TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2016

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

352 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Good afternoon. I call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for January 13, 2016. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Commissioner Verruck is absent. Vice Chair Graeck? Here. And Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand and join me for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag.

0:35 of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, I'll open the meeting for public comments. Public comments is for anyone that would like to speak on any item that is not on today's agenda.

1:13 The outside events ad hoc committee. We've made some good progress so far. Our goal is identifying outdoor event venues that will see 10 to 15,000 people that has the potential to grow in these next 10 years at the minimum of three annual events. Tomorrow is our third meeting. We are going through the process of reviewing the HVS report that was published in October 2013, never adopted but accepted. And we're going through USFF land management issues.

1:42 Land exchange, what the parameters are, timelines, et cetera, educating the group. We've got a team of about 42 to remain at this point. We're going to complete the opportunities and constraints matrix. We're looking at evaluation criteria and a rubric that's associated with that criteria. We'll begin to eliminate sites. We have about 37 different pieces of parcel at this point in time. We're kind of excited looking at the broad breadth of what might be out there. It's about an hour and a half tomorrow morning, 8 o'clock here. It's open to the public. Come on down. We're going to get on the 21st.

2:11 The 28th will bring closure. We'll bring something to MLR forward, something to the Planning Commission, Town Council, and go from there. The goal is to have a small group that we can get some direction on by probably Lee Markson. Thank you for the opportunity to share. Thank you very much. Are there any other public comments? With that, I will close the public comments. Before we open the public hearings, I just would like to make two announcements.

2:45 Due to a conflict of interest, we consulted with our town attorney. I need to recuse myself from public hearing number one and public hearing number two. So our vice chair will be conducting the public hearing for those two agenda items. And I'd just like everybody to know in the audience that

3:06 Commissioner Verruck seriously had a very serious family issue, so she did not miss this meeting lightly. So there will just be three commissioners hearing those first two public items. Thank you, Mickey. And with that, we'll move on to our first public hearing. Consider approval of District Zoning Amendment 15-001, Lodestar at Mammoth Master Plan Amendment, including the consideration of Addendum No. 3 to the Lodestar.

3:49 at Mammoth Environmental Impact Report. Our staff contact is Ruth, Sandra. Thank you. The proposed district zoning amendment to the Lodestar Master Plan is tied to both the Gray Bear 2 and Talus projects, which are items 2 and 3 on today's agenda. The approval of Gray Bear 2, which includes a tentative tract map and use permit, is contingent upon the approval of this DZA because of the request for reduced setbacks.

4:17 However, the Talos project may be approved without the approval of the DCA, which will be discussed in more detail when we get to Agenda Item 3. The original Lodestar Master Plan, which was adopted by Town Council in 1991, envisioned the development of a major commercial, residential, and recreational hub, including a golf course. Since the master plan's approval, the golf course in various residential areas have been subdivided, built upon, and entitled.

4:46 In 2013, the Lodestar Master Plan was amended by DZA 12-002. The 2013 amendment did several things, including cleaning up the original and conceptual maps, allowing for transient rentals in Development Area 1, and permitting residential single-family setbacks for single-family structures in Development Area 5. The current amendment to the Lodestar Master Plan addresses Development Area 2 only, shown on the screen in the crosshatch marks.

5:18 and proposes two things. The first is allowances and standards for accessory structures, and the second is revised setbacks for single-family structures. I'll describe each of the proposed amendments and then what is currently permitted. The first amendment is related to accessory structures and allows for reduced perimeter setbacks for those accessory structures only. Proposed setbacks for accessory structures in Development Area 2 are 10 feet from project perimeters

5:50 And 20 feet from arterial roads. Accessory structures may include accessory buildings, secondary dwelling units, or, in the case of Talus, on-site manager's units. Specific standards for on-site manager's units are proposed to ensure that appropriate use of the unit as a manager's unit for an associated HOA. Since the publication of the packet, the applicant for Graybar II, John Hooper, has noted that he is willing to modify the provision related to simultaneous rental of the accessory secondary units.

6:19 If necessary. And we can discuss that more after the report's concluded. The second amendment to the Lodestar Master Plan focuses on reduced setbacks for single-family structures. The original request included in your packet was to allow single-family structures and two-unit townhomes to be subject to the residential single-family setbacks in the municipal code, which are 20 feet in the front and 10 feet along the sides and rear.

6:45 This was in line with what was approved by the Commission in 2013 for single-family structures in Development Area 5, which was the Greystone project. However, due to concerns brought up by Mammoth Mountain in regards to the reduced setbacks along the golf course boundary, we have revised the proposed amendments to request reduced setbacks along the front and side property lines only, maintaining the 20-foot setback along the rear property boundaries, which are primarily adjacent to the golf course.

7:14 The TALIS project is no longer a part of the reduced setback request. Because these amendments have been revised since the packet was distributed, I'd like to go through and read the specific amendment language, which is shown on the slide. I'm not sure if that's too small to be readable. So the amendments are as follows. The first is to allow accessory structures within Development Area 2 to be located a minimum of 10 feet from any residential resort or commercially zoned property.

7:44 To be located a minimum of 20 feet from any arterial street, subject to the following requirements and limitations. Accessory structures approved as secondary residential dwelling units on single family lots are subject to the development standards in Municipal Code Section 17.52.270, with the exception that the primary dwelling and the secondary dwelling unit may both be rented simultaneously and the deed restriction or covenants are not required.

8:10 Accessory structures approved as on-site manager's units shall be subject to the following limitations. An on-site manager's unit shall be used exclusively by an on-site manager or other employee of the development and at no time shall the unit be used as transient rental. A deed restriction or covenant acknowledging the requirements contained in section 4.8.2b of the Lodestar Master Plan shall be recorded prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the unit. An on-site manager's unit shall be owned and maintained by the HOA for the development.

8:37 And shall not be otherwise sold or separated from the common area parcel. At least one enclosed parking space shall be provided for an on-site manager's unit and shall meet the town standards for parking space size. The maximum floor area for an on-site manager's unit shall be 1,200 square feet. An on-site manager's unit shall be constructed to be architecturally compatible with the remainder of the development. Compatibility includes the coordination of exterior colors, materials, roofing, other architectural features as appropriate in landscaping.

9:07 An on-site manager's unit shall at minimum contain a kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping area. Number two is that within development area two, allow single family residences to be subject to the following setbacks, 20 feet in the front, 10 feet on the sides, and then at no change is 20 feet along the rear. In section B.2, building separation, we've deleted the following sentence, single unit residential structures and planned unit development subdivisions within development area two shall have a minimum separation.

9:38 Between structures of 20 feet, which was already included as a part of the DZA 12-002. So on the basis of the analysis presented in the staff reporting resolution, staff makes the determination that the project meets the findings as required to approve the project. Those findings are as follows. The proposed project is consistent with the general plan. The project conforms the municipal code. The project is not detrimental to the public interest, health, safety, convenience, or welfare of the town.

10:10 The project is compatible with the surrounding area. The project is physically suitable and provides a functional relationship throughout the development of the master plan, and the project is consistent with CEQA. Staff recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission consider the addendum to the Loadstart Mammoth Master Plan Environmental Impact Report and adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, and approve District Zoning Amendment 15-001 with modifications to the amendment as recommended by staff at this public hearing.

10:41 I'm happy to answer any questions, and then I'd also note that we have both of our applicants, John Hooper and Eric Fishburne, here to answer questions as well. Commissioner Stein, do you have any questions at the moment? Can you go back to that first page, please? I'm sorry, to the actual... The amendments. Yeah, the revision, yes. Sure. You talked about here, with the exception, that the primary dwelling and secondary dwelling unit may both be rented simultaneously.

11:19 I thought we had a conversation earlier about this, that this was going to be modified. So we've gone back and forth about this several times with the applicant. And the most recent interpretation is that they may both be rented simultaneously, but not for transient rental purposes. But that the intent is that the accessory dwelling unit may function as a caretaker's quarter or a long-term rental unit.

11:49 Pursuant to whatever the owners are looking for, and that the primary unit could be used either as the owner's seasonal housing, primary housing, or as a transient rental. So there's a variety of options there, and dependent on how the commission feels, it may be appropriate to keep the allowance that they can be rented simultaneously or concurrently in the amendment.

12:16 And just to clarify, in this particular case, we're really talking about Phase 2 of Gray Bear 2. Correct. A lot from the northern section. Correct. And I think, so it's highlighted there, yeah, the northern parcel of Gray Bear 2. It's proposed that those accessory structures may be located on the northern side of the extension of East Bear Lake Drive. Okay. Commissioner Vanderhurst, do you have any quick questions? I don't at this time. Okay.

12:46 Maybe this is a good time to hear from our applicants.

13:32 The setback variance mainly applies to them. The one thing that I've seen over the last few years, and I've been here a long time, is that in Mammoth, there are no new homes under a million. When you're dealing with lot prices that are 200 to 400,000, it just doesn't exist. So, the reason for this amendment, at least as far as setbacks, the reverse setback to be 10, 10, 10 on the side, 20 in the front.

14:02 Is to create these smaller lots to create homes that are between about 1800 and 2100 square feet. They've been well received, four or five of them are reserved, and they're under a million, which doesn't exist in them. So I'm trying to create a market that probably won't be able to be addressed again. That was the main reason for the smaller lots. As far as a rear setback from the golf course being 10 feet, don't care.

14:32 It's 20, it's mainly for the smaller interior lots that we've created in phase one or two. That would be the reason for the setback variance on these smaller lots. The second which really isn't mentioned, it's very minor, the town standards require or allow for height limitation that increases from 35 feet to 40.

15:04 There's over 6 and 12 on my homes are. That's why I wanted town standards to be applied here. I have to get a height cert on everything I build and it's quite expensive. I don't know if that's part of what we're dealing with, but that's what I would request. That's what I thought it was requesting. The North side variance, so 50 feet to 10 feet, originally the 50 foot setback from a resort area would be, let's say, from a quiet residential area.

15:35 On the north side of phase two, which is what I call gray bear three, everything is on Main Street, and everything is high density. It's been there a long time. I don't see any reason why there's setbacks attempt now that I would be required, or this project would be required to have a 50 foot setback. If you're wondering about the accessory,

16:05 Structure, it's something I've been wanting to do for a long time and not been allowed because in a residential, extremely residential running area, you really can't allow, you're not allowed to build a second unit as a rental. What I was trying to do in the phase, to put the map up instead of the wording there. On that back area, those are going to be larger homes as seven lots and by creating an accessory structure,

16:40 It's really meant to be either a studio or a one bedroom. It could be a maid's quarters or a caretaker's quarters or a regular couple. It creates affordable housing. It was a great place to maybe create a caretaker's quarters. So that was the reason for the best restructuring.

17:21 There's another really good reason for the at least the setback variance is you've already done it. This is one of the four projects I'm bringing to you to approve. You've already approved the setback variance to town standards. I think in 2013 at Greystone. So I'm really here to answer your questions. It's pretty straightforward. So if you have any questions, I'd be glad to answer. Thank you, John.

17:56 Sandra, do you think it would be best if we address the Gray Bear portion of this separately from the Talos portion, or should we hear from the applicant of the Talos portion of the project? I think it's at the commission, the pleasure of the commission, however you'd like to do that. Okay. I think it would be helpful just to keep it all wrapped in together then, if we could hear from the applicant of the Talos project. Thank you, John.

18:43 We continue on building the house out as we originally conceived. A few small changes to it, but the key part concerning the setbacks is the gatehouse. When originally built, it was setback at 50 feet, which we understood that was setback in the street. And because we were rushing to market, trying to get our sales office and model home in, we used provision in the city ordinances that allowed us to do so. So we built the

19:15 Thank you very much.

19:56 Bill Raskin, Forest Wells, a second version. That, to us, that unit is a, the front gate is a key element of the overall design conceit. The original concept was a kind of told story about how the clubhouse was possibly an older estate with the gatehouse, and from that, the DNA of the architectural design and language was said used to build the rest of the sort of the underlying story. So.

20:30 Okay. Thank you, Eric. So with that being said, do you have any further questions for staff or for the applicant?

21:08 I think we'll start with the setbacks for Gray Bear. I don't have any further questions for staff on Gray Bear or the DZA. I do have a quick question for Mr. Fishburne and the TALIS project. Sorry to have you walk away. It had been mentioned, or I maybe had read it in the packet, that there was a proposed enclosed parking structure behind the proposed.

21:40 Caretaker's Unit, which is now the gatehouse. What would you foresee doing with the paved slab in the front that is currently parking? Got it. Thank you. That is my question.

22:26 Amy, did you? Thank you. Paul, did you have any questions? No, we have received some of these letters from neighboring HOAs. Is this something that we can have them also address during the public hearing or read the letters as some of the... I think we should address those as a part of the Gray Bear 2 project specifically because they relate to the extension of East Gray Bear.

23:02 Road, which is a design feature of the tentative tract map specifically and not a component of the DZA. So if it's all right, I would suggest that we address those public comments as are specific to the Gray Bear 2 project. Agenda item 2. So there were no comments about? With the exception of the Millers for the Talus project. Right. But I thought there were a couple comments that were specifically involved in sitbacks.

23:31 There are public comments from both Camille Miller and the mountain related to the DZA. And then the comments from San Joaquin Villas are related specifically to the Gray Bear tentative tract map project. Do you have any other questions regarding the DZA? No, not at this time. Okay. So, John, if you would mind stepping back up. I just have a question. So regarding the two interior lots, lots 24 and 25,

24:14 I believe. Yes. So can, or maybe this is a question, but for staff as well, can we clarify then how, since those lots don't have the golf course adjacent to it, how the revised setbacks would affect those lots in particular?

24:48 Yes, and when John was speaking earlier, I made a note that we actually need to revise the revised amendments to indicate that we're proposing to maintain the 20-foot setback on lots adjacent to the golf course along the rear and to allow a 10-foot setback according to RSF standards for lots interior to the project, as well as to allow the RSF height standards.

25:13 As well as the RSF height standards. Correct. Okay. So those are, if you'd like, I can add those to the text during the meeting, or we can just, at the conclusion, during the action items, we can just references modified by the discussion that we're having right now. Okay. I think for the sake of clarity, I think we're going to want to add it. By the text? Yeah. Okay. Definitely. Okay. And if you can...

25:49 Right. This is just a complicated. It is. Complicated amendment with a lot of components here. And I think anything we can do to make it as clear as possible would be very helpful. Okay. And then we have a clean draft to work off of. Okay.

26:24 John, is 20 feet, is that considered standard or industry norm for properties that do sit on a golf course? I don't know that. I know that our standards are 10 feet, at least in residential. I can't answer that question. I don't know. There are flight line setbacks that they are recorded, but they are not. We've stuck it.

27:12 Thank you. And so just to clarify then, there's no setback, change in setback requirement requested by the Talus project for the residential units. Correct. We only discussed the gatehouse, but I believe there was a change required for the maintenance garage as well? Correct. And I'll have Nolan walk through the changes to the Talus amendments. Correct.

27:44 New microphones here. The accessory structure setbacks for Talus would apply to the maintenance garage, the clubhouse, and the gatehouse manager's unit to allow those to be within 10 feet of the perimeter of the project and 20 feet from an arterial street. The setbacks with relation to the residential units, those units were originally considered

28:10 The property line adjacent to the golf course was considered a side yard setback in the 2004 project. Since it's a plan unit development project, they're not individual single family lots. So the front setback would be the meridian boundary. The rear would be the northern property. And then the western and eastern boundaries of the property would be side yard setbacks. Therefore, they're allowed 10-foot setbacks by the master plan.

28:46 And that's what was originally approved in 2004. Okay. Mr. Cooper, if you don't have the approval of the sitbacks, how would that affect your design? For the smaller lots? Correct. Probably a very awkward design, a much smaller home. How small? Now that it's, it works very well with about 1990.

29:40 2,100 feet of the designs that we have. And what's a lot of coverage on the, on those? Far less intense. Which is? Which is the setbacks are a little bit prohibitive on the interior parts. Right. You got 20 foot front, 20 foot back, that's fairly prohibitive. And all these are, I think, or the smaller ones. Right. Michael, any further questions at this time before we hear from the public? No, I'm ready to hear from the public. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, John.

30:23 Any members of the public that would like to speak regarding this item? Come on up. If you would please state your name. My name is Maxine. I believe the Commission has received my request. Plus you probably also received five or six other letters reiterating the same issues and concerns.

31:09 I really appreciate the time and, you know, the ability to come and share our concerns. St. Paul King-Villis sits on the northeast corner of the Great Bearer, the Great Heart of the Wolfstone, and it was originally designed as a housing authority for our housing workforce housing development back in 05-06.

31:39 In 2007, when the Housing Authority was trying to fill those residences, they weren't very successful in doing so, so we are not, San Jose Pinto is not a workforce housing development in our perspective. There are, of the 40 townhome units, there are only 16.

32:06 Affiliated with the Housing Authority. And all of those 16 are owner-occupied, except for one, which is a long-term rental, but they are renter-occupied full-time. The unit is sold at 100%. We've had turnover, and it's been turning over four statements very, very quickly.

32:35 We do currently have 22 units being lived in full time. So I know in the original road star master plan that we were considered an exclusion for setbacks and we received a very tiny setback around the perimeter of San Joaquin Villas, which is only 10 feet.

33:03 And I have to say that since 2007, we've certainly enjoyed the forest ambiance around our economy and humor project. And so therefore the development coming in, we do appreciate very, very much that these are high-end homes. It's definitely going to decrease the amount of nuisance.

33:33 The surrounding area. We've been actually enjoying a very nice, quiet area. I think the thing that is the biggest concern for most all owners is the extension of the East Bear Lake Road and the path that it's going to be taking.

34:03 We're very, very concerned that it's way too close to the buildings B and A, which are on the western edge of the San Joaquin Road. It's not easily clear to me when I look at the maps just how much. We know that we have 10 feet, and when the surveyor came through this summer and put his stakes in and said that that was the middle of the road,

34:38 We could easily measure and say that the road is going to be within an arm's reach of our setback. So we're asking the commission to consider the fact that people are, this is not a transient community at all. People are living in San Joaquin buildings 100% of the time. And in the two buildings, the A and B that are on the western edge.

35:05 of those 12 townhomes, there are 6 that are being lived in full time. So 50% of those townhomes have families living there. I'm thinking if we could be allowed to have a little bit more of a setback between

35:36 Our part of the line and where the road. It has one, two, three big S curves going right up to the building, rebuilding, around and back along the side, and then going west out to Minaret. That's the way it's drawn right now. And this is actually a brand new drawing. It hasn't been.

36:07 Visualize like this. We don't know if anybody ever did originally put in a road through that property. And so my request is that it get pushed back a little bit more. I would like to see 50 feet, but people have talked somewhere between 20, 25, 30, or 50 feet between us and the edge of the road, if at all possible. We, there's,

36:41 If the, you know, if they do make the rentals in those homes, we are going to see traffic surge. At night, we are going to see traffic and headlights right smack into our bedrooms and living rooms, right on our decks where people enjoy outdoors in the summertime. The other component of the map, I believe, showed a multi-use path. Am I correct?

37:13 Correct. You are correct. Yes. Okay. And it was originally stated to be along the northern edge of the new East Fair Lake Road, right? Correct. Yes. Okay. Which is even closer to, I mean, the path, the multi-use path, which would be like, where are you?

37:44 At the bottom of those decks. We would like to ask that that multi-use path be moved to the west and south of East Bear Lake Road. If you look at the current East Bear Lake Road, there is a multi-use path that is on the western side of that road. That road goes essentially east to west, north to south, and on the

38:15 The current path is on the west side. I'd like to propose that it stay on the west side as it comes around and goes north and then it comes on the south side of the road as the road goes east. Is that clear? Okay. We're going to have to ask you to wrap up. I'm sorry? We're going to have to ask you to wrap up. I'm sorry.

38:49 We're asking for an appropriate tall tree buffer between the road and San Joaquin Villas, which would be the S-curves, the big curves around there. Can I assume that you'll respond to all of our requests in some format? We'll have some time to discuss, and there will be some time for the applicant to respond once we get through the rest of public comment. Dust abatement is a critical issue for us.

39:28 With the current development that's already occurred, there was really nothing much downwind, but in phase two, you have 40 townhomes which are downwind, and the issue of cutting and clearing trees and building disturbing the soil, except we're very concerned about dust, and so we would want to enforce the

39:58 Abatement and medication for dust and dirt issues. The concern when you said that the environmental impact report is not affected by any of these constructions, it will seriously be affecting noise and dust for San Joaquin Villas. As it is through the last summer,

40:33 of the work that was already done, east of East Fair Lake Road, that noise was very, very apparent in our area. And this is going to be a lot closer to us. We're a little bit concerned about the hours going into 8 o'clock at night. I would request that

40:58 I know that there's a lot of daylight in the summertime, but we also have families, dinnertime, relaxation time, some comment about mitigation for us. Okay. Thank you very much. The zoning for rentals is going to cause perhaps some parking issues, and the last request I make is that perhaps the CCNRs

41:36 Thank you. Okay. Thank you very much. Is there anyone else from the public who would like to speak?

42:12 We would ask you to respect the five minutes per speaker. Thank you. Going forward. Could you say your name for the record, please? Thank you, Elliot. You asked a question. Yes. There is a goal. It does recommend variances, but mostly it asks a few within that union. Got it. Okay. Thank you for clarifying that. Thank you. Is there anyone else from the public? Tom? Good afternoon. My name is A. Mouse Reyes. I'm a property owner at 171 Lawrence.

43:01 Around property A and B. I'm here today to discuss this letter I wrote back in 2006 to the Pound Down Plates and to the project of Talos. And I'll read my letter. This is back in 2006 and then I'll explain what happened here. So we experienced flooding into our property due to snow melt.

43:31 We had a record stone path that year. It did damage our property. We believe that since Talos Project contractor has changed the grade and slope of the land adjacent to our property from Talos Project to Joaquin Road, the water now has taken a new path to drain to a low point, which would be our property, specifically our garage.

43:57 This is due to the construction and infrastructure of the TELUS project. We have been advised by our attorney just to write a letter and go on record about our concerns and problems we face with this drainage issue and see what can be done. Maybe a storm drain is already planned for this area. If not, some kind of storm drainage can be placed at a low point area by our property.

44:25 and thus incorporate into future plans for storm drainage. That would be the most sensible solution for all parties involved, especially if they plan on paving the road down from the TALUS project to the San Joaquin Road. The town of Mammoth Lakes has installed a storm drainage system not too long ago in this area. Okay, so the town of Mammoth Lakes, they were great.

44:56 After I wrote this letter, I had registered letters sent to Talos and to Mammoth. I met with staff from Mammoth Lakes. It was a code enforcer. He brought the plans showing me what the storm drainage was going to be developed. In 2006, Talos went bankrupt. Okay? So he told me, well, I'm sorry, there are probably just going to be a limbo now and nothing's going to be done.

45:25 So that's why I'm here to address this. Because now, they have the money, they're going to expand the development, and the storm drainage is supposed to go from the Tallis to the corner of the Dorrance and Joaquin. So I would just like to go on record for the townbound place in Tallis to see if anything can be done for putting in the storm drainage so it won't flood our property. Thank you.

45:55 Thank you. Thank you very much.

46:56 So I think I'll just, for the purposes of reading this in the record, you know, I'll read this letter. That'd be great.

47:25 To the Commission, this letter is submitted in connection with the Planning and Economic Development Commission's consideration of District Zoning Amendment 15001, Mammoth Master Plan Amendment 3. Mammoth Mount Scurriot LLC, MMSA submits these comments as, among other things, the operator of CRSR Golf Course, which sits within the Lowe Star Master Plan area. MMMSA opposed the adoption of Addendum Number 3 for the reasons set forth herein. MMMSA's primary objection to Addendum Number 3 arises from the proposal

47:55 To reduce setbacks for single-family residences, two-unit townhomes, and accessory structures. In short, the existing approved setbacks are already less than those indicated as necessary by the golf course architect. Approval of the data number three will place homes, townhomes, accessory structures, all of which are intended for use by residents, residents, and guests. Well, inside the golf course lifeline setbacks recommended by the golf course architect, creating a potentially unsafe situation, which puts owners, occupants,

48:25 Invitees, and Pete Carroll. The sequel analysis accompanying item number three is instructive. At page two of the analysis states that there is a required finding that the proposed addendum is not detrimental to the safety of the town. Despite this required finding, in no place does the sequel analysis consider the Gulf Coast Architect's recommendations on required flight line setbacks or the relationship to Gulf Coast flight lines.

48:50 Rather, the analysis simply concludes that there is no negative impact of safety because the revised development standards will allow for development of more density and was approved for this area. This is a complete non-sequitur. Were the density reduced to one unit, that reduction in density would be irrelevant to the question of safety if the unit was built in the middle of the seventh hole. This is perhaps an extreme example, but the point stands. Placing inhabitant structures even closer to the Gulf Forest fairways than already approved

49:19 There is no meaningful analysis of this issue in the town's CEQA discussion. That's part of the addendum that you're considering. Based on the foregoing, should the town of Mammoth Lakes prove addendum number three? It does so with the knowledge that it is acting contrary to the adult course flight line setbacks created by the course architect in doing so without any analysis underlying that decision.

49:47 It is obviously inappropriate to replace a noted golf course architect's recommendation with the town's unowned, unsupported, and unanalyzed conclusions that no safety issues created thereby. Accordingly, as a golf course operator, MMSA will hold the town responsible for any injuries or damage that occurs as a result and will seek equitable indemnity against the town and any pertinent developers should any related action be brought against MMSA. So I have submitted an email that's sent to

50:16 So again, our point is that the secret analysis is inadequate as it's in your staff report currently that you're considering that it didn't consider public safety.

50:45 In any fashion in order to address any of the issues with respect to setbacks. I understand there's, I had a meeting with staff this morning at 10 o'clock and the applicants to discuss this issue. There was some further discussion, some other things went on afterwards. I'm not party to. There's some proposed modifications to the language of the setbacks. I'm not completely clear on what is being proposed. It's hard for me to sit here and digest what you guys threw out there.

51:14 One thing I want you guys to understand is that the decision you're making now applies to the whole Area 2. Okay, we're considering, you're considering subdivision maps specifically for graveyard 2 and Talos, but there are other properties within Area 2 that are affected by this amendment as well. So any confusion that you guys create by approving this or any unintended consequences that may occur, I don't think have been considered. So I feel that because of this issue, unfortunately, you know, the staff report wasn't published

51:44 One other point we like to make to you guys

52:13 We would like to go on record as non-addressed in this letter. However, for the public record, we feel that the CEQA analysis is also inadequate on the grounds that it does not analyze the negative economic impact on the community, the continued approval of these projects at low agencies that won't specify the low-star master plan. We feel that that needs to be addressed in some form of fashion in the CEQA analysis that has made in the product.

52:44 Those are our points. Thank you. Thank you very much, Tom. Thank you, Tom. Are there any other comments from the public? Actually, John, you'll have an opportunity in just a moment to respond to the public comments, but I just want to make sure there's nobody else in the public that would like to speak before we close the public comment period. Okay. So, John, thank you.

53:47 Of course, then we're in compliance with exactly what's in, what's the law is not on the 25th day. I mean, that's 25 foot front, 25 foot rear. So, if we're willing to do that on the golf course, then we've addressed Tom's concerns. I'd also like to point out that, you know, it's almost a threat of a lawsuit because you're not adhering to flight lines. Boy, Mammoth Mount known as this property when these flight lines existed.

54:20 And they chose never to record them. If they have one project where they are recorded, that would be Solstice 2, which became Greystone. I have a project that was approved where they are not recorded and we adhere to the 20-foot setback. That was right there. So I'm a little confused about whether or not you're required to adhere to flight line setbacks. You aren't. If they're recorded, I would think that you wouldn't be. But in this case, I just don't think you are.

54:51 Thank you. Amy, if you would like, sorry to interrupt, would you like me to review, as Tom requested, because I think it's difficult to digest so quickly, what exactly the revised proposed amendments are since this morning's meeting? Yeah, I think that would be very helpful. Okay, let's go back to the slide. It is a working document as of today.

55:28 So at the meeting this morning, we met with the applicants and Tom as a representative of the Mountain to talk about their concerns related to the setbacks specifically adjacent to the golf course. And as a result of that meeting, we essentially eliminated the request for a reduction to the rear setbacks adjacent to the golf course.

55:55 So the 20-foot setbacks that are presented in this revision are what's in the master plan right now. So that's not an amendment from what's currently existing. The only change which is specific to interior lots would be a 10-foot setback for lots on interior to the project. So that could, and that, again, applies only to single-family structures on single-family lots.

56:21 Right now in Lodestar Area 2, that's specific to Gray Bear 2. There is one undeveloped parcel in Area 2, which is currently owned by Terry Plum. If he constructed single-family structures on single-family lots,

56:39 He would be required to comply with the current rear setback of 20 feet adjacent to golf courses, but would also then be allowed for lots interior to the project, which may not be adjacent to the golf course, a 10-foot rear setback. And that 10-foot rear setback is consistent with what we do on other single-family lots across town. And then there was some analysis done on TALUS after that meeting as well, and Nolan can speak in more detail to that, but essentially that research showed

57:09 That the 10-foot setback on Talus adjacent to the golf course was considered to be a side yard setback because for planned unit developments, the setbacks are considered for the project as a whole. So that 10-foot setback was not considered to be a rear setback, it was considered to be a side setback. And that interpretation was considered and approved by the Planning Commission at the time of the original Talus approval back in 2004. So do you need, is there any further clarification that you need on that?

57:38 The setbacks issue. It's hard to get an orientation to understand. Really, it's hard to visualize. There's a lot of numbers being thrown around here. Especially for the just a lot of movement. You're saying the rear setback technically is not a rear setback, but it's a size. For TALIS. For TALIS specifically because it's a PUD.

58:02 Style development. Sure. The setbacks were considered in a different way than they are for single family structures on single family lots. And so we discovered going back to the earlier project approvals that that's how that 10 foot setback was approved adjacent to the golf course in that location. Okay. So just in summary for, we'll get to you just a second, Tom. For the Gray Bear 2 project, the applicant is requesting

58:28 So those are only for single family?

58:58 And that's only for single-family structures on single-family lots. Thank you. Okay. Tom, did you have another comment? Yeah, you wouldn't mind. I don't, yeah, in this case, that's... So, you know, it's, again, it's, you know, I think John's intention. You know, I'm just hesitant to encourage you guys that if you're not comfortable at this, that maybe you continue the discussion. But, for example, you know, where do you interpret it as a side versus a rear? You know, I...

59:43 My concern is setback at the golf course, period. I don't care whether it's a side yard or a rear yard or a flat yard. So, you know, to me, depending on how Terry Plump, for example, chooses to develop his site in the future, there may be an instance where his lot, if you look at that property of a piece where it wraps around the eighth green, there may be a boundary on that potential lot there that they would consider society.

1:00:13 Development and all of a sudden, he's saying, hey, I don't have to be 10 feet. Am I lying? Well, no, because now we've got to make clear, you guys understand, is the recommended flight line setbacks from the Gulf Force Architect, in many cases, are greater than even the 20 feet that are specified in the plan. So, we already have a bad situation, and, you know, this is a little more complicated than, I think, than all that's going to be recognized. I know well enough to know that

1:00:43 I think that there's confusion. I mean, no one's already trying to clarify what happened in the quarrel with Talos and why it was at 10 foot. I'm a little unclear. There's some purported communication with the architect. In no instance in this particular sequel analysis and report for what you're considering today, was there any discussions with the golf course architect to talk about this issue specifically.

1:01:11 I think it's incumbent upon the town and their due diligence to do a thorough sequel analysis because this is a concern that they should be consulting with Bell Force Architect to thoroughly understand the issue. So I feel like there's just not enough information available to you today to make a legitimate decision. And as I've stated, we feel like you've disturbed the sequel process in this particular issue. One other thing I'll point out to you is that you cannot

1:01:37 As I understand it, you're not going to be able to approve the tentative tract maps for even these projects without first approving these amendments to the master plan. So, you know, we're kind of going to be a lawyer here because I honestly don't feel you guys have grounds to approve the amendment. Thank you, Tom. Thank you. Just, can I ask staff a question really quick? Please. The previous developments along the golf course that Mr. Hooper had mentioned, are those 20-foot setbacks?

1:02:08 There are several projects, Talus and Greystone, including, which have been approved for 10-foot setbacks adjacent to the golf course. And those were approved with similar... Can you just repeat that, please? There are projects, Talus, the original Talus project, as well as Greystone, which is a single-family project in Development Area 5, which were approved for 10-foot rear or side yard setbacks as applicable adjacent to the golf course.

1:02:34 With similar or exactly the same CEQA analysis as we've done now. And we have discussed that CEQA analysis with the town attorney. And he is comfortable and is in support of the analysis that has been completed for the project. Just to kind of rack your memory a little bit, do you remember if there was a conversation about the flight line when that setback was modified to 10 from 20 originally? For Greystone.

1:03:06 Graystone would be the one I'm interested about. Well, so flight lines are, they are recognized as a part of the overall master plan and development project. Unfortunately, those flight lines in many cases were never recorded or codified. And so in some circumstances where they haven't been recorded or codified, you know, it's recommended that construction occur behind those flight lines, but it's not required.

1:03:35 By the master plan or the code. Got it. Thank you. Okay. Absolutely. Please. Yes.

1:04:20 Thank you. Okay. So just so I'm kind of clear on the procedure here, Sandra, the first course of action will be to consider the DZA and then

1:05:05 The second and third course of action will be to consider the track maps for the two different projects. When we consider the track maps for the two different projects, assuming we get through the first point of discussion, is that when we can start to talk about the issues with the road at Grey Bear 2 and the issues with the multi-use path at Talus? Yes. That's correct. This one. Yes.

1:05:46 So, again, it's a phone record for a phone conversation on a plan that's prepared by Cal, it's not by Cal Wilson. So, you know, it may be valid data, I don't know, but the flight lines that I have from Cal Wilson that I've provided to you guys show our competitors will see. So, again, nobody can talk about Cal Wilson in these projects in the last few months. I spoke with them yesterday. And so,

1:06:16 You know, I just think there's a lack of clarity here, honestly. And, you know, another point I would think to you guys is that, you know, if something was done back then and it was done incorrectly, you know, it'd be too wrong to make a right. You know, if we move ahead and go, oh yeah, well, he proved it last night, even though it was wrong, we'll do it again. I don't know. One other point, and I brought this up to the applicant today when we met, is why can't we just move his development back to him?

1:06:44 You know, is there not, it looks like there's enough room to make it work. You know, why can't we at least exercise that alternative and understand the implications of what that would be? You know, they've got the road in, they've got the parking. Which one are you, are you talking about Talos at the moment? Talos specifically. Okay. And I haven't seen the discussion, maybe the amount of care on that, but again, it's just the last minute and, you know, have we had enough time in advance to look at this stuff because we need to analyze these things a little more early, but

1:07:14 You know, I don't get wrong, you know, we support these, these developments, you know, with respect to providing some transient event base, but, but same token, you know, rush to do a decision, we make some wrong, like I say unintended consequences, it's very complicated, trying to understand these, what the implications of all these specific setbacks are, and I just feel like at this point, there's been so many modifications being proposed here at the last minute, it's inappropriate to. Thank you. Thank you.

1:07:53 No further comment from the applicants. Do we close the public hearing at this point? Okay, and then we can begin deliberation and questions. Okay, so at this point we'll close the public hearing and this is time for us to deliberate and ask questions. So I think it might be helpful, Ruth, if we can go through talking about it amongst ourselves in the order of your proposed amendments that you had up on the screen. Okay.

1:08:29 Let's see if I can get back to that. So again, based on what you received in the published staff report on Friday, there's been no modifications to the proposals related to accessory structures. You said there have not been? There have not been any revisions. Okay. The revisions are focused only on, oh here, let me make that, yeah. The revisions are limited.

1:09:02 to the discussion on setbacks. Okay. And so we did two things. We allowed reduced setbacks for interior lots only, lots adjacent to the golf course or still required to comply with the typical rear yard setbacks. And then we excluded talus from the setbacks discussion entirely because we discovered that

1:09:31 The 10-foot setback adjacent to the golf course in Tallis is because setbacks are interpreted for PUDs differently and that that was considered to be a side yard and not a rear yard. So Tallis was removed from the discussion related to setbacks entirely and no revisions to setbacks for the primary structures in Tallis are being considered right now. And again, this is all for single-family homes in Zone 2. Correct.

1:10:03 So the only discussion related to setbacks here is for single-family structures on single-family lots and development areas. And maybe I should note as well that we did discuss all of these revisions with the town attorney subsequent to making the changes and prior to the meeting. And he's comfortable with the changes and in support of the direction that staff is taking. Okay. So we've made some changes since...

1:10:40 You've made some changes here during the meeting. Correct. Yes, you're right. As well as to the height. That would be the other addition that we made. Which is just essentially saying single family structures on single family lots are also subject to the single family height limitations that apply in the municipal code. Okay. Clarification. I think it would, I think really that you should separate out the height component. Okay. Just to make it a separate.

1:11:12 Just a separate topic, or a separate bullet point. Should we start by any comments or discussion about the secondary structures? We'll just go in order. I think that the one concern I had about that amendment was with the gatekeeper unit slash caretaker unit with TALIS that's in the master plan, but knowing that that parking structure is going to be behind the unit,

1:11:50 And not in front of the unit makes me a little bit more comfortable with that situation. Is it possible to get that written into? Is it already written into the tract map for the TALIS? Nolan. Proposal? Yes, for TALIS it does show the location of the enclosed garage on the rear of the gatehouse structure. Thank you, Nolan. That was my main concern with the accessory facilities and buildings. Did you have any issues? Paul?

1:12:29 We're going to go down bullet points. Is that kind of your thought? Yes, yes. No, I don't have any issue with the secondary unit, the accessory housing for that. So this first, the first item involves a change in the setback from the arterial street. It involves modification setbacks for accessory structures only along the perimeter of the project, which are identified here.

1:13:09 Okay. So it allows for 10-foot setbacks for accessory structures. And then that does include the 20-foot setback from arterial streets, which was 100 feet. 20 feet is consistent with what a street side yard setback is for residential areas for all development. So in this particular case, we're asking to change the setback from 100 feet from the arterial street to 20 feet. That's correct. The TALUS project...

1:13:42 The building is currently at 50, so it won't be at 20, but for other projects, if there is adjacent to an arterial street, it would be 20 feet just to be consistent with what those residential standards are. But that's a residential standard, that's a standard for a residential building on a residential lot. Correct, that's the... That doesn't really fit the case here if I'm understanding that. This is an accessory structure on a much larger PUD lot.

1:14:14 That is correct. We applied that standard to be consistent with what would be in other residential areas. If up to the commission you prefer, we could amend that to 50 feet. I don't believe it impacts any other projects within Development Area 2, since this is the only project that is adjacent to an arterial street within Development Area 2. Correct. I personally would be more comfortable if that, if we reduce the,

1:14:56 Change the setback, that setback on the arterial street from 100 to 50 rather than 100 to 20. And if there's consensus among the commission, I can make that change right now. And the current structure sits 50, you said, Nolan? Correct. There is an exhibit on the TALUS map that does show where the setbacks of the current structure are. Okay. I'm fine with that modification. Okay.

1:15:32 Commissioner Chang? How would that affect the design of... It really won't affect them at all. It just, in my mind, it could prevent further development within 20 feet of the arterial street moving forward. So it won't, it doesn't affect really anything insofar as what Talus has proposed.

1:15:57 In their tentative tract map. But this only applies to Development Area 2. This is only applying to Development Area 2 and this particular clause. No other development areas within the LMP. Correct. Yes, no other sites are adjacent to an arterial street either. Arterial streets are really the major thoroughfares in town and the Talus portion is the only one adjacent to that. Okay. I certainly would agree to it. Okay, great. Any comments regarding

1:16:29 Occupancy, what is it, simultaneous, simultaneous occupancy for, or renting of accessory structures. And if I remember right, you guys decided to maybe back that language out with the idea of that one, if there's two structures on a lot, one is a long-term rental and the other one would be a short-term rental. Is that kind of what I heard? I think we could ask the applicant if he would be amenable to that. And as a resort.

1:17:04 Zoning District, so there's a little more flexibility implied in a resort zoning district than we would typically apply to a residential area if both units wanted to be rented transiently, so we left the flexibility in there, but if the commission was interested and the applicant agreed, we could discuss having a limitation that concurrent rentals allowed as long as

1:17:32 You know, one rental was long-term and one was transient. Would you mind if... Do you have any feeling either way about that? Actually, if it's acceptable, I'd love to hear Mr. Hooper, if he has a thought on that. Sorry. John, can you come up to the podium, please? That's all? Okay. So he agreed, so it's... Okay. Commissioner Chang?

1:18:04 So just so we're clear, so what I'm proposing is that if there are two structures on one lot, they cannot be concurrently being rented out on a nightly basis. One has to be a long-term rental, and the other one can be a short-term or nightly rental. Okay. Commissioner Chang, any thoughts on that? You know, my initial concern was, you know, when I saw the war simultaneously, I was thinking more of it on a TOT basis.

1:18:41 If we can change it to that, I think that's okay. I just want to make sure that we're on the same page, that no one from the public is asking for this to be changed. So it's just a question of do we feel that we want to change it? From my perspective, these are already greatly reduced density lots in a resort zone. I don't have any problem with both...

1:19:10 You know, an accessory structure being rented simultaneously to the primary structure. These are very, they're really large lots. Well, when I first initially read this, I thought you had to rent both units at the same time. You can't separate them. Oh, I don't think that's the intention. The language... That may not be the intention, but I just, when I read it, I just, and it just says, may both be rented simultaneously.

1:19:40 So there's a difference between simultaneously and together and simultaneously but separate. And we included may language so that there was the option of concurrent or simultaneous rental. Okay. And my understanding is that they could be rented simultaneously but separately. Correct. At different, you know, basically, essentially treating them as two properties, they just happen to be on the same lot. And that's fine. Yeah.

1:20:10 I certainly don't like me again. Okay. Does that make sense, Michael? The reason I brought it up was it might help alleviate some of the concerns with congestion and noise with the neighbors. Because mainly we're talking Gray Bear 2, Phase 2. Yes. So, and that was one of the concerns brought by the lady from the San Joaquin Villas was the coming and going of multiple renters.

1:20:42 I'm wondering if that might be something that we can help. I see. I understand what you're saying. In my view, the proposed lot division on the Phase 2 of Gray Bear is such that the density is much lower than what could otherwise be proposed and built there. I really don't see it as being any different than a multifamily residential development being built, which it's currently zoned for.

1:21:13 It doesn't seem to me like it's an unreasonable request. Okay. So may I ask, is the consensus to leave the language as written? I can live with the language as written. Okay. Okay, moving on to the next one. Accessory structures approved as on-site manager's units shall be subject to the following limitations.

1:21:48 An on-site manager's unit shall be used exclusively by an on-site manager or other employee of the development, and at no time shall the unit be used as a transient rental. A deed restriction or covenant acknowledging the requirements contained in section 4A to B of the master plan shall be recorded prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the unit. Any comments or concerns? I don't. I don't have any comments or concerns with that one. Is this considered an affordable unit?

1:22:23 Or is this something that the company owns and basically it's a company property? This will be company owned or owned by the HOA for exclusive use of an employee of the TALIS project. So once the development's done, the HOA will take over and now the HOA will own that particular unit? At some point in the future, the HOA, yes, will own that unit and the deed restriction will

1:22:57 be recorded to restrict that use. So that does carry on with whether it's the current project applicant or the HOA that owns it. Just out of curiosity, were there any feedbacks from any of the homeowners as to the location of that particular type of unit setting in front of the area of the project? We have not received any. But presumably they were all

1:23:31 Noticed. They were noticed. Okay. I don't think I have any particular other comments or questions. Do you feel, is that something you feel comfortable with then? You can move forward. Initially I wasn't too comfortable about it just because of seeing either a manager unit or a slash affordable unit in front of such a prestige, expensive, multi-million dollar project.

1:24:17 It's an idea that I wasn't used to, but if none of the homeowners have any issue with that particular design, I certainly don't have any issue with that. Related directly to Talos as well, in the comments I gave you, the applicant did provide some other examples of gatehouse structures and kind of his original vision for the project, which

1:24:46 I had this gatehouse and clubhouse as part of the overall project. So that'll be discussed further during the talus portion. Okay. So I feel like the rest of these all sort of fall into line of what we were just discussing. The ownership, the parking, floor area, construction materials and design, and the amenities.

1:25:24 Which, to me, all are reasonable for a manager's unit. I agree. Okay, so I think then, with the exception of the change to 50 feet in that very first portion, we've got consensus on number one. So we'll move on to the tricky one here, number two. I have to admit, I'm a little... I understand what, I think, where everyone's trying to go with this, but...

1:26:05 I think seeing some of this a little bit more visually with respect specifically to the Talus Project and the vacant parcels to the north of the Talus Project and then being able to sort of visually see the differences between the types of lots we're talking about in the Gray Bear 2 Project would be really helpful. I understand that what Tom was saying about

1:26:37 Yeah, as of yet undeveloped parcels in the development area too. And what's the different definition of a side street versus a front street and the rear street? And their primary concern being the proximity or the setbacks along the golf course. But I think we need to think very carefully about the language. I just, I don't know that I'm entirely comfortable.

1:27:15 Without some further study of it all. Are you proposing a continuation, Amy? Is that kind of what you're thinking? That's definitely something that we could consider. What are your feelings? What are your thoughts? Sandra, schedule-wise, if we did continue this, where would it fit back into our schedule in terms of Planning Commission?

1:27:50 We would recommend continuing it to a date certain so we don't have to re-notice the project and you could consider it at your February meeting, which I think is February 10th. 10th? Yes, February 10th. Okay. And do you think that would give you, staff, and the applicants enough time to provide greater detail and clarification? Yes. For this particular component? Yes.

1:28:22 Do you think there would be time to organize some sort of a site visit for Commission? Yes, we can do that as well. So we could physically see what we're considering? Mm-hmm. I think that would be a good idea. Should we, um, would either of the applicants for TALIS or Gray Bear 2, would there be strong opposition to a continuance for a month? I probably don't care because I don't want, because I'll do respect the other, again, Tom, I don't, TALIS and my project be dramatic.

1:29:07 Right. Do you think that having the meeting will give the public enough time to analyze the amendment itself? I mean, we would be...

1:29:59 Well, so I think what Sandra is saying is that if we continue to a certain date, this serves as notification to the public that that is the decision and that we'll re-hear the project again at our next meeting. I just want to make sure, I mean, that's considered the timeline that we have is sufficient for the public to provide more feedbacks or...

1:30:27 And really consider this. I mean, after all, we did only have less than five days to review this particular process. It's not like this is a variance request. I mean, we're talking about zoning amendment here. I think it's certainly our responsibility as commissioner and as a town that we really think through this topic carefully. Amy, can I ask, are there specific considerations that we might address?

1:30:58 Now are specific questions we might address for the benefit of the applicant to try to sort through some of what you might be looking for us to analyze further. We did exclude Talus from the proposed amendment. I think, okay, I guess what I'm primarily just not comfortable with, I'm sorry, I'm just reading it again. That's fair. And it's a little small. What I heard was that the commission would like to have a site visit.

1:31:57 And that the commission would like to see these items visually. So on the maps, show how this language would affect the entire area development area. So show where the setbacks would be 20 feet, show where they would be 10. That's what I heard from the commission. That would be very helpful. Is it appropriate for me to make a motion right now? It's at your pleasure. I would like to make a motion that we continue.

1:32:25 Action Item 1, the DZA for a month into the February meeting, and in between now and the February meeting, we organize a site visit for the Planning Commissioners and the public as well to take a look at what we're considering, take a look at some of the different modifications that are being considered, the setbacks, the flight lines, all those things. Can I just ask a question? Yes.

1:32:55 Is it possible to separate out some of the elements of this DZA and approve portions of it now and continue portions of it to the next meeting? I think we could consider modifying this request and then doing a secondary essentially application number in February. I just don't know if that makes any sense at all from your perspective.

1:33:30 If I may, I think it's probably more appropriate to look at this DZA as a whole versus trying to dissect the individual items and trying to approve something today and look at something else because there's something that we might not be, there might not be unintended consequences by just looking at one specific, approving specific item today and not the others. And I think the

1:34:00 The item that's tied specifically to the Gray Bear 2 project, which is the request for reduction in front and side setbacks in Lodestar Area 2 for single family structures on single family lots, if that's the item that's going to be continued and that's the item specifically tied to the applicant's request, then there's no point in maybe approving the other things and continue with that one separately. Okay. Are you talking about agenda number two?

1:34:29 So you're saying we'll just keep it together? Okay. So is there a second for the motion? There's a motion on the floor. I second that. Okay. So then we will continue this discussion. We'll roll. Oh, wait. Sorry. Okay. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Rayek? Yes. So motion passes. Motion passes. We then move to the agenda item three.

1:35:24 So, that's a really good question. I think we can open item two, at least for public comment. Okay. So then we'll move on to... Sorry, and just as a note, I believe item two can be approved contingent on the approval of the DZA, but we may open some discussion with the applicant. If he's no longer interested in being a party to that DZA, then we could modify that action item. Okay.

1:36:07 Okay. So we'll move on to item number two. Consider approval of Gray Bear 2, tentative tract map 15-003, and use permit application 15-003, a 32-lot single-family subdivision that would allow transient rentals, including finding the project consistent with addendum number three to the Lodestar at Mammoth Environmental Impact Report. The subject properties are located at 1,001 and 1,501 East Bear Lake Drive.

1:36:47 No, presentation by staff. Oh, sorry. Okay. So the development proposal is a tentative tract map for a new single-family 32-lot subdivision in Development Area 2 of the Lodestar Master Plan. Transient use of the single-family residences is also proposed, which requires a use permit under the master plan. The project site is located along the western and northern sides of East Bear Lake Drive. The property has not been previously entitled.

1:37:12 Great Bear 1, currently entitled and under construction, is located to the east of East Bear Lake Drive and has been approved for 12 single-family residences that may also be used on a transient basis. The proposal is to subdivide the approximately 10.78-acre site into two phases. Phase 1 is the southern parcel and will be subdivided into 25 lots, and Phase 2 is the northern parcel, which will be subdivided into 7 lots. The lots range between 8,045 square feet.

1:37:43 and 38,919 square feet with the majority of the larger lots located on the northern parcel. I had described some the previous district zoning amendment which was tied to this project and I think we'll need to open up some discussion with the applicant as to how to address that as a part of this map approval and consider whether he would like to move forward with the map with modifications removing the tie to the DZA or whether he would still like approval

1:38:14 contingent on that potential DZA. Another component of the project is the extension of East Bear Lake Drive, which will provide access to Phase 2 and will be continued through Lots 26 to 32 as a private road easement to be maintained by the Gray Bears Homeowners Association. Bearclaw Lane and Bearclaw Court are also private road easements maintained by the Gray Bear Homeowners Association. Public comment from property owners in San Joaquin Villas have been received by staff and have been distributed to the commission for consideration.

1:38:44 The road alignment and multi-use path location have been prescribed by the Lodestar Master Plan and other adopted town documents since the origination of that master plan. And while staff does not necessarily recommend relocation of the extension of East Bear Lake Drive, it is recommended that a visual and or noise barrier, as approved administratively by the town, be located so as to mitigate impacts of the vehicle traffic. And this could be added as a condition to the approving resolution.

1:39:09 Based on recent comments from the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, staff also recommends the addition of a condition to the resolution which would require snow removal as a part of the maintenance of the emergency egress location within San Joaquin Villas. So on the basis of the analysis presented in this report and the resolution, staff makes the determination that the project meets the findings as required to approve the project. Those findings are as follows. The proposed project is consistent with the general plan. The project conforms to the municipal code. The project conforms to the Lodestar Master Plan.

1:39:39 The project conforms to the Subdivision Map Act, and the project is consistent with CEQA. Staff recommends that the Commission move forward with Option 1, as described in the Staff Report, and adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required Municipal Code findings, adopt the required Subdivision Map Act findings, and this last approval recommendation may need to be modified again, dependent on direction provided by the applicant, but approve tentative tract map 15003.

1:40:09 And use permit 15003, with modifications to the conditions as recommended by staff at this public hearing and subject to approval by Town Council of District Zoning Amendment 15001 by March 31, 2016, without which a tentative tract map and use permit will be deemed denied. And so that last component, which ties the approval of this map to the DZA, could be modified if the applicant chooses not to move forward with his request for modified setbacks. Okay.

1:40:40 Thank you. Mr. Hooper?

1:41:33 Let me, I'll be really brief here because this is a continuation of four projects. There was a Greystone, Greystone, it was, I think it was a lot in front of me in 2013, it was a seven-lot subdivision, it was Nightly Reynolds, first project, second was Grey Bear, 12-lot subdivision, Nightly Reynolds, and Grey Bear 2 is two phases, I can really consider Grey Bear 2 and 3, but you would consider it Grey Bear 2 and 3.

1:42:10 They do the same thing. Very complicated. The reasons for doing it are the same. You've got, especially after Proposition Z, you've got some of the only legal nightly rentals to bring in TOT, their single-family loans, in Mammoth, which was the reason for dealing with Graystone. Really, another reason is, I've been told many times that property tax doesn't really affect Mammoth, but I could probably

1:42:48 Some of it probably trickles down to us and we're creating that. The main benefit to me of a project like this is the same as the first two, which is we've created 6080 jobs since 2013 and with the approval of this project, there are a few families involved in that too. And with the approval of this project, we can continue that for two or three years. There's not much activity in Mammoth and this seems to be well received. I was actually going to mention that the smaller lots will be

1:43:18 While we see, that may go by the wayside. The lot still exists. There'll be different homes for them. I'm really, again, just here to answer any questions you have. I've heard some concerns that were mentioned by the San Joaquin folks that were actually mentioned. The master plan amendment that happened with this project. I would defer to staff on the location of the road. I can't tell you that we moved that road down 50 feet from the North property line.

1:43:51 And therefore, the headlight concern actually is decreased. It would have been involved in units up on the north end of the San Joaquin area. So we've actually decreased headlight depth. I will tell you that this road has been in a sense in the same place it is now on four different plans to staff and verify for a long time.

1:44:29 The path is always a amusement across the 2 parcels that are in between. The area between San Joaquin and the extension. So, I'm actually just here to answer your question. The project is. Thank you. Do you have any questions?

1:45:05 No, I'm good right now. Paul, do you have any questions? This is just a quick design question. When I drove down east, Gray Bear, I noticed some of these trees are super, super closed within the interest of the actual building itself. Does that pose any

1:45:41 Danger to the property itself? Building of the homes or building of the well-rapped? The homes. Just... Are you asking about that? Historically, I see trees. I see. Now I've designated 52 large trees on this property. Oh, white clients that have been there a long time. I just designate them not to be disturbed and build them. I build up that one too.

1:46:16 Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Greyhack, may I ask John a question before we present an option that we haven't discussed yet? Yes. We thought there might be an opportunity to separate out the DZAs so that the district zoning amendments to the Ludstar Master Plan so that John's project would be subject or contingent

1:46:53 upon approval of a DZA specific to your project only, which could reduce those rear yard setbacks to 10 feet, allow the height standards as allowed by the single family zoning district, and reduce those front and side setbacks that would be specific to your project only, if that was something the commission and the applicant were interested in seeing, ultimately so that the original design of your project wasn't compromised.

1:47:22 I would ask a question then. As far as the amendment's concerned, if it's possible, and I don't know procedurally if this is an option or not, but my project will work with or without the amendment. Is it possible to either approve or deny the project with or without the amendment? Because to change the setbacks to 20 foot in the rear is about the only.

1:47:55 The thing that I was concerned about. For the interior lots. For the interior lots. I thought that, so, I don't know procedurally how that would work, but I don't care about the amendment. If it happens to be approved, then God bless it, and I can apply to my project. But if it doesn't, I'm fine with that too. So then my suggestion would be to approve the map subject to the current Lodestar master plan.

1:48:24 Standards, and then come forward with the DZA that would then go back and modify it. But essentially you'd have the map with the existing LOADSTAR standards, and then if a DZA were approved, it would then retroactively apply to that map, but the map wouldn't be subject to it. But no changes would be necessary to this map either way. The map can be approved as stands.

1:48:53 Excuse my confusion, but we've been through this once with Graystone and nobody has a problem with it. Nobody has a problem with it. Nobody has a problem with it. We have a problem with it. Do we do setbacks? And suddenly they become a problem. They don't have to. If that's an option that I would set. Okay. So we can remove the DZA language from this item. From the track map. From the track map.

1:49:24 Because you're really just approving, the commission would really just be considering approval of lots, not homes, not setbacks, not anything. You're really just approving a map showing subdivision of land. Okay. So there's no adoption of CEQA findings and also the municipal findings, right? Yes. Yes, we still have two. Because we have four items in here. Right. So the first two will be eliminated.

1:49:55 No, I think you're saying that all we would remove is the language relating to the district zoning amendment. Correct. So I think we'd want to clarify, so in item four it would read, approved tentative tract map 1503 and use permit 1503 with modifications to conditions as recommended by staff and subject to the current standards in the Lodestar Master Plan. I think just in light of...

1:50:22 Okay. The things that the meeting and the way the application was originally presented, it might be beneficial to clarify that point. Sandra? I don't know if we have to clarify it because it is subject to the current Lodestar Master Plan right now. Whether we say anything about it or not is subject to the Master Plan. And then if a DZA was approved, subsequently it could apply to this parcel. But right now, if this tentative map was approved, it would be subject to the current Lodestar Master Plan. Right. Okay.

1:50:54 Commissioner, do you have any questions of staff or the applicant? No, no on this one. I don't, no. No questions? Actually, I do have a really quick one. John, is it, I'm sorry, is it your responsibility to put in the light and noise abatement tree line along the property line with the San Joaquin Villas? I don't particularly want to talk to the bottom of the property. Okay.

1:51:31 Thank you. Thank you, John. So you're referring to the eastern property line of the northern parcel.

1:52:05 Okay. Is there language in the conditions of approval about that already, or is that something we would have to add? I'm sorry, could you repeat the question? Is there language in the approval about the applicant supplying the tree line or the... I don't remember that. ...for the light and noise abatement for the S-turns on the northern parcel of Phase 2?

1:52:36 There is. So that was included in the discussion in my presentation. And then as a part of number four of the recommended action, it says as modifications to the conditions as recommended by staff. So what we'll require is either landscaping or fencing as approved administratively by the town that will reduce noise and visual impacts to the San Joaquin Villas from the road. Okay. Does the word fencing have to be included?

1:53:03 It's an and or situation, landscaping and or fencing. And is that as specific as we would need to get? Or do we need to, should we specifically reference that eastern property line of the northern parcel? I think we're referencing the impacts from the road to the San Joaquin Villas. Hayes, do you have a comment on that? That just seems sort of a vague statement that could be taken to mean a lot of different things.

1:53:33 We can clarify the location? Right. So we can, so as a part of this discussion, and it's really just the wording and the actions is modified, you know, by staff at this public hearing. So, okay, as a part of this discussion, yes, we're acknowledging that the location of that mitigation will be on the westerly property boundary of the San Joaquin Villas or the easterly property boundary of Grey Bear 2 Phase 2. Okay.

1:54:04 May I ask a little bit of additional language? I don't want to particularly have to block out the entire property line. It would be just that effective. I think, okay. So as... Any project here, since this is a very densely zone, would have always affected this. Yes. The location would have always been there. Right. That's understood. That's... I think that's fair. So mitigation will be in the location as affected by headlight glare.

1:54:45 Okay. I don't. Thank you, though, John. Thank you, Mr. Groot. I don't have any. I don't have any additional questions at the moment. Are there any comments or questions from the public specifically about this project that we haven't already addressed?

1:55:36 All of Area 2 in the Lodestar Master Plan were identified to have 210 dwelling units as a result of the earlier subdivision of Greater 1 on 8th Fairway. And what we understand are plans for this project as well as what we anticipate will happen with the remaining pieces on Area 2 that we estimate.

1:56:06 There'll be 140 undeveloped units in Area 2 of the low star master plan. And there's been no analysis performed done with the economic impacts are on the town, the lost TLT, the result of the down zone of the parcels piece by piece. Thanks, Tom. I want to make sure it has nothing to do with this project, actually, except for the fact that there is one project right now that has an access road that comes off of this road.

1:56:48 That is the remodel of the Holiday House. And then in all likelihood, depending on what's proposed, at least at this point for Los Sierras, there'll be another access road, which will be fire lanes leading into that particular development. So just remember, as you start playing with the location of this road, there will be spur roads.

1:57:13 Sandra, I'm not sure I understand. Is there an easement for a road then that's a part of this map that's not shown? Hayes, can you respond? Hayes can address that.

1:57:54 Can you repeat the question? Well, I just, I'm not quite sure I understand. I think Tom Heller was referencing a future or possible access road from the parcels directly to the north. Yeah. But is there an easement? There is not currently an easement recorded across that property. There is an access easement for Las Sierras into the Gray Bear 2 Phase 2 parcel, but not an access road across the parcel.

1:58:24 Or from that road. So La Sierra's is the middle lot directly to the north? The one that jogs to the south, correct. That's the easement that's shown. Yep. Holiday House being to the left, correct? Right. Okay. So we're showing the easement on the tract map and presumably the applicant is aware of this. There is no easement to the north from the existing road.

1:58:57 Recorded or proposed. There is no easement. There is no easement. Okay. Is it possible that it can happen? That would be up to the... Sure. It's actually the easement on the panel. Okay. Thanks, John. All right. Are there any other comments from the public? Very much appreciate our requested barrier trees, which would be our preference as well.

2:00:06 But I did want to bring forward a comment that I had made earlier, whether you would be considering moving the multi-use trail or the path, multi-use path, which is currently designed for the north and east side of the road. Our request was to move that to the south and west side of the road. For that new extension, that would also be a possibility that would give us even more space for those trees.

2:00:36 If you have that path on the north and east side of that road, I don't even see more trees that aren't going to be running against our house. Okay, thank you. Sandra, or maybe Hayes, just a question of clarification. Is the right-of-way for the road shown on the map inclusive of the multi-use path? Or does that take up further?

2:01:07 Further space. Little column A, little column B. The multi-use path easement to the property on the left is actually shown on the map, and that's not part of the subject project, but that is within the right-of-way on what was previously the Tana Vista parcel. On the Gray Bear 2 Phase 2, there is an easement described as actually

2:01:33 All of the area north of the right-of-way of the road so that it allows for future alignment and design. We're not calling out because we don't know where the trees are. We don't know what future structures will be there. So the applicant has allowed us the flexibility to design that at a later date within that entire area. The road easement is specific for street purposes, snow storage, and those sorts.

2:02:01 And is there a sidewalk component in addition to the multi-use path? No, just the multi-use path. So no sidewalk? No sidewalk. So to a certain extent, a multi-use path being located on the north and then as you move east on the east side of the road sort of in itself creates some kind of a buffer between the adjacent property and the road? Correct. In a way. Okay.

2:02:35 And that would be in substantial conformance with the Lodestar Master Plan, Trail System Master Plan, Bicycle Master Plan, Sidewalk Master Plan, and Proposed Mobility Element. That's quite a few documents. I had to memorize them. Thank you very much. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:03:15 And the reason that we created this large easement and did not designate the path in a certain place is if we designate it somewhere, then it's that tree that we have to take trees out. By creating this different buffer and open space, we can wind the trail in and out, which would be a lot more practice to do and save a lot of trees. So there are reasons for not having this on the other side of the road and designate it a certain area.

2:03:45 And that is for the attractiveness of the trail and the fact that we can wind it in our rock formation trees. That's the reason the transport is. So a little bit of flexibility. Flexibility was suggested by the county. Okay. Thank you. Thanks for clarifying that, John. Are there any other comments from the public? Then, unless, John, you have anything further to add, we'll close the public hearing at this time.

2:04:37 Do you have any further questions or comments as we begin our deliberation? Yeah, I don't have any further questions. Any comments regarding the multi-use path? No. I think the clarification that John just made kind of answered any questions I had. Okay. Commissioner Tang? In terms of timing and responsibility, who actually creates that trail, that multi-pass use? Who is responsible for making that?

2:05:13 We have conditioned, we've given the option to the applicant in one of the conditions to either construct the path as defined in the various plans I discussed, or to pay into a pedestrian fund so that we could use the same, the dollar amount to go towards other pedestrian improvements in other areas, and then we could come back at a later date and build this path. The reason we did that is because we have no access to the north.

2:05:42 Because we haven't gone through a process with Holiday House or La Sierra's to actually obtain an easement, we'd basically be building a dead end. So instead of building a dead end, we may apply those funds to another project, or if John so selects, he may build it as we previously described. In terms of timing, potentially this could look... It could happen with, once he gets through his MAP process and moves forward, he could elect to do it.

2:06:13 You know, this summer, or he may elect to pay into a fund, and it gets built once the town has connectivity to the north. And that could take? It would be probably based on whenever Holiday House or Los Angeles comes forward with a map project that would allow us to obtain those easements. Okay. Do you have any indication from the applicant as to which, is this preference? No, it's just the flexi, basically. Does that answer your question? Yes. Thank you.

2:06:59 And that's included as condition number 85 in the engineering conditions. Other than that, I don't. I have a question for staff or some comments. I sort of want to address the comments from Tom Hodges regarding downzoning or development at a lesser density than what's originally planned in the master plan.

2:07:39 Correct me if I'm wrong from reading the master plan though that it was written to include a maximum build out and the CEQA analysis is performed from the perspective of not wanting to over develop. Correct. Is that correct? Correct. So the CEQA analysis is done analyzing a maximum build out and are CEQA analysis specific to these projects?

2:08:10 says there's reduced intensity and density because of these projects and no new significant impacts are anticipated. Economic analysis is not a component of CEQA. Correct. So I wasn't here at the time that the master plan was being discussed. Was there ever any, just as a point of information, was there ever any conversation about a minimum density?

2:08:40 I know this is something that we brought up when we were beginning the FAR discussions to avoid exactly this perceived problem, but my understanding is that there's no minimum set. Was there ever a discussion about that? A discussion came up in 2013 among the commission, but it never moved kind of beyond just a preliminary discussion on minimum densities for the low star area.

2:09:09 We are including minimum densities in the FAR work that we're doing. So it may be appropriate, kind of as a separate discussion, separate from these items, to discuss that. Yes, separate. I agree. So if the commission gives staff direction to, we can talk to the town manager, talk to the council to see if they'd want to hold a joint workshop to just discuss minimum densities in the lodestar area. We can move forward with that. Okay.

2:09:41 So with that being said, because we're within the maximum density and because economic analysis is not part of the CEQA, we're essentially within being able to make those findings. Correct. While I understand exactly Tom's point and Mammoth Mountain's point, I think it seems to me anyway that our hands are tied in this case, in this situation.

2:10:17 Do you have any comments on that? No, I don't. I do believe it's appropriate for us to look at that specific topic to maybe come up with some sort of minimum guidelines. After all, I mean, you have a master plan that has specific density requirements or a maximum density requirement for a specific purpose.

2:10:45 And in a, in a, in a, in a, this is considered zone, uh, resort zone area, and you're trying to create a vibrant, um, uh, environment, I think it's, and for the purpose of the, you know, town's TLT collection, um, I, I think there's, there's some sort of a missed opportunity at this moment because we have so little units at this moment, even though I do, I do like the development.

2:11:15 The current project itself, you know, the product that we have here. But certainly it is a, I think we need to have some sort of a discussion and come up with a plan in the near future. Is there consensus from the commission? We'll move forward with that. Okay. Then I feel we have consensus on the project as a whole? Yeah. Okay. Anyone like to make a motion?

2:11:49 Paul, do you want to make a motion? I'd like to make a motion to approve. Do you need page seven? I think one, two, and three remain the same. It's on page seven. Number four would be the one that has some modifications. Approve the option to adopt the required CEQA findings. And number two, adopt the required municipal code findings. Number three, adopt the required subdivision map act findings.

2:12:29 Number four, approve tentative tract map, TTM 15-003, and use permit, UPA 15-003, subject to the condition. Actually, in this case, it would not be subject to this condition, right? With modifications to the conditions as recommended by staff at this public hearing. Okay. And without which tentative tract map? We don't need that part. Oh, we don't need this part. Okay. Great.

2:13:00 So I move motion to approve these items. Is that sufficient, that motion? Yes, and so the condition that we would add is the condition regarding the screening for the San Joaquin Villas that you discussed. Okay. Any other comments before with the motion on the table? No. I'll make a second to approve the motion. Okay. Can we have a vote? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Greyeck? Yes.

2:13:31 Motion passes, 3-0. Thank you, Ms. River. Thank you, Ms. River. One comment I'd like to make for the members of the San Joaquin Villa associations that are still here.

2:14:15 Thank you. Thank you. All right. Thank you.

2:14:46 So the public hearing number three has been continued, and so we'll move to our business matter number, I'm sorry, where's the police station? We still, yeah. Oh, for the TALIS? Right. Oh, we do? Okay. So I will now, so we're going to actually,

2:15:08 Because I know we're really, let me just talk about this quickly, because I know we need to get through the police station, we've got two big business matters, so what are we going to do? We're just going to open the public hearing? Well, I think we'd like to present the item and allow public comment. I think it's the applicant, this item is not also contingent on the Lodestar Master Plan. Oh, okay, so they could have. So they could have a consideration today, so I think they would like to move forward with the hearing. Okay, all right, I'm sorry. Yeah. All right.

2:15:34 So, at this point, then, we move to public hearing number three, consider approval of the TALIS amendment, tentative tract map 15-002, use permit application 15-002, design review 15-002, located at 525, 380, 360, 340, 320, 300, 280, 260, 240, 220, and 200, obsidian place, including the consideration of an addendum to the 2004 TALIS mitigated negative

2:16:03 Thank you very much. Can I just interrupt for a second? Because I know that there is people in the audience that are waiting for this business discussion. But, you know, unfortunately we have a set deadline at 5 p.m. that we have to be finished.

2:16:35 So do we want to make some comment about, I mean, I'm not sure we're going to get to the business discussion. I hate having them sit there and wait in the audience. I mean, if we have time, we can discuss it. If the commission would like to just continue that item, we can continue it to the February meeting. I think we did let the interested parties know that this was a big meeting and it could get continued. Okay. So I think it's the pleasure of the commission if you'd like to.

2:17:04 Take that action now. Okay. So if anybody that wanted, if we get to the business items, I mean, we can just continue it now or you can wait to 45 minutes. I'm really sorry. We try to, it's a big agenda. We try not to have people sit and wait for a long time in the audience, so. I'd say the only question. Typically. Okay. We will do our very best on that. I was going to say typically public hearings.

2:17:56 Always come before business matters on the agendas. The commission could consider an earlier start time. If, you know, we could notice it as a special meeting and start maybe at 1 o'clock if we think it's going to be another big agenda item and we could notice it that way and let the applicants know so that we would have time at the next meeting. So we would do that if the next agenda is also significantly large because we always do our public hearings first but we could start at 1 and then that way would allow us time to do the business matters.

2:18:26 Okay. All right. Okay. So with that, we will move to our public hearing on number three, and our staff person is Nolan on this. All right. Thank you. The proposed project, the TALUS Amendment, is requesting approval of a tentative tract map, use permit, and design review. The proposal is to re-subdivide lots 10 through 19 of tract map 36-216 for the 10 unbuilt fractional ownership.

2:18:54 Single Unit Residential Lots within the Talus Planned Unit Development, or PUD, into 20 whole ownership townhome lots. On the screen here is the proposed tentative tract map. So the areas related to this are the northern parcels in the center of the screen here. I may have zoomed in too far.

2:19:24 So each set of townhome lots will match the location and size that was originally approved for lots 10 through 19. Within each set of lots, a two-unit townhome will be built. There are two designs being proposed for the duplex-style buildings, and the design and materials will match the existing structures on the site. As part of the design review, the design committee conducted a site visit and viewed the proposed materials and the site. I do have the materials board here. It's in this suitcase over here.

2:19:53 Pull out real quick. Ah, the suitcase. I like that I've never seen a suitcase before. Is that the manager's unit? It is the same size, yes. So in addition to the re-subdivision, let me get a PowerPoint here, this is not. Uh-oh. So in addition to the re-subdivision, the applicant is proposing amending their affordable housing mitigation plan to be consistent with the town's adopted housing ordinance, allowing payment of fees,

2:20:58 Conversion of the fractional ownership lots into whole ownership, conversion of the existing temporary gatehouse sales office into a permanent manager's unit, construction of a maintenance garage, relocation of the multi-use path, creation of a remainder parcel, and completion of the emergency access through Dorrance Drive. With regards to the relocation of the multi-use path, the proposed location provides the maximum separation

2:21:25 And the adjacent residential structures is possible while still maintaining the required setbacks and features on the site. The current approved and proposed alignments are all shown on the screen. So the current alignment existing goes through the center of the site. The approved alignment goes right against the residential parcels to the east.

2:21:53 Adjacent to the parcel closest to Dorrance to provide additional separation. Comments have been received by the Millers who live adjacent to the site in Dorrance Drive. As indicated, the path does deviate from what was currently approved to provide additional separation. Additionally, a fence will be required for noise mitigation anywhere where the road is closer than 50 feet to a residential property.

2:22:21 Regarding the conversion of the existing gatehouse sales office to an on-site manager's unit, the conversion does require approval of DZA 15-001 or a subsequent DZA to allow accessory structures to be in that location and requires approval from the commission. So as shown on the screen, the existing building is 14.8 feet from the perimeter and 50 feet from the street.

2:22:51 The structure is integrated into the existing gate for the project and the applicant always envisioned the gatehouse as being a permanent part of the project. The applicant has provided examples of the project with similar gatehouses and the original vision for the project. That's in your packets I handed out. The applicant will be required to de-restrict the use of the gatehouse to an employee and provide an enclosed parking space in the rear.

2:23:20 So here's this showing directly adjacent to the gate, and the proposed parking area will be approximately where that ladder is. Additionally, they will be removing the paved parking area on the front and landscaping that area. Additional comments have been received from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area regarding the flight line safety easements. The proposed re-subdivision does not deviate from what was approved in 2004.

2:23:51 And therefore, are consistent with what was previously evaluated and approved, and that's for the proposed lot locations. The applicant did contact Cal Olsen, the golf course architect, in 2004 regarding the golf course flight lines and design the lot locations for the project accordingly. I'm additionally tempered glass.

2:24:15 has been and will be used on the structures, and the CC&Rs include covenants regarding damage and danger from golf balls. On the screen is an exhibit from 2004 showing those flight lines along with the proposed lot locations. You also have this in your packets. It's on the back page of one of the comment letters. Additionally, since this was a PUD and not individual single-family lots, the property lines adjacent to the golf course

2:24:43 were considered the side yard and therefore allowed 10-foot side yard setbacks. As indicated before, these lots are existing in their current configuration and location and could be built on without approval of the map. The map only approves the split of the parcel for separate ownership. As shown in the option denial of the project would mean the project would revert back to the current parcel configuration with the 19 lots that are there.

2:25:13 Regarding the affordable housing mitigation, Talos was originally required to provide six employee housing units or bedrooms prior to the completion of phase one. Phase one is still under construction, and therefore the applicant is able to request an amendment. They are proposing a plan consistent with the town's housing ordinance and to pay the current housing fees. They will be required to pay the fee for lots one through nine and the clubhouse unit.

2:25:41 Prior to certificate of occupancy for the ninth unit and subsequent fees will be paid at the time of building permit issuance. In addition to the evaluation of the project, staff prepared an addendum to the original mitigated negative declaration and found that since no changes were being proposed to the building locations, the change or the impacts would be the same as what was previously analyzed. And therefore, a new environmental analysis was not required.

2:26:09 Staff has made the determination that the project meets the required findings to adopt the addendum and approve the tentative tract map, use permit, and design review permit, and is recommending approval of the project. And with that, that concludes my presentation. Obviously, the applicant is here also to answer any questions. All right. So my question is, so where is the applicant as far as the DZA on this?

2:26:40 So the DZA only applies to accessory structures on the perimeter of the site. The amendments to, there's no required amendments to the setbacks or other items since there's no proposed changes to what is approved or permitted there, other than the gatehouse, which applies with the accessory structures. Okay. Are there any other questions of staff at this time? Yeah, I'm going to answer my question.

2:27:17 Okay. Does the applicant, would the applicant like to make him a statement?

2:28:21 Okay, so

2:29:05 If we move forward with this hearing today, what is your understanding about the accessory structure? Okay. And so you want to still move ahead? Okay. Are there any other questions? The conditions are written for the accessory structures that they're subject to approval of the DZA, and then there's alternatives if DZA is not approved that would require mitigation or changes to those accessory structures. Okay. I have a quick question.

2:29:39 The fence that's being discussed along the property line with the Millers and the Tallis, I guess this would be phase two project, would that be your responsibility to construct that? And if I'm not mistaken, they have expressed interest in more of a solid fence as opposed to a split rail. Is that correct from their correspondence, Nolan? Correct. And the correspondence received just prior to the meeting, they would prefer a solid fence.

2:30:08 In discussions with Eric, the applicant, Ann, Hayes at the exact location, someone up in the air we could hear in the hearing discussion get solid answers as to the location. Miller's request that it would be right adjacent to the path. Mr. Fishburne request that it's between the road and the path. And from a public work standpoint for snow removal,

2:30:36 They would prefer that it be as close to the property line as possible. Right. Hayes has indicated that he would be receptive to a point halfway between the path and the property line, so it would be approximately five feet from either for the solid fence. Okay. So then that would provide about eight to ten feet of separation from the Miller's house to the fence. And eventually when there is snow removal on that pathway, Hayes, that gives you sufficient room or gives your team sufficient room?

2:31:03 It would provide flexibility to either clear the snow or provide for over-snow treatments for alternative uses. Yes. Got it. And you're comfortable with the idea of a solid fence as opposed to a split rail? Actually, I think it would be more. Thank you. Just to be clear, the fence that we're talking about really serves as function of privacy as well as noise abatement? Correct. It was required for noise mitigation, but obviously with a solid fence it will provide privacy as well. Okay.

2:31:56 And we're talking about fencing not just adjacent to the millish property, but? Anywhere that it's within, the road's within 50 feet. As part of the conditions and prior discussions, Forest Creek Meadows was afforded a fence as well on the southern portion of their property. So that's on the adjacent RMF2 parcel, as well as on the west side of theirs along the pathway. Okay. And those are the only areas that it is within 50 feet is in that.

2:32:26 Section there. Okay. Commissioner Chang, did you have any questions at this time, maybe to the applicant or staff? Oh, no. Thank you. I did have one other question on your existing eight buildings that are built. Your ninth one doesn't have a certificate of occupancy, right? So you have eight that are being occupied? Correct. Right. Okay, so have you had any golf ball issues to date? No personal injury.

2:33:17 So I just want to just clarify this. So what we're going to be being asked to do moving forward today is to make the approvals based on the existing Lodestar Master Plan, correct? Yes. Okay. Thank you very much. At this point, I'll open up the meeting to public comments.

2:34:34 So, and the reason I make that point is that the maps that I have don't map that map. They show the innocent approaching on the property as you get away from teasing cut out, but that's a fair way. So my, you know, the request I have was, why can't we lay out the flatline setback on the map, have triad do it, so it's a...

2:35:03 Third party, impartial third party, professional surveyor, who can lay down the recommendations that were from Cal Olson. I sent an email with Sandra that I believe she forwarded to all the commissioners that showed the maps that we have from Cal Olson that show what the flight line setbacks are on parcels. And again, this map that has been handed to you guys for the results of the teachers today, doesn't match those maps. And so again,

2:35:34 I'm not comfortable with what's being represented today, what the setbacks are, and it's material to his map, because his map is essentially equipment for this building. And if I look at the map, I don't understand why we can't.

2:36:01 Find 10 feet more. I don't know why they have to be right there. I look at the layout of, I understand there's a driveway depth of 20 feet as necessary. You have a roadway of 24 and you have the path. But it appears there's enough room to make it work. So why is it such a problem? And why can't that stuff be fine? So that's my testimony with respect to the setback. So I think it is material for this map group because this map is essentially the exit.

2:36:33 And again, for the record, one of the long record that, you know, we, we have concerns about, there's a lack of analysis with respect to the down zone of all properties in the CRSR particularly on this side. And if there's been a net loss of in our estimation of 140 units based on what's been approved and developed and what is reasonable plus that.

2:37:03 It's 4A, I believe. Is it separate? Okay. All right, fair enough. But in any event, staff clarified that it's not part of CEQA. I wasn't clear on that, but it certainly seems like it's in fact that we're losing 140 units of resorts not only DOT generating units. And, you know, it's...

2:37:33 It's an unfortunate consequence of the economic cycle we're going through. As you know, in the past, the plans were proposed without those sites with higher densities, and, you know, that's, that boat's going to sail on us, and we're going to get that TOT as we get to build out as a community. So, just understand that every single decision you guys make that's a cumulative impact and consequence on the community as we look at our economic viability and sustainability.

2:38:02 I have a question before you sit down. So, currently, are there safety nets between the golf course and certain condominium projects? And then who is responsible for installing safety nets? The individual. You know, obviously, from the standpoint of the integrity of the golf course and the experience of the golfer, it's very desirable now in that subject. So, yeah, I mean, we're, again, you know,

2:38:46 We want to be on record clearly that there's recommendations from the college architect who's prescribed flatline setbacks and safety setbacks. As much as they can be accommodated, they should be accommodated. And certainly where you're allowing encroachment that even goes beyond the original CRFR master plan. And I understand there's this kind of points been made that on this property, the front setback was considered to marine in.

2:39:17 And is it your understanding of the Lodestar master plan that there's no minimum set in that master plan?

2:39:48 Minimum building standard set for that. Just maximum? Density. Maximum density, no minimum? With respect to density? Yes. It's listed and table listed. Right. Okay. Thank you very much. Are there any other public comments? With that, I'll close the public comment period on this project. I do have a question for staff. So I'm confused by the comment that

2:40:22 The golf course was considered the side setback, and Meridian was considered, so can somebody please explain that to me? It was because they considered it all one parcel, and typically the front is the most narrow side of the parcel that abuts the street. So usually the property is addressed off the front. So when they looked at this as one parcel without, you know, in 2004, they considered Meridian the front, and then

2:40:49 The sides, the golf course, and then the side to the east, and then the rear, the side to the north. So that's why. And if a new project came forward to commission today, would we still consider it the same way? I think so, yeah. Okay, and we have no zoning code on our books currently regarding a standard for setbacks with golf courses? Correct.

2:41:22 The Lothstar Master Plan shows golf setbacks. However, they're described as, as we said, a should rather than a shall. Okay. Okay. Should we start deliberations? No, I have another couple of questions. Yes, go ahead. Just a clarification on the map, and maybe it's just because it's not large enough scale for me to be able to see, that each of the individual 10 lots that we're talking about subdividing are,

2:42:00 appear to be set back from the overall PUD property line by a certain amount. Is that correct? Do you mean the actual building location? Well, maybe I'm just not sure what we're, it looks to me like there's a lot, you know, there's these 10 individual lots within the entire Talus PUD that are removed from the PUD property line by a certain amount. Is it 5 feet, 10 feet? Because then, presumably, there is a, is there a building setback in a,

2:42:34 Addition on each of these individual lots? Or are we showing building outline? So the building outline is set back 10 feet from the parcel boundary. And then there's an area outside of the building footprint that will be common area. As described, it's for landscaping and maintenance purposes. So that boundary is not the same as the building footprint, which is 10 feet.

2:43:05 So, just looking at the map on TTM 3, the solid line that we're looking at is the building outline, and that's 10 feet from, currently as shown, it's 10 feet from the parcel boundary on the west side. And then the dotted dash line surrounding each one of those is the common area that you're referring to, which is within the 10 foot side. It is, and that would be owned by each.

2:43:36 Property owner, since it is a townhome development, you own that central area, and then the rest of, outside of that, all is the common area of the HOA. Okay, thanks. I just wanted to clarify that we're all understanding the map in the same way, and so, is there, do we have any, I mean, I do understand some of Tom's comments and questions regarding why these were considered side setbacks.

2:44:14 As opposed to rear step backs when access to each individual parcel is from Obsidian Place. Is this the time and the place to discuss that? Yes, it is. Okay. Is that something that can be changed in this meeting if we so decide? Or maybe can you answer? Is there, in reality, room to grant the additional 10 feet that the golf course that Tom is requesting? I don't know.

2:44:44 Consideration of the side and the front, that is standard of a planning unit development where you have your kind of building footprints, parcels. We went through a similar process on the mountainside project in determining what was a front, side, rear, and then not being a street side because it was adjacent to a parking lot. So it really becomes what on the parcel as a whole, the front setback would be a portion adjacent to the street with the sides then.

2:45:13 Accordingly. In the 2004 amendment, this was a research I'd done, heavily gone back and forth, a series of meetings between the developer and staff to come to that conclusion, and that was how the project was approved and is currently existing on paper as well as on parcels. Okay. Are you able to say how much

2:45:54 How much leeway there actually is to maintain the 20-foot driveway and the road location as planned with respect to granting additional separation between the lots on the golf course or in the property line? I think we'd ask the applicant to respond to changes of that nature.

2:46:53 To realign the road that would require us to move a million dollars worth of utilities on fare, and it's already approved, I'm not asking for anything other than taking those lots to duplexes. And the flight line, there was, we have in our records, there was a mistake in the flight line plan, and we worked with Powell and he corrected that. It was ended through the initial process, and it was recognized by staff, and that's what determined the location.

2:47:28 Whether there is another map floating around or not, we were in compliance and we were approved according to this. When you say initial process, you're referring to when the very first entitlement.

2:48:08 I did not receive that map. Do we have any other questions? I do not have any questions. Before we move into deliberations, I'd just like to make a couple of comments. Personally, when

2:48:32 You know, when you have a project, unfortunately, that has gone through a series of ownerships, okay, I think sometimes you lose a certain continuity of things, certain records of documents. You know, I really pride myself on reading very carefully packets, studying packets, and I'm really taken aback about this whole comment about

2:49:01 that the side yard is along the golf course and so I would really would like Commission to consider us continuing this to a date certain so that we can really study these issues and understand what we're actually asking to do and also have a site visit I think would be really important so and I mean I would be willing to do a

2:49:30 Special meeting this month, if that would work. I don't know if that works for anybody else. Which would be then the fourth Thursday? January 27th. I don't know what that... That would work for me. Hmm? That should work for me. Right. What time? Well, but I guess we can't do that because what did you do for your DZA? So the DZA, the first one was considered a date certain in February, right? February 11th. Right. This item could be considered...

2:50:00 Separate from the DZA though. Okay. So it's up to the commission if you want to hold a special meeting to consider this again without considering the DZA or if you want to consider it at the same time as the DZA. Well, there's really no difference. There's no difference in approving it. Say we approved it today without having the DZA approved or we approve it in two weeks without having the DZA approved. Right. Right. There's no difference. Can you say one more thing? Yes. Frankly, I find that... Okay.

2:50:41 All right. Thank you very much. Do we need a motion? No. Okay. We'll move on to business matter number four. Consider approval of design review 15-005 for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Police Station, including the consideration of an addendum to the 2007 Mammoth Lakes Police Station mitigation negative declaration. Staff, just no one. All right. The proposed project, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Police Station, actually let me pull up the PowerPoint here.

2:51:38 So the town of Mammoth Lakes Police Station is requesting design review approval. The proposed police station will be located at 280 Thompson's Way on the town-owned parcel adjacent to the courthouse, Mammoth RV Park, and Sierra Park Road. The parcel is mostly vacant with the exception of the Mammoth Community Church and 10 parking spaces from the courthouse parking that encroach onto the town-owned site. The proposed building will be a single-story building that is 5,380 square feet.

2:52:08 In addition to the building, the site will have 33 parking spaces available, 15 for police vehicles and 18 public parking spaces, a 45-foot communications tower, a trash slash generator enclosure and a patio area that will also serve as an area for a future building expansion of up to 1,500 square feet.

2:52:29 The site was chosen for a variety of reasons, including that it will be adjacent to the courthouse, creating a public safety complex, and retains a large amount of the site for future uses. The project as proposed meets all the development standards of the municipal code for public and quasi-public zone sites. The PEDC Design Committee participated in a design charrette

2:52:56 on November 5, 2015, and provided initial thoughts and comments on the site design, the building design, and the materials. The final design was considered by the design committee on December 17, 2015, and the committee made recommendations to the design that have been incorporated into the final design.

2:53:16 The final design is here on the screens and in your packets. HMC, the design team, have proposed two different shades of blue for the building, Booth Bay Blue and Evening Blue. So on the screen here is the Booth Bay Blue. It's a little hard to see on the screens. The difference, this shade is slightly lighter. And then the Evening Blue is the darker shade. Would you like us to move those closer? She has young eyes.

2:53:46 No, I've already seen them. And so yeah, with the two shades of blue, we are asking the commission to make a selection on which shade they prefer. The other proposed materials are Corten steel, bronze storefronts, and beige siding, all of which are consistent with the town's design guidelines. Additionally, Corten is used on the adjacent courthouse and gateway monument signs, which provides a visual connection to those structures.

2:54:14 The sally port is proposed to be a slightly darker shade of beige to provide some variation in the building. In addition to the evaluation of the design, staff prepared an addendum to the 2007 police station mitigated negative declaration and found no new significant impacts or substantial increase in impacts would result from the proposed project. Staff has made the determination that the project meets the required findings to adopt the addendum.

2:54:42 and the design review permit, and is recommending approval of the project. With that, that concludes my presentation, and representatives from HMC are here for any questions, as well as Hayes is really the project lead on the police station. Commissioner Gregg, you're the design committee on this. I would just like to say that we've, the design committee, Commissioner Veruck and I have met with

2:55:12 The architects and the town a couple of times about this, and we've seen the project evolve just slightly, but overall I think we've come to a fairly architecturally pleasing building given the constraints that we have on the project. It's very helpful to see all the materials and colors in person. Thank you very much. I'm personally completely happy with what you're showing there.

2:55:40 And I think the most recent change being the storefront system and the continuation of the blue, I think that really resolves any of the reservations that I had or the comments that I had previously. So overall, I think that the process was very efficient and glad to see, hopefully see it move forward. I do have a question, I think, for Hayes.

2:56:10 Just really quickly, looking at the site plan, can you just maybe clarify for us and for the public, I know access is said to be off Thompson Way, but realistically, access to the primary public parking and to the front entrance of the building is through what is currently the courthouse parking lot? Correct. Which is my understanding is a piece of land owned by the courthouse? Actually, the parking is actually... By the county?

2:56:41 Yeah, it's owned by the county, leased to the courthouse, and we've had conversations with the courts about using the lot and accessing, which is actually town-owned land where the parking is shown in front of the police station through their lot. Right. So we don't really have any imminent danger of losing access to the front of the building should the county decide that this is a piece of land they want to use for something other than the parking lot? No.

2:57:11 It'll remain a parking lot for the courts. And so we'll still have access through that. Okay. That's the only question that I have. Did you have any questions, Commissioner Chang? I do. I understand that according to the development standard, the proposed setback have been increased based on the zoning code, existing zoning code, right?

2:57:44 This does comply with what is in the zoning code currently. Okay. That's all I have. I don't have any questions. Okay. Yeah, the red dash line is not the project site. It's just the kind of extent of the disturbed area of this. It's not the actual parcel boundary. Right. Okay. Yes, absolutely.

2:58:43 So I did want to note that. I want to make sure that everyone's clear that it's not a 50-foot radio tower currently. It's 90-foot. I thought the variance, the document, in the document, it provided that there was a variance approval that indicated at 90 feet. Sorry. The variance did approve it at 90 feet in 2007, and that variance still does stand since it runs with the land. But you're going to do mitigation measures, right?

2:59:13 So it's just not this big tower. It's my understanding, correct? It does require mitigation measures listed in the MMRP there. Right. Such as it's mainly due to colors that are being proposed on it. Okay. And the rendering that you have there, is that showing a 90-foot tower? Yes. Okay. If we need a 90-foot tower, then we need a 90-foot tower. Okay. Does anybody else in the public like to comment on the police station? Okay. Can I have a motion?

2:59:54 I will make a motion that we accept the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, excuse me, municipal code findings, and approve the major design review 15-005 with conditions as recommended by staff and as modified by the Planning Commission. Do I have a second? I second that. Discussion? Did we modify any conditions?

3:00:31 Just for clarify? Okay. So the conditions stand as in the report. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Grayack? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Is there any possibility, my fellow commissioners, that we can extend our meeting 15 minutes to hear this first business matter? Yes. I can stay until 5-15. Yes. Can I take a two-minute break? Are you okay?

3:01:03 Sandra, if we, for 15 minutes, or you? Yes. Yeah, Ruth was going to present the item. Okay. But I can kind of walk through the application or the, you know, proposed changes. The only thing is that some of the members who were interested in this left because I think they thought it wasn't going to get heard today. So... Well, so we have...

3:01:33 Two items. One was the change of our commercial code and the other, well we had three, commercial code, water efficiency, and the non-conforming structures. So I believe everybody from the commercial code is still in the audience, right? Okay, and then the non-conforming folks have left, so we'll continue that to next time.

3:02:01 And then the water efficiency have left, right? So can we just continue those two items till next time? This is just a business matter discussion, yeah. So it's really just intended to allow the commission to discuss this. No decisions are made today. Right. So I can go forward. I will need a 515 hard stop, though. Right. Okay. Would you like a presentation? Well, I guess the question... Would you like to just discuss or... Let me ask...

3:02:28 The folks that are interested in the commercial code change, we can give you 10 minutes. Is it worth 10 minutes or would you like to come back next month? Okay. All right. All right. We know you can speak quickly.

3:03:20 Anyway, the Main Street plan and the zoning code update, I know a lot of work went into that, which you guys put a lot of work into it. I have participated on it to some levels and interviews. And I like so much of the plan, what it has to offer. And the reason I really wanted to come and talk to you today is, as we've heard with other items on the agenda, sometimes grave plans have unintended consequences.

3:03:49 And I think in this particular case, what I'm asking the commission and staff to consider is while we have a great plan laid out, there are just some things that are properties that, you know, are a little bit unique. And we're in certain circumstances now where with the evolution of our plan and the Main Street plan, you know, we'd like to see great ground floor retail and residential above in the long term.

3:04:17 Unfortunately, one of the problems I've always had with it is that how do we get from here to be? Today, you know, looking back to early 1980s, we had a population that wasn't too much different than it is now. And we had skier visits that are comparable to probably what we're going to experience this year, maybe a million and a half visitors. But something unique happened in 1980, and that was that the, you know, this building, the Sierra Center Mall, the Mammoth Mall,

3:04:46 And a number of other buildings were built all the same period of time. And we saw a big saturation of retail and office space during that period of time. And what we're seeing today, if you drive down Old Mammoth Road and into parts of Main Street, we're starting, you know, while the residential economy and the condominium market has been, you know, rising over the last couple of years, the commercial market really has it.

3:05:12 A lot of that through the increased supply, a lot of that has to do with changes, you know, with the internet, maybe it's, you know, Amazon, people are able to order, they're not shopping out as much, or if they are, they're going in and they're working and they're not buying. So we're finding a difficulty in the commercial market to really fill the space we have. As you go down, you look at those buildings, like I said, Sierra Center Mall, Mammoth Mall, the Remax building, which would be, you know, these buildings are 50% or less empty now. So,

3:05:41 As I look at it, and I think as my client looks at it, you know, what do we do today before we come up with this big redevelopment plan that really doesn't exist anymore? It used to be that California could go and apply for a redevelopment district and put these plans into place, but now we can't really do that. So owners like D English are faced with, you know, what do they do with their property?

3:06:08 There's already so much retail that's empty right now. She has a retail space for Mammoth Mount Mary. And that space may be becoming empty. And she has a choice to say you can try to sit on this property for a long period of time and try to compete with all the other retail space that's out there. Or she can look at other alternatives and look to where the market is today and say we need to fill the needs of the market.

3:06:34 And one of the needs that we have found out there is that the residential market, as I said, has been increasing and the apartment market in particular has been very strong. We've heard affordable housing come forward and nobody else saying that a lot of local people are looking for affordably priced housing. And in this particular case, the owner is trying to look at some alternatives to what can be done with this property and unfortunately,

3:07:03 Our alternatives aren't really conforming with our new zoning code update. And what we're really looking to do is to ask the commission and staff to consider some of these alternatives, at least until a solution presents itself where we can make the changes and conform with this plan on a more homogeneous and a larger scale. Because doing it in silos and doing it with individual properties, in my opinion, is just not going to work.

3:07:31 If they end up closing, if the town ends up closing, let's say, a portion of the frontage row to make the whole strip work, that may work out where you have an animated sidewalk and the ability for all the commercial districts to push themselves out and reanimate the whole street. But to do it one at a time, I just don't think will work because you can't close down a portion of the street, portions of parking, and that nature.

3:07:58 As we go through the study that was prepared for the town of Mammoth Lakes, there are a number of different issues that have presented itself, and part of this plan, the purpose of it, was to determine the potential economic viability of the plan that we created. And again, while I think it's a wonderful plan, there are certain properties that are more challenged than others. Development costs are going to be extremely high.

3:08:26 Rents aren't adequate to support those development costs. And in the study that was presented, the presenters of the study determined that in order for a developer to go in and actually make a profit and create a viable project, they needed to see about 15% return on their equity. Well, unfortunately, some of the properties, particularly Site 2, which my client's property falls under, we see that they had even suggested that

3:08:56 Returns would probably fall somewhere between negative 2% and 7% over a 15-year period of time, which basically suggests it's just not a viable, there's really not a viable alternative for them, and that's if they were to create retail or something along those lines. And so the best solution, you know, in this particular case is to look at alternatives until we can come up with a bigger, better plan. And in her case, that solution is to look at residential housing.

3:09:25 Apartments, excuse me, multi-family housing. And I believe Mr. Kappley will be able to present some solutions that he's been able to come up with. And I've studied the market and really tried to come up with something that will help prevent Mammoth and Main Street from becoming more boarded up properties. You know, we've had a problem with looking at properties like the Los Sierras property. And we've obviously, you guys have taken big strides to take.

3:09:52 So, and I don't mean to be abrupt or rude.

3:10:21 But I just really want to give you some very quick feedback. So personally, I started working on this, the downtown area, the Main Street, the zoning code update, it was December 2012, so it was like...

3:10:39 Almost three and a half years ago. I mean, it's pretty unbelievable. And there was a lot of, you know, numerous meetings, workshops, groups, et cetera, that went into that whole zoning code update and the discussion about active frontage roads. So where we are today is, as we've talked before, it's like we're on the five-yard line, but we haven't taken the ball across the goal line yet.

3:11:08 in the fact that we have not finished our CEQA. And our CEQA is all predicated on FAR and these theoretical and realistic densities and buildouts. So as far as a commission goes, I would not want to talk about any kind of zoning code update until we finish that CEQA process.

3:11:34 If there's anything that we could look at as an individual property, we could certainly discuss that. You made a comment, Matthew, that until the whole frontage road is built out, it's difficult, but I can remember specifically being at a workshop with Nori Winters where he showed how you could take certain properties and not build those out to the frontage road. But, yes, we want to have...

3:12:01 An active area. We don't want to have a lot of empty retail. But as a commission, it's really important that we finish this work for the overall good of the town. So, you know, what we have to do is we have to, you know, close our meeting. But Sandra, I can stay back and talk to them if they'd like to or, you know, I know everybody else has to.

3:12:29 We have to wrap the meeting up. But I'd just like to know, so we're going to have to move off this agenda item, but I'll be happy to continue the conversation after the formal meeting with you. And I don't know if anybody else had any other comments on that. I just had comments too, just to bring up just quickly key points that there were several other items within the new zoning code update, not just specific to this property, but several things that we're dealing with in the residential developments.

3:12:55 Right, so, but the nonconforming. 17, but can we talk about that after the meeting? Well, yeah, and the nonconforming and the water efficiency, we said, because I'm sorry, we didn't realize you were still here. We said we would talk about the next meeting, but yes, we can talk about that, too. Okay. Does that work? Is that acceptable? So we'll bring the entire item back to you at your February meeting. But I just wanted to give them some feedback. Okay.

3:13:20 Really quick, is there anything that we have to talk about in commissioner reports, director's reports? So for director's reports, just quickly back on the police station, we had posed a question about which blue the commission preferred. So based on your decision, we are assuming that either is preferable and the staff can choose, or would the commission like to go back to that item and pick one of the two colors?

3:13:55 I'm going to defer to the design review subcommittee. So you approved either? Well, I guess we did without realizing. I mean, I have a preference. Which one? I prefer the darker one. Okay, we agree. And that's the staff's preference. That's what we would pick? Just to clarify. Done. That's the evening blue. The evening blue. Okay. No.

3:14:19 So just the only item I had was to request that the commission consider appointing an alternate for the design committee. We may have the need to have a design committee meeting next week, and we don't know what Commissioner Verruck's schedule will be. Okay. So if we could appoint someone to serve in her place, because it's nice to have two commissioners as the design committee, just as an alternate, we would ask that. Would you be able to do that, Commissioner Chang? Next week? Yeah. I'll be happy to. Okay. All right.

3:14:49 Thank you. Okay. When? We don't know. I move that we adjourn our meeting to the next regularly held meeting February 10th, 2016 at 2 p.m. Thank you very much. And if there is a special meeting in between? There is not. No. There is no special meeting. Is there the chance that