Town Council Special meeting
· recording 2 hr 45 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
330 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:43 Did you get a haircut? It looks good. You didn't notice? I got one too. No, I was going to ask, but I... So are we ready to get started? Good to know. They're here. It takes everybody's car a while to warm up in this one. We'll wait a couple minutes. Are you inviting Rich up to the table? Yeah, Rich. Rich, you're being invited up to the table. Come on up. Good afternoon.
2:31 Yes, it is. It is. Goes by quick. Time zone. Yeah. What was that for? April receipt. You keep stuff with me for a while. I do. Just in case. Just never. You never know. You never know.
3:12 Michael, what's our highest complaint so far? 28,000. I don't know the exact number, though. I'd have to look it up. John has it. Yeah, I think it was just under 29. Want to get started? Okay.
3:49 I will call to order the Town Council Town of Mammoth Lakes special meeting Tuesday, December 15, 2015, 101 p.m. Seeing all council is here, would you all please join me in the pledge? Where's the... It's behind us. That's okay. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible,
4:21 With liberty and justice for all. Okay, before we get started, I want to open the floor for any public comments. Okay, seeing none, we'll move on to our workshop item one, workshop to discuss the town council's strategic goals and priorities. Michael, you're back. I'm back. Welcome. Thanks for having me. I want you to notice that I have symbolically blocked myself into this place.
4:54 When I move this aside and step out, this meeting's officially over. You'll like this meeting because I'm going to do all of the writing and all of the recording. Jennifer? No, I think that's Michael's water bottle. It's just me trying to create a little space. So we have a really simple meeting. It has a couple of parts. The first part is actually
5:26 Take this document, which you all have in front of you on a copy of it, so I hope you have annotated forms of it, and make sure that we have clean refinements on your short-term telepathic commitments on the 18-month cycle revision by this whole process. Once we're clear on that, I'm going to record those notes over here, and we're going to move to the core part of this workshop, which is
5:55 To get to your 2025 goals and refine an iterative work that's been done over several workshops. So I'll offer you a preamble about that. I've got a set of guidelines for that and I've laid all the materials out ahead of time. As I mentioned, I'm going to do all of the recording. I'm hoping that when we walk out of here in two, perhaps 2.5 hours max, you'll have great clarity.
6:23 On the 18-month targets and the 2025 targets through and within which you can construct the action plan that you need to actually realize those outposts. All right? So, with that in mind, I've also given you a second handout that is formatted to align with the order of the
6:50 Strategic priorities of the Council, but all of the work included in here came out of our second workshop together in this room. This is work we did up on sticky wall. I believe we have all of this time to carry it forward. Some of your targets have changed a little bit, but I want to remind you of your own good thinking three months ago so that we do not find ourselves re-brainstorming the process, which I'm allowed to do.
7:19 All right. So we're going to take these in order. So we're going to work only on
7:45 Number one, under the Town Mammoth Lakes Strategic Priorities, that's to enhance our recreation deals with economy, but we're only looking at the second column, which is the 2015-17 Commitments. I understand that you, and I'm going to ask Council to guide the dialogue here as the elected officials of the town. It's your challenge, I think, and your responsibility to provide direction on these commitments and outcomes.
8:14 with the participation, active participation of the NGO executive leadership. We'll say a little bit more about that as we get into this exercise. So I think some of you have some action notes. Dan and I exchanged some dialogue about this. So I'm expecting you may have some revisions. Yeah, literally right down to anything you want changed or revised.
8:44 And the second column under Enhance Our Recreation-Based Economy, 1517 Commitments. Was that A to F? Was that captured what we went through in the last meeting? Or any additions. So for A, and I'm going to, there's a couple of wordsmithing things, let me just kind of clean up at the same time. So the updated implement economic vitality plan.
9:14 Well, let me ask another question, and I don't understand what's the difference between A and B. Okay, so let me, well, I do, so I have a thought about that. After the last session, we were talking about the economic model, John Urdi came up to me and made a recommendation of a group that can do an analysis of how our economy functions.
9:43 And to me, that's what B is, and that makes some sense. It's not what we want to be or what we're going to be in 15 years. How does this place actually work? But the thing I wanted to talk about is data, and we have a community indicators report, which I think comes out every quarter. Okay, so I'm thinking that with this part of this economic vitality plan strategy, having a quarterly, you know,
10:11 Get a set of economic metrics and data that comes out whenever is appropriate that it will be used for everybody in the city. A measurement tool. Yeah, whatever the indicators are so that we know we're all working off a data set. And that would be a component of A, I think. The community indicators report has a lot of stuff that doesn't really tie back to it. And I'm looking at it would be updated and it would be revisited.
10:41 Okay, so then B, it's really what you're talking about there is some kind of a baseline. B, what we just talked about about establishing a data set, I'm thinking that could be part of A or not. I don't know. But B would be a baseline of how the economy of Mammoth Lakes works. So I think personally if that's what B is intended to be, I think that language is going to be.
11:13 Yeah, I would agree. You know, that's when it's very different. Yeah. So, you know, establish a baseline understanding. Or document the workings of the economy. I'm going to try to not editorialize a lot here just to keep us going. From my experience, my recommendation would be that you actually.
11:53 Take the two things you're talking about, which is some type of economic modeling and some type of community indicator reporting, and make them component tasks of A. There's no point in developing an economic strategy without having those two elements. So they're really embedded in your economic strategy. Well, I mean, I can see both of them being different, to John's point. Why do we call it, and B, develop an economic baseline model?
12:22 That we can start working off of so there's measurable things as we move forward and use the data points as we're getting them to inform that. So we have to develop that community economic model, the baseline, if you will. And then on a quarterly basis, per day, the metrics. I think I struggle a little bit with that to me to understand. We're not trying to change. We want to just be aware.
12:59 Of how it works and what it is, to me, develop doesn't work there. Okay, well, what, what, what? Prepare, prepare, a community economic baseline model. Not develop, but I agree, yeah, prepare. And just so I'm clear, we're only looking right now, Michael, at the 2015 to 17 committee. Okay. This year was read, going through it at the last meeting, and I would say, did we capture it correctly? Yeah, yeah, I just, I have notes on both, so I'll just.
13:31 Are we, John, are you suggesting the wordsmith A? No. We can put plan and strategy. Let's get to the second thing. So we did that one, that B, so we prepared the model. Then we need to update it quarterly. Makes sense.
14:04 Yeah. I think you're task analyzing now and you're getting into the action plan. I want to discourage you from doing that today. Just name the commitments you want after 18 months and then we're going to get to the commitments you want after 10 years. Got it. Don't get into the how of it or we will not get out of here tonight. Just for clarification, so with the 18 months, we're talking visiting year 17?
14:30 Which would be June of 2017. I think we are at this point. We're close to that. So June of 2017, not calendar year. It's the action plan we're going to do in January, so you're going to literally be June of 2017. So for A, so far, 1A, you want to remove the slash input and strategy. And for B, we're changing this to prepare a community economic baseline model.
15:02 And I've been updated on a regular basis without being too specific, but the model can be updated. What else? Anybody get something on C? Let's just do them quick. Nothing on C. C's good. C's good. D? Fine. I think D's okay. All right. E? You guys have discussed this in our recent workshops. Yeah.
15:40 Initially I thought maybe it's low, but I think that's a good one. 18 months, yeah. 30,000? I think that's good for 18 months. Was the MLT recommended target for us? 30,000 appointments? F? I would just take a, I don't know why D395 is one tool in parentheses, I would just take it F. Well, it actually belongs then, I think it's going to end up under the TOML, and that's what our discussion was. So it kind of goes into the TOML column in the middle.
16:15 Okay, yeah, I don't know why it's a parenthesis. It was just there because of the way that was structured originally. They said they called it initially D-95. So we'll put it into the T-O-Mail column? Yeah. Oh, the working group will. I think that was just a carry forward from one of the prior iterations so that it was a reference to Digital 390. Okay. It's a good time to take that stuff out. So are we good on, is there, are there any additions?
16:46 My question, we had a little talk about that, but if it's develop and maintain, if it's an iterative thing, it's going to be
17:28 Maintain over time? Well, it's a living deal. It's a living deal, exactly. Yeah, so I could put maintain in there, develop, maintain, and implement. Something so that it's ongoing. It's iterative, it's ongoing. So 2A, develop, maintain, and implement. True. Is that good? We use commas, not slashes. I still think implement is placed there.
18:00 Yeah, I'd be okay with development and maintain because I'm not sure how much of it, you know, we implement or we enable. I think we're getting caught up in semantics here. It's not, you know, it's not a hell of a diet. What? Yeah. Well, we don't implement a story. No. Pieces that are involved in the story map that get implemented. But not as the fact of being on the map.
18:35 So that's why I think develop and maintain. Okay, if you want to develop, maintain, then implement someplace else because we'll be very. Implement's coming off, but we're going to put it down below because we do implement. To speed us up, I will not call for consensus on each one of these. When it sounds like you have exhausted your disagreements, I'm going to record what I hear and then you can tell me if it's correct or not.
19:08 How about 2B? 2B, actively engage with developers? That's fine. Good. 2C? Good. Good. I was looking at this in preparation for this meeting and thinking about how we just recently talented away with inclusionary housing, which is one of the major goals of inclusionary housing is to have integrated housing, you know, mixed.
19:44 And now it's on the table again. And is there an error there? Or is that... I think inclusion is a very specific term of art, and I think the council decision was specific to that. But I think that we still strive to have our housing opportunities to be integrated. Somebody articulate that word. What do you mean by integrated housing?
20:13 It could get taken in wrong. I had a question. Let's not mix colloquial terms. Yes. They have specific foundation in housing. Jennifer, what's your thought or guidance to Council? Well, I don't know what the intention of that was. If it's not to be integrated, because I interpreted it as mixed.
20:42 Diverse economically, integrated and diverse economically. To me that means mixed incomes, living by one another, sharing neighborhoods, being neighbors, not having pockets of workforce and pockets of second homeowners. That's how I interpret it. I think that's what demographically mixed housing is meant to convey, but how do we make this language
21:09 I say we take integrated out. Take the integrated and out. I think it's a tough sentence. I think we could just say, provide economically and demographically diverse housing opportunities. That's fine. Yeah, that's great. Can you say it one more time? Provide economically and demographically diverse housing opportunities. And then we have diverse in the sentence twice? No, take diverse out. Integrate and diverse out.
21:42 Yeah, but when you keep reading, with a focus on the diverse, creative, and innovative. Second, diverse. Right, with a focus on creative, innovative. Innovative use. Better. Second, diverse. Yeah, okay. I think when in doubt, when you're framing commitment language, just being descriptive, is more helpful than trying to be precise. Precise obligate to a particular solution.
22:35 It may not be come in evidence when we put the action plan together. That would be my biggest concern. All right, so 2D. Again, it's just sort of a capital's grammatical cleanup. I'll take a shot at it. Parking plan for village in place, period. Short-term solution to village implemented, semicolon, lowercase l, long-term town-wide parking solutions are integrated with our recreation-based culture, including parking, mobility, and transit programs.
23:08 Just remove the cabs. Yeah. Doesn't the first part of that kind of repeat itself, though? If we said short-term parking plan for village in place, period, and then went to long-term town-wide? I would do that as a separate. Yeah. Well, in place and implemented to me are the same thing. Yeah, I agree. Short-term solution. Period.
23:42 Renew sentence. It's done, right. Then long-term. So parking plan for village and places struck and you say short-term solution to building parking solution? Yeah. Short-term parking solution? Right. Yeah. Short-term parking solution. Period. Then. Do you want the word solution or did you want parking plan? Parking solution. Parking solution, I think. Long-term. Right. Uh-huh. With recreation, da-da-da-da-da. Yeah. Implemented or in place?
24:16 Implement it. Implement it's fine. This time implement is appropriate. And after the semicolon? The rest of it's okay, right? Yeah. Well, no, no, I would start. I'd put a period. Period, then it's, yeah, then the cap is correct because long term would be a new sentence. New sentence, right. Yeah. I think we need a long term town developed. They're supposed to be developed and planned.
24:51 You're right. We're missing that. We had something in there before, and it kind of got wordsmithing. It was changed because it was village, long-term village in place and town, and we just kind of consolidated that. Right. So I just think we need a long and planned. Yeah. I mean, based on what we're planning on doing. So you want to simply substitute plan for integrated? Yes.
25:34 A, that should be an S sighting, not a C sighting.
26:07 Is siting the right word? I mean, did we? Yeah, siting of new trails, having, you know. We had groundbreaking, but. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. I've got a question about the title. Enhanced community and amenities serving residents and visitors. That's not going to be pulled from the one side over. Right. Yeah. I just, I'm wondering if you want to pull community out of that. Because I think if we go down this road where we're constantly differentiating between community and non-community.
26:36 It's a distinction without meaning. I think in the end it can lead to a lot of confusion. So you're just saying enhanced amenities serving residents and visitors? Yeah. I can live with that. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I don't think serving residents. Yeah, I agree. I kind of think we should, I kind of like the way it was before. It was shorter. It was more, it was just enhanced community amenities.
27:03 Can I challenge you on this? I've got to challenge you on this one. So from the very first workshop, that flip chart, I went to great pains to establish that community meant visitors and residents. And when you're done with this process, you need to have a dialogue with the community at large over a long period of time. Simple things like leaving community and residents and visitors in there will help facilitate that dialogue.
27:31 Otherwise, it just sounds like you're going to build stuff without a clear customer. See, I have a little bit different take on exactly what you're saying. I think by putting residents and visitors on there, that's indicating that we're drawing a distinction line. And I don't find the two to be mutually exclusive. I think anything that we do as far as a community amenity is going to serve our residents and our visitors.
27:58 Equally. You know, if it's, like I said, if it's important to some people that it's in there, but I think all of these titles are clean and to the point, and this just seems to drag on, for me, unnecessarily. So, that's just one perspective I don't want to find. Well, it's just going to be important, if we go with amenities, which is fine, if we take community out, just go with enhanced amenities, but Michael's point is, I mean, in our local dialogue,
28:26 People will draw the distinction of, well, that's not driving visitation. You know, and if we establish a term of art that says it's an amenity, and then you sort of analyze it, whether it's driving visitation or whether it's not, we can do that, but we have to stick to, we have to stick to what...
28:46 I think ultimately we're saying the exact same thing, but in my opinion, calling that out specifically to say that it serves residents and visitors actually enhances people's ability to draw that distinction. Okay. So if it's just enhanced amenities, just enhanced amenities, just leave it right there. I defer to you, but just remember the view from inside the castle is way different than the view outside. Yeah. I think there's still enough of the
29:16 Legacy in the community of making clear the differences between residents and visitors. I mean, when I, let's see, when was that? About 2006, I applied for the Recreation Commission and that was the whole question. That was one of the interview questions. It's that whole business. Well, are we serving residents? Are we serving visitors? So I'd leave it in. But I think the community then makes it confusing. You leave in serving residents? Yeah. Okay.
29:41 Because that's what people out there are still thinking. Right. Because it's duplicative if we say community and residents. Correct. So I think it's a community out. Yeah. So I have these slightly out of order, but we'll get that. Okay. How about, so other than changing the spelling on citing, the last paragraph needs a D. Oh, thank you, John. I was going to ask you. Wasn't that supposed to be, the participate is supposed to be D? That's a D. Yeah.
30:12 So let me do B and C first. Are you ready for B and C? I think you plan either. Yeah. So maybe what we do is we'll just generally call out all the capitalizations throughout the plan. How about C? Was that good? Yeah. Yeah. And then D. And so part 3D begins participating. Yeah. Okay. Anything else? Number four.
30:49 Doing well. Effective municipal services. So we have A, B, and C, and a lot of bullets. And D. And D. Yes, yes, yes. So effective municipal services, is that still a title that you want for the priority? How about 4A, financial stability? Essentially what you're saying there is financial stability as defined by the following elements, and that gets mirrored on the right-hand side.
31:20 2025 goals. Higher finance director needs, does need a period, it doesn't need to have two capital letters. Yeah, okay. So, any other changes there for A? Do we maybe need to, under B, you know, permitting? We need to explain what that means a little better. Permit streamlining? Yeah, streamlined permitting or something like that. You're under B.
31:59 Yeah, streamlined or expedited or something. Yeah. I like streamlined. Okay. Yeah, because we're still permitting, but it's whether or not it's doing what it should, right? Yeah. So, remove the semicolon and, Colin, you're saying just insert streamlined? Yeah, streamlined. In the title of B, can we take out organization, so just recognize as a response and effective local government services such as colon? Organization.
32:35 Yeah, take that out. John, give it to me again so I get the correct note here. So this is 4B. 4B, correct. The word organization comes out. Oh, I see. I don't think that's the right word. I don't know if consider tools such as EIFD is the right word. I don't know what our dialogue was on that off the top of my head. That actually came out of the very first workshop in this room back on August 27th.
33:12 Because you guys were having an EFID discussion that day. So we referenced, I remember this distinctly, we referenced it as an example, a current example of a tool. So this became, remember when I asked you guys as council, what you wanted to keep, refine, or change, that you guys wanted to have some way of referencing EIFD as one?
33:37 Possible tool. But it's not really necessary to establish that in a commitment statement. Well, now that we have this center area for the tools, would it go over there? And is the statement over there is explore new financing options? Yeah, you could. I think you could take out EIFD as it would. Because we don't anywhere say, you know, we want to grow things, but we don't want to explore new things. So maybe that's what...
34:02 Because the EIFID is a new thing for us. Correct. I just had a hard time with the word consider. That was my hang-up. I think it goes into the middle. Yeah, we could take out that entire bullet. Yeah. I'm saying, though, replace it with some kind of thing. Explore new financing options. I mean, you could still save.
34:28 Yeah. Explore financial options such as the FID. I mean, you can still utilize. I think it should still be in. I just think consider. I just don't like the word consider. How about make use of? Utilize. Utilize. I like the word explore. Explore. Evaluate. Evaluate. That's good. All right. Evaluate's good. I like evaluate.
34:59 Yes. Without being specific to EIFD. I think what you're trying to do here is you're trying to lock in place a guiding principle that you know for 18 months new financing tools will emerge so you're not just...
35:36 Committed to using what you already have. Correct. Exactly. And some of this will be provided for you. Some of it you'll discover on your own. So you're really committing to a guiding principle there. And so we're going to remove. So that was 4A, B, C.
36:08 What are the quotes for? I think before we were looking at it, they were on two separate pages, but why on earth would any use of Synergy Summits be in quotes? Exactly. Take the quotes off. It was a matter of making sure we captured it. Same thing happened on that. Remember, you guys had previously committed to four of these Synergy Summits. You took that out and then said, wait a second, we're doing this process. This is the... So how... Just take the quotes off. Just take the quotes off.
36:41 We need to add hyphens. Town Council is committed to effectively integrating with hyphen as utilizing expanding capacities offered by hyphen, MLR, MLT, MLH, Esther. No? It's a bulky sentence. It's long, but... This commitment was added also on August 27th. I don't know why.
37:13 Having this intense deja vu experience. But we added it to establish the foundation for all the rest of the workshops to follow. So however you want to frame that, still leave it like it is to sort of close it. And then 4D was a carryover that was also reworded. And the change was the insertion of the word regional, if I recall correctly. Is that right? Yeah.
37:45 Do we decapitalize solid waste? Yeah, we could. I kind of like it. Anything else? You know, just a general comment. I think we've arrived at a good place as far as, you know, the four strategic priorities. They're very clearly articulated, you know, four is a manageable number. These are all things that personally I can very much get behind, so I think.
38:24 Recognizing that we're a recreation-based economy and enhancing that is critically important. You know, we have to develop a comprehensive plan so we know what we want to be when we grow up. And, you know, I think we are deficient as far as our amenities in town, and so I'm very supportive of expanding those. And I think, you know, one of our major jobs as a council in the town is to provide effective municipal services. So I think it's a good list that I feel comfortable.
38:55 He's working in it. In your spare time. Yeah. Yeah, we appreciate that. Any other reflections or comments on the commitments? Do we have a solid framework that we can now project forward and have an equally clean discussion about the 2021?
39:24 I would think so, yeah. Okay. Yeah, nice work. All right, so moving along, we're going to do the same thing. We're going to go one section at a time, starting with enhance our recreation-based economy. Without inserting myself in your process too much, I'm going to suggest a couple things. One, I've sort of laid out a way to do this so that I don't have to rewrite, but I can use handy references. I'm going to encourage you to think about...
39:53 Less is more in terms of your 2025 outcomes. Right now we have six, seven pages and the right-hand column is there. There's a lot of words there. I think there's only about 10 or 12 actual goals there. And there's a bunch of associated outcomes. There's only about 10 or 12 goals. So I'm going to just plan for you in the center of the room. By the time we're done here, I'd like you to walk out of here.
40:23 Knowing that you have about 10, maybe 12 solid 10-year goals and a whole series of outcomes attached to those goals, not walk out of here with 30 or 40 goals. It's unmanageable, unimplementable, it will conspire against your success.
40:45 We're working off this. That's in a large version. Two tools. One is, this is a reference document. This is actually your work product. You created this at our second workshop together, which was our first with all the NGO leaders integrated in the session. I took you through an exercise then to isolate outcomes and indicators and metrics and so on at a high level.
41:14 For many of the goals that we were strategizing. And so I've been waiting to carry those forward. So I brought them back just to stick them in front of you to remind you as we go through the exercise. So we're not reading off that list. We're not working off that list. We're only working off this. We just don't want us brainstorming anew. The second thing is I've come up with a framework.
41:42 That I want to advocate so that we don't find ourselves brainstorming or getting lost at a 30,000 foot level. Remember that goals are supposed to be descriptive statements of outcomes that are done in 2025. So we should not have goals that have the words planning or studying.
42:09 Or processing, or talking about, or dialogue. You should not have those kinds of words and goals. In 2025, what you're looking for is descriptions of something that's finished that maybe conforms to some of these criteria. So here, we're going to give you a set of criteria. First, there should be a specific observable outcome. You can either measure it, or you can look at it.
42:37 The stuff that you can't look at, you measure because they're reports and they're documents and studies and things like that. If they're buildings, you can take a look at it and everybody can really agree. The goals themselves do not have to be written in language that have a specific number embedded in the goal statements. In other words, it doesn't have to say X number of emplainments. It may simply say, refer to a form of air service.
43:06 That means your economic needs. But attached to that will be a bunch of indicators that should be measurable either in fiscal or financial performance or experience terms, user experience terms. This is how you're going to address not just council level needs or executive leadership team needs, but community level needs. As I mentioned,
43:32 The goals must reflect a 10-year result linked to a current short-term priority. If your priorities today and your goals in the future are not integrated, there's really no point in having them on paper. The goal statements become somebody else's plan. Goals should be as smart as possible. You guys know what that acronym stands for, right? Smart is specific, measurable, attainable.
44:00 Reliable. Some groups use reasonable. I'll get to that later. And time-bound simply means you want descriptive language that's specific. And I'm going to, rather than teach you how to do that on paper, I'm actually going to just take you through it as we do the exercise. The key thing here is the goal should stretch you to someplace in 2025 that's not just an easy step from today.
44:29 Easy steps we should write into three-year goals. They should achieve one or more of your images of greatness, otherwise our vision exercise and imaging work wasn't very valuable. Where's the inventory of visions of greatness? So you all have the refined version, but we didn't make additional handouts. If somebody wants to do that, you guys want that handy?
44:59 Otherwise, I thought I'd call them out as we got to it. And then lastly, we'll add these last, they should be framed, the goals should be framed in a way that invites the contributions of partners, specifically the four NGOs that have been taking the journey with the council, but perhaps other partners, for example, the Chamber of Commerce may be an important partner.
45:26 In one or more of the goals. But if the goals are framed in ways that don't invite that contribution, this alignment exercise won't work. The last two are really notes. They're not so much seven and eight. They're just additional notes. So that we don't get stuck in trying to write goal statements that themselves are measurable, it's actually just fine to have a series of indicators like you just did on the last.
45:53 Page under Commitments for Effective Municipal Services. If you look at the first one, financial stability is really a short-term goal statement. And then you have a whole series of indicators attached to that. So we can do the same thing at the 2025 level, which I believe we will do. And then lastly, there may be, I went through this again last night, and I was thinking that some
46:23 We fixed two endpoints, 18 months and 10 years. I think we've discussed a little bit, and you guys probably have, but I'm not around, that some of these goals, some of the indicators may be achieved on a different time scale, like five years out or seven years out. So let's call that out as we go through. So we're not locked into 18 months or 10 years, because that will help shape what you commit to in your action planning in January.
46:53 So I'm going to leave this up. Is there something that's important to you about goal setting on a 10-year time scale that's missing from here? These could be amended. What kind of framework I like to use in these kind of sessions? Just so we don't bounce all over the map. And I can keep going back to it and say, well, how is that measurable in fiscal performance or user terms? All right. So we're looking at...
47:25 Page one. And on page one, I'm going to try and jumpstart you a little bit. On the right-hand column, we have under vibrant economy, we have a whole series of bulleted elements there that all are framed in the column 2025 major goals. These are not all 2025 major goals. In fact,
47:52 I'm going to suggest to you there may actually only be two goals on that page. So this is me trying to see the process. What do you want to be your goal statements for vibrant economy in 10 years? Where do you want to arrive that's measurable? And then what are the component metrics that you want to attach to? I think the 10 months. The 10 months with a million plus in TOT is the goal. Right.
48:26 I think you're exactly right. Which infers year-round. Pretty much. So I'm going to use shorthand for these unless you guys change the language itself. So the proposal is that the goal statement is actually 10 months with 1 million in TOT, 1 million plus in TOT revenues. Daniel and I have a couple of discussions about that. Is that...
48:57 Average, does that unintentionally limit you, John, in the months in which you're already far exceeding? Yeah, I think it's, exactly. Yeah, I think it's, I think we need to use something to do with shoulder. Well, I think that, I mean, I think it's just, it's, you can just say it's 10 months because, I mean, we've got six months that we're not, that we shouldn't go backwards on. We've got three months that are fairly close and then we've got three months that we're.
49:26 Working halfway, a third of the way to halfway there, so. I think you could just put like 10 months with a million plus in TOT revenues achieved by growing shoulder. Again, I don't think you need to put it in there. Again, we're 1.9 million for December, January, February, March. We're not going to. No, I think it's just 10 months.
49:56 Five, six, seven words. Trust me, as we get to the next phase of this, it'll be a lot easier for you to process. I appreciate the succinct representation of it. Is that ambitious enough? Well, I think it's actually, it could be overly ambitious if we don't have the development to go with it. Because, you know, you're not going to move the dial of May, October, and November without the Convention Center or something else that's going to give us that.
50:22 I mean, it's not just magically going to happen. People are going to say, hey, let's go there in May. We have to have the infrastructure. So I think that 10 years, you're right. I mean, I think we'll be in nine months in the next two years. But that 10th month, or the 11th month, or the 12th month, is going to be a slog. Well, that's, and you already talked about that, because I mean, June right now, we're
50:49 We could potentially be looking at going backwards $200,000 in June. That's one of our months that's fairly close, but it could go well backwards. But then if November keeps going, then November. So it's a moving target, no question. Which is why I think leaving shoulder out of it is because how are you defining shoulder? We don't know what it is. We could have a great start to summer or we could have a great start to winter. This November, right now our high is $323,000 in TOT. That's a high for November.
51:19 We'll probably be over $400,000 this year, but we still have a long way to go to get to a million after a kick-ass winter, you know, winter month of November. Okay. So we're saying 10 months with a million plus TOG revenue. Period. Period. Yeah. So that becomes your goal statement.
51:38 You guys good with that? Yeah. All right. We can come back. We'll do a little resolve thing at the end, but we can come back. And the plus written out, because it gets lost, it's just a little plus sign. Nobody reads right past it. 10 million plus. Yeah. Yeah, I added it here. Okay. One mil plus. So, that would work. You just say it should be spelled. P-L-U-S. Or spelled plus. Because the, yeah. Or with minimum one million. Yeah, with minimum. Yeah, something. Whatever the wordsmithing turns out to be.
52:08 Is there, before we look at the component metrics there, is there another dual statement on this page? This isn't a test, you don't have to flip my expectation. Just under vibrant economy or under? Just under vibrant economy. Okay. The green stuff. Say it again? The green part. Yeah, just the green part. I would say expanded events calendar is a goal. I agree. I agree. Yeah.
52:37 To me, that's an outcome. I'm looking at something that, because I'm going back to vibrant economy, and I very much appreciate using this TOT thing as a metric and a goal. It makes a lot of sense. I'm looking for the thing that balances, and I'm cognizant of things we've talked about. If we do everything we do, we're just going to blow this place up. It's going to get too hot.
53:05 It's just not going to be a place to live. It's not going to be a place to actually live. So I'm looking, I'm kind of looking at this expanded job base for young employees. I've got a problem with the age range in there. But, because I think in the conversations that you and I have, that specifically, I think we're looking at late 20s, early 30s, people making decisions to stay in the community versus, okay, I'm not going to live before condo anymore. It's that slice that needs to get focused. But I'm looking for something that...
53:34 That would keep this, that keep things in balance. So I'm looking at that quality job base, but not defined by change. Yeah. I don't know why we define that. Yeah. Quality job base, whatever. Yeah. But I'm wondering if that's the appropriate goal that would keep us in balance with, so we have a higher global economy, we're not just... But again, I think in the succinct world, it's expand job base.
53:59 Sure. If that's the spirit to keep things... I mean, it's the same thing. I mean, the way you look at it here is if you're talking about a $25 million budget in 2025 and we've got all this business coming to town, then we have to go back and look at the issues with where people are going to live. Exactly. I don't care how old they are. I mean, it's great, sure. So if that will provide a balance, then that's the kind of thing we're looking for. I mean, we're going to need people to build things. Sure.
54:29 So we're not just going to go to 20, 25, 25 million dollars by doing what we're doing right now. No, exactly. Yeah, I think it's an increased career opportunity. I wouldn't say, I don't know about that. I'm not sure being a server at the side door is a career opportunity. Yeah, yeah. For many people it is. But it is for a lot of people, and I don't think we should be in the business of judging that. If somebody is a 50-year-old bartender and that's fulfilling and sufficient for them, then...
55:00 But I think the career is the important part, that it isn't just, you know, that you can have a career here, not just a job. Right. So you're looking to expand that quality of that job in terms of is it career, is it economics, is it all the pieces that roll into it? Yeah. I mean, the careers we're talking about are in three major categories. It's hospitality, rec, and tech. Yeah. Right? Mm-hmm. Yeah. Governments, they want to work. Good point. Yeah.
55:29 Yeah, that's a good one. That could work, but that's as long as we all, I think we also understand that that is the balancing thing. Yeah. That's certainly what I saw as your second goal. Nice job. You actually have four bullets in a row that kind of say the same thing four different ways. They're slightly nuanced, but what you want as goal two is
56:01 Remember, this is not increased as in plan to. This is the outcome in 2025. So how do you want to spend an amount of time? Expanded career opportunities. I think it's job-based. Expanded job-based. I did say it, but I came here for a job. I mean, it's my career, but I came here for a job. So expanded job-based opportunities? Expanded job-based opportunities? Or just job-based?
56:36 Well, that does infer more opportunity. Expanded, doesn't it? I think job base is pretty wide work. Again, if I think you're talking about career opportunities, while you could say that a career opportunity of working to register at Old New York, there are some things that are jobs.
57:02 To John's point, you can go expand a job base and over here in terms of outcomes. I was going to ask you what the metrics are on that. Well, and I think expanded job base also infers all that diversity and non-snow dependency and all of that. Yeah, I think expanded does a good job of that. So a good way to test this and test our assumptions, is that measurable today through 10 years out?
57:31 The metrics are kind of readily available. Can you qualify it and parse it into a bunch of qualitative elements? Of course you can. Is it essential to achieving a vibrant economy? Not today, but 10 years out. This is a really good example of how I think we do the whole rest of this document. All of this language here, and we've got two goals. Do you see a third goal?
58:04 I'm not suggesting there is, but just to be thorough. Well, I think we have to talk about housing. We have all these people here, this expanded housing opportunities. I think we talk about it in another place. Expanded housing opportunities. I think it's part of making the economy vibrant. You can't have jobs without, expanded jobs without expanded housing. Agreed. And so a good question for you. If you look at page four of the version I have, so we have a whole...
58:35 Page on Housing there. And so I want to encourage you to not repeat goals, but make sure that the metrics, outcomes, and timing accurately capture what you're doing. Which one is it? It's under
58:58 Housing on page four? It's on page three of the previous project. It's developing a comprehensive community plan. There's a whole bunch of housing. So that's part of developing a comprehensive community plan. Right. Right. So I think it's covered just like, you know, the third bullet under the stable economy where we were talking about the resort amenities and everything. Well, they're going to be under amenities. They don't need to be repeated. Right. Now it's going to make a note to move that. Yeah, move it. Uh-huh. So I think we're just trying to decide that if we...
59:26 If housing is covered in the, yeah. Does the vibrant economy stay here or are we just looking at goals? We see like all these headings we have, are those headings going away? No, we're going to get to each page in turn. So we are, they are, like goal one and two will be under vibrant economy. So these become your, so far these are your first two goals as we get to the next. In vibrant economy. In vibrant economy.
59:54 As we get to the next page. Well, we don't have anymore. Then we go to air service. Right. Yeah, but now air service is under enhance our recreation. But it's not under Bible. It stands at the same level. But it stays. Do you see what my point is that all of these things.
1:00:15 Contribute to a vibrant economy. Correct. Correct. And maybe a vibrant economy should come off, or it should be the overarching, I don't know, I'm not sure if it's necessary. I think that, once we get it all together, we can go back and look at it. Agreed. But I think that... Because it all ties together, to your point. But I think we've got a place where we're talking about metrics, analysis, tracking, some very fundamental components of the economy.
1:00:44 And I feel kind of comfortable that these pieces are getting locked in this place. To Jennifer's point, let me offer you an easy out on this. I think actually when we're done with this goal exercise, you get to remove all the headaches. But I was saving that for later, but since you kicked that cat into the center of the room, I think we get rid of all those. And that's why I've laid this out on two different sheets. So in a sense what we're going to do is we're going to have a series of goals.
1:01:12 A series of metrics and outcomes attached to those goals. Because if we think about it, the entire overarching goal is to define and activate a strategy to create a sustainable economic security for the community. Exactly. So that's everything that we're doing ties back to a vibrant economy. And this priority area is enhance our recreation-based economy. So that's your big header. Now we're setting a whole series of goals. One's about
1:01:41 T.O.T. Revenue, one's about a job base. We're going to get to air service and technology and so on. So this will, at the end you'll go, wow, this made perfect sense. And so we decided we're going to kind of move this year-round resort amenities down, right? Yeah, because it's going to show up later under number three. Okay. So let's look at the rest of the stuff on page one and I'm going to try and speed us up just a little bit because we're kind of rehearsing the process in this first round.
1:02:10 Are there, in those, a list of sort of hyphen bullets there, are there key outcomes or indicators that you want to preserve for each of these two goals? Just on page one. So for example, we have increased visitation and shoulder seasons. So is that a standalone outcome that needs to be...
1:02:37 I think the value of what we've just done is that, and I would just chuck all the stuff out, and then when we get into working groups to work on the stuff, we visit and figure out what's needed. Yeah, how to define it. How to define it. And I think this is very useful when we're taking all the stuff and rolling it out, getting good goals, and I chuck all the rest, unless someone sees them they want. No, I think, I kind of agree with you, John. I think maybe if we go through and we get...
1:03:02 If we get the goals for all four of them outlined, and if we have time, then to go back or send it to the working groups, because some of these are repetitive or they're just slightly different versions of the same thing, and rather than us sit here and spend a long time debating, the wording is to... Can we work through all the goals? Because then that helps us align, well, where did we put the housing stuff? We got it all into one goal, then, yeah.
1:03:31 I like it because it also gets to my very last task, which was I was going to take you all the way back and say, can we simplify this any further? I want to just remind you that we generated these through an exercise up on the wall in which we were clustering like ideas. Correct. It went together so many times. The reason we have four different bullets that address a different component of housing or jobs was because four different people had a different...
1:03:59 Okay, so we can move on from page one to the next page. We've got three sub-headers here. Air service, leverage technology, and new investment. What I want you to look at is where are the goal statements on this page.
1:04:27 I can give you, I mean, in a nutshell, I think you can put air service down as, you can do two things. You can say expanded air service to 50,000 plus employments based on demand and new terminal capacity, or you can leave the 50,000 employments out if you wanted to not. So it's either expanded air service based on demand and new terminal capacity, or it's expanded air service to 50,000 plus employments based on demand and new terminal capacity.
1:04:55 I see three different. One, you want to construct the air terminal. Well, I think what John is saying is if you say it, if it's based on new terminal, then that means the terminal was there. Expand air service to 50,000 plus in place based on demand and new terminal capacity. Okay. Correct. Okay.
1:05:24 Because the new terminal constructed has to happen in the interim. We want to build a terminal. We want to have 50,000 people. And we want to have six new cities. But I don't think we need to put that in there. I think it's based on demand of the new terminal capacity. Yeah, I think in year seven. Well, I mean, I don't, based on demand.
1:05:48 7 is about when the terminal would be? I don't think that is objective. From where we are now? I mean, it's an objective is to build a terminal. Yeah, oh, okay. Open 20. Yeah, build a terminal, get to 50,000 employments, and have six cities. Those are the...
1:06:07 Those are the measurables in my opinion. I was having trouble with the number of cities or whether or not it was replacements and things like that because that's kind of like a detail. I like the way John put it out there. I would not embed things like number of cities in the goal statement in 2025. I would make them part of the metrics because they may be midterm outcomes. We may decide to have four flights from LA. Yeah.
1:06:31 And what's your time horizon on the terminal? 1920. Six years. Six years. So I think that John Shields has it right in saying that 10 years out, the terminal is there facilitating this new demand along with everything else that you'll do. Right. But there are a lot of variables that we don't have control over right now. Plane types.
1:06:55 I was looking at one of the other things, talking about the fact that we're going to work with four airlines. We don't have four airlines that want to work with us. Correct. You know, we can't fly 737s from D.C. and Boston. So, I mean, there are some limitations. That's why I think if we say that it's expanded air service to get to 50,000 plus in planements, I can see us doing that with CRJs and Q400s or Embraer or whatever the next plane is without saying that we're going to be flying A319s here in five years. Yeah.
1:07:20 So based on what John has formulated, which is saying essentially the 50,000 emplainments based on the new terminal in demand, or whichever region you had them, is one of the outgoals and the timing that the terminal has completed in 2020. That's what I was trying to say. So that's, okay, so it's a midterm. So we would put a midterm. Right. Give me the clean statement again, John. Expanded air service.
1:07:53 50,000 plus. Appreciate that. I had the plus. Plus. We'll spell it out. 50,000 plus in claimants based on demand. So look at the rest of, and then Joe, I'm going to capture this sort of midterm piece here. Okay. Look at the rest of the items under air service and can we follow the strategy John Wentworth was suggesting earlier that we don't need to
1:08:35 Are there any other goals there as well? I think it's pretty critically important that somewhere we capture maybe an interim goal that we have a diverted flight in place. That's a totally separate deal. It should probably be achieved well before 10 years. We've got to put that in place.
1:09:06 That should be an 18-month goal.
1:09:36 I just want to challenge the thought process is that one of the metrics is, you know, we have a way to manage to put the flights and those passengers get here. So I understand exactly what you're saying. It's not, for me, it's not tied directly to the number of people landing here. It's tied to the guest experience. It's a poor guest experience. And I say this understanding that we have a lot of constraints, but to just turn somebody around and send them back to where they came from is not the experience that we should be providing.
1:10:06 Another thing to consider is, you know, what type of passengers are those 50,000? Are they passengers for weekends? Are they passengers for a week? I mean, are we... What is our goal? And... Well, I mean, the employment number is the main number because the air travel... Come from further and stay longer. ...more than the drive. So it's not necessarily saying that we want them here Sunday through Thursday. It's not saying... It's just 50,000 people... Okay, should that... I may be saying...
1:10:37 Should we add that as a goal? 50,000 deployments, it's going to be a natural, I mean, I think it's going to be a natural piece that we are filling up the, just like the 20. We're filling up midweek? We're filling up midweek because we're not. Right, you're getting people traveling from a longer distance and staying longer. I mean, that's. Well, okay. I mean, capacity on the hill on the weekends, I mean, you're not going to. They can only handle so much. Part of the whole new terminal is you have three gates and you have three planes in there.
1:11:14 Right. No, and that's why I think that as you're working through it, you're going to deal with all those differences. I mean, I still remember the picture on the Mammoth Times. I think the name was different. The brick wood standing there smiling when the 737 flew over his head at the airport.
1:11:45 And that was the future. 57. 57. Yeah, 57, 57. But, well, the airline industry changed. So I think that you want to leave it, there's going to be different plans and strategies that are going to get you to that. Right. And I think that's exactly what I'm saying. I don't think we want to, you know, says we're going to X number of markets because I'm not just going to have a market because it's going to fail. Right. And just for the high fidelity of this exercise, I'm going to suggest you keep the goal at this level.
1:12:15 You're going to develop an air service plan that's got a bunch of qualifiers in it, markets, number of planes, and so on. You're going to revise that on a year-in and year-out basis. So I think you add all those quality features, including user experience, but it may be worth noting. That's all I'm saying. I understand. You've got a problem you're trying to solve. Right. Completing the terminal kind of gets partitioned off, and I just want a diverted flight plan.
1:12:46 So what is the date? Was it six years? 2020, yeah. 2020, yeah. Right? Is that everybody's understanding? 2020? Yes. Is that where we hand them parachutes and let them jump out? Our clients would like that.
1:13:14 I know. Some would, yeah. Yeah, I was going to say, what an experience. Getting free skydiving. Yeah. How many employments are we doing now? It is. How many employments are we doing now? 26,000. Okay, 26,000. So we're not... We've done over 30. We've done 30 change. Okay, so what I'm saying is we're not even doubling at 50. And wait a minute.
1:13:42 And if we're going to a 10-month, if one of our goals is to a 10-month and we're at a 6-month right now, that's just doing the same thing we're doing. We're not expanding air service, in my opinion. Well, to me, I understand what you're saying, Shields, but if you don't have the terminal in place until 2020, you can't do expansion, then you're going to have to have a lot of that growth in the last couple of years because there's a point where before that, we're maxed out.
1:14:10 And we've also, when we did 30,000 deployments, we had 111,000 available seats. This year we had 54,000. So we've right-sized a lot of the air service. So I mean, we were, yes, we were bringing in more people, but we also had a lot of cost of that incremental. So I think what Shields is getting at, not to substitute words for you, but is this a stretch, sufficient stretch goal for 10 years out?
1:14:39 Given the qualifier about the terminals not in place until 2020, constraints on available seeds. That's what I was saying. With or without the terminal, it is. So you think it's realistic without the terminal? Yeah, we lost so much money on those. Subsidy-wise, we've spent a lot of money on those. It's higher efficiency.
1:15:21 It is. We're now much more efficient. That's right, which is great. So you're saying 50 is too low? Well, 50 is based on FAA forecast is where we grab that number from. Well, a couple things I'm saying. One is if we're trying to do the stretch. Right. This is your goal. Yeah. And you know what? Actually, I think it's very achievable. I mean, if we get all these things going like we're supposed to. Right. Okay. If we achieve the 10 months of a million plus.
1:15:51 50,000. So I would say, one, we should look at stretching it. Two, is I would look at, again, I think we have to look at midweek employments to expand that. I don't know if there's a subset of that saying, okay, hey, you know, if the 50,000, 15,000 or 20,000 are, you know, Sunday through Thursday. I'm just trying to...
1:16:22 Give some qualifiers there. John is, from MLT's perspective, is 50,000 conservative or stretch? I think it's just like the 10 months of viability. There are a lot of things that have to happen. Sure, that's right. Yeah, development, all the things we've been talking about. This is goal setting. Well, I mean, I think that if you give me 10 years to get us to 50,000, I think it's realistic. I mean, the FAA forecast is based on X number of flights from X number of markets and the exact plane type that we're using today.
1:16:54 So if that changes in five years, then, you know, a lot of all bets are off. But like Brady said, I think that the way that we're going right now, we're coming out of summer with a pretty strong number. We're in winter with a pretty strong number. We'll be back probably at 30,000 next year. I wouldn't push it. I don't think it's conservative, but I don't think it's a stretch. I think it's where it needs to be. Well, you know very well if you meet it at year 8, then you'll get a new goal.
1:17:25 Nothing prevents you from accelerating goals to a different time scale at any point in time. This is just to get the markers planted so we have to work. I think what you're saying, you're basically saying that if we're at 30 now, 50 in 10 years is just not enough growth. Well, I would say, hey, it might be enough growth, but I think we could stretch it more. But I think there should be a subset of that saying, hey, you know, we...
1:17:53 We're trying to work on longer stays. So can we have a goal of saying, you know, 20% or 25, 30% of that is midweek employments? It's just, you know, it's a goal. Yeah, whatever. What I'm saying is getting me like that. Yeah.
1:18:23 Our hospitality partners in the future are going to demand it, is all I'm saying. So we've got to figure it out. It'll add. No doubt it'll add, but we're at six flights a day and seven passengers a plane. So it's not like you can look at the growth in occupancy midweek because we're still going to have 2,000 people here and 10% of them are going to be. Okay, I'm going to help you move along.
1:19:00 Because what we're doing is we're action planning now. We're actually trying to solve the problem. And we can't do that here. I did capture shields that I think you have to, within this goal structure, somebody has to specify some qualitative aspects very clearly, including things like midway, length of day, and so on. So this is sort of the airport terminal version of the marketing plan. So you want to have all those components in there.
1:19:28 But if I can park that there and move us along, you guys, you can take that? I'm good. I'm good. Anything else under air service? I'm good? All right. How about leverage technology? What's the goal? All right. You can achieve that. Yeah, you can take that off. Yeah. Okay. According to the sheet. Okay. So what? I would close this.
1:19:59 Broadband opportunities are fully integrated into public and private sector operations. It's vague. There aren't metrics to them. This stuff is changing, so put that up. I mean, you know. Say it again, John. Broadband opportunities are fully integrated into public and private sector operations. Sounds good. Because even, I'm sorry, if we're at gigabit now, what's the term and what's the...
1:20:28 Capacity going to be in 2025. Gigabits old technology. Yeah, see, it's old technology. It's already here. Opportunities or actual capacity? Broadband capacity. Well, no, because there's the infrastructure broadband hardware side, but then there's the what we do with it, the articulation, the messaging, the communication, all the rest of it. It comes with that also.
1:20:58 It's not just your connection, it's your website that you have to communicate with. But we want to be honest, there's just the opportunity sitting here. Well, if it's... Broadband utilization is integrated. Okay. I was just trying to think, it's not integrated. Here's the fiber you can plug into. We actually want them to plug in. I'm just trying to clarify. Okay, sure. Broadband utilization is fully integrated. I think that's better than opportunity.
1:21:25 I thought opportunities is fine because utilization is something that, how on earth are you going to measure that? Well, you do though, but you can actually say how many of our businesses are connected to broadband versus other things. Only the ones that have survived. Broadband utilization is fully integrated into public and private sector operations. How many of our major businesses are connected to digital 395 at a terabit speed?
1:21:54 The key to this is public and private operations. That's a really nice qualifier. Is there anything, do we have a metric note of any kind attached to this? Are we good with that? Is that a sufficient goal to, essentially, you're casting a big net forward 10 years out. Do we have the value that you want there? Yeah, I think some of the other ones are going to, again, fall over to the metrics.
1:22:25 Because there are many examples to figure out. Right. Bring it all over there. How about the next one, then? New investments. We've got a series of bullets. Is there a new or separate goal? Like convention space. I think that should be separate than... But I think that's... Is that a metric based on something else? We get $500 million of new project investment. That's basically five or... I'd make convention space.
1:23:08 Open. That's a separate. Separate item? Separate item. I think they're all important. Well, it's a dance. There's a number that you need to summarize this in like an hour investment. Like what we were saying. That's what I'd be looking for is something because every single one of these would be a component of an investment plan. Right.
1:23:42 But you want a set of goals that are actually going to roll up and inform your economic development strategy for the community. So a new four- or five-star hotel property with convention space, what dollar would you attach? We could do like half a billion dollars. No, I'd say at least a billion. A billion dollars in investment. Yeah. And that would cover EFIDs and public and private infrastructure.
1:24:09 So it would be the aggregate of all strategies. Right. Ten years out. A billion dollars. A billion plus dollars. So then my question is, does it belong here or does it belong under where we're talking about financial stability? Great question. It depends on how many people come in on the plane. And how many big bills they have in their pockets? Yes. Exactly. So if you're trying to define it in terms of...
1:24:37 How many of the enhancing the recreation-based economy, then your goal should in some way reflect that part of it. If you're just talking about attracting new investors and things, maybe that goes down under the financial stability that's in another one of the areas. No, because I think that I would argue that our recreation, a recreation-based economy is the recreation, as broadly defined as you can define it, is the compelling
1:25:07 Draw. Okay. And from that draw, investors go, we are now going to invest. So how do you turn that into, what's the goal? The goal is to get them to invest. So I would say a goal, $1 billion in capital investment in public and private projects. I'd say, you've got to be careful.
1:25:33 Private, because then you'd get homes and whatever else. Commercial. Can't you just say a billion plus of new investment? Commercial investment. New capital investment. New capital investment. New capital investment. Just leave it at that. That's very clean. Yeah. That's all it needs to say. So a billion plus of new capital investment. Do we need to say public and private sectors? No. No.
1:25:59 Well, I don't know that there's enough public money for a billion. I think it infers a combination. Correct. Yeah, but that's more detail than you want in your goal. $120 million. Just for that. Then you've got all the other stuff, the detention centers, and you're probably fine with hotels like that.
1:26:25 Right there, that's 699. Right, now we're on running the lab. Develop comprehensive community plans. On this section, we have a community vision as a subheader. We have housing. That's it. So we have housing and community vision under develop comprehensive community plan. What are the goals? Same exercise we've been doing.
1:26:58 The vision plan executed, the story map, I think needs to be somehow worked into this. I don't know what the right language is. Well, if we developed it in the first 18 months and implemented it somewhere, what is it that the story map looks like at the other end in 2025? I would say that it would be current. In 10 years from now, the story map will be current where we're at.
1:27:32 Yeah, I mean, it's what we're building is a visioning, if you will, a master plan. I call it a master plan, a story map. But, you know, it's something that will be implemented over not just 10 years, maybe 15, 20 years. So we'll be right in the middle of it someplace.
1:27:59 Where will we be that we will commit to? Right. What's the goal? I think we've just said a billion dollars of... I think if you look at that second bullet point, is it really a story map, is that what creates even by voice? I think it does. I think selling it. So potentially if you combine the first two, it could be a story map completed and utilized to sell Mammoth as a place to live, work, recreate, and invest.
1:28:28 You know, I really think those things can actually happen in the first 18 months. Well, yeah, this year, there's a lot of, this is, in 10 years, we've certainly been successful in that. Right, and we're, but in 10 years, we're continuing to utilize it. In 10 years, you've actually. It's a place to live, work, recreate. Right. Yeah, I think Colin's right, and the reality is, is you might have the map done, but knowing the construction cycle and everything like that. That's right. You know, it's going to be close, and you're going to have seen X amount done.
1:28:56 I don't know whether or not goal five kind of covers. That's what I said, yeah. Do you need to say more or do we put in something about, I think that having the qualities there is still important. I like the statement because you're taking something you've done and you're actually utilizing it for this purpose. The goal is to take this thing and create, it's selling or it's... So is it story map projects implemented and then the selling part?
1:29:24 Yeah, I don't know, I think it's up to, we're using it as a communication tool, and I think that goes both. Well, to community and to an investor, to investors, right, to both. Right. Whether that's visitor, investor, to the day, because I like the idea, it's a little different strategy, because we're talking about, you know, the comprehensive plan, which that's one of the reasons for it, but there's other reasons too. Sure. It helps with implementation, so.
1:29:54 Let me play this back to you. If story map is a sort of shorthand for the comprehensive plan, and you are actively able to sell from that map, deliver your value proposition to investors, tourists, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, in 10 years, that would be an enormous accomplishment. How do you capture that in a statement? A short statement. Yeah.
1:30:22 Give it to us again. All right. So it's story map completed and utilized to sell Mammoth as a place to live, work, recreate, and invest. Yeah, I was kind of suggesting that it utilized. In use. Yeah, story map is in use to sell Mammoth Lakes as a place to live, work, recreate, and invest. So I can use the rest of that.
1:30:59 Yeah. Yeah. In use or utilize? No, we're using it. In use? In use sounds. It's more like USA Today 5th grade level instead of 10th grade level. Utilize is just a longer way of saying in use. Yeah, right. Which means you have to have updated and et cetera. So story map, so long as everybody's clear, story map is your language for your comprehensive plan. Correct.
1:31:31 So are there other elements in this section that get pulled out as separate goals or are they all metrics or outcomes associated with that goal statement? To me they're either metrics or outcomes or they were again duplicates of things we're going to put elsewhere. Is there anything there, just in the interest of being thorough, is there anything else that stands out there that needs to be separately captured?
1:32:01 If not, so far, I did this in advance. So far, we are exactly on it. All right. Next section. Go ahead. I was just going to say, so far. So far. He's not over. He's not over. All right. Next section. Housing. I would suggest that I fully support this vision of the story of Mammoth. It is as described. Housing does not.
1:32:33 So I'm thinking that housing either needs to go into economy or we should put it as its own section or something. Because it doesn't, it doesn't. I see what you're saying. This thing is, it's good, it's focused, it's very clear to me what the story of that process is. But housing, housing doesn't fit. I think it does. I think it's. No, I think what John is, at least what I hear John saying is housing.
1:33:02 Might be a goal of its own? Yeah, I would go. I would do it as a goal. Yeah. I would really encourage this. But let me ask you to say a separate heading over here completely. I would say separate heading completely. I think it's... Well, let's just put it as a goal because I think when we get back we may find that all of them, that one, two, three, and four all become one statement and we have a list of goals that apply to all of them.
1:33:32 Because remember, we keep doing this. We keep saying, well, does it go here or it goes there? So I'd say, let's set it up with a goal and then worry about when we go back whether or not the subheadings on the right-hand side or the strategic priorities on the left-hand side end up getting rewritten when we're going through it. Yeah, because that makes sense. Because the storm accident is going to encompass everything. Correct. It's going to encompass everything. But housing needs its own place. Right.
1:33:58 I can see it being part of the economy, but if that doesn't quite fit, then make that as its own thing. Well, let's just go through the goal on this. Let's just go through the goal on this and then... Okay, so what's the goal? Well, again, not wanting to put in numbers and not wanting to presuppose master agreements or CEQA documents and things like that. Leave all that out. Yeah, I think it's kind of like what we did on...
1:34:28 Where goal number two, it's more like expanded housing opportunities and then which kinds, where they go, et cetera, are over in the metrics outcomes. I'm also looking at it as a metric that the housing situation, I think we've got a lot of work to do to define what the housing needs are that are particular to our idiosyncratic community. The housing thing needs to track with our goals.
1:34:58 So if we get a billion dollars of investment, if we expand our air service, if we start doing all this stuff, the housing opportunities have to track with it. Right, but so that's what I'm saying is your goal is something about, you know, expanded in number and type or something like that. Because you've got, what's that thing called, Jennifer, that you have to do every so many years where you actually analyze? Yeah.
1:35:27 Yeah. So, John, there's already something that, well, I've seen two of them, so I don't remember what the schedule is. But there is something out there where all that is analyzed. How many houses do you have that are overcrowded? How many da-da-da-da? Where's your need? That kind of stuff. Okay, so that document, whatever that... That goes over in metrics. Fine. But then, I think Shields and I have this idea that our housing program tracks with our community investment.
1:35:52 Jo's saying the same thing. She's actually analogizing this to goal two. So if, in fact, you're going to set the metrics for driving more revenue, increasing the job base, and you don't have a goal for expanding your housing stock, the rest of this, that becomes the weak link. Yeah, exactly. So you want it to track. Want it to track. I think that's good. Because it needs it to expand and tighten the scope.
1:36:20 Expand in type and scope to meet demand is similar because, you know, number three talks about expand to meet demand. It's an easy way to wrap it up with the words that make sense but without getting into X number here and that number there. Produce the words. Somebody give me the seven to nine version. Expand housing. I'm sorry, what? To meet demand.
1:36:48 Expand housing types and whatever, expand housing to meet demands. Types and opportunities. Options. Housing options to meet demand. To meet and track with. Well. And that's where I think our story. Yeah, expanded. Expand to expand. Will really help. Housing options. Options. To meet demand. See where it goes.
1:37:21 Yeah. I don't want to... Because demand will have... We will have figured... All these other things we do, figure out what to meet demand. Housing options meet demand. This is the 10-year statement. Yeah. Right. Housing options meet demand. Expanded housing options meet demand. It's a little redundant, but if you wanted to just be very clear here, you would say 2025. Okay. So this is where you are.
1:37:51 And so you're describing a change in the market at that point in time. Right. So this is extremely key because all the rest of this falls like a house of cards. Right. Well, and we don't get there unless we have all of those plus whatever else we're going to have. They all have to be happening. Just for the sake of being thorough, is there any sense in also adding the word improved? How do you mean?
1:38:23 Well, in the sense that, you know, I think one of the housing challenges we have here, in addition to just expanding options, is improving our existing stock. Agreed. So, I don't know that it's critical, but I just... I agree with you, but to me, if it's not livable, it's not an option. So, to me, by saying having the options there infers livability.
1:38:45 And your metrics could talk about. I mean, when we get into the specifics of it, we've got to talk about all the different options. Oh, yeah, all the options, yeah. I just wanted to bring it up. No, you're right, is that. We have to deconstruct a lot. Deconstruct. Deconstruct itself. And reconstruct. The other thing, in the 10 years, I don't mind staying in the 2025 demand.
1:39:12 But ideally, we're meeting that demand through this panel. I'll just say it's increasing demand. Yeah, that's a way to say it. I guess, yeah, if we wait until we get out there and say, oh, here's our number, I don't think this is going to happen. Yeah, I mean, we haven't decided. It's also not going to be just 2025. No.
1:39:31 Exactly. Yeah, I mean, we're just... In fact, it was obvious this year that there was more construction going on. We're not putting specifics to it right now. ...by construction companies. We don't need it. I think it should just be demand. Just demand. Because the demand is whatever it is. Well, that's true. I don't know why we need to stay. It's a supposition...
1:39:58 That demand is increasing, but I think what you want to do is say if everything else is true and we meet demand. It's going to be increasing. It's implicit. So, you guys okay with that? I got more stuff. So expanded housing options meet demand. And, Colin, we have a note here to carry forward improved housing options as one of the key metrics. This might be a metric. I'm not sure. But it came off of page two.
1:40:28 Under new investment is the daycare and preschool offerings. I know that's a real issue today, and I know that we have this, we want to have an expanded job base, which means we're going to need daycare and preschool offerings. We're already seeing that as a challenge right now, and that's probably just going to grow. I feel like it needs to be addressed either as a goal or as a metric maybe within housing.
1:40:55 Perhaps. I don't know. Or somewhere. I think it's a metric, but it might be a metric of number two. I mean, as you say, we know it's already not adequate. It's just like right now, we know that our housing options are not adequate to meet the demand right now. But I think it will end up somewhere in the metrics. We have a group of these community service items like child care being a highlighted one right now that are deficient almost today in what it will look like.
1:41:22 If all this is getting successful, what's our role in creating those other community services that are going to be necessary? Isn't that a private issue that's going to be done? Yeah, I agree, but when this head starts and such, and like in housing, it's not uncommon for child care to be coupled with housing developments. It's very uncommon. That's true. Just presume that you're going to need it. Yeah, and you build it on site along with your housing.
1:41:52 So I've just codified it slightly sloppily here as for goal two associated with expanded job base, daycare, preschool, and other support services. Whether or not it's connected with, I mean, it'd be fantastic if you can build it with a project for affordable housing, but.
1:42:19 I think it makes a lot of sense to connect it to the job base versus housing. Yeah, it could just become a metric in that later. So then anything else under housing? They've done a great job of getting down to what I would call the right number of homes. Next page, we are good here. Enhanced community amenities.
1:42:51 Serving residents and visitors. I think we've changed that to enhance amenities serving residents and visitors in our earlier dialogue. Right. And so we have recreation and arts and culture separated as subheaders here. Where is our, what's our, I think we can combine both these two. I would say expand and enhance facilities and programs to support.
1:43:21 Sustainable Recreation Opportunities. We'll get it up there and then we'll wordsmith it. Yes. Expanded and enhanced facilities and programs to support sustainable recreation opportunities. Expanded recreation. Expands facilities and programs to support.
1:43:53 Sustainable recreation. Okay, so I'm going to take the two out. Yeah, it's pretty broad. Support. That's a big push. Sustainable recreation. Yeah. Sustainable recreation. Yeah. And I think it is expanded and enhanced because the reality is that we have some facilities that...
1:44:18 Still need some enhancement. Don't take a capital project. I think a key idea that I'd like to discuss is integration. If we're doing a billion dollars of capital investment, we've got this air service, we've got all these things going on, the recreation opportunities have to be directly integrated into everything. And I'm interested in having that word integration considered as part of this.
1:44:48 Trying to get my head around that goal. I mean, I get it. The goal to me is a little, I mean, you could say it that way, but I think we have to be doing something that's action-based, that ties in 10 years from now, when people are making a decision to come here, the degree to which the things, the experiences they're going to be having is integrated into everything that we do, it's a competitive advantage.
1:45:18 Over other resorts and other destinations. Okay, there to me is a goal. I mean, I look at the first like six, seven goals there and there's, you know, 10 months with a million, 50,000 employments, 1 billion plus in capital. Number eight, I think it's just, it's too broad. Too broad for me. Well, it's broad and it's soft and it's not very, I don't know how you put the metrics to it.
1:45:44 Well, I think all the things, John, that are over here, 100 miles of trails is a metric against that. It's a metric against it, agreed. Okay, so let me get back to that word integration. I like what you said, you know, that puts us above any other mountain resort, a competitive advantage. I mean, I think that's the goal.
1:46:12 Something like that. Yeah, just switch it. I'd like to say, okay, against who? I mean, we can do some of this in the next six months. And that goal is met. What if we just said support integrated sustainable recreation? Actually, I think where John maybe is going is you just get rid of support and you just, and programs integrate. Oh, integrate. And really what you're...
1:46:46 Then it's an open sentence and you want to finish it with... Sustainable recreation. To me, it's not enough. Measured against what? I'd say measured against other resorts. To me, there's no measurement there. There's measurement in all the others. There's opportunities for measurement in all the other ones. Well, the metrics are the...
1:47:24 The metrics describe everything, like the stuff that's under recreation and arts and culture right now are the metrics, but I think that you want to leave it a little bit vague because whatever the next recreation opportunity is that comes up in 2023, if you didn't have as a, you know, I don't want to short ourselves by saying we only wanted to have X, Y, and Z. No, agreed, agreed with that, but I'm just saying measure it against, okay.
1:47:54 Expanded and enhanced facilities and programs to integrate sustainable recreation, but it's lacking in what? It's very rewarding. Does that drive our visitor experience? It is our visitor experience. Well, right, and is that a measure? Is that a goal? You're right. Because it gets to, I mean...
1:48:20 The sustainable gets to things like carrying capacity and all the rest of it, which is important. We need to start, we need to be in the business of making sure people have good experiences. So I think the sustainable thing can cover that when we get to metrics. Well, my point is there's metrics in all those goals above, pretty much. I mean, we can, and then we can get into specifics, agreed, you know, the 100 miles of.
1:48:49 Trails, all that type of stuff. But I'm saying, measure it against what? If it's other resorts, mountain resorts, if it's, you know, in California, if it's, you know. Well, the demand, I mean, you could do like a demand analysis. If we get this right and we've integrated our capital investment with our experienced amenity base, then it works. Peak visitors, people come, you know, people come back.
1:49:18 And in that case, the demand analysis happens up front and soon, and I think we kind of already did that in saying that we're going to implement a strategic plan for investment of, you know, R&U and things like that. I think you're going to be getting the demand analysis. You're going to get to that. I think, to answer your question, Shields, I think we have to measure it against both ourselves and the competition. Where we are now is, yeah. Yeah, that's great, and I think you're on the right track there.
1:49:47 But I don't want to say, you know, like X or Y or Z because they may totally change. Yeah. But it's against, you know, it's measured against where we are now and whatever the competition is going to be at in 2025. Become a top five or top three. Based on what? Yeah. I don't know. I don't know.
1:50:14 I'm throwing ideas out there. I wouldn't link to any of that. I might suggest you use language like provide distinct competitive advantages, something along those lines. And I think the only thing you can measure yourself against is where we are currently. I mean, I think that's where you can say this is where we've come.
1:50:33 Yes. From here to 2025. And I think we have to presume that what we did in the time were made because we answered the questions of why it was a top-tier priority project because it met X, Y, and Z. But it also goes to things like we don't know where we are in terms of so like over Christmas with the conflagration of human beings that's going to happen, say, up in Lakes Basin.
1:50:59 And all the negative experiences that people are going to have, because we haven't put together, with our partners like the Spirit, a good program for that. We don't know where we are with that stuff. It's Mammoth. We just do it. Everybody shows up and things are crazy. That's just kind of what it is. We have to start getting, so the expanded and enhanced facilities and programs, that sustainable recreation, that all kind of works. We flip that around.
1:51:23 The question is about integration within all these other things that we're doing. How we integrate the recreation experiences into the capital investments and that kind of stuff. Yeah, it goes with goal five. It goes with goal one. I think we can talk about advancing and expanding facilities and programs. That's totally measurable.
1:51:44 Yeah. Okay, that's fine. And I think sustainable... If you go from 100 miles of trails to 200 miles of trails, that's measurable. Right. If you go from 50 kids in a program... Understood. But then you have to have sustainable there because it's a carrying capacity issue. I mean, the landscape... It's the same thing with housing. I mean, it's like if we get... You know, the landscape's only going to carry so much stuff. And we've got a federal agency at some point to start looking at this and going, wait a minute, you guys are destroying this place. I mean, you're doing a great job, you're all having a great time, but the impacts you're having on the landscape are going to be a problem.
1:52:13 So the sustainable piece is really important. And I'm just looking at how to make sure we integrate these. Yeah, I think you almost flipped that on that. Integrate sustainable recreation. And it's through the expanded and enhanced, I think, facilities program. The program isn't just about what you're programming at a facility with kids, but it's the programming of our parents. So what if we did just start the sentence with integrate sustainable recreation through expanded and
1:52:41 I can't read it sideways. Enhanced facilities and programs. That'll work. I think that'll work. Flip it around? Yeah, just flip the sentence. Yeah, just flip the sentence. Eight. But now we won't be able to read your writing. Integrate, yeah. Sustainable recreation. It has to be integrated. Integrated. Integrated. Sustainable recreation. Sustainable rec. Through. I'm going to read it down. Expand and enhance facilities and programs. Mm-hmm.
1:53:22 Shields, does that work for you? I know what you mean. Can you articulate it to me? Better measurable. So I'm going to suggest that...
1:53:38 What happens over here is... What happens over there is the X number of trails and so on and so forth. Two kinds of outcomes are either physical products or actual ingredients. Yeah. So you're going to measure in terms of user activities. That fits our criteria over here. And carrying down from the previous one is this is where the...
1:53:58 Single integrated events calendar of more events falls instead of wherever we had it before. It's kind of duplicated here. Yeah. I think also that it goes the importance of getting these terms, you know, they're going to mean something. Yeah. I mean, every single one of those words, you know what I mean? It's got, it's not just, needs to have some teeth. Yeah. And when they get into the metrics, it's like, yeah, we got to answer what integrated sustainable, right, for all these things.
1:54:26 Each word that typically should be worded when you get into a session when you're putting meat on it. You're defining it through programs and tasks. I'm just saying in 2025, we want to go back there and say, did we achieve these goals? Sure. Yeah. And we have to say, yeah, this was built, this was approved. Yes, and, or no, and why. The descriptive goal statement, the associated metrics to breathe life into it. Right.
1:54:58 And we'll spell this all out correctly. Are there any other section of enhanced amenities serving residents and visitors? In my mind, they're all metrics. They're all metrics. That we can list out there. Like the USOC, okay, you know, timing, that takes either three years or five years or seven years.
1:55:28 And we are on the last on social issues, effective municipal services. And under this area, we have four subheaders, financial resources, compliance, workforce, and hard assets. Maybe I missed you guys talking about it, but I only have page six or seven.
1:55:54 It's, or on the old version, it's four of five. Yeah, don't go over the numbers, you're going to get confused. Yeah, it's just the pagination. Yes. Far be it for me to be confused. It's just the pagination. It's to keep us on our toes. I thought we were good. All right, we're doing good. It's three o'clock. I know you're messing with us. We get out of here on schedule, though. We've done up no mysteries.
1:56:20 What do you see here under effective municipal services looking at these subheadings either together or separately? What, if any, goal statements stand out? Remember, where have you arrived in 2025 as it relates to effective? Now, what did you plan to do? A lot of this stuff has already been... I mean, there's metrics here, but a lot of it's been... Well...
1:57:01 I think if we have all this stuff is happening, we'll certainly have a much larger budget. Well, yeah, and those are, and I think that most of what we have on the right side are really the metrics. So it's kind of like, so if you're saying you're...
1:57:18 Effective municipal services is that somehow, and I'm being simplistic to start with, we're spending the money in the right way, we're giving out the right, you know, the right services are being performed and they're being performed in an efficient, effective manner, is really what your goal is. Something along those lines, as opposed to these specific metrics. Also, you have, I'm going to put it hard assets, almost like you have the necessary public facilities in place to carry out your...
1:57:47 Well, to me, that's a part of we're providing services. But a lot of those hard assets, to me, are going to end up being part of the story map. Well, they're called out there, but do we actually have the resource ability to do it? So what if we said something like... Achieve financial stability? Enhanced...
1:58:18 Municipal assets and financial resources provide an effective town government. Don't forget it while he writes it down. Write it down fast. Say it again. Want to try it again? Did you write it down? Yep. Enhanced. How many times have we used enhanced? That's all right. That's all right. Enhanced municipal assets and financial resources facilitate an effective government.
1:58:52 Yes. Facilitate? Mm-hmm. A financially solvent government? Solvents, good. Resources. What's the effort of maybe not facilitate? Deliver? Provide? Provide? Deliver services? Deliver, and I forgot what your adjective was. I said effective. Effective, yeah.
1:59:38 Did you have been local in front of government, or how did you want to say that? I would just say government. Local? Or effective government. I would say government. Yeah. Yeah, if you say... Say that. An enhanced municipal asset and financial resources. Yeah, but you're also a lot to handle responsibility for those things that you have no jurisdiction. Yeah.
2:00:09 City of LA or the Fed. Well, are we going to say anything about the financial stability of our government? Well, that's our whole other, that's our goal over here for our economy. It's financial stability here. Is it government or is it government services? You want to add on there the financial stability that we've paid off the... Government? Okay. It needs to be government because you've got assets as well. I would say it. Okay. Resources. Increased our bond rating.
2:00:40 Well, those are metrics. I know they're metrics. I'm just saying, but where does that metric go in that goal? Financial resources. Yeah, your growth and assets and financial resources allow you to do all of that. Pay off your... Pay off your... Yes. And those all become metrics. Yeah, and actually, I like enhanced there better because I know one of the things that...
2:01:14 We have worked on is delivering services in different ways that don't necessarily mean expanded. And I think that one of your huge metrics under number nine is the use of the NGOs to provide some of the things that might have been done differently in the past. Yeah, exactly. That's a key part. I think that, you know, it's a differentiator in the community business. I mean, that's how we're getting, I mean, the capacity we've got around this.
2:01:42 Right. So let me ask the question, it seems like what we did is we encapsulated financial resources and hard assets into a goal statement. Is there, before I go to compliance and workforce, is there anything else under financial resources or hard assets that we conceived before that needs to be appended to this or forms a separate goal statement?
2:02:14 Well, to me, the hard assets end up over in the metrics, those which are obtainable. Law-abiding citizens and businesses. Well, but to me, compliance is a result of having the assets and resources. It's not a separate goal of its own. No, it's a metric. Right. Yeah, I think these, everything they're under...
2:02:43 Compliance are very much tactics in the pursuit of this. People are voluntary. Yeah. That's right. How about workforce? I think that the, Jo's kind of your point about the integration, the working with NGOs and these kinds of things. Yeah. The degree to which we're successful, which I think we all have every intention of being, informs the nature and the makeup of the workforce we're going to need to deliver that.
2:03:14 And I think it's, you know, the municipality retains and invests in the workforce that's necessary given the alignment that we have with the NGOs. I'm not sure how to word that. And that's kind of why I was intentionally vague there because if you tie, like, hard assets, it's just physical buildings, but, you know, bodies.
2:03:39 Yeah, to me, asset, yeah. Manpower, those are staff, capacity, that's all an asset that we have. Right. And the all-encompassing sense of, you know, municipal assets. Right, correct. Every resource that we have, whether it be building manpower, etc., to deliver services. Right, we have, but I'm looking for the nuance, which may be in a metric, about how we staff, as part of our staffing, which we're talking about, in terms of workforce, we are configured to support
2:04:09 This innovative delivery system. And that goes to the statement before we had that 21st century statement about the workforce. Does that mean we have new ways of delivering service? In other words, the workforce may not be employees of the town. Sure. But there are going to be employees of the town that are critical to make this work. What I'm saying is there's this integration of how we provide service to what you're saying. And the other side of that, one of the statements made before, we go to a 24-7 government.
2:04:40 How do we respond? We do a lot of that now with snow removal, police services, those types of things. But are there other elements in how we provide those services? Maybe that's too much detail. I think that's metric. Innovation starts to get their input beyond that. But issues like if we're going to be a successful destination, this issue of 24-7 government is a very big deal because we're heading into the busiest two weeks
2:05:10 of the year, how are we all aligned to ensure that the visitor experience is the best it can possibly be? And we can't do that. These are all metrics. These are some tactics within there. We all need you working some shifts. Yeah. But that's exactly the point. We all got to be, when we get into a situation like that, we all have to work into shifts, which goes also about, I was concerned earlier about if we're going to increase shoulder season, increase peak season, when is anybody going to get a break around here?
2:05:39 We'll figure all that kind of stuff out. But how we configure ourselves into a 20th century alignment to be successful with what our core business is, I don't know what kind of a word you use for that, but we have to be aligned with that. I still think it falls on the metric side. Yeah, I think you're right. Yeah, I agree. I think we're all confined with that term.
2:05:57 Because if you haven't done that, if you haven't figured out how to be innovative and do the 24-7 and so on and so forth, then you're not effective. And everything on there is innovative. Some of the rest of this is pretty innovative for this town.
2:06:26 Right. Yeah. Yeah. The world has changed. Yeah. We'll continue to. Quick facilitator's perspective on this. So, in working with other communities who arrive at similar goal statements, in a sense, your municipal assets and financial resources describe your enhanced capacity and what you're circling around is what the additional piece you need, which is enhanced capability. Capacity is your
2:06:56 Physical assets, people and resources, but experience, delivery, innovation, that's about, can you deliver in 2025 all of this and all this enhancement without expanded capabilities? More innovative, more, you cannot, you will not be competitive. So you could encompass that with enhanced municipal assets, financial resources.
2:07:27 Capability in addition to capacity, is what you're saying, yeah. So it goes to workforce talents, innovation, strategies. In other words, 24-7, you just want a government that's adapted to this goal set. Well, no, we want a government that's helping us get to those. Absolutely. It plays its role.
2:08:06 Okay, so my only concern is that we got through all these goals and we have our really nice statement and everything, but I'm concerned that the 4C about effectively integrating and utilizing the expanded capacities of the NGOs should maybe be a goal. On our side?
2:08:40 Well, what I'm saying is we've got it stated there as a 2017 goal, but we don't have an equivalent on this other side that really says we accomplished all this because we worked together. Or is that also inferred? I don't know. Is it inferred? Okay. Well, that's true.
2:09:08 So you don't talk yourselves out of this too quickly. I think this is actually a brilliant insight. Is that somehow we have to say that that way of working is still happening. All right, I would support putting that as a goal to your point. But I don't know how we say it, that we've worked cooperatively.
2:09:34 Over the last 10 years, it's made the other 9 happen. And I don't just know how you'd say it. But I don't want it to all of a sudden have dropped out of 2025. Because it's going to be these relationships. How about a goal that's worked so good the last 10 years, we want to do it another 10 years. We want to renew it. We want to renew it. Let's expand number 9, effective government in partnership with NGOs. That will do it. In partnership with NGOs.
2:10:06 Yeah, and by just saying it as NGOs, that leaves it wide open because I hope in the innovation in the next 10 years, there's some other NGOs that are established. I mean, housing is 10, 11 years old. That's our oldest one. MLT is six, five and a half. You know, so in another year or two, there might be an opportunity for another NGO. I would throw out, though, a distinction that these NGOs have been more...
2:10:36 No, no, but what I'm saying is as we're going through the innovation and we're trying to deal with getting all the other things to happen, I didn't want to specifically list them like we did in the 18-month one because there may be more NGOs by that time or more partners of other kinds. This is a differentiating aspect of your community that either will help you get to all the rest of this.
2:11:02 Or it will get in your way. And my bet is that it's going to help you achieve all the rest of your goals. Is it with NGOs or just with NGOs? Yeah, with NGOs. You leave the eye out. With NGOs, yeah. And to be clear, is the term of art NGOs, non-governmental organizations? Is it not a public-private partnership? No, I think it is. The key word there was in partnership. Yeah, yeah.
2:11:31 And John, I think that, yeah, it can be more broad. I mean, technically, NGOs were made up as this stuff was changing around. I don't think it limits us to only NGOs that the town has had some part in establishing. Right, but I think it's important because in the Forest Service world, they're very quick to say, oh, we're going to be partners. And if you're partners with everybody, it doesn't mean it. And we have partnerships with three...
2:12:00 Entities that the town's for, sorry, that the town specifically took direction by action of the council to incorporate, to establish. And that's, you know, that's not like we're friends with everybody. It's like, look, we've recognized specific capacities we want to have, the council took action, they could have them.
2:12:18 I'm okay leaving it that way, but I want to make sure that it's clear, it's not, we're just not doing everything. I think, I think that's part of the same discussion we had, is we know there are more partners out there that we didn't draw in in the first step, because we didn't have that direct relationship. Right. So I think that leaving it like that, it also gives you the opportunity to expand that if you need to, as you're starting to have with other, some of the other governmental jurisdictions. Right. We're rolling with four. Yeah.
2:12:47 Right. You know, there's going to be, yeah. That's different. That's different. Again, this is. This is contractive work, right? This goes into the decision-making process and accountability and strategic work. Yeah, I think that's one of the things we're trying to make. We do a lot of these other things. Right. But this does have some uniqueness to us in how we deliver these core delegates. Just a thought. After effective government to say,
2:13:32 With service partners where appropriate. Ooh. That's what you're really talking about. Yeah. Partners that deliver service. With service partners. And then that can be broader. What if you took the where appropriate off since it's 2025 and it was just with service partners? Well, the concern there is, is that just, well, we want to, you know, the more the merrier. Let's bring in lots and lots and lots of partners. And some of those might not be appropriate. That was my thinking on that.
2:14:01 I would kind of leave it the way it is. I mean, because the only sense that we're settling on this idea of the NGO is being the term of art. Correct, but it's a somewhat incorrect term because ESTA is not an NGO, it's a JPA. And that's why maybe service partners is a little broader. Leaves a little more options too, right?
2:14:32 With service partners. I think that that's what it should be. With service partners. Yeah. I think that's a clear word. And it's different. It's a nice kind of weird term. What do you mean by it? Well, it's this. And then the partners with NGOs are just like, oh, yeah, we're all. And then that allows us to expand it. Yeah, exactly. Oh, you want to be a service partner? We got contact.
2:15:02 Here's what we want. Be mindful of the time here. Are there any other goals that stand out in this section affecting municipal services? We will have four feet. You're at nine goals, which certainly is even better than the initial target I was throwing. I said 10 to 12.
2:15:34 It's a lot of consolidation. And that's true. It's why I state it more than once when you find that you can't. Exactly. So being able to get it all to one page, because when that's done up, it is one page. That's so important. And the nice part is you can do that as a goal statement, and you're not making number one has these two goals, number three has these two goals. Correct.
2:15:57 Yeah, they don't have to... No, they don't because as we saw, even in what's over there, they cross. So if you have your four, if your four areas are, yeah. Michael's going to make that look pretty. Beautiful. Like the circle images of greatness. So what I find is useful at the end is to play it back to you in context. But instead of just doing that, I actually...
2:16:26 Thought we might get here. And so I have a confidence feasibility scale for you. We're going to write goals. I don't know if you guys can see this. So you've got a five-part scale. One is, this is going to be difficult. And five is, we can do this. So I'm going to read them to you. Well, let me ask you a question.
2:16:56 Why are those the opposite ends of scale? Why isn't it this will be difficult and we can do this? This is a confidence rating. And what I find is that the level of difficulty is inversely correlated with confidence. So what we're looking for is where are you as a group, as a leadership team? If these are your goals, what's your confidence level? In the nine goals. In the nine goals.
2:17:26 Let me read them to you in context. Goal one, ten months with a million plus in total revenue. Five. T.O.T. revenue. T.O.T. revenue. Five. Five. Five. Four. I'm thinking, wait, I'm interpreting. This is going to be easy. So I'm saying. Yeah, yeah, see, I'm having the same problems. Just because it's difficult doesn't mean we can't accomplish it.
2:17:53 4.85. Confidence. That's right. Okay. It's just for those who can't do this. Come on, John. John. It's a five. If we can't do one, we're going to have a problem doing the rest of them, we'll tell you that. Exactly. If it's a five, then we haven't said, then we're just, we're not stretching.
2:18:19 Oh, no, no. That's a good point. No, I don't see it as that at all. I don't think that saying we can do it is not saying it's easy. No, no, no. It's a confidence. The reason, like John said, nine's easy, I think, ten's the hard one. Goal two, expanded job base. Yeah. I think 4.5. 4.5. We're going 4.4. 4.4.
2:18:56 Goal three, stay with me, expanded air service to 50,000 plus emplanements based on demand and new terminal capacity. I think that's a six. That's a six. I think that's a six. I think that's a five. I'd even be a ten. Goal four, broadband utilization is fully integrated into public and private operations.
2:19:26 I think the cost of it's going to be... The cost, right. Don't leave out that small piece. So they're already running the ads on something like 30 gigabyte into Monday. Really? Yeah. Now you're using the scale.
2:19:55 Goal five, a billion plus in new capital investments. I'd put that right in the middle, put a three. Goal six, story map in use to sell Mammoth Lakes as a place to live, work, recreate, and invest. That's gonna happen. Goal seven, expanded housing options meet demand.
2:20:33 That's a tough one because I certainly think we will expand housing options, but I think that's a perpetual struggle worldwide right now. I think you can look at these in a similar way. That's it, three and a half. That's it, probably 3.5. Three? Three is good. Consistent? Okay. Goal eight, integrated sustainable recreation through expanded and enhanced facilities and programs. Seven. Seven.
2:21:04 You said six, I've got to go one-up on it. Yeah. That's the confidence over here. I'd say, you know, since it's so nebulous, I'd say five. Five? That's a five. That's a five. That's a five. That's a line of goal number five, too. Yes. It's true. It is. It is true. So you've got to be mindful of it. Yes. This is about scalability. All right, so goal nine.
2:21:34 Enhanced municipal assets and financial, municipal assets, financial resources and capabilities deliver effective government with service partners. Effective government, that's a key, I'd say three. Oh, I'd say five. Well, I mean, I look at enhanced municipal assets, I mean,
2:22:03 It depends. I mean, if we are able to reach goal one. It's a four for me. Yeah, if you're one and five, I'm sure. Four? Four. That's a good number. All right. Not bad. So, your slam dunks are the story map and the expanded air service yielding complainants. Get to work. And your struggle areas are slam.
2:22:34 Broadband. These often difficult infrastructure capacity building stuff for all the reasons you already know. I think that's a pretty, that's very consistent with the way this plays out in many other communities. What I really like is the things that are going to pull you forward, the top end pieces you have high confidence in. Yes.
2:23:04 The system that you have to bring along to sustain that is always the lag or drag on the process. So I think you have what I would call an eyes wide open approach to these goals. So you should be, as a general rule, I would say you have a pretty confident framework here. And I think, you know, one thing that's important out of that is, you know, the slam dunks are all things that have
2:23:31 It's not necessarily their entire encompassing goal, but we have significant partners that are going to further that. If you look at the story map, we have partners that are engaged in making that a reality. Same with MLT really pushing on the expanded air service things and Mammoth Lakes Recreation really pushing on expanded recreation programs and facilities. So we already have very clear, tangible partnerships pushing that.
2:24:00 Well, housing, and the lift for housing is... Well, and I think... I was just calling out specifically the things that we've talked about. I don't think that's anything against housing because we know that housing is part of that infrastructure and having to figure out how to actually get it built takes longer. I think it's telling. I think it's a good thing that the two threes are the billion-dollar capital investment and the house. Those two things are tied. Sure. That's a good indicator for me.
2:24:28 We ask you, just to get you to a place of resolve so you can leave here with confidence today, are there any of these goals that if you just flat failed in 2025, the rest could all still be achieved? In other words, they have a low level of criticality? No. From my mind, they all have to happen. It's systemic. Yeah.
2:24:59 Is the reverse true then? Are these goals all interdependent? Well, I guess you could have one month where you could do $25 million, but that would solve it all. But I think those are existential at this point.
2:25:28 The question is really framed into the extent that you have control over it. Yes. All right. I think that's a solid framework. That's a nice distillation. Come a long way. Yeah, yeah. And it connects you very well to the council commitments in the near term. So I believe the next step is a little bit of work group activities specifically. And I think, again, stop me by.
2:25:59 I think what is going to happen is each of the NGOs, the council are settled on short-term commitments and 2025 goals. The NGOs are invited to do in your separate board processes is to deliberate on these goals and commitments and build on your prior inputs around what your incremental contribution is.
2:26:25 We've got two these out. And we'll have two things with that one being happened so that go back and have that discussion. But we also want some cross-pollination work groups so we have a council member, we have NGOs. That's right. And so we get that cross-pollination. It's not building in silos. And then the caveat I want to suggest to you for that is that you not have the how discussion but more the what discussion. Less about problem solving and developing action plans in work groups.
2:26:55 That's inconsistent with the framework we've been following. The idea here is that you build the work plan together just like you just built the rules together. So in the working groups, you're settling on the incremental contribution of each NGO to these outcomes based on short-term commitments. You've already provided input, but some of that input was not framed in milestone terms.
2:27:25 So you want to do that both at your governance level and in these work group processes. Then when you come back, we have a fully fleshed out set of beginning and end markers and incremental milestones. And we're going to put the action side of the how-to and the whole thing for 18 months' work activity group process.
2:27:50 Okay, I'm not understanding that at all because I thought the idea was, for example, on one of those previous ones that has been dropped out, there were assignments of who was going to grow events, and we all know we need to grow events, and I thought it was a cooperative way of figuring out how to do that, not...
2:28:13 Individually and then coming back with an action plan. I thought it was whomever was assigned to that would really try and figure out how do we get that accomplished. So I think that you can do that level of work in your working groups but without mapping out an 18-month plan. What I would hate to see happen is you're now putting an 18-month plan together in a whole separate series of working groups.
2:28:38 With no continuity of close. Describe us what are the next steps, because it's not clear what happens. Dan, your thoughts on... Literally, document by document, step by step, step back for a second, what happens next? Can I just say something real quick? I can't believe I'm doing this, because I'm hearing you wrap up, but I would be remiss if I didn't say something about the fact that we have four NGO partners in the room.
2:29:07 I don't see any clear goal or tie to ESTA anywhere in here. Well, ESTA actually, if you go through the document prior, the more fleshed out versions of these, ESTA has kind of a foundational contribution to a bunch of these goals. So they're... ESTA's here. Yeah, they're part of this. I'm just saying that a lot of those goals are clearly tied to...
2:29:36 Well, and we kind of threw it in there in the parking and the multimodal and things like that that are not.
2:30:01 I'm assuming that we're going to take each one of these commitments.
2:30:30 These guys would look at, with your boards, can we make a contribution to this? Is it a role for MLR, MLT, housing, rest in any one of these things? Exactly. Then, with that, then we assign working groups, right? Yes, I think you have a two-step process. Working groups is a thing, and then we bring the action plan out of that. I need to, because we've had some trouble in this process, funky documents, people not knowing what's happening next, I just want to make sure we leave here.
2:30:58 Right, for all of us to be confident, to be very clear as to what the next steps are. So we've had a very good session today, but I don't want to get confused. If everybody else is comfortable with it, I'm fine. It's just more like, I can clearly see how, you know, MLR can say, all right, we need to glom on to this goal of expanding and enhancing our facilities and programs for recreation. I just don't see that tie for ESTA, but maybe it's more in the need of what we do. I think it's global. I think it's probably global that it's going to be on the whole journey.
2:31:27 John, do you have an insight about that? Well, I think that's a good point, Colin. I think there really is something to that. From the beginning, I mean, for the very first workshop, it was clear there's a much more direct affiliation for all the NGOs that start with ML. If you put it one way. But to Joe's point and Michael's point, I think that the services that we provide for the town, in the town,
2:31:56 Need to be supportive of all of this and are that we provide, we create and provide a transit service that makes people realize they don't need a car and that differentiates Mammoth. They have a great experience here because they can come here, hop in the bus and get efficiently wherever they need to go. And that was kind of simply my point that a goal number 10 should be like Mammoth is a recreation destination where you don't need a car or something like that. You know, that it's like very clear and tangible. Yeah.
2:32:25 I'm just, I like round numbers, 10's good, and I just, I could see a place for that potentially that, you know, we really have some sort of goal tying back to the fact that if we do have a world class transit system, how that differentiates Mammoth from other places to live and to visit.
2:32:53 A lot of agencies have their own transit service and you pay to use it, et cetera, et cetera. We've actually said we want to be feet first. We want to be, if you have a car, park it, leave it there for the week. And it's free. And the transit service is provided free. Well, no cost to you, sir. That's what I mean. That's what I meant. Nothing's free. So I'm going to offer this. If you decide to add a tenth goal,
2:33:23 to frame that as an outcome. What I would discourage you from doing is not having ESTA sitting down at the governance level and saying, what's our contribution to each one of these? So for example, if you look at the list of metrics that are on the document there, there's a bunch of places where you can't realize the outcomes of this. ESTA's delivering them. They're just wondering if something like...
2:33:51 If we develop a comprehensive community plan, the goal of that or an outcome of that isn't that we have a planned community where vehicle travel is not necessary. I think it's in there. I think that that's... Actually, the story map is going to help with it. Yeah, I want to get us to a level where we're competent, we're doing what we're doing, the thing is working.
2:34:20 Because that's a huge, that's an extremely ambitious goal. Because it's a fundamental change in the infrastructure. And I think we can do a lot of it on a step-by-step basis. We're doing a lot of it right now that's really, really good. But I don't know how you put a goal in there that is, on this one-to-five thing that we even get in the ballpark with. I mean, it's interesting to hear what you might have to say. But that really takes the automobile out of the equation.
2:34:48 Completely, because... I'm not suggesting completely, it's like a diminished need. I think it's going to happen if we do all this stuff. Do we add something on to number eight? Facilities and programs? No. No. But first community? No. I mean, I appreciate the fact that there's nothing up there that calls that thing out. But I think it's so integrated into all these things that it's a fundamental piece of it. And I'd be interested in hearing...
2:35:17 Especially by going beyond that. It's already part of our general plan foundation. And it is going to show up in the metrics. But to that point, the entire goal of this effort is how we tie our four NGO partners together. Right. I see one that's noticeably absent in those ten goals. I would be less concerned. I would flip the way you're thinking about that. I was looking at John and saying,
2:35:48 You're going to sit down as a ward and say, at a governance level, what is our contribution? And they're going to have contribution across the board, that diverted plan group and fast response time, or whatever it is. And I think each of the NGO partners has to do the same thing. Not just, where's the housing goal?
2:36:16 What's the incremental contribution of affordable, diverse, workforce-centric housing options to the achievement of each of these schools? Same thing with each of their respective roles here. Yeah, and John, I'm thinking that, you know, based on the conversations we've had with the Esther board, because it was...
2:36:40 More focused and it relates to air service and the planning and, you know, an X, Y, and Z that we kind of already have a pretty good idea of what that is. It's limited. You're right. It's a slightly different relationship. You know, we buy services from them. They'll develop what we ask for. It's a little bit different than asking MLT to go out there and find bodies to put on these planes.
2:37:07 It's a slightly different way of looking at it, even though it's a baseline valuable service. Correct. That's a great point. I think it's going to be interesting, actually, when it comes back.
2:37:29 And the NGOs and the JPA are saying, we think we fit in here, here, and here. It might be interesting to see how that's going to look, because it may not be where we first presumed they may fit. I think also the long-term part, man. Right, all of that. Yeah. Let's see how this... Multimold. Incrementally, which I think we all want to do, get less and less dependent on the car. We may get there as a result of what we do, as opposed to establishing a goal. Right.
2:38:01 It's another one of those service partners. So let me make sure I understand the next steps we're talking about is were you suggesting, Michael, that each one of the
2:38:35 Individual boards has time to review this before we meet together as a group again? Yes, because... So we're talking that we as... The problem for these guys is they cannot make formative contributions to an action plan without the governance function, and if they participate in an action plan, then you have to send back the governance review, and then we have to reconvene again.
2:39:01 Right. To resolve all discrepancies. So the next thing that's going to be, so the next step is to get this information and get it out with a time frame that allows all of those boards to have time to meet and discuss it. We're January 4 or 5. And what are we, John? John, John, when's our meeting? Well, I know, the next one after that. This refined document could come out tomorrow.
2:39:26 Yeah, if you can get that in the... Because we have a meeting Friday. Yeah, we get it up tomorrow. Yeah. This one's actually... So the first step is the document, right? The document goes out. Yeah. And it's locked. It doesn't change until... Right. We have one goal. We have four strategic priorities and nine goals. Is that what I mean? Uh-huh. Yes. Yes. So that becomes your book-ended framework, your short-term commitments.
2:39:56 Your long-term outcomes that you've envisioned. You've also got two sets of guides here. You've got some community values that you've framed, and you've got these images of greatness. So these are going to become the lens to support the decision-making around the action plan. The very last question I'm going to take you through is go, how does this plan produce that image of greatness?
2:40:25 We're going to do that literally one by one until it's complete. So the idea is governance process to review what is our incremental contribution. I'll put that in the language to each one of these goals. If the answer is none, then you move on. But for everyone, and you're looking at...
2:40:47 A near-term time frame, not looking necessarily at 10 years. Looking at 18 months. Now it's conveniently June of 2017, so that we have a nice range. Okay, so then what happens? So these guys all see this stuff for the first part of January, then what do they do? Then you convene the working groups if you want to have another level of screening on that a little bit.
2:41:16 Take everything out of what's gone through the governance bodies back to the working group and say, okay, are we on the same page that way? It's a peer review, basically, on the governance process. Okay, so how do the working groups get, who makes assignments for working groups and how do they be? So I think we could work that out. Yeah, I think we're heading into, we're kind of getting rid of the land here and we don't want to go sideways. My thought is to keep it really simple, really streamlined.
2:41:44 Task level achievable in two hours, not a half day workshop, and not create a duplicative planning process. That's my, I've been telling Deanna all along, my biggest concern about working groups is it goes out of this room, now you're in a new planning process. You have to reconcile. So the working groups do some work. How does that, does those efforts then...
2:42:10 Populate this as a draft, the center part of this as a draft. Yes. Right? And then this final meeting of the action plan thing is reconciliation of all this stuff. Only we're going to put it literally on a quarter by quarter by quarter timetable. We're going to do six quarters worth of milestones for each of those contributions. Okay. So in these working groups, who's capturing and who's updating this document? Well, we'll lay that out in a work plan document. Okay. You got to be very clear about that. Yeah.
2:42:39 Keep it super simple. We're not looking for tons and tons of stuff. I understand. It's got to be very clear. The author's got to be, if there's issues with it, it's got to be accountable as to who wrote it and who did it. We've got to be very, very clear. One of the easiest ways to do this is actually set up a real simple charter document. I'm happy to just do that. Give you a one-page charter so that you're a time-limited group. You convene with a specific purpose, specific outcome, and a couple of caveats about don't really dive into
2:43:09 Problem solving this stuff in isolation from the whole group. The whole premise of this process was strategic alignment between council, staff, and NGOs in an integrated partnership. So you don't want to get a bunch of parallel path processes going. You guys have done great. You've got vision, goals. You've got short-term council commitments and priorities.
2:43:37 You've got a clear set of core community values. We just need to make it actionable over 18 months, and we need each of your governance functions to have the same opportunity that council has had here. Otherwise, we'll get stuck. But my goal for you is by the end of January, early February, middle February, somewhere in there, you have a complete executable plan.
2:44:07 Short-term, long-term, detailed action plan, commitments, names attached, roles, functions, communication strategies. And we're closing with a dialogue about community engagement. That's the next phase of this. Real active community engagement. That's key to this whole thing. Otherwise, it's just you guys in the room. I actually want to applaud you. I thought you did great with this today.
2:44:38 Went as I envisioned it. I'm sorry for the sloppy writing. Nice job overall. Good job. We've got 15 minutes over our time, but Mr. Mayor, I give it back to you. Well, that's it. I guess we will adjourn to our next regular meeting scheduled tomorrow, 5 o'clock. Sweet Z right here.