Town Council
· recording 3 hr 36 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
505 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:23 Good. Is that good? Yeah, great. Fantastic. I'm going to go ski tomorrow. Are you really? That's cool. Because crowds are showing up. Crowds are going to be showing up. Although I thought Friday would be... Did you get the... Yeah. Well, all week is. We're not 100% to the phone. I don't know whether John wants a comfy chair where you can see the chart. You want to see the chart? Yeah, I want to see the chart. John, get a comfy chair. Come on, John. Can you turn on the lights? Yes.
0:56 Are we live now? We are live. Six o'clock. You are. Five o'clock. You mean five o'clock. I was going to say it's six o'clock already. Let me turn it this way so it can catch you, too. How are you doing? Check, check. We can hear you. You got the wire. That one's picking up very good, too. Wired.
1:37 These are pretty nice set up. Cold, huh? It is cold. It is cold. It is. 21? Yes. Yeah. Thank you very much. 21. I remember 21. I'll do well. Probably too well. Next one of us. Joe. Hello. Salutations. Good afternoon. We're here again.
2:14 We were here. It was like I didn't leave. Same spot. I learned from the master. The blue ones died. All right. Ready to go, Grady? Okay, I'll call to order our Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Wednesday, December 16th, 5 p.m. workshop regarding the capital improvement and major maintenance program review. Grady, turning it over to you. Thank you.
2:45 First, I'd like to describe what we think we want to get out of today, which is always a place to start, I think. Over the last few months, actually a year and a half, I guess, Public Works has been looking at our overall capital improvement program, major maintenance program, certainly in the last year and a half, thank you, and recently there's been a lot of changes. In fact, Council goals and priorities just earlier this week, and tonight you're going to be looking at MLR priority projects.
3:14 So this list has been constantly changing. In the last year, we've updated a lot of our planning documents. We've updated the diff study. We have a stormwater management plan. We have the mobility element under review. We've done a new ALP and a new ACIP. So there's a lot of flux. It doesn't happen every year, but this year specifically, I think we've made a lot of changes. What we've really worked on and what we want to focus on tonight is really the process and the format and where we want to end up. We looked at...
3:42 CIP programs and booklets from other communities, you know, a whole bunch of different examples. Everybody has different reasons for doing them in different ways. We looked at previous ones that the town had, and a lot of them, frankly, resembled the old diff study. In other words, there was a long list of projects, but that didn't mean that all of them were going to be done, and it was really hard to tell what was real, if you will, in those old CIPs and the facilities master plans.
4:10 So from a process standpoint, we decided to do two things. One is you'll have individual sheets, which we'll talk about later. And this is going to describe its individual project that's going to end up in this book. These are not in final form. They say draft. I have not edited all of them. Sierra Schultz and Hayes have done most of the work on this. We're going to get to that. But I wanted to make sure I brought to you today an example of what that is. And then for tonight, we really want to focus more on the overall chart.
4:41 Having said that, the goals, really, we try to list every project that we've heard of, okay, whether it came out of the DIF study, whether it came out of the Sunwater Master Plan, ACIP, all those different things in the far left column. Then we will talk about...
4:57 The background for each of these, what's been happening or what we expect to happen in the next five years. We talk about the plan reference, which means is it from the ALP? Is it from the DIF study? Is it from the Stormwater Master Plan? Is it from the Trails Master Plan? Again, this isn't complete, but we wanted a chart to start with. And then we actually took a shot at laying out the first five years, and then there are six through 10 for each of these projects. So you can see.
5:26 Overthinking. Tonight, I'd really like to have input, though, on one, are we on the right track in terms of what you expect to see? You want a realistic document? Our thought is, again, go out five years, as hard numbers as we can, and after that, you know, we put in the information as we can. What else would you like to see in the booklet, if you will?
5:46 Because, again, everybody who reads it is looking for something different. Some people are looking just for the cost. Some people are looking for schedule. Some people are looking for finite information on each project. One thing that we, in reviewing this just in the last few days, that we want to add the individual sheets was a good question that we had asked, which is, well, where did this project come from?
6:09 I mean, some of them are very simple. It's like the Mammoth's Creek Gap Closure. That's been on the books for decades, frankly. And we're saying, look, it went through this planning process that comes out of the trails master plan. That's why it's on the list rather than just have a project description, which is really more what's on these individual sheets. What you have up on the screen is
6:31 Impossible to read. We know that. I just wanted to show it as a demonstration. It's also on the board that's in front of you, which might be easier, and on that individual sheet that you have in your hands right now. But the way we looked at it, we thought we really had to back up and look at it as a whole. And if you have to turn 30 pages, it's really hard to get kind of a flavor for what we're talking about. But you look at the overall sheet, and you see that
6:55 Sure enough, we have in the first 10 years $154 million in projects that we think are important to the community and that might happen. So that's really the reason for that. I know you can't read it, so don't think that I can barely read it from here. What we then did was we broke it down where we got rid of most of the columns, frankly, and you refer back to the handout. But what we'd like to do is...
7:20 Frank, you just attack one group at a time and just kind of describe what we're talking about for each one, what kind of input we'd like to see. We'll take good notes and we'll come back to you in January, early February with the next iteration. I think, again, we'll learn more tonight about our priority projects and what the council does with those and all the other goals and priorities that are happening. There may be some things that we need to add on to this. But looking at just the screen for the moment,
7:49 We actually think that these projects are quite doable, and it says one through ten years, but we really think it's one through six years. All of these are in our ACIP, and it really is focused, of course, on the first one, and the first in line is the reconstruction of the West GA apron, which you awarded last year, earlier this year, which will be under construction in May and June.
8:11 The next one on the list is the perimeter fence, which we've described before. We've got our wildlife hazard assessment done, the plan done, and we're looking for FAA funding for that, and they're encouraging us to do that. And the big ones there, of course, are the terminal and the land side.
8:30 I thought there is, you know, we will assign a priority to it or a list, if you will, and we'll want you to respond to that maybe at the next meeting. We'll get it out a couple weeks in advance of that so you can have a chance to really study it in detail. Grady, didn't we not see something previously, though, that more or less laid out? Are these in the order that they need to occur? Are they going to occur? Or are there going to be changes? So I wasn't sure what staff recommended.
8:56 Primary priority was because I thought we'd seen a previous document which essentially said these things come first and then we work. That's correct. And we looked at the ACIP, which is a different document that we have to submit to FAA. They were laid out more in that order. What we tried to capture here is...
9:14 Everything in the next six to seven years, or six to ten years, actually, one to ten years, get it all in one place. We have not assigned a priority yet for each one of these. We know what it is for most of them on the airport as an example. When you get down into things like some of the multimodal stuff and street improvements, and we want more input on that in terms of what... Okay, so the numbering system is not...
9:40 A prioritization. It's just assigning a number for parties. Right. In fact, what we tried to do... And there will be a recommendation when we see it again. Correct. In fact, what we tried to do was relate it right back to the diff study because it's the most recent one that everyone has seen that has a list of projects. So we use the same numbering convention, if you will. If there's a number on here, it's also on the... Well, if there's a number in the diff study, it's also on here and it's the same number. And then we added ones for other CIP projects.
10:09 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
10:39 You know, for our matches, or is there, is there kind of a, anything that shows kind of the breakdown of that? Or is there a way to build a column to show that? We added more columns and it became more illegible. And what we're going to do is we, if you pick up the individual project sheets, an example, the Mammoth Creek gap closure, that does show the funding, it shows where each of them comes from over each of the years. And that'll be defined in that.
11:05 But we'll also do a summary chart for that. And as you said, we'll break it into other pieces and things like that so you can read it more legibly. And again, this is not that we're not complete. We really wanted to come to you before we finished this and just kind of get your general sense for the process. Yeah, I think the schedule of funds and the way the funding source is broken out in the detail sheet is really great.
11:28 Right. And that's what will happen for each one of these projects. We'll have an individual sheet so you can look at it in more detail. Knowing that we were going to spend roughly an hour on a workshop, again, how much can we really cover? And Dan and I discussed it with the engineering staff. We thought, let's give you a focus of the process, the intent, make sure you think we're on the right track. Frankly, we've been working on it for a while, but the priorities change. Not daily, but there's things that happen.
11:58 Do you have any specific questions on the airport itself and any project that you don't recognize or something? Because Brian is here as well and can answer any questions that we do have. We don't want to get too tied up in the detail of each project because with 70-some of them or so, we won't possibly get done in a half an hour or so. Is the second ARF vehicle, is that a requirement?
12:25 It's not a requirement to have two ARC vehicles, but by the time we're eligible to have it, because that's really looking at about 2020, 2021, after the terminal. We'll have had our existing ARC vehicle 15 years. You have to have it 15 years before you can even ask for another one. And at that point in time, it would be wise to have a backup ARC. We would greatly benefit from having two ARC vehicles so that we didn't have to contract out with Long Valley and Mammoth.
12:50 That come down and provide fire services. It's a little expensive to do that. So having two armed vehicles would make a lot of sense. All right. Thank you. So in a project, there's a bottom line amount of $17 million over there in the far right. Years 6 to 10? 10 years. Years 6 through 10. Yeah. So my question is, when you look at a project like this with all these parts, how do we...
13:24 Or how does someone understand what, if they're matching requirements and if they're, you know, if they're, I mean, I'm looking at this as like it's opportunistic you guys go get it, but if there's going to be some hard dollars in here, they've got to come in. And again, we refer you back first to the individual sheets, but then we will also summarize those match requirements in another more detailed spreadsheet, but again, it begins to look like the budget documents.
13:49 Pretty thick, but what we're getting there. But if you look at the individual sheets, we will actually include in there what our matching funds are. If you look down below on that very first one, funding source. You got the airport one, John, there? If you flip through it, there's one that kind of shows the breakdown. Is that the third page? On the back side or something? Yeah. Yeah. Let's turn to that. That's an example that shows.
14:17 This is for the reconstruction of the West GA apron. And again, it shows the schedule of funds, the funding source, FAA, sponsor participation, unfunded. So this will be in place for each one of these projects. And again, when you see this again, you'll have an attachment that shows what each category is and on each year as well. Would it be helpful to have something in here that gives the date?
14:44 And I'm assuming it's a council recommendation approval to do something where that agenda item is listed that goes with these things. Yes, if there's an action that's already taking place to me. Yeah, so if there's a question of, okay, all this stuff is happening, where's the agenda, what was the vote, where's the agenda bill, what was the specific direction so that it ties a decision to all the effort together? You'd have some of that stuff, I think, especially in like the first year or two of these. If you get further out, it wouldn't be a specific project three years from now.
15:13 That was the whole idea of tying it back to the documents. It came out of the Trail of Master Plan or it came out of the General Plan or the Mobility Development. Those are approved. But when you look at the 10-year window or the 5-year window, you're probably not going to find a specific action that said these are the 32 projects that were approved. I heard John ask for something else that I presume staff has in the folders is the actual.
15:42 Actions where there was a resolution to allocate funds and things like that. That's what you're talking about, right? Exactly. Projects actually approved we would have that. Correct. I mean, but that's somewhere in the staff folders. What I described too is in the individual sheets we're going to add more text that basically says where does the project come from, prior approvals, prior things, because one thing we noticed that as an example, last year, two years ago there were different council people here and you don't necessarily have all that.
16:11 History. While we don't want to make these each sheet 10 pages long, if we can keep it to two, we're going to put as much of that information as possible. So as an example, a brand new council person, a planning commissioner, a member of the public can pick it up and go, okay, well this was in the trails master plan. It came from, you know, let's use the multi-use facility as an example. It was in the parks and rec plan in 1989.
16:36 Okay, and we did this. Here's some of the history. On these dates, these were the actions that we're taking. I think that's important. That would be helpful to have. Yeah, I think that's important so that there's a track record of the decisions that were made. Yeah, track, plus we can go back and flip through it and a few questions. Yes, exactly. Yeah, and that's, and for as councils change and things get attenuated out, it's like, okay, it happened here, they made these decisions. It's also clear so that things don't...
16:59 For the public work side, things don't end up on your list of them being funded and someone go, well, where did this come from? It's like, well, it came from right here and it's clear. And let me describe something about the book, if you will, that we'll get you a first draft of in January. The intent is to have an introduction that goes through the whole reasoning behind the CIP and major maintenance program and what's included and what's not. As an example, redoing the parking lots up at the community center is on the rec commissions.
17:26 List. It's a public works work item. We're just going to get it done. We don't need to put it in here. It's just part of the annual budget. Having said that, if we do individual sheets two or three pages well on each of these projects and every other one, it'll be so thick. And again, it'll turn out like the old CIP. It doesn't really make sense. So what we're suggesting is in that booklet, you get really that five-year picture, individual sheets, great amount of detail.
17:50 And then in the back, it basically has a list. Here are the other projects, very much for shortened descriptions of those projects. But in the engineering records in our database, we have the full thing. We don't want to spend five years printing copies of projects that aren't going to happen, but we are going to keep that detail. And as they come to the forefront, then more detail gets put into the CIP as they, you know, as they.
18:15 Mature, I guess you'd call it. I'm assuming it would be, I mean, the master would be like a PDF document, so it's searchable, so you're not. Exactly. You can take a code, type it in, find it, it's there. Probably be good to have it electronically. Oh, for sure, absolutely. Really easy to go through. Absolutely. So on the, after the airport, we have, again, this is based on the examples in the diff study. The police department is next. The only other police station, one was acquiring vehicles.
18:49 We didn't add this on the list because we don't consider it a CIP project. It's just more of an acquisition. It'd be in the budget. We have the police department there. Now, the next one in the diff study, it lists under ST, if you will, the streets, combine the streets and multimodal circulation and everything else.
19:10 We have it broken out on the large spreadsheet in front of you in two pieces, which is the diff grouping, vehicle circulation system and then the multimodal circulation system.
19:21 After looking at this and producing the documents for today, we thought we would take that second grouping, the multimodal, and break it down further to one being really pedestrian trails, sidewalks, street lights, things like that, and the other being transit facilities, parking areas, things like that, just to give it more clarity in the end to break that apart.
19:42 And again, that's, we want your input on that, but I, we think that's a good idea, the smaller pieces and a little bit better groupings on that part. Yeah, I'd agree that. Yeah, that makes sense. Makes a lot of sense. Yeah, again, once we've printed a look at it and...
19:55 Again, we've been working on this a long time. I don't want you to think this is last minute. We just had to decide when to stop and come to you and say, this is where we are. I thought you did this all this afternoon. Pardon me? I thought you did this all this afternoon. Sierra probably thinks so, because we are doing quite a bit of work this afternoon. It's probably been, after we had the initial list three or four months ago, it's probably been two or three months of iterations. Again, just sort of a checkpoint. One thing I want to point out.
20:25 I have a question on the very last ones of the multimodal. Yes. Where you have the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, and I think it's important to have it here and then have the detail over there. But I noticed that you have funded it past the current council.
20:44 Through 1617, which is the, that is all that has been approved by Council. So I noticed that you've got some other things there that are not yet approved. Absolutely. In fact, another thing. Which I think might be somewhat confusing. Kind of leads back to John's statement of where does this come from? One of the things we're also doing, again, I appreciate that input, is again, when you see this the next time, each thing that actually is funded, money allocated.
21:10 For it, those will be bolded. We'll have a separate total of those. What we try to do here is what the funding need is going to be. It doesn't necessarily mean they're all approved for those years. So yeah, we'll definitely bold the ones that are actually allocated. Absolutely. We learned that actually when you're going through the stuff with the rec commission. We have a lot of things on the work program, but we were able to identify the ones that are actually funded, and it made a lot more sense. So there probably still will be a couple more columns then. Again, yeah.
21:40 Yeah, and to get, to let that information get really fat and bring it down so it's digestible is really the trick, and we're about halfway through that, just very frankly. Question on the, it says road reconstruction. Is that just like a overall? In our budget, I've heard that...
22:00 This council and previous councils have talked about getting that budget up to a million dollars a year to make sure that we stay in front of the infrastructure. Last year we had 590 in there. This year we have 580. We just put 580 all the way across for the moment. There's a whole payment management program. Okay, so I mean, it's a town-wide. Yes, correct. Okay. Now having said that, some of the balancing act, and we're, again, anxious to see what happens.
22:29 This year in the first two meetings, a couple of meetings in January, ST44 is village area parking improvements. You know, we've been asked to look at village area parking improvements, the hillside lot and other areas and opportunities around that. We're actually making good progress and be able to come back to you in January with a recommendation, but we just put an estimate in there of a total of $300,000 for that.
22:54 I'm not sure they had, but we wanted to capture it. Well, that budget might actually come out of the road reconstruction and the road rehabilitation funds. But, again, we want to hear more this month and what you had to say on that, and then we'll take our best shot at it. I was just curious what a road reconstruction meant. It's generally excluding some of the assessment districts.
23:19 Last year we allocated a dollar for a couple different places out in assessment districts. This is primarily those town roads that are not part of that. There could be some match dollars on the road that. I think, Grady, you kind of touched on an interesting thing. I mean, you're obviously aware of the prioritization process that council's going through, everybody's going through. How do you see that, the priorities of council, their annual updates, how is that going to integrate with this? I mean, it may be too much of a...
23:48 You know, to chase it with a complex document like this might be kind of fruitless, but how would you anticipate integrating those things? I think we can chase it. I think we can catch up to it, and then it'll change, and we'll keep running, but that's okay. But I think after we hear, you know, through this goals and priorities, we really are learning a lot about what your thoughts are.
24:11 We'll take our best shot at it. And as an example, when you see it again, we probably won't have 580 for road rehabilitation. We'll have 200 and the rest on village area parking, if that's the council's pleasure in January to direct us to do that. But again, the rationale going back to when decisions get made by council and dollars start moving around, it's going to be very useful to have some kind of a citation there that says this is why or this is the rationale for moving things around.
24:40 And when we come back with this, and again, at this meeting, we want to do another one in January. We'll probably come back in March to ask you to adopt the CIP because we'll all know a lot more then. We'll actually also summarize it down to years one and two. This is what we're doing, and we really can't stop these. These are going to be difficult to not keep the process going. I think annually you're going to have a budget year that is funded. Specifically, you call out your budget process. Here's the capital projects that are funded in this.
25:09 Annual budget. Now some of those can move obviously again something happens or that element. And in that process generally every year then you're updating your five year to ten years is rolling out. It's a rolling, yeah. So you will have at least that opportunity annually in a bigger picture to look at it and say these are the six or five or four or twelve projects that are in the current year budget. Some of that might truly be a carryover project that we would highlight as well as a new project being initiated that year.
25:39 That then would go forward. And so there will be that type of a check on a regular basis as well as in throughout the year when stuff comes up or there's a grant opportunity or you have savings and we want to add to and those come in for particular actions by council. And then in agenda items, the council priorities, I'm assuming there'd be some, there's a statement of rationale of how it lines up with.
26:02 Council priorities and stuff as they come forward. And when we come back for adoption of this document in March or whenever that is, we'll have worked a lot on the financing side to make sure that it does make sense. In other words, we want you to be able to approve a document that has at least the first two years a very high level of chance that those things will get funded.
26:23 So what Dan said kind of brings up another question. We have year one, which we're halfway through 15-16. This should match what we did in the budget or we've amended since then, right? Yeah, ultimately that category is there for that first year. Right. Based on what actions that we're taking in the budget or later adoption of things. Okay. So then later this year you'd be adopting that.
26:51 16, 17, which will become the base year, kind of rolling forward with the five-year capital program. While we're looking at streets, basically, the vehicle circulation, I want to mention fully three projects, two in there and one in the next group, because it's a suggestion from staff that we should approach something. We have...
27:13 The Main Street Sidewalk Project, which is right now, it's $2,090,000, we hope, from STIP in the next year or two. You know, those of you who are on LTC heard that discussion the other day. Yeah, let's get to that in a second. Yeah, we'll get to that. There's that project. There's also Lower Main Street and the rest of those sidewalks, both on the north and south of Main Street.
27:35 There's also the improvements at Minaret and Forest Trail. There's been discussion over the years that that should be a roundabout. In fact, in our plan, it shows a roundabout.
27:47 You may have heard me before say it. My own opinion is I love roundabouts, but that's probably not the right place for one because of the geometrics coming down the hill, a lot of different things. But we have on there, the last one on that list is Minaret Forest Hill intersection improvements. So we described it that way because we do think there's something can be done with that intersection to make it better, whether it's wider, better turning lanes, better turning movements, better stacking. So we left it there. The one that isn't on this list.
28:15 Is a roundabout at Minaret and Meridian. That's in the plan. In fact, that's in our stip four years out, I think, Hayes. So you pulled it off of here? We pulled it off of here because our idea, and this is where we need guidance from you, is to take the roundabout funds from Minaret and Meridian, which are programmed right now, which...
28:36 Frankly, from a warrant standpoint, that intersection barely warrants stop signs, but the signal works just fine so we wouldn't take it out. But we think that a million and a half to two million dollars is much better spent.
28:49 On Main Street, improving the crossings, possibly a Hawk, you know, pedestrian crossing and those things. That's a suggestion from staff, and if you feel otherwise, you know, let us know, because otherwise we're suggesting when you come back to approve the CIP that it includes a recommendation to go to Caltrans and reprogram that money into Lower Main Street instead of that roundabout. Is that possible to utilize maybe that for some of the median?
29:14 The quick winds and the median on Main? We've heard, you know, the sense of the council is lower Main Street, those walks, the medians, the crossing, the safety things, those are much more important than a roundabout up there. Well, then let me ask this question. What did it end up called? Old Mammoth Place required a signal at Azimuth.
29:36 Now I understand they're talking about coming back in for even more density and things like that. How would that affect? Because the problem was is doing it in phases on Meridian. If you put in the roundabout and didn't have that other signal, you'd have this continuous stream of traffic down Meridian. So how do you balance something like that? I'm okay with there not being a roundabout. I think that they'd be more of a...
30:01 But that is... They'd be more of an excursion for people to watch everybody not succeeding through the roundabouts in our icy streets. But how do you then balance against projects that are or are not coming forward and all of that? Well, two comments. One is the roundabout, there was no, in my understanding, and Hayes correct me if I'm wrong, but there was no traffic basis for it. It was just...
30:27 It was roundabouts were a cool thing. Yes. I agree. There was no numbers value for that. Having said that, Old Mammoth Place and a signal on asthma, that would be a direct impact of that project and they'd have to build it. Okay. But part of that was then, what does that do, you know, because these all do kind of snowball on themselves, is what does that do with the idea of putting a signal here where the school is, where we have...
30:54 Traffic problems all the time. You know, because it was going to be moving the stop sign. Right. You know, signals, you can actually systematically coordinate them together better. No, but what I'm saying is in the original plan, the roundabout was going to go in and that signal was going to get moved down to Sierra Park. So now, what does that, then how do you adjust for what you're going to do at Sierra Park? Just a question of, you know, how do you cascade all of these?
31:21 Not to get off the subject, but I'll answer that one. We did a pretty significant traffic study over there, and we can't warrant them. So, Caltrans will not pay. So, we cannot use that funding. We can't use CTC money. Okay. Stip, okay. CTC approves the stip funds, but they're the same thing. But, yeah, we can't use it for that. Okay. Well, I wanted to point out the big changes from previous plans, because, like you said, they all come from a plan. Well, if you look at the mobility element, there's a roundabout.
31:53 Three locations in town. One is Forest Trail and Minaret, which we would not recommend for geometric reasons, and we don't think Caltrans would necessarily support it, but we want to do improvements there. The other roundabout, which we think the funds are better spent in other areas, and the third one, which was at Maine and Old Mammoth? No, that's no creek. That one. So, still out there, but that's a change to the plan, if you will, and we want to incorporate that, and when we come back, we'll have a...
32:23 More precise recommendation of why these changes are made. At LTC, last week, Sandy brought up very clearly, what about that roundabout at Minaret and Meridian? We want to start getting people used to the idea that the sidewalks are more important. They come back someday. I think it makes a lot of sense to take those funds and allocate them to the improvements on Main Street. In the Main Street plan and then our whole new
32:51 The visioning plan that we're going to be working on, I mean, it talks about quick wins and it talks about, you know, if we're already doing the sidewalk work and for us to start to have some safety zones and the median piece, I mean, it's kind of all part of the big picture. So, I mean, I'd be very supportive of, you know, using those funds. I think it'd be very helpful and it makes total sense. We had a very interesting discussion about STIP and funding.
33:20 of large transportation capital projects given the dysfunction of the Aztecs collection, given efficient vehicles. Yeah. And it's a really significant problem. And I think in terms of the expectations that we may have for good projects, even if they're modestly budgeted, that the collection of the revenue to pay for these things on the state and the federal levels is really dysfunctional. And I think that's probably not a discussion for this group, but I think we should.
33:48 At some point, talk about that and start factoring that into what we're doing with these projects because it's great to have a good project on the list, but if the funding source that is outside of our neighborhood, oh, it's going to show up someday, I don't think it is going to show up. Yeah, the funding source isn't there. It's not there. And I think we need to start factoring into decisions. Right, exactly. Great point. But to Michael's point, I think the quick wins are those that are relatively...
34:15 Less expensive. Sure. And we may want to be thinking about pulling those out of funding sources that they just don't exist. Right. The classic example I just mentioned, though, is we go through the RTP and then this dip and the planning process. And initially there's dollars there. We build that in. We get a program. And then they come back and, sorry, we're $150 million short. If you get below this line, it's not going to be funded or it's going to get shoved out multiple years.
34:42 That's when you start the flexibility, okay, those projects and that funding source is going to be moving. If there's still a high priority, there's other funding, does that start to move other stuff around? And that's the council discussion of what gets moved or, yes, we think it's a good program, but maybe it's going to be three years from now, not one year from now. And it would be very helpful when the decisions are being made to have a good discussion about what these funding sources are looking like.
35:06 It's important to keep those at a high level because even if we don't have the funding source from STIFF, if we can articulate the high priority of the project, it puts us in a good position for other funding sources. And I think to be, but that's for us to be mindful of those things so we can put the things in the right places you guys go after. We're not just sort of lying around waiting for the cowboys to show up. And again, we'll document that with our recommendation when you go to adopt this, but this is two examples.
35:36 You're absolutely right. That's why we're looking at that roundabout up there and saying, look, there are far greater needs. And this Tesla charging station is a big part of the problem. I don't know why we're... One other thing, though, that when we see the sheets, it's going to be easier because the descriptions here are almost impossible to figure out. Exactly. No, I understand that, but you can't... We wanted to make it so we could at least have a discussion in the big context. One thing I would add, though, is...
36:05 If you've got a PDF and you've got a code and you can type it in, it works. No, what I'm talking about is that the perfect example of funding disappearing was the 2002 project to have everything on Meridian done all at once, which the CTC said nope. So it's now in several phases, but in looking at here, you can't really see where those phases are because these descriptions are...
36:33 That's where, but the individual sheets will make clear which pieces are which. The other comment is, again, ask where these projects come from. Well, we will, when this comes back for adoption, you'll have a starting point. Okay, this is where we are. Up to this point, we are seriously just listening to you. I'm listening about Bill and Jerry Park and listening about Main Street, and that's how we populated this list. But when you come back, then we'll have an actual reference. Right now, we're just, we hope we're listening anyway.
37:02 I think we're getting most of it. So in this next part, it really does, as I said, we want to break it into sort of the trails and mups and pedestrian-oriented stuff versus village area parking and transit things and stuff like that. So we haven't got to that yet. Let me ask you a question. How much in advance will this document be publicly available? And I'm thinking that if the council got a priority about amenities for visitation, these other kinds of things.
37:33 Again, not wanting to have you guys reformat that in that format, but to have MLRs, MLTs, you know, other folks be able to look at this and be able to have enough advance to be able to go through here and figure, okay, that's what that is, that's what this is, so that recommendations for prioritization can come out of this. It'll be helpful if this is available with this, you know, a month in advance kind of thing or something like that. We want to, in fact, it's not a...
37:59 It's not a long-range plan, but we understand that our budget cycle starts in March, really, maybe a little bit before that. It would be perfectly fine with Public Works if this was adopted along with the budget because then they can line up. Yeah. People can digest and ask the questions. We want to come back to you in a couple of months, but we really, if we do that, it'll work. And one of the options on this one might be we have the first year of the sheet showing 15, 16, the year we're in right now.
38:28 That may be moot to some degree, but I think we've approved that in the budget process, and maybe we really focus on 16, 17, and builds in the timeline, and gives out, we can still highlight, because I'd like to show, start to build in last year's accomplishments, and you have two or three years of accomplishments shown in the document. Yeah, but I still think as long as you're in the year and the projects are being done, I think it's important to have them here. Yeah, yeah. It'll show 15, 16 based on projects that are carryovers, but absolutely.
38:57 That the focus will be on. But it's going to be a running 10-year. Yeah. I mean, you're going to be adding on. Yeah, adding and enjoying and adding. But it certainly makes sense to adopt the budget and this. Right, together. That's the same time. Makes a lot of sense. But we'd show that 15, 16-year because it's being worked. Ideally, it's your one-year passing where things are completed or rolling forward so you get a feel for the scope of a project that's over time. Right. And let's see this.
39:25 The portion that's up on the screen, if you look at the storm drain, which on this is down here in the middle under SD, you note there's about 11 projects and there isn't anything in the first five years because there isn't any funding for that right now for none of these. We've shown some of them in the DIF study. Where we really anticipate a lot of these funds coming from is through the IRW-MP.
39:54 I got most of the letters in there. Thank you. Because now that we've finished our storm drain master plan, we can go to them and look for funding. And there is money there, we think, in the future. Because a lot of these projects, especially the first...
40:08 Let me see one, Upper John Muir, Upper John Muir, Lower John, those are not in the diff because those are existing development. We cannot charge the diff for it. So we have to find the money someplace else to solve those issues that are up there. So you'll see there's just no funding there. Are there, I mean, they're all important on storm drain, but are there any more that are like... There are, and the stormwater master plan pointed some of that out, correct, in terms of priority? Yeah, and...
40:37 And they have, some have more potential for damage and number one with drainage is floods and safety has got to be the first thing. So we will, again, we will order these and come back. And one of the reasons is we may have 10 projects there. Well, there may be a funding source that will pay for numbers one and two, but not for four and five for whatever reason. Well, we want to give you a tier and say, look, these are what we think are the top five.
41:02 We're going to be opportunistic and look for funding, but when we find that grant that we want to apply for, we'll come back and we'll say, look, this is why, this is the one we're going for. Right, you're going to prioritize for need and urgency. Okay. Town administrative offices, just because we know when the lease expires, we put some of the initial design work out, you know, in, I think it's year five. Correct, out in year five and construction after that.
41:33 There's no commitment, there's no funding for that yet, but we're just looking at the lease, and that's when we have to start design, if it's 2023? Yeah, I think it's 2022. Yeah, the point is, so we're going to take our best shot at this, and when we come back, yes, we'll get it to you in plenty of time so that we can look at it, the public can look at it, you know, I'll have workshops if need be with the public and let them ask all the questions, but again, the idea is adoption with the budget, so we have...
42:03 Six months. We want to finish most of it in the next month and a half and then be able to catch up and make it in line with the budget by that time that happens. So plenty of advance notes. Parks and Rec. We know a lot more about Mammoth Creek Park West and what the goals are there, so we have a lot more detail in those projects. But we also include some of the diff projects like parkland acquisition and development.
42:33 That's pretty undefined, but that was based on the need identified in the diff study. So we put it in there in years 6 through 10. No funding allocated to it, of course. Just curious how you came up with the number. That was actually based on, in the diff study, we did a needs analysis for a number of acres of undeveloped and developed parkland in town based on population. And if you go back to that diff study, there's a pretty detailed analysis on that. And then we applied a certain cost per acre.
43:01 Which was tied to some of the historic land exchanges. All right. So it was pretty scientific. It wasn't, gee, what's available by any means. It was just that. So we don't really know what that means yet. No, I just said, I mean, it's a curious number based on all the numbers that you have. It's, you know. It's pretty finite because we took the diff study and just. Got it. I'm just curious how you came up with it. Thank you. Great. Just a couple of details on some of those. You've got.
43:30 Parking lot rehab at Mammoth Creek Park West, is that just to rehab the existing asphalt? Correct. It's our opinion that whether anything happens there next year, the year after or not, that parking lot needs some work. So that doesn't include any expansion of existing parking spots? That is not correct. Okay. Then... How about refurbished chillers? Yeah, refurbished chillers. So is that the time frame where...
44:00 Time frame we're looking at right now, even if we use the existing chillers and moved them. Correct. There's only a three-year life left on the existing chiller. Right. And what we understand, one, we bought them used. Two, our chiller guy says they're actually in pretty good shape, but it's time within a couple of years to go ahead and refurbish those. And I think he said that we'd get another 10 to 15 years out of them if we do that refurbishment. Okay. So we put that, we actually put it so that if we're making the move at the same time.
44:30 We take them out of service, we refurbish them, when we reinstall it, it's ready to go. So it's about the right timing. Gotcha. And then... Let me go back to one of the questions you mentioned, like we rehab a parking lot, we're going to do that. You look at that and say, does that parking lot need to have an expansion to it, and that can be any of them we're looking at. So I can come back and say, we had this project planned to do the rehab, if we modify it, we could add extra spaces there, or we want to reduce the space out, or we want to make a modification to it, that could come back and say...
44:59 This is the rehab dollars for an additional $20,000, $30,000, $50,000. Do you want to do X with that? Okay. Could be a street project too. Do you want to, is there another piece we pick up or a sidewalk piece or a curb cut or. Okay. So some of those are a little dynamic in their process at times. And sometimes that can be based on the bid as well. All right. And in that parks and rec list, if you look at.
45:20 15, 16, what's really in there is part of the design and the environmental process we're starting in January is in that year, a total of 150-some thousand. Right. And then really the next year is the beginning of that construction. Right. Knowing that, again, if we start in May, we have May and June in one year and the rest of it in the next year. Moves to 17. Right. And we also, Dan pointed out that we needed to make sure, which we've done is...
45:46 It's not realistic to put $30 or $40 million worth of work in one year. It's just not going to happen. So we've made sure that there's a balance there as well because just from a capacity standpoint. Right. Okay. Last question on PR18. You know, some of the kind of preliminary estimates on the accessible playground were significantly higher. This is now down in the...
46:10 $200,000 range, so what's the change on that? When we met with the rec commission and with MLR, we noted that one of the things we needed very soon was the size of that playground. So in order to give detailed information to first the rec commission on what that means, we've done research and...
46:30 The Shane's Inspiration Playgrounds are all over the place. I mean, they're all over California. There's many of them. The average size of those are actually smaller than what we have today. If you look at it, they range from anywhere from 3,000 to 19,000 square feet. But the average is 5,000 to 7,000 to 8,000, and that's it. Even in much larger communities. So based on that, we thought we're going to make a recommendation to the Rec Commission, which we're not doing yet, but they will be talking about in January.
46:57 We're going to list 8 or 10 projects in different areas. This is the true size of those. And what we found that if we just take that 7,000, today our recommendation to recognition would be just take the 7,000 and just make it accessible, make it an inclusive playground. There's no need to go 20,000. No need to go to 20. 19,000 square feet that you found.
47:21 Right. So it's, well, we found it realistically, no, $7,000 is actually pretty good for a larger community. I think part of the problem was is a request came in to MLR in the first go-around of the interim funding for this $500,000, and he says, well, we don't know, let's put it aside and figure it out later. So everybody's decided all of a sudden that means that it needs $500,000. No, no, no, I totally understand it was more just set aside. So I think when we get to the one tonight, I want to talk about that one some, too. Okay. But it does bring up an interesting...
47:50 It's sort of a tail wags dog question. I come back to that. You guys are looking forward to putting something together. Rec Commission hasn't weighed in on it yet. Again, it goes back to having those citations in here that says when a decision is made, things tie to that. So things need to get straightened out. It's like it happened here. Here was the decision and it's clear. Because, you know, you don't want to get in a situation where you guys are making recommendations, but...
48:14 Time goes by, all of a sudden the recommendation becomes the fact and you don't want to be in that position. Yeah, but, you know, just to kind of reiterate, to tie back to what the initial recommendation was, it was just to include some park space undefined in the EIR. So, you know, it wasn't 20,000 square feet, it wasn't pigeonholed to a Shane's inspiration, any of those type of things. So it's much more in the infancy stages than... Yeah, I just, it's a general just procedural thing going forward.
48:44 To make sure, and again, if you've got that decision memo or something in it that says what it is, it covers everybody's. But it's a good example because the first filter, if you will, is, you know, an idea comes around and it ends up, they ask engineering, what does that mean? And we say, well, we're really going to do 20,000 square feet of, you know, we would not recommend that for a minute, but we're going to tell you what we recommend. Well, and that clearly articulates to me where the number came down to two. It's simply we would recommend a smaller footprint.
49:13 Okay. $7,000 would be a big one. It's too big. Yeah. See, I think that's all the real detail. One question is great is when you're talking about, you know, obviously it makes sense. Focus on the five years and a little less detail on the six to ten. And then deferred maintenance, is that some kind of an appendix as well?
49:46 You know, the biggest one we have is always two big ones. One is road rehabilitation budget, and the other one is vehicle replacement. Well, and I'm also thinking of, like, the Recreation Commission has gone through and identified the deferred maintenance in all of the parks, and yet, so when does that get daylighted?
50:05 A lot of that, actually, and we'll probably include the work program for, we took the Recreation Commission as an appendix or as, you know, in toward a staff report. But we begin to look at a lot of that with the Rec Commission. We had a major maintenance category, which was the CSP. Right. It's definitely maintenance. Correct. But somehow we have to make sure that people understand that there's other things out there. Absolutely.
50:31 And we would bring those forward at the same time as we look, and here's what the Recreation Commission has, and here's what's in our work program. As an example, when we're working today with Warren Bowling working more through parks and recreation, frankly, than with Public Works, but they talk all the time, is we're actually putting more money into the parks. And I've said that. Nobody said don't do that. So we have a certain budget of
50:57 Roughly 80,000, let's say, for parks maintenance. There's another 50,000 that's in the public works program for fixing the parking lots, ADA compliance, the bigger stuff. And we will daylight that definitely in this. I'm just in support of what you're saying because we, you know. We tend to forget. And we're not getting the life cycle in facilities. You know, we're having facilities falling apart before they get their life cycle because the maintenance programs, and this is a big part of the Measure R campaign and all the rest of it.
51:25 And I think it's going to be very important to try to get back in the neighborhood of what we need to maintain. We need to look at that, too. As an example, the community center is way past its life vanity. But if you look at town facilities other than the roads and the equipment, it's a pretty short list of ones that we need to do that projection on. Now, once we get a new police station and once the lease is out on this space and we end up in a new facility, those become much more important. Right now, we have the shop. What else do we have?
51:56 Airport, but it's going, you know, those are big changes at the airport, so we're not as focused on that because we're hopefully making a lot of big changes in the next five or six years, but it's absolutely, another thing to mention here that isn't detailed is operation maintenance cost. We just started to look at that for these projects, but.
52:15 Even existing projects, any new stuff, we want to make sure we put in an operation maintenance component because you can't build a park and not be able to maintain it. You can't build it. I know it's a little bit pie in the sky, so it might take you a couple years to incorporate it, but one of the discussions we had before, during, and after the settlement agreements was the replacement cost also starting to actually not just
52:43 Plan for maintenance, but, you know, end of life cycle, when are you going to have to have a new X, Y, or Z? I think, and the maintenance component also, we talked, I think, I thought we had a really good session yesterday, but when we have visitor-facing stuff that, with the level of maintenance and the quality, it affects experience and things like that, I don't know how we get into that in terms of what, how we prioritize that maintenance and that, those kinds of things, that's important.
53:11 I mean, if we're putting people into places they're having experiences and things are, well, it's okay, it's, you know, still there, you know. And the parks are a great example, and Mammoth Creek Park is west. The tents are still there. Yeah, the tents are still there. But the parking lot and everything else, and there's weeds all over the place, and we're spending a lot of time on it, but, you know. Yeah, and there's that nice trash catcher in the middle. It's mostly just a trash catcher.
53:40 Again, today, all we're looking for is, you know, we're on the right direction. We've got some great comments on what to include on the individual sheets, on the spreadsheets, the kind of detail. But we didn't want to get too far before we touched base. And also to get your comfort level that we are looking at all those things. We are looking at operation, maintenance, projects, funding sources, you know, all those things. And even that kind of overview took an hour. Just a quick question. I've been here when...
54:08 Public Works Directors have said, hey, we can't get it done. We can't make the CIP work. What is, what, you know, in a couple minutes, what went wrong in the past? Why is this going to work? What's different this time? And how do we know that this thing's going to sit, you know? Let's see what he has to say. Go ahead, Hayes. So, you probably noticed a difference right on the cover. This is a capital improvement program. It's not a plan. Difference being, this is a decision-making tool. We've got away from
54:38 The master facilities type document where we just throw everything in it and we'll just hope that the money appears. We're trying to create a decision making tool for you. So any comments that you can give us that will help you guys make decisions or any information that you need to make decisions, please let us know so that we can include it. And our goal is so that, you know, if we have a great winner and you have a windfall, you can look at the program and say, okay, here's what we can add. Or if we have a bad year, you can say this is what we believe.
55:05 So that's the kind of document that we're trying to create. That is the real difference between this document and the ones that you see before. I think the other two pieces of that is, Grady mentioned earlier, we had a discussion. It doesn't make a lot of sense to have, here's this one year with $30 or $40 million worth of projects in it because it's totally unrealistic. And that leads to frustration, frankly. It also leads to that as once you get the item on the list, it never goes off, which stays at the big number. And then it truly turns into that wish list versus
55:36 Reality. An actionable thing. And then it's easy to come back and say, nope, this one's getting pushed out to year 20 because it's not going to happen. And that's how we should be using it. Exactly. So it comes into a working document. Every year you're going through that process and going real, real, maybe, maybe, don't bother. So there does become some realism, I think, in a program that's an actual.
56:05 Plan for construction and a financing plan with it versus just here's what we wish to build. And also on top of that, Dan, I think it's very important that we have a program maintenance with that too. I mean, you don't want to just build it and all of a sudden it's instant here. You've got to have that program in. No, I don't think we need to be back in the time when there were, you know, a Taj Mahal for the council chambers and all of those other things. We just need realism. So I hate to see staff wasting time on all that other stuff that is just...
56:33 Not going to happen. The classic example of that would be the police department. We went from a $13 million to a $2 million functional office space for people who will work for the next five to ten years. That's a start. Yeah, that's a big start. I think it's very good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for the work. Thank you. Is that it?
57:02 All right. That's it? That's it. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, Gary. Thanks.
57:33 Thank you.
58:02 Got it.
59:19 Yeah, well, I think everybody knows really bad. Yeah, I was really glad we got together. So, what are you paying off?
59:40 Thank you.
59:55 First thing in the morning.
1:01:03 Thank you.
1:01:39 Thank you.
1:01:46 Annual report down here.
1:02:15 Thank you.
1:02:45 I saw that. I saw that.
1:03:52 Working? Good. You guys ready? I turned it sideways so I have more room on the glass. That's a good idea. Yes. They pick up really well.
1:04:17 My clock is fast. 6.02, yeah. 6.02. In the Apple world, yes, in the cell phone world, it's 6.02. You guys ready to go? All right.
1:04:52 That's right. All right. Okay, I'll call to order Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes, a regular meeting for Wednesday, December 16th, 2015, 6.02 PM. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I've asked Mayor Pro Tem Richardson to lead us in the pledge this evening. Please all stand, face the flag, and repeat after me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.
1:05:31 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, I'll open up the floor for any public comments this evening for items that are not on our agenda. Okay, seeing none, I'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Any additions to the agenda this evening? Okay. Colin, I'm going to start with you. What about public comment? Oh, I'm sorry, never mind. Sure. We're in a hurry tonight. Thank you. Just a couple of things for me.
1:06:13 We all attended what I thought was a very productive strategy meeting yesterday. I think that effort is kind of coming full circle there and I'm excited to kind of see the action plan that comes out of that. Tuesday morning I attended the inaugural peak performance program that the Chamber of Commerce launched. Our entire staff was there between
1:06:41 Monday night and Tuesday morning, they had two sessions. There were about 60, 65 people in attendance Tuesday morning, and I understand about the same Monday night. So all in, you know, probably 125 to 150 people attended, which I think was a really encouraging turnout for a first-year deal. The speaker, Murray Banks, was awesome and heard a lot of good feedback from our staff and from people in general about the presentation.
1:07:10 So I think that was a really successful launch of that program. On Monday, Councilmember Wentworth and I met with some representatives from MMSA, and I thought that was a really positive meeting, just kind of talking about strategic visioning and those type of things. On Wednesday, December 9th, I attended a Plan This Park meeting.
1:07:40 That's kind of going to be a strategy for how we move forward with Mammoth Creek Park West. The Recreation Commission has got a pretty robust calendar of dealing with that on a monthly basis and community outreach on that facility. So that's definitely a facility and park that we're looking to get a lot of public input on. So I think there's going to be a lot of opportunity for that.
1:08:05 A couple of my meetings this month for both MLR and MLH, but I do have a report out from MLH from that meeting. One of the things I'm going to try and make an effort to do is just provide some better report outs as the council liaison on those boards. So I've asked MLH and I will ask MLR as well to agendize that, just kind of what through the agenda they would like report out from council. So if you can give me one second here, I'll just.
1:08:35 Pull up that report out from MLH. Excuse me. Waiting for this thing to show up. So we're not on the one gig internet, huh? Yeah, I guess it's moving a little slow. Let's see here. Here we go. So a couple of items that MLH board wanted me to report out.
1:09:10 On the November 17th meeting, the Mono County Board of Supervisors also approved the creation of a revolving loan fund, which is similar to what we already have set up here in the town. So the county's RLF is going to allow MLH to borrow up to $300,000 in the preservation of town's deed-restricted workforce homes. So that's a major goal for MLH is to preserve our existing deed-restricted homes.
1:09:40 And so that'll really help us to kind of double down in that effort. In November, a MLH unit was leased to a family of four. So the father's working in the Mammoth Lakes food preparation industry. So that's been a big focus for MLH is just kind of trying to tie a face to some of the efforts that have been done there.
1:10:02 We did have our strategic meeting, which I've already reported out on, and so Jennifer and Patricia are in the process of updating that, and once we kind of refine that strategic plan, there'll be a report out on that. And then the last thing coming from the board is a number of the board members reported back on a current shortage of housing options for some of their employees. So it's just something that they wanted the community to be aware of is that there's a little bit of a shortage on some of the employee housing stuff.
1:10:32 So, that's it. Thank you.
1:10:33 Thanks, Colin. Jo? Just two items. At the last Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting, we were able to see some video that shows that the dune project of putting the straw bales out there and the plants worked over the wind events that were around Thanksgiving. We were able to see video from where there's a hole of clear air in the dust.
1:11:02 So that was quite good that it's actually working and the plants are growing. It's incredible how well they're doing. The other thing was that last Saturday I was one of the gift wrappers for Shop with a Cop, 40-some kids.
1:11:18 Absolute chaos and a total blast gift wrapping for three hours straight where these kids will come up with an entire shopping basket full of the gifts that they've been able to purchase for their family members, including the cats and dogs. So that was something I will definitely do in future years. Sounds fun. Thanks. John? Thank you. On December 10th, I attended the Broadband Task Force meeting.
1:11:47 And we had a very interesting discussion. One of the things coming out of that, and Councilmember Fernie and I have been talking about the Foundation for Future Synergy Summit having to do with what we do with the broadband capacity we've got and how we start talking about coordination of web platforms, authoritative information, digital asset management, these kinds of things. I was hoping to try to pull something off this week, but it's...
1:12:14 The holidays are upon us, and that's not going to happen. But we'll be working on that in the new year, so I'm trying to bring these kinds of things together. On the 14th, I attended the LTC meeting, which I know you couldn't make it because of a personal conflict or concern. And the fundamental focus of that meeting was the approval of the Regional Transportation Plan and its EIR. I stole your CD from the mailbox in here so I could have my computer because your binder was about that.
1:12:44 That big, great, big, huge document. A lot of work, a lot of very interesting stuff in that. A lot of time and effort in it. A lot of time and effort. And I think it's a very good regional document. It really lays out a really good vision for the transportation needs in the region. But there was a very interesting discussion as we talked in our workshop about STIP, gas tax, funding, and all this kind of stuff. And it really is...
1:13:09 It's something that we should be talking about as we start looking at big capital projects with expectations of funds coming out of the state because it's just not working. And we had a nice update from Mr. Helm from Mesta, but then the meeting ran a little bit late. I had to leave. Then I met with Colin. We went to the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for a liaison meeting.
1:13:31 And there's a representation meeting that some of their consultants are going to be in town the first part of the year, and I thank council. We need some direction from staff or something to figure out kind of how to engage with that process, and I'll leave it to larger minds of mine to figure that out. I thought our workshop yesterday was really good, and I thought, you know, we've been messy and kind of chaotic, but I think we'll really come back to where we want to get to, and I'm very much looking forward to the next steps. And that's it. Thank you. Thanks, John.
1:14:01 Nothing to add. Nothing to add. Nothing to add. Okay. I attended our strategic, another strategic session meeting with MLT on Monday, the 14th. We continue to make progress there. Nothing to report out on that at this time. Also, our strategic meeting yesterday, I thought, went really well, and we've been working really hard for a long time on this, and I think we finally are starting to really channel it in.
1:14:28 Next steps of doing some working groups with our NGO partners and get this wrapped up. A lot of good work and a lot of time and commitment. I'll be attending our monthly air group meeting tomorrow and ESTA and ESCOG meetings on Friday. So we'll be reporting out on those on the next meeting. So that's all I have for tonight. I'm going to move on to reports from commissions and or departments.
1:14:56 Grady Dutton, Public Works, just a couple of things. Snow removal is going really well. We've had very few phone calls amazingly. A couple of comments, not even really complaints. Residents are used to it. One of them, we put a little bit of extra snow on a walkway that we shouldn't have. We took care of that right away, but nothing to really report. One comment I did want to make on the sidewalk clearing, we're going to keep up with Lake Mary Road up to Kelly as long as we can. We think that one...
1:15:24 Could last quite a while. Canyon Boulevard, so far so good. If we get a couple of good dumps in a row, of course, again, I just, everybody who thanks us for doing that, I caution them that that can't go on all year because we just don't have a place to put the snow. But so far, hopefully you're getting good comments as well. Just an add-on to the Mammoth Creek Park West comments.
1:15:43 Councilmember mentioned the meetings that are already going on. We do have good proposals from the planning and design consultant and the environmental consultant. They're not quite within our budget yet, but we're working on that. We'll get back to you on January 6th with a request for an authorization for those two agreements. The scopes look really good, and we're going through that negotiation process. The only other thing I wanted to comment on, and it sort of leads into the next item on your agenda after reports, is to wrap up the year, we have...
1:16:12 Four individuals that had anniversaries in Public Works this year, and I just want to mention it. I mentioned a couple last week. One is Lon, who's here again tonight, going to get used to public speaking, who's been with the town now for 15 years. Dennis, who was here last time, 20 years. Derek Shea in Parks Maintenance, five years as of this last January. And Lauren Kane, who is now here for 15 years in the road crew. So that's...
1:16:36 That's, again, a real good comment on their longevity, and we appreciate all their efforts, but I wanted to mention it tonight. Great. Thank you, Grady. Grady, I have a real quick question on the power outage. I know that's not maybe in your bailiwick, but maybe you know about it. What caused it? Mr. Brown's got a full report on that. Wonderful. He's been talking to SC&E, and he'll bring that right up to speed. Thank you. All I knew was I made a lot of phone calls, a lot of texts, and it was dark for five hours where I live. Grady, one quick question as well. Yes.
1:17:06 So I'm not sure if you'd be the right person for this, but maybe you can look into it a little bit and get back to me. But in light of all the new snow, which is a fantastic thing, we all know that Davidson is one of the most dangerous roads we have in town. And we have to do a lot of business up there, up at Timber Ridge. And in the first couple of years we were here, they would often...
1:17:31 Open that kind of emergency access gate from Bridges Lane. In the past couple of years, that was mostly shut down unless there was some sort of emergency situation. I noticed when I was up there the other day it was open, so I was just curious if anything has changed about that regarding snowstorms and the gate closure there because Bridges Lane is significantly safer than Davis and up to John Muir. Agreed. It's more than timely. Late this morning, I actually got a call from the
1:18:01 I want to say Mark, but I don't think that's his correct last name up there who had been talking to Tom Heller and Frank Freevault about opening and closing the gate. He'll be back in February, but before then, I'm going to sit down with Frank and Tom on our road crews and look back at those agreements. His comment was, look, we don't want to be restrictive and we don't want to be exclusive.
1:18:23 But we want to make sure if we can add some in the community to make it safer, we want to do that. So we're actually engaging them in that conversation in the next couple of weeks. So, I mean, seriously, he called me today. Okay. Yeah, I know it's complicated with the private road and all that stuff, but I was just curious if anything has changed up there as far as maybe that being open during storm cycles and stuff. I think it was just with low snow last year as they left it and it wasn't a big deal with more snow.
1:18:47 It's become more of an issue. Okay. But we absolutely agree on Davison. I mean, we know people who live up there who just watch the show sometimes. Sure. And don't deflate the ticket prices, you know. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. So maybe if you could just kind of report back out on anything you hear on that, that would be great. It was great because he called today, so I'm glad everybody's thinking about it. Okay. Thanks. Really quick, any update on the ribbon cutting for the Tesla station?
1:19:16 They're out there working. They said they were going to be done today. It may be another couple of days. They're actually looking at how to best patch the asphalt in that location. They talked about using a cold mix. Well, they don't have any. They're not in Bishop. The only people who seem to have any around is us. They've actually approached us as of today and said, you know, maybe we could work something out. We're happy to pay for it. So I actually asked Ron Fensler.
1:19:41 Inspector to talk to them and say, well, what do you mean? How much would it be? And if we come back to the proposal that makes sense that we can get it cleaned up, it could be this week. I mean, they're really close. Great. Really close. Okay. Thanks. Evening. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager and Public Information Officer. Just so that people will kind of forget. Stuart Brown. So I'm just going to give a brief update on the SCE power outage and also want to just touch base on activities at the ice rink. We have a big special event Saturday night that the town's engaged with.
1:20:15 That we'll also talk about briefly and then the Recreation Commission and its upcoming plan. So I'll just briefly run through the SCE power outage. Any questions, we'll answer those at the end. So as everybody knows, at approximately 1.35 on Sunday, the town of Mammoth Lakes experienced an unscheduled power outage. SCE informed the town at the post-event that the cause of the outage was a 150,000 kilovolt line that automatically tripped that shut down two substations.
1:20:44 Substations were located at the COSO sub and the HIWE sub, south of us. So big substations. At the peak of the outage, over 10,000 customers were without power from as far as Lone Pine and Mammoth Lakes. Initial information stated that the power would be restored in phases, just due to the equipment, and would take between 30 minutes and two hours. As you can imagine, in any situation like this, sourcing factual information is very challenging, so we're all in contact with each other.
1:21:13 In all, I believe, power was fully restored in homes by about 8.30 in Mammoth Lakes. In regards to the dissemination of public information and planning for contingencies, the town PO was in the office on Sunday afternoon, was in contact with representatives from MMSA, the chief.
1:21:30 Fire District. And then communication via text to local media was sent out at about 3.40 that afternoon with an update to the community. And then power was restored to the town offices. Again, we were without power at approximately 4 p.m. And then the computers and internet was restored by approximately 5 p.m. So we can actually start reaching to the community. At the end, I think, of that three-hour period, all we had was probably a phone and a text. But we got the word out.
1:21:57 Rudy Gonzalez was here previously probably a couple of months ago. He's our representative from SCE and he's kind of our contact during these situations. So he provided the town with several tools to help manage these situations that the entire community can utilise. All this information is actually found on the town's website. Under quick links on the home page it says emergency information. You can reach it from there. You can also do the drop down on the visitors and the residents top down nav bars.
1:22:25 There's emergency information as well. But specifically from SCE, they have that power outage hotline. People can call 800-611-1911. There's also a website that lists those power outages by zip code as well. So you can go and type in the zip code. You can look in what the outages are and also a map. It'll pull up the map as well. And then you can also get an app for your phone. If you haven't already, it's MySCE. You can just download.
1:22:50 You know, that to your phone. And the same situation applies. You can kind of find that information as well. So that was kind of really the update. If it was kind of extending later in the evening, then we're kind of putting those plans in place to kind of reach out in a broader fashion to kind of our local media, the partners.
1:23:09 Whether we needed to look at opening the EOC from a minimum point of view for public information and then also whether we needed to look at shelters and those type of things. But the initial information we received was 30 minutes to two hours. So that was it. That's information we have. Thank you. Just quickly on the ice rink, we're open. It's been a bit temperamental, but we're there. On the weekend we hosted an evening hockey tournament.
1:23:36 Which I believe went really well. I think we just lost the last two games. But all in all, we're really kind of programming as aggressively as we can. We move into the holiday schedule this Saturday, and that's this Saturday through January 3rd. We really go to a restricted schedule, so from 12 to 3, 3.30 to 6.30, and from 7 to 10 are those peak times that folks can come in and ice skate. We also have the return of the Calder Classic, that big hockey tournament.
1:24:04 For our youth coming into town, I believe it starts about December 28th and runs through that kind of week and weekend. So all those games are scheduled in the morning. Again, we'll converse with the library and schedule that parking and all that type of mitigation that we need to do. But that's a big tournament. Certainly more teams coming up. So hopefully, fingers crossed, the weather will dissipate with us.
1:24:26 Tomorrow night, the ice rink hosts the Meet Santa and Skate for Free event. That's from 4.30 to 7. We've got flyers in the back there as well. If people are interested in learning more information, it's also in the sheet on our website. But again, that's anybody who can come along and meet Santa, get their photo taken for free. We'll also have professional photographers there for portraits as well. And then finally, the Recreation Commission meets on January 5th again. That's our regular scheduled meeting.
1:24:52 They're going to review, as we've been talking about, the Plan MCP program. That's kind of what we're calling it now. That's the dedicated website as well, planmcp.com. It's not live yet, but we're building all that capacity right now. So the commission will review that plan. We're formulating it right now. We're also rolling out communication plans for the larger project as well, which is the community design, planning, and the EIR process.
1:25:18 And then the Recreation Commission runs in a subsequent and parallel process regarding the programming of the facility. So we're kind of moving along on some fast tracks. That programming will start essentially at the end of January with the community. They'll also be looking at the 2016 summer programming menu. And again, as we talked about this evening at the workshop, the Recreation Commission's major maintenance list as well. Stu, do you know how many teams are signed up for Calder right now?
1:25:45 It's about twice as many as last year right now. So we've extended it from, I believe, three days to a seven-day tournament right now. So it's kind of big. And then we've slotted in just the early sessions from 7 to 12. So there's five games scheduled each day for, I think, about six, seven days. Is the expansion regionally or just age group-wise? Age group. Yep. Cool. I've got just a quick question about Sunday. So you mentioned that at one point the town only had a cell phone and another piece of equipment.
1:26:15 Can you talk about that a little bit? So we tripped at the same time that we lost power. We also tripped the phones internally and also the Internet that we can access in the offices. I don't believe that's a common occurrence. I think there's measures in place to kind of not let that happen, but that was the situation we dealt with. So that was kind of what we were faced with at the time. Do we have – I'm just wondering about generators and backup systems and that kind of stuff? Yeah, we actually do have those in place.
1:26:44 Working on one tighter for our IT side of the house. But actually, one of the generator backups didn't kick on. We've tested it three or four times. It's worked flawlessly. We actually ran one council meeting on a generator backup. And I don't know the history or the why yet, but the generator did not kick over on this power outage. I'm a little concerned because the Round Valley fire, we were in a similar kind of a situation. And I don't think this is something that we want to, I think.
1:27:09 We may want to take a look at this at some point. So we'll work through that in here in terms of the generator stuff. Grady may have some additional data on that. We're going to be going to a VoIP phone system, other things like this. I think that backups, I think that we don't want to be in this situation. You do two things with the phone system. You do have the VoIP system as the primary, but you do have some plain old telephone plug-in stuff still for the emergency systems if you lose your VoIP. Yeah, I just can't imagine if we're in the middle of Christmas holidays and power goes down.
1:27:40 We're dark for six hours. That's not probably a good place to be. Grady's going to mention something about the generator. On the generator, we'd actually been working with IT to get a second tank and second generator for them. They're running the wires now. They hope to have it up in the next couple of weeks. In terms of the town generator for this space, it was actually as simple as we poured a new slab, we reset everything, we got a new tank, a new vendor for the propane, and believe it or not, somebody didn't turn the valves on.
1:28:08 So we actually, I was here in town. Stu called me. I called one of our mechanics. He came over, checked it out, and as soon as he got here, the power's back on. So it really only cost us 20 minutes until you're here. But we already have discussed how to eliminate that from happening in the future. It was just absurd because we do. We do check it off, and it's worked every time until Sunday afternoon for about a half an hour. It's going to be busy. We have something in place. Yeah, it's going to be a busy holiday season. I remember several years ago.
1:28:38 Right. You know, we don't want to go there again. Right. And one other thing, this beautiful Gig City thing appeared, Stuart, with your appearance at the podium. Did you put that up there? Is that just... I would be remiss to mention, did you put that up there? I wanted you to speak to it. One of our... Suddenlink, working closely with Mono County IT, we are now officially a gigabit community. It's a little surreal, given that we were writing that down as a goal about a year ago.
1:29:07 And through good partnerships, good work with the provider, a goal has been achieved. It's a remarkable thing to consider. I want to make sure we call that out. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you. I figured the sign would be a good reminder that we're at. It works, yeah. It's readable. The other item I wanted to touch on real quick is to give Council a quick update on our solid waste flow agreement working with Mono County.
1:29:36 Give you an idea of the kind of the business deal points we're working through. We don't have a finalized agreement to bring to you. Basically, there's five basic deal points. First one being just a term of the agreement. We looked at either following the five-year parcel fee agreement or to January 1, 2023, which is the life of the landfill. You got about a year and a half or so difference in the term. We're working through that question. The county's preference is to go to January 1, 2023.
1:30:02 We're also looking at the parcel fee participation, looking at a process that we put in place where we would end up sharing over time going up to 25% of the fees generated within Mammoth coming back to Mammoth for support of the kind of a regional solid waste program that works throughout the county and the county services there for the transfer station. It also, that fee can support other required services, you know, you're recycling and some of those types of things. So being able to...
1:30:30 Be part of that regional system, countywide waste stream system here within Mammoth. Looking at our tipping fee stabilization, we're looking at the question there. It's currently $74 a ton. One of our goals is if you can stabilize that out, we know what it is for our rates going forward and working with Mammoth disposal. But also the county needs to know kind of that stability too where they know the amount of revenue coming into the facility.
1:30:55 At the same time, tied to that would be a fourth item being a tonnage commitment. Right now, we're looking at probably that 13,000 tons a year ballpark number, maybe a little less. We need to have some discussions with Mammoth Disposal to nail that down. That becomes very important on the county side to say we're planning for a closure of X tons. If we're way over that, that impacts them timing-wise. If we're way under, that impacts them in terms of finances and...
1:31:23 What they're actually planning for in terms of the closure components. So looking at those two pieces kind of together gives you some better revenue and cost estimates as well as you look forward. And then fifth, probably the most significant issues to the town in terms of the agreement itself is being able to define the scope of liability, that indemnity to the town.
1:31:46 That can be provided for the ongoing closure and post-closure issues. The life of a landfill does not end when you close it. It can go on for another 20 or 30 years or longer. And there can be different issues that happen. I don't believe this one is fully lined or not lined, so that's a real concern that we don't want to be on the hook for, frankly. And so Andy's been working through some of that issue. So we're close on some of these, I think, with the county, but working through the term, the parcel fee participation, tipping fee stabilization, tonnage.
1:32:16 And liability are kind of the five key business deal points that need to get hammered out in a good fashion to come forward. We'll have the standard work through some of the other legal stuff. I call it the boilerplate stuff. Andy's very versed at that, so it's half a dozen agreements pulling those together. I think we have a pretty good framework for an agreement in place. We'll be working through some of these details.
1:32:39 And then the timing of that, I know Tony DiPlano at the county is looking at a full presentation, I think on the 19th to the Board of Supervisors, talking a lot about the solid waste program and stuff, and this would end up most likely coming in along with that because it ties a lot of things together. So we should have a draft agreement in January for the council to look at or maybe look at some of the deal points and if there's direction we need at that point to ask that. And then we'll figure out whether it goes to the county first for approval and back to us or us to them.
1:33:09 Ultimately, the document needs to be identical between the two of us in the agreement, so we'll work through that process. And Andy's been coordinating with county council on it, so we'll work through those legal pieces. But I wanted to give you the idea, though, of the five primary deal points we're working through. If we get those resolved out, then we would have a pretty solid agreement to go forward with. Great. Next question. Just someone from, there'll be a presentation. I'm assuming some folks from Mono County will be there with that presentation to us.
1:33:38 Yeah, when we actually pulled something together, yes. On the 19th, I think the Mono County presentation is theirs to their board. I think Tony's planning on a, sounded like a rather lengthy presentation on solid waste in a broad scope. They're dealing with the same issues. When Benton closes, where did their trash go? What are they doing for transfer stations? What are they doing with contracts? They have a lot of issues they're dealing with as well. And ultimately, some of this likely feeds together in a regional solid waste solution concept. Thanks, Dan.
1:34:08 Do you have anything further, Grady? Okay. We're going to move on to introductions. Item two, introduction of new mechanic trainees, Justin Dagenhart. Did I get that right? And John Roster. Grady? We have Lon back tonight. Come on, guys. Get up there. That was made for you this time. You guys go with him. Anyway, I'm just going to turn it over to Lon for a second.
1:34:36 We're going to turn him into a great public speaker one of these days, and he's got a good start last week, so Lon, would you like to introduce it? These are actually, the only comment I'll make is these are actually new positions for us in terms of a mechanic trainee versus just the other thing, and the response that I've been getting from the other mechanics and down in the shop is that it's really great to have some, not just some new blood, some younger folks that are excited to be there every single day, and I hope that remains the case for a long time, so go ahead, Lon.
1:35:02 Got a little follow-up on Grady. We wrote a job description to go after some of these young guys right out of tech school. And we have John Roster, who just recently graduated from WyoTech in Laramie, Wyoming. He studied automotive technology and chassis and frame welding. So he's going to be one of our new welders. Awesome. Justin studied at Truckee Meadows Community College in diesel technology. So he's going to help us with those big diesel blowers.
1:35:30 Last week I got to talk to you about Dennis going away and now we've got our two new young guys coming in. We're two weeks into this program and it's really working out good so far and I've got good feedback from the other guys. Great. Excellent. Welcome. Welcome. Welcome. If you each want to say anything. Glad to have you here. Welcome. Thank you. Welcome from Wyoming.
1:36:07 Okay, we're going to move on to public presentations. Item three, annual Eastern Sierra Transit Authority update presented by Executive Director of ESTA, John Helm. John? Good evening. With your permission, I'll distribute a quick copy of our... Thanks, John. Thank you.
1:36:51 Again, good evening. My name is John Hellman, Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. It's my pleasure this evening to provide a brief information update for the Council regarding the annual report of Eastern Sierra Transit Authority and an opportunity to tell the community a little bit about what's happening in ESTA's world. Each year at the end of our fiscal year, we prepare an annual report that recaps the operating and financial performance of the authority.
1:37:18 And I'm going to forgot. I almost forgot my slides, which are going to keep me on track. And that report has presented for you there. There are some copies on the media table here for any members of the community that would like to also take a look at that. As a brief recap, the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority is a joint powers authority consisting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, Inyo County, and the City of Bishop.
1:37:50 I was formed in 2006 and began operation in July of 2007. And in FY 12-13, we exceeded the one million passenger trips threshold, which for a rural transit agency is a very significant number.
1:38:07 Again, our operations are in Inyo and Mono counties. Eastern Sierra Transit's predecessor agency was Inyo Mono Transit, a division of Inyo County, and hence it makes a lot of sense that all of our services are primarily within Inyo and Mono counties. Although we do operate north to Reno in Nevada, south to Lancaster in Los Angeles County.
1:38:30 And I typically forget this, but we also operate to the east to Pahrump, Nevada, twice a month out of Tacopa on a lifeline service. This map identifies or depicts the route structure that we operate along. It's primarily along the U.S. 395 spine. Although, and you can kind of see from the...
1:38:50 The multiple colors in the area between Mammoth and Bishop and Lone Pine, the majority of our services are in that area. In fact, greater than 80% of our services are operated in the Mammoth and Bishop areas. In fact, my next shot will show that. This pie chart shows a breakdown of the services by community or contract type. And again, the vast majority are in the Mammoth.
1:39:21 Bishop area and within that really in the Mammoth Lakes area. The Eastern Sierra Transit Authority is governed by a board of directors, two elected officials appointed from each of the four governing bodies. Actually, there was an amendment that was passed by each of the governing bodies a little earlier this year that amended that and allows for one of the representatives to be not from the governing body but a member of the public at large.
1:39:51 And in fact, we're anticipating that Mono County is going to appoint a member of the public at large to serve on our board in the very near future. Again, as I mentioned, operations began in July of 2007 under the ESTA banner. That was the last year of the operation under Inyo Mono Transit, the predecessor agency. At that time, the services were a relatively even mix of demand response service and fixed route service, about 50-50.
1:40:20 Comparatively low productivity, which is typical of a predominant demand response service. So we did just under 150,000 passenger trips a year and about four passenger trips per hour. Fast forward seven years to 2014, and we've seen significant growth in the agency. Total service hours have increased 43%, but passenger trips have jumped forward fully 550%.
1:40:49 And that is due to a couple of factors, significant factors that I'll highlight, but dramatic expansion of fixed drought services in and around the Mammoth Lakes area really contributes to that. So as I mentioned, in 13-14, we went over a million. In 2014, we were just under that mark. That's because that was the first year of the really significant drought, and some of the winter service was not as...
1:41:16 Popular as the year before. But again, we work from four passengers per hour system-wide to over 18 in that seven-year period. Now, we pay for all these services from a variety of sources. We cobble together monies from wherever we can get it. About 11% of our funds come from federal grants, about 32% from state grants, two primary pots of funding there.
1:41:43 About 18% from fares that are collected on our routes that collect a fare. And then the largest portion, 37%, is from contracted services. And that is the services primarily in and around the Mammoth Lakes area, specifically contract services that we operate under arrangement with the Town of Mammoth Lakes to expand the fixed route services here, as well as significantly the contract with Mammoth Mountain Securia for those contracted routes.
1:42:12 As a point of fact, we had roughly $4.7 million in revenues last year at FY14-15, and close to $1.8 million of that was in contract revenue. If you go back in time to that 2007, the inception of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, that piece of the pie basically didn't exist at that time. That is what has really grown and what the existence of a joint powers authority in our area has allowed and facilitated.
1:42:43 So we obviously have expenses related to the operation of these services. Far and away, the biggest chunk of that pie are salaries and benefits. Transit service always has been, and as far as I'm concerned, is always going to be a labor-intensive business. It takes an operator for every bus. It takes mechanics to maintain and keep those buses running. It takes dispatchers to get it all coordinated. And until they get a driverless bus...
1:43:09 And I think they're a long, long way from that. And as somebody joked in one of my presentations earlier about this, I don't want to be on the first driverless bus that's going up or down Red's Metal Grade. It's going to continue to be a labor-intensive business. Materials and supplies and services are the other two big areas, and that's really related to the fuel and the maintenance for the buses, for the services that we provide.
1:43:35 Now, if you did some quick math from the last two slides I saw, you may have noticed a distinction. We had roughly 4.7 in revenues and roughly 3.8 in expenses. And that is, in fact, true. And we've had a couple of years with that situation. And what that has resulted in is some surplus funds for the authority. And what that has really done is allow, for the first time,
1:43:57 The authority to really stand on its feet financially. It wasn't so many years ago that I came before this body every year asking for a loan basically to provide us operating capital just to make...
1:44:09 Payroll and to pay for fuel. The organization started very thinly capitalized. But we've been able through this process and through the expansion of our services to generate some reserves and to generate a healthy fund balance. And for the first time last year...
1:44:29 The ESTA Board approved and created specific reserve funds, and we have a dedicated capital replacement fund, a dedicated budget stabilization fund, a healthy general reserve fund to fund our ongoing operations. And that's been the real benefit of both the expansion of our services and some factors, quite honestly, that have resulted to a degree in some of that surplus. Part of it, I will share, is
1:44:56 Comparatively low fuel prices that we've had the last couple years. We budget conservatively. We budget where fuel was about three years ago, and it's been significantly below that. So that has helped contribute to a healthy bottom line in that area. We've also had some additional and new state funding sources. There's a low carbon transit operations program that we're able to expand some services with. And the STA funding through our...
1:45:25 Which is one of the two state funds of money is growing as well. And encouragingly, that's growing as a fact that we are growing and our revenues are growing. There's a really convoluted formula that generates what that STA money is. But as we grow and we have more revenues, we get more state money. And we're starting to see that as well.
1:45:48 This pie chart breaks down the passenger trips that we operated in the last year. And again, the vast majority of it is in the Mammoth Lakes area. This is where our concentrated fixed routes are. We operate, for example, Mammoth Mountain ski area contracts, the red line, blue line, green, and yellow lines at rates of 40 passenger trips per hour. That's a big number in an urban environment. It's unheard of in a rural environment.
1:46:17 But we have a unique service here that's really well utilized. People recognize the value in using the bus. It's quite honestly easier to use the bus to get to Main Lodge rather than park way down the road and wait for another bus to take you up to the Main Lodge anyway. That results in these kind of passenger loads. While I'm on that subject, I will mention we typically will see numbers of 40 passengers per hour on those routes. We were in excess of 60.
1:46:46 The next two slides just depict the service hours that we operate by jurisdiction.
1:47:12 The majority are in the Mammoth Lakes area. That's Red's Meadow Shuttle Service, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Contract Service, and the services that we operate for the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and the miles as well. These two factors are presented each year, twice a year, to the ESTA Board.
1:47:30 In conjunction with the proposed services that the authority will operate for the coming six months. And that's the opportunity for the board to approve those services system-wide that Eastern Sierra Transit operates. And what this does is it also paints a picture for each of the representatives from their governing bodies on the resources that are being provided to fund the services and the services that are actually being received.
1:48:00 We're not seeking absolute parity, but we want to make sure it's within a reasonable range, and it always has been. There's been roughly a 5% variance that the ESTA Board has said is appropriate. And I think that all for one, one for all philosophy of the ESTA Board has been a big part of the success of the organization to this point. Lastly, our annual report identifies some key performance indicators that we measure.
1:48:30 Again, as I said, over 18 passenger trips per hour. That's pretty much flat from 13-14, but again, those were similar years from our perspective because they were both significant droughts here in Mammoth Lakes that had an impact on the winter service. System-wide, we have a 23% fare box recovery ratio. That means fares pay 23% of the operating costs. We're mandated to meet 10% in order to receive our state monies, so we're well above that number.
1:48:59 We have a $2.99 subsidy per passenger system-wide, nominal increase from 13-14 in keeping with nominal operating cost increases relative to wage increases and other things. And we had 1.09 preventable accidents per 100,000 miles. That was a 12% decrease from FY 13-14 and is below our maximum standard of 1.25.
1:49:25 That concludes a brief presentation about our annual report and the services that we operate. Again, I appreciate this opportunity to present this information tonight for the council and for the community. Great job. Great job, John. Any questions? Yeah, I have a couple. First of all, I just want to say thank you and commend you on the progress that ESTA's had over those number of years. I sat on the board last year, and I remember one of the first meetings.
1:49:54 I came across what the board wanted to do with the surplus that you kind of alluded to, and the direction given was to put in place a capital replacement program. So I think that's a very encouraging thing that now we've got some funds going towards that and we're planning for the future. So that's exciting to see that moving forward. I did have a couple of general questions. You had kind of alluded to...
1:50:22 Passengers per hour and how that compares in rural settings and urban settings. We're at 18.2 from that last slide. Comparative to like a typical urban setting, what is the average in an urban setting? Well, again, I mean, even within urban, there are great fluctuations depending on population density and trip generators along that area.
1:50:47 The more important measurement, I think, on productivity, we refer to that number of passengers trips per hour, is relative to the service. There's fixed route, there's paratransit, and those are apples and oranges. You know, four passengers per hour on paratransit is good. It sounds horrible for a fixed route service. But fixed route services in very rural and low-density communities can be in six to eight passengers per hour, and that's an okay number.
1:51:17 Just, you know, to give you an idea, 25 to 30 for an average urban fixed drought service. And 18 is a number that you feel good about in this setting? Very good. Good. Can you go back to one of your original slides, which wasn't in our packet, that just kind of broke down the percentage of service by area, Mono County, MMSA? Just didn't catch that real quick. Okay.
1:51:49 It's a little bit hard to read here. That's 34% in the town? 34% Town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay. 24% Inyo Bishop. Okay. 25% Reds MMSA. Okay. And then the last thing on another slide where you talked about operating revenue sources and passenger fares, could you just...
1:52:13 Can you elaborate a little bit on what some of those passenger fares are? I know we have passenger fare service to Reds Meadow. We have passenger fare service on the longer routes to Reno and those type of things. Can you just elaborate on the breakdown of that AED a little bit more? A little bit. One thing, again, for the council and for the community in terms of an understanding, other than the fixed route services in the town of Mammoth Lakes,
1:52:41 Everything else that ESTA operates does have a fare. So everything in Bishop, everything in Lone Pine, the route to Reno, the route to Lancaster, that twice-a-month thing to Pahrump, all have a passenger fare. In terms of the numbers here, it's $880,000. $450,000 roughly of that was Red's Meadow Shuttle. So over half.
1:53:08 Was Red's Meadow Shuttle. Probably 175, and I'm going off the top of my head, was the Reno-Lancaster routes. So those are the two biggest portions. Okay. Yeah, that's helpful. Thanks. Other questions? Hey, John, on the trolley list of seven, I know we have another one on order. Is that calculated? No, that was what we had last year. It's the 14-15 annual report. Okay. We're anticipating delivery this spring. Right. Okay.
1:53:38 Well, I just want to say great job, John. I think John's being a little modest, talks about the mechanics and the dispatch and the drivers, but I think there's some kudos to you running a great organization and being a great partner. So I just want to say great job. Well, I appreciate that, and actually it reminds me, and I blew it because I...
1:54:00 Keep forgetting this at the end of the presentation. But in 2014-15, the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority was recognized by the California Association of Accordinated Transportation as the outstanding rural transportation provider. So I'm far remiss. And that's all in stock. Thank you, John. Okay, I'm going to move on to a consent agenda. Are there any items that council, public, or staff would like to pull? Okay, seeing none, I'll entertain a motion.
1:54:36 Mr. Mayor, I'd be happy to make a motion. Council approves consent agenda items 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8. Second. Okay, I have a first and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Going to move on to policy matters. Item number 9, approve Mammoth Lakes Recreation Priority Listing of Amenities to be Funded by Measures R and U. Rich?
1:55:04 Today's the mayor's birthday. Is it appropriate to sing happy birthday? On three. One, two, three. Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday, Mr. Mayor. Happy birthday to you. Thank you. Happy birthday, sir. Thanks, Rich. That's a first.
1:55:29 Where's the cake? It was the cake. Where are my presents? After the meeting. All righty. Good evening, Council. It is recommended the Mammoth Lakes Town Council approve the prioritized list of primary amenities to be recommended for financial support with Measure R and U funds. We were here last time on November 18th to walk you through the process, so I have a short update. In your council packet, there's some background information.
1:55:57 We reviewed the number of foundation documents we used to make these recommendations. We went through some next steps we were taken to make these recommendations that included presentations to Council, to rec commission to the MLR board. We kind of modified, made some adjustments. The board, as the executive director of MLR, we're here tonight to make a final recommendation to meet that deliverable. We made some minor internal adjustments in our language.
1:56:25 We went from top tier, which was a little confusing for some folks, so we transitioned that language to priority phase. There is substantial work associated with this project, as well as planning history, partnerships, funds committed, and general community buy-in that would deem it as appropriate project to recommend moving forward or a priority needed as defined by the Town Council.
1:56:48 Developmental phase, that language remained the same. Substantial community and MR interests in developing these projects. Further work is required in order to move into a priority phase. Our appropriate task force is to be convened immediately in order to perform due diligence on potential locations, funding and partnerships, business plans in order to package projects for further priority and consideration. And then we changed the last one to the sideline.
1:57:14 These are projects that are deemed important for consideration, but there is need to further define the scope of work to identify appropriate funding and entity leadership for the project to be elevated to the development of priority phase. The projects listed in this category appear to be not eligible for Measure RU funding.
1:57:30 And then based on yesterday's conversation, our workshops, data 12-15-15, we looked at our overall goal of sustainable economic security for the community. So we feel like this recommendation really fits within those four strategic...
1:57:44 Enhance our recreation-based economy, develop a comprehensive community plan, enhance amenities serving residents and visitors, and effective municipal services. We crafted nine goals yesterday, and that is still in draft form, but we believe that goal number eight really does encompass some of this work, and that was integrated, sustainable recreation through expanded and enhanced facilities and programs. So we're trying to make sure we're aligned as we make recommendation to the larger picture of the council priorities.
1:58:13 So as we crafted those, we got into our phases once again. Priority phase, the community complex, and you'll see we have some asterisks here because we're really looking at elements of high-altitude training. Look at the USOC piece. I did an email today to Alicia McConnell in Colorado Springs. You look at the application. Page 7 indicates what world-class facilities look like.
1:58:36 Give us a parameter what that is so we can make sure as we move forward we're meeting those considerations. The community center, inclusive playground. Grady alluded to that early in the evening. You know, that footprint right now in the park is about 7,000 square feet. It would make sense to, as we move forward, I think Colin made mention of that before, that we look forward to that in terms of is it inclusive but playground space.
1:58:58 So we've done some due diligence. Complete Trails End Park, I saw that in your CIP roster for 145, the Arts and Culture, the Master Plan, and the Outdoor Events Site Venue. We've got a pretty good group in process right now. We met once December 10th. That ad hoc committee will continue to meet Thursday mornings at 8 o'clock, again on January 7th, and hopefully bring something to this council by the first week in February so we can tackle that project and you can give us some more direction. Developmental phase, Aquatic Center, Whitmore and Snow Creek.
1:59:28 Hayden Cabin, Fieldhouse, Indoor Sports Complex. What could that look like? Had a good conversation with Ralph again today. He wants to be actively engaged. Biathlon Center, Whitmore Complex, and the Sideline. We talked about other park or playground projects, municipal wayfinding and signage. So we walked through those. We gave some explanations, which is in your packet, why we made these recommendations. And then I want to add one more in here.
1:59:55 And you look at the bullet, which is right in the middle of the page. Once we complete these projects and they're either in progress, we need to determine appropriate signage. You know, your measure are or you got tax dollars at work. People need to know this is where your money is going. So I think we need to have that conversation, what that looks like. Any project you have, it says this is how it's being funded. So I think it's a good way to celebrate where our news is going, especially when we're looking to the future for maybe some other initiatives that will need to support some of the projects.
2:00:23 And then we continue moving forward with bundling our projects. You know, we begin to sort our themes, you know, the high-altitude training, the arts and culture, the recreation, the sideline. So the board made some minor recommendations based on your input, and we're comfortable at this point in time making this recommendation for a prioritized listing of primary amenities to be funded through R&U. Thank you for the opportunity to make this presentation, and we'll answer any questions you may have. Questions? Yeah.
2:00:51 I have one, Rich. At the time I left the MLR board, the inclusive playground was hardly developed at all.
2:01:02 I don't know if I would have even called it in the sideline area. And I'm wondering if there's actually been a significant discussion. I realize that there's a value to including a discussion of playground enhancements in the CEQA for Mammoth Creek Park West, but I'm wondering whether or not the inclusive playground is really in the priority phase, whether substantial work is by your definitions, or whether it belongs in the development phase. Can you tell me what the conversations over the last six months have?
2:01:31 Have been about that? I think we've gone back and forth on that, which phases of belonging. I think one of the challenges we were having, looking at the allocation of budget allocation by council, probably last spring, there was a $500,000 potential allocation for a Shane's Inspiration inclusive playground.
2:01:50 So at that point, we thought perhaps that that is a priority from Council, and that's why this is in priority phase. You notice the language has changed. It is inclusive playground, not specifically chains. You talked a little bit about it in terms of parameters and costs in the earlier workshop, and we believe, you know, being in the CEQA document right now, we'll come back and look at where does it actually fit, because there is no funding allocation. I think once you all make a decision which way to go, we work with staff in terms of...
2:02:19 How do we fund some of this stuff? How are we leveraging funds, fundraising, et cetera? So I think that could go either way at this point in time. Any questions? I would just add, Colin and I have been in these multi-use facility meetings, and there's been a lot of discussion about scoping it, making it a complementary facility with the others in the area.
2:02:42 I don't know on the... At the point when I was there, location had not been determined. You know, the question was, well, is it better over by the Wounded Warrior Center? Was it better at Shady Risk? So more discussion has happened and it is decided that this is the site? Correct. That's the recommendation at this point. That's, okay. Any other questions right now? Yeah, I mean, you know, I can just elaborate a little bit more from my perspective. I mean, as Rich mentioned, there was... I wasn't...
2:03:10 I wasn't really involved in any of the recommendation because it was going to come back before council, but, you know, I was there for the process and there was a lot of conversation back and forth about whether it was more appropriate in development phase or priority phase. I think there has been some development as far as assessing that as the recommended location and the recommendation simply came out to say, hey, we should include some sort of inclusive playground element in the CEQA work for the park as that is.
2:03:39 The recommended location, but it was kind of wavering between those two phases because I don't think it's fully developed into an implementation phase. Any public comment? Dan, did you have something? Last time when this was presented to Council,
2:04:04 Okay, Councilman Wentworth had asked the question. We've done a presentation, MLR, on some of the financial elements that impacts a lot of the projects and process from the RNU side. And we have a short PowerPoint. We can walk through that. I can hand it out and just speak to it from that if you like, depending on your druthers. Information, I'm not sure it impacts so much the priority side, but it starts to give you a feel and scope of what the dollars are actually able to fund over time.
2:04:36 Shorten this up from our previous one. And I think it will give you a quick view of kind of a rough element of some of the funding. This first slide kind of looks at where we're at from a working capital standpoint. I won't walk through all the details on it, but at the bottom of those, about $1.6 million in Measure R and about $1.4 million in Measure U funds are actually available that could be spent. This includes allocations of dollars. Council will set aside dollars for capital projects undefined.
2:05:11 Or, like, for example, the Measure U, the half a million for Shane's Inspiration Park would be in that number. So it is available for those types of uses. If you look at potential uses of working capital, this is, again, kind of a rough idea of where the dollars could go. Measure R, if you took, you know, the trails in park at $150,000, I think it's recommended $145,000 in there.
2:05:37 If you ended up taking a half a million from either of these into the Mammoth Creek Park West Outdoor Event Center, whether that fits under R or U in terms of eligibility, looking at some dollars, it could go into that element. On the Measure U side, the MAC is coming forward. We've looked it up to maybe a $400,000 one-time capital. That still isn't defined, moving target at this point, but ultimately some other things.
2:06:05 Previous reserves, there was, you know, the multi-use facility roof had $300,000 allocated to it. Shane's had $500,000 allocated to it. The MAC had $100,000. So depending where that starts to fall out in there, in terms of where those can go, you're pretty much, you know, out of money very quickly in terms of what's sitting in the bank from the cash flow, current dollars.
2:06:30 It's a lot of money, but it goes very quickly when you start to look at some larger projects. And this doesn't necessarily fund out any of these projects with the exception of Trails in Park. So it's all just contributions into a larger project. One of the other questions came up is looking at if you actually utilize R&U for debt financing. Just run some different scenarios, what you can look at. For example,
2:06:54 You know, if you were looking at about a half a million a year in debt service on a 10-year program, that's about $4 million in debt in terms of a project, in terms of borrowing money. It gives you a different feel here, you know, depending on your term. Interest rates, when we just did the refinancing for the police station, we were a little less than 3.5%, so this is a little aggressive in terms of the 4.5%.
2:07:18 So that always plays a little bit into that and then what's your dollar amount. But it starts to give you a feel. When you look at some large projects out there that could be in the $8 to $9 to $10 million range when you look at a full-blown pool or something, your ability to finance that is relatively limited in one sense. And so that's been the discussion on fundraising and other things. Same thing here, a little larger numbers, just playing around. If you end up, you earn $8 million at 20 years, you're at $615,000 a year.
2:07:45 In order to put together some projects. Basically, input-output here for the slides, you can pretty much pick any number you want and work it through in terms of cost. Dan, what's the maximum leverage you've experienced for stuff like this? Well, you're going to look at the dollar amounts you have available, the million and measure. Is it 80%? Yeah, you're looking at one and a quarter minimum on your coverage, up to one and a half.
2:08:14 And because we have other operating costs, your ability to leverage all of the money is probably not available to us, but you're probably looking at about half the funding being available to leverage into debt. Thank you. But you're going to need a 1.25 or 1.5 coverage on the debt here. And so, for example, this is very illustrative. If you looked at the budget and said on major U, say, or R, you've got a million bucks a year.
2:08:39 Advent and Trails is a half a million, let's say. Right now we're allocating $300 each. These could both go up a little. Check to make sure the council member is okay. CIP match funds, often we come in and we have something that goes there. We have current town obligations. And if you actually had a new facility operation in debt, you can kind of mix and match those, but your debt limit there gets down pretty low in terms of...
2:09:08 What you would put into that. Measure U, the same thing, about $800,000 annual revenue. If, assuming we make a significant commitment to the MAC, $300,000, that could be $250,000, it could be played through those numbers. Events ongoing with the dollar amount there, the trolley element goes on. Some of the ongoing town elements of the maintenance side, again, if you had a debt element in there of $300,000, the two of those at the $500,000 is kind of debt on purpose, that generates that.
2:09:34 Four million in debt service, so if that was a target number to build something or finance a portion of something. And then the operations side, if you're going to build new facilities, you have those dollars going into it. And again, this here can move around, obviously, and there's some assumptions in here. I'm not saying this is, you know, adopted or formalized by the council at this point. But it starts to go, okay, so we have a lot of dollars. If we're going to leverage the debt, that really impacts what we can do for ongoing commitments or operations.
2:10:03 As we talked earlier in the capital program, what's that? Here's my debt to build it. Here's my O&M. Here's my replacement or life cycle costing on it. The numbers get constrained pretty quickly. And so as we look at those priority projects, can we do a lot of those? I think the answer is yes. But it really constrains the R&U funds of where they can be utilized. And there are a couple different restrictions on the two of those. So I do keep them separate from that perspective.
2:10:27 But again, just a real rough high-level overview of some of the impacts in terms of the dollars and what you could actually borrow out of them. And if you're actually funding things kind of at current projected levels, your debt level is actually pretty low, probably in that $4 million, $4.5 million range in terms of being able to borrow money for any significant projects. I can answer any questions to that. Again, I think it ties into how we look at the priorities and ultimately the fundraising and other elements that go into play on those.
2:10:56 As mentioned last time, we gave this a more detailed presentation at MLR that was beneficial at that point, so wanted to provide it for Council's information as well. Okay, questions? So, Dan, if I understand what you're saying, sorry, even those items that are in the priority phase, we don't have enough funding to accomplish all of them at the same time. There's going to have to be some way of determining
2:11:23 Which comes first, which one gets told you're two years away or whatever, even with fundraising efforts? Correct, unless you have a substantial donor coming in of some sort, but yes. I think you're going to have to phase it out in the funding because we have other ongoing commitments we need to meet. I'm making the assumption in there there's an ongoing commitment to trails, for example, which I think is important. There are some other things of that nature you'd look at and say,
2:11:48 And as we begin to prioritize these, and Rich has talked about it before, is in what is that funding plan? What's the process looking at? The environmental work, the cost projections, those elements that come into play. So I have a rhetorical question for Rich and the MLR board, so don't go away, Rich. So presuming we approve...
2:12:13 This structure for right now. Then will you be coming back with recommendations on which ones go first? You know, how do we get from, yes, these are all a priority and they can't all be done at the same time, so then what? Well, let me hit that real quick because the priority phase, the very first one there, the community complex work.
2:12:39 That can be done in the current financial structure, I believe. Correct, and we've already said go with that one, but then. Go moving that forward. The Trails in Park, that's a one-shot, one-time funding. We believe that could come out of the fund balance and be able or current year allocations and be funded. The Mammoth Arts Culture Center, the MAC, that is primarily being driven somewhat by the construction for the college side. They're actually doing fundraising. There are major C funds going into that.
2:13:08 Again, the allocation from Measure U there most likely, maybe in that $400,000 range, could be less, could be done over a couple of years pending what comes out of the final design and construction plan for the actual facility. And Dan, that $400,000 is essentially a one-time? That's a one-time shot. Ongoing, you're going to have to look at probably some of the neighborhood of $300,000 a year, give or take, for operations. We don't have that nailed down yet, but it's going to be a number.
2:13:36 The trail system master plan implementation plan, that assumes the annual allocation going into the trail system. An outdoor event site, that one, you're right, that is not funded. We don't know what it looks like yet. That could be extremely expensive or it could be relatively inexpensive. If you're just building some basic infrastructure in a wooded area, if we can get a, you know, cheap special use permit, for example.
2:14:02 Or if you're actually going to buy 15, 20 acres of property and do a full-blown stage construction and the whole nine yards. I mean, so that one is really, I think it has a high priority because we need to nail it down because we're going to not have a venue shortly, potentially. The cost element on that can, it's bigger than a bread box and hopefully smaller than a Mack truck and we can start from there. And then I think as you go to the next larger projects and Councilmember Bacon, your question is exactly correct of,
2:14:33 Which one's next and how far out do they have to go before there's adequate funding to be able to do that? And this makes the assumption you're just using RNU funding. So that fundraising effort, that corporate sponsorship, whatever comes into play will be a critical element to be able to move those forward. So hope that helps. And so there will be some of these projects. I'm sure it'll be pushed out two, three, five, seven years even. But I think that your short answer is that most of the things
2:15:03 They're currently in the recommended priority phase can be done, are a go from a funding standpoint. And actually, it'll be an outdoor event site. Right. Understood. But there's more development that's needed there. I mean, the discussion on that is why it was moved from development phase to priority phase is because it was just seen as a really high priority. I think it's...
2:15:25 Pretty well recognized that we need more development on what that looks like, what the cost is, but it was really the discussion was highest priority out of those, so move it in there so it's almost a placeholder. Well, and Grady had a figure earlier on the CIP of how much we've actually had, we've accomplished in capital projects in the last 10 years, and it was some huge number.
2:15:51 Well, there's a difference between what the town has done and what the, I guess, the area has done, but when we talked about the diff from 2007, there were actually over $80 million in projects from the diff that had been done. Now, some of it were ours, some of it were by others, a lot of stip funds, a lot of other things, so there's funds coming from all over the place. It sounds like a couple of these items will move out of priority phase and into implementation, and then you focus on the next. That would be correct. Dan.
2:16:20 Can you touch again what you said on the annual commitment on the MAC of $300,000? Is that recommended at this point? Is that going to move around? What's happening on that is we've been working with the college. Bottom line is that there's not operating funding within the college or within Mammoth Lakes Foundation to pay for the operations of the facility.
2:16:44 The commitment of Major C funds brings with it a commitment from the town to make sure that they don't have any operational costs that are ongoing. They're not going to be able to handle the utility bills, staffing, cleaning, whatever those costs are of operations. The original business plan that was put together for AMAC, I think it had half a million or more in operational costs. A chunk of that coming from Major U, ongoing supporting that facility.
2:17:12 It won't be self-supporting. I'm not sure of any I'm aware of that actually are because of the types of programming you run through those. A lot of it is nonprofit. A lot of it is community-based. It's not necessarily, you know, driven to pay for itself on purpose, but they do cover a lot of their costs. So I think you're going to have a shoring up going, here's a commitment to make sure that we meet the operating costs. What that number turns into, I think in the early years, it'll probably be more, and as it gets more successful, it'll be less.
2:17:41 And my guess would be it's an allocation of, yes, we'll backstop $300,000. If we only need $200,000, that's all they get. If they go over that, there's going to be another challenge to figure out how to fund that. So there's some reserve issues in there. Replacement costs for items, those types of elements. That will come forward ultimately in a multi-party agreement between the college, the foundation, and the town of how do we shore up the financial elements of the MAC.
2:18:10 They've committed the front end to get it built, which is critical, obviously. But ultimately, it's no different than the other community facilities we have that I don't anticipate any of them being fully self-sufficient, mainly because they are community facilities. They're not designed to charge, make a profit. We charge this because we have to make a profit, and user groups that would normally use those things, you don't turn them away.
2:18:40 It's skating rink currently. We can charge two bucks a student. I think that piece that Dan's just describing was...
2:18:52 In the Measure You campaign, the arts and culture piece was that piece. And it was promoted. I'm just trying to understand a breakdown of the cost, the operation cost, and make sure that you have that breakdown, that you guys are going through that in detail. Absolutely. That will not be firmed up until they finish the drawings and the architectural and everything else. Biggest question on those is what you're staffing, what's required.
2:19:17 The whole lighting system and stuff and air handling systems are expensive for those types of facilities to manage. Michael, I was on that business plan group that Evan put together a few years back and it was, you know, depending on what your facility looks like, it is $250 to $300 in the beginning but then as you get more groups in that are selling tickets and then, you know, you're going to offset some of it but not all of it. Yeah, no, I understand. So that's, I don't think we can ignore it as an upcoming cost.
2:19:46 But it won't be nailed down for probably at least another two years would be my guess working with the foundation. Questions? Okay. Bring it back to council for discussion. Well, did you ask a public comment? I did. Okay. Further discussion and or motion? I'm willing to make a motion, to entertain a motion. I just wanted to throw one thing out there is that
2:20:15 We do realize, that's why I ask the questions, that we will work with these and we'll essentially check them off the list. I think that one of the things that we want to have...
2:20:29 MLR bring back to us after working with the staff is what this inclusive playground looks like and potentially releasing the remaining funds from that reserve because they can't be spent on anything else while they're sitting there. And we have to be able to give MLR funds to work with to get these things accomplished. At least a big majority of it. Yeah. Well, however much it needs to be. But the $500,000 was just totally, you know. Right. Probably $100,000. Who knows? But, yeah, but I think.
2:20:58 I think we should recognize that the remaining funds should be released and go back to undesignated reserve, because as they sit there, everybody presumes it's been allocated at $500,000 and $500,000 spent. And when we have looked at the costs for Mammoth Creek Park West, none of that was included. Right. So, Jo, at what point is the appropriate time to do that? I think that as they're working through the project and this
2:21:23 It's called Plan This Park now? Is that what it's called? Or Plan A Park? What's the new name of your group? Plan MPC. Plan MPC, okay. Then I think that when that group comes back and reports to us, it'd be an appropriate time. Sure, and I'm assuming that's a technical thing that we have to do to release the funds back. Correct, correct. Yeah, we actually have to. Okay. Yeah, I'm definitely supportive of that statement. I think, you know, we talked a little bit earlier, and Grady made the comment that, you know, one of the major goals out of what they're trying to do is,
2:21:53 Is to put things before us that are reasonable and achievable. And so I think that's been done here, you know, walking through some of the finances, the things that reside in the priority phase right now are implementable, which I think is important. And we've got a lot of things that sit in development phase that I think are tremendously important to the community, but they just need some more development, which is why they're there.
2:22:18 Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you.
2:22:47 So you're going to make a motion? I'll make a motion. Sure. If I could get one clarity before, if I could ask one question on it. I think at the list here, we're moving forward with the community complex. You're aware of that. We're moving forward with the MAC working with the foundation. Mammoth Lakes Trail System, we're working through that. You'll see some of that coming up on the agenda. The other question, we have the complete trails in park as a priority. The question will be is bringing that forward ultimately through MLR for an allocation. So it's a priority.
2:23:15 We've talked about funding, but it hasn't come forward for a full, so we'll be looking for that direction soon if we want us to charge ahead on that. Well, I kind of presume that when you said, you know, because you have mentioned it before, that it might be the only other thing that we allocate out of Measure R right now, but sure, I don't see any reason why not to bring it forward, get it done this summer. Okay, absolutely. Just clarifying our program, and as Rich mentioned, we're working on the outdoor event center at a working group level. Okay, I'll make a motion to...
2:23:44 Support the recommended Mammoth Lakes Town that we approve the prioritized list of primary amenities to be recommended for financial support with Measure R and Measure U. Second one. I'd like to add further discussion. I'd like to add one thing. Rich made a comment, and I'm shocked that there is not an appropriate graphic representation of the funding source that is paying for these projects associated with these projects. I know the Measure R campaign prepared a Measure R work.
2:24:14 It's graphic, and I think it's critical going forward that the appropriate assignment through a graphic representation funds at work is assigned to the projects as they go forward. Yes. I'd like to add that to the motion. I can say it in a more intelligent way if you would comment, Dan. You can put that in the motion, or we can take that from a staff direction. It's nice to have the signs at work, your dollars at work, be it Measure R, be it Town, be it...
2:24:37 As we do those – and I think there is that graphic that's been used in the past on some of the major – Yeah, but I think – Use different. I think what Doug is saying is to create a new one, create one for you. We have – the graphics exist. Right. We're getting ready to roll projects out and make things happen, and I think we need to start going to the public and saying, look –
2:24:55 That one is R. That one is U. That one is a combination. We need to make these things as visceral and tangible as possible. Agreed. And I think we should – I would like to include that in a motion. Well, I think direction is okay. Or do you want – well – If you want to add it. We can add it. We can add it. Just to add it. I'm not going to say how or why or – Give me some language. Language.
2:25:21 And to include in the motion the assignment of appropriate graphic representations of the funding source, be it Measure R, Measure U, or both, that is supporting the projects as they go forward. I'll make the motion as amended. Second. Okay, I have a motion and a second with an amendment. Roll call, please.
2:25:55 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We move on to item number 10 under policy matters, Mammoth Lakes Trail System Maintenance and Construction. If I kick it off shortly and I'll hand it over to Joel. This item is coming before you after, frankly, almost a year and a half, probably in discussions with the Forest Service and looking at ways that we can partner on different elements.
2:26:23 Looking at what their needs were really from a strong partnership with the town of Mammoth Lakes. And one of the things that continually came through that process was as we look at the system that's out there within the town from the Forest Service, they are underfunded from the federal level in terms of maintenance priorities, and that includes their infrastructure, that includes their trails, that includes their backcountry. And each year we're going to, I think...
2:26:49 We're seeing, I think, I can't recall now, it's 40-plus percent of their budget going to firefighting. We talked about that last week for quite a while, so we anticipate that to, frankly, continue. And so one of the things we tried to come back with and say, how can we step and make a meaningful contribution and difference in the trail system in Mammoth Lakes that is partnered with the Forest Service part of their system, Trails? To that end, when Joe was brought on as a Trails Manager and Coordinator,
2:27:15 Was to take a look at this element and say, what does that mean from a maintenance standpoint? He's done a lot of work for that. I'll let him speak to some of that. But the bottom line, we came back with the Forest Service and said, what would a program look like if we brought the resources to bear to upgrade the trail quality within the Town of Mammoth Lakes incorporated boundary, utilizing the resources that have been allocated via Measure R? And so this program came out of those dialogues and discussions, and there's more to be had there.
2:27:44 But I can say if Bob Becker from the Forest Service is here, and so we'll introduce him shortly. But I think they're excited about this partnership, but we're not just going to the Forest Service and saying, hey, how do you improve your system trails? We're coming to them and saying, we have some resources. We want to partner with you to improve these system trails for our...
2:28:04 Community for the experiences that we can have here in Mammoth. So that's kind of the genesis of this. That's covered about a year and a half of dialogue with the Forest Service and the town. So we actually have a program hopefully coming forward that makes a lot of sense and is very doable and achievable within the next summer. With that, Joel. Thank you, Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers. First, I'd like to sort of describe graphically with this map.
2:28:32 On the monitor in front of you the scope of what we're proposing. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System team is quite pleased to be presenting to you today a proposal for a very robust trail maintenance program. Mammoth Trails Committee and the Mammoth, the MLR Board unanimously approved a reallocation of funding within the existing trail system budget.
2:29:01 To go toward trail maintenance. And the specific number is $80,000. Having been a trails coordinator for the last decade, I'm quite comfortable with the scope of what we're proposing. It's about 30 miles of trail maintenance within the municipal boundary of the town. And for me, it was a very comforting number. A nice coincidence, I spent 10 years taking care of 30 miles of trails.
2:29:29 And so I could really immediately wrap my head around what this might take, given different geography, different challenges, things like that, but I'm quite familiar with 30 miles of maintenance. And I can tell you that $80,000 is a substantial amount of money for a trails maintenance program. And I spent some time this fall exploring with the Mammoth Lakes Trail System team.
2:29:58 Some of the challenges that we're facing. And, you know, there's some trails that need some love out there. There's sort of a deferred maintenance issue. Some segments of trails in the lower elevations aren't suffering as badly, but most of the steeper segments up in the lakes basin will really need some work, potentially some very calculated, careful rerouting.
2:30:24 And we've had some great conversations with Forest Service staff, the ranger, on what this might take. And so this map on the monitor, the brown line is the municipal boundary. And these sort of bold maroon or red lines are trails that we hope to take into a maintenance program. And so an example, Mammoth Pack Station Trail.
2:30:53 I've estimated that it may cost upwards of $7,700 to do that based on a cost per mile. Other trails like the Mammoth Crest Trail, very expensive. There's a lot of damage. Have to be very careful with that one. So there are some basic concepts to understand with some of these trails. A lot of them are very steep and they break what is called the half rule. It's a very basic concept.
2:31:23 So if you have a side slope of 20% and the trail is about 10%, that's sustainable. If your trail exceeds 10% on that 20% side slope, you're breaking the half rule and you end up in the fall line. And as many people here are skiers, snowboarders, we all know what a fall line is.
2:31:50 Drop a bowling ball on a hill and you watch it roll, you shouldn't put a trail in that direction. And so what we're going to try to do is create what are called rolling contour trails in this system where we'll follow that half rule as much as we can. Some of these alignments are probably going to have to remain steep. We'll have to create drainage structures. That's where the cost comes in. We'll have to do a lot of rock work and think about hydrology and things like that.
2:32:20 First, it's about sustainability. We want to get water off the trail at all costs. And so if we achieve that, these trails, I'm confident, can handle the use. This is a subject that's come up a number of times in discussions where someone will say, well, we have such high usage. There's so many people using the trail. That's what's destroying it. And I disagree. We have segments.
2:32:49 of trail that by design are failing. You know, so we all can maybe visualize a trail up in the lakes basin where you have a trenched out channelized section and then for a while it's just fine. You know, maybe 20 feet, maybe 50 feet, it's really good. The same amount of people have been traveling both sections and so that speaks to the original design. So we'll try to correct some of those design flaws.
2:33:18 I want to go over a couple of things here. So we did a geotagged GPS inventory of some of the issues, and you may wonder, why do we need $80,000 for maintenance? And we have 796 documented problems, and that's the reason. And this is a really handy tool if I'm to work with...
2:33:46 Contractors on what we're faced with. If I'm to work with fire crews on what we're looking at, I can send this around to folks so they can really wrap their head around what we're faced with for problems. And really, there's a lot of exposed route systems, a lot of channeling, trenching going on, and this is a handy tool. So if you can see the monitor clearly, this is not what a trail is meant to be.
2:34:18 It's just, you can tell that erosion is taking a toll on this facility. This reallocation of funding, the intention is that we will create a different experience on this facility. Maintenance is critical in trail systems, first for sustainability, but also for fun. We want people to have a great experience when they're in the Mammoth Lakes area.
2:34:46 And this is just a start. Next summer, fall, we'll be really working in the dirt. It's my favorite thing to do in my life. I really look forward to it. And it's kind of funny, the other day I read an article about dirt and how healthy it can be for your own personal psychology. So I look forward to digging in the dirt. The other thing...
2:35:16 That I'd like to share with you is we want to accept U.S. Forest Service trail maintenance standards for this program. I've been over these a number of times in the past. I have other resources that I use as well, but we're dealing with Forest Service land, and I'm quite confident in their material. A lot of science backs this up, years and years of research, trial and error to see what works.
2:35:43 In 2007, they incorporated several other groups, soil science and hydrology, into their own document. And it's really a good piece of literature. It's the Trail Construction and Maintenance Notebook, 2007 edition. But there are several other resources that the Forest Service brings to the table to complement this handbook.
2:36:10 This is what I'll be providing to anyone who wants to do work as a part of this program. They're going to need to know this back and forward, backwards and forwards. And here it is on a monitor, and there's one page that I'd like to share with you. It's one small example of why it's critical for people to be on the same page with specifications for trail maintenance or construction. And this is from their own document.
2:36:43 But if you've traveled your own trail system extensively, one thing that you'll notice is that there are hundreds, perhaps thousands of water bars throughout the system. And in this U.S. Forest Service handbook, clearly they're saying to us that water bars should not be used. So this tells us, read the manual. And I say that frequently in meetings with
2:37:13 Other trail system team members. This will really set the standard for a sustainable trail system. And if there's ever any question, I'll be able to point to a page, to a diagram, and there won't be any misunderstanding as far as what we're shooting for. So I'm asking that we accept these documents specifically for this program. In addition, one more thing, and I'll try to hurry here. This program...
2:37:50 Really critical piece of this is a challenge cost share agreement. And we have a master challenge cost share that was signed in 2013. It's good until 2018. And we want to do a supplemental agreement to the master. Get the master here. I just want to read one short paragraph from this master challenge cost share agreement. The purpose.
2:38:29 The purpose of this agreement is to document the cooperation between the parties to implement trail and facility construction, maintenance and promotion projects in accordance with the following provisions and any incorporated supplemental project agreements. So this really set the stage in 2013 for a program like this. It's really perfect. And with a supplemental agreement, we can really focus in on some of the detail.
2:38:56 And engage on a very formal level with the Forest Service. And with that, I would like to introduce Bob Becker. He's the current temporary recreation officer with our local ranger district. Hi, good evening. My name is Bob Becker, and I'm the acting recreation staff officer for the Mammoth and Mono ranger districts here. I'm here on behalf of our district ranger, John Regalbrugge.
2:39:30 Who would like me to express his support of this proposal that's on the floor tonight. It serves many purposes. In a large picture, I'd like to start small and I'll, or excuse me, start large and I'll go to the smaller point and I'll be brief, I promise. The Forest Service mission statement is caring for the land and serving people. And the public expects us not only to be good stewards of the land,
2:39:59 But also to provide, and this is a mouthful, high quality, a broad spectrum of high quality, sustainable recreation opportunities. That's kind of our mission, that's our mantra, that's our goal that we try to provide from a recreation perspective to the public. Well, we know that Mammoth is a world-class destination, and we're trying to encourage people to come here. They're coming not only for the wonderful opportunities that are available in the community, but also experience the public lands that are...
2:40:24 They're here, obviously so special. The Eastern Sierras are a very unique, special place. That's why I'm enjoying my time here. From the Forest Service perspective, we do have challenges. Dan expressed our budget challenges, our manpower challenges. Because of our fire budgets, that's taken a lot of our money. We're down to about 40% of our staffing from historic levels. But that leaves us the challenge to provide, again, those important words, high-quality, sustainable,
2:40:54 Opportunities here. And what do we offer here in the Inyo? I mean, it almost goes without saying, but I have a purpose for saying that during the winter, of course, we have world-class skiing opportunities, we have Nordic opportunities, we have groomed trail systems. You don't see that very many national forests. Of course, during the summer, the opportunities here are endless from camping, from day use opportunities, visitor centers.
2:41:19 The rec residences we offer, the rec events that go on in all of our public lands, and including things like opportunities on trails. So when it comes to trails, we tend to, in the Forest Service, break it down between backcountry and frontcountry. What's in the backcountry for us, and we do spend a lot of our time there, that's where we have these world-class draws like the Pacific Crest Trail, John Muir Trail.
2:41:45 These are important for us and it's important for us to maintain those. But with limited funding, limited manpower, we can't get to what we call the front country and give it the maintenance and the attention that it needs. It's not that we don't get there, but there's a huge amount of trails in this front country and some of it fall within your town boundaries. We are, as an agency, are leaning more and more towards partnerships. That's about the only way we're going to be able to maintain
2:42:13 Our resources to provide that stewardship that's required and also provide those opportunities. And at the end of the day, especially in from a place like the NL and selfishly the Mammoth Ranger District, a degraded resource is going to serve nobody. And we're looking at the long term here. We've got to maintain these resources for a long, long time. We don't have the ability to do it.
2:42:35 To the level that we would like, and so it's important that these resources, that we partner and be able to pull these off. The important aspect for us is that if we're going to go into maintaining these trails, that we maintain them to a standard. I think you've hired a good person with Joel. He knows the program from our perspective. We support how he wants to use our standards to maintain those trails. And at the end of the day, we're here to serve the public.
2:43:03 They have high expectations of us, and they deserve a high quality resource and recreation opportunities. So at the end of the day, that's why we're here to support this proposal. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions? I have a question of Dan, I think. On the agenda action sheet, there's an inconsistency. The third part of the recommended motion ends with authorize the town manager to sign the agreement, but the end of the background...
2:43:35 Information says that the final agreement would come back to us. Yeah, we do want to. So would it be better to strike the authorized assigning part of the motion? Yeah, if you want. If we needed to get something to the district and the front end, if they want our signature first to get to them, we can still bring the agreement to you at that point. Part of that was just trying to work through the timing to get it done in a hopefully efficient fashion.
2:43:58 We can bring it to you, though, unsigned, and nobody will sign it at that point, and then we sign first, and it goes down to the district ranger for supervisor for signature on that. It can go either way. Okay, now I'm still confused. So are you saying you're going to bring it back to us to approve signing it, or you want the approval now? I can make it work either way. Having authority to sign it first probably keeps the process shorter. I think I would bring the final document back to you to look at it regardless.
2:44:27 If you want to see it, somebody take a step back. If you wish to see it before it's signed, we can definitely make that work if you'd rather have that comfort level. But staff recommendation is to let you sign it? Right. You said a whole bunch, but you still didn't answer my question. You can strike the authorization at this point. Or if, I'm just trying to, so you would be bringing it back to us for informational purposes. You'd see it at that point, so it'd be informational coming back to you, you know what we're working on. Okay.
2:44:57 Huh? I have a question, Joel. You mentioned we're reallocating funds. What are we reallocating? Because I don't see any clarity of what's getting reallocated. Sure. I can share with you. I believe it was in your packet. Okay, here we have a list of all of the initiated projects for the trail system, and everything marked in red is a reallocation.
2:45:28 And these are not projects that we're proposing to not do. These are projects that are not timely today. Got it. Okay. The other question I had was when you come up with the number, the $80,000 number, it's about $2,600 a mile, right? Is there any kind of standard of what is spent on this type of maintenance? Very good question.
2:45:56 Forest Service numbers. They have a handy website tool. They have an outfit they actually have a long-term agreement with. And they have sort of an average cost you can use. Also, I use the International Mountain Biking Association text that's available. They have estimated costs. And then also, based on my own experience of previous 10 years of trail maintenance. So several sources. Great. Thanks.
2:46:25 Any questions? Yeah, Joey, a great presentation, by the way. You mentioned 798 projects? 796. 796, okay. How long is it going to take you to do 796? It's all in the planning for mobilization. So the money should allow for us to send multiple crews out. I shouldn't just be relying on one crew. Right. Okay.
2:46:56 And so I recognize that the season here is short. So it will be all in. I'll be engaging with the local newly formed chapter of the International Mountain Biking Association to work on, example, Mountain View Trail. We'll be continuing to engage with Friends of the Inyo.
2:47:19 I plan to use inmate fire crews. That has not been done here yet. I plan to use hot shot crews when they're not on fires. Potentially contractors that specialize in things like rock work with granite and things like that. And after tonight, that's my directive is to figure that out. How long do you think it might take? I mean, assuming you get all the help you need.
2:47:45 Okay, so based on past experience, working on 30 miles every season, I would cover 30 miles in about a month, a month and a half, depending on the rains that came. And so in this system, there's going to be some segments where in three or four days, I'm confident that with a good crew, I could really fix up the Mammoth Rock Trail and make that great.
2:48:12 Likewise with the Mountain View Trail, Uptown, Downtown, similar situation. Once we get up into the Lakes Basin, we're going to be talking about more time, you know, a month or two of work. But I expect by, you know, the end of the season, once we get into October, that I'm confident we can finish and touch every linear foot of this 30-mile system. Sun up to sun down. Impressive. Thank you.
2:48:41 Any questions? Yeah, one more. Will having this challenge cost share agreement get us into the position where all of this trail work is appropriate under Measure R as town owner, town managed? Yes, if I may, that's one of the elements we've been working through on this one, looking at the, starting with the MOU between the town and the Forest Service for the trail system and how we've utilized that in the past to move it forward. The challenge cost share agreement to
2:49:12 The broader one really talks about the partnership, as Joe mentioned. And then this here particular program would be one that is actually a managed program by the town. The oversight would be through the trails coordinator. Our long-term goal in this, if this is successful, would be could we move this into more of a use permit to where it's an ongoing program under the town in partnership with the Forest Service and shared resources.
2:49:39 So it starts to move into that ongoing programmed facility that we work with. This is similar to what we've done a little bit with the trail days and the stewardship programs that we funded out of Measure R. I think the key difference here we're trying to move into that is actually having the town managing the program itself. Obviously, it's in partnership with the Forest Service, but the oversight, the work, and the actual development of the program, what it looks like on the ground.
2:50:06 And what that means for a future follow-up, hopefully, as an ongoing maintenance element to these trails at a much lower cost element and potentially with other funding sources coming to be available through the process with the Forest Service and the nonprofit groups that Joel mentioned. So it would be a system. No, but I think it's important to note that we would be cleaning up what's been a questionable area. Yes. Yes. Any questions?
2:50:36 Questions, comments from the public? Okay. Seeing none, I'll bring it back for discussion and or motion. I think this evening is a culmination of a lot of work over a lot of years by a lot of people. And I see Supervisor Corliss out there. I remember back in 2007 or something when we started, we initiated the Summer Stewardship Program. And the idea was that someday the Summer Stewardship Program would become this.
2:51:08 First Class Trails Coordinator like Joel here to do this and have a partnership with the Forest Service that is substantial and meaningful. And I'm not going to go on about this, but there's this little document here, the Framework for Sustainable Recreation. And there are communities all over the country that are looking to, trying to figure out how to implement this, how to try to make this real. And we are doing that here in Mammoth Lakes. And I think it's a key part of our conversation about our destination, our brand, and who we are going for.
2:51:37 Doing the kind of innovative work that people, the highest levels of the leadership of the Forest Service back in Washington, D.C. are trying to figure out how to get this stuff done, and we're making it happen here on the ground. And I especially want to thank Bob and John Regelberger and your team for coming together around this, appreciating these opportunities, and for lending your expertise, your professionalism, and your insights, and appreciating the value of what this community can do with this program.
2:52:07 One of our strategic goals is to put a sustainable recreation program together here in Mammoth Lakes. I think this is something we're going to be working on for the entire eastern Sierra, but it's really kind of getting started here in Mammoth Lakes. And the other thing, I'll make a quick pitch for something called SHIFT, where conservation meets adventure. And this is where we bring the conservation community and the recreation community together around these public lands initiatives, and that's going to be a big part of this going forward.
2:52:36 Love to make a motion unless there's any further conversation. It's all you. Thank you. I would move that the Council approve the reallocation of fiscal year 15-16 budget to support a soft surface trail maintenance program in fiscal year 15-16 and fiscal year 16-17. Number two, accept the U.S. Forest Service trail construction and maintenance documents as the framework for the program's on-the-ground work.
2:53:03 Number three, direct staff to proceed with the challenge cost year agreement for trail maintenance and construction with the Mammoth District of the Indio National Forest and authorize the town manager to sign the agreement. Okay. I have a motion. Second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. With that, we're going to take a five-minute recess. Two tickets to my New Year's Eve party.
2:53:49 James Bond in the mouth. James Bond? James Bond? James Bond? Okay, let's get real.
2:54:31 Thanks, Grady. Okay, we're going to move on and resume tonight. We're going to go on to item number 11, award contract for construction for the Lake Mary Road to Lake George Road multi-use project. We have to quiet the celebration down. We need to quiet everybody down. Thank you. Grady?
2:54:54 If I could, I'd actually like to address items number 11 and 12. They're two parts of a very connected project, so I'll speak to both of them. The trail from Lake Mary Road to Lake George Road has been discussed in this room and other rooms for quite some time.
2:55:11 We went out to bid for those and got what we thought was a very competitive run. We got actually five bids, which is somewhat unusual. Two of them were very close. Speech was actually second. I just have to note it because he does so well here. Another contractor out of Menden who was our low bidder on that. We found that we had enough funds to also recommend award of the additive alternates, which included...
2:55:33 It's sort of a staging area, if you will, at the what we call the temporary terminus of the trail at Lake George Road. We're going to be able to add a pad there, a bike rack, and some additional wayfinding signage. The project has been vetted through...
2:55:47 Not just the trails coordinator, but also the Mammoth Trails Committee and the Labs Technical Committee have been out on site, reviewed the alignment, and are all satisfied that we're doing the right thing. The Labs Technical Committee will continue to study that whole area to make sure that the next phase of the trail connects appropriately to other paths and user paths and other things that will happen in the future. As a footnote, we did, as you know,
2:56:14 Apply for a grant for that second phase. We did not get that grant. We just found out a few days ago. The response from the reviewers was actually quite positive. They said, you know, in any other year.
2:56:25 We hate to hear this, but in any other year, you would have gotten that $740,000 grant. It was very competitive. There was almost $70 million in applications. Only about $10 million was awarded, and we were just barely off the list. They encouraged us to submit, not only submit next time, but submit the same package. Frankly, they couldn't even consider any improvements because they thought it was a real good package. You just feel short.
2:56:50 So we would like to recommend a ward of both these things. One thing I need to point out in the last page of the staff report for each item under environmental considerations. Working with the Forest Service, you'll recall that they did a NEPA process for both these pieces for the trail. In fact, their NEPA process also included the second half of the trail and maintenance of the roads in that area when we were looking for the flap grant about a year ago. In discussions with the Forest Service, they indicated, and I'm not...
2:57:19 Beaten on them. It's just in discussion with them. They said, yeah, we're doing the NEPA. We're the lead agency. We'll cover everything you need. And it was their comment that we didn't need to do any additional CEQA review. We actually went back and forth on that with staff for some time. We found an exemption that we thought covers it after looking at some of the checklists for CEQA. However, leading up to this meeting,
2:57:44 At that time, staff thought that we likely did not have to do initial CEQA review. After talking to not just the trails coordinator to get Joel's experience in other areas, talking to our CEQA consultant that just did workforce on Main Street, talking to the ones that are doing other work for the town, and talking to the town attorney, we find that we really should go through a process. We're going to do the checklist.
2:58:08 It's our guess, if you will, that we may not have to do a lot for CEQA, but we do need to do the checklist. We do need to go through the process. So I'd like to recommend, at your pleasure, if you'd like to go ahead and move forward with this award, which we should not do without recognizing the CEQA process as necessary, that we amend the motion to include some language that we will go through a CEQA process. I did speak with a town attorney earlier, and he has some suggested language for that. Okay. Thank you, Grady.
2:58:38 Any questions? I've got some comments or observations. Okay. Questions, comments from the public? None? Okay. John? Yeah, a couple things. This is very exciting stuff moving forward. It's too bad that other grant didn't come through, but I think that the MLR's MTC committee is doing good work vetting these things, bringing partnerships together, and making sure that...
2:59:07 When the town is building facilities and whatever partnership they're building it with, they're bringing all the recreation assets together and making sure that things work. My understanding is that in a field review of this alignment, some agreements, and the colloquial term is the key agreements, were established between the Tamarack folks because these two things will likely affect trails in the Tamarack system.
2:59:36 And the idea was that should we approve this award when the folks are on the ground flagging it and actually putting in where the thing is actually going to go.
2:59:47 That town staff, the trails coordinator, will reach out to the Tamarack folks and make sure that they see where things are going to be. They make sure that things are done in the right place so that everybody... Coordinating. Exactly. Gets along in the sandbox and we're not going to do something that's going to turn voodoo into a non-usable Nordic trail experience. So I think that that's an important part to include in a motion to move this thing forward. And I think also that it was several years ago when the Trail System Master Plan was adopted, there was a very...
3:00:16 Expensive, programmatic CEQA document dumped the TRAIL system master plan, including the SHARP document. And there was the desire and there was the direction for the staffs of the two agencies to work together to do a joint CEQA-NEPA document to identify some joint CEQA-NEPA, you know, efficiencies with environmental work. It didn't happen.
3:00:35 And there's no use saying why it didn't happen, but it didn't happen. As we enhance this relationship with the Forest Service, we've got to work closer together on this stuff. And these environmental documents can be done where the field analysis can be done at the same time. There's lots of efficiencies that can be gained if we're doing these things together. And I appreciate Grady bringing this forward and start looking at this environmental stuff so that as we go forward with these projects, CEQA and NEPA efforts can be done. They can be done at the same time. We can save money.
3:01:04 And frankly, we've been working on this sharp, you guys have been working on a sharp NEPA document for three or four years. It hasn't gone anywhere. I think the District Ranger is now interested in entertaining the idea of doing third-party CEQA, hiring outside consultants. We've got a lot of opportunities opening up. So I appreciate Grady and Andy taking a look at this and starting to define a way forward that can make things more efficient and more cost-effective over time. Did you have some language that you...
3:01:32 Yeah, it happens. I would suggest that the recommendation, well, I think the staff recommendation should include and maybe the motion should include something like that no work will be started until the appropriate CEQA review has been completed and the deadline for anyone to file a lawsuit has run, has expired. It's important because there are groups and we're going to bring the recreation and the conservation communities together.
3:02:00 But there are folks from all kinds of different directions who will look at, hey, you didn't cross a T or dot an I, especially in an area like the Lakes Basin. I think it's very important that we be crossing T's and dotting I's as we're doing this stuff. Okay. Okay. Is it appropriate to make the motion by saying what is written and what has just been stated by the town attorney, or do I have to try and remember what you said? I think you've got the intent.
3:02:26 I think you've got the intent. I think that's good enough. So moved. John, did you need to add anything to that? I just wanted to add that. If I may on that, because I agree with what John is saying. Can we have that as maybe a separate motion? Sure. I think that would clean it up. No problem. So I think the statement and direction for the motion is fine. Okay. But if we could do it as two separate options. So the motion is as presented here. As written plus the statement that the attorney has made about.
3:02:56 The CEQA work. I'll second that. Okay. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Now, do you want to address the second? Yes. I would move that key agreements as established between Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Tamarack Cross Country Ski Center, and town staff for the
3:03:28 Final alignments of this MUP be coordinated as was discussed in the field in December of 2015. Is that suffice? Yeah, I think we got the intent of that. We can utilize that. Yeah. I think it's that issue of, I'm reading into it, the primary, making sure that we're coordinating the underground issues that were agreed to in the field, the preliminary field law. Right. So we don't have unintended consequences or consequences.
3:03:59 Yes. Yeah, we understand clearly what that is. Yeah, do you have to add before any work has started or anything like that? Well, we would do it before we ask the program. Right. Right, okay, I'm just, I know it's inferred, but. It's part of the alignment process. Well, I think it's inferred because you have to do the alignment before you do the secret document because the secret document has to analyze where it's going to be. Sure. Okay, I'll second. Okay, motion to second. Roll call, please. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Brinney? Yes. Council Member Whitlock? Yes. Council Member Whitlock? Yes.
3:04:29 Yes, motion passes 5-0. We'll go on to the second part, item 12, award contract for the fabrication of Lake Mary Loop, prefabricated design, build steel bridge. My only comment to add to that, that's the portion of the bridge, or the portion of the trail up close to Lake George Road. It goes over the outfall there, and I just ask that you make the same comment regarding the sequit when you make that motion. Okay. And I would have that same, we could do it, it's basically the same motions. We're going to go to the public first. Oh, I'm sorry, yeah. Do you have any questions?
3:05:00 Comments, questions from public? Okay. You want to make that motion, John? I think what we're asking is the recommended motion as presented by staff would be the recommended motion with the additional language provided by the town attorney regarding the inclusion of CEQA work. That would be the first motion. So moved. Second. Okay. Motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Draney? Yes. Council Member Draney? Yes. Council Member Draney? Yes.
3:05:31 Yes, motion passes 5-0. And your additional? You want the same? The same thing. It's the same deal. Do you have a second motion? Timing of the work in coordination with MNSA and Tamarack town staff to ensure that there are no conflicts or unintended consequences based on the location of the actual trail on the ground based on the fieldwork agreements entered into or discussed in the fieldwork. December 2015.
3:06:04 I'll second that also. Okay. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Lemon? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We'll move on to item 13, consider establishment of a special events working group. Mr. Mayor, I can kick this one off. Following at the last council meeting and the allocation of funding for events through the MLR recommendation process that came up through the council,
3:06:35 Council requested that we actually come back and look at a group that would really look at the special events and kind of nail this down in terms of finding funding for it and a home for it. Again, questions in terms of the restrictions ultimately and also just ultimately lack of funding in the Measure U component where most of this has resided before. As we begin to look at that, we want to bring something back for Council consideration. At the time, the discussion was to have this as a formal public.
3:07:04 So it came together relatively quickly moving from last meeting to this meeting. There's some attached information in here also on the public meeting process and what's required there from a Brown Act standpoint. In looking at it, the recommendation was to look at a working group from those who have vested interest, both in terms of funding or in participation.
3:07:32 Including MLR, MLT, the Chamber, the Event Coalition, potentially the Theater, whether that can be the same is an option there, the Rec Commission. Town staff, not so much as voting members on the committee, but really your admin support and structuring, getting notices out from that perspective. I've also got some feedback from some of the other participants related to the committee, one trying to keep it as smaller than larger, just in terms of effectiveness.
3:07:59 The other question was raised whether or not if we had a small group interim touch base with each of the various bodies here to actually have somebody, a name versus just an organization, which we could do and do a little bit of footwork on the front end of that and that would come back to you for a formal appointment at that point in time. That would give us a couple of weeks to, I'm assuming probably myself and Rich Boccia from MLR and John Urdi from MLT could have that dialogue and say, do we want particular people?
3:08:28 To be appointed versus just representatives from a group of interested parties, and we could do that as well. So a couple options for you. One is you can move forward as presented. It's a group that ultimately could be as high as 11 people. Or if you want us to spend a little more time between now and your next meeting to come back with, here's our recommendation from MLT, from MLR, with an actual person to appoint.
3:08:54 We could do that as well with some direction from Council this evening. That would give us a couple weeks at a smaller scale to kind of frame it up a little better maybe too. So kind of two options for you to move it forward. Okay. Questions for Dan? Questions, comments from public? Okay. I have a few comments. Sure.
3:09:19 We've moved a whole long way in how we work through RNU. We've had steering committees. We've implemented them. We're getting close to the end, and we know that where special events sits is the final piece to kind of figure out.
3:09:35 I'm thinking that we don't want to lose the work that MLR has done in the last two and a half years, including some people on the board who were original members of either the Measure R or Measure U Steering Committee. So my recommendation would be that for...
3:09:55 MLR and MLT and the chamber that we consider it being one board member if they want to and the executive director or some other staff person be included. Then I would also recommend that we not include a foundation when there are several foundations and the reality is if this is to determine the funding and the home for it
3:10:18 And we have said that the Recreation Commission is going to work on community recreation, as I think that we're already asking them to do a lot, and I would suggest that they did not need to be on this one. So I would recommend that it be council, and then from MLR, MLT, and chamber, potentially two, a staff and a board member, if we're not crossing over. So that gives us eight? And then events coalition. Eight, nine? Yeah. Okay.
3:10:48 I think what I've heard is that we need to get to a strategy. We need to get to a rationale. And I'm looking to inject some maybe new blood into this stuff. I appreciate the term vested interest, but I think we've got to get the interests out of this. And I'm wondering if it makes sense for someone from the PEDC.
3:11:16 To maybe be involved in this from an economic development perspective to bring maybe some of that kind of perspective, if that would be helpful. To really to get to the point of, you know, why are we doing this? What is our expectation for it? And get something that's strategic. It could be very simple. But then from that we can tier to implementing it and not, you know, the momentum wants to drag it back down and get everybody going like this. And we've got to figure out a way to keep it clean and high.
3:11:46 Yeah, I think ultimately the realization of how important this is to the community. Absolutely. And to be able to articulate it in a nice, simple, clear way, and then that's going to help figure out, okay, then it should live here, it should look like this, and then... I'm concerned, too, that it can get, you know, it's too big, too many, and nothing's going to get accomplished. I'm kind of in the mindset of what Dan was stating to try to...
3:12:14 Keep it smaller, at least initially. But, you know, I think, you know, Dan's preamble basically kind of gave us two options. Like, are we ready to really iron out the framework of this group or maybe we need a little more work on that? And that's kind of what I'm hearing from the council. We've stated that three different ways. I mean, from my perspective,
3:12:35 You know, I think many people in the community see the value of the special events and how that's driving visitation and how that's breeded success for us, especially in the summers. I think we need to expand that programming out throughout the year personally. But, you know, I haven't heard anything contrary from this council. I think everybody up here supports the value of it. You know, I think coming out of this, we need to iron out three things we need to say. Where does this live? How is it funded?
3:13:03 I'm used to seeing...
3:13:28 Blue Ribbons, Ad Hocs, whatever we've called them over time, come to us with recommended names. So that it isn't, you know, the usual suspects or something like that. I just had one thing to call what you said. Those three things are really important. You started beginning by saying we all appreciate the value of it. I'd really like to see that articulated. Right. So it's not an assumption. It's like this is why we value these things. Sure.
3:13:53 Well, I think, too. It's less anecdotal. Exactly. It's like figure what that kind of that mission statement kind of thing is for that thing. And I think, you know, my role as the liaison with MLR, I mean, I think it was very, very apparent the struggles that we have from both a funding standpoint and an implementation standpoint currently. It's just not the right fit, you know, and I think we made some emphatic statements at the last meeting about the fact that, you know, coming forward next year, we can't have the same structure. So I think.
3:14:22 This will get sorted out, but to Joe's point, at this point, it's kind of nebulous as far as what this group looks like and who that would be. So maybe, Dan, your suggestion of maybe bringing back a more well-articulated group of people might be helpful. I think times are the essence, too, because we did an interim funding cycle, and by March, we need to have something back and figure it out. Yeah, I think we need that hard timeline. Yeah.
3:14:49 So, Dan, do you think you can bring that back in January? Yeah, we can bring back something on January 6th. John, I'm trying to think about, you know, why the PEDC? Well, I'm thinking that it's the Planning and Economic Development Commission, and I think that when I look at the candidate lists on Dan's list here, I'm seeing the components of churn.
3:15:16 And I'm looking to try to find, to bring another perspective in here that can, you know, articulate the economic value of it, keep us focused that way. And maybe they haven't been involved in a lot of this. New blood. New blood, a new perspective to it. And it's just, it's a thought. Yeah, I mean, I think there's always value to having that balance of institutional knowledge and new blood, you know, and so I think maybe we want to try and achieve that here. Okay.
3:15:42 Just make some fresh eyes. So do you have direction? Do you need a motion to bring it back? Yeah, I think what I'm hearing on that would be we'd be looking at the MLR, MLT, and chambers and representation out of that group. The event coalition, it sounded like something that may be a PEDC member. It would be kind of the organizational groups. And we'd come back with a recommendation, as Councilmember Bacon mentioned, an ED or board member, one or both.
3:16:09 The chamber and MLT have some crossovers, so maybe that's just one from one of those and one from the other, from looking at how large the group gets versus a couple of positions, maybe just more effective. And I would assume that group would determine the direction of how that would be made up in the future. Well, I think this is a short-term ad hoc. Yeah, this is just the last. Yeah, right. And then once the home is found, something else goes.
3:16:37 Right. They would need to work through some of that. Kind of like the RNU steering committees. They were short-term. Right. I think it just puts the order of purpose and quickness that I've heard Council express at the last meeting. That's why it was on the agenda the way it was. We wanted to get it back very quickly. Basically, we have about three days to put this together from one meeting to the next. But I think it's important to recognize, you know, when you had said it, it's, you know, the funding and a home for it, but we need to include what Colin said about just actually.
3:17:06 The home for it and how it's going to get implemented. Correct. And I think it has to come, the recommendation has to come back. It can't be, it shouldn't feel like anything is self-serving. Correct. It's got to be something that, okay, this makes sense and this something can work, we can debate it, but there's not the sense that there's serving anybody's masters or anything. Right, nor is, and it still needs to be transparent. Absolutely. Because it's, yeah. Yep. Okay.
3:17:31 Is that fine? Yeah, if we can take that direction, we'll plan to have an item back on the 6th that has more of that detailed meat to it. Okay. All right, we'll move on to item number 14, authorized. Oh, you missed the public comment section. Come on up. Through the eyes of MLR, there are two distinct pieces of this. First, we've got to figure out funding. It's a separate conversation. And then the strategy.
3:17:58 The recommendation might be get a smaller group together to say, where's the money coming from? And then this group's not going to deal with money. They're going to deal with strategy. Let's separate those two pieces. That's a great point. Yeah. Yep. Could you incorporate that, Dan? Sure you don't want to come back? Okay. We'll move on to item 14, authorize the mayor to sign and forward a letter to the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments.
3:18:26 Regarding working relationships and joint effort in the area of broadband and leveraging of digital 395. Yeah, I'll kick this off again. This was a request that came out of the last council meeting again to bring an item back related to some of the work that Councilmember Whitworth and others have been involved in related to ESCOG. There's a letter that's a draft in your packet. It has been looked at by a couple of the other boards. I know I spoke with via email with Inyo County today on it.
3:18:58 They had one recommended modification to the letter, if I can note that. It's in the second full sentence, basically taking out the, in its ad hoc governance committee, taking that out of the formalized letter. Mainly on that because that does work as an ad hoc committee and as you start to formalize it in this process, the concern was that that now becomes a standing committee of SCOG, which then requires...
3:19:19 A whole different process for how they meet and discuss things. So that was the recommendation from Inyo County to pull that out. So that's the second line? Yeah, the second line. And it's at our committee. Yeah, and it's at our governance committee to take that statement out. Sure. I think overall it sounded like they were supportive of the direction for the work and supportive of some training work from Institute for Local Government.
3:19:45 Continue to be looked at and potentially pursued by SCOG, assuming the other parties agree to that concept. So those are the only changes from staff. I know there's been some other comments from Councilmembers as we walk through this to look at a couple of items there for discussion. Okay. Any questions? Public comments? Questions? Stacey? Good evening. Stacey Corliss, Mountain County Board of Supervisors. I'm really here tonight in my role as member of the COG and of this committee.
3:20:16 That's been working to see what our next steps will be toward taking a regional approach to these three issues. So I just wanted to say thanks to you for considering this and to Councilmember Wentworth in particular for bringing this forward and moving forward so quickly. I think getting Council's support of this direction and of the workshop will really strengthen our case on Friday at the ESCOG meeting. So thanks. Thank you, Stacey. Anybody else?
3:20:43 If I may, Mayor, the one other item I'd like to note on it, it's under technologies, it references the Eastern Sierra Connect Regional Broadband Consortium. One of the elements that we've talked about, and again, discussed this with Inyo County, was if there's a way to look at that consortium kind of becoming one of the roles for ESCOG, and so it would actually become more of an Inyo Mono Consortium, it would be taking Eastern Kern County and letting it focus more to that side or south.
3:21:12 And he's there for Kern. I think it creates a better alignment for the work, and we've talked actually with RIT folks here. I think they're in agreement with that. It would be something the ESCOG would need to have some discussion on, but if they could serve in that consortia role, when it helps give more focus to Inyo and Mono as it relates to technology and the leveraging of digital 395 and the broadband elements and being a gigabit community.
3:21:38 That would be one ask. We would go to SCOG to say we have this LF technology. We think there's a role there. There's some funding that comes with that, whether it's consortia funding or allocated back into the various communities, however that ends up going. But there would be a good role for them to take on that regional broadband and narrowing that region down really to Inyo and Mono counties. I spoke with John on that. He can elaborate on more details as need be there.
3:22:04 Process begins to set that up for ESCOG to kind of take on that regional role in that area. Okay. Yeah, I sit on the consortium board, and we had kind of a strategic session about a year ago, and we acknowledged the fact that, you know, trying to work in Kern, Inu, and Mono, I mean, it's a geographic stretch, and it's kind of, we all sort of acknowledged that that was the reality of it.
3:22:33 It's also becoming clear that the economic, the way this technology supports the economic interests of these regions is critical, and with the, you know, recreation, tourism economies, Nino and Mono, that starts going one way. Kern's got aerospace and defense and other kinds of things going on, and it's creating...
3:22:54 You know, some tension, and it's just sort of unwieldy. I've advised the board that this was coming forward. The Cog was going to be talking about it, seeing where this would go. And so it won't be a surprise to anybody in the consortia that these discussions are happening. But I think Dan put it very well. It's an opportunity to start leveraging state funds from the developing technology funds that can line up and support implementation of what we're doing here in the region and start talking about
3:23:23 Regional brand, regional update, all this kind of stuff that feeds into this Eastern Sierra destination idea. So I think it's a worthy endeavor, and it's worthy to get the cog to see what we can do with this thing. Yeah. My only comments are on the regional air service piece. I think we need some wordsmithing on that.
3:23:50 My main concern is today we have a viable commercial FA certified successful airport serving the region today. I think we need to include in this, I think the language is just too vague. I think we need to add that with the folks on Mammoth Yosemite Airport or something to do with based on current FA approvals and
3:24:20 Investment. A little bit more language. Yeah, I think it's in all of our interest maybe to keep it vague at this point. I think that, you know, I don't, you know, staff has been talking to whatever's going on down there and it's, the immediate focus obviously is around the technology and the recreation piece and the air service, the degree to which, if we can get, we're starting kind of with the technology because that's what's in the ground.
3:24:48 Right. And that's becoming something that can bring folks around that idea. Let's see how that goes. Well, I agree and disagree. I mean, the air surface is on the ground, too. My point is, is it's we have an airport that's already supporting the region today. I understand. I mean, I know there's dialogue of potential, you know, work with Bishop Airport, and I think we're all supportive of that.
3:25:14 But I just think there's got to be a little bit more support. I don't think that this gives enough support to go from the town. I'm hoping any words you want to put in there. I just wouldn't want anything that would be seen as being provocative. Well, no, I'm not suggesting that. I hear what you're saying, Michael. And so I'm going to ask the first question is with the short part of trying to get this to your group on.
3:25:41 Friday. Friday. Is it possible to just speak to the tech and rec and leave out the air service at this point? No, I think, well, I'm just looking at adding a couple, I'm just looking at a couple little wordsmith and we can get this done tomorrow and we can have it ready for Friday. Yeah, because right now it makes it sound like there isn't reliable regional air service and there certainly is. That's exactly how it reads. I mean, is it provocative to put Mammoth Yosemite in there?
3:26:09 Reliable research. I don't think it is with the focus on Mammoth-Yosemite Airport. I mean, I mean, Grady, could you guys have more conversation? Or you could make a statement there that we want to, you know, with leveraging the federal investment at Mammoth, something like that. That way we're saying if one of our leverage points is do we have alternative landing areas? Do we have an alternative if need be?
3:26:35 And that's kind of the discussion we've had with the Bishop Airport. So maybe we try to look at it that way and say how do we look at leveraging that current investment that we have in Mammoth already to the regional benefit or something like that. Yeah, that's totally appropriate. And just something to the effect of recognizing that we have a viable commercial airport and there's significant investment in the past and we're looking for it in the future. We're still interested in...
3:27:00 Regional solutions to some of the other issues. Recognizing that we have a successful airport might be plenty, but we can help write a couple of sentences that meet that intent. I think keeping it short, if we can talk about, you know, if we leverage what we've already invested at Mammoth. Why don't you work with these guys and figure it out. Just as long as there's consistent counsel that we can go ahead and wordsmith that section a little bit. And short and sweet. I'm not looking to write a story there. Sounds good.
3:27:28 Is there consensus for us to work on that because it won't have an opportunity to come back? No. Yes, that's fine. Okay. Okay, great. So, public comment? You sure you don't want to come up? Let me try an amended motion. Okay, Jo? Authorize the mayor to sign and forward a letter to ESCOG regarding working relationships and defined regional efforts after amendments as discussed this evening.
3:27:57 Great.
3:27:58 Are made.
3:27:58 Okay.
3:27:59 So that, and just to be clear, that's the two, the one.
3:28:01 Yes.
3:28:02 The move in the ad hoc and then.
3:28:03 The ad hoc and the expanding the regional air service.
3:28:06 Okay.
3:28:06 I'll second that.
3:28:07 Okay.
3:28:08 Any other discussion?
3:28:10 Motion to second.
3:28:10 Roll call, please.
3:28:11 Council Member Bacon?
3:28:12 Yes.
3:28:12 Council Member Frank?
3:28:13 Yes.
3:28:14 Council Member Webber?
3:28:14 Yes.
3:28:15 Council Member Webber?
3:28:16 Yes.
3:28:16 Mayor Ramondon?
3:28:17 Yes.
3:28:17 Motion passes 5-0.
3:28:19 We'll move on to item 15.
3:28:20 Consider a crossing guard program to be implemented at the intersection of Meridian Boulevard and Sierra Park Road.
3:28:26 Chief?
3:28:27 Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, about a month and a half, two months ago, we began discussions with the Mammoth School District, Lois Klein, also the traffic engineer, Hayes, trying to look at safety for the pedestrian students at that intersection. It was prompted by several near misses of students and then a bicyclist collision with a motor vehicle. And in that case specifically, it was the bicyclist fault.
3:28:54 So we looked at several ideas, ways to increase the safety of the students to and from school as they walk and sometimes potentially at lunchtime as well. And the best two options we were able to come up with was to increase the education levels of the students at the school, which we're actually starting working on right now. And the other was to hire crossing guards to man the intersection. The intersection would be manned from about...
3:29:20 7.15 to 8.15 before school, noontime. Potentially we'll have to see how that plays out with the high school students coming over to this shopping center for lunch and then after school as well. So the idea is to be able to hire two people at a higher level intern rate at about $18.55 an hour and use this as a beta test for the rest of the year.
3:29:48 We hope to be able to get the people hired, trained, and up and running by the end of January or sooner if possible. We want to house it within the police department. The authority in order to have non-sworn traffic people is on my shoulders.
3:30:05 As well as the shoulders of the police department to actually conduct the training. So in that case, what the training would be ongoing to make sure we can stay on top of the training, what the crossing guards are doing and the traffic flow is going correctly. Some of the reasons the traffic flow and potential for near misses is what's called platooning. We don't have kids as they're crossing platooning as in groups.
3:30:28 Crossing Guard would allow us to hold a group of them and then cross them together and then increase the safety and visibility to the students as they're crossing the street. Currently what's happening is we're getting streaming across. So kids just walk across the street not knowing that they have to actually yield to vehicles. And so with the crossing guards, we'd be able to actually control that a little better. It would increase the traffic flow. Since the elementary school redesign of the parking lot, that's actually increased the traffic on that area.
3:30:58 Groups of cars coming in, so congestion does go on pretty bad. Again, we want to keep it within the department because of the training, control, the staffing levels, and in case we don't have a crossing guard available that day, there's potential that one of my officers or civilian staff can actually get out and take care of that. The liability associated with it, there's no real increased liability when it comes to the actual pedestrians or the drivers.
3:31:28 A official traffic enforcement officer, whether it's a crossing guard or otherwise, people have to follow those laws. So if they're not following the direction of that traffic person, then they're actually at fault violation of the law. So therefore, that doesn't take us completely out of liability, but now it shows the liabilities on them because they failed to follow traffic laws and regulatory signs.
3:31:52 So that's kind of typically where we want to go with this. There are associated coursework workers' comp, potential liability issues, slip and falls. That would be part of the town's responsibility. But again, we would make sure they have all the proper safety equipment, the training, everything to make sure that they're as safe as possible. Not that we can't account for everything, but it would be on us. So that's essentially it. Any questions?
3:32:17 Questions? Yeah, just a quick one, Chief. So by controlling the pedestrians, we hope, that, but it's not going to change like if you had someone there as a traffic officer who's all of a sudden, you know, waving 10 cars through this way and then 10 cars through that way. We're just going to try and control the pods of pedestrians. Correct. That's the goal is the pedestrians instead of being out in the middle of the street. The general monitoring that happens now. Correct. Okay.
3:32:48 Any other questions? Questions from the public? Okay. Bring it back for discussion and or a motion. I like it. Yeah, I mean, I think we're all pretty familiar with that being kind of a standard practice is, you know, high traffic areas around schools typically have crossing guards. You know, I think it's concerning that we've had a couple of near misses and an actual non-miss.
3:33:20 I'm definitely supportive of the program. I suppose I wonder a little bit about the placement and the pay rate and those type of things. I mean, I've always kind of associated that as maybe a volunteer position. Is that something that we are going to explore down the line? We just haven't had time to look at that as an option? Having run volunteer programs in the past, we can't...
3:33:45 We'll assuredly put people out there. We're employees. We can schedule to be on site, and they become a town employee at that point. Volunteers, again, we can't say we definitely are going to have people housed, and then we have to worry about training, ongoing training of multiple people, not just a couple. There are options that we're looking for the future. Next year, we really want to look at this as a beta test to see what worked. Did it work? Is it worth the money? And then also reach out to the schools more, because as it stands right now,
3:34:15 Unified School is willing to put up about $4,000. Right. The Mono County Office of Education will also throw in some money to assist with this as well as, you know, the town of Mammoth Lakes. So the concern going that route is just a reliability factor of it? Correct. Okay. You know, I totally understand that this is kind of a beta test and see how it works. And, you know, obviously we're not talking a huge dollar amount total of $8,000 and contributions coming from a...
3:34:42 A number of different sources. So I just thought it was worth bringing up for discussion. Yeah, I think you touched on one concern just with liability of slip and fall kind of work that's comp kind of claim. But if you're going to take the measures and make sure that we do what we can do to make sure that doesn't happen because it's pretty easy to do out on icy roads. When it's four degrees. Oh, yeah.
3:35:07 Yeah. And part of the funding for that will be the safe routes to schools to pay for the equipment, you know, crampons, all the safety equipment, everything. Good. And so assuming this will run basically through the end of the year and then there'll be some sort of report back to us, evaluation of how it went? Yes. And an assessment of whether that would move forward for the...
3:35:28 The next year? Correct. And we would also, you know, again, look at other funding sources and, you know, other ways to pay for it in the future. But I think, you know, us having control of it keeps it going further and we keep the training, education, and the safety aspects all there. Okay. Okay. Okay. Someone care to make a motion? Sure.
3:35:50 Make a motion that Town Council approves the hiring of two part-time police department employees to act as crossing guards at the intersection of Meridian Boulevard and Sierra Park Road. Second. Okay, motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. We will now enter into item 16, closed session conference with labor negotiators, and we will announce any actions taken.
3:36:19 which are required to be disclosed after we're complete. Thank you. Good night. No issues. Live within your means.