48:07 Yeah.

3:48:08 Yeah.

3:48:09 I think sustainable recreation could tuck under place, put outdoors, that.

3:48:12 Yeah.

3:48:13 Yeah.

3:48:14 Yeah.

3:48:15 Yeah.

3:48:16 Yeah.

3:48:17 Yeah.

3:48:17 Love Plagues, Plagues, Fire My Natural Resources, Great Outdoors, Sustainable Brick. These are pretty good. I usually end up with orphans of some kind. Now I want you to look at your cards. You should have at least four left. I want you to identify in your team two cards that do not already have a column up here. Two different ideas about values.

3:48:18 Yeah.

3:48:19 Yeah.

3:48:20 Yeah.

3:48:47 If they're not different, just hang on to them. If you have something different, we want to expand our scope.

3:49:13 You guys here at these are already up? Yeah? Okay.

3:49:17 Anybody else? I think it's kind of fixed with this. Really? How does it fit? I don't see that anywhere. Let's throw it up there. I like to turn it into homework. I want the brief to close it. Okay, ready?

3:49:46 I'm still standing between you and lunch and we have one more step we're going to do before lunch and then we'll do the final piece after we get your food. Alright, so I'm going to add these down below if you can still see how I'm trying to get out of your way. Compact size. A year-round economy equals economic security.

3:50:18 Cultural integration. Any explanations for any of these yet? I think the cultural integration, we'll take credit for that one. If you look in this room right now, half of our community is Hispanic. Yes. We've got a single representative in this room. Thank you. Thank you for calling it out. I don't ever want to be the first one to say that out loud. Okay. So I want to come back to this this afternoon when we do the buy-in exercise very, very specifically.

3:50:47 Because otherwise we're going to have a buy-in where we're talking to half of our community. And this is actually an enormous problem in South Tahoe for which I need to do two workshops this week. We're not that remote. Air service digital 395. We need active partners to survive. Collaborative partnerships and volunteerism. Education. Diverse talent.

3:51:19 Any requests for clarification of any of these? Do you all know what they mean? They all mean the same thing to all of you? What's compact size? Yeah, good question. What is compact size? We've struggled a little bit with it. I mean, it's sort of a characteristic, but I think it's also holds some values, too, that there's sort of like keys into this, like self-sufficiency and this density, this tight-knit community. It fits under place.

3:51:50 It elaborates all the way. Is that where you want to put it? Does that explanation make sense? So you're a non-sprawl environment, but it's not just a physical design attribute. She's actually attaching, this group is attaching other meaning to them. You can be, it's a more intimate community. It's part of what makes us unique. Okay. Cool.

3:52:19 So compact size, do you think that went here? Yeah. Okay. Where might the rest of these, are there any new pairs that aren't already up here? The talent and that cultural element, I'm not sure it fits into the current stuff. Talent and cultural integration? I mean, for a small place, there's a lot of different things out there going on, bringing quality to the community. I think both those go into real talent.

3:52:50 I don't think Realtown always has that. Yeah, I think that's true. I think it's better. Do they go together or are they different things? So we've got private partnerships and volunteerism and we need active partners to survive. I think cultural integration has to go under Realtown because you can't have a Realtown and community pride without cultural integration.

3:53:32 I see that as being quite beyond. So what is cultural integration then? Who's the author of the fight? What did you guys, I want you guys to resolve the debate. I would say anything else? Frustration over lack of culture. And missed opportunity. Missed opportunity. So is it about diverse talent? Or is it about place? Or is it about something else? I think it's real talent. You know it takes pride in it. It was not diverse talent.

3:54:08 It's not there as hell.

3:54:10 So I want the authors of the card to state their intention and help guide us.

3:54:18 Yeah, it feels like it might be doing that.

3:54:20 I understand your point about it being under Realtown.

3:54:24 I think it's enfranchised for the local community.

3:54:28 I think it's just because of how I feel.

3:54:30 Yeah, enfranchised for the local community.

3:54:33 So it goes with Realtown.

3:54:35 It goes with Realtown and they enfranchise the local community.

3:54:39 So, more like that. Dan, are you okay with that? Yeah, I was reading cultural information, and it's not so much from social economic or race. I was looking at this culture that we have in our community. How do we take our music and arts and visual, and all those elements, bring that together as a line. It's talent we have. Very well-educated, talented people in town that bring something to us.

3:55:10 In the spirit of being inclusive here, unless somebody else has already articulated that on a different card, if you want to add a card, I'm inviting you to submit one. So where would you all put the first card?

3:55:34 Community, I'm in real town. Yeah. Yeah, it's an asset. It's an asset for us. Yeah. Diversity, a talent. Any disagreement on this? Sure. No. We need absence consensus on this. And you're doing a great job of exhibiting willingness to adjust, by the way. I would suggest we're not that remote under place with the compact size.

3:55:58 Right, because our intention was, you know, everybody comes here because they think they're renewable, but we're really not. Right. Right, but you were right. You were somewhere, right? Yeah. Okay. All right, we've got innovation is key to our future. A year-round economy equals economic security and education. A year-round goes under, can you afford clear care? So, a year-round under... Right, thank you.

3:56:27 Who's clearly a student? Education. So who offered innovation's key to our future? I just think it's its own category personally. I think it's an ideal that needs to permeate all the things that we're doing. This idea that accepting the status quo is no longer acceptable.

3:56:55 In the tourism business, if you're not changing your guide. Doesn't that go under new experience? I think the visitor needs drive innovation to a certain extent. But that's really focused on the guest experiences. If you look through that list, there's 21st century municipal government. There's the reason we're all in this room today. We've established all these NGOs. And I think it's a much broader ideal than just the guest experience.

3:57:24 So in the spirit of saying yes and, not yes but, because we concluded the prior exercise making exactly this case, but because in my experience most overarching ideas like community pride and innovation is key are better understood when they're associated with other ideas than when we try to sit them on top.

3:57:52 I like the idea that innovation is tied to the local community, which is like they can afford to live and work here.

3:58:24 Under Real Town? No. No. No. There you go. I mean, I think it could, for me, it could fall under place, potentially. I agree. It's a defining of the place. I was thinking of that, when the word innovation, she was talking about the size of the community, I think of these little unscrawled communities as laboratories.

3:58:53 So if I go downstairs to Bonds right now and I say,

3:59:23 Describe Mammoth Lakes as a place. I believe that visitors and locals alike will say things like natural resources, great outdoors, you know, a small town, everything under place, I think would be repeated back to me, reflected back to me. I don't think move somewhere else. And so my concern... On that size and recreation, you said, what do you think it will take for a stay that way? You've changed the question.

4:00:45 Now you can start to invite the response. So if we compromise between these perspectives and we frame innovation in the context of a need, a value that will drive the place forward in terms of this vitality, we get satisfied with diverse interests in the world. I don't need to talk you into this stuff. I still think innovation stands by itself because remember we were talking about GESTA.

4:01:11 On Thursday, and their ability to come up with different ways of approaching things and all of that stands by itself, regardless of what the outcome is. Okay. So, for now, it's like a... John? No, I'm just going to say, just based on the definition of innovation, evolve, I think that that first problem works. I mean, new experiences, we're innovating to create new experiences, whether it's the mountain putting in the zip line or adding trails here or there, or we're expanding on hospitality options.

4:01:47 You know, I think that's the header for that problem. I think innovation is driving, innovation is driving the changes for the community and new experiences are changes and expanding on the boundary options. Well, if you didn't, if you did the innovation as the header of those communities, that starts to kind of exist. Well, we're not limiting innovation to just that. Yeah, it's not what we intended for the card. Like, it's not that. You know, we've done some innovative approaches to public safety.

4:02:14 So we've got two more cards. I'm going to leave it there for now because what we're doing is we're bouncing ideas around until they settle where they belong. We have, Dan has contributed arts and culture diversity. Is that, tell me where that goes.

4:02:42 Is that what you would have in mind for that? Arts and culture, diversity, diverse talent, community pride, cultural integration, enfranchised social community. I'd say it comes to their sense of place. It helps define who we are in place. It offsets sustainable recreation of big playgrounds. It's nothing to mention. You guys are comfortable with that?

4:03:17 Culture comes out of, like, culture comes out of April 10th. That's right. It's directly related to that. It's got nothing. They're parallel, but they don't, I don't see a fitting. Okay, so I'm going to give you a way to think differently about this. I'm going to park it there for the time being. And let me ask you about education. What kind of is this? Okay. What was your intention there? And does it have a home?

4:03:45 Yes, if you're K-12 system, as you well know,

4:04:10 Isn't delivering at a very high value proposition, you are not going to get the succession millennial leadership community that you need to thrive well into the future. But this is a problem all over the country right now. Okay, so we've given every concept to home. Do any of these, we've got one, two, three, four, seven separate little clusters, do any of these naturally go together?

4:04:41 The idea of safe and being part of it, the town, the place, the idea of feeling safe, in my mind, it's a safe community, people, you know, they're out and about, I'm not sure it stands alone. You guys be okay with that? I like it. All right, we went from seven to six. Keep going. Any other logical affinities here? I feel like yes, experience is tied with hospitality and new experiences.

4:05:11 The two right columns, or the two left columns, I mean. The two left columns, so. I think that the quality of this experience goes together with new experiences and expand the hospitality in my home. Other way. Other way. Other way. So if you're these. Move that one. Move that one. Move that one. Yeah, move that one.

4:05:40 While I'm rearranging, tell me if you see any more. I think volunteerism goes under Realtown also. Collaborative partnerships and volunteerism? That's Realtown. Realtown. I see them as staying by themselves. Do you go anywhere else?

4:06:14 I think that the volunteer, the volunteer, like, I think we wrote passion for the community, like, the fact that people here are so active has a lot to do with community pride and being a part of this, like, arts and culture, diverse community. I think the volunteer stuff and collaborative partnerships. Well, and maybe then what has to happen is you split volunteers out onto a separate car. Yeah, so we could do that? Yeah. Do you want to offer that?

4:06:43 Because I agree with you, this community doesn't exist without volunteers, but I think partnerships and partners are still set separately, so I can live with being volunteer-ism on a separate card. Okay. We'll get under Real Town. Give me a new card with volunteerism on it. You should have an overlying cover of people. Yeah.

4:07:08 This is obviously semantics, but I think on the far left column, that should be, the bottom should be the top. Because expanding hospitality and providing good experiences are components of providing a good guest experience, not vice versa. Everybody good with that? By the way, we're not necessarily referring a hierarchy of value.

4:07:37 By the way, I've placed them here. This happens to be the way we're developing it. So do these stand alone? You have five? All right. I'm going to, I've stuck these little symbols on here just so that you can look at your remaining cards. This is the last step we're going to do. Look at your remaining cards and if you have cards that fit naturally within these clusters.

4:08:07 Put the symbol that I've associated with them on the card in the lower right-hand corner or lower left, whatever works for you, and bring them up here and post them, and I'll help you. So once you get a mark, bring them up. I'll let you do the work.

4:09:12 Thank you.

4:09:22 Thank you.

4:09:52 Okay, here's what I'm going to propose. There's actually two more steps, and these are extremely important. Let me tell you what they are, because then I'm going to let you get your food. We're going to do what we did last Thursday if you weren't here. We've got the food. Do you guys want to take a long lunch break, or do you want to shorten it and work? Get your food. Shorten the lunch and shorten the workshop. I'd like to shorten it if it works. We can take a few minutes.

4:10:20 Yeah. So let me tell you what we're going to do. We'll stop at like 12.15. You'll get your food at 12.30. Try to eat enough that I can get you into the next step. You're mostly going to be thinking and commenting, so you won't need to write anything. And what we're going to do is we're going to decide what the thread is in each one of these clusters. The theme.

4:10:50 Or central idea that holds all these other ideas together. We're going to name the cluster according to that theme. Those five names are going to become your five core community values. And then we're going to go into one more exercise and I'm going to put you back in your work teams again and then we'll be ready to do the theme.

4:11:18 The buy-in communication piece after. So I'm going to do a little bit of rearranging while you get your food. Because Shields had brought one up here that said everyone is connected to the community, I happen to have produced these ahead of time. I was talking to a colleague that was doing a workshop like this, and he said that in all places he had worked, the success of a community

4:11:47 Can be defined by the success of its, quote, third places. And I asked him to explain that to me and he said, well, third places, if you're home and work are the first two places. The third places are the bakery, they're bonds, they're the market, they're the pharmacy, they're the pubs and the restaurants, they're the ski slopes where people connect with one another. So how do you develop those third places?

4:12:16 And how you infuse your values into those third places becomes the center of gravity for the health of the community and its future vitality. So I want to sort of leave that provocative idea with you, send you to lunch, have you come back with a little bit of nourishment. Thank you for participating so well. And then at 12.30 we'll get going again. All right?

4:14:17 Watch the matter.

4:16:42 Thank you.

4:19:12 So, let's . . . .

4:22:05 We'll see. We'll see. We'll see. We'll see. We'll see. We'll see. We'll see. Yeah, I'll share some information. Okay, do we have anywhere near a forum? No. Four, five, six, eight. Yeah, yeah.

4:22:34 I'm ready to go. Here they go. We are ready. The mayor is in his chair.

4:23:00 We're going to do a two-step process. The very first one, we're going to take these in the order of the density of cards that were placed because those reflect

4:23:26 So we're going to start here in the center. And by the way, the first words I'm reading are not intended to be the title.

4:23:58 Real Town, that's where we started. Enfranchise the local community. Cultural integration. Community pride. Diverse talent. Arts and culture diversity. Education. Openness and inviting. Safe community. Safety. Sense of community. Everyone's connected to the community. Small town environment.

4:24:28 Passion for the community. Volunteers. A lot of concepts. Community. Yeah. Connected community. Vibrant community. Just community. Vibrant community. Community pride. Community pride. At what point do we take a term that's so encompassing that it... The next step. Okay, great. That's at what point? Right away. Well, Tom was the one that said it, but...

4:25:06 People. Yeah. Inclusive community. Vibrant community. Inclusive. Can we pair some of these ideas together? I'd like a title or a name for this that's three to five words. Vibrant. Vibrant inclusive community. Vibrant inclusive community. I like that. That's safe. That's safe. Safe, vibrant. Safe, vibrant inclusive community. Yeah, that's pretty good.

4:25:43 You guys want to place hold that? Safe, vibrant, inclusive. How many communities in the United States do you think, running through a similar exercise, can come up with a value frame that sounds just like that? So it means you are in the norm, and the question is what you will do with this, and that's where you can separate. Let's park that there for a moment. That's our triangle.

4:26:25 So let's go to this one, place, I think these follow, place, the place is defined by natural resources, compact size, not that remote, air service digital 395, great outdoors, sustainable recreation, the big playground, high value on natural resources, natural environment, great people, places, experiences.

4:26:55 Sustainable Recreation, Ease of Access to All Natural Resources. We have some replication. Environment. Environment. So this is about the environment. What else? Okay, so what's that? You can't send the environment to that place of enjoyment. I mean, it's not just ethereal environment out there, but it's actually a place we enjoy because of that environment. A place of enjoyment. What do you think? Suggestions?

4:27:42 What's the theme? Is a place of enjoyment the theme that holds this or the central organizing idea? I think it's a little deeper. Natural, active place. Natural, active place. Natural, active place. Natural, active place. It's also about the building. Sustainable. No. Accessible.

4:28:10 So let me argue with that a little bit. So maybe in the general sense, the place infers the built environment, but you all did not put reference to the built environment. You're right. I don't find it unless you're going to extrapolate out of complex size. I think it's natural. It's not there. Yeah, you're right. So what was our suggestion? A natural...

4:28:45 Okay. Smaller columns. Now this one is can afford, pay close attention on this one. Can afford to live and work here. Wages, careers, etc. equal the cost of living. Those are in balance.

4:29:18 A year-round economy equals economic security, cost-effective living, affordable housing, jobs, livable community, career opportunities, economic stability. Sustainability has three more securities.

4:29:47 There's something about access as a concept in this as well because sometimes when we talk about economic stability we're talking about the business community and how to grow the business community but when we're talking about jobs and being able to afford to live here there's something about

4:30:14 Yeah, so you've got two cards here that are about the broader economy and all the rest are, as you've just suggested, they're about its livability, affordability, cost-effective affordability, livable, sustainable economy. Yeah. That's so fuzzy. Yeah, give me, give me an, let's...

4:30:43 This is a core value of what we want. This is a core value for what the community wants. It's not a core value that we currently have. Correct. It's a core value for what the community values that you want to be available to.

4:31:14 Economic quality life. So say that in a way that your neighbors would see themselves in it. Yeah, you can live here. If somebody was going to ask me, I would love to come to Mammoth, can I live there? I would love to be able to say, yes, you can live here. You can live there. You can live there.

4:31:45 Can we do that? Let me put it up and see what it looks like. This means one of my personal requirements, it has small words and it has no buzzwords in it, which is...

4:32:11 Always helpful you don't want a bunch of core values that sound like a consultant to you because when we get to the buy-in exercise the community will not subscribe. It's going to be like we can all live here instead of you can, I don't know, there's something like really aggressive about that. Inclusive. Well, your visitor or your person, your

4:32:40 25-year-old who's thinking, I'd like to leave LA and come be a future leader of Mammoth. If you said, well, we can live here, might not be as invited. Is there a way to make that inclusive? Let's all live. Let's all live. Let's all live. Pull my out. Join in. It's a place you can live.

4:33:06 It's going to be hard to find the authenticity of that one. Let me come back to it because I'm going to offer you a way to think about this in just a moment that maybe we'll tie that on together. I mean, I could just say it's livable. There's something I hear a lot here and it's like, oh, you know, you're surviving in Mammoth. Right, right. That's the bars. That's what we're struggling with. Yeah.

4:33:36 Let's link these as placeholders because I want to let you guys do one more sentence. You may want to improve on the title.

4:34:06 And by the way, the Strategic Growth Council in California issued funding under rounds one, two, and three over the last four years and caused 72 communities in California to develop sustainable communities programs. So now every community in the state of California has a liberality framework, a sustainability framework, an economic security framework, and they all mean nothing.

4:34:33 This second to last one, community needs to deliver a quality guest experience.

4:35:02 Expanded hospitality options and recreation experiences, new experiences, enhance our amenities and infrastructure, good customer service consistency. What's the central idea? Resort. Resort. Overall experience. You will enjoy being here.

4:35:21 We do have, you've got an idea that's percolating through here that everybody's using, everybody that does customer service work is talking about customer experience. Like I have two big clients, I just spent a whole year converting their customer service program to a

4:35:52 So, it's guest focused and hospitality focused.

4:36:27 It's innovation focused, keeping it fresh, I think you guys said. It's amenity rich from an infrastructure standpoint. And it's got this customer funliness piece. So this is all a prescription for what value? A memorable guest experience. A memorable guest experience. Desirable.

4:36:53 I have a great opportunity to guess that. It was just a memorable experience. Hopefully a positive one. Don't let me write too soon. Does that work for you? Well, in some way it should be positively acceptable. No, let me take that back because the CPUC was here.

4:37:21 I've talked about the phone service, and the digital 395, and the woman who's on the public utilities commission, was here as a kid, involved in an avalanche, up at Canyon Lodge, I'm not sure exactly what happened, but that's a touchstone experience for her. And she came back to that over and over and over again as a need for why the state invested $20 million in digital 395, which means public safety.

4:37:44 So it may not be, yeah, she survived, she lived, but it made an indelible surprise. So we're going to just park this, and the last one should be easy, but I find the short ones are hard. We need active partners to survive collaborative partnerships and volunteerism.

4:38:14 What is this value? We're in it together. Partner. We work together. We're in it together. Think about. Say it again. Collaboration. Collaboration. So partnership and collaboration awards I'm using and we're going to use in every one of four workshops. Does the community resonate to those words? Partnership and collaboration. Support.

4:38:42 Working together. Working together. We're in it together. All in. All in. Yeah. We are all in. Teamwork. Teamwork. Still collaboration. Just I want to steer you away from those words if I can. It takes all of us. It's a village. It takes all of us. It's a village. A lot of these seem to be time acts are inclusive though. We already have them stay inclusive. So if we want to draw a distinction. We work together.

4:39:14 I'll tell you what, I'm going to...

4:39:59 I like that. I'm going to place hold it and let this next piece of the process, let your individual groups sort this out. Let me read it back to you. You would like a safe, vibrant, inclusive community, which is a natural, active place. You want it possible for everyone to live here, that wants to live here. You want to offer a memorable experience.

4:40:34 And to accomplish all of that, you recognize the only way. So that's kind of how you think about taking these value statements and bringing a little life into them. They don't just mean something vertically. They have to mean something this way as well. They have to go together. They have to be five facets on one diamond. What's the overarching core value? The overarching core value will become

4:41:07 A community vision that enables all of these values to be true in the long term. We're not going to do that until the third workshop. We're going to factor in this piece about innovation is key. I'm going to call that a driver. We'll find a place for that later. So here's what I would like. I want five groups, not by organization. This is the final step in this process.

4:41:40 So five groups of four, four groups of four, one of five. I'm going to assign each group one of these clusters. And I'm going to ask your group to look at the title, the name we've given to the cluster, and the component cards,

4:42:10 And you're going to write a one to two sentence description of how we would implement that value. How would we convert that value to an actual guiding principle that you would then use as organizations. So for example, we might say, our value is a safe, vibrant, inclusive community. What principle could we author one or two sentences?

4:42:40 That we would always use as a decision criteria in every policy decision, funding decision, priority decision, strategic planning decision, zoning decision. How would we convert that into an active principle? Okay? This will start out being hard and it will get easier as you spend a few minutes on it. So I'd like, now this time I'm going to let you self-select.

4:43:11 How are you? Good.

4:43:42 I might jump in with you guys.

4:44:03 Who's there? Someone has a seat?

4:44:17 Alright, perfect.

4:44:47 All right, now you're going to volunteer. Which group would like, and I absolutely do not care, the safe, inclusive community? Can I have a question before I do this? Do I need to pull the cards off and hand them to you, or can you read them well enough?

4:45:06 We can read them.

4:45:08 We can read them.

4:45:09 I'd like to leave them up for the next exercise.

4:45:11 Otherwise, I have to reconstruct everything.

4:45:14 No, that's fine.

4:45:14 You don't want to watch them do that.

4:45:15 If you can't read, we'll walk them through.

4:45:16 Okay.

4:45:17 They're pretty big.

4:45:19 So who's going to do safe, vibrant, inclusive community?

4:45:22 They're going to read them.

4:45:23 I think we need to go with that.

4:45:26 Why don't you guys just remember to volunteer?

4:45:28 We're volunteering with more memorable experience.

4:45:30 All right, you got memorable experience?

4:45:32 Should we take you, maybe?

4:45:33 We'd like to have people here.

4:45:35 I was in the place.

4:45:39 You can go with this.

4:45:40 You guys got this?

4:45:42 You can live here.

4:45:44 Who's got the number one?

4:45:45 No, we want you can live here.

4:45:47 You can live here.

4:45:48 That means you guys can take the seat on my wrist.

4:45:52 Here's what I want you to do. I want you to discuss the cards under the title. I want you to think about the extent to which these cards make the title even more clear. I want you to feel empowered by that title. Now I want you to put on your hat.

4:46:22 As an NGO executive director, a board member, a council member, I want you to think about your formal role and say, how would we use that value as a guiding principle when we make decisions? This is really about decision making. Decision making isn't choosing winners and losers. It's about doing this, not that. It comes down to that. It's that simple.

4:46:52 How do we know that we've applied safe, vibrant, inclusive community to two choices so that we made the right choice? Because if we're not using this stuff that way, they're just words that they don't have. So if you can do it in one sentence, I would love you for it. If you can do it in two sentences, we'll still be friends. If you can do it in three, okay, you can stay on the list.

4:47:19 So I would like you to start each guiding principle with the following two words. We will, in this case it's not a we must, it's a we will, because it's a commitment. It's a two to one ratio, John. So start with we will.

4:47:49 Okay? And then I'll come around and help each group. So I'm going to give you a yellow card here. You can start. When I think you're far enough along, I'll call time.

4:48:02 So here's what smacks around in my head about the increasing best. I was talking at lunch about the culture at MLT, right? And MLT's pretty innovative. I mean, John, it falls upon us to be innovative. But we're innovative in this context of a lot of like... Guiding decision principles.

4:48:24 I feel like you need two things. You need to be brave and help.

4:48:53 How you include everybody, even people who don't agree with you. And then you have to protect each other. But maybe I'm up here and we need to just be down here. We will be...

4:49:12 Fearless. In. Right. But whatever.

4:49:41 Yeah, I agree, but I feel like the inclusiveness, to your point, you know, if you start inviting people and groups in the interest of inclusivity, like, you really have to be brave and open-hearted about what they're going to tell you. So if you're going to include the Hispanic community and they're like, we think you guys suck, you have to be...

4:50:03 You have to create space for that. Right, but then when you provide the environment, it sets up that power differential whereby you are the power holder and then you're just being gracious by inviting them to see an idea.

4:50:32 That's cool. All I know is that when the chips are down to Rusty's point in the paper, we like to circle the wagon and fire at each other. And then if we're going to create a safe, vibrant, inclusive community, we need to figure out how to...

4:50:56 It's really interesting to me because I

4:51:25 Okay.

4:52:53 So what I hear you saying is like MLT is a little bit of an outlier from the rest of the community and community organizations?

4:53:22 More of a way.

4:53:51 If you take MLT out of the equation and you just start with a normal community organization.

4:54:20 Right, right, right, right.

4:54:49 So how would we then, given that, with the, um, yeah, well, I mean, given that other experience,

4:55:19 I have a family experience, and Michael's right, I don't have a family, so I just go home and, you know, I just need to kick my dog. Bitterness. So if, like, what is his name? Michael? Yeah. Like Michael said, if we're making decisions as NGOs, whether it's MLT or not,

4:55:48 And we want to make sure that the decisions that we make provide a safe, vibrant, inclusive community. What will we do to ensure that? Yes.

4:56:17 So we have to say, we will do such and such that will provide a safe vibrant.

4:56:46 Advocate for what?

4:57:16 We will actively and courageously let the verb out. We will actively and

4:57:45 So if we're actively advocating, does that also mean that we're taking a stand and being courageous so we will actively advocate for a safe environment for all community members?

4:58:14 Yeah, because he also protects his staff and his board is, yeah, and the board is, you know, yeah.

4:58:43 So the only thing we're missing is the vibrancy part with the arts and culture, the education, diversity of talents, all communities.

4:59:12 I don't know. I'm bad at this because I just do like consulting speak all the time.

4:59:42 Thank you. Thank you.

4:59:44 Right, right, right.

5:00:14 I guess I'm trying to figure out, though, in terms of the vibrancy, like how to fit the arts and culture and the recreational activities and the, you know, all the things that we do. Like, when you talked about being a dad and the other things you're involved in, those are centered around sports and AYSO and events, because your wife and with David Page's theater.

5:00:43 I encourage you to decide if you can use more declarative verbs than things like advocate. Can you guarantee? Can you commit?

5:01:12 You know? I mean, the promise that you don't make is the promise you can never make. So, it's when you say, because you don't want it to sound like we will try. Right? We're going to try super hard. We're going to try really hard every day. But we will commit. We're all in. I think this is the all in.

5:01:41 I got it. Hold on.

5:02:02 We promise all community members and visitors a safe fun. All these words are perfect. We promise. I think it promises to drive.

5:02:32 Well, I think Promise gets, I think Promise is stronger than actively doing whatever.

5:02:53 Thank you.

5:03:08 Safe from gang bangers and murderers. A relatively safe environment unless you're a complete idiot. In which case you deserve it.

5:03:38 We got the hard one.

5:04:07 Thank you.

5:04:22 A safe community base of outdoor presentations. Unforgettable experiences. No, now we're like getting out of the other town. I totally like.

5:04:51 I like the idea of also a safe community that respects different points of view.

5:05:20 Did I miss you? Sorry. I just did that to everybody, though. So a couple things just to loosen this up for you. So sometimes it's our tendency to think about an action like we will provide. You can simply say our principle is that we will ensure. What we're committed to...

5:05:50 I feel like you're backing away from the staking and claim principle, the promise, what's your promise, now we're kind of backing away from that.

5:06:19 I wanted to, don't use my, I wanted to feel like you're doing it in your meeting. Yeah, taking a stand. Puzzle with it a couple more minutes, you're sort of, I trust you.

5:06:48 I think we will ensure. Both residents and visitors, a safe community.

5:07:17 Inviting. I think in our second sentence.

5:07:46 I don't think my job is very lasting. And I stood there listening, and they did this back and forth, and I thought, you suspect. And this is impossible. I'm never going to pretend. I'm trying this thing, I'm going to pretend. It's like, in Tahoe we call couch stuff. So, so that's, so you said it's perfect.

5:08:16 We will ensure our community is safe, inviting, and what else? I have a placeholder sentence that we will include all communities.

5:08:45 Community groups and stakeholders in the sphere of mutual respect and collaboration. Even when they disagree and we hate them. Okay.

5:09:14 Safe inviting. What else is up there?

5:09:43 What about passion? Will we infuse this with that passion? I would be thinking about that 50% of your community is not responding to your outreach or engagement. I would say, does our principal bring them in and invite them in as well as the rest of us?

5:10:12 So we will ensure our community is safe, inviting, and respectful.

5:10:42 No, I'm dumb thinking. You know I have RBF.

5:11:11 I just went down ACDC, ACDC, ACDC. We will ensure our community is safe, inviting, and inclusive.

5:11:35 Feels thin. I'm also wondering like in terms of

5:12:04 The inclusiveness, like, whether inclusive words, like, we will invite people to the table, you know, like, we'll invite, yeah, we will invite community groups, we will invite participation, I don't know, I'm trying to think of some better words, inviting, we will celebrate, celebrate.

5:12:33 It feels thin to us. We will ensure our community's safe and fighting.

5:13:03 So now what we're doing is we're thinking about like what actions can we take? What does this look like, right? So when we're meeting and we're making decisions, we invite all groups at the way. When we have educational wins in the community or theater, we celebrate that. So how do we like wrap this up into a tight little new sentence that is both meaningful and concise?

5:13:32 Yeah, so those are great ways to think about this. The acid test of whether your principle works or not is that you can fight in real life, you know, when to celebrate and so on. Maybe, what I've been saying to the other groups is this is all about your intention. You know, what's in your mind when you're making decisions about allocating resources, about scaling service?

5:13:55 You know, about changing the plan on Friday, because suddenly the environment's different. How do you keep applying those principles? We want to make sure everyone's ready. We want to make sure everyone's ready.

5:14:25 I guess my question about vibrancy is how do we know vibrancy when we see it and then what do we want to do in the face of it? So I'm going to take the pressure off you for now because I know you can get a lot stuck in here. I think let's frame your intention here. We're going to invite feedback from the group on this and we'll park it as a placeholder for this program.

5:14:54 I have RBF, don't worry about it. Yeah? So should I take it as it is?

5:15:23 You want to rewrite it? Maybe. This one here, right? I think all this stuff. Okay. Alright. Reconvene. 1.30. We're the hardest one. Put you in your last exercise and get you out of your way so you would.

5:15:52 I thought I'd play a little game with this. Instead of having you report it out, I thought I would read them out, and other than the people who authored it, you can tell me which one of these values this is the principle for. If it's 1.30, I've got to wake you up a little bit. We will strike the balance between people, buildings, and our beautiful natural environment. A natural active place. A natural active place.

5:16:21 Can you read that? We will strike the balance. What do you think about that? Can you read it again? We will strike the balance between people, buildings, and our beautiful natural environment. What does that say to you? I don't like buildings in there. You don't like buildings? Well, I know that. But you have to make those decisions, too. We originally said built environment in a sense of trying to keep it more in layman's terms or similar.

5:16:50 Vernacular and political. The value is a natural active place. Does the principle support the value? If so say so, if not, what adjustments? We will strike the balance between people. I like that the balance is in there because it matters how you build a building if it's going to fit in a place like this.

5:17:24 What if we just said like people and the man made and natural? Women make stuff too now. Just put women made.

5:17:50 Creative? Well, you know, as we said, built environment, but less bustling. If you say infrastructure, yeah, less bustling. That only means something in this room, but buildings. Build. Buildings. Build

5:18:19 Manscaped. Manscaped? That's really going down. Getting punchy. They expect things to connect. They expect to arrive at a place and things work and stuff like that. Your commitment.

5:18:48 Preserves the natural environment. That's good. So can you read it with that addition in there? Try it.

5:19:06 People of development demand our beautiful natural environment. I hate the world development. It's got a thesaurus app on their device. I mean, we're all circling around this sentence that the man-made shall not dominate the natural environment, right? Restarting a balance, it's a general plan ideal, like how do we articulate that? When they put people first and they decide the balance, that's the principle. Well, and is it the balance or it is a balance? No, we talked about that because a balance could be a...

5:19:36 Well, we just talked about it. We made a really bad balance. Oh, okay. So the balance could be like this. Exactly. Okay. The balance. The balance. How about people strive to balance people, buildings, and our beautiful natural environment? That's good.

5:20:02 So I was discouraging the groups from saying things that sounded like we will try to and say we will commit to, we will always. Well, strike sounds a lot like tackle to me, but anyway. Okay, so I'm going to call this arm wrestling match a draw.

5:20:30 And we're going to leave that one like it is for now. Next one. Working together as partners will lead to wise decisions for the community. How does this decision strengthen our partnerships? We're all in it together. Is that correct? Working together as partners, we're all in it together. Working together as partners will lead to wise decisions for the community. So they would always ask,

5:21:00 How does this decision strengthen our plan? That's a good one. That's how you express it in a meeting. Underline the word this, because we're talking this thing that we do. You guys did that? Yeah. Does that work for you guys? Yeah. So in a sense, I would actually encourage us to have that sentence after every principle. Yeah. So whenever you're in a meeting, policy, planning, budget, whatever you're saying, so, okay, we've...

5:21:30 We've heard from all the experts, how does this option enable us to work together? How does it help us achieve this sense that we're all in it together? That's what we're trying to do in this process. These get easier. We will foster a thriving community where people can live, work, and play for the long term. You can live here.

5:22:03 Yeah, you can live here. So once again, we will foster a thriving community where people can live, work, and play for the long term. I would just take out a will just so we foster, it's words for me, but we foster, so it's more direct, it's more focused.

5:22:26 You guys good with that? So it's in the present, not the future? Yeah, it's in the present. Yeah, that's good. We could do the same thing with the first one, say we strike the balance. Yeah, because you're the one who gave us the will. Yeah. As a matter of fact, I am the one who gave you the will, and now you're able to make the commitment. You should thank me for that. Thanks, Michael. You're welcome.

5:22:53 We will enhance memorable experiences through active community conversations. A memorable experience? Does that sound way better than... Can we get rid of Will? Yeah. Yeah, I can get rid of Will. You guys okay? You like it? You like it? Because we don't do it yet. Because we're not doing it now.

5:23:21 I'll talk about it. Yeah, I don't know. I like it, but maybe something more active, action-driven? So here's where I kind of do a little quick. I'd like to do these incidental teaching moments. So are you familiar with the difference between the Greek and Roman and Latin versions of the use of the word dialogue? No. So conversations,

5:23:51 Can be the Latin form of dialogue, and they can be the Greek form of dialogue. The Latin form of dialogue is two people talking, it's via logos, right? And most people in our country think dialogue means two people talking. Meaning, and the way it really works in real life is, you talk, and I'm thinking about what I'm going to say when you're talking, but as soon as you take a breath, I'm going to speak.

5:24:20 And then you do the same thing and we go back and forth and we don't really hear each other. The alternative translation, the historical root of this is search for meaning. Search for meaning. So the point of dialogue is a search for mutual understanding, for meaning. Conversations at the community level in most communities are talking at, not talking to.

5:24:47 They're not actually a search for mutual understanding and meaning. They're, with all respect, Mr. Mayor, three minutes at the podium, right? It's public comment. In fact, our whole democracy has sort of ironed in bad dialogue. Quite frankly, we've built it into our governance process. So when you move from engagement to conversation, you've moved a step up in terms of equality.

5:25:18 Conversation to dialogue. Now it's reciprocal, it's mutual, and it's meaning-centric. So through meaningful dialogue might be conversation can leave you with no decision. I feel like a lot of experiences require no dialogue. That's the point of a lot of the experience up here.

5:25:51 Is what you gain from an experience maybe on your own? Personal discovery. Yeah, personal discovery. But the front end of this is to enhance. So you're going to implement all these powerful, purposeful strategies to create more memorable experiences. And the operative word here is enhance. If you're going to do that, you're going to engage.

5:26:20 I'm kind of flipping the syntax here. I could sell them on the minority so I'll back down. But you're saying meaningful dialogue is going to lead to those things on that list.

5:26:49 Yes, what the key word here is to promote, create more memorable experiences. Just by talking about it. By dialogue on the front end. Well, think about, like, the chamber doing their guest service training for a large employee. To find out from the stakeholders, from the legal members, what do you want? What do you wish, want, and desire in this community that will enhance that experience? Is this something we're doing? We can kick it up a notch.

5:27:20 Is it something we need to invent at this point in time? How do we find out from the folks here what they want so we can help provide that support to them? Versus us telling them this is the kind of car you're buying. It takes you out of the role of being a sales organization and puts you back into that service organization. So we have a late submission.

5:27:53 Not turning this bus around.

5:28:21 Well, I just felt like it's the natural act of plays speaks to plays. Remember the experience we're talking a lot about.

5:28:36 The guest experience. I would argue that amenities and infrastructure relate to the guest experience. There's nothing like watching a family of four trying to make their way down Main Street in a snowstorm with no sidewalk. That's part of their memorables. Yes. They're remembering something. Their big Park City boots on.

5:29:06 So, let me sum it up this way so I can move this up. We're connecting real dots and some implied dots as well. Hopefully they're not imaginative. Alright, last one. We will ensure our community is safe, inviting, inclusive, and playgrounds.

5:29:31 Oh, yeah, we needed some help on this. We had a real hard time trying to synthesize. We actually had it nailed down. Yeah, we had the draft here. Read the original. Well, the original wasn't finished either. Well, not really. We need a community conversation to finish this piece. Yeah.

5:29:58 We will ensure our community is safe, inviting, inclusive environment. What they're attempting to do is kind of capture all of the elements that are included here. And the key piece there is we'll ensure. So in a sense, when you're making policy, budget, planning, outreach, marketing, communication decisions, you would ask the question this group asks, how does this decision

5:30:29 So I think if we marry a second question to this, we might give this the strength that it needs. No, I agree. I think that second sentence fully applies it. Would you all agree with that? Don't agree because you're tired. Yeah? What are you proposing?

5:31:06 Okay, so we're proposing adding, how does this decision? It's like you said, all that should just be on all of that. We can put it on all of that, yeah. But I think it adds, let's call it this effective for now. So we've got a framework of core values and a translation of those values into a decision-making guiding principle. Is it absolute? Are they absolute? No.

5:31:43 Are they final? No. Are there many variables that go into making decisions? Yes. Budget, timeliness, you know, access, availability, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. But what I'm asking you to do is to go all in on the commitment to say we won't expend public resources, we won't make major infrastructure decisions, we won't plan

5:32:11 MLR amenities. We will not develop brand strategies without factoring, running these core values as a filter against those decisions. If you can't do that, then they're not really values. They're just kind of nice to have ideas about an imaginary community. You want it to be a, what was it? A real community.

5:32:45 I was talking to John Wentworth earlier about this, and to Dan also, in a sense where I see this going, if this were your evolving strategic plan and your core values, the guiding principles sit to the left of these strategic priorities, and they become a screen against, that you apply against, are these the right priorities, are these the right powerful, you know,

5:33:15 Ways to align our collective resources to achieve what's imagined by all these values. We'll get this down to a simple one-page document. I think it would be cool if this was something that we could give any employee that starts in any of our organizations. This is what we stand for. In all of your actions, this is what you should strive to do, you know, from the permit tag.

5:33:48 All the way up to the tourism marketing stuff. I think that's a wonderful lead-in. You did it again. Last piece we're going to do today, we're going to do this in 25, 30 minutes, is we're going to get this elusive concept of buy-in. What is buy-in?

5:34:16 You all use this word, this phrase a lot last Thursday. When you use the word buy-in, are you thinking in positive terms or negative terms? Positive. How do you experience buy-in, the positive or negative? The presence or absence? I think right now you see a lot of negative on that side. The concept is people are not bought into where anything goes. There's been more of a negative. We experience it as elusive.

5:34:46 It's missing. Well, we don't have enough of it. John, I look to you because I know we've talked about this a lot. You guys are publishing a ton of data. You're delivering all kinds of information, right? You're telling about activity, productivity, outcomes, and it's not, and you said you were frustrated, if I heard you correctly, because it's not translating to buy-in.

5:35:13 That's not unique to your organization. It's not unique to this community. I find this everywhere. So some of the things I look to do are go. How simple and clear is the future you're trying to create to everybody that lives here? Or is it, I mean, you use language and tools and stuff that's so exclusive that only the planners and the planning commission and the councils and the, and so on and so on can engage with that.

5:35:42 To what extent is your planned future accessible to everyone? When you can answer that question, that's how you're fostered by it. And so people will buy into what? That's the question. What will they buy into? Is that what I understand? No, no, that's what I'm saying, is you have to define. I think that's the problem. People buy into what they experience. So people buy into what they experience. Tell me more. What do you buy into?

5:36:23 It has to have something in it for me. It's got to have something in it for you. It needs to say something about me. It's got to say something about me. It literally needs to speak to me. You have to have a connection. It has to be real. What kind of connection? Visceral. What does visceral actually mean? From the gut. From the gut. That's what it means. What is from the gut? Is it left brain intellectual? Jesus.

5:36:53 Where does it live? It's emotional. It's totally emotional. Is branding a wordsmithing exercise that is a left-wing, literal, fancy speech way of saying what a community is? Or is it a from-the-gut way of going, that's how I experience that place? It's visceral. It's emotional. That's what Steve was saying. Yeah, it's got that feel good. Yeah.

5:37:27 Anything else about buy-in? It has to connect to you. It's got to be personal. It's got to be visceral. It has to identify what's in it for you. You've got to like it. And there's another piece of it that buy-in always bothers me because you can get someone to accept and understand your point of view and agree to disagree with you but still have, quote, bought into it without jumping the fence. That's right. So I'm super mindful of that.

5:37:58 I want you to not buy it. I want you to subscribe.

5:38:26 Right? I want you to become a membership society, not a buy-in society. So our first opportunity is to actually get rid of that. Right? Where's my red pen? I suggest that we can step back from that and stop selling. Right? Buy-in isn't a sales process, so we don't have to sell. Although, I teach sales.

5:38:57 And I like to say, you know, the definition of sales is a mutual exchange of value. So in a proper sales environment, you're talking to what's good for people and what they like and what they need and what they care about. But buy-in has a lot of connotation. What's a better term for, I mean, this group over here wrestled with this through community dialogue and community conversations. You guys started with engagement, I think.

5:39:33 Let's imagine you're all working together as a collaborative of four NGOs, a town, elected officials, and staff. You've got core values, strategic priorities, and a set of powerful, purposeful, and functionally aligned commitments. Let's imagine all of that's in place and you're moving forward with it. When you communicate

5:40:05 This is the experiences that I share with people and doing so is I have

5:40:36 What do you guys think?

5:41:04 Organic ownership as opposed to buy-in, does that shift your thinking about how you might communicate with and conduct dialogue? I think there's also what Joe brought up, though, is like the agree to disagree thing, that there's some areas where someone's not going to take ownership over something, but they may have an understanding. The reason I shared the piece about the more enlightened form of dialogus is...

5:41:32 A search for meaning doesn't mean a search for agreement. It means a search for meaning. Yeah, very rarely are you going to get 100%. It's almost 100%. So saying both will turn around and say, we've agreed to disagree because this is our account. Now, we're looking at it differently. But we both in our heart want to say we believe this is the best for our community that we're a part of, even though we disagreeing on what that best is.

5:42:00 You're not coming at it from an adversarial one side, but that's not the focus of it. How do we make this place better? And now we don't know if we have to get there. Yeah. But we both have the end goal of a better place for what I'm at. So everyone has ownership over the end goal, but there may be more of just like an understanding about the ways you can reach there. I don't think that's the right way to get there. We disagree there, but we all understand we want it.

5:42:28 Like we want more jobs in our community. Does that mean in the way jobs? So without puzzling too hard over, I'm not looking for a title for the flip chart page. I don't really care. I wanted to move you past buy-in to a more kind of what I would call enlightened self-interest kind of approach, right? And simply let's just call it organic ownership.

5:42:57 For the purpose of saying, for your collaborative of your NGOs and council and staff to work effectively together, you're going to need more than just agreement on values and priorities and your commitments. You're going to need to actively engage with your community. Proactively, during, pre-brief, brief, debrief.

5:43:28 All of those phases. So you're going to need to communicate with people. So there are a number of ways in which you already do this. I've captured some. You distribute information. Forget this header here. You distribute information. You provide data. You share narratives. You provide explanations of data. You offer reports. You probably heavily weighted report side because it's a municipal government. What other ways?

5:43:58 So, right now, you're...

5:44:33 There's dialogue, which is one-to-one. An informal can be formal, can be conducted by a town council with the community participating. It can be, are most of your board meetings for your NGOs, are those open to public participation? So can you, and from my experience here, you have active public participation for the most part? Not dramatically.

5:45:02 Depends on the issue. Depends on the issue. Of course. How else is information delivered? How else is hard stories or data or outcomes or intentions or commitments or we're thinking about, you know, we're planning on all this stuff. How is all that delivered right now? In what ways?

5:45:35 Do you reach out to the community to bring it in? I don't think you do a very good job with that. How do we do it now? There's been some, I'll say, some direction, serving work, I don't see that, but what, with the housing out there? Okay, surveillance. There's public nosing for planning. So I noticed that around town, you have post meetings and things like that, and newspaper announcements. But what's the fly in the ointment of this?

5:46:08 Delivery System. What causes this to break down? People aren't paying attention. People aren't paying attention. Why not? Because they don't care. Give me the headset. They've got something else on there. They've got something else to do. It takes time to do that. Because they have busy lives. People have busy lives. Moving here doesn't make them different than they are in L.A. They just have busy lives. And those busy lives get in the way of

5:46:36 Participation. So the all-volunteer army, that's all y'all, show up for everything. Right? The same people participate in everything. Let me just ask, I mean, people have busy lives, but they have plenty of time to complain. That's my concern. They don't read the information, but then they have plenty of time to find and complain about things. Yeah. Is it the same eight trolls in every...

5:47:02 Is it a WordPress site, or is it really the community at large? It's the same group. It's the same people. It's the loud people that Jamie said. In total, I know, on a first-name basis, all the choice. Challenges, some of them are unfair. They're exhausting. No, they're always a newspaper. No, they write the newspaper. No, that's true. But it's unfair of us, I think, to generalize that that is representative of everyone.

5:47:32 It feels like we have no way to know if it is or it isn't. So in Southall we have three newspapers. Two of them think every single decision we make came directly from Satan. 100% of the other people. I have a bigger photo library. Yeah, the nice one. My kids have seen these pictures of me. They'll go, Dad, did you really?

5:48:00 So we've got a way of delivery. We've got content. We've got a way of delivery. And yet our goal, as Dan has prompted us here, is to attract ambassadors. We want to, John, we want to compete with the people with nothing better to do and the glass is always half empty. And

5:48:30 Not be dismissive of them, but simply create a larger presence for a positive image of the future. Not to be positive, but to create the momentum that you all need under your feet and in your wings to make this all happen. So my question to you is, what could we deliver better in terms of, and I've used careful words here, prized stories?

5:49:00 Your community doesn't really care about your data, I'm sorry. The data is what is the opposite of this role. It is completely the opposite. It's not that it's unimportant, they just don't care. And that doesn't say a bad thing about the community. It's just not how people... You deliver a lot of stuff. What they care about is the story of how the community is getting better, stronger, a more memorable, a nicer place to live, safer, et cetera, et cetera.

5:49:34 That's the narrative that they want to affiliate with. That's what they want to connect with. The method of delivery is usually formal and structured. Noticing, posting, delivering, inviting in the same people. And so we can either take the view that it's not working and it's their fault, or we can take the view that it's not working and, Colin, innovation is key to our future.

5:50:09 We need to get better at how we deliver. Enable this community dialogue because our goal is to attract ambassadors. So I'm going to challenge you with one final task today. One final task today. I want you to think about the prized stories, how you might deliver, what are they, how you might deliver them differently to attract the ambassadors that you want.

5:50:43 So I'm going to put you one last time for a very short period of time. We'll pick this up in the visioning exercise. Back in your organizational groups. So I don't want you mixed up. I want you back. I want MLT back. MLR back. Council back. And so on. And I want you to think. Thanks, guys. It was real. So you're going to answer two questions. What are the prize stories? And how can we deliver differently?

5:51:13 Thank you. More effective, more engaging, more people. I want to. Yeah. Thanks. I want to plant the 50% of the Spanish community. Right in the center. It's always in English. Right. Yeah. We can fix it.

5:51:32 All right, so this is going to be a 10-minute exercise. I'm excited about this exercise. 10-minute exercise. Give me one more minute. One more minute. 10-minute exercise. You're going to answer two questions.

5:52:02 What are the stories that we should be telling that will be prized not by us but by the readers, by our community, by the recipients? How can we deliver more effectively, more engaging? And the canary in the coal mine for this exercise, familiar with that concept? The canary in the coal mine is the 50% of your community that is not a naturally English-speaking population.

5:52:30 That's your canary in the coal mines. So it has to work for them.

5:52:34 Highest stories, how delivered. Yeah, town staff, distribute with an MGO, because you'll give some breath to those dialogues.

5:54:31 Thank you.

5:55:01 Yes, I have.

5:55:02 What do you call that?

5:55:04 Yeah, I can have a...

5:55:05 Yeah, sometimes it's just been awkward.

5:55:10 What about a local service?

5:55:13 I'm not eating a five-year-old, but now you need a lot of issues.

5:55:18 Right, that would help us.

5:55:19 Right.

5:55:21 Is there a way to tell the story?

5:55:25 Doesn't have like a few years.

5:55:27 Thank you.

5:55:30 Oh yeah, he did. This news release was like dry too. Consider it. Thanks.

5:56:42 We'll have a lot of time. We'll have a lot of time.

5:57:11 We don't always have news stories.

5:58:39 Yeah. So we're looking at parks, trails, recreation. Plus there's some fun things that people like. As opposed to the recreation. Because it's all about theater. It's all like how to get deported or arrested. Yeah. That's a different thing. And we're going to focus on, what is the recreation program? Recreation programs? Trails?

5:59:08 Thank you.

5:59:37 I'm reading over your shoulders. Okay.

6:01:44 Two minutes, finish up, two minutes.

6:03:12 Thank you.

6:04:48 And, I mean, I don't know, we have, what is that note?

6:05:18 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

6:05:47 Okay.

6:06:16 Thank you.

6:06:45 Okay, let me reconvene you one final time.

6:07:14 One final time. I hate to get you going on a good dialogue and then stop you, but I want to get you out of here. So rather than have you report and put up enough paper, I want you to just group by group tell me an example.

6:07:42 of something you discussed that you thought was very important from a kind of prized stories standpoint. We're putting stories in quotes here. Why am I using stories instead of data, reports, information, all this other stuff? Because it's what people connect to. So it's the idea of what can you translate into narrative form and then tell me what you've been thinking about in terms of delivery. So anyway. Joe's ready to go.

6:08:12 John, you're up. So, let's see, under prize, so recreation as a header, and parks, escape parks, trail facilities, schools and churches, is that what that says? Yeah, that's what that says. Did you say escape or escape park? Escape. What's an escape park? All escape parks. Yeah. Okay, so,

6:08:46 What about these recreational, so are these prized by people who are users from schools, churches? How did you guys talk about that? I think we were saying the way to spread the word about the story is through those venues. Through those venues. Because people actually don't come in this door, they come in this door. Right. So they're experiencing it through, and these are actually,

6:09:14 Ambassador subgroups. Exactly. Right? They're ambassador subgroups. It's a way to capture the community to communicate the work with a goal to begin with the younger generation to create junior ambassadors. Yes. So they engage in the process and become part of the process. The little ones talk to moms and dads and you grow it over time. Okay. Very nice. So how did you talk about delivery then of this, the how? So we talked about putting the need to put together some programs that will efficiently capture

6:09:44 The interest that these folks have coming in this way. These programs are put together by figuring out kind of what they might look like to become stewards, become future leaders, become people engaged with these things, then bring the business community in to support these identified programs. So then you've got young people to help fund them and provide some support for them. So you've got the kids and the people doing something around, something that socially they're enthusiastic about. You start bringing the business community in to kind of support it.

6:10:13 Just took off future retail managers. So, can I challenge this a little bit? I'm sorry. Can we add that real quick before you talk? Yes. We had some same conversation after that. Practical experience of talking. I tried to drive through the road there. But the idea there was, do we actually put the information, do we have a way there, a static way. It was like the biggest, four or five hundred people out.

6:11:22 Do we have a way of reaching those? What about as simple as? Joel, on behalf of his group, has highlighted recreation is kind of the medium. There are multiple channels of participation that represent different community segments. You've talked about sponsorship, event venues where there's captive audiences as a way of reaching. Our minds, this is probably one of the challenge.

6:12:06 In our minds, we tend to think in terms of programs and services, but do you have a lot of flex time within your resources available to you right now? Do you have some communications people without something else to do about 20% of the time? I'm being facetious for a reason. So do you have, honest question, do you have people, PR people who just aren't working hard enough?

6:12:35 So if we think in terms of programs, then programs automatically translate to personnel or resources that somebody has to pay for it and so on. I really like the idea of engaging the business community in active sponsorship because that gets your private partnership going. But what if you simply took...

6:13:03 This simple idea, I think it's the right idea, and said, how do we coach the ambassadors within the groups? So we don't create a program that people have to come to, or we have to bring it to them, or you have to manage it as a group. They actually, what did you say, junior ambassador program? So it's like your junior, we are all in a together group, right? Because you can live here.

6:13:34 And because we all want to see vibrant, inclusive community that provides a member of experience and it's in a natural, active place, so we create this kind of junior ambassador program. So you could actually create mentors and coaches so now when you have a captive audience, those individuals who have way more credibility than we do, right, are delivering messages and they're speaking the language understood. So maybe some type of...

6:14:03 Junior Ambassador Program. You get the idea. So how do we, because what we want to do, we want to get past buy-in, and we want to get past conversations that don't lead to engagement, and we don't have extra resources to spend. So how do we organically, to Dan's point, grow adoption, sponsorship, stewardship, and so on?

6:14:35 In very organic ways when we actually give the community a job. Right? Give the community a job. Stop trying to deliver a job. That's kind of the point. In fact, what I wrote up here to remind me is that you know they're prized stories that reflect these values. They don't reflect these values. They're just reports. We don't want to deliver reports anymore because they're now producing buy-in. Let's just accept that. What else did you talk about? Very, very nice work. What else did you talk about?

6:15:07 That was a prize. What did you guys talk about? Real quick. We talked about personal stories, actually, you know, actual families that we help, stories about them, stories about collaboration with folks like the chamber, et cetera, and then grant storytelling about grants we get, fundraising, and specifics on those grants.

6:15:33 So of the three, Collaboration, Families, and Grants, rate those for me one, two, three in terms of their compelling value. Well, Families, obviously, number one. I would say Grants, number two. And Collaboration, probably three. Yeah, because that's just kind of the how of it. It sounds sexy to us, but... Yeah.

6:15:56 I'm never in a room anymore where somebody's done talking about collaboration, so I have to believe that that's my church. Right. Right. But it's the family story. Grant's why. How does it get to what people care about? Because then we could possibly help them. How does that affect me? Could this affect me? Could this help me? Or my friends, my neighbors? Right. So what if you change? So how do you guys talk about the readings before I start? Okay, sure.

6:16:27 We talked about some of the different things we're doing, actually. Going to our rentals that are low income and posting flyers about our programs for ownership. So going to the rentals, posting flyers about ownership in both Spanish and English.

6:16:51 So we know that they rent, we know they're low income, they probably qualify for our ownership program. So we've been doing that. One of the things we're excited about, this weekend we're going to have a booth at the Tri-County Fair, which attracts people from all over Mono County and Inyo County because we have funds for Mono County, Mammoth, and Bishop.

6:17:13 And a lot of Latinos go there. We have Spanish-speaking staff, so that's perfect to reach out bilingually. Go ahead. I really like the booth at the fair idea because this is an idea that builds on this idea, which is go where people are already going. So you stop trying to create and manufacture.

6:17:44 Events, you stop trying to turn dialogue into events. You simply make it part of the familial process. The fact that you have staff who can facilitate is excellent and that you're publishing both languages and you're posting kind of at this level of housing what that level of housing opportunity might be like because people are looking for it. They don't want to come to an office. So these are all good.

6:18:14 Very nice. Somebody else, what did you guys come up with? Well, I think, you know, the prize is the visitation successes. Yeah. You know, really telling the story about the results of bringing people here. And we currently have that with doing third-party stories through the blog, through social media, and PR placements. So being able to show people that these lodging properties or these restaurants were listed in this article.

6:18:45 So is it both articles about the properties and venues and also testimonials like TripAdvisor kinds of? Not as much on TripAdvisor. It's more articles that have been written that include the property or the business. Tell the story of the destination through the properties.

6:19:11 And does, were you also implying or am I reading into some level of testimonials? That's the, does the blog post about, about businesses. Okay. So telling the story about businesses. Which in turn, hopefully, the hope with that is that we're creating ambassadors out of those business owners, whether they've included in an article, and they see the value from it, or that they see the value from being highlighted as a business. Okay.

6:19:40 Can I jump in? Okay, so one of the big questions for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, you know, we go out there and we market and we have our big campaigns and our brands and those and that and our open houses, and one of the questions that we hear individual businesses ask the team is, what are you doing for me?

6:19:59 And so what we're trying to do is we're trying to hit individual businesses and start to tell their stories on appropriate channels and then coming back to them and saying, hey, check it out. You know, we wanted to serve you. We wanted to incorporate your story into this campaign. Here were the results. Here's how it actually did benefit you. And it's a slower process. It's harder to scale.

6:20:27 So I see at least three audiences in this process. One is individual businesses.

6:21:19 And our how also both with PR and interactive are the ones that work most with individual businesses.

6:21:52 One of our huge communication channels is creating online. And so once we tell a business a story, we're all encouraging that business. Putting it out in the public sphere amongst interest groups. Are you able to close the loop on the effectiveness or move that back in terms of whether or not you're getting the kind of scope, expansion, acceleration? Am I going back to the businesses and saying, here's what?

6:22:51 What happened? Are they expressing a higher level of satisfaction with your services? Are they coming back to you and saying, thank you, do more? So, and then, yeah, we reach out to them and report on what. And then, Laura and I were both talking that we try to hit off the spectrum, not just the people who we know are our raving fans purposefully or ambivalent that they've had. Okay, very nice. How about, how about, did I,

6:23:48 Do you guys have something to do? I just think the other thing that we've done, I mean, we hold these open houses in the spring and fall, and I think that we've, you know, a lot of it's been data-driven with the idea that that's what people need to see, but we need to figure out how we get that to be a little bit less data, a little bit more dialogue, and how it relates to the businesses, and how do we get the businesses to tell our story, you know, that they have the best summer ever, or, you know, that they've seen the impact of X, Y, and Z.

6:24:16 Yeah, the word about me is so huge. I started this organic produce thing here.

6:24:45 And I knew it was awesome, and I told all my friends it was awesome, but only a couple of them signed up to start. And then those couple told, it was the influence of them telling each other that really made it mushroom. And, you know, within a few months there were 400 people signed up. So, it's really just the word of mouth. It's so huge, especially in a small town. Yes. We are still fundamentally tribal in our orientation to virtually everything.

6:25:12 And the farther we stray away from that, the more we get into trouble and we just spend money. Offline, separately, I would like to talk to you guys about an exercise if we have time where we do it now, but it takes about two hours. I'll just plant it. I'll plant it. It's what I would call the so-what-for-me approach to open house. So-what-for-me. Okay. How about back here? What did you guys talk about in terms of prize?

6:25:42 Storytelling and any innovation around it. I think we talked about consistency in the message. You might have a set of points there that we all talk to. It's not just heritage of something, but there's consistency in the message that's going on. It's that commonality of the role. And regardless of that location or wherever, it has the personal touch to it.

6:26:14 Thank you.

6:26:43 I was waiting for that one this morning. So here's a little trick I've learned about this to build on that point, and I think you just alluded to it, and that is your consistent messaging shouldn't just be about how and what, but why. And the why part of it should always be linked back to these values. So the best way to teach the community to embrace its own core values, because they're gut-level visceral values.

6:27:10 Is to pair the language with every message you put out. If you make this a recurring habit, it is my number one recommendation from today. You can actually take all the rest of this and park it and simply use that method and you'll start to get a lot more pull, a lot more traction. We're going to build on that idea the next workshop on September 10th. So the last group, you guys have the local regional piece.

6:27:39 Anything reprised and delivery that we could add to our... Well, not really. Again, we started with the whole discussion of the story has got to address what's in it for me. It's got to provide some guide, but for it to be visceral, it's going to be that. And what we talked about were things like...

6:28:01 A family that doesn't need to own a car, doesn't need to own a second car, because they can get around town, they can get to work, they can get to the dentist, they can get wherever they need to go on transit, and there's a true benefit, personal benefit to them, because they don't have the ownership and hassle of a car ownership or a second car ownership. And the how, we just kind of went through all the things that should be done, which, you know, websites, press release, one of the things we talked about,

6:28:31 Okay, so you could kind of piggyback on existing. So this sort of builds on this earlier theme about go where people are already convening.

6:28:59 So deliver through channels that people already expect as opposed to creating new ones, spending more money, creating home. It gets confusing. So kind of piggybacking a bad way of capturing your point. Anything else there? So focus on what's in it. For them, use the narrative of personal experience, how individuals benefit.

6:29:33 So this is in sales, selling on benefits, not on selling. This is how we deliver. This is our wonderful algorithm for scaling our service. This is, we deliver on time and it gets people to work, right, so they don't get fired. You know, the family's able to visit with one another on weekends at all hours. Our safety officer was here earlier, he says, so we're getting less drunk driving citations late at night.

6:30:05 Thank you.

6:30:42 That align you with the town's strategic priorities. We've built a set of core values that reflect community values and translated those into some guiding principles for decision making. And we've had what I'm going to call a preliminary conversation about how to pull community support and engagement and ambassadorship through dialogue, innovative approaches to your channels.

6:31:10 So we're going to take all of this content and all of this framework. In the next session, we have a half-day session on the 10th of September. We're going to say, so if all of this is true, if all of this is in motion, where do we see ourselves getting to in terms of big goals five, seven, and ten years out? And if we could achieve those goals, what kind of community might we imagine?

6:31:41 It's the realization of these values, the realization of these commitments. Ten years out, and if you let me, I'm probably going to try to stretch you out a little bit further even than that. But we'll go, we'll call it a safe ten years, and if you start getting real innovative, we'll go 20 years. And so that's the exercise we're going to do. And then we're going to send you off to the homework assignment. I'm inviting you.

6:32:08 To discuss this at the NGO level amongst your boards if you meet over the next 10 days or so at council if you guys have a meeting in the next week. After the third workshop there will be a month interval and our intention was to give you each a round to brief and debrief with your full boards since obviously all of your board members are not here. We're going to give you a document trail, sort of a simplified version.

6:32:38 So that you can communicate this. And then we'll bring you back and we'll do an 18-month action plan on the ground, prescriptive, descriptive, with outcomes, with commitments, fully aligned, all in, living in these values. In October. October 8th. And that date may move. And that date may move. I've been hearing. So whenever that date is, at least four weeks pass this third worship.

6:33:07 Okay, so that's our process. Okay, closing comments, questions, concerns? Is this useful today? Yes. Yes? I was telling Dan that I was really thrilled. This is our last time you guys have stayed. You stayed all day. There were enough people coming and going, which is kind of what I experienced. So I thank you for that. I thank you for sticking it out and for your commitment to the community and to this work here.

6:33:39 Thank you.