Town Council Special meeting
· recording 4 hr 29 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
592 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:08 Thank you.
0:20 Let's see, I think I printed it. That's an easy way to find. It's right there.
0:43 Thank you.
0:54 That was a little more elaborate setup. Donuts.
1:24 We are here in a city of Belize, Stu.
1:28 Hi, Michael.
1:29 Hi, Michael.
1:30 Hi, Michael.
1:30 Hi, Michael.
1:30 Welcome back.
1:32 Thank you for the evening.
1:33 That's great.
1:33 Yeah.
1:35 Whoa, yeah.
1:35 That's right then.
1:36 A couple months to go.
1:38 Hey, Stu, I got here late last night, and I remember watching you making presentations on your bookshops.
1:48 Okay.
1:49 The various projects he's got, so I'm just going to get to it.
1:51 All right.
1:52 Thank you.
1:53 What do you want to do in that facility? You know, we get them to complete a worksheet.
2:22 So we really ask a lot of questions.
2:34 A little horrifying.
3:04 All right. Good morning, everybody. Thanks for joining. We're going to call to order Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes special meeting Wednesday, March 23rd, and it is 834. Seeing all councils present, you all rise and call me to pledge to this. I pledge allegiance to the flag.
3:36 Of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, invisible, with liberty and justice for all. Are there any public comments for any items that are not on today's agenda from anybody? Okay, seeing none.
4:06 We'll move on to item one, our workshop. Workshop to discuss the town council's strategic goals and priorities. Welcome back, Michael. And we're going to turn it over to you to get it started. Good morning. Thank you all for coming. Full room. That makes me happy. This will be very tough to do without everybody involved. So we've been on a kind of eight-month journey together.
4:28 To effect a strategic alignment. What is that? What did that mean? What was the idea of strategic alignment involving the town, the council, and the NGOs? What was the whole point of this? See if you're awake. I'm awake. I've been working. We're hoping unity. Rowing in the same direction. Rowing in the same direction. Rowing in the same direction. Facilitating unity. What else? What is the idea here? Focusing on the same goals more. Tell me more.
4:59 Efficiencies. Working together. Working together. Leveraging resources. Leveraging resources. So all of that, right? So the idea here is that you can, in theory, it's just a theory, that you can accomplish more together than you can separately and after the fact trying to roll your accomplishments together. That's the way this works. But collaboration is not...
5:25 Really a noun. It's really a verb concept. It's an action concept. It's not about sort of collaborating in name or in principle. It's actually making the process of working together as real as possible and as frequent as possible. Not something that I've watched communities do this. They develop a comprehensive collaboration plan and their idea is that every six months
5:54 They'll check in on how they're doing. I say, well, how are you doing on what? They say, well, how are we doing collaborating? I say, well, what was your strategy for collaborating during the intervening six months? Well, occasionally, we're in the same committee rooms together. Occasionally, we have phone conversations with each other. We have coffee together. I say, but actually, how are you aligning your very precious limited resources, people, dollars, messaging,
6:23 You know, the community will only tolerate you coming back to them a few times with the same idea before they get tired of it, get burned out on it, and say, okay, now what? So in a sense, you're trying to activate and breathe life into a real process. So Dan, do you have, are you finding that link? Nope. Let me check here. Punch it up. I want to show you guys, while Dan's looking for this, back in the,
6:52 Early 90s and early 2000s, I was part of a consulting group called the Continuous Learning Group out of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. There's a bunch of PhD, organizational industrial psychologists, behavior analysts, and so on. And one of the things we were doing was we were working in private sector and public sector organizations during the era of Latin America. That's it.
7:22 During the era of flattening the organization, remember this? Any of you old enough to remember this era we went through of trying to move away from centralized forms of governance to more decentralized instead of vertically structured organizations to flattened organizations? In the public sector it meant fewer layers of decision making. In the private sector it meant
7:49 Sales and marketing were on the same level instead of, and they were cross-functional. So the idea was, how do we optimize or sort of help these entities work more effectively together? So there was a project that was done down in San Diego in 1983 by the Building Industry Association of San Diego, and they published a video. These are the actual original videos.
8:18 I brought them with me just so I could reminisce in public. Not really. Yeah, yeah, but I knew you wouldn't have the, I wouldn't, I knew you would not have this advanced technology, so we've loaded it up on YouTube, which we're going to sacrifice a little bit of quality, but this is, Building Industry Association participated in a competition to determine whether or not an entire house could be built from the ground up in four hours.
8:47 A year before, a record had been set by another community and they wanted to compete. This is the 25-minute version. This is the 12-minute version. We're going to look at the 10-minute version in a YouTube clip without all the intro. So I want you to watch this video. It's 10 minutes long. And I'm going to ask a few questions about it at the end. So this is literally 700 workers on a flat piece of ground.
9:17 Building a house from the ground up, their attempt is under four hours. Go for it. So, Dan, let's stop it and go back. I'll show this at the end, too. So, go back to your Google screen. Just go back to your YouTube screen and in the search, punch in BIA for a four-hour house.
10:30 We should get the 10-minute version. Probably the third one down. That's the one below. Is that it? That's 11 minutes. Yeah, there it is. All right. Yeah, the commentary is helpful. It's nice to have this technology in this room. Yeah. We never had this before.
11:03 Today, from San Diego, California, world record competition. An attempt to build a complete house from the ground up in four hours. The standing world record is four hours and 18 minutes set one year ago. Today, two teams will compete with each other and with the clock. Can they do it? Standing by to keep you up to date is Ted Leitner, and I'm Mark Larson. Look, they keep world records for everything. Sports, non-sports, everything ever done. But a four-hour house.
11:35 This, I have to be here, I have to seat the boat. The most surprising part is that there's nothing quick and easy about this. A lot of people expect it to be prefabricated. That's not the case. We're going to see today a full-blown house built from standard materials using the normal techniques. Obviously, though, you can't do this just by speeding everything up and hammering fast. That won't get it done. A lot of these people have been out here since wee hours of the morning, some midnight, setting up and getting ready for what we're going to see today.
12:00 That's right, Ted. Preparations have gone on for some time. This morning at around 6 a.m., 700 workmen reported the roll call. That's not including the support people. Every conceivable trade is represented today in just the logistics of moving that many people, their equipment, and necessary materials in and out of the site is tremendous. It's one massive job, but looking at these guys, you'd think it's a piece of cake. We are just about set. All the planning coming to a hand here as far as the competition is concerned.
12:29 All set on the record-breaking, we hope, for our house, the TMA, and here they go!
12:37 Fascinating. After weeks of preparation, we're going to see some exciting activity today. The world record as it stands now before this morning is four hours and 18 minutes set a couple of years ago up in Riverside. Now the key today is to break that record and do it hopefully in less than four hours and 18 minutes. Two practice houses built last week and they didn't quite make it, but a lot of things learned from that competition last week. So today it's for real. 700 plus people working on this. Let's see how it works out. Organization. I want to show you this thing.
13:05 Because the organization of what's happening here is not just, well, it happened at 9.17, it may happen at 10.17. Here's a schedule.
13:13 of the entire four hours, everything that they're going to be doing, set the rough plumbing at 8.04, place the steel reinforcements at 8.09, inspect it only for 10 minutes, so not only is the exact time set, but how much time they're then going to spend on it, whether it's 10 minutes or 15 minutes, it goes all the way down, lay out walls, fiberglass tubs, set the frame walls, and up and down the entire time, and obviously there are other things involved here than just sending the people out and letting them run out and do it.
13:39 There have been several promotional events that led up to the building and the houses today. How do you give a pre-game pep talk to 700 construction people? Well, flavor it with rock and roll, fine food, a dance or two, and prodigious amounts of beer, and you let them do the talking. Okay, let's say 3 hours and 50 minutes. I figure probably about 3 hours and 59 minutes, under 4 hours. 47 minutes.
14:13 Probably three different pieces of trenching equipment, a small wheel. But even as the team spirit gained momentum, the task of refining details was staggering. We're looking at a three-bedroom, two-bathroom house, complete, ready to move into in four hours or less. The planning left no room for error. If one step were to fall behind, it would affect a dozen others, with little chance to make up the time.
14:41 As all the preparations neared completion, we talked with the team captains, Chuck Kuhn and Randy Muelheim. Because of the tremendous amount of planning and organization that's gone into it, it appears that everybody's doing their job exactly the way they're supposed to. It is a little frightening that it seems to be going so smooth at this point. We've got a number of concerns at this point, one of which you can see right now is starting to rain on us here, and that's something that's being dealt with now. We've got a lot of the people individually working on it.
15:11 The trades, how they're each going to handle it, and we'll get together at the proper time. It takes training to break a record, but how do you train for this? Simple. You build two houses for practice. One week before the event, we watched Team A and Team B give it a go. The time was nearly six hours, but the experience gained was tremendous. All right, that was last week. This is this week and the real thing setting the world record here in San Diego. Now, they tell me that a major milestone...
15:38 It's about to be set down there. So let's go down there, find Mark, who is in the middle of all of it. This competition is moving so fast that we expected to be over here in time to see the concrete beginning to pour. They're a little bit ahead of schedule, it appears, and already pouring this fast-cure concrete out here onto the foundation on House A. It's a little bit touchy because of the San Diego codes here as far as the competition is concerned and other world record attempts.
16:05 They've been able to just pour the slab and go from there. San Diego codes require stricter quality as far as the steel reinforcements are concerned. They've done the rough plumbing. They've been working on that this morning, digging out the concrete puddings from the ground up. When the concrete goes over it, there's no turning back, so the plumbing's got to be right. All the specifications that match up with the walls when they bring the walls in that are being built now in other areas here on the site.
16:29 They've all got to match up or there's a lot of trouble. Keeping in mind, the building inspectors are here in referee shirts, much like an NFL football game. They're going around ready to blow the whistle if they have to, to have them pull out something that can be pulled out and start over if there's a problem. Let's hope this gets finished before it sets up, Ted. How can you set concrete and then put a house on it? I mean, that's not normal, is it? No, it's not normal. Basically what we're doing is we're chemically heating the concrete.
16:58 To a degree where the concrete gels, thickens, and sets in 15, 20 minutes and where we're able to walk on it and have steam is coming off the concrete. That concrete is hot. You look like you've been working. You're sweating heavily. This is not the normal job, is it? No, it's not. And let this be a lesson to you. It's a lot of fun. It is that. We're going to do it. See? See? It's incredible on this is they're moving the walls down right now.
18:16 They're going to put these up, then the roofing goes on there next. And again, the timing is crucial. One false move, and you either start over again, or the house falls down. And that certainly, we don't want that to happen during a world record attempt. Here's another view of the roof construction going on right now. You can really see there's been a lot of activity going on here behind the scenes. We were on the other side a few minutes before. Already the air conditioning and the heating duct work. You can see some of the electrical wiring hang out. All that will be in place when the crane comes and moves the roof.
18:56 We'll see them lift up the walls, move them over, put them onto the concrete. At that point, the house really starts to take shape. The insulation is coming in here. The drywall is going in. Now, this is kind of tough because the supply of drywall is not unlimited. They've got just enough to finish the project. Now, if they don't coordinate use and cut it...
20:07 They'll run out and put a stop to the record right now. They have to nail down and secure the drywall here. They'll have to be taping, of course, much like if you've ever had a house built or seen this happen. A lot of work that normally happens over several days and hours. Again, the entire house here will hopefully be built in a record-breaking time of under 4 hours and 18 minutes. It looks like A-Team here has about completed the house from the outside anyway. We've got the landscaping all finished. A lot of things are going on inside there right now to finish things up.
20:52 That means we set a new world record of unofficially two hours and 53 minutes. Not only a three hour house, but a two hour 53 minute house. Huh? Did we tell you? You were skeptical? Didn't think it could be done in four hours? It wasn't. Two hours and 45 minutes. But, in case you missed it, would you like to see it in one minute? Have any of you seen this before?
22:29 So I have a couple of you here. So I have the 25-minute version. It shows a lot more detail about the ways in which... On a normal autop... What was so neat about it is... You have all these... ...to our situation here. What stood out for you in this video? A lot of meetings. A lot of meetings. They had a plan.
22:54 Teamwork. Tremendous amount of teamwork. So they had to kind of carefully orchestrate that. They literally had it down to the minute. How many of you have actually built a house or remodeled a house? How many of you experienced the greatest problem in remodeling, which is getting the electricians, plumber, and drywall people to actually sequence their work appropriately? They're all impatient to get in the building.
23:22 And you can't actually put up the sheetrock before you do the electrical work, right? So you have a general contractor to do all of that. That's kind of the idea here. What else do you think was necessary for 700 people 30 years ago? No nail guns, no easy spray application of sheetrock taping.
23:49 What was necessary? One thing that could have been perceived as a barrier is concrete, so that is not a norm. That's right. What did you notice about the walls or the roof? What did you see happening there? You don't have to have been in the trades or worked in carpentry or anything to recognize what's going on. They built it and they brought it together. What's the conventional approach? The conventional approach is build it on site, build it incrementally.
24:29 Take long lunch breaks. Do this over months, or as we like to say in the mountains, during the building season, right? And sort of people sort of get around to the work and they work at a slow pace. What's the sense of urgency in getting the work done? Not very great unless there was a performance bonus or an incentive to get it done. How about the roof? What did they do with the roof? Build it off site. Build it off site.
25:01 Used a crane and dropped it on. In fact, the Building Industry Association statewide took many of the innovations and the mechanisms they created in this competition and then generalized those to the building industry and they actually found their way into the apprenticeship programs and code enforcement and so on. They said there's no need to keep incrementalizing our way to the future when we already know how to accelerate.
25:29 What was the most important thing the announcer said at the beginning of the video? Do you remember what he said? He said, you can't, in order to build a house in four hours, you can't, what? You can't have anything off the time frame, that was clear. So that, they had to follow the plan, or it wasn't going to work. You can't take things out of order. He said, you can't just speed up and nail faster.
26:04 You can't just speed up and nail faster. Nor can you. Your 2025 goal framework, your vision of mammoth greatness is your four-hour house. Why is it a four-hour house? It's a metaphor. Why is it a four-hour house? Why is there an urgency about 2025? Come on, you guys know this. Is everything going to be the same each year between now and 2025?
26:38 What's unpredictable? The weather, the climate, visitation? How much of your own destiny do you have direct control over? These are rhetorical questions, but not a great deal. What can you do in that space? If you don't get to control the wild cards, weather, climate, visitation?
27:12 The global economy, the national economy, God forbid this year's election is just a frightening proposition for everyone involved because the trickle-down effects of this election might be absolutely devastating to states, counties, and cities. That could all happen. You don't get to control any of that. What can you control? In this case, you control the creation of the community that you want to live in, the community that you want to live in.
27:48 Because your theory of benefit is that the community you want to live in will attract other like who want to affiliate with that community. You're relying on the psychological principle of affiliation. The most beyond our basic needs for food, shelter, and water of our single greatest need psychologically is affiliation. It's actually connection with others who believe what we believe.
28:17 Who share our values and want to be connected to that kind of experience. So in effect, this whole schematic we've been trying to create for months and months, which sounds like strategic alignment between NGOs, we're like in the acronym soup of the NGOs, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, sort of getting together, optimizing your resources, just all fancy language for creating the future.
28:47 Community that you want to live in that will attract other like-minded people and I want to bring to you the sense of urgency with thoughtfulness, urgency with thoughtfulness that you might apply to building a four-hour house. You don't have five years to plan and five years to do if your 2025 goals are real. You have 10 years to do.
29:17 And this workshop is about the doing. So you know my style. I've created a big landscape that summarizes all of your inputs and your work to date. You have a couple of handouts in front of you. Let's make sure you all have what I have. You have something that looks like this. Mine has a colored band on top. It says Town of Mammoth Lakes, NGO priority alignment, and integrated 2025 major goals.
29:47 Everybody got that one? Well, it probably has your vision and values piece on top. So let me start there. So you have your vision frame. You have the core values. And remember, these were core community values, not core leadership team values. The values you believe the community at large shares in common. And on this worksheet, in just a very few pages, we have
30:19 The town's four major strategic priorities. Enhance our recreation-based economy. These are listed in order. Develop a comprehensive community plan. Enhance the many of these serving residents and visitors and effective municipal services. The second, that's the left-hand column. The second column, moving from the left, represents the council.
30:49 On behalf of the town's commitments to implement each of these priorities. On the far right, we have the concise set of nine goals that we framed all of us together collectively for 2025 so that we have some markers out in the future for what we want to realize, where we want to arrive. And in that middle space,
31:20 Conveniently the white space over here. We did a series of workshops earlier this month. Many of you participated in those workshops. We took each of the priority areas and we drilled down into a much more targeted, more focused series of actions or milestones. Actions meaning things that you get going or keep going, milestones being
31:49 Increments of accomplishment that you actually complete. So when I use the words like that, that's what we're talking about. So I took all of that and exploded it up real large. It's all up on this wall here. I didn't reprint the goals. You had those goals. What we're going to do here is go through a systematic process of review and refinement of that work group input. That was the point of the work groups.
32:18 So everything that's in that middle column are contained on these cards. Our thinking was that we were going to approach this work in six quarters. Quarter one, kicking off April 1st. You can adjust these time frames later if you need to. April 1st to June 30th will be quarter one of 16, and July 1st to September 30th of 17 being the sixth quarter, the last quarter.
32:50 Our sort of victory column, meaning what is it that we hope to celebrate together on October 1st, 2017? That's the last column. We have a kickstart column, and then we have all the rest of the content. So I've come up with a very simple process. You also have a handout that looks like this. This handout is actually just to guide you if you don't work well from
33:20 These sort of large wall images. This whole wall is contained in this document in front of you. And your finished product, when we're done with all this work, will look a lot like this. At least the action plan component, there'll be a whole narrative sitting on top with everything else you've done around vision, guiding principles, and so on. So this is just to help you navigate this process. So I think I've got this down to 10 steps.
33:49 And it's going to look a little like this. We're going to start by asking you to self-select into four working groups. So I want you to start thinking about this now. Enhance our recreation-based economy through effective municipal services. The idea here is you work in four teams, because I don't want to do this with 25 people all at once. It doesn't get better. It actually elongates our discussion.
34:18 We've already had a lot of discussion. We don't need to do, we're not brainstorming all over again, we're not action planning all over again, we're actually taking the ideas you've already formed and putting them into a scope and sequence that you believe you can implement effectively. That's what we're doing here today. So you're going to form these four groups. I'm going to have somebody in each group to chair, small c, the group, just to keep it on task.
34:48 Keep it focused. You guys did some of this back in the fall. We did some working groups then. Keep the group focused and make sure we're moving through these steps. I'll leave all these steps up here on this flip chart board. So in your groups, by the way, here's a simple rule about the groups. If you feel like you have critical input in more than one group, start in one and move to another. This is a community exercise. It's a community leadership exercise.
35:17 There's no hard and fast rules here. Do what works best for you. I don't personally care about that. I want you to come out with a product that you feel ownership for at the end. That's what I care about here today. So the first thing you're going to do is you're going to come up and you're going to collect all your action cards. So I've color-coded them to make it easy for you to track and not get confused. So the Enhancer Recreation-Based Economy Group is going to come up and collect all these cards.
35:47 And bring it back to your table. And the way I would do this is you're going to lay them out on the table. You're going to read through them. I suggest you read through them out loud. It's actually a better way to listen and to process than everybody reading independently. You'll actually, you read them independently, you'll all end up with a different impression of what's going on. And your first discussion is, what's the big idea? What's the sum of all these cards?
36:14 Let's say we did all these things. What is that? I mean, enhance our recreation-based economy? That sounds great. What is that? What would that look like? What's the big idea that's holding all those cards together? When you figure out what that is, I'd like you to come and edit your MasterCard and give us that big idea. So that's going to be your first step. Discuss the big idea and name it.
36:43 The second step is to refine the cards. Look, in those working groups, sometimes we had four, sometimes we had six. They were not a consensus of the whole. They were just a working group. I knew that. And in between, I've been thinking about this a lot. We need a good consensus. If the cards don't make sense to you, or you don't remember talking about it, or it looks like the way I talk, not the way you talk, because I was taking the notes,
37:11 I recorded all this stuff. When I transcribed them, I transcribed them the way you gave it to me. I did a little editing, but if it doesn't make sense to you, refine the cards. Make them more specific. Make them more clear. Make them more actionable. So that's your second step. Your third step is to sequence them. Sequence the cards. This is the only real project management part of this. In project management, one of your most important...
37:40 Actions, the most important action in the four-hour house was to literally get down to minutes. All you have to do is quarters. And there doesn't have to be a card for every quarter. Could be that there's three milestones in one quarter and three quarters with no milestone. I personally don't care. All that matters is that it makes sense to you. And it's an approach that you think you can live with. I would suggest that you lay the cards out on your table.
38:08 So that you can discuss them in that context. And then when you come up here, you're going to create the sticky wall image for us of what that sequence looks like. You're going to place the cards as milestones quarter by quarter. The fourth step is get it up there and go, okay, if this is our big idea and this is our refined set of cards and this is the sequence we think we should do this work in. In other words,
38:38 There's some dependencies. How many of you have project management experience? A few? So what does dependencies mean in project management? Somebody, what does dependencies mean? Something that you need in order to complete the step. Something you need in order to complete the step or to move on to the next step. It may be that you'll see, hey, wait, there's gaps here. We can't actually complete this milestone unless we do something else first.
39:06 After the milestone, it looks like the milestone gets orphaned. Those are the two things that I think will happen for you. You'll say, we don't know what the step is before it, and it looks orphaned, now what? So if you find yourself going, okay, great fourth quarter milestone, now what? Give us the now what, meaning add another card. So I've provided you with all the colored cards and the pens in order to do this. So for your group, just stay with your...
39:35 Color sequence. Once you get all that done and you feel like you've got it nailed, then these two steps become extremely important. Start with the end. Go to October 1st, 2017. I'm going to take you through all of this and we'll do about this much of it and then we'll do this separately. Discuss and decide what is it we will celebrate October 1st, 2017. What's the big outcome?
40:05 So if you stay in the mindset of,
40:36 How are we serving the 8,000 plus residents and the many aspirational visitors that come here looking for an experience? How do we celebrate with them October 1st, 2017? This will start to kick in for you. And then go back to the beginning. I've created two landscapes here just so that we have more space. So you want to go to this kickstart item and say, these are the actions. We've got it in the right order.
41:04 We got the right milestone. What is the very first thing that needs to happen to set this process in motion? April 1. If it's not April 1, make it April 15th or May 1. I don't care. Whatever. Just pick a kickstart action. Sometimes I see groups default to the two safest kickstart actions that we all know professionally. The first one is
41:34 Call a meeting. Call a meeting. The problem with that kickstart action is it sounds like we're going to start brainstorming all over again. Don't do that. Don't start with call a meeting unless you're going to name the action agenda for that meeting. Then that would be okay. And the second default kickstart action is create a plan. We've been doing that for eight months. Don't create any new plans.
42:06 Don't make those your kickstart actions. Then, you've got all this done, then you're going to go back and say, who owns these milestones? During the working groups, we named either Town of Mammoth Lakes or one of four NGOs or all. So this one here says MLT, this is MLR, MLT, Town of Mammoth Lakes, NGOs, all. Some say all, here's all. ESTA, MLR.
42:40 That was just the work group's perspective at the time. You may revisit these cards and say, wait, I don't think we have the right owners here. Owners just mean somebody has to be accountable or nobody's accountable. And if nobody's accountable, we have wasted our time. Let's not waste our time. Make sure you have clear owners. And the very last thing I'm going to ask you to do is step back from your whole plan and look at the question of budget resources.
43:10 I did an exercise like this. We did a couple of business walks last week in South Tahoe. We had about 80 people participate over two days. People came back with all these recommendations for project, project, project, project. And so we asked them to estimate the financial or resource implications of each of these projects. And every one of them on their own looked achievable when we rolled them all together. We had something like $65 million.
43:39 Worth of work. And then all the air went out of the room really fast. But it's necessary to take that deep collective breath. Otherwise, you can talk yourself into a bunch of ideas that you cannot source. You cannot actually realize. Or you might say, all right, we're setting the bar super high here. We're going for it. That's our deal. What's the deal? One billion? You said one billion is a low ball, right? A low ball.
44:08 So you have to have a sense of what that is. So we may do that one collectively. I may just guide you through that. And assuming you're productive in these first seven steps and we get through the budget piece, then I'm going to add a couple of pieces around communications and metrics and all that. So I put, that was a lot of talk, but I put the entire process here. So your very first question is,
44:41 What group do you want to work in? Or start in. Or start in. And you can rotate, and you can mill about, but the chairs, whoever chairs the group needs to stay with your group. You've got to provide some continuity for us. So if you feel like enhancing our recreation-based economy is where you would like to spend the next couple of hours, please come up, collect the yellow cards, choose a working space, these tables.
45:11 This table here, I'll move all my stuff. I'll get another table. There's another table. You can create a space over here, spread out a little bit. So who would like to work on enhancing our recreation-based environment? Okay, and let's try and get council distributed. All right, so four or five of you guys. So you guys come up, we get the yellow cards, choose a chair. I don't care who that is. How about developing a comprehensive community plan? Show of hands.
45:44 Three, we need more. John, are you, we need more than three for comprehensive community plan. Shields. Four? Michael, do you want to go to the table? Sure. Okay, so at least four, otherwise this will be hard. We just sent shields to them. Yeah? Okay, so a group for orange cards, come and collect these. White. Yes, absolutely.
46:21 So how about enhanced amenities? I'll make sure we have at least four. Where are they here? So one, two,
46:50 Three, four, and then municipal services. One, two, three, four. Dan, are you going to go with municipal services? Okay.
47:18 So I'm moving the flip chart over here so you all can see it. Follow the script.
47:31 All of the scripts. Big idea.
48:02 You want my yellow fruit? Yeah, we'll be moving around.
48:09 So, it was the big idea to create a true year-round destination offering the best outbound recreation opportunities.
49:53 Make sure you get them. Identify notes, access points to national cores, and mobile, and year round.
50:20 Thank you.
50:54 Bucket. That's exactly what I was saying, Brian. That's exactly what I was saying. I think that's address capital A's when you have business plan, it's just business plan, it's just operation and delivery of this.
51:23 Thank you.
51:53 What's the big idea, right?
52:19 We're talking about four business plans for priority projects, but we only have one priority project.
52:48 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
52:56 What is the big idea? The big idea and then we can refine these cards.
53:19 So we're supposed to write our big idea on one of those.
53:48 It's definitely a better one.
53:53 You guys ended up with a blue card. Well, they gave it to you? Really? It's the last word group. That one got moved from here to there.
54:22 I agree.
54:51 I think he's now the advisors of the state about the recreation. I think his point was $9 billion.
55:21 Thank you.
55:47 Isn't that a way that's kind of their life? It's just in that local, community area that some of the others... I know which is called for my last 30 years, is equity and fundraising, but it's the moment that the body isn't kind of restricted by its ability to do that, because it's something I made by the councils that have to change. I think it's...
56:16 Thank you.
56:41 It's almost like it's two.
57:11 Thank you.
57:33 This area should be able to be modified. Yeah, but isn't it like two of the goals are here. There's no overlap here.
58:01 Those commitments should be on your head.
58:30 Everything that's up there you have in front of you.
58:38 So let me ask you, so D, why is it just written for me?
59:07 Yeah. To make this, to create a sustainable recreation program, wouldn't it be beneficial?
59:37 I guess we're dictating that, like, some influence in the national forest and revision, AMS, D, have created a sustainable recreation program in this era, right? And these are, well, I think if you put them in the text, and you dropped in your national edition, it would read, Mammoth Lakes entries are reflected in the national forest by the revision that AMS created a sustainable recreation program for the region.
1:00:06 Thank you.
1:00:35 I think D is broader. I think there's multiple plans. Whoever's providing recreation programs for the community.
1:00:52 Matt has their own plans. So I think C is participating in the creative and implementation of the Sustainable Recreation Program. That would bring in business plans into that section. It's been a broader collaborative collaborative versus C is very specific to Inyo, and I think Inyo is its own. It's entity. There's four content just related to Inyo.
1:01:21 I like the idea that it includes plans, fundraising, leveraging.
1:01:45 So that means that you're engaging, we're engaging everybody in the soup.
1:02:14 Thank you.
1:02:27 Thank you.
1:02:56 Thank you.
1:03:23 To work with the RNF, you're my name.
1:03:52 Thank you.
1:04:22 Yeah, we don't need to see what we need to talk about and then it gets on and on and on because if they, you know, it's like you start, if you put them here, it's no policy, you don't have to ask you, right?
1:04:33 Okay, accessing the financial details to TML projects, the island, you just wanted to talk about.
1:04:39 I'm gonna spend something nice, I just like talking about exotic sources.
1:04:42 So, that was meant to say that...
1:04:46 Not every kind of funding is good for every single project, and so it's a sense of doing that piece where, okay, now we know that the police department was going to talk about what are the best people there. Whereas, we're ready to ask to finish the sidewalk out here, what are the best people there? But I don't know that that would be...
1:05:15 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:05:45 Is it to make a bit more general work with partners to plan strategic oversight of
1:06:14 Thank you.
1:06:32 I think we should be in shape for some groundwater.
1:06:35 This is everything, right?
1:06:35 Yeah.
1:06:36 Yeah.
1:06:36 And then we're going to maybe put a point to, which includes, and I find that, it's different
1:06:42 information about environmental studies.
1:06:47 So now that he's been taught, we're making sure that there's a huge amount of ways, and we can
1:06:54 help you build this, and to support them, and to improve.
1:06:58 We want to put a point where that might include us, and the time.
1:07:00 We'll be right back.
1:07:00 Yeah, I think this was an important planning and implementation. Yeah, planning, yeah. Strategic planning and implementation, and effective implementation. Yeah, work with partners to affect planning, planning, planning, planning, and access to resources. I don't think you put strategic up here in planning. I think there's more space. I mean, there's a network of partners, people that are testing people to develop, to plan, to develop.
1:07:30 Okay, to work with partners. It's a chicken and egg.
1:07:59 What are we trying to achieve? Which is called scoring. What do we oversee?
1:08:28 Thank you.
1:08:57 We have to make sure that they're all in alignment with what they want to do and that any conflict
1:10:11 So, yeah. Dr. Lee? I think this is a, maybe it needs to be framed. I think it's a part of all this. Yeah, it's, it's a narrow approach. It's just, it's bigger than the, I don't know. To me, it's like, obviously, it's almost strategy to achieve goals to affect your partnership. I'm wondering if there's another question.
1:10:40 I think what we need to do is just put this in a description.
1:11:10 Thank you.
1:11:32 But then is she then, is it perhaps more narrow based around just the international forest plan? Because the international forest plan is on its own. But I think that's a tactic. You know what I'm saying? That's just, we engage. I think it's coming back to recreation assets. Yeah. Recreation assets. You guys are better to manage recreation assets.
1:12:01 I work with partners to effectively manage the recreational access.
1:12:17 So let's write that.
1:13:45 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:14:38 Oh, oh, okay.
1:16:35 Also, think about it as, though, these squares become... All right, so it's part of the infrastructure. Do you know what it is expected of? Yeah. So try to avoid...
1:17:04 We're going to put these points under here and see what it looks like.
1:17:34 Okay.
1:18:03 Thank you.
1:18:20 Yeah, because that even happens. Doesn't it come under here? I think it comes under.
1:18:49 Well, that's why I think we're coming back to this. We can further define that.
1:19:19 This is what we want to put in here for stewardship. What about environmental studies? Do we need to put that in there? Because we've got user conflicts citing environmental.
1:19:31 Studies on... Are we addressing that in here? Now we need to get down to... Is that going to be in here, right? We have to go back. It's the same thing as well? Is that town? Is that town or is that what we just got over there? Because it's parlors, right?
1:20:00 Yes.
1:20:02 We've got a milestone.
1:20:31 So this is the overall strategy. So, well, this is probably
1:21:01 Thank you.
1:21:30 Well, I agree. But I'm saying this already exists.
1:21:43 Thank you.
1:22:12 So, we don't mention that anywhere in the discussion.
1:23:28 So, results?
1:23:29 Okay, so that could be in the second quarter of the year.
1:23:32 Identify, you know, identify capital responsibility.
1:23:35 Identify credit and funding.
1:23:38 Identify or secure?
1:23:41 Well, that's right.
1:23:43 Secure capital funding?
1:23:46 Secure capital funding.
1:23:49 Well, this is a nerve.
1:23:51 That's a hell of a deal of capital.
1:23:53 You don't have to change.
1:23:54 That's what we need to secure capital funds.
1:23:57 That's right.
1:23:57 Thank you.
1:24:16 So maybe over there? Okay. Alright.
1:24:46 What do we have? Try to use this context.
1:25:15 So we've rewritten actually one of the commitments.
1:25:41 Thank you.
1:25:52 Yes. D. And what are we doing over here? This is kind of rewriting just the cluster. So this goes on top of this stuff, right? Which is all the stuff we need to write. Exactly. And this one should go over here. So that relates to C. Bring D back down. So that's the overarching. Yes. Then we have A, B, C, D. Let's get together here. We seem to put them into the three packets now.
1:26:22 Thank you.
1:26:44 Which one do you think it? Yeah, it's B. It's under B.
1:26:53 Okay.
1:27:22 Thank you.
1:27:44 Right. That's the...
1:28:42 Thank you.
1:29:42 Well, and when we were doing this one, what are the gaps in discussion?
1:31:30 And we need one here that Judge Descension said, let's just do that it's staff, which is because your new council is excited. But, no, but that you, yeah. But he does so much of that already. So, you know, trying to do that.
1:32:21 Thank you.
1:32:31 I think, you know, looking at right now, so citing?
1:33:00 Oh, it's anti-sides. Okay. Yes. Okay.
1:33:30 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:34:20 Do we have any?
1:34:44 Thank you.
1:34:51 Thank you. Thank you.
1:37:58 About 20 more minutes for this part. Try to get down to at least...
1:38:25 We're at three. Number six, maybe seven. Just get the six. We're just at three. You guys have been doing gaps. That's really how you're going to get the lights.
1:38:54 Thank you.
1:39:03 Go back to your big idea.
1:39:32 Thank you.
1:40:02 We're ready to support. We're completely ready to support.
1:40:13 These are good milestones.
1:40:43 Yes. We're trying to get to six. Five and six. Five and six.
1:41:12 Oh, you know what I'm saying? Oh, she did it immediately.
1:41:41 Alright, so then we've got basically the compliance system which is producing business plans.
1:42:10 Okay. All right.
1:42:39 Thank you.
1:42:46 We could put that in. Yeah, so really just the free one. I think this one may be...
1:43:15 Thank you. Thank you.
1:43:22 Yeah, so Q2-ing, just do a separate part.
1:43:25 Complication of trail rides on Q2.
1:43:28 Yeah, constructively.
1:43:29 What do you do, but it's not a kickstart?
1:43:32 Well, so April, when, what we do with that is,
1:43:35 if you were to see the question of whether it's a key structure of the time,
1:43:38 so that's where the market rod comes up and that leads to the end.
1:43:41 Oh, okay.
1:43:41 Oh, they don't like it.
1:43:43 Okay.
1:43:43 Okay.
1:43:44 So maybe that's construction.
1:43:47 Well, that's all well good.
1:43:49 Yeah, somebody shows up the door.
1:43:50 Yeah, I got a,
1:43:51 Thank you.
1:43:52 Thank you.
1:44:21 I mean, those might be good.
1:45:38 Okay.
1:45:43 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
1:46:13 Thank you.
1:46:42 Yeah, all the, okay, it's interesting, and then all the things that we have to say, everything, and then everything.
1:46:49 Thank you.
1:47:18 Yeah, that's what it is. Development.
1:47:48 That's the best word. I don't know.
1:48:17 Thank you.
1:48:46 So we need a completion of the EIR.
1:50:07 I think both of those are. Well, we're going to try to complete the hour, and we start construction, and then we're completed. So what needs to happen between the business plan and the completion plan? I don't know.
1:51:25 So we know there's a certain amount of funds available. We just don't have to fund that. We're doing it. We're doing it.
1:51:54 Thank you.
1:52:01 The other hand, if you have two ones and we're driving, why isn't it none? We're a team when we work together. We get stoned for being late or early, I hope. But that is to keep it, you know, so it's all for six minutes. That's why there needs to be. Propose a strategy for land ownership and financing housing options. Should that make me think you know how much it is? I think there is a funding plan, who knows for nine minutes. That would be on at any single point.
1:52:30 We're going to do all this.
1:53:00 Try and get to step six in the next few minutes if you can. Ten minutes.
1:54:19 This is, we need this in place for 2018. The whole site.
1:54:45 We're trying to get the timing of it.
1:55:15 Thank you.
1:55:36 So I think we could probably get an interesting time.
1:56:06 Thank you.
1:56:28 I would encourage you to have them done. Make them milestones. Don't put initiatives and initiatives in portals. It's actually... Put done votes.
1:57:26 Thank you.
1:57:34 Oh, good evening.
1:58:03 Thank you.
1:58:18 Go ahead and create your... Okay.
1:59:58 I think that would have multiple pieces. That's actually Q5. Q6 would actually be the end goal.
2:01:13 Should we just say Q3 and Q4?
2:01:43 I think, let's say, you know,
2:02:12 Thank you. Thank you.
2:02:28 Thank you.
2:02:57 Oh, that's victory. This is the communications role of bottom. I don't know if there's any particular. But the thing here, we have 22 different websites out there.
2:03:18 I think it's down here. But I'm not sure. I think the communication messaging on the bottom. This one will be fine.
2:04:24 Whatever. Yes, you're right. It should be a dynamic.
2:04:54 Yeah, you got two. Five. Okay. Six.
2:05:23 Thank you.
2:05:40 No, no, we were, we were displays.
2:05:42 Oh, you, we saw, okay.
2:05:43 If these Beginnings and Councils already signed off, are we, we need to get together.
2:05:52 I think so, if we'll attempt these, I Host-
2:05:58 Yeah, I think the angle of that, we need to try to.
2:06:02 These were actually counts of how do we actually fund theny of theño community.
2:06:06 We have my best equipment there.
2:06:07 So we'll just keep moving.
2:06:09 Thank you.
2:06:37 Thank you. Thank you.
2:06:48 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:07:17 Thank you.
2:07:31 So the first line says that strategy for land ownership. I think what they were trying to do was that should be one item.
2:07:53 Some of that can be private, public. That's very specific. This becomes an amendment. That's in, you know, this cover was the ALM.
2:08:06 Well, this should be capital, I think the first one is high digital," and the next one is going to be high digital," and the next one is going to be high digital?"
2:08:22 I think that actually works, and then larger thicker people.
2:08:31 You've seen a lot of front-loading going on, which makes me feel a bit rather slow.
2:08:36 When you guys report it out, I'll ask that question.
2:09:05 And the group will also weigh in.
2:09:19 So do you want to lay these all together?
2:09:43 Thank you.
2:10:13 I don't know, I think they're like the first particular kickstart. All these go into Q1.
2:10:42 Here, John, we'll just go pick at these. I'll put these up.
2:12:40 That has to come to the town to get the products.
2:13:09 They are going to be hired by the mountain. And that's the kickoff. But that's a separate, that's a separate car. It was over here. So let's come back to that with a couple of other kickoffs.
2:13:37 What else is the kickstart? So Batman is charging. Are we going to authorize the construction? Authorize the construction parking.
2:13:47 The more you can use decisions, the better.
2:15:00 I mean if you go back up there
2:15:30 Okay.
2:15:59 Okay, now we'll just explain.
2:16:28 Boushka. Boushka. Boushka. Boushka. Boushka. Boushka. C'est vrai. C'est très vrai. C'est très vrai, Québécois.
2:16:44 Thank you.
2:17:11 Would it be authorized counsel to? Counsel authorizes the hiring of a firm. The college is contracting? Yes. To begin.
2:17:32 I'm so glad that somebody has one of these consequences. What does that mean?
2:19:46 Excellent. We got three things in victory.
2:20:15 We'll talk to your wife. I'm going to adjust it as they develop strategies. I put that again. It comes after the math, right? I think my point is we have to develop strategies while we're doing the math.
2:20:39 To make sure that the strategy is working together, investment will be so bad. Right, that's actually probably going to run it too. Yeah, probably. We have things that we have plans on, but they're not even, nobody would ever invest. I probably think it's done in Q2.
2:20:53 Thank you.
2:21:15 Okay, so discuss what we will celebrate.
2:21:35 Okay, so you guys are all the way done. We just don't have victories yet. We're working on that. We're working on victory, okay. Does that go on though?
2:22:03 I would say that's a good number. Well, I mean, if you put up there a million dollar budget. So right underneath the...
2:22:23 That's what I'm always thinking. It's how much are you going to get from leverage when it comes to housing. If we're going to get $20 million and we need to put up two, I think that would be good. Oh, yeah, I asked. They put it over there. So it's not going to be our money, per se.
2:22:52 I'm working with a group right now.
2:23:08 So, looking at the server sites and looking at the performa for developing technical analysis, that we have viable performa and investment strategy for . Well, I think .
2:23:37 Okay, so we're just waiting on victory. And there could be one or two, or you decide. There could be a few. They don't have to horizontally line up, is what I'm saying. It's your discretion.
2:24:06 Yeah, stuff like that. Good. Not talking about it. Not planning on it. Cars are driving in and out of the parking lot. Story map.
2:24:40 Done. So let me challenge you guys. Story map complete. Is complete inspiring? Or if it was complete and it was in use, you know, maybe that's what you want to get to.
2:25:06 Yeah, it's displayed in council chambers and seeds all discussion. Yeah, yeah. Because we could complete all kinds of stuff. Okay.
2:25:38 Where did the rest of your group go? Let's get everybody back together. I haven't thought about us not leaving until 2 o'clock. Oh, you did? At noontime? Yeah. Okay.
2:26:02 You are? Yes. Okay. So, let's get everybody back. These guys are getting one more. Are you guys done on big training?
2:26:30 Okay. All right. So if we have reasonably everybody back, so we're going to go in this order. These were designed in a logical order. So you can either have a spokesperson or a spokes group. You can either have one person speak or just have your whole group come up. We want you to do...
2:27:01 Tell us first what your big idea was and what was important about that. Tell us what your victory elements are. Second, then go back to your kickstarts and then tell us the logic of your sequencing of actions. And if you've changed out cards or you've modified things, kind of explain it to us. Because remember, we did all these in groups.
2:27:31 So we want to make sure that as a working group, you get the whole group to sign off on all these changes. And I'm going to editorialize throughout. John, are you going to kick us off here? Yes, thank you very much. Go for it. So this is the Enhance Our Recreation-Based Economy Group. That gaggle of misfits over there. Some have already left the room. They just couldn't take it. So with our big idea, we spent a fair amount of time talking about
2:28:02 The naming of a recreation-based economy really defining what it was. And Michael Armando pointed out that Michael Ward made a very good suggestion that really helped us frame this thing, which is that we're wrestling with a healthy, sustainable economy, visitation, recreation experiences. How do all these things fit together? Michael Ward pointed out that visitation is the currency of our economy that drives all this stuff. So from a...
2:28:29 A higher level, obviously, we want to have a sustainable, healthy economy, but visitation is the currency that makes all that possible. And the visitation is fueled by experiences, primarily recreation experiences, that inspire the visitation that creates our currency, that gets us to a good, sustainable, healthy economy. So that's where we came up with that. So I'm going to skip over here to the victories and kind of work backwards.
2:28:58 For special events in the summer of 2017, we have special events being implemented based upon a special event strategy that will get started. It's getting started in this quarter right now. The air terminal is on target for 30,000 enclaimants. The terminal is funded with a construction date set, and there are partners involved in this terminal. There are stakeholders that we may not know of now that are involved in.
2:29:28 Working backwards to some victories. John, real quick. Sure. Is the special event strategy implemented? Yes. So the events that happened in the summer of 2017 are a result of that strategy. I'm just suggesting I had the word implemented. Sure. I'll do it while you keep going. Okay. So working backwards, another victory is a tourism economic study that
2:29:57 Will tell us from an analytical academic perspective exactly how our economy functions is completed in the second quarter. From that, MLR and MLT are using that analysis to now figure out MLT is looking out into the world. What is it the visitor looking for? What is it that we have? MLR is then working to implement those needs on the ground so what we're marketing we can deliver.
2:30:25 But that needs to follow from, that's a sequencing question that needs to follow from that study. So now I'll go back over here to the Kickstarters. The engagement with air service stakeholders regionally has already kind of started, but that's an engagement process that will lead to hopefully some funding commitments and some buy-in and a partnered effort to come up with a reliable regional air service. The broadband
2:30:55 Advocacy and integration into the community. We took Chamber out of this and took to the Broadband Task Force to get that stood up so that becomes a body that's really, that's where this lives, the implementation and the integration of broadband into our local economy and looking at it as well. This is established clarity about the local economy, includes as key assets and drivers, that is this study over here.
2:31:23 So that, we're going to kickstart getting that study done. That study happens in the second quarter. The special event strategy is underway now, but that's, we put that up as a kickstarter, so we've got to get that thing going. And then, should I go to the individual quarters? Yeah, just, if you can kind of, by quarter, give us the logic scheme that you can put together. So the, this is, this is funding for
2:31:54 Internal major capital projects. We changed this to be MLR focused. This is not something where MLT is looking at in the world of trying to find people to help raise money and build capital projects. Working on MLT exploring new markets with the air service. This is something MLT and MSA, they're already working on this. There's questions about technical viability of certain types of aircraft.
2:32:22 That's already underway with these discussions that MLT and the town will figure out how that's all working. The terminal strategy to raise the capital and to activate the stakeholders is really an ongoing effort, but it's very much engaged between the first quarter over to the third. So there's a lot of things going on with this, but it's straddling these quarters like this. And then in the third quarter,
2:32:48 We spent a lot of time talking about whether we're revealing or optimizing flight scheduling. We came up with optimizing because it kind of includes a lot of analysis, a lot of different things that go into that. There's a tech or there's a program component coming out of Air Alaska that will happen in the third quarter. So that's why that's there. And that's about it. Did I miss anything, team? Are you happy with the presentation? Absolutely. Good job. Thank you.
2:33:19 So for the victory for the on target for 30,000 claimants or else under the terminal issue for the dollars, is that the bottom one there, the terminal funded, whatever that says? Yes. So my question there would be at the end of this 18 month period, do we have an additional million dollars in the kitty? Yes. The terminal is funded. Okay, so that case, that means you got $5 million in 18 months.
2:33:49 Identified and committed. That means that... I'm just trying to narrow that down to a hard thing we can measure. It's... The hard thing to measure is a new terminal is funded and a construction data set. Okay, so... The dollar amount isn't clear because that may be a moving target, but that's the thing. But in 18 months, have we set aside dollars, a measurable dollar amount... Yes. ...for that funding and what is that number that we're targeting to set aside? I don't know what the number is, but we have...
2:34:19 Funded it. Okay. Well, the funding amount is $5 million. We didn't talk about the $5 million. We didn't talk about all $5 million. Yes, Michael, at the end of 18 months, do you have an additional $1 million, $1.5 million, $2 million actually set aside for that funding? Otherwise, we're saying it's funded, but we... Okay. Yeah, I mean, I think we're... What is the threshold? I think we're more going on the mechanism that the funding will be in place with stakeholders, with all... I mean, that's kind of our discussion. Do you have a dollar amount that we need to put up? I'm just...
2:34:48 For me, for that victory to try and say, look, we have X dollars in the bank, it's more measurable than it's funded with, we don't know what we're shooting for. Is there a dollar amount we should put that? That's kind of, I don't know if you guys had to debate, so that's why I'm asking. That dollar amount's 5 million. Yeah. We won't have that in the bank in 18 months. Yeah, but yeah, we're going to have 5 million in 18 months. Yeah, when you think about it like that, maybe it's not an achievable victory goal. Again, I'd suggest, as you said, the funding mechanism is in place because there's...
2:35:15 A variety of pieces that are going to come together for that, but you've identified all those pieces, where they're coming from, and when you'll have the cash. You may not have... If you actually have 5 million in cash in 18 months, I'm not sure that's really... It may be financing tools. What I'm looking for is if we start to look at the dollar numbers through all of these, it's going to be that competing... I want to go spend a million dollars on a transit hub, but actually that should be going to the terminal as the first priority in the short term. So we're going to have competing elements there that...
2:35:44 Walking through this really helps because I'm going to also get requests in town. We're going to go put a million dollars into a trail system. No, we're going to put it into this capital project. So are we going to be able to see the competing needs for resources as we walk through this? That is the budget resource question. How do we decide between A and B? Yeah, so I just, that's why I'm looking for these hard victories on that, to have a funding mechanism in place of good, and I would probably come back in 18 months, and you have a
2:36:13 An additional million plus in the bank. I had a related question, John. Anyway, so I'm just trying to narrow it down. If the target is five million terminal fund construction date set, is there an earlier date by which that funding needs to actually be identified in order to set a construction date? Is this a difference between securing commissaries and actually setting the construction date? That's a little bit of a technical question, I think, for...
2:36:42 Grady Gann, because we weren't clear what the thresholds actually were. Is there an earlier date by which that funding needs to be secured in order to get the construction date? I think there is, right? Because we're going to have matches along the way. Right, Grady?
2:37:01 That's correct. In the first, say, 18 months to two years, the total outline is going to be about a million dollars and we'll have to have 10% of that. We've already identified that between our entitlements and things, so I'm not sure we need to put that out. So you don't need to put that out. But in terms of the actual construction start, when you authorize the construction contract, you have to have all of them in place. But that doesn't happen until another year after that. It's two and a half years out. Okay, so within this 18 months? Correct.
2:37:29 Yeah, so based on that, within this 18 months, this is fine? So these are fine, because when we get, the environmental document will be complete anywhere from 18 months to 24 months. We don't know that yet. But when it's done, we want to be able to start the process, which means we have a funding mechanism in place, and we have a construction date set. So those are good. I, to change it, I struggle with on target for as being a victory. So.
2:37:58 If we're saying in 18 months 30,000 enclaimants is the goal, why don't we just drop it on target? If enclaimants are based on a calendar year, you're only going to be nine months out of that year. Well, but we're on target now for 30,000. Let's just assume annualized total is an arbitrary point in time, John. So what you want is, if that was the goal, then you want an annualized equivalence. Sure, if it's qualified that way, then it's fine.
2:38:26 You're not seeing the trend, you're seeing the change. That's why I said on target for it. So 30,000 deployments. Gotcha, I didn't understand what you got. You're pacing to 30,000. That's good. Got it. I'm adding annualized. Yes, Joe. I'm just having a little bit of difficulty understanding
2:38:50 Whereas, what we had in the town was a lot broader, is how the victories are all just related to special events and the airport, whereas we had quite a few more things in A through F. Like broadband got started, but there's no victory for it anywhere. What's in the group? Broadband. Broadband. Joe, we kind of thought a lot of stuff was victory, but we just didn't put it all in victory. Oh, okay.
2:39:19 I think we were trying to narrow it down a little bit. All right. Well, in the 18 months, John, did you have any comments on the broadband? A victory in the 18 months? Where should we be in 18 months, John? I hesitate to say I would qualify that. I think a victory, if the kickoff is to have the broadband implementation efficacy live somewhere, because Ryanair doesn't live in a place that's effective.
2:39:51 We figured, okay, that's a victory to get started with that so we know that it lives somewhere. But I wouldn't know how to quantify what the victory would be in 18 months. It would be so speculative that it would... Here's how I would think about it. This is a question. Enhanced broadband opportunities for visitors, residents. It's a statement, but it's actually a question. How to provide enhanced broadband. What we don't want it to still be in 18 months is an open question.
2:40:26 We want to have moved the needle somewhat in attempting to resolve. One way to do that is, you know, we're overusing the words strategies and business plans. But without some type of go-to-market plan for broadband, we'll still be debating how this community keeps up with other communities. Well, you could say that the broadband, now that we say it's going to live with what we say, it's going to live with the broadband task force, that group can establish
2:40:55 In Q1 establish a march to victory with metrics that we can have. So the key here is the broadband task force. Is that referenced up there? Yeah, it's script. I'd like to make it a score because I'm going to talk to someone. Yeah. So I'm going to actually move this.
2:41:26 Into here. And everything's front loaded. I made the same comment over and over. Is there... So this is actually a good sign to me that as a community you are front loading your expectations. I was mentioning to a couple people that did a similar exercise in a different town recently and that people were back loading everything which told me they were totally afraid of their own commitments and actions. You are not.
2:42:05 What do you guys think, Art?
2:42:36 If we can get special events, complainants, and terminal funded, so very specific actions, it's Joe's question, so other things, we call that broadband. You want to update and implement an economic vitality plan and strategy, for example. So that, if you're looking for that kind of a thing, we talked about having that being used.
2:43:02 In the town's 17-18 budgeting process. Oh, so we need that gap. Yeah, so that would be, that would be 16-17. No, 17-18. So you're a year and a half away of doing that. Yeah, because it'll get, the study gets done this summer, so a year from now, it's being used. March for your 17-18 fiscal year budget. So you're, yeah. But you want it done by the quarter that ends 6-37. We want it done by 16-7.
2:43:34 Q5. Yeah. Can this study get done timely to your current budget cycle? I don't think so. For next fiscal year. 16, 17? The economic vitality plan? It has to be done by Q5. Which is the, yeah, 630, 17. Yeah, 630, 17. Yeah. John, that could be done. Ideally, it should be. That could be done now. That could be done now. That could be done on June. But if.
2:44:04 Well, Dan, if this study, this is a full economic analysis of how our economy functions. Right. Can this be done, completed, and back to cancel in a way that is meaningful to use as part of our budget discussions for the next fiscal year? I don't think it can. Well, not fiscal year study. It's done next fiscal year for the following year. Exactly. So that's why we had it getting done. But you don't have a... I don't see where it's...
2:44:34 Done up there. What I'm looking for is on the board. Yeah, we're going to put it on the board. Okay, so we had as a stick. We had as a kickstarter here, so we get kickstarter here. It's about when it's done, though, right? Yeah, it's Q5. Keep moving. Keep going. So just draw up a card that says completion of that study by Q5. The kickoff of the study is... I'll write a kickoff. So while John's writing the card...
2:45:02 I want to just remind us that last summer we did a series of council meetings to sort out and prioritize these commitments. And the very first commitments, these are not listed arbitrarily. The very first commitment was that they implement an economic vitality plan and study. And we've literally been building an economic universe absent that.
2:45:27 We've been working all the way around it. I can assure you from my own professional work, this is not a six-month project. You could do this in three months. You built rec strats, rec strats one, two, MLR. You did all this stuff over really elongated periods of time. You do not need that amount of time. The data's known. All the data's available. You know what's needed here. But you can't act without that strategy.
2:45:56 Binding all these pieces together. So I would get, I think we need that card, it certainly should inform your budgeting, I think it should inform some of your other capital decisions, should inform your decision making about this, not that investment. So that's your mission. We're going to move this here.
2:46:26 Q3, Q4, Economic Strategy Study. Which one, John? It needs to be done this calendar year. It needs to be done. So that you have time to vet it, discuss it, go through your community dialogue process, and be ready. You don't want to set this late, have that be on somebody's work plan late, and then risk not framing your budget around it. All the stuff that's feeding into something that doesn't...
2:47:00 That's right. That's actually the elephant in the room for me with this whole process. It's a good thing we're calling that out now. Okay. What else? Whole group. What else is missing? Any other refinements? Any other gaps? Any other sort of carryover actions that close the gap between these milestones and these victory elements?
2:47:32 That's what we're really trying to do here. My question would be is on the airport work, I don't know what the airport group's working on this, but by June 30 will we actually have a determination on the aircraft that work here or is that an ongoing work program with the airlines in terms of what do they have, what can the airport handle? Or is that actually done as of June 30 if we know the answer to that question definitively in three months? It's ongoing. I mean, we've been in process with this for months now. Well, that's my question.
2:48:03 Well, it starts, it's, I mean, we put it in as starting now. We didn't put it in. So when does it end there? Yeah, what do you think, John? Because this will look to me like the red flag issue in our workgroup session. Because if, does the airline know when it's going to implement its obsolete fleet strategy? Yeah, pretty good idea. But I was looking for these interview.
2:48:27 We were trying to walk through when does this stuff end versus start. In some cases we have when we start it, but initiating it's going to be a six-month process. So I'm reading that as of 6.30 we would have an answer to that question of which planes will provide sustainable air service. I think we could. 6.10. We're very limited to our options. Well, yeah, I know it's a very, so I'm just asking the question. The technical part of which planes work best here, that's something we can do by June.
2:48:55 Which airlines have the planes and are they willing to bring in here? That's ongoing. That's a different question. That will never end. Okay. Can you guys write that card out then? Give us a June 30th, 17 action point for a fleet replacement. June 30th, 17? 630. 16. 16? Yeah. Is it 16 or 17? It's not going to change another year. It's not going to change another year.
2:49:23 And just give us a 636. Well, it's sitting there, so that's the third one under Q1 is what I was looking at, determining which plane. So that's actually done in June. Yeah, so if that's done in June, we don't need to move forward. Yeah, okay.
2:49:45 I would tend to agree with Joe that, I mean, I know it's difficult to articulate, but looking through taking from A, B, C through F to victory in 18 months, I think the only thing that's really absent is some sort of development of an enhanced process. I think everything else is pretty well articulated now. So if I'm hearing you correct, we'll actually... That's a victory, I think.
2:50:16 E, B, and C are actually all parts of one thing. But C stands out. You could do an economic vitality plan that doesn't focus in very clearly and very sharply on building out your shoulder seasons. Building out your shoulder seasons is the other linchpin. It's the fulcrum for this whole deal here. So this economic strategy study and action plan needs to be...
2:50:48 I've made it one of your three or four top priorities. So the other group is that if the town commitment of 2015 to 2017 says that we're at the 10 months, how come there's not one of those things we're going to do? I'm not going to tell you we're at the 10 months and 18 months. No way to help us. That's 25.
2:51:13 I can't, that would be. But what increment? Well, and I guess that's where I'm confused, is we have it on the commitments now, and then we have it on the 2025. That's a good question. But it's listed on both sides. What's the increment? Jo's question's a good one. What is the increment of million-dollar monthly TOT that we could hit by June of, or September of 2017? Is it, we're at six months? We're already at six months. Can we get to eight months?
2:51:42 I mean, existing strategies. I'm not sure I can give you a number because it's all based on some infrastructure that we don't have. But this is a plan. It's what? It's a plan. And if you don't set the target, then we... But do I plan to have a convention set? I mean, there are a lot of variables that I can't... Are we going to have a great winter? Are we going to have an early summer? But you can't talk yourself out of your planning based on bakeries. You just say, look... Here's...
2:52:10 John, what you want to do is say, I know the uncertainty of that bothers you a lot, but you want to say, where do we want to be, all other things being equal? If we can control what we can control, and everything else remains steady state, where do we want to be? What's achievable under our sphere of influence in 18 months? Seven to eight months at a million plus. Because if we just say, I don't know,
2:52:39 Because I can't control all these variables, we actually don't need any of this. You just don't need any of this. Just go, just keep doing what you're doing. Our closest million dollar month is April did 985 one year, in a good snow year. We're not going to do that this year. So that's the closest one. And June has been successful over the past four years at the risk of winter. So I don't have a month for it. I mean, I can't tell you which one's going to be the next month because it's...
2:53:09 I don't think it's the next month. My question would be is all things being equal right now, are we moving toward a seven to eight month business cycle now that's hitting that million dollars a month for eight months out of the year? I'm not going to say which month it is. We have six. Right. So do we have strategies in the next 18 months to start to push us to seven months or to eight months? I think it depends on what we have for infrastructure and programs. I don't think it's something you can just pick one out of the air. I'm not saying which month.
2:53:34 I'm just saying, can we move to seven months? I think the risk is that you're going to gain in certain months and lose in other months. Like I said, this year, we may lose in June. We may go backwards 20% in June because of snowfall. So as much as June has grown 102% in the last five years, we can go backwards when we have a good winter. Does that mean November goes over? Do we have a great winter? I'm not trying to say the month. We can't, you know, I think we're going to, if we are where we are now,
2:54:05 By 17, it's a very short window. Right. That's not a bad place. That's for the purpose of planning, that's something that's... So what I'm hearing there is we want to maintain the six months of a million plus. Well, there's... Because it's a joke, but there isn't anything that we have in our control that we can cite to say that's going to push it over. Right. If you told me I had a 40,000 square foot convention center in the next six months, I could say, sure, we're going to see another number.
2:54:33 But I don't see the changes that are going to make these numbers move. You know, I don't think there's any risk in any of the six months we currently have of going below a million. Right. But again, the seven busiest month is April. It's high, all-time high was $9.85, but we averaged $700,000 in the five-year average. Right. June is up to $773,000. But for each snow year, it screws June a little bit. Right. September, we've grown to $782,000. But in order to grow another $220,000, that's another one point.
2:55:02 Five million dollars in direct spending and lodging without some catalyst. Okay, so the plan is that you maintain where you are, and then as the other things are happening, then the number goes up and you still make a difference. Well, and that's been the point. In order to get to these, we need to have things fall into place because we have to weatherproof. Because right now, all these months are completely weather dependent. Right. You know, there are very few things that we can say that if it's going to be a long winter, we're going to gain this. If it's going to be a short winter, we're going to gain that.
2:55:30 It's something that, you know, for a convention center takes the weatherproofing into town. So then maybe what we need to do is look at the town commitment level, you know, the focus on growing shoulder months is good and it doesn't have a number in it and maybe that's, maybe victory is, it doesn't need to be stated in here if it's further down in the process. Other years.
2:55:58 Because we're looking at 18 months and we're looking at 9 years, 8 years. Maybe it doesn't have anything at this part. But I don't know how to note that somehow. Here's my perspective. Not to just push you back for no good reason. The community that does not set targets for where it wants to be will not achieve.
2:56:26 Okay, then my card would be to get April, June, or September to consistent $850,000. Perfect. So if you guys could write that card. So, and here's why it's important. You guys have an election in the fall? June. June? Okay, June. How many council seats are up for? Two. Two?
2:56:51 Let's say you have a 40% new council, all due respect to the council members in the room. So in a sense, you're saying, what is the charge that we're handing off to the successor leadership body here? What is our vision for all things being equal, what we think we can achieve? If your economic vitality plan and strategy has in the first paragraph, assuming good snowfall,
2:57:18 Yes, so what you guys are trying to do with all of this is mitigate
2:57:47 Business cycles. You're actually trying to shift the economy in your direction, favorably in your direction. The sum of all these activities are we build a story map and we populate it with real stuff. We add these new amenities. We add this convention center. We align the town services so we're highly efficient and streamlined. That's a victory, right? Yeah, I'm going to stick it right there.
2:58:17 And the sum of all these initiatives gets you to the ability to shift the economy weatherproof. You've used the right word there. You have to weatherproof. They're projecting La Nina for next year. I just was at a NOAA event in Sacramento. The Sierra-wide conservancy is projecting very serious water shortages.
2:58:48 Over the next five years, that's your backdoor way of thinking about snowfall. You're still going to be here. You're still going to be trying to thrive, and these problems are still going to be your problems. So you're trying to literally mitigate the economy. This is actually the most hubristic thing that a community can try to do. Try to actually shift the economy in your own favor, independent of larger trends. That's really what we're trying to create. So don't, you know,
2:59:18 I wouldn't attach people's performance incentives to these numbers, but if you don't have the targets that you can communicate and set those expectations, council can't go, do we fund this or fund this? If I'm council, I want to say, which investment gets us more quickly to this because visitation is our currency without which none of the rest of this is achieved anymore?
2:59:47 So we get down to this really simple equation. Super simple. Okay. Let's do, develop comprehensive community planning. I guess I'll be the speaker on that. Go for it. Okay. Team number two, the number one in your heart, right here. And thank you, Michael, for that part, because I think it's very important to understand that as a community, what we're really...
3:00:26 Develop a comprehensive community plan. For us, we call the kickstart, not kickstart, but the big idea, integrated global community-based vision slash plan to show what investing in Mammoth Lakes means. And by investing, we don't mean just for building hotels, that type of stuff, but also business investment, other types of investment. So it's a wide-ranging investment.
3:00:55 And I want a little quote here. A goal without a plan is just a wish. So we have to have that plan. Our victories, I'll do the same thing that John did. That's a good idea. Our victories are going to get a village parking lot open within the next 18 months and get our story map complete and in use. Our kickstart to do that is...
3:01:27 We have to get counsel to authorize the hiring of a firm to complete what we call the initial story map. We think the story map is a living document. It's going to give us 90% of what we want as a community going forward, but we have to populate that with data as data comes in and what we're going to need. And that's what all this is about in here.
3:01:54 The other kickstart we had was authorization by council to develop a short-term parking solution, which goes together with the victories down here. And then through the next six quarters, we start quarter one as we actually start the story map program. We meet with the group that would actually start putting together this vision story map.
3:02:24 And giving them the current data that we have so that they can start building it, which includes all the different NGO inputs, housing, recreation, ESTA, and tourism. Create a budget for what our parking lot is, which is about $500,000, we're guessing. Q2, we present the story map.
3:02:56 We have stuff that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is going to do.
3:03:31 Housing is going to have data input that they're going to bring to the story map. ESTA will bring some of their information to the story map. You know, whether we need a transit map or one or two to be discussed, financing of housing, business plan and analytics for asset development to link to a community plan, that's all the NGOs. So the other is we...
3:04:03 We agree that our map cost is probably somewhere in the $100,000, our initial map cost is somewhere in the $100,000 to $500,000 range, approximately. Questions for finance? Gaps? I just wonder how some of our studies relate to that tourism and economic study, because we have the idea to gather a lot of data, a lot of preferences, and maybe that's something that we would work together with the tourism and economic study. Yeah, I see a lot of this, like you said, all this kind of flow.
3:04:39 To the extent that an economic vitality study is not just an economic development strategy, but a community development strategy. You know, back in the day, Dan Contest provided this, every community had a separate economic development, community development department. That's really a thing of the past. These are really merged functions. So in fact, I think that strategy should encompass these elements. So that's a good insight. I think we've touched on each one of these.
3:05:14 Yeah, so are the victories compelling? Village parking lot is open. Remind them what, not everybody participated in their work group, why is this important? What was going on in the village parking lot? Well, the reality is we're going to be losing village parking as we know it now. Regardless of whether the current owner of the property opens it up for this year or not, that's going to go away. So we've got to start putting together a plan for that.
3:05:44 Right now, we have the opportunity, based on some property that the town owns, to put a short-term, and we don't know what that really means. Short-term can be, you know, five years, it could be 15 years. But it will start alleviating the parking issues that we have right now. It's not the panacea. I don't think we know what the panacea is until we get into this visioning and how it might also be. But we can actually...
3:06:15 Build somewhere in the neighborhood of spaces, property service lines. We're not going up. It's relatively inexpensive spaces. I think our discussion in the work group is this addresses some workforce challenges, child care, access challenges, and so on. And as Dan reminded us, it doesn't have to be permanent. It can be a short-term solution, and you still preserve some flexibility around the asset itself. And the land asset, if...
3:06:49 You know, it was eventually to be sold. You know, there's not a building on there that would have to be. The story map, complete and in use. We were talking about, you know, it's, I think this connects to your big idea. I would offer that it's not just capital and business investment, it's actually community investment. The sort of active...
3:07:21 Participation by your community members. I mean, this has been one of your challenges. How do we come to a broad enough consensus on doing this, not that, so that the community gets behind it and supports it? The story map gives you sort of a visual representation of all the important decisions about how you use your limited space to co-locate
3:07:49 Housing and Transit, where's the optimal transit locations, if not hub, hubs, you know, or mini hubs. How do you make sure, do you do it downtown? Every community in the country right now is struggling with this downtown concept, and whereas I personally as a consultant think it's valuable, I also see it having a paralyzing effect on communities because
3:08:17 Getting from here to there looks so daunting. It involves so many political decisions. It looks like budget resources. That's why you have to have the story map so you can start the discussion. And begin to visualize all of it so that you can see it very, very clearly. Anything, I like the distribution cross. You've got activity going. You front loaded. Venturies look good. Kickstarts look good. Any gaps?
3:08:47 Just based on your sense of this. Yeah. I'm just wondering, because we had a parking discussion, we talked about that in the context of a mobility, several larger mobility discussion also. I'm just wondering how, I'm assuming you want to kind of get through this stuff today and then leave maybe those kinds of refinements or those synergies, do that kind of stuff later. Yeah, because what we looked at for that was like coming back, that's when we had this queue for like the transit hubs. How do those connect the community? Right.
3:09:15 We talked a lot about the mapping. How does that connect things? We have an immediate need, but ultimately this stuff, we did talk about how to just move people from in town to outdoors and what are those options, but that comes through the mapping process, planning process. There's a lot of data gathering that we're going to be doing. You have to get that in place and then you can start making some decisions. We have a couple of key short-term issues. Trying to balance those two.
3:09:47 John's ready to build the traffic up tomorrow. Absolutely. Transit. So, John, do our cards reflect what you're wanting to get at there? John? You guys have a five-year, I'm looking at John Helmut actually, because they've got a five-year strategy for transit they're working on, which helps to do some of that, I guess. We don't have any key milestones that need to be plugged in here to hold your respective feet to the group fire here? No? John Wentworth? Yeah. No, I am looking at...
3:10:21 A data development process to get into a holistic, definitive kind of sense of where we're at. That goes into an analysis process to figure out the kind of things that we're doing. I think the five-year thing that Dan's referring to is some very exciting elements in there that I think will feed right into this. Right. That they'll complement it. It could be a good opportunity to have those two things happening at the same time. Can you guys elaborate on financing of housing options being placed in Q6? Yeah.
3:10:53 The issue on that one was at the front end, you're going to be looking at a number of different opportunities where it could go, where do you put housing? There may be other financing pieces that run through that, but kind of a bit broader end-of-game strategy. Do we have, we kick that around for housing from the Shady West to the Mammoth Lakes Foundation property to Setpage Mountain Homes to, it's not just one piece of dirt. So how do you finance housing across the spectrum of this mapping that's probably not going to be a single, okay, we're done.
3:11:22 So we're putting it in Q6. It doesn't mean we may not have some other successes before that. So it's essentially an ongoing. Yeah, but by the, yeah, at the end of the time frame, we're hoping to say, here's our next three or four housing projects that we're envisioning at some level. Well, is that intended to be in place by Q6? The financing strategies would be in place. Yes. So. Okay. I mean, hopefully our story map has fared out a lot of the stuff, you know, where they might reside.
3:11:53 I wonder if we just should use more direct language on that, like maybe write over that a little. Yeah, I'm inclined to want to do the same thing that we kind of did with, you know, terminal funding. Right. It's one thing that we're saying will be done in Q6, that any financing strategy is in place, that financing options are available for discussion. What are we saying will be done?
3:12:27 Because I feel like housing options, if they're ongoing, should more be in Q1 or Q2. I mean, if we're talking about something being funded or a strategy in place, that's a little different. Feed your story map. But actually, on that one, we have the early on doing, it doesn't say housing there, but it's that other half one about strategy. To me, we have the opportunities. We're building the housing element, if you will. This is actually your... It's the financing of it.
3:12:57 Yeah, do we actually, and you might even take that to a strong, or do we have, you know, our first couple projects financed? So do we want to just reword that as like funding strategy in place? Like strategy, I think that's fair. Financing strategy in place for housing. Yeah, I think that's fair. So funding strategy in place. There's a couple places working on housing through this, but...
3:13:24 You know, you could have a funding strategy, but we were talking about it earlier with some of the changes in that right now with cap and trade and other issues. It's a very dynamic market right now for us. Jennifer, what should this say? Well, I think that that piece there was specific about future projects. For future projects. Well, based on what comes out of the story map.
3:13:57 Because we're all not sure where we're putting housing, right? Where are we putting people? We have land dedicated, but we don't have commitment to that. So that's down the road. Some of the things are looking at things that could happen right away. And that's how I see it. As the housing person, that's how I see it. Can we modify this to say that? Okay, in place?
3:14:27 Housing, winning strategy in place is what I had written for it. And really, when you get there, you're going to look at a project when it comes to the table because financing is changing all the time. I tried to illustrate that here. Well, some might be on leasehold. And the goal there was this isn't just affordable housing, this is housing. Tax credit dollars. Change, right. Good point.
3:15:03 Any other call-outs for this comprehensive community plan? If not, Shields? Nice job. All right. Let's do the third one. We have pizza coming in 12 minutes. Let's get through the third and fourth one, and we'll step back and look at it as a whole while we meet. Okay. I guess I just got volunteered. All right.
3:15:39 So I'll kind of follow the same strategy. We were enhancing amenities serving residents and visitors. So we looked at what is really the big idea. And we came up with to be the best Alpine recreation destination in the country or world. So let me slip that in. But, you know, basically enhancing our amenities services, what we've already talked about, if we develop a plan for these amenities.
3:16:07 That it serves our recreation-based economy. Our victories, you know, we tried to really tease things out and be as tangible as possible. So our victories include the completion of the Park West project, you know, by the end of Q6. We kind of threw the Outdoor Performing Arts Center in there, but they did it July.
3:16:33 2018, so it doesn't really fall into Q6, but we put that up there as a placeholder. And then the development of 20 miles of new trails as well as the implementation of a maintenance strategy on existing trails, so those are done by Q6 as well. Completed, yeah. We took the word refine and really ran with that.
3:17:03 Most other people use the existing cards and put them up here. We kind of use the verbiage from the existing cards to build out a whole new set of refined cards. So we need to do a couple of things to kickstart those victories, one of which would be produce business plans and secure capital funding to implement our priority projects. So those include five things right now, which are the completion,
3:17:33 So those are kind of the business plans that need to be produced and we need to secure capital funds to implement those five projects.
3:17:55 Construction and completion of the Trails End Park into Q2. So that's already funded. That's already allocated. That should be able to be completed by the fall. Did you have that for a victory also? Sure. I think that's a nice tangible groundbreaking. Okay. Yeah, we can put duplicate and victory. Okay. Trails End Park. Sounds good. I think it's a victory. You know, that was really kind of how we...
3:18:25 We worked with combining items A and B, the siding of new trails and community amenities, and we're going to kind of go through and tease those out, but also the implementation and strategic plan for investment of R and U. And then the bottom two are kind of in conjunction, Mammoth Lakes interests are reflected in the Indian National Forest Plan and participate in the creation of the Sustainable Recreation Program. So we said we need to work.
3:18:52 Effectively with partners to manage recreation assets for the benefits of the community, which includes stewardship, access, maintenance. We also need to participate in the creation of a sustainable recreation program. And then kind of moving on to get to a victory of the Park West project, we lined out things by quarter. So we need to produce a business plan for the facility.
3:19:20 Then we need to Park West project funding is secured by quarter three. We also need to complete the design work for the Park West project by quarter three. By quarter four, we have the completion of the environmental work for that project. And then construction occurs in queues five and queues six to get us to victory. So we kind of lined out each thing by quarter by quarter.
3:19:52 And really effectively, except for Trails End Park, which we have completed by Q2, that's really the same set of strategies for each of those. So if we want to put the Outdoor Performance Arts Center completed by 2018, we first need to start with a business plan and then go really through essentially the same steps, secure funding, design work, environmental work, and then construction. So we kind of ran out of time, so we just said that...
3:20:21 For all those goals, there's kind of a placeholder for that. We'll apply to the same framework across the board. The same framework across the board, yeah. In Q1, we need to identify and secure funding for existing trail development. We already have some, but we just need to, like, iron that out a little bit. Then we need to cite 100 miles of new trails, because that's our 2025 goal. So it starts with citing it.
3:20:51 Concurrently, we're running with a maintenance program of our existing trails, so they're kind of two separate deals. I think that's pretty much all of it. I'll let Gary talk a little bit about this one, but we did go through and identify a couple of gaps that we just wanted to highlight.
3:21:18 You know, for the MAC specifically, that is very much of that is dependent on an outside partner, so they need to develop the project and the business plan, and we're still waiting on that stuff from the foundation. For the Outdoor Performing Arts Center, we noticed a gap that we seem to be running up against this need for Forest Service participation in a lot of cases, so we need to deal with that.
3:21:46 And we probably have a necessary funding partner that is an existing gap. And then the third one that we identified is, you know, for these items, C and D, we struggled with identifying milestones to kind of tease that out. So I know you had some thoughts on that. But these are kind of the two that we can maybe discuss further. What else am I missing?
3:22:12 So, Gary, do you want to maybe talk about this and Michael can talk about this a little bit? So, obviously, we have to raise a lot of capital. We have to look at private-public partnerships. And at the moment, I think what we desperately need is a funding direction of some sort, whether that is particular to MLR or preferably someone who could oversee all the projects. I think we need more of a powerhouse to do that. We can't really rely...
3:22:40 I think this is actually a really signature idea. If you were an organization, let's say you were one nonprofit instead of four engineers in a town by itself in the eastern Sierras, you would actually, and you wanted to do big things in big ways, you wouldn't have
3:23:11 Your board members and a few staff, in addition to their full-time duties, going out trying to raise the very large amounts of capital, you actually dedicate some resource time that is not conflicted with other duties and functions. So I think what Gary's teed up here, whatever you call a funding broker, somebody whose job it is to essentially, that you might pay on a performance basis.
3:23:41 That somebody whose job it is to actually put the capital together to fund these projects or to maximize all of the streams. Now your NGOs are set up to be the optimizers of particular funding for particular needs, but I wonder if in fact you're not operating with fairly slim capacity across all those NGOs, very slim, and the part of the capacity
3:24:10 That doesn't stand out for me very apparently is this capacity. How is this going to get done? I think the National Wounded Warrior Center is probably an interesting parallel. You know those details better than I do, but they're trying to do a big thing. They're trying to raise $25 million for a National Wounded Warrior Center. And I think as they got along that process, they quickly realized if they're going to try and raise that kind of money, they need to outsource that piece of it. Yeah, there's a professional.
3:24:40 I think that's the distinction here, whether that's an in-house or contract or connection to all those different NGOs. Kathy Copeland's the executive director. She has a lot of other work that she's doing and found that she needed to go out towards a professional. She is a force in nature. But even her. Even her, exactly. But it's a collective deal. There's no question about it. We've got out professionally.
3:25:10 So do you have this existing capacity and capability right now to support this whole wall map? I think that's what they're framing here. The answers, no. We might have some comments towards that in our municipal services one. Okay. So let's come back.
3:25:35 So what did you add here? Trails and park completion. Throw it on victory, yeah. Q2. Well, it's in the victory. It's the victory. It's going to be completed in Q2, but it's okay. We'll celebrate the victory. Double it up. So let's, when we get back to budget, we're going to come back to budget, so let's come back to this. What else do you guys think, John? So that is a couple of points. In no particular order.
3:26:05 The Park West project, I think it's going to be very important for the final, whatever the victory is, that we're very clear about what the expectation is. Because the whole community center, everything's not going to be done by that day. I'll just caution us to make sure we're very clear about what that expectation is. So people would say, oh, I don't know, maybe a candle will be done by that day. Let's set them low. We definitely discussed that as a group.
3:26:34 You know, does that include any sort of playground expansion? Does that include two complementary facilities, one facility? I mean, I would open that up to the group. I have my own personal opinion on that, but I agree it would help to articulate it. We discussed it and we weren't really comfortable drawing that out, you know, out of the gate. That makes sense. Just a set of expectations, everybody's comfortable with it.
3:26:59 Well, before you go on, since you teed it up, the question is, what does the word completion mean? Right. Yes, right? And where do you want to set the bar? And that's your, you know, that's aspirational. So you can set the bar at a completely realistic low bar level, or you can simply define completion in a very specific word. Well, we need to get like that. Yeah. Well, I think that there's a lot of conversations that I've had with people.
3:27:28 I think it's important for us to set an expectation that we can publicly say, we'll have this done.
3:27:56 And certainly from a council perspective, we're going to hold staff and deliver what that expectation is. And so that it's a community building kind of an exercise. It's like, well, look, guys, we said we were going to do this, and it actually got done. And I think that that's an important component of this particular project. Well, you know, I would say from my personal perspective with both council and MLR, I don't think we've really developed the...
3:28:22 Funding and strategy necessarily around the playground component. That was more put in for EIR purposes. But we have had discussions both financially and as a council about the complementary facilities being done together by that date. So I'm certainly comfortable with those two as a victory. Maybe the third can be set off to the side a little bit as far as the playground component.
3:28:51 I'd say the first two. So maybe what you need to do in Q1 is to find what completed on that Park West meets. Q1, you can find it. So what I'd suggest, first on trails in just real briefly, with the possible exception of the delivery of the pavilion, that's a Q1. We, you know, it's not a huge goal, but we expect to finish that before July 1st.
3:29:19 What about the pavilion? The pavilion will be ordered. It may be in before that. It may be a week later. I mean, it's going to be so close. We really think we can get it all done by July 1st. So I'd move it to Q1 to make sure we stretch on the goal. Okay. Again, if we're three days off, if we're four days off, don't leave this up. But the point is, we want to set a goal, and we're telling staff, let's get this done. Let's do it now. Okay. That's first. Second on Park West.
3:29:46 I would suggest you add a Q1 for that for approving the site plan itself. And because there's nothing in there that says approve the site plan and initiate the environmental thing, that's a big milestone for that project. Can we just add it to Q1? We have something. What's in Q1 right here? Yeah, the second one down. What's in Park West for Q1? Let's write one up. Park West Q1 is really approving the site plan and initiating the environmental.
3:30:13 To that, you also might want to consider giving direction to staff, MLR, whoever, that the community center needs to happen to go get the money for it. In other words, that decision really hasn't been made yet. It certainly has been stated it's a high priority project, but there hasn't been direction to say, okay, go get that money. And that should be a Q1. For the community center.
3:30:42 The direction hasn't been given, but the discussion's been had. Right, but a Q1 milestone should be okay. We'll do it. On the environmental and the final design for Park West, I would flop those Q3, Q4. The environmental really is a late Q3. See, this is right under Q4, completion of environmental work. So you want completion in Q4?
3:31:11 The completion of the environmental work is in Q3. Move that to your right, Michael. There you go. And move the one right above that to the left. Because you really need to finish the environmental work by the end of the year in order to move into the final design. But how can you have the environmental work done without the design work done? See, the Q1 is that site plan. And that site plan in the project description leads to the environmental work. And that's Q1.
3:31:37 We were stuck on the facility line because we haven't really. So the process is. So is this just useless then? No, no, that has to be done before you can bid the project. So leave it right there. That's fine. Now the only suggestion I'd make in terms of. I'm not following you. Okay. So the process is this. We come to Town Council hopefully April 20th. Here's the site plan. We want to now request direction.
3:32:06 To do the actual project description and start the environmental process. We then finished the environmental process by Q3, by the end of Q3. We moved into final design and we did something as soon as we can. And by something I mean we are still committed to getting that rink up by Halloween, okay? The community center, depending on what's going into it, will take longer to design.
3:32:33 We may be building the exterior wall so that it's going to happen all at once, but we may not be able to finish the community center part. It's just a longer construction period and there's a lot more intensity. So that's how you can bifurcate that victory. The victory is the rink, the multi-use facility is operational in October. The community center, you know, you might still be inside the building, you're going to be painting, you're going to be doing things inside the building. So that's the process.
3:33:01 We can drop all this into GAM charts so that you then have effective decision dates and trigger dates for council staff. And we're bringing that to council on April 20th, the whole plan for, okay, this is how it has to happen, using the decision plans. I'd like you adding the sort of co-marriage of decision and a large trigger. And from a full first step, we're ready to commit that we can open a community center by Halloween. I just said, I said, rink is functional, community center is constructed.
3:33:30 Okay. Exactly. So that's what, anyway, I think that captures the pieces to make sense. I like you're bringing a stretch mindset. So a couple other things. We're entering into a period with the Forest Service where we have a... Yeah, and so I'm interested from a GAP perspective, a financing perspective, who's going to be responsible for the advocacy work necessary for the forest plan revision?
3:33:59 Developing the Sustainable Recreation Program and the OSV NEPA. I just, I, I just. That's what that is. Yes. Yeah. It's important. I just don't know if, I don't know if you've addressed, you know, where that's going to live, how we're going to pay for it, how we're going to engage with it. I think, yeah, Michael was going to kind of double. Yeah, I think you just teed it up. I mean, this is running coincidence. So the DEIS for Indio Natural Forest is about to be released, and that kicks in the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaboratives certified.
3:34:28 Corridor-wide role, but what you've been trying to do through this process is make sure Mammoth's recreation-based economy is reflected in the final management maintenance plan for Inyo National Forest, in particular because you want the connectivity to trails and so on between your investments and their investments, what you maintain and what they maintain.
3:34:57 Where you share or overlap and so on. So John's question properly is who will own this? Within this, within all of us. Because if I recall correctly, I don't feel like we had, John and I both worked on this for a long time and I don't, I never felt, we didn't actually post any sessions in Mammoth. We went to Bishop and Jude Lake and
3:35:26 Lee Biden and so on. I never felt like we actually had a strong Mammoth Lakes presence. We had participants that wasn't the same thing. So we weren't overtly making the connections. And I think the other part of that is the sustainable recreation term, which you've heard bandied around a lot, like Dan and I have talked about, getting out to all of you, it's a nice little seven or eight page document. But this is more...
3:35:53 Even though it says recreational title, it's about a lot more than that. It's about the roads, it's about the culverts, it's about the transportation infrastructure, it's about whatever they do that we have an interest in, it's about putting together a program so we work effectively with that. And again, it goes back to that question of how we do that. It's an overall program. Yeah, anything the Forest Service does. So it says recreation, but it's...
3:36:20 Anything that they do would fit into that policy document coming out of Washington, D.C. And it's very important that we figure out who's going to own that and how we're going to do this. What are your thoughts on this? I mean, Dan has a role as a town manager at a relationship level. MLR could be a participant because it's a recreation strategy framework.
3:36:49 You've actually, each of your NGOs, perhaps less housing, but as to so on, you have connectivity to this. You may need a mini task force, an ad hoc task force that's representative of your larger body to participate in this process. It'll run you by really fast. Yeah, you know, that's an overall plan, right? And that's what I look at.
3:37:19 Our story map being that overall plan that all of these other things kind of fit into and, you know, how they all kind of mesh together. You know, we have specifics in here, you know, the Muff and Community Center. I think it's important that those things are integrated into the overall plan. Yeah, I would even go further, though, she'll see the management of maintenance plan for Indian National Forest.
3:37:50 Is their story map aligned with your story map? And you just want to make sure that your story map values find their way into their story map plan. I think, Mike, your suggestion about an ad hoc task force is probably the best way to do that. I think maybe we can... I would just, yeah, if you throw that up there, I'm just going to say that same thing. It's a town takes to leave the task force. The task force has to involve other people outside the town. Very collaborative. Could you guys generate our...
3:38:20 A card like that, so an ad hoc, international forest, recreation strategy, task force, town as lead. Should we need an acronym for that? One other point is that from the economic development side, we talked about a relationship between MLT and MLR, basically around product development.
3:38:47 A lot of the projects we've got right now are coming out of municipal stuff. They're easily kind of R&U funded, and so that's all moving forward. But I think we need to have some discussion. This is tied to the economic analysis report, how the economy works, which you put a gold star on up there. As soon as that gets done, that's going to flow right into product development. And at that point, the MLT, MLR conversation starts happening in earnest about to inform our amenity base.
3:39:17 To start prioritizing where we start to invest. So our investments are bringing resources back to the community. And that's going to be very important. And I don't know how that fits in all this, but that's something we should be getting into in the next six months. Because we're going to have to make decisions about capital investment that are going to return dividends to the community. And I appreciate that we're pulling all this together to do it, but that's going to be in front of us pretty soon.
3:39:45 I think your economic strategy and storing that together needs to find those decisions. Right. And that's all going to come together. One last point I've got is that there are going to be a bunch of things coming out of the Recreation Summit that just happened this last weekend that are things that should be in line, on the ground next winter. And I'm not sure how that
3:40:15 How to get that in here, but I think that these are things that will affect the winter recreation experience. Is that D for us, Colin? That was, I think, we were looking at D and we kind of wrote it in the Kickstart. The one that we wrote maybe fit into that? Correct. Because it kind of speaks to that a little bit, doesn't it? Yeah, maybe add in. Yeah, something like that. We kind of looked at it a little broader, right, than just kind of the International Forest, so we kind of tried to tie in.
3:40:45 You know, all the programs and the partners it takes to kind of implement. That was kind of our strategy there. So, I think that fits. So, John, do we need a Q4 follow-up to this? So, you may anticipate the original summit as a development opportunity? Well, just the recommendations coming out of that, we're going to have to get those funded this year so that on the ground makes winners.
3:41:15 That's kind of why we rewrote this a little bit, because we felt that participation specifically with the Indian National Forest Plant was a little bit too narrow. So this idea basically says we're going to participate in the creation of a sustainable recreation program for the community, which includes this plus others. It includes the story map, it includes the economic vitality plan, it includes the recreation summit, like all those are informing documents to help engage with it.
3:41:43 You're right. The council, you guys essentially approved these priorities and these commitments. You could flip these and make that the broader context and make that the one. Right. It's only Q1, Q2. Because we talked also when we talked with John about the MLR-MLT connection. I'm pretty confident that between the funding resources that MLT has, he can do whatever he's got to do to make things work. MLR is pretty constrained by R&U.
3:42:11 And I think as we start getting into these things, we may need to be thinking about to ensure that the other partner of this has got the capacity to make these things happen, to look at the resources and make sure that we can deliver these things. That may just be a gap we have to get to when we get into specific things, because I think we're doing a good job of stewarding the measures of R&U to make sure that they're being used as the voters intended. We may have some needs that are beyond that.
3:42:39 So you guys actually addressed this in your group. There was a work group recommendation to address R&U constraints on strategy, and you guys removed that language and changed it. What was your thinking here? Completion of the measure of R&U strategy. Don't we have an R&U strategy? It's in the process of being completed. It came out of an MLR to complete the strategy document, how that gets allocated and funded. Yeah, we said that it should be completed by QTIS. So just completed by that. So is that consistent with your thinking?
3:43:09 Correct. Yes. No, I just said the two different things, the constraints of R&U, meaning we have to find ways of getting away from that so we can leverage funds in a different manner, whereas the strategy was so that we could allocate funds to the events that we're going to start applying in the next summer. Yeah, the R&U funds were intended to VC funds. But you come back at that whole fundraising discussion and other gaps for that, how do you end up financing stuff?
3:43:40 Those two funds are not legally allowed to be useful. That's what the constraint was. Right. As we come back to your budget resources. It's constraints versus opportunities. Okay. Anything else on this area? All suggestions? Nice job. Last one. You want to get the piece and then we'll do the working session? Yeah. Let's try and
3:44:12 Let's try and finish by one o'clock, huh? Let's go to two. Enter your seats! You guys want to grab your seats so we can finish up? Grab your seats, take them away.
3:44:47 Thank you, Michael. Get out that whip. Get out that mayoral whip. Okay, so we were affected municipal services and we really focused on the service part of that. We added to it a system of responsiveness, which we'll make clear as I go through this. We set our victory as April 1st, 2017. And our victory is that
3:45:20 We are ready to support new projects, developments, et cetera, based on identified council priorities. So figuring that most of what we're going to deal with here is partnership or financial and those things, and those have to happen up front so the other things can actually happen. Our kickstart actually has two pieces.
3:45:44 One was to hire the finance director and the discussion behind that is that right now Dan is town manager is trying to be town manager and finance director and we really need both for the pieces that have to get accomplished. So in the first quarter, which is starting, you know, in a week and a half, our second one is to have an open transparent budget document that's adopted before June 30th, 2016. So in the first quarter there are the pieces that need to be
3:46:13 Finish in order to have that budget. It is revisit the political commitments and in conjunction with the REU, ensure that there's active contracts, meaning nobody's contract is past due for the NGOs with aligned contract deliverables. It is each of the NGO and the town have set up a near term list of potential projects for funding options. And what we mean there is
3:46:42 This year, it looks like there might be some money to spend, and in other years, there might be, is to have things ready. If you remember, when ARRA first came out, Townstaff was able to convince the Forest Service to do the lake basin path because it was shovel ready, and it met their requirements. And we got housing done through ARRA. And we got housing done, yeah. So it's having this list of potentials, or for when there's money available, and say,
3:47:06 Well, if we have money, what would you spend it on? So we can balance all the different things. A council can decide how to spend it. And the final thing is determine how to have all the NGOs use the Granicas to support a meeting space. And incidentally, Esther already said yes to this at our meeting last Friday after it was discussed in the work group.
3:47:26 Awesome. Jo, real quick, would you explain RU to the full group? Reserve for Economic Uncertainties is the reserve that was set up late 90s, early 2000s, and it was just set up as well. We're going to save it for the bad snow years, except it was a policy at that time, or shortly thereafter, to have it be 25% of the budget. You know, okay, 25 sounds good. During the settlement, we said, okay.
3:47:54 Three million looks good, and we're at the three million. And I'll get into that a little bit more when we get four. So that's the RU. And that's all by June 30th because those are all related to having a budget for 16-17. And in the first quarter is determining the town's options to match funding to leverage our capital resources, general funding and all the other ones. So we're thinking that, even so some of you guys put in a little bit later, we're thinking it has to happen in the second, in our second quarter.
3:48:23 That we would identify technology and equipment improvements that add benefit while we're lowering costs. We didn't get all of the owners in here yet. We would identify reserve funds like the REU and identify how and when these funds can be used. In other words, do you have just one big REU or do you specifically say you want vehicle replacement, you want computer equipment replacement, new chairs for suite Z, you know, whatever it might be.
3:48:50 And then finally, decide staffing requirements needed for effective service levels. Is that, you know, get the budget done and then really talk about, so now that we look like things are looking better instead of being scrimped and saved, what does that look like? And then the final piece there, the regional salaries plan, because that has to be an early one and it's already being worked on, but that would be done, so that's everything done by September. By December,
3:49:19 Develop, identify, and market investment methods and opportunities to attract active private capital, and we have assigned that to the town manager because that's what the town manager's job is, is to go out and find the next John Baruch who's going to take old, run-down apartments and turn them into affordable housing or whatever it is. In this second, by December, is partnered with the county to scale or regionalize service strategies at lower total costs. We have the success back there.
3:49:49 County IT also does the town's IT, and it's improved both sets of services. Are there others out there? The other thing to happen there is develop an action plan for determining conversion of existing potential housing inventory, which would be assigned to MLH to get accomplished. In the final quarter, before we get to our victory, is develop, identify, and support infrastructure needs to support revenue growth. That's the roads, the housing, and other kinds of asset development, so that literally on
3:50:18 On the 1st of 2000, April 1st, 2017, everything is in place and has been worked out and so that even though there might be some other projects that are starting to struggle with some of these same issues, once it's all set, then you can be responsive because it's not saying, oh, well, we're going to have to have six months to think about how you would fund this or fund that. It's having the toolbox there so that it's ready to be responsive. That's where our...
3:50:48 So I just want to underscore this point. I really love the insight of this group to connect its big idea and its victory together. So the big idea is that a system of responsiveness moves us past the inertia of endless planning, difficulty making decisions, difficulty achieving consensus, and so on. And they're saying, so what does that system need to look like?
3:51:17 To be responsive when project opportunities come forward. So can we move, it really means, can we move quickly, expeditiously in the direction of our own vision, our own dreams, and so on. So we put these tools in place. So they came up with this really nice project management structure for putting the tools and systems in place to be able to do that. This is really very smart thinking, by the way.
3:51:46 Did I miss anything? So, what do you... I know, we're now in the post-brand, he'll dip. Your blood sugar levels should still be high until you finish the pizza. So, what are they missing? Any gaps? Does the idea of this make sense? From effective municipal services, or as Dan would say, 21st century municipal services?
3:52:15 I would add to that the system of responsiveness, it also becomes a culture of responsiveness in terms of how people embrace it and engage in it. It's a culture change as well as a system change. Yeah. We talked about being responsive and responsible and, you know, several things like that. Somebody can play with the word smithing later. I just like that. But just the whole idea is that unlike that other agency that's close by that isn't responsive, they're saying, hey, we've got the opportunity to be ready.
3:52:46 Me personally, this is what, this is being ready for investment. Strikes me similar to the conversation on funding director. Yeah. You know, when we talk about utilizing the town manager role to attract investment opportunities, is that the best role to do that? Yeah, and we didn't, you know, without having, you know, until we all get together as the group, it's true, it's so.
3:53:18 We haven't really supposed to have been at the part where we assigned everybody, but we were trying to explain it as, you know, one of the things that person does is it's often your economic development is done by your town manager. You know, but fairly recently we had Mark Wardlaw in that position, you know, head of community equity. He was really seeking that type of investment as part of his role, so I just think it's worthy of discussion is, you know, is that a potential gap?
3:53:47 It possibly is, but then I also know that Dan is doing some of that now, but it is a gap of how all of this happens without some kind of a coordinated fundraising, because, you know, it's no worse than, and I won't pick on the Girl Scouts too long, but, you know, the Girl Scouts want cookie money, you know, and then the next one comes up, and then it's somebody selling candy bars for bleachers, and so on and so forth, is, I think that's what you guys were talking about in it.
3:54:15 In having a coordinated funding approach so we're not all hitting the same doors once a week. I'm thinking a bigger picture than that. It was sort of like a whole vision of Mammoth in the region. Yeah. And we should be looking at a much more regional and national level fundraising to meet that expectation. I agree. Okay. You also have multiple channels. That adds to, I mean, it's hard, hard. We have to do it locally. We have to do it locally.
3:54:47 And I think part of Rich's conversations with the USOC is kind of that national approach. Well, to give you guys an example, when the library was built, which was one of the first partnership cooperative facilities we've managed to do in this town, is there was funding coming from seven different sources, which was federal, state, local, individual partnerships, etc.
3:55:13 And that's the kind of thing that at the time we were the only ones asking. And it's kind of easy to support a library. But still. So that calls out that I want to make this the case that whether it's a position or a coordinated function, you need the ability to maximize private capital, public capital, and philanthropic sources of capital, the great unwashed.
3:55:43 Remaining element that often gets omitted from community plan work. I don't know what assessment's been done on your philanthropic capacity here based on either your expat part-time residency here in Mammoth or your friends of Mammoth that you have all over Southern California and the rest of the world, but that's a third channel that can often be equivalent.
3:56:09 Any other...
3:56:38 Let's do some wrap-up things. Any other gaps or missing items for this group? We ended up consolidating a lot of the other cars and rewriting some and cutting them apart, and I think we found the gaps and had it down. Okay. We stuck this blue part over here as kind of an outlier card. It's a communication tool. It says address and resolve multiple social media sites, support, and clear strategy.
3:57:08 That achieves 2025 goals. And previously it had an MLR, MLT, Town, Mammoth Lakes, could have just said everybody, chamber, just virtually everybody. It was a blue card originally placed up here, came out of a work group. The question is, what is the, what is address and resolve? What's the action item? When do you want it done? And who should own this?
3:57:39 The idea here, what is the idea here? What's the concern behind this? Too many different areas to find things. Not one source. Not one source. And so, who is that a problem for? All of our customers, I think, and us. It's virtually for everybody. Basically, it splinters your brand into 42 different versions of what Mammoth is, right? That's just not proven in any other environment to be helpful.
3:58:09 Whose job is it to address and resolve? Is that a city or town job? Is that an NGO job? I don't see it in the specific sweet spot of any of maybe MLT. John, didn't you have some discussions about this? Yeah, we had a very good conversation about it. And I think
3:58:37 Colin and I talked about a synergy summit to address this, and I think that might be a good avenue to start with. I think we could do a little ad hoc work to get the thing going, and I think that, you know, the mystery with this is that there really isn't a mystery. This could be figured out on paper, and there's a lot of work that could be done to make things a lot better without having to get a lot of very expensive technical information.
3:59:08 So I think we can maybe start that as a synergy side of the thing and try to figure out where that lives. I think that ultimately the MLR, MLT conversation about what's being marketed outside, the outbound marketing is compelling people to come here and do something, but then you need the resources once you get in the market to be able to know what it is you have to do. So I think there's probably going to be some coordination with that, but I think it's defining what the town's website and communications needs to do.
3:59:38 You know, needs to do this. And you can do it as a very kind of simple strategic plan kind of classic strategic planning effort. Public safety does this. Town website will provide information. And MLT's doing what it's doing. And do it almost as a mission-based conversation. What is the mission of each one of these communication channels? See where they overlap, see where the gaps are, and start figuring out what they're able to do. That was slightly additional, not different, additional take on it. I think putting a plan together is easy.
4:00:08 I think the challenge is actually building consensus among the disparate parties to agree to agree on a synthesized brand experience. And I think a lot of that has to do with, in that paper, sort of mission-based conversation, well, okay, what is ESTA's site going to do? And ESTA says, well, we're going to do this. Okay, really, that's what you're going to do. Now, are you going to stick to that? Yeah, we're going to stick to that. Then it becomes reliable to the other partners to know,
4:00:38 Okay, they are very specifically doing that. There's a lot of basic housekeeping to start with. So your idea is use the Synergy Summit. Is that scheduled? Not yet, no. So a Synergy Summit to build some coalition around coordinated media, multimedia, social media. Any other thoughts on this? Where does this belong then? Who owns this?
4:01:11 Who should have done this? Right now it says MLR, MLT, and Amanda Blakes. Who's caught me in college? That's all I care about. All right. Anything else? Anything else missing from Jo and her groups affected municipal services?
4:01:49 Is that Barry? I didn't say victory. Did we cover that? Yes. Our victory was, yes. They celebrated their victory. Thank you. We put in the quarter that it was happening. Their victory is that they're sort of dressed up and ready to go for ongoing. So they can move their victory up. All right. Nice work, you guys. All right. So I have a series of questions for you.
4:02:17 And then we'll close on budgets. So as you look at all the milestones up here, I stuck a gold star on complete an economic analysis study. I just inserted myself in your process and said if you don't do that, then half of the rest of this isn't going to make sense. It's not going to be coherent. Where else do you see milestones, two or three or four milestones,
4:02:47 That should be signature milestones. Literally, these are the absolute must-do. There's a lot of should-do's and could-do's up here. What are the three or four absolute must-do's? I think the Park West is a big milestone to prove to this community we can get something right. So that was up here. Park West.
4:03:18 Say, the multi-use facility. I would say with Park West. So you're saying that if, I think the multi-use, what you're saying is it's more important, the Park West, than the facility. If the facility, for some reason, can't go there for whatever reason, you know, you have lawsuits and everything else. So you're going to say Park West is the more important thing than the facility. I'd say the facility is more important. I'm saying using Muth.
4:03:48 Because I don't like the name, I'm trying to rename it as Park West. Park West Facility. School's Arena. School, whatever it is. That project alone, wherever this site is, finish that project within that timeline. I would say that. I would say that project is mammoth. Well, it says project. Yeah, it says project. I think you guys are on the same page. So why is this one important?
4:04:18 That's what Rich just said, is to prove that we can actually accomplish something. Who cares about that? Do it. 8,200 people. You know, we're going to celebrate when Trails End Park is done, and we're going to try not to remember how many years that took. So that's the way you want to think about this. It's not about you. You're all leaders of respected functions and so on, but it's not about you. It's about building community confidence.
4:04:46 In your own future, those goals are just images of greatness, right? That's right. Where else? We got two. Complete a project. I think it's a story map. Complete a study. A story map. Complete the story map. This is sort of the corollary to the economic study and everything else. Without it, we could end up doing a bunch of disconnected projects, and we don't end up, we cobble together a community. It's not by design. We need to have a,
4:05:18 Reliable understanding with the Forest Service about what it is that we can get as private, sustainable, recreational. Because if you look at, if the public land is in a lot of ways, it's the landscape that drives the experiences that can help people to come here, and we're willing to plan and raise money and invest and tax ourselves and all the rest of it, we need to really understand the framework to set the expectation of what we're doing.
4:05:54 So otherwise we could waste a lot of money. We've also got some social concerns with folks in the community who are starting to get pretty frustrated with this. And it's a social issue that we're going to have to address. It is? This one's starting to say hard to identify. I think people who live in this community who see things like trail systems and amenities happening on public lands happening all over the western United States, and for some reason they don't seem to be happening in Nama.
4:06:23 And I think we've bought some more time now with the new trails coordinator. We've got another chapter in this. But I think if the next year or two, if we're not building things and things aren't happening on the ground, I think we're going to get into some tricky waters. And this is going to happen now, starting next month. The opportunity starts this next month. But I think we're going to have to come out of that saying, okay, whoever's the town manager, whoever's the council, whoever's living here, we have a framework and an understanding with this public land. To your story map,
4:06:53 You know, Shields. It's like, these are reliable places we can invest. Or do we have to take all that opportunity? I would say that the strategic plan for the implementation of R&U deserves a gold star. So... It's up in the blue. Up in blue. Up in blue. Blue, Q1, Q2. Q2, I think it was. Yep. Because if we're acknowledging that we're a recreation-based economy, we develop a
4:07:24 This is the University of Sydney New Synergy Signals.
4:07:56 Hear that what you invest in and what the Forest Service invest in. Look how they overlap. Isn't that just amazing? That's a synergy signal from the universe to you. Let's make sure we have one signature element in all areas. I know what stands out for me in effective municipal services. I'd say that in effective municipal services, the big idea is that. Yes. And it's corollary.
4:08:26 It was just being ready to go. They made the same thing, which was the goal. We probably should put two stars on visitation because nothing's going to happen without that. I've got a feeling we're getting too many stars and we're going to get nothing accomplished. That's right. Two of them are big ideas. There's another one on that. Is he exercising the mayor's prerogative or something? How long are you still in office?
4:08:58 So we got two big ideas and we've got one, two, we got five, six hours. Terminal. Funding construction date? Yeah. That's a time sensitive deal. I would agree. And I guess if we're just rolling with it, probably something with our broadband opportunities. I mean, if we really think about what potentially distinguishes this place.
4:09:33 That's our diversification. Yeah. I mean, that's really what we're talking about up here is weatherproofing our visitation model and, you know, the air terminal is critical to that and so is broadband opportunities. Yeah, I'd like to work with John a little bit. This is the one card up here I'm not personally thrilled with because I don't think it's descriptive of what you're imagining. And so I think we need to tighten up this outcome. We can do that.
4:10:03 Offline. There's no limitation on gold stars. It's just that you've got 65 cards up here. They're not all equivalent. What are the things that matter most to you is what we're trying to get at. Anything else? All right. So, yeah, nobody mentioned the village parking lot. So, for you personally,
4:10:30 For you as individual leaders in all your respective roles, what are the milestones that are grabbing your personal attention? What's attracting you to this process? It's a bunch of work. What's attracting you? I would say it's actually having at this point, as one of the members of this group said, oh, now it's all really starting to come together, is that we've actually got a map of how to get there now. That's good.
4:11:00 I like the fact that many of the stars are the victories. Yeah, I like that too. Focused on good ends. I think it's a good framework for decision making because what staff is going to do, at least on our side, is take that thing and we're going to come back to council when you said and say, okay, make a decision. Let's do it. You said this is a priority. You said you're going to get the money. We're ready. Let's go for it. And I think this helps us clarify that.
4:11:28 20 different, you know, things to talk about. It helps to bring us back April 20th. Here we are. So let's do something. It helps everybody. One thing that I notice, I'm not sure if this exactly answers your question, but it seems like we're really heavy on to-do items in the first three quarters, and I just want to make sure that we're being realistic about that. Yeah, good question. So this is always a concern when you're front-loading. You're wanting to get things done, and I heard within the groups,
4:11:59 People kind of hedging and going, hmm, I'm not really sure we'll actually finish that. So there's nothing that prevents you from pushing back from one quarter to another your expectations. What you don't want to do is institutionalize the practice of constantly rolling your process forward. The easiest thing for you to do is to give yourself permission to delay.
4:12:25 Procrastination is built into every work culture I've ever been affiliated with, and you will embrace it as well. In fact, if anything, you've already got some kind of built-in systems of procrastination. You're trying to get past that. Yes? One thing we do on the public worksite, which we'll do for anything that relates to us on this thing, is we'll actually do a full chart, you know, using a project that lists every single project, every step, and shows, guess what, it's cost-loaded at the bottom.
4:12:55 Not just by dollars, but by staff time. We did that for this summer, and we may come to Sarah and say we need two interns, because if all goes well, we could be building a sidewalk and a path out of this. And I'd suggest everybody do the same kind of thing. Once you get this back to us, all laid out, we're going to cost-load it hours and say, okay, we can't really spend 800 hours in that week. It just doesn't work that way. That's my job. But that's a tool.
4:13:19 Your observation is a good one. I was thinking about this. I think Colin, you presented this one, right? I was watching you were, you gave us a good example of thinking about through the lens of projects. And you guys lined out, to use your words, you lined out the project increments. And others have kind of looked at, some of these other areas had kind of strategies are still one of the outcomes. So a strategy is a not yet,
4:13:49 So to the extent that we finish things like a study or a strategy, that then has to get spelled out. So I know Dan's vision from the very beginning was you'd end up with this 18-month action plan not to keep rolling the outcomes forward, but to give you a constant review mechanism. So, and I'm anticipating one of my questions here, council needs to be able to say not once a year,
4:14:19 But probably every quarter. Actually, let me cut to that question. Let me come to that one in just a moment. Which milestones will stretch you beyond your current capacity or capabilities? Which ones? John and I were talking about this one. What milestones we've been talking a little bit about
4:14:49 Funding and fund acquisition. Which ones are going to push you beyond what you have the capacity to actually do right now? I think a lot of these aren't in our current work program. The things that aren't in our current work program. Not in the current work program. So as you come back to that, as I was going to raise, if this becomes the priorities, there will be other things that we need to come back and say, we're no longer working on X. That is now sidelined. Exactly. And or we're going to end up with a conflict between other town priorities that we need to have on
4:15:19 The ground getting done as a town, and you're going to end up with this conflict over resources. You know, this is great, but that means public safety just got eliminated from the budget because there's no room to do anything but go invest in our economy. And so I think I see some of those working through that, but there will definitely be some reality conflicts coming into... Think of a building. There you go.
4:15:46 But I think that'll be a challenge for business and communities. That's why we have Picard over there in the second quarter of staffing and resources, and it also infers reporting back on what the work plan is and if there is something to be dropped, being honest about what's going to be dropped. So in effect, what you're both describing is this transition period between where you are and where you want to go. So you're going to have to do a little bit of recalibration in here.
4:16:16 I think I gave my little speech at one of the workgroups about there. It's not true that there's 110% effort. There's only 100%. You have 100% of what you have. And so you either invest all your dimes on the right effort, or you just cause people to struggle. So you're going to have to recalibrate. I think what this doesn't bring into play is that ongoing work program across all the organizations.
4:16:45 The question we'll be struggling with on some of this is how does this plug into that existing work program? Yes. And how does that effectively work through that? Because there's some elements we can't drop. I mean, you get legal timelines for a project coming in for review, let's say. Of course. That's going to drive something that may trump what we're working on. And that stuff's easy to see. I think it's going to be the other ongoing, well, why don't we do X? It's Chasing the Squirrel, if you're used to the movie Up. Yes. The shiny new thing.
4:17:16 And what this hopefully does is give us that focus so that doesn't happen. Or says, yes, that's a great idea. If you want us to go get that, that means it's other priority now. Are you saying that's no longer a priority? In a sense, what you've done is created a scope of work for all of you, and you now need to adjust your component scopes of work so that they are aligned not just to victory and to starts and milestones, but within the capacity that you have.
4:17:45 And begin to identify where you have gaps. What will, I always have to ask this question, I know you're running out of time here, but what will cause this to fail? It'll implode on the weight of the work. It'll implode? What does that mean? Basically, there's so much to get done, I'm going to do a little bit in a bunch of areas and achieve nothing. It still is, it's focused, but there's a whole lot of, you know, you've got the equivalent of, you know,
4:18:16 Three to four full-time people doing nothing but this. It currently don't exist. I think it's going to fail in part of opinion. And that's where that study comes into play. And we all need to understand that the study is smarter than we are. Yeah, my hope for you is that this study doesn't describe, as I often see, describe rural communities in general, Alpine communities in general.
4:18:48 Snow Sport communities in general. It's a mammoth-centric, mammoth-exclusive, not comparing you to national, comparing you to state, comparing you to all other alpine communities. Trust me, this does not work. It's a mammoth-centric, your peculiar, interesting, sometimes helpful, sometimes not, artifacts and features. So you want to be driven.
4:19:18 By data you trust. And I think we've all had a fair amount of experience dealing with that to consult to me. I think we know how to write a scope, to your point, but it's a very good point to bring up. I think the other thing that we have to be careful about is digesting this properly. I think that there's probably another step or two that we've got to go through, optimize it, focus it, bring it before we just start setting everybody loose. I think we can do another couple steps here to kind of focus it, bring it in, and really make it work.
4:19:49 I think we're all here to get to work on it. I think Brady's point is that there's an opportunity to convert this to work plan that may look different on the municipal side. When we started this in the first session, it was all everybody in the same road, we're in the same direction. If we don't monitor that closely, and then getting to John's point, what happens next? We talked about Town Council adopting this. Okay, April 20th.
4:20:15 You know, it's, it's, it's, we talk about our staff a lot about commitments and things like that. Is that April 20th? If that's April 20th, it has to go to the NGOs in your next meeting every April, period. Which means, guess what, that means you have to have it to us by Monday. So, I'm just saying, that's where, that's just where it starts. Everybody here making the agreement, okay, we're all good. Now let's take it through the board, so let's get it back to council, and it's go time. Otherwise, we're not. I don't know what your thoughts are on that, but is it April 20th when we get this back to town council?
4:20:49 Yeah, it sort of leads to my next question. Let me place that in this context. When I showed you the four-hour house video, what was hiding behind all that, there was a general contractor overseeing because this was a coded development and they had to go through permitting and so on. Who's the general, who's the GC for this? Who's the general contractor for this? That probably comes from me to the council. So town manager is the general contractor.
4:21:19 What's going to be required, final question, of every one of you in order to activate this? Wait for Dan? That's a pretty small army. This is going to require a different way of working, a little different way of working, unless...
4:21:46 A less parochial way of working, less old way of working, will actually require not just a system of responsiveness, but literally we could have extended this across the board. We could have said really the two big ideas here are it's about visitation, if this was Bill Clinton, you would have said it's about visitation student, right? 1992? And a system of responsiveness.
4:22:15 Across all participating partners. That's actually the macro idea here. So we did not effectively surface out. I had some vision of surfacing out a total dollar impact. Maybe that's a follow-up discussion. You get this whole work plan. You detail out and say, in what order are we going to require capital and of what kinds in order to get these?
4:22:48 These projects done. And the very last piece is what's the value to the community of you all having done all this work? How do you want to talk about this? How do you want to message this? I don't mean message for the purpose of selling it. I mean message for the purpose of inviting people to share your spirit of vision and direction and so on. I think one thing just, have we, are you going to make sure that all the
4:23:19 My thought on your behalf without
4:23:51 Over inserting myself in the process, not just to give this back to you, formatted something like this so you can see the entire plan across all these priorities and so on, but to give you the MLR slice, the MLH slice, the MLT slice, the ESTO slice, literally it's pull out all these component pieces and becomes your initial draft scope of work starting place.
4:24:18 And I hate to, I agree with you, Michael, and I'm thinking about it, is there's no way that we can expect the other boards to have really absorbed this in whatever the first week of April meeting is. So are we really looking at, I'm not as concerned because everything that we put into the first quarter for the effective municipal services is on tap to happen in that quarter, but
4:24:45 I think that trying to get this back to council on the second meeting in April isn't going to work because you're going to need to give the boards time to deal with it. But it'd be nice to come out of here with a somewhat agreed to date because, you know, we put something, we have the one over there about everybody having their meetings webcast and archived. Well, that might take some discussion from some of the other boards.
4:25:12 So what would be a reasonable... I don't know. We could take, for one, just to give us six points. ...of what they think is a reasonable... My thought was that even if it was introduced at their April meeting, they probably wouldn't be able to discuss it until their May meeting. I'm just guessing. That sounds like a fair timeline. I mean, our agenda is pretty much packed and ready to roll for April 5th. I could include this as doing some homework, but come back and put a big chunk of time in May and really kind of walk through it.
4:25:42 My question is, I think a lot of the stuff, the boards have seen this. They've seen it, but that's why I'm asking it, because I'm sorry, if there isn't an official sign-off by them and an official sign-off by council that this is truly a commitment, you know, we've all signed it in blood or whatever.
4:26:06 Our souls. For MLR, there's nothing on that board that we haven't talked about, but it's not in our strategic planning process at this point. Okay. So do you think you can do that? Go through it in person. Sure, my three and a half hour meeting will become four and a half hours. I think John's point, and I agree with MLT, I think we can go through this in person in April. We're not surprising anybody. What do you think John?
4:26:37 I don't see an issue from ESTA, again, all the concepts have been presented to the ESTA Board, and quite honestly, the key decision makers on the ESTA Board related to this process have been part of the process. Yeah, I don't see any surprises, and I don't see any reason why we can't, if we have it in time.
4:27:06 Presented at our April meeting. All right. So we need to turn this out and get it back to the end. There's a breakdown. This is my fifth workshop in the last six days, and I have TRPA governing board tomorrow for nine hours. I can start on Friday. Start on Friday. So what do you think? Pretty solid?
4:27:42 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. A long journey from last summer to now. I think we've recaptured some of the momentum we maybe transitioned away from over the wintertime. I compliment you on your willingness to stick with this and come to some consensus amongst yourselves. I feel more hopeful about your future now than at any point in the last eight months.
4:28:14 So, Dan, anything else from your side? No, I think we're good. Any other questions, comments, concerns? Mr. Mayor? I'm forward to having us come back to Council. Thank you, everyone. It's been a long process that we've covered a lot of ground. Yeah, you can adjourn. And that's it for me today. We'll adjourn to our next regular schedule meeting, April 6 to 6 p.m. Thanks.
4:29:02 Thank you.