TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 1 hr 23 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

168 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 So when I was on vacation I had to do like a hard reset on my phone. So I wasn't able to, so I just haven't reinstalled it onto my phone. So I, and then I forget to check it out. I just need to like re-install it.

0:22 Oh.

0:53 Good afternoon. I call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Thursday, November the 12th. Confused me all week. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang.

1:31 He's not here. He called in and he'll be retarded. Okay. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Commissioner Verruck? Here. Vice Chair Grayick? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to every republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, and liberty and justice for all.

2:08 At this time, we'll have public comments. Public comments is for anybody that wishes to speak on any item that's not on today's agenda. Do we have anybody for public comments? Would anybody like to comment on our snow conditions? Which are wonderful. Okay, then we'll close the public comment period and we'll move to our first business matter, which is the status update on the police station. Thank you, Madam Chair and Commission. Grady Dutton, Public Works.

2:43 Just last month, Town Council authorizes to sign an appointment with HMC Architects out of Ontario, California, for the design of a new police station. It's going to be located over on the McFlix parcel south of the courthouse. Actually, the architects were in town last week for a full four days, and by a full four days, I mean they were here from...

3:04 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and then worked at their cabin that they'd rented until 11 o'clock every night at least. And they really went through a lot of things. They met with 17 different either individuals or group at town offices and here and around town. They went through programming for the facility, space planning, site opportunity constraints, site planning, preliminary design. They toured the site. They toured the existing police station. I thought they really did a great job. They even met with the design committee of PEDC as a first shot to try to get.

3:33 Get a sense of what you'd be looking for when it comes back with design. Overall, we're very happy with it. Nolan was involved with some of it when he was in town and when he wasn't. Has reviewed this stuff since. Again, I thought the whole thing went very well.

3:50 Our next steps, if you will, next week at the workshop with Town Council, which is next Wednesday, I believe, at 5 o'clock, we're going to provide another update of the police facility just to give you a better idea and talk a little bit more about budget and architecture.

4:04 Then we'll be back to the design committee probably in December and back to this group in January. It's moving very quickly because I think everybody knows what we want. The police facility is ready to go. We have the funding for it, so we'll keep it moving. And we actually expect to advertise this thing sometime in the summer and be under construction and finish it mid to the next year. So it's moving right along. What you see on the screen up there is...

4:30 A first shot at the site planning. I say that because our real intent was to go through the process to locate the police station in the right place and then look at flexibility for the rest of the site. What you see on the right up near the courthouse parking lot is about a 5,200 square foot police facility. It has a sally port. It'll have enough parking there for police vehicles secured in the back and some public parking that we'll actually share with the courthouse in front.

4:56 Those last few spaces next to the courtyard are actually on our property as opposed to the courtyard's. Along those lines, we've actually met with... Excuse me. So, I'm sorry. I'm having trouble getting the orientation. So, where's the... Thank you. Well, it's not always like that. Yeah, I know. But where's the existing courthouse? The dark part on the upper left is the existing courthouse. Right. To the right is their parking lot. Okay. And to the right of that is Thompson Way. Okay, right.

5:26 So we'd actually take access off of Thompson Way. What we found was that corner of the site had utilities already there, it was flatter, and also it was actually constrained by a utility easement that goes through the site. They're both utilities and a water line, so that ended up being the best spot for that. As for the rest of the site, we do show a possible future administrative area for the town.

5:54 Off in the future at that location. That does not by any means mean it's going to be there. We just wanted to demonstrate that it fits there. It would also fit if we slid that building to the east. It would fit if we slid it to the north. As I started, we talked to the hospital, we've talked to the courts, and we've talked to the county about the possibility of joint use for maybe a parking structure or some other accessibility issues. They're all very excited that we're moving forward.

6:19 And they're ready to talk to us about all those things. Pam's heavily involved with that because she's managing our process with the Reflex and tying up some of the loose ends there. So, again, we've had good meetings with all three of those. That's about it for today. I just wanted to give you a brief update again. We are looking at 1,500 square feet. The architects have already started looking at architecture, and they'll be back before you most likely in December at design review and then back to this group in January.

6:46 With that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Again, we just started last week, so we've come a long way. Do we have any questions? What's your goal for expected completion? Summer of 2017. In fact, the architects are saying spring. If anything, we're going to slow them down a little bit to make sure we get all due diligence done, but early 2017. And budget?

7:11 It's still holding strong at $2 million. We have a design contingency of about $100,000, but we feel pretty good about that. Again, we don't even have much preliminary design yet, as you saw, but we're getting a good start at it, but we're confident with that, right around $2 million. Brady, once we vacate the old lease building, what happens to that structure? Well, our lease actually runs out in December of 2017, so we're required to move out, and I don't know if the owners...

7:40 We certainly haven't put them on notice yet, but they know the lease is expired at that time and what they choose to do with it. We will be reusing as much as we can, which for those who toured that facility isn't going to be much, frankly, but we'll take what we can out of there and reuse it and then it just goes back to the owners because the lease will expire. So, I'm sorry, I thought I had marked it, but later on today we'll be talking about priorities that council's working on and one of their...

8:12 Priorities was this joint, you know, working with our police department and the sheriffs and the highway patrol, and I just didn't know if this facility tied into that in any way, or is that more of a personnel issue versus a facility issue? We have actually talked to them about the facility needs with CHP, with the sheriff's office and everybody. They don't really have anything they want to locate here, so that discussion is more about just coordination, I believe, with personnel and operations. Okay. Are there any other questions?

8:42 All right. We look forward to you coming back. Thank you very much. Okay. And then we'll move on to our next business matter, which is a status update on the community multi-use facility at Mammoth Creek Park West. Thank you. Town Council has provided direction to staff to move forward with the planning and the environmental work for a new community multi-use facilities at Mammoth Creek Park West. That'll include not only the...

9:20 Reconstructed ice rink slash multi-use facility with a roof on it, but it will also include at least the planning for a community center. When the ad hoc group and town council considered what was the best complementary use on that site for the multi-use facility, it was determined the greatest need at that time is a new community center. I think I've mentioned before in this group, the old one is held together by paint.

9:47 and wire, so we're happy to move forward with that. We actually already sent out an RFQ, a request for qualifications for a design consultant. The stated goal in that request is to get a consultant on board who will help us plan the site and then do the preliminary architecture and design for both a

10:07 New multi-use facility and a community center of up to 10,000 square feet as a basis for the CEQA documentation. That's clearly stated in the RFQ and everything we're telling everybody because we've had a lot of comments from the public about the facility, about noise and lights and traffic and everything else. We want to make sure we make it clear that our next step is preliminary design, CEQA process.

10:29 If at the end of that time, when that document is certified, the Town Council then directs us to move forward, we will. The expectation is we will for the multi-use facility. We've identified most of the funds for it, not all of it yet, but most of those funds, and we've been telling the public that our goal is to open that facility, have an actual ribbon cutting by Halloween of 2017. We think that's very doable.

10:52 At the same time as we're looking for that planning and architectural consultant, Sandra sent out a request to our environmental consultants for proposal for an EIR on that site. While we certainly don't conclude the discussion and decide early on that we're going to have an EIR, thanks guys, because of the amount of interest from the community and amount of controversy from the last project, we pretty much said, look.

11:22 Well, we don't know that it's technically required. We think it's the best thing to do, and that's what we've recommended to town council to do that. It'll include quite a bit of community outreach. In addition to postings in the newspaper and the normal mailings, we're going to see if we can't contact every homeowner and business within an X amount of radius. We're going to have at least one public workshop in January. We'll narrow down from three site.

11:47 Planning alternatives down to one. We'll have another public meeting at that time, even before we start the environmental process. And then, of course, during that, the public will have a chance to comment as well. As far as the community center goes, there is no funding set aside yet for that. There's been no funding identified to build any of it. The Rec Commission is going to work on programming that facility and see that...

12:11 See what might make sense for a first phase. If it's 3,000 square feet, we might come back and recommend that, 5,000. Eventually, though, it could be up to 10. From a CEQA perspective, we want to analyze the largest foreseeable facility so that we don't have to go back and do it again. So at the end of that time...

12:29 We may or may not have a community center under construction in 2016 or 17. That's not known yet because the funding isn't there. And it certainly will be a part of the council goals and priorities to talk about that project and see where it falls. With that, I'd be glad to answer any questions. Do we have any questions? So really for our viewing public, I think there's a tremendous amount of confusion.

12:56 Out there and maybe even some misstatements of facts. So I just really want to verify that if this moves forward that this project is currently within our zoning and general plan for that particular land area, correct? We would not be asking for any zoning changes. It's already zoned for that. That's correct. It's zoned public, quasi-public.

13:18 So it's appropriate for that. We are not going to, we do not anticipate looking for any type of a height variance. The only thing that we may consider is a setback on the south side of the property. We abut up to the U.S. Forest Service land there to open space. And we've already talked to Forest Service there. They said they would not object to that. It doesn't really impact any of the other neighbors. So that's the only thing we may be looking for is a setback variance on the south side.

13:48 And then there has been no placement of a proposed building on the site yet, right? I mean, that is still being reviewed, discussed, correct? We have had sessions where we've talked about where it could go, where it probably shouldn't go. But as far as we're concerned, we're starting from scratch. We're going to rely on our planning consultant to give us three alternatives, and we'll go from there. Okay. And that no matter where the facilities are placed,

14:16 The park, there would still be an existing park on the property for the children to play, correct? Absolutely. Okay. And then just for clarification, and then for this year on the existing ice rink, then we're not moving forward with any kind of shade screen because the cost is prohibitive, right? That's correct. We studied that, looked at a lot of different things. We are not moving forward with a temporary shade this season. Okay. I just really want to make sure if any...

14:47 My fellow commissioners have any questions? I mean, it's pretty amazing some of the things I've heard out in the community, and I think it's really important. One of our roles is always to make sure that people understand what the facts are on a particular project. So did you have anything else? Would you like to add about that, Sandra? No. All right. And frankly, that's one of the reasons we're here today, because the more often we get back in front of yourselves and the public and give them an opportunity, you know, the better information we're on.

15:15 I appreciate it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Did anybody else have any comments in the public about either about the police station or the multi-use facility? Okay. Thank you very much. Okay. We'll move on to our third business matter, which is the CEQA Environmental Impact Report training. This is really part two of our training, and Nolan's going to help us with this. So you guys all have a copy of the handouts as well.

16:00 Again, this is, I guess, part two of the CEQA training. We had kind of just overview of the whole CEQA process and history at last month's meeting. And this training will really focus on the Environmental Impact Report, or the EIR. This slide was included in the previous presentation. I included it again because I think it kind of accurately portrays the varying levels of CEQA review.

16:31 I did include the red boxes on here to highlight where the EIR is within this. As you see, it's doing the EIR presents the lowest risk, but it has the most time and cost. So again, it's the most defensible, can stand up to any legal challenges, but it's going to take a lot longer. On here it says minimum 9 to 18 months. I think that's reasonable for a full project EIR. There are shorter ones.

16:58 Kind of a specific or focused EIR on just certain components. A quick recap, EIR is required when it's been identified that there has a potential to be significant environmental impacts. If it's identified there's no significant impacts, then you can adopt just a negative declaration or a mitigated negative declaration. Types of EIR, there's kind of a lot of them. Typically what the

17:31 Planning Commission will see is either a project EIR or a subsequent EIR or an addendum to it. The project EIR is really starting from scratch looking at all the potential impacts of a project that's coming forward. Where the subsequent EIR, that's going to look at a project that already has a certified EIR, so like the Inn at the Village at 8050 that came before you that had an EIR done. The subsequent EIR only analyzed impacts.

18:00 That were based on the changes to the project. So it's really more of a focused EIR that tiers off of the original project EIR. And that's the same with the supplement as well as the addendum. The addendum's really used only when there's minimal changes to it, technical changes such as for Greystone.

18:24 John Hooper's project that was previously phase two of solstice, they did an addendum to the load start plan since it didn't change any of the impacts, it only changed briefly what the project was, the same type of project, residential housing. Quick thing, this is all the contents of the EIR, this is what the state and their CEQA guidelines require an EIR to contain.

18:52 The ones in orange I highlighted, those are the ones I'm going to really touch on in this presentation. Those are generally the most kind of important sections of the EIR that contain the most information on what the project is, what the potential impacts of the project might be, as well as what the mitigation measures would be. So the summary of the EIR, this is generally one of the most valuable sections of the EIR. If you have limited time available to review, this is the section you're going to want to

19:22 Read and look at the most. It should contain pretty much everything on what the project is, the proposed action, all the mitigation measures, comparison of the alternatives, as well as it should discuss areas of controversy. This is areas that either responsible agencies, the public, other groups have brought up during the public hearings. And so this should all be contained in that summary so you can get

19:51 Really an overview of all the potential impacts of the project and all the necessary information. In fact, the state now, where previously had to submit 15 copies of the entire EIR to the state, they now accept 15 printed copies of the summary and then 15 copies of the full EIR on a CD to accompany it. And then also, as noted, the state recommends that it should not exceed 15 pages.

20:23 EIR everything was to provide a document that was easy to read for anyone to find out what the impacts of the project. It's kind of morphed into this beast that's way beyond that now, but their intent is to at least keep the summary easy to read, easy to identify all the potential impacts as well as the mitigations. Next up, the project description. This is developed early on in the process.

20:51 Such as for the FAR, it already came to the Planning Commission for the project description. So this really is going to dictate and direct the whole rest of the process. It's going to identify the objectives and the purpose of the project. And should it contain a clearly written statement that will help the lead agency develop a reasonable range of alternatives and will aid the decision makers in preparing the findings. Real quick on the contents of the ER, this is...

21:22 All the different impacts that you might look at during the initial study is when you'd first see these. With the initial study, you can eliminate the ones that clearly will not have an impact or there's no impact, so you can really focus on those impacts that might be found to be significant. Again, you have direct impacts and indirect impacts.

21:46 Direct impacts are those directly caused by the project, such as construction impacts or additional traffic. Indirect impacts are those that are caused by the project, but you won't see until later in time. It's still reasonable, foreseeable. These might be things such as contribution to air pollution. These impacts are analyzed using thresholds of significance. The town

22:12 has in their work plan to develop specific thresholds of significance that are kind of town specific. I don't believe we've started on that process, but it is in the work plan for a future item when there is staff time available to do it. Generally, thresholds of significance, some are standard ones set by the state, such as air quality thresholds where the project's going to exceed that. You have to identify what mitigation measures will

22:41 Reduce it to less than significant. Others such as traffic, generally it's going to be identified in the mobility element for certain areas of town such as vehicle miles traveled and then specific studies for the project will identify whether it exceeds those or whether it's below and then no mitigations would be required. So if like a common one it would be traffic study would be done to

23:09 determine what impacts the project will have on traffic. Another one that is fairly new in the guidelines, I touched on the bottom here, is economic impacts. It identifies they must be discussed where the economic impact would lead to a physical change in the environment. I don't have too much time to research exactly how that, when that triggers. I know

23:36 Chair Brown mentioned San Luis Obispo has an economic component. I tried to look through theirs whether it is required in every EIR to have a full chapter, and I couldn't find anything in their documents on their website that identified when that comes into play or not. Okay, but for clarification, though, these sections are mandated by the state. Correct. I mean, you have no leeway in these sections. I mean, this is the outline you're given, correct? Yeah, this is the outline, so it identifies you have to have these. Right.

24:07 Look at these impacts and it's at the beginning with the initial study you're going to already take out the ones that are identified as no impacts and then you're only further analyzing the ones that would have an impact and identifying mitigations for those. Okay. So then going into that, the mitigation measures, so for every significant impact mitigation measures need to be identified.

24:34 These must be enforceable. They're not limited to the lead agencies, so they could default to responsible agencies, such as for, like, wetland mitigations would follow to Fish and Wildlife and the Army Corps and the Regional Water Quality Control Board. The one that can participate in existing programs, if there's already an existing conservation plan, they can...

24:59 Include their mitigations in that, or if they already have existing housing mitigations, they can include their housing mitigations within that. And then the other one, any impacts from those mitigations or significant effects also need to be analyzed within that and how those are going to be reduced, whether that's additional mitigations from those. It can definitely get kind of cumbersome looking through these. So these mitigation measures will be,

25:29 Analyze and discuss throughout the document. Then they're also going to be contained in the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, the MMRP, which is typically adopted at the same time as the EIR. And this is going to be almost a chart table that identifies what the mitigation measure is, who's responsible for implementing it or enforcing it, any deadlines associated with it. Some might be at prior to construction,

25:59 On first season, depending on certain things, such like nesting bird surveys, have a typical, very specific time frame they need to occur. So all that's going to be really identified in the MMRP. That way it can be tracked throughout the project as well. Those are typically tied back to conditions of approval also that then would be verified and checked when the project comes in and different milestones throughout that project. Then, real quick on there, I have

26:29 This is just what the CEQA identifies as what a mitigation measure may be. It either needs to avoid, minimize, rectify, reduce or eliminate, or compensate. There's a brief explanation of each one there in your packet. The other kind of key section of the EIR is the alternatives. So there's one, they need to propose the no project alternative. This would be leaving the site as is.

27:00 With nothing done to it. So for undeveloped site, it'd be comparing the proposed project against leaving the site untouched. And so for others, like if it's an existing project that is going to be torn down and rebuilt and something else gets a little trickier because it's comparing what's there now versus what's proposed. And the other one it requires is that they have to analyze and review and identify a reasonable range of alternatives.

27:31 Alternative is expected to be potentially feasible, so you couldn't propose something just completely unrelated to it. In CEQA, the key thing is, though, that they're not expected to be analyzed at the same level of detail. In the NEPA process, you have to analyze everything at the same level of detail, so that's on the national side. So for California, you have to analyze it and look at any

28:00 Significant effects and possible mitigation measures, but you don't need to go as in-depth on it. So it's going to be just one chapter of the EIR versus the entire 500-page EIR for each alternative. So going forward, once the EIR comes to the decision-making body, it needs to be certified. This has to be done prior to project approval. This is going to either be done just as the first.

28:30 Item in the resolution or it can be done as a complete separate resolution. There are some timelines from when the ER certified to when the project has to be approved. But the key thing is just that it has to be certified prior to project approval. And with that, they are required, there's required CEQA findings in the guidelines. They're very specific. Here, so if it's been found that the project with

28:59 If all the mitigations will have no significant impacts on the environment, then it would be the findings listed in this section 15091. It identifies all the impact and all the mitigations that reduce it and that it will have no impact on the environment. Alternatively, there's an option if there are going to be significant effects, but it's been

29:25 Identify that the project is such of a community benefit that it outweighs environmental impacts. The decision-making body can adopt a statement of overriding considerations. There is additional items that need to be supported in that. On both, they need to be backed by substantial evidence, which is generally going to be the EIR and the final EIR, as well as all the appendices and studies that go with it, and then the administrative record.

29:55 On top of that, which is everything that went into that report or into the project. This just touches briefly on what the three findings are. First one is the project's been changed to avoid or substantially reduce impact magnitude or the changes to the project are within another agency's jurisdiction and such changes have been or should be adopted. Or the third one is

30:25 That there are specific economic, social, legal, technical, or other considerations that make a mitigation measure or alternative infeasible. Depending on the impacts, one or all these may apply. So real quick here, just touched on what this infeasibility finding is. Can we just interrupt a second? We just switched for the day because Commissioner Root wasn't sure if she was going to be able to stay for the whole meeting. So I want you to be confused. We're glad you're here.

30:56 Commissioner Chang. Thank you. And we're doing EIR Part 2. That's where we are on the agenda. Commissioner Chang, you have the presentation there. I don't know what page we're on of it, but I might be able to help you out there. It's page 5 of the press. We're on page 5 of the... So, yeah, just the infeasibility. If you do make this finding, such as taking out a mitigation measure or an alternative, you have to state the specific reason why that's infeasible.

31:31 Have substantial evidence supporting that finding. Just touching on reading an EIR. There's kind of three, I think, broad questions you can have back in mind when you're really reading the document. One is, does the EIR accurately describe the project? Two, are the likely impacts accurately described? So when you're going up, they say, you know, everything is no significance except this one item.

32:00 In your mind, you say, well, I think there may be significant impacts on all these other items. Why aren't those included? So that might be when you add the draft EIR or before, hopefully before it's to the certification process, you state, I think you need to analyze these impacts further. And the last one, do the mitigation measures actually reduce the impact to less than significant? So again, kind of similar to the first one. If you're reading and you think these mitigation measures don't actually do anything,

32:30 And it's good to put that out there at a public hearing prior to the certification process so that it can be further analyzed and developed. This last part I found is a presentation to the City of Davis and their kind of how to read an EIR. It touched on how much time you have and what to really touch on. So it kind of listed from 30 minutes, an hour, five hours, unlimited time.

32:58 So that's really touching, if you know, really pressing time to really look through that summary and read everything through there, because that should provide all the necessary, really relevant facts for the project. Next, if you have additional time, they say read the executive summary, and that's going to be similar to the regular summary. If you have extensive time, it says to really read the whole document, including then all the appendices, studies, everything else that goes with it. I mean, it could be a...

33:27 On a full EIR, 700 pages, quite a bit, and it's fairly complex, and like I said, it's kind of gone away from where it's supposed to be this easy-to-read document to this highly complex, almost scientific document in some cases. Next, in reading it, it's again from the project description where it clearly identifies the objectives and purpose of the projects. You should really have that in the back of your mind reading through it, is does this...

33:56 Identify an answer and serve to identify all the objectives, answer all the questions, analyze and identify all the impacts of the project. Next one, impose local values on the EIR process. So again, this kind of falls back to this significance of thresholds that can be fairly location specific, such as obviously here we have visual impacts are really

34:26 I think an important aspect here locally, it's somewhat difficult to identify threshold significance for some visual impacts on what's going to be significant and not. Our general plan does identify view sheds and corridors that can be used, but again, it's still, some of these items are somewhat difficult to identify. One person might say everything is significant, view another would argue with them, so that's one area.

34:56 And the other one I talked about was if a mitigation measure might lessen the impact of one item, but it could increase another impact locally. So you said, okay, widen the streets, have more traffic flowing, but it's going to reduce bike lanes or sidewalks. Is that a good mitigation measure? Is it not? Depending on your local values and what you value in that.

35:19 The last one suggested was the no project alternative because this is really where you're going to see that comparison of absolutely nothing done on the site to the proposed project. So you can really see what those impacts, what the level of change might be. Then the last one it said was don't expect to find all the answers in the EIR. The EIR is an information document meant to disclose and identify any potential impacts and then mitigations to reduce those.

35:46 It's not meant to make the decision or write policy for it. That's really up to the decision-making body to take that document and say, yes, this analyzes all the potential impacts. It reduces them with these mitigation measures. And therefore, we think this supports the project moving forward and that it's passed the CEQA clearance. And with that, that is the end. Any other questions?

36:23 You choked her up with your... I don't have any questions. Do you have any questions? I don't. Did you have any? I think so. We need to get you like hot water. I had... Dola, would it be possible to get you to email this PowerPoint to us? Yes, absolutely. There's a little bit of some of the... Yeah, the black and white makes it tricky. I think I emailed the part one out to everyone. I'll send this one out as well. Thank you. And I'll double check that I sent part one. If I didn't at all include that.

36:54 Yeah, because you missed part one. It was pretty interesting. I'm sorry. Oh, you missed it too. That's right. So yeah, you should go take a look at it. It was just interesting because we're going to have some big EIRs coming up in the future. Did you have any questions, Commissioner? I know you. I do have a quick question on the discussion. Okay. So for ours, it would be, generally our general plan identifies

37:35 Key visual, the scenic corridors, so it would be any project within there, visual resource identified in the general plan or otherwise of significance to the area. Big ones are scenic highways. We're not on any scenic highways here in town. We're close to one, 395. Really, it's somewhat subjective, but it really is looking at anything of high, I forget the exact terms, like high scenic quality.

38:04 When I think of visual, I think of aesthetic. Oh yeah, that's what it falls about. It's aesthetics, but it's like design, but really it's looking at two visuals. So if you're putting large buildings, it's going to block your view of the scenic order of the Sherwins, of the mountain, one or the other. So it touches on aesthetics as well as your local views. That was a significant discussion when we were talking about height planements on Main Street in Old Mammoth Road.

38:35 about how it would impact the viewshed of the local mountains. There's quite a bit of documentation on that. And then I just want to make sure that everybody's clarified. When we discuss viewsheds, it's only public viewsheds. We do not discuss somebody's private viewshed, for example, from their condominium. Because often when we're in a public hearing, somebody will say, well, if you build this building, then I'll no longer be able to see Lincoln Mountain or whatever.

39:05 Yeah, so it's closed on, yeah, from the public right-of-way streets, public areas. So we can be empathetic about that, but that is not what this is pertaining to. Did you have any other questions? Okay, so I had a question. This goes back to the EIR certification. It says that the EIR needs to be reviewed and considered before approving the project. So what's the definition of approving the project?

39:38 So that's what I said where generally it'd be like the first item before you actually make the finding approving the project. So typically you'll see in the resolution it'll have kind of the first one will be find the environmental document that's adequate and certify whether it's EIR or that. It's like the first finding with the findings to support that. Then the next ones after would be

40:06 Approve whatever the project would be. So whether it's a tentative map, conditional use permit. So it would really be that it's the first action or it can be a completely separate action. It can be you could certify the EIR at one hearing and then at a following public hearing. There is a certain timeline after you could adopt or approve the project. So that's actually making the findings for whatever the project is, whether it's a tentative map, a use permit, et cetera, making those findings.

40:35 Okay. But we can never approve a project with the condition that the EIR work will be completed? Correct. The environmental clearance has to be before approving the project. Okay. You can adopt the MMRP after, but the actual certification of the environmental document has to be prior to approval of the project. Are we good? Good.

41:09 So when we get our first 700-page document, we're ready. Hopefully it will be a smaller one. We'll report back to you. Do you know of which upcoming projects might have an EIR? The Florida ratio analysis will. We anticipate, based on what a consultant's proposed for Old Mammoth Place, they're suggesting that it's likely going to be some kind of...

41:39 EIR for that, whether it's going to hopefully be a subsequent EIR or an ADEM, they haven't determined the exact impacts yet, but with it, where it's proposed, that's what they're proposing is the likely one, and then the police station, it's likely that that will be an EIR as well. And the multi-use facility. Or not the police station. The multi-use facility. The multi-use facility. The police station had a previously certified negative declaration done for that site and for a much larger scale police station. Right.

42:10 Okay. All right. Well, thank you very much. I found both today and last month really helpful, and so I really appreciate your effort in putting this together. Well, now move on to our next agenda item, which is to discuss items for the Joint Town Council Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting scheduled for November the 18th.

42:45 And Sandra's going to lead us in this discussion. Thank you. So I have prepared a brief summary for this item, but the intent is to discuss, is to come to some sort of consensus on what you would like to discuss with the town council next week. Some suggestions that we had was to discuss the draft priorities prepared by the council, to

43:12 To provide input on how the commission, I guess the commission's opinions on those priorities. The town manager also suggested that we have a brief discussion on the design for the police station. Grady mentioned that in his presentation. And the town manager also suggested that we maybe just talk about the top kind of priorities of the community and economic development department's work program.

43:35 So I think we can maybe start and see if there's consensus to talk about the police station and our top priorities and then maybe move on to the town council tractors since they're so long. So I think we're all in agreement that we should talk about the police station. Oh, you know, I printed that. Oh, the packet. It's probably at the front desk. You have an attachment. You can find it. And I just have it printed out.

44:12 Okay. No, it's your attachment that you'll pick up on there. And I just happened to print it out because I wanted, I like both paper and digital. All right, so we're in consensus that we would like to talk about the, right? And then I think we're, are we in consensus about the community economic development discussing their work program? And then I had some comments about that. Okay, so one thing that,

44:46 At that meeting that I would really like to stress at this point the importance of finishing our CEQA work. I just think that's hugely, I mean, you know, there's so many important projects, but if we can get this finished in the next 60 days, you know, and then by the time we do our whole noticing project, you know, we're looking at June of 2016, and that's

45:16 Two years after our original date. And so I just think it's really important for personally that the new council understands that this has to be a priority to get it finished. I mean, to me, that's like our number one priority. And then, you know, there's some other things about here that I think actually ties into the work program. But I didn't know if anybody else had any other comments about the work program and going back to council on that. Did you have any comments?

45:48 Do you think it would be more appropriate to put this, to have that discussion when we discuss their priorities or our own?

46:36 Your department's work program. I think with the work program would be fine and that's an opportunity for me to just kind of summarize what we've done in the past on that and then it might pave the way for the discussion on the priorities. Okay. So I think, you know, look, we have new council people and new priorities and I think it...

47:00 I was discussing this with Sandra prior to the meeting. I think it's really important that Sandra prepares a summary both on the wayfinding and on our Main Street project about what the process was, the consultants, the number of meetings that went into it, and what the next steps are so that people really understand the efforts that have been put into these projects and that now they're just sitting there.

47:28 Ready to move forward. So, I mean, we have to be like the torch carriers for this that, you know, we don't want these, after all these years of working on these projects and the money that we spent to get to this point, it'd be really sad to see them shelved, so. Especially the wayfinding. The wayfinding needs a champion, whether it's us or somebody on town. Right, but the main, you know, the thing about the main street is, is there was a list of quick fixes for main street.

47:57 I mean, so there were things that we could do to the median, there were things we could do to the bus stops, you know, I mean, and that kind of ties into the way finding. So we're not talking about a $20 million project, but if we, it's just the entrance to our town and creating a better statement about it. So that was, those were the, and then, I mean, and then they do talk about in their priorities about parking in the EIFD and

48:28 You know, those were the other things that were personally on my list. But those are my big ones. I didn't know. Does everybody, do you agree or do we have other hot points that we really want to bring up? I agree with the EIFD, absolutely. Yeah. Okay. And did you? No, I think that's fine. I think that those are good points to talk to them about and there's a good crossover on those items. And then, of course, you know,

49:02 Then my, you know, secondary one personally then would be the North Village specific plan. So, I know I have a vision. There's nothing for us to report, but I think it's certainly something that the commission can express some. Well, my concern is, is if you get a major developer coming forward in the North Village, I mean, it really becomes, I mean, it doesn't, the current plan does not,

49:33 Right.

50:08 Pardon me. I'm just going to throw a wallet card out. Okay. You can do that if you want. I would love to see kind of where the filming board is. Media priority for anyone, staff or resident in town right now. No, I'll stay at the Westin. And they're actually approving 700 room nights. So imagine what that means. As somebody, I also sit on a Mono County Tourism and Film Commission. So I think it's low.

51:22 Yeah, so what we've done to try to improve the process for filming is we've lowered the fee. So I think it used to be like $400 and sometimes, you know, small budget production companies couldn't afford that. So now I think it's only $50. We have been working with Alicia at the county to try to make sure that we're processing these as quickly as we can. And I think that, in my opinion, our process has greatly improved from just two years ago.

51:49 We have, Nolan handles all the film permits. We know they're a priority. We get them done extremely quickly now, where it used to not take, it used to take a lot longer to get the film permits done. So we understand that. So we've reduced the price. We process them quickly. And we've been working kind of on and off with Alicia trying, our goal would be to have a, like a one-stop shop, at least the information. And we understand that you can't, you're not going to be able to get permits from Caltrans.

52:18 The Forest Service and everybody right away, but at least have a place where someone can go, you know, a website that has all the links, explains all that information, and it's quick and easy. Right. So, we have been working with Alicia to do that, and I think it's, she's kind of, I think, working to put that together. Yeah. Because she chairs the film commission, I think. She's the Mono County Film Commissioner. Right. Herself, yeah. Yeah. So, and she always works with us. Anytime there's someone who might want to come in, she, you know, we're always in contact with her on.

52:46 Those, you know, when there's new filming or people are looking at filming. So we try to be really customer service, you know, friendly. We understand that it brings a lot of TOT and it brings a lot of revenue to local businesses and that kind of thing too. So I think it's something we would want to discuss more with Alicia, but I don't know if maybe an ordinance is the answer. It may just be more streamlined permitting. Sure. You know, more, like you said, clarifying some of the permitting requirements, getting that one-stop shop.

53:15 And I think we've worked really well with the police, public works, we all kind of understand what the requirements are, when you need what, and before I think it was kind of disjointed. So I think we are working, but there are still steps that need to be taken. So we are working on that, even though we're not developing that ordinance. And maybe it's something that we do at some point, but I think if the process is fine, I don't know if we really need to have an ordinance that spells out the process. Right, and I think, like you said, Sandra, just having a one-stop shop for basic information.

53:45 And like I said, the feedback I get is not so much about difficulty pulling a permit with the federal agencies. Yeah. So if they have like a contact person, what's the standard turnaround time to get the things? Yeah. So I don't know about an ordinance, but general information. And I could follow up with Alicia on that. I'm not sure where she is with it or, you know, what's going on with that. But I'll follow up with that. Thank you so much. It depends where they're shooting. And they might have to pull like five different permits, like a permit from the town, permit from the Forest Service, permit from the state for Caltrans.

54:39 You know, I don't know if BLM has something separate, but, and then work with, if they're on the mountain, they have to work with Mammoth Mountain to get, you know, authorizations to do that. So there's a lot, because there's so many different agencies in this small area, there sometimes can be a lot of different permits, a lot of processes that someone has to go through. So I think that we, like I said, we've worked hard, and I know Alicia works really hard to help them with all of that, because I'm sure she's calling, because she calls us, so I think she's calling the forest, so she's calling these people to try to get these permits.

55:09 It's streamlined, so. But yeah, I'll follow up on it. I'll let the commission. So maybe what we should say underneath your work program rather than ordinance or at least in. Streamline process or something like that. Because I'm not sure we need another ordinance. Yeah. No, I don't think an ordinance is needed. Right. Thank you. Sorry, that's my walker. No, but it's legitimate. It's a good discussion. Thank you. And I know this is a big commercial.

55:35 They're setting up like a Nordic village down in Sunny Slopes, and they have these. Oh, really? They have a lumberjack camp. They have at least two trained wolves, too. I know. Yeah. It's pretty exciting. And I know that, you know, anything goes, and some of the other catering businesses are crazy busy with all the filming. Right. Yeah. So the rippling effect is pretty. So it's a lot of income that comes through this town. So not the oversimple, but the process. Would you want to pull your mic?

56:05 It's not something that, so let's say Nolan gets a permit to request, he can just send an email blast to all the independent agencies that are needed to be involved. No. There's no such a. Yeah, well, I think. There's no, each of those entities don't have a specific department that you can just send a quick email to.

56:31 I think that's kind of what Alicia does. Right. She calls. She's kind of the clearinghouse for the permit. But it's also, it's the person who is looking to pull the permit, they have a certain amount of responsibility to find out exactly what they need. And that's where Alicia comes in and kind of helps them on the path to the proper permits they need, depending on the piece of land. You know, if they're in a shoot on private land, they don't need necessarily a lot of permits, but if public, they need a lot.

57:00 All the agencies, Paul, don't necessarily talk. So that's the problem. So if the town's set on a blast, you know, different agencies may not respond to it that would need to respond to it. We coordinate like internally, like with the police department, we coordinate with the fire, kind of our local agencies, public works, you know, so a lot of times if it involves kind of driving on town roads or if they're going to shut down lanes, that's kind of our coordination. And then...

57:29 And then, yeah, like Alicia, she really, you know, kind of spearheads getting the people in touch with the right people at the other agencies. Thank you, Sandra. Okay, so then let's move to our third part, and then we have a copy here of what the Town Council has been working on, on their vision for 2025, which, you know, I do really like.

57:56 That is a vision. I think it's really appropriate because you can't accomplish all your things in a year or two years. You need something a little bit longer range, but you don't want it so long range that we get lost in the process. My first thought was that, oh, 2025, that's so far away. It's only 10 years.

58:19 What would be easiest? I mean, and this is a little bit difficult for Sandra because this is not her document. This is really council's document. So I thought what we should do is maybe put a list of questions together that we had about this document unless somebody had some preliminary questions that they just wanted to ask Sandra beforehand. I don't have any questions beforehand. Let me start. I'll start with some questions and then maybe I'll spur some thoughts. Yeah, I think that would be helpful.

58:53 So these are my questions about this document that we maybe can have council answer for us. And one is, you know, they have these vision elements, and I think they're really nice, but I was curious if these vision elements tie in, or are they ultimately meant to replace our Dr. Seds, our destination resort document, and some of the statements in the general plan. So are you familiar with the, we use this,

59:22 acronym DR. SEDS. It was a destination resort economic development document that we did, and it was done in 2010 and 2012. We spent a lot of work on really detailing about how we thought we needed to grow in the future. So when we say DR. SEDS, it's not like a shoe company or something like that. So that was one question I had.

59:49 And then when you go into the document on the left-hand side, they have these core community values, which I think are really nice. I was just curious. I don't think I've ever read them before. So I was curious if those were new core community values or if they'd come from a previous document. I think that they were, I mean, obviously they're very similar to, you know, some of the values that we have in our vision statement. But I think that they came from the group. Okay.

1:00:19 And they kind of talked about what are their core values, and I think that's where they came from. All right. And then on that page underneath a natural active place, underneath the town of Mammoth Lakes, there's this state, this is like on the short-term strategies, that says groundbreaking for new trail and first new community amenity. So do you happen to know what they were referring to on that?

1:00:48 I think it's just supposed to be high level so that we've broken ground on something on a trail and then a community meeting. I don't think they wanted to specify like police station or multi-use facility. I think they just wanted to say we've broken ground on something so we can check something off the list that way. All right. And then did you happen to have any feedback on the second one which was enhance and expand the transit services? Was that just another high level?

1:01:18 I think it is a high-level goal, but I'm not sure beyond what we're kind of currently doing what the intent is that this would be. Okay. Yeah. All right. So we can just, you know, so that they just get an idea about what some of our questions are. Yeah. Pardon me. And then on page four of the document, we're all in together. You know, we had started these synergy summits and, you know, with council and the county and

1:01:54 Then everybody's workload got a little intense. And so I was just curious if, you know, one of the questions would be for council, if they have some sort of regular schedule that we're all going to get together, I think it would be really a good thing. They were great summits when we did them. And then right below that, it says town-wide parking solutions in process. So I wasn't sure what that was about. Did you have any comments about that?

1:02:24 I think it's obviously solving the parking issues at the village, looking at parking across town. So I think they're just saying that we would be making progress on solving these parking issues, which was their priority last year as well. So I think it's similar to last year's priority. Okay. All right. And then, of course, my other two one was Main Street.

1:02:52 Was the page called, and maybe what we should just do is print that one page out. Wasn't it called Quick Fix? Is that what it was? Quick Wins. I have it here, actually. Quick Wins. Is that what it was? Yeah, Quick Wins. So it says Quick Wins refers to short-term actions that beget long-term change. They could begin immediately, can be completed within one to two years, and are estimated to cost around $910,000. Okay. But there's a bunch of different ones. There's establishing a maintenance district, establishing a parking district.

1:03:22 Kind of doing some preliminary work, conducting our surveying, utility verification, installing medians, traffic controls, pedestrian controls, and signage. And they're all broken out into different pieces, so you wouldn't have to always do, you could do, you know, maybe one or two, but you could do everything. So I think it would be really, if we came to the meeting with that, I think it would be really helpful to hand out. Yeah. I got a quick question to these priorities. Yes.

1:03:55 That's not in the orders of importance, is it? Well, we don't know. I mean, it's the council's document. And one thing is they're not finished with it either. And they have a meeting on the 17th. Right. And so you'll notice that like these enhanced, you know, like underneath strategies and priorities, these six things repeat underneath each one of these categories. So I don't, but that's a good question. I mean, we can ask them what are their priorities on this too, maybe. Yeah.

1:04:25 And they may have more information after the 17th, so that might help inform the discussion. No, do you have any other comments? Do we have any comments from the public on this? Did you take a number, Tom? Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountains here. Chairman Brown, I think you're right on the mark as far as the priorities. I mean, I read through that document as well, and the things that caught my attention were...

1:05:09 You know, focusing on finishing the FAR, CEQA approvals, and the Main Street plan was noticeably absent. As much as, you know, all the effort that's gone into it, I think it would be a good time to maybe just refresh their memory about all the steps that were taken and what the status of the document is and, yeah, exactly the quick wins. I looked at it, too, myself after I read their preliminary.

1:05:38 Draft, and I was like, wow, where did we leave the Main Street plan? And I went back and pulled it out, and same exact thing. I was like, gosh, you know, there's a short list of things we could do to make an immediate impact on the downtown corridor, which hopefully then would spur people's interest in carrying through with the rest of the plan. So I agree 100% with that, and Commissioner Vanderhurst's comment about the signage of wayfinding. I've been always waving the flag saying, hey, don't forget about the signage of wayfinding.

1:06:06 As much as it's done, again, vetted out at Council or Commission and Council previously, and it's on the shelf, ready to implement. You know, and I know there's been, you know, there's been comments from people saying, well, now you can just look on your phone and find out where you, you know, punch in your map app and figure out where to go. But I think, you know, a big part of the signs and wayfinding isn't just finding your way, but it's also just creating a continuity across the resort in terms of our character.

1:06:36 And our vernacular. And, you know, if you've been to resorts that have science done really well, it just makes you feel comfortable and you identify with, you know, the community itself. And so there's a lot of other benefits aside from just the wayfinding part of it. But, yeah, I think you're completely on the mark with all the things you mentioned. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, Tom. And then the only other comment I had that I thought about was that

1:07:08 They kind of use this weird phraseology about top destination. I mean, you know, we worked forever on our phraseology about what we were going to be. We probably should use some of the similar. I think we ended up in the Dr. Seds as a resort community, right? I think so, yeah. But we should just double check that and go back to that. Any other comments? No comment.

1:07:45 Okay. I'll tell you those hours, that hour always goes very fast with council. It is going to go, especially since we're talking about the police station and the other item. It's going to end quick. We'll have to be speaking quickly. Yes. All right. Then we'll close the business matters part of our meeting and we'll move on to consent agenda. Do we have a motion for the consent agenda? I would like to make a motion that we approve the minutes of the October 14, 2015 meeting.

1:08:15 Second that. I second that. Aye. Aye. Okay. We'll move on to Commissioner Reports. How's our design committee doing? So Commissioner Veruck and I had a meeting as part of the design committee last week on site about the police station. And we met with the architects and Sandra was there.

1:08:50 A few other people. We did a brief tour of the site and talked about the relationship with the courthouse and just talking about building materials and orientation and the actual physical relationship between the buildings. I think it's still preliminary stages for the project, but considering the small budget that they have, I think it could very well end up being a...

1:09:20 You know, a successful one and, you know, pleasing, pleasing, pleasing building, pleasing styles. I don't know, you want to talk about materials, building materials? Is it too early to talk about the look and feel of the building? That's what I was just. Yeah. They, I mean, they want, obviously, we want to, or they want to bring in, tie in the courthouse, but not as, I mean, it's not going to be quite as, I think, I guess the word would be.

1:09:50 Contemporary. Right. It has a little more of a woodsy element to it, but obviously not like lodgepole woodsy, but just a clean, it's a very clean look. More in keeping with the mountain resort style that we've come to like, but they talked about using similar materials, such as at least similar to the...

1:10:13 Some of the brick that's on the courthouse and some of the quartet and steel, just so that the two buildings can relate to each other, but instilling, keeping it a mountain rustic style. I'm assuming there's an SD on this, a schematic design? A what? A schematic design? Oh, well, they're very much in the schematic design process right now. You want to comment on the process that you were through with them? Yeah, so they were out here last week and they met with

1:10:46 Great, you said 17 different groups to talk about the project. So they were meeting with the courts, office of the courts, kind of all the different players. And so basically they were here last week, the architects, and they went from nothing to get basically a schematic design. So they're refining that and they're going to submit, they said probably next week for preliminary, for their design review application because that's the only entitlement they need is a design review.

1:11:15 Because the use is a permitted use. So they'll submit and then we will meet with the design committee formally to review the project in December and then come back to the commission in January for an approval. So the commission is really just looking at the design of the project and not the use, obviously. And then that's it. You're the final decision makers on the item. So when can we see the SD? The schematic, well, so Grady brought just a site plan and showed the site plan.

1:11:44 But the first time you see it, likely, unless we publish it on the website, I'm not sure if we're going to post a web page for it or not, but the first time you see it will likely be when it comes to you before, in January. Got it. Yeah. Does design have anything? After this meeting, we'll have a brief site visit over at Talus to meet regarding the potential further expansion of Talus. I'm sorry, potential what? Expansion of Talus. Expansion.

1:12:17 A garage, definitely a garage, a batteries unit, so there's building three potentially units, or build structures. How big is the garage, Dawn, do you know? In my head, what? The maintenance garage is, there's some numbers on here, but I can't see them. But it looks like it holds about four vehicles, and then there's a building. All right.

1:12:55 I'm sure you'll get back to us. I didn't bring my... I said we haven't had the meeting yet. Next. It will come formally until next year sometime. Okay. Okay. All right. Thank you. Anything else from design? No. Do either of you have anything else you'd like to report on? No, but I did notice that Grumpy's is moving... Well, it's not Grumpy's anymore, maybe, but they're starting on their elevator.

1:13:23 They're working on construction of the elevator. It came before us months ago. Mammoth Mountaineering is moving in there. Yes. It still says Grumpy's as of today. Right. But is that an elevator that's going in? Yes. And I didn't know, I'm not sure if Grump, the actual restaurant's closing, or if they're going to share that space, or if Mammoth Mountaineering is going to have a whole space, but I know Mammoth Mountaineering is going to be. They're going to move basically a new restaurant down to the lower floor. Oh. With the intent of opening.

1:13:51 As soon as it can, but probably not until the springtime, at least. And then Mammoth Mountaineering will be on the upper level. Will the current Mammoth Mountaineering spot be on vacated on three? Yes. I would assume so. I don't know. That was my understanding. That's all I have. Okay. Commissioner Cheng, did you have? Nothing for me. So, Commissioner, tell us about the whole world. Well, we finally, we got our...

1:14:28 Our TOT and TBID numbers for September. Yes. And if Mammoth Lakes felt busy, it was busy in September. So we were on TOT, we were up 19%. This is year over year. That's awesome. TOT came in at $730,000, which was, like I said, a 19% growth over last year. And TBID came in at $214,000, which is a 32%.

1:14:55 Congratulations. Just for the month of September? That was just the month of September. One of the priority items, I don't know if everybody saw in the town council document, was to create a 10-month economy in the town of Mammoth Lakes in September, October, are two of the 10 months that we'd ideally like to hit a million dollar TOT revenue goal. So what are our two vacation months? May's going to be a tough one. May's always a little bit of a tough one. June has got...

1:15:27 Tons of potential. Right. And then, you know, October, I think has got a lot of potential. November is going to be the one that's going to be very dependent on early snow. Right. We'll always be very dependent on early snow. But we're doing it this year. We're doing it this year. I don't know, maybe, Tom, I don't know if you've got the numbers off the top of your head, but I know the mountain booked an astronomical amount of room nights in a very short window of time once the mountain opened early.

1:15:54 All the snow fell, so I think Thanksgiving is going to be really lost. Yeah, I don't have specifics, but anecdotally I've been told today, in fact, that even advanced bookings for Christmas have gone up extraordinarily here in the last few days. So, yeah, I mean, it's the best start in...

1:16:12 Five years, and, you know, I made the comment, I think everybody can notice if you've been up on the hill, that, you know, with the snow conditions up there right now are better than they've been any time last year. Yeah. I mean, the fact that the mountain's completely covered in snow and two to three feet or even, you know, up on the top of the mountain, I think we're reporting five to six feet of snow. So, yeah, it's a fantastic start. It's open a week early. We've been doing...

1:16:36 Anywhere from 1,500 to 2,000 skiers a day. Yesterday, on Veterans Day, we did, I think, close to 3,000 skiers visits. So, fantastic start. You know, we've got another storm coming this weekend, so it keeps coming, and, yeah, couldn't be happier. 3,000 skier visits for a Wednesday, holiday Wednesday, is a really, really good number. Yeah, yeah. No, I mean, it's, as we say, it's all unbudgeted. I thought I heard it. So it's great.

1:17:05 On KFI, they had a live broadcast here. KTLA did. On opening day. KTLA. Yeah. That's great. On another note, really quick, Tom, if you wouldn't mind passing it back to your peers up on the fourth floor, I just had a chance to do a little bit of traveling to touch with some of our travel trade partners in the UK and Germany, and the one repeated message that...

1:17:34 What was given to me was the level of customer service, the level of customer service that their clients are receiving in Mammoth Lakes has been fantastic. And it's definitely was a memorable experience for a lot of people, whether summer or winter. So I know you guys have put a ton of effort and focus into that on the ski hill, and it's bearing fruit. So please pass that on to your colleagues. That's it. Well, congratulations.

1:18:06 For all your international travel and for making it back to the fair town of Mammoth Lakes. Yeah. There we are. Dawn and I had an opportunity to have coffee with some of the local people the other day. And there was just a couple of comments that I'd like to bring back to commission. And, you know, it's just so important, you know, because one of our missions is to really work with all the other groups in town.

1:18:38 John, these meetings where we don't have really big agendas, I think, you know, it might be nice to ask, like, the school district, the hospital, you know, these people, if they'd like to come forward and do a 20-minute presentation. Not that we have the biggest attendance at our meetings, but the really nice thing is they're televised, and it's a great way for those groups to share with a large audience about what's happening in their organizations.

1:19:06 So over the next couple of months, I just thought we might see who we could slot in in those different organizations. And then the other thing that I thought was mentioned, and I almost feel bad that I didn't think about it, but at all our meetings, we hear a lot about illegal nightly rentals and TOT enforcement.

1:19:31 And it's true, I'm asked this, you know, well, where are the legal nightly rentals? And I think the town could be, you know, this is one thing that the town could really do is just make sure that like on our business license website perhaps or something that it's really clear, well, these properties are legally nightly rentals. I mean, it'd be a great boost for them and they deserve it because they're legal, they've done everything that you've asked them to do and it's putting things in a proactive camp versus the...

1:20:03 Sandra can tell you in detail that she braved the elements this week, drove to Reno, and she passed the AICP exam, which is a certification for planners. Congratulations, Sandra. And she made it home. Yes, it was snowing up to Shea Lake, and then it was clear, easy going.

1:20:33 Tell us exactly what it stands for. American Institute of Certified Planners. So it's through the American Planning Association. So basically it's just you are tested on like 10 different subject matter that's related to planning, history, theory, law, working with different federal, you know, different agencies and, you know, just kind of a broad test on planning. Yeah, so I've been studying for two and a half months. So yeah, I was very, very excited.

1:21:05 The nerve-wracking part is you instantly get your results. Yeah. Wow. You can't even, like, go home and dwell on it at all. It was good because I passed. It would have been, yeah. Well, we're proud to have you as our leader, so. Thank you. Yeah. Congratulations, Amy. Sounds like you really earned it. Thanks. And then do you have a director's report? Just quickly, obviously, everyone will be here. I think all the commissioners will be here for the joint meeting next Wednesday at 5 o'clock.

1:21:33 And two updates on, I wanted to update you on the building official recruitment. So we're interviewing for the building official on Monday. So I think we have six applicants we're interviewing. So hopefully we can get through that process quickly and get somebody on board as soon as possible, depending on where they're coming from. And the senior planner position, we're finishing up some interviews this week and next week. So hopefully it'll be similar. We'll be able to make a decision soon and get somebody on board.

1:22:03 But depending on where they come, in both positions, depending on where they're coming from, if they're coming from out of town, it might not be until January, I would guess. But soon we will have two new staff members here, which will be definitely a relief for all of us. That's great. And that's all I have? Just for clarification, I think I did a reply saying on the 18th my attendance might be tentative. Yeah.

1:22:30 So we're not having the Old Mammoth Place item at 4 o'clock, and I sent everyone an email out, so it's only the 5 o'clock item, so. Okay. I will not be here on the 18th. Oh, okay. Okay. Aren't you done with that travel yet? So do we technically adjourn to the 18th, or are we technically adjourning to our meeting December? Okay. 9th. All right. Does anybody else have any other business issues, comments?

1:23:06 So then I move that we adjourn to our next regular scheduled planning and economic commission meeting, which is December the 9th at 2 p.m. in Sweet C. Thank you very much. Thank you, Pam.