TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 21 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

3 findings

Transcript

292 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:21 Good afternoon. I call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for December 9th, 2015. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Commissioner Varouk? Here. Vice Chair Grayhug? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? Commissioner Varouk, would you like to lead us? Sure. Let's begin. Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

3:21 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, we'll have public comments. Public comments is for anybody in the audience that would like to speak on any subject that is not on today's agenda. We'll close the public comment period, and then we'll move to our first presentation for the day. It's a broadband task force presentation by Nate Greenberg.

4:17 Thank you.

4:43 Really could be understood more fully by having the proper people at the table, local stakeholders, and sort of the role that the agencies play in really moving the conversation of broadband forward in our communities. So I'm going to just start by saying things that I think a lot of people around here already know, and I've sort of beat the drum on several times in the past, but the first is really that as agencies, we see communication networks as critical infrastructure.

5:11 I feel it's important to say this over and over again because the Planning Commission, as a town council, as a county agency, it's our responsibility to look at permitting, to look at encroachment, to look at what the different pathways for approval for infrastructure projects are, and at the end of the day, really put into place policy that's relevant to moving these things along efficiently and effectively because they do benefit us and they benefit the people that we serve.

5:41 For local agencies like the county and the town, we use broadband for telephony, for video conferencing, for just kind of day-to-day communications, e-government, government transparency and open access and various things like that. The Water District is using broadband for their SCADA systems for water monitoring, well monitoring, treatment system monitoring, things like that. And really the drought and the fire situation.

6:10 I realize I didn't unmute that. I think those topics as they're evolving in the state are very, very much tied to broadband as well. And we're seeing the impact of broadband in the public safety side through radio communications like radio over IP or cellular-based networks, other types of things that help keep our firefighters safe. And on the drought side, you know, there's some very interesting things that are coming out with respect to monitoring.

6:37 Whether it's watering on the ground within communities like Mammoth or Smart Ag or various different things like that. And so these networks really help open a lot of those opportunities up. The consumer use pattern really is growing and it's changing so rapidly. I mean, just the topics that I was talking about two years ago here and today, you know, they've just completely gone along the continuum in ways that many of us couldn't necessarily have seen.

7:08 I think the three major categories that we're seeing locally are in the schools. And I've announced previously that this last summer, all of the schools in Mono County as well as Eastern Sierra Unified and Mammoth Unified School Districts are now gigabit schools. So that's every campus from Edna Beeman and Benton to Mammoth High School and Mammoth Elementary here in Mammoth. And it's huge because

7:32 You know, a lot of these communities, especially the more remote communities in Mono County, don't have the population of students and don't have the same sort of access to hands-on education maybe as we do in Mammoth, but we're including those communities in the same expectation to compete or have the kids compete, you know, with kids from the metro cities throughout the U.S.

7:54 The Gigabit supports our one-to-one programs that are happening in the schools with iPads and tablets and computers and really opening up education opportunities for the kids at the campuses. The hospital, Mammoth Hospital, is the region's first gigabit hospital. Inyo is coming online here shortly. And within the hospital, that opens up a lot of opportunities around telemedicine, but it also really drives a lot of the technology use at home for home health monitoring,

8:24 Pacemakers and the connection between patients to their doctors or the ability for patients to be able to video conference with the doctor. The telemedicine sort of evolution is happening and it's something that is evolving very, very rapidly. And then I think we're all fairly aware of the benefits of broadband at home, whether it's for entertainment purposes or kids doing homework. You know, we're seeing a lot of smart homes come up, whether that's in more efficient heating and cooling.

8:53 Water consumption, water usage, security and monitoring, and then just the general kind of Internet of Things that's driving that. Broadband is very, very important there as well. One of the stakeholders that we brought into the task force was Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Tom Johnson, who is one of the senior marketing managers up there, is involved in this. And we were really interested as a town within the task force.

9:18 To look at how one of the biggest businesses really in town is leveraging broadband and what they see the direction of things going in the company relative to broadband utilization. So there's a few key areas that they are seeing broadband be important. One is in the B2B channel. And I'm assuming by now all of you guys have heard about what the B2B sort of direction or ideas that the ski area has. But what they're really looking to do is to

9:45 Draw upon the business communities in LA and the rest of California as well as just the nation as a whole and to bring those people to Mammoth to provide unique visitor experiences so they can come and recreate, they can ski on the hill, they can go to Tamarack, they can go to any one or the other.

10:04 Mountain properties as well as enjoy the town as a whole, but also had the ability to perform business or to be engaged in some sort of a leadership retreat or various different things that can be offered and experiences can be tailored to meet individual business needs that are coming up. Well, in order to do that, obviously, we need to be able to provide capacity, broadband capacity for them to be able to work remotely, to stay connected, to have very similar types of experiences here as they would at home when they're in.

10:33 Sort of a commercial or business sense. The other big one is the guest experience. And this is something that they're admittedly a little bit behind on. But what they are hearing from their guests is the expectation is to have access everywhere, both in town and on the mountain, and have it be sort of commensurate with what they're used to seeing at home. So they want to be able to come to Mammoth and...

10:58 You know, theoretically unplug and recreate and have a little more of a wilderness experience, but kind of only to an extent. You know, they still want to have access to email. They still want to have access to Netflix. They still want their kids or, you know, their wives who are maybe CEOs or CFOs to be able to get access to work remotely. And so that kind of rolls out to the public Wi-Fi experience on the mountain, whether it's in a lodge or actually on the slopes, as well as just how they get information out.

11:27 From them that I think is really interesting is they're trying to move away from printed collateral and paper material for some of their big events. So the motocross event in Gran Fondo are two really good examples where they went to an app for those events. So instead of producing thousands of pieces of actual printed material, they're delivering everything through their app. And if you're hearing what they're saying through events like early ups and just the general consumer experience up there, they're really driving the Mammoth app.

11:57 Both the economy and ecology kind of components of that. And really, it gives them the ability to use the technology effectively and to engage people through it. And it ties back into operations as well. And I know Tom's here, and I probably shouldn't just totally speak for you. But, you know, leveraging broadband for the resort connectivity has been a big piece. And talking to my counterpart at the ski area, especially with the purchase of Bear,

12:25 You know, their central point of sale system is here in Mammoth, although they're providing or they're using that to all across all of their different resorts, whether it's Bear or June, they're all coming back home to Mammoth in terms of being able to handle that customer experience. So the broadband connectivity between the resorts is incredibly important, but it's also...

12:48 Expensive to host some of that stuff locally. And so through having higher capacity broadband and better access, they're looking at things like moving to the cloud, like Amazon Web Services, for example, and getting some of that stuff off premise so that they can provide better experience to all of the mountain employees that are at those locations doing business. Part of the reason that we wanted to bring Skiri into the conversation was that we really believe that

13:15 The support of our visitor base is really key in that broadband does support the tourism-based economy that's here. Just as the ski area indicated that the user or the visitor is expecting a certain amount of access, you know, we strongly believe that and we're hearing from people coming to visit us, whether it's for a weekend or whether it's for a Christmas holiday, the frustrations in the past around access to high-quality broadband has been

13:44 One of the major detriments. It's been a frustration of a lot of people and in some cases it's been one of the things that's driven people to other resorts as a result of not having the same type of access as they have at home. And today, as I'll announce in a minute, we're really excited to see that really change. Digital 395 really opened up.

14:07 A tremendous amount of opportunity for us. And, you know, with everything that's happening in LA and the Silicon Beach sort of boom that's going on down there, as well as all the stuff that's happening in Reno with Tesla. I don't know if you guys have heard about the Switch Data Center that's being built up there, but a super multi-billion dollar data center that's being built in Reno and the whole tech park that's happening up there. You know, Mammoth is really at the core of both of those.

14:35 Locations, both geographically as well as kind of spiritually, I think in terms of what the recreation opportunities from Tahoe and LA sort of looking at, they're looking for sort of a less populated, more unique experience and Mammoth really is the epicenter of that or the Sierra as a whole is the epicenter of that.

14:54 So by providing more of a continuous and a connected user experience for folks coming down from the Reno and Tahoe area or up from LA, we're able to draw them in to help them realize that this is a place that they can come and recreate, they can stay connected, and potentially turn them into year-round residents or at the very least keep them here longer as opposed to just here for a few days. So the Broadband Task Force

15:22 Right now consists of John Wentworth, who's a council member, supervisor Stacy Corliss, Tom Johnson, who I mentioned earlier, Dan Holler, and Pam Kobylarz from the town administrator's office, and myself. And we really got together with kind of three main purposes or goals initially. And first was to really identify and understand the barriers around access within Mammoth and maybe the immediate area outside of Mammoth.

15:48 We look at access as where is the infrastructure and what are some of the gaps in terms of the infrastructure that are keeping people from physically getting a connection or getting access to high capacity broadband. And ultimately that's kind of focused at the livability piece. So how do we improve the livability for locals here or the businesses that are here year-round? Then it's how do we more effectively communicate the value of broadband?

16:16 And this is really looking more at the adoption level. So once you have broadband, how do you use it? How do you take the most advantage of it? How do you know how much you should have? If you're running a hotel and you have 100 rooms, what kind of experience do you want to provide for visitors? And how much bandwidth do you actually purchase in order to do that? Or are you running a coffee shop and people are coming in there to work for the day or they're just coming in there to grab a cup of coffee and a muffin in the morning before heading out?

16:45 How much broadband bandwidth do you need in order to provide a good experience? How do we be leaders in that? I mean, given the fact that we have unlimited capacity, true unlimited broadband capacity throughout the region, you know, what is enough? What is something that's going to indicate that we understand that as a community, as a region, businesses within that? So how do we, as a town, as a task force, sort of have those communications effectively?

17:13 With sort of the end user. And then ultimately to develop these scalable stakeholder driven solutions. So, you know, we recognize that there are differences in Mammoth than in other parts of the county or potentially other counties within the region. But a lot of the ideas, philosophies, issues, opportunities are very, they're very much the same. They're scalable across sort of all of our communities.

17:41 And there's no reason that we shouldn't be looking at ways to establish short, mid, long-term objectives that leverage economies of scale and look for sort of commonalities so that we can develop programs that, you know, really attract people here, help build an economic base and really are leadership sort of oriented in terms of using broadband. So in terms of what we have, you know, I've heard or you guys have all heard me talk about

18:11 Digital 395 and what it means. You know, I've heard from a lot of people within the community as well as outside of the town of Mammoth that, you know, they still don't really get what Digital 395 is or what it's doing for them. And, you know, that's something that we need to work on in terms of an engagement or communication sort of method. But really what it comes down to in town is there's three main providers. Suddenly, who operates a fiber-rich coaxial cable network.

18:40 Inyo Networks, which resells fiber-to-the-premise directly connected to Digital 385, and Verizon, which is a DSL, copper-based provider. Both Inyo Networks and Suddenlink are directly connected to the Digital 385 network. They can provide capacity that's theoretically limitless. Inyo Networks, 10 gig circuits and up, no problem.

19:07 Part of the development that's happening up in Reno with the Switch Data Center is tied to Inyo Networks directly through the Digital 395 Network. One of the requirements that was placed on the network on Digital 395 and Inyo Networks was seven millisecond connectivity between Reno and Las Vegas, which prior to Digital 395 being in the ground would have never been possible. And that's basically all being fed by the Digital 395 Network.

19:37 As well as a little leg off of the Level 3 network out of Barstow. So that's great for the commercial space. It really means that there is unlimited potential in terms of whether we wanted a data center here or whether you wanted a small, you know, a coffee shop or you wanted something that was in the middle like a call center or something like that. But what's really exciting is what is happening on the residential level.

20:06 Actually, as of today, is offering gigabit service to every customer in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And this is something that we've really been pushing, and we've been working very closely with Suddenlink on for the last 18 months or so. And we sort of saw that it was evolving and happening, and then they kind of got to the point where enough of the pieces were in place that they felt...

20:32 compelled to just get it done and really to try to get it done before Christmas this year. So as of today, actually, they will be opening up service codes for people to purchase gigabit circuits. And with that, not only will they be offering gigabit service, but they've previously had three different tiers of service. They had a 50 meg, a 75 meg, a 100 meg, and I guess, sorry, they had four and 150 meg.

21:01 They're going to be taking everybody in the 75 meg and moving them to 100, and everybody in the 100 and 150 and moving them to 200. So their new service offerings will be 50, 100, 200, and a gig. The gig plan will be $109 a month, which is an incredible deal, really, for the value that is coming with that. So that's really, really exciting. That's what this poster is actually about. Again, it just launched today. Can our camera see that, Pam?

21:30 Okay. And so, you know, one of the things that the task force is looking at now is how do we educate on what's possible with that? You know, what can people do with that? How do we effectively inform them about what it means and sort of what some of the potential hurdles are? You know, one of the things that we've been talking with with Suddenlink is just because you're connected to the house with a gig.

21:56 A lot of people have equipment that's three, four, five years old. You might have an old laptop. You might have an old wireless router that could be a bottleneck between those things. The technology is moving so fast that really for people to take full advantage of these things, we need to be able to educate them in terms of how to sort of keep pace with that. And in some cases, that means replacing hardware or really understanding what the use cases are to be able to make good decisions around that.

22:25 We are working within the task force on some different strategies to help residents and businesses make those decisions. You know, effective utilization, how to purchase, how much to purchase, and then really trying to help them realize the value and what they can really do with it. I want to talk for just a moment about the Eastern Sierra Connect Regional Broadband Consortium. I've mentioned this before.

22:49 And this is a group that's funded out of the California Public Utilities Commission, a ratepayer fund called the California Advanced Services Fund. And we're wrapping up our fourth year of operation. We were basically funded for four years. And the operations and the fiscal year ends at the end of February. The consortium has been really successful in moving a few key initiatives and success areas forward. One has been just the infrastructure project or the program sort of as a whole.

23:17 The consortia has advocated or worked very closely with providers like Race Communications. If you guys are not aware, Race Communications built a gigabit network in Chalfant, Fiber to the Premise, went live about a month ago. They're bringing on customers. They're offering 100 megs to the home for $49 a month or a gigabit for $100 a month, symmetric gigabit up and down. Crowley Lake will be coming on next.

23:45 Hopefully after the first of the year, followed by Sunny Slopes and Tom's Place. There's a resolution in the works right now for more or less the entire rest of the southern part of Mono County, Benton, the rest of Chalfont, Sunny Slopes, Tom's Place will be picked up from the last one. So we have Swall Meadows and Paradise, which are in this grant, Lee Vining and Mono City. And with all of that being done,

24:14 About 80% of our residential base in Mono County will have gigabit service. And that's pretty compelling. It's pretty revolutionary. There's not many rural counties like Mono that have service like that. And certainly we're one of the first. I'm not sure if we're the first resort community in the West, but we're definitely number two if we're not number one in getting gigabit service. And we're certainly the first in California.

24:42 So that's really exciting. The consortium has also been really focused on sort of that utilization piece. So we did a program a couple of years ago where we took six local businesses in eastern Kern, Inyo and Mono counties, offered them $1,000 to develop a very small, simple brochure-style website and followed the success or the impact that that had on that business over a two-year period.

25:09 The smallest incremental increase in revenue that any one of those businesses realized through the website was 15%. We had one business that actually had to relocate into a space that was twice their size. They had a clothing business in Tachapi because the amount of draw that was coming from or basically the amount of interest that was coming to their business based on.

25:32 The presence that their website had was that significant. So we're really excited about that because we think we can take it to the greater community and really help educate businesses on how to better use the internet to improve their revenue base. The reason I bring the consortia up is that while the town and the county have been very much engaged in the conversations with the consortia, our priorities have not necessarily always been in alignment. And as we're going into

26:01 The closeout of year four and looking forward to reapplying for revenue or reapplying for money from the CPUC for ongoing consortia operations, you know, we're really trying to look at can we more closely align the consortia and sort of the goals of the town and the county with the goals of the consortia to move some of these conversations forward more efficiently.

26:26 So goals and objectives for the task force really are around these access and adoption kind of categories. So on the access side, really it's developing a proactive approach to infrastructure development. And part of this piece is really understanding where the gaps are and what the needs are that are associated with those specific geographies. So, I mean, this can be as specific as saying how do we get gigabit service to Tamarack Lodge, for example.

26:56 In order to do that, you know, there's probably two or three different ways that we can get up there. So as we start to, say, look at building fiber along Old Mammoth Road to get to Tamrac, what are the different businesses, what are the different residents that we pass, and how do we begin to have conversations with all of those about aggregated need and splitting the cost for extension of fiber or critical infrastructure into some of these other locations? Same thing with going out to, say, the water treatment plant out by Snow Creek.

27:24 You know, we've got to get from the police station effectively around Old Mammoth Road out past Snow Creek. As we do that, you know, there's an aggregated opportunity there, and we really want to sit down and have a long horizon sort of look at where some of these large gaps are and how do we have meaningful conversation with the players, the stakeholders along those routes to try to get them built. On the adoption side, really,

27:52 It's my interest to change the conversation from it's not working to we have it and this is how we're using it. And I think with the launch, with Suddenlink's launch, that's going to begin to move the needle a little bit on that conversation. And I think that as an agency, it really comes down to being a leader and to leveraging what we have and to being innovative in terms of how we're using it.

28:19 Just today I was actually talking with Council Member Wentworth and Suddenlink about putting a gig, gigabit public Wi-Fi in Suite Z. And I think it's something we're going to look at doing in the next few months, for example. Again, how do we harness sort of the Reno and the Silicon Beach effect? How do we provide that no-gap experience? How do we educate people that are coming here about what is really here? And, you know, really some of that is a branding piece.

28:48 Letting them know that the capacity is here. It's available. These are the ways you can gain access to it. These are the locations that have it currently. If you're looking for something, who do you go to? How do you begin those conversations? And really, as I've said repeatedly, I think some of that comes back to us as a town and a council and a commission of really being innovative, demonstrating leadership, and trying to embrace change and be disruptive.

29:16 So in terms of getting there, I've touched on a lot of these points. One of the specific ways for that targeted communication is something that the county, the town with the consortia are developing that's called the broadband access tool. It's going to be a web-based tool which allows people to come in to a mobile-first application and basically say, I just moved to Lone Pine.

29:42 And I'd like to know who the service providers here and what kind of service they offer. Or I'm looking to relocate a business and I need a gigabit and I want to know which communities I can get that in and where there are some opportunities or locations that already have that versus maybe even some open real estate where it could be easily built to. So we're hoping to have this online first quarter next year as sort of the goal.

30:10 And it's going to be one of those things that we're going to be continuing to build onto and to add information to and to more closely integrate with some of the other products that we have, like the Parcel Viewer and some other information lookup tools. In IT, we try to have a very broad view of how communications are used, and we're in the midst of a big radio system.

30:38 inventory, a big public service as well as just administrative radio network, whether it's Mammoth PD or Mammoth Fire or Monon County Sheriff, it's a very antiquated radio network and we're looking at how we can use broadband, digital 395 specifically, to really improve the level of communications or quality of that network as a whole.

31:03 And really do so strategically in a way that we can think about not just that system but what some of the other benefits or implications are of using that system for emergency response and also potentially some consumer-based systems or services that could come out of those like cell sites, things like that. So I really feel and we're starting to sort of work toward a rough outline of a communication strategic plan that would be countywide. It's something I'm hoping to sort of get to a decent position.

31:33 This next summer. And that will look at kind of the gamut of communications. And then as an agency, really, it's continuing to look at how we can adopt broadband, what we can do with it now that we have it. It's everything from, you know, a new phone system, voice over IP phone system, to more effectively using video conferencing, for example. We're already using Granicus for public engagement, but really opening up that government transparency piece, leveraging applications.

32:03 You know, really pushing the mobility piece. So really just being leaders and showing the community as a whole, the region, more broadly, that we get it as an agency. So some action items. This was really brought to the council last week. Some of these do relate to the commission as well. But one of the things that we're kind of missing in the policy space is this dig once policy. And, you know, the reason that this is important is, you know, we've seen a number of different infrastructure projects, road rehab projects or similar types of things happen.

32:33 Throughout the county or the town, for example, with the Rule 20B project that's going on up on Main Street, where we're cutting into roads or we're doing some kind of road rehab or improvement, but we're not really looking at how the impact of that could be lessened in the future for people wanting to come in and put conduit in the ground, for example. So Dig Once policy sort of sets the stage for saying any time a road's opened up, we will reach out to all potential interested parties.

33:03 And say, do you have a desire to put conduit in this road? If not, we go back to look at available funds within the town to say, is this a critical gap, say, based on that aggregated needs study that we were talking about earlier? And if so, let's put some town-owned conduit in the road. So we don't have to cut into the road in the future. We don't have to use the excuse that, well, it's too expensive to get fiber in the road because we didn't think of it.

33:32 You know, five years ago, and, you know, sort of remove those barriers for some of the infrastructure extension. You know, I mentioned the alignment of the town with the consortia, and that's something that's actually moving relatively quickly. We need to reapply for consortia funding and operations by the end of January, so the task force is engaged in conversations about where common interests lie between the county, the town, as well as the City of Bishop and Inyo County. And then,

34:02 The franchise fee or just the revenue analysis piece relates to the first, to the Dig Once policy, but also just from the standpoint of really, especially as Suddenlink turns up service and we are likely to see an increase in revenue from these franchise fees, how do we effectively use that money? Can we put it into a fund?

34:22 That's held back that could be used for infrastructure extension or matching funds or reinvestment in technology. Obviously, we're using it in the council chambers, you know, the mics, the room setup is being funded partially by that. So how do we continue to use that money to sort of effectively move ourselves forward? Lastly, really communicating consistently around what we have, the opportunities that come with it.

34:49 And really who the players in the broadband game are in town I think is really, really important. And Suddenlink's announcement of Gigabit in Mammoth is huge. We're the first community that's served by Suddenlink in their entire operation space throughout this nation that's Gigabit. We beat Truckee by I think about nine months. Bishop's going to be 2017. June Lake should be about three months.

35:19 So it's happening here, and I think we need to all understand what that means and what opportunities kind of come with that. So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions and appreciate the time. For the benefit of our two newer commissions that weren't here in May when we did our joint workshop on the subject.

35:41 So Suddenlink has a franchise agreement, but the town of Mammoth Lakes does not manage that franchise agreement. It's managed by the California Public Utility Commission. And so for Suddenlink to have this vote of confidence in the town of Mammoth Lakes is really greatly due to the efforts of the stakeholders and to what they really believe that they can accomplish. So it's, I mean, this...

36:05 In May, if you told me you'd be standing here in December, I would not have ever thought that it would have happened. So really, my hat's off to everybody. It's wonderful. It's great news. So with that, let me open up Commissioner and Farouk. Do you have any questions? I don't, no. Thank you, though, Nate. Do you have any questions? I'm just curious.

36:29 Gotten any indication that Verizon's going to do the work to increase their capacity as well, or is Sunlink and Inyo Network's going to be kind of it for the future? Well, so you're probably aware of Verizon, well, Verizon's being sold to Frontier Communications. I'm not sure if people are aware of that. So all of Verizon California, Texas, and Florida are being sold to Frontier Communications.

36:59 What that means for us is Frontier has some holdings in the northern part of Mono County and they're relatively small sized telco. This is a huge acquisition for them. There's a lot of questions that kind of come out of that and I've briefed the council about this in the past and happy to come back and talk to you more about it. What it means long term kind of remains to be seen. The one thing that we have seen with Frontier

37:27 Is that they have been engaged in the broadband conversation fairly recently. Whereas Verizon's somewhat shied away from the conversation. Frontier extended DSL service in Colville, Walker, and Topaz about a year ago using Digital 395. So they see the value. They, I think, also see the transition that's happening from traditional copper-based landlines to people going to cell phones or using voice over IP.

37:57 through broadband networks. And so they do recognize that. I think they're also faced with the reality of this aging copper infrastructure and the cost of both upkeep or replacement of that being fairly significant. So in a nutshell, I think it remains to be seen how this all plays out. But I'm cautiously optimistic that they will sort of come to the conversation.

38:22 More openly and look for how to solve solutions in some of these more remote communities. Great. Thank you. You need to turn your mic on. Sorry. With Inyo Broadband? Inyo Networks? Networks. I'm pretty sure they're a related entity of Digital 395, right? Correct. Are they the only entity that is laying fiber here in town? Or is Sunlink upgrading their?

38:55 So Sunlink's network is what's called a fiber-rich, or, you know, you sometimes hear it as fiber-deep. So essentially their model is fiber to a node or a translator from which they break out coax and distribute to, you know, between 50 and a couple hundred homes or endpoints. So one of the things...

39:23 It's important for us to say that, you know, two years ago, they were offering 1.5 megs, you know, and then shortly after Digital 395 broke, 15, shortly after that, 30, then all the 30 went to 50, and now this. I mean, this has all happened really within 18 months. So as that transition happened, you know, they were realizing a lot of vulnerability in their network and some specific bottleneck areas, and some of that was replaced with fiber.

39:52 A lot of the nodes that were congested were broken out to deal with places where you had, say, a lot of condos or maybe a lot of units in just a few different condo developments. So they will continue to be a fiber-fed coax network, but they do have, on the commercial side, fiber to a lot of businesses. So there are suddenly customers in malls and also just...

40:18 Individual sort of standalone commercial buildings that do have fiber to them. And I should say outside of that, so yes, Inyo Networks will build fiber to the premise. They only build fiber, incidentally. But Race Communications is a fiber to the premise company as well. So they are building fiber directly off the digital 395 network in the same manner that Inyo Networks is. Can you comment on Sudlink's service over Thanksgiving when we...

40:50 With our first big crowd since they've upgraded their equipment? So I can, obviously, not being in the company to only a limited extent, but I have asked these questions and, you know, definitely hammered on them because I know that people are asking you and asking me. So we first heard that Suddenlink was making the gig move well before Thanksgiving. It was late summer.

41:19 Some of the things that we all felt and some of the feedback that suddenly got through that, they went and upgraded their network again after having upgraded it prior to that Christmas and spent a lot of time tuning it and really looking at saturation and flow and things like that. And so they were basically poised to take the town to a gig prior to Thanksgiving but wanted to watch. And over Thanksgiving, they got one trouble call.

41:49 They have tried to look at all of the network utilization graphs and have seen zero saturation problems throughout the entire network. Now, it doesn't mean that there aren't people that might be experiencing a little bit of issue at home and speaking on behalf of them, you know, they want to say if anybody is having problems, they want them to call immediately because, as I said, with just the realization of putting more capacity through the network,

42:17 You're dealing with aging infrastructure in some places. In some cases, you've got old modems, Suddenlink-owned modems even, or maybe a computer. And the problem could be someplace in the middle, but it's not the network core itself. So they're really interested in solving those customer problems because they want this to go really well. They want that reputation to be unmarred.

42:43 Thanksgiving went really, really well for them, and they're really hopeful with launching the gig that Christmas is going to go just as well or better. That's good news. So when we met back in May at our joint workshop, when we were talking about barriers, we really talked about two barriers at that time, what, quote, our local provider, and then the cost to connect. So do you feel that we've really now eliminated both of those barriers?

43:10 I think so. I think so. So the $109 residential offering is, you know, on par, as good or better than many metro cities in the West for a gig. I believe the commercial cost for a gig is only a few hundred dollars, which is also incredibly, incredibly low. So at least through their service, yes, I think that those barriers are gone. Now, it doesn't mean that

43:40 It's going to solve everyone's problems. You know, each case is a little bit different. And, you know, for example, we talk about the water treatment plant out on Old Mammoth Road. You know, they may or may not be able to use Suddenlink's infrastructure as effectively as, say, digital 385 infrastructure. So there may still be some barriers there depending on the use case or the situation. But in general, yeah, I think that they're solved.

44:07 And we also talked about the Inyo Obsidian project. Are they still moving ahead with that? They are. There is a grant application into the CPUC. I believe it covers Alantia, Keeler, and Darwin. And that would be the first three communities that would get built, essentially fiber to the premise, gigabit service, and it would be working within that sort of construct of the Obsidian project.

44:34 So can you just give a little background to the two new commissioners? Sure. So essentially the way Inyo County is approaching the last mile. So digital 395 is what's called a middle mile network. You can think of it as the highway corridor 395 itself, 203 into town. But how do you get from that highway to the home? That's sort of the last mile piece. And we in all of our communities that have broadband for the most part have

45:03 Aging infrastructure or, you know, just missing providers that are able to provide that last mile of connectivity. So the Obsidian Project is Inyo County-driven effort that's really looking at leveraging public money either through USDA, like RUS funds or the California Demand Services Fund from the CPUC to have a municipally owned and operated network.

45:29 That is very, very similar to how Digital 395 runs. So instead of a provider like Suddenlink who owns that network and is the service provider, the county would own the network and would lease the infrastructure to a service provider like Suddenlink or Inyo Networks or anyone else who wants to be on that to provide those last mile services. So it's kind of a really interesting and actually very exciting approach to things.

45:58 In Mono County, we're lucky enough that, you know, we've had two very engaged providers, both Suddenlink and Race Communications. So we've really just been partnering with them to help them move along their projects to solve the problem sort of, you know, in just a different way. So besides ultimately working on a Dig Once policy ordinance, what else can we as a commission do to support you and your project?

46:26 Well, I think one of the things that we all need to be able to do, and I think some of this falls back on myself and the task force, is to really have a clear understanding of what it is that we have and what some of those barriers to adoption are, what some of the potential hurdles once people have adopted are. And, you know, I do think that without really getting into the weeds on this,

46:54 It's important that we as a community sort of be able to communicate consistently about what the opportunities are so that we don't sort of end up in this scenario like we did when Digital 3 and 5 first launched where, well, it's there but it doesn't really work. So I think, you know, it's an important thing for all the commissioners, all the council members, staff to really to know what we have and know how to gain access to it.

47:23 You know, to the extent that's practical, understand the differences in some of the technologies. And that's where, you know, I think some of the tools like this broadband access tool or some one sheet kind of pieces of collateral that help convey some of that information are going to be important in that. But then continuing to just promote the town really leveraging broadband and really looking for creative solutions through technology.

47:49 It's going to be important because I think we want to show that we have vision and there's leadership and that we understand what we have and that we're able to use it effectively. All right. One last chance. Anybody have any questions? I don't. So I just have one practical comment for my fellow commissioners that what I have found in some dealings is that there's been some frustrations on the local level, and if you just tell those people to go to the local office versus calling their...

48:20 National call number. Everybody's always happy with the local office. I think sometimes the near national call center isn't quite caught up. So that's just a little practical piece. And once again, I'm absolutely ecstatic. I think this is just terrific news. And congratulations to everybody on this force. You did a great job. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay. At this point, we'll move on to our public hearing.

48:51 This public hearing, consider approval of the Mammoth Hillside Project Amendment, amendments to the tentative tract map 36-20, 36-235, use permit, 2005-09, use permit, 2007-11, and use permit, 2007-14, and associated time extension request, 15-003.

49:16 It's located at the northwest corner of Canyon Boulevard and Lake Mary Road, including finding the project consistent with a subsequent project environmental impact report for the North Village specific plan. And at this time, our public hearing procedure is that we'll have a statement and presentation by the staff. We'll have a statement and presentation by the property owner or the representative.

49:44 We'll have questions from the Planning Commission. We'll call for testimonies for those wishing to speak from the public. We'll have any rebuttal. We'll close the public hearing. The Commission will then deliberate on the matter. So with that, we'll turn the meeting over to the staff, and you can do your presentation. Thank you. The proposed project consists of amendments to the conditions of the approved Mammoth Hillside project as well as the time extension request.

50:12 The Mammoth Hillside project, which consists of the tentative tract map and use permit, was originally approved in 2006. Two subsequent use permits for parking and an in-lieu fee for affordable housing were approved in 2007 and 2008. So there are a total of four projects and three approving resolutions that make up the existing entitlements for the Hillside project. The purpose of this proposal in front of you today is to amend and combine the resolutions that make up the existing entitlements on record.

50:41 To more closely reflect current market conditions and changes to the standard conditions typically required by the town. The other component of this proposal is the time extension request, which would extend the current expiration of January 12, 2016 to January 12, 2021.

50:59 Tentative tract maps typically expire after 24 months. However, due to extensions filed by the applicant, as well as extensions mandated by the state due to challenging economic conditions, the project's expiration has been extended to January 12, 2016. This request is for one additional extension of up to five years, which would extend the expiration until 2021. If it's approved, no additional time extension requests may be granted.

51:25 Proposed amendments and the time extension request were discussed with the commission at the workshop on September 9th, and feedback from that meeting has been incorporated into this project. In staff's review of the proposed amendments to the resolutions, we focused on four primary issue areas. The first was a condition to require a four- or five-star hotel. The applicant has noted that they no longer have a preference for a four- or five-star hotel, and it was never a requirement of the town, so that condition has been removed.

51:54 The second issue area we reviewed were the conditions related to the requirement for a pedestrian bridge over Canyon Boulevard that would connect the project site to the gondola in the village. After significant research, we determined that the pedestrian bridge was not required by the town or by the North Village Specific Plan, and we removed the conditions related to the bridge as well. The third area reviewed by staff was Resolution 2007-22, which referenced a private parking agreement with the owners of the 8050 Residence Club.

52:23 The condition was amended in the resolution you have in front of you to clarify that the town acknowledges that the private parking agreement exists and that the 50 parking spaces required by that agreement may be accommodated in the hillside parking garage. It is standard practice for the town to not enforce private agreements. However, based on discussions that we had today between the applicant and Mammoth Mountain ski area,

52:46 We suggest a revision to Condition 2B related to this parking agreement of the resolution as follows. Unless an alternative arrangement, acceptable to the town and approved by the Community and Economic Development Director, is agreed upon by the applicant and another party within 60 days, then in accordance with the private agreement with the 80-50 Residence Club, an additional 50 parking spaces may be accommodated in the parking garage. So essentially it gives the applicant, as well as Mammoth Mountain Skaria,

53:16 An additional 60 days to agree upon another condition that would also be agreed upon by the town to find a solution to those 50 parking spaces. Can you read that again, please? Thank you. The revised condition? Yes, please. So the revision that we're proposing is, unless an alternative arrangement acceptable to the town and approved by the Community and Economic Development Director is agreed upon by the applicant and another party within 60 days,

53:43 Then in accordance with the private agreement with the 8050 Residence Club, an additional 50 parking spaces may be accommodated in the parking garage. So we added a clause in front of the condition that is included in 2B right now to allow the applicant as well as Mammoth Mountain Ski Area another opportunity to address those 50 parking spaces in a way that would be acceptable to the town.

54:11 So is the town now becoming part of that agreement or is it still a private agreement? No, we've discussed this with our attorney and we're not willing to include the town as an enforcer of that private agreement. Okay. But if the applicant in Mammoth Mountain and Skiria can come up with some other acceptable language that references it in some way, again, without including the town as part of the agreement, we would approve that and revise it.

54:41 All right. Okay. Thank you. Steph also amended several references throughout the three resolutions to fees. We revised the related conditions to require the applicant to pay the fees in place at the time of building permit submittal or issuance as applicable. This is in accordance with conditions applied to current development projects. And it's worth noting, however, that the payment of the affordable housing mitigation fees will result in the loss of the 35% state density bonus that was a part of the original project.

55:10 In addition, the Engineering Division revised Condition 23 of the original resolution to require participation in the creation of a pedestrian area of interest or transit shelter located at the northeasterly portion of the property along Canyon Boulevard. On the basis of the analysis presented in the staff report and resolution, staff has made the determination that the project meets the findings as required to approve the project. Those findings are as follows. The proposed project is consistent with the vision

55:39 Goals and policies of the general plan, the project conforms to the municipal code, the project is consistent with the North Village specific plan, and the project is consistent with CEQA. Staff recommends that the commission move forward with option one as described in the staff report, and adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, and approve tentative tract map 36-235A, use permit 2005-09A,

56:08 Use permit 2007-11A, use permit 2007-14A, and time extension request 15-003 with modified condition 2B as described previously in my presentation. So that concludes my staff report and Dave Harvey, the applicant, as well as representatives from Cerberus are here to answer any additional questions. Mr. Harvey, do you have any comments at this time? I will try to be brief. Planning Commission.

56:49 Madam Chair, staff, audience. This is a project, first of all, my name is Dave Harvey, Mammoth Lakes here. This is a project that began for me approximately five, six years ago. In 2010, we looked into what it might take to get this particular project on the books and

57:24 into the queue, if you will, and ultimately developed. And as we went through that process, we realized that there were a number of things, a number of issues in the conditional use permit that although were very probably acceptable at that time of approval, they, because of

57:56 Financial conditions, economic conditions now were not practical. So we methodically went through this and working since June directly with staff, we were able to figure out what might work and what might not work. You see the dilemma here is

58:22 Seven acres of prime TOT producing property is sitting vacant and that certainly doesn't help our financial situation here with the town. So our efforts went forward and I want to give a tremendous amount of thanks to our entire staff at the town level for approaching this with the same amount of

58:53 Interest and excitement that we brought forward to the town in what we saw as solutions for these issues of the existing conditional use permit. We'd like to thank the town for their timely processing, the access for questions. Many questions have been answered over these last six months.

59:23 And staff was right there and ready and helpful. They always had a very positive attitude about solving these critical issues that we had. And I think that this is very worthy of mention because they do very hard, tedious work sometimes that we don't necessarily get to see immediate results from. So you should be very, very proud of your...

59:53 Staff and their efforts here. Thank you. Thank you very much. I'd like to introduce our consultant team, Mr. Bill Myers. Bill is our asset manager, if you will, for the hillside property. Keeps everyone on track and going in the right direction. Tim Crump. Tim has a lot of experience here in Mammoth.

1:00:25 Weston and the 8050 and all of these projects on the construction level. And for us to put together a project on the hillside property, we certainly have to know what the costs and what the challenges are going to be. So he serves a very critical role. Tom Platts provides all of our engineering services. It's always great to use local folks.

1:00:55 He's done an outstanding job of creating some product that we'll be sharing with you in the near future of redesigning the type of project that may be on the hillside property. We had a workshop a number of months ago. It was a very productive workshop. And I think from that, there was direction given to staff.

1:01:27 Thank you.

1:01:55 A couple of them have traveled quite a ways and they've got great knowledge and would be able to give you some very solid and professional answers. So I hope you take that into consideration. With that, I'll be open for questions. All right. So since we seem to always have questions for both our staff and the applicant at the same time, it would probably be helpful if you just stayed right there at the podium. All right.

1:02:29 And then Commissioner Chang, do you want to start? Do you have any questions? I saw a reduction of the 35%. You need to turn your mic back on. I'm sorry. Thank you. We'll have to get used to this new procedure here. I saw a reduction of a 35% density bonus on the report. Can you elaborate on that just briefly? Sure.

1:02:58 State density bonus was allocated based on the original inclusionary housing that was proposed as part of the project. If the project moves forward with paying the standard fees that's required now for affordable housing mitigation, they don't meet the requirements for that state density bonus. So that would be removed from the project. Is there still, would there still be another way for them to meet the requirements to recoup that density bonus?

1:03:28 Or are those mutually exclusive? The applicant could propose changes to the project that would add that inclusionary housing back on site. They're not mutually exclusive, but at this point the applicant has expressed a preference for paying the standard fees and removing the opportunity for the density bonus. So in other words, providing inclusionary housing is the only way that they could qualify for that bonus?

1:03:58 Correct. Okay. Yeah. Did you have any other questions? Commissioner Greig, did you have any questions? Not a big question, but I was just curious, since we haven't seen a time extension request in the past year, am I correct in assuming that those are usually processed administratively? They're processed in association with the body who approves the associated project.

1:04:35 So if the project is administrative, the time extension request can be processed administratively. If the project was approved by commission, the time extension request has to be approved by commission. Okay. This is the first one that I've seen. So it's new territory for me. And I'm just curious, hopefully this doesn't happen, but if five years rolls around, 2021 seems like so far from now on paper, but

1:05:06 If five years comes around and we don't have sticks in the ground on the project, what happens? Do they have to come back and start drawing board on again? They have to start from the very beginning? And that doesn't preclude them from using existing plans or surveys and documents that they've worked on, but it requires a new submittal hearing approval by the commission. Subject to the zoning ordinance.

1:05:36 Exactly. At that time. Exactly. Okay. To me, it seems reasonable, so hopefully we don't have to cross that bridge at any point. The Commission received a letter via email from John Verruck with regards to a parcel that connects to Lakeview, and I don't happen to have that letter in front of me right now, but can you just address that briefly?

1:06:08 So he had current concerns related to an easement that was possibly located on that property or who actually owned that property. And so I spoke with him and confirmed that that property was a part of the Hillside Project and that any easements recorded were recorded and weren't modified by these amendments. Okay. Dave, do you have any additional information there? I know you spoke with John as well.

1:06:36 No, the best that we can ascertain is that that particular easement that he was referring to was a proposed easement at that time. That was not by the then owners of the property approved. Okay. They decided to go a different direction. That's the same understanding we had? Yeah. So, in fact, there is no easement. Turn your mic.

1:07:04 Is your mic on Ruth? So, in fact, there is no easement on record? Not of what he was describing, no. Okay. Commissioner Vanderhurst, do you have any other questions? I don't, no, not at this time. Thank you. Commissioner Verruck, did you have any questions? My questions were already asked and answered, so. All right, so one question I had for staff initially is,

1:07:32 So the packet that we saw today, can you please expand on how that may differ from the package we saw at the workshop? So the package at the workshop did not contain any specific language revisions to the conditions in the original resolutions. This packet contains a revised and combined resolution, specifically combined resolutions, I don't know if I have the numbers in front of me, but the 2006, 2007, 2008.

1:08:02 Resolutions. Okay. And so we amended conditions in those four issue areas that we talked about, the four and five star hotel, the pedestrian bridge, the 50 parking spaces, and then related to the fees. And then we also did numerous other updates related to just standard engineering planning conditions that are typically included in resolutions today. So we updated.

1:08:28 Some of those areas. For example, we added some language related to the water efficient landscaping ordinance that was adopted since the time of the existing resolutions. Okay. And I just want to, just because it's such a big issue, so I just really want to clarify that you did have legal counsel then review all the language relating to the parking and the fact that it's a private agreement, correct? Yes.

1:09:02 Well, Andy reviewed the resolutions before they were included in the staff report, of course. And then we did have additional discussions today based on the concerns that Tom Hodges with the mountain that he brought up. And Andy's counsel was that the town should not be a party to any private agreement. And by adding...

1:09:30 more specific language to the resolution requiring accommodation of those 50 parking spaces, it makes the town a party to that private agreement, and we don't want that enforcement responsibility. So his recommendation was to

1:09:50 Keep the language in the resolution, or he was comfortable with this provision that allows an alternative arrangement acceptable to the town, again, with his review to be included. I'm sorry. Yes. What was the town's concern? I mean, the mountain or Tom's concern? Maybe Tom should speak to him. We'll wait for the public comments. Oh, okay. Got it. Okay. All right. And then,

1:10:17 Condition 14, which is the badge, your benefit assessment district, condition 22, you know, we have these conditions that address traffic assessment districts. I mean, there's actually a couple of them. And I believe, from reading the document correct, though, that nowhere we talk about an infrastructure finance district in the future, correct? Is that correct?

1:10:46 Okay. And so what were the issues about the traffic? I believe it's addressed in Condition 22. There was a comment in there about the mobility. A comment in the report? That was in the actual condition. The condition that reads the project will participate in the required North Village traffic and circulation mitigation measures on a fair share basis? Yes. I think those are looking at...

1:11:20 Well, let me step back. The town does an evaluation of traffic in the North Village specific plan area on a biannual basis. If certain thresholds are exceeded, there are certain improvements that need to be implemented. I don't have them all off the top of my head, but they include such things as a pork chop delineator at Forest Trail and some other measures. Sorry, what? A pork chop? I'm sorry.

1:11:47 I know I'm not the only one who asked that question. Sorry. I got caught up in my own jargon. It's a right turn delineator to force people to make a right turn and take away the ability to make a go straight or a left turn when you're coming off a forest trail onto Highway 203. So that's a traffic calming measure that was outlined as an, you know, if certain thresholds, and there's other ones in there, but if those.

1:12:15 They're going to participate in the fair share portion of those if they're exceeded. Okay. And did you have any other comments regarding the conditions and the traffic in the North Village? Not specific to traffic, no. Okay. All right. Mr. Harvey, so I just wanted to really just...

1:12:41 Not only, I mean, we've already talked now about the private agreement, but the condition still talks about tandem and mechanical parking in that condition. I just wanted to see your comfort level with that. If you had any comments. I'm assuming you're explicitly meant to leave that in there. Yes, definitely. We don't want to take away any of the options that we already have approvals on. Okay.

1:13:07 So that will stay in there until a decision is made as to exactly what we will use. But this at least gives us that option to consider. All right. And I agree, you know, about the pedestrian bridge being a condition.

1:13:28 But if there was the opportunity someday to participate in a pedestrian bridge theoretically and to participate in an infrastructure financing district, I mean, these are all things that we're hoping to do in the North Village to make all the North Village a better marketable area, better experience for our tourists. I just wanted to make sure that you have discussed those possibilities with your client about someday participating in infrastructure financing district. Yes. Yes, we have.

1:13:58 All right. And then I just want to confirm then about the fees and the housing and the 35% state reduction density bonus. That is an agreeable condition to everybody? It's an agreeable condition. We have spoke with staff and should, through our workouts, we find that additional density than what is left on the property.

1:14:29 which is considerably less than what it was approved for back in 2006, that there would be a direction to take to come back to this body for a request for additional density which may entail a North Village specific plan amendment and possibly a general plan amendment. So obviously the project cannot

1:15:00 Thank you.

1:15:31 We're also seeing. Okay. And due to the way these conditions have evolved since 2006, it's probably one of the more complicated set of conditions. I mean, we've really now have worked to clarify our conditions and categorize them a little bit better. So I just want to make sure that you've read all those conditions and they're all agreeable to your client. Yes. Okay. That's all the questions I have. Does anybody else have any questions?

1:16:02 At this time? All right. Then we'll open the meeting up for public comment. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, Commission. Tom Heller with the Fire Department. My comments, I believe, tear a little bit into Commissioner Brown's, Chairman Brown's comments. The bridge. If the town didn't require the bridge, the bridge obviously got in there based on the design of the building.

1:16:37 That we were all looking at five years ago. It seems like it's a little premature to eliminate the bridge as a potential option. And again, if the town didn't direct that to occur, obviously there was a need for that based on the design, the problems that we have with Canyon Boulevard, the problems we have with Lake Mary Road. We've had two storms this year. We've already had pileups of cars at both of those locations.

1:17:06 And I know there's some plans down the road to do some modifications as far as the pedestrian crossing on Canyon Boulevard, but the perception one gets right now is that the bridge is off the table as far as something that's going to be discussed once we have a set of plans in front of us. And I guess I would urge the commission to just leave the bridge just as it is right now. If it's something that the design necessitates, then those discussions will occur when...

1:17:35 A final set of plans comes forward and we have a chance to review the situation. To lend the perception that the bridge is not a possibility down the road to me seems like it eliminates something that may be a necessity based on some of the issues that we're seeing out there on Canyon Boulevard and on Lake Mary Road in the vicinity of this project. All right. Thank you very much.

1:18:05 Do we have any other public comments? Good afternoon, Commission. Madam Chair, Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. So I apologize. I didn't have a chance to review this staff report until last night. And so it kind of caught me a little off guard with some of the proposed conditions with respect to the parking that you guys have heard mentioned already. And so I did raise concerns and called Sandra.

1:18:40 This morning, late this morning, had some discussions about our concerns, had a subsequent discussion with the applicant, and we had requests that our staff had mentioned to you that there's a request for an amendment to the conditions of approval that are before you right now. However, as I'm...

1:19:03 Reading back through this here, and actually sitting here in the audience, I realized a couple things that I didn't realize before, and so I have some questions, and it may be appropriate to caucus, I don't know what is appropriate protocol here for the public hearing, but I do have some further questions with respect to the process that I'd like to clarify. I'm happy to do it here at the podium, so I don't know, bear with me maybe.

1:19:33 A couple things. I understand these conditions of approval. So if you have, do you have comments other than the parking agreement? No, not specifically, no. Okay. So what I would suggest if you are in agreement, Sandra, is that we hear all the public comments, then we'll take a 10-minute recess. You can caucus and come back with whatever your comments are about the parking agreement. Does that work? Okay.

1:20:02 Yeah, so I'll take this opportunity just to go on public record real quick if you don't mind. As I understand these conditions, they replace, they supersede, it says right at the first condition that this supersedes all prior conditions of approval. So this is a new list of all the conditions that replaces all the prior, which is very material because there's language in the prior conditions that varies, especially with respect to the parking that we feel.

1:20:32 Isn't properly addressed here. That's why we're asking for this change. Now, that said, our concern is that this proposed amendment that you guys are considering that staff had mentioned to you during the report, we don't want to be in a situation where if we're not able to come to an agreement after 60 days with this issue, that it just defaults to the current language that's in the proposed.

1:21:00 Conditions of approval. Our request would be that it defaults to the prior use permit conditions that specifically address the parking. So that's our concern. And just, you know, it's always been this elephant in the room with this issue of this parking. It is, I'll agree with staff and everyone that it is, there's private agreements between the mountain and 8050, subsequently agreements between

1:21:29 80-50 residences and the hillside parcel that encumbered that parcel with 50 spaces, an obligation for 50 parking spaces that were party to our agreement with 80-50, which allowed them to put the sky bridge in. So, you know, we very much have concerns that we want to protect our right to park our, you know, have access to parking 50 cars.

1:21:54 You know, again, our feeling is reading the current conditions as they're drafted compromises the prior approvals. So if we can come to an agreement on this amended language, and maybe we could do it, like I say, offline after you close a public hearing and reconvene, we're happy to do that. But we do have some concerns. All right. So I just have a couple of questions for you. So when we did our workshop on this issue,

1:22:21 I don't recall you making any comments about the private agreement. Did you make any public comments? I don't remember attending. Okay. I may have missed that. All right. And then my recollection is that when we did the DDZA for 80-50,

1:22:40 And this thing came up about the parking agreement, that it was discussed at that time, it was a private agreement, and also my recollection of that conversation was that a statement was made publicly by the 80-50 representative that those 50 cars could be parked anywhere. Was that also your recollection? I do recall Dana Severy making that statement. Yes. Okay. However, I conditioned that saying that I, you know.

1:23:05 Our feeling at that point, I don't think we made public comment at that time, was that there exists this other parking arrangement between 8050 and Hillside that very much encumbers that property with 50 parking spaces. So we felt like our interests were covered. So we didn't feel the need to correct Mr. Severi in his statement, whether it's right or wrong. From a legal perspective, we think the agreements that are on title that carry with the property speak for themselves.

1:23:35 You know, again, didn't feel a need. Now, whether or not 8050 would choose to park cars elsewhere, that's their volition. I mean, from our perspective, that's their decision. But we do know that in the spirit of the negotiations that occurred, which we were very much participated in, I personally participated in, that the nature of those negotiations were and the intent of these agreements that were ultimately the parking obligation on 8050 was placed onto the hillside parcel to provide 50 parking spaces. And I think it's important.

1:24:02 For both commission and town staff to recognize the fact that, right, wrong or indifferent, whether you feel that you can't enforce private agreements, we will seek to park our cars on that, notwithstanding subsequent agreements to the contrary. We'll demand the use of our 50 parking spaces, and they'll go to park them on Hillside. If there's not 50 additional parking spaces in that garage, there's going to be inadequate parking, and they're going to have to park their residences.

1:24:32 People who have on the properties elsewhere to accommodate our need for 50 spaces. So, you know, there's a little bit of a quandary here. I'm not quite sure what the exact legal interpretations are from, you know, property rights and so forth. That's why we had very much concerns today. I didn't have time to consult with our council. I would like the opportunity and time to do that, but I don't want to have, be fortunate in a situation where if we can't come to an agreement in 60 days, that it times out and we're

1:25:02 The new conditions are forced down our throat. So that's our position. Okay. And then I want to clarify, do you believe there's two parking agreements, one between Mammoth Mountain and 8050 and one between Mammoth Mountain and the hillside? Or are we referring to one parking agreement? There are two agreements. There's an agreement between Mammoth Mountain ski area and 8050 private residences for 50 parking spaces.

1:25:31 And there's a subsequent agreement. This is back from 2007 when Sean Combs was still a developer for both 8050 and the hillside parcel. When he was getting his use permit approvals, he recorded a parking agreement between 8050 private residences and the hillside, encumbering 50 parking spaces on the hillside to satisfy the fact that he didn't have enough physical parking on

1:26:01 The 8050 site to accommodate the 50 spaces he guaranteed us under our parking agreement. So that's all the dirty laundry. And I understand it's messy and people don't like it, but, you know, we have a right to park 50 cars on 8050 and they have the right to park 50 cars on Hillside and that's where it stands. Okay. I'm a little disappointed that you didn't come and express all that at the workshop. That's the reason we had the workshop. And I apologize.

1:26:30 I don't know that I attended, and I must have missed it. All right. Are there any other public comments? Hello, my name is Bill Myers. I'm here to represent Cerberus, the landowners, the landowners, actually Mammoth Land Co. LLC. First, I'd like to thank the Planning Commission and Chairman and staff for all their work on this. There has been a tremendous amount of work on this. We've...

1:27:03 We've assembled a very local consultant team and will remain with that through this development. Our goal here is to refine the conditions to reflect market conditions to allow this project to move forward. And right now I'm working with, I think, five different cities and their staff. And I really do want to commend this.

1:27:31 The staff in the city in the manner in which they've approached this very professionally, very responsibly, and in many instances, the density in particular, saying, you know, what's good for the goose is good for the gander. And, you know, if we're going to take away the affordable...

1:27:53 Elements of it. The staff came back very appropriately and said, well, you're going to lose your density. And as Dave mentioned, that may be something that we may need to address in the future. But again, what we're trying to do here, and the bridge over the river, I guess we'd call it, is a good example. From a financial perspective, this transaction is very challenging, this development is very challenging to come up with

1:28:22 a type of product that will bring the town, TOC, excuse me, or TOT, and to, and at the same time, provide a product that is appealing to the type of individuals that we hope will come at today's pricing. So I think we've come up with a very good

1:28:49 Compromise here in the conditions that gives the city everything the city needs while at the same time allowing us to move forward in our development plans with our local team. Getting to the parking, I think it is a little bit unfortunate it's coming out in this manner, but I do want to clarify things a little bit to make it hopefully very simple. Mammoth Mountain has an agreement with 8050.

1:29:17 Mammoth Mountain does not have an agreement with us for parking on our parcel. We have an agreement with 8050 relating to parking. Those are private agreements. They should not be the subject of the city being involved in any way, and I think the city's in agreement with that. When we were approached earlier today by Mammoth Mountain, by Tom, we offered to, look, we'll take the language out if you don't like it. We'll live with it the way it is.

1:29:43 Or we'll go with this language. And then it was suggested by the town that we have the revised language, which allows us to work cooperatively, because we want to work cooperatively with the mountain, of course. And they have certain interests that are important to them that they want addressed. But I don't think the way to address those issues is through the conditions of approval for this project.

1:30:11 There are private agreements between the parties, private parties, parties can meet. We're willing to amend language if we can reach agreement and the town approves that language. We're more than willing to do that. But to hold up our conditions and our moving forward in our project, because we want to move this forward. We want to be paying.

1:30:38 Transit occupancy tax. We want to be doing those type of things that, you know, making this development move forward. And I think they want to move, I think Mammoth Mountain wants to have it move forward as well. I think we can work cooperatively. So I would ask that we do go forward with the suggested language. Maybe we can resolve issues over the next 10 minutes in a break and we can resolve it. I thought we had it resolved before, but apparently, and again, everybody's in good faith doing the best they can. You know,

1:31:08 Maybe we can come up with some language that resolves their issue. When I look at the language, I think it's very beneficial to Mammoth Mountain. I mean, it says, you know, staff wanted to put in, at their insistence, the final number of units permitted to be constructed may be limited by the available parking spaces in the Mammoth Hillside parking garage. So we're the ones that are at risk for

1:31:33 You know, loss of units if we can't do the parking, and then they added the language. Staff wanted to add this language too. In accordance with the private agreement with the 8050 Residence Club, an additional 50 parking spaces may be accommodated in the parking garage. When I read that, I don't see how Mammoth Mountain can be concerned, but I can't speak for them, and they're acting in good faith. You know, they have their issues as well. So, but I do think we have covered the issue under the existing language as proposed.

1:32:02 The phrase that was added that had been reviewed by the town attorney were agreeable to that as well. So, again, thank you, everybody. I think this is a very good first step in getting this development back on track. I'm very excited about this project. We've assembled, I think, a very good local team, and we hope to be breaking ground.

1:32:30 Not in the near future, but in the midterm. So thank you. Are there any public comments? Do we need a motion as far as taking a recess? So why don't we make this a 15-minute recess? The reason I'd like to do this is because we've had people travel quite a distance. But when you come back from recess, one of the answers I'd like to this question is I'm really confused.

1:33:08 If this parking agreement that we're discussing today is between 8050 and the hillside entity, then I'm not quite sure how Mammoth Mountain, in essence, is negotiating the terms of this new revised condition. So I'd like to have that question answered when you come back. I ask my commissioners that nobody discuss this when we...

1:33:35 Return for recess. So, yes, sir. I was just going to suggest that your pleasure, I'm going to be here regardless, but if you'd like to cover item number three, rather than take a recess and just come back, I'm perfectly happy to do that now. I wouldn't take 15 minutes anyway, but completely up to you. I have plenty of other things at your pleasure. The only thing is that, Sandra, I don't think, I don't know how that works near, it's up to you, Sandra. I'm probably going to go and discuss this with them, so.

1:34:04 If you don't need to hear my update, you'll hear it next Wednesday. Again, it's up to you. I just offered to make better years. Why don't we just take a 15-minute recess, and then that way it will let Sandra focus on one subject. But thank you very much for your offer. You bet. All right. So we will re-adjourn at 12 minutes to 4. I'll have to raise the mics back on. Okay. Staff, do you have additional information for us? Yes. We discussed condition 2B.

1:35:06 with the applicant and the mountain, and we are back where we started today with suggestion to revise condition 2B to read, unless an alternative arrangement acceptable to the town and approved by the Community and Economic Development Director is agreed upon by the applicant and another party within 60 days, then in accordance with the private agreement with the 8050 Residence Club, an additional 50 parking spaces may be accommodated in the parking garage.

1:35:36 So it allows the applicant, as well as the Mountain, 60 days to negotiate an additional condition that would be approved administratively by the town, reviewed by the town attorney. If that negotiation isn't complete within 60 days, the condition allowing but not requiring the 50 parking spaces in the Hillside Garage will be used. Does the applicant have any additional comments about that? Yes, we're, again, we believe that

1:36:19 Private agreement should be between private parties. Excuse me, is your mic on? Is it green? It's green, yeah. Is that better? Thank you. We believe private agreement should be between private parties. We have an agreement with 8050. We do not have an agreement with Mammoth Mountain. Mammoth Mountain has certain concerns over that language. We've offered to go back to the original language in Resolution 2007.

1:36:50 Dash 22. And I believe Mammoth Mountain would rather stick with the language which we now have in the resolution which is pending, which absent a separate agreement between the parties, which is approved by the city, that would replace the language that is in number two, the language in number two.

1:37:21 Will prevail. So there's a 60-day period where we can go out and talk with Mammoth Mountain and 8050 about this language. If we want to change that language, we will obtain the Community Development Director approval, and it will be changed. If not, then the language will be as written, which is that, I don't want to misquote it. Could you read it, please?

1:37:50 In accordance with the private agreement with the 8050 Residence Club, an additional 50 parking spaces may be accommodated in the parking garage. Yes. All right. So can we give that language some sort of phrase so that when we start deliberating and have to come up with a motion that we can refer to it? I think in your motion, probably the cleanest way to address it would be at the end, you would say with modified condition to be

1:38:21 As described in today's meeting. Okay. Probably modified condition 2B. Modified. Thank you. Thank you. Tom Hodges, did you have any additional comments? Thank you for hearing our concerns, and again, I apologize for the last-minute drama. We're certainly supportive of the applicant's project, and we certainly want to facilitate their development and assist them in their planning.

1:38:56 As they move forward with the project, and I want to thank you guys for your willingness to work with us here at the last minute. Apologize again. Yeah, I'm just hoping that the 60 days will give us an opportunity to have a little bit further discussions offline and resolve our concerns and work everything out. So, yeah, we had asked to try to change the language back to the prior condition. Town Attorney wanted to add some additional.

1:39:26 Subsequent language that I wasn't comfortable with, so I felt that it was better just to go with the proposed modification, and we're comfortable with that. Okay. And Ruth had asked that I address your specific question about why it is that we're coming to the podium and negotiating the parking agreement when we're not party to the private agreement between 8050 and Hillside, and I just, again, you know, we were very much engaged in the 2007 negotiations with

1:39:56 At that point, it was one developer that owned both parcels, and it was all quid pro quo, although now it's a separate party and it's a separate owner now, not the original developer, Sean Combs, who owned both parcels. So, you know, even though we're not party to that private agreement between 85th and Hillside, at the time, in the spirit of the negotiations, which we were deeply involved in, it was very much the case that

1:40:25 That was how we were solving this problem, that we were party to it. So that's why we're here. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. Are there any other public comments? Does anybody else have any other additional questions on this issue? All right. So, Sandra, does it need to be input into the public record that you consulted with the town attorney during this meeting? It can be, yes. Can you please make sure that's noted, Pam?

1:40:59 All right. Per the applicant's request, we will not technically close the public hearing, but we will move to deliberate. Sorry, I lost my page here. So how I'd like to do this is what we'll do is we'll go through. Pardon me just one second.

1:41:34 We will initially, I'll just ask each commissioner to speak on the four issues, which are on page five of your staff report, and so, and then what we'll do is address the issues that are addressed in the motion. So, I'm sorry, so the issues are,

1:42:07 The four or five star hotel operator, the pedestrian bridge, the 8050 residence club, 50 parking spaces, the fees. Okay. And then there was that additional request that a condition 23. So that's really five issues. So I think it would just be easiest if our deliberation, if each commissioner made any comments they had about those five issues. And then would you like to start, Commissioner Chang? Yes. Okay.

1:42:42 Let's see. In regards to, I think the first one is. The hotel. Yeah. We're on page five. You want the, it's, you're page five of 80 on your, I'm sorry that during our break, the internet timed us all out here, so we have to find our pages again. Yeah. I can't. Maybe you can just show them your hard copy. I hate to do that. Go back to the paper copy. All right.

1:43:20 In terms of the rating of the hotel, as a hotel operator, I, you know, while my personal experience is, you know, I certainly like having a, you know, four-star hotels in town, but I don't believe that's a, that's a restriction that we need to place on the applicant, since we're not, you know, we're not in the position to.

1:43:52 You know, we're not an operator, a hotel operator, and so forth. So, you know, and I would agree with the applicant that we can remove that condition. Okay. At the Austrian Bridge, Mr. Tom Heller, he was not here, but I thought he made a great point on his, and I do. However, I think

1:44:32 You know, from the, you know, I do understand and I have to understand that, you know, the developer's perspective in terms of the financial impact and the viability, the viability of the project itself, you know, I would also agree to have that removed as well. 80-50 parking, the 50 parking spaces, I would agree. With the modified condition? With the modified condition, yes.

1:45:05 And on the last item would be the fees, and I have no objection when on the fees, paying low fees. Right. And then technically there's the addition of revised condition 23, but I'm assuming that's, which was the? Oh, the time extension. Correct. Okay. I would agree with it. Okay. All right. Any other comments? No. Commissioner Greig. Can you please go through? Sure. I see no reason to require a fortified host.

1:45:41 Star Hotel Operator. I would imagine that the applicants would be looking for something in the realm of what that might be defined as, but in order to require it as a condition of approval, it seems a bit prohibitive, and I don't see why we as a town should be in the business of making such requirements of our applicants, so I'm perfectly in agreement with that. I'm a little concerned about the pedestrian

1:46:13 Bridge, but until the project is, and the project, the scale of the project is developed to a point where we're actually going to see sticks on the ground, and I don't know that it makes sense for us to put that stipulation in there as well. I mean, by the time this project moves forward, there may very well be some other solution that is much more sensible than a pedestrian bridge, so I think we can address that if the project requires it.

1:46:43 And I have no issues with the modified parking verbiage in the condition. As for the in-lieu fees, I think we've seen from several of our applicants in the past that the desire to pay in-lieu fees is much higher than the desire to include affordable housing on site, and I think that makes a lot of sense to me, particularly for this site.

1:47:13 I do fully expect that we will see some sort of request in the future for an increase in the density because it's a little bit surprising to me that the loss of 35% of the rooms is actually going to make this project pencil, but I am not a financial person at all. But it seems to me like there are methods where the applicant could come back and

1:47:43 Request the amendments necessary for such an increase in density. And I just realized my microphone's not on. So overall, I think I'm pretty happy with the way things stand at the moment. Commissioner Van. No, I really have no problem with these, removing these conditions. The four or five star hotel condition,

1:48:15 I don't have a problem removing. I'm hoping that the quality of the development will dictate the fact that it's a four or five star type of property. It's a niche that this community and this destination and this resort need more of as an amenity. So I'm quite hopeful on that. I'm sad the pedestrian bridge is being removed, but I completely understand the rationale from it.

1:48:45 Not only from a developer perspective, but the fact that we actually had nothing in the town records that required it. So that was a little bit of a surprise, but I understand why we're dropping that. The 50 parking spaces, it sounds like we've kind of, well, at least the private parties have kind of come to some sort of, at least an extension to come to an agreement. I very much would like to keep the town out of those private agreements.

1:49:14 going forward, and this sounds like a perfect example of why. And then the fees. No, I have no problem with dropping the fee condition and modifying it to the current schedule of fees. Timing as well, the extension, the five-year extension, I have no problem with that condition as well. Commissioner Verruck? I don't need to go over every single one in detail, but I do agree with

1:49:48 I do agree with everything that's been said, and I would like to just reiterate or emphasize what Tom Heller talked about with regard to the pedestrian bridge. I see that it in the future may be a great benefit to the community, but I don't see that one developer should be responsible for building and paying for it. I think it's something that hopefully in the future, as

1:50:15 I just discussed earlier that hopefully in the future there will be maybe some grant funding and that the other parties within the North Village will be able to kick in some money to pay for something like that. But as far as any one particular developer having to pay for it, I agree. I don't think that we should require this developer to do that. But I am fine with...

1:50:44 With everything else that we've discussed. Okay. So I agree with my fellow commissioners on those points. So I just want to make sure, do we believe that the requested actions are consistent with our vision, goals, and policy of the general plan? Is everybody in agreement that they're consistent? Yes. That they conform with the Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code? Yes. Conform with the North Village Pacific Plan?

1:51:13 Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. And that it's consistent with the CEQA, right? Yes. Anybody have any questions about that? So if there's no further deliberation, I call for a motion. I'd like to make a motion that we adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, and approve tentative tract map 36-235A, use permit 2005-09A, use permit 2007-11A,

1:51:44 Use permit 2007-14A and time extension request 15-003 subject to all conditions of approval as modified, including planning condition number 2B as modification of planning condition 2B as described in today's meeting. Do I have a second? I'll second. All right. Before we discuss the motion on the table, I do want to technically close the public hearing.

1:52:11 All right. Is there any discussion on the motion on the table? Are we ready for a roll call? Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Did you want to discuss, or are we going to do a roll call? Roll call is fine. Okay. Here. No, you got it. Yes or no? Oh, yes. Yes. I'm sorry. Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Commissioner Verrug? Yes. Vice Chair Grayag? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. I just would like to thank, again, Ruth.

1:52:43 This is a very, as I know, it's very technically difficult in the sense that it's gone on almost nine years, ten years, so you had to take a lot of different conditions, uses, documentation. You did a great job with the staff report of making it very simple for us to understand. I really appreciate yours and Sandra's work. I really appreciate all the work that Mr. Harvey put in it, and I thank you very much for showing up, Mr. Myers, at our meeting.

1:53:10 The back row back there. So thank you, everybody, and thank you, Tom Hodges, for your input today. So thank you very much. We'll now move on to our business matter of our agenda, which is Capital Improvement Program Status Update. Thank you, Grady Dutton Public Works, Commissioners and Chair.

1:53:36 Next Wednesday at Town Council we're having a workshop at 5 o'clock to really start the process of updating our CIP, our major maintenance program. What I want to do today is just give you a brief kind of an outline of the process we're going through and encourage you to either attend that meeting or certainly read the agenda items so you know what we're up to basically.

1:53:58 Really, over the past few months, staff has been compiling information to update that CIP and major maintenance plan. We've looked at some of the older CIPs. We've looked at the master facilities program, examples from other agencies to find a format that really works for us. As you know, our budget from year to year is quite variable. From the public works side, anyway, it's even more variable than the towns, frankly. As an example, last summer, public works did over $6.5 million worth of improvements, about $300,000.

1:54:27 That was town funds, the rest was grant money, SIP money, ATP money, from all over the place. So we don't have that much control as to what our capital budget is from year to year. We're always out there looking for funds. As you know, just a few months ago, we got a grant to the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure. That was a great one, a $900,000. Unfortunately, we did not get our...

1:54:49 Our funding request through OGAL is for a RTP grant for the second half of the life-money bike path. That shows you the variable nature. Certainly today there's so much competition for grant monies, we can't control it. So what we looked at was looking at the development impact fee study, the update, because some of the old master facilities programs were kind of like the old diff fee. There were so many projects in there that were unrealistic. It just didn't make any sense to keep them all in the five-year program. It was just not going to happen.

1:55:17 We looked at our stormwater management plan, which we just updated and council approved a couple of months ago. We've had ongoing discussions with FAA about the new terminal and the apron. As late as two weeks ago, we had a very positive meeting with FAA, and we're confident that's going to move forward. And in fact, we may get out with a request for qualifications for consultants in January or middle of February. So that's moving forward. Those of you who have been able to attend some of the town goals and priorities workshops,

1:55:45 That changed our list quite a bit as well. So we've gone through quite a bit lately. In addition to meetings with this group, with the Recreation Commission, MLR, so we're trying to bring that all into a sense of reality. So we have a book, if you will, that we can bring back to Council probably in January or February to say, look, we want you to adopt this CIP, but we want it to be a meaningful book that you can look at and know that there's some certainty in it or at least a plan and that we'll update that on an annual basis.

1:56:15 In addition to compliant court of a preliminary needs list, again, we look back at the general plan, the master plan, all the specific plans, the mobility element. I mean, the mobility element itself is undergoing revision right now with the FAR study and everything. So everything's sort of gelling at this time. And what we came up with, frankly, was it's a two-page list. It's really pretty short. The first page of about...

1:56:41 25 projects. We really do anticipate that we would be underway with in some form or another over the next five years. We have a strong sense of certainty for that. Some will come out of the general fund. Some will measure our dollars, frankly. Some will be projects, the FAA, like the new terminal in the apron. Some will be grant funds like the Lake George Connector Path Phase 1, which we're going to award next Wednesday and be under construction on next summer. With each of those, we are underway.

1:57:10 Including a single page or a two page at most description of each one. This description, and again I'm just trying to provide the process, it'll include not just a project description, what we're doing today with the project, some of them are actually under construction, we have one at the airport, it'll start back up in May for rehabbing the general aviation aprons.

1:57:30 We'll talk about the planning documents. This needs to be based on something. We've heard that many times from the dais here at Town Council that we don't just bring forward a project. It's like, where did this come from? Some of them will go back 20 years, like some of the PATH projects, the bikeway plan, the pedestrian master plan, trail system. I mean, we have a lot of planning documents in the town. We want to make sure they're on here so when something doesn't come forward to you or to Town Council, there's a reference back. There's been a lot changed over the years. We'll describe the public benefit.

1:57:59 Talk about the background and some of the analysis. And then we'll go through a schedule of funds. On this one, for example, the Mammoth Creek gap closure, we identify the costs for planned specs and engineering, for right-of-way, for construction. And then we talk about where the funds are.

1:58:16 This one is more certain because we believe we have the funds for right-of-way and for that. Some of them will just say a future ATP grant or a future STIP document at some point. We can't be certain. But the document will make it clear what we know and we don't know at least. Previous ones, again, it was sort of like the diff study, not to criticize it, that's what staff was asked to do, but it was a long list of projects and not all of them were going to certainly come to fruition. So we'll do that for the 20-some projects on that first page.

1:58:45 In addition to that, however, so we can look at at least 20 years and in some ways, or at least 10 years and in some cases 20 years, we're also going to have a segment at the back which talks about some of the longer range things. The storm drain master plan update is a good example of that. It identified eight or nine million dollars in projects that really need to be done, starting up at the top near John Muir in Davis and solving some old problems.

1:59:09 Most of those aren't even tied to the diff. Some of them are, but most of them aren't because they're not based on new development. There's no nexus there. So we don't know where we're going to get that $8 or $9 million. Having said that, the IRWMP, if I screw up that acronym again, it'll not be the first time.

1:59:27 We're working with them as a regional agency, and now that we've updated our stormwater master plan, we're eligible to put in money for real dollars to solve some of these problems. So a lot of these are on the back page, if you will. That doesn't mean they're not important. It's just that we don't, we're not confident we'll have that money in five years. So we want to describe them, make sure that the town council and you guys, everybody knows that we're looking far into the future.

1:59:50 And even in terms of the front page and the priorities that we might suggest, we don't talk about that too much because we want to have, if you will, tiers of projects. In other words, we have three or four that we'd really like to do on trails. Well, sometimes we have an opportunity to provide to us.

2:00:06 Excuse me, to apply for an OGALS grant for a certain type of trail, a recreational trail, a regional trail. There's so many different potential sources of fun that we don't want to say this is our number one period and focus just on that. We will have a tier.

2:00:21 And we'll go look for the funds for that group of projects. Whichever one pops out will be opportunistic. We'll come back and recommend that. So again, all I want to do today was sort of outline the process. Be happy to answer any questions. If you have any questions about specific projects, again. Well, you know what we're going to ask you about. Whichever ones you like. We can go through any of them you like. Is the one favorite project of the commission on there? I know which one it is.

2:00:52 Let me see. It's on page one. Amazing wayfinding. It's actually, we do have it because, again, we consider at least the first phase of that is shovel ready, if you will. You know, we have the plans and specs ready to go and ready to bid on that. So we will have a full page on that one. We can't identify the funding yet because it's, you know, we don't have a grant for anything, but it's absolutely on the list. So, you know, when we were in our joint workshop, just talking about wayfinding.

2:01:22 Let's see, Councilman, I guess Wentworth, we had a question about, well, were those plans still updated, et cetera? And, you know, we know we put a lot of work into it, but I was just curious, do we need to come back to commission and just do a quick review so we can go to council and say, yes, that's ready? We did speak with Hayes about that after that meeting, and I think it was agreed that we should come back before you and just...

2:01:50 You know, discuss the project, discuss what was approved, and that way we can at least say, and the commission has reviewed it recently. Yeah, there's a, you know, I've looked through it as well. There's a good solid program for all the phases. Phase one, there are plans and specs for, but it certainly wouldn't hurt for the town council and yourself to see it again so that everyone understand what's in there and what's not. Is it really just for vehicles? Is it for pedestrians?

2:02:14 You know, is it, what is it for? It would be great to have that in either as an item or a workshop whenever or however you'd like to do that. We're ready to do that at any time. Okay. And so I just was curious. So if you have something on the DIFF list, is it also on this list? Or are they mutually exclusive? No, the ones, in fact, the numbering system and everything that we're using in previous iterations, they weren't consistent. So you couldn't really put them up next to each other. We started with the DIFF.

2:02:44 Naming convention and, you know, the titles and lists and things on that. That's sort of the basis in terms of the groupings, airports, storm drain, streets, that type of thing. Actually, airports isn't in the diff anymore, but we're starting with those conventions so that they will relate. If it's on the diff in the five-year plan, it's almost certainly in the CIP. There will be some in the CIP that aren't on the diff because, again, some of those storm drain projects just aren't eligible.

2:03:10 The CIP project will be all-inclusive. If we miss some, there will be some reason that maybe it's eight years out on the diff and we have it on page two, you know, on the back part. But we started with the diff. Again, we want to make them consistent. They weren't before. Okay. And do you feel that comprehensively now we have a good document that at least outlines all the projects? I mean, I always felt like in the past that maybe there were some dangling ones out there. I mean, do you feel like now we really...

2:03:36 At least identify what the projects are? We really do, but we'll, you know, once we have that agenda item out, and it's going to be an iterative process with Town Council, we'll go to them initially, try to make sure that we're in alignment with their goals and priorities, you know, and we're having another meeting on that next week. Then we'll prepare sort of a draft book. Once they...

2:03:56 accept the project list. We'll come back to you also for a finding of consistency with the general plan as well. But yes, and that's the idea of the two tiers. But we don't want to put it all, again, in one book that makes people think, gee, this is all going to happen. No, we want to be very serious about the things we think we can get done. And then the rest will be, yes, these are...

2:04:15 Also very important, but they may not happen in the next two or three years, or the funding isn't identified. And if there's any dangling ones out there that you think of during this process, please bring them to our attention, because we want it to be all-inclusive. Do you have any other questions? Do you have any questions? I do have one question. When will you have those single sheets? Are they all available now? Are you still working on them?

2:04:45 We have a pretty good list. Staff is right now putting in the years and the dollar amounts. So we expect to present that to council next week, a first shot at that. And it won't be in the package, which is already done, but we'll hand it out. We'll have it available. We'll post it on the Internet. You can look at it, read that, come to me, whatever. So we'll have that available. And they won't be making any decisions on this next week. It's really just sort of an initial shot at it so they can have a turn. Nice.

2:05:12 It'll be, again, an iterative process. All right. Well, thank you very much. Sorry to make you wait so long. No, I was trying to help you. I'm good. Thank you. All right. So if there's no other questions, we'll move on to consent agenda. Do we have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of the November 12, 2015 Planning Commission meeting. Do you have a second? Second. All in favor?

2:05:43 Aye. All right. We'll move on to commissioner reports. What's up with the design committee these days? Dawn, do you want to talk about TALIS? Yeah, we met at TALIS, and we looked at the proposal for the last phase of TALIS, as well as the utility garage that they're building, the garage that they're building.

2:06:10 You know, I mean, basically it's not, you know, as far as aesthetically, it's going to look exactly as, for the most part, as what's already there. So there really isn't a huge discussion as far as design. They are building duplexes, they're doing duplexes instead of a single freestanding.

2:06:32 However, if people were too interested in purchasing one unit, they would let them choose a floor plan of the original three and have one single stand. And how many units are they building? It's five buildings, right? Isn't it? The new? No, I think there's more than that. I think there's more. I just don't know off the top of my head. It was 19. I thought total with Taos was 19, but maybe. I think there's 10 new buildings, so it could be 20 units. Up to 20, yeah.

2:07:02 Right. So if someone wants to buy a full building, full building, like duplex building, they can turn that into a single family resident? Correct. They would purchase it before it was built, and then they would build one of the original ones that was a single unit, so I think that's the intent. Yes. Oh, and they're also turning the front office space into a caretaker unit, so they have to create a garage and a

2:07:35 You know, kitchenette and add a bathroom or add a full bathroom. So that'll be the on-site manager's unit. And this project, that requires a tentative map, also design review and a district zoning amendment for the change to the manager's unit. So that will be coming before the commission in January. Who's the applicant? Eric Fishburne.

2:07:59 So he, well, who's the legal owner, actually? I don't know the legal owner off the top of my head. I know Eric Fishburne's representing the owners. All right. So this is Zone R2. It's Zone, it's within the Lodestar Master Plan. It's Zone Resort. Resort. Yeah, within the Lodestar Master Plan. Okay. So I had just a comment for the design committee just to...

2:08:26 Sometime to put on your to-do list. So when we read these conditions and it says that they have to bring a color material board forward, I mean, it's like kind of archaic, isn't it, to bring color material boards? I mean, isn't there a better way for an applicant today to show? I just didn't know if you had a... In my experience, there is no substitute for seeing the real thing in person. Okay. So it might seem a little bit archaic, but because of...

2:08:56 The differences in people's computer screens and printers and you just have absolutely no idea if what you're looking at on the screen is what you're going to get. All right. That's my opinion. Well, no, but that's why we have the two of you because you work on that every day. Okay. All right. Did you have anything else to report? No, I don't think so. No, we'll be meeting next week, I believe, to have a further discussion about the police station and, I believe, a new development on the corner of Hillside and Canyon Boulevard.

2:09:27 Condo, condo complex? Apartments. Apartments. Apartments. So, we'll have to read it. Commissioner Chang, it's on the vacant lot. Explain to them where we're talking. Hillside. Hillside. So, um, the corner that, that is adjacent to the village on the corner of Hillside and Canyon Boulevard. There's those two small lots there. Got it. Okay. I think they were a quarter. John Hooper is currently building on the one across, across Hillside from it. Okay. Right now it's.

2:09:57 You know what we're talking about? Unofficial parking. Yeah, I was going to say. Unofficial overflow parking. I think Councilman Fernie talked one day at a council meeting about how he counted 60 cars parked all along the hillside on those dirt lots, you know. So it's the dirt parking lot, right? All right. Are there any other commissioner reports? What's new with tourism? Well, I was just going to mention, it's not so much MLT specific, but it's chamber specific.

2:10:28 For the business community and since there's really nobody here but Tom, maybe for our viewers online, there's a program that the chamber is putting out there next week called the Peak Performance Program and it's being spearheaded by a guest speaker named Murray Banks and the idea is to improve the level of customer service.

2:10:55 Here in Mammoth Lakes, whether it's food and beverage or retail or hospitality or whatever the business sector may be. They're free seminars and like I said, they're hosted by the chamber in partnership with Mono County. So the first one is on the 14th of December from 4 to 5.30 at the Mammoth Brewing Company upstairs and I think there's some light hors d'oeuvres that will be served.

2:11:25 You do have to RSVP for these presentations, so that can be done through the chamber. The second one is the next day, which is December 15th. It's from 8.30 to 10 a.m., and again, it's at the brewery, the room upstairs, which has now been converted into a meeting space, and again, that one will be hosted by the chamber.

2:11:47 The idea is business owners here in town would raise the level of customer service from their employees, maybe increase the level of enthusiasm, and the presenter will lay out a strategy on how to do that. So I would highly recommend any business owner or employee to attend one of those. Our staff is going to attend. Great. Do we have any other commissioner reports?

2:12:16 Okay, so we'll close commission reports and we'll go to the director's report. So quickly, for the senior planner recruitment, we picked someone, we've offered the job, he's accepted. His name is Bob Nevins and he currently works in Silverton, Colorado, which is a very, very small town outside of Durango.

2:12:35 He has worked in the past in Aspen Snowmass. He's been on the private side building ski resorts. So he has a lot of experience. So he's going to start in early to mid-January. He's still trying to figure out his whole relocation. But I think he'll make a great addition to our team. He's going to bring a lot of experience from those other ski resorts and from his private work. And I think that'll really help us out. So we'll introduce him to you at the next commission meeting if he's started at that point.

2:13:04 The building official, we've interviewed people, we have a candidate, we've made an offer and we're waiting to hear back from that candidate. So we will let everyone know when we hear from him.

2:13:17 And then just another item, I did, I've been in communication with the Mono County Office of Education about presenting to the commission. Chair Brown suggested that at any of the future light meetings, we might have possibly the school district or the hospital, you know, present on some of their ideas. I did speak with Stacey Adler. She has an item that she'd like to bring to you. And I suggested the meeting in February, because at this point, the January meeting is

2:13:47 Relatively full with the TALIS project. We will be bringing a tentative tract map from John Hooper and an associated district zoning amendment that relates to both of those projects as well as we'll be talking to the commission about a possible zoning code amendment to deal with some issues we're seeing with non-conforming uses, non-conforming structures actually. So we suggested that she come to the meeting in February and we'll let you know we're still communicating on that.

2:14:16 That's all I have. Congratulations on the staff. Yes, we're really happy. Which is only half. Congratulations. I know. We're waiting. You're happy to have half. Yes, I am happy to have half. Okay. So, John Hooper's coming forward in January. Right. All right. Is everybody going to be present in January? I'm going to have to recuse myself from that portion of the meeting. So. What is that?

2:14:43 It's a tentative tract map for the west side of East Bear Lake Road. Okay. He's out there under construction right now, which is fine. He just needs to get the map in order to sell the houses. So it's that. It needs a final map? No, it's a tentative tract map. Sorry, I'm sorry, it's a tentative. Yeah. Okay.

2:15:09 Gray Bear, what, Phase 2? I'm not sure which gray, I think it's. I think you're okay because you did the house in Phase 1. Yeah, I'm in Phase 1. My issue with Phase 2 is I have a client who has one of those underneath reservations, so. And we're happy to talk to any of you if you feel like you may have a conflict, you're not sure, we can meet with you offline to discuss the project and make sure that you don't have a conflict. Will it be an issue if I'm not here on that day? Well, I mean. Since you're going to recuse yourself. Well, then they would leave three, so.

2:15:40 It just always makes me a little nervous to only have three. Right. Okay. And the other thing is, is that we were talking about, and are we going to do this in the January meeting, is to have Hayes come forward and talk in general about irrevocable easements and the town's policy of not accepting them and what that means for developers. He was just going to speak in public comment at the very beginning of the meeting. And that goes back to yours and my discussion about irrevocable roadie easements? Correct. Okay.

2:16:09 That's specifically to the tract that we live in. Right. But I was surprised there's a lot of irrevocable easements out there. I don't know how many we have. I think there are a few, right? And I'm looking forward to him to explain the detail, but that's quite common practice. You don't always accept those because you take on the liability, but he can explain that. So that's real common. And then while we're on this, so what...

2:16:39 What may just come out of that discussion is someday we may decide to change that condition slightly. Because the issue is if you do an irrevocable road easement, and then as Commissioner Chang and I are personally experiencing, and then if a development agreement is delayed, okay, then you have these unintended consequences that there's no maintenance agreement. I mean, so we kind of, we're going to have to figure out.

2:17:05 Where the town's role and responsibility is on that. So we'll talk about that sometime in the future. But I also think that I received a suggestion, which is probably a good suggestion, that we consider adding a condition into a future condition that basically says that no private agreements can be made for parking requirements.

2:17:31 That alter parking requirements. We should ultimately work on some sort of condition so that we don't get into the same kind of situation that we were today. I don't know if the town can regulate that. I mean, we can't. They obviously know private agreements can be made to reduce parking requirements. That's what we'd want to do is not reduce. And that's not what they did today. They still, Mammoth Hillside Project still needs to meet the minimum parking requirements for their project, but then provide these additional. So we just really, I think we should be explicit about that they can't reduce.

2:18:00 We just want to make sure that somebody can't come in and reduce parking requirements. Right, right. Whether by a private agreement, right? Right. We might just, might be just something, since we've all been talking about it, just to look at. Yes. Okay. Then, we received this letter, I think both commission and council received a letter from George Archer, I believe that was his name, about his senior pass and how he didn't think it was. I didn't receive.

2:18:31 I received it, and I actually received it really... I did not receive any emails on this. I received it, and I received, got a pretty detailed response from Eric Forsell on it. You know, I think it went to Dave Harvey and Elizabeth Tenney, and not... Did it go to any town staff? I don't, I have not seen it. But I got through my town email. Okay. Well, I just wanted to make sure that if it was addressed to commission, that commission addressed it. But are you saying somebody answered that letter? I believe...

2:19:02 Yeah, I believe someone from Eric's team answered his concerns. All right, so we don't need to be. This gentleman felt that the senior pass was unfairly priced compared to other ski resorts and that it was hindering economic development. All right. In the American Planning Association, in the newsletter or the online newsletter I got, I noticed they had a blurb in there about

2:19:30 Short-Term Rentals, and they have an information packet. I don't know if you saw that. I tried to open it up, and I couldn't get it to open the link. I can look and see if I can get it. It's a technical problem on my side. Okay. Okay. And then I just wanted to ask the commission about how they felt on an issue, and that is that probably in January, regarding our CEQA, regarding FAR,

2:20:00 You know, a big part of that is the water study, and how would you feel either myself or myself and Sandra, depending on her schedule, went to the water district meeting representing the Planning Economic Development Commission and just giving the current board of the water district some background on our Main Street project, the importance of the FAR and the CEQA, and really asked them to, you know,

2:20:28 Really work with us on completing this last phase of the CEQA study. I'm very comfortable with that. I just don't want to go and say I represent somebody. All right. And that was all that was on my list. So is there anything else on your list, Sandra? Nope. Okay. Does anybody else have anything else? No. Okay. I move that we adjourn to our next meeting January 13, 2016 at 2 p.m. Thank you. I don't see you.

2:21:00 Happy to all holidays. Get those powder skis out. Thank you very much.