TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2015

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 41 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

593 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Thank you. Thank you. I'm not sure. I think we may wait a time. I'm ready to go. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Here. Yeah. I know.

1:01 Wow. Wow.

3:17 Shocking. Shocking.

4:29 All right. We're going to get our workshop going. We're going to start a workshop with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and Garden MLR Strategic Planning Efforts. It is, what time is it? It is 4 o'clock. I'm going to turn it over to Dana. She's going to open up and then turn it over to Rich. Thank you. I'm going to call for, sorry.

4:57 Is there any public comment before we get started? We're also going to have an opportunity to public comment at the end. At the end? Yes. So would you like to come forward now or at the end is fine? Or both? I'm going to come forward now. Okay. Good afternoon. I'm Jennifer Halperty with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so I just want to say that I read through the material presented today on the draft strategy.

5:34 I think I'd like to offer up Mammoth Lakes Housing as a potential partner. I noticed you have partners listed and Mammoth Lakes Housing wasn't listed. And I think that given what's in your strategy, land acquisition and shady rest partial tract, and that it has an affordable housing overlay, it makes sense that we would be, to me, a very intuitive partner, I would say.

6:03 Mammoth Lakes Housing has been successful in the past in getting grant funding for various workforce housing, but also working with the town for the trail that you see in front of the Aspen Village apartments on Old Mammoth Road. That was done through CBG funding, which we were able to get because it supported workforce housing, low-income housing.

6:30 Otherwise, I don't know if that trail would even be there and all those bus pull-outs along Old Mammoth Road. So, you know, those are types of things that if we collaborate, we can do because there is an affordable housing overlay specifically on that site, but other things too where I think we could be good partners. And so I just wanted to offer that up. Thank you. Anybody else?

7:10 Thank you. I'm Dana Stroud. I'm current president of the board for Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and I would like to take a quick moment to introduce representatives from the MLR board who are here today. Drea Perry is on our board. Tom Johnson is on our board. Terry Stelick is on our board. Colin Fernie represents the council on our board. Two of our members are currently out and about. David Page and Brent Truax are the other two members who aren't here this afternoon.

7:43 So we are extremely excited to bring forward to you tonight a strategy far new now to come up with this strategy in wanting to meet the deliverable that has been assigned to us via the contract. And so we want to come to get some because we intend to be back to you in December with the deliverable that we've announced to provide. We're excited to be here tonight and looking forward to your feedback.

8:26 I'm going to turn it over to Rich Baccia. He's our Executive Director, and he will take us through this afternoon's... Rich, thank you so much. Give him a medal. Give him a medal. Okay, I'm going to break this up into three parts. Some opening comments, review the exact summary, and then engage in dialogue with you all based on some of the questions I have for you in the conversation. Number one, Town Council accepted the five...

9:13 Thank you.

9:49 We find a great sense of that. MLR has been conceived as a useful and important way to enhance and build on existing recreation assets and opportunities that exist from both private park. The Mammoth Lakes Council, the steering committee, and public participants have expressed consistent agreement during each phase in the development of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the community. Number one, we'll need to augment and enhance recreation assets, venues, programs, services for being compared

10:22 Number two, the window of opportunity to invest proactively will not remain open. The Town of Mammoth Lakes Town Council provide a direction for the work of Mammoth Lakes Recreation through a number of deliverables. This afternoon we'll focus on the initial draft of the strategic documentation. The purpose of this document is to establish a working scope and framework to use guidelines and direction for the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board.

10:58 The Executive Director, and the staff to prepare and provide to the prioritized list of primary amenities recommended to be supported through measures you and our funds by December of 2015. That's per Pacific's AMB of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, MLR Services Agreement dated October. Let's go to number two in our document today. I want to do a quick review of the summary of the draft strategy document. For folks in the audience, those documents are on the back table.

11:29 Page 1 outlines vision, mission, guiding principles, and the relevant planning documents that we use to put this strategy together. Page 2 talks about identified partnerships that will be essential to the success of the mission. Page 3 of the executive summary talks about organizational items, leveraging and raising funds, a comprehensive communication plan, and building and developing business plans for each one of the projects specific.

12:00 Synthesize specific capital facilities projects for measure R&U utilization. Each project contains elements of context, history, current status, vision for the facility, locations, partnerships, or agency options. Cost estimates including maintenance and operation costs for long time sustainability and potential funding scenarios. Some of those include the multi-use facility, community center, arts and culture center, Mammoth Lakes Trail System.

12:29 The Aquatic Center, Recreation Center, Completion of Trails End Park, Completion of plans for two training facilities, an outdoor venue, niche projects, Shane's inspiration, potential land acquisition. Page 12 outlines our next steps in this project based on this conversation. We see our next steps to include. Create a filter that provides data about the project to generate a priority listing for Town Council regarding those prioritized projects with locations and costs for their consideration.

13:11 Number four, what are the priority next steps that the council has? I would make the following recommendation. We have four questions on the table.

14:21 Let's start with elements of draft strategic planning documents. Let's start with the celebration. Let's start with the challenges. I know we have some work to do on the document itself. Well, I like it. Congratulations. Obviously, we've got some vision to be adding and talking about, and that's what this is all about. That's why we're here.

15:16 From my perspective, having been involved in earlier versions of this, whether it's 8.5 or now it's 9.0, I'm glad to see a lot of the things getting further fleshed out, and I know it's been a priority at the meetings. When we come back around to it, I do have a couple of comments on things that need to be added, but I don't know if you want to include them at the same time. One of the things is, you know, there is a list here, and it's a somewhat distilled list from all that's available.

15:47 But I think that there should still be one more public process time for people to bring up what about, and it is a joke, if it's Joe's climbing wall or something else, because that would never be built, but it's a good example to use, is to do one more check to see if there's anything else that should be included in determining. And we did promise that in funding scenario 2.0, that there would be a public process to say,

16:15 Hey, guys, did we miss, you know, because it was standing right in front of us, did we miss one of the items that would fall into the potential projects? Then when my suggestion is when you get down to that, there has been some discussion that I think Council will be looking forward to about the filter. One of the things I'm going to suggest, though, and hopefully my fellow Council members would agree with me, is that

16:41 When you are getting down to it and you're actually using the filters and you're figuring out the feasibility is to group them into first tier, second tier, more years out rather than trying to argue which one is one and which one is two. Instead of trying to get a single list is that maybe there are three, maybe four in the top tier.

17:04 And then you start working on each of those. If funding comes up for them or funding comes up for one of the second tier ones, that there's the ability to move it. Because that's the reality. As we get all down to this, none of this happens if we can't leverage the funding and do all of those kinds of things. So rather than trying to argue which one is number one and which one is number two, let's say focus on which are the top tier and keep it a small-ish number. Other thoughts, reflections on the draft topic?

17:35 No, as far as, you know, pros and kudos, you know, the word that came to mind was comprehensive. I joined later in the game when you had already went through seven iterations of this document, so I appreciate the tremendous amount of work that's gone into this, and it is very comprehensive. I got a couple of comments for later as far as just general comments and then maybe some additions and subtractions. But in general, I think we're really moving in the right direction.

18:05 I don't know if you notice when you walk in, but we had some recently printed visioning maps, and that to me is a very exciting opportunity to start to bring all the different plans and visions we have and put them into one place. So this first iteration was really focused on entitled development. I would love to see our trail system overlay go on top of that, what we intend to do with that in the long run.

18:32 And, you know, the most important part of this document and this meeting is to really finalize that strategic plan. But as we are able to do that and filter projects and finalize them, I see God fitting in very well there as well. This is the long-term vision for the community. This is where we see these top-tier facilities going. And, you know, if this goes here, that means this goes there, et cetera. So I think it's a nice segue for us.

19:00 continue to vision what this place could look like. Go ahead. Rich, I think the document's done well, and goodness as well, you guys working on this, vision, funding, execution, right? It's going to take that, and I want to make sure that we, it's important to me that MLR doesn't become everything to everybody, because if that's a case, nothing will ever be done. So,

19:28 I'll comment a little bit more on priorities when we get to that point. There's some further comments that I have on some of that, but I think the documents are well done and have to stay focused on the vision plan and execution. So just to tear off that, I think that I really want to express the fact that I believe this is the right document at the right time. There was some discussion before about, oh, we're working on a strategic...

20:01 I very much appreciate the way you've broken down each of the program areas.

20:28 You know, previous documents, things that previous planning efforts that have been done. It's enormously encouraging to think between the work that you guys are doing, that the Rec Commission, Regulation Commission is doing, is that all the planning efforts that have happened over the last, I don't know, 10, 15 years, getting pulled into one place, you're getting looked at from an execution perspective. I think that's enormously valuable. And...

20:52 So I think the way, I mean, you can feel it from reading it that this is the right way to strategically look at all this stuff. It gives me an enormous amount of confidence of the outcomes that you're going to get to something the council can engage with, the public can engage with. And I would just, again, really encourage members of your board and members of the public, this alignment process that's going on with the NGOs and the council is enormously important. And this fits right into this.

21:19 And I think that Jennifer coming forward and saying what she did, this is an unexpected gift. These are the kinds of unexpected gifts we're looking to find. And we should not be looking at this process. This has been sort of a gotcha sense of, oh, why wasn't I, you know, all this kind of stuff. But to encourage and look for these opportunities to bring these things forward, it's going to make this thing richer and more substantially more forward. Very good. Thanks. Challenges? I've seen this document that's a concern or maybe gaps. Would you like to add?

21:50 Well, I think, you know, John's comments and Jennifer's comments are a good segue there. As we start to do this strategic planning process that, you know, MLR was involved in, you know, one of the things that I think has become abundantly clear is as we put this new structure in place for how we are operating our government, we really need to look for those collaboration opportunities, and sometimes they might not be as obvious as others, but...

22:18 You know, we have MLT out there. We have MLH out there. We have PESTA out there. We have NLR out there. There's a lot of very intuitive areas to collaborate and then maybe some that aren't so. And so just encourage you guys to look at as many opportunities to work with those partners and achieve goals there. You know, one of the things that we talked about in the strategy session is

22:46 What is really the intent of a lot of these NGOs? And I see the same themes permeating all of these different NGOs, and that is singular focus, expertise, and the ability to leverage funding. So I just want to continue to reiterate that throughout this process, that MLR is our expert on recreation infrastructure enhancement programming.

23:08 And then that programming tiers down to the work that the Recreation Commission does as far as on the ground stuff. But we really need to focus at this point, I think getting the strategy document out of the way by December is a huge hurdle and we're on the way to getting there. But after that phase, we really need to focus on leveraging resources. We are a town with limited resources right now and that is something that the

23:38 The longer established NGOs have done well. And in order for MLR to be successful in the long run, it's going to have to do that. And maybe in certain cases, it might be the most difficult job as far as leveraging funds. There might not be as many clear opportunities to do that. So I just want to encourage those things.

24:01 And then there's a couple of kind of more nitpicky things, but I think those are the overall comments that I have. Okay, so I have, like I said, I got into this a little bit late in the game. I, looking through this list of things that have made the strategy document, I support all of them. The one that I'm a little bit unsure of whether that really falls under NLR's purview and makes sense to be in this realm would be a conference center.

24:30 So I'm wondering if maybe we can have a discussion about that as a group. Maybe I'm off. Maybe I just need you to articulate that a little further for me. It's certainly something that I think we have a tremendous need for in this community. But I think that that falls more into the sector. I'm not sure what the role of MLR is in executing that facility that we need for our community.

24:57 That was going to be one thing that I just wanted to pose for discussion. Just to kind of respond on that real quick, we did have some good discussion about that at our board level regarding that, and I think we note in there that this really does become part of the private sector, but the idea of having it in the document.

25:18 I think we did also point out that this really is going to become a private

25:48 Okay. I think that sufficiently answers my question. I just want to make sure that we're clear on that, that I don't necessarily see this as something that MLR should be going out and actively looking to build.

26:06 I think that's something that there is.

26:29 A niche project, sure. But I would think that that might be something we want to put on our radar for a niche project. Did Grady mention on that? He is not the head of that club. Is he a member of that club? Yeah, that's Grady. He's playing frisbee golf. I don't have the list of members, but I think maybe for a niche project that's something that can just be on our radars.

26:58 Relatively low cost. I think it fits in well with our idea of, you know, just having as many diverse outdoor activities as you can. And I just noticed that was something that I'd like to throw out the consideration. Okay. I would just respond to your comment about the conference center belonging or not belonging in here. One thing that I think we agreed to our board when we were talking about whether to keep it in the document or not was the value of filtering it.

27:25 Because the definitions of an art center or a community center or a conference center can kind of be blurred sometimes in the different iterations that we've seen come across our table as we're discussing what these facilities would look like and whether there's multi-use capability in some of these. So we felt like there was some value in just filtering that.

27:48 And kind of getting it on the table in line with some of the other facilities that we're looking at. I appreciate very much what you're saying because if you read this very closely, that comes through. My confidence is as you continue to do this work, those things will find their way into where they belong. So I hope I'm reading that correctly. I appreciate you acknowledging them and putting a T and I on them, but I have a certain confidence that they're going to end up...

28:11 And I think I can speak to the board that the general consensus was aligned with your evaluation. You've sufficiently elaborated the position. I'm comfortable to stand down there. I just thought it was worthy of discussion. There's a gap in your next steps that, again, I was privy to because of prior conversations, but the whole discussion of

28:36 How much of the funding goes into strategy, priority projects, and how much goes into funding ongoing projects and, well, some kind of a cycle needs to be, not that you're necessarily ready to tell us that today, when it comes back, all of that needs to be explained.

28:58 If I'm correct, unless it changed since I went, at some point early on, you have to be letting the community know if and when there is another funding cycle or how it's going to be accomplished, etc. And that did come up at the meeting on Monday. It's definitely on the radar that that needs to be sorted.

29:20 Well, and I say it because as we were going through last spring, the document said for the fall funding cycle, but there have been later conversations that no way are we ready because the priority document comes first, and if whatever percent of the funding is going towards a priority project, that will reflect differently in the short term or one-offs, whatever you want to call them, but I don't know that the community has really heard that yet, so I'm just recommending. Because that becomes the challenge. Right. If we're all of a sudden in a fall allocation,

29:50 Thank you.

30:14 And I'm also looking that somehow in here, because it's really based on, it's buried on page four, but your paragraph about priority is wonderful, but nothing in here really talks about how you would take any kind of an annual cycle and apply it against whatever criteria you're going to have or whatever priorities you're setting up.

30:38 I know, I know the focus got into this, but it's like it's definitely on our mind and we're fully aware of the public's interest in whatever cycle or not this starts to look at.

30:57 Correct. Correct. So there needs to be that kind of communication in either through this workshop or, you know, at some point just letting people know. There won't be applications coming out sometime this month, I'm presuming. I didn't think that had changed. I think you're correct on that. Uh-huh. This is the focus, but if somehow so, then how is that other going to incorporate?

31:19 And I also wanted, it's not a gap, but I thought it was very important that as we're looking at page three and we're talking about the strategic regulation elements, that there are some inferences in there when it comes to special events that I think need to be daylighted sooner rather than later. I know there's been a, I don't want to call it if it's a congruent or a parallel or whatever, there are discussions going on there that need to come forward at some point.

31:46 I understand what's in here, but if the special event people who got funding this summer look at this, I think the first question is going to be, well, where do we fall? So I think that needs to be answered. Yeah, that may be something that gets to a council level, but I appreciate that. Correct, correct, but with the recommendations from NLR, because I know there have been discussions on options on how to approach that. They're just, and again, since you're focusing on this, but how much of that needs to be daylighted at some point.

32:15 Maybe when we see the whole thing in December. I've got a couple things. Just on gaps. No, because we're going to get to additions in a second. But from the gap side, it's a general sort of concern. This is a very rich, good, thorough effort. And I'm assuming that MLT, you know, housing, they're all going to be doing similar kinds of efforts.

32:45 When we're working with this council alignment effort and the goal setting stuff, I have a concern about how the awareness of what you guys are doing, what the other groups are doing, how that's going to be, how that gets communicated. I'm turning a little bit to Dan on this because from a council perspective, we have some Brown Act constraints, but I think that even in the session we had on Friday, just the very preliminary conversations about,

33:15 What MLI, what happens at the MLR table, what MLR is doing, and there still seems to be some sort of mystery about these things, and I want to make sure that the burden, I'm not putting a burden on you guys to address that, but I think larger from the work that we've done with Michael Ward, we need to figure out how we're going to start getting everybody to cross-pollinate in a way that to really physically start breaking these silos down, because we are building this horizontal...

33:41 The second one is the first couple of pages from the outdoor recreation economy.

34:07 We don't have to talk about this now, but this is an enormous and important piece, and I appreciate that this focus is for a specific deliverable that's in your contract you need to provide, but how, because, you know, you're talking about R&U funds, these are specific things we've got to be focused on, but how MLR with its own capacities to raise its own funds for its staff to engage with these kinds of issues is going to be, I'm very interested in that. I'm not sure it's a gap yet, but moving forward.

34:36 I'm going to be at a conference in Jackson Hole at my own expense, specifically about the intersection of recreation and conservation, which informs who we are as a destination. And I think how this starts moving into what we're talking about is going to be important. I don't know if it's a gap gap, but it's something different. Sorry, one last thing. And I'm specifically concerned in terms of the town staff.

35:05 And this communication, the awareness of what you're doing. I'm also very interested in the Forest Service. How is this being communicated to the Forest Service? We can't have this kind of stuff lagging behind their understanding. They can't be, you know, we do not want critical partners to be showing up two months from now saying, I didn't know anything about this. We need to document that outreach. It's not a full public outreach thing, but it's a documented effort, I think, from the town manager. It was a detonated point of contact in the Forest Service to say, look, we're doing these things.

35:34 And it's not in anybody's interest to show four months from now or come back in December and say, I had no idea you were doing this. Which might be John Pitson, too, as we get to the closure of that conversation. Number four, what are the priority next steps the council will give you to the board? Perhaps, yeah. Because we want to find out, are we moving in the right direction? Are we meeting the target at this point? Do we need to do some mid-course adjustments? And so what are they? And what are your recommendations for next steps? Simple answers, yes. Yeah.

36:04 Kind of like the vision. Love that part. And I love the vision. It's broad. It's lofty. It's sudden shoot for it. But in doing that, I want you to understand or help me understand what the recreation community is. Is that Mammoth? Is that the eastern Sierra? What is that?

36:35 I think our board has had conversations about this over the formation and now into the actual transition. First off, because there is the focus on R&U, we have to have an attention paid to the community of Mammoth Lakes. As we start to broaden beyond that R&U funding of our own, I think we do have the ability to look out to other partners throughout the region as we begin to

37:04 And we've started to, you know, in some of the relationships that we're starting to develop through the trails effort, you know, Friends of Vieno is a part of this and their reach is broad. We've started to do some interpretive association. We'll be looking at some activities with them.

38:04 Their reach is broad also, and so we have those opportunities out there, and we certainly look, we're going to take this. If I get just one thing, the ESCOG, one of the things that's on the agenda, with the three priorities we're looking at with the ESCOG, Recreation, Technology, and Air Service, that's exactly, that's what this is. That's what I'm saying, it all ties together. In my Wizard of Oz world, Mammoth is the emperor.

38:53 Who's got this? This is all over me. And I would use high altitude training, 9,000 feet to 4,000 feet in a conversation with Andrew Castro at lunch yesterday, Rich. You know, Michael, and we get the Olympics in 2016, right around the corner, one NGO's coming, 2020's right around the corner. Andrew, what are you going to have in 2020? How about five males and five females that have been competitive? So how do we begin to bring those folks here to train and identify at an early age? LA in 84 is an option for the games.

39:30 I mean, that's 80 years out. That's right around the corner. So how do we expand this regional base that we have all this natural environment to take advantage of? I agree with you. I mean, we have Oz, and it is Oz. It's Oz. Well, you know, trails is a great example of that. You know, obviously, our trail system here locally, both soft service and multi-use, should tie in very well to a broader system of trails that runs throughout the entire region and really...

39:58 From Mexico to Kansas. Actually, it does. It does. Yeah, but that was part of the hiring process with Joel was the trails coordinators to say, you know, you've got some limited scope uses with R&U funding, but also has that versatility to tap into town funds, collaborate with the Forest Service, collaborate with the entire region. So, Shields' point is well taken that

40:27 It's got to be both micro and macro, but I think we're on that page. And when we were working through the forming last fall and actually getting into bylaws and things like that, MLR was purposefully nonspecific. Recreation was all forms. We didn't sit there and start making the list. It's always been broad. Community is intended to be broad, even though the reality is it's going to be a ripple effect. So to a certain degree, it's intentional.

40:57 To the recreation community is going to be whatever it can be in the greatest dreams. That's important. In fact, you know, our executive director was originally one of the board members because we had specifically said board members did not all have to live in Mammoth. So that was part of starting to expand and regionalize or even farther.

41:24 Gaps? Gaps? Gaps on the way.

41:26 I might address one thing that I kind of constantly frame that I'm hearing.

41:40 We all understand that this deliverable is very much about amenities and measure arm and measure you.

41:48 but in every comment I've heard.

41:53 Vision, funding, execution. Singular focus, expertise, leverage funding. There's this idea of what is the identity of MLR after this deliverable comes to you. And I think we as a board are pretty agreed that it is about supporting execution in terms of leveraging partnerships and leveraging funding. And I think there's got to be a deliverable just like this that's more of an execution deliverable that actually addresses how do you construct your funding campaigns.

42:21 What does that look like? What does your army of fundraisers look like? How do we build a structure like that in this town that's, you know, next level? I'd like to follow up on that when we get to that for the conversation. Well, and actually just, and maybe what you need to do in here is expand the business plans a little bit more to say, not just that you're going to have them, but the why, which is what Tom just stated, the why you're going to have business plans to get to that.

42:50 That's always been a gap for this community. We've got a lot of studies and pieces of paper and boxes over at the non-office and taking that leap to execution has been a shortfall. And I think that this group can help to do that, moving into a new era as far as how we conduct our business.

43:14 That's an important step. So if I could, maybe just to follow up on that, I think one thing that's important, again, this is a communication piece, and I looked to my fellow council members and there stood a consensus about this. The understanding that the investment that the town makes in the overhead, the administration, those pieces of MLR, that I don't have an expectation, I don't think the council has an expectation, that your job is to go out there and raise money to cover the cost of your staplers and your copy machines.

43:42 That we're looking to the programs that you establish. You go back to when MLR was originally proposed and the mayor at the time, Rick Wood, put a banner up there that said, you know, community visual arts performing center, trail system, recreation center. I'm looking at these programs you're working on that by December you're going to be able to say to us, okay, this one is tangible.

44:07 Trail system is ready to go. We've got a brand on it. It's happening. The recreation center or the performing arts center is tangible. We're putting a brand on it. We can tell the community how to go to that. Multi-use facility. Multi-use facility. Whatever these things are that you've got, they become things that are on websites. They're things that people talk about that the community can engage with. And I think my expectation is that the dollars that you raise through those programs, that's the leverage that we're looking for.

44:32 We're looking for the advocates, the passionate people who are involved in those programs to be delivering cash, dollars, money, in-kind contributions, and volunteer hours. And I'm expecting that that kind of reporting come up to the council to say NLR, through its programs, is leveraging these resources. I hope that that's, it may be a consensus we share, maybe not, but that it's not about

44:59 I think the Council is fully prepared to say, look, we are investing in this organization to do those kinds of things. And that we're not going to get, there's a lot of semantics about this when MLR was being formed about overhead administration. But I think we're moving beyond that now. We're looking at the value of this thing in terms of how the resources you bring into the passionate users of the programs you guys have established.

45:23 One more gap, or it may be there, but it needs to be there, is the discussion on Monday, we got down to innovation was going to be a driver, it wasn't a specific piece of what we were working on in the strategy session, to make sure that the filter gives some emphasis to innovative approaches to getting these things accomplished.

45:53 Anything else on gaps or additional recommendations that the council has as we begin to finalize this document? I'm sorry, what? Question number three, what recommendations might you have for the MLR boards and move this document forward? Just a couple to follow up with. One is that this comes back to us that the degree that you can, you put it in the context of those program areas. So you've got...

46:19 We were just talking about it. The recreation facility, that's a known, that's going to be a program area. So ranking these things are relative maturity. Like the trail system is up and running. It's something that exists. Wherever you're at with the performing arts center, it's relatively mature. We can start going after community engagement. It'd be helpful to know where you think these things are on the relative maturity. I think that's a great point. Is that what they, John, put in as readiness?

46:45 It may be. Is maturity readiness? And that's what will happen as we're going through the process. That would be very helpful to get a sense of where these things are. And the other thing is to continue, Tom, you're sort of a parsing of a recreation center versus a community center that developed those things out so there's a consensus from your boards and we think a recreation center is really good.

47:10 This. Community centers will leave this. Because that goes... Better defining. Better defining that stuff. You're in the process of doing that. Just continue along that. Not to say that we might not stack them on top of each other at the same location, but to maybe get the definition clear. Sure. Okay. I think we should stack them on top of each other. Maybe side by side. Well, that was the whole discussion about a parking structure that had recreation center on the top or something like that.

47:41 Okay, additional recommendations from the council? Is there something on this? Gaps? Thoughts? I'm just, I'm happy to see how, I know how much hard work is going to this, so I'm going to thank the board members for continuing to do the hard work, and Colin's now finding out that how much hard work he's gotten himself into, but he knew, he was part of the nation. Just to keep doing it, we've now got someone to...

48:11 Expedite, which is a fancy word for nag, you into getting your decisions through and stuff, and so just keep going. I'd like to follow that kudos to the board, because it's been a working board for almost a year. The staff didn't come on here about two months ago. More than two years. Kudos to the board for all the work they've done in the formation committee. This NGO is as powerful as the other NGOs. We're still young, we're developing, and I have full faith in who we are and where we're going.

48:38 And we're going to help us get there as a community. We call it a collective genius. Right. And even though I just said, okay, everybody, you're in for more work, I think, Richard, it would be a good time to mention that there are two open guard positions and people can file for them by the 4th. Thank you very much. If there's anyone in the audience who are the usual suspects, they might want. September 4th. September 4th. Yeah, September 4th. Okay. Two days, but it's not a long application. Okay.

49:07 So I don't hear any other additional recommendations, gaps, issues, concerns. We're kind of on the same page at this point. Maybe a thing is that because the next steps are pretty broad, is there an opportunity to have some kind of reporting back before we get to December? Is it during your quarterly report or is it a separate presentation on here's what the criteria is starting to look like or things like?

49:33 I'm just thinking, rather than going dark for three months. I realize that your board meetings are open, but, you know, for... You could add that to our October quarter report. Yeah, just to say, you know, now we've gotten to this point or that it's starting to look like this or that. Well, and we also have, well, it's not, we don't have the timeline yet, but as a part of the public review of this document, there is that...

49:59 Thank you. Thank you.

50:27 It might be helpful to, I mean, to show the kind of results of that public meeting, but also at some point of kind of filtering maturity, just so you guys kind of know what the process is looking like and making sure that that's going to be made. Well, if you could present it as just maybe like a one sheet or something that's on top of this, it's like a track change kind of thing to say, these are the changes or things that we're pursuing as we go forward.

50:53 Well, or to the point that what's starting to float up to that top tier, so that there's that level of awareness that this is really where energies are going to start to be spilled. As an example, on your outdoor venue, CMS for a place, there's very real possibility that you would say we might go into escrow at any time. In six months, we could not.

51:30 I did, and I was trying to, it's kind of.

52:06 So I'm kind of wondering, though, since those meetings may be open to the public but they're not really, shall we say, accessible or recorded or anything like that, is to maybe plan some kind of a thing there because, you know, we've discussed some other things like

52:35 Well, this involving ESTA as a partner when you're starting to talk about trailheads and how you're going to get people to and from them, that kind of thing. This is great about the current efforts and all that, but it doesn't really talk to what's next in the trails area. And again, maybe that can grow out of what's being discussed in the strategy sessions. Rich, with our time left, I know you have an agenda you want to get your things on. I'm interested in hearing...

53:05 From our staff, perhaps, if they've got any thoughts, any thoughts from your board, you're hearing from us a lot, to review these four points, and then some folks. You may have one question. Oh, sure, please. Can we go there? That's okay, Richard. We finished the last. Sounds like we're moving on. I'd say keep doing, if you can, daylight the priorities that come out of the public process, or what's still on the list, or what went from bottom to top.

53:47 And if you can give the community an idea of what this actual criteria is going to look. And I realize that draft pieces have been in MLR agendas, but this is a slightly different forum for another way to let everyone know how the criteria is starting to look. Very good. So we talked about the priorities here, and I'm assuming that there's a breakdown of the list here. As far as Bill, we've got a lot of discussion about the Bill D.

54:19 The other thing that I want to make sure we're going to do is we're going to

54:55 Really focus on completing what's started. Other than those couple of first items, I mean, you just mentioned the outdoor calendar and that dialogue as well, but, you know, the Trails End Park and some of these other things that are starting, I really want to get those finished. I'm talking about the things about page 10. Yeah, yeah. The stuff that's, you know, complete, so, I mean, in addition to those top three items, and then, again,

55:24 I don't want to just get us all over the board, you know, so we can really get these three top things going at the same time while we can work on completing some of the things that are out there. Because our goal is to come back as Joe's going to tears, really the top tier. Is that where we're going? We'll chase that down. Check it off next, next, next. And that brings me to another comment, as you know,

55:50 We have certain things that got started, so I'm presuming when you talk about completing Whitmore, well that's a lot of things, but the people who were driving that have moved on, and so within the criteria when you're identifying who the partners are going to be, it's making those really strong connections so that, you know, because a lot of people still call it Jim and Elaine's track, but they've moved on, so what happened to the

56:18 Community uprising or all that initiative to help and make it move to the other phases. So I think there needs to be a recognition that we don't keep doing kind of one-offs. Yeah, just to follow up with what Michael said, turn your focus onto those things and bring back recommendations that make sense and are feasible and are doable. I think it's kind of interesting. Yeah, they have timelines that are real, right? Exactly.

56:45 We're going to have a multi-use rank at a community center open in 2017, and by this date, we're not going to do it. Instead of, you know, the community's concern is 2017 is going to turn into 2021. Sure. Right? So, and these things, like I said, these other items that have started there. Be realistic. That's right.

57:10 Well, it's a wish list, right? Nothing ever happens. No, or like the Dr. Stead's document, where there was no way you were going to get all that done in the first three years. Realistic, definitely realistic is important. Well, okay, if you lose that, you lose the events in summer. Right. No, no. That's major. But, in saying that, and looking for, you've got to get the process. It doesn't mean you're not going to go.

58:05 That's what I'm saying. If you get a tier and you're working on them or focusing on them, which is what we want MLR to do, you're right. And, you know, there's going to be an easy solution where there's going to be tough. But I think Shields, again, because you guys are a working, I look at this, you know, you are a working capacity to help inform this council or to move all these things forward. If you...

58:28 You know, getting a process started, it's valuable for the council, but we need to understand, okay, that thing's in escrow now, we're going to come to you guys and say, what are you looking at? Not produce it tomorrow, but is this two years? You know, so realistically we can plan, that may help with negotiations with the process, let's say, okay, look, can you give us a couple of years? We could have something really, really. If it goes into escrow, it's gone. I understand. I mean, it's not going to wait around two years. I understand. We have no leverage.

58:57 With the owner of the properties. So, you know, it's maybe six months. These may be hard truths, but it's better to know them. That's what I'm saying. Exactly. So I'm going to turn to my board. Anything we're missing on as a council at this point? What the direction they've given us? Comments? I think the last comments are the critical ones.

59:25 about being really focused in on doable projects. And I feel like that's another thing that has maybe been missing from the recipe over time, but there hasn't been this crystallized focus and, frankly, leadership behind it so that when you do go to fundraising, when you do go to executing, it's just kind of a vague moving target. I think that's something we need to carry through our final recommendations to the council. If I just add it, sorry to interrupt, but that goes to us as council.

59:53 Because if we're setting them up to go out there and do these things and they're putting things in place, we all need to be able to have done our work to say, we're committed, it's going to happen, we're going to have your back. Because you go out there to leverage money and get money for folks. We're representing Mammoth Lakes. Exactly. And we just have to make, we've got their back to do this stuff. Well, if we're doing it in the context of...

1:00:17 The top tiers, we've gone through the filter, criteria's been put in place, that these things are being constructed, built, programmed, no matter who's driving it, no matter who's at the table, who's got the interest in it, that it becomes such a priority, it's on that list, it was put on there for a reason, and so we're going to pursue it.

1:00:38 Because it met all of these requirements, and it doesn't matter who's in the chair, that is going to continue. The project will be completed, the programming will be in place, and it's something that becomes, you know, threaded through the fabric of the community. It becomes a piece of the community, and it's not just because somebody, one person was into it. We want this to become sustainable for the entire community, and that it will

1:01:05 Succeed because everybody is behind it, not just individuals. One would be in the prioritization of the items here, and I like a lot of the comments in May too, but also kind of breaking a little about with their primary measure R, measure U.

1:01:32 That helps us in terms of the funding structure and how we look at those. And there are different restrictions. So that would help in terms of how money that you're really focusing on the product to come out of in terms of part of that process. Then the other thing, when you look at the discussion on kind of completion of things, meaning that's looking at our existing parks, and Betsy's in the audience, and Terry's here from the rec commission. They've done a lot of work in some areas, I think, and I think on trails in parks.

1:01:59 For X dollars, if you go complete that, it's not a heart, and it's something that they would fall off, and your plate is having to really work through that, and you hand it off, this is back to the partnerships, great, can I hand it to the Red Commission and say, here, complete that part, you kind of know where it's, what the elements are. Again, that should move up an overall priority strategy, but if it's there, then just kind of handing that to the partner and going, go complete this for us so it's off our, I mean, it's kind of like the town looking at some stuff going.

1:02:27 Good, Rich, here you go. Have fun. We only do some of those things. But I think there's a couple of elements that we have some of the partnerships in place already that you could hand off. It's an easy win, and it's really building off a lot of work that's been done for multiple years, I think, in landing some of these pieces together. It'd be nice to see, boom, done, dot the I, cross the T, that one's out of the way, low dollar, high visibility, what's the next one? And then that gets into that.

1:02:56 Priority process, I think, a little bit, and kind of readiness in the other discussions. And I think the other side, and I forget who mentioned it here, but as you look at the facilities to leverage with one another, the multi-use in the center, we can leverage some stuff together, and how do we help do that? Again, that might be asked, but I think that's something we can reach through as well as, again, looking at some costs. If you're not on your own, I guess, doing some of that, I would really encourage that cross-pollination of that information that's there. A lot of the documents you've had already.

1:03:42 I think there's some very short-term real wins that can happen until next year. It gets exciting about that, as well as the long-term projects that take a lot more. Do you have any thoughts about this awareness question based on... Yeah, yeah. And I think a lot of the communication elements on that is we've looked at internally, we've been looking at some different... And trying to use those core staff members like that that come in, talk, and let that go back out. Trying to get every body in the room is problematic. Do you anticipate that in appropriate times...

1:04:37 Members of your staff will be involved in meetings, will be expected to be participating in conferences as relatives. Absolutely. Any public comment? Additional public comment? I haven't addressed all you people. Just start talking. Perfect. All right. How do you rank when it says like three out of nine? What's the nine? What's the one? There is no one, actually. So, I mean, is it like we have nine projects and this is three out of nine? Is the number one out of nine?

1:05:29 Is number nine highest priority? Number three high? I mean, how does that work? It's not prioritized. I don't, they're not, they're not in the hierarchy. It's not in the hierarchy. It's just, yeah, this is essentially just getting all the projects, viable projects, and then as, as Joe mentioned, we would go out to one more public hearing to make sure that this kind of master this.

1:05:55 So it's not like 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9? No, at this point there's no ranking. Right. Because it's his ranking. That would be kind of the next phase. That would be the next phase. When it comes back to us, yeah. I was just curious. Because my little pet project doesn't have a number. Also, I mean, I don't know if this is a place to talk about the possibility of getting the shade on. I know when my guys mentioned it the other day, it was like,

1:06:23 Bringing it to the mid-October meeting. I know it's been a drought and stuff, but it does snow here, and it may snow sooner than later. I know in 2004 we had 80 inches of snow in October, and if we have another 80 inch in October, it won't go up. I can guarantee you that. I just wonder if we can speed that process along somehow, or figure something out to appease the masses. Because I think waiting until October is way too late, because it's going to get cold.

1:06:53 You know, concrete doesn't pour very well in the cold, right? With that asphalt. See, I'm not that, you know, I don't know. Either way. Even if that's not related to the strategy, maybe Dan can give you an update on what's happening with all of that. Yeah, I mean, the group has been meeting, a smaller group, and working through that whole issue in terms of timing for the multi-use facility relocation work and the interim shade component.

1:07:18 It's going quite well. We've actually reviewed a number of different types of potential shade structures, some of those which community members have brought forward. We're right now trying to do a cost estimate looking at the preferred option which takes off probably the Breckenridge model to say what does that begin to look like. We anticipate to have that information within the next week or so to be able to take a hard look at that and the timing just going to council with the process to work through that.

1:07:47 Just from a flat-out timing and agenda process would probably be that October 7th meeting just to have the right data available to do a good presentation for understanding. And that's just, I hate to say, that just kind of the way that lines up in terms of the dates that hit that. We also don't want to do a knee-jerk come and go, hey, let's go do this for X, and then all of a sudden it's back. Nope, nope, we missed something. So we want to make sure we have good data, good information. The timing is very critical on the weather side.

1:08:16 The other, frankly, has it been a thought process, again, depending on cost, if we're doing this for one season versus two, or is it then just a little bit of cost-benefit analysis until we kind of know what that is. It's hard to guess. Okay, well, I know there's hockey tournaments being planned for February. That will not happen if we don't have to share it. Yeah, I understand the concerns there that are driving, and I'd say everybody involved in the process, that's been a high point of discussion. Number one of nine.

1:08:46 Thanks. Anybody else? Okay, seeing none, we will adjourn to our 6 o'clock meeting.

1:09:56 Yeah. Wait for John.

1:10:44 We're missing the Councilmember. What? Starbucks. Is that? Starbucks. Yeah, probably. No way. That's awesome. That's once-in-a-lifetime experience. Glad you can join us.

1:11:52 Good evening, everybody. Thanks for coming. I will now call our meeting to order of the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes. We're meeting for Wednesday, September 2, 2015 at 6.01 p.m. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I've asked Councilmember Ferney to lead us in the pledge this evening. Thank you. If everybody could please stand and follow after me. United States of America.

1:12:36 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Colin. Now I'll open up public comments for any items that are not on our agenda tonight. Please come forward. Okay, see you none. Are there any additions to the agenda? Okay, I'll move on to Councilmember Reports. John, can I start with you? Yes, thank you very much, Mr. Mayor.

1:13:11 I've attended two meetings of the multi-use facility meeting with representatives of MLR, Recreation Commission, Town Staff. They've been very useful and productive. I attended on August 21st the California Public Utilities Commission meeting regarding the Verizon and Frontier Communications merger, which is very interesting and a lot of real implications for our region, especially from a public safety perspective.

1:13:35 I've attended, along with all of us, two meetings of this Town Council NGO goal setting and strategic alignment process. And Jamie, just a question to you. Those meetings, the full meetings are available in Granicus, is that correct? I really encourage the public to check in on those things if you get a second because they're very interesting. We're doing some very interesting work, I think. The summer stewardship event in Horseshoe Lake, August 29th, which was very interesting. Councilmember Bacon was there and did a great job with that.

1:14:03 And September 10th is a future item that Town Council and NGOs are doing their goal setting and other strategic alignment session. I'd also like to request my fellow council members' consideration of just moving a couple items around on the agenda for this evening. And I'm wondering, I'm very impressed by the work that the staff has done with the identification of the best practices for the single family rental item. And I think that this is the kind of information the community has been waiting for for many, many months.

1:14:31 And I think it would be very useful to the community to maybe take on that item first as a framing piece that gives the community a context over how we're going to be discussing the quality of life ordinance. And I'm wondering if there's any consensus just to flip those two. I'd prefer to leave them as they are, but I'm just one of five. Sure. What's the pleasure, Council? I'm fine either way. But I think that you mean doing it because the ordinance is on consent.

1:15:05 No, I'm sorry. It's policy as well. Let's talk about 13 and 14. 13 and 14. I don't know. I don't have a strong preference either way. I think whatever's the pleasure of the rest of the council. Yeah, because, you know, on the quality of life ordinance, we discussed it at length last meeting, and all we're doing is looking at the items that we didn't want to wordsmith.

1:15:43 Yeah, I'm just, I'm not sure, given Measure Z and the community's interest in those types of topics, if a lot of people may be showing up for that item first, and I think that the item that's the most valuable to the community from an information perspective, I think, is that best practices piece. And I think that it's a nice, it's a good opportunity to frame to the community the kinds of breadth of the issue that we're talking about.

1:16:08 And all the steps that Council is taking to involve in that issue, I just think it may be a better thing to do that first, kind of frame where we're coming from, and then move on to the second reading of the ordinance, which may not take very much time. I just want to make sure we're being cognizant of not throwing anybody off as far as their scheduling. Okay. Do you like to leave it as is?

1:16:31 I don't have a strong preference either way. I don't know that it makes a huge difference as far as the time frame. I just want to make sure. I just wanted to bring that up. I think it's important. I appreciate it. Sure. Okay. So we'll leave it up for the agenda. Okay. Thank you. Anything else, Joe? No. Thank you. Thanks. Colin? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just a couple items for me. A lot of them are overlapping with other council members, but I also have been attending the weekly multi-use facility meetings. I think good progress is being made by that group on both, you know, long-term.

1:16:59 Citing for that facility and temporary shade structure due diligence. So I think we have some more updates coming towards us soon. I also attended our goal setting session on Thursday, August 27th. It was good to have a check-in, see where we're at as far as achieving the 18-month strategies. And I was pleasantly surprised to see the number of things that have been

1:17:27 Checked off and a number of things that are well on their way to being completed. So that was encouraging. Also thought that our Council and NGO Strategy Alignment meeting on the 31st is just a critical piece for us moving forward. So I'm really encouraged by those discussions. I think a lot of good things coming out of that. Also on the 31st attended our monthly MLR meeting, mostly in preparation for the meeting tonight, which I thought was very productive.

1:17:57 On more of a personal fun note, I did travel up to Lake Tahoe the weekend of August 22nd for a regional hockey tournament with all the Mammoth Hockey Boys. So that was a great time had by all, but also it's good for us to get up and see other facilities and how that functions for those communities. So it's certainly something that I'm excited to work towards for our community.

1:18:24 And then I traditionally try not to be outdone as far as peer resort touring on an annual year, so I'm taking off on another personal peer resort tour, which is both business and personal. I'm heading to Colorado on the 13th, so I will be missing our next meeting. I'm going to be in Aspen for our annual black tie retreat, also going to Crested Butte for a few days and then into Denver. So, again, on my own dime.

1:18:54 Get a little feedback when I return. Thanks. Great. Thank you. Jo? Well, I'm not having any kind of a tour planned recently, but everything else that John and Colin said were things I was involved in, so I'll just mention that on Friday the MLR Reconciliation Committee will meet again, and we hope to be able to finalize everything so it can come forward as an agenda bill and close out those programs sometime later this month. Thank you. Great. Thank you.

1:19:23 No, that's it. Thank you. Not much to add. Went to the same meetings as pretty much everybody else as far as the goal setting and NGO alignment meetings. I think they're very productive. It just shows that when our groups get together that we can work together. So there should be some real positives coming out of the future meetings. Thank you. I as well was at the same two meetings.

1:19:54 I think 16 hours it was? Yeah. And lunch, thanks to Dan. I also attended our monthly ESTA meeting. Just a few numbers to report from ESTA for July. We had a pretty impressive ridership increase year over year. Our trolley was up 25 percent, town trolley. The Lakes Basin trolley was up 10 percent. Overall, total ridership was up 12 percent, so it was a

1:20:21 Big increase. The town trolley is – the thought behind that is the late night addition and events. So there's a lot of ridership and, of course, the basin did very well. That's all I have to add. And we'll move on to reports from commissions and or departments. Mr. Mayor, I'll kick off for departments as others move forward there. I want to give just a quick report. It's a positive element. It came out yesterday and today, actually.

1:20:53 As you're aware, we were working with the Sherwin Creek Road Project. We awarded that bid and started that. As that project was being developed, I had the idea that, hey, is there any way to leverage that project with the Forest Service for part of an amenity out by the propane tanks to add some parking? A lot of people utilize that in the summer as well as in the winter for staging areas into the Sherwins. We had three things that had to happen to make that work. One would be getting our project done and bid out.

1:21:21 Secondly, was getting a United States Forest Service permit through the Inyo National Forest to allow us to expand that parking in that area and actually pave it. And then actually getting the work done. And so happy to report, one, the construction work is underway. If you go out there now, you'll see the road work being done. Secondly, we just got a notice that they approved the permit element with the Forest Service. So very quick process on that. And I want to note a couple things out of the permit that I thought were very positive for us.

1:21:51 Same thing as we're looking at it. We looked at the elements of enhanced public access. We looked at the element that sites are already being used for parking. This will actually help mitigate dust and storm runoff in the area. And the other side of that was the Forest Service was able to move quickly because of those elements, the fact that it's a small area. And they referenced in that particularly that this project was in keeping with the

1:22:19 I'm just going to read this here. In keeping with the Sherwin Area Recreation Plan that was developed by the Sherwin Working Group in 2010, so utilizing the work of the community, coming back to the town process, we've got a few years in between that work, but we're actually going to see the first, I'll say, enhanced amenity coming into the Sherwin's area, hopefully in the next couple of months or better, or earlier in terms of about a 50-space parking area, give or take, kind of where the pavement ends there.

1:22:46 And then we'll work with them on an operations plan in terms of snow and managing trash in restroom facilities as normally as people utilize those facilities. But we're very pleased that Forest Service is very responsive to our request. They moved fairly quickly to give us use permits so we can actually, if it doesn't snow next week, we'll be able to hopefully have that project in this fall. So we're very excited to see that happen and getting the partnership coming together and building off of the community's work that...

1:23:13 What's done back in 2010 has been continuing through that process. So that was great to see and hear. Thanks. Great. Thanks, Dan. Thank you, Dan. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. I just wanted to mention that the commission meets on Tuesday morning, September 8th, here in Suite Z at 9 a.m., and we will just have a verbal update out of our multi-use facility working group.

1:23:40 That Colin and John mentioned. And I also just wanted to add that Commissioner Bill Sauser is at home and he's doing well. He's making a recovery from bypass surgery. So he's doing well. We expect to see him out and about in a couple more weeks. Sounded my best. Thank you. Thanks. Evening, Chair, Council Members, Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. Just a brief update on the opportunities and excitement happening in the Parks and Recreation Department. Summer camp's wrapped up for the season.

1:24:13 We're just doing all the analysis now, but looks like they were very successful. Our mini-programs were full. In youth theatre, we had over, actually just under about 40 campus participating in that youth theatre program, which was great. That was Grease and Cinderella recently, if you saw that one. The rec zone is still open and is programmed through September. We have drop-in street hockey running over there.

1:24:34 The Whitmore Pool closes this Friday, so that's the last opportunity for lap swim at 6 o'clock. Events this weekend include the Labor Day Arts Festival at Sam's Woodside. Staff's engaged in setting up that event as well. Rock and Rise in the village and the Mammoth Rock Race begins on Monday, I believe, from Mammoth Creek Park.

1:24:55 The next major event coming up is the Mammoth 4th Century in Gran Fondo. The town's heavily involved in that event. As you know, we'll essentially be closing off Canyon Boulevard that'll run down Main Street. They'll hope to have about 1,200 riders in that event. So that's a big event. Also Mammoth 12th, sorry, also September 12th, is opening day of the Mammoth A-Worso Soccer Season, and that's our biggest youth sporting group. Over 600 players utilize both Shady Rest and Whitmore.

1:25:25 So that begins on September 12th, runs for about two months. So staff are heavily engaged in supporting those activities as well. And that's all I have. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Welcome back. Thank you. We got to hear about the good snow that he got for the last two weeks, by the way, so I wanted to report that. One thing Dan mentioned about Old Mammoth Road, we are working on that. In fact, we expect to finish striping it this Friday before the Labor Day weekend, as anticipated, so that's gone well.

1:25:56 I reported last meeting the elementary school project was complete. The drop-off has actually worked, for most people's opinion, very well for drop-off in the morning. It's always chaotic. They go through a learning process. They add cones. They take them away. They have lots of people out there. But overall, we understand the improvements are working really well, and it's just a matter of managing parents dropping off their students. SCE will be working in the community for the next month, starting September 8th.

1:26:24 I don't have specific details as to addresses, but mostly in residential areas, they'll have a program whereby they'll be testing some of the cables. A lot of the cables in the community are 40 years old or so. This is something they're doing to invest in the community so that we don't have breakages and things like that during the tougher winter months when we start to.

1:26:45 It will cause real damage. They will begin on September 8th and work through October 1st. They are notifying each and every one of their customers, and we'll do what we can to get the word out as specifically as we can as it moves forward. Town staff has finished their striping work, and basically the yard's getting ready for winter, bringing all the equipment in, making sure we're greased up, ready to go. We've sent rehire letters out to four of the seasonal workers that are coming back for certain and looking for two or three more to fill the rest of the spots.

1:27:15 The last comment I want to make, and it's something we'll put behind us next time, but ESCOG will be here, of course. The reason I mention it is that last ESCOG meeting we actually met at Bishop Airport and a brief discussion there before moving on to Bishop Council Chambers. This time we're going to start with a tour at Mammoth Airport on September 11th in the morning, run through there for half an hour, 45 minutes before we come back here. So we're glad to have that whole group back here in town, take a look at what we're doing, hear our story, and then...

1:27:44 They'll be back here. Thank you. Quick question. I was very interested in the SCE work, and I think the Broadband Task Force, we're going to be talking about that a little bit tomorrow, but I would encourage you to keep, I know you will, but keep your eyes on that in terms of our, you know, last mile connectors and medium mile connectors. There may be a lot of opportunities if we have to start digging up a lot of trenches for some bad old cables. Let's just keep our eyes on that for last mile connectivity.

1:28:14 Can you give us an update on the Main Street Undergrounding SCE project? Yes. They still expect to finish all the undergrounding, meaning, excuse me, the trenching and laying of the conduit this year. You know, they started down near the gas station at Mountain Boulevard. They're heading up to the west. John Lum, their representative, stated that it's going very well. I also think so in terms of traffic control. You know, it's a SCE Caltrans project.

1:28:38 So we're kind of staying out of the way. But I think they're doing well in terms of the traffic control. But it's moving along as they expect it to. They still expect to do all the trenching and conduit lane this season. Next season they'll come back, pull the wires, take down the transformers, take those out, and then take down the poles themselves. That's in the spring? That's correct, yes. So it's a two-stage, but I think it's going well. It's going on the schedule they expected. Great. Thank you.

1:29:08 Jo, would you like to make an answer? Yes. I'd just like to take a minute to recognize Gordon Alper, who passed away recently. He was a very active member of our community. Not only did he serve as a council member and on the airport commission, but he was also involved in the general plan update that we all talk about that went from about 2003 to 2007 and still stayed active in the community, so it will be a great loss to us. Thank you for that.

1:29:37 Okay, we will move on to introductions. Item number four, introduce executive assistant to the police chief. Chief Hannah Degoe. Did I pronounce that right? Did I say that right? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council members, and

1:29:59 Sheriff Braun, thank you for showing up. Tonight's a great night for Mammoth Lakes Police Department and the town. I get the honor, the privilege to introduce the new executive assistant to the police chief for the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Ms. Hannah DeGoy. Right? Thank you. I was close. I was close. A little bit about Hannah. She's originally from Virginia. She was raised there and then attended George Washington University where she was studying international security and conflict resolution.

1:30:28 So I think we'll be able to utilize some of that within the police department somehow. She also served as a congressional intern for the House Committee on Foreign Affairs. About six years ago, Hannah moved to Mammoth area and began working for the Mammoth Mountain ski area. She had several jobs up there. Most recently, since we stole her, she was the Black Diamond manager for the Black Pass program up there. And so here she is living in Mammoth. She enjoys skiing, motocross, and running.

1:30:57 So, Hannah DeGoy, and welcome aboard. We appreciate you being here and look forward to some exciting times. She's really nervous about talking, but I'm going to make her say something. Thank you for the introduction and a warm welcome. I'm very happy to be here and excited to get to know a different part of the town outside the mountain. Great. Welcome. Thank you. There's no swearing in for Hannah, but she promises to do a good job. Good stuff.

1:31:45 Our next item will be an administrative oath of the office and introduce police officer Grant Zimmel. So this is Grant Zimmel, the newest police officer for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Police Department. Grant comes to us from Beaumont Police Department. He was reserved for us about a year ago and has been trying to get up here for quite some time, so fortunately an opportunity came up and we were able to scoop him up.

1:32:14 Grant was raised in San Bernardino County. He was also a Marine and later a Military Reserve Police Officer. He became a police officer at the Colton Police Department in 1998, then later moved on to Beaumont Police Department in 2007. He's got a pretty varied background in law enforcement. He's been a motor officer, explorer advisor, field evidence technician, field training officer, honor guard member, detective, weapons armor, range master, gang task force officer. Anything else?

1:32:43 He's got a lot of stuff, so he brings a lot to us. He's also received several awards for MAD, Mothers Against Drunk Driving, for arrests and things he's done with that, as well as his forensic work when it comes to fingerprints. So with that, and he's here with his family, but I'll let him introduce them later. With that, we'll have him step on out and take the oath of office from the town clerk. And if his wife would step up, she'll be doing the pinning.

1:33:19 Thank you.

1:33:34 No blood.

1:34:15 Thank you for that warm welcome as well. This is a new adventure for me and my family up here. You know, we came up here and I fell in love with this place and I just had to work here. You know, like the Chief said, I started up as a reserve and I was hoping for that full-time position which finally opened up and patience paid off.

1:34:55 And we appreciate everybody welcoming us up here. Thank you very much. And with the addition of grant, we are now full staffing, so we're excited. Great. Congratulations. This is my wife, Vanessa. Hi, Vanessa.

1:35:36 Welcome. Do we need to recognize Jamie for memorizing that? No, she was reading. I didn't see much looking down. I was pretty impressed. Thanks, Chief. Thank you. Okay, we'll move on to our consent agenda. Are there any members of the council, staff, or public that wish to pull any items? Mr. Mayor, I would like to pull number eight. Okay, and I will pull number six.

1:36:18 So I'll entertain a motion for items 5, 7, and 9, please. Mr. Mayor, I'd be happy to make a motion to approve consent agenda items 5, 7, and 9. Okay. I have a first. Is there a second? Second. I have a first and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. I pulled item 6. I would like Dan to give us an update on...

1:36:47 The adopted resolution updating the compensation schedules for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. If you can please give a council and the public an update on that. Yes, I can walk through the item before you. The current memorandum of understanding with our employee associations had provided parameters for a cost of living adjustment, referred to as a COLA. It was tied to two different elements. One was that based on projections made through

1:37:14 The TOT component on a five-year projection plan and a restructuring plan of the town, that if those TOT revenues increased by more than 5% over top the projections, which would have meant $11,223,000, that there would be a COLA eligibility. We've come in close to $11,280,000 plus, and so we've hit that threshold. Once that threshold was reached, the question was then,

1:37:41 Based on CPI, there would be a COLA of a minimum of a 1.5%, maximum of 3.5%. CPI was actually running just below 1%, and so it's that minimum level. In order to implement that, we take the current pay scales, and there's an adjustment of the pay scale itself. The whole pay scale moves up that 1.5%, and each step in the pay scale moves up. And so in order to utilize that for implementation and for

1:38:11 This is information that's also filed with PERS and those types of elements. So they ask that it be adopted by the governing body for implementation, which it's before you for that purpose. Walk through one quick example, too, just a lot of numbers attached to your staff report. So the first one deals with our General Employees Association. This would be true through all of the bargaining units.

1:38:36 Each pay grade in here, you'll say something like a G113 or G140, all of those are pay ranges. Generally, they're 1% apart as they go up, and then each step increases by 5% across to the top. Now, depending on the association, some have five steps, some are seven, some are, I think, eight or six in the different elements, depending on what was put in place several years ago, frankly, for the pay scales.

1:39:03 And so the ranges become, if you're at the top of that range, the only adjustment you get is that COLA adjustment. You move along with it, each one goes. If you're somewhere in the bottom portion of that range, you would have that COLA adjustment. And then when your evaluation is due, you would go through an annual evaluation, a process looking for that. And if you meet standards and elements, then you would move up from a step C to a step D on a merit base through the program.

1:39:32 So the COLA applies to everybody in terms of that. Merits only apply to those who have eligibility. About 70% of our employees are at that top range, so often that push on the COLA and that discussion falls into that's how everybody benefits some growth in salary-based versus merit, which is based on do you have room to move within the pay range. Both the COLA and eligible merits were built into the budget.

1:39:58 So this isn't adding any additional stress, if you will, on our financial position of the budget. These were anticipated. We knew that could happen in the budget discussion. There was a question of whether or not the COLA would be met. And if you go back to mid-year, last December, January, it looked like there was no way we would get there. We actually did a budget reduction from 11.6 in TOT down to about 11.2, a little over. And the fact that we came in just under 11.3, I think, speaks highly to this tail end of some...

1:40:27 Great work in terms of the activity in the community in the latter part of the fiscal year. And so they're all treated the same through that in terms of all the bargaining units. The other element that's in here ties to our part-time employees who aren't represented. The main change there was starting kind of at the bottom with the minimum wage law going to $10 per hour in January. We kind of started that as a base and then worked up on some of those other salary elements to keep it competitive in terms for that.

1:40:55 We're also seeing ongoing competitiveness for part-time employees. It's large in the community, if some of you know, in terms of that piece for that. And so in order to be competitive and attract folks and to meet, not have to be back in January to have another amendment related to the change in state minimum law wages, $10 an hour, we built that into the part-time scale. And so with that, I mean, we've done the adjustments for each of the bargaining groups.

1:41:23 The other element that we do that's not so much a council decision on this but staff management is we take each of our classifications. So I take our planning manager, for example, and plug that position into the pay grade at which that classification drops into. And through that process, often we'll walk through and, for example, you take a look at that. This isn't a salary issue, but in that case, in some cases, we'll look at do we have a name change, do we have an updated job description.

1:41:51 Salary is the same, but for example, for Sandra, as long as she's sitting next to me here, actually looking at that to be modifying that to, you know, planning economic development manager versus just planning manager because of those scopes of duties that are currently in her job description that she's already doing. So there's no salary impact, but I think it's more reflective of the work being done. We've done that in a couple different areas with some of the title changes to reflect.

1:42:15 More of what the employees are actually doing. That's an ongoing process that we review and place people into those elements. The item before you really is focused on the new salary ranges per the MOU agreements and then for the part-time employees. And we'd be glad to answer any particular questions. Thanks for that, Dan. Any questions for Council? I have two quick questions. The first, if you could perhaps translate the very eloquent explanation of what this is into layman's terms.

1:42:44 It sounds like a certain threshold was met and therefore. Yeah. Basically we have an agreement with employees that says if this threshold gets met for TOT revenue, they will receive a cost of living adjustment and we are implementing that cost of living adjustment. Okay, good. Thank you. Second question is this wonderful attachment that's in our item here and I pride myself on being a real kind of excel. I can.

1:43:11 Rick itself at a third grade level. I'm hoping our new finance system may address documents like this that, I mean, you can't, you know, I can't make any sense of this. I'm assuming you can, but I'm hoping that this kind of documentation coming forward, that they will have, you know, narrative aspects to it so people can make sense of it. I think what will happen to these, like the paid, because these are paid codes, grades, and just hourly rates.

1:43:38 Actually, they get uploaded from Excel into our payroll system. Right. And then the employee is tied to that particular pay range, and so it works that process. It doesn't have to be any more elaborate than that in terms of pay plan, than that for our purposes. But the system will lead it. It will reduce a lot of manual input. Okay. Okay, good. Thank you. Colin? I just have a couple of practical questions for you.

1:44:01 The cost of living adjustment is retroactive back to July 1st based on the MOU, correct? That is correct. Okay. So that will just show up on subsequent paychecks for employees in the form of? Yeah, it will be a retro payment that will be calculated based on that date. Is it a one-time? One-time. Okay. And then the new pay scale will go forward. Okay. Now, I would assume that that retroactive back to July 1st just applies to the COLA and for full-time employees, correct?

1:44:31 We are also making some adjustments to the pay scales for part-time employees. Is that just moving forward? Yeah, that would be – right now, it sets those new pay scales in Sarasota. So as we're bringing – we're actually in that transition between our summer and winter employees. Right. So the renew people on, they would come into that new pay scale, but it's not an automatic – you get a retroaction for the whole of your – Sure. And so that would be effective as of –

1:44:58 Tomorrow as far as part-time employees? Yeah, it'd be a new plan and I think we verted it to where it would end up impacting those as they'll complete their, we have a couple people like a week they'll be done. Okay. We're not going to retro that back. It would be going prospectively. Okay. And so this basically addresses the January minimum wage increase in advance. So anybody that's transitioning now into a winner position would start at the new pay scale.

1:45:23 Yeah, and the pay sales are a different level there, but the bottom one has that minimum amount of $10 an hour. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Any questions from the public on this item? Okay, seeing none, I'll bring you back for a motion. Well, to make it easy, I'll just move we adopt the motion as written. Okay, I'll second. Thank you. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0.

1:45:57 Next item is number eight that was pulled by Councilmember Bacon. Yes, I pulled this just because I felt that it needed to not necessarily be hidden on consent since it is a response to the grand jury, which has been somewhat of an issue in the past. So I would just ask staff to give a quick overview of what the issues were and the responses. Thank you, Madam Mayor.

1:46:22 Previous, Madam Mayor. Old habits die hard. Excuse me, Michael. Hair's growing out. This item in the grand jury's report was

1:46:39 Generated by the grand jury, it wasn't the result of a complaint, so I think that's a positive element, but as the grand jury has the option to look at various services and how we provide them, that's one of their charges, and so they took a look at part of our animal control processes, and we're looking at the levels of service, how it's managed between the town and the county, and worked through a couple different findings in there looking at just the changes that's happened since the town's incorporated.

1:47:08 Non-automated system in our animal control side. Currently the town really does not have an animal control officer to speak of in terms of licenses and dogs and kind of the focus of this. We do have a wildlife management, I don't know if Steve's still in the room or not, who does help in some of these areas but more focused on bears and other wild animals versus domesticated.

1:47:35 A question came up in terms of how we manage that, and this is one of the services that's been reduced in the town that we do not currently do. We do not anticipate purchasing or moving forward the new record system just to track the animal control components. It is tracked in our CAD system or REMS as something comes into the police department if it's called through that, so it would be like other information that we track in that system.

1:48:02 If somebody walks in the door and there's a complaint that doesn't go to that level, then that would not be in the system. It's not an automatic input. So some of it's paper records. Some of the requests in terms of looking at things different, be able to pull that past comparative data, frankly, is an extremely low priority for the town in terms of a service standard. I don't think it buys us a lot of benefit in terms of how we manage animal control efforts.

1:48:26 It does look at the issues regarding in Title VI of Muni Code that addresses animal control, and that's something we can look at. If need be, we could actually change the code to reflect our current service levels, which would be something we could be willing to do that. The other question was taking a look at continuing to work with the county for animal control. We've talked to them, and if we're willing to propose into an agreement, a contractual arrangement, they would provide additional animal control services.

1:48:55 At this point, I would not suggest that's a service level that is a priority for funding. If we had that type of funding available, we'd much rather see it go into other police services first before it went into animal control services where we kind of have a dual service component there as a priority. We also have talked to the county regarding common software between the two of us.

1:49:19 It's manual and mainly managed by the person in charge who a lot of I think is mentally carried around versus in a computer if I can put it that way. And so at this point we're not looking at any changes that way. If they went to a system we'd probably take a look at or vice versa. But at this point none of us really have that as a priority expenditure for resources.

1:49:43 We agree with a couple of the findings, either in whole or in part, but also as a service level standard. There's no recommendations that we agree with to move forward to enhance that level of service. Okay. Any questions? Just one observation. I know that there is a significant discrepancy between the regulatory framework of the Forest Service regulations relative to domestic animals and, like, the town and the county. I'm a little surprised that that issue didn't come up in this, but it would be a significant...

1:50:14 thing if we could reconcile what the Forest Service standards are and what the town standards are and then advertise it to people so there's one kind of consistent standard of what the expectations are for animals and pets. But that's sort of as a... I'm not prepared to give the precise details on it, but they're not the same. So the town stuff is different than the Forest Service stuff. And so when Horseshoe Lake...

1:50:37 There's a lot of dogs up there. I know the Sherwin's Working Group talked about establishing a dog park area for the wintertime out on Sherwin Creek Road. So there's some things that are in play to kind of address this kind of stuff, but that – does that make sense? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Thanks, John. Anybody else? Any public comment? Okay. Seeing none, I'll bring it back to the council. Okay. I move that we accept the draft.

1:51:03 Response to Case Number 03 and for staff to finalize it and submit it. Okay. Second. Motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jen. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. So we're going to move on. Our next item is our public hearings. Item Number 10, waive the first reading introduced by title only, the Quality of Life Ordinance.

1:51:31 Adding Chapter 5.40 and amending Section 5.04.055 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code. Continuing from the August 19, 2015 meeting, I'll open up the public hearing and take a presentation for staff. Thank you.

1:51:47 As you stated, this item was continued from your last meeting. At that meeting, Town Council directed staff to bring back updated occupancy requirements. The Town Council directed staff to bring back occupancy requirements of two persons per bedroom plus two. The Council also requested that language be included to indicate that for the purposes of transient occupancy, loft should be considered a bedroom.

1:52:10 And finally, the Council directed that the occupancy requirements should include language to allow the Community and Economic Development Director to approve greater occupancy for certain situations. Staff included all of that information in the ordinance, and we have the information included in your staff report as well. And I think that completes all of the items that the Council directed of staff, and I'm...

1:52:36 Available for any questions that you have on these items. Thank you. Any questions? Just a quick one. Is in other sections where we've designated someone to make a decision, we have said or designee, and this isn't in here. Is it... We can include that. Not need... I was just thinking that. So if it said C, you know, Community Development Director, which we don't have with the person. Right.

1:52:58 Or designee, would we be consistent with what we've done in the past? I think we haven't been consistent. In both ways? Okay. And if we have both, then no reason to change it. Okay. Any other questions? No. Yeah. Condo and all other types of units. I noticed here that there wasn't a maxima occupancy. Should we have one?

1:53:25 The council can consider one. I'm just saying it should match maybe the – Yeah, the building code doesn't have a maximum occupancy for those types of uses, which is why we didn't include it. They do have – the building code does have a maximum occupancy for single-family homes, townhomes, and duplexes, which is why they're split out. The council can be more restrictive than the building code. Are you thinking about just mirroring it? Yeah, I was thinking about mirroring it, but, you know, I'm trying to think of a situation where there would actually be more than 10 people in a condo.

1:53:58 Well, I think when we were discussing, we were just saying it was so easy to say you've got X number of rooms and therefore, you know, but some of our single family homes may have more than five bedrooms. Well, I see a single family home. I'm talking about a condo, though. Yeah, no, but on the condo side, I think that if it's two per room, I can't think of a single condo we have that's even. I mean, Stonegate is considered a condo. Yeah, but how many does it sleep? I don't know. A lot.

1:54:26 Mostly four bedrooms. Not so much the size of the building itself, but it would tie to the bedroom count and then two additional. So you could have a very large building with two bedrooms so they would have six people. Or you could have five bedrooms. You could have five. In that case, the question is do you want the ten limit or are you okay with just the mathematical limit for countries? I'm pointing it out. Good. We can discuss when we read about it. All right. Sounds good. Unless there's – I'm good either way. I just wanted to point it out. Yeah, no. I appreciate it.

1:54:56 Any other questions? Any public matter? Any public comment on this matter? I probably should have brought this up earlier, so I apologize for that. The lofts, you were considering those as one bedroom, where there are lofts which have the proper egress, have bunk beds or twin beds that sleep more than just two people. And so it kind of goes with your tent.

1:55:32 Know that we have been renting those in this entire town with more than just two people in a loft. And that's been approved by the fire department. It's been approved with licenses. And so it's kind of problematic as to the verbiage in there as far as a loft goes. Well, I'm wondering if the same point that was brought up about bedroom count, is there something in the code that says a loft has a count associated with it?

1:55:59 It would just be two again. And that's for the total counting. So if you have a loft in the bedroom, that's two, four plus two more would be six people. Yeah. So, you know, you have, you do. We can do a bed count. Speak to the California building code, egress code, but, you know, I don't know because it definitely would reduce a lot of the occupancy in some of the condos and the majority of the condos that are loft units in this town.

1:56:27 In terms of the, I'm sorry, are there often more than 10 people? Not more than 10. And so that, we're still that total number because it's two for two for two, so you'd add it up. It's not that you can. Actually, there could be more than 10. There are some pretty big condos. There's, I think you have, you probably have Talish, you have, what's the one over by CF Star over there? You mean Stonegate? Timbers. Timbers. Timbers, Stonegate, you have bridges.

1:56:54 There are a few that would probably take more than 10 people. Yeah, so the question here currently, if I may, is we don't cap condos at 10, but we have the same math going on. So if it's a three-bedroom, it'd be two, four, six, and two would be eight people. If it's a four-bedroom, obviously it'd be 10, and on up. We didn't try to make it account to the number of beds. Okay. Yeah, but there's an out. You know, you say unless the unit is approved by the Town of Mammoth Lakes Community and Economic Development.

1:57:22 Director for such occupancy. So, I mean, it could, if it's okay. And we could add that language, but I want to make sure it applies to condos as well as others. Since there's no cap on condos, if we, if. I mean, if you put a cap on condos, you put that language. Then we should add that language, yes. Right, exactly. Cap it, we want the language. I think it kind of goes back to your parking and your, you know, condos are going to have their policies within themselves as well, CC&Rs.

1:57:48 Yeah, I think Terry's point's valid that we don't want to be more restrictive than the building code, but I think because there's no restriction on condos, we don't have an issue here. We're saying it can be more than 10, but it's still that mathematical where if you actually have enough beds to put 20 people in there, but you only have four bedrooms, we're saying you still only can go to 10. But there is a built-in scenario where we can come before the community.

1:58:19 Development Director and say, we think this particular condo, because of the loft situation and the egress, warrants higher occupancy and that can be approved, correct? If you want to add that one. That's assuming we put a limit on condos. Right. But if we don't put the limit, we don't have to worry about it. Right. I think we're getting kind of confused back and forth between condos and otherwise because there is no limit on condos. There's a limit still in terms of, because we're still saying,

1:58:47 Two per bedroom plus two. So it doesn't matter how. If you have 15 beds in there and you only have three bedrooms, you can only put eight people. We didn't do a pillow count, so to speak. Right. So there is a limit by math, but we're not saying it's 10 maximum because you could have two lofts in a bedroom. But doesn't condo not fall under any of this?

1:59:11 We said it doesn't have a maximum associated with it, so it shouldn't have a 2 plus 2. It has a 2 plus 2 still for the calculations currently. It does. Yes. Well, we're going to bring it back to the discussion. Okay. Is there any further public comment? Okay, seeing none, I'll close public hearing and bring it back to Council for discussion, so if you want to continue on your point. Well, let me just try a really quick math thing. Terry, in those ones where you're talking about the loft with the separate egress, they might have what?

1:59:40 Four bunk beds up there? Twins? Okay. So in my mind, if you've got a two and a loft, and that loft counts as a bedroom, that was six, and then you get two more, which would allow you really to have four people up in the loft. So with that? I think you might still have a scenario where there would be more people. Okay.

2:00:01 Loft could be split even, and you count that as two. I don't know. There's definitely different scenarios that you might have. Yeah, I think the point's valid that there's a lot of different scenarios around town. Then what if the language was just that instead of saying the maximum occupancy exceeds 10, which is what's in the code on the single-family homes, if on the other one we just said if someone needed to go above that number?

2:00:27 It would be approved. Yeah. What we can do on that is without putting a maximum. Correct. You could still have the same language that say if there's a case to go beyond the math that, again, the Community Economic Development Director could approve additional occupancy. Without setting any kind of a max. Right. That's the point. So you could have a review process to have that happen.

2:00:52 I'm comfortable with that. I think that satisfies it, that as long as there's some flexibility in the ordinance where a legitimate scenario that deviates from the norm can be approved. So similar language, and I'm looking at page one of the staff report at the bottom that says, unless the unit is approved by the Town of Mammoth Lakes Community Economic Development Director for higher occupancy or such occupancy. Yeah. I'll defer to Andy and Sandra how to write it. I have language.

2:01:21 Subsection G2. The first sentence, which currently ends with plus two, would go on plus two, comma, unless a higher occupancy limit is approved by the town and workplace community cannot involve the director. And Andy, you wouldn't consider that a substantial change? Like, we can roll that up into... Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. I just wanted to clarify that.

2:01:51 Just wanted to make a motion. Yeah, you know, I just want to thank staff for bringing this back. You know, this is the few changes that we asked and well articulated. Also just wanted to kind of point out that, you know, as we've talked about working through a program, you know, one of the first things we wanted to do is just go out and create reliable data.

2:02:20 One of the other things we wanted to do is put together a quality of life ordinance. And so we've been moving slowly through the process, but we're getting where we intend to be. So I think this is a substantial thing for us to put through and support it. So are you making a motion? Sure. Mr. Mayor, I'd make a motion to

2:02:48 Waive the first reading and introduce by title only the Attached Quality of Life Ordinance, adding Chapter 5.40 to the Municipal Code and amending Municipal Code Section 5.04.055 with suggested additional language. Second. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to discuss some further discussion. Sure. I would just, to follow up with what Colin was saying, I think that we have an election, special election coming up.

2:03:18 And I think I see some members in the audience who are very interested in those matters. And I want to make sure to encourage you all to hang around for item number 13, discussing transient mental best practices. And I want, I think it's important for everybody in the committee to understand that this is a component of a larger, complex.

2:03:38 This is a program that the Council is working very hard to bring forward to the community for your participation, your suggestion, your comment. I'm very much looking forward. No one's commenting on this part of it. This is maybe a little bit technical. I look at this quality of life ordinance as being iterative. It may change over time given the program that we all put together down the road. So I'm supporting this motion, but I want to make sure that we're all recognizing this lives in a much larger context.

2:04:04 And I look forward to that. Item number 13 and hearing comments from folks as item number 13 comes up. So thank you. Great. Thank you. So I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Move on to policy matters. Item number 11, appoint two applicants to the Plan and Economic Development Commission with terms expiring on July 31, 2016.

2:04:33 And I'll go ahead and lead this off. We had our second round of applicant interviews today. We brought back four very qualified applicants. I think, again, I want to thank all four of you for coming back. I think you're all very qualified, and unfortunately there's only two spots. So I encourage you to continue to apply for other commissions and to be involved. With that, I'd like to...

2:05:03 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, and I get to go first again, and I very much appreciate that. I want to reiterate how impressive the depth of talent we have in this community to serve in this capacity. We all serve.

2:05:34 Staff serves, community serves. I very much want to appreciate and acknowledge those folks who stepped forward. It was a difficult choice for me. And for a variety of reasons, and looking at the Planning Commission moving forward, I would nominate Mr. Chang and Ms. Farouk. And what? Paul Chang. Paul Chang and Don Farouk. Don Farouk. Okay. Thank you, Don. You're welcome.

2:06:05 Joe, did you like to comment? Ditto to all of that. And looking at a comment that Colin made in our first interview about having diversity, my choices would be Paul Chang and Patricia Robertson. Okay. Are you keeping score, Jamie? Yes. Okay. Colin? Yeah, thanks for stealing my thunder, Joe. I'm sorry. That's also what I was going to say is

2:06:37 You know, we had a group of eight excellent applicants that was really hard to whittle down to four, and today is even much more difficult to discern between those four candidates because any one of those four would serve really, really well in this commission. So my decision really comes down to trying to think about, you know, the best diversity and strength for the Planning Commission moving forward, which was, like I said, a difficult call.

2:07:06 But I also had Paul Chang and Dong Baruch. Okay. Shields? Yeah. Ditto to everything that's been said. This is not an easy process. And I appreciate the people that have come forward and submitted their names and actually gone through the process. They're all great candidates. We got down to the last four. And it is. It's difficult because, you know, they're all qualified.

2:07:39 Every one of them qualified. But you have to look at, you know, how the fit goes. And who do you think is going to work together best? And for that reason, my two picks are Paul Chang and Don Druk. Okay. Again, as I made my comments earlier, I appreciate all the applicants. We did have eight very qualified candidates, narrowed down to four. I have a little concern with the depth.

2:08:09 We lost two commissioners that have been involved for a long time. So my two choices would be Greg Eckert and Don Verruck. So with that, what do we have for count? So Paul Chang has four. Okay, with that, I'll make a motion to appoint Paul Chang and Don Verruck to serve as members of the Planning and Economic Development Commission with terms expiring on July 31, 2016. Second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please.

2:08:44 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Move on to item number 12, approve the submission of application for grant funds from the Recreational Trails Program, RTP. The trail that we're talking about today is really the second phase of the trail that we've talked about before from Lake Mary Road up to Lake George. The first phase, which was the subject of the Sarbanes Grant,

2:09:26 Which, now that the NEPA is done for that, we will advertise it either late this year, in other words, in the next month or so, or early in the spring so that it can be constructed next spring. Goes from Lake Mary Road up to Lake George Road.

2:09:38 In previous discussions, the second half of the path was actually included in an application that you authorized for a FLAP grant earlier in the year, if you recall. The second half of the path and then a reconstruction of Lake George was involved in that. That was not approved. It was approved by you for a submission, but we did not acquire that grant. We had had some concerns and council expressed some concerns about the second half.

2:10:02 Frankly, previously, we had talked about the fact that there weren't other amenities attached to that, how it fit in with the overall trail system. At that time, the Forest Service was very adamant as to the precise alignment for that and where it let out, frankly, up at Lake George itself. We had considered we wanted to head over towards the restrooms and towards the park and towards, excuse me, the...

2:10:27 Those areas itself, they wanted it on Lake George, and that's the way it was designed because, again, it is their property. We believe that we have an opportunity to look at some of those design features as we move forward and try to realign that a bit and try to make better use of those facilities. One of the things that we would have to do should we receive this grant, and it's through the Regional Trails Program, RTP, a major difference is that through the RTP, the trail itself is required to be

2:10:56 We did not

2:11:18 We weren't confident that the NEPA work was going to be done, frankly, this season. We just didn't think that was going to happen. About five weeks ago, we got indication that the Forest Service might complete that work. Therefore, we looked at it, and our engineering staff took a hard look at the possibilities, looked at the RTP grant process, and found that if the NEPA was, in fact, done by September 15th, we could submit a grant application for the construction of that second half.

2:11:46 Now the cost estimate for that, it isn't included in your packet because we were looking at the impacts of going to go from 8.3 to 5% of those other things. But the estimate for the as previously designed is about $780,000. The grant itself includes a 12% match. Two things on the cost estimate and the match. One, the cost estimate we do expect to go up.

2:12:08 We don't know if it's 50 or 100,000 yet. We haven't done that design yet. We don't know what else we can add into it in terms of the amenities at the top and that alignment. In terms of the match itself, while we haven't identified a specific source for that, our recommendation is that we believe very strongly that we can find, again, let's say it's $80,000 to $90,000. Although LTC funds, which we've mentioned in here, and the STIP funding is pretty well locked up for a few years,

2:12:37 For a smaller project like this, are there other LTC funds available that we can work through the commission, the LTC commission, and that's how we would propose that we would at least look for those funds, but they, frankly, they have not been identified yet. We had about four or five weeks to put the application together. We worked very closely with the trellis coordinator on some of the language there. He's been helpful on that because he has more experience in some of these things than engineering staff does.

2:13:04 And again, we want to continue this process. We'd like to submit for this grant with the commitment that we will continue to work with the Forest Service. We will come back to the Mammoth Trails Committee, MLR, however that works out, talk about the precise alignment, identify those matching funds as we move forward. But again, this is a path we've talked about before. We do need to tweak it a bit, but I still do agree with some of the discussion we've had that there's still some holes we still need to fill. But it's an opportunity to get.

2:13:33 You know, up to $900,000 or so based on that estimate for that next piece of it. And in that interim, we can work on the design and improve it even further. Okay. Any comments? I have lots of questions. So let me run you through a series of them, Grady. So this is a competitive – the RTP is a competitive grant. Correct. How often does this cycle come up to have an application cycle for RTP?

2:14:02 I believe it is annual, but I'm not sure the amount of funds that are available are annual. It's different from the flap where it's a cycle of three to five years. It comes up more often, but I don't know how much money there will be next year. You just never know. Right. Okay. As far as the match, this resolution says that we have to say we have the money in hand when we sign this resolution. Correct. Which I don't know.

2:14:28 And you were saying the STIP cycle. And I'm sorry, guys. Until you've been on the Local Transportation Commission, these acronyms don't make any sense to you. So excuse me for making them short. But we don't know when there would be that funding available. So you're suggesting we'd have to pull it from some other funding that's within Local Transportation Commission? That's correct. And it's either LTC or we do come back to the town. We come back to town funds. We come back.

2:14:53 And, again, I'm not suggesting any specific one other than the LTC because that's sort of the first one we looked at. But it may be something that if this, well, this would be incorporated into the special use permit. We will have, you know, management of that path. We will have maintenance responsibilities long term. So we can look at all the funding sources. What the commitment is from Council if we agree to move forward with the application is we're basically telling them

2:15:20 We have the money. We don't have to designate whether it's LTC funds, general funds, road recap funds, wherever it comes from. We just have to say, yes, we're committed to spending that money. Okay. And a lot of the conversation when the flap was in front of us was that that particular grant would have funded the public outreach to discuss alignments for this trail and so on and so forth. Because we didn't get that grant, has any of that public discussion happened?

2:15:50 We haven't done any more yet. What we are proposing, though, is as we move forward with the rest of the Sarbanes Grant, which we're still in the planning stages for that, we've done a lot of the field work for the Brown Lake Mary Road, is that we would include in that public outreach when we take that both to the Trails Committee first, of course, and then out to the public, that we would talk about this specific one as well. Because we do really believe they're all connected. They're all one part of the system, and we need to address them together.

2:16:18 Okay. Those are my questions. Thanks, Joe. Yeah, I've got some questions also. And I have had some significant concerns, which I've shared with staff, and we've talked through this at length. And I think I see a way forward that is designed to take advantage of opportunities in front of us and changing conditions on the ground.

2:16:45 So what I would propose to you, Mr. Mayor, I have two motions that I've written up. We're not ready for motions yet. Okay. But I have two motions that I would like to bring forward that are not directly related to the value of the grant itself. I think Joe's question about whether or not we're willing to make a commitment of, what, $40,000 or how would the match be? I'd say 12% of $90,000.

2:17:08 Of $800,000, it could be $800,000. Yeah, so we'll leave that. I'd like to leave that as a separate question, but when the time is right, I've got two motions, I think, that could enhance the opportunities of this process going forward. Any other questions? Any questions from the public on this item? Okay, seeing none, I will bring it back. John? Okay. So a lot has happened since Grady mentioned the FLAP grant, and a lot of things have happened since that time. Key Forest Service staff are no longer there.

2:17:39 The town has accepted the Lakes Basin Special Study as an advisory and informational document. The key agreements for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, the relationship of MLR to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, that was actually formalized about a year ago. The town has hired a trails coordinator with help from NGOs and certain partners to bring this stuff together. So I think it would be helpful to sort of address some kind of process issues for how we move forward and how these things come forward to us.

2:18:07 So they're perhaps a little bit more robust. And Jamie, I've written this down. So I'm going to read aloud from this and I can share printed copies of this. And I'll try to make it as succinct as possible. So I hand these out to you now. Is that okay? There's one for Jamie also. And is there one for staff too? Should be an excellent one. There's one more after too. Okay. Okay. I will now read slowly and coherently. Give it a 20 second. Sure. Are we good? Shall I read it? Yeah. Okay.

2:19:11 Motion number one, direct the town manager such that public works staff, the trails coordinator, and a designated representative of the Mammoth Trails Committee, number one, develop a final alignment for the proposed multi-use path connecting the Lake George Recreation Area to other proposed multi-use paths in the Mammoth Lakes Basin that will specifically integrate and accommodate trail development concepts one, three, four, and nine for the Lakes Basin Special Study Labs.

2:19:38 As accepted by the Town Council on March 4, 2015. Number two, working with the United States Forest Service, provide a recommendation for the final multi-use path alignment to Town Council for review and approval prior to the acceptance of any grant funds should they be awarded. Okay. I have a motion. Do I hear a second? I'll make a second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call, please.

2:20:02 Wait, wait, wait, wait. I want to make sure we understand what John's asking for. Okay. Because that is kind of long. Okay. So you're essentially saying that separately from the grant application, develop a final alignment, but to not accept the grant if awarded until that alignment's been approved by council? Correct. Okay.

2:20:29 I'm just trying to do the USA Today approach. No, of course. John, we've got a second motion here. We'll get to that after this. I have a question to staff. Okay, when they award the grant, how do they go about it? Do they award it and then say, we go, oh, well, thanks, but no thanks? That's always possible. I mean, we don't have to accept it just because they award it. Gotcha.

2:21:01 It is not official until we do go through that action and accept it. So this motion would be okay then? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Any other councils? Just a quick question. As someone who is not as familiar perhaps with lab study, concepts one, three, four, and nine. These trail development concepts developed by collaborative process, public process, specifically interact with

2:21:31 That proposed MUP. Okay. So they either connect directly to it, they would feed off of it. Exactly. These are the other trails that would come into it. Okay. They would be affected by that. Gotcha. Okay. Thank you. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. The second part. Okay. The second part. Should I read it or need a second?

2:22:01 Go ahead and read it. Okay. Direct the Town Manager to provide a detailed update to the Mammoth Trails Committee at their September 9th meeting on any and all projects currently being pursued by the town that may have a relationship to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Number two, on a regular and ongoing basis, provide relevant information on all Mammoth Lakes Trail System projects being pursued by the town to the Mammoth Trails Committee to ensure coordination of MLTS efforts as articulated in MLTS key agreements as adopted by Town Council.

2:22:30 Okay. I have a motion. Do I hear a second? I'll second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. I have a question. Okay. I have a question. Why do we need this? Isn't this what MLT, excuse me, MTC and staff are doing already? And I very much appreciate that question, Joe. I think we are in the midst of a very significant set of opportunities.

2:22:59 And changing our culture of our organization and how we do things. And this is kind of a housekeeping matter, but I think it's just important moving forward that the council is explicit and clear in their direction to staff that these are our expectations. And I think in this process we just went through, maybe some T's didn't get crossed and some I's didn't get dotted.

2:23:18 But I think for the new trails coordinator on staff, and this is consistent with council direction to date, that we just reaffirm that these are our expectations of how things will happen moving forward. Further discussion? Yeah, I'm just a little concerned at the specificity of...

2:23:37 You know, directing people to do something by next Tuesday when I know those meetings are going on and these kinds of things are happening. My understanding is that this item will be on the agenda. It's already been discussed. It will be on the agenda for next week. I know it's on the agenda because I posted the agenda. Okay, good. So I guess my question is, so do we really need to put it in? I think based on what I've seen, how this came forward again to us, I think it's important that we reiterate our commitment to this process and how we do business.

2:24:06 And I think it's a staff knows this. They inherently know that these are our expectations. But I think it's important to be clear from our perspective that these are expectations for how we expect it. Yeah, like it is an update. Can I ask the town attorney a question? Can I abstain from something if I don't really agree that we need it but I don't want to say no? Certainly. Okay. Just checking.

2:24:41 Yeah, I just, I had a comment along those lines that I just wanted to kind of make publicly, but, you know, we've, one of the things we've asked our town manager is to think creatively and innovatively about how we staff and deliver services, and I want to commend him for the job that we've done in getting Joel, our new trails coordinator, in place. And I think the intent of really that creative positioning

2:25:10 Was to have a very good liaison between all parties. And so I think there's probably some unfortunate timing. I can appreciate the fact that this was on a track well before his hiring and he's recently been put in place. But I think, you know, I understand where Jo's coming from. She doesn't feel like it's entirely necessary. But I think we just want to make sure that moving forward, we have a really good line of communication between all parties on this.

2:25:38 So I don't see a problem with reaffirming that in the motion. I don't see that it holds us back in any way. But I just wanted to kind of make that statement that I think moving forward, maybe we can address some of the concerns you articulated about the flow of information. And I think the process that we're doing with the strategic work, and we talked about the workshop with MLR, there's...

2:25:58 As things are moving around, we can almost not have too much communication. And the degree to which we're reaffirming to people what our expectations are, not as an admonishment, but just to make sure that we're all clear on what our expectations are, I think it's helpful to staff. Okay. Any further discussion? No. Okay. I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. I will abstain. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:26:27 Yes, motion passes 4-0 with one abstention. We're going to take a quick recess and we'll be right back. Oh, no. We've got to finish with this. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Yes. Yes. Time out. We need a third motion. Yeah, we need it. If I could add one thing, we do have a resolution attached to this, which we probably needed in order to get this passed. So I'd suggest that we approve the submission. You're actually approving the resolution, authorizing the submission. If I can.

2:26:57 And I would make a motion to approve and accept the resolution as drafted. Along with the motion here. Yeah, I'm sorry, I can read from the motion. To approve the submission of an application for grant funds from the Recreation Trails Program, RTP, if the NEPA, if the NEPA document is not signed prior to September 15, 2015, town staff is not to submit the application to the California Parks and Recreation.

2:27:24 Along with the resolution. And approve the resolution. And approve the resolution. Second. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And again, we will take a quick recess before continuing on. Thank you. Okay. We're going to move on to policy matter item 13, transient rental best practices and options. Staff?

2:28:45 Thank you. The item before you tonight is a report on transient rental best practices and options. This item is related to the Town Council's goal to tackle single-family transient rentals, single-family short-term rentals on a town-wide basis. Over the past year, town staff has completed a number of items related to this priority, including gathering data on transient rentals, updating the zoning code to remove the use permit requirements for transient rental within the RMF2 zones, and preparing a quality-of-life ordinance.

2:29:13 As part of our work on this topic, we have prepared a summary of best practices along with information on how we are currently implementing these best practices. And we've sorted them into five categories. And I'll just walk through the five categories for you tonight.

2:29:28 The first one is transient rental inventory and tracking. The council has continued to emphasize the importance of gathering data regarding transient rentals. We've been working to complete this through implementation of our new finance software, as well as working with the county to obtain additional land use data. We currently require license numbers on advertisements. We maintain a staff team dedicated to transient rental and TOT.

2:29:54 And we also take tips on illegal rentals. One of the best practices that was noted was to track the conversion of long-term rentals to short-term rentals so we would have data on whether or not long-term rentals were being lost to short-term transient rentals. We don't currently track this. We don't actually issue business license tax certificates for long-term rentals unless the rental is owned by a property owner who's renting two or more rentals.

2:30:22 It may be difficult if the council would like us to track this. It may be difficult for us to track this data. And the data that we have might not tell the whole story just because we don't track all of those single long-term rentals. If the council does provide direction that they'd like us to look into this, we can look into it further and try to come up with something that might address this issue. The next item was the quality of life regulations.

2:30:46 The Council adopted the quality of life ordinance tonight, which implements a large number of the best practices we've seen for quality of life. One thing that was not included in our quality of life ordinance was a requirement to notify neighbors when a new transient rental was proposed. As transient rentals change constantly, it may be difficult for the town to provide this kind of notice. If the Council would like to consider requiring notifying neighbors when new transient rentals are allowed, we can return with recommendations on how to accomplish this.

2:31:15 And it may be in certain areas or certain types of transient rentals, that kind of thing. But we would look into how we could accomplish this if we receive that direction. Another best practice that was suggested was to work with homeowners associations to encourage them to strengthen and to enforce their CCNRs.

2:31:34 If the Council provided direction for us to work on this, we could draft a letter to the HOAs explaining how they can go about this, what their enforcement process is, and really kind of give them more information on how they can also help us enforce these regulations. Moving on to zoning. We provided information on where and how transient rentals are allowed in town. Additionally, we provided options that describe ways other communities regulate single-family transient rentals.

2:32:02 This includes allowing a limited number of rentals either by a percentage like a certain percentage of homes in town or a maximum cap like a maximum cap of 200 or something like that. There's also other communities who use a sliding scale for regulations depending on where the rental is located or how often it's rented. So the regulations that might be permitted in some areas of the city.

2:32:24 And then it's, you know, a use permit in other areas or renting less than a certain number of nights it's permitted and then renting more than that certain number of nights it has to go through a different process. Others, communities also use a lottery system. So they may have a cap and people, everyone applies and then they just have a lottery system to fill that kind of quota for that.

2:32:45 We also provide an attachment that describes the frequently asked questions on transient rentals, and we would like to hear some input from the council on this topic when we move to discussion. This fourth item was enforcement education and TOT program staffing. We're really doing well in this.

2:33:06 We have a team that's focused on education enforcement, TOT collection. We've been implementing all of the best practices throughout the time that this committee has been, or the TOT group has been established. And we are working to bring back our comprehensive audit program in the next year or so. We kind of put that on hiatus with staffing changes, but we are looking to get our staff trained up.

2:33:28 And bring back audits, which is one of the best practices for transient rentals. Finally, workforce housing. This is definitely a hot topic when discussing transient rentals. A lot of the current news sources cite concern over long-term rentals being converted to short-term rentals and how that affects our workforce housing stock.

2:33:48 The town has – we have worked to protect workforce housing by funding Mammoth Lakes Housing. We seek grants for affordable housing, and we have maintained restrictions on transient rentals in our workforce neighborhoods. We'll continue to work with Mammoth Lakes Housing as topics of transient rentals and workforce housing come up. And we did prepare four initial discussion questions for the council. The council can feel free to add, modify, however you'd like on those questions.

2:34:15 And that concludes my summary, and I'm available for any questions that you have. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. Any other questions? Yeah, I have a couple. Go ahead. Sandra, regarding the zoning, you had articulated two different options for regulating single-family transient rentals, one of which would be allowing a limited number of rentals, either percentage-based or a number cap.

2:34:42 And then also further down we talked about using a lottery system to allow a limited number of single family homes. Can you articulate for me what the difference between those two is?

2:34:51 I think that those could work together. We could have a limited number, say, you know, just 200 as a number. We could have that number, and then we could hold a lottery for all 200 spots. So the communities that I spoke with that do this, what they do is they take all the applications, they draw random numbers through a separate party, and then they just say number 10 receives a permit, number 20 kind of go through it that way. So what you're really getting at here is,

2:35:21 Do we use a lottery system to allocate the limited number or come up with some other system to do so? Right. The other system, it could be first come, first serve. It could be an administrative permit, a use permit. There's a lot of different ways to regulate it as we move forward. Gotcha. Okay. Thank you. And then just so I'm clear as far as questions, you know, in our...

2:35:45 In our report we have town council discussion questions. There's four of them. And then also in working through the staff report and the presentation you just gave, it seems like you have some additional questions of council regarding do we want you to attempt to track conversion of rentals, do we need to notify neighbors, and do we want to do anything as far as information towards HOAs?

2:36:11 The three additional questions that you're looking for direction from Council on? Yes. So it's seven total? Yes, thank you. Okay, thank you. Thanks, Colin. Just one quick thing. I think I very much appreciate the breadth and the scope of this, and I think it really provides the community a sense of what it is in any community, whether it's us or New York or Santa Barbara or San Francisco, the kinds of things you've got to do to come up with an incredible program. So I very much appreciate putting a full venue in front of us and a lot of these things are what I didn't care.

2:36:40 On the data side, there's a couple things in here about having agreements and conversations with the Airbnb or the online system, which is probably not practical, but our support of the legislation at the state level, which is moving through, which I would hope, we would all hope has a favorable outcome, would mean that we could be able to access the data coming out of those services to plug into our systems.

2:37:09 Are we anticipating? If that were to happen at the state level, are we going to be able to consume that data and do the kinds of things we need to do with it to help our enforcement members? If I can speak to that, based on the legislation that was previously drafted that we have set in support on, yes, we would actually get that data that then we could plug into our systems and work through that. It's pretty comprehensive, I think, what they have to provide, and so we would be able to utilize that information very well. Any other questions?

2:37:39 Okay, I'll open up public comment on this item. I'm going to limit public comment to three minutes. I have no intention of bringing this item back after public comment is done to give council some time to spend some quality time on this discussion. It's the first time that the full council can really go through this whole item and really spend some time on it. So if you guys want to come forward, please comment on all aspects.

2:38:10 We'll go from there. Hi, Tom Cage. Two quick things. I didn't see anything or hear anything, and I might have missed it, on licensing of cleaning companies and making sure that that cleaning company only cleans a home or a condo that has a posted rule book or, you know, occupancy license.

2:38:39 So forth and so on so that you can get some accountability. I brought that up before to Council. I haven't seen it. It just seems to me that you want the cleaning people to be licensed, maybe even bonded. It could be a requirement. And if they're licensed, then you can make sure that if their license gets at jeopardy if they clean a home that isn't showing a TOT license. So you're suggesting it's an enforcement tool. It's something that could be used as part of an enforcement tool. Yeah.

2:39:08 Another check in the system. Exactly. And they don't have to be self-pleasing. It's just if they're going to be cleaning something, then they've got to show that. And then the other thing that I understand, and I don't know all the details, Santa Barbara has had some difficulties, and I think even to the point where they've thought about discontinuing any single-family rentals.

2:39:33 I don't know if we got a copy of their best practices or what they tried to implement so we could see what maybe didn't work. So I don't know if you did any research with any other communities that put this in place. We looked at a number of different communities. I don't think Santa Barbara was one of them that we looked at, though. But we did look at South Lake Tahoe, which I know they're changing the way that they do business up there, too. I think one piece of that, I think my own personal research on this stuff,

2:40:02 Santa Barbara and South Utah are examples of communities, I think San Francisco is the same way, where they went down a road in terms of allowing a wide, kind of not very well regulated program, only to find out that all these social issues, quality of life issues became an enormous problem. And Santa Barbara had built their T.O.T. expectations out of a program like this. And so what they're doing is trying to unwind something. And South Utah, I think it's the same position.

2:40:31 Trying to unwind a program that's had a lot of very difficult side effects. So they didn't start with a rule book, so to speak. Exactly. And that's a very key way to look at a lot of this stuff is because the technology showed up and people said, oh, okay, we can just kind of do this stuff. And no one had had the chance to look at the kind of best practices that we've been able to gather now and start saying, oh, when you start doing something like this, a lot of the time it's not optional.

2:41:00 It just starts happening because people are using the technology. You're going to use up my three minutes. So if South Lake Tahoe didn't start with a rule book, did you check any community that did start with a rule book? Well, we looked at it, yes. Or best practices. Yeah, I mean, that's kind of what we drew all of this information from is communities that had those rule books and how they worked. Is there an example of a community that started with best practices?

2:41:24 It sounds like South Lake Tahoe didn't. Right. It sounds like I recommend the Colorado Association of State. No, no, I appreciate you recommending something to me. I'm wondering what. Let me pull a city. Yeah, just one city so I can, you know, have a comparative. Durango, Colorado. Durango, Colorado. So they had a best practices before they started allowing single-family rentals. I don't know if that's true. I don't know if any of these committees, I don't know if anybody had a rule book in place before they started. I just, I haven't found it. Nobody? What's that? Nobody?

2:41:53 Well, not that it was comprehensive enough that it covered all of the things that have started to happen. I don't think anybody, I mean, I haven't found it. Maybe you know what I'm saying. Yeah, we did it previous life as a manager in Douglas County, Nevada, different environment there, but we actually put a lot of the rules in place to manage Tahoe rentals, similar to what's here in terms of occupancy and trash and parking and it actually auditing and it's worked pretty well.

2:42:21 When I was there, it's been a few years back. And South Lake Tahoe did some at the time, much broader with less regulatory scheme. And I think they're paying for that where the county is still, as far as I know, operating relatively well under that regulatory framework. My time's up. Thank you. But if we could find out a list of two or three of the communities that you did look at so that we can do our own comparative so that we can research it also. Great. Thanks, Tom.

2:42:57 Good evening. My name is Dana Stroud. I'm representing the committee to vote no on Z. My comments are coming from committee discussion. First of all, we'd like to acknowledge

2:43:09 Thank you very much.

2:43:39 You also recognize the same thing. Question number two is would the council consider allowing transient rentals throughout town regardless of zoning? We're hoping that that's a no answer this evening also when you discuss it, that you focus on no, that this is not allowing transient rentals throughout the entire town regardless of zoning.

2:44:00 On number three, transient rentals were allowed within single-family areas. What limiting factors should be considered as part of a possible program? We have three that we would like for you to consider this evening during your discussion. These are the limiting factors, very specific. We believe that there should be limited days to the rental opportunities. We believe that there should be limited number of permits issued.

2:44:24 Whether it's through a lottery system or not, but if you do pursue lottery, we would ask that you consider, through that process, consideration for our permanent residents over potential speculators or second homeowners. I appreciate the idea of putting everybody's name into a hat or numbers into a hat, but we would also like you to consider that permanent residents perhaps may have a primary

2:44:51 And then the third restriction has to do with what has been referenced earlier is the strengthening of the CCNRs and the town having the opportunity to actually provide language that the CCNRs could use to integrate into their existing documents that would help address some of the concerns that our various homeowner associations may have relative to the

2:45:21 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:45:38 The efforts and the governance of those CCNRs for those respective homeowners associations. And with that, I'm happy to answer any questions you might have, but we hope that you will consider those three restricting factors during your deliberation this evening. Thank you. Thank you, Dana. Any questions for Dana? Anybody else? I just have a question for Andy to kind of follow up on what Dana just mentioned. I certainly appreciate

2:46:07 The sentiment behind maybe a different treatment with this program on permanent residents versus non-permanent residents. Can you talk to us a little bit about is there any legal issue surrounding that? Is that something that we can effectively do? I'd have to look into it to give you a definitive answer. My initial impression as I sit here is that that might be kind of tough to do. Okay. I'm not sure the drawing distinction between locals and out-of-town second homeowners.

2:46:36 It's tenable. But, like I said, if you really want to have a definitive answer, a little bit of time to look at it. Okay. But, you know, essentially looking at two different tracks, that might be something you caution against, but you need a little more time to determine that. Okay. Then can I ask about the second part of that, the final part of that is the town recommending language to homeowners associations? You know, the town, I think, could

2:47:04 Suggest language to HOAs that might be interested in tightening up what they've got. I mean, it wouldn't be the town acting in a regulatory role. It would simply be, I think, providing a resource to HOAs, and I don't have any particular concern about that. With that language, Andy, it doesn't put the town in any type of liability? No, it doesn't, because I think it would just be HOAs saying, hey, if we...

2:47:26 We want to do this. We're not sure how to go about it. Can you give us a starting point? And I think we can do that. I don't think that was subject to town with any liability. Because it wouldn't be us dictating the procedure or the process or the voting or anything like that. That would be entirely up to the HOAs. It would just be, if this is something you're interested in doing, here's some language you could use. You figure out what your process is under your CC&Rs. You figure out where it goes in your CC&Rs. You figure out your own enforcement. Thank you. Anybody else like to comment? Flip or go in. Terry Stelick.

2:48:09 Been involved in this in a long time. Been lodging for a very long time. Been involved with the TOT committee since its inception. And I appreciate all the information that's been brought forward. And I have to say that I just did a search online and I haven't, I've had to step back from this issue because it became far too emotional for me and it just wasn't something that I was going to deal with anymore because I was preaching to the choir. And hopefully this council is different.

2:48:39 You know, actions speak far louder than words or black writing on a piece of paper. And so we do have a full TOT committee that's enforced right now, but it's only been there probably for the last couple of months where they're back working on enforcement. So allowing that group to do their work is going to show actions speak louder than words.

2:49:06 And so I appreciate the committee and what they've been doing. I'll tell you, you've got a lodging community that they don't even want to come here anymore because they don't feel that there's been a voice. They don't feel that they've been heard. They feel that illegal rentals have ran rampant and that there's nothing that's been done, yet we're all being told that we're all going to be audited again. And so as soon as we come back and say, hey, audits are going to start.

2:49:34 In September, they're like, you know what, we've been doing everything we can to do business legally and everything else, yet there's, you know, just the tip of the iceberg that's been happening as far as violators go. Past councils have not held up zoning violations, so we've, as I suggested even last time when I came up to speak,

2:49:57 I appreciate the information that's been brought forward. Some of these things that are happened that are in place right now came from the TOT committee that's

2:50:23 Been working on this. There's been other suggestions that haven't been implemented that we've been suggesting for a long time that some of them are showing up in information that's coming forward here, so that's great. But anyways, you know, I see everybody being very honest and earnest and trying to do what they're supposed to do, but I will tell you, actions speak louder than words. There's, you know, a couple appeals. Let's see how those come out.

2:50:53 Thank you, Terry. Yes, I'm Ron Day, and my comment would be a little different take to this in that sometimes if you do a cluster of it, let's say it passes them, you can do a cluster of rentals without, let's say, people living there year-round. Sometimes you can get a group together, and that is another way to make this work to where you're not getting the people that are living there upset with the people that are renting. It's called a cluster.

2:51:30 So do you have an example of that or something? Is there a community that's using that? Well, right now, Mono County does that in one sense. I was part of that group that dealt with that, and basically we have areas that allow just the area to do it because they all could agree that, yes, it's okay. It could be some permanent people who don't mind it. Right. So they just did a basic cluster type of situation. That's really where I got this from.

2:51:59 You say that's in Bono County and they refer to it as a cluster thing. We first looked at how to do this. That was one of the ways we thought it might jive with the communities. Okay. June Lakes. Yeah. And that. Essentially an overlay of sorts. Yes. In a very focused area. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Ron. Thank you. Anybody else? Sandra, could I just follow up with

2:52:25 With Terry's comment regarding a letter going out to the legally zone, I know that we had discussed that at the last meeting. I think that's a very valid suggestion and something that we had directed staff to go ahead and do. That's in our work program? Yeah, it would get done. It's a matter of timing for staff to have them. Okay. But presumably that's something that we can do this fall. Yeah, we'll have them. Okay. Thank you.

2:52:48 I have a request. My name is Kathy Cage. I get the impression that there is this past report out there that a lot of people have read. They've tried to find it online. It's not available readily that way. Is that something that staff used in any way to inform any of your work? Yes, we read that. Okay, since that was...

2:53:10 Seems like it might have had a big impact on what you've provided there. Is there a way that copies of that could be made available to the public to review? You know, I don't know that it's been, you know, I don't know if it's been cherry-picked for information or what, but I personally would like to be able to read it and wondered if that could be made available. I would just offer that. I paid for it. It costs $100. I can provide you the URL. It's an enormously useful document, and $100 is not a lot of money.

2:53:40 They spend a lot of money developing all the information. So they've got a big investment in it. And there are restrictions on how it can be used and distributed. And I think it's a concern that if it will become a public document, there may be some copyright issues and that kind of stuff. So I would just encourage you as a citizen, I know you're involved in the Z campaign, these kinds of things. It's enormously informative. And certainly it's informing my thinking to an enormous degree.

2:54:10 A lot of topics to talk about in common. And I think you underscore my point.

2:54:14 It sounds like it was enormously influential in informing our policymakers toward a policy direction, and we have no access to it. No, you can – I can provide you the URL, and you can go download it yourself. Generally, those things are made available at no cost for the public even to look at. I don't have to have it to keep. Even if there's a review copy, people could have it for a few days and return it, like a lending library kind of thing. I'm happy to do that. It's a copyrighted thing just like any other book. Like if you bought a book, you're not supposed to make copies of that either. But if it's a document that is a form –

2:54:43 Informed a number of you to a significant extent. Why shouldn't the general public be able to see that as well? Because it looks like it has informed a lot of this. Well, we could, I'll defer to the town attorney. Maybe we can figure something out. I'm just trying to respect the intellectual property of the people in Colorado. I could maybe provide a little light. I actually spoke to the director at the cast. When I first was able to view it, it was through, as a board member for Mammoth Lakes Housing.

2:55:13 And so Mammoth Lakes Housing, again, like John, purchased the study at a cost of $100. The agreement that Mammoth Lakes Housing made with the cast was that they wouldn't distribute it outside of their board. You're articulating that it's a very odd situation. I mean, I didn't really know how to handle that as well. So I called cast. I spoke to them.

2:55:36 What they're essentially trying to avoid is mass distribution, public consumption, attaching it to staff reports and those type of things. But when I spoke to them on the phone, they were certainly understanding of the fact that people that are involved in this and have a stake in it are going to want to view this study because it is really...

2:55:57 The Bible on this study. Right. Why can't we see it? You absolutely can. So I've seen it as a member of MLH. Town staff has it as a purchase. If you'd like Kathy, I can email you the contact information for Joyce, and I'm sure she would be happy to provide that to you guys as a group, and you just need to probably pay for it. I presume town staff has one, right? Why can't you loan that out? They do. So there you go. That's my request. Thank you. Kathy, would you like me to email you your info? Sure.

2:56:27 Okay. And I'll just request staff, within the legal constraints of what we're dealing with, could you please follow up with the request with Cassie? Make sure she gets a copy of it. Thank you. And anyone can purchase this report. Correct. Anybody can purchase it. Right. So if anyone wants to spend $100 on it, they can purchase it. It's kind of an odd situation of, you know, trying to keep it tight-lipped but also being able to distribute it to interested parties. I mean, I've never seen anything like that before.

2:56:56 Certainly, Kathy, if you want to take a look at it, which you should, you know, you can go to CAST and purchase that study for $100. Andy, can you respond, is that, can something be used as backup for a public document and not be made public? Yeah, I think it can, because you're not, your ultimate conclusions are going to be reflected in whatever the council approves.

2:57:20 So that's really the important thing is what the council is approving. You don't have to make public everything that you've ever read that might have influenced your decision. But I do understand Kathy's question and frustration. It's a very comprehensive 52-page document that really looks at all angles of the study from a very unbiased perspective. And I would suggest that anybody that's interested in this topic takes a look at it. Okay.

2:57:52 Anybody else? Good evening. It's Jay Cole. And I want to have just two quick comments. I believe the name is Ron. Very creative. Awesome. Thank you for coming up and mentioning that. I think that's worth considering. And then a quick question for Tom. On the cleaning, is that limited to any kind of cleaning in town? Or does it any sort of short-term rental? All right. Well, let me.

2:58:25 Ask you the question. We should consider whether or not the license cleaning is something that's just attributed to or applied to condos or condos and short-term rentals of any sort or just homes or whatever. Because I'm just wondering how I call the housekeeper and have them come in and how that works. I don't know how that works. Exactly the same way. If there's a way to, you know.

2:58:53 Segregate that. Find out. Designate it. But I don't know how you'd do that, the cleaning company. Well, it'd have to be fair playing field, right? It'd have to be all or none. Well, don't they already have to have a business license? Well, they have to have a business license, but if they come into my house and they start asking me, do I have the right to rent, and, you know, it doesn't make sense. Anybody else?

2:59:22 Yes, Sandy Hogan, and I do want to thank staff for really an exhaustive piece of work. It was very, very complete. I know that it stopped at one point in time, probably before the CASP report even came out. That's what I figured from reading it, I could tell that. But anyway, it's very good. It gives a lot of information, I think, to everybody, things to consider in this whole matter. A couple of points. Tom asked you about, doesn't anybody have a rule book?

2:59:52 We have probably the best rule book of any city or town that I've seen. It's called a general plan and zoning. It's been in place. I've been here only 20 years, a little more. It's been in place all that time, and they mesh as far as the zoning, what's allowed and what isn't. So, you know, before you break a rule book like that, you really want to be careful. And so I thank you for some good deliberation on this.

3:00:20 As far as enforcement, I know I said a couple of weeks ago, and just, I believe, Terry said it too, actions speak louder than words. Last week, I'm sure that everybody in here that owns property in Mammoth got this from Vacasa. Whether we're in a legal place or not, inviting us to, you know, call them and have them manage our property for short-term rentals. I know that when they first came to town,

3:00:49 I made, well, I know that our folks talked to them because I made our staff aware of it and I know that they gave them a real talking to because I talked to the person also and yet here we are and so people who live in our neighborhoods are being invited to violate the law. These are the kind of things that really we need to follow up on.

3:01:13 A heart with every one of them. And I think, I know that John Urdi did talk to Airbnb a long time ago, and one day I sat and reviewed all of their listings, and by gosh, there wasn't one illegal house. So those contacts do work. And you're seeing actually countrywide lawsuits against a lot of those companies so that they do help us, you know, help us become legal. And then Lake Tahoe.

3:01:41 I'm very familiar with Lake Tahoe. I haven't come from there. This is Lake Tahoe Real Estate reporting on the CAST report, and it says, study links vacation rentals to housing prices. And you sat here last Tuesday or Wednesday and heard Michael Ward say that 70% right now of the ownership of their second home and that every day they have 10,000 workers going over because they are losing

3:02:11 Thank you, Sandy.

3:02:42 Business License in the future. Thank you. A question real quick. Could you share that? I don't own property in town, so the CASA, whatever that. What CASA? Yeah. If you could share that with staff or something, I'd be interested to take a look at that. Good. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Anybody else like to comment? We're not going to come back to comments, so if anyone else wants to come up, now's the time. Okay. See you, none. You're bringing it back to council for discussion. How would you? Do you want to?

3:03:22 Do you want to talk through the best practices? Do you want to go to the four items? What's your pleasure? Well, I think we've got seven questions, don't we? Okay. Well, I would just offer the observation that these best practices, you know, I think we're finally maybe starting to have a conversation, which is...

3:03:44 I know this is a little, you know, we sit up here at a dais with microphones, you guys get to sit up there, but despite the formality of it, this is exactly the kind of thing we need to start to be doing because the only way we're going to succeed with a program is for this community to work together to address these challenges. These challenges are 21st century challenges, Ubered, a $50 billion business model just got undermined by a labor board ruling in the state of California. This is a very

3:04:12 Big, interesting, crazy world we live in, but it's great to be having this conversation with folks to figure out how we're going to address it. I have two observations about the best practices. One is this data comment being much more than just our GIS stuff. We have to have all that in place. But again, the ability to be able to tap into larger systems that may be able to help us, I think that's very important. The second thing is I think that in the best practices, there's a recommendation for the

3:04:42 Rental Housing piece with MLH. And Dan, maybe you can help. MLH is, you know, we haven't asked them. They haven't really provided any comment. How can we request to get some, or through Sandra, somehow some very direct analysis of the situation for our community? I think there's two different elements there. One is a lot of the best practices look at trying to track that transition of homes. I think that's very problematic for us, frankly, to do that. Okay.

3:05:10 What we would want to make sure is any place where we have deed restrictions in place or we've helped, you know, I'll say, you know, first-time homebuyer program or we have something like that nature is not allowing those to move to a rental program, you know, a transient rental program. I'm assuming that's something we could end up restricting if we're putting dollars into it.

3:05:29 And I think there's some restrictions on that already in our workforce housing program. I'd have to check with MLH. Because I'm just wondering if MLH could provide an analysis. There is, Ken. Yeah. This particular to our community. I mean, it's all these other places. It's well documented. It's causing problems in Los Angeles and all over the place. It would be nice to have some kind of analysis from MLH or from someone that looks at this problem specific to this community and what the implications would be if we don't get this right.

3:05:57 They could look at it. I think it would be an unknown work right now because it's not expanded. There's probably some impact, but what that would be now, I think they could ask them to look at it, but I think it would be looking at existing data to say. Okay. Well, maybe something down the road to look at, but to help inform this discussion, I think it would be helpful. So how about we take the best practices?

3:06:19 Item by item and go through it. So if it's by project area or something? By group or something? By group, yeah. And then we'll come back to the discussion questions of the four that are listed. Sure, sure, sure, sure. Sure, so we're starting with the transient rental inventory tracking and there was one question out of there from staff on do we want them to track conversion of rentals? Correct. Okay.

3:06:43 If I may on that too, leave that off. I know it's a question that we currently don't do it. It's a program that potentially could be done, but I think it would be very problematic because a lot of we'd be tracking in both directions. If it goes to ownership, if it goes to transient, if somebody just changes rental, and we don't track a lot of the single ownership items. So a program could go in place, but I think it would be extremely difficult to implement. And I'm going to agree with that. First of all,

3:07:12 We don't have the data. We don't have the data that two of the units in my complex that used to do nightly rentals have gone to seasonal or longer rentals. But what are you going to do with that information once you get it? If someone is going to convert an apartment...

3:07:28 To transient purposes, that goes through planning commission, am I correct? So we have the major ones that would be seen, but if someone pulls theirs off of the transient market, you know, we just don't have it. Or on the other hand, if someone wants to put it on, they're going to do a permit, so you've got the information. So my question is,

3:07:47 What would you get if you, because that would be a huge tracking item, because you don't have it. In the case of the two remitters, they just quit remitting and they may not have even renewed their licenses. But from the state level, and I appreciate it from our local level, Airbnb and those kinds of operations may be required to provide that data. Well, that's possible. Possibly. And that's what I'm exactly talking about. If that data were to become available.

3:08:12 If it were to become available, if someone else is doing it rather than our staff who's already doing other things, and there's a value to it, but at this point in time, I just see that it's not what's it going to give us. I agree with you, but I think, again, being ready, because I'm sort of, I don't know if I'm betting on it, but I kind of have the sense that because these things are statewide causing all these kinds of problems, I would anticipate that we may get a ruling that's going to support it.

3:08:37 John, the question is, we'd get data on what they're renting, but we would not know whether it was a conversion from point A to point B. I understand, I understand, I understand. It'd be a different set of data that we're getting, which would be helpful, but it wouldn't get to the point that's discussed in the best practice. Okay. Well, I think your point is, that you're articulating, is since we don't track what point A is, that's really the difficult side of it. And I can appreciate the sentiment here, because

3:09:03 You know, we're all kind of aware of all the issues wrapped up in this thing, and I think of any of the issues that have been discussed, to me, the one that's most poignant would be, you know, effects to affordable long-term housing. So I think this is something that we have to treat delicately and really analyze. But I'm hearing from staff that this is something that they just don't think is feasible to take on, and I think we have to be sensitive to that.

3:09:30 In regard to the particular question of do we want staff to put together a program, I'm comfortable with saying no on that. Agreed. Just a clarification for me, I mean, Airbnb, VRBO, how many hosting sites are there out there now? More and more every day. You'll get a new one will pop up every day. And they're buying each other and they're splitting up.

3:09:59 It's hard to keep track of. Yeah, I would imagine. I mean, there's a handful of, like, a half dozen of the major players, but to your point, it's like, this is a daily changing thing, but. The RPO just bought HomeAway or the other way? I got you. It's HomeAway that's the whole family, I think, you know, and they've got, right. So I think this is a big one that's growing exponentially. Exponentially, yeah. One other question from the data side. How far are we out from?

3:10:28 From the GIS perspective of having an inventory in our GIS database that identifies all the units that are legal and available or not illegal and available for our program. Have we asked for that? Well, that one, that's the data that we started this data back in the fall. No, no, no, but I mean, did we specifically ask for a GIS overlay? Well, I'm assuming it's happening. The data collection is being, it's coming out of the county, right? It's coming out of those records.

3:10:58 Are we – is it complete? Do we have all the information that we need from our side that ties into the TOT collection and all the rest of it? I think it's going to come online when we finally get community development into the new finance system. But in terms of how reliable the county database is that we're tying in, I –

3:11:18 Couldn't answer that. Okay. It would be good at some point to maybe come back and give us a little report of where we're at with that. I know there's been some issues up in northern Mario County with the reliability of the GIS data tied to the tax rolls, so that would be helpful to get an update on that. Okay. Which one would you guys like to go over next? Let's see here. I think we're down. Well, I was just going to move on down until we find the next one that has a question, which I think is on.

3:11:48 Number four, which is about the CC&Rs. We have contacting neighbors was the second question. I know, but I, it's over there, it's in the text, but is it on the list? Well, anyway. Where are you? Well, that's, I was trying to, I was trying to work through the table and find the questions as we came to them there just to have an order. Are we done with the, have I made the alternative?

3:12:16 If I may, the only thing I'm tracking also that was in here is one of the recommendations was whether or not the town should have a website that would actually, I'm going to say post or advertise rentals. That would be another one I would recommend that we not go into that business. Right. However, I would make a distinction in that

3:12:34 To take the GIS data that we have that shows where it is allowed. We have something like that currently. Exactly, but to continue to develop that platform because that could be a very useful thing for the enforcement side who said, oh, wait a minute, you're not supposed to be doing that. That's different than advertising. Exactly. I just want to clarify, that's not something that we would recommend getting into that business. Yeah, we need information out there, not advertising rentals for people.

3:13:03 Notify next is fine. I was just trying to find it in the table if that question was asked again there because we've got like two sets of questions. But anyway, so on the notify, my thought is one of the reasons why we put it in the ordinance that they have to post it is because it would be extremely staff intensive to have the town running around notifying people. And if it's posted that it's being rented, isn't that noticed to the neighbors?

3:13:35 You're talking about if an owner or partner manages posting? Well, you know, the outside posting that we just passed in the ordinance earlier tonight. Would that be enough? She says rhetorically. So, Sandra, as far as the language you have in here, it doesn't necessarily...

3:13:57 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:14:27 With the contact information, et cetera, would have neighbors notified if they have a contact if there's issues versus on the front end. And part of that is notifying them, but it doesn't get into, well, yeah, and I want to come in and complain about it. Well, all we did was notify you. There's no hearing. So I guess the question becomes a little confusing to the community as well. Mr. Mayor, where are we on this? Are we still in this? In the text under quality of life regulations. Okay. Yeah, we're just kind of jumping around.

3:14:59 I can appreciate that, and we certainly want to be cognizant of not making this overly complicated or onerous, but from where I'm sitting, I see some merit to the idea of notifying immediate neighbors. And I think that we're addressing an issue that's being driven by technology.

3:15:27 And I think that there are things in here we might find, okay, that might be something we might want to do, but until we can find a way to do it, to Joe's point, we're not going to take on these issues, because these things from a staffing perspective are huge, time sucks potentially. So we've got to say, okay, that's something we may want to try and do that, but we've got to find a way to do it that is not going to tax the staff in some absurd way. And I, yeah, I certainly understand that. You know, this basically asks us.

3:15:55 You know, staff hasn't really done the work to say how they would implement such. It leaves it open for us to have staff come back and say, is this going to be feasible? I mean, the same way I'm hearing from Dan that he doesn't think that staff can really take on and handle this idea of tracking whether long-term rentals go to transient, I just don't know that we've taken it to that step yet, and there is some merit to me in just simply notifying the immediate neighbors that

3:16:24 This is now having a change of use. Well, except it was only a couple meetings ago when we said it didn't have to be done on use permits, which is so, you know, if we said no, the neighbors didn't need to be notified there, why would this be any different? Well, I mean, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and I would concur with that. Just, you know, good to bring these things up. This is all going to, we're.

3:16:50 Building a boat here, and it's going to have to float at some point. Okay. Yeah, we want to be careful that some of this stuff in here, all of a sudden, there's an expectation when we start noticing everybody. Yeah. Right. Every time we renew a permit, is that a notice? Talk about the immediate neighborhood. Is that a 300-foot rule? Right. Is that neighbors? I can recognize when I'm in the minority, so that's fine. I'll back down.

3:17:13 Is there anything else under the rail industry tracking? Yeah, the HOA. The CCNR thing, as a general comment, I think that within the legal, you know, constraints that we work in, I think it's going to be important for all of the HOAs to, you know, review their CCNRs, make sure they're current, make sure the CCNRs reflect the desires of the HOAs. Revalidate them. Yeah, revalidate them. Again, this is a whole new thing that didn't exist how many years ago.

3:17:42 To encourage those HOAs to do that. And if we can play any kind of a helpful, productive role, let's maybe figure out what you think that might be. But I think that would be a very important thing to do. Sandra, how many HOAs would be covered by this? It's more or less just the neighborhood HOAs. It would not be any condominium HOAs. Right. So it would be like the trails, the slopes. Yeah, we could, I mean, I think that would be appropriate. I don't think, yeah, I don't think it would be too significant. I just, you know, it's,

3:18:12 To kind of Sandy's point, this is a very difficult thing to deal with. I mean, this is a worldwide issue that every single community, resort or not, is starting to deal with. And with rapidly changing technology and the advent of, you know, the sharing economy, I think we need to look at as many partners and avenues as we can to help regulate this activity. And HOAs have to be

3:18:40 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:19:06 Yeah. On how we work together on this issue. Okay, so let me ask you, so strengthen their CCRs to respond to the issues within the neighborhood, so we give them both sets, how to make it not allowed and how to make it allowed? It's up to them. I mean, it's up... Well, I mean, I'm just asking, so what goes out in whatever the town... No, I think it's, I mean, it's obviously up to the HOAs to determine what they want to do.

3:19:28 If I can clarify the question. Yeah, because what we're saying is we're going to reach out to them on strengthening their CCNRs. Both sides? We might put information on and say, you know, here's some language that would make it very clear that you don't allow transient rentals. Here's some language that makes it very clear that you do. If you wish to incorporate those into your CCNRs, you know, go through whatever your processes are to do that.

3:19:57 Giving them information but not telling them what to do with it or their choice would still be up to them. Andy, can you maybe, you know, you and I have discussed this, and I mean, I think this is something that's going to need some further work and treatment, but can you speak to a little bit of the conversations we've had around this? We can provide some advice. It's going to be real general because HOA has been formed at so many different times over the last 40, 50 years.

3:20:26 Their CCNRs, some of them are very old, very primitive, some of them are new, pretty modern. So there's not really a one-size-fits-all set of language that we could give them. We can just kind of provide some in general, and they'll have to figure out how to make it work. But in general, I get that the council wants to respect CCNRs and not allow rentals maybe where HOAs don't want them or where they're prohibited. Wading into the nuances of interpreting CCNRs and dealing with HOAs that may not really be anything other than dormant.

3:20:55 It's kind of a mess, truthfully. I don't think we want to go down that road. It would be enormously time intensive. Yeah, and that's where my concern about spending time on it, because, you know, for those several years that we had at the NECCNR...

3:21:10 Group that came to us and wanted to have single family rentals in their neighborhood could do so. That was the policy for several years. We didn't have a single one come forward. So I would not want to spend a whole bunch of time trying to put stuff together. Maybe it's just a saying, hey, reach out and say that if you want help, rather than sit there and even draft stuff. Sure. I just, even a note of saying, are your, dear HOA, are your CCNRs current and reflect the desires of your HOA relative to the transit rental issues?

3:21:40 Something simple. Yeah, something simple. I think the other piece would be that's interesting, and we're not there yet, but as the enforcement mechanisms become clear to what we want to do to be able to enlist the HOAs and partners in that effort, that's probably a further discussion, but I think in terms of your point, Colin, about we need to be working together with these HOAs to help enforce the program we put in place, that's going to be something needed down the road. I don't think we have to get into that tonight, but that's something that's a very important opportunity.

3:22:11 Do you guys want to move on to the zoning section? Sure. Staff had no other questions through the best practices. Okay. Thank you. Well, I'm looking at, I mean, starting on page five of the table, there's all kinds of, like, input direction, right? Under zoning? Right. Right. That's the...

3:22:42 Correct. Future questions, right. I think in terms of the text moving down zoning, the only comment I would have is I'm not interested in looking at any sort of sliding scale regulations. I think that's far too onerous and cumbersome. How are you going to enforce this? Right. At this point, I'm prepared that if staff has direction on the questions they specifically asked,

3:23:10 I think we might want to go through a couple of – But there are questions on – starting on page five at the table. Okay. Oh, I'm sorry. Okay. So you're just saying – Each one – yeah. Okay. Those are questions they're asking. Okay. I'm sorry. And I think those relate to number three of the Town Council discussion questions. Okay. Right. So do you want to go through them here or do you want to come back to when we go through the one through four?

3:23:31 Questions? I think it'd be more productive to come back to them in the one through four because it gives kind of an overview, a higher level kind of policy direction that may be more helpful. I'm anticipating staff takes whatever direction they get tonight, they're going to work this thing and start looking for redundancies or things that don't fit together and start bringing the whole thing back. Okay, why don't we move down to workforce housing then? Okay. So wait, are we skipping enforcement?

3:24:00 Education, DOT program staffing? Well, we're not skipping it. We can come back to it unless there's something that you want to address in that certain area. Not yet, no. I don't see anything there. And workforce housing prohibit transient rentals in workforce housing neighborhoods. I had a little concern with this. If it's truly a subsidized, it's one thing, but because it meets a workforce need, I feel it restricts property rights on that piece. So I don't know if you guys want to have a little discussion on this.

3:24:29 On the, yes, prohibits. Sorry, which page of the table are you on? Oh, the workforce housing page, okay. Prohibits transit rentals in workforce housing neighborhoods. We don't have workforce housing neighborhoods. We have workforce housing nicely spread through all the multi, yeah. So I'm not sure how to answer that one. Yeah. You know, I think.

3:25:00 We tend, like the Sierra Valley sites, we tend to refer that way, and it's currently not allowed there as workforce, but it's not necessarily based on price or value or, you know, you can do different types of rentals there. So we really don't have a lot of neighborhoods that we would classify truly as workforce by income or it's more by practicality where people live.

3:25:22 I think it should apply if there's a deed restriction or if we've done something that way that we can, you know, we have a legal right to restrict. And that's already in place. Right. That's in place just like the transitioning apartments to transient is in place. The same thing, deed restricted becoming unrestricted goes to Planning Commission, you know, or at least somehow someone's notified of it. MLH is made aware. MLH is made aware. Okay. We have options often to acquire or do something, so. Right.

3:25:52 Okay. Again, I just have a general desire to get some analysis from MLH about these types of questions that are specific to our communities. You know, I know it's a real problem, we've really got to deal with it, but I assume that's what they're there for, so, and I want them to start taking some ownership of this issue so that, you know, we can get some granular specific analysis relative to our community. All right. Okay. Is there any other questions on any of these items in here?

3:26:27 I think we get down to town council discussion questions. Develop a program to replace lost housing units that are converted. Well, but I think that would be specific. Would that not have to be part of the time when that workforce was, when rental was switched to transient? Would that not be part of the report?

3:26:50 I mean, I specifically heard staff ask us for some direction on conversion of rentals, which we did, notifying neighbors, which we did, and, you know, kind of how we address HOAs, which we did. So I see that we're kind of down to the discussion questions here. Okay. So we'll go through these one through four then and have some discussion on that. And it's the council's pleasure to...

3:27:16 Get consensus and an actual vote on these items, a few of them? I think we should go through and vote on each one of them. I think that the community has waited probably a very long time to hear the council's voice. I think we're finally looking at this, the totality of it, and I think it would be useful for the community to understand where we're at. I think we owe it to the community.

3:27:38 We've been waiting for a long time to get to the point where we have the critical mass of information in front of us, which I think we're at. Right. We asked for data collection. That's been done. We asked for quality of life ordinance. That's been done. Now this is really kind of the third part, which is engaging in the community conversation, which maybe has taken longer than it should have, but that's where we're at. Okay. We'll go through the first number one. Are the current practices working, not your business as usual?

3:28:05 I have a hard time with that because we just passed an ordinance that's going to change a lot and it won't be business as usual. So are we talking about up until today or where we hope it to go? We're talking about up until today. Yeah, I agree. Well, I think we'd already answered it, that no, they weren't working and that's why we've done what we've done and done the quality of life ordinance. Whether that works, we have to wait a little bit to see. Oh, for sure. So why don't we take this one and...

3:28:35 I'll entertain a motion on number one, and then we will vote on one and then go on to the next one. Yeah, I mean, I have a little bit different take on it. I think the entire system that we have, I don't even want to call it a program, is not working. So for me, I've been very vocal on that since day one, that I think, you know, we have a system right now that is not working for any of the stakeholder groups. And so for me, number one's an emphatic no.

3:29:01 I'd just like to point out, you don't actually need a motion for any of these because you're not really taking any action. You can kick these around and if you reach consensus, you can give additional direction to staff or you can just say this is kind of what we think, but because there's no action. Yeah, but again, I think we've been, I think a lot of, you know, there's a lot of turmoil being, developing in the community because we've been faced with a very difficult, challenging problem.

3:29:28 And we, for a variety of reasons, discretion, waiting for information, et cetera, we waited to kind of get that stuff together. And I just, I think it would be helpful for the community to let folks know what we're thinking. We have a motion if you want. I think you achieved the same thing. Yeah, just with a discussion. Okay. We can come to consensus and a response on each one about going through the long motion process if that's what counts. Yeah, it's fine. Okay. So.

3:29:55 We wouldn't be going through this discussion if it was working. Right. Okay. So consensus on item one of the current practices working, business as usual, consensus on the council is a no. Is that correct? Sure. Except I'm still saying as well. We've been saying that since 2006. We're making changes and we don't know if those are going to be any different. Right. We're hoping we're going to make it better. Hopefully going in the right direction. We're hopefully going in the right direction. Okay. Item two, would the council consider allowing transient rentals?

3:30:24 Throughout town, regardless of zoning. No. No. No? I mean, it's all zoning-based. I think as somebody that's spent countless hours researching and dealing with this, I've talked to over a half dozen of our peer resorts personally. One of the mistakes that's made and articulated well in the CAS study is if this activity is unregulated and just we allow the floodgates to open.

3:30:54 We're going to see a lot of these quality of life issues that people are dealing with. Loss of affordable housing, you know, impacts of neighborhood character, trash parking, all the things that we've talked about. I think it would be completely irresponsible of us to just open the floodgates on this. Yeah, to Tom Cage's point, you know, the playbook, you know, obviously the playbook didn't work when they did that. Yeah. We have studies now. We have empirical data. People have looked at the effects of

3:31:21 Regulation changes over the last seven, ten years, and I think that's one that's rang pretty loud and clear with everything I've looked at, that not limiting it in some sort of fashion is very problematic, so I don't support that at all. And I think, too, that the full council has said, since we said we were going to tackle this issue, that we weren't going to, you know, look into HOAs.

3:31:49 I'm going to say that the

3:32:18 The integrity of residential neighborhoods as residential neighborhoods needs to be a fundamental informing value for any action that we take. In other words, we can't take neighborhoods that are residential neighborhoods and compromise their character as being residential neighborhoods. This doesn't mean we can't, you know, there's not, that can mean a lot of different things. But I think we have to start from the understanding of the zoning that we have, the intention behind that.

3:32:47 We can build upon it. We can do things to enhance it. But I think if a residential neighborhood is a residential neighborhood and residents want to be a residential neighborhood and they see this as being something being problematic about it, we need to talk about it and there may be ways to enhance that. But I think we need to set that as a principle and as a value that for further discussion, that's where we're starting from. I hear what you're saying, John, but I have a problem with the word residential neighborhood because I think all of Mammoth is a residential neighborhood.

3:33:17 I mean, I live in a neighborhood. Also, for the zoning, this would be a zoning discussion. And so if a zone is a residential neighborhood, the people that have expectations of it being a residential neighborhood, we should start with that. You know, okay, as an example, Starwood. All right. I don't know what the zoning is on that exactly, but, you know, there's CC&Rs, to my understanding, prohibit. All right.

3:33:47 So I think it's more than the zoning. I think if they're CC&Rs and they vote as a group to say, hey, we're not allowing single-family nightly rentals, then that should be upheld. Oh, absolutely. So regardless of whether it's a residential neighborhood in the... Okay, well then maybe what I'm trying to say is to respect the...

3:34:10 Stated needs and desires of neighborhoods for what it is that they want to do. That we're not going to legislate from up here and tell folks what they're going to do. It's like the community is going to be making these decisions. Right. If they live in a neighborhood that says, hey, residential or not, that says, hey, we're not going to allow this. And there's a lot of, there's several neighborhoods that.

3:34:34 Have those HOACs in place. Right. Start with one example, trails another, nulls another. Sure. The list goes on, so there are several. Yeah, we shouldn't compromise that. The discussion, the idea and thought of limited of days renting and limited of permits issued kind of struggle with the limited of days, and I'd like to have some other council members' thoughts on that.

3:35:03 And the limited issued of permits issued versus just, you know, as we said, just open it up, which we haven't had intention to do. Well, I think regarding limit of days, that's something that I support. You know, looking at all the CAS study, the peer resorts, et cetera, et cetera, all the research that I've done, you know, really I think

3:35:30 That is encompassed often as a best practice and an emerging best practice. And one of the reasons behind that is what I think it does that we want to promote is it attempts to limit this idea of people just turning it into a speculative business where they're going to come up and say, hey, I want to buy nine homes in this neighborhood, run them all out on a transient basis for

3:35:59 250 days a year, and that's my business model. By limiting the number of days, it limits making that activity pencil. It also limits the activity and the impact in that area. So I think there's a lot of merit to looking at a limited number of days. I mean, the intent really behind that is to say, hey, this can potentially be an offset against so many of your expenses, but it's not a business.

3:36:26 And I think to build on that, I think if there's a way to structure the limiting of days, that it can benefit our local resident population. That's how I'm looking at it. To help mitigate the cost of living in a very, very expensive area. Again, in my reading of the CAS study, there's all kinds of different iterations of all this. Some work, some don't. It's very...

3:36:46 It's complicated and complex, but as a value, if that's something that could be incorporated, I would support that. And to answer your question, Michael, I don't think staff is asking us tonight to say the number is 122. No, no, no, I'm just trying to understand how do you come to that number. Well, and I think, you know, that's, we can give direction to staff to say whether or not we think that's a valid framework for limiting the activity.

3:37:10 I would look for staff to come back to us and say we think the correct number is this based on the research we've done and this is what backs that up. But I think, you know, to John's point, I mean, that's kind of how I'm looking at it. If you can envision a local that's trying to make a leap to buy a home, they envision being out of town a couple of weeks a year or something of that nature and some sort of offset will help them make the difference in their mortgage payment. That's...

3:37:38 Really where a lot of these best practices are looking at with this. I hope staff is kind of capturing this because we're layering in some, these are ideas, these are sort of principles and values, but they're complicated, they overlap, none of these things is absolute, and ultimately we're trying to get to a program that's going to work and is going to be successful. Right. So any one of these things, if something's not going to work, okay, it's not going to work. But I think these are the kinds of things to look at.

3:38:05 To start seeing if these will be components of success. This for me is all predicated on the idea that it's not working right now. Right. Go ahead. I look at it maybe a little bit differently. I mean, if we were to allow single-family rentals, we know that there's illegal – that's the wrong word. We know that there's single-family rentals going on out there right now that aren't –

3:38:37 Not zone. That's a good word. The idea would be to actually get these guys from the underground and come out. A road to compliance. A road to compliance. And if you limit the number of days too much, I don't think you're going to achieve that. So I think, you know, as we look at this number of days, and as staff does, we have to be cognizant of that.

3:39:06 I think it's a ceiling, if you will. It doesn't mean that you allow, let's say, 120 days just to throw out a number, and everybody's going to rent their place 120 days. I don't think that. I think it's a ceiling that you want to talk about.

3:39:37 It's going to require some real analysis. Oh, no question. A lot of question work to kind of. And from my perspective, I don't think we're asking the question in the right way. When I look at this, I see the limiting factors as things like, okay, I can understand the idea of how do you keep speculation out so staff can come up with some ideas on that. But to me, the real whole issue is the infrastructure that we either have or don't have that supports any kind of expansion.

3:40:05 We, you know, if you live on Sugar Pine, I have friends who live there, you know, they're not the first road that gets plowed. So what would it take to provide the, quote, service that the people staying there as a nightly rental would expect that it's not that, you know, one little lane goes through the middle and they go back later and clean up? How much more staff does that take to increase your snow removal? How much more policing are you going to need? What's the impact on the use of the roads that right now we have in a

3:40:34 Hierarchy of arterial collector and local.

3:40:39 You know, those are the kinds of things that I think are the ways you get to this answer, the limiting factors. Infrastructure is a huge part of it, so I would want to see analysis each way that additional traffic, additional use, what's the water district going to say about, you know, the joke about you know how much, what your capacity is at the first commercial break in the Super Bowl when everybody heads to the restroom? You know, those kinds of things to me are your limiting factors that would get you a number of this is the

3:41:08 What I think it underscores, I think, again, a higher value in all this stuff is that this has to work as an integrated program and that all these pieces have to talk to each other. And there's a lot of scenarios that we can come up with that we have to go back and test them against the quality of life ordinance. We have to test them against the values we got that we're using to frame this discussion to see if things are going to work. I think it's important, skipping a little bit to number four, which I don't necessarily want to do, but that the enforcement component of this,

3:41:38 We have to start addressing an enforcement program that we can get in place as soon as we can that is going to help us figure out how this...

3:41:49 Is it going to work? Because if we can't get there's two enforcement pieces, though, if you do limit the days, well, what's that going to take to enforce? If you're really looking at this full program, is we really got to get down to the nitty gritty? Is the limiting factor is not us deciding it's 126 or something like that? It's what is the capacity that we have? What's the infrastructure that we have?

3:42:12 I'm sorry, I hadn't heard anybody else mention that, so I just got fed up to say, hey, that's the reality. Well, I think the capacity changes as, I mean, if they were allowed, I would imagine. Sure, but when you start looking at the town getting back its percentage of T.O.T. is not going to pay for the needed infrastructure, so how else are you going to fund the rest of that? So I'd like to bring another value to this on number three. Because we're already splitting T.O.T. in so many ways.

3:42:40 We need to look at this program on its merits and that the revenue component of it is not a value that we're looking to this program to provide. We need to get a program to work from the issues of quality of life, from success, and that whatever the revenue...

3:43:01 Or non-revenue comes out of it. We use that as part of the analysis. But it cannot be something that's driving it. I don't think it's the driver. I agree with you. But I think it's to offset certain problems that might come up, infrastructure, as Joe was saying. I think you have to look at that and say, okay, well.

3:43:18 Well, and also back to staff, the cost of the enforcement of the program. We've got to, like, say whatever revenue comes out of this, we have to anticipate how that's going to help pay for the staff that's going to have to implement all this stuff. Sure. That revenue needs to go to staff. It needs to go to Plowing Roads. It needs to go to public safety. It needs to go to all those. Right. So we have to – And I think that's going to be more than the money we get, but that's what we need to see. I agree with Joe. I think it's going to be more – so we have to prioritize where is that revenue going to go first because just the cost of having a good, credible enforcement program –

3:43:48 You know, we don't know what that's going to be like, but we've got to target those dollars in that direction. So the way I view this is the nuance here is staff is kind of asking us to look at this from a macro level, all the different components that come together to make something like this successful. They're asking us to drill down to a micro level here in the sense that they're looking for some direction as far as how they pursue a program because there's a lot of different stuff out there.

3:44:14 What was framed from question one to question two to question three is if we're at the zero yard line right now, do we want to stay there or do we think that's not working? Question two is are we going to open 2,380 homes up in this community? That's the 100 yard line. And we've said no to both of those. So the question then becomes for staff as we provide direction to them to build a program, what are those limiting factors?

3:44:42 The umpteen number of them that communities have used around to say we're not going to just let the floodgates on this activity open, but what do we want to use as limiting factors? And I think to me one of the major ones that's been brought up is some sort of consideration of CCNR and HOAs that don't want that activity in their neighborhood. That's something that is making it problematic currently. We have a lot of neighborhoods that don't want that activity.

3:45:09 Because we have nine legally licensed homes right now and a demand that far exceeds that, we are having a lot of issues in those neighborhoods. Okay, so that to me is a limiting factor that we need to bring to staff, which needs probably some further development with Andy for how's the best way to approach this so that we don't get down into the weeds of

3:45:36 Our town attorney and our town staff trying to interpret CC&Rs all over the town from 1965, not the correct date, but you know what I'm saying. If we could establish a way to document these things that we're saying. So, Colin, just the respect for, let's put that down and say that's something we agree on. That is a limiting factor that we need to develop how we're going to look at that. Okay, go read it back to us, right? Right.

3:46:01 There's been consensus, I think, that the CC&Rs are limiting factors, HOAs, I'm reading those together. The question that we had in here is the unknown is how do we work with them to enhance that relationship and that partnership with them, whether that's here's information, here's without doing all the research on that. We have that down as a consensus decision that says we want to honor HOAs and CC&Rs that are in place.

3:46:26 And if that means we need to do some outreach to them in terms of making sure if there's questions we can answer, we can do those things without becoming their attorney. Right. So what about the limited days question? So that would be the next question, I think, that came up that I was trying to – well, let me take one step back because I think Councilmember Bateman's comment on looking at some of those capacity issues, difficult, but I think it's a valid question to address.

3:46:56 I think it's valid, and there's no question, but I'm reading the question, if transient rentals were allowed. Right. What would be some limiting factors? What would be some limiting factors? And I think. So one of those would be some sort of acknowledgement of the will of CC&R HOA neighborhoods.

3:47:18 That's one limiting factor. The other ones that were brought up were number of days and also limited number of permits issued. So we're turning a little bit on number of days. Do we want to move to number of permits and come back to days, or where are we at with days? I think we need input from staff on number of days.

3:47:38 And also on number of permits. And probably on number. Because if they get to that point and you do have a communication with the HOAs and now you know there's two of them that are interested, then that affects your number that you might consider. Right. True. But I also can't imagine that we would go forward with this without being able to say to our community is here's how much it's going to cost to support this in all the different ways and here's how it would be funded.

3:48:06 Versus what we're doing today, right? Right. Okay, and what it's costing today. Right. Okay. And what we're collecting today. Right. Is that all clear? Did you guys get that? If I'm hearing that correctly, is to take a look at options for number of days, options for number of permits, and the impact on the town's capacity to provide services. You've set no minimum or maximum on those. It's really a research project that, frankly, it'll...

3:48:34 Probably take more than one iteration through this process. Sure. Yeah, but I think I'm not hearing from the council. Staff's not asking us to determine the number of days or the number of permits today. We would be coming back at some time in the future. What staff is asking us is does limiting this activity, if it were to change, by number of permits or by number of days have merit? And for me, it does. My answer is yes on that.

3:49:04 If it has merit, we'll go look at it. If the council is saying it doesn't have, then we won't spend time. I understand. I think we do. Let's look at it. I mean, let's give staff the direction to take a look at it. Again, in the context of a program for this community, let's look at this. Okay. So those would be some limiting factors, would be days, permits, overall permits. Days and number of permits. So, and in regards to permits, there were kind of two ideas brought up by Sanders as far as limiting, percentage-based.

3:49:34 Cap number, lottery, all that kind of, do you need further direction on that right now? I think that's something we would come back to you with that versus, and then the other element I would look at is trying to address that capacity issue. I think that's a valid concern, so. Okay, so do we have enough, do you have enough direction on number three? Yes. Okay, number four, are there other best practices that the council would like to see included in staff's work program? I would like to, for staff to take,

3:50:05 I'm interested in hearing any ideas you might have. Be innovative.

3:50:34 The success of this program, the needs of the crying from the community is enforce this thing and make it work. I would love to hear some ideas what you think. Yeah. Versus what's happening now. Yeah. Right. What is it going to take to really enforce this program and make it work? So I. Yeah. I don't have an answer, but yes. And we would be basing. We take a look at the best practices that are outlined that you kind of walk through and highlighting some of those areas.

3:51:04 Put a program through that would kind of start with that element of the base and what does it take and that would be an integrated discussion across planning and the TOT team and the community and how the community gets involved in this and looking at all the things we're seeing, we go back to that playbook, which everybody's kind of making this up as they go along. What do we, what do you, what's it going to take to make this thing work?

3:51:31 One that I would offer, I think there's a lot of really good best practices as far as, you know, question number four. One thing that I would just put out there to staff, maybe council as well, is, you know, one of the best practices that I've gleaned that I didn't see in there was at least a discussion on should there be additional revenue, earmarking that revenue for a specific purpose.

3:51:57 That's been laid out in a number of communities as a best practice to say, you know, this particular activity, what does it really have a burden on? It has a burden on affordable housing sometimes. It has a burden on public safety and police enforcement. It has a burden on code compliance. If you take Big Bear's program, for example, which has been very successful for that community,

3:52:22 In order to get the compliance and the enforcement that they have, obviously there's dollars that need to flow to the program to support it. They get near $3 million a year off of this program that they use. But one of the things that they fund out of that is they have two code compliance officers that are specifically dedicated to this activity, 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

3:52:47 And they also have a 24-hour hotline that you can get a hold of one of those code compliance officers. They gave me some information on how they staff it, deal with overtime, pay, all those type of things. But that's how they've put together their permit structure is to pay for those two people, including overtime and on-call time and those type of things.

3:53:08 You know, that is something that has really taken the complaint level and driven it way down in that community. They have a much higher compliance rate because of having this 24-hour service where, hey, if you've got an extra car parked in the middle of the road, you have someone that you can call 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and get a mitigation of that issue. And we do not have that currently here. But I'm thinking that in terms of the enforcement, I mean, that seems to be a very credible part of that. I think the idea there is

3:53:36 What is it going to cost? Not only do we need to make a credible enforcement program, but what is it going to cost to do it? And then to Joe's point, we can start trying to reconcile, okay, it's going to cost this. What does the anticipated revenue look like? Are these things even in the same ballpark? Sure, and that's a very valid study. But what I'm saying is that I would like us to consider potentially earmarking dollars in directions that we think make sense.

3:54:03 In this idea that, hey, if we are going to have a further burden on affordable housing, we need to try and restore some dollars there so they can offset. If we are going to have a potential burden on our police force, which is already strapped as is, you know, do dollars flow to PD and putting more cops in our force?

3:54:26 Do we add more code compliance officers, those type of things? And I'm not saying we have to iron that out today, but I just think it's valid for discussion to say if there is additional revenue, where does it go? Well, I think the first priority for any revenue has to be to the program. Well, let me ask a couple questions, because back when we first started increasing DOT enforcement, or actually having DOT enforcement, we want to say it that way,

3:54:52 The budget said, okay, we're going to give you staff, but you've got to raise $500,000 in TOT. But that TOT was still split along the existing political lines, you know, 2% to NLT, etc. So you're suggesting not doing that with this? I'm suggesting. With the additional funds here? I'm just trying to understand what you're talking about earmarking. Well, I'm suggesting that potentially we have that conversation. Okay.

3:55:18 That is a best practice that I've seen utilized elsewhere that I don't see in any of the materials we have here, so I just think it's worthy of discussion. I'm not saying we have to do that. We have to encumber ourselves on something 15 years from now, but I think it's worthy of discussion. Yeah, and I think it's the impact. You know, what's creating the impact, right? Right. As you said, public safety, public works, which you did say.

3:55:43 Yeah, I didn't say that. You're right. Because to find what Joe is saying just as an idea, if the revenue stream...

3:55:51 That is, if it is T.O.T. that's coming out of this and the collections of these rentals, that we would look at that T.O.T. and take out those political commitments to various programs that come out of a T.O.T. stream so that we can commit sufficient dollars to enforce the program and make it work. I think that's the kind of idea we might want to think about. It's twofold. It's T.O.T. certainly, but it's also permitting fees.

3:56:14 So if we've got a set of homes currently right now that are legally able to rent, some of them are going to choose not to do that. But if we do this outreach that's been discussed and instead of nine, we all of a sudden have 20, structuring that permit fee so that those dollars flow back to the success of the program as well. So that would be a two-fold thing as far as funding the program. And you're talking about new dollars. Correct.

3:56:43 Not existing change in minutes today. Correct. Correct. So is there consensus from Council that we would want to include earmarking? Well, we want to consider. Consider. I'm just asking for consideration on, you know, question number four, looking at best practices, I would like that to be considered in that discussion. And that the dollars would go to what's creating the impact. Right. Yeah. Okay, great. Anything else on number four?

3:57:14 For me, the only other item that we've talked about or looked at is that if we did anything, would it be on a pilot basis or would it be kind of just implemented and run with it? No, I think my sense is we've got a lot of work still to do. I mean, this direction to staff is, I think we want to start, personally, I want to see the comprehensive program. You know, what does this look like based on the best practices, soup to nuts the whole way through it, and push it a little bit, test it a little bit.

3:57:43 Before we start doing anything, we need to, you know. No, what Dan's asking is, as you look at the framework of this, is this something that would be set up on a pilot like a two-, three-year program to see if it's indeed working, if we get to that point. Yeah, let's bring it back. Let's see where we're at. I think we need more information because, you know, are you talking about a pilot, you know, if the number was small, why would you bother with a pilot? But if the number is huge of potential additional permits,

3:58:12 Then maybe he'd wanted to, you know, I think we'd have to scale it based on whatever answers we get back to. There's a lot of information here about cost, viability. There's a lot of things flying around. Right. I mean, I think it's clear that there needs to be, you know, more coming back from staff to us and more work done. But, you know, they've specifically asked to get some framework direction to steer them in a certain degree so it's not just going all over the place.

3:58:40 So I think that's why it was structured the way it is, and I think we've provided that. Maybe the way to ask the question is to ask them to research whether or not other jurisdictions that had a successful program started with a pilot rather than sit here and try to figure out. That makes sense. Yeah. Just like the question of whether or not they started with a rule book. Right. Do you guys have enough information?

3:59:08 Can you do us a big favor and perhaps type up what you've heard at some point and provide it back to us so that we can just, I mean, in terms of minutes, so we can hear what, you know, whatever you've written down. It's like we've all been on the same page as what we, I mean, this is, it's a discussion. It's very important to have these kinds of discussions. It could be very helpful to have back from you guys in writing what it is you heard. Yeah, we can kind of walk through the program that way.

3:59:37 My other issue will be this is something that's going to be very time-consuming, so don't expect to report back quickly. Well, that's fine. I mean, you gave us several hours, weeks of work here, so. Oh, understood. We just need to get it right. We'll start the process. Take your time and just whatever what you heard so we can make sure that as we go through this thing that's, oh, yeah, we said that, that's coming back. We didn't miss anything. Okay. Sure.

4:00:05 Just something you talked about, and I was trying to look for nodding heads, and I didn't pick up on it. Back to Colin's analysis of the zero to a hundred yard line, some consensus where zero, do I understand zero means keeping the current zoning in place and just enforcing that, if that's zero? Are we saying there's no one on council that supports that? Correct. No, that's not right. That's not right. Zero is the status quo.

4:00:33 Yeah, that's what I meant. Zero resistance. But not just zoning. Okay. Everything. Enforcement, data collection, quality of life. Where are we at right now from a holistic program? So we haven't broken out that particular component necessarily, like the zoning. And I think you kind of went past the zoning. Maybe I just missed it. So the zoning.

4:00:52 You're exactly right because we're looking at this thing holistically. Okay. And the zoning is – We haven't taken a position. Is that what you're telling me? No, we've got a lot – we have – On the zoning. No. We have not taken a position on the zoning. Well, I think there – Well, what if I just missed it? No, no. I appreciate that clarification. I think there was clear direction on not opening up the zoning to a free-for-all. Yeah, there was that – That was number two. Yeah. There was that direction for sure. Yes. But number one was – is – number one was no.

4:01:23 Let me go back to that a second. Hold on a second. My notes. Right. Our current practice is working, and that's the no, and that's where you said we were at the zero to 100, right? Right. If you want to elaborate a little bit on that. No, no, that's fine. I mean, zero is current practices. Okay. Does that help? All right, we're going to move on to our next agenda, item number 14. Sure. Thank you. Yes, sir.

4:02:33 Oh. As long as you stay green. Okay. We're going to continue on to Agenda Item 14, Council's consideration of ordinance for adoption of Municipal Code 8.13, Construction Demolition Waste Management. Grady? Thank you. This item was before Council on August the 5th. We had a bit of a short Council that night, so I'll go into just a little bit of detail for the benefit of...

4:03:01 Those who weren't able to attend. Basically, this is introducing an ordinance to manage the construction and demolition waste in town. It's something that CalRecycle has been after us for a number of years to do. It will show our good faith efforts and our overall efforts to increase the amount of recycling to what we're trying to get to, which is 50 percent overall. The comments that we had that night from the construction industry, and we agreed with them, by the way, is that they wanted to have an opportunity to vet this with their whole group,

4:03:31 Possibly gather a smaller group together to study this with us. And so what the council decided to do with our, you know, which was our recommendation as well, was go ahead and do the first reading, introduce the ordinance. If, through our work with that construction industry and building industry group, there were substantive changes to that wording, we'd bring it back for a first reading and we'd go through the process again. We met, one, two, three, I met.

4:03:56 I met myself twice. Other staff met twice because I was out of town with what I thought was a very good cross-section of the industry. Jesse brought forward to their monthly meeting at the Contractors Association. We had Building Advisory Council we met with as well. We had representatives from the mountain. Tom Hodges didn't attend every meeting, but I talked to him extensively. We had John Hooper, one of the builders in town. I thought, again, it was a great cross-section.

4:04:26 The other two is one is we took the actual

4:04:56 Security deposit information, in other words, the limits for that security deposit. We took them out of the ordinance and we're suggesting you adopt those by resolution. That's something that was supported. That's something we can change over time. We didn't change the amount of deposits, just the implementation of that. Because what the group recognized is that this is our first shot at this. I mean, we looked at C&D ordinances all over the place. They were very different.

4:05:22 We're in a remote location. As Rick and Volkin from Mammoth Dispositive, we only have five things that we can really recycle right now in town anyway. So it's not like we have the opportunity that other places do. So we want to take a shot of this, have a good solid framework that's not punitive, and get it going. So we've taken that out. The other item, turn to the other page, there was also a section 8.13100 stating that

4:05:49 Violators could be basically incarcerated. And we thought, well, you know, we don't really need to say that. The comment was we wouldn't do that anyway, of course, unless, you know, they really upset the chief. But other than that, we just left it a maximum of $1,000 fine and moved on. We didn't need that language. The real key, though, was the fact that in the implementation, we did a couple things. One, and the last thing, if you will, I'll jump back, is we're working with the industry.

4:06:16 I mean, they met again after our last meeting to talk about the form. And, in fact, Ron Day is working with our Ron Fowler to beat the heck out of it and try some projects on it, just fill out projects they did this year, make sure it's going to work. Okay? Another comment we had is that somebody thought, are you guys going to request an administrative fee?

4:06:35 We pay enough fees. They pay enough fees, excuse me. The processing of a small fee just to do this one other thing when you're already doing a building permit, in our opinion, was it just really wasn't necessary. We actually talked to our permit technician, and she says, it takes me longer to, I mean, some things are just not worth it. We'll monitor that, though. We're going to monitor in time. I know for over a year, if the contractors aren't doing the job real well and it's costing us a lot more, we'll bring it back, and we've told them that.

4:07:04 The other item, and probably the most important, is in terms of the deposit. I'll just describe the process. The contractor comes in for a building permit for a 4,000-square-foot house, fills out the permit, submits a waste management plan. We calculate the fee on that. It's 1% of the valuation. So let's say it's $8,000. The maximum for a single-family home is $5,000 anyway. So we set it at $5,000. We note that. We take their waste management plan. They go about their business.

4:07:33 When they come back to close out the project for their certificate of occupancy or for smaller projects, whatever instrument is that closeout document, if they've done their job, if they have the documentation to back up their plan that they've done it as they said they would, if they meet our requirements, they hand it in, we check it, and they're done. If they don't, okay, basically then we say, okay, if you want your certificate of occupancy, now you give us a deposit and you have 90 days to work to get it back.

4:08:01 They really appreciated that because one of the suggestions rather than have a deposit was we'll just tie it to certificate of occupancy. I not argued, I just told them this is not a good idea because what I pictured in my head, and I explained this to one of the participants, John Hooper, I said, you're sitting there, you're done with your house, you're trying to close the loan, the family's trying to move in, and you're going to say the town's going to hold us up because we don't have the form filled out. So we gave them an out, basically.

4:08:29 No deposit up front. You come in and get done. If you haven't done your work, then you give us the deposit. We track it. You have 90 days to get it back. So I think we ended up in a good place. And, again, we'd recommend, as the motion states in the agenda sheet, that we go ahead and pass the ordinance. Not pass, but introduce it and wave the first reading and introduce the ordinance, but also adopt the resolution that would set the fees that would go into effect at the same time the ordinance does. Thank you, Grady.

4:09:00 Any questions? One question I received on the ESCOG. We received something from Inyo County. Are you familiar with that? Does that support any of you? Okay. It's about a regional waste issue. Had some recycling issues involved in that as well. I was wondering if you'd seen that or not. I will mention that in the Solid Waste Task Force, and that doesn't include Inyo, but we are talking to them as well now pretty regularly, Solid Waste Task Force. We'll report what we did there and talk about that as well, which is separate, but we'll let Inyo know. Okay.

4:09:29 Just one comment, Greg and Dan, I appreciate you guys bringing this back. Concern of another upfront fee. You know, we're trying to do whatever we can to get some things going, and I think this compromise is a good one, and I just wanted to commend you for that. Any other questions? Any comments from public? Ron Day again. I'm a general contractor. I'm in the contractor's board, and I was on this committee.

4:10:05 And I just want to thank the town on their effort on this. We all put a lot of work into it to get it where it is, and we all are aware that maybe next year we're going to change some of it. But it's really being all done because of the state of California, basically. It's why he's here, why I'm here. My forms now are more rigid than what we're doing here with the CD, what I have to do to get a set of plans through. So I just really wanted to thank the town for their effort.

4:10:34 We're not quite done, but we're really close, and we're making it simple, so contractors should be able to do it without a lot of problems. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Rick Voll, man at disposal. The shields that I've sat here all night. I wasn't going to say anything, but I am now. Investing my time wisely. A few things. I really appreciate Grady and just the town and coming together to build this framework. After working with Cal Recycle for the last year and a half, they want programs.

4:11:08 And whether or not you're achieving your goals, giving your numbers, even though we are, they love exactly what we're doing. This is great. I've gotten a lot of feedback from them. And also, Grady brought up the five things that we can recycle. That's what we're going to be measuring to this 50% diversion rate. So I think it's achievable. And I want to highlight a few things. So as it stands today, of course, we haul everything down to the Benton Crossing landfill. And I think there's a savings in it for contractors.

4:11:36 For general construction and demolition waste, it's $74 per ton. An average 20 cubic yard roll-off has about three tons in it, $250. So if you go down and you start to separate loads, I bring in 20 cubic yards of wood, it's at $17.25 per ton versus $75 per ton, or excuse me, $74 per ton.

4:12:05 So you can see there's a big difference. If you have clean dirt or soil, $5. And we didn't get ahead of it this year, but brown is the new green. And I think, you know, it kind of correlates with construction and demolition, but people are ripping up their sod. And so next spring we hope to take advantage of this pricing scenario and then also add it into the town's diversion. Not specifically C&D related, but it's a great opportunity for us.

4:12:35 I wanted to highlight another thing completely separate. We just closed the last month, looked at recycling numbers in town, and we shipped off 264,000 pounds of recycling. We had six loads, which is hopping.

4:12:55 So we've been working really hard. That's 132 tons of recycling. And this C&D ordinance, I expect to see it climb, just like we're seeing plastic, aluminum, cardboard, paper, tin start to increase year over year. So I appreciate your good help on this. Thank you. Thank you. Mayor, Town Council, Jesse Baldwin, President of the Mammoth Lakes Contractor Association. I'm a local electrical contractor. I just wanted to thank town staff and town council.

4:13:32 You know, we had some misunderstandings and fears among some of the contractors about this. There were a lot of emails that went around. The best term I could describe of some of went on, you know, was fear-mongering, basically, about how this was going to affect us. Frankly, like I spoke the last time this came up at Council, I'm not a huge stakeholder in this, personally, for my business.

4:14:01 Our membership understands and is represented and has a say. And so that's what I asked for. And everybody, I know we had a much smaller town council at that meeting, but everybody was very agreeable to that. And what we did is, just like you heard tonight, I appointed Ron Day. We had that voted on at our monthly contractors meeting to head a committee. And what we did is we appointed one of our board members who's a general contractor and a couple other general contractors.

4:14:30 Because they're the ones that it affects the most. They got on that committee and with that focus group and in accordance, like what Grady said, with some of the other stakeholders like Mono County, some of the other big general contractors in town on meeting multiple times between then and now, just like you heard tonight. I talked with Ron and he said, yeah, we got it worked out. It wasn't a big deal. Tim Flynn was here earlier.

4:14:56 Same thing. Not a big deal. It's saving me money to be sorting the stuff. And, you know, we knew it wasn't going to be a really big deal, but I'm glad we all got to communicate about it. And, you know, I just, the only reason I'm even speaking tonight is that I want to, you know, recognize that, like I said, it helps a lot. If we have this type of policy brought to us, we get the opportunity to discuss it and work with the town staff.

4:15:24 And then come here and then we can all be on the same page just like you see tonight rather than, you know, like I said, there was a lot of disinformation and stuff that did go around at first. As a board, we took some action, kind of, you know, stem that and put the right people, you know, in place. And, you know, I think all of us working together got us where we're at. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comment?

4:15:51 Okay, seeing none, I'll bring it back to Council for further discussion and or a motion. I am prepared to make a motion. I just have a couple short comments too, but yeah, I just, Jesse, Ron, I appreciate the comments. I would also like to, you know, reverse that appreciation that I'm not a general contractor. I'm certainly not an expert in this area and C&D. And so to have an active group,

4:16:22 And I think some of the changes that have been made

4:16:52 We're well worth putting this off for 30 days. So thank you guys for your input on this and your volunteering your time for it. Makes it really clean and easy for us to feel comfortable improving something like this and that it's achieving the goal that we're hoping to do. So with that, unless anybody has anything else, I can make a motion. Cool.

4:17:13 Mr. Mayor, I'd move that we waive the first reading and introduce by title only an ordinance adding Municipal Code Chapter 8.13, Construction and Demolition Waste Management, and adopt a resolution setting deposit amounts for a waste management plan. Second. Okay, motion and second. Roll call from Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

4:17:41 Yes, motion passes, 5-0. Move on to item number 15, waive the reading introduced by title only, the ordinance adding municipal code chapter 8.10 pertaining to disposable and reusable bags. Mr. Mayor, this is brought back to you based on your direction from the last meeting where we brought it forward for discussion. It's basically the same ordinance that was prepared several months ago and then put on hiatus pending the state action and then with the referendum is now before you again.

4:18:11 Based on the discussion last time and for the direction this evening, the one item that we do need council direction on deals with the effective date of the ordinance, assuming you're still moving forward with the adoption of it. And really it's up to the council on that. We have now set the second reading ideally for October 7th to get some time to go out and talk to the community if need be.

4:18:36 We're also looking at a timeline that would allow a chance to utilize people to utilize some of their existing stock and go through that. But the actual effective date is really up to the Council on that. We can give you some ideas if need be. The other component on this, it would be effective through next November for sure, and then depending on the statewide referendum, it could be superseded by the state again or could continue in effect pending on the outcome of that vote.

4:19:02 Yeah, so the soonest it could possibly take effect would be 30 days from the second reading. You could do a second reading in two weeks, so it would take effect in mid-October. And you can have the ordinance take effect, the procedure will take effect then, but not substantively take effect until some later date. We've left a placeholder in Section 810-020. So if you want to give some time for a little community outreach and talk to merchants and letting people burn their stock of bags, that's fine. Most cities that have adopted these have...

4:19:29 Had some period of time. What's typical? A couple months to a year. Oh, pardon me? Six months to a year? A few months to a year. Oh, a few months to a year. Somewhere in there. I mean, it's whatever you think is reasonable. Right. Give people a chance to run through some inventory. And should the state referendum not go through and therefore the state ordinance would supersede, really effectively what that reverts back to is we're talking about Vons and Rite Aid, correct?

4:20:00 From a layman's perspective, yeah. That's basically it. Okay. Any other questions? Public? Seeing none, I'll bring it back for further discussion and or a motion. Well, we need to come up with an effective date first. And, you know, I think we want to balance things and we don't want to put it so far out that it's only in effect for a few months. But I think that...

4:20:27 At least getting through the holidays season makes sense. So I was going to propose March 1, 2016, because that would be after the holidays and President's Day. Yes.

4:20:42 And it gives people a chance to use up. You know, we do have firms that have already switched over, but for those that need to switch over, it would give them time to use stuff over. It gives us a chance to do an outreach. To do outreach and for them to use up their inventory. Who's going to do the outreach? There was actually a very active citizens group initially on this and some folks were involved. Are any of them here this evening? No, but I actually have received comments from them.

4:21:10 Very appreciative. This is moving forward. I'm meeting with one of them tomorrow morning. Okay. And then also, John, there was an original plan to discuss whether or not Mammoth had a branded recycled bag, and I don't know, Dan, if you had a chance to catch up with. I have not yet. Chamber of Commerce and MLT were talking about coming together on that as well. Yep. So. It would be nice to get. Which could also be outreach. Yeah. Yeah, I actually, I was thinking of a date even earlier than that, but if.

4:21:41 I was thinking February 1st. Well, I thought about February, but then you got President's Day weekend, which is still big. I'm just wondering if, I guess there's no answer to this, if people are going to go through their stock over Christmas and then reload. Let's hope so. Well, I don't know. Well, but they can always reload with the new ones. They don't have to wait. There's no way to answer it, I guess. And I think effectively it's not a big deal one way or the other. So if people are more comfortable with March 1st, I'm fine with that.

4:22:11 How would a place like Vons, have they, have you heard from them, would they have any interest in helping to be sort of an outreach partner to be able to say this ordinance will take effect on such and such a date? I don't know. From that perspective, I know there was conversations with them and they're definitely not opposed to the ordinance going forward. I mean, as a company, they've incorporated this around the state. Yeah, in other cities, what they've done, including trucking, is they've posted little signs inside the store saying, hey, by the way, effective as of this date.

4:22:40 It's going to be $0.10 for a paper bag or plastic bag. So they've been fairly cooperative, but they're not going to do proactive outreach in the community. But with that little thing that you're talking about, is that, could we? We can ask them if they would do that. Yeah, that would be something just as a nice point of sale kind of thing. I think it's one of the things that, you know, it was on our list, and even though we removed it from the list, the

4:23:02 Communication conversations we've been having in the strategy sessions will kind of inform just, you know, essentially taking a moment to figure out how does this word get out. Yeah. Yeah. So consensus on a March 1, 2016 date? Sure. Sure. Earlier it would be nice that Betsy. Then we will just write that in to 810-020, bring this back to the second reading. If you do the first reading now at the very next meeting, it will take effect.

4:23:30 In October with the substantive requirements taking effect March 1st. Okay. I will entertain a motion. I just need to clarify what Andy just said. Dan was talking about having the second reading at the first meeting in October rather than the second meeting. We can do it sooner. I was looking at that if you wanted to have outreach time, if there was going to be any input to the ordinance. But at this point it's not. We can just do the.

4:23:54 Second reading quickly. It's 30 days, but the actual effective really operable date is until March 1 regardless. So if the motion is as written, it would be the next meeting and it will only be if the motion is set and have the second reading on the, okay. Correct. All right. So go ahead.

4:24:12 I move the council waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance adding Chapter 8.14 pertaining to disposable and reusable bags and finding the ordinance to be categorically exempt from CEQA Environmental Review pursuant to Section 15307, actions by regulatory agencies for protection of natural resources and Section 15308, actions by regulatory agencies for protection of the environment and direct staff to file a notice of exemption. Very good.

4:24:39 Included with the effective date of March 1? Oh, with the effective date of March 1, 2016. I'll second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Move on to item 16 on our agenda. Consider approval of an amended employment agreement and merit pay increase for Town Manager Daniel C. Holler. I guess I will start this out.

4:25:12 So I've worked with Dan and the town attorney. We have a draft agreement present in the agenda bill. And currently we're going to discuss salary in open session for a new Brown Act requirement. So what I'd like to do is first talk about the evaluation that we did. That's good. And then from there we could talk about the proposed term.

4:25:42 And then lastly, Merit, you guys are okay with that? Sounds good. Sounds good. Okay, so as far as the evaluation, does anyone want to lead off? Sure. Yeah, I just, as far as the evaluation, you know, I went through and filled it out, you know, based on the evaluation form that we were provided. You know, the one comment that I think I have is I appreciated the fact that I felt

4:26:12 Dan was very honest with his own evaluation. I think being aware of his strengths and weaknesses, and that came out in his evaluation of himself, I found it to be very much in line for what I had down on nearly everything. So I think as is with everything, there's areas of improvement, and I think Dan's aware of those and will continue to try and address them.

4:26:41 I think overall my evaluation was positive. I think, you know, our relationship between our town manager and our council is good. It's healthy. I appreciate the job that Dan's doing and I most appreciated the fact that we were very much on the same page based on Dan being realistic, I think. Great. Anyone else? I had a similar experience and I think that I've never performed

4:27:11 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

4:27:40 Just a ditto to all that's been said. I think the one piece that

4:28:08 Hasn't been covered yet is that Dan has done a great job of meeting our priorities and goals in a timely manner. We've actually, you know, as we've seen in the strategy sessions, we're clicking things off and even before we had that in the prior year, you know, in his time as an interim, the things are getting done that we need to have get done. I think that needs to be stated. Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, I don't know that I can add much more. I mean, I concur with all the

4:28:38 Prior comments. I appreciate Dan's honesty about himself. I would add that, you know, as far as our priorities and what have you, I think Dan's been a great listener and, at least for me, this is a new deal. A great counselor, giving me some good guidance, so I appreciate that. You know, you have three new guys up here and...

4:29:07 I think we're all trying to find our way, but I think with your help, we're starting to achieve that. Yeah, I think everything's been said. Just a couple things I want to add. As Joe said, we've set some milestones, especially the finance piece. Dan got that done. I think Dan came in at a pretty rough time, so I'm sure it's not been a joyride.

4:29:39 And I think a lot's been accomplished. I think there's still plenty to do. You know, if Joe and I remember, but it wasn't too long ago, the town had two town managers and a very costly expense to the taxpayer. Dan came in and worked on new salary ranges, scale, so to speak, you know, with management and took the job on the lower end. Right.

4:30:10 I agree. I think that the evaluation that we did and that he did himself was very in line with the council. So I'm very supportive of extending Dan's term. And we've talked about extending that as a two-year term. And Dan's accepted that term. Again, going back to

4:30:40 The salary range, Dan did come in on the low end of the pay range, and he actually set a lot of that himself, so could have set those higher, knowing our financial situation in the town and where we've been and where we have to go. So I'd like to have consensus that we have an agreement with a two-year extension.

4:31:07 Yep. I mean, that's what we discussed. It's crazy to think that Dan's been here almost two years already. But, you know, that's two years longer than most town managers for us recently. Maybe a year and a half longer. So, you know, I think two years in so far, we've gotten some things accomplished. We've got some things on track that, you know, another couple of years.

4:31:35 We should be able to wrap some of those things up. I think, you know, a two-year agreement is the right length of time. And my other question I have for Council is... I have one more question on the agreement. Sure. You know, because we did not actually see the agreement. We talked about term, but we didn't look at the other items that are within here. And I realize that I have no problem with the December of 2017.

4:32:03 Okay. And I'm just not sure if we are...

4:32:27 If we consider changes to that, as we've talked about 21st century and needing to make changes, is whether or not there'd be a reopener to this. That's a good point. And not having looked at it, we had not discussed that, so I'm not sure, maybe Andy, how would, is there, because I didn't see anything in here that's a reopener. As currently drafted, there isn't anything. If you would like to have me add some language, I can. It would be,

4:32:59 There's only a couple sections. I mean, the salary would be unaffected. Correct. Retirement. Would be, well, might be, yeah. Maybe. Maybe. I don't think you're going away from 2.7 to 55 for Dan. No. I was looking more at the leaves. Yeah, leave and maybe insurance. Mm-hmm. So, I mean, I could add some language in here indicating that to the extent that the town

4:33:28 Well, are you suggesting – Well, are you suggesting –

4:33:59 I all of a sudden realized that, oh, so this is, since we have all these different due dates, I'm suggesting that should we make, should we have to make changes to the benefits package for the other management employees because it's part of an MOU is could we discuss or negotiate those changes with Dan as well or would he be on the old set?

4:34:26 So you're saying not necessarily tie it to whatever happens in future negotiations, but just have the opportunity to work. Have the opener to consider it. So there's three ways to tackle this that I see. One is totally grandfather Dan, which is what you're saying, let's not do that. One is to have any amendments apply to Dan, no matter what, just sort of automatically. And then the third one, which is what you're describing, is a re-opener. Now, people talk about re-openers, but bear in mind,

4:34:55 That if you set it up that way, it will require Dan to agree. Yes, no, and that's, I know, and that's why it's really difficult to do this stuff. So if that's what you have in mind, we can add a sentence or two, but since you require Dan's consent to make any changes anyway, you really don't have to have any language in the agreement since any changes require his consent anyway.

4:35:18 Okay. Okay, because see, I didn't find the section that said that, you know, that you could change the agreement. We can add that. Okay. Is everybody else okay with that? Yeah. Just to have a little bit. How about Dan? Is Dan okay with that? Yeah, I mean, if we're going to change stuff for our employee base to come back and have that discussion at my level, I think that's reasonable to do that. Yeah, I'm comfortable with that. Okay. Okay, nice.

4:35:42 So our last discussion piece is the eligibility of up to 5% merit increase, which is in his agreement. So I'd like to kind of get some council feedback on this 5% merit, which applies to all staff, right? And Dan was very clear on the consent agenda, number 6, clarifying that for council.

4:36:11 Yeah. The word is up to, correct. So I'm going to defer a little bit to maybe council members who have been here for a little bit longer and folks who have maybe a little more experience in these kinds of matters. I think what's important is that the merit in terms of the signal that it sends or does not send to the staff and to the community reflects our confidence in Dan as the town manager. I have enormous confidence in him. I'm very much looking forward to the future.

4:36:41 And I want to provide a merit that's appropriate to what he's been doing. My sense it's 5%, but that's a signal that's sent out to the community. This is not unexpected. This makes sense. If you believe this guy's going to do a good job, that's what he should be getting. If council's any other, if I'm off on that, I would appreciate your insights, but I want to make sure that we're, that the signal that we're sending, that component of it is we have confidence and faith in this guy and the merit that he's receiving.

4:37:09 Is commiserate with that support and trust? And just to reiterate and clarify, this is already, all the merit increases are already budgeted. Right. Okay. Is this one budgeted? Yeah, we took a look at everything that Adam built in, because of the unknown, you don't want to be short, if you will. Well, I did. Well, it's in the agreement to be considered again after the next evaluation. Yeah, double check that, yeah, so that.

4:37:40 It's not an odd, you know, it's always based on evaluation and review. I actually asked Andy to give me the individual ones and, you know, depending on the percentage you get, essentially if it's a 5%, it's going to put him at a little over 168, which is still within the range, less than we have covered before, but...

4:38:03 I just want to make sure everybody understood that it was $168,389 because the monthly one doesn't make much sense just when we're looking at it. So it's still putting it at mid-range. Seeing as he has not had any kind of a merit increase, I think that that's appropriate. But one of the reasons for looking at the lower amounts, which are, you know, slightly less, like $166 something, is that yes, 5% is

4:38:30 A norm, but when you get up to higher level salaries, it is a much bigger number. Yeah, of course. Understood. That's good input. I was going to ask if there are any merit increases in the first two years that there were none. Yeah, I think that's an important point. There's been no merit increase to this point.

4:39:00 Also, I think it is important that we are cognizant of the fact that when Dan came in, he consciously accepted a lower salary than what we had paid previously. And I think that's important to note. From my conversations, it seems as if a lot of the eligible employees have received merit increases over the last couple of years. Is that a correct statement? Yes. Okay.

4:39:31 But you were, of course, suggesting that they all earned them. Of course. I was curious at a frequency. Yeah. So again, I go back to kind of my earlier comments. Dan came in on the lower end. Dan helped craft this new management structure that we now have, and I think that's helped us to, as we talked before, live within our means.

4:39:57 And the fact that he has not had a merit increase, I'd be supportive of a 5% increase. And I'm prepared to make a motion to extend this contract with the language that Joe wanted to add. And approve the increase? And approve the increase. So the motion would be that Council approve the amended employment agreement with Town Manager Daniel C. Holler and authorize the Mayor to sign the agreement, too, based on the performance evaluation of the manager.

4:40:29 Authorized approval of a 5% merit pay increase. With the additional language? With the additional language, correct. I'll second. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Dan? On a clarifying question, the way we have it structured now, that would be effective January 1. I just want to confirm that. The way the language is currently in the salary section of the agreement. We actually have to merit out a way, so it's your call to leave it that way or not. Yeah, I'm fine with that. Yeah.

4:40:59 Consensus. Right. That's essentially your anniversary date? That's fine. Dan, that's essentially your anniversary date? It was the evaluation date, February, so that ties to that, yes. It is now. It is now, yeah. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Dan, you're stuck with us. Thank you. Thank you. We'll now adjourn to our next regular meeting.

4:41:32 To be held Wednesday, September 16th, 2015, 6 p.m. in the Council Chambers. And just a reminder, I will not be here. Noted.