TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2016

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 58 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

384 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:41 Yeah, really has. Is this item, Jamie, different than the one that we had?

1:40 Got it. Okay. Okay. No problem. Rich! Are you guys taking a midnight run tonight? Wow. Good for you. Ready to go, man.

2:14 Any one of those shirts. I like that shirt. It's pretty fancy. Really? Impressive.

2:45 Still missing Colin? He's over there. You ready? You guys ready?

3:30 Good evening. I'd like to call to order Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes regular meeting for Wednesday, March 16th, 2016, 6 p.m. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I've asked our Town Clerk, Jamie Gray, to lead us in the pledge this evening. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands.

4:06 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Jamie. I'll now open up the floor for public comments. For any items that are not on our agenda, please come forward. In case of seeing none, I'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Oh, there is one. Sorry. Is that on? There it is. Martin Kleinbarton, member of the town, community. I forgot to say to, and I don't see the member from the finance, but I wanted to.

4:44 Say thanks for the tax certificates getting out really fast and promptly this year because I thought it was in the online portal to pay your tax and get it done was pretty easy and straightforward. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Anybody else? Okay, I'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Are there any additions to the agenda this evening? Okay. Colin? Sure, thanks.

5:15 Just a couple items for me. I, along with the rest of the council, attended our strategic meeting Tuesday, March 8th. I'm excited the way that that's kind of wrapping up. We've got our final meeting on the 23rd, and looking forward to kind of putting some action steps together and tying that all together. Yesterday, I attended the...

5:41 A planned Mammoth Creek Park meeting at the community center with Councilmember Bacon. So that one was specifically looking at the community center element of the plan and programming and those type of things. So there's some good stuff coming out of that. There's another Mammoth Creek Park meeting coming up this Friday, March 18th, from 4 to 6 here in Suite Z. And that'll be looking at a design alternative for the site.

6:10 Yesterday I also attended the Chamber Power Lunch, which was a really impressive presentation from Chrissy Osborne with MLT about social media in 10 minutes a day. So it was a really interesting presentation, a lot of good content, so that was pretty cool. We'll be attending some events at the Winter Recreation Summit this weekend. I'm sure we'll hear a little bit more about that from some other people.

6:39 But excited to have that going on. On March 7th, I attended our monthly Mammoth Lakes housing meeting and just have a couple of items to report out on that. We reviewed and adopted our final audit for 2015. That's a really exciting read, as always. But we did get through that and accepted that.

7:09 And then the only other item, the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board did a box holder mailer back in January to kind of talk about the programs and offerings. And as a result of that, we have a local family in escrow to buy a deed restricted condo. We bought that condo back using the town's revolving loan fund. So that's exciting whenever that works as it's supposed to. So that's it. Thanks. Great. Joe?

7:38 I just wanted to add on the Plannier Park is that it was great to see the community involved and getting down into some of the details, and I think they had a great time. It looks like it's going to pull together some great information for us. The only other thing I had was that I was going to ask town staff to see what kinds of discussions they can have with Vons over not just getting thicker plastic bags, which are technically

8:07 Okay, under the ordinance, but I can just see our landfill filling up with all of those plastic bags. So is there consensus to ask the town to see what kind of negotiations they can do with Vons? Yes. Thank you for bringing that up. That's it. Thank you, Joe. John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. A couple things. I heard from some folks about the Vons plastic bag situation. I appreciate you bringing that up. On Thursday, March 3rd, I attended a meeting with the

8:37 Hart Howerton Group with Rich Bacia and members of the ski area staff. I just want to emphasize to folks that this is a constituent like any other. I meet with all kinds of people. It's part of our duty to meet with people and talk with people. It's a fully Brown Act compliant series of meetings. If anything comes out of that, it's going to be decided here at the dais with the council. It's not anything nefarious that I know of.

9:00 So I had an interesting meeting with them. Attended a day-long SCOG workshop down in Bishop. This is our Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. Priorities are focused on recreation, broadband, solid waste, and airports. Good day-long workshop looking at what we can do as a region. There's a lot of, I think, consensus and buying and a sense of recognition of having some unique opportunities these days and some folks willing to work on it.

9:25 And the idea of the regional air service, again, is kind of rising to the top of something to talk about. So that's something we can be talking about at the ESCOG meeting this week. On March 7th and 8th, they participated in the strategic planning workshop, as Colin mentioned. It was very interesting. On March 10th, met with the broadband task force getting ready for the Winter Recreation Summit. Suddenlink is providing high-speed broadband access for free over in the event center, which is nice because I've been to conferences there and there is no Internet access. And now there's going to be something, so that's interesting.

9:54 Just to help raise awareness of our gigabit opportunities, the Eastern Sierra has a more broadband access by a factor of 60 over the U.S. national average. And we pay half of what the national average pays for that same level of service. Just a little tidbit. And then on Monday I attended the LTC meeting with Chairman Richardson here, and he'll, I'm sure, give you some details.

10:23 A lot of that. The thing that was particularly interesting has to do with an investment that the Region 5 of the Forest Service is making in the environmental and design work to rebuild the road down to Reds Meadow. And they're committing to about three-quarters of a million dollars to do the design and the NEPA work. It's a very exciting, very interesting opportunity. I think the staff is going to come back and provide a presentation. But I think in terms of our community, if you look at the Devil's Postpile beautiful management plan,

10:53 The town of Mammoth Lakes, the community of Mammoth Lakes is mentioned on every page of this document. And the opportunity for us as a community to get really connected to a national monument, to funding resources through the Department of Interior, a lot of very interesting opportunities there. I'm very heartened to see the LTC wanting to move forward and try to put something together with that. So that's very interesting. There will be a lot more on that going forward.

11:19 Just been generally involved in helping put together the Mammoth Lakes Winter Recreation Summit. I know folks will be talking about that in more detail. There's some data that came out from NOAA today advising that this was the warmest winter on record. And just in case you were kind of harboring those kinds of suspicions, it's true. It's the warmest winter on record. And the closing night session of the Winter Recreation Summit is going to be addressing those issues specifically and specifically what we as a community and a town can do to be adapting to these new normals.

11:46 So it's going to be a very exciting series of meetings. I really hope everybody can come. And I think that that is it. Thank you very much, John. Okay. I'll get into the LTC meeting that John just spoke about here in a minute. But first, I went to a TOT meeting. The numbers are continuing to progress very nicely with TOT.

12:17 The enforcement side of TOT is going quite strong. So, you know, I've heard some rumblings out there that the enforcement might be lacking. It is not. I think we have 91, if I got the number right, I think 91 enforcement action is going on right now. And I think it will be brought before us here in the next couple of months about how those are going.

12:48 And with that, I want to say a little thing about LTC. LTC is, I'll tell you what, I am glad to be involved with the LTC. It's a great group of people. They put a lot of work in. This document right here is their overall work program. They do it every year. It's an extensive piece of work that...

13:13 Shows us what they work on on an annual basis. And it's quite a piece. But anyway, they are working on it, and I just wanted to point out a couple things. One, they're going after quite a bit of funding. LTC, which is Local Transportation Commission, is going after quite a bit of money through grants and what have you because we've lost a lot of income.

13:39 From our federal and state coffers for roads. And it's a very difficult time, and they're doing a great job going after monies. They also are working on airport planning, which is very important to us. We're also looking at a transit center, and ESTA is going to be working on that program for us. I think it would be great for us to actually have John Helm.

14:08 From us to come in and give us a report on that particular transit hub and what their thoughts are on that. Is that good with everybody? So if you could program that, that would be great. And let me see what else. Hold on. Got to put the glasses on this time. Oh, they have another program that's going on right now.

14:41 And it's the California Road Charge Pilot. And I'm sorry we don't have any handouts in the back. We'll try and get them back there. But we've been relying on gas tax for many years, and our gas tax has been shrinking quite a bit as gas prices have gone down. And so we're not getting monies into our state coffers for road repair. So they've come up with a new program, and it's a mileage-based program.

15:11 And it's a pilot that they're putting together, and they're looking for 5,000 people to actually be involved in the pilot. And we have actually quite a few of the LTC staff has signed up. So if anybody in the public wants to be involved, it would be a great program to be involved in. Because the more we can get our rural investment in Sacramento,

15:37 The more we're going to get in return. So I think it would be a great program. So we'll – I think they do. Yes, it's CaliforniaRoadChargePilot.com. So if you guys are interested, please take a look. Good. Thank you, Shields. Nothing additional to add other than I'll be attending, as John mentioned, the ESCOG meeting and ESTA. This Friday we'll report on that on our next meeting.

16:06 With that said, I'll move on to reports from commissions and or departments, please. Town Clerk Jamie Gray. Today at 5 o'clock was a deadline for candidates for the two upcoming Town Council vacancies. We have five candidates. The candidates are Jennifer Burroughs, Brent Truax, Cleland Hoff, Bill Sauser, and Jeff Posey. Thank you, Jamie.

16:32 If we can add to that with the new candidates coming up and we'll send some information out to them and he can get some of the details on that as there are certain rules that apply to them as candidates as if they were council members. Yeah, just, I mean, if they get elected and the Brown Act applies to them, I'll just remind them about the campaign filing statements they have to do and some possible conflict things for them to start thinking about and remind them that they can't talk to all five of you at once about current issues, just minor stuff intended to help them.

17:00 Andy, is that something you can e-mail to them? Yeah, that's what I'm going to do. I'll e-mail them and copy Jamie and Dan. Great. Perfect. Thank you. Grady? Thank you. Grady Dutton, Public Works. Just one thing additional to report. Yesterday, Brian Picken, our airport manager, and I were in F.A. offices in San Francisco.

17:17 We had great attendance, about six FAA staff members from the San Francisco AD over there as well as three others on a video conference from Los Angeles. We basically updated on where we were with the entire airport all the way back from safety all the way up through the project that we're hoping to move forward with soon.

17:36 There, again, we're very supportive of what we have. They have programmed this effort into their five-year program, so we do anticipate getting funding for a significant portion of the airport work. They have some issues they need to take care of in the house, and we hope that within a week to a month to get a note from them that says it's time to issue RFQ.

17:56 We talked to them about the possibility of starting our request for qualifications, our consultant selection process, sooner than later because it does take two or three months to go through that process, negotiate a contract with the consultant and be ready to go even before they're ready to issue the grants. We wouldn't spend any money except staff time. They were supportive of that and asked that we write them a letter kind of laying out the process and that they would likely respond to the positive. But again, we'll hear more on that later. But overall, again, it was about a two-hour meeting, very positive.

18:26 We met the new San Francisco Airport District Officer, Jim Lohman, recently moved down here from Alaska to California. He's excited to be here. In fact, he wants to come to Mammoth. He owns an RV and wants to come to our park. But it was a very good meeting and nothing but positive things to say about how we're approaching things. I do want to mention that we brought up our discussions with regional partners and the fact that

18:48 While we don't see, you know, two or three airports in the region, what we do see that there are opportunities for us to all work together on providing the best service possible. And again, we're very encouraged that we're doing that both at ESCOG and in every town council goals and priorities workshop we have. Great. Thank you. Thanks. Thank you. Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department.

19:12 I wanted to announce that we hired a new building official. Tom Perry, who is currently the building official for Mono County, will be coming over to the town starting on April 11th. It's very exciting. He worked for the town before for five years under the county, and he's back home.

19:30 We're looking forward to having them start on April 11th. Also, we've had some questions from the Lodging Association, some council members and others about code-compliant versus non-compliant lofts. The issue has really come up recently because we do inspections as required by the Quality of Life Ordinance, which has raised these issues when the inspectors are going out in the field.

19:55 And the town, we have adopted a municipal code section that addressed lofts and escape and rescue requirements. We adopted that back in 1986. So what we're going to do is clarify those requirements, the building code requirements, provide that information to the inspectors. We want to make sure that everybody's on the same page out there because it sounds like there's been some miscommunication out there in the field. So we are working on that summary sheet of the loft and just general exiting requirements for rental properties.

20:25 So that's all I have. Any questions? That's great. That would be really helpful. There's a lot of dialogue and confusion. Yes. Thank you. On the loft question? Yeah. Yeah, that would be very helpful. If I can just add to that real quick, too, we've had some good dialogue with the fire chief, and there's a strong desire on his part as well to say, let's look at how we define this together so we're on the same page as it goes to review and if they're looking at something and those types of elements.

20:52 People don't get a mixed message from what the town's codes are, the building code, and what the fire department's looking at. So we had a very good dialogue and discussion with that, and actually it's one of the press as well, just in terms of how do we come together and have a common goal here and really, I'll say, relying on the town, the building official, and that use definition and working through those elements together. So that was a very positive discussion going forward. So we're working through that. Great. Thank you. Thank you, Senator.

21:25 Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. Just a couple of announcements from Parks and Recreation and from the Commission. On Friday, March 25th, the department will be holding an annual Easter egg hunt and play date at our existing community center on Forest Trail. So it starts at 3 o'clock. Bring your baskets. Don't be late.

21:47 Also, our annual youth sports funding process is now open. The deadline for applications is March 31st. I'm pleased to say that we have a total funding amount of $34,800. That includes $6,000 from Mono County that we will administer through our process where the Recreation Commission will make recommendations at our meeting on April 5th to send to Town Council.

22:13 As Councilmember Bacon and Councilmember Fernie both mentioned, we've been very busy with our community outreach and programming workshops for our proposed new facilities. Back in February, on February 22nd and 23rd, we held workshops for the multi-use facility. We had about 50 people total at those. We had about 30 people come to the most recent ones at the community center, focused on the community center.

22:40 We also ran through this process with our Youth Advisory Committee, and we're working on doing some targeted outreach. We did some outreach with hockey players at Mammoth Brewing Company, which was very successful. And we're also working on putting together a Hispanic-specific outreach. So if you know anyone that is not able to come to our workshops, they can participate online or we'll take our show on the road.

23:05 But it's been really great to have all that community input. We're working with our Recreation Facilities Programming Committee, which may need an acronym, to distill that down to bring to the commission and then to council. And then our next workshop is actually right here in Suite Z. It's on Tuesday, April 5th. It will be at noon. We'll do a lunchtime meeting. And that one is specifically focused on the park and playground. And that will be right after our commission meeting.

23:31 Come. We're going to talk about some inclusive elements for our playground. We've been talking to some vendors. I think it's going to be a really fun workshop. And then on April 12th at 6 o'clock again here in Suite Z, we'll kind of have a general wrap-up of all of our workshops. And finally, the commission is looking forward to our workshop scheduled with town council on Wednesday, April 6th. So any questions? Just one question. So the amount of money available for youth funding this year versus last year, is there a percentage increase or a dollar increase on top of your head?

24:01 So last year we had lost that $6,000 from the county and the town was able to put in that $6,000. This year the county has put in the $6,000 and directed the town to administer it. Okay. So we're about even year over year? It's the same dollar amount. Same dollar amount. Correct. But really important funding for these organizations that are growing and we really want to encourage them. They do great work. So great to have that resource. Thank you. Thank you, Betsy. Thanks, everybody.

24:34 Hi, Joel Ratchie. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, Councilmembers. Just wanted to provide a brief overview of the upcoming Winter Recreation Summit happening this Friday evening and all day Saturday and Saturday evening. We're very excited. And just to inform Councilmembers and the public, the main purpose of this, the outcome, the desired outcome, is to solicit public feedback.

25:02 To inform decision making as we implement the trail system master plan. We've had a series of stakeholder meetings with Forest Service staff, Forest Service leadership, Mammoth Mountain, Public Works staff, MLTPA staff, and MLR staff. Anyway, been a part of most of those personally. Been very constructive. We really hope to solve some of the issues.

25:31 That people have been discussing over time. So I'm very encouraged. Also very excited to hear public feedback on some of the items we'll be discussing. Friday evening, we're very fortunate to be having a keynote speaker, Luis Benitez. He is the director of the State of Colorado Outdoor Industry Office. And he'll be speaking to us about the Eastern Sierra.

26:00 Outdoor recreation industry opportunities that we have here. Also, Kenji Haratunian, I hope I pronounced his name correctly. He'll be joining us that evening as well. And then to close the event, Saturday evening, we have a panel discussion, as John mentioned earlier, on the changing climate and how we might be able to adapt and optimize.

26:29 Our economy, our recreation offerings. So we're very excited about that. Some of the tracks that we'll be discussing throughout the day Saturday, fat biking, 7.30 in the morning, we have fat bike demos out at Sierra Star Golf Course. I got to ride the course last week myself. It was a lot of fun. So I encourage the public to come join us for that.

26:51 And then at 1030, the Forest Service will be discussing their OSV NEPA efforts. Public participation is critical for this topic, so we encourage you to join us for that. Other subjects will include things like winter snow play and where we might be able to direct folks to be able to play in the snow. Winter transit is a topic of discussion and also winter recreation in the Lakes Basin. I would encourage everyone to...

27:18 Go to mltpa.org to find out the schedule of events, all the information you need to know. Can't cover everything right here, right now. But everything is up. I must say I'm delighted to have been working with the team on this. Everything came together beautifully in a relatively short period of time. It's been very exciting. Great. Any questions? Great, Joel. Thank you. Thank you.

27:47 Okay, I'm going to move on to Council Presentations, Item 2, Proclamation and Recognition of Dan and Leslie Dawson for their contributions to the community. I'm going to have Councilmember Bacon present that this evening. Thank you, Michael. I used the smallest type font we could find and still be readable because if we had really listed everything that Dan and Leslie have done for us, it'd be a 10-foot-long proclamation. So please bear with me as I read you the abridged version.

28:14 Whereas Dan Dawson has turned two obscure reserve sites into nationally renowned research sites in his 37 years as reserve director, designed and constructed the first net zero energy building in Mono County, the Page Center at Snarl, developed and implemented an aggressive forest management plan at Valentine Camp,

28:35 Formed the Valentine Reserve Fund, a private donor group working in support of the reserves. Created a graduate student grant program attracting the best and the brightest grad students from across the country to the Eastern Sierra and brought millions of dollars to Mono County in the form of grants that were virtually all spent locally.

28:55 And whereas Dan testified at his first Mono County Board of Supervisors meeting in 1980, was a member and chair of the Mono County Planning Commission before the town incorporated, during which he was instrumental in the completion of the county's general plan update, countywide avalanche zoning, and other contentious issues.

29:15 And whereas Dan has been active in town and county planning and environmental issues, participated in the CEQA process on scores of projects, helped form the stakeholders group that allowed completion of the 2005 TOML general plan update, and worked on the Mammoth Creek EIR, which established minimum stream flows from Mammoth Creek. And whereas Dan was appointed to the original Mono Basin Scenic Area Advisory Board when the scenic area was created by Congress,

29:45 And whereas Leslie Dawson has been Education Coordinator for the Valentine Reserve for 20 years, developing outdoor science field trips for more than 40,000 elementary school students in Mono and Inyo counties, and creating the Snarl Lecture Series, Summer Camps for Students, and Interpretive Tours for the General Public. And whereas Leslie has been a true steward of our public lands through providing naturalist interpretive tours for the Forest Service, Mono Lake State Reserve,

30:13 Bodie State Historic Park and Tamarack Cross Country Ski Area for many years. And whereas Leslie has been active in local schools as a volunteer in elementary and middle school classrooms for both daughters and has taught elementary school at Lee Vining, high school special education at Camp O'Neill and middle school for the Mammoth Unified School District.

30:34 And whereas both Dan and Leslie have been active in the community through AYSO and other community organizations, now, therefore, be it resolved that the Town Council recognizes the actions of Dan and Leslie Dawson as active, contributing members of the Mammoth Lakes community and wishes them well in their future endeavors beyond Mammoth. And I said, that's the condensed version of what they have done for us.

31:01 I know several people are here somewhat to support them. I'm wondering if there's anyone who would want to step up to the podium and say a few words. And you don't have to. So may I ask that we move approval of this proclamation? Yes. Yes. Yes. Do we get a second? I'll second. Thank you. Roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

31:30 Yes, motion passes 5-0. So if you two will join me up here. Unless they were some of the first people I met when I got to Mammoth and I have enjoyed every single day of it. And we will miss you when you move to Ashley.

32:12 Dan has something. Dan, I was going to say, I hope something. I just have a few, a few words. You got a couple notes? Well, Dan puts his glasses. I'd like to say that in 1980, he started coming to a lot of meetings, came for many years, and when he walked out the door, I always said, don't say anything quotable and keep your name out of the paper. And this is the first time I didn't say that to him. I just want to say.

32:39 Thank you very much on behalf of both of us for this honor and special thanks to our good friend and our dedicated volunteer at the Reserves, Jo Bacon, for spearheading this effort for us. Jo started volunteering for us almost before she came to Mammoth and has been a continuous volunteer ever since and we rely a lot on other community volunteers.

33:03 As you all know, communities work best when everyone contributes and pulls together, and I think that's especially true in small towns where there's a limited pool of participants. And when Leslie and I came to town 37 years ago, we saw plenty of opportunity to participate, and so we stepped up and did so. And it's been a pleasure to participate in Mammoth and Mono County, in government, in sports, in schools, in service.

33:30 And I hope we can serve as examples for more young people in this community that are moving to Mammoth and so that they'll all do the same. We had the good fortune to work for the University of California and ultimately the University of California exists to benefit the people of California. And so through education, research and public service. And so we were able to contribute both through our work and

33:59 On sort of on our private side. And I'd like to call out special thanks to a few people in this room. I already mentioned Councilmember Bacon. She's volunteered for us and been important to us. She started our first website and maintained it for many years after her term was up. I'd also like to call out Rusty Gregory. He's not here tonight, but he's been a special supporter of both us.

34:28 Privately and our school programs. One of the little-known facts is that Mammoth Mountain Ski Area underwrites our school field trip program and has done so for 20 years without getting much publicity for it, and it's certainly been important to Inyonmono County school kids.

34:47 And then we've got a cadre of people in this room who both volunteer for us and help support the reserves financially. And really, we couldn't have done some of the things we've done without their support. So thank you very much for this honor. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, I'm going to move on to public presentations. Presentation regarding the Mammoth Community Water District Water Supply and Rates Update presented by Pat Hayes.

35:24 Executive Director of MCWD. Pat? Good evening. I'm pulling up my presentation. Thanks for inviting me to come talk about one of my favorite subjects was water and wastewater. Tonight I'm addressing questions that you raised in regards to water supply and what that translates into in terms of conservation. And also recently we passed a rate increase which

35:59 I'd like to also mention in passing as well. The first item in my agenda is about water supply. It's been a concern for us for many years. We've had four years of drought, and the community has been extremely supportive of the conservation efforts that were necessary last year. The state mandated a 20% reduction.

36:26 But locally, because we were completely dependent on groundwater and nine groundwater wells, we needed to go at a much higher level, 30% reduction. And we had, during the summer months, more than a 35% reduction in water consumption. Just an extraordinary effort on everyone's part. I know it wasn't pleasant to see your lawns go brown and parkways go, but

36:51 We did get through, and I think you'll see some of the data I have here that there was strong reasons why that was the case. We had to go to that level. So what does it look like going forward? This slide is as of March 16th. It's put out weekly by both the DWR and the LADWP. This represents the precipitation data at our go-to location at Mammoth Pass. There's a snow pillow there. Occasionally they go out with their big straws and take weights.

37:21 To make sure it's calibrated. But what's interesting on this diagram, the line in red is our current year. And as of yesterday, we were at 41.8 inches of water equivalent snow. That means that we're at 104% of average. And by mentioning average, you'll see the dark straight line there that it's almost resting on, this red line. That's an average year.

37:47 In hydrology, that's a big joke. There's no such thing as an average year, but it happens to be following that. A couple other traces are on this, notable. Starting at the top, the best year on record was 82-83, and that's what you see winding across the top of this screen. The blue one is actually the last El Nino, 93-94, and we've actually been tracking that fairly closely.

38:15 What's to be taken from that is that this is actually a relatively normal El Nino sort of undertaking. What it tells us is between now, which is mid-March until the end of April, we might be seeing another five to eight inches of water equivalent. Not necessarily snow, but more water potentially if it follows the track that we've been on. The worst year of record? Well...

38:41 Nobody would be surprised to hear that that's the bottom trace, and that was last year. So it's an encouraging trend. Here's how we stack up in the region. The data on the left is for snow pillows. The data on the right is from rainfall. We're at 104%, and you can see we're the top of the pile here as far as precipitation. That bodes well for this year, but what does it mean in terms of going forward?

39:10 We're going to be looking at for water conservation. These traces here show the sources of our water supply over the last year from January of 15. It's color-coded. Brown means groundwater. And you can see that most of our supply is coming from groundwater. And just that little bit of blue for February was the couple of days we were able to run our Lake Mary surface water plant.

39:37 We're still reliant on those wells. During the summer months last year, the untreated groundwater in yellow, the reclaimed water in purple, those were used, the purple is used at the golf courses. This year, both Snow Creek and Sierra Star will be on that, and they're mandated to buy that water by contract. We built the system, costs about $10 million, they have to buy the water. But more to the point, we're still on groundwater.

40:06 I won't bore you with the details here, but these are the nine wells, and they're all significantly drawn down. I'll show you a couple of traces from wells. This is a long timeline, taking you from June of 2013 to the present. Well 10, it's out in Snow Creek, and you can see a downward trend going on with this well. And the warning level is that orange line, and we were seeing that all the time during last year about when it had to be shut down.

40:35 The bottom of the well is the red line. Well 15, very indicative as well. You can see the long-term trend is down. Well 17, Sam's Wood Site, down. Well 20, down. So until we see some improvement in these well levels, we can't really get out of our conservation mode. We don't think it's prudent to say otherwise. Currently, we're in level 3.

41:03 Level 3 means that we have a very limited water supply, asking for 30% reduction, so it would be basically rinse and repeat from last year. However, with the water supply situation in snowmelt, we expect to see two important factors happen, groundwater recharge, and that we'll be able to run our surface water plant at Lake Mary and be able to rest the well. So the combination of those two,

41:33 Is a great thing to be looking forward to. But until we see recovery, it wouldn't be prudent to change where we're going on the trajectory. So level three, just for your edification, it means a 30% reduction, very limited amount of irrigation going on, three hours twice a week. It's very limited. We hope in...

41:58 In our April board meeting to make a recommendation, but we probably won't be able to see any real change in that until at least May when some of the recharge starts to occur. Wastewater and water rates is the other aspect of this. I have here the complete presentation given by our consultant to our board for rates. For those of you who are truly interested, I invite you to go to the town's website where the entire presentation is listed.

42:29 I'd like to just cut to the chase. In the period from 2012 to 2015, each year from our last rate study, we had a 1% increase for wastewater and a 2% for water each year. The rate study, same consultant, the projected rate increases for the next five years are identical. 2% for water, 1% for wastewater.

42:56 I ask the question, I don't think we're really keeping up with inflation, and I think that's the answer, is we're just creating regular rate increases to make sure we continue on a good track. A lot of water utilities make the mistake of not doing a rate increase for five or six years, and all of a sudden, rate shock. So having regular small increases is important. How does this go to the affordability? Our water rates, in comparison with at least 15 water utilities throughout the state, are the lowest.

43:26 We've lost about $800,000 in revenue cumulatively over the last two years. So we're bearing that with our reserves. However, going forward, we've

43:56 Taken great pains to look at our reserve policy and make sure that we're keeping adequate reserves. Currently, we have $11.7 million in reserves. Our reserve policy is based on a replacement value of our asset. It may come as a surprise to you that a replacement value of this asset, the entire utility, is some $287 million. Over a quarter billion dollars of invested utility out there, pipes.

44:22 Pumps, pump stations, wells, treatment plants, and everything that goes with that. So our reserve policy is seeking with these rate increases also to put about 4% or 5% of our income into reserves to bolster them up over the next five years to hit our target of about $15 million. At that rate, we're looking at a replacement period of about an average life of an asset of about 25 years.

44:50 When we did the rate study, the other thing we looked at was adjusting it according to making sure parity, and the result was that the multifamily was getting a bit of a free ride, and so instead of being at 0.75 of a rate for a single family, it's now at a full 1.0. Other than that, there's really not much in the way of rate shock or anything of particular interest. We sent out a Prop 218 notice required by law for this.

45:17 And we tally the protests. We received one protest from almost 10,000 property owners that we sent it to. We also sent it out to all the post office boxes because not everyone is a property owner, but they also pay for water. There was some interest, but no particular pushback from the community that was there about the rates that we did do. So that concludes my presentation. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.

45:44 Great. Thanks, Pat. Questions? Yeah. I have a couple. Pat, you know, in all of this, of course, the first question comes, okay, we understand that the costs were up, but what have you done as far as either minimizing costs or being efficient with the staff or whatever you have? Can you make any cuts there that would affect new rates? The first part of the answer to the question is how we're structured.

46:11 We're more like a private utility rather than a public agency in many regards. A special district has a little bit more latitude than, say, a municipal government. First and foremost, the board of directors, which has been very stable over the last 20 years, the track we have taken for employee benefits is not the CalPERS program, which is a defined contribution plan.

46:35 With not nearly particularly good actuarials on how much it will actually cost because you don't know what the investments will bring back, yet there's an obligation of the agency to pay those. So we're not a CalPERS utility. We have a defined contribution plan, and that has greatly controlled those costs and the risks to the utility in that regard. We have a very stable workforce. We have 42 full-time positions. Currently, we have two vacancies.

47:04 One of those vacancies has been kept open for quite some time because simply stated we haven't needed to fill that position. So you would look immediately to what the salaries and benefits are. Those are areas where we've controlled it by that means. When we can, we hire people through an employment agency rather than have them around for a short period and then be obligated for a long-term commitment to them. We do a lot of work in-house.

47:33 We have a summer construction crew, and that saves millions of dollars every year where they go out and do lateral replacement and mainline replacement valve replacements rather than hiring contractors who come in from afar, pay for their per diems and all the other accoutrements. Doing it with in-house summer construction crews has been a great step. But the most important area is in our capital program.

48:01 That's where the bulk of our money goes to. The rates that our rate payers pay is to maintain the assets we have out there. In the last 20 years, we've replaced virtually the entire distribution system. It was originally steel. When it was installed, it was not particularly well inspected. 20 years ago, our leakage rate was 45%. So roughly said, you put two gallons in the system, you get one gallon out.

48:29 We're now in the 5% sort of range with that investment. The other is in the asset management. We take great pains to look at the actual risk element. What's the probability of failure? What's the consequence of failure? We rank all of our projects, and we only fund those at the top of the list with the highest priority and the highest risk. So that in itself sets us up so that we're only taking care of what really needs to be done. The real gotcha in all this

48:59 Is that trumping any of that is regulatory control. In 2007, the EPA changed the minimum level for the contaminants of copper and lead. Lead's been in the news recently with Flint, Michigan and other places. We don't have any lead pipe here. The issue is we have a lot of copper pipe. Snow melt is fairly acidic water. And so left in the pipe for long periods, acid and metals don't do well together.

49:29 They like to get together. And we had to implement, by regulatory requirement, an $8 million capital plan to provide buffering of the system to address that, which has been implemented. It's working perfectly. We've just had the second of two results since the plan has been put in place, and we're in full compliance for lead and copper. The regulatory part is somewhat unpredictable, but you can predict that it's not going to get less.

49:59 In terms of regulations. Thank you. Any other questions? Just a couple questions. You mentioned seeing evidence of recovery in May. Is that about right? Yes. That's driven by speculation. You mentioned it was the warmest year on record. When the snowmelt occurs is somewhat speculative. So that's a normal sort of cycle when we expect to see snowmelt going on up in the lakes basin.

50:28 That will drive our ability to run the Lake Mary treatment plant and see if there's any recharge going on in the nine well systems we have. Okay. And I think that, I mean, it's a testament to the community. You've put out a call for reduction, state mandated, but also for the needs of our own system. The community seems to have responded very well and conserved water and done all the things we asked of them. Can you paint for us a scenario where...

50:57 This good behavior will be rewarded with rates going down at some point? Or is that just not ever going to be in the cards? Well, it doesn't exactly work that way. And what I'm going to say is going to sound somewhat like heresy to you. Running utility is pretty much a fixed cost. It doesn't really matter how much water we sell or don't sell. But part of our income stream is from rates. There are a number of utilities in the state who are in very deep trouble.

51:25 About 30% of their income comes from fixed charges, but 80% of their costs are fixed. So when you drop water sales, they go deeply into the red. Our situation is far better. We're almost aligned with what our fixed costs are and what our base charges are. But it's really not about the gallon of water you consume. It's all the things that have to be done to get that water there, the fixed costs that drive that.

51:55 So from that perspective, I mentioned a moment ago, and just to reiterate, in 2014 and 2015, the utility, because of lowered water sales, lost about $800,000, which was not passed on to consumers. That was taken from reserves. But now we need to build those reserves back up to be prudent for our asset management side of the equation. So, but tactically, how you guys are approaching is about a 1% a year.

52:23 I mean, that over time, that works for you guys, for your projections going forward. Yeah, 1% for wastewater, 2% for water, which is an anomaly pacing with inflation. Okay. And finally, do you have anything you can share about your ongoing conversations with ORMAT and that whole process? I'd be happy to. We've had a number of meetings with them. The last one was January 26th.

52:53 Consultants in that field. ORMAD made a significant offer, a concession, to put in one deep well at their cost. However, one deep well is a point in space. You really need at least two wells to have a gradient, if you will. And they here in that case offered to lead the grant writing for a California Energy Commission grant.

53:22 The district would be the sponsor of that, the water district, and that if it were successful, it would result in an 80-20 grant, the 20% coming from Wormat, the 80% from the CEC grant. However, the caveat that's missing there is what happens if there isn't a grant, and they have as yet not been willing to guarantee the drilling of that second well. We're talking about a million and a half dollars on a $150 million project.

53:48 Are you going to go ahead with the grant writing process? Is that proceeding? That's what we've agreed to, but things have gone relatively quiet in the last six weeks or so. Okay. So I'm sure we'll pick up the gauntlet again soon. Good. Well, yeah, keep us posted. Certainly. Thank you. Anybody else? Thanks, Pat. Thanks very much. Thank you. Any question? Any comment? Sure. Amy Cutter. I have a question.

54:19 You talked about the 30% reduction. Is the 30% reduction on top of what we've already reduced? Or if you can clarify that? Because I'm all about conserving water, but at some point, you know, if we've all been conserving, how do you get 30% more? Thank you. That's a very good question. Sorry for the confusion. The 30% is based on, and this is the state's rules on it, it looks at the 2013 water year.

54:50 And they mandated for us 20%. We said 30%. It's only relative to what the consumption was in 2013. And we more than achieved that. So you could actually back off a little and still be at 30% because overall, I mean, as a community, not necessarily individually, but we were above our goal. And we're optimistic that come May we can back off at least an increment on that.

55:20 In terms of conservation. But no, not another 30% on top of what you did relative to the 13%. Thanks. Thanks for that clarification, Pat. Thank you. Okay, we're going to move on to our consent agenda. I have a... Oh, I'm sorry. Sorry about that. I skipped over. Our staff presentation item four, update regarding the police station project presented by Public Works Director Grady Dutton. Sorry about that, guys. It's okay.

55:47 Thank you. We have another Hayes before you tonight. This one is Haislip Hayes, our engineering manager. Hayes is going to present really the overall status on the police station project, really where we started, where we ended up with right now. Just a quick brief. We are actually in plan check. We've got a first round of some comments. What we don't have for you yet tonight is our final budget numbers.

56:09 We're working through that with our consultant and their cost estimator. That estimator has reported they're contacting local contractors as well to try to make sure that we have a really good read on what we think this is going to cost before we go out to bid. And we'll be back before you before we do that to let you know exactly where we are. We don't know yet that we'll need any budget adjustments or any requests for that, but I want to let you know that we're not ready for that tonight. We're still working on those numbers. With that, I'll turn it over to Hayes and let him walk through the process.

56:38 Thanks, Grady. So just going to walk you through where we are today and how we got there. So July of 2015, you authorized financing for the new police station. In September, we issued an RFQ for architectural and engineering services. In October, we received five responses and ultimately selected HMC architects.

57:03 Later in October, you awarded a contract to HMC. So in a matter of just a few months, we went from zero to, you know, designing the project. Thank you. I now have theme music. We spent the week of November 2nd working with the architect to develop a preferred alternative. This was more than just a kickoff meeting. It was a kickoff week. We spent the entire week going through the entire process.

57:34 We started off that week looking at sighting, and the first slide I have here just kind of shows the overall parcel we're considering for the police station. And it shows a town hall and some sites for a future building and an extra parking lot because we didn't want to preclude ourselves from building something in the future. You know, there are future visions for this project. This doesn't really tell you where everything has to go, but we just want to make sure we weren't stepping on our own toes.

58:04 We ultimately selected the location kind of highlighted in red here. It's the preferred location because of its proximity to utilities. It's flat, easy for construction. We could just share the parking lot with the courthouse, and it provides kind of a justice center feel.

58:23 So we have our courts and our police station in close proximity. We also met with our neighbors, the courts and the hospital, to understand how this could impact their future development. And ultimately, everyone was really supportive of this location and felt that this was a good location for the site. Later on that week, we began meeting with police station staff. We evaluated their operations to appropriately program the space.

58:54 Floor plan. And I'll kind of just walk you through it quickly. There's really four quadrants to it. The upper right-hand corner has an entry vestibule with a telephone for 911 calls. It's sheltered so anybody who does go to the police station when they're not in operations has the ability to get services. It has a public restroom, which we currently do not have. It has a public live scan room for backgrounds and so forth, which is currently shared with a copy machine.

59:21 We have a new large conference room, which currently doubles at our existing station as a break room and staff writing room. The kind of quadrant to the upper, let's see if you're your looker's left, is the administrative side of things. And it's approximately the same size as what we have now. We didn't really expand upon our office spaces. We did add an electrical room. We added a data room, which is currently housed in the hallway.

59:49 And some janitor spaces and some additional storage, which we currently don't have. On the lower left of this is the holding area when we keep evidence and Al can keep his customers overnight or for as long as he needs to. It has two holding rooms and a booking area.

1:00:09 On the right-hand side, lower right-hand side, we have kind of our offices, locker rooms and restrooms and a shower, which we currently use for storage of ammunition and a couple other spaces that we're in desperate need of. At the end of the day, we're ending up at about 5,300 square feet total office space. Once we kind of had the floor plan laid out, we started doing some massing exercises to figure out what the structure should ultimately look like. These are just a couple of slides.

1:00:40 Massing that we did using Google SketchUp to kind of see how it looked on the site. We worked with HMC to kind of refine these alternatives, and 100% schematic design was submitted in December. In January, we took that design to the Planning and Economic Development Commission, and we had an administrative hearing on the design review application. These are the material boards.

1:01:10 These are the colors that were presented and ultimately selected. These are hardy plant, concrete board, dark blue, light beige. We have some accent materials. The core 10 steel is kind of mirrors off of the existing courthouse. We are trying to take some architectural elements from the courthouse to kind of mute the courthouse and make them kind of look similar in nature but still retain that kind of mountain architecture that we're more fond of.

1:01:39 Planning Commission did approve that design review, and once we had that, we authorized HMC Architects to go ahead and move forward with the final plans and specifications. Those were submitted on February 22nd, and the application is currently working through the various departments, MCWD, Mammoth Lakes Fire, Public Works Planning, and so forth. And we're hoping to have a building permit in our hands sometime April, which would put us starting construction sometime around June.

1:02:08 And then we'll have a ribbon cutting ceremony sometime probably Memorial Day or July 4th of next year. So that concludes my presentation if you guys have any questions. One question, Hayes, and it has to do with the hardy board, hardy plank, whatever it's called.

1:02:30 You know, that's been in use around our town for about eight to ten years, and I know the library in particular has had some real problems with it not holding up to our weather. Will you be asking for certain ratings on it or things like that? Yeah, we'll be definitely getting a warranty on it. We're using a little bit different style as well. It's a board and batten. It's a heavier, bigger planks. Okay. So some of the early products are just not holding up? Absolutely. And it's also, you have to install it correctly. If you make any mistakes along that process, you will have issues.

1:03:02 Questions? I'm assuming there's a snow removal, snow storage plan for this whole project. Right. So fortunately right now the whole area to the south of the building is vacant. So we can store all of our snow back there. And the lot is currently being plowed for the court. So we have some ability to share those responsibilities with the court to kind of mitigate our costs up front. Is the entire building single story?

1:03:35 It is all single story. And how much larger can it go? It says future. We have it designed to expand an additional 2,000 square feet. You can see to the right of the building, there's a little white area, and that's for future expansion. So that's 2,000 feet. Correct. Okay. Thank you. All right. Now we'll move on to our consent agenda. I have a request from the public to pull.

1:04:07 Martin Kleinberg from the public to pull item 8. Is there any other items that the public council staff would like to pull? Okay, seeing none, I'll entertain a motion on all others other than 8. Mr. Mayor, I'd be happy to make a motion. Council approves consent. Agenda items 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, and 12. Second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:04:39 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Martin, would you like to come up and talk on your item or you'd like staff to? Okay. Sandra? Good evening. In response to the information that we received or the questions, I just want to reiterate that the amendment that we're proposing to the Towns Municipal Code is really solely

1:05:16 To ensure that we have the tools, the teeth, to enforce working without a permit or in any way working outside of the California Building Standards Code, which our municipal code adopts. There's no other intention. So do you want to add anything? Okay. Martin, comments? Good evening, Martin Kleinbard. Good evening, Mayor and staff.

1:05:52 All of you guys have seen the questions and the statements that I've made, and I reiterate the same context as from last town council meeting where there's a question of everyone's just avoiding the big elephant in the room, which is why the need to classify a construction issue that may or may not result in a

1:06:22 Stop order, work being done without a permit when we have current laws, regulations that allows a town to abate, to fine, to prosecute, to even have one greater avenue which is charged with a misdemeanor instead of an infraction. And there's underlying causes that will be available to the town if it's classified as a nuisance.

1:06:52 And I don't know why everyone's avoiding that. That was even part of a discussion at any time that I've had with staff. If you Google the term, the 1997 Human Habitation Law or something for California, in plugging with Mammoth, you'll get a staff report from the Quality of Life Ordinance. So the manner in which that

1:07:19 The comment was in the staff report was the square footage of a building of a dwelling for habitation, but staff said that they reviewed it. Staff told me that when I wasn't even talking about that subject, I was just talking about lofts and how do you go from an existing non-conforming, which everyone...

1:07:41 You need to understand that in the building industry, nonconforming doesn't mean that it just doesn't conform. It means that it was built legitimately at the time, planned, approved, inspected, and signed off for what the use and the construction. And we have a tremendous amount of properties that may fall into categories of nonconforming. Town has a policy.

1:08:11 On the books, as we say, that they want to get rid of nonconforming uses. Martin, let me stop you for one second. I mean, you're talking about two different things, right? You're talking about loss, which is not this item. This item is a stop work on it. I know perfectly well that what I'm trying to clarify is that we're enacting a law when we already have building code violations law that offers prosecutorial

1:08:41 And if the intention is not to classify any...

1:09:09 Any work done that is contrary to our building code, because that's basically what the ordinance is going to read for this nuisance, take out nuisance and classifying it as a nuisance. Don't put it in the nuisance ordinance. Say we adopt all the remedies available under Chapter 8, whatever the remedies are, and we incorporate those remedies into this without classifying them as a nuisance. I offer that suggestion.

1:09:36 Two weeks ago at the last town council meeting. And I think that that's only fair because otherwise my feeling and other people's feeling that I've been talking to will say that the goal is to classify something as a nuisance so that they can do and impose other things. And that's where it's about. And that's where everyone's failing to recognize the situation. In all fairness,

1:10:08 Remove the words nuisance from it and just because after all what you guys want is essentially what you already have but you want more so just say we also include under the building code section of our thing which is chapter 15 we include all the remedies available in chapter 8 under nuisances. So thank you for your time. Thank you.

1:10:34 Mr. Mayor, I had also taken a look at this item, and I requested of staff if they could provide some examples without violating confidentiality issues of situations where there have been projects that have preceded that staff has lacked the authority to do the things they needed to do. And I'm going to give staffs prepared to give some...

1:11:02 Some details or some update on that of examples. They've issued stop orders and they've kept working? Yeah, where theoretically the need for this would come into play and you guys would fulfill that gap. Yeah, and we actually went back and looked at some records of that and they can speak to the details of some of the items, as you mentioned, the specific names and locations.

1:11:23 Have a confidentiality component for code enforcement. But we've had a half a dozen places where those issues have been notified and put on that and people continue to work or it's after hours and different times. And having some additional teeth in the code to do certain things likely would have allowed us to put additional efforts into compliance, which is our goal. Some issues with nuisances come into play. It gets to be a real long, drawn-out process.

1:11:51 Abatement nuisance and you want to go through ultimately to condemn a property, so to speak, and have somebody do a lot of work to fix it up and you go through a whole, that is a, I don't know, Andy could tell you, multi-months or years process, but that's not the intent. The intent is how do we get enough teeth so we can actually end up in a compliance mode and have that, whatever it takes in some cases, because a lot of folks, I hate to say it, just, yes, we heard you, but we're going to finish our project.

1:12:17 And we're trying to figure out and, you know, we've had a lot of support from the contracts in general on, you know, get a permit, build it correctly, get the licensed people in there, and we still see instances around town where there's either work without a permit, there's a stop work order, they continue to work, and so we work through those things. And we have used some of the other remedies we do have, but again, not always successfully without going through quite a process. Andy, if you want to add any of the details.

1:12:45 The biggest change that this makes is that right now we can't declare simple building code violations to be nuisances, which means that we don't have the ability to force people to clean them up, short of going to court and getting an order. If we could declare work without a permit or work that's not consistent with the current code to be a nuisance, then we could, theoretically, we could tell the owner, look, if you don't fix this, we're going to.

1:13:11 And then we'll bill you for it and we'll put a lien on the property. It's not something we, I don't think we would do very often. Mr. Kleinbart is incorrect in his email where he's saying that this is a way of trying to enforce current codes against older buildings. That's not what this does. It's not something we've ever discussed. It's not the intent. This really is just one more tool that we have to go.

1:13:34 Proceed against people who are working without a building permit, working through a red tag, or doing stuff that just isn't consistent with the current code. It is not about trying to make old structures comply with today's codes. Thanks for clarification. Real quick. Okay. So under our building code.

1:13:55 Section 15.04.160. So where do these violations not work? Because you have the ability for prosecution of a violation. If a notice of violence is not complied with promptly, the building official is authorized to request legal counsel of the jurisdiction to institute appropriate proceeding of law. Same thing, violation penalties. You have all that. You don't need to declare anything other, a nuisance,

1:14:25 Thank you. Any other?

1:14:56 Sure. Jennifer Halferty. I didn't come here to talk about this, but I'm really glad that this is coming up. I didn't even know it was on the radar. I've worked with Shireen. I have a neighbor who started erecting a structure that people would walk under without a building permit. That's dangerous because that holds snow, and they kept working, and I would love to see them have to either take it down or fix it and give some teeth, and I'm hoping that this can be retro.

1:15:29 So, that's it. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Any other dialogue from Council? There's somebody. Hi, Amy Kutter. I have two questions. One is, so, specifically in the half a dozen or so cases that you were talking about, Dan, how is it that what is already on the books, you could not achieve the goal of getting compliance?

1:15:58 Let me go to the comment that Andy mentioned on that. One of under a nuisance element, we could actually go in in a more timely fashion and do the work ourselves if we had to. And then you bill that back to the person. The other process, you go through court and stuff, and ultimately it's an order to the property owner to still do it. And so by telling them, hey, here's your deadline to fix it, or we will go through the process and fix it for you and bill you accordingly, most folks actually don't want us doing that. It tends to be more costly.

1:16:27 Obviously the court issues and time and those types of things. Ultimately a lot of this is back. You do look at can we find you, can we do this? And some folks, hate to say it, it doesn't get their attention until you do something much more drastic. And so are we saying? Some of those we ultimately I think got some compliance issues, but having that extra issue going, we're not going to wait six months, nine months or a year in a court process and have a dangerous condition out there.

1:16:55 Okay, so it's really about you, the town, going in and using that as a stick, that you're going to go and be in the construction business and do the work on behalf of this homeowner and charge him back. You hire a contractor, the whole nine yards, you do it according to a permitting process, yes. But I don't think we do it very often. I mean, I think it's helpful to have that as a possibility, but I don't think it's one that we'd ever, or not that we'd ever use, that's not true. But I don't think it's one that we would use lightly or frequently.

1:17:24 I see. So in the case of, sorry, the tree that fell on hillside, so you're saying in a case like that, the town did not have the tools by which to come in and take that tree down? We actually have used this tool to take down trees in the past in a couple of areas. In the existing law? As a nuisance, because a tree can be. That's not a red tag issue.

1:17:51 So that's already a nuisance that we can declare through other processes. Right, so it's already on the books without this law, for example. For the purpose that you said, yes, and it can be very effective to use. In terms of, we've had, I think, two examples that we actually had to take a tree down and charge back to the property owner. Right, so the existing codes. But we cannot do that on the working outside of a building permit. We don't have that authority to call that a nuisance. The tree, we can call a nuisance.

1:18:20 That gives us authority to go do it. And then on a separate line of questioning, has the town pursued a grant in any way, shape, or form to support the code enforcement option? Is there any kind of outside funding that has been pursued and achieved? Not achieved. We went after a grant for a particular area in the community to enhance code enforcement efforts. We were not successful with that. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion. Okay.

1:18:51 I would like to make a motion to adopt the attached amendment to Chapter 8.20.020 of the Municipal Code. Okay. I have a motion and do I hear a second? Second. Second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Friend? Yes. Council Member? Yes. Member Wilson? Yes. Member London? Yes. Member London? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We're going to move on to Policy Matters, Item 13. I hope I could real quick. On 13 or 14? Both.

1:19:22 Okay. So just, yeah, real quick before we jump into it, I just wanted to, you know, mention publicly that I did spend some time considering whether items 13 and 14 would be a conflict for me personally. We do conduct some business at the property as we do it.

1:19:41 Every property in town. I consulted with Andy on that, and determination has been that I have no conflict in this particular case. I don't know if you want to add anything further, but just wanted to reveal that. Great. Thanks for sharing. Okay, we'll move on to item number 13, Appeal of Planning and Economic Development Commission's approval of the TALUS Amendment tentative track map 15-002, use permit 15-002, and design review 15-002. Staff? All right, thank you, Mayor.

1:20:12 This item is to consider an appeal of the Planning and Economic Development Conditions February 10th approval of the TALUS Amendment. The TALUS Amendment proposes to subdivide lots 10 through 19 of the TALUS Planned Unit Development, or PUD, into 20 townhome lots. The TALUS PUD is located adjacent to Meridian Boulevard within the Lodestar Master Plan in Development Area 2.

1:20:39 Development Area 2 is primarily intended for transient residential uses comprised of single-family and multifamily homes. The TTM for the TALUS PUD was approved in 2004 and consisted of 19 fractional ownership homes. In 2005, the final map was recorded, which legally created the 19 lots within the TALUS PUD in the exact location they exist today.

1:21:07 The 2004-2005 approval is still valid and the developer could pull a building permit to construct the approved approximately 5,000 square foot single residential units within each lot. However, rather than construct the large single residential units, the developer is requesting approval to construct duplex units. Each set of duplex units will be in the same location as the originally approved single residential unit.

1:21:36 And the structure will be approximately the same size. So on the screen here we have lots 10 through 19. And overlaid is the duplex units showing where they're going to be. So this project was approved by the PEDC on February 10th. On February 24th, an appeal of the PEDC approval was filed by Mammoth Mountain Ski Area.

1:22:07 So the appeal raised three issues. One, the lot lines were incorrectly determined. Their appeal reads, MMSA contends that the property line which abuts Sierra Star Golf Course should be considered the rear yard since every home thus far developed at Talos and all remaining homes proposed to be developed are front entrances, driveways, and garages accessed by the interior roadway.

1:22:33 And thus the rear of each home faces the golf course property line. So the zoning code has clear definitions for what constitutes the front, rear, and side lot lines. For an interior lot, the front lot line is defined as the property line separating the parcel from the street. The rear lot line is defined as the property line most distant and most closely parallel to the front lot line. And the side lot lines are any lot line.

1:23:02 That is not a front lot line or a rear lot line. Based on these definitions, it was determined in 2004 and reaffirmed in 2016 that the lot line closest to Meridian Boulevard is the front lot line, the northernmost lot line is the rear lot line, and the lot lines adjacent to the golf course and the residential property to the east are the side lot lines. This is consistent with the zoning code definitions.

1:23:29 And how staff has consistently established lot lines for other PUD and condo projects throughout town since for PUD and condos, the single large parcel, i.e. the common area parcel, is what the lot lines are based off of. For PUDs and condos, the orientation of the building does not affect how the lot lines are determined since the buildings can be oriented multiple directions. The appeal raised issue two.

1:24:00 Furthermore, MMSA brought to the attention of both the applicant and staff that the proposed 10-foot setback to the golf course also encroaches upon the golf course flight line safety setbacks defined by golf course architect Cal Olson, which in some cases even exceed the 20-foot rear-road setback specified in the Lodestar Master Plan. The golf course flight lines are not recorded on the Talos property nor any other property along the golf course.

1:24:32 And are not included as requirements in the Lodestar Master Plan and therefore are only suggested setbacks but not actual requirements. The TALUS project does include overflight covenants in their CC&Rs which inform buyers that they are within a golf course development and there is a risk of golf balls entering into the project area. And appeal issue number three reads, the Lodestar Master Plan clearly states that side yard setbacks shall be half the building height,

1:25:04 But not less than 10 feet. MMSA notes that the plans submitted with use permit and TTM 15-002 indicate that all building heights are 35 feet. Therefore, lacking an amendment to the Lodestar Master Plan, the town would have no choice but to interpret that the home should maintain at least a 17-6 inch setback. In actuality, the Lodestar Master Plan section referenced by that statement reads,

1:25:33 It begins with single-family detached structures on individual lots except lots in Development Area 5 south of Westbury Lake Road and east of Sierra Star Parkway shall maintain the following setbacks, and then it lists that half of the building height requirement. Since this approval is not for single-family detached structures on individual lots, but rather to subdivide 10 existing PUD lots within the TALUS PUD,

1:26:02 Based on the analysis in the staff report, staff's recommendation to the town council is to determine that substantial evidence exists to support the PEDC's approval of the TALUS amendment project and to deny the appeal to affirm the PEDC's adoption of the addendum.

1:26:32 To the 2004 Mitigated Negative Declaration, and three, affirm the PEDC's approval of the TALUS Amendment Project, which consists of tentative track map 15002, use permit 15002, and design review 15002. With that, that concludes my presentation. I believe the appellant is here, as well as the applicant for the project. Okay. Any questions for staff?

1:27:01 Thank you for your time this evening to hear our appeal to this use permit approval. These ones are the colored one.

1:27:50 The colored one. There you go. And I can zoom in as well. Great. We'll go back to the full screen. There you go. Again, thank you for your time this evening to hear our appeal on this approval. I just would start by saying that I think there's a lot of ways that this can be interpreted, and I don't know that necessarily the way that the staff went through their process of

1:28:21 Defining what the setbacks were, we completely disagree with. So that's primarily why we're here. We have a disagreement. And we're trying to clarify for you to deny our position on this issue. And it really boils down to one basic concern, and that's public safety. And we feel that the way the staff's analyzed the

1:28:48 The use permit and the track map and the setbacks has actually, in fact, increased or jeopardized public safety, and that's been completely ignored in this process so far. I'm going to have Dave Schott, our golf course professional, provide some professional opinion to you guys with respect to the play of golf on this hole in particular and the fact that

1:29:15 This development actually is going to be much more susceptible to golf ball strikes because it falls within the drive, the initial drive on the whole where the existing homes further up the fairway are beyond the drive landing zone. So he'll clarify some of those concerns and explain to you what the potential ramifications are from the actual play of golf on the golf course with respect to these homes where they're located.

1:29:42 Real quick, I just want to let you know, we have participated in this process today. We attended the Planning Commission hearing in January, where there was first an amendment to Low Star Master Plan, as well as the use permit review on these. At the time, we made testimony that we had concerns about what was being asked on the setbacks and so forth. As a result of that testimony and during that course of that public hearing, the applicant chose to withdraw.

1:30:12 His application, and that was the end of it at that January hearing. So unbeknownst to us, the applicant came back in, I think, within that same week and reapplied for his application and got on the February agenda for the Planning Commission hearing in February, which we were not informed about. I didn't...

1:30:37 I thought that they had withdrawn and I thought I would be notified when they resubmitted so we'd have an opportunity to try to discuss this issue further and maybe avoid where we are today in front of you in an appeal hearing. I was informed. I'm not blaming anybody, but there was some criticism of us at the last Planning Commission hearing that, you know, we didn't...

1:30:57 Ask staff and address staffers in the process to not be making public comments again at the second planning commission hearing. The reason was is I didn't know that it had been resubmitted. I wasn't contacted back even though we had made specific...

1:31:13 I had specific disagreement with the application, and the content of the reapplication didn't change that situation at all, and staff continued to ignore our concerns, and we were never contacted about it until I saw the agenda came up on Friday before the Planning Commission hearing, and then we're like, ah, we didn't have a chance to talk about this, now we're back here having to make public comment again about our concerns about safety. So, in any event, that's what led us here today, unfortunately, and just real quick,

1:31:43 I wanted to provide our perspective on the setbacks. The Lodestar Master Plan is a very brief document. I don't know if you guys looked at it in your review for this hearing tonight. The setback standards in here don't, in fact, address all types of land uses or types of buildings. There's very specific language with respect to single family, and it says that a front yard setback is 25, a side yard...

1:32:08 As Nolan explained, it was half a billion height or no less than 10 feet and the rear yard is 20 feet. You know, our interpretation to look into this is that you look at the map here on the screen and you look at these homes, there's a street within the development. Now, Grant, they're saying it's a planned unit development. But in terms of the functionality of the site or the way that any layman would look at this property and say,

1:32:33 Okay, that street, the front of the houses are there, the driveways, there are garages, the front doors, and the rear of the house faces the golf course. So, you know, our interpretation is that's the rear yard and that it would be a 20-foot setback requirement. There was a comment that the applicant is originally these were single-family homes. He's proposing that he would do duplexes. However, in the...

1:33:01 In the use permit application or use permit staff report from February, there was specific language in here in the development proposal that stated that, I'm reading from that staff report from February, in the development proposal it said, depending on buyer interest, developers have requested to retain the right to merge two townhomes lots back into one lot. So, in essence, they're, and I, you know,

1:33:29 My understanding is they can do this, that they can say, well, the market's not good for duplexes, or we have an owner that wants to buy the whole house, the whole 5,000 foot and do one of our existing plans of similar to what's already been developed. And therefore, it would be a single family home. So, you know, in that respect, again, it's a single family home, I guess, is the way we're looking at it in the worst case scenario. Otherwise, you know, you can't make, you're making a decision based on it being a duplex.

1:33:58 And there's no language in here that, I mean, there's language that applies to single family. So my point is, they have the option to do single family, so why wouldn't you apply the single family requirements on it? You know, I think the other thing to take the position that this is a planned unit development and that, hey, we do this in other places in the town, is completely...

1:34:21 Has no applicability to this location because here you're next to a golf course. None of those other places in town are next to a golf course. We have a known safety concern with golf balls flying on the golf course. And we have, in my appeal letter, I provided a written statement from the golf course architect, Cal Olson, who stated that the flight line setbacks, which we represented on this map, which is the red line.

1:34:46 is what he recommends, and that was 20 years ago when the golf course was first developed, and today if he was going to recommend it, they'd be even larger because of the changing in equipment technology. So, and I understand that that's not a recorded easement on the property, but it is a known safety hazard concern.

1:35:10 And you can see the yellow line I've represented on this drawing shows a 20-foot setback, and then you can see where the buildings are proposed, and they're even further into the golf course. So what we're saying is, hey, respect the 20-foot setback, and if possible, if the developer would oblige, stay behind the flight line so that we eliminate the safety concern.

1:35:38 I'll try to summarize it real quick here. Tom, real quick question. So are you requesting the flight line or the 20 feet? I mean, what is... Well, I'm requesting that it be at least a 20-foot setback because, you know, we think a reasonable interpretation of the master plan would lead one to believe that it should be 20 feet, and the reason being is because it's next to a golf course and there's, you know, a concern with errant golf balls. So, again, I think staff...

1:36:07 They're going to go back to generic zoning code because there's not specific language that says a townhome setback in the master plan should be this. They're just saying, okay, we're going to go to the generic zoning code and apply those standards. But they're ignoring the fact that this is on a golf course where you've got a safety concern. So, again, this is about safety. And the fact of the matter is, if you look at the plan,

1:36:31 The road could be moved back. We're talking about moving the buildings back 10 feet. It can be accommodated on the site. And I've checked into the fact that the utilities, the applicant had made a statement that the utilities were on the ground. It would cost too much to move them. I actually conferred with the water district, and they said, yeah, we've accepted those facilities. And I said, hey, would you have required the utilities to be moved if we moved the road back 10 feet? They said, no. You could leave the utilities where they are. They don't have to be moved.

1:37:00 Roadbed back 10 feet to move the buildings back. And you can see there's room to make that work in most cases. So again, I think that the staff was very liberal in their interpretation of this, and they've completely ignored the fact that you're on a golf course where there's a danger of errant golf balls, and that we need to maintain as much of a setback as we possibly can. And so there's no reason to build it that close.

1:37:29 Thank you.

1:37:58 You know, come to a reasonable conclusion that safety does matter. You know, we're talking about people getting hit by golf balls here. So, you know, we want to do what we can to mitigate it and put a reasonable setback in place that could be reasonably interpreted from the master plan. Okay. Questions? Tom, I have one question as far as a mitigate. I mean, have you guys had conversation? I mean, plant more trees, put up netting. I mean, is there anything that could be done to? So, you know.

1:38:28 I mean, yes, you could put netting up, but that just diminishes the experience on the golf course. We're trying to avoid that by, again, just trying to respect the advisement from the golf course architect to try and stay behind these flight lines. And I think in most cases, if you look around the golf course,

1:38:50 That's been respected in all the developments. There may have been a few encroachments in the past, but for the most part, you know, InterWest worked with us to do that, and, you know, you have a much better experience out there as a result. Okay. Question for staff. On the existing homes, one through nine, what is the setback for adjacent property of the golf course?

1:39:16 So the setback there for the units further to the north is right at 10 feet, and then as you go to the south, the setback increases based on how the lot goes. Looking at these, I don't know if the mouse, yeah, so the units 9, 8, and 7 are right on that, and then as the bend goes, the setback grows. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? All right, no.

1:39:54 Hello, everybody. My name is Dave Schacht, and I am the PGA Head Professional at Sierra Star Golf Club, and I've just been asked to make a few comments about the danger or increased issue with safety. The 10th hole to which Talos is adjacent on the left side is a par 5. Sierra Star is a...

1:40:22 Fairly narrow golf course and probably not recommended that driver be used all the time, but it's pretty much used by 100% of the people every time they tee off on this hole. And as Tom indicated earlier, when Cal Olsen designed it, it's hard to believe it was 20 years ago, but technology has improved. The faces of the drivers have gotten thinner.

1:40:48 Club head speeds have increased due to no physical activity or exercise that you may endeavor in. And the balls are hotter. So basically what that means, if a driver has somewhere between 8 or 11 degrees aloft, it has very little backspin. And effectively, depending upon where the face is pointing at impact,

1:41:17 Scatters a little bit more. Like as you move further north and hit your approach shot, you know, the homes toward meridian probably wouldn't be in as great a jeopardy because you're hitting a wedge or a nine iron, eight iron, and that's going to impart more backspin on the golf ball. So it helps it fly straighter. So with everybody teeing off with the driver,

1:41:45 The increased technology, it is my professional humble opinion that if someone snipes one or pull hooks it, you know, the ball can be traveling as fast as 140 miles an hour. It's different if you're on the right side of a golf course or a home is on the right side because it kind of, I call it a popcorn fade and it doesn't carry the same velocity as a pull hook. So, and the mammoth green,

1:42:14 Is located on the left side of the third hole and in fact has had some issue with golf balls hitting and they did put up a net and that's something that I think a homeowner doesn't really like to look out their deck through a net so if that could be prevented that would be super and that's all I have. Any questions for me? Questions?

1:42:40 You weren't talking about me. Shields, you came up, but I didn't say anything. Okay, just one question. Who prepared the orange and yellow lines on the drawing? I believe that was Kyle Wilson. So the yellow line is a 20-foot parallel line to the property line. So this was prepared by my GIS technician, Chuck McGivern.

1:43:12 The red line, which represents the flight line setback that was provided to us by Cal Olsen, we were able to translate that information that he provided us, and there's detailed maps in my appeal letter to you guys that show those. Is that the original? Setbacks. Flight line, or is that the new? Yes, that's the original flight line from 20 years ago. Thank you. And is the tee box on that map? Yep. It's at the very, very, there's three of them. Yeah.

1:43:41 Yeah, I'm just wondering if given, I'm wondering if there shouldn't be a relationship between where the tee box is and the range of the hazard. I can't, I'm sort of puzzled that it would be a consistent, the red line represents a consistent ratio of hazard all the way out along the length of development. But it narrows from the tee shot, so it's closer to the tee, if you look closely at the map, and then it widens out to 150 feet from the center line.

1:44:11 Of the landing, the average landing zone center line of the fairway, and then it maintains 150 feet on down the fairway till the green. Okay, so this is truly drawn from the perspective, from a golf ball's perspective from the tee box. Right, right. Okay. So there's only four lots based on this that... Four lots. No, all of them are...

1:44:39 Encroaching on the 20 feet. Oh, you mean on the flight line. Flight line, yeah. I think there's the only home that might is the very, very furthest north home pad. Even that has a slight overlap, as shown on the plan. And then after that, it's just progressively worse as you go down the fairway. Right. So, I mean, the flight line issue versus the 20-foot setback. Right. Even if you go to the 20 feet, there's going to be three or four homes that still will be.

1:45:09 Within the flight line. But at least it's a huge improvement for the majority of the sites that are proposed. Thank you. Good evening. Ron Cohen, Chief Administrative Officer and General Counsel for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. I just wanted to address a couple of additional points on this. So when we first went to the Planning Commission, in advance of that, we submitted a letter.

1:45:31 Made a few points in there about the CEQA analysis and the lack of analysis on public safety. And the staff report really dealt with that in two ways. One, it said that it looked at what we'd said about looking to the town for liability when somebody gets hurt with one of these rifle shots coming off a driver. And the response on that was, well, we're statutorily immune, so don't worry about it.

1:46:01 Okay. That may be. That may be that you're statutorily immune from the liability for that incident. So, you know, I know the government makes rules to protect themselves, and that may very well be the case. The second issue is the issue of the CEQA analysis, and the response in the staff report was a statement and a cite to a case from Orange County, and it said, you don't have to consider

1:46:31 And that's an interesting thing to say. There's certainly some case law that talks about that. There's case law that says otherwise. That's an appellate court case from...

1:46:49 Orange County, the California Supreme Court, has a slightly different take on it. In a different case, they said, well, when a proposed project risks exacerbating environmental hazards or conditions that already exist, an agency must analyze the potential impact of such hazards on future residents or users. Ron, what's the site? That's California Building Industry Association versus Bay Area Quality Management District. The one from December? Yeah, from December, yeah.

1:47:19 And so, you know, look, that's a legal issue, right? We can argue about that in court. Which rule? CEQA is very complicated. There's lots of shades in there about what applies where. This issue of whether the project, whether it's the project's impact on the environment or the environment's impact on the project, kind of hard to tell where that lands. It's a good lawyer's argument, in fact, in that case.

1:47:47 The court said as early as 1983 there had been discussion of dismissing the, quote, artificial distinction between examining the effects of the project on the environment and the effects of the environment on the project. It's really hard to figure out which side of that coin you're on because you're just sort of shading.

1:48:09 And so, you know, that's a basis. You can find on that basis that this is analyzing the environment's impact on the project. You can probably base your decision on that. You could also base your decision on the other, that it's not, that it's exacerbating a situation, an existing situation. And in fact, what the Supreme Court said was, nor for that matter does CEQA prohibit

1:48:36 So I think, you know, your council gave you good advice. That's a case. It's a case that's not turned over. It says that you can base your decision on that. But that doesn't mean you have to base your decision on that. So that's your council's advice. And now you're in the position of deciding what's the right thing to do.

1:49:05 You have the right, as the court has said, to require that be analyzed. That was not analyzed. I think we can all agree that the issue of are these homes, where they're being built, going to be in that zone of that rifle shot? Is there a threat to public health and safety of the future users of that project? I think we can all agree that's something worth analyzing.

1:49:30 We just started doing it right here. We're looking at Cal Olsen's, the expert. He's the expert. He's saying, well, that's where the line is. And is it 20 feet? Is it the flight line setback? Which is it? Well, you know, we can debate it. We can take the expert's opinion. He's the golf course designer. He's saying, look, I said this line back then, and now we're 20 plus years later. The clubs are hotter. The balls are hotter. You know, so it's even worse than it was before. We can take his expert opinion and say,

1:50:00 Maybe we might want to consider that. And then we look at the law and we say, well, you could say we don't have to. And maybe that's right. Maybe this is exacerbating a condition. Maybe you do have to. Either way, it's very clear that you are certainly entitled to require that that be analyzed. And this is exactly the situation where you should. So you've got, you're in a position with a served up right for you, teed up for you.

1:50:29 Is a decision of, look, do I need to, can I just push this off, rely on my statutory immunity, and rely on the contention that the law says that I don't have to do this, I don't have to analyze this. You could go down that road, or you could go down the road of, yeah, but I'm allowed to require that it be analyzed. I want to see what that analysis looks like, that I'm not putting in people in harm's way, and that I'm not doing it.

1:50:58 On the basis of it's okay if somebody gets hurt from me, the town's perspective, from my perspective, because I'm immune. So that's what's on your plate. And, you know, we respectfully request that you do the right thing and take a look at it and make sure you're not exacerbating an existing environmental condition and putting people directly in harm's way. And that we think the public health and safety analysis would bear that out. Thanks, Ron.

1:51:27 Questions? A couple questions, yeah. I have a question for the Mountain. Seeing as there have been several statements recently about not operating the golf course, why is this an issue? Yeah, so, I mean, it's a great question. I can see Ted back there exasperated on the issue of why are we fighting this when we're going to close a golf course? You know, look, we're absolutely looking at what's the right use for the golf course. We've talked about that openly with...

1:51:52 Many members of town government. We've talked about it with town council members. We've talked about it widely. We're looking at it. And, you know, you've got 120 acres in the center of town. It's being used for a relatively narrow group of people. And the purpose of it was to generate hotel buildings. And those hotels haven't gone up yet. And instead, piece by piece, we're chipping away.

1:52:17 At the golf course and at the viability of the golf course and the viability of the potential of putting hotels on those sites. So piece by piece we're doing that. And so we're looking at that absolutely. Have we made a final decision? No, absolutely not. And so we're looking at you. Here's another opportunity. Do we want a golf course? Do we want it to be set up to operate correctly? Do we want it to be set up in a way that's sustainable?

1:52:46 Here's another opportunity for you to give a signal. Does it matter? Or should we just keep crowding it in, chipping away at the viability of the golf course, chipping away at the viability of putting hotels on the sites where they're supposed to be? So that's why it matters. It's still absolutely on the table. I've got a couple questions. Sure. Go ahead. Ron, does the Mountain have any concern of liability in this question at all or no?

1:53:16 Well, as a golf course operator, of course we do. And, you know, like any other sports, there's inherent risks. But that's all, you know, as a lawyer, I kind of make a joke, you know, to people. Once you hire a lawyer, you've already lost.

1:53:34 You know, it's easy to rely on your immunities and to rely on inherent risk law and those sorts of things, but it costs you sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars to get to the point where you win, even though it's an obvious risk. I understand, but is the mountain representing that your level of liability is tied to whatever decision we make?

1:53:59 Is our level of liability tied to the decision? No, the level of risk is tied to your decision. The level of peril to the people in those homes is tied to your decision. Does that change our liability? I don't know. I'm trying to really understand what the motivation is. The motivation is exactly what I just said, which is you're taking people and putting them right directly in the hook zone of that rifle shot. So the mountain's interest in this is just a general concern for public safety. The mountain has no specific...

1:54:28 Concern about its liability in this question. This is a representation of public safety. General concern, yes. General concern of public safety. Okay. So the second question is, if the applicant wasn't applying for change of use, my understanding is that the applicant could build what they're entitled to build right now. Would the Mountain be here saying we should be denying them their ability to build what they wanted to build because of a public safety concern? We wouldn't have that opportunity. Okay. So you're taking advantage of this opportunity to point out to the community of public. That's right.

1:54:57 Public safety issue that you feel is important. That's right. Okay. Again, I just, you know, I made testimony in the prior planning commission hearings that unfortunately this project was overlooked when it went through the approval and we missed it. And so this obviously came back to the consideration through an application. We had a chance to correct the mistake and we're asking for it to be corrected. So, you know, our point is just because, you know,

1:55:25 There was an approval in 04. It was wrong, in our opinion, at that time. So, you know, two wrongs don't make a right is the bottom line. Okay. Question? Yeah. So, based on the safety issue, your concern, then, is not the yellow line so much as it is the... The red line. The red line. No. The red line is... The red line is the safety. I'm sorry. Yeah, the red line is the original...

1:55:55 Yeah, but that's a safety issue originally. That's right. Okay. And, you know, the 20-foot setback line was drawn. It's through most of the area. It's pretty close. What we're talking about is inside both of those. Yeah, okay. And just for clarification, lot 17, 18, how far down the fairway is that? I can't read which ones are which. Dave might know.

1:56:29 It's kind of where the red line starts to go to the east of the yellow line. Oh, is that in the landing? I think that's in the landing zone of the tee shot. You know, depending on how good of a golfer you are, Shields. I think that's... I can't hit it that far. I think Ted can. No, he can't. I think where the fairway widens out about there is where an average golfer's ball lands.

1:57:00 Let's put it that way. Yeah, because I look at the flight, the red line, and just, to me, that doesn't make sense, going farther down that way. Well, you know, I mean, a couple things, too. I mean, I watch golf. I actually like golf. And, you know, you look at the statistics, even on a professional golfer in the PGA, the best golfers in the world. Sure, they have errant shots. It only hit the fairway, you know, 70% of the time.

1:57:28 This is something that happens. Don't kid yourselves. I mean, it happens. I just played a few weeks ago down south and hit a crazy tee shot that went and hit a roof on a home next to the golf course. I'm just trying to make sure that I understand what you're saying. One other thing I just wanted to point out, in the Low Star Master Plan, there is a Exhibit A, Existing Site Conditions, that does identify

1:57:57 Golf setbacks in a red dashed line. So, you know, again, I don't know how you interpret that. It's not in the text of the master plan, but it isn't in an exhibit, and it does identify that it overlaps the development parcels, and it says golf setbacks. So, one could be led to believe that that would apply, even if it's not recorded, it's in the master plan. So, I think that gives credence to the fact that

1:58:27 There is a legitimate concern here. Let me answer your question directly. What you're asking about, this lot versus this lot, where the line goes through it here, where it doesn't go through it there, how far down the fairway is it? That's exactly the analysis that's missing in the staff report on the public health and safety element that's the required element of CEQA. That's exactly the type of analysis. What that ultimately results in as far as

1:58:54 What is approved is exactly what should have been analyzed, and it isn't. So you're asking those questions, you're right there. Thanks, Ron. Is the applicant here? Is that to come forward? That'll be after. Yeah, after they're done. Mr. Mayor, Council, my name's Eric Fishburne. I represent Mammoth Springs Resorts, which is the current owner of the project. I was the original developer as well, as well as designer, and I processed the original use permit and all the plants and everything associated with this.

1:59:37 Very well familiar with the process we went through at the outset of this project. Quick, Eric, are you referencing the exhibit from the 2004? Yes. Okay. The one that had the notes and the map. When we were processing this, we worked closely with staff. Karen Johnston was assigned to the project at the time. And I was also told to talk to Cal Olson.

2:00:02 The landscape architect of the golf course, as well as the manager whose name I can't remember at the time. The gentleman was very concerned. And in the process, we negotiated putting some hold harmless language in our documents. There's almost a full page of legal acknowledgement in our CCNRs, as well as the public report, as well as when guests and people sign up or own buy-in, they sign.

2:00:28 In acknowledgement and agreement that this is a hazardous thing, there could be issues. As a practical matter, there has never been, I've been in continuous contact with managers throughout the last 10 years, there's never been an incident. Nobody's been hit by a ball, we've never lost a window or anything doing this. But in 2004, when I talked to Cal Olsen and I worked with staff and the golf course,

2:00:55 We had, and Nolan found in the original report a map that was that determined the actual location of all the houses. And it's a setback that was determined at that time. And we meant it exactly. And if you look at this map in the line, the houses are, as they're set up now, are exactly right on that line and they conform to it exactly. So...

2:01:18 Earlier in an earlier planning meeting, Tom tried to characterize that maybe that wasn't an honest map because it was generated from my office, but then he just produced a map that he generated as well. This map was vetted, like all our building plans, our engineering, everything else, by staff. It was talked about with the golf course superintendent at the time, and it was incorporated into our plans. So now they're coming back and asking to change something that was approved.

2:01:44 And essentially what they're saying is golf has changed. The golf balls fly farther. The clubs are stronger. They shoot rifle shots. This is something that has evolved on the golf course side, not on our side. We haven't changed anything. We want to build buildings exactly where they were approved to be built. The only difference we're asking for is essentially to put a wall down the middle and put two front doors on it. Other than that, we're asking for the same thing.

2:02:14 So we already have that by right. And it was by the original setbacks. Correct. So if golf has changed, isn't it incumbent upon the golf operator to adjust their issues? This is their issue. And it would also apply throughout the perimeter of the golf course, not just in this one place. So it seems peculiar that this is one issue that they're picking on us for. So as far as the PUD,

2:02:46 It is what it is. We can't change it. We process this math through the state and through the local planning, and this is how it was interpreted, and it's in the code. To change it now is not possible. If you change it, you're going to make our previously built buildings be non-conforming. That's not fair. As far as moving everything back towards the end of the last

2:03:14 Three or four lots, it gets very narrow there. If we had to push everything back, we would lose almost all the trees back there, and it would be almost all paving between the bike path, the road, the driveway, and the house. It would obliterate the whole thing in the back, and we might lose a couple sites. And if we move the road, it will. We've looked at it, and even though he characterized that the water department doesn't think so, we've looked at the maps as built.

2:03:43 If we move the road, we have to move all our utilities. And that's about a million-dollar hardship for us to have to do that at this point. And another practical matter, if these golf balls go 150 miles an hour, what does 10 feet do for you? I mean, how much does the golf ball slow down by moving 10 feet over? So is it really this hazard that they talk about if there's never been an incident? We have a lot of trees all along there.

2:04:13 Particularly towards the end, there's 30, 40, 50 feet deep of trees, so the balls don't come through. We find them on the edge, but not hitting the houses, not coming back into the property. So it's an immaterial change we're asking for. We just want to be able to take these 10 units previously approved, turn them into 20 exactly as they were originally designed. Eric, I've got a quick question for you. The language to the option to go from the...

2:04:43 You know, the duplex back to single houses. What's your comment on that? We're already approved for the single houses. Right. So we just want to leave some market flexibility in there. The single family houses, we don't generate any TOT on, correct? No, they do. They do. The whole project is zoned resort. Okay. And actually doing very well this year. Okay. I just wasn't sure if there was a difference on the duplex side. And these will not be fractional ownership.

2:05:13 Right. I think that was my question. We're marketing such that they're much more affordable and that they will be used for TOT generation. We have spent a lot of money, millions of dollars here in the last year, finishing a couple things there, doing a lot of improvements, rebranding, remarketing, and setting up a rental program. We have a whole platform.

2:05:38 On the Internet, we've rebranded it, and we're generating a lot of rental interest when our owners aren't there, and that's kind of the hallmark of what our Phase 2 will be, is to sell them whole ownership and then have this platform on site where we can manage and rent out for the owners all these units. Okay. Any other questions? A couple of just quick questions. You mentioned trees. The trees are on your side of the property line?

2:06:09 They're on our side, but also on the golf course. Golf course fairway is pulled back from the property line a bit down there, so this tree is probably 20, 30 feet. Okay. And I'm certainly not a lawyer, and I'm not going to pretend to be one, but a question I have, if the town were to, you know, change something like this, say that for some reason we're going to, entitled project, we're going to move something after the fact.

2:06:38 What does that look like? I mean, is that something that we can do? Is that something that, I mean, what are the consequences of doing something like that? Well, the consequences in terms of liability or the process by which you would do it? Both, I guess. Okay. Let's address the liability first. As Ron noted, the town's immune, and I pointed that out, and I'm glad that the mountain acknowledges it. The town has two separate statutory immunities, so if we got sued, I mean, the case would be thrown out.

2:07:08 I mean, almost at the outset, you have an immunity for legislative enactments, which some of this would be. You have an immunity for granting any permit, which the use permit would be. Between the two of them, the town is protected, liability-wise. In terms of how you would go about changing the setback requirements, I'm not sure you can do that with respect to this application. What you can do is you can uphold the appeal and deny the application.

2:07:33 So I'm assuming that the setbacks and the placements of the buildings

2:08:01 Has legal standing at this point, and we would be under an enormous burden to provide a rationale why we would want to change that. That's correct. Okay. A couple questions. First for Eric, there were some comments made about some of the other properties on the golf course, not on this specific hole, and screens that were put up and those type of things as a protection measure. Have you guys...

2:08:26 Have you looked or explored any of those options as far as do you have any thoughts, things that maybe are more aesthetically pleasing but will provide the same safety and protections that you may implement with the new homes coming in or existing for that matter? I think aesthetically it would be pretty unattractive if you're there. It's like going behind the screen at a baseball game. You're looking through. It's a different feeling. People are there to enjoy nature and to not.

2:08:54 See that screen there. As a practical matter, it's immaterial. We haven't had any hits. We've got trees in the way. It really has not been an issue. And, you know, the mountain in Interwest, when they built and then controlled the golf course and they had all the properties around it, they had their opportunity for years to put these easements in, and they chose not to.

2:09:21 Probably because they wanted to sell the land and not lower its value by encumbering it with any sort of an overlay. So now they're willing to impose it on land when somebody else owns it, but they didn't do it when they had it themselves and had that opportunity to do so. So let me rephrase my question to somebody that doesn't know very much about this particular realm. We've talked about trees as protection. We've talked about a screen shade as protection. Are there any other potential remedies out there that I'm just not aware of that you guys...

2:09:51 Have come up with, thought about, or is that just something that doesn't really exist? Other than a screen, I can't really imagine something that would work and how that would be suspended in the trees. It would be tangled in a lot of branches and everything. I'm not sure. We wouldn't want to hang it on the house. It would be pretty untaxed. Okay. Could be more trees, right? Yeah. I didn't know if there's anything else.

2:10:19 Anybody that's golfed with me knows it's not my strong suit. And then, you know, for staff, we've talked a lot about a specific project here tonight. That's what's in our purview tonight. Regarding other holes on the golf course, I mean, what are we mostly looking at? Similar 10-foot setback, 20-foot setback? I mean, do 10-foot setbacks exist on other portions of the golf course?

2:10:47 Within other projects that have been approved in the past, they've acknowledged the setback was no less than 10 feet. So one was the bungalows project. It was approved prior for where the Gray Bear 2 project was. It wasn't built. But again, their reference was the setback from the golf course is no less than 10 feet. Another one was Solstice 2.

2:11:13 Again, it wasn't built, but the setback from the golf course on the side closest to Minaret was approximately 11 1⁄2 feet. Okay. And those were both entitled and approved. Okay. Thanks. Any other questions? Thank you. Go to the public for public comment, please. Come on up, Ted. Ted Carlton. One thing that was brought up by Mr. Hodges was

2:11:47 He said that there was a chipping away of the viability of the golf course. Outside of this particular issue of 10 feet, can he explain other places where it's been chipped away at? Tom? So, you know, I think our statement on that, actually, I think Ron made the statement, but I can elaborate, is, you know, the zoning that's in place, if you look at the Low Star Master Plan, the contemplation of what gets developed at the...

2:12:25 Hotel site around Bear Lake and the clubhouse. I'll describe it to you. It's 500 hotel rooms. There's another 108 dwelling units. There's 80,000 square feet of commercial that's contemplated in the master plan. Just to give you an idea of scale, that's about equivalent to the village that exists today on the west side of Minaret Road. So what was contemplated in the master plan

2:12:54 Was to be another village that was a resort within a resort, a golf resort within the resort of Mammoth Lakes. And as a result of the recession, the land going back to the lender, the lender then selling the land at pretty low prices in the recovery market, being picked off by John Hooper and, you know, single family developers who are looking for the cheapest product they can put in that they can make money on.

2:13:22 You're effectively undermining the overall densities on the whole master plan and the viability of the hotel site. So that's our issue with Lodestar. But isn't that fair? I mean, these are market forces that are well beyond the control of...

2:13:43 This council will have any effect. Are these just the realities of the market? We can't control these things. It is. I mean, it's unfortunate. In fact, you know, and I think that's, you know, nobody anticipated that the market was going to shrink, right, and that people were going to be asking for the lowest density they can get on a site. Before, you're always fighting trying to get the highest density, and it was, you know, dealing with that. But, you know, it's having the reverse effect, and the cumulative effect economically on the community is you've lost beds. You've lost...

2:14:12 Hotbeds. You've lost transient occupancy tax generating revenue as a result of each of these pieces getting bought and underdeveloped. There's going to be over 100 units left on the table on the densities on the east side of Sierra Star. There's already over 100 units that InterWest didn't develop on stuff that they did build that was underzoned or underdeveloped. And there's already been people looking at the remaining properties that are the hotel site and looking just to put duplexes in there.

2:14:41 Like I said, you know, from our perspective, it's just completely blown out the master plan, even though you can make, you can say it complies with the master plan because it's multifamily housing. A duplex is multifamily, but that would be, you know, 10 units versus, you know, 100 hotel rooms or, you know, just 500 hotel rooms entitled on that property. So that's the concern. But not on this site. You're not right. I mean, at the Bear Lakes. You're talking about the Bear Lakes site, yeah.

2:15:10 Yeah, I mean, I think. So, again. I certainly understand where you're coming from in respect to how things have changed from the overall perspective, but that doesn't seem to be germane to this particular project because we're actually talking about an increase in units rather than a decrease. That's correct. This would go, you know, an additional nine or ten homes doubles. I'm going to just address in Ted's question so you can elaborate on in the chamber about it. Okay. All right. You know, I'm just trying to, you know, and again, I think to reiterate Ron's point to us is like, hey, you know, it.

2:15:39 You can sit here and say it's town. We have no liability under the regulations. But you know what it does? It does throw more liability in our laps. And we have nothing we can do about it. And so, again, as a golf course operator, it's just like, yeah, just squeeze the experience down, make it tighter, make it a worse experience, make more liability for the operator, take away all the densities. Why are we running a golf course?

2:16:07 That's kind of – I mean, I think that Mr. Fishburne's statement about, you know, as sports and activities change, the people who are profiting from those types of activities, if they're going to continue to be in that business, they're going to have to dress and deal with the liabilities that come with it. I think that's a reasonable statement. So, anyway, thank you. Yeah, yeah. Just as long as I'm here real quick. As far as the maps go, again, I think there's, you know, there's maps that –

2:16:36 That the one that's on the screen currently that Eric's represented from 2004 doesn't match the flight lines that I have from Cal Olsen. That's all I'm saying. So, again, there's just a difference of opinion. I offered it. I said, hey, why can't we get Triad to take, you know, be an impartial, you know, professional civil engineer, take these lines, lay them on the map once and for all so there's no disagreement about where they exist and understand what the implications are. So, again, to Ron's point that, you know, you guys could certainly say, hey, you guys.

2:17:05 Underperformed under CEQA, didn't analyze the effects of public safety. If we were to do that, we could maybe answer a lot of these questions that are coming up. So, Tom, you don't think that you guys can get in a room at a table and hash this out and try to come up with something that works for both? I offered to the applicant to do that before this meeting. And they said, well, we're not going to be up there, can't do it, blah, blah, blah. So I just figured, you know, they're probably going to be easier just to...

2:17:33 Take it to the finish line here and see what happens, I guess. I've been at golf courses where they've actually put a hedgerow there. For you? Specifically for me. But on the golf course side you're talking about? On the golf course side, absolutely. Yeah, I mean, you know, the angle. So, you know, I concur it would be, I think, smart if you guys would. There's no question that trees and vegetation will help.

2:18:03 But, you know, the only point I would make to you guys on a tee shot, and I'm sure Dave could weigh in, but, you know, on a hook tee shot, it's not going straight, it's hooking. So by the time it's going into those homes, it's coming in straight into them. It's not coming in on an angle. So the obstruction of the trees, you know, trees lined up like this doesn't do you as much good because it's only the one tree, and that thing's coming in like this straight into the home. So, you know, again, that's just the reality of the way the game's played or, you know, the way the ball flies.

2:18:32 Anybody who's hit a hook wouldn't know that, right? Thanks, Tom. Thanks. Go ahead. Come on up. Good evening. My name's Colin Miller. I'm the property owner, so if this isn't an appropriate time to make comment, please let me know. Councilman, to address your first question, we, in several phone conversations with Mr. Hodges, Eric Fishburne, told him that he was welcome to go visit the site at any point with our engineers.

2:19:06 And that myself and Mr. Fishburne would be available to discuss with him on a conference call. I'm not available to come up here. My personal schedule doesn't allow me to come up here whenever I can. So we thought that that was a reasonable solution to their request to meet. And that's still available to do that? Absolutely. We're always open to talk and try to come up with something. The problem we have is...

2:19:32 The conversation continues to be on what can we do. And to Eric's earlier point, I'd like to know why the Mountain, the golf course, can't either shorten the distance of the hole or move the tee box over 10 feet. That would be my question to Mountain. Okay. Any response, Tom? He had a question for him, so I'll let him answer it.

2:20:04 We're the highest golf course in California and at 8,000 feet the ball already flies 20 to 30 percent further so if you shorten the hole it would bring the par from 70 and it was originally designed to be 72 down to 69 and that's there's a strange people sort of avoid courses that aren't 70 or higher for whatever reason and there is absolutely no room

2:20:35 To move the tee box further to the right on the property. So that would be... What's that? No, there's our tip shot, our halfway house is located right there. So... Okay, thanks. Anyone else for public comment? Good evening again, Martin Kleinbard. I'm a bit confused here because...

2:21:18 You know, we've got all these things being discussed recently about public safety. We had developments in the past where, through California law, they were given concessions to reduce setbacks. So, for housing projects. Housing projects received reduced setbacks and then snow shed off roofs on the neighboring properties. We created a nuisance.

2:21:46 For the property owners that were next door. We've got an issue here where it seems to be the public safety issue is the key component here over the flight line of the golf ball. And, I mean, yes, there may have been a mistake, but, I mean, do we continue to just pile on one mistake after the other and just make some, you know, kick the can down the road to make somebody else responsible for it? Or when do we...

2:22:14 Own up to the mistakes and just do our best to mitigate them. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Anybody else? Hello, I'm Mickey Brown. I'm chair of the Planning and Economic Development Commission, and I chaired two meetings where we heard this issue. And I think it's really important for council to understand, because this meeting went over a two-month period, we probably spent five to six weeks studying the issues.

2:22:48 And while there's been some incredibly interesting conversations tonight, you know, the role of planning commission is very narrow and very focused. And basically, this is what is being heard here is an amendment to a 2004 tentative track plan.

2:23:08 There's nothing that's changed in the footprints of those buildings, and that was very important to us. The original footprints are still the footprints today, so I just want you to know that was one very important finding to us. There was no changes. The other thing that was important to the commission was that if there was concern, this was a 2004...

2:23:32 Tentative track map that's being amended, and we felt that if it was really a concern of safety, that easements could have been recorded prior to the hearing this year. So those were a couple of our concerns, how we made our decision, and I'm happy to answer any questions that Council may have. Okay. Any questions for me? Have you heard anything this evening that you didn't hear at your hearings, your testimony? From the applicants and from the mountain?

2:24:02 Well, I mean, there was a couple. So, just so that you know, I mean, in their appeal, their item number three was never discussed at our planning and economic commission meetings. Okay. Okay. Anybody else? Okay, I'll bring you back to council for dialogue. I just, I mean, I'll just throw out the mediator hat and, I mean, it seems to me we, both you guys are willing to.

2:24:33 You know, investigate and discuss this further. I mean, I don't know if you guys want to do that or not, but it seems to me that you both are willing to do that.

2:24:44 I'm going to disagree with you, Michael, in that I don't think it is an issue between the two of them. We have one person who has an entitled project that we're not changing to any significant degree, and then we have someone else who has an issue of items leaving their property and going to somebody else's. So I don't know that they have to talk about it any further.

2:25:09 What staff is recommending is that we apply similar standards that are included on all the other projects in and around the golf courses and throughout town. I don't think we're ignoring a safety issue. I think we're looking at the fact that people who buy new golf course know that.

2:25:27 I mean, I grew up in a neighborhood where there were resident feral peacocks and people moved in and they go, what the heck are these birds? You know, you have to know what you're getting into as the buyer. I also see that what we've got here is an opportunity for hotbeds on what is admittedly not going to work as the fractional 19 buildings that they originally expected and I think the flexibility to either build the

2:25:54 Two at 2,500 or one at 5,000 is something that should also be allowed, and I would support the Planning Commission's activities and their decision. Thanks, Joe. I have one question for staff, and then I can follow up on what Joe said. Mr. Cohen's point about the analysis and CEQA of the public safety, I wonder if you could address that. Yeah.

2:26:17 With all due respect to Ron, who is very eloquent and stated his position very, very well, the CEQA issue is a red herring, in my opinion. He did cite the right case. The California Supreme Court looked at this issue three months ago in a case that came out in December, looking at the issue of what's called reverse CEQA, whether you have to look in your environmental documents at the impact of the environment on the project.

2:26:39 The Supreme Court said generally no, you don't. They did say that in narrow circumstances where there might be an exacerbation of existing environmental hazards that you do, but the example they gave was what if there's a plume of contaminated groundwater next to a project and then the project is going to physically disturb it, therefore making it worse, that's a situation in which you would have to look at the effects of the environment on the project. To me, it's not clear at all that

2:27:06 Errant golf balls are an environmental hazard in the first place. But even if you do accept them as an environmental hazard, I don't think that this is the kind of situation that the Supreme Court had in mind when they said you have to look at, in those unusual circumstances, you might have to look at the effects of the environment on the project. I simply don't think that's the case under the analysis that the Court gave us three months ago. So to me, the environmental document is adequate. I don't think that it was required to...

2:27:33 To address the possibility of errant golf balls. Does the environmental document, has it been certified? Does it need to come, I'm not sure exactly what level that is at. Where does that stand right now? Where does that stand? Does that have to be certified by anybody, by us or anything? Or is it just, it was just an analysis? Help me understand where that stands right now. Sure, and 2004 is a mitigated negative declaration that was prepared for the project. That was certified in 2004 by the Planning Commission.

2:28:01 The notice of determination was filed. On this project, we did an addendum to it, which looks at addendums appropriate when there are totally no changes to the project that would require additional analysis under CEQA. So that addendum was approved or adopted by the Planning Commission and a notice of determination was filed. And then again with here, one of the recommendations is to affirm that

2:28:31 Although I'll point out that we're only making that recommendation out of an abundance of caution because the applicant did not actually appeal the approval of the addendum. Right. Okay. So we're talking about the 2004 environmental document. Yeah. Okay. So my feelings, I very much appreciate the testimony of all the parties. I think it was very illuminating for me to help you kind of understand what's going on with this. I think that in this case, I think that

2:28:57 The standing of the approved track map, the approved project is what matters. I think that the applicant's not asking for any variance beyond the footprints as originally, you know, imagined and approved. I think that, you know, I think if the argument's being made that the sport has changed and therefore things have to change, I think it's probably the burden is on the person who's operating that

2:29:24 The other thing is in the email that Cal Olson wrote to Tom Hodges, he states, golf has changed a lot over the almost 20 years since that was depicted. Quote, there's no written standard for setbacks as the industry changes.

2:29:49 So I'm not sure that going down the road of trying to figure, you know, trying to really establish what is a, you know, what is the flight line, all that kind of stuff, is really going to have any bearing on this. And I think that even if it were to be established, I think you'd be looking at the entire project having moved to a different neighborhood, and that starts getting in the realm of being unreasonable. So I'm inclined to support the Planning and Economic Development Commission's recommendation and to deny this appeal. Thanks. Colin, any comments? No further comments.

2:30:19 Shields? My only comment is that when I mentioned about the TOT and Joe mentioned about increased density, I mean, we're talking about, you know, this specific, not the other piece where all the hotel is, but, you know, to me, potential hotel, yeah, sorry. To me, I think safety is a big concern, but I also think that TOT is a big concern, and I think the increase in this area

2:30:46 You know, if it could be worked out, I think it's a win, you know, for us. So, I mean, I'll entertain a motion if one is prepared to make one. Okay, I'll make a motion, and I'm going to read all this text as it is here in my packet.

2:31:06 Determine that substantial evidence exists to support the Planning and Economic Development Commission's approval of the TALUS Amendment Project tentative track map 15-002, use permit 15-002, design review 15-002, and to deny the appeal.

2:31:21 Affirm the Planning and Economic Development Commission's adoption of the addendum to the 2004 Mitigated Negative Declaration, State Clearinghouse No. 2004042055, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act CEQA guidelines, and affirm the Planning and Economic Development Commission's approval of the TALIS Amendment Project, tentative track map 15-02, use permit 15-002, and design review 15-002.

2:31:49 Okay. I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember? Yes. Councilmember? Yes. Councilmember? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We're going to take a five-minute break. Thank you. Mayor Pro Temp is going to join us. Okay. We're going to move on to item 14, public hearings. Waive the reading introduced by title only.

2:33:15 The ordinance making the required findings and approved in District Zoning Amendment 15-001, Lodestar Mammoth Master Plan, Amendment for TALUS. I'm going to open up the public hearing. Take staff testimony, please. All right. Thank you. District Zoning 15001 proposed minor changes to the Lodestar Master Plan. Once again, this is specific to the TALUS project, which is adjacent to Meridian Boulevard.

2:33:41 DZA 15001 proposes to reduce the perimeter setbacks for accessory structures for properties located within Development Area 2 adjacent to Meridian Boulevard, i.e. Talus, and delete unnecessary text in the master plan. The proposed changes to the setbacks for accessory structures

2:34:02 We'll change the 50 and 20 foot perimeter setbacks to 10 feet for areas adjacent to residential, resort, or commercial zoned properties and the 100 foot arterial street setback to 50 feet from arterial streets.

2:34:15 These changes are consistent with the residential standards for accessory structures in other residential areas, with the exception of the arterial street standard setback, which in this case is larger than what is required for residential areas. The proposed amendments are similar to what was adopted earlier for accessory structures in the Gray Barrett II area of the Lodestar Master Plan. The accessory structures within TALIS that will benefit from this reduction are the existing clubhouse,

2:34:45 The existing gatehouse sales office and the proposed maintenance garage. The existing sales office is proposed to be converted into an on-site managers unit. This use would still be considered an accessory structure. In addition to the language for accessory structures, there is language specific to on-site managers units. I do have it on the screen here. I don't expect you to read it.

2:35:14 Hopefully you've already read it in your packet. These requirements are similar to what would be required for secondary dwelling units, and they limit the size, ownership of the unit. It requires that it has to be owned by the HOA or the property, cannot be sold separately, cannot be separated out through a parcel map, and then it has a few other requirements for size and parking.

2:35:43 So here on the screen we do have photos of the existing sales office that will be converted. They are proposing and required by their conditions of approval for the tentative map to remove this front paved parking area. This is between Meridian and the structure. Revegetate that area. And the enclosed parking unit will be on the rear of the structure within the talus property on the inside of the gate.

2:36:13 So with that, that concludes my presentation on that. Our recommendation is once again to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance making the required findings. Thank you. Is there any statement from the property owner? None? Okay. Questions from council? Questions from the public? Okay, seeing none, I'll close public hearing, bring it back to council for further dialogue and motion.

2:36:51 I'll make a motion that we waive the first reading, introduced by title only. An ordinance making the required findings in a proven district zone amendment 15-001 is recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Second. Okay, motion is second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. We're going to move on to policy matters. Item 15, 2016 paving project Old Mammoth Road.

2:37:23 Grady, are you still here? Okay. Thank you, Grady Dutton. We sent a note out in early February about some conditions we found on Old Mammoth Road, really on the whole stretch from Main Street all the way to Sherwin Creek Road where that takes off. And in that notice, I...

2:37:59 Gave some background about a paving project that was done by the town in 2003 and 2004 and certain issues with the asphalt and the way it was constructed at that time. The bottom line, though, is regardless of what happened over 13 years ago, we set about doing all our due diligence to find out how to fix the problem as best we could.

2:38:19 We hired a separate consultant for that. He went through three or four iterations on his report because we continued to ask him question after question about what the right fix was. We did ten borings out on the street to make sure that we knew all we could about the paving itself, the various layers, the base material and everything else. And when it came down to it, we found that...

2:38:43 The right solution, if you will, the best solution we thought for the town would be to grind down the top two and a half inches of that and then replace it with a new two and a half inch cap. The consultant's recommendation actually at one time, and I'm not going to overly criticize him because we kept asking him questions, okay, was to do just that.

2:39:04 And towards the end, he kind of wavered a little bit and said, well, maybe you should go ahead and take out the whole pavement section. Either one of those is actually fine with us. Either one of those will work. But in the analysis that's included in your packet, what we looked at was really the cost benefit of that. We could come in and just put another overlay on. We could grind it down very slightly. We could take out the whole pavement section. We found that taking off the top two and a half inches and replacing that cap, it allows us to do some other things with the road in terms of repair.

2:39:34 Crossfall, that type of thing. And it's just more cost effective because we think of the estimate for that's about $650,000. The estimate to replace the entire pavement section was well over a million dollars, and we think it'll only buy us another three or four years. In other words...

2:39:49 650, we get 15 to 20 years out of the pavement. For an incremental cost, we only gain, you know, a very small amount. So it's our recommendation from staff, and after discussing it with our consultant, to do just that, to take off that top two and a half inches. The reason we didn't have it before you last time is because, again, we wanted to continue that due diligence. We actually sat in a room with not just the engineers.

2:40:14 Just the engineers, but also our inspector who's done a lot of road work. We sat down with our road crews with Todd and Pat and everybody and said, okay, guys, let's troubleshoot this. We actually did blow-ups of the entire Old Mammoth Road from Main Street all the way to Sherman to look at access issues, all those types of things. This is still our recommendation. If the council asks us to do so, we'll complete our plans and specifications. We want to advertise it next Friday if we can do that on the 25th.

2:40:44 At that point in time, we would actually leave it somewhat to the contractor in terms of means and methods in terms of the schedule. The reason we say that is that our initial reaction is let's do the section from Meridian.

2:40:58 To the south, towards Sherwin Creek Road, early in the season, which means May or very early in June, so we're done before July 4th, we're done before the initial events happen. However, depending on, and the rest of it then from Meridian to the north, would be done later in the season, you know, separated between the two shoulder seasons. If, however, we have a contractor who bids the project, you know, maybe it's one of the larger ones in the state, and they commend, they could...

2:41:23 Very easily knock the whole thing out in three or four weeks. I mean, that's entirely possible. With the right equipment, the right manpower, that could happen. So we didn't want to preclude that. But we'll make them prove it to us that they can do that because we're very protective now that we've built our summer season into what it is last summer especially. We're very protective of that and we'll make sure that that doesn't happen. So with that, we're really just asking for your direction to continue the process we've started to put this package together, get it out on the street, and we'll be back to you.

2:41:53 This is the middle of March. We'll be back to you sometime in April, the first meeting in May for an award. So let me ask, so Hayes is here and ask if you have anything to add or did I get all the pieces? You get all the big major points. That's a good answer. Quick question, Grady. I mean, once you guys get into this, I mean, it could be far worse than you anticipate and the cost could, you know, climb considerably or? In fact, one of the things we talked about with our consultant was

2:42:21 We don't really know what that base material or what the last two and a half, three inches of paving looked like until we take the top off. And those conditions could change if we were to allow a lot of traffic on it. We don't expect and don't intend to do that. However, that's why we went back out. Initially, we'd done three corings.

2:42:39 I understand. I understand.

2:43:02 We could make the cost more certain by taking the whole thing out and just committing to that $1.1 million or $1.2 million, but that's not our recommendation. We think this is going to work. We've looked at the corings. We've talked to the consultant, and we're fairly confident of that, but you're correct. We don't know until we take that top two and a half off. But that would effectively represent the worst-case scenario. That's correct. It's somewhere between $6.50 and $1.1 million. That's correct, yeah, because we're really confident with that. Based underneath the asphalt.

2:43:31 You know, appeared to be fine. And in most of the corings, the asphalt itself was not as bad as we thought. Basically, what we're creating is a better base section. It just has to be base and then two and a half inches of not so good asphalt. But it's still a really good solid base. A Grady, you're saying it's 15 or 20 year life? We believe so, yes. In our conditions, again, we, I mean, if you were.

2:43:53 In other places in the state, you know, down south or something, we'd expect it to last much longer. It's 15 to 20, but that also... I was going to ask what the maintenance was on. That also represents that we're going to recommend that we implement the maintenance program that we'll be bringing forward to you in our CIP process and the budgeting that in all the town roads we really have to look at...

2:44:14 The appropriate slurry sealant, whatever the treatment is over the years to make sure we do that. Typically, that's every five years maybe or something like that. Again, it depends. Three to five years. But it depends. We're also very sensitive that old mammoth road is one of our most highly traveled ones, most visible. And in our program, we'll take care of that. Now, I don't know what anybody else does in 10 years or so, but that's really what we're going to put in the program and we're going to put in our budgets.

2:44:42 Is there time in all of this? I know this is a rehab, which essentially means put a new top coat down. Is there an opportunity for you guys to consider whether or not that six-inch wide bike lane should just not be repainted on there since it is such a hazard? Are you looking at options? You know, we beat this up because we looked at all these options. We looked at what the cost would be, frankly.

2:45:10 Old Mammoth Road used to be wider, and it was moved in, and I remember when that happened as a visitor. We actually looked at, gee, do we take that out? Do we get rid of that two-foot landscaping dirt, if you will, strip? I mean, that would be great in the future, but I'm just wondering, in the meantime, if you just, you know, because by having the bike lane there that is only six inches wide, or at least appears only six inches wide,

2:45:35 I think we're sitting ourselves up, and I don't know if that's even been thought of in the design, if that could be something you look at. We're actually looking at this. And route people other ways instead of down there. We're looking at the striping for the whole street, and we're looking at the dual left turn lane, and Hayes is tied into the mobility element and kind of the other options we've looked at as well.

2:45:56 So basically we're looking at options and how we can reconfigure the travel lanes to accommodate bicycle lanes. And so we're doing some analysis, some CAD drawings to see if we can fit it in. A wider bicycle lane, you mean? A real bicycle lane. Yes, okay. I think that would be extremely important. I think there's a couple other pieces here. The first is that with the water situation we've got, we've got that.

2:46:21 I've got a question about the crossings that were put in place. I'm not...

2:46:36 Sure that those are entirely successful. What is your plan with regard to the crossings going forward? Let me address the first just comment you made really quickly first on that two-foot section. We actually have in our budget for the Old Mammoth Road Assessment District about $200,000 to look at start removing those and hardscaping them, you know, making it either concrete or, you know, something that makes more sense. The issue there, just so you know, so you understand, we're being very comprehensive.

2:47:04 That becomes a snow storage issue for us in the winter. Because right now, even that two-foot strip, if you see, it's two foot wide and three feet tall sometimes. But we are looking at that. In terms of the crossings, as it said in the staff report, we are not in favor of...

2:47:20 Different materials for those crosswalks regardless because anytime you have a joint between two kinds of materials, you're inviting water to come in, you're inviting other issues. So at least the ones that run east-west across Old Mammoth Road, we're going to take them out as we go. When we do that, okay, as we do in all of our projects, we're going to take every measure we can to...

2:47:42 Install conduits, things like that, whether it's something that can be used later for a digital 395 for the one that wants to go in near Sierra, or whether it's just extra conduits for future streetlights or other things, we're going to do everything we can to do that. Again, we'll look at the schedule, look at the cost. Okay, because there's a lot of very good ideas here, and I think I'd like to, without delaying...

2:48:05 What you're doing to get out to bid, but to bring back so we can have some specific sense of what you're doing. I think the conduit issue is what I was going to get to with the crossings. I was going to mention that, too. And I think we're on the same page. We've talked about that in the past. Any step that we tear up going forward, we're going to do this. It's a dig once. I think they're on the same page. Yeah, yeah. So I think it would be useful to come, if you can, just to come back to say, this is where they're proposed, where you want to run conduit. This is whether you can or cannot.

2:48:33 Get rid of that hardscape and put in some bike lanes so that I think we have a sense of what we're doing. Yeah, and I don't think that that stands in the way of tonight. No, I don't think it does, but I think it would be because there's a little bit of analysis so the digital 395 folks can look at it and say, yeah, make sure you get one here. If a choice has to be made, we can make sure we're being strategic about where we put those things.

2:48:55 I can elaborate a little bit on the conduit. So since we're only taking out the concrete from gutter pan to gutter pan, we'll lay conduit within that space right there so that we can utilize it for future. For something as extensive as like a digital 395 or an undergrounding project.

2:49:12 That wouldn't really provide them any benefit. They'd have to remove the concrete curb and gutter sidewalk, ADA ramps and so forth in order to access that and set vaults. And then they would also have to direct board to that specific location in order to work, in order to make it happen. So it's actually more beneficial for them to go right underneath that. Well, I'd like to, because I've heard, I think we should look at it. I think it would be.

2:49:40 If we can at least get the conduit in the ground. I've already actually written the conduit in the bid. That's a done deal. But I'm just saying in terms of access for larger projects, I don't want to provide some illusion that this is going to be the panacea for, you know. But within the scope of this project, we'll put the conduit, do what we can, and then there's other things down the road. At least we've taken care of that stuff. And the discussion around sidewalks and removing the different asphalt types.

2:50:06 You're just suggesting making that uniform concrete, not necessarily suggesting removing those as actual crosswalks, just the deviation and the difference. It would certainly be crosswalks. It would just be asphalt. Just be paint. It would not be the paint stuff. Every year and everything. It would be a continuous concrete. So nothing really changes as far as the pedestrian flow. Absolutely. Just the materials. In fact, this gives us an opportunity to look at some other ADA ramps because once you spend, well, we do it anyway, but once you spend, is it $50,000 on a project?

2:50:35 It's actually tied to the treatment. So anything above a fog seal requires you to bring all your pedestrian components into ADA compliance. So we'll be updating 17 ramps to make them ADA compliance part of this project. Okay. Any comments from the public? That's left. Okay. Seeing none, I'll bring it back for discussion or a motion. I'd like to make a motion. Okay. The council wishes to direct staff to prepare plans and specifications.

2:51:06 To incorporate the discussion you've heard this evening for the rehabilitation of asphalt concrete pavement on Old Mammoth Road from Main Street, State Route 203 to Sherwin Creek Road. Second. Okay, motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. We're going to move on to our last item of the evening, item 16. Consider making a contribution to Inyo Monyo Regional Water Management Group to fund a programming gap.

2:51:37 Dan, Grady? Thank you. A couple of times in recent months you've heard presentations from Caltrout and IRWMP, I get that wrong half the time, about what they're doing for us and the stormwater master plan update that we recently did with a grant from them. Just in fact on January 20th I think it was that Mark Drew was here and went through a number of slides and show you what we're doing.

2:52:06 More than fully in support of their efforts. It was really through their efforts that we got $88,000 in grant funds to update our stormwater master plan. What that really does for us is, in addition to helping us immediately in terms of our maintenance program and what we're already doing in town, it really makes us eligible for future capital funding for larger projects.

2:52:28 As Mark said, we are now used as not exactly the poster child, but they are taking our stormwater master plan, what we're doing, and showing it to other people and showing them how to do it. What we found is that, and we knew this was coming for quite some time, we just wanted them to use every effort they could to find funds someplace else. They're going to have a gap between

2:52:49 The Proposition 84 funding and the first Proposition 1 funding, and please don't ask me to go into detail on those propositions, but they do expect to have additional funding come summer. In fact, I think it's November, November 2016. They do expect to have that to be able to continue their mission, if you will, but they have a gap in their interim. They have beaten the bushes, if you will, and talked to a number of other agencies. I've listed seven here that have already made a contribution.

2:53:15 The Mammoth Community Water District is the largest of those. In addition to a contribution, they've also said that the next 4,000 that anybody gives, they'll match. So while they've only been able to gather 6,000 out of their projected $20,000 need, if we provide, as an example, $4,000, Mammoth Community Water District will match that. So they'll be up to...

2:53:36 $14,000 out of their $20,000. Based on the relationship and based on what we think is the current and future benefit of this, staff's recommending that we go ahead and contribute the full $10,000, which will get them to their goal of $20,000. That's our recommendation.

2:53:54 We think that it's the right year, if you will, to do that. We've showed benefit very recently. We think that the funds are available. If council wishes to consider a smaller number, certainly anything helps them. Anything helps them get towards their goal, and they can keep looking for more funds. But if you have any questions on that, we can answer them. Okay, questions? So this is a one-time gap.

2:54:18 That's correct. They've been around for quite a while, and again, the Prop 84 funds basically is just a gap until Prop 1 comes in, and they've said it many times. In fact, I have a comment, I think it was distributed to everyone by email from Mark Drew, who was trying to be here tonight, but wasn't able to make it. Just, again, thanking you for whatever support you can have and going through the reasons why this is, to them, certainly an important program. Can I understand how the...

2:54:44 Funding goes, is part of that $6,000, is that part of Mammoth Community Water District? Is that $4,000 in that $6,000? I think there was $1,000 that Mammoth Community Water District just gave, and then the rest would be matching funds, so another $4,000. So within the $6,000 that's been given, the $4,000 that they said that...

2:55:06 Is on top of that. Is on top of that. If they have six now, if we give four, they'll match that four, which gives them the 14, then their gap is then six. We're suggesting that we give them the whole 10, so they're the matching in the other. Mammoth Community Water will give another four if we give four. And if we give 10, they hit their 20. Correct. With that match. Okay. But they'll still give four.

2:55:29 Right. So they've given $14,000 so far? I believe, and again, I'd have to look back at the other records, but I believe they've already made a contribution. I don't have that number. What are the county? Do we know what the county? No, I don't have the numbers on the individual contribution. That was going to be one of my questions, Grady. You don't have the breakdown of how those seven entities funded the original six?

2:55:57 No, I don't have the numbers from each one. Grady, what was the amount you said that we had received from IRWIMP so far? It was an $88,000 grant. And to this point, we have not contributed anything. Now, we did have a match with that grant. The total was, I think the total project was around $130,000. So we had a match, but...

2:56:19 We have not funded their staff or funded them in any other way. We haven't made any contributions? No. Okay. Yeah, I think we're all enormously impressed by the work that they've done. And, you know, it's a partner that we work with. They haven't asked us for anything before, but we leverage millions of dollars out of all this stuff. John, let me go to the public and then we'll come back and talk if you guys have any other questions. Any public comment on this? Okay. John? Sorry. So I'm inclined to...

2:56:47 I'm prepared to make a motion to just go ahead with the full 10 and call it good. And I'm going to agree with you, and I'll second your motion when we get that far, but I also wanted to point out this is one group that has really got the whole idea of working regionally down. Oh, yeah, absolutely. It is happening. We need to support that as well. Okay. I'll let her take a motion.

2:57:15 I would move that the Town of Mammoth Lakes contribute $10,000 to the Inu-Mona Regional Water Management IRWM Group to fund a programming gap. Second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Michael, if I could answer it real quick. If you include in that the approval of the resolution that authorizes that budget amendment. As amended. Okay. So amended. Amended your second? Yes. Okay. Motion to second. Amended. Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:57:48 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That will conclude our meeting tonight. We'll adjourn to our next regular meeting scheduled Wednesday, April 6th at 6 p.m. right here. Good night. Thank you.