Town Council Special meeting
· recording 3 hr 26 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
340 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:19 Thank you.
1:34 So I need, there's one hand out, there's two hand out.
2:03 Thank you.
2:16 All right.
3:34 Thank you.
6:08 Thank you very much.
10:31 Everybody welcome back. Thanks for joining us. I'm going to call the order our special meeting for Thursday, September 10th.
10:58 I pledge to Jesus to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
11:40 What we did in the first workshop was we took the existing
12:11 The strategic plan was developed by the town in August 2014, and we engaged in something called a performance tune-up, the strategic plan tune-up, and we reassigned the existing strategies and commitments to set up categories, ones that we would keep, ones that were complete, ones that we would keep as is, ones that would be revised and deleted. We were able to go through and reduce the total scope.
12:42 of those existing commitments by working on behalf of us or so. And we published all of that data back to you. We have that additional work that day in setting direction and looking at the council's wants and expectations for this process going forward. And we started to look at things like how you communicate with the second workshop, which all of you participated in a number more than 25 years.
13:20 This is how, I think this is how this is going to go, it just gets smaller and smaller. And then the serious, the serious wagon pullers that stayed together. What we did last night, everybody remember what we did at the last workshop? What did we do? We worked on our values, and we actually called those core community values, but we framed them from the perspective of each of your role as both a resident citizen and
13:56 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
14:24 Your priorities, MLR, MLT, MLH, and ESPA, to make sure that we understood how you saw the near-term in particular, and it was pretty near-term focused, and where you saw clear alignment between what you were working on and committed to, and how that aligns with the town's priorities going forward. And that's all captured in this document that has the repeated reading ahead of it.
14:53 So remember we had this whole map of a sticky wall and there were tons of items up there and it all got reduced to just this three-page framework. You may recall that we looked at alignment in four different ways and for our discussion purposes I said they ranged from powerful alignment at the most impactful end to purposeful alignment.
15:22 We're going to try and stretch some of those ideas out over a much longer time.
15:55 And we did the core community values piece in the afternoon, late morning or early afternoon. And that's captured here on this document. There were kind of five in the yellow. The question that we used is at the top in the yellow. A little canary color there were the titles or names that you gave to how you would describe these core community values. And then immediately below it, we kind of put you to an exercise.
16:25 Thank you.
16:54 And of course, at the very end of that, when we talked about it at the last session, about how do you communicate across your organizations, within your organizations, and most powerfully within your community, so that the community becomes active, enthusiastic, not just raving fans, to use the marketing, but active ambassadors.
17:23 So that, by design, Dan and I kind of spoke out this process. We imagined that we would tune up the existing council plan that the council and the staff provide an organizing center of gravity. We called that and we said the force that you want to exert
17:54 The community is not centrifugal, but centrifugal, you want to pull in to that center concept, the contributions and resources of each of the respective communities with this simple idea that the more that you're working together, the same mental, emotional, and philosophical vision of the future, the more that you're committed to the same priorities.
18:24 The same ways of executing on those priorities, the more likely you are to build simple agreements, maybe not always 5-0 votes, but at least substantial votes in favor of policies, investments, funding strategies, commitments. We want it to become as the most of these apart because we're going to do a little bit of, this is not navel-gazing, this is actual vision.
19:03 How many of you have done, what was your experience doing? Tedious. Tedious, why? The words meaning of a conversation, the words meaning of a dialogue. Yeah, words meaning of a dialogue. So vision sometimes gets lost in the language that we use. What else? What's been your experience of vision? In fact, diversity is a strength, but a weakness in vision. Otherwise, you get kind of tunnel vision, to borrow a phrase.
19:51 And that tunnel vision can be framed by the organization and the mission that you have, not the community and the mission that the community has. To the extent that we're all in service to the larger community, that's where we want to work. Anybody else have a different experience or insight of that vision? You start adding words to make everybody happy. You start adding words to make everybody happy. Yeah, I'm going to make sure that we're out.
20:20 Yeah, so that, so the sense of inclusiveness, visioning can outrun the usefulness. And it can be used. And it can be used. And what? You sit down with a bunch of people to help with a vision statement, understand that that thing's going to show up. Yeah. Do you see it on documents? Do you see it? I did a quick scan again last night just to remind me.
20:50 But I went back and I scanned 10 tourism-driven communities around the country that tout their mission work as state of the art. And 9 of the 10 had 9 different ways of saying the same thing.
21:20 In the future, we will be better than we are today. And we will be the best that we could possibly become. It sounds like the Marines vision. And so I long, long, long time ago stopped thinking about visioning as a statement, not as a sentence, not as a carefully crafted, maybe I just...
21:47 That's a fully totally exactly. A carefully crafted attempt to include a lot of ideas in nine words. That's not really what visioning is. So I'm going to tell you a little story, but I'm going to invite Christy, because we were standing out in the hall for a long time having a preview of this meeting. So you were starting to ask me a question. I thought it was a good question to ask me.
22:17 Yes. It's kind of a two-part question. One, how did you get interested in how did you actually get into this? Yes, thank you for asking me that question in front of the group at this particular time. So I can tell you a quick little story about my journey and my vision. And it's just a five-minute version. And I don't throw this in to take your time, but actually to tee up the work that I think we might do. So I spent the first 20 years of my career doing clinical behavior change work.
22:50 I was a clinician. And so my first master's degree was in clinical analysis. And I worked in schools, governmental settings, and private center settings, working with individual students, families, and caregivers. And many of you have had any of special ed and other mechanisms. And I've worked with autism and serious emotional disturbance and schizophrenics. And I, in my particular career,
23:28 And I learned something over those years, which is two lessons. One is that behavior change is extremely hard, extremely hard to do and execute. Two is you can do it when your mind is right about helping an individual move. And working one individual at a time and one student at a time requires a very thoughtful, scripted, flexible, adaptive self.
24:07 Thank you.
24:40 All of the children were incarcerated because they had disabilities. They developed 24-hour care programs. I could go on and on. It was a great part of my life. But after 20 years, I was exhausted. Along the way, I had to learn how to train trainers, train other people. Promote the same set of events by helping other people be the meat leaders of change. And that required a lot of staff development. Train the trainer capacity.
25:24 Around 1994, I decided 20 years was long enough. I was pretty tired. I had five kids of my own. I was thinking, you know, what's really appealing to me now is not working one individual at a time, but working in groups. So I went and got certified as a professional facilitator so I could begin working in a group context. I started to evolve a vision. And what I was trying to do when I changed careers was
25:58 I'm trying to figure out, well, I know what my skills are, because I have all this education, I have a couple of undergraduate degrees, investors in education, instructional design, student agile teaching, and so I always had a really diverse skill set. I wasn't really sure what my talents were. I just knew that I've been effective, but I wasn't sure if my talents and my passions, I just knew I was paying bills and caring for my kids.
26:41 With a particular skill set that was paying me pretty good money. But I wasn't really happy. I thought, okay, what do I want to do? So I started investigating my own talents, what really motivated me to get up every day, what really inspired me to want to become more skillful, more impactful, more useful to people that I work with.
27:10 How many of you know the difference between inspiration and motivation? Picture that. So motivation, by definition, is what happens when you get a hold of an idea and you don't let it go until you're fulfilled. You're motivated. You get up every day thinking about it. You say, I'm going to do this thing. I'm going to build workplace housing. Inspiration is the reverse. It's when the idea gets a hold of you. I'm going to let you go. I'm a powerful force.
27:58 I wanted to work nationally. I wanted to work internationally.
28:35 I wanted to figure out how to craft a life in which I could have all those things that's going to be paid for. So that's how I started that path of facilitation, because I found that it was sort of sector agnostic, and that I had good planning skills, good development skills, and I could be to honor that one. And over the next 20 years, I've, so I'm now on my second full career. I've been able to work in 20 years.
29:09 And I guess what I realized was my vision wasn't a statement. It wasn't wanted. A series of ideas that tapped into what inspired me, get me up every day. My wife is retired and said, what was this to me? I'm 62 now. She says, you know, you can retire.
29:46 So they put a lot more time on the trails instead of working to develop the trails and say, you know, I get up every city's better. And it's a small little play in that. We do not want to do that work. So my idea of vision is you figure out who you are, what your talents are, what your passions are, what difference you want to make in the world, on what scale, local, regional, state, national,
30:24 And you figure out whether or not you're willing to, whether or not you're willing to cooperative work entity. It's not really efficient. It's a commitment to maybe different, maybe better, maybe just enhanced. That's a look that I'd like. We've got a series of strategic priorities and commitments. Those commitments lay out what the town will focus on and how the NGOs can align the role and function.
31:05 We did the give and get exercise and all those things. We got a lot of data together. We haven't operationalized that yet. We haven't played on the ground. And we haven't given it a long-term content. We haven't said, well, wait, here we are in 2015. Let's go out some input. Right now, our strategic priorities will all be executed by 2017. We'll look at the plan we have. Then what? We'll just keep coming back.
31:35 Thank you.
32:01 We're going to look back to look forward. We're going to craft a combination of images and outcomes that reflect who you are, what your actual talents are, what your actual capabilities are, where you're going as organizations. We're going to take all of that.
32:29 And roll it into a structure that you can actually measure, develop policy around, talk about, strategize around. And when we come back, as I said, we're going to end today giving you all the homework assignments. And we're going to come back in four weeks, get the homework assignment completed, and we're going to go all in and through this slide on October 12, revised date of October 8.
33:00 October 12th is a Monday. In the afternoon like this, when we want to modify it, we're going to actually roll forward a detailed 18-month action plan that isn't just the town's action plan and the staff and council, but a combined, integrated, fully functional action plan, and we're going to vet and discuss all the underlying contradictions that might keep you from actually
33:32 So before I ask people to do something hard,
34:07 Ask them to do an easier version of it. So if I can find a partner, it could be somebody from opposite you, next to you, or across the group, you decide. We have an even number 246, 18, 12, perfect, 20, so it should be 10 pairs. Individuals identify your partner right now by making eye contact.
34:36 Alright, everybody has a partner? Anybody missing a partner? You were all good at the junior high school dance. You did not stand on the wall too long. Alright, I want you first to think and then to dialogue with your partner. The thing you're going to think about is, where do I see myself in 2025? Where do I see myself in 2025? What am I doing?
35:09 Why is that important to me today? Where do I see myself in 2025? What am I doing? And why is that important to me today? And then I want you to have a conversation with your partner and exchange the information so when I ask for some report outs, your partner will share your relationships. 2025, where do I see myself? What am I doing? And you're going to have only three minutes per person.
35:44 to exchange this. So I find the vision that is done on top of mind is the best. Ready, set, begin.
40:28 30 seconds, finish up.
40:57 10 seconds.
41:27 And we'll call time. So I'm looking for some volunteers, like a couple of volunteers to share the vision. Where are you in 2025? What are you doing and why?
41:56 That you learned from your partner. Brent, go first. Listen to the great, I can't wait. He loves what he does. Someday he will retire, but he won't retire. He has such a love for community and helping others. He has the skill set to consult and help his community grow. So I'm pretty excited for him.
42:26 I think it's a great game plan. Fantastic. Is that a fair representation? Yeah. Yeah? Do you want to share, Chris? Yeah. We want to keep him around as well because in 10 years, he's also going to be mostly retired, but he won't be living here probably in Montana or in his latest with his grandkids. Again, mostly retired, but again, involved with the community. But hopefully, he's made enough money in the next 10 years where he can travel more and have the freedom to do those things without having to worry about. And that's what he does. Let's change the communities.
42:55 He's really enjoyed building the Chamber of Commerce really from the ground up here in the last few months. So a next stage of life, but very similar, expressing passions in similar ways, and Montana and entities could not be more different, so that's a pretty nice question. I interviewed Dan, and in 10 years, Dan also expects to be retired and wants to spend his time
43:23 Continuing his mission work in third world countries and also spending time with his family. And we talked about how he's already doing mission work and the way that affects his work-a-day environment is it allows him to take a global perspective about what's going on both in our community and in the world, allowing him to have perspective but also to remain calm and be balanced.
43:52 Drive to make a difference and impact communities positively, whether it's this community or a community in Uganda. That's impressive. So, Dan's vision is that in 10 years, he'll be expressing his passion in a channel that's familiar to him, but in a very specific way. But he's actually performing much that same work now, and he sees his future vision in his day-to-day work today. In part.
44:26 This is a super important idea that I want you to latch on to. We won't do this with everybody, but you want to give us a question while we're at it? Her passion is teaching, not necessarily her full-time necessarily. Today, right now, she looks at that as a skill session to do. What I would be doing, or whatever that is. So a second example of sort of living, and then with you guys, living today, the values that people carry you.
45:12 Tomorrow, the specific instance of what that will look like is less important. Who else? Somebody from this table? Sure. Okay, this is Jo. She'll be in Mammoth, and what she's very involved with, everybody understands, she's not going to be on council. She'll have the time, you know, interpretive work, and why that's important. She knew in the mid-80s that she... I love that. So in a sense, you see that you've been on this journey.
46:11 And 2025 is another iteration of that journey, and you're all in. It'll only be my third retirement. I'm going to make you the poster child. You're the poster child for our visioning session. Okay? Want to give us a chance? Sure. Shields is still going to be in, but he's also going to be splitting time sailing the South Seas. Grew up as a saver, because that's the first question. You do know how to sail.
46:43 He's going to slow down on how much he is working in order to accommodate that. But his reason for being here and why it's important is he has two daughters who live and work here and he wants to see that Mammoth can reach its potential and that they have a community. Yeah, thanks for that. So I'm going to tell you a little story about some kids here in a moment. And I love that your vision is attached to opportunity.
47:10 And experience for your own kids. That's part of how we think about vision. It's not, we externalize our own frame of reference, I want to sail, but we also try to encompass a bigger set of community interests. Very nice. How, somebody from this take me this. Sure. It was, our vision was very similar, so I'll probably overlap a little bit, but she intends to be in Mammoth.
47:41 We talked about some specifics like, you know, having a family, owning a home, those type of things, but more along the lines of just being established in this community. She said she would love to take over Rich's job because he's going to just be so, so old in 10 years. 10 years, you've got to deal. We won't be able to do it anymore. 20.5 years. SEW, SEW old? Yeah.
48:08 She's just waiting in the wings for when Ritz can no longer... I thought I liked you. Today's your last day. Don't drink the coffee. Stewie, be quiet. So, but, you know, her vision was really along, you know, being established in this community ten years from now. That's why she is getting involved now as a younger person because, you know, she sees this vision of where Mammoth can be.
48:38 So in a lot of strategic planning processes of late, we're talking about succession planning because of the great gray baby boom wave that's about to leave the workplace. But the conversation gets kind of stuck in the techniques of succession planning instead of the visionary aspect, which is, I see where this community can be, and I want to be an instrument. Want to give us a comment?
49:18 Colin, very similar, you know, like he, you know, came here to Mammoth, the black tie skis, and wants to continue to own that business, maybe other businesses someday, but, you know, laying up the groundwork now for being able to live in a prosperous and positive community in the future, you know, wanting to own a home, have a family.
49:46 I guess, you know, same age range, so. Very nice. And thanks for adding this sort of develop and operate a business and expanding that business to another key part of the vision of the future you're trying to create. Rich, what were you going to add? I want to piggyback on Leslie's conversation. Sure, sure. I think we make a good pair because of the maturity of age and the young millennium. You know, I think it's imperative for all of us to begin to think about succession plans. Yes. You know, our conversation with Leslie, what are you going to be in 10 years?
50:15 What do you want to be doing to grow up? What are you willing to do to get there? Learn as much as you can. Because we need to think about that. As we build these organizations, who is in the pipeline? We have the right people in the right seats. Are we bringing them along so we're able to continue the work we're doing? Yes, I think it's so important that, just to build on your comment even further, when you're planning your community's future, you don't want to simply plan from within the base of
50:44 Capability and capacity you now have. Your goal has to be to create the community that attracts the people who are not here today that will come here and become part of that new leadership and will fill those new roles and become established and develop businesses and want to make an impact and express talents they've developed in some other location and develop those here further. You've also got a base of young people.
51:12 Who are growing up here, you have a strong service sector. So that service sector is putting families on the ground here, kind of one foot in, if I can be candid about this, kind of one foot in the community and one foot not sure. If we were doing this vision exercise in a different part of town, we might have a really less clear set of ideas about what 2025 looks like. It might start sounding like.
51:41 Well, I know where I don't want to be in 2025. I know what I don't want to be doing. But I'm hopeful that I can get from where I am to this other place. So it's that hopefulness and your willingness to commit to a long-term vision that becomes key to growing the community you have and attracting the world in the future. Anybody else had anything that was just public?
52:10 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
52:40 As far as John, I think John will be the Executive Director of a big state for a larger destination. John enjoys what he does here and he is looking to continue to grow, grow the destination. He will also return as a GM of a major ski resort. So I think John's got a couple kids that are growing up.
53:10 He's been working for a while. He's got his money into a couple of college funds. So big ambitions are also part of the vision. We actually see ourselves in the future more capable, more able, and more successful than we see ourselves today. It's very natural. The gap between where we are and where we want to be sometimes can seem difficult to figure out. How am I going to get from here to there?
53:39 And in a sense, as community leaders, that's actually your challenge in strategic planning is not just to plant flags in the future and say, I want like the other nine of ten sites I looked at and everybody said I want a better town than I have today. I don't know what to do with that vision statement. So I guess we just kind of keep tinkering away. That's not going to get you there. You need a very clear sense of where you're going so that you know when you've arrived.
54:07 And then you need an effective pathway for actually navigating that course. So each of you brings your own vision. And to Joe's comment earlier, your vision for the town and the community really is, without adding words one at a time, the sum of your personal aspirations. And your aspirations are driven by that which inspires you. And I think we just heard a dozen different examples.
54:37 So I want you to keep all of that in mind as I put you through a series of four, maybe five different exercises to see if we can't surface out a meaningful picture of what your future will look like, not in a sentence, but in a series of images and outcomes. Okay? So that's what we're going to do. We're going to build on the dialogue that you just had, who you are, where you're going,
55:06 What you're going to be doing and why it's important to you. Many of you are rehearsing today the skill sets that you see having currency in the future and we're trying to build on that. I want to remind you that my purpose for doing all of this and keep carrying this forward was to define and activate a strategy-driven process. It just means a purposeful process.
55:31 It clearly aligns and integrates all of your respective organizational roles and functions with the town to achieve sustainable economic security for your community. Sustainable economic security is the centerpiece. And it's just consultant speak for we're not broke, we're not bankrupt, we're not reliant on a single economic revenue stream, we have some diversity.
55:59 We're resilient when there's drought. We're resilient when there's economic cycling taking place around us at the national level, the regional level, the state level. We're resilient in the face of unplanned, unexpected episodes and occurrences. They could be in the natural environment, the social environment. They could be in the policy environment. It could have been SB 350.
56:27 Why would that have been? It did not pass. Why would that have been? It did not pass. Why would that?
56:54 Whatever you may think about climate change in that situation, why might that have been a disaster for the town of Mammoth Lakes that is physically, geographically isolated from distant communities who reliance on people driving and flying here from some distance? 50% reduction in consumption would have impacted your economy in an adverse way. You would have had to adapt. You would adapt.
57:22 So I wanted to take you through a series of exercises. Here's the first one I put on your table. There's three different color cards, half sheets. They're yellow, they're canary, orange, and white. I want you to look to the
57:52 The canary sheets first. I put some of these fine point sharpie markers on the table. You recall from our work last time, I'd like you to turn these horizontally or landscape view. It's just easier to move stuff around on this wall, which is also landscape format. I want you to think about the last 10 years. From 2005 to 2015, I want you to think about
58:24 What has changed in your community that you're proud of and continues to inspire you? And you can think individually as a resident or you can think through the lens of your organization or in my preferred mode you would do both. And I'd like you to write one change or outcome or shift.
58:54 Remember, these can be – I'm not just looking for the names of buildings. They can be very tangible. They can be intangible. They can be impressions. You decide what's changed that you're proud of and continues to inspire you. And I'd like you to put a date on it, if you will. You know, some year between 2005 and 2015.
59:22 But when you're done writing them, I want you to come up and post them on the wall here. Below this blue line, in this space here, corresponding to the year. Individually? Individually. Yeah. This will give you some exercise. Between three of these exercises, we'll get you about 50 calories. Awesome. So some of these things were brought online. I don't know when they were brought online, but I've only experienced them moving back to the community.
59:54 How do I deal with that? For you, for you, just put it down. The canary one? The canary one. One per? Yeah, one per. One per. I got a lot. Yeah, go ahead and put them up. We'll overlap them and we'll stamp them over. Accomplishments, outcomes, the shift, change.
1:00:31 Thank you for the last 10 years. More than one? Pardon me? More than one? If you've got more than one, you want one. You achieve. You achieve. You achieve. It's magical. It actually takes your ideas and makes things stronger. I just, I want to edit them out as much as you move around and it's important.
1:01:24 You don't have to be neat and orderly, just give them a home.
1:02:00 So LP is long, long, long, long, long, long.
1:03:43 Anybody else? Anything else? Okay.
1:04:09 So let's see what we got here. Kind of quick impressions. We're not going to read all of them. So 2005, I'm going to go bookend this thing. Establish a successful business. Enhance the concept of adapting our government model.
1:04:38 The Lakes Basin Bike Path, 2012, a couple times on here. The MLR Board was established, 2014. Continuing to drive visitation during a historic drought. Enormous, affected outcome. The Mammoth Lakes New Library, a community-level asset. We approved air service, 2008, to the president. Important.
1:05:07 Asset connecting you to your future in both a real and metaphorical way. We have a new middle school back in 2005. What did that do for the community? What did the new middle school do for the community? It made those parents and those kids really proud. Yeah, because they weren't just trailers. Yes, proud parents are more likely to stay. Somebody put college up here.
1:05:38 I think Dan did. What he means is our community college. The community college was established. Yes. The Sierra Coastal campus. Right. An official California welcome center. What did that do for the community? Lens a lot of credibility. Yes. Puts us on maps. Puts you on a map in a very both formal and tangible way.
1:06:06 Televising better public access to public meetings. What did that do? For transparency. For transparency. Yes, okay. Greater choice in restaurants, 2005. What did that do for all of you? You can see what it did to me. Thank you for that testimony.
1:06:33 Inspired by the growth of young 20 to 30-somethings coming into our community. So that's kind of built on the idea that we were just talking about. Succession isn't a mechanical concept. It's actually about real people becoming community leaders. 2013, we were forced to become physically responsible. You can move that back to 2005. So in a sense,
1:07:02 I was mentioning at lunch today the old African problem about turning liabilities into assets. You know, resilient communities are particularly good at taking what look like negative events and saying, how do we grow from that? How do we become better? How do we move in the direction of our imagined best future? That's our vision. Let's see. Mammoth Lakes found a key.
1:07:32 For our family to be able to live in a ski town, our dream. It's a vision statement already realized in 2015. So that's a vision looking to be exploited further, inspired by the number of people willing to commit to community service. Something that I sit outside or I get to observe as I come and go here. And trail development and so on and so on. So a pretty, that was just a quick and dirty download.
1:08:03 A pretty impressive array of accomplishments in the last 10 years. You've just practiced the process of thinking about your own 10-year best future going forward. So let me prompt you with a couple of additional attempts to inspire you a little bit. And then we're going to move to the right-hand side of the screen here. And we're going to say if that's what the last 10 years were like, let's imagine what the next 10 years are going to be like. We'll go out to 2015.
1:08:32 I've kind of a little device for framing this, so I'll pass this around, just so you get a mental image. This is a picture of a group of eight-year-olds from an elementary school being led a hike in the wilderness, and these are eight-year-olds that had no prior alpine hiking experience. So this is their first exposure.
1:08:59 I want you to imagine that these are eight-year-olds in your community. They're eight-year-olds in the school district. And in 2025, they're going to graduate with a lot of expectations about the future. And the challenge I want to give you is to identify a vision for 2025 that will create a platform for them to begin to realize their own dreams, their own ambitions.
1:09:29 Some of them will not stay. Others will have to choose between staying and going. And the choice will have as much to do with what you are able to put on the ground to support the community you can build and sustain, how you talk to one another, how you solve problems, what resources are in place and what opportunities there are, as you guys were testifying to. So 2025.
1:10:00 Those eight-year-olds are going to graduate from high school full of expectations. Their challenge is to not disappoint them. And I want to suggest that this is a quote from Jonathan Swift. I can't see it from the back. Jonathan Swift said, the art of vision is seeing what is invisible to others. Why is it invisible to others? Why might vision be invisible to others? Why is there an art to see?
1:10:40 Because it hasn't happened yet. Because it hasn't happened yet. So that's the art of it. What separates those who can look out 10 years and make a connection to the future from those who can't see it at all? Anybody? Imagination. Imagination. The future is completely about imagination. In fact, this is the way I think about it. It's something I did for another group at different times. This is my own reminiscence.
1:11:17 We looked back and looked at sort of your retroactive vision of accomplishment in order to move forward with the next phase of this. So I think that vision emerges at that intersection between what you've already done, your memory, and your imagination. It's what you are hopeful about. It's the combination of all of your personal aspirations
1:11:47 Rolled together into organizations that are trying to actually build things. Great momentum. So your challenge on the orange cards is to begin to imagine the year 2025. It's just 10 years. This is literally a two-eye blades from that. My youngest son,
1:12:17 I still look out at the world through 18-year-old eyes. Anybody else struggling with this? Yeah, all the guys that are older and closer to my age all raise their hands. Thank you for that. So I still see the world through 18-year-old eyes. My youngest son is 32 years old. I just graduated my granddaughter from high school. I don't know how this happened. I don't know how this happened.
1:12:46 She was just born. He was just born. It was just two idlings ago. Ten years is nothing. You can take ten years to plan, discuss, analyze, overanalyze, take baby steps, iterate like this to the future, or you can get bold and say, I want to expand my business. I want to create impact for my community. I want to do all things.
1:13:17 You all just told me our vision. And I think we can get there in 2025. Maybe you see that there's a couple of incremental steps that would be useful along the way, but get us out here. Think about family, community, resources, assets. What's different in 2025 that would inspire you to want to share that story?
1:13:49 With others. What's going on? If you're super ambitious, you want to drag us out a full generation, I've got 235 plans today. 2025, what should be in place that's not there now? Maybe it builds on this foundation. Maybe it's brand new. Populate the lower half on the right side, just the lower half.
1:14:23 Orange cards. Family. Community. Resources. One card per idea. What will keep you here in 2025 or bring you back if you have plans to go away? Your kids or your neighbors to stay if they can just solve a problem that presently holds them back.
1:15:56 You can be as didactic or as abstract as you like. To translate that, you can be conceptual or you can be completely measurable.
1:18:01 Anybody else? Yeah, Shields is still working over here. Okay.
1:18:30 Anybody else? All right, let's debrief this. I'm going to take another step. Then we'll take a short break and do the rest of it.
1:18:59 Let me get you back. Let's take 10 minutes and we'll take a short break. So what's cool about this, from my impression, is you have as much vision for the future as you have accomplishments over the last 10 years. That's very encouraging. I've actually seen groups put four cards up and get stuck. So you're not lacking for vision. Let's see what kinds of things in the short term. Strong community pride.
1:19:27 Every person who wants to live in Maryland can affordably and safely. That builds on one of the core sets of strategic priorities that are in this document here and also builds on the You Can Live Here core value framework. Let's see. A welcoming business environment early on. A new police station early on. This is in the works now.
1:19:57 A new airport terminal. These are early on. These are a new airport terminal and expanded air services. These are kind of enabling outcomes that you have to get in place early in a 10-year cycle in order to get to the big 10-year outcomes. A world-class resort community. Parking crisis solved. A bunch of stuff on airport. Improved infrastructure. Multi-use facility for these departments.
1:20:29 M.H. Banff Lakes Housing? Airport. Airport? Oh, that's their airport. Like LAX or ATL. LAX. A digital 395-based business sector, this goes to your economic diversification strategy, a new town hall. What will the new town hall do? Crime. Crime. Crime.
1:21:00 Accessibly. Better efficiency. Amplified arts and culture programs and facilities, what would that be for the community about halfway out? What would that be for the community? Vibrant community. More open, more vibrant, more identity, more reasons to stay. Strong sense of community.
1:21:31 Be the best Alpine Recreation Community in the country, set a very high bar for that. Better year-round jobs available, all these other communities stronger than that. Sustainable economic security, which yields on our framework there. Mr. Mayor, a $22 million budget, not in 2025, but sometime soon. How big a shift is that from where you are today?
1:22:00 It's 18, 15. So it's a 20, but it's a 20%. Yeah, 20%. Yeah. All right. Mammoth Lakes Region is a thriving U.S. O.S. I didn't say it's Olympic Committee. Olympic Committee National. Okay, high altitude training center. All right. NLR focus project. Mammoth Lakes has a vibrant, powerful K-14 school system. Why is this important?
1:22:30 In 2025. Great schools, great communities. Great schools, great communities. I mean, the best way to think about it is to think about the alternatives, right? The ultimate gentrification is no young people, no families, at least not here on full-time basis. You can't build a community.
1:23:00 Hopefully, we have a community that's trying to find its way right now.
1:23:33 Find its direction. Who do we want to become? Hopefully in 2025 everybody's on board and going for that similar thing. A culture of stewardship toward the mountains and trails. Somebody in here had 100 miles of, who is it? Over 100 miles of new well-designed single track trails.
1:24:04 Lots of stone and water. So those are three different wishes. Sustainable integration of a vibrant community and its unique place, self-sustaining economy, increased career opportunities, better coexistence with wildlife. So that's kind of all about the place, which is consistent with the values you guys illuminated. Joe was first up here, I think. Sustainable economies of the 18-year-olds.
1:24:34 Is there anything about that depiction of 2025 that is
1:25:04 Surprising to anybody? Pretty familiar stuff, yeah? Is there anything that's missing? I guess I would just add that, you know, there's been talk about some blighted buildings and what we're going to do with the weird frontage roads on Main Street. Translate that into gibbous because you started with blight and then it started with something really concrete. Okay, let me break it down like this.
1:25:55 Just like not pulling any punches. I would like to have a more beautiful one. Wow, that's what I was thinking. Right behind you. Storyboard. Shields, what did you call this? The Shields plan. Okay, storyboards, I think. Story examples. Yeah, that's, I mean, I put up there smart development content. What you see up there is just the plans we have in place right now. There's many others to come. But right there, my guess, my development.
1:26:38 Understanding, and I've been, that's about 20 years, that's not an overnight vision, that's going to take a while, and so, and there'll be changes to that, and that's the whole idea, but that's our vision now, and it's okay for that, but we've got to do smart development. We're going to call that 2035, and before I come to you, I want you to find a way to cross the bridge from Blight to a beautiful town, and what will be different in 2025, when you think about putting it on the yellow card.
1:27:21 So you've kind of circled around a couple cards around 2021 related to it all about a shady rest track. Shady rest track. Shady rest track. Shady rest track. But I'd like to be a little more general and just say sufficient, you know, an adequate supply of housing. So this one, very nice. This one says the shady rest track house is only setting to workforce households. Let's leave the very concrete cost back. Better for jobs, these start to co-locate a residential neighborhood in shady rest.
1:27:55 The more stable year-round economy.
1:28:29 So the more stable the year-round economy, what? Is that risk? The more stable the year-round economy is at risk. John, you started to say how things are tied to Japanese. Yeah, I think if you're talking about, you know, Michael put up there a $22 million budget somewhere around 2022, I think for a lot of the things prior to that posted, it has to be earlier in order to accomplish those things. You need the resources or you need the plans in advance.
1:28:55 Yeah, the terminal, the airport terminal, which is up there a couple of times, I mean, realistically, we have approval for that. We are looking at probably 2019 to have that completed, so that's a fairly easy one to say that that's the time frame, but the rest of the stuff, I think, is really going to depend on. And the more we can grow visitation, the more we can grow measure our measure view, get Rich more money to work with, get us more money to market with, get the town, you know, town keeps 65% of TOT, so if we get up to a...
1:29:20 So I want to make a distinction between how many of you have project management experience or have project management training? Good, good. I can use this example. So project management, we talk a lot about dependencies and dependent relationships between tasks. I don't want you to think like a project manager when you're doing vision and work.
1:29:46 Because that starts to put you in the process of iterating steps. I think what John's hinting at here is there's certain things that you need to do early that need to be in place where all the rest of your vision collapses like dominance. They just can't be realized. If we've built a vision statement that was just kind of the sum of these ideas,
1:30:15 And we didn't put on the ground some of the specific investments that are necessary to create them. The vision would serve no purpose. My sense is you have a mix of two things up here. You've got outcomes and images. Some of these are just images. Some are outcomes. And that's actually how visioning works. It's a mix of images and outcomes. Some are tangible. Some are abstract.
1:30:53 Some we can see it in our mind's eye. Some we just see us in our mind's eye, living differently, living better. We put ourselves in that picture. We're going to take a little break. I'm going to do a little bit of rearrangement. When we come back, we're going to take all these large cards, and we're going to sort them into images and outcomes. And then we're going to translate all of this into a giant mind map. Does that sound interesting? Yeah? Really?
1:31:22 We're going to have a vision you can actually realize. A vision you can realize. Okay, so how about 15 minutes? Matthew 15, 17, 18, something like that.
1:31:58 Thank you.
1:32:24 Wow. Well, that's a lot better.
1:32:54 Thank you.
1:33:23 No, he's done this school. He's getting married until the third.
1:33:52 He went to school there for a year because there was a receptacle in Montana.
1:34:51 Hey, Michael, I had a request for you. Did you distill that?
1:35:05 Yes, that was the last name of the next line. Yeah, so I actually planned a variety of the last names, but all of this is going to get delivered to the digital panel. So in fact, everything is going to get delivered as part of the panel at this moment.
1:36:44 Howdy. Howdy. What's happening, man? How are you? Just give me a wall report here.
1:37:03 It's good stuff to talk about. Yeah.
1:37:32 Thank you.
1:37:49 I think that his is the wildlife one. I was like, did Sam sleep after that one?
1:38:59 I'm glad you're here.
1:41:24 Michael, I'm so sorry I didn't ask if you wanted anything downstairs from Starbucks. There's no line. You need a little jolt.
1:41:53 Thank you.
1:42:21 Yeah, that voice is very elaborate.
1:44:12 Oh, really? Oh, really?
1:44:41 Very good.
1:45:59 I like that. Can they still do that in the middle of it?
1:46:29 I think I went too fast.
1:46:58 Thank you.
1:47:27 Okay, shall we reconvene? He is 318. What if you guys added a card, right?
1:47:50 Nice. 2035? Around then. I think it might be 2036. It's close enough. Oh, I know. Yes. We have that date behind. Okay, we're going to do a little calibration work. I put up on these...
1:48:18 On these yellow cards, two words, images and outcomes. What does the word images convey to you? What do you think about when I put that word up there? What are images? Visuals. Visuals. Visuals. Say again? Things that words can't really describe. Things that words can't really describe. What else? I was just going to say visual. Visuals. Visceral. Tangible. Tangible.
1:48:47 What else? Images. What do you think of with images? It's a thousand one explanation and it's simplified. How do we experience images? Emotions. Emotions. Emotionally. We connect with images differently than we connect with buildings, right? And then we connect with trails. What's, in your experience, what is the unique thing about images in a group setting?
1:49:21 You take 20 people, there are 20 of you here today, and I ask you to pool all of your images, concepts, ideas of the future. What, if anything, is unique about group imagery? We tend to all see much the same thing, and why is it, you're on it, why is it that we all tend to see the same thing? Brainwashing.
1:49:58 Because we see ourselves in the future, we cannot be dispassionate about images. We can be dispassionate about outcomes. What are outcomes? Intellectual. An intellectual product. To me, the outcome is tangible, not the image. The outcome is tangible, so I was waiting for somebody to pick that up. So if the outcomes are tangible, what are the images then?
1:50:30 They are, in fact, intangible because they are not concrete. We can't stick them in a 3D program. Because it's subject to your imagination. It's subject to your imagination. It lives in your head, your heart. It lives in this constant thing that's going on in our heads where we...
1:50:59 Imagine the future. All of you imagined your future for me. And then we create this picture. And we start to populate the picture with a bunch of features. And the last thing we do is place ourselves in it. I'm not saying it's literally exactly like that every time. But if you take yourself out of the picture, it's not really an image that is endearing to you. It doesn't pull you. We see ourselves. Sometimes it's fuzzy. Sometimes it's not clear to us how to fit ourselves in the picture.
1:51:30 But our desire to be in the picture is what lines us all together. Outcomes are quite tangible. They're things we build. They're things we create. They're the answer to the question, how do you know when you see it? We use the word done or complete or in progress or in process to describe it. So I would like your help in...
1:51:58 I'm going to do something different than we did last time. We're not going to cluster this except in two groups. I'm going to take every one of your vision cards and assign it to one of two conditions. It's either an image or it's an outcome. And the reason will become evident in a moment, so I'm just going to take them in this order. Strong community guide. Image or outcome? That's a tough one. That's outcome. Image. Image. Image.
1:52:27 Let's start here. This is an image. Parking crisis solved. That one is kind of easy. Some of these will be hard. World-class resort community. Any debate on that? I'm not on the same page. Have you seen that? That's right. I'm carrying you in my head when I do these workshops because you've planted an idea about innovation is the key to the whole process.
1:53:03 Last time, I wanted to know I captured that, and I have saved it for a special place. All right, so I'll bow up for this process, because I'm, like, literally on the opposite side. No, but what I would encourage you to do, Colin, is see if it becomes clear to you. Okay. And it's the point that it doesn't feel like, go like this and tell us that it would be cool. Okay. How about a welcoming business environment? Image. Image.
1:53:32 I guess I look at the outcome of that because it's an image you see but you actually have people seeing that. You can see it, touch it, feel it, hear it. So you're answering the question. The way I would sort that out between image and outcome is what would be happening? Would be the outcome. Just telling us that would be the outcome. That's what I'm struggling with because I see if we take a welcoming business environment to me. I'm going to say this in four workshops. Just trust me. Just trust me.
1:54:24 New police station. That's an imaginary activity. The multi-use facility will be done before the police station. The challenge is on. Feet first character. Outpage. Outcome. Outcome. Outcome. Outcome. Outcome. Outcome. We're walking. Are we debating? Yeah, because it's not just walking. Biking. I guess there's no herb in there, so it's not enough. What outcome, what would have to be in place for this is an image?
1:55:05 The sidewalks, the transit. So I'm going to plug it over here, an image for the title. How about numerical criminal expanded air service? How about $22 million budget? How about the minimum place region of driving the U.S. Olympic Committee National High Altitude Training Center?
1:55:44 About a community that has a similar direction. About this residential neighborhood of Shady Rest. Let's stay on that theme. Shady Rest Tract houses 117 workforce households. How about redevelopment of key sites in town to incorporate mixed-use daycare, walkability, more diverse retail and restaurant outfits. How about cultural stewardship toward the mountains and trails? What was your clue?
1:56:26 Culture. Culture, absolutely. It's intangible. Again, you buy a community. How about the lawsuit is paid off. Thanks for adding the card. Outcome. Outcome. Sustainable economic security. Immigration. You guys are doing this. Houses, not condos, affordable for Mammoth's workers. Outcome. This place has a vibrant, powerful K-14 school system.
1:57:08 More stable year-round economy. Image. You debate? You guys good with that? Smart development continues. Image. New airport terminal, we're going to stick to that, the airport, expanded air service, opening Mammoth Lakes to the world. Image. Mammoth Lakes is a true year-round destination. Image. The town has a reputation for leadership and getting things done.
1:58:04 I guess for some of these I'm struggling with how you measure it. Yeah.
1:58:49 Every question you ask me is the next step. If you could measure it, would it be an outcome or an image? Outcome. To be the best Alpine recreation community in the country. Image. Infrastructure. Outcome. Budget. Improved infrastructure, multi-use facility, police departments. Outcomes.
1:59:28 Establish an entrepreneurial development pipeline to grow a successful business community. Energy. Proud, cohesive community focused on success. Energy. Their leadership. A digital 395-based business sector. Outcome. A better set of community assets and amenities. Outcome. Assets and amenities are tangible products.
2:00:10 I'd say that's an outcome. That was his moment. I think he said it. A hundred miles of new, well-designed single track trails.
2:00:41 A beautiful town that fits with a natural environment where visitors and locals can gather and connect with one another. A new town hall. A self-sustaining economy. A community that knows its direction and is working together to achieve. Professional jobs for young people. You measure jobs, right?
2:01:28 Yes, so the term you can measure starts to become important here. Continuing affordability at times for local families. Outcome. Amplified arts and cultural programs and activities. Outcome. Sustainable integration of a vibrant community and its unique place. Better coexistence with wildlife. Image. Image. I could be an outcome. Who's the outcome? Steve Stearles.
2:02:09 He's gone. He's gone. Oh, he's gone. So we can't ask his attention. He has a job as well. What do you guys think? Image or outcome? Image. Image. We do the edge. Better coexistence with what I read. I bet he thinks it's an outcome. Better coexistence. Less animals. Yes. Bears killed on the runway. But everything you need.
2:02:38 If professional jobs are done.
2:03:13 No, I'm in comments, though. Building consensus, one person knows. Stable economy, so the 18-year-old can decide to stay, but we're still surrounded by the effort leaders that they want to stay and enjoy. What's the key, what is the key to this one? Stable economy, so... This happens.
2:03:43 Outcomes. Yeah. There's the outcomes already described. So if we stick it there, we've got some other, we've got a self-sustaining economy, a sustainable economic security. So we've got some dimensions of the economy. But this one is spelled out in terms of what it's actually thinking. Can you read it again? Yes. Stable economy.
2:04:16 It may not be easy to measure, but I think it describes completely where we really need to get.
2:05:02 Because you were saying, you know, a lot of them will leave, and we know that with our graduating classes now. A lot of them leave and stay if you want to be able to give them a real choice. So without parsing too delicately or making too fine a point in distinguishing between images and outcomes, the point of the exercise is this. Images frame your vision, and outcomes frame the major goals necessary to achieve your vision.
2:05:39 But if I'd asked you to give me your major goals, you would have given me a mix of things. So we've actually sorted it out in reverse. Everything on the orange cards here surrounding image will become part of the vision frame. It's got a self-sustaining economy in it. You have a reputation for leadership. You've got a proud, cohesive community focused on.
2:06:08 Success, these are what we call vision elements. They're descriptive language that says our community is thriving because we have all these attributes. So images become attributes when they become real. When people are actually saying we have effective leadership, we have effective participation, we have a culture of stewardship, the community is moving together in a similar direction. Our vision is realized when all of that is in play.
2:06:38 So your vision is captured here. We'll do a little bit of refinement with that. I want to go over here to this other side, outcomes. So we've got some outcomes that look similar and go together. I wonder if I can get you to come up here to the board with me.
2:07:07 So if we get the right vision, I'll tell you.
2:07:41 Here's your assignment. I want you to start reorganizing what looks like 25 cards or something? Or four cards? And start reorganizing them into meaningful clusters where things go together. So I want them to stand out in your super audience. Anywhere on your experience? Yeah. For the win.
2:08:09 Thank you.
2:08:37 Because it's a training center. They're all actual facilities.
2:10:16 So far we've got, what's going on here, what's going on here? This is housing. Over here?
2:11:54 Thank you.
2:12:20 No, no, it's a community challenge. No, I'm not going to disagree with you there. If we don't have a community involved, it's not going to happen. Well, but I can't see, I just think, I think it's just a community asset. I'm not trying to do that. No, I'm not kidding. I feel like you said community so much.
2:12:49 Thank you.
2:13:18 Yeah.
2:14:17 Here's my suggestion. If it's critical to your future to call it out so it doesn't vary in a general category like infrastructure.
2:14:43 So, what's going on here? What is this all about? I'm trying not to use the word infrastructure. Infrastructure is just a government buzzword for boring stuff. It's kind of boring. It's kind of big, boring stuff.
2:15:11 It doesn't matter. By the time we get something done, we will make it sexy. We will make people excited about it. You will see them. I can't wait. I don't need to argue. We can do this. It is sexy.
2:15:41 Arts and Recreation. Buildings. Community buildings. Buildings. Hard assets. Hard assets. Hard assets. Jobs. Jobs driven economy. Digital technology. Money. Budget. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven. So I'm going to suggest that if this is your vision, these are your goals. This is your goal framework.
2:16:14 All right, so I'm going to have you...
2:16:47 Go ahead and go back to your seats. I'm going to just rearrange you here.
2:17:18 Thank you.
2:17:39 Housing is good. But if you want some more words to do anything, I can probably craft some more words.
2:17:53 Michael, do you think affordable would probably be? What? Do you think?
2:18:22 That should be affordable housing versus housing. Rather than housing that gentrifies. Yeah, I apologize. No, I think more vague is that because it's affordable, that should make step with low income only, and we've been talking about doing more housing for a high income. Workforce. Workforce. Well, even workforce, you need good housing for those specifically retired. I mean, okay. Let's let the clarity, it's a good question, let's let the clarity emerge out of the next part of this.
2:18:54 John, what were we calling the Gigabyte Community Digital 395? Leverage technology, but it's also, it's leveraging opportunity, but you can call it, it happens to be technology, but it's leveraging opportunity, but leveraging technology. Okay, but leveraging opportunity is vague, and leveraging technology is more specific. I brought these, actually, you can't buy these in the United States, I brought these from Goldberg, Sweden, Vermont.
2:19:34 In market or online? No, I was there. Because they have very, very cool tools. Some leveraged technology. Yes, remember mind mapping? Anybody use mind maps?
2:19:57 Yeah? Okay, good, good, good. What are we calling a $22 million budget and lawsuits? Money. Financial resources. Financial resources. A budget's just a budget unless it lets you do something, right? This was all about jobs, year-round.
2:20:50 Jobs, more stable year-round economy, stable economy, career opportunities. We've got both jobs and stable economy. What do you want to focus? I'd say that's stable economy. Yeah, I agree. You guys good with that? Stable economy. It sounds a little static. Maybe I could go to vibrant. Diversify. But could vibrant economy mean...
2:21:17 What's happening in the stock market right now? No, no, no, that's a different word. That's the other B word. All you guys think is about retiring in 10 years? Bye now. As I'm putting these together, I want you to start thinking about how you're going to measure and report on these.
2:21:55 Components. Let's imagine that what we're crafting here are a series of major goals to realize your vision, but we need the ability to track whether or not we're making progress in that direction. So we're thinking about do we have systems of measurement today? Do we need to create new systems of measurement? Are we already collecting all the right data, we're just not optimizing its use?
2:22:32 Is our data too complicated? That's my normal experience. It is larger than what it's designed to serve, and so it suffers under the weight of accumulation, and then it doesn't get used for decision-making. So what is this thing about air service? What should we call it? Air service. We're going to give that...
2:23:12 Let's use just general titles to start with.
2:23:42 This one was the High Altitude Training Center, was it Arts and Recreation?
2:23:49 Recreation and Culture.
2:23:51 Arts, Recreation and Culture.
2:23:54 Arts, Recreation and Culture, do you want to hold that?
2:24:12 Just put in the high altitude front that you're walking apart.
2:24:29 Alright.
2:24:40 And the last one, this big category between the million crowds and grounds, was dropped, just about a number of standard, what do you call it? What did you call it, Dan? Hard access? Physical access, right? Extra water? No, Dan had a good time with some hard access.
2:24:57 It looks even weirder when you're writing it. Since you brought it up.
2:25:45 All right, so our space is a little tight here. I want you to imagine that all of these vision elements sit right here, right in the center. It's a collection of images in 2025 that you imagine as your best possible future collectively. It's what you were able to do together. It's 2025.
2:26:12 And all of these characteristics or attributes are in place in that year. And in order to achieve this level of imagery, this sense of reputation for getting things done, this sense of community pride which you've enumerated, this strong self-sustaining economy, this feet-first town, this true year-round destination, all this imagery
2:26:41 This only happens not when we live in our heads and we just imagine the future, but we actually get some things done. These are some of the things that you're imagining if you could get them done. If you had housing at the right level, you were able to leverage this emerging digital technology, you could cultivate the level of financial resources that would drive
2:27:12 Well, no. Tourism makes...
2:27:48 Those things happen. It enables a stable economy. It enables housing. So you bring over really, so I've been in a, which is the, is your goal to drive tourism, or is your goal the economy through tourism? It depends on the community, and I believe in our community, a percent of our budget based on tourism, we have to be able to drive tourism so we can go make those other things happen.
2:28:35 Okay, so in the spirit of yes and, not yes but, if I were to say to you that the scenario of the next 10 to 15 to 20 years is going to conspire against that 65-35 and drive down tourism or cause tourism as you think about it to become a diversified set and your historical reliance on winter tourism, for example, has already become
2:29:06 I disagree. Well, I think it's, there's a semantic component to this. You know, in terms of what tourism is, what visitation is, I think it's worth having a discussion at some point to kind of break that down a little bit. But I'm very, in a way, very encouraged.
2:29:42 That tourism as a thing. That we all sat here and came up with all this stuff that are components of things. I think we all know how our economy is. And I don't think that the fact that tourism isn't up there isn't a slight to it. I think it's encouraging to see a lot of ideas coming forward that are saying these are things we're going to do. We all know that tourism is going to be the tool to make a lot of this stuff happen. Okay, that's where I kind of wonder. Because we all want these...
2:30:12 Amenities, all these things for, and I totally understand it, I do too. I'm just looking at, okay, how do we make that happen? You can't make it happen. In our economy, when 65% of... It's almost 70. It's 71 if you're a TOT in sales tax. Yeah. 71% is driven... I think that's an argument of a certain kind of fatalism. I think that if we focus on this, we're going forward.
2:30:53 That makes these things happen. So tourism is the horse. I have a question just as I guess in tourism, obviously, so I believe that tourism will get. But as a community member, one question that I have for 20 years is do we want the same reliance on tourism then as we do? Do we want the same reliance? Well, I mean, I'll tell you what, if we didn't have to and we were just a zone monies, is we are our destination.
2:31:56 I totally agree. And for that, hopefully, we do smart development in the future. And I'm not just talking about development for tourist space, but development for home, so that we can live in a better place. I do wonder, though, in the interest of diversifying or something like, Shields, I guarantee you, I don't think we're ever going to lose our dependence on tourism as our main bread and butter. But I'm wondering, as we're missioning out to 2020, if we start to layer other options.
2:32:50 We have eliminated geographic constraints, financial constraints. So we're looking for those right businesses to come up here and those right people and be involved so they're not starting to join that. But I still think... But I also think that if we don't get clarity on this issue at this stage, that we're still a community about economic diversity without understanding what that means or what the... Tourism dependent, yes, that's... But I feel like we need to have a tough conversation now when we're visioning out into 2025.
2:33:46 So that when we are going out to the community telling this story and getting that buy-in, we have to get out of diversity right now. I go back to this sell, not only to our own kids, get excited about me. You know, it has a lot, not only for those people, and we have to sell both sides of that, but the driving force for us, our financial, the way it was set up during incorporation was go along the way. What we got is tourism drives financial engines.
2:34:44 That allows us to do the things that we want to do as a community. In my opinion, we have to embrace that and say, okay, we're behind that because we as a community want all the benefits that that will bring for our community. And it's not just people. It's a stable economy. It's financial resources. It's housing. It's all those things that we want as our community. If we didn't have tourism.
2:35:36 Neither one exists. But if we didn't have tourists, we'd be a better person. So all I'm saying there is we have to decide as a community what we want, where we are and what we want to be. And if the idea is to one side saying, okay, all we want to be is a better community. And I don't think that that's right. Okay.
2:36:11 I didn't say anybody did, but I'm saying that's one end of the deal. The totally other spectrum is, okay, to hell with our community, and we're just going to go out and build 75-story hotels and what have you. And that's not where we want to be either. It's somewhere in the middle. And I don't know where that middle is, but we have to find that middle and actually...
2:36:42 I think it's important that you have clear eyes and clear vision for your future and that you not leave underlying all of this some tension between is it about tourism or is it about the community? I think it's actually about both.
2:38:13 And it is a yes-and equation. You cannot imagine, none of you can imagine a future in which tourists love it here and no one likes living here. You can't imagine that. None of you put that on our radar screen. And none of you can imagine a future in which you like living here because of the natural assets and the beautiful place, but there's no wealth, there's no income, there's no revenue stream because you're so disconnected.
2:38:44 From the rest of the world, you can't fly the money in. You can fly people in and they can spend money. So tourism is your lifeblood. Whether or not in the future you can diversify within tourism, across tourism, whether or not you can build through arts and culture and so on the kind of community that keeps the community old, you know, keeps 8,000 people here year-round, not fluctuating populations based on your age now.
2:39:21 I want to encourage you to be the foundation to this. You want to live it. Remember, we started with what was your vision for yourself in 10 years. Most of you said you were going to be here full time or you were going to be doing something else, but it was building on attributes of your lifestyle to create that. Certain things need to be put in place to make that happen, and you have to provide care and feeding the economy that you have, which is tourism. You should say, thank God for it.
2:40:04 I encourage you to actually step over that and go to this imagery
2:40:40 You're a town that gets things done. It's place-based. It's a year-round community. This imagery connects perfectly with this value framework that you created last time. We're going to put all of this together in our last session. Let's take a deeper dive. I want to park the mission over here. We've got this mind map with seven different major goal problems. It's kind of a wheel of...
2:41:09 activity that you can imagine getting in place over 10 years. And we've sorted into it the individual component goals that you'd like to see done. Imagine it's 2025 and you're taking stock of how much progress you made on getting these goals implemented. What you're looking for is you want a report that attracts you.
2:41:41 You want to be attracted to the outcome. There's professional jobs for young people as part of a stable economy. What would you need to know at 25 that would attract you to believing that goal was met? What data would you look at? Professional jobs for young people. Census data. There'll be another census in 2020. So there'll be a census. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
2:42:09 Bureau of Labor Statistics, the BLM data. I can talk to business owners. People who want to make an entrepreneurial investment in the community, can they get the labor force that they need to make things work? So you could look at primary data sources, secondary data sources, like you simply talk to, Craig's not with us right now, but the chamber could survey, like they're doing now, the business community, and say, how are we doing given our goal? I think also the types.
2:42:47 I come from a very mature tourism region. It's the Berkshires in Massachusetts. And it is a tourism-driven economy. But it also has a stable dance. It is, there's a diversity. And so, you know, the tour, I'm so lucky, you know, job, elsewhere against me when I came here at 21, to not be a bartender. And so, I really do want to provide clarity about what it means to be a tourism-centered town and provide.
2:43:44 Point well taken. So let me underscore tourism driven. You decided to incorporate as a town. You actually made a decision to not be a bedroom. That was your decision. You said, we also want to live here and we want it to be a place for six months of the year. So that's what you're creating. You're reliant on tourism because you've got a mountain and you've got all these regional assets. That's what you're tapping into. If it was 100 years ago, you'd just be mining.
2:44:23 I just want to answer your question. Don't tell my boss, don't fire me, I promise. It's for the good. In 1985, to give up property tax. So in their mind, tourism was the driving. We can't change that now. Wish we could. I agree. Wish we could. The property taxes was more of our lives so heavily on tourism.
2:45:16 And we could be doing a lot more because everybody is property tax. Homeowners, second homeowners. We'd have a lot more responsibility because we'd have to have, you know, we'd have to provide our own mental health and the sheriff wouldn't. No, you'd be in a split. We'd have to do more. You'd be in a split with a county and a 50-50 split versus the county getting the majority and the town stuff. But they provide a lot of services. Shields, just to build on your argument, we are bound.
2:45:48 Bounded in by public land. We cannot open up farms. We don't have the capacity for server farms. We cannot build out. But tourism is notoriously known for low-wage, low-skill jobs. And so how do we bridge the gap between we are a tourism town, we accept it, and we want professional young people to have jobs here? That's a good question. And those are all good points. I'm just telling you, we have to deal with our reality.
2:46:17 Yeah. And if we don't deal with our reality. I think also the aspiration of the nature of the conversation, we don't have to be limited by our time. We have to steward our reality, we have to. Exactly. But we're not going to be limited or defined by going forward. But I think to Shields' point, we do have to ensure that we have certain limits. You know, you can dream in one hand. There are real constraints. There are some real constraints.
2:46:54 I don't want to start down into the economic strategy here
2:47:26 I think we'll pick that up in some more detail in the last session. The tourism isn't there as well in terms of anything specific. So if we went back, you know, I don't want to add more papers, but I'd add increased visitation in shoulder seasons, which we've talked about. And it's sort of around economy, but it's not there. This is specific in tourists. And then under hard assets, I'd add something like visitor amenities, new hotels, a zip line, other attractions. They're just not there.
2:48:04 So here's what I want you to do. Last step of this process for now.
2:48:39 I want you to, I've got these little yellow post-it pads on your tables, your little 3x3 pads. I'm going to invite you to come up with, you can start at your table, but I'm going to ask you to bring them with you and your marking pens. And I want you to think about 2025 and your envisioning accounting for progress against all of these seven big goal areas.
2:49:10 Keeping in mind, this is the vision. This is what we're trying to get. It sits right in the center of this wheel. And you're going to account for progress. And I want you to identify an acceptable measure of success. An acceptable measure of success. If you have a hard number, somebody gave us 100 miles of trails. If you have a hard number, give us a hard number.
2:49:37 If it's soft, we were debating the difference between BLM or LMID data and an employer survey. Give us a way of assessing an acceptable level of success in 2015. And stick the yellow post-its on the card, a specific card, a specific goal area that you're not associated with. This is going to get very busy and very messy. Don't worry about that. All right?
2:50:07 Post-it pads, they have sticky backs on them. Hard measures or soft measures. Housing folks, think about your goals. Recreation folks, think about what you're trying to put on the ground going forward. Sandy Transit, we don't have all our town staff.
2:50:44 I participated all the way through. You guys can... Hard or soft measures, an acceptable level of success in 2025. Stick them on the...
2:52:08 Housing quotes. So we have some of your cards have very specific numbers like the 172 households. Are those 10-year targets? Those are 10-year targets?
2:52:38 Would you be measuring occupancy? Would you be assessing 100%? Oh, yeah. Can you put that on there, though? I put a percentage of workforce living in town.
2:52:55 I think you guys can negotiate first targets with the talent at policy. But you're trying to get as much specificity as possible about what success looks like.
2:53:22 I see if they're in place, if they're restricted.
2:54:21 That was my question, too.
2:54:36 Yeah, well, it's, it's, you can't add a lot of, you know, pre-flight, you can try to squeeze the stuff that would, like, drive you to the world, and also, Denver is huge.
2:54:54 New Jersey, New York.
2:55:02 If you see any cards without
2:55:06 stickers on the way,
2:55:09 it's not to
2:55:10 be in your respective roles
2:55:12 but we might like to see measurable
2:55:14 with your
2:55:15 You can leave on Wednesday.
2:55:20 Anybody want to give us something on parking crisis? Sure.
2:56:42 Thank you.
2:57:20 Did you hear about the one in France? Yeah.
2:57:47 It's the new bullet train that's supposed to go 360 miles an hour or something like that. And it came into a station because it was wider than... Oh, the train was wider than the tower? Yeah, they didn't figure that out before the platform. The platform. The platform. The platform. Oops. There's some engineering team. Yeah, exactly. Some other guy built in. Yeah.
2:58:16 9 meters versus 9 yards. That'd be embarrassing.
2:58:26 Anybody got any more?
2:58:52 A couple of houses, but they're already numerical in terms of their quantification. All right, so let's debrief this just a little bit. So we started with professional jobs for young people, and one of our stickies is a local economic income survey that works.
2:59:24 30% of young residents, 25 to 35, are professional middle class income bracket, so you can begin to stratify your community in terms of where people sit. Are you guys collecting that data? Yeah, we know roughly. Between you and the chamber? Well, it mostly comes from the census, and it doesn't single, no, it does single out, Mammoth, yeah. Okay. So it's like 60% of our locals are low income.
2:59:54 Let's see, about financial resources, Joe put up, pay off the lawsuit early, no prepayment penalties, so you take advantage of no disincentive to do that, what would be the advantage of paying it off early? Three says, two million dollars a year. Two million dollars a year. So, in other words, the measure starts to make
3:00:24 What sounds good, the lawsuits paid off, sound way more important in terms of its net effect on everything else you're able to do. Let me flip it. Continuing to pay the lawsuit off in its current increments has an opportunity cost associated with it. It's the loss of $2 million at your disposals to do some other things. How many other things on here could you do with those $2 million? Hold on.
3:00:55 So that's an example of something that we might want to elevate very, very high on these things. Intangible of that is also our financial position in the bondage. Earlier today about institutional investors' willingness to see you as a good bet for investment capital relative to all other places they can place their money, banks, and so on.
3:01:25 So getting your financial house in order, this is probably sitting at the top up here. How about under stable economy, we've got things like some more stable year-round economy, three new hospitality projects complete, 150 full-time jobs, 4 million in T.O.T., 300,000 in property tax. Who put this up here? Nice job. Good job, Dan.
3:01:58 I think I could have guessed. It should be, when you're not doing that impact work, and you're not doing that impact work. So here's, this is a reply to Tom as well, there are year-round jobs available, one quantification is, people only need to work one job to support their families, because that contributes to sustainable economic security. In fact, we say in Tom, in South Tom, that's where I live, we have jobs, and you just have to have three of them.
3:02:35 In order to live there if you're between 20 and 30. So that's not, there's some economic security. When we ask young people, they say, oh yeah, I can make it. They go, how about until you're 40? No, no, no, no, I don't have to leave. That's what we're trying to do. How about for new infrastructure, demand for transit with funding for a 15-minute headway between 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. to 2 a.m. during the business.
3:03:09 The supercharger, supercharger highway, who's is this? Yeah, what did you have in mind with it? Just the marketability of being on those, and we actually have Tesla looking at putting an eight right now and getting us on that map. Right, and that's a big win for the town. Is there a charging corridor between here and LA? It's starting to go out. Can a vehicle do it in fewer than 100-mile immigrants?
3:03:47 Yes. Over two. It's going north, too. We're working on that. Let's see. Some buildings in the ground. So 40 spaces of service parking. That's the town hillside lot. Here's 220 spaces of parking garage. These are very tangible.
3:04:16 Are these practical and achievable? Are they stretch and achievable? Practical. Practical? Yes and yes? They're both practical. I'm a little concerned that a lot of this stuff, which is fine, seems aspirational, which is good, but I think there's a larger concern that I have in terms of decision making, getting good information to make decisions with, just as a generic question.
3:04:46 So what, you know, whether we achieve a goal or we don't, what is the information, the data, how do we measure the common, what, so we're measuring it by a unit of spaces. I'm looking at the data, you know, what specifically could be the metrics, so we could say, this is how we're measuring it. So when the information comes into decision, they know, oh, we're up or down. It's great to be aspirational to say these things we want to do, but to start setting up a flow of information. That's the operational. Yeah.
3:05:46 Council needs the budget level, town manager and staff need clarity about what are the targets. At this point, I think we want to set targets. No, it's fine. But I think also for the NGOs as well, did we have to start establishing a set of data that we're all looking at and all be making decisions based on that is kind of where a stable economy is a place where a lot of your work together will find it's going to be about jobs, diversity.
3:06:32 So, in a sense, what you're doing is
3:07:26 Each of you in your respective organizations is ponying up your own metrics. And that's part of our exercise here is to integrate your metrics together around what's called a mind map. And a mind map is a way of taking a lot of disparate goals and ideas and organizing them as a wheel around the central idea. The central idea is this vision. It's not a sentence. It's a series of elements.
3:08:00 It sits here and it holds all these goals together. Vision elements are extracted out of the same exercise. So if I were to propose to you that between now and October 12th, I can give you back your vision elements organized into a clear, concise framework. When you move the duplication, we've got two different ways of saying the same thing several times here.
3:08:45 We take these goal frames, component elements, and the measurements, and give it back to you in a two-page framework. Clear, concise, simple. The shorter, the easier to implement. And it builds on and aligns with both your priority framework and the value framework that you established last time. And all of that for the purpose on October 12th.
3:09:18 of putting this 2025 framework into motion for the next 18 months so that by 2017, the spring of 2017, should be your 18-month target. Not just rolling over existing projects but actually recalibrating them within the spring. And every organization knows its role, its value-add,
3:09:48 And it's measurement. What you'd be looking for from the non-profit boards in the town is some dialogue offline between now and October 12th. Each of the NGOs, I think, will all of the NGOs, will MLT has a meeting next week, Mammoth Lakes Housing, what's your next board meeting? It'll be early October. Early October before the 12th. Hasta? Tomorrow. Tomorrow. Yeah.
3:10:20 So they needed to get assignment tonight. I can give you, I can, what times are you meeting tomorrow? 11.30. Are you here? 11.30, no, 10. No, it's 11.30. I will actually, I will actually give you the rough cut, the open version of this before you're meeting. Okay, great. Okay. Good. Not synthesized in tweets and all that kind of stuff, but take it one more time.
3:10:50 And then who did I leave out? October 5th. So the homework assignment will be to take the, we've given you three documents, the value frame, the integrated strategic priorities, and the product from the first workshop. And we give you this framework and ask you to conduct a dialogue at the board level for the purpose of coming back prepared to make
3:11:21 Committance to an action plan that's integrated across all of the groups. Left out of the group, which is the Council of the Town. So, yeah, left out for a reason. So the Council will meet at least twice between now and then, right? Two more times? Wait a minute. Only one that we can actually add to an agenda. Because you've already got that set. So that would be the second one from now.
3:11:51 So what we'd be looking for, I think, for the town would be a review on the tune-up that we did on the strategic priorities and commitments. And this mind map as a framework for putting into operational practice contracting process with the NGOs, the specification of outcomes, the targets around.
3:12:20 Just a question is, you know, when we first went through last year's list, and there were certain ones that were pulled off as completed, and there was a whole discussion about what's...
3:12:48 What's council level and what's staff? Are you expecting that that discussion happens before the next meeting of this group? Well, we actually already produced that. Well, we kind of did, but we haven't really reviewed it. Okay. So, yes, that would be helpful for you guys to review. Yeah. And if there are other, you know, because when we did it before, there were certain things that had absolute deadlines and things like that. Do you expect those to be part of this? Okay. So that's a different action plan. Yes.
3:13:17 So, in a sense, what we're going to be doing is taking your existing action plan, from which you have six months left, or five months left, and we're actually going, it gets you to first base, and this process, we're actually going to build a complete new 18-month action plan, rolling forward the pieces that are not yet complete, and adding this framework, but instead of it just being a town action plan, council staff action plan,
3:13:47 It's going to be an integrated cross-functional action plan. Some of the things I will be looking for on October 12 are how you cascade the plan goals, components, and metrics through your contracting mechanisms, your funding mechanisms, any incentives that you set in motion across your organizations, how you measure the report's success.
3:14:20 How you conduct your communications. We've been doing a piece on communications in every workshop. That will be the last piece. We will end on that. So the way we'll do this on October 12th is in three parts. We're going to have all of the documents that we've created so far. It'll be in a concise framework so you won't have to remember all of the workshops. You'll only, I'll ask you, I'll debrief you a little bit, but you'll have a simple, concise framework.
3:14:50 And I'm going to ask you to expose the underlying contradictions, I'll just tell you now, that are going to block you from succeeding. We're going to commit our paper to work together, but it's not going to work in real life, or we don't really have the financial resources to act on these goals, or they're too aspirational and we don't have the concrete systems on the ground in place, etc., etc., etc. We're having a big debate about
3:15:21 We're going to expose every one of those contradictions and resolve them very quickly.
3:15:51 Housing communicates with tourism, how MLR communicates with the town, those kinds of things. Look at your partners and figure out, okay, this is how we're doing things now. What is it that you guys, what we're all going to need, and how do we move the chairs around? How do we move around how we work together as an integrated team? I'd be very interested in doing that. So in the action plan that we're going to build, we're actually going to use a giant wall if any of you participated with me with the Eastern Sierra.
3:16:21 Recreation Collaborative work. You may recall we had these giant, Chris was asking about this, we had these giant 24-foot walls, and we literally built out month by month, probably in your case I'm going to look at six quarters, so we'll do a quarterly frame. We're going to look at kickstart actions, the very first thing you're going to do. We're going to look at the very last thing you're going to do. We're going to integrate your...
3:16:49 Horizontal communication strategy between and amongst partners and between partners and the community. We're going to integrate your metrics. We're going to have a victory dance scheduled at the back end of the whole process. And we're going to ask you to make organizational level commitments. That will be the center of gravity of the whole process. So what we need you to do, and we'll give this all to you and write it so you can, I'll give you the,
3:17:19 The roughest form of this. But for the rest of you guys, for your upcoming meetings, we'll give you a clear set of kind of agenda framework for how to have it. You don't have to preview a complete operational plan at your meetings. We just want you to discuss at the board level, because many of the board members have not been participating with us. So they have not been taking this sort of thinking, discovery, you know,
3:17:50 We need you to have a synoptic form of this dialogue within your organizational groups and say, the town community are looking for us to collaborate. Here's the framework that we're conceiving for how to do that collaboration. What are the concerns? What are the needs? What are the expectations of the board? We'd love you to come back ready to come in, all in. Otherwise,
3:18:22 If you're 70% in and you're not all the way in, we'll have a nice, we'll have a bunch of pictures and a nice colorful set of documents, but you're not going to get to 2025 with this vision. Our theory from the beginning is define and activate a strategy-driven process that clearly aligns and integrates all of you with the town which uses the American security.
3:18:57 If the theory underlying that is not true and not correct, then everybody doing their own thing individually will produce the same result, then I would suggest you not waste your time. But I think the theory is correct. I think it's the right way to go, and I think you know it's the right way. So we want to create the plan that forces the efficiencies that produces the effectiveness that you need. That's our concept from beginning to end.
3:19:36 Today we have, we've taken a look at the success you've had over 10 years, pretty impressive, pretty amazing, despite some big obstacles and right in the middle of it was a gigantic economic downturn from the sort of the middle out. In the last three years you've been struggling through a big drought. I was talking to John Urdi, who's not here right now, but I was talking to him yesterday.
3:20:05 He was talking to me about this breakthrough data that suggests that your summer numbers are equivalent to or better than your historical March numbers. I may be misrepresenting that if I am, you guys correct me. But a significant breakthrough in the direction of the year-round economy, the kind of adaptive, resilient community you can become, drought may persist.
3:20:35 We get the Godzilla, El Nino, and it's all rain. You know, and all it does is it fills up the lake out here. It fills up lake top. Yeah. The lake is so far down right now, it'll take three years of Godzilla. So there's not going to be any pie in the sky solutions. It's just you working together, committed to a shared vision.
3:21:06 Major goals, lighting them up, doing first things first, clearing your debt obligation and releasing the opportunity value of that, enabling the NGOs to pursue your own strategic vision. That's our theory of change and benefit. It's just 10 years. It's two items. My kids will be...
3:21:41 So that's it. I'm going to get you the rough cut of this. I'll add some votes for you. Part of our future conversation is trying to figure out how do we celebrate our accomplishments. We've got some great stuff that Town has accomplished in the last five years. How do we get up on top of the hill and yell as loud as we can, hit, hit, right, look what we've done, people.
3:22:14 Yeah, it's almost like the story map looks to the future, but it already has this baseline accumulated narrative that goes with it. The community should, look, you struggle through bankruptcy, you struggle through these issues that have, I think, had a suppressive effect on the community in spite of that and drought and economic downturn.
3:22:43 You've accomplished a huge amount. You really should have a town hall celebration. In fact, maybe we should capture some of this and produce a slightly different product and we should think about that sometime soon. Maybe the kickstart should be not just the evening of the 12th, but an actual go-to-market celebration.
3:23:17 You guys know about Guy Kawasaki? He used to be an Apple executive. Chief Evangelist. Chief Evangelist. But he's made a living in the last 15, 20 years talking about this idea of becoming new again and revitalizing organizations and communities where you have a calling card or a rallying crime. The rallying crime becomes day one. You don't say we're
3:23:47 One thing you mentioned earlier about taking something that's seemingly a negative, trying to get positive. One thing I love about small towns, especially small mountain towns, ski towns, is kind of some ethic that goes back a couple hundred years where it's a sense of neighborliness where
3:24:25 You know, no matter what, I go to the end of the earth for you. You know, a lot of you had a rough time in the last 10 years or so, but that's something really powerfully intrinsic that I see in this community coming in fresh, that it's there. You know, it's very old. It's powerful. And we're isolated, but you can really tap into that kind of old west town. Hey, we're out here in the middle of nowhere.
3:24:58 I can disagree with you, but look you in the eye and shake hands at the end of the day. That's true. We're all smiling at each other in the grocery store. This is the first set of lives I view. The person most recently visited sees only the gilded edges of the town and doesn't see that people that have moved here recently are so happy to be here and so thrilled to have a place that they can
3:25:26 They can actually recreate where they live as opposed to saving that up for two weeks a year. They're not noticing the missing 40 parking spaces. They're not noticing all these things. Oh, yeah, they are. They're not missing the parking ticket. So that's the lens that we want to bring back to your process. So on that elevating note and comment, I think I'll wrap for today.
3:25:57 And I think we all, on the positive note, we all probably owe ourselves a round of applause for the participation. So I think we should definitely do that. I want to say thanks for all the participation. Everyone's gone out of the way. We've done three meetings. We've still got one more to go.