TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2015

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 38 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

345 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 It's ridiculous. And when are we going to start looking at this browning? It's, it's, it, it, the unintended, I'm sure the people working on this, the unintended consequences of that. What? Yeah. It, it, it, I would say it, it creates an atmosphere of suspicion and doubt. Because people say, what do you mean you guys don't talk about that? Okay. Because I'm hearing that from a lot of different people.

0:29 We're saying that, you know, the value is obvious. The value is important. But the unintended consequences are not getting addressed in a way that, you know what I'm saying? Shields, how are you? John, how are you doing? Joe, how are you doing down there? I know, I feel like I'm going to fall off the end here.

1:25 You guys ready? John, are you ready? Yes, sir. I will call to order a regular meeting for the Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes, for Wednesday, September 16th at 6 p.m. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Thank you. I'll now open up public comments for any items that are... Oh, I'm sorry. I missed it.

2:00 That jumps the gun. Oh, Mayor Pro Tem Richardson, will you lead us in the pledge? You're happy to. Everybody rise, face the flag. Repeat after me. I pledge allegiance to the flag, the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thanks, Joe. I will now open up public comments for any items that are not on tonight's agenda. Please come forward.

2:39 Mr. Mayor, Council Members, thank you for allowing me to speak this evening under public comment. I came here this evening and have a letter I'd like to read to you, but before I read it, I just wanted to mention a couple things. I'm here to speak on the rough fire, and isn't it nice to have the last three days behind us? We sucked the smoke from that fire for six weeks.

3:03 And I'm here to speak even though that the smoke danger has pretty much passed. I think it's still a relevant issue because we'll have fires in the future and we'll have fires in the future that those in charge of management of those fires will make determinations to let the fires burn or use whatever terminology they have at that time. So after I read the letter tonight,

3:33 I would like the council at some point to consider appointing two members of the council as a subcommittee to meet with two members of the board of supervisors. I suspect that those two members of the board of Mono County supervisors might be supervisors Johnston and Fred Stump. They seem to be the two board members that are following this issue. This summer,

4:03 Way back at the end of July when a lightning strike hit a tree in the forest east of Fresno, the rough fire began. In the old days when a fire, just like the rough fire, was started by a lightning strike, the U.S. Forest Service or the National Park Service would send out a small crew of five or ten firefighters with their picks, packs, and shovels and maybe a couple of chainsaws and put the tree fire out.

4:31 Then return home within a day or two with the total cost of around $10,000. But today in this age of advanced knowledge of fire behavior plus a focus on cost savings in firefighting, these same two federal agencies have settled on a mutual policy of treating a fire caused by a lightning strike differently.

4:58 Both the Forest Service and the Park Service now believe that because lightning is a quote-unquote natural occurrence, it should be allowed to burn naturally. This new policy is literally to allow a fire to burn so long as it does not threaten a community, a recreation facility, or old historic trees. The theory is to reintroduce fire back into the forest ecosystem.

5:28 A good thing. And to save firefighting money, another good thing, through a new policy of just monitoring the fire and allowing either the topography or the winter rains to put the fire out over time. Naturally, neither of these two federal agencies will readily admit to their let burn policy. Instead, they will use code terms like a managed fire

5:58 Or fire suppression. The rough fire, unfortunately, is one such fire. Once Hume Lake, some recreation camps and local communities were determined to be safe, the rough fire was allowed to burn freely, both to the north and to the east, towards natural topographic fire breaks, such as no more trees to burn. The Forest Service and the Park Service strategy was initially a very simple-minded theory.

6:28 Yet once again, both the forest and the communities they were trying to protect and the eastern Sierra communities that they never considered have suffered the consequences of this misplaced theory. Because of the Let Burn experiment, almost seven weeks after the fire is beginning, there are new evacuation orders in communities on the western border of the fire.

6:57 When this was written, that was the case. As of today, those evacuation orders have been lifted. I just wanted to clarify. Additionally, both the eastern and northern flanks of the fire are being allowed to continue to burn unabated. That's still true. The size of the fire is now in excess of 140,000 acres instead of less than one acre that it could have been had they put the tree fire out initially.

7:29 And today, the cost is likely to exceed $70 million instead of the $10,000 it would have cost to put the true fire out the first day or two. I keep hearing that these two federal agencies don't have big enough budgets to fight fires. Incidentally, they're budgets that they keep exceeding.

8:02 And that they can't fight the fires because they don't have enough personnel or money. Personally, I have a really good suggestion to both the Park Service and the Forest Service. Instead of deploying 3,700 firefighters, which was reported today, 3,700 firefighters, as opposed to 5 or 10, over a period of two months and burning 140,000 acres and costing in excess of $70 million,

8:35 Just put the fire out in a day or two costing $10,000 and you've saved tens of millions of dollars for your budget. In March of 2013, an article appearing in the Huffington Post, the Park Service admitted to letting fires burn, this is a quote, excuse me, letting fires burn has its dangers. This obvious observation by the Park Service came to life in Lassen,

9:05 National Park in Northern California, resulting in letting a small half-acre fire burn into a 42-square-mile fire. The town of Mammoth Lakes is four square miles, so this is something in excess of ten times the size of the incorporated area of the town of Mammoth Lakes, costing $15 million. The issues mentioned previously by myself tonight

9:32 Do not even get into the many other damaging impacts of the current let burn policy of these two agencies. What about the smoke impacts to the health of eastern Sierra residents and visitors? What about the detrimental financial impacts to tourism in the eastern Sierra? People in the Sierra recognized that there will always be periodic fires. We can put up with fires and smoke periodically.

10:03 Experiencing smoke for several weeks, as we have with the rough fire, should not be acceptable in any manner to humans. By allowing both the Forest Service and the Park Service to continue a policy of let burn, the federal government, our federal government, has chosen to hypocritically ignore their own Clean Air Act. And more importantly, the same federal government has chosen to prioritize the health of the forest

10:34 The critter animal mortality rate is assuredly much greater

11:05 Under a let burn policy, least we forget the massive destruction of these fires to the habitat of these same creatures and their need for survival. Thank you. Thank you, John. Hello, my name is Kathy Cage. I wanted to request to have item number six off the consent agenda pulled. I had just a couple of clarifying questions. Okay. Anybody else for public comment? Okay. Seeing none.

11:47 Move on. Are there any additions to the agenda tonight? No? Okay. I'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Jo? Oh, thank you. Last Thursday, and John did come to that meeting and read a similar statement as to what he just did. Last Thursday, as an urgency item, the Great Basin Board took on the issue of the health, economic, and infrastructure impacts from

12:16 The rough fire and all other fires and directed staff to send a letter to the California Air Resources Board that notes that asks for an understanding of the Forest Service policies and a working together cooperatively to make sure that the east side is not

12:41 Thank you.

12:57 Group that is dealing with this. So in reference to what John had said about setting up a subcommittee, I would suggest instead that we ask staff to analyze who might be the best body to carry forward that idea because I know other groups have discussed it as well, but I think it'd make more sense to have a coordinated approach so that we haven't got...

13:21 Yes, there's a reason to have a diversity of opinions going in, but if council is actually going to take an active role in it, we want to make sure it's through the right one of our liaisons or whatever is going on. There was also a second action that the Great Basin Board took that related to Pat Hayes from the Water District coming and reading the press release that had come out that same day about filing the appeal. Obviously, as you know, Great Basin cannot...

13:49 Comment directly on it because they are one of the partners in the litigation, but instead staff was directed and it has just been released a letter asking Bureau of Land Management to do whatever it can to come to a good solution and if there's any way that the air basin staff can help with the...

14:14 Determining that final monitoring plan that they would do so. So that was also discussed, as I said, not directly speaking of the litigation, but supporting the BLM and working through a mitigation and monitoring plan that will support the water district's interests, the town's interests.

14:39 Then on Friday I attended the ESDA meeting along with our mayor and we did discuss the strategy with them and got some feedback that will be fed into the meeting that's now on October 12th. Yes. And then also they demonstrated their new website, excuse me, which is much more interactive as it comes to showing people the regional approach.

15:07 John?

15:38 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This is kind of a point of order of both the fire question and this water district question. I think it would be important to agendize those things going forward. Well, the correspondence from the water district has been forwarded to Jamie, but it was late this afternoon. It will be correspondence on the next council agenda. Okay, and on the fire topic. And the same thing. It will be correspondence. Well, that one I think will actually be an agenda item because.

16:05 We'll be asking whether or not we want to send a similar letter. Okay. So as long as it's going to come back. Once we know how we're going to offer to help. Yeah. There's a lot to talk about. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. September 3rd, I attended a meeting of the recently convened broadband task force with our mayor. We're meeting again tomorrow. September 4th, I attended the Multis facility effort. Again, that's meeting again this Friday.

16:34 September 8th, I attended the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board meeting. Colin wasn't there. No, actually, Colin was there, but it's an interesting meeting. I think it's good for us to be showing our faces at our NGO board meetings and seeing what's going on. September 10th, another broadband task force meeting in the council goal setting. And then September 1st, the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative had a leadership team meeting, and I'm looking forward to bring back some updates on that effort.

17:01 Thank you.

17:29 I attended the ESCOG meeting. We had a great tour of the airport, thanks to Grady. The ESCOG established an ad hoc committee to explore options for changing governance of ESCOG. Mike was there. The mayor was there with that. Focused around regional air service, regional solid waste solutions, technology, and recreation. And that group will be reporting back out probably by December, but it's an effort that I think everybody in the region recognizes the need for regional voice on a number of topics. September 12th, I attended the Imbus Summit.

17:58 The 14th, I attended the LTC.

18:27 And I heard a lot about Mammoth County's Regional Transportation Plan. There's a CEQA document out on that, I think, staff, when he made me take a look at that at some point. We had a good discussion about Forest Service roads, especially about those up in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. The county's got similar issues with kind of a retreat of the Forest Service from a lot of their significant capital infrastructure. I advise that we in Mammoth have been hearing issues about roads in Lakes Basin that we need to probably get involved in that.

18:55 I also attended the Chamber Power Lunch for discussion on Mammoth Lakes Library, and that was an interesting one. I would defer to Joe a little bit, the Friends of the Library, in terms of what's going on with those issues. I left the meeting a little less alarmed than when I walked in, but I think it's something to still keep an eye on. And so that's it. I have something that we have an election coming up, a special election coming up. I prepared a statement. I hope it's...

19:21 I hope it feels short when I'm done with it, but if Mr. Maveritt's okay, I'd like to share that with the public. And I offer these thoughts and observations in all humility. We are a new council. We are not a perfect body. We're doing the best we can for the best interests of the community, so I'd just like to share some thoughts with everybody. Measure Z is a response to the challenge of a shared economy as imagined by Silicon Valley that depends on historically residential neighborhoods all around the world accommodating a new kind of traveler in order to make a profit.

19:51 Silicon Valley is not only interested in our neighborhoods, they are creating expectations in the minds of travelers as to what kind of accommodations they will find when they arrive in desired places like Mammoth Lakes. And they are succeeding. These are serious, legitimate, and important issues for this community's consideration. The ability of the town to maintain its zoning laws and enforce its taxing authority. The effects on the availability of our very limited stock of long-term rental properties for our workforce.

20:18 The implications of our quality of life should our residential neighborhoods be transformed into ordinary opportunities for investment, and importantly, the reputation of our visitor experience. The world is changing rapidly and right in front of our eyes. It is threatening to disrupt values cherished and deeply held by this community. Within two months of an election in 2014 that ceded three new members to the Town Council for the first time in recent memory, this new Council chose to prioritize and to take on this challenge.

20:47 Agreeing to, quote, tackle single-family residential short-term rental decision on a town-wide basis during a public meeting. The topic of single-family rentals was a hot topic during the Council election campaign, the focus of much public debate, with candidates repeatedly asked to clearly state their positions. Soon thereafter, this Council invited public comment on its priorities, which included public criticism of its desire to take on the single-family rental issue at all.

21:14 Council subsequently directed its staff to analyze a number of tasks essential for a robust, incredible nightly rental program to regulate and enforce a potentially serious threat to this community, a threat for which there is no existing playbook, no easy way forward, which has cities and towns across the nation scrambling for solutions. At no time did this new council consider, debate, vote on, or approve any expansion of nightly rentals into residential neighborhoods.

21:43 Nor any meaningful change to the zoning laws to strike the appropriate balance between our residential neighborhoods and our resort zones. However, within six months of this new town council committing to directly confront a serious and significant challenge to our community, a group of interested citizens advised the council and the community that they had, quote, filed paperwork to begin the initiative process to allow voters to approve any changes in single-family rentals and residential neighborhoods. This initiative process is now called Measure Z.

22:13 It will change our general plan. It will bypass CEQA, and it will bypass the established and well-defined process for the public's participation in our community's decision-making. This is how initiatives work. They give extraordinary powers to voters organized around a single specific issue. Given a choice between simply accepting Measure Z or guaranteeing that every registered voter has access to the only opportunity this council can provide to ensure that their voices are heard, this council made the right choice.

22:43 Put the question to a vote. The cost of the election pales. The effort is inconsequential if it means that a single vote of our community is guaranteed the opportunity to have their voice heard. As a council member, I was elected to represent all the voters in Mammoth Lakes, and I do. This community should not support narrowly focused initiatives, referendums, or actions of the town council that circumvent or end run the public process and risk disenfranchising any voter in Mammoth Lakes.

23:12 By putting Measure Z to a vote, this council has demonstrated that we take our obligations to every registered voter in Mammoth Lake seriously. The community should expect and should demand nothing less. Four years of historic drought is not a good thing for a ski town, and nobody wants to end up on the wrong side of a $50-plus million legal settlement. This community's responses to these challenges are telling. We've just had our best summer ever. We are successfully compelling hundreds of thousands of people to travel and to experience our unique place.

23:43 Businesses I've talked to aren't just up 3% or 5%, they're up 25%. We are demonstrating a stubborn resilience in the face of unprecedented adversity. Yet at the same time, we are failing to take advantage of our greatest strength. We are a small town and a small community. If we choose to, we can talk to each other. We can envision a future together. We can work things out together. We can take on our most difficult and vexing challenges efficiently.

24:14 Effectively and together. Why are we talking past each other? Why are we resorting to expensive, divisive means to address fundamental, predictable challenges? The true legacy of the Mammoth Lakes land acquisition lawsuit may be that it's really not that hard to write a $2 million check every year for 20-plus years. Confronting the damage inflicted on the confidence, the trusting nature, and the spirit of our community, that's going to be the tough part. We cannot carry forward the toxic cynicism of that time.

24:44 We must leave it in the dust where it belongs. Wounds we inflict upon ourselves and upon our public institutions that draw upon that public anguish will only be self-inflicted. We can maybe afford paying off all those millions of dollars. We cannot afford to perpetuate the humiliations of that era. The Town Council is elected to take on, engage with, tackle the challenges that come our way. The community does not need, and I do not believe it desires, leadership that evades the challenges of

25:13 Challenges of its unique future. We must be vigilant when dealing with all enemies, both foreign and domestic. A multi-billion dollar technology concern whose business model insists on turning residential neighborhoods into hotel rooms could very well be considered a domestic threat. It's okay to be afraid of Silicon Valley. It's okay to be wary of their billion dollar speculations. It's not okay for us to refuse to talk to each other.

25:37 It is not okay for us to refuse to exhaust every opportunity to communicate and to persuade our elected representatives as to what we think is best for the community. That is not what happened here. If this community can't exercise the most fundamental prerequisites of a democracy, then maybe somebody needs to call Mono County and let them know that we're through, that after 30 years we no longer believe in the institutions of representative government and would they consider taking us back. On October 7th, we'll wake up and digest the decision we have made.

26:07 And everybody better vote. It's costing us a lot of money. No matter the outcome, there will be work to do. And the only work that will matter is the work that we will do together. I recognize and support the very real concerns of members of our communities as articulated in Measure Z. I will do everything I can to not only maintain but to enhance the integrity of our residential neighborhoods as I make clear in the campaign.

26:32 But to my mind, Measure Z is the sad retelling of a familiar tune here in Mammoth Lakes, one that we must leave behind if we are ever to truly move forward. The rallying cry is clear. The town council cannot be trusted. I get it. We all get it. But we can no longer afford any easy cynicisms. A little humility is probably in order. I cannot support how we are going about this. We can do a lot better than what we have been doing.

27:01 I cannot support Measure Z, and I will not vote for it on October 6th. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, John. That was very well done. Thank you. Okay. I also have a statement that is going to be real condensed. John hit a lot of the points. But before that, I'd like to tell you, I went to a Mammoth Trails commission meeting on September 9th. On the 10th,

27:35 We had this special meeting with the NGOs, which I thought was very informative. On September 14th, I attended the LTC meeting along with John. That also was very informative, a lot going on with LTC. And on September 15th, we had a TOT meeting. To reiterate your point, it was an all-time great summer for us. So the numbers speak for themselves. Hopefully we can keep it up.

28:05 On the topic of Measure C, I'd like to admonish both sides of this issue. There are people on both sides that, in my opinion, have acted irresponsibly. Actually, they've acted like kids, you know, yelling in libraries or at post offices, telling people not to go to certain businesses.

28:38 We're a better community than that. And I hope as we go forward with this we can become a community again because this type of decisiveness between two groups of people shouldn't have to happen. We are better than this. We need to come, have the discussion, have the dialogue. I think what got me upset more than anything else was this group.

29:09 They sadly decided to take it on themselves, and I don't know whether they were afraid or what it was, to go out and say, we don't trust the council, we are going to take it upon ourselves. They brought us an ultimatum. They said 800, or 1,073 originally, which was cut down to 800 and some odd votes, which represents about 29% of the registered voters in our town. They said, okay,

29:40 Accept our ultimatum or we're going to go to a $50,000 special election. As a duly elected official, I cannot accept that ultimatum. I have a fiduciary responsibility to everyone in Mammoth, registered voter or not, everyone, children, parents, people that work here, people that visit here. That is the fiduciary responsibility that I accepted by being elected.

30:14 So I cannot accept that ultimatum. And for that reason, and for that reason alone, I will be voting no. And I hope that you understand that and you allow me to do the job I was elected to do. I think if we would have sat down as a community, there's no preset agenda on this deal, no one up here said, okay, we're going to expand out to all the different neighborhoods.

30:50 But what we did is we said, look, we have confidence in this council. It's a new council. We believe we can tackle this issue that has been on the agenda for years. And it's just, it's wrong. And I think we still can. By a 5-0 consensus vote, we said the status quo isn't working. And it's not. We have to find solutions. Together we can find solutions. So I hope.

31:27 That people will understand that. And that whatever happens during the election, that we can come back together and come to real solutions. Because yes is not giving us any solutions. Thank you. Thank you. Well, I as well attended, as John stated, broadband meeting, ESCOG meeting, ESTA and MLT. I think everyone's kind of covered most of that.

32:02 Again, I want to take a minute, too, and talk about Measure Z vote. I think, John, you did a great job. I don't have a four-page document prepared, but covered a lot of stuff, as you did Shields, too. You know, as I said before, I kind of question how we got here. I still question how we got here. Very sensitive to our neighborhoods. I'm very interested in protecting our neighborhoods.

32:31 Again, the notion that this council was planted a steamroll and crammed down a town-wide zoning change has never, ever, ever been the focus or the dialogue. The dialogue has been, very simply, to tackle this issue. You know, I got on council three years ago, a little over three years ago. We were faced with bankruptcy when I joined council. I ran for council to try to support, make a difference.

33:02 And bring some common sense to council. First thing was is that we're going to bankrupt, sign up for bankruptcy. We did. We then did a settlement. There was only no vote on that settlement, not because I didn't believe a settlement was the right thing. I didn't believe the terms were the right thing for this community for the next 20-plus years. We have an $18 million budget we're working with. Take $2 million off the top. You're already seeing impacts.

33:33 We have less cops on the street. We're constantly cutting roads. We're cutting children's programs. The list goes on and on. Just last year, we can't cut another $350,000 out. We're asking Dan to cut another $350,000 again. The only way that we're going to solve success in this town is to grow our way out of this mess. It's to grow our TOT. We run this town at 70% TOT and tax because

34:05 We get very little on our property tax. So sales tax and TOT are 70% of our budget. Think about that number, 70%. So, you know, the thought that we're going to continue to not provide a road to compliance for single family rentals or other rentals of that matter, this is not just about homes. We've got condo complexes in town.

34:33 That are divided two-thirds, one-third. Two-thirds you can rent. Nightly one-third you can't. We wanted to address that issue. With this measure passing, we can't. It ties our hands unless it goes back to a vote. So another $20,000 on top of $50,000 to go to a special election. A yes means a no. A no means a yes. It's very confusing. The bottom line is it's happening, and it's going to continue to happen. It's a phenomenon. People will continue. It's a product that.

35:03 Is in need. It's happening in other peer resorts. I just came back from five different ones. Every five, they're renting homes. They're renting condos. They're renting timeshares. They're renting hotels. They're renting Airbnbs. They're renting it all. What are they doing? They're giving the product to the guest as the guest has the demand to come to their town. So should you have a $3,000 a night trophy house? Should you have a $60 green shag condo and everything in between? I think you should.

35:32 If we can manage it, we can regulate it, and we can have a program. We've been working on a program. Quality life ordinance we're going to pass tonight. It's a great program, but it doesn't go to illegal properties. It goes to legal properties. So a passing of Z does nothing. It's not going to address the issues. It's not going to shut down the neighbor and the problems that we're facing.

36:00 What's going to shut it down is giving a road to compliance, getting people to follow regulation, follow a tough regulation, get them to comply. Many people that I talk to day in and day out want a road to comply, and they want to participate. They want to give us TOT. We can put that TOT to work. The conversation is how much TOT is it? What's the new money? Nobody knows the answer on either side. But I can tell you it's a lot more than we're trying to shake down people now.

36:31 And we're trying to sting and bust somebody one night. They shut down or they don't or they shut down temporarily. They start back up. The next guy up the street starts back up. It's a wild, wild west in Mammoth. And it's going to continue to be. We need to tackle this issue. We need to give a road to compliance. We need to get people to follow a program. We need to utilize revenue that's being now spent on.

37:00 $2 million of debt. We need to focus on paying that debt. We need to focus on putting cops on the street. We need to focus on better roads and maintenance. We need to focus on building assets that we so desperately want in town. Well, what does it take? It takes money. 70%, 7-0 of our budget is generated from TOT and sales tax. It's a big number. So, you know, the thought to have an issue around government, I mean, I feel this is...

37:29 I feel this is just step one of more to come. There's the conversations. People don't like the conversations that council has. Follow initiative. Shut it down. If that's the case, just as John said, disincorporate. Go back to the county. I mean, you elect officials to deal with all these tough issues. Not everyone agrees. They're tough issues. But we need to grow out of this. You know, we need to grow our economy.

37:59 Our TOT. And not with sacrificing quality of life. We're putting together a great quality of life ordinance. We need to have an ordinance that can be enforced, regulated, and have a product that people are certainly, you know, demanding that we have as they continue to do it illegally. So, again, I said many times the notion that we're just going to shut this down and we're going to spend all this staff time, money, and resource to hope to collect. And hope's a big word.

38:28 I just don't believe it's the way to go about it. So there is a forum tomorrow night, I believe at 5 o'clock, that the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors are hosting. There will be folks from the pro and con side there taking questions. It's at the theater, the old theater in town at 5 o'clock. I encourage everyone to show up. Old Mammoth Road, right. But don't make a decision on the ballot box on Noise and Fear.

38:58 Make it on fact. There's a lot of factual information that is out there. There's a lot of our peer resorts that have successfully rolled out this type of program, and I think we can do it too. And, I mean, let the council finish what we started. We've started a long road to come up with a plan to address this issue, not to cram it down and push it through. Like, you know, again, we've said, the cart was put in front of the horse, in my opinion.

39:27 Is more than capable to address the issue and work through it. So, again, when you go to the box in a couple weeks, I, you know, encourage you to vote no and let us continue our program. That's all I have. Mr. Mayor, before you go on, since I seem to be the only council member who didn't know ahead of time to bring a prepared campaign speech, I must not have gotten the memo that the three of you knew about. I would like to make a few comments. As the elder statesman.

39:57 up here with my eight years on the council and actually since 2006 which was the first time I ran for town council this has been an issue the basic

40:09 Portions of the issue have not changed. I am going to totally disagree with my younger statesman, John, when he says that the initiative is not a part of democracy. It is most definitely a part of democracy. We are here because of a feeling from parts of the community that there are certain questions that are critical enough that they should be involved in the decision.

40:35 As a statesman, I also know that even though I was the dissenting vote, I have not spoken out because one of the things you do on council is whether you disagree or agree with the decision of the majority, you follow that decision. So I have not spoken out, but I will tell you all now that as a person, I will be voting yes on Measure Z. Thank you. Thank you, Joe. Okay, we'll move on to reports from commissions and or departments. Thank you, Mayor.

41:10 Just a few quick items. First of all, if you saw the crews out this week, the snow stakes are going up. The crew said they wanted credit for that half an inch we got up on the mountain. We didn't give them that, but they are up, so you'll see a lot of orange stakes coming in the next few weeks. Second, the paving project that we did on Sherwin Creek Road.

41:29 And the intersection of Minaret and Old Mammoth Road, we think it came out very well. They did finish it on Friday before Labor Day as expected. They finished the striping, and while we didn't get any comments on it, we think that's a good thing because that means it wasn't a problem. Out at the airport, we did finally, as quick as FAA was to provide us the funding for the West GA apron in a quick manner, it took a couple, three extra weeks to just get the notice to proceed from them. We did get this today.

41:57 And we do hope to go ahead and do the electrical work in the next few weeks as advertised. If we can't get it done, again, it'll be next spring. We've already talked to the FBO and everybody. They're happy with that. It'll work out very well. The fourth item I have deals with grants. There's actually two parts to that. The first one is the OGALS grant, if you will, for that name that we brought before you some time ago.

42:22 We were waiting for a decision memo from the U.S. Forest Service on the NEPA work for that area. We did receive that, and we did indeed submit that grant earlier this week. So with that submittal, we are poised to come back and begin working again with the Mammoth Trails Committee and our new trails coordinator to refine some of the alignments here, look at some of the options that we have, look at amenities on the top and the bottom and some of the other.

42:46 I call it more regional, but more lakes basin oriented parts of that grant application. But now that it's been formally submitted, we're poised to go ahead and do that. The other item, some weeks ago back in May, we brought forward a grant application that we were submitting for the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project.

43:04 One that's been on the books for quite some time. We're happy to mention that pending a confirmation by CTC in Sacramento on October 21st or 22nd, we did indeed receive that ATP grant in the amount of $874,000 to complete that huge missing gap in our overall plan. I'll just note that May of last year we submitted for four different grants and four different projects for that. We received none of them.

43:34 There was great confusion with Caltrans about how the scoring went, why this happened, why that happened. We went to seminars, we listened in, we did everything we could. This time we submitted a great deal of backup information, including things about the community. We had a conference at the school. And for whatever reason, I still won't count it all towards that credit, but staff deserves a lot of credit. We did receive that grant of $874,000. With that, there is a...

44:01 Matching component, if you will, but the other $79,000 we already have in the bank. One was from a previous grant from the state of California, and the other was some Measure R funds, of which we've spent most of in terms of planning this document, about $10,000. There's a few left on that, so we're very happy to receive that. That's what I have. Thank you. Thank you, Greg. Sure. A couple quick questions. The grant that you received is the one, this is Old Mammoth Road. That's correct.

44:29 Correct. That goes wrong along Old Mammoth Road that closes that asphalt piece of loop that was missing. Right. It's from along Old Mammoth Road on the north side from Minaret down to near Mammoth Creek Park West. Okay. So there are some concerns about that alignment involving a private property owner. Sure. I attended that meeting with the schools. There are some representations made. Will you be able to come back to council and advise on alignment or advise on what you're doing with that private property owner? Absolutely.

44:58 It includes a component for right-of-way acquisition. A grant like this, you don't get the right-of-way first and then apply for the grant. It actually works the other way with the state. So we now have the grant. We don't have it in hand again until sometime in October. But now we can start that process. We'll look at alternative alignments. We'll look at the right-of-way acquisition process itself and come back to you very formally with, here's the steps we have to go through. Hopefully it'll be a friendly one, but we'll certainly bring that back to you.

45:27 As soon as we can. Okay. And you'll advise council on any actions that you will be considering? There were some representations made at that meeting that I'd be interested in your follow-up on that. Absolutely. The other question is, so it's your understanding that the conditions that the council put in place for the acceptance of that grant going for the Muppets going up to Lake George, you guys will now go do some alignment work, look with the trails coordinator, figure out how that whole thing works. Correct.

45:53 And then you'll come back to Council. Should you be awarded the grant before we accept any money to pursue that project? Correct. And we'd like to get the answers to those questions in that process before we even hear. Yeah. The point is now that we know it's submitted, we can jump on that due diligence. Okay, good. Thank you. Grady, I might be mistaken here, but you might be able to help me. Okay, so the Mammoth Creek gap closure goes along Old Mammoth there. And what we're doing with the LTC,

46:24 Up on Main Street and the sidewalks, will that complete the town loop? In fact, it will. You know, there are staff that have been here a lot longer than I have that brought me a booklet today that shows it in 1991 with the first Mammoth Lake trail system master plan, if you will. It showed a slightly different town loop, but it was a town loop, so it's been 24 years in the making.

46:46 And with the acceptance of this ATP grant and with the STIP funding that we expect to receive, again, it's not part of the STIP that's being delayed, it's part that will still happen. Within the next three to four years, we will indeed complete the town loop, and that absolutely, that should be celebrated. That's a milestone. Congratulations. That's great. Thanks to everybody that's worked for 24 years to get it. Yeah, right. 24 years and we finally got it. Great. Thank you. Thanks, Grady. Stu. Thank you, Mayor. Recreation Manager.

47:18 I'm going to mention that actually too, so I'm glad Councilmember Richardson jumped on that. Yeah, 1991, Great Town Loop, and that'll be great for our recreation community as well. So you can actually get a bike, you can walk around town, so great asset. I know there's been a little bit of discussion on Measure Z and Suite Z. The election is actually taking place here on October 6th. I think everyone's aware of that. That was also the date for the Recreation Commissions meeting. So as such, we've moved that back to October 13th. Okay, just a little housekeeping.

47:46 With summer winding down, you can still stay fit and healthy with the Recreation Department. We have a number of programs still operating this fall. The Mammoth Rec Zone runs through Sunday, September 20th. So we're operating Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. We'll continue with pick-up street hockey all the way through October. So if you're interested in joining us, that's every Sunday night from actually Sunday afternoon from three for a couple of hours. That's just drop-in street hockey. Sunday tennis social at the tennis courts. That goes every Sunday morning, obviously.

48:16 9.30, refreshments provided by the tennis club. We're still operating our tennis program through October 8th, Tuesday and Thursday afternoon. That's with Kyle, our tennis pro. So you can jump up there. And then women's drop-in soccer is still operational at Shady Rose Park, and that's every Sunday morning at 10 a.m. And I think that's all I have. So there we go. Thank you. Thank you. You're welcome. Stuart, I have a copy from the IMBIT conference of a copy of the bike park document, so maybe in the break I can give it to you. That would be great.

48:45 And we'll try and get that on our commission agenda in October. Yep. Okay, terrific. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I just wanted to announce and invite everyone to the final Summer of Stewardship Trail Day this Saturday, September 19th. This day will be focused on trash and garbage litter pickup throughout the Lakes Basin. We have partners for this project.

49:22 The Sierra Conservation Project. And the day corresponds with the great Sierra River cleanup throughout the Sierra. So it's nice that that happens the same day, the last day. I expect to see a lot of volunteers out cleaning up and hope to see you as well. And lastly, I'd like to really thank the town of Mammoth Lakes, my new employer, Inyo National Forest and Measure R.

49:51 For supporting this. And our sponsors throughout the season, Old New York Deli and Bagel Company, Blue Handcrafted Foods, Mammoth Sunrise Rotary, Friends of the Inyo, and MLTPA. I've had a great time getting to know my new neighbors out on these trail days and very much look forward to this Saturday. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any others? Okay, we'll move on to our first.

50:20 Item on our agenda, staff presentations, overview of transient occupancy tax, TOT collections, and enforcement programs. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Council.

51:03 Thank you for about 15 months. As you know, we've had a complete reorganization in the finance department. And one of the things that we were tasked to do was to get a hold of where our CO2 money was. We spent a significant amount of time working on that. And finally have common terminology that we can use and a set path on how we get money in the door on a regular basis.

51:33 So I want to talk about some of our common terminology. First would be that we have legal operators. Those are the operators that are licensed and they submit their TOT on a regular basis, on a timely basis. Those are the good folks. And then we have revenue violators. Those are folks that may or may not be licensed but they're not submitting.

52:07 And then we have the zoning violators. Those are folks that are operating transient facilities in violation of our zoning. They can never be compliant and most likely do not obtain TOT. That's the idea. So this is a tip of adding the idea. I focus mostly on TOT. So I'm going to talk about those folks. If you're a TOT operator, licensed operator, you need to file a return every month. It's November 28th of the month.

52:36 So every month we get those 681 new returns as well as another couple hundred that have too many.

53:11 So when I first took over this program and put into place a process for reminding people gently that they might have missed that 20-30, we were sending out on average 131 percent. A year later, we're sending out an average of 67 percent. So we've gone from 81 percent of our legal operators submitting on time to 90 percent in a year.

53:43 Thank you.

54:12 We're averaging 15 per month and now we're down to two.

54:43 So we're so close to 100% for the revenue for legal offers. Should those folks make it all the way to that process, I then take those cases and do an assessment. That would be a revenue violation assessment. And thankfully, I'm going to do a lot of those. Danny does the majority of our assessments under pure revenue violations or zoning violations. So I'm going to take over for the rest of it.

55:16 Good evening, Councilmembers. Thanks for the opportunity tonight to speak about the enforcement program. Since reaching adequate staffing levels three months ago, we've reignited this program. We've made some great momentum. That being said, it is a slow, time-consuming process. So I do want to go over the process to you guys while I do give you numbers in the way. So most cases start with tips or online research.

55:52 And we've had 34 cases open since we started three months ago. Nine of those have come in via tips that required no administrative attention. They were either legal, remitting TOT with business tax certificates, or long-term renters. When tips come in and there's no hard evidence, we send out warning letters just to discourage any illegal activity. Let them know they're on the radar. You know that we are watching.

56:26 It stays that way. Hopefully, the item on consent tonight will pass, and as of October 16th, we will begin enforcing online rental ads that will be putting their business tax certificate number on there. So that should drastically increase research efficiency, particularly with legally zoned revenue violators. Those are definitely the toughest ones to locate.

57:00 When definitive evidence is found in regards to illegal zoning violations or administrative citations are mailed together along with the zoning violation, violators can avoid paying the citations as long as they become compliant within 15 days. We've had 13 citations mailed so far with one being paid and no appeals being requested. We also send out the TOT remittal forms at the same time.

57:35 And give an opportunity to send in and remit their taxes. We've had four units since we started become compliant and now are monthly legal remitters. Moving on to the ugly, when you get down to assessments. When citations don't evoke remittals, an assessment is conducted. So far we have eight assessments being mailed for a total of $430,000. Only two of the assessments have now transitioned in the stage of placing a lien.

58:16 In the event that an assessment does not get their attention, or if they choose to, they can appeal their assessment. It will move on to an appeal with the tax collector, which we had our very first one this week. I'm happy to report it went well. It ended amicably in a payment program for us. So I do believe that we will have several more coming from those eight. As you know, the next step...

58:44 That we haven't had to take advantage of is an appeal to the town council. So we've avoided that altogether so far. Moving on, it goes to an intent to lean. Like as I said, we're looking to file two of those in the coming weeks. You know, to wrap it up, I just want to reiterate that this is a time-consuming process. And as you spoke to earlier, compliancy is the goal for the town. And we want to increase the quality of life in the neighborhoods and in the community.

59:21 So we're definitely moving towards that, and we appreciate the Town Council's support and the community's voice in helping encourage us. Great. Okay, and to wrap it up, the bottom of my report talks about staffing considerations. We are fully staffed now. We have a team of four. We have two other revenue specialists that work on half. Each of them have half of the licensed caseload.

59:52 Which beyond the TOT and TBID remitters are also our other business license holders. So they are doing the monthly transactions as well as the yearly transactions. And the goal is that with the new software system greatly reducing our administrative load there that we'll start moving into audits. Audits are another tool in enforcement that we are required to do in the...

1:00:20 Municipal Code, and we have not been doing due to lack of staffing, lack of training, lack of time, but I think we're going to get there soon. So we'll be happy to answer any questions you may have. Any questions? I very much appreciate the work that you're doing, and I very much, I think we all see this, how this is a component of the program that we're putting together, and I hope there's been a lot of...

1:00:49 Criticism about what's happened to TOT enforcement and why are we not doing these things. I hope we can all see that this is obviously a critical component. New software programs coming into place, staffing getting online, new staff. And rather than get too detailed at this point, I'm hoping that these components, you advise council and the public of what's happening, but we get to a workshop format to start talking about how

1:01:17 I would like to ask you about are you aware of the best practices document, but I don't want to get into all that kind of stuff. Are you aware of the state legislation that may be very helpful? Are you aware about the GIS and data services that might be helpful? But rather than getting into all that here, I think it would be most productive to bring it back as a workshop item so we can really start looking at all the pieces together and how this whole thing works as a whole rather than trying to do it from the dais in this setting. So I hope that if we could do something like that, I think that would be really helpful.

1:01:47 Those are my thoughts. Thank you. Yeah, I just, you know, again, I want to say thank you, and I know how hard you guys are working. You guys are ramping, if you will, and ramping the right way. Obviously, you're getting results, so keep it up. Thank you. Yeah, I know it's a tedious process, and I've spent a lot of time, so I think it's great. Any public comment, please, on this? Questions?

1:02:20 I was going to cut you off. Hi, my name is Kathy Cage. Dan, I had a question, and you probably could answer it for me if you did it as an example. So let's say I call, I'm in a single-family neighborhood, I'm in the trails, and I can see my, I'm guessing my neighbor rents nightly. Maybe I even go on VRBO and say, hey, look, this is the ad, this is my neighbor, and they're doing it. So can you explain to me, like,

1:02:46 How you identify how many violations it is. Is one violation, like every time they have a new set of people come in, or is it like I do a complaint and the first violation is, hey, you're doing it, stop, and that's the violation. Yeah, in that example, you know, if you were to call me and you had a VRBO ad, which does happen, we're going to assume that they're going to go ahead and blatantly list that they're renting nightly at a nightly rate, which most of them, if you look, aren't doing.

1:03:19 That would be one violation. We would collect that information and we would move on from there. Every case is very unique. And then depending on how they react to mailing that zoning violation and the citation would dictate the road you would go down. Okay. So the reason I'm asking the question is because I'm trying to understand if our penalties for this, for being caught, are meaningful.

1:03:41 You know, because the quality of life ordinance has a $500 penalty for first offense and $1,000 for a second offense. And I wonder, at some of the nightly rental rates, are those really meaningfully deterrent? I don't think I said that right. That's a good question. And that's kind of a policy level, probably, I'm guessing. Well, again, if I could, I'm just thinking that what you're seeing at various council meetings is components.

1:04:08 of the program being presented. And I think what's going to be useful for all of us is to bring it back in a workshop setting and have the components of the program be able to answer and talk to these questions so we can get some meaningful information. And your question about if is the enforcement not meaningful, that's an entirely legitimate question, but I think that there may be other components of the program that might be able to say, oh, wait a minute, that's actually that party, that's

1:04:37 And that's a look at it, put the metrics together, see how the program works, and then it's like we're at the very kind of initial stages of it, and I think it's going to be more useful to look at it holistically. Well, it was my recollection that used to be like you had a per-day penalty. And do we still have the per-day penalties? And is that, you know, just for the number of days you can document that someone was in there? And that kind of thing is...

1:05:03 You are correct. The citation is by the day. But as I spoke to earlier, if they become compliant within 15 days, then they're not subject to the citation. But they still would be assessed for the TOT that they fail to pay. So then, like, as a neighbor, if I see they still have people coming in, you know, then I would call you again. And you'd say, okay, is this time number two? And then you go into that system. But, again, you have the fundamentals is some kind of per-day penalty.

1:05:29 It's not that $500 or $1,000, right? It's a separate penalty? No, it is the citation. That is the one. Okay. But it's not $500 per day, right? For the second violation, yeah, it will be $1,000. Oh, it is per day? Because it said per violation, and I wasn't really sure what that meant. Oh, okay. Very good. Thank you. That answers my question. Some good questions there. Sandy Hogan, a long-time supporter of this effort.

1:06:06 I just want to say it's been very hard, I know, for this effort. Two councils, the last council, the previous council, had TOT Enforcement and Education as a priority. This council decided to drop it, and I apologize to staff for that, because when it was a priority with the previous council, it was very clear to staff that they wanted this done.

1:06:36 And I'm apologizing for the lack of leadership on this council because I personally asked you a year ago, August, to keep this as a priority. It was in your revenue enhancement and it was TOT enforcement and education and you dropped it. Instead, you put on the Measure Z decision to make townwide, which was the hot button. And I'm just going to say the three of you all speaking together and campaigning on Measure Z, thank you.

1:07:05 Joe, for speaking up. You never asked her for any history. We're not talking about that right now. I know that. I just want to know that. So address this issue, please. I am Michael. Thank you. Because she was a strong supporter of the enforcement over the years, and it brought in money. And I feel bad because the staff has, you know, they've had to reorganize. If you notice the dates, it was in July of 2014, right after the new council came in. We had turnover.

1:07:35 And I really appreciate their effort to try to get this going again and be successful. And I apologize to them for your, specifically, Michael, throwing up your hands. And Colin, who's not here, saying, we just can't do it, you guys. I'm sorry. That's not the case. Well, that's what I heard. I'm sorry. If I misheard, then I'm sorry. I think you did. But the community supports it. And so I just want them to know that. Specific comments, I will make a few, because I'd like to go after the ugly, as you guys know.

1:08:05 Maybe that's because I have a law enforcement background. And I do believe, and I'm very happy that penalties cannot be just administrative. They can also be criminal. And I encourage folks to go after the criminals when you have somebody egregious, like the one up on the Knolls, which I've mentioned before, and hopefully he's under investigation. But that gentleman collected $54,000 of our tax money. That's not what he made.

1:08:36 He made well over a million, I'm sure. And Kathy's question about the cost of doing business, I'm glad to hear it's a daily penalty. I'd like to see those really slammed on. Those are the kind of things that, that's our tax dollars that are wrapped up in his house. And the very night that he was appealing here, the 2B Sheriff Braun sat in back of me and he was still advertising. So those are the kind of egregious ones. Go after him.

1:09:06 A couple of the things I would like to see is hopefully I did not see any here how you coordinate with our code compliance officer. She's out in the field. She's your eyes and ears. And she's going to see stuff and pick up stuff. So that coordination, that's a team thing. And I'm sure you do coordinate. Hopefully that is not split out. I would like to see the first time you find it going on, red tag them, you know, just like a code compliance would do. Shut them down first.

1:09:36 Don't build a case as we did with that guy. And, you know, he has a lot of our tax dollars because we took a lot of time building a case rather than shutting down in the first place. So anyway, I would just concentrate on the uglies is where I'm coming from because I think your other process, I've seen it work. I've followed through the appeals processes, how they worked. And Joe can give you some history on that too and Michael, I'm sure.

1:10:06 Do not forget the using criminal justice procedures. That is in there. And I would encourage the town attorney to work with the DA on them whenever possible because one good example really does help the whole process. Otherwise, I'm so glad to see this. This is a really good report. And I'm sure in the next few months we'll be seeing some reports about money brought in and violators, red tag, whatever. So, any questions? I do. Yeah.

1:10:36 So, Sandy, in July 2014, how many compliance officers and TRT enforcement people did we have on? I know that there was... How many did we have on? At that point, it depended because some days... So this council... So how many do they have now? Well, you have a code compliance officer who... No, we have... We're fully staffed now, and that was done by this council. So I want you to understand that. This council...

1:11:06 Fully staffed this enforcement group. Fully staffed. It also decided to purchase the accounting system that they're going to be using to do enforcement. That's what this council has done. So you can't sit and tell the people and the public something that's not true. You have to stop that. You have to stop that. Did I not hear Michael say this is just too...

1:11:32 They're just too creative. They're under the table. We can't go after them. I heard Colin, and he was quoted in the paper saying it's not realistic to do this. So those are not untruths. I think you have some things confused of what was said. Maybe you can go back and watch tape of exactly what was said. I will bring it to you in a quote if you'd like. Great. Thank you. Because I have it at home. Okay. Thank you. Anyone else? I'm just saying just support them, please. We are.

1:11:59 If I could, Sandy, I think that, again, to reiterate what we're seeing here is the components of a program being assembled. You've got a lot of really good ideas. They're interesting ideas. But I would encourage you, as you have done in the past, keep bringing these things.

1:12:14 Let's look at these things as parts of the component of the program. A lot of the things in that Colorado study that I read, that I paid for personally that I read, talked about what different communities have done with the criminal side of it. There's a lot of good examples out there to look at.

1:12:31 And it's going to be very helpful to bring into the process. I think also the question about data and dollars and the degree to which we're moving to staff being the source of the credible data that we're dealing with. Appreciate all the efforts you did with the inventory, very important work, but I think we all need to be moving towards looking to the staff, you know, right or wrong, but that's going to be the source where the information is coming from. Absolutely. And I very much encourage you to keep coming. We totally support them.

1:12:57 Yep, and I hope that when we get to a workshop format that some of these ideas you've got, we can be looking at these in the context of the holistic program. Right, and I believe both of you received from me in July, I believe in 2014, right after you were elected, two pages worth of suggestions with this program, how to support it and keep it moving forward. You, Shields, got the first one, and John, you got the second one, I believe.

1:13:22 Okay, well, good. Here we are. We're building a program. We're moving forward. We're trying to build a program. Let's keep going forward. We're trying to build a program. I'm just saying support your staff. Oh, we do. We absolutely do. We very much are. We do. We do not undermine our staff. Thank you, Sandy. Any other public comment? Good evening, Council. Terry Stelick. I am part of one of the lodging people that have been sitting with the TOT compliance teams, and the teams have changed over many, many times, and I would like to commend our team.

1:13:58 They are very hardworking and are up and running and we're moving in the right direction again. And so, you know, I do want to thank them for the job that they're doing. And I want to thank council for having this team and moving them forward. John, you referred to something that I had set up here at the dais and you mentioned that tonight again. And what I'm saying is we want this current council to continue to support.

1:14:28 This team. This team's been torn apart by not always just the council, actually, with different shorthanded being shorthanded at staff. The team's been sitting at the front desk handling, you know, front desk issues. They've had two accounting systems, basic dev to go through, and this team, as well as the team prior. And so there's a lot of things that have happened.

1:14:52 That has pulled this group apart and has been very destructive to the finance specialists and the TOT compliance. And that is what I was referring to. Sure. We're on the right track right now. I'm just hoping that that support stays there and we continue to support our staff moving forward. Absolutely. Thank you, Gary. I think it is our intention to continue that. Sure.

1:15:19 Somebody texted me from home and said they can't hear the staff presentation about TOT. Something's wrong with your microphone. It was making some noise before. Thanks, Kathy. Any other public comment? You want to give the presentation again? Okay, I'll close the public comment. Is there any other further questions? Do we need a motion on this now? No. Okay. No motion necessarily. This is just a staff presentation. Great. Thank you. All right. Thank you.

1:15:45 We're going to move on to consent agenda. We had item six pulled from the public. Is there any council members to pull any other items? Any other items to be pulled from the public or staff? I don't need to pull the item, but on item 10 with ESTA, I just wanted to note that the word statute that's in the amended section needs to be reflected to read amendment. Okay. Just a typographical fix. Okay. I'll entertain a motion on items. Sorry, I'm sorry. Can we pull item nine, please? I'm sorry. Pull nine? Yep.

1:16:18 Okay, so we're going to pull item 6 and item 9, so I'll entertain a motion on 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, and 11. 10 with the language update. So moved. Okay. Second. I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Item 6. 4-0. I'm sorry, I'm missing the person. 4-0.

1:16:48 Six was pulled by Kathy Cage. Would you like to come forward, Kathy? Again, Kathy Cage, I apologize if this is a question that got answered last time and I just missed it. But it was a question for staff. For the effective implementation of this quality of life ordinance, are you going to need to add staff? I don't end.

1:17:16 Anticipate that at this point in time. Okay. So most of it will be handled kind of by the code compliance folks, I'm guessing. It will be a combination of we have actually a code compliance team that meets. It involves our code compliance, finance, and police department, et cetera. So it will be through that process. Okay. And then my next question is for council, actually. If Measure Z passes, does that change your level of commitment to doing the quality of life, you know, the implementation of the quality of life ordinance in any way?

1:17:45 How do we respond to a question like that? Well, I mean, to speak from the manager's standpoint, right now the quality of life ordinance applies as written to all the legal areas within the town where this can be applied. If you adopt this ordinance, we will enforce it to the capabilities that we have where it applies. So I don't think that's yay or nay on Z. I mean, it deals with the current legal areas that we're...

1:18:13 Tie in this two. It doesn't apply to an illegal operator regardless if you can't tell them. So are you asking, are you trying to ask us about our political commitment to, I mean if I come out and say I'm not going to vote for Measure Z, are you asking me whether or not I'm going to be passively aggressive and not pay attention to or something? It was more like, I remember hearing a lot of conversation about

1:18:33 You know, needing revenue to come in to help support. You know, this was in the other agenda item about the best practices, looking at maybe tracking how revenue would come in and have it tie back in to supporting staff, that kind of stuff. And it might just be that I got them kind of...

1:18:50 Confused in my mind because in some ways they're a little bit overlapping. The best practices includes, you know, quality of life enforcement, that kind of thing. So that's what I was just trying to understand. Do any of you have any sense that your commitment to the quality of life enforcement kind of stuff changes, whatever happens on Measure Z, one way or the other? Why would it?

1:19:15 Good. I wasn't sure. You know, I was hearing kind of rhetoric out in the community and, you know, as we all know. We work, Kathy, we work for the voters of this town. If the voters prove to pass Measure Z, we're going to do our dangdest. We will. We'll incorporate into our policies. We'll move forward and we'll come up with solutions. That's great. Great. Thank you. Good evening, Terry Stelick. Since this was pulled, I do have a question. I actually have a legal question.

1:19:55 Campaign speeches earlier, which I didn't really realize was legal from the dais. But as far as the quality of life, I just want our community to know that we've always had a quality of life ordinance. There have been some changes, and it will help tighten up some issues with the single family as far as posting a sign outside the building.

1:20:18 And there's some with the business license having to go on advertisements. That'll be a good thing as far as enforcement goes. Andy, I have a question because Michael said that, you know, we will be able to have this new quality of life ordinance and it will cover legal transient rentals. Doesn't the quality of life ordinance cover our entire community? Well, some aspects of the requirements in the quality of life ordinance.

1:20:49 Don't apply to people who are renting illegally. And what would that be? Well, I mean, we can't make somebody post a sign if we don't know that they're renting or if they're not renting legally, for example. There are some things in there that you have to include in your TOT. You have to include your TOT license number in your ads. If you don't have one, if you don't have a TOT license number because you're not renting legally, you're not going to be able to include that, et cetera, et cetera.

1:21:19 This should be seen as a tool to address the legal rentals, and there are other tools to address the illegal rentals. Okay. So this quality of life only covers transient rentals? What happens if there's noise and parties and parking issues and other things that are disturbing your quality of life, whether it's a transient rental or a long-term rental? Isn't this still going to cover that other than the signs?

1:21:47 No, I mean, simply because it's called the quality of life ordinance doesn't mean it's intended to be sort of the silver bullet that addresses all potential quality of life issues. I mean, of course, if people have noise complaints, parking complaints, whatever, there are other things in the code and other mechanisms dealing with those. If you have a noise issue, call the police. If you have a parking issue, you can talk to the manager of that complex, or if it's really bad, call the police. But there are other ways of dealing with these issues. Okay, so it's truly only as going a quality of life ordinance.

1:22:15 Truly only covers a transient rental. The way this one is drafted, yes. And if it turns out that at some point the town needs additional tools to deal with some of the other issues or additional tools to deal with the illegal rentals, we can, of course, look at that. Well, then I think it's pretty short-sighted that that is exactly what we do because you are always going to have illegal rentals, no matter what you do. I don't care where there's other areas that we open up for single-family rentals.

1:22:40 You will always have illegal rentals. You have people illegally renting in legally zoned areas. So I find that very short-sighted. So I didn't realize that that was the case. But thank you. Well, I think, just to be clear, I think we talked about this at the first reading. I think this question came up. And I think council advised that for nuisance issues, parking noise, things like that, that happen outside of

1:23:07 Of a transient rental situation, I think the advice was given that we have codes in the book and those things we'll use to enforce. And again, I'll just say that as we bring the program together and we look at how the pieces work or don't work, it's going to be a constant need to be reviewing it, addressing it, tweaking it to find out to get it to work the way that it can work best. I put a lot of faith in the state legislation. I think that this SB, what's the number of that bill?

1:23:35 593, I mean, if we as a community, like communities all over the state, if we can directly access what the online rental platforms are doing in terms of who's renting, what their information is, things like that are going to do it a whole lot of good to help us really address this issue. And some things are just, they're going to be hard and we're going to have to figure out how to work together to address these things. But I think, again, if once we start getting all the components of the program at the table, we can kind of

1:24:03 Bat it around a little bit and things are falling through the cracks. Okay, we've got to figure out a way to deal with this, that or the other. Okay. Well, you know, then I'm going to take a moment because our council took a moment to actually speak. And so it kind of goes to the quality of life. But I will say, so not only do we have this that's dealing with transient rentals, but we do then obviously have other ordinances that will deal with noise, whether it's an illegal rental, whether it's a long-term rental or anything else.

1:24:33 So that can be upheld. So as far as it being said that there's nothing being done about the rest of it, there are two different items. Our regular ordinance for our quality of life, I guess, or our nuisance ordinance maybe is what it is. I don't know. But anyways. And then there's also something that's been going around on the, and I think, Michael, you hit on it today, so I obviously understand exactly where it's coming from because I think it's coming from you.

1:25:02 Is that there's a lot of rhetoric going on about because we're spending this money on an initiative that we are not putting a roof on our ice rink or we are not improving our- Never came from me. I'm not sure what you're hearing in your room. Or we are not doing anything else because you actually said that if we didn't have to do this, we could improve our other facilities. And this has nothing to do with recreation.

1:25:29 And I would love those people to come to a Recreation Commission meeting or before this council and ask for our recreation facilities to be supported. Because there has not been a council, and if we look at this council's priorities, recreation, our community recreation facilities is not one of them. So our facilities have been falling apart for a long time, and I'm really having a hard time that the no site is actually bringing this up as an issue.

1:25:59 Thank you. I'll make a motion to waive the reading and adopt by title only the Quality of Life Ordinance, adding Chapter 5.40 and amending Section 5.04.055, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code. Second. Go ahead. Can I have a motion and a second? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0.

1:26:30 Next item that was pulled is item nine. John? Yeah, I'm great. If you could want to share with everybody a little update on this item. Just a little bit of background on, I guess, the overall trail system and the area that we're talking about. There currently exist two crossings now of Mammoth Creek in this old Mammoth area, if you will. One is at Sherwin Street. I do not know when that bridge was constructed, but it was in the last several years.

1:27:00 The other is the Waterford Bridge, which was just completed last fall, if you will. The subject before you is the northerly end of Owen Street. There was never a component of the trail system that was at the southerly end of Owen Street. There's not a trail on the south side of Mammoth Creek through that area that would connect to Owen Street. However, with good prudence, frankly, the council back in 2003, when the homeowners came to the council and said,

1:27:29 Irrevocable Waterford dedication for Owen Street. We don't think it needs it anymore because the street doesn't go anyplace and it's not going to. The town staff and council agreed with them and vacated that portion of Owen Street. But because Waterford Crossing wasn't there yet, they said, look, that's great, but let's reserve an opportunity.

1:27:48 To do a trail easement at this location should something unforeseen occur with Waterford or Sherwin or whatever. So they reserved that at that time with the commitment to the property owners that should Waterford Bridge in fact happen that that vacation or that IOD would then be vacated. That's why we're before here tonight. The homeowners came to us and said, look, you finished the bridge, get rid of the easement. The staff agrees it would be an island of an easement.

1:28:12 That doesn't connect anything anyway. Prior commitment to the owners and the appropriate thing to do. Thank you very much. I just wanted to make a lot clearer to everybody. Any questions from the public? Okay. Any further discussion, Council? Oh, I would move that we approve the resolution regarding the vacation of an offer of dedication of a portion of Owen Street for a trail easement. Second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Well call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:28:44 Yes, motion passes 4-0. We'll move on to policy matters, item number 12, approve the updated town of Mammoth Lakes stormwater management plan. Great. Thank you. Some time ago, the council, or the town, applied for and received a grant from the Inyo Mono Integrated Regional Water Management Program, of which we're a part, and we've updated that MOU from time to time, to update our stormwater management plan.

1:29:10 It was a total amount of some $113,000, $80,000 of which was in that grant. Town staff went out and found NCE. Jason Drew is here with us this evening. We'll give a presentation. Basically what we're doing is we're not asking you to adopt the plan, if you will, because that has certain CEQA connotations that we're not ready for yet, but we do want you to approve the plan. Moving forward.

1:29:36 We'll use this plan as a guide, if you will, to look at stormwater throughout the community. There are two major components, and I'll let Jason go through his slideshow in just a second. One is really operation and maintenance. That's something that we've been doing.

1:29:49 Historically, anyway, this research and this assistance we've gotten from NCE has helped us put together a tighter plan, something we can document better. We have better GIS information throughout town, and we're already beginning to implement some of the measures that are described in there. That doesn't take a CEQA action to do any of that, and it's just regular maintenance. The projects that he will talk about, there are eight of them in there specifically, and it will be revised as time goes on. If we do come forward with a specific

1:30:18 Project, that would have its own CEQA review, certainly, whether it's a category exemption or whatever it is, but each project will have its own review at that time. So what we're asking tonight is please listen to what Jason had to say. It's quite comprehensive. We think it's a great roadmap moving forward, and then we ask that you approve this plan and we can start putting in action. One thing that it does enable us to do is once we have a plan approved by the town, we can go back to IRWMP once they have

1:30:47 Better funding sources. They've been pretty dry lately as well. But now we will be able to go back to them and say, okay, now we have a capital project, and we can apply for funds to do a capital project. To this point, we haven't been able to do that. We did include some of these projects in the diff that you saw just a couple months ago, so we are hoping to get some funding out of that, but the rest of it will continue to look for funds. With that, turn on with Jason. Thank you, Grady. Thank you, Jason.

1:31:14 Good evening, Mayor, Councilmembers. Thank you. Jason Drew, NCE. So I wanted to spend the next 15 to 20 minutes just touching on really three important things. The first is sort of the history and background, talking a little bit about why are we even discussing this topic. Grady touched on it a little bit. I'll go into a little more depth. And we'll talk about outcomes in terms of for the town, what can we do? And then we'll get the third piece will be is getting into more specificity in terms of what the next steps actually are.

1:31:45 So a little background. Some of these pictures that you'll see in this presentation may look familiar to you. One of the things that's been a real challenge, and some of you are probably aware of this, is that stormwater and runoff and erosion associated with it have been a challenge for the town for a very long time. These pictures here represent some of the things that we found when we did our field work as a part of this project. And one of the challenges the town faces is aging and adequate infrastructure.

1:32:15 And especially related to the storm drain system, the picture on the right you can see is an area of town, an older part of town where there's a lack of infrastructure. So sometimes it's an aging issue, sometimes it's a lack of infrastructure. But one of the things that was really evident is it's obvious that a lot of the town, a lot of the infrastructure in the town was constructed before the town was incorporated and it was inherited by the town at that time. And so in addition to it being aging.

1:32:41 There weren't a lot of facility design standards in place when a lot of it was built. So it creates a number of issues. Some of them were identified in 2005. The town updated its storm drain master plan, which was an update of the 1984 plan that was done. This really focused particularly on storm drain pipes, typically under the roads, and culverts that bring water from one side of the road to the other. It was very focused on that. And so with that, one of the other things that was identified, the picture on the right,

1:33:10 This was from a 2007 event. So in addition to aging and inadequate infrastructure, one of the other issues is the fact that there are some pretty significant erosion, drainage, and sites that are prone to flooding in town. And a lot of you are probably familiar with those from some of the events that we've had. Particularly the late 2006 event, which is what the picture is on the right, really highlighted some of these inadequacies and problems in town.

1:33:40 And so essentially what happened was the town recognized at that point that to the staff's credit at the time that, look, we've got to figure out what is the root cause of these issues. So one of the things that we did as a part of the project in 2006, 2007 was to do an existing condition analysis. And the point of that was really to document what was the cause of these issues specifically and what are some potential solutions that the town can look at in terms of trying to address them.

1:34:09 So some of the key findings that came out of that 2007 report is there are a number of places in town where erosion is a really significant issue. The picture on the left, Upper John Muir.

1:34:20 Many of you are familiar with some very large cut slopes. There are a number of those throughout town. Erosion is a pretty significant issue. The other thing that we found was the size and number of unpaved and bare areas in town that generate a lot of erosion and sediment during either wind events or rain on snow events or summer thunderstorms.

1:34:41 Another finding in the 2007 report was that there's, and I mentioned this earlier, that there are a lot of parts of town, especially the older parts of town, that tend to be the steeper portions of town where there's a complete lack of infrastructure. It just was never built. And a lot of that goes back to what site design standards were in place at the time when it was constructed. Again, another area where it produces erosion sediment as a result of that. One of the major things that happens is because of the slopes in the town,

1:35:11 That's mobilized during those events, moves downstream and clogs the existing facilities that you do have. And that in turn creates, in a moment I'll talk more about it, other issues. The other thing that was really evident is the drainage pathways in town are really highly connected. And basically what that means is there's more water faster getting to the core parts of town.

1:35:31 And that in itself has a number of issues. One of the other things that was noted was just the amount of large impervious areas in town that generate runoff during storm events, big commercial parking lots, large driveways, private roads, those types of things are the kinds of areas we're talking about when we're talking about large impervious areas that are generating runoff. And the last thing that was really interesting is a lot of property owners in town, when they have an issue on their property,

1:35:59 They want to deal with it. They want to try and improve that on their property. And what happens is you get all of these uncoordinated private improvements that are all well-intentioned, but collectively, because they're not coordinated, create more issues. So essentially what you have, and these three pictures, again, are just locations in town. The upper picture is...

1:36:19 A mass erosion site that was a result of that 2006 event. Basically an entire front yard disappeared in a couple of hours. On the right is the flooding that was associated with that. So you get this erosion.

1:36:33 Mobilize the sediment, moves down into your system, clogs the system, you have a lot of runoff coming out of parts of town. Those two things combined lead to drainage issues and flooding. And it's essentially, one of the problems is it's a vicious feedback loop because one just feeds the other. You essentially have runoff, it causes erosion, causes drainage problems, that causes more erosion, which causes more drainage problems, and then you end up with flooding, which many of you have seen in town.

1:37:01 Transitioning from what the issues are to, okay, what do we do about this? One of the things that came out of this process, the earlier project, was in 2008, this final recommendations report. And one of the key things that came out of that recommendations report was

1:37:17 The town had been doing a really good job of trying to react to issues as they were happening. They were being responsive to complaints from residents, property owners, but the reality is being reactive is both costly and inefficient. And so the main recommendation that came out of the 2008 report was we need to shift the management focus from being reactive to proactive. It'll be more efficient. You'll be able to address these issues in a more cost-effective manner. And one of the main things that came out of that is there was a number of things that the town was doing.

1:37:47 And that process started earlier this year. And essentially, the purpose of the Stormwater Master Plan was really to try and

1:38:16 Create an atmosphere where the town could shift from that reactive to proactive approach to managing stormwater within the town. We identified, we worked very closely with town staff throughout the development of this document, and there were six priorities that were identified there on the screen. I won't walk through all of them with staff that were really...

1:38:37 It was made very clear to us, these are our local focuses. This is what's really important to the town. And we spent a lot of time talking about that before we started to put the stormwater master plan together so that we made sure that this document made sense to the staff who are closest to the issues because they were hearing from the community about the things they were seeing. And as some of you may know, right now the town operates under an MOU with the Lahan Regional Water Quality Control Board. And that MOU provides some requirements on the town to deal with stormwater.

1:39:06 What's nice right now for the town is you're not currently regulated under an NPDES permit or a national pollutant discharge elimination system permit or any other regulation that deals with stormwater. It's really just the MOU. And the nice thing about that is it allows you to stay in the driver's seat. And one of the things that we really focused on with this plan was to make sure that that was the case, that we shifted that.

1:39:31 Approach from reactive to proactive and kept the town in the driver's seat looking into the future. Because one of the things that can change in the future with either a small increase in population or a change in the quality of surface waters in town is you could come under an NPDES permit or other regulation. And from our experience in dealing with a lot of smaller communities across California dealing with stormwater issues is in the past two to three years there have been a number of them.

1:39:56 So our focus was...

1:40:21 And to keep the town on the path to avoid this from happening in Mammoth Lakes. So the Stormwater Master Plan has essentially six components. These are the six components. This is really the foundation for the stormwater program moving into the future. It really focuses on what we heard were the local priorities. And I think the thing that's key with this is we developed this in a way working with staff so that it has the ability to scale over time so that when things change in the future,

1:40:51 This plan anticipates that and will be easy to adopt to what those changes are because priorities will change over time. So just touching on each of these quickly, the first one is the program management. This is really just sort of the cookbook piece of the plan. It really describes how the town is going to manage this internally, how departments are going to work together, how the town is going to work with other partners. It provides sort of the procedures.

1:41:22 And it reiterates what the goals and priorities are so that it's very clear what the following elements of the plan are focused on. The next section, Grady mentioned this as he was talking, is the capital improvement program section. So we spent a lot of time working with town staff on identifying.

1:41:42 Where the really key priority parts of town were in terms of the issues from erosion, drainage, and flooding. And essentially what we did is we built on the work that had previously occurred with the 2005 Storm Drain Master Plan update as well as the 2005 recommendations report. And we identified eight projects. And these eight projects...

1:42:01 We're really focused on addressing the high priority issues that were identified in previous work. And we did really two things when we defined the boundaries of these projects. One was we wanted to make sure that they could be feasibly constructed in the short construction season we have here in the High Sierra. We wanted them to be able to be built essentially in one summer. We also wanted the construction cost to be $1.5 million or less. And there's two important reasons for that.

1:42:25 One is with storm drain projects and water quality projects, typically projects that are bigger than $1.5 million, you have a hard time building in one season. The second thing is that that $1.5 million number is really a key number for going after grant funds. You are much more competitive.

1:42:41 For identifying grant funds if you stay under that $1.5 million mark. So that was the reason that we essentially identified these projects and kept the boundaries so that they could be built in one season in less than $1.5 million. So this is a figure of where these eight projects are. The black line around this is the town boundary. The color polygons are the different projects in town. So let's take a look at one of them.

1:43:07 What you're looking at here is Davidson Road and the lower part of John Muir. This is one of the projects. What this project really focuses on is a series of conveyance and detention facilities to try and address the amount of runoff that is coming from this area that right now basically kind of goes everywhere and anywhere. And a lot of times in springtime, it has a lot to do with where snow is plowed to. And it will look for anywhere to try and get downhill.

1:43:35 So that's what each project has a figure like this to show you where it is in town and what's a part of that figure at a conceptual level. And then the second part is essentially what we call a project description. And this includes a couple of really key things. One is it describes narratively the location so that someone can really understand specifically where it is in the town.

1:43:58 It provides a description of the types of improvements that are proposed as a part of that project. It also gives a description of what the benefits are because that's really important moving down the line that people not only understand what the project is but the benefit that's associated with it. And then there is a construction cost estimate and a maintenance cost estimate. And so each project consists of a figure and a description like this.

1:44:27 Both the staff and our team working on this, we understand the town doesn't have the money right now necessarily to build these projects, but what we needed to do was put the information together that's necessary so the town can pursue grant funds to build those projects over time. The next component of the Stormwater Master Plan, and this was one of the most important that we heard right away very early on from the town, was the operations and maintenance aspect of the plan.

1:44:55 As I mentioned earlier, the staff does a really good job of reacting to when an issue comes up, they're out there fixing it. What we heard, and we spent a lot of time with your operations and maintenance staff, the road guys, out both in the field and meeting with them at the office, talking about, okay, what are you seeing? How can we build on what you're doing now? What's working? What's not working? And so what we really wanted to do is take the burden off. What we heard was there was a lot of burden because there's a lot of knowledge in your operations and maintenance staff's head.

1:45:25 That isn't necessarily documented somewhere else. So if A, they leave or B, they're not on duty that day, there's a knowledge gap and there's a communication transfer that's missed. So what we wanted to do was a couple of things. One was update the GIS inventory. So actually get all of your facilities on a map that someone can look at so they can know what you have, where it is. And then we wanted to be able to prioritize actions because what was happening is

1:45:51 There was just basically each year the staff would go out to similar facilities and every year they would go to those same facilities. They had no means of prioritizing where they were doing their operations and maintenance. So by creating this database and this inventory, what we can do is actually do that prioritization. And essentially there's a couple of things that happen with that. One is it makes it more efficient. Two is it takes...

1:46:18 The burden of having to make that decision every day of where I'm going to go, it takes that off the hands of the operations and maintenance staff so they can just focus and go to those highest priority needs. And the beauty of the way that we set this up is it creates an in-house work order system. And so to kind of describe what that looks like, essentially what we did is we took what was sort of just a repetitive process and we turned it into a priority-based process, and it has four steps.

1:46:46 The first thing that's going to happen, which hasn't happened in the past, is the appropriately trained staff are going to go out and inspect all the facilities. They'll bring that information back, give it to the GIS staff. They'll put that into the database. So we'll immediately know condition, which was an unknown data point before. That will then allow the GIS staff to create work orders on those prioritized. So the ones that are in the worst condition and the highest need of maintenance are going to get the early work orders.

1:47:16 Give it to the operations and maintenance staff. They don't have to think about it. They can just go. They do it. They document it. When they're finished with their maintenance operations, they bring that back. They give it to the GIS staff. That gets input into the database, and the loop is completed until a new set of inspections is done. So what we heard, and your staff has already started to use this, is

1:47:37 It's been a big relief for them. It's made it more efficient, and it's taken a burden off of them in terms of trying to figure out where their highest priorities are. It's all inherently done through this new process, and it's automated so it's more efficient. The fourth component is the public education and outreach component. This is really important. With stormwater, if you don't have a common understanding among your community about the issues, it's very difficult to be successful in implementing a program.

1:48:07 And so right now I'm going to talk about the next component, which is the retrofit component, which is where most of the education and outreach effort is going to happen here in the near future. This is really a foundational placeholder for a more comprehensive program that the town may want to endeavor on in the future. So that retrofit program that I talked about, this...

1:48:29 This came out of the early work that we did. We saw two really critical things in the field when we did our early work. The first thing was, as I mentioned earlier, the size and number of these unpaved and bare areas in town. You can envision some of the unpaved driveways you see in town. There's bare parking areas, particularly associated with multifamily or commercial sites. They tend to generate a lot of sediment, and they create a lot of issues in terms of what that sediment does when it gets downstream.

1:48:57 The other thing we saw was the number and size of these large impervious areas, as I mentioned, parking lots, private roads, large driveways that are contributing runoff to the town right-of-way. It's that idea of more water faster. These two things have a very significant effect on the town's right-of-way and the town's infrastructure. And without addressing this, it's going to be very challenging to address some of the larger issues that you're seeing with your stormwater facilities and stormwater infrastructure.

1:49:22 So we really focused on working with town staff to come up with really reasonable and feasible education and outreach approaches that we could use to reach out to property owners, residents, and the community to try to raise awareness and provide them practical solutions of what they could do to help address this issue. So some examples of what that looks like. This is the brochure that was put together for the idea of this large impervious areas that

1:49:51 Don't deal with the runoff coming from them. And each of these has really three sort of critical components. One is to identify what the issue is, so to raise that common awareness so that people understand what the issue is.

1:50:04 Describe why it's important. That's really the most important part is you can tell someone there's an issue, but if you don't describe what its impacts actually are, it doesn't typically resonate. So we spend a lot of time describing not only what it is, but why it's important to them as a property owner or resident. And then the third piece is to look at really feasible and practical solutions that they can do on their property that not only address this issue, but maybe raise the value of their property because it improves aesthetics or landscaping on their property.

1:50:32 The next one is for dealing with the bare or unpaved areas on property. Again, describing what it is, why it's important, and providing some practical solutions for property owners that they can do on their property. The last component is the construction site program.

1:50:49 And this is really focused on the town already has an active construction site program. What we really wanted to do was just update it. So we eventually essentially just looked at where we can improve the effectiveness of the construction site program. And a lot of this was focused on the town was getting very similar.

1:51:07 Questions and comments and concerns from the construction community about the process. And so what we did is really tried to focus on how can we upgrade and update the grading permit application to make it easier for those who have to go through the process. And so as a part of that, we not only updated...

1:51:25 Over on the left is a grading checklist that we've updated to make it easier to flow through. On the right is a brochure that was put together specifically for the construction community, anyone who's going to be doing grading, to answer those frequently asked questions so that they don't have to come in and ask staff about it, pull staff away from other things that they're doing. Or from the construction community's perspective, every time they have to leave the site to come and get a question answered, that's a cost for them. So try and make that more efficient.

1:51:52 So that was the last component. So to wrap this up, the next steps are a couple of important things. The first step in the process is approval of the stormwater master plan. A couple of other things that are going to happen as a result of that, one will be to take those CIP projects, the stormwater CIP projects that I gave you an example of, and in the future integrate those into the town's overall CIP.

1:52:20 The town staff are already using the operations and maintenance plan that's been put together, that database I spoke to. And then we'll start to move forward with conducting the outreach through the retrofit program for property owners, residents, construction site operators. So it's all yours. Thanks, Jason. I want to thank you for your patience and time given to this because it's, you know, is it...

1:52:50 A presentation that he held to precisely the length we asked him to, 20 minutes, but I think he covered a lot of the entire program itself is, you know, on Granicus, it's available for anybody to see and everything else. Again, this is the first step. We are already starting to implement some of the maintenance things. We're starting to get out there and we're going to try to do what we can to get the funds to do this. Now, when we described the eight projects, we have not prioritized those in terms of one through eight yet.

1:53:17 We're going to do that later this year as we work through our whole CIP program. We're starting to put that all together for you. We'll come back with recommendations. And then once we prioritize those, as money become available, we'll be able to jump on them as quick as we can. If you have any questions at all, Jason's here. I'm glad to answer your questions. I have a couple questions. I don't know if anybody else does. Okay, a couple questions here. Let's start with the scary.

1:53:45 Who is our water? Is Lahontan our board that we're under the jurisdiction of Lahontan Water District? Is that correct? Correct. So if Lahontan's looking at a community's conformance, are they looking at their legal municipal boundary? I mean, the activities that are happening within that town's incorporated town's municipal boundary? It depends on what you're talking about, but if we go back to the NPDES permits that I mentioned earlier, those will govern all of the runoff within the town's jurisdiction.

1:54:14 Okay, because I'm a little concerned because the map that you showed up there is not our municipal jurisdiction. That's our urban growth boundary. And I'm concerned about the liability that we may have, you know, within our incorporated municipal boundary, not just within our urban growth boundary. I'm going to answer a question for staff or attorney maybe to make sure that we're looking at the full scope of where we're incorporated. The second thing within that is a lot of the land within our municipal boundary is United States Forest Service.

1:54:44 And to what degree, if we're taking the proper steps and we're doing what we're supposed to be doing, but we've got a federal partner for budget reasons, all kinds of other reasons, can't be conforming or complying to that, are we then exposed legally under whatever Lahontan might be looking at at that point? It's a great question. I live in South Lake Tahoe. We have the same exact issue. We have a lot of federally and state-owned property.

1:55:14 Within both the city of South Lake Tahoe's jurisdiction as well as Eldorado County's jurisdiction. And fundamentally, the way that the permits, now you're not under a permit right now, but other communities that are, those permits are written that the jurisdiction is responsible for all runoff within its jurisdictional boundary, regardless of land ownership. Okay. The reality is the water board has yet, in my experience, to actually enforce that if there's an issue coming off of federally owned or state owned property.

1:55:43 As an example, in the Tahoe Basin, we have a lot of urban lots that are owned by the United States Forest Service. A lot of them have unauthorized trails. They have large compacted bare areas. And during storm events, a lot of that runoff with the sediment included in it comes into county or city right of way.

1:56:05 There have been discharges to surface waters as a result of that, and I have yet to see the water board actually come after the city or county for that particular issue. Okay. There's other issues that the water board then deals with directly with the federal or state agency. Okay. In this community, we have accepted a document called the Lake Space and Special Study that focused a lot on runoff sediment issues and those kinds of things.

1:56:32 I'm just – it's very useful your comments are helpful, but I think it's something that in terms of we have to start looking at helping out a federal partner who can't clean out their culverts or can't do things like that, that may be something to look at. The second thing is our relationship with the Mammoth Community Water District. And I'm interested in understanding what we're talking about here. Is this just the surface? Because the water district is responsible for all the stuff that happens in the drains. Is that correct?

1:57:00 Okay. If you could define, like, where the lines of responsibility are. The water district really is sewer and water. Okay. And the community water has nothing to do with storm drain. Okay, so all the runoff, storm drain, that's all our responsibility. That's correct. Okay. One thing I might, I want to mention, it's kind of related, we mentioned Lahontan. When we were doing the Waterford Bridge, we had a tough time getting through a permit process with them. We educated them on what it's like to be up here. The reason is...

1:57:27 Manhattan's broken into two areas. There's a northern area and a southern. We're on the north end of the southern. Their office is in Victorville. They had no idea what we were dealing with up here, so we actually convinced them to come on up. They toured with us, and you could see them nodding as they walked around Waterford, like, oh my gosh, we had no idea. So we helped them a lot. They helped us. I think we have a good relationship now, but they really, they did not, they weren't, we weren't communicating. We've come a long way with that. But to answer your question specifically, Mammoth Community Water District is sewer and water.

1:57:56 Okay. So is there any need to – I mean, this is totally our stuff. Their GIS data, all that kind of stuff doesn't affect what we're doing? Okay. I think I guess the final question I have is the action we are accepting or we are – what are we – I'm a little clear on what is it we're doing. We're approving the stormwater. They've asked us to approve the document. They haven't asked us to adopt it by resolution.

1:58:27 Accept the document, approve it as a plan moving forward. But again, from a CEQA perspective, any project that we do will come back for the appropriate. Okay, so the difference between approve and accept, is that the same thing? Accept is a little more passive. It's just someone hands you something and you kind of shrug. Approving is sort of, yes, we approve of this. It's kind of taking an action to say that you like it. Okay. It's a little more official. Okay. The recommendation is to approve versus adopt. Okay. We need to approve the document.

1:58:58 One last question. The Sierra Valley sites, there was a lot of talk about stormwater issues in the Sierra Valley sites. Maybe just talk to that. It's a great question. I actually had a lot of very lengthy conversations with property owners in the Sierra Valley sites over the last six to seven years as we've worked on different aspects of this project.

1:59:22 As I was mentioning earlier, one of the big issues that we saw is that you have, there are a lot of drainage issues and localized flooding that occurs in Sierra Valley sites. The reason for that is two part. One is all that sediment that's coming from upper areas is clogging the facilities that exist in Sierra Valley sites and that is at times overwhelming the system.

1:59:45 So by addressing sediment coming from the upper parts of town, the older upper parts of town that were developed long before the town was incorporated, you're going to address some of those issues. The other thing I mentioned was that idea of more water faster, just the peak flows that come off the upper parts of town into that flatter area of Sierra Valley sites. By addressing some of these issues of trying to reduce both the volume

2:00:09 And peak of water coming from above, you're going to essentially address a lot of the issues that you see in Sierra Valley sites. Okay, good. Thank you very much. I just had a question. When you mentioned a million and a half dollar grant, or up to, can you just give me some clarification on that? Sure. Because I didn't really understand. What happens with a lot of communities across California is they identify all kinds of infrastructure projects that they want to build, and they're often pursuing grant funds.

2:00:37 To try and implement those projects because there's limited local funds to pay for them. In the stormwater world, there were two things that we looked at. One was the length of time to build it, and the second thing was the cost associated with it. So we basically, from our experience working with a variety of communities, particularly those in the high Sierras dealing with these issues, and Dan may remember this from his time at Douglas County, the reality is that

2:01:04 You stay more competitive for state and federal grants if you keep your projects below $1.5 million.

2:01:12 As soon as you get upwards of $2, $2.5 million, your competitiveness goes way down because you're taking such a large chunk of the money. So for two reasons. One is typically you can build a $1.5 million project in three or four months. And the second thing is it will keep the town a lot more competitive as you pursue grant funding to build the projects. So would this be 100% grant funded or do we have matches or what would we have? It could be a combination. Okay.

2:01:41 We really don't know that answer until we identify the grant source itself. But once we get this approved, we will have a better basis, if you will, to talk to IWRMP about what those avenues are and what they're suggesting. Exactly. And we'll rely on these guys as well to help us point in the right direction to look for them. So some may have matches, some may not. And where those matches come from, we don't know yet. We have to start with this. Great. Any other questions from the council? No. Any questions from the public?

2:02:11 Okay, I'll bring it back for the discussion and or a motion. Mr. Mayor, I move we approve the stormwater management plan. Okay. Second. I'll second. Second. Roll call, Jamie, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0. Our next item is number 13, authorize the town manager to finalize scope and fee negotiations and execute an agreement with top-ranked

2:02:40 Consultant for Environmental and Engineering Design of the State Route 203 Main Street and Minaret Sidewalks. Grady? Thank you for reference. Can't do anything about that. This part of the project, or the presentation tonight, as Shields mentioned earlier, the other part of the town loop, if you will, this really will help bring to fruition that closing of the town loop.

2:03:07 Now, many parts of this have been in our state program for state transportation improvement program funds for some time, especially phases one and phase two, and I'm going to walk through each one in just a moment. Phase three, really, on the north side of Main Street will complete the town loop. The third part of that would be on the south from Manzanita Road down to Laurel Mountain Road. It's not part of the town loop, but it's identified in the Main Street plan and some other things.

2:03:36 Before I go further, I do need to mention there were a couple of errors in your staff report and the action sheet itself in terms of the project description. I think we did a good job looking at the details of it and for whatever reason, you know, we didn't describe the phases appropriately. They were in the backup and I'll show them to you tonight to make sure everybody's very clear about that. This is an overall slide that shows all three phases that we're talking about.

2:04:06 Phase 1, if you will, left center, is really the area that SE is working in right now on Main Street to underground the power lines. We've coordinated with them and with Caltrans very carefully to make sure that nobody has to redo any work. They're undergrounding the power lines or putting the new conduits in this season. Next season, they're going to come in and actually take down the poles, and we hope to...

2:04:29 Be there to construct the sidewalk on the north side of Main Street from Minaret down to Mountain Boulevard next season. And we do have the funds for that program in the STIP documents. And again, this is a project that's been in that for several years. This is not new to anybody. And anybody who walks in areas I do now knows that that's one of the most dangerous places in town, frankly, especially at night because there's no sidewalks on either side of the street.

2:04:54 Phase two on the left-hand side is a sidewalk from about in the front of 8050 down to Main Street. Again, that's been in process for some time. We have talked to the property owner there, and we're confident that we can resolve any right-of-way issues, but that's a smaller section. And again, we've talked to the village. We've talked to the property owner in the corner. We've talked to the tenant there. They're all looking forward to this smaller phase of the project. We anticipate this would occur the next summer, so not.

2:05:22 Phases 3A and 3B are also on the north side of Main Street. The first one is really between Mountain Boulevard and Sierra Boulevard. Again, there's no sidewalk there. There is a path on the east end of that starting at Sierra Boulevard and heading east.

2:05:44 But there's none in that area. Phase 3B, further down from the post office to the east to Forest Trail, is the last gap, if you will, in the town loop itself. And we're looking forward to completing that. 3C is a component of the main street plan. It's something that's been in that for some time. And it, again, helps up with the pedestrian access on the south side of the street. These documents, again, they're in the general plan, the mobility element.

2:06:14 There's even a council policy that deals with this and the general bikeway plan, pedestrian master plan, the trail system master plan, all those documents. And again, phase one would be 2016, 22 and 17, and phase three in 2018. I do want to mention phase three again. The first two phases have been in the STIP for quite some time. As you've all heard, the STIP was in serious trouble for projects.

2:06:43 Further out in 2018, there basically will be no new money for no new projects. However, they will let us utilize money that we've already programmed for projects that are already in the STIP. Phase 3 is related to Phases 1 and 2. It's on Main Street. We've talked to Caltrans and they're very comfortable that we can move forward with this Phase 3. Right now in our...

2:07:06 Descriptions, we actually have that money and it used in other areas in town. It's our recommendation that we use it for this phase three because we can, first of all, and because, again, it completes a critical component. We'll bring that back to you later this year when we get into our CEP process about...

2:07:22 Phase 3 and some of the details, especially the sidewalk on the south side. Because as long as we stay in those constraints, if you will, from Old Mammoth Road to Minaret on Main Street, there are some other things we may be able to do with some of those funds as long as it meets those same goals regarding pedestrian access. As an example, we have for a long time wanted to do some kind of a pedestrian refuge as you cross the street through there. The flashing light at the post office and the one further down.

2:07:48 They help, but they're not as much as we'd like to do. If we can do some meeting improvements that fit within those guidelines, we believe we have that flexibility, and again, we'll bring those recommendations back to you later this year. Just a little bit more detail, and again, it's a long meeting, and I can't talk either, so I'll keep it short, but this shows a little bit closer up to phase one and phase two, phase one from Minaret down two mountain, and phase two in front of the village.

2:08:16 In this area, it goes really from the corner up to the area right in front of 8050. Phase 3 is further east from here and completes the section from Mountain to Sierra, from the post office down to Forest Trail, and then considering looking at the south side, all in front of the outlet center and all the way down to the sports store. And that's really all I have. If I can answer any questions, I'd be glad to do so. Again, this is the next step, if you will.

2:08:48 We wanted to make sure we got the preliminary design done, the environmental work for the entire stretch. We have the dollars programmed for construction for Phases 1 and 2, and we'll look at the details for Phase 3 before we move forward with those. And, of course, we'll be back to Council and anybody else that's appropriate to keep you up to speed as we go. Questions? I have one real quick, if you can talk.

2:09:18 Are the sidewalks, are they going to be the same as before concrete, or do we know? A little bit concrete. In terms of the alignment, as an example on phase one, it'll basically be just contiguous to the roadway. In fact, this is one of the things we go through on these type of things, just so you understand how detailed Caltrans gets. We have to sign an agreement with them for maintenance of these sidewalks adjacent to the roads, even though we're using state dollars to build it.

2:09:48 We have to maintain it long term. It's not part of the state highway. And therefore, when they come and plow Main Street, they dump snow on the sidewalk. And we have 72 hours to get it off the sidewalk to clear the sidewalk. It gets very complicated, but it's tough. The area in front of the village, that phase two, is actually meandered some because it comes in and out near 8050 and is not all contiguous to the street.

2:10:12 Further east from that, some of it, again, will meander off of that and not be as contiguous. If you're familiar with some of the mups through there or the sidewalks through there, some of them are meandering in the park, others are contiguous. So it's a mix of both. But all concrete, yes. All concrete, okay, thank you. So in consideration of your respiratory health, let me just throw a couple things out there.

2:10:37 The articulation of what is and what is not the town loop around Main Street from what I'm hearing is not correct. And I don't want to get into it now, but I think we should take this offline with staff and look at it. There is no section of the town loop that's on the north side of 203. And there's a lot of – we look at the signage and wayfinding program. It's just – we've got to go back and look at this because that's how the whole signage and wayfinding program on the website.

2:11:03 This town staff was involved in all this. We've got to go back and look at this and make sure we understand what we're talking about. The second thing is that the intersection of 203 and Minaret is a key node, for lack of a better term, at this point. There's going to be development someday. A lot of other things are going to be happening. But the connectivity from the Lakes Basin Path down 203, the tying of that into the uptown-downtown trails, the tying of that into the current

2:11:33 MMSA bike loading thing at the village. The direction we gave about 80-50 about incorporating that in there. I'm getting a little nervous that we're starting to kind of have a lot of things that aren't going to start talking to each other. And I think it's very important. This is not big capital stuff. A lot of this may be painting things on roads and stuff like that. But we look at this whole intersection, this whole program holistically so that

2:12:01 At least for the time being in the short, medium term, we're putting together a program that's going to work. And I don't, I could add that. Excuse me? Comprehensive. A comprehensive plan. Again, it's not, I mean, we're starting to do some planning work. We're bringing some people to look at some stuff. We've got to have it connecting to these other pieces. And so I would add that to the motion if that's helpful. I don't know what the best way to proceed is going to be, but. My only comment on it, again, is that.

2:12:25 Staff is well aware of that. We have the signage and wayfinding program. We have the fact that part of it is Caltrans, part of it is town. We want to make sure that we accommodate a future MUP on the...

2:12:35 Okay, well, I'm looking for a way. I don't know what the most efficient and effective way to do it is, but we've got to look at this thing holistically.

2:12:59 He can direct me to do it, but I think we've already talked about it. Dan, could you maybe convene the appropriate wherever you need to get this thing? Yeah, we'll keep that going. We've had discussions internally on it to try to make sure that that doesn't get done in a vacuum with the other pieces that they're all linked together. So we'll be bringing that back forward from discussions to the MTC as well. Okay, because I think we're all going to want to make sure that this thing is all talking to each other and we're not. Okay. Grady, just a quick comment. I keep coughing too. Sorry. I think this is really exciting.

2:13:29 We've been talking about this for a long time, and it adds to the feet first. It adds to exactly where we're going. There's some very dangerous areas there. I think the possibilities of incorporating medians and some safe zones is great. We've had that discussion, so I really look forward to seeing that come back. Okay. Okay, so with that, I'd like to make a motion, if that's okay.

2:13:53 And I would move that we authorize the Town Manager to finalize scope and fee negotiations and execute an agreement with the top right consultant for environmental engineering design of the SR203 Main Street Minaret Road sidewalks and to further direct the Town Manager to convene as appropriate the means and tools necessary for holistic trail and recreation recommendations for the intersection of Minaret and 203. Second.

2:14:25 So I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you, Grady. Thank you. Move on to item number 14, waive the first reading introduced by title only of the Ordinance Amending Municipal Code Chapter 3.12 to allow the Town Council flexibility to waive compounding of penalties and interest from delinquent transient occupancy tax payment calculations. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

2:14:55 Kick off the initial part of this is the items before you as part of an ongoing process we've been working through and cleaning up some of the code sections. We brought other ones several months ago relating to some of the TOT work and some of those areas. The bottom line for this one is really addressing the question of how we have been addressing compounding of penalties and interest in the past and the way the code is written.

2:15:22 Frankly, it hasn't really been followed to the letter of the code right now because of the complexity and process it has that goes into our systems. If you ask somebody from the public to actually walk through and calculate it, I'll say 99.9% of the time it's wrong. And so we're doing it over again. And this came back forward recently looking at the Cassell update and how do we build the forms and put the calculations in there.

2:15:47 And instead of spending a whole lot of extra time and effort to try to create a very complex calculation for this compounding process, we had the discussion of do we just go through a process so we can take that compounding piece out and simplify the process. And so I think it simplifies it for staff, it simplifies it for our users, and it allows us to be able to continue to do the collection issue. It doesn't waive any of the penalty or any of the interest.

2:16:14 It's the compounding factor that we're cleaning up to be able to make it simpler in process. How that specifically works, Susan and Andy have worked through that, so I'll turn it over to Susan. She can kind of talk to you what actually happens there, walks through that. But I know the simplification process seemed to make a whole lot of sense. So the way that our code is currently written, someone who is late will incur a 15% penalty and then a 1.5% interest charge.

2:16:44 The following month that they're late, they will incur the same, but on the original tax amount, the first penalty, and the first interest charge. The third month, there isn't a penalty charge. We no longer have them after that, so that's a different formula, and it just keeps compounding. It's very difficult for the public to figure out with paper and pencil and a calculator and an abacus and all of their toes. I have a problem doing it a lot of times, remembering, is this a penalty month? Is this not?

2:17:14 Certainly we have software that can handle it, but for someone to figure out paper and pencil is very, very difficult. Looking at how much we would have captured had we been requiring that compounding in the last year would have been $2,200 on a very high penalty and interest year because we've been receiving a lot of penalties and interest. And just to clarify, would you estimate that we...

2:17:37 We would spend a lot more than that in staff time. Absolutely. Just trying to figure this out. Absolutely. So in talking with Andy, because of Prop 218 issues and stuff, we don't want to take it out of the code. We'll be bringing back a resolution if you approve this ordinance amendment this evening, the first reading. We'll be bringing back a resolution to temporarily suspend the compounding in case a future council wants.

2:18:07 Someone to figure all that out. Okay. Any questions? Any questions for the public? Okay. Seeing none. So just for clarification, we're not looking to waive any penalties and interest. No. Just the compounding. That's been asked. Okay. I will entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to recommend that we waive the first reading.

2:18:35 And introduced by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code 3.12 to allow Town Council flexibility to waive compounding of penalties and interest from delinquent transient occupancy tax payment calculations. Okay. Second. I have a motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you. We're going on to item 15, an interesting item, exciting item.

2:19:07 Authorizing the lease with Tesla Motors for space within the existing park and ride lot for electrical vehicle charging stations. Dan? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. For the last, I guess over a month now, we've been working with representatives from Tesla Motors regarding leasing space in the town's park and ride lot on Old Mammoth Road to put in a supercharging station. So it takes 20 to 30 minutes or so for a Tesla vehicle to be recharged.

2:19:34 Before I keep going, also, one of your last public attenders this evening is Andrew Levy from Tesla Motors, so we'll ask him to speak if need be to the item. We've worked through the draft lease agreement, and the draft that's in your packet had about a half dozen items that needed some additional follow-up between Tesla and the town. We have actually done that, I think, fairly effectively. I think there's one item for some additional discussion between the two attorneys.

2:20:02 Between Andy and the Tesla Motors attorney and one policy item that I wanted to highlight. Otherwise, I think we're pretty well in agreement on the rest of the details that have been worked out between staff and the Tesla representatives there. And before I jump into that, one is you're all familiar with the parking lot. We're talking about the parking lot of Old Mammoth Road. There's about 68 spaces in that lot today.

2:20:29 This would take basically 16 of those, a limit eight, and then commit eight to the charging stations that basically would be in the center of the lot. We've had to widen out the spaces to accommodate the charging stations and to be able to make sure we have clear area for snow removal. We don't want to be running over bollards and other elements in terms of protecting the charging stations. So it's been one of the key issues in working in this environment, walking through that capability to deal with snow removal.

2:20:59 The item between the attorneys that wrap up will be a question on indemnification and waiver and I'll let Andy speak to that as need be in terms of cleanup there. The other policy question is in paragraph 18 but it deals with relocation as we are going into a public parking facility. One of the questions that...

2:21:21 We were up front on the front end that there had been discussions over time about this being a parking structure. There were tentative plans a few years ago for an affordable housing project on top of a structure and those things. So the question was raised is what happens if the town would either dispose of the property or do some other project there and would we be displacing the charging station?

2:21:46 The concern on Tesla's side is we just get people trained up or to come and charge their cars and then we, oh, sorry, we're moving the station problem on that. The proposal coming back would be that in the initial term, the first five-year term, that we would not require relocation. We actually don't, frankly, see any type of project being able to come forward in that time frame. There's nothing.

2:22:08 Pending to come and look at that. But that would be one of the policy questions of giving that first five-year term where we would not require them to relocate. In a future term, if we did, there would be a notification. I think it's a one-year notification, which would tie into any planning and CEQA process and those types of things to move something forward. And then we would work with them in finding another similar type of place for the charging station to remain in the town.

2:22:33 So those are the key elements to that, and I'll let Andy address some of the key pieces of that and the outstanding identification item. I'll say feel free to touch on any of the other issues we've worked through, and then I'll have Mr. The other aspect of the relocation that we've talked to Tesla about is in addition to agreeing that we would not be able to make them relocate in the first five years, if we asked them to relocate in the second five years, we would split the cost with them, which Tesla has been...

2:23:00 Been gracious enough to agree to that. They haven't done that in the other two cities that I'm aware of in California where they have similar leases in those cities, which is Ukiah and Crescent City. Those cities agreed that they would pay all the relocation costs for the first 10 years. So we're getting a little bit better deal and it's up to you as to how you feel about committing this site for that length of time. The indemnity issue that Dan mentioned is a relatively minor one. We're just...

2:23:23 Great.

2:23:52 Questions from Council? I'd like to turn over to Mr. Levy if you'd like to add any additional items to the conversation. Andrew Levy. I'm a resident of Berkeley, California, and I work for Tesla Motors. I'm a project developer for them. So I build these supercharger sites all throughout the country. So this is a part of a network.

2:24:15 It is not just a stand-alone site. It is part of a network that we're building throughout the country. It's ever-expanding. We have about 240 of them right now in the country. That number is increasing every week.

2:24:27 So with this, Mammoth is an interesting place in that people want to come here and stop here, but there also will be stopping and passing through. So it's a good opportunity for people as they go sort of from LA up to Reno that this would be the place that they stop. The next spot that we have on the way down to LA, we have one in Lone Pine, there's one in Inyokern, there's one in Mojave.

2:24:55 And then there are numerous throughout LA. So it's going to bring a lot of people to whoever is a Tesla driver that's going to be on this road, they will stop here. So there's not only guaranteed, but most of them will stop here because this is going to be the one location in the area that they're going to be able to get this rapid charge.

2:25:19 They could go ahead and get a slower charge. A lot of people who are residents may choose to install charging at their home, but this is going to be the rapid charge for them to come and go. As Dan mentioned, it's about 30 minutes for people to stop, which is just enough time for them to go get some lunch, have dinner, check out the town, do whatever they want during that time. Just a couple quick questions.

2:25:49 Guard dog, bulldog attorney to get something figured out here. Tell us what's north in your network of 395 and also what's to the east because I know Nevada is working on something they're calling the electric highway from Reno to Las Vegas. Is there an opportunity to

2:26:09 I'm thinking like the LTC and going back to some of a regional articulation of what we're doing with this. Is that an opportunity for us? Yeah, I think there is an opportunity for marketing with that. I will speak to what we don't, we're not.

2:26:24 We didn't create that electric highway that they're talking about, so I can't speak to that fully. But we would name this the Mammoth Supercharger. It would immediately go up on our website. We have numerous events where our drivers, we have a very active community of drivers that are very interested and they have rallies. As soon as they find out that there will be a site in Mammoth, they'll start...

2:26:52 Getting interested, and then they'll drive up here. As for further north, we don't have any at this point. It is on our schedule for future builds to connect with Reno. As you may know, we're building a gigafactory. What we call a gigafactory is a battery factory. It's a very important facility for us, and people are going to be going back and forth from LA. So that is the continuation north on 395.

2:27:20 Proposed and coming up after this. So if they get a charge in Mammoth, can they get to your Gigafactory in Reno? It depends on the weather conditions. We set up our cars have a range of 270 miles for the largest battery pack. So that usually can make it, but the terrain obviously makes a difference, and then very cold weather. So we're designing our network.

2:27:47 To have sites that are within about 100 to 120 miles away from each other. Okay. So we want to have another one so that people don't feel like they just got there. Right. That they were able to stop and charge up and feel comfortable. And they would go to the Gigafactory on 395, right? They wouldn't go up? Yeah, it's in Sparks. Okay. So we'll run it that way. And finally, is there another community that's got one of these supercharging stations that you would point to as being a good?

2:28:11 Model a good way for a community to integrate the opportunities of a charging station into the local community, if that's appropriate to say. I'm not quite sure the question. Well, because we're going to be in a municipal parking lot. People are going to show up there. They're going to say, okay, I'm at my beautiful Tesla supercharging station. Where is something? How do I?

2:28:34 You know, how do I find something in this place? Do other communities do something like that to help them? You can. I mean, it's your property. If you wanted to put a sign up on the property that said, you know, please be happy to join, you know, go to the restaurants across the street. Right. We're happy to have that.

2:28:49 The car itself has navigation and also on the website. So we do have in the navigation there are not specific names, but there will be icons of, you know, food amenities or a restaurant or hotel or whatever the amenity is nearby. So it will indicate that. And then on the website itself we do list whatever is within walking distance. Okay. So we don't promote, we wouldn't promote necessarily.

2:29:18 You know, the mountain for a place that's down, you know, in that location. But for the restaurants that are right there and the hotels, those will be listed on our site. Okay, good. And don't forget, John, being the park and ride lot, it's a...

2:29:31 Tied right into our transit system. No, exactly. That's perfect. Get on and go. We look for specific locations that are safe, that have amenities nearby, that somebody can jump on the trolley. These are, again, most of the time...

2:29:50 They're going to be 30 minutes or 30 to 40 minutes. So most people are not going to park there all day long, get on the trolley and go up to the mountain, but they could. We would ask them to move out of that space. If they're staying longer. If they're staying longer, yeah. Just a couple comments. I don't know if you guys follow your Tesla chat board very closely, but I do. And there's a lot of comments about.

2:30:20 building the supercharger station here. Since you guys put in Lone Pine in Mojave, we've started seeing Teslas arrive in town more and more. So I think this is a big win. I think it's a big win for the Tesla community that's been asking for this to happen. There's a lot of rumors and stuff that, you know, we wouldn't work with you guys and we didn't have a site and all this crazy stuff. But to be on your supercharger map, I think it's great for the town. And I'm glad that you guys are

2:30:49 Come into town and hopefully you guys will consider like Carson or Gardnerville or that way. You know, to pass would be great before, you know, another stop before going up towards Reno so, you know, you don't have an issue with distance.

2:31:05 That's right. The other aspect that's already here in Mammoth is that some of the hotels have put in what we call our high-powered wall connectors. Those are for overnight guests, so that's attractive. If you don't have a house or a condo here, you can go stay at the hotel. By the morning, you can charge up. That's probably what I'll do tonight.

2:31:28 And then lastly, how do we get Elon to come for the ribbon cutting? You know, I suppose you could invite him. All right, great. Any other questions? Any questions from the public? Okay, I'll entertain a motion. So we'd ask that you authorize Dan to sign the lease with whatever minor amendments we figure out soon. So it's not going to be the exact one. It's in the packet. It will be an updated one.

2:31:56 Reflects a few changes. Okay. I'll go ahead and make a motion that authorized the lease between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Tesla Motors for space within existing park and ride lot for electric vehicle charging stations in substantial, what is that? Conformance. Conformance, I couldn't see it. With the presented draft lease and authorized the Town Manager to sign the lease subject to final legal review with modifications. Second. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Roll call. Yes. Yes.

2:32:31 Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0. Thank you very much. Thanks for coming. Thank you very much. The last item tonight is item 16, provide direction regarding the Town Council's position on League of California Cities resolutions to be voted on at the annual League meeting to be held on October 2, 2015. Dan? Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

2:32:54 Brought the item forward each year as part of the League of Cities meetings. There's an annual meeting of the various member cities. They have a variety of items that come before them. In this case, there's four different items. One of them deals with their governance structure and how to handle issues where if somebody's scheduled to be in a position of leadership, it's not reelected and they can't fulfill that term. The other three deal with particular issues. One of them, SB.

2:33:22 593, the town has taken a position on in the past regarding transient rentals. There's a couple others there that deal with concentrations of alcohol and drug abuse recovery facilities. There's another one dealing with Southern California Edison and directing for provision of compensation in areas where you have a prolonged electrical outage.

2:33:45 With the exception of the one on SB 593 where the council has taken a position, I'm assuming that will be consistent with the actions we have taken. You actually see a letter from us in support of that measure. I just want to confirm council's direction regarding voting on these. I'll be attending the meeting. I know that Councilmember Richardson had planned on going and ended up with a family commitment where he could not attend.

2:34:09 So rather than going out and voting without Council's direction, the request is for Council to review these and provide any direction. From the initial review at the staff level, we saw nothing jump out at us that would say to oppose any of the proposals. So the recommendation would be to look at supporting those. But rather than just assuming that, I did want to bring the item forward and get formal direction from Council regarding the vote on these matters.

2:34:38 Okay. Thank you, Dan. Any comments? No, I'm in support of the ones that are here. I'm hoping also, though, that we could start the discussion about some of these potential fire impacts and see if that's another avenue to start working with it. I realize nothing could be voted on at this point, but it's just getting it out there because it's got to be hitting everywhere else.

2:35:04 Cities everywhere else. Yeah, and I would hope what we could do is just request that as you're attending the conference, please gather any information that you hear about fire stuff. Also, as it may relate to...

2:35:21 The, what is it, the WIP program for the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, the Watershed Improvement Plan, the Healthy Forest Initiatives, anything that's related to the, because all these things are tied together. And the governor of the state is ultimately the one who's trying to beat up the Forest Service to deal with a lot of this stuff. Anything, forest health, fire, drought, water yields, all that kind of stuff, that stuff would be helpful. I think as it relates to the fire and the Great Basin and the CARB issues and the letters we're doing on that and the smoke impacts,

2:35:49 I think that would be something very appropriate to bring up with our division. There's actually a separate meeting in the division at the conference and to begin that conversation for that to roll up into some of the policy committees. So it's a good point to begin to lay those issues out and pick up the other data. There will be breakouts. I don't think there's anyone who thinks there will not be impacts next summer. Right, right, right. There will be breakouts for those groups, right? Yes. Yes. Just one other point.

2:36:18 Very intelligent man, talked about a whole range of subjects. When it came time to advising what things he would consider, you know, worthy of putting any effort into back in Washington, he said, well, public safety. If you can frame it on a public safety issue, I want to hear about it. This is obviously a public safety issue. And I think we're talking with the League, we're talking with our chapter, but ultimately this becomes a congressional issue. There is stuff happening in Congress now about this. Secretary Vilsack.

2:36:44 He's going to the Congress and saying we spent, I think, over half of their appropriated budget for the Forest Service has been on fires. This is an unsustainable, ridiculous situation. But I think our voices need to be heard on those channels as well. Yeah, to John Eastman's letter. Exactly. But we've got to channel all that stuff. No question. Agreed. To D.C., so. Well, we've cleared the roast. There's no public comment. We've only seen a motion. I'll make a motion. Unless you, if not to Joe.

2:37:13 No, no, no. Go right ahead. I'll make a motion to direct the town manager to support the four items that will be before him, which is our council's position on the California League of Cities resolutions to be voted on at the annual meeting on October 2, 2015. I would second, adding only that he...

2:37:41 Bring back any information pertinent to fire for itself. Bring that back without a formalized motion. Okay, fine. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Janet. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes for zero. We will now adjourn to our next regular schedule meeting to be held on Wednesday, October 7th, 2015 at 6 p.m. right here in Suite Z. Good night. Yeah, we can take it.